article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
the x - ray ( @xmath1110 kev ) luminosities from galactic black hole candidate ( bhc ) transients range from values below @xmath2 erg s@xmath3 when the sources are in quiescence @xcite to values that can approach or exceed @xmath4 erg s@xmath3 for some sources @xcite . during outbursts , luminosities above @xmath1@xmath5 erg s@xmath3
are usually seen for at least several months @xcite , and significant changes in the x - ray properties occur over time . we do not have a detailed understanding of all the physical changes that lead to changes in the x - ray emission properties , but the physics involves the structure of the accretion disk around the black hole as well as the connection between the accretion disk and the steady or impulsive jets that can be launched from these systems .
the changes in the x - ray emission properties are partially caused by changes in the mass accretion rate onto the black hole ; however , it has been demonstrated that other physical parameters must also be important for determining those properties @xcite .
the emission properties of accreting black holes are often classified in terms of `` spectral states . ''
recently , efforts have been made to make the state definitions more quantitative and to connect these definitions directly to the continuum spectral components @xcite .
the spectra can often be described as the combination of a soft , thermal component along with a hard component that can fall off more or less steeply with energy .
the thermal component is almost certainly blackbody emission from an accretion disk , as in @xcite , but the mechanism for producing the hard component is less clear .
accreting black holes can be highly variable , sometimes with quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) ; spectral and timing properties are both incorporated in the following spectral state definitions from @xcite . in the thermal - dominant ( td ) state , the thermal component accounts for @xmath675% of the total 220 kev flux . in this state ,
no or weak qpos are seen with rms levels below 1% , and the 0.110 hz continuum rms is @xmath76% . in the steep power - law ( spl )
state , the hard component is a power - law with @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the power - law photon index .
a source is said to be in the spl state if qpos are present and the hard component contributes @xmath620% of the 220 kev flux or if , regardless of the timing properties , the hard component contributes @xmath10% of the 220 kev flux .
finally , in the hard state , the hard component is much less steep , at @xmath11 , the hard component contributes more than 80% of the 220 kev flux , the 0.110 hz continuum rms is between 10% and 30% , and the presence of radio emission signals the presence of a compact jet @xcite . as discussed in @xcite , systems also exhibit intermediate states , with properties that are usually some combination of the three main states ( td , spl , and hard ) .
the x - ray activity from the bhc transient 4u 163047 over more than two years during 20022004 along with good high energy coverage of the source by the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer ( rxte ) _ and the _ international gamma - ray astrophysics laboratory ( integral ) _ provide an opportunity to study the long - term evolution of the source as it enters different spectral states and exhibits different emission properties .
4u 163047 is among the most active of the bhc transients and has produced strong hard x - ray emission during its 17 detected outbursts @xcite .
the source has a quasi - periodic @xmath1600700 day outburst recurrence time @xcite , which is unusually short for systems of this type , probably indicating a higher time - averaged mass accretion rate from its companion @xcite .
highly polarized radio emission was detected from 4u 163047 during its 1998 outburst @xcite , indicating the presence of jets , and the source is often compared to microquasars such as grs 1915 + 105 and gro j165540 .
the compact object mass has not been measured for 4u 163047 , but @xcite classify it as a very likely `` category a '' bhc .
also , the binary orbital period is not known , and our lack of knowledge is due to the difficulty in performing optical and infrared studies of the source due to its high column density ( but see * ? ? ? * for the likely identification of the source s infrared counterpart ) . .
also , the pca count rates for the final four observations ( see panel _ b _ ) are consistent with little or no contribution to the emission from 4u 163047.[fig : lc],scaledwidth=52.0% ] the current outburst from 4u 163047 , which began in 2002 september @xcite , is one of the brightest and longest recorded outbursts from this system . a new high - amplitude flaring behavior has been reported at different times during this outburst @xcite , and , in this work , we study this behavior in more detail . also , transitions between spectral states have been observed during this outburst @xcite .
in addition to the high level of recent activity from 4u 163047 and the recent work on defining spectral states , our study comes at a time when _ integral _ is providing high quality hard x - ray images .
images of the 4u 163047 field , which we present in this work and in @xcite , are extremely useful for avoiding source confusion . in the following , we present x - ray spectral and timing studies of 4u 163047 .
_ rxte _ regularly monitored 4u 163047 in outburst with pointed observations between 2002 september 12 ( mjd 52,529 ) and 2005 january 4 ( mjd 53,375 ) . here , we study the evolution of the x - ray properties throughout the outburst by analyzing data from the 318 _ rxte _ observations that occurred during this time . with the exception of five 22 - 36 day observing gaps caused mainly by sun angle constraints
, pointed observations occurred , on average , approximately every other day for 2.3 years .
the observations were made under seven different proposal ids ( see table [ tab : observations ] ) : in three cases ( p70113 , p80117 , and p90128 ) , we observed 4u 163047 in conjunction with our _ integral _ program ; and , in the other four cases ( p70417 , p80417 , p80420 , and p90410 ) , the observations were made under a public `` target of opportunity '' program , and we analyzed data from the public archive .
the proportional counter array ( pca ) and high energy x - ray timing experiment ( hexte ) light curves shown in figure [ fig : lc ] indicate the times of the _ rxte _ observations .
after the launch of the esa satellite _ integral _ @xcite in 2002 october , we triggered our target of opportunity to observe 4u 163047 when the source became observable while it was in outburst in early 2003 .
we obtained a 293 ks exposure between ut 2003 february 1.2 and ut 2003 february 5.3 , and the time of this observation is marked in figure [ fig : lc ] .
we previously used the data from this observation for studies of the obscured x - ray source igr j163204751 (= ax j1631.94752 ) , which is a hard and persistent ( though highly variable ) source that is close to 4u 163047 @xcite , and we used these data to report detections of two other new _ integral _ sources @xcite .
in addition , the 2040 kev images from this observation can be found in @xcite along with information about the sources in the _ integral _ field of view , including an initial look at the hard x - ray and gamma - ray properties of 4u 163047 . although we do not present a full analysis of the _ integral _ data here , the hard x - ray _ integral _ images are important for interpreting the _ rxte _ data .
diameter , corresponding to the full - width zero - intensity ( fwzi ) collimator response .
we used different _
rxte _ pointing positions in an attempt to minimize contamination of 4u 163047 by nearby sources.[fig : image],scaledwidth=48.0% ]
we extracted energy spectra and light curves from the _ rxte _ data using scripts developed at the university of california , san diego and the university of tbingen that incorporate the standard software for _ rxte _ data reduction ( ftools ) .
we processed the data using the most recent _ rxte _ calibration files , which were released on 2003 july 7 , and performed extractions using ftools v5.3 and v5.3.1 .
the _ rxte _
routines are identical for these two versions of ftools .
we performed time filtering for the 330 observations using data from times during which the following criteria are satisfied : the _ rxte _ pointing is within @xmath12 of the nominal pointing position ; the nominal pointing position is more than @xmath13 above the limb of the earth ; a south atlantic anomaly ( saa ) passage has not occurred within the previous 30 minutes ; proportional counter unit ( pcu ) 2 is turned on ; and the pcu 2 electron ratio is less than 0.25 .
we chose pcu 2 because , in normal _ rxte _ operation , this unit is programmed to have a very high duty cycle to allow for the most precise observation - to - observation comparisons .
our filtering led to zero exposure time for only 12 out of 330 observations ( 3.6% ) , leaving us with 318 observations for further study .
as shown in table [ tab : observations ] , we typically obtained 13 ks of exposure time per observation , but exposure times vary greatly from 96 s up to 11 ks . for all 318 observations , the mean exposure time is 1.8 ks .
we extracted the following information for each observation : the 320 kev pcu 2 count rate ; the 39 kev pcu 2 count rate ; the 920 kev pcu 2 count rate ; the 20100 kev hexte - a count rate ; the 3200 kev pca+hexte energy spectrum ; and the 320 kev pca light curve with 16 s time bins .
we took the pca information from the `` standard 2 '' data , which includes 129 channel energy spectra taken with 16 s time resolution .
we used the `` sky - vle '' model to estimate and subtract off the background .
for hexte , we used `` event list '' data , and we used the normal hexte rocking mode to estimate and subtract off the background .
as described below in
@xmath14 , we also selected five observations for more detailed study , and , for these , we used the higher time resolution pca data to produce power spectra . for four of the observations , we used a pca mode with 64 energy channels and @xmath15 s (= 122 @xmath16s ) time resolution . in the fifth case , we combined the data from two pca modes : a mode with @xmath17 s ( 7.8 ms ) time resolution , covering the lower energy portion of the spectrum ; and a second mode with higher time resolution , containing an event list for the higher energy photons .
we used data from all the active pcus when producing the power spectra . _ integral _ hard x - ray images from the observation described above ,
show that 4u 163047 lies in a region of the galaxy that has a high density of hard x - ray sources , including a source , igr j163204751 , that is @xmath18 from 4u 163047 .
the 2040 kev imager on - board the _ integral _ satellite ( ibis ) image , produced using the off - line scientific analysis ( osa-4.2 ) software @xcite , is shown in figure [ fig : image ] .
when we realized that there is another hard x - ray source within the _ rxte _ field - of - view ( fov ) for the nominal 4u 163047 pointing position , we requested a change in the pointing position to avoid igr j163204751 . from mjd 52,691 to 52,722 , we used the pointing position marked `` offset # 1 '' in figure [ fig : image ] .
however , the presence of igr j163934643 @xcite and a third x - ray transient , igr j163584726 @xcite , prompted another change in pointing position to `` offset # 2 , '' and we used this pointing position from mjd 52,722 to 52,781 .
the pca and hexte collimators have a triangular response with a full - width half - maximum ( fwhm ) fov of @xmath19 and a full - width zero - intensity ( fwzi ) fov of @xmath20 .
where necessary in the work described below , we corrected for the collimator response when producing light curves or response matrices for spectral analysis .
figure [ fig : lc]a shows the _ rxte _ all - sky monitor ( asm ) 1.512 kev light curve for 4u 163047 with the source in outburst from 2002 september to the end of 2004 .
in addition to being the longest outburst during the _ rxte _ lifetime , at its peak , its asm flux is @xmath1800 mcrab ( 1 crab = 74 asm c / s ) , which is @xmath150% brighter than any previous outburst observed by the asm .
below , we divide the outburst into the various spectral states the source entered , but , in general , the asm light curve shows two very bright and highly variable periods : the first occurred for @xmath1120 days between mjd 52,530 and @xmath152,650 ; and the second occurred for @xmath1200 days in 2003 between mjd 52,750 and 52,950 .
the source was also bright for much of 2004 , but it did not become as bright as the previous two periods of very high activity . twice in 2003 and once in early 2004 , the source flux was low enough to be only marginally detected by the asm .
the source became undetectable again in late 2004 , and it appears that the source has remained in quiescence into 2005 . figure [ fig : lc]b shows the count rates measured in the 320 kev band by the pca during the pointed _ rxte _ observations .
for the observations made at the offset pointing positions , the count rates are corrected using the pca collimator response .
the _ rxte _ monitoring program began soon after the source was detected by the asm .
while the source flux was at the asm sensitivity limit at times , the pca , with its better sensitivity , shows continuous activity until 2004 november 16 ( mjd 53,326 ) .
after this date , there was a 36 day gap in coverage , and we obtained four more pca measurements after this gap . for these observations ,
the pca rates are consistent with galactic ridge emission and flux from igr j163204751 , with little or no emission from 4u 163047 .
they are not included in the spectral and timing analysis in the next two sections ( leaving 314 observations ) .
figure [ fig : lc]c shows the hexte - a 20100 kev count rate , and figure [ fig : lc]d shows the source hardness , defined as the ratio of the 920 kev pca rate to the 39 kev pca rate .
for the 314 observations , we used the xspec v11.3.1 t software to perform @xmath21-minimization spectral fits to the pca+hexte 3200 kev energy spectra . for the pca spectra ,
we included systematic errors at a level of 0.6% for 38 kev and at a level of 0.3% for 825 kev , and these numbers are derived by fitting energy spectra of the crab nebula as described in @xcite . for many of the observations , the standard two component model
disk - blackbody @xcite plus power - law with interstellar absorption provides acceptable fits , but , for 31 observations , we obtain @xmath22 for 63 degrees of freedom ( dof ) , and , for the 314 observations , the mean @xmath23 is 1.51 . by examining the residuals for several of the spectra with statistically poor fits , we found two main reasons for the poor fits
. first , in many cases , large residuals ( positive and negative ) are present around the iron k@xmath24 complex .
second , negative residuals are sometimes seen at high energies , above 50 kev , indicating the presence of a cutoff in the spectrum .
the presence of iron features and high energy cutoffs are not surprising as they have been seen previously for 4u 163047 as well as for other black hole sources @xcite .
thus , we refitted all the energy spectra after adding a narrow iron k@xmath24 emission line and a smeared iron edge @xcite in a similar manner to that described in @xcite .
we restricted the line energies to be between 6.4 kev and 7.1 kev , spanning the possible iron k@xmath24 range for non - redshifted lines .
similarly , we restricted the edge energy to be between 7.1 kev and 9.3 kev .
sample fits to several spectra show that the width of the smeared edge is not well - constrained in most cases , and we fixed the width to 10 kev @xcite .
we also added a high energy cutoff allowing the model to exponentially turn - over above an energy @xmath25 with an e - folding energy of @xmath26 .
finally , although the column density ( @xmath27 ) has been fixed to values close to @xmath28 @xmath29 in some previous studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , the results for this _ rxte _ data set indicate significant changes during the outburst .
thus , we have left @xmath27 as a free parameter , except that we have restricted the column density to be greater than @xmath30 @xmath29 , which is the lowest value that has been measured for 4u 163047 by a soft x - ray instrument @xcite .
this value may represent the interstellar value along the line of sight . .
( _ b _ ) and ( _ c _ ) show the disk - blackbody parameters .
( _ d _ ) shows the power - law photon index .
( _ e _ ) shows the power - law ratio ( see text for definition ) . in panels ( _ b _ ) through ( _ e _ ) , an average - sized error bar is shown , although it should be noted that there is some variation in the error bar size from observation - to - observation ( see table [ tab : spectra ] ) .
[ fig : parameters],scaledwidth=52.0% ] these additions to the spectral model produce significant improvements in the quality of the fits . for the 314 spectra ,
the mean @xmath23 is 1.15 for 57 dof , and only 13 have @xmath22 .
we examined the spectral residuals as well as the 16 s light curves for the cases where the worst fits are obtained . in most of these cases ,
the light curves show a high degree of variability , suggesting that spectral variability during the observation degrades the quality of the fits .
however , in several cases , the level of variability is not particularly high , and , in four of these observations , significant positive residuals are present at high energies , above @xmath140 kev . although it is possible that these residuals indicate a high energy excess from 4u 163047 , the observations for which the excess is present occurred at the nominal pointing position for 4u 163047 so that the _ rxte _ field of view includes the persistent hard x - ray source igr j163204751 ( cf .
figure [ fig : image ] ) . using _
integral _ flux measurements and _ rxte _ pointings at the 4u 163047 position during times when 4u 163047 was not active , we demonstrate in appendix a that the positive high energy residuals are very likely caused by igr j163204751 .
the four observations with positive high energy residuals occurred between mjd 52,560 and 52,596 , and , as the spectra for these four observations are likely contaminated , we do not consider them in the following analysis . figure [ fig : parameters ] shows the pca rates and spectral parameters vs. time .
the spectral parameters shown include the temperature of the disk - blackbody component ( @xmath31 ) , the normalization of this component ( @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the inner radius of the accretion disk in km , @xmath34 is the source distance in units of 10 kpc , and @xmath35 is the disk inclination ) , the power - law photon index ( @xmath9 ) , and the ratio of the unabsorbed 220 kev power - law flux to the total flux ( @xmath36 ) .
when the entire outburst is considered , the range of @xmath31 values is 0.493.81 kev , while the range is 0.634.13 for @xmath9 .
we use the spectral parameters and the @xcite state definitions to divide the observations into different spectral states , and the classifications are indicated in figure [ fig : parameters ] .
the steep power - law ( spl ) observations have @xmath8 and @xmath37 .
those in the thermal - dominant ( td ) state have @xmath38 . the source was only in the hard state with @xmath11 and @xmath39 for two observations near mjd 53,069 .
the remainder of the observations do not fit into any of the spectral states as defined by @xcite , and we say that the source was in one or more intermediate states ( is ) during these observations . it should be noted that we have divided the observations into spectral states using only spectral and not timing information . while timing information is important to the study of spectral states and
is part of the full @xcite definitions , our results for a sample of the power spectra ( see @xmath14 ) show that the timing properties are in - line with the @xcite criteria for the various states .
if we had included timing information in dividing up the spectral states , it is possible that some td observations with higher noise levels would be re - classified as is and that if some of the is or td observations have qpos they may be re - classified as spl . however , such re - classifications would not change the results or conclusions of this work .
there are seven observations with distinctly different spectra . for these observations ,
the power - law is very hard with values of @xmath9 between 0.6 and 1.7 , and it is sharply cutoff with e - folding energies between 10 and 50 kev .
while such a spectrum would represent the discovery of a new black hole state , we strongly suspect that these observations are contaminated by emission from the hard x - ray transient igr j163584726 .
although igr j163584726 was not detected during our 2003 february _ integral _ observation ( see figure [ fig : image ] ) , four of the observations for which we see the very hard x - ray spectrum occurred during the time period from mjd 52,701 to 52,722 , when the source was known to be active @xcite . during this time period
, we used the offset # 1 pointing position , so the field of view included igr j163584726 but not igr j163204751 .
in addition , the hard spectrum is not detected for any of the observations for which we used the offset # 2 pointing position , which does not include igr j163584726 in the field of view . in appendix b ,
we include details about the hard spectra , as they provide useful information on igr j163584726 .
other than in appendix b , we do not consider these observations further .
an inspection of the 320 kev 16 s pca light curves for all 314 observations indicates that in addition to the observation - to - observation variability that is clearly seen in figures [ fig : lc ] and [ fig : parameters ] , many of the light curves show high amplitude variability during the observations . to quantify the level of variability
, we calculated the peak - to - peak amplitude for each observation , @xmath40 , defined simply as the maximum pca count rate minus the minimum rate divided by the mean rate for the observation . the errors on @xmath40 depend on the uncertainties in the count rates for the individual maximum and minimum 16 s time bins as well as the error in the mean rate .
for the 314 observations , the mean value of @xmath40 is 0.26 and the standard deviation is 0.20 .
while the majority of the observations have some form of significant variability , we focus on the observations with high - amplitude variability defined as the observations during which @xmath40 minus the 2-@xmath41 error on @xmath40 is greater than 0.3 . with this definition ,
there are 72 observations with high - amplitude variability . and [ fig : parameters ] .
note that the observations for ( _ a _ ) , ( _ c _ ) , and ( _ d _ ) were made in the nominal pointing position while the observation for ( _ b _ ) was made in one of the offset pointing positions.[fig : lc16f],scaledwidth=52.0% ] , scaledwidth=52.0% ] a more careful examination of the 72 light curves with high - amplitude variability indicates that there are at least four types of high - amplitude variability , and examples of the most common type are shown in figure [ fig : lc16f ] while the other three types are shown in figure [ fig : lc16o ] .
the light curves shown in figure [ fig : lc16f ] can be interpreted as a series of 10100 s flares ; however , in some of the light curves the flares occur so often that it is difficult to distinguish the individual flares .
we refer to this as `` flaring '' behavior below , and we chose the examples to illustrate that flaring occurs over a wide range of times during the outburst as shown in figures [ fig : lc ] and [ fig : parameters ] . while all of the examples shown in figure [ fig : lc16f ] are from is observations , flaring also sometimes occurs during observations classified as td and spl .
figure [ fig : lc16f ] also shows the 920/39 kev hardness as a function of time .
for the observations shown in panels _ a _ , _ b _ , and _
c _ , the hardness is tightly correlated with the total 320 kev rate ( i.e. , these are hard flares ) .
however , this correlation is not seen for the panel _
d _ observation .
even more extreme variability with @xmath42 is seen in the two light curves shown in figure [ fig : lc16o]a and [ fig : lc16o]b .
these light curves exhibit deep dips that are clearly different from the other types of variability observed .
the dip shown in figure [ fig : lc16o]a is very similar to the dip observed from 4u 163047 during its 1996 outburst @xcite .
spectral analysis of the 1996 dip indicates that it is likely caused by absorption , perhaps from accretion disk material , but the fact that the dip is not spectrally hard indicates partial covering of the x - ray source @xcite .
similarly , the dip shown in figure [ fig : lc16o]a shows , at most , only a moderate level of hardening . a third type of variability is illustrated in figure [ fig : lc16o]c and can be described as short , 1020 s dips , and similar dips have been reported during the 1998 outburst from 4u 163047 @xcite .
the hardness ratio indicates that the spectrum becomes softer during the dips . during this outburst
, we only see these short , soft dips during the three observations from mjd 52,794.289 , 52,795.340 , and 52,801.445 , and a total of 7 or 8 short dips are seen in the 19 ks of exposure time accumulated for these three observations , which are all classified as spl .
the final type of high - amplitude variability is shown in figure [ fig : lc16o]d and consists of a single , very hard flare that occurred at the end of the observation performed on mjd 53,087.832 , at which time the source was in the td state .
the flare did not occur close to the time of any saa passage , and we checked that the pca electron ratio was not high during the time of the flare , indicating that the flare did not have any instrumental or environmental cause .
in addition , we checked for solar flares using the x - ray data from the solar x - ray imager ( sxi ) on the geostationary operational environmental satellites ( goes-12 ) , but the sun did not flare during the _ rxte _ observation .
finally , we extracted a 16 s hexte light curve , and we see that hexte also detected the hard flare . thus , we conclude that origin of the flare was an astronomical source in the _ rxte _ field - of - view . it is likely that the flare came from 4u 163047 , but we can not rule out the possibility that it came from one of the other sources in the field - of - view , such as igr j163584726 or igr j163204751 .
for details such as observation ids , observation times , and parameter values.[fig : spectra],scaledwidth=52.0% ] , illustrating examples of the following states or behaviors : spl , flaring , td , is , and hard .
the solid lines represent model fits , and the parameters for these models are given in table [ tab : power ] .
[ fig : power],scaledwidth=52.0% ] we selected representative observations for more detailed spectral and timing analysis .
the selected observations include one observation from each of the spectral states ( spl , td , and hard ) , and two observations from the is state : one that exhibits the flaring behavior described above , and one that does not .
the energy spectra from these observations are shown in figure [ fig : spectra ] , and the parameters from the spectral fits are given in table [ tab : spectra ] . from the spl state to the hard state , the spectra are ordered according to decreasing @xmath31 and 3200 kev flux , as shown in table [ tab : spectra ] . while @xmath31 is correlated with the flux , the disk - blackbody normalization is anti - correlated with the flux .
the changes for @xmath9 and @xmath36 do not have a simple relationship with the total flux .
the @xmath36 is the highest at the highest flux and the lowest flux , but the thermal , disk - blackbody , component contributes a higher fraction of the flux at intermediate flux levels .
table [ tab : spectra ] also provides the measured values for the column density ( @xmath27 ) .
the values , with 90% confidence error bars , indicate that the column density drops significantly with flux .
the 0.00564 hz rms - normalized power spectra for the same five observations are shown in figure [ fig : power ] .
in fitting the power spectra , we considered various combinations of three different components , which we also previously used to fit the 4u 163047 spectra from the 1998 outburst @xcite : a power - law function ( pl ) ; a band - limited noise component ( bl ) , which we modeled as a zero - centered lorentzian ; and a qpo , which we modeled using a lorentzian . for the spl state ,
the 0.00510 hz continuum is well - described by the pl model .
in addition , a qpo is present at @xmath43 hz with a quality factor of @xmath44 and a fractional rms of 1.30%@xmath450.07% ( see table [ tab : power ] ) . above this qpo
, the power drops much more rapidly than the extrapolation of the pl .
for the is observation with flaring , nearly the entire 0.00564 hz range is well - described by the pl .
there are no qpos in this case , but there is excess power below @xmath10.02 hz due to the flaring .
the td state power spectrum has approximately a power - law shape from 0.00510 hz .
there appears to be a narrow dip in the power at 10 hz , and the power drops off more rapidly than the extrapolation of the power - law above 20 hz . in the is state , there is evidence for bl and pl components , although the statistics are rather poor for this state due to a lower count rate and a lower rms noise level .
there is no evidence for the presence of qpos in the is state .
finally , in the hard state , the continuum is well - described by only the bl component , and a qpo is present at @xmath46 hz with @xmath47 and a fractional rms level of 5.4%@xmath450.3% .
the other hard state observation exhibited a very similar power spectrum but with the qpo at @xmath48 hz .
the power spectra for the observations we previously identified as being in the td , spl , and hard states based on their spectral properties are consistent with the typical power spectra expected for these states as described by @xcite .
td power spectra typically have 0.110 hz rms values @xmath76% with weak or no qpos and a power - law shape , and these properties are consistent with our example td power spectrum . for spl
power spectra , the continuum often ( but not always ) has a power - law shape , and low - frequency ( 115 hz ) qpos are usually present .
our example spl power spectrum exhibits similar properties .
based on the fact that the qpo in our spl example is relatively broad , it would be classified as type a or b ( depending on its phase lag properties ) using the qpo classifications given in @xcite , and the combination of a power - law continuum and type a or b qpos is typical @xcite .
the power spectra for the two observations identified as being in the hard state have relatively strong band - limited noise , which is a characteristic of hard state power spectra .
the 0.110 hz rms values for these two observations are 9.6%@xmath450.4% and 9.0%@xmath450.6% , lying just below the 1030% range that is typical for the hard state .
while this could indicate that the source was close to but not quite in the hard state , it is important to note that these are the only two observations for which we found strong band - limited noise .
we produced power spectra for the five is observations closest in time to the two hard state observations .
we fitted them with a power - law model and obtained reduced-@xmath21 values between 0.4 and 2.1 for 17 dof .
the power - law fits give 0.110 hz rms values between 1% and 4% , indicating that the noise level is much lower for these observations than for the two observations identified as hard state observations .
thus , these two observations distinguish themselves from the other observations based on their spectral and timing properties , which appears to indicate that the source did briefly enter the hard state . the properties of the qpos seen for the two hard state power spectra are also different from the qpo seen in the spl .
in addition to being at lower frequency 45 hz , the hard state qpos are much narrower , and they would be classified as type c qpos .
the combination of type c qpos and band - limited noise is typical @xcite .
it is also notable that the hard state power spectra are very similar to those seen at the end of the 1998 outburst from 4u 163047 @xcite .
as the source declined in 1998 , the qpo was first detected at 3.4 hz and then gradually dropped to 0.2 hz .
thus , the 45 hz qpo we see in the 20022004 outburst likely indicates that a similar phenomenon began to occur but was stopped , perhaps by an increase in the mass accretion rate .
good x - ray coverage of 4u 163047 during the 20022004 outburst has allowed us to study its source properties throughout the outburst in detail , and here , we discuss these properties in the context of previous outbursts from 4u 163047 as well as in the context of accreting black holes in general .
the 20022004 outburst is , by far , the longest and brightest that has occurred during the _ rxte _ era , and , in
@xmath49 , we make comparisons to historical outbursts . in our study
, we have found several extreme and unusual source properties , and , in
@xmath50 , we discuss our measurements of the soft component , including the extremely high inner disk temperatures that occur for some of the steep power - law state observations . in
@xmath51 , we extend the analysis described above to constrain the nature of the high - amplitude flaring . in
@xmath52 , we compare the x - ray and radio properties of the 20022004 outburst to those of the 1998 outburst and discuss radio / x - ray connections . finally , our study has provided a test of the quantitative @xcite state definitions , and , in
@xmath53 , we discuss some of the pros and cons of these definitions . prior to the 20022004 outburst from 4u 163047 ,
four outbursts from this source had been observed by the _
rxte_/asm during the _ rxte _ era ( 1996present ) .
the mean duration of these four outbursts as measured by the _
rxte_/asm is 140 days , and the mean peak asm count rate is 28 c / s ( 0.38 crab ) . from the asm light curve ( figure [ fig : lc]a ) , the duration of the 20022004 outburst is 825 days , and the peak asm rate is 62 c / s ( 0.84 crab ) , making it longer by a factor of nearly six and brighter by a factor of 2.2 than the mean values for the first four outbursts . while the current outburst is unusual compared to the 4u 163047 outbursts of the past decade , it is not unprecedented in duration or in brightness when compared to the entire group of outbursts going back to 1969 .
although there are many cases where poor x - ray coverage makes it difficult to tell whether outbursts were extended or not , the clearest example of an extended outburst occurred when the _ ginga _ all - sky monitor detected the source for 2.4 years between 1988 october and 1991 march @xcite .
the _ ginga _
light curve shows that the 19881991 outburst had many similarities to the current outburst , including flares where the flux reached @xmath10.6 crab as well as multiple time periods of low flux during the outburst . for the 19881991 outburst ,
the low flux periods are separated by @xmath1220 days @xcite .
the asm light curve for the 20022004 outburst has local minima at mjd 52,685 , 53,000 , 53,075 , and 53,250 , indicating separations of 315 , 75 , and 175 days ; thus , they are the same order of magnitude as the 220 day separations , but they are clearly different . with a peak flux of 0.84 crab ( 1.512 kev ) , the 20022004 outburst is somewhat brighter than the 0.6 crab ( 120 kev ) flares detected during the 19881991 outburst . however , at a 36 kev flux of 1.4 crab @xcite , the 1977 outburst , which lasted for about 0.3 years , was brighter than the current outburst . in summary ,
while the 20022004 outburst is one of the longest and brightest outbursts ever detected from 4u 163047 , it is not unprecedented in either category . on the other hand ,
no previous outburst was both brighter and longer than the current outburst , so it is very likely that the total mass accreted is higher for the 20022004 outburst than for any previous outburst .
the high level of recent activity from 4u 163047 strengthens the argument made by @xcite that the mass accretion rate from the binary companion ( @xmath54 ) is unusually high for this source .
further , @xcite point out that this implies a very long binary orbital period ( @xmath55 days ) for 4u 163047 based on the calculations of @xcite , which show that , for a given @xmath56 , an x - ray binary will only be transient if @xmath54 is smaller than a critical value . in bhc energy spectra ,
the presence of a strong soft component is a clear indication that we are seeing thermal emission from an optically thick accretion disk .
the basic physical properties that determine the shape of the soft component include the mass accretion rate , the mass of the black hole , the inner radius of the disk , and the binary inclination .
if we could assume a standard @xcite accretion disk , at least some of these parameters might be directly measurable by modeling the shape of the soft component ; however , in practice , other physical processes can be important and can complicate the interpretation of any derived parameters . , the bolometric disk luminosity derived from the diskbb parameters assuming a distance of 10 kpc and a binary inclination of @xmath57 , vs. the inner disk temperature , @xmath31 . the colors / symbols in ( _ a _ ) represent the different spectral states ( red triangles = spl , green open diamonds = is , blue circles = td , black squares = hard ) .
representative errors are shown in the bottom right hand corner of the plots . in ( _ b _ ) , the observations with high - amplitude variability are marked with diamonds . in (
_ a _ ) and ( _ b _ ) , the _ solid and dashed lines _ are lines of constant @xmath33 ( @xmath0 ) , while the _ dotted line _ indicates a @xmath58 relationship ( see text for a discussion of the physical significance of these relationships).[fig : dl],scaledwidth=52.0% ] for 4u 163047 , we detect the soft component over a wide range of luminosities and mass accretion rates . while we have modeled the soft component using the disk - blackbody ( diskbb ) model , the limitations of this model
must be understood when interpreting the parameters .
for example , the shape of the soft component can be drastically changed if the disk opacity is dominated by electron scattering rather than free - free absorption @xcite .
it has been shown that this effect can cause measurements of inner disk radii to be underestimated by a factor of five or more @xcite .
in addition , at high mass accretion rates , additional cooling mechanisms may cause a change from the thin @xcite disk solution to a geometrically thicker `` slim '' disk @xcite .
this can lead to significantly more material , and thus emission , at small radii and can also produce a much flatter radial temperature profile ( @xmath59 ) , with a change in @xmath60 from 0.75 to @xmath10.5 @xcite . as a final example of the limitations of the diskbb model , it has been shown that assumptions about the boundary conditions at the inner radius of the disk can be important .
the nonzero torque boundary condition assumed ( basically for computational convenience ) in the diskbb model can lead to an overestimation of the inner disk radius by a factor of more than two @xcite . using observations of bhc systems xte j1550564 , gro j165540 , lmc x-3 , and observations from previous outbursts of 4u 163047 ,
kubota and co - workers show how effects of electron scattering and changes in the radial temperature profile can manifest themselves @xcite . following these studies , we plot in figure [ fig : dl ] the disk temperature ( @xmath31 ) vs. the bolometric disk luminosity ( @xmath61 ) as derived from the 4u 163047 diskbb parameters . in deriving the luminosity
, we assume a source distance of 10 kpc and a binary inclination of @xmath57 , but these are highly uncertain . in figure
[ fig : dl ] , we plot a solid line representing the slope of the @xmath0 relationship that is expected for a standard @xcite accretion disk with a constant inner radius ( @xmath33 ) . a large number of mostly td and is points at disk luminosities between @xmath62 and @xmath63 erg s@xmath3 lie close to the line of constant @xmath33 , and , for these observations , we may be seeing a standard disk with a relatively stable inner radius .
however , many of the points also deviate from this line , and we identify three regions of deviation that likely have distinct explanations .
first , several is and hard state observations at the lower luminosities ( @xmath7@xmath64 erg s@xmath3 ) show disk temperatures well below values that would be consistent with the line of constant @xmath33 .
these are cases for which the overall source luminosity and presumably also the mass accretion rate are low , and these are likely cases where the inner disk radius increases or at least where the inner part of the disk is radiatively inefficient .
a second region of deviation includes td , is , and some of the spl observations and occurs at the highest disk luminosities .
this flattening of the @xmath61-@xmath31 relationship may be similar to what has been seen for xte j1550564 at high @xmath61 @xcite .
for xte j1550564 , @xcite showed that the relationship flattened to a slope close to @xmath58 , which could be an indication of a transition to a slim disk based on the work of @xcite . in 4u 163047 , it is clear from figure [ fig : dl ] that the source leaves the solid line above @xmath1@xmath65 erg s@xmath3 , and it appears that it may begin to follow the @xmath66 relationship ( the dotted line in figure [ fig : dl ] ) for at least some luminosity range .
however , the source appears to deviate from the @xmath66 relationship at the very highest values of @xmath61 , and it is possible that the source recovers the @xmath67 relationship ( the dashed line in figure [ fig : dl ] ) . although the exact evolution is not completely clear , it is interesting that the observations at the highest values of @xmath61 that deviate from the solid line are also the observations for which the high - amplitude flaring occurred ( see figure [ fig : dl]b ) . for transitions between the standard disk and the slim disk ,
theory predicts a limit cycle with a region of instability in between the two solutions .
thus , the flaring may be a consequence of the limit cycle , and below this is a possibility we explore further .
a third region of deviation from the line of constant @xmath33 is contains mostly spl observations for which @xmath31 is extremely high , including 15 observations with @xmath31 between 2.7 and 3.8 kev . along with extremely high temperatures , the spectra exhibit very low values of @xmath68 in the range of 1.212.3 , implying values of @xmath33 that are unphysical . as an example , for a source distance of 10 kpc and a binary inclination of @xmath57 ( as assumed above ) , this range of normalizations indicate inner radii between 1.5 and 5.0 km ; the former being an order of magnitude lower than the gravitational radius of a 10 black hole . rather than extremely small inner disk radii ,
these high temperatures and luminosities are much more likely to be caused by spectral hardening due to the dominance of electron scattering in the inner region of the accretion disk .
although the explanation for the high spl state values of @xmath31 is very likely electron scattering , it is notable that the extremely high temperatures are seen for such a large number of observations . during its 1998 outburst , 4u 163047 entered the spl state , and fits to _ rxte _ spectra gave @xmath691.7 kev and @xmath70 @xcite , which are considerably less extreme when compared to the 20022004 values .
very high values of @xmath31 have been seen for other accreting bhcs , although they are not common .
for the ten spl spectra of accreting black holes studied by @xcite , only xte j1550564 and gro j165540 have @xmath71 kev . in 1998 , the xte j1550564 spectrum showed @xmath72 kev and @xmath73 @xcite , which are within the range of values we see for 4u 163047 ; however , for xte j1550564 , this spectral shape was only seen for a single _ rxte _ observation that occurred during a remarkable 6 crab flare , during which powerful superluminal jets were ejected @xcite . for gro
j165540 , another superluminal jet source , @xcite give a spl example where the disk - blackbody temperature is 2.2 kev , and this source showed temperatures of @xmath12 kev for a few other observations @xcite .
however , for the other eight @xcite spl systems , @xmath31 is in the range 0.51.7 kev . although not discussed in @xcite , very high disk - blackbody temperatures have also been seen for grs 1915 + 105 . for six of the 19961997 observations made
when the grs 1915 + 105 luminosity was very high , @xcite report values of @xmath31 in the range 2.64.8 kev . based on the @xcite definitions and the parameters reported in @xcite , grs 1915 + 105 was in the spl state during these observations , but it should be noted that the properties of grs 1915 + 105 make it difficult to classify its behaviors into the canonical spectral states @xcite . concerning 4u 163047
, we can conclude that the extremely high disk - blackbody temperatures that we measure during the 20022004 outburst are rare and may be a new phenomenon for this source .
when compared to other bhc sources , the 4u 163047 temperatures are only matched by xte j1550564 and grs 1915 + 105 . for 4u 163047 and xte j1550564 ,
the high temperatures are only measured during observations for which the sources are at their very brightest , and , for grs 1915 + 105 , the high temperatures occur when the source is at or close to its brightest level @xcite .
it is possible that these high temperatures are an indication of the highest accretion rates that are possible from these systems .
as described above , the cause of these high temperatures may be electron scattering in the inner disk .
this causes the observed temperature , @xmath31 , to be higher than the effective temperature , @xmath74 , by a factor of @xmath75 . for the highest value of @xmath31 that occur for 4u 163047 and grs 1915 + 105 ( @xmath14 kev )
, @xmath75 would need to be @xmath13 to obtain the temperatures expected for a @xcite disk around a 10 black hole .
although this is higher than the value of @xmath76 theoretically expected for luminosities around 10% of the eddington luminosity @xcite , these authors also find that much higher values of @xmath75 can occur for luminosities approaching the eddington limit .
, scaledwidth=52.0% ] flaring from accreting bhc systems is seen on a wide range of time scales and may have various physical origins , including ( but not limited to ) accretion of clumps of matter or magnetically powered particle acceleration . while black hole variability is common , the flaring we see for 4u 163047 , with amplitudes as high as @xmath77 on time scales of 10100 s , is extreme .
the 4u 163047 amplitudes are comparable to the wild variability seen for grs 1915 + 105 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) ; however , the 4u 163047 light curves do not show the distinctive repeating patterns seen for grs 1915 + 105 .
recently , high amplitude variability at relatively long time scales has been seen for the black hole systems xte j1859 + 226 @xcite and h 1743322 @xcite .
although the flares in these systems are not as extreme as we see in 4u 163047 , they may be related . to determine if the flaring is unique to the 20022004 outburst from 4u 163047 , we inspected the 16 s light curves for the nearly 300 pointed _
observations made during the four previous outbursts .
similar flaring only occurred for three of the observations , and these observations were made during the 20002001 outburst over the time period 2000 november 1618 .
figure [ fig : lc_50120 ] shows the 16 s light curve and hardness ratio vs. time for the november 18 observation , and it is notable that the pca count rates and hardness levels are similar to those seen during the 20022004 flaring observations . for the november 18 observation , we extracted a pca plus hexte energy spectrum and fitted the spectrum as described above for the 20022004 observations .
the spectral parameters are remarkably similar to those seen for the 20022004 flaring observations .
the measured inner disk temperature is @xmath78 kev , and @xmath79 erg s@xmath3 , putting it in the same region as the other flaring observations in figure [ fig : dl ] .
also , @xmath80 and @xmath81 , so the observation would be classified as is . .
( _ a _ ) and ( _ b _ ) show the disk - blackbody parameters , while ( _ c _ ) and ( _ d _ ) show the power - law parameters , including the flux of the power - law component in units of erg @xmath29 s@xmath3
. for both observations , the two clear trends are an increase in @xmath31 and a hardening of @xmath9 with rate.[fig : flaring],scaledwidth=52.0% ] for the observations with light curves shown in figures [ fig : lc16f]b ( 70113 - 01 - 43 - 00 ) and [ fig : lc16f]c ( 80117 - 01 - 13 - 02 ) , we performed spectral fits to study the spectral evolution as a function of pca count rate . in both cases , we divided the 16 s time resolution data into different pca count rate ranges .
we separated the full range from minimum rate to maximum rate into four sub - ranges of equal size and produced four pca spectra .
we did not use hexte for this analysis because the hexte rocking would complicate the analysis .
we fitted the four spectra simultaneously , leaving the parameters for the iron features free , but requiring that they be the same for all four spectra .
we did not include a high energy cutoff as a cutoff was not required for either observation .
originally , for both observations , we allowed the column density to be different for the four spectra . for 70113 - 01 - 43 - 00 , when we forced @xmath27 to be the same for all four spectra , the quality of the fit changed from @xmath82 to @xmath83 . for 80117 - 01 - 13 - 02 ,
the change was from @xmath84 to @xmath85 , indicating that the spectra are consistent with a constant @xmath27 for both observations .
figure [ fig : flaring ] shows the evolution of the spectral parameters with count rate . for both observations ,
clear trends are seen with @xmath31 increasing and @xmath9 hardening with count rate .
the results indicate that both the soft and hard components are affected . in light of the above standard / slim disk discussion above
, perhaps the most important result is the clear and strong increase in @xmath31 .
the temperature increase is expected if the disk solution changes from a standard disk at low count rates to a slim disk at high count rates .
this , along with the fact that the flaring may be a consequence of the zone of instability between the standard and slim disk solutions , make this explanation attractive .
however , from the spectral evidence alone , we can not rule out that the disk temperature rises because of an increase in the mass accretion rate .
although the spectral analysis indicates that changes in the accretion disk are important in producing the flaring , one might also ask whether the flaring behavior could have any physical connection to outflows or jets in the system . for example , in the case of the bhc h 1743322 , from which spectrally hard flares were also recently detected , the flaring was accompanied by the presence of blue - shifted absorption lines detected in spectra taken with the _ chandra x - ray observatory _ @xcite . as these authors point out , the blue - shifting of the lines strongly suggest the presence of an outflow .
in addition , @xcite find that the line strength varies during the @xmath1300 s variations seen in h 1743322 , and @xcite suggest the possibility that , if the outflow is energetic enough , it may be able to produce hard emission via up - scattering . for 4u 163047 , we do not have information about the presence of absorption lines , but , as our spectral analysis indicates that the flaring is connected to the accretion disk , a link between the flaring and an outflow would represent an important disk / jet connection .
one might expect that an outflow energetic enough to lead to strong flares would also lead to a high level of radio emission .
however , for h 1743322 , the radio flux is actually lower during _ chandra _ observations when the absorption lines are detected than when they are not detected @xcite . for 4u 163047
, @xcite observed the source in the radio band on three occasions ( 2002 september 16 , 19 , and 24 ) when the source was exhibiting flaring , and they obtained upper limits on the 3 cm and 6 cm radio flux of 95 , 180 , and 180 @xmath16jy , respectively , for the three dates .
this does not preclude the presence of an outflow , but it does place limits on how strong any outflow might be .
we note that several other radio observations of 4u 163047 occurred during various parts of the 20022004 outburst ( including times of other flaring episodes and when the source was in the spl state ) , but no radio detections were reported .
the absence of radio emission during the 20022004 outburst is also interesting when comparing the x - ray properties during this outburst to those seen during the 1998 outburst , which is the only time radio emission has been detected from 4u 163047 . in figure
[ fig : hi ] , for both the 20022004 and 1998 outbursts , we show the hardness , defined as the ratio of the 920 kev pca count rate to the 39 kev pca count rate , vs. the source intensity ( the 320 kev pca count rate ) . for the 20022004 outburst
, we divide the observations into the different spectral states .
all of the 1998 observations are marked with open squares .
there are potentially important differences between the x - ray properties for the two outbursts in light of the fact that radio jet emission was only present for the 1998 outburst .
although both outbursts have `` c''-shaped hardness - intensity diagrams , as is relatively typical for bhc systems @xcite , the 1998 outburst is shifted in hardness , indicating that the spectrum was harder in 1998 than in 20022004 .
also , as marked in figure [ fig : hi ] , 4u 163047 traveled through the hardness - intensity diagram in a counter - clockwise fashion during its 1998 outburst , while , in 20022004 , the source often moved in the clockwise direction .
a related fact is that 4u 163047 entered a hard and bright state at the beginning of its 1998 outburst , whereas in 20022004 , there is no evidence that this occurred .
although it is likely that 4u 163047 did enter a hard state during the 20022004 rise as this is the common pattern in bhc systems , the combination of the asm and pointed _ rxte _ observations ( see figure [ fig : lc ] ) indicate that such a state would have had to last a very short time and be limited to a time period when the source was dim . and [ fig : dl ] .
the 1998 observations are marked with open black squares .
the thick - lined arrow with the filled arrowhead shows the counter - clockwise motion seen for the 1998 outburst . for the 20022004 outburst
, the pattern of the motion is complicated as shown by the thin - lined arrows with the un - filled arrowheads .
[ fig : hi],scaledwidth=52.0% ] these patterns are especially interesting in light of recent work on connections between black hole x - ray states , a source s position in the hardness - intensity diagram , and radio jet ejections @xcite .
a general pattern seen in a number of bhc outbursts is that the systems will evolve from the hard state to an intermediate state and then a radio ejection will occur during the subsequent transition to the spl state @xcite .
@xcite use the hardness - intensity diagram to quantify this effect , and it should be noted that they follow @xcite by using somewhat different terminology , describing the transition from the is to the spl states as a transition from the `` hard intermediate '' state to the `` soft intermediate '' state .
@xcite suggest that each bhc system has a threshold hardness and that major jet ejections are only produced when the source crosses this `` jet - line '' from a high to a low hardness level .
if this is the case , figure [ fig : hi ] suggests that the jet - line for 4u 163047 may be around a hardness of 0.4 .
our results for 4u 163047 provide evidence in favor of the jet - line concept ; however , based on the behavior of 4u 163047 , it is not entirely clear if the presence of a radio jet in 1998 occurred because the outburst was harder overall or if the source simply entering a bright hard state led to the jet ejection .
our analysis of this data also provides a test of the quantitative spectral state definitions of @xcite . in some ways ,
these definitions are quite successful .
for example , it is impressive that the only two observations with spectral parameters meeting the hard state requirements are also the only two we found with power spectra that include a strong band - limited noise component .
also , looking at the hardness - intensity diagram in figure [ fig : hi ] , these two observations lie at the extreme end of the c - shaped pattern . however ,
in other areas , the definitions appear to be less satisfactory .
although most of the observations labeled as spl lie at the other end of the c - shaped pattern in the hardness - intensity diagram , the spl observations have a extremely wide variety of properties .
for example , for about half of the spl observations @xmath31 lies in the 2.73.8 kev range , while the other half have temperatures @xmath861.8 kev .
we argue above that there are important physical differences between these two groups . also , it is notable that over half of the observations made during the 20022004 outburst are put in the is , meaning that a large fraction of the observations have x - ray properties that do not meet the requirements for any of the @xcite states .
overall , while the @xcite criteria appear to be useful for classifying the observations at the extremes of bhc behavior , it should be recognized that they , by themselves , do not provide a complete description of a bhc outburst due to significant variations in properties within states and the large fraction of is observations .
outstanding _ rxte _ coverage of 4u 163047 during its 20022004 outburst has allowed us to study the detailed evolution of its x - ray spectral and timing properties over a period of more than 2 years . historically , this outburst is among the longest and brightest seen in 36 years of observing 4u 163047 , and it is very likely that it is the largest ever observed in terms of total mass transfer . the x - ray properties during this outburst were also extreme , including 15 observations with very high disk - blackbody inner disk temperatures between 2.7 and 3.8 kev .
the inner disk radii inferred from these fits are unphysically small , and it is likely that the high temperatures and small radii are caused by electron scattering .
this explanation requires a spectral hardening factor of @xmath87 , implying a source luminosity that is considerably higher than 20% of the eddington limit @xcite , which is not unreasonable as we measure 3200 kev luminosities of @xmath88 erg s@xmath3 ( @xmath89/10 kpc)@xmath90 . at the highest disk luminosities
, we detect a deviation from the @xmath0 relationship ( line of constant @xmath33 ) seen at lower luminosities as well as high - amplitude flaring .
the deviation may be a sign of a transition from a standard disk to a slim disk as suggested by kubota and co - workers .
the flaring behavior of 4u 163047 may be consistent with this interpretation as a zone of instability is expected between the two disk solutions .
also , our spectral analysis of flaring observations , showing that @xmath31 is correlated with pca count rate is consistent with a change from a standard disk to a slim disk .
although sensitive radio observations occurred during the 20022004 outburst , no strong radio emission that would indicate the presence of radio jets was detected .
this is interesting in light of the fact that the x - ray properties were very different during the 1998 outburst when radio jet emission was detected .
compared to the 20022004 outburst , the 1998 outburst hardness - intensity diagram was shifted to a higher hardness level , and , in 1998 , the source entered into a bright and hard state , while it did not in 20022004 .
these findings support the connections between radio jets and spectral states found by @xcite and the jet - line idea recently proposed by @xcite .
finally , our analysis of a large number of _ rxte _ observations has provided a good test of the quantitative @xcite spectral state definitions .
while the hard state appears to be well - defined , the spectral and timing properties of the observations selected as spl are highly non - uniform .
also , it is notable that over half of the observations are put in the is because they do not meet the requirements of any of the @xcite definitions .
the results show that 4u 163047 exhibits many properties not encompassed by the @xcite definitions that are likely to be physically important .
jat would like to thank tomaso belloni , ken ebisawa , joern wilms , rick rothschild , and katja pottschmidt for useful discussions .
jat thanks jerome rodriguez , luigi foschini , and katja pottschmidt for help with the _ integral _ data analysis .
jat acknowledges partial support from nasa grants nag5 - 12703 and nng04ga49 g .
we thank the referee , tomaso belloni , for a useful report that helped us to improve the manuscript . as described in @xmath91 above , there are four _ rxte _ observations for which we see strong positive residuals at high energies ( @xmath9230 kev ) after fitting the pca plus hexte spectra with our standard spectral model .
these occur for observations made at the nominal pointing position , and during these observations , igr j163204751 was in the field - of - view ( fov ) , @xmath18 from 4u 163047 and the center of the fov . due to the high level of activity from igr j163204751 ,
its known hard spectrum , and its known strong variability ( see * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) , we suspect that this source may be producing much of the high energy emission that we see in the four observations with strong positive residuals . as a test , we compare the flux of the high energy emission seen in one of these observations ( observation i d 70417 - 01 - 07 - 02 taken on mjd 52,539.094 ) to measurements of igr j163204751 taken at other times .
our 2003 february _ integral _ observation provides the cleanest measurement of the high energy flux from igr j163204751 . from the @xcite analysis of the isgri spectrum , the peak 2060 kev flux during this observation
is @xmath93 erg @xmath29 s@xmath3 , and the energy spectrum is consistent with a power - law with @xmath9 between 2.6 and 3.1 . in figure
[ fig : spectra_a ] , we plot the _ rxte _ spectrum for observation i d 70417 - 01 - 07 - 02 and the 2060 kev flux measured by _ integral _ @xmath1135 days later .
we reduced the _ integral _ flux appropriately to account for the _ rxte _ collimator response at the location of igr j163204751 .
although the measured _ integral _ flux at the time of the _ integral _ observation is a factor of @xmath123 too low to explain the strong residuals , long - term variability at higher levels than this has been reported from igr j163204751 @xcite , making it probable that the source gets bright enough to explain the strong residuals at times .
further evidence that igr j163204751 is sometimes bright enough to explain the strong residuals comes from _ rxte _ observations made of 4u 163047 between 1999 december 25 and 2000 january 14 .
these observations were made when 4u 163047 was in quiescence in an effort to observe 4u 163047 as it turned - on ; however , it did not turn on during this sequence of 36 very short ( typically 500 s ) observations . during this sequence of observations ( observation ids 40112 - 01 - 01 - 00 to 40112 - 01 - 36 - 00 ) the pca count rate varied significantly between 8 and 26 c / s / pcu .
although some of the detected emission is probably galactic ridge emission , the high level of variability indicates that a compact source is producing much of the flux , and igr j163204751 is the most likely candidate . in figure
[ fig : spectra_a ] , we show the pca spectrum from the observation with the highest count rate , which was made on 2000 january 11 ( observation i d 40112 - 01 - 31 - 00 ) .
we note that no collimator response correction is necessary because the pointing position is approximately the same for this observation and for 70417 - 01 - 07 - 02 .
another technical note is that although we attempted to also use hexte , with such short observations in a crowded field , this was not straightforward .
figure [ fig : spectra_a ] indicates that the source was very hard @xmath94 , and the extension of this spectrum is more than bright enough to explain the high energy residuals , even if the spectrum breaks above 20 kev . in summary , this analysis provides strong evidence that igr j163204751 is the cause of the high energy residuals .
in addition to the four observations discussed in appendix a , there are seven other observations for which it is likely that the high energy emission is dominated by a source other than 4u 163047 .
the spectral parameters for these seven observations are shown in figure [ fig : parameters ] , and these are the extremely hard observations with @xmath9 in the 0.61.7 range . as discussed in @xmath91 above , four of the seven observations ( 70113 - 01 - 20 - 00 , 70113 - 01 - 21 - 00 , 70113 - 01 - 25 - 00 , and 70113 - 01 - 28 - 00 ) occurred during a time period when igr j163584726 was active according to reports from _ integral _ , _ chandra _ and other _ rxte _ observations @xcite . as was the case for igr j163204751 ,
_ integral _ provides the cleanest measurement of the high energy flux due to its imaging capabilities , and @xcite report a 1540 kev flux of 50 mcrab ( @xmath1@xmath95 erg cm@xmath3 s@xmath3 ) and a 40100 kev flux of 20 mcrab ( @xmath1@xmath97 erg cm@xmath3 s@xmath3 ) . on mjd 52,727.4 .
our observation 70113 - 01 - 25 - 00 occurred on the same day ( mjd 52,727.633 ) , and , after correcting the _ rxte _ collimator response for the position of igr j163584726 , which is @xmath98 from the center of the `` offset # 1 '' fov , we measure 1540 and 40100 kev fluxes of @xmath99 and @xmath100 erg cm@xmath3 s@xmath3 , respectively .
the 1540 kev flux is a factor of 2.7 lower than the _ integral _ measurement , and the 40100 kev is nearly the same in the two cases .
although the 1540 kev flux measured by _ rxte _ is somewhat low , the difference is consistent with a report by @xcite that the flux varies by a factor of @xmath12 on a time scale of hours .
more importantly , the flux comparison confirms our suspicion that the 4u 163047 spectrum is contaminated by the flux from igr j163584726 at high energies .
although it is clear that we are seeing emission from igr j163584726 in four of the seven observations with low values of @xmath9 , it is less clear whether the high energy emission for the other three observations : 80420 - 01 - 15 - 00 made on mjd 53,002.863 ; 80117 - 01 - 24 - 00 made on mjd 53,076.664 ; 90410 - 01 - 01 - 01 made on mjd 53,114.410 ; is also dominated by igr j163584726 because no _ integral _ detections of igr j163584726 were reported and also because igr j163204751 was in the _ rxte _ fov for these three observations . in figure
[ fig : spectra_b ] , we compare the pca plus hexte spectrum from 90410 - 01 - 01 - 01 to that of 70113 - 01 - 25 - 00 , where we know the emission is from igr j163584726 , and the spectra are remarkably similar . after correcting for the _ rxte _ collimator response , the 1540 and 40100 kev fluxes for 90410 - 01 - 01 - 01 are about a factor of 1.8 higher than for 70113 - 01 - 25 - 00 .
even though this may be considered an argument in favor of the emission being from igr j163584726 , igr j163204751 is also known to produce very hard ( @xmath101 ) spectra at times @xcite .
15 kev is dominated by another source .
the black _ rxte _ spectrum ( thin histogram ) from observation i d 70113 - 01 - 25 - 00 was taken on the same day as an _ integral _ observation of the region , and we argue in the text that it is very likely that the high energy flux comes from igr j163584726 .
the red _ rxte _ spectrum ( thick histogram ) comes from much later ( observation i d 90410 - 01 - 01 - 01 taken on mjd 53,114.410 ) , but the two spectra are very similar , suggesting that they may be from the same source.[fig : spectra_b],scaledwidth=52.0% ] | the black hole candidate ( bhc ) x - ray transient 4u 163047 continuously produced strong x - ray emission for over 2 years during its 20022004 outburst , which is one of the brightest and longest outbursts ever seen from this source .
we use over 300 observations made with the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer ( rxte ) _ to study the source throughout the outburst along with hard x - ray images from the _ international gamma - ray astrophysics laboratory _ , which are critical for interpreting the _ rxte _ data in this crowded field .
the source exhibits extreme behaviors , which can be interpreted as an indication that the system luminosity approaches the eddington limit . for 15 observations , fitting the spectral continuum with a disk - blackbody plus power - law model results in measured
inner disk temperatures between 2.7 and 3.8 kev , and such temperatures are only rivaled by the brightest bhc systems such as grs 1915 + 105 and xte j1550564 .
if the high temperatures are caused by the dominance of electron scattering opacity in the inner regions of the accretion disk , it is theoretically required that the source luminosity is considerably higher than 20% of the eddington limit .
we detect a variety of high - amplitude variability , including hard 10100 s flares , which peak at levels as much as 23 times higher than non - flare levels .
this flaring occurs at the highest disk luminosities in a regime where the source deviates from the @xmath0 relationship that is seen at lower luminosities , possibly suggesting that we are seeing transitions between a shakura & sunyaev disk and a `` slim '' disk , which is predicted to occur at very high mass accretion rates .
the x - ray properties in 20022004 are significantly different from those seen during the 1998 outburst , which is the only outburst with detected radio jet emission .
our results support the `` jet - line '' concept recently advanced by fender and co - workers .
our study allows for a test of the quantitative mcclintock & remillard spectral state definitions , and we find that these definitions alone do not provide a complete description of the outburst .
finally , for several of the observations , the high energy emission is dominated by the nearby sources igr j163204751 and igr j163584726 , and we provide information on when these sources were bright and on the nature of their energy spectra . |
ground - breaking papers are extreme events @xcite in science
. they can transform the way in which researchers do science in terms of the subjects they choose , the methods they use , and the way they present their results .
the related spreading of ideas has been described as an epidemic percolation process in a social network @xcite .
however , the impact of most innovations is limited .
there are only a few ideas , which gain attention all over the world and across disciplinary boundaries @xcite .
typical examples are elementary particle physics , the theory of evolution , superconductivity , neural networks , chaos theory , systems biology , nanoscience , or network theory .
it is still a puzzle , however , how a new idea and its proponent can be successful , given that they must beat the rich - gets - richer dynamics of already established ideas and scientists . according to the matthew effect @xcite , famous scientists receive an amount of credit that may sometimes appear disproportionate to their actual contributions , to the detriment of younger or less known scholars .
this implies a great authority of a small number of scientists , which is reflected by the big attention received by their work and ideas , and of the scholars working with them @xcite .
therefore , how can a previously unknown scientist establish at all a high scientific reputation and authority , if those who get a lot of citations receive even more over time ? here
we shed light on this puzzle .
the following results for @xmath0 nobel prize laureates in chemistry , economics , medicine and physics suggest that innovators can gain reputation and innovations can successfully spread , mainly _ because _ a scientist s body of work overall enjoys a greater impact after the publication of a landmark paper .
not only do colleagues notice the ground - breaking paper , but the latter also attracts the attention to older publications of the same author ( see fig .
[ h ] in 1989 and is the most cited work of fenn , with currently over @xmath1 citations .
the diagram reports the growth in time of the total number of citations received by this landmark paper ( blue solid line ) and by six older papers .
the diagram indicates that the number of citations of the landmark paper has literally exploded in the first years after its appearance .
however , after its publication in 1989 , a number of other papers also enjoyed a much higher citation rate .
thus , a sizeable part of previous scientific work has reached a big impact after the publication of the landmark paper .
we found that the occurrence of this boosting effect is characteristic for successful scientific careers . ] consequently , _ future _ papers have an impact on _ past _ papers , as their relevance is newly weighted .
we focus here on citations as indicator of scientific impact @xcite , studying data from the isi web of science , but the use of click streams @xcite would be conceivable as well .
it is well - known that the relative number of citations correlates with research quality @xcite .
citations are now regularly used in university rankings @xcite , in academic recruitments and for the distribution of funds among scholars and scientific institutions @xcite .
we evaluated data for @xmath0 nobel prize laureates that were awarded in the last two decades ( @xmath2-@xmath3 ) , which include an impressive number of about @xmath4 million citations .
for all of them and other internationally established experts as well , we find peaks in the changes of their citation rates ( figs . 2 and 3 ) .
[ h ] for nobel laureates [ here for ( a ) mario r. capecchi ( medicine , 2007 ) , ( b ) john c. mather ( physics , 2006 ) , ( c ) roger y. tsien ( chemistry , 2008 ) and ( d ) roger b. myerson ( economics , 2007 ) ] .
sharp peaks indicate citation boosts in favor of older papers , triggered by the publication and recognition of a landmark paper .
insets : the peaks even persist ( though somewhat smaller ) , if in the determination of the citation counts @xmath5 , the landmark paper is skipped ( which is defined as the paper that produces the largest reduction in the peak size , when excluded from the computation of the boost factor ) .
we conclude that the observed citation boosts are mostly due to a collective effect involving several publications rather than due to the high citation rate of the landmark paper itself . ]
[ h ] versus traditional citation variables .
each panel displays the time histories of four variables : the boost factor @xmath6 , the average number of citations per paper @xmath7 , the cumulative number of citations @xmath8 , and the @xmath9-index earned until year @xmath10 @xcite .
the panels refer to the same nobel laureates as displayed in fig .
the classical indices have relatively smooth profiles , i.e. they are not very sensitive to extreme events in the life of a scientist like the publication of landmark papers .
an advantage of the boost factor is that its peaks allow one to identify scientific breakthroughs earlier . ]
moreover , it is always possible to attribute to these peaks landmark papers ( fig .
4 ) , which have reached hundreds of citations over the period of a decade .
we first determined the ranks of all papers of an author based on the total number of citations received until the year @xmath3 inclusively .
we then determined the rank of that particular publication , which had the greatest contribution to the peak .
this was done by measuring the reduction in the height of the peak , when the paper was excluded from the calculation of the boost factor ( as in the insets of fig .
the distribution of the ranks of `` landmark papers '' is dominated by low values , implying that they are indeed among the top publications of their authors . ]
such landmark papers are rare even in the lives of the most excellent scientists , but some authors have several such peaks . technically , we detect a groundbreaking article @xmath11 published at time @xmath12 by comparing the citation rates before and after @xmath13 for the earlier papers .
the analysis proceeds as follows : given a year @xmath10 and a time window @xmath14 , we take all papers of the studied author that were published since the beginning of his / her career until year @xmath10 .
the citation rate @xmath15 measures the average number of citations received per paper per year in the period from @xmath16 to @xmath10 .
similarly , the citation rate @xmath17 measures the average number of citations received by the same publications per paper per year between @xmath18 and @xmath19 ( or @xmath3 , if @xmath19 exceeds @xmath3 ) . the ratio @xmath20 , which we call the `` boost factor '' , is a variable that detects critical events in the life of a scientist : sudden increases in the citation rates ( as illustrated by fig .
1 ) show up as peaks in the time - dependent plot of @xmath21 . in our analysis we used the generalized boost factor @xmath6 , which reduces the influence of random variations in the citation rates ( see materials and methods ) .
figure 2 shows typical plots of the boost factors @xmath6 of four nobel prize laureates .
interestingly , peaks are even found , when those papers , which mostly contribute to them , are _ excluded _ from the analysis ( see insets of fig .
that is , the observed increases in the citation rates are not just due to the landmark papers themselves , but rather to a collective effect , namely an increase in the citation rates of _ previously _ published papers .
this results from the greater visibility that the body of work of the corresponding scientist receives after the publication of a landmark paper and establishes an increased scientific impact ( `` authority '' ) . from the perspective of attention economics @xcite , it may be interpreted as a herding effect resulting from the way in which relevant information is collectively discovered in an information - rich environment .
interestingly , we have found that older papers receiving a boost are not always works related to the topic of the landmark paper .
traditional citation analysis does not reveal such crucial events in the life of a scientist very well .
figure 3 shows the time history of three classical citation indices : the average number of citations per paper @xmath7 , the cumulative number @xmath8 of citations , and the hirsch index @xcite ( @xmath22-index ) @xmath23 in year @xmath10 . for comparison ,
the evolution of the boost factor @xmath6 is depicted as well .
all indices were divided by their maximum value , in order to normalize them and to use the same scale for all .
the profiles of the classical indices are rather smooth in most cases , and it is often very hard to see any significant effects of landmark papers
. however , this is not surprising , as the boost factor is designed to capture abrupt variations in the citation rates , while both @xmath8 and @xmath23 reflect the overall production of a scientist and are therefore less sensitive to extreme events . to gain a better understanding of our findings , figs . 4 and 5 present a statistical analysis of the boosts observed for nobel prize laureates .
[ h ] and @xmath14 .
the power law fits ( lines ) are performed with the maximum likelihood method @xcite .
the exponents for the direct distribution ( of which the cumulative distribution is the integral ) are : @xmath24 ( top left ) , @xmath25 ( bottom left ) , @xmath26 ( top right ) , @xmath27 ( bottom right ) .
the best fits have the following lower cutoffs and values of the kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) statistics : @xmath28 , @xmath29 ( top left ) , @xmath30 , @xmath31 ( bottom left ) , @xmath32 , @xmath33 ( top right ) , @xmath34 , @xmath35 ( bottom right ) .
the ks values support the power law ansatz for the shape of the curves .
still , we point out that on the left plots the data span just one decade in the variable , so one has to be careful about the existence of power laws here . ]
figure 4 demonstrates that pronounced peaks are indeed related to highly cited papers .
furthermore , fig .
5 analyzes the size distribution of peaks .
the distribution looks like a power law for all choices of the parameters @xmath14 and @xmath36 ( at least within the relevant range of small values ) .
this suggests that the bursts are produced by citation cascades as they would occur in a self - organized critical system @xcite .
in fact , power laws were found to result from human interactions also in other contexts @xcite .
the mechanism underlying citation cascades is the discovery of new ideas , which colleagues refer to in the references of their papers .
moreover , according to the rich - gets - richer effect , successful papers are more often cited , also to raise their own success .
innovations may even cause scientists to change their research direction or approach .
apparently , such feedback effects can create citation cascades , which are ultimately triggered by landmark papers . finally , it is important to check whether the boost factor is able to distinguish exceptional scientists from average ones . since any criteria used to define `` normal scientists ''
may be questioned , we have assembled a set of scientists taken at random .
scientists were chosen among those who published at least one paper in the year 2000 .
we selected @xmath37 names for each of four fields : medicine , physics , chemistry and economy .
after discarding those with no citations , we ended up with @xmath38 scientists . in fig .
6 we draw on a bidimensional plane each scientist of our random sample ( empty circles ) , together with the nobel prize laureates considered ( full circles ) .
the two dimensions are the value of the boost factor and the average number of citations of a scientist .
a cluster analysis separates the populations in the proportions of @xmath39 to @xmath40 .
the separation is significant but there is an overlap of the two datasets , mainly because of two reasons .
first , by picking a large number of scientists at random , as we did , there is a finite probability to choose also outstanding scholars .
we have verified that this is the case .
therefore , some of the empty circles deserve to sit on the top - right part of the diagram , like many nobel prize laureates .
the second reason is that we are considering scholars from different disciplines , which generally have different citation frequencies .
this affects particularly the average number of citations of a scientist , but also the value of the boost factor . in this way , the position in the diagram is affected by the specific research topic , and the distribution of the points in the diagram of fig .
6 is a superposition of field - specific distributions .
nevertheless , the two datasets , though overlapping , are clearly distinct . adding further dimensions could considerably improve the result . in this respect
, the boost factor can be used together with other measures to better specify the performance of scientists .
in summary , groundbreaking scientific papers have a boosting effect on previous publications of their authors , bringing them to the attention of the scientific community and establishing their `` authority '' .
we have provided the first quantitative characterization of this phenomenon by introducing a new variable , the `` boost factor '' , which is sensitive to sudden changes in the citation rates .
the fact that landmark papers trigger the collective discovery of older papers amplifies their impact and tends to generate pronounced spikes long before the paper receives full recognition .
the boosting factor can therefore serve to discover new breakthroughs and talents more quickly than classical citation indices . it may also help to assemble good research teams , which have a pivotal role in modern science @xcite .
the power law behavior observed in the distribution of peak sizes suggests that science progresses through phase transitions @xcite with citation avalanches on all scales from small cascades reflecting quasi - continuous scientific progress all the way up to scientific revolutions , which fundamentally change our perception of the world .
while this provides new evidence for sudden paradigm shifts @xcite , our results also give a better idea of why and how they happen .
it is noteworthy that similar feedback effects may determine the social influence of politicians , or prices of stocks and products ( and , thereby , the value of companies ) .
in fact , despite the long history of research on these subjects , such phenomena are still not fully understood .
there is evidence , however , that the power of a person or the value of a company increase with the level of attention they enjoy .
consequently , our study of scientific impact is likely to shed new light on these scientific puzzles as well .
the basic goal is to improve the signal - to - noise ratio in the citation rates , in order to detect sudden changes in them .
an effective method to reduce the influence of papers with largely fluctuating citation rates is to weight highly cited papers more .
this can be achieved by raising the number of cites to the power @xmath36 , where @xmath41 .
therefore , our formula to compute @xmath6 looks as follows : @xmath42 here , @xmath43 is the number of cites received by paper @xmath44 in year @xmath45 .
the sum over @xmath44 includes all papers published before the year @xmath10 ; @xmath14 is the time window selected to compute the boosting effect . for @xmath46 we recover the original definition of @xmath21 ( see main text ) . for the analysis presented in the paper we have used @xmath47 and @xmath48 , but our conclusions are not very sensitive to the choice of smaller values of @xmath36 and @xmath14 .
we acknowledge the use of isi web of science data of thomson reuters for our citation analysis .
a.m. , s.l . and d.h .
were partially supported by the future and emerging technologies programme fp7-cosi - ict of the european commission through the project qlectives ( grant no . :
h . e. and s. f. gratefully acknowledge ictecollective , grant 238597 of the european commission .
0.5 cm boyack kw , brner k ( 2003 ) indicator - assisted evaluation and funding of research : visualizing the influence of grants on the number and citation counts of research papers .
j am soc inf sci technol 54 : 447461 . | nobel prizes are commonly seen to be among the most prestigious achievements of our times .
based on mining several million citations , we quantitatively analyze the processes driving paradigm shifts in science .
we find that groundbreaking discoveries of nobel prize laureates and other famous scientists are not only acknowledged by many citations of their landmark papers .
surprisingly , they also boost the citation rates of their previous publications .
given that innovations must outcompete the rich - gets - richer effect for scientific citations , it turns out that they can make their way only through citation cascades .
a quantitative analysis reveals how and why they happen .
science appears to behave like a self - organized critical system , in which citation cascades of all sizes occur , from continuous scientific progress all the way up to scientific revolutions , which change the way we see our world .
measuring the `` boosting effect '' of landmark papers , our analysis reveals how new ideas and new players can make their way and finally triumph in a world dominated by established paradigms .
the underlying `` boost factor '' is also useful to discover scientific breakthroughs and talents much earlier than through classical citation analysis , which by now has become a widespread method to measure scientific excellence , influencing scientific careers and the distribution of research funds .
our findings reveal patterns of collective social behavior , which are also interesting from an attention economics perspective .
understanding the origin of scientific authority may therefore ultimately help to explain , how social influence comes about and why the value of goods depends so strongly on the attention they attract . |
one of the basic unsolved problems of dissipative quantum mechanics and quantum transport through mesoscopic systems is the nonequilibrium kondo model . in its simplest version ,
it consists of a spin-@xmath1 system coupled via exchange processes to the spins of two fermionic reservoirs , which are kept at two different chemical potentials @xmath2 , see fig .
[ fig : kondo ] . besides the importance of the kondo model for many aspects of strongly correlated fermion systems ( see ref . for an overview ) , it was suggested to realize this model in transport experiments through quantum dots.@xcite this has been achieved @xcite with the particular advantage of full control over all parameters such as temperature , voltage , magnetic field , and exchange couplings . the central idea is to lower temperature and bias voltage such that only one single - particle level of a quantum dot will contribute to transport .
adjusting the gate voltage such that charge fluctuations of this level are suppressed ( coulomb blockade regime ) , the dot can either be occupied by a spin up or a spin down electron , and the spin can fluctuate via second - order cotunneling processes , leading precisely to the model depicted in fig .
[ fig : kondo ] . in this realization ,
one obtains an antiferromagnetic exchange coupling of the order @xmath3 ( in dimensionless units ) , where @xmath4 is the density of states in the reservoirs , @xmath5 denotes the tunneling amplitude ( hopping parameter ) between the leads and the dot , and @xmath6 is the energy of the virtual intermediate state ( charging energy ) . quantum system coupled via exchange to two reservoirs . @xmath7 and @xmath8 involve exchange between the spins of the left / right reservoir with the local spin , and @xmath9 transfers a particle from one reservoir to the other during the exchange process . ] in equilibrium ,
the kondo model has been analyzed by various many - body methods ( for an overview , see ref . ) and can be solved exactly by bethe ansatz @xcite or conformal field theory.@xcite powerful numerical techniques such as the numerical renormalization group have been developed @xcite from which all thermodynamic and spectral properties can be calculated .
the basic physics can already be understood from poor man scaling arguments.@xcite if all exchange couplings are the same @xmath10 , one obtains the renormalization group ( rg ) equation @xmath11 with the solution @xmath12 here , @xmath13 is the kondo temperature and @xmath14 denotes an effective exchange coupling corresponding to an effective band width @xmath15 of the reservoirs ( @xmath16 is the original band width ) . for the antiferromagnetic case @xmath17 ,
one obtains an enhancement of the exchange coupling by reducing the effective band width until @xmath15 reaches @xmath13 , where @xmath14 diverges .
this indicates a logarithmic enhancement of the linear conductance for temperatures above the kondo temperature ( weak - coupling regime ) , and a complete screening of the dot spin by the reservoir spins below @xmath13 ( strong - coupling regime ) . in the latter case
, it can be shown that the conductance becomes unitary , i.e. , @xmath18 , at zero temperature @xmath19 and zero bias voltage @xmath20 . in nonequilibrium
, the kondo model is not yet solved completely .
some numerical techniques have already been developed to describe either the time evolution of an out - of - equilibrium initial state by using time - dependent numerical renormalization group ( td - nrg ) ( ref . ) or to describe the stationary current in the presence of a bias by using nrg in a scattering wave basis @xcite or using an iterative real - time path integral approach.@xcite scattering wave bethe ansatz methods based on the lippmann - schwinger equation are currently under way to solve the single - impurity anderson model in nonequilibrium.@xcite concerning analytical rg methods , it has been emphasized that it is important to understand how the rg equations are cut off by the bias voltage and by relaxation and dephasing rates.@xcite the problem can be stated as follows .
performing perturbation theory in the bare exchange coupling @xmath21 ( disregarding for the moment the differences between @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 ) , logarithmic terms occur , which , at zero temperature and depending on the physical observable under consideration , have the form [ we indicate only the order in the exchange coupling leaving out numbers of @xmath25 and other physical energy scales from @xmath26 and @xmath27 in the prefactor ] @xmath28 with @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 . here
, @xmath32 is the current , @xmath33 are the spin relaxation / dephasing rates , @xmath34 is the renormalized @xmath0 factor , and @xmath35 denotes the magnetization .
@xmath36 is the band width of the reservoirs and @xmath27 is the bare magnetic field .
@xmath37 denotes the number of particles transferred between the reservoirs and @xmath31 characterizes whether spin flip processes occur or not .
the points @xmath38 correspond to resonance positions , where certain higher - order processes are allowed by energy conservation , e.g. , the value @xmath39 corresponds to the onset of inelastic cotunneling processes.@xcite higher - order terms with @xmath40 have so far not been discussed in the literature for the kondo model , but are generically expected @xcite ( for other models in the charge fluctuation regime , corresponding terms have been calculated in ref . ) . for given perturbation order @xmath41 , the allowed values for @xmath42 depend on the value of @xmath37 .
for @xmath43 it is known that @xmath44 . even in the weak - coupling regime @xmath45
the logarithmic terms can lead to a breakdown of perturbation theory if @xmath46 is small enough such that @xmath47 . furthermore , at resonance @xmath38 , the logarithmic terms even diverge .
therefore , it is necessary to resum the logarithmic terms in an appropriate way using rg and , at the same time , introduce the physics of relaxation and dephasing rates to cut off the divergencies at resonance .
this idea has been proposed in ref . .
in a first step , within a standard poor man scaling approach , one resums all leading order logarithmic terms of the form @xmath48 where @xmath49 depends on the physical observable under consideration [ see eq .
( [ log_pert ] ) ] .
this leads to an effective exchange coupling @xmath50 , given by eq .
( [ solution_poor_man_scaling ] ) evaluated at @xmath51 : @xmath52 in a second step , one tries to expand the physical observable systematically in powers of the effective coupling constant @xmath50 , leading to a series with terms similiar to eq .
( [ log_pert ] ) , but with the replacements @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
if , in addition , one cuts off the resonances by an appropriate relaxation or dephasing rate @xmath55 , a new series of the form @xmath56 is expected , where @xmath57 is the renormalized magnetic field . as pointed out in ref .
this perturbation series in @xmath50 is well - defined for @xmath58 , because the maximum value of the logarithm at resonance is given by @xmath59 , where we have used the rough estimate @xmath60 based on a simple dimensional analysis .
therefore , at resonance , we expect terms of the form @xmath61 which are not dangerous since @xmath62 if @xmath58 ( note that @xmath63 ) .
the leading order result is the term @xmath64 ( denoted as one - loop in this paper ) , whereas the first logarithmic correction @xmath65 is the first subleading term ( denoted as two - loop in this paper ) .
the purpose of the present paper is to present a well - defined two - loop rg approach to work out the above - described procedure .
thereby we will apply a recently proposed real - time renormalization group method in frequency space ( rtrg - fs).@xcite this method has the advantage that formally exact rg equations can be set up in nonequilibrium which include the relaxation and dephasing rates in all resolvents appearing on the right hand side ( r.h.s . ) of the rg equations .
furthermore , in leading order , precisely poor man scaling equation ( [ poor_man_scaling ] ) is obtained .
this provides the possibility to proceed in two steps : first one expands the exact rg equations systematically around the poor man scaling solution for @xmath66 , and , in the second step , one solves the rg equations perturbatively in @xmath50 for @xmath67 .
as we will show in this paper , in both steps two - loop terms are important to obtain the first logarithmic corrections beyond leading order . in the first step , two - loop terms arising from higher - order terms on the r.h.s . of the rg equation
generate terms @xmath68 which depend only weakly on the voltage and are incorporated into a redefinition of the coupling constant @xmath50 ( or , equivalently , the kondo temperature ) .
these terms lead to an overall increase ( or decrease ) in the physical observable under consideration but show no interesting dependence on voltage or magnetic field .
in contrast , in the second step , logarithmic contributions of form ( [ log_rg ] ) are generated which give rise to a logarithmic enhancement ( suppression ) at resonance .
this means that the various two - loop terms ( leading all to terms of the same order of magnitude ) can be systematically divided into important and unimportant terms concerning their dependence on voltage and magnetic field . in accordance with results of refs . and
, we emphasize that it is very important to include the frequency dependence of the vertices generated from the first step @xmath66 since this influences the prefactor of the logarithmic contributions calculated in the second step @xmath69 . in one - loop order ( but including certain two - loop terms from the frequency dependence of the vertices ) , the conductance and the magnetization have been calculated previously for the nonequilibrium kondo model .
pioneering works are refs . and , where the slave particle approach was used in combination with the keldysh formalism and quantum boltzmann equations .
the rg was formulated only on one part of the keldysh contour and a real - frequency cutoff was used . in these works , it was investigated how the voltage and the magnetic field cut off the rg flow and it was emphasized that the frequency dependence of the vertices is important to obtain the first logarithmic contributions beyond leading order . in fact , the result of the present paper concerning the conductance and the magnetization is precisely the same as that of refs . and , up to the redefinition of the kondo temperature .
this means that we will prove in this paper that all two - loop contributions neglected in refs . and do not influence the prefactor of the first logarithmic correction beyond leading order . furthermore , in refs . and
, diagrams connecting the upper with the lower part of the keldysh contour have been neglected . within these works , it was therefore not possible to describe the cutoff of the logarithmic terms by relaxation and dephasing rates on a full microscopic level . in this paper
, we will show how this can be achieved within rtrg - fs , which provides a consistent formalism to calculate the line shape at resonance and to see whether the spin relaxation rate @xmath70 or the spin dephasing rate @xmath71 cuts off the logarithmic divergencies ( in ref .
, the latter question was adressed only in bare perturbation theory and zero magnetic field ) .
in addition , in this paper we will also discuss the anisotropic case and calculate the spin relaxation / dephasing rates together with the renormalized @xmath0 factor up to the first logarithmic contribution ( corresponding to a three - loop calculation in conventional rg methods ) .
besides the known reduction in the magnetic field in first order in @xmath14,@xcite we find that the renormalized magnetic field in second order in @xmath14 is proportional to logarithmic terms similiar to eq .
( [ log_rg ] ) with a significant dependence on voltage and magnetic field .
we propose an experimental setup with a weakly coupled third lead to measure the voltage dependence of the renormalized @xmath0 factor .
moreover , we find that the logarithmic terms of @xmath71 and @xmath34 are controlled by @xmath70 , whereas those of @xmath70 are controlled by @xmath71 . in the anisotropic case
this leads to the effect that the logarithmic resonances of @xmath72 become sharper with decreasing @xmath73 since @xmath70 does not contain any terms proportional to @xmath74 in second order . furthermore , we will show that the susceptibility depends only weakly on the tranverse coupling @xmath73 and the logarithmic resonances even survive in the limit @xmath75 .
the anisotropic kondo model has recently been proposed to be realizable in low - temperature transport through single molecular magnets @xcite and experiments are starting to investigate such systems.@xcite since the transverse coupling is induced by small magnetic quantum tunneling terms , giving rise to rather small kondo temperatures , the susceptibility might be an interesting physical quantity to measure signatures of the kondo effect even for very small values of @xmath73 . using flow equation methods,@xcite a consistent two - loop approach including the cutoff by spin relaxation / dephasing rates has been presented in ref . for the isotropic kondo model in the absence of a magnetic field .
within this method , the cutoff from the rate @xmath55 occurs due to a competition of certain one - loop and two - loop terms on the r.h.s . of the rg equation for the vertex .
this is a completely different picture compared to rtrg - fs , where the cutoff parameter @xmath55 together with the voltage occurs already in the one - loop terms as an additional term in the denominator of the resolvents .
thus , the rtrg - fs method is closer to conventional poor man scaling and the physics of relaxation and dephasing rates occurs naturally as a resummation of a geometric series similiar to self - energy insertions in green s function techniques . in this sense
the rtrg - fs method proves that conventional scaling equations ( properly generalized to the keldysh contour ) can account for the cutoff of the rg flow by rates and the voltage .
furthermore , the rtrg - fs method provides a generic proof in all orders of perturbation theory in the renormalized vertices that the various cutoff scales @xmath76 are the physical relaxation and dephasing rates governing the time evolution of the reduced density matrix of the quantum system .
the rtrg - fs method used in this paper has been proposed in ref . and is a natural generalization of an earlier developed real - time rg method.@xcite as described in detail in ref .
, many technical improvements have been incorporated , the main ones being a formulation of the rg in pure frequency space , integrating out the symmetric part of the fermi distribution function before starting the rg , and formulating the nonequilibrium rg on the imaginary frequency axis . as a consequence , the rates determining the cutoff of the rg flow
obtain the right scale , and it is possible to show generically that relaxation and dephasing rates cut off the rg flow in all orders of perturbation theory and within all truncation schemes .
furthermore , the dependence on the keldysh indices can be completely avoided , and one can calculate the time evolution and the nonequilibrium stationary state in pure matsubara space without the need of any analytic continuation .
the latter idea has first been proposed in ref . in the context of nonequilibrium functional renormalization group within the keldysh formalism .
a particular advantage of the rtrg - fs method is that relaxation and dephasing rates occur naturally as the negative imaginary part of the eigenvalue of the kernel determining the kinetic equation of the reduced density matrix , and do not arise from more involved combinations of self - energies and vertex corrections as in slave particle formalism.@xcite furthermore , it is straightforward to calculate the time evolution from rtrg - fs since the rg gives directly the result for the kernel in laplace space .
for generic problems with spin and/or orbital fluctuations , it was described in ref . how to solve the rg equations analytically in the weak coupling regime up to one - loop order .
in this paper we will provide the technically much more involved two - loop case , which is necessary to calculate consistently the important logarithmic terms at resonance discussed above , see eq .
( [ log_rg ] ) .
the result will be applied to the calculation of the conductance and the magnetic susceptibility of the anisotropic kondo model in the presence of a magnetic field .
furthermore , we will also analyze quantities characterizing the time evolution of the kondo model .
thereby , we will concentrate on the calculation of the dominant exponential decay of the magnetization in two - loop order , which is determined by the spin relaxation and dephasing rates @xmath77 and the renormalized magnetic field @xmath57 . finally , in addition to ref .
, we will generically show that precisely these physical quantities control all resonant line shapes ( in ref .
, the question whether the cutoff scales of the logarithmic terms are exactly identical to the physical relaxation / dephasing rates was still open ) .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : generic_model ] , we will set up the generic model and the perturbative series .
section [ sec : rg_equations ] is devoted to the general rg formalism and the derivation of the two - loop rg equations for an arbitrary quantum dot coupled via spin and/or orbital fluctuations to reservoirs .
the systematic way to analytically solve these rg equations up to two - loop order is presented in sec .
[ sec : generic_2_loop ] .
the general formalism is applied to the nonequilibrium kondo model in sec .
[ sec : kondo ] . in sec .
[ sec : kondo_model_algebra ] , we will set up the algebra in liouville space needed to evaluate all expressions explicitly , and sec .
[ sec : kondo_2_loop ] describes the evaluation of the general two - loop equations for the kondo model .
the final results for the conductance , the magnetic susceptibility , the spin relaxation and dephasing rate , and the renormalized @xmath0 factor are presented for the isotropic case in secs .
[ sec : relaxation_dephasing_rates ] , [ sec : magnetization ] and [ sec : current ] , whereas the anisotropic case is discussed in section [ sec : kondo_results_anisotropic ] .
we close with a summary in sec .
[ sec : conclusion ] .
a list of all symbols used in this papers is presented in sec .
[ sec : list_of_symbols ] .
we emphasize that a reader , who is not interested in the formal derivation but only in the final physical results of the paper , can skip the following formal secs .
[ sec : generic ] and [ sec : kondo ] , and can directly move over to sec .
[ sec : kondo_results ] , where the notations needed to understand the results are again repeated .
in this section , we describe a generic quantum dot coupled via spin and/or orbital fluctuations to several reservoirs . in secs . [
sec : generic_model ] and [ sec : rg_equations ] , we introduce the basic notations , the perturbative series and summarize shortly the setup of the rg equations as explained in more detail in ref . .
in sec . [ sec : generic_2_loop ] , we present a systematic way how to solve the rg equations analytically up to two - loop order in the weak - coupling regime ( the one - loop case has been treated in ref . ) . throughout this paper ,
we use units @xmath78 . _ model .
_ we consider a quantum dot with fixed charge in the coulomb blockade regime where only spin and/or orbital fluctuations are possible via the coupling to external reservoirs . as shown in detail in ref .
, a standard schrieffer - wolff transformation leads to a hamiltonian of the form @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the reservoir part , @xmath81 characterizes the isolated quantum dot , and @xmath26 describes the coupling between reservoirs and quantum dot .
they are given explicitly by @xmath82 here , @xmath83 are the creation ( @xmath84 ) and annihilation ( @xmath85 ) operators of the reservoirs , and @xmath86 is an index characterizing all quantum numbers of the reservoir states . in the absence of further symmetries , @xmath86 contains the reservoir index @xmath87 and the spin quantum number @xmath88 ( for two reservoirs and spin-@xmath1 particles , we use the notation @xmath89 and @xmath90 ) .
@xmath91 is the energy of the reservoir state relative to the chemical potential @xmath92 of reservoir @xmath87 .
the eigenstates and eigenenergies of the isolated quantum dot are denoted by @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
the interaction @xmath26 is quadratic in the reservoir field operators , which arises from second - order processes of one electron hopping off and on the quantum dot coherently ( for negative charging energies , also two electrons can hop off or on the dot @xcite ) .
this keeps the charge fixed and allows only spin and orbital fluctuations .
the coupling vertex @xmath95 is an arbitrary operator acting on the dot states .
it is written in its most general form , depending on the quantum numbers and energies of the reservoir states in an arbitrary way . however , as explained in ref .
, the rg approach can be set up in its most convenient form if one assumes that the frequency dependence of the initial vertices is rather weak and varies on the scale of the band width @xmath36 of the reservoirs .
therefore , we will assume this in the following and introduce below [ see eq .
( [ cutoff_contraction ] ) ] a convenient cutoff function into the free reservoir green s functions . to achieve a more compact notation for all indices
, we write @xmath96 and sum ( integrate ) implicitly over all indices and frequencies . the interaction
is then written in the compact form @xmath97 @xmath98 denotes normal ordering of the reservoir field operators , meaning that no contraction is allowed between reservoir field operators within the normal ordering .
a contraction is defined with respect to a grand - canonical distribution of the reservoirs , given by @xmath99 @xmath100 is the fermi distribution function corresponding to temperature @xmath101 ( note that the chemical potential does not enter this formula since @xmath91 is measured relative to @xmath92 ) .
furthermore , @xmath102 is the @xmath103 function in compact notation , and @xmath104 .
the cutoff by the band width @xmath36 can be introduced in many different ways into the reservoir contraction .
we use a lorentzian cutoff and replace the contraction by @xmath105 with @xmath106 within the normal ordering of eq .
( [ spin_orbital ] ) , the field operators can be arranged in an arbitrary way ( up to a fermionic sign ) , therefore the coupling vertex can always be chosen such that antisymmetry holds , @xmath107 furthermore , due to the hermiticity of @xmath26 , the vertex has the property @xmath108 the particle current operator flowing from reservoir @xmath109 to the quantum dot is defined by @xmath110 $ ] , where @xmath111 is the particle number in reservoir @xmath109 . using eqs .
( [ h_total ] ) and ( [ coupling ] ) , a straightforward calculation leads to @xmath112 with @xmath113 we are interested in the time evolution of the reduced density matrix @xmath114 of the quantum dot and in the average @xmath115 of the current operator .
formally , they follow from the solution of the von neumann equation @xmath116 where @xmath117_-
\quad,\quad l_{i^\gamma}\,=\,{i\over 2}\,[i^\gamma,\cdot]_+\ ] ] are operators in liouville space acting on usual operators in hilbert space via the ( anti)commutator @xmath118_\pm = ab\pm ba$ ] .
initially , we have assumed that the density matrix is a product of an arbitrary dot part @xmath119 and a grandcanonical distribution @xmath120 for the reservoirs .
it is convenient to introduce the laplace transform @xmath121 _ perturbative expansion . _
the next step is to expand expressions ( [ laplace_rho ] ) and ( [ laplace_current ] ) in the interacting part @xmath122_-$ ] of the liouvillian and to integrate out the reservoir part . as outlined in detail in ref .
, this leads to a diagrammatic representation in liouville space .
we shortly summarize this procedure here .
first , @xmath123 can be written in the form @xmath124 where @xmath125 is a quantum field superoperator in liouville space for the reservoirs , defined by ( @xmath126 is an arbitrary reservoir operator ) @xmath127 @xmath128 is the keldysh index indicating whether the field operator is acting on the upper or the lower part of the keldysh contour .
@xmath129 is a superoperator acting in liouville space of the quantum dot , and is defined by ( @xmath126 is an arbitrary operator of the quantum dot ) @xmath130 inserting the form ( [ coupling_product ] ) into eqs .
( [ laplace_rho ] ) and ( [ laplace_current ] ) , expanding in @xmath123 , and shifting all reservoir field superoperators @xmath131 to the right , one can show that each term of perturbation theory can be written as a product of a dot part and an average over a sequence of field superoperators of the reservoirs with respect to @xmath120 . evaluating the latter with the help of wick s theorem
, one can represent each term of the wick decomposition by a diagram , see , e.g. , fig .
[ fig : diagram_example ] describing a certain process for the time evolution of the reduced density matrix of the dot . between the local quantum system and the reservoirs .
each vertex corresponds to two adjacent dots indicating that two reservoir field operators are associated with each vertex .
the horizontal lines connecting the vertices denote the free time propagation of the quantum system , leading to the resolvents @xmath132 in laplace space .
the lines connecting the dots are the reservoir contractions arising from the application of wick s theorem .
the dashed vertical lines between the vertices are auxiliary lines to determine the energy argument @xmath133 of the resolvents . ]
each process consists of a sequence of interaction vertices @xmath134 between the dot and the reservoirs , and a free time propagation of the dot in between ( leading to resolvents in laplace space ) .
since the reservoirs have been integrated out , the vertices are connected by reservoir contractions ( the solid lines without arrows in fig .
[ fig : diagram_example ] ) .
this means that the various diagrams represent terms for the effective time evolution of the dot in the presence of dissipative reservoirs .
each diagram for the reduced density matrix has the form @xmath135 where @xmath136_-\quad,\ ] ] @xmath137 indicates an interaction vertex , and @xmath138 is a contraction between the reservoir field superoperators , defined by @xmath139 to factorize the wick decomposition , a fermionic sign has to be assigned to each permutation of reservoir field superoperators , indicated by the sign factor @xmath140 in eq .
( [ value_diagram ] ) . for each pair of vertices connected by two reservoir lines , a combinatorical factor @xmath1 occurs , leading to the prefactor @xmath141 in eq .
( [ value_diagram ] ) .
the value of the frequencies @xmath133 in the resolvents between the interaction vertices is determined by the sum over all variables @xmath142 of those indices belonging to the reservoir lines which are crossed by a vertical line at the position of the resolvent ( see the dashed lines in fig . [
fig : diagram_example ] ) .
thereby , the index of the left vertex has to be taken of the corresponding reservoir line , e.g. , the diagram of fig .
[ fig : diagram_example ] is given by ( the obvious dependence on the keldysh indices has been omitted for simplicity , i.e. , @xmath143 and @xmath144 ) @xmath145 where the resolvents are defined by @xmath146 with @xmath147 as can be seen from example ( [ diagram_example ] ) , each diagram consists of a sequence of irreducible blocks ( where a vertical line always cuts at least one reservoir line ) and free resolvents @xmath148 in between .
similiar to dyson equations one can formally resum this series with the result @xmath149 with @xmath150 where the kernel @xmath151 contains the sum over all irreducible diagrams .
a similiar procedure can be used to calculate the average ( [ laplace_current ] ) of the current operator with the result @xmath152 where the current kernel @xmath153 is defined similiarly to @xmath151 , but the first vertex @xmath154 is replaced by the current vertex @xmath155 , defined by @xmath156 such that , in analogy to eq .
( [ coupling_product ] ) , @xmath157 using eq .
( [ value_diagram ] ) , a certain diagram for the kernels has to be translated according to @xmath158 where the subindex @xmath159 indicates that only irreducible diagrams are allowed where any vertical line between the vertices cuts through at least one reservoir contraction .
the stationary solutions for the reduced density matrix and the current follow from the laplace transform by @xmath160 and @xmath161 , and can be calculated from @xmath162 in addition to previous formulations @xcite of the perturbation series , we note that the diagrammatic series can be partially resummed by taking all closed subdiagrams between two fixed vertices together which contain only contractions connecting vertices between the two fixed ones .
this has the effect that the resolvents in eq .
( [ value_kernel ] ) are replaced by @xmath163 i.e. , the full effective liouville operator occurs in the denominator .
this means that eqs .
( [ l_eff ] ) and ( [ value_kernel ] ) turn into self - consistent equations for @xmath164 for any approximation .
of course , the number of diagrams is reduced in this formulation .
no diagrams are allowed anymore which contain closed subdiagrams between two vertices .
when calculating diagrams with the replacement ( [ resolvent_replacement ] ) , one faces the problem that the frequency integrations can not be performed analytically because the energy dependence of the effective liouvillian is not known .
this would require the solution of a complicated self - consistent integral equation . to avoid this ,
it is useful to formulate an appropriate approximation for the resolvents which can be improved systematically . to define this approximation
, we write the resolvents in terms of the eigenvectors and eigenvalues of the liouvillian @xmath165 , @xmath166 where the projectors are defined by @xmath167 and @xmath168 and @xmath169 are the right and left eigenvectors of @xmath165 , @xmath170 with eigenvalues @xmath171 . assuming that @xmath168 and @xmath169 have no poles ( or poles with very large negative imaginary part so that they influence only the short - time behaviour ) , the poles @xmath172 of the resolvent follow from the self - consistent equation @xmath173 for all values of @xmath174 .
expanding @xmath171 , @xmath168 , and @xmath169 around @xmath175 , we see that the nonanalytic part of the resolvent is given by @xmath176 with residua ( also called @xmath177 factors ) given by @xmath178 equation ( [ pi_nonanalytic_part ] ) defines our approximation which is the appropriate one to describe especially line shapes at resonance ( analytic parts are expected to have no special features at resonance and will only lead to an overall perturbative shift of the background ) . to avoid the summation index @xmath174 ,
we will write the approximation in the more compact form @xmath179 where we use the convention that any function of @xmath180 and @xmath181 is interpreted as @xmath182 the eigenvalues @xmath172 can be decomposed into real and imaginary parts @xmath183 and are the poles of the original full resolvent @xmath184 . according to eq .
( [ reduced_dm ] ) , this resolvent describes the reduced density matrix in laplace space .
therefore , the resolvent must be analytic in the upper half of the complex plane since otherwise solutions would exist in time space which are exponentially increasing and no stationary state can be reached .
thus , the negative imaginary parts @xmath185 must be strictly positive and describe the various relaxation and dephasing rates of the different modes described by the eigenvectors @xmath186 .
correspondingly , the real parts @xmath187 describe the oscillation frequencies of the modes , e.g. , the effective magnetic field for the kondo problem .
the renormalization group treatment described in the next section can be set up within the original perturbation series ( [ value_kernel ] ) or the partially resummed series using the replacement ( [ resolvent_replacement ] ) .
since we aim at a weak coupling expansion , the partially resummed series makes only sense if the full liouvillian is expanded in the same parameter as the renormalized vertices .
therefore , we will make use of the resummed series only at the end of the rg flow where perturbation theory in the renormalized couplings at a fixed physical cutoff scale can be used . for other problems like quantum dots in the charge fluctuation regime or systems in the strong coupling regime
, it might be helpful to use the resummed series from the very beginning .
finally , we note some useful symmetry properties for the vertices and the liouvillian ( see ref . for the proof ) , @xmath188 where @xmath189 and the @xmath190 transform @xmath191 of any dot operator @xmath126 in liouville space is defined by @xmath192 properties ( [ l_c_transform ] ) and ( [ sigma_i_c_transform ] ) are important to show in time space that the reduced density matrix of the dot stays hermitian and the current stays real .
property ( [ l_property ] ) leads to conservation of probability , i.e. , the normalization of the reduced density matrix stays constant . from this property
it also follows that @xmath165 has an eigenvector with zero eigenvalue : @xmath193 this eigenvector corresponds to the stationary state for @xmath194 and depends on the physical system under consideration .
in contrast , the corresponding left eigenvector is unique and , according to eq .
( [ l_property ] ) , is given by @xmath195 as a consequence , in combination with property ( [ g_property ] ) , we obtain zero if the left eigenvector for zero eigenvalue acts from the left on the vertex averaged over the keldysh indices : @xmath196 therefore , by decomposing the vertex according to @xmath197 we see that the zero eigenvalue of @xmath165 can only occur in the resolvents when the part @xmath198 of the vertex is standing right to the resolvent . therefore , to avoid this zero eigenvalue in the rg treatment , we will first use a certain perturbative treatment to eliminate the part @xmath198 of the vertex from the very beginning .
this is described in the next section .
_ first rg step .
_ the first discrete rg step consists in integrating out the symmetric part @xmath199={1\over 2}$ ] of the fermi function in the contraction ( [ liouville_contraction ] ) .
this part depends only weakly on the frequency and creates no logarithmic divergencies in perturbation theory .
furthermore , as explained in detail in ref . , it is the symmetric part of the fermi function which allows the zero eigenvalue of the effective liouvillian @xmath164 to occur in the resolvents between the vertices .
this part should be integrated out before starting the continuous rg in order to show that the renormalization of the vertices is cut off by relaxation and dephasing rates .
to get rid of the symmetric part , one decomposes the contraction ( [ liouville_contraction ] ) according to @xmath200 \,\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath201 . using this decomposition in eq .
( [ value_kernel ] ) , one finds that each diagram , which is irreducible with respect to the full contraction @xmath109 , decomposes into a series of blocks which are irreducible with respect to the symmetric part @xmath202 ( i.e. , any vertical line hits at least one symmetric contraction ) and connected to each other by antisymmetric contractions @xmath203 .
the blocks which are irreducible with respect to @xmath202 can be formally resummed into an effective liouvillian @xmath204 or into effective vertices @xmath205 , which obtain an additional energy variable to account for the reservoir contractions which cross over the effective quantities .
the lowest - order diagrams for @xmath206 and @xmath207 are shown in fig .
[ fig : discrete_lg ] .
( @xmath208 ) denotes the symmetric ( antisymmetric ) contraction @xmath202 ( @xmath203 ) . ]
the first two diagrams correspond to the effective liouvillian ( no free lines ) and the third one to the effective vertex ( since two lines are free ) . using the diagrammatic rules ( [ value_kernel ] ) together with eq .
( [ contraction_decomposition ] ) and the convention ( [ e_omega_definition ] ) , we obtain for the first two diagrams , @xmath209 and for the third one ( including the interchange @xmath210 ) @xmath211 we use here the original perturbation series ( [ value_kernel ] ) so that the unperturbed liouvillian @xmath212 occurs in the resolvents .
performing the frequency integrations and omitting terms of order @xmath213 , we obtain the following perturbative result for the effective liouvillian and the effective vertex containing the symmetric part of the contraction : @xmath214 analog equations hold for the effective current kernel @xmath215 and for the effective current vertex @xmath216 .
these are obtained by replacing the first vertex @xmath154 by the current vertex @xmath155 in eqs .
( [ sigma_initial ] ) and ( [ g_initial ] ) . after integrating out the symmetric part of the fermi function in this way
, we obtain a new diagrammatic series for the kernels analog to eq .
( [ value_kernel ] ) , but the liouvillian and the vertices have to be replaced by the effective ones and the contractions between the effective vertices contain only the antisymmetric part @xmath203 . furthermore
, since the effective quantities have become energy dependent ( also the effective vertex @xmath217 becomes energy dependent in higher order perturbation theory ) , one has to replace @xmath218 in eq .
( [ value_kernel ] ) .
since the antisymmetric part of the contraction ( [ contraction_decomposition ] ) does not depend on the keldysh indices , only the effective vertex @xmath217 averaged over the keldysh indices occurs in the new perturbative series . as a consequence
[ see eq .
( [ zero_eigenvector_g_property ] ) ] , the zero eigenvalue of the effective liouvillian can no longer occur in the denominator of the resolvents . and @xmath219 ( first two diagrams ) and the one - loop renormalization of the vertex in @xmath220 ( last diagram ) .
the slash indicates the contraction where the fermi function has to be replaced by @xmath221 . ]
( two - loop ) . ]
_ second rg step .
_ the task of the second continuous rg procedure is to integrate out the antisymmetric part of the fermi distribution function step by step . in each infinitesimal step ,
a small energy shell is integrated out and is incorporated into renormalizations of the vertices and the liouvillian .
however , instead of integrating out the energies on the real axis , it has turned out to be more efficient to integrate out the matsubara poles of the fermi distribution function on the imaginary axis,@xcite i.e. , in each rg step one integrates out one matsubara pole starting from high energies . to obtain a continuum version at finite temperatures ,
one introduces a formal cutoff dependence into the antisymmetric part of the fermi distribution by @xmath222 where @xmath223 are the matsubara frequencies corresponding to the temperature of reservoir @xmath87 , and @xmath224 is a theta function smeared by temperature . for @xmath225 , eq . ( [ fermi_cutoff ] ) yields the full antisymmetric part @xmath226 of the fermi distribution . in each rg step , one reduces the cutoff @xmath15 by @xmath227 , and integrates out the infinitesimal part @xmath228 of the fermi distribution . the new effective liouvillian and the new effective vertices at scale @xmath229 ,
@xmath230 can be calculated technically in the same way as for the first discrete rg step .
the only difference is that an infinitesimal small part is integrated out so that the rg diagrams contain only one contraction involving the part @xmath231 .
furthermore , since the diagrams should be irreducible with respect to this part , this contraction must connect the first with the last vertex of the diagram .
up to @xmath219 ( which we call two - loop here [ @xmath219 ] are called one - loop ( two - loop ) terms . for the rg of the vertices ,
this is in agreement with the conventional classification but the two rg diagrams in fig .
[ fig : rg_liouvillian_g ] for the liouvillian are also called two - loop and three - loop terms in the literature . ] ) , the rg diagrams for the liouvillian and the vertices are shown in figs . [
fig : rg_liouvillian_g ] and [ fig : rg_g_2_loop ] . using the definition @xmath233 together with the convention @xmath234 , @xmath235 and @xmath236 we obtain the following rg equations : @xmath237 for the liouvillian , and @xmath238 for the vertex .
similiar rg equations hold for the current kernel @xmath153 and the current vertex @xmath239 by replacing the first vertex in all terms on the r.h.s . of the rg equation by the current vertex .
the initial conditions of the rg equations are given by eqs .
( [ l_initial])([g_initial ] ) from the first discrete rg step . since @xmath240 , the final solution at @xmath241 provides the result for the effective liouvillian and the current kernel @xmath242 from which the reduced density matrix and the current can be calculated in laplace space via eqs .
( [ reduced_dm ] ) and ( [ current ] ) .
we note that one can stop at each step of the rg and use the perturbative series ( [ value_kernel ] ) with the contractions @xmath243 at scale @xmath15 together with the replacement @xmath244 for the resolvents and the vertices , where @xmath245 and @xmath246 are the renormalized quantities at scale @xmath15 [ in higher order in the coupling , also vertices @xmath247 with more than two indices can be generated ] .
if the exact rg equations in all orders are used , this perturbative series gives the full kernels at each scale @xmath15 .
therefore , it is possible at each step of the rg to resum all closed subdiagrams between two vertices , leading to the replacement @xmath248 where @xmath164 is the full effective liouvillian at the end of the rg flow at scale @xmath241 . using the perturbative series in a certain approximation
, one can set up a self - consistent equation for @xmath164 at each step of the rg .
however , this is only possible if the perturbation theory in the renormalized coupling is well defined .
we will see that this is only possible at a certain scale @xmath249 where some physical cutoff scale is reached , see sec .
[ sec : generic_2_loop ] . up to this scale
, we will always use the renormalized liouvillian @xmath245 in the denominator of the resolvents .
_ rg in matsubara space .
_ using the fact that the resolvents and the vertices on the r.h.s . of the rg equations
are analytic functions in all frequencies @xmath250 in the upper half of the complex plane , all frequency integrations can be calculated analytically by closing the contour in the upper half of the complex plane .
the only poles occurring there are the poles of the contractions and their derivatives , given by @xmath251 @xmath252 denotes the matsubara frequency @xmath253 which lies closest to the cutoff @xmath15 . after performing the integration we find that , due to the presence of the cutoff function @xmath254 , the r.h.s . of the rg equations gives a negligible contribution for @xmath255 .
therefore , we can start the rg at @xmath256 and omit the cutoff function @xmath257 ( finally , the precise ratio between @xmath258 and @xmath36 is determined such that no linear terms in @xmath36 are generated , see below ) . as a consequence , only the matsubara poles of the fermi function in the upper half of the complex plane will contribute to the frequency integrations and all real frequencies are replaced by matsubara frequencies .
from now on , we write the frequency dependence explicitly and define the analytic continuation of the liouvillian and the vertices in imaginary frequency space by @xmath259 where @xmath260 , @xmath261 correspond to matsubara frequencies . with the definition @xmath262 the rg equations in matsubara space
can be written as @xmath263 in these equations , the index @xmath264 includes no longer the frequency variable , and we implicitly sum over all indices and matsubara frequencies on the r.h.s . of the rg equations which do not occur on the left hand side ( l.h.s . ) .
only positive matsubara frequencies smaller than the cutoff @xmath15 are allowed and each sum has to be written as @xmath265 which reduces to an integral @xmath266 for zero temperature .
the frequency arguments of the vertices in the terms of @xmath219 in eqs .
( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) and ( [ rg_g_matsubara ] ) have been omitted since they are not needed for the weak coupling analysis up to two - loop order , see below .
the rg equations in matsubara space are the final result of this section and are the starting point for the analytical solution in the weak coupling regime presented in the next section .
similiar rg equations hold for the current kernel and the current vertex in matsubara space by replacing the first vertex in all terms on the r.h.s . by the current vertex . using eqs .
( [ l_eff_final ] ) , ( [ sigma_i_final ] ) , and ( [ l_matsubara ] ) , the effective liouvillian and the current kernel follow from @xmath267 finally , we note that all symmetry properties stated in eqs .
( [ g_symmetry])([i_c_transform ] ) are preserved under the rg flow ( see ref . for the proof ) , @xmath268 where all energy variables are real .
similiar to the discussion at the end of sec .
[ sec : generic_model ] , properties ( [ rg_l_property ] ) and ( [ rg_g_property ] ) have the consequence that we obtain zero if the left eigenvector @xmath269 of the effective liouvillian @xmath270 for zero eigenvalue acts from the left on the vertex @xmath271 compare with eq . ( [ zero_eigenvector_g_property ] ) .
therefore , it is not allowed that the zero eigenvalue of @xmath270 occurs in the resolvents on the r.h.s . of the rg equations , proving that the rg is always cut off by relaxation and dephasing rates ( this property holds in all orders of perturbation theory and within all truncation schemes ) . as we will see in the next section ,
this property is essential to prove that a systematic weak coupling analysis can be carried out in the generic case . in this section ,
we solve the two - loop rg equations ( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) and ( [ rg_g_matsubara ] ) analytically in the weak coupling regime up to two - loop order .
weak coupling is defined by the condition that the renormalized vertices @xmath272 stay small compared to one throughout the rg flow so that a systematic expansion is possible on the r.h.s . of the rg equations .
this condition is fulfilled if the various cutoff scales occurring in the resolvents @xmath273 are larger than the energy scale @xmath13 at which the vertices would diverge in the absence of any cutoff scales ( the so - called kondo temperature for the kondo model ) . from the form of the rg equations , we see that the resolvents at scale @xmath15 have the form @xmath274 with @xmath275 and positive matsubara frequencies @xmath276 for @xmath277 . here
, @xmath278 is the original laplace variable at which we want to calculate the final effective liouvillian @xmath279 , and the index @xmath280 corresponds to the contraction connecting the first with the last vertex of the rg diagram ( where the matsubara frequency is replaced by the cutoff @xmath252 ) . expanding the resolvent ( [ form_resolvent ] ) around its poles analog to the discussion at the end of sec .
[ sec : generic_model ] , we arrive at the approximation ( [ pi_general_approximation ] ) which contains the most important terms leading to logarithmic enhancements @xmath281 with @xmath282 where @xmath283 , @xmath284 , denote the positions of the nonzero poles of the resolvent ( we assume single poles here , but the following discussion holds also for other cases ; note that the zero pole of the stationary solution can not occur in the resolvent as discussed at the end of the last section ) . since all matsubara frequencies and the relaxation / dephasing rates are positive , we see that the resolvents can not become large . using @xmath276 for @xmath277 , and setting @xmath285
, we find that the resolvent is cut off at the scale @xmath286 where the maximum is taken over all values of the occurring indices . here
, temperature is a trivial cutoff parameter , because , for @xmath287 , the sum ( [ matsubara_sum ] ) over the matsubara frequencies for reservoir @xmath87 reduces to one term @xmath288 and the cutoff @xmath289 becomes independent of @xmath15 .
therefore , temperature is a unique cutoff for all terms on the r.h.s . of the rg equations , like in equilibrium problems .
this trivial cutoff is set to zero in the following , i.e. , @xmath290 , and we discuss only the nontrivial dependence on the other cutoff scales .
the minimal cutoff scale occurs for @xmath291 and is given by the relaxation or dephasing rates @xmath292 .
these points define the positions of resonances where renormalization - group - induced logarithmic enhancements or suppressions have to be expected .
however , as we will show in the following , these logarithmic terms can be calculated systematically by perturbation theory in the renormalized couplings , provided that the weak coupling condition @xmath293 is fulfilled , where by convention @xmath294 denotes the final ( physical ) renormalized oscillation frequency at scale @xmath241 ( we will see that the difference between @xmath295 and @xmath296 is proportional to the final renormalized coupling , i.e. , only a small perturbative correction ) .
@xmath249 is an important energy scale separating two energy regions where the rg equations are solved in a different way .
it is given by the maximum of the laplace variable @xmath297 , the chemical potentials of the reseroirs ( giving some voltage @xmath26 ) , and the oscillation frequencies @xmath187 of the different physical modes ( e.g. , the renormalized magnetic field in the kondo problem ) .
this is roughly the maximum value the various cutoff scales @xmath298 of the resolvents can take , see eq .
( [ cutoff_resolvent ] ) .
thus , for @xmath299 , the cutoff scales do not play an important role and we get @xmath300 , where @xmath301 is the order of magnitude of the vertex at scale @xmath15 . since @xmath15 is the relevant energy scale in this regime , the order of magnitude of the relaxation / dephasing rates is given by @xmath302 ( note that the rg for the liouvillian starts in second order in @xmath14 ) .
therefore , the relaxation and dephasing rates are small perturbative corrections in the denominators of the resolvents and do not lead to any cutoff of the rg in the regime @xmath303 .
since all vertices are small , we can systematically truncate the hierarchy of rg equations and expand the solution systematically around the poor man scaling solution ( i.e. , the lowest - order solution for the vertex in the absence of any cutoff scales @xmath304 ) .
this gives a certain initial condition for the rg at @xmath51 presented as a power series in @xmath305 . in the second regime @xmath306 ,
the rg for @xmath292 is very weak and will be roughly cut off by @xmath249 .
the reason is that there are many terms on the r.h.s . of the rg equation involving different
cutoff scales @xmath307 , but usually one of them will be given by @xmath249 already in second order in @xmath14 . in this case
( see a comment below for the other cases ) , we get @xmath308 for all @xmath306 because @xmath292 becomes smaller for decreasing @xmath15 .
this means that even at resonance , the minimal cutoff scale is given by @xmath309 .
therefore , by expanding the solution for the vertices systematically in @xmath50 , we get in the worst case at resonance a series of the schematic form @xmath310 for @xmath311 , the logarithmic term becomes maximally of the order @xmath312 , which is a perturbative correction in the weak coupling case @xmath58 . therefore , under condition ( [ lambda_c ] ) , we stay in the weak - coupling regime and the rg equations can be solved perturbatively in @xmath50 in the whole regime @xmath306 .
we note that this fact relies essentially on the condition that all resolvents on the r.h.s . of the rg equations contain some relaxation / dephasing rate @xmath292 . as explained at the end of the last section , our rg approach gives this property in the generic case in all orders of @xmath14 by construction . in case that the rg equation for @xmath292 contains a smaller cutoff scale @xmath313 in second order in @xmath14
, we expect @xmath314 for @xmath315 , with @xmath316 . in this case , the logarithmic term in eq .
( [ worst_case ] ) leads to contributions @xmath317 for @xmath311 , giving rise to additional enhancements and sharper features at resonance .
however , even for @xmath318 , there is no divergence since the cutoff scale @xmath249 will certainly occur in some higher order term on the r.h.s . of the rg equation for @xmath292 .
thus , the minimal cutoff scale will be of order @xmath319 with @xmath320 .
this gives a maximal value @xmath321 for the logarithm which is again a perturbative correction just enhanced by a factor of @xmath41 .
this shows that the height of logarithmic enhancements at resonance are expected to be increasable only by factors of @xmath25 , but the sharpness of features at resonance ( which are controlled by @xmath185 ) can become orders of magnitude smaller . as a consequence
, we have seen that for @xmath306 , we can perform a perturbation theory in @xmath50 , which is the order of the vertex at scale @xmath249 .
this means that we can equivalently stop the rg at @xmath51 and use the perturbative series ( [ value_kernel ] ) with the contraction @xmath322 at scale @xmath249 together with the replacement @xmath323 for the resolvents and the vertices .
in contrast to the perturbative series at scales @xmath324 , this perturbative series at scale @xmath249 is well defined and can be used alternatively to the rg approach . furthermore , as explained in sec .
[ sec : generic_model ] , the perturbation series can be partially resummed , leading to the replacement @xmath325 i.e. , the final full effective liouvillian can be written in the denominator .
this series has the advantage that the oscillation frequencies @xmath187 , defining the resonance positions @xmath326 and the relaxation / dephasing rates @xmath185 , cutting off the logarithmic enhancements at resonance , are the final physical ones at scale @xmath241 .
this is expected on physical grounds and leaves no question open what the precise prefactor of these energy scales is . using the replacement ( [ rg_lambda_c_resolvent_replacement ] ) , one can either write down directly the perturbative series or one can use the rg equations [ again using the replacement ( [ rg_lambda_c_resolvent_replacement ] ) to define the resolvents ] and solve them perturbatively in @xmath50 .
both approaches give the same because the rg equations are formally exact .
having shown that a weak coupling analysis is well defined for all cutoff scales under the condition ( [ lambda_c ] ) , we proceed to show analytically the perturbative solution of the rg equations in all details for the two regimes @xmath303 and @xmath306 in the generic case .
_ lowest order . _ for @xmath303 , we define the reference solution for the vertex by considering only the first term on the r.h.s . of rg equation ( [ rg_g_matsubara ] ) with @xmath327 ,
i.e. , by setting all frequencies to zero and omitting the cutoff scales from @xmath297 , @xmath328 , and @xmath329 .
this defines the leading order rg equations @xmath330 the initial condition for these rg equations is the bare vertex .
the order of magnitude of the leading order solution is denoted by the dimensionless parameter @xmath331 .
the connection to conventional poor man scaling is established by recognizing that the leading order vertices have the same form in liouville space as the original vertices , given by eqs .
( [ vertex_decomposition ] ) , ( [ g_vertex_liouville ] ) , and ( [ current_liouvillian_vertex ] ) , i.e. , one can prove that @xcite @xmath332_-\quad,\\ \label{g_tilde } \tilde{g}^{(1)}_{12}\,&=&\,[g_{12},\cdot]_+\quad,\\ \label{i_bar } \bar{i}^{\gamma ( 1)}_{12}\,&=&\,c^\gamma_{12}\,\tilde{g}^{(1)}_{12}\quad,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath333 thereby , the form ( [ i_bar ] ) of the current vertex can only be proven if one takes the @xmath334 over the local quantum system , i.e. , it holds only for the combination @xmath335 . implicitly , for all following equations , we will always consider this combination for the current vertex because this is finally needed for the calculation of the average of the current .
equation ( [ rg_g ] ) is the usual poor man scaling equation which can also be derived on a pure hamiltonian level by , e.g. , leaving the @xmath5 matrix invariant.@xcite next we set up the lowest order rg equation for the liouvillian @xmath336 by considering the first term on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) and replacing the vertices by the leading order ones .
furthermore , we replace @xmath336 by @xmath212 in the resolvent .
this gives @xmath337 with @xmath338 to extract the lowest - order term @xmath339 from this equation we treat the terms @xmath340 of @xmath341 separately by the decomposition @xmath342 so that @xmath343 is integrated by the function @xmath344 with the following asymptotic behavior : @xmath345 \quad \mbox{for } \lambda \gg |z| \,.\ ] ] using eq .
( [ rg_l_approx ] ) , the second term on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ k_tilde_function ] ) leads to the following rg equation for the liouvillian in leading order : @xmath346 with the initial condition @xmath347 when integrated , we obtain a contribution @xmath348 , i.e. , one power less than expected due to the factor @xmath349 [ compare with rg equation ( [ g_reference_solution ] ) , where the same happens ] .
in contrast , the contributions from @xmath343 are of second and third order in @xmath14 , as will be discussed below .
we write @xmath350 with @xmath351 , and @xmath352 we note that @xmath353 can be interpreted as the @xmath177 factor in liouville space at scale @xmath15 , and it can be shown that @xmath354 and @xmath355 are hermitian operators .
similiar equations can be set up for the current kernel @xmath356 in leading order by replacing the first vertex on the r.h.s .
( [ l_first_const ] ) and ( [ z_first ] ) by the current vertex .
when integrating the rg equations ( [ l_first_const ] ) and ( [ z_first ] ) up to @xmath249 , we obtain a linear contribution in the renormalized coupling @xmath50 at scale @xmath249 . since the perturbative treatment in @xmath50 for the regime @xmath306 can only give corrections @xmath357 to the liouvillian , we know that the final effective liouvillian up to @xmath358 is given by @xmath359 with @xmath360 and @xmath361 . _ second order . _ with the vertex and the liouvillian in leading order , we can now expand the full rg equations systematically around these reference solutions and calculate the higher orders .
the liouvillian and the vertex are written as an expansion in @xmath14 , @xmath362 where @xmath363 ( possibly with additional factors @xmath364 with @xmath365 , see below ) . to get an rg equation for @xmath366 and @xmath367 , we insert the expansions ( [ l_expansion ] ) and ( [ g_expansion ] ) into the r.h.s . of the full rg equations ( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) and ( [ rg_g_matsubara ] ) . for the rg of the liouvillian ( vertex ) ,
the resolvents are expanded such that we collect all terms in @xmath368 $ ] \{@xmath369 $ ] } , with @xmath370 , and @xmath371 [ @xmath372 on the r.h.s . of the rg equation ,
where @xmath373 is some cutoff scale arising from @xmath374 , @xmath329 , or the frequencies . to achieve this , we leave out @xmath366 in the resolvents [ leading to terms of @xmath375 on the r.h.s . of the rg equation ] , and use eq .
( [ l_first_decomposition ] ) .
this gives for the resolvent @xmath376 with the hermitian operator @xmath377 _ vertex in second order .
_ we start with the rg equation ( [ rg_g_matsubara ] ) for the vertex ( or equivalently the current vertex by replacing the first vertex by the current vertex in all equations ) . for the resolvent in the first term on the r.h.s . of this rg equation ,
we expand ( [ resolvent_form ] ) in the following way : @xmath378 together with the two vertices , this approximation contains systematically all terms of @xmath379 , @xmath380 , and @xmath369 $ ] , with @xmath370 , which are important to calculate the vertex up to @xmath381 .
the last three terms on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ rg_g_matsubara ] ) are already @xmath382 , therefore we replace the resolvents by their lowest order term @xmath383 : @xmath384 note that @xmath385 is an integration variable and has to be kept in the resolvent . as a result , we get the following rg equation for the vertex in second order in @xmath14 : @xmath386 the first term [ eq .
( [ g_second_term_1 ] ) ] on the r.h.s .
containing the logarithm induces the frequency dependence of the vertex . if we neglect in this term the derivative of @xmath387 with respect to @xmath15 ( giving rise to terms of @xmath388 $ ] , with @xmath370 , contributing to @xmath389 ) , we can decompose the vertex in the following way to solve the above rg equation in @xmath381 : @xmath390 with @xmath391 using this solution in the second term [ eq .
( [ g_second_term_2 ] ) ] on the r.h.s . , and neglecting again terms of @xmath388 $ ] , we can use the approximations @xmath392 in eq .
( [ g_second_term_2 ] ) , which lead to two terms cancelling precisely the second term of eq .
( [ g_second_term_3 ] ) .
thus , we obtain the following rg equation for the frequency - independent part @xmath393 of the vertex in @xmath381 : @xmath394 where the initial condition is given by the second term of the inital condition ( [ g_initial ] ) for the vertex . it can be shown @xcite that the form of the initial condition is preserved [ with the vertices given by the leading - order solutions ( [ g_bar ] ) and ( [ g_tilde ] ) ] if one considers only the first term on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ rg_g_2a ] ) .
therefore , we decompose the frequency - independent part of the vertex in second order as @xmath395 with @xmath396 and @xmath397 fulfils the same rg equation ( [ rg_g_2a ] ) as @xmath398 , but with zero initial condition . since no explicit imaginary factors occur in eq .
( [ rg_g_2a ] ) , the decomposition ( [ g_2a_decomposition ] ) can also be viewed as a decomposition of the vertex into real and complex parts ( provided there are no complex terms in the initial condition for the original quantities ) .
therefore , the two parts have a completely different physical meaning .
whereas the part @xmath399 is even important to calculate the rates in second order in @xmath14 ( see below ) , the part @xmath397 denotes a renormalization of the coupling constants in two - loop order , which can lead to logarithmic corrections of the form @xmath400 , where @xmath21 denotes the original coupling constant ( see sec . [
sec : kondo_above_lambda_c ] , where such terms are explicitly calculated for the kondo model ) .
such terms are not well defined in the scaling limit @xmath401 and , therefore , should be taken together with the leading order vertex by redefining certain characteristic low - energy scales ( like the kondo temperature for the kondo model ) .
thus , in the following we will redefine the leading - order vertex by the replacement @xmath402 and will consider only the part @xmath403 explicitly in all equations .
we note that it can not generically be shown that the replacement ( [ rg_g_replacement ] ) can be accounted for by just renormalizing the kondo temperature in the lowest - order vertices . for the kondo model ,
this can be shown in all orders @xcite because only one coupling constant remains in the scaling limit @xmath401 , @xmath404 , such that @xmath13 stays constant .
however , for more complicated models including orbital degrees of freedoms , interference effects , etc . , it can happen that the matrix structure of @xmath405 in liouville space is different from that of @xmath406 . in this case
, new terms can finally arise from the second - order part of the vertices , and their influence might be quite nontrivial .
we note that all equations also hold for the current vertex @xmath407 by replacing the first vertex in all terms on the r.h.s . of the rg equations by the current vertex .
thereby eq .
( [ g_2a_1 ] ) is only valid if the trace @xmath334 over the local quantum system is taken from the left ( which we always implicitly assume for the current vertex and the current kernel ) .
_ liouvillian in second order .
_ we proceed with rg equation ( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) for the liouvillian ( or equivalently the current kernel by replacing the first vertex by the current vertex in all equations ) . inserting the expansion ( [ g_expansion ] ) into this rg equation , using eqs .
( [ g_second_decomposition ] ) , ( [ g_2a_decomposition ] ) , and ( [ rg_g_replacement ] ) , and neglecting all terms of @xmath375 on the r.h.s . , we obtain @xmath408 for the terms ( [ l_expansion_term_1 ] ) , ( [ l_expansion_term_2 ] ) , and ( [ l_expansion_term_4 ] ) we need the resolvent integrated over frequency , which , by using eqs . ( [ resolvent_form ] ) , ( [ tilde_l ] ) , ( [ k_function ] ) and ( [ k_tilde_function ] )
, can be expanded as @xmath409 the first term is of order @xmath410 , the second one of order @xmath411 , and the last one contains terms of @xmath25 and @xmath412 $ ] , with @xmath370 .
therefore , when multiplied with @xmath413 and integrated , the first term gives a contribution of order @xmath414 , the second one leads to @xmath415 , and the last one gives @xmath416 or @xmath415 .
thereby , the terms @xmath417 are cancelled by the initial condition from the first rg step ( see below ) .
therefore , for the calculation of @xmath418 , the terms ( [ l_expansion_term_1 ] ) and ( [ l_expansion_term_2 ] ) give rise to @xmath419 as is shown in appendix [ sec : appendix_a ] , the other two terms , eqs .
( [ l_expansion_term_3 ] ) and ( [ l_expansion_term_4 ] ) , have nearly no effect when expanded systematically , one just has to replace the function @xmath420 in eq .
( [ l_2_term_a ] ) by the function @xmath421 according to the three terms eqs .
( [ l_2_term_a])([l_2_term_c ] ) , we decompose @xmath422 with @xmath423 note that , according to eq .
( [ f_tilde_asymptotic ] ) , the initial value of @xmath424 is given by @xmath425 which coincides with the first term of the inital condition ( [ sigma_initial ] ) from the first rg step if we choose @xmath426 one can group the various terms occurring in eqs .
( [ l_2_decomposition])([z_2c ] ) regarding the occurence of the complex factor @xmath174 .
the rg equations ( [ l_2c ] ) and ( [ z_2c ] ) do not contain an explicit factor @xmath174 and integrating them up to @xmath249 , one generates a second - order contribution which is negligible compared to the first - order terms ( [ l_first_const ] ) and ( [ z_first ] ) ( up to this value of the cutoff parameter , no logarithmic contributions are generated , i.e. , the terms just have one factor more in @xmath14 ) . in contrast , the second - order terms containing the factor @xmath174 are not negligible because they do not occur in first order .
they are generated by eq .
( [ l_2a ] ) [ with @xmath427 replaced by its real value ] and by eqs .
( [ l_2b ] ) and ( [ z_2b ] ) .
this is a general rule that the terms containing the factor @xmath174 are always generated one order higher in @xmath14 compared to those without this factor .
the two - loop rg until @xmath249 has resummed all leading and subleading logarithmic contributions in @xmath428 into the renormalized vertices .
this means that we have considered all terms of the form @xmath429 for the liouvillian and the vertices , where @xmath21 denotes the original coupling constant .
the terms with @xmath430 and @xmath431 are defined in our terminology as one - loop and two - loop terms , respectively , irrespective of the topology of the diagrams , which is not a unique definition and depends on the formalism used .
roughly speaking , at @xmath51 , the band width @xmath36 has been replaced by an effective band width @xmath249 and the bare coupling constant is replaced by a renormalized one @xmath50 ( including one - loop and two - loop renormalizations ) .
this eliminates all the logarithmic contributions of eq .
( [ log_terms ] ) , and a simple power series in @xmath50 remains , which is well defined for @xmath58 , as described in detail at the beginning of sec .
[ sec : generic_2_loop ] . as a consequence
, we solve the rg equations perturbatively in @xmath50 in the regime @xmath306 .
furthermore , we replace the liouvillian in the resolvents by the full effective liouvillian @xmath432 , and we use the approximation ( [ pi_general_approximation ] ) @xmath433 together with the convention ( [ tilde_lz_convention ] ) .
the corrections to this approximation are at least of order @xmath358 and contain no poles in the variable @xmath278 ( at least if we assume that the projectors on the eigenvectors do not contain poles or do not contribute ) .
therefore , when inserted in the rg equations , these corrections lead to terms of order @xmath434 without any logarithmic enhancement , which we neglect in the following .
the eigenvalues of @xmath181 are given by @xmath435 with @xmath436 .
these eigenvalues are finally calculated self - consistently from eq .
( [ pole_equation ] ) .
in contrast , the @xmath177 factor is expanded as @xmath437 where @xmath438 .
this first - order correction to the @xmath177 factor can in principle be calculated from the effective liouvillian up to first order in @xmath50 , given by the result ( [ l_eff_1_order ] ) . if the eigenvalues of @xmath212 are separated well compared to the first - order corrections to the effective liouvillian , we get @xmath439 where @xmath440 is the diagonal part of @xmath441 with respect to the eigenbasis of @xmath212
. however , we will see later that @xmath442 does not enter our final result so its precise value is of no relevance . in the rg equations ,
the variable @xmath297 is replaced by @xmath443 and @xmath91 is the imaginary part of the laplace variable plus the integration variables ( the cutoff @xmath15 and some masubara frequencies ) .
thus , in the end the low - energy cutoff will be given by an expression of the form @xmath444 where from now on @xmath91 is the imaginary part of the original laplace variable .
resonance positions are defined by @xmath445 , see eq .
( [ resonance_positions ] ) . at these points , logarithmic terms of the form @xmath446 are generated with @xmath447 . at resonance ,
the logarithmic terms are of order @xmath448 since @xmath449 , leading to enhanced , but still perturbative corrections .
our first aim is to collect all terms of the form ( [ log_terms_with_gamma ] ) with @xmath450 and @xmath451 , i.e. , all terms of the form @xmath452 only terms of @xmath434 without a logarithmic factor are neglected [ note that approximation ( [ pi_lambda_c_approximation ] ) for the resolvent is already neglecting such terms ] .
therefore , it is not necessary to calculate the liouvillian in third order in @xmath14 for @xmath303 since no logarithmic contributions are generated up to @xmath249 .
furthermore , for @xmath453 , we see that the lowest order term on the r.h.s of the rg equation ( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) for the liouvillian is already of @xmath454 .
therefore , we need the vertices only up to @xmath454 , and it is not necessary to calculate the vertices up to third order for @xmath303 . _ vertices .
_ we start with the perturbative expansion for the vertices .
up to order @xmath454 , we get from the rg equation ( [ rg_g_matsubara ] ) together with eqs .
( [ pi_lambda_c_approximation ] ) , ( [ z_expansion ] ) , and ( [ low_energy_cutoff ] ) @xmath455 integrating this equation from @xmath51 to @xmath15 , we obtain in @xmath454 @xmath456 where @xmath457 is the value of the vertex in second order at @xmath51 . inserting this value from eqs .
( [ g_second_decomposition ] ) , ( [ g_second_frequency ] ) , and ( [ g_2a_decomposition ] ) , we find up to @xmath454 @xmath458 where we have used that @xmath459 .
note that the part @xmath405 is always taken together with @xmath406 , see eq .
( [ rg_g_replacement ] ) , therefore it does not occur in eq .
( [ g_second_order ] ) .
_ liouvillian .
_ we proceed with the perturbative expansion for the liouvillian given by the rg equation ( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) . in the second term on the r.h.s . of this rg equation
, we can replace the vertex by the lowest - order term @xmath460 and the resolvent by @xmath461 , according to eq .
( [ pi_lambda_c_approximation ] ) . in the first term on the r.h.s .
, we have to consider the first - order correction @xmath442 of the @xmath177 factor as well , and we have to use the second - order term for the vertex given by eq .
( [ g_second_order ] ) , which gives @xmath462 for the frequency integral over the resolvent , we use @xmath463 using these replacements in eq .
( [ rg_l_matsubara ] ) and collecting the various terms according to their order in @xmath50 , we obtain up to @xmath434 @xmath464 with @xmath465 using @xmath466 for the third term on the r.h.s .
( [ rg_l_3b ] ) , we obtain after some manipulations @xmath467 equations ( [ rg_l_2 ] ) and ( [ rg_l_3a ] ) can be integrated easily from @xmath51 to @xmath241 by using @xmath468 where @xmath469 is defined by eqs .
( [ tilde_f_prime ] ) and ( [ f_tilde_function ] ) . using @xmath470 , we get @xmath471 the value of the liouvillian at @xmath51 in second order has to be taken from eqs .
( [ l_2_decomposition])([z_2b ] ) . when integrating eq .
( [ rg_l_2 ] ) , the part from the first term on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ cal_l_integral ] ) cancels term ( [ l_2a ] ) for @xmath472 if we neglect the difference between @xmath212 and @xmath181 [ leading to terms of order @xmath434 ] .
thus , for @xmath241 , we obtain the contributions @xmath474 thereby , we have only included the logarithmic terms in @xmath475 , i.e. , terms @xmath476 without a logarithmic factor are neglected . finally , integrating eq .
( [ rg_l_3b_simplified ] ) , we obtain @xmath477 neglecting again terms @xmath476 , the double logarithmic integral can be replaced by ( with @xmath478 and @xmath479 ) @xmath480 and analog for @xmath481 by interchanging @xmath482 .
for some special cases , ( [ double_logarithmic_integral ] ) can be written as @xmath483 equations ( [ l_1_final])([l_3b_final ] ) together with eqs .
( [ double_logarithmic_integral])([double_logarithmic_integral_special ] ) are the final results for the effective liouvillian ( or the current kernel if the first vertex in all terms is replaced by the current vertex ) for a generic model of a quantum dot in the coulomb blockade regime .
the vertices @xmath484 and @xmath485 at @xmath51 follow from eqs .
( [ g_reference_solution ] ) and ( [ g_2a_1 ] ) .
the first - order quantities @xmath486 and @xmath441 follow from the solution of the rg equations ( [ l_first_const ] ) and ( [ z_first ] ) at @xmath51 , and the second - order terms @xmath487 , @xmath488 , @xmath489 , and @xmath490 are determined by the rg equations ( [ l_2b])([z_2c ] ) .
looking back at eqs .
( [ rg_l_2])([rg_l_3b ] ) , we see that the third - order terms involving three vertices on the r.h.s . of the rg equations enter only explicitly via the last term on the r.h.s .
( [ rg_l_3b ] ) .
this part is of @xmath434 and does not contain any logarithmic contribution since @xmath491 for @xmath311 .
this means that the logarithmic contributions are only generated by the terms in second order in the renormalized vertices , but including their corrections in second order in @xmath50 via eq .
( [ g_second_order ] ) . both the imaginary parts @xmath492 and the frequency dependence generate logarithmic contributions .
implicitly , third - order terms in the vertices are also present in the last term on the r.h.s .
of the two - loop rg equation ( [ rg_g_2a ] ) , which determines the contribution @xmath493 , see eq .
( [ rg_g_replacement ] ) . as already mentioned after eq .
( [ rg_g_replacement ] ) , it may happen for more complicated models than the kondo model that this part can change the leading - order vertex in a nontrivial way ( i.e. , not only by a change of the kondo temperature ) leading to new logarithmic contributions not expected from the matrix structure of the leading order vertices . for @xmath285 and away from resonance @xmath494 , we have @xmath495 and @xmath496 , with @xmath497 and @xmath498 being real . in this case , we get for eqs .
( [ double_logarithmic_integral ] ) and ( [ double_logarithmic_integral_special ] ) @xmath499 for @xmath285 , we see that the terms containing explicitly the complex factor @xmath174 start always one power less in the logarithm compared to those without the factor @xmath174 .
the terms without the factor @xmath174 start with the logarithmic contribution @xmath500 , whereas the ones with the factor @xmath174 start with terms @xmath501 .
therefore , in the following section , where we apply the general formalism to the kondo model , we will restrict ourselves only to those terms .
this means that for @xmath285 we take into account all terms of order @xmath25 , @xmath358 and @xmath502 without the factor @xmath174 , and all terms of order @xmath454 and @xmath503 with the factor @xmath174 .
thus , we can neglect the contributions from @xmath504 and @xmath490 in eq .
( [ l_2_final ] ) [ according to eqs .
( [ l_2c ] ) and ( [ z_2c ] ) ] , and the first two terms on the r.h.s . of eq . ( [ l_3a_final ] ) .
therefore , the first - order correction @xmath442 is not important for the final result
. furthermore , we can neglect all real terms in eqs .
( [ double_logarithmic_omega=0 ] ) and ( [ double_logarithmic_special_omega=0 ] ) .
this leads to the final equations @xmath505 with @xmath506 and @xmath507 close to resonance , where the effect of @xmath55 can not be neglected , we have to consider the imaginary parts of the eigenvalues of @xmath181 as well .
if an eigenvalue @xmath508 occurs , we have to replace @xmath509 , and @xmath510
_ model . _ now the rg formalism developed in the previous section is applied to the anisotropic spin-@xmath511 kondo model in an external magnetic field @xmath512 . in this case
, we have @xmath513 where @xmath87 denotes the reservoir index , @xmath514 , and @xmath515 @xmath516 is the @xmath174 component of the spin-@xmath511 operator of the quantum dot , @xmath517 is a pauli matrix , and @xmath518 @xmath519 $ ] are the initial exchange couplings which correspond to processes without ( with ) spin flip .
if we choose the reservoir states such that the exchange couplings are real , we find from hermiticity ( [ hermiticity ] ) that the exchange coupling matrices are symmetric , @xmath520 if one derives the kondo model via a schrieffer - wolff transformation from an anderson impurity model ( see , e.g. , ref . ) , one finds @xmath521 which is used sometimes to simplify the calculations .
furthermore , although the general formalism and many of the following formulas are also valid for an arbitrary number of reservoirs , we will finally consider the case of two reservoirs only , with @xmath89 , and chemical potentials given by @xmath522 where @xmath26 is the applied voltage .
_ representation in liouville space .
_ in liouville space , the initial liouvillian and the initial vertex are given by @xmath523_-=h_0\,(l^{+z}+l^{-z})\quad,\\ \nonumber g^{pp}_{11'}&=&{1\over 2}\,\left\ { \begin{array}{cl } ( j^i_{\alpha\alpha'})_0\,l^{pi}\,\sigma^i_{\sigma\sigma'}\ , & \mbox{for } \eta=-\eta'=+ \\ -(j^i_{\alpha'\alpha})_0\,l^{pi}\,\sigma^i_{\sigma'\sigma}\ , & \mbox{for } \eta=-\eta'=- \end{array } \right.\,,\\ \label{g_initial_kondo}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the spin superoperators @xmath524 are defined by their action on an arbitrary operator @xmath126 in hilbert space via @xmath525 we will now derive a closed set of basis superoperators to represent the renormalized liouvillian and the renormalized vertices ( note that this set will be more complex than the one derived in ref . for the isotropic kondo model ) .
because the hilbert space ( spanned by the states @xmath526 and @xmath527 ) is two dimensional , the liouville space of operators acting on it is four dimensional , and the superoperators defined in this section can be represented by @xmath528 matrices .
this means that we need at most @xmath529 basis superoperators .
we define the four scalar superoperators @xmath530 where @xmath531 is the identity superoperator , and the vector superoperators @xmath532 because the hamiltonian is not isotropic , we have to split the vector superoperators into their components and consider these separately .
we define @xmath533 and find that we get a convenient superoperator basis if we add the set @xmath534 to the four scalar superoperators , where @xmath535 this set of @xmath536 basis superoperators is sufficient to describe the anisotropic kondo model with @xmath537 , where rotational invariance around the @xmath538 axis holds . in the case of the fully anisotropic kondo model with @xmath539 , two additional superoperators @xmath540 have to be used , which we do not need in the following .
we note the properties @xmath541 together with the transformation under the @xmath190 transform ( [ c_transformation ] ) @xmath542 using spin rotational invariance around the @xmath538 axis and spin conservation , together with the properties ( [ traceless_1])([tracefull_3 ] ) and @xmath543 [ see eq .
( [ rg_l_property ] ) ] , we find that the liouvillian and the current kernel can be represented as ( in each step of the rg ) @xmath544 where as usual we always assume implicitly that the @xmath545 is acting from the left when we consider the current kernel or the current vertex @xmath546 from eqs .
( [ rg_l_c_transform ] ) , ( [ rg_sigma_i_c_transform ] ) , ( [ c_transform_1 ] ) , and ( [ c_transform_2 ] ) , we get the following transformation under complex conjugation : @xmath547 the various terms in eq .
( [ l_representation ] ) can be interpreted if one analyzes the spectral properties of the renormalized liouvillian .
@xmath548 has four eigenvalues , @xmath549 @xmath550 corresponds to the stationary state , @xmath551 describes the relaxation mode , and @xmath552 correspond to the two dephasing modes .
the projectors @xmath553 onto the four eigenspaces are given by @xmath554 and the right and left eigenvectors follow from @xmath555 according to eq .
( [ rd_stationary ] ) , the eigenvector @xmath556 corresponds to the stationary state .
therefore , we get @xmath557 where @xmath35 denotes the magnetization , which is related to @xmath558 ( if no argument is written , we implicitly assume @xmath559 and @xmath560 ) .
the stationary current follows from eqs .
( [ current_stationary ] ) and ( [ sigma_current_representation ] ) as @xmath561 which , by using eq .
( [ rd_stationary_kondo ] ) together with @xmath562 and @xmath563 , gives @xmath564 to represent the vertices , we define the reservoir spin matrices @xmath565 and the following operators in combined reservoir spin space and liouville space of the dot @xmath566 using spin rotational invariance around the @xmath538 axis , together with the properties ( [ rg_g_property ] ) and ( [ traceless_1])([tracefull_3 ] ) , the renormalized vertices can be represented as ( for @xmath567 ) @xmath568 in these equations , we have used a compact matrix notation in the reservoir indices @xmath569 and the reservoir spin indices @xmath570 . whereas @xmath571 and @xmath572 denote matrices in the reservoir indices , the quantities @xmath573 are matrices in the reservoir spin indices according to definitions ( [ l_spin_1 ] ) and ( [ l_spin_2 ] ) .
again , we note that eq .
( [ i_representation ] ) holds only if the trace @xmath545 is taken from the left . for @xmath574
, we use the antisymmetry properties ( [ rg_g_symmetry ] ) and ( [ rg_i_symmetry ] ) , and obtain from eqs .
( [ g_representation ] ) and ( [ i_representation ] ) @xmath575 where @xmath576 denotes the transpose only with respect to the reservoir indices or the reservoir spin indices @xmath577 using the properties ( [ rg_g_c_transform ] ) and ( [ rg_i_c_transform ] ) together with eqs .
( [ c_transform_1])([c_transform_4 ] ) , we obtain the symmetry relations @xmath578 and the same for @xmath579 .
_ algebra .
_ the results of a multiplication of two of the operators @xmath580 are summarized in the following table ( all products not shown are zero ) : @xmath581 note that , according to definitions ( [ l_spin_1 ] ) and ( [ l_spin_2 ] ) , the operators @xmath580 are matrices in the reservoir spin indices , where each matrix element is a superoperator in the liouville space of the dot .
the same algebra holds without the reservoir spin indices if one replaces @xmath582 in eq .
( [ algebra_l ] ) , with the only difference that also some products not shown are nonzero [ these are the products @xmath583 defining the basis superoperators @xmath584 according to eqs .
( [ l_++ ] ) and ( [ l_ ] ) , which are not needed for our case of rotational invariance around the @xmath538 axis ] .
furthermore , we note that the algebra ( [ algebra_l ] ) is also not changed if we replace @xmath585 which turns out to be very helpful to consider the two cases @xmath586 for creation and annihilation operators , see the representations ( [ g_representation_t ] ) and ( [ i_representation_t ] ) .
finally , we note that the spin matrices ( [ spin_matrices ] ) fulfil the algebra ( all products not shown are zero ) @xmath587 and the same holds if one replaces @xmath588 _ initial values .
_ we start with the determination of the initial values of the liouvillian and the vertices together with their values after the first rg step , given by eqs .
( [ l_initial])([g_initial ] ) .
the initial values for the liouvillian @xmath212 and the vertices @xmath589 and @xmath590 follow from eqs .
( [ l_initial_kondo ] ) and ( [ g_initial_kondo ] ) as @xmath591_-\,=\,h_0\,l^h\quad,\\ \label{g_bar_initial_kondo } \bar{g}_{11'}^{(1)}\,&=&\,\sum_p g^{pp}_{11 ' } = -\hat{j}^i_0\,l^{2i}\,\sigma^i\quad,\\ \label{g_tilde_initial_kondo } \tilde{g}_{11'}^{(1)}\,&=&\,\sum_p p\,g^{pp}_{11 ' } = -{1\over 2}\hat{j}^i_0\,(l^{1i}+l^{3i})\,\sigma^i\quad,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have taken @xmath592 and used a matrix notation @xmath593 $ ] for the exchange couplings in the reservoir indices . inserting the various definitions of the basis superoperators
, we find the following representations for @xmath592 : @xmath594 where we sum implicitly over @xmath595 on the r.h.s .
according to eq .
( [ current_liouvillian_vertex ] ) , the initial current vertex is given by @xmath596 .
using eq .
( [ g_tilde_components ] ) , we obtain for @xmath592 @xmath597 where @xmath598 we have left out the components @xmath599 and @xmath600 in eq .
( [ i_components ] ) because we assume implicitly that the @xmath334 acts from the left on the current vertex . to calculate the second - order contributions ( [ l_initial])([g_initial ] ) from the first rg step , we use the following identities for any two superoperators @xmath601 and @xmath602 , which can all be proven easily by summing over the two possibilities @xmath603 : @xmath604 with @xmath605 . here ,
@xmath606 and @xmath607 denote the trace with respect to the reservoir indices and the reservoir spin indices , respectively .
applying these identities to eqs .
( [ l_initial])([g_initial ] ) , inserting the results ( [ g_bar_components])([i_components ] ) for the vertices , and applying the algebra of the basis superoperators , we find after some straightforward calculation the following result for the liouvillian and the current kernel after the first rg step : @xmath608 thereby , the terms proportional to the band width cancel with terms generated by the second rg step , see eq .
( [ lambda_initial ] ) .
therefore , we can omit them together with the real terms of second order in @xmath14 [ which are not the leading order ones in this order , see the discussion before eq .
( [ l_1_final_omega=0 ] ) ] .
thus , we are left with the following inital condition to solve the rg equations ( [ l_2b ] ) and ( [ z_2b ] ) : @xmath609 we now calculate the form of the vertex ( [ g_initial ] ) after the first rg step , which leads to the initial condition for the vertices @xmath403 and @xmath610 , given by eq . ( [ g_2a_1 ] ) .
we use the following identity , valid for @xmath592 : @xmath611 applying this property to eq .
( [ g_2a_1 ] ) , inserting eqs .
( [ g_bar_components])([i_components ] ) , and applying the algebra of the basis superoperators , we find after some straightforward calculation for @xmath592 @xmath612 _ vertices in first order .
the rg equations for the lowest order vertices @xmath589 and @xmath613 are given by eqs .
( [ g_reference_solution ] ) and ( [ i_reference_solution ] ) with initial conditions ( [ g_bar_components ] ) and ( [ i_components ] ) .
using eq .
( [ product_decompose_3 ] ) , one finds after some algebra that the initial form of the leading order vertices is preserved , i.e. , for @xmath592 @xmath614 with @xmath615 provided that the renormalized exchange coupling matrices fulfil the poor man scaling rg equations @xmath616 where @xmath617 is the dimensionless flow parameter and @xmath618 is the initial condition .
the poor man scaling equations have the invariant @xmath619 they can be solved easily if one assumes the form ( [ j_form ] ) for the initial couplings . in this case
, we have the same form for the renormalized couplings , @xmath620 and the two exchange couplings @xmath74 and @xmath621 fulfil the rg equations @xmath622 these rg equations have two invariants @xmath623 where @xmath624 for @xmath625 .
@xmath13 denotes the kondo temperature , which can also be written as @xmath626 with @xmath627 and , for @xmath625 [ where @xmath628 , the imaginary part of the logarithm is defined such that @xmath629 ( such that @xmath13 does not jump during the rg flow and is exponentially small ) .
thus , for @xmath625 , we obtain @xmath630 for the isotropic case ( @xmath631 ) , we get the usual form @xmath632 . in terms of the invariants ,
the solution of eq .
( [ rg_j_kondo ] ) can be written as @xmath633 in the scaling limit @xmath634 and @xmath635 , such that @xmath636 and @xmath637 ( which is possible for @xmath638 or @xmath625 ) , we obtain the well - known isotropic form @xmath639 with @xmath13 given by eq .
( [ t_k_kondo ] ) ( where the anisotropy of the initial exchange couplings still enters ) .
_ liouvillian in first order . _
to determine @xmath640 from eq .
( [ l_first_decomposition ] ) , we use the solution ( [ g_bar_leading_kondo ] ) for @xmath406 together with the identities ( [ product_decompose_1 ] ) and ( [ product_decompose_2 ] ) to evaluate the r.h.s . of the rg equations ( [ l_first_const ] ) and ( [ z_first ] ) .
we obtain @xmath641 with the invariant @xmath190 given by eq .
( [ invariant ] ) . using @xmath642 and @xmath643 according to eq .
( [ poor_man_scaling_kondo ] ) , we find the solution ( note that the inital conditions are zero in first order in @xmath14 ) @xmath644 where the flow parameter @xmath645 can be expressed in terms of the exchange couplings by using eq .
( [ invariant_c_tk ] ) : @xmath646 whereas the logarithms in this formula are pure anisotropy terms depending on the ratios of the exchange couplings , the prefactor @xmath647 gives @xmath648 , i.e. , the second terms @xmath649 on the r.h.s .
( [ l_first_kondo ] ) and ( [ z_first_kondo ] ) are of the same order @xmath650 as the first terms . _ current kernel in first order . _
the current kernel @xmath356 can be determined similarly to @xmath640 , one just has to replace the first vertex on the r.h.s . of the rg equations ( [ l_first_const ] ) and ( [ z_first ] ) by the current vertex ( [ i_components ] ) . using the identities ( [ product_decompose_1 ] ) and ( [ product_decompose_2 ] ) together with the algebra of the basis superoperators
, we obtain zero on the r.h.s . of the rg equations , i.e. , @xmath651 _ vertices in second order . _
the vertices in second order in @xmath14 follow from the decomposition ( [ g_2a_decomposition ] ) , where the first ( imaginary ) part @xmath652 ( or @xmath653 for the current kernel ) is given by eq .
( [ g_2a_1 ] ) . since the renormalized vertices in
first order have the same form as the initial ones , we obtain the same form as eqs .
( [ g_2a_1_initial_kondo ] ) and ( [ i_2a_1_initial_kondo ] ) with @xmath654 , @xmath655 in contrast , the ( real ) parts @xmath405 and @xmath656 have to be calculated from the rg equation ( [ rg_g_2a ] ) with zero initial condition .
we use the same ansatz ( [ g_bar_leading_kondo ] ) and ( [ i_leading_kondo ] ) as for the vertices in lowest order , i.e. , for @xmath592 @xmath657 with @xmath658 . however , instead of eq .
( [ current_exchange_renormalized ] ) , we set @xmath659 which can be viewed as a definition of @xmath660 . inserting eqs .
( [ ansatz_g_2a_2_kondo ] ) , ( [ ansatz_i_2a_2_kondo ] ) , ( [ g_bar_leading_kondo ] ) , ( [ i_leading_kondo ] ) , and ( [ z_first_kondo ] ) into the rg equation ( [ rg_g_2a ] ) , and using the following properties [ analog to ( [ product_decompose_3 ] ) ] , valid for @xmath592 : @xmath661 we obtain after some lengthy but straighforward algebra the following rg equations : @xmath662 together with eq . , we have derived here the full two - loop equations for the vertex and the current vertex in the most general case , including anisotropies and all possibilities for the dependencies on the reservoir indices .
if we define the total vertex by @xmath663 and take the sum of the rg equations ( [ poor_man_scaling_kondo ] ) , ( [ rg_k_z ] ) , and ( [ rg_k_perp ] ) , we get , by neglecting terms of @xmath375 and terms of @xmath664 ( which vanish in the scaling limit @xmath401 ) , the following result : @xmath665{\hat{\cal{j}}}^z\quad,\\ \label{rg_total_perp } { d \over dl}{\hat{\cal{j}}}^\perp & = & \left(1-\text{tr}{\hat{\cal{j}}}^z\right ) { 1\over 2}({\hat{\cal{j}}}^z{\hat{\cal{j}}}^\perp + { \hat{\cal{j}}}^\perp{\hat{\cal{j}}}^z ) + { 1\over 2}\left[\text{tr}({\hat{\cal{j}}}^\perp)^2\right]{\hat{\cal{j}}}^\perp\quad.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath666 and the case of two reservoirs with @xmath667 , these equations reduce to the two - loop equations of ref .
[ where the nonuniversal parameter @xmath208 in eq .
( 104 ) of this reference has to be chosen as @xmath668 . in equilibrium ( i.e. , for a single reservoir )
, we recover the well - known two - loop rg equations for the anisotropic kondo model derived in ref . [ up to nonuniversal terms arising from adding terms proportional to the invariant @xmath669 .
if the exchange couplings fulfil the relation ( [ j_form ] ) , the rg equations can be solved easily . in this case
, we have @xmath670 and @xmath671 with @xmath672 special solutions of these equations are given by @xmath673 and the initial conditions @xmath674 can be fulfilled by adding linear combinations of the following solutions of the homogeneous part of the rg equations : @xmath675 as a consequence , the final solutions are given by @xmath676 using eq .
( [ l_j ] ) and @xmath677 , we see that the vertices in second order contain four different types of terms @xmath678 in addition to factors which contain ratios of @xmath679 or @xmath680 . in the scaling limit ,
the terms of order @xmath681 can be neglected .
the terms of order @xmath381 are just a perturbative correction to the first - order vertices and can be neglected too .
therefore , we see that the terms @xmath682 are not important and the current vertex ( [ k_current_k_2a_2 ] ) in second order can be written as @xmath683 the terms of order @xmath684 are logarithmic corrections , which are of order @xmath685 smaller compared to the first - order vertices . since @xmath686 they are also perturbative corrections and can be omitted .
they lead only to an overall change of the physical quantities without any interesting dependence on some physical energy scale ( like e.g. the voltage , magnetic field , etc . ) .
the most important terms are those of order @xmath687 since they diverge in the scaling limit .
therefore , they have to be incorporated into the definition of the kondo temperature . using the solution ( [ rg_leading_solution ] ) with @xmath688 and expanding in @xmath689 , we find @xmath690 i.e. , the terms of order @xmath691 in eqs .
( [ k_z_solution ] ) and ( [ k_perp_solution ] ) can be acccounted for by the redefinition @xmath692 as a consequence , the main effect of the two - loop terms for the vertices is the replacement @xmath688 , which we will always implicitly assume in the following . in other ( more academic ) cases , where the form ( [ j_form ] ) of the exchange couplings is not fulfilled ,
the part @xmath693 can generally not be written in the form ( [ r_gamma_form ] ) , i.e. , @xmath109 must not necessarily be equal to @xmath87 or @xmath694 . from the rg equations ( [ rg_r_z ] ) and ( [ rg_r_perp ] ) , one can only prove that @xmath695 however , in the special case of two reservoirs , these conditions lead again to the form ( [ r_gamma_form ] ) .
it is an open question of future research to analyze the two - loop equations in all cases and to find out whether there are interesting situations where the two - loop contributions can not be simply accounted for by a renormalization of a single parameter . in addition , it is not clear whether the corrections @xmath696 to the current vertex are generically unimportant . in this paper , we discuss only the physically realizable situation , where the exchange couplings fulfil the property ( [ j_form ] ) . _
liouvillian in second order .
_ for eq .
( [ l_2_final_omega=0 ] ) , we need the following second - order contribution to the liouvillian : @xmath697 where @xmath698 and @xmath699 are determined by the rg equations ( [ l_2b ] ) and ( [ z_2b ] ) with initial values given by eqs . ( [ l_2b_initial_kondo ] ) and ( [ z_2b_initial_kondo ] ) . inserting the results ( [ g_bar_leading_kondo ] ) and ( [ g_2a_1_kondo ] ) for the vertices into eqs .
( [ l_2b ] ) and ( [ z_2b ] ) , and using the identities ( [ product_decompose_1 ] ) and ( [ product_decompose_2 ] ) , we find after some algebra the rg equations @xmath700 using @xmath701 according to eq .
( [ poor_man_scaling_kondo ] ) together with the inital condition ( [ l_2b_initial_kondo ] ) , we find the result @xmath702 where we have used that @xmath703 is an invariant according to eq .
( [ invariant ] ) . _ current kernel in second order . _
analog to @xmath704 , we evaluate the current kernel @xmath705 from the rg equations ( [ l_2b ] ) and ( [ z_2b ] ) by using the results ( [ i_leading_kondo ] ) and ( [ i_2a_1_kondo ] ) for the current vertices .
this gives the rg equations @xmath706 and @xmath707 . using @xmath643 and @xmath708 according to eq .
( [ poor_man_scaling_kondo ] ) , we find together with the initial conditions ( [ sigma_current_2b_initial_kondo ] ) and ( [ z_2b_initial_kondo ] ) the result @xmath709 l^b\,,\\ z_\gamma^{(2b)}&=0 . \end{split}\ ] ] we now start to evaluate the final formulas ( [ l_1_final_omega=0])([l_3b_final_omega=0 ] ) for the effective liouvillian and the current kernel , which are represented in terms of the basis superoperators according to the forms ( [ l_representation ] ) and ( [ sigma_current_representation ] ) .
all final quantities are evaluated at @xmath285 and are meant at @xmath241 which is not indicated explicitly , i.e. , we write from now on @xmath710 since only the first - order vertices evaluated at @xmath51 occur in the final formulas , we will furthermore use the convention @xmath711 according to eq .
( [ lambda_c ] ) , the scale @xmath249 is defined as the maximum of all physical energy scales , i.e. , in our case of the kondo problem @xmath712 where @xmath57 is defined by the renormalized magnetic field or , more precisely , as the real part of the eigenvalues of the operator @xmath181
. therefore , we have to keep in mind that the renormalized exchange couplings ( [ j_c_convention ] ) depend implicitly on the variables @xmath297 , @xmath26 , and @xmath57 via the scale @xmath249 . according to eq .
( [ tilde_lz_convention ] ) , any function @xmath713 of the quantities @xmath714 is defined by @xmath715 with @xmath716 and @xmath717 . @xmath718 and @xmath719
are given by eqs .
( [ eigenvalues ] ) and ( [ projectors ] ) , with @xmath720 . as a consequence , we obtain the following self - consistent equations for @xmath172 : @xmath721 the pole @xmath722 corresponds to the stationary state , which does not occur in the resolvents between the renormalized vertices due to our special construction , where the eigenvalue zero is perturbatively integrated out during the first discrete rg step . the poles @xmath723 and @xmath724 correspond to the spin relaxation and dephasing modes . using the symmetry properties ( [ symmetry_gamma_l ] ) and ( [ symmetry_h ] )
, we obtain under complex conjugation @xmath725 which gives @xmath726 as a consequence , eq .
( [ h_decomposition ] ) becomes @xmath727 where we sum over @xmath595 .
inserting eq .
( [ delta_decomposition ] ) for the various functions occurring in eq .
( [ l_2_final_omega=0])([l_3b_final_omega=0 ] ) , we see that the projectors stand always left to @xmath728 or @xmath729 . using the results ( [ g_bar_leading_kondo ] ) and ( [ g_2a_1_kondo ] ) for these vertices together with the algebra of the basis superoperators , we conclude that the parts of the projectors ( [ projectors ] ) containing either @xmath730 or @xmath731 do not contribute , and we can replace @xmath732 .
thus , by inserting eq .
( [ projectors ] ) in eq .
( [ delta_decomposition ] ) , we obtain the useful identity @xmath733 which will be used frequently during the following analysis . as a consequence , we find that the spin relaxation rate @xmath70 will cut off all logarithms where the magnetic field does not occur , and the spin dephasing rates @xmath71 cuts off all logarithms where the magnetic field occurs .
this is expected since the spin dephasing rate corresponds to spin flip processes .
in addition , we also conclude from eq .
( [ delta_decomposition_rg ] ) that the pole of the projector @xmath734 at @xmath735 does not contribute .
_ liouvillian and current kernel in first order . _ the liouvillian and the current kernel in first order in @xmath14 have already been determined in eqs .
( [ l_first_e_kondo])([z_first_kondo ] ) and ( [ sigma_current_first_kondo ] ) , which gives @xmath736 with @xmath737 , and @xmath738 _ liouvillian and current kernel in second order . _ the first two terms on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ l_2_final_omega=0 ] ) have already been evaluated in eqs .
( [ l_2b_kondo ] ) , ( [ z_2b_kondo ] ) , and ( [ sigma_current_2b_kondo ] ) . for the evaluation of the last two terms on the r.h.s . , we use eq .
( [ delta_decomposition_rg ] ) and the identity [ @xmath739 is any function ] @xmath740 together with the results ( [ g_bar_leading_kondo ] ) and ( [ i_leading_kondo ] ) for the first - order vertices .
after some algebra , we obtain for the components of the effective liouvillian in second order @xmath741=\\ \nonumber & & \hspace{0 cm } = { \pi\over 8}\left\{|e_{\alpha\alpha'}-\tilde{h}|(j^z_{\alpha\alpha'})^2 + \label{re_gamma_ac_2 } & & \hspace{2 cm } + ( e\rightarrow -e)\quad,\\ \nonumber & & \hspace{-1 cm } \text{im}[\gamma^{a(2)}(e)+\gamma^{c(2)}(e)]=\\ \nonumber & & \hspace{0 cm } = -{1\over 4}\left\{(e_{\alpha\alpha'}-\tilde{h}){{\mathcal{l}}_2({e_{\alpha\alpha'}-\tilde{h}})}(j^z_{\alpha\alpha'})^2+\right.\\ \label{im_gamma_ac_2 } & & \hspace{0 cm } \left.+e_{\alpha\alpha'}{{\mathcal{l}}_1({e_{\alpha\alpha'}})}(j^\perp_{\alpha\alpha'})^2\right\ } -(e\rightarrow -e)\quad,\\ \label{gamma_3z_2 } & & \hspace{-1 cm } \gamma^{3z(2)}(e)={\pi\over 2}h_0\text{tr}\hat{j}^\perp\hat{j}^\perp\quad,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the following result for the components of the current kernel in second order : @xmath742 where we have used the shorthand notation @xmath743 for the logarithmic terms .
note that the results respect the symmetry properties ( [ symmetry_gamma_l])([symmetry_h ] ) , i.e. , the real parts of all quantities are symmetric in the laplace variable @xmath297 , whereas the imaginary parts are antisymmetric in @xmath297 .
as we can see , for finite laplace variable @xmath297 , logarithmic corrections occur already in second order in @xmath14 .
this is the case for the real part of @xmath744 and the imaginary parts of @xmath745 , @xmath746 , and @xmath747 .
therefore , in the stationary state ( i.e. , for @xmath559 ) no logarithmic contributions occur in @xmath381 for the conductance and the magnetization , whereas the time evolution is influenced by logarithmic contributions already in this order , see sec . [
sec : relaxation_dephasing_rates ] for more details .
_ liouvillian and current kernel in third order .
_ in third order , there are two contributions to the effective liouvillian and the current kernel , denoted by the superscript @xmath748 and @xmath749 and given by the two expressions , eqs .
( [ l_3a_final_omega=0 ] ) and ( [ l_3b_final_omega=0 ] ) .
the components @xmath748 from eq .
( [ l_3a_final_omega=0 ] ) can be evaluated similiar to the components in second order from eq .
( [ l_2_final_omega=0 ] ) shown above , just by using in addition the results ( [ g_2a_1_kondo ] ) and ( [ i_2a_1_kondo ] ) for the imaginary part of the vertices in second order .
we obtain after some algebra for the components of the effective liouvillian @xmath750 and for the components for the current kernel @xmath751 as expected , the logarithmic terms for the real parts of @xmath558 and @xmath752 start in order @xmath753 .
this means that the logarithmic terms for the stationary magnetization ( [ rd_stationary_kondo ] ) and the stationary current ( [ current_stationary_kondo ] ) start in third order in the exchange couplings .
note that we have not calculated the terms in order @xmath754 without a logarithmic contribution .
the remaining logarithmic contributions in third order are contained in the component @xmath749 , given by ( [ l_3b_final_omega=0 ] ) and ( [ double_logarithmic_omega=0_approx ] ) . with @xmath755 and @xmath756
we have to evaluate expressions of the form [ note that @xmath757 and @xmath758 according to eqs .
( [ g_bar_leading_kondo ] ) , ( [ i_leading_kondo ] ) , and ( [ hermiticity_exchange ] ) ] @xmath759 where @xmath760 , and the two functions @xmath761 and @xmath762 are either both symmetric or antisymmetric : @xmath763 .
this identity can be derived by summing over the two possibilities @xmath603 and using the representations ( [ g_representation ] ) , ( [ i_representation ] ) , ( [ g_representation_t ] ) and ( [ i_representation_t ] ) .
the functions @xmath764 on the r.h.s . can be expressed in terms of the basis superoperators by using eq .
( [ delta_decomposition_rg ] ) , @xmath765 where @xmath766 . inserting this result in eq .
( [ product_decompose_7 ] ) , we find after some straightforward algebra @xmath767 and for @xmath559 @xmath768 using this result in eq .
( [ l_3b_final_omega=0 ] ) , we have to distinguish many different cases in order to evaluate the logarithmic contributions according to eq .
( [ double_logarithmic_omega=0_approx ] ) . to simplify the discussion
, we will assume in the following only two reservoirs with chemical potentials @xmath769 .
furthermore , we take w.l.o.g .
@xmath770 . as we will see in sec .
[ sec : relaxation_dephasing_rates ] , we need only the two cases @xmath559 and @xmath771 in eq .
( [ l_3b_decomposition ] ) for the calculation of the renormalized @xmath0 factor and the spin relaxation and dephasing rates @xmath33 up to the first logarithmic correction . for the magnetization and
the current , we consider the stationary case @xmath559 . we start with @xmath559 . in this case
, there are four possibilities for the parameters @xmath772 and @xmath773 in ( [ double_logarithmic_omega=0_approx ] ) : @xmath774 according to eq .
( [ double_logarithmic_omega=0_approx ] ) , logarithmic contributions can only occur if at least one of these parameters is small compared to one .
therefore , we can distinguish three cases @xmath775 and all the other parameters not indicated are of order one . discussing these three cases separately and collecting only the logarithmic terms according to eq .
( [ double_logarithmic_omega=0_approx ] ) , we find after some lengthy calculation @xmath776 with @xmath777 all other components do not contain any logarithmic contribution in third order in @xmath14 .
next we consider @xmath771 . in this case , there are six possibilities for the parameters @xmath772 and @xmath773 in ( [ double_logarithmic_omega=0_approx ] ) , @xmath778 in addition to the three cases shown in eq .
( [ e=0_cases ] ) , we have to consider the additional case @xmath779 discussing these four cases , we find after a lengthy calculation the following logarithmic terms for the effective liouvillian at @xmath771 : @xmath780
in this section , we summarize the zero temperature results for the anisotropic nonequilibrium kondo model in a finite magnetic field , introduced at the beginning of sec . [
sec : kondo_model_algebra ] .
we will calculate quantities characterizing the exponential time decay of the magnetization , i.e. , the spin relaxation and dephasing rates @xmath33 together with the renormalized magnetic field @xmath57 . furthermore
, we present results for the stationary current @xmath781 and the stationary magnetization @xmath35 .
all quantities are calculated one order beyond leading order , i.e. , up to the first term leading to logarithmic enhancements ( suppressions ) at resonance . for simplicity
, we evaluate the results for two reservoirs with voltages @xmath782 the diagonal and nondiagonal exchange couplings are denoted by @xmath783 the various couplings are renormalized couplings evaluated at ( note that the laplace variable @xmath297 is fixed to either @xmath559 or @xmath771 in the following ) the cutoff scale @xmath784 unrenormalized ( bare ) couplings are denoted by the index `` 0 '' .
furthermore , we consider w.l.o.g . the case @xmath770 .
although our results of the previous section include all cases for the ratios between diagonal and nondiagonal couplings , we will treat in this section the realistic case where the exchange couplings fulfil the relation ( [ j_form ] ) , i.e. , @xmath785 in this case , the two couplings @xmath74 and @xmath73 can be calculated analytically from eq . with @xmath786 according to eqs .
( [ invariant_c_tk ] ) and ( [ t_k_2_loop ] ) .
furthermore , we note that some of the third - order terms can be taken together because @xmath787 finally , for the logarithmic terms we use the shorthand notation @xmath788 and close to resonance , we use the broadened sign function @xmath789 where @xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) has to be chosen when the magnetic field does not ( does ) occur in @xmath790 ( this rule refers to the case @xmath559 , for @xmath771 also other cases can occur , see below ) .
furthermore , we use the broadening of the sign function also for expressions involving the absolute value or the theta function via @xmath791\quad.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this section , we determine the renormalized magnetic field @xmath57 or the renormalized @xmath0 factor @xmath792 together with the renormalized spin relaxation and dephasing rates @xmath33 . these quantities
enter all formulas , especially they determine the resonance position @xmath793 and how the logarithmic divergencies are cut off by the rates .
we note that previous works have only calculated @xmath33 up to @xmath381 in bare perturbation theory,@xcite and the renormalized magnetic field has so far been calculated only up to @xmath650 , see , e.g. , ref . .
in contrast , here we perform a renormalized perturbation theory for the rates and calculate in addition the logarithmic terms of @xmath794 for @xmath33 and those of @xmath795 for @xmath57 ( corresponding to contributions in three - loop by using the conventional classification ) .
furthermore , we emphasize that we do not need to combine self - energy terms with vertex corrections as in slave - particle formalism @xcite since we have directly set up a kinetic equation from the very beginning where the renormalized rates and the renormalized magnetic field can be directly read off by studying the poles of the reduced density matrix of the quantum dot in laplace space , see the discussion at the end of sec .
[ sec : generic_model ] .
we now calculate @xmath57 and @xmath33 perturbatively in the renormalized exchange couplings by using our results ( [ h_1])([gamma_c_1 ] ) , ( [ re_h_2])([im_gamma_ac_2 ] ) , ( [ gamma_a_3b ] ) , ( [ gamma_ac_3b ] ) , and ( [ gamma_a_3b_e = h])([h_3b_e = h ] ) for @xmath796 and @xmath797 ( note that we take the analytic continuation @xmath798 of these equations ) .
thereby , we consider all terms of @xmath799 for @xmath33 , and all terms of @xmath800 , @xmath650 , @xmath795 for @xmath57 . terms of @xmath754 [ @xmath381 ] without any logarithmic contribution are consistently neglected for @xmath33 ( @xmath57 ) . to get the perturbative solution , we insert first the lowest order results ( [ h_1])([gamma_c_1 ] ) into eqs .
( [ z_1 ] ) and ( [ z_+- ] ) .
this gives @xmath802 using the forms ( [ z_1_form ] ) and ( [ z_+-_form ] ) for @xmath723 and @xmath803 , we see that @xmath33 starts at @xmath381 .
therefore , neglecting terms of @xmath375 , we can replace @xmath804 and @xmath805 in the arguments of @xmath806 and @xmath807 for @xmath808 .
furthermore , we can neglect all contributions of @xmath754 for the first term on the r.h.s .
( [ z_1_zw ] ) , and all terms of @xmath381 for the first term on the r.h.s . of eq . ( [ z_+_zw ] ) ( since they do not contain any logarithmic contribution ) .
thus , we finally obtain @xmath809 where @xmath810 is the renormalized magnetic field up to first order in @xmath14 . inserting the results ( [ re_h_2])([im_gamma_ac_2 ] ) , ( [ gamma_a_3b ] ) , ( [ gamma_ac_3b ] ) , and ( [ gamma_a_3b_e = h])([h_3b_e = h ] ) into eqs .
( [ tilde_gamma_1])([tilde_h ] ) , and specializing to the case ( [ two_reservoirs ] ) of two reservoirs and the special form ( [ exchange_couplings_special ] ) of the exchange couplings , we obtain @xmath811 these formulas show precisely which rate cuts off the various logarithmic terms .
since the determination of the renormalized rates and the renormalized magnetic field involves also the value of the liouvillian @xmath329 at @xmath771 , we can not just use the simple rule that @xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) cuts off the logarithms where the magnetic field does not ( does ) occur ( as it is the case for the stationary case @xmath559 ) .
in contrast , we find that the logarithmic terms of @xmath57 and @xmath71 are cut off by @xmath70 , and those of @xmath70 by @xmath71 .
@xmath812 is the well - known renormalized magnetic field up to first order in @xmath14 which determines the precise resonance positions .
note that the sign of the linear terms in @xmath14 in eq .
( [ renormalized_h ] ) is different from the one in eq .
( [ l_first_kondo ] ) , showing that it is important to consider the linear term in frequency of the renormalized liouvillian to determine the correct renormalization of the magnetic field ( similiar to field - theoretical rescaling techniques from the @xmath177 factor@xcite ) .
note that the renormalized magnetic field is linear in the renormalized coupling , but starts only in second order with respect to the bare coupling .
furthermore , we note that the determination of the renormalized magnetic field up to first order in @xmath14 is usually associated with a two - loop calculation , see , e.g. , ref . , i.e. , the first diagram of fig .
[ fig : rg_liouvillian_g ] is called a two - loop diagram .
we are not adopting this notation in the present paper because this diagram arises from closing the one - loop diagram for the renormalization of the vertex ( the third diagram in fig .
[ fig : rg_liouvillian_g ] ) .
therefore we call this diagram also one - loop and the second diagram of fig .
[ fig : rg_liouvillian_g ] a two - loop diagram ( which usually would be classified as three - loop ) .
we note that the classification in one - loop and two - loop contributions is not unambiguous , e.g. , if one uses a not - normaled ordered version of the rg formalism , the renormalization of the magnetic field in lowest order in @xmath14 would arise from closing the renormalized vertex with itself , i.e. , in this case one would classify it as one - loop .
therefore , we prefer in this paper a classification according to the orders in @xmath14 and not with respect to the loop topology of the diagrams . some insight into the logarithmic terms in @xmath33 and @xmath57 can be gained by differentiating these quantities with respect to the bare magnetic field @xmath27 [ for the rates @xmath33 and the second - order terms in @xmath57 , it is actually equivalent to differentiate with respect to @xmath57 because multiplying with @xmath813 would just bring the expression one order higher in @xmath14 , leading to terms which we have neglected anyhow ] .
furthermore , we differentiate only the prefactor of the logarithmic terms and disregard the dependence of the renormalized exchange couplings on @xmath27 ( which are small corrections since the logarithm varies only slowly ) .
this gives @xmath814 where we have used eq .
( [ eq:3rd - order - jz - jp ] ) to take some terms together . and @xmath815 , derived with respect to the magnetic field @xmath27 , for the isotropic kondo model with @xmath816 and @xmath817 .
@xmath818 exhibits a logarithmic enhancement for @xmath819 whereas @xmath820 is suppressed for @xmath821 . ]
factor @xmath822 , derived with respect to the magnetic field @xmath27 , for the isotropic kondo model with @xmath816 and @xmath817 . ] for both rates @xmath33 , we get a jump in @xmath823 at @xmath824 in the leading order . in the next to leading order
, there is a logarithmic enhancement for @xmath825 for both rates and a logarithmic enhancement for @xmath819 in @xmath826 while we find a logarithmic suppression in @xmath827 for @xmath821 , see fig .
[ fig : rates ] . the renormalized @xmath0 factor shows a logarithmic suppression for @xmath825 and another logarithmic suppression for @xmath828 which is symmetric , in contrast to the effects we observed for the rates , see fig .
[ fig : gfactor ] .
as one can see , the second - order logarithmic terms lead to significant changes of the first - order shift of the @xmath0 factor . especially at resonance @xmath793 , where one usually reads off the renormalized magnetic field from the conductance ( see below ) ,
the change in the @xmath0 factor by the logarithmic contributions is very important .
however , fixing the voltage at @xmath793 , we obtain @xmath829-(j^\perp_{\text{nd}})^2\ , \left(\ln{v\over\tilde{\gamma}_1}\right)|_{v=\tilde{h}}\quad,\ ] ] with @xmath830\quad.\ ] ] as a consequence , the @xmath0 factor at @xmath793 shows only a weak dependence on the bare magnetic field @xmath27 via the renormalization of the exchange couplings .
the second - order terms just lead to an additional overall decrease @xmath831 . to see the suppression of the @xmath0 factor more clearly at resonance ,
it is necessary to measure it directly for various values of @xmath832 . in principle
this can be achieved by electron spin resonance ( esr ) , but , similiar to previous measurements of the splitting of the kondo resonance in the spectral density,@xcite we propose here a simpler setup with a weakly coupled third lead , see fig . [ fig:3_lead_configuration ] .
we use the form ( [ j_form ] ) and , for simplicity , choose a symmetric coupling to the left and right leads , @xmath833 , in order to measure the renormalized @xmath0 factor as function of the applied voltage @xmath834 . ] by changing the voltage @xmath835 of the probe lead and measuring the differential conductance @xmath836 , one can probe the renormalized @xmath0 factor as function of the voltage @xmath837 between the strongly coupled left and right leads .
the reason is that the contribution of inelastic cotunneling to the probe current changes when the probe voltage crosses the resonance points @xmath838 .
the probe current up to second order in @xmath839 can be calculated from eqs .
, , and with the result @xmath840 where @xmath841\quad,\\ \nonumber \gamma^{1z(2)}_p(0)~&=&~-{\pi\over 4}\ , \left(|v_p-{v\over 2}-\tilde{h}|_2+|v_p+{v\over 2}-\tilde{h}|_2-\right.\\ \label{gamma_1z_probe } & & \hspace{-2 cm } \left.-|v_p-{v\over 2}+\tilde{h}|_2-|v_p+{v\over 2}+\tilde{h}|_2\right ) \,\left(j^\perp_{p , nd}\right)^2\quad.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath35 is the magnetization , which in lowest order is independent of the probe lead and is calculated in the next section .
taking the derivative with respect to @xmath835 , we find that @xmath842 is independent of @xmath835 , whereas @xmath843 gives rise to a steplike structure shown in figs . [ fig:3-terminal-1 ] and [ fig:3-terminal-2 ] for the two regimes @xmath844 and @xmath845 , respectively .
sufficiently far away from resonance , we obtain analytically from eq . for @xmath844 @xmath846 and for @xmath845 @xmath847 from the width of the steplike
features one can read off the renormalized magnetic field @xmath57 at given voltage @xmath26 and magnetic field @xmath27 .
thus , by varying @xmath26 or @xmath27 , one can measure the renormalized @xmath0 factor as function of @xmath832 , thereby revealing the suppression at resonance @xmath793 as shown in fig .
[ fig : gfactor ] .
we note that the experimental situation is usually in the strong coupling regime @xmath848 , where the qualitative features are expected to be more pronounced .
, @xmath849 , and @xmath817 . ] , @xmath850 , and @xmath817 . ]
the stationary magnetization ( which is nonzero only if a magnetic field @xmath851 is applied ) can be calculated from the stationary density matrix ( [ rd_stationary_kondo ] ) .
this density matrix is the solution of the kinetic equation and is a diagonal matrix .
the occupation probabilities for the states @xmath526 and @xmath852 are @xmath853 and the magnetization is given by @xmath854 @xmath855 is given by eq .
( [ tilde_gamma_1_final ] ) .
@xmath856 can be calculated from eqs .
( [ gamma_3z_2 ] ) and ( [ gamma_3z_3a ] ) : @xmath857 where we have replaced @xmath858 in the first term , which gives only rise to negligible terms of @xmath859 .
because we have considered all terms of @xmath799 for the rates , we can calculate the leading order @xmath800 ( which is independent of the couplings ) and logarithmically enhanced terms in @xmath860 of the magnetization .
using eq .
( [ eq:3rd - order - jz - jp ] ) and the abbreviation @xmath861 we can write the magnetization in the compact form @xmath862 we note that , in the isotropic case , and when expanded systematically in @xmath14 , the terms of @xmath863 are in agreement with the perturbative results obtained in ref . and the poor man scaling results of ref .
if the different definition of the magnetization is taken into account ( the magnetization in those references is @xmath864 in the ground state , whereas it is @xmath865 here ) .
however , we have shown here how the spin dephasing rate cuts off all the logarithmic divergencies ( the treatment in ref .
was only perturbative in the bare coupling and did not treat the case of finite magnetic field ) . if the voltage is smaller than the renormalized magnetic field @xmath57 , the logarithmic term @xmath866 in the numerator of eq .
( [ magnetization_compact ] ) must be consistently neglected and the magnetization is equal to @xmath867 .
this is because the energy difference provided by the voltage is insufficient to flip the spin @xmath868 in the dot out of its ground state @xmath527 . in the limit @xmath869 , the logarithmic term @xmath870 in the denominator of eq .
( [ magnetization_compact ] ) must be neglected and the magnetization is given by @xmath871 which , for @xmath872 , can be expanded as @xmath873 as we see , there is an interesting logarithmic enhancement at @xmath874 , which is a pure nonequilibrium effect [ if we set @xmath875 in eq .
( [ magnetization_v>>h ] ) , we get @xmath876 . in the limit @xmath877 , @xmath878 , ( i.e. , for voltages which are slightly larger than the renormalized magnetic field )
, we can neglect all logarithmic terms @xmath866 and find after expanding in @xmath14 @xmath879\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result shows the logarithmic enhancement of the magnetization slightly above the resonance . from the magnetization
, we can also calculate the susceptibility @xmath880 which we calculate by differentiating the magnetization with respect to the bare magnetic field @xmath27 [ or the renormalized field @xmath57 by multiplying with @xmath881 . in the special case of symmetric couplings
( @xmath882 for @xmath883 ) , the magnetization for @xmath877 can be expanded as @xmath884 and the susceptibility becomes @xmath885 to visualize the logarithmic effects better , we multiply @xmath886 with @xmath887 and get @xmath888 plotting eq . as function of the magnetic field @xmath27 emphasizes the logarithmic enhancements at @xmath889 and @xmath828 , see fig .
[ fig : susceptibility ] . , multiplied with @xmath890 , as function of the magnetic field @xmath27 for the isotropic kondo model with @xmath816 and @xmath817 . ] in this plot , we multiply the susceptibility @xmath886 not with @xmath891 , but with @xmath890 because this change causes only subleading corrections and because the unrenormalized magnetic field @xmath27 is easier to access experimentally . in summary , from the various expansions eqs .
( [ magnetization_v>>h_expanded ] ) , ( [ magnetization_at_resonance ] ) , and ( [ magnetization_symmetric_case ] ) , we find that , for @xmath877 , the logarithmic terms at @xmath874 and @xmath824 are essentially proportional to the longitudinal exchange coupling @xmath74 .
this means that even in the limit @xmath75 , these logarithmic contributions survive , which is an interesting nonequilibrium effect . the stationary current can be calculated from eq .
( [ current_stationary_kondo ] ) , @xmath892 where the stationary magnetization @xmath35 follows from eq . and
the components @xmath893 and @xmath894 of the current kernel are listed in eqs . , , , and .
for the special case ( [ two_reservoirs ] ) of two reservoirs and the relation ( [ exchange_couplings_special ] ) between the exchange couplings , we obtain @xmath895 where we have used @xmath896 . for @xmath897 ,
the logarithmic terms @xmath898 can be neglected and the magnetization is given by @xmath899 . according to eq .
( [ current_stationary_kondo_final ] ) , this leads to @xmath900 , and we see that the logarithmic terms @xmath901 cancel .
this gives the result of elastic cotunneling @xmath902 but with renormalized exchange couplings . at @xmath903 ,
the differential conductance @xmath904 has an interesting feature , see fig .
[ fig : conductance ] . for voltages slightly below the renormalized magnetic field ( @xmath905 , @xmath906 )
, we get in units of @xmath907 ( as before , we list the leading order and logarithmic terms in next - to - leading order ) @xmath908 . \label{inelastic_cotunneling_1}\ ] ] for voltages slightly above the renormalized magnetic field ( @xmath877 , @xmath878 ) , we get @xmath909\\ + \left(j^z{_{\text{l}}}+j^z{_{\text{r}}}\right)\left(j^\perp{_{\text{nd}}}\right)^2 \left[3+\left(\frac{2j^\perp{_{\text{nd}}}}{j^\perp{_{\text{l}}}+j^\perp{_{\text{r}}}}\right)^2\right ] { { \mathcal{l}}_2({v-\tilde{h } } ) } \bigg\}. \label{inelastic_cotunneling_2}\end{gathered}\ ] ] two interesting features happen at @xmath903 : there is a jump in the leading order term in the conductance ( if @xmath910 ) that is due to inelastic cotunneling which sets in at this voltage .
the jump is superposed by a logarithmic term which becomes largest for @xmath793 .
the experimentally accessible parameters characterizing the line shape are given by the position , broadening and height of the resonance .
the position is approximately at @xmath793 [ up to unimportant terms of the @xmath911 , and the broadening of the left side of the resonance is given by @xmath71 . using eqs . and
, we obtain at resonance @xmath912 the right side of the resonance has no characteristic broadening : asymptotically it reveals the logarithmic voltage dependence of the exchange couplings .
the value of the conductance at resonance can be calculated in good approximation by taking the extrapolation of eq .
( [ inelastic_cotunneling_2 ] ) at @xmath793 , i.e. , by replacing @xmath913 in eq .
( [ inelastic_cotunneling_2 ] ) . together with eq .
, this reveals the kondo - induced logarithmic enhancement @xmath914 of the conductance at resonance superposed on the enhancement from inelastic cotunneling .
the result for the maximal conductance can be simplified by using the relation ( [ exchange_couplings_special ] ) , which gives @xmath915 with @xmath916 this result for the value of the maximum conductance at resonance has first been noted in ref . for the case of the isotropic kondo model and @xmath917 .
our results for the differential conductance agree with those of refs . and
. however , note that the precise line shape at resonance can only be obtained if one includes the cutoff scales @xmath33 into the logarithms and uses the correct smearing ( [ sign_replacement ] ) of the sign function . in the numerical plots
, we have always used these smeared forms and we calculated @xmath57 and @xmath33 self - consistenly from eqs .
( [ tilde_gamma_1_final])([tilde_h_final ] ) ( the same procedure has been used for the susceptibility ) . as function of bias voltage at @xmath918 for the isotropic kondo model with @xmath919 . ] in this section , we discuss how the results for the differential conductance , the susceptibility , the relaxation and dephasing rates , and the renormalized @xmath0 factor are affected if we consider the symmetric , but anisotropic kondo model with @xmath920 . as
recently proposed,@xcite such models can , e.g. , be experimentally realized by studying quantum transport through single molecular magnets , where the transverse exchange coupling is induced by magnetic quantum tunneling terms due to transverse anisotropies . to investigate this ,
we vary @xmath74 and @xmath73 such that the kondo temperature @xmath13 remains constant and only the other invariant of the rg equations , i.e. , @xmath677 is changed , see .
if @xmath921 is positive , @xmath74 is larger and @xmath73 is smaller than the isotropic coupling in the case @xmath922 . as function of bias voltage at @xmath918 for the isotropic kondo model ( solid line ) and the anisotropic kondo model with two different values of @xmath677 ( dashed and dash - dotted lines ) .
the kondo temperature @xmath919 is the same in all cases . ]
the differential conductance is shown for three different values of @xmath921 in fig .
[ fig : anisotropic - conductance ] . for growing @xmath921 ,
i.e. , increasing @xmath74 and decreasing @xmath73 , we can observe a number of different effects compared to the isotropic case : first , the conductance for @xmath897 which is proportional to @xmath923 according to eq .
is increased .
second , the step at @xmath793 that is due to inelastic cotunneling decreases its height which is proportional to @xmath924 in leading order according to eqs . and .
third , also the logarithmic enhancement at @xmath793 is reduced for increasing @xmath921 .
the prefactors of the logarithmic terms in eqs . and are proportional to @xmath925 , a quantity which decreases for increasing @xmath921 . finally , the position of the step and the logarithmic enhancement shifts to the right , i.e. , @xmath57 is increased .
the reason is that the leading contribution to @xmath926 is negative and proportional to @xmath927 , i.e. , the renormalization of the coupling @xmath74 , according to eq . .
this renormalization is in leading order determined by @xmath924 , see eq . .
an increase in @xmath921 which is connected to a decrease in @xmath73 therefore leads to a weaker renormalization of @xmath74 and hence to a larger value of @xmath928 .
figure [ fig : anisotropic - susceptibility ] shows the magnetic susceptibility @xmath929 , multiplied with @xmath890 , for different values of the anisotropy . , multiplied with @xmath930 , as function of the magnetic field at @xmath816 for the isotropic kondo model ( solid line ) and the anisotropic kondo model with two different values of @xmath677 ( dashed and dash - dotted lines ) .
the kondo temperature @xmath817 is the same in all cases . ] for larger @xmath921 , i.e. , increased @xmath74 , the logarithmic enhancements become larger , see eq . .
this is an effect already mentioned at the end of sec .
[ sec : magnetization ] .
the susceptibility depends only on the longitudinal coupling @xmath74 and the logarithmic contributions survive even in the limit @xmath75 . especially for molecular magnets with a very small quantum tunneling term ,
this might be an interesting possibility to observe logarithmic contributions in the susceptibility although the kondo temperature might be quite small .
furthermore , the resonance at the point where @xmath824 shifts slightly , this is due to the dependence of @xmath57 on the anisotropy which was discussed above .
the derivatives of the rates @xmath931 and @xmath815 with respect to the magnetic field @xmath27 are shown in figs .
[ fig : anisotropic - gamma1 ] and [ fig : anisotropic - gamma2 ] , respectively . , derived with respect to the magnetic field , as function of the magnetic field at @xmath816 for the isotropic kondo model ( solid line ) and the anisotropic kondo model with two different values of @xmath677 ( dashed and dash - dotted lines ) .
the kondo temperature @xmath817 is the same in all cases . ]
increasing @xmath921 , i.e. , decreasing @xmath73 , leads to a decrease in the leading - order contributions to the derivatives of the rates which are proportional to @xmath924 , see eqs . and . ,
derived with respect to the magnetic field , as function of the magnetic field at @xmath816 for the isotropic kondo model ( solid line ) and the anisotropic kondo model with two different values of @xmath677 ( dashed and dash - dotted lines ) .
the kondo temperature @xmath817 is the same in all cases . ]
the dependence of the logarithmic effects at @xmath874 and @xmath824 on the anisotropy is different for the derivatives of the two different rates : the features in @xmath932 become less pronounced whereas the resonances in @xmath933 become sharper .
the reason is as follows : all logarithmic terms in next to leading order in the rates are proportional to @xmath934 which decreases for larger anisotropy , but the logarithms are broadened by @xmath815 in the case of @xmath932 [ see eq . ] and by @xmath931 in the case of @xmath933 [ see eq . ] .
the fact that @xmath931 , which is proportional to @xmath935 in leading order according to eq . , decreases for larger @xmath921 , and @xmath815 , which contains a term @xmath936 , see eq . , increases with @xmath921
, explains the observed behavior .
finally , we discuss how the renormalized @xmath0 factor is affected by the anisotropy , see fig .
[ fig : anisotropic - g - factor ] .
factor @xmath937 as function of the magnetic field at @xmath816 for the isotropic kondo model ( solid line ) and the anisotropic kondo model with two different values of @xmath677 ( dashed and dash - dotted lines ) .
the kondo temperature @xmath817 is the same in all cases . ] for growing @xmath921 , the deviation of @xmath34 from the unrenormalized value 2 becomes smaller .
the reason has already been discussed above : like the renormalized field @xmath57 , the @xmath0 factor is in first order given by the renormalization of the coupling @xmath74 which is determined by @xmath935 and is therefore decreased for positive @xmath921 .
also the prefactors of the logarithmic terms depend on @xmath935 and therefore become smaller for growing @xmath921 .
we have presented a systematic and analytic weak - coupling analysis in two - loop for a generic quantum dot coupled to reservoirs via spin or orbital fluctuations .
we have used a nonequilibrium rg formalism in liouville space ( or , equivalently , on the keldysh contour ) , which is a natural and formally exact generalization of conventional poor man scaling methods .
the essential difference between the rtrg - fs method and other rg formalisms in nonequilibrium @xcite is the fact that rtrg - fs analyzes the dynamics of the reduced dot density matrix in laplace space by calculating an effective dot liouvillian . in each step of the rg approach an effective kinetic equation
is obtained .
the rg equations are coupled differential equations for the kernel determining this kinetic equation and for the vertices in liouville space .
the structure in liouville space is essential for the generation of dissipation and to obtain the _ transport _ relaxation and dephasing rates together with the _ transport _ oscillation frequencies of the various exponentially damped modes ( rather than quantities of quantum decay theory , which describe the decay of a discrete dot state into the reservoir continuum ) .
technically , it is known from the keldysh formalism @xcite that dissipation ( or the collision term of a quantum boltzmann equation ) is generated by diagrams connecting the upper with the lower part of the keldysh contour .
therefore , to get the correct transport rates and the precise position of resonances from the oscillation frequencies , it is essential to include these contributions in the theory and , at the same time , combine it with rg methods to get rid of logarithmic divergencies .
we note that the rtrg - fs formalism is not based on the usual keldysh formalism as , e.g. , methods based on slave particles @xcite or nonequilibrium functional rg methods.@xcite since the unperturbed part of the hamiltonian contains strong interactions , the rtrg - fs integrates out only the noninteracting reservoirs but takes the correlation effects on the quantum dot exactly into account .
this leads to a natural formalism in terms of liouville operators and vertices in liouville space , which we have combined with quantum field theoretical methods of diagrammatic representations and rg . in this sense
, we have combined the advantages of liouville operator techniques ( providing very compact notations for the time evolution of the reduced density matrix in laplace space ) , diagrammatic methods ( to identify and calculate irreducible blocks leading to the oscillation frequencies and the relaxation / dephasing rates ) , and rg methods ( reorganizing the perturbation theory in such a way that logarithmic divergencies are absent ) . in particular , it is possible to prove generically in all orders of perturbation theory and within all truncation schemes that the cutoff scales for the vertices are the physical relaxation and dephasing rates of the exponentially decaying modes of the reduced density matrix of the dot .
this provides a reliable calculation of the line shape at resonances .
in addition , one obtains the kernel of the kinetic equation in laplace space from which the time evolution into the stationary state can be calculated .
it is important to note that the possibility to calculate the time evolution is closely related to the fact that we obtain a systematic theory for the line shape at resonances , since the oscillation frequencies and the relaxation / dephasing rates governing the exponential decay of the _ time evolution _ are the _ same _ scales which determine the resonance positions and the cutoff of logarithmic divergencies at resonances for _ stationary _ quantities such as , e.g. , the magnetization or the conductance . in comparism to previous formulations of rtrg ( refs . ) ( where the physics of cutoff scales by relaxation / dephasing modes was also included ) , the recently proposed rtrg - fs method @xcite is a formulation in pure matsubara frequency space and avoids the need of the keldysh indices after a first discrete rg step where the symmetric part of the fermi distribution is integrated out .
the main advantage of this development is the possibility to prove that the perturbation theory in the renormalized vertices on the r.h.s .
of the rg equation is a well defined series in the weak - coupling regime .
essential for this proof is the fact that the imaginary part of the denominators of all resolvents consists of a sum of strictly positive matsubara frequencies ( bounded from above by the cutoff ) , the cutoff scale @xmath15 , and some positive relaxation or dephasing rate @xmath185 . as a consequence , it is possible to solve the rg equations analytically in the weak - coupling regime by a systematic perturbative expansion in the renormalized couplings .
in this paper , we have described this procedure for a generic quantum dot in the coulomb blockade regime where spin and/or orbital fluctuations dominate the transport properties .
we have included all two - loop contributions to calculate physical quantities up to the first logarithmic contribution at resonances .
we have shown that the latter are well defined after renormalization and can be treated within perturbation theory in the renormalized couplings .
we have applied the formalism to the anisotropic kondo model at finite magnetic field and finite bias voltage .
we calculated stationary properties ( magnetic susceptibility and conductance ) and the parameters characterizing the exponentially damped modes of the time evolution ( renormalized magnetic field , spin relaxation and dephasing rate ) .
in comparism to the case of zero magnetic field ( which was treated within flow equation methods already in ref . for the isotropic kondo model ) , the central issue is the calculation of logarithmically enhanced contributions at the resonance positions @xmath828 and @xmath889 .
the one - loop leading order theory of ref .
was able to obtain these logarithmic contributions but it was not shown how to include microscopically the cutoff scales from relaxation and dephasing modes into the rg formalism .
furthermore , the renormalization of the magnetic field was not taken into account and the calculation was restricted to the stationary values of the magnetic susceptibility and the conductance ( the spin relaxation and dephasing rates were calculated only perturbatively in the bare coupling and in the absence of a magnetic field in ref . ) . in this paper
, we have included the renormalization of the magnetic field in @xmath650 and @xmath795 together with the spin relaxation and dephasing rate in @xmath381 and @xmath794 .
this provides a consistent theory for the resonance position and the line shape at resonance , and answers the question which rate occurs in the various logarithmic terms . for stationary quantities , the obvious physical result that the spin dephasing rate cuts off the logarithmic contributions is obtained . for the rates and the renormalized field itself
, it turns out that the spin relaxation rate determines the resonant line shape for the spin dephasing rate and the @xmath0 factor , whereas the spin dephasing rate controls the resonant line shape for the spin relaxation rate .
in addition , it turns out that the logarithmic enhancements or suppressions at the resonance @xmath824 are quite different for the various physical quantities regarding the symmetry for @xmath819 and @xmath821 .
the @xmath0 factor shows a symmetric suppression , the conductance an asymmetric enhancement , the suspectibility shows only an enhancement for @xmath821 , the derivative @xmath938 of the spin relaxation rate only an enhancement for @xmath877 , and the corresponding quantity for the spin dephasing rate only a suppression for @xmath905 .
we proposed an experimental setup with a weakly coupled probe lead to measure the logarithmic suppression of the renormalized @xmath0 factor as function of voltage @xmath26 or magnetic field @xmath27 .
this has to be contrasted to the usual measurement of the @xmath0 factor at resonance @xmath793 from the position of the cotunneling- and kondo - enhanced conductance peak , which provides the @xmath0 factor only for one special value of the voltage . in the anisotropic case ,
we find the obvious result that all logarithmic contributions involving the transverse coupling are suppressed for increasing longitudinal coupling since the renormalization of the transverse coupling is reduced .
however , for the magnetic susceptibility this does not hold since the transverse coupling cancels out in the prefactor of the logarithmic terms .
therefore , the logarithmic enhancements become larger for the susceptibility if one increases the longitudinal coupling .
this result might be helpful to find kondo physics in transport through single molecular magnets , where the transverse coupling can be smaller than the longitudinal one .
concerning the line shape at resonance when increasing the longitudinal coupling , it turns out that the logarithmic features become less pronounced if the spin dephasing rate determines the line shape , whereas it becomes sharper when the spin relaxation rate is involved .
the reason is that the spin dephasing rate involves a voltage - induced term @xmath939 , which increases with increasing longitudinal coupling , whereas the spin relaxation rate involves only the transverse coupling in order @xmath381 .
in this section we provide a complete list of all symbols used in this paper .
we present two tables , one for the symbols used in sec .
[ sec : generic ] of the generic case , and one for sec .
[ sec : kondo ] where the method is applied to the kondo model . the table for the symbols used in sec . [ sec : generic ]
is given by [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ]
we thank n. andrei , l. glazman , s. jakobs , s. kehrein , h. kroha , j. knig , t. korb , v. koerting , m. kurz , v. meden , j. paaske , m. pletyukhov , a. rosch , d. schuricht , m. wegewijs , p. wlfle , and a. zawadowski for valuable discussions .
this work was supported by the dfg - forschergruppe 723 , the vw foundation , and the forschungszentrum jlich via the virtual institute ifmit .
in this appendix , we prove that the effect of the rg terms ( [ l_expansion_term_3 ] ) and ( [ l_expansion_term_4 ] ) is the replacement @xmath940 in eq .
( [ l_2_term_a ] ) , with @xmath941 defined by eq .
( [ tilde_f_prime ] ) .
first we consider the term ( [ l_expansion_term_4 ] ) .
the terms of @xmath942 can be extracted by using the expansion ( [ integral_resolvent_expansion ] ) for the integral over the resolvent and considering only the terms of @xmath25 and @xmath410 in this expansion , @xmath943 where we have defined @xmath944 inserting this in eq .
( [ l_expansion_term_4 ] ) for the two independent integrals over the resolvents and collecting the terms in @xmath942 leads to the result @xmath945 equations ( [ g_2b_term_1 ] ) and ( [ g_2b_term_3 ] ) are independent of the integration variable @xmath949 , and we can replace the logarithm by @xmath950 inserting eqs .
( [ g_2b_term_1 ] ) and ( [ g_2b_term_3 ] ) in ( [ l_expansion_term_3 ] ) , using eq .
( [ integral_resolvent_lowest ] ) , and collecting all terms of @xmath942 , we find @xmath951 i.e. , the terms cancel each other .
in contrast , eqs .
( [ g_2b_term_2 ] ) and ( [ g_2b_term_4 ] ) are not independent of the integration variable @xmath949 . when inserted in eq .
( [ l_expansion_term_3 ] ) , we need the integral ( @xmath952 is replaced by its eigenvalue in this equation ) @xmath953 where we have expanded up to linear order in @xmath954 .
this gives @xmath955 using the antisymmetry property ( [ rg_g_symmetry ] ) , we see that the second term is zero and the first term agrees with eq .
( [ l_expansion_term_4_new ] ) , leading to the final result @xmath956 finally , using the leading - order rg equations ( [ g_reference_solution ] ) or ( [ i_reference_solution ] ) , we see that eq .
( [ l_expansion_term_34_new ] ) can be written in the form @xmath957 i.e. , a similiar term to eq .
( [ l_2_term_a ] ) results , which proves the replacement ( [ tilde_f_prime ] ) .
l. i. glazman and m. pustilnik , in _ nanophysics : coherence and transport _
( h. bouchiat et al . , elsevier , 2005 )
p. 427 ; note that a typing error occured in eq .
( 5.63 ) of this reference , the coefficient in front of the @xmath958-function must be @xmath600 and not @xmath959 . | we apply a recently developed nonequilibrium real - time renormalization group ( rg ) method in frequency space to describe nonlinear quantum transport through a small fermionic quantum system coupled weakly to several reservoirs via spin and/or orbital fluctuations . within a weak - coupling two - loop analysis
, we derive analytic formulas for the nonlinear conductance and the kernel determining the time evolution of the reduced density matrix .
a consistent formalism is presented how the rg flow is cut off by relaxation and dephasing rates .
we apply the general formalism to the nonequilibrium anisotropic kondo model at finite magnetic field .
we consider the weak - coupling regime , where the maximum of voltage and bare magnetic field is larger than the kondo temperature . in this regime , we calculate the nonlinear conductance , the magnetic susceptibility , the renormalized spin relaxation and dephasing rates , and the renormalized @xmath0 factor .
all quantities are considered up to the first logarithmic correction beyond leading order at resonance . up to a redefinition of the kondo temperature ,
we confirm previous results for the conductance and the magnetic susceptibility in the isotropic case .
in addition , we present a consistent calculation of the resonant line shapes , including the determination whether the spin relaxation or dephasing rate cuts off the logarithmic divergence .
furthermore , we calculate quantities characterizing the exponential decay of the time evolution of the magnetization .
in contrast to the conductance , we find that the derivative of the spin relaxation ( dephasing ) rate with respect to the magnetic field is logarithmically enhanced ( suppressed ) for voltages smaller ( larger ) than the renormalized magnetic field , and that the logarithmic divergence is cut off by the opposite rate .
the renormalized @xmath0 factor is predicted to show a symmetric logarithmic suppression at resonance , which is cut off by the spin relaxation rate .
we propose a three - terminal setup to measure the suppression at resonance . for all quantities ,
we analyze also the anisotropic case and find additional nonequilibrium effects at resonance . |
inclusive semi - leptonic decays are the cleanest way to access the matrix elements of the ckm matrix . in order to achieve precision in the determination of the ckm parameters
a reliable theoretical framework is needed in addition to precise data . from the off - diagonal ckm matrix elements only @xmath5 and @xmath3
are known very precisely from direct measurements @xcite , and both determinations can be related to a clean theoretical treatment : while the theoretical machinery for the determination of @xmath5 from @xmath6 decays is chiral perturbation theory , the theoretical basis for the precision determination of @xmath3 is the heavy quark expansion ( hqe ) . the hqe @xcite has become a very reliable theoretical tool , in particular for semi - leptonic decays . at present , data on inclusive semi - leptonic decays @xmath7 are so precise that not only a determination of @xmath3 at the level of 2% accuracy is possible @xcite , but also a check of the consistency of the hqe can be performed by determining the parameters of the hqe in different ways @xcite .
these parameters are the kinetic energy parameter @xmath8 and the chromo - magnetic moment @xmath9 at order @xmath10 and the darwin term @xmath11 and the spin - orbit term @xmath12 at order @xmath1 .
we shall stick here with the kinetic scheme , the alternative @xmath13 scheme @xcite yields similar precision . using the moments of the hadronic invariant mass spectrum and the charged lepton energy spectrum these parameters
can be consistently determined with an accuracy of about ten percent . within the hqe the order of the moments
is related to the order in the @xmath0 expansion @xcite .
for example , the moments @xmath14 for the case of charmless semi - leptonic @xmath4 decays are determined by the contributions of the order @xmath15 .
thus in order to exploit precise measurements of the lepton energy spectrum , i.e. measurements of higher moments , it is mandatory to perform the theoretical calculation up to a sufficient order in the @xmath0 expansion .
the current theoretical state of the art which is used in the fits is already quite elaborate . at leading order ( which is the partonic rate ) the full @xmath16 and the partial @xmath17 result
is known , while the @xmath10 and @xmath1 results are used at tree level .
hence the leading uncertainties are the @xmath16 contributions at @xmath10 and the tree level contributions to order @xmath2 . in the present paper
we present a systematic way to perform the calculation of higher order terms in the @xmath0 expansion .
this approach is then used to perform the complete calculation of the @xmath2 terms for the semi - leptonic decay @xmath7 , keeping the charm mass to all orders . in the next section
we shall outline our calculational method , which amounts to a systematization for the tree - level calculation of terms to some order @xmath15 .
this method is then applied to the case of @xmath2 . in section [ hqeparameters ]
we identify and discuss the parameters appearing at @xmath2 , where we find in total five independent matrix elements , which , however , have a simple physical interpretation . in section [ semilep ]
we discuss the impact of these additional terms on the analysis of semi - leptonic decays .
in this section we outline a method which allows us - at least in principle - to calculate the decay rates of semi - leptonic inclusive decays at any order in the @xmath0 expansion at tree level . the starting point for such
a calculation is the hadronic tensor , which according to the optical theorem can be related to the discontinuity of a time - ordered product of currents across a cut .
thus one starts with a correlator of two hadronic currents @xmath19 here @xmath20 is the left - handed current , @xmath21 the four velocity of the decaying b meson and @xmath22 the momentum transfer to the leptons .
it is convenient to decompose this correlator into lorentz scalar structure functions according to @xmath23 where the scalar @xmath24 are only functions of @xmath25 and @xmath26 . using the optical theorem
we obtain for the relevant imaginary parts a similar decomposition : @xmath27 and the hadronic tensor , needed for the transition amplitude , can be computed from @xmath28 by @xmath29 the differential decay rate is then obtained by contracting the hadronic tensor with the leptonic tensor @xmath30 , and one obtains @xmath31 where @xmath32 denotes the corresponding phase space element . using the charged lepton energy @xmath33 , the leptonic invariant mass @xmath34 and the rescaled total lepton energy @xmath35 as independent variables one obtains the triple differential decay rate in terms of the scalar functions @xmath36 @xmath37 decays . ]
the tree - level expansion in @xmath0 is most easily set up by studying the feynman diagram shown in fig .
the double line denotes the propagator of a charm quark which is propagating in the background field of the soft gluons of the @xmath4 meson .
after rescaling the @xmath38 quark momentum according to @xmath39 we write for the background field propagator @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 denotes the covariant derivative with respect to the background gluon field
. the tree level ope for semi - leptonic processes is obtained by multiplying ( [ bgfprop ] ) by the appropriate dirac matrices for the left handed current ( [ sm_current ] ) . a calculation to order
@xmath15 requires to expand this expression to @xmath43 order in the covariant derivative @xmath44 according to @xmath45 we note that this keeps track of the ordering of the covariant derivatives .
the remaining task is to evaluate the forward matrix elements of operators of the from @xmath46 where @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) carries the spinor indices @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) .
the field @xmath48 is still the full qcd field , but redefined by a phase factor to remove the large piece of the @xmath38-quark momentum according to ( [ bquarkmom ] ) .
this field satisfies the useful relations @xmath51 which follow from the equation of motion for the @xmath38 quark field . here
@xmath52 are the projectors on the `` large '' and `` small '' components of a dirac spinor .
note that this way of expanding will yield only matrix elements of local operators ; however , these matrix elements contain still a nontrivial mass dependence , which will be discussed in the following .
the evaluation of these matrix elements is performed most conveniently in a recursive fashion .
the starting point is always the matrix element of highest dimension , i.e. the one with the maximal number of covariant derivatives . for these matrix elements one may neglect all contributions of order @xmath0 relative to this matrix element ;
in other words , this matrix element may be treated in the static limit .
thus the first step is to consider the static limit of the forward matrix element of the highest dimensional operator , which has the form @xcite @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the generalization of the pauli matrices to the case @xmath55 and @xmath56 is the static limit of the @xmath4 meson state @xmath57 .
the tensor structures @xmath58 and @xmath4 have to be related to a minimal set of fundamental matrix elements which are defined by contracting the indices in the various possible ways . in the following ,
these matrix elements are called _ basic parameters _ for a certain order in @xmath0 .
for example , at order @xmath1 these basic parameters are the darwin term @xmath59 and the spin - orbit term @xmath60 defined by @xmath61 while at order @xmath10 the basic parameters are the kinetic energy parameter @xmath62 and the chomomagnetic moment @xmath63 given by @xmath64 the hat above the quantitites means that we have defined these parameters in a covariant way .
the definitions which have been recently used refer to the spatial components of the derivatives only and differ from the ones used here by higher - order terms in the @xmath65 expansion .
the usual definitions of these quantities are given by @xmath66 where the spatial components are @xmath67 at @xmath2 the correction terms in the relations between the covariant and the usual definition do matter and are given in the next section .
once the tensors @xmath58 and @xmath4 for the matrix elements of the highest order in the @xmath0 expansion have been expressed in terms of these fundamental parameters , one proceeds in a similar way with the matrix elements of dimension @xmath68 .
however , now we have to take into account all possible dirac structures , such that @xmath69 where @xmath70 are the complete set of the sixteen dirac matrices . by using the fact that the relations ( [ use1]-[use5 ] ) connect different orders of the @xmath0 expansion we may express the tensor coefficients @xmath71 in terms of the basic parameters of the order @xmath72 and the ones of the order @xmath15 .
this prescription defines a way to recursively compute the relevant matrix elements of the @xmath0 expansion up to order @xmath15 at tree level , starting from the operator of highest dimension .
thus the leading matrix element of dimension three will then be expressed by this recursive method as a series in @xmath15 involving all the basic parameters up to this order .
finally , the hadronic tensor is obtained from the trace formula @xmath73 where the tree level expansion of the background - field propagator ( [ bgfexpansion ] ) automatically yields the correct ordering of the covariant derivatives .
note that this saves us from computing the one- and even more - gluon matrix elements which would be necessary to obtain the correct ordering of covariant derivatives in the standard computation . in the follwing
we explicitely perform this recursion to order @xmath2 , and we first identify the basic parameters for the order @xmath2 .
at @xmath2 we have to deal with operators of dimension 7 , containing four covariant derivatives .
we find in total five basic parameters at order @xmath2 , three of which are spin independent , while two are spin dependent .
written in a covariant form we define the basic parameters of order @xmath2 to be @xmath74 which are real , since they are forward matrix elements of hermitean operators . in order to obtain some intuition concerning the physical meaning of these parameters , we may relate them to some more intuitive quantities , which are @xmath75 the basic parameters defined in ( [ p1]-[p5 ] ) can be related to the intuitive quantities by and the intuitive quantities are not entirely unique .
for example , @xmath76 could also be defined by the completely symmetrized combination of the covariant derivatives ] @xmath77 which also gives some information on the sign of the non - perturbative parameters .
these parameters have to be determined independently from the lower - order parameters ; however , for a numerical estimate it is useful to note that some of these parameters can be estimated in naive factorization , such as @xmath78 while the two remaining matrix elements do not have a simple interpretation in naive factorization .
based on the interpretation of the parameters @xmath79 in terms of physical quantities we define a `` guestimate '' for the basic parameters @xmath79 by @xmath80 where at least the sign of the contributions should be correctly reproduced . in this way
all the basic matrix elements up to order @xmath2 have been identified and the remaining task is to express any matrix element in terms of these basic quantities according to ( [ general ] ) . in appendix [ me ] we list all the necessary general matrix elements up to dimension seven in terms of the basic parameters @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath81 , @xmath60 and @xmath82 .
finally , we may now consider the relation between the covariant definition of the basic parameters and the usual ones shown in ( [ mupiu]-[rholsu ] ) .
this relation is given by @xmath83 \\
\hat\mu_g^2 & = \mu_g^2 - \frac{1}{m_b } [ \rho_d^3 + \rho_{\rm ls}^3 ] - \frac{1}{4 m_b^2 } [ s_2 + s_3 + 4 s_5 ] \\
\hat\rho_d^3 & = \rho_d^3 \vphantom{\frac{s_1}{m_b } } \\ \hat\rho_{\rm ls}^3 & = \rho_{\rm ls}^3 - \frac{s_1}{m_b } \end{aligned}\ ] ]
the remaining task is to evaluate the scalar components of the hadronic tensor at tree level using ( [ trace ] ) and the formulae from the appendix .
we first compute the correlator ( [ tprod ] ) involving the time - ordered product . from the scalar components shown in ( [ stprod ] ) we need only @xmath84 ,
@xmath85 and @xmath86 due to current conservation of the leptonic current .
the resulting expressions up to order @xmath2 are tedious and are given in appendix [ ti ] taking the imaginary part to obtain the components of @xmath87 according to ( [ ot ] ) we use the relation @xmath88 from which we can obtain the triple differential rate up to @xmath2 at tree level using ( [ tdr ] ) .
the resulting expressions of the double differential rate , the single differential rate and the total rate are quite lengthy and given completely in appendix [ rates ] .
the relevant quantities for the experimental analysis and the determination of @xmath3 are the moments of the lepton energy spectrum and the moments of the hadronic invariant mass spectrum . in order to get a quantitative idea of the effect of the @xmath2 terms we consider the @xmath2 to the moments , normalized to the partonic rate at tree level .
thus we define @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the contribution of order @xmath2 .
we first study the dependence of the @xmath91 contributions to the moments on the different non - perturbative parameters @xmath79 .
we write the moments as @xmath92 .values of the coefficients @xmath93 with a weak dependence on @xmath94 .
the values quoted are for @xmath95 gev . [ cols=">,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] the contribution to the total rate is very small ; using our estimates for the parameters @xmath79 we get @xmath96 resulting in a completely negligible shift of the central value of @xmath3 from the terms of the order @xmath2 .
in this paper we presented the complete result for the @xmath91 contributions to the semileptonic rate at tree level .
although we have in total five new , non - perturbative parameters , we can use the known matrix elements to order @xmath97 to estimate the size of the contributions .
it turns out that the size of the @xmath2 terms is `` normal '' , i.e. we do not see any abnormally large coefficients in the @xmath0 expansion , at least in this tree level calculation .
the formulae collected in the appendix allow us to include now the @xmath91 contributions into the moment analyses of semi - leptonic decays .
in particular , the fourth central moment in @xmath98 is dominated by the @xmath2 terms , so these terms are required for a sensible analysis of higher - order moments .
the method suggested here allows in principle the calculation of arbitrarily high orders in the @xmath0 expansion at tree level .
however , the limitation is the number of basic parameters , which is presumably growing factorially , leading to a factorially growing effort to express the general matrix elements through the basic parameters . on the other hand , assuming that the @xmath99 terms also behave `` normally '' , the uncertainty from these contributions in the determination of @xmath3 will really be extremely small .
the uncertainty currently assigned to the use of the hqe for the detemination of @xmath3 is about 1% ; a conservative estimate is to use the size of the last term calculated as the uncertainty means that the uncertainty in the @xmath3 determination due to hqe may be reduced to @xmath100 .
this work was supported by the german research foundation dfg under + contracts no .
ma1187/10 - 1 and kh205/1 - 1 .
99 w. m. yao _ et al .
_ [ particle data group ] , j. phys .
g * 33 * ( 2006 ) 1 .
j. chay , h. georgi and b. grinstein , phys .
b * 247 * , 399 ( 1990 ) .
i. i. y. bigi , m. a. shifman , n. g. uraltsev and a. i. vainshtein , phys .
lett . * 71 * , 496 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9304225 ] .
a. v. manohar and m. b. wise , phys .
d * 49 * , 1310 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9308246 ] .
t. mannel , nucl . phys .
b * 413 * , 396 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9308262 ] .
d. benson , i. i. bigi , t. mannel and n. uraltsev , nucl .
b * 665 * , 367 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0302262 ] .
p. gambino and n. uraltsev , eur .
j. c * 34 * , 181 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0401063 ] . c. w. bauer , z. ligeti , m. luke and a. v. manohar , phys .
d * 67 * , 054012 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0210027 ] .
a. h. hoang , z. ligeti and a. v. manohar , phys .
d * 59 * , 074017 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9811239 ] .
o. buchmller and h. flcher , phys .
d * 73 * , 073008 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0507253 ] .
a. f. falk , m. e. luke and m. j. savage , phys .
d * 53 * , 2491 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9507284 ] .
a. f. falk and m. e. luke , phys .
d * 57 * , 424 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9708327 ] .
t. mannel , phys .
d * 50 * , 428 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9403249 ] .
in this appendix we list the general matrix elements up to dimension seven in terms of the parameters @xmath101 ( [ mupi ] ) , @xmath102 ( [ mug ] ) , @xmath103 ( [ rhod ] ) , @xmath104 ( [ rhols ] ) , and @xmath82 ( [ p1]-[p5 ] ) .
the results are written as dirac matrices which have to be inserted into the trace formula ( [ trace ] ) .
mathematica notebooks with the corresponding expressions can be obtained from the authors .
@xmath105 @xmath106 @xmath107 @xmath108 @xmath109 @xmath110
to compute the differential rate in the limit of vanishing lepton masses only the functions @xmath84 , @xmath85 and @xmath86 are needed . in the following subsections
we give the complete expressions for these scalar functions up to order @xmath111 .
we use the notations @xmath112 furthermore we use dimensionless variables according to @xmath113 mathematica notebooks with the corresponding expressions can be obtained from the authors . @xmath114 @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath117
finally we list in this appendix the full expressions for the differential and the total decay rate at tree level up to order @xmath2 .
mathematica notebooks with the corresponding expressions can be obtained from the authors .
[ [ double - differential - rate - textnormalfontd2-gammatextnormalfontdhate_0-textnormalfontdm_x2 ] ] double differential rate @xmath118 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ we use in this differental rate the dimensionless variable @xmath124 furthermore x is a short hand notation for @xmath125 .
@xmath126 means therefore the nth derivative of the delta function with respect to its argument x. to rewrite the argument and derivative of the delta function linear in y , we use @xmath127 where @xmath128 @xmath129 | we give a systematic way to compute higher orders in the @xmath0 expansion in inclusive semi - leptonic decays at tree level .
we reproduce the known @xmath1 terms and compute the @xmath2 terms at tree level .
the appearing non - perturbative parameters and the impact on the determination of @xmath3 are discussed .
si - hep-2006 - 15 + november 13 , 2006 * inclusive semi - leptonic @xmath4 decays + to order @xmath2 * benjamin m. dassinger , thomas mannel , sascha turczyk + theoretische physik 1 , fachbereich physik , universitt siegen + d-57068 siegen , germany |
many astrophysical quantities obey a distribution well described by power - laws .
important insights into the physical processes producing such distributions can be obtained from their power - law index .
in addition , the location at which the distribution departs from a power - law is also of great importance . in most cases ,
a change in the distribution laws is observed at their high end , in the form of either a steepening of the distribution , or an exponential cutoff .
for example , the peak frequency in the synchrotron emission of active galaxies is associated to the largest energy attainable by relativistic electrons and it carries essential constraints on the acceleration and cooling mechanisms .
equally important is the determination of the behavior of the distributions at the low end as it might reveal the presence of , e.g. , a minimum mass for the formation of a star or a galaxy .
unfortunately , the low end behavior is often unaccessible to observations or , in other cases , it is blurred by the emergence of strong selection biases . in this letter
we focus on the radio luminosity function ( rlf ) of two classes of active galaxies at low redshift , @xmath9 .
the first is formed by low radio power ( lrp ) agn : within the considered redshift limit , most of the radio emitting agn are indeed objects of low power , @xmath10 .
the second consists of bl lac objects . according to the unified model for agn
, these two rlfs are expected to be connected with each other , as lrp agn should represent the parent population of bl lac objects . in both cases
the rlfs are observationally well defined over a very broad range of radio power .
the rlf of lrp agn also presents a break at high luminosity .
conversely , at their low luminosity end , both rlfs are well described by a pure power law by current observations , without clear signs of a change in their slopes . in this letter
we show that it is nonetheless possible to constrain the power at which a low luminosity break in the rlf must occur . throughout the paper we adopt @xmath11 , @xmath12 , and @xmath13
the number density of agn can not exceed that of their potential hosts : this argument has been used by @xcite and @xcite to constrain the low luminosity behavior of their rlf .
they found that a break must occur at a radio luminosity @xmath14 and @xmath15 , respectively .
we use the same rationale , but including the information that their hosts , as shown in more detail below , are associated almost exclusively to very large black holes .
the rlf of nearby galaxies extending to the lowest luminosity has been obtained by @xcite .
it is derived from a sample of 7824 radio sources from the 1.4 ghz nvss survey cross - correlated with the second data release of the 6 degree field galaxy survey ( 6dfgs , @xcite ) .
@xcite separated radio sources associated to agn from star - forming galaxies relying on their optical spectra .
their resulting rlf covers the range @xmath16 and shows a steepening at high luminosities ( above @xmath17 ) .
@xcite obtained an independent estimate of the agn rlf .
this is slightly shallower ( reaching a luminosity @xmath18 ) but , since their sample is drawn from the sdss , they could take advantage of the optical data to better characterize their properties .
the main result is that their hosts are almost exclusively massive early - type galaxies with black hole masses ( derived from the stellar velocity dispersion adopting the @xcite law ) larger than @xmath19@xmath20@xmath21 ( see also @xcite ) .
the sdss survey provides us with a highly complete sample that can be used to estimate the number density of galaxies with large black holes . to this purpose
, we analyze the 818,333 galaxies ( mpa - jhu sample hereafter ) in the value - added spectroscopic catalog produced by the max planck institute for astrophysics , and the johns hopkins university , and available at http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/sdss/ @xcite .
we consider all galaxies from redshift @xmath22 to @xmath23 to ensure a high level of completeness ( see below ) within the largest possible volume , which results in 0.053 gpc@xmath24 .
we then select elliptical galaxies in the mpa - jhu sample by setting a threshold to the concentration index @xmath25 ( e.g. @xcite ) and to their stellar velocity dispersion adopting , conservatively , @xmath26 , corresponding to @xmath27 , finding @xmath2038,000 objects .
the resulting sample has a high level of completeness . according to @xcite the completeness of the sdss decreases with decreasing apparent magnitude , starting at @xmath20 95% at the sdss spectroscopic limit of @xmath28 , and being still higher than 80% at @xmath29 .
the vast majority of the lrp agn hosts have a magnitude in the range -23.5 @xmath30 -26.5 @xcite .
this translates into @xmath3116.3 at @xmath22 ( and @xmath3217.8 at @xmath33 ) having adopted @xmath34 @xcite .
this implies that most of such galaxies in the selected redshift range are included in the mpa - jhu catalog .
we now estimate how the total number of predicted lrp agn varies depending on the behavior of the rlf at low power . a low luminosity break must occur in order to avoid the divergence of the lrp agn number .
the @xcite results suggest that it is located below @xmath35 , where the limited number of observed objects makes the rlf shape uncertain .
we assume that the lrp agn number density follows , below a break luminosity @xmath5 , a power law with an index @xmath36 .
we investigate the effects of varying @xmath36 from 0 ( a flat number count distribution ) to infinity ( equivalent to a sharp cutoff below @xmath37 ) , see the left panel of fig .
we integrate numerically the rlf starting from @xmath38 , a factor of 100 below the observational limit : the total number of predicted lrp agn grows rapidly at decreasing @xmath5 ( fig . [ rge ] , right panel ) .
for @xmath39 it exceeds the total number of available hosts when @xmath40 , a value that is inconsistent with the @xcite results even assuming that _ all _ massive galaxies host a lrp agn . for larger @xmath36 ( and already for @xmath41 )
the tension with the observations is eased , as we obtain @xmath42@xmath43 . however
, this requires an occupation fraction @xmath44 of 100% , i.e. , all massive galaxies must harbor a radio - source with at least @xmath45 .
the bivariate rlfs , obtained by @xcite splitting the sample into bins of infrared luminosity ( their fig .
16 ) , indicate instead values in the range @xmath46 depending on the host magnitude .
this implies that the values of @xmath37 derived above should be considered as strict lower limits .
we conclude that : 1 ) the rlf of lrp agn must break to a shallower slope for radio luminosities smaller than @xmath47 , and 2 ) the number density below @xmath48 must significantly decrease , leading to a peak in its distribution .
in this section we consider the rlf of bl lacs at 1.4 ghz .
we adopt the same line of reasoning followed above . in this case
, the constraint on the rlf is derived imposing the requirement that the total number of bl lacs does not exceed the total number of appropriate ( see below ) radio sources in the same volume .
@xcite provides us with a sample of 18,286 agn obtained by combining the sdss dr7 mpa - jhu sample with the nvss and the first surveys , down to a flux density level of 5 mjy in the nvss .
we consider the same volume as in sect . 2 , i.e. , @xmath49 .
we select the sources with 1 ) a rest - frame equivalent width of all emission lines smaller than 5 ( the standard threshold for a bl lac classification , @xcite ) , and 2 ) a flux of the central radio component in the first images larger than 5 mjy . the latter requirement ( based on the measurement of @xcite ) is needed to isolate potential bl lac objects according to their radio core emission while excluding , e.g. , double lobed sources lacking of a core .
the threshold is set at the same radio flux limit that defines the selected sample and it is included self - consistently in the analysis that follows .
we are left with 524 potential bl lac objects .
we further check their radio morphology : indeed bl lacs are only associated with specific radio structures on the kpc scale , being dominated by a compact radio core and , in some cases , showing also a one - sided jet or a halo @xcite .
we found that 49% of the selected sources are instead well defined fanaroff - riley type i or ii ( fr i or fr ii ) radio galaxies with sizes larger than 1020 kpc .
the 267 remaining objects are not necessarily all bl lacs and certainly include intruders , for example , fr i with size smaller than @xmath2010 kpc that , due to the limited resolution of the first images , are not recognized as such . however , with only a handful of exceptions , the selected objects are all massive early - type galaxies , conforming with the standard lrp agn hosts . on the other hand , there is the possibility that bl lacs are so nuclearly dominated to be confused with stars in the sdss images ( and for this reason they might not be included in the mpa - jhu galaxies catalog ) .
however , this possibility can be discarded .
first of all , in the roma - bzcat catalog of bl lacs @xcite there are only 8 objects with 0.05@xmath50 0.1 and covered by the dr7 .
all of them have been selected as sdss spectroscopic targets .
furthermore , the brightest of these objects has a radio luminosity of @xmath51 w hz@xmath52 .
we estimated the corresponding non thermal contribution to the optical ( @xmath53 band ) magnitude for similarly bright objects by assuming , conservatively , a radio - to - optical spectral index of 0.5 , typical of high energy peaked bl lacs @xcite .
we obtain @xmath54 at @xmath22 ( and @xmath5519.0 at @xmath33 ) , @xmath564 magnitudes fainter than lrp agn hosts .
only much brighter bl lacs might be confused with stars .
however , very luminous sources have a low space density and indeed no such object , that would have been easily discovered , is known within the volume considered . we conclude that our estimate of 267 objects is a robust upper limit to the bl lacs number in our volume .
@xcite derived the rlf of bl lacs at 5 ghz based on the deep x - ray radio blazar survey .
they obtained a rlf consistent with a single power - law with a slope of 2.12 @xmath57 0.16 in the range @xmath58@xmath59 . by adopting this rlf
we estimate the predicted number of bl lacs in the selected volume when varying the luminosity , @xmath6 , at which the rlf breaks , see fig .
[ bllac ] . in our calculation
we assume a null radio spectral index , i.e. @xmath60 @xcite .
a steeper radio spectrum would slightly increase the derived limits on @xmath6 . ] to convert from 5 to 1.4 ghz and take into account that objects with radio flux density smaller than 5 mjy are not included in our sample ( this effect causes the flattening of @xmath61 for @xmath62 in fig .
[ bllac ] ) .
we conclude that the number of bl lacs predicted by extrapolating their rlf to low luminosities exceeds the total number of possible hosts for @xmath63@xmath64 , depending on the rlf slope below the break . on the other hand ,
the rlf data points of @xcite exclude @xmath65 .
we conclude that the rlf of bl lacs must break to a shallower slope for radio luminosities smaller than @xmath66@xmath67 . in the sdss / dr7 area as a function of the low luminosity break of their rlf , @xmath6 , and of the slope @xmath36 of the number density below the break .
the solid horizontal line represents the total number of radio galaxies ( weak lined and core dominated , see text for details ) in the same volume ; the dashed horizontal line corresponds to a bl lacs percentage of the selected radio - sources of 10%.,width=328 ]
the results presented indicate that the rlfs at 1.4 ghz of both lrp agn and bl lacs must decrease their slope at , or just above , the low luminosity limit at which they are currently determined .
this might appear as a contrived coincidence , while , conversely , it is the natural consequence of the behavior of the rlf at low power .
in fact , the number of objects below the break that can be detected in a flux limited survey depends on the radio power as @xmath68 , where @xmath36 is the number density slope for @xmath69 .
the strong dependence on @xmath70 implies that these objects are missing altogether in the currently available surveys ( or at most found in a small number ) and this prevents the rlf determination below @xmath71 . for lrp agn
we find that the number density below the break must significantly decrease producing a peak in the distribution .
it is tempting to associate the presence of this peak to a minimal level of emission that is invariably associated with a supermassive black hole located at the center of a massive galaxy , which unavoidably accretes gas from the interstellar medium .
the peak might instead correspond to a minimum level of accretion at which a radio jet can be produced .
a better definition of the rlf at low luminosity is essential in this context : in the first case , we expect to find that all potential hosts harbor a lrp agn , albeit of very low luminosity while , in the second alternative , the occupation fraction would never reach 100% .
note that @xcite found a similar dramatic fall of the number density from the analysis of a sample of 179 qsos ( @xmath72 - 23 ) from the sdss in the redshift range 0.2 @xmath73 0.3 , for radio luminosities below @xmath74 ( at 6 ghz ) .
unfortunately , we have only sparse information on the radio properties of massive galaxies below @xmath75 .
these can be obtained with deep targeted observations of nearby galaxies . in the virgo clusters
there are two ( out of 11 ) giant elliptical galaxies lacking of any sign of radio emission down to a limit of @xmath76 @xcite , despite their large mass ( @xmath77 ) and large black hole mass ( @xmath78@xmath79 ) .
the small number statistics prevent us to derive any firm conclusion based on these observations , but they apparently favor the interpretation that not all massive galaxies are able to produce a radio jet . the two rlfs considered in this letter are expected to be linked with each other . indeed , according to the agn unified scheme ,
bl lacs are the beamed version of low luminosity agn ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , i.e. , bl lacs are objects in which a highly relativistic jet is seen at an angle close to our line of sight .
this accounts for their extreme properties , such as strong flux variability and apparent superluminal motion of radio components .
the effects of relativistic beaming on the rlf was analyzed in a series of papers @xcite .
if the rlf of the parent population of unbeamed objects is described by a broken power law , the break will produce a change of slope in the bl lac rlf at @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is the maximum value of the jet doppler factor distribution is defined as @xmath82^{-1}$ ] , where @xmath83 is the bulk lorentz factor , @xmath84 is the velocity in units of the speed of light , and @xmath85 is the viewing angle .
the exact value of the @xmath86 exponent depends on the geometry of the emitting region . ] .
the ratio between @xmath5 and @xmath87 is a factor @xmath7 , which suggests a value of the doppler factor @xmath88 , remarkably consistent with the typical results obtained from the observations and the model predictions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this analysis implicitly assumes that all lrp agn produce relativistic jets , a requirement that is not necessarily met by the objects at the very faint end of the rlf .
the consistency between the estimates of the doppler factor we just obtained with the theoretical expectations appears to confirm the overall validity of this assumption .
how can we improve our knowledge of the rlf at low power ?
for lrp agn the lower limit to the break power , @xmath89 , is not far from what is currently accessible to radio observations of large sample of galaxies such as the nvss .
a factor of @xmath20 10 improvement in the flux threshold is already accessible to the jvla and it will be sufficient to measure directly the rlf of lrp agn below the break value we predicted . while waiting for such a survey it is possible to take advantage of the stacking technique ( e.g. @xcite ) to measure the median radio luminosity of the population of massive elliptical galaxies at sub - mjy levels . in case
the number density presents a peak in its distribution , as our results suggest , this median luminosity is predicted to be located close to the peak value . | we constrain the behavior of the radio luminosity function ( rlf ) of two classes of active galactic nuclei ( agn ) namely agn of low radio power ( lrp ) and bl lac objects .
the extrapolation of the observed steep rlfs to low power predicts a space density of such objects that exceeds that of the sources that can harbor them and this requires a break to a shallower slope . for lrp
agn we obtain @xmath0 at 1.4 ghz to limit their density to be smaller than that of elliptical galaxies with black hole masses @xmath1 . by combining this value with the limit derived by the observations
the break must occur at @xmath2 . for bl lacs
we find @xmath3 otherwise they would outnumber the density of weak - lined and compact radio sources , while the observations indicate @xmath4 . in the framework of the agn unified model
a low luminosity break in the rlf of lrp agn must correspond to a break in the rlf of bl lacs .
the ratio between @xmath5 and @xmath6 is @xmath7 , as expected for a jet doppler factor of @xmath8 .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : active galaxies : bl lacertae objects : general galaxies : jets |
complex @xmath0-invariant modified korteweg - de vries ( mkdv ) equations @xmath4 ( where @xmath5 are real constants ) arise in many physical applications , such as short wave pulses in optical fibers @xcite and deep water waves @xcite .
of particular mathematical and physical interest are the two integrable equations in this class , given by the hirota equation @xcite @xmath6 and the sasa - satsuma equation @xcite @xmath7 the integrability properties of these two equations consist of multi - soliton solutions , a lax pair , a bilinear formulation , a bi - hamiltonian structure , and an infinite hierarchy of symmetries and conservation laws .
both equations possess ordinary soliton solutions of the form @xmath8 which are solitary waves with speed @xmath9 and phase angle @xmath10 .
collisions of two or more solitary waves are described by multi - soliton solutions . in all collisions , the net effect on the solitary waves is to shift in their asymptotic positions , while their asymptotic phase angles stay unchanged in the case of the hirota equation but become shifted in the case of the sasa - satsuma equation .
the actual nonlinear interaction of these solitary waves during a collision exhibits interesting features which depend on the speed ratios and relative phase angles of the waves , as studied in previous work @xcite .
( see the animations at http://lie.math.brocku.ca/~sanco/solitons/mkdv_solitons.php ) in a recent paper @xcite , we began a comprehensive study of a more general type of soliton solution with the form @xmath11 which is a harmonically modulated solitary wave , called an _ oscillatory soliton _
, where the temporal modulation frequency @xmath12 and the speed @xmath13 obey the kinematic relation @xmath14 this relation is required for the oscillatory soliton to be a solution of the the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation .
in contrast to an ordinary soliton , the speed @xmath13 of an oscillatory soliton can be positive , negative , or zero .
consequently , these solitons have three different types of collisions : ( 1 ) _ right - overtake _ where a faster right - moving soliton overtakes a slower right - moving soliton or a stationary soliton ; ( 2 ) _ left - overtake _ where a faster left - moving soliton overtakes a slower left - moving soliton or a stationary soliton ; ( 3 ) _ head - on _ where a right - moving soliton collides with a left - moving soliton .
all of these collisions are described by oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions @xmath15 whose temporal frequencies @xmath16 , @xmath17 and speeds @xmath18 , @xmath19 satisfy the kinematic relations @xmath20 in the present paper we will study the asymptotic features of colliding oscillatory solitons for both the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation .
these collisions can be expected to exhibit highly interesting new features compared to collisions of ordinary solitons . in section [ solns ]
, we recall some details of the oscillatory @xmath1-soliton and @xmath2-soliton solutions derived in for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation . in section [ asymptotics ] ,
we carry out an asymptotic analysis using moving coordinates to show that the @xmath2-soliton solutions for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation reduce to a superposition of two @xmath1-soliton solutions with speeds @xmath18 , @xmath19 and temporal frequencies @xmath16 , @xmath17 in the asymptotic past and future .
this analysis rigorously establishes that these @xmath2-soliton solutions describe collisions between two oscillatory waves when both @xmath18 and @xmath19 are non - zero , or collisions of an oscillatory wave with a standing wave , when one of the speeds @xmath18 or @xmath19 is zero . in section [ com ] , for the @xmath1-soliton and @xmath2-soliton solutions
, we discuss the primary constants of motion arising from the conservation laws for momentum , energy , and galilean energy admitted by @xcite the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation .
in particular , from conservation of galilean energy , we show that the center of momentum for the @xmath2-soliton solutions moves at a constant speed throughout a collision .
our main results are obtained in section [ results ] . for overtake and head - on collisions described by the @xmath2-soliton solutions ,
we first show that the net effect of a collision is to shift the asymptotic positions and phases of the two waves while the speed and the temporal frequency of each wave remains unchanged .
explicit formulas for these asymptotic shifts are presented in terms of the speeds and temporal frequencies of the two waves in the collision .
next , from these formulas , we find that for overtake collisions the faster wave gets shifted forward relative to its direction of motion while the slower or stationary wave gets shifted in the backward direction .
in contrast , for head - on collisions , we find that both waves get shifted forward relative to their directions of motion . finally , for all collisions
, we show that the position shifts of the two oscillatory waves are related by the property that the center of momentum of the waves is preserved in the collision . in section
[ interactions ] , we discuss a few interesting features of the nonlinear interactions that occur for oscillatory waves and standing waves during collisions , such as the appearance of nodes , phase coils , and phase reversals .
we also make some concluding remarks . previous work on soliton solutions of the hirota equation and sasa - satsuma equation appears in .
this work amounts to deriving the @xmath1-soliton and @xmath2-soliton formulas in a mathematically equivalent but less physically useful envelope form , without any analysis of the asymptotic behaviour and the constants of motion for these solutions .
all computations in the present paper have been carried out by use of maple .
hereafter , by scaling variables @xmath21 , we will put [ scaling ] = 6 , = 24 , = 1 for convenience .
for the hirota equation @xmath22 and the sasa - satsuma equation @xmath23 we will first summarize the expressions for the respective travelling - wave functions @xmath24 in the oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solutions .
let @xmath25 where @xmath13 and @xmath26 obey the relation , which corresponds to the properties @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
[ thm:1soliton ] the hirota and sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solutions @xmath29 expressed using a travelling wave coordinate are given by @xmath30 in terms of the respective envelope functions @xmath31 with @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
when @xmath34 , these @xmath1-soliton solutions are harmonically modulated standing waves .
we next summarize the expressions for the travelling - wave functions @xmath35 and @xmath36 in oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation .
let @xmath37 with @xmath38 where @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 obey the relations , corresponding to the properties @xmath41 [ thm:2soliton ] as expressed using travelling wave coordinates
@xmath42 and @xmath43 when @xmath44 , the hirota and sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions @xmath45 are given by @xmath46 in terms of the respective envelope functions @xmath47 in the hirota case , and @xmath48 in the sasa - satsuma case . in both cases , @xmath49 for convenience , we also write out the half - angle expressions needed in equations : @xmath50 and @xmath51 where @xmath52
an oscillatory wave having phase angle @xmath53 , temporal frequency @xmath54 , and speed @xmath13 reduces to an ordinary travelling wave when ( and only when ) @xmath55 . in this case
the kinematic relation implies @xmath9 , showing that all ordinary travelling wave solutions of the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation are right - moving .
in contrast , when @xmath26 , the kinematic relation states @xmath56 which allows @xmath57 and @xmath34 , in addition to allowing @xmath9 .
correspondingly , oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solutions from proposition [ thm:1soliton ] for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation consist of right - moving oscillatory waves when @xmath9 , left - moving oscillatory waves when @xmath57 , and standing waves when @xmath34 . we will now show that the oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions with @xmath44 from proposition [ thm:2soliton ] for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation reduce in both the asymptotic past ( @xmath58 ) and future ( @xmath59 ) to a linear superposition of oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solutions whose speeds are precisely @xmath18 and @xmath19 .
since the solutions are symmetric under simultaneously interchanging @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , we will assume @xmath63 hereafter without loss of generality .
to proceed , we first note @xmath64 are moving coordinates centered at positions @xmath65 and @xmath66 , respectively .
consider @xmath67 with @xmath68 whereby @xmath69 is the rightmost coordinate and @xmath70 is the leftmost coordinate .
asymptotic expansions for @xmath71 then correspond to asymptotic expansions given by @xmath72 . in each expansion
, we separately hold fixed the coordinates @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
we begin by holding the rightmost coordinate fixed , and expressing the leftmost coordinate in terms of the expansion parameter @xmath73 from equation , so thus @xmath74 as @xmath72 . in the hirota oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution from proposition [ thm:2soliton ] , applying the expansion to the functions , , and neglecting subdominant terms , we find @xmath75 ( with @xmath76 due to equation ) . up to the exponential factor @xmath77 , the asymptotic functions and resemble the form of the numerator and denominator in the oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solution and for the hirota equation .
specifically , the expansion can be expressed as @xmath78 where @xmath79 is a shifted moving coordinate .
then the expansion can be written in terms of this coordinate , which gives @xmath80 hence we have @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the function and @xmath83 is the function .
finally , the phase factor @xmath84 can be combined with @xmath85 to get a shifted phase angle @xmath86 in a similar way , the expansion gives @xmath87 whence @xmath88 combining equations and with equation , we see that the asymptotic expansion of the hirota oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution with respect to its leftmost coordinate is given by @xmath89 next , we hold the leftmost coordinate fixed , and express the rightmost coordinate in terms of the expansion parameter @xmath73 from equation , so now @xmath90 as @xmath72 . applying this expansion to the functions , ,
, we obtain @xmath91 ( with @xmath92 due to equation ) .
the expansions and can be expressed as @xmath93 and @xmath94 where @xmath95 is a shifted moving coordinate .
hence we have @xmath96 the phase factor @xmath97 can be combined with @xmath98 to get a shifted phase angle @xmath99 similarly , the expansion gives @xmath100 whence @xmath101 combining equations and with equation , we see that the asymptotic expansion of the hirota oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution with respect to its rightmost coordinate is given by @xmath102 for the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution from proposition [ thm:2soliton ] , we apply the asymptotic expansions and to the functions , , . first using the expansion and neglecting subdominant terms for @xmath103
, we find @xmath104 ( with @xmath76 due to equation ) .
the expansion can be expressed as @xmath105 where @xmath106 is a shifted moving coordinate . then writing the expansion in terms of this coordinate , and using the relations , we get @xmath107 these functions and resemble the denominator and numerator in the oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solution and for the sasa - satsuma equation .
specifically , we have @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the function and @xmath110 is the function .
finally , the phase factor @xmath111 can be combined with @xmath85 to get a shifted phase angle @xmath112 in a similar way , the expansion gives @xmath113 whence @xmath114 combining equations and with equation , we see that the asymptotic expansion of the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution with respect to its leftmost coordinate is given by @xmath115 next using the expansion and neglecting subdominant terms for @xmath103 , we find @xmath116 ( with @xmath92 due to equation ) .
we express the expansion as @xmath117 where @xmath118 is a shifted moving coordinate .
then we write the expansion in terms of this coordinate , and use the relations , giving @xmath119 hence we have @xmath120 the phase factor @xmath121 can be combined with @xmath98 to get a shifted phase angle @xmath122 similarly , the expansion gives @xmath123 whence @xmath124 combining equations and with equation , we see that the asymptotic expansion of the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution with respect to its rightmost coordinate is given by @xmath125 the precise correspondence between the moving coordinate expansion given by @xmath126 and an asymptotic expansion @xmath127 will now be explained . in particular , through equations and , we will determine how large @xmath128 must so that the expansions and derived for the hirota oscillatory @xmath2-soliton and the expansions and derived for the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton are approximately valid over some interval in @xmath129 at a finite time @xmath130 . from equations and equations , we see that the expansions and remain approximately valid if @xmath131 holds , with @xmath132 .
these two conditions can be expressed explicitly as conditions on @xmath133 after we use equations , , and to get @xmath134 .
then the condition @xmath131 gives @xmath135 while the other condition @xmath132 implies @xmath136 we now combine these two inequalities and , yielding @xmath137 which determines the minimum size of @xmath138 .
finally , from inequality , we have @xmath139 which determines the interval in which @xmath129 lies .
these are the conditions on @xmath133 under which the expansions and approximately hold , giving @xmath140 there are similar conditions for the expansions and to hold approximately from equations and equations , so thus @xmath141 we see that these equations remain approximately valid if @xmath142 holds , with @xmath143 . by using equations and
, we get @xmath144 .
the condition @xmath142 thereby gives @xmath145 while the other condition @xmath143 implies @xmath146 then , combining these two inequalities and , we obtain @xmath147 which determines the minimum size of @xmath138 . then from inequality , we have @xmath148 which determines the interval in which @xmath129 lies .
an important observation now is that the approximate expansions and will hold simultaneously if @xmath138 satisfies both conditions and .
since equations , , , show that @xmath149 and @xmath150 in all cases , a simple sufficient condition on @xmath138 is given by latexmath:[\[\label{tlargecond } another useful observation is that the previous analysis holds independently of the signs of @xmath18 and @xmath19 , including cases when one of @xmath18 or @xmath19 is zero .
hence , we have established the following results .
[ prop : h2solitonlarget ] for @xmath138 satisfying the condition , the hirota oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution , with parameters @xmath152 , @xmath153 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath154 has the form of an asymptotic superposition @xmath155 in which @xmath156 and @xmath157 are distinct oscillatory waves having respective speeds @xmath18 and @xmath19 , temporal frequencies @xmath16 and @xmath17 , phase angles @xmath158 and @xmath159 given by expressions and , and having positions that are determined by the respective moving coordinates and . [
prop : ss2solitonlarget ] for @xmath138 satisfying the condition , the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution , with parameters @xmath152 , @xmath153 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath154 has the form of an asymptotic superposition @xmath155 in which @xmath156 and @xmath157 are distinct oscillatory waves having respective speeds @xmath18 and @xmath19 , temporal frequencies @xmath16 and @xmath17 , phase angles @xmath158 and @xmath159 given by expressions and , and having positions that are determined by the respective moving coordinates and .
when these oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation have either @xmath160 or @xmath161 , then the respective asymptotic wave @xmath156 or @xmath157 as @xmath71 is a standing wave .
for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation , we recall that the conserved integrals defining momentum , energy , and galilean energy are given by @xcite ( up to arbitrary normalization factors ) @xmath162 which yield constants of motion for all smooth solutions @xmath163 with sufficiently rapid decay @xmath164 as @xmath165 . these integrals are related to the center of momentum defined by ( t)= _ -^+ x |u|^2 dx = ( 0 ) + t [ comom ] where = t -(t ) = ( 0)= -(0 ) .
[ comomrel ] this is the same relation that holds for the corresponding constants of motion of the mkdv equation @xcite .
the hirota equation admits an additional conserved integral given by the angular twist @xcite ( up to an arbitrary normalization factor ) @xmath166 holding for all smooth solutions @xmath163 with sufficiently rapid decay @xmath164 as @xmath165 .
this integral is not conserved for the sasa - satsuma equation .
it is straightforward to evaluate these constants of motion explicitly for the oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solutions from proposition [ thm:1soliton ] for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation . for notional convenience
we will denote @xmath167 [ thm : com1soliton ] the hirota oscillatory @xmath1-soliton , has angular twist , momentum , energy , and galilean energy given by @xmath168 the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath1-soliton , has momentum , energy , and galilean energy given by @xmath169 in both cases , the center of momentum is @xmath170 with @xmath171 .
we note that the center of momentum of these oscillatory @xmath1-solitons can be shifted arbitrarily by means of a space translation @xmath172 applied to the moving coordinate @xmath173 in equation , which leads to @xmath174 this changes the galilean energy @xmath175 while the momentum and energy are unchanged . from the previous expressions
, we can evaluate the momentum , energy , and galilean energy of the oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions from proposition [ thm:2soliton ] for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation .
in particular , we know from lemmas [ prop : h2solitonlarget ] and [ prop : ss2solitonlarget ] that each solution @xmath176 is asymptotically a superposition of two waves @xmath156 and @xmath157 as @xmath127 .
hence the conserved integrals , , are respectively given by a sum of the momenta @xmath177 , @xmath178 , the energies @xmath179 , @xmath180 , and the galilean energies @xmath181 , @xmath182 associated with each individual wave .
this yields the following result , using the notation .
[ thm : com2soliton ] the hirota oscillatory @xmath2-soliton , has angular twist , momentum , energy , and galilean energy given by @xmath183 where @xmath184 and @xmath185 are given by equations and .
the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton , has momentum , energy , and galilean energy given by @xmath186 where @xmath184 and @xmath185 are given by equations and . in both cases ,
@xmath187 is the center of momentum , which moves at constant speed @xmath188
as shown by lemmas [ prop : h2solitonlarget ] and [ prop : ss2solitonlarget ] , in the asymptotic past @xmath58 and future @xmath189 , the hirota and sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions given in proposition [ thm:2soliton ] reduce to a superposition @xmath190 of oscillatory @xmath1-solitons @xmath156 and @xmath157 having speeds @xmath18 , @xmath19 , temporal frequencies @xmath16 , @xmath17 , phase angles @xmath158 , @xmath159 , and having centers of momentum @xmath191 , @xmath192 , with @xmath44 . without loss of generality , we will assume @xmath154 hereafter , since @xmath193 is symmetric under simultaneously interchanging @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 .
we begin by examining some properties of the asymptotic oscillatory @xmath1-solitons @xmath194 where @xmath195 are shifted moving coordinates , and where both @xmath196 and @xmath197 are given by the envelope function in the hirota case and in the sasa - satsuma case .
first , the functions @xmath196 and @xmath197 are symmetric around @xmath198 and @xmath199 , coinciding with the positions of the centers of momentum @xmath200 for the two asymptotic oscillatory waves .
second , at these positions , the phase of both functions @xmath196 and @xmath197 vanishes , @xmath201 third , away from the positions , the amplitude of the two asymptotic oscillatory waves has exponential decay @xmath202 while their phase has linear behaviour @xmath203 where @xmath204 in the hirota case , and @xmath205 , @xmath206 in the sasa - satsuma case . for graphical and analytical purposes , it will be more useful to work with the envelope phase of the two waves .
we recall that the envelope phase of an oscillatory wave @xmath207 expressed in terms of a moving coordinate @xmath208 , with phase angle @xmath53 , temporal frequency @xmath54 , speed @xmath13 , and center of momentum @xmath209 , is defined by @xcite @xmath210 note @xmath211 is the total phase of @xmath193 , so thus @xmath212 represents the contribution to the phase of @xmath193 after the linear contributions @xmath213 from the harmonic modulation are removed , which corresponds to writing @xmath214 applied to the asymptotic oscillatory waves , this yields the envelope phases @xmath215 , @xmath216 .
the phase property shows that @xmath217 where @xmath218 , @xmath219 , in the hirota case , and @xmath220 , @xmath221 in the sasa - satsuma case .
away from the center of momentum positions , the envelope phases approach constant values @xmath222 as @xmath71 , the asymptotic positions of the two oscillatory waves lie on straight lines in the @xmath223-plane , with the lines @xmath224 and @xmath225 being each shifted relative to the lines @xmath226 and @xmath227 by a constant value @xmath228 likewise , the asymptotic phase angles of the two oscillatory waves are each shifted by a constant value @xmath229 hence the envelope phases also undergo shifts @xmath230 which are determined entirely by the asymptotic shifts and . from lemmas [
prop : h2solitonlarget ] and [ prop : ss2solitonlarget ] , we have the following expressions for the shifts and .
[ thm : hshift ] for @xmath127 in the hirota oscillatory @xmath2-soliton , , with @xmath154 , the asymptotic soliton with speed @xmath18 and temporal frequency @xmath16 undergoes a shift in position and envelope phase given by @xmath231 while the asymptotic soliton with speed @xmath19 and temporal frequency @xmath17 undergoes a shift in position and envelope phase given by @xmath232 where @xmath233 are given in terms of @xmath234 by equations .
[ thm : ssshift ] for @xmath127 in the sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton , , with @xmath154 , @xmath39 and @xmath235 , the asymptotic soliton with speed @xmath18 and temporal frequency @xmath16 undergoes a shift in position and envelope phase given by @xmath236 while the asymptotic soliton with speed @xmath19 and temporal frequency @xmath17 undergoes a shift in position and envelope phase given by @xmath237 where @xmath233 are given in terms of @xmath234 by equations . for both the hirota and sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-solitons , as @xmath71 the centers of momentum and
the phase angles of the two asymptotic oscillatory waves are given by @xmath238 and @xmath239 the hirota and sasa - satsuma oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions describe a collision between two asymptotic oscillatory waves with speeds @xmath154 ( or @xmath240 ) .
the collision is a right - overtake if @xmath241 ( or @xmath242 ) , a left - overtake if @xmath243 ( or @xmath244 ) , and a head - on if @xmath245 ( or @xmath246 ) .
as will be now illustrated , in all cases the net effect of the collision is only to shift the asymptotic position and asymptotic phase angle of each wave , where these shifts are given in theorems [ thm : hshift ] and [ thm : ssshift ] .
the positions shifts are seen graphically in the asymptotic amplitude of the @xmath2-soliton solution , since for large @xmath128 we have @xmath247 from lemmas [ prop : h2solitonlarget ] and [ prop : ss2solitonlarget ] , where @xmath248 and @xmath249 are the shifted moving coordinates which determine the positions of the two asymptotic oscillatory waves , and where @xmath196 and @xmath197 are the envelope functions for these waves , given in proposition [ thm:1soliton ] .
similarly , we have @xmath250 yielding the asymptotic phase of the @xmath2-soliton solution . to see the phase shifts graphically , it is useful to remove the asymptotic linear part of @xmath251 by defining an envelope phase for the @xmath2-soliton solution similarly to the definition for oscillatory waves @xcite .
consider , for a @xmath2-soliton solution , the factorization @xmath252 where @xmath253 , @xmath254 , @xmath255 are the envelope functions in proposition [ thm:2soliton ] , and where @xmath256 is an amplitude normalization factor . equating this form for @xmath193 to the oscillatory form
, we obtain the envelope phase @xmath257 with @xmath258 the envelope phase essentially represents the contribution to the phase of @xmath193 after the linear contributions from the harmonic modulation of the two asymptotic oscillatory waves are removed .
in particular , let @xmath259 denote normalized envelope functions satisfying the properties @xmath260 then we can write the envelope phase as @xmath261 with @xmath262 the properties combined with the asymptotic phase show that @xmath263 whereby the envelope phase of @xmath193 asymptotically matches the envelope phase of each asymptotic oscillatory wave . the amplitude and envelope phase of the oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions
are illustrated in for the hirota case , and in for the sasa - satsuma case .
.5 -soliton right - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton right - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton left - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath270 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton left - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath270 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton head - on ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath272 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton head - on ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath272 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton right - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton right - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton left - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath270 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton left - overtake ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath270 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton head - on ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath272 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton head - on ( in solid ) and oscillatory @xmath1-solitons ( in dots and dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath272 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] in a right - overtake collision with @xmath273 , the asymptotic solitons @xmath156 and @xmath157 are oscillatory waves that each move to the right , where @xmath156 is the faster wave and @xmath157 is the slower wave .
the effect of the collision on the asymptotic positions of these waves is to shift the fast wave forward ( / to the right , since @xmath274 ) and the slow wave backward ( / to the left , since @xmath275 ) .
similarly , in a left - overtake collision with @xmath276 , the asymptotic solitons @xmath156 and @xmath157 are oscillatory waves that each move to the left , where now @xmath156 is the slower wave and @xmath157 is the faster wave .
the collision affects the asymptotic positions of the two waves by shifting the fast wave forward ( / to the left , since @xmath275 ) and the slow wave backward ( / to the right , since @xmath274 ) .
in contrast , in a head - on collision with @xmath277 , the asymptotic soliton @xmath156 is a right - moving oscillatory wave while the other asymptotic soliton @xmath157 is a left - moving oscillatory wave .
the collision has the effect that the asymptotic positions of both waves are shifted forward relative to their directions of motion , since the right - moving wave undergoes a shift to the right ( due to @xmath274 ) and the left - moving wave undergoes a shift to the left ( due to @xmath275 ) . in all cases , the asymptotic positions shifts @xmath278 and
@xmath279 satisfy the algebraic relation @xmath280 which holds as a direct consequence of the oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solution having a center of momentum that moves at a constant speed , as shown by equation .
an oscillatory @xmath1-soliton with @xmath34 and @xmath26 is a time - periodic standing wave .
the standing wave solutions for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation are presented in oscillatory form in proposition [ thm:1soliton ] .
collisions of an oscillatory wave with a standing wave are described by the oscillatory @xmath2-soliton when @xmath160 , @xmath281 , @xmath282 , or when @xmath161 , @xmath283 , @xmath40 .
these collision solutions for the hirota and sasa - satsuma equations are special cases of the solutions presented in proposition [ thm:2soliton ] .
they have not previously appeared in the literature .
we remark that theorems [ thm : hshift ] and [ thm : ssshift ] hold for collisions of an oscillatory wave and a standing wave .
thus , in a right - overtake collision with @xmath284 , the effect of the collision on the asymptotic positions of the waves is to shift the right - moving asymptotic oscillatory wave @xmath156 in a forward direction ( / to the right , since @xmath274 ) while the asymptotic standing wave @xmath157 is displaced in the opposite direction ( / to the left , since @xmath275 ) .
similarly , in a left - overtake collision with @xmath285 , the collision affects the asymptotic positions of the two waves by shifting the left - moving asymptotic oscillatory wave @xmath157 in a forward direction ( / to the left , since @xmath275 ) while the asymptotic standing wave @xmath156 is displayed in the opposite direction ( / to the right , since @xmath274 ) . in both cases ,
the asymptotic positions and the asymptotic phase angles of the waves are given by equations .
the position and phase shifts are shown in for the hirota equation , and for the sasa - satsuma equation .
.5 -soliton collision ( in solid ) of a left - moving oscillatory wave ( in dot - dash ) and a standing wave ( in dots ) with @xmath160 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton collision ( in solid ) of a left - moving oscillatory wave ( in dot - dash ) and a standing wave ( in dots ) with @xmath160 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton collision ( in solid ) of a right - moving oscillatory soliton ( in dots ) and a standing wave ( in dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath161 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 -soliton collision ( in solid ) of a right - moving oscillatory soliton ( in dots ) and a standing wave ( in dot - dash ) with @xmath264 , @xmath161 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 , @xmath271 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 , @xmath161 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ] .5 , @xmath161 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269,title="fig : " ]
in previous work @xcite , collisions of ordinary solitary waves ( / with no temporal harmonic modulation ) have been studied for the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation .
a collision in this case consists of a right - moving faster solitary wave with speed @xmath18 and phase @xmath152 overtaking a right - moving slower solitary wave with speed @xmath19 and phase @xmath153 .
the corresponding ordinary @xmath2-soliton solutions exhibit several distinguishing properties .
first , at a particular time @xmath286 the amplitude displays invariance @xmath287 @xmath288 under spatial reflection around the center of momentum @xmath289 of the two solitary waves .
this time @xmath286 can be understood to represent the moment of greatest nonlinear interaction of the waves during the collision .
second , the amplitude is always non - zero , @xmath290 , throughout the collision . as a consequence of these two properties
, the interaction of the two waves can be characterized primarily by the convexity of @xmath291 at the center of momentum @xmath292 at time @xmath286 .
the case of negative convexity describes a collision such that the waves undergo a merge - split interaction in which @xmath291 has a single peak with an exponentially decreasing tail , while the case of positive convexity describes a collision such that the waves exhibit either a bounce - exchange interaction in which @xmath291 has a double peak with an exponentially decreasing tail , or an absorb - emit interaction in which @xmath291 has a pair of side peaks around a central peak and an exponentially decreasing tail , depending on the speed ratio and relative phase angle of the two waves , as explained in .
in contrast , collisions of oscillatory waves described by the @xmath2-soliton solutions from proposition [ thm:2soliton ] have very different features ( animations can be seen at http://lie.math.brocku.ca/~sanco/solitons/oscillatory.php ) : ( 1 ) the amplitude @xmath293 exhibits invariance under spatial reflections only in special cases ; ( 2 ) the amplitude @xmath293 vanishes at certain positions @xmath129 and times @xmath138 ( / @xmath193 has nodes ) ; ( 3 ) the phase @xmath251 exhibits rapid spatial change at certain positions @xmath129 and times @xmath138 ( / @xmath193 has phase coils with large spatial winding ) ; ( 4 ) the phase gradient @xmath294 changes sign at certain positions @xmath129 and times @xmath138 ( / @xmath193 has spatial reversals of phase winding ) .
a detailed study of the interactions of oscillatory waves for these equations will be presented in a sequel paper .
our work in the present paper has two immediate extensions .
first , the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation are known to be gauge - equivalent to third - order nls equations @xcite @xmath295 through the galilean - phase transformation t = t , x = x+vt , u(t , x ) = q(t , x)(i(x - ( 2v/3)t ) ) [ nlstransformation ] where @xmath296 is a speed parameter , with @xmath297 , @xmath298 in the hirota case and @xmath299 , @xmath300 in the sasa - satsuma case . under this transformation , the oscillatory @xmath1-solitons shown in proposition [ thm:1soliton ] for the hirota and sasa - satsuma equations
correspond to nls solitons of the same form @xmath301 parameterized by a speed @xmath302 , a temporal frequency @xmath303 , and a phase @xmath53 , where @xmath304 consequently , we obtain nls oscillatory @xmath2-solitons @xmath305 with @xmath306 where the functions @xmath307 and @xmath308 are given in proposition [ thm:2soliton ] for the oscillatory @xmath2-solitons of the hirota and sasa - satsuma equations . in addition , we obtain nls oscillatory breathers in the special case @xmath309 , discussed in .
the main results stated in theorems [ thm : hshift ] and [ thm : ssshift ] on the properties of collisions described by oscillatory @xmath2-solitons , carry over directly to the third - order nls equation .
in particular , the net effect of a collision is to shift the asymptotic positions and phases of the individual oscillatory waves while the speed and the temporal frequency of each wave remains unchanged , such that the center of momentum of the waves is preserved in the collision .
second , the hirota equation has two natural multi - component generalizations given by @xmath310-invariant integrable mkdv equations @xcite u_t + 12 ( |u|^2u_x + ( u_x)u ) + u_xxx=0 [ vecmkdv1 ] and u_t+24 ( |u|^2u_x + ( u_x)u -(u_xu ) ) + u_xxx=0 [ vecmkdv2 ] where @xmath311 is a @xmath312-component complex vector variable . for all @xmath313 ,
these two vector equations admit vector oscillatory wave solutions of the form u(t , x ) = ( it)f_h(x - ct ) with wave speed @xmath13 and temporal frequency @xmath54 , satisfying the kinematic relation , where @xmath314 is an arbitrary constant complex unit vector and @xmath315 is the complex envelope function for the oscillatory @xmath1-soliton solution of the scalar hirota equation . in forthcoming work , we plan to generalize the results in the present paper to study the vector oscillatory @xmath2-soliton solutions and vector oscillatory breather solutions of both equations and .
s. anco is supported by an nserc research grant .
the authors thank nestor tchegoum ngatat for assistance in an early stage of this work . | the hirota equation and the sasa - satsuma equation are @xmath0-invariant integrable generalizations of the modified korteweg - de vries equation .
these two generalizations admit oscillatory solitons , which describe harmonically modulated complex solitary waves parameterized by their speed , modulation frequency , and phase . depending on the modulation frequency
, the speeds of oscillatory waves ( @xmath1-solitons ) can be positive , negative , or zero , in contrast to the strictly positive speed of ordinary solitons . when the speed is zero ,
an oscillatory wave is a time - periodic standing wave .
oscillatory @xmath2-solitons with non - zero wave speeds are shown to describe overtake collisions of a fast wave and a slow wave moving in the same direction , or head - on collisions of two waves moving in opposite directions .
when one wave speed is zero , oscillatory @xmath2-solitons are shown to describe collisions in which a moving wave overtakes a standing wave . an asymptotic analysis using moving coordinates
is carried out to show that , in all collisions , the speeds and modulation frequencies of the individual waves are preserved , while the phases and positions undergo a shift such that the center of momentum of the two waves moves at a constant speed .
the primary constants of motion as well as some other features of the nonlinear interaction of the colliding waves are discussed .
= 10000 # 1eq .
( [ # 1 ] ) # 1#2eqs . ( [ # 1 ] ) and ( [ # 2 ] ) # 1#2eqs . ( [ # 1 ] ) to ( [ # 2 ] ) # 1#2eqs . (
[ # 1])([#2 ] ) # 1fig .
[ # 1 ] # 1sec . [ # 1 ] # 1#2sec . [ # 1 ] and [ # 2 ] # 1appendix [ # 1 ] # 1ref .
# 1refs .
# 1@xmath3 # 1 /i.e .
/e.g .
/etc . |
large cluster surveys like the spt , act , planck and erosita promise to detect from a thousand to a few hundred thousand clusters in the coming decade .
the abundance and redshift distribution @xmath3 of these clusters are important probes to understand the nature of dark energy as well as to constrain other cosmological parameters like @xmath1 and @xmath2 @xcite . to deduce a cosmology from these @xmath3 observations ,
one requires a precise knowledge of the limiting mass of the survey as a function of redshift .
one frequently uses proxy observables such as x - ray surface brightness and temperature @xcite , sunyaev zeldovich effect ( sze ) decrement @xcite , cluster richness @xcite and lensing @xcite for the masses of clusters , related through simple power - law scaling relations .
these scaling parameters are highly degenerate with the cosmological parameters , and breaking this degeneracy is crucial to obtain tight constraints on cosmology .
this may realized , for example , through the so called ` self - calibration ' techniques @xcite .
other approaches include an ` unbiased ' mass follow - up of a sub - sample of the survey clusters @xcite or better theoretical modeling of clusters to predict the form of mass - observable scaling relation @xcite .
one can also try to optimize the cluster surveys so as to get the best possible survey yield @xcite .
measurement of the angular diameter distance , @xmath4 , at the redshift of the cluster using a combination of sze and x - ray observations have been routinely made over the last 30 years .
the results have suffered , in the past , from various systematics and reliable estimates have only been achieved recently with analysis of statistically significant samples of galaxy clusters @xcite .
these new observations have demonstrated the power of using clusters to measure ` @xmath4 vs @xmath5 ' and use it to study the expansion history of our universe @xcite .
however , these recent progress has been done with targeted observations . since
, targeted observations are costly , this approach limits the size of the sample of @xmath6 . in this _
, we show that one can build up an ` ensemble ' of by picking a sub - sample of clusters discovered in both x - ray and sze surveys with overlapping area and redshift coverage . since
, the surveys are already geared towards getting clusters for @xmath3 , we get the without any _ extra _ targeted observations .
addition of to helps in tightening cosmological constraints , especially on dark energy equation of state .
this is not surprising , since using from clusters is akin to adding @xmath0 information from supernovae ( sne ) observations .
the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in 2 ,
we briefly discuss cluster number counts and the procedure to estimate from sze + x - ray observations ; in
3 we describe the surveys , the choice of cosmological and cluster models and also summarize our methodology ; in 4 , we forecast constraints on cosmological parameters ; and finally , we conclude in 5 .
[ fig : mocking ] the redshift distribution of detectable clusters is given by , @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the co - moving volume element , @xmath9 is the cluster selection function incorporating a logarithmic scatter in the luminosity to mass conversion and @xmath10 is the halo mass function taken from simulations @xcite . for a x - ray / sze survey
the limiting mass @xmath11 is found from flux limit , @xmath12 , of the survey . for x - ray survey
, we adopt luminosity - mass relations from @xcite given by @xmath13 . for an sze survey , our sze flux - mass relation is @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the integrated sze distortion and is in mpc .
the parameters @xmath16 mimics any ` non - standard ' evolution of cluster scaling relations @xcite . for the x - ray survey ,
our fiducial parameter values are : @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 with a log - normal scatter of 0.246 ; while the corresponding values for the sze scaling relation are : @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 with a log - normal scatter of 0.2 .
the distance @xmath23 , of a cluster observed at a redshift @xmath5 depends on the expansion history of the universe as , @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the hubble expansion .
the seminal paper by @xcite defines the procedure to measure from observations of clusters in sze + x - ray .
this depends on ` assuming ' a profile for the intra - cluster medium , icm , typically taken to be an isothermal @xmath26-profile - profile , this leads to bias and scatter .
the impact is less for ensemble of clusters .
moreover , the uncertainty can be calibrated to first order using cluster simulations . ] with @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the electron number density , @xmath29 is the radius from the cluster s center , @xmath30 is the core radius , and @xmath26 is a power - law index .
note , that one can always use a more realistic icm model with better data .
for example , one can fit a temperature profile to improve upon the errors .
the x - ray brightness , @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is the x - ray cooling function of the gas ; while for sze , @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the icm temperature .
eliminating @xmath28 , gives the angular diameter distance @xmath35 ; see @xcite for more details .
we adopt our fiducial cosmology from the wmap 7-year results ( table 6 of @xcite ) along with the following priors @xmath36 . for simplicity , we choose a flat universe since for an open wcdm model , wmap7+bao+h0 tightly constraints @xmath37 . with a small number of clusters , as suggested by recent sz observations @xcite , just data would not be sufficient to break the cosmology - cluster physics degeneracies .
we therefore put priors on the scaling parameters @xmath38 and @xmath39 motivated by recent observations @xcite .
in addition , we put a weak prior of @xmath40 in all the cases .
we consider the following surveys with overlapping sky coverage - + ( 1 ) act / spt : we model the ongoing act / spt survey as a @xmath41 deg@xmath42 with a @xmath12 of 75 mjy ( at 150 ghz ) , so as to give @xmath43 1000 clusters .
+ ( 2 ) planck : ongoing all sky sze survey .
we take @xmath12 to be 300 mjy ( at 353 ghz ) which returns @xmath43 2000 clusters in @xmath44 deg@xmath42 .
the higher flux limit means that planck would detect only massive low @xmath5 clusters .
+ ( 3 ) erosita : upcoming full sky x - ray survey .
we assume a [ 0.5 - 2.0 kev ] band @xmath45 erg @xmath46 s@xmath47 which gives us @xmath48 clusters for @xmath44 deg@xmath42 .
all clusters detected by both planck as well as act / spt are expected to be detected by erosita as it has a much smaller @xmath49 ( see fig .
[ fig : m_lim ] ) .
the redshift distribution of clusters is obtained by using the cluster scaling relations to convert flux to the corresponding lowest observable cluster mass @xmath11 .
figure [ fig : m_lim ] shows the @xmath49 for some of the surveys that we have considered .
we further place a lower cut - off of @xmath50 on @xmath49 and a redshift cut - off of 0.1 .
the @xmath3 ( @xmath51 = 0.1 ) likelihoods are computed using cash c statistics .
we generate the mock @xmath4 catalog as follows . for a cluster to be visible in both x - ray and sze surveys ,
its mass must lie above the highest of the @xmath11 from either of the surveys . to estimate @xmath4 ,
one also needs _ at least _ a single isothermal temperature measurement of the icm , which is possible for 10 times the detectable flux ; for this we calculate the corresponding higher @xmath52 .
next , to fit a @xmath26-model , we also require that the clusters be well resolved ; i.e. be larger than a certain minimum angular size , so as to estimate its core radius @xmath53 .
this is fulfilled by the condition that @xmath53 be _ at least @xmath54 times _ the minimum resolution of the survey ( 16 for erosita ) .
we convert this to isophotal size @xmath55 and use the scaling relation between cluster mass and its size @xcite to enforce this constraint .
[ fig : m_lim ] shows all the limiting masses described above as a function of redshift .
the redshift @xmath4 catalog is constructed from [ [ eqn : dndz ] ] by integrating over the highest of these @xmath56 s in the plot .
the from these clusters are distributed randomly with a gaussian scatter of 25% about the from fiducial cosmology ( see fig . [
fig : mock ] ) .
such catalogs are created for overlaps of sze and x - ray surveys like act / spt + erosita and planck + erosita for @xmath54 s of 2 , 3 and 4 .
a higher value of @xmath54 implies a selection of only the larger clusters ; see fig .
[ fig : m_lim ] .
the @xmath57 catalog is analyzed using a chi - square statistic for the likelihoods .
finally , we do a joint analysis of the likelihoods from and those from number counts . to forecast the constraints from cluster surveys we use mcmc simulations in the parameter space of 6 cosmological parameters
@xmath1 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 and @xmath62 and 3 scaling parameters
@xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 . to [ tab : results_spt ] regions in the order of overlap ( decreasing area ) are , number counts with mass follow - up(no priors on @xmath63 and @xmath64 ) with @xmath66 ( red ) and @xmath67 ( dark - blue ) ; only number counts ( light - green ) ; with ( @xmath68 , 578 clusters ) ( dark - green ) ; with cmb priors on @xmath1 and @xmath2 ( orange ) ; with 557 sne from scp union 2 dataset ( light - blue).,width=340 ]
our main results are summarized in tables [ tab : results_spt ] and [ tab : results_planck ] , which list the 1-@xmath69 uncertainties on the cosmological parameters .
the numbers in bold highlight the improvement in the dark energy constraints on adding to .
the benefits of having additional information from is also illustrated in figures [ fig : spt ] and [ fig : planck ] . in all cases ,
we consider erosita as the x - ray survey and either planck or act / spt as the sze survey . to [ tab : results_planck ] in figure [ fig : spt ] , we see a significant improvement in cosmological constraints from act / spt , when @xmath4 for @xmath68 is added to . as seen in table [ tab : results_spt ] the 1-@xmath69 region in the dark energy plane @xmath58-@xmath59 shrinks by factors of 3.8 , 1.7 and 1.6 when the datasets with @xmath54 = 2 , 3 and 4 are added to ; while in the @xmath1 - @xmath58 plane it decreases by factors of 4.1 , 1.8 and 1.1 .
the corresponding marginalized constraints on a single equation of state @xmath70 improves from 0.20 to 0.15 and 0.18 for @xmath54 = 2 and 3 respectively when is added to .
there is not much improvement with the smallest dataset of @xmath54 = 4 , since the sample has only 25 clusters now . since sne
ia are also used to measure distances ( @xmath0 ) , we compare our results with the benefits of adding the union 2 compilation of the supernova cosmology project ( scp ) dataset in column 6 .
as expected , with the sne data of a similar size but with much smaller errors ( 7 - 10% ) , we get tighter constraints on dark energy with @xmath71 = 0.15 and @xmath72 = 1.0 .
column 7 of the same table lists the effect of using cmb constraints from the wmap7 results on @xmath1(=0.019 ) and @xmath2(=0.059 ) with the data from act / spt to further improve the constraints on dark energy with @xmath71 = 0.4 and @xmath72 = 2.0 .
these constraints are very similar to the ones through for @xmath54 = 2 ; compare column 3 and 7 in table [ tab : results_spt ] .
next , we compare our constraints with those that would be obtained from dedicated follow - up observations of cluster masses requiring detailed x - ray , sze or galaxy spectroscopic observations @xcite . adding a mass follow - up to @xmath3 constraints the cluster scaling relation and is similar to putting priors on the scaling parameters .
we build two mock catalogs of 97 clusters each , one with errors between 15 - 50% and the other with 30 - 100% errors .
we find that the constrains from both the mass follow - up s ( now without priors on the scaling parameters @xmath63 and @xmath64 ) are very similar to those obtained using priors of the scaling relations , compare column 2 with 8 and 9 in table [ tab : results_spt ] .
this also implies that addition of can further improve constraints even when a mass follow - up is done .
compare columns 3 - 5 with 8 and 9 .
the erosita survey will detect all the clusters seen by planck and hence together , these surveys will yield a large number of candidates for estimating @xmath23 . in our mock catalog
the number of cluster datasets for which @xmath4 can be measured , for this combination , are found to contain 1829 , 951 and 202 halos for @xmath54 = 2 , 3 and 4 , respectively .
however , in contrast with act / spt , planck would be able to detect only the most massive clusters due to a lower resolution and mostly the ones occurring at lower redshifts
. there would be a only very few clusters at higher redshifts ( @xmath73 ) and hence we consider the constraints only on a constant equation of state @xmath70 .
table [ tab : results_planck ] lists the results for the improvement in the constraints from when from an overlap of planck and erosita are added .
we see here that @xmath74 decreases by factors of 1.7 , 1.3 and 1.1 with the addition of datasets with @xmath54 = 2 , 3 and 4 respectively .
regions in the order of overlap ( decreasing area ) as follows : just ( yellow ) ; with for @xmath54 = 4 ( light - green ) , 3 ( indigo ) and 2 ( magenta ) respectively.,width=340 ]
we show that just using number count observations from the ongoing sze galaxy cluster surveys like act / spt would not be sufficient to put tight constraints on the cosmological parameters , especially the dark energy parameters . however these constraints can be significantly improved by doing a joint analysis with .
these @xmath23 can be constructed out of clusters detected jointly in x - ray and sze observations having overlapping areas .
the optical follow - up providing the redshifts for will , also , naturally provide the redshifts for . with the current and upcoming large area surveys one will be able to get thousands of clusters providing us with us with @xmath4 at various redshifts without much effort .
we find that adding to number count observations always improves the dark energy constraints , from alone by _ factors of 1.5 to 4_. this leads to better constraints not only on dark energy but also on the parameter @xmath1 .
even when a targeted mass follow - up of clusters helps in breaking the cluster - cosmology degeneracies , addition of helps in further tightening of the cosmological constraints .
moreover addition of improves dark energy constraints comparable to the improvement brought by adding cmb priors on @xmath2 and @xmath1 .
thus , our proposal of adding the data to cluster number counts provides a natural way of improving the cosmological constraints using clusters alone . | ongoing and upcoming surveys in x - rays and sze are expected to jointly detect many clusters due to the large overlap in sky coverage .
we show that , these clusters can be used as an ensemble of rulers to estimate the angular diameter distance , .
this comes at no extra observational cost , as these clusters form a subset of a much larger sample , assembled to build cluster number counts . on using this ,
the dark energy constraints can be improved by factors of 1.5 - 4 , over those from just . even in the presence of a mass follow - up of 100 clusters ( done for mass calibration ) ,
the dark energy constraints can be further tightened by factors of 2 - 3 .
adding from clusters is similar to adding @xmath0 , from the sne observations ; for eg . ,
( from act / spt ) plus is comparable to plus @xmath0 in constraining @xmath1 and @xmath2 . |
it is almost universally accepted that most of the matter in the universe is non - baryonic .
this dark matter is the chief constituent of gravitationally bound objects from dwarf galaxy scales and larger .
identifying the nature of dark matter is one of the most important problems in astrophysics , cosmology , and particle physics .
perhaps the best motivated candidate for cold dark matter is the lightest of the so called neutralinos arising in supersymmetric extensions to the standard model @xcite .
these are the spin-1/2 majorana fermion counterparts of the neutral gauge and higgs bosons , and are expected to have masses at the weak scale ( of order 100 gev ) .
this scale is intriguing as the relic density of a stable particle with this mass and corresponding cross section turns out to be of order the critical density , as we observe the matter density to be today .
any stable particles with weak scale masses could thus naturally account for the dark matter . in this paper
, we will focus on supersymmetry , but our conclusions are fairly generic to dark matter candidates at the tev scale .
we outline a new signature of annihilating dark matter in satellites of the milky way galaxy .
prospects for detecting high energy photons as dark matter annihilation products , primarily from the @xmath0 decays that are generic to hadronization processes , have been discussed for many years ( for a sample see ref .
@xcite ) . necessarily coming with these photons are high energy electrons and positrons from the analogous @xmath1 decay chains .
charged particles suffer complicated motions in the galactic magnetic field , and furthermore they lose energy to synchrotron and inverse compton processes .
searching for the synchrotron emission from the galactic center @xcite and from galactic satellites @xcite has been discussed previously , though neglecting the diffusion of the charged particles .
we will show that the inverse compton emission , extended over a large area from the charged particle annihilation products may be observable for some models of particle dark matter and of galactic satellites .
in the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) the lightest of the superpartners ( lsp ) is often the lightest neutralino .
the latter is a superposition of the superpartners of the neutral gauge and higgs bosons , @xmath2 with r - parity conserved , this lightest superpartner is stable . for significant regions of the mssm parameter space ,
the relic density of the stable neutralino is of the order @xmath3 , thus constituting an important ( and perhaps exclusive ) part of the cold dark matter .
note that @xmath4 is the neutralino density in units of the critical density and @xmath5 is the present hubble constant in units of @xmath6 km s@xmath7 mpc@xmath7 .
current observations , included those of the wmap satellite and the sloan digital sky survey ( we take the wmap values ) , favor @xmath8 and a matter density @xmath9 , of which baryons contribute a small amount @xmath10 @xcite .
if we assume that neutralinos are the only constituent of matter ( neutrinos are a small contribution , @xmath11 ) , we can then infer @xmath12
. we will apply a generous 3@xmath13 constraint on the relic abundance from the wmap data as follows : @xmath14 . using the darksusy code @xcite ,
we have explored the supersymmetric parameter space in both a phenomenological mssm @xcite and in minimal supergravity ( using the isajet code @xcite ) .
each model is subjected to current accelerator constraints on masses of superpartners and higgs bosons @xcite and on the @xmath15 branching ratio @xcite .
crucial for studies of dark matter , the relic abundance of neutralinos @xmath16 is calculated based on refs .
@xcite .
the only detailed information about models we require for this study ( apart from the relic density constraint ) is the annihilation cross section at non - relativistic velocities @xmath17 ( accounting for the factor of two due to identical particles in the initial state ) and the spectrum of annihilation products , in particular the photons , electrons and positrons .
the photons are primarily from the @xmath0 decays associated with hadronic final states , whereas the leptons can be from the associated @xmath1 decays , or more directly from massive gauge boson decays . in fig .
[ fig : inputspec ] we illustrate two models in the generic mssm , one with a typical featureless spectrum of annihilation products , and the other clearly exhibiting the feature from @xmath18 decays .
the calculation of the diffuse emission from the annihilations proceeds in several steps .
first , the time dependent density of charged particles is determined according to a diffusion model .
the charged particles are trapped by the galactic magnetic field , which extends for several kpc from the stellar disk . here
we stress that we are concerned only with those galactic satellites that are currently ( or in the recent past ) within this `` diffusion zone '' . a time dependent treatment is necessary because a satellite moving with the typical galactic velocity of 300 km s@xmath7 crosses the diffusion zone in roughly one diffusion time : both timescales are of order tens of millions of years .
the second step in the calculation is to calculate the column density of particles along various lines of sight , as a function of particle energy .
lastly , the inverse compton and synchrotron spectra can be calculated from the particle spectrum under some assumptions about the galactic magnetic field and radiation fields .
the propagation of charged particles in the tangled galactic magnetic field can be modeled as diffusion .
electrons and positrons lose energy rapidly to synchrotron radiation , and also to inverse compton scattering on the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) and on starlight .
we will use the diffusion model of ref .
more sophisticated models are available , e.g. the semianalytic treatment of ref .
@xcite and the fully numerical galprop model @xcite , but our model is simple to implement , yielding quantitatively similar results , and affords an intuitive understanding .
we will make the assumption that the charged particle velocity distribution is locally isotropic , namely that the particles `` stick '' to the galactic magnetic field , and that the velocity distribution contains no record of the initial conditions .
this is important as we consider sources ( satellite halos ) that move a significant distance in a diffusion time .
if the velocity distribution was isotropic in the satellite frame ( as could be the case if the satellite had a significant magnetic field of its own ) , our results would be different .
the time dependent diffusion loss equation in homogeneous space for the density of charged particles as a function of energy @xmath19 is the following , @xmath20 where @xmath21 $ ] is the energy dependent diffusion constant , with @xmath22 @xmath23 s@xmath7 and @xmath24 .
energy loss due to any electromagnetic process where the exchanged energy is much less than @xmath25 scales as @xmath26 , and is proportional to the energy density in photons ( or equivalently magnetic field ) .
we consider synchrotron losses dues to a 3 @xmath27 g galactic magnetic field ( 0.2 ev @xmath28 ) , inverse compton losses from the cmb ( 0.3 ev @xmath28 ) , and inverse compton losses due to starlight ( 0.6 ev @xmath28 ) @xcite .
we thus set @xmath29 , with @xmath30 gev , and @xmath31 s.
lastly , q is the source function . solving instead for @xmath32
, we find @xmath33 we can calculate the green function for this operator simply by 4-dimensional fourier transform in @xmath34 and @xmath35 , @xmath36 \tilde{g}&=&\frac{1}{(2\pi)^4}\,e^{i(\omega t'+\vec{k}\cdot\vec{x}')}\ , \delta(e - e').\end{aligned}\ ] ] we should note that the green function vanishes for @xmath37 and for @xmath38 because time increases monotonically , and energy decreases monotonically .
this equation is easily solved for @xmath39 : @xmath40},\ ] ] with @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
hereafter we will denote the difference @xmath43 for some variable @xmath44 .
we now apply a jump condition to fix @xmath45 : for @xmath46 , @xmath47 .
the condition is @xmath48 and we thus derive the fourier transform of the green function , @xmath49 inverting the transform , we find the expected behavior that time and energy propagate in lockstep , yielding the free space green function @xmath50 defining the effective diffusion length @xmath51 .
this scale indicates that particles travel only a few kpc before losing most of their energy ( @xmath52 ) .
the galactic magnetic field has a limited extent , which can be modeled simply by defining a diffusion zone at the boundary of which particles freely escape .
diffusion models typically require that the height of the diffusion zone is larger than @xmath53 kpc from the disk on both sides , and the radius is at least 20 kpc , and probably larger .
for example the best galprop models @xcite use @xmath54 kpc and a radius of 30 kpc . as
the radial boundary is far from the earth , we can safely neglect it in considering satellites within 10 kpc of us .
we thus model the diffusion zone as an infinite slab of thickness @xmath55 , and we take @xmath53 kpc . we impose the boundary conditions that the density vanish at @xmath56 , which can be effected by a series of image charges at positions @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 the density of charged particles is now derived , @xmath61 for diffuse emission we are interested not in the local density of particles , but in the column depth of particles , @xmath62 placing the observer at the origin , at an angle @xmath63 from the galactic plane and an angle @xmath64 from the line @xmath65 , we find that for a distance @xmath66 from the observer , @xmath67 for simplicity we define @xmath68 . the integral in @xmath66
can be applied directly to the free green function , yielding the column depth at coordinates @xmath69 due to a source at @xmath70 ( and we truncate at the edge of the diffusion zone , @xmath71 ) , @xmath72/d^2 } \left[\erf\left(\frac{\ell_{\rm max}-\hat{x}\cdot\vec{x}'}{d}\right)- \erf\left(\frac{-\hat{x}\cdot\vec{x}'}{d}\right)\right ] \delta(\delta t-\tau\delta u).\ ] ] the green function satisfying the boundary conditions is now simply @xmath73 and the column density of charged particles is @xmath74 we consider a toy model for dark matter clump undergoing annihilations .
assuming a very cuspy profile , most annihilations will occur very close to the center , and we can assume the clump is a point source .
taking the clump to be at position @xmath75 today @xmath76 , moving with constant velocity @xmath77 , we can write the source function as @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the annihilation rate in the clump , and @xmath80 is the spectrum of @xmath81 per annihilation .
the delta functions simplify matters greatly , leaving only an integral in energy . the charged particle density ( both @xmath82 and @xmath83 ) at the earth and the column depth
are given by @xmath84 @xmath85/d^2 } \left[\erf\left(\frac{\ell_{\rm max}-\hat{x}\cdot\vec{w}_n}{d}\right)- \erf\left(\frac{-\hat{x}\cdot\vec{w}_n}{d}\right)\right ] \theta\left(l-|w_z|\right).\ ] ] the effective position @xmath86 , and @xmath87 .
we recover the steady state solution by taking @xmath88 , indicating a source that has been at location @xmath89 for all time .
we observe that looking at lower energies implies looking back in time , to when the source was in a different position .
this leads to the formation of a `` wake '' of diffuse emission extending from the current position of the source ( which will be a bright , concentrated source of gamma rays ) in the direction it came from .
the spatial signature is not unlike a comet , with a bright `` nucleus '' of gamma rays from the @xmath0 decays , and an extended tail of diffuse emission .
the energy loss time @xmath90 represents all energy loss mechanisms : inverse compton scattering from both the cmb and starlight , and synchrotron emission .
the total power emitted in any one of these is inversely proportional to the timescale for the individual process : @xmath91 , @xmath92 , and @xmath93 .
integrating in energy , @xmath94 and we note this has units power per area per solid angle . in fig .
[ fig : totalpower ] we illustrate contours of the total power in diffuse emission for several geometries of satellites .
finally , we note that the density of charged particles at the position of the earth coming from the clump is typically unobservably small . for electrons of lorentz factor @xmath95 scattering from a blackbody spectrum of photons with @xmath96 ,
the photon spectrum is given by the usual inverse compton formula @xcite , integrated over the blackbody spectrum @xmath97 with @xmath98 .
it is easy to show that this expression integrates to unity .
this formula is inherently non - relativistic , implying that @xmath99 . for the cmb ,
this is easily satisfied , as @xmath100 mev for a 2.725 k blackbody spectrum . for starlight , we assume a blackbody spectrum with @xmath101 k @xcite , thus @xmath102 ev . the non - relativistic condition is satisfied for electron energies @xmath103 tev .
this is true for most if not all of the annihilation products we will consider .
we use @xmath104 to find the spectrum from a single particle ( in power per frequency ) , @xmath105 the spectrum from the full column of particles is then simply ( in power per area per frequency ) @xmath106 .
\label{eq : fullspectrum}\ ] ] detecting a diffuse signal in gamma rays will necessarily be hampered by at least the extragalactic background .
the egret satellite measured this to be @xcite @xmath107 the total power in synchrotron radiation is similar to that in inverse compton emission in that both are proportional to @xmath26 .
the spectra are different however .
@xmath108 and now @xmath109 , with @xmath110 hz .
this is just the usual synchrotron formula , isotropically integrated over the angle the particle trajectory makes with the magnetic field .
it is again easy to show that this expression integrates to unity .
the spectrum from the full column of particles is then easily recovered from eq .
[ eq : fullspectrum ] , replacing the @xmath111 with the synchrotron formula , and replacing @xmath112 with @xmath113 ( and we take @xmath114 g ) .
the chief diffuse background for this synchrotron signal is the cmb , which peaks at 160 ghz . at 1 ghz ,
the power is @xmath115 jy sr@xmath7 . in fig .
[ fig : diffspec ] we plot the spectra of inverse compton and synchrotron emission from a line of sight that is 5 degrees behind the current position of a clump .
we will neglect complications such as synchrotron self - absorption and synchrotron self - compton processes as we calculate the photon density to be much smaller than in previous treatments @xcite due to the diffusion of the source electrons .
many authors have discussed the distribution of substructure in galactic halos .
there are two important issues relating to the detectability of annihilations in these structures , both their mass distribution and their density profile .
again we stress that we are interested only in those satellites within the diffusion zone .
as the diffusion zone is fairly extended , there should be a significant number of such satellites : even out to a radius of 30 kpc , the diffusion zone is roughly 15% of the total volume of the galactic halo .
we first discuss the density profiles of the satellite halos that we hope to detect .
numerical n - body simulations find that structures at all scales diverge as a power law at small radii .
in particular , the popular nfw profile @xcite is given by @xmath116 these profiles can be normalized according to simulations , based on the virial mass and radius , where the density is roughly 340 times the cosmological density ( for the concordance model ) @xmath117 .
the relevant parameter is the concentration @xmath118 , with @xmath119 @xcite , finding @xmath120.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the specific annihilation rate is then given by @xmath121 the moore profile has a steeper central cusp with a divergent total flux @xcite .
thus a minimum radius @xmath122 needs to be defined to regularize .
the profile is given by @xmath123},\\ \frac{\gamma}{m_{\rm vir}}&\rightarrow&\frac{{\langle\sigma v\rangle}\rho_0}{m^2 } \frac{\ln(a / r_{\rm min})}{\ln c}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for cusps @xmath124 steeper than @xmath125 , we find the behavior ( with the proper limit as @xmath126 ) @xmath127 simulations indicate that the mass distribution of subhalos is a power law , given by @xmath128 with a normalization that about 500 clumps with masses larger than @xmath129 are found in a halo like that of the milky way @xcite .
this means that there will be only a handful of clumps more massive than @xmath130 . at @xmath131 ,
the concentration is @xmath132 .
the specific annihilation rate for a clump is easily determined , using @xmath133 . using @xmath134 for any of these halo models , we can find a simple expression for the total annihilation rate in a `` large '' clump , defined as @xmath131 , @xmath135 kpc ( and @xmath136 kpc ) : @xmath137 in supersymmetric models , @xmath138 .
the moore profile has a logarithmically diverging flux , but the enhancement factor is less than 40 if annihilations empty the central cusp , and much less than that for other mechanisms . for example , if interactions with a central black hole sweep out the central region ( of order 1 pc ) , the enhancement is less than 10
. this may be the case for the full galactic halo , but for dark clumps without stars , there may be no central black hole .
steeper profiles can in principle have much larger enhancement factors , though with a cutoff of 1 pc , the enhancement is less than of order 1000 even for @xmath139 . in the next section , we will see that annihilation rates of order @xmath140 are needed for point sources to be confidently seen in diffuse emission , thus @xmath141 is probably required . coincidentally , steeper profiles look more like point sources , so clumps with high enough annihilation rates will be easy to model from this perspective . however , the nfw profile is not too far from detectability for a 10@xmath142 clump , if the annihilation cross section is the maximum allowed .
some clumping of the halo might tip the balance and make even this profile a candidate for detection in inverse compton emission .
here we note that the effect that clumpiness in galactic halos has on dark matter detection has been discussed at length , e.g. ref.@xcite .
the egret gamma ray survey discovered a large number of point sources , a large fraction of which remain unidentified @xcite .
these sources typically have fluxes of order @xmath143 we investigate the possibility that some of these might be milky way satellites undergoing annihilations at their centers .
the annihilation scenario requires that there is no other concentrated emission than the gamma rays .
other astrophysical sources of just about any type are expected to have emission at other wavelengths as well .
these sources ( identified or not ) are not measured below about 100 mev , thus the turnover expected for @xmath0 photons at @xmath144 mev could not have been observed .
however , the spectrum of an annihilation source should be closer to flat around 100 mev , as seen from fig . [
fig : inputspec ] , thus the egret point sources are typically not very good candidates for annihilation radiation . however , they do set the scale of possible annihilation sources quite well .
the yield of gamma rays predominantly from @xmath0 decays in the hadronization of annihilation products is typically @xmath145 annihilation@xmath7 at energies of @xmath146 gev .
this means the inferred rate of annihilations for these sources is @xmath147 @xmath148 s@xmath7 . for a clump at a distance of 8 kpc ,
the inferred annihilation rate is @xmath149 s@xmath7 .
as we have seen in the previous section , this rate likely requires a central density cusp at least as steep as @xmath150 .
we ask the following question : can glast confirm or rule out the hypothesis that some of the unidentified egret point sources are the annihilating cores of very steep profile dark matter subhalos ?
we argue that the answer is yes , for two reasons .
first , glast will have improved performance an energies below 100 mev , down to a threshold of 20 mev .
certainly , the turnover in spectrum at about 70 mev that should be present in an annihilation source should be visible .
second , the diffuse inverse compton emission associated with a few times 10@xmath151 annihilations per second , covering hundreds of square degrees , should yield both a significant fraction of the background and a statistically significant detection .
glast will have an enormously improved exposure over egret : at 1 gev and above , the expectation is @xmath152 @xmath23 s to any point on the sky , per year @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : mapspec ] , we illustrate the integrated flux from inverse compton on starlight in four energy intervals due to an annihilation source of @xmath153 s@xmath7 with the spectrum of the left panel of fig . [
fig : inputspec ] .
we find that such a source should be easy for glast to detect , in fact a source ten times less active , with @xmath154 annihilations per second should be detectable .
these results are summarized in table .
[ tab : egretglast ] .
.detectability of diffuse inverse compton emission in egret and glast .
an annihilation source of @xmath149 s@xmath7 is assumed , with the spectrum of the left panel of fig .
[ fig : inputspec ] .
the egret exposure is assumed to be 10@xmath155 @xmath23 s. for glast , we assume a 5 year mission , with a total exposure of @xmath156 @xmath23 s for energies above 1 gev . in the energy bins below 1 gev , we assume exposures of 50% ( 0.31 gev ) , 25% ( 0.10.3 gev ) , and 10% ( 0.030.1 gev ) of this value @xcite .
the size column indicates the 68% containment region .
the signal / background column represents the total number of photons , inside the 68% containment region , compared with the extragalactic background . for a convincing detection ,
we require that the signal be an appreciable fraction of the background , as the anisotropies in the background are in principle considerable .
we of course also require a significant signal to noise ratio .
lastly , we require a significant total number of photons .
based on these rough criteria , the detectability of the diffuse emission by egret seems marginal , though glast should be able to detect it easily .
if the annihilation rate were ten times smaller , glast should be able to find the signal as well .
note that `` 3 '' in the energy bands means @xmath157 , i.e. the energy bands cover 0.5 decade each . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
an annihilation rate of @xmath158 s@xmath7 produces a significant amount of diffuse synchrotron emission .
previous authors have discussed this in the context of clumps @xcite , neglecting the effects of diffusion .
their calculation essentially assumed a point source of synchrotron radiation ( actually @xmath159 sr ) , with the same total power as we find .
we calculate that the diffusion of the charged particles spreads out the synchrotron signal over roughly @xmath146 sr , a huge area compared with the previous assumption . for this clump ,
the synchrotron emission exceeds the cmb only below 1 ghz . in principle , with spectral information the synchrotron and cmb can be untangled , but as the signal lies near the galactic plane , this may not be feasible .
the galactic center is known to be a bright source of gamma rays , with a broken power law spectrum measured by egret to be @xcite @xmath160 we briefly discuss the possibility that this is an annihilation source . at 100 mev , this spectrum corresponds to @xmath161 annihilations @xmath148 s@xmath7 . assuming the galactic center source is at a distance of 8.5 kpc , the inferred annihilation rate is @xmath162 s@xmath7 .
this is a factor of ten brighter than the bright clumps discussed previously . in fig .
[ fig : mapspecgc ] we illustrate the inverse compton emission that would be associated with the galactic center source .
we find that the emission corresponds to a small fraction of the diffuse emission near the galactic center @xcite , and furthermore , it falls with distance from the center much more quickly than the observed halo ( for an analysis of the gamma - ray halo see ref .
if the galactic center region were better understood , it might be possible to uncover such a signature .
we have calculated the spectrum and spatial extent of diffuse emission from the charged particle products of dark matter annihilations .
in addition to the synchrotron emission discussed previously , we have studied the inverse compton radiation , primarily on starlight photons .
we have focused on galactic satellites that are currently within the diffusion zone , namely within a few kpc of the stellar disk . for satellites moving with typical galactic halo velocities of 300 km s@xmath7 ,
the crossing time of the diffusion zone is of the same order as the diffusion time , thus an inherently time - dependent treatment is required . for annihilation sources ,
e.g. galactic satellites at typical distances of 10 kpc , the diffuse emission in both inverse compton and synchrotron extends over roughly 300 square degrees .
we have shown that at least in terms of the number of photons , the diffuse inverse compton emission might be detectable by glast , assuming bright enough annihilation sources .
the spatial extent of the emission makes its detection problematic of course .
glast will certainly detect a significant number of point sources in a region of this size . in a future work we will study in detail the feasibility of separating these signals . as mentioned previously , these results are fairly generic , and do not depend strongly on the particle physics model .
as we are concerned with the electrons and positrons , we do not even require that the dark matter have hadronic interactions .
leptonically interacting dark matter @xcite would still provide photons and electrons , albeit by different processes and with different spectra .
such photon sources would be even harder to reconcile with the egret point sources , but annihilation sources below the egret detection limit may be detectable by glast in any case .
j. e. gunn , b. w. lee , i. lerche , d. n. schramm and g. steigman , astrophys .
j. * 223 * , 1015 ( 1978 ) ; f. w. stecker , astrophys .
j. * 223 * , 1032 ( 1978 ) ; j. silk and m. srednicki , phys .
lett . * 53 * , 624 ( 1984 ) ; j. silk and h. bloemen , astrophys .
j. * 313 * , l47 ( 1987 ) ; g. lake , nature * 346 * , 39 ( 1990 ) ; l. bergstrm , p. ullio and j. h. buckley , astropart .
* 9 * , 137 ( 1998 ) .
v. berezinsky , a. v. gurevich and k. p. zybin , phys .
lett . b * 294 * , 221 ( 1992 ) ; v. berezinsky , a. bottino and g. mignola , phys .
b * 325 * , 136 ( 1994 ) ; p. gondolo , phys .
b * 494 * , 181 ( 2000 ) ; g. bertone , g. sigl and j. silk , mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . * 326 * , 799 ( 2001 ) ; r. aloisio , p. blasi and a. v. olinto , astro - ph/0402588 p. gondolo , j. edsj , l. bergstrm , p. ullio , and e. a. baltz , astro - ph/0012234 ; p. gondolo , j. edsj , p. ullio , l. bergstrm , m. schelke and e. a. baltz , astro - ph/0211238 ; http://www.physto.se/~edsjo / darksusy/. l. bergstrm , j. edsj , p. gondolo and p. ullio phys .
d * 59 * , 043506 ( 1999 ) ; e. a. baltz , c. briot , p. salati , r. taillet and j. silk , phys .
d * 61 * , 023514 ( 2000 ) ; c. calcneo - rodn and b. moore , phys .
d * 62 * , 123005 ( 2000 ) ; a. tasitsiomi and a. v. olinto , phys .
d * 66 * , 083006 ( 2002 ) ; r. aloisio , p. blasi and a. v. olinto , astrophys . j. * 601 * , 47 ( 2004 ) ; s. m. koushiappas , a. r. zentner and t. p. walker , phys . rev .
d * 69 * , 043501 ( 2004 ) .
p. l. nolan et al . , astrophys .
j. * 459 * , 100 ( 1996 ) ; b. l. dingus et al . , astrophys .
j. * 467 * , 589 ( 1996 ) ; p.
sreekumar et al . , astrophys .
j. * 464 * , 628 ( 1996 ) ; y. c. lin et al . , astrophys .
j. suppl .
ser . * 105 * , 331 ( 1996 ) ; r. c. hartman et al . , astrophys .
j. suppl .
ser . * 123 * , 79 ( 1999 ) . | annihilating dark matter particles produce roughly as much power in electrons and positrons as in gamma ray photons .
the charged particles lose essentially all of their energy to inverse compton and synchrotron processes in the galactic environment .
we discuss the diffuse signature of dark matter annihilations in satellites of the milky way ( which may be optically dark with few or no stars ) , providing a tail of emission trailing the satellite in its orbit .
inverse compton processes provide x - rays and gamma rays , and synchrotron emission at radio wavelengths might be seen .
we discuss the possibility of detecting these signals with current and future observations , in particular egret and glast for the gamma rays . |
after a quarter of a century of modest progress , a breakthrough in gamma - ray burst ( grb ) research came in 1997 , when @xmath0-ray and optical afterglow emission was first detected from grb 970228 @xcite , showing a redshift of @xmath1 .
this confirmed the cosmological origin of grbs and to date , cosmological redshifts have been obtained for about 50 afterglowsjcg / grbgen.html for the most recent list . ] .
initially , afterglow light curves were often sparsely sampled and had a natural explanation in the standard fireball model ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * for a recent review ) .
many showed a smooth power - law decay followed by a steepening one to two days after the burst .
this temporal behavior has been interpreted as being due to a relativistically expanding collimated outflow ( e.g. * ? ? ? *
hereafter r99 ) or more recently to a structured jet viewed off axis ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the standard fireball model assumes a single energy release event with subsequent interaction with an ambient medium with constant density or a stellar wind density profile .
it was also generally assumed that the electron energy distribution index , @xmath2 , was independent of time and had values between 2 - 3 , based on theoretical arguments and energy considerations ( e.g. * ? ? ?
it is quite remarkable that the light curves of most observed afterglows where sufficiently detailed data coverage exists , can be explained within the standard fireball model or slight improvements thereof ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this most likely reflects the underlying universality of the afterglow generation mechanism .
for some bursts , however , interpretations with the unmodified standard model , have proved difficult due to bumps in the light curves or because some basic model parameters turn out to have values outside the range assumed in the model . in particular ,
the slope of the power law energy distribution of the radiating electrons , @xmath2 , is found to be less than 2 in some cases ( e.g. * ? ? ?
@xcite and @xcite have explored the light curves and spectral signatures in models with @xmath3 .
numerical calculations of relativistic shock acceleration suggest a universal value of @xmath4 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
other work suggests an even higher value of @xmath5 @xcite .
this has been referred to as the @xmath2-problem @xcite .
recent afterglow observations do indicate , however , that the value of @xmath2 may not be universal @xcite .
the @xmath2-problem arises when the standard model is being used to interpret light curves that decay much slower than suggested by the model .
such a slow decay had in fact been anticipated ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* hereafter rm98 and sm00 , respectively ) by the natural assumption that the mass ejected in each event ( and the associated energy ) is released with a range of lorentz - factors rather than a single value .
the distributed energy injection into the fireball sustains higher fluxes for longer periods of time , thus resulting in slowly decaying light curves , without requiring @xmath3 .
the cause of the slow decay is thus shifted from the electron population to the properties of the source itself .
this extension of the standard model was , however , not used to interpret actual data until later ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . as continuous energy injection can sustain slower light curve decay rates with @xmath6 , it is important to explore fully the properties and light curve signatures of such models .
in addition to the above quoted references , energy injection in the context of grbs has previously been considered by e.g. @xcite who give an example of how the afterglow of grb 970508 may be explained by refreshed shocks , although a spherically symmetric model may also work .
@xcite explore the self - similarity of spherical blast waves with continuous energy injection , while @xcite consider a model in which a pulsar is assumed to provide the additional energy , a variant of which was also considered by @xcite .
@xcite explore a toy model of the interaction of two colliding shells and estimate the flux contribution from both the forward and the reverse shocks .
then , @xcite consider the interaction of two colliding shells in detail and determine a criteria for such collisions to be mild or violent .
@xcite considers additional energy injection in interpreting observations of several grbs .
in addition , @xcite and @xcite conclude that discrete energy injections are needed to properly account for the optical afterglow of grb 030329 .
all adopt different degrees of approximations on various model ingredients . in recent months , observations by the _ swift _ satellite
have shown that the early light curve behavior may not be as smooth as previously thought .
the origin of these variations may be due to the transition from the prompt phase to the afterglow phase or due to a strong initial reverse shock @xcite .
the slower decaying portions of the light curves may be due to continuous energy injection @xcite .
in particular , grb 050319 @xcite and grb 050315 , have shown this kind of a behavior ( see * ? ? ? * for the latter burst and further examples ) . in this paper
we present a detailed analysis of relativistic fireballs with either discrete or continuous energy injection .
we show that this has interesting observational consequences in addition to the slower decay and provides clear signatures in the light curves .
an example of these effects has already been presented by @xcite , where a discussion of the polarization properties can also be found .
the clearest of those signatures are bumps in the light curves due to refreshed shocks , which may in fact have been observed in e.g. grb 021004 and grb 030329 .
these signatures provide additional information on the hydrodynamic properties of the fireball .
we give examples of fits to three grb afterglows and show that even with the additional energy injection , there remains some discrepancy between the model and the data , especially at radio wavelengths . in our approach
we try to keep the treatment as self - consistent as possible and improve on several of the approximations of some of the previous work .
the paper is structured as follows : in section [ sec : dynamics ] we review the effects that energy injections have on the dynamics of the fireball and outline our approach to the problem . in section
[ sec : approx ] we present approximations for simple modeling of the dynamical evolution . in section [ sec : lcurves ] we discuss the ingredients in the radiative component of our model and in section [ sec : interp ] we give examples of bursts that may be interpreted with this modified model .
finally , in section [ sec : conc ] we discuss our results and conclude the paper .
we begin this section by considering energy and momentum conservation .
we follow the approach of rm98 and sm00 and assume that energy is released over a period that is short compared to the duration of the afterglow .
we then specialize the method to three cases : an instantaneous energy injection in section [ subsec : single ] for easy comparison with r99 ( see also * ? ? ?
* ) , several discrete injection events in section [ subsec : discrete ] , and finally continuous injection with a power law distribution of the lorentz factors in section [ subsec : continuous ] .
we assume the dynamical evolution to be adiabatic in all cases .
assume that the total ejected mass with initial lorentz factor higher than @xmath7 can be written as @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the mass ejected with the highest lorentz factor @xmath10 , and @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is a function specifying the distribution of ejected mass with lorentz factor @xmath7 .
we prefer to use @xmath13 as a variable , and introduce a dimensionless function @xmath14 , defined by @xmath15 , in the interval @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the minimum lorentz factor occurring in the ejected mass .
we then have @xmath18 .
note that in general @xmath19 , since in realistic scenarios we must have @xmath20 .
note also that @xmath21 . the original fireball scenario with an instantaneous energy release is equivalent to @xmath22 .
the energy of a mass element @xmath23 is @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is the velocity of light , and the total energy of the ejecta with lorentz factor greater than @xmath7 is therefore given by @xmath26 where @xmath27 .
integrating by parts we find that @xmath28 the expanding shell decelerates by sweeping up the ambient medium . assuming that the instantaneous total mass of the swept up medium is @xmath29 , the total energy of the shell can be expressed as @xmath30c^2)$ ] , where @xmath31 is the average internal lorentz factor of the particles in the expanding shell . ) below . ] using this and equation ( [ eq : eintegral ] ) above , we find that the conservation of energy may be written as @xmath32+f , \label{eq : econs}\ ] ] with @xmath33 and @xmath34 note that the swept up mass ratio , @xmath35 , increases as @xmath7 decreases . in the preceding equations we have assumed that the slower moving mass shells ejected by the central engine catch up with the decelerating shock front as soon as the lorentz factors of the two coincide .
this is a simplification , as the speed difference between the ejected mass elements will cause a time delay .
the dynamical evolution is however not affected by this , but it should be kept in mind when considering reverse shocks originating from shells colliding with the shock front . a method for including this time delay will be discussed in section [ subsec : discrete ] . before impact with the expanding shock front
, each mass element has momentum @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the velocity of the mass element in the burster frame .
hence the total momentum before impact is @xmath38 with @xmath39 . as the momentum of the hot shell is @xmath40\beta c$ ] , momentum conservation results in @xmath41 where @xmath42 dividing equation ( [ eq : momcons ] ) by equation ( [ eq : econs ] ) , we obtain an expression for the dimensionless velocity of the expanding fireball , @xmath43+f}. \label{eq : beta}\ ] ] we then find that the lorentz factor is given by @xmath44+f}{\sqrt{[\gamma_0[xf(x)+i_1]+f]^2-[\gamma_0\beta_0-i_2]^2}}. \label{eq : gamma}\ ] ] this is an implicit equation for @xmath7 , and describes the evolution of the lorentz factor with radius ( or time ) , once the distribution of the injected lorentz factors , @xmath14 , has been specified along with the initial conditions of the fireball ( e.g. @xmath10 and @xmath9 ) .
a description of the swept up mass , @xmath35 , is also required ( see eq .
[ [ eq : dfdr ] ] below ) .
equation ( [ eq : gamma ] ) is the key equation for obtaining the dynamical evolution of the fireball and has to be solved numerically in all realistic cases .
since we take the evolution to be adiabatic , the dynamics can be solved for separately and the radiative properties computed afterwards . for a complete description of the fireball evolution
we must solve four differential equations ( r99 ) @xmath45 here , @xmath46 is the radial coordinate in the burster frame and @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 are the burster frame time , the comoving frame time and the observer frame time , respectively .
the solid angle into which the energy is beamed is estimated by @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the initial opening angle of the collimated outflow and @xmath52 is the sound speed in the comoving frame , assumed to be relativistic .
the mass density of the external medium is @xmath53 , which in general is a function of radius . in the standard fireball scenario
it is assumed that the energy is released instantaneously with @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
we then find that @xmath56 ; @xmath57 and equation ( [ eq : gamma ] ) reduces to @xmath58 ^ 2-[\gamma_0 ^ 2 - 1]}}= \frac{\gamma_0+f}{\sqrt{1 + 2\gamma_0f+f^2 } } , \label{eq : e_inst}\ ] ] which agrees with the result of @xcite and is the starting point of the r99 analysis ( see his eq . [ 4 ] ) .
some authors have based their analysis of grb afterglows on this equation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
grb 990510 is an example of a burst where the afterglow may be readily interpreted with a single instantaneous energy release event .
we present our fit to the observations in section [ sec:510 ] .
assume that in addition to the initial injection @xmath9 , the central engine expels several shells with masses @xmath59 and lorentz factors @xmath60 .
converting to dimensionless variables , @xmath61 and @xmath62 we have that @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the heaviside step function .
we then obtain , @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
note that by the assumptions of our approach discussed in the first two paragraphs of section [ sec : dynamics ] , the @xmath67 s form a decreasing sequence .
inserting equation [ eq : fdiscrete ] into equation ( [ eq : gamma ] ) we obtain @xmath68 ^ 2 - \left [ \gamma_0\beta_0 + \sum m_i \sqrt{\gamma_0 ^ 2x_i^2 - 1 } h(x_i - x ) \right]^2}}.\ ] ] because the heaviside function is zero until @xmath69 , it is clear from this equation that the dynamical evolution between injections is similar to the instantaneous case as the evolution of @xmath7 depends only on @xmath35 in the same way .
when a shell collides with the shock front , a reverse shock may propagate back through the shell if the collision is violent @xcite .
depending on the circumstances , radiation from the reverse shock may make a substantial contribution to the afterglow light @xcite . according to @xcite , the liklihood of getting a reverse shock depends on the relative energy and speed between the shells and the width of the incoming shell .
as the energy is known and we neglect the dynamics in the shell collision , only the relative speed is needed .
assuming that only the shock front slows down due to interaction with the surrounding medium and that the trailing shell travels with constant speed , shells ejected with the average lorentz factor of the shock , @xmath70 , will have reached the shock front at @xmath46 in time @xmath49 . replacing @xmath71 with @xmath72 in equation ( [ eq : gamma ] )
is then sufficient to account for the delay .
as shown by @xcite , the lorentz factor of the incoming shell is @xmath73 in a constant density environment for most of the evolution .
combined with the results from @xcite ( see their figure 3 ) this indicates that for a reverse shock to result , the energy of the incoming shell must be at least twice the energy of the shock front .
we emphasize that in our numerical calculations we assume the shell collisions to be instantaneous and we neglect the effects of the interaction on the light curves .
these effects are expected to be small considering that the relative lorentz factor of the collision is @xmath74 @xcite .
we estimate that the shells would have to be at least several hundred light seconds thick for the effects of the interaction to be measurable with current instruments ; these would also be strongly smoothed because of the equal arrival time surface ( eats ) .
an example of an afterglow that may be interpreted with discrete energy injections is that of grb 021004 .
@xcite showed that its properties , including polarization , could be explained by using such a model .
energy injection does affect the polarization levels calculated using the model of @xcite as these are most strongly determined by the lorentz factor .
changes in the lorentz factor therefore manifests itself not only in the light curve but also in polarization data .
an analysis of a more detailed data sets for grb 021004 has been presented by @xcite .
the late time afterglow and the host galaxy of this burst have been studied by @xcite .
the afterglow of grb 030329 also showed variations both in the optical and the polarization light curves .
these have previously been interpreted with energy injections @xcite , although other alternatives have also been explored @xcite .
an application of our approach to that particular burst will be presented elsewhere ( guizy et al . in preparation ) . here , we follow the approach of rm98 and sm00 and assume that @xmath75 , with @xmath76 , i.e. the energy is dominated by the lowest lorentz factors .
( the case @xmath77 is equivalent to instantaneous injection as the energy is then dominated by the highest lorentz factors ) .
then @xmath78 , where @xmath79 to evaluate @xmath80 , we assume that @xmath81 , which is always a good approximation if @xmath82 .
we then find @xmath83 .
the dynamical equation for @xmath7 ( eq . [ [ eq : gamma ] ] ) in this case becomes @xmath84 note that for @xmath85 , we recover the result for the instantaneous case ( eq . [ [ eq : e_inst ] ] ) .
also note that the second term under the square root is @xmath86 when @xmath87 .
when considering models with continuous injection , we numerically solve equation ( [ eq : gamma_con ] ) , since in all relevant cases @xmath88 .
the quantities that determine the dynamical evolution of the fireball are the dimensionless mass ratios @xmath14 and @xmath35 , representing the injected energy and the swept up mass , respectively ( see eq .
[ [ eq : gamma ] ] ) .
@xmath14 is an input quantity in the model , and hence each case has to be solved separately . on the other hand
, @xmath35 is only dependent on the evolution of @xmath46 , @xmath53 and @xmath89 .
in general , @xmath90 , where @xmath91 for constant density interstellar medium ( ism ) and @xmath92 for a wind like environment . the evolution of @xmath35 can easily be obtained in two cases : the _ confined outflow _
case when @xmath93 and @xmath89 may be considered to be a constant . in this case the dynamics is that of a spherical outflow .
the second case is that of a _ laterally spreading outflow _
, when @xmath94 and @xmath89 is large enough to neglect the initial opening angle .
these cases were referred to as the power law regime and the exponential regime , respectively , in r99 . that naming convention is however too limiting as we show below
, since for a continuous energy injection there is no exponential regime . as a prescription for @xmath35 in the confined case ,
we evaluate it as @xmath95 while in the laterally spreading case we adopt ( see r99 ) @xmath96 to obtain a full solution of the problem and the light curve behavior , these need to be consistently included in the calculation .
approximate solutions applicable in the instantaneous case have been discussed in detail by e.g. r99 and @xcite .
we emphasize that the approximations can give useful insight into the properties of the fireball but they should , however , only be expected to be valid during limited time intervals in the afterglow evolution .
this is partly due to the validity of the underlying assumptions in those limited intervals , and partly due to the influence of the eats on the evolution ( see section [ sec : eats ] ) .
another factor is the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) , that is not really a set of broken power laws ( see appendix [ sec : app ] ) , but has an intrinsic curvature , and so do the lightcurves . in the following
we first give a brief discussion of the discrete case but then concentrate on the case of continuous energy injection . if the energy is released in several discrete events ( as discussed in section [ subsec : discrete ] ) , the evolution after a shell impact can be approximated with the evolution following a single release event with the appropriate initial parameters .
of these , only the energy is relevant , being equal to the total energy that has accumulated in the shock front after the impact .
integration over the eats then smooths out the transition .
as mentioned in section [ subsec : discrete ] , the relative speed between the impacting shell and the decelerating shock front is an important factor in evaluating the reverse shock emission arising from the collision .
the speed of the incoming shell equals the average speed of the shock front at the time of collision , and to estimate it , we need to know how the radius of the fireball , @xmath46 , evolves with time in the burster frame , @xmath47 . using @xmath97 , appropriate for a single release ( see r99 ) , and equations ( [ eq : ffix ] ) and ( [ eq : dfdr ] ) , it is easy to show that in the confined case the speed of the incoming shell is @xmath98 . although this should only be valid early on in the evolution , numerical calculations indicate that it is in fact appropriate during most of the evolution .
all results derived in this section assume that the shock speed , @xmath99 .
we first note that as @xmath35 is the swept up mass in units of the initial ejected mass , it is small compared to the other terms in equation ( [ eq : gamma_con ] ) for a substantial fraction of the initial fireball evolution , but will dominate at later times . early in the evolution of the fireball , when @xmath71 is close to 1 , @xmath100 and we recover equation ( 4 ) in r99 , and an identical initial fireball evolution .
the most interesting case , however , is when @xmath101 . from the definition of @xmath102
we see that this occurs when @xmath103 , i.e. when @xmath104 for @xmath105 and for @xmath106 , when @xmath107 . in this case equation ( [ eq : gamma ] )
simplifies to @xmath108 when both @xmath10 and @xmath35 can be neglected compared to @xmath102 , we have that @xmath109 . dividing by @xmath10 and solving for @xmath13 , we find @xmath110 note that in the limit , @xmath111 , we recover the power law behavior of the instantaneous injection case , where @xmath112 ( r99 ) . _ confined outflow : _ here
, we adopt equation ( [ eq : ffix ] ) , with @xmath113 , as the solid angle into which the beam propagates . inserting into equation ( [ eq : x ] )
, we find that @xmath114 as in r99 , we also evaluate the relevant times . from @xmath115 ,
we find by integration that the time in the comoving frame is @xmath116 similarly , from @xmath117 , the time in the observer frame is given by @xmath118 inverting this result and inserting into equation ( [ eq : xx ] ) , we find that @xmath119 , in agreement with the sm00 result . also note that if we set @xmath120 and @xmath91 , we recover the results of r99 . _ laterally spreading outflow : _ the treatment is similar to that of r99 .
the @xmath92 case can not , however , be solved analytically due to the coupling of the variables .
we therefore only consider the case @xmath91 in this section ( constant density ism ) .
the general case has to be solved numerically .
we start from equation ( [ eq : dfdrexp ] ) , divide by @xmath121 and integrate to obtain @xmath122 in agreement with equation ( 14 ) of r99 if we set @xmath120 . here , @xmath123 is a constant of integration to be determined by the initial conditions .
it becomes negligible when @xmath124 .
the exponential behavior discussed by r99 is seen to follow from equation ( [ eq : fs ] ) .
if @xmath120 ( formally equivalent to the instantaneous case ) , then equation ( [ eq : fs ] ) shows that @xmath125 so that @xmath126 , and the time in the comoving frame increases exponentially with @xmath46 .
therefore @xmath35 also increases exponentially with @xmath46 . on the other hand , if @xmath76 , the behavior becomes a pure power - law , @xmath127 and @xmath128 which shows that the exponential regime is a special case .
it follows that @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 .
the physical reason for this change in behavior is that the dynamical evolution is now determined by the power - law energy injection rather than the lateral spreading .
we note that in general , if the incoming shell has the same opening angle as the initial @xmath51 , the resulting decay will be a mixture of a power - law decay for the part of the outflow within @xmath51 , and an exponential for that part of the flow that is outside of @xmath51 . by assumption ,
the dynamical evolution is independent of the radiative properties of the fireball . to proceed , a prescription of the radiative processes is required .
we adopt the standard synchrotron emission mechanism ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * for a review ) , that is widely assumed to be the source of radiation in grbs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the details of the radiative component of our modeling are given in section [ sec : lcurves ] and in appendix [ sec : app ] .
to explore the approximate light curve behavior , @xmath132 , we need to evaluate the characteristic frequencies @xmath133 , @xmath134 and the flux @xmath135 at the former ( see appendix [ sec : app ] for definitions of these quantities ) . for the confined case , the temporal behavior of the characteristic frequencies , the @xmath135 , and the light curve decay indices , @xmath136 , agree with those previously derived for the forward shock by sm00 ( see table 1 in their paper ) . for the laterally spreading case we find on the other hand @xmath137 .exponents for @xmath132 for a laterally expanding beam . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : fitpar ] grb 990510 was the first burst where a polarized afterglow was detected @xcite .
however , as there was only one positive detection it does not constrain the model very much , although it further strengthens the case for a synchrotron origin of the afterglow emission .
this polarization measurement is easily accounted for by an off - axis viewing angle .
it was not included in the fit presented here .
the afterglow of grb 000301c is well time resolved at optical and radio wavelengths and was observed in the near infrared and at mm wavelengths although no @xmath0-ray observations have been published .
a short lived brightening was observed in the optical light curves at about 3.5 days followed by a steep achromatic break around 7 days after the burst @xcite .
it has been suggested that this bump may be caused by micro - lensing @xcite .
their @xmath138 value of the fit is reduced by half by introducing the lens effect . here
, we fit the afterglow light curves with our model containing one additional energy injection , @xmath139 at @xmath140 days post - burst .
this is shown in figure [ fig:000301c ] , where a host contribution of @xmath141 @xmath142jy at 8.5 ghz has been subtracted from the data .
the data in the figure is corrected for galactic extinction of @xmath143 @xcite , and an intrinsic smc like extinction of @xmath144 using the profile of @xcite .
this value for the intrinsic extinction was found by @xcite which fitted a power law spectrum with various extinction curves to the measured seds .
fitting the data with a model with just an initial instantaneous energy release results in @xmath145 ( dotted curves in fig .
[ fig:000301c ] ) . adding the energy injection @xmath139 ,
reduces this by a a factor of three to @xmath146 , and gives the parameters presented in table [ tab : fitpar ] .
most of the reduction in the @xmath147 is due to the optical light curves , as the energy injection allows for a fairly constant emission at 8.5 ghz and the sharp steepening of the optical light curves at approximately 6 - 7 days ( solid curves in fig .
[ fig:000301c ] ) .
the remaining contribution to the @xmath147 is due to the bump at 3.5 days in the optical light curves , that rises too sharply to be fitted with an injection event .
this is because of the eats and the homogeneity of the emitting region in our model , making the flux increase too smooth to fit the sharp rise and decline observed .
this sharp bump may be due to an injection that is local in the sense that it only affects a small patch of the radiating shock front .
we also note that the best fit is obtained by having the energy injection at @xmath140 , i.e. just before the first optical data points , rather than at times just before the light curve bump .
such an early injection does fit the flux levels in the various bands better than an injection that is constrained to lie within the time window of the observations .
our model parameter values agree with those of @xcite within a factor of 2 or 3 , except for quantities that are defined differently ( such as @xmath148 ) . given the differences in approach and the different level of details in his work and ours , these differences are rather minor . finally ,
although energy injection that is uniform across the forward shock front is unable to account for the bump in the lightcurves at 3.5 days , other explanations may apply besides micro - lensing .
these could be density inhomogeneities in the ambient medium or an inhomogeneous injection that energizes the emitting surface only partly ( patchy shell ) .
grb 010222 had well time resolved afterglow light curves at most wavelengths and can be interpreted with the standard broken power law in the optical bands .
the shallow slopes of the light curves require a hard electron energy distribution ( @xmath3 ) , if interpreted within the standard model .
an unknown host extinction may influence the sed slope that in turn may lead to an inconsistent determination of @xmath2 , between the spectra and the light - curves .
@xcite found that a continuous energy injection in an otherwise standard fireball model could explain both the light curves and seds without a hard electron energy distribution .
we follow their suggestion and use continuous energy injection model to fit the afterglow data .
the result is shown in figure [ fig:010222 ] where the data points have been corrected for galactic extinction of @xmath149 @xcite and intrinsic smc like extinction of @xmath144 using the profile of @xcite , that was also adopted by @xcite .
the host of grb 010222 is a bright starburst galaxy @xcite and where available , the host contribution has been subtracted from the light curves .
the fit resulted in @xmath150 with the model parameters presented in table [ tab : fitpar ] .
the fit is not particularly good , mainly because the model gives too high a flux at the radio wavelengths .
both the optical and the x - ray data are well accounted for .
we note that the value of @xmath17 is rather high ( table [ tab : fitpar ] ) and the continuous energy injection ceases at approximately @xmath151 day , which along with the jet geometry ( @xmath152 at about 3 days ) , accounts for the steepening in the light curves . if we fit the data without the continuous energy injection , we obtain @xmath153 instead of 4.6 , with the additional contribution mainly due to a worse fit at radio wavelengths .
the model parameters , however , are similar in both cases ; a narrow and energetic jet with a low magnetic field strength in a low density environment .
the continuous energy injection thus better accounts for the radio light curves but otherwise the evolution in both cases is similar .
we are therefore able to fit the optical data reasonably well within the standard model and still have @xmath154 .
we have presented a detailed description of a relativistic fireball afterglow model with discrete and continuous energy injection .
we have given explicit examples of fits to observations for both types of injections and shown how they can provide a better fit to afterglow measurements than the standard model with single initial energy release .
although not a direct subject matter of the present paper , we note that even polarization measurements can in some cases be accounted for with the extended model @xcite .
however , interpreting afterglow polarimetry is not straightforward
. first , polarization measurements are difficult as the polarization level in general seems to be small in afterglows .
the data may therefore be sensitive to polarized contributions from other sources such as the host galaxy , which however is most likely to be constant .
second , our model is sensitive to the geometry of the outflow and the assumed homogeneity of the emission region .
the expanding shock front is unlikely to be homogeneous during its entire evolution , especially with the added energy injections .
this is because an injected shell will not expand laterally in exactly the same way as the original shock front
. the transverse size of the incoming shell will then be smaller and its energy deposition in the shock front will be concentrated in the contact zone between the two .
accounting for the effects of the eats , could then lead to a rise in the level of polarization shortly after the injection and even abrupt changes in the polarization angle if the center of the colliding shell does not coincide with the geometrical center of the front .
the origin of the additional shells is most likely the same as the origin of the shells producing the gamma ray burst in internal shocks .
it is highly unlikely that the matter ejected from the central engine always collides and collects into one shell in the gamma ray burst event .
the remaining shells will then be the ones to refresh the external shock later on in the evolution of the fireball
. this might even be the case in most bursts , but goes unnoticed in many cases since the energy of the colliding shells must be of the same order or higher as the total accumulated energy of the front if their interaction is to produce a measurable brightening .
when fitting grb afterglow light curves with the standard fireball model , it is quite common to use power law approximations with a light curve break due to jet structure . the slope of the light curve , @xmath136 , before and after the break is then used to determine the electron energy distribution index , @xmath2 , which is then compared to the value of @xmath2 inferred from the sed of the burst ( see e.g. sari et al .
these results must , however , be carefully considered , as the value of @xmath136 depends on @xmath155 as well ( see table [ table : exps ] ) , and may not be smoothly varying between two fixed asymptotes , although that seems to be the general case .
this is especially true when the characteristic frequencies of the synchrotron spectrum , @xmath133 and @xmath134 , are near the observing frequency , where the sed does not follow a power law .
the light curve break time has traditionally been used to infer the jet opening angle from the assumption that it occurs when @xmath156 .
this can lead to erroneous angle estimates , because energy injections can delay the appearance of the light curve break .
an example of this is grb 021004 @xcite . as a result
, the opening angle will be overestimated and the energy corrected for beaming may thus not be correct @xcite .
studies based on such energy estimates ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , should include error analysis that accounts for this bias.
we approximate the synchrotron radiation power density , @xmath157 , in the comoving frame ( primed quantities ) with a smoothly joined power - law at the characteristic frequencies .
this takes the form @xmath158^{-1/\kappa_1 } \left[1+\left(\frac{\nu'}{\nu_m'}\right)^{(-1/2+p/2)(\kappa_2)}\right]^{-1/\kappa_2}\ ] ] for the fast cooling regime , @xmath159 , and @xmath160^{-1/\kappa_3 } \left[1+\left(\frac{\nu'}{\nu_c'}\right)^{(-(p-1)/2+p/2)(\kappa_4)}\right]^{-1/\kappa_4}\ ] ] for the slow cooling regime , @xmath161 . here
@xmath2 is the electron energy distribution index and @xmath162 and @xmath163 are the characteristic synchrotron frequencies corresponding , respectively , to the minimum lorentz factor of the distribution , @xmath164 and the lorentz factor above which electrons are radiative , @xmath165 here , @xmath166 and @xmath167 are the mass of the proton and the electron , respectively , @xmath148 is the fraction of thermal energy in the electrons compared to the total thermal energy of the fireball , @xmath168 is the thompson scattering cross section .
furthermore , @xmath169 is the dimensionless speed of the shock front and @xmath170 is the magnetic field strength , with @xmath171 the fraction of magnetic field energy compared to the total thermal energy of the fireball and @xmath172 is the density in the comoving frame .
the characteristic frequencies are given by @xmath173 where @xmath174 is either @xmath175 or @xmath25 .
the maximum values for the power density are given by @xmath176 where , @xmath177 , is the elementary charge and the parameters , @xmath178 and @xmath179 , are introduced here as in @xcite to account for an isotropic distribution of angles between the electron velocity and the magnetic field . comparing the results from these approximations with the more accurate calculations using the approach from @xcite , we find the following @xmath2-dependence of the exponents and coefficients in the fast cooling regime to be @xmath180 in the slow cooling regime , we find similarly , @xmath181 the difference between these approximations and the more accurate calculations is generally less than 10% unless @xmath134 is close to @xmath133
. then the difference can be up to 40% .
however , for most parameter sets the characteristic frequencies are close , only very early in the afterglow evolution and this is therefore not a concern in the later evolution .
even then , the difference is mostly smoothed out because of the integration over the equal arrival time surface .
we find the difference between the two solutions to be less than 10% for most realistic cases .
we also remind the reader that the electron energy distribution is an approximation and little is known about the detailed microphysics of the shocked material . | we extend the standard fireball model , widely used to interpret gamma - ray burst ( grb ) afterglow light curves , to include energy injections , and apply the model to the afterglow light curves of grb 990510 , grb 000301c and grb 010222 .
we show that discrete energy injections can cause temporal variations in the optical light curves and present fits to the light curves of grb 000301c as an example .
a continuous injection may be required to interpret other bursts such as grb 010222 .
the extended model accounts reasonably well for the observations in all bands ranging from @xmath0-rays to radio wavelengths . in some cases ,
the radio light curves indicate that additional model ingredients may be needed . |
the existence of neutrino mass and dark matter is a clear sign of new physics beyond the standard model ( sm ) .
another long - standing issue in sm is the strong cp problem @xcite which is elegantly resolved by the peccei - quinn ( pq ) mechanism @xcite .
it predicts a hypothetical particle called the axion as a pseudo - nambu - goldstone ( ng ) boson of an anomalous global symmetry @xmath0 which is spontaneously broken at an intermediate scale @xmath1 gev @xcite .
the pq symmetry is realized typically in the context of a heavy quark ( ksvz ) model @xcite or a two - higgs - doublet ( dfsz ) model @xcite .
the pq symmetry breaking may be related to the seesaw mechanism explaining the smallness of the observed neutrino masses @xcite identifying the pq symmetry as the lepton number @xmath2 @xcite .
let us note that the seesaw mechanism realized at the intermediate scale @xmath3 can provide a natural way to explain the matter - antimatter asymmetry in the universe through leptogenesis @xcite .
an attractive feature of this scenario is that the axion is a good candidate of cold dark matter through its coherent production during the qcd phase transition @xcite .
as the axion is well - motivated dark matter candidate , serious efforts are being made to search for it by various experimental groups such as admx @xcite , capp @xcite and iaxo @xcite .
the traditional ksvz or dfsz models have been considered as two major benchmarks in search for the axion dark matter . in the context of the pq mechanism combined with the seesaw mechanism , however
, the electromagnetic and color anomaly coefficients can take different values , and thus can have different predictions in the future axion search experiments .
this moviates us to consider minimal extensions of the sm in which various seesaw models @xcite are extended to realize the ksvz or dfsz axion , and compare their predictions with the conventional ksvz and dfsz models .
this paper is organized as follows .
we will first set up minimal extensions of the sm to combine the pq and seesaw mechanisms in non - supersymmetric and supersymmetric theories in sections ii and iii , respectively .
the corresponding model predictions are presented in section iv , and then we conclude in section v.
a pq seesaw model is characterized by how a global @xmath4 symmetry , playing the role of the pq symmetry and the lepton number , is implemented to act on a specific set of extra fermions carrying non - trivial @xmath5 charges .
such an @xmath4 symmetry is supposed to be broken spontaneously by the vacuum expectation value of a scalar field @xmath6 assuming a scalar potential : @xmath7 with @xmath8 gev which sets the scales of the axion decay constant @xmath9 and the heavy seesaw particles . in the case of the type - i and type - ii seesaw introducing a singlet fermion ( right - handed neutrino ) @xcite and a higgs triplet scalar @xcite respectively ,
their combinations with the ksvz and dfsz axion models leads to the same results to the conventional ones .
thus , we consider the type - iii seesaw ( by heavy lepton triplets ) @xcite implementing the pq symmetry in the manner of ksvz or dfsz . * * ksvz+type - iii ( ksvz - iii ) * : in a ksvz model combined with type - iii seesaw ( lepton triplets with zero hypercharge ) , we add as usual an extra heavy quark field @xmath10 which transforms as ( 3,1,0 ) under @xmath11 , and three ( majorana ) lepton triplets which transform as ( 1,3,0 ) .
the right - handed and left - handed lepton triplets are denoted by @xmath12 where heavy neutrino @xmath13 , heavy charged leptons @xmath14 , @xmath15 with the charge conjugation @xmath16 and the pauli matrix @xmath17 .
the non - trivial x - charges are assigned as follows @xmath18 compatible with the yukawa lagrangian for the ksvz - iii model , @xmath19 \cr \frac{1}{2}{\rm tr}[\overline{\sigma^{c}}h_\sigma\sigma^ * \sigma ] \end{cases } + \text{h.c . }
\label{lagrangian2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath20 and @xmath21 stand for the higgs doublet and the lepton doublet in the sm , respectively , and @xmath22 . depending on the @xmath5-charge signs of the triplet fermion one couples @xmath6 or @xmath23 to the triplet as denoted by iii@xmath24 or iii@xmath25 , respectively .
note that we took the normalization of @xmath26 in eq .
( [ xcharges11 ] ) under which the qcd anomaly is the number of the heavy quarks : @xmath27 .
+ after the @xmath4 breaking by an appropriate scalar potential ( [ vsigma ] ) , the complex scalar field @xmath6 can be written as @xmath28 where @xmath29 is nothing but the ksvz axion , and the real scalar @xmath30 is supposed to get mass @xmath31 which sets the axion and seesaw scales . + * * dfsz+type - iii ( dfsz - iii ) * : in a dfsz axion model , the pq symmetry is implemented by extending the higgs sector with two higgs doublets , @xmath32 with @xmath33 , and a higgs singlet @xmath6 , and allowing the scalar potential term @xmath34 which sets the pq ( @xmath5 ) charge relation of the two higgs bosons : @xmath35 again under the normalization of @xmath26 .
+ then the yukawa lagrangian for dfsz - iii reads @xmath36 \cr \frac{1}{2}{\rm tr}[\overline{\sigma^{c}}h_\sigma\sigma^ * \sigma ] \end{cases } + \text{h.c . } , \label{lagrangian21 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where one can choose @xmath37 or @xmath38 depending on which we categorize two different dfsz models . as we again have two choices for the triplet mass operator with @xmath6 or @xmath23 , there are four different dfsz - iii models
. + eqs .
( [ v21],[lagrangian21 ] ) give six @xmath5-charge relations to be satisfied by the eight fields ( other than @xmath6 ) .
as will be discussed shortly , the orthogonality of the axion and the longitudinal degree of the @xmath39 boson gives another condition .
then , one finds that there is freedom to choose one of the three quark charges .
taking @xmath40 , we get the following x - charge assignment : @xmath41 where we have @xmath42 and @xmath43 leading to the qcd anomaly @xmath44 with the number of the generation @xmath45 .
+ after the breaking of @xmath46 by the vacuum expectation values , @xmath47 and @xmath48 , of @xmath49 and @xmath6 , the axion and the longitudinal degree of the @xmath39 boson denoted by @xmath50 and @xmath51 , are given by @xcite : @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the phase fields of @xmath49 and @xmath6 .
then the orthogonality of @xmath50 and @xmath51 is guaranteed by @xmath55 with the normalization @xmath26 and @xmath56 .
to implement the pq symmetry in supersymmetric models , let us introduce two chiral superfields @xmath57 and @xmath58 having the opposite x charges , say , @xmath59 , and its spontaneous breaking is assumed to occur by the typical superpotential : @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 is implied in the notation .
here @xmath63 is a gauge singlet superfield and carry pq charge zero .
the supersymmetric version of the ksvz model introduces the heavy quark superpotential @xmath64 which defines the pq charge relation : @xmath65 leading to the qcd anomaly : @xmath66 as in the nonsupersymmetric case . here
@xmath67 is the usual minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) superpotential given by @xmath68 which is separated from the pq mechanism .
the supersymmetric dfsz model provides a natural framework to resolve the @xmath69 problem as well @xcite by extending the higgs sector @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the reduced planck mass and the right size of the @xmath69 term , @xmath72 , arises after the pq symmetry breaking .
the usual pq charges assignment consistent with the above superpoential is @xmath73 where we have put @xmath74 as before and @xmath75 follows from the charge normalization of @xmath76 . at this stage , there is arbitrariness in choosing the value of @xmath77 , but it will be fixed in seesaw extended pq models which has no physical consequences .
note that the qcd anomaly of the supersymmetric dfsz model is again given by @xmath78 .
now let us consider the seesaw extensions of the supersymmetric pq models .
as in the non - supersymmetric case , type - i seesaw introducing right - handed ( singlet ) neutrinos does not change the results of the standard ksvz and dfsz models .
thus , we discuss the type - ii and -iii extensions in order . * * ksvz+type - ii ( sksvz - ii ) * : type - ii seesaw introduces a dirac pair of @xmath79 triplet superfields with the hypercharge @xmath80 : @xmath81 and @xmath82 .
its combination with the ksvz model can be realized by the superpotential : @xmath83 which set the pq charges of the leptonic fields : @xmath84 * * dfsz+type - ii ( sdfsz - ii ) * : similarly to the previous case , the superpotential for the dfsz model combined with type - ii seesaw takes the form : @xmath85 which is invariant under the pq symmetry with the charge assignment of ( [ xdfsz ] ) extended to the leptonic sector as follows : @xmath86 * * ksvz+type - iii ( sksvz - iii ) * : in supersymmetric type - iii seesaw one introduces three triplet superfields ( with @xmath87 ) denoted by @xmath88 then the whole superpotential of the ksvz model realized in type - iii seesaw is @xmath89 \cr { 1\over2 } \lambda_{\bar\sigma } \hat { \sigma } \mbox{tr}[\hat\sigma \hat\sigma ] \cr \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which defines the pq charges of the leptonic fields as in the non - supersymmetric case : @xmath90 * * dfsz+type - iii ( sdfsz - iii ) * : type - iii seesaw introduces three triplet superfields ( with @xmath87 ) : @xmath88 + the superpotential is @xmath91 \cr { 1\over2 } \lambda_{\bar\sigma } \hat { \sigma } \mbox{tr}[\hat\sigma \hat\sigma ] \cr \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which set the pq charges of the leptonic fields : @xmath92
to discuss the implications of the pq seesaw models presented in the previous sections , let us first summarize some basic properties of the axion relevant for our discussion @xcite .
after the pq symmetry breaking by a generic number of scalar fields @xmath93 having the pq charge @xmath94 and @xmath95 , the following combination of the phase fields @xmath96 defines the axion direction : @xmath97 integrating out all the relevant pq - charged fermions , the axion gets the effective axion - gluon - gluon and axion - photon - photon couplings through its color and electromagnetic anomalies , respectively : @xmath98 where the axion decay constant @xmath9 is defined by @xmath99 , and @xmath100 is the ` modified ' electromagnetic anomaly normalized by the color anomaly @xmath101 of the pq symmetry . below the qcd scale @xmath102 mev
, the axion - gluon - gluon anomaly coupling induces the axion potential @xmath103 where the axion mass is calculated to be @xmath104 with @xmath105 , @xmath106 mev and @xmath107 mev . under the pq charge normalization of @xmath108 ( and @xmath109 ) in the non - supersymmetric ( supersymmetric ) axion models discussed in the previous section , the color anomaly @xmath101 counts the number of distinct vacua developed in the axion potential ( [ va ] ) which sets the axionic domain wall number @xmath110 . then the axion - photon - photon coupling constant is given by @xmath111 @xmath112 \over c_{3 } } \quad\mbox{and}\quad c_{\chi sb } \equiv { 2\over 3 } { 4 + 1.05 z\over 1 + 1.05 z } \approx 1.98 \nonumber\ ] ] where
@xmath113 counts the electromagnetic anomaly normalized by the color anomaly , and @xmath114 is the modified effect by the chiral symmetry breaking including the strange quark contribution .
+ each pq seesaw model presented in the previous section give a different prediction on the coefficient @xmath113 and thus on the future sensitivity of the axion search at admx or capp .
following eq .
( [ cagg ] ) , the electromagnetic anomaly of each model is given by @xmath115 where @xmath116 and @xmath117 are used for the ksvz and dfsz models , respectively . in fig .
i , we plot the axion - photon - photon coupling @xmath118 as a function of axion mass @xmath119 , and compare them with the conventional ksvz ( @xmath120 ) and dfsz ( @xmath121 , or @xmath122 ) predictions .
the experiments such as admx @xcite , capp @xcite , cast @xcite , iaxo @xcite , are projected to probe some regions of the parameter space of the axion coupling to photons and its mass . in fig . 1 .
the cyan- ( red- ) thick dashed boundary indicates the future sensitivity of the axion dark matter search by admx ( capp ) @xcite .
the current admx results @xcite excludes only a limited region of ksvz type models and dfsz@xmath123-iii@xmath124 , sdfsz - ii@xmath125 models over the mass range of @xmath126ev .
solar axion search experiments like cast and iaxo are also sensitive to the pq axions . cast probes the axion mass range of @xmath127 ev for @xmath128 , while iaxo would have sensitivity to much larger axion masses compared to cast if @xmath129 .
most recently , cast has improved the limit on the axion - photon - photon coupling to @xmath130gev@xmath131 at 95@xmath132 c.l .
this may exclude the models above the ksvz line over the mass range @xmath133 ev , which can be seen by considering the mass values at @xmath134 gev@xmath131 in the various models like sksvz - ii@xmath25 ( @xmath135 ev ) , sksvz - ii@xmath136 , sksvz - iii@xmath25 , ksvz - iii@xmath124 ( @xmath137 ev ) , sksvz - iii@xmath24 , ksvz - iii@xmath136 ( @xmath138 ev ) , sdfsz - ii@xmath125 ( @xmath139 ev ) , dfsz@xmath123-iii@xmath124 ( @xmath140 ev ) , and ksvz ( @xmath141 ev ) .
we have considered minimal extensions of the sm combining the ksvz or dfsz axion with various seesaw models in the framework of the ( non- ) supersymmetric theories , which provides a popular solution to the strong cp problem as well as the smallness of neutrino masses .
we have showed that depending on how to embed @xmath0 in a seesaw model , the electromagnetic and color anomaly coefficients take different values , and thus each model has a different prediction on the axion - photon - photon coupling which could be tested in the future axion search experiments .
this sets up various benchmark points for the minimal pq seesaw models in comparison with the standard ksvz and dfsz models which are summarized in eq .
( [ cagg ] ) and fig .
i. 99 # 1#2#3phys .
* b#1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3nucl .
* b#1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3phys . rev .
* d#1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3phys .
lett . * # 1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3mod .
* a#1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3phys . rep .
* # 1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3science * # 1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3astrophys .
j. * # 1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3eur .
j. * c#1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3jhep * # 1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3j .
* g#1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3int .
j. mod .
# 1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 # 1#2#3prog .
# 1 * , ( # 3 ) # 2 for comprehensive reviews of the axion physics , see , j. e. kim , phys .
rept . * 150 * , 1 ( 1987 ) ; h. -y .
cheng , phys .
* 158 * , 1 ( 1988 ) .
r. d. peccei and h. r. quinn , phys .
lett . * 38 * , 1440 ( 1977 ) . for a revew , see , j. e. kim and g. carosi , rev .
* 82 * ( 2010 ) 557 [ arxiv:0807.3125 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. e. kim , phys . rev .
* 43 * , 103 ( 1979 ) ; m. a. shifman , a. i. vainshtein and v. i. zakharov , nucl .
b * 166 * , 493 ( 1980 ) .
m. dine , w. fischler and m. srednicki , phys .
b * 104 * , 199 ( 1981 ) ; a. r. zhitnitsky , sov .
j. nucl .
phys . *
31 * , 260 ( 1980 ) [ yad . fiz . * 31 * , 497 ( 1980 ) ] .
p. minkowski , phys .
b * 67 * , 421 ( 1977 ) ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond and r. slansky , conf .
c * 790927 * , 315 ( 1979 ) [ arxiv:1306.4669 [ hep - th ] ] ; t. yanagida , conf .
c * 7902131 * , 95 ( 1979 ) ; r. n. mohapatra and g. senjanovic , phys .
* 44 * , 912 ( 1980 ) ; j. schechter and j. w. f. valle , phys .
d * 22 * , 2227 ( 1980 ) .
w. konetschny and w. kummer , phys .
b * 70 * , 433 ( 1977 ) ; s. bertolini , l. di luzio , h. kolesova and m. malinsky , phys . rev .
d * 91 * , no . 5 , 055014 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1412.7105 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. foot , h. lew , x. g. he and g. c. joshi , z. phys .
c * 44 * , 441 ( 1989 ) .
k. kang , j. kim , j. e. kim , k. s. soh and h. s. song , phys .
d * 22 * , 2869 ( 1980 ) .
s. l. cheng , c. q. geng and w. t. ni , phys .
d * 52 * , 3132 ( 1995 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.52.3132 [ hep - ph/9506295 ] .
r. n. mohapatra and g. senjanovic , z. phys .
c * 17 * , 53 ( 1983 ) ; q. shafi and f. w. stecker , phys .
lett . * 53 * , 1292 ( 1984 ) ; p. langacker , r. d. peccei and t. yanagida , mod .
lett . a * 1 * , 541 ( 1986 ) ; a. g. dias , a. c. b. machado , c. c. nishi , a. ringwald and p. vaudrevange , jhep * 1406 * , 037 ( 2014 ) doi:10.1007/jhep06(2014)037 [ arxiv:1403.5760 [ hep - ph ] ] ; a. salvio , phys .
b * 743 * , 428 ( 2015 ) doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2015.03.015 [ arxiv:1501.03781 [ hep - ph ] ] ; c. d. r. carvajal , a. g. dias , c. c. nishi and b. l. snchez - vega , jhep * 1505 * , 069 ( 2015 ) [ jhep * 1508 * , 103 ( 2015 ) ] doi:10.1007/jhep05(2015)069 , 10.1007/jhep08(2015)103 [ arxiv:1503.03502 [ hep - ph ] ] ; j. d. clarke and r. r. volkas , arxiv:1509.07243 [ hep - ph ] .
m. fukugita and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 174 * , 45 ( 1986 ) .
p. sikivie , lect .
notes phys .
* 741 * , 19 ( 2008 ) [ astro - ph/0610440 ] ; and the reviews in @xcite .
s. j. asztalos _ et al . _
[ admx collaboration ] , phys .
d * 69 * , 011101 ( 2004 ) [ astro - ph/0310042 ] ; see also , http://depts.washington.edu/admx/index.shtml e. j. chun and a. lukas , phys .
b * 357 * ( 1995 ) 43 [ hep - ph/9503233 ] .
j. e. kim and h. p.
nilles , phys .
b * 138 * ( 1984 ) 150 .
e. j. chun , j. e. kim and h. p. nilles , nucl .
b * 370 * ( 1992 ) 105 .
j. hoskins _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 84 * , 121302 ( 2011 ) doi:10.1103/physrevd.84.121302 [ arxiv:1109.4128 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
ibs - multidark joint pocus program : wimps and axions , see gray rybka and yannis sermertzidis talks in https://indico.ibs.re.kr/event/7/ | the pq mechanism resolving the strong cp problem and the seesaw mechanism explaining the smallness of neutrino masses may be related in a way that the pq symmetry breaking scale and the seesaw scale arise from a common origin .
depending on how the pq symmetry and the seesaw mechanism are realized , one has different predictions on the color and electromagnetic anomalies which could be tested in the future axion dark matter search experiments .
motivated by this , we construct various pq seesaw models which are minimally extended from the ( non- ) supersymmetric standard model and thus set up different benchmark points on the axion - photon - photon coupling in comparison with the standard ksvz and dfsz models . |
the studies of dielectric polarization in fluids @xcite are based on the following relation between the polarization @xmath0 and the electric field strength @xmath1 inside the dielectric : @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the field dependent dielectric permittivity .
the internal field is often called maxwell field @xcite which differs from the external field @xmath4 applied to the dielectric medium . in the low - field limit
the linear dielectric permittivity @xmath5 of an isotropic fluid is given by the ratio of the polarization to the internal field strength : @xmath6 in strong electric fields the polarization response acquires in addition nonlinear contributions , so that the electric permittivity turns into a nonlinear function of the maxwell field : @xmath7 for simple molecular liquids
the coefficients of the power series decrease rapidly @xcite .
thus in general dielectric experiments can be well described in terms of the linear dielectric permittivity . for liquids consisting of small molecules this series can be limited to the second term .
the corresponding nonlinear dielectric effect ( nde ) is determined by the coefficient @xmath8 of the contribution @xmath9 in eq .
( [ sor ] ) : @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the nonlinear dielectric permittivity which , upon substituting eq .
( [ sor ] ) into eq .
( [ fpol ] ) , is given by @xmath12 although the nonlinear dielectric behavior of liquids has enjoyed a long lasting scientific interest @xcite accurate measurements of ndes have become possible only recently due to the development of new techniques @xcite , which in an applied electric field are capable to separate from the nde , e.g. , the joule effect due to heating of the sample induced by its finite conductivity .
experimentally , @xmath11 is determined from the small change of the dielectric permittivity ( @xmath13 ) induced by static @xcite or pulsed @xcite strong electric fields and is detected by a weak radio - frequency probing field . in nonlinear optics
the nde can also provide useful information for laser induced molecular reorientations in isotropic and liquid crystalline phases @xcite .
the first nde measurements were carried out by herweg in diethyl ether @xcite yielding @xmath14 .
if @xmath8 has a sign opposite to that of @xmath15 one often speaks of normal saturation because in this case the first correction term to the linear behavior @xmath16 for @xmath17 is in line with the levelling off at large @xmath18 .
this effect is mainly connected to the ordering of the orientation of dipoles in strong electric fields .
the negative value of @xmath8 corresponds to the negative value of the third order term of the power expansion of the langevin function for small @xmath18 .
strongly dipolar liquids , such as nitrobenzene , show anomalous ( positive ) dielectric saturation because in such systems the external electric field influences the formation of antiparallel pairs of dipolar nitrobenzene molecules @xcite .
nonlinear dielectric effects have become also very useful for analyzing intermolecular association @xcite , conformational equilibria @xcite , and critical phenomena in liquids and liquid mixtures @xcite .
recently the nde has also been used to study isotropic - mesophase transitions of various liquid crystals @xcite .
the theoretical models of nonlinear dielectric phenomena are based on classical electrostatics and statistical mechanics of liquids .
there have been early attempts by debye @xcite , onsager @xcite , and kirkwood @xcite to calculate the nonlinear dielectric permittivity on the basis of phenomenological theories of dielectric continua .
nice summaries of these nonlinear theories can be found in refs .
@xcite and @xcite . from a microscopic point of view
rasaiah et al .
@xcite and martina and stell @xcite have proposed a statistical mechanics description for nde and electrostriction on the basis of a quadratic hypernetted chain approximation . using molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations
the dielectric saturation of water has been studied by alper and levy @xcite , but they have not published any numerical value for the nonlinear dielectric permittivity . yeh and berkowitz @xcite have obtained new md simulation data for the electric field dependence of the dielectric permittivity of water and they found that @xmath3 decreases with increasing applied field strength in accordance with the expectation of a normal saturation effect .
their external field simulation data show good agreement with a phenomenological equation proposed by booth @xcite .
this equation has been used in the calculation of dielectric saturation of water in membrane protein channels @xcite . recently
fulton @xcite has compared the nonlinear dielectric permittivity of water obtained from simulation , theory , and experiment .
he concluded that an upgraded approach by booth @xcite renders the best agreement between the simulation and experimental data ; but the extent of the agreement depends on the water model used for determining the corresponding correlation functions .
it is also shown that the calculated nonlinear dielectric permittivity strongly depends on the application of phenomenological cavity and reaction field corrections .
these findings underscore the ongoing interest in statistical mechanics analyses of nonlinear dielectric effects of dipolar liquids . within the framework of density functional theory ( dft ) and the mean spherical approximation ( msa )
we have proposed an equation @xcite for the magnetic field dependence of the magnetization of ferrofluids , which turned out to be successful in comparison with corresponding monte carlo ( mc ) simulation data . translated into the synonymous electric language
this means that we have obtained an analytical ( implicit ) equation for the electric field dependence of the polarization . here , from our previous results
@xcite , we deduce a formula for the nonlinear dielectric permittivity of dipolar fluids .
moreover , we compare our theoretical findings with canonical mc simulation data using the corresponding fluctuation formulae in the absence of external fields .
the motivation for our study is to deduce an analytical theory of a realistic model for nonlinear phenomena in dipolar liquids .
this theory has to be quantitatively correct in the sense that it withstands the comparison with mc simulation data and it has to be easily applicable for interpreting corresponding experimental data .
we expect that our model calculations can be used to shed light on the role of nonlinear dielectric saturation for solvation effects of ions in dipolar solvents @xcite .
we study hard core dipolar yukawa fluids which consist of spherical particles interacting via a hard core yukawa ( y ) potential characterized by parameters @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 : @xmath22 & , & r_{12}\geq\sigma .\\
\end{array } \right . \label{usw}\ ] ] in addition there is a dipolar interaction due to point dipoles embedded at the centers of the particles : @xmath23 with the rotationally invariant function @xmath24 where particle 1 ( 2 ) is located at @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) and carries a dipole moment of strength @xmath27 with an orientation given by the unit vector @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) with polar angles @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) ; @xmath32 is the difference vector between the centers of particle 1 and 2 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 is a unit vector with orientation @xmath35 .
the hard core dipolar yukawa interaction potential is defined by the sum of the aforementioned potentials as @xmath36 the msa is defined by three equations relating the total correlation function @xmath37 and the direct correlation function @xmath38 as follows : @xmath39 @xmath40 and @xmath41 here and in the following @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath44 is the temperature , and @xmath45 is the pair potential characterizing the system .
the number density @xmath46 is given by the number @xmath47 of molecules in the system of volume @xmath48 . equation ( [ oz ] ) is the ornstein - zernike ( oz ) relation , eq .
( [ oz1 ] ) is an exact relation for hard spheres , and eq .
( [ oz2 ] ) is the closure relation for the msa ( for details see ref .
@xcite ) . for dipolar hard sphere ( dhs )
fluids an analytical solution of the msa was reported by wertheim @xcite .
later the msa for hard core yukawa fluids has also been solved analytically by waisman @xcite . following the ideas of wertheim , for hard core
dipolar yukawa fluids henderson et al .
@xcite found an analytical solution in the framework of msa . within this theory
the direct correlation function of the dy fluid can be expressed as @xmath49 where @xmath50 is a rotationally invariant function .
( we note that a similar equation is valid for the total correlation function @xmath51 of the dy fluid . )
the radially symmetric function @xmath52 is the solution of the oz equation with a simple hard - core yukawa msa closure and is given in refs .
@xcite while the functions @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the solutions of two msa integral equations ( derived from the oz equations ) with the corresponding dipolar hard sphere msa closure , depending therefore on the dipole moment of the molecules @xcite . in eq .
( [ cdy ] ) @xmath55 and @xmath56 are given by eqs .
( [ ddd ] ) and ( [ del ] ) respectively .
the coefficients @xmath53 and @xmath54 ( together with @xmath57 and @xmath58 ) are independent of the yukawa potential parameters @xmath20 and @xmath21 as well as of @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 and are given in ref .
the main feature of this solution is that it decomposes into contributions from the yukawa potential and from the dipolar hard sphere potential with the latter ones factorizing into radial and angular dependences . in ref .
@xcite it has been shown that , within the framework of msa , the free energy @xmath62 of the dy fluids can be written as @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the ideal gas free energy and @xmath65 , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 are the excess free energies of hard sphere @xcite , hard core yukawa @xcite , and dipolar hard sphere fluids @xcite , respectively . within this approximation
the dielectric constant of the dy fluid is given by the formula due to wertheim @xcite and henderson et al .
@xcite : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the reduced inverse compressibility function of the hard sphere fluid .
the parameter @xmath70 stems from the dhs msa and is given by the implicit equation @xmath71 where @xmath72 measures the reduced dipole strength .
the disadvantage of the msa is that it can predict the polarization only for weak electric fields because in essence it is a linear response theory . in order to overcome this shortcoming
we resort to density functional theory . within this framework
we first have to determine the orientational distribution function in an applied external field . for an inhomogeneous and anisotropic dipolar
fluid the one - particle distribution function @xmath73 depends on the position @xmath74 and the orientation @xmath75 of the particles .
accordingly the number density is given by @xmath76 and @xmath77 is the orientational distribution function . in a homogeneously polarized bulk phase ( concerning influences from the sample shape
see below ) the number density @xmath78 is spatially constant and the orientational distribution function @xmath79 depends only on the angle @xmath80 , which measures the orientation of the dipole of a single particle relative to the field direction .
( here we do not consider electrostriction , i.e. , the dependence of @xmath78 on @xmath18 , because this contribution to @xmath81 is one order of magnitude smaller than the corresponding contribution of the orientational ordering of dipoles in the presence of an applied electric field @xcite ) .
the orientational distribution function can be obtained by minimizing the following grand canonical variational functional : @xmath82=f_{id}[\rho,\{\alpha(\theta)\},t]+\nonumber\\ f^{ex}_{dy}[\rho,\{\alpha(\theta)\},t]-\nonumber\\ \rho\int{d^3r}{d\omega}\alpha(\theta)(\mu+me\cos{\theta } ) , \label{gra}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath64 and @xmath83 are the ideal gas and the excess dipolar yukawa free energy density functionals , respectively , @xmath84 is the chemical potential , and @xmath18 is the internal electric field in the sample . in this theory
we assume that the volume of the fluid @xmath48 has the shape of a macroscopic prolate rotational ellipsoid ( elongated around the electric field direction ) so that the internal field strength @xmath18 is equal to the strength of the externally applied electric field @xmath85 ( see ref .
the excess dy free energy functional for an anisotropic system is not known .
however , it can be approximated by a functional taylor series , expanded around a homogeneous isotropic reference system with bulk number density @xmath78 . neglecting all terms beyond second order
, one has @xmath86={\beta}f^{ex}_{dy}(\rho , t)-\nonumber\\ \frac{\rho^2}{2}\int{d^3r_1}{d\omega_1}\int{d^3r_2}{d\omega_2 } \delta\alpha(\theta_1)\delta\alpha(\theta_2)\times\nonumber\\ c_{dy}(\mathbf{r}_{12},\omega_1,\omega_2 ) , \label{ser}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath87 is the difference between the actual anisotropic and the isotropic orientational distribution function and @xmath88 is the excess dipolar yukawa free energy for an isotropic distribution given by the last three terms in eq .
( [ fdyuk ] ) . using the msa direct correlation function of the dy fluid ( eq .
( [ cdy ] ) ) within this approximation the anisotropic excess free energy functional @xmath89 $ ] can be calculated analytically , which allows one to obtain @xmath90 by minimizing the grand canonical functional in eq .
( [ gra ] ) . from the orientational distribution function the polarization
@xmath91 ( the direction of which coincides with the direction of the external electric field ) can be obtained as @xmath92 based on the orientational distribution function @xmath90 eq .
( [ pola ] ) leads to the following polarization function : @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the well known langevin function @xcite .
this is an implicit equation for the external field dependence of the polarization .
the details of this calculation can be found in ref .
@xcite ( where the equivalent magnetic language was adopted , i.e. , the particles carry magnetic dipole moments and interact with an applied magnetic field ) . in order to obtain the nonlinear dielectric permittivity
@xmath11 the third order derivative of the polarization with respect to the maxwell field has to be calculated ( see eq .
( [ der3 ] ) ) . to this end
we introduce the following dimensionless form of eq .
( [ pol ] ) : @xmath95 where @xmath96 are the dimensionless polarization and electric field strength , respectively , and @xmath97 is a field independent parameter . from eq .
( [ main ] ) one obtains @xmath98 where @xmath99 .
the corresponding second order derivative is @xmath100 for the third order derivative one has @xmath101 since we consider thermodynamic states without spontaneous polarization ( see ref .
@xcite ) one has @xmath102 so that @xmath103 . with
@xmath104 one finds @xmath105 @xmath106 and @xmath107 equations ( [ ep0 ] ) , ( [ yp ] ) , and ( [ d01 ] ) render back the expression in eq . ( [ ep0msa ] ) for the linear dielectric permittivity . for the nonlinear dielectric permittivity eqs .
( [ der3 ] ) and ( [ d03 ] ) yield @xmath108 we note that for @xmath109 eq .
( [ main ] ) reduces to the langevin equation for non - interacting dipoles , @xmath110 while for @xmath111 one obtains the well known mean field debye - weiss polarization equation @xmath112 accordingly , for non - interacting dipoles ( i.e. , @xmath109 and @xmath113 ) one has for the linear and nonlinear dielectric permittivities @xmath114 respectively , and within the framework of the debye - weiss theory ( i.e. , @xmath111 and @xmath115 ) @xmath116 the latter equations show that not only the linear but also the nonlinear dielectric permittivity diverge for @xmath117 , which for a fixed value @xmath27 of the dipole moment provides the debye - weiss critical temperature @xmath118 of the isotropic liquid - ferroelectric liquid second - order phase transition . in the following these theoretical predictions will be compared with corresponding monte carlo simulation results .
we have performed monte carlo simulations for dy fluids using the canonical nvt ensemble and applying boltzmann sampling , periodic boundary conditions , and the minimum image convention @xcite . in order to take into account
the long - ranged character of the dipolar interaction the so - called reaction field ( rf ) method is used . according to this method we consider our system to be a macroscopic spherical sample composed of a number of replicas of the basic simulation cell embedded in a dielectric continuum with dielectric constant @xmath119 . in this case in the spherical sample the internal ( maxwell ) field @xmath1 is not equal to the external applied field @xmath4 , but @xcite @xmath120 for such a system , using the third order taylor series expansion of the polarization with respect to the external field , kusalik @xcite has shown that @xmath121e_0 ^ 2 , \label{enl}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath122 in eqs .
( [ enl ] ) and ( [ el ] ) @xmath123 is the total dipole moment of the system of volume @xmath48 , @xmath124 and @xmath125 , @xmath126 are the ensemble averages of the corresponding moments in zero external field . in our simulations
we apply a conducting boundary condition which means @xmath127 . in this limit eqs .
( [ nau ] ) , ( [ enl ] ) , and ( [ el ] ) for the internal field dependent dielectric permittivity lead to @xmath128 with @xmath129 comparing eq .
( [ nde ] ) with eq .
( [ lam ] ) for the nonlinear dielectric permittivity we obtain @xmath130 in our nvt ensemble mc simulations @xmath5 and @xmath11 are calculated from eqs .
( [ de ] ) and ( [ lam2 ] ) , respectively .
a spherical cutoff of the hard core dy pair potentials at half of the cubic box has been applied and long - ranged corrections ( lrc ) were taken into account @xcite . in our simulations @xmath131 particles have been used .
we have not resorted to any finite - size scaling analysis for detecting the occurrence of the isotropic - anisotropic phase transitions .
the simulations were started from a hcp lattice configuration with randomly oriented dipoles .
after 20.000 equilibration cycles , @xmath132 - @xmath133 production cycles were used .
statistical errors were calculated from the standard deviations of sub - averages containing @xmath134 cycles .
in the following we shall use reduced quantities : @xmath135 as the reduced temperature , @xmath136 as the reduced density , @xmath137 as the reduced dipole moment , and @xmath138 as the reduced nonlinear dielectric permittivity . concerning the range of the yukawa potential
, all our results correspond to @xmath139 .
figure 1 shows the linear and nonlinear dielectric permittivity as function of the reduced number density @xmath140 . for @xmath141 and @xmath142 the predictions of our msa theory ( see eqs .
( [ ep0msa])-([yp ] ) and ( [ lammsa ] ) ) and @xmath142 in comparison with the corresponding langevin and debye - weiss approximations .
the symbols in both figures represent our monte carlo simulation data whereas the lines are obtained from the three corresponding theories . in ( a ) the size of the error
bars is that of the symbols . within the debye - weiss theory
both @xmath5 and @xmath143 diverge at @xmath144 .
note that according to eqs .
( [ lamser ] ) and ( [ diff2 ] ) @xmath143 vanishes linearly for @xmath145 . ]
1.2 are compared with the langevin ( eq .
( [ la ] ) ) and debye - weiss ( eq . ( [ dw ] ) )
approximations and our mc data .
the langevin theory predicts , in general , a linear dependence of @xmath5 and @xmath11 on @xmath78 .
figure 1 shows that the interparticle interaction enhances @xmath5 and @xmath146 relative to the corresponding values of the langevin theory .
the debye - weiss theory overestimates the msa results for @xmath5 and @xmath146 .
the critical density , at which within the debye - weiss theory @xmath5 and @xmath11 diverge , is @xmath147 .
the behavior of @xmath5 and @xmath11 shown in fig . 1 for various approximations can be understood in terms of a low density expansion which amounts to an expansion in terms of @xmath148 which is proportional to @xmath78 ( see eq .
( [ yyy ] ) ) . within msa
the linear dielectric permittivity of the hard core dipolar yukawa fluid has the expansion @xcite @xmath149 from eqs .
( [ ep0msa ] ) , ( [ yp ] ) , and ( [ msaser ] ) one finds @xmath150 so that @xmath151 the corresponding expansions within the debye - weiss approximation are @xmath152 and @xmath153 equations ( [ diff1 ] ) and ( [ diff2 ] ) explain the trends of the various curves shown in fig .
1 . for the present choice of @xmath154 and @xmath155
the mc data and the msa results for the linear dielectric permittivity agree very well .
this agreement remains rather good also for the nonlinear dielectric permittivity .
we note that the very good agreement between the msa and the mc simulation data for the linear dielectric permittivity has also been reported in ref .
@xcite . .
within the debye - weiss theory both @xmath5 and @xmath143 diverge at @xmath156 . ]
1.5 as shown in fig .
2 , the increase of the reduced temperature from @xmath142 to @xmath157 does not change the character of the curves .
the msa results are in good agreement with the simulation data . with increasing temperature the discrepancy between the debye - weiss theory and the simulation data
is reduced because for higher temperatures the critical density , at which within the debye - weiss theory @xmath5 and @xmath11 diverge , is shifted to higher densities ( here @xmath158 ; we note that this value of the density is physically not accessible , because the corresponding packing fraction @xmath159 would be larger than 1 ) .
the absolute values of @xmath5 and @xmath11 are considerably reduced upon raising the temperature . .
within the debye - weiss theory both @xmath5 and @xmath143 diverge at @xmath160 . ]
1.5 figure 3 shows that upon increasing the dipole moment from @xmath141 to @xmath161 the agreement between the msa and the monte carlo simulation data does not change significantly .
however , the discrepancy between the debye - weiss theory and the simulation data has widened because due to the increase of the dipole moment the critical density , at which within the debye - weiss theory @xmath5 and @xmath11 diverge , is shifted to a lower value ( @xmath162 ) .
the langevin theory underestimates both @xmath5 and @xmath146 .
the increase of the dipole moment significantly increases @xmath5 and @xmath146 .
figure 4 shows that upon increasing the temperature from @xmath142 to @xmath157 at a fixed value @xmath161 of the dipole moment the agreement between the msa and the simulation data is improved and the values of @xmath5 and @xmath146 are significantly reduced .
the discrepancy between the debye - weiss theory and the simulation data is decreased because the critical density @xmath163 , at which @xmath5 and @xmath143 diverge according to the debye - weiss theory , is increased . .
within the debye - weiss theory both @xmath5 and @xmath143 diverge at @xmath144 . ]
1.5 from figs . 1 - 4 we conclude that for hard core dipolar yukawa fluids the msa describes the linear and nonlinear dielectric permittivities with an adequate accuracy up to liquid number densities @xmath164 ( note that freezing occurs at @xmath165 ; see ref .
@xcite for the related stockmayer system ) , while the langevin and the debye - weiss theory can be used only for @xmath166 and @xmath167 , respectively . within the framework of our msa theory and
in agreement with our mc simulation data we have obtained a negative nonlinear dielectric permittivity for hard core dipolar yukawa fluids .
we note that using a cluster expansion and the quadratic hypernetted chain ( qhnc ) approximation martina and stell @xcite obtained positive nonlinear dielectric permittivities for dipolar hard sphere fluids .
they tried to explain the positive sign in terms of electrostriction ( i.e. , the dependence of @xmath78 on @xmath18 ) which is included in their theory .
however , from an experimental point of view this explanation is unlikely because the effect of electrostriction is so weak @xcite that it can not overcompensate the contribution to @xmath81 of molecular orientations in the presence of an applied external field ( see ref .
@xcite ) . note that eq .
( [ lammsa ] ) as well as eq .
( [ ep0msa ] ) are also valid for dipolar hard spheres , which implies that within msa the dispersion forces do not influence the dielectric properties .
in the present study of the nonlinear dielectric effect for dipolar fluids the following main results have been obtained : + 1 ) we have applied an extension of the mean spherical approximation ( msa ) theory to determine the internal electric field dependence of the polarization for hard core dipolar yukawa fluids .
+ 2 ) from the electric field dependence of the polarization analytical equations have been obtained for the linear and the nonlinear dielectric permittivity of these dipolar fluids .
the predicted nonlinear dielectric permittivity is negative , which corresponds to the so - called normal saturation effect of dielectric media .
+ 3 ) canonical monte carlo simulations have been carried out for the determination of the linear and nonlinear dielectric permittivity of dipolar yukawa fluids .
there is good agreement between the results from the msa and the monte carlo simulation data for the reduced dipole moments @xmath168 studied here ( see figs . 1 - 4 ) .
+ 4 ) we have compared our theoretical results with the corresponding langevin and debye - weiss approximations .
the observed trends are in agreement with the low density behavior of the various approximations ( see eqs .
( [ diff1 ] ) and ( [ diff2 ] ) ) .
our new theoretical approach provides a quantitatively reliable description for the nonlinear dielectric permittivity .
this raises the expectation that actual experimental systems can be analyzed and understood along these lines
. it will be also interesting to detect model systems which exhibit anomalous dielectric saturation , i.e. , a positive nonlinear dielectric permittivity .
100 c.j.f .
bttcher and p. bordewijk , _ theory of electric polarization _
( elsevier , amsterdam , 1978 ) , vol . 1 . b. groh and s. dietrich , phys .
e * 53 * , 2509 ( 1996 ) .
s.j . rzoska and v.p .
zhelezny ( editors ) , _ nonlinear dielectric phenomena in complex liquids _ ( kluwer , london , 2004 ) , nato science series ii : mathematics , physics and chemistry , vol
j. herweg , z. phys .
* 3 * , 36 ( 1920 ) .
a. piekara , acta phys .
10 , 107 ( 1950 ) .
j. malecki , j. chem .
faraday trans . 2 * 72 * , 1214 ( 1976 ) .
i. szalai , m. lszl - parragi , and f. ratkovics , monatshefte fr chemie * 120 * , 413 ( 1989 ) .
m. gorny , j. ziolo , and s.j .
rzoska , rev .
* 67 * , 4290 ( 1996 ) .
khoo , phys .
reports * 471 * , 221 ( 2009 ) .
j. malecki , s. balanicka , and j. nowak , j. chem .
faraday trans . 2 * 76 * , 42 ( 1980 ) .
j. nowak and j. malecki , chem .
. lett . * 116 * , 55 ( 1985 ) .
rzoska , j. chrapec , and j. ziolo , int .
j. thermophys .
* 11 * , 1087 ( 1990 ) .
rzoska , phys .
e * 48 * , 1136 ( 1993 ) .
a. drozd - rzoska , s.j .
rzoska , and j. ziolo , phys .
e * 54 * , 6452 ( 1996 ) .
p. debye , z. phys .
* 36 * , 100 ( 1935 ) ; * 36 * , 193 ( 1935 ) .
l. onsager , j. am .
chem . soc . *
58 * , 1486 ( 1936 ) .
kirkwood , j. chem . phys .
* 7 * , 911 ( 1939 ) .
w.t . coffey and b.k.p .
scaife , proc .
irish acad .
* 76 * , 195 ( 1976 )
rasaiah , d.j .
isbister , and g. stell , j. chem . phys . * 75 * , 4707 ( 1981 ) .
e. martina and g. stell , phys .
a * 24 * , 2765 ( 1981 ) .
alper and r.m .
levy , j. phys .
* 94 * , 8401 ( 1990 ) .
c . yeh and m.l .
berkowitz , j. chem .
phys . * 110 * , 7935 ( 1999 ) .
f. booth , j. chem .
* 19 * , 391 ( 1951 ) . m. aguilella - arzo , a. andrio , v.m .
aguilella , and a. alcaraz , phys .
phys . * 11 * , 358 ( 2009 ) .
fulton , j. chem .
phys . * 130 * , 204503 ( 2009 ) .
f. booth , j. chem .
* 23 * , 453 ( 1955 ) .
i. szalai and s. dietrich , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 3 * , 111 ( 2008 ) .
h. kitamura and a. onuki , j. chem .
phys . * 123 * , 124513 ( 2005 ) .
a. onuki and h. kitamura , j. chem . phys . *
121 * , 3143 ( 2004 ) .
hansen and i.r .
mcdonald , _ theory of simple liquids _
( elsevier , amsterdam , 2005 ) .
wertheim , j. chem .
phys . * 55 * , 4291 ( 1971 ) .
e. waisman , mol . phys . *
25 * , 45 ( 1973 ) .
d. henderson , d. boda , i. szalai , and k .- y .
chan , j. chem .
* 110 * , 7348 ( 1999 ) .
i. szalai , d. henderson , d. boda , and k .- y .
chan , j. chem .
phys . * 111 * , 337 ( 1999 ) . c. hausleitner and j. hafner , j. phys .
phys . * 18 * , 1013 ( 1988 ) .
t. krupkowski , g.p .
jones , and m. davies , j. chem .
, faraday trans . 2 * 70 * , 1348 ( 1974 ) .
allen and d.j .
tildesley , _ computer simulation of liquids _
( clarendon , oxford , 2001 ) .
m. neumann , mol .
* 50 * , 841 ( 1983 ) .
kusalik , mol . phys . * 81 * , 199 ( 1994 ) . s. klapp and f. forstmann , europhys
. lett . * 38 * , 663 ( 1997 ) . | the nonlinear dielectric effect for dipolar fluids is studied within the framework of the mean spherical approximation ( msa ) of hard core dipolar yukawa fluids . based on earlier results for the electric field dependence of the polarization
our analytical results show so - called normal saturation effects which are in good agreement with corresponding nvt ensemble monte carlo simulation data . the linear and the nonlinear dielectric permittivities obtained from mc simulations are determined from the fluctuations of the total dipole moment of the system in the absence of an applied electric field .
we compare the msa based theoretical results with the corresponding langevin and debye - weiss behaviors . |
determining the indistinguishability based on the experimental data is achieved using the canonical functions for two - photon interference ( tpi ) @xcite , assuming 50% reflection and transmission at both beamsplitters : @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the exciton fluorescence lifetime , @xmath73 is the fibre delay in the mach - zehnder interferometer , @xmath74 is the visibility and @xmath75 is the photon coherence time .
these functions are then convolved with the set - up instrument response function ( irf ) , which is determined to be well approximated by a gaussian peak with full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of 750 ps .
this yields an analytical expression for the convolved function in terms of real physical parameters .
we use this convolved function to fit the raw data , and the deconvolved fit can be plotted by using these parameters extracted from the fit in eqs .
( [ eq : g2]-[eq : para ] ) .
@xmath72 is extracted from a fit to the second order coherence function using @xmath10 , and is then used as a fixed parameter in the tpi fitting . in the convolved tpi data , there is a certain amount of ambiguity between the effects of visibility and coherence time on raw dip depth that determines the photon indistinguishability .
as photons become more distinguishable , @xmath74 drops from 1 to 0 for perfectly distinguishable photons ( e.g. photons with perpendicular polarisations , photons with very different energies ) , which reduces the depth of the central dip for @xmath76 even after deconvolution .
however , when the interacting photons are indistinguishable but have very short coherence times , the width of the central dip for @xmath76 from 50% to 0 will significantly narrow . in this case
the experiment is more strongly affected by the system irf @xcite .
this raises the question whether a dip depth above zero in the raw data is an effect of photon distinguishability or very short coherence time .
[ fig : s1 ] demonstrates this ambiguity .
in this manuscript , near ideal transform limited linewidths are observed in the high resolution spectra . in the case of @xmath6
, we show the non - ideal behaviour is due to raman scattering at energies detuned from the central transform limited peak in the spectra .
we therefore assume this is the origin of the reduced raw ( experimental ) tpi visibility , rather than reduced coherence or pure dephasing . as observed in fig . 3
, spin pumping in the 4-level system leads to bunching in @xmath10 and tpi plots .
this is captured in the fitting process by replacing the @xmath10 expression given by eq .
( [ eq : g2 ] ) in eqs .
( [ eq : cross ] ) and ( [ eq : para ] ) with an exponential dip multiplied by an exponential peak with background 1 and a longer decay time @xmath77 : @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the amplitude of the bunching . in fig . 3 , this yields @xmath80 and @xmath81 ns .
the electron and hole wavefunctions of self - assembled iii - v quantum dots ( qd ) extend over a large number of spin bearing nuclei .
the nuclear spins generate an effective magnetic field , called the overhauser field , that couple with the spins via the hyperfine interaction and can lead to relaxation and dephasing . in the context of the low temperature experiments performed in this manuscript ,
the `` frozen - fluctuation model '' @xcite , in which the nuclear spins are considered to be stationary for a timescale ( @xmath2 1 @xmath49s ) much greater than the optical transition lifetime ( @xmath2 1 ns ) , is most relevant for self - assembled quantum dots @xcite . in this picture , the electron spin precesses around the hyperfine field on a ns timescale .
here we are interested in changes to the energy levels and selection rules caused by the random overhauser field orientation . in particular , we develop a theoretical model for predicting the resonance fluorescence spectrum of the photons scattered from the x@xmath82 transition of the qd . our model features four levels , two of those representing the electron spin of the qd s ground state , and the other two the unpaired ( heavy ) hole spin states of the first excited state .
we let the electron spin levels be zeeman split by the total magnetic field , i.e. the sum of the externally applied field @xmath83 plus the effective overhauser contribution @xmath84 ( in the frozen fluctuation regime ) .
by contrast , we assume the hole spin only ` sees ' the external field that is applied along the @xmath85-direction .
( due to the reduced hole bloch functions at the nuclear positions , the hyperfine interaction coupling coefficient between a hole and nuclear spins is only @xmath2 10 % that of the electron spin coupling coefficient @xcite .
further , the hyperfine interaction for an ideal heavy hole takes on an ising - like form such that heavy hole spin dephasing is greatly suppressed by an in - plane magnetic field @xcite ) .
as the basis for our model we adopt the zeeman eigenstates of both electron and hole ( but with respect to different magnetic fields as discussed above ) , see fig .
[ fig : levels_overhauser ] for a schematic depiction of the relevant level structure . writing the total magnetic field
@xmath86 as @xmath87\ ] ] the electron spin zeeman ( @xmath88 ) eigenstates are @xmath89 denoting the trion states with hole spin ( anti)parallel to the @xmath85-direction as @xmath90,@xcite we obtain the following optical dipole transition matrix elements : @xmath91 where @xmath92 refers to the two possible circular polarisation states . including the dependence of the selection rules on the magnetic field direction and under a rotating wave approximation , the system hamiltonian
is then given by where @xmath94 denotes the hermitian conjugate , @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath17 is the optical rabi frequency and @xmath38 the laser detuning from the qd transition in the absence of any magnetic field , and @xmath97 is a unit vector in the direction of the polarization of the driving laser field .
the selection rules eqs .
( [ eq : sel1]-[eq : sel4 ] ) also imply spontaneous emission decay channels with polar angle @xmath98 dependence as follows @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the inverse lifetime of the qd . these processes are depicted schematically in fig .
[ fig : levels_overhauser ] .
further , we define a lowering operator for each circular polarisation @xmath101 using these equations , we can obtain the temporal evolution of the density matrix , given by numerically integrating the master equation @xmath102+l(\sigma^{(\uparrow)}_-)\rho + l(\sigma^{(\downarrow)}_-)\rho ~,\ ] ] where @xmath103 is the standard lindbladian dissipator@xcite .
we proceed to calculate the first - order correlation function @xmath104 , which will give us access to the fluorescence spectrum of the photons scattered by this four - level system . in our case
we have ( due to the two orthogonal polarisations ) @xmath105 the fluorescence spectrum is independent of both the azimuthal angle @xmath106 and the polarisation angle for a linearly polarised driving field .
it is calculated by taking the real part of the fourier transform of the first - order correlation function .
for all results presented below , the @xmath107-peaks of elastically scattered photons and the raman transitions are artificially broadened by making the expected number of photons equal to the area of a lorentzian curve of width @xmath108 mhz , corresponding to the resolution of the fabry - perot interferometer used in the experiments .
the ( elastically ) scattered rayleigh peak is present for any orientation of the magnetic field , but its intensity depends on @xmath98 . in faraday geometry ( @xmath109 ) , there is no raman transition and the elastic peak is accompanied by two detuned side peaks at @xmath110 which possess a width limited by the decay rate of the optical transition [ fig .
[ fig : of_single_spec_gf=0 ] ( a ) ] .
the relative amplitudes of the central to detuned peaks is determined by the rabi frequency .
when the magnetic field is between the faraday and the voigt geometry , the relative weight of the two vertical transitions decreases whilst the two diagonal transitions become allowed .
this gives rise to two raman transitions [ fig .
[ fig : of_single_spec_gf=0 ] ( b ) ] .
these appear as @xmath107-peaks , but have here been broadened by the detector resolution . in the voigt geometry ( @xmath111 )
, all four transitions have equal weight , thus maximising the intensity of the raman transitions , which now account for @xmath112 of the total number of scattered photons [ fig .
[ fig : of_single_spec_gf=0 ] ( c ) ] . to reproduce the long time measurements ,
it is necessary to average several spectra with different instantaneous nuclear fields @xmath113 . considering that the overhauser field has no preferential direction
, we will realise @xmath114 ( as required ) upon performing uniform averaging over the solid angle .
it remains to specify a radial distribution of @xmath84 to represent the magnitudes of the instantaneous overhauser fields .
we consider the case of a normal distribution with generally finite mean @xmath115 and variance @xmath116 . for @xmath117
the difference between the energy of the raman scattered and the rayleigh photons is typically small , and consequently the average over the raman peaks yields a single gaussian envelope of width proportional to @xmath116 [ fig . [
fig : of_noise_spec_gf=0 ] ( a ) ] .
by contrast a finite mean @xmath118 separates the rayleigh from the raman peaks , leading to two shifted gaussian raman envelopes either side of the central elastic peak [ fig .
[ fig : of_noise_spec_gf=0 ] ( b ) ] .
this latter case gives very close agreement with our measured spectra shown in the main text [ see also fig . [
fig : of_noise_spec_gf=0 ] ( c ) ] . | a semiconductor quantum dot can generate highly coherent and indistinguishable single photons .
however , intrinsic semiconductor dephasing mechanisms can reduce the visibility of two - photon interference . for an electron in a quantum dot , a fundamental dephasing process is the hyperfine interaction with the nuclear spin bath . here
we directly probe the consequence of the fluctuating nuclear spins on the elastic and inelastic scattered photon spectra from a resident electron in a single dot .
we find the nuclear spin fluctuations lead to detuned raman scattered photons which are distinguishable from both the elastic and incoherent components of the resonance fluorescence .
this significantly reduces two - photon interference visibility . however , we demonstrate successful screening of the nuclear spin noise which enables the generation of coherent single photons that exhibit high visibility two - photon interference .
indistinguishable single photons are an essential resource for quantum photonic logic gates and networking @xcite . among the various approaches to generate identical light quanta , resonance fluorescence ( rf ) from a semiconductor quantum dot ( qd )
@xcite is one of the most promising for practical technological implementation .
the rf spectrum is composed of elastic and inelastic scattered light @xcite .
the elastic or rayleigh scattered light , first measured in homodyne absorption experiments on a qd @xcite , has the first order coherence properties of the laser but the second order coherence properties of the emitter @xcite .
this light , which can be imprinted with an arbitrary phase or temporal profile @xcite , is fundamentally indistinguishable .
rf can therefore relax the requirement for a perfectly stable , transform - limited optical transition that is difficult to realize in the solid - state .
in particular , compared to non - resonant excitation followed by spontaneous emission , rf helps overcome the relatively slow spectral fluctuations caused by charge noise in the qd environment @xcite .
in addition to the elastic and incoherent components of rf , near resonant excitation can lead to raman scattering into another ground state .
raman scattering from a qd with a resident electron or hole can have several attractive features .
first , below saturation , the coherence of the raman photons is determined by the ground state dephasing rather than that of the excited state @xcite .
second , raman photons are highly tunable : their energy is determined by the detuning of the driving field rather than the fundamental optical transition energy @xcite . finally , due to clean selection rules in a qd , the polarization of the raman scattered photons can be linked to the spin of the final state @xcite , enabling spin - photon entanglement @xcite and raising the prospect for quantum networks @xcite . typically , spin - flip raman photons are generated using an in - plane external magnetic field ( @xmath0 ) to mix the spin states @xcite .
a iii - v qd also contains an intrinsic effective magnetic field , the overhauser field ( @xmath1 ) , due to coupling of the qd s constituent atoms nuclear spins with the electron spin via the contact part of the hyperfine interaction .
incomplete cancellation of the finite random nuclear spin orientations leads to an effective field @xmath1 @xmath2 10 - 30 mt that fluctuates on a @xmath3 s timescale @xcite .
the electron spin precession around @xmath1 leads to ensemble dephasing on ns timescales @xcite .
the fluctuating arbitrary orientation of @xmath1 also leads to an almost always present in - plane component @xmath4 which affects the optical properties of a quantum dot .
kuhlmann _
et al .
_ have investigated the role of nuclear spin noise on the neutral ( @xmath5 ) and negatively charged ( @xmath6 ) states of a qd @xcite while hansom _
et al . _
recently exploited @xmath4 to achieve coherent control and two - color coherent population trapping with @xmath6 @xcite . here
we report new insights on the effect of @xmath4 on the rf spectrum of a single qd and its consequences on indistinguishable photon generation .
we find spin - mixing causes raman scattered photons clearly distinguishable from the elastic spectrum that reduce the visibility ( @xmath7 ) of two - photon interference ( tpi ) for @xmath6 .
we demonstrate successful screening of @xmath4 for both @xmath5 and @xmath6 via either an effective magnetic field due to exchange interaction ( @xmath8 ) or a perpendicular external magnetic field ( @xmath9 ) , respectively . in each case
, the spectra exhibit near ideal two - level behaviour and ultra - high visibility tpi is achieved .
the self - assembled ingaas qds studied in this work were embedded in a gaas schottky diode for deterministic charge state control .
numerous qds from two samples at t = 4k were investigated providing consistent results .
sample 1 , previously used in ref . , yields @xmath2 350 khz from a single qd on a single photon detector at saturation in cw rf . sample 2 has the identical schottky diode design but the qds are positioned at an anti - node of a fifth - order planar cavity on top of a au layer which functions both as a mirror and schottky gate .
sample 2 yields @xmath2 10 times higher count rates due to the planar cavity design @xcite .
the rf , obtained using orthogonal linear polarizers in the excitation and collection arms of a confocal microscope @xcite , is characterized by three techniques : high - resolution ( 27 mhz ) spectroscopy using a fabry - perot interferometer ( 5.5 ghz free spectral range ) , a hanbury - brown and twiss interferometer to measure @xmath10 , and an unbalanced mach - zender ( mz ) interferometer ( @xmath11 ns ) with polarization control in each arm to measure post - selected , two - photon interference @xcite . in the mz setup ,
the beamsplitters have nearly perfect 50:50 reflection : transmission .
for tpi experiments , a grating ( bandwidth @xmath12 ghz ) is used to spectrally filter the zero - phonon line from the majority of the phonon sideband .
( a ) high resolution spectra as a function of laser detuning @xmath13 demonstrate the central and sidebands are dependent on the laser energy .
( b ) the integrated intensity of the detuned spectra reveal a lorentzian lineshape ( red curve ) .
( c ) a simulated spectrum based on the 4-level model including @xmath1 ( black curve ) fit to the experimental data ( black points ) for @xmath14 .
the green line represents elastically scattered photons .
the red and blue lines represent the red- and blue - detuned raman photons as shown in the level diagrams for two different @xmath4 values .
( d ) : level diagrams for two different values of @xmath15 . for constant excitation energy , changes in @xmath15
changes the splitting of the raman transitions from the laser : fluctuations in the overhauser field therefore result in broadened raman sidebands.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] figure [ fig1 ] reveals our main spectroscopic result . here
, we compare the resonantly scattered zero - phonon photon spectra from three scenarios : @xmath5 and @xmath6 with @xmath16 , and @xmath6 with @xmath9 = 0.6 t. the spectra are recorded over a range of rabi frequencies ( @xmath17 ) , from @xmath18 where coherent scattering dominates to @xmath19 where incoherent emission dominates . here
the saturation parameter @xmath20 is given by @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the lifetime and @xmath23 the dephasing time .
fig .
[ fig1 ] ( c ) shows that near ideal elastic and inelastic spectra are observed for @xmath5 , although for @xmath19 the sidebands of the mollow triplet are slightly broadened from mollow s theory due to a modest amount of slow spectral fluctuations ( which do not lead to pure dephasing ) @xcite .
the central incoherent lorentzian linewidth is measured as @xmath24 mhz ( fwhm ) , closely matching the fourier transform limit of the measured @xmath22 value of @xmath25 ps .
crucially , when the population of the excited state is minimal ( @xmath18 ) , the elastic component dominates the @xmath5 spectrum confirming minimal pure dephasing . in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( b ) we plot the ratio of the elastic component to the total spectrum ( er ) . the solid line is a fit given by @xcite : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the ensemble dephasing time obtained in time - averaged spectra . by fitting the complete data set we can determine the only unknown parameter , @xmath27 , accurately and we find @xmath28 ns for @xmath5 .
the spectra for @xmath6 with @xmath16 in fig .
[ fig1](b ) deviate significantly from the near ideal two - level behaviour exhibited by @xmath5 .
all @xmath6 spectra show a reduced elastically scattered component compared to @xmath5 . additionally , a doublet surrounding the elastic peak is clearly evident . for @xmath18 ,
the doublet is separated by @xmath29 190 mhz and each peak in the doublet has a linewidth of @xmath29 210 mhz .
fig .
[ fig1](b ) shows that the er saturates at only @xmath30 and the fit yields @xmath31 ns .
however , the near ideal two - level behaviour can be recovered with a modest magnetic field in the growth direction , as shown in fig .
[ fig1](e ) for @xmath32 t . based on the fit to the er , @xmath33 ns . second - order correlation measurements on the zeeman - split @xmath6 transitions at @xmath34 t and @xmath35 .
single laser excitation of the ( a ) blue- and ( b ) red - shifted lines show bunching around @xmath36 with decay time @xmath37 ns .
simultaneous two - laser excitation ( c ) shows suppressed bunching , demonstrating that its origin is spin pumping.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] to investigate the origin of the sidebands for @xmath6 , we characterize the rf spectrum as a function of laser detuning @xmath38 for @xmath18 . here
we observe that the entire spectrum follows @xmath38 ( fig .
[ fig2](a ) ) , and the integrated intensity of the spectrum exhibits a lorentzian lineshape with a linewidth of @xmath2 850 mhz ( fig .
[ fig2](b ) ) .
this observation eliminates the possible presence of incoherent emission in the spectrum , which is independent of laser detuning .
we therefore identify the central peak as the elastic component and the doublet as spin - flip raman scattering .
a schematic of the effect is shown in fig . [
fig2](d ) , in which we depict the four - level system for two values of the @xmath4 component which split the ground - state electron spin states .
we assume degenerate excited states as the hyperfine interaction for hole spins is significantly reduced compared to the electron for @xmath4 @xcite .
the solid green arrows represent the driving field on resonance with the unperturbed ( e.g. @xmath4 = 0 ) transitions .
this driving field determines the elastic scattering spectrum .
the red and blue dashed lines represent red- and blue - raman scattering detuned by @xmath39 .
the linewidth of these photons is inversely proportional to the incoherent spin - flip time .
the experimental measurement time of a few minutes for each spectrum signifies a time - averaged measurement of @xmath40 orientations of @xmath1 , effectively broadening the observed raman side - bands according to the variance @xmath41 .
notably , we also observe qds which exhibit sidebands with smaller detuning than in figure 2(a ) that can be caused by either reduced @xmath1 or @xmath42 .
further details on numerical simulations of the resonantly scattered power spectrum based on the optical bloch equations of the 4-level system with a linearly polarized driving field are provided in the supplemental information .
numerical simulations to fit the experimental spectra yield a mean energy of @xmath43 = @xmath44 mhz , with a standard deviation @xmath45 of @xmath46 mhz .
the black curve in figure [ fig2 ] ( c ) shows this simulation . assuming a typical isotropic electron g - factor of -0.6 corresponds to a mean overhauser field @xmath1 = @xmath47 mt and @xmath48 mt .
as the overhauser field is ubiquitous in iii - v qds , the spectra from both @xmath6 with modest @xmath9 and @xmath5 demonstrate successful screening of the nuclear spin fluctuations . in the case of @xmath5 , the exchange interaction ( @xmath8 )
generates a fine - structure splitting of @xmath2 10 @xmath49ev , much larger than @xmath50 @xmath49ev . in the case of @xmath51 for @xmath6
, @xmath9 stabilizes the electron spin which then precesses around @xmath52 @xcite .
this significantly reduces the branching ratio for spin - flip scattering , which can be estimated by @xmath53 @xcite .
hence , the nuclear spin fluctuations are effectively screened and raman scattered photons are not visible in the spectra of fig .
[ fig1](e ) . as a precursor to tpi experiments ,
we first investigate the effect of @xmath1 on the second - order coherence ( @xmath10 ) .
fig .
[ fig4](a ) shows the auto - correlation from @xmath5 with a raw value of @xmath54 , limited by detector jitter . upon deconvolution of the detector response , @xmath55 . for @xmath6 , while near ideal anti - bunching is again demonstrated , significant bunching around the @xmath56 = 0 dip is observed at @xmath57 t ( see fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a)-(b ) ) due to optical spin pumping caused by electron spin mixing @xcite .
the bunching amplitude is determined by the spin pumping fidelity and the decay of the bunching is determined by the spin - relaxation dynamics .
a two - color excitation scheme can be used to frustrate the spin pumping mechanism , which unambiguously demonstrates that the nature of the bunching is spin initialization ( fig .
[ fig3](c ) ) .
although we have observed small bunching amplitudes even at @xmath16 for a few qds , typically it is negligible for on resonance driving as in fig .
[ fig4 ] ( b ) .
the canonical test for photon indistinguishability is two - photon interference , and the visibility is defined as @xmath58/g^2_{\perp}(0)$ ] , where @xmath59 and @xmath60 use orthogonal and parallel linear polarizations , respectively , in the two mz arms .
tpi measurements from @xmath61 at @xmath35 ( fig .
[ fig4](a ) ) reveal near perfect photon indistinguishability , with a deconvolved ( raw ) fit value of @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) .
this impressive result is expected based on the near - ideal high - resolution spectrum , confirming that @xmath8 screens @xmath1 for @xmath5 . in contrast , the same measurement on the @xmath6 with @xmath16 t ( fig .
[ fig4](b ) ) shows reduced @xmath7 : a deconvolved ( raw ) fit value of @xmath64 ( @xmath65 ) is measured .
nevertheless , a high degree of indistinguishability is still observed , somewhat surprising considering the spectra in fig .
[ fig1](d ) .
however , in the frozen - fluctuation model , @xmath1 is static within the @xmath11 ns , signifying that only one spin - flip raman transition energy is relevant for tpi . in other words ,
only narrowband raman photons will accompany the elastic and modest incoherent components of the rf spectrum over this timescale at @xmath66 . finally , applying @xmath34 t to screen the ground state electron from the nuclear field fluctuations recovers high visibility tpi with a deconvolved ( raw ) fit value of @xmath67 ( @xmath68)(see fig .
[ fig4](c ) ) .
this near perfect indistinguishability meets the expectation based on the spectra in fig .
[ fig1](e ) . in summary
, we have characterized the effect of nuclear field fluctuations on the rf spectrum and photon indistinguishability from @xmath61 and @xmath6 in self - assembled ingaas qds . for the @xmath61 , the large @xmath8 relative to @xmath1
suppresses the effect of nuclear field fluctuations even at @xmath16 t. for a qd with a resident electron in the ground state , the rf spectrum exhibits an inelastic doublet due to spin - flip raman scattering which reduces the tpi visibility .
application of @xmath69 screens the electron spin from @xmath4 , drastically decreasing the rate of raman scattering and recovering near - ideal indistinguishability .
an interesting prospect would be to investigate the positively charged exciton @xmath70 , for which the ground hole spin states can be more robust against nuclear spin noise at @xmath16 .
this work was supported by the epsrc ( grant numbers ep / i023186/1 , ep / k015338/1 , and ep / g03673x/1 ) and an erc starting grant ( number 307392 ) .
bdg thanks the royal society and emg thanks the royal society of edinburgh for personal research fellowships . 100 j. l. obrien , a. furusawa , and j. vukovi * 3 * , 687 ( 2009 ) .
s. ates _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 103 * , 167402 ( 2009 ) . c. matthiesen _
et al _ , nat . comms . * 4 * , 1600 ( 2013 ) .
y .- m .
he _
et al _ , nat
. nanotechno .
* 8 * , 213 ( 2013 ) .
l. monniell _
et al _ , phys . rev .
b * 90 * , 041303(r ) ( 2014 ) .
r. proux _ et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 114 * , 067401 ( 2015 ) .
b. r. mollow , phys . rev . * 188 * , 1969 ( 1969 ) . h.s .
nguyen _
et al _ , appl .
. lett . * 99 * , 261904 ( 2011 ) . c. matthiesen , a. n. vamivakus , and m. atature , phys .
rev .
lett . * 108 * , 093602 ( 2012 ) .
k. konthasinghe _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
b * 85 * , 235315 ( 2012 ) . a. hgele _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 93 * , 217401 ( 2004 ) .
r. loudon , oxford university press , oxford ( 2000 ) .
a. v. kuhlmann _ et al _ , nat . phys .
* 9 * , 570 ( 2013 ) .
g. fernandez _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 103 * , 087406 ( 2009 ) . c. santori
_ et al _ , new j. phys .
* 11 * , 123009 ( 2009 ) .
y. he _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 111 * , 237403 ( 2013 ) . t. m. sweeney _
et al _ , nat
. phot .
* 8 * , 442 ( 2014 ) .
s. t. yilmaz , p. fallahi , and a. imamolu , phys .
rev .
lett . * 105 * , 033601 ( 2010 ) .
k. de greve _ et al _ , nature * 491 * , 421 ( 2012 ) .
w. b. gao , p. fallahi , j. miguel - sanchez , and a. imamolu , nature * 491 * , 426 ( 2012 ) .
j. r. schaibley _ et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 110 * , 167401 ( 2013 ) .
a. delteil _
et al _ , arxiv:1507.00465v2 ( 2015 ) .
x. xu _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 99 * , 097401 ( 2007 ) .
i. a. merkulov , a. l. efros , and m. rosen , phys .
rev .
b * 65 * , 205309 ( 2002 ) . b. urbaszek _
et al _ , rev .
mod .
phys .
* 85 * , 79 ( 2013 ) .
p .- f .
braun _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 94 * , 116601 ( 2005 ) . a. v. kuhlmann _ et al _ , nat comms . * 6 * , 8204 ( 2015 ) .
j. hansom _
et al _ , nat .
phys .
* 10 * , 725 ( 2014 ) .
b. d. gerardot _ et al _ , appl .
phys .
lett . * 90 * , 221106 ( 2007 ) .
y. ma , p. e. kremer , and b. d. gerardot , j. appl .
phys . * 115 * , 023106 ( 2014 ) .
a. muller _ et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . * 99 * , 187402 ( 2007 ) .
j. fischer , w. a. coish , d. v. bulaev , and d. loss , phys .
rev .
b * 78 * , 155329 ( 2008 ) . j. houel _
et al _ , phys .
rev .
lett . *
112 * , 107401 ( 2014 ) .
j. dreiser _ et al _ , phys .
rev .
b * 77 * , 075317 ( 2008 ) . |
in several machine development ( md ) studies ( see ref . @xcite and the references therein ) , reduced crossing angles have been used to enhance long - range beam beam effects and thus facilitate their measurement .
the basic assumption made in this paper is that under such conditions , a single non - linearity , the one caused by beam beam , dominates the dynamics .
hence the method followed : we choose some simple low - order dynamical quantity that characterizes phase space distortion and assume that when this quantity is the same , the behaviour of the system is the same .
a most obvious candidate is the first - order smear
the r.m.s .
deviation of the phase - space ellipse from the perfect one . at a fixed amplitude
, smear is defined as the averaged generalized courant
snyder invariant over the angle variable @xcite .
an analytical expression has previously been found @xcite for the smear @xmath0 as a function of amplitude @xmath1 .
suppose that the parametric dependence of @xmath2 on several beam beam related parameters the relativistic @xmath3 , the number of particles per bunch @xmath4 , the crossing angle @xmath5 , and the normalized separations @xmath6 is known . according to the above assumption , for two machine configurations _ a _ and _ b _ one should have @xmath7 as a particular application of eq .
( 1 ) , we considered two experiments where the intensities are @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
all other parameters being the same , given @xmath10 , one can compute the expected @xmath11 .
our task will be to show that the result agrees with observations .
our derivation of @xmath12 is based on the lie algebraic method
concatenation of lie - factor maps and is valid only to first order in the beam beam parameter and in one - dimension , in either the horizontal or the vertical plane , but for an arbitrary distribution of beam beam collisions , head - on or long - range , around the ring . for a ring with a _
single head - on collision point _ ,
hamiltonian perturbation analysis of the beam
beam interaction without or with a crossing angle has been done by a number of authors , mostly in the resonant case .
non - linear invariants of motion , both non - resonant and resonant , were analysed by dragt @xcite , with the one - turn map as observed immediately after the kick being l3 cm @xmath13 here , @xmath14 is the linear one - turn map and the kick factor @xmath15 is the beam beam potential ( or hamiltonian ) . for small perturbations and far from resonances , particle coordinates in phase space are restricted on the poincar surface of section @xmath16 a detailed derivation of @xmath17 to first order in the beam beam perturbation strength can be found in a. chao s lectures : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the ring phase advance and @xmath20 are coefficients in the fourier expansion of @xmath15 , when the latter is rewritten in action - angle coordinates @xmath21 .
the coefficients are shown to be related to the modified bessel functions .
analytical expressions for the invariant @xmath17 , the first - order smear , and the second - order detuning for the case of non - linear multipole kicks distributed in an arbitrary way around the ring have been derived by irvin and bengtsson @xcite .
smear , the distortion of the ideal phase - space ellipse , is formally defined in ref .
finally , note that extracting the smear is a natural step in the procedure that brings the map into its normal form @xcite . in ref .
@xcite , following the lie algebraic procedure in refs . @xcite and @xcite , we generalized eq .
( [ hafi ] ) to describe multiple head - on kicks ( ip1 and ip5 ) for the case of the lhc . in ref .
@xcite , an expression was presented that was valid for an arbitrary number of head - on ( h.o . ) and long - range ( l.r . )
this expression , to be derived in detail next , has been used on several occasions to interpret results from sixtrack simulations .
the horizontal betatronic motion of a weak - beam test particle depends on its initial amplitude @xmath1 ( in units of @xmath22 ) and the collision set : a set of all h.o . and l.r .
collisions , also known as interaction points ( ips ) , that this particle sees over a single revolution .
let us label the set with an index @xmath23 , limiting ourselves to only ips located within the main interaction regions ir5 ( horizontal crossing ) and ir1 ( vertical crossing ) . in the case of 50 ns
bunch spacing , @xmath23 ranges from 1 to 34 , which includes 32 long - range ips ( @xmath24 ) .
the lie map depends on the above - defined collision set through the normalized separations @xmath25 and the unperturbed horizontal betatronic phases @xmath26 at the ips . here
, @xmath27 is the real - space offset of the strong - beam centroid in the @xmath28 or @xmath29 direction , and it has been assumed that both the weak- and strong - beam transverse distributions are round gaussians of the same r.m.s . that is : @xmath30 in eq .
( [ round ] ) , @xmath31 are the beta functions and @xmath32 is the emittance
. it will be shown below that off - plane collisions contribute very little to smear ; thus after excluding these , the problem becomes one - dimensional and may easily be illustrated ( see fig . [ nxset ] ) . here , @xmath33 are the strong - beam centroids in amplitude space : points @xmath34 , with @xmath35 being the distance to ip5 in metres .
( @xmath36 ) . ] for a single collision ( see eq .
( [ oneip ] ) ) , by omitting the superscript @xmath23 in @xmath22 and @xmath37 , the @xmath28-motion is described by a kick factor @xmath15 ( or hamiltonian @xmath38 ) @xcite : @xmath39 @xmath40\,,{\nonumber}\label{p1}\ ] ] where @xmath15 is in units of @xmath41 , @xmath42 is the classical particle radius , @xmath43 denotes the upper incomplete gamma function @xcite , and @xmath44 = 0.577216 is euler s constant . the corresponding beam
beam kick is as follows : @xmath45 .
\label{kick}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the fourier expansion of @xmath38 is as follows : @xmath46 where @xmath47 .
these coefficients are easily computed numerically by using the implementation of @xmath48 in _ mathematica _ @xcite .
further , analytical expressions in the form of single integrals over bessel functions have been derived in ref .
we display these again in the simplified case @xmath49 ( no off - plane collisions ) : @xmath50 & \\
\mbox{if } m=0 \mbox { \ \
and}\\ \displaystyle -\mathrm{e}^{-\frac { t } { 2}n_x^2 } \mathrm{e}^{-\frac{t}{4 } { n_{\sigma}}^2 } \sum_{k=-\infty}^{\infty } i^{m } i_{m-2k}(t\ , { n_{\sigma}}n_x ) i_{k}(-\frac { t}{4 } { n_{\sigma}}^2 ) & \\ \mbox{if } m \neq 0 . \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the head - on case ( @xmath51 ) , the coefficients @xmath52 reduce to the @xmath53 from ref .
note that in the most interesting case , amplitudes near the dynamic aperture , both @xmath1 and @xmath54 and hence the bessel function arguments are large ( @xmath55 ) . our first step is to remove the linear and quadratic parts @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the non - linear kick factor and the corresponding kick are as follows : @xmath58 as a next step , we rewrite eq .
( [ hnon ] ) in action - angle coordinates @xmath59 by substituting in it @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the test particle amplitude ( eq .
( a.1 ) ) .
next , we expand in fourier series : @xmath62 the coefficients @xmath63 are naturally the same as @xmath52 above , with the exception of @xmath64 and @xmath65 , which contain additional @xmath66 and @xmath67 terms ( see eq .
( a.1 ) ) . for an arbitrary set of collisions @xmath68 , @xmath26 ( @xmath69 ) ,
we represent the lhc lattice by a combination of linear elements and non - linear kicks .
it is shown in the appendix that , to first order in @xmath70 , the lie map has the same form as the one for a single kick ( [ oneip ] ) where , however , the factor @xmath15 is given by the sum @xmath71 and @xmath72 are such that , compared to eq .
( [ coef1 ] ) , the @xmath23th ip participates with a phase shifted by @xmath26 : @xmath73 the shift in phase means that the coefficients in eq .
( [ ftilde ] ) are simply related to @xmath74 : @xmath75 and still satisfy @xmath76 .
another important property of the expansion is that only the oscillating part is taken ( the @xmath77 term is excluded ) .
the invariant for multiple collision points is as follows ( see the appendix ) : @xmath78 the surface of the section in phase space is given by @xmath79 .
a natural initial condition is now imposed : that the initial point in phase space for a particle starting at @xmath80 that is , with an amplitude @xmath81 lies on the curve representing the invariant : @xmath82 for a fixed @xmath83 , this equation implicitly defines @xmath84 as a function of @xmath85 .
it satisfies the initial condition @xmath86 : @xmath87
@xmath88 note that , to first order , the argument in @xmath89 has been replaced with @xmath83 .
we have also separated the two sums so that @xmath90 is the individual contribution of the @xmath23th ip . in the same way , a different initial condition may be used ( more suitable for plots ) : @xmath86 , instead of @xmath91 . the smear @xmath12 is now defined as the normalized r.m.s . of the invariant that is , @xmath92 , with @xmath93 being the variance : @xmath94
as an example application , this section studies the very simple collision set that still possesses all the symmetries with the l.r . set at 8 sigma , as depicted in fig . [ reduced ] .
both ir5 and ir1 are included .
the goal here is to test the invariant @xmath95 by tracking with a simple model built with kicks @xmath96 alternating with linear matrices and sixtrack .
the parameters are as follows : energy @xmath97tev , @xmath98 , and normalized emittance @xmath99 .
tracking single particles at various amplitudes with the simple model produces the results shown in fig .
a particle starts with @xmath100 , or @xmath101 ( @xmath102 , or @xmath103 ) .
the @xmath63 are computed with an accuracy of @xmath104 the value of @xmath105 in eq .
( [ dinv ] ) is about @xmath106 . ) for @xmath107 turns .
red : invariant @xmath108 ( initials chosen so that @xmath91).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] ) for @xmath107 turns .
red : invariant @xmath108 ( initials chosen so that @xmath91).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] since the beam beam potential changes the linear optics , we need to find the linearly perturbed matched @xmath109-function value at the initial point for tracking .
for the plots in fig .
[ i-7 ] , this is done in a separate run , using a linear kick @xmath110 ( only terms @xmath111 in the hamiltonian ) .
this is similar to what is done in sixtrack .
the resultant matched @xmath109 is used to define the initial coordinate @xmath112 ( through @xmath113 ) .
the values of the smear are shown at the top of each plot . plotting the smear over a range of amplitudes with all three methods model , sixtrack , and analytical @xmath12 results in fig .
[ figsm ] . note that here the images of the strong - beam centroids ( see fig . [ nxset ] ) are represented by vertical grey lines drawn at @xmath114 and @xmath115 sigma .
let us now look at the individual contributions to @xmath95 of the six ips at three amplitudes chosen arbitrarily ; say , @xmath116 , and @xmath101 . the excursions ( w.r.t .
@xmath83 ) of the individual invariant surfaces are shown in fig .
[ pltc13 ] . here , @xmath86 .
the colour code is as in fig .
[ reduced ] , and in addition for the head - ons we use solid black for ip5 and dashed for ip1 .
near the axis ( @xmath117 ) , only the two head - ons contribute and , being of opposite signs , almost compensate each other . at @xmath118 , one begins to see long - range contributions that grow when @xmath119 . at such large amplitudes ,
the compensation is no longer true .
magenta and green are barely seen , meaning that the contribution of off - plane collisions is negligible .
thus in the case of a test particle moving in the horizontal motion , the contribution of all l.r . in ir1 can be neglected , and vice versa for vertical motion and ip5 .
above some critical strength of beam beam interaction that is , quantities @xmath120 and/or @xmath121 and/or an inverse crossing angle the first - order theory is no longer an adequate description of the smear .
however , as we will see , the behaviour of @xmath12 may still be used as an indication of the dynamic aperture , since it exhibits a local maximum near it . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] .,title="fig : " ] .,title="fig : " ] .,title="fig : " ] .,title="fig : " ] of the four plots in figs .
[ crang12 ] and [ crang16 ] , on three occasions the 3%-smear line intersects a monotonic part of @xmath12 where , as we already know from section 4 , there is an exact agreement with sixtrack . the rough indication for the dynamic aperture , as the amplitude corresponding to a maximum of @xmath0 , has been used in only one case : @xmath5=53 . 99 r. assmann et al .
, `` results of long - range beam beam studies scaling with beam separation and intensity , '' cern - ats - note-2012 - 070 md ( 2012 ) .
w. herr and d. kaltchev , `` analytical calculation of the smear for long range beam beam interactions , '' proc .
pac 2009 .
dragt and o.g .
jakubowicz , `` analysis of the beam
beam interaction using transfer maps , '' proc .
beam interaction seminar , stanford , ca , 2223 may 1980 , slac - r-541 .
j. bengtsson and j. irwin , `` analytical calculation of smear and tune shift , '' ssc-232 ( february 1990 ) .
furman and s.g .
peggs , `` a standard for the smear , '' ssc - n-634 ( 1989 ) .
e. forest , `` analytical computation of the smear , '' ssc-95 ( 1986 ) .
d. kaltchev , `` on beam beam resonances observed in lhc tracking , '' tri - dn-07 - 9 ( 2007 ) .
a. chao , `` lie algebra techniques for nonlinear dynamics , '' http : www.slac.stanford.edu / chao m. abramowitz and i.a .
stegun , _ handbook of mathematical functions _ ( new york : dover , 1972 ) .
d. kaltchev , `` hamiltonian for long - range beam - beam , fourier coefficients , '' triumf note ( 2012 ) .
the use of @xmath122 as an alternative does not change any results .
the non - linear kick factor in eq .
( [ fnon ] ) is @xmath123 by following ref .
@xcite , the lie map is given by an expression of the following form : @xmath124 here , @xmath125 are linear operators and for brevity we have replaced @xmath126 with @xmath127 .
we will show that since @xmath128 depends only on the normalized coordinate @xmath129 , once we rewrite it in terms of the eigen - coordinates at the @xmath23th kick , the local beta functions @xmath31 disappear , while the phase @xmath26 is simply added to @xmath85 . by reversing the order ,
the map transforming the test particle @xmath130 for one turn around the ring is @xmath131 reversal of the order means that in the first line all @xmath132 are now functions of the same initial variables @xmath130 . in the second line , accumulated linear maps @xmath133
have been applied to transform the initial vector to the kick location .
thus , as a first step , we have moved all kicks to the front of the lattice and @xmath134 is the total one - turn linear lie operator .
let us denote matrices corresponding to lie operators with hats ; for example , @xmath135 . as a second step , with @xmath109 ,
@xmath5 being matched twiss parameters at the end of the lattice , one uses an @xmath136 transform that transforms the ring matrix to a rotation ( inserting identities @xmath137 in between the exponents ) : @xmath138 @xmath139 the two steps above combined are equivalent to replacing the argument of @xmath140 by @xmath141 the eigen - coordinate at the @xmath23th location . to see this ,
apply the @xmath142 transform to both kick factor and coordinate : @xmath143 @xmath144 one can now drop the @xmath142 on both sides of @xmath145 and consider the map : @xmath146 to first order , one can just sum the lie factors : @xmath147 by noting that above , as in ref .
@xcite , @xmath148 precedes the kick , while in eq .
( [ oneip ] ) and ref .
@xcite the kick is assumed to be at the end of the lattice , our map is identical to eq .
( [ oneip ] ) . the first - order invariant @xmath17 is now found with the bch theorem .
let us write @xmath149 , where @xmath150 is the oscillating part . by taking only @xmath150 : @xmath151 where according to eq .
( [ ftilde ] ) , @xmath152 a basic property of @xmath153 is to operate in a simple way on functions of @xmath154 , or eigenvectors @xmath155 .
also , functions @xmath156 can easily be applied to eigenvectors : @xmath157 @xmath158 if we choose @xmath159 , then we have : @xmath160 by substituting all these in eq .
( a.2 ) and using the property @xmath161 , we obtain : @xmath162 | we find that the observed dependencies ( scaling ) of long - range beam beam effects on the beam separation and intensity are consistent with the simple assumption that , all other parameters being the same , the quantity preserved during different set - ups is the first - order smear as a function of amplitude . |
the standard model has been tested to a high degree of precision and the only missing link is the higgs scalar .
apart from the direct search for higgs at lhc , the other purpose of lhc is to test the various extensions of the standard model such as supersymmetry , extra dimensions , technicolor , neutral vector boson @xmath8 and standard model with fourth generation of quarks and leptons ( sm4 ) .
the search for new degrees of freedom at lhc can be done in two distinct ways .
one is the direct search of the higgs boson and the particles beyond the sm to establish the new physics ( np ) theories .
the other is the indirect way where we test the sm with high theoretical and experimental precision for which the rare @xmath4 meson decays are an ideal probe . among different
@xmath4 meson decays the one which proceed through flavor changing neutral current ( fcnc ) transitions , like @xmath9 and @xmath10 , are of special interest .
this lies in the fact that fcnc transitions generally arise at loop level in the sm , and thus provide a good testing ground for the various extensions of the sm .
the radiative decays @xmath11 and @xmath12 are easy to calculate but they have limited physical observables in comparison to the semileptonic @xmath13 decay
. in semileptonic decays one can study number of physical observables like decay rate , forward - backward asymmetries , lepton polarization asymmetries and the isospin symmetries .
the theoretical research in these semileptonic decay modes has been done with highly improved precision , see ref .
@xcite , with good support from their experimental studies at b factories and the hadron colliders @xcite . with the start of lhc we are expecting better statistics ,
the lhcb experiment can accumulate 6200 events per nominal running year at @xmath14 tev @xcite .
the sensitivity of measuring the zero - position of the forward - backward asymmetry at lhc will reduce to @xmath15 which may be further improved to @xmath16 after the upgrade @xcite .
hence , its investigation will not only provide us an opportunity to discriminate between the sm and different np models but will also improve our understanding of the short - distance physics at an unprecedented level .
the experimental observation of the @xmath17 decay at babar and belle @xcite indicates that its branching ratio is comparable to @xmath12 . the related decay mode with photon in the final state replaced by a pair of charged leptons
has already been seen for @xmath18 .
like @xmath19 the decay @xmath20 is also described by the quark level transition @xmath21 and hence the same np would be expected to affect their measurements .
therefore , the analysis of @xmath6 process will usefully complement the much investigated decay process @xmath22 @xcite .
the experimental observation of this decay will provide some supplementary tests of the predictions of sm btotensor .
it has already been mentioned that the unitarity of quark mixing matrix forbids the fcnc transitions at tree level in the sm . when loop corrections are taken into account
, @xmath23 arises from the photon penguin , @xmath24 penguin and the @xmath25-box diagrams .
the large mass scale of virtual states leads to tiny wilson coefficients in @xmath26 quark decays and thus @xmath23 would be sensitive to the potential np effects @xcite .
these np effects enter in two distinct ways : in one scenario new operators not present in sm can emerge while in other scenario only the wilson coefficients of the sm operators get modified .
sm with an extra generation of quarks is one of the simplest scenario of the later category and recently it has attracted an increasing interest ( see ref .
@xcite for brief review on sm4 ) . in this work
we study its impact on @xmath27 decays .
the electroweak precision data does not exclude the complete existence of the fourth family and there are many reasons to introduce an extra generation of heavy particles @xcite .
especially , lhc has a potential to discover or fully exclude the existence of a fourth generation of quarks up to 1 tev @xcite .
even if they are too heavy to be observed directly they will induce a large signal in @xmath28 which will be clearly visible at the lhc @xcite .
the sequential fourth generation model is a simple and non - supersymmetric extension of the sm , which does not add any new dynamics to the sm , with an additional up - type quark @xmath29 and down - type quark @xmath30 , a heavy charged lepton @xmath31 and an associated neutrino @xmath32 .
being a simple extension of the sm it retains all the properties of the sm where the new top quark @xmath29 like the other up - type quarks , contributes to @xmath33 transition at the loop level .
due to the additional fourth generation the quark mixing matrix ( ckm ) will become @xmath34 , i.e. , @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 are new matrix elements in the sm4 .
the parametrization of this unitary matrix requires six mixing angles and three phases [ 9 ] .
the effects of sequential fourth generation have already been studied on different physical observables in @xmath4 , @xmath3 and @xmath5 decays , see ref .
@xcite for a short list . in this work ,
we analyze the possible fourth generation effects on the decay rates , forward - backward asymmetry @xmath38 , the final state lepton polarization asymmetries @xmath39 and the helicity fractions of @xmath40 meson @xmath41 in @xmath42 decays .
it is well known that the constraints on the np parameters in @xmath43 are obtained mainly from the related decay modes @xmath44 and the golden channel @xmath45 . due to the large hadronic uncertainties ,
the exclusive decays ( under discussion here ) @xmath46 provide weaker constraints than the inclusive decay modes @xmath47 .
clearly our aim here is not to obtain the precise predictions of the sm4 but rather to obtain an understanding of how np arising from the sm4 affects different physical observables . in these fcnc transitions the fourth generation top quark @xmath29 , like @xmath48 , @xmath49 , @xmath50 quarks , contributes at loop level which result in the modification of the corresponding wilson coefficients . in our numerical study of @xmath6
decays , we shall use the the form factors calculated using lcsr approach in ref .
@xcite . by incorporating the recent constraints on the fourth generation parameters , @xmath51 gev and @xmath52 @xcite ,
our results show that the decay rates of @xmath53 are quite sensitive to these parameters .
the np effects in the decay rate are usually masked by the uncertainties associated with the different input parameters especially arising from the form factors .
therefore , one has to look for the observables which have mild dependence on these form factors .
the zero position of fba , lepton polarization asymmetries and helicity fractions of final state mesons are efficient tools to search for np .
we have studied these asymmetries in the sm4 and found that the effects of fourth generation parameters are quite significant in some regions of parameter space of the sm4 .
a qualitative comparison of the results of different physical observables of decays @xmath54 and @xmath55 will show that these two decays will compliment each other for certain physical observables . the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we present the effective hamiltonian for the semileptonic decay @xmath56 , section iii contains the definitions and the numerical values of the form factors . in sec .
iv we present the expressions of physical observables under discussion here .
section v is devoted to the numerical analysis where we analyze the sensitivity of these physical observables on fourth generation parameter @xmath57 .
finally , the main results are summarized in sec .
in the standard model ( sm3 ) the @xmath58 transition is governed by the effective hamiltonian @xmath59where @xmath60 @xmath61 are the four - quark operators and @xmath62 are the corresponding wilson coefficients at the energy scale @xmath63 .
currently these wilson coefficients are calculated in the sm at next - to - leading order ( nlo ) and next - to - next leading logarithm ( nnll ) and their explicit expressions are given in the literature @xcite . out of these 10 operators the ones which are responsible for @xmath6 are @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 and their form is given below @xmath67with @xmath68 . in terms of the above operators ,
the free quark decay amplitude for @xmath69 @xmath70 in the sm can be derived as : @xmath71where @xmath72 is the square of the momentum transfer .
the operator @xmath66 can not be induced by the insertion of four - quark operators because of the absence of the @xmath24 -boson in the effective theory .
therefore , the wilson coefficient @xmath73 does not renormalize under qcd corrections and hence it is independent of the energy scale .
in addition to this , the above quark level decay amplitude can receive contributions from the matrix elements of four - quark operators , @xmath74 , which are usually absorbed into the effective wilson coefficient @xmath75 , usually called @xmath76 , which can be decomposed into the following three parts @xmath77where the parameters @xmath78 and @xmath79 are defined as @xmath80 .
@xmath81 describes the short - distance contributions from four - quark operators far away from the @xmath82 resonance regions , which can be calculated reliably in the perturbative theory .
the long - distance contributions @xmath83 from four - quark operators near the @xmath82 resonance can not be calculated from first principles of qcd and are usually parameterized in the form of a phenomenological breit - wigner formula making use of the vacuum saturation approximation and quark - hadron duality .
we will neglect the long - distance contributions in this work because of the absence of experimental data on @xmath84 and also the np effects lie far from the resonance region .
the explicit expressions for @xmath81 can be written as buras @xmath85with @xmath86 apart from the correction to @xmath87 , the non - factorizable effects @xcite from the charm loop can bring about further corrections to the radiative @xmath11 transition , which can be absorbed into the effective wilson coefficient @xmath88 . specifically , the wilson coefficient @xmath88 is given by @xcite @xmath89with @xmath90 , \\ g_{1}(x_{t } ) & = & { \frac{x_{t}(x_{t}^{2}-5x_{t}-2)}{8(x_{t}-1)^{3}}}+{\frac{3x_{t}^{2}\mathrm{ln}^{2}x_{t}}{4(x_{t}-1)^{4}}},\end{aligned}\]]where @xmath91 , @xmath92 , @xmath93 is the absorptive part for the @xmath94 rescattering and we have dropped out the tiny contributions proportional to ckm sector @xmath95 . in addition , @xmath96 can be obtained by replacing @xmath97 with @xmath98 in the above expression .
similar replacement @xmath99 has to be done for the other wilson coefficients @xmath76 and @xmath73 which have too lengthy expressions to be given here and their explicit expressions are given in refs .
@xcite .
it has already been pointed out that the sequential fourth generation does not change the operator basis of the sm , therefore , its effects will change the values of the wilson coefficients @xmath100 , @xmath101 and @xmath73 via the virtual exchange of new generation up - type quark @xmath29 .
the modified wilson coefficients will take the form;@xmath102where @xmath103 @xmath104 and the explicit forms of the @xmath105 s can be obtained from the corresponding expressions of the wilson coefficients in sm by putting @xmath106 .
the addition of an extra family of quarks will also add an extra row and a column in the ckm matrix of the sm which now becomes @xmath107 and the unitarity of which leads to@xmath108since @xmath109 has a very small value compared to the other ckm matrix elements , therefore , it is safe to ignore it . thus from eq .
( [ unitarity - condition ] ) we have @xmath110 which by plugging in eq .
( [ wilson - modified ] ) gives@xmath111here , one can clearly see that under @xmath112 or @xmath113 the term @xmath114 vanishes which is the requirement of gim mechanism . after including the @xmath29 quark in the loop the relevant wilson coefficients
@xmath115 and @xmath73 can take the following form@xmath116we recall here that the the ckm coefficient corresponding to the @xmath50-quark contribution , i.e , .
@xmath117 is factorized in the effective hamiltonian given in eq .
( [ effective hamiltonian 1 ] ) and the wilson coefficients @xmath118 corresponds to the ones which appear in eq .
( effective hamiltonian 1 ) .
now @xmath119 can be parameterized as : @xmath120where @xmath121 is the phase factor corresponding to the @xmath69 transition in sm4 which was taken to be @xmath122 @xcite in the forthcoming numerical analysis of different physical observables . in terms of the above sm4 wilson coefficients ,
the free quark decay amplitude for @xmath69 @xmath70 becomes : @xmath123
with the free quark amplitude available ( c.f .
( [ quark - amplitudetot ] ) ) , one can proceed to calculate the amplitudes for the exclusive semi - leptonic @xmath0 decay , which can be obtained by sandwiching the free quark amplitudes between the initial and final meson states . in general
these matrix elements can be parameterized in term of the form factors as follows : @xmath124 \notag \\ & & -ia_{2}(q^{2})\frac{\varepsilon _ { \nu \alpha } ^{\ast } p^{\alpha } q^{\nu } } { m_{b}(m_{b}+m_{k_{2}^{\ast } } ) } \left [ ( p^{\mu } + k^{\mu } ) -\frac{m_{b}^{2}-m_{k_{2}^{\ast } } ^{2}}{q^{2}}q^{\mu } \right ] \label{axial current}\end{aligned}\]]@xmath125 \frac{1}{m_{b } } \notag \\ & & + t_{3}(q^{2})\frac{\varepsilon _ { \nu \alpha } ^{\ast } p^{\alpha } } { m_{b}}q^{\nu } \left [ q^{\mu } -\frac{q^{2}}{m_{b}^{2}-m_{k_{2}^{\ast } } ^{2}}(p^{\mu } + k^{\mu } ) \right]\end{aligned}\]]where @xmath126 is the momentum of the @xmath127 meson and @xmath128 is the polarization of the final state @xmath129 meson . in case of the tensor meson
the polarization sum is given by@xcite@xmath130with @xmath131we define@xmath132and the resulting matrix elements will look just like the @xmath133 ( e.g. @xmath134 meson ) transitions .
the form factors for @xmath135 transition are the non - perturbative quantities and are needed to be calculated using different approaches ( both perturbative and non - perturbative ) like lattice qcd , qcd sum rules , light cone sum rules , etc .
earlier , we considered the form factors calculated by li et al . using perturbative qcd @xcite and their evolution with @xmath72
is given by : @xmath136where the value of different parameters is given in table i. in pqcd the uncertainties are fairly large , see table i. thus in this research work we will incorporate the form factor calculated in the light cone sum rules ( lcsr ) technique @xcite .
the form factor in lcsr are parameterized as @xmath137form factors calculated using lcsr technique have less uncertainties , see table ii .
.@xmath138 form factors in the pqcd frame work .
@xmath139 denotes the value of form factors at @xmath140 while @xmath141 and @xmath26 are the parameters in the parameterizations shown in eq .
( form - factor - sq)@xcite . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
we have carried out the study of invariant mass spectrum , forward - backward asymmetry , lepton polarization asymmetries and the helicity fractions of the final state meson @xmath142 for the semileptonic decay @xmath143 @xmath144 in sm4 . in particular , we have analyzed the sensitivity of these physical observables on the fourth generation quark mass @xmath145 as well as the ckm mixing angle @xmath146 . we have also made a qualitative analysis between @xmath147 and the corresponding @xmath148 decays .
the main outcomes of this study can be summarized as follows : * the differential branching ratios deviate sizably from that of the sm especially both in the small and large momentum transfer region .
these effects are significant and the branching ratio increases by a factor of @xmath149 for @xmath150 @xmath151 @xmath152 gev and @xmath146 @xmath151 @xmath153 in @xmath154 decay . though the branching ratio of this decay is an order of magnitude smaller than its brother decay @xmath148 but the sm4 effects in both the decays are same . now for the final state tauon s case ,
the increases in the value of the branching ratio of @xmath155 decay is very small and is usually masked by the uncertainties involved in different input parameters like form factors .
* the value of the forward - backward asymmetry decreases significantly from that of the sm value in the sm4 when the mass of the fourth generation quark varies from @xmath156 gev to @xmath152 gev .
the value of the zero position of forward - backward asymmetry shifted towards the left for all values of @xmath157 in @xmath158 decay .
this shifting is significant for large values of the fourth generation ckm matrix elements @xmath159 and fourth generation top quark mass @xmath150 .
it is known that the nlo corrections to @xmath160 decay can bring @xmath161 corrections to the zero position of the fba , therefore , such calculation for @xmath162 is still lacking . *
the longitudinal , normal and transverse polarizations of leptons are calculated in the sm4 .
we observed that the longitudinal and transverse lepton polarization asymmetry in @xmath163 and @xmath164 decays are same but the normal lepton polarization of these two decays is different .
it is found that the sm4 effects are very promising in both decays , which could be measured at future experiments , and would shed light on the new physics beyond the sm .
it is hoped that this can be measurable at the lhcb where a large number of @xmath165 pairs are expected to be produced . *
the sm4 effects on helicity fraction are mild but still notably different from sm . in case of @xmath166
the asymptotic values of @xmath167 and @xmath168 are distinctly different from their sm values .
this observable is also important to probe np effects on the final state tensor meson @xmath169 and vector meson @xmath170 .
a comparison of the helicity fractions of @xmath171 and @xmath134 was also investigated and it was found that both decay modes are not entirely similar in all respects . in summary , the experimental investigation of observables , like branching ratios , forward - backward asymmetry , lepton polarization asymmetries and the helicity fractions of the final state @xmath171 meson in @xmath172 decay will be a useful compliment of the much investigated @xmath173 decay .
helpful discussions with prof . riazuddin and prof .
fayyazuddin are greatly acknowledged .
we would like to thank s. nandi for some useful comments and wang wei for reading the manuscript and pointing out several typos .
we also acknowledge our colleague ishtiaq ahmed for some useful discussion on helicity fraction calculations .
m. j. a acknowledge the grant provided by quaid - i - azam university from university research funds .
a. ali , p. ball , l. t. handoko et al .
, phys . rev . * d61 * , 074024 ( 2000 ) .
[ hep - ph/9910221 ] ; c. s. kim , y. g. kim , c. d. lu and t. morozumi , phys .
rev . * d62 * , 034013 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0001151 ] ; m. beneke , t. feldmann , d. seidel , nucl . phys . * b612 * , 25 - 58 ( 2001 ) .
[ hep - ph/0106067 ] ; c. h. chen and c. q. geng , nucl
b636 * , 338 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0203003 ] ; f. kruger and j. matias , phys . rev . * d71 * , 094009 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0502060 ] ; a. ali , g. kramer , g. -h .
zhu , eur .
j. * c47 * , 625 - 641 ( 2006 ) .
[ hep - ph/0601034 ] ; c. bobeth , g. hiller and g. piranishvili , jhep * 0807 * , 106 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0805.2525 [ hep - ph ] ] ; u. egede , t. hurth , j. matias , m. ramon and w. reece , jhep * 0811 * , 032 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0807.2589 [ hep - ph ] ] ; w. altmannshofer , et al .
, jhep * 0901 * , 019 ( 2009 ) .
[ arxiv:0811.1214 [ hep - ph ] ] ; c. w. chiang , r. h. li and c. d. lu , arxiv:0911.2399 [ hep - ph ] ; a. k. alok , a. dighe , d. ghosh , d. london , j. matias , m. nagashima and a. szynkman , jhep * 1002 * , 053 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0912.1382 [ hep - ph ] ] ; q. chang , x. q. li and y. d. yang , jhep * 1004 * , 052 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1002.2758 [ hep - ph ] ] ; a. bharucha and w. reece , eur .
j. * c69 * , 623 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1002.4310 [ hep - ph ] ] ; a. khodjamirian , t. mannel , a. a. pivovarov and y. m. wang , jhep * 1009 * , 089 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1006.4945 [ hep - ph ] ] ; c. bobeth , g. hiller and d. van dyk , jhep * 1007 * , 098 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1006.5013 [ hep - ph ] ] ; a. k. alok , a. datta , a. dighe , m. duraisamy , d. ghosh , d. london and s. u. sankar , arxiv:1008.2367 [ hep - ph ] .
b. aubert et al .
[ babar collaboration ] , phys .
* 102 * , 091803 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0807.4119 [ hep - ex ] ] ; j. t. wei et al .
[ belle collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 171801 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.0770 [ hep - ex ] ] ; t. aaltonen et al .
[ cdf collaboration ] , phys . rev . *
d79 * , 011104 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0804.3908 [ hep - ex ] ] .
s. rai choudhury , et al .
, phys . rev .
* d74 * , 054031 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0607289 ] ; s. r. choudhury , a. s. cornell and n. gaur , phys . rev . *
d81 * , 094018 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0911.4783 [ hep - ph ] ] ; h. hatanaka and k. c. yang , phys . rev . * d79 * , 114008 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0903.1917 [ hep - ph ] ] ; h. hatanaka and k. c. yang , eur
j. * c67 * , 149 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:0907.1496 [ hep - ph ] .
m. hashimoto , arxiv:1001.4335 ; j. alwall et al .
, eur . phys .
j. * c49 * ( 2007 ) 791 - 801 , hep - ph/0607115 ; m. s. chanowitz , phys . rev . * d79 * ( 2009 ) 113008 , arxiv : 0904.3570 ; v. a. novikov , a. n. rozanov , and m. i. vysotsky , arxiv : 0904.4570 ; j. erler and p. langacker , arxiv : 1003.3211 ; h .- j .
he , n. polonsky , s. su , phys . rev .
* d64 * ( 2001 ) 053004 , [ hep - ph/0102144 ] ; p. q. hung and c. xiong , arxiv : 0911.3890 ; p. q. hung and c. xiong , arxiv : 0911.3892 ; k. s. babu , x. g. he , x. li , and s. pakvasa , phys .
* b205 * ( 1988 ) 540 ; d. london , phys . lett .
* b234 * ( 1990 ) 354 ; y. dincer , phys . lett .
* b505 * ( 2001 ) 89 ; a. arhrib and w .- s .
hou , eur .
j. * c27 * ( 2003 ) 555 - 561 , hep - ph/0211267 ; w .- s .
hou , m. nagashima , and a. soddu , phys . rev .
* d72 * ( 2005 ) 115007 , hep - ph/0508237 ; w .- s .
hou , m. nagashima , and a. soddu , phys . rev .
* d76 * ( 2007 ) 013504 , hep - ph/0610385 ; t. m. aliev , a. ozpineci and m. savci , nucl
b585 * ( 2000 ) 275 .
t. m. aliev , a. ozpineci and m. savci , eur .
j. * c29 * ( 2003 ) 265 ; v. bashiry and k. azizi , jhep 0707 ( 2007 ) 64 ; v. bashiry and f. flahati , arxiv : 0707.3242 ; f. zolfagharpour and v. bashiry , arxiv : 0707.4337 ; v. bashiry and m. bayer , arxiv : 0903.2631 ; a. soni , a. k. alok , a. giri , r. mohanta , and s. nandi , arxiv : 0807.1971 ; j. a. herrera , r. h. benavides , and w. a. ponce , phys . rev .
* d78 * ( 2008 ) 073008 , 0810.3871 ; m. bobrowski , a. lenz , j. riedl , and j. rohrwild , phys . rev . * d79 * ( 2009 ) 113006 , 0902.4883 ; g. eilam , b. melic , and j. trampetic , phys . rev . * d80 * ( 2009 ) 113503 , 0909.3227 ; wei - shu hou , chin.j.phys.47:134 ( 2009 ) , arxiv : 0803.1234 [ hep - ph ] ; fayyazuddin , arxiv : 0907.3285 [ hep - ph ] ; a. soni , a. k. alok , a. giri , r. mohanta , and s. nandi , arxiv : 1002.0595 ; a. j. buras , b. duling , t. feldmann , t. heidsieck , c. promberger , and s. recksiegel , arxiv : 1002.2126 ; w. s. hou and c. y. ma , arxiv : 1004.2186 ; e. lunghi and a. soni , arxiv : 1007.4015 ; z. murdock , s. nandi , and z. tavartkiladze , phys
b668 * ( 2008 ) 303 - 307 , arxiv : 0806.2064 ; r. m. godbole , s. k. vempati , and a. wingerter , arxiv : 0911.1882 ; m. jamil aslam , phys . rev.*d83 * ( 2011 ) 035017 , arxiv : 1007.4865 [ hep - ph ] ; g. w. s. hou , arxiv : 1101.2158 [ hep - ph ] ; h. chen and w. huo , arxiv : 1101.4660 [ hep - ph ] ; otto eberhardt , alexander lenz , 1005.3505 [ hep - ph ] ; a. k. alok , a. dighe and s. ray , phys .
d * 79 * ( 2009 ) 034017 [ arxiv:0811.1186 [ hep - ph ] ] . | the @xmath0 @xmath1 decays are analyzed in the standard model extended to fourth generation of quarks ( sm4 ) .
the decay rate , forward - backward asymmetry , lepton polarization asymmetries and the helicity fractions of the final state @xmath2 meson are obtained using the form factors calculated in the light cone sum rules ( lcsr ) approach .
we have utilized the constraints on different fourth generation parameters obtained from the experimental information on @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 decays and from the electroweak precision data to explore their impact on the @xmath6 decay .
we find that the values of above mentioned physical observables deviate deviate significantly from their minimal sm predications .
we also identify a number of correlations between various observables in @xmath0 and @xmath7 decays .
therefore a combined analysis of these two decays will compliment each other in the searches of sm4 effects in flavor physics . |
supernova remnants ( snrs ) have long been considered to be likely acceleration sites of cosmic - ray particles below the energy of the _ knee _ , @xmath3 .
the energy supply to explain the energy density of comic rays is satisfied if @xmath410% of the energy of each supernova is transferred to accelerated particles . also , the well developed theory of diffusive shock acceleration nicely explains the universal power - law spectrum of cosmic rays ( e.g. @xcite ) .
although synchrotron emission detected in the radio band supports this idea observationally , no evidence of acceleration to tev energy had been observed until recently . during the last decade , such evidence was revealed through observations of x - rays and tev gamma rays from several shell - type snrs .
@xcite discovered synchrotron x - rays from the shell of sn 1006 , which indicates electrons are accelerated up to multi - tev energies .
this finding was followed by detections of synchrotron x - rays from other snrs , including rx j1713.7@xmath03946 ( e.g. @xcite ) .
further evidence for multi - tev particles ( electrons and/or protons ) has been provided by discovery of tev gamma rays from some snrs , such as cassiopeia a @xcite or rx j1713.7@xmath03946 @xcite , although their spectral parameters and morphologies were not well determined due to the limited sensitivity of tev observatories .
subsequently , high quality morphological and spectral studies have been performed by h.e.s.s .
( e.g. @xcite ) .
these pioneering measurements by the h.e.s.s .
telescope , together with the high resolution x - ray data , have enabled direct comparison of x - ray and tev gamma - ray data .
the shell - type snr rx j1713.7@xmath03946 ( also known as [email protected] ) , is one of the best - studied snrs from which both non - thermal x - rays and tev gamma rays are detected .
this snr was discovered in soft x - rays during the _ rosat _ all - sky survey @xcite .
the _ asca _ satellite , with wider energy coverage than that of _ rosat _ , revealed that the x - ray spectrum is featureless and can be best interpreted as synchrotron emission from very high energy electrons in the tev regime @xcite .
the x - ray spectrum was well fitted with a power - law function of photon index @xmath5@xmath6 and interstellar absorption column density @xmath7@xmath8 without any observable evidence for a thermal emission component .
subsequent observations by _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ have unveiled structure with a complex network of bright filaments and knots , in the western part of the snr @xcite . tev gamma - ray emission from rx j1713.7@xmath03946
was first reported by the cangaroo collaboration in 1998 @xcite , and confirmed by the subsequent observations with cangaroo - ii in 2000 and 2001 @xcite .
later , the h.e.s.s .
collaboration obtained a resolved image of the source in tev gamma rays @xcite showing that the gamma - ray emission from rx j1713.7@xmath03946 arises mainly in the shell .
these observations revealed a striking correlation between the x - ray and the gamma - ray images , which indicates a strong connection between the physical processes responsible for x - ray and tev gamma - ray emission components @xcite .
based on the spectral and morphological information , they discussed two possible gamma - ray emission scenarios , one where gamma rays are generated by inverse compton scattering of accelerated electrons with diffuse radiation fields ( the so - called leptonic scenario ) and the other where the decay of secondary @xmath9-mesons is responsible for gamma rays ( hadronic scenario ) .
the later observations with h.e.s.s . revealed that the flux extends to 30 tev and , likely , beyond , which implies particle acceleration up to energies well above 100 tev for either model @xcite .
most recently , our x - ray observations using _ chandra _ and _ suzaku _ have provided important clues for understanding the acceleration process in the snr . from a series of observations of the northwest part of the snr with _
chandra _ in 2000 , 2005 and 2006 , we discovered that compact regions of the northwest ( nw ) shell are variable in flux on a one - year time scale @xcite .
the fast variability was interpreted as one - year scale acceleration and synchrotron cooling of electrons with amplified magnetic fields of order of 1 mg .
such a large magnetic field in compact regions strongly favors @xmath10-decay emission as the origin of tev gamma rays .
also , thanks to the wide - band coverage of _ suzaku _ and its low background level , we were able to measure a hard x - ray spectrum up to 40 kev from the southwest portion of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 with a clear indication of a high - energy cutoff in the synchrotron spectrum ( @xcite , hereafter paper i ) .
combined with the upper limit on a shock speed of @xmath11 placed by _
, the cutoff energy determined by the _ suzaku _ observation of the southwest part indicates that particle acceleration within the snr shock is so efficient that it approaches the theoretical limit corresponding to the so - called bohm diffusion regime ( e.g. @xcite ) . in this paper
, we present results of mapping observations of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 with _ suzaku _ , which covers about two - thirds of the snr region with 11 pointings .
the low background level of the hard x - ray detector ( hxd ) enables us to detect hard x - ray emission up to @xmath1 from each of the pointings . at the same time
, its small field - of - view ( fov ) of @xmath12 fwhm gives us information about the spatial distribution of hard x - ray emission and spectral differences from region to region .
thanks to its low instrumental background and large effective area , the other detector system aboard _ suzaku _
, the x - ray imaging spectrometer ( xis ) , also uncovers new observational facts , such as spectral features below 10 kev and the morphology of relatively dim regions left unclear in previous studies by _ asca _ , _ chandra _ , and _ xmm - newton_. by combining the xis and hxd spectra summed over the data from all the pointings , we show a wide - band x - ray spectrum ( 0.440 kev ) with quite high statistics , with which we investigate not only the existence of a cutoff , but also its shape .
we then compare the cutoff shape obtained with theoretical predictions . in section 2
, we describe our _ suzaku _ observations and the data reduction procedures .
analysis and results of hxd and xis data are shown in 3.1 and 3.2 , respectively .
we present the wide - band spectrum by connecting the xis and the hxd data in 3.3 . a detailed study regarding the cutoff structure
is also given there .
section 4 is devoted to multi - wavelength spectral and morphological studies .
the results obtained are discussed in the following section , and the results are finally summarized . throughout this paper , we assume that the distance to rx j1713.7@xmath03946 is close to 1 kpc as proposed by @xcite based on the @xmath13 value .
a similar distance has been claimed based on the nanten co data @xcite .
the typical age of the remnant for such a distance is estimated of order of 1000 yr , which can be an indication of association of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 with an explosion in a.d .
393 as proposed by @xcite .
the _ suzaku _ observatory @xcite is the fifth japanese x - ray astronomy satellite , jointly developed by japan and the us .
its scientific payload consists of two co - aligned detector systems , the xis @xcite and the hxd @xcite .
the xis consists of four x - ray ccd cameras which are located in the foci of x - ray telescopes ( xrt ; @xcite ) .
three of the xis sensors are front - illuminated ( fi ; 0.412 kev ) ccds and the other is back - illuminated ( bi 0.212 kev ) .
the non - imaging , collimated hard x - ray instrument , the hxd , covers the 10600 kev bandpass .
two main detector units , silicon pin diodes and gso scintillators , are buried at the bottom of well - type active shield of bgo .
the former covers the lower energy band of 1060 kev , while the latter detects higher energy photons of 40600 kev .
we performed 11 pointing observations of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 with _
suzaku_. the observation log is summarized in table 1 , and the pointing position of each observation is shown in figure [ fig : obs_fov ] . the southwest part of the snr , labeled as pointing 0 , was observed in 2005 during the performance verification phase , while the other ten observations were performed in 2006 during the _ suzaku _ ao1 phase . since the snr is located on the galacic plane , it is of importance to check the hard x - ray background associated with the milky way .
we therefore observed two nearby background regions containing no bright x - ray point sources .
the pointing positions of these `` off '' observations are shown with red squares in figure [ fig : obs_fov ] .
the xis was operated in the normal full - frame clocking mode without spaced - row charge injection during all the observations . since the results from pointing 0 , together with those from the off observations ,
are already reported in paper i , we do not give a detailed description on the analysis and results for these data .
we used data products from the pipeline processing version 1.2 . for the xis analysis
, we retrieved `` cleaned event files '' which are screened using standard event selection criteria .
for the 2006 data , we recalculated the values of pulse invariant ( pi ) and the grade values since incorrect caldb is applied to the pipeline processing of these data as announced by the _ suzaku _ instrument teams .
we further screened the cleaned events with following criteria as recommended by the _
instrument teams ( 1 ) cut - off rigidity larger than 6 gv and ( 2 ) elevation angle from the earth rim larger than @xmath14 . for the hxd data ,
`` uncleaned event files '' were screened using standard event screening criteria .
the exposure times after these screenings are shown in table 1 . due to unstable operation of 16 pin diodes installed in well - counter units , w00w03
; hereafter w0 , the bias voltage for these diodes was reduced to 400 v from the nominal voltage of 500 v on 26 may 2006 . on 2006
october 4 , the bias voltage of 16 more pin diodes ( the pin diodes in the well - counter units of w10w13 ; w1 ) was reduced to 400 v for the same reason .
the reduction of the pin diode bias voltage leads to a decrease of their effective area and also affects their energy response .
since the current response matrices do not include these effects , only the pin diodes with a bias voltage of 500 v are utilized in the following analysis . throughout this paper , the data reduction and analysis
are performed using headas 6.2 and the spectral fitting is done with xspec 11.3.2 .
ccccc [ tab : obs ] 0 & 100026010 & ( @xmath15 , @xmath16 ) & 55/48 & 26/9/2005 + 1 & 501063010 & ( @xmath17 , @xmath18 ) & 17/17 & 11/9/2006 + 2 & 501064010 & ( @xmath19 , @xmath20 ) & 18/22 & 11/9/2006 + 3 & 501065010 & ( @xmath21 , @xmath22 ) & 19/18 & 11/9/2006 + 4 & 501066010 & ( @xmath23 , @xmath24 ) & 19/21 & 12/9/2006 + 5 & 501067010 & ( @xmath25 , @xmath26 ) & 16/19 & 12/9/2006 + 6 & 501068010 & ( @xmath27 , @xmath20 ) & 20/19 & 13/9/2006 + 7 & 501069010 & ( @xmath28 , @xmath22 ) & 12/11 & 19/9/2006 + 8 & 501070010 & ( @xmath29 , @xmath30 ) & 19/20 & 19/9/2006 + 9 & 501071010 & ( @xmath31 , @xmath32 ) & 16/15 & 20/9/2006 + 10 & 501072010 & ( @xmath33 , @xmath24 ) & 15/15 & 5/10/2006 + off1 & 100026020 & ( @xmath34 , @xmath35 ) & 28/24 & 25/9/2005 + off2 & 100026030 & ( @xmath36 , @xmath37 ) & 30/28 & 28/9/2005
the hxd pin spectrum from each pointing was constructed and compared with the background model estimated for the each observation period . in the analysis below
, the non - xray background ( nxb ) model @xcite provided by the hxd team is used for the background generation .
since the nxb model does not include the contributions from the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) , a simulated cxb spectrum was added to the nxb model .
specifically , based on the reanalysis of the data from _ heao-1 _
observations in the 1970 s @xcite , the cxb spectrum was modeled as @xmath38 where @xmath39 and @xmath40 .
we estimated the cxb signal in each hxd pin spectrum using the response matrix for spatially uniform emission , ae_hxd_pinflat_20060809.rsp , ae_hxd_pinflat123_20060809.rsp , and ae_hxd_pinflat23_20060809.rsp . the contribution from the cxb flux to the detected count rate
is estimated to be @xmath41% of the nxb .
figure [ fig : hxd_spec_p8 ] shows the hxd pin spectrum obtained from pointing 8 , where a clear detection of hard x - rays can be seen .
likewise , the hxd pin detected signals from all other pointings with a count rate of 2050% of the nxb .
we fitted the background - subtracted spectra with a simple power law model : @xmath42 . since the extended nature of the source does not cause any spectral steepening or flattening ( paper i ) , we used the point - source response matrix at the xis - nominal position , ae_hxd_pinxinom_20060814.rsp , ae_hxd_pinxinom123_20060814.rsp , and ae_hxd_pinxinom23_20060814.rsp .
table 2 gives the best - fit parameters with the statistical errors at 90% confidence level .
the obtained photon indices are generally larger than those obtained from the corresponding xis spectra ( see below ) .
this difference indicates that a spectral cutoff is not unique to the sw region ( paper i ) , but a common feature throughout the remnant . in order to confirm the results obtained above
, we evaluated the systematic errors due to uncertainties in the nxb modeling .
as described in @xcite , the current reproducibility of the nxb model is @xmath41% .
therefore , we examined how much the values of the photon index change by increasing or decreasing the background model by 5% .
the systematic errors were found to be smaller than the statistical errors indicated in table 2 .
the systematic errors due to the misestimation of nxb were examined in another way . considering the physical size of this target ,
the emission from the remnant should be constant during the observations .
therefore , background - subtracted lightcurves should be constant during a observation .
although the lightcurves shown are almost constant within statistical errors , the background - subtracted count rate becomes higher when the total count rate increases for pointings 0 and 8 .
the light curves for pointings 0 and 8 are shown in paper i and figure [ fig : hxd_lc_p8 ] , respectively . since this behavior is thought to be caused by misestimation of the nxb , we examined how much the photon indices change with and without those time regions . when we discard the time region which corresponds to the last bin of figure [ fig : hxd_lc_p8 ] , the photon index changes by @xmath43 from the values in table 2 .
diffuse emission from the galactic plane also can affect the spectra .
however , no emission above the 5% level of the nxb was detected from the off pointings ( paper i ) .
moreover , when the excess counts marginally detected from the off pointings are added to the background spectrum for each pointing , the fitting result agrees within the statistical errors .
ccccc [ tab : hxd_fit ] 0 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & 1.15 ( 36 ) & w03 + 1 & @xmath46 & @xmath44 & 0.91 ( 18 ) & w13 + 2 & @xmath47 & @xmath44 & 0.84 ( 21 ) & w13 + 3 & @xmath48 & @xmath49 & 0.58 ( 17 ) & w13 + 4 & @xmath50 & @xmath51 & 0.77 ( 23 ) & w13 + 5 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & 0.76 ( 17 ) & w13 + 6 & @xmath50 & @xmath54 & 0.72 ( 20 ) & w13 + 7 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & 0.42 ( 9 ) & w13 + 8 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & 0.87 ( 19 ) & w13 + 9 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 & 0.86 ( 12 ) & w13 + 10 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & 0.20 ( 8) & w2 , 3 using the spectral parameters obtained for the 11 , pointings we attempt to reconstruct the spatial distribution of the hard x - ray emission .
since we expect spatial variation of both brightness and spectral index , we use a monte carlo simulator , simhxd @xcite , for the estimation .
we input the spatial distribution of brightness and spectral index into simhxd , and compare the simulated spectra with observed ones shown in [ subsec : rxj1713_hxd_spec ] .
firstly we simulated by taking a simple model in which the brightness distribution is same as the _ asca _ image shown in figure [ fig : sim_dist4 ] and the spectral index is constant at @xmath63 throughout the snr ( _ simulation1 _ ) . by using the _ asca _ image as an input to simhxd , we simulated hard x - ray spectra in 1040 kev , which are expected to be observed by the pin in each pointing .
figure [ fig : norm_hikaku ] compares the flux from the observations and the simulations . in this figure , each value is normalized to that of pointing 0 . here
, the systematic error for each observational data point is @xmath64% if we use the 5% of the background as systematic errors .
the observations and the simulations appear consistent with each other .
therefore , we expect the brightness distribution above 10 kev is not drastically different from the distribution below 10 kev . the largest discrepancy between the observation and the simulation is found for pointing 4 . in this pointing , there is a known point source at the corner of the hxd - pin field of view .
the source is listed in the second ibis / isgri soft gamma - ray survey catalog @xcite as igr j17088@xmath04008 . according to @xcite , the average flux of this source is @xmath60 mcrab in 2040 kev and @xmath65 mcrab in 40100 kev .
it is noted that the source is not bright enough for ibis / isgri to determine spectral parameters .
the transmission of fine collimators of the hxd for the source is estimated to be @xmath66 .
the estimated count rate of this source corresponds to @xmath67% of the detected signals from pointing 4 .
however , the variability of this source could increase the count rate to a non - negligible level .
the observation and the simulation become consistent if the point source was 10 times brighter than its average value during the _ suzaku _ observation .
also , the angular response of the hxd near the edge of the fov can have some uncertainties since calibrations for a source with such a large offset angle is difficult .
the uncertainties can affect our estimate of the contamination from igr j17088@xmath04008 . at this moment
, we can not conclude that the large difference between the observation and the simulation is due to the spatial distribution of the snr emission or the point source in the fov .
next we tried another simulation taking into account the spatial distribution of spectral indices ( _ simulation2 _ ) .
we adopt a `` toy model '' shown in figure [ fig : sim_dist4 ] since the results of the spectral analysis presented in table 2 suggest that the hard x - ray spectrum may be flatter in the inner region of the snr than near the rim . in the model , the photon index of the inner region is set to @xmath68 and that of the rim region is set to @xmath69 .
the _ asca _
image was used to provide the brightness distribution at 10 kev .
comparisons of the data and the simulation results are shown in figure [ fig : norm_hikaku ] and figure [ fig : index_hikaku ] for the flux and photon index , respectively . the detected flux obtained from _
simulation2 _ is somewhat similar to that from _
simulation1 _ , and the simulation data generally follow the observational data . as for the distribution of photon indices , the toy model gives a similar distribution to the observational results for the western portion of the snr . obtaining a better fit for the eastern region ( pointing 7 , 8 , and 10 ) may require more complex assumptions than the toy model for _ simulation2_. figure [ fig : xis_mosaic_image ] shows mosaic images of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 , constructed using the data from xis0 , 2 , and 3 ( fi - ccds ) .
the upper panel shows the soft band image in 15 kev and the lower panel shows the hard band image in 510 kev .
both images are smoothed with a gaussian of @xmath70 .
instrumental background signals are subtracted from both images . the signal to
background ratio in the hard band is smaller than that in the soft band by one order of magnitude .
thus , the background must be carefully subtracted .
we utilized the night earth background database consisting of event data obtained when the satellite is looking at the night earth and the non x - ray background becomes dominant . after subtracting the background ,
the vignetting effects of the xrts were corrected by means of the simulation program called xissim @xcite . in the program , an image from a flat field can be simulated by a monte carlo method . as is seen in figure [ fig : xis_mosaic_image ] ,
the _ suzaku _ xis has covered most of the remnant .
thanks to little stray - light contamination of the xrts and low background level of the xis , high quality images are obtained even in the high energy band above 5 kev .
the double shell structure revealed by _ xmm - newton _ is clearly seen in the xis images .
in addition to the bright structures of the western part , the xis revealed detailed morphology of the dim parts of the remnant .
the dim structures are highlighted in figure [ fig : xis_hess_image ] , which is the same as figure [ fig : xis_mosaic_image ] ( a ) but displayed with a different color scale . in this figure , the contours of the h.e.s.s .
gamma - ray image ( from @xcite ) are overlaid for comparison . as is clearly seen , not only the bright rims but also the eastern portion shows a striking similarity between the two energy regimes .
this correlation is discussed more quantitatively in [ subsec : mws ] .
two point sources seen in the soft band image are listed in the _ rosat _ bright source catalogue .
one is 1wga j1714.4@xmath03945 , which was associated with a wolf - rayet star by @xcite .
the other is 1wga j1713.4@xmath03949 , which is located between the two fovs of pointing 2 and 6 .
this source has been suggested to be the neutron star associated with the snr by @xcite .
comparing the soft - band and hard - band images provides information about the spatial variations of the spectral properties . at first sight ,
the bright structures are very similar in the soft band and hard band images . in order to compare the images in more detail , a radial profile around the center of snr ( @xmath71 , @xmath72 )
is presented in figure [ fig : xis_radial ] , where circular regions of @xmath73 radius centered on the two point sources are excluded .
the hard band to soft band ratio is significantly different between the bright outer region part and the interior .
this difference suggests a corresponding difference in spectral properties .
as already reported in paper i , the xis data reveal a cutoff below 10 kev in the spectrum of the sw rim .
the xis spectra from the various regions should reveal whether the cutoff varies across the remnant .
we extracted spectra from the regions shown in figure [ fig : xis_mosaic_image ] with the green squares .
the region labeled as 1 ( region 1 ) is the same one that we used for the spectral analysis in paper i. the background spectrum needs to be accumulated from nearby regions since rx j1713.7@xmath03946 is located almost on the galactic plane .
the off observation data can not be used for background estimation other than for region 1 .
this is because the contamination on the optical blocking filters of the xis @xcite significantly changed the detector response to low - energy x - rays between 2005 and 2006 . for region 110
we therefore accumulated a background spectrum from the regions indicated with the magenta polygons in figure [ fig : xis_mosaic_image ] . in the spectral
fitting discussed below , the standard rmf files version 2006 - 02 - 13 were used , whereas arf files were produced using xissimarfgen . each spectrum is binned so that each bin contains at least 300 counts .
after the binning , we ignore those bins whose energy is smaller than 0.4 kev or larger than 12 kev .
we also excluded bins between 1.7 and 1.9 kev because there exist large systematic uncertainties in the response matrices .
finally , we co - added the spectra , rmf files , and arf files from the fi chips to produce a single data set for the xis .
first , we fitted all the spectra with a simple power law absorbed by the interstellar medium .
the results are summarized in table 3 .
this model yields acceptable fits for most of the spectra .
however , the fits to the spectra of region 1 , 2 , and 6 are not acceptable even at the 99% confidence level .
we show the spectrum of region 2 with the best - fit power - law and the residuals in figure [ fig : xis_spec_reg2 ] .
although not so drastic as region 1 which is shown in paper i , a correlated pattern to the residuals can be seen for the region 2 .
a similar pattern is also seen in the data of region 6 .
we the fitted all the spectra with a cutoff power law .
this function gives acceptable fits for all regions , and consistently gives better values of @xmath74 .
in figure [ fig : xis_spec_reg2 ] , we plot the residuals for the spectrum of region 2 . these results , together with the steeper spectra detected with hxd ,
indicate the existence of a cutoff somewhere between the bandpasses of the xis and hxd .
although statistically rejected for some regions , the results obtained with the power - law fits are consistent with previous studies with _ asca _ , _ chandra _ , and _ xmm - newton _ @xcite . the results with _ suzaku
_ suggest that the photon index is larger and the absorption is smaller for the inner regions than for the outer regions .
this tendency agrees with the radial profile shown in figure [ fig : xis_radial ] .
the difference of @xmath13 between the western bright spots and the inner region is @xmath75@xmath76 , which is consistent with the results from _ xmm - newton_. according to the discussion by @xcite , there could be a correlation between the difference of @xmath13 and the presence of the molecular clouds in the western part of the snr detected with the nanten telescope @xcite .
cccccccccccc [ tab : xis_fit ] 1 & 108 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & 1.38 ( 718 ) & & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & 1.04 ( 717 ) + 2 & 77.2 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & 1.23 ( 242 ) & & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & 1.01 ( 241 ) + 3 & 86.6 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 & 1.14 ( 94 ) & & @xmath94 & @xmath58 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & 1.02 ( 93 ) + 4 & 42.2 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & 1.38 ( 44 ) & & @xmath100 & @xmath65 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & 1.23 ( 43 ) + 5 & 116 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & 1.18 ( 120 ) & & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & 1.12 ( 119 ) + 6 & 51.4 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & 1.63 ( 48 ) & & @xmath113 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & 1.24 ( 47 ) + 7 & 59.6 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & 1.15 ( 56 ) & & @xmath120 & @xmath49 & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & 1.03 ( 55 ) + 8 & 72.4 & @xmath103 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & 1.10 ( 110 ) & & @xmath125 & @xmath107 & @xmath126 & @xmath109 & 0.92 ( 109 ) + 9 & 65.9 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & 1.11 ( 109 ) & & @xmath130 & @xmath58 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & 1.03 ( 108 ) + 10 & 54.0 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 & 0.88 ( 75 ) & & @xmath136 & @xmath137 & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & 0.79 ( 74 ) in this section , we connect the xis and hxd spectra , which is crucial for a quantitative study of the cutoff structure and also for multi - wavelength study described in [ subsec : mws ] .
in order to study the general characteristics of the emission from rx j1713.7@xmath03946 , the xis and hxd spectra obtained in [ subsec : xis_ana]/[subsec : hxd_ana ] were co - added .
then , the summed xis and hxd spectra were scaled to account for the flux from the whole remnant , which makes it easier not only to connect the xis and hxd spectra but also to compare the combined spectrum directly to those of other wavelengths in [ subsec : mws ] . in scaling the spectra to the whole remnant
, we assumed the surface brightness of the _ asca _ gis image ( 15 kev ) shown in figure [ fig : obs_fov ] , the angular response of the xis / xrt system ( arfs ) , and that of the hxd pin presented in figure 6 of paper i. the relative normalization factor between xis and hxd derived from crab observations @xcite is included in the scaling .
therefore , the scaled xis and hxd can be connected to each other without additional scaling if no systematic errors are considered .
however , we estimate that the normalization of the xis and hxd spectra obtained by the procedures above should contain systematic errors of 1020% . in order to account for the systematic errors ,
we include a constant normalization factor and deal with this factor as a free parameter when fitting the xis+hxd spectrum below . in this procedure , we discarded the hxd data from pointing 4 since they seem to be contaminated by a nearby hard x - ray source as described in
[ subsec : hxd_spatial ] . before the xis and hxd spectra were jointly analyzed , each co - added spectrum was independently fitted using a power - law function .
table 4 summarizes the fit results .
the hxd spectrum gives an acceptable fit .
in contrast , the xis does not , with a large chi - squared value of @xmath140 for 711 degrees of freedom and residuals that begin to become large at @xmath141 kev .
this fact is clearly seen in figure [ fig : joint_spec_pl ] , where the xis and hxd spectra are plotted together with a power - law function which represents the xis spectrum .
the spectral steepening begins in the xis band and continues smoothly into the hxd band .
this plot strongly suggests that spectral steepening occurs around 10 kev .
we have already reported such a spectral feature in paper i for pointing 0 data .
the same kind of feature has been revealed in this spectrum averaged over the snr , which suggests that the spectral steepening is common in the entire region .
we then quantitatively evaluated the spectral steepening by fitting a model with a cutoff structure to the combined xis / hxd spectrum .
below we use our numerically calculated synchrotron spectrum which was embedded into the xspec package . as an electron distribution , we adopt a generalized form , namely , @xmath142\label{eq : e_spec},\end{aligned}\ ] ] instead of taking a simple _ exponential cutoff _ often used in the literature . here , @xmath143 represents index of electron spectrum and @xmath144 determines rapidity of high - energy cutoff .
the photon spectrum can be calculated as @xmath145 here the function @xmath146 is defined as @xmath147 where @xmath148 is the modified bessel function of 5/3 order .
when pitch angles are isotropic , the characteristic photon energy @xmath149 is given as @xmath150 the model consists of four parameters : @xmath143 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 , and the flux normalization .
photon spectra were calculated and tabulated for reasonable ranges of the four parameters , to be used as an xspec table model .
the parameters characterizing the electron energy distribution can be obtained directly from the fit to the x - ray data . for rx j1713.7@xmath03946 ,
the most probable value for @xmath143 is 3.0 rather than 2.0 due to significant synchrotron cooling of electrons during the lifetime of the snr @xmath153 ( @xmath154 ) . the electron spectrum becomes steeper by a factor of 1 ( @xmath155 ) , when the injection of electrons is constant and the lifetime @xmath153 is smaller than the time scale of synchrotron cooling @xmath156 .
since @xmath156 can be written as @xmath157 the condition above is satisfied in the energy range , @xmath158 to explain the variability of x - ray emission reported on a year timescale from compact regions of the shell of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 , @xcite proposed that the magnetic field in these compact regions is amplified to 1 mg .
the average large - scale magnetic field in the remnant should be significantly lower , but even for @xmath159 the above condition in the x - ray domain is safely satisfied .
therefore , for a strong shock with a compression ratio of 4.0 , the index of x - ray emitting electrons should be close to @xmath160 .
we fitted the _
spectrum with the synchrotron spectrum described above . in the fitting procedure
, we fixed the electron index @xmath143 .
table 5 summarizes the result in the case of @xmath160 , which corresponds to the most probable case following the discussion above .
we also present results when @xmath161 for comparison .
this case can be realized if the magnetic field and/or the age of the remnant are much smaller than we expect , as is seen in equation ( [ eq : ebreak ] ) .
the spectral fitting with the electron index of @xmath160 yields rather rapid steepening with @xmath162 compared to the conventionally used _
exponential cutoff_. however , one should be careful with the physical interpretation of the fit based on equation ( [ eq : e_spec ] ) .
indeed , while the electron spectrum is derived from the broad - band _ suzaku _ x - ray data assuming a specific spectral form given by equation ( [ eq : e_spec ] ) , the curve 1 in figure [ fig : cutoff_hikaku ] has a more general meaning .
it does not depend on the assumed analytical presentation and , in fact , relates _
uniquely _ the energy spectrum of electrons to the measured x - ray spectrum .
indeed , the curve 1 can be presented in different mathematical forms . in particular , the electron spectrum shown by curve 1 in figure [ fig : cutoff_hikaku ] is quite close to the theoretical prediction for the spectrum of shock accelerated electrons in a young snr @xcite , @xmath163^{9/5 } \exp \left [ -\left ( \frac{e}{e_0 } \right)^2 \right ] .
\label{za07_e_spec}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this spectrum is derived under the assumption that electrons are accelerated by a strong shock in the bohm diffusion regime and that the energy losses of electrons are dominated by synchrotron cooling .
it is seen that the energy spectrum below the cutoff is described by a function which deviates from a pure power - law form , by an exponential term with @xmath164 .
the latter has a simple physical interpretation and is a result of combination of two effects acceleration in the bohm diffusion regime , and energy losses in the synchrotron regime .
the curve 2 shown in figure 12 is calculated for the parameter @xmath165 .
the energy spectrum of synchrotron radiation corresponding to the electron spectrum given by equation ( [ za07_e_spec ] ) has a form @xcite @xmath166^{2.29 } \exp \left [ -\left ( \frac{\varepsilon}{\varepsilon_0 } \right)^{1/2 } \right ] .
\label{za07_sync_spec}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this spectrum fits well the broad - band _ suzaku _ x - ray data for a single parameter @xmath167 kev .
note that the exponential term in the synchrotron spectrum is a weak function of energy ( @xmath168 $ ] ) ; therefore the characteristic energy @xmath169 only formally can be considered as the cutoff energy .
in fact , for the shape given by equation ( [ za07_sync_spec ] ) , the break in the spectrum starts at much higher energies ( @xmath170 ) .
ccccc [ tab : xishxd_all_plfit ] xis ( 0.412 kev ) & @xmath171 & @xmath172 & @xmath173 & 1.57 ( 711 ) + hxd ( 1240 kev ) & & @xmath174 & @xmath175 & 1.16 ( 67 ) cccccc [ tab : xishxd_all_modelfit ] electron distribution & @xmath176 & @xmath177 & @xmath178 ( fixed ) , @xmath162 , @xmath179 & @xmath180 & 1.11 ( 778 ) + of equation ( [ eq : e_spec ] ) & @xmath181 & @xmath182 & @xmath183 ( fixed ) , @xmath184 , @xmath185 & @xmath186 & 1.07 ( 778 ) + z&a ( 2007 ) & @xmath187 & @xmath188 & @xmath189 & @xmath180 & 1.11 ( 779 ) the high quality data of _ suzaku _ obtained over two decades in energy and combined with the tev gamma ray data , allow definite conclusions concerning the origin of multi - tev parent particles based on the comparison of model predictions with observations . in particular it is important that the _ suzaku _ data provide unambiguous information about the shape of the energy spectrum of electrons in the cutoff region .
figure [ fig : sed ] shows the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) , @xmath190 , of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 from radio to tev energies .
the x - ray data correspond to the entire remnant ; they are reconstructed assuming the best - fit model given by equation ( [ za07_sync_spec ] ) corrected for the interstellar absorption with @xmath191 .
the points in the tev gamma - ray range corresponding to the fluxes of the whole remnant , are from the latest report of the h.e.s.s .
collaboration @xcite .
the egret upper limit is taken from @xcite ; it is obtained through modeling and subtracting the resolved egret source 3eg 1714@xmath03857 @xcite .
the two data points in the radio band are shown as measured with the atca telescope @xcite .
but it should be noted that these fluxes are detected only from the nw rim region , therefore they should be treated as lower limits when compared to model predictions for the whole remnant .
the recent estimates based on observations with atca and the 30-m radiotelescope ira show that the flux of the entire remnant should be a factor of few larger than the flux of the nw rim ( f. acero et al .
2008 , in preparation ; g. dubner 2008 , private communications ) . in figure
[ fig : sed ] we show theoretical fluxes of broad - band electromagnetic radiation produced by both accelerated electrons and protons .
the results depend strongly on the strength of the average magnetic field @xmath192 .
although the magnetic field in compact filaments can be as large as @xmath193 @xcite , the field in less bright and more diffuse regions where the bulk of the synchrotron x - ray emission is produced , should be significantly weaker . yet ,
a moderately large field exceeding @xmath194 is required to explain the x - ray flux ratio between the diffuse and compact zones . the integrated x - ray flux from the diffuse zone ( zone 1 ) is larger by a factor of @xmath195 than that from the compact zone ( zone 2 ) : @xmath196 @xcite .
using the ratio of the emission volumes estimated from the x - ray image ( @xmath197 ) , the number density of x - ray emitting electrons , @xmath198 , in the zone 2 relative to the zone 1 is estimated as @xmath199 . for @xmath200 , and assuming @xmath201 , one finds @xmath202 . in figure
[ fig : sed ] the synchrotron , inverse compton ( ic ) , and @xmath10-decay fluxes are calculated assuming strong uniform magnetic field of strength @xmath203 .
the calculations are performed with constant injection of electrons and protons over the last 1000 yr . the injection spectrum for both electrons and protons is assumed to be a power - law with an index @xmath183 . for calculations of ic fluxes we used the diffuse photon fields proposed by @xcite , including 2.7
k cmb , as well as interstellar radiation consisting of two , optical ( starlight ) and infrared ( dust ) emission components .
the best fits for the synchrotron radiation and @xmath10-decay gamma rays are achieved for cutoffs in the energy distributions of electrons and protons at 28.4 tev and 130 tev , respectively .
the spectra of @xmath10-decay gamma rays are calculated using the analytical presentations by @xcite .
since the highest energy tail of the observed gamma - ray spectrum is best fitted with @xmath204 $ ] with @xmath205 @xcite , the proton spectrum in the cutoff region should have an exponential behavior , @xmath206 ( see @xcite ) .
the electrons suffer synchrotron losses , thus the electron spectrum above a certain energy becomes steeper ( @xmath207 ) .
the position of the break in the electron spectrum appears at @xmath208 for a magnetic field @xmath209 and age of the source @xmath210 yr , the spectral break in the synchrotron spectrum corresponding to the transition of the electrons spectrum from uncooled to cooled regime , appears around 1 ev ( see figure [ fig : sed ] ) .
thus , for young snrs the detection of the synchrotron break at optical / infrared wavelengths would be an additional argument in favor of strong magnetic field .
the cooling break in the electron spectrum is reflected also in the gamma - ray band .
namely , for @xmath209 the corresponding signature in the ic gamma - ray spectrum appears around 10 gev .
unfortunately ( see figure [ fig : sed ] ) , for such a strong magnetic field , the ic component is suppressed , and falls well below the sensitivity of gamma - ray detectors in this energy band , including _
glast_. at the presence of such a strong magnetic field , the only viable mechanism which can produce tev gamma - rays at the flux level detected by h.e.s.s . is related to interactions of ultrarelativistic protons with ambient gas through production and decay of @xmath10-mesons . to explain the detected flux of gamma - rays protons
should be accelerated to energies well beyond 100 tev , and the parameter @xmath211 should be between 1.53 , depending on the spectrum of protons . in order to increase the ic flux to the level of the observed tev gamma - ray flux , the magnetic field
should be reduced down to @xmath212 and @xmath213 . for the given magnetic field ,
the high quality x - ray data of _ suzaku _ obtained over two energy decades allow derivation of the electron spectrum with high accuracy within the interval covering one energy decade : from @xmath214 to @xmath215 .
this allows us to calculate the spectrum and absolute flux of ic gamma rays above a few tev without any model assumptions , as long as the main target for the ic gamma - ray production remains the 2.7 k cmb .
the contribution of the diffuse optical / infrared radiation fields generally is less , however the optical photons may provide enhanced tev emission at low , sub - tev energies . for calculations of the ic spectrum we used the interstellar radiation model of @xcite , who proposed significantly larger flux of optical and infrared components compared to
the generally accepted flux .
however , the results presented in figure [ fig : sed_leptonic ] show that even this high diffuse optical and infrared radiation fails to account for the observed gamma - ray flux below a few tev . in order to fill this gap one needs to assume an unreasonably large density of optical radiation .
this is demonstrated in figure [ fig : sed_leptonic_opt ] , where an agreement of ic calculations with the reported gamma - ray fluxes is achieved assuming an additional , although in our view quite unrealistic , component of optical radiation with a density of @xmath216 .
it should be noted that the problem of explanation of low energy gamma rays in figure [ fig : sed_leptonic ] is related to the large energy of the break in the electron spectrum given by equation ( [ eq : ebreak_electron ] ) , and correspondingly to the position of the compton peak which appears above 1 tev in the spectral energy distribution of gamma rays .
thus , the reduction of the break energy down to 200 gev could in principle solve the problem .
however , since the magnetic field in this model can not exceed @xmath213 , the only way to shift the compton peak to sub - tev energies is to assume that the supernova remnant is older than @xmath217 yr . an alternative solution for explanation of gamma - ray data within the ic models is to assume a higher density of relativistic electrons responsible for @xmath218 tev gamma rays , i.e. to postulate a second , low - energy electron component in the shell .
formally this assumption does not _ a priori _ contradict the observations since the additional electrons are required to be present below 20 tev , i.e. in the energy range which is not constrained by _ suzaku _ observations ( for production of the lowest energy x - rays detected by _ suzaku _ in a magnetic field of @xmath213 the electron energy must exceed 40 tev ) .
the results calculated under such assumption are shown in figure [ fig : sed_leptonic_2ele ] .
the second electron component is assumed to have a power - law injection spectrum with the same index as the first ( main ) component , @xmath183 , but with a high energy cutoff around 10 tev .
the latter is required to prevent the conflict with the observed gamma - ray spectrum above 1 tev . a comparison between the x - ray and the tev gamma - ray morphology is expected to provide information about the acceleration / emission processes .
as is already shown in figure [ fig : xis_hess_image ] , the _ suzaku _ xis image revealed a significant correlation with that of h.e.s.s .
telescopes not only in the bright structures but also in the dim regions of the remnant . in the following ,
the two images are compared with each other on a more quantitative basis .
it should be taken into account that the x - ray morphology can be affected by the spatial distribution of absorption column density , @xmath13 . in order to avoid the effect ,
here we disregard the energy band lower than 1 kev , and use two energy intervals , 25 kev and 510 kev , for comparison . for the @xmath13 variation as shown in table 3 , the count rate can vary by 5% and 0.7% in the 25 kev band and 510 kev band , respectively .
one should also take into account the difference of point spread functions between _ suzaku _ xis and h.e.s.s . when comparing the two images . to prevent this , we compare surface brightness for each square region with a size of @xmath219 , which is larger than the point spread functions of either observatory .
the regions are indicated with green dashed lines in figure [ fig : mosaic_image_sqreg ] .
figure [ fig : plot_kev_vs_tev ] shows a scatter plot between the _ suzaku _ xis count rate ( @xmath220 ) and that of h.e.s.s .
( @xmath221 ) .
as seen in this plot , the x - ray count maps correlate strongly with the gamma - ray count map .
the correlation coefficients are calculated to be 0.85 and 0.83 , for 25 kev band and 510 kev band , respectively .
it is worth noting that there are some deviations ( x - ray intensity excesses ) in the bright regions .
figure [ fig : map_kev - tev ] shows a map of @xmath222 ( for 25 kev band ) overlaid with the h.e.s.s .
contours , in which one can see that the x - ray excesses are present along the nw and sw rims .
we conducted a series of _ suzaku _ observations which covers about two - thirds of the surface of snr rx j1713.7@xmath03946 . through the data analysis , we successfully detected signals up to @xmath223 kev from each of the pointings .
the hxd spectra above 10 kev are significantly steeper than those obtained from the xis below 10 kev , suggesting that a spectral cutoff is common throughout the remnant . by combining the xis and hxd spectra
, we obtained a wide - band spectrum with high statistics , which clearly shows a cutoff around 10 kev .
taking advantage of the high photon statistics , we performed a detailed study of the cutoff shape and compared it with a recent theoretical prediction by @xcite .
a sharp cutoff of the accelerated electron spectrum is needed to reproduce the cutoff shape in the synchrotron spectrum detected with _
suzaku_. the spectrum of electrons derived from _ suzaku _
data is in good agreement with the analytical model of @xcite .
the cutoff energy in the spectrum of synchrotron radiation contains an important information about the efficiency of diffusive shock acceleration . for acceleration in the bohm diffusion regime and when
energy losses of electrons are dominated by synchrotron cooling , the cutoff energy , @xmath169 in equation ( [ za07_sync_spec ] ) is expressed as @xcite @xmath224 where @xmath225 is the shock speed and @xmath226 is the so - called `` gyrofactor '' . the case of @xmath227 corresponds to the `` bohm limit '' , and implies high level of turbulence @xmath228 .
the _ suzaku _
spectrum is characterized by the best - fit parameter @xmath229 which gives @xmath230 . here
, we assume that the shock speed @xmath225 is uniform throughout the remnant , which is supported by the fact that the outer boundary of the x - ray morphology is nearly circular .
the upper - limit of the shock speed @xmath231 derived from the _ chandra _ data @xcite , results in @xmath232 .
this is a strong evidence of acceleration of electrons in the regime close to the bohm limit .
note that a similar result was obtained for the sw rim of the remnant in @xcite .
here we confirm this conclusion for a larger area of the remnant with higher statistics . while there is little doubt in the synchrotron origin of broad - band x - ray emission measured by _ suzaku _ , the x - ray spectrum alone does not give preference to the strength of the magnetic field in the region of production of synchrotron radiation .
formally , the field can be as small as @xmath233 and as large as @xmath194 .
meanwhile , the strength of the magnetic field has dramatic impact on the origin of tev gamma - rays .
the so - called leptonic or inverse compton models require magnetic field between @xmath212 and @xmath213 .
even so , it is difficult to achieve , at least within a simple one - zone model , a satisfactory explanation of both x - ray and tev gamma - ray spectral features , unless we invoke an extremely high diffuse radiation field of optical photons to enhance the ic gamma - radiation below 1 tev ( see figure [ fig : sed_leptonic_opt ] ) .
a more realistic approach for explanation of the broad - band tev gamma - ray spectrum within ic models can be realized under the assumption of existence an additional , low - energy electron component in the shell ( see figure [ fig : sed_leptonic_2ele ] ) .
even so , the most serious problem for ic models remains the requirement of low magnetic field in the gamma - ray production region , in contrast to large magnetic field required to explain the fast variability of x - ray emission on small scales .
formally , one may assume that gamma - rays are mainly produced in `` voids '' , i.e. in regions with very low magnetic field .
this would imply quite inhomogeneous distribution of the magnetic field in the shell .
one the other hand , the observed strong x - ray and tev correlation within the ic models can be explained only in the case of homogeneous distribution of magnetic field .
the large - scale magnetic fields on parsec scales with an average strength larger than @xmath234 make the ic gamma - ray production inefficient , and thus give preference to the so - called hadronic models of gamma - rays produced at interactions of accelerated protons with the ambient gas via production and decay of secondary @xmath10-mesons .
what concerns x - rays , they are produced , as in leptonic models , by synchrotron radiation of directly accelerated electrons .
this is demonstrated in figure [ fig : sed ] for very strong magnetic field , @xmath203 . note that while comparing the model predictions with measurements in the radio band , one should take into account that the radio points shown correspond to measurements of nw rim , while the x - ray and gamma - ray points are for the entire remnant .
if the ratio of the radio flux from the nw rim to that from the whole remnant is not much different from the corresponding ratio in x - rays , the flux from the whole snr should be significantly larger .
this would reduce the difference between the measurements and predictions . in any case
, the radio flux can be significantly reduced assuming somewhat smaller magnetic field or harder electron spectrum . indeed , in figure
[ fig : sed_100ug ] we show model calculations performed for a magnetic field @xmath235 . while the synchrotron x - ray flux is described perfectly as before ( in figure [ fig : sed ] ) , the radio flux is by a factor of four lower ; at 1.4 ghz it is 34 jy , which is close to the latest estimates of radio flux from the whole remnant based on observations with atca and the 30-m radio telescopes of ira ( f. acero et al .
2008 , in preparation ; g. dubner 2008 , private communications ) . the radio flux can be suppressed even for the ambient field larger than @xmath236 , provided that the electron injection spectrum is harder than @xmath237 .
figure [ fig : sed_17 ] demonstrates this possibility , where we assume an electron / proton index of @xmath238 which corresponds to a compression ratio of @xmath239 .
note that @xmath240 can exceed the adiabatic upper limit of 4 as described by @xcite .
note that the value of @xmath238 is consistent with the conclusion of @xcite based on semi - analytical derivation of the parent proton spectrum from the h.e.s.s .
data . in model calculations shown in figure [ fig :
sed_17 ] , the spectrum of protons requires an `` early '' exponential cutoff at @xmath241 .
note that formally the spectral index @xmath242 implies shock acceleration in non - linear regime which in fact predicts some deviation from pure power - law distribution of accelerated particles ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
this would lead to further reduction of the radio flux .
the convection of low energy electrons could be another reason for low radio flux .
note that the escape of electrons through convection has strong impact only on low energy electrons ; because of fast synchrotron cooling , the effect of escape is negligible for multi - tev electrons .
a significant quantity of low - energy electrons can escape from the shell of the snr before emitting radio photons .
therefore , the radio flux can be reduced while the x - ray flux will remain unchanged . for calculations shown in figure [ fig : sed ] ,
the total energy of electrons is estimated as @xmath243 , and the energy for protons as @xmath244 . in the case of harder energy spectra with power - law index
@xmath242 corresponding to figure [ fig : sed_17 ] , one has @xmath245 , and @xmath246 , respectively .
the proton / electron ratio in either case is very small , @xmath247 .
this value is significantly smaller than that for directly observed local cosmic rays ( @xmath248 ) , unless a large ambient matter density of @xmath249 is assumed .
@xcite and @xcite argued that the hadronic scenario for this snr has difficulties because the @xmath250 value should be consistent with local cosmic rays and other snrs .
however , the @xmath250 value of one snr at a fixed age does not necessarily need to agree with the local cosmic ray value .
the low - energy electrons are likely produced in later stages of snr evolution , when the @xmath250 value can be different from the present value .
a comparison with other snrs should be performed with care , as well .
cutoff energy in the gamma - ray spectrum should give an important hint whether snrs are sources of cosmic rays below the _ knee _ , if gamma rays observed by h.e.s.s . have hadronic origins .
@xcite argued that the cutoff energy of the h.e.s.s .
spectrum of rx j1713@xmath03946 is around 18 tev , which can be translated to proton energy more than 10 times below the energy of the _ knee_. indeed our multi - wavelength study requires a cutoff in the proton spectrum around 100 tev or even less for hard acceleration spectra of protons .
however , one should take into account that even in the case of effective acceleration the highest energy protons beyond 100 tev escape the source in a quite short time scales , and hence do not contribute to the gamma - ray production at the present epoch @xcite . a unique feature of rx j 1713.7 - 3946 is the lack of thermal x - ray emission .
recently , @xcite and @xcite interpreted this fact as an argument against the hadronic model for tev gamma rays .
generally it is true that plasma in young supernova remnants is heated to high temperatures observed via thermal x - ray emission of hot electrons .
however , one should take into account that we deal with a unique object , and the lack of thermal x - ray emission can not _ a priori _ be invoked as an argument against the hadronic origin of the observed tev gamma rays .
it is important to note that in snr shocks the formation of high plasma temperatures with @xmath251 is relevant only to protons ( ions ) , and that a high ion temperature does not automatically ( from first principles ) mean a high electron temperature .
in fact , the only known heating process of thermal electrons is coulomb collisions between electrons and protons ( ions ) , which , however , has too long time scale to establish electron - proton equipartition . on the other hand , we do know from x - ray observations that the electrons in young snrs are heated to kev temperatures .
this can be explained by assuming that a hypothetical mechanism , most likely related to the energy exchange through excited plasma waves , is responsible for effective electron heating in snrs .
as long as the nature of this mechanism in collisionless shocks remains unknown , one can not predict , even qualitatively , the specifics of its operation on a source by source basis .
we indeed deal with two interesting facts .
first , many young snrs , like tycho and cassiopeia a , with intense thermal x - ray emission and intense nonthermal radio emission emit little ( or do not emit at all ) tev gamma rays . on the other hand , rx j1713.7@xmath03946 , with lack of ( or rather very low ) thermal x - ray emission and with relatively weak nonthermal radio emission , is a source of powerful tev radiation .
these two facts can be treated as a hint for low efficiency of establishing equipartition in the thermal plasma in very effective tev particle accelerators like rx j1713.7@xmath03946 .
it is interesting to note in this regard , that such a tendency is found also for another effective tev accelerator sn 1006 @xcite .
whether the reduction of the exchange rate between different particle species in thermal plasma has a link to the particle acceleration in high mach number shocks , as proposed by @xcite , is a very interesting question to be explored in future deep theoretical and phenomenological studies . in this regard ,
rx j1713.7@xmath03946 can serve as a key `` template '' source for such studies .
@xcite also discussed low electron temperature based on _ chandra _ observations of a young snr in the small magellanic could , 1e 0102.2@xmath07219 .
they measured a blast - wave velocity of @xmath252 from the expansion rate and predicted the electron temperature of @xmath253 by considering coulomb heating .
however , the electron temperature derived from their spectral analysis is 0.5 kev , which is far below the prediction . according to their discussion , not only electron heating but also ion heating is suppressed and substantial fraction of energy
may be going into cosmic - ray production due to the non - linear effects in the shock .
the nonlinear shock acceleration in this object can convert a significant , up to @xmath254 fraction of the kinetic energy of explosion into relativistic particles .
correspondingly the fraction of available energy which goes to the heating of the ambient plasma will be reduced @xmath255 . yet
, conservative estimates show that plasma in rx j1713.7@xmath03946 can be heated to quite high temperatures even the heating of electrons and protons proceeds only through the coulomb exchange .
this question recently has studied by @xcite for a standard snr of age @xmath256 yr and energy @xmath257 erg . in particular
, it has been shown that in the case of effective diffusive shock acceleration and the plasma density @xmath258 , the ratio of synchrotron luminosity to thermal ( bremsstrahlung ) luminosity can be as large as 100 .
this implies that in the case of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 , from which thermal x - ray emission is not observed , the plasma density can not significantly exceed @xmath259 ( the luminosity of thermal bremsstrahlung is proportional to @xmath260 ) .
the low density of order of @xmath259 reduces the parameter space for hadronic models but does not exclude it . indeed , as mentioned above , the tev gamma - ray flux of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 can be explained by interactions of protons if the parameter @xmath261 exceeds 1.5 to 3 , depending on the spectrum of protons . assuming that more than @xmath262 of the explosion energy of this snr is released in accelerated protons , and that the plasma in the gamma - ray production region is compressed by a factor of few , we find that the located of the source at a distance of about 1 kpc would marginally support the hadronic model . while closer location of the source would make the model requirements quite viable and flexible , the location of the source beyond 1
kpc hardly can be accommodated within a standard shock acceleration scenario .
if the snr is closer , the distance of @xmath263 seems reasonable considering the upper limit on the shock speed of @xmath264 by @xcite .
finally we should mention the model suggested by @xcite which can naturally explain both the low synchrotron flux at radio frequencies and lack of thermal x - ray emission of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 .
the standard scenarios of gamma - ray production in snrs assume that radiation is produced in downstream where the density of both relativistic particles and thermal plasma is higher than in upstream .
however , in the cases when the shock is expanding into a low - density wind bubble and approaching cold dense material , e.g. swept - up shell or surrounding molecular clouds , the gamma - radiation is contributed predominantly from upstream .
while the energy distribution of accelerated particles downstream is coordinate - independent in both linear and nonlinear regimes , the particle distribution upstream is coordinate - dependent . because of energy - dependent diffusion coefficient , the high - energy particles diffuse ahead of low - energy particles , thus a dense material adjacent upstream will `` see '' relativistic particles ( protons and electrons ) with low - energy exponential cutoff , @xmath265 , which depends on the location of the dense regions .
this implies that the effective production of tev gamma - rays ( from _ p - p _ interactions ) and x - rays ( from synchrotron radiation of tev electrons ) will be not accompanied by low energy ( gev ) gamma - rays and synchrotron radio emission . obviously , this model is not constraint by lack of thermal emission .
in addition to the spectral information , the comparison of x - ray and tev gamma - ray images presented in figure [ fig : plot_kev_vs_tev ] helps us to draw the physical picture of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 .
let us first discuss the tight correlation observed in most parts of the remnant . within the hypothesis of hadronic origin of gamma - rays ,
the gamma - ray flux is proportional to the number densities of the ambient matter and relativistic protons , while the x - ray flux is proportional to number density of electrons . if the matter distribution significantly varies throughout the snr , we need fine parameter tuning among the matter distribution , the electron injection rate , and the proton injection rate , in order to produce the tight correlation . therefore , more natural explanation is that the matter density is uniform and the injection rate of the electrons and that of the protons are proportional to each other .
the x - ray flux excess along the nw and sw rims provides a unique probe of recent acceleration activity .
let us consider a `` toy '' model and compare its predictions with the observational results . in the toy model ,
the injection rate of electrons and protons keeps constant but increases by a factor of 1.5 in the last 10 yr only at the nw and sw rims .
what is important here is the difference of cooling time between electrons and protons .
the synchrotron cooling time of an electron emitting synchrotron photons with energy of @xmath266 is given as equation ( [ eq : sync_cooling_time ] ) , while the cooling time of protons due to @xmath267-@xmath267 interactions is expressed as @xmath268 and is almost energy - independent .
for the magnetic field @xmath269 , the cooling times of electrons emitting 2 kev and 5 kev x - rays are @xmath270 and @xmath271 , respectively . for any reasonable density of ambient gas , the cooling time of protons
is much longer than the lifetime of this snr . while the synchrotron x - rays we observe at present are emitted by electrons accelerated during the last @xmath272 .
the flux of @xmath10-decay gamma rays is provided by protons accelerated throughout the lifetime of the snr .
figure [ fig : plot_kev_vs_tev_toymodel ] shows the scatter plot of @xmath220 and @xmath221 expected from the toy model , which shows a similar distribution to the observational results in figure [ fig : plot_kev_vs_tev ] .
the recent active acceleration increases the x - ray flux while keeping the gamma - ray flux almost unchanged .
we observed snr rx j1713.7@xmath03946 with the _ suzaku _ observatory .
hard x - rays up to @xmath1 are detected from each of the 11 pointings .
the hard x - ray morphology estimated by the hxd pin data is generally consistent with an extrapolation of that in the energy region below 10 kev .
when the hxd spectra are fitted with a power law , the photon indices are larger than those obtained from the xis data .
the difference of photon indices between the xis and the hxd varies from region to region . although this may suggest a variation of spectral shape or cutoff energy , the fov of the hxd pin is not small enough to allow detailed imaging spectroscopy .
such studies will become possible with upcoming missions with hard x - ray mirrors like _ next _ , _ nustar _ , or _
simbol - x_. moreover these missions will extend the effective studies up to 100 kev .
if the tev gamma - ray emission of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 is of hadronic origin , this should allow detection and study of synchrotron x - ray emission of electrons produced in proton - proton interactions via decays of secondary charged pions @xcite .
in this regard , the above mentioned missions can provide very effective tools for deep ( at the level as low as @xmath273 ) probes of hadronic processes in snrs in the @xmath274 tev energy regime with unprecedented ( subarcmin ) angular resolution .
using the xis and hxd data , we obtained a synchrotron spectrum in the energy range of two decades ( 0.440 kev ) , which means we can probe the parent electron distribution in the energy range of one decade regardless of the magnetic field strength .
the wide - band coverage enables us to see a clear high - energy cutoff in the synchrotron spectrum , and for the first time allows detailed studies of the cutoff shape and derivation of the spectrum of the parent electrons . the spectral shape in the cutoff region was quantitatively evaluated , which revealed that the cutoff shape is compatible with a theoretical prediction by @xcite .
based on their model , the cutoff energy is obtained as @xmath275 .
this result , together with upper limit of the shock velocity from _ chandra _ @xcite , indicates that acceleration efficiency in this remnant approaches the bohm limit .
we modeled the multi - wavelength spectrum of rx j1713.7@xmath03946 within both the leptonic and hadronic gamma - ray production scenarios .
the hadronic model nicely fits the data while it seems difficult to explain all observational data with a simple leptonic model .
the major problem with leptonic models is related to the requirement of low magnetic field , @xmath276 which does not agree with the recent discovery of variability of local regions of the shell on year timescales .
the hadronic models recently have be criticized based on the lack of thermal emission and low radio flux .
however , these fact can be accommodated within a standard shock acceleration model in a young snr with magnetic field as large as @xmath236 , plasma density @xmath277 , and distance to the source @xmath278 , assuming that more than 30% of energy of explosion is released in relativistic protons with spectrum as hard as @xmath237 and exponential cutoff around 100 tev .
finally , besides the general strong correlation between x - ray and tev gamma - ray emission , we found an excess x - ray emission compared to gamma - ray emission in the brightest regions of the remnant .
this excess can be explained by recent activity accompanied by effective acceleration of electrons in localised reagions of the shell .
the authors would like to thank all the members of the _ suzaku _ science working group for their help in the spacecraft operation , instrumental calibration , and data processing .
the authors thank una hwang for carefully reading the manuscript and stefan funk for assisting with the comparison of the morphologies with the h.e.s.s . data and for his helpful comments on the manuscript .
the authors also thank misha malkov and vladimir zirakashvili for discussions related to different aspects of the diffusive shock acceleration theory . t.
tanaka and a. bamba are supported by research fellowships of the japan society for the promotion of science for young scientists . | we present results obtained from a series of observations of the supernova remnant rx j1713.7@xmath03946 by the _ suzaku _ satellite which cover about two - thirds of the remnant surface .
hard x - rays have been detected from each pointing up to @xmath1 .
the hard x - ray spectra are described by power - law functions with photon indices of @xmath2 , which are larger than those in the energy region below 10 kev .
the combination of the spatially - integrated xis and hxd spectra clearly reveals a spectral cutoff in the x - ray spectrum which is linked to the maximum energy of accelerated electrons emitting synchrotron radiation .
the broad - band coverage of _ suzaku _ observations from 0.4 kev to 40 kev allows us to derive , for the first time , the energy spectrum of parent electrons in the cutoff region .
the inferred cutoff energy in the spatially - integrated x - ray spectrum indicates that the electron acceleration in the remnant proceeds close to the bohm - diffusion limit .
we discuss implications of the spectral and morphological properties of _ suzaku _ data in the context of the origin of nonthermal emission .
the _ suzaku _
x - ray and the h.e.s.s .
tev gamma - ray data together hardly can be explained within a pure leptonic scenario , unless we introduce an additional component of relativistic electrons with softer energy spectrum .
moreover , the leptonic models require very weak magnetic field which does not agree with the recently discovered filamentary structure and short - term variability features of the x - ray emitting region .
the hadronic models with strong magnetic field provide perfect fits to the observed x - ray and tev gamma - ray spectra through the synchrotron radiation of electrons and _ p - p _ interactions of protons , but require special arrangements of model parameters to explain the lack of thermal component of x - ray emission . for the morphology studies , we compare the x - ray an tev gama - ray surface brightness maps using the _ suzaku _ xis and the h.e.s.s .
data .
we confirm the previously reported strong correlation between x - ray and tev gamma - ray emission components . at the same time
the _ suzaku _ data reveal a deviation from the general tendency , namely , the x - ray emission in the western rim regions appears brighter than expected from the average x - ray to gamma - ray ratio . |
aharonov and bohm @xcite pointed out that a charged quantum particle may acquire an observable phase shift by circling around a completely shielded magnetic flux .
this remarkable effect is purely non - classical as the electromagnetic field vanishes at the location of the particle , which thereby experiences no lorentz force .
the origin of the phase shift is topological : it only depends on the winding number of the particle s path around the magnetic flux .
the original aharonov - bohm ( ab ) setup for electric charge belongs to a larger class of topological phase effects .
this includes topological phase shifts arising for electrically neutral particles in certain electromagnetic configurations @xcite as well as in general quantum systems that undergo adiabatic evolution @xcite .
a paradigmatic example of the latter is a molecule that acquires an ab phase shift when it reshapes slowly around a conical intersection in nuclear configuration space @xcite .
this adiabatic ab effect is imprinted in the spectral properties related to the pseudorotational molecular motion , and has been observed @xcite in the metallic trimer na@xmath0 .
it has further been predicted @xcite in scattering - type chemical reactions , such as in the hydrogen exchange reaction @xmath1 . due to subtle cancellation effects
, however , direct observation of the ab effect in molecular scattering has been elusive in the past @xcite .
matter waves in spatially varying electromagnetic fields is a tool to engineer a wide range of quantum effects @xcite .
if the variation of these fields is sufficiently slow , the particle motion is governed by adiabatic gauge fields @xcite similar to those in molecules and has been proposed to give rise to ab phase shifts under certain conditions @xcite . here
, we develop an adiabatic ab effect for matter waves that scatter on a static inhomogeneous magnetic field produced by a current - carrying wire .
the setup uses the quantum properties of neutrons to induce the ab effect .
earlier experimental demonstrations of other topological phase effects , such as the aharonov - casher @xcite and scalar ab phase shifts @xcite , as well as related berry phase induced spinor rotations @xcite , have shown that neutrons are suitable to realize ab effects due to their robust internal structure , the ease of detecting them with almost 100 % efficiency , and their weak coupling to the environment .
our setup is similar to the one proposed in ref .
@xcite for a nanoelectronic system .
imagine a colimated beam of neutrons that scatter on a long straight wire of radius @xmath2 , carrying an electrical current @xmath3 .
the resulting magnetic field is given by biot - savart s law @xmath4 where we have assumed that the wire points along the @xmath5-axis and carries a uniform current density .
here , @xmath6 is the polar angle in cylindrical coordinates with corresponding basis vector @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the distance from the wire in units of @xmath2 , and @xmath9 is permeability of vacuum .
the magnetic field induces a local energy splitting of the neutron spin states , as described by the zeeman hamiltonian @xmath10 with @xmath11 j / t the neutron magnetic moment and @xmath12 the standard pauli operators representing the neutron spin .
the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian are @xmath13 , which introduce a potential energy barrier ( well ) of height @xmath14 ( depth @xmath15 ) at the surface of the wire .
the hamiltonian relevant for the ab effect is given by the kinetic energy of the neutron in the @xmath16 plane , plus the hamiltonian describing the neutron spin , i.e. , @xmath17 we write the total wave function as @xmath18 , where @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the local spin eigenvectors with @xmath21 , @xmath22 .
the two spin eigenstates are associated with the potential energies @xmath23 . here ,
@xmath24 ( dimensionless time ) with @xmath25 kg being the neutron mass . to determine the spatial wave functions @xmath26 we eliminate the spin degree of freedom by multiplying the schrdinger equation with @xmath27 yielding the coupled equations @xmath28 \varphi_{\pm } ( { \bf r},s ) \nonumber
\\ & & + \left ( \frac{1}{2r^2 } + i \frac{1}{r^2 } \partial_{\theta } \right ) \varphi_{\mp } ( { \bf r},s ) , \label{eq : exact}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath29
. the adiabatic regime is characterized by negligible born - huang potential @xmath30 and off - diagonal coupling terms @xmath31 . for low neutron velocities ,
the wire is impenetrable and the validity of the adiabatic approximation can be checked by comparing the size of the scalar potential @xmath32 and @xmath33 at the surface of the wire .
this yields the adiabatic condition @xmath34 . in this regime
, it follows from eq .
( [ eq : exact ] ) that the spatial wave packets @xmath26 are separately determined by the effective schrdinger equations @xmath35 \varphi_{\pm } ( { \bf r},s ) \label{eq : se}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath36 is the mead - berry vector potential pointing in the @xmath6 direction .
the shift @xmath37 is the key origin of the ab effect .
it originates from the adiabatic elimination of the spin , which introduces the mead - berry vector potential @xcite @xmath38 in the kinetic energy of the neutron .
this defines the effective magnetic flux @xmath39 picked up by the phase when the neutron moves around the wire along a loop @xmath40 . @xmath41
vanishes if the neutron does not encircle the wire .
the vector potential thus corresponds to an ab flux line carrying half a flux unit ( semi - fluxon ) sitting at the conical intersection point at @xmath42 .
the flux - induced phase is a topological property as it depends neither on the detailed shape of the loop @xmath40 nor on the dynamical parameters of the system , such as the electrical current @xmath3 and the speed of the neutron .
a consequence of the topological nature of the phase shift is that for a non - uniform electrical current density , we can predict that there must be an odd number of points at which the magnetic field vanishes inside the wire as each conical intersection carries half a flux unit @xcite .
we numerically simulate an unpolarized neutron that scatters on the wire .
we solve eq .
( [ eq : se ] ) for the two adiabatic channels and calculate the density profile @xmath43 obtained by tracing over the spin .
we choose @xmath44 ma and @xmath45 m , which yields @xmath46 .
the spatial degree of freedom of the neutron is modeled as an incoming gaussian wave packet of @xmath47 @xmath48 m width , whose centre is moving in the @xmath16 plane straight on to the wire at relative velocity @xmath49 .
the wire is assumed to be made of an electrically conducting material with a positive neutron optical potential that can reflect slow neutrons .
an appropriate choice would be copper with a positive optical potential corresponding to a critical neutron velocity of about 5.7 m / s .
we assume neutron velocities @xmath49 well below this critical value , which means that we can take @xmath26 to vanish at @xmath50 . with the chosen @xmath51
, we expect the adiabatic treatment to be valid , which has indeed been confirmed numerically to a high degree of accuracy by comparing the wave packet dynamics arising from eqs .
( [ eq : se ] ) and ( [ eq : exact ] )
. the summation - by - parts simultaneous approximation term ( sbp - sat ) method @xcite is a time - stable well - proven high - order difference methodology suitable for solving wave - dominated phenomena @xcite . in the present study
a sixth - order accurate sbp - sat approximation has been employed , solving eq .
( [ eq : se ] ) with high fidelity . to study the adiabatic ab effect we first compare the dynamics with @xmath52 m / s for @xmath53 and @xmath54 , where the latter case corresponds to ignoring the adiabatic flux .
as seen in fig .
[ fig:1 ] ( see also supplementary movies 1 and 2 ) , the effective ab flux introduces a nodal line in the forward direction , which is not visible when @xmath54 .
this is the key signature of the adiabatic ab effect related to the effective flux line carrying half a flux unit associated with destructive interference in the forward direction @xcite
. it would be directly detectable by measuring the neutron density profile in the @xmath16 plane behind the wire .
we further perform simulations at @xmath55 and @xmath56 m / s , shown in fig . [ fig:2 ] .
the nodal line persists , which demonstrates the nondispersive nature of the ab effect and opens up for the possibility to perform the test even if we allow for a distribution of incoming velocities within the adiabatic regime .
a significant simplification of the experimental setting is that unpolarized neutrons can be used , due to the spatial bifurcation caused by the energy splitting of the two local spin eigenstates .
we demonstrate this effect in terms of the local spin density @xmath57 the scalar part @xmath58 is shown fig .
[ fig:3 ] ( see also supplementary movie 3 ) .
we note that only @xmath59 contributes significantly to the ab phase shift ; the reason being the attractive nature of the adiabatic potential @xmath60 associated with this state for @xmath61 . the low neutron velocities can be experimentally achieved by letting the neutron hit the wire at small angle .
this can be realized for cold neutrons ( speed a few 100 m / s ) initially moving parallel to a horizontal wire .
the bending of the neutron beam in the gravitational field induces a small velocity component @xmath49 towards the wire . for fixed incoming speed , the relative velocity @xmath49
can be controlled either by moving the wire in the vertical direction or by tilting it slightly upwards in the direction of motion . the incoming wave packet used in the numerical simulations
have been chosen to clearly demonstrate the adiabatic ab effect on the spatial distribution of the scattered neutrons . however , to reproduce this wave packet dynamics in an actual experiment would be challenging as it would require a very high angular resolution and precise centering of the neutron beam .
the difficulty is associated with the small size of the wave packet that would decrease the number of neutrons that would hit the wire in the desired manner .
a less demanding setting would require the transversal width of the wave packet to be much larger than the width of the wire as this would allow for higher neutron flux .
the ab - induced destructive interference effect in the forward direction would be intact for such a wave packet , as the ab effect is topological and therefore independent of shape and size of the neutron wave function .
we have demonstrated an adiabatic ab effect for slow neutrons that scatter on a magnetic field produced by an electrical current through a very long wire .
the mechanism of the effect is the berry phase of the neutron spin restricted to the plane perpendicular to the wire .
therefore , the acquired phase shift is restricted to @xmath62 , known to be the only possible non - trivial value of a planar spin .
the @xmath62 phase shift causes destructive intereference in the forward direction , providing an unambigous signature of the adiabatic ab effect in a scattering setup .
we have further demonstrated the nondispersive nature of the effect , which opens up for the possibility to observe the effect for higher neutron velocities in the adiabatic regime .
e. s. acknowledges support from the swedish research council through grant no .
b. h. was supported by the national research foundation and the ministry of education ( singapore ) .
99 y. aharonov and d. bohm , _ significance of electromagnetic potentials in the quantum theory _ , phys
. rev . * 115 * , 485 ( 1959 ) .
y. aharonov and a. casher , _ topological quantum effects for neutral particles _ , phys .
rev . lett . * 53 * , 319 ( 1984 ) .
h. wei , r. han , and x. wei , _ quantum phase of induced dipoles moving in a magnetic field _ ,
lett . * 75 * , 2071 ( 1995 ) . m. v. berry , _ quantal phase factors accompanying adiabatic changes _ , proc .
london , ser .
a * 329 * , 45 ( 1984 ) . c. a. mead , _ the molecular aharonov - bohm effect _ , chem .
phys . * 49 * , 23 ( 1980 ) .
h. von busch , v. dev , h .- a .
eckel , s. kasahara , j. wang , w. demtrder , p. sebald , and w. meyer , _ unambiguous proof for berry s phase in the sodium trimer : analysis of the transition _
@xmath63 , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 4584 ( 1998 ) .
b. lepitit and a. kuppermann , _ numerical study of the geometric phase in the _ h+h@xmath64 _
reaction _ ,
. lett . * 166 * , 581 ( 1990 ) .
b. k. kendrick , _ geometric phase effects in chemical reaction dynamics and molecular spectra _ , j. phys .
chem . * 107 * , 6739 ( 2003 ) .
j. jankunas , m. sneha , r. n. zare , f. bouakline , and s. c. althorpe , _ hunt for the geometric phase effects in _ @xmath65 , j. chem
* 139 * , 144316 ( 2013 ) .
j. juanes - marcos , s. c. althorpe , and e. wrede , _ theoretical study of geometric phase effects in the hydrogen - exchange reaction _
, science * 309 * , 1227 ( 2005 ) .
zhu , h. fu , c .- j .
wu , s .- c .
zhang , and l .- m .
duan , _ spin hall effects for cold atoms in a light - induced gauge potential _ , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 240401 ( 2006 ) .
g. juzelinas , j. ruseckas , a. jacob , l. santos , and p. hberg , _ double and negative reflection of cold atoms in non - abelian gauge potentials _ ,
lett . * 100 * , 200405 ( 2008 ) .
j. y. vaishnav and c. w. clark , _ observing _ zitterbewegung _ with ultracold atoms _ , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 153002 ( 2008 ) .
j. ruseckas , g. juzelinas , p. hberg , and m. fleischhauer , _ non - abelian gauge potentials for ultracold atoms with degenerate dark states _ , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 010404 ( 2005 ) .
lin , r. l. compton , k. jimnez - garca , j. v. porto , and i. b. spielman , _ synthetic magnetic fields for ultracold neutral atoms _ , nature ( london ) * 462 * , 628 ( 2009 ) .
j. dalibard , f. gerbier , g. juzelinas , and p. hberg , _ artificial gauge potentials for neutral atoms _ , rev . mod
. phys . * 83 * , 1523 ( 2011 ) .
j. larson and e. sjqvist , _ jahn - teller - induced berry phase in spin - orbit - coupled bose - einstein condensates _ , phys .
a * 79 * , 043627 ( 2009 ) .
huo , w. nie , d. a. w. hutchinson , and l. c. kwek , _ a solenoidal synthetic field and the non - abelian aharonov - bohm effects in neutral atoms _ , sci . rep . * 4 * , 5992 ( 2014 ) .
a. cimmino , g. i. opat , a. g. klein , h. kaiser , s. a. werner , m. arif , and r. clothier , _ observation of the topological aharonov - casher phase shift by neutron interferometry _ ,
rev . lett . * 63 * , 380 ( 1989 ) .
b. e. allman , a. cimmino , a. g. klein , g. i. opat , h. kaiser , and s. a. werner , _ scalar aharonov - bohm experiment with neutrons _
* 68 * , 2409 ( 1992 ) .
t. bitter and d. dubbers , _ manifestation of berry s topological phase in neutron spin rotation _ ,
* 59 * , 251 ( 1987 ) .
d. j. richardson , a. i. kilvington , k. green , and s. k. lamoreaux , _ demonstration of berry s phase using stored ultracold neutrons _
* 61 * , 2030 ( 1988 ) .
d. frustaglia , m. hentschel , and k. richter , _ quantum transport in nonuniform magnetic fields : aharonov - bohm ring as a spin switch _ ,
* 87 * , 256602 ( 2001 ) .
j. w. zwanziger and e. r. grant , _ topological phase in molecular bound states : application to the @xmath66 system _ , j. chem .
87 * , 2954 ( 1987 ) .
y. aharonov , s. coleman , a. s. goldhaber , s. nussimov , s. popescu , b. reznik , d. rohrlich , and l. vaidman , _ aharonov - bohm and berry phases for a quantum cloud of charge _
rev . lett . * 94 * , 918 ( 1994 ) .
m. svrd and j. nordstrm , _ review of summation - by - parts schemes for initial - boundary - value problems _
, j. comp .
phys . * 268 * , 17 ( 2014 ) .
m. almquist , k. mattsson , and t. edvinsson , _ high - fidelity numerical solution of the time - dependent dirac equation _ , j. comp .
phys . * 262 * , 86 ( 2014 ) .
j. schn and h. kppel , _ femtosecond time - resolved ionization spectroscopy of _
na@xmath0(b ) _ and the question of the geometric phase _ chem . phys
* 231 * , 55 ( 1994 ) . | the adiabatic aharonov - bohm ( ab ) effect is a manifestation of the berry phase acquired when some slow variables take a planar spin around a loop .
while the effect has been observed in molecular spectroscopy , direct measurement of the topological phase shift in a scattering experiment has been elusive in the past . here ,
we demonstrate an adiabatic ab effect by explicit simulation of the dynamics of unpolarized very slow neutrons that scatter on a long straight current - carrying wire . |
neutrino properties are among the most difficult to be probed experimentally , due to the weakness of their interactions .
data from particle accelerators tell us that there are only three flavor neutrinos , while neutrino oscillation experiments show evidence for non - zero neutrino masses ( for a recent review , see e.g. @xcite ) .
recent results strongly constrain the mass differences of the individual neutrino masses ( actually masses squared , @xmath6 ) and mixing angles , but no definite conclusion can be drawn neither on the absolute scale of neutrino masses , nor on the existence of weakly coupled sterile neutrinos .
fortunately , cosmology is quite sensitive to the neutrino sector ( see @xcite for a review ) , and can shed light on these questions , as well as other interesting issues regarding the early universe , such as the process of neutrino decoupling from the primordial plasma . currently , the most popular cosmological model is the flat adiabatic @xmath7cdm scenario , in which the present density of the universe is shared between baryons , cold dark matter ( cdm ) and a cosmological constant @xmath7 .
this model makes rather simplistic assumptions concerning the neutrino sector , consisting only of three ultra - relativistic neutrinos .
it turns out that with a more refined description of the neutrino sector , one finds that only small corrections to the standard picture are allowed after comparing with current data on cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) anisotropies and large scale structure ( lss ) .
however , these small corrections carry enough interesting physical implications to justify an active research effort , in particular after the first releases of the wmap and sdss data .
the results of this effort are not only new cosmological bounds on neutrino properties but also a better understanding of how the errors depend on ( i ) the experimental cmb and lss data , ( ii ) external priors on the cosmological parameters , ( iii ) intrinsic parameter degeneracies in the theory of cosmological perturbations , ( iv ) assumptions concerning the underlying cosmological model and parameter space .
we here perform a new analysis using the most recent lss ( 2df , sdss ) and cmb ( wmap , acbar ) data and an extended cosmological model with an arbitrary number of massive neutrinos and additional relativistic particles , parametrized via an effective number of neutrinos ( @xmath8 ) .
we extend the recent work of @xcite and those that appeared after the release of wmap data @xcite-@xcite .
in particular , our underlying model is identical to that of ref .
@xcite , but our analysis differs since we include an extended set of data ( such as the sdss results and a more updated version of the 2df ones ) , a new prior on the matter density from sn - ia @xcite and non - linear corrections to the lss power spectrum on scales @xmath9 .
furthermore , we increase the number of free parameters to ten , in order to analyze the bounds in the presence of primordial tensor perturbations .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . after a short summary of the effects of neutrino masses and additional relativistic particles in sec .
[ effects ] , we describe our analysis method and dataset in sec .
[ method_data ] .
we discuss our results and compare with previous works in sec .
[ results ] .
finally , we conclude in sec .
non - standard neutrinos and other weakly - interacting light particles leave their imprint on the evolution of the universe , both at the level of background quantities and spatial perturbations . here
we describe the main effects of additional relativistic particles , massive neutrinos and their simultaneous presence .
the density of radiation in the universe is usually assumed to be given by that of photons and of three thermally decoupled neutrinos .
these contributions are of the same order and fix the evolution of the universe in the radiation - dominated epoch ( rd ) .
thus , if the three neutrinos did not decouple thermally , or in the presence of sterile neutrinos , the total density of the universe during rd ( as a function of the photon temperature @xmath10 ) would be significantly affected , producing a change in the time of equality between radiation and matter , and in the sound horizon at the time of decoupling .
these changes are known to shift the angular scale of the acoustic peaks in the cmb anisotropy spectrum as well as their amplitude ( mainly , through the early integrated sachs - wolfe effect ) .
they also have an impact on the matter power spectrum @xmath11 , because a shorter matter - dominated stage implies less growth for perturbations inside the hubble radius . as a consequence
, the wave - length corresponding to the maximum in @xmath11 will be shifted proportionally to the hubble scale at the time of equality .
thus , the effect of @xmath2 is mainly to change the background evolution .
however , ultra - relativistic particles also have a smaller effect directly at the level of perturbations , explained in detail in ref .
@xcite .
all these effects can be parametrized by a single quantity : the effective number of relativistic degrees of freedom during rd , defined by the relation @xmath12 \frac{\pi^2}{15 } t_{\gamma}^4 \ , .
\label{def_neff}\ ] ] here , @xmath13 stands for the total energy density of radiation and @xmath14 is the contribution of photons .
the parameter @xmath2 is defined in such way that if neutrinos decoupled following the instantaneous decoupling approximation , @xmath2 just gives the number of flavor families .
however , @xmath2 could differ from three in the presence of extra relics ( sterile neutrinos , light gravitons , gravitinos , majorons , effects from extra dimensions , etc . ) or in the case of non - thermal decoupling . actually , in the standard case
a careful study of non - instantaneous neutrino decoupling shows that @xmath15 for three flavor families @xcite .
note that @xmath2 is constant only when the neutrinos or the other relics are ultra - relativistic .
the value of @xmath2 is constrained by big bang nucleosynthesis ( bbn ) from the comparison with the measured primordial abundances of light elements . during the bbn epoch the nuclear reactions freeze out at a scale factor that depends on the expansion rate , which in turn is fixed by the total energy density of radiation .
a bbn analysis shows that @xmath16 @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , which is perfectly compatible with the number of flavor neutrinos . however , it is interesting to measure @xmath2 independently of bbn ( e.g. using cmb and lss data ) for at least two reasons .
first of all , because the number @xmath2 could change between the two epochs @xcite .
a second reason is because the standard bbn model might be a good first - order description , but with possible corrections due to spatial inhomogeneities , leptonic asymmetries , etc .
, that could be evaluated with an independent measurement of @xmath2 .
neutrinos that possess masses larger or of the same order than the relevant photon temperature have different effects than a constant @xmath2 .
for instance , neutrinos heavier than roughly @xmath17 ev are not relativistic today .
neutrino masses have implications for the evolution of cosmological fluctuations , both at the level of background quantities and directly on the perturbations .
it is well - known that massive neutrinos could account for a significant fraction of the total energy density of the universe today , unlike relativistic thermal relics ( @xmath18 per neutrino family ) .
for fully non - relativistic flavor neutrinos , the contribution to the present energy density is directly proportional to the number density . for vanishing neutrino chemical potentials ,
the total neutrino contribution to the critical density is given by @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the hubble constant in units of @xmath21 km s@xmath22 mpc@xmath22 and @xmath23 runs over all neutrino mass states .
for fixed neutrino masses , @xmath24 would be enhanced if neutrinos decoupled with a significant dimensionless chemical potential @xmath25 ( or equivalently , for large relic neutrino asymmetries ) , simply because their number density would increase . in principle there exist some combinations of pairs @xmath26 that pass the bbn test and are not yet ruled out by the cmb+lss limits on @xmath2 @xcite .
however , it was recently shown that the stringent bbn bounds on @xmath27 apply to all flavors , since flavor neutrino oscillations lead to flavor equilibrium before bbn @xcite .
the contribution of a potential relic neutrino asymmetry is limited to such low values that it can be safely ignored .
when the density of the other fluids ( photons , cdm , baryons , dark energy ) is kept fixed , the sum over the neutrino masses @xmath3 has a direct repercussion on the geometry of the universe .
if instead the spatial curvature is kept fixed , the total mass affects the relative contribution @xmath28 of the other fluids . in any case
, this background effect has an impact on the observable cmb and lss power spectra .
for masses of the order of @xmath29 ev , this signature is rather small , but can be marginally detectable . in general , neutrinos tend to stream freely across gravitational potential wells , and to erase density perturbations .
free - streaming is efficient on a characteristic scale called the jeans length , corresponding roughly to the distance on which neutrinos can travel in a hubble time . for ultra - relativistic neutrinos ,
the jeans length is by definition equal to the hubble radius @xmath30 , but for non - relativistic ones it grows at a slower rate than @xmath30 ( in comoving coordinates , it even decreases with time during matter domination ) .
neutrinos with masses smaller than approximately @xmath31 ev are still relativistic at the time of last scattering , and their direct effect on the cmb perturbations is identical to that of massless neutrinos . for bigger masses , the decrease of the free - streaming scale
is felt by perturbations which enter inside the hubble radius before decoupling , which results in a small enhancement of the acoustic peaks with respect to the massless situation . in the intermediate mass range from @xmath17 ev to @xmath32 ev , the transition to the non - relativistic regime takes place during structure formation , and the matter power spectrum will be directly affected in a mass - dependent way .
wavelengths smaller than the current value of the neutrino jeans length are suppressed by free - streaming .
the largest observable wavelengths , which remain always larger than the neutrino jeans length , are not affected .
finally , there is a range of intermediate wavelengths which become smaller than the neutrino jeans length for some time , and then encompass it again : these scales smoothly interpolate between the two regimes .
the net signature in the matter power spectrum is a damping of all wavelengths smaller than the hubble scale at the time of the transition of neutrinos to a non - relativistic regime @xcite @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the contribution of matter to the critical density .
the damping is maximal for wavenumbers bigger than the current free - streaming wavenumber @xmath35 @xmath36 we have summarized both the background and the direct effects of the neutrino masses on the cmb and lss perturbations .
the total signature is difficult to describe analytically .
however , one should remember that for masses of order @xmath29 ev or less , the dominant effect is the one induced by free - streaming on the matter power spectrum .
therefore , the usual strategy is to combine cmb and lss measurements , where the former roughly fix most of the cosmological parameters , while the latter is sensitive to @xmath35 and provides bounds on the neutrino mass . in a situation with @xmath37
thermalized massive neutrino species , the cosmological model should include an equal number of parameters , namely @xmath38 .
however , at first order such a model could be described by only two parameters , @xmath37 and the sum of all individual masses @xmath39 .
this choice not only simplifies the problem , but also provides the correct contribution of neutrinos to the total energy density both at early times , when all neutrinos are ultra - relativistic and the radiation density depends only on @xmath37 , and at a late epoch when at least one neutrino mass is large compared with the temperature and the density is given in good approximation by the total mass .
however , for a precise description @xmath37 and @xmath39 are not the only relevant parameters . as an example
, let us compare two scenarios with three neutrinos but different mass spectra : a degenerate case with @xmath40 and a case with @xmath41 , where @xmath42 . in both scenarios
the neutrino density is the same for early and late stages of the universe .
but at intermediate temperatures of the order @xmath43 , the energy densities are different .
it is easy to show that the expansion rate is temporarily enhanced in the second scenario , but this will only have a small signature in the cmb spectrum for @xmath44 ev . on the other hand ,
the free - streaming wavenumber @xmath35 of the heaviest neutrino is larger in the second scenario .
thus , in principle we expect more damping and sharper bounds on the mass in the degenerate case . nowadays , after many years of experimental effort , we know that neutrinos must be massive in order to explain the evidences for flavor oscillations from measurements of atmospheric and solar neutrinos , independently confirmed by data from the detection of neutrinos from artificial sources at experiments such as k2k and kamland .
these results lead to specific differences between the individual neutrino masses , at two different scales : @xmath45 ev@xmath46 and @xmath47 ev@xmath46 @xcite .
but one of the masses remains unconstrained , which reflects the fact that oscillation experiments can not fix the absolute scale of neutrino masses .
it is clear that , considering the present cosmological data , in order to have a measurable effect the three neutrinos should have roughly the same mass , following a degenerate scheme @xmath40 , where @xmath48 ev . on the other hand , the positive results from the lsnd experiment point to neutrino oscillations with @xmath49 .
the less disfavored scenario that could explain the lsnd data , together with the results of atmospheric and solar neutrino experiments , contains 4 neutrinos following a 3 + 1 scheme where one of them is much heavier than the others ( see for instance @xcite ) and the fourth neutrino must be sterile .
it has been shown @xcite that all four neutrino models lead to a full thermalization of the sterile neutrino before bbn , so they are disfavored by bbn . however
, current cmb and lss data can not completely rule out this possibility @xcite .
the most general scenario is that of a cosmological model with @xmath50 thermally - decoupled massive neutrinos and extra relativistic degrees of freedom , parametrized by @xmath51 not necessarily integer .
this model is described by a set of @xmath52 parameters : @xmath53 . however , since such a parameter space is too large for a systematic analysis we will consider restricted cases described by only two parameters : the total effective neutrino number @xmath54 and the total mass @xmath55 . in order to check the impact of the distribution of the total neutrino mass among the individual states , we will study two cases : * the model that we call _ degenerate _
has @xmath2 massive neutrinos with the same mass .
let us emphasize that this is a simplified model where the physical interpretation of non - integer values of @xmath2 is not obvious . * a second model
the we denote _
1+r _ has only one neutrino with a significant mass , while the other @xmath56 species are ultra - relativistic .
these two models are not chosen arbitrarily .
first , the _ degenerate _ model includes the standard situation with only 3 flavor neutrinos degenerate in mass , while the _ 1+r _ model includes the 3 + 1 scenario described above .
second , and most importantly , the _ degenerate _ and _ 1+r _ models appear as limiting situations of the general case once the parameters @xmath2 and @xmath55 have been fixed . indeed , the former has the smallest possible value of the free - streaming wavenumber , while the latter has the biggest @xmath35 . for any intermediate model ( like ,
for instance , the third case studied in @xcite , with three effectively massless standard neutrinos and @xmath57 species with equal mass ) , the observational bounds deduced from the cmb and lss observations should lay between those that we get in the _ degenerate _ and _ 1+r _ limits .
the wmap spectrum and many other cosmological data can be accurately fitted with a six - parameter flat @xmath7cdm model @xcite , described by the hubble parameter @xmath20 , the fractional density of matter @xmath58 , the baryon density in dimensionless units @xmath59 , the optical depth to reionization @xmath60 , and finally , the amplitude and the spectral tilt of primordial perturbations @xmath61 .
most of our calculations correspond to a model with eight parameters : the six previous ones plus @xmath2 and @xmath55 , as previously defined for the _ degenerate _ and _ 1+r _ models .
we will also study the consequences of the presence of a background of primordial gravitational waves , which would contribute to the cmb anisotropy spectrum .
for this case , our parameter space will be ten - dimensional , adding the tensor - to - scalar ratio @xmath62 and the tensor tilt @xmath63 . in all cases
, we use the cmbfast code @xcite to calculate the power spectra . in order to compare the theoretical cosmological models with current observations
, we use a bayesian grid - based method described in some previous works ( e.g. @xcite ) , instead of the widely used monte carlo markov chains ( mcmc ) technique employed for instance in @xcite .
the former has the inconvenient of being considerably slower from the computational point of view , and the advantage of being very robust if the hypersurfaces with the same likelihood in parameter space have very complicated shapes ( for instance , an elongated and curved _ banana _ shape ) .
also , the mcmc method can not deal with likelihood distributions with nearly degenerate local minima ; mathematically , the existence of local minima can not be disproved , but in practice , using current data and the wide variety of models discussed in the literature , such a situation never appeared . in order to analyze unusual models with many parameters , it is safe to use at least once a grid - based method , avoiding surprises that could arise from parameter degeneracies .
however , our analysis always shows quasi - ellipsoidal likelihood contours for various combinations of parameters .
thus we believe that a mcmc method would give similar results . for each combination of data set and
priors , we plot the bayesian likelihood of each point in the two - dimensional space of neutrino parameters @xmath64 after marginalization over the other free parameters . actually , for simplicity we approximate the integration process required for a true marginalization by a maximization of the likelihood over the remaining parameter space .
integration and maximization are known to be equivalent in the case of a multigaussian likelihood distribution and we expect the maximization technique to be reasonably accurate in our case , where we obtained quasi - ellipsoidal contours .
we checked this explicitly by computing the marginalized likelihood of each of the six @xmath7cdm parameters : our results are very close to those of @xcite , obtained with a mcmc technique and marginalized by integration over the likelihood .
of course , our maximization routine needs to compute the likelihood not only at grid points , but also in between . at a given point in parameter space , this is done by interpolating quadratically each value of the @xmath65 and @xmath11 from the nearest neighbors of the grid .
our cmb data include the 1348 correlated points of the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) , which measure the temperature @xmath66 temperature ( tt ) @xcite and temperature @xmath66 e - polarization ( te ) @xcite correlation functions on the cmb sky .
wmap provides the best available data on multipoles @xmath67 . for constraining the tt spectrum on smaller scales ,
we employ the results of the arcminute cosmology bolometer array receiver ( acbar ) experiment @xcite .
we remove the highest band powers ( probing the region @xmath68 ) which could be contaminated by foregrounds .
the published acbar band powers are decorrelated , so it is self - consistent to use only the first 11 points of data .
our lss data set consists of 32 correlated points from the 2 degree field ( 2df ) galaxy redshift survey @xcite , covering the range @xmath69 , and of 19 decorrelated points from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xcite in the range @xmath70 . in order to compare the smallest wavelengths with the data ,
it is necessary to take into account small deviations with respect to the linear power spectrum . following the analysis in @xcite , we compute non - linear corrections for each point in parameter space using the numerical procedure described in appendix c of @xcite .
since these corrections rely on n - body simulations of a pure cdm universe they might not be perfectly optimized for hot plus cold dark matter .
however , the models studied here include only a small fraction of non - relativistic neutrino density .
therefore , at first order the fitting formula of @xcite should be reasonably accurate in our case ( and certainly better than introducing no corrections at all ) . each redshift survey is expected to constrain the total matter power spectrum modulo a global normalization factor called the bias @xmath71 .
unless otherwise stated , all our results were obtained after marginalizing over the 2df and sdss bias , treated like two free parameters .
we will also use a prior on the current value of the hubble parameter , measured by the hubble space telescope ( hst ) key project @xcite : @xmath72 ( 1@xmath1 ) .
finally , we will impose some constraints on the current density of the cosmological constant deduced from the redshift dependence of type ia supernovae luminosity . for a flat universe ,
perlmutter et al .
@xcite give a conservative bound @xmath73 ( 1@xmath1 ) that we denote as the sn99 prior .
in addition , we will calculate the impact of using the more restrictive result @xmath74 ( 1@xmath1 ) from the recent work by tonry et al .
@xcite , that we label the sn03 prior .
in order to understand the impact of each data set and prior on the final results , we will introduce them step by step in the calculation of the likelihood .
we will first focus on the _ degenerate _ model .
we start using only cmb and lss data without any prior , apart from the top - hat priors defined implicitly by the boundaries of our grid .
we look for the two - dimensional probability distribution of the neutrino parameters in the range @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
we find that most of this parameter space is allowed at @xmath77 , as shown in panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig1abcd ] .
actually some of the grid boundaries are reached by the allowed models , or @xmath78 , the best - fit models reach the extreme values of @xmath79 $ ] and @xmath80 $ ] . however , the global maximum - likelihood fit has @xmath81 and values of the other cosmological parameters well inside the grid boundaries .
] unlike in the rest of our analysis where they have no influence on the @xmath77 allowed regions .
two - dimensional likelihood in @xmath82 space , marginalized over the six remaining parameters of the model .
we plot the 1@xmath1 ( green / dark ) and 2@xmath1 ( yellow / light ) allowed regions . here
we used cmb ( wmap & acbar ) and lss ( 2df & sdss ) data , adding different external priors as defined in section [ method_data ] : ( a ) no priors , ( b ) hst , ( c ) hst+sn99 , ( d ) hst+sn03 . ]
the physical explanation for such loose constraints is well - known : when the density of relativistic relics is left free , there is a parameter degeneracy between @xmath83\ ] ] and @xmath84 .
indeed , one can vary these two quantities in the same proportion while keeping fixed @xmath85 , the redshift of equality between matter and radiation . in order to remove this degeneracy ,
it is necessary to impose some priors on @xmath20 and @xmath34 .
thus we repeat the same analysis , using now the hst prior . in this case
, we obtain a band of allowed models shown in panel ( b ) of fig .
[ fig1abcd ] .
this region stretches up to the maximal values of @xmath55 and @xmath2 in our grid , so we can not derive yet limits on these parameters .
however , the other grid bounds are now irrelevant , since none of the models allowed at @xmath77 ever reaches them .
the @xmath86 preferred region includes models with ( @xmath87 , @xmath15 ) , showing that there is no evidence for massive neutrinos and/or extra relativistic degrees of freedom .
however , it is interesting to see that large departures from the standard @xmath7cdm model can not be excluded .
these results show clearly how difficult is to put bounds on the neutrino mass in presence of an excess of relativistic relics during rd , and vice versa .
for instance , if we assume @xmath88 , we get a @xmath77 upper bound @xmath89 ev , while for @xmath90 this bound spectacularly increases to @xmath91 ev .
this trend was already observed in @xcite , and can be explained as follows .
suppose that we start from the best - fit standard model with ( @xmath87 , @xmath88 ) , and that we increase @xmath2 in such way that the radiation density in the early universe is multiplied by a factor @xmath92 .
then , in order to keep the cmb power spectra roughly constant , we should maintain a fixed value both for @xmath85 and @xmath93 .
this would be achieved with a transformation of the type @xmath94 . however , it is well - known that the shape of the matter power spectrum is given roughly by the parameter @xmath95 , that scales like @xmath96 with the previous transformation , meaning that the spectrum will have more power on small scales relatively to large scales .
a neutrino mass can balance this increase through the free - streaming effect .
therefore , models with high values of @xmath8 are compatible with larger neutrino masses .
we illustrate this parameter degeneracy in fig .
[ figdeg ] , where we show the cmb temperature spectrum ( normalized to wmap ) and the matter power spectrum for three particular models .
the first model ( red / solid curves ) is the best - fit model for the standard case @xmath97 . in the second model ( green / dashed curves ) , we have increased the number of degrees of freedom to @xmath98 and performed the transformation on ( @xmath99 , @xmath20 ) as previously discussed , leaving both @xmath100 and @xmath101 invariant .
we have also increased @xmath102 a little bit .
on the cmb figure it is difficult to distinguish the curves because they perfectly overlap , especially for the best measured scales ( those of the first acoustic peak ) , while the difference at @xmath103 is masked by cosmic variance .
but as expected , the shape of the matter power spectrum is modified , with more power on small scales relatively to large scales .
this leaves plenty of room for models with a significant neutrino mass and free - streaming effect , like the one featured here ( blue / dotted curve ) which has @xmath104 . in order to obtain bounds on the mass ,
it is necessary to add more restrictive priors . in particular
, the supernova priors should help to better constrain @xmath34 ( around the central value @xmath105 ) and therefore also the shape parameter @xmath106 ( around @xmath107 ) .
this value of @xmath106 is in very good agreement with the constraint obtained from lss data , assuming no neutrino mass : the sdss power spectrum points to @xmath108 @xcite .
therefore , we expect the sn prior to restrict the possibility of a large neutrino free - streaming effect and to improve the upper bound on @xmath55 .
this is what we observe by successively adding the sn99 and sn03 priors in our analysis .
the corresponding contours , shown in panels ( c ) and ( d ) of fig .
[ fig1abcd ] , are the main results of this work .
with the sn03 prior , our one - dimensional bounds on the effective neutrino number ( marginalized over @xmath55 ) read @xmath109 at @xmath77 , in very good agreement with our previous results @xmath110 @xcite obtained without sdss , no sn priors and fixing @xmath111 .
the one - dimensional upper bound on the total neutrino mass ( marginalized over @xmath2 ) is @xmath112 ev at @xmath77 . for comparison
, we list the bounds for fixed integer values of @xmath8 are in table [ table1 ] , for different priors .
since we use more recent 2df and sdss data , as well as more restrictive sn priors , we are not surprised to find stronger bounds than hannestad & raffelt @xcite . .[table1]the
2@xmath1 upper bound on the total neutrino mass @xmath55 ( ev ) , after marginalization over the six cosmological parameters of the flat @xmath7cdm model , for particular values of @xmath2 .
we show the results for two limiting cases of splitting the total mass between the neutrino states : _ degenerate _ ( all neutrinos with the same mass ) and _ 1+r _ ( one massive neutrino and the other treated as relativistic relics ) . here
we have used the full cmb and lss data set , either alone ( no priors ) or combined with the hst and sn03 priors . for large @xmath2 values and in absence of priors ,
the upper bound is larger than the maximal value of @xmath55 in our grid ( 2.25 ev ) . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] so far we have used the lss data as an indication of the shape of the matter power spectrum , but not its overall amplitude .
this amplitude is difficult to measure , because of possible differences between the two - point correlation function of luminous galaxies and that of matter , a problem known as the bias uncertainty .
the 2df team has established that the bias @xmath71 is almost scale - independent , and derived some constraints either on the redshift distortion parameter @xmath113 @xcite or directly on @xmath71 @xcite .
these two results must be employed with great care since the bias is expected to depend on the mean luminosity and redshift of each particular galaxy sample . in order to use a self - consistent bias prior , we would need to compute some correction factors for each model ( see for instance refs .
this technically difficult procedure , that relies on many assumptions , is beyond the goal of the present paper and we prefer to conservatively discard any bias prior , as in @xcite . just for indication
, we tried to repeat the previous analysis with a very naive bias prior . instead of leaving the 2df bias as a free parameter
, we tried to add the constraint @xmath114 @xcite to our full set of data and priors ( which includes all the cmb+lss data , the hst prior , and one of our two supernovae priors ) . as shown in panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig3abcd ] , our results remain unchanged .
this is consistent with the analysis of elgary & lahav @xcite , who treat the bias prior in a detailed way and find no impact on the neutrino mass determination .
impact of various assumptions related to the lss data set .
the default model for which we show 1@xmath1 ( dashed ) and 2@xmath1 ( solid ) contours was obtained with wmap , acbar , 2df , sdss , plus the hst and sn99 priors .
each panel shows the 1@xmath1 ( green / dark ) and 2@xmath1 ( yellow / light ) allowed regions ( a ) when including the 2df bias prior @xcite , ( b ) without the sdss data , ( c ) without the 2df data , ( d ) without non - linear corrections . ] since the lss data plays a crucial role in constraining the neutrino mass , it is worth comparing the impact of the 2df and sdss power spectra .
we go back to a data set consisting of cmb+lss+hst+sn99 , and remove either the sdss or 2df spectrum from the analysis .
the results , shown in panels ( b ) and ( c ) of fig .
[ fig3abcd ] , should be compared with the combined analysis previously shown in ( c ) of fig .
[ fig1abcd ] .
the sdss power spectrum appears to be much more conservative , in good agreement with previous papers : the wmap+sdss constraint on the neutrino mass for @xmath88 is as large as @xmath115 ev @xcite , while a wmap+other cmb+2df analysis gives @xmath116 ev @xcite .
consistently , our combined analysis gives intermediate results : for @xmath88 our wmap+acbar+2df+sdss bound is @xmath117 ev .
our results seem also consistent with the recent analysis in @xcite , where the corresponding bound @xmath118 ev was found including data from both galaxy surveys up to @xmath119 . note that
in order to employ the sdss data until @xmath120 , it is crucial to include the non - linear corrections to the matter power spectrum , in particular for the @xmath2 bounds .
the panel ( d ) of fig .
[ fig1abcd ] was obtained with all the cmb and lss data , plus the hst and sn99 priors , but in absence of non - linear corrections .
a comparison with fig .
[ fig1abcd]c shows that the constraints on @xmath2 are lifted by one unit .
this can be easily understood .
[ fig4 ] shows a typical power spectrum with and without non - linear corrections .
the linear power spectrum has less power on small scales , i.e. a smaller effective shape parameter @xmath106 .
as explained earlier in this section , this can be easily compensated by an appropriate increase in @xmath2 , @xmath99 and @xmath20 , while leaving the cmb spectrum almost invariant .
we have discussed so far the dependence of our results under the choice of data set and priors . however , generally speaking , the bounds on a particular parameter also depend on assumptions concerning the underlying cosmological model , a simple six - parameter flat @xmath7cdm model in our case .
it is clear that by adding extra physical ingredients that would compensate the effect of neutrinos , we would relax the bounds on ( @xmath2 , @xmath55 ) .
it is inviable to perform a systematic study of all the @xmath7cdm variants proposed in the literature , but one of them deserves a particular interest .
indeed , the six - parameter @xmath7cdm relies on the existence of super - horizon cosmological fluctuations at early times , which strongly suggests that perturbations are of inflationary origin .
but inflation also predicts a background of primordial tensor perturbations : the question is whether these gravitational waves are large enough to contribute to large - scale cmb anisotropies ( fundamentally , this depends on the energy scale of inflation ) . it is thus important to see how the neutrino parameter bounds evolve in presence of two extra parameters , the relative amplitude and tilt of the primordial tensor spectrum @xmath121 .
previous analyses @xcite showed that for eight - parameter models ( flat @xmath7cdm + tensors ) a significant contribution of gravitational waves is disfavored .
however , one could expect that in a ten - dimensional model ( flat @xmath7cdm + tensors , with @xmath2 and @xmath55 ) , a new parameter degeneracy would show up and relax the various bounds .
we performed such an analysis for our full cmb and lss data set , adding the hst and sn03 priors .
the resulting two - dimensional likelihood for ( @xmath2 , @xmath55 ) , marginalized over the other eight parameters , is shown in fig .
[ fig_tensor ] .
it is almost indistinguishable from that with a vanishing contribution of gravitational waves , which shows that the current data is clearly able to distinguish between the respective effects of tensors and neutrinos .
thus the cosmological bound on neutrino masses is robust with respect to tensors .
this robustness also holds when including a non - adiabatic , incoherent contribution to the power spectrum such as those predicted by topological defects , as shown in a very recent work @xcite .
1@xmath1 ( green / dark ) and 2@xmath1 ( yellow / light ) allowed regions in ( @xmath55 , @xmath2 ) space , marginalized over the eight other free parameters of the flat @xmath7cdm+tensors model . for comparison
, we show the contours corresponding to the case with no gravitational waves .
the difference is very small , showing the ability of the data to make a clear difference between the effect of neutrinos and gravitational waves . ]
our aim is to constrain cosmological models with an arbitrary number of massive neutrinos and with extra relativistic degrees of freedom .
however , so far we reduced the analysis to two parameters ( @xmath55 , @xmath2 ) , with the implicit assumption that all neutrinos were degenerate in mass .
we have not discussed the fact that for a fixed total number of degrees of freedom @xmath2 and total mass @xmath55 , the evolution of cosmological perturbations depends on the splitting of the mass between the different species .
as explained in section [ effects ] , for fixed ( @xmath55 , @xmath2 ) , in some sense the opposite case to the _ degenerate _ model is the _
scenario , for which all the mass corresponds to a single neutrino eigenstate , instead of being equally shared .
we built a second grid of _
1+r _ models and analyzed it with our most restrictive set of data ( wmap+acbar+2df+sdss ) and priors ( hst+sn03 ) .
we show in fig .
[ fig_split ] the new allowed regions , compared with the previous ones .
1@xmath1 ( green / dark ) and 2@xmath1 ( yellow / light ) allowed regions in ( @xmath55 , @xmath2 ) space for the _
1+r _ model , compared with the _ degenerate _ model ( dashed 1@xmath1 and solid 2@xmath1 contours ) .
here we have included all cmb and lss data , plus the hst and sn03 priors . ] in the limit of small mass and small @xmath2 , the cmb and lss power spectra are almost identical in the two cases , because the effect of the mass splitting is second - order with respect to that of the total mass . a priori
, this does not guarantee that the ( @xmath55 , @xmath2 ) iso - likelihood contours are asymptotically equal , because we are doing a bayesian analysis and the contours are defined with respect to the best - fit model .
for instance , in ref .
@xcite , the best - fit models for the _ degenerate _ and _ 1+r _ cases correspond to high values of ( @xmath55 , @xmath2 ) and are different from each other .
this explains why the authors find different contours in the two cases even in the massless limit .
the same occurs in our analysis when we do not impose any prior .
however , when at least the hst prior is taken into account , the best - fit model is very close to @xmath97 and the contours only differ at high values of @xmath55 and @xmath2 . as expected from the physical discussion in sec.[effects ] , the model with only one massive neutrino is less constrained : remember that in that case , for a fixed @xmath55 the free - streaming wavenumber @xmath35 is larger .
therefore , the damping of the matter power spectrum is less efficient .
the one - dimensional bounds on the effective number of neutrinos ( marginalized over @xmath55 ) now reads @xmath122 at @xmath77 , and the limit on the total neutrino mass ( marginalized over @xmath2 ) increases to @xmath123 ev ( 2@xmath1 ) .
the bounds for fixed integer values of @xmath2 are given in the last column of table [ table1 ] .
we have calculated cosmological bounds on neutrino masses and relativistic relics ( @xmath2 ) using the latest data on cmb ( wmap and acbar ) and lss ( sdss and 2df galaxy surveys ) in the framework of an extended flat @xmath7cdm . in the cases in which a comparison is possible , our results are in good agreement with those of previous analyses @xcite-@xcite . in the well motivated case of three flavor neutrino with degenerate masses
, we found an upper limit on the total masses of @xmath124 ev using only cmb and lss data and priors ( resp . including priors on @xmath20 and @xmath93 ) .
the bound for four thermalized neutrinos with only one of them carrying a significant mass is @xmath125 ev , depending on the priors used .
therefore , the 4-neutrino solution to the lsnd results is not completely ruled out , but some tension with cosmological data exists , especially if the strong sn03 prior is taken into account . in the case of arbitrary @xmath2 ,
our results are summarized in fig .
[ fig1abcd ] and listed in table [ table1 ] .
they clearly show the existence of a parameter degeneracy between the total neutrino mass and @xmath2 , a trend already observed in previous works @xcite that we have explained in sec .
[ results ] .
external priors on @xmath20 and @xmath93 are found to be of particular importance for constraining respectively @xmath2 and @xmath55 .
since the standard @xmath7cdm model ( with its three effectively massless thermal relics ) sits within the 1@xmath1 preferred region , we find no evidence for exotic physics such as out - of - equilibrium neutrino decoupling , non - standard nucleosynthesis , extra relativistic relics , a significant amount of hot dark matter , etc .
however , large deviations from the standard case are still compatible with observations : for instance , a model with one neutrino of mass @xmath126 ev and eight relativistic degrees of freedom is allowed by cmb and lss data , even when all priors are included ( see fig .
[ fig_split ] ) .
in order to exclude this model , it is necessary to take into account the prediction of standard bbn , which gives stronger limits on @xmath8 .
the bounds obtained in this paper are based on the observation of cosmological perturbations ( cmb and lss ) , combined with constraints on the current expansion and acceleration rates of the universe ( hst and sn priors ) . therefore they are completely independent from the predictions of primordial nucleosynthesis .
it is remarkable that in the space of the two standard bbn free parameters @xmath127 , the preferred regions deduced from cosmological perturbations and from primordial abundances are perfectly compatible with each other , and more or less orthogonal : indeed , our analysis ( with the most restrictive priors ) gives @xmath128 and @xmath122 , while standard bbn favors @xmath129 and @xmath130 @xcite ( all these bounds are at the 2@xmath1 level ) . in order to test their robustness ,
we have also calculated the bounds on @xmath55 and @xmath2 in the presence of primordial tensor perturbations .
our results show that the bounds are practically unchanged , because current cosmological data is able to distinguish between the respective effects of tensors and neutrinos .
finally , we have considered the impact of a different splitting of the total neutrino mass among the individual states , an analysis also recently performed in ref .
we compared the case of complete mass degeneracy ( all neutrinos with the same mass ) with that where one neutrino state effectively possesses the whole mass .
we found that the bounds on the degenerate case are more restrictive due to its more efficient free - streaming , in particular for larger values if @xmath2 .
however , for three or four neutrinos the differences between the two cases are not significant .
our bounds are a clear indication that present cosmological data provide interesting bounds on the neutrino sector , complementary to those from terrestrial experiments .
these include tritium beta decay experiments , which provide a current upper bound on the total neutrino mass of @xmath131 ev at 2@xmath1 @xcite , while the katrin experiment @xcite is planned to have an accuracy of the order @xmath132 ev .
sub - ev sensitivity to neutrino masses is also expected for experiments measuring neutrinoless double beta decays @xcite , but only for majorana neutrinos and with a dependence on the details of the mixing matrix .
however , the cosmological bounds should be taken with care , due to their dependence on the data ( or priors ) used , and also on the assumption of a particular underlying model .
examples are given by the works @xcite , where non - zero neutrino masses are preferred .
this warning should not prevent us to be confident on the power of future cosmological experiments to limit ( and eventually detect ) neutrino masses and other neutrino properties .
for instance , forecast analyses have shown that with future data there will be potential sensitivities to @xmath133 @xcite ( eventually improving bbn results ) and neutrino masses of the order @xmath134 ev with planck and final sdss data @xcite , or with galaxy and cmb lensing @xcite .
this research was supported by a cicyt - in2p3 agreement .
sp was supported by the spanish grant bfm2002 - 00345 , the esf network neutrino astrophysics and a ramn y cajal contract of mcyt .
m. maltoni , talk given at ahep-2003 , valencia ( spain ) , oct 2003 [ hep - ph/0401042 ] .
dolgov , phys .
rept . * 370 * , 333 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0202122 ] .
v. barger , d. marfatia and a. tregre , hep - ph/0312065 .
spergel et al . , astrophys .
j. suppl . * 148 * , 175 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302209 ] .
p. crotty , j. lesgourgues and s. pastor , phys .
d * 67 * , 123005 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302337 ] .
e. pierpaoli , mon . not .
soc . * 342 * , l63 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302465 ] .
s. hannestad , jcap * 0305 * , 004 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0303076 ] .
. elgary and o. lahav , jcap * 0304 * , 004 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0303089 ] .
v. barger , j.p .
kneller , h.s .
lee , d. marfatia and g. steigman , phys .
b * 566 * , 8 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0305075 ] .
allen , r.w .
schmidt and s.l .
bridle , mon . not .
soc . * 346 * , 593 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0306386 ] .
a. cuoco , f. iocco , g. mangano , g. miele , o. pisanti and p.d .
serpico , astro - ph/0307213 .
m. tegmark et al .
[ sdss coll .
] , astro - ph/0310723 . s. hannestad and g. raffelt , hep - ph/0312154 .
tonry et al . , astrophys . j. * 594 * , 1 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0305008 ] .
s. bashinsky and u. seljak , astro - ph/0310198 .
dolgov , s.h .
hansen and d.v .
semikoz , nucl .
b * 503 * , 426 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ph/9703315 ] .
g. mangano , g. miele , s. pastor and m. peloso , phys .
b * 534 * , 8 ( 2002 ) [ astro - ph/0111408 ] .
cyburt , b.d .
fields and k.a .
olive , phys .
b * 567 * , 227 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302431 ] .
white , g. gelmini and j. silk , phys .
d * 51 * , 2669 ( 1995 ) [ astro - ph/9411098 ] .
m. kaplinghat and m.s .
turner , phys .
lett . *
86 * , 385 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0007454 ] .
j. lesgourgues and s. pastor , phys .
d * 60 * , 103521 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9904411 ] .
dolgov et al .
b * 632 * , 363 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0201287 ] .
wong , phys .
d * 66 * , 025015 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0203180 ] .
abazajian , j.f .
beacom and n.f .
bell , phys .
d * 66 * , 013008 ( 2002 ) [ astro - ph/0203442 ] .
w. hu , d.j .
eisenstein and m. tegmark , phys .
* 80 * , 5255 ( 1998 ) [ astro - ph/9712057 ]
. t. schwetz , talk given at ahep-2003 , valencia ( spain ) , oct 2003 [ hep - ph/0311217 ] .
p. di bari , phys .
d * 65 * , 043509 ( 2002 ) .
[ hep - ph/0108182 ] . k.n .
abazajian , astropart .
* 19 * , 303 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0205238 ] .
u. seljak and m. zaldarriaga , astrophys . j. * 469 * , 437 ( 1996 ) [ astro - ph/9603033 ] .
l. verde et al . , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 148 * , 195 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302218 ] .
g. hinshaw et al . , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 148 * , 135 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302217 ] .
a. kogut et al .
, astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 148 * , 161 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302213 ] . c. kuo et al .
[ acbar coll .
] , astrophys .
j. * 600 * , 32 ( 2004 ) [ astro - ph/0212289 ] .
goldstein et al . , astrophys .
j. * 599 * , 773 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0212517 ] .
percival et al . , mon . not .
astron . soc .
* 327 * , 1297 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0105252 ] .
m. tegmark et al .
[ sdss coll .
] , astro - ph/0310725 .
smith et al .
[ the virgo consortium coll .
] , mon . not .
. soc .
* 341 * , 1311 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0207664 ] .
freedman et al . , astrophys . j. * 553 * , 47 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0012376 ] .
s. perlmutter et al .
[ supernova cosmology project coll .
] , astrophys . j. * 517 * , 565 ( 1999 ) [ astro - ph/9812133 ] .
j. lesgourgues and a.r .
liddle , mon . not .
* 327 * , 1307 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0105361 ] .
peacock et al . ,
nature * 410 * , 169 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0103143 ] .
l. verde et al . , mon . not .
* 335 * ( 2002 ) 432 [ astro - ph/0112161 ] .
o. lahav et al . , astro - ph/0112162 .
brandenberger , a. mazumdar and m. yamaguchi , hep - ph/0401239 .
j. bonn et al . , nucl .
* 91 * , 273 ( 2001 ) .
a. osipowicz et al .
[ katrin coll .
] , hep - ex/0109033 . s.r .
elliott and p. vogel , ann .
sci . * 52 * , 115 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0202264 ] .
a. blanchard , m. douspis , m. rowan - robinson and s. sarkar , astron .
astrophys . * 412 * , 35 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0304237 ] .
r. bowen et al . , mon . not .
soc . * 334 * , 760 ( 2002 ) [ astro - ph/0110636 ] .
eisenstein , w. hu and m. tegmark , astrophys .
j. * 518 * , 2 ( 1998 ) [ astro - ph/9807130 ] .
j. lesgourgues , s. pastor and s. prunet , phys .
d * 62 * , 023001 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9912363 ]
. s. hannestad , phys .
d * 67 * , 085017 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0211106 ] . | we combine the most recent observations of large - scale structure ( 2df and sdss galaxy surveys ) and cosmic microwave anisotropies ( wmap and acbar ) to put constraints on flat cosmological models where the number of massive neutrinos and of massless relativistic relics are both left arbitrary .
we discuss the impact of each dataset and of various priors on our bounds . for the standard case of three thermalized neutrinos
, we find @xmath0 ev ( at 2@xmath1 ) , using only cmb and lss data ( resp . including priors from supernovae data and the hst key project ) , a bound that is quite insensitive to the splitting of the total mass between the three species . when the total number of neutrinos or relativistic relics @xmath2 is left free , the upper bound on @xmath3 ( at 2@xmath1 , including all priors ) ranges from @xmath4 to @xmath5 ev depending on the mass splitting .
we provide an explanation of the parameter degeneracy that allows larger values of the masses when @xmath2 increases .
finally , we show that the limit on the total neutrino mass is not significantly modified in the presence of primordial gravitational waves , because current data provide a clear distinction between the corresponding effects . |
optical frequency combs ( ofc ) , generated by femtosecond mode - locked lasers , are recognized to be very powerful devices for spectroscopy .
they offer large bandwidth ( @xmath7 ) discretized at the comb mode frequencies .
they are defined by the repetition rate of the femtosecond oscillator @xmath8 and by a carrier - envelop offset frequency @xmath9 translating the whole comb of a constant value comprised between @xmath10 and @xmath8 , each comb mode frequency being indexed by an integer @xmath11 and defined as @xmath12 .
several approaches @xcite have been designed to combine ofc s with the extended path lengths associated with high finesse cavities , to attain high sensitivity in molecular absorption spectra . some resolve the comb mode structure ( with 1 ghz mode locked laser ) @xcite , some are fast ( around or below the ms timescale of acquisition ) @xcite , some particularly sensitive ( baseline noise around 10@xmath13 ) @xcite , but none truly exploit the full bandwidth of ofc , restricting the accessible spectral range to roughly a few hundred of wavenumbers , around ten percent of the entire range of a typical titanium : sapphir ( ti : sa ) mode - locked laser .
recently , we have developed a new scheme enabling the injection of the full spectrum of an ofc through a high finesse optical cavity and achieving high sensitivity , ghz resolution and sub - second acquisition time @xcite .
it uses vernier filtering , whereby the laser repetition rate and the cavity free spectral range @xmath14 are deliberately mismatched ( as are the two divisions of a vernier caliper ) so that the cavity outputs a new comb whose mode - spacing is sufficiently large that it can be dispersed with optical gratings .
this vernier coupling scheme is currently established as a calibration strategy for the astro - comb extensively developed to calibrate spectra recorded from telescope , creating the so - called astro - comb @xcite .
gohle _ et .
@xcite first applied it to laboratory molecular spectroscopy , resolving the comb mode structure of a 1 @xmath15 ti : sa mode - locked laser over 4 thz ( 130 @xmath0 ) , in 10ms , but at the price of a poor sensitivity ( baseline noise of a few 10@xmath16@xmath0 with an effective optical path - length around 300 m ) . in 2014
@xcite , the same philosophy was extended to a 250 mhz erbium doped fiber mode - locked laser @xcite without the comb mode resolution ( a resolution of 1,1 ghz is obtained ) . a spectral coverage of 160 @xmath0 and a sensitivity of 8@xmath310@xmath4@xmath0 ( with an effective optical path - length of 11 km )
was demonstrated on a time scale of 1 s. still , only a small part of the ofc was exploited and sensitivity performances were again limited by the strong frequency - to - amplitude noise conversion resulting from the un - stabilized cavity with respect to the stabilized ofc .
our approach is distinguished by the degree of mismatches between @xmath14 and @xmath8 . in astro - comb or previous work in molecular spectroscopy ,
the mismatch is large enough to filter out comb teeth adjacent to the tooth transmitted by the cavity .
each tooth of the new comb created at the cavity output thus corresponds to a single tooth of the original optical comb . to extract spectroscopic information from the sample placed inside the cavity ,
the cavity length is slightly swept to permit the transmission of the successive comb teeth through the cavity .
the cavity transmission is thus modulated by the matching condition .
conversely , our scheme uses sufficiently small mismatches that several adjacent teeth are simultaneously ( partially ) transmitted
. the matching condition is always fulfilled , and the cavity length sweep induces a continuous transmission . with a particular cavity locking scheme , this continuous vernier filtering enables to probe the entire range of a free - running 100 mhz repetition rate ti : sa mode - locked laser , at ghz resolution and an optimized sensitivity . with this approach , an absorption baseline noise of 2@xmath310@xmath4@xmath0
is demonstrated with an effective optical path - length of 1,5 km and a spectral coverage larger than 2000 @xmath0 with 31300 independent spectral elements acquired in 1 s. we derive a full analytical model to describe the cavity transmission in presence of intracavity absorbing species for this continuous vernier filtering regime .
we show that both the real and imaginary part of the resonant molecular response need to be take into account revealing a strong dependency of the measured line profile on the sign of the vernier mismatch . using the full model and a non - linear fitting algorithm , we present results of the 3@xmath1+@xmath2 water vapor band adjustment over more than 100@xmath0 including more than 350 lines , and the measured spectra of the hot band of the magnetic dipole intercombination transition in molecular oxygen .
the vernier approach relies on a controlled mismatch between @xmath14 and @xmath8 from the reference position corresponding to the perfect match ( pm ) . in the frequency domain , this pm coupling
occurs when both the scale and the origin of the ofc are tuned to match those of the cavity grid . in our system , @xmath14 ( controlled by the cavity length ) , and @xmath9 are tuned to match @xmath8 and the cavity offset frequency @xmath17 respectively .
a large fraction of the ofc modes are transmitted simultaneously through the cavity , which can be expressed as @xmath18 ( with @xmath19 ) where the integer m is the order of the longitudinal cavity mode .
this reference position is easily identified by applying a small cavity - length modulation , for instance with one of its mirrors mounted on a piezo - transducer ( pzt ) .
the global effect of this length - detuning is to dilate / compress the cavity grid , but at first order ( if all intracavity dispersion sources such as mirror coatings or gas pressure are neglected ) it shifts all the laser teeth out of resonance simultaneously .
filtering out the laser repetition rate , the optical power signal measured at the cavity output when a small dithering is applied around the pm resembles the signal obtained with a single frequency continuous - wave laser : a resonance curve corresponding to the airy function ( a lorentzian line shape at high finesse ) if the scanning speed guarantees the adiabatic response of the cavity , and the emergence of a more and more pronounced ringing when the scanning speed is increased @xcite . for a cavity length ( round - trip ) detuning corresponding to @xmath20 , the longitudinal cavity mode of order @xmath21 reaches the laser mode @xmath11 and secondary peaks appears in transmission . due to the slight @xmath14 variation , all the laser teeth can no longer enter in resonance simultaneously , and only a partial ofc is transmitted simultaneously through the cavity : if the equality @xmath18 @xmath22 is satisfied for one laser mode , the following mode will be slightly shifted with its corresponding cavity resonance , and hence , partially transmitted through the lorentzian line shape .
the secondary transmission peak is thus weaker in intensity and broader than the pm position .
this situation is schematically depicted on fig.[pm_and_2pks ] .
the pattern is symmetrical around the pm position .
but if @xmath9 is not initially matched to the cavity offset , this symmetry is broken , resulting in a shifted and broadened main feature that is less intense than the pm peak and un - symmetrical neighboring peaks . around @xmath23 length at the pm , for matched offset frequencies @xmath24 ( black dotted line ) and mismatched ( red line ) .
( b ) frequency and resonance combs in both cases .
curved arrows indicate the path to reach the matching of the @xmath22th resonance with the nth tooth . in the case where @xmath25 , @xmath14 is already reduced to reach the main peak and a lower reduction
is required to match the @xmath26th resonance .
conversely , a larger increase of @xmath14 is required to match the @xmath27th resonance , reducing the number of teeth simultaneously transmitted and hence the optical power . ] once this pm position is identified , a cavity length variation @xmath28 of a significant number of laser wavelength which depends on the cavity finesse is applied .
this creates a moir pattern between the laser comb and the grid of cavity resonances where some comb teeth are periodically coupled with a periodicity given by the mismatch @xmath28 . the ofc
cavity - filtered makes appear at the cavity output periodic and controllable vernier coincidences defining the vernier comb .
the vernier comb and its response function can be derived with the cavity transfer function @xmath29 , expressed for the optical power as : @xmath30}\ ] ] with the cavity finesse @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the round - trip amplitude reflection factor , and the maximum transmission @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the product of the input and output coupler transmission amplitude .
@xmath35 is the phase accumulated over one round - trip , with @xmath36 a constant phase shift of the cavity inducing the cavity offset frequency @xmath37 .
we consider here neither absorption nor phase dispersion . at the perfect
match all the comb frequencies are at perfect resonance , meaning @xmath38 for all integer
n of the laser comb . this can be written as : @xmath39 from which round - trip length at the pm , @xmath40 , and the laser frequency offset at the pm , @xmath41 are deduced from the laser repetition rate .
if the cavity round trip length is now varied by @xmath28 , the round trip phase expressed at the comb frequencies takes the form : @xmath42 where we deliberately introduced a possible variation , @xmath43 , of the laser frequency offset from its value at the pm . finally , with the help of eq.[pm_roundtrip_phase ] , the phase of eq.[roundtrip_phase_comb ] ( modulo @xmath44 ) is rewritten as : @xmath45 the cavity transfer function being described by the airy function ( eq.[cavity transfer function ] ) , the comb tooth of order @xmath11 is coupled ( at least partially ) to a cavity mode when @xmath46 . if furthermore @xmath47 , adjacent teeth are also partially coupled to their respective resonance .
in fact , using eq.[roundtrip_phase_vernier ] , this last relation can be expressed as @xmath48 or equivalently as @xmath49 . in this regime , injecting the round - trip phase expression of eq.[roundtrip_phase_vernier ] in the cavity transfer function ( eq.[cavity transfer function ] ) , a new airy function is obtained .
this function , plotted as a solid line in fig.[verniercomb ] , has the following expression when sampled by the teeth of the ofc : @xmath50}\ ] ] and corresponds to the envelope of vernier coincidences .
it can be viewed as the response function of the vernier filtering process , a comb of equally spaced lorentzian profiles .
measuring the optical power transmitted through such a profile with a bandpass detector lower than the laser repetition rate eliminates the tooth structure and gives a weighted average frequency for the kth order given by : @xmath51 corresponding to central frequency of the profile .
the spacing between successive orders is the free spectral range of the vernier comb and is given by @xmath52 .
the vernier comb origin has an offset frequency , @xmath53 , directly linked to the offset frequency of the ofc with respect to the cavity .
an important property appearing in view of eq.[vernier_airy_function ] where the factor multiplying the sine function is unchanged with respect to eq.[cavity transfer function ] , is that the cavity finesse also corresponds to the finesse of the vernier comb .
hence , each profile has a linewidth @xmath54 given by @xmath55 . for cavity finesses in the thousand range ,
a 100 mhz repetition rate mode - locked laser can provide vernier order linewidth in the ghz range ( ten successive teeth ) with a vernier comb easily spectrally resolved using standard optical diffraction devices as a moderate resolution of 1 thz is required here .
eq.[order_frequency ] reveals an other important feature of the vernier comb .
order frequencies of the vernier comb are defined by just three free parameters : @xmath8 , setting the cavity length @xmath23 , the mismatch from this length @xmath28 , and the difference between offset frequencies @xmath56 .
any drift or fluctuation of two of those free parameters can thus be balanced by the control of the third .
this property will be exploited to lock the order frequency to a desired value . finally ,
introducing the factor @xmath57 as the inverse of the relative vernier mismatch , all parameters of the vernier comb , @xmath58 , and the profile linewidth @xmath54 can be written as : @xmath59 showing that , as long as @xmath60 , the vernier coupling magnifies the cavity spectral structure probed by the ofc by the factor @xmath61 .
for an empty cavity , the complete expression of the power transmitted from the kth vernier order corresponds to the sum of all transmitted power by adjacent coupled teeth and is given by : @xmath62 where the sine function of eq.[vernier_airy_function ] has been linearized around the vernier order frequency @xmath63 and the relation @xmath64 has been used .
@xmath65 is the index of the laser tooth closest to @xmath63 and @xmath66 the spectral power of the laser comb .
the sum is applied over half of the @xmath67 on each side of the vernier order , which corresponds to @xmath68 in terms of teeth number .
if sufficient adjacent teeth are included under a vernier order envelope , this sum expression can be written as an integral form as : @xmath69 where the position of the laser teeth under the envelope does not appear anymore .
the integral form thus provides a useful analytical expression to process the measured power as tooth position information is not required ( the measured power is insensitive to the location of teeth within the envelope ) .
provided this integral form is appropriate , free - running mode - locked lasers where the whole comb is affected by spectral drift and noise can be used .
we have already seen that this noise can be balanced with the cavity length to not affect the vernier frequency .
now it also appears that it does not affect the transmitted power if the integral form applies .
this is the main feature of continuous vernier filtering .
the power transmitted from an order when its frequency is scanned is only affected by the laser spectrum envelope variation ; the ofc filtering process is continuous . assuming a constant power per tooth @xmath70 , the cavity transmission is constant and simply given by area of the lorentzian profile : + @xmath71 , where the ratio @xmath72 derived with the help of eq.[gamma_v ] , appears as the number of teeth included in the vernier order linewidth .
obviously , in cavity enhanced molecular spectroscopy , the cavity transmission is not constant anymore and we will discuss in the section [ subsec contvernfiltandabsorption ] the modification of eq.[vernier_airy_function ] in presence of intracavity absorption . in any case , it is useful to evaluate the limit of the continuous filtering process as it gives a range of validity and the highest resolution ( the lower value of @xmath54 ) accessible with this approach .
this has been done numerically and the result is plotted in fig.[modulation ] . for a chosen number of teeth @xmath72 in the kth order linewidth , the cavity transmission is simulated using eq.[vernierpower_sum ] when the order frequency is scanned over few @xmath8 around the reference frequency @xmath73 .
the number @xmath72 and the cavity finesse determine the mismatch length as @xmath74 and the frequency scan is induced by a slight variation @xmath75 around the round trip length @xmath76 .
eq.[order_frequency ] provides the needed length variation to scan @xmath8 , @xmath77 , which itself depends on the mismatch .
the power oscillates with a period of @xmath8 when the vernier order envelope slides across the laser teeth .
it is clearly visible in fig.[modulation ] when few teeth form the envelope and it disappears progressively when the number increases .
the average cavity transmission is given by the area of the lorentzian curve and it corresponds directly to ratio @xmath72 when it is normalized by @xmath78 .
the right axis of the graph indicates the value of the length mismatch @xmath28 for each curve , and it corresponds to the inverse of @xmath72 when expressed in unit of @xmath79 .
finally , the graph above the figure shows the residual modulation amplitude as a function of the number of teeth where it appears that the amplitude reduction is fast and at @xmath80 , the modulation is already below @xmath81 . in practice , it is the level of experimental noise which sets the limit but it is hardly below this value and we can reasonably affect a number of five teeth in the linewidth of the vernier order profile as the limit of our approach .
for a 100 mhz mode locked laser , an ultimate resolution of 500 mhz is attainable .
data acquisition rates are of course linked by the rate at which vernier orders can be scanned .
this limit is set by the condition needed to retrieve quantitative absorption measurement through the use of the cavity transfer function . in order to let the resonating optical field build up to its maximum value where the cavity transfer function applies
, cavity resonances have to be swept across a laser tooth in a time longer than the cavity response time : @xmath82 .
this defines the adiabatic cavity excitation and the adiabatic scanning speed , @xmath83 , when single frequency lasers are used . in the vernier coupling case ,
the sweep of the resonance grid over a given spectral range induces a sweep of vernier orders over a frequency range magnified by the magnification factor @xmath61 . as illustrated in fig.[fig_scanningspeed ] , when resonances are swept over @xmath84 , vernier orders are swept over @xmath54 .
the adiabatic frequency scanning speed of vernier orders thus corresponds to the adiabatic frequency scanning speed of the cavity magnified by @xmath61 : @xmath85 .
this enables to cover extremely broad spectral range in a reasonable time .
when the cavity is filled with an analyte absorbing in the spectral range covered by the laser , the vernier comb response function , which includes several cavity resonances , has to be modified in such a way that all effects affecting resonances are taken into account .
their amplitudes are reduced by absorption , their linewidths increased , but also their frequencies are shifted due to the small phase dispersion induced by resonant absorption .
this phase dispersion stretches the cavity fsr under the line core and slightly compresses it into wings @xcite .
the main absorption effect on a vernier order power is of course its reduction .
however , in the continuous vernier filtering limit , if effects are independently compared , the one on the amplitude reduces the power whereas the one on linewidth acts in opposite way as it slightly increases the teeth coupling and hence the power .
the impact of @xmath86 variations is more subtle and appears to discriminate the sign of the vernier mismatch .
for instance , for negative values of @xmath28 , @xmath86 is larger than @xmath8 .
the fsr stretch into the line core thus further reduces the teeth coupling , and reduces the transmitted power .
the situation is reversed for positive values where @xmath86 is lower than @xmath8 resulting into a tooth - coupling increase into the line core . for both signs , the opposite discussion holds in the line wings .
experiment confirms that raw measured absorption profiles are dependent on the mismatch sign .
measured absorption profiles in the continuous vernier filtering limit are not a straightforward convolution of the absorption line with the empty cavity response function . this effect is depicted in fig . [ fig.signdl ] showing some transitions recorded in ambient air taken with mismatch on either side of the pm .
it is here clearly visible that contrasts and lineshapes are affected by the sign of the vernier mismatch . to derive the full vernier response function , it is preferable to start here with the cavity transfer function expressed for the electric field : @xmath87 where the absorption per unit length @xmath88 is introduced and where the round - trip phase now includes an absorption - induced dispersion term : @xmath89 the absorption - induced phase : @xmath90 , is derived from the optical index variation @xmath91 , induced by absorption which is itself deduced from the absorption coefficient through the kramers - kronig relations .
. [ field_transfer_function ] being evaluated at the comb frequencies around the kth vernier order , it can be rewritten in terms of the vernier order frequency @xmath63 as : @xmath92}}\ ] ] the argument of the exponential function is always small around @xmath63 and the denominator can be expanded to the first order as : @xmath93 the last term of eq [ denominator1 ] may be written @xmath94}\ ] ] where @xmath95 corresponds to the increase of resonance linewidth induced by absorption , and @xmath96 corresponds to the shift of the resonance frequency due to absorption .
the cavity transfer function for the optical power expressed at the comb frequencies in the vicinity of the kth vernier order can now be expressed as : @xmath97}\right]^{2}}\right . \end{split}\ ] ] and corresponds to the complete response function of the kth vernier order .
the three effects of absorption are clearly identified , and this expression reveals that the two spectral features , linewidth and shift , of a cavity resonance , are here again magnified by the @xmath98 factor .
moreover , it also shows that the sign of @xmath28 now affects the response function .
being quadratic , it does not impact the linewidth term , but the shift is sign - dependent . using the factor @xmath61 , the vernier response function can be written as : @xmath99}\right]^{2}},\ ] ] where @xmath54 is now defined with the absolute value of @xmath61 and , in the continuous vernier filtering limit , the power transmitted from the kth vernier order as : @xmath100 of course , expression [ vernierpower_int ] is retrieved if @xmath101 .
eqs.[vernier_resp_func_abs ] and [ vernierpower_int_abs ] define the analytical function used to retrieve absorption spectrum from the measured cavity transmission . once an absorption profile adapted to the thermodynamic conditions is selected , this function requires to apply the kramers - kronig relations to express @xmath102 as a function of the fitted parameters .
as will be shown in the following , despite the fact that absorption varies significantly over the integration range , standard non - linear fitting algorithms efficiently converge to retrieve absorption spectra . for extremely low absorption coefficient ,
however , expressions can be simplified by neglecting the tiny effect of absorption phase and by applying first order expansions to @xmath103 and the vernier response function to be expanded as : @xmath104 which can be further reduced to : @xmath105 in this regime of extremely weak absorption , the fractional power reduction is then simply given by : @xmath106 corresponding to the intuitive cavity - enhanced absorption loss convoluted with the normalized lorentzian profile of the vernier order .
the factor 2 results from the integration over the profile , similarly to what is obtained in integrated cavity enhanced approach @xcite . from a more general point of view , we see that the vernier coupling in the continuous limit induces a situation with respect to resolved absorption lines which is almost equivalent to what is obtained when dealing with cavity resonance linewidth in the same range as the absorption linewidth . in this particular case which could be encountered in cavity - enhanced saturated - absorption spectroscopy , the absorption phase also distorts the spectral lineshape of the resonance .
however , the sign of this phase is here controllable with the sign of the vernier mismatch .
the set - up is described in fig.[fig.setup ] .
the fc is provided by a 90mhz mode - locked ti : sapphire laser with a fwhm bandwidth of 30thz centered at @xmath107=785 nm delivering an average output power of around 0.5w .
the beam is mode - matched to the open - air optical cavity formed by four broad - band dielectric mirrors in a bow tie arrangement , lowering high order modes excitation below the percent level .
input and output couplers have a nominal transmission of 0.1% and dominate cavity losses , resulting in a cavity finesse @xmath108 .
one of the two other mirrors is mounted on a fast piezo - transducer ( pzt1 ) with the holder described in @xcite .
the second is also mounted on a piezo - transducer ( pzt2 ) with a travel range of 20@xmath109 m and is supported by a translation stage .
the cavity round - trip length is around 333 cm , and the perfect - match length @xmath23 is found by modulating the pzt2 with an amplitude of a few @xmath109 m and by translating the stage , looking at a photo - detector signal temporarily placed just after the output mirror . from this position , the cavity length is adjusted to the desired value of @xmath76 with the translation stage .
the output beam is then sent onto a 1200l / mm optical grating which diffracts vernier orders in the horizontal plane .
this way , any variation of their frequency induces variation of their location in this plane .
one of them is selected by a split - photodiode ( spd ) .
the current difference of the two elements is amplified to provide a position error signal with a 100khz bandpass .
it results in a frequency error signal which is converted into a correction signal through a integrator - proportional - integrator and sent back to the fast pzt1 .
this closed - loop stabilizes the selected vernier orders optical frequency at a 100mhz level with a bandpass of 20khz filtering out efficiently thermal , mechanical and acoustic noise .
a periodic frequency scan of the vernier order is then obtained by applying an oscillating voltage to the galvo - scanner rotating the grating . the same voltage ( adapted in phase and amplitude )
is also applied to pzt2 as a feed - forward signal in order to reduce the range of the correction signal , which then essentially images relative fluctuations between the comb and the cavity .
it can be noticed that a @xmath110-phase shift of the feed - forward and correction signals is applied when the vernier mismatch sign is changed .
the power transmitted from the vernier order is obtained by the sum of the amplified currents of the spd elements .
this signal , translating the laser spectrum affected by the cavity enhanced absorption , is then sent to a 16-bit analog - to - digital converter ( adc ) during a half period of the oscillating signal also used to trig the acquisition .
the data treatment is processed in a labview environment during the second half the period . in view of eq.[order_frequency ] , the vernier order frequency could , in principle , be deduced from the knowledge of @xmath28 during the scan
. it also requires the precise knowledge of the offset frequency mismatch @xmath56 , of the laser repetition rate from which is deduced @xmath23 and an accurate calibration of the pzt response .
however , the cavity gdd , which depends on the used mirrors but also on the gas pressure , slowly varies the cavity free spectral range and must also be accurately determined to correct for the slight deviation it induces to eq.[order_frequency ] .
we circumvent those difficulties by sending a part of the selected beam onto a solid glass talon without coating and a thickness of 1 cm . the reflected beam measured with a photodiode
is also sent to the adc .
once normalized by the sum spd signal , this talon signal gives a quasi - sine function from which is extracted , during the data treatment time , a quasi - linear relative frequency scale with a wavenumber sampling around 0,333@xmath0 .
this way , the cavity transmission on a relative frequency scale is obtained at each period of the oscillating voltage applied to the galvo - scanner and can be conveniently time - averaged .
the absolute frequency scale of an averaged spectrum is deduced by selecting two observed lines referenced in the hitran database @xcite and placed on each side of the spectrum .
it can be noticed that due to the broad spectral coverage , a linear absolute frequency scale can only be retrieved if the spectral dependance of the talon optical index is taken into account . of + 50@xmath109 m . the calculated baseline retrieved from the raw spectrum
is also plotted with a vertical offset for clarity .
the inset shows the relative frequency ruler provided by the talon reflection .
the absolute frequency scale is determined using the two transitions identified with the hitran database and marked with stars .
( b ) the normalized cavity transmission resulting from raw data and the frequency calibration procedure spanning more than 2000@xmath0 .
the final spectrum of ambient air covers the entire weak @xmath111 band of water vapor ranging from 11600 to 12800@xmath0 and the beginning of the @xmath112 band starting at 13400@xmath0 . between those two water bands ,
the full oxygen a - band is also measured . ] in fig.[rawdata ] ( a ) are depicted the measured signals from the spd and the talon pd acquired during a half period of the vernier sweep when the length mismatch is set to @xmath113 .
the spd signal describes the laser spectrum affected by the cavity - enhanced absorption of ambient air while the talon pd provides a quasi - sinewave signal ( enlarged in the inset ) used as a relative frequency ruler .
the laser spectrum without absorption is determined with a baseline fitting algorithm applied to the spd signal .
those steps enable to retrieve the normalized cavity transmission spectrum over the full bandwidth of the fc .
the final spectrum of ambient air covers the entire weak @xmath111 band of water vapor ranging from 11600 to 12800@xmath0 and the beginning of the @xmath112 band starting at 13400@xmath0 . between those two water bands ,
the full oxygen a - band corresponding to the @xmath114 magnetic dipole intercombination transition is also identified .
the frequency @xmath115 of the sinewave applied to the galvo scanner is set by the probed optical range and the adiabatic scanning speed @xmath116 which depends on the cavity finesse .
for a finesse value around 3000 , a cavity length of 333 cm , a mismatch of 50@xmath109 m and a spectral coverage of 2000@xmath0 , @xmath115 should not exceed 0.5hz which set the acquisition time to 1s .
also , the spectral resolution of the vernier order ( @xmath117 ) is 2ghz ( corresponding to 0.067@xmath0 ) with those parameters providing 31300 independent spectral elements in 1s . of course
, for such a broadband spectrum , the finesse can not be assumed to be constant over the whole range .
however , based on a finesse measurement outside the molecular bands using the ringing method @xcite in well agreement with the specifications provided by the constructor , the finesse is expected to remain within a variation of less than 20% .
after acquisition , the cavity transmission calibrated against the talon ruler can be averaged thanks to the good stability provided by the correction loop . to demonstrate the precision of the relative frequency axis over several measurements , three broadband normalized cavity transmissions are shown in fig.[reproducibility](a )
( offseted for clarity ) , where it is already visible that no major frequency shift is observed .
the three spectra are superimposed and enlarged in panel ( b ) together with a benchmark of 100mhz , confirming the previous statement of a spectral stabilization at 100mhz level .
thus the successive spectra can be efficiently averaged several times without being affected by the drift of the talon fringes due to the low frequency thermal noise .
molecular spectroscopic information , such as width , position and strength of atmospheric transitions , can be deduced from the normalized cavity transmission using the formalism developed in section [ subsec contvernfiltandabsorption ] . especially , eqs .
[ vernier_resp_func_abs ] and [ vernierpower_int_abs ] show that the measured signal is not a simple convolution of the absorption line with the vernier order profile , and particularly that the sign of the length mismatch affects the result . to check the model validity ,
two averaged cavity transmissions were recorded with opposite length mismatches as already shown in fig.[fig.signdl ] and an isolated line , referenced in the hitran database @xcite , was selected out of the weaker part of the water band around 12541@xmath0 . during the baseline correction , two additional sinewaves were added to the baseline algorithm to correct for the small talon fringes induced by two 3 mm thick cavity mirrors .
both normalized spectra are superimposed on fig.[posneg](a ) .
as previously mentioned , the positive mismatch exhibits a reduced contrast compared to the negative one .
small lines are also visible on both sides . both spectra were adjusted using a non - linear algorithm developed in a matlab environment based on eq.[vernierpower_int_abs ] which is replaced by : @xmath118 as the slowly varying laser spectrum can be taken out of the sum and disappears in the experimental normalization process .
as the probed gas is at atmospheric pressure , a purely collisional regime is assumed to govern the absorption profile which is then by a lorentzian profile . in this case
, the shift of the resonance frequency due to absorption @xmath102 , involved in eq.[vernier_resp_func_abs ] , takes the following expression : @xmath119 = + 50@xmath109 m , blue markers @xmath28 = -50@xmath109 m ) superimposed on their respective fits calculated with a cavity finesse of 3150 ( black solid curves ) .
( b ) residuals of the positve mismatch fit ( in red ) and of the negative mismatch fit ( in blue ) .
( c ) comparison between the hitran absorption spectrum calculated for a relative humidity ( rh ) of 45@xmath120 ( black solid curve ) and the absorption spectra retrieved from the fits of the transitions frequencies , linestengths and total linewidths ( negative mismatch with blue markers , positive mismatch with red markers ) .
the agreement between the different lines parameters is better than 2@xmath120 , at the level of precision of the fits residuals . ]
both measurements are fitted and the adjusted curves are superimposed on the measured spectra in fig.[posneg](a ) . for both mismatch signs , measurement and fit are indistinguishable demonstrating the ability of the derived model to apprehend the whole vernier behavior .
the residuals of the fits are plotted in fig.[posneg](b ) and confirm the good agreement between data and model .
appart from some remaining talons , the distortions exhibited by the residuals in the center of the lines are whithin the expected residual distortion induced by the simplistic lorentzian profile that would be of the order of 3@xmath120 of the absorption line contrast at atmospheric pressure , actually showing the need to switch for a more sofisticated line profile such as voigt good up to 310@xmath121 precision of the line at atmospheric pressure .
the result of the fits gives access to the three lines linestrengths , linewidths and transition frequencies .
fig.[posneg](c ) shows the comparison of the absorption spectra recalculated from the fitted line parameters for both mismatch and the absorption spectrum calculated using the hitran database parameters and the relative humidity ( rh ) measured using a commercial hygrometer .
both spectra compare well with hitran prediction .
10@xmath121 , demonstrating the high sensitivity of the system .
the average peak to peak value stays within the limit expected from the lorentzian profile approximation .
( c ) relative humidity retrieved from the fit , indicating an average humidity of 45.2@xmath120 that agrees well with the laboratory measurement of 45@xmath120 using a commercial device ( dashed grey line ) . ] the same model is applied to a spectrum covering a broader range , shown in fig.[h2obroadband](a ) , extracted from the full spectrum already shown in fig.[rawdata ] .
it contains 358 water absorption lines that are fitted using the hitran parameters to retrieve the water concentration .
as previously mentionned , the finesse spectral variations can not be neglected on such a large spectral coverage .
taking it into account , the whole spectrum is fitted piece by piece with a step of 5@xmath0 to retrieve the accurate concentration distribution .
the equally good quality of the fit is assessed with the residuum in panel ( b ) .
the sharp peaks present in the residual are attributed to the lorentzian approximation and the 100mhz instability of the frequency axis .
the resulting rh distribution is plotted in panel ( c ) - the saturation pressure at 23@xmath122c is assumed to be equal to 0.0277atm .
the average rh is equal to 45.2@xmath120 , which compares well with the rh value of 45@xmath120 measured in the laboratory .
final consideration on this spectrum is about the overall sensitivity demonstrated here that can be express in terms of figure of merit ( fm ) defined as the noise equivalent absorption ( nea ) normalized by the square root of the acquisition time of a single spectral element .
the standard deviation of the residuum calculated over the 400@xmath0 is equal to 3@xmath12310@xmath121 .
the sd can be converted linearly to a nea via the usual cavity - enhancement relation for integrated measurement @xcite @xmath124 , leading to a nea of 2@xmath12310@xmath4@xmath0 .
the 2100@xmath0 coverage of the whole spectrum ( fig.[rawdata ] ) were aquired in 1s with a resolution of 0.067@xmath0 , which makes the acquisition time of one spectral element equal to 32@xmath109s .
the fm is then equal to 1.1@xmath12310@xmath5@xmath125 . to further assess the sensitivity of our system ,
a 100 time - averaged cavity transmission was acquired around 12945@xmath0 , covering 120@xmath0 ( fig.[o2sensitivity ] ) .
it was again measured with a resolution of 2ghz and for a positive sign of the mismatch .
again , two sinewaves were added to the baseline normalization procedure in order to correct for the mirror - induced talon fringes . the normalized cavity transmission ( in red )
is plotted together with a fit ( in black - panel ( b ) ) and residuum ( panel ( c ) ) .
the noise level of 3@xmath12310@xmath13 , calculated over the residuum part that is not affected by the lorentzian profile distortion , confirms the white noise averaging effect since it is reduced by a factor 10 compared to the previous value obtained from a single acquisition spectrum ( fig.[h2obroadband](c ) ) .
this spectral ranges contains the low energy tale of the @xmath114 doubly forbidden band of @xmath126 , interleaved with the hot band of the same system , three order lower in intensity .
the oxygen concentration retrieved from the fit agrees within 0.5@xmath120 with the expected concentration in atmosphere at sea level . to illustrate this high sensitivity , the inset fig.[o2sensitivity](c ) focuses on the weakest oxygen doublet measured in the fundamental band , that exhibits a signal to noise ratio close to 2 , giving access to rotational quantum number up to @xmath127 .
it is plotted with both absorbance ( on the left of the inset ) and absorption ( on the right of the inset ) scales , converted using the same linear relation as the nea .
it demonstrates our ability to measure absorption line as weak as 7@xmath12310@xmath128@xmath0 .
eventually , this last result illustrates the ability of this approach to measure and quantitatively exploit absorption lines on a dynamic range of three orders of magnitude .
l = + 50@xmath109 m ) together with a fit of the @xmath126 concentration ( in black ) based on the hitran parameters and a lorentzian absorption profile .
( b ) residual of the fit with a standard deviation of 3@xmath310@xmath13 .
the inset ( c ) shows a enlargement of the weakest o@xmath129 doublet around 12014@xmath0 . in this regime ,
the vernier transmission is purely linear and the absorption scale is shown on the right axis of the inset , demonstrating our ability to measure absorption lines of 7@xmath12310@xmath128@xmath0 with a signal to noise ratio close to 2 . ]
we have developed a formalism that comprehends the whole behavior of the vernier coupling of a frequency comb into a mismatch cavity .
this formalism enables to adjust spectra taken for both sign of the mismatch with the same good agreement , describing the observed discrepancy between both sign contrasts with a reliable accuracy .
the cavity dispersion , that is one of the major bandwidth limitations of other direct frequency comb cavity - enhanced spectroscopy techniques , does not have to be considered in this formalism .
this is enlighten by our ability to measure spectra that cover 2100@xmath0 , which would be impossible with any other tight - locked technique .
the vernier order filtered by the cavity is yet tightly locked with a simple locking technique which is both robust and inexpensive .
the combination of the grating with the split photodiode exploited here effectively stabilize the cavity resonances in regards of the comb modes at 100mhz level , already enough to be able to average the successive spectra .
this gives high signal to noise ratio , which actually makes essential to implement the voigt profile in our model to describe with better veracity the actually doppler broadened measured lineshapes .
the overall performance gives a figure of merit equal to 1.1@xmath12310@xmath5@xmath125 which compares well with the other comb - based spectroscopy techniques , and absorption detection down to the level of 7@xmath12310@xmath128@xmath0 has been demonstrated .
the technique only require the additional measurement of the cavity finesse and of the length mismatch @xmath130l to precisely calibrate the absorption scale .
on the other hand , the frequency calibration is realized with the relative frequency ruler provided by the low finesse talon , that contribute to the simplicity of the setup and is already enough precise for the presented measurements .
yet , this calibration could be made more accurate by replacing the solid talon by a stabilized michelson interferometer and by adding an absolute reference in the ofc beam path .
further developments of the spectrometer include a vacuum cell containing the cavity in order to reliably control the probed gas settings , and to measure accurately the cavity finesse by ringdown measurement over the whole spectral range
. this will also enable to measure the real background of the absorption spectrum , thus opening up to the detection of broad spectral features such as large molecules or aerosols .
anyhow , the vernier spectrometer is already a reliable , simple and low - cost device delivering high sensitivity molecular spectra on a spectral range only limited by the laser bandwidth .
we believe it can find potential application in exploratory spectroscopy , multispecies detection for atmospheric and climate research .
tobias wilken , gaspare lo curto , rafael a. probst , tilo steinmetz , antonio manescau , luca pasquini , jonay i. gonzlez hernndez , rafael rebolo , theodor w. hansch , thomas udem , and ronald holzwarth , nature 485 , 611 - 614 ( 2012 ) | we have recently introduced the vernier - based direct frequency comb cavity - enhanced spectroscopy technique and we present the corresponding formalism for quantitative broadband spectroscopy . we achieve high sensitivity and broadband performance by acquiring spectra covering more than 2000 @xmath0 around 12600@xmath0 ( 800 nm ) , resolving the 3@xmath1+@xmath2 band of water vapor and the entire a - band of oxygen in ambient air .
31 300 independent spectral elements are acquired at the second time scale with an absorption baseline noise of 2@xmath310@xmath4@xmath0 providing a merit figure of 1,1.10@xmath5@xmath0/@xmath6 with a cavity finesse of 3000 and a cavity round - trip length around 3,3 m .
this state - of - the - art performance is reached through a continuous vernier filtering of a titanium : saphire frequency comb with the cavity grid of resonances , obtained when the cavity free spectral range and the laser repetition rate are slightly mismatched . here
, we discuss the effect of the vernier filtering on the measured absorbtion lineshape and we derive the formalism needed to fit molecular spectra . |
@xmath5-axis is vertical in the figure .
solid grey lines indicate unit cell .
( b)high resolution tem of gd@xmath6te@xmath7 along [ 101 ] direction , showing alternating single and double te layers .
, width=288 ] recently the two closely related families of compounds @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4 ( @xmath0=rare earth elements ) have attracted considerable attention for their low dimensional electronic structure and associated charge density wave ( cdw ) formation .
these materials are based on single and double te layers respectively , separated by @xmath0te block layers .
their electronic structure is especially simple , being determined by te @xmath8 and @xmath9 orbitals in the nominally square te planar layers . in the case of @xmath0te@xmath4 , large portions of the resulting quasi 2d fermi surface ( fs )
can be nested by a single incommensurate ( ic ) wave vector , resulting in a sharp peak in the general susceptibility @xmath10 .
the material suffers a cdw distortion at this wavevector for all members of the rare earth series ( @xmath0 = la - nd , sm , gd - tm and y ) , with @xmath11 values depending sensitively on @xmath0 due to the lanthanide contraction.@xcite in contrast , the maximum in @xmath10 for the related single layer compounds @xmath0te@xmath3 ( @xmath0 = la , ce ) is less well defined , and the resulting superlattice modulation varies between rare earths.@xcite the cdw gap is larger in the ditelluride than the tritelluride ( for instance , the maximum gap in cete@xmath3@xcite is 600mev in contrast to 400mev for cete@xmath4@xcite and although the cdw transition has not yet been identified in the ditelluride , transition temperatures are anticipated to be somewhat higher , too ) .
the title compound @xmath1te@xmath2 has an orthorhombic structure ( cmcm ) as illustrated in figure [ fig : crystalstructure ] .
note that for this space group setting , the long @xmath5 axis is _ perpendicular _ to the te planes , while the shorter @xmath12 and @xmath13 lattice parameters lie in the te planes and are almost equal in length .
@xcite the material is intermediate between the two better - known families @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4 described above , consisting of alternating single and double te layers , separated by the same @xmath0te blocks ( figure [ fig : crystalstructure ] ) . as we will show in this paper ,
the electronic structure of this material is reminiscent of the single and double layer variants , essentially comprising sheets associated with each of the te layers separately .
the existence of this compound raises the question of whether separate modulation wave vectors might exist on the single and double te planes separately , and if so how these wave vectors might interact or compete with each other .
although crystals of @xmath1te@xmath2 have previously been grown from an alkali halide flux and their average structure reported , to date no superlattice modulation has been identified for this material . in this study
, we describe an alternative method to grow high quality single crystals from the binary melt , and use transmission electron microscopy ( tem ) to probe the lattice modulation .
we find that all three compounds exhibit a modulation wavevector oriented along the @xmath14 axis with a magnitude close ( @xmath0=nd , gd ) or equal ( @xmath0=sm ) to 2/3@xmath14 , similar to that of the tritelluride compounds .
in addition , each compound exhibits at least one further set of superlattice peaks oriented away from the @xmath14 axis .
calculations of the lindhard susceptibility show that contributions to @xmath15 enhancements arise from sections of the fermi surface associated separately with the single and double te planes and indicate that these different wavevectors , at least for @xmath0=sm and gd , originate from cdw formation in the double and single te planes respectively .
high quality single crystals of @xmath1te@xmath2 ( @xmath0=nd , sm , gd ) were grown by slow cooling a binary melt .
inspection of the equilibrium binary alloy phase diagrams@xcite reveals that @xmath1te@xmath2 has a much narrower exposed liquidus than does either @xmath0te@xmath3 or @xmath0te@xmath4 , corresponding to a temperature range of less than 50@xmath16c and a melt composition that varies by less than 3 at.@xmath17 .
hence , for each rare earth it has been necessary to carefully determine the precise melt composition and temperature profile to achieve the optimal growth conditions that avoid the appearance of second phases . for this reason ,
we have focused on just three members of the rare earth series , nd@xmath3te@xmath2 , sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
lrr crystal & melt composition ( at.@xmath17te ) & temperature profile + + nd@xmath3te@xmath2 & 92.50@xmath17 & 1050 - 880@xmath16c + sm@xmath3te@xmath2 & 90.00@xmath17 & 1000 - 920@xmath16c + gd@xmath3te@xmath2 & 92.00@xmath17 & 1050 - 900@xmath16c + elemental starting materials of rare earth metal ( ames mpc , 99.50@xmath17 for sm and 99.80@xmath17 for nd and gd ) and tellurium(alfa aesar , 99.9999@xmath17 ) were cut and placed in alumina crucibles and sealed in evacuated quartz tubes . the ampoules were placed in a furnace and ramped to 1050@xmath16c before slowly cooling to an end temperature ( table i ) at which they were removed from the furnace and the remaining flux separated from the crystals by decanting in a centrifuge .
the optimal melt composition and temperature profile varied even for the three closely spaced members of the rare earth series studied here , and are listed in table 1 .
the resulting crystals were gold in color , forming thin , malleable and micaceous plates .
single crystal x - ray diffraction was used to confirm the phase of the crystals .
@xmath18 - 2@xmath18 scans along the @xmath19 direction revealed clear peaks for even @xmath20 with the appropriate lattice parameter , indicating well formed single crystalline phase of @xmath1te@xmath2 . in the measurement
, it was observed that some crystals showed weak @xmath0te@xmath4 peaks mixed with very strong @xmath1te@xmath2 peaks .
the @xmath0te@xmath4 peaks could be reduced in magnitude or even caused to totally disappear by removing the surface layers of the crystals using adhesive tape .
this thin layer of @xmath0te@xmath4 forms on the surface of the @xmath1te@xmath2 crystals during the rapid cooling , while the remaining melt is removed by centrifuge , and is essentially a consequence of applying this growth technique to a material with such a small exposed liquidus in the phase diagram.@xcite the composition of the crystals was examined by electron microprobe analysis ( empa ) , for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 . in both cases ,
tellurium content was determined to be 72 @xmath211 at.@xmath17 , consistent with the value anticipated for @xmath1te@xmath2 ( @xmath22 ) .
te@xmath2 looking down the [ @xmath2301]direction .
the image shows regular crystal structure over a macroscopic length scale ( more than 25 nm ) without intercalation or stacking faults in the layering along the @xmath5-direction .
, width=288 ] cross - sectional tem samples were prepared using a sandwich method " : a small , plate - like gd@xmath3te@xmath2 single crystal ( @xmath242 x 2 x 0.1 mm ) was placed in between a small stack of spacers cleaved from a single crystal silicon wafer that snuggly fit inside a 3 mm diameter quartz tube .
the open spaces were in - filled using epoxy ( epo - tek 353nd ) to hold the stack together .
a disk with a thickness about 0.5 mm was cut from the quartz tube using a diamond saw .
the gd@xmath3te@xmath2 single crystal was oriented such that the @xmath5-axis lay in the plane of the disk and the [ 101 ] direction was close to the disk normal .
the disk then was ground and polished to about 30@xmath2450 @xmath25 m thickness .
a vcr dimpler was used to further thin the disk center area to less than 30 @xmath25 m .
the final thinning of the tem sample was performed at room temperature using a fischione model 1010 ion - miller .
the milling with an initial setting of the ar ion guns condition started at 23@xmath16 , 5 kv and 5 ma , at room temperature till perforation , then followed with 3 kv and 3 ma , 15@xmath16 for 15 min , and final with 2 kv , 3 ma , 10@xmath16 for 20 min . a tecnai g@xmath26 f20 stem ( point - to - point resolution : 0.25 nm ) operated at 200 kv was employed to do the microstructure investigation .
high resolution tem ( hrtem ) simulation was done using the national center electron microscopy simulation program which employs the multi - slice approximation .
large crystalline regions were separated by residual flux inclusions that appears continuous along the micaceaous planes .
nonetheless , the hrtem image of the gd@xmath3te@xmath2 single crystal shows a highly perfect crystal structure over a large area ( @xmath24400 nm@xmath26 , figure [ fig : hrtem ] ) .
image matching to the simulations of the [ 101 ] image ( figure [ fig : crystalstructure ] ) suggest that the isolated bright spots are columns of te atoms which make up the single and double layers of te planes along the c - axis direction .
the elongated bright dumbbell features are the gd - te pairs in the gd - te block layers .
electron beam diffraction was also measured at room temperature using a philips cm20 feg - tem operating at 200kv in vacuum in order to determine the @xmath27-plane modulation structure in @xmath20 space .
samples were carefully cleaved to generate thin crystal pieces with thickness less then 30@xmath25 m , which were mounted on a copper grid .
optimal thickness for the measurement was achieved by making a small hole in the middle of the crystals by ion - milling in vacuum for a few hours .
electron beams at 200kv were aligned normal to the @xmath27 plane in [ 010 ] zone axis and selected area diffraction patterns ( sadps ) from the flat thin edge of the crystal hole were observed at room temperature in vacuum .
te@xmath2 ( b ) sm@xmath3te@xmath2 , and ( c ) gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
bragg peaks are labeled by ( @xmath28 ) .
systematic modulation wavevectors are listed in table ii .
, title="fig:",width=2 ] te@xmath2 ( b ) sm@xmath3te@xmath2 , and ( c ) gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
bragg peaks are labeled by ( @xmath28 ) .
systematic modulation wavevectors are listed in table ii . ,
title="fig:",width=2 ] te@xmath2 ( b ) sm@xmath3te@xmath2 , and ( c ) gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
bragg peaks are labeled by ( @xmath28 ) .
systematic modulation wavevectors are listed in table ii .
, title="fig:",width=2 ] all three compounds studied exhibit a complex set of superlattice peaks in the @xmath27 plane(figure [ fig : tem ] ) .
as previously observed in other families of rare earth tellurides , the satellite peaks in the quadrant defined by the bragg peaks for @xmath29 translate equivalently by reciprocal lattice wave vectors @xmath30 , @xmath29.@xcite the relative satellite peak positions in the first quadrant are listed in table ii in units of the reciprocal lattice parameters .
the sadps for nd@xmath3te@xmath2 , sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 are all different , but nevertheless have some common features .
in particular , all three compounds exhibit an ` on - axis ' superlattice reflection @xmath31 oriented along either the a@xmath32 or c@xmath32 direction . within the resolution of tem
, we can not distinguish @xmath12 and @xmath13 lattice parameters .
however , high resolution x - ray diffraction on gd@xmath3te@xmath2 indicates that @xmath31 is , in fact , oriented along the c@xmath32 direction.@xcite for simplicity , we have also listed this lattice modulation as being along c@xmath32 for nd@xmath3te@xmath2 and sm@xmath3te@xmath2 in table ii , although this remains to be confirmed .
this on - axis modulation wave vector is incommensurate for nd@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 with @xmath31 = 0.688 @xmath33 and 0.687 @xmath33 for the two compounds respectively ( figure [ fig : tem](a),(c ) ) . in contrast , the on - axis wave vector for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 is commensurate within the resolution of the measurement , with @xmath31 = 0.667@xmath33= 2/3@xmath33 ( figure [ fig : tem](b ) ) .
lcrr crystal & q & @xmath34 & @xmath35 + + nd@xmath3te@xmath2 & q@xmath36 ( on - axis ) & [email protected] & [email protected] + & q@xmath37 ( off - axis ) & [email protected] & [email protected] + & q@xmath3 ( off - axis ) & [email protected] & [email protected] + + sm@xmath3te@xmath2 & q@xmath36 ( on - axis ) & [email protected] & [email protected] + & q@xmath37 ( off - axis ) & [email protected] & [email protected] + + gd@xmath3te@xmath2 & q@xmath36 ( on - axis ) & 0.0000@xmath38 & 0.6871@xmath39 + & q@xmath37 ( off - axis ) & 0.417@xmath38 & 0.083@xmath38 + & q@xmath3 ( off - axis ) & 0.083@xmath38 & 0.417@xmath38 + in addition to the on - axis cdw , each of the compounds has a distinct and unique off - axis cdw structure
. neglecting the small difference in @xmath12 and @xmath13 lattice parameters , which is below the resolution of this measurement , the off - axis cdw in nd@xmath3te@xmath2 seems to have four fold rotational symmetry and the lattice modulation can be simply characterized by a single wavevector @xmath40 .
the second equivalent wavevector @xmath41 is generated by reflection symmetry about the @xmath42 and @xmath14 axes .
similar symmetry mapping has been reported for the off - axis superlattice peak @xmath43 in late@xmath3@xcite .
the off - axis cdw in sm@xmath3te@xmath2 is unique among the three compounds studied in that @xmath31 and @xmath40 generate the off - axis higher harmonics @xmath44 and @xmath45 which are _ incommensurate _ in the @xmath12-direction and _ commensurate _ in the @xmath13-direction .
all the other peaks can be expressed in terms of linear combinations of q@xmath36 and q@xmath37 as indicated in figure [ fig : tem](b ) , which means that the remaining other peaks are higher harmonics of those two q vectors . correspondingly , @xmath46 = 2/3@xmath14 = 0.667@xmath14 and @xmath47 are stronger in intensity than the higher harmonics @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
a similar higher harmonic cdw structure formed by linear combination of two distinct q vectors was also recently found in erte@xmath4 by high resolution x - ray diffraction measurements.@xcite in contrast to nd@xmath3te@xmath2 and sm@xmath3te@xmath2 , the off axis cdw in gd@xmath3te@xmath2 is fully commensurate in both a@xmath32 and c@xmath32 .
high resolution x - ray diffraction measurements at stanford synchrotron radiation laboratory(ssrl)@xcite confirm that all peaks can be indexed by linear combinations of the two wavevectors @xmath40=5/12 @xmath42 + 1/12 @xmath14 and @xmath41=1/12 @xmath42 + 5/12 @xmath14 , although it is not immediately clear that these are really the two fundamental wavevectors since other linear combinations are also possible in such a fully commensurate satellite peak structure .
te@xmath2 calculated by lmto for @xmath0=lu .
the blue solid lines arise from te @xmath48 states in the square planar layers .
( b ) and ( c ) the resulting fermi surfaces , illustrating the trilayer splitting that arises due to coupling between the three te planes . red and yellow sheets in ( b ) and blue and purple sheets in ( c ) indicate the weaker bilayer splitting originating from te double layer , while orange and green sheets in ( b ) and ( c ) are due to te single layer and the splitting is significant .
the @xmath49-point at the centre of the zone and other high symmetry points have been labeled .
, title="fig:",width=3 ] te@xmath2 calculated by lmto for @xmath0=lu .
the blue solid lines arise from te @xmath48 states in the square planar layers .
( b ) and ( c ) the resulting fermi surfaces , illustrating the trilayer splitting that arises due to coupling between the three te planes . red and yellow sheets in ( b ) and blue and purple sheets in ( c ) indicate the weaker bilayer splitting originating from te double layer , while orange and green sheets in ( b ) and ( c ) are due to te single layer and the splitting is significant .
the @xmath49-point at the centre of the zone and other high symmetry points have been labeled .
, title="fig:",width=3 ] the electronic band structure for @xmath1te@xmath2 was calculated using the linear muffin - tin orbital ( lmto ) method within the atomic sphere approximation including combined - correction terms as described in refs . and and
the results are shown in figure [ fig : bandstructure ] specifically for @xmath0=lu ( chosen to avoid the complications associated with the description of ( band ) @xmath50-electrons within the local density approximation ) . the slight difference in lattice parameters originating from the structural orthorhombicity
was ignored in the calculation and the value of a = c=4.36@xmath51 ( b / a=10.06 ) from ref .
for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 was used , which is very close to a=4.34@xmath51 for smte@xmath4.@xcite since the fs is comprised of te @xmath48 states originating from the te atoms in the square planar layers , the general _ topology _ of the fs is relatively insensitive to the particular choice of rare earth atom , and indeed to changes in the lattice parameter of @xmath52% , allowing us to interpret these results as prototypical for all of the other rare earth compounds .
all calculations included a basis of @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 and @xmath50 states , and self - consistency was achieved at 1280 k - points in the irreducible @xmath56 wedge of the bz ( corresponding to a mesh of @xmath57 in the full bz ) .
as previously found for @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4,@xcite the electronic structure for @xmath1te@xmath2 is two dimensional and has minimal dispersion perpendicular to the te planes(figure [ fig : bandstructure](b ) and ( c ) ) .
six bands formed by @xmath48 orbitals from te square planes were observed to cross the fermi level ( blue solid lines in figure [ fig : bandstructure](a ) ) and the corresponding fs at @xmath58 is depicted in figure [ fig : fsnesting ] . in the tritelluride compounds ,
the inequivalence of the two te atoms in the double square planar layer breaks the degeneracy of these bands , and the resulting bilayer splitting has been observed directly in arpes studies .
@xcite for @xmath1te@xmath2 , in addition to this double te sheet , there is an additional single te layer , and the band structure reflects this via a triple splitting of its te states .
the splitting between states originating from the double layer is weak and of a similar magnitude to the bilayer splitting in the tritelluride compounds , whereas the splitting between either of these double layer states and the state due to the single layer is more significant.@xcite .
red and green lines approximately indicate sections of fs , formed by @xmath48 orbitals from the single and double te layers respectively .
arrows indicate the on - axis lattice modulation @xmath59 observed in sadp for nd@xmath3te@xmath2 , sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 . ,
width=3 ] in addition , a small circular electron pocket due to the hybridization with a lu _ d_-state above @xmath60 ( indicated by red arrows in figure [ fig : bandstructure ] ( a ) ) was observed around the @xmath49 point .
details of this hybridization are sensitive to the rare earth involved in the calculation , unlike the other te @xmath48 bands , and hence we might expect that the presence and exact volume of this pocket varies , as we progress through the lanthanide series .
this in turn may vary the precise location of @xmath61 within the te 5@xmath54 bands , although small fluctuations of the electron pocket volume do not seem to significantly impact interactions between 5@xmath54 electrons in the te square planes .
in addition , the topology of this small circular section does not contribute any appreciable peak structure to the susceptibility , leading us to put less emphasis on it in the subsequent analysis of @xmath15 .
even with the same @xmath12 and @xmath13 lattice parameters used in the calculation , the orthorhombicity due to the relative orientation of @xmath0-te slabs in different layers is reflected in the electronic structure and produced unequal electron pockets centered at x and z ( figure [ fig : fsnesting ] ) . the directional difference in the electronic structure , in turn
, suggests that the band splitting at the fermi level partially depends on the relative geometry and interactions between te atoms in square planes and rare earth atoms in the @xmath0-te slabs , even though the interplanar interaction is believed to be small .
nevertheless , the overall topology of the fs is surprisingly similar to the individual sections of mono- and bi - layer fs structures of @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4 ( figure 3(a ) and figure 5(a ) in ref . ) and thus can be approximated by superposing the corresponding fermi surfaces of those two materials with only minor changes to account for differences in band filling .
a close investigation of the character of the wavefunction at each point supports this view and revealed that the origin of the individual fs sections can mostly be attributed to @xmath48 atomic orbitals in either the ditelluride - like single te planar layer or the tritelluride - like double te planar layers respectively(red and green lines in figure [ fig : fsnesting ] ) , if the strong orbital hybridization or orbital mixing is ignored near the band crossings at the fermi level .
this is somewhat as expected , considering that the orthorhombic structure of @xmath1te@xmath2 is intermediate of @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4 with very close @xmath27 parameters and alternating single and double te layers along the [ 010 ] direction .
cdw formation is described by the second quantized frhlich hamiltonian , @xmath62 where @xmath63 and @xmath64 are the electron creation operator in the @xmath65 band , and phonon creation operator in the @xmath66 mode respectively .
the electron - phonon interaction is tuned by the coupling @xmath67 between the @xmath65 electron band and the @xmath66 phonon mode and the effect on the lattice distortions can be shown by obtaining the renormalized phonon mode and the dispersion relation from equation ( 2 ) : @xmath68,h\right]\nonumber\\ \ddot{q}_{m , q}&\approx&-\omega^{2}_{m , q}q_{m , q}-\sum_{n}g_{n , m , q}\left(\frac{2\omega_{m , q}}{m\hbar}\right)^{1/2}\rho_{n , q } \nonumber\\ \rho_{n , q}&=&-\chi_{n}(q)\sum_{m'}g_{n , m',q}\left(\frac{2\omega_{m',q}}{m\hbar}\right)^{1/2}q_{m',q}\nonumber\\ \ddot{q}_{m , q}&=&-\omega^{2}_{m , q}q_{m , q}\nonumber\\ & + & \sum_{n , m'}\frac{2g_{n , m , q}g_{n , m',q}(\omega_{m , q}\omega_{m',q})^{1/2}}{m\hbar}\chi_{n}(q)q_{m',q}\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath69 and @xmath70 refer to the oscillation energy frequency and the fourier component of the non - interacting normal coordinate of the m@xmath71 phonon mode respectively and @xmath72 indicates electron density in the n@xmath71 electron energy band .
the resultant phonon mode softening strongly depends on the strength of @xmath67 and @xmath73 .
while the coupling strength @xmath67 singles out the electron bands and phonon modes relevant to lattice distortions , the distortion wave vectors are selected by the peak structure in @xmath73 , which is mainly decided by fs nesting : @xmath74 where @xmath75 and @xmath76 refer to fermi - dirac function and the energy of the electron in n@xmath71 band .
although it has never been easy to obtain the exact @xmath77,@xmath78 and @xmath79 dependence of the coupling strength @xmath80 theoretically or experimentally , @xmath73 is relatively accessible from band structure calculations , and indeed several authors have argued the origin of cdw formation in both @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4 in terms of simple fs nesting conditions using tight binding band calculations.@xcite this model was successful in identifying the sections of fs which drives the cdw modulation in these compounds , and the details of the nesting was found to be dependent mainly on the _ topology _ of the fs at the fermi level rather than of the whole band structure .
we have used the same approach for @xmath1te@xmath2 , calculating the lindhard susceptibility @xmath15 of the lmto band structure illustrated in figure [ fig : bandstructure ] in order to examine the origin of the _
on- _ and _ off - axis _ cdw super lattices observed for this family of compounds . for computational simplicity , the two dimensional band structure at @xmath81=0 was considered for the summation in the 1st brillouin zone(equation 3 ) . however , if we assume an isotropic coupling strength @xmath67=@xmath80 and consequently calculate @xmath15 by summing over all bands including inter single - double layer contributions , this quantity is found to be relatively uninformative .
broad maxima are found centered around 0.5@xmath42 and 0.5@xmath14(figure [ fig : chiq](a ) ) , but otherwise there is not a well - developed peak structure that would lead one to anticipate one particular wavevector to be favored over another .
deeper insight can be gained when more general coupling strength @xmath80 s , varying for individual phonon modes and te layers , are introduced .
motivated by the identification of distinct sections of the fs associated with the single and double te square planes ( figure [ fig : fsnesting ] ) , we accordingly divide the six @xmath48 bands crossing the fermi level @xmath60 into two relevant subgroups that form ditelluride - like fs sections from single te layers , and tritelluride - like fs sections from double te layers .
the contributions to the lindhard susceptibility from each subgroup , @xmath82 and @xmath83 , can be calculated as shown in equation ( 4 ) , where @xmath84 and @xmath85 refer to single and double layers respectively : @xmath86 results of these calculations are shown in figures [ fig : chiq](b ) and ( c ) .
inspection of these figures indicates that @xmath82 and @xmath83 have a more finely peaked structure than the total @xmath15 ( figure [ fig : chiq](a ) ) . using this division , and following equation ( 2 ) ,
the resulting renormalized phonon mode dispersion is given by : @xmath87 this dispersion relation ( equation 5 ) explicitly shows how the phonon mode softening depends on the average coupling strengths @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 , and the lindhard susceptibility contributions @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath93 , from the single , double and inter single - double layer contributions respectively .
this division makes it possible , at least in principle , to identify the relative coupling strength as well as the most relevant electron bands from the observed lattice distortions . in the following two sections , we address the origin of the _ on_- and _ off - axis _
lattice modulation with reference to these contributions .
= @xmath94 at @xmath95=0 , summed for all the bands including inter single - double layer pairs .
( b ) @xmath83 : contribution to @xmath15 from the double te layers . _ on - axis _ wave vectors for all three compounds lie on the _ global maximum_. inset : a line cut following the dashed line , illustrating the resonant enhancement of the mixed harmonics @xmath96 and @xmath97 for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 . ( c ) @xmath82 : contribution to @xmath15 from the single te layers .
symbols represent first harmonics of the _ off - axis _ modulation vectors for all three compounds , and second harmonics for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
upper inset : a line cut following the horizontal dashed line .
the _ off - axis _
modulation lies close to the _ global maximum _ of @xmath82 for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 .
lower inset : a line cut following the vertical dashed line , showing the resonant enhancement of the commensurate _ off - axis _
lattice modulation for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
, title="fig:",width=2 ] = @xmath94 at @xmath95=0 , summed for all the bands including inter single - double layer pairs .
( b ) @xmath83 : contribution to @xmath15 from the double te layers . _ on - axis _ wave vectors for all three compounds lie on the _ global maximum_. inset : a line cut following the dashed line , illustrating the resonant enhancement of the mixed harmonics @xmath96 and @xmath97 for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 .
( c ) @xmath82 : contribution to @xmath15 from the single te layers .
symbols represent first harmonics of the _ off - axis _ modulation vectors for all three compounds , and second harmonics for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
upper inset : a line cut following the horizontal dashed line .
the _ off - axis _
modulation lies close to the _ global maximum _ of @xmath82 for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 .
lower inset : a line cut following the vertical dashed line , showing the resonant enhancement of the commensurate _ off - axis _
lattice modulation for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
, title="fig:",width=2 ] = @xmath94 at @xmath95=0 , summed for all the bands including inter single - double layer pairs .
( b ) @xmath83 : contribution to @xmath15 from the double te layers . _ on - axis _ wave vectors for all three compounds lie on the _ global maximum_. inset : a line cut following the dashed line , illustrating the resonant enhancement of the mixed harmonics @xmath96 and @xmath97 for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 .
( c ) @xmath82 : contribution to @xmath15 from the single te layers .
symbols represent first harmonics of the _ off - axis _ modulation vectors for all three compounds , and second harmonics for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
upper inset : a line cut following the horizontal dashed line .
the _ off - axis _
modulation lies close to the _ global maximum _ of @xmath82 for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 .
lower inset : a line cut following the vertical dashed line , showing the resonant enhancement of the commensurate _ off - axis _
lattice modulation for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
, title="fig:",width=2 ] all three compounds exhibit an on - axis lattice modulation with wave vector oriented along either the a * or c * axis . as noted in section iii
, tem can not distinguish these two lattice parameters , but high resolution x - ray diffraction experiments for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 have determined that @xmath98 is in fact oriented along the c * direction for this compound . the orientation of the on - axis wave vector for nd@xmath3te@xmath2 and sm@xmath3te@xmath2 remains to be determined , but for simplicity we have referred to these as also lying along the c * direction .
the magnitude of the on - axis wave vectors for the three compounds are very similar , being commensurate @xmath99 c * for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 , with very close incommensurate values for nd@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 ( table ii ) . significantly
, the on - axis wave vectors for all three compounds correspond to a very well - defined sharp maximum in @xmath83 calculated from the sections of the fs associated with the double te layers ( figure [ fig : chiq](b ) ) .
a substantial fraction of the fs coming from these double layers are nested by this wave vector , as indicated by vertical arrows in figure [ fig : fsnesting ] .
the actual modulation wave vectors are very close to the maximum in @xmath83 , and @xmath100 is smaller by less than 5@xmath17 compared to the calculated _ global _ maximum .
this striking correspondence is highly suggestive that the double te layers drive the _ on - axis _ cdw .
the simpler double - layer compound @xmath0te@xmath4 also exhibits an on - axis superlattice modulation , also corresponding to a similarly well - defined peak in the susceptibility . in that case , the wave vector @xmath98@xmath245/7@xmath14=0.71@xmath14 over the entire range of the compounds(@xmath0=la - tm),@xcite which is also very close to @xmath98 for @xmath1te@xmath2 .
the difference in @xmath101 values between the two families of compounds can be attributed to differences in band filling , as well as to the more complicated electronic structure in @xmath1te@xmath2 .
nevertheless , the similarity in the nesting mechanism driving the _ on - axis _ modulation in the two compounds , and its stability across the rare earth series for both families , is remarkable .
given the clear correlation between the on - axis modulation wave vectors and @xmath83 , it is natural to reason that the off - axis wave vectors might be more closely associated with the single te planes .
indeed , with the possible exception of nd@xmath3te@xmath2 , none of the three compounds studied exhibit any obvious correlation between the off - axis wave vectors and @xmath83 , whereas , as we show below , there is a close correlation with @xmath82 , at least for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 .
however , the off - axis modulation is not as simple to account for as the on - axis modulation . in particular
, there is considerable variation in the off - axis wave vectors for the three compounds studied ( table ii ) , reminiscent of the variation in the lattice modulation for the simpler single - layer compound @xmath0te@xmath3 ( @xmath0 = la - er ) .
consequently , we consider each of the three compounds separately below .
first , sm@xmath3te@xmath2 .
for this compound , the off - axis modulation lies along the @xmath12-axis , with an incommensurate wave vector @xmath102 ( here we preserve the notation _ off - axis _ " to indicate that @xmath40 is not oriented parallel to @xmath31 , even though , in this case , @xmath40 lies along a high symmetry direction ) .
as can be seen from the inset to figure [ fig : chiq](c ) , this wave vector lies very near to the _ global _ maximum in @xmath82 , indicating that the single te layers do indeed play a significant role in driving this off - axis cdw .
the behavior is also reminiscent of the unit cell doubling associated with the cdw superlattice found in some of the rare earth ditellurides @xmath0te@xmath3.@xcite as described in section iii , sm@xmath3te@xmath2 is unique among the three compounds studied in that the mixed harmonics of the cdw modulations @xmath103 and @xmath104 are evident in sadp patterns .
close inspection of the inset to figure [ fig : chiq](b ) reveals that these wave vectors , which have a different incommensurate / commensurate structure in the @xmath12 and @xmath13 directions , are in fact closely associated with noticeably significant peak structures in @xmath83 .
the same figure also shows that @xmath105 , equivalent to @xmath106 , is actually very near to another global maximum in @xmath83 adjacent to ( 101 ) .
this maximum is equivalent to that which is close to @xmath31 by a simple reciprocal lattice translation , suggestive of a resonance in the interaction due to the crystal symmetry : @xmath107 these observations suggest a significant coupling between the two wave vectors @xmath31 and @xmath40 in sm@xmath3te@xmath2 .
even though the off - axis modulation is principally driven by the single te - planes ( i.e. @xmath40 is very close to the global maximum in @xmath82 ) nevertheless , it is not insensitive to the double layers . in contrast , the on- and off - axis cdw modulations in nd@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 seem to be independent or minimally coupled to each other , without any commensurate / incommensurate mixing .
in contrast to sm@xmath3te@xmath2 , the off - axis cdw in gd@xmath3te@xmath2 is fully commensurate . although the modulation wave vectors @xmath108 and @xmath109 for gd@xmath3te@xmath2 are different to that observed in sm@xmath3te@xmath2 , both lie close to global maxima in @xmath82 , suggesting that the single te planes play the dominant role in driving the off - axis cdw for this compound , too . it is worth noting , however , that the peak structure in @xmath82 ( figure [ fig : chiq](c ) ) is far less well developed than that in @xmath83 ( figure [ fig : chiq](b ) ) . rather than
a single _ global _ maximum with little in the way of additional features , @xmath82 exhibits a broad range of maxima along sharp ridges " ( dark red regions in figure [ fig : chiq](c ) ) connecting four relatively sharp local peaks centered close to @xmath110=(0 0 0.5),(0.5 0 0),(-0.5 0 0 ) and ( 0 0 -0.5 ) .
the resulting figure is reminiscent of similar calculations for the simpler single layer compound @xmath0te@xmath3 , which also lack a well - defined single peak , and for which the superlattice modulation vectors also vary across the rare earth series.@xcite we will return to the variation in the off axis wave vectors later .
the two commensurate cdw vectors , @xmath108 and @xmath109 , in gd@xmath3te@xmath2 span the entire commensurate cdw super lattice peaks in @xmath111 space .
such an extensive commensurate modulation structure may not allow a simple explanation in terms of perturbative higher harmonics . however , it is interesting to note that @xmath112 , a second harmonic of @xmath108 , lies exactly on top of an additional weak local maximum in @xmath82 , which may give some hint as to the origin of this extensive commensurate structure ( inset to figure [ fig : chiq](c)-the strength of this feature depends sensitively on details of the calculation , but appears to be robust ) .
specifically , rather than just a simple perturbation of @xmath108 , 2@xmath108 itself also seems to be directly coupled to the relevant electronic structure through the _ local maximum peak _ at @xmath113 .
this effect coherently enhances the cdw instabilities at @xmath110=2@xmath108 and seems to help the commensuration mechanism of the off - axis cdw to extend to higher @xmath78 harmonics or integral multiple of @xmath108 , while it is , in contrast , weakly or minimally coupled to the on - axis cdw leaving that incommensurate .
this behavior is in distinct contrast to that of the other two compounds studied , neither of which exhibits higher harmonics of the off - axis modulation vectors . by way of comparison with sm@xmath3te@xmath2
, it is also worth noting that the off - axis cdw peaks in gd@xmath3te@xmath2 lie in a high but flat region , without any sharp peak features , when mapped onto @xmath83 of the ditelluride - like double te layers . as such , and in contrast to the case of sm@xmath3te@xmath2
, the off - axis cdw wave vectors observed in gd@xmath3te@xmath2 appear to get enhanced mainly within the te single layer by this subtle interaction and develop an extensive commensurate cdw structure .
although the off - axis lattice modulation is different for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 , and although they each exhibit different resonant mechanisms which enhance the off - axis cdw based on interaction with the double or single te planes respectively , nevertheless , the off - axis cdw for both compounds appears to be principally driven by the single te planes .
in sharp contrast , nd@xmath3te@xmath2 appears to defy this simple model .
specifically , the off - axis modulation wave vectors for this compound do not lie close to the global maximum in @xmath82 ( triangular points in figure [ fig : chiq](c ) ) . instead , they are found near _ local _ maxima which have values about 20@xmath17 less than the _ global _ maximum in both @xmath82 and @xmath83 , although these features are very weak .
taken at face value , it appears that both single and double planes contribute towards the off - axis cdw in nd@xmath3te@xmath2 , although it is impossible from this analysis to determine whether one or the other plays a dominant role .
one of the principle defining features of the off - axis lattice modulation is the huge variation between the three compounds studied , especially given the minimal differences observed in the on - axis wave vector . given that the electronic structure is essentially identical for all three compounds , this large variation suggests that differences in the phonon mode characteristics play an important role .
the atomic masses of nd , sm and gd differ by up to 10@xmath17 , affecting the lattice instability through equation 5 .
presumably , the very well - defined peak feature in @xmath83 ( figure [ fig : chiq](b ) ) ensures that the on - axis wave vector remains tied to the wave vector at which this quantity peaks , even as the phonon modes and electron - phonon coupling change .
however , the more poorly defined maximum in @xmath82 ( figure [ fig : chiq](c ) ) is apparently not strong enough to completely dominate the electron - phonon coupling to the extent that variation in the phonon characteristics are able to affect the lattice modulation . this behavior is consistent with that of the single and double layer compounds @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4 - the former having a poorly defined peak in @xmath15 and a lattice modulation very sensitive to changes in rare earth,@xcite the latter having a very well - defined peak in @xmath15 , and a lattice modulation that hardly changes across the entire rare earth series .
in summary , we have presented an alternative method to prepare large , high - quality single crystals of @xmath1te@xmath2 ( @xmath0=nd , sm and gd ) via a binary self flux method , and have presented the first evidence for charge density wave formation in this material .
all three compounds exhibit an _ on - axis _ modulation with @xmath114 along the @xmath14-direction , in combination with an _ off - axis _ superlattice which varies significantly between the three compounds studied . based on a consideration of contributions to the lindhard susceptibility from the single and double te planes of the layered structure
, it appears that the on - axis cdw is driven by the double te planes , whereas the off - axis cdw is principally driven by the single te planes .
resonant effects associated with coupling of higher harmonics of these modulation wave vectors to local features in the susceptibility of the double and single te planes appear to be relevant for sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 respectively , stabilizing in the first case mixed commensurate / incommensurate off - axis harmonics , and in the second an extensive commensurate structure associated with just the single te layers , decoupled from the on - axis modulation .
we gratefully thank robert e. jones and a. marshall for technical assistance with empa and tem measurements and analysis .
this work is supported by the doe , office of basic energy sciences , under contract no .
de - ac02 - 76sf00515 .
efforts at the ames laboratory were supported by the doe under contract no .
de - ac02 - 07ch11358 .
irf is also supported by the terman foundation .
portions of this research were carried out at the stanford synchrotron radiation laboratory(ssrl ) , a national user facility operated by stanford university on behalf of the us department of energy , office of basic energy sciences . | the rare earth ( @xmath0 ) tellurides @xmath1te@xmath2 have a crystal structure intermediate between that of @xmath0te@xmath3 and @xmath0te@xmath4 , consisting of alternating single and double te planes sandwiched between @xmath0te block layers .
we have successfully grown single crystals of nd@xmath3te@xmath2 , sm@xmath3te@xmath2 and gd@xmath3te@xmath2 from a self flux , and describe here the first evidence for charge density wave formation in these materials .
the superlattice patterns for all three compounds are relatively complex , consisting at room temperature of at least two independent wavevectors .
consideration of the electronic structure indicates that to a large extent these wave vectors are separately associated with sheets of the fermi surface which are principally derived from the single and double te layers . |
heavy quark production in deep inelastic electron - proton scattering proceeds via the following reaction ( see fig . [ fig:1 ] ) @xmath12 where @xmath13 denotes any inclusive hadronic final state and @xmath14 stands for the neutral intermediate vector bosons given by @xmath15 . in this paper
we treat the case that @xmath16 so that the process in fig .
[ fig:1 ] is dominated by the one photon exchange mechanism only .
if we also integrate over the momentum @xmath17 of the heavy ( anti ) quark @xmath2 the unpolarised cross section is given by @xmath18\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath19 denotes the centre of mass energy of the electron - proton system and the heavy quark component of the spin averaged structure functions are given by @xmath20 ( @xmath21 ) . in the case the proton is polarised parallel ( @xmath22 ) or anti - parallel ( @xmath23 ) with respect to the spin of the incoming electron we obtain the cross section @xmath24\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath1 denotes the heavy quark component of the longitudinal spin structure function .
further we have defined the scaling variables @xmath25 ( 170,130)(0,0 ) ( 0,20)(80,30 ) ( 80,40)(160,80 ) ( 80,30)(160,35)5 ( 80,25)(160,25)5 ( 80,20)(160,15)5 ( 80,30)200.3 ( 50,100)(80,40)37 ( 0,100)(50,100 ) ( 50,100)(100,120 ) ( 0,110)[t]@xmath26 ( 100,130)[t]@xmath26 ( 0,15)[t]@xmath27 ( 160,75)[t]@xmath28 ( 60,70)[t]@xmath14 ( 175,30)[t]@xmath13 ( 40,20)[t]@xmath29 ( 25,115)[t]@xmath30 ( 75,125)[t]@xmath31 ( 80,70)[t]@xmath32 ( 120,55)[t]@xmath17 in qcd the twist two contributions to the charm component of the structure functions defined above can be written as @xmath33 \nonumber\\ & & + e_q^2 \big [ f_q^{\rm s}(\frac{x}{z},\mu^2 ) \otimes h_{i , q}^{\rm ps}(z,\frac{q^2}{m^2},\frac{m^2}{\mu^2 } ) + f_g^{\rm s}(\frac{x}{z},\mu^2 ) \otimes h_{i , g}^{\rm s}(z,\frac{q^2}{m^2},\frac{m^2}{\mu^2 } ) \big ] \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath34 further @xmath35 denotes the number of light flavours and @xmath36 stands for the mass factorization scale which is put to be equal to the renormalization scale .
the charges of the light quark @xmath37 and the heavy quark @xmath2 are given by @xmath38 and @xmath39 respectively .
notice that @xmath35 is determined by all quarks which are lighter than the heavy quark @xmath2 and eq .
( [ eqn:5 ] ) has to be understood in the fixed flavour number scheme . in eq .
( [ eqn:5 ] ) the gluon density is denoted by @xmath40 and the singlet ( @xmath41 ) and non singlet ( @xmath42 ) combination of quark densities are defined by @xmath43 \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath44 the heavy quark coefficient functions @xmath45 and @xmath46 ( @xmath47 ) are distinguished according to the production mechanisms from which they originate .
the quantity @xmath45 is given by the processes where the virtual photon couples to the light quark whereas @xmath46 originates from the reactions where the virtual photon is attached to the heavy quark .
hence these coefficient functions in eq .
( [ eqn:5 ] ) are multiplied by @xmath48 and @xmath49 respectively . .
[ fig:2 ] up to order @xmath0 the heavy quark coefficient functions are given by the following parton subprocesses . in order @xmath50 we have the virtual photon gluon fusion mechanism given by @xmath51 from which one obtains the heavy quark coefficient function @xmath52 . here
the superscript denotes the order in the perturbation series . in next - to- leading order ( nlo )
one has the following processes .
first one has to include the virtual gluon corrections to reaction ( [ eqn:9 ] ) which have to be added to the gluon bremsstrahlung process @xmath53 this leads to the coefficient function @xmath54 .
finally we also have the subprocess @xmath55 the above reaction has two different production mechanisms .
the first one is the bethe - heitler process where the virtual photon is coupled to the heavy quark which leads to the coefficient function @xmath56 . here
ps means purely singlet since this function originates from the partonic process where a gluon ( flavour singlet ) is exchanged in the @xmath57-channel between the light quark @xmath58 and the heavy quark @xmath2 .
the second one is the compton process where the virtual photon is coupled to the light quark from which one obtains @xmath59 .
the expressions for the order @xmath50 contribution @xmath52 can be found in @xcite ( @xmath60 ; unpolarised ) and @xcite ( @xmath61 ; polarised ) .
the exact analytic expressions for @xmath62 are calculated in @xcite ( @xmath60 ; unpolarised ) and @xcite ( @xmath61 ; polarised ) .
the exact heavy quark coefficient functions @xmath56 and @xmath54 have been only calculated in the unpolarised case ( @xmath60 ) ( see @xcite ) but the exact expressions in polarised scattering ( @xmath61 ) are not known yet .
however in @xcite and @xcite we could derive analytic formulae for the asymptotic heavy quark coefficient functions up to order @xmath0 for unpolarised and polarised electroproduction respectively .
the asymptotic heavy quark coefficient functions are defined by @xmath63 \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these asymptotic expressions are very useful because * they provide us with a check on the exact calculation . *
the exact calculation of @xmath56 and @xmath54 ( @xmath21 ) is semi - analytic and they are only available in the form of long computer programs ( see @xcite ) .
the latter show numerical instabilties at @xmath4 which are remedied by using in this region @xmath64 . * further if these asymptotic heavy quark coefficient functions are substituted in eq .
( [ eqn:5 ] ) it turns out that ( see @xcite , @xcite ) @xmath65 tends to unity as @xmath66 and @xmath67 . in the case of charm production ( @xmath68 and @xmath69
this happens for @xmath70 .
this implies that above a rather low value of @xmath7 it does not make any difference whether we use the asymptotic or the exact expressions for @xmath46 .
* the asymptotic forms of the heavy quark coefficient functions also play a major role in the derivation of the variable number flavour scheme ( vfns ) from the fixed flavour number sheme ( ffns ) ( see @xcite , @xcite ) the asymptotic heavy quark coefficient functions get the typical form @xmath71 with an analogous expression for @xmath72 .
there are two ways to determine eq .
( [ eqn:14 ] ) . *
evaluate the phase space integrals and the feynman integrals in the usual way for @xmath4 .
* use operator product expansion techniques and the theorem of mass factorization .
the last method was applied in @xcite and @xcite to compute the asymptotic forms of the heavy quark coefficient functions for unpolarised and polarised scattering respectively .
in this section we will analyse the charm component of the longitudinal spin structure function @xmath73 . to compute the latter in nlo the following coefficient functions are available : @xmath74 ( born ) , @xmath75 ( compton process ) , @xmath76 ( gluon bremsstrahlung ) , @xmath77 ( bethe - heitler ) .
like in unpolarised scattering the gluonic coefficient functions indicated by @xmath78 are the most important ones .
therefore deep inelastic electroproduction of charm quarks provide us with an excellent way to determine the gluon density in polarised scattering ( see eq .
( [ eqn:5 ] ) ) .
however as we will show below the charm component in the spin case is much smaller with respect to the light parton contribution to the structure function as observed for @xmath79 in unpolarised scattering .
this is revealed by @xmath76 in fig .
[ fig:2 ] where we observe a strongly oscillatory behaviour which is in contrast to its unpolarised analogue shown in fig . 8 of @xcite .
further it satisfies the sum rule @xmath80 which holds in any scheme .
notice that the born contribution @xmath81 also satisfies the above relation and we may safely assume that eq .
( [ eqn:15 ] ) holds in all orders for general @xmath7 and @xmath82 .
further it turns out that the coefficient functions @xmath83 ( @xmath84 ) are much smaller than their unpolarised analogues .
in particular the large logarithmic terms of the type @xmath85 which are characteristic of the latter do not show up in the spin case .
the absence of these corrections and the oscillatory behaviour leads to much smaller charm quark contributions to @xmath73 than observed for @xmath79 or @xmath86 . to give a better estimate of the order @xmath0 corrections we have to improve the asymptotic form of the coefficient functions @xmath76 and @xmath77 a little bit . in @xcite
we multiplied them by @xmath87 and added to @xmath76 the soft gluon bremsstrahlung term which is universal ( see eqs .
( 5.1)-(5.3 ) in @xcite ) .
these approximations were tested for @xmath88 and @xmath89 and we found a fairly good agreement with the exact results as long as @xmath90 and @xmath91 . .
[ fig:3 ] choosing the parton density set in @xcite ( standard scenario ) with @xmath92 and @xmath93 we have plotted the charm component of @xmath94 and @xmath95 at @xmath96 in fig .
3 . from this figure
we infer that the charm component becomes maximal in the region @xmath97 .
further we observe that in nlo the result becomes twice as large than in lo .
we also made a comparison in fig .
4 with the quantity @xmath98 which is due to light partons ( @xmath99 and @xmath100 ) only . here
we see that the charm component amounts to about @xmath101 of @xmath98 .
this is in contrast to the observation made for the structure function @xmath79 in unpolarised scattering ( see @xcite , @xcite ) . in the latter case
the charm component becomes large at very small @xmath11 ( i.e. @xmath102 ) and it amounts to about @xmath103 with respect to the total structure function . in @xcite
we also studied the spin structure functions plotted at @xmath104 and @xmath105 .
these plots show the same features as the ones made for @xmath96 so that our conclusions are unaltered . .
since we know the exact result for @xmath106 @xcite we can compute the order @xmath0 correction to the bjrken sum rule due to heavy flavour contributions .
the latter is given by @xmath107= \frac{1}{6 } \mid \frac{g_a}{g_v } \mid \big ( l_{1,q}^{\rm ns } \big ) ^{(1)}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the superscript @xmath108 denotes the first moment ( mellin transform ) . in order
@xmath0 we have the following properties @xmath109 which shows the decoupling of the heavy quark when @xmath110 . @xmath111\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the light parton contribution to the bjrken sum rule is given by @xmath112= \frac{1}{6 } \mid \frac{g_a}{g_v } \mid \big ( { \cal c}_{1,q}^{\rm ns } \big ) ^{(1)}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath113 denotes the massless quark coefficient function .
the first moment of the latter quantity has been calculated up to order @xmath114 in @xcite and the order @xmath115 term has been estimated too ( see e.g. @xcite .
it turns out that the charm contribution to the bjrken sum rule is even smaller than the the estimated order @xmath115 correction ( see @xcite ) .
the contributions coming from the bottom and top quark are even smaller which can be attributed to the decoupling of heavy quarks shown in eq .
[ eqn:17 ] .
finally we have the relation @xmath116 so that for @xmath4 the large logarithm @xmath117 in the heavy quark coefficient function @xmath118 ( eq . ( [ eqn:19 ] ) ) can be absorbed in the light quark coefficient function @xmath113 .
hence the number of light flavours in the running coupling constant and in @xmath113 on the righthand side of eq .
( [ eqn:20 ] ) will be enhanced by one unit .
99 e. witten , nucl . phys . *
b104 * ( 1976 ) 445 ; + j. babcock and d. sivers , phys . rev .
* d18 * ( 1978 ) 2301 ; + m.a .
shifman , a.i .
vainstein and v.j .
zakharov , nucl .
b136 * ( 1978 ) 157 ; + m. glck and e. reya , phys . lett . *
b83 * ( 1979 ) 98 ; + j.v .
leveille and t. weiler , nucl .
b147 * ( 1979 ) 147 .
watson , z. phys .
* c12 * ( 1982 ) 123 .
m. buza , y. matiounine , j. smith , r. migneron and w.l .
van neerven , nucl . phys .
* b472 * ( 1996 ) 611 .
m. buza , y. matiounine , j. smith , and w.l .
van neerven , nucl . phys .
* b485 * ( 1996 ) 420 .
e. laenen , s. riemersma , j. smith and w.l .
van neerven , nucl . phys .
* b392 * ( 1993 ) 162 , 229 , + s. riemersma , j. smith and w.l .
van neerven , phys . lett .
* b347 * ( 1995 ) 143 , + b.w .
harris and j. smith , nucl . phys . * b452 * ( 1995 ) 109 .
m. buza , y. matiounine , j. smith , and w.l .
van neerven , desy 96 - 278 , hep - ph/9612398 , to be published in z. phys .
* c * ( 1997 ) .
m. buza et al . , `` deep inelastic production of heavy quarks '' , proceedings of the workshop `` future physics at hera '' , desy , hamburg , 25 - 26 september 1995 , p. 393 - 401 .
aivazis , j.c .
collins , f.i .
olness and w.k .
tung , phys .
* d50 * ( 1994 ) 3102 .
van neerven , `` charm production in deep inelastic lepton - hadron scattering '' , lectures presented at the xxxviith cracow school of theoretical physics , 30th may- 10th june , zakopane , poland . to be pub . in acta phys .
b. m. glck , e. reya , m. stratmann and w. vogelsang , phys . rev .
* d53 * ( 1996 ) 4775 .
c. adloff et al .
( h1 collaboration ) , z. phys . * c72 * ( 1996 ) 593 .
m. derrick et al .
( zeus collaboration ) , phys .
* b349 * ( 1995 ) 225 ; + m. derrick et al .
( zeus collaboration ) , xxvii int .
on hep 96 , warsaw ( 1996 ) ; + j. breitweg et al .
( zeus collaboration ) , desy-97 - 089 .
larin and j.a.m .
vermaseren , phys . lett . * b259 * ( 1991 ) 345 . m.a .
samuel , j. ellis , m. karliner , phys .
74 ( 1995 ) 4380 .
j. blmlein and w.l .
van neerven , to appear . | we discuss the order @xmath0 corrections to the longitudinal spin structure function @xmath1 which are due to heavy flavour contributions . here
@xmath2 denotes the virtuality of the photon and @xmath3 stands for the heavy flavour mass .
since the exact heavy quark coefficient functions are not known yet we have used the asymptotic forms which are strictly speaking only valid in the region @xmath4 .
however an analysis of the exact and asymptotic expressions for @xmath5 and @xmath6 reveals that the asymptotic forms can be also used at smaller @xmath7 .
it appears that for the region @xmath8 the nlo charm quark component can become twice as large as in lo .
however it is still much smaller than @xmath9 due to light parton contributions .
this is in contrast to the observations made for @xmath10 at small @xmath11 .
also the charm quark contribution to the bjrken sum rule turns out to be very small .
epsfig.sty * heavy flavour contributions to the spin structure function @xmath9 and the bjrken sum rule * + |
the reliable transport of quantum information will enable operations between any arbitrarily selected qubits in a quantum processor and is essential to realize efficient , large - scale quantum information processing ( qip ) .
trapped ions are a promising system in which to study qip @xcite , and several approaches to achieving reliable information transport have been proposed @xcite . in
most demonstrated entangling gate operations that use ions , qubits stored in the internal atomic states of ions are entangled by coupling the internal states with a single shared motional mode through a laser - induced interaction @xcite . however , as the number of ions grows large ( @xmath2 ) , it becomes difficult to isolate a single mode during gate operations @xcite .
one way around this issue is to distribute the ions over an array of harmonic potentials , where the number of ions in each trapping potential can remain small .
the potentials can be adjusted temporally to transport the ions throughout the array and combine selected ions into a particular harmonic potential .
once combined , gate operations can be performed on the selected ions by use of a local shared mode of motion @xcite .
initial demonstrations of such distributed architectures have incorporated simple linear arrays @xcite , where all ions are confined in potential minima on a line along an axis of the trap .
the order of ions within the linear array can even be changed @xcite . however , multidimensional arrays @xcite provide the greatest flexibility in ion - trap processor architectures , and permit more efficient reordering of ion strings for deterministic gate operations .
the key technical element that must be realized towards this end is the two - dimensional junction , which consists of multiple intersecting linear arrays .
the potentials in a junction are more complicated than those in a linear array , making transport through a junction challenging .
since the fidelity of the gates is highest if the ions are near their motional ground state , it is important that transport through such arrays be performed reliably and with minimal excitation of the ion s motion in its local trapping potential .
if multiple transports are needed , each transport should contribute well under a single quantum of motional excitation , though sympathetic cooling can be used to remove excess motional energy , at the cost of increased experiment duration ( and accompanying decoherence ) @xcite .
for simple linear arrays , reliable transport with little motional excitation has been demonstrated @xcite . to date , transport through a t - junction @xcite ,
an x - junction @xcite and surface - electrode y - junctions @xcite have been demonstrated .
however , such transport has not yet been demonstrated with sufficiently - low motional excitation ( at or below a single quantum ) . using the apparatus in ref .
@xcite , we have now realized highly reliable transport through an x - junction with excitation of less than one quantum of motion per transport , a decrease of approximately 50 compared to the results in ref .
@xcite . this has allowed us to observe a process where energy can be exchanged between motional modes in certain situations , and demonstrates motional control over the ions at the single - quantum level .
the paper is organized as follows : we begin in sec .
[ sec : trap ] with a description of the x - junction trap array used for transport .
section [ sec : waveforms ] lays out the procedure for calculating the time - dependent trapping potentials that transport the ion .
a description of the basic transport experiment is given in sec .
[ sec : experiment ] .
section [ sec : heatingsources ] covers the various mechanisms that excite the ion s motion during transport , as well as the filtering techniques used to mitigate those excitations .
this understanding of the noise sources , and the subsequent improved filtering techniques , allowed the reduction in motional excitation relative to ref .
@xcite . to mitigate the effects of magnetic field fluctuations on qubit decoherence ,
a mu - metal shield and field - coil current stabilization were used , which is explained in sec .
[ sec : shield ] . finally , in sec .
[ sec : exchange ] , we discuss a procedure for swapping motional energy between motional modes at the center of the junction array .
this swapping process can potentially be used to laser - cool multiple modes of motion without the need for a direct interaction between the cooling laser and every motional mode .
the x - junction array was based on the design of previous two - layer linear rf paul traps @xcite .
the current trap consisted of a stack of five high - purity alumina ( @xmath3 al@xmath4o@xmath5 ) wafers clamped together ( fig .
[ fig : trapwafers ] ) with screws ( visible in fig .
[ fig : actual_trap ] ) .
the trap electrodes resided in the ` top ' and ` bottom ' wafers .
these wafers ( @xmath6 m thick ) were laser machined to cut out ` main channels ' through the wafers , with opposite sides of the channel forming rf and control electrodes .
slits , nominally perpendicular to the main channel axes , separated the control electrode side of the channel into a series of cantilevered structures to produce separate control electrodes .
electrodes were formed onto the al@xmath4o@xmath5 by evaporating through a shadow - mask a @xmath7 nm titanium adhesion layer followed by @xmath8 m of gold , then overcoating with @xmath9 m of electroplated gold .
care was taken to coat all sides of each cantilevered structure to minimize exposed dielectric that could otherwise charge and shift the potential minima in an uncontrolled way .
plane at the experiment zone ( @xmath10 ) .
each wafer had a channel cut through it to define the electrode structure and to provide a path for laser beams to pass through the wafer stack .
the top and bottom wafers provided the confining potential ; the ions were trapped between these electrodes as indicated .
the rc low - pass filters were surface - mounted to the filter board with gold ribbon attached by use of resistive welds .
the bias wafer was a single electrode used to null stray electric fields along @xmath11 .
gold ( represented in yellow ) was coated on the top side of the trap wafers and wrapped around to the bottom side , and vice - versa for the bias wafer .
gold wire bonds connected traces on the trap wafers to traces on the filter board . ] a spacer wafer provided a separation of @xmath12 m between the two trap electrode layers .
these three wafers sat atop a @xmath13 m thick ` filter board ' , upon which in - vacuum rc filtering components were mounted .
the ` bias wafer ' resembled the ` top ' and ` bottom ' wafers but with a single continuous control electrode extending along all sides of the main channels .
the bias wafer sat below the filter board and was used to compensate stray electric fields along @xmath11 . )
.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] gauge pins were used to help align the wafers during assembly .
a misalignment error of approximately @xmath14 was measured between the @xmath15 axes of the two electrode wafers , and this error was included in the computer model of the trap used to determine the appropriate transport potentials . ) , the main experiment zone ( @xmath10 ) , the vertical zone ( @xmath16 ) , the horizontal zone ( @xmath17 ) and the center of the junction ( @xmath18 ) are labeled .
( c ) schematic of the rf bridges from an oblique angle ( not to scale).,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the electrode layout of the array is depicted in fig .
[ fig : xtrap ] and consisted of 46 control electrodes that produced 18 possible trapping zones .
the experiment zone , @xmath10 , was chosen as the zone where the ions interacted with lasers for cooling and qubit operations .
in addition to @xmath10 , zones @xmath17 , @xmath16 , and @xmath18 ( at the center of the junction ) composed the four destinations of the transport protocols .
the final zone of interest was the load zone , @xmath19 , where the ions were initially trapped .
the trap dimensions were similar to those in refs .
the width of the channel between the rf and control electrodes was @xmath20 m , except near @xmath19 , where it increased to @xmath21 m to increase the volume of the loading zone and , with it , the loading probability .
most control electrodes extended @xmath20 m along the trap axis , but those nearest to the junction were @xmath22 m wide to ensure sufficient control when ions were transported in this region . at @xmath18 , two main channels crossed to form an x - junction , and two rf bridges connected the rf electrodes on opposite sides of that junction ( one on the top trap wafer and one on the bottom ) . without such bridges , the array would not have provided harmonic three - dimensional confinement at the center of the junction @xcite .
the widths of the bridges were @xmath23 m , though the trapping potential was not strongly dependent on this dimension .
these bridges introduced four axial pseudopotential barriers , one in each of the entrances to the junction ( along @xmath24 and @xmath25 ) .
figure [ fig : pseudopotx ] shows the two simulated pseudopotential barriers along the @xmath15 legs in the x - junction array going toward @xmath10 and @xmath17 ( the asymmetry was due to the trap misalignment mentioned above ) .
the height of these barriers was a significant fraction of the transverse pseudopotential trapping depth and was approximately 0.3 ev for @xmath0be@xmath1 , with rf potential of @xmath26 v ( peak amplitude ) and frequency @xmath27 mhz . at
the apex of the barriers , just outside the center of the junction , the pseudopotential was anti - confining in the axial direction but still harmonically confining in the two radial directions .
it was possible to use the control electrodes to overwhelm this anti - confinement and produce a 3d harmonic confining potential at all points along the axis of the array .
axis produced by the rf bridges in the x - junction , with 0 being the junction s center . here
, we assumed @xmath28 v and @xmath27 mhz .
the asymmetry between the two barriers was due to a slight misalignment of the trap wafers.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] zone @xmath10 was positioned far
( @xmath29 m ) from the junction to reduce the residual slope of the pseudopotential barrier in this zone .
the amplitude of the axial pseudopotential at @xmath10 was estimated , by use of computer models , to be @xmath30 ev with a @xmath31 ev@xmath32 m axial gradient , which would give rise to an axial micromotion amplitude of 47 nm at the drive amplitude specified above .
direction ( above the trap ) and could be heated to produce a flux of neutral be .
this be would then travel down onto the trap , with a portion of the flux passing into trap s main channel at the load zone .
copropagating photoionization and doppler - cooling laser beams intersected the be in the load zone at 45@xmath33 to the @xmath34 plane of the page and parallel to @xmath35 .
an ` l'-shaped oven barrier obscured the line - of - sight between the oven flux and the zones used during the transport experiments to prevent neutral be from accumulating on the surfaces of the electrodes near the junction .
this barrier was positioned just above the trap electrodes , extending 1.6 cm along @xmath11 out of the plane of the page .
additional laser access was available for beams passing through @xmath10 ( at 45@xmath33 to the @xmath34 plane ) allowing for cooling , detection , and gate operations at @xmath10 . ]
ions were loaded into the array from a flux of neutral be that passed through @xmath19 and was photoionized with a mode - locked laser that after two stages of doubling produced 235 nm resonant with the s - to - p transition of neutral be . to help prevent buildup of neutral
be from the beam in other regions of the array , @xmath19 was located sufficiently far from @xmath10 .
in addition @xmath19 was displaced along @xmath36 from @xmath10 , by use of two @xmath37 bends in the main channel , to allow an ` l'-shaped stainless - steel shield to be placed 0.5 mm above the trap wafers , preventing neutral be from striking the experiment zone while allowing laser access , as shown in fig .
[ fig : gooseneck ] .
transporting ions through such @xmath37 bends is relatively straightforward , and we were able to easily transport ions between @xmath19 and @xmath10 . whenever an ion was lost , a new ion was loaded into @xmath19 and immediately transferred to @xmath10 .
it was also possible to use zone @xmath19 as a reservoir zone , where extra ions were loaded and held in reserve until needed to replace ions lost in the experiment region .
this allowed the loading process to be performed less often , which avoided heating the neutral be oven and the concomitant degradation of the vacuum .
potentially many ions could be simultaneously stored in such a zone , though we only stored a small number and did not regularly make use of this feature of the trap . by enabling a better vacuum ,
a reservoir can significantly increase ion lifetime . in this scenario , it is desirable to maintain doppler cooling in @xmath19 to extend the ion lifetime .
the first demonstrations of ion transport in a multi - zone trap involved moving an ion along a linear array @xcite . a protocol where two ions were placed in a single trapping well and separated into two wells or combined from two wells into a single well
was also demonstrated @xcite . since then
, transport through linear arrays has been extended to other contexts @xcite , including transport through a junctions @xcite and switching of ion order @xcite . here
we outline the process used to calculate the time - series of control potentials , or ` waveforms ' , used to transport ions through the x - junction .
this same basic procedure would be generally applicable to many ion - transport situations .
the goal was to move ions quickly , over long distances , while maintaining low excitation of the ion s secular motion in its local potential , and traversing non - trivial potential landscapes such as those near junctions .
ideally , the ion should move along the axial direction of the array while remaining at the transverse pseudopotential minimum .
the control electrodes were used to create an overall harmonic trapping well whose minimum moved along this desired trajectory . the procedure for determining waveforms
can be broken down into four steps : modeling the trap , determining the constraints , solving for the appropriate potentials , and assigning the time dependence of potentials .
an electrostatic model of the trap was constructed by use of boundary element method ( bem ) software @xcite . for each of @xmath38 electrodes ,
the model was run once , applying 1 v to the @xmath39 given electrode while grounding all other electrodes .
the potential resulting from each of these voltage configurations , @xmath40 , was extracted ( in the form of a @xmath41 m grid ) in the region through which the ion would pass .
these individual electrode potentials could then be weighted by the actual voltage applied to the electrode , @xmath42 , and summed to find the total potential : @xmath43 here we have included the contribution of the rf pseudopotential @xmath44 .
the pseudopotential was found by first modeling the rf potential @xmath45 as if it were a _
static _ potential at 1 v. then an additional step was used to convert the rf potential into a time - independent pseudopotential by use of @xmath46 where @xmath47 was the peak voltage applied to the rf electrode , and @xmath48 and @xmath49 are the charge and mass of @xmath0be@xmath1 , respectively .
( throughout this section , all @xmath50 potentials ( including @xmath44 ) are reported as electric potentials ( in units of v ) and not energy potentials ( units of ev ) ; these are related by a factor of @xmath48 . )
the waveform was built up from a string of individual solutions , where each solution satisfied a set of constraints on the trapping potential centered at a certain position .
these constraints are defined below , but relate to defining the secular frequencies and orientation of the principle axes of the potential . by advancing that position by @xmath41 m along the intended ion trajectory for each subsequent solution
, the series of potential steps was created that moved the potential well along the sequence of positions . in theory , the constraints can be set to completely define a harmonic potential localized at the desired position , while also constraining the three secular frequencies and the orientation of the principal axes .
this would imply nine constraints , which we assume for now , though below we will relax some of these constraints when solving for the experiment waveforms . to produce a trapping potential , @xmath51 , with a minimum at @xmath52
, we enforce @xmath53 where @xmath54 is used to mean ` constrained to be true ' . the hessian matrix , @xmath55 \phi(\mathbf{r}_0),\ ] ]
can be used to extract the remaining six parameters of the harmonic potential : the eigenvalues @xmath56 of @xmath57 are related to the secular frequencies , @xmath58 and the eigenvectors point along the principal axes . by completely constraining the hessian ,
we constrain these quantities . note that the hessian is symmetric ( @xmath59 ) , and has only six independent entries .
it is most convenient to evaluate the hessian in the frame of the desired principal axes , @xmath60 , in which case the hessian constraint equation simplifies to @xmath61 , \ ] ] where diagonal entries constrain the desired secular frequencies @xmath62 , and the off - diagonal entries constrain the principal axes to point along @xmath60 . if the hessian is evaluated in a different basis , the right - hand side of eq .
( [ hessianconst ] ) will not be diagonal , and the frequency and axis constraints are mixed .
nonetheless , an appropriate choice for the right - hand side can still be made in that case @xcite . from here on , we assume @xmath63 . in the interest of compact nomenclature ,
it is convenient to define several column vectors : @xmath64^{\mathrm{t}}\ ] ] and @xmath65^{\mathrm{t}},\ ] ] where @xmath66 denotes the transpose of @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
finally , we define the 12-component operator @xmath69^{\mathrm{t } } , \end{split}\]]where the first three components are the gradient and the next nine components are the hessian operator .
the nine position , frequency , and axis constraints defined by eqs . [ positionconstr ] and [ hessianconst ] can be assembled into one equation : @xmath70 where @xmath71 is a @xmath72 matrix and @xmath73 is a @xmath74 column vector , where @xmath75 for this example .
the position constraints in eq .
[ positionconstr ] can be reconstructed by using @xmath71 to pick out the three gradient components of @xmath76 and @xmath73 to set them to zero .
the constraints in eq .
[ hessianconst ] can be treated in a similar manner .
thus , to encode the nine desired constraints , we use @xmath77 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1\\ [ 6pt ] 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 \end{array } } \right]\ ] ] and @xmath78 ( m / q ) \omega_x^2 \\ ( m / q ) \omega_y^2 \\ ( m / q ) \omega_z^2 \\ [ 6pt ] 0 \\ 0 \\ 0 \end{array } } \right].\ ] ] additional white space has been inserted in both equations to aid the reader by separating the position , frequency , and principal axis constraints into groups in the vertical direction , as well as separating the gradient and hessian components of eq .
[ positionconstr2a ] in the horizontal direction . once @xmath71 and @xmath73 are determined , eq .
( [ matrixconst ] ) can be solved for @xmath79 by inverting @xmath80 , thus determining the control voltages that create the desired trapping potential .
this inversion may not be strictly possible , as is the case when the number of constraints does not equal the number of control potentials , leading to an over- or under - determined problem .
also , we are interested only in solutions where the magnitudes of all control voltages are smaller than a maximal voltage @xmath81 ( for our apparatus , @xmath82 v ) .
to achieve this , we use a constrained least - squares optimization algorithm , as described in ref .
@xcite , to calculate @xmath83 in cases where eq .
( [ matrixconst ] ) is over - constrained , this method yields a `` best - fit '' @xmath79 . when eq .
( [ matrixconst ] ) is under - constrained , as is usually the case for large trap arrays with many electrodes , it returns a null space in addition to @xmath79 , which can be added to @xmath79 to find multiple independent solutions .
nine constraints were used above , but many are unnecessary . for qip in a linear trap array , constraining the axial mode frequency and orientation is often sufficient .
parameters for the other two modes are less important and often achieve reasonable values without being constrained , in which case they can be omitted from the constraint matrices .
in addition to explicitly defined user constraints , there are implicit physical and geometric constraints that must be considered . as an example , take the three secular frequencies of the ion , @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 .
these frequencies result from a hybrid potential that includes both pseudopotential and control potentials .
the contributions from both potentials can be separated mathematically into components , @xmath87 and @xmath88 respectively , which add in quadrature to give the overall frequency : @xmath89 .
( an imaginary frequency component would imply antitrapping , while a real component yields trapping . )
the control electrodes produce a quasi - static electric field , which laplace s equation requires to be divergenceless .
this places a physical constraint on the frequencies components due to the control potential , namely @xmath90 .
thus , laplace s equation permits only certain combinations of the secular frequencies . for a _ linear _ paul trap , where @xmath91 , the secular frequencies must obey @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the pseudopotential radial trapping frequency .
the trap geometry can place constraints on the trapping potentials , as well .
for example , in traps where the geometry contains some symmetry , the potentials must preserve that symmetry .
care must be exercised to ensure that user - defined constraints do not contradict physical or geometry constraints , as this will invalidate the solution . though we invoke only position , frequency , and orientation constraints here , other varieties of user - defined constraints can be easily included with this framework , and a more complete discussion of these constraints is presented in @xcite .
the constraints used to construct the waveforms in the x - junction array were as follows : 1 .
the position of the potential minimum was constrained in three directions to be at @xmath94 .
one of the principal axes was constrained to lie along the trap axis ( which involves two constraints on axes orientation ) .
the ion axial frequency was constrained ( usually to 3.6 mhz ) .
4 . the voltages were constrained to be between @xmath95v ( to conform to the limits of the voltage supplies used in the experiment ) .
this relatively sparse set of constraints tended to give good solutions at most locations considered .
item 4 is an inequality constraint that is easily implemented by use of the constrained least - squares method .
when solving waveforms that transport across multiple zones , @xmath79 can become discontinuous from step to step , especially when transitioning between sets of control electrodes .
these jumps occur when an under - constrained problem ( with null space rank @xmath96 ) has multiple linearly - independent solutions and the algorithm returns a different solution from one step to the next : during transport there will be some position at which it is suddenly easier to produce the desired potential using a new combination of electrodes . in principle
, such jumps should not have adverse effects on the potential at the ion , as the potentials on both side of the jump fulfill the same constraints and should transition smoothly .
however , since the potentials on the electrodes are filtered , we would expect the potential at the ion to experience a transitory jump during the transition .
these solution jumps can be handled by various means .
we used the constrained least - squares method to seed each new solution with the solution of the previous step while introducing a cost for deviating from the previous solution by replacing eq .
[ llseqn ] with @xmath97 for a positive constant @xmath98 .
this removes the need for iteratively choosing weights to keep the voltages within bounds , as suggested in ref .
this forced the jump transition to be extended over multiple steps , rather than allowing a discontinuous jump .
another approach is to average the two @xmath79 s on each side of the discontinuity , taking advantage of the linearity of the equations , to produce an intermediate solution that still satisfies the constraints @xcite .
performing several steps of such averaging will smooth the jump .
alternately , trial and error can often be used to determine a set of constraints that does not produce a jump , but this can require significant effort .
if the spatial interval between steps in the waveform is small enough , the potential , once applied to the electrodes , will move smoothly from step to step @xcite .
the velocity of the potential well ( and , thus , the ion ) is controlled by the rate at which the waveform steps are updated on the electrodes . in our case ,
the control potentials were supplied by digital - to - analog converters ( dacs ) that had a constant update rate @xmath99 khz and the number of update steps was adjusted to change the velocity .
different velocity profiles have been considered for minimizing excitation while transporting @xcite . in this report , the ions were usually transported by use of a constant velocity with equally spaced waveform steps .
this could potentially lead to the ion being ` kicked ' as the velocity jumps at the beginning and end of the transport , resulting in motional excitation .
however , these velocity jumps were smoothed by low - pass filters placed on the control potentials ( see sec .
[ subsec : dacnoise ] ) .
a smoother ` sinusoidal ' velocity profile was also tested but was abandoned after observing no discernible difference in the amount of motional excitation by use of the different profiles .
this suggests that both transport protocols were well within the adiabatic regime at the speeds used .
low - pass filtering ( 160 khz corner in our case ) can also potentially distort the waveforms when transporting quickly , placing an upper limit on the ion speed .
however , the practical speed limit was set by the combination of the maximum update rate of the digital - to - analog converters and the number of update points required to accurately produce a continuous harmonic potential in the region of the pseudopotential barrier .
this limit was experimentally determined for each waveform by adjusting the number of update points until minimum motional excitation was achieved .
if faster dacs are available and distortion of the waveforms due to low - pass filtering is of concern , the waveform can be pre - compensated to account for these distortions and produce the desired waveform at the ion .
m , to the center of the junction at @xmath100 m . we plot voltage versus the @xmath101 position of the minimum of the trapping potential during the transport .
the locations of the electrodes near the junction are depicted , along with their electrode number , by the rectangles in the bottom of the figure .
the region from @xmath102 to @xmath103 m is inside of the junction .
the voltage traces are numbered to show which electrode they correspond to .
electrodes 8 and 9 remain near 0 v and are omitted for clarity .
in addition , the potentials applied to the control electrodes on the bottom wafer are not displayed , as they are nearly identical to those applied on the top wafer .
( b ) a schematic of the trap , showing the range over which this waveform transported.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the waveforms used to transport from @xmath10 to @xmath18 are displayed in fig .
[ fig : wvf ] as a function of the position of the minimum of the trapping potential ( the ion s location ) .
the potentials applied to the lower trap - wafer control electrodes ( on opposite sides of the main channel ) were nearly identical and are omitted for clarity .
these waveforms could be run left to right to transport an ion @xmath29 m from @xmath10 to @xmath18 , or they could be run in reverse . the waveforms that transported ions into the other two branches of the junction ( to @xmath17 and @xmath16 ) were similar to this waveform due to the approximate symmetry of the trap . in a typical transport , the potential minimum was moved at a constant velocity , and there was a direct linear relationship between the location of the minimum ( horizontal axis of fig .
[ fig : wvf](a ) ) and the time elapsed since the beginning of the transport .
the typical transport duration for the waveforms in fig .
[ fig : wvf](a ) was approximately 165 @xmath104s , with 50 @xmath104s to cross the pseudopotential barrier .
some control potentials reached the @xmath105 v limit placed by use of the constrained least - squares method while traversing the pseudopotential barrier near the junction .
other control potentials had sharp and abrupt changes , which resulted from the constraint in eq .
[ llseqn2 ] that prevented ` solution jumping ' by defining how much a given waveform step can deviate from the previous step . instead of jumping ,
the voltages ramped linearly over several steps .
although these individual potentials were not smooth in time , they were continuous , which was sufficient to ensure that the overall potential experienced by the ion evolved smoothly .
the axial frequency was chosen to be 3.6 mhz and was held constant during much of the transport starting at @xmath10 and moving toward @xmath18 ( fig .
[ fig : wvffreq ] ) .
the frequency was ( adiabatically ) linearly ramped to 4.2 mhz as the ion approached the apex of the pseudopotential barrier , making the ion less susceptible to rf - noise heating of the secular motion ( see sec .
[ subsec : rfnoise ] ) .
the value 4.2 mhz was the maximum axial frequency attainable at the apex due to the strong anti - confinement of the pseudopotential at that location and the @xmath105 v limit of the dacs providing the control potentials .
the axial frequency then continued to increase as the ion descended the barrier , reaching a final value of 5.7 mhz at @xmath18 . at this location ,
all control potentials were 0 v and the pseudopotential provided all the trapping , resulting in near - degenerate 5.7 mhz confinement along the @xmath106 and @xmath15 directions , while the @xmath11 secular frequency was 11.3 mhz . when transporting multiple ions in the same potential well , it would be preferable to break the frequency degeneracy at @xmath18 to ensure well - defined axes for the ions . in practice ,
the motional excitation rates when moving pairs of ions were still relatively low despite the near degeneracy at @xmath18 ( see table [ tab : heatingrates2ions ] ) . .
the axial frequency along @xmath15 was constrained to be 3.6 mhz during the majority of the transport , while the radial frequencies were unconstrained . as the ion ascended the pseudopotential barrier ,
the axial frequency linearly ramped up to 4.2 mhz . beyond the apex of the barrier , a second linear ramp was applied to bring the frequency up to 5.7 mhz .
as the ion approached the center of the junction , the @xmath36 and @xmath101 frequencies became nearly degenerate.,scaledwidth=45.0% ]
the transport experiments were performed with @xmath0be@xmath1 ions inside a vacuum system with a pressure of @xmath107 torr @xmath108 pa . a @xmath109 t magnetic field was applied to split the zeeman states , and the ions were optically pumped to the @xmath110 state ( henceforth @xmath111 ) .
manipulation of the @xmath0be@xmath1 ion motional and internal states used the techniques of refs .
two - photon stimulated - raman transitions enabled coherent transitions between the qubit states @xmath111 and @xmath112 at frequency @xmath113 ghz .
in addition , by tuning the difference frequency of the raman beams to @xmath114 , it was possible to drive a blue(red)-sideband transition : @xmath115 . here @xmath116 is a fock state of a selected motional mode .
ground - state cooling was performed by use of a series of red - sideband pulses , followed by repeated optical pumping to @xmath111 .
state detection was performed using state - dependent resonance fluorescence , where predominantly the @xmath111 state fluoresces .
each transport began by cooling an ion ( or ion pair ) in @xmath10 to the motional ground state .
the ion was then transported into or through the junction and returned to @xmath10 .
three transports patterns were used : @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath10 moved to @xmath18 and back , while @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath17-@xmath18-@xmath10 and @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath16-@xmath18-@xmath10 moved to @xmath17 and @xmath16 , respectively , before returning to @xmath10 .
the @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath10transport moved the ion @xmath117 mm , while @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath17-@xmath18-@xmath10 and @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath16-@xmath18-@xmath10 moved the ion @xmath118 mm and @xmath119 mm , respectively .
once the ion returned to @xmath10 , the motional excitation was determined by measuring the asymmetry in red- and blue - sideband raman transitions @xcite . to determine the single - ion transport success rate for @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath17-@xmath18-@xmath10 transports ,
two sets of 10,000 consecutive transport experiments were performed @xcite , but with the imaging system focused on @xmath10 in the first set and on @xmath17 in the second .
the first set verified that the ion successfully returned to @xmath10 every time .
the second set verified that the ion always reached @xmath17 at the intended time .
together , these sets of experiments imply the success rate for going to @xmath17 and returning to @xmath10 exceeded 0.9999 .
the procedure was repeated for @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath16-@xmath18-@xmath10 , with the same result .
the @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath10transport can not be verified in the same manner because the bridges obscure the ion at @xmath18 , but since the ion must transport through this location to reach @xmath17and @xmath16 , the reliability should be no worse .
ion lifetime , and thus transport success probability , was ultimately limited by ion loss resulting from background - gas collisions @xcite . with this in mind , the ion loss rate during transport was not larger than that for a stationary ion ( @xmath120hr ) . having observed millions of successive round trips for all three types of transport , combining all losses implies a transport success probability of greater than 0.999995 , not whether the ion successfully moved the ion through the junction . given the low rates of motional excitation , and the fact that we did verify that the ions move through the junction using 10,000 experiments
, it is reasonable to assume the ion did travel through the junction if the ion successfully returned to @xmath10 . ] .
since transport comprised a small fraction of the total experiment duration , many of these losses likely occurred when the ion was not being transported . in one instance , more than 1,500,000 consecutive @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath10transports were performed with a single ion .
loss rates for transported ion pairs were again comparable to stationary pairs ( @xmath121 per hour ) .
absolute pair loss rates were higher than those for single ions , presumably due to multi - ion effects @xcite .
excitation of the ion s motion during transport was attributed to two main mechanisms : one due to rf noise near @xmath122 and the other due to excitation from the digital - to - analog converters ( dacs ) .
consider a trapping rf electric field with an additional sideband term , @xmath123,\ ] ] where @xmath124 , and @xmath125 is at one of the two axial motional sidebands of the ion . in @xcite
, it was shown that the two terms will beat at @xmath86 to produce a force that can excite the ion s motion .
if the second term is not coherent , but instead is broad - spectrum noise , this will lead to excitation of the axial motion at a rate of @xmath126 ^ 2 \times \\ & \quad \left ( \frac{s_{v_{\textrm{n } } } ( { \omega_{\mathrm{rf}}}+ \omega_z ) } { v_{\mathrm{rf}}^2 } + \frac{s_{v_{\textrm{n } } } ( { \omega_{\mathrm{rf}}}- \omega_z)}{v_{\mathrm{rf}}^2 } \right ) , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath127 is the voltage - noise spectral density at either the upper or lower rf sideband , and @xmath47 is the amplitude of the trapping rf potential being applied to the rf electrodes .
@xmath128 is the axial rf electric field amplitude at the location of the ion .
this heating mechanism is proportional to the _ slope _ of the pseudopotential and is significant only in places with a large slope , such as the pseudopotential barriers near the junction ( but not in , for example , @xmath10 ) .
this heating mechanism was verified in ref .
@xcite by measuring the heating rate at various locations along the pseudopotential barrier between @xmath10 and @xmath18 , while spectrally - dense white noise ( centered on the lower sideband , @xmath129 ) was injected onto the trap rf drive .
figure [ fig : rfheating ] plots the ratio of measured heating rate to estimated injected @xmath130 and theoretical values of this ratio according to eq .
( [ n1heatingrate ] ) based on simulations of trap potentials , for the ion held at several positions between @xmath10 and @xmath18 . a plot with the theoretical values multiplied by a scaling factor ( @xmath131 )
is also included .
the deviation of the scaling factor from 1 is not unreasonable due to the difficulty of accurately measuring a variety of experimental parameters . to voltage noise spectral density @xmath132 for various locations along the trap axis (
@xmath18 is located at 0 @xmath104 m ) .
this figure is reproduced from ref .
the theoretical prediction used a pseudopotential modeled from electrode geometry and is shown both with and without a scaling parameter ( @xmath133 ) .
the simulated pseudopotential is overlaid in the background , in units of ev . since heating was gradient dependent ,
we saw very little heating at the peak of the pseudopotential barrier , even though this was the point of maximum ( axial ) rf electric field and therefore maximum axial rf micromotion .
nearly identical pseudopotential barriers were present on the other three legs of the junction . ]
the motional excitation for full junction transports to @xmath18 was observed to decrease as the ion speed was increased , which minimized the exposure to the rf noise while on a pseudopotential slope .
this continued up to a maximum speed limit , due to the slow dacs , above which the other excitation mechanism ( below ) began to dominate . at the optimum speed , the ion spent only approximately @xmath134s on each barrier ( above 10% of the barrier height ) . another approach to mitigate rf noise is to suppress the sideband noise with better filtering of the applied rf trapping potential . in ref .
@xcite , the large rf potential ( @xmath28 v@xmath135 at @xmath27 mhz ) was provided by a series of tank resonators , which suppressed noise at the motional sidebands ( @xmath136 mhz ) .
the primary resonator was a quarter - wave step - up resonator @xcite with a loaded @xmath137 and corresponding bandwidth ( fwhm ) of 2 mhz .
this resonator extended into the vacuum , with the trap attached to the voltage anti - node .
a second half - wave resonator with @xmath138 was attached , in series , to the input of the primary resonator , with a 3 db attenuator in between to decouple the two resonators .
the resonant frequencies of the two resonators were tuned to be equal .
this network resulted in an estimated ambient @xmath127 of -177 dbc at the ion . in the work reported here ,
the second resonator was replaced with a pair of half - wave tank resonating cavities .
this filter pair provided more than 38 db suppression at frequencies @xmath139 mhz ( when not coupled to the primary resonator ) , an additional suppression of approximately 10 db over the half - wave filter used in ref .
@xmath130 at the ion was not re - measured with this new filter pair , but observed reductions in excitation during transport were consistent with a 10 db drop in rf noise .
another primary source of motional excitation was attributed to the 16-bit , @xmath105 v dacs that supplied the waveform potentials to the electrodes .
the dac voltages were updated at a constant rate @xmath140 ( @xmath141 khz ) , resulting in fourier components that could excite the ion s motion if @xmath142 , for any integer @xmath143 .
this effect was observed by first preparing the ion in the motional ground state at @xmath10 and then transporting toward @xmath18 .
instead of proceeding all the way to @xmath18 , the transport was stopped ( at @xmath144 m ) before the axial frequency began to ramp up .
thus , the local potential - well frequency remained approximately constant at @xmath145 mhz . the ion was then returned to @xmath10 .
a red - sideband raman @xmath146-pulse for @xmath147 to @xmath148 excitation was applied to determine if the ion remained in the ground state @xcite .
if the ion was excited out of the ground state during transport , the raman pulse had a certain probability to transfer the ion into the @xmath112 state , which did not fluoresce during detection .
if the ion remained in the ground state , this side - band pulse had no effect and the ion remained in the bright @xmath111 state .
thus , fluorescence detection after the side - band pulse could distinguish an excited ion from a non - excited ion .
s following round - trip transport and a subsequent red sideband pulse , for various dac update rates @xmath140 . before transport , the ion was prepared in the motional ground state and then transported through a specific waveform , where @xmath149 mhz was maintained during the entire transport .
if the ion remained in the ground state after transport , the ion fluorescence was at its maximum value ( approximately 8 photon counts detected ) , but when the ion became motionally excited , the fluorescence dropped .
as can be seen , the motion was excited at specific update frequencies that correspond to @xmath150 for @xmath151 to @xmath152 ( marked by the vertical red lines ) . ]
this experiment was performed for various values of @xmath140 , and the results are shown in fig .
[ fig : dacheating ] .
it was difficult to extract the ion s exact motional state after the transport , but the correlations between the ion s motional excitation and @xmath86 corresponding to a harmonic of @xmath140 were evident .
the energy gain exhibited a resonance at several values for @xmath150 with @xmath151 to @xmath152 . when the number of update steps was increased , while the update rate was held constant ( which resulted in an increased transport duration ) , the bandwidth of these resonances decreased , as expected from a coherent excitation .
use of an update rate that was incommensurate with the motional frequency ( @xmath153 ) minimized this energy gain .
however , increasing the transport speed ( using the same update rate ) required a reduction in the number of waveform steps , which caused the resonances to broaden . minimizing the rf - noise heating required fast transport ,
so at the speed that gave the lowest rf - noise excitation rates , the dac heating resonances were so broad that they overlapped , and there was no achievable @xmath140 that would not result in energy gain .
the dac heating effect was further compounded by the fact that the axial frequency was not constant during a full junction transport , making it impossible to achieve @xmath153 for any constant @xmath140 .
the update frequency @xmath154 khz appeared to be most favorable and was used for the results here and in ref .
@xcite .
faster dacs capable of @xmath155 should significantly suppress this motional excitation . alternatively ,
aggressive filtering of the dac output can combat this problem .
the results in ref .
@xcite used the rc filter network shown in fig .
[ fig : dcfilters](a ) , which provided suppression by two orders - of - magnitude over the range of @xmath156 values used during transport ( 3.6 to 5.7 mhz ) , but was not sufficient to completely suppress the dac heating .
increasing the rc time constant would increase the filtering but would also slow down the rate at which the ion can be transported . instead , these simple rc filters were replaced with the approximately third - order butterworth filter @xcite shown in fig .
[ fig : dcfilters](b ) .
( the output impedance of the dac was @xmath157 and contributed minimally to the filter response . )
-order ` butterworth ' filter shown here.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] a butterworth filter has a frequency response given by @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the @xmath160-order butterworth polynomial and @xmath161 is the corner frequency .
if @xmath162 , the frequency response reduces to a rc frequency response . in the experiments here ,
such higher - order filters provide stronger noise suppression at @xmath86 while still allowing fast transport . a comparison of the theoretical response functions for the rc filters used in ref .
@xcite and the butterworth filters used here is shown in fig .
[ fig : filterreal ] . the internal vacuum rc components already on the filter board were taken into account when planning the butterworth filter , but the external filter components were designed to dominate the filter s response in the frequency range of concern .
thus , the filter was approximately third - order , despite the presence of four components ( including the filter board capacitor ) with frequency - dependent impedances .
the new filters increased the noise filtering by 22 db at 3.6 mhz and 26 db at 5.7 mhz .
furthermore , the electric - field noise at the ion due to johnson noise in the resistive elements of the new filters was less than that for the previous filters for all frequencies of interest . for the transport durations used , these filters did not appreciably distort the waveform . versus frequency for the original rc filter ( dashed ) and the improved approximately-`butterworth ' filter ( solid ) , where the new filter had a faster roll - off at high frequency .
since the pass - band extended farther for the new filter , the transport speed could be increased while providing more filtering at the secular frequency ( 3.6 mhz to 5.7 mhz ) .
both traces include the rc components inside the vacuum . ] the ` anomalous heating ' , which is thought to arise from noisy electric potentials on the surface of the trap @xcite , was measured to be 40 quanta / s for @xmath163 mhz at @xmath10 and was not a significant source of excitation during the transport experiments . for example , we estimate that it should have contributed only 0.007 quanta for @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath10 transport . to compare the measurements of various ion traps
, it has been common to express the heating in terms of the electric field noise with the expression @xcite : @xmath164 where @xmath165 is the spectral density of electric field fluctuations at the secular frequency . from the results here we found @xmath166mhz@xmath167 , where the distance of the ion to the nearest electrode surface was @xmath168 m .
this result , when compared to other traps as in refs .
@xcite , was significantly below that of most other room - temperature ion traps .
the cause of this relatively low heating rate is not known , but surface preparation could be a contributing factor . in the experiments here ,
the transport was slow and the trapping potential changed slowly compared to the motional frequencies , so we did not expect non - adiabatic excitation of the motion .
this was supported by observations that the excitation did not decrease as the transport was slowed .
for very slow transport , the heating actually increased because the ion spent more time crossing the rf barriers , resulting in increased rf - noise heating .
furthermore , no reduction in heating was observed when a gradual ( sinusoidal ) velocity profile was used instead of a constant velocity over the entire transport .
the waveforms were produced assuming a specific value of @xmath47 and corresponding pseudopotential . in theory , if the actual @xmath47 does not match the assumed @xmath47 , the axial trapping potential will not be as intended at the barriers .
in practice , there was an optimal value for the rf power which resulted in the lowest excitation rates and likely corresponded to the assumed @xmath47 .
the rf power was prone to slow drifts over many minutes ( likely due to temperature drifts in the resonators ) which resulted in modest increases in motional excitation ; it was necessary to occasionally adjust the rf power ( every 10 to 30 minutes ) and hold it to within @xmath169 to achieve the lowest motional - excitation rates . in practice , this was performed by ensuring that the radial secular frequencies at @xmath10 remained constant .
the motional excitation for single - ion transports was measured by use of sideband asymmetry measurements @xcite after a single pass through the junction , and the results are summarized in table [ tab : heatingrates ] .
these results were significantly better than those in ref .
@xcite , which are listed for comparison . in ref .
@xcite , rf noise was estimated to contribute 0.1 to 0.5 quanta of excitation per pass over a pseudopotential barrier , which explained between 3 and @xmath170 of the excitation seen .
the remainder of the excitation was attributed primarily to dac update noise .
the new trap rf filters and control electrode butterworth filters produced the observed reduction in excitation rates .
.the axial - motion excitation @xmath171 for a single @xmath0be@xmath1 ion for three different transports through the x - junction .
the results of this work , as well as that of ref .
@xcite , are given for comparisons for transporting from @xmath10 to @xmath18 , @xmath21s to go from @xmath10 to @xmath16 , and @xmath172s to go from @xmath10 to @xmath17 .
this error did not affect any other results in ref .
@xcite . ] .
the transport duration includes @xmath173s for the ion to remain stationary at the intermediate destination ( @xmath174s for the data from ref .
@xcite ) , before returning to @xmath10 .
the energy gain per trip is stated in units of quanta in a 3.6 mhz trapping well where @xmath175 quantum corresponds to 1.6 nev . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] we expect ( and observed ) less excitation of the stretch mode relative to the com mode , for two reasons .
first , the stretch mode frequency was higher than that of the com mode ( @xmath176 ) .
thus , the filters on the rf and control potentials were more effective at suppressing noise that could excite the stretch mode .
second , a stretch mode can be excited only by a differential force on the two ions , while the com mode is excited by a force common to both ions .
given the proximity of the ions to each other ( a few micrometers ) compared to the distance of the ions to the trap electrodes , the relative amplitude of differential forces acting on the ions are expected to be less than common forces .
so far , we have discussed the suppression of undesired excitation of motional degrees of freedom . we now discuss how magnetic - field fluctuations affecting internal - state ( qubit ) coherence are suppressed in the x - junction trap array .
decoherence of superpositions of the @xmath111 and @xmath112 qubit basis states occurs both during transport and while the qubit is stationary .
previous experiments demonstrated that junction transport contributed negligibly to decoherence @xcite .
magnetic field fluctuations form the dominant contribution to qubit dephasing , yielding typical values ( in this trap and others ) of less than @xmath22s @xcite .
use of a magnetic - field - insensitive qubit configuration enables extension of the coherence time to approximately 10 s and can be used with some gate operations such as the mlmer - srenson gate @xcite , but excludes implementation of @xmath177 gates @xcite . to suppress the effects of magnetic field fluctuations
, we enclosed the trap and field coils inside a high - magnetic - susceptibility mu - metal shield and implemented an active magnetic field stabilization system .
the shield ( fig .
[ fig : shield ] ) was designed for compatibility with the existing trap vacuum envelope and optical systems , and for ease of installation without the need to lift the trap apparatus from the supporting table .
a cylindrical body and approximately hemispherical dome were selected based on general guidelines for magnetic shielding and manufacturing constraints .
the main body and baseplate of the shield were constructed of @xmath178 mm thick , single - layer mu - metal in order to provide maximum shielding of low - frequency magnetic field fluctuations and to suppress magnetic saturation of the mu - metal .
this latter constraint arose because part of the field coils defining the quantization axis of the qubits were located approximately 1 cm from the walls , where a calculated field of @xmath179 t was expected for typical operating conditions .
direction at the trap .
reentrant flanges minimized field leakage around the imaging and optical access points . ]
openings in the shield for optical components or laser beams were outfitted with a reentrant flange fastened to the main body of the shield .
the flanges extended both outwards and inwards in the shield in order to maximize flux - line redirection .
a target length - to - diameter ratio of 5:1 guided design but was typically not achieved due to geometric constraints arising from the exterior dimensions of the vacuum envelope and the desire to position optical elements as close as possible to the shield for maximum beamline stability .
these flanges were designed to be modular , allowing for redesign and replacement if increased shielding became necessary .
magnetic continuity was achieved for all mating flanges by use of internally threaded fasteners , producing a snug contact fit .
the structure was designed to provide a minimum 22 db shielding of low - frequency fields .
this was confirmed by use of a pickup coil and detecting 60 hz fluctuations .
the minimum suppression measured for the shield alone was @xmath180 db parallel to the @xmath15 axis of the trap , and the direction of the largest access opening in the shield . shielding in excess of 60 db at 60 hz
was measured in transverse directions . the @xmath181 t quantization field is oriented @xmath182 with respect to the vacuum envelope axis .
initial measurements identified current instability due to power - supply ripple as dominating measured decoherence once the shield was installed .
we implemented a custom current - regulation system based on a proportional - integral - differential feedback circuit , a series current - sense resistor , and a low - current field - effect transistor . to minimize the effect of thermal drifts in the electronic circuit on magnetic field stability , we selected special low - tc ( thermal coefficient ) components and temperature - stabilized the enclosure .
the most critical components were the gain and sense resistors ; these were selected to be low - tc metal foil resistors with less than @xmath183 ppm / k and less than @xmath184 ppm / k stability , respectively .
a four - terminal current - sense resistor was selected with high - power - handling construction ( @xmath185 for the main coil and @xmath186 for the transverse shim coils ) .
similar care was taken to select low - tc difference amplifiers for the input stage and a low - tc voltage reference .
all sense and feedback components were thermally sunk to an al enclosure that was thermally stabilized by use of peltier coolers and a commercial temperature controller with millikelvin stability .
stabilization reduced current ripple from @xmath187 ma to @xmath188a on the main field - coil current of 1.2 a. net magnetic field fluctuations due to current ripple at the location of the ions were @xmath189 nt .
measurements of the dephasing time including both the magnetic shield and the stabilization circuitry demonstrated extension of the qubit coherence to @xmath190 ms , more than 15@xmath191 longer than that without shielding and current stabilization , and sufficient for multiple transports before the qubit dephased .
a spin - echo pulse doubles the coherence time to @xmath192 ms , indicating that slow shot - to - shot field fluctuations are small , and that decoherence is dominated by fluctuations on a millisecond time scale .
the secular modes of the ions were constrained to change throughout the transports , both in frequency and orientation . for most parts of the transport ,
the splittings between the mode frequencies were sufficiently large and the transport speed was sufficiently slow that modes changed adiabatically and energy did not transfer between modes .
however , at @xmath18 , the two principle axes that lie in the @xmath193 plane were designed to have nearly degenerate secular frequencies ( @xmath194 mhz ) , which could lead to mode - mixing .
the third mode along @xmath11 had a significantly higher frequency @xmath195 mhz , and would remain decoupled from the @xmath36 and @xmath101 modes .
since the radial modes were only doppler laser - cooled before transport , @xmath196 mode mixing would increase the excitation of the axial mode during transport .
we employed two approaches that would minimize such axial excitation .
first , the duration during which the ion was at @xmath18 could be adjusted such to minimize the energy transfer between modes ( by using a duration that corresponded to a full cycle of the mixing process ) .
alternately , a potential could be applied to various electrodes , which we will call the shim potential , to sufficiently break the degeneracy ( in practice , @xmath197 khz could be achieved ) and suppress the mixing .
both methods were effective and yielded similar transport excitation , though the second approach was used for the results in tables [ tab : heatingrates ] and [ tab : heatingrates2ions ]
. however , in separate experiments , we explored a method for controlling energy transfer between the motional modes of a single ion by using field shims near the junction to tune @xmath198 and @xmath199 to near - degeneracy .
ideally , a demonstration of the method would work as follows .
prior to transport from @xmath10 , the ion is cooled to the axial ground state @xmath200 along @xmath15 and prepared in doppler - cooled thermal states in the transverse modes . if the relative orientation of the modes remains stationary as the ion approaches @xmath18 , the modes should not exchange energy , even if they become degenerate .
however , if the @xmath36 and @xmath101 mode directions diabatically ( fast compared to @xmath201 ) rotate @xmath182 to new directions given by @xmath202 and @xmath203 , we would expect the initial @xmath36 oscillation to project onto the new mode basis with half of the energy going into each of the new modes .
if @xmath204 , the two oscillations would then begin acquiring a relative phase @xmath205 , where @xmath206 is the period spent at @xmath18 . by then quickly transporting away from @xmath18 towards @xmath10 such that the mode axes rotate diabatically by @xmath207 back to their original orientation , the oscillations would project back onto the original oscillator basis . if the wait period is such that @xmath208 ( where @xmath209 is an integer ) , the motion originally in the @xmath36 mode would project back into the same mode . if , however , @xmath210 , then the @xmath36-motion would project into the @xmath101 mode ; that is , the energy would exchange between @xmath36 and @xmath101 modes .
we demonstrated the basic features of this exchange as follows . to tune the @xmath198 and @xmath199 close to degeneracy , an external shim potential with an adjustable amplitude was applied .
the shim potential consisted of various contributions from 17 control electrodes near @xmath18 , each multiplied by the overall scaling factor @xmath211 .
these contributions were selected so that the net shim potential would primarily alter the frequency splitting without significantly affecting other trapping parameters ( such as the position of the trapping minimum and the @xmath212 mode frequency ) . in the axial mode after an @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath10 transport , versus the duration at @xmath18 ( wait period ) .
the black trace indicates exchange of energy between the @xmath101 mode , prepared near the ground state ( at @xmath10 ) , and the @xmath36 mode , prepared in a thermal state via doppler cooling .
the smaller blue trace represents the identical preparation , except the transport was performed twice . during the first transport ,
the wait period was set to maximize the energy transfer from the radial mode to the axial mode , followed by returning the ion to @xmath10 .
after re - cooling the axial mode to the ground state , the round - trip transfer was repeated .
the contrast was decreased ( blue trace ) , indicating that less transverse mode energy was available for transfer to the @xmath101 mode and therefore indicating cooling of the @xmath36 mode .
( b ) and ( c ) the exchange contrast and exchange frequency ( respectively ) , plotted versus the shim - potential scaling factor @xmath211 . ] the black trace in fig .
[ fig : exchange](a ) shows @xmath213 for the axial mode after @xmath10-@xmath18-@xmath10 transport , as the wait period at @xmath18 was varied .
we derive @xmath213 from sideband measurements , as described above , and assume a thermal distribution .
although this assumption may not be strictly valid , it should give a reasonable approximation for @xmath214 .
oscillations between an excited and near - ground state energy are visible .
the projection process began prior to the ion reaching @xmath18 and transport was too slow for the projection to be perfectly diabatic .
thus , the phase of the exchange oscillation in fig . [ fig : exchange](a ) is not well determined and was observed to depend on both the exchange frequency and the details of the approach to @xmath18 ( including speed and trajectory ) . in practice , it was difficult to maintain a constant phase for more than a few minutes , as drifts in the potential , likely caused by transient charge buildup and dissipation on the electrodes and also pseudopotential amplitude changes , caused the exchange frequency to drift over that time scale . figure [ fig : exchange](b ) displays the oscillation contrast @xmath215 for various scaling factors , @xmath211 , of the shim potential , while fig .
[ fig : exchange](c ) gives the frequency of those oscillations versus the shim scaling factor .
in separate experiments , the two mode frequencies at @xmath18 were measured as a function of @xmath211 by driving excitations with an oscillatory potential applied to the control electrodes .
the difference between the two mode frequencies , @xmath216 , was observed to match the oscillation frequency of the exchange process .
figure [ fig : exchange](c ) suggests @xmath217 is high on the extreme ends of the @xmath211 range , while fig .
[ fig : exchange](b ) shows a reduction in contrast in these regions of high @xmath217 , likely due to the reduction in diabaticity when @xmath217 was large .
this conclusion was supported by the observation that the contrast decreased as the ion transport speed was reduced .
however , there was a maximum speed , above which contrast no longer increased , because other sources of excitation began to obscure the oscillatory signal . from fig .
[ fig : exchange](b ) , we see that the fringe contrast was also minimized for shim scaling factors near @xmath218 , where @xmath217 was small .
this reduction in contrast can be explained as coinciding with the condition where the initial mode orientation is identical to the rotated mode orientation and thus the modes do not mix when projected , which is a condition not necessarily related to @xmath217 .
( we note that the @xmath211 value for minimum exchange frequency does not match that for minimum contrast . )
unfortunately , it was not possible to verify this , as we could not measure the mode orientation at @xmath18 , due to lack of laser - beam access . in the case where the energy from the @xmath36 mode was transferred into the @xmath101 mode , the ion could be returned to @xmath10 for a second round of ground - state cooling of the @xmath101 mode . in the experiment ,
the exchange process in @xmath18 was repeated and the results are shown as the blue trace in fig .
[ fig : exchange](a ) , where a noticeable decrease in the ion s axial excitation was observed compared to the first experiment without the second stage of cooling . the small relative phase shift for the two traces in fig .
[ fig : exchange](a ) was due to the slow drift of @xmath217 over the several minutes required to take the two traces . ideally ,
all of the energy would be transferred from the @xmath36 mode into the @xmath101 mode , and the subsequent cooling of the @xmath101 mode would leave both modes in the ground state , leading to no oscillation during the second trip into @xmath18 . in practice
, complete transfer was inhibited for two primary reasons .
first , the ions were not being transported fast enough to make a clean diabatic projection of the motion onto the switched axes .
second , for complete energy transfer , the projection should be onto axes rotated by @xmath219 .
any other angles would have resulted in incomplete transfer of energy .
attempts were made to adjust additional shims in hopes of realizing configurations closer to @xmath220 . however , as @xmath221 , it , again , becomes difficult to predict the mode orientation with our idealized computer models and we could not experimentally determine the mode axes in @xmath18 .
nevertheless , we observed a clear and easily reproducible reduction in maximum oscillation amplitude ( fig .
[ fig : exchange](a ) ) from @xmath222 to @xmath223 after the second round of cooling , indicating the radial mode energy was being reduced .
the use of additional rounds of exchange followed by cooling reduced @xmath224 further , but after three or four exchange rounds , other sources of excitation offset the energy reduction .
when optimized , this technique might be used to cool all modes of a single ion to the ground state , while having the ability only to ground - state cool a single mode , as for the laser beam configuration used here .
a junction is not required ; all that is needed is a trap that can diabatically change the relevant mode orientations by @xmath219 , which could be possible in many trap configurations .
in conclusion , we have demonstrated that transport through a two - dimensional trap array incorporating a junction can be highly reliable and excite an ion s motion by less than one quantum .
this is a significant improvement over prior work with junction arrays @xcite and suggests the viability of trap arrays incorporating junctions for use in large - scale ion - based quantum information processing . in addition , we have implemented a mu - metal shield and current stabilization to reduce qubit decoherence .
we have also examined a technique for transferring energy between motional modes .
dac - update noise can be mitigated with the use of more appropriate filters such as the butterworth filters used here and/or faster dac update rates .
noise on the trapping rf potential can result in motional excitation at pseudopotential barriers as described in sec .
[ subsec : rfnoise ] .
the junction design criteria in ref .
@xcite included minimizing these barriers .
however , the results here show that the slope of the pseudopotential barrier is more important than the barrier height for suppressing motional excitation , suggesting that suppression of barrier height may not be a necessary constraint in future designs . also ,
as observed here , with proper rf filtering , significant barrier slopes can be tolerated without causing significant heating .
the technique for determining the waveforms described in this report can be extended to incorporate multiple trapping wells by expanding eq .
( [ matrixconst ] ) to include multiple minima .
transport procedures such as the ion exchange in ref .
@xcite are also amenable to these solving techniques .
separating and combining of trapping wells requires consideration of the potential s quartic term @xcite .
therefore , @xmath76 in eq .
( [ derivvector ] ) could be expanded to include fourth - order derivatives . with the use of multiple junctions
, the techniques described here could help provide a path toward transfer of information in a large - scale ion - based quantum processor and enable an increased number of qubits in quantum algorithm experiments . to do this
, waveforms must be expanded to incorporate many trapping wells .
also , it is likely that a sympathetic cooling ion species will need to be co - trapped with the qubit ions to allow removal of the motional excitation from electronic noise , multiple junction transports , and separating and re - combining wells @xcite . if sympathetic - cooling ions are present , it may be advantageous to transport both ion species through a junction in a single local trapping well .
since the pseudopotential ( and micromotion ) are mass dependent , the qubit and cooling ions will experience different potentials , which could lead to additional motional excitation . if such excitation is excessive , it should still be possible to separate the ions into individual wells by species and pass the different species through junctions separately , followed by recombination .
we thank j.m .
amini , k.r .
brown , and j. britton for contributions to the apparatus and r. bowler and j.p .
gaebler for comments on the manuscript .
this work was supported by iarpa , onr , nsa , and the nist quantum information program .
this is a publication of nist and not subject to u.s . | we have demonstrated transport of @xmath0be@xmath1 ions through a 2d paul - trap array that incorporates an x - junction , while maintaining the ions near the motional ground - state of the confining potential well .
we expand on the first report of the experiment @xcite , including a detailed discussion of how the transport potentials were calculated .
two main mechanisms that caused motional excitation during transport are explained , along with the methods used to mitigate such excitation .
we reduced the motional excitation below the results in ref .
@xcite by a factor of approximately 50 .
the effect of a mu - metal shield on qubit coherence is also reported .
finally , we examined a method for exchanging energy between multiple motional modes on the few - quanta level , which could be useful for cooling motional modes without directly accessing the modes with lasers .
these results establish how trapped ions can be transported in a large - scale quantum processor with high fidelity . |
as one of the few supernova remnants ( snrs ) that were historically recorded by people from different countries or continents @xcite , sn 1006 is of great interest and has been extensively studied at multiple energy bands .
it is located far away from the galactic plane , with a galactic latitude of @xmath3145 , in a relatively low ambient - density ( @xmath4@xmath5 ; e.g. , @xcite ) environment .
the long - term proper motion measurements of the shock front at optical narrow band , combined with the expanding velocity , implies a distance of @xmath32.2 kpc for the snr @xcite .
multiwavelength emission from sn 1006 shows that the remnant has a diameter of 30(or 19 pc at 2.2 kpc ) , with two main lobes located at northeast ( ne ) and southwest ( sw ) parts of the snr s disk - like region .
while the interior of the snr is dominated by thermal emission ( e.g. , @xcite ) , the shell is dominated by synchrotron emission which is bright in radio @xcite and hard x - ray @xcite bands .
snrs are considered to be the main sites in the milky way for producing cosmic rays with energies up to a few 10@xmath6ev .
charged particles are accelerated in their shock fronts due to the diffusive shock acceleration mechanism ( e.g. , @xcite ) . as for sn 1006 , in addition to
hard x - rays that indicate high - energy electrons accelerated to 100tev in the shock front @xcite , very high energy ( vhe ; @xmath7gev ) emission was also detected with the high energy stereoscopic system ( hess ) .
the two hess sources j1504@xmath2418 and j1502@xmath2421 correspond to the ne and sw shell regions respectively @xcite , with the former approximately 50% brighter than the latter . given these , gev @xmath0-ray emission from sn
1006 has been searched in observations with the large area telescope ( lat ) onboard fermi gamma - ray space telescope ( fermi ) . using 3.5 and 6 years of _ fermi _ lat data ,
only upper limits have been obtained by @xcite and @xcite , respectively . combining the tev spectrum with the gev upper limits , a leptonic scenario , in which @xmath0-ray
photons arise from the inverse compton ( ic ) scattering process , is favored for the @xmath0-ray emission @xcite .
the _ fermi _ upper limits already tightly constrain the models typically considered for young snrs ( e.g. , cas a : @xcite , @xcite ; tycho : @xcite ) or for snrs having a tev shell - like morphology @xcite .
evidence for the interaction with a hi cloud in the sw limb region of sn 1006 has been reported by @xcite . with the release of the best _ fermi _ lat dataset ( pass 8 data ) in early 2015 and the accumulation of 7 years data , detailed analysis of the @xmath0-ray emission from sn 1006
is thus warranted . in this paper
we report our analysis of the _
fermi_lat data of the sn 1006 region and the likely detection of @xmath0-ray emission in 0.15300 gev energy range from the ne region of the snr .
lat is a @xmath0-ray imaging instrument that scans the whole sky every three hours and is basically conducting long - term @xmath0-ray observations of gev sources @xcite . for this analysis we selected _ fermi
_ lat pass 8 events in the energy range from 150 mev to 300 gev centered at the simbad position of sn 1006 , which is ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 ) = ( 15@xmath1002@xmath1122@xmath121 , @xmath242@xmath1305@xmath1449@xmath150 ) , obtained by @xcite .
the events below 150 mev were excluded to reduce the effects of the galactic background and the relatively large uncertainties of the instrument response function of the lat in low energy range .
the time period of the lat data is from 2008 - 08 - 04 15:43:36 ( utc ) to 2015 - 09 - 24 00:03:16 ( utc ) . following the recommendations of the lat team
, we included those events with zenith angles less than 90 degrees , which prevents the earth s limb contamination , and excluded the events with quality flags of ` bad ' .
we included all sources within 20 degrees centered at the position of sn 1006 in the _ fermi _ lat 4-year catalog @xcite to make the source model .
the spectral forms of these sources are provided in the catalog .
spectral parameters of the sources within 5 degrees from sn 1006 were set as free parameters , and the other parameters were fixed at their catalog values .
the background galactic and extragalactic diffuse emission were also added in the source model with the spectral model gll_iem_v06.fits and the file iso_p8r2_source_v6_v06.txt , respectively , used .
the normalizations of the diffuse components were set as free parameters .
we first performed standard binned likelihood analysis to the lat data in the @xmath161 gev band using the lat science tool _
gtlike _ in the science tools software package v10r0p5 .
the instrument response functions ( irfs ) of p8r2_source_v6 were used .
test statistic ( ts ) maps obtained in this higher energy range would likely be better resolved in a possibly crowded region and source positions be better determined as well . with the fitted source model , we calculated the binned ts map ( using _ gttsmap _ in the _ fermi _ software package ) of a @xmath17 region centered at sn 1006 .
all sources in the source model were considered and removed .
the obtained residual ts map of the source region is shown in the top panel of figure [ fig : tsmap ] .
excess emission in the sn 1006 region was detected with a maximum ts value of @xmath325 .
the ts value at a given position is a measurement of the fit improvement for including a source , and is approximately the square of the detection significance of the source @xcite .
therefore , the excess was detected with @xmath18 significance .
we noted that no catalog sources are within the square region , but there is an additional source in the top left corner of the ts map .
region centered at the x - ray center of sn 1006 in the 1300 gev band , with the green dashed circle indicating the x - ray region of sn 1006 and the green contours indicating the 2.07.2 kev x - ray intensity measurements of the ne and sw limbs of sn 1006 ( at a level of 19 counts s@xmath19 ; obtained from the xmm - newton map rebinned to the @xmath3004 pixel@xmath19 scale ) .
the image scale of the maps is 004 pixel@xmath19 .
all catalog sources were considered and removed .
the non - catalog source detected in the top left corner ( the _ top _ panel , indicated by a cyan cross ) was removed in the _ bottom _ panel .
the dark and red crosses mark the positions of hess j1504@xmath2418 and qso j1504@xmath24152 , respectively .
the dark dashed circle marks the 2@xmath20 error circle of the best - fit position obtained for the excess emission .
[ fig : tsmap],title="fig : " ] region centered at the x - ray center of sn 1006 in the 1300 gev band , with the green dashed circle indicating the x - ray region of sn 1006 and the green contours indicating the 2.07.2 kev x - ray intensity measurements of the ne and sw limbs of sn 1006 ( at a level of 19 counts s@xmath19 ; obtained from the xmm - newton map rebinned to the @xmath3004 pixel@xmath19 scale ) .
the image scale of the maps is 004 pixel@xmath19 .
all catalog sources were considered and removed . the non - catalog source detected in the top left corner ( the _ top _ panel , indicated by a cyan cross )
was removed in the _ bottom _ panel .
the dark and red crosses mark the positions of hess j1504@xmath2418 and qso j1504@xmath24152 , respectively .
the dark dashed circle marks the 2@xmath20 error circle of the best - fit position obtained for the excess emission .
[ fig : tsmap],title="fig : " ] we investigated if the nearby additional source might contaminate the detection of the excess emission in the sn 1006 region .
gtfindsrc _ in the lat software package , and determined its position : ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 ) = ( 2270 , @xmath2412 ) with 1@xmath20 nominal uncertainty of 02 .
adding the nearby source in the source model as a point source with power - law emission at its best - fit position , we re - performed the binned likelihood analysis . the ts map with this nearby source considered in the source model
is shown in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : tsmap ] .
now with the nearby source totally removed , the maximum ts value for the excess emission in the sn 1006 region was @xmath322 , still significant . in the following analysis the nearby source was considered in the source model . for the confirmed excess source
, we determined its position , which is ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 ) = ( 2259 , @xmath2418 ) with 1@xmath20 nominal uncertainty of 01 .
the vhe source hess j1504@xmath2418 ( @xcite , marked in figure [ fig : tsmap ] ) is 008 from the best - fit position and within the 1@xmath20 error circle .
we then investigated whether the confirmed excess source is point - like or extended . using both point - source and uniform disk models with power - law spectra at the best - fit position
, we performed likelihood analysis to the data in 1300 gev energy range .
the radius for the uniform disk was set in a range of 0105 with a step of 01 .
the spectral parameters of the sources within 5 degrees from sn 1006 were set as free parameters , and all other parameters in the source model were fixed at their catalog values .
no significant extended emission was detected .
the ts@xmath21 values , calculated from ts@xmath22 @xmath2 ts@xmath23 ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , were smaller than 0 .
we included the excess source as a point source in the source model with power - law emission and performed likelihood analysis in 0.15300 gev band .
the photon index @xmath240.3 and the photon flux @xmath25 photons s@xmath19@xmath26 were obtained , with a ts value of 15 .
in addition to the vhe source hess j1504@xmath2418 , there is an another known source located in the 2@xmath20 error circle of the best - fit position , that is the quasar qso j1504@xmath24152 @xcite .
its position is marked in figure [ fig : tsmap ] .
given that active galactic nuclei ( agn ) are the dominant source class detected by _
lat @xcite , we thus searched for long - term variability for the purpose of checking any possible association between qso j1504@xmath24152 and the excess source .
we calculated the variability index ts@xmath27 for the point source in sn 1006 region with 87 time bins ( each bin constructed from 30-day data ) in the energy range of 0.15300 gev , following the procedure introduced in @xcite .
if the flux is constant , ts@xmath27 would be distributed as @xmath28 with 86 degrees of freedom .
variable sources would thus be identified with ts@xmath27 larger than 119.4 ( at a 99% confidence level in the @xmath28 distribution ; see @xcite ) .
the computed ts@xmath27 for the source is 48.9 , corresponding to a @xmath291% confidence level for a variable source .
the value indicates that there was no signifiant long - term variability observed in the @xmath0-ray source .
considering the excess emission at the sn 1006 region as a point source at the best - fit position , we extracted its @xmath0-ray spectrum by performing likelihood analysis to the lat data in 5 evenly divided energy bands in logarithm from 0.15300 gev .
the excess emission was modelled with a power law in each energy band .
the fluxes obtained in this way are not dependent on the emission model assumed for a source , providing a good description for the @xmath0-ray emission of the source . in the extraction ,
the spectral normalizations of the sources within 5 degrees from the central position of sn 1006 were set as free parameters , while all the other parameters of the sources were fixed at the values obtained from the above maximum likelihood analysis .
the obtained spectrum is plotted in figure [ fig : spectra ] , where we kept the data points with ts greater than 9 ( corresponding to the detection significance of 3@xmath20 ) , and derived 95% flux upper limits otherwise .
the fluxes ( or flux upper limits ) and ts values are provided in table [ tab : tab1 ] .
we also estimated the systematic uncertainties for the spectral data points due to the galactic diffuse emission model , by repeating the likelihood analysis in each energy band with the normalization of the diffuse component artificially fixed to the @xmath306% deviation from the best - fit value ( see e.g. , @xcite ) .
the uncertainties estimated in this way are provided in table [ tab : tab1 ] , which have been considered together with the statistic ones in figure [ fig : spectra ] .
-ray spectrum of the excess source at the best - fit position in the sn 1006 region .
the 0.15300 gev power - law fit to the source is shown as the dashed line .
the grey area marks the power - low spectrum for the ne region of sn 1006 , obtained with hess .
[ fig : spectra ] ]
having analyzed 7 years of _ fermi _ lat pass 8 data , we found excess @xmath0-ray emission at the sn 1006 region .
as shown in figure [ fig : tsmap ] and [ fig : spectra ] , both the position and spectrum ( i.e. , the high - energy data point at 30 gev ; see table [ tab : tab1 ] ) match those of the tev emission from the ne shell region of sn 1006 ( see @xcite for details )
. the detected excess emission may well be the gev counterpart to sn 1006 that has been previously searched @xcite .
we tested to repeat the analysis in @xcite , where 6 years of p7rep data were used , and obtained the same non - detection result as theirs .
then as we changed to repeat our above analysis using pass 8 data in the same 6 years time period , the @xmath161 gev excess emission was detected with ts@xmath31 .
therefore our detection of the source should be due to the overall sensitivity improvement in the pass 8 data . .
[ fig : model ] ] considering the _ fermi _ source as the gev counterpart and combining its spectrum with the hess tev one , we checked if a leptonic model that has been proposed ( see @xcite ) could decribe the broadband spectrum of sn 1006 .
we employed a simple one - zone stationary model , in which the synchrotron and ic emission originates from the same population of electrons with a power - law form plus an exponential cutoff . given the radio spectral index of @xmath30.6 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , the electron spectral index was set to @xmath32 .
to fit the data , for which we have included radio @xcite , x - ray @xcite , and gev and tev @xmath0-ray , the required parameters were found to be : the cutoff energy @xmath33 tev , the total electron energy @xmath34erg , and the magnetic field strength @xmath35 @xmath36 24 @xmath37 g .
these parameter values are compatible with those considered in the previous leptonic models ( see @xcite ) .
the broadband spectral energy distribution ( sed ) and the model spectrum are shown in figure [ fig : model ] , where because the radio and x - ray data were emission from the whole remnant , the synchrotron flux was multiplied by a factor of 2 in our calculation assuming a symmetry between the ne and sw parts for simplicity .
not surprisingly as indicated by the previous studies , the leptonic model generally can describe the broadband data .
the observed flux at 1.5 gev is higher than the model flux , but within the 2@xmath20 uncertainty .
analysis of the lastest _ fermi _ lat pass 8 data for the sn 1006 region results in the detection of a source at a @xmath1 significance level in 0.15300gev .
the spectrum of the excess emission can be described by a @xmath38 power law ( the dashed line in figure [ fig : spectra ] ) , which can be connected to the hess spectrum . both the quasar qso j1504@xmath24152 @xcite and the vhe source hess j1504@xmath2418 @xcite are within the 2@xmath20 error circle of the best - fit position of the source .
we searched for variability in the source , but no significant variations were found .
in addition the spectral index of 1.9 does not favor the association to agn since agn generally have soft power - law spectra with photon indices up to @xmath33.0 in the lat @xmath0-ray energy range @xcite .
all of these indicate the source is more likely the gev counterpart to sn 1006 .
the combined _ fermi _ lat and hess spectrum can be described by a leptonic model with reasonable parameters , although the data point at 1.5 gev is slightly higher than our model spectrum .
the discrepancy may suggest that a more complicated model , e.g. , multi - emission zones , would be needed in order to better fit the broadband sed . on the other hand , we note that the index @xmath39 is compatible with those of the other 4 ( rx j1713.7@xmath23946 , rx j0852.0@xmath24622 , rcw 86 , and hess j1731@xmath2347 ; @xmath40 ) tev shell snrs summarized by @xcite .
this similarity may provide additional evidence for supporting the @xmath0-ray excess emission as the counterpart to the snr .
at the source distance of 2.2 kpc , the 0.15300gev luminosity is 1@xmath41 erg s@xmath19 , estimated from the best - fit model .
the luminosity value is consistent with the general emissional property for the currently _ fermi _ detected snrs : young snrs ( with ages no larger than a few thousands of years ) have @xmath0-ray luminosities of @xmath42@xmath43ergs@xmath19 , while middle - aged , dynamically evolved snrs are two orders of magnitude brighter due to their interaction with nearby molecular clouds ( see , e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) .
finally , @xcite have reported that the sw limb of sn 1006 is interacting with an atomic cloud , and predicted a 330 gev flux of @xmath44 erg@xmath26s@xmath19 based on their hadronic model proposed to explain the tev emission .
the flux is reached with the current _ fermi _ lat data ( see figure [ fig : spectra ] ) .
however in our analysis , we did not see any significant sources in the sw region of sn 1006 ( see figure [ fig : tsmap ] ) . a simple estimation for its flux can be used by scaling the ne flux with the ratio between the hess sw and ne fluxes ( 0.67 ; @xcite ) , which gives 1.53.4@xmath45erg@xmath26s@xmath19 and 0.83.6@xmath45erg@xmath26s@xmath19 at 1.5 and 30 gev ( table [ tab : tab1 ] ) , respectively . with the _ fermi _ lat observation time increasing for the source region
, it can be expected that the sw gev emission would likely be detected in the near future .
the detection will help confirm our result presented here in this work .
this research made use of the high performance computing resource in the core facility for advanced research computing at shanghai astronomical observatory .
the research was supported by the shanghai natural science foundation for youth ( 13zr1464400 ) , the national natural science foundation of china for youth ( 11403075 ) , the national natural science foundation of china ( 11373055 ) , and the strategic priority research program the emergence of cosmological structures " of the chinese academy of sciences ( grant no .
xdb09000000 ) .
z.w . acknowledges the support by the cas / safea international partnership program for creative research teams .
y.c . and x.z .
acknowledge the support of nsfc grant 11233001 and 973 program grant 2015cb857100 .
, f. r. , & green , d. a. 2002 , historical supernovae and their remnants , by f. richard stephenson and david a. green .
international series in astronomy and astrophysics , vol .
oxford : clarendon press , 2002 , isbn 0198507666 , 5 | we report the likely detection of @xmath0-ray emission from the northeast shell region of the historical supernova remnant ( snr ) sn 1006 . having analyzed 7 years of _ fermi
_ lat pass 8 data for the region of sn 1006 , we found a gev gamma - ray source detected with @xmath1 significance . both the position and spectrum of the source match those of hess j1504@xmath2418 respectively , which is tev emission from sn 1006 . considering the source as the gev @xmath0-ray counterpart to sn 1006 ,
the broadband spectral energy distribution is found to be approximately consistent with the leptonic scenario that has been proposed for the tev emission from the snr .
our result has likely confirmed the previous study of the snrs with tev shell - like morphology : sn 1006 is one of them sharing very similar peak luminosity and spectral shape . |
[ [ motivation - for - electric - storage - ring - traps - for - electrons - or - protons . ] ] * motivation for electric storage ring `` traps '' for electrons or protons . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the u.s .
particle physics community has recently updated its vision of the future and strategy for the next decade in a particle physics project prioritization panel ( p5 ) report .
one of the physics goals endorsed by p5 is measuring the edm of fundamental particles ( in particular proton , deuteron , neutron and electron ) .
since standard model edm predictions are much smaller than current experimental sensitivities , detection of any particle s non - zero edm would signal discovery of new physics .
if of sufficient strength , such a source could support an explanation for the observed matter / antimatter asymmetry of our universe .
a proton edm collaboration@xcite has proposed a storage ring proton edm measurement at the unprecedented level of @xmath0 cm , an advance by nearly 5 orders of magnitude beyond the current indirect bound obtained using hg atoms .
the proposed edm measurement is based on the accumulation of tiny `` wrong - plane '' ( i.e. `` right '' for edm , `` wrong '' for mdm ) spin precessions that can be accounted for only by a non - zero edm .
polarized beams can be frozen ( for example in longitudinally - polarized states ) in storage rings containing appropriate combinations of electric and magnetic bending elements ; the relative amount depends on the magnetic dipole moment of the particles being stored . only for a few particles ,
of which the electron and the proton are the most important , can the spins be frozen in purely electric rings .
this is highly advantageous , since such rings support beams circulating both clockwise and counter - clockwise , permitting measurements for which important systematic errors cancel . the electric dipole moment ( edm ) of the proton
is known to be so small that , in order to reduce systematic errors enough to measure it in a storage ring requires measuring differences between counter - circulating beams .
this can be done sequentially or , to provide differential beam position precision at the cost of beam - beam complications , with simultaneous circulating beams .
( direct colliding beam - beam effects are calculated to be negligible . )
a comparably important advantage of electric bending is that the absence of intentional magnetic fields will reduce the presence of unintentional ( radial ) magnetic field components , which are expected to be the dominant source of spurious precession , mimicking the edm effect . to freeze the spin procession , conventional storage ring bending
magnets are replaced with the corresponding electric elements . though the circulating particles are constantly being attracted to the inner electrode
, their centrifugal force causes them to circulate indefinitely in a more or less circular orbit .
this establishes the storage ring as an electric `` trap '' , albeit for an intense moving bunch rather than for a few slow particles . in a storage ring edm measurement
, bunches of longitudinally polarized protons will circulate for `` long '' time intervals such as 1000 seconds .
because of inevitable parameter spreads , individual particle spins will precess differently and , after a spin coherence time _
, the beam polarization will have been attenuated ( due to decoherence ) to a point where the edm precession rate has become unmeasurably small . the wrong - plane polarization difference between early and late times , when ascribed to the torque of the bend field acting on the electric dipole moment , will provide a measurement of the proton edm . for measuring edm s
the accumulation and measurement of small effects requires analysis , mitigation and control of various systematic errors .
issues to be studied with eteapot include : radial b - field : since the torque due to any residual radial b - field acting on the magnetic dipole moment ( mdm ) mimics the edm effect , this is expected to be the dominant systematic error . geometric phase : some edm - mimicking precessions would average to zero except for the non - commutativity of 3d rotations .
non - radial e - field , vertical quad misalignment , rf cavity misalignment etc .
: these cause the closed orbit to deviate from design .
the systematic errors they cause cancel to `` lowest order '' but higher order effects need to be investigated .
polarimetry : realistic beam distributions need to be used to identify and reduce left - right asymmetry bias , which is another source of systematic error . [
[ initial - storage - ring - simulation - tasks . ] ] * initial storage ring simulation tasks . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + initial tasks for the eteapot code are to simulate the performance of arbitrary electric storage rings . as with any storage ring , these tasks ( which now include also spin tracking ) are 1 .
evaluation of linearized lattice functions such as tunes , the twiss , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 functions , dispersion function , and spin tunes , as well as chromatic dependence of these functions , and their sensitivity to imperfections . 2 .
short term tracking , for confirmation of the lattice functions , for determining dynamic aperture , and for investigating the performance of analytically - derived spin decoherence compensation schemes .
3 . guaranteed to be _ stable _ , long term tracking .
the edm experiment requires _
sct _ to be 1000s or longer . during this time every particle executes about @xmath4 betatron oscillations .
the code is required to exhibit negligible spurious growth or decay for this interval of time .
compared to magnetic bending , electric bending complicates these tasks .
this requires the eteapot treatment to differ from the well - established teapot treatment .
as implemented in ual / teapot , lattice function determinations use a truncated power series formalism that has not ( as yet ) been established for electric rings . translating the arbitrary order formalism from magnetic to electric elements is a huge task that has only just begun . to cover all three storage ring simulation tasks on the time scale required for edm planning we have , therefore , had to proceed along more than one track .
one track starts by implementing exact ( and therefore exactly symplectic ) tracking in the inverse square law potential electrical field between spherical electrodes .
the optimal electric field shape will differ from this , however .
this makes it necessary to introduce artificial _ virtual _ quadrupoles in the interiors of bend elements , in order to model deviation of the actual electric field away from its idealized representation .
_ real _ quadrupoles are typically also present in the lattice , for example to alter the lattice focusing , or to control dispersion .
thin sextupoles ( present for example to adjust chromaticities or to compensate spin decoherence effects ) and other thin multipole elements are also allowed .
causing only `` kicks '' , these thin elements , either real or virtual , also preserve symplecticity .
now complete , this track allows tasks ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) to be completed for arbitrary lattices .
since ( linearized ) transfer matrices are not used , the eteapot code can not be used to extract twiss functions directly , as is commonly done in conventional courant - snyder accelerator formalism .
however , tunes and twiss functions can be obtained ( to amply satisfactory accuracy ) using fft and mia ( model - independent analysis ) .
now complete this code also provides transfer matrix determination which , in turn , allows determination of all the lattice functions required to complete task ( 1 ) .
implementation of the ual truncated power series approach for electric rings has just been begun .
its progress is contingent on obtaining government funding@xcite . after comparing eteapot simulation results to results measured on the ags analogue ring this
paper briefly describes simulation of spin evolution in a proton edm storage ring .
of the more than 100 relativistic accelerators ever built , only one has used electric rather than magnetic bending .
it was the ags electron analogue machine at bnl .
curiously it was also the first ring ever to use alternating gradient ( ag ) focusing .
( the cornell 1.1gev alternating gradient electron ring was commissioned at more or less the same time and the bnl ags ring itself somewhat later . ) along with using _ electrons _ instead of _ protons _ , and limited by achievably high electric field , cost minimization of the ags analogue led to the choice of 10mev maximum electron energy , 4.7 m bending radius , 6.8mhz rf frequency , and 600v rf voltage .
these optimization considerations are very much the same as will be used to fix the parameters of a frozen spin proton ring ( which is tentatively expected to have a bend radius of about 50m)@xcite .
the ual / eteapot code ( documented in the accompanying paper ) was developed with this application in mind .
the present paper gives initial results .
starting from fragmentary documentation , the paper starts by reverse engineering the ags analogue lattice and producing a lattice description file e@[email protected] , in the format needed for processing in the unified accelerator libraries ( ual ) environment .
results obtained using eteapot are then compared with measurements performed on the ring at bnl in 1954 - 55 . by chance ,
the magic kinetic energy for freezing electrons , which is 15mev , is not very different from the 10mev of the ags analogue ring . so that ring could have been used to measure the electron edm just by increasing the electric bend field by a factor of 1.5 .
morse@xcite and others have suggested building such a ring for this purpose .
the eteapot code can therefore be used to to simulate an electron edm measurement using a ring whose successful performance as a storage ring is all but guaranteed by the successful operation of an `` identical '' ring in 1955 .
15mev is a very convenient electron energy and high quality electron source would be available , for example as described by bazarov@xcite .
the present paper describes our `` resurrection '' of ags analogue ring from historic bnl documentation , and simulates its performance with codes intended for the proton edm experiment .
a quite superficial ( day long ) search of the bnl library and the accelerator - collider report library found one quite extensive report , produced retrospectively in 1991 by martin plotkin@xcite , and a few ancient reports describing machine studies results .
also a report privately communicated from ernest courant@xcite contains experimental data to be simulated in this paper . before starting on this project ,
one of the authors , rt , benefited from three brief but valuable meetings with ernest courant , perhaps the father , or at least one of the parents , of the electron analogue ring , inquiring about his recollections concerning the dynamics and performance of the ring .
this contributed to our reconstruction .
bill morse@xcite reports having had a similar conversation with courant a few years earlier .
bill recalls asking ernest whether , back in 1953 , he ( courant ) understood the difference between electric and magnetic focusing .
ernest s replied `` of course '' in his always kindly , but in this case somewhat exasperated , tone of voice .
[ [ historical - bnl - documents . ] ] * historical bnl documents . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the `` conceptual design report '' for the ags analogue electron ring was a four page letter , dated august 21 , 1953 , from bnl director haworth to the a.e.c .
( predecessor of d.o.e . ) director of research johnson , applying for funding .
the letter is reproduced in its entirety in figure [ fig : haworthletter ] in the appendix . as brief
as it is , this letter along with hints from plotkin and courant , includes everything needed to reconstruct the ring , as shown in figure [ fig : ags_analogue ] . by 1955
the ring had been approved , built , and commissioned , and had achieved its intended purpose . following the haworth letter in the appendix are two other especially informative figures from the paper by plotkin .
figure [ fig : ags - analoguetanks ] is especially useful for visualizing the physical layout of the ags analogue ring and its vacuum system .
figure [ fig : plotkincourantdata ] is a more polished version of figure [ fig : quadstrvstunes ] which plots tune scans actually performed on the ags - analogue ring and reported by ernest courant in a july 28 , 1955 bnl technical report@xcite . in these plots ,
points of observed beam loss and observed beam disruption in the @xmath6 tune plane are correlated with expected resonances .
beam loss occurs on integer resonances , beam disruption occurs on half integer resonances .
the courant report on , and analysis of , data collected in machine studies less than two years after the submission of the ring funding proposal , would certainly deserve an a+ grade by modern machine studies grading standards .
the axes are voltages ( proportional to focusing strengths ) applied to the tune - adjusting quadrupole families .
short heavy lines indicate regions with no beam survival ( presumably due to integer resonance ) .
dots indicate points reported by courant as `` showing the characteristic double envelope of the oscilloscope pattern , sometimes accompanied by beam loss '' .
( these were presumably due to `` very narrow '' 1/2 integer resonance ) .
the nominal central tunes values are @xmath7 .
stop bands due to the eightfold lattice symmetry are also shown .
our ags analogue lattice reconstruction is shown in figure [ fig : ags_analogue ] .
the courant tune plane plot is shown in figure [ fig : courantdata ] .
it is to be compared with a similar plot , simulated by teapot and shown in figure [ fig : quadstrvstunes ] .
as far as we know this code and this lattice representation are completely equivalent courant s model and analysis in 1955 . in the teapot tune plane plot ,
boxes indicate points on integer resonance boundary curves of the stable diamond centered on nominal tune values @xmath7 .
points lying on 1/2 integer resonance lines are indicated by dots .
superperiodicity ( eightfold periodicity ) causes resonances with @xmath8 or @xmath9 indicated by broad blank bends bounded by narrowly - spaced lines .
courant refers to these as `` stop bands '' .
horizontal / vertical axes @xmath10 are `` electrode voltages on the quadrupoles in odd / even - numbered tanks '' .
( for the meaning of `` tank '' see figure [ fig : ags - analoguetanks ] . )
the quadrupole strength coefficients for variable quadrupoles @xmath10 were determined empirically to match the central tunes .
this means that absolute focusing strength scales are not checked .
otherwise there are no significantly adjustable empirical lattice parameters .
the ags analogue ring provides only a coarse test of eteapot since , for strong focusing , the change from electic and magnetic bending is quite minor .
this is illustrated in figure [ fig : elecmagncompare ] which shows that the @xmath6=(6.5,6.5 ) tunes in the ags analogue ring are high enough that the tune plane structure is quite insensitive to whether the bends are treated as magnetic or electric .
treating the difference perturbatively , the effects of changing from magnetic to electric bends are inversely proportional to @xmath2 s , which are both 6.5 in this case . for
the eventual proton edm ring the vertical tune has to be reduced from @xmath11 by at least a factor of ten which completely invalidates any such perturbative estimation and requires radical adjustment of quadrupole strengths .
reducing @xmath12 from 6.5 to 2.25 has been straightforward but , as the electric focusing became increasingly important , to decrease @xmath12 further will require substantial design effort .
spin evolution in the ags analogue ring is shown in figure [ fig:6plus3dplots ] and described in the caption . from these results we are confident in out understanding of electric rings and of our ability to simulate their performance using eteapot .
plots so far have simulated the evolution of 10mev electrons in the ags analogue electron ring . these roughly indicate the performance to be expected in a modern day electron edm storage ring measurement . of more immediate interest
is the expected behavior of 230mev protons in a significantly larger , but still all - electric proton edm storage ring .
a single particle tracking example , taken from a recent proton edm study , is illustrated in figure [ fig : plots ] .
the particle orbit and spin components are tracked around a prototype proton edm storage ring for 33 million turns using eteapot . as stated earlier the tracking is exact and no artificial `` symplectification '' is applied .
any spurious damping or anti - damping of the spatial orbit over the full run is less than ten percent over the 33 million turns .
the ( unit - magnitude ) spin vector * s * is initially purely tangential ( forward ) and the vector magnitude never changes from its initial value of 1 .
it is characteristic of spin evolution for the transverse spin components to change over narrow ranges in synchronism with betatron oscillation and larger but still small , ranges in synchronism with synchrotron oscillation .
the upper left graphs of figure [ fig : plots ] show this , along with a sinusoidal fit with the parameters shown .
these precessions are not expected to contribute significantly to spin decoherence . but any systematic growth over millions of turns will eventually lead to beam decoherence and limited spin coherence time .
an important computational task in planning to measure the proton edm is to determine the spin coherence time @xmath13 of the circulating beam .
this is the time after which inevitable spreads in beam parameters will have attenuated the beam polarization significantly due to decoherence in the spin propagation .
as long as both @xmath14 and @xmath15 magnitudes remain small , * s * remains in the forward hemisphere , and decoherence is suppressed .
one sees from the graphs of figure [ fig : plots ] that both @xmath14 and @xmath15 gradually deviate from zero .
but , for the particular particle being tracked , these deviations are limited to small values . in particular , since @xmath16 remains always much less than 1 in magnitude , @xmath17 therefore remains not much less than 1 .
so the beam polarization remains always in the forward hemisphere .
depolarization is therefore unimportant for particles of amplitude comparable to , or smaller than , this particle s .
the tracking is therefore consistent with the sct value exceeding the 33 million turns shown .
the lattice investigated in figure [ fig : plots ] is a `` mbius lattice '' in which the horizontal and vertical betatron oscillations interchange on every turn .
this strongly suppresses spin depolarization because precession in horizontal and vertical oscillation phases tend to cancel on a turn - by - turn basis . by fine tuning
this cancellation it is anticipated that extremely long sct values can be obtained . this will leave beam energy spread as the dominant source of beam depolarization .
fringe fields at bend elements are one such significant source of spin precession slewing . in this respect spin tracking
is more sensitive than orbit tracking .
fringe fields are not very important in orbit calculations . treating bends as `` hard edged ''
mainly causes small tune shifts which are not very important , since both tunes are always set operationally using spectrum analysis .
but , because of the spin precession sensitivity , in eteapot , fringe fields are treated as linear ramps of length comparable with the gap between the electrodes , and not by hard edges . in any case synchrotron oscillation averaging
also strongly suppresses this fringe field depolarization .
this places further demands on longitudinal particle tracking , which is always delicates , because nonlinearity of synchrotron oscillations contributes to spin decoherence .
the particle revolution period is about one microsecond so the plots shown correspond to about thirty seconds of real clock time in the laboratory . in a laptop computer
this computation takes a few hours per particle .
the ratio of computation time to real laboratory time for a single particle is in the range from one to ten thousand .
the present eteapot single particle tracking approach is sufficient for early design tasks .
edm storage ring beams will contain perhaps @xmath18 particles .
adequately precise simulation of the edm experiment will require fewer than this , but at least thousands of particles to be tracked for significantly longer times than shown .
this will require heavy parallelization of the tracking . with little particle - to - particle interaction ,
the code is easily parallelizable . for more advanced tasks , such as investigating polarimeter biases or emittance growth caused intrabeam scattering ,
an efficient and scalable map - based computational approach is under consideration .
j. talman and r. talman , bnl internal reports , _ ual / eteapot results for proton edm benchmark lattices , _ april , 2012 , _ ual / eteapot proton edm benchmark comparisons ii : transfer matrices and twiss functions , _ august , 2012 , and _
ual / eteapot proton edm benchmark comparisons iii : dispersion , longitudinal dynamics and synchrotron oscillations , _ april , 2012 | there has been much recent interest in directly measuring the electric dipole moments ( edm ) of the proton and the electron , because of their possible importance in the present day observed matter / antimatter imbalance in the universe .
such a measurement will require storing a polarized beam of `` frozen spin '' particles , 15mev electrons or 230mev protons , in an all - electric storage ring .
only one such relativistic electric accelerator has ever been built
the 10mev `` electron analogue '' ring at brookhaven national laboratory in 1954 ; it can also be referred to as the `` ags analogue '' ring to make clear it was a prototype for the ags proton ring under construction at that time at bnl .
( its purpose was to investigate nonlinear resonances as well as passage through `` transition '' with the newly - invented alternating gradient proton ring design . ) by chance this electron ring , long since dismantled and its engineering drawings disappeared , would have been appropriate both for measuring the electron edm and to serve as an inexpensive prototype for the arguably more promising , but ten times more expensive , proton edm measurement .
today it is cheaper yet to `` resurrect '' the electron analogue ring by simulating its performance computationally .
this is one purpose for the present paper .
most existing accelerator simulation codes can not be used for this purpose because they implicitly assume magnetic bending .
the new ual / eteapot code , described in detail in an accompanying paper , has been developed for modeling storage ring performance , including spin evolution , in electric rings . illustrating its use , comparing its predictions with the old observations , and describing new expectations concerning spin evolution and code performance , are other goals of the paper . to set up some of these calculations has required a kind of `` archeological physics '' to reconstitute the detailed electron analogue lattice design from a 1991 retrospective report by plotkin@xcite as well as unpublished notes of courant@xcite describing machine studies performed in 1954 - 55 .
this paper describes the practical application of the eteapot code and provides sample results , with emphasis on emulating lattice optics in the ags analogue ring for comparison with the historical machine studies and to predict the electron spin evolution they would have measured if they had had polarized electrons and electron polarimetry . of greater present day interest
is the performance to be expected for a proton storage ring experiment . to exhibit the eteapot code performance and confirm its symplecticity ,
results are also given for 30 million turn proton spin tracking in an all - electric lattice that would be appropriate for a present day measurement of the proton edm . the accompanying paper `` eteapot : symplectic orbit / spin tracking code for all - electric storage rings''@xcite documents in detail the theoretical formulation implemented in eteapot , which is a new module in the unified accelerator libraries ( ual ) environment@xcite . |
the experimental studies of nucleus - nucleus ( a+a ) collisions at the sps and rhic provide a rich information on hadron observables ( multiplicities and momentum spectra ) .
an extensive experimental program is motivated by a possibility to create a new state of matter the quark gluon plasma ( qgp ) in a laboratory .
any theoretical description of the qgp requires a macroscopic approach : statistical mechanics to describe the static properties of the matter and hydrodynamics to describe the system evolution . the equilibrium hadron gas ( hg ) model describes remarkably well the hadron multiplicities measured in pb+pb and au+au collisions at top sps ( @xmath1 gev per nucleon pair ) @xcite and rhic ( @xmath2 gev ) @xcite energies , where the creation of qgp is expected .
the hg model assumes the following formula for the hadron thermal multiplicities in the grand canonical ensemble ( g.c.e . ) : @xmath3^{-1}~,\ ] ] where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the system volume and temperature , respectively , @xmath6 and @xmath7 denote particle masses and degeneracy factors .
the particle chemical potential @xmath8 in eq.([stat ] ) is defined as @xmath9 , where @xmath10 denote the baryonic number strangeness and charm of particle @xmath11 .
the baryonic chemical potential @xmath12 regulates the baryonic density of the hg system whereas strange @xmath13 and charm @xmath14 chemical potentials should be found from the requirement of zero value for the total strangeness and charm in the system ( in our consideration we neglect small effects of a non - zero electrical chemical potential ) .
the total multiplicities @xmath15 in the hg model include the resonance decay contributions : @xmath16 where @xmath17 are the corresponding decay branching ratios .
the hadron yield ratios @xmath18 in the g.c.e .
are the functions of @xmath5 and @xmath12 and are independent of the volume parameter @xmath4 .
the temperature parameters extracted from fitting the multiplicity data are approximately the same for the sps and rhic energies : @xmath19 mev @xcite .
this value is close to an estimate of the temperature @xmath20 for the qgp
hg transition obtained in lattice qcd simulations at zero baryonic density ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
one may therefore argue that qgp formed at the early stage of a+a reaction hadronizes into a locally equilibrated hg , and the chemical composition of this hadron gas is weakly affected by the subsequent hadron rescatterings .
the production of charmonium states @xmath0 and @xmath21 have been measured in a+a collisions at cern sps over the last 15 years by the na38 and na50 collaborations .
these studies were mainly motivated by the theoretical suggestion @xcite to use @xmath0 meson as a probe for deconfinement in a+a collisions .
recently the thermal model @xcite and the statistical coalescence model ( scm ) @xcite ( see also @xcite ) for the charmonium production in a+a collisions were formulated .
the total @xmath0 multiplicity , @xmath22 , in the thermal model @xcite is given by eq .
( [ dec ] ) , where @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 are calculated according to eq.([stat ] ) and @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 are the decay branching ratios of the excited charmonium states into @xmath0 .
the thermal model @xcite predicts that at high collision energies the @xmath0 to @xmath30 ratio is independent of @xmath31 and the number of nucleon participants @xmath32 .
this is because both @xmath33 and @xmath34 multiplicities are proportional to the system volume and the hadronization temperature is expected to be approximately constant at high collision energies .
the scm @xcite assumes that charmonium states are formed at the hadronization stage .
this is similar to the thermal model @xcite .
however , in the scm the charmonium states are produced via a coalescence of @xmath35 and @xmath36 ( anti)quarks created by the hard parton collisions at the early stage of a+a reaction .
the number of created @xmath37 pairs , @xmath38 , in hard parton collisions , differs in general from the result expected in the equilibrium hg .
one needs then a _ charm enhancement _ factor @xmath39 @xcite @xcite in the hg model . ] to adjust the thermal hg results to the required average number , @xmath40 , of @xmath37 pairs .
the open charm hadron yield is enhanced by a factor @xmath39 and charmonium yield by a factor @xmath41 in comparison with the equilibrium hg predictions .
this leads to a difference between the thermal model and scm predictions for charmonia multiplicities . the canonical ensemble ( c.e . ) formulation of the scm is @xcite : @xmath42 where @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the hg multiplicities of all particles with hidden and open charm , respectively .
the canonical suppression factor @xmath45 in eq.([ncc1 ] ) is due to the exact charm conservation ( see e.g. , @xcite , @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the modified bessel functions ) .
if @xmath48 is known , eq.([ncc1 ] ) can be used to find the charm enhancement factor @xmath39 and calculate then the @xmath0 multiplicity : @xmath49 where @xmath22 is the total ( thermal plus excited charmonium decays ) hg @xmath0 multiplicity .
note that the second term in the right - hand side of eq.([ncc1 ] ) gives only a tiny correction to the first term , i.e. most of the created @xmath37 pairs are transformed into the open charm hadrons .
eqs.([ncc1],[npsi ] ) lead then to : @xmath50 @xmath51 eq.([ncc1 ] ) assumes an exact conservation of @xmath52 and ` statistical fluctuations ' of @xmath53 numbers .
a more accurate treatment with ` dynamical ' ( poisson - like ) distribution of @xmath54 leads to @xcite : @xmath55 eq.([jpsi ] ) coincides with eqs.([ncc1],[npsi ] ) at both @xmath56 and @xmath57 limits ( see eqs.([npsi1],[npsi2 ] ) ) .
this is because at @xmath56 the probabilities to create zero , @xmath58 , and one , @xmath59 , @xmath37 pairs are only important . on the other hand , at @xmath60 the statistical and dynamical fluctuations of @xmath54 both obey the poisson law distribution .
the centrality dependence of @xmath61 in a+b nucleus - nucleus collisions can be calculated in glauber s approach , @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is the impact parameter , @xmath64 is the nuclear overlap function and @xmath65 is the @xmath66 production cross section for nucleon - nucleon collisions . as discussed in ref.@xcite , the deconfined medium can substantially modify charm production at the sps , i.e. , @xmath65 in a+b collisions can be different from the corresponding cross section measured in a nucleon - nucleon collision experiment .
the present analysis treats @xmath65 at the sps energy as a free parameter .
its value is fixed by fitting the na50 data . in the na50 experiments @xcite the drell - yan muon pair multiplicity ( either measured or calculated from the minimum bias data )
is used as a reference for the @xmath0 `` suppression pattern '' .
the number of drell - yan pairs is also proportional to the number of primary nucleon - nucleon collisions : @xmath67 , where @xmath68 is the nucleon - nucleon production cross section of @xmath69 drell - yan pairs .
the prime means that the pairs should satisfy the kinematical conditions of the na50 spectrometer .
as the drell - yan cross section is isospin dependent , an average value is used : @xmath70 . for the case of pb+pb collisions , @xmath71 and @xmath72 @xmath73b @xcite .
the quantity to be studied is the ratio @xmath74 @xmath75 is the decay probability of @xmath0 into @xmath76 .
only the fraction @xmath77 of @xmath76 pairs satisfying the kinematical conditions of the na50 spectrometer can be registered .
we treat @xmath77 in eq.([rb ] ) as one more model free parameter . in the na50 experiment ,
the neutral transversal energy @xmath78 of produced particles was used to measure centrality of the collisions .
this variable , however , provides a reliable measure of the centrality only if it does not exceed a certain maximum value : @xmath79 gev ( see ref.@xcite ) .
the average number of participants is a linear function of the transversal energy , @xmath80 , in the domain @xmath79 gev ( @xmath81 gev ) . at @xmath82
gev the number of @xmath83 does not change essentially as @xmath78 grows .
therefore , the data at @xmath84 gev do not represent a centrality dependence of the @xmath0 suppression pattern but rather its dependence on fluctuations of the stopping energy at approximately _ fixed _ number of participants .
the influence of such fluctuations on @xmath0 multiplicity can be studied in the framework of the scm model @xcite .
+ fig . 1 : the dependence of the @xmath0 to drell - yan ratio on the transversal energy .
the normal nuclear suppression curve is obtained at @xmath85 mb .
the scm lines are calculated using eq.([rb ] ) .
the vertical line shows the applicability domain of the scm , @xmath86 .
the scm fit of the na50 data with eq.([rb ] ) is shown in fig . 1 ( see refs .
@xcite for details ) .
the model parameters are : @xmath87 with @xmath5 and @xmath12 fixed by hadron yield data .
the model requires rather large enhancement for the open charm production ( up to a factor of about @xmath88 within the rapidity window of the na50 spectrometer ) .
a direct measurement of the open charm in pb+pb at cern sps by na60 would allow to test this prediction .
the scm does not describe the na50 data at small values of @xmath78 ( the peripheral collisions with @xmath89 gev ) .
this can be also seen from the @xmath90 data . for @xmath91
mev the value of the thermal ratio is @xmath92 .
this is in agreement with data in pb+pb collisions at sps for @xmath86 , but is in contradiction with data in p+p , p+a and very peripheral a+a collisions .
this fact was first noticed in ref .
the number of directly produced @xmath37 pairs at the rhic energies can be estimated in the pqcd approach and used then as the input for the scm .
the pqcd calculations for @xmath93 production cross sections were first done in ref.@xcite . for the cross section @xmath94 of the charm production in p+p collisions
we use the results presented in ref.@xcite .
this leads to the value of @xmath95 mb at @xmath96 gev and the @xmath31-dependence of the cross section for @xmath97 gev is parameterized as @xcite : @xmath98 with @xmath99 @xmath73b , @xmath100 gev , @xmath101 and @xmath102 .
the number of produced @xmath37 pairs in a+a collisions is proportional to the number of primary n+n collisions , @xmath103 , which in turn is proportional to @xmath104 @xcite : @xmath105 where @xmath106 mb is the inelastic n+n cross sections , @xmath107 barn@xmath108 .
the results of the scm can be studied analytically according to eqs.([npsi1],[npsi2 ] ) in the limiting cases of small and large numbers of @xmath48 . for @xmath109
one finds : @xmath110 where we use the energy dependence of the pion multiplicity per nucleon participant @xmath111 @xcite which approximately works in the sps
rhic energy region .
the behavior ( [ lim1 ] ) corresponds to the @xmath0 suppression : the ratio @xmath112 decreases with increasing of both @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
this takes place at the sps : this energy is still too `` low '' as @xmath113 even in the most central pb+pb collisions .
however , the behavior of the @xmath0 to @xmath54 ratio is changed dramatically at the rhic energies @xcite ( see fig . 2 and ref .
@xcite for details ) . in central au+au collisions at
@xmath96 gev the expected value of @xmath114 is essentially larger than unit . for @xmath115 one finds ( @xmath116 ) : @xmath117
in ref.@xcite we formulated the hypothesis that the kinetic freeze - out of @xmath0 and @xmath21 mesons takes place directly at hadronization .
the effect of rescattering in the hadronic phase was recently studied within a `` hydro + cascade '' approach @xcite .
a+a collisions are considered there to proceed in three stages : hydrodynamic qgp expansion ( `` hydro '' ) , transition from qgp to hg ( `` switching '' ) and the stage of hadronic rescatterings and resonance decays ( `` cascade '' ) .
the switching from hydro to cascade takes place at @xmath119 , where the spectrum of hadrons leaving the surface of the qgp hg transition is taken as an input for the subsequent cascade calculations .
the results of refs .
@xcite suggest that the transverse momentum spectra of @xmath120 is only weakly affected during the cascade stage and give therefore a straightforward measure of the collective hydro velocity at the ` switching ' surface @xmath119 . in ref .
@xcite we demonstrated that in pb+pb collisions at 158 a@xmath121gev the @xmath118-spectra of @xmath122 @xcite can be explained simultaneously with the @xmath118-spectra of @xmath0 and @xmath21 mesons @xcite using the same set of the hadronization parameters . assuming the fluid freeze - out at constant temperature @xmath5 , the transverse mass spectrum of @xmath123-th hadron species in cylindrically symmetric and longitudinally boost invariant fluid expansion equals approximately to ( see ref .
@xcite for further references and details ) : @xmath124 where @xmath125 and @xmath126 is the average transverse flow velocity .
+ fig . 3 : the @xmath118-spectra measured at midrapidity in pb+pb at 158 a@xmath121gev by wa97 @xcite for @xmath120 and by na50 @xcite for @xmath0 and @xmath21 are presented ( in arbitrary units ) versus @xmath127 .
the solid lines correspond to eq.([hydro1 ] ) with @xmath128 mev and @xmath129 . in fig .
3 we present the fit with eq.([hydro1 ] ) of the measured @xmath118-spectra .
the temperature is fixed as @xmath128 mev and @xmath126 is considered as a free parameter .
the shapes of all spectra are simultaneously reproduced at @xmath130 .
statistical hadronization of the qgp is probably an important source of @xmath0 production @xcite . within the scm @xcite
the na50 data on the @xmath0 production in pb+pb at 158 a@xmath121gev can be fitted @xcite ( see fig .
1 ) for central collisions @xmath86 .
a large enhancement of the open charm over an extrapolation from the p+p data is however required @xcite .
a direct measurement of the open charm in pb+pb at cern sps by na60 would allow to test the scm selfconsistency .
the scm predicts that the @xmath0 _ suppression _ at the sps should be changed into the @xmath0 _ enhancement _ in central au+au collisions at the rhic energies @xcite ( see fig . 2 ) .
the shapes of @xmath118-spectra for @xmath120 , @xmath0 and @xmath21 are simultaneously reproduced @xcite ( see fig .
3 ) in the hydrodynamical picture of the qgp hadronization with @xmath128 mev , @xmath131 . this supports the hypothesis that formation and the kinetic freeze out of charmonia occurs at the hadronization @xcite .
99 j. cleymans and h. satz , z. phys . *
c57 * ( 1993 ) 135 ; j. sollfrank , m. gadzicki , u. heinz and j. rafelski , z. phys . * c61 * ( 1994 ) 659 ; p. braun - munzinger , i. heppe and j. stachel , phys . lett .
* b465 * ( 1999 ) 15 ; g. d. yen and m. i. gorenstein , phys . rev .
* c59 * ( 1999 ) 2788 ; f. becattini _ et al_. , phys . rev .
* c64 * ( 2001 ) 024901 .
n. xu and m. kaneta , nucl .
* a698 * , ( 2002 ) 306 ; p. braun - munzinger _
et al_. , phys .
b518 * ( 2001 ) 41 ; w. frolkowski , w. broniowski and m. michalec , acta phys . pol .
* b33 * ( 2002 ) 761 .
f. karsch , nucl .
* 83 - 84 * ( 2000 ) 14 . t. matsui and h. satz , _ phys .
_ * b178 * ( 1986 ) 416 .
m. gadzicki and m.i .
gorenstein , phys .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 4009 .
p. braun - munzinger and j. stachel , phys
b490 * ( 2000 ) 196 .
gorenstein , a.p .
kostyuk , h. stcker and w. greiner , phys . lett .
* b498 * ( 2001 ) 277 , j. phys * g27 * ( 2001 ) l47 .
kostyuk , m.i .
gorenstein , h. stcker and w. greiner , hep - ph/0110269 .
kostyuk , m.i .
gorenstein and w. greiner , phys . lett .
* b519 * ( 2001 ) 207 .
gorenstein _ et al_. , hep - ph/0012292 , phys
b524 * ( 2002 ) 265 .
j. rafelski , phys . lett .
* b62 * ( 1991 ) 333 .
j. rafelski and m. danos , phys . lett . * b97 * 279 ( 1980 ) ; k. redlich and l. turko , z. phys . * c5 * ( 1980 ) 541 ; j. cleymans , k. redlich and e. suhonen , z. phys .
* c51 * ( 1991 ) 137 ; m.i .
gorenstein , m. gadzicki and w. greiner , phys . lett .
* b483 * ( 2000 ) 60 .
abreu _ et al . , _ ( na50 ) , phys . lett . * b410 * ( 1997 ) 327 , * b410 * ( 1997 ) 337 , * b477 * ( 2000 ) 28 * b450 * ( 1999 ) 456 . a.p .
_ et al_. , ( in preparation ) .
h. sorge , e. shuryak and i. zahed , phys . rev
* 79 * ( 1997 ) 2775 .
combridge , nucl . phys .
* b151 * ( 1979 ) 429 .
et al . _ ,
phys . * a10 * ( 1995 ) 2999 .
m. gadzicki , private communication .
eskola , k. kajantie and j. lindfors nucl . phys .
* b323 * ( 1989 ) 37 .
k. a. bugaev , m. gadzicki and m. i. gorenstein , phys . lett .
* b523 * ( 2001 ) 255 ; k. a. bugaev , nucl - th/0112016 . s. bass and a. dumitru , phys .
* c61 * ( 2000 ) 064909 .
d. teaney , j. lauret and e.v .
shuryak , nucl - th/0110037 .
gorenstein , k.a .
bugaev and m. gadzicki , hep - ph/0112197 .
_ et al_. , ( wa97 ) , j. phys .
* g27 * ( 2001 ) 375 .
abreu _ et al_. , ( na50 ) , phys .
b499 * ( 2001 ) 85 . | a recently developed statistical coalescence model of the @xmath0 production is presented .
the na50 data on the @xmath0 suppression pattern and the transverse mass spectra in pb+pb collisions at the sps are analyzed .
the model predictions for the rhic energies are formulated .
the measurements of @xmath0 in au+au collisions at rhic are crucial for disentangling the different scenarios of charmonia formation . * statistical coalescence model * + * of @xmath0 production at the sps and
rhic * + mark i. gorenstein + _ bogolyubov institute for theoretical physics , kiev , ukraine + institut fr theoretische physik , universitt frankfurt , germany + _ |
planetary nebulae ( pne ) are expanding ionized nebulae expelled from asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) stars .
the remnant of the agb star , i.e. , its core , ionizes the nebula as it evolves to become a white dwarf . as the gas expands , its density drops and its expansion starts to be influenced by the ism .
if there is a relative motion between the pn and the ism , the ism signature on the pn structure will emerge first on the nebular side facing the ism , i.e. , the upstream direction , where the ism ram pressure on the nebula is the largest . at late times ,
when the nebula is relatively large and of low density , this type of interaction forms a bow - shaped nebula , e.g. , sh 2 - 216 ( tweedy , martos , & noriega - crespo 1995 ) , kewe 5 ( kerber et al . 1998 ) , kfr 1 ( rauch et al .
2000 ) , and sb 51 ( pn g 357.4 - 07.2 ; beaulieu , dopita , & freeman 1999 ) , sometimes with a long extension of the bow - shaped region on the down stream direction , e.g. abell 35 ( jacoby 1981 ; hollis et al .
since the nebula is large and of low surface brightness at this late stage , telescopes with large fields of view should be used to detect these pne , as was done by xilouris et al .
( 1996 ) and tweedy & kwitter ( 1996 ) in their study of many ancient pne interacting with the ism . due to these and other ( e.g. , borkowski , tsvetanov , & harrington 1993 ; tweedy & kwitter 1994 ; muthu , anandarao , & pottasch 2000 ; kerber et al . 2000 , 2002 )
observational studies , and several theoretical works ( e.g. , borkowski , sarazin , & soker 1990 ; soker , borkowski , & sarazin 1991 , hereafter sbs ; villaver , manchado , & garca - segura 2000 ; dopita et al .
2000 ) the basic physics of this stage of pn - ism interaction is well understood and there are many examples of pne evolving through this stage .
the pn - ism interaction process may be influenced by the ism magnetic field ( e.g. , soker & dgani 1997 ; soker & zucker 1997 ) and several types of instabilities ( e.g. , sbs ; dgani & soker 1994 ; see review by dgani 2000 ) .
of particular interest is the rayleigh - taylor ( rt ) instability , which may fragment the outer halo , hence allowing the ism to stream and interact with nebular material closer to the central star ( dgani & soker 1998 ) . at early stages
the rt instability manifests itself as ` tongues ' located outside , but connected to , the main nebular shell ( e.g. , sbs ; dopita et al .
this is a general type of structure found in simulations of other dense clouds moving through a low density medium ( e.g. , jones , kang , & tregillis 1994 ) . to our best knowledge ,
no such rt ` tongues ' were reported before for pne interacting with the ism .
the only claim for a rt instability at an early stage of pn - ism interaction was made by zucker & soker ( 1993 ; hereafter zs93 ) for ic 4593 . in ic 4593
the nebula is compressed in the upstream direction , such that its density becomes higher , and there is a structure protruding from the nebula in the upstream direction . zs93
term the region which protrudes from the nebula a ` bump ' .
however , in ic 4593 the ` bump ' is blobby , and does not show any large scale internal structure , i.e. , no rt tongues are observed . in the present paper
we report the detection of a structure in the upstream side of the interacting pn ngc 40 ( pn g120.0 + 09.8 ) , which closely resembles the structure of rt instability obtained in numerical simulations .
we focus on the rt instability feature , which following zs93 we term a ` bump ' , although its internal structure reveals features not seen in ic 4593 , and which are predicted by numerical simulations .
it is quite possible that in ngc 40 the interaction process is at an earlier stage than that of ic 4593 .
other properties of ngc 40 are thoroughly studied by meaburn et al .
( 1996 ) , and hence will not be discussed here .
in addition to strengthening the theory of pn - ism interaction , we hope that this first example of a rt instability at very early stages of pn - ism interaction will stimulate further observations in searching for such features .
thirty minute exposures were taken of ngc 40 in two narrow band interference filters with the fan mountain @xmath1 astrometric telescope on the night of december 4 , 2001 .
the two filters are centered at @xmath2 , to isolate [ oiii]@xmath3 emission ( [ oiii ] filter ) , and @xmath4 , to isolate h@xmath5 and [ nii]@xmath6 emission ( h@xmath0 filter ) .
the fwhms ( full width at half maximum ) of the filters are @xmath7 and @xmath8 , respectively , and both filters have a throughput of about @xmath9 .
the detector is a san diego state / site @xmath10 engineering grade ccd , and each pixel has a spatial resolution of @xmath11 .
the images were reduced using the standard procedures of the iraf data reduction software .
bias subtraction , dome flat field correction , trimsec , and biassec were done . as stated above
, we focus only on the outer regions which are dominated by the h@xmath0 and [ nii ] emission , so only the h@xmath0 filter image results will be discussed .
the effective seeing of the h@xmath0 filter image is @xmath12 fwhm and the mean airmass during the exposure was 1.21 .
the idl routine , ` sky ' , was used to determine the value of the sky in units of @xmath13 on a region of the chip that is dominated by background and is free of vignetting effects .
the image was normalized by subtracting the value of the sky .
the subtracted image was then median smoothed by 8 pixels with even interpolation .
the median smoothed , subtracted image has a sky value of @xmath14 .
our results are presented in figures 1a-1e , where the intensity scale is linear .
the rt instability feature is seen on the northwest side of the main ( bright ) nebular shell .
following zs93 we term this region the ` bump ' .
the ram pressure of the ism decelerates the expanding gas facing the ism and flattens the nebula as can be seen in the extended isophotes of figures 1b-1e .
the limb brightened regions of the bump which are attached to the main nebula , and which are termed ` rt - tongues ' , are indicated in figure 1b , as well as the bright clumps that are observed at the front of the bump .
note that the other ` blobs ' and ` filaments ' in the images which are scattered around the main nebula have coherence scales much smaller than the size of the ` bump ' and the flatness to its sides .
such ` blobs ' are expected to be scattered around pne , in particular pne interacting with the ism ( zs93 ) .
the bright blob adjacent to the southwestern edge of the nebula are two close background and/or foreground stars .
figure 1a shows the light profile along a cut through the bump and between the rt - tongues , as indicated in figure 1b .
the cut distinctly shows a minimum at @xmath15 , a sharp rise again when it encounters the clumps , and a return to the background as the cut moves into the surrounding ism .
hints of the rt - tongues are seen in figures 2a and 2c of meaburn et al .
the bent northern jet , a condensation , which may result from the interaction with the ism , and the direction of proper motion are indicated in figure 1d .
note that the condensation ( ` cond ' in fig .
1d ) does not have the point spread function of the known stars in the field .
the proper motion of the central star was measured by the hipparcos mission ( perryman et al .
1997 ) to be @xmath16mas yr@xmath17 , and @xmath18mas yr@xmath17 .
the thick arrow indicates the proper motion , while the two thin arrows indicate the extreme @xmath19 limits of the total proper motion direction . to demonstrate the similarity of the rt - bump , rt - tongues , and flatness , to the structure obtained in 2d numerical simulations , we show in figure 1f the results from sbs , where more details are given
( see also jones et al .
1994 for a very similar rt instability structure ) .
note that the numerical results present the density in the symmetry plane , while the observations are the integrated emission along line of sight through the nebula .
hence , there is projected emission near the symmetry axis of the interaction flow ( tip of the bump ) in the h@xmath0 images , although no dense material is located there in the simulations .
prior to our work , there were two indications for the interaction of ngc 40 with the ism : ( i ) the bent northern jet ( for its detailed structure see meaburn et al .
1996 ) , and ( ii ) condensations ( dense clumps ) and filaments around the nebula , which are thought to be formed from instabilities of the outer low density halo as it interacts with the ism ( zs93 ) .
the proper motion is more or less along the direction expected from the bending angle of the northern jet .
these features remind us of ic 4593 , which has its northern flier ( fast low - ionization emission regions along the symmetry axis ) closer to the central star than the southern flier ( zs93 ; corradi et al .
1996 ) , and condensations outside the main nebula ( zs93 ) .
we were not surprised therefore to find a ` bump ' in the direction of proper motion ( more or less ) , as in ic 4593 ( zs93 ) .
whereas in ic 4593 the bump is only suggestive for a rt instability , here the similarity between the bump and the numerical simulations is obvious . for comparison we present in figure 1f the density contours map in the symmetry plane from the 2d simulations of sbs . in that figure
the nebula is moving upward , with the left edge of the panel being the symmetry axis .
the rt instability and the flatness are clearly seen ; a similar structure with higher numerical resolution , can be seen in the numerical simulations of a dense cloud moving through a low density medium ( jones et al .
1994 , their fig .
we see in ngc 40 ( figs 1b-1e ) both the rt tongues ( which in projection appear as a limb brightened bump ) and the flatness of the nebular edge in the upstream direction ; this flatness results from the deceleration of the nebular material in the upstream side .
we note that the size of the bump is about equal to the deceleration distance of the upstream side , as expected at early stages ( sbs ) .
we conclude that the bump is due to rt instability .
the condition for the development of the rt instability is that the ism density be lower than that of the nebula ; for that the ism should be hotter than the nebula ( sbs ; we follow their analysis ) .
sbs assume that the nebula is at a temperature of @xmath20 , and calculate the cooling time of the hot shocked ism to that temperature ( sbs ) .
the cooling time depends on the relative velocity of the ism and the nebula , and on the density and ionization stage of the ism . for the angular proper motion given in the previous section and a distance of @xmath21 to ngc 40 ( bianchi and grewing , 1987 ) ,
the transverse motion is @xmath22 .
the heliocentric radial velocity of ngc 40 is @xmath23 ( meaburn et al . 1996 ) .
the absolute value of the velocity of ngc 40 relative to the sun is therefore @xmath24 . for a nebular expansion velocity of @xmath25 , and neglecting the ism motion , we find for the relative velocity between the nebular gas and the ism , @xmath26 .
we can safely take then @xmath27 .
we assume that ngc 40 is moving in the warm ionized medium , for which the average hydrogen number density at the location of ngc 40 , namely @xmath28 from the galactic plane , is @xmath29 ( reynolds 1989 ) .
the ism is shocked to a temperature of @xmath30 , from which the cooling time to a temperature of @xmath20 is @xmath31 .
the radius of the ngc 40 ( at the location of the bump ) is @xmath32 , or @xmath33 , assuming a distance of @xmath34 to ngc 40 .
the flow time of the ism along a distance of @xmath35 , and for @xmath36 , is @xmath37 . since @xmath38 ,
the ism has no time to cool and an adiabatic flow , prone to rt instability , commences ( sbs ) .
in addition , at a very early stage , before the nebula is ionized , its temperature is @xmath39 , so even if the ism cools faster down to @xmath20 , its cooling will be slower below that temperature , and the ism will be hotter and less dense than the nebular gas at early stages .
the expansion time of the material in the bump , since it left the central star , is @xmath40 , long enough for the development of a rt instability bump ( sbs ) . to conclude ,
ngc 40 is moving through , and interacting with , the ism .
the motion and indication for this interaction were known previously .
we report for the first time the detection of a structure on the upstream edge of the main nebula which is predicted by numerical simulations , and which is attributed to rt instability at an early stage of the interaction process .
such a rt instability is expected to occur at early stages of the pn - ism interaction under conditions similar to those for ngc 40 .
* acknowledgments : * we thank robert oconnell for valuable comments on the original manuscript .
j. m. was supported by the nasa long term space astrophysics grant nag5 - 6403 .
n. s. was supported by a celerity foundation distinguished visiting scholar grant at the university of virginia , and by a grant from the us - israel binational science foundation .
dopita , m. a. , massaglia , s. , bodo , g. , arnaboldi , m. , & merluzzi , p. 2000 , in asp conf .
199 , asymmetrical planetary nebulae ii : from origins to microstructures , ed .
j. h. kastner , n. soker , & s. rappaport ( san francisco : asp ) , 423 kerber , f. , furlan , e. , rauch , t. , roth , m. 2000 , in asp conf .
199 , asymmetrical planetary nebulae ii : from origins to microstructures , ed .
j. h. kastner , n. soker , & s. rappaport ( san francisco : asp ) , 313 rauch , t. , furlan , e. , kerber , f. , & roth , m. 2000 , in asp conf .
199 , asymmetrical planetary nebulae ii : from origins to microstructures , ed .
j. h. kastner , n. soker , & s. rappaport ( san francisco : asp ) , 341 * fig1 * mosaic figure emphasizing the rayleigh - taylor ( rt ) instability ` bump ' , and its internal structure with the tongues and clumps .
north is up and east is to the left .
these features , which are defined on panel @xmath41 and @xmath42 , can be clearly seen in panels @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
( @xmath45 ) h@xmath0 filter intensity vs. distance from the central star in units of arcsec , and along the radial cut marked on panel @xmath41 .
the intensity scale in the images is linear in units of @xmath13 .
( @xmath41 ) h@xmath0 filter surface brightness contour map of the rt ` bump ' region .
the contours have the values ( same scale as in panel @xmath45 ) of 9 ( dark line ) , 10 ( medium line ) , and 11 ( light line ) .
axes are distance from the central star in arcsec .
( @xmath43 ) gray scale image ( @xmath46 ) .
image is scaled between the values 5 and 50 @xmath13 .
( @xmath42 ) h@xmath0 filter surface brightness contour map of @xmath43 .
the contours have the values of 9 , 10 , 11 , 25 , 200 , 700 , 2000 , and 6000 .
the arrows indicate the direction of the proper motion of the central star .
the bold arrow is the direction measured by hipparcos and the lighter arrows indicate the extreme @xmath19 directions given by the errors in the hipparcos measurement .
` cond ' stands for a condensation .
units on the axes are arcsec .
( @xmath44 ) gray scale of the rt ` bump ' region of @xmath41 .
again , the image is scaled between the values 5 and 50 @xmath13 . ( @xmath47 ) density contour map for an adiabatic simulation of a dense pn shell from soker et al .
the nebula is moving upward in this panel , with the left edge of the panel being the symmetry axis of the flow .
contours marked 0.006 and 0.01 indicate the location of the ism shock front .
units on the axes are @xmath48 cm , and density levels are in units of @xmath49 g cm@xmath17 . | we report the detection of an h@xmath0 emission - line structure in the upstream side of the planetary nebula ngc 40 , which is predicted by numerical simulations , and which is attributed to rayleigh - taylor instability .
such a rayleigh - taylor instability is expected to occur at early stages of the interaction process between the interstellar medium ( ism ) and a fast moving planetary nebula , as is the case for ngc 40 .
we resolved the rayleigh - taylor instability ` tongues ' , as well as the flatness of the nebula around the ` tongues ' , which results from the deceleration by the ism .
-0.5 cm 0.15 cm = 10000 = 24pt # 1#2#3#4 # 1 , _ # 2 _ , * # 3 * , # 4 |
singly deuterated ammonia , nh@xmath0d , was first tentatively detected toward the kleinmann - low nebula in orion @xcite and toward sgr b2 @xcite .
however , due to the molecular richness of these objects , a blending with transitions from other molecular species could not be discarded at that time .
the first unambiguous detection of nh@xmath0d was subsequently performed by @xcite in the cold environment of l183 , s140 and dr21(oh ) at 85 ghz and 110 ghz , thanks to the high spectral resolution of the observations which enabled to resolve the hyperfine structure of the lines . since then
, its centimeter and millimeter rotational transitions have been used as tracers of the physical conditions and chemistry of the molecular gas over a wide range of conditions , ranging from cold prestellar cores ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) to warm star
forming regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in cold environments ,
the deuterium fractionation was derived to be several 10@xmath7 .
such high fractionation ratios are within the values predicted by gas phase models at low temperatures @xcite . in warm environments such as orion kl , the fractionation ratio was derived to be 0.003 by @xcite and interpreted as a possible signature of mantle evaporation .
more recently , nh@xmath0d has been detected at much higher frequencies thanks to herschel . in orion kl @xcite ,
several excited levels of nh@xmath0d up to @xmath8 = 7@xmath9 ( @xmath3 @xmath4 600 k)d is an asymmetric top whose rotational energy structure can be described with the @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 quantum numbers .
alternatively , one may use the pseudo quantum number @xmath13 . in
what follows , we mainly use the @xmath14 notation to describe the rotational energy levels but can alternatively make use of the @xmath8 notation , which is usually employed in astrophysical studies . ]
were detected and the fractionnation ratio was derived to be 0.0068 .
the temperature and density associated to the emitting regions were estimated to t @xmath4 100300k and n(h@xmath0 ) @xmath4 10@xmath15 -10@xmath16 @xmath17 . in order to interpret the nh@xmath0d observations , a key ingredient of the modelling are the collisional rate coefficients .
before the current calculations , the only available rate coefficients considered he as a collisional partner @xcite .
however , it was shown in the case of nd@xmath0h that the rate coefficients with he and h@xmath0 can differ by factors 330 , depending on the transition @xcite .
thus , a dedicated calculation for nh@xmath0d with h@xmath0 is required in order to interpret the observations of this molecule .
indeed , as discussed by @xcite , a simple scaling of the nh@xmath0d / he rate coefficients is insufficient to accurately model the observations , at least under cold dark clouds conditions .
the paper is organized as follow .
the potential energy surface is described in section [ potentiel ] and the collisional dynamics based on this surface in section [ dynamique ] .
we then describe the rate coefficients in section [ rates ] with some emphasis placed on their expected accuracy . in section [ discussion ] , we discuss the current results with respect to other related collisional systems and finally , we present conclusions in section [ conclusion ] .
the rigid - rotor nh@xmath0d - h@xmath0 potential energy surface ( pes ) was derived from the nh@xmath18-h@xmath0 pes computed by @xcite , but in the principal inertia axes of nh@xmath0d .
the scattering equations to be solved ( see below ) are indeed written for a pes described in the frame of the target molecule , here nh@xmath0d . in the original nh@xmath18-h@xmath0 pes ,
the ammonia and hydrogen molecules were both assumed to be rigid , which is justified at temperatures lower than @xmath41000 k. the nh@xmath18 and h@xmath0 geometries were taken at their ground - state average values , as recommended by @xcite in the case of the h@xmath0o - h@xmath0 system .
the rigid - rotor nh@xmath18-h@xmath0 pes was computed at the coupled - cluster ccsd(t ) level with a basis set extrapolation procedure , as described in @xcite where full details can be found . in the present work , the geometry of nh@xmath0d was assumed to be identical to that of nh@xmath18 , i.e. the effect of deuterium substitution on the ammonia geometry was neglected .
this assumption was previously adopted for the similar nd@xmath0h - h@xmath0 system by @xcite .
we note that internal geometry effects are indeed expected to be only moderate ( @xmath19 30% ) at the temperatures investigated here , as shown by @xcite for the d@xmath0o - h@xmath0 system .
the main impact of the isotopic substitution on the nh@xmath18-h@xmath0 pes is therefore the rotation of the principal inertia axes .
we have thus expressed the nh@xmath18-h@xmath0 pes of @xcite in the principal inertia axes of nh@xmath0d .
the transformation can be found in @xcite ( eqs . 2 - 3 ) where the @xmath20 angle is equal to -8.57 degrees for nh@xmath0d , as determined experimentally by @xcite .
the shift of the center of mass was also taken into account : the coordinates of the nh@xmath0d center of mass in the nh@xmath18-h@xmath0 reference frame were found to be @xmath21=0.101312 bohr and @xmath22=-0.032810 bohr , where @xmath21 and @xmath22 were calculated for the ground - state average geometry of nh@xmath18 used by @xcite .
the nh@xmath0d - h@xmath0 pes was generated on a grid of 87 000 points consisting of 3000 random angular configurations combined with 29 intermolecular distances in the range 3 - 15 bohr .
this pes was finally expanded in products of spherical harmonics and rotation matrices , as in @xcite ( see their eq .
4 ) , using a linear least - squares fit procedure .
we selected iteratively all statistical significant terms using the procedure of @xcite applied at all intermolecular distances .
the final expansion included anisotropies up to @xmath23=10 for nh@xmath0d and @xmath24=4 for h@xmath0 , resulting in a total of 210 angular basis functions .
the root mean square residual was found to be lower than 1 @xmath25 for intermonomer separations @xmath26 larger than 5 bohr , with a corresponding mean error on the expansion coefficients smaller than 1 @xmath25 .
in order to describe the nh@xmath0d energy structure , we adopted the same approach than @xcite , i.e. we assumed that nh@xmath0d is a rigid rotor and we neglected the inversion motion corresponding to the tunneling of the nitrogen atom through the h@xmath0d plane .
the spectroscopic constants , adapted from the cdms catalogue @xcite and from @xcite , are given in table 2 of @xcite .
as outlined in @xcite , neglecting the inversion motion leads to neglecting the difference between the ortho and para states of nh@xmath0d , which are thus treated as degenerate . indeed , by considering the inversion motion , every rotational state would be split in two states which are either symmetric or anti
symmetric under exchange of the protons . by combining the symmetry of each state with the symmetry of the nuclear wave functions
, each state will either correspond to an ortho or para state to ensure that the overall wavefunction is anti
symmetric under the exchange operation .
since the collisional transitions are only possible within a given symmetry , the treatment of the collisional dynamics would be essentially similar for each species , except for the slight differences of energy between the ortho and para states , which is of the order of @xmath40.4 @xmath25 independently of the rotational state @xcite .
hence , by neglecting the inversion motion , we obtain a set of rate coefficients which applies to both the ortho and para symmetries of nh@xmath0d .
finally , we also considered h@xmath0 as a rigid rotor and adopted a rotational constant of 59.2817 @xmath25 @xcite .
the reduced mass of the collisional system is @xmath27 = 1.812998990 amu . in order to solve the collisional dynamics
, we used the molscat code .
since nh@xmath0d is observed in warm media and since the transitions detected include levels up to @xmath28 , our goal was set accordingly .
we performed the calculations in order to provide rate coefficients for the nh@xmath0d energy levels up to @xmath2 and for the temperature range @xmath5k . a first step consisted of adjusting the convergence of the dynamical calculations for these levels and for total energies up to @xmath29@xmath43000 @xmath25 .
we thus performed a few calculations at some specific values of the total energy for which we determined the number of nh@xmath0d rotational energy levels , as well as the integration step required to insure a convergence better than 1% below 530 @xmath25 and better than 5% above this threshold .
these test calculations are summarized in fig .
[ fig : param - conv ] and the parameters used for each energy range are also indicated .
we found that including the @xmath30 level of para
h@xmath0 in the dynamical calculations had a large impact on the resulting cross sections .
indeed , at some specific energies , we found that the cross sections obtained with the @xmath31 or @xmath1 basis can differ by up to a factor 7 .
an example of the influence of the @xmath30 energy level of h@xmath0 on the cross sections is given in fig .
[ fig : method ] .
this figure will be further discussed below .
.step between the consecutive total energies used to characterize the cross sections . [
cols="^,^",options="header " , ] [ table : rates_j2=0 - 0 ] as outlined in section [ dynamique ] , the transitions @xmath32 where @xmath33 ranges from @xmath34 to @xmath35 with a step of 2 are predicted to be equal to zero with the cs formalism . using the available cc calculations , we are however able to calculate these rate coefficients for the transitions with @xmath36 and up to 300 k with a reasonable accuracy ( see appendix b ) .
since the current set of rate coefficients considers levels up to @xmath2 , it is necessary to estimate the rate coefficients for the transitions that connect the fundamental energy level to the levels with @xmath37 which are predicted to be null with the cs formalism .
to do so , we extrapolate the behaviour observed for the rates with levels such that @xmath38 and derive the following expression : @xmath39 we can expect large errors of the corresponding rate coefficients , typically of a factor 10 or higher , since this expression is established on the basis of a poor statistics .
however , since the corresponding rate coefficients should play only a minor role in the pumping scheme , these uncertainties should not have noticeable consequences on the predicted line intensities . in any astrophysical application
, this assumption should however be checked .
for example , as was done in @xcite , the sensitivity of the line intensities to the corresponding rate coefficients can be assessed by considering randomly scaled values for these rates around their nominal value .
the accuracy of the current rate coefficients is limited by the following assumptions
. a first source of error comes from the neglect of the inversion motion .
however , we expect that this hypothesis should only have marginal effects on the rate coefficients , at least in comparison to the other sources of error .
a second limitation comes from the fact that the pes was calculated for the equilibrium geometry of the nh@xmath18 molecule .
the pes was corrected for the displacement of the center of mass between nh@xmath18 and nh@xmath0d , but the variation of the bond length from nh to nd was neglected .
the effect introduced by taking into account the vibrationally averaged geometry of nh@xmath0d , rather than taking the nh@xmath18 internal geometry , can lead to noticeable effects .
such a modification was tested for d@xmath0o by @xcite , where rate coefficients for this isotopologue were calculated using the h@xmath0o internal geometry .
differences of the order of 30% were found and we might expect differences of the same order for nh@xmath0d .
finally , a third source of error resides in the use of the cs formalism at high temperatures . as described in sec .
[ dynamique ] and in appendix a , the cs calculations were scaled according to some reference calculations performed with the cc formalism . however
, an inherent limitation of this procedure comes from the uncertainty introduced by the scattering of the ratios which are due to the resonances .
moreover , the ratios were extrapolated at the highest energies . finally , for the transitions that involve energy levels higher than the @xmath40 level , we directly computed the rate coefficients using the original cs cross sections . in order to have an estimate of the error introduced in the rate coefficients due to the use of the cs formalism , we compared the rate coefficients calculated with the scaled cs cross sections ( noted @xmath41 ) to the rates calculated with the unscaled cross sections ( noted @xmath42 ) .
the minimum and maximum values of the ratios @xmath43 found in the range @xmath5 k are reported in the upper panel of fig . [
fig : accuracy ] for all the de - excitation transitions up to @xmath44 .
in the lower panel of this figure , we report the same quantities , but for levels up to @xmath6 and for the temperature range @xmath45 k. from this figure , it can be seen that for the transitions that involve levels up to the @xmath46 ( e@xmath475 @xmath25 ) , the scaled and unscaled rate coefficients differ by less than 20% ( upper panel ) . on the other hand , for higher energy levels , the differences can be as high as a factor @xmath42 but most of the transitions ( 93% of the 253 transitions considered here ) show differences below a factor 1.3 .
we note that the reason why the lowest energy levels are less affected by the scaling of the cross sections comes from the fact that a larger part of the grid correspond to cc calculations for these levels .
finally , given the variations observed for the @xmath43 ratios , we can expect that the transitions that involve an energy level above @xmath6 will have a typical accuracy of 30% , since these transitions are directly calculated from the cs cross sections .
+ k , between the scaled and unscaled collisional rate coefficients for the levels up to @xmath44 .
the x axis gives the final level of the de excitation collisional rate coefficient .
for each final level , the variations are given for all the de excitation rates , ordered by increasing value of the upper energy level state . * lower panel * : same as the upper panel but for the transitions which consider levels up to @xmath6 and for the temperature range @xmath45 k. ] to summarize the previous considerations , considering the current pes , we expect that the current rate coefficients will be accurate within 5% for the transitions up to @xmath6 . for higher energy levels , the accuracy should be of the order of 30% .
this holds true for all transitions except for the transitions @xmath32 where @xmath33 ranges from @xmath34 to @xmath35 with a step of 2 . for these transitions and for the levels
such that @xmath47 , the rates should be accurate to within 30% . for higher levels , i.e. with @xmath37 , we can expect an error up to a factor 10 in the rate coefficients .
most importantly , a dominant source of error resides in the fact that the pes was calculated for a molecular geometry which corresponds to the nh@xmath18 internal geometry .
thus , we might expect an additional 30% uncertainty on the rate coefficients @xcite .
the previous discussion dealt with rate coefficients where para
h@xmath0 was restricted to its fundamental state @xmath31 .
such rate coefficients are enough to tackle astrophysical applications that deal with cold media ( i.e. @xmath48 ) . however ,
at higher gas temperatures , we expect a larger fraction of the h@xmath0 molecules in excited states ( @xmath49 ) . as discussed in sec .
[ dynamique ] , the cross sections with @xmath50 are of larger magnitude than the cross sections associated with the @xmath51 transitions .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig : ratio_j2=2 ] where we represent the ratio of the rate coefficients with @xmath50 to that with @xmath51 , for temperatures of 10 and 300k . on average , the rate coefficients with @xmath50 are of larger magnitude , with an average ratio slightly increasing from 2 to 2.4 with temperature increasing from 10k to 300k . however , as can be seen from fig .
[ fig : ratio_j2=2 ] , the variation in magnitude of the rate coefficient depends on the absolute magnitude of the rate , the variation being larger for the rates of lower magnitude .
moreover , as seen in fig .
[ fig : ratio_j2=2 ] , there is a large scatter of the ratios . over the rate with @xmath51 , as a function of the magnitude of the rate coefficients associated to the para
h@xmath0 fundamental state .
the ratios are given at t= 10 k ( lower panel ) and t = 300k ( upper panel ) . ]
thus , by varying the relative populations of the fundamental and first h@xmath0 excited states , the number of collisionnally induced events will be modified accordingly , i.e. the number of events becomes larger with increasing the fractional abundance of the first excited state . to take this effect into account
, we define thermalized rate coefficients , following the definition given in @xcite ( i.e. eq . ( 4 ) in this reference ) .
finally , we stress that in hot media , the relevant collisional partner will be ortho
h@xmath0 rather than para h@xmath0 and in such a case , it should be necessary to calculate the corresponding rate coefficients .
however , in the case of the h@xmath0o / h@xmath0 collisional system it was found that the effective rate coefficients for @xmath30 and @xmath52 agree within @xmath430% @xcite .
more generally , these studies showed that apart from the rate coefficients in @xmath31 , all the effective rate coefficients with @xmath49 are qualitatively similar , independently of the h@xmath0 symmetry .
as a consequence , in astrophysical applications , the thermalized rate coefficients with ortho h@xmath0 or para
h@xmath0 lead to similar line intensities at high temperatures @xcite . to conclude
, this means that in principle , the rate coefficients with @xmath50 can serve as a template to emulate the rate coefficients of ortho
h@xmath0 ( @xmath53 ) .
we checked this assumption by performing a few calculations with ortho
h@xmath0 as a collisional partner . in fig .
[ fig : xs_j2=2 ] , we compare the cross sections of the @xmath54 transition associated with either @xmath50 or @xmath53 .
it can be seen that these two cross sections are qualitatively similar for the energy range considered here .
such an agreement is also found on a more general basis .
considering a statistics over the @xmath55 transitions , we obtained that , whatever the energy , the mean value @xmath27 of the ratios @xmath56 is @xmath57 , with a standard deviation @xmath58 that vary with energy in the range @xmath59 . for each energy , @xmath470% of the transitions
vary by less than @xmath60 around @xmath27 and @xmath495% of the transitions are within @xmath61 .
thus , this confirms that the rate coefficients in @xmath50 are a good approximation for the ortho h@xmath0 rate coefficients .
prior to this work , the only available rate coefficients for nh@xmath0d were calculated with he as a collisional partner .
rate coefficients with he are often used as a template to estimate the rate coefficients with h@xmath0 .
however , for many molecules , large differences exist and the rates do not scale accordingly to the factor @xmath41.4 deduced from the difference in the reduced masses of the two colliding systems . concerning the deuterated isotopologues of ammonia , such a conclusion was already reached for nd@xmath0h .
indeed , for this particular isotopologue , the he and h@xmath0 rate coefficients were found to vary by factors in the range 330 @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : comp - he ] , we give the ratios of the current nh@xmath0d / h@xmath0 rate coefficients with the rates calculated with he @xcite , as a function of the magnitude of the h@xmath0 rate coefficients and for temperatures of t = 10k and t = 100k .
the comparison concerns the transitions that involve levels up to @xmath62 ( the highest level considered in * ? ? ?
* ) . from this figure
, it appears that the h@xmath0 and he rate coefficients show large variations , as expected from the previous studies of nd@xmath0h . at t = 10k ,
the ratios are in the range 1100 .
moreover , it appears that the largest differences are also found for the largest rate coefficients . at higher temperatures ,
we obtain the same trend except that the range of variations is reduced .
for example , at t = 100k , the ratios for the lowest rate coefficients are around 1 while they are around 20 for the highest rates .
d / h@xmath0 rate coefficients with the rates calculated with he as a collisional partner @xcite . ]
finally , one may wonder if it is possible to infer the rate coefficients of singly deuterated ammonia from the rates of doubly deuterated ammonia , or vice versa .
a direct comparison of the current rates with the values reported by @xcite for nd@xmath0h / h@xmath0 would not be totally meaningful , at least quantitatively , since in the latter study , the dynamical calculations were performed with a @xmath63 = 0 basis for h@xmath0 . as discussed in sec .
[ dynamique ] , considering a @xmath63 = 0,2 basis for h@xmath0 can induce variations as large as a factor @xmath47 and the magnitude of the effects are presumably similar for nd@xmath0h .
we thus performed a few additional calculations for the nd@xmath0h / h@xmath0 system .
these calculations are similar to the ones presented in @xcite except for the h@xmath0 basis which is now set to @xmath64 . in fig .
[ fig : comp_nh2d - nd2h ] , we compare the cross sections of nh@xmath0d and nd@xmath0h for the six de excitation transitions possible when considering the levels up to @xmath65 . from this figure
, it appears that on the average , the cross sections are of the same order of magnitude for the two colliding systems .
the differences are definitely lower than those found with he as a collisional partner . however , above 5 @xmath25 , differences of a factor @xmath43 or higher may occur when considering individual transitions .
this implies that a dedicated calculation is necessary to infer accurate rate coefficients for a particular isotopologue .
furthermore , given the differences obtained between the rate coefficients calculated with h@xmath0 or he , the current comparison shows that in the absence of a dedicated calculation , the rate coefficients of a deuterated isotopologue should be preferentially taken from another isotopologue with the same symmetry rather than scaled from the he rates . as an example , to emulate the cd@xmath0h / h@xmath0 rate coefficients , it should be more accurate to take the ch@xmath0d / h@xmath0 rate coefficients than the cd@xmath0h / he one .
d ( red ) and nd@xmath0h ( black ) cross sections calculated with h@xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) . ]
we reported the calculation of collisional rate coefficients for the nh@xmath0d / h@xmath0 system for nh@xmath0d rotational energy levels up to @xmath2 ( @xmath66k ) and for temperatures in the range t = 5300k .
these rate coefficients will be made available through the basecol @xcite and lamda @xcite databases .
the current rate coefficients were calculated by adapting the nh@xmath18 / h@xmath0 potential energy surface presented in @xcite .
the dynamical calculations were performed at the close - coupling level at low total energy ( @xmath67 @xmath25 ) and with the coupled states formalism at higher energies . for the levels up to @xmath6 the cs cross sections were scaled according to some reference points performed with the accurate cc formalism . for these transitions and for the current pes ,
the accuracy of the rate coefficients is expected to be of the order of 5% . for higher energy levels ,
the accuracy is limited by the use of the cs formalism , and the corresponding rate coefficients are expected to be accurate within 30% .
these uncertainties concern all the transitions except the @xmath32 transitions with @xmath14 varying from @xmath68 to @xmath69 in a step of two . for these latter transitions
, we expect the rate coefficients to be accurate within 30% for the levels with @xmath70 while for the levels such that @xmath37 , the rate coefficients have uncertainties of the order of a factor 10 .
we note that these errors only consider the accuracy of the dynamical calculations and do no take into account other sources of uncertainty like the accuracy of the pes or the neglecting of the inversion motion . for what concerns the pes
, we might expect an additional 30% uncertainty on the rate coefficients , which is to be added in quadrature to the previously mentioned uncertainties , since the current pes was calculated for an internal geometry suitable to nh@xmath18 .
all ( or most of ) the computations presented in this paper were performed using the ciment infrastructure ( https://ciment.ujf-grenoble.fr ) , which is supported by the rhne - alpes region ( grant cper07_13 cira : http://www.ci-ra.org ) .
support for this work was provided by nasa ( _ herschel _ ot funding ) through an award issued by jpl / caltech .
this work has been supported by the agence nationale de la recherche ( anr - hydrides ) , contract anr-12-bs05 - 0011 - 01 and by the cnrs national program `` physico - chimie du milieu interstellaire '' .
99 busquet , g. , palau , a. , estalella , r. , et al .
2010 , a&a , 517 , l6 cohen , e. a. , & pickett , h. m. 1982 , journal of molecular spectroscopy , 93 , 83 coudert , l. , valentin , a. , & henry , l. 1986 , journal of molecular spectroscopy , 120 , 185 coudert , l. h. , & roueff , e. 2006 , a&a , 449 , 855 daniel , f. , dubernet , m .-
l . , pacaud , f. , & grosjean , a. 2010 , a&a , 517 , a13 daniel , f. , dubernet , m .-
l . , & grosjean , a. 2011 , a&a , 536 , a76 daniel , f. , goicoechea , j. r. , cernicharo , j. , dubernet , m .-
l . , & faure , a. 2012 , a&a , 547 , a81 daniel , f. , grin , m. , roueff , e. , et al .
2013 , a&a , 560 , a3 dubernet , m .-
, daniel , f. , grosjean , a. , & lin , c. y. 2009 , a&a , 497 , 911 dubernet , m .-
l . , alexander , m. h. , ba , y. a. , et al .
2013 , a&a , 553 , a50 faure , a. , valiron , p. , wernli , m. , et al .
2005 , jcp , 122 , 221102 hatchell , j. 2003 , a&a , 403 , l25 heil , t. g. , kouri , d. j. , & green , s. 1978 , jcp , 68 , 2562 huber , k. p. , herzberg , g. , molecular spectra and molecular structure iv .
constants of diatomic molecules , van nostrand , new york , 1979 machin , l. , & roueff , e. 2006 , a&a , 460 , 953 machin , l. , & roueff , e. 2007 , a&a , 465 , 647 maret , s. , faure , a. , scifoni , e. , & wiesenfeld , l. 2009 , mnras , 399 , 425 mcguire , p. , & kouri , d. j. 1974 , jcp , 60 , 2488 mller , h. s. p. , thorwirth , s. , roth , d. a. , & winnewisser , g. 2001 , a&a , 370 , l49 neill , j. l. , crockett , n. r. , bergin , e. a. , pearson , j. c. , & xu , l .- h . 2013 , apj , 777 , 85 olberg , m. , bester , m. , rau , g. , et al .
1985 , a&a , 142 , l1 pillai , t. , wyrowski , f. , hatchell , j. , gibb , a. g. , & thompson , m. a. 2007 , a&a , 467 , 207 rist , c. & faure , a. , 2011 , j. math .
, 50 , 588 rodriguez kuiper , e. n. , kuiper , t. b. h. , & zuckerman , b. 1978 , apjl , 219 , l49 roueff , e. , lis , d. c. , van der tak , f. f. s. , gerin , m. , & goldsmith , p. f. 2005 , a&a , 438 , 585 saito , s. , ozeki , h. , ohishi , m. , & yamamoto , s. 2000 , apj , 535 , 227 schier , f. l. , van der tak , f. f. s. , van dishoeck , e. f. , & black , j. h. 2005 , a&a , 432 , 369 scribano , y. , faure , a. , & wiesenfeld , l. 2010 , jcp , 133 , 231105 shah , r. y. , & wootten , a. 2001 , apj , 554 , 933 tin , s. , roueff , e. , falgarone , e. , gerin , m. , & pineau des forts , g. 2000 , a&a , 356 , 1039 turner , b. e. , zuckerman , b. , morris , m. , & palmer , p. 1978 , apjl , 219 , l43 walmsley , c. m. , hermsen , w. , henkel , c. , mauersberger , r. , & wilson , t. l. 1987 , a&a , 172 , 311 wiesenfeld , l. , scifoni , e. , faure , a. , & roueff , e. 2011 , mnras , 413 , 509 wiesenfeld , l. , & faure , a. 2013 , mnras , 432 , 2573
in order to obtain accurate cross sections , we scaled the cs cross sections according to a few calculations performed with the cc formalism .
these cc calculations were performed for total energies in the range 110 @xmath25 @xmath71 e @xmath71 250 @xmath25 .
the ratio of the cc and cs cross sections is reported in fig .
[ fig : scaling ] for a few transitions . in order to correct the cs cross sections
, we performed an analytical fit of the ratio and to that purpose , we used two fitting functions : @xmath72 where @xmath73 corresponds to the total energy .
the latter functional form was used to reproduce the oscillating behaviour seen in some transitions ( like e.g. the transitions @xmath74@xmath75 , @xmath76@xmath75 or @xmath76@xmath77 shown in fig .
[ fig : scaling ] ) .
the choice of the functional form is made automatically , and for a given transition the function @xmath78 is selected as soon as the @xmath79 obtained with this function is lower by at least a factor 3 by comparison to the @xmath79 obtained with the function @xmath80 . considering the behaviour of the ratios reported in fig .
[ fig : scaling ] , it appears that the ratios depend on the total energy and , in most cases , tend to get close to 1 at the highest energies .
since we are interested in scaling the cross sections up to @xmath4 3000 @xmath25 , we extrapolate the ratios at energies higher than 250 @xmath25 .
to do so , we proceed as follow .
we first fit a linear function using the ratios obtained at the highest energies .
this leads to two possible behaviours depending on the energy where the resulting line crosses the @xmath81 axis ( denoted @xmath82 in what follows ) . in the first case , x@xmath83 @xmath84 250 @xmath25 , and
we then use the @xmath80 functional form to extrapolate the ratios at high energy . in the fitting procedure
, we put as an additional constraint that the ratio is 1 at @xmath85 . above @xmath86 ,
the ratio is set to one . in the second case , x@xmath83 @xmath71 250 @xmath25 . in this case
, we fix the ratio above 250 @xmath25 and keep the value obtained at this latest energy . this extrapolation procedure
thus gives the function @xmath87 .
these two cases are illustrated in fig .
[ fig : extrapol ] where we show the result of the fitting procedure for the @xmath88 transition ( case 1 ) and @xmath89 transition ( case 2 ) .
finally , to insure the continuity between the two fitting functions , we define the function @xmath90 , which gives the correction of the cs cross sections in the range 110 @xmath71 e @xmath71 3000 @xmath25 : @xmath91 where @xmath92 is a weighting function that vary linearly between 0 and 1 in the range 170 @xmath71 e @xmath71 250 @xmath25 .
the resulting fit is shown in fig .
[ fig : scaling ] for a few transitions which are characteristic of the behaviour observed on the whole sample of transitions .
as outlined in section [ dynamique ] and [ rates ] , the transitions @xmath32 where @xmath33 ranges from @xmath34 to @xmath35 in a step of 2 are predicted to be equal to zero with the cs formalism . since we performed cc calculations below 110 @xmath25 with some additional points between 110 and 250 @xmath25 , we are however able to calculate the rate coefficients for a few of these transitions and up to 300 k , despite the lack of calculated points above 250 @xmath25 .
this is due to the fact that the corresponding cross sections decrease sharply with the kinetic energy .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : ratios_rates ] for the @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath95 transitions . , @xmath94 and @xmath95 transitions as a function of the total energy .
the plain curves correspond to an extrapolation of these cross section based on a polynomial fit .
the dashed curves , which assume constant values above 250 @xmath25 , would correspond to an upper limit of the cross sections at high energies .
the lower panel give the ratios of the rate coefficients obtained with the two extrapolations considered in the upper panel ( same color code ) . ]
the upper panel in this figure shows the available cc points as well as two possible extrapolations of the cross sections above 250 @xmath25 .
the first extrapolation is obtained using a polynomial fit of the cc cross sections ( plain curves ) while the second way of extrapolating takes a constant value for the cross sections above a total energy of 250 @xmath25 ( dashed curves ) .
these two limiting cases seem reasonable in view of the overall behaviour of the cross sections shown in fig .
[ fig : cs_null ] . using these two extrapolations
, we then calculated the corresponding rate coefficients for @xmath5 k and their ratios are indicated in the bottom panel of fig .
[ fig : ratios_rates ] .
it can be seen that for these transitions , the rate coefficients are identical , within 2% , below @xmath96 k. for larger temperatures , we obtain larger differences , the discrepancies being the highest at 300 k. however , the variations are always below 25% and this conclusion holds true for the 7 transitions that consider the levels below the @xmath97 level .
since the current set of rate coefficients considers levels up to @xmath98 , it is necessary to complete the current set .
to do so , we extrapolate the behaviour observed for the rates with levels such that @xmath38 . in fig .
[ fig : extrapol_cs - null ] , we show the various rate coefficients calculated for the levels up to @xmath44 .
first , as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : cs_null ] , the rate coefficients associated with the transitions predicted to be null with the cs formalism are systematically of lower magnitude than the rates of the other transitions .
thus , they should presumably play a minor role in the radiative transfer calculations .
moreover , all these transitions show a similar trend with temperature and are roughly proportional . as a consequence , it is possible to mimic the rate of a given transition using the rate coefficient , for example , of the @xmath93 transition .
the dotted curves in fig .
[ fig : extrapol_cs - null ] , for the transitions from j = 2 and j = 3 , are approximated in this way by using the analytical expressions : @xmath99 it can be seen in fig .
[ fig : extrapol_cs - null ] that this simple scaling of the @xmath93 rate coefficient can reproduce qualitatively the rate coefficients directly obtained from the integration of the cross sections ( dashed curves ) . from this trend , we can generalize the above equations and the resulting expression corresponds to eq .
( 1 ) of sections [ rates ] .
( lower panel ) , @xmath100 ( middle panel ) and @xmath101 ( upper panel ) to the fundamental energy level .
the transitions for which the cs formalism predict non null rate coefficients are indicated in plain curves . for the other transition
for which the cs formalism predict null cross sections , the dashed curves correspond to the rate coefficients calculated from the available cc points . in the latter case , for the transitions from @xmath100 and @xmath101
, we also show rate coefficients which are scaled from the @xmath93 transition ( dotted curves ) . ] | the availability of collisional rate coefficients with h@xmath0 is a pre - requisite for interpretation of observations of molecules whose energy levels are populated under non local thermodynamical equilibrium conditions . in the current study , we present collisional rate coefficients for the nh@xmath0d / para h@xmath0(@xmath1 ) collisional system , for energy levels up to @xmath2 ( @xmath3@xmath4735 k ) and for gas temperatures in the range @xmath5k .
the cross sections are obtained using the essentially exact close coupling ( cc ) formalism at low energy and at the highest energies , we used the coupled states ( cs ) approximation . for the energy levels up to @xmath6 ( @xmath3@xmath4215 k ) ,
the cross sections obtained through the cs formalism are scaled according to a few cc reference points .
these reference points are subsequently used to estimate the accuracy of the rate coefficients for higher levels , which is mainly limited by the use of the cs formalism .
considering the current potential energy surface , the rate coefficients are thus expected to be accurate to within 5% for the levels below @xmath6 , while we estimate an accuracy of 30% for higher levels .
[ firstpage ] molecular data molecular processes
scattering |
the 20th century is well known for its critical works of kuhn , popper , lakatos and feyerabend that tried to build models of how the science should work or to show how it does in fact work . in the same , owing to the entrance into era of overwhelming information it was possible to tackle this problem quantitatively
@xcite , pointing out specific phenomena observed in science .
several studies are bound to answer such questions like `` how to measure who the best scientist is ? '' @xcite or try to simulate the process of paradigms shifts @xcite . in this study , we make use of complex networks tools @xcite to show how this issue is resolved at the level of scientific institutions ( i.e. , universities ) , to be more specific ( i ) what is the correlation between university rank and the number of papers in a specific discipline and ( ii ) what are the components of the scientific collaborations .
in order to estimate the correlations between university rankings and scientific productivity we had to identify two different sources of data : ( i ) first devoted to the university ranking with at least 10 years activity , ( ii ) second connected to actual bibliographic information , in particular complying with the following rules : ( 1 ) allowing to view categories of publications,(2 ) allowing to view address of the publication , ( 3 ) allowing to view year of publication .
the lists of top hundred universities were downloaded from two services : academic ranking of world universities - later referred to as arwu and qs world university ranking - later referred to as qs .
the rationale behind choosing two rankings that follow different rules was to check the robustness of the performed analysis .
after preliminary analysis , we have chosen the service web of science as a data source for obtaining the information on citations .
for one institution the average number of publications ranges between few to dozens of thousands of publications . as a result
each university has two tables containing the following fields : ( i ) published ( date of publication),(ii ) i d ( reference to the second table),(iii ) subject category ( category of publications),(iv ) language . the key information used in this report is the subject category of the published paper ( we will refer to it later as to simply _ category _ ) we start the analysis with the estimation of correlation reflecting the dependence of the number of papers a university has published on its rank in the list . to be more precise , for each of 180 categories we build a 100 by 2 matrix , where the first row gives ranks @xmath0 of all universities in this category and the second one gathers the number of papers @xmath1 published in this category by the given university . as one of the variables is already given in the form of rank we decided to use spearman s rank correlation coefficient @xmath2 as the measure of dependence between @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
the results are gathered in table [ tab : all ] together with the total number of papers in the given category and the statistical significance of the test .
it is of use to examine the relation between the size of the category , measured by the number of papers @xmath5 belonging to it and the above mentioned correlation coefficient @xmath2 .
those results are shown in fig .
[ fig : rho ] giving the evidence that lower correlation ( i.e. , larger number of papers following higher rank ) is in general characteristic for categories with large total number of papers .
moreover , the correlation for such categories are statistically significant . here , we would like to check the hypothesis of categorical separation of science .
it is our belief , that certain categories ten to `` glue together '' the scientists working in them . in other words ,
the possibility of interdisciplinary research is not that high as one would expect it to be . in order to test this assumption
we we performed the principal component analysis ( pca ) for 10 most prominent categories ( in sense of the total number of papers ) . as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : pca]a , the first three principal components explain 90% of variability in the data , so the analysis can be restricted just to them .
further , by plotting 2nd component vs 1st ( fig .
[ fig : pca]b ) and 3rd component vs. 2nd ( fig .
[ fig : pca]c ) we can identify the main directions of the dataset . in fig .
[ fig : pca]b we have biochemistry , biology , neuroscience , medicine and psychology in the positive part of x - axis while chemistry , physics , materials science , engineering and computer science are in negative part of this axis . in
can thus mean that the 1st component divides the categories into technical sciences ( negative values ) and medicine - related ones ( positive values ) .
the 2nd component is much harder to be identified a rough estimate could link positive axis with _ fundamental sciences _ as we have physics , chemistry and biology .
finally there is a clear interpretation as to the 3rd component the only significant positive value is connected to physics .
apart from the categorical point of view we can also consider university quality by analyzing the direct connections between universities @xmath6 and @xmath7 on the basis of the collaboration matrix @xmath8 where the element @xmath8 gives the number of common publications of institutions @xmath6 and @xmath7 .
the principal concept of the network analysis is depicted in fig .
[ fig : sch1 ] . using 100 highest ranked universities , for each of them ( @xmath9 ) we search for its publications @xmath10 . then
, if among the co - authors of @xmath11 there is any that comes from either of the universities @xmath12 a link of weight @xmath13 between those universities ( e.g , @xmath14 and @xmath15 ) is established .
the weight is increased by one each time @xmath15 is found among the following publications of @xmath14 . finally the weight of the link between nodes @xmath14 and @xmath15 is just the number of their common publications ( as seen in the database ) . [ [ weights - probability - distribution ] ] weights probability distribution + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the first , fundamental quantity to be computed is the probability distribution of weights @xmath16 giving the idea about the diversity of number of publications between universities .
figure [ fig : pw ] presents @xmath16 for raw data ( black circles ) as well as for the logarithmically binned ones ( with the base @xmath17 , red - filled circles ) .
the plot suggests that the majority of weights can be found for w between 1 and 10 - there a plateau can be clearly seen .
however , there is still a clear pattern for the remaining part even for weights as large as @xmath18 that could be presumably fitted by a power - law function .
however it is possible to fit a full - range log - normal function ( red curve ) @xmath19 with the parameters @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( values obtained by a maximum - likelihood fitting ) .
however , the kolmogorov - smirnov goodness - of - fit test accepts the hypothesis that the data points come from the distribution described by ( [ eq : pw ] ) for relatively low level of significance ( @xmath22 ) .
the result is similar to this obtained in performing this search for consecutive universities from the ranking we obtain a fully connected network of all 100 universities with links denoting the number of common publications . [ [ dependence - of - edge - width - on - node - strength ] ] dependence of edge width on node strength + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + an interesting point of the further analysis is to test if the strength of the university , measured as the total number of its publications with other universities from the ranking influence the affinity of one university to link to another one . more precisely , we shall test what is dependence of the weight @xmath23 between universities @xmath24 and @xmath25 on the product of their strengths @xmath26 . a log - log scatter - plot of this relation for all pairs of universities
is shown in fig .
[ fig : wsasb]a with black circles .
it brings clear evidence that the larger is the product of universities strengths the higher is the number of common publications between them . by performing a logarithmic binning ( red - filled circles )
it is possible to analyze the specific form of the relation .
the outcome is presented in fig .
[ fig : wsasb]b , where two fits are shown : a linear one ( blue line , slope @xmath27 and negligible intercept ) and power - law one ( red dotted line , exponent @xmath28 ) . the linear fitting has the @xmath29 value of 0.99 while the power - law one 0.94 .
taking into account those value as well as close to 1 exponent of the power - law fitting it is reasonable to assume that the average weight between universities characterized by strengths ( number of publications ) @xmath30 and @xmath31 is given by the relation @xmath32 equation ( [ eq : wab ] ) can serve as a kind of predictor for estimating a possible level of cooperation between two universities .
also , observed deviations from this law could indicate either a presence of outliers in a given dataset or invalid data , thus eq . ( [ eq : wab ] ) might be useful as a first - step verification procedure of the examined data .
[ [ weight - threshold ] ] weight threshold + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + following analysis will use the concept of weight threshold @xcite depicted in fig .
[ fig : sch2 ] .
let us take the original network of 5 fully connected universities from fig .
[ fig : sch2]a .
let us assume now that we are interested in constructing an unweighted network that would take into account only the connections with weight higher than a certain threshold weight @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) . a possible outcome of this procedure is presented in fig .
[ fig : sch2]b - all the links with @xmath35 are omitted and as a result we obtain a network where links indicate only connections between nodes ( i.e. , they do not bear any value ) . using weight threshold as a parameter it is possible to obtain several unweighted networks - for each value of @xmath33 in the range @xmath36 we get a different network @xmath37
whose structure is determined only by @xmath33 .
then , for each of these networks it is possible to compute standard network quantities : ( i ) number of nodes @xmath5 that have a at least one link ( i.e. , nodes with degree @xmath38 are not taken into account ) , ( ii ) number of edges ( links ) @xmath39 between the nodes,(iii ) clustering coefficient @xmath40 , ( iv ) assortativity coefficient @xmath3 ( v ) entropy @xmath41 of node degree probability distribution and ( vi ) the average shortest path @xmath42 ( see materials and methods for details ) .
[ [ network - observables - as - function - of - weight - threshold ] ] network observables as function of weight threshold + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + figure [ fig : allw ] gathers the plots of the above described network parameters as a function of @xmath33 .
first , as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : allw]a , the number of nodes @xmath5 is a linearly decreasing function of the weight threshold @xmath33 .
the number edges @xmath39 decreases even faster - for @xmath43 it follows an exponential function ( fig .
[ fig : allw]b ) . similarly to @xmath44
the clustering coefficient also drops down linearly with the weight threshold ( fig .
[ fig : allw]c ) , although several small jumps over the trend can be seen .
the most interesting is the behaviour of @xmath45 shown in figure 5d : the coefficient starts with @xmath46 , while for larger thresholds it crosses @xmath47 and for @xmath33 in range @xmath48 $ ] it takes its maximal value .
then it once again drops down below zero reaching @xmath49 for @xmath33 around 1000 .
finally it increases toward zero for large @xmath33 .
a non - monotonic behaviour is also observed in the case of the normalized entropy @xmath50 ( fig .
[ fig : allw]e ) - here a rapid growth occurs at the very beginning ( for small @xmath33 ) , then a linear decrease happens . for large @xmath33 the normalized entropy @xmath50 again increases . the average shortest path ( fig .
[ fig : allw]f ) resembles the shape of @xmath3 except for the lack of growth at the end .
[ [ network - visualisation ] ] network visualisation + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the above described non - trivial behaviour of quantities @xmath3 , @xmath50 and @xmath42 can not be the sole cause of the relations presented by eqs ( [ eq : pw ] ) and ( [ eq : wab ] ) .
it seems that there has to be another phenomenon leading to such an effect . using pajek program as well as a tool for community detection it is possible to visualize connections between universities and community structure ( denoted by color ) for different values of @xmath33 .
the results for @xmath51 and 1200 are shown in figs [ fig : w250]-[fig : w1200 ] , providing an input for further analysis .
up to @xmath52 the network is percolated ( it is possible to reach any node from another one ) ; over that value a separation occurs - chinese , australian and singapore , danish and swedish as well as swiss universities all form separate clusters .
the giant cluster is built out of american , canadian , english , dutch , swiss , german and japan universities ( fig . [ fig : w250 ] ) .
for @xmath53 dutch , swiss , german and japan universities are separated from the giant cluster ( fig .
[ fig : w600 ] ) and for @xmath54 also the english ones ( fig .
[ fig : w800 ] ) .
the final separation touches also american universities ( @xmath55 , fig . [ fig : w1200 ] ) .
it seems that the key aspect governing this kind of phenomenon is the geographical distance between the universities .
in fact , figure [ fig : dw ] confirms this supposition : the number of publications between universities a and b is a decreasing power - law function of the geographical distance between them .
the gap around @xmath56=5000 is most probably caused by the presence of continents .
similar results regarding the role of geographical distance in science were obtained in @xcite .
our preliminary results show that even such fundamental and straightforward analysis as calculation of correlation coefficient between position of the university in the ranking and the number of papers published by its employees may reveal some non - trivial relationships .
in particular , one may use it as indicator of the interest a certain scientific area gains over the years .
thus it can be possible to spot an emergence of certain trends in science and , in effect , react for example establishing a new direction of research in the university .
our final results show that the scientific collaboration is highly embedded in the physical space - it seems that the key aspect that governs the number of common publications is the geographical vicinity of the universities .
it is relevant even in the case of links between continents ( link between australia and singapore ) . on the other hand
the strength of the ties between universities is proportional to product of their total number of publications .
these two relations could be used as a starting point for modeling of university collaboration .
* data verification * _ abbreviations_. the seemingly straightforward procedure of querying for a specific university name encounters some problems that could have a strong impact on the further results .
web of science has a set of abbreviations commonly used for searching such as _ univ _ for `` university '' or _
coll _ for `` college '' .
moreover it is essential to notice that one has to form a very specific query in order to get rid of severe mistakes .
table [ tab : univ ] shows an exemplary list of the search universities together with the exact search phrase that had to be used .
_ ambiguity of queries_. the search field is a search key that we use to associate with the authors of the publications and it can consist of one of the operators : _
+ _ which stands for _ and _ operator in boolean logic and _ @xmath57 _ which stands for _ not _ operator in boolean logic .
these operators are used to clearly assess the origin of the publication .
table 2 shows that using just the names of universities from the list ( first column ) would lead in the case of number 98 to obtaining publications of both _ technical university in munich _ and _ university of munich _ , instead of just the latter . to omit this problem one has to insert a query _ univ munich @xmath57 tech univ munich _ that ensures achieving proper results . on the other hand for the case shown as number 78 , it was not sufficient to enter it washington univ , as there are many universities with such an abbreviation ; it was necessary to add _ st .
louis _ in the query text .
* network analysis * _ clustering coefficient _ @xmath58 for node @xmath6 is defined as the number of existing links among its nearest neighbors @xmath59 ( i.e , nodes to which it has links ) divided by the total number of possible links among them @xmath60 @xmath61 the total clustering coefficient for the whole network is calculated as the average over all @xmath58 .
+ _ assortativity coefficient _ @xmath3 defined by @xmath62 ^ 2 } { \frac{1}{2e } \left ( \sum_i j_i^2 + k_i^2 \right)- \left [ \frac{1}{2e } \sum_i \left(j_i + k_i \right ) \right]^2}\ ] ] where i goes over all edges in the network .
the coefficient is in the range @xmath63 $ ] , @xmath64 means that the highly connected nodes have the affinity to connect to other nodes with high @xmath65 while @xmath66 happens when highly connected nodes tend to link to nodes with very low @xmath65 .
+ _ entropy _ of node degree probability distribution .
it is calculated by first obtaining the degree probability distribution @xmath67 ( i.e. , the probability that a randomly chosen node has exactly @xmath68 edges ) and then evaluating the expression : @xmath69 where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are , respectively , the smallest and the largest degree in the network .
for the sake of comparison we divide the obtained value of entropy by its maximal value , i.e. , @xmath72 .
_ average shortest path _ @xmath42 .
it is calculated as the average value of shortest distance ( measured in the number of steps ) between all pairs of nodes @xmath6 , @xmath7 in the network .
we acknowledge support by fp7 fet open project dynamically changing complex networks - dynanets eu grant agreement number 233847 . this work has been supported by the european union in the framework of european social fund through the warsaw university of technology development programme , realized by center for advanced studies .
kuhn t. s. ( 1996 ) .
the structure of scientific revolutions . _ university of chicago press , 3rd edition_. popper k. ( 2002 ) . the logic of scientific discovery .
_ routledge , 2nd edition_. lakatos i. ( 1980 ) .
the methodology of scientific research programmes .
_ cambridge university press_. feyerabend p. ( 2010 ) .
against method .
_ verso , 4th edition_. merton , r. k. ( 1968 ) . the matthew effect in science .
_ science 1968 , 159 _ , 56 - 63 .
king , d. a. ( 2004 ) .
the scientific impact of nations .
_ nature 430 _ , 311 .
hirsh j. e. ( 2005 ) .
an index to quantify an individual s scientific research output .
sci usa 102 _
radicchi f. , fortunato s. , castellano c. ( 2008 ) .
universality of citation distributions : toward an objective measure of scientific impact .
usa 105_,17268 .
radicchi f. , fortunato s. , markines b. , vespignani a. ( 2009 ) .
_ physical review e 80 _ , 056103 .
petersen a. m. , wang f. , stanley h. e. ( 2010 ) .
methods for measuring the citations and productivity of scientists across time and discipline . _ physical review e 81 _ , 036114 .
radicchi f. , castellano c. ( 2011 ) . rescaling citations of publications in physics .
_ physical review e 83 _ , 046116 . mzaloumian a. , young - ho e. , helbing d. , lozano s. , fortunato s. ( 2011 ) .
how citation boosts promote scientific paradigm shift and nobel prizes .
_ plos one 6 _ , e18975 .
bornholdt s. , jensen m. h. , sneppen k. ( 2011 ) .
emergence and decline of scientific paradigms .
_ physical review letters 106 _ , 058701 .
kondratiuk p. , siudem g. , hoyst j. a. ( 2012 ) .
analytical approach to model of scientific revolutions .
_ physical review e 85 _ , 066126 .
fronczak p. , fronczak a. , hoyst j. a. ( 2007 ) .
analysis of scientific productivity using maximum entropy principle and fluctuation - dissipation theorem .
_ physical review e 75 _ , 026103 .
barabsi a .-
l . , albert r. ( 2002 ) .
statistical mechanics of complex networks .
_ reviews of modern physics 74 _ , 47 .
chmiel a. , sienkiewicz j. , suchecki k. , hoyst j. a. ( 2007 ) networks of companies and branches in poland .
_ physica a 383 _ , 134 .
hennemann s. , rybski d. , liefner i. ( 2012 ) the myth of global science collaborationcollaboration patterns in epistemic communities .
_ j. informetr 6 _ , 217225 .
pan r. k. , kaski k. , fortunato s. ( 2012 ) world citation and collaboration networks : uncovering the role of geography in science . _ sci .
rep . 2 _ , 902 .
[ cols="^,^ " , ] | we perform the analysis of scientific collaboration at the level of universities .
the scope of this study is to answer two fundamental questions : ( i ) can one indicate a category ( i.e. , a scientific discipline ) that has the greatest impact on the rank of the university and ( ii ) do the best universities collaborate with the best ones only ? using two university ranking lists ( arwu and qs ) as well as data from the science citation index
we show how the number of publications in certain categories correlates with the university rank .
moreover , using complex networks analysis , we give hints that the scientific collaboration is highly embedded in the physical space and the number of common papers decays with the distance between them .
we also show the strength of the ties between universities is proportional to product of their total number of publications . |
a clathrate is an ice - like crystalline solid consisting of water molecules forming a cage structure around smaller guest molecules under suitable conditions of low temperature and high pressure . on earth
, it is considered that clathrate hydrates are the most important reservoirs of fossil energy @xcite , and that favourable conditions for gas hydrate formation exist in about 25% of the earth s land mass . moreover , the thermodynamics conditions of pressure and temperature prevailing in the oceans are such that hydrates should easily be formed in about 90% of the ocean or sediments .
the most common guest molecules in terrestrial clathrates are of organic aliphatic nature like methane , ethane , propane or butane , but other small inorganic molecules like nitrogen , carbon dioxide , and hydrogen sulfide can also be trapped in the cages of clathrates @xcite . in the advent of global warming
, these clathrates can enhance the temperature rise when the trapped species are released .
clathrate hydrates are also suspected to be extensively present on several planets , satellites and comets of the solar system .
planetologists are thus concerned with the possible clathrate impact on the distribution of the planet s volatiles and on the modification of their atmosphere s compositions @xcite .
hence , it is of great interest to correctly determine the amount of species potentially trapped in the cages of clathrates , @xmath0 the fractional occupancy of guest species under the thermodynamic conditions ( pressure and temperature ) prevailing in the regions where clathrates might form . from a theoretical point of view
, the thermodynamics of the formation or dissociation of clathrates is most often based on the model developed by van der waals and platteeuw @xcite following the same hypotheses under which was developed the adsorption theory of langmuir @xcite .
the langmuir isotherms of adsorbed molecules on a surface are determined from the calculation of the langmuir constant , which is also the main parameter to be considered in the determination of the amount of species trapped in the clathrate cages as a function of pressure and temperature . to calculate these langmuir constants ,
most of the models are based on a molecular description of the guest - water interactions using a lennard - jones or kihara potential form .
the parameters of these potentials are usually empirically obtained from experimental data of phase equilibrium .
such models most often neglect interactions of the guest molecules with water beyond a few cages only and are therefore questionable @xcite .
moreover , it is generally assumed that the environment of the cage in which a gas molecule is trapped in clathrates is of spherical symmetry .
whereas this assumption may be justified for molecules such as ch@xmath1 or nh@xmath2 , it is certainly not well - suited for molecules such as co@xmath3 and n@xmath3o or so@xmath3 which are of cylindrical or oblate symmetry and for which the hypothesis of a free rotation at the center of a spherical cage is no longer valid . in the case of ethane and cyclo - propane clathrate hydrates ,
an analytical method based on the spherical cell model has been used to extract spherically averaged intermolecular potentials from experimental data on the temperature dependence of the langmuir constant by bazant and trout @xcite . for other guests in clathrate hydrates , in particular , argon , hydrogen , nitrogen , methane , ethane , propane , cyclo - propane , and carbon dioxide ,
other workers @xcite have explicitly taken into account the angle - dependence of the guest - water intermolecular potential in an atom - atom or site - site description to calculate the corresponding langmuir constants . however , in most of these studies the water and guest molecules were simply described as one , two or three interaction sites for the lennard - jones or kihara potential contributions although more than three sites are involved .
this work aims at providing a vant hoff law expression of the langmuir constant for single guest molecules incorporated in clathrate hydrates as a function of the temperature by improving the potential model used in the determination of the langmuir constants , that is by using an atom - atom and site - site potential and by considering explicitly the effect of water molecules beyond the trapping cage and the resulting anisotropic environment . in the present work , the langmuir constant
is determined by taking into account all the external degrees of freedom of the guest molecules , @xmath0 the center of mass ( c.m . )
translational motion and the orientational motion in a true crystallographic clathrate lattice , not necessarily of spherical symmetry as it is often assumed when using the van der waals and platteeuw model @xcite . in the following ,
we recall in section 2 the model used for the calculations of the langmuir constants that are necessary to determine the fractional occupancy of guest species in clathrates .
then , in section 3 , the geometry and interaction potential considered here are described . finally , in section 4
, the coefficients for a simple vant hoff expression of the langmuir constants are given for a large set of guest molecules .
the langmuir constants calculated using this model are compared with available experimental data , @xmath0 , for ethane , cyclo - propane guest molecules .
in contrast to natural ice which solidifies in the hexagonal structure , clathrate hydrates form , as water crystallizes , in the cubic system in several different structures which are characterized by specific cages of different sizes .
the two most common types are `` structure i '' and `` structure ii '' . in structure
i , the unit cell is made of 46 water molecules forming 2 small ( 12 pentagonal faces 5@xmath4 ) and 6 large ( 12 pentagonal and 2 hexagonal faces 5@xmath46@xmath5 ) cages , while in structure ii , the unit cell is made up of 136 water molecules forming 16 small ( 12 pentagonal faces 5@xmath4 ) and 8 large ( 12 pentagonal and 4 hexagonal faces 5@xmath46@xmath6 ) cages @xcite .
calculations of the relative abundances of guest species incorporated in a clathrate lattice structure of type i ( si ) or ii ( sii ) at given temperature - pressure conditions can be performed using classical statistical mechanics which allows the macroscopic thermodynamic properties of the clathrates to be determined from the interaction energies between the guest species and the clathrate water molecules . in 1959
van der waals and platteeuw @xcite developed a model of clathrate s formation in which the trapping of guest molecules in nano - cages was considered to be a generalized case of the three - dimensional ideal localized adsorption .
their model is based on the following hypotheses : 1 .
the contribution of the host molecules to the free energy is independent of the occupational mode in the cages .
this implies in particular that the guest species do not distort the trapping cage .
the encaged molecules are localized in the cages , each of which can never hold more than one guest .
the mutual interaction of the guest molecules is neglected , i.e. , the partition function for the motion of a guest molecule in its cage is independent of the other guests .
classical statistics is valid , i.e. , quantum effects are negligible . from the configuration partition function and the thermodynamic equilibrium condition on the chemical potentials of the guest and host molecules in coexisting phases in clathrate @xcite , the fractional occupancy of a guest molecule @xmath7 in a given `` structure type - cage size '' @xmath8 ( @xmath8 = structure - type i or ii - small or large cage )
can be written as : @xmath9 where the sum in the denominator includes all the species present in the initial gas phase , @xmath10 is the langmuir constant of species @xmath7 in the structure type - cage size @xmath8 , and @xmath11 is the fugacity of the species @xmath7 which depends on the total pressure @xmath12 of the initial gas phase and on the temperature @xmath13 .
the langmuir constant in equation ( 1 ) depends on the temperature @xmath13 and on the strength of the interaction energy between the guest species @xmath7 and the water molecules in the cage .
it is expressed as : @xmath14 in this equation @xmath15 is the interaction potential energy experienced by the guest molecule for a given position vector @xmath16 of its center of mass with respect to the cage center and its orientational vector @xmath17 , and @xmath18 is the boltzmann constant .
the integral value must be calculated for all external degrees of freedom of the guest molecule inside the structure type - cage size @xmath8 . to evaluate the langmuir constant @xmath10 , two additional assumptions are often made , namely : ( @xmath19 ) the symmetry of the guest molecule s environment is considered to be spherical and ( @xmath20 ) the guest molecule can freely rotate in the corresponding spherical cage ( spherical cell potential approximation ) , in accordance with the lennard - jones and devonshire @xcite theory applied to liquids .
then , the langmuir constant can be cast as : @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the radius of the spherical cage and @xmath23 is the spherically averaged potential energy between the guest molecule and the clathrate water molecules .
note that eq .
( 3 ) is commonly used by planetologists and as a result , it may introduce significant inaccuracies in the evaluation of the relative abundances of gas species in clathrate hydrates when the assumed spherical symmetry of the interaction potential is questionable .
in contrast , the langmuir constant for enclathrated single guest molecules is determined here by taking into account all the external degrees of freedom of the enclathrated molecules , i.e. the center of mass ( c.m . )
translational motion and the orientational motion in a real crystallographic clathrate lattice , not necessarily of spherical symmetry . as a consequence , eq .
( 3 ) is no longer valid in our approach and should be replaced by a more general form , as explained below .
let us consider a non - vibrating single gas species ( atom or molecule ) trapped in a small or large cage of a clathrate structure of type si or sii .
the positions of the hydrogen and oxygen atoms are given by their coordinates in a reference frame fixed to the clathrate lattice , while those of the guest molecule are usually given in a frame tied to the molecule with the * z * axis coinciding with the rotational axis of highest symmetry as shown for the trapping of a guest molecule ( ch@xmath1 for instance ) in the small cage of the clathrate structure type i , in figure 1 .
for instance ) in a small cage of the structure type i. ( o,*x*,*y*,*z * ) represents the absolute frame tied to the clathrate lattice.,width=453 ] the interaction potential energy @xmath24 between the guest molecule @xmath7 and the surrounding water molecules of the structure type - cage size @xmath8 , considered as a rigid clathrate crystal , is modeled as a sum of a 12 - 6 lennard - jones ( lj ) pairwise atom - atom potential characterizing the repulsion - dispersion contributions and an electrostatic part due to charge - charge interactions between the charges in the guest molecule and those in the water molecules of the clathrate system .
it is expressed as : @xmath25 , \label{vkt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath26 is the distance vector between the _
_ i__th site , with electric charge @xmath27 , of the guest molecule ( @xmath28 sites ) and the _
_ j__th site , with electric charge @xmath29 , of the _ _
k__th water molecule ( @xmath30 sites ) of the clathrate matrix ( containing @xmath31 water molecules ) ; @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the mixed lj potential parameters , using the lorentz - berthelot combination rules as : @xmath34 where @xmath35 and @xmath36 are the lennard - jones parameters for the @xmath37 interacting atomic pair , which are taken from the literature @xcite .
the effective electric charges for the water molecules @xmath38 = + 0.4238 @xmath39 , @xmath40 = - 0.8476 @xmath39 are from reference @xcite and those for the guest species are from references @xcite .
.pure lennard - jones potential parameters@xmath41 used in our calculations . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ cycpropane ] it can be seen that the values calculated here are in good agreement with those extracted from experimental data .
the ratios @xmath42 vary between 0.5 and 1.2 for ethane , and between 0.7 and 1.1 for cyclo - propane , depending on temperature .
note that the same ratios calculated within the same temperature range for the large cages of structure sii lead to values ranging from 320 to 540 for ethane , and from 920 to 1100 for cyclo - propane .
these results are consistent with the fact that ethane and cyclo - propane form si - large cage clathrate hydrates only .
moreover , tables 5 and 6 show that the best agreement between the values calculated here and those extracted from experiments is found when temperature is higher than 260 k. below this temperature , the calculated values are systematically lower than the experimental ones . to extract a quantitative value for our comparison , we use the following least square deviation parameter @xmath43 defined as : @xmath44 where @xmath45 are the values calculated at different temperatures in this work and @xmath46 are the values obtained experimentally @xcite or from the spherical model as often used in the literature .
@xmath47 is the number of temperatures considered ( @xmath47 = 10 in table 5 ) . we find values of @xmath43 equal to 1.6 @xmath48 pa@xmath49 and 3.3 @xmath48 pa@xmath49 , respectively .
moreover , note that in our calculations , the minimum of the potential energy corresponds to ethane s center of mass located at 0.12 from the center of the large cage of structure si , i.e. , a value that is consistent with observations from single crystal x - ray diffraction studies that place the center of mass at 0.17 from the center of the large cage @xcite .
as for cyclo - propane ( values given in table 6 ( @xmath47 = 6 ) ) , we calculate values of @xmath43 equal to 1.3 @xmath50 pa@xmath49 and 3.3 @xmath50 pa@xmath49 , respectively . to summarize , when compared to experimental results , the values of the langmuir constants calculated here for ethane show a better agreement with experimental data than those calculated from the spherical model , although they are of the same order of magnitude
. nevertheless , for cyclo - propane table 6 shows that values obtained from a simple spherical model disagree with experimental data and then they are certainly not correct .
therefore , the comparison of values calculated in this work with values issued from experimental work provides firm and sufficient grounds to validate the results obtained here for ethane and cyclo - propane .
in the present work , calculations of the langmuir constants and their temperature dependence for simple - guest clathrate hydrates have been performed for nineteen gas species using the van der waals and platteeuw model and an all - atom approach for calculating the interactions between guest and water molecules in the clathrate cages .
this approach accounts for the atomic character of the guest species and for the non - spherical water environment .
this simple expression could thus be easily applied in various situations , especially when experimental data are not available .
for example , it can help planetologists in the determination of the fractional occupancies of gas species trapped in the clathrates that are suspected to exist in various solid bodies of the solar system .
indeed , this information is mandatory to analyze the atmospheric compositions of planets and satellites like mars and titan , for example , and thus to better understand their way of formation
. unfortunately , the temperatures usually considered in clathrate experiments are often far from the temperature range of interest for planetology . as a consequence ,
calculations of clathrate occupancies is a preliminary step for any formation scenario that would consider clathrate influence . in that purpose ,
using the vant hoff expression given here would be much more simple than the usual approaches .
k. a. sparks , j. tester , molecular simulation of gas hydrates , report to norsk hydro .
chemical engineering department , massachusetts institute of technology , cambridge , 1992 ; j. phys . chem . * 96 * ( 1992 ) 11022 .
b. j. anderson , molecular modeling of hydrate - clathrates via ab initio , cell potential , and dynamic methods , ph .
d. , department of chemical engineering , massachusetts institute of technology , cambridge , 2005 . | this work gives a vant hoff law expression of langmuir constants of different species for determining their occupancy in the nanocavities of clathrate hydrates .
the vant hoff law s parameters are derived from a fit with langmuir constants calculated using a pairwise site - site interaction potential to model the anisotropic potential environment in the cavities , as a function of temperature .
the parameters can be used for calculating clathrates compositions .
results are given for nineteen gas species trapped in the small and large cavities of structure types i and ii @xcite .
the accuracy of this approach is based on a comparison with available experimental data for ethane and cyclo - propane clathrate hydrates .
the numerical method applied in this work , was recently validated from a comparison with the spherical cell method based on analytical considerations @xcite |
the interest in iridates grows fueled by the prospect of discovering novel electronic and/or topological orders that emerge from the interplay of spin - orbit coupling and electron correlations .
sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 is an archetypal example of such new phases , exhibiting a mott gap and a distinct spin - orbital entangled magnetic structure @xcite .
although sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 has been studied since the early 90 s in connection to high temperature superconducting cuprates @xcite , the important role of spin - orbit coupling had not been appreciated then . from recent studies of electronic and magnetic excitation spectra ,
it is now well understood that the insulating nature of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 is due to strong spin - orbit coupling @xcite , suppression of which results in a metallic phase in sr@xmath0rho@xmath1 @xcite , a 4@xmath4 counterpart of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 . the magnetic structure and dynamics of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1
are now reasonably well understood within the theoretical framework in the strong spin - orbit coupling limit described in terms of the @xmath5 - 1/2 kramers doublet .
remarkably , the @xmath5 - 1/2 isospins allow rich expressions of magnetic coupling depending on the lattice and bonding geometry , ranging from isotropic heisenberg interaction to a bond - directional , ising - like interaction @xcite .
the latter provides a basis for implementing exotic quantum magnets inspired by the kitaev model @xcite .
the former surprisingly indicates that a system with very strong spin - orbit coupling can mimic a system without it .
experimentally , it has been confirmed that the canted antiferromagnetic structure of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 derives from a predominantly isotropic nearest - neighbor magnetic exchange coupling @xcite .
thus , sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 becomes the first non - cuprate material to realize a ( iso)spin-1/2 heisenberg antiferromagnet in a quasi - two - dimensional square lattice a possible platform for high temperature superconductivity @xcite .
most recently , tantalizing indications of @xmath4-wave superconductivity have been seen in electron - doped sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 @xcite : a gap of predominantly @xmath4-wave symmetry is observed in the low - temperature angle - resolved photoemission spectra @xcite , and a particle - hole symmetric density of states is observed in scanning tunneling spectra below a temperature as high as 50 k @xcite . above this temperature , the @xmath4-wave gap evolves into a pseudogap , in striking parallel with the cuprates @xcite .
however , because of the inherently surface sensitive nature of the technique used to dope the sample in these studies , involving in situ deposition of alkali metal atoms on the surface of undoped sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 , it remains unclear at this point whether the @xmath4-wave gap originates from superconductivity without evidence from bulk measurements .
at least , these results indicate that highly nontrivial electronic phases emerge from doping a `` spin - orbit '' mott insulator .
the more traditional method of chemical doping @xcite through , for example , substitution of sr by la , has proven much more difficult than in cuprates .
la - doped sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals have only become available in the last couple of years @xcite , but angle - resolved photoemission studies on them @xcite do not fully reproduce the observations made via the in situ doping method @xcite . while it is unclear at the moment what leads to such differences between the two doping methods , we note that a well - defined quasiparticle peak is absent for any doping level in la - doped samples , indicating suppressed coherent motion of doped electrons presumably due to disorder created by chemical doping .
moreover , we note that previous studies on the parent sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and its sister compounds have shown significant variations in the magnetic properties even without doping , likely reflecting different defect concentrations @xcite .
for example , the sizable @xmath6-axis component of the uniform magnetic susceptibility is not understood and seems incompatible with the known magnetic structure of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 .
in addition , the diamagnetism initially reported for sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 is completely unexplained and is absent in samples grown under different conditions @xcite .
therefore , we believe it is imperative to establish the intrinsic magnetic properties through growth of stoichiometric single crystals of the parent iridates before the doping - induced phenomena can be fully explored . in this paper
, we describe the synthesis and characterization of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals .
synthesis of stoichiometric single crystals was achieved using the flux method , and characterizations were performed using magnetization , x - ray diffraction , raman scattering , and optical conductivity measurements .
we find that the magnetic response depends very sensitively on subtle details of the growth condition . through energy
dispersive x - ray spectroscopy ( edx ) , optical spectroscopy , and raman scattering , we infer that oxygen vacancies are the likely culprit of the divergent properties reported for sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 .
furthermore , by systematic variation of the growth temperature , we are able to introduce , in a controlled way , layers of sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 into the bulk sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals .
our results thus emphasize that revealing the intrinsic magnetic properties of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and related materials requires careful attention the oxygen stoichiometry .
single crystals were grown using the flux method .
powders of iro@xmath7 , srco@xmath8 , and srcl@xmath7@xmath96h@xmath0o were thoroughly mixed and placed in a platinum crucible covered with a lid .
the crucibles were heated in a programmable box furnace in air then cooled to room temperature and removed from the furnace .
the details of the growth conditions are documented in table [ table1]-[table3 ] . after cooling ,
crystals were separated from the residual flux by rinsing out with distilled water .
the crystals were found to have a regular shape with a large flat shiny surface with lengths up to few mm .
the characterizations of crystals were performed using powder x - ray diffraction ( xrd ) in debye - scherrer geometry with ag - k@xmath101 radiation , single crystal xrd in a high - resolution four - circle diffractometer with cu - k@xmath101 radiation , as well as energy dispersive x - ray spectroscopy ( edx ) equipped with a scanning electron microscope .
the magnetization measurements were carried out using a commercial superconducting quantum interference device magnetometer ( mpms squid vsm , quantum design ) .
the low temperature raman scattering experiments were performed in the backscattering geometry using a jobinyvon labram hr800 spectrometer and the 632.8 nm excitation line of a hene laser was used .
the power of the laser beam was 1.5 mw and the diameter of the beam @xmath11 .
the samples were cooled down in a he - flow cryostat . to describe the scattering geometries
, we use the porto notation a(bc)a@xmath12 , where a(b ) and a@xmath12(c ) stand for the propagation ( polarization ) directions of the incident and scattered light relative to the crystalline axes .
all of the data presented in this paper were taken with the light propagation direction along the crystalline @xmath6-axis ; hence only the polarization orientations will be specified .
crystals were cleaved @xmath13-situ to obtain a fresh clean surface . the far infrared ( fir ) ellipsometric measurements were carried out on a home - built ellipsometer attached to a bruker 66v / s ft - ir spectrometer located at the ir1 beamline of the anka synchrotron at kit , germany .
the experiments were performed on the same samples as used for the raman spectroscopy studies .
the complex optical conductivity @xmath14 is obtained from the ellipsometric angles @xmath15 and @xmath16 by direct inversion of the fresnel formulae .
we start by looking at the magnetic properties of four sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals ( labelled sr214@xmath17 through @xmath18 ) grown from the same molar ratio of starting materials under varying heating sequences as described in table [ table1 ] .
the biggest difference in the growth condition is between sr214@xmath17 and sr214@xmath18 .
while both start from heating the starting materials up to 1300 @xmath19c , sr214@xmath18 is exposed to elevated temperatures for a longer time .
the growth sequence of sr214@xmath20 and sr214@xmath21 are modifications of sr214@xmath17 and sr214@xmath18 , respectively .
note that our growth is performed in much lower temperature ranges than used in most of the earlier works @xcite . in fig .
[ figure_f](a ) , we plot the temperature dependence of the magnetization @xmath22(@xmath23 ) of each crystal measured in a magnetic field of 5 koe applied perpendicular to the crystallographic @xmath6-axis ( @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 ) , well above the metamagnetic transition that occurs at @xmath27 @xmath28 2 koe ( see inset of fig .
[ figure_f](a ) ) . above this field ,
canted moments that result from rotation of oxygen octahedra stack ferromagnetically along the @xmath6-direction , and the uniform susceptibility looks similar to that of a ferromagnet .
comparison of different curves shows that the highest saturated magnetic moment is achieved for sr214@xmath17 ( @xmath22 = 0.98 emu / g and 0.08 @xmath29@xmath30/ir at @xmath23 = 5 k , @xmath24 = 5 koe ) .
other batches show significantly lower values ranging between 0.82 and 0.92 emu / g .
further , a ` two - step ' structure in the @xmath22(@xmath23 ) curve is noticed for sr214@xmath21 , and a slight decrease in the magnetization is observed at low temperature below @xmath3130 k for sr214@xmath18 . in the inset of fig .
[ figure_f](a ) , we plot the isothermal magnetization @xmath22(@xmath24 ) curve of all samples . in sr214@xmath17
the metamagnetic transition is much sharper compared to the other three crystals .
( color online ) temperature dependent magnetization , @xmath22(@xmath23 ) , of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals measured on warming after field - cooling ( fcw mode ) with an applied field of ( a ) @xmath24 = 5 koe and ( b ) @xmath24 = 1 koe perpendicular to the crystallographic @xmath6-axis ( @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 ) .
the inset of ( a ) displays isothermal magnetization @xmath22(@xmath24 ) of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals at @xmath23 = 5 k ( @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 ) and the inset of ( b ) shows expended plot of @xmath22(@xmath23 ) at low temperatures for sr214@xmath18.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] these differences in the @xmath22(@xmath23 ) curves ( fig .
[ figure_f](a ) ) are more prominent in measurements performed in applied field below the metamagnetic critical field at @xmath24 = 1 koe , shown in fig .
[ figure_f](b ) .
whereas sr214@xmath17 with the highest saturated moment shows a sharp peak at @xmath23 = 215 k , sr214@xmath18 shows a broad hump peaked at a much lower temperature @xmath23 = 175 k. two anomalies are found in sr214@xmath20 and sr214@xmath21 , suggesting coexistence of the two features seen in sr214@xmath17 and sr214@xmath18 . it is noteworthy that previously published results share more resemblance to the broad profile of sr214@xmath18 rather than the sharp profile of sr214@xmath17 @xcite .
sr214@xmath18 shows another anomaly in the low temperature region ( inset of fig .
[ figure_f](b ) ) similar to earlier data , based on which a transition to a different magnetic structure , possibly a non - coplanar structure that has a @xmath6-axis component , has been suggested @xcite . however , these anomalies are clearly absent in sr214@xmath17 .
furthermore , we observe almost zero @xmath6-axis magnetic susceptibility ( fig .
[ figure_b ] ) , in sharp contrast to earlier studies that report a sizable @xmath6-axis response @xcite .
our measurements highlight the strong dependence of the magnetic properties of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 to subtle differences in the growth condition . as we shall see later on
, we judge based on optical conductivity and raman scattering spectra that sr214@xmath17 has the lowest defect concentration among all crystals we have grown . therefore , we believe that the magnetic behavior reported above for sr214@xmath17 is representative of the clean , ideal phase of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 .
( color online ) temperature dependence of magnetization @xmath22(@xmath23 ) of a sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystal ( sr214@xmath17 ) in zero field cooled ( zfc ) and field cooled warming ( fcw ) modes at @xmath24 = 5 koe with @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 and @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath6 , respectively .
inset : isothermal magnetization @xmath22(@xmath24 ) at @xmath23 = 5 k with @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 and @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath6 , respectively . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] ( color online ) ( a ) temperature dependence of magnetization @xmath22(@xmath23 ) for sr214@xmath17 , sr214@xmath32 , and sr214@xmath33 at @xmath24 = 5 koe with @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 in zero field cooled ( zfc ) and field cooled warming ( fcw ) modes .
( b ) inverse magnetic moments around @xmath34 .
( c ) magnetic field - dependent magnetizations @xmath22(@xmath24 ) for sr214@xmath17 , sr214@xmath32 , and sr214@xmath33 at @xmath23 = 5 k with applied field perpendicular to the @xmath6-axis ( @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 ) .
inset : expanded plot of @xmath22(@xmath24 ) for sr214@xmath33 . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] given that samples that were exposed to high temperature for longer time have lower sample quality , we further investigated the effect of prolonged exposure at 1300@xmath35 c ( sr214@xmath32 , see table [ table2 ] ) .
this sample showed significantly reduced magnetic ordering temperature , and a down turn in the @xmath36 curve below @xmath3150 k. most of the earlier data on sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 show such down turn in the @xmath36 curve @xcite .
our edx measurements indicate that sr214@xmath32 is deficient in oxygen ( see table [ table1 ] ) .
although edx is not very sensitive to oxygen , the difference in the oxygen content from sr214@xmath17 is statistically significant . a similar magnetic behavior is observed in a sample ( sr214@xmath33 ) grown using the same heating sequence as in sr214@xmath17 but with 10% less molar ratio of srco@xmath2 .
this further indicates that the different magnetic behavior is due to a non - stoichiometry in the sample , also supported by the edx measurement of sr214@xmath33 showing a further deviation from the ideal stoichiometry ( table [ table2 ] ) . in fig .
[ figure_ac ] ( a ) , we plot the @xmath22(@xmath23 ) curves measured on zero field cooling ( zfc ) and on field cooled warming ( fcw ) modes at @xmath24 = 5 koe .
both sr214@xmath32 and sr214@xmath33 show substantial decrease in the magnetic moment and the transition temperatures ( @xmath34 ) .
further , sr214@xmath33 shows glassy behavior at low temperature . in fig .
[ figure_ac ] ( b ) , we plot the inverse of the zfc data to highlight the change in transition temperature from @xmath23 @xmath28 240 k to @xmath23 @xmath28 200 k. for sr214@xmath32 and sr214@xmath33 , @xmath22(@xmath24 ) curves show hysteresis , which is absent in sr214@xmath17 ( fig .
[ figure_ac ] ( c ) ) .
we now look for structural distortions associated with the oxygen vacancies .
single crystal xrd experiments on sr214@xmath17 and sr214@xmath33 reveal an increase in the mosaicity of the non - stoichiometric sample as seen in the width of the rocking curve through the ( 0,0,4 ) bragg reflection ( fig .
[ xrpd](c ) ) , pointing to decreased structural quality .
nevertheless , neither powder nor single crystal xrd resolve a systematic change in the lattice parameters or atomic positions , as seen in the nearly identical powder patterns in fig .
[ xrpd](a - b ) . since x - rays are rather insensitive to oxygen atoms , we investigated the nature of this distortion by looking at the lattice dynamics using low temperature raman spectroscopy .
previous raman results on sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and sr@xmath0ir@xmath37ru@xmath38o@xmath1 have observed that the 34 mev @xmath39 phonon mode , associated with in - plane bending of the ir - o - ir bonds , is extremely sensitive to structural distortions @xcite .
an additional phonon mode was for instance found in the vicinity of this mode in sr@xmath0ir@xmath37ru@xmath38o@xmath1 due to the formation of two ir(ru)-o - ir(ru ) bond angles , indicating a phase separation @xcite .
we therefore look for signature of structural distortions in sr214@xmath17 , sr214@xmath32 , and sr214@xmath33 by measuring their 34 mev in - plane bending mode with raman scattering . in fig .
[ raman ] ( a ) , we show the low energy raman spectra of sr214@xmath17 , sr214@xmath32 , and sr214@xmath33 taken at @xmath23 = 20 k using the @xmath40-channel probing modes with @xmath39 and @xmath41 symmetry .
three @xmath39 phonon modes are observed in the presented energy range for sr214@xmath17 , the aforementioned 34 mev mode along with two smaller modes around 42 mev .
this is in good agreement with previous findings @xcite . for sr214@xmath32 and sr214@xmath33 ,
an additional raman - active mode becomes visible around 32 mev , while the two modes around 42 mev vanish and the 34 mev mode broadens and shifts to lower energy .
this result is indicative of distorted in - plane ir - o - ir angle ( @xmath39 ) @xcite , most likely originating from in - plane oxygen vacancies . in fig .
[ raman ] ( b ) , we show the high energy raman spectra of the same samples taken @xmath23 = 20 k using the @xmath42-channel ( @xmath43 ) . in this geometry
the two - magnon signal can be observed @xcite .
the two - magnon signal , found around 160 mev , becomes weaker and broader in sr214@xmath32 and sr214@xmath33 .
these raman results consistently indicate that oxygen vacancies lead to the observable difference in the magnetization data between sr214@xmath17 and other samples .
we now investigate the effect of oxygen vacancies on the infrared ( ir ) active phonons and the in - gap spectral weight .
[ raman ] ( c ) shows the real part of the optical conductivity @xmath44 in the far - ir spectral range .
compared to the clean sample sr214#1 both oxygen - deficient samples show a significant increase in the background level of the optical conductivity @xmath44 .
we attribute this rise in absorption to an increased number of defect states due to oxygen vacancies .
while the phonon line shapes of sample sr214-@xmath45#2 are rather similar to the clean case with just a small increase in the peak width the sample sr214-@xmath45#1 shows a remarkable difference .
the phonon at @xmath46 experiences a significant energy shift to @xmath47 whereas the one centered at @xmath48 softens to @xmath49 and its intensity strongly decreases .
these two phonons have been assigned to in - plane bending modes of the @xmath50 oxygen octahedra @xcite .
this suggests even stronger in - plane distortions of the oxygen octahedra in the sr214-@xmath45#1 sample although the overall background level of absorption appears to be smaller compared to sr214-@xmath45#2 .
[ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] ( color online ) temperature dependence of magnetization @xmath22(@xmath23 ) at @xmath24 = 5 koe ( @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 ) for sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 ( sr214@xmath17 ) , sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 ( sr327 ) and intergrowth samples ( sr214/327@xmath17 , @xmath51 and @xmath21).,scaledwidth=50.0% ] we now move on to demonstrate that layers , or slabs , of sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 can be introduced into a single crystal of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 by further altering the growth sequence . in table
[ table3 ] the growth sequence and molar starting ratio of parent sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and parent sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 single crystals can be seen .
we have confirmed the quality of our parent sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 single crystals by measuring the magnetic susceptibility . in fig .
[ figure_h ] , we plot @xmath22(@xmath23 ) for sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 in fcw mode with applied field being perpendicular to the @xmath6-axis ( @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 ) .
three different fields were used , @xmath24 = 10 oe , 1 koe , and 5 koe . in all measurements a magnetic phase transition is observed at @xmath23@xmath52 @xmath28 285 k. at lower temperatures , no other transition is seen in contrast to previous results @xcite .
one can notice that in order to produce pure sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 single crystals the starting temperature of the growth sequence for sr214@xmath17 has to be substantially reduced , along with a change in the molar ratio .
therefore one way to induce intergrowth of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 would be to systematically reduce the starting temperature of the growth sequence for sr214@xmath17 , from 1300 @xmath19c to 1050 @xmath19c , while at the same time keep the molar starting ratio unchanged .
this approach is displayed in table [ table3 ] where we present in details the growth sequence for intergrowth of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 samples ( sr214/sr327@xmath17 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 ) .
( color online ) single crystal x - ray diffraction pattern of the ( 0,0,l ) reflections for a crystal grown using similar conditions to sr214/sr327@xmath17 .
peaks identified with the periodicities of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 are denoted by vertical lines .
small peaks in the background are associated with stacking faults .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] in fig .
[ figure_d ] ( a ) we plot the temperature dependence of the magnetization @xmath22(@xmath23 ) of each crystal in table [ table3 ] with @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 .
comparison of different curves reveals that by lowering the starting temperature of the growth sequence the saturated magnetic moment gradually approaches the value measured for pure sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 .
interestingly , in fig .
[ figure_d ] ( b ) , where we show a closer look at the onset of magnetic order , one can notice a two - step structure in the @xmath22(@xmath23 ) curve of sr214/sr327@xmath20 and @xmath21 .
comparison to pure sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 reveals that the transtion at @xmath23@xmath52 @xmath28 285 k is associated with the sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 portion of the intergrowth samples while the stronger transition @xmath23@xmath52 @xmath28 240 k comes from the sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 part .
moreover , by looking at the saturated magnetic moments in @xmath22(@xmath23 ) ( see fig .
[ figure_d ] ( a ) ) , the ratio of the two phases can be estimated ; sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 has a saturation magnetic moment of @xmath311 emu / g while in comparison , in sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 the magnetic moment at @xmath24 = 5 koe is negligible ( @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 ) . using this method we can control , by varying the synthesis conditions ( table [ table3 ] ) , the proportion of the two phases .
the sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 contribution to sr214/sr327@xmath17 is about 0.5 while this ratio drops to about 0.2 in sr214/sr327@xmath20 and around 0.03 in sr214/sr327@xmath21 .
given the difference in the @xmath6-axis lattice parameter , the intergrowth nature of these samples is confirmed by using single crystal xrd to study the bragg reflections along l. as seen in fig .
[ xrd214_327 ] , reflections corresponding to sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 or sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 can be observed in the same single crystal .
we have investigated the relationship between different synthesis conditions and magnetic properties in sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals . depending on the synthesis condition we observe varying magnetic properties most likely due to oxygen vacancies . for off - stoichiometric samples ,
additional phonon - modes appear in raman scattering spectra due to structural distortions and in - gap states appear in optical conductivity measurements .
consistent with the magnetization measurements , we find that the two - magnon raman peak broadens , signaling weaker magnetic correlations in these distorted samples .
in addition , we have shown that intergrowth of the sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 phase into sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals can be be controlled by varying the synthesis conditions .
our results therefore emphasizes that revealing the intrinsic physical properties of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and related materials require scrupulous control of the synthesis conditions .
n. h. sung was supported by the alexander von humboldt foundation .
we gratefully acknowledge y .-
mathis for support at the ir1 beam line of the synchrotron facility anka at the karlsruhe institute of technology .
we acknowledge financial support of the dfg under sfb / trr80 . j. g. vale , s. boseggia , h. c. walker , r. springell , z. feng , e. c. hunter , r. s. perry , d. prabhakaran , a. t. boothroyd , s. p. collins , h. m. r?now , and d. f. mcmorrow , phys . rev .
b 92 ( 2015 ) p.020406(r ) . a. de la torre , s. mckeown walker , f. y. bruno , s. ricco , z. wang , i. gutierrez lezama , g. scheerer , g. giriat , d. jaccard , c. berthod , t. k. kim , m. hoesch , e. c. hunter , r. s. perry , a. tamai , and f. baumberger , arxiv:1506.00616 .
veronique brouet , joseph mansart , luca perfetti , christian piovera , ivana vobornik , patrick le fevre , francois bertran , scott c. riggs , m. c. shapiro , paula giraldo - gallo , and ian r. fisher , phys .
b 92 ( 2015 ) p.081117(r ) .
xiang chen , tom hogan , d. walkup , wenwen zhou , m. pokharel , mengliang yao , wei tian , thomas z. ward , y. zhao , d. parshall , c. opeil , j. w. lynn , vidya madhavan , and stephen d. wilson , phys .
b 92 ( 2015 ) p.075125 . | we report on the growth of stoichiometric sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 single crystals , which allow us to unveil their intrinsic magnetic properties .
the effect of different growth conditions has been investigated for crystals grown by the flux method .
we find that the magnetic response depends very sensitively on the details of the growth conditions .
we assess the defect concentration based on magnetization , x - ray diffraction , raman scattering , and optical conductivity measurements .
we find that samples with a low concentration of electronically active defects show much reduced in - gap spectral weight in the optical conductivity and a pronounced two - magnon peak in the raman scattering spectrum .
a prolonged exposure at high temperature during the growth leads to higher defect concentration likely due to creation of oxygen vacancies .
we further demonstrate a systematic intergrowth of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and sr@xmath2ir@xmath0o@xmath3 phases by varying the growth temperature .
our results thus emphasize that revealing the intrinsic magnetic properties of sr@xmath0iro@xmath1 and related materials requires a scrupulous control of the crystal growth process . |
the spreading of epidemics is a threat to the world public health .
it has also been arising large scientific attention due to the potential harm to the society @xcite . in particular , the infection by the human immunodeficiency virus ( hiv ) which causes aids
has been the subject of intense studies since the early 1980s , when the virus started spreading quickly throughout the globe and has become a worldwide concern @xcite .
estimates reveal that by the end of 2010 more than 30 million people were living with the infection worldwide . as a comparison , about 2.7 million new infections were identified on the globe just in 2010 @xcite . the study of the epidemiology of hiv infection using accurate surveillance data
has been providing essential information in guiding rational control and intervention programs , as well as in monitoring trends of the epidemic in many countries @xcite . for example , it has been shown that new hiv infections among adults depend on their geographic region in the globe and social contact groups distributions @xcite .
brazil the world s fifth most populous country , with almost 200 million inhabitants was the first developing country to implement a large - scale control and intervention programs @xcite .
the brazilian response to aids has included effective prevention strategies with strong participation of the civil society , multi - sectoral mobilization , and intense use of antiretroviral therapies @xcite . in a global scenario , these facts has attracted significant attention from the scientific community to the dynamics of hiv / aids epidemic in brazil @xcite . in the present work ,
we investigate the evolution and current status of the aids epidemic in brazil by analyzing its annual absolute frequency per city .
our analysis points in the direction of an alternative approach to the usual methods of epidemics analysis , emphasizing how the dynamics of the virus at the level of municipalities behaves collectively .
the data were obtained from datasus , a database of the national public health system freely available online and maintained by the department of informatics of the brazilian health system @xcite .
in this section we report the results that we obtained by analyzing the empirical data which cover the first 33 years of the aids infection in brazil .
specifically , we investigate the annual absolute frequency @xmath0 , defined as the number of new aids cases diagnosed in the year @xmath1 at a given city @xmath2 .
it is valid noting that the system data registry of datasus hosts only mandatory cases of aids reported by health professionals to health services .
therefore , the number of hiv positive patients was not available in datasus until 2012 , but only the number of aids cases .
altogether , we analyze data ranging from 1980 up to 2012 of 5138 brazilian cities with at least one aids case in the aforementioned period . up to the end of 2012 , the infection had already reached more than 5000 cities ( @xmath3 of the brazilian cities ) .
we start with an overview of the spatial spreading of the virus .
next , we focus on the temporal evolution of the infection in brazilian cities . the first aids case in brazil was identified in the year 1980 in so paulo , the most populous brazilian city ( southern region ) . in the next few years
, new satellite cases came out and the infection started spreading to a larger area . in this mean time , the infection spread to other cities and the whole country was already taken by the end of the 1990s .
the current status of the aids infection in brazil is depicted in figure [ growth ] , where the size of the circles is proportional to the logarithm of @xmath0 and the histograms along the axis detail the annual absolute frequencies as function of the geographic position of the cities .
a chronological evolution of the aids cases per year among brazilian cities is available as a supplementary figure ( figure [ chronology ] ) . as clearly illustrated in figure [ growth ] , the infection is concentrated in some key cities located mainly next the atlantic littoral , where is concentrated most of the brazilian population . .
the histograms along the axis represent the dependence of the distribution of the aids cases on the geographic position ( latitude and longitude ) of the cities .
besides reflecting in a great extent the population distribution , this figure also provides a general information concerning the spatial spreading of the epidemics over the country . ]
first we considered @xmath4 , the total annual absolute frequency at each year @xmath1 , obtained by summing @xmath0 over the total of @xmath5 brazilian cities , @xmath6 .
figure [ dynamics]a shows the temporal evolution of @xmath4 and compares it with the curve @xmath7^{\frac{1}{\nu}}}\ , , \label{logistic}\ ] ] for different non - negative values of @xmath8 . , emphasizing their discreteness nature . ]
this curve is obtained as the solution of the richard s differential equation and represents a generalized logistic growth @xcite .
classically , logistic - like equations have a vast application in systems related to the dynamics of populations where there is a strong competition of increasing and establishing factors , exactly as in the case of diseases growing and spreading @xcite .
a dimensional analysis reveals that @xmath9 has the dimension of @xmath10 , @xmath11 goes with @xmath12 , while @xmath13 and @xmath8 are dimensionless . within the period 19802012 for 5138 brazilian cities .
the dashed blue line is equation ( 1 ) with the parameters @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
the continuous red line is equation ( 1 ) with the parameters @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
( b ) growth of the corresponding accumulated number of cases @xmath22 shown in log - lin scale .
the inset represents the first points of the curve of @xmath22 , corresponding to the period 19801985 .
the solid line is a fit in this region , given by @xmath23 with @xmath24 .
( c ) decay of the actual reproduction number @xmath25 for the whole period shown at log - log scale .
the solid line is a linear fit ( in log - log scale ) giving a power law exponent @xmath26 .
the green points correspond to the numerical solution of the continuous equation @xmath27 with @xmath28 for the gompertz model , connecting the fit of equation ( 1 ) to the patterns of the data . ]
the particular case @xmath29 corresponds to the usual logistic curve . for this case , a least - squared regression to the data . ]
( see the dashed curve on figure [ dynamics]a ) leads to @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) , where the uncertainties correspond to 99% confidence intervals .
this type of curves have also been identified in si ( susceptible - infected ) simulations of the initial evolution of epidemic outbreaks in growing scale - free networks with local structures @xcite .
similar curves has also been identified in networks whose nodes are not only the media to spread the virus , but also to disseminate their opinions about it @xcite . in the aids spreading case ,
the establishment of an almost constant growth per year after 1999 ( figure [ dynamics]a ) could be associated with factors such as the impact on using arv therapies as well as the extensive broadcast prevention campaigns realized in brazil @xcite .
it is also evident that the limit @xmath34 leads to the gompertz model .
] , that was originally proposed to model mortality of an aging population @xcite .
almost century later , this approach still has applications in biological growth curve @xcite , in survival analysis @xcite and in regeneration @xcite .
a least - squared regression of the gompertz curve with @xmath35 to the data ( see the continuous curve on figure [ dynamics]a ) leads to @xmath36 and @xmath37 ( @xmath38 ) , where the uncertainties correspond to 99% confidence intervals .
it is noticeable that the gompertz model is better than the generalized logistic model ( for different values of @xmath8 ) when describing the beginning of the curve , but looking at the residuals of fit , both models are in good agreement with the data .
figure [ dynamics]b shows @xmath22 , the correspondent accumulated annual absolute frequency defined mathematically as @xmath39 . in a few words
, @xmath22 represents the total number of aids cases diagnosed in brazil until the year @xmath1 . for small times
, @xmath22 exhibits an exponential growth , @xmath23 ( inset in figure [ dynamics]b ) , where @xmath40 has the unity @xmath12 .
the limit @xmath41 can be recovered ( analytically ) from equation ( 1 ) when @xmath42 is very small .
a numerical comparison with the data reveals a relative error of 0.8 ( for the logistic model ) or of 0.5 ( for the gompertz model ) for small times . in this background
, @xmath40 can be considered an estimate of the intrinsic growth rate describing the initial growth of the epidemic , which underlies the entire spreading of the infection in the surrounding regions .
naturally , the intrinsic growth rate @xmath40 can be estimated from this approach since in the beginning of the epidemic @xmath22 practically corresponds to the prevalence of aids infection cases .
a linear regression to the data leads to @xmath43 @xmath12 ( 99% confidence interval ; @xmath44 ) for the aids epidemic among brazilian cities .
similar analysis for aids epidemic in france , in the uk , and in western germany have led to @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and @xmath47 respectively @xcite .
as for hiv / aids epidemic among homosexual population in england and wales ( 19811996 ) , it was found @xmath48 @xcite .
in contrast to the intrinsic growth rate @xmath40 , reproduction numbers describe a more local or individual quantity . the actual reproduction number @xmath25 is defined as the average number of secondary cases per case to which the infection was actually transmitted during the infectious period in a population .
an estimate of @xmath25 can be obtained assuming that @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the average length of the hiv infectious period ( @xmath51 years ) @xcite . since the ratio ( @xmath52 )
can be associated to a transmission index , reproduction numbers carry important indicators like the threshold for pandemics . figure [ dynamics]c shows the temporal evolution of @xmath25 in brazil in comparison with a power law decaying in the form @xmath53 with @xmath54 ( 99% confidence interval ; @xmath55 ) . for sure ,
equation ( 2 ) can be associated from equation ( 1 ) with the assumption that accumulating a discrete time series is a good approach for an integration process over a continuous variable .
in particular , the numerical solution to the continuous approach @xmath27 with @xmath28 given by equation ( 1 ) also leads to consistent results within the confidence intervals ( see the green points in figure [ dynamics]c )
. using incidence data of hiv / aids epidemic only among homosexual population in england and wales ( 19811996 ) , a power law pattern could not be identified @xcite .
clearly , that data are a small fraction of the population and have severe limitations in time and space , which does not happen with the brazilian data , which have continental proportions , including more than 5000 urban centers and more than 30 years of data .
as usually happens in a epidemic spreading , the aids infection had focus in a specific region and then spread to a larger area ( see figure [ chronology ] ) . during the spreading process ,
individuals in many different urban centers get infected and the radius of the infection grew fast . a natural measure characterizing such process is a function indicating the number of cities with the same number of aids hosts .
we investigated that through the probability density function ( pdf ) of the annual absolute frequency of aids among brazilian cities @xmath56 for fixed years .
figure [ powerlaw]a shows @xmath56 of the set of all the @xmath0 in the year 2012 in comparison with the power law decay @xmath57 this result indicates that the distribution of the set of @xmath0 over all the brazilian cities has a robust long - tailed behavior .
similar power laws can also be identified for all the @xmath0 with @xmath1 fixed . in particular ,
the cramr - von mises test assures that for @xmath58 the null hypothesis that the yearly data is distributed accordingly to power law curves can not be reject at a confidence level of 99% ( the @xmath59-values lies in the interval @xmath60 $ ] ) .
the annual evolution of the power law exponent @xmath61 with 99% bootstrapped confidence intervals is shown in figure [ powerlaw]b .
in particular , for the year 2012 , @xmath62 ( 99% bootstrapped confidence interval ) .
the values for @xmath61 were obtained by a maximum - likelihood estimation . in spite of large fluctuations for initial times due to a small quantity of infected individuals , @xmath61 stays practically constant over the whole period ( @xmath63 ) , but exhibiting a slight trend to decrease if the error bars were disregarded .
, where @xmath0 corresponds to the number of aids cases diagnosed in 2012 on 2891 brazilian cities .
the solid line has slope 1.87 and was obtained by a maximum likelihood fit to the data .
( b ) temporal evolution of the power law exponent @xmath61 for the period 19862012 .
the error bars correspond to 99% bootstrapped confidence intervals . ]
the actual number of infected individuals per capita depends on many different factors and can not be expected to be a constant .
factors related to high - risk behaviors are connected with the majority of new infection cases .
naturally , the frequency of some infection in a given city should be related somehow to the size of that city ( as its number of inhabitants ) . to investigate this possible size dependence
, we crossed the aids data with data on the population of cities obtained from the brazilian institute of geography and statistics ( ibge ) a federal government s institution which performs a national census about every ten years @xcite .
figure [ allometry ] shows @xmath0 of each city as a function of its number of inhabitants @xmath64 . in order to obtain a better approach
, we selected only the cities with @xmath65 for two fixed years and considered windows - averaged values .
figure [ allometry]a shows both @xmath0 and @xmath64 in year 2000 , while figure [ allometry]b shows the analogous plot for the year 2010 .
the curves are well described by the scaling law @xmath66 in particular , we found @xmath67 ( 99% confidence interval ; @xmath55 ) for the year 2000 and @xmath68 ( 99% confidence interval ; @xmath44 ) for the year 2010 .
note that the annual absolute frequency of aids cases depends on the population with a non - trivial rule , since @xmath69 .
this super - linear dependence indicates that the infection grows in average faster than the population , meaning that the more populous the city , the greater the density of the infection per capita .
similar allometric scaling laws have been identified in many biological systems .
classical examples are the metabolic rates scaling with the mass of animals and plants proportions @xcite .
consistent results were also found for data on new aids cases from u.s . related to the period 20022003 ( @xmath70 ) , as well as some social indicators @xcite . as a function of the population of the city ( @xmath64 ) shown at log - log scale for fixed years : ( a ) 2000 ; and ( b ) 2010 .
the solid lines are linear fits performed for cities with 3000 or more inhabitants .
the solid lines have slopes ( a ) 1.37 and ( b ) 1.31 . ]
it is clear that an allometric relationship between two variables is usually outlined by the probability distribution of both the variables .
studies in the literature investigate such type of connection .
as an example , there is an evident relationship between homicides and population / urban indicators @xcite . in particular , by a direct transformation of probabilities @xcite , it is possible to show that an allometric exponent @xmath71 can be connected with two other power law exponents @xmath72 and @xmath11 by the equation @xmath73 . in our scaling laws , @xmath72 represents the exponents obtained by the probability distribution of aids cases on the brazilian cities for each year ( see equation ( 3 ) and figure [ powerlaw]b ) and @xmath11 came from the probability distribution of sizes of the brazilian cities .
@xmath74 refers to the zipf law of the brazilian cities @xcite . naturally , concerning our data
, the exponent @xmath11 can be slightly different because we are considering only the cities that had at least one aids case in the corresponding year . as pointed out before
, brazil is a forefront reference in providing aids prevention campaigns and treatment services @xcite .
the country has been investing systematically for years . for example , only in 2008 , brazilian government invested more than us$ 600 million ( around 1/3 of the amount spent in caribbean and all the three americas ) in hiv domestic and international spending @xcite . as a consequence , these efforts should have had an impact over the epidemic of aids in brazil . to quantify such impact , disregarding other possible contributions
, we split all the brazilian cities with at least one aids case since 1989 into 4 groups accordingly to their average absolute frequency per year , denoted by @xmath75 in @xmath76 and defined as an arithmetic mean of @xmath0 : group i accommodates 4029 cities with @xmath77 .
group ii encompasses 565 cities with @xmath78 .
group iii accommodates 259 cities with @xmath79 , and , finally , group iv covers 48 cities with @xmath80 .
it is evident from figures [ allometry ] that , @xmath0 has a well - defined allometry with the population of cities .
for this reason , separate groups of cities accordingly to @xmath75 is also equivalent to separate @xmath0 by population - sizes , apart from random fluctuations . in figure [ momentos ]
we show average values and variance for each one of these groups .
we can see that for small cities ( groups i and ii ) , the average number of cases and the respective fluctuations are still growing , while large cities ( groups iii and iv ) exhibit a different behavior : the number of cases are already decreasing , as well as the fluctuations .
this could reflect that the intensive broadcast programs of the brazilian government against the infection has been giving results mainly in the largest urban centers , where is concentrated most of the cases .
intense treatment therapies started in brazil at the beginning of the 1990s and had a peak in 1996 with the introduction of haart ( highly active antiretroviral therapy ) which substantially reduces the infectiousness of people living with aids @xcite .
estimates suggest that more than 1.2 million of life - years are estimated to have been gained in brazil between 1996 and 2009 @xcite .
their impact over the frequency of new infection cases is evident in cities of the groups iii and iv since the end of the 1990s .
many therapeutic approaches have been under constant investigation in order to develop vaccines against the hiv virus or at least control some effects of the infection .
but ongoing research is unavoidable to identify a solution to this devastating worldwide epidemic . in brazilian cities in the period 19892012 . *
the total of 5138 cities are split in 4 groups : @xmath77 ( group i ) , @xmath78 ( group ii ) , @xmath79 ( group iii ) , and @xmath80 ( group iv ) . ]
in the present work , we showed that the aids epidemic in brazil ( 19802012 ) exhibits the following growth patterns : _
( i ) _ logistic - type growth of total aids cases per year with an exponential regime in the first few years of the aids spreading and _ ( ii ) _ power law - type decaying of the actual reproduction number ; _ ( iii ) _ power law behavior with a robust exponent in the pdf of the annual absolute frequency among cities ; _ ( iv ) _ a robust allometric relationship between the epidemic and the population of the cities ; and , finally , _ ( v ) _ different profile for the temporal evolution of the epidemics depending on the average absolute frequency of cases in the cities . the result shown in figure [ dynamics]a suggests a logistic - like growth of the total aids cases per year in brazil .
typically such curves are associated with a competition of increasing and establishing agents . for this reason
, they have a vast application in the dynamics of populations , including the spreading of infectious diseases . in the aids case ,
the establishing agents seems to be connected to the impact of the large - scale control and programs of hiv / aids intervention in brazil , like the extensive broadcast prevention campaigns and the evolution with the antiretroviral therapies @xcite .
looking carefully at figure [ dynamics]a it is possible to identify that , mainly after the year 1999 , there is a tendency to saturation of @xmath28 .
such region represents the period where the impact of the efforts against the aids epidemics became more intense .
it is well - known that the number of cases of a new infection in a confined area grows exponentially . for the aids epidemics in brazil
, we found that this exponential provides the parameter @xmath81 ( inset of figure [ dynamics]b ) which are in good agreement with the growth of aids in some europeans countries @xcite . for small time scales ( typically smaller than the characteristic time for infection - related deaths ) the prevalence of an infection can be associated to the whole number of infected individuals .
using this assumption , we obtained figure [ dynamics]c , which shows that the growth in the absolute frequency of cases is decreasing with time .
this result is consistent with the literature @xcite and predicts that the infection is growing slower with time .
it should be noted that the fluctuations after _ ca . _
1992 occurs because it is the region where the small time scale is already broken ( _ ca . _ 10 years for aids ) .
we also showed that the distribution of the aids epidemics in small spatial scales ( over cities ) follows a power law behavior for the whole period with an decreasing exponent typically around 1.9 and systematically below the inverse - square law ( @xmath82 ) widespread in the nature . yet , the infection over cities scales with the population in that region .
we showed through figure [ allometry ] that the scale rule follows a super - linear allometric pattern ( @xmath83 ) .
in contrast , mortality rates from influenza and pneumonia in us cities surrounding the 1918 pandemic scales linearly with the population size ( @xmath84 ) @xcite . in a general scenario , new aids cases in brazil are running to a plateau ( figure [ dynamics]a ) . assuming that this behavior is mainly due to the results of the programs and strategies , against the aids infection , we focused on the level of cities , elaborating figure [ momentos ] . by using it
, we showed that the first results of the efforts against the infection occurred mainly in urban centers with an average of more than 10 aids cases per year ( groups iii and iv ) .
that is , the infection is not expected to grow uncontrollably in such cities ; in particular , it is expected to lose its strength in the largest urban centers ( average of more than 84 aids cases per year ) .
naturally , this result is reinforced by the power law decaying in the actual reproduction number ( figure [ dynamics]c ) , what indicates that the fraction of number of new cases per case is decreasing and whose effect is noted mainly in the larger cities because the fluctuations of cases appears to be smaller . on the other hand , the average number of new infections per year ( as well as their fluctuations ) in cities of the groups i and ii are still growing .
the data is not long enough in time to identify if this fact is just a delay period or if such cities have not experienced sufficiently the brazilian control strategies against aids . in any case , they merit further attention from the brazilian health authorities . in a general summary , we proposed in this work an alternative approach to the usual methods of epidemics analysis , emphasizing how the dynamics of the virus at the level of municipalities behaves collectively .
the authors thank for the financial support of the brazilian agencies cnpq , capes , and the national institute of science and technology for complex systems .
f.j.a . is especially grateful to capes / fundao araucria for the grant number 87/2014 .
10 [ 1]`#1 ` urlstyle [ 1]doi:#1 [ 1 ] [ 2 ] _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ key : # 1 + annotation : # 2 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ kreiss jk , koech d , plummer fa , holmes kk , lightfoote m , et al .
( 1986 ) aids virus infection in nairobi prostitutes .
new engl j med 314 : 414
morris m , kretzschmar m ( 1997 ) concurrent partnerships and the spread of hiv .
aids 11 : 641 648 .
newman mej ( 2002 ) spread of epidemic disease on networks .
phys rev e 66 : 016128 .
riley s , fraser c , donnelly ca , ghani ac , abu - raddad lj , et al .
( 2003 ) transmission dynamics of the etiological agent of sars in hong kong : impact of public health interventions .
science 300 : 1961
lipsitch m , cohen t , cooper b , robins jm , ma s , et al .
( 2003 ) transmission dynamics and control of severe acute respiratory syndrome .
science 300 : 1966 1970 .
neumann g , noda t , kawaoka y ( 2009 ) emergence and pandemic potential of swine - origin h1n1 influenza virus .
nature 459 : 931 939 .
curran jw , jaffe hw , hardy am , morgan wm , selik rm , et al .
( 1988 ) epidemiology of hiv infection and aids in the united states .
science 239 : 610 616 .
bor r , miller r , goldman e ( 1993 ) hiv / aids and the family : a review of research in the first decade .
j fam ther 15 : 187 204 .
vogl d , rosenfeld b , breitbart w , thaler h , passik s , et al .
( 1999 ) symptom prevalence , characteristics , and distress in aids outpatients .
j pain symptom manage 18 : 253 262 .
hayes r , weiss h ( 2006 ) understanding hiv epidemic trends in africa .
science 311 : 620 621 .
fonseca mgp , bastos fi ( 2007 ) twenty - five years of the aids epidemic in brazil : principal epidemiological findings , 1980 - 2005 .
rev saude publ 23 : s333 s343 .
walker bd , burton dr ( 2008 ) toward an aids vaccine .
science 320 : 760
764 .
hall hi , espinoza l , benbow n , hu yw , for the urban areas hiv surveillance workgroup ( 2010 ) epidemiology of hiv infection in large urban areas in the united states .
plos one 5 : e12756 . unaids .
unaids report on the global aids epidemic @xmath85 2010 . http://www.unaids.org/globalreport/documents/20101123_globalreport_full_en.pdf . accessed on february 2014 .
accessed on february 2014 .
amundsen eja , stigum h , rttingen ja , aalen oo ( 2004 ) definition and estimation of an actual reproduction number describing past infectious disease transmission : application to hiv epidemics among homosexual men in denmark , norway and sweden .
epidemiol infect 132 : 1139 1149 .
beyrer c , baral sd , walker d , wirtz al , johns b , et al .
( 2010 ) the expanding epidemics of hiv type 1 among men who have sex with men in low- and middle - income countries : diversity and consistency .
epidemiol rev 32 : 137151 .
alsallaq ra , baeten jm , celum cl , hughes jp , abu - raddad lj , et al .
( 2013 ) understanding the potential impact of a combination hiv prevention intervention in a hyper - endemic community .
plos one 8 : e54575 . quinn tc ( 1996 ) global burden of the hiv pandemic .
lancet 348 : 99 106 . meiners c , sagaon - teyssier l , hasenclever l , moatti jp ( 2011 ) modeling hiv / aids drug price determinants in brazil : is generic competition a myth ?
plos one 6 : e23478 .
bailey ntj ( 1988 ) simplified modelling of the population dynamics of hiv / aids .
j r statist soc a 151 : 31 43 .
teixeira pr , antnio mv , barcarolo j ( 2004 ) antiretroviral treatment in resource - poor settings : the brazilian experience .
aids 18 : 5 7 .
accessed on february 2014 .
nelder ja ( 1961 ) the fitting of a generalization of the logistic curve .
biometrics 17 : 89 110 .
gaillard jm , pontier d , allaine d , loison a , herve jc , et al .
( 1997 ) variation in growth form and precocity at birth in eutherian mammals .
proc biol sci 264 : 859
868 .
murray jd ( 2002 ) mathematical biology : i. an introduction .
springer , 3 edition .
ni s , weng w , shen s , fan w ( 2008 ) epidemic outbreaks in growing scale - free networks with local structure .
physica a 387 : 5295 5302 .
ni s , weng w , zhang h ( 2011 ) modeling the effects of social impact on epidemic spreading in complex networks .
physica a 390 : 4528 4534 .
grangeiro a , escuder mml , castilho ea ( 2010 ) magnitude and trend of the aids epidemic in brazilian cities , from 2002 to 2006 .
rev saude publ 44 : 430
441 .
gompertz b ( 1825 ) on the nature of the function expressive of the law of human mortality , and on a new method of determining the value of life contingencies .
philos trans r soc lond 115 : 513 585 .
winsor cp ( 1932 ) the gompertz curve as a growth curve .
proc natl acad sci usa 18 : 1 8 .
coe jb , mao y ( 2005 ) gompertz mortality law and scaling behavior of the penna model .
phys rev e 72 : 051925 .
wallenstein s , brem h ( 2004 ) statistical analysis of wound - healing rates for pressure ulcers .
am j surg 188 : 73 78 .
nishiura h ( 2010 ) correcting the actual reproduction number : a simple method to estimate @xmath86 from early epidemic growth data .
int j environ res public health 7 : 291 302 .
gran jm , wasmuth l , amundsen ej , lindqvist bh , aalen oo ( 2008 ) growth rates in epidemic models : application to a model for hiv / aids progression .
stat med 27 : 4817 4834 .
ftp://ftp.ibge.gov.br/censos/censo_demografico_2000/dados_do_universo/municipios . accessed on february 2014 . ibge . ftp://ftp.ibge.gov.br/censos/censo_demografico_2010/resultados_do_universo/xls/municipios . accessed on february 2014 . west gb , brown jh , enquist bj ( 1999 ) the fourth dimension of life : fractal geometry and allometric scaling of organisms . science 284 : 1677 - 1679 .
niklas kj ( 2004 ) plant allometry : is there a grand unifying theory ?
biol rev camb philos soc 79 : 871 889 .
bettencourt lma , lobo j , helbing d , khnert c , west gb ( 2007 ) growth , innovation , scaling , and the pace of life in cities .
proc natl acad sci usa 104 : 7301 - 7306 .
alves lga , ribeiro hv , lenzi ek , mendes rs ( 2013 ) distance to the scaling law : a useful approach for unveiling relationships between crime and urban metrics .
plos one 8 : e69580 .
gomez - lievano a , youn h , bettencourt lma ( 2012 ) the statistics of urban scaling and their connection to zipf s law .
plos one 7 : e40393 .
malacarne lc , mendes rs , lenzi ek ( 2001 ) @xmath87-exponential distribution in urban agglomeration .
phys rev e 65 : 017106 .
nj , ribeiro mb ( 2006 ) zipf law for brazilian cities .
physica a 367 : 441 448 .
nunn as , fonseca em , bastos fi , gruskin s , salomon ja ( 2007 ) evolution of antiretroviral drug costs in brazil in the context of free and universal access to aids treatment . plos med 4 : e305 .
porco tc , martin jn , page - shafer ka , cheng a , charlebois e , et al . ( 2004 ) decline in hiv infectivity following the introduction of highly active antiretroviral therapy .
aids 18 : 81 88 .
grangeiro a , escuder mm , menezes pr , alencar r , de castilho ea ( 2011 ) late entry into hiv care : estimated impact on aids mortality rates in brazil , 2003
plos one 6 : e14585 .
ahead of world aids day 2013 unaids reports sustained progress in the aids response .
/ en / resources / presscentre / pressreleaseandstatementarchive/2013/november/20131120report/. accessed on june 2014 .
acuna - soto r , viboud c , chowell g ( 2011 ) influenza and pneumonia mortality in 66 large cities in the united states in years surrounding the 1918 pandemic .
plos one 6 : e23467 . | brazil holds approximately 1/3 of population living infected with aids ( acquired immunodeficiency syndrome ) in central and south americas , and it was also the first developing country to implement a large - scale control and intervention program against aids epidemic . in this scenario , we investigate the temporal evolution and current status of the aids epidemic in brazil . specifically , we analyze records of annual absolute frequency of cases for more than 5000 cities for the first 33 years of the infection in brazil .
we found that _
( i ) _ the annual absolute frequencies exhibit a logistic - type growth with an exponential regime in the first few years of the aids spreading ; _ ( ii ) _ the actual reproduction number decaying as a power law ; _
( iii ) _ the distribution of the annual absolute frequencies among cities decays with a power law behavior ; _
( iv ) _ the annual absolute frequencies and the number of inhabitants have an allometric relationship ; _ ( v ) _ the temporal evolution of the annual absolute frequencies have different profile depending on the average annual absolute frequencies in the cities .
these findings yield a general quantitative description of the aids infection dynamics in brazil since the beginning .
they also provide clues about the effectiveness of treatment and control programs against the infection , that has had a different impact depending on the number of inhabitants of cities .
in this framework , our results give insights into the overall dynamics of aids epidemic , which may contribute to select empirically accurate models . |
the identification of stable charged hadrons at momenta above 1 gev / c is difficult to accomplish , particularly in a colliding beam environment where spatial limitations constrain detector design .
this problem has received increased attention in the past few years in the context of flavor - dependent processes ( e.g. @xmath1 violation ) in decays of @xmath2 mesons , where pions and kaons must be identified with high efficiency and accuracy . to study such processes in @xmath3 collisions at the @xmath4(4s ) resonance will require devices which can provide identification for particles with momenta up to @xmath5 gev / c .
presented here is a design for a particle identification ( pid ) device based on the erenkov effect , working mainly in the threshold mode with a radiator of pressurized gas .
the detector concept is generally applicable in situations with moderately high rates and low particle multiplicities .
it has been applied here to the proposed cleo iii detector@xcite , an upgrade to the cleo ii detector at the cornell electron storage ring , and some of the detector parameters reflect our accommodation of constraints imposed by the existing system .
specifically , the radial gap available for a pid device was fixed at 20 cm , between the main tracking chamber ( at a radius of 82 cm ) and the calorimeter .
in addition , it was prescribed that the pid device should comprise no more than 0.12 radiation lengths of material , so as to have a minimal impact on the performance of the csi calorimeter .
we first discuss the overall approach used to arrive at a design , including development of components and tests needed to establish validity .
a description of a working prototype and tests with cosmic rays follows .
finally , results from these tests are used to tune a monte carlo simulation , which is then used to evaluate the performance of a full - scale system in the proposed cleo iii detector@xcite for physics analyses in symmetric @xmath3 collisions in the @xmath4 region ( @xmath610 gev ) .
a threshold erenkov counter has several advantages over other pid devices .
its readout can be simple and the number of channels few .
the response time is intrinsically fast , and timing and pulse height calibration requirements are minimal .
these features make the offline software requirements rather simple .
furthermore , such a device may be included in the trigger .
design considerations are dominated by the need to maximize photon detection efficiencies , because the absolute number of photons produced by erenkov radiation is relatively small .
it is also desirable to restrict the material thickness of the detector and to minimize inactive volume within the central region .
other considerations include ability to operate in high magnetic fields , robustness , cost , and personnel requirements . as is described below , the index of refraction required for the desired threshold limits the choice of radiator to pressurized gases or silica aerogel @xcite .
we pursued the possibility of pressurized gas because it has better transparency , particularly at shorter wavelengths , where the erenkov spectrum is concentrated .
another advantage of gas is that there is some flexibility to vary the threshold through adjustments of the gas pressure .
the high transparency enables the design of a long cylindrical detector module , in which radiated light is transported up to 2 meters before being detected .
the modules may thus be arranged to span the central solid angle of a collider detector , and are sufficiently large that the number of readout channels required is small , of order 100 .
this system can be made conservatively , relying only on readily available components and proven technologies .
more specific aspects of the design are discussed below . in many detector systems , and specifically in this case , hadrons with momenta below 0.8 gev / c are readily identified through measurements of specific ionization ( de / dx ) in tracking devices , so that the desired range of operation for an additional pid device is in the region above 0.8 gev / c . to provide good identification at 0.8 gev / c
we select an index @xmath7 , which places the pion threshold at 0.70 gev / c .
the kaon threshold for this index is 2.45 gev / c , which is near the kinematic limit for products of @xmath2 decay in the rest frame of @xmath4(4s ) events . for erenkov photons to be detected
, the radiator must transmit them , and the photodetector must be sensitive to them . for a system sensitive to photons with energies between @xmath8 and @xmath9 ( in ev ) , a particle traveling with speed @xmath10 a distance @xmath11 ( in cm ) through a medium with refractive index @xmath12 produces @xmath13 detectable photons , where @xmath14 is the erenkov angle .
the most effective device for detection of individual photons is still the conventional photomultiplier tube , which maintains a high quantum efficiency for wavelengths below 600 nm and may detect photons with wavelengths below 200 nm if the window is made of a medium transparent to them , such as quartz .
sensitivity to shorter wavelengths is desirable , as the erenkov spectrum is more concentrated in that region .
however , because many common impurities absorb strongly at wavelengths below 200 nm , the practical range for detection is 200 - 600 nm ( 2.1 - 6.2 ev ) . in this range , in a material with index @xmath7 ,
1 gev / c pions radiate 30 erenkov photons / cm , while 2.8 gev / c pions radiate 60 photons / cm . if the detector system is able to count the number of photons , some separation of pions and kaons can be maintained even above the kaon threshold ; only 11 photons / cm are emitted by 2.8 gev / c kaons .
thus , pions and kaons at momenta in the range 0.8 - 2.8 gev / c produce erenkov signals which should be readily distinguishable from each other .
the selection of erenkov gases at our chosen index is limited , as many either liquefy under pressure at room temperature before reaching the target index or require undesirably high pressures .
sulfur hexafluoride ( sf@xmath15 ) satisfies our criteria . at an absolute pressure of 20 atmospheres ,
its room - temperature index of refraction is @xmath7 .
its inertness , non - flammability , and previous use as radiator @xcite make it an attractive candidate for this application .
ethane ( c@xmath16h@xmath15 ) is an alternative which reaches the same index at somewhat higher pressure but has a longer radiation length .
the higher pressure required , in combination with its flammability , dissuaded us from pursuing ethane for this design . for pathlengths up to 1 atm@xmath17 m ( 1 m pathlength at 1 atm )
, sf@xmath15 is known to have excellent transparency to light with wavelengths above 190 nm@xcite . however , because this application requires good transparency over a pathlength of 20 atm@xmath17 m , we performed an independent measurement using a mcpherson 218 0.3 m scanning monochromator illuminated by a deuterium lamp .
the monochromator was made to scan through wavelengths from 200 nm to 350 nm .
the resulting beam traversed 1 meter of gas contained in a pressure vessel with sapphire end windows and was detected in an emi - gencom rfi / b-214 solar - blind photomultiplier tube .
the anode current of the photomultiplier , which is proportional to the intensity of the transmitted light , was converted to a dc voltage by a keithley 440 picoammeter , digitized by an ar - b3001 adc plug - in card ( acrosser technologies , inc . ) , and read out at 0.25 nm intervals .
the wavelength scanning and data acquisition of this system were controlled by a personal computer ( ibm at286 equivalent ) .
two grades of sf@xmath15 were studied , instrument ( 99.99% pure ) and ultra - pure ( 99.996% ) . as a baseline reference we used ultra - pure nitrogen ( 99.9999% ) , which has a transparency comparable to vacuum . for a pathlength of 1 atm@xmath17 m , both grades of sf@xmath15
were found to be as transparent as nitrogen above 200 nm , in agreement with @xcite .
each gas scan was therefore normalized to its own 1 atm baseline rather than to nitrogen , reducing substantially the systematic error from variables such as changes in alignment between gas fills or drifting of electronic calibrations over time .
the gas vessel was initially filled with sf@xmath15 at the maximum pressure delivered by the cylinder ( @xmath1820 atm ) and allowed to stabilize @xcite .
scans were then taken at different pressures by releasing gas successively until the ambient pressure was reached , at which point a scan was taken to act as the baseline for that set of measurements .
the resulting transmission efficiencies as a function of wavelength are shown in figure [ fig : sf6_280 ] .
20 atm@xmath17 m of both instrument and ultrapure sf@xmath15 were found to have transparencies comparable to 1 atm@xmath17 m nitrogen , down to 320 nm .
however , at shorter wavelengths , the instrument grade is more transparent than the ultra - pure , confirming the results in @xcite .
more than 90% of light down to 240 nm is transmitted by the instrument grade , dropping to 72% by 200 nm as rayleigh scattering becomes more prevalent .
although it is not known to this group why the lower purity gives better performance , it has the fortuitous result of greatly reducing the cost of the gas needed for this detector . the pressure vessel is designed with a cylindrical shape to insure the required mechanical strength with minimum wall thickness . within each module
, photons are transported via reflections off mirrored surfaces to the tube ends , where they enter a transparent window and are collected by photomultipliers .
the vessel itself should be composed of a strong , low-@xmath19 material to minimize the number of radiation lengths of material penetrated by particles .
in designing a device for cleo iii we envision modules with @xmath1810 cm diameter and 2 m length .
two close packed layers , arranged in a barrel , surround the interaction point just outside the central tracking chamber ( figure [ fig : system ] ) . an economical option for the tube material is aluminum .
a 0.1 cm wall thickness is within the limits prescribed for cleo iii and is adequate from the point of view of safety .
the hoop stress for this design is about 1@xmath20 pa , while al tubes of grade 7075-t6 will maintain their strength to about 5@xmath20 pa , providing a five - fold safety factor .
other materials considered include carbon fiber and beryllium .
these could reduce the material thickness but were not studied fully . the relatively small diameter and long transport distance of the envisioned module place severe constraints on the optical design .
to obtain good collection efficiency , photons should experience no more than 4 - 5 reflections before reaching the photomultiplier , as reflectivities in the ultraviolet region can be expected to be @xmath21 at best .
the simple option of placing a smooth cylindrical reflecting liner in the pressure vessel works remarkably well for tracks which are moderately angled toward the tube ends , at polar angles of 65@xmath22 or less ( @xmath23 ) .
we used a mylar sheet , 0.076 mm thick and coated with a thin film of al and a mgf@xmath16 overcoating@xcite , which was rolled and placed inside the tube .
measurements on one sample indicate that its reflectivity at normal incidence ranges from 7680% at 200 nm to approximately 90% at 600 nm .
for tracks in the central region , at polar angles of 65@xmath22 to 115@xmath22 , the simple cylindrical mirror does not transport sufficient light .
monte carlo simulations show that the efficiency for transporting photons to either end of the tube drops from 30% at 65@xmath22 to zero at 90@xmath22 .
to improve this situation we have developed a specialized reflector for the central region .
it is designed to redirect a large fraction of the photons such that they exit the region before encountering another mirror surface and are then able to reach the end of the module with just one or two additional reflections .
this reflector has a faceted surface with a sawtooth - shaped cross section ( figure [ fig : grating ] ) .
each facet is a planar strip with a width of order 1 mm @xcite , oriented such that an incoming photon produced by a particle from the interaction point is reflected toward the end of the tube , as shown in figure [ fig : bounce ] .
this faceted mirror system extends parallel to the beam line , 0.61 m to either side of the interaction point ( @xmath24 m to @xmath25 m ) , is about 5 cm wide , and faces the beam line .
the optimal combination of facet orientations varies with the polar angle of the incident particle .
our design incorporates ten different mirror sections , each with area @xmath26
@xmath27 and a different combination of angles ( table [ tab : angles ] ) .
the facets reflecting photons toward the nearer phototube make an angle @xmath28 with respect to the @xmath29 axis , while those reflecting photons toward the more distant pmt make an angle @xmath30 , as shown in figure [ fig : grating ] .
the optimal values of @xmath28 and @xmath30 as a function of @xmath29 depend on the tube length , its radius , the perpendicular distance to the interaction point , and the reflectivity as a function of wavelength .
a monte carlo simulation was used to find a set of discrete angles for the ten sections spanning @xmath31 m @xmath32 0.61 m. once a photon reaches the end of the tube , it may need to be funneled to a smaller area in order to be delivered to a photocathode ; affordable pmt s have typical photocathode diameters of 3.8 or 6.4 cm .
in addition , a pmt can not survive a high pressure environment , and must therefore be located outside the pressure vessel .
the light is delivered to the pmt through a quartz window which serves as pressure barrier , uv - transparent window , and light funnel . for this test
the window was made of corning excimer grade quartz , in the shape of a simple truncated cone , with an inner face slightly smaller than the diameter of the tube ( 9.7 cm ) , an outer face matching the photocathode ( 6.4 cm diameter ) , and a thickness of 3.8 cm .
the conical side wall was coated with aluminum .
this window works in two ways : because of the change in index of refraction , rays that come in at large angles of incidence refract to smaller angles , thereby aligning their trajectories more parallel to the axis of the tube ; secondly , many of the photons striking the mirrored conical wall are directed into the pmt .
monte carlo studies of photon transport predict that such a window is about 65% efficient in transmitting photons from the inner face of the window to the photocathode . to minimize transmission loss ,
the windows of the pressure module and the pmt must be coupled to each other by an index matching fluid . using the monochromator apparatus described in section [ radiator ] , we compared transmission of light through the window with and without each of four recommended coupling greases , general electric viscasil , oken 626a , dow corning q2 - 3067 , and shinetsu .
of the four , only the general electric viscasil performed well .
it improved transmission through the window down to 220 nm and gave diminishing efficiency at lower wavelengths , dropping to 80% at 200 nm .
the other three did not transmit light efficiently below 270 nm ( less than 40% transmission ) . in many experimental configurations ,
the pid detector is located in a strong magnetic field . in such cases ,
conventional photomultiplier tubes can not function , and it is necessary to use a specialized photodetector which is able to operate in such an environment .
we tested one such pmt , a hamamatsu r3386 `` fine mesh '' tube @xcite , to evaluate its suitability for this application .
for our erenkov detector the primary concern is resolution , particularly at low light levels ; loss of gain may in principle be recovered with additional amplifiers .
signal resolution in conventional pmt s is determined mainly by photoelectron counting statistics , as well as the quantum efficiency of the photocathode . in fine mesh tubes
the resolution is complicated because the dynodes are partially transparent ( @xmath1850% ) , yielding anomalously shaped distributions at low intensities .
in fact , a single photoelectron signal will not show a well - defined peak , due to this partial transparency@xcite .
to evaluate the hamamatsu r3386 , we set up a test system to deliver calibrated light pulses to the pmt and then to measure the gain and resolution of the output .
a bnc light pulser was used to deliver up to several hundred photons , and pulse height spectra were recorded using a lecroy qvt and a canberra multichannel analyzer .
the light output of the pulser was calibrated using a hamamatsu r2059 `` photon counting '' photomultiplier tube .
the fractional width of the r2059 was found to be ( @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the number of photoelectrons , in agreement with expectations for a `` photon counting '' pmt .
the gain and resolution of the r3386 were then measured in and out of the cleo ii solenoid s 1.5 tesla magnetic field . for this test
the axis of the pmt was oriented parallel to the field .
the high voltage on the r3386 was varied in the range 1200 - 2000 v at 0 t , and 2500 - 2700 v at 1.5 t , such that all measurements could be carried out within the same range of signal heights .
the gains and widths at 0 t were extrapolated to the higher voltage region for comparison with the data at 1.5 t. separate measurements in 0 t at the higher voltages were used to confirm that the extrapolations were reasonable . for signals of three or more photoelectrons delivered to the r3386 in the absence of a magnetic field ,
a clear peak was visible .
the fractional width of the signal was found to be equal to @xmath35 . in the 1.5 t field
the gain was found to be reduced by a factor of @xmath36 .
this corresponds to a mean loss of @xmath1831% in multiplication at each of the sixteen stages of the r3386 .
the width of the signal was measured to be @xmath37 .
the responses to a mean signal of 10 photoelectrons are shown in figure [ fig : pmt ] for magnetic fields of 0 t and 1.5 t. we conclude that the r3386 is suitable for use in our detector but that it is important to take into account the broadening of the signal distribution in predicting identification efficiencies . in our detector simulation the photomultiplier was modeled by broadening the delivered photon signal by 35% .
this is somewhat wider than what we have observed , and should therefore give a conservative assessment of feasibility for this detector .
the electronics to read out this detector needs to satisfy only modest demands .
the number of channels is low , 200 or less , so that cost is not an issue .
resolutions of @xmath38 ns on timing and 5% on pulse height are adequate , and the required dynamic range is three decades .
if the system is to operate in a high magnetic field , preamplification of the phototube signal is required , as the gain of the fine mesh pmt may be as low as @xmath39 . for a gain of @xmath39
, a single photoelectron will result in signal charge of 1.6 fc on the anode .
if this charge is spread over 5 ns , it gives a current amplitude of 0.32@xmath40a .
a preamplifier gain of 30 mv/@xmath40a is needed to translate this into a 10 mv signal .
the noise at the output should be less than 1 mv .
these criteria are nearly satisfied by the lecroy tra4402 , which provides a gain of 25 mv/@xmath40a with an input noise @xmath41 65 na rms ( 1.6 mv at the output ) .
there are other amplifiers which have input noise current more than a factor of 3 lower than this @xcite , which should easily meet the requirements .
to explore the design parameters and to verify the simulation of this complicated optical system , we set up a model of a tubular module with a laser configured to simulate erenkov radiation .
the model tube was half length , 10 cm in diameter , and lined with aluminized mylar d-1 overcoated with mgf@xmath16@xcite .
the simulated radiation , an annular `` cone '' of laser light , entered the tube through one of several ports along its length .
the light was produced with an opening angle of 7.9@xmath22 , to simulate the radiation from a 1 gev / c pion . to produce the conical distribution , the monochromatic beam from a green hene laser was first transported through a beam expander with adjustable mask and iris diaphragm to generate an annular beam of parallel rays .
this beam was then directed onto an axicon , which transformed the beam into an annular cone of light .
the location for the origin of the simulated radiation was adjusted by varying the mask position in the beam expander , and the path length over which the radiation was emitted was set by the iris diaphragm .
this radiation pattern differed from real erenkov light in two ways : it did not have the correct spectral distribution or polarization .
a schematic of the beam and apparatus is shown in figure [ fig : laser ] .
one end of the tube was equipped with an array of photodiodes attached to a movable stage that could scan the entire area of the end of the tube .
the source intensity was measured by shining the cone directly onto the photodiode array .
the transport efficiency is then the ratio of light intensity detected at the end of the tube to the intensity of the source . to correct for temporal fluctuations in laser power ,
a fraction of the beam was extracted via a pellicle beam splitter and monitored during all measurements . to measure its intensity in a manner insensitive to spatial fluctuations ,
the extracted beam was directed into an integrating sphere , where it was diffusely scattered from an inner wall coated with highly reflective white paint and detected in a photodiode placed out of the beam s path . in our first test
, we injected the simulated erenkov light at several angles , each at the position along the tube corresponding to that expected from particles in an actual colliding beam experiment .
a 3.0 cm thick plain quartz disk was placed before the detector array to simulate a thick transparent endplate .
the light intensity was measured over the entire cross section of the tube , and the results were compared to expectations from the simulation . the measured transport efficiency as a function of angle
is shown in figure [ fig : transport ] , with predictions calculated by the same monte carlo simulation used to design the faceted mirror .
the agreement between the measured and simulated efficiencies is excellent .
it varies from zero for a polar angle of 90@xmath22 to 88% for incidence at 43@xmath22 , positions corresponding to the center and end of the tube , respectively . in a detector module
the efficiency is further reduced by the fact that even the larger pmt photocathode ( 6.4 cm diameter ) covers only @xmath1840% of the total cross sectional area of the tube .
thus , with a plain window and the large photocathode , only about 40% of the photons reaching the window would strike the photocathode .
this yield can be raised to around 65% by using the conical window discussed earlier .
data taken with the conical window , shown as triangles in figure [ fig : transport ] , are in agreement with this prediction . finally , several 5@xmath425 @xmath27 prototype sections of the faceted mirror were produced commercially@xcite .
a single section , designed for placement at polar angles near 90@xmath22 , was inserted near the far end of the tube .
a particle at 90@xmath22 was simulated and the delivered light measured with each of the two windows in place .
the transport efficiency was found to be ( 22@xmath432)% for the plain window .
the simulation predicts a value of ( 23@xmath431)% , in good agreement with the measurement .
these values imply an efficiency of around 8% for delivery to a 6.4 cm diameter photocathode . for the conical window
the corresponding efficiency was measured to be ( 13@xmath432)% . in a detector module ,
photons produced by tracks incident at a 90@xmath22 polar angle are reflected equally by the faceted mirrors to both ends of the tube , so the total transport efficiency with the conical window will be 26% .
to verify several critical aspects of the design , we constructed one half - length module to serve as a prototype ( figure [ fig : crtower ] ) . a 1 m long , 10 cm
diameter stainless steel tube was lined with aluminized mylar d-1 overcoated with mgf@xmath16 @xcite .
two prototype sections of the faceted mirror were placed inside the tube near one end , corresponding to the center of a full - length module , and the endplate was blackened to eliminate extraneous reflections . placed at the other end of the tube was a hamamatsu r4143q photomultiplier with quartz window , viewing the pressurized gas through the mirrored conical quartz window , described earlier .
the pmt was optically coupled to the quartz window using general electric viscasil .
to study the response of this prototype module to energetic particles , we constructed a cosmic ray telescope , using plastic scintillators to trigger on muons with momentum above 1 gev / c .
three small scintillators above the module insured that the cosmic rays passed directly through the desired region of the gas .
an 82 cm thick absorber of lead was placed directly below the prototype , and two larger scintillators were placed under the lead . to trigger all five scintillators in coincidence ,
a cosmic ray muon would need not only to pass through the prototype at the desired position and angle , but also to have sufficient momentum to penetrate the lead , at least 1.0 gev / c .
the prototype was supported on a u - channel which pivoted about a steel rod such that its angle with respect to the vertical axis and its position along the tube axis could be easily modified . a schematic view of the cosmic ray test configuration is shown in figure [ fig : crtower ] .
the photomultiplier signal from the prototype was amplified by a hewlett packard 5582a linear amplifier and delivered to a canberra 750plus series pulse height analyzer .
the gate for the signal was 4 @xmath40s wide , generated in an eg&g 416a gate generator by a five - fold coincidence of the scintillators .
the measured signal was calibrated by operating the photomultiplier with its face covered , such that the observed signal corresponded to single photoelectron noise .
the erenkov light yields were studied for cosmic rays at many positions along the length of the module . in one set of readings ,
the incidence angle and position were varied simultaneously to reproduce those expected of particles entering the actual detector .
this set consisted of the following combinations of polar angle ( @xmath44 ) and distance from the window ( @xmath45 ) : ( a ) @xmath46 , @xmath45=35 cm , ( b ) @xmath47 , @xmath45=50 cm , ( c ) @xmath48 , @xmath45=65 cm , and ( d ) @xmath49 , @xmath45=75 cm .
in the final detector , there would be a faceted mirror module at each of the settings ( b ) , ( c ) and ( d ) , but in this test none was employed .
these test configurations were duplicated in a monte carlo simulation , where particles penetrate the prototype and generate erenkov photons at the expected rate , distributed at the expected angles and energies .
each photon then propagates through the gas volume and is absorbed or reflected at each mirrored surface encountered with a wavelength - dependent probability based on the measured reflectivity .
a photon reaching the front face of the end window may be either reflected from the quartz or transmitted . after entering the quartz , a photon
is reflected back out the front face , absorbed by the mirrored wall , or transmitted to the photocathode .
once the photon enters the photocathode , the manufacturer s tabulation of its quantum efficiency is used to determine whether a photoelectron is produced .
the data were compared with the monte carlo predictions , and simulation parameters were adjusted until agreement was achieved .
we found that excellent agreement was obtained if the reflectivity of the liner in the simulation was adjusted upward by approximately 1% over all wavelengths .
since the reflectivity used originally as input to the simulation was measured on an earlier sample than the liner in the prototype , it is possible that an improvement was made .
figure [ fig : data1 ] shows one set of data with its prediction from the tuned simulation . after verifying agreement between the simulation and data without the faceted mirror
, we aligned the prototype module horizontally , in an orientation corresponding to a polar angle of 90@xmath50 .
for each of several positions , a faceted mirror section was placed such that erenkov photons would strike it and be directed toward the pmt .
the mirror and trigger were set up such that cosmic rays entered at average distances of 45 cm , 57 cm , 73 cm , and 90 cm from the pmt .
it is important to note that only the 90 cm position corresponds to a physical situation if the module were installed around an interaction region . in this configuration , because the area of a faceted mirror section is comparable to that of the trigger counters , the raw data include events where most of the light misses the faceted section . to account for such events ,
each test was repeated with the mirror section covered with black paper , and the resulting spectrum was normalized to the number of triggers and subtracted directly from the raw data collected with the mirror section uncovered .
the results are in good agreement with our simulation , if the reflectivity of the mirror sections is taken to be about 0.65 times that of the reflective liner .
the sections used here were the first replicas to be produced from a master .
it is expected that with a better understanding of the replication process , the reflectivity of the faceted mirrors would increase substantially .
results for the 90 cm position are shown in figure [ fig : data2 ] .
the agreement between data and monte carlo is excellent , giving us confidence that the simulation is a reasonable representation of the prototype and that the critical parameters of this system are well understood . in the final system ,
the light collected from charged particles penetrating near the center of the detector module would be approximately doubled , as the module would be approximately twice as long and would be instrumented with pmt s at both ends .
to evaluate the effectiveness of the full detector system for physics results , the monte carlo simulation described in the previous section was incorporated into the cleo iii geant - based @xcite package .
it was then used to study two specific physics problems in @xmath3 annihilation events in the @xmath4 region : ( 1 ) separation of modes @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and ( 2 ) extraction of @xmath53 from a large background of @xmath54 .
this simulation includes track curvature due to the magnetic field , interactions at the various detector interfaces , splashback from interactions in the csi electromagnetic calorimeter , and the performance of the fine mesh pmt in a magnetic field .
the signal for each module is derived by summing the outputs from both pmt s . since a track almost always traverses two modules , the net signal is the sum of outputs from two to four pmt s .
the noise rate of the fine mesh pmt is of the order of 1 khz above the 0.5 p.e .
level , and the event gate in cleo is estimated to be in the 100 ns range ; this implies that there is no significant noise contribution when the outputs of more than one pmt are summed .
first , single @xmath55 and @xmath56 tracks were generated with momenta in the range 0.8 - 3.0 gev / c and polar angles between 45@xmath50 and 135@xmath50 ( this angular region is set by the active volume of the detector ) . as an example , we show in figure [ fig : pik25 ] the expected photoelectron yield for pions and kaons of momenta 1.0 and 2.5 gev / c and polar angle between 85@xmath50 and 95@xmath50 . at 2.5 gev
/ c the kaons are slightly above threshold . beyond the expected signal
, it is seen that a small fraction of kaons produce a substantial false signal due to an interaction in the material before the detector , which may produce a pion or delta ray which is above threshold . to be identified as pions ( kaons ) , we require the photoelectron yield to be above ( below ) a certain value .
the cut values are different for pions and kaons and are functions of the track momentum and polar angle . to reduce the rate of false identifications due to interactions , we require alignment between the projected track and the shower centroid as measured in the calorimeter .
the degree of alignment required is in the range 1.7@xmath22 - 2.3@xmath22 and depends primarily on the track momentum .
it is chosen such that 80% of pions pass it . in table
[ tab : str ] we show the net pion efficiency , @xmath57 , and kaon fake rate , @xmath58 , where the cuts have been optimized by maximizing @xmath59 , which is proportional to the ratio of signal to background ( s / b ) . at
momenta 2.5 - 2.8 gev / c , s / b ranges from about 30 to 60 , depending on the angle of the track ; this translates roughly to 2.5@xmath0 @xmath60 separation .
combining this information with measurements of specific ionization in the drift chamber will increase the @xmath60 separation to above 3@xmath0 @xcite . using the criteria
developed from simulations of single @xmath55 and @xmath56 tracks , we studied some specific decay modes in fully simulated events .
the efficiencies presented below are due only to particle identification , since all other efficiencies , such as geometric cuts , kinematic cuts , lepton identification , and isolation of tracks to eliminate multiple hits , cancel to first order for this evaluation .
we have studied the two decays @xmath61 and @xmath62 , where each mode poses the most serious background for the other and the two branching fractions are thought to be comparable .
if we choose pulse height cuts by maximizing s / b , we find that the pid efficiency for detecting the @xmath63 final state is @xmath64 , whereas the background from the @xmath65 state is @xmath66 .
if instead , we wish to detect @xmath61 , then the efficiency is @xmath67 and the background from the @xmath68 final state is @xmath69 .
these efficiencies imply a rejection ratio of at least 1/20 , which corresponds to a separation of 2.5@xmath0 .
the s / b for the two modes are different because kaons have a long tail at high photoelectron yields , while pions do not have a similar tail at low yields .
further separation between the two samples can be achieved by using de / dx information @xcite from the drift chamber and the kinematic quantity @xmath70 .
we also studied the decay @xmath71 , a cabbibo - suppressed decay where there is a large background from the unsuppressed decay @xmath72 . in this case
, cuts were optimized by maximizing s@xmath73/(s+b ) , where the @xmath55 mode was assumed to have a rate 15 times smaller than the @xmath56 mode .
we selected @xmath74 mesons produced with momenta above 1.9 gev / c , and with @xmath55 or @xmath56 polar angle between 45@xmath50 and 135@xmath50 .
the resulting efficiencies for detecting the pion in @xmath75 and fake rates from kaons in @xmath72 are presented in table [ tab : semil ] .
these results indicate a s / b of about 20 .
it is clear that , even after allowing for the higher rate for @xmath76 , the final sample is enriched with the signal decay .
this is much better than the current cleo ii performance@xcite , where the final sample is dominated by background from @xmath77 events .
additional signal enhancement may be achieved through kinematic requirements and measurements of specific ionization@xcite .
it has been demonstrated that a simple , compact gas threshold erenkov counter which utilizes commercially produced photodetectors can provide hadron identification in the momentum region 1 - 3 gev / c .
the design described here can be implemented as is , with the development of a mechanical design .
possible improvements requiring some further development include better quality reflective liners and faceted mirrors , optimized design of the quartz window , and use of low-@xmath19 materials such as carbon fiber or beryllium in the tubes to reduce the thickness of material .
in addition , continuing improvements in photodetection technology are beginning to yield devices with better operating characteristics , _
e.g. _ , higher quantum efficiency , than the fine mesh pmt studied here@xcite .
although this detector was developed for implementation in the cleo iii detector , it could be used in a much broader set of applications .
because of its speed and the low number of readout channels , it can be used in most settings with moderately high rate and low particle multiplicities . by using multiple layers and varying gas pressures ,
this design can be applied to all particles with momenta above 1 gev / c , up to 10 gev and above .
these are difficult regions in which to achieve hadron identification , and the detector presented here does so simply and at moderate cost .
thanks are due for assistance provided by colleagues in the cleo collaboration , to brian heltsley for assistance with incorporating our monte carlo into the cleo iii geant environment , to jim alexander for providing funds for materials from his nsf - pyi award , and to the high energy physics group at the university of california , santa barbara , for use of equipment .
we thank karl berkelman and the laboratory of nuclear studies , cornell university , for providing laboratory space and material for conducting this research .
jim mccormick of hamamatsu corp .
is gratefully acknowledged for providing us with a fine mesh photomultiplier tube for test purposes .
jon e. sollid of sollid optics , inc . ,
is acknowledged for providing valuable advice on the design and for finding sources for many of the optical components critical to our tests .
since the operating pressure is very close to the liquification point of sf@xmath15 , transmission immediately after filling was poor .
once stable , transmission was observed to remain constant over periods of greater than one week . according to our simulation
, the facet strips may be as wide as 3 mm without undue loss of signal .
the larger width is desirable for reducing the cost associated with fabricating master forms for the mirrors but increases the net thickness of the mirror .
the 1 mm width in our design was chosen as a compromise between thickness and cost .
a. sawaki _
_ , ieee trans .
* ns-31 , 1 * ( 1984 ) 442 ; m. d. rousseau _
_ , ieee trans .
* ns-30 , 1 * ( 1983 ) 479 ; h. kume _ et al .
_ , ieee trans .
* ns-32 , 1 * ( 1985 ) 355 ; s. suzuki _ et al .
_ , ieee trans .
* ns-33 , 1 * ( 1986 ) 377 . in cleo
ii pions and kaons of momenta less than 0.8 gev / c can be separated by better than 3.0@xmath0 , and those above 2 gev / c or so can be separated by 1.5 - 2.0@xmath0 .
it is expected that cleo iii performance will be similar . | we discuss the design and performance of a threshold erenkov counter for identification of charged hadrons .
the radiator is pressurized gas , which is contained in thin - walled cylindrical modules .
a mirror system of novel design transports erenkov photons to photomultiplier tubes .
this system is compact , contains relatively little material , and has a large fraction of active volume .
a prototype of a module designed for the proposed cleo iii detector has been studied using cosmic rays .
results from these studies show good agreement with a detailed monte carlo simulation of the module and indicate that it should achieve separation of pions and kaons at the 2.5@xmath0 - 3.0@xmath0 level in the momentum range 0.8 - 2.8 gev / c .
we predict performance for specific physics analyses using a geant - based simulation package . |
graphene plasmons ( gps ) , the intrinsic collective oscillations of electrons coupled with electromagnetic waves in doped graphene , have attracted enormous interests for their unique properties , including such as inherently highly controllable , long - lived and extremely electromagnetic field confinement and enhancement in mid - infrared and terahertz spectral regimes@xcite . since theoretically proposed by jablan _
et al _ in 2009@xcite , gps have been widely studied for electro - optical modulation@xcite , quantum plasmonics@xcite , light harvesting@xcite , transformation optics@xcite and infrared biosensors@xcite at nanometer scale . due to large wavevector mismatch between gps and free light field , propagating gps
are usually excited by deep sub - wavelength point - like sources@xcite . in these cases ,
the sources such as emitters , absorbers and scatterers serve as dipoles perpendicular or parallel to the propagation plane of gps@xcite . however , the propagation direction of excited gps is usually isotropic in the graphene plane as a result of the symmetry of structures and excitation configurations . and the unidirectional launching of gps is still unsolved problem although it is important in ultracompact plasmonic devices at the chip scale .
on the other hand , to achieve highly directional launching of surface waves in metal , attempts have been made to break the symmetry by introducing oblique incidence@xcite , double slits@xcite and circularly polarized incident waves@xcite , etc . among the numerous reported methods ,
the use of near field interference of a circularly polarized wave is cornerstone for active switching , along with very high extinction ratio between different directions .
however , the current experimental effort to mimic a two - dimensional rotating dipole by oblique incidence is controversial due to the inevitable magnetic induction currents@xcite .
it is well - known that two orthogonally oriented dipoles can be induced by two orthogonally polarized incident plane waves .
aware of that a circularly polarized dipole can be efficiently mimicked by a nanowire illuminated by two orthogonal plane waves due to the extremely localization of gps , it is natural for us to consider realizing unidirectional generation of gps by using a combined circularly polarized dipole in unstructured graphene .
furthermore , the combined dipoles can be separated in space compared to a single circularly polarized dipole , which provides us another degree of freedom to control the excitation of gps . in this study , two orthogonally
oriented dipoles are employed to efficiently excite symmetric and anti - symmetric charge ordering modes in flat and arc graphene planes .
as long as the constructive and destructive interferences of near - fields take place in different propagation directions , the unidirectional launching of gps occurs . due to the inherent phase difference between symmetric and anti - symmetric evanescent modes induced by @xmath1-polarized and @xmath0-polarized dipoles , the extra phase difference of @xmath2/2 , e.g. , circularly polarized dipoles , should be introduced . moreover ,
when the circularly polarized dipole is decomposed into two linear polarized ones and separated on different sides of the graphene , the behaviors of induced charge distribution and handedness of the background field are opposite . in
further , the circularly polarized dipole can be efficiently mimicked by a semiconductor nanowire illuminated by two orthogonally polarized plane waves in experiments , and the problem about magnetic induction currents induced by oblique incidence can be solved in our considered system .
we believe our findings should be found applications in compact plasmonic circuits in mid - infrared and terahertz regimes .
the phenomena of unidirectional excitation of gps can be understood by considering a dipole placed at a subwavelength distance close to a free standing graphene sheet .
[ fig1](a ) illustrates the scheme employed in our design .
a two - dimensional ( 2d ) dipole with momentum @xmath3 $ ] is placed above a graphene sheet .
a cartesian coordinate system is chosen with the graphene sheet laying in @xmath4 and the position of the dipole is ( 0 , @xmath5 ) . without loss of generality ,
the result can be extended to three - dimensional ( 3d ) treatment directly@xcite .
the vector potential * a * induced by the dipole without graphene can be expressed as @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the 2d green s function in free space@xcite , and @xmath8 is wavenumber in vacuum .
the angular spectrum decomposition of the vector potential can be written as @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the longitude wavenumber .
thus the magnetic field can be deduced as @xmath11e^{ik_z|z - z_{\text{dip}}|}e^{ik_xx}dk_x}$ ] .
the angular spectrum of the magnetic field can be written as @xmath12e^{ik_z|z - z_{\text{dip}}|}$ ] .
schematic of directional excitation of graphene plasmons by a dipole source .
the dipole source can be mimicked by a semiconductor nanowire .
, width=321 ] next we turn to the case where the dipole is laid on top of graphene . due to the extremely large wavenumber of gps ,
i.e. , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 is satisfied , so the induced magnetic field has a relation of @xmath15 .
one can conclude that the complete interferences take place as long as @xmath16 and @xmath17 have equally modulus with phase difference of @xmath18/2 .
the contribution from the graphene can be included by introducing reflected and transmitted fields , which can be calculated via simply multiplying the individual angular spectrums with corresponding fresnel coefficients @xmath19 and @xmath20 , respectively .
when the dimensionless conductivity @xmath21 in units of the fine - structure constant @xmath22 was adopted , the fresnel coefficients can be written as@xcite : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is dielectric constant of substrate , @xmath10 and @xmath25 are magnitudes of the longitudinal wavenumbers . for the reflected and transmitted fields , one can obtain the angular spectra @xmath26e^{ik_z(z+z_{\text{dip}})}$ ] and @xmath27e^{-ik_z(z - z_{\text{dip}})}$ ] , respectively .
the angular spectra of total magnetic fields in the spaces on top of and bottom of graphene are calculated as @xmath28 and @xmath29 , respectively . from the customary boundary condition and charge conservation law , i.e. , @xmath30 and @xmath31 , the induced charge density @xmath32 in the graphene layer
can be obtained from the difference of magnetic fields at each side of the graphene @xmath33 from now on , the prefactor @xmath34 will be omitted for convenience , thus the angular spectrum of @xmath32 can be written as @xmath35e^{ik_zz_{\text{dip}}}\\ \rho_s^{ind}(k_x)={[t^p-(1+r^p)]}\frac{ik_x}{4\pi}[p_z\frac{k_x}{k_z}+p_x]e^{ik_zz_{\text{dip}}}.\ ] ] noting that @xmath19 and @xmath20 depend on the modulus of @xmath36 only , naturally , one can divide the contributions of a circularly polarized dipole into two parts , i.e. , @xmath37 .
the former induced by @xmath0-polarized dipole ( abbreviated as @xmath16 for convenience ) satisfies @xmath38 , while the latter induced by @xmath1-polarized dipole satisfies @xmath39 .
the fundamental mechanism for directional generation is the charge density induced by @xmath16 has an even parity both in angular spectrum and real space@xcite , whereas the opposite hold true for a @xmath17 dipole .
the superposition of @xmath40 and @xmath41 ( not the @xmath42 with opposite parities ) leads to the constructive and destructive interferences in different directions . when the @xmath16 or @xmath17 dipole is moved to its image position ( 0 , -@xmath43 ) , noting that @xmath44 and the minus sign should be adopted before @xmath17 in the expressions of @xmath42 thanks to @xmath45 , therefore the charge density can be written as @xmath46 where the tildes means the quantity induced by dipoles located at its image position .
therefore , one can obtain the relation of @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
this result means that moving the @xmath16 dipole to its image position will switch the preferred propagation direction of gps , while moving the @xmath17 dipole will not change the preferred direction .
this behavior is quite counterintuitive . because the magnetic field induced by the dipole satisfied @xmath49 and @xmath50 , which means that moving a @xmath17 dipole to its image position will change the incident dipole fields , while they keep unchanged when moving @xmath16 dipoles .
combination of these two facts leads to an amazing result that the incident and induced fields have different preferred propagation directions .
remarkably , the finally preferred direction of gps is determined by the induced charge pattern rather than the incident field .
there are a lot of parameters to quantitative describe the asymmetrical excitation . among them ,
the angular spectrum ratios satisfy @xmath51\equiv|f(k_x)/f(-k_x)|=|\frac{\frac{p_z}{p_x}\frac{k_x}{k_z}+1}{-\frac{p_z}{p_x}\frac{k_x}{k_z}+1}|$ ] , ( @xmath52 ) which depend on @xmath53 only
. moreover , the spatial dependent near field ratios defined as @xmath54\equiv|f(x)/f(-x)|$ ] , ( @xmath55 ) are also very important for gps which can be obtained via full - field simulations and verified by near field experiments directly . in engineering ,
another important parameter to quantify the asymmetrical transmission is extinction ratio , which is defined as the logarithm of energy flux ratio in opposite directions @xmath56 .
the right and left energy flux along the graphene can be obtained by integrating the relative poynting vector along @xmath0 direction far from the dipole source @xmath57
we present several scenarios in which the proper choices of dipoles close to graphene sheet provide possibilities for directional excitation of gps .
first of all , we consider the basic model described in sec [ sec : level2 ] , and compare the simulated results to the analytical results calculated from angular spectra . in the simulation ,
the frequency of electromagnetic field emitted by the dipole is 30 thz ( corresponding to @xmath58 ) .
the dipole is situated at a distance of @xmath59 on top of the graphene plane and has a momentum of [ 1 , @xmath60@xmath17 , where the unit length momentum @xmath61 is adopted for convenience , and the ratio @xmath62 is discussed later .
chemical potential of the doped graphene is set as @xmath63=0.4 ev , and ambient temperature is set as t=300 k , the in - plane conductivity of the graphene is computed within the local - random phase approximation ( rpa)@xcite with an intrinsic relaxation time @xmath64 fs ( indicating the mobility of @xmath65 @xmath66/vs ) , which is a typical parameter derived from experiments@xcite .
commercial software comsol multiphysics based on fem method is adopted to solve the maxwell equations . from the dispersion relations of gps ,
the wavenumber of gps for this free - standing graphene is @xmath67 , indicating the plasmon wavelength @xmath68 is 459 nm , and the extinction parameter is @xmath69 .
therefor @xmath70 will lead to completely destructive interference of the excited gps in a certain direction .
directional excitation of gps by a circularly polarized dipole .
( a ) magnetic field distributions for gps excited by a 2d circularly polarized dipole @xmath71p_0 $ ] , where @xmath72 .
( b ) angular momentum spectra of initial ( @xmath73 ) , reflective ( @xmath74 ) and total ( @xmath42 ) magnetic field magnitude of the polarized dipole ( solid lines ) and an ideal circularly polarized ( dashed lines ) .
the dotted lines indicate the wavenumbers of gps .
( c ) the simulated ( solid line ) and analytically calculated ( marked by red circle ) spatial dependent charge density in graphene .
( d ) spatial dependent near field ratio @xmath75=|h_y^\text{ref}(x)/h_y^\text{ref}(-x)|$](colored in black ) , @xmath76=|\rho(x)/\rho(-x)|$](colored in red ) and @xmath77=|p_x(x)/p_x(-x)|$](colored in blue).,width=321 ] the simulated distribution of @xmath42 field @xmath78 is depicted in fig .
[ fig2](a ) .
clearly , the plasmon mode is unidirectionally excited by the circularly polarized dipole , which has a much larger amplitude along @xmath79 than @xmath80 . besides , one can find that the background field is anticlockwise rotational due to the individual rotational dipole source .
thus the angular momentum density of the background field is @xmath81 , which is along @xmath82 direction , where @xmath83 is the poynting vector@xcite .
moreover , the angular momentum direction of preferred exited gps is consistent with the angular momentum direction of background fields due to the conservation of angular momentum . when the phase difference between @xmath17 and @xmath16 changes from @xmath84 to @xmath85 or placing the rotational polarized dipole on bottom of the graphene plane , the directions of angular momentum as well as the propagating gps inverse
. therefor one can determine the preferred excitation directions simply by the direction of angular momentum .
on the other hand , the directional excitation of gps in real space can be understood by the asymmetry of the angular spectra in different directions .
the angular spectra of initial , reflected and total magnetic fields are shown in fig .
[ fig2](b ) .
one can find the angular spectra have constructive and destructive interferences at @xmath86 and @xmath87 , respectively . to understand this effect ,
the fresnel coefficient @xmath19 is considered within plasmon pole approximation ( @xmath88 ) .
the coefficient @xmath89 has peaks when @xmath90 .
specifically , when @xmath62 equals to @xmath91 , @xmath92 , this is a peak due to constructive interference and the intensity is twice larger than the magnitude of magnetic field induced by @xmath17 or @xmath16 individually . in the same manner , the valley exists due to constructive interference occurs at @xmath93 . as a result ,
the angular spectra of initial , reflected and total fields have peaks at @xmath94 as well as valleys at @xmath95 for @xmath96 .
as to an ideal rotational polarized dipole , e.g. @xmath62 equals to @xmath97 , and @xmath98 is about 2 owing to @xmath99 .
however , there is a remarkable difference near @xmath100 , where it is a peak instead of valley for the ideal circularly polarized dipole .
this comes from that @xmath101 is maxima at @xmath95 and @xmath102 is a slowly varying quantity . in
further , the spatial distribution of charge density is a vital physical quantity to describe the collective oscillations , such as plasmons . in fig .
[ fig2](c ) , the simulated charge density distribution in the graphene plane is compared to the analytical result from eq .
( [ rho ] ) .
they are in perfect agreement and have apparently constructive and destructive interferences in @xmath103 and @xmath104 , respectively . the spatial dependent near field ratios of exited gps
are shown in fig .
[ fig2](d ) .
we can see that the near field ratios of reflected magnetic , charge density and energy flux are over 100 for @xmath105 .
directional excitation of gps by two separated orthogonal polarized dipoles .
( a ) magnetic field distributions for gps excited by two orthogonal polarized dipoles @xmath106p_0 $ ] and @xmath107p_0 $ ] located at ( 0 , 0.01@xmath108 ) and ( 0 , -0.01@xmath108 ) , respectively .
the insert figure shows the enlarged excitation region .
( b ) angular momentum spectra of initial magnetic field magnitude ( @xmath73 ) and charge density ( @xmath109 ) in the graphene plane , the initial and induced quantities have opposite preferred direction for excitation of gps .
( c ) the simulated ( solid line ) and analytically calculated ( marked by red circle ) spatial dependent charge density in graphene .
( d ) the spatial dependent extinction ratio for a single circularly polarized dipole ( case , colored in black ) , and two separated orthogonal polarized dipoles ( case , colored in red).,width=321 ] a circularly polarized dipole can be decomposed into two orthogonal polarized dipoles , thus it is interesting to see what will happen if these two dipoles are placed on the different sides of graphene .
specifically , two orthogonal polarized dipoles with momenta @xmath110p_0 $ ] and @xmath107p_0 $ ] are considered , where they are located at ( 0 , 0.01@xmath108 ) and ( 0 , -0.01@xmath108 ) , respectively .
the simulated results are shown in fig .
( [ fig3 ] ) .
one can find that the rotational direction of background field in fig .
[ fig3](a ) is the same as that in fig .
[ fig2](a ) , however , the propagation direction of excited gps inverses .
this result means that one can not distinguish these two cases from the far fields excepted for the preferred propagation direction of excited gps .
considering that the @xmath42 is discontinuous across the graphene plane , the @xmath74 changes from upside to downside of graphene when the dipole is placed to its image position .
meanwhile , @xmath73 and the induced charge @xmath109 remain unique .
similar to the results in fig .
[ fig2](b ) , the angular spectra of @xmath73 and @xmath109 are also shown in fig .
[ fig3](b ) to demonstrate the mechanism of directional excitation in this scenario .
remarkably , the preferred directions of background field and induced charge are opposite , which are along @xmath79 and @xmath80 , respectively .
this result is rather counterintuitive and means that the angular momentum is non - conservation at first sight .
actually , one can find this puzzling result comes from the magnetic field discontinuity at upper and lower sides of graphene ( @xmath111 ) , and the angular momentum is conservation . in our proposed scheme ,
the angular momentum is zero at the original point with both positive and negative signs in @xmath4 plane simultaneously .
thus the use of the conservation of angular momentum can not determine the preferred direction of gps directly .
to demonstrate the physical factor to determine the preferred directions , we turn to see the dependence of directional generation on phase difference @xmath112 .
similar to the superposition of polarizations , these two opposite sense of rotations lead to a classification of vibration ellipses according to their handedness , which is decided by the phase difference of two vibration vectors .
if the phase difference satisfies @xmath113 , the superpositions are linear polarized dipoles , and their angular momenta is zero due to @xmath114 , thus the excited gps should be isotropic without any other asymmetry to fulfill the conservation of angular momentum .
when the phase difference satisfies @xmath115 , the near fields rotates in the anticlockwise sense , it is said to be left - handed .
if extra @xmath2 phase is introduce to the @xmath116 , the handedness and preferred direction of excitation will change . in the proposed system
, there are three important factors to determine the handedness and preferred direction .
the first one is the initial phase difference @xmath116 which is from the dipoles themselves , e.g. , if the initial @xmath117 changes from @xmath84 to @xmath118 , the handedness , i.e. , rotational direction of background field and preferred direction will change .
the second factor is the dipole position relative to the graphene . from the relation
@xmath119 $ ] , one can known that moving @xmath17 dipole to its image position will introduced a minus sign due to the sign function , which is equivalent to introduce extra @xmath2 phase difference when talking about the handedness and the initial electromagnetic field , while there is no extra phase difference when moving the @xmath16 dipoles to their image position . the total extra phase difference from aforementioned two factors
will determine the handedness and the preferred direction of initial field .
however , they are insufficient to determine the preferred direction of exited gps . noting that the scattering field of upper and lower sides of graphene satisfied @xmath120 for free standing graphene , which introduced a minus sign compared to the continuous boundary condition @xmath121 .
this is the last vital factor to determine the preferred direction of induced field .
actually , the aforementioned counterintuitive result is originated from the minus sign , which can not be treated as extra phase difference as before because it only acts on induced field and do not affect the handedness and the distribution of initial magnetic field . in a word , there are three factors for @xmath17 to affect the preferred direction of excited gps , while only two factors for @xmath16 to affect the preferred direction of excited gps in our considered system .
when the @xmath17 and @xmath16 locate in the same side of graphene , @xmath122 always denotes the magnetic field in the dipole side , thus the angular momentums of @xmath73 and @xmath109 have the same sign owing to the conservation of angular momentum .
when they are in the different side , @xmath74 in @xmath4 induced by the two dipoles denotes different sides of graphene , and the preferred direction of gps should be decided by @xmath109 rather than @xmath73 . due to the extra minus sign ,
the preferrer direction of @xmath109 and @xmath73 is always opposite in this condition .
the spatial dependent induced charge density is plotted in fig . [ fig3](c ) .
one can find that the charge oscillates only in the -@xmath1 direction which is in good agreement with the analytical result .
the comparison of spatial dependent extinction ratio of a single circularly polarized dipole ( named after case ) and two orthogonal polarized dipoles placed at both sides of the graphene ( named after case ) are shown in fig . [ fig3](d ) .
one can see the extinction ratio is over 20 for @xmath123 , and the ratio in case is less than that in case , this originates from the opposite preferred directions of the initial and induced fields in case .
the difference on extinction ratio between these two cases can be ignored when @xmath124 .
directional excitation of gps on curved free - standing graphene . the distribution of magnetic field @xmath125 for gps excited by the configuration of case ( a ) and two separated orthogonal polarized dipoles ( c ) .
simulated and analytically calculated spatial dependent charge density for the case ( b ) and case ( d ) .
the phase in ( c ) is set as @xmath2/4 in order to show the two individual sources.,width=321 ] except for the scenario of directional excitation of gps in a flat graphene plane , the directional generation of gps on a curved free - standing graphene sheet is also investigated .
the curvature breaks the mirror symmetry relative to graphene plane , then the induced radiative loss will affect the excitation and propagation efficiency of gps .
the critical curvature radius which permits confined wave exist can be calculated by @xmath126 , thus a circular radii as @xmath127 is chosen , which is a typical value in flexible transformation plasmonics@xcite .
a circularly polarized dipole with momentum as the same as in flat graphene is placed above the graphene circle at a distance of 100 nm .
the configuration and simulated @xmath42 field amplitude are shown in fig . [ fig4](a ) .
remarkably , the mode propagates mainly along clockwise direction . which is in coincide with the result in flat graphene ( case ) .
we can describe the induced charge density by @xmath128)+\rho^f(x\in[-2 \pi r , -\pi r ] ) , l\in[0 , \pi
r]\\ \rho(l)\approx\rho^f(x)+\rho^f(x\mp2\pi r ) , ~l\in(-\pi r , \pi r ] % \rho&\approx&\rho^f(x\in[-\pi r , 0])+\rho^f(x\in[\pi r , 2\pi r ] ) , l\in[-\pi r , 0]\\ % \rho(l)&\approx&\rho^f(x)+\rho^f(x+2\pi r ) , ~l\in[-\pi r , 0)\ ] ] the upper ( lower ) sign in eq . [ eqrho ] applies to @xmath129 ( @xmath130 ) , where @xmath131 is arc length away from the dipole .
the spatial charge density ratio is shown in fig . [ fig4](b ) .
one can know that the directional excitation behavior of gps in arc surface can be understood well by flat graphene with the same parameter .
when the circularly polarized dipole is decomposed into two dipoles located both above and below the graphene , the simulated @xmath42 field amplitude shown in [ fig4](c ) and charge density distribution shown in [ fig4](d ) can be understood well from flat graphene in configuration of case .
these results show that directional propagation of gps can be extended into arc surfaces directly .
directional excitation of gps using @xmath132 nanowires illuminated by two orthogonally polarized plane waves .
( a ) schematics representation and electric field distributions @xmath133 for excited gps , the insert figure is normalized absorption cross section of the @xmath132 nanowire with radii of 20 nm , 50 nm and 100 nm .
( b ) the dependence of the angular spectrum ratios @xmath134 on extinction parameter @xmath135 .
the blue circle indicates the parameter of the considered nanowire .
the insert figure is the polarized circle of the nanowire with ( solid line ) and without ( broken line ) graphene sheet .
( c ) the simulated and theoretically calculated spatial dependent charge density in graphene .
the thick line indicates the charge distribution induced by ideal circular polarized dipole with dipole momentum as @xmath136 , the thin line indicate the case of dipole momentum as @xmath137 and @xmath138 , respectively .
the dot marked line indicates the simulated result of semiconductor nanowire .
( d ) the energy flux ratio of ideal dipole ( @xmath139 , solid line ) , actual dipole(@xmath138 , broken line ) and simulated result of semiconductor nanowire ( thick line).,width=321 ] next , we turn to discuss how to realize our proposal in real experiments .
the dipole employed in the paper can be mimicked by a semiconductor nanowire illuminated by two orthogonally polarized plane waves . due to the wave interference ,
the background standing wave satisfies @xmath140 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 , thus the amplitude condition of ideal circular dipole requires @xmath143 , where @xmath144 is the dimension of nanowire . in the configuration of directional excitation of metallic plasmons , @xmath145 ,
the induced dipole moment is too nonuniform to be treated as ideal circular dipole source . that is to say
, this method is not suitable for directional excitation of metallic plasmons .
however , this is not a limitation any more in excitation of gps due to the deep sub wavelength of the nanowire size in infrared spectrum , ie , @xmath146 . in our simulation , an @xmath132 nanowire with diameter @xmath144 of 100 nm ( 0.01@xmath108 )
is used to mimic the rotational polarized dipole .
drude model was adopted to model the dielectric constant of @xmath132 . in this model , the dielectric function is given by @xmath147 , where @xmath148 is the plasma frequency , @xmath149 is the high frequency dielectric constant , and @xmath150 is damping rate . extracted from the reference in@xcite , the parameters of @xmath132 are @xmath151 , @xmath152 ps , and @xmath153 .
moreover , @xmath154 is used to realize the resonance of the nanowire at 30 thz . the absorption cross length normalized to geometry cross length for different diameters of the nanowire
are showed in the insert figure of fig .
[ fig5](a ) , the absorption peak lays at 30 thz and is independent on the diameter of the nanowire because the electrostatic approximation is satisfied .
two time harmonic orthogonal incident plane waves with amplitude of 1 v / m and phase difference of @xmath84 are taken to illuminate the wire , the schematic and simulated electric field distribution are depicted in fig .
[ fig5](a ) , where the incident field has been subtracted from the total field .
the expression of the incident fields adopted in the simulation is expressed as @xmath155 it would be expected that the nanowire serves as a circularly polarized dipole with @xmath156 . from the figure , one can see that induced near field along @xmath79 with a much larger amplitude than the one along @xmath80 , which is very similar to the case of a circularly polarized dipole with @xmath156 .
the induced dipole of the nanowire in the diameter of 100 nm is @xmath136 and @xmath139 , which means that the semiconductor nanowire can serve as an ideal circularly polarized dipole as expected . when a graphene sheet is introduced close to this nanowire ,
the electric field reflected from the graphene will act on the nanowire as well , and this changes the parameters of the induced dipole to @xmath137 and @xmath138 , respectively .
the vibration ellipses of the induced dipole with and without graphene are shown in the insert figure of fig . [ fig5](b ) . from the angular momentum ratio shown in fig .
[ fig5](b ) , the angular momentum ratio can over 1000 for the nanowire . the induced charge density distribution is shown in fig . [ fig5](c )
, one can find that the charges oscillate only in the @xmath79 direction .
the simulated charge distribution is in good agreement for analytical calculation when the dipole moment is set as the actual value of @xmath137 and @xmath138 , respectively .
the charge distribution of unperturbed ideal circular polarized dipole is shown in thick line , one can see that the oscillation amplitude is a bit larger than actual situation .
the energy flux ratios are shown in the fig .
[ fig5](d ) , the asymmetrical energy flux is very apparent , the unperturbed ideal result is given for comparison as well .
the energy flux ratio with extinction parameter of @xmath138 is similar to the ideal case except for small extra oscillation and less magnitude due to the existence of real part of the extinction parameter .
the simulated result of nanowire is similar to the analytical result with actual extinction parameter , one can see that the energy flux ratio mimicked by nanowire exceed 100 when the propagation length is less than 2@xmath68 , and the extinction ratio exceed 10 in the whole calculation window .
we demonstrated here that near field interference of a circularly polarized dipole and two mirror image symmetric dipoles with orthogonally polarizations can directional generate propagating gps .
the viewpoint of angular momentum conservation is very efficient to determine the preferred direction of exited gps .
when the dipoles are laid in different sides of graphene , the spatial charge density rather than the magnetic field should be adopted to analysis the excited gps due to the extra minus sign from the discontinuous of magnetic field . in this condition ,
the magnetic field of dipole and induced charge distribution have opposite preferred directions and the properties of excited gps should be described by the behavior of induced charge .
moreover , the direction generation of gps can be extended into arc surface directly .
furthermore , a semiconductor nanowire can be regarded as a localized source to mimic the polarized dipoles , which can be realized in real experiments .
w cai , x zhang , and j xu acknowledge support from the national basic research program of china ( 2013cb328702 ) , program for changjiang scholars and innovative research team in university ( irt0149 ) , the national natural science foundation of china ( 11374006 ) and the 111 project ( b07013 ) .
y. luo acknowledge support from the national natural science foundation of china ( 61574122 ) .
27ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/nn406627u [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.nature.com/nphoton/journal/v6/n11/abs/nphoton.2012.262.html [ * * , ( ) ] http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/ph400147y [ * * , ( ) ] http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.80.245435 [ * * , ( ) ] http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature10067 [ * * , ( ) ] , http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/nl3047943 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.nature.com/nphys/journal/v9/n6/abs/nphys2615.html [ * * , ( ) ]
http://www.nature.com/ncomms/journal/v2/n8/abs/ncomms1464.html [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.sciencemag.org/content/332/6035/1291.short [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.aab2051 [ * * , ( ) ] http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/nl201771h [ * * , ( ) ] http://journals.aps.org/prb/abstract/10.1103/physrevb.84.195446 [ * * , ( ) ] http://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/physrevlett.108.213907 [ * * , ( ) ] http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11468-009-9086-2 [ * * , ( ) ] http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/journal/apl/98/25/10.1063/1.3602322 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.sciencemag.org/content/340/6130/328.short [ * * , ( ) ] http://iopscience.iop.org/2040-8986/16/10/105002 [ * * , ( ) ] http://arxiv.org/abs/1306.5068 [ ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) http://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/physrevlett.96.256802 [ * * , ( ) ] http://link.springer.com/article/10.1140/epjb%2fe2007-00142-3 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v487/n7405/abs/nature11254.html [ * * , ( ) ]
@noop _ _ , vol .
( , ) http://stacks.iop.org/0295-5075/25/i=7/a=004 [ * * , ( ) ] http://www.osapublishing.org/abstract.cfm?uri=oe-21-9-10475 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://www.nature.com/nmat/journal/v6/n12/suppinfo/nmat2033_s1.html [ * * , ( ) ] | the highly unidirectional excitation of graphene plasmons ( gps ) through near - field interference of orthogonally polarized dipoles is investigated .
the preferred excitation direction of gps by a single circularly polarized dipole can be simply understood with the angular momentum conservation law .
moreover , the propagation direction of gps can be switched not only by changing the phase difference between dipoles , but also by placing the @xmath0-polarized dipole to its image position , whereas the handedness of the background field remains the same .
the unidirectional excitation of gps can be extended directly into arc graphene surface as well .
furthermore , our proposal on directional generation of gps can be realized in a semiconductor nanowire / graphene system , where a semiconductor nanowire can mimic the circularly polarized dipole when illuminated by two orthogonally polarized plane waves . |
the inflationary paradigm was originally proposed to address the horizon , flatness , and monopole problems in the standard big - bang cosmology @xcite .
moreover , inflation can be responsible for the generation of primordial density perturbations @xcite and gravitational waves @xcite by stretching quantum fluctuations over super - hubble scales .
the simplest slow - roll inflationary scenario driven by the potential energy of a single scalar field gives rise to nearly scale - invariant primordial power spectra of scalar and tensor perturbations .
while the primordial scalar perturbation has been observed by cobe @xcite , wmap @xcite , and planck @xcite satellites as a form of temperature anisotropies of the comic microwave background ( cmb ) , gravitational waves had eluded the detection for a long time .
this is attributed to the fact that the relative amplitude of gravitational waves to scalar perturbations is suppressed in the standard inflationary scenario ( see refs .
@xcite for reviews ) .
the tensor - to - scalar ratio @xmath14 and the spectral index @xmath15 of scalar perturbations are two important quantities to probe models of inflation by using cmb observations . although the planck satellite measured @xmath15 in high precision , this is not sufficient to narrow down the allowed models of inflation unless @xmath14 is constrained tightly @xcite .
the detection of primordial gravitational waves is crucial to break the degeneracy between inflationary models .
in fact , there is the consistency relation between @xmath14 and the spectral index of primordial gravitational waves @xmath16 : @xmath17 for potential - driven slow - roll inflation @xcite .
the detection of gravitational waves is a litmus test for inflationary cosmology .
recently , the bicep2 collaboration reported the evidence for the detection of b - mode polarization in the cmb @xcite .
they claimed that the observed b - mode can be fit by a lensed @xmath18-cold - dark - matter ( @xmath18cdm ) model with @xmath19 . this bound is larger than the upper limit @xmath20 derived by the planck data of temperature anisotropies @xcite combined with the wmap large - angle polarization ( wp ) data @xcite .
there is also an argument that the presence of the polarized dust weakens the constraints on @xmath14 @xcite .
since the bicep2 measured the b - mode polarization at a single frequency ( 150 ghz ) , the upcoming independent observations at different frequencies with precise measurements of the dust polarization will be crucial to clarify whether the signal is really the cosmological origin or not .
if the b - mode polarization reported by bicep2 comes from the primordial origin , it marks a milestone in the inflationary cosmology @xcite . since the primordial b - mode can be generated only from tensor or vector perturbations @xcite and vector perturbations sourced by topological defects are disfavored by the cmb data @xcite , the detection of b - mode polarization indicates an indirect discovery of inflationary gravitational waves .
a relatively large value of the tensor - to - scalar ratio of the order of 0.1 can be explained by the so - called large field inflationary models in which the field variation @xmath21 during inflation is greater than @xmath22 , where @xmath23 gev is the reduced planck mass @xcite .
the typical examples of the large - field models are chaotic inflation @xcite and natural inflation @xcite .
although chaotic inflation with quartic potential is disfavored by the planck data @xcite , the non - minimal coupling @xcite can reduce the value of @xmath14 @xcite so that the model can be compatible with the data .
a similar property also holds in the presence of galileon couplings @xcite and field derivative couplings to the einstein tensor @xcite .
if the large - field models correspond to a realistic paradigm of inflation , the next generation interferometric detectors such as decigo @xcite and bbo @xcite may allow us to detect inflationary gravitational waves directly .
these instruments are designed to measure tensor perturbations at much shorter wavelengths relative to the perturbations associated with the cmb b - mode polarization .
these frequencies correspond to the mode that re - entered the hubble radius during the radiation - dominated epoch .
the direct detection of gravitational waves @xcite contains useful information of the very early universe , such as the effective relativistic degrees of freedom @xcite and the reheating temperature after inflation @xcite . in this paper
, we compute the spectra of the gravitational wave background for several large - field inflationary models : chaotic inflation , natural inflation and non - minimally coupled inflation with quartic potential .
then , we update the previous calculations @xcite of signal - to - noise ratios by decigo and bbo with various reheating temperatures .
we also calculate signal - to - noise ratio for ultimate decigo whose sensitivity is only limited by quantum noise @xcite .
we show that , even if these models are degenerate in terms of the cmb observables @xmath15 and @xmath14 , it is possible to distinguish them from the direct detection of inflationary gravitational waves .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ secback ] , we present background equations of motion during inflation / reheating in the presence of non - minimal couplings . in sec .
[ secinf ] , we review primordial gravitational waves generated during slow - roll inflation including non - minimal couplings between the inflaton field @xmath11 and the ricci scalar @xmath12 . in sec .
[ secspe ] , we calculate the spectra of the gravitational background for the three large - field inflationary models by using the bounds derived from the recent cmb data . in sec .
[ secsnr ] , we study the detectability of inflationary gravitational waves by computing the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) associated with upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo .
section [ secsum ] is devoted to summary .
we start with the inflationary model given by the action s = d^4x , [ action ] where @xmath12 is the ricci scalar of the metric @xmath24 , @xmath25 is the potential of a scalar field @xmath11 , and @xmath10 is the non - minimal coupling . in our sign convention
, the conformal coupling corresponds to @xmath26 .
we study the following three models in which the variation of the field during inflation is greater than the order of @xmath27 : & & v = m^2 ^ 2,=0 , [ mo1 ] + ( ii)&&v=^4 , = 0 , + ( iii)&&v=14 ^4 , 0 , [ mo3 ] where @xmath28 , @xmath18 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 are constants .
the models ( i ) and ( iii ) belong to the class of chaotic inflation @xcite with the quadratic potential and the quartic potential , respectively . in the case ( iii ) , we have introduced the non - minimal coupling @xmath10 , as this can reduce the tensor - to - scalar ratio @xmath14 .
the potential of the model ( ii ) corresponds to that of natural inflation @xcite .
the slow - roll inflation is possible for @xmath31 . for large decay constant @xmath32
, it is known that natural inflation is indistinguishable from quadratic chaotic inflation .
we consider the flat friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) background described by the line - element @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the scale factor with cosmic time @xmath35 . during the reheating after inflation
, the inflaton energy density decays into the radiation energy density @xmath36 .
the born decay to light particles ( decay constant @xmath37 ) during the oscillating stage of a scalar field can be effectively described by taking into account the friction term @xmath38 to the inflaton equation of motion @xcite ( a dot represents a derivative with respect to @xmath35 ) .
then , the friedmann equation and the scalar field equation of motion are given , respectively , by & & 3h^2 ( m_pl^2-^2)=12 ^2 + v()+6h + _
r,[be1 ] + & & + ( 3h+ ) + v _ , + 6(2h^2 + ) = 0,[be2 ] where @xmath39 and @xmath40 is the hubble parameter .
we caution that eq .
( [ be2 ] ) with the @xmath38 term is valid only during the oscillating stage of the inflaton around the potential minimum @xcite .
provided that @xmath41 during inflation , the decay term @xmath38 does not play any significant role until the onset of reheating . due to the energy conservation
, the radiation density @xmath36 obeys the equation of motion _ r+4h_r=^2 .
[ rhoeq ] from eq .
( [ be1 ] ) , we obtain h=. [ hu ] taking the time derivative of eq .
( [ be1 ] ) and eliminating the term @xmath42 on account of eq .
( [ be2 ] ) , we have & = & -\{m_pl^2 [ ( 3h+ ) + v _ , ] - + & & + 6(-2h ) ( + h ) ^2 } /[m_pl^2+^2 ( 6 - 1 ) ] .
[ ddotphi ] we solve the differential equations ( [ rhoeq ] ) and ( [ ddotphi ] ) with eq .
( [ hu ] ) . for the models ( i ) and
( ii ) , the slow - roll inflationary stage is followed by oscillations of the massive inflaton field .
this corresponds to the temporal matter era during which the evolution of the scale factor is given by @xmath43 . around the time @xmath44 ,
@xmath36 catches up with the inflaton energy density @xmath45 @xcite . here
, the subscript rh " denotes the value at the end of reheating .
we numerically find that the radiation energy density at @xmath46 is given by @xmath47 . on using the relation @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is the temperature and @xmath50 is the number of relativistic degree of freedom ,
the reheating temperature is given by t_rh 1.1g_*,rh^-1/4 ( m_pl)^1/2 .
[ reheat ] we take @xmath51 for the value of @xmath50 at the end of reheating . for @xmath52 ,
the universe enters the radiation - dominated epoch . in the model ( iii ) , the cmb observables @xmath15 and @xmath14 are subject to change relative to the case @xmath54 because the effect of non - minimal couplings can not be neglected due to the large inflaton value . as we will see in sec .
[ bicepcon ] , the model is compatible with the observational data even for @xmath53 . since the amplitude of the field @xmath11 drops below @xmath27 after inflation , the effect of non - minimal couplings on the background eqs .
( [ rhoeq])-([ddotphi ] ) should be negligible during reheating for @xmath53 . in this case
, the dynamics of reheating is driven by a massless inflaton field , so that the scale factor evolves as @xmath55 and hence , there is no transient matter era between inflation and the radiation - dominated epoch . for the model ( iii ) with @xmath53 ,
the dynamics of reheating can be analytically known by using the virial theorem @xmath56 , where @xmath57 corresponds to the time average over inflaton oscillations .
dropping the contribution of non - minimal couplings in eq .
( [ be2 ] ) , it follows that _ + ( 4h+4/3 ) _ 0 .
[ rhophi ] integration of eq .
( [ rhophi ] ) gives _
= _ i ( ) ^2 e^-(4/3)(t - t_i ) , [ rhophi2 ] where the subscript `` @xmath58 '' is used for quantities at the onset of inflaton oscillations and we used the solution @xmath59 for @xmath60 . substituting eq .
( [ rhophi2 ] ) into eq .
( [ rhoeq ] ) , i.e. , @xmath61 , we obtain the following solution _
r = _ i ( ) ^2 .
[ rhor2 ] the time @xmath62 can be estimated as @xmath63 .
provided that @xmath64 , the time @xmath65 at which @xmath66 equals @xmath67 is given by @xmath68 .
on using the relation @xmath69 , we have @xmath70 .
equating this with the radiation density @xmath71 , it follows that t_rh 1.4g_*,rh^-1/4 ( m_pl)^1/2 .
[ reheat2 ] we have numerically solved ( [ rhoeq ] ) and ( [ ddotphi ] ) with eq .
( [ hu ] ) from the onset of reheating and confirmed that the above analytic estimation shows good agreement with our numerical results for @xmath53 . in sec
. [ secsnr ] , we employ the relations ( [ reheat ] ) and ( [ reheat2 ] ) to estimate @xmath0 for a given decay constant @xmath37 . as we see in sec .
[ secspe ] , the absence of the temporal matter era for the model ( iii ) affects the resulting spectrum of the gravitational wave background relative to the models ( i ) and ( ii ) .
the number of e - foldings during inflation is defined by @xmath72 , where @xmath73 is the value of @xmath74 when a wave number @xmath75 equals @xmath76 during inflation and @xmath77 is its value at the end of inflation .
this quantity is related to the observables such as @xmath15 and @xmath14 , so the accurate estimation of @xmath78 is necessary to place concrete constraints on inflationary models .
after inflation , there is a reheating stage followed by the radiation - dominated epoch .
then , the wave number @xmath79 divided by @xmath80 ( the label `` 0 '' represents today s values ) reads = e^-n(k ) , [ kah ] where we express the hubble constant as @xmath81 gev and @xmath82 .
we assume that the entropy at the end of reheating ( with the relativistic degrees of freedom @xmath83 ) is conserved in the photon and neutrino background today .
this leads to the following relation @xcite : g_s , rht_rh^3 a_rh^3= a_0 ^ 3 , where @xmath84 gev is the cmb temperature at present and today s temperature of neutrinos is given by @xmath85 .
then , we obtain =( g_s , rh ) ^1/3 . if the total energy density @xmath86 during reheating
is given by @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is constant , the number of e - foldings in the reheating period can be estimated as @xmath89 .
the energy density @xmath90 is related to the reheating temperature @xmath0 , as @xmath91 , where @xmath92 is the number of relativistic degrees of freedom at the end of reheating . on using the aforementioned relations in eq .
( [ kah ] ) , it follows that n(k)=- ( ) - ( ) -13 ( ) + ( ) - ( ) + ( ) . [ nesti2 ] here the hubble parameter @xmath93 is associated with the inflationary energy density @xmath94 , as @xmath95 .
since @xmath96 differs from @xmath94 , we define , to quantify their difference . in the following , we set @xmath97 by assuming that no entropy production occurs after the reheating stage until the neutrino decoupling ( @xmath98 mev ) . depending on the values of @xmath88
, we shall discuss two qualitatively different cases .
the models ( i ) and ( ii ) belong to the class in which the energy density during reheating decreases as @xmath100 . in this case
, the number of e - foldings ( [ nesti2 ] ) reads n(k ) = 55.9 - 13 - ( ) - ( ) + 13 ( ) + 23 ( ) .
[ efoldq=3 ] as we will see in sec .
[ secinf ] , the hubble parameter @xmath93 is related to the amplitude @xmath101 of tensor perturbations as @xmath102 , where @xmath103 is the amplitude of curvature perturbations constrained by planck @xcite . then , the inflationary energy scale can be generally estimated as _ inf^1/4=1.8410 ^ 16 ( ) ^1/4 gev .
[ rhoinf ] for the monomial potential @xmath104 the field value during inflation is analytically known as @xmath105 , with @xmath106 .
hence the parameter @xmath107 can be estimated as 43 43 ( ) ^n/2 , [ alpha ] where the factor @xmath108 comes from the contribution of the inflaton kinetic energy to @xmath96 .
for the model ( i ) , i.e. , @xmath109 , we have @xmath110 .
this leads to a non - negligible change to @xmath78 of the order of 1 .
accordingly , eq . ( [ efoldq=3 ] ) becomes n(k)=56.5 + 13 n(k)- ( ) - ( ) + 13 ( ) + 16 ( ) .
[ efoldq=3d ] for given @xmath75 , @xmath111 , and @xmath0 , @xmath78 is known by solving eq .
( [ efoldq=3d ] ) . in fig .
[ fig1 ] , we plot @xmath78 versus @xmath0 for several different values of @xmath75 .
this result is obtained by numerically solving the background equations of motion from inflation to the present epoch .
we have confirmed that the numerical values of @xmath78 show good agreement with those estimated by eq .
( [ efoldq=3d ] ) . on the largest scale observed in the cmb ( @xmath112 ) , the number of e - foldings is in the range @xmath113 for @xmath114 . for larger @xmath75 ,
@xmath78 becomes smaller .
the number of e - foldings @xmath78 versus the reheating temperature @xmath0 for the model ( i ) ( solid line ) and the model ( ii ) with @xmath115 ( dashed line ) .
we choose four different values of @xmath75 which are inside the observed cmb range . for increasing @xmath0 and decreasing @xmath75 , @xmath78 gets larger.,width=460,height=316 ] in natural inflation ( the model ( ii ) ) , the number of e - foldings can also be calculated as n -2()^2 , with @xmath116 $ ] .
then , the parameter @xmath107 reads 43 .
accordingly , eq . ( [ efoldq=3 ] )
is replaced by n(k ) & = & 56.5 + 13 - ( ) - ( ) + & & + 13 ( ) + 16 ( ) . [ efoldq=3dnatural ] in the @xmath117 limit , natural inflation becomes indistinguishable from quadratic chaotic inflation , so that eq .
( [ efoldq=3dnatural ] ) reduces to eq .
( [ efoldq=3d ] ) . in fig .
[ fig1 ] , we show numerically derived values of @xmath78 versus @xmath0 for the model ( ii ) with @xmath115 .
the number of e - foldings exhibits only a tiny difference from that in the model ( i ) .
for @xmath53 the model ( iii ) belongs to the class of massless inflaton characterized by @xmath119 . in this case , the number of e - foldings ( [ nesti2 ] ) does not depend on @xmath0 .
following the same argument as before and using the relations ( [ rhoinf ] ) and ( [ alpha ] ) with @xmath120 , we obtain n(k ) = 61.6 + 12 n(k ) - ( ) - ( ) - ( ) + 14 ( ) .
[ efoldq=4 ] if @xmath121 , @xmath51 and @xmath122 , we have @xmath123 for @xmath112 and @xmath124 for @xmath125 mpc@xmath126 .
we consider the following perturbed metric on the flat flrw background @xcite : ds^2=-(1 + 2a)dt^2 + 2_i b dt dx^i+a^2(t ) dx^i dx^j , [ permet ] where @xmath127 , @xmath128 , and @xmath129 are scalar perturbations , and @xmath130 is the tensor perturbation .
we choose the unitary gauge in which the field perturbation @xmath131 vanishes , such that the gauge - invariant curvature perturbation @xmath132 is identical to @xmath129 .
this fixes the time component of the gauge - transformation vector @xmath133 .
we have also fixed the spatial component of @xmath133 by gauging away the scalar perturbation @xmath134 appearing as the form @xmath135 in the metric ( [ permet ] ) .
expanding the action ( [ action ] ) for the transverse and traceless tensor perturbation , the second - order action reads s_t^(2)=d^4 xa^3 , [ secondten ] where @xmath136 .
we write @xmath130 in terms of fourier components , as h_ij(t , x)=_=+,^ _ ij^ ( k)h_k^(t)e^ik , [ hij ] where @xmath137 is a comoving wave number . the polarization tensors @xmath138 satisfy symmetric and transverse - traceless conditions and are normalized as @xmath139 . from the action ( [ secondten ] )
, the fourier mode @xmath140 obeys the equation of motion _
k^+ ( 3h+ ) _ k^ + h_k^=0 .
[ heq2 ] for the quantization procedure , we express @xmath140 in the form h_k^(t)=h_k
( t)a _ ( k)+ h_k^ * ( t)a_^(-k ) , where the annihilation and creation operators satisfy @xmath141 = \delta_{\mu \mu ' } \delta^{(3)}({\bm k}-{\bm k}')$ ] . a canonically normalized field , which is defined by v_k z h_k , z am_pl , obeys the equation of motion v_k+ ( k^2- ) v_k=0 , [ vkeq ] where a prime represents a derivative with respect to the conformal time @xmath142 . in the asymptotic past
, the solution corresponding to the bunch - davies vacuum is given by @xmath143 , i.e. , h_k = , - .
[ initial ] on the quasi de sitter background with a nearly constant hubble parameter , the variation of the quantity @xmath144 is negligibly small relative to that of @xmath74 , such that @xmath145 . under this approximation ,
the solution to eq .
( [ vkeq ] ) during inflation reads h_k ( ) ( 1+ik ) .
[ hktau ] we define the tensor power spectrum , as _ t _ = + , | h_k^ |^2 .
[ ptdef ] after the hubble radius crossing ( @xmath146 ) , the solution ( [ hktau ] ) approaches @xmath147 so that we obtain the primordial power spectrum _
t^prim |_k = ah . [ pt2 ]
the formula ( [ pt2 ] ) has been derived under the condition that the variations of @xmath148 and @xmath144 are negligible during inflation .
this is a good approximation for the perturbations relevant to cmb anisotropies ( @xmath149 e - foldings before the end of inflation ) , but it is not so for the modes associated with the direct detection of gravitational waves ( @xmath150 e - foldings before the end of inflation ) . for precise computations of the spectrum of the gravitational wave background , we shall numerically solve eq .
( [ heq2 ] ) under the initial condition ( [ initial ] ) without using the formula ( [ pt2 ] ) . for the study of scalar perturbations and the tensor - to - scalar ratio , it is convenient to perform the so - called conformal transformation @xmath151 , where a hat is used for quantities in the new frame and @xmath152 is a conformal factor . for the choice @xmath153
, the action ( [ action ] ) transforms to @xcite = d^4x , [ eaction ] where u= , ( ) d , ( ) .
[ ure ] the perturbed metric in the einstein frame ( [ eaction ] ) is given by @xmath154 , where @xmath155 corresponds to the metric ( [ permet ] ) .
decomposing the quantity @xmath144 into the background and perturbed components as @xmath156 , we obtain the following correspondence : & & = a,=dt,= ( h+ ) , [ conre1 ] + & & = a+,=b,=+,_ij = h_ij,[conre2 ] so that the tensor perturbation is invariant under the conformal transformation . on using the relations ( [ conre1 ] ) , the power spectrum ( [ pt2 ] ) reads _
t^prim |_k= , at leading order in slow - roll ( under which the term @xmath157 is negligible relative to @xmath148 ) . using the correspondence ( [ conre2 ] )
, one can show that the curvature perturbation @xmath158 is invariant under the conformal transformation @xcite . in the einstein frame
the power spectrum of @xmath159 is equivalent to the one in standard slow - roll inflation , so it is given by @xcite _
r^prim |_k= , at leading order in slow - roll , where @xmath160 . the scalar spectral index @xmath161 and the tensor - to - scalar ratio @xmath162 are n_s=1 - 6_u+2_u , r=-8n_t = 16_u , [ nsr ] where @xmath163 and @xmath164 is the tensor spectral index .
for a given inflaton potential , these observables can be explicitly expressed as a function of @xmath11 by using the relations ( [ ure ] ) .
we compute the cmb observables ( [ nsr ] ) for the models ( i)-(iii ) to confront them with observations .
we refer the readers to refs .
@xcite for detailed calculations of @xmath15 and @xmath14 .
the number of e - foldings during inflation can be expressed as the integrated form @xmath165 in the jordan frame . with a proper choice of a reference length scale ,
the number of e - foldings is a frame - independent quantity @xcite . from the third relation of eq .
( [ conre1 ] ) , it follows that n=__f^ d+12 , [ efold ] where we have employed the slow - roll approximation in the einstein frame .
two - dimensional observational constraints on the models ( i ) and ( ii ) ( left ) , and the model ( iii ) ( right ) in the @xmath166 plane with the pivot wave number @xmath167 mpc@xmath126 .
the gray shaded regions represent the 68 % c.l .
( inside ) and 95 % c.l .
( outside ) parameter spaces constrained by the joint data analysis of planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 .
we also show the 68 % c.l .
( inside ) and 95 % c.l .
( outside ) boundaries constrained by planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168+bicep2 with dotted ellipses . in the left panel , the three large black points correspond to the theoretical prediction of the model ( i ) for @xmath169 , whereas the small black points represent the prediction of the model ( ii ) for @xmath170 with @xmath169 . in the right panel ,
the theoretical curves are plotted for @xmath171 with several different values of @xmath10 between @xmath172 and @xmath173.,title="fig:",width=336,height=336 ] two - dimensional observational constraints on the models ( i ) and ( ii ) ( left ) , and the model ( iii ) ( right ) in the @xmath166 plane with the pivot wave number @xmath167 mpc@xmath126 .
the gray shaded regions represent the 68 % c.l .
( inside ) and 95 % c.l .
( outside ) parameter spaces constrained by the joint data analysis of planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 .
we also show the 68 % c.l .
( inside ) and 95 % c.l .
( outside ) boundaries constrained by planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168+bicep2 with dotted ellipses . in the left panel , the three large black points correspond to the theoretical prediction of the model ( i ) for @xmath169 , whereas the small black points represent the prediction of the model ( ii ) for @xmath170 with @xmath169 .
in the right panel , the theoretical curves are plotted for @xmath171 with several different values of @xmath10 between @xmath172 and @xmath173.,title="fig:",width=336,height=336 ] for the cmb likelihood analysis , we expand the primordial power spectra @xmath174 and @xmath175 as a taylor series about a pivot wave number @xmath176 .
we employ the consistency relation @xmath17 and set the scalar and tensor runnings to be 0 in the likelihood analysis .
the likelihood results are derived with the cosmomc code @xcite by assuming the flat @xmath18cdm model and @xmath177 relativistic degrees of freedom with an instant reionization . in fig .
[ fig2 ] , we plot the 68 % c.l . and
95 % c.l . regions ( plotted as the gray shaded color ) in the @xmath166 plane constrained by the joint data analysis of planck @xcite , wp @xcite , baryon acoustic oscillations ( bao ) @xcite , and atacama cosmology telescope / south pole telescope temperature data of high multipoles @xmath168 ( high-@xmath168 ) @xcite .
the tensor - to - scalar ratio is constrained to be @xmath178 at 95 % c.l .
we have chosen the value @xmath167 mpc@xmath126 in fig .
[ fig2 ] , but the results are insensitive to the choice of @xmath176 as long as the pivot scale is in the observed range of cmb . hence , the likelihood contours for different choices of @xmath176 are similar to those given in fig .
we also show the 68 % c.l . and
95 % c.l . boundaries ( dotted curves ) constrained by adding the bicep2 data @xcite to the planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 data . in this case , @xmath14 is bounded from below . for the monomial potential @xmath104 with @xmath54 , the observables ( [ efold ] ) reduce to @xcite n_s=1-,r=. [ nsrcha ] from eq .
( [ efoldq=3d ] ) , the number of e - foldings for the quadratic potential ( @xmath109 ) depends on the reheating temperature @xmath0 and the wave number @xmath75 . for the pivot scale @xmath167 mpc@xmath126
the number of e - foldings is in the range @xmath179 for @xmath180 . if @xmath181 , then @xmath182 for @xmath180 . in fig .
[ fig2 ] , we plot the theoretical curves of the model ( i ) in the @xmath183 plane for @xmath184 between 50 and 60 . for @xmath185
the quadratic potential is inside the 95 % c.l .
boundary constrained by the planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 data . in fig .
[ fig2 ] , we also show the theoretical prediction of the model ( ii ) for @xmath169 with @xmath29 between @xmath186 and @xmath22 . when @xmath187 , natural inflation is inside the 95 % c.l .
boundary constrained the planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 data for @xmath188 . in the @xmath117 limit
, inflation occurs in the region around the potential minimum ( @xmath189 ) , in which case @xmath15 and @xmath14 approach the values ( [ nsrcha ] ) with @xmath109 . in the model ( iii ) with @xmath53 , the number of e - foldings ( [ efoldq=4 ] ) does not depend on @xmath0 . for given @xmath176 , the value of @xmath184
is fixed , e.g. , @xmath190 for @xmath167 mpc@xmath126 . in the right panel of fig .
[ fig2 ] , we plot the theoretical values of @xmath15 and @xmath14 for @xmath191 with several different values of @xmath10 . for @xmath13 of the order of @xmath192 , the presence of non - minimal couplings allows a possibility of reducing the values of @xmath14 to be compatible with the upper bound derived from the planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 data . in the @xmath193 limit ,
we obtain the same values of @xmath15 and @xmath14 as those in the starobinsky @xmath194 model @xcite , i.e. , @xmath195 and @xmath196 @xcite .
in this section , we calculate the spectrum of the gravitational wave background generated in large - field inflationary models discussed in sec .
[ secinf ] . from the second - order action ( [ secondten ] )
, the energy density @xmath197 of gravitational waves corresponds to the ( 00 ) component of its energy - momentum tensor @xmath198 , i.e. , _
. [ rhogw ] after the perturbations enter the hubble radius during the radiation or matter era , the wkb solution to eq .
( [ heq2 ] ) is given by h_k^ a^-1 e^ik , [ wkb ] where we have neglected the variation of @xmath144 relative to that of @xmath74 . substituting eq .
( [ hij ] ) with the solution ( [ wkb ] ) into eq .
( [ rhogw ] ) and taking the spatial average , the energy density reads _
gw= _ = + , |h_k^|^2 . [ rhogw2 ]
we define the intensity of the gravitational wave background as _
gw = ( ) ^2 p_t , [ omegw ] where @xmath199 is the critical density of the universe , and @xmath101 is the tensor spectrum defined in eq .
( [ ptdef ] ) . in the second equality of eq .
( [ omegw ] ) , we have substituted the energy density ( [ rhogw2 ] ) . in order to compute the spectrum ( [ omegw ] ) today , we need to solve eq .
( [ heq2 ] ) from the onset of inflation to the present epoch . as we have already studied in sec .
[ secinf ] , the background dynamics during inflation and reheating are known by solving eqs .
( [ rhoeq])-([ddotphi ] ) numerically . to discuss the cosmological dynamics after the radiation era
, we need to take into account the contribution of relativistic particles , non - relativistic particles ( dark matter and baryons ) , and dark energy to the friedmann equation . the entropy density of relativistic particles at temperature @xmath49 is given by @xmath200 .
due to the entropy conservation @xmath201constant , the radiation energy density @xmath202 evolves as @xmath203 .
the explicit forms of @xmath204 and @xmath205 are given in ref .
the energy density of non - relativistic particles decreases as @xmath206 . for dark energy
, we assume that its energy density @xmath207 is given by the cosmological constant @xmath18 .
we can consider some other sources for dark energy , but it hardly affects the resulting gravitational wave spectrum unless eq .
( [ heq2 ] ) is subject to change under some modification of gravity .
the term @xmath144 is very close to 1 around today , so the effect of non - minimal couplings is negligibly small at the late cosmological epoch . defining today s density parameters as @xmath208 ,
where @xmath209 and the subscript `` 0 '' represents the present values , the friedmann equation after the end of reheating can be expressed as = .
[ hubble ] for numerical simulations , we take the present radiation density to be @xmath210 and use the mean likelihood values derived from the planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 data @xcite : the non - relativistic matter density @xmath211 , the dark energy density @xmath212 , the amplitude of primordial curvature perturbations @xmath213 , and the normalized hubble constant @xmath214 . for the calculation of relativistic degrees of freedom , we only include particles in the standard model of particle physics , where the maximum values of @xmath50 and @xmath215 are @xmath216 .
since the primordial tensor perturbation is frozen by the second horizon crossing characterized by @xmath217 , today s power spectrum @xmath218 is related to the primordial one @xmath175 via @xmath219 .
if the scale factor evolves as @xmath220 , where @xmath221 is a constant , the hubble parameter @xmath148 is proportional to @xmath222 , so that @xmath223
. then , today s gravitational wave intensity ( [ omegw ] ) has the momentum dependence _
gw k^n_t+2(2p-1)/(p-1 ) , where @xmath16 is the primordial tensor spectral index . during the radiation era ( @xmath224 ) and the matter era ( @xmath225 )
, we have @xmath226 and @xmath227 , respectively .
the nearly scale - invariant property of the primordial tensor perturbation is imprinted for the modes that re - entered the hubble radius during the radiation - dominated epoch .
this is the case for the frequencies @xmath228 associated with the direct detection of gravitational waves by decigo or bbo ( @xmath229 hz ) . for the perturbations that re - entered the hubble radius during the matter era
, the intensity @xmath230 has a highly red - tilted spectrum . for the inflationary models like ( i ) and ( ii )
, the reheating stage corresponds to a temporal matter - dominated epoch driven by a massive inflation field .
then , there is a suppression of @xmath231 at high frequencies .
this suppression occurs for @xcite f > f_rh 0.26 ( ) ( ) ^1/2 ( ) ^-1/3 hz .
[ freq ] for increasing @xmath37 , the critical frequency @xmath232 becomes larger . in the model ( iii ) with @xmath53 , the evolution of the scale factor during reheating is given by @xmath55 , so the suppression of @xmath230 mentioned above is absent . as we explained in sec .
[ secback ] , we compute the reheating temperature numerically at the time when the field energy density @xmath233 drops below the radiation energy density @xmath36 . today
s intensity @xmath230 of the gravitational wave background versus the frequency @xmath228 for the four models : ( i ) @xmath234 with @xmath54 , ( ii ) @xmath235 $ ] with @xmath54 and @xmath115 , the potential @xmath9 with @xmath54 , and ( iii ) @xmath9 and @xmath236 .
we also show the sensitivity curves for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo .
each panel corresponds to the spectra around the detection sensitivity with @xmath237 gev ( left ) and the spectra in the wide range of frequencies with @xmath238 gev ( right).,title="fig:",width=321,height=259 ] today s intensity @xmath230 of the gravitational wave background versus the frequency @xmath228 for the four models : ( i ) @xmath234 with @xmath54 , ( ii ) @xmath235 $ ] with @xmath54 and @xmath115 , the potential @xmath9 with @xmath54 , and ( iii ) @xmath9 and @xmath236 .
we also show the sensitivity curves for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo .
each panel corresponds to the spectra around the detection sensitivity with @xmath237 gev ( left ) and the spectra in the wide range of frequencies with @xmath238 gev ( right).,title="fig:",width=345,height=259 ] under the slow - roll approximation the primordial spectral index is given by @xmath239 .
note , however , that this formula overestimates the amplitude of the gravitational wave spectrum at @xmath240 hz by 20% for chaotic inflation models @xcite .
therefore , we compute the intensity @xmath230 for three inflationary models ( i)-(iii ) without employing the slow - roll approximation .
we numerically solve eq .
( [ heq2 ] ) for each wave number @xmath75 together with the background equations of motion ( [ rhoeq])-([ddotphi ] ) during inflation / reheating and eq .
( [ hubble ] ) after the end of reheating . in fig .
[ fig3 ] , we show today s gravitational wave intensity versus the frequency @xmath29 for the three large - field inflationary models ( i)-(iii ) with @xmath237 gev ( left ) and @xmath241 gev ( right ) .
recall that the reheating temperatures for the models ( i ) and ( ii ) are related to the number of e - foldings @xmath184 , as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] . in the left panel
, we see that the anisotropic stress due to neutrino free streaming @xcite at @xmath242hz does not affect the amplitude of the gravitational waves at the direct detection scales ( @xmath243hz ) . since the primordial tensor - to - scalar ratio in the model ( i ) is greater than that in the model ( ii ) ( see fig .
[ fig2 ] ) , the amplitude of @xmath230 in the former is larger than that in the latter at the cmb scale ( @xmath244hz ) . in fig .
[ fig3 ] , the suppression of @xmath230 due to the presence of the temporal matter era after inflation is clearly seen for large frequencies . as estimated by eq .
( [ freq ] ) , the critical frequency @xmath232 becomes larger for increasing @xmath0 . in the model ( iii ) with @xmath53 , the reheating stage
is characterized by the oscillation of a massless inflaton , so the suppression of @xmath230 mentioned above is not present .
however , due to the steepness of the potential , the evolution of the inflaton is faster than that in the models ( i ) and ( ii ) around the end of inflation . as we see in the right panel of fig .
[ fig3 ] , this leads to the mild decrease of the power spectrum around the frequencies @xmath245 hz . in fig . [ fig3 ] , we also plot the sensitivity curves for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo . in particular , the sensitivity of upgraded decigo is improved over decigo to cover a wider range of frequencies . in the model ( i ) , bbo , and upgraded decigo can potentially measure inflationary gravitational waves for @xmath246 gev and @xmath247 gev , respectively . in the model ( ii )
, the intensity @xmath230 becomes smaller for decreasing @xmath29 , but the detection is still possible for @xmath248 .
the model ( iii ) allows the possible detection in the frequency range @xmath249 , irrespective of the reheating temperature . in the next section
, we shall discuss this issue in more detail by taking into account the noise associated with the interferometric detectors .
in order to discuss the detectability of inflationary gravitational waves , we compute the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) by two interferometric detectors . here the snr is expressed in terms of @xmath250 given by eq .
( [ omegw ] ) and the functions related to the experimental design , such as the noise spectrum @xmath251 and the overlap reduction function @xmath252 , as @xcite ^2=2()^2t_obs _ ( i , j)^_0df , where @xmath253 is the duration of observations , and the subscripts @xmath254 and @xmath255 refer to independent signals obtained at each detector , or observables generated by combining the detector signals .
the overlap reduction function @xmath252 can be calculated with information about relative locations and orientations of detectors @xcite . in the following , we present explicit forms of the noise spectra for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo .
* decigo + decigo is planned to be a fabry - perot michelson interferometer with an arm length of @xmath256 m @xcite .
the noise spectral density is given by @xcite n_1(f)=n_2(f)=s_shot^2+s_accel^2+s_rad^2 , where @xmath257 is the shot noise , @xmath258 is the acceleration noise , and @xmath259\,{\rm hz}^{-1/2}$ ] is the radiation pressure noise , with @xmath260hz being the cutoff frequency .
* upgraded decigo + in order to resolve all foreground gravitational waves coming from neutron star binaries , it is necessary to improve the sensitivity of decigo by a factor of 3 @xcite .
we consider the following noise spectrum as an example of an upgraded version of decigo : @xmath261 and @xmath262 with the cutoff frequency @xmath263hz , which would be possible by upgrading the arm length from @xmath264 m to @xmath265 m , the laser power from @xmath266w to @xmath267w and mirror radius from @xmath268 m to @xmath269 m . for radiation pressure
, we adopt the same noise spectrum as that of decigo , which is negligible compared to the acceleration noise .
* bbo + bbo adopts a technique called time - delay interferometry ( tdi ) , in which new variables ( @xmath270 ) are constructed to cancel the laser frequency noise .
the noise transfer functions for the tdi variables are given by @xcite & & n_a(f)=n_e(f)=8
^ 2(/2 ) \ { ( 2+)n_shot + 2[3 + 2+(2)]n_accel } , + & & n_t(f)=2(1 + 2)^2 [ n_shot+4 ^ 2(/2)n_accel ] , where @xmath271 . in the case of bbo ,
the arm length is @xmath272 m and the noise functions are @xmath273 and @xmath274~{\rm hz}^{-1}$ ] . *
ultimate decigo + ultimate decigo is an ideal experiment whose noise is limited only by quantum noise @xcite .
we consider a tdi type experiment whose arm length is @xmath272 m and the noise functions are @xmath275 and @xmath276~{\rm hz}^{-1}$ ] @xcite .
the snr versus the reheating temperature computed for the model ( i ) , the model ( ii ) with @xmath115 , the potential @xmath9 with @xmath54 , and the model ( iii ) with @xmath277 .
each panel corresponds to the snr for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo , from top to bottom , respectively .
the gray region shows the 1@xmath278 uncertainty in the amplitude of primordial curvature perturbations @xmath279 constrained from planck @xcite . for observation time of the gravitational wave ,
we assume @xmath280 .
the snr scales as @xmath281 . , title="fig:",height=211 ] + the snr versus the reheating temperature computed for the model ( i ) , the model ( ii ) with @xmath115 , the potential @xmath9 with @xmath54 , and the model ( iii ) with @xmath277 .
each panel corresponds to the snr for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo , from top to bottom , respectively .
the gray region shows the 1@xmath278 uncertainty in the amplitude of primordial curvature perturbations @xmath279 constrained from planck @xcite . for observation time of the gravitational wave ,
we assume @xmath280 .
the snr scales as @xmath281 .
, title="fig:",height=211 ] + the snr versus the reheating temperature computed for the model ( i ) , the model ( ii ) with @xmath115 , the potential @xmath9 with @xmath54 , and the model ( iii ) with @xmath277 .
each panel corresponds to the snr for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo , from top to bottom , respectively .
the gray region shows the 1@xmath278 uncertainty in the amplitude of primordial curvature perturbations @xmath279 constrained from planck @xcite . for observation time of the gravitational wave , we assume @xmath280
. the snr scales as @xmath281 .
, title="fig:",height=211 ] + the snr versus the reheating temperature computed for the model ( i ) , the model ( ii ) with @xmath115 , the potential @xmath9 with @xmath54 , and the model ( iii ) with @xmath277 .
each panel corresponds to the snr for decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo , from top to bottom , respectively .
the gray region shows the 1@xmath278 uncertainty in the amplitude of primordial curvature perturbations @xmath279 constrained from planck @xcite . for observation time of the gravitational wave ,
we assume @xmath280 .
the snr scales as @xmath281 .
, title="fig:",height=211 ] in fig .
[ snr1 ] , we show the snr versus the reheating temperature @xmath0 for the cross - correlation analysis expected with 10-year observations by decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo . because we consider the standard model particles alone and take @xmath51 rather than @xmath282 used in ref .
@xcite . ] for the models ( i ) and ( ii ) , the snr decreases significantly for @xmath0 lower than @xmath283 gev because of the suppression due to the presence of the temporal matter era after inflation .
the snr of the model ( ii ) is smaller than that of the model ( i ) for the same reheating temperature . as we see in the left panel of fig .
[ snr2 ] , the snr of natural inflation increases for larger @xmath29 to approach that of the model ( i ) in the @xmath117 limit . this tendency is also seen in table [ table ] , in which the snr as well as @xmath14 and @xmath230 are given for @xmath284 gev . in fig .
[ snr1 ] , we find that the snr of the model ( iii ) is practically independent of the reheating temperature for @xmath53 .
the primordial tensor - to - scalar ratio @xmath14 gets smaller for increasing @xmath13 . as we see in the right panel of fig .
[ snr2 ] , the snr starts to decrease for @xmath285 .
this is inside the 95%c.l .
region constrained by the planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 data ( see fig . [ fig2 ] ) .
if the snr is larger than 3 , the primordial gravitational waves could be directly measured at @xmath4 ( under the assumption of gaussian noise ) . for the model ( i ) ,
the detections by decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo at @xmath4 would be possible if the reheating temperature is larger than @xmath286 gev , @xmath287 gev , @xmath288 gev , and @xmath289 gev , respectively .
the detections by upgraded decigo ( bbo ) are also feasible at 5@xmath278 if @xmath290 gev ( @xmath291 gev ) .
the situation in the model ( ii ) is similar to that in the model ( i ) . for @xmath115 , decigo , upgraded decigo and bbo could measure the primordial gravitational waves at @xmath4 if @xmath292 gev , @xmath293 gev , @xmath294 gev , and @xmath295 gev , respectively .
the detections would be possible at 5@xmath278 for @xmath296 gev ( upgraded decigo ) and @xmath296 gev ( bbo ) .
the snr increases for larger @xmath29 and converges to that of the model ( i ) . for @xmath297 gev
the snr is insensitive to the reheating temperature .
the detections by upgraded decigo ( bbo ) would be possible for @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) at @xmath4 and for @xmath298 ( @xmath299 ) at 5@xmath278 .
the @xmath29 dependence of the snr for ultimate decigo is the same as that of decigo / bbo seen in the left panel of fig .
[ snr2 ] , but the scale of the vertical axis is much larger because of the extremely high sensitivity .
thus , ultimate decigo can detect the signal with a very good accuracy as long as we consider the parameter region indicated by planck , @xmath300 .
the snr in the model ( iii ) is independent of @xmath0 , but it depends on non - minimal couplings @xmath10 . from the right panel of fig .
[ snr2 ] , we find that the detections at @xmath4 by decigo , upgraded decigo and bbo would be feasible for @xmath301 , @xmath302 and @xmath303 , respectively
. the 5@xmath278 detections by upgraded decigo ( bbo ) would require @xmath304 ( @xmath305 ) .
this corresponds to the regime in which the tensor - to - scalar ratio is larger than 0.05 .
if the b - mode polarization measurements convincingly confirm the existence of primordial gravitational waves with @xmath14 larger than 0.05 , its direct detection by upgraded decigo and bbo could be also possible in the future .
( left ) dependence of the snr on the parameter @xmath306 for the model ( ii ) .
( right ) dependence of the snr on the non - minimal coupling @xmath10 for the model ( iii ) .
each line is the snr calculated with noise curves of decigo , upgraded decigo and bbo , respectively , with @xmath307 year . in both cases ,
we assume @xmath241 gev . , title="fig:",width=336,height=235 ] ( left ) dependence of the snr on the parameter @xmath306 for the model ( ii ) .
( right ) dependence of the snr on the non - minimal coupling @xmath10 for the model ( iii ) .
each line is the snr calculated with noise curves of decigo , upgraded decigo and bbo , respectively , with @xmath307 year . in both cases ,
we assume @xmath241 gev . ,
title="fig:",width=336,height=235 ] 1.0@lccccc ' '' '' model & @xmath14 & @xmath230 & snr ( decigo ) & snr ( upgraded decigo ) & snr ( bbo ) + ' '' '' model ( i ) & 0.153 & @xmath308 & 3.90 & 8.67 & 17.2 + model ( ii ) ( @xmath309 ) & 0.117 & @xmath310 & 3.52 & 7.87 & 15.6 + model ( ii ) ( @xmath311 ) & 0.086 & @xmath312 & 3.03 & 6.81 & 13.4 + @xmath313 ( @xmath54 ) & 0.275 & @xmath314 & 3.24 & 6.94 & 14.2 + model ( iii ) ( @xmath315 ) & 0.144 & @xmath316 & 3.43 & 7.56 & 15.1 + model ( iii ) ( @xmath317 ) & 0.085 & @xmath318 & 3.06 & 6.90 & 13.6 +
in this paper , we have discussed the possibility of the direct measurement of primordial gravitational waves by next generation interferometric detectors .
the prospects for the direct detection depend on the ratio @xmath14 between tensor and scalar perturbations generated during inflation .
if the b - mode polarization measurements of the cmb really confirm the presence of primordial tensor modes with @xmath14 of the order of 0.1 , it is expected that the interferometric detectors like decigo and bbo will be able to detect inflationary gravitational waves in the future .
we have focused on the three large - field inflationary models : quadratic chaotic , natural , and quartic chaotic with non - minimal couplings .
the tensor - to - scalar ratio in the model ( i ) is larger than that in the model ( ii ) for a given number of e - foldings during inflation .
we have studied the background dynamics after inflation including the discussion of the inflaton decay associated with the reheating temperature . the model ( iii ) with @xmath53 can be distinguished from the models ( i ) and ( ii ) , in that the reheating dynamics in the former is driven by a massless inflaton field rather than the massive field .
this difference affects the resulting spectrum of the gravitational wave background .
we have also precisely estimated the number of e - foldings relevant to the cmb anisotropies , which is important to place accurate constraints on inflationary models from the cmb .
we illustrated theoretical predictions ( sec .
[ secinf ] ) for the cmb observables in each inflationary model as well as the likelihood contours constrained from the joint data analysis of planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 without employing the slow - roll approximation .
adding the recent bicep2 data in the analysis leads to the bound : @xmath319 ( 95% c.l . ) . since there is a tension between the planck and bicep2 data , we have not literally used the constraints derived from the bicep2 data .
the future independent b - mode polarization measurements will provide us with more convincing bounds on @xmath14 .
we have computed the spectra of the gravitational wave background @xmath230 for the parameter space inside the 95% c.l .
boundary constrained by planck+wp+bao+high-@xmath168 . for the models ( i ) and ( ii ) there is a suppression of @xmath230 for the frequencies satisfying ( [ freq ] ) . in this case , the critical frequency @xmath232 depends on the reheating temperature @xmath0 .
provided that @xmath0 is larger than the order of @xmath264 gev , the models ( i ) and ( ii ) can reach the detection sensitivity of gravitational waves by decigo and bbo for @xmath320 ( see fig .
[ snr1 ] ) .
when @xmath53 , the model ( iii ) is not plagued by the sharp suppression of @xmath230 due to the absence of a temporal matter era after inflation , so the direct detection is possible regardless of the value of @xmath0 .
we have calculated the signal - to - noise ratio of decigo , upgraded decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo for the models ( i)-(iii ) . compared to the snr of decigo computed in ref .
@xcite , we considered the upgraded version of decigo that improves the sensitivity of measurements . for the model ( i )
the direct detections by upgraded decigo and bbo are possible for @xmath290 gev , @xmath321 gev , and @xmath322 gev at @xmath323 , respectively . for
the model ( ii ) the upgraded decigo and bbo could detect the primordial gravitational waves at 5@xmath278 for @xmath298 and @xmath299 , respectively , provided that @xmath324 gev .
for the model ( iii ) the direct detections would be feasible for @xmath304 ( upgraded decigo ) and @xmath325 ( bbo ) .
we have thus shown that the large - field inflationary models with @xmath14 larger than the order of 0.01 leave interesting observational signatures in the gravitational wave background .
in particular , the models in which reheating is driven by an effective massless inflaton field can be distinguished from the massive models with a temporal matter era after inflation .
we hope that , in addition to the indirect detection of tensor perturbations from the b - mode polarization , the measurements by interferometric detectors will shed new light on the nature of primordial gravitational waves in the foreseeable future .
this work is supported by the grant - in - aid for scientific research from jsps ( nos.24540287 ( tc ) , 24540286 ( st ) , 25287057(ns ) ) , by the grant - in - aid for scientific research on innovative areas ( no .
21111006 ( st ) ) and in part by nihon university ( tc ) and by world premier international research center initiative ( wpi initiative ) , mext , japan . compared to the version published in physical review d , we also incorporated the sensitivity curves and the signal - to - noise ratios of ultimate decigo in this updated arxiv version .
we thank takashi nakamura for his suggestion to include the discussion of ultimate decigo .
v. f. mukhanov and g. v. chibisov , jetp lett .
* 33 * , 532 ( 1981 ) [ pisma zh .
fiz . * 33 * , 549 ( 1981 ) ] ; a. d. linde , phys .
b * 116 * , 335 ( 1982 ) ; s. w. hawking , phys .
b * 115 * , 295 ( 1982 ) ; a. a. starobinsky , phys .
b * 117 * , 175 ( 1982 ) ; a. h. guth and s. y. pi , phys . rev . lett . * 49 * , 1110 ( 1982 ) .
a. a. starobinsky , jetp lett .
* 30 * , 682 ( 1979 ) [ pisma zh .
* 30 * , 719 ( 1979 ) ] ; v. a. rubakov , m. v. sazhin and a. v. veryaskin , phys .
b * 115 * , 189 ( 1982 ) ; l. f. abbott and m. b. wise , nucl .
b * 244 * , 541 ( 1984 ) . c. l. bennett _ et al .
_ [ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 148 * , 1 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302207 ] ; d. n. spergel _ et al . _
[ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys . j. suppl . * 148 * , 175 ( 2003 ) [ astro - ph/0302209 ] .
j. e. lidsey _ et al . ,
_ rev . mod .
phys . * 69 * , 373 ( 1997 ) [ astro - ph/9508078 ] ; d. h. lyth and a. riotto , phys .
rept . *
314 * , 1 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9807278 ] ; b. a. bassett , s. tsujikawa and d. wands , rev .
mod . phys . * 78 * , 537 ( 2006 ) [ astro - ph/0507632 ] ; d. baumann , arxiv:0907.5424 [ hep - th ] .
s. tsujikawa , j. ohashi , s. kuroyanagi and a. de felice , phys .
d * 88 * , 023529 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1305.3044 [ astro-ph.co ] ] ; s. tsujikawa , ptep * 2014 * , no .
6 , 06b104 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1401.4688 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
j. lizarraga , j. urrestilla , d. daverio , m. hindmarsh , m. kunz and a. r. liddle , phys .
lett . * 112 * , 171301 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.4924 [ astro-ph.co ] ] ; a. moss and l. pogosian , phys .
* 112 * , 171302 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.6105 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
n. makino and m. sasaki , prog .
86 * , 103 ( 1991 ) ; r. fakir , s. habib and w. unruh , astrophys .
j. * 394 * , 396 ( 1992 ) ; d. i. kaiser , phys .
d * 52 * , 4295 ( 1995 ) [ astro - ph/9408044 ] ; j. c. hwang and h. noh , phys .
lett . *
81 * , 5274 ( 1998 ) .
e. komatsu and t. futamase , phys .
d * 58 * , 023004 ( 1998 ) [ astro - ph/9711340 ] ; e. komatsu and t. futamase , phys .
d * 59 * , 064029 ( 1999 ) [ astro - ph/9901127 ] ; s. tsujikawa and b. gumjudpai , phys . rev .
d * 69 * , 123523 ( 2004 ) [ astro - ph/0402185 ] ; t. chiba and m. yamaguchi , jcap
* 0810 * , 021 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0807.4965 [ astro - ph ] ] ; n. okada , m. u. rehman and q. shafi , phys . rev .
d * 82 * , 043502 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1005.5161 [ hep - ph ] ] ; a. linde , m. noorbala and a. westphal , jcap * 1103 * , 013 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1101.2652 [ hep - th ] ] ; n. okada , v. n. senoguz and q. shafi , arxiv:1403.6403 [ hep - ph ] .
k. kamada , t. kobayashi , m. yamaguchi and j. yokoyama , phys .
d * 83 * , 083515 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1012.4238 [ astro-ph.co ] ] ; l. a. popa , jcap * 1110 * , 025 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1107.3436 [ astro-ph.co ] ] ; j. ohashi and s. tsujikawa ,
* 1210 * , 035 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1207.4879 [ gr - qc ] ] . l. amendola , phys .
b * 301 * , 175 ( 1993 ) [ gr - qc/9302010 ] ; c. germani and a. kehagias , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 011302 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1003.2635 [ hep - ph ] ] ; c. germani and y. watanabe , jcap * 1107 * , 031 ( 2011 ) ; s. tsujikawa , phys .
d * 85 * , 083518 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1201.5926 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
n. seto , s. kawamura and t. nakamura , phys . rev .
* 87 * , 221103 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0108011 ] ; s. kawamura _ et al .
_ , class .
. grav . * 23 * , s125 ( 2006 ) ; s. kawamura _ et al .
_ , class .
* 28 * , 094011 ( 2011 ) .
s. phinney _
_ , _ the big bang observer : direct detection of gravitational waves from the birth of the universe to the present _ , nasa mission concept study . m. s. turner , phys .
d * 55 * , 435 ( 1997 ) [ astro - ph/9607066 ] .
t. chiba , y. himemoto , m. yamaguchi and j. yokoyama , phys . rev .
d * 76 * , 043516 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0705.2851 [ gr - qc ] ] .
n. seto and j. yokoyama , j. phys .
jap . * 72 * , 3082 ( 2003 ) [ gr - qc/0305096 ] ; k. nakayama , s. saito , y. suwa , and j. yokoyama , phys .
rev . * d77 * , 124001 ( 2008 ) .
[ arxiv:0802.2452 [ hep - ph ] ] ; k. nakayama , s. saito , y. suwa , and j. yokoyama , jcap * 0806 * , 020 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0804.1827 [ astro - ph ] ] .
r. catena , m. pietroni and l. scarabello , phys .
d * 76 * , 084039 ( 2007 ) [ astro - ph/0604492 ] ; n. deruelle and m. sasaki , springer proc .
phys . * 137 * , 247 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1007.3563 [ gr - qc ] ] ; t. chiba and m. yamaguchi , jcap * 1310 * , 040 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1308.1142 [ gr - qc ] ] . f. beutler _ et al .
_ , mon . not .
416 * , 3017 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1106.3366 [ astro-ph.co ] ] ; n. padmanabhan _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1202.0090 [ astro-ph.co ] ; l. anderson _
_ , mon . not .
* 427 * , no . 4 , 3435 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1203.6594 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
k. yagi and n. seto , phys .
d * 83 * , 044011 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1101.3940 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
t. a. prince , m. tinto , s. l. larson and j. w. armstrong , phys .
d * 66 * , 122002 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0209039 ] . | the prospects for direct measurements of inflationary gravitational waves by next generation interferometric detectors inferred from the possible detection of b - mode polarization of the cosmic microwave background are studied .
we compute the spectra of the gravitational wave background and the signal - to - noise ratios by various types of interferometric detectors ( decigo , bbo , and ultimate decigo ) for large - field inflationary models in which the tensor - to - scalar ratio is greater than the order of 0.01 . if the reheating temperature @xmath0 of chaotic inflation with the quadratic potential is high ( @xmath1 gev for upgraded decigo , @xmath2 gev for bbo , and @xmath3 gev for ultimate decigo ) , it will be possible to reach the sensitivity of the gravitational background in future experiments at @xmath4 confidence level .
the direct detection is also possible for natural inflation with the potential @xmath5 $ ] , provided that @xmath6 ( upgraded decigo ) and @xmath7 ( bbo ) with @xmath0 higher than @xmath8 gev .
the quartic potential @xmath9 with a non - minimal coupling @xmath10 between the inflaton field @xmath11 and the ricci scalar @xmath12 gives rise to a detectable level of gravitational waves for @xmath13 smaller than the order of 0.01 , irrespective of the reheating temperature . |
for three - body systems the faddeev equations are the fundamental equations .
after one iteration they possess connected kernels , consequently they are effectively fredholm integral equations of second kind .
thus the fredholm alternative applies : at certain energy either the homogeneous or inhomogeneous equations have solutions .
three - body bound states correspond to the solutions of the homogeneous faddeev equations at real energies , resonances , as usual in quantum mechanics , are related to their complex - energy solutions . the situation becomes more complicated if the coulomb potential enters into the game .
the faddeev equations were derived for short range interactions and if we simply plug - in a coulomb - like potential they become singular .
the solution has been formulated in the faddeev - merkuriev theory @xcite on a mathematically sound and elegant way via integral equations with connected ( compact ) kernels and configuration space differential equations with asymptotic boundary conditions .
recently , along the concept of a three - potential picture , a novel method has been proposed for treating the three - body coulomb problem via solving the set of faddeev - noble and lippmann - schwinger integral equations in coulomb sturmian - space representation .
the method was elaborated first for bound - state problems @xcite with repulsive coulomb plus nuclear potential , then it was extended for calculating @xmath1 scattering at energies below the breakup threshold @xcite . in these calculations
an excellent agreements with the results of other well established methods were found and the efficiency and the accuracy of the method were demonstrated .
also atomic bound - state problems with attractive coulomb interactions were considered @xcite .
the mathematical validity of the procedure , in the context of the faddeev - merkuriev theory , has also been established @xcite . in this article
we seek to extend this novel method for calculating resonant states , the complex - energy solutions of the homogeneous faddeev - type integral equations .
first , along the method of ref .
@xcite , we recapitulate the solution of the homogeneous integral equations , then we show how to continue analytically the green s operators onto the unphysical sheet . as an illustration of the feasibility of this method
we calculate a model three-@xmath0 system interacting via short - range plus repulsive coulomb interaction .
the hamiltonian of a three - body coulombic system reads @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the three - body kinetic energy operator , @xmath4 stands for the three - body potential and @xmath5 denotes the coulomb - like interaction in the subsystem @xmath0 .
we use throughout the usual configuration - space jacobi coordinates @xmath6 and @xmath7 . thus @xmath5 only depends on @xmath6 ( @xmath8 ) , while @xmath4 depends on both @xmath6 and @xmath7 coordinates ( @xmath9 ) .
the physical role of a coulomb - like potential is twofold .
its long - distance part modifies the asymptotic motion , while its short - range part strongly correlates the two - body subsystems .
merkuriev proposed to split the potentials into short - range and long - range parts in the three - body configuration space via a cut - off function @xmath10 @xcite , @xmath11 and @xmath12 . \label{potm}\ ] ] the function @xmath13 is defined such that it separates the asymptotic two - body sector @xmath14 from the rest of the three - body configuration space . on the region of @xmath14
the splitting function @xmath13 asymptotically tends to @xmath15 and on the complementary asymptotic region of the configuration space it tends to @xmath16 .
rigorously , @xmath14 is defined as a part of the three - body configuration space where the condition @xmath17 is satisfied .
so , in @xmath14 the short - range part @xmath18 coincides with the original coulomb - like potential @xmath5 and in the complementary region vanishes , whereas the opposite holds true for @xmath19 . from its
construction follows that if @xmath20 is chosen big enough @xmath21 in the three - body hilbert space does not support any bound state @xcite .
this phenomena is analogous to the observation that some special atomic three - body systems does not have any bound states @xcite .
note that for repulsive coulomb interactions one can also adopt noble s approach @xcite , which can be considered as a special case of merkuriev s splitting , where the splitting is performed in the two - body configuration space .
then @xmath19 coincides with the whole coulomb interaction and @xmath18 with the short range nuclear potential . in the faddeev procedure we spilt the wave function into three components @xmath22 here
@xmath23 is the resolvent of the long - ranged hamiltonian @xmath24 and @xmath25 is the complex energy parameter .
the wave - function components satisfy the homogeneous faddeev - merkuriev integral equations @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the resolvent of the channel long - ranged hamiltonian @xmath28 merkuriev has proved that egs .
( [ fn - eq ] ) possess compact kernels for positive @xmath29 energies , and this property remains valid also for complex energies @xmath30 , @xmath31 .
we solve these integral equations in coulomb sturmian - space representation .
the coulomb - sturmian ( cs ) functions are defined by @xmath32^{1/2 } ( 2br)^{l+1 } \exp(-b r ) l_n^{2l+1}(2b r ) , \label{basisr}\ ] ] with @xmath33 and @xmath34 being the radial and orbital angular momentum quantum numbers , respectively , and @xmath35 is the size parameter of the basis .
the cs functions @xmath36 form a biorthonormal discrete basis in the radial two - body hilbert space ; the biorthogonal partner defined by @xmath37 .
since the three - body hilbert space is a direct product of two - body hilbert spaces , an appropriate basis is the angular momentum coupled direct product ( the possible other quantum numbers are implicitly assumed ) @xmath38 with this basis the completeness relation takes the form @xmath39 note that in the three - body hilbert space , three equivalent bases belonging to fragmentation @xmath0 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 are possible . in ref .
@xcite a novel approximation scheme has been proposed to the faddeev - type integral equations @xmath42 i.e. the short - range potential @xmath18 in the three - body hilbert space is taken to have a separable form , viz .
@xmath43 where @xmath44 . in ref .
@xcite the validity of the approximation were proved .
the argumentation in ref .
@xcite relies on the square integrable property of the term @xmath45 , @xmath46 .
thus this approximation is justified also for complex energies as long as this property remains valid . in eq .
( [ sepfe ] ) the ket and bra states are defined for different fragmentation , depending on the environment of the potential operators in the equations .
now , with this approximation , the solution of the homogeneous faddeev - merkuriev equations turns into solution of matrix equations for the component vector @xmath47 @xmath48 where @xmath49 .
a unique solution exists if and only if @xmath50^{-1 } - \underline{v}^{(s ) } \ } = 0.\ ] ] the green s operator @xmath51 is a solution of the auxiliary three - body problem with the hamiltonian @xmath52 . to determine it uniquely one should start again from faddeev - type integral equations , which does not seem to lead any further , or from the triad of lippmann - schwinger equations @xcite .
the triad of lippmann - schwinger equations , although they do not possess compact kernels and thus they are not amenable for practical calculations , also define the solution in an unique way .
they are , in fact , related to the adjoint representation of the faddeev operator @xcite .
the hamiltonian @xmath53 , however , has a peculiar property that it supports bound state only in the subsystem @xmath0 , and thus it has only one kind of asymptotic channel , the @xmath0 channel .
for such a system one single lippmann - schwinger equation is sufficient for an unique solution @xcite .
the appropriate equation takes the form @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the resolvent channel - distorted long - range hamiltonian , @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the auxiliary potential @xmath58 depends on the coordinate @xmath7 .
it is defined such that it does not support any bound state and has the asymptotic form @xmath59 as @xmath60 .
in fact , @xmath58 is an effective coulomb interaction between the center of mass of the subsystem @xmath0 ( with charge @xmath61 ) and the third particle ( with charge @xmath62 ) .
its role is to compensate the coulomb tail of the potentials @xmath63 in @xmath14 .
if @xmath58 is a repulsive coulomb potential the requirement that it should not support bound states can can easily be fulfilled . for attractive @xmath58 the infinitely many bound states
should be projected out , which leads to a non - local potential .
it is important to realize that in this approach to get the solution only the matrix elements @xmath64 are needed , i.e. only the representation of the green s operator on a compact subset of the hilbert space are required .
so , although eq .
( [ lsgc ] ) does not possesses a compact kernel on the whole three - body hilbert space its matrix form is effectively a compact equation on the subspace spanned by finite number of cs functions @xcite .
thus we can perform an approximation , similar to eq .
( [ sepfe ] ) , on the potential @xmath65 in eq .
( [ lsgc ] ) , with bases of the same fragmentation @xmath0 applied on both sides of the operator .
now the integral equation reduces to an analogous set of linear algebraic equation with the operators replaced by their matrix representations .
the solution is given by @xmath66^{-1 } = [ \underline{\widetilde{g}}_\alpha ( z)]^{-1 } - \underline{u}^{\alpha}.\ ] ] the most crucial point in this procedure is the calculation of the matrix elements @xmath67 , since the potential matrix elements @xmath68 and @xmath69 can always be calculated numerically by making use of the transformation of jacobi coordinates . the green s operator @xmath55 is a resolvent of the sum of two commuting hamiltonians , @xmath70 , where @xmath71 and @xmath72 , which act in different two - body hilbert spaces .
thus , using the convolution theorem the three - body green s operator @xmath55 equates to a convolution integral of two - body green s operators , i.e. @xmath73 where @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
the contour @xmath76 should be taken counterclockwise around the continuous spectrum of @xmath77 so that @xmath78 is analytic in the domain encircled by @xmath76 . to examine the structure of the integrand
let us shift the spectrum of @xmath78 by taking @xmath79 with positive @xmath80 . by doing so ,
the two spectra become well separated and the spectrum of @xmath81 can be encircled .
next the contour @xmath76 is deformed analytically in such a way that the upper part descends to the unphysical riemann sheet of @xmath81 , while the lower part of @xmath76 can be detoured away from the cut [ see fig .
[ fig1 ] ] .
the contour still encircles the branch cut singularity of @xmath81 , but in the @xmath82 limit it now avoids the singularities of @xmath83 .
moreover , by continuing to negative values of @xmath80 , in order that we can calculate resonances , the branch cut and pole singularities of @xmath83 move onto the second riemann sheet of @xmath81 and , at the same time , the branch cut of @xmath81 moves onto the second riemann sheet of @xmath83 .
thus , the mathematical conditions for the contour integral representation of @xmath84 in eq .
( [ contourint ] ) can be fulfilled also for complex energies with negative imaginary part . in this respect
there is only a gradual difference between the bound- and resonant - state calculations .
now , the matrix elements @xmath85 can be cast in the form @xmath86 where the corresponding cs matrix elements of the two - body green s operators in the integrand are known analytically for all complex energies @xcite , and thus the convolution integral can be performed also in the practice .
to illustrate the feasibility of this method we examine the convergence of the results for three - body resonant - state energies .
for this purpose we take an ali bodmer - type toy - model for the charged three-@xmath0 system interacting via @xmath87-wave short - range interaction . to improve its properties
we add a phenomenological three - body potential . adopting noble s splitting we have @xmath88 with @xmath89 mev , @xmath90 mev , @xmath91 fm , @xmath92 fm , and @xmath93 we use units such that @xmath94 mev , @xmath95 mev fm .
the mass of the @xmath0-particle is chosen as @xmath96 , where @xmath97 denotes the mass of the nucleon .
the three body potential is taken to have gaussian form @xmath98 where @xmath99 , @xmath100 mev and @xmath101 fm . here
@xmath102 stands for the position vector of @xmath103-th particle in the center of mass frame of three-@xmath0 system .
we select states with total angular momentum @xmath104 . in table
i we show the convergence of the energy of the ground - state and of the first resonant - state with respect to @xmath105 , the number of cs functions employed in the expansion .
the selected resonance is the experimentally well - known sharp state which has a great relevance in nuclear synthesis . for comparison
we have recalculated the results of ref.@xcite , where a two - channel model has been proposed for the three-@xmath0 system .
table ii shows a good agreement between the two independent methods as far as the position of the resonance is considered . for the width of the resonant state we got an order of magnitude less which indicate an order of magnitude longer lifetime .
the origin of the discrepancy , in our opinion , could be due to the not proper implementation of the asymptotic boundary conditions in ref .
in this article we have proposed a new method for calculating resonances in three - body coulombic systems .
the homogeneous faddeev - merkuriev integral equations were solved for complex energies . for this , being an integral equation approach , the no boundary conditions are needed .
the procedure is an extension of the well - established coulomb - sturmian separable expansion approach @xcite .
in fact , the extension is nothing else but the proper analytic continuation of the contour integral representation of the green s operator . in the non - coulomb case
the method is readily applicable , only the coulomb green s operators have to be replaced by the free one .
this work has been supported by otka under contracts no .
t026233 and no .
t029003 , by russian foundation for basic research grant no .
98 - 02 - 18190 and partially by the exchange program between the hungarian and the russian academies of sciences .
.convergence of the ground - state and of the first resonant - state energy ( in mev ) of a three-@xmath0 system interacting via the potential of ( [ filpot ] ) with increasing basis for the separable expansion .
@xmath105 denotes the maximum number of basis states employed for @xmath33 and @xmath106 in eq .
( [ sepfe ] ) . [ cols=">,<,<",options="header " , ] papp z. : j. phys .
a * 20 * , 153 ( 1987 ) ; phys .
c * 38 * , 2457 ( 1988 ) ; phys .
a * 46 * , 4437 ( 1992 ) ; comp .
comm . * 70 * , 426 ( 1992 ) ; ibid * 70 * , 435 ( 1992 ) ; knya b. , lvai g. and papp z. : j. math . phys .
* 38 * , 4832 ( 1997 ) . | we propose a novel method for calculating resonances in three - body coulombic systems .
the method is based on the solution of the set of faddeev and lippmann - schwinger integral equations , which are designed for solving the three - body coulomb problem .
the resonances of the three - body system are defined as the complex - energy solutions of the homogeneous faddeev integral equations .
we show how the kernels of the integral equations should be continued analytically in order that we get resonances . as a numerical illustration a toy model for the three-@xmath0 system
is solved . |
the collective self - examination made possible in astronomy by the decadal review process is a prime opportunity to engineer the incentives and institutions that shape our profession .
we need not simply accept as inevitable the institutional framework that we ve inherited . the standard trajectory of the american academic career has been essentially fixed since the mid-20th century , when postdoc appointments started becoming common [ 1 ] .
however , the practice of astronomy has changed since the 1950 s : we now deal with increasingly enormous telescopes , collaborations , and data sets .
the lack of similar evolution in graduate training has resulted in ph.d .
recipients who are no longer optimally trained for the skills and new positions required by modern astronomical research . in 2 ,
we discuss these issues in detail and identify inefficiencies in the current structure for funding and training new professionals .
the practical structure of academic astronomy has also changed significantly . while the ph.d .
overproduction rate compared to faculty spots has remained approximately steady over the past two decades , there were many fewer postdoc positions in the past [ 2 ] . in recent years , however , increased federal funding has led to a boom in graduate student and postdoc positions without a concomitant expansion in the number of permanent faculty positions [ 3 ] . in 3 , we explore the implications of these realities in our field .
additionally , the past half - century has witnessed a dramatic change in the workforce . the opportunity to gain the contributions of many excellent astronomers
is currently missed . in 4 , we consider only one example of this phenomenon : how the resulting rise in the demand for `` child - friendly '' careers has been borne by our field .
progress to date has been minimal , and the evidence is that this situation systematically selects against women .
there is thus a good case to be made that the institutional framework of academic astronomy is suboptimal and disserves both the practitioners of astronomy and the public that ultimately funds it .
fortunately , this is an issue that we , the astronomical community , can solve .
we argue that the subcommittee on the state of the profession ( ssp ) should direct its attention toward improving the structure of our instutional framework .
we outline below the evidence for a few outstanding problems , describe their costs to the community , and provide some suggestions that we hope will prove useful to those charged with charting the course of astronomy over the next decade .
the training of professional astronomers is integral to the discussion of what science will be done in the coming ten years . in this section , we discuss the current state of astrophysics training and propose that adaptations to this process will be necessary in order to best use financial resources and personnel to produce the best science .
significant financial resources are currently invested in the training of the next generation of astronomers . a typical astronomy ph.d .
candidate may earn $ 20k annually , with an additional $ 20k spent by the pi or department to pay tuition and university fees .
assuming that the average student spends 5 years in graduate school and requires an additional $ 50k over the course of this time to support equipment , travel , and miscellaneous expenses , every graduate student will cost the profession a quarter of a million dollars .
each year in the past decade , there have been @xmath0170 astronomy ph.d.s awarded in the united states [ 4 , 5 ] , _ for a total of over $ 43 m spent annually to produce new professionals _ ( see also the seth _ et al . _ position paper on `` employment & funding in astronomy '' ) .
this is almost quadruple the annual operations budget of the keck observatory [ 6 ] .
graduate students are typically funded through research grants and are typically expected to devote the vast majority of their time to pure research .
this policy is even expressly stated in some graduate student guides ( _ e.g. _ [ 7 ] ) and is pervasive in the professional culture .
few programs offer any incentives to broaden coursework beyond astronomy and physics to include computer science , engineering , public policy , business , or education . while many astronomy graduate programs mandate that students spend one or more semesters as teaching assistants , training in teaching skills is generally minimal , although there are laudable exceptions [ 8 , 9 ] .
development of the skills needed for teaching at the non - university level and public outreach is typically absent from the curriculum .
there is only room in the field for @xmath150% of ph.d .
recipients to become faculty at colleges and universities [ 3 ] .
in fact , self - reporting of the careers of 651 astronomy ph.d . recipients from 1980 - 2000 at eight universities
reveals that 34% currently hold tenure - track faculty positions at research universities . the remaining two - thirds of ph.d .
astronomers are employed at teaching colleges as tenure - track faculty ( 10% ) , at k-12 schools as educators or elsewhere as education researchers ( 2% ) , at observatories and national laboratories as permanent support / research staff ( 38% ) , and within business and industry ( 17% ) .
that is , almost one third of ph.d .
recipients are not primarily employed in research .
an informal survey of uc berkeley faculty indicates that they spend approximately 25% of their work time on research ( excluding student and postdoc interaction ) , 25% on teaching , 19% on administrative duties ( including committee participation and large - scale project management ) , 14% on advising students and postdocs , 12% on securing funding ( for personal research as well as observatories / organizations / departments as a whole ) , and 5% on public outreach . despite the small sample size
we feel that it is fair to say that * even `` research university '' faculty spend the majority of their time on activities other than research*. overall , we find that * training is a significant expenditure in the field of astronomy * and that * a majority of astronomy ph.d .
recipients spend a significant fraction of their time on activities other than research*. although the critical problem - solving skills obtained via research training are unarguably used by all astronomy ph.d.s , regardless of career , there are other , equally valuable skills that these ph.d.s will need that are not currently included in graduate training .
this mismatch between the training of young professionals and the skills required in their future employment will only continue to grow in the coming decade .
the increasing size and scope of projects in astronomy ( _ e.g. _ keck , vla , alma , tmt , supercomputing and data management facilities ) are creating increasingly large collaborations in which diverse skills are needed [ 10 ] .
obviously , the success of these projects depends critically on the @xmath1@xmath2 of ph.d.s who become faculty and pis .
such success is , however , dictated by much more than the pi s ability to do excellent science .
lead scientists within collaborations must also excel at managing funding and personnel , communicating science needs and results to the public ( including the general public , government agencies , private investors , and industrial partners ) , and instructing and mentoring junior members of the group .
many of the requisite skills for these tasks are , in general , completely ignored during graduate and postdoctoral training and developed only later through trial and error .
the lack of these skills in pis can result at best in inefficiencies and at worst in misuse of funding and failure of strong scientific programs . about two - fifths of ph.d .
astronomers find employment in permanent support or research staff positions , which require skills in areas such as data management and the construction , operation , and maintenance of hardware and software .
this proportion will likely increase with the increasing scope of planned facilities . despite this fact , ph.d .
programs generally do not have formal structures that encourage candidates to develop sophisticated programming or engineering skills . even more critically , the funding of the field and influx of talented individuals into it rely on education and outreach at all levels .
this is the explicit career of 11% of ph.d .
astronomers ( k-12 educators , education researchers , and professors at teaching colleges ) , but it is also an important role of university faculty ( @xmath130% of whose time is devoted to teaching and public outreach ) and , to varying extents , of support astronomers .
the importance of this part of astronomy can not be understated : in the notable case of the hubble space telescope ( hst ) , public enthusiasm for the field directly led to the continuation of nasa support and congressional funding that would have otherwise been cut [ 11 ] .
nevertheless , education and outreach typically have minimal roles in astronomy training ( 2.1 ) . finally , @xmath1@xmath3 of ph.d .
astronomers leave the field entirely .
while , as argued by the seth _ et al .
_ position paper on `` employment & funding in astronomy '' , there are not enough permanent positions in the field for all astronomy ph.d.s , there is no reason to believe that those who leave are uniformly less excellent astronomers than those who stay .
* the training that ph.d.s receive creates expectations about the profession and signals what it values .
the mismatch between that training and actual employment opportunities may drive talented young scientists to leave the profession .
* the above breakdown of job outcomes is a statistical reality .
graduate mentors need to both support and provide training for a number of possible employment opportunities .
we suggest that the ssp investigate ways in which funding structures and associated directives to universities can be altered to support this realignment .
in particular , * we suggest the following * : 0.5 in * ( a ) * that the definition of a career in astronomy be broadened to include the true assortment of potential careers in astronomy that ph.d.s eventually have ; that this be assessed via rigorous tracking of the employment statistics of all ph.d .
recipients from graduate school through postdoc positions and culminating only when permanent positions are attained ; and that updated statistics be regularly disseminated within the academic community .
this is also one of the main points of the seth _ et al . _ position paper on `` employment & funding in astronomy '' . *
( b ) * that the training given at universities granting astronomy ph.d.s reflect this paradigm shift , such that graduate students are trained for the jobs they will eventually hold . * ( c ) * that communication and leadership skills be emphasized in a meaningful and substantial way in ph.d .
programs , helping the next generation to garner support from non - scientists , lead successful scientific projects and collaborations , and attract , educate , and mentor future generations of scientists
. 0.25 in creative thinking will obviously be necessary to effect such a change in the astronomy education system at the graduate level .
here we list some means through which this might be achieved , which we intend not to be exhaustive but rather to initiate discussion : new ph.d .
programs could be funded to provide the breadth of knowledge and specialization now required by many careers in astronomy , _
e.g. _ , joint programs between astronomy and computer science , engineering , business , public policy , or education ( dual ph.d . , ph.d./masters , ph.d . with a `` minor '' )
; federally - funded astronomy ph.d .
students could be required to spend a semester away from research in , _
e.g. _ , government agencies , student teaching positions , or internships within industry ; quantifiable mentoring , teaching , and outreach requirements could be attached to federal grants ( expanding on the latest nsf proposal and award policies and procedures guide ) such that young professionals are required to devote part of their time to improving their leadership and communication skills .
most likely , a combination of many changes and initiatives will be needed to ensure that the training of young astronomers is best - suited to the positions that will need to be filled in the next ten years and beyond .
the structure of the traditional academic career has not kept up with the realities of the modern university .
the postdoctoral position , once a short stopping point between ph.d . and
the tenure track , has evolved into a substantial phase of the academic career , with recipients holding 23 postdoc positions ( _ i.e. _ , 49 years ) until a permanent job is obtained [ 3 ] . along with the increasing duration of this phase
, it is also becoming increasingly and unnecessarily demanding and demoralizing .
three fundamental factors are responsible for the transformation of the character of the postdoc phase : ( 1 ) the boom in ph.d.s granted , ( 2 ) the lack of a similar expansion in permanent academic positions , and , importantly , ( 3 ) the failure of most ph.d .
training programs to adapt to this discrepancy , as described in 2 .
the interaction of these factors results in a situation where there are many people competing for few spots . while intense competition for prestigious jobs is natural , the incentives of the field encourage maximization of the amount of work extracted from trained astronomers , _
i.e. _ , the attrition of ph.d.s out of the running for those jobs as late as possible . this situation does not select for higher - quality faculty it merely places unnecessary burdens on those who do not end up attaining faculty jobs .
the explicit recommendation of the previous decadal review committee to increase federal funding for postdoctoral fellowships has played a role in this effect [ 12 , p. 198 ] .
the consequences of this situation are acute .
* current postdocs endure a period of intense competition , prolonged job insecurity , multiple relocations with little or no choice in destination , and the prospect of a forced late - stage ( mid-30 s ) career change .
* as we discuss in the following section , the implications for those who also wish to start a family are particularly dire .
this situation will not change as long as the three factors described above hold . because our field is vibrant and competitive and academic jobs are very attractive to many , it would be incorrect to suggest that the difficulty of the postdoc phase will lead to unfilled tenure - track positions . however , the simple fact is that _ we can do better_. the problems of the postdoc system are not limited to astronomy , nor can they be solved overnight .
one advantage that our field has , however , is relatively small size and the importance that federal funding plays within it .
* we recommend that the ssp * : 0.5 in * ( d ) * re - evaluate postdoctoral and pre - tenure positions and recommend funding changes to remove the `` arms race '' incentives of the current system . 0.25 in
we hope that the ssp discusses a wide range of approaches to meeting this challenge , such as : eliminating the plethora of federally funded postdoctoral fellowships in favor of funding more diverse permanent positions ; completely reconceptualizing the postdoctoral process and the transition from graduate school to permanent positions ; encouraging the creation of a more fluid workforce in which early - career jobs can be held for longer periods of time and transitions between positions flow naturally with project timescales rather than in rigid ( typically 3 - 5 year ) timescales .
it is worth noting that the tenure system plays a fundamental role in shaping the current postdoctoral system . finally ,
in this topic , academic systems outside of the united states can provide examples , both good and bad , from which to learn .
the lack of adaptation in our professional institutions to social change has dramatic effects on the retention of excellent astronomers , with particular impact on underrepresented groups .
lengthy reports can be ( and have been ) written on this topic ; we will focus on one example , the area of `` child - friendliness '' within astronomy and its effect upon women in our field .
we will treat it briefly and consider again how the structure of our institutions affects the profession ; we hope that other position papers will deal with this , and the other ways in which our field loses excellent astronomers , much more fully . in the past , most couples had one working spouse and one spouse who performed virtually all childcare duties . in such situations , it is viable for the working spouse to have an extremely time - demanding job .
the modern norm is for families to be dual - income , and professional couples with children increasingly expect that both partners will work hard , pursue a fulfilling career , and share in childcare duties [ 13 ] . in this situation
time - demanding and relatively low - paying jobs are much more difficult to accommodate .
the increase in demand for careers that accommodate two - income families has occurred more - or - less simultaneously with the severe lengthening of the postdoc phase .
all of the difficulties mentioned in 3 are particularly problematic for parents ; moreover , the postdoc stage usually happens at the exact age in the late 20 s and early 30 s in which most families are started .
the hardship of multiple relocations is especially trying for those with long - term partners let alone those with long - term partners _ and _ children who therefore need to solve the `` two - body problem '' not once but several times over the course of only a few years .
the reality of these concerns is well - established in our field and others . in a survey of university of california
graduate students in all disciplines , 74% of the male respondents and 84% of the female respondents reported being `` somewhat '' or `` very concerned '' about the family - friendliness of their career paths [ 14 ] .
( here , we treat issues relating to family - friendliness as a superset of those relating to child - friendliness . )
exacerbating the problem is the difficulty of re - entering the field after any significant time away from it , discouraging would - be parents from leaving the field temporarily to care for young children .
in fact , even junior faculty are uncomfortable with lessening their workload for maternity / paternity . according to the uc faculty work and family survey [ 15 ] , less than a third of eligible faculty used the university s tenure `` clock stoppage '' option for new parents ; of the survey respondents who did not , a significant fraction ( @xmath130% ) cited `` it might have hurt my career '' as a reason for not invoking it .
while the difficulties of raising a family affect all academics , there is no question that they disproportionately impact the careers of women , regardless of their level of talent . in [ 14 ] , 46% of the female respondents who began graduate school with the goal of becoming faculty but shifted their goals cited `` issues related to children '' as a major factor , while only 21% of the male respondents did .
the results of [ 15 ] make for sobering reading : in virtually every aspect , female faculty find more of a tension between their careers and their families than their male counterparts .
* we emphatically reject the notion that a prioritization of family life over career necessarily implies a lack of excellence in the field . *
improving the representation of women in astronomy depends upon addressing the child - friendliness of academic careers , though * the status of women in astronomy depends on far more than this one factor*. conversely , * genuine efforts in this direction will make it a better field for all of its members , not just women . * we believe that the inequities alluded to in this section are all serious and worthy of correction on their own merits .
however , they also have a damaging effect on the field by injuring its legitimacy in the public eye .
legislators and other funders may question justifiably whether they should direct spending towards a field that is only sluggishly addressing its glaring inequalities [ 16 , 17 ] .
this is especially true for a field which generally aspires to be a meritocracy in which individuals succeed purely based on the quality of their contributions .
while astronomy is not the only offender , other fields , notably biology , do a better job of retaining excellent scientists [ 18 , 19 ] .
significant federal effort is now directed towards rectifying gender inequalities in stem ( science , technology , engineering , and mathematics ) professions . in
[ 17 ] , the national academies stated that in order to `` maintain scientific and engineering leadership amid increasing economic and educational globalization , the united states must aggressively pursue the innovative capacity of _ all _ of its people , '' regardless of gender ( emphasis original ) . in october 2008 ,
barack obama responded to a query from the association for women in science with the following statement of policy [ 20 ] : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we will need to significantly increase our stem workforce , and to do that we will need to engage not just women and minorities but also persons with disabilities , english language learners , and students from low income families
we also support improved educational opportunities for all students , increased responsibilities and accountability for those receiving federal research funding , equitable enforcement of existing laws such as title ix , continuation and strengthening of programs aimed at broader engagement in the stem disciplines _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ there has , in fact , been formal federal investigation into forcing university science programs to begin addressing inequalities by applying title ix to them ( _ e.g. _ [ 21 , 22 ] )
. it will take concerted effort across many sectors of academia , government , and society to enable us to attract and retain the best astronomers from all demographics .
nevertheless , the decadal review is an opportunity to begin implementing necessary policies .
we * suggest that the ssp * : 0.5 in * ( e ) * mandate that job ads and offer letters at _ all _ levels in the field include information on the hiring institution s family - friendly policies . *
( f ) * identify model programs that have demonstrated positive impacts on the demographics and family - friendliness of astronomy and recommend that funding be allocated for duplications , expansions , and improvements of these programs . *
( g ) * identify policies that help retain the most talented astronomers and recommend that required implementation of these policies be attached to federal funding .
study the examples of other fields for lessons , both positive and negative . *
( h ) * consider any changes to the postdoctoral system in the light of the effect they will have on family - friendliness and the retention of excellent astronomers . 0.25 in we reiterate that *
many of the current challenges in astronomy careers are due to institutional structures than can be changed*. some ideas to initiate discussion are : establishing opt - out minimum tenure `` clock stopping '' or parental leave policies ; issuing comprehensive employer childcare assistance standards . a community approach to the enforcement of title ix ,
should it be mandated , should be discussed .
the decadal review provides an invaluable opportunity to affirm _ and revise _ our values as a community and set priorities accordingly .
this process has been tremendously successful in establishing support for instruments that have been the basis for ground - breaking science : the very large array , hst , and spitzer were all made possible in large part due to recommendations of past decadal review committees .
the decadal review process has also won support in washington for the field of astronomy and indirectly led other fields to establish their own similar review processes [ 23 ] .
however , while past reviews have been extremely successful in shaping the technologies used to pursue the next generation of science , less attention has been directed towards properly training and maintaining the astronomers who perform the science .
still less has been focused on training the next generation of astronomy educators , public policy experts , and project managers .
while the needs of the profession and the labor market have evolved significantly since the astronomy decadal review process was established , the overall academic structure of the field has remained largely unchanged .
many of our current practices are outmoded , resulting in misallocated resources and attrition patterns that cause us to lose the contributions of excellent scientists .
the failure of past decadal review processes to allocate sufficient time and funding to revising these practices represents an undervaluation of the field s human resources . in a time of economic downturn and budget shortfalls , it is in our best interest to put stock in the ability of talented individuals to develop creative new solutions to outstanding problems in our field , whether those problems be in basic research , education , public outreach , or policy .
we urge the subcommittee to develop strong , concrete recommendations tied to funding which acknowledge and support the important role human contributions make to the scientific endeavor .
0.25in1 [ 6 ] `` first triple quasar discovered at w. m. keck observatory '' , 8 jan 2007 , _ news and outreach _ ,
w. m. keck observatory : http://keckobservatory.org/index.php/news/first_triple_quasar_discovered_at_w._m._keck_observatory/ [ 7 ] `` a guide to the astronomy graduate program '' , 2007 , university of arizona , department of astronomy and steward observatory ( 12 mar 2009 ) : http://www.as.arizona.edu/academic_program/graduate_program/graduate_academic_guide.html [ 12 ] astronomy and astrophysics survey committee , commission on physical sciences , mathematics , and applications , national research council .
`` astronomy and astrophysics in the new millennium '' , 2001 , the national academies press : http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?isbn=0309070317 [ 14 ] mason , m. a. & goulden , m. `` uc doctoral student career life survey '' , 2006 , the uc faculty family friendly edge : http://ucfamilyedge.berkeley.edu/why%20graduate%20students%20reject%20the%20fast%20track.pdf [ 15 ] mason , m. a. , stacy , a. , goulden , m. , hoffman , c. , and frasch , k. `` uc faculty family friendly edge report '' , 2005 , the uc faculty family friendly edge : http://ucfamilyedge.berkeley.edu/ucfamilyedge.pdf [ 18 ] `` digest of education statistics '' , fall 2005 , u.s .
department of education , national center for education statistics , 200405 integrated postsecondary education data system ( ipeds ) : http://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d06/tables/dt06_258.asp [ 19 ] leadley , j. , magrane , d. , lang , j. , and pham , t. `` women in u.s .
academic medicine : statistics and benchmarking report , 2007 - 08 '' , 2008 , association of american medical colleges ( aamc ) : http://www.aamc.org/members/wim/statistics/stats08/stats_report.pdf [ 20 ] `` campaign responses to questions from the association for women in science & the society of women engineers '' , 15 oct 2008 , association for women in science ( awis ) : http://www.awis.org/documents/obamamccainresponses.pdf [ 22 ] `` gender issues : women s participation in the sciences has increased , but agencies need to do more to ensure compliance with title ix '' , 22 jul 2004 , government accountability office ( gao ) report , gao-04 - 639 : http://www.gao.gov/products/gao-04-639 | while both society and astronomy have evolved greatly over the past fifty years , the academic institutions and incentives that shape our field have remained largely stagnant . as a result
, the astronomical community is faced with several major challenges , including : ( 1 ) the training that we provide does not align with the skills that future astronomers will need , ( 2 ) the postdoctoral phase is becoming increasingly demanding and demoralizing , and ( 3 ) our jobs are increasingly unfriendly to families with children .
solving these problems will require conscious engineering of our profession .
fortunately , this decadal review offers the opportunity to revise outmoded practices to be more effective and equitable . the highest priority of the subcommittee on the state of the profession should be to recommend _
specific , funded _ activities that will ensure the field meets the challenges we describe . |
music summarization has been the subject of research for at least a decade and many algorithms that address this problem , mainly for popular music , have been published in the past @xcite . however , those algorithms focus on producing human consumption - oriented summaries , i.e. , summaries that will be listened to by people motivated by the need to quickly get the gist of the whole song without having to listen to all of it .
this type of summarization entails extra requirements besides conciseness and diversity ( non - redundancy ) , such as clarity and coherence , so that people can enjoy listening to them .
generic summarization algorithms , however , focus on extracting concise and diverse summaries and have been successfully applied in text and speech summarization @xcite .
their application , in music , for human consumption - oriented purposes is not ideal , for they will select and concatenate the most relevant and diverse information ( according to each algorithm s definition of relevance and diversity ) without taking into account whether the output is enjoyable for people or not .
this is usually reflected , for instance , on discontinuities or irregularities in beat synchronization in the resulting summaries .
we focus on improving the performance of tasks recognized as important by the community , e.g. music genre classification , through summarization , as opposed to considering music summaries as the product to be consumed by people .
thus , we can ignore some of the requirements of previous music summarization efforts , which usually try to model the musical structure of the pieces being summarized , possibly using musical knowledge .
although human - related aspects of music summarization are important in general , they are beyond the focus of this paper .
we claim that , for tasks benefiting from summaries , it is sufficient to consider the most relevant parts of the signal , according to its features . in particular , summarizers do not need to take into account song structure or human perception of music .
our rationale is that summaries contain more relevant and less redundant information , thus improving the performance of tasks that rely on processing just a portion of the whole signal , leading to faster processing , less space usage , and efficient use of bandwidth .
we use @xcite , lexrank @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and support sets @xcite to summarize music for automatic ( instead of human ) consumption . to evaluate the effects of summarization
, we assess the performance of binary and 5-class music genre classification , when considering song summaries against continuous clips ( taken from the beginning , middle , and end of the songs ) and against the whole songs .
we show that all of these algorithms improve classification performance and are statistically not significantly different from using the whole songs .
these results complement and solidify previous work evaluated on a binary fado classifier @xcite .
the article is organized as follows : section [ sec : music - summarization ] reviews related work on music - specific summarization .
section [ sec : generic - summarization ] reviews the generic summarization algorithms we experimented with : ( section [ sub : grasshopper ] ) , lexrank ( section [ sub : lexrank ] ) , ( section [ sub : lsa ] ) , ( section [ sub : mmr ] ) , and support sets - based centrality ( section [ sub : support - sets ] ) . section [ sec : experiments ] details the experiments we performed for each algorithm and introduces the classifier .
sections [ sec : binary - results ] and [ sec : multiclass - results ] report our classification results for the binary and multiclass classification scenarios , respectively .
section [ sec : discussion ] discusses the results and section [ sec : conclusions ] concludes this paper with some remarks and future work .
current algorithms for music summarization were developed to extract an enjoyable summary so that people can listen to it clearly and coherently .
in contrast , our approach considers summaries exclusively for automatic consumption .
human - oriented music summarization starts by structurally segmenting songs and selecting meaningful segments to include in the summary .
the assumption is that songs are represented as label sequences where each label represents a different part of the song ( e.g. , ababca where a is the chorus , b the verse , and c the bridge ) . in @xcite ,
segmentation is achieved by using a to detect key changes between frames and to detect repeating structure . in @xcite ,
a gaussian - tempered `` checkerboard '' kernel is correlated along the main diagonal of the song s self - similarity matrix , outputting segment boundaries .
then , a segment - indexed matrix , containing the similarity between detected segments , is built .
is applied to find its rank-@xmath0 approximation .
segments are , then , clustered to output the song s structure . in @xcite , a similarity matrix is built and analyzed for fast changes , outputting segment boundaries ; segments are clustered to output the `` middle states '' ; an is applied to these states , producing the final segmentation . then , various strategies are considered to select the appropriate segments . in @xcite , a modification of the divergence
is used to group and label similar segments .
the summary consists of the longest sequence of segments belonging to the same cluster . in @xcite and @xcite ,
average similarity is used to extract a thumbnail @xmath1 seconds long that is the most similar to the whole piece .
it starts by calculating a similarity matrix through computing frame - wise similarities .
then , it calculates an aggregated similarity measure , for each possible starting frame , of the @xmath1-second segment with the whole song and picks the one that maximizes it as the summary .
another method for this task , maximum filtered correlation @xcite , starts by building a similarity matrix and then a filtered time - lag matrix , embedding the similarity between extended segments separated by a constant lag .
the starting frame of the summary corresponds to the index that maximizes the filtered time - lag matrix . in @xcite
, music is classified as pure or vocal , in order to perform type - specific feature extraction .
the summary , created from three to five seconds subsummaries ( built from frame clusters ) , takes into account musicological and psychological aspects , by differentiating between types of music based on feature selection and specific duration .
this promotes human enjoyment when listening to the summary .
since these summaries were targeted to people , they were evaluated by people . in @xcite
, music datasets are summarized into a codebook - based audio feature representation , to efficiently retrieve songs in a query - by - tag and query - by - example fashion .
an initial dataset is discretized , creating a dictionary of @xmath2 basis vectors . then , for each query song , the audio signal is quantized , according to the pre - computed dictionary , mapping the audio signal into a histogram of basis vectors .
these histograms are used to compute music similarity .
this type of summarization allows for efficient retrieval of music but is limited to the features which are initially chosen .
our focus is on audio signal summaries , which are suitable for any audio feature extraction , instead of proxy representations for audio features .
applying generic summarization to music implies song segmentation into musical words and sentences .
since we do not take into account human - related aspects of music perception , we can segment songs according to an arbitrarily fixed size .
this differs from structural segmentation in that it does not take into account human perception of musical structure and does not create meaningful segments .
nevertheless , it still allows us to look at the variability and repetition of the signal and use them to find its most important parts .
furthermore , since it is not aimed at human consumption , the generated summaries are less liable to violate the copyrights of the original songs .
this facilitates the sharing of datasets ( using the signal itself , instead of specific features extracted from it ) for research efforts . in the following sections , we review the generic summarization algorithms we evaluated .
[ [ sub : grasshopper ] ] the @xcite was applied to text summarization and social network analysis , focusing on improving ranking diversity .
it takes an @xmath3 matrix @xmath4 representing a graph where each sentence is a vertex and each edge has weight @xmath5 corresponding to the similarity between sentences @xmath6 and @xmath7 ; and a probability distribution @xmath8 encoding prior ranking .
first , @xmath4 is row - normalized : @xmath9
. then , @xmath10 is built , incorporating the user - supplied prior ranking @xmath8 ( @xmath11 is an all-1 vector , @xmath12 is the outer product , and @xmath13 is a balancing factor ) . the first ranking state @xmath14 is found by taking the state with the largest stationary probability ( @xmath15 is the stationary distribution of @xmath16 ) . each time a state is extracted ,
it is converted into an absorbing state to penalize states similar to it . the rest of the states are iteratively selected according to the expected number of visits to each state , instead of considering the stationary probability .
if @xmath17 is the set of items ranked so far , states are turned into absorbing states by setting @xmath18 and @xmath19 , @xmath20 .
if items are arranged so that ranked ones are listed before unranked ones , @xmath16 can be written as follows : @xmath21 @xmath22 is the identity matrix on @xmath17 .
@xmath23 and @xmath24 are rows of unranked items .
@xmath25 is the expected number of visits to state @xmath7 starting from state @xmath6 ( @xmath26 ) .
the expected number of visits to state @xmath7 , @xmath27 , is given by @xmath28 and the next item is @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the size of @xmath17 .
lexrank @xcite relies on the similarity ( e.g. cosine ) between sentence pairs ( usually , _
tf - idf _ vectors ) .
first , all sentences are compared to each other . then , a graph is built where each sentence is a vertex and edges are created between every sentence according to their pairwise similarity ( above a threshold ) .
lexrank can be used with both weighted ( eq . [ eq : lex - rank - w ] ) and unweighted ( eq . [ eq : lex - rank - u ] ) edges .
then , each vertex score is iteratively computed . in eq .
[ eq : lex - rank - w ] through [ eq : lex - rank - u ] , @xmath31 is a damping factor to guarantee convergence ; @xmath32 is the number of vertices ; @xmath33 is the score of vertex @xmath6 ; and @xmath34 is the degree of @xmath6 .
summaries are built by taking the highest ranked sentences . in lexrank
, sentences recommend each other : sentences similar to many others will get high scores .
scores are also determined by the score of the recommending sentences .
@xmath35 @xmath36}\frac{\text{sim}\left(v_{i},v_{j}\right)}{\sum_{v_{k}\in adj\left[v_{j}\right]}\text{sim}\left(v_{j},v_{k}\right)}s\left(v_{j}\right)\ ] ] @xmath37}\frac{s\left(v_{j}\right)}{d\left(v_{j}\right)}\ ] ] [ [ sub : lsa ] ] was first applied in text summarization in @xcite .
is used to reduce the dimensionality of an original matrix representation of the text .
-based summarizers start by building a @xmath38 terms by @xmath32 sentences matrix @xmath39 .
each element of @xmath39 , @xmath40 , has a local ( @xmath41 ) and a global ( @xmath42 ) weight .
@xmath41 is a function of term frequency in a specific sentence and @xmath42 is a function of the number of sentences that contain a specific term .
usually , @xmath43 are _ tf - idf _ scores .
the result of applying the to @xmath39 is @xmath44 , where @xmath45 ( @xmath46 matrix ) are the left singular vectors ; @xmath47 ( @xmath48 diagonal matrix ) contains the singular values in descending order ; and @xmath49 ( @xmath48 matrix ) are the right singular vectors .
singular values determine topic relevance : each latent dimension corresponds to a topic .
the rank-@xmath0 approximation considers the first @xmath0 columns of @xmath45 , the @xmath50 sub - matrix of @xmath47 , and the first @xmath0 rows of @xmath49 .
relevant sentences are the ones corresponding to the indices of the highest values for each right singular vector .
this approach has two limitations @xcite : by selecting @xmath0 sentences for the summary , less significant sentences tend to be extracted when @xmath0 increases ; and , sentences with high values in several topics , but never the highest , will never be included in the summary . to account for these effects , a sentence score was introduced and @xmath0 is chosen so that the @xmath51 singular value does not fall under half of the highest singular value : @xmath52 .
[ [ sub : mmr ] ] sentence selection in @xcite is done according to their relevance and diversity against previously selected sentences , in order to output low - redundancy summaries .
is a query - based method that has been used in speech summarization @xcite .
it is also possible to produce generic summaries by taking the centroid vector of all the sentences as the query .
uses @xmath53 to select sentences . @xmath54 and @xmath55 are similarity metrics ( e.g. cosine ) ; @xmath56 and @xmath57 are unselected and previously selected sentences , respectively ; @xmath24 is the query , and @xmath13 balances relevance and diversity .
sentences can be represented as _ tf - idf _ vectors .
this method was first applied in text and speech summarization @xcite .
centrality is based on sets of sentences that are similar to a given sentence ( support sets ) : @xmath58 .
support sets are estimated for every sentence .
sentences frequent in most support sets are selected : @xmath59 .
this is similar to unweighted lexrank ( section [ sub : lexrank ] ) , except that support sets allow a different threshold for each sentence ( @xmath60 ) and their underlying representation is directed , i.e. , each sentence only recommends its most semantically related sentences . the thresholds can be heuristically determined .
@xcite , among others , uses a passage order heuristic which clusters all passages into two clusters , according to their distance to each cluster s centroid .
the first and second clusters are initialized with the first and second passages , respectively , and sentences are assigned to clusters , one by one , according to their original order .
the cluster that contains the most similar passage to the passage associated with the support set under construction is selected as the support set .
several metrics were tested for defining semantic relatedness ( e.g. minkowski distance , cosine ) .
we evaluated generic summarization by assessing its impact on binary and multiclass music genre classification .
these tasks consist of classifying songs based on a scheme ( e.g. artist , genre , or mood ) .
classification is deemed important by the community and annual conferences addressing it are held , such as , which comprises @xcite for comparing state - of - the - art algorithms in a standardized setting .
the best 2015 system @xcite for the `` audio mixed popular genre classification '' task uses for classifying music genre , based on spectral features .
we follow the same approach and our classification is also performed using @xcite .
note that there are two different feature extraction steps .
the first is done by the summarizers , every time a song is summarized . the summarizers output audio signal corresponding to the selected parts , to be used in the second step , i.e. , when doing classification , where features are extracted from the full , segmented , and summarized datasets .
the features used by the consist of a 38-dimensional vector per song , a concatenation of several statistics on features used in @xcite , describing the timbral texture of a music piece .
it consists of the average of the first 20 concatenated with statistics ( mean and variance ) of 9 spectral features : centroid , spread , skewness , kurtosis , flux , rolloff , brightness , entropy , and flatness .
these are computed over feature vectors extracted from 50ms frames without overlap .
this set of features and a smaller set , solely composed of averages , were tested in the classification task .
all music genres in our dataset are timbrically different from each other , making these sets good descriptors for classification .
our experimental datasets consist of a total of 1250 songs from 5 different genres : bass , fado , hip hop , trance , and indie rock .
bass music is a generic term referring to several specific styles of electronic music , such as dubstep , drum and bass , electro , and more .
although these differ in tempo , they share similar timbral characteristics , such as deep basslines and the `` wobble '' bass effect .
fado is a portuguese music genre whose instrumentation consists of stringed instruments , such as the classical and the portuguese guitars .
hip hop consists of drum rhythms ( usually built with samples ) , the use of turntables and spoken lyrics .
indie rock usually consists of guitar , drums , keyboard , and vocal sounds and was influenced by punk , psychedelia , post - punk , and country .
trance is an electronic music genre characterized by repeating melodic phrases and a musical form that builds up and down throughout a track .
each class is represented by 250 songs from several artists .
the multiclass dataset contains all songs .
two binary datasets were also built from this data , in order to test our hypothesis on a wider range of classification setups : bass vs. fado and bass vs. trance , each containing the 500 corresponding songs .
10-fold cross - validation was used in all classification tasks .
first , as baselines , we performed 3 classification experiments using 30s segments , from the beginning , middle , and end of each song .
then , we obtained another baseline by using the whole songs .
the baselines were compared with the classification results from using 30s summaries for each parameter combination and algorithm .
we did this for both binary datasets and then for the multiclass dataset .
applying generic summarization algorithms to music requires additional steps .
since these algorithms operate on the discrete concepts of word and sentence , some preprocessing must be done to map the continuous frame representation obtained after feature extraction to a word / sentence representation . for each song
being summarized , a vocabulary is created , through clustering the frames feature vectors .
mlpack s @xcite implementation of the @xmath0-means algorithm was used for this step ( we experiment with some values for @xmath0 and assess their impact on the results ) . after clustering ,
a vocabulary of musical words is obtained ( each word is a frame cluster s centroid ) and each frame is assigned its own cluster centroid , effectively mapping the frame feature vectors to vocabulary words .
this transforms the real / continuous nature of each frame ( when represented by a feature vector ) to a discrete nature ( when represented as a word from a vocabulary ) .
then , the song is segmented into fixed - size sentences ( e.g. , 5-word sentences ) . since every sentence contains discrete words from a vocabulary , it is possible to represent each one as a vector of word occurrences / frequencies ( depending on the weighting scheme ) which is the exact representation used by generic summarization algorithms .
sentences were compared using the cosine distance .
the parameters of all of these algorithms include : features , framing , vocabulary size ( final number of clusters of the @xmath0-means algorithm ) , weighting ( e.g. , _ tf - idf _ ) , and sentence size ( number of words per sentence ) . for the multiclass dataset , we also ran experiments comparing human - oriented summarization against generic summarization .
this translates into comparing average similarity summaries ( for several durations ) against 30-second generic summaries , as well as comparing structural against fixed - size sentences .
we also compared the performance of generic summaries against the baselines for smaller summary durations .
every algorithm was implemented in c++ .
we used : opensmile @xcite for feature extraction , armadillo @xcite for matrix operations , marsyas @xcite for synthesizing the summaries , and the segmenter used in @xcite for structural segmentation .
our experiments covered the following parameter values ( varying between algorithms ) : frame and hop size combinations of ( 0.25,0.125 ) , ( 0.25,0.25 ) , ( 0.5,0.25 ) , ( 0.5,0.5 ) , ( 1,0.5 ) and ( 1,1 ) ( in seconds ) ; vocabulary sizes of 25 , 50 , and 100 ( words ) ; sentence sizes of 5 , 10 , and 20 ( words ) ; `` dampened '' _ tf - idf _ ( takes logarithm of _ tf _ instead of _
tf _ itself ) and binary weighting schemes . as summarization features , we used vectors of sizes 12 , 20 , and 24 .
these features , used in several previous research efforts on music summarization in @xcite , describe the timbre of an acoustic signal .
we also used a concatenation of vectors with the 9 spectral features enumerated in section [ sub : features ] . for
, we tried @xmath13 values of 0.5 and 0.7 .
our implementation also makes use of the sentence score and the topics cardinality selection heuristic described in section [ sub : lsa ] .
first , we analyze results on the binary datasets , bass vs. fado and bass vs. trance . the reason we chose these pairs was because we wanted to see summarization s impact on an easy to classify dataset ( bass and fado are timbrically very different ) and a more difficult one ( bass and trance share many timbrical similarities due to their electronic and dancefloor - oriented nature ) .
for all experiments , classifying using the 38-dimensional features vector produced better results than using only 20 , so we only present those results here .
the best results are summarized in tables [ tab : binary - baselines ] , [ tab : bass - fado ] , and [ tab : bass - trance ] .
.bass vs. trance summaries [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : avg - sim ] we can see that this type of summarization reaches the performance of generic summaries ( 30 seconds ) and full songs when the summary duration reaches 80 seconds ( 89.2% accuracy ) .
this means that , for a human - oriented summary to be as descriptive and discriminative as a generic summary , an additional 50 seconds ( 2.67 times the length of the original ) are needed .
even though the starting point of this contiguous summary is carefully selected by this algorithm , it still lacks diversity because of its contiguous nature , hindering classification accuracy for this summarizer .
naturally , by extending summary duration , summaries include more diverse information , eventually achieving the accuracy of full songs .
another form of human - oriented summarization is achieved by using generic summarization operating on structurally segmented sentences , done according to what humans might consider to be structurally meaningful segments .
after structural segmentation , we fed each of the 5 generic algorithms with the resulting sentences instead of fixed - size ones and truncated the summary at 30 seconds , when necessary .
the parameterization used for these experiments was the one that yielded the best results in the previous experiments for each algorithm .
the accuracy results for , lexrank , , , and support sets were , respectively , 82.64% , 83.76% , 81.84% , 82.40% , and 83.84% . even though structurally segmented sentences slightly improve performance , when considering classification accuracy , they are still outperformed by fixed - size segmentation .
the best algorithm can only achieve 83.84% accuracy .
this is because these sentences are much longer , therefore harming diversity in summaries .
furthermore , important content in structural sentences can always be extracted when using smaller fixed - size sentences .
thus , using smaller sentences , prevents the selection of redundant content .
we ran the wilcoxon signed - ranked test on all of the confusion matrices presented above against the full songs scenario .
the continuous sections p - values were @xmath61 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 for the 30-second beginning , middle , and end sections of the songs , respectively , which means that they differ markedly from using full songs ( as can also be seen by the accuracy drops they cause ) .
the summaries , however , were very close to full songs , in terms of accuracy .
the p - values for , lexrank , , , and support sets were @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 , respectively .
thus , statistically speaking , using any of these 30-second summaries does not significantly differ from using full songs for classification ( considering 95% confidence intervals ) .
furthermore , the p - values for 20-second summaries and for 10-second support sets summaries were @xmath69 and @xmath70 , respectively , with the remaining p - values of increasing summary sizes also being superior to @xmath71 .
thus , statistically speaking , generic summarization ( in some cases ) does not significantly differ from using full songs for classification , for summaries as short as 10 seconds ( considering a 95% confidence interval ) .
this is noteworthy , considering that the average song duration in this dataset is 283 seconds , which means that we achieve similar levels of classification performance using around 3.5% of the data .
human - oriented summarization is able to achieve these performance levels , but only at 50-second summaries and with a p - value of @xmath72 , barely over the @xmath71 threshold .
however , the 60-second summaries produced by this algorithm can not reach that threshold . only at 80 seconds
is a comfortable p - value ( @xmath73 ) for the 95% confidence interval attained .
although every algorithm creates summaries in a different way , they all tend to include relevant and diverse sentences .
this compensates their reduced lengths ( up to 30 seconds of audio ) allowing those clips to be representative of the whole musical pieces , from an automatic consumption view , as demonstrated by our experiments .
moreover , choosing the best 30-second contiguous segments is highly dependent on the genres in the dataset and tasks it will be used for , which is another reason for preferring summaries over those segments .
the more varied the dataset , the less likely a fixed continuous section extraction method is to produce representative enough clips .
bass and trance were the most influenced genres , by summarization , in these experiments .
these are styles with very well defined structural borders , and a very descriptive structural element the _ drop_. the lack of that same element in a segment markedly hinders classification performance , suggesting that any genre with similar characteristics may also benefit from this type of summarization .
it is also worth restating that hip hop and indie rock were very positively influenced by summarization , regarding classification performance improvements over using full songs .
this shows that , sometimes , classification on summarized music can even outperform using the whole data from the original signal .
we also demonstrated that generic summarization using fixed - size sentences , that is , summarization not specifically oriented towards human consumption greatly outperforms human - oriented summarization approaches for the classification task .
summarizing music prior to the classification task also takes time , but we do not claim it is worth doing it every time we are about do perform a task .
the idea is to compute summarized datasets offline for future use in any task that can benefit from them ( e.g. , music classification ) .
currently , sharing music datasets for research purposes is very limited in many aspects , due to copyright issues .
usually , datasets are shared through features extracted from ( 30-second ) continuous clips .
that practice has drawbacks , such as : those 30 seconds may not contain the most relevant information and may even be highly redundant ; and the features provided may not be the ones a researcher needs for his / her experiments . summarizing datasets
this way also helps avoiding copyright issues ( because summaries are not created in a way enjoyable by humans ) and still provide researchers with the most descriptive parts ( according to each summarizer ) of the signal itself , so that many different kinds of features can be extracted from them .
we showed that generic summarization algorithms perform well when summarizing music datasets about to be classified .
the resulting summaries are remarkably more descriptive of the whole songs than their continuous segments ( of the same duration ) counterparts .
sometimes , these summaries are even more discriminative than the full songs .
we also presented an argument stating some advantages in sharing summarized datasets within the community .
an interesting research direction would be to automatically determine the best vocabulary size for each song .
testing summarization s performance on different classification tasks ( e.g. , with more classes ) is also necessary to further strengthen our conclusions .
more comparisons with non - contiguous human - oriented summaries should also be done .
more experimenting should be done in other tasks that also make use of only a portion of the whole signal .
m. cooper and j. foote , `` summarizing popular music via structural similarity analysis , '' in _ proc . of the ieee workshop on applications of signal processing to audio and acoustics _ ,
2003 , pp . 127130 .
j. carbonell and j. goldstein , `` the use of mmr , diversity - based reranking for reordering documents and producing summaries , '' in _ proc . of the 21st annual intl .
acm sigir conf . on research and development in information retrieval _ , 1998 , pp .
335336 .
t. k. landauer and s. t. dutnais , `` a solution to plato s problem : the latent semantic analysis theory of acquisition , induction , and representation of knowledge , '' _ psychological review _ , vol .
104 , no . 2 ,
pp . 211240 , 1997 .
x. zhu , a. b. goldberg , j. v. gael , and d. andrzejewski , `` improving diversity in ranking using absorbing random walks , '' in _ proc . of the 5th north american chapter of the association for computational linguistics - human language technologies conf .
_ , 2007 , pp . 97104 .
y. vaizman , b. mcfee , and g. lanckriet , `` codebook - based audio feature representation for music information retrieval , '' _ ieee / acm trans . on audio , speech and language processing _ ,
22 , pp . 14831493 , 2014 .
y. gong and x. liu , `` generic text summarization using relevance measure and latent semantic analysis , '' in _ proc . of the 24th annual intl .
acm sigir conf . on research and development in information retrieval _ , 2001 , pp .
1925 .
k. zechner and a. waibel , `` minimizing word error rate in textual summaries of spoken language , '' in _ proc . of the 1st north american chapter of the association for computational linguistics
_ , 2000 , pp
. 186193 .
wu and j .- s .
r. jang , `` combining acoustic and multilevel visual features for music genre classification , '' _ acm trans . on multimedia computing , communications and applications _
12 , no . 1 ,
pp . 10:110:17 , 2015 .
r. r. curtin , j. r. cline , n. p. slagle , w. b. march , p. ram , n. a. mehta , and a. g. gray , `` mlpack : a scalable c++ machine learning library , '' _ journal of machine learning research _ , vol .
14 , no . 1 ,
pp . 801805 , 2013 .
f. eyben , f. weninger , f. gross , and b. schuller , `` recent developments in opensmile , the munich open - source multimedia feature extractor , '' in _ proc . of the 21st acm intl .
conf . on multimedia _ , 2013 , pp .
835838 .
francisco raposo graduated in information systems and computer engineering ( 2012 ) from instituto superior tcnico ( ist ) , lisbon .
he received a masters degree in information systems and computer engineering ( 2014 ) ( ist ) , on automatic music summarization .
he s currently pursuing a phd course on information systems and computer engineering .
his research interests focus on music information retrieval ( mir ) , music emotion recognition , and creative - mir applications .
ricardo ribeiro has a phd ( 2011 ) in information systems and computer engineering and an msc ( 2003 ) in electrical and computer engineering , both from instituto superior tcnico , and a graduation degree ( 1996 ) in mathematics / computer science from universidade da beira interior .
his current research interests focus on high - level information extraction from unrestricted text or speech , and improving machine - learning techniques using domain - related information .
david martins de matos graduated in electrical and computer engineering ( 1990 ) from instituto superior tcnico ( ist ) , lisbon .
he received a masters degree in electrical and computer engineering ( 1995 ) ( ist ) .
he received a doctor of engineering degree in systems and computer science ( 2005 ) ( ist ) .
his current research interests focus on computational music processing , automatic summarization and natural language generation , human - robot interaction , and natural language semantics . | in order to satisfy processing time constraints , many tasks process only a segment of the whole music signal .
this may lead to decreasing performance , as the most important information for the tasks may not be in the processed segments .
we leverage generic summarization algorithms , previously applied to text and speech , to summarize items in music datasets .
these algorithms build summaries ( both concise and diverse ) , by selecting appropriate segments from the input signal , also making them good candidates to summarize music .
we evaluate the summarization process on binary and multiclass music genre classification tasks , by comparing the accuracy when using summarized datasets against the accuracy when using human - oriented summaries , continuous segments ( the traditional method used for addressing the previously mentioned time constraints ) , and full songs of the original dataset .
we show that , lexrank , , , and a support sets - based centrality model improve classification performance when compared to selected baselines . we also show that summarized datasets lead to a classification performance
whose difference is not statistically significant from using full songs .
furthermore , we make an argument stating the advantages of sharing summarized datasets for future research . |
a very interesting topic in medium energy nuclear physics is the electromagnetic production of mesons on light nuclei in order to study possible changes of the elementary reaction in a nuclear medium .
of particular interest is the reaction on the deuteron for the following reasons .
the first one is that the structure of the deuteron is well understood in comparison to heavier nuclei .
thus , the low binding energy of the deuteron allows to compare the contributions of its constituents to the electromagnetic and hadronic reactions to those from free nucleons in order to estimate off - shell effects .
secondly , the deuteron may be viewed as a neutron target in order to extract under quasifree conditions the elementary neutron amplitude with the tacit assumption that binding and final state interaction effects are small . to assess the validity of this method it is necessary to estimate the effects of mechanisms beyond this approximation quantitatively .
first investigations on pion photoproduction on the deuteron go back to the early fifties , e.g. @xcite and @xcite , with view on the general structure of spin flip and no spin flip amplitudes . later , a more systematic calculation was done by laget @xcite and blomqvist and laget @xcite . in this work the influence of pion rescattering effects and nn final state interaction is approximatly included within a diagrammatic ansatz .
however , they used different @xmath1-parametrizations for neutral and charged pion production .
the aim of the present paper is to study pion photoproduction on the deuteron within the spectator nucleon model using a unified elementary production operator .
we have taken the full on - shell amplitude of the elementary process but have neglected all kind of final state interactions and furthermore two - body operators . in view of the extraction of neutron data from experiments on the deuteron
we put our emphasis on the special kinematical situation corresponding to the quasifree pion production on one nucleon .
however , this kinematical condition does not necessarily imply that the pion has been produced on the active nucleon and not on the spectator .
therefore , we have also studied for this kinematical situation the influence of the second nucleon on the differential cross section due to the antisymmetrization of the final nn state . in sect .
[ kap2 ] , the elementary process of pion photoproduction on the nucleon is briefly reviewed .
the nonresonant amplitudes and the contribution of the @xmath1 resonance are given .
the model for the process on the deuteron is outlined in sect .
finally we present and discuss our results in sect .
we will briefly review pion photoproduction on the nucleon @xmath4 because we need the elementary production amplitude for its implementation into two - nucleon space . in this section
we will first consider the elementary process in the center of mass frame @xmath5 and generalize later to an arbitrary frame for the calculations on the deuteron .
the amplitude contains besides nonresonant terms a resonance contribution from the @xmath1(1232 ) excitation which is described in the framework of an isobar model including its @xmath2 and @xmath3 channel contributions . for the @xmath1n@xmath0-vertex we use @xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are spin and isospin transition operators , respectively .
we have introduced a hadronic monopole form factor @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the c.m .
pion momentum on the top of the resonance , i.e. , when the invariant mass @xmath11 of the @xmath0n state equals the mass of the @xmath1 resonance @xmath12 for the coupling constant , the cutoff and the @xmath1 mass we have used @xmath13 in the description of the @xmath14 vertex we follow @xcite .
the nonrelativistic limit of the n@xmath1 current matrix element contains contributions of the magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole .
since the strength of the electric quadrupole excitation is much smaller than the magnetic dipole one ( see e.g. @xcite ) we will neglect it here
. then the @xmath14 vertex has the form @xmath15 here @xmath16 is the photon polarization vector .
the energy dependent and complex coupling @xmath17 is taken from @xcite . using the nonrelativistic form of the @xmath1 propagator
, one finally gets for the resonance part of the production operator @xmath18 } { 3 } \hspace{.1 cm } \frac{\vec{\sigma}_{n\delta}\!\cdot\ !
\vec{q}\ , \vec{\sigma}_{\delta n}\!\cdot\ !
\vec{k}\times\vec{\epsilon}}{w_{\pi n}-m_{\delta } + \frac{i}{2 } \gamma_{\delta}(w_{\pi n } ) } \\ & & + \frac{f_{\delta}\left(0\right)}{m_{\pi } } \hspace{.1 cm } \frac{e f_{\delta n\pi } g^{m1}_{\delta n}(0 ) } { 2\sqrt{e_{p}e_{p^{\prime } } } } \hspace{0.1 cm } \frac{\{\tau_{\mu}^{\dagger},\tau_{0}\}+ \frac{1}{2}[\tau_{\mu}^{\dagger},\tau_{0}]}{3 } \hspace{.1 cm } \frac { \vec{\sigma}_{\delta n}\!\cdot\ ! \vec{k}\times\vec{\epsilon}\ , \vec{\sigma}_{n\delta}\!\cdot\ !
\vec{q}}{e_{\vec{p}^{\ , \prime } } - \omega_{\gamma } - e^{\delta}_{\vec{p}^{\ , \prime}-\vec{k } } } \ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath19 is the energy dependent width of the @xmath1 resonance above pion threshold @xmath20 in the @xmath3 channel contribution given by the second term in ( [ res ] ) , we take the values of the form factor @xmath21 , the electromagnetic coupling @xmath22 and the width of the resonance @xmath19 at pion threshold . for the nonresonant background we used the born termes in pseudovector @xmath0n coupling with the coupling constant @xmath23 from @xcite . in order to obtain a better description of the leading multipoles ( @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 ) it was necassary to introduce a form factor @xmath27 with the cutoff @xmath28 mev .
the parameters of the @xmath1 resonance are fixed on the @xmath26 multipole . due to the use of a constant @xmath1 mass in the @xmath1 propagator and a different cutoff @xmath29 we had to increase @xmath17 from @xcite by a factor of @xmath30 to fit the experimental multipole . as shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] the agreement of our results with the data from @xcite is very good for both the real and imaginary part of the @xmath26 multipole up to a photon energy of about 400 mev .
we would like to note that for a better description of the real part of the @xmath26 multipole the suppression of the nonresonant background by the form factor was essential .
the inclusion of the @xmath3 channel of the @xmath1 resonance improved the description of the @xmath31 multipole . in fig .
[ fig2 ] the results for the other leading multipoles in the three isospin channels are also shown .
the description of these multipoles is in general quite satisfactory . due to the neglect of the @xmath32 excitation of the @xmath1 resonance
we fail to describe the behaviour of the @xmath33 multipole .
furthermore the imaginary part of all multipoles apart from the @xmath26 vanishes in our model because we have not included other resonances . in the upper part of fig .
[ fig3 ] we show the total cross sections for pion photoproduction on the nucleon compared to experimental data .
in contrast to @xcite we used in our calculation the same parametrization of the @xmath1 resonance both for neutral and charged pion photoproduction .
the price we have to pay in order to achieve a good description of all physical channels is the introduction of the above mentioned form factor into the nonresonant background amplitude .
the agreement with the experimental data is good up to an invariant mass of about 1300 mev ( @xmath34mev ) in the case of @xmath35 production .
the @xmath36 data are slightly overestimated in the resonance region by our calculation .
it is reasonable to expect that the dominant process will be the quasifree reaction on one nucleon while the other acts merely as a spectator remaining at rest in the laboratory system so that the final state interaction between the nucleons and pion rescattering on the spectator nucleon may safely be neglected . in this spectator nucleon ansatz
we will use the elementary amplitude discussed in sect .
[ kap2 ] . due to the fermi motion in the initial state
we have to use this amplitude in a form which is not restricted to a special frame of reference . for the nonresonant background
this is achieved by evaluation of the corresponding feynman diagrams in an arbitrary frame .
this leads to the following expression for the nonresonant production operator @xmath37 \ , [ \,\hat{e},\tau_{\mu}^{+}\ , ] \nonumber \\ & & -\frac{\tau_{\mu}^{+}\vec{\sigma}\!\cdot\!\vec{q}\left ( 2\left ( \vec{p}^{\ , \prime}+\vec{q}\right)\!\cdot\!\vec{\epsilon } \,\hat{e}+i\vec{\sigma } \!\cdot\!\vec{k}\times\vec{\epsilon}\left(\hat{e}+\hat{\kappa}\right)\right ) } { 2e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}+\vec{q}}\left(\omega_{\vec{q } } + e_{\vec{p}^{\ , \prime}}-e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}+\vec{q } } \right ) } -\frac{\left(2\vec{p}^{\,\prime}\!\cdot\!\vec{\epsilon}\,\hat{e } + i\vec{\sigma}\!\cdot\!\vec{k}\times\vec{\epsilon } \left(\hat{e}+\hat{\kappa}\right)\right)\tau_{\mu}^{+ } \vec{\sigma}\!\cdot\!\vec{q } } { 2e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}-\vec{k } } \left(e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}}-e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}-\vec{k}}-\omega_{\gamma } \right ) } \nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ m_{n } \omega_{\vec{q } } \vec{\sigma}\!\cdot\!\vec{\epsilon } \left ( \frac{\tau_{\mu}^{+}\hat{e}}{e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}+\vec{q}}\left ( e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}+\vec{q}}+e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}}+\omega_{\vec{q } } \right ) } + \frac{\hat{e}\tau_{\mu}^{+}}{e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}-\vec{k}}\left ( e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}-\vec{k}}+e_{\vec{p}^{\,\prime}}-\omega_{\gamma } \right ) } \right ) \right\}\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath38 and @xmath39 denote nucleon charge and anomalous magnetic momentum . in the resonance amplitude @xmath40 in ( [ res ] ) , the photon and pion momenta have to be replaced by the relative photon - nucleon momentum @xmath41 and respective pion - nucleon momentum @xmath42 in the expressions of the form factors , the coupling @xmath17 and the width of the @xmath1 resonance we use the c.m .
pion momentum as given by the invariant mass of the @xmath0n subsystem @xmath43 with @xmath44 we use as pion photoproduction operator in the two - nucleon system @xmath45 since the final state interaction is neglected we take plane waves for the pion and the nn - final states . for the spin @xmath46 and isospin @xmath47 part of the two nucleon wave functions we use a coupled basis .
the complete antisymmetric final nn wave functions is @xmath48 only the @xmath49 channel contributes in the case of charged pions whereas for @xmath50 production both @xmath51 and @xmath49 channels have to be taken into account .
now one easily writes down the matrix element for pion photoproduction on the deuteron @xmath52 with @xmath53 from ( [ g17 ] ) , where we have used the covariant normalization @xmath54 and the deuteron wave function in the form @xmath55 with @xmath56 in the laboratory frame ( deuteron rest frame ) one finds for the matrix element the following expression @xmath57 note that in ( [ g16 ] ) all spin and isospin operators act on nucleon `` 1 '' .
the differential cross section is then given by @xmath58 ) and performing the spin summation in ( [ g18 ] ) explicitly , we formally reproduce the expression for the differential cross section given in @xcite for an uncoupled spin basis .
now we will present our results on pion photoproduction on the deuteron using the deuteron wave function of the bonn potential ( full model ) @xcite .
the discussion is diveded into two parts . in the first we compare with experimental data of the total cross section @xmath59 and the semi - exclusive differential cross section @xmath60 as a test of our model .
it is obtained from the fully exclusive cross section @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the total momentum of the two nucleons in the final state . in order to include symmetrically the contributions of both nucleons in the numerical integration
, we have chosen @xmath63 to be an independent quantity . in the second part
, we have studied the influence of pauli correlations in the final state on the differential cross section in a special kinematical situation which allows a direct comparison to the free nucleon process .
we will concentrate our discussion on @xmath36 photoproduction , since no data for @xmath35 and @xmath50 production in the @xmath1 region are available . in the lower part of fig .
[ fig3 ] we show the total cross sections for pion photoproduction on the deuteron which can be compared to the free nucleon case in the upper part . in the case of @xmath36 production on the neutron
we compare our results with data from the inverse reaction @xmath64 @xcite and with data extracted from experiments on the deuteron @xcite .
for the pion production operator of sect .
[ kap2 ] we find an overestimation of the total cross section in the resonance peak for @xmath36 production both on the neutron and on the deuteron .
for this reason we have calculated the cross sections using a nonresonant background for a lower @xmath0n coupling constant @xmath65 . in this case
the description of the experimental data in the resonance peak is good .
however , for photon energies below the resonance up to about 280 mev the theoretical results underestimate the data significantly . the differential cross sections @xmath60 are shown in fig . [ fig7 ] . the use of the pion production operator of sect .
[ kap2 ] leads to an overestimation of the data for energies above 300 mev .
however , the shape of the curves is in good agreement with the experiment . using the lower @xmath0n coupling @xmath65 we found a good description of the data for photon energies above 300 mev .
now we will discuss the effect of the pauli correlations , i.e. , antisymmetrization of the final nn state for quasifree kinematics . in order to compare with pion photoproduction on the nucleon we did the calculation in the rest frame of the quasifree @xmath0n subsystem ( see fig .
[ fig10]a ) so that its contribution to the t - matrix will be the same as that of a free nucleon in the center of mass frame apart from some minor approximations which are discussed in appendix [ app3 ] . for the genuine quasifree case in fig .
[ fig10]a the relative momentum of the two nucleons in the initial state vanishes while for the spectator contribution in fig .
[ fig10]b , i.e. , reaction on the spectator , the relative momentum is @xmath66 . in particular for pion production at backward angles ,
the contribution of the spectator nucleon will be largely suppressed by the deuteron wave function because of the large momentum mismatch , but this will not work for small pion emission angles . in appendix [ app3 ]
we show that the neglect of the contribution of the nucleon with momentum @xmath67 in the final state leads to a very simple relation between the differential cross sections of the quasifree and the elementary processes , namely @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the momentum space wave function of the s - wave at zero momentum and @xmath70 is the total momentum of the @xmath0n system .
the results for the ratio of these cross sections are shown in fig .
[ fig11 ] . for backward pion emission the relation ( [ g19 ] ) is verified within about @xmath71 justifying the neglect of the second nucleon for larger pion angles .
however , for forward pion emission this is not any more the case .
here one finds a decrease of the cross section up to about @xmath72 for small pion angles due to pauli correlations .
this means that even for quasifree kinematics one will get a modification of the observables for certain kinematics which is not negligible . in our opinion
, this is a very important point for the extraction of neutron data from experiments on the deuteron .
we have investigated pion photoproduction on the deuteron in the @xmath73 resonance region in the spectator nucleon model neglecting final state interactions and two body processes . within this framework ,
the t - matrix is given as a linear combination of the on - shell matrix elements of pion photoproduction on the two nucleons .
the elementary amplitude is fitted to the pion photo production multipoles .
we have presented results for total and differential cross sections .
a comparison with experimental data has been possible only for @xmath36 production , where we found a slight overestimation of the data which largely go back to an overestimation of the elementary reaction on the neutron .
particular attention was paid to the quasifree case for which we have studied the effect of the antisymmetrisation of the nn - final state .
even for quasifree kinematics where the process is dominated by the reaction on one of the nucleons , we found an effect of about @xmath74 in the differential cross section due to presence of the second nucleon .
the differences between the theoretical results and the experimental data show very clearly that the calculation of pion photoproduction on nuclei in the nucleon spectator model can only be considered as a first step towards a more realistic description of this process .
the studies discussed here will serve as the basis for further investigations including the dynamics of the @xmath0nn system in a more satisfactory way .
here we will give a brief derivation of equation ( [ g19 ] ) and a discussion of the approximations used .
the general expression for the exclusive differential cross section is given in ( [ g18 ] ) .
evaluating the @xmath75-functions with respect to the independent kinematical quantities @xmath70 and @xmath76 , one finds in the frame of reference defined in fig . [ fig10 ]
@xmath77 taking into account only the contribution of the nucleon with momentum @xmath78 in the final state the corresponding t - matrix @xmath79 is given by @xmath80 performing the spin summation in ( [ c1 ] ) explicitly one finds @xmath81 where @xmath82 and @xmath83 are the spin projections of the nucleon in the initial and final states , respectively . due to the small binding energy of the deuteron
we can use the approximation @xmath84 in the c.m .
frame , the invariant mass of the @xmath0n system is given by @xmath85 from ( [ c1 ] ) with the help of ( [ c3 ] ) it is now easy to verify equation ( [ g19 ] ) @xmath86 here a second approximation is used implicitly because we compare the elementary and the quasifree process for a given invariant mass of the @xmath0n system . due to the binding of the nucleons in the deuteron
there is a small difference in the corresponding photon energies @xmath87 and @xmath88 . expanding the ratio of the photon energies for a given @xmath11 with respect to the relative binding energy @xmath89 yields @xmath90
the coefficient of the linear term is about @xmath91 at pion threshold and decreases with increasing @xmath11 .
thus this approximation is very well justified .
references chew , g. f. , lewis , h. w. : phys . rev .
* 84 * , 779 ( 1951 ) lax , m. , feshbach , h. : phys
. rev . *
88 * , 509 ( 1952 ) laget , j
: nucl . phys . *
a296 * , 388 ( 1977 ) laget , j .-
: phys . rep .
* 69 * , 1 ( 1981 ) blomqvist , i. , laget , j. m. : nucl . phys . * a280 * , 405 ( 1977 ) wilhelm , p. , arenhvel , h. : nucl
. phys . *
a593 * , 435 ( 1995 ) weber , h. j. , arenhvel , h. : phys .
* 36 * , 278 ( 1978 ) davidson , r. m. , mukhopadhyay , n. c. , wittman , r. s. : phys
* d43 * , 71 ( 1991 ) scattering analysis interactive dial - in ( said ) , virginia polytechnic institute , blacksburg , virginia arndt , r. a. , zhujun li , roper , l. d. , workman , r. l. : phys .
lett . * 65 * , 157 ( 1990 ) machleidt , r. , holinde , k. , elster , c. : phys . rep . *
149 * , 1 ( 1987 ) comiso , j. c. , blasberg , d. j. , haddock , r. p. , nefkens , b. m. k. , truoel , p. , verhey , l. j. : phys
. rev . * d12 * , 719 ( 1975 ) salomon , m. , measday , d. f. , poutissou , j
: nucl . phys . *
b414 * , 493 ( 1984 ) von holtey , g. , knopp , g. , stein , h. , stmpfig , j. , wahlen , h. : nucl .
* b70 * , 379 ( 1974 ) fujii , t. , kondo , t. , takasaki , f. , yamada , s. , homma , s. , huke , k. , kato , s. , okuno , h. , endo , i. , fujii , h. : nucl . phys . *
b120 * , 395 ( 1977 ) fischer , g. , von holtey , g. , knop , g. , stmpfig , j. : z. phys . * 253 * , 38 ( 1972 ) benz , p. , braun , o. , butenschn , h. , finger , h. , gall , d. , idschok , u. , kiesling , c. , knies , g. , kowalski , h. , mller , k. , nellen , b. , schiffer , r. , schlamp , p. , schnackers , h. j. , schulz , v. , sding , p. , spitzer , h. , stiewe , j. , f.storim , weigl , j. : nucl . phys . * b65 * , 158 ( 1973 ) chiefari , g. , drago , e. , napolitano , m. , sciacca , c. : lett .
nuovo cim .
* 13 * , 129 ( 1975 ) asai , m. , endo , i. , harada , m. , hasai , h. , ito , h. , iwatani , k. , kasai , s. , kato , s. , maki , t. , maruyama , k. , murata , y. , muto , m. , niki , k. , rangacharyulu , c. , shimizu , h. , sumi , y. , wada , y. , yoshida , k. : phys . rev .
* c42 * , 837 ( 1990 ) | photo production of pions on the deuteron is studied in the spectator nucleon model .
the born terms of the elementary production amplitude are determined in pseudovector @xmath0n coupling and supplied with a form factor .
the @xmath1 resonance is considered both in the @xmath2 and the @xmath3 channel .
the parameters of the @xmath1 resonance and the cutoff of the form factors are fixed on the leading photoproduction multipoles .
results for total and differential cross sections are compared with experimental data .
particular attention is paid to the role of pauli correlations of the final state nucleons in the quasifree case .
the results are compared with those for pion photoproduction on the nucleon .
mkph - t-96 - 3 + r. schmidt , h. arenhvel and p. wilhelm + institut fr kernphysik + johannes gutenberg universitt + d55099 mainz , germany + march 8 , 1996 + |
the interplay between transport currents and magnetization dynamics continues to be a major research topic in ferromagnetic metal spintronics.@xcite the current understanding of this class of phenomena has been derived mainly from numerous studies of spin - transfer torques ( stts ) , which arise when spin polarized currents traverse _ non - collinear _ magnetic systems .
stts can be exploited to achieve current - induced magnetization reversal and current - induced domain - wall motion , both of which have potentially important technological applications .
there have been comparatively few studies of the influence of transport currents on magnetization in _ uniform _ ferromagnets , presumably because spin transfer torques vanish in these systems . yet , as pointed out independently by several researchers@xcite , current - induced reorientation of magnetization does occur in some uniform ferromagnets .
the first experimental fingerprint of this phenomenon was uncovered by chernyshov _
et al._@xcite who demonstrated that an electric current alters magnetization reversal characteristics in strained ( ga , mn)as films with a single magnetic domain . stts can be considered to be one member of a family of current - induced torque ( cit ) effects by which transport currents influence magnetization in ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic@xcite systems .
the aim of this paper is to contribute to the theoretical analysis of current - induced torques in uniformly magnetized ferromagnets . in sec .
ii we study the effect responsible for this type of torque , which we refer to as the ferromagnetic inverse spin - galvanic effect.@xcite in non - magnetic conductors the inverse spin - galvanic effect ( isge ) refers to current - induced spin density .
since a non - zero spin - density already appears in the equilibrium state of a ferromagnet , the ferromagnetic inverse spin - galvanic effect has a distinct experimental signature .
specifically , we find that in gyrotropic ferromagnets the magnetization direction is altered by a steady - state transport current . at a conceptual level ,
we associate this reorientation with a change in magnetic anisotropy in the presence of a transport current .
an important implication of this connection is that the magnetic anisotropy energy in the transport steady state of a ferromagnet which exhibits the isge is _ not _ invariant under magnetization reversal , essentially because the applied current breaks time reversal invariance . at a practical level
, we provide a concise analytical expression for the current - induced change in the magnetic anisotropy .
this expression is suitable for evaluation from first principles because it requires the knowledge of only the band structure of the ferromagnet and the lifetime of the bloch states . at a technical level
, our theory allows for the spatial inhomogeneities that inevitably occur in the _ magnitude _ of the ferromagnet s exchange field at atomic lenghtscales . in sec .
iii we carry out quantitative calculations for the isge of strained ( ga , mn)as using a 4-band kohn - luttinger model .
this calculation directly addresses the experiment by chernyshov _
et al._@xcite and corroborates their interpretation of the data . by computing the anisotropy field both in absence and in presence of an electric current
, we find that in ( ga , mn)as magnetization reversal may in principle be achieved solely by electric means : the required critical current densities are in the order of @xmath0 and depend on the strain , mn concentration and hole density . sec .
iv contains a brief summary and presents our conclusions .
the main conclusions of our work coincide with those reached by manchon and zhang in their independent and previously published work described in ref .
yet , our analysis highlights aspects that have not been emphasized previously .
first , we assert that in ferromagnets with inversion symmetry , the current - induced spin - density vanishes _ to all orders _ in the strength of the spin - orbit interaction .
second , when evaluating the current - induced spin polarization we include a contribution from interband coherence which can become quantitatively important in disordered ferromagnets such as ( ga , mn)as .
third , we identify the current - induced transverse spin - density associated with the isge in ferromagnets as a consequence of a change in magnetic anisotropy in the presence of an electric current .
we thus promote transport currents to the same status as temperature@xcite , gate voltages@xcite , strain@xcite and chemical processes@xcite , all of which are well - established control parameters for the tuning of magnetic anisotropy .
in non - magnetic metals or semiconductors that are gyrotropic , _ i.e. _ non - centrosymmetric _ and _ chiral,@xcite a dc charge current is generically accompanied by a non - zero spin polarization.@xcite this phenomenon is sometimes referred to as the inverse spin galvanic effect ( isge).@xcite because of the advent of spintronics and subsequent attempts to control spin polarization by electric means , even in paramagnetic materials , the isge has received widespread experimental@xcite and theoretical@xcite attention . the isge is purely a consequence of symmetry since i ) current , which is odd under time reversal , is the dissipative response of a conductor to a dc electric - field , ii ) spin is also odd under time reversal and therefore allowed as part of the dissipative response , and iii ) axial vectors ( like spin ) and polar vectors ( like current ) are coupled in gyrotropic materials.@xcite the direction of the carriers spin is determined by the direction of the electric field as well as by the axis along which inversion symmetry is broken.@xcite the isge is sometimes viewed as a possible route toward the development of spintronics effects in paramagnetic materials that are as robust as effects like giant magnetoresistance that occur only in ferromagnetic materials .
partly because spin - orbit interactions tend to be fairly weak , it appears to be difficult to make spin - galvanic effects in normal metals useful . in this section
we turn the tables on this strategy by concentrating on the inverse spin - galvanic effect in _ magnetic _ conductors . in uniformly magnetized ferromagnets with inversion symmetry ,
the transport current is spin polarized because the conductivities of majority and minority spin channels are different .
this familiar fact is unrelated to the isge .
since spin - polarization is already present in the thermodynamic equilibrium state of a ferromagnet , the ferromagnetic isge is manifested not by the presence of a non - zero spin - density but instead by a change in magnetization direction in the non - equilibrium steady - state which is dependent on the magnitude and direction of the electric field . in this paper
we formulate a theory of the isge in ferromagnets by evaluating the torque which acts on the collective magnetization of a magnetic conductor due to spin - orbit interactions in the presence of a transport current .
when the current is set to zero , the torque we evaluate vanishes along easy ( and hard ) magnetization directions and is normally viewed@xcite as a precessional torque due to magnetocrystalline anisotropy fields .
these torques are in turn associated with the magnetization - direction dependence of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy energy . at zero current , the anisotropy torques must change sign when the magnetization direction is reversed because time reversal symmetry requires that the anisotropy energy be invariant under reversal . the ferromagnetic isge in gyrotropic crystals
may be viewed as a change in anisotropy torque due to a transport current .
significantly , the isge torques are _ not _ odd under magnetization reversal .
the ferromagnetic isge is reminiscent of the magnetoelectric phenomena that have been extensively studied in multiferroic materials,@xcite _ i.e. _ materials in which magnetism coexists with ferroelectricity .
a common characteristic of multiferroic perovskites is the presence of canted magnetism that stems from the dzyaloshinskii - moriya interaction . since the direction of canting is determined by the symmetry of the crystal , one can envisage@xcite scenarios in which an electric - field - mediated reversal of the ferroelectric polarization causes a simultaneous reversal of the canting angle or of the magnetization . another interesting property of multiferroic materials is the coupling between ferroelectricity and antiferromagnetism.@xcite this coupling makes it possible to switch the magnetization of an exchange - biased ferromagnet by the application of an electric field . in spite of the contextual similarities ,
there are fundamental differences between the aforementioned phenomena and the ferromagnetic isge .
for one thing , ferroelectricity occurs only in insulators while the isge occurs only in conductors .
we evaluate the ferromagnetic isge microscopically within the framework of linear response theory ( fig .
( [ fig : bubbles]a ) ) : @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the current - induced spin density ( @xmath3 ) , @xmath4 is the applied electric field , and @xmath5 the dissipative spin - current response function : @xmath6 this linear response theory expression applies for time - independent uniform applied electric fields , and may be derived in the standard way@xcite by analytically continuing the imaginary@xcite part of @xmath7 , where @xmath8 @xmath9 is the matsubara frequency at temperature @xmath10 and @xmath11 is the frequency of the external field . in eq .
( [ eq : chi ] ) @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the @xmath14-dependent matrix - elements of the spin and velocity operators ( @xmath15 ) between bloch states ( @xmath16 ) in bands @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
note that the bloch states are in general spinors in which orbital and spin degrees of freedom are entangled .
@xmath19 is the retarded ( advanced ) green s function evaluated at the fermi energy @xmath20 , and @xmath21 is the quasiparticle lifetime .
for simplicity we have ignored disorder vertex corrections to both velocity and spin operators . in the numerical calculations discussed in section iii
we will in addition take the quasiparticle lifetime to be a phenomenological parameter which is independent of momentum and band labels .
as we discuss below , the transverse components of the spin - density are directly related to the anisotropy field , which exerts a torque on the macrospin . on the same footing , the current - induced contribution to the transverse spin density
is directly related to the current - induced contribution to the anisotropy field . for a ferromagnet with inversion symmetry
@xmath22 irrespective of spin - orbit interaction strength , for essentially the same reasons as the isge vanishes in normal conductors with inversion symmetry.@xcite this property can be verified by recognizing that in presence of inversion symmetry the hamiltonian of the ferromagnet is invariant under @xmath23 , which implies that @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
consequently , the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq : chi ] ) vanishes after summing over all @xmath14 . from a crystal symmetry classification standpoint
there are 21 non - centrosymmetric crystal classes , among which three ( @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 ) are not gyrotropic .
the occurence of the isge is therefore restricted to 18 crystal classes.@xcite the main objective of this section is to relate the ferromagnetic isge to a current - induced change in the magnetic anisotropy field , yet before we do so it is beneficial to pave the way by reviewing the nuances of magnetic anisotropy in electric equilibrium . in the absence of currents ,
magnetic anisotropy describes the dependence of the free energy of a ferromagnet on the direction of its magnetization.@xcite magnetic anisotropy originates from@xcite magnetic dipolar interactions and spin - orbit interactions .
the former lead to shape anisotropy in non - spherical samples while the latter produce magnetocrystalline anisotropy by communicating the lack of rotational symmetry in the crystalline lattice to the spin degrees of freedom . in practice ,
magnetic anisotropy reveals itself in dynamical processes such as ferromagnetic resonance through an anisotropy field that forces the magnetization to precess unless it is along an easy or hard axis , _ i.e. _ along a direction in which the anisotropy energy is minimized or maximized .
this precessional magnetization dynamics is properly characterized by the landau - lifshitz equation , @xmath30 , where @xmath31 is the direction of the ferromagnet s collective dynamical variable ( which may be chosen to be either the magnetization or the ferromagnetic exchange field ) and @xmath32 is an effective magnetic field , taken here to include reactive as well as dissipative processes.@xcite the anisotropy field may then be defined as the contribution to the non - dissipative part of the effective magnetic field which survives in the absence of true magnetic fields : @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the ground state energy of the ferromagnet in equilibrium ( we take zero temperature throughout ) and @xmath35 is the total spin ( magnetization@xmath36 volume ) of the ferromagnet .
[ fig : cartoon ] when we discuss ( ga , mn)as in the following section , we will use spherical coordinates ( fig .
[ fig : cartoon ] ) in which the anisotropy field may be written as @xmath37 where @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the azimuthal and the polar unit vectors , respectively .
the longitudinal component of the anisotropy field is irrelevant because @xmath40 . in order to elaborate on the microscopic theory of the anisotropy field in a concrete way we work within the spin - density - functional theory of a magnetic material , in which the effective hamiltonian that describes the theory s kohn - sham quasiparticles can be expressed as @xmath41 in eq .
( [ eq : h_ks ] ) @xmath42 is the exchange effective - magnetic - field of the ferromagnet , @xmath31 is the direction of the exchange field , @xmath43 is the quasiparticle spin operator , @xmath44 captures spin - orbit interactions , and @xmath45 collects all spin - independent terms in the kohn - sham hamiltonian . in this work
we characterize the macrostate of a ferromagnet by specifying the direction of the exchange field .
@xmath31 is assumed to be uniform in space but the magnitude @xmath46 of the exchange field is allowed to have spatial dependence at the atomic lengthscale.@xcite we neglect dipolar interactions since they are not directly influenced by currents and can normally be cleanly separated from magnetocrystalline anisotropy .
it follows that the zero - temperature anisotropy field is given by @xmath47 in eq .
( [ eq : h_an_eq ] ) we have used@xcite @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is the energy of the bloch state quasiparticles and @xmath50 is the equilibrium occupation factor at zero temperature .
furthermore we have exploited the fact that @xmath51 since the number of electrons in the ferromagnet is invariant under rotations of the magnetization .
this implies a @xmath31-dependence of the fermi energy,@xcite which is taken into account in the calculations of sec .
( [ eq : h_an_eq ] ) may be rewritten in a more informative manner using the feynman - hellmann theorem , which implies that @xmath52 then , @xmath53 where @xmath54 .
for the envelope - function model we use in the next section , the magnitude of the exchange field is a spatially constant @xmath55 and the torque exerted by the anisotropy field is simply equal to the @xmath55 times the transverse spin - density divided by the total spin of the ferromagnet . in _
ab initio _ calculations , the magnitude of the exchange field always varies substantially on an atomic scale and , as we have emphasized previously,@xcite this variation must be accounted for . in this case
the anisotropy field is evaluated by integrating the product of the exchange field magnitude and transverse spin density over space .
( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) may be separated into azimuthal and polar components : @xmath56 if we neglect spatial variations of @xmath46 , eqs .
( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) and ( [ eq : h_pt ] ) indicate that the torque created by the anisotropy field will vanish when the ( spin ) magnetization @xmath57 is parallel to the exchange field .
conversely , whenever the direction of magnetization is misaligned with @xmath58 , the anisotropy field will be nonzero and will produce a torque on the magnetization . in transition metals spin - orbit interactions
produce a misalignment between the exchange field and the magnetization , unless @xmath31 is pointing along some special crystalline direction that corresponds ( by definition ) to an easy or hard axis .
a similar picture applies to local - moment ferromagnets as well , where due to spin - orbit coupling the direction of the local moments is generally misaligned with the direction of the itinerant spin density .
one of the targets of this section is to present formulae that are useful for researchers working on both model systems as well as _
ab - initio _ electronic structure calculations . therefore , we digress to explain that eq .
( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) is equivalent to the alternative expressions found in _ ab - initio _ studies . in first principles
magnetic anisotropy theory@xcite eq .
( [ eq : fh ] ) has been approached from a different perspective . in such approach
it is customary to choose the spin quantization axis along the direction of magnetization , so that @xmath59 is independent of @xmath31 .
when this choice is made , the spin - orbit term in the hamiltonian becomes explicitly @xmath31-dependent .
consequently , @xmath60 the anisotropy field is then evaluated combining eq .
( [ eq : so ] ) with the force theorem@xcite and a full - potential electronic - structure calculation.@xcite of course , the final result is invariant with respect to the choice of the spin quantization axis . in order to prove the equivalence of eqs .
( [ eq : fh ] ) and ( [ eq : so ] ) it is convenient to rewrite@xcite eq .
( [ eq : so ] ) as @xmath61\rangle\vert_{0}$ ] and @xmath62\rangle\vert_{0}$ ] . to see that these expressions agree with eq .
( [ eq : h_pt ] ) note that @xmath63=[{\cal h}-{\cal h}_{\rm kin}+{\bf\delta}\cdot{\bf s},{\bf s}]$ ] , that @xmath64\equiv 0 $ ] , and that @xmath65|a,{\bf k}\rangle=(\epsilon_{{\bf k},a}-\epsilon_{{\bf k},a})\langle a,{\bf k}|{\bf s}|a,{\bf k}\rangle = 0 $ ] . in this way the derivative of energy with respect to magnetization direction can be related to the exchange term in the kohn - sham equation rather than to the spin - orbit coupling term .
( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) and ( [ eq : h_pt ] ) are recovered after using @xmath66=i\epsilon_{ijk } s_k$ ] to simplify @xmath67\rangle$ ] .
we now show that the green s function expression we use to evaluate the ferromagnetic isge ( eq .
( [ eq : chi0 ] ) ) corresponds to the current - induced change in eq .
( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) .
we begin by mentioning that the application of an electric current can alter the magnetic anisotropy field , which leads to a current - induced torque on the magnetization . for an arbitrary orientation of the exchange field ,
the change is given by @xmath68 adopting the relaxation - time approximation , @xmath69 reads @xmath70 and for the change in the matrix elements we use @xmath71 with @xmath72 in eq .
( [ eq : state2 ] ) we have once again appealed to linear response theory and have used the fact that the electric field is uniform .
recognizing the fact that the integration of equal - band green s functions gives rise to a factor of @xmath84 , @xmath85 yields the intraband piece of eq .
( [ eq : chi ] ) modulo a factor of @xmath86 .
similarly , @xmath78 brings in the interband part of eq .
( [ eq : chi ] ) modulo a factor of @xmath86 ; in order to verify this we recall@xcite that @xmath87 in sum , we find @xmath88 which agrees with the isge expression for the current - induced spin density ( eq . ( [ eq : chi ] ) ) except for an overall normalization factor ( @xmath89 ) and the fact that the spin - operator is weighted by an spatially inhomogeneous magnitude of the exchange field . with the aim of making eq .
( [ eq : complete ] ) more manageable for first principles calculations , we will ignore the interband contribution as well as the @xmath90 term ; both omissions are justified in most metallic ferromagnets.@xcite in this case eq .
( [ eq : complete ] ) simplifies into @xmath91 where we have re - inserted @xmath92 . while approximate , eq .
( [ eq : simplified ] ) may provide a valid platform to explore current induced magnetization reversal in real gyrotropic ferromagnets with a single magnetic domain . in the next section
we will describe in detail how a large @xmath93 can produce a large reorientation of the magnetization .
if the spatial dependence of @xmath46 is negligible ( as it will be in the model studied in the next section ) , eq .
( [ eq : complete ] ) may be rewritten in a more compact way : @xmath94 where @xmath95 is the spin - current susceptibility introduced in eq .
( [ eq : chi ] ) .
( [ eq : link ] ) proves that the ferromagnetic isge describes the change in the magnetic anisotropy field due to a current . in other words ,
ferromagnetic isge determines how an electric current changes the location of the extrema in the micromagnetic energy functional .
this is the central idea of this section . as a final sidenote
, we point out that this section has concentrated on evaluating the change in magnetic anisotropy under a perturbation represented by @xmath96 , where @xmath97 is the electromagnetic vector potential .
the anisotropy is evaluated by calculating the change in the expectation value of @xmath98 , thus leading to a rather standard linear response function calculation .
we could in the same way calculate the change in the transverse spin - spin response function due to an electric field as indicated in fig .
( [ fig : three ] ) , in order to determine how small amplitude magnetic fluctuations are altered . if , however , we are interested only in uniform magnetization dynamics no additional information is obtained by doing this calculation .
the key point is that the response to a transverse field @xmath99 is already built in our expression for the equilibrium anisotropy field ( eq . ( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) ) , to _ all _ orders in @xmath99 . in other words , the reference ( unperturbed ) macrostate to which we apply a current contains a magnetization that is `` arbitrarily '' misaligned with the exchange field .
hence , eq . ( [ eq : link ] ) along with eq .
( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) offers a complete account of the nonequilibrium magnetic anisotropy of uniform magnetic states in the presence of a transport current .
magnetoelectric phenomena in dilute magnetic semiconductors@xcite such as ( ga , mn)as have attracted special attention because these materials are more compatible with current microelectronics technology than metals .
in addition , electric field control of magnetism has turned out to be more feasible in ( ga , mn)as than in conventional dense - moment metallic ferromagnets because of their small magnetization , high carrier spin polarization , strong spin - orbit interactions , and carrier - mediated ferromagnetism.@xcite in particular , the recent experiment@xcite by chernyshov _
on ( ga , mn)as wafers under compressive strain has demonstrated the ability of transport currents to reversibly _
assist _ the reorientation of magnetization in _ single - domain _ ferromagnets .
as we demonstrate here this effect is dependent on having both spin - orbit interactions and broken inversion symmetry . in this section
we compute the change in the magnetic anisotropy due to an electric current for a realistic model of ( ga , mn)as .
our calculation is directly relevant to the experiment of chernyshov _
et al._. our results corroborate their interpretation of the data and predict the possibility of all - electric magnetization switching in ( ga , mn)as .
our analysis is limited to zero temperature and neglects the shape anisotropy , which for typical mn doping concentrations is 10 - 100 times weaker than in conventional ferromagnets .
the dependence of the magnetic anisotropy of ( ga , mn)as on doping , external electric fields , temperature and strain has been successfully explained@xcite by combining ( i ) a mean - field theory of the exchange coupling between localized mn moments and valence band carriers with ( ii ) a phenomenological four or six band envelope function model in which the valence band holes are characterized by luttinger , spin - orbit splitting and strain - energy parameters .
the results presented below predict the rate at which these fields change with external electric field . in line with this
we adopt the following hamiltonian for ga@xmath100mn@xmath101as : @xmath102 @xmath103 is the 4-band kohn - luttinger hamiltonian@xcite with luttinger parameters @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 .
@xmath107 is the spin operator projected onto the j=3/2 total angular momentum subspace at the top of the valence band .
@xmath108 is the exchange field , @xmath31 denotes the orientation of the local moments , @xmath109 is the p - d exchange coupling parameter , @xmath110 is the spin of the mn ions , and @xmath111 is the mn concentration ( @xmath112 is the lattice constant of gaas ) .
this four - band model is expected to be adequate for small and intermediate mn doping strengths .
@xmath113 is the strain hamiltonian@xcite given by @xmath114\nonumber\\ & + & c_4 \left [ j_x \left(\epsilon_{yy}-\epsilon_{zz}\right ) k_x + c.p.\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath115 is the total angular momentum ( @xmath116 by the wigner - eckart theorem ) , @xmath117 are diagonal elements of the stress tensor , @xmath118 is the axial deformation potential and the parameter @xmath119 captures the strain - induced linear in @xmath120 spin - splitting of the valence bands in paramagnetic gaas . in eq .
( [ eq : strain ] ) the notation _ c.p .
_ stands for cyclic permutations and @xmath121 for @xmath122 $ ] growth lattice - matching strains .
the term proportional to @xmath123 is crucial for the occurrence of the ferromagnetic isge because it breaks inversion symmetry ( we are neglecting the intrinsic lack of inversion symmetry of the zinc - blende structure , which is relatively inconsequential ) , and it introduces chirality . ( a bulk , unstrained zinc - blende crystal is not gyrotropic because it corresponds to the @xmath27 symmetry point group . ) eq .
( [ eq : strain ] ) may be simplified to @xmath124 where @xmath125 is the purely axial strain component . in this paper
we take @xmath126 ( compressive strain ) , which applies when ( ga , mn)as is grown on top of a gaas substrate . using eqs .
( [ eq : h_an_eq2 ] ) , ( [ eq : link ] ) and ( [ eq : model ] ) we evaluate the magnetic anisotropy field both with and without electric current ; the results are highlighted in figs .
( [ fig : h_an_eq1])- ( [ fig : critical ] ) . figs .
( [ fig : h_an_eq1 ] ) and ( [ fig : h_an_eq2 ] ) correspond to electrical equilibrium and illustrate @xmath127 for @xmath128 and @xmath129 for @xmath130 , respectively .
the extrema of the micromagnetic energy functional are characterized by @xmath131 and by inspection we locate them at @xmath132 and @xmath133 where @xmath134 . for our parameters ( see figure captions ) the energy minima that define metastable magnetic configurations are found at @xmath135 .
that is to say , the easy directions correspond to [ 100 ] , [ 010],[@xmath13600 ] and [ 0@xmath1360 ] , which are contained in the plane of the ( ga , mn)as wafer . for later reference , we consider an initial condition in which the magnetization is pointing along [ 100 ] .
if a small static perturbation tilts it towards [ 110 ] , the negative anisotropy field ( @xmath137 for @xmath138 ) creates a torque that will , in conjunction with damping,@xcite turn the magnetization back to [ 100 ] .
( [ fig : intra vs inter ] ) illustrates how an electric current along [ 010 ] alters the azimuthal anisotropy field@xcite for fixed @xmath130 .
the cosine - like shape is consistent with the dresselhaus symmetry of the @xmath123 term in the strain hamiltonian .
if the system had a perfect dresselhaus symmetry the change in the micromagnetic energy functional under an electric current @xmath139 would read @xmath140 which means that a current along [ 010 ] ( [ 100 ] ) would tilt the steady - state magnetization direction along [ 010 ] ( [ @xmath14100 ] ) . using @xmath142 and @xmath143 it follows that @xmath144 , and hence a cosine - like dependence in @xmath145 is indeed expected for a current along [ 010 ] .
we have verified that a current along @xmath146 gives rise to a sine - like dependence with the appropriate sign .
nevertheless , eq .
( [ eq : dress ] ) is not exact because the magnetization vector introduces another preferred direction ; for instance , we find that an electric field pointing along @xmath147 ( i.e. [ 001 ] ) can also alter the steady - state spin orientation .
this effect , which vanishes in the paramagnetic limit , highlights one instance in which the ferromagnetic and paramagnetic isges differ .
another attribute of fig .
( [ fig : intra vs inter ] ) is that it determines the quantitative importance of interband contributions to the current - induced spin density in ( ga , mn)as . although normally neglected , interband transitions become quantitatively significant in strongly disordered ferromagnets . in particular , interband and
intraband contributions are largely indistinguishable in ferromagnets with @xmath148 .
we note parenthetically that neither intraband nor interband contributions display the smooth sinusoidal shape portrayed by their sum .
in addition , we remark that reversing the sign of the axial strain ( i.e. making it tensile ) leads to a sign reversal of @xmath149 without substantial changes in its magnitude.@xcite fig .
( [ fig : h_an_neq1 ] ) demonstrates that a sufficiently strong current is able to rotate the magnetization by @xmath150 or @xmath151 .
we explain this property by considering the case in which the equilibrium magnetization is pointing along [ 100 ] .
if a small current is applied along [ 010 ] , then [ 100 ] is no longer an extremum of the micromagnetic energy functional ( because @xmath152 ) .
the modified _ easy _
direction remains in the neighborhood of [ 100 ] since the restoring torque ( @xmath137 ) again crosses zero at @xmath138 .
once the applied electric field exceeds a critical value ( @xmath153 in the present figure ) the @xmath137 region near [ 100 ] disappears completely and hence assisted by damping the magnetization eventually points along [ 010 ] .
in other words , at ( and above ) the critical switching field the energy minimum that is nearest to [ 100 ] is located at [ 010 ] ( note that this direction remains stable when the current flows along [ 010 ] ) .
once the magnetization is aligned with [ 010 ] , an equally strong electric current in the [ 100 ] direction will rotate it towards [ @xmath13600 ] . in this fashion
it is possible to switch the direction of magnetization by @xmath151 solely by application of transport currents .
the procedure sketched above accomplishes magnetization switching by application of two perpendicular current pulses , each of which forces a @xmath150 rotation .
yet , it is also possible to achieve the @xmath154\to[{\bar 1}00]$ ] switching with a single _ unidirectional _ pulse , provided the electric field along [ 100 ] is ramped up sufficiently ( @xmath155 for the parameters of the present figure ) . in order to understand this , recall that @xmath156 . consequently , for a strong electric current [ @xmath14100 ]
is the only easy direction ( [ 100 ] becomes a hard direction ) .
the inequivalence between [ 100 ] and [ @xmath13600 ] does not violate any symmetry principles;@xcite in effect , an electric current breaks time reversal symmetry and can thus connect time - reversed magnetic states .
using @xmath157 as the typical resistivity for ( ga , mn)as samples we deduce that @xmath158 corresponds approximately to a current density of @xmath159 , hence the critical switching current is on the order of @xmath0 .
it is plausible that a detailed exploration of the parameter space comprised by the mn concentration @xmath160 , the hole density @xmath161 and the axial strain @xmath162 will enable lower critical currents , thereby diminishing the importance of the joule heating . as a word of caution
, we note that the 4-band model employed here typically overestimates the effect of spin - orbit interactions , thus potentially leading to an underestimate of these critical currents .
there is in addition some uncertainty associated with the use of a life - time approximation for bloch state quasiparticles in these strongly disordered metallic conducting ferromagnets .
overall , the magnitude of the critical switching current depends on ( a ) the size of the equilibrium anisotropy barrier , ( b ) the extent to which inversion symmetry is broken and ( c ) the strength of spin - orbit interaction . in ( ga ,
mn)as the first two factors are tunable .
on one hand , ( a ) may be optimized by choosing appropriate doping concentrations : in general lower mn density is beneficial ( fig .
( [ fig : critical ] ) ) , as it reduces the equilibrium anisotropy without significantly affecting the magnitude of isge . however , for very low mn concentrations a metal - insulator transition is impending , which hampers isge . on the other hand , ( b ) may be modified via strain engineering : as shown in fig .
( [ fig : critical ] ) , the critical current is ( roughly ) inversely proportional to the strength of the uniaxial strain that breaks inversion symmetry .
the inverse proportionality may be understood on the basis of eq .
( [ eq : dress ] ) combined with the fact that the equilibrium anisotropy does not change to _ first _ order in @xmath162 ( because @xmath14-linear terms vanish after summing over all momenta ) .
in this work we have presented a theory of the current - induced spin torques in uniform ferromagnets .
the torques can be viewed as due to a difference between the magnetic anisotropy energy of a ferromagnet which carries no current and the magnetic anisotropy of a ferromagnet in the transport steady state , which give rise to a corresponding change in anisotropy effective magnetic fields .
when the transport steady state is described using a relaxation time approximation , the current - induced contribution to the anisotropy field of a strongly metallic ferromagnet is given in energy units by @xmath163_{a , a}{\bf v}_{a , a}\cdot{\bf e } \ , \frac{\partial f_{{\bf k},a}}{\partial\epsilon_{{\bf k},a } } \ , \tau_{{\bf k},a}.\ ] ] where @xmath164_{a , a}$ ] is the spin - density weighted average of the exchange splitting of a particular state .
we refer to the existence of this current - induced anisotropy field as the ferromagnetic inverse spin - galvanic effect . in bulk materials
this current induced field is non - zero only in gyrotropic ferromagnets , _
i.e. _ only in ferromagnets that have broken inversion symmetry and are chiral .
although uniform ferromagnetism may appear to be incompatible with broken inversion symmetry because of the the dzyaloshinskii - moriya interaction , the equilibrium magnetic anisotropy is often strong enough ( or at least can be engineered so that it is strong enough ) to prevent the formation of spiral magnetic states .
as an illustration of our theory , we have estimated current induced torques in uniform ( ga , mn)as , which is not gyrotropic when it has pseudo - cubic symmetry but becomes gyrotropic when strained . since substrate - dependent strains are present in all ( ga , mn)as thin films , the strength of the ferromagnetic isge is expected to be strongly sample - dependent .
we have concluded that it should _ a priori _ be feasible to design ( ga , mn)as samples in which it is possible to switch the magnetization purely by electrical means . for typical sample parameters the necessary switching currents are on the order of @xmath165 , but
the value may be tuned by adjusting the doping concentration and the axial strain . at these critical currents
the joule heating is not negligible ; however , it is possible that further studies exploring the entire parameter space of mn concentration , hole density , and the axial strain will identify circumstances under which the critical currents are smaller .
another possible avenue for further research consists of evaluating the anisotropy fields which can be generated by electrical currents in strain engineered samples of appropriate technologically useful ferromagnets . since we are not aware of room - temperature transition metal ferromagnets that are gyrotropic,@xcite we propose arranging a room - temperature , non - gyrotropic ferromagnet ( e.g. permalloy ) in contact with a non - magnetic , gyrotropic material ( e.g. strained gaas ) . in these artificial heterostructures room - temperature magnetism and gyrotropic symmetry
would coexist by virtue of the proximity effect .
finally , effects similar to those studied in this work would allow transport currents to change spiral states , and possibly to induce or remove them .
ralph and m.d .
stiles , j. magn .
magn . mater . *
320 * , 1190 ( 2008 ) ; p.m. haney , r.a .
duine , a.s .
nunez and a.h .
macdonald , _ ibid _ * 320 * , 1300 ( 2008 ) ; y. tserkovnyak , a. brataas and g.e.w .
bauer , _ ibid _ * 320 * , 1282 ( 2008 ) .
a. manchon and s. zhang , phys .
b * 78 * , 212405 ( 2008 ) ; a. manchon and s. zhang , phys .
b * 79 * , 094422 ( 2009 ) .
a. chernyshov , m. overby , x. liu , j.k . furdyna and l.p .
rokhinson , arxiv:0812.3160 ( 2008 ) .
i. garate , ph.d .
thesis , university of texas at austin ( 2009 ) ; i. garate and a.h .
macdonald , aps march meeting ( pittsburgh , 2009 ) , url : http://meetings.aps.org/meeting/mar09/event/95816 .
a.s . nunez , r.a .
duine , p.m. haney and a.h .
macdonald , phys .
b * 73 * , 214426 ( 2006 ) ; z. wei , a. sharma , a.s . nunez , p.m. haney , r.a .
duine , j. bass , a.h . macdonald and m. tsoi ,
* 98 * , 116603 ( 2007 ) .
dyakonov and v.i .
perel , phys . lett . *
35a * , 459 ( 1971 ) ; e.l .
ivchenko and g.e .
pikus , jetp lett .
* 27 * , 604 ( 1978 ) ; e.l .
ivchenko , g.e .
pikus , i.i .
farbstein , v.a .
shalygin and a.v .
sturbin , jetp lett .
* 29 * , 441 ( 1979 ) ; a.g .
aronov and y.b .
lyanda - geller , jetp lett .
* 50 * , 431 ( 1989 ) ; v. edelstein , solid state commun . * 73 * , 233 ( 1990 ) ; a.g .
aronov , y.b .
lyanda - geller and g.e .
pikus , sov .
jetp * 73 * , 537 ( 1991 ) ; e.l .
ivchenko and s. ganichev , _ spin physics in semiconductors _
dyakonov ) , ( springer , new york , 2008 ) .
m. ranvah , y. melikhov , d.c .
jiles , j.e .
snyder , a.j .
moses , p.i .
williams and s.h . song , j. appl .
phys . * 103*,07e506 ( 2008 ) .
d. chiba , m. sawicki , y. nishitani , y. nakatani , f. matsukura and h. ohno , nature * 455 * , 515 ( 2009 ) . t. maruyama , y. shiota , t. nozaki , k. ohta , n. toda , m. mizuguchi , a.a .
tulapurkar , t. shinjo , m. shiraishi , s. mizukami , y. ando and y. suzuki , nature nanotechnology * 4 * , 158 ( 2009 ) . m. weiler , a.brandlmaier , s. gepraegs , m. althammer , m. opel , c. bihler , h. huebl , m.s .
brandt , r. gross and s.t.b .
goennenwein , new j. phys .
* 11 * , 013021 ( 2009 ) .
b. botters , f. giesen , j. podbielski , p. bach , g. schmidt , l.w .
moelnkamp and d. grundler , appl .
* 89 * , 242505 ( 2006 ) .
a. lemaitre , a. miard , l. travers , o. mauguin , l. largeau , c. gourdon and v. jeudy , appl .
. lett . * 93 * , 021123 ( 2008 ) .
p. gambardella , s. stepanow , a. dmitriev , j. honolka , f.m.f .
de groot , m. lingenfelder , s.s .
gupta , d.d .
sarma , p. benc
ok , s. stanescu , s. clair , s. pons , n. lin , a.p .
seitsonen , h. brune , j.v . barth and k. kern , nature materials * 8 * , 189 ( 2009 ) .
all gyrotropic crystals are non - centrosymmetric , but not all non - centrosymmetric crystals are gyrotropic .
silov , p.a .
blajnov , j.h .
wolter , r. hey , k.h . ploog and n.s .
averkiev , appl .
* 85 * , 5929 ( 2004 ) ; y. kato , r.c .
myers , a.c .
gossard and d.d .
awschalom , phys .
* 93 * , 176601 ( 2004 ) ; v. sih , r.c .
myers , y.k .
kato , w.h .
lau , a.c .
gossard and d.d .
awschalom , nat . phys .
* 1 * , 31 ( 2005 ) ; c.l .
yang , h.t .
he , l. ding , l.j .
cui , y.p .
zeng , j.n .
wang and w.k .
lett . * 96 * , 186605 ( 2006 ) ; s.d .
ganichev , s.n .
danilov , p. schneider , v.v .
belkov , l.e .
golub , w. wegscheider , d. weiss and w. prettl , j. magn .
magn . mater .
* 300 * , 127 ( 2006 ) .
burkov , a.s .
nunez , and a.h .
macdonald , phys .
b * 70 * , 155308 ( 2004 ) ; o. bleibaum , phys . rev .
b * 73 * , 035322 ( 2006 ) ; m. trushin and j. schliemann , phys . rev .
b * 75 * , 155323 ( 2007 ) , h.a .
engel , e.i .
rashba and b.i .
halperin , phys .
98 * , 036602 ( 2007 ) . by definition , axial vectors and polar vectors transform in identical manner under operations belonging to gyrotropic point groups .
consequently , gyrotropic crystals ( which are invariant under transformations from gyrotropic point groups ) enable the coupling between axial and polar vectors . as a simple example , consider a two dimensional electron gas ( 2deg ) with rashba spin - orbit coupling . under a 90@xmath166 rotation around the @xmath167 axis ( perpendicular to the 2deg ) ,
the current @xmath168 changes to @xmath169 and the spin operator @xmath170 changes in the same manner , namely to @xmath171 .
since the 90@xmath166 rotation around @xmath167 is a symmetry of the rashba hamiltonian , a nonzero current - induced spin polarization is allowed under such operation . for paramagnetic metals
it is straightforward to deduce the relative orientation between the applied electric field and the induced spin polarization from symmetry arguments .
for instance , the hamiltonian for a 2deg with rashba spin - orbit interaction is invariant under a 90@xmath166 rotation around the @xmath167 as well as under a reflection with respect to the plane perpendicular to @xmath172 . according to neumann s principle ,
the tensor relating the electric field and the spin polarization must be invariant under the above mentioned symmetry operations . from this requirement
it follows that the spin polarization must be perpendicular to the current .
see for example j. stohr , _ magnetism _
( springer , berlin , 2006 ) . for reviews see _
e.g. _ s.w .
cheong and m. mostovoy , nat .
materials * 6 * , 13 ( 2007 ) ; r. ramesh and n.a .
spaldin , _ ibid _ * 6 * , 21 ( 2007 ) . c. ederer and n.a .
spalding , phys .
b * 71 * , 060401(r ) ( 2005 ) . t. zhao , a. choll , f. zavaliche , k. lee , m. barry , a. doran , m.p .
cruz , y.h .
chu , c. ederer , n.a .
spaldin , r.r .
das , d.m .
kim , s.h .
baek , c.b .
eom and r. ramesh , nat materials * 5 * , 823 ( 2006 ) .
i. garate and a.h .
macdonald , phys .
b * 79 * , 064403 ( 2009 )
mahan , _ many particle physics _ , physics of solids and liquids series , 3rd ed .
( kluwer academic / plenum publishers , new york , 2000 ) . in the zero frequency limit the real part of @xmath173 is cancelled out by the diamagnetic response .
this reflects the fact that in non - superconducting metals the current induced spin density is dissipative .
liu , b. zhou , s.q .
shen and b.f .
zhu , phys .
b * 77 * , 125345 ( 2008 ) .
s.v . vonsovskii ( editor ) , _ ferromagnetic resonance _
( pergamon press , oxford , 1966 ) . for reviews see _
e.g. _ p. bruno , in _ physical origins and theoretical models of magnetic anisotropy _
( frerienkurse des forschungszentrums julich , julich , 1993 ) ; m.t .
johnson , p.j.h .
bloemen , f.j.a den broeder and j.j .
de vries , rep .
. phys . * 59 * , 1409 ( 1996 ) ; j. stohr , j. magn .
magn . mater . *
200 * , 470 ( 1999 ) .
d. steiauf , j. seib and m. fanhle , phys .
b * 78 * , 020410(r ) ( 2008 ) .
the sum of the single - particle kohn - sham eigenvalues does not account for the actual ground state energy of the ferromagnet because it neglects the double - counted hartree and exchange - correlation contributions .
however , we invoke the _ force theorem _ which states that the extra terms will cancel when we one takes the difference in total energies between two macrostates with non - collinear exchange fields .
see for instance a.r .
mackintosh and o.k .
andersen , _ electrons at the fermi surface _ ( ed .
m. springford ) ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1980 ) ; a.i .
liechtenstein , m.i .
katsnelson and v.a .
gubanov , j. phys .
f * 14 * , l125 ( 1984 ) ; m. weinert , r.e .
watson and j.w .
davenport , phys .
b * 32 * , 2115 ( 1985 ) ; see also ref . [ ] .
daalderop , p.j .
kelly and m.f.h .
schuurmans , phys .
b * 41 * , 11919 ( 1990 ) .
j. wunderlich , t. jungwirth , b. kaestner , a.c .
irvine , k.y .
wang , n. stone , u. rana , a.d .
giddings , a.b .
shick , c.t .
foxon , r.p .
campion , d.a .
williams and b.l .
gallagher , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 077201 ( 2006 ) .
x. wang , r. wu , d.s .
wang and a.j .
freeman , phys .
b * 54 * , 61 ( 1996 ) .
k. gilmore , y.u .
idzerda and m.d .
stiles , phys .
99 , 27204 ( 2007 ) . for reviews see _
e.g. _ a.h .
macdonald , p. schieffer and n. samarth , nat .
materials * 4 * , 195 ( 2005 ) ; t. jungwirth , j. sinova , j. masek , j. kucera and a.h .
macdonald , rev .
phys . * 78 * , 809 ( 2006 ) .
n. nagaosa , j. sinova , s. onoda , a.h . macdonald and n.p .
ong , arxiv:0904.4154 ( 2009 ) .
strictly speaking eqs .
( [ eq : state2 ] ) and ( [ eq : trick ] ) are accurate only in absence of disorder .
nevertheless , the connection between them remains intact in presence of impurities .
the leading o(@xmath83 ) correction due to interband transitions would be captured by the second line of eq .
( [ eq : h_inter ] ) . i. stolichnov , s.w.e .
riester , h.j .
trodahl , n. setter , a.w .
rushforth , k.w .
edmonds , r.p .
campion , c.t .
foxon and b.l .
gallagher , nature mater .
* 7 * , 464 ( 2008 ) .
h. ohno and t. dietl , j. magn .
magn . mat .
* 320 * , 1293 ( 2008 ) .
m. abolfath , t. jungwirth , j. brum and a.h .
macdonald , phys .
b * 63 * , 054418 ( 2001 ) .
t. dietl , h. ohno and f. matsukura , phys .
b * 63 * , 195205 ( 2001 ) .
j. zemen , j. kucera , k. olejnik and t. jungwirth , arxiv:0904.0993 ( 2009 ) .
p. yu and m. cardona , _ fundamentals of semiconductors _ , 3rd ed .
( springer , new york , 2005 ) . m. silver , w. batty , a. ghiti and e.p .
oreilly , phys .
b * 46 * , 6781 ( 1992 ) . for an exhaustive list of symmetry - allowed strain terms
see _ e.g. _ r. winkler , _ spin - orbit coupling effects in two - dimensional electron and hole systems _ ( springer , berlin , 2003 ) . in absence of damping the magnetization would keep precessing indefinitely .
the combined action of the anisotropy field and damping is what ultimately drives the system to the minimum energy state .
our discussion concentrates on @xmath174 .
although @xmath175 too generally changes in presence of a current , it is not pertinent to the [ 100]@xmath176[010 ] or [ 100]@xmath176[@xmath14100 ] magnetization reorientations that we are interested in .
it is known that in gaas quantum wells the strain - induced * k*-linear terms have negligible impact if the strain is compressive , yet they matter if the strain is tensile ( see _ e.g. _ ref . [ ] ) .
this observation does not apply to bulk ( ga , mn)as .
j. stohr , h.c .
siegmann , a. kashuba and s.j .
gamble , appl .
. lett . * 94 * , 072504 ( 2009 ) .
however , it has been suggested that sizeable rashba spin - orbit interactions arise in magnetic interfaces of rare earth metals such as gd , where the atomic spin - orbit coupling is strong .
see o. krupin , g. bihlmayer , k. starke , s. gorovikov , j.e .
prieto , k. dobrich , s. blugel and g. kaindl , phys .
b * 71 * , 201403(r ) ( 2005 ) . | current - induced torques are commonly used to manipulate non - collinear magnetization configurations . in this article
we discuss current - induced torques present in a certain class of collinear magnetic systems , relating them to current - induced changes in magnetic anisotropy energy .
we present a quantitative estimate of their characteristics in uniform strained ferromagnetic ( ga , mn)as . |
high - resolution observations of the galactic center at near - infrared wavelengths first revealed the remarkable arches stellar cluster located at @xmath4=012 , b=002 , 11 ( or 27.5 pc ) in projection from sgr a@xmath5 ( nagata et al .
1995 ; cotera et al .
1996 ) . here
, we assume a distance to the galactic center of 8.0 kpc ( reid 1993 ) .
nagata et al . (
1995 ) identified the 14 brightest stars in this cluster with jhk photometry and br@xmath3 and br@xmath2 hydrogen recombination lines , showing that these stars had the characteristic colors and emission lines of wolf - rayet ( wr ) and he i emission - line stars .
the strength of the br@xmath2 and br@xmath3 emission lines suggests that these stars are losing mass at rates of 2@xmath610@xmath7 .
using k - band spectroscopy , cotera et al .
( 1996 ) also found 12 stars in the cluster with spectra consistent with late - type wn / of types , and which have 1@xmath820 @xmath6 10@xmath7 m@xmath9 , and 800@xmath81200 .
recent observations of the arches cluster indicate that the number of massive stars is much greater than suggested by the initial studies .
serabyn et al .
( 1998 ) estimate that at least 100 cluster members have masses @xmath10 20 m@xmath9 , and figer et al .
( 1999 ) calculate that the total cluster mass exceeds 10@xmath11 m@xmath9 with as many as 160 o - stars and a stellar density of @xmath12 3@xmath610@xmath13 m@xmath9 pc@xmath14 .
these parameters make the arches cluster one of the densest and most massive young stellar clusters in the galaxy .
in addition , the ionizing flux ( estimated to be a few 10@xmath15 s@xmath16 ) is sufficient to ionize the surrounding arched filaments h ii complex ( serabyn et al . 1998 ; lang et al . 2001 ) .
the relative placement of the arches cluster and the filamentary nebular features is depicted in figure 1 .
thermal radio emission from ionized stellar winds is detectable at radio wavelengths and arises from the outer parts of the wind envelope .
the classic theory of panagia & felli ( 1975 ) and wright & barlow ( 1975 ) predicts that the spectrum of radio emission from a stellar wind is @xmath17 @xmath18 for a spherically symmetric , isothermal , stationary wind expanding at a constant velocity .
previous surveys made with the very large array ( vla ) of the national radio astronomy observatory have detected radio emission from ob supergiant and wolf - rayet stellar winds ( abbott et al .
1986 ; bieging et al .
recently , lang et al .
( 1999 ) detected six radio point sources in the vicinity of a similar galactic center cluster , the quintuplet , which have spectra consistent with the theoretical predictions and close positional correspondances with known near - infrared stellar sources .
here , we present multi - frequency vla observations of the arches cluster in an attempt to detect stellar wind emission from the individual stars known to be members of this dense cluster .
vla multi - frequency continuum observations were made of the arches cluster in july 1999 ( a - array ) at 4.9 ghz and 8.5 ghz ( 4 hours each ) , and in october 1999 ( bna array ) at 43.3 ghz ( 3 hours ) .
the phase center of all observations was the position given for the bright , central source in nagata et al .
( 1995 ) : = 17 45 50.41 , @xmath828 49 21.8 .
standard procedures for calibration , editing , and imaging were carried out using the _ aips _ software of nrao . at all wavelengths ,
3c286 was used for flux density calibration , and at 8.5 and 4.8 ghz , 1751 - 253 was used as a phase calibrator . at 43 ghz ,
fast switching between the bright source sgr a@xmath5 and the phase center of the observations ( an angular distance of 125 ) was carried out on a 90 second cycle in order to closely track the phase variations . the resulting spatial resolutions and rms noise levels in the images are 079 033 , pa=128 and 45 @xmath19jy at 4.9 ghz ; 041 016 , pa=28 and 25 @xmath19jy at 8.5 ghz ; and 029 007 , pa=492 and 300 @xmath19jy at 43.3 ghz .
figure 2 shows the 8.5 ghz image of the radio sources within a 16 ( 0.7 pc ) region centered on the bright source at the cluster center .
the crosses represent the positions of 9 of the 14 stars in nagata et al .
( 1995 ) which showed br@xmath3 and br@xmath2 recombination lines .
these positions have been shifted by 005 ( 066 ) to correct for what appears to be a systematic offset to the west . at 8.5 ghz ,
eight sources are detected above a 6@xmath20 level and are referred to as ar1@xmath88 .
seven of the sources ( with the exception of ar6 ) appear to be associated with the stellar positions plotted in figure 2 .
ar7 also shows a larger displacement ( @xmath21@xmath2=05 ) from the corresponding stellar position than the rest of the radio sources .
however , the absolute uncertainty in the near - infrared positions is 2 or less , so an association is quite possible within these limits . since the a priori probability of finding a 8.5 ghz background source with flux density greater than 0.1 mjy in the region considered is 0.005 ,
we conclude that all the radio sources detected are indeed associated with the galactic center arches cluster .
the positions and properties of ar1@xmath88 are listed in table 1 .
four of these sources are detected in the 4.9 ghz observations ( ar1 , ar4 , ar6 , ar7 ) , while the central source ar1 is additionally detected in the 43.3 ghz observations . at 43.3 ghz
, ar1 has a flux density of 3.10.1 mjy , consistent with the 4.9/8.5 ghz spectral index ( @xmath2 + 0.35 ) .
spectral indices between 4.9/8.5 ghz are calculated for the sources detected at 4.9 ghz .
upper limits for the flux densities at 4.9 ghz can be estimated for the remaining sources , with resulting lower limits for the spectral indices .
seven of the sources show rising spectra in the range of + 0.3 to + 0.9 with the exception of ar6 , which has a nonthermal spectral index ( = @xmath80.7 ) .
the sources ar2@xmath88 are point sources with angular sizes @xmath22 025 .
the deconvolved size of ar1 at 8.5 ghz is 011 ( 0.005 pc ) , implying a brightness temperature of 3000 k , a reasonable value for an ionized wind .
the spectral indices of the detected sources are consistent with values expected from stellar wind emission .
several of the sources have spectra which are flatter ( @xmath2 + 0.3 ) than the predicted @xmath2=+0.6 , and ar6 has a negative spectral index ( @xmath2 @xmath80.7 )
. however , these spectra do not rule out stellar wind detections . about 25% of stellar winds arising from massive stars have been found to have flat or nonthermal spectra in the radio regime ( bieging , abbott & churchwell 1989 ) .
the precise mechanism that produces these nonthermal spectra is not established , but internal shocks in the wind of a single star ( white 1985 ) or the presence of interacting winds in close binary systems have been proposed ( contreras & rodrguez 1999 ) . for a typical late - type wn star at the galactic center ,
the expected flux density at 8.5 ghz arising from a stellar wind is 250 @xmath19jy based on the assumed values of 1000 , 5@xmath610@xmath7 and t10@xmath11 k. this value is similar to the flux densities we measure at 8.5 ghz for ar2@xmath88 .
figure 2 also shows an excellent positional correspondence between the radio sources and the stellar sources detected by nagata et al .
table 2 lists the spectral types of these stars as determined by cotera et al .
the stars have been classified as late - type wn and of stars , all of which are expected to be losing mass at high rates from their surfaces . as noted above , such stars often exhibit flattened or nonthermal spectral indices due to the presence of a nonthermal component .
therefore , the range of spectra we detect is consistent with predictions for late - type wn stars .
the radio source ar6 is displaced by @xmath21@xmath2=1 from the corresponding stellar position of nagata et al .
( 1995 ) . at 8.5 ghz
, there is a 75 @xmath19jy source ( 3@xmath20 ) closer to the stellar position , which may be the correct identifcation .
the stellar source at this position has been classified as a wn8 star by cotera et al .
if this displacement is real , we have then to consider the possibility that ar6 is associated with another star in the cluster .
t tauri stars are sometimes found to have associated nonthermal emission , usually interpreted as gyrosynchrotron produced by electrons accelerated in situ by magnetic reconnection flares near the stellar surface ( andr et al .
1988 ; rodrguez , anglada , and curiel 1999 ) .
if this is the case , we may be detecting for the first time a young , low mass member of the cluster .
the flux densities at 8.5 ghz were used to calculate a mass - loss rate based on panagia & felli ( 1975 ) : @xmath23 where s@xmath24 is the flux density of the source at 8.5 ghz , is the terminal velocity of the wind , and d is the distance to the source ( 8 kpc ) . we have assumed an electron temperature of = 10@xmath11 k , z=1 , and a mean molecular weight , @xmath19=2 , due to the enrichment in heavy elements of the late - type wn stars ( leitherer et al .
. the mass loss rate of ar1 has the largest value , = 1.7 10@xmath25 yr@xmath16 , comparable only to stars with extreme values for , such as in the r136 stellar cluster at the center of 30 doradus ( de koter et al .
the values of for ar2@xmath88 are in the range of [email protected] 10@xmath7 , consistent with values found for for late type wn stars by leitherer et al .
( 1997 ) : [email protected] @xmath610@xmath7 yr@xmath16 . the rich population of massive stars in the radio arc region , which includes both the arches and quintuplet clusters ( figer et al .
1999 ) , suggests that the interstellar environment should be strongly influenced by the energetic processes related to such massive star formation and evolution .
ionization of the molecular material in this region and formation of the unusually shaped arched filaments and sickle h ii regions can be accounted for by the ionizing fluxes of each cluster ( lang et al .
1997 , 2001 ) .
in addition , interactions between the winds in the densely - packed arches cluster may give rise to a shock - heated diffuse `` cluster wind '' , which could have a temperature as high as 10@xmath26 k ( cant , raga & rodrguez 2000 ) .
this emission is predicted to be detectable in the x - ray regime with the _ chandra x - ray observatory_. studies of the interaction between the massive stars in the arches and the surrounding interstellar environoment are currently underway at a number of complementary wavelengths .
we present the following results from our 4.9 , 8.5 , and 43.3 ghz observations of the arches cluster : \(1 ) eight radio sources are detected at 8.5 ghz , four sources at 4.9 ghz , and one of them is detected also at 43.3 ghz .
seven of the eight detections show rising spectral indices between 4.9 and 8.5 ghz in the range + 0.3 to + 0.6 , while one source shows a nonthermal spectrum ( @xmath80.7 ) .
all of the detections are consistent with stellar wind emission from mass - losing stars .
however , the nonthermal source may be tracing a young , low mass member of the cluster .
this is the first detection of emission associated with the members of the arches cluster at a band other than the near - infrared .
\(2 ) seven of the eight radio sources are coincident in position with the br@xmath3 and br@xmath2 emission - line stellar sources of nagata et al .
( 1995 ) , which correspond to the late wn and of stellar types as classified by cotera et al .
these positional correspondences further confirm that the ionized winds from stars in the arches cluster are detected .
\(3 ) based on the radio flux density , ar1 has a mass - loss rate of 2@xmath610@xmath25 yr@xmath16 , comparable only to that of the stars in 30 doradus ( de koter et al .
mass - loss rates for ar2@xmath88 are found to be in the range [email protected]@xmath610@xmath7 , similar to the large mass loss rates for other late - type wn systems ( leitherer et al .
1997 ) .
abbott , d. , torres , a. , biejing , j. , & churchwell , e. 1986 , apj , 303 , 239 andr , p. , montmerle , t. , feigelson , e.d . ,
stine , p. c. , & klein , k. l. 1988 , apj , 335 , 940 bieging , j. , abbott , d. & churchwell , e. 1989 , apj , 340,518 cant , j. , raga , a.c . & rodrguez , l.f .
2000 , apj 536 , 896 contreras , m. e. & rodrguez , l. f. 1999 , apj , 515 , 762 cotera , a. , erickson , e. , colgan , s. , simpson , j. , allen , d. , & burton , m. 1996 , apj , 461 , 750 de koter , a. , heap , s. & hubeny , i. 1997 , apj , 477 , 792 figer , d.f . , kim , s , morris , m. , serabyn , e. , rich , m. , & mclean , i. 1999 , apj , 525 , 750 lang , c. c. , goss , w.m . , & wood , d.o.s .
1997 , apj , 474 , 275 lang , c.c . ,
figer , d.f . ,
goss , w.m .
& morris , m. 1999 , aj , 118 , 2327 lang , c.c . ,
goss , w.m . , & morris , m. 2001 , aj , _ in press _ ,
astroph e - print 0102130 leitherer , c. , chapman , j. , & koribalski , b. 1997 , apj , 481 , 898 nagata , t. , woodward , c.e . , shure , m. , kobayashi , n. 1995 , aj , 109 , 1676 panagia , n. & felli , m. 1975 , , 39 , 1 reid , m. 1993 , a&a review , 31 , 345 rodrguez , l. f. , anglada , g. , & curiel , s. 1999 , apjs , 125 , 427 serabyn , e. , shupe , d. , & figer 1998 , nature , 394 , 448 white , r.l .
1985 , apj , 289 , 698 wright , a.e . &
barlow , m.j .
1975 , , 170 , 41 lcccccc ar1&17 45 50.42&@xmath828 49 22.0&1.700.05&1.400.03&+0.350.04&1.710@xmath25 + ar2&17 45 50.39&@xmath828 49 21.0&0.230.02&@xmath270.13&@xmath10 + 0.9&3.910@xmath7 + ar3&17 45 50.20&@xmath828 49 22.0&0.170.02&@xmath270.13&@xmath10 + 0.4&3.210@xmath7 + ar4&17 45 50.47&@xmath828 49 19.2&0.230.02&0.160.03&+0.650.13&3.910@xmath7 + ar5&17 45 50.57&@xmath828 49 17.2&0.160.02&@xmath270.13&@xmath100.3&3.010@xmath7 + ar6&17 45 49.76&@xmath828 49 25.7&0.270.02&0.400.03&@xmath80.710.08&4.510@xmath7 + ar7&17 45 50.83&@xmath828 49 26.1&0.250.02&0.210.03&+0.310.05&4.210@xmath7 + ar8&17 45 50.45&@xmath828 49 31.7&0.200.02&@xmath270.13&@xmath10 + 0.7&3.610@xmath7 + | the galactic center arches stellar cluster , detected and studied until now only in the near - infrared , is comprised of at least one hundred massive ( m@xmath0 20 m@xmath1 ) stars . here
we report the detection at centimeter wavelengths of radio continuum emission from eight radio sources associated with the cluster .
seven of these radio sources have rising spectral indices between 4.9 and 8.5 ghz and coincide spatially with the brightest stars in the cluster , as determined from jhk photometry and br@xmath2 and br@xmath3 spectroscopy .
our results confirm the presence of powerful ionized winds in these stars .
the eighth radio source has a nonthermal spectrum and its nature is yet unclear , but it could be associated with a lower mass young star in the cluster . to appear in the astrophysical journal letters |
for a one dimensional system of length @xmath5 , the thermal conductivity can be defined through the stationary flux of energy induced by connecting the system to two thermostats at different temperatures @xmath6 and @xmath7 .
this flux of energy @xmath8 is proportional to the difference of temperature @xmath9 , and we define the thermal conductivity @xmath10 as @xmath11 if @xmath12 exists and is finite , then the conductivity is normal and the system is said to satisfy fourier s law @xcite .
the limit @xmath13 is the thermal conductivity of the system .
it is well known , by numerical experiments and certain analytical considerations , that the thermal conductivity diverges for one dimensional systems of oscillators with a momentum conserving dynamics @xcite .
this is also consistent with some experimental results on the length dependence of the thermal conductance of carbon nanotubes @xcite . in the case of a chain of harmonic oscillators ,
@xmath8 can be computed explicitly @xcite and does not decrease when the size @xmath5 of the system increases .
this is due to the ballistic transport of energy carried by the non - interacting phonons , and it happens also for _ optical _ ( pinned ) harmonic chains , where momentum is not conserved .
ballistic transport of energy is expected for all systems whose dynamics is completely integrable @xcite , as for the toda chain @xcite .
numerical evidence shows that _ non - integrability _ ( whatever the definition of this concept one considers ) is not a sufficient condition for normal conductivity , in particular for anharmonic chains of unpinned oscillators like the fpu model @xcite .
an energy superdiffusion is expected in these momentum conserving systems , and the thermal conductivity diverges as @xmath14 , for some @xmath15 .
there exists a wide debate in the physical literature about the existence or non - existence of one ( or more ) universal value of @xmath4 @xcite .
stochastic perturbations of the dynamics have been introduced in order to understand these phenomena .
a model where langevin thermostats are attached to each oscillator in a harmonic chain was first introduced by bolsterli _
et al _ @xcite .
this noise destroys all types of conservation laws , including energy , and the corresponding conductivity is finite ( see @xcite and @xcite for the anharmonic case ) .
also , stochastic perturbations that preserve only the energy of the system give finite thermal conductivity @xcite .
the situation changes dramatically if the stochastic perturbation conserves both the energy _ and _ the momentum @xcite .
such stochastic conservative perturbations model the chaotic effect of non - linearities .
these systems may then be seen as _ completely non - integrable _ , since the only conserved quantities left are the energy and the momentum . in this case , at least for harmonic interactions , the thermal conductivity can be explicitly computed by the green - kubo formula . for unpinned models , it remains finite only in dimension @xmath16 , while it diverges when @xmath17 or @xmath18 .
more precisely @xmath19 when @xmath17 , and @xmath20 when @xmath21 @xcite .
analytical considerations for the same harmonic stochastic systems in non - equilibrium setting give the same results for the thermal conductivity computed according to , see @xcite . for anharmonic interactions ,
rigorous upper bounds can be established , again by the green - kubo formula . in the one dimensional case , this leads to @xmath22 .
these rigorous results motivated us to analyze the effect of stochastic perturbations on another completely integrable system , the toda chain .
the thermal conductivity of toda lattices was already studied in @xcite , where it was shown that the ballistic energy transport is destroyed for a diatomic system .
in contrast with the harmonic case where many computations can be performed analytically , the nonlinear dynamics considered here has to be solved numerically .
we considered a chain in the nonequilibrium steady state setting , with two langevin thermostats at different temperatures attached to its boundaries .
we chose the simplest possible stochastic perturbation conserving both momentum and energy : each couple of nearest neighbor particles exchange their momentum at random times distributed according to an exponential law of parameter @xmath23 .
our main results are the following : a. [ r1 ] as soon as some noise is present , _
i.e. _ @xmath24 , the ballistic transport is immediately destroyed ( as in the harmonic case ) and energy superdiffuses , with @xmath14 for @xmath25 ; b. [ r2 ] the exponent @xmath4 seems to depend on the noise strength @xmath0 , and is increasing with @xmath0 .
if [ r1 ] was somehow expected , [ r2 ] is quite surprising .
it may be explained by the noise destroying some diffusive phenomena due to non - linearities , like localized breathers , with the result that current - current correlation decays slower when more noise is present . besides , [ r2 ] suggests that any theory claiming the existence of a universal parameter @xmath4 has to be properly circumstanced .
this paper is organized as follows .
the dynamics we consider is described in section [ sec : stochastic - dynamics ] .
the numerical simulations we performed are described in details in section [ sec : simulations - results ] , whereas the obtained results are discussed in section [ sec : disc - numer - results ] .
[ [ hamiltonian . ] ] hamiltonian .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + the configuration of the system is given by @xmath26 , where @xmath27 is the displacement with respect to the equilibrium position of the @xmath28-th particle , and @xmath29 is its momentum .
all masses are set equal to 1 .
the hamiltonian is given by @xmath30 where the interaction potential is defined by @xmath31 and @xmath32 are constants , @xmath33 , @xmath34 .
observe that if the product @xmath35 is kept constant , the harmonic chain is obtained in the limit @xmath36 , while the hard sphere system is recovered as @xmath37 . in our simulations , we chose @xmath38 and @xmath39 in order for @xmath40 to be non - negative and to be minimal at @xmath41 .
the potential is therefore determined by a single parameter @xmath42 , which determines the strength of anharmonicity .
[ [ boundary - conditions . ] ] boundary conditions .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we set @xmath43 , which amounts to removing the center - of - mass motion by attaching the particle at the left end of the system to a wall .
however , we do not fix the total length @xmath44 , and consider free boundary conditions on the right end .
we checked that our numerical results are robust with respect to the boundary conditions .
in particular , the same kind of scalings are obtained for fixed boundary conditions .
the stochastic dynamics we consider has the following generator : @xmath45 where @xmath46 and @xmath0 are two positive constants . in , @xmath47 is the hamiltonian vector field : @xmath48 @xmath49 are the generators of the langevin thermostats attached at atom @xmath50 and @xmath51 : @xmath52 and @xmath53 is the generator of the random exchanges of momenta between nearest neighbor atoms : for any smooth function @xmath54 , @xmath55 where @xmath56 is defined from @xmath57 by @xmath58 and @xmath59 if @xmath60 . finally @xmath61 is the strength of a constant external force applied to the last particle @xmath1 . in , we choose the temperatures @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
we define the energy of the oscillator @xmath28 for @xmath64 as @xmath65 locally the energy conservation is expressed by the stochastic differential equation @xmath66 the energy currents @xmath67 are the sum of contributions from the hamiltonian and the stochastic mechanisms . for @xmath68 ,
the currents are @xmath69 where @xmath70 is a martingale , @xmath71 is the instantaneous hamiltonian current , while @xmath72 is the instantaneous stochastic current ( the intrinsic transport of energy due to the stochastic exchange ) .
the martingale term @xmath70 can be characterized in the following way : let @xmath73 be independent poisson processes of intensity @xmath0 .
then @xmath74 where @xmath75 . at the boundaries of the system ,
the energy currents are @xmath76 ds + \sqrt{\xi t_r } \int_0^t p_n(s ) \ , dw_n(s)\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath77 and @xmath78 are independent standard wiener processes , and the last integrals on the right hand side of the previous formulas are it stochastic integrals . if @xmath79 , we know explicitly the stationary probability measure of the dynamics , given by the gibbs measure @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the relative displacement , @xmath82 is a normalization constant , and @xmath83 is a boundary term .
if @xmath84 , there is no explicit expression of the stationary measure for anharmonic potentials . for certain classes of anharmonic potentials ,
the results of @xcite show that there exists a unique stationary probability measure .
the assumptions on the potential made in @xcite or similar works are not satisfied by the toda potential ( in particular , the growth at infinity is too slow in the limit @xmath85 ) , but we believe that the techniques from @xcite can be extended to treat the case under consideration here .
we denote by @xmath86 the expectation with respect to this stationary measure , as well as the expectation on the path space of the dynamics in the stationary state . by stationarity
we have @xmath87 because of energy conservation , @xmath88 does not depend on @xmath28 , but only of the size @xmath1 of the system .
consequently , @xmath89 in view of , the thermal conductivity can be defined by @xmath90 it is clear from - that the direct contribution of the stochastic current to the conductivity is close to @xmath0 and remains bounded in @xmath1 .
hence only the first term of , namely the hamiltonian current @xmath91 can be responsible for a possible divergence of the conductivity . in the sequel , we hence consider the conductivity @xmath92 rather than .
we are also motivated by the following numerical considerations .
as reported in the sequel , we numerically observe that @xmath93 for some @xmath15 , hence @xmath94 for @xmath95 . as a consequence ,
the second term of is indeed negligible with respect to the first term , in the limit @xmath96 .
the regime of large @xmath1 may yet be difficult to reach numerically , so that the stochastic current contribution in may be small but not negligible compared with for the considered values of @xmath1 . by a linear response theory argument
, the thermal conductivity of the finite system can also be defined by a green - kubo formula : @xmath97 where here the expectation @xmath98 is with respect to the dynamics starting with the equilibrium gibbs measure given by ( [ eq:14 ] ) ( we assume here that the integral indeed exists ) . in principle , for finite @xmath1 , @xmath99 , but we expect that they have , qualitatively , the same asymptotic behavior as @xmath100 .
all the simulations performed in this work were done with @xmath101 and @xmath102 .
this temperature difference is small enough so that the thermal conductivity around @xmath103 should be approximated correctly .
we also set the external force to @xmath104 .
we denote by @xmath105 approximations of @xmath106 at time @xmath107 .
the time - discretization of the dynamics with generator is done with a standard splitting strategy , decomposing the generator as the sum of @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
the hamiltonian part of the dynamics and the action of the thermostats on both ends of the chain are taken care of by the so - called bbk discretization @xcite of the langevin dynamics : @xmath110 & & \displaystyle + \delta_{i,1 } \left ( -\frac{{\delta t}}{2 } \xi p_1^{m } + \sqrt{\frac{\xi { \delta t}}{2 } \ , t_l } \
g_1^{m } \right ) \\[10pt ] & & \displaystyle + \delta_{i , n } \left ( -\frac{{\delta t}}{2 } \xi p_n^{m } + \sqrt{\frac{\xi { \delta t}}{2 } \ , t_r } \ g_n^{m } \right ) , \\[10pt ] q_i^{m+1 } & = & \displaystyle{q_i^{m } + { \delta t}\ , p_i^{m+1/2 } } , \\ [ 5pt ] p_i^{m+1 } & = & \displaystyle p_i^{m+1/2 } - \frac{{\delta t}}{2 } \nabla_{q_i } \mathcal{h}(q^{m+1 } ) \\ & & \displaystyle + \delta_{i,1 } \left ( -\frac{{\delta t}}{2 } \xi p_1^{m+1 } + \sqrt{\frac{\xi { \delta t}}{2 } \ , t_l } \ g_1^{m } \right ) \\[10pt ] & & \displaystyle + \delta_{i , n } \left ( -\frac{{\delta t}}{2 } \xi p_n^{m+1 } + \sqrt{\frac{\xi { \delta t}}{2 } \ , t_r } \ g_n^{m } \right ) , \\[10pt ] \end{array}\right.\ ] ] where @xmath111 and @xmath112 are kronecker symbols and @xmath113 are independent and identically distributed random gaussian variables of mean 0 and variance 1 .
notice that the last step in the algorithm , written as an implicit update of the momenta , can in fact be rewritten in an explicit manner .
alternatively , one can first integrate the hamiltonian part of the dynamics with the verlet scheme @xcite using a time step @xmath114 , and next analytically integrate the ornstein - uhlenbeck processes on the momenta at both ends of the chain , associated with the generator @xmath115 . in this work , we rather considered algorithm .
we tested two different friction parameters , @xmath116 and @xmath117 , to study how the results depend on the boundary conditions .
the noise term with generator @xmath109 is simulated by exchanging @xmath29 and @xmath118 at exponentially distributed random times , with an average time @xmath119 between two such exchanges .
more precisely , we attach to each spring a random time @xmath120 , with @xmath121 drawn from an exponential law with parameter @xmath0 .
this time is updated as follows : if @xmath122 , then @xmath123 , otherwise @xmath29 and @xmath118 are exchanged and @xmath124 is resampled from an exponential law of parameter @xmath0 .
the initial conditions are chosen by imposing a linear temperature profile .
we used to this end the langevin dynamics of generator @xmath125 , where @xmath47 is given by , and @xmath126 once a linear temperature profile , obtained from the time - average of the local kinetic energy , is indeed obtained , the term @xmath127 is switched off , and replaced by @xmath128 .
the dynamics with generator is then integrated using the numerical scheme described in section [ sec : integration_dynamics ] , and the spatially averaged instantaneous hamiltonian current is monitored . at time @xmath129 , this current is defined as @xmath130 where the instantaneous hamiltonian current @xmath131 is defined as in , upon replacing @xmath132 and @xmath133 by their approximations @xmath134 and @xmath135 .
the thermalization time is somehow loosely defined as the time after which the variations of the instantaneous current stabilize ( see figure [ fig : thermalization ] for an illustration ) .
this time could be determined more carefully by estimating some local - in - time variance of the current , and requiring that this variance stabilizes . ,
@xmath136 , @xmath117 , @xmath137 , @xmath138 .
the thermalization time is @xmath139 .
[ fig : thermalization],width=377 ] once some steady state has been reached , the instantaneous hamiltonian current is computed at each time step , and an approximation of the hamiltonian current is obtained as a time average : @xmath140 in the limit of a large number of iterations @xmath141 and for a small time - step @xmath142 , we have @xmath143 . using the current
, we define the conductivity @xmath144 and the exponent @xmath4 by @xmath145 a priori , the exponent @xmath4 depends on all the parameters of the model : the anharmonicity parameter @xmath42 , the magnitude @xmath46 of the coupling to the end thermostats , the noise strength @xmath0 , and the temperatures @xmath6 and @xmath7 . in our simulations , we have explored how the numerical results ( and in particular the exponent @xmath4 ) depend on the first three parameters , and we have kept @xmath6 and @xmath7 fixed . we wish to point out that the results reported here already required an extremely large cpu time .
indeed , for the largest system considered ( @xmath146 ) , several months were needed to integrate the dynamics with a small enough time step to ensure accuracy ( @xmath137 here ) , on a time @xmath147 long enough such that convergence of the time average is reached ( see section [ sec : variance ] for more details ) .
there are two types of error in the numerical estimation of the currents : a systematic error ( bias ) due to the time step error ( @xmath148 ) , and a statistical error due to the finiteness of the sampling ( @xmath149 ) .
we consider successively these two issues .
the time step should be small enough in order for the dynamics to be numerically stable .
when the size @xmath1 of the system , the noise strength @xmath0 , the anharmonicity @xmath42 or the langevin friction @xmath46 are increased , the time step should be reduced .
indeed , in all these cases , the energy of the system increases ( at least locally ) . due to nonlinearities ,
this energy may concentrate on a few sites , and hence trigger numerical instabilities .
such issues are not encountered with harmonic potentials , where some uniform stability condition is valid . in the case @xmath150 and @xmath151 , most of our computations have been done with @xmath152 .
however , for the largest systems , and for the largest values of @xmath0 , we had to use the smaller value @xmath153 ( otherwise , the simulation blows up due to numerical instabilities , as for @xmath154 and @xmath155 ) . for @xmath150 and @xmath156 , that is a stronger noise at the boundaries thermostats , we also observe that we have to reduce the time step .
we worked with @xmath153 for all values of @xmath1 .
when @xmath42 is increased from @xmath150 to @xmath157 ( with @xmath151 ) , the potential energy becomes stiffer , and we again need to use a smaller time step . in the case @xmath157 and @xmath151 , we worked with @xmath158 for all values of @xmath1 and @xmath0 , except for the large values of @xmath0 and when @xmath159 , for which we used @xmath160 .
let us now describe two artifacts of the numerical results that occur when the time step is too large .
observing them in practice is an indication that the time step is too large and should be reduced . in figure
[ fig : dep_dt ] , we plot the hamiltonian current as a function of the chain length @xmath1 , for @xmath150 , @xmath156 and @xmath155 , for two different time steps .
these currents have been computed as the time averages on simulations long enough . for @xmath152 ,
the current is not monotically decreasing with @xmath1 , which is clearly a numerical artifact .
the simulation blows up for @xmath154 and is stable for @xmath161 , but it is clear that the latter point can not be trusted . , for @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( with @xmath150 , @xmath156 and @xmath155 ) .
[ fig : dep_dt],width=302 ] on figure [ fig : profile ] , we plot the temperature profile , at the end of the simulation ( @xmath162 ) , in the case of a chain of length @xmath161 ( with @xmath150 , @xmath156 and @xmath155 ) . when we use @xmath153 , we obtain a decreasing temperature from the left end to the right end , which is in agreement with what is expected .
when @xmath152 , the results are completely different , and physically unreasonable , which again shows that these results can not be trusted .
, for @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( with @xmath150 , @xmath156 and @xmath155 ) at the end of the simulation .
[ fig : profile],width=302 ] we mentioned earlier than we needed extremely long simulations to obtain a good accuracy .
the reason for that can be well understood from figure [ fig : variance ] , on which we plot the instantaneous hamiltonian current @xmath163 ( defined by ) and its time average as a function of time , for a chain of length @xmath154 ( for the parameters @xmath150 , @xmath156 and @xmath155 ) .
we observe that @xmath163 roughly oscillates between @xmath164 and @xmath165 , whereas its time average is close to @xmath166 .
hence the variability of @xmath163 is extremely large in comparison with its expectation .
we hence need to run a very long simulation to be able to average out most of the fluctuation and obtain @xmath167 with a good accuracy .
these heuristic considerations can be quantified by a simple computation .
the standard deviation of the instantaneous current in figure [ fig : variance ] is of the order of @xmath168 , while the average value of the current is @xmath169 .
in addition , it is possible to estimate the typical correlation time @xmath170 using block averaging ( also called batch means in the statistics literature ) , see @xcite . here , we obtain @xmath171 .
the time @xmath172 required to obtain a 1% relative accuracy on the average current is such that @xmath173 this yields @xmath174 .
since the time step is @xmath175 , this means that a huge number of time steps should be used to reach convergence . for large values of @xmath1 and large values of @xmath0
, we observe that @xmath167 is very small ( see the numerical results below ) .
its accurate computation hence needs an even longer simulation time .
in addition , the cost of the simulation of a chain , on a given time range , linearly increases with the size of the chain .
this explains why computing the average currents for the longest chains is an extremely expensive task .
( for the parameters @xmath150 , @xmath156 and @xmath155 ) .
[ fig : variance],width=302 ] we present the conductivity as a function of the system length in figure [ fig : hamcur ] .
we considered the choices @xmath150 and @xmath157 for @xmath151 to study the influence of the potential energy anharmonicity .
we also simulated the system with @xmath150 and @xmath156 to study how the results depend on @xmath46 .
the total simulation time for each point ranges from @xmath176 to @xmath177 , depending on the size @xmath1 of the system . , defined by , as a function of the system size @xmath1 .
[ fig : hamcur],title="fig:",width=415 ] + , defined by , as a function of the system size @xmath1 .
[ fig : hamcur],title="fig:",width=415 ] + , defined by , as a function of the system size @xmath1 .
[ fig : hamcur],title="fig:",width=415 ] the slope @xmath4 , defined by , is estimated using a least square fit in a log - log diagram .
this estimate is quite sensitive to the choice of the number of points entering the fitting procedure , and only the very first digits of the estimated slope are reliable .
theoretical results ( see @xcite ) show that the exponent @xmath4 is expected to be lower than @xmath178 .
our numerical results , gathered in table [ tab : alpha ] , are in accordance with the theoretical upper bound .
we also observe that , for @xmath155 , the value of @xmath4 is close to @xmath178 .
now recall that , in the harmonic case @xmath179 , the value of @xmath4 is always equal to @xmath178 , independently of @xmath0 .
this seems consistent with the fact that , for large values of @xmath0 , the precise details of the potential @xmath40 do not matter ( the dynamics is mostly governed by the stochastic terms ) , and the behaviour of the system is close to the harmonic behaviour .
.conductivity exponent @xmath4 , estimated from , for different values of @xmath0 and @xmath46 , and different potential energies .
[ tab : alpha ] [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ]
several conclusions can be drawn from the numerical results given in the previous section : a. the ballistic transport , observed in the deterministic toda lattice , which is due to the complete integrability of the system @xcite , is broken by the presence of noise in the dynamics .
energy transport becomes superdiffusive , _
i.e. _ @xmath180 , with @xmath181 . for a low level of noise ( @xmath0 small ) , this superdiffusive regime may be seen only for systems large enough ( @xmath182 or more , depending on the stiffness parameter @xmath42 of the system and the coupling @xmath46 to the boundaries thermostats ) .
the asymptotic regime in @xmath1 for the conductivity is attained for smaller values of @xmath1 when @xmath0 or @xmath46 is larger , or when @xmath42 is smaller .
b. the value of @xmath4 seems to depend on the noise strength @xmath0 in a monotonically increasing way .
if @xmath183 had the same behavior , this would suggest that increasing the noise induces a slower time decay of the current - current correlations , in contradiction with the naive intuition that a stronger noise enhances the decay of time correlations .
we believe that noise tends to suppress scattering effects due to the nonlinearity of the interaction .
observe that , in the harmonic case @xmath179 , the value of @xmath4 is always equal to @xmath178 and in particular does not depend on @xmath0 @xcite .
the dependence of the exponent @xmath4 on the noise strength @xmath0 in the toda case also contradicts general theories about the universality of @xmath4 ( see for instance @xcite ) .
these theories need then to be restricted to more specific dynamics .
f. bonetto , j. l. lebowitz , and l. rey - bellet .
fourier s law : a challenge for theorists . in a.
fokas , a. grigoryan , t. kibble , and b. zegarlinsky , editors , _ mathematical physics 2000 _ , pages 128151 .
imperial college press , 2000 . | we study the thermal conductivity of the one dimensional toda lattice perturbed by a stochastic dynamics preserving energy and momentum .
the strength of the stochastic noise is controlled by a parameter @xmath0 .
we show that heat transport is anomalous , and that the thermal conductivity diverges with the length @xmath1 of the chain according to @xmath2 , with @xmath3 . in particular , the ballistic heat conduction of the unperturbed toda chain is destroyed .
besides , the exponent @xmath4 of the divergence depends on @xmath0 . |
the origin of the extragalactic diffuse mev and gev gamma - ray background ( egrb ) radiation has been argued for a long time in astrophysics , although it is well known that radio quiet active galactic nuclei ( agns ) take account for the cosmic x - ray background ( cxb ) below several hundred kev ( for reviews * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. the egrb spectrum at 0.330 mev is measured by _ smm _
@xcite and comptel on board the compton gamma - ray observatory @xcite . in the gev energy range
, egrb was first discovered by the _
sas_2 satellite @xcite .
egret ( energetic gamma - ray experiment telescope ) on board the compton gamma - ray observatory confirmed the egrb spectrum at 0.03 - 50 gev @xcite .
recently , lat ( large area telescope ) on board the _ fermi _ gamma - ray space telescope ( _ fermi _ ) made a new measurement of the egrb spectrum from 0.2 to 100 gev @xcite .
the observed integrated egrb flux ( @xmath6 mev ) is @xmath7 photons/@xmath8/s / sr with a photon index of 2.41 .
several sources have been suggested to explain the mev background .
one is the nuclear decay gamma - ray from type ia supernovae ( sne ia * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
however , the recent measurement of the cosmic sne ia rate suggests that the expected flux from sne ia is one order of magnitude lower than the measured mev egrb flux @xcite .
comptonization emission from non - thermal electrons in agn coronae is also proposed @xcite .
this model explains the origin of cxb and the mev egrb in the same population .
blazars , which is one type of agns with the direction of a relativistic jet coinciding with our line of sight , are also proposed @xcite .
very recently , @xcite has shown that the gamma - ray emission from lobes of radio galaxies will explain @xmath9% of the mev background flux .
mev mass scale dark matter ( dm ) annihilations has also been discussed @xcite , but there is no natural particle physics candidate for a dark matter with a mass scale of mev energies .
however it is still discussing about the origin of the mev background due to the difficulties of mev gamma - ray measurements . in the case of the gev background , since blazars are dominant extragalactic gamma - ray sources @xcite , it is expected that unresolved population of blazars would explain the gev egrb @xcite .
recently , @xcite showed that unresolved blazars can explain @xmath10% of the egrb above 0.1 gev by analyzing 11-month _ fermi _ agn catalog .
very recently @xcite proposed that the unresolved blazar population would be able to explain the egrb spectrum below 1 gev by taking into account of the energy dependence of source confusion effects .
other gamma - ray emitting extragalactic sources have also been discussed as the origin of the gev egrb .
those are intergalactic shocks produced by the large scale structure formation @xcite , normal and starburst galaxies @xcite , high galactic latitude pulsars @xcite , kilo - parsec ( kpc ) size agn jets @xcite , radio quiet agns @xcite , and gev mass scale dm annihilation or decay ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . here , _
fermi _ has recently detected gev gamma - ray emissions from 11 misaligned agns ( i.e. radio galaxies ) , which are one type of agns with the direction of a relativistic jet _ not _ coinciding with our line of sight @xcite .
their average photon index at 0.1 - 10 gev is @xmath11 which is same as that of gev egrb @xcite and blazars @xcite .
although they are fainter than blazars , the expected number in the entire sky is much more than blazars .
then , it is naturally expected that they will make a significant contribution to egrb .
therefore , in this paper , we study the contribution of such gamma - ray loud radio galaxies ( not blazars ) to egrb .
to study the egrb contribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies , their gamma - ray luminosity function ( glf ) is required . because of limited samples , it is not a straightforward task to construct it using only _ fermi _ samples .
therefore , we first investigate the correlation between radio and gamma - ray luminosities of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies . in the case of blazars ,
the correlation between gamma - ray and radio luminosities have been presented in many papers since egret era @xcite . since the radio luminosity function ( rlf ) of radio galaxies is well studied ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we are able to obtain the glf by converting the rlf to the glf using a luminosity correlation . with that glf , we evaluate their contribution to egrb .
this work is organized as follows .
samples used in this study are shown in .[sec : sam ] . in
.[sec : glf ] , we will investigate the radio and gamma - ray luminosity correlation and determine our glf to reproduce the number of detected gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
the egrb will be calculated and compared with the observed data in
.[sec : egrb ] .
discussion and conclusion will be given in
.[sec : dis ] and .[sec : con ] , respectively . throughout this paper ,
we adopt the standard cosmological parameters of @xmath12 .
_ fermi _ has reported the detection of 11 fanarof - riley ( fr ) radio galaxies including 7 type - i fr ( fri ) galaxies and 4 type - ii fr ( frii ) galaxies by the entire sky survey for 15 months @xcite .
fri galaxies have decelerating jets , knots at kpc distance from the core and edge - darkened lobes , while frii galaxies have relativistic jets and edge - brightened radio lobes with bright hotspots @xcite . in the scheme of the agn jet unification scenario , fri and frii galaxies are the misaligned agn populations of bl lac objects and flat spectrum radio quasars ( fsrqs ) , respectively @xcite . in this study , we use 10 samples ( 6 fris and 4 friis ) from @xcite which were already reported in 11-month _ fermi _ catalog @xcite .
this is because , as discussed in
.[sec : glf ] below , we use the detection efficiency of _ fermi _ shown in @xcite which are constructed from the 11-month catalog .
1 lists the gamma - ray loud radio galaxy samples used in this study .
it gives the object name , the first source catalog ( 1fgl ) _ fermi_-lat source name , redshift , gamma - ray photon flux above 0.1 gev , photon index at 0.1 - 10 gev , radio flux at 5 ghz , spectral index at 5 ghz , radio classification .
the definition of photon index , @xmath13 , and spectral index , @xmath14 , is the index of power - law differential photon spectrum , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 , respectively .
llrrrrrcc[h ] 3c 78/ngc 1218 & 1fglj 0308.3 + 0403 & 0.029 & @xmath17 & @xmath18 & @xmath19 & 0.64 & fri&1 + 3c 84/ngc 1275 & 1fglj 0319.7 + 4130 & 0.018 & @xmath20 & @xmath21 & @xmath22 & 0.78&fri&2 + 3c 111 & 1fglj 0419.0 + 3811 & 0.049 & @xmath23 & @xmath24&@xmath25 & -0.146&frii&3 + pks 0625 - 354 & 1fglj 0627.3 - 3530 & 0.055 & @xmath26 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & 0.53&fri&1 + 3c 207 & 1fglj 0840.8 + 1310 & 0.681 & @xmath29 & @xmath30 & @xmath31 & 0.9&frii&2 + pks 0943 - 76 & 1fglj 0940.2 - 7605 & 0.27 & @xmath32 & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & 0.79&frii&4 + m87/3c 274 & 1fglj 1230.8 + 1223 & 0.004 & @xmath35 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 & 0.79&fri&2 + cen a & 1fglj 1325.6 - 4300 & 0.0009 & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 & 1.2&fri&1 + ngc 6251 & 1fglj 1635.4 + 8228 & 0.024 & @xmath41 & @xmath42 & @xmath43 & 0.72 & fri&2 + 3c 380 & 1fglj 1829.8 + 4845 & 0.0692 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & 0.71 & frii & 2 from table .
1 , the mean photon index of gamma - ray spectra at 0.110 gev , @xmath47 , is 2.39 and the spread is 0.28 .
this index is same as that of blazars , 2.40 @xcite , and the egrb spectrum , 2.41 @xcite . from the individual source studies @xcite ,
the typical gamma - ray seds are well explained by synchrotron - self - compton emission models . here , by taking account of particle cooling effect ,
the electron spectrum is given by @xmath48 at @xmath49 and @xmath50 at @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the cooling break lorentz factor .
the inverse compton ( ic ) photon spectrum is given by @xmath53 where @xmath54 corresponds to the ic photon energy from electrons with @xmath52 @xcite .
the sed fitting for ngc 1275 and m87 show that the ic peak energy in the rest frame locates at @xmath55 mev @xcite . in this study
, we use the mean photon index , @xmath47 , as @xmath13 at 0.110 gev and we set a peak energy , @xmath54 , in photon spectrum at 5 mev for all gamma - ray loud radio galaxies as a baseline model .
then , we are able to define the average sed shape of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies for all luminosities as @xmath56 at @xmath575 mev , and @xmath58 at @xmath595 mev by following equation [ eq : sed ] .
however , only 3 sources are currently studied with multi - wavelength observational data .
we need to make further studies of individual gamma - ray loud radio galaxies to understand their sed properties in wide luminosity ranges .
we examine other spectral models in the section [ subsec : unc ] .
to estimate the egrb contribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies , we need to construct a glf . however , because of a small sample size
, it is difficult to construct a glf using the current gamma - ray data only . here
, the rlf of radio galaxies is extensively studied by previous works ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
if there is a correlation between the radio and gamma - ray luminosities , we are able to convert the rlf to the glf with that correlation . in the case of blazars
, it has been suggested that there is a correlation between radio and gamma - ray luminosity from the egret era @xcite , although it has also been discussed that this correlation can not be firmly established because of flux limited samples @xcite .
recently , using the _ fermi _ samples , @xcite confirmed that there is a correlation between the radio and gamma - ray luminosities . to examine a luminosity correlation in gamma - ray loud radio galaxies ,
we first derive the radio and gamma - ray luminosity of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies as follows .
gamma - ray luminosities between the energies @xmath60 and @xmath61 are calculated by @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the luminosity distance at redshift , @xmath64 , @xmath13 is the photon index and @xmath65 is the observed energy flux between the energies @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
the energy flux is given from the photon flux @xmath66 , which is in the unit of photons/@xmath8/s , above @xmath60 by @xmath67 f_\gamma , \
( \gamma\neq2)\\ s_\gamma(\epsilon_1,\epsilon_2 ) & = & \epsilon_1\ln({\epsilon_2}/{\epsilon_1 } ) f_\gamma,\ \ \ \ \ ( \gamma=2).\end{aligned}\ ] ] radio luminosity is also calculated in the same manner .
figure [ fig : lrlg ] shows the 5 ghz and 0.1 - 10 gev luminosity relation of _ fermi _ gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
square and triangle data represents fri and frii radio galaxies , respectively .
the solid line shows the fitting line to all the data .
the function is given by @xmath68 where errors show 1-@xmath69 uncertainties .
in the case of blazars , the slope of the correlation between @xmath70 , luminosity above 100 mev , and radio luminosity at 20 ghz is @xmath71 @xcite .
the correlation slopes of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies are similar to that of blazars .
this may indicate that emission mechanism is similar in gamma - ray loud radio galaxies and blazars .
we need to examine whether the correlation between the radio and gamma - ray luminosities is true or not . in the flux
limited observations , the luminosities of samples are strongly correlated with redshifts .
this might result in a spurious luminosity correlation . as in previous works on blazar samples
@xcite , we perform a partial correlation analysis to test the correlation between the radio and gamma - ray luminosities excluding the redshift dependence ( see the appendix for details ) .
first , we calculate the spearman rank - order correlation coefficients ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
the correlation coefficient is 0.993 , 0.993 , 0.979 between @xmath72 and @xmath73 , between @xmath72 and redshift , and between @xmath73 and redshift , respectively .
then , the partial correlation coefficient becomes 0.866 with chance probability @xmath74 .
therefore , we conclude that there is a correlation between the radio and gamma - ray luminosities of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies . in this section , we derive the glf of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies , @xmath75 .
there is a correlation between the radio and gamma - ray luminosities as equation [ eq : lrlg ] . with this correlation
, we develop the glf by using the rlf of radio galaxies , @xmath76 , with radio luminosity , @xmath77 .
the glf is given as @xmath78 where @xmath79 is a normalization factor .
we use the 151 mhz rlf @xcite .
since they presented the formula of fri and frii rlfs separately , we combined them as in their paper because it is difficult to analyze each population separately with our limited number of samples . moreover , since the cosmological parameters in @xcite are @xmath80 and @xmath81 , we also convert the rlf to the standard cosmology adopted in this study . the rlf is given by @xmath82,\ ] ] where @xmath83 is the conversion factor of cosmology , @xmath84 is the fri rlf , and @xmath85 is the frii rlf .
the fri rlf and frii rlf are given by @xmath86 @xmath87 here , @xmath88 is the evolution function and given by @xmath89 & z \le z_{\rm ii , c } , \\
\exp\left[-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{z - z_{\rm ii , c}}{z_{\rm ii,2}}\right)\right ] & z > z_{\rm ii , c}. \\ \end{array}\right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the parameters of these rlfs are summarized in table .
[ tb : rlf ] . as in @xcite , the conversion factor of the cosmology @xmath83 is @xmath90 the comoving volume element of cosmology in @xcite is @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the speed of light and @xmath93 is @xmath94 .
that of our standard cosmology is rr[b ] [ h ] @xmath95 & @xmath96 + @xmath97 & 0.586 + @xmath98 & @xmath99 + @xmath100 & 0.710 + @xmath101 & 3.48 + @xmath102 & @xmath103 + @xmath104 & 2.42 + @xmath105 & @xmath106 + @xmath107 & 2.03 + @xmath108 & 0.568 + @xmath109 & 0.956 @xmath110 where @xmath111 is @xmath112 .
since equation [ eq : lrlg ] is for radio luminosities at 5ghz in the unit of erg / s , we assume spectral index @xmath113 for all radio galaxies to convert 151 mhz luminosity to 5ghz luminosity as assumed in @xcite . although @xmath114 would affect the fraction of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies in radio galaxy population , @xmath114 does not affect main results on the egrb calculation in this paper because our glf is normalized to the cumulative source count distribution of the gamma - ray loud radio galaxies detected by _
fermi_. the normalization factor @xmath79 , which corresponds to the fraction of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies against all radio galaxies ,
is determined by the normalizing our glf to the source count distribution of the _ fermi _ radio galaxies , which is sometimes called logn logs plot or cumulative flux distribution .
source count distribution is calculated by @xmath115 where @xmath116 is the gamma - ray luminosity of a blazar at redshift @xmath64 whose photon flux at @xmath117100 mev is @xmath66 .
hereinafter , we assume @xmath118 and @xmath119 in this study .
these assumptions hardly affect the results in this study .
since the completeness of the _ fermi _ sky survey depends on the photon flux and photon index of a source , we need to take into account this effect ( so called the detection efficiency ) to compare glf with the cumulative source count distribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
the detection efficiency of _ fermi _ is shown in figure 7 of @xcite for the sources in the 11-month catalog with test statistics ts@xmath120 , at the galactic latitude @xmath121 , and with a mean photon index of 2.40 , which is similar to that of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies ( see section [ sec : sam ] ) .
it is shown that results for blazar source count distribution analysis did not change even if samples with @xmath122 are included .
furthermore , even if they include samples with ts@xmath123 , the systematic uncertainties are small .
therefore , we adopt the detection efficiency shown in @xcite to our samples from the _ fermi _ 11-month catalog , although not all the samples locates @xmath121 or have ts@xmath120 .
figure [ fig : logn_logs ] shows the source count distribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
the data is after the conversion of the detection efficiency .
solid line shows in the case of @xmath124 which corresponds to the case that all radio galaxies emit gamma - rays . dashed curve corresponds to the glf fitted to the _ fermi _ data with @xmath125 .
@xmath126 gamma - ray loud radio galaxies are expected with 100% complete entire sky survey above the flux threshold @xmath127 above 100 mev .
we note that the current detection efficiency of _ fermi _ at @xmath127 is @xmath128 .
we calculate the egrb spectrum by integrating our glf in the redshift and luminosity space , using the sed model shown in section . [
sec : sam ] .
the egrb spectrum is calculated as @xmath129}{d\epsilon}\times \{1.0 - \omega(f_\gamma[l_\gamma , z])\}\\ & & \times \exp[-\tau_{\gamma,\gamma}(\epsilon , z)],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath130 is the cosmic time and @xmath131 can be calculated by the friedmann equation in the standard cosmology . the minimum gamma - ray luminosity is set at @xmath132 because there is no reported gamma - ray loud radio galaxies below this value .
@xmath133)$ ] is the detection efficiency of _ fermi _ at the photon flux @xmath66 which corresponds to the flux from a source with a gamma - ray luminosity @xmath134 at redshift @xmath64 .
high energy @xmath135-rays ( @xmath13620 gev ) propagating the universe are absorbed by the interaction with the extragalactic background light ( ebl ) , also called as cosmic optical and infrared background , @xcite .
@xmath137 is the optical depth of this background radiation . in this study
, we adopt the model of @xcite for ebl and @xmath138 .
the gamma - ray absorption creates electron positron pairs .
these pairs scatter the cosmic microwave background radiation to make the secondary emission component ( so called cascade emission ) to the absorbed primary emission @xcite .
we take into account the first generation of the cascade emission following the formulations as in @xcite . in the following result ,
the cascade emission cause a small effects on the egrb flux .
hence , the other generations of cascade emission do not have a serious effects on our conclusion in this study .
[ fig : egrb ] shows the @xmath139 egrb spectrum in the unit of @xmath140 predicted by our glfs . the intrinsic ( the spectrum without the ebl absorption effect ) , absorbed , and cascade components of the egrb spectrum and the total egrb spectrum ( absorbed+cascade ) are shown .
the data of heao - i @xcite , _
swift_-bat @xcite , _ smm _
@xcite , comptel @xcite , and _
fermi_-lat @xcite are also shown .
as in the figure , the cascade emission does not contribute to the egrb spectrum significantly .
the expected egrb photon flux above 100 mev from gamma - ray loud radio galaxy populations is @xmath141 . as the unresolved _ fermi _
egrb flux above 100 mev is @xmath142 @xcite , the gamma - ray loud radio galaxies explains @xmath3% of the unresolved egrb flux . for the comparison , recent analysis of _
fermi _ blazars showed that blazars explains @xmath10% of the unresolved egrb @xcite .
therefore , we are able to explain @xmath4% of egrb by radio loud agn populations . to avoid the instrument dependence , we also evaluate the total egrb photon flux ( i.e. resolved + unresolved ) from gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
the contribution to total egrb is @xmath143 and this corresponds to @xmath144% of total _ fermi _ egrb flux which is @xmath145 @xcite .
figure [ fig : egrb ] also shows that gamma - ray loud radio galaxies would also contribute to the mev egrb at @xmath146 mev significantly . although it has been suggested that radio quiet agns @xcite , mev blazars @xcite , mev dm annihilation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , it is still uncertain because of luck of observational evidences .
as shown in this study , gamma - ray loud radio galaxies would also be a candidate for the origin of mev background .
this situation will be solved by future x - ray and mev gamma - ray experiments such as astro - h @xcite and dual gamma - ray mission @xcite , respectively .
we should examine the uncertainties in the model prediction . since the normalization of the glf is determined from 10 samples ,
there is a statistical uncertainty of 32% in its normalization of the egrb at 68 % confidence level .
the correlation of the radio and gamma - ray luminosities also has uncertainties in their slope and normalization as in
.[subsec : lrlg ] . by taking into those uncertainties ,
the fraction of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies in unresolved egrb varies from @xmath9% to @xmath147% .
furthermore , as discussed in @xcite , the energy dependence of source confusion effects would alter the egrb spectrum below @xmath1481 gev .
however , the angular resolution is also depends on the position of the source in the field of view @xcite .
the further careful evaluation is required to discuss the source confusion effects .
since jet is brighter to observers with a smaller viewing angle from the jet axis because of the beaming effect , the fraction of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies @xmath79 would be related with the viewing angle .
it is believed that radio galaxies have bipolar jets @xcite .
the fraction of radio galaxies with the viewing angle @xmath149 is given as @xmath150 .
in this study , the fraction of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies is derived as @xmath151 as discussed in
.[subsec : lognlogs ] .
then , the expected @xmath152 is @xmath153 .
the viewing angle of ngc 1275 , m 87 , and cen a is derived as 25@xmath154 , 10@xmath154 , and 30@xmath154 by sed fitting @xcite , respectively . therefore , our estimation is consistent with the observed results . here ,
beaming factor @xmath155 is defined as @xmath156 , where @xmath13 is the bulk lorentz factor of the jet and @xmath157 . if @xmath158 which is typical for blazars , @xmath155 becomes @xmath1481 with @xmath159 .
this value means no significant beaming effect because the observed luminosity is @xmath160 times brighter than that in the jet rest frame . on the other hand ,
if @xmath161 , @xmath155 becomes greater than 2 with @xmath159 ( i.e. beaming effect becomes important ) .
@xcite proposed the spine and layer jet emission model , in which jet is composed by a slow jet layer and a fast jet spine .
the difference of @xmath13 between blazars and gamma - ray loud radio galaxies would be interpreted with structured jet emission model .
we note that @xmath79 depends on @xmath162 as in sec .
[ subsec : glf ] . by changing @xmath162 by 0.1 ( i.e. to 0.7 or 0.9 ) , @xmath79 and @xmath152 changes a factor of 1.4 and 1.2 , respectively . thus ,
even if we change @xmath114 , beaming effect is not effective with @xmath158 but with lower @xmath13 value , @xmath161 .
as pointed in section [ sec : sam ] , there are uncertainties in sed modeling because of small samples such as photon index ( @xmath13 ) and break photon energy ( @xmath163 ) . in the case of blazars ,
@xcite calculated the blazar egrb spectrum including the distribution of the photon index by assuming gaussian distributions even with @xmath164 samples .
we performed the kolomogorov - smirnov ( k s ) test to see the goodness of the gaussian fit to our sample and check whether the method in @xcite is applicable to our sample .
the chance probability is 12% .
this means that the gaussian distribution does not agree with the data . to investigate the distribution of photon index , more sample would be required .
we evaluate the uncertainties in sed models by using various seds .
figure [ fig : egrb_index ] shows the total egrb spectrum ( absorbed + cascade ) from the gamma - ray loud radio galaxies with various photon index and break energy parameters .
the contribution to the unresolved _ fermi _ egrb photon flux above 100 mev becomes 25.4% , 25.4% , 23.8% for @xmath165 2.39 , 2.11 , and 2.67 , respectively . in the case of @xmath166 , the contribution to the egrb flux above 10 gev becomes significant . for the mev background below 10 mev ,
the position of the break energy and the photon index is crucial to determine the contribution of the gamma - ray loud radio galaxies . as shown in the figure [ fig : egrb_index ] , higher break energy and softer photon index result less contribution to the mev background radiation . to make a further discussion on the sed modeling , the multi - wavelength spectral analysis of all gev observed gamma - ray loud radio galaxies are required .
it is well known that blazars are variable sources in gamma - ray ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
if gamma - ray loud radio galaxies are the misaligned population of blazars , they will also be variable sources .
@xcite has recently reported that ngc 1275 showed a factor of @xmath167 variation of gamma - ray flux .
for other gamma - ray loud radio galaxies , such a significant variation has not observed yet @xcite .
therefore , it is not straightforward to model the variability of radio galaxies currently . in this paper , we used the time - averaged gamma - ray flux of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies in the _ fermi _ catalog , which is the mean of the _ fermi _ 1-year observation .
more observational information ( e.g. frequency ) is required to model the gamma - ray variability of radio galaxies .
further long term _
fermi_observation will be useful and future ground based imaging atmospheric cherenkov telescope , cherenkov telescope array ( cta ) would be a key to understanding short period variabilities .
in this study , we find that the contribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies to the unresolved egrb above 100 mev is @xmath3 % .
@xcite recently showed that unresolved blazars can explain only @xmath10 % of the unresolved egrb by analyzing one year catalog of the _ fermi _ blazars .
therefore , the origin of rest @xmath14853% of egrb is still missing .
various gamma - ray emitting extragalactic sources have also been discussed as the gev egrb origin .
those are intergalactic shocks produced by the large scale structure formation @xcite , galaxies @xcite , high galactic latitude pulsars @xcite , kilo - parsec ( kpc ) size agn jets @xcite , radio quiet agns @xcite , and gev mass scale dm annihilation or decay ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
[ fig : egrb_z ] shows the gamma - ray loud radio galaxy egrb spectra at each redshift bins . because of ebl
, the spectrum above @xmath5 gev shows the absorbed signature . here
, the cosmological sources have their evolution peaks at @xmath168 such as cosmic star formation history and agn activity ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this means that the gamma - rays from extragalactic sources ( e.g. galaxies and agns ) will experience the ebl absorption .
however , as shown in fig .
[ fig : egrb_z ] , _ fermi _ egrb spectrum does not show such an absorbed signature .
this might suggest that nearby gamma - ray emitting sources or sources with very hard gamma - ray spectrum would be the dominant population of egrb above 10 gev . to address this issue
, we should await the egrb information above 100 gev by future observations such as _ fermi_. cta would also be possible to see the egrb at much higher energy band .
we also need to examine the ebl models at high redshift .
it is expected that cta will see blazars up to @xmath169 at very high energy band @xmath5 gev @xcite .
therefore , _ fermi _ and cta will be a key to understanding the origin of egrb .
agn unification scenario explains various properties of agns in terms of viewing angle @xcite . in the scheme of agn
jet unification scenario , fri and frii galaxies are thought as misaligned populations of bl lacs and fsrqs , respectively . from table .
[ tb : sam ] , the mean photon index of fr is and friis are 2.27 and 2.58 , respectively .
therefore , the fri population tends to have harder spectra than the frii population as shown in @xcite .
this trend is also same as that between bl lacs and fsrqs @xcite .
this result would support that fris and friis are the misaligned population of bl lacs and fsrqs .
it is also important to compare the cosmological evolutions of blazars and radio galaxies based on the recent _ fermi _ data .
although a theoretical blazar glf model @xcite is briefly compared with the _ fermi _ egrb result and the cumulative source count distribution of the _ fermi _ blazar data @xcite , comparison in redshift space has not yet been done .
this is because redshifts of about a half of bl lac samples has not yet determined @xcite .
in addition , @xcite treated blazars as one population using blazar sequence @xcite .
blazar glf models which divide fsrqs and bl lacs is required such as @xcite to interpret the unification scenario . since our model in this paper
also does not treat fri and frii separately because of small samples , glf models of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies dividing these two population are also required . therefore , redshift information of all blazars and more data of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies would be required to make a comparison of the cosmological evolutions of blazars and radio galaxies .
in this paper , we studied the contribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies to the egrb by constructing their glf .
first , we explored the correlation between the radio and gamma - ray luminosities of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies which are recently reported by _
fermi _ @xcite .
we found that there is a correlation @xmath170 by a partial correlation analysis , where @xmath134 is the 0.1 - 10 gev gamma - ray luminosity and @xmath0 is the radio luminosity at 5 ghz .
this slope index is similar to that of blazars .
based on this correlation , we defined the glf of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies using the rlf of radio galaxies .
we normalized the glf to fit to the cumulative flux distribution of _ fermi _ samples by using _
_ detection efficiency @xcite .
then , we predicted the contribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies to the mev and gev egrb . the absorption by ebl and the reprocessed cascade emission are also taken into account .
we found that gamma - ray loud radio galaxies will explain @xmath3% of the egrb flux above 100 mev and also make a significant contribution to the 130 mev egrb . since blazars explain @xmath10% of egrb , we are able to explain @xmath4% of egrb by blazars and gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
we also make an interpretation on the origin of the egrb above 10 gev from the point of view of the ebl absorption effect .
since the ebl absorption signature is still not appeared in the egrb spectrum , the origin would be nearby sources or sources with hard gamma - ray spectrum .
we should await the egrb data at higher energy band for this issue .
the author thanks the hospitality of max planck institute for physics at munich where this work took place .
the author also thanks m. hayashida , d. paneque , and h. takami for discussion .
the anonymous referee is thanked for his / her constructive suggestions .
this work was supported by the grant - in - aid for the global coe program `` the next generation of physics , spun from universality and emergence '' and scientific research ( 19047003 , 19740099 ) from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan .
the author also acknowledges support by the research fellowship of the japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) .
129 natexlab#1#1 , a. a. et al .
2009 , , 699 , 817 . 2009 , , 699 , 31 . 2009 , , 707 , 55 . 2010 , , 188 , 405 . 2010 , , 720 , 912 . 2010 , , 719 , 1433 . 2010 , , 722 , 520 . 2010 , physical review letters , 104 , 101101 . 2010 , , 720 , 435 . 2010 , , 715 , 429 , f. a. , coppi , p. s. , & voelk , h. j. 1994 , , 423 , l5 , e. , bertone , g. , merritt , d. , & zhang , p. 2007
, , 76 , 023517 , k. & komatsu , e. 2005 , , 71 , 021303 . 2005 , , 72 , 061301 , k. , komatsu , e. , & hflich , p. 2005
, , 71 , 121301 , m. et al .
2008 , , 689 , 666 . 2009 , , 699 , 603 , s. 2004 , , 354 , 414 . 2009 , , 80 , 023520 , s. & komatsu , e. 2006 , , 73 , 023521 , s. , komatsu , e. , narumoto , t. , & totani , t. 2007 , , 75 , 063519 , w. b. et al .
2009 , , 697 , 1071 , s. a. , heckman , t. m. , bridle , a. , van breugel , w. j. m. , & miley , g. k. 1988 , , 68 , 643 , a. s. 1962 , , 125 , 75 , l. 2000 , reports on progress in physics , 63 , 793 , d. & sreekumar , p. 2009 , research in astronomy and astrophysics , 9 , 509 , d. , sreekumar , p. , & mukherjee , r. 2009 , research in astronomy and astrophysics , 9 , 85 , s. et al .
2010 , arxiv:1006.2102 , e. 1987 , , 146 , 215 , a. m. & hunstead , r. w. 2006 , , 131 , 100 . 2006 , , 131 , 114 , j. o. , feigelson , e. d. , & schreier , e. j. 1983 , , 273 , 128 , j. , fichtel , c. e. , von montigny , c. , nolan , p. l. , & petrosian , v. 1995 , , 452 , 156 , j. & mukherjee , r. 1998 , , 496 , 752 , d. d. & ward , r. a. 1975 , , 198 , 241 , z. g. , zhang , b. , gou , l. j. , mszros , p. , & waxman , e. 2002 , , 580 , l7 , c. d. 2007 , , 659 , 958 , l. & ghisellini , g. 1995 , , 273 , 583 , j. s. & peacock , j. a. 1990 , , 247 , 19 , r. d. , wall , j. v. , shaver , p. a. , goss , w. m. , fosbury , r. a. e. , danziger , i. j. , moorwood , a. f. m. , malin , d. f. , monk , a. s. , & ekers , j. a. 1989 , , 236 , 737 , a. c. & barcons , x. 1992 , , 30 , 429 , b. l. & riley , j. m. 1974 , , 167 , 31p , c. & loeb , a. 2010 , jcap , 1 , 5 , c. e. , simpson , g. a. , & thompson , d. j. 1978 , , 222 , 833 , b. d. , pavlidou , v. , & prodanovi , t. 2010 , , 722 , l199 , j. d. , razzaque , s. , & dermer , c. d. 2010 , , 712 , 238 , g. , maraschi , l. , celotti , a. , comastri , a. , & ghisellini , g. 1998 , , 299 , 433 , a. , rodighiero , g. , & vaccari , m. 2008 , , 487 , 837 , s. & blasi , p. 2003 , astroparticle physics , 19 , 679 , g. , ghisellini , g. , tavecchio , f. , & foschini , l. 2010 , , 407 , 791 , g. , ghisellini , g. , tavecchio , f. , foschini , l. , & bonnoli , g. 2010 , arxiv:1007.2751 , g. , tavecchio , f. , & chiaberge , m. 2005 , , 432 , 401 , r. , comastri , a. , & hasinger , g. 2007 , , 463 , 79 , r. c. , madau , p. , primack , j. r. , somerville , r. s. , & haardt , f. 2009 , , 399 , 1694 , p. , colafrancesco , s. , cavazzuti , e. , perri , m. , & pittori , c. 2006 , , 445 , 843 , d. e. , matteson , j. l. , peterson , l. e. , & jung , g. v. 1999 , , 520 , 124 , r. c. et al . 1999 , , 123 , 79 , g. , miyaji , t. , & schmidt , m. 2005 , , 441 , 417 , a. m. & beacom , j. f. 2006 , , 651 , 142 , s. & ando , s. 2006 , , 74 , 103504 , s. & beacom , j. f. 2010 , , 723 , 329 , y. , inoue , s. , kobayashi , m. a. r. , totani , t. , kataoka , j. , & sato , r. 2011 , , 411 , 464 , y. & totani , t. 2009 , , 702 , 523 . 2011 , , 728 , 73 , y. , totani , t. , & mori , m. 2010 , , 62 , 1005 , y. , totani , t. , & ueda , y. 2008 , , 672 , l5 , p. a. & mcadam , w. b. 1992 , , 80 , 137 , g. , kamionkowski , m. , & griest , k. 1996 , , 267 , 195 , s. c. et al .
1996 , , 120 , c619 + , j. et al .
2010 , , 715 , 554 , m. , kohri , k. , & nakayama , k. 2009 , , 80 , 023517 , m. & stuart , a. 1979 , the advanced theory of statistics .
vol.2 : inference and relationship , ed .
kendall , m. & stuart , a. , u. , waxman , e. , loeb , a. , springel , v. , & hernquist , l. 2003 , , 585 , 128 , t. m. , bretz , t. , mannheim , k. , & hartmann , d. h. 2004 , , 413 , 807 , t. m. & dole , h. 2010 , , 515 , a19 + , t. m. & mannheim , k. 2008 , , 479 , 41 , h. , takahashi , t. , madejski , g. , tashiro , m. , makino , f. , inoue , s. , & takahara , f. 1998 , , 504 , 693 , r. a. , riley , j. m. , & longair , m. s. 1983 , , 204 , 151 , r. & perley , r. 1984 , , 279 , 60 , a. & waxman , e. 2000 , , 405 , 156 , r. , totani , t. , & kobayashi , m. a. r. 2010 , arxiv:1005.1390 , f. & ajello , m. 2011 , arxiv:1102.0774 , d. & raue , m. 2007 , , 471 , 439 , f. 2002 , , 337 , 199 , r. , killeen , n. e. b. , & tadhunter , c. n. 1993 , , 263 , 1023 , a. & pohl , m. 2000 , , 312 , 177 , a. et al .
1997 , , 320 , 33 , r. & chiang , j. 1999 , astroparticle physics , 11 , 213 , k. , asano , k. , & nagataki , s. 2007 , , 671 , 1886 , t. & totani , t. 2006 , , 643 , 81 , t. , totani , t. , & nagashima , m. 2005 , , 633 , l65 , p. 1992
, , 256 , 399 , p. , ghisellini , g. , fabian , a. c. , & celotti , a. 1993 , , 260 , l21 , v. & fields , b. d. 2002 , , 575 , l5 , v. & venters , t. m. 2008 , , 673 , 114 , w. h. , teukolsky , s. a. , vetterling , w. t. , & flannery , b. p. 1992
, numerical recipes in c. the art of scientific computing , ed . press , w. h. , teukolsky , s. a. , vetterling , w. t. , & flannery , b. p. , m. & mazin , d. 2008 , international journal of modern physics d , 17 , 1515 , s. , dermer , c. d. , & finke , j. d. 2009 , , 697 , 483 , s. , mszros , p. , & zhang , b. 2004 , , 613 , 1072 , g. b. & lightman , a. p. 1979
, radiative processes in astrophysics , ed .
rybicki , g. b. & lightman , a. p. , d. j. , subrahmanya , c. r. , patnaik , a. r. , unger , s. w. , cornwell , t. j. , graham , d. a. , & prabhu , t. p. 1986
, , 219 , 545 , m. h. & stecker , f. w. 1994 , , 430 , l21 . 1998 , , 493 , 547 , j. m. , reesman , r. , pavlidou , v. , profumo , s. , & walker , t. p. 2010
, arxiv:1011.5501 , h. , marr , j. , aguilar , l. , & djorgovski , s. 1985 , , 97 , 932 , p. et al .
1998 , , 494 , 523 , . , kneiske , t. m. , & kataoka , j. 2006 , , 637 , 693 , f. w. , malkan , m. a. , & scully , s. t. 2006 , , 648 , 774 , f. w. & salamon , m. h. 1996 , , 464 , 600 , f. w. , salamon , m. h. , & malkan , m. a. 1993 , , 410 , l71 , f. w. & venters , t. m. 2010 , arxiv:1012.3678 , l. e. , beacom , j. f. , walker , t. p. , & zhang , p. 2005 , jcap , 4 , 17 , a. w. , moskalenko , i. v. , & reimer , o. 2004 , , 613 , 956 , t. et al .
2010 , in presented at the society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference , vol . 7732 , society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , d. j. & fichtel , c. e. 1982 , , 109 , 352 , t. a. , quataert , e. , & waxman , e. 2007 , , 654 , 219 , t. & kitayama , t. 2000 , , 545 , 572 , t. & takeuchi , t. t. 2002 , , 570 , 470 , y. , akiyama , m. , ohta , k. , & miyaji , t. 2003 , , 598 , 886 , p. , bergstrm , l. , edsj , j. , & lacey , c. 2002 , , 66 , 123502 , s. w. , booler , r. v. , & pedlar , a. 1984 , , 207 , 679 , c. m. & padovani , p. 1995
, , 107 , 803 , t. m. 2010 , , 710 , 1530 , x. y. , dai , z. g. , & lu , t. 2001 , , 556 , 1010 , k. , hartmann , d. h. , leising , m. d. , & the , l. 1999 , , 516 , 285 , k. , hartmann , d. h. , leising , m. d. , the , l. , share , g. h. , & kinzer , r. l. 1997 , in american institute of physics conference series , vol . 410 , proceedings of the fourth compton symposium , ed . c. d. dermer , m. s. strickman , & j. d. kurfess , 12231227 , c. j. , rawlings , s. , blundell , k. m. , lacy , m. , & eales , s. a. 2001 , , 322 , 536 , a. a. 1996 , , 281 , l9 + , l. , cheng , k. s. , & fan , j. h. 2001 , , 53 , 207
to study the correlation between luminosities at different wavelengths , we use luminosities directly . however , the correlation in luminosity space is distorted by redshift , if samples are flux - limited .
this will result in a spurious correlation .
therefore , we need to test the correlation excluding the redshift dependence .
partial correlation analysis is the analyzing method for such a condition ( see * ? ? ? * for details ) .
the partial correlation analysis method is as follows .
we have parameter sets of @xmath171 , @xmath172 .
let @xmath173 be the rank of @xmath174 among the other @xmath175 s , @xmath176 be the rank of @xmath177 among the other @xmath178 s , and @xmath179 be the rank of @xmath180 among the other @xmath64 s .
the spearman rank - order correlation coefficient between @xmath175 and @xmath178 is defined to be the linear correlation coefficient of the ranks as @xmath181 where @xmath182 and @xmath183 is the mean of the @xmath184 and the @xmath185 , respectively ( see * ? ? ? * for details ) .
the correlation coefficients between @xmath175 and @xmath64 , and @xmath178 and @xmath64 are also given in a same way .
then , the correlation coefficient between @xmath175 and @xmath178 excluding the dependence on the third parameter of @xmath64 is evaluated as @xmath186 where @xmath187 and @xmath188 is the correlation coefficient between @xmath175 and @xmath64 and between @xmath178 and @xmath64 , respectively @xcite . | the _ fermi _ gamma - ray satellite has recently detected gamma - ray emissions from radio galaxy cores . from these samples ,
we first examine the correlation between the luminosities at 5 ghz , @xmath0 , and at 0.1 - 10 gev , @xmath1 , of these gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
we find that the correlation is significant with @xmath2 based on a partial correlation analysis .
using this correlation and the radio luminosity function ( rlf ) of radio galaxies , we further explore the contribution of gamma - ray loud radio galaxies to the unresolved extragalactic gamma - ray background ( egrb ) .
the gamma - ray luminosity function is obtained by normalizing the rlf to reproduce the source count distribution of the _ fermi _ gamma - ray loud radio galaxies .
we find that gamma - ray loud radio galaxies will explain @xmath3% of the unresolved _ fermi _ egrb flux above 100 mev and will also make a significant contribution to the egrb in the 1 - 30 mev energy band . since blazars explain 22% of the egrb above 100 mev , radio loud active galactic nuclei ( agns ) populations explain @xmath4% of the unresolved egrb .
we further make an interpretation on the origin of the egrb .
the observed egrb spectrum at 0.2 - 100 gev does not show an absorption signature by the extragalactic background light .
thus , the dominant population of the origin of egrb at very high energy ( @xmath5gev ) might be nearby gamma - ray emitting sources or sources with very hard gamma - ray spectrum . |
nearly everyone has tried to throw a stone on a lake and count the number of bounces the stone was able to make .
of course the more , the better.@xcite our intuition gives us some empirical rules for the best throw : the best stones are flat and rather circular ; one has to throw them rather fast and with a small angle with the water surface ; a small kick is given with a finger to give the stone a spin . of course these rules can be understood using the laws of physics : the crucial part of the motion is the collisional process of the stone with the water surface . the water surface exerts a reaction ( lift ) force on the stone , allowing it to rebound .
this process is quite complex because it involves the description of the flow around the immersed stone.@xcite some energy is also dissipated during a collision , so that after a few rebounds , the initial kinetic energy of the stone is fully dissipated and the stone sinks .
the purpose of this paper is to propose a simplified description of the bouncing process of a stone on water , in order to estimate the maximum number of bounces performed by the stone .
this problem provides an entertaining exercise for undergraduate students , with simple explanations for empirical laws that almost everyone has experienced .
consider a flat stone , with a small thickness and a mass @xmath0 .
the stone is thrown over a flat water surface .
the angle between the stone surface and the water plane is @xmath1 . a schematic view of the collisional process is shown in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] .
the velocity @xmath2 is assumed to lie in a symmetry plane of the stone ( the plane of the paper ) .
the difficult part of the problem is , of course , to model the reaction force due to the water , which results from the flow around the stone during the stone - water contact .
it is not the aim of this paper to give a detailed description of the fluid flow around the colliding stone .
rather i shall use a simplified description of the force keeping only the main ingredients of the problem .
first , the velocity @xmath2 of the stone is expected to be ( at least initially ) the order of a few meters per second . for a stone with a characteristic size @xmath3 of the order of a few centimeters , the reynolds number , defined as @xmath4 , with @xmath5 the kinematic viscosity ( @xmath6 for water ) , is of order @xmath7 , that is , much larger than unity.@xcite in this ( inertial ) regime ,
the force due to the water on the stone is expected on dimensional grounds to be quadratic in the velocity and proportional to the apparent surface of the moving object and the mass density of the fluid.@xcite because the stone is only partially immersed in water during the collisional process , we expect the force to be proportional to the immersed surface ( see fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] ) .
the force can be adequately decomposed into a component along the direction of the stone ( that is , along @xmath8 , see fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] ) and a component perpendicular to it ( that is , along @xmath9 ) .
the latter corresponds to the lift component of the force , and the former corresponds to a friction component ( of water along the object ) .
i write the reaction force due to water , @xmath10 , as : @xmath11 where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the lift and friction coefficients , @xmath14 is the mass density of water , @xmath15 is the area of the immersed surface , and @xmath9 is the unit vector normal to the stone ( see fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) . note that in general , both @xmath12 and @xmath13 are functions of the tilt angle @xmath1 and incidence angle @xmath16 , defined as the angle between velocity @xmath2 and the horizontal . in the simplified analysis
i will assume that both @xmath12 and @xmath13 are constant and independent of tilt and incidence angles.@xcite this assumption is not a strong one because ricochets are generally performed with a small tilt angle , @xmath1 , and a small incidence angle , @xmath16 .
if one denotes the initial components of the incident velocity by @xmath17 and @xmath18 ( parallel and perpendicular to the water surface , respectively ) , the latter assumption amounts to @xmath19 .
we expect the lift force to be maximum when the object is only partially immersed due to the lack of symmetry between the two sides of the stone
. therefore , if the object reaches a depth such that it becomes completely immersed , the lift force would be greatly diminished and would probably not be able to sustain the weight of the stone anymore . for simplicity
, i will assume that the lift force vanishes for completely immersed objects .
the model for the force in eq .
( [ force ] ) is crude , but it is expected to capture the main physical ingredients of the stone - water interaction . it might fail for lower stone velocities or larger incidence angles , where a bulge of water could be created and affect the lift and friction forces on the stone.@xcite however , in this case it is expected that the stone will be strongly destabilized during the collision process and perform only a very small number of bounces .
we will restrict ourselves to large initial velocities and small incidence angles , such that the number of bounces is sufficiently large .
consider the collisional process , that is , the time during which the stone is partially immersed in water .
i will assume in this section that the incidence angle @xmath1 between the stone and the water surface is constant during the collisional process .
the validity of this assumption is considered in detail in sec .
the origin of time , @xmath20 , corresponds to the instant when the edge of the stone reaches the water surface . during the collisional process ,
the equations of motion for the center of mass velocity are [ eom ] @xmath21 with @xmath22 and @xmath23 is the acceleration due to gravity .
note that in eq .
( [ eom ] ) the area @xmath15 depends on the immersed depth and thus varies during the collisional process . equation ( [ eom ] ) is non - linear due to the @xmath24 terms on the right - hand side , but also due to the dependence of the immersed area , @xmath15 , on the height @xmath25 .
however , we can propose a simple approximation scheme : the magnitude of the velocity , @xmath2 , is not expected to be strongly affected by the collision process ( as i shall show in sec . [ bounces ] ) .
i thus make the approximation that @xmath26 on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eom ] ) .
the validity of this assumption requires a sufficiently high initial velocity , @xmath17 , and it might fail in the last few rebounds of a stone skip sequence . with this approximation , eq .
( [ comz ] ) decouples from eq .
( [ comx ] ) .
i thus first focus the discussion on the equation for the height @xmath25 , which is the height of the immersed edge ( see fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) . note that the equation for @xmath25 is equivalent to the equation of the center of mass position , eq .
( [ comz ] ) because @xmath1 is assumed to be constant ( see sec .
[ spin ] for a detailed discussion of this point ) .
hence , we may identify @xmath27 with @xmath28 and eq .
( [ comz ] ) yields a closed equation for the height @xmath25 .
to solve eq .
( [ comz ] ) we need to prescribe the @xmath25 dependence of the immersed area @xmath15 .
this quantity depends on the precise shape of the stone .
a natural choice is circular , which i will treat in sec .
[ sec : circle ] .
however , it is enlighting to first consider a square shape ; this shape greatly simplifies the mathematics and already contains the basic mechanisms involved . in this case , the immersed area is simply @xmath29 ( see fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) , with @xmath3 the length of one edge of the stone .
the equation for @xmath25 thus becomes @xmath30 where @xmath31 , and i have used @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) .
we define the characteristic frequency @xmath34 as @xmath35 and rewrite eq .
( [ eq_z_square ] ) as @xmath36 with the initial conditions at @xmath20 ( first contact with water ) , @xmath37 and @xmath38 , the solution of eq .
( [ zequ ] ) is @xmath39 equation ( [ sol_z ] ) characterizes the collisional process of the stone with water . after a collision time
@xmath40 defined by the condition @xmath41 ( @xmath42 ) , the stone emerges totally from the water surface .
it is easy to show that the maximal depth attained by the stone during the collision is @xmath43 .
\label{zmax}\ ] ] as discussed in sec .
[ sec1 ] , the stone will rebound if it stays only partially immersed during the collision .
the rebound condition can be written as @xmath44 .
if we use eqs .
( [ zmax ] ) and ( [ def_omega0 ] ) , this condition can be written after some straightforward calculations as @xmath45 where the incidence angle @xmath16 is defined as @xmath46 .
therefore , we obtain a _ minimum critical velocity _ for skimming . using the typical values , @xmath47 kg , @xmath48 m , @xmath49 , @xmath50kgm@xmath51 , and @xmath52
, we obtain @xmath53ms@xmath54 .
the physical meaning of this condition is clear : it simply expresses the fact that the lift force @xmath55 has to balance the weight of the stone @xmath56 in order for it to bounce . for a circular stone ,
the immersed area is a more complex function of the height @xmath25 , and is given in terms of the area of a truncated circle . a simple integral calculation yields @xmath57\,,\ ] ] with @xmath58 ( the maximum immersed length ) and @xmath59 as the radius of the stone . the equation of motion for @xmath25 , eq .
( [ comz ] ) , thus becomes non - linear .
however , it is possible to describe ( at least qualitatively ) the collisional process and obtain the condition for the stone to bounce .
i first introduce dimensionless variables to simplify the calculations .
the dimensionless height , @xmath60 , time , @xmath61 , and immersed area , @xmath62 , are defined as @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 .
( the minus sign in @xmath60 is introduced for convenience . )
if we use these variables , eq .
( [ comz ] ) , and @xmath66 , we obtain @xmath67 with @xmath68 .
equation ( [ eom_circle ] ) is the equation of a particle ( with unit mass ) in the potential @xmath69 .
we can use standard techniques for mechanical systems to solve eq .
( [ eom_circle ] ) .
in particular , eq .
( [ eom_circle ] ) can be integrated once to give the constant energy " condition @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the energy of the system and is given in terms of the initial conditions @xmath72 the potential @xmath73 can be calculated analytically using the expression for the immersed area @xmath15 given in eq .
( [ sim ] ) .
an integral calculation gives @xmath74 \nonumber \\ & & -(1-{\tilde{z } } ) { { \arccos}}(1-{\tilde{z}})\biggr)-\alpha{\tilde{z}}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this potential is plotted in fig .
[ fig : potential ] as a function of @xmath60 . as a consequence of the constant energy condition , eq .
( [ energy ] ) , @xmath60 exhibits a turning point at a maximum depth defined by @xmath75 . here
again , the condition for the stone to bounce is that this maximum depth be reached before the stone is fully immersed , that is , @xmath76 . in terms of dimensionless variables , we obtain the condition : @xmath77 , with @xmath78 defined by @xmath79
. this condition can be explicitly solved .
let me introduce @xmath80 such that @xmath81 at @xmath82 : @xmath73 is a monotonically increasing function of @xmath60 for @xmath83 .
now it is easy to show that @xmath84 ( because @xmath85 and @xmath86 ) , and the condition @xmath87 is therefore equivalent to @xmath88 , that is , @xmath89 .
then the condition for skimming can be rewritten ( recalling that @xmath90 ) @xmath91 up to ( slightly different ) numerical factors this condition is the same as in eq .
( [ condition_vx_square ] ) for a square stone .
note moreover , that the reasoning used for the potential @xmath92 is quite general and can be applied to the square shape as well .
this reasoning yields the same condition as eq .
( [ condition_vx_square ] ) in this case .
note also that for the circular stone , a simplified analysis of the motion could have been performed .
first if @xmath60 remains small during the bounce of the stone , a small @xmath60 expansion of @xmath73 is possible , yielding @xmath93 ( corresponding to a parabolic approximation for the shape of the stone near its edge ) .
moreover , we remark that for small @xmath18 , the energy @xmath71 goes to zero , so that @xmath78 is defined in this case by @xmath94 .
if also use the previous approximation , we obtain @xmath95 .
the condition for the stone to bounce , @xmath87 , therefore yields @xmath96 . in terms of @xmath17
, this condition gives again a minimum critical velocity for skimming , defined as @xmath97 with @xmath98 .
this result is thus close to the
exact " condition found in eq .
( [ condition_vx_circle ] ) for the @xmath99 case .
i have so far described the rebound of the stone by analyzing its vertical motion .
this analysis gave a minimum velocity for skimming which results from the balance between the weight of the stone and the lift of the force due to water .
however , some energy is dissipated during the collision due to the friction " contribution of the force ( the component along @xmath100 ) .
this mechanism of dissipation leads to another minimum velocity condition , in terms of the balance between dissipation and initial kinetic energy .
only a qualitative description of the dissipation is given here .
as shown by eq .
( [ eom ] ) , the component @xmath101 of the reaction force in the @xmath100 direction ( parallel to the water surface ) will decrease the velocity of the stone . then after a few bounces , the condition for the stone to bounce , eq .
( [ condition_vx_square ] ) or eq .
( [ condition_vx_circle ] ) , will no longer be satisfied and the stone will stop .
it is possible to estimate the decrease in the @xmath100-component of the velocity using the equation for the center of mass position , eq .
( [ comx ] ) . if we multiply both sides of eq .
( [ comx ] ) by @xmath102 and integrate over a collision time , we obtain the decrease in the kinetic energy in the @xmath100 direction in terms of the work of the reaction force : @xmath103 where @xmath17 and @xmath104 are the @xmath100-components of the velocity before and after the collision , @xmath40 is the collision time , and @xmath105 is the @xmath100-component of the reaction force , with @xmath106 . a rough estimate of the right - hand side of eq . ( [ deltav2 ] ) is @xmath107 now we have the simple relation @xmath108 , with @xmath109 ( see eq .
( [ force ] ) ) .
moreover , it is expected that the average vertical force during a collision , @xmath110 , is the order of the weight of the stone , @xmath56 .
this point can be explicitly verified for the square stone case , using the expression of the force @xmath111 in terms of the height @xmath112 and eq .
( [ sol_z ] ) .
the final result is @xmath113.@xcite .
moreover , as shown in the above ( and in particular for the square stone , although the results remain qualitatively valid for the circular one ) , the collision time is given approximatively by @xmath114 .
we eventually find that the loss in kinetic energy in eq .
( [ deltav2 ] ) is approximatively given by @xmath115 where @xmath116 is defined as @xmath117 the quantity @xmath118 is the distance along @xmath100 traversed by the stone during a collision .
if the energy loss @xmath119 is larger than the initial kinetic energy , the stone would be stopped during the collision .
using eq .
( [ deltav2 ] ) , this condition can be written explicitly as @xmath120 .
we deduce that the initial velocity should be larger than the minimum velocity @xmath121 in order to perform at least one bounce , that is , @xmath122 if we use the same numerical values as in the previous paragraph , we obtain @xmath123 , @xmath124 cm , so that @xmath125ms@xmath54 .
this criterion is more restrictive than the previous one , eq .
( [ condition_vx_circle ] ) .
i thus consider in the following that eq .
( [ min_dissip ] ) is the criterion for the stone to skim over water .
the previous calculations assumed a constant angle @xmath1 . it is obvious that the rebound of the stone is optimized when @xmath1 is small and positive ( see , for example , the value of the force constant @xmath126 which decreases when @xmath1 increases ) .
now , if after a collision , the stone is put in rotation around the @xmath127-axis ( see fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) , that is , @xmath128 , its orientation would change by an appreciable amount during free flight : the incidence angle @xmath1 for the next collision has little chance to still be in a favorable situation .
the stone performs , say , at most one or two more collisions .
there is therefore a need for a stabilizing angular motion .
this is the role of the spin of the stone .
let us denote @xmath129 as the rotational velocity of the stone around the symmetry axis parallel to @xmath9 in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] .
i neglect in the following any frictional torque on the stone ( associated with rotational motion ) . during the collision ,
the reaction force due to the water is applied only to the immersed part of the stone and results in a torque applied on the stone . for simplicity ,
i consider only the lift part of the force .
its contribution to the torque ( calculated at the center @xmath130 of the stone ) can be readily calculated as @xmath131 , where @xmath132 is the unit vector in the @xmath127 direction in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] and @xmath133 , the point of application of the lift force , is located at the center of mass of the immersed area .
this torque is in the @xmath127 direction and will eventually affect the angular motion along @xmath1 .
however a spin motion around @xmath9 induces a stabilizing torque : this is the well - known gyroscopic effect.@xcite the derivation of the equation of motion of the rotating object ( the euler equations ) is a classic problem and is treated in standard mechanics textbooks ( see for example , ref . ) . on the basis of these equations ,
it is possible to derive the stabilizing gyroscopic effect .
this derivation is briefly summarized in the appendix . in our case
, the equation for the angle @xmath1 can be written as @xmath134 where @xmath135\dot \phi_0 $ ] , @xmath136 is the initial spin angular velocity ( in the @xmath9 direction ) , and @xmath137 and @xmath138 are moments of inertia in the @xmath9 and @xmath8 directions , respectively ; @xmath139 is the initial tilt angle and @xmath140 is the projection of the torque due to the water flow in the @xmath127 direction .
equation ( [ momentum ] ) shows that in the absence of spin motion , @xmath141 , the torque due to the lift force will initiate rotational motion of the stone in the @xmath1 direction . as discussed above
, the corresponding situation is unstable .
on the other hand , spin motion induces a stabilizing torque that can maintain @xmath1 around its initial value .
the effect of the torque can be neglected if , after a collision with the water , the maximum amplitude of the motion of the angle @xmath1 is small : @xmath142_{\rm max } \ll 1 $ ] .
if we use eq .
( [ momentum ] ) , an estimate of @xmath143 can be obtained by balancing the last two terms in eq .
( [ momentum ] ) , yielding @xmath144 ( note that up to numerical factors ( @xmath145 and @xmath146 , with @xmath147 the radius of the stone ) .
the order of magnitude of @xmath148 can be obtained using the results of sec .
[ dissip ] .
the average vertical force acting on the stone has been found to be the order of the weight of the stone ( see the discussion after eq .
( [ approx ] ) ) : @xmath149 .
if we take @xmath150 , we obtain the simple result @xmath151 .
the estimate for @xmath152 follows directly as @xmath153 .
therefore , the condition for @xmath1 to remain approximately constant , @xmath154 , is @xmath155 for a stone with a diameter of 10 cm , eq .
( [ spin_condition ] ) gives @xmath156s@xmath54 , corresponding to a rotational frequency larger than a few revolutions per second ( @xmath157hz ) .
this condition is easily fullfilled in practice and corresponds approximately to what we would expect intuitively for a successful throw .
note that the condition ( [ spin_condition ] ) is independent of the center of mass velocity of the stone @xmath2 .
the estimation of the maximum number of bounces is the most difficult and tentative part of the analysis because many factors can in principle slow down or destabilize the stone , some of which are extremely difficult to model ( such as irregularities of the water surface and the wind ) .
we shall assume the idealized situation described above ( perfect surface , no wind , idealized reaction force ) and focus on two specific factors , which appear , at least intuitively , as natural candidates for stopping the stone . as i have discussed in sec .
[ dissip ] , energy is dissipated during a collision and the @xmath100 component of the velocity of the stone will decrease during each collision : after a few collisions , all the initial kinetic energy will be dissipated .
this process can be easily formulated .
i consider a succession of @xmath158 collisions . between two collisions ,
the motion is parabolic ( wind and air friction are neglected ) and the initial @xmath100 component of the velocity at the next collision is equal to the final @xmath100 component of the velocity at the end of the previous collision .
the important point to note is that the energy loss during one collision , eq .
( [ calcul_w ] ) , is independent of the velocity @xmath17 before the collision .
therefore , the velocity of the stone after @xmath158 collisions obeys the relation @xmath159-{1\over 2 } m v_{x}^2[0 ] = -n \mu mg \ell \ , , \label{ncolls}\ ] ] so that the stone will be stopped at a collision number @xmath160 such that the total energy loss is larger than the initial kinetic energy ( similar to the argument leading to the critical velocity for skimming , @xmath121 , in eq .
( [ min_dissip ] ) ) .
this criterion corresponds to @xmath161=0 $ ] in eq .
( [ ncolls ] ) , and @xmath160 is given accordingly by @xmath162 \over 2 g { \mu } \ell}\ , .
\label{number_of_collisions}\ ] ] if we use the same typical values as before ( @xmath47 kg , @xmath163 m , @xmath164 , @xmath50m@xmath51 , @xmath52 , we obtain @xmath165 and @xmath166 cm .
we then find @xmath167 for the initial velocity @xmath168ms@xmath54 , @xmath169 for @xmath170 ms@xmath54 , and @xmath171 for @xmath172ms@xmath54 .
the latter number of bounces corresponds to the world record.@xcite it is interesting to calculate the distance between two successive collisions . as noted ,
the motion of the stone is parabolic out of the water : the position \{@xmath173 } of the particle is given by @xmath174 , @xmath175 .
the next collision will occur at a distance @xmath176 .
the dependence of @xmath102 on the number of collisions @xmath158 is given by eq .
( [ ncolls ] ) . on the other hand , @xmath27 does not depend on the number of collisions because the stone rebounds elastically " in the @xmath25 direction , as follows from the analysis of the collisional process in sec .
[ collision ] ( see , for example , the conservation of the energy @xmath71 during the collision discussed for the circular stone ) . if we use eq .
( [ ncolls ] ) , we obtain the simple result @xmath177=\delta x_0 \sqrt{1-{n\over n_c}}\ , , \label{deltax}\ ] ] where @xmath178 .
note that @xmath179 is approximately equal to the distance between the two first ricochets , @xmath180 $ ] , when @xmath181 . for @xmath170ms@xmath54
, we obtain @xmath182 m. equation ( [ deltax ] ) for @xmath183 $ ] is plotted in fig .
[ fig : deltax ] .
we remark that the decrease in the distance between two successive ricochets is first rather slow ( @xmath184\simeq \delta x_0 ( 1-{n\over 2 n_c})$ ] for @xmath185 , see eq .
( [ deltax ] ) ) , but strongly accelerates for the last collisions when @xmath186 , due to the square root variation of @xmath183 $ ] close to @xmath160 .
this result is in agreement with observation .
such an effect is known to specialists of stone - skipping as `` pitty - pat.''@xcite however , there is another possible destabilizing mechanism in the collision process . as was discussed in sec .
[ spin ] , the rotational stability of the stone is crucial in the collisional process .
a criterion for stability has been found in the form of a minimum spin velocity of the stone .
however , each collision will perturb the rotational motion and the sum of all these effects can eventually bypass the stability condition .
this argument can be easily formulated . as shown above
, the amplitude of the angular motion of @xmath1 is @xmath153 , with @xmath187 , the ( constant ) spin velocity of the stone .
now assume that the destabilizing effects add , a reasonable assumption .
then , after @xmath158 collisions we expect that @xmath188 .
the stone is completely destabilized for a collision number @xmath160 such that @xmath189 , yielding @xmath190 if we use the same numerical values as before , we obtain , for example , @xmath191 for a initial spin velocity @xmath192rev / s and @xmath193 ( the world record@xcite ) for @xmath194rev / s .
note , however , that there is a quite large uncertainty of the numerical prefactors in the above estimate of @xmath160 , and this estimate is merely qualitative and should not be taken literally .
at the level of our description , the maximum number of bounces results from the combination of the two previous mechanisms : slow down and angular destabilization .
the maximum number of bounces is therefore given by the _ minimum _ of the two previous estimates , in eqs .
( [ number_of_collisions ] ) and ( [ nc_omega ] ) . the estimate @xmath195 obtained in eq .
( [ number_of_collisions ] ) from the slow down of the stone depends only ( quadratically ) on the initial velocity of the stone : in principle , a very large number of bounces could be reached by increasing the initial velocity of the stone .
but on the other hand , the angular destabilization process results in a maximum value of @xmath196 which is independent of the initial velocity of the stone , as indicated by eq .
( [ nc_omega ] ) .
this shows that even if the initial velocity of the stone is very large , that is , @xmath197 , the stone will be stopped by angular destabilization after @xmath196 bounces . in other words ,
the initial kick " that puts the stone in rotational motion is a key factor for a good throw .
the results presented here are in agreement with our intuition for the conditions of a good throw .
some of the results are also in agreement with observations , for example , the acceleration of the number of collisions at the end of the throw ( a phenomenon known as pitty - pat " in stone skipping competitions @xcite ) .
some easy checks of the assumptions underlying our calculations could be performed , even without any sophisticated apparatus .
for example , taking pictures of the water surface after the ricochets would locate the positions of the collisions ( because small waves are produced at the surface of water ) . a simple test of the variation of the distance between two collisions as a function of collision number , eq .
( [ deltax ] ) , would then be possible .
a more ambitious project would be to design a `` catapult , '' allowing one to throw stones with a controlled translational and spin velocity ( together with the incidence angle of the stone on water ) .
a measurement of the maximum number of bounces performed for various throw parameters would allow us to check the assumptions underlying the present simple analysis and to determine some of the parameters involved in the description ( such as @xmath198 and @xmath116 ) .
it would be also interesting to repeat the experiments reported in ref .
using modern techniques ( such as fast cameras ) , in order to image and analyze in particular the rebound process as a function of the throw parameters .
hopefully a better understanding of the mechanisms of stone skipping will allow someone to break the actual world record !
i thank my son lonard for his ( numerous and always renewed ) perplexing questions .
i thank my colleagues from the physics laboratory of the ens lyon , and in particular bernard castaing and thierry dauxois , for their constant interest in discussing
simple " physics problems .
i am grateful to the referee for pointing out refs . and to me .
i briefly recall the derivation of eq .
( [ momentum ] ) , from the euler equations described in ref .
the latter are written as:@xcite in eq .
( [ euler ] ) , @xmath200 , @xmath201 , and @xmath202 ( @xmath203 ) are respectively the moment of inertia , angular velocity , and torque along the direction of a particular principal axis , denoted as @xmath204 . in our case ,
the direction 1 is taken along the axis perpendicular to the vectors @xmath9 and @xmath8 ( the direction 1 is along the @xmath127 axis in fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) , the direction 2 along @xmath9 and the direction 3 along @xmath8 .
we therefore have @xmath205 , and due to the symmetry of the circular stone , @xmath206 and @xmath207 .
moreover , because only the lift component of the reaction force ( along @xmath9 ) is considered in the present analysis , we have @xmath208 and @xmath209 . equation ( [ euler.b ] ) yields immediately that @xmath210
. we therefore have @xmath211 , with @xmath136 the initial spin velocity .
equation ( [ euler.c ] ) can be therefore written as : @xmath212 if we use @xmath205 , eq .
( [ thiseq ] ) can be integrated once to give @xmath213 with @xmath214 , the initial tilt angle .
the substitution of eq .
( [ a3 ] ) into eq .
( [ euler.a ] ) leads to eq .
( [ momentum ] ) .
note that the nontrivial point is to assume that @xmath12 does not vanish and reaches a finite value in the small @xmath1 and @xmath16 limit .
we may invoke the finite aspect ratio ( thickness over lateral size ) of the object .
for example , if the stone is an ellipsoid of revolution with thickness @xmath215 and radius @xmath3 , with @xmath216 , we expect @xmath217.@xcite however the proportionality constant is expected to be sufficiently large so that the lift effect is non - negligible .
this property is exemplified by water skiing . in this case , the lift force is sufficiently large to sustain the weight of a skier on small boards , while both tilt and incidence angles are close to zero .
it is amusing to note that the laws of friction for the stone are similar to those of solid friction .
we have indeed @xmath218 , with @xmath109 , independent of the velocity and surface of the stone .
of course , the same result holds for water skiing , which is not obvious . | the motion of a stone skimming over a water surface is considered .
a simplified description of the collisional process of the stone with water is proposed .
the maximum number of bounces is estimated by considering both the slowing down of the stone and its angular stability .
the conditions for a successful throw are discussed . |
with the possibility of solving precisely few - nucleon equations and the availability of high precision nucleon - nucleon potentials it is tempting to ask very detailed questions about the properties of light nuclei .
spin dependent momentum distributions of nuclear clusters inside light nuclei have been studied at many places , see for instance @xcite .
especially the @xmath3he nucleus is interesting .
the availability of highly polarized @xmath3he allows one to perform very detailed electron scattering experiments , which , due to the recent progress in the calculations of three - nucleon ( 3n ) bound and scattering states , can be analyzed very precisely .
this makes it tempting to extract information on its properties . in a recent paper
@xcite we addressed the question whether momentum distributions of polarized proton - deuteron ( pd ) clusters in polarized @xmath3he could be accessed through the @xmath5 or @xmath6 processes .
final state interactions ( fsi ) and meson exchange currents ( mec ) turned out to destroy the clear picture offered by the plane wave impulse approximation ( pwia ) and the assumption of the single nucleon current operator .
this we found for most of the cases studied in the kinematical regime below the pion production threshold . only for small relative pd momenta
direct access to the sought @xmath3he properties appeared possible .
the @xmath5 or @xmath6 experiments would require , however , measuring the polarizations of the outgoing particles , which is very demanding .
in this paper we would like to investigate theoretically two processes , @xmath0 and @xmath1 , measured recently at mami @xcite and show that under the same pwia assumption they provide equivalent information about @xmath3he properties .
we remind the reader of our formalism in sec .
[ sec:2 ] .
section [ sec:3 ] shows our results for the exclusive proton - deuteron breakup of @xmath3he and sec .
[ sec:4 ] deals with different aspects of the semi - exclusive @xmath1 reaction .
we end with a brief summary in sec .
[ sec:5 ] .
the spin dependent momentum distributions of proton - deuteron clusters inside the @xmath3he nucleus are defined as : @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the proton momentum ( the deuteron momentum is @xmath9 ) ; @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath12 are spin magnetic quantum numbers for the proton , deuteron and @xmath3he , respectively .
these quantities can be written as @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the overlap of the deuteron state and the @xmath3he state calculated in momentum space @xcite @xmath15 here @xmath16 are the partial wave projected wave function components of @xmath3he and @xmath17 are the s- and d - wave components of the deuteron .
the set @xmath18 contributes only for the deuteron quantum numbers @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
further @xmath22 for @xmath23 and @xmath24 for @xmath25 .
it is clear that using this quantity @xmath14 the spin dependent momentum distribution @xmath26 can be constructed for any combination of magnetic quantum numbers and any direction @xmath27 .
in @xcite we also showed that under the pwia treatment and in the non - relativistic limit there are simple relations between different @xmath28 s and the response functions @xmath29 , which enter the laboratory cross section for the process @xmath30 .
this cross section has the form @xcite @xmath31 where @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 are analytically given kinematical factors , @xmath35 is the helicity of the incoming electron and @xmath36 represents the initial @xmath3he spin direction .
this means that both the cross section and the helicity asymmetry @xmath37 @xmath38 for the @xmath0 process can be obtained , assuming pwia , in terms of @xmath39 , the electromagnetic proton form factors @xmath40 and @xmath41 , and simple kinematical quantities .
the response functions read @xmath42 @xmath43 @xmath44 @xmath45 @xmath46 @xmath47 the auxiliary quantities
@xmath48 , @xmath49 , @xmath50@xmath51 , which appear in the helicity - dependent response functions @xmath52 and @xmath53 in eqs .
( [ wtp ] ) and ( [ wtplp ] ) are @xmath54 @xmath55 @xmath56 @xmath57 @xmath58 @xmath59 we assume the reference frame , for which the three - momentum transfer @xmath60 is parallel to @xmath61 and @xmath62 , as well as @xmath63 . here
@xmath64 and @xmath65 are the initial and final electron momenta . in this system
@xmath66 and @xmath67 are the polar and azimuthal angles corresponding to the direction of the final proton - deuteron relative momentum @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 are the polar and azimuthal angles corresponding to the direction of @xmath71 .
the initial @xmath3he spin orientation is defined in terms of the @xmath72 and @xmath73 angles .
further , @xmath74 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 , where @xmath77 and @xmath78 are the final proton and deuteron momenta .
finally @xmath79 is the nucleon mass .
these expressions simplify significantly if the so - called parallel kinematics is assumed , for which the final proton is ejected parallel to @xmath80
. then @xmath81 and the response functions given in eqs . ( [ wt])([wtplp ] ) and ( [ b1])([c4 ] )
reduce to @xmath82 @xmath83 @xmath84 @xmath85 @xmath86 this allows us to express the parallel and perpendicular helicity asymmetries in terms of @xmath14 . for the parallel kinematics they are @xmath87 @xmath88 here , the @xmath3he wave function enters through the combinations @xmath89 and @xmath90 in terms of which @xmath91 and @xmath92 the crucial observation is now that @xmath93 and @xmath94 are related to the spin - dependent momentum distributions @xmath95 in the following manner @xmath96 where @xmath97 and @xmath98 where @xmath99 denotes the spin quantization axis .
similarly @xmath94 can be written as @xmath100 where @xmath101 @xmath102 and @xmath103 the values of spin projections appearing in eqs .
( [ p1.1 ] ) and ( [ p1.2 ] ) suggest that @xmath93 and @xmath94 are just the ( negative ) proton polarizations for two different proton momenta @xmath104 inside polarized @xmath3he . to see that this is true we formally define the proton polarization @xmath105 @xmath106 then it is easy to verify that @xmath107 and @xmath108 we also define the total ( integrated ) proton polarization as @xmath109 it is clear that @xmath110 is negative .
its numerical value obtained with the nuclear forces used in this paper will be given below .
thus we can conclude that @xmath93 and @xmath94 , which can be extracted from the parallel and perpendicular helicity asymmetries for the @xmath0 process , if the pwia approximation is valid , are directly the proton polarizations inside the polarized @xmath3he nucleus . in the following
we will check this simple dynamical assumption and compare the results based on the pwia approximation to the results of our full faddeev calculations .
we refer the reader to @xcite for a detailed description of our numerical techniques , which we do not want to repeat here .
note that @xmath93 and @xmath94 are not independent : they are simply related since according to eqs .
( [ p1 ] ) and ( [ p2 ] ) @xmath111 if eqs .
( [ aparap1 ] ) and ( [ aperpp2 ] ) are used to obtain the @xmath93 and @xmath94 values from an experiment , then eq .
( [ p1 - 2 ] ) gives some measure of the validity of the pwia assumption , since the relation ( [ p1 - 2 ] ) will in general not hold for the extracted @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
when the argument of @xmath112 and @xmath113 is small ( @xmath114 mev / c ) , then @xmath113 is much smaller than @xmath112 .
thus one can expect , quite independent of the details of the electron kinematics , that @xmath115
we studied the spin dependent momentum distributions in @xcite and had to conclude that ( at least in the nonrelativistic regime ) one can access these quantities only for rather small pd relative momenta .
the results of @xcite applied to the @xmath5 and @xmath6 processes but are also valid for the @xmath0 reaction , since the same current matrix elements enter in both calculations .
the important difference is , however , that a measurement of the latter reaction , which requires only a polarized electron beam and a polarized @xmath3he target , can be easier realized .
in fact , this paper is motivated by a very recent experiment @xcite , where for the first time the electron - target asymmetries @xmath116 and @xmath117 were measured for both the two- and three - body breakup of @xmath3he . here
we restrict ourselves to one electron kinematics from @xcite and show its parameters in table [ tab1 ] .
.[tab1 ] electron kinematics from @xcite .
e : beam energy , @xmath118 : electron scattering angle , @xmath119 : energy transfer , @xmath120 : magnitude of the three - momentum transfer @xmath121 , @xmath122 : angle of the three - momentum transfer with respect to the electron beam , @xmath123 : four - momentum transfer squared , @xmath124 : magnitude of the deuteron momentum for proton ejected parallel to @xmath121 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] the dynamical input for our calculations is the nucleon - nucleon force av18 @xcite alone or together with the 3n force urbanaix @xcite .
we include in addition to the single nucleon current the @xmath125- and @xmath34-like two - body currents linked to the av18 force , following @xcite two - body electron induced breakup of @xmath3he is a very rich process .
for example , the description of the deuteron - knockout is not possible within the simplest pwia approximation and complicated rescattering effects as well as the details of the nuclear current operator play there an important role .
a much simpler dynamical picture is expected in the vicinity of the proton knock - out peak .
we focus on this angular region and show in fig .
[ sigma ] the proton angular distribution for the selected electron configuration .
the fsi effects for strictly parallel kinematics amount to 5 - 7 % . note that the pwia results shown in fig .
[ sigma ] are obtained without inclusion of a 3n force but the full results including the 3n force required both the initial and the final state to be calculated with this dynamical component .
the 3n force effects come mainly from the initial bound state and altogether reach almost 20 % at @xmath126 .
note that in this case mec do not play a big role .
let us now turn to the helicity asymmetries shown in figs .
[ apara.fig ] and [ aperp.fig ] . for @xmath116
the 3n force effects are much smaller ( below 1 % for strictly parallel kinematics ) .
fsi are still visible and slightly reduce the value of @xmath116 in relation to the pwia result for parallel kinematics ( by nearly 6 % ) .
the least sensitivity to the different dynamical ingredients is observed for @xmath117 . in fig .
[ aperp.fig ] we see that in a certain angular interval around @xmath127 all curves overlap .
that means that in this case one has direct access to important properties of @xmath3he .
let us now address the question how ( in the given dynamical framework ) different @xmath3he wave function components contribute to @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
we compare in figs .
[ h0.v4.fig][y1-2.v4.fig ] results , for the full @xmath3he wave function to results obtained with truncated wave functions . besides the full results , we show curves including the dominant principal @xmath128-state , dropping the @xmath129- or the @xmath130-state contribution . the results , where only the principal @xmath128-state is included , and the ones with the @xmath129-state dropped agree rather well but
differ visibly from the full prediction .
the neglection of the @xmath130-state is hardly noticeable .
the same is true for the @xmath131-state ( not shown ) .
further we show in fig .
[ y1-2.cmp.fig ] that the 3n force effects for the quantity @xmath93 are rather small .
the same holds for @xmath94 ( not shown ) .
we end this section with fig .
[ f1-f2.fig ] , which shows the integrands @xmath132 and @xmath133 appearing in the second line of eq .
( [ pnewtotal ] ) .
we see that relatively small @xmath134 values ( @xmath135 ( mev / c ) contribute to @xmath110 .
the @xmath110 value calculated with ( without ) the inclusion of the 3n force is -0.364 ( -0.362 ) . for completeness
we give also the values of the two integrals appearing in eq .
( [ pnewtotal ] ) : @xmath136 = 0.127 ( 0.128 ) , @xmath137 = 0.348 ( 0.354 ) when calculated with ( without ) the 3n force .
the latter integral gives up to the factor @xmath138 the probability to find a proton - deuteron cluster inside @xmath3he .
in this section the results for the three - body breakup will be discussed .
a general discussion would require that all the elements of our dynamical framework are involved , i.e. that the initial @xmath3he and final scattering states are calculated consistently and many - body currents are taken into account .
we refer the reader to @xcite for a discussion of the numerical techniques necessary to perform calculations for such an approach .
it , however , precludes any analytical insight .
thus , as for the @xmath0 process , we start with the pwia approximation . additionally , we restrict the full @xmath3he state to its main , principal @xmath128-state component . in this case the six nonrelativistic response functions @xmath29 for the exclusive @xmath1 reaction take especially simple forms @xmath139 @xmath140 @xmath141 @xmath142 @xmath143 @xmath144 as before , @xmath66 and @xmath67 are the polar and azimuthal angles corresponding to the @xmath145 = { \vec p}_p - \frac13 { \vec q } $ ] direction .
the quantity @xmath146 is defined as @xmath147 where @xmath148 is the jacobi momentum describing the relative motion within the @xmath149 ( proton - neutron ) pair : @xmath150 the individual final nucleon momenta are denoted by @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 and the proton , to which the virtual photon is coupled , is the nucleon 1 .
the wave function @xmath154 is the momentum part of the principal @xmath128-state : @xmath155 where @xmath156 is the completely anti - symmetric 3n spin - isospin state .
the vanishing of the @xmath157 and @xmath158 response functions reflects the well known fact that for the principal @xmath128-state the proton in @xmath3he is totally unpolarized .
the situation for the case where the photon ejects the neutron is quite different and corresponds very closely to electron scattering on a free , fully polarized neutron at rest .
the six nonrelativistic response functions @xmath29 for the exclusive @xmath2 reaction under the pwia approximation and assuming only the principal s - state in the @xmath3he wave function can be written in the laboratory frame as @xmath159 @xmath160 @xmath161 @xmath162 @xmath163 @xmath164 now the @xmath66 and @xmath67 angles correspond to the @xmath165 direction and @xmath148 is the jacobi momentum describing the relative motion within the @xmath149 proton - proton pair .
let us first illustrate the influence of different @xmath3he wave function components on the asymmetries @xmath116 and @xmath117 performing calculations that take various components of the @xmath3he wave function into account .
this is done in figs .
[ apara.pwia.ppn ] and [ aperp.pwia.ppn ] for the @xmath166 reaction .
we note that the formulas ( [ wl.ppn])([wtlprime.ppn ] ) and ( [ wl.npp])([wtlprime.npp ] ) apply also to the semi - exclusive reaction .
one has to make a simple replacement @xmath167 i.e. , to integrate over the unobserved direction of the relative momentum within the @xmath149 pair .
we see that both asymmetries change quite significantly in the given @xmath168 range and become very small for the largest @xmath168 values . for the principal @xmath128-state alone
both asymmetries are zero .
therefore the smaller @xmath3he components ( except the @xmath131-wave ) are significant in pwia and change the asymmetry in the proton case . thereby the @xmath130-contribution is more important than the @xmath129-wave piece .
the situation is quite different for the neutron knock - out asymmetries shown in figs .
[ apara.pwia.npp ] and [ aperp.pwia.npp ] . in this case
the asymmetries are non - zero even for the principal @xmath128-state wave function .
all results are quite stable in the shown @xmath169 range .
the change due to different @xmath3he states for @xmath116 amounts to 2 % and @xmath117 varies by @xmath170 3 % .
the asymmetries reach the specific values which depend only on the neutron electromagnetic form factors and trivial kinematic factors @xmath33 appearing in eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) .
the pwia picture is very simple but quite unrealistic .
that is why fsi has to be taken into account . in order to retain analytical insight but make our framework more realistic we will in the following additionally allow for the rescattering effects in the subsystem @xmath149 and call the resulting approximation @xmath171 .
the @xmath3he wave function will still be restricted to the principal @xmath128-state .
thus we need the following matrix elements @xmath172 of the single nucleon current @xmath173 ( see @xcite for more details of our notation ) @xmath174 where @xmath175 the @xmath149 pair spin and spin projection are denoted by @xmath176 and @xmath177 , the @xmath149 pair isospin and isospin projection are @xmath178 and @xmath179 and the spin and isospin magnetic quantum numbers of the nucleon 1 are @xmath180 and @xmath181 . the total @xmath3he spin and isospin projections
are @xmath182 and @xmath183 , respectively .
further @xmath184 is the nn @xmath178-matrix acting within the @xmath149 pair and @xmath185 is the free 3n propagator . the six nonrelativistic response functions @xmath29 for the exclusive @xmath1 reaction under the fsi23 approximation and assuming only the principal s - state in the @xmath3he wave function can be written in the laboratory frame as @xmath186 @xmath187 @xmath188 @xmath189 @xmath190 @xmath191 the auxiliary quantities @xmath192@xmath193 are @xmath194 @xmath195 @xmath196 @xmath197 @xmath198 @xmath199 @xmath200
@xmath201 @xmath202 the different @xmath203 functions that appear in the equations are the integrals @xmath204 for different combinations of @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath205 , @xmath178 and @xmath179 : @xmath206 in the case of @xmath3he @xmath207 is absent . due to the assumed @xmath178-matrix properties ( isospin invariance and invariance with respect to time reversal ) @xmath208 some of the combinations could be eliminated .
when the term @xmath209 in eq .
( [ fs ] ) is dropped then @xmath210 the quantities @xmath113@xmath193 vanish and @xmath192 reduces to @xmath211 . in this way
the pwia results of eqs .
( [ wl.ppn])([wtlprime.ppn ] ) are recovered . for the sake of completeness
we give also the corresponding ( and much simpler ) expressions for the six nonrelativistic response functions @xmath29 in the case of the exclusive @xmath2 reaction under the same dynamical assumptions : @xmath212 @xmath213 @xmath214 @xmath215 @xmath216 @xmath217 the response functions have the same form as for the pwia approximation displayed in eqs .
( [ wl.npp])([wtlprime.npp ] ) .
the simple form of eqs .
( [ wl.npp.pss.fsi23])([wtlprime.npp.pss.fsi23 ] ) is guaranteed by the fact that for the neutron emission only @xmath178-matrices with the total subsystem isospin @xmath218 contribute .
if one forms now the helicity asymmetries @xmath219 , then exactly the same form is obtained as in the case of pwia , i.e. , all information from @xmath3he ( restricted to the principal @xmath128-state ) disappears .
the formula ( [ fsi23 ] ) and the following @xmath178-matrices are given in the three - vector representation . since we work with partial wave decomposed @xmath178-matrices , it is adequate to ask the question if the interaction is dominated by one or very few channel states .
further we would like to see if the truncation of the @xmath3he wave function to the principal @xmath128-state is reasonable , at least for the highest energies of the emitted nucleon .
let us start with the more intricate case of the proton emission . in figs .
[ apara.fsi23 ] and [ aperp.fsi23 ] we show different curves obtained with the full @xmath3he state ( thick lines ) and with @xmath3he truncated to the principal @xmath128-state ( thin lines ) for different number of @xmath178-matrix partial waves .
we note first of all that both cases of the parallel and perpendicular asymmetries are quite similar , especially for the range of the asymmetry values .
it is clear that the truncation of the full @xmath3he wave function to the principal @xmath128-state is valid only for the highest emission energies .
otherwise the influence of the smaller @xmath3he wave function components is very strong .
another important observation is that even for these highest energies the action of the @xmath178-matrix can not be restricted to just one @xmath220 channel and the inclusion at least of the @xmath221 partial wave state is inevitable . since then both spins @xmath222 and
@xmath19 appear for the @xmath223 subsystem , the photon couples to the proton which is polarized along and opposite to the spin of polarized @xmath3he .
if in the @xmath223 subsystem only the spin @xmath222 were active , the photon would couple to the 100 % polarized proton .
the situation for the neutron emission shown in figs .
[ apara.fsi23.npp ] and [ aperp.fsi23.npp ] is much simpler and we do not observe so much sensitivity to different dynamical components .
the @xmath178-matrix is anyway forced to act in the total isospin @xmath218 states . since additionally for the highest neutron energies ( the lowest subsystem @xmath149 energies ) the nucleon - nucleon interaction
is restricted to @xmath176-waves , that implies that only the @xmath220 partial wave should be important .
this expectation is confirmed by our results . in the group of figures [ apara.full.ppn][aperp.full.npp ]
we demonstrate results for much more complicated dynamical frameworks .
we show first the results based on the full treatment of fsi .
then we add to our single nucleon current the @xmath125- and @xmath34-like meson exchange currents .
finally we show the results where on top of all that the urbanaix 3n force is present both for the initial @xmath3he bound state and for the final scattering states . for proton emission the @xmath171 approximation but taking the full @xmath3he state into consideration
turns out to be satisfactory at the upper end of the energy spectrum .
this is valid for the both asymmetries . in the case of neutron emission
the situation is different and the full dynamics , especially for @xmath117 is required .
it is only in the case of @xmath116 that at the highest neutron energies all curves coincide . as pointed out before @xcite that means that the extraction of @xmath224 from a measurement of the parallel asymmetry @xmath116 seems to be quite model independent
this is not the case for the extraction of @xmath225 from a measurement of the perpendicular asymmetry @xmath117 , which shows more sensitivity to different dynamical ingredients ( see fig [ aperp.full.npp ] ) . to minimize the effects from complicated dynamics ,
measurements are performed on top of the quasi - elastic peak .
since the cross section drops very fast for the neutron energies below the maximal one ( see fig [ sigma.full.npp ] ) , @xmath117 receives main contributions from the regions where the model dependence is somewhat reduced . finally in figs .
[ sigma.full.ppn ] and [ sigma.full.npp ] we show for the sake of completeness our predictions for the six fold differential cross sections both for the proton and neutron knock - out processes .
the present paper is motivated by a recent experiment @xcite , where for the first time the @xmath116 and @xmath117 asymmetries were measured for proton emission in the two- and three - body breakup of @xmath3he .
we present results for one of the electron kinematics measured in @xcite . for the @xmath0 process
this paper is a continuation of work in @xcite , where the spin dependent momentum distributions of proton - deuteron clusters in polarized @xmath3he were investigated .
thus we can confirm that choosing the so - called parallel kinematics and small final deuteron momenta , information about proton polarization in @xmath3he is directly available .
we found that in such a case the polarizations extracted from the parallel and perpendicular asymmetries are not independent but simply related .
this relation has been to some extent confirmed in @xcite . for
these specific kinematical conditions fsi ( including the 3n force effects ) and mec do not play a big role and the pwia picture is sufficient .
one should exploit this opportunity and obtain all possible information about @xmath3he . on the other hand , this could also be a method to measure the proton electromagnetic form factors , even though they are known from direct electron scattering on a proton target .
such a measurement on @xmath3he would verify our knowledge about this nucleus and help set a limit on medium corrections of the form factors .
the situation for the @xmath1 reaction is more complicated since the simplest pwia approximation is not valid . for the proton emission
we find a lot of sensitivity to the smaller @xmath3he wave function components because for the main principal @xmath128-state of @xmath3he the asymmetries are zero .
fsi has to be taken into account but for the parallel kinematics and high emitted proton energies it can be approximated by a simpler @xmath171 prescription .
this is in agreement with the results of a study performed in @xcite .
we find , however , that no picture of electron scattering on a polarized proton arises .
the reason is that even at the highest proton energies partial waves with spin @xmath222 and @xmath19 contribute . for the @xmath2 reaction we see again ( see @xcite ) different sensitivities of the @xmath116 and @xmath117 asymmetries to the dynamical ingredients of our faddeev framework .
this proves that the extraction of @xmath224 from a measurement of the parallel asymmetry @xmath116 would be very simple .
this is not quite the case for the extraction of @xmath225 from a measurement of the perpendicular asymmetry @xmath117 , where corrections from fsi , mec and 3n forces would play a more important role .
the theoretical uncertainties can be , however , minimized by a proper choice of experimental conditions .
finally , we would like to emphasize that the results reflect our present day understanding of the reaction mechanism and the structure of @xmath3he .
therefore new data for the processes addressed in this paper would be extremely useful .
this work was supported by the polish committee for scientific research under grant no .
2p03b00825 , by the nato grant no .
pst.clg.978943 , and by doe under grants nos .
de - fg03 - 00er41132 and de - fc02 - 01er41187
. one of us ( w.g . ) would like to thank the foundation for polish science for the financial support during his stay in krakw .
we would like to thank dr .
rohe and dr .
sirca for reading the manuscript and important remarks .
the numerical calculations have been performed on the cray sv1 and on the ibm regatta p690 + of the nic in jlich , germany .
j. golak , r. skibiski , h. witaa , w. glckle , a. nogga , h. kamada , in : n. kalantar - nayestenaki , r.g.e .
timmermans , b.l.g .
bakker ( eds . ) , few - body problems in physics , aip conference proceedings no . 768 ,
aip , melville , ny , 2005 , p. 91 | we study within the faddeev framework the @xmath0 as well as the @xmath1 and @xmath2 reactions in order to extract information on the proton and neutron polarization in polarized @xmath3he .
we achieve clear analytical insight for simplified dynamical assumptions and define conditions for experimental access to important @xmath3he properties .
in addition we point to the possibility to measure the electromagnetic proton form factors in the process @xmath4 which would test the dynamical picture and put limits on medium corrections of the form factors . |
interfaces between light and matter are key building blocks of a future _ quantum web _ , a global secure communication network where the manipulation and transmission of information are regulated by the quantum laws @xcite .
the transfer of quantum states and the distribution of correlations across the interfaces are enabled by the common mathematical language of canonically conjugate observables with continuous spectrum , such as the quadratures of light and the collective spin components of atomic ensembles .
it is thus very fascinating to witness how the second generation of quantum information research is focusing more and more , from both theoretical and experimental viewpoints , on the characterization of continuous variable ( cv ) entanglement and its applications for communication , computation and metrology @xcite . out of the infinite - dimensional hilbert space of cv states ,
a special class of states has played a prominent role in recent years : gaussian states .
their mathematical treatment is advantageous thanks to a compact formalism based on symplectic analysis , and a very accurate degree of control is reached in their experimental realizations with light and matter @xcite .
there are however many tasks which are impossible by using only the gaussian states and operations toolbox ( e.g. , entanglement distillation @xcite and universal quantum computation @xcite ) , and many other tasks which can be sharply improved by suitably resorting to some non - gaussianity ( e.g. cv teleportation @xcite and loss estimation @xcite ) .
these premises have spurred astonishing progresses in the experimental engineering of non - gaussian states , such as fock states and states obtained by degaussifying gaussian resources via addition and/or subtraction of single photons @xcite .
it has been in particular verified experimentally that a photon subtraction from a two - mode squeezed entangled gaussian state leads to an enhancement of the entanglement ( at fixed squeezing ) @xcite , and it is known that such resource might be used for a more performant quantum teleportation of classical and nonclassical states ( a primitive of the quantum internet ) @xcite and for yet - to - be - achieved demonstrations of loophole - free bell tests of nonlocality @xcite . the bottleneck for unleashing the power of non - gaussian cv quantum technology has remained the quantitative characterization of entanglement in states which deviate from gaussianity , a crucial step to evaluate and control their usefulness for applications and the _ bona - fide_ness of their preparation . while for gaussian states all the information is encoded in the second moments of the canonical operators ( collected in the covariance matrix ) , for any other state an infinite hierarchy of moments is in principle needed for an exact entanglement quantification @xcite .
this translates , in experimental terms , into the demand for a complete state tomography @xcite , a process which is time- and resource - consuming especially for two or more modes . in this paper
we provide an advance in the characterization of non - gaussian entanglement which reduces the complexity of its experimental determination exactly to the same level of gaussian states
. this can not be possible for _ any generic _ non - gaussian state : hence here we focus on the important class of photon - subtracted states ( pss ) under quite realistic conditions @xcite , which represent the preferred resources for most current and future applications requiring non - gaussianity . combining results from the extremality of gaussian states @xcite with an analysis of quadrature correlations , we derive analytical lower and upper bounds which individuate the entropy of entanglement of pure two - mode pss ( obtained from gaussian twin beams by conditional subtraction of @xmath0 photons per beam ) within a very narrow band , with relative error vanishing with increasing entanglement .
the bandwidth is linked to the degree of non - gaussianity @xcite of the analyzed pss .
the results are extended to bound the entanglement of formation of a class of mixed pss obtained by means of realistic `` on / off '' type photodetectors .
crucially , all these bounds are only functions of the second moments of the non - gaussian states .
a novel method for the fast and reliable reconstruction of the complete covariance matrix of optical two - mode cv states has been recently demonstrated @xcite : our result proves that it can be applied to real degaussified pss as well and it is enough to quantitatively estimate entanglement with surprisingly high accuracy .
we deal with a cv system of @xmath1 bosonic modes , associated to an infinite - dimensional hilbert space @xmath2 @xcite . here
@xmath3 is the fock space of each individual mode @xmath4 , described by the ladder operators @xmath5 satisfying the canonical commutation relations @xmath6=\delta_{ij}$ ] .
we can collect the field quadrature operators into the vector @xmath7 , with @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
the exact description of a generic cv ( non - gaussian ) state requires arbitrary - order moments of the canonical operators . in general , the first moments @xmath10 can be adjusted by local displacements without affecting entanglement : they will be set to zero without loss of generality .
two - mode gaussian states are henceforth completely specified by the @xmath11 real symmetric covariance matrix ( cm ) @xmath12 of the second moments @xmath13 @xcite .
the cm elements for an arbitrary two - mode cv state can be efficiently reconstructed in the lab by means of homodyne detections @xcite .
we recall that any physical two - mode cm @xmath14 can be converted by local unitaries into a standard form @xcite where @xmath15 and @xmath16 with @xmath17 , @xmath18 is universally quantified by the von neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix of each subsystem ( entropy of entanglement @xmath19 ) @xcite .
the optimal convex - roof extension of @xmath19 for a mixed state @xmath20 defines the entanglement of formation @xcite @xmath21 , where the infimum runs over all pure - state decompositions of @xmath22 .
another popular measure of entanglement for pure and mixed states , whose computation is in general simpler , is the logarithmic negativity @xcite @xmath23 $ ] @xcite , where the partial transposition @xmath24 is obtained from @xmath20 by transposing the degrees of freedom of one subsystem only . for pure states @xmath25 .
an important result in cv entanglement theory is the ` extremality ' of gaussian states : for any cv state @xmath20 with second moments given by @xmath26 , the corresponding gaussian state @xmath27 defined by the same cm has smaller entanglement ( quantified by a continuous and strongly superadditive measure ) than @xmath20 @xcite .
it is also known that for arbitrary two - mode gaussian states @xmath28 is computable , additive , and strongly superadditive @xcite .
the starting point for the definition of `` ideal '' pss is a pure two - mode squeezed gaussian state ( or ` twin beam ' in the optical language ) , @xmath29 , where @xmath30 and the positive @xmath31 is the squeezing degree .
the cm @xmath32 for this state is already in standard form with @xmath33 .
the beam @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) of @xmath36 is let to interfere , via a beam splitter with transmittivity @xmath37 ( preferably @xmath37 close to unity ) , with a vacuum mode @xmath38 ( @xmath39 ) .
the output is a four - mode gaussian state of modes @xmath40 . a photon - number - resolving detection of exactly @xmath0 photons in each of the two beams @xmath38 and @xmath39 , conditionally projects the state of modes @xmath41 into a pure symmetric non - gaussian state @xcite , given in the fock basis by @xmath42 , with @xcite @xmath43 where @xmath44 denotes the gauss hypergeometric function .
we define an effective squeezing parameter @xmath45 such that @xmath46 thus @xmath47 , where @xmath48 ^ 2 \\ & = k!^2\ , _ 2f_1\left(k+1,k+1;1;\tanh ^2 r\right ) \cosh^{\!-2}\ !
k}\ ! r\,.\end{split}\ ] ] the logarithmic negativity of the pss states for arbitrary @xmath0 can be computed in simple closed form via the formula @xcite @xmath49 $ ] and reads in our notation @xmath50\,.\ ] ] notice that @xmath51 increases with @xmath0 : iteration of the photon subtraction process further enhances the entanglement compared to the original gaussian instance .
we aim at an estimate of the entropy of entanglement of pss for any @xmath0 , and specifically at accurate bounds on this universal entanglement quantifier which can be measured experimentally with high efficiency .
we will now derive the cm of pss states in closed form and show that it contains enough information , straightforwardly accessible in the lab , for the desired task .
+ denoting by @xmath52 an observable involving normally ordered combinations of ladder operators on modes @xmath34 and @xmath35 , we observe that @xmath53 , that is , we can evaluate expectation values of relevant operators in terms of normally ordered higher moments computed on the unperturbed gaussian twin beams . recalling that ,
for @xmath54 , the normally ordered characteristic function reads @xcite @xmath55\}$ ] , we can write the ( normally ordered ) moment generating formula : @xmath56 the formula eq .
( [ eq : momgen ] ) can be readily applied to compute the second moments of the canonical operators on our non - gaussian states .
after some algebra , the cm @xmath57 of pss of the form @xmath58 turns out to be that of a symmetric two - mode squeezed thermal state , automatically in standard form , with @xmath59 , and @xmath60 .
explicitly : @xmath61^{-1 } \nonumber \\ & \!\!\!\!\!\!\qquad\times&[2(k+1)^2 \sinh^2 r \ , _ 2f_1(-k ,-
k;2;\tanh^2 r ) \nonumber \\ & \!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! & + \ _ 2f_1(-k ,-
k;1;\tanh^2 r)]\ , ; \\
\label{eq : cx3 } & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\gamma^{(k)}= & \frac{2 \tanh r ( k+1 ) \ , _ 2f_1(k+1,k+2;1;\tanh^2 r)}{\ , _ 2f_1(k+1,k+1;1;\tanh^2 r)}\ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] we will now show how to extract from the cm elements a lower and an upper bound on @xmath62 .
_ lower bound_. the extremality of gaussian states @xcite entails that @xcite @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the mixed gaussian state with cm @xmath57 .
explicitly , @xmath65 $ ] where @xcite @xmath66- \frac{(1-x)^2}{4x}\log \left[\frac{(1-x)^2}{4x}\right]$ ] .
_ upper bound_. the logarithmic negativity of pure pss is already an upper bound for @xmath19 , however it is defined in terms of all the moments of the state , and its experimental determination ( in real conditions requiring a complete state tomography ) becomes rather demanding even when the states take very special forms @xcite .
the strength of our investigation is to derive a slightly looser upper bound but which is a function of the second moments only of the pss , i.e. of @xmath57 .
we simply observe that for @xmath67 , namely for gaussian twin beams , @xmath68 $ ] .
the standard - form parameter @xmath69 quantifies the maximum quadrature correlation between the two modes @xcite .
it is tempting to postulate that , for pss @xmath58 with an arbitrary degree @xmath0 of degaussification , a function of @xmath70 may yield an overestimate of the actual entanglement ( which , we remark , is nontrivially encoded in higher - order correlations too ) .
we can turn this blurry bit of intuition into the following + _ theorem 1 .
_ for all @xmath71 , @xmath72 \ge e_n(\psi_k ) \ge e(\psi_k)\,.\ ] ] _ proof .
_ the rightmost inequality holds by definition .
here we sketch the ( quite technical ) proof of the leftmost one , which is one of the main results of this paper .
the simple cases @xmath73 can be proven by inspection , hence we specify here to arbitrary @xmath74 .
using eq .
( [ eq : pslogneg ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : cx3 ] ) , and exponentiating both sides of the inequality , the problem reduces to proving that @xmath75 where we recall that @xmath76 .
we can write @xmath77 as a power series , @xmath78 , where @xmath79 { { \frac{1}{4 } \left(-1+(-1)^m\right)+k+\frac{m}{2 } } \choose k}^2 -{{2k+m+1 } \choose { 2k+1}}$ ] .
we observe that @xmath80 and @xmath81 @xmath82 , and moreover @xmath83 @xmath84 .
this entails that by truncating the power series at @xmath85 we discard a positive remainder : @xmath86 .
let us now define a parametric class of hypergeometric sums , @xmath87 . by means of zeilberger s
algorithm @xcite one can verify that @xmath88 @xmath89 .
we will now show that @xmath90 to conclude the proof .
we take the ratio @xmath91/[s_0^{(k ) } z^{2k+2}]$ ] and expand it in power series around @xmath92 : @xmath93 ( z-1)^l$ ] .
but trivially @xmath94 , and being @xmath95 the alternating sign is cancelled to yield @xmath96 .
@xmath97 we have shown that , quite remarkably , the simple measurement of the cm of a pure pss enables to pin down the entropy of entanglement quantitatively within analytical _ a priori _ bounds .
in fact , one can appreciate how close the lower and upper bounds ( both functions of the second moments only ) are to each other for various values of @xmath0 in fig .
[ fig : bounds][_(a)(c ) _ ] .
a crucial fact is that the absolute error @xmath98 on the entanglement quantification asymptotically saturates ( for @xmath99 ) to a constant value @xmath100,\ ] ] being @xmath101 for any finite @xmath45 .
accordingly , since the actual value of the entanglement ( measured by the average between lower and upper bound ) diverges linearly with the squeezing @xmath45 , the relative error @xmath102 on the estimate of @xmath62 from the cm _ vanishes _ for @xmath103 , rendering our method rigorously accurate .
we notice that , in general , the error @xmath104 increases with @xmath0 , although it stays of the order of few units on a scale ranging to infinity even for big @xmath0 ( e.g. @xmath105 for up to @xmath106 photon subtractions per beam ) , thus scarcely affecting the quality of the estimate [ see fig .
[ fig : bounds ] ] .
we believe that a physical explanation for the scaling of @xmath104 is rooted in the fact that with increasing @xmath0 the pss @xmath58 are increasingly more non - gaussian , hence there is more information not retrievable from second moments only .
this argument can be made quantitative by evaluating the entropic non - gaussianity @xcite @xmath107 of @xmath58 , which simply amounts in this case to the von neumann entropy of the associated gaussian state with cm @xmath57 .
we obtain , for @xmath103 , @xmath108.\ ] ] for any @xmath45 , the non - gaussianity and the absolute error are very close to each other , with @xmath109 , and exhibit the same scaling with @xmath0 ( see fig .
[ fig : plhysto ] ) .
this fascinating connection adds insight to our analysis and leads us to sum up the results achieved so far as follows .
_ entanglement in ideal photon - subtracted states can be measured from the covariance matrix up to a narrow error that scales with the states non - gaussianity_. of the asymptotic absolute error @xmath110 on the estimate of entanglement via second moments ( dark bars ) and of the asymptotic entropic non - gaussianity @xmath111 ( light bars ) for pure @xmath0-photon - subtracted states @xmath58.,width=302 ]
in most practical implementations , efficient photon - number - resolving detectors are not available and the conditional generation of pss is achieved by means of `` on / off '' type detectors which are only able to discriminate the vacuum from a bunch of an undefined number of photons @xcite .
this means that a more appropriate description of a class of pss must be in terms of statistical mixtures of the form @xmath112 , where we can define @xmath113 as the ` average ' number of photons subtracted per beam @xcite . for these mixed states
not even the logarithmic negativity is available in closed form ( and its numerical evaluation on a computer requires several days for any given squeezing degree @xcite ) , let alone the entanglement of formation .
remarkably , our bounds can be immediately extended to pinpoint the entanglement of formation of mixed symmetric pss from the sole knowledge of second moments .
we first observe that ( having zero first moments ) the cm transforms linearly : @xmath114 , hence it can be computed analytically for any probability distribution @xmath115 from eqs .
( [ eq : cx1],[eq : cx3 ] ) .
the @xmath28 of the corresponding gaussian state with cm @xmath116 , according to the extremality theorem @xcite , stands as a lower bound for the @xmath28 of the non - gaussian mixed pss @xmath117 @xcite . on the other hand , denoting by @xmath118 the @xmath119 element of the mixed - state cm @xmath116 , @xmath120 , the upper bound eq .
( [ eq : eup ] ) is immediately extended to the mixed case : @xmath121 \ge e_f(\varrho_{\bar k})$ ] .
the proof follows from the concavity of the log function , the convexity of the entanglement of formation , and obviously theorem 1 .
namely , @xmath121 \ge \sum_k p_k \log[1 + 2 \gamma^{(k ) } ] \ge \sum_k p_k e(\psi_k ) \ge e_f ( \varrho_{\bar k})$ ] .
the behavior of the bounds in such more realistic conditions is shown in fig .
[ fig : bounds]_(d ) _ for an instance with @xmath122 .
we observe , in general , that for reasonable modeling of the mixture ( e.g. , @xmath123 following a binomial distribution ) the loosening of the bounds compared to the ideal cases with @xmath124 is negligible : our scheme is efficient and _ robust _ against the specific source of imperfection considered here ( the usage of non - phon - number - resolving detectors ) .
we plan to deepen our investigation in the future following the experimental progresses in the generation of ( generally non - symmetric ) pss states @xcite , thus properly modeling other sources of imperfections ( e.g. mismatches or dark counts in the photon conditioning ) that arise in practical demonstrations @xcite , in order to test the robustness and reliability of our techniques for estimating entanglement in fully realistic situations . in this context ,
let us briefly comment on the direct implementation of our results in experiments .
once a two - mode pss is prepared , one needs to measure the full cm by homodyne detections as in @xcite , transform it in standard form ( i.e. extract the symplectic invariants @xmath125 ) @xcite , and then ( upon verification that the standard - form cm has the structure predicted here : a benchmark for the state engineering ) readily evaluate our lower and upper bounds to ensure an accurate estimate of the entanglement of formation of the produced non - gaussian state .
in this paper , in the spirit of @xcite , we have gone beyond the conventional belief that out of gaussian states the covariance matrix plays a marginal role in cv entanglement quantification . on the contrary
, we demonstrated that clever exploitation of such an easily accessible component of the state , bears extremely useful and precise information on the quantification of non - gaussian entanglement produced in experiments , specifically for the important class of ( realistic ) photon - subtracted states @xcite .
this is the start of a program which will continue with the systematic investigation of quantitative entanglement witnesses for other classes of non - gaussian states in terms of low - order moments .
we hope with our result to stimulate advances in the engineering and characterization of non - gaussian resources , and their exploitation for demonstrations impossible to achieve with gaussian states only , in order to explore the actual limits that quantum mechanics poses on the access and manipulation of information .
s. l. braunstein and p. van loock , rev .
phys . * 77 * , 513 ( 2005 ) ; n. cerf , g. leuchs , and e. s. polzik ( eds . ) , _ quantum information with continuous variables of atoms and light _ ( imperial college press , london , 2007 ) .
a. i. lvovsky , h. hansen , t. aichele , o. benson , j. mlynek , and s. schiller , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 050402 ( 2001 ) ; a. zavatta , s. viciani , and m. bellini , science * 306 * , 660 ( 2004 ) ; j. wenger , r. tualle - brouri , and p. grangier , phys .
. lett . * 92 * , 153601 ( 2004 ) ; j. s. neergaard - nielsen , b. melholt nielsen , c. hettich , k. mlmer , and e. s. polzik , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 083604 ( 2006 ) ; k. wakui , h. takahashi , a. furusawa , and m. sasaki , opt .
express * 15 * , 3568 ( 2007 ) ; a. ourjoumtsev , h. jeong , r. tualle - broui , and p. grangier , nature * 448 * , 784 ( 2007 ) .
t. opatrny , g. kurizki , and d .-
welsch , phys .
a * 61 * , 032302 ( 2000 ) ; p. t. cochrane , t. c. ralph , and g. j. milburn , _ ibid . _ * 65 * , 062306 ( 2002 ) ; s. olivares , m. g. a. paris , and r. bonifacio , _ ibid . _ * 67 * , 032314 ( 2003 ) . v. dauria , s. fornaro , a. porzio , s. solimeno , s. olivares , and m. g. a. paris , phys .
* 102 * , 020502 ( 2009 ) .
a similar method had been demonstrated for the detection of continuous variable entanglement in cold atomic ensembles by v. josse , a. dantan , a. bramati , m. pinard , and e. giacobino , phys .
lett . * 92 * , 123601 ( 2004 ) .
j. laurat , g. keller , j. a. oliveira - huguenin , c. fabre , t. coudreau , a. serafini , g. adesso , and f. illuminati , j. opt .
b * 7 * , s577 ( 2005 ) ; j. diguglielmo , b. hage , a. franzen , j. fiurasek , and r. schnabel , phys . rev . a * 76 * , 012323 ( 2007 )
. symmetry between the parties is typically required by quantum protocols and should be fulfilled by experimental realizations , hence we do not consider here non - symmetric states where a different number of photons is subtracted from each beam .
however , since these instances can more closely resemble realistic implementations , we commit ourselves to extend our methods to encompass such a more general framework in further work .
d. zeilberger , discrete math .
* 80 * , 207 ( 1990 ) ; m. petkovsek , h. s. wilf , and d. zeilberger , _ `` a = b '' _ ( a. k. peters publishers , wellesley , ma , 1996 ) ; p. paule and m. schorn , j. symb . comput . * 20 * , 673 , 1995 . | we demonstrate that the entanglement in a class of two - mode non - gaussian states obtained by subtracting photons from gaussian twin beams can be bounded from above and from below by functionals of the second moments only .
knowledge of the covariance matrix thus suffices for an entanglement quantification with appreciable precision .
the absolute error in the entanglement estimation scales with the non - gaussianity of the considered states . |
in contrast to the case for the nucleon , little is known about the distribution of gluons in nuclei , especially in the region of bjrken-@xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the fraction of the nucleon s momentum carried by the parton .
studies of deuteron(proton)+nucleus collisions at large center of mass energy ( @xmath4=200 gev ) can provide constraints on the gluon density in heavy nuclei . in the perturbative qcd explanation of particle production at large pseudorapidity , a large-@xmath3 parton scatters from a low-@xmath3 parton and then fragments into the observed particle(s ) .
forward charged particle production is found to be suppressed in d+au collisions @xcite , consistent with the expectation of gluon saturation @xcite , possibly indicating a different mechanism for particle production .
explanations of the suppression based on leading - twist pqcd calculations using a model of gluon shadowing have also been suggested @xcite .
further tests of the possible role played by gluon saturation at rhic energies are provided by the study of particle correlations @xcite . at @xmath5=200 gev and larger collision energies , there is quantitative agreement between nlo pqcd calculations and measured p+p cross sections at mid - rapidity @xcite .
this agreement has been found to extend to @xmath0 production at @xmath6 @xcite .
further tests of the underlying dynamics responsible for forward particle production can be obtained from the study of particle correlations . in particular ,
strong azimuthal correlations of hadron pairs are expected when particle production arises from @xmath7 parton scattering .
this paper reports cross sections for forward inclusive @xmath0 production for p+p collisions at @xmath5=200 gev .
the azimuthal correlations between a forward @xmath0 ( @xmath8=4.0 ) and mid - rapidity charged hadrons were studied .
in addition , exploratory studies with d+au collisions at @xmath4=200 gev are reported , and azimuthal correlations of hadron pairs are compared to those for p+p collisions .
the inclusive yields of @xmath0 mesons in p+p and d+au collisions will be forthcoming , and details pertinent to this analysis are presented here .
forward @xmath0 production in d+au collisions refers to observation of the @xmath0 in the direction of the incident deuteron .
the solenoidal tracker at rhic ( star ) is a multipurpose detector at brookhaven national laboratory .
one of its principal components is a time projection chamber used for tracking charged particles produced at @xmath91.2 .
a forward @xmath0 detector ( fpd ) comprising @xmath10 matrices of @xmath11 @xmath12 pb - glass detectors ( towers ) was installed @xmath13 cm from the interaction region near the beam pipe to detect high energy @xmath0 mesons with @xmath14 .
data were collected over two years of rhic operations . in the 2002 run ,
p+p collisions were studied with a prototype fpd @xcite . in the 2003 run ,
p+p collisions were studied and exploratory measurements were performed with d+au collisions .
inclusive @xmath0 production cross section versus @xmath0 energy ( @xmath15 ) at average pseudorapidities ( @xmath16 ) 3.3 and 3.8 .
the inner error bars are statistical , and are smaller than the symbols for most points .
the outer errors combine these with @xmath15-dependent systematic errors .
the curves are nlo pqcd calculations evaluated at @xmath17 and 3.8 using different fragmentation functions .
, width=302 ]
the differential cross section for inclusive @xmath0 production for @xmath18gev at @xmath6 was previously reported @xcite .
the event reconstruction and normalization methods were extended to allow measurement of the differential cross section at @xmath19 @xcite .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig : crosssec ] in comparison to nlo pqcd calculations evaluated at @xmath20=3.3 and 3.8 .
the nlo pqcd calculations are consistent with the data , in contrast to @xmath0 data at lower @xmath5 @xcite .
the inclusive yield was also found to agree with predictions of the pythia event generator @xcite , which uses initial- and final - state parton showers to model effects beyond leading order .
diphoton invariant mass spectra as a function of energy deposited in the calorimeter for d+au data and hijing+geant simulations .
the histograms are reconstructed simulation events .
the points are data with statistical errors , normalized to equal area in each bin .
, width=302 ] nuclear effects on particle production are quantified by @xmath21 , the ratio of the inclusive yield of particles produced in d+au collisions to p+p collisions .
the value of @xmath21 for forward @xmath0 mesons is expected to be smaller than was seen for negative hadrons @xcite due to isospin suppression of the @xmath22 process @xcite .
we proceed to discuss considerations relevant to an accurate determination of @xmath21 for forward @xmath0 production . the data in fig .
[ fig : crosssec ] show that the cross section falls rapidly with @xmath15 .
accurate yield determinations require accurate energy calibrations and good energy resolution .
the energy calibration of the fpd is performed by reconstruction of the invariant mass of the @xmath0 meson , @xmath23 .
an analysis of the topology of the energy deposition , based on measured shower shapes @xcite , is used to reconstruct the relative energy of the two photons and their separation ( @xmath24 ) .
the @xmath0 energy is taken to be the total energy in the calorimeter .
the gain of each tower is determined iteratively by associating @xmath23 with the tower containing the most energy in the event .
after convergence , an energy - dependent correction is applied to account for material between the interaction region and the detector , which causes decay photons to shower prior to reaching the fpd .
it also corrects for the non - linearity implied by using digitizers with a finite number of bits .
the energy can be accurately associated with @xmath23 up to a point set by the systematics of reconstructing @xmath24 . at 50gev , @xmath25 the linear dimension of a tower .
the @xmath23 distribution can be seen in fig . [
fig : overlay ] , with resolution @xmath26mev / c@xmath27 from @xmath28gev .
simulation study of the fractional difference of reconstructed and simulated energy versus simulated @xmath0 energy .
the energy calibration is determined to an accuracy of @xmath29 .
systematics of reconstructing the di - photon opening angle are seen beginning around @xmath30gev .
, width=302 ] a simulation is used to model the events using the pythia ( hijing)@xcite generator for p+p ( d+au ) collisions , together with a geant simulation to model the detector response , including intervening material .
after calibrating the simulation with the same technique as the data , the overlay of data and simulation for @xmath23 can be seen in fig .
[ fig : overlay ] .
the simulation describes the data well for @xmath23 as well as several other kinematic variables .
the simulations are used to determine the efficiency of @xmath0 detection . as was observed in @xcite ,
the detection efficiency is dominated by the geometrical acceptance of the calorimeter .
coincidence probability as function of azimuthal angle difference between a forward @xmath0 and a midrapidity leading charged particle for p+p ( left ) and d+au ( right ) collisions .
the upper plots are simulation using pythia 6.222 and hijing 1.381 described in the text , while the lower plots are data.,title="fig:",width=302 ] coincidence probability as function of azimuthal angle difference between a forward @xmath0 and a midrapidity leading charged particle for p+p ( left ) and d+au ( right ) collisions .
the upper plots are simulation using pythia 6.222 and hijing 1.381 described in the text , while the lower plots are data.,title="fig:",width=302 ] using the simulation , a comparison of the kinematics of events that contain @xmath0 mesons with reconstructed variables gives an estimate of the accuracy of the analysis techniques used .
the fractional difference in energy between the generated and reconstructed @xmath0 meson in bins of generated @xmath0 energy can be seen in fig .
[ fig : association ] .
the uncertainty on the energy calibration is @xmath29 , implying an uncertainty on the yield of @xmath31 . the data in fig .
[ fig : crosssec ] show that the cross section increases rapidly with @xmath20 .
accurate yield determinations require accurate position determinations .
a beam position monitor ( bpm ) is located in the vicinity of the fpd , and has been accurately surveyed .
relative to the bpm , the absolute position of the fpd is presently measured with an accuracy of 5 mm , giving an absolute accuracy of @xmath32 at @xmath33 .
this implies an uncertainty on the yield of 11% .
correlations between a @xmath0 produced at large rapidity with large feynman @xmath3 and charged particles produced at midrapidity were studied with p+p collisions and d+au collisions .
details of the analysis , including detailed comparisons to simulations , may be found in ref .
@xcite . the leading charged particle ( lcp ) analysis selects the mid - rapidity track with the highest @xmath340.5 gev / c , and computes the azimuthal angle difference @xmath35 for each event
. the normalized @xmath36 distributions are fit with the sum of a constant and a gaussian distribution centered at @xmath37 .
the fit parameters are the area under the gaussian ( s ) , representing the azimuthally correlated coincidence probability ; the uncorrelated coincidence probability ( b ) ; and the gaussian width ( @xmath38 ) .
the normalized @xmath39 distribution for d+au collisions is shown in comparison to p+p for both simulations and data in fig .
[ fig : daucorr ]
. the simulations account for detector resolution and reconstruction efficiency for both the forward @xmath0 and the midrapidity charged particles .
we observe a large increase of b@xmath40 relative to b@xmath41 .
the growth in b arises from additional nucleon - nucleon collisions as the deuteron and au beams interact . for the data ,
@xmath42 is much smaller than @xmath43 , most likely reflecting the inadequacy of the functional form used to represent @xmath44 .
the azimuthally correlated @xmath45 coincidence probability is smaller in d+au collisions than in p+p collisions , qualitatively consistent with behavior predicted in a gluon saturation picture @xcite .
complete assessment of systematic errors is underway .
in summary , cross sections for the inclusive production of @xmath0 mesons in p+p collisions at @xmath5=200 gev , at @xmath46=3.3 and 3.8 are consistent with nlo pqcd calculations . the azimuthal correlation between pairs of hadrons separated by large @xmath47
is described by pythia @xcite , which uses leading order pqcd with parton showers .
agreement of these calculations with the inclusive cross section and di - hadron correlations suggest that forward @xmath0 production arises from partonic scattering at this collision energy .
exploratory studies of forward @xmath0 production in d+au collisions suggest that the azimuthally correlated component of hadron pairs separated by large @xmath47 is suppressed relative to p+p collisions .
more data for forward particle production and di - hadron correlations in d+au collisions are required to reach a definitive conclusion about the possible existence of gluon saturation in the au nucleus . | measurements are reported of the production of high energy @xmath0 mesons at large pseudorapidity , coincident with charged hadrons at mid - rapidity , for proton+proton and deuteron+gold collisions at @xmath1gev .
the p+p cross section for inclusive @xmath0 production follows expectations from next - to - leading order perturbative qcd .
a suppression of the back - to - back azimuthal correlations was observed in d+au , qualitatively consistent with the gluon saturation picture .
experimental uncertainties regarding the inclusive measurement are discussed . |
there has been much interest in studying models of conformal matter coupled to 2d quantum gravity and in particular in investigating the nature of the @xmath9 barrier , beyond which kpz theory @xcite breaks down .
these models tend to exhibit a branched polymer phase for large enough values of the central charge @xmath10 , and our aim is to shed some light on the extent of this phase for the multiple ising model .
this letter extends the work of a previous paper @xcite in which we studied a model of @xmath0 independent ising spins coupled to 2d gravity , the central charge of this model being @xmath11 .
the partition function of the model is z_n(p ) = _ g ( z_g ) ^p , where the sum is over some set @xmath12 of connected planar @xmath13-vertex 3 graphs .
the symmetry factor @xmath14 is equal to the order of the symmetry group of the graph @xmath15 .
@xmath16 is the ising partition function for a fixed graph @xmath15 with a single spin per vertex and coupling constant @xmath17 , that is , z_g = _ \{s } ( _
< i j > s_i
s_j ) , with z_0 = 2^n ( ) ^. @xmath18 is the spin on the @xmath19-th vertex ( @xmath20 ) and the sum in the action is over nearest neighbours on the 3 graph .
as in our previous paper we define three different versions of the model . for model
i the set @xmath12 consists of all connected planar @xmath13-vertex 3 graphs . in model ii the set @xmath12 is restricted to one - particle irreducible graphs and for model iii only two - particle irreducible graphs are used .
it has been proven @xcite that in the limit of large @xmath0 tree - like graphs dominate the partition function , for model i ( see fig [ fig : tree ] for an example of a tree graph ) . by solving a model in which the free energy of the ising partition function was truncated to a single term we managed to show how this change to dominance occurs , for small @xmath17 . in this approximation
the change was continuous and for finite @xmath0 there was no phase transition to a tree - like region ( which we would associate with the branched polymer region occurring in other similar models ) .
( 100,35)(-45,0 ) the purpose of this letter is to extend the calculation by including two terms in the truncated free energy .
we will show that for this two - term truncation of model i there exists a third order phase transition from a pure gravity region ( with @xmath1 ) to a tree - like region ( for which @xmath2 ) and that @xmath3 on the critical line .
the location of this critical line approximates to that in the full untruncated model and allows us to estimate the value of @xmath0 for the point at which the tree - like , unmagnetized and magnetized phases meet in this model ; the result is @xmath21@xmath5 , corresponding to a central charge of @xmath6@xmath7 . in this letter
we present the main details of the calculation , further information about the solution can be found in reference @xcite .
for a given 3 graph @xmath15 , the ising partition function can be written in terms of @xmath22 as a high temperature expansion , z_g = 1 + _
l n_l t^l , where @xmath23 is the number of closed ( but possibly disconnected ) loops in the graph , which contain @xmath24 links and use no link more than once . defining @xmath25 by _
n z_g , we have for model i , _ g = . defining @xmath26 to be the number of connected loops of length two ( hereafter referred to as `` 2-loops '' ) then @xmath27 and we have _
suppose that we truncate @xmath25 to the first two terms of the series , denoting this new quantity by @xmath28 and consider the model with the partition function [ eq : partfunc ] z_n(p ) = _ g e^_g^t n p , which we will refer to as the two - term truncated model .
from now on @xmath12 is taken to be the set of model i graphs . in the limit of small @xmath17
we might expect it to reproduce the behaviour of the full model . for larger @xmath17 it will be a bad approximation to the original model and in particular it has no magnetized phase .
however we can modify the truncated model slightly so that it is a reasonable approximation to the full model for large @xmath0 at any value of @xmath17 .
the key to doing this is to note that one can factor out the entire contribution to @xmath16 resulting from loops of length one ( `` 1-loops '' ) giving z_g = ( 1+t)^n_1 z_g , where @xmath29 is the partition function on the graph @xmath30 for which 1-loops have been cut off ( leaving vertices of coordination number two , see fig [ fig : cut ] ) .
it is impossible to factorize all the contributions from 2-loops in the same fashion , but suppose that we consider the partition function = ( 1+t)^n_1 ( 1+t^2)^ = 1 + _
l n_l t^l .
( 100,20)(0,0 ) this corresponds to a model in which we count @xmath31 the number of ( possibly disconnected ) loops of length @xmath24 , but restrict each of the connected parts to be of length two or less .
this is a good approximation to the full model if @xmath32 is small or if the dominant graphs only have short loops in them ( which is precisely what happens for large @xmath0 since we know that tree - like graphs dominate in this limit ) .
thus we might expect the modified two - term truncated model to give a reasonably accurate indication of the transition to a tree - like phase even for values of @xmath17 which are not small .
the corresponding @xmath28 is [ eq : mugt ] _
g^t = . in this letter
we will solve exactly this modified truncated model , defined by equations ( [ eq : partfunc ] ) and ( [ eq : mugt ] ) , and relate the results to the untruncated model .
for technical reasons it is much easier to solve the model if we use 3 graphs which have a `` root '' ; that is , in the terminology of @xmath33 theory , we are going to use 1-legged green functions rather than vacuum diagrams - this will not change the free energy and should not affect any of our conclusions .
in this case we have @xmath34 \\ & = & \sum_{n_1=0}^{\infty } \sum_{n_2=0}^{\infty } \ { \cal g}_r^{(1)}(n , n_1,\tloop ) \
v^{n_1 } y^{\tloop } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined v ( 1+t)^p , y ( 1 + t^2 ) ^p and @xmath35 is the number of @xmath13-vertex rooted model i graphs with @xmath36 1-loops and @xmath26 2-loops ; the subscript `` r '' indicates that we are using rooted graphs .
the grand canonical partition function is [ eq : defcalzr ] z_r = _
n=1 odd^ e^-
n z_n(p ) = _ n=1 odd^ _ n_1=0^ _
n_2=0^ g_r^(1)(n , n_1 , ) x^n v^n_1 y^ , where we have put @xmath37 .
in the calculation that follows we will need the generating function for @xmath38 , the number of @xmath13-vertex ( unrooted ) model ii graphs with @xmath26 2-loops . determining this is equivalent to solving the one - term truncation of model ii and the calculation follows that given in @xcite for models i and iii . as in that paper one can derive a recurrence relation valid for @xmath39 , [ eq : rrtwo ] ( -2 ) ( n , ) + 2 ( + 1 ) ( n,+1 ) = ( + 1 ) ( n+2,+1 ) .
the generating function is defined as ( x , y ) = _
n=4 even^_=0^(n , ) x^n y^ .
this is given by [ eq : solntwo ] = x^2 ( h^-3 - 3 y + 2 ) - h + _
n=4 even^ x^n h^-3n/2 , where @xmath40 and @xmath41 is the number of @xmath13-vertex model ii graphs , [ eq : counttwo ] = e^ ( ) n n^- .
in the previous section we gave the generating function for @xmath42 , which is the number of one - particle irreducible ( denoted `` 1pi '' ) graphs with a given number of vertices and 2-loops .
if we could generalize this generating function to the case of 1pi graphs with @xmath43 legs , then connecting together such graphs into cayley trees would give model i graphs and allow us to keep track of both @xmath36 and @xmath26 .
( 100,30)(0,0 ) ( 100,25)(0,0 ) the generating function for 1pi graphs with a root and @xmath44 other legs will be denoted by @xmath45 and drawn as in fig [ fig : roottree]a ( sometimes the root will be labelled with an `` r '' to distinguish it from the other legs ) .
it is a sum over such graphs weighted with factors of @xmath46 .
note that although the legs have been drawn on the exterior of the green function some of them may in fact be attached to links in the interior .
the generating function for trees will be denoted @xmath47 and is drawn as in fig [ fig : roottree]b .
fig [ fig : roottree]c gives an example of a tree contributing to @xmath47 . figure [ fig : eqntree ] shows that @xmath47 satisfies the equation [ eq : trelation ] t= _ m=0^_1m^ t^m
. it will be convenient to define a slightly different function @xmath48 which generates 1pi graphs with a root and @xmath44 `` exits '' .
an exit is defined to be a place at which a tree can be hung ( in either of two directions ) and is drawn as a link with a cross on it .
for example fig [ fig : exit]a contributes to @xmath49 and there are four corresponding contributions to @xmath50 . in general @xmath51 , but it should be noted that fig [ fig : exit]b can not be represented in this fashion and must be excluded from @xmath49 . to compensate an extra term ( fig [ fig : exit]c ) , @xmath52 ,
must be added to the equation , giving [ eq : treltwo ] t= _ m=0^ _ 1 m ( 2t)^m + x t^2 .
this formula then correctly distinguishes between graphs which differ only in that a tree has been hung off a link in the opposite direction ( these correspond to different triangulated surfaces ) .
( 100,25)(0,0 ) now define a generating function for the @xmath48 , [ eq : genexit ] ( x , y , z ) = _
n_2^c=0^ _
m=0^ g_1m(n , n_2^c ) x^n y^n_2^c z^m , where @xmath53 is the number of 1pi graphs with one root , @xmath44 exits , @xmath13 vertices and @xmath54 2-loops , that is , _ 1m= _
n_2^c=0^ g_1m(n , n_2^c ) x^n y^n_2^c .
this is what is needed , except for the fact that the 1-loops have been ignored .
the only contribution to ( [ eq : genexit ] ) from 1-loops occurs in @xmath55 and is equal to @xmath56 . the 1-loops will be weighted with an extra factor of @xmath57 and this is achieved by defining [ eq : tildegamma ] ( x , y , z , v)= ( x , y , z ) -x + xv .
hence from ( [ eq : treltwo ] ) we have that @xmath47 must satisfy [ eq : maineqn ] t= ( x , y,2t , v ) + x t^2 and then the solution @xmath58 is equal to @xmath59 defined in ( [ eq : defcalzr ] ) . the next task is to find the function @xmath60 .
in this section we are going to determine @xmath62 the generating function for @xmath53 .
however it is useful to find @xmath63 first , as this will provide a boundary condition .
below we show that [ eq : gonezero ] g_10(n - 1,n_2^c - 1)= 2 n_2^c ( n , n_2^c ) , for @xmath64 ( @xmath13 is even ) .
( 100,23)(0,0 ) take an @xmath13-vertex model ii graph @xmath15 with @xmath54 2-loops .
it has @xmath65 orientated 2-loops ( ie we count each
2-loop twice , once with an arrow going in one direction and once with the arrow reversed ) .
these can be grouped into equivalence classes of size @xmath14 ; each class consists of 2-loops which can be transformed into each other under the action of the symmetry group . removing an orientated 2-loop and replacing it with a leg ( as shown in fig [ fig : rootmod2]a ) produces a graph with @xmath66 vertices and @xmath67 2-loops .
note that we are ignoring the special case fig [ fig : rootmod2]b , for which @xmath68 and @xmath69 ; so the resulting formula will not apply for @xmath70 .
there is a one - to - one correspondence between equivalence classes of orientated 2-loops and rooted graphs .
the number of equivalence classes is _ g : ii ( n , ) = 2 ( n , ) , where the subscript on the summation means that we are summing over model ii graphs labelled with a @xmath15 , which have @xmath13 vertices and @xmath26 2-loops . equating this with the number of rooted graphs @xmath71 gives the required result .
now , ( x , y , z=0 ) =
= 0^ g_10(n , ) x^n y^and substituting ( [ eq : gonezero ] ) into this yields [ eq : boundary ] ( x , y , z=0 ) = + x , where @xmath72 is given by ( [ eq : solntwo ] ) .
( 100,20)(0,0 ) having determined the number of rooted @xmath13-vertex 1pi graphs with @xmath26 2-loops , we wish to generalize this to the case in which the graphs have @xmath44 `` exits '' .
consider adding an exit to a graph which has @xmath73 exits and @xmath66 vertices ; this will produce an @xmath13-vertex graph with @xmath44 exits .
if the exit is added to an ordinary link then @xmath26 is unchanged ( fig [ fig : addexit]a ) , if added to a 2-loop then @xmath74 ( fig [ fig : addexit]b ) and if added to a 1-loop then @xmath75 ( fig [ fig : addexit]c ) . ignoring the special case ( fig [ fig : addexit]c ) for a moment
, then we wish to make @xmath13-vertex graphs , with @xmath44 exits and @xmath26 2-loops .
bearing in mind that each such graph can be produced in @xmath44 ways ( ie any of the @xmath44 exits could be the one that we have just added ) , we have [ eq : exitrec ] m g_1m(n , ) = l_1 g_1 m-1(n - 1 , ) + l_2 g_1 m-1(n - 1,+1 ) , where @xmath76 is the number of ordinary links in a graph with @xmath66 vertices , @xmath73 exits and @xmath26 2-loops , and @xmath77 is the number of links lying on a 2-loop in a graph with @xmath78 such loops .
one can easily show that @xmath79 thus we have a recurrence relation for the coefficients of @xmath48 in terms of those in @xmath80 and a formula for @xmath55 .
note that ( [ eq : exitrec ] ) does not apply for @xmath70 , @xmath81 due to the special case ( fig [ fig : addexit]c ) . using ( [ eq : exitrec ] ) one can derive the following differential equation for @xmath62 , x^2 + 2x ( 1-y ) - ( x z + 1 ) - x + x^2 ( y-1 ) = 0 .
the solution is straightforward and gives @xmath82 as [ eq : thesolution ] ( x , y , z , v ) = _ 0 ( x ( 1-xz)^- , 1 + ( y-1 ) ( 1-x z)^2 ) + x^2 z ( y-1 ) + x(v-1 ) , where @xmath83 . using ( [ eq : boundary ] ) and ( [ eq : solntwo ] ) , this is given by [ eq : definegzero ] _ 0(x,y ) = x , with @xmath84 .
putting @xmath85 and using ( [ eq : maineqn ] ) gives [ eq : zeqn ] xz = 2x ( x , y , z , v ) + ( xz)^2 . as @xmath56 is increased from zero there is a non - analyticity at some critical value , @xmath86 .
this will give us the free energy of the model through @xmath87 . in order to determine @xmath86 we first need to find an expression for the grand canonical partition function @xmath59 .
defining @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 we can eliminate @xmath56 and @xmath91 from ( [ eq : zeqn ] ) in favour of @xmath92 and @xmath93 giving [ eq : chvarone ] ( 1-y^2 ) = ( 1- y^2 ) ^2 + 2 y^3 q . now defining [ eq : defineh ] h = =
, we have using ( [ eq : definegzero ] ) [ eq : definef ] _ 0 ( q,1 + y^4 ) = q^= q^f(h ) , where we have defined a function @xmath94 . putting this into ( [ eq : chvarone ] )
gives [ eq : chvartwo ] 0 = y^4 - 1 + 4 ^4 f(h ) + 4 ^6 ( ( 1-y^2 ) + ) .
noting that @xmath95 we can use ( [ eq : defineh ] ) to eliminate @xmath92 and write ( [ eq : chvartwo ] ) in terms of @xmath96 and @xmath97 , [ eq : sixthorder ] ( 3 ^2 ) f^6 + f^4 - 4 f^3 ( + ) - f^2 ( 4 f(h ) + ) + 1 = 0 .
this is a sixth order polynomial in @xmath98 , giving @xmath99 . to proceed further we require a more compact form for @xmath94 .
@xcite give a formula for the 2-legged 1pi generating function @xmath100 ( equation 64 of that paper ) , _ 2 = , ^2= ( 1- 2 ) ^2 where each vertex has a weight of @xmath101 ( note that @xmath101 is equivalent to @xmath102 in their notation ) .
now if we take each @xmath13-vertex model ii graph , pull out an orientated link from each equivalence class ( of size @xmath14 ) and cut it , then we get _ g : ii ( n ) = 3n 2-legged green functions .
each possible connected 2-legged green function is generated exactly once , so that denoting the number of such functions by @xmath103 we have @xmath104 . thus defining a new symbol @xmath105 , _ n=4 even^3n ^n = _ n=4
even^g_2(n ) g^n .
however @xmath100 generates 1pi 2-legged green functions and thus the right - hand side of the above equation is given by @xmath106 ( see fig [ fig : selfenergy ] ) ; the @xmath107 subtracts off the @xmath70 case .
( 100,20)(0,-5 ) the critical value of @xmath101 is @xmath108 and the corresponding critical value of @xmath109 is @xmath110 .
hence , @xmath111 we are lead to define the variable @xmath109 by h^3 = ( 1 - 2 ) ^2 and thus 4 h^2 f(h ) + 1 = ( 1 + 6 ) ( 1- 2 ) . now defining @xmath112 we can rewrite ( [ eq : sixthorder ] ) as 3 ^2 k^6 ^2 + 2 k^4 - 4 k^3 ( + ) ( 1 - 2 ) - k^2 ( 1 + 6 ) ( 1 - 2 ) + ( 1 - 2 ) ^2 = 0 .
this is a quadratic in @xmath109 and can be rewritten as [ eq : tauquad ] a(k ) ^2 + b(k ) + c(k ) = 0 with @xmath113 the aim of this calculation is to find the closest singularity to the origin for the grand canonical partition function , @xmath59 ( note that @xmath114 ) and thus we wish to express @xmath59 in terms of the new variables and hence in terms of @xmath56 . from ( [ eq : defineh ] ) we have that [ eq : zedroot ] z_r = and any non - analyticity in @xmath59 is due to the singular behaviour of @xmath115 , which is given by [ eq : fhinkt ] = . since the term in the square brackets is a function of @xmath116 it will be convenient to define a variable @xmath117 ( bear in mind that we have already defined @xmath118 , so that @xmath119 ) . given the definition of @xmath120 , k^3 = f^3 = ( 1 - 2 ) , so that [ eq : tau ] = and substituting this into ( [ eq : tauquad ] ) yields ( ) ^2 ( a+2b+4c ) + ( ) ( b+4c ) + c = 0 .
using equations ( [ eq : funca ] ) to ( [ eq : funcc ] ) this gives [ eq : kquartic ] k^4 - 2 q k^3 - k^2 + 8 q k - 4 q^2 = 0 , which is quartic in @xmath120 , so that we can in principle solve for @xmath121 .
this leaves the question of which root should be chosen . in the limit @xmath122 , we have from ( [ eq : zedroot ] ) that @xmath123 , @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
thus from ( [ eq : fhinkt ] ) we require @xmath126 , looking at ( [ eq : kquartic ] ) we see that at @xmath127 it becomes @xmath128 and the root we want is the one for which @xmath129 . using ( [ eq : fhinkt ] ) and ( [ eq : tau ] )
we can express @xmath115 in terms of @xmath120 and @xmath130 .
thus finally we have a formula for the grand canonical partition function , [ eq : finalsolution ] z_r= , where @xmath131 is a calculable function given by solving ( [ eq : kquartic ] ) . at this point
the simplest course of action was to write a computer program , which could evaluate ( [ eq : finalsolution ] ) at different values of @xmath56 and , by slowly increasing @xmath56 from zero , locate the closest singularity to the origin .
the non - analyticity occurs when @xmath131 , which is real for small real @xmath56 , becomes complex as @xmath56 is increased .
examination of the data for @xmath132 indicates that there is a third order phase transition ( see fig [ fig : thirdd ] , which plots various third derivatives of @xmath132 ) .
the location of the transition is most clearly seen in fig [ fig : reftau ] , which plots the quantity @xmath133 evaluated at @xmath86 ; the axes used are @xmath32 and the product @xmath134 .
there are two regions one for which @xmath135 and the other for which @xmath136 .
( 120,90)(0,0 ) ( 100,100)(0,0 )
in this section we are going to derive an equation for the critical line in the two - term model and determine the exponent @xmath137 for the different regions of the phase diagram .
it will be convenient to rewrite ( [ eq : kquartic ] ) as [ eq : kfour ] k^4 + a_3 k^3 + a_2
k^2 + a_1 k + a_0 = 0 , where we have defined the coefficients @xmath138 .
away from the critical line the closest singularity to the origin is due to a double root in this equation and thus , evaluating everything at @xmath86 , [ eq : kthree ] 4 k^3 + 3 a_3 k^2 + 2 a_2 k + a_1 = 0 . on the critical line
we have a triple root and hence [ eq : ktwo ] 6 k^2 + 3 a_3 k + a_2 = 0 .
now we have three equations in four unknowns ( @xmath139 ) giving a one parameter solution . in general
it would be difficult to solve these equations , but in this case there is a short cut ; we know that on the critical line @xmath135 and so @xmath140 ( from ( [ eq : tau ] ) ) . substituting this into ( [ eq : kthree ] ) to eliminate @xmath141 yields 6 k^2 + 3
a_3 k + 2 a_2 = 0 .
comparing this with ( [ eq : ktwo ] ) we have @xmath142 and @xmath143 . introducing a parameter @xmath144 gives = , k = e , ( + ) = ( 1 + 3 e^2 ) , q= e^3 .
it is easy to check that ( [ eq : kfour ] ) is satisfied and to derive a formula for the critical line , = ( + 3 ) - . at @xmath145 , @xmath146 ;
the above equation gives @xmath147 and hence the critical line intercepts the @xmath145 axis at @xmath148 . for @xmath149 , @xmath150 and
the intercept with the line @xmath151 occurs at the root of ( 1+t ) = ( 1+t^2 ) ^ , which is @xmath152 ( note that @xmath153 is not the correct root ) . in order to calculate @xmath137
it is necessary to find out how the derivatives of @xmath59 diverge as @xmath154 .
putting @xmath155 , [ eq : dzdq ] = - - - , where @xmath156 ; note that @xmath157 and @xmath158 in general , but that on the critical line @xmath159 . for the region at large @xmath0 and @xmath32 , @xmath160 and hence ~ ~ .
noting that for rooted graphs ~(q - q_c)^- , we have @xmath2 ( that is , this is a tree - like region ) . for the region at small @xmath0 and @xmath32 , @xmath135 and
the first derivative of @xmath161 is finite . differentiating ( [ eq : dzdq ] ) with respect to @xmath130 we find that ~ ~(q - q_c)^- ( + 1 ) and hence @xmath162 ( the pure gravity value ) . on the critical line ~ , giving @xmath3 .
thus the third order phase transition in the two - term model is a transition from an unmagnetized non - tree - like region to a tree - like phase .
this provides good evidence for the existence of such a transition in the full model .
presumably as more terms are included in the free energy , the critical line will move somewhat and it is not entirely obvious whether the intercept with the line @xmath151 will occur at non - zero @xmath32 or @xmath153 in the full model .
the original aim of solving this model was to determine the extent of the tree - like region , in particular we are interested in finding the point at which the tree - like , magnetized and unmagnetized phases meet ( assuming that such a point exists ) ; the value of @xmath0 at this point is denoted @xmath163 . in previous work we made an estimate of the location of the tree - like region based on the region for which @xmath132 was approximately linear .
it will be useful to compare the location of the critical line with the boundary of the approximately linear region ( referred to as the `` knee '' of the solution ) ; the linear region can be defined to be that for which @xmath164 . we will take @xmath165 giving @xmath166 at the knee ; this corresponds to our previous estimate that the graphs were tree - like for @xmath167 at small @xmath32 @xcite . in fig
[ fig : phaseknee ] is plotted the line of the phase transition in the @xmath0@xmath32 plane and also the location of the knee .
the tree - like phase is inside the linear region and the two lines are quite close in the area of interest ( near @xmath168 ) . using the phase line as an approximation to the location of the phase transition in the full model we can estimate the point at which it intercepts the boundary of the magnetized region .
although we do not know exactly where the critical line separating the magnetized and unmagnetized phases lies , we have that @xmath169 for the single spin ising model @xcite and we know from monte carlo simulations @xcite that @xmath170 only increases slowly with @xmath0 .
taking @xmath171 gives an estimate of @xmath172 , but this is likely to be an over - estimate since the phase line changes rapidly with @xmath32 and the value of @xmath32 that we are using is too small ( it corresponds to the critical coupling for @xmath173 ) .
an estimate using our old criterion based on the knee would give a value of @xmath21 .
overall then we conclude that @xmath21 @xmath5 and that the corresponding value of the central charge , above which there exists a tree - like phase in the full model , is @xmath6 @xmath7 .
( 150,110)(0,0 )
in fig [ fig : phase ] we have drawn some possible forms for the phase diagram of model i. the magnetized region is labelled m , the tree - like region t and the remaining unmagnetized non - tree - like region u. if the critical line in the two - term model were an accurate representation of that in the full model then the correct phase diagram would be fig [ fig : phase]a .
however , one expects that as more terms are included in the truncated model the location of the critical line will change and it is not entirely clear where point a will move to .
it is possible that a tends towards the @xmath153 axis as more terms are added in which case fig [ fig : phase]b would be the correct diagram .
other possibilities , such as fig [ fig : phase]c or the absence of a tree - like region , can not be entirely ruled out , but seem unlikely given the results presented in this letter and those due to wexler @xcite .
( 140,120)(0,0 ) the two - term model has a third order transition with @xmath174 on the critical line ac and the full model may well show the same behaviour .
it is interesting to note that the model in reference @xcite also has @xmath174 on the line separating the branched polymer and unmagnetized phases ( in this model @xmath175 at the point where the three phases meet ) .
the order of magnitude estimate of @xmath21@xmath5 ( point c in fig [ fig : phase ] ) is similar to the largest value of @xmath0 ( ie @xmath176 ) used in simulations so far .
it is to be hoped that future simulations will manage to locate the onset of the branched polymer phase .
one should note that our estimate of @xmath163 is not sufficiently accurate to exclude the possibility that @xmath177 , although numerical simulations seem to rule this out . in conclusion then , significant progress has been made in elucidating the nature of the phase diagram for the multiple ising model on dynamical planar 3 graphs , in particular in the large @xmath0 limit , but much work remains to be done before the nature of the @xmath9 barrier is fully understood .
i would like to thank john wheater for useful discussions concerning this work and to acknowledge the support of pparc through the research studentship gr / h01243 . | we consider a model of @xmath0 independent ising spins on a dynamical planar 3 graph . truncating the free energy to two terms yields an exactly solvable model that has a third order phase transition from a pure gravity region ( @xmath1 ) to a tree - like region ( @xmath2 ) , with @xmath3 on the critical line .
we are able to make an order of magnitude estimate of the value of @xmath0 above which there exists a branched polymer ( ie tree - like ) phase in the full model , that is , @xmath4@xmath5 , which corresponds to a central charge of @xmath6@xmath7 .
epsf by 8 mm 3@xmath8 |
recently , a lot of works have been carried out to investigate the phase effects induced by one single photon with many atoms @xcite . in these
works the single photon not only supply energy to the system but also act as information ( phase ) carrier .
a position - dependent excitation phase , dependent on the positions of excited atoms , is brought when atom in the ensemble is excited by one single photon .
and such position - dependent excitation phase leads to a large number of quantum phenomena , such as directed spontaneous emission @xcite , dynamical evolution of correlated spontaneous emission @xcite , collective lamb shift @xcite , quantum interference and quantum storage in photon echo media @xcite , etc . in order to describe this position - dependent excitation phase , timed dicke state which contains
the information of the excitation phase was introduced by scully and his colleagues @xcite , through this state phase effects caused by one single photon can be explained and this kind of excitation phase can also be further understood . it is well known that one of the factors effecting the coupling strength between light and matter is the light intensity .
the coupling strength may be very weak when a single photon field interacts with matter , because the single photon has little intensity .
however , by means of the cavity the coupling strength can be greatly enhanced even between one single photon and matter @xcite .
the simplest model of the cavity qed is one atom cavity system , which is a well - known quantum system and is intensively used in quantum optics and quantum information science @xcite . while further elaboration of single photon technologies push for the new quantum systems . here
two atoms in cavity promises to be very useful tool for quantum control of the single photon field , because the two - atom cavity system can realize more rich physical processes due to larger controllable hilbert spaces .
it is worth noting that the coherent control of two - atom cavity system has been already demonstrated in recent experiments @xcite . in this paper
, we investigate the quantum transport effects caused by excitation phase of one single photon in a two - atom cavity system . in this system two atoms located at different positions in an open cavity and they are excited by one external single photon with equal probability but with different excitation phases for their different positions . due to the basic characteristic of cavity qed
, energy exchange is existed between the cavity mode and atoms , the excitation phases brought by photon will be transferred between atoms and cavity mode with the photon exchange .
we show that the cavity mode could get a photon with different excitation phases which can lead to quantum interference effect .
we have also demonstrated that the coherent photon transfer is highly effected by the different coupling constants due to the different atomic positions in the cavity , because in such situation new coupling relationships are introduced for coherent exchange of photon between the atoms and cavity mode .
we analyze the dynamical and decoherent behaviors of this system with considering the interatomic dipole - dipole interaction and interaction with the free space light modes through the open cavity , which can greatly influence the evolution of two - atom cavity system .
all of those properties are summarized by analyzing the dynamical behaviors of the dark state .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii we present a scheme for preparation of the initial state in two - atom cavity system and analyze the states of the system under the conditions when two atoms have equal and unequal coupling constants with cavity mode . in sec .
iii we give the dynamical behaviors of the system by using master - equation approach .
finally , we give our conclusion in section iv .
is absorbed by two atoms .
the preparation of a heralded single - photon field with narrowband spectrum and efficient absorption by a single atom in a free space scheme has been reliably experimentally observed @xcite with the probability excitation close to one percent . ] the principal scheme of the proposed experiment is depicted in fig .
[ fig:1 ] . here
two identical two - level atoms are located in an open cavity .
one heralded single photon with wave vector @xmath0 incidents from side of the cavity , which ensures the photon initially absorbed by the atoms instead of the cavity mode .
if no photon detected ( by the detector d2 ) at the emitting direction outside of the cavity we know that the single photon is absorbed by atoms , and the state of the system can be expressed as @xmath1 ( @xmath2)indicates that the atoms with position @xmath3 and @xmath4 are in the excited ( ground ) and ground ( excited ) state , respectively , @xmath5 indicates no photon in the cavity mode .
the phase factor @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) shows that an atom with position vector @xmath8 is excited by the photon with wave vector @xmath0 .
these two atoms are strongly coupled with the cavity mode , with free space ( vacuum modes ) outside the open cavity and interact with each other via the dipole - dipole interaction . for simplicity , in this section
we consider only the interactions of atoms with the cavity mode , or the atoms with free space modes ( in appendix b ) separately .
we briefly describe the main properties of these interactions and present the quantum states which play important role in the evolution of two - atom cavity system .
the interaction hamiltonian of this atom - cavity system is @xmath9 where @xmath10 ( @xmath11 ) is the raising ( lowering ) operator for the @xmath12th atom , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are field creation and annihilation operators of the cavity mode , @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the resonance frequency of atoms and cavity mode , respectively .
@xmath17 is the coupling constant between @xmath12th atom and cavity mode and has the form of @xmath18 @xcite , @xmath19 is the wave vector of the cavity , @xmath20 is the projection of the @xmath21 to the cavity axis and @xmath22 , @xmath23 is the angle between @xmath19 and the atomic joining line @xmath24 . due to the interaction between atoms and cavity , photon together with excitation phases
will be transferred between atoms and cavity .
but the dynamical behaviors of photon displays very different features for the cases of @xmath25 and @xmath26 , which actually corresponds to different physical essences . in the following subsections
we focus our discussion on these two conditions . in order to investigate the dynamical evolution of the photon unitary time - evolution operator method @xcite
is used , and the unitary time - evolution operation is given by @xmath28 for simplicity , we consider the simplest condition that the frequency of cavity mode @xmath16 is equal to the resonance frequency of the two - level atoms @xmath15 , the analytic form of @xmath29 under the condition of @xmath25 is given in appendix a. the state of system at any time @xmath30 can be simply obtained by using the relation : @xmath31 on substituting @xmath32 and @xmath29 from eqs .
( [ 1 ] ) and ( [ a1 ] ) into eq . ( [ 4 ] ) , we have @xmath33 where @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 contained in the first term indicates one photon in cavity mode .
three terms are contained in eq .
( [ 5 ] ) , which correspond to three different states .
the state contained in the first term describes the excitation of the cavity mode and it includes two kinds of excitation phases which originate from absorbing photon with phases @xmath38 and @xmath39 from atoms located in the positions @xmath3 and @xmath4 , respectively .
from this term it can be seen that the cavity mode may absorb the photon with the same probability but different excitation phases .
we calculate the probability of cavity mode to show the dynamical behavior of the photon : @xmath40 where @xmath41 ( @xmath42 is the amplitude of the cavity mode ) and @xmath43 is conjugate of @xmath44 , substituting eq .
( [ 5 ] ) into eq .
( [ 6 ] ) @xmath45),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the interference term exhibits a cosine modulation with relative phase @xmath46 .
thus the change of the wave vector @xmath47 will provide a coherent control of the photon emission in the cavity mode .
the state contained in the second term is identical to the initial state of eq .
( [ 1 ] ) and this corresponds to a process that the photon is firstly transferred from an atom ( e.g with position vector @xmath8 ) to the cavity mode and then transferred back to the same atom ( still the atom with position vector @xmath8 ) .
the state described by the third term has the similar expression with eq .
( [ 1 ] ) but with the excitation phases interchanged , which indicates that a photon is firstly transferred from an atom ( e.g with position vector @xmath8 ) to the cavity mode but transferred back to another atom ( the atom with position vector @xmath48 with @xmath49 ) .
actually the last two states of eq .
( [ 5 ] ) can be separated into two parts , one is decoupled from the cavity mode ( time - independent terms ) and we use @xmath50 to express it @xmath51 where @xmath52 is also the dark state of the free space ( see appendix b ) and it is decoupled from the cavity mode under the condition of @xmath25 @xcite . the remaining part is coupled with the cavity mode and we use @xmath53 to express it @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the bright state of the free space ( see appendix b ) , which is coupled with the cavity mode and can exchange energy with the cavity mode under the condition of @xmath25 . in the basis of @xmath56 and @xmath57 , the initial state ( [ 1 ] )
can be decomposed into two components @xmath58 , @xmath59 .
apparently the dark state @xmath56 shown in eq .
( 10 ) is decoupled with both cavity mode and vacuum under the condition of @xmath25 , and therefore photon assumes to be conserved in this state for a very long time . in this atom - cavity system
only the bright state @xmath57 exchanges photon and excitation phases with the cavity mode and finally leads to the quantum interference effects . for two atoms with different positions
, they may posses different excited phases during the excited process as shown in eq .
( [ 1 ] ) , while for a standing wave cavity the different atomic positions may also lead to the different coupling strengths , i.e. , @xmath26 .
the simple analytic form for @xmath29 in the condition of @xmath26 can not be obtained , but different physical essences can be revealed by comparing the dynamical behaviors of the dark state at the conditions of @xmath61 and @xmath26 . by using the interaction hamiltonian of eq .
( [ 2 ] ) the dark state of the cavity can be obtained according to the following definition @xmath62 where we still only consider the resonance condition @xmath63 . here
@xmath64 is used to present the dark state of the cavity mode and it can be expressed as latexmath:[\[\label{12 } unlike the dark sate @xmath56 shown in eq .
( [ 8 ] ) the dark state of the cavity mode of eq .
( [ 12 ] ) is related to the coupling constants @xmath66 when @xmath67 .
the bright state of the cavity mode can be obtained according to @xmath68 latexmath:[\[\label{13 } we can infer that when @xmath25 the dark and bright states of cavity mode @xmath64 and @xmath70 are the same with the ones of free space @xmath56 and @xmath57 , because in the free space each atom also has the equal coupling strength with the vacuum modes .
however , when @xmath26 they are different from the ones of free space , because in this situation two atoms have unequal coupling strengths with the cavity mode but equal coupling strength with the vacuum mode .
so when @xmath25 the dark and bright states of free space ( @xmath56 and @xmath57 ) and cavity mode ( @xmath64 and @xmath70 ) have the same expression and do not need to distinguish , while when @xmath26 the dark and bright states of free space and cavity mode are different and should be distinguished . due to the difference of @xmath71 and @xmath72 eqs .
( [ 12 ] ) and ( [ 13 ] ) can also be written as latexmath:[\[\label{14a } latexmath:[\[\label{14b } which are superposition states of the dark state @xmath56 and bright state @xmath57 . from eq .
( [ 14b ] ) we know that the dark state @xmath56 is no longer decoupled with cavity mode when @xmath26 , therefore in this condition the dark state @xmath56 also exchanges energy with the cavity mode
. what s more , from eq .
( [ 14b ] ) we can conclude that the states @xmath56 and @xmath57 could get coupled via the cavity mode .
all of which can greatly effect the dynamical behavior of the cavity mode and atoms .
in section ii we discussed the two - atom cavity system with considering the effects of cavity and free space separately .
however , for an open cavity system the atoms interact with the cavity mode and free space mode simultaneously .
we analyze these effects in the framework of master equation approach . in this system
the distance between two atoms is closer than the radiation wavelength where the dipole - dipole interaction of two atoms @xcite will play a significant role in the analyzed processes .
the master equation of this atom - cavity system can be expressed as @xmath74-i\omega_{c}[a^{\dag}a,\rho]-i\sum_{i\neq j}\omega_{ij}[\sigma_{i}^{\dag}\sigma_{j},\rho ] \notag \\ & & -i \sum_{i=1}^{2}[g_{i}a\sigma_{i}^{\dag}+h.c,\rho]-\sum_{i , j=1}^{2}\gamma_{ij}(\rho\sigma_{i}^{\dag}\sigma_{j}+\sigma_{i}^{\dag}\sigma_{j}\rho\notag \\&&-2\sigma_{j}\rho\sigma_{i}^{\dag})-\kappa(\rho
a^{\dag}a+ a^{\dag}a\rho-2a\rho a^{\dag}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath75 is the energy operator for @xmath12th atoms , @xmath76 and @xmath77 are the dipole - dipole interaction term and the cooperative decay rate , respectively , @xmath78 describes the cavity losses .
the expression of dipole - dipole interaction and the cooperative decay rate are @xcite @xmath79\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath80\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath81 is the spontaneous decay rate of the individual atom , @xmath82 is the dipole moment , @xmath83 is the distance between the two atoms , @xmath84 is the angle between the dipole moment @xmath82 and the vector @xmath85 , @xmath86 .
similar to @xcite , in our system the excited atoms bring the position dependent excitation phase excited by a single photon .
but general form of the master equation eq .
( [ 15 ] ) does not contain information about the initial state of two atoms . we can easily account for the initial state by using the basis atomic states that contain the initial phases of the excited atoms .
@xmath87 is the ground state of the system , @xmath88 ( @xmath7 ) means that atom with position vector @xmath8 is excited and brings an position - dependent excitation phase @xmath6 , @xmath89 indicates the excitation state of cavity mode . by means of these basis states
the dynamical behaviors of the two - atom cavity system can be investigated through density matrix equations given in appendix c. especially , we are interested in the dynamical behaviors of cavity mode and atoms when the excitation phase is considered .
( the angle between wave vector @xmath0 and @xmath90 ) .
the inset figure does not consider the dipole - dipole interaction , i.e. @xmath91 , @xmath92 .
other parameters : @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath23 is the angle between @xmath19 and the atomic joining line @xmath24 and here @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 . ] in fig .
[ fig:2 ] we give the probability of finding the input photon in the cavity mode under the condition of @xmath25 and @xmath93 . as shown in fig .
[ fig:2 ] the probability of cavity mode show oscillation and has the maximum value in each period with @xmath100 , and the amplitude decreases with @xmath101 decreasing .
these phenomena match the result given in eq .
( [ 7 ] ) , when @xmath100 the interference term @xmath102 $ ] has value of 1 , which corresponds to the completely constructive interference . when @xmath103 and @xmath104 the values of the interference term are smaller than 1 , which corresponds to the incompletely constructive interference , thus the amplitudes of cavity mode in these cases are smaller than the case of @xmath100 .
the only changed parameter in fig .
[ fig:2 ] is the angle @xmath101 and the different angle @xmath101 actually introduce different excitation phases , which correspond to different degrees of quantum interference on the cavity mode . such quantum interference can also be explained by eq .
( [ 10 ] ) , with @xmath25 only bright state @xmath57 couples to the cavity mode and the probability amplitude of this state is related to the angle @xmath101 . .
the inset figure does not consider the dipole - dipole interaction , i.e. @xmath91 , @xmath92 .
other parameters : @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath105 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 . ] in fig .
[ fig:3 ] we give probability of finding the input photon in the cavity mode under the condition of @xmath26 .
the probability of cavity mode still show oscillation forms , but when @xmath100 the cavity mode has the minimum value in each period , which is very different from fig .
[ fig:2 ] . because when @xmath26 the amplitudes of the cavity mode not only dependent to the angle @xmath101 but also sensitive to the coupling constants between atoms and cavity mode . when @xmath26 the state of the cavity mode would be @xmath107 is a function of @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath30 .
according to eq .
( [ 6 ] ) the probability of cavity mode absorbing a photon is @xmath108),\ ] ] and we can infer that the quantum interference displays very differently under the conditions of @xmath109 and @xmath110 . in fig .
[ fig:2 ] with @xmath109 constructive interference is displayed with the increase of the angle @xmath101 , while in fig .
[ fig:3 ] with @xmath110 it presents destructive interference with the increase of the angle @xmath101 . on the other hand we notice that the lifetime of the cavity mode in fig .
[ fig:3 ] is longer than that in fig .
[ fig:2 ] though the cavity mode has a smaller amplitudes in fig .
[ fig:3 ] .
the reason is that in fig .
[ fig:2 ] with @xmath25 only bright state @xmath57 couples to the cavity mode , while in fig .
[ fig:3 ] with @xmath26 both the dark state @xmath56 and bright state @xmath57 couple to the cavity mode .
therefore when @xmath26 the energy exchange is also existed between dark state @xmath56 and cavity mode and it is known that the lifetime of the dark state @xmath56 is longer than the bright state @xmath57 . finally ,
when analyzing the properties of photon exchange in the two - atom cavity system , we should notice a visible influence of the dipole - dipole interaction to the amplitude and period of the photon oscillations .
in particular , in fig . [
fig:2 ] the dipole - dipole interaction decreases the oscillation amplitude .
the situation is complicated in fig .
[ fig:3 ] , where the dipole - dipole interaction decreases the oscillation amplitude when @xmath100 but increases the oscillation amplitude when @xmath104 and @xmath103 .
besides , in fig . [ fig:3 ] the oscillation period is also changed by the dipole - dipole interaction , for example , when @xmath100 the cavity mode has faster oscillation in the first period and slower oscillation in the second period then similar situation repeats in the following periods . while when @xmath103 and @xmath104 oscillation velocity in each period is opposite to the one when @xmath100 . in order to further illustrate the difference between the conditions of @xmath25 and @xmath26 , time - evolutions of dark states and atoms
are given in fig .
[ fig:4](a ) and fig .
[ fig:4](b ) . in fig .
[ fig:4](a ) when @xmath25 , dark states @xmath56 and @xmath64 decay exponentially with time and the two curves are overlapping as we analyzed in section ii .
however , with @xmath26 the dark states @xmath56 and @xmath64 are non - overlapping and decay faster than the case of @xmath25 . besides , when @xmath26 the curves of @xmath56 and @xmath64 show oscillation forms .
( @xmath95 ) and @xmath26 ( @xmath105 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] ) .
other parameters : @xmath104 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 . in fig .
( [ fig:4 ] ) @xmath111 and @xmath112 are the population of @xmath64 and @xmath56 , respectively .
@xmath113 is the population of atoms.,title="fig : " ] ( @xmath95 ) and @xmath26 ( @xmath105 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] ) .
other parameters : @xmath104 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 . in fig .
( [ fig:4 ] ) @xmath111 and @xmath112 are the population of @xmath64 and @xmath56 , respectively .
@xmath113 is the population of atoms.,title="fig : " ] these difference can be explained by means of eq .
( [ 14b ] ) , usually the dark state @xmath56 decouples to the cavity mode but when @xmath26 it couples to the cavity mode , so energy exchange is existed between the dark state @xmath56 and the cavity mode when @xmath26 and oscillation is appeared . from eq .
( [ 14b ] ) we also notice that with @xmath26 the dark state @xmath56 also get coupled with the bright state @xmath57 via the cavity mode , therefore the dark state @xmath56 can decay to the vacuum through both the cavity losses and the bright state which leads to its faster decay .
similar situation happens to the cavity mode dark state @xmath64 , when @xmath26 the @xmath64 is the dark state of the cavity mode but not the free space . in this situation
the dark state @xmath64 couples to the bright state @xmath57 and decays to the vacuum through the bright state @xmath57 , which leads to its faster decay in comparison with the case of @xmath61 .
the oscillation shown on the @xmath64 is caused by dipole - dipole interaction but not the energy exchange between the cavity mode , because @xmath64 is decoupled with the cavity mode . in fig .
[ fig:4](b )
the probability of photon in atomic excitation state shows oscillation forms under the conditions of @xmath25 and @xmath26 , but when @xmath26 the atoms decay faster than at the condition @xmath25 .
the population of atoms can be expressed as @xmath114 where @xmath112 and @xmath115 are the population of dark state @xmath56 and bright state @xmath57 . @xmath111 and @xmath116 are the population of dark state @xmath64 and bright state @xmath70 .
when @xmath25 dark state @xmath56 and bright state @xmath57 are decoupled and these two components decay independently , the bright state decays faster than the dark state and finally only the dark state left .
however , when @xmath26 dark state @xmath56 and bright state @xmath57 get coupled via the cavity mode .
the decay process of the dark state @xmath56 is affected by the bright state @xmath57 and the decay rate of atoms is larger compare with the condition of @xmath25 , which leads to the faster decay of atoms . in fig . [
fig:4](b ) we also notice that the oscillation under the condition of @xmath26 last longer than the condition of @xmath25 and similar phenomenon also happens in the cavity mode of fig .
[ fig:3 ] .
here this phenomenon is also caused by the energy exchange between dark state @xmath56 and cavity mode .
( @xmath95 ) and @xmath26 ( @xmath105 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] ) .
other parameters : @xmath117 , @xmath104 , @xmath94 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
the inset of fig .
[ fig:5](a ) show the dynamical behavior of dark state @xmath56 under the atomic distances of @xmath117 and @xmath93 .
the inset of fig .
[ fig:5](b ) show the dynamical behavior of dark state @xmath56 affected by different cavity decay rates @xmath99 and @xmath118.,title="fig : " ] ( @xmath95 ) and @xmath26 ( @xmath105 $ ] , @xmath106 $ ] ) .
other parameters : @xmath117 , @xmath104 , @xmath94 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
the inset of fig .
[ fig:5](a ) show the dynamical behavior of dark state @xmath56 under the atomic distances of @xmath117 and @xmath93 .
the inset of fig .
[ fig:5](b ) show the dynamical behavior of dark state @xmath56 affected by different cavity decay rates @xmath99 and @xmath118.,title="fig : " ] as was shown above the two atom cavity system excited by a heralded single photon can demonstrate a variety of quantum dynamics scenario .
this is of particular interest to consider the generation of long - lived dark state in these processes . in fig .
[ fig:5 ] we analyze the factors which could affect the generation of dark state . in fig .
[ fig:5 ] we present the population probability of the dark state under the distance of @xmath117 and @xmath104 .
the reason for choosing such small atomic distance is that the small atomic distance can increase the decay rate of bright state and decrease the decay rate of the dark state .
the population probability of the dark state under the condition of @xmath93 and @xmath117 is compared in inset of fig . [ fig:5](a ) .
the initial value of dark state is larger when @xmath93 but it decays very quickly and almost 0 at @xmath119 .
this means that under a given excitation phase the generation of the dark state is strongly influenced by the dipole - dipole interaction related to the different atomic distances . in fig .
[ fig:5](a ) we give the dynamical behavior of dark state under the condition of @xmath25 and @xmath26 . as shown in fig .
[ fig:5](a ) the dynamical behavior of dark state is a straight line with small decay rate when @xmath25 . while when @xmath26 oscillation form is displayed on the line of dark state , which violate the stability of dark state should be . in fig .
[ fig:5](b ) we present the effect brought by cavity losses . as shown in fig .
[ fig:5](b ) the population of atoms @xmath113 oscillates at the beginning due to the periodic energy exchange between atoms and cavity mode then it tends to the line of @xmath112 . that s because the initial state of eq .
( [ 1 ] ) contains components of dark state @xmath56 and bright state @xmath57 , the bright state decay faster than the dark state and finally only the dark state left in this system .
the cavity decay rate determines the time to obtain a dark state and it needs shorter time to get a pure dark state in a bad cavity . as shown in fig .
[ fig:5](b ) after @xmath120 almost a pure of dark state can be obtained with @xmath99 , while this time can be greatly decreased when @xmath118 .
this happens because the large cavity losses lead to a faster decay for the bright state but has no effect on the dark state .
however , the cavity losses can effect the dynamical behavior of dark state when @xmath26 , the inset of fig .
[ fig:5](b ) shows that with @xmath26 the dark state will decay rapidly and we can not obtain a dark state under this situation .
two atom system is a promising system that attracts an increasing wave of attentions @xcite . in this paper ,
two atoms are located in an optical cavity .
we study the phase effects in a coherent transport of a single photon excitation in this system that is induced by external heralded single photon .
we show that this process seems to be interesting for efficient coherent control and storage of single photons by manipulating the initial excitation phase of two atoms .
we first analyze the role of the prepared initial quantum state and we find that the excitation atomic phases can lead to strong quantum interference effects on the cavity mode excitation .
we further show that such quantum interference of the intracavity photon is not only effected by the excitation phase but also controlled by the coupling constants between atoms and cavity .
when the coupling constants are different for two atoms , interesting physical phenomena are displayed in the dynamical behavior of cavity mode and atoms .
all of these phenomena are caused by new coupling relationships between atoms and cavity mode .
especially , when the coupling constants between atoms and cavity mode are different , the dark state of free space couples to the cavity mode and energy exchange is existed between such dark state and cavity mode .
in addition , due to the existence of excitation phase the initial state can be decomposed into dark and bright states , which can present a feasible scheme to generate dark state through this two - atom cavity system using one narrowband heralded single photon .
also we have found that the dipole - dipole interaction plays an important role in the photon transfer in the two - atom cavity system . in particular this interaction can influence the photon exchange and for small interaction distance it provides stronger generation of the long - lived two atomic dark states .
however , clearer understanding the role of dipole - dipole interaction to the properties of two - atom cavity system requires further studies that will be a subject of future investigation .
we acknowledge support on the national natural science foundation of china ( grant no.11174109 ) .
sergey a. moiseev thanks support of high - end foreign experts from the state administration of foreign experts affairs of china ( grant no , gdw 20152200077 ) and russian foundation for basic research ( grant no.14 - 02 - 00903/14 ) .
substituting eq . ( [ 3 ] ) into eq .
( [ 2 ] ) and after a long and tedious calculation eq . ( [ 2 ] ) has the expression as @xmath121 \notag \\&&-i\frac{1}{c}\sin(gtc)a\sum_{i=1}^{2}\sigma_{i}^{+}-ia^{\dag}\frac{1}{c}\sin(gtc)\sum_{i=1}^{2}\sigma_{i } \notag \\&&-\sum_{i\neq j}\sigma_{i}^{+}\sigma_{j}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath122 .
in fig . [ fig:1 ] atoms can interact with the free space mode through the open cavity .
the interaction hamiltonian which considers the dipole - dipole interaction is @xmath123 according to the hamiltonian of eq .
( [ b1 ] ) the dark state of the free space can be expressed as @xmath124 and the bright state of the free space is @xmath125 eqs .
( [ b2 ] ) and ( [ b3 ] ) are also known as antisymmetric and symmetric @xcite states when not consider the cavity vacuum part ( i.e. @xmath5 ) .
we derive the equations of evolution for the elements of the density operator by using master equation of eq .
( [ 15 ] ) and the basis of eq .
( [ 18 ] ) . where @xmath135 , @xmath136 , with @xmath101 being the angle between the propagating direction of driving field and the joining line of the two atoms .
the position vectors of atoms can be any values because the dynamical behaviors of the system are only affected by the interatomic distance @xmath24 .
for simplicity , we here assume position vector @xmath137 , so only relative phase left in the density matrix equations .
piro , nicolas , and j. eschner , _ single photon absorption by a single atom : from heralded absorption to polarization state mapping . engineering the atom - photon interaction _
( springer international publishing 2015 ) . | we investigate the quantum interference effects of single photon transfer in two - atom cavity system caused by external excitation phase . in the proposed system , two identical atoms ( with different positions in the optical cavity )
are firstly prepared into a timed state by an external single photon field . during the excitation ,
the atoms grasp different phases which depend on the spatial positions of the atoms in the cavity . due to strong resonant interaction between two atoms and optical cavity mode the absorbed input photon
can be efficiently transferred from the atoms to the resonant cavity mode .
we show that the quantum transfer is highly sensitive to the external excitation phases of atoms and it leads to quantum interference effects on the cavity mode excitation . besides
, the quantum transfer is also influenced by the dipole - dipole interaction dependent to the atomic distance . in this system
the atomic positions also determine the coupling constants between atoms and cavity mode which causes additional interference effects to the photon exchange between atoms and cavity .
based on the characteristics of excitation phase we find that it is a feasible scheme to generate long - lived dark state and it could be useful for storage and manipulation of single photon fields by controlling the excitation phase .
pacs number(s ) : 42.50.pq , 42.50.nn , 37.30.+i |
one of the main problems in boundary integrable field theories is to find boundary conditions that preserve the integrability of a given bulk integrable field theory , that is , integrable boundary conditions .
this has been carried out for several models by direct inspection of higher - spin conserved charges @xcite . in @xcite
( see also @xcite ) it has been shown that models with @xmath1 or @xmath3 symmetry admit a family of @xmath4 integrable boundary conditions , which are obtained by requiring @xmath5 field components to satisfy neumann and the remaining @xmath6 to satisfy dirichlet , @xmath7 .
these conditions are of diagonal type , which means that scattering off the boundary will not change the flavor of the incoming particle
. we will refer to this type of boundary scattering problem as the diagonal case .
a natural question one would ask then is if there are more integrable boundary conditions for these models with @xmath1 symmetry , or if the diagonal case exhaust all possibilities .
the purpose of this paper is to study the possible integrable boundary conditions for models with @xmath1 global symmetry .
we find nondiagonal integrable boundary conditions for the @xmath1 nonlinear @xmath2 ( nl@xmath2 ) model .
these are genuinely nondiagonal boundary conditions in the sense that they can not be put into diagonal form by a redefinition ( global rotation ) of the fields .
these conclusions should carry out to other models , like the @xmath3 gross - neveu and principal chiral models .
the structure of this paper is as follows . in the next section
we review some of the generalities of boundary integrable field theories which are relevant for our discussion .
we also review the goldschmidt - witten argument , and use it to establish the integrability of the @xmath1 nonlinear @xmath2 model . in section 3
we look at a very simple example , to illustrate some of the issues that are relevant in our analysis . in section 4
we introduce the new integrable boundary conditions for the nonlinear @xmath2 model , which are the main concern of this paper . in section 5
we compute the nondiagonal reflection matrices associated to these boundary conditions by solving the boundary yang - baxter equation , in particular we look at the @xmath8 case , and present a solution for the @xmath9 case to which we do not know what are the corresponding boundary conditions .
finally in section 6 we present our conclusions and some possible directions for further work .
let us consider a bulk integrable field theory defined by an action s= _
-^+ dx_1 _ -^+ dx_0 _ b ( , ) , where @xmath10 is the bulk lagrangian , which depends locally on the field @xmath11 and its partial derivatives . is symbolic and may denote a collection of fields , bosonic or fermionic fields and so on .
] we say that it may be defined by a local action because there are several bulk integrable models that are not , such as perturbed conformal field theories .
as is well known , in two - dimensions integrability has several important consequences : in a multi - particle scattering process there is no particle production and the set on in and out momenta is the same , the @xmath12-matrix factorizes into a product of two - body @xmath12-matrices , and the two - body @xmath12-matrix satisfies the yang - baxter equation , besides the usual requirements of unitarity and crossing - symmetry .
these conditions , together with the knowledge of the symmetries of the @xmath12-matrix , often allow one to determine the two - body @xmath12-matrix exactly , up to cdd factors .
when we consider this theory on the half - line , the introduction of a boundary may easily break the conservation of bulk charges , as it is seen in the simple case of linear momentum .
therefore we are not assured that the resulting model will be integrable , and we must specify boundary conditions .
these boundary conditions correspond to boundary dynamics , which may be described by some local lagrangian .
the boundary version of a given bulk model is defined by the action s=_-^0 dx_1
_ -^+ dx_0 _ b ( , ) + _
-^+ dx_0 _ b(.|_x=0 , .
|_x=0 ) , where @xmath13 is the boundary action , depending only on the values of the field @xmath11 and its time derivatives , at @xmath14 .
the boundary lagrangian defines the boundary dynamics , and it s easy to see that it induces boundary conditions through equations of motion .
for example , for a scalar boson we have _ 1 in order to have a boundary integrable model , we have to pick a suitable boundary action such that a combination of bulk conserved charges is still conserved .
in order to discuss boundary conserved charges , we briefly review the bulk case . a local ( bulk )
conservation law of spin @xmath15 is written as _
-j_+^(s+1)=_+ r_-^(s-1 ) _ + j_-^(s+1)=_- r_+^(s-1 ) , and from these equations , one easily establishes the conservation of the following charges q_+=_-^+ dx_1 ( j_+^(s+1)- r_-^(s-1 ) ) q_-=_-^+ dx_1 ( j_-^(s+1)- r_+^(s-1 ) ) in proving that these charges are conserved we have to use the fact that we can discard surface terms .
when we restrict our model to the half - line we can not do that with the surface term at @xmath14 . on the other hand , if the following condition @xcite is satisfied j_-^(s+1 ) -j_+^(s+1 ) + r_-^(s-1 ) -r_+^(s-1 ) = ( t ) [ condition ] where @xmath16 is a _ local _ field , then = _
-^0 dx_1 ( j_- ^(s+1)+j_+^(s+1 ) -r_-^(s-1)-r_+^(s-1 ) ) -(t ) is a conserved charge .
for example , in light - cone coordinates the energy - momentum charges are @xmath17 , but after the introduction of a boundary only @xmath18 is conserved , with @xmath19 .
we should look for the possible boundary conditions that we can impose to a given model such that [ condition ] holds .
once this is done one should look for solutions of the boundary yang - baxter equation ( bybe ) which can be related to the proposed boundary conditions .
we describe the bybe in the next subsection boundary integrability is encoded in the boundary yang - baxter equation ( bybe ) in a similar way as bulk integrability is encoded in the yang - baxter equation ( ybe ) .
we should stress that , unlike the bulk case , we do not know what is the symmetry group at the boundary a priori . in the bulk case
the knowledge of the bulk global symmetries greatly simplify the form of the @xmath12-matrix .
unfortunately we do not have a similar set up for the boundary case , and therefore the analysis of the possible structure of the reflection matrix will have to rely on general physical arguments .
recently this issue has been addressed in @xcite for the case of the nonlinear schroedinger model .
we review now a few well - known concepts . for a more complete discussion , see @xcite the hilbert space of in ( out ) asymptotic states is spanned by the multi - particle states |a_i_1(_1),a_i_2(_2 )
a_i_1(_1)a_i_2(_2 )
a_i_n(_n)|0_in(out ) , where the @xmath20 are the faddeev - zamolodchikov ( fz ) operators that create the one - particle asymptotic states , the @xmath21 are the rapidities and @xmath22 for in - states and the other way around for out - states , and @xmath23 is the in ( out ) vacuum .
we assume henceforth that the in and out vacuum are the same .
multiparticle scattering processes factorize in a product of two - body @xmath12-matrix , which is defined in terms of the fz operators by a_i(_1)a_j(_2)=s_ij^kl(_1-_2 ) a_l(_2)a_k(_1 ) .
[ twobody ] the ybe is obtained by requiring the associativity of the algebra defined by [ twobody ] in defining the reflection matrix we have to change the hilbert space .
boundary scattering processes are defined in terms of the boundary state @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is the so - called boundary - state operator @xcite .
the hilbert space is spanned by @xmath26 , where the in ( out ) states are obtained by setting @xmath27 ( @xmath28 ) .
similarly to the bulk case , the reflection matrix is defined by a_i()b = r_i^j()a_j(-)b .
[ rmatrix ] we represent the @xmath12-matrix and the reflection matrix @xmath29 graphically as in figure 1 .
0.5 cm 0.5 cm fig .
1 the s - matrix and the reflection matrix the bybe is obtained by requiring the compatibility of [ rmatrix ] with [ twobody ] by looking at the process @xmath30 .
0.5 cm 0.5 cm fig .
2 the boundary yang - baxter equation . in terms of the two - body @xmath12-matrix and reflection matrix
, it reads s_ji^nm()r_n^p(_1)s_mp^ql(_+)r_q^k(_2)= r_i^p(_2)s_jp^nm(_+)r_n^q(_1)s_mq^kl ( ) , [ bybe ] where we introduced the variables @xmath31 and @xmath32 , and sum over @xmath33 and @xmath34 . besides the bybe
, one must impose unitary and crossing - symmetry conditions on the reflection matrix .
we quote them here , and refer the reader to @xcite for more details .
the unitarity condition is r_i^k()r_k^j(-)=_i^j [ unitarity ] , and the boundary crossing symmetry is r_i^j(-)=s_kl^ij(2 ) r_k^l(+ ) , where we are assuming implicitly that the particles are invariant under charge conjugation . for the general case
we refer to @xcite and the appendix of @xcite .
in this subsection we briefly review the main features of the @xmath1 nonlinear sigma model .
the model is defined by the following lagrangian = where @xmath35 is an @xmath36-dimensional vector subject to the constraint @xmath37 .
this constraint can be implemented by means of a lagrange multiplier @xmath38 in the action .
it is straightforward to see that the equation of motion for @xmath35 in light - cone variables ( @xmath39 ) is _
+ _ - = -(_+ _ - ) . this will be used in establishing the integrability of the boundary conditions of section 4 .
the main features of the model is that it is classically conformal , asymptotically free , and displays dynamical mass - generation .
we can use the fact that the model is classically conformally invariant in order to show that it is indeed an integrable model at the quantum level . starting with the classical conformal symmetry and exploring the structure of the possible anomalies that appear after quantization
, goldschmidt and witten @xcite , and earlier polyakov @xcite , have shown that some conserved currents are not spoiled by quantization , that is , there _ are _ anomalies , but their structure is such that one can rewrite the quantum corrections to the conservation law as a total derivative , allowing us to write down non - trivial conserved charges .
this argument can be used to establish the integrability of the gross - neveu model @xcite and of the principal chiral model @xcite . in this subsection
we review the goldschimdt - witten argument and write down the conserved currents that will be of use to establish the integrability of the new boundary conditions for the model .
the goldschmidt - witten ( gw ) argument starts by observing that the trace of the energy - momentum of a classically conformal - invariant theory vanishes , that is @xmath40 .
this implies that the conservation of energy - momentum reads
_ - t_++=0 _ + t_=0 which , on its turn has as a consequence that for any integer @xmath5 _ - ( t_++)^n=0 _ + ( t_)^n=0 .
[ tower ] therefore , we generate towers of classically conserved currents .
after we quantize the theory the equations [ tower ] do not make sense any more , since we are considering products of operators at the same point , and these operators should be redefined .
in general these equations will be spoiled by anomalies .
the right hand side of [ tower ] will be nonzero , but there are still several constraints we should impose on the possible terms that are generated : whatever comes due to anomalies has to have the correct dimension , lorentz weight , a quantity @xmath41 , we say that @xmath11 has lorentz weight @xmath42 .
] , and group theoretic properties as the left - hand side . by analyzing all the possible terms that may appear on the right - hand side of [ tower ] , with @xmath43
, gw showed that they can all be written as total derivatives , which implies that we have a nontrivial conserved current .
for the model they showed that the possible anomalies can be written as _ + ( t_)^2=c_1 _ + ( _ -^2_-^2)+ c_2_- ( _ + _ - _ -_-)+ c_3_-(_-^3_+ ) , [ chargenls ] with some constants @xmath44 and an analogous equation for @xmath45 .
in @xcite we used these charges to establish the integrability of the aforementioned diagonal boundary conditions .
we will see that we can use them to establish the integrability of nondiagonal boundary conditions too .
once the model has been established to be integrable we can proceed and compute its two - body @xmath12-matrix .
this has been done in @xcite , and we quote it here for further reference . since the bulk is @xmath1 invariant , the @xmath12-matrix has to be of the form s_ij^kl()=_1()_ij^kl+ _ 2()_i^k_j^l+ _ 3()_i^l_j^k where the @xmath46 are determined by the solving the ybe @xcite , unitarity , and crossing - symmetry . in @xcite
a large-@xmath36 expansion check has been performed to show that this is indeed the exact @xmath12-matrix of the @xmath1 model .
the @xmath46 are given by & & _ 1()=-_2 ( ) , _ 3()=-_2 ( ) + & & _ 2()= .
where @xmath47 .
we will also need the isoscalar @xmath12-matrix element @xmath48 , which can be written as _
i()=- _ 2 ( )
. this will be useful when we solve the boundary crossing unitarity condition in section 5 .
for @xmath49 one has to be careful , since @xmath50 but @xmath51 . in this limit
we get _ 1()=-f ( ) , _ 2()=0 , _ 3()=-f ( ) where the function @xmath52 is given by f()= .
the @xmath8 model is not a simple massless free boson , as the map @xmath53 and @xmath54 would suggest .
it is actually the sine - gordon model at @xmath55 , the sine - gordon potential being a marginally - relevant perturbation at this point , and it describes the kosterlitz - thouless point of the classical @xmath56 model .
before we analyze the nondiagonal boundary conditions for the model , let us look at a very simple example of nondiagonal scattering , consisting of 2 free bosons @xmath57 and @xmath58 , with equal mass @xmath59 , on the half - line , which captures some of the main physical aspects for the case of the model . the action we consider is s=_-^ dx_0 _ -^0 dx_1 ( _ 1)^2 + m_1 ^ 2 _ 1 ^ 2 + ( _ 2)^2 + m_2 ^ 2 _ 2 ^ 2 + _ -^ _ b(_1 , _ 1 , _ 2 , _ 2 ) , where @xmath60 is the boundary action , to be chosen shortly . clearly any quadratic form at the boundary can be solved exactly , being obviously integrable .
we have consider two possibilitites is trivial , since there is no coupling between the two fields .
we are also disregarding possible boundary mass terms . ]
= g_1 _ 1_2 [ l1 ] + _
b^2= g_2 _ 1 _ 2 [ l2 ] recall that a boundary lagrangian @xmath61 induces the following boundary condition .
|_x=0 = .|_x=0 .
since the masses of the two particles are the same , which is required to have nondiagonal scattering , we can define new fields
@xmath62 by _ = ( _ 1 _ 2 ) , which leave the bulk action with the same form but takes the boundary action to = g_1 ( _ + ^2 - _ -^2 ) and therefore we conclude that the boundary condition induced by [ l1 ] is not really nondiagonal . on the other hand , for the second boundary lagrangian it is not possible to find an orthogonal transformation which diagonalizes the boundary lagrangian . in this sense
we can say that the boundary lagrangian ii corresponds to nondiagonal boundary scattering .
it is fairly easy to find the reflection amplitudes for [ l2 ] .
the boundary conditions induced by [ l2 ] are ( using @xmath0 for @xmath63 ) .
|_x=0&= & .
g |_x=0 + .
|_x=0&= & .
-g |_x=0 by using the mode expansion for the fields , _
i(x , t)=d ( a_i()e^(im()t - im()x)+ a_i^ ( ) e^(-im()t+im()x ) ) where the @xmath64 are the fz operators , and the definition of the reflection matrix @xmath65 given in [ rmatrix ] , we find the scattering amplitudes to be r_i^j()= ( cc & + & ) .
notice that , as expected , the diagonal amplitudes are the same , and the off - diagonal ones have opposite signs . moreover if we expand the elements of the reflection matrix in powers of the coupling constant @xmath0 , the diagonal elements are even functions of @xmath0 , whereas the off - diagonal ones are odd functions of @xmath0 .
this can be understood by noticing that each flavor change at the boundary is accompanied by a factor of @xmath0 , and so in order to have diagonal ( nondiagonal ) boundary scattering we need an even ( odd ) number of @xmath0 s .
we will use some of the intuition from this very simple model in the study of the nondiagonal boundary conditions for the model .
as we have seen in section 3 there are essentially two possibilities we could try for the boundary conditions in the model .
one of them , [ l1 ] , is not even integrable in this case .
we are left then with the boundary conditions induced by a boundary lagrangian of the form [ l2 ] , s_nl = s_b + _ -^+ dx_0 m_ijn_i , [ action ] where we have to have @xmath66 , and the indices @xmath67 and @xmath68 run through a subset of @xmath69 . for the remaining indices , which correspond to particles scattering diagonally , we choose dirichlet boundary conditions _ 0 n_j|_x=0=0 .
[ bcnls1 ] the reson for this choice will become clear in the next section . from [ action ] we get the following boundary conditions for the non - diagonally scattering fields _
1n_i|_x=0=m_ij_0n_j|_x=0 .
[ bcnls2 ] we have to check that the condition [ condition ] is satisfied for these boundary conditions , that is & & ( _ -_-)^2-(_+_+)^2 + c_1(_+^2_+^2- _ -^2_-^2)+ + & & + c_2(_+_- _ + _ + - _ + _ - _ -_-)+ + & & .
+ c_3(_+^3_--_-^3_+ ) |_x=0= ( t ) for some local field @xmath16 .
we discuss this condition term by term .
the first term can be simplified to ( _ -_-)^2-(_+_+)^2= 8_0_1(_0_0+_1_1 ) , where the subscripts @xmath70 and @xmath71 denote time and space derivatives , respectively .
the `` @xmath72 '' term can be simplified to _ + ^2_+^2-_-^2_-^2=16_00_01- 8_0 _ 1 ( _ 0_0-_1_1 ) , the `` @xmath73 '' term to _ + _ - _ + _ + - _ + _ - _ -_-=4_0_1 ( _ 0_0-_1_1 ) and the `` @xmath74 '' term to _ + ^3_--_-^3_+= 8 _ 0(_01_0-_00_1)-2 _ 0_1 ( _ 0_0-_1_1 ) we see from these that we have to have @xmath75 in order that [ condition ] is satisfied . moreover , if we consider [ bcnls1 ] and [ bcnls2 ] , we immediately see that the one `` bad '' remaining term @xmath76 vanishes .
this establishes the integrability of [ bcnls1 ] and [ bcnls2 ] .
since @xmath77 is an antisymmetric matrix , there is a real - orthogonal matrix @xmath78 , such that @xmath79 is block - diagonal , each block being an antisymmetric @xmath80 matrix .
if @xmath77 has @xmath81 zero eigenvalues we readily see that its structure will have @xmath82 symmetry , where there are @xmath83 @xmath8 s ( and therefore @xmath84 must be even ) .
the @xmath8-symmetric blocks correspond to interactions between pairs of field components at the boundary , that is , a particle of a given type , say @xmath67 , can scatter diagonally or onto some other fixed particle of type @xmath68 , where the pairing @xmath85 is fixed .
the question we should try to answer now is , in which ways can we break the boundary symmetry ? in the diagonal case , the bulk @xmath1 symmetry is broken to @xmath86 at the boundary , with @xmath87 .
we will be looking at solutions that respect this symmetry , and so we should consider matrices @xmath77 symmetric under @xmath88 . but
this implies that the only case we should consider is @xmath89 , where the @xmath8-symmetric part corresponds to non - diagonal scattering , and the remaining @xmath90 to diagonal scattering , that is , the components @xmath91 satisfy & & _ 1n_1|_x=0=g_0 n_2|_x=0 , _ 1n_2|_x=0=-g_0 n_1|_x=0 + & & _ 0n_j|_x=0=0 j=3,4, ,n .
[ bcnls ] we have chosen the diagonally - scattering field components to satisfy dirichlet boundary conditions , but at this point it seems that we could have chosen them to satisfy neumann . as we will see later , the solutions of the boundary yang - baxter equations are such that in the `` diagonal '' limits the correct choice for the diagonally - scattering components is indeed dirichlet boundary conditions . in @xcite corrigan and sheng have established the classical integrability of the neumann boundary condition for the @xmath1 model , for all @xmath36 , and found one extra boundary condition for @xmath92 . in @xcite
we showed that this special boundary condition was integrable at the quantum level to .
we will show now , that it is actually related to the ones we propose in this paper .
the explicit form of the corrigan - sheng boundary condition for the @xmath93 model is _
1 |_x=0= -k _ 0 |_x=0 + ( k_0 ) |_x=0 k _ 0 choose @xmath94 , where @xmath0 is a coupling constant .
this means that @xmath95 and so @xmath96 is a constant at the boundary .
this , together with the constraint @xmath97 , imply @xmath98 at @xmath14 .
the corrigan - sheng boundary condition reduces to & & _ 1 n_1|_x=0 = _ 0 n_2 & & _ 0 n_3 |_x=0 = 0 .
this is the same boundary condition we are considering in the @xmath93 model case .
in this section we will compute the reflection matrices associated to the boundary condition identified previously .
we will concentrate on the model , since the ones for the gn and pcm models , can be found by attaching suitable cdd factors .
since we are interested in the integrable flows for these boundary conditions , we will revisit the diagonal case before . in @xcite the reflection matrices associated to the diagonal boundary conditions found in @xcite
were computed ( see also @xcite ) .
one question one may ask is if there are integrable _ diagonal _ flows , that is , if it is possible to go from a configuration with , say , @xmath77 components satisfying neumann and the remaining @xmath99 dirichlet boundary conditions , to some other other configuration with @xmath100 neumann and @xmath101 dirichlet boundary conditions . we will see that this is not possible .
let us suppose that there are two flavors @xmath67 and @xmath68 that scatter diagonally . consider the scattering process @xmath102 .
let s call the reflection amplitude for the @xmath67 particle @xmath103 , and for the @xmath68 particle @xmath104 the bybe for this process is , therefore & & r_1(_1)r_2(_2)_2(_+)_3(_-)+ r_2(_2)r_2(_1)_3(_+)_2(_-)= + & & = r_1(_1)r_1(_2)_2(_-)_3(_+)+ r_1(_2)r_2(_1)_3(_-)_2(_+ ) .
dividing by @xmath105 and introducing @xmath106 , and @xmath107 , we get ( x(_1)-x(_2))_3(_-)= ( x(_1)x(_2)-1)_3(_+ ) . by taking the limit @xmath108
, we arrive at the following differential equation x()= .
[ ratio ] the solutions for [ ratio ] are @xmath109 which means that the amplitudes @xmath110 , or x()= .
[ x_eq ] notice that this result is true for any pair of diagonally scattering flavors . using [ x_eq ]
we will show now that there are no integrable diagonal flows .
suppose there are 3 diagonally scattering flavors , and call them @xmath111 and @xmath112 . from [ x_eq ] we know that = , = = with some constants @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
but these equations are incompatible , unless one of the ratios is @xmath71 .
this proves that we can not have more than 2 different types of reflection amplitudes in the diagonal case .
moreover , as it was shown in @xcite , if we assume that there are only 2 types of reflection amplitudes , the constant @xmath115 in [ ratio ] can be fixed using the bybe to be @xmath116 .
now we can easily show that there are no diagonal integrable flows . since the ratios are fixed by the bybe
, we simply can not go diagonally from a reflection matrix where there are @xmath81 particles satisfying neumann boundary condition , to one where there are @xmath117 .
in this subsection we use the bybe [ bybe ] in order to find the reflection matrices corresponding to the boundary conditions identified earlier . using the intuition gained in section 3 we have the following ansatz for the reflection matrix r= ( ccccc a ( ) & b ( ) & 0 & 0 & + -b ( ) & a ( ) & 0 & 0 & + 0 & 0 & r_0 ( ) & 0 & + 0 & 0 & 0 & r_0 ( ) & + & & & & ) , [ r_matrix ] where @xmath118 , @xmath25 and @xmath119 are to be determined .
let us consider the scattering process @xmath120 the bybe for this process is & & r_0(_1)r_0(_2)_3(_+)_2()+ r_0(_2)a(_1)_2(_+)_3()= r_0(_1)r_0(_2)_3()_2(_+)+ + & & + a(_1)a(_2)_2()_3(_+)- b(_1)b(_2)_2()_3(_+ ) . [ block ] dividing this equation by @xmath121 , and defining @xmath122 and @xmath123 , we get ( x(_1)-x(_2))_3()= ( x(_1)x(_2)-1)_3(_+)- y(_1)y(_2)_3(_+ ) , and by taking the limit @xmath124 , we obtain the following differential equation x()= .
[ ratio1 ] notice that if @xmath125 this equation reduces to the one for the diagonal case [ ratio ] .
since we have two unknown functions now , we need one more equation .
this is accomplished by the bybe for @xmath126 after dividing by @xmath127 , and taking the limit @xmath124 , we get y()= .
[ ratio2 ] we can easily solve equations [ ratio1 ] and [ ratio2 ] by introducing @xmath128 , which satisfy z_()= . this is the same equation we obtained earlier for the diagonal case [ ratio ] .
the solution for @xmath129 and @xmath130 are , therefore x()=(+ ) y()=(- ) [ xy ] notice that the purely diagonal case corresponds to @xmath125 , that is @xmath131 , and we recover [ x_eq ] .
one aspect that may look puzzling is the fact that , at this point , we have two constants to be fixed , @xmath115 and @xmath132 , but only one coupling constant @xmath0 . in order to find a further constraint involving @xmath115 and @xmath132 , consider the scattering process @xmath133 after dividing by @xmath134 , we plug the solutions [ xy ] into [ cc ] to obtain , after an elementary but tedious calculation , that c+c=-i [ c+c ] we have checked that the expressions [ xy ] together with [ c+c ] solve all the remaining bybe s .
there are two ways to get diagonal reflection matrices from [ xy ] and the constraint [ c+c ] .
the first one is by setting @xmath131 , and we obtain the result for the diagonal case with @xmath135 fields satisfying neumann boudary condition and the remaining @xmath136 dirichlet @xcite .
this is the deciding factor that made us choose dirichlet boundary conditions for the diagonally - scattering fields in section 4 .
the other way to have diagonal reflection matrices is by having both @xmath115 and @xmath132 go to @xmath137 . in this case
we have @xmath109 and we conclude that all field components satisfy the same boundary condition , that is , dirichlet . therefore if we write @xmath138 and @xmath139 , where @xmath140 is a ( unknown ) function of the boundary coupling constant , we have that , for @xmath141 ( @xmath135 neumann , @xmath136 dirichlet ) we should have @xmath142 ( and so @xmath143 ) , and for @xmath144 ( all dirichlet ) , @xmath109 and so @xmath145 . we see , then , that there are integrable flows between diagonal reflection matrices , and that the reflection matrices we found have the correct behaviour , as compared to the one dictated by the microscopic boundary lagrangian .
all that is left to do now is to solve the boundary unitarity and boundary crossing - symmetry conditions , which will be dealt with shortly .
based on the `` very simple example '' studied before and the solution we found for the case of 2 nondiagonal fields , we are tempted at constructing other solutions of the bybe in a similar fashion as the one just done . as we will see now , there are no such solutions .
consider the following ansatz for the @xmath146 model r()= ( ccccc a ( ) & b ( ) & 0 & 0 & 0 + -b ( ) & a ( ) & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & 0 & a ( ) & b ( ) & 0 + 0 & 0 & -b ( ) & a ( ) & 0 + 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & r_0 ( ) ) , [ 4fields ] this reflection matrix should correspond to the following boundary action s_b=_-^+ dx_0 ( n_1-n_2 + n_3-n_4 ) in principle we could have two different coupling constants , one for the fields @xmath147 and @xmath148 and another for @xmath96 and @xmath149 , but we are choosing them to be equal in order to simplify the argument .
since this case is a special point of the general case , the absence of solutions in this case will establish our claim that there are no solutions with more than 2 nondiagonal fields .
we will look at the @xmath146 case , but the argument is the same for @xmath1 with more than on nondiagonal block .
the bybe for the processes @xmath150 and @xmath151 and @xmath152 have the same form as the ones given in [ xy ] . if we consider now the bybe for the process latexmath:[$|a_5(\theta_1)a_5(\theta_2)\rangle
\rightarrow besides the diagonal one ( @xmath131 ) for the constants @xmath115 and @xmath132 , and therefore there is no solution of the bybe consistent with [ 4fields ] .
before we proceed , we should mention another solution of the bybe for even @xmath36 , but to which we do not know how to assign microscopic boundary conditions .
let us consider the following block - diagonal ansatz for the reflection matrix r()= ( ccccc a ( ) & b ( ) & 0 & 0 & + -b ( ) &
a ( ) & 0 & 0 & + 0 & 0 & a ( ) & b ( ) & + 0 & 0 & -b ( ) & a ( ) & + & & & & ) , the bybe for the process @xmath154 , and taking the limit @xmath155 , we get ( ) = ( ) , whose solution is = , where @xmath156 is a constant .
we have checked that this alone solves all the remaining bybe s , and therefore @xmath156 is left as a free - parameter .
all we need to do is to fix @xmath157 using unitarity and boundary crossing symmetry . since their solution is quite straightforward , we will not quote it here . the only diagonal reflection matrix that can be obtained from this solution
is by taking @xmath158 , which corresponds to all components satisfying neumann boundary conditions .
if @xmath159 we have a block diagonal solution , each block being antisymmetric .
note that one must be careful in taking @xmath160 , since unitarity and crossing symmetry will give a prefactor with an overall dependence on @xmath156 , which precisely cancels the @xmath156 dependence of @xmath161 in this limit . in the limit
@xmath162 we can solve the bybe completely . in this subsection
we will not write down the bybe s explicitly , since they can be derived quite easily , and the @xmath8 case is not our main interest .
we will describe which equations one needs to solve to fix the structure of the reflection matrix completely , in any case .
initially consider the general form for the reflection matrix r()= ( cc f ( ) & w ( ) + h ( ) & g ( ) ) .
the bybe for @xmath163 gives h(_1)w(_2)=h(_2)w(_1 ) .
[ hw ] if these amplitudes are non - zero , we have to have w()=h ( ) , where @xmath156 is a constant .
next , the bybe for @xmath164 requires ( ) = ( ( ) ^2 - 1 ) whose solution is = for some constant @xmath165 . finally , the bybe for @xmath166 demands g()=h ( ) .
the reflection matrix is , then , r()=h ( ) ( cc & + 1 & ) .
[ r_o2 ] to obtain the solution where we would have set @xmath167 ( or equivalently @xmath168 ) in [ hw ] , all we should do is to set @xmath158 in [ r_o2 ] .
we have checked that [ r_o2 ] solves all the remaining bybe s .
the function @xmath169 may be fixed by unitarity and boundary crossing - unitarity , but again , we are not going to carry out this computation here .
one aspect that may look puzzling is the fact that we know that the @xmath8 model is related to the sine - gordon model , and [ r_o2 ] has 3 independent parameters , unlike the boundary sine - gordon model , where one has only 2 independent parameters .
the reason for that is that we are not looking at the sg model at arbitrary coupling constant , but at @xmath55 , and as pointed out in @xcite , at special points for the coupling constant ( like this one ) there are more solutions than the ones presented there for arbitrary @xmath165 .
we now go back to the solution of unitarity and boundary - crossing symmetry conditions for the reflection matrix [ r_matrix ] .
the next two subsections refer to this reflection matrix .
the boundary - unitarity condition implies that r_0()r_0(-)=1 , [ u1 ] and a()a(-)-b()b(-)=1 a(-)b()+a()b(-)=0 .
[ u2 ] by dividing [ u2 ] by @xmath170 , and using the explicit forms [ xy ] , we see that [ u2 ] is satisfied trivially .
therefore , all we have to solve from unitarity is [ u1 ] .
the boundary - crossing unitarity condition for the diagonal part of the reflection matrix is r_0(-)=((n-2)_1(2)+_2(2)+ _
3(2))r_0(+)+ 2_1(2)a(+ ) [ bcu ] . using [ xy ] and [ c+c ] ,
we can rewrite [ bcu ] as r_0(-)=r_0(+)(_i(2 ) + 2_1(2)(x(+)-1 ) ) [ bcu2 ] .
all the other boundary - crossing unitarity equations are equivalent to this one.using the parametreization for @xmath115 and @xmath132 introduced after equation [ c+c ] , and after some elementary , but tedious , computation , we can cast [ bcu2 ] into a quite compact form r_0(-)=r_0(+)_i(2 ) [ bcu3 ] finally we can fix @xmath171 by solving [ bcu3 ] and [ u1 ] & & r_0()= - + & & k ( ) where @xmath172 is the solution of [ bcu3 ] and [ u1 ] without the @xmath173-dependent factors @xcite ,
k()= - this fixes the reflection matrix completely .
this solution for the reflection matrix reduces to the appropriate diagonal solutions in the limits @xmath174 ( @xmath135 neumann , @xmath136 dirichlet ) and @xmath175 ( all dirichlet ) .
it would be interesting to study the analytical structure of this reflection amplitude , but this requires the knowledge of the explicit form of the function @xmath140 .
we have found new integrable boundary conditions for the @xmath1 model which are nondiagonal and depend on one free parameter .
the integrable boundary conditions presented here break the @xmath1 symmetry to @xmath89 .
a similar conclusion has been reached for the @xmath176 spin chain in @xcite .
these boundary conditions , together with the diagonal ones proposed in @xcite , are argued to exhaust the possible integrable boundary conditions for the @xmath1 model .
we also found solutions of the bybe which depend on one parameter and that can be associated to these boundary conditions , and saw that they do satisfy the appropriate limits , which correspond to the coupling constant @xmath177 or @xmath137 .
we found the most general solution of the bybe for the @xmath8 model , which is described by a three - parameter family , unlike the well - known two - parameter solution of the boundary sine - gordon .
this is understood by noting that the @xmath8 model corresponds to the @xmath55 sine - gordon model , and as pointed out in@xcite , at this point , and in general for points where @xmath178 , there are additional solutions . in section 4
we established the integrability of the nondiagonal boundary conditions , by inspecting the spin-@xmath179 charges proposed in @xcite .
there were no constraints on how many nondiagonal blocks one can have , whereas we found that there are solutions of the bybe only in the case of one single nondiagonal block .
one possible explanation for that is that by inspecting higher spin charges there would be further constraints on the possible boundary conditions , but this is still to be checked .
recently , mackay and short @xcite have studied the principal chiral model with a boundary and found an interesting relationship between their boundary conditions and the theory of symmetric spaces .
their solutions , though , are quite different from ours , and some work should be done in trying to clarify their relationship .
there are several directions to be pursued now .
the @xmath12-matrix for the elementary excitations in the @xmath3 principal chiral and @xmath1 gross - neveu models , are , up to cdd factors , the same as the one for the @xmath1 model , and therefore the bybe s for all the three models is the same .
this means that it should be possible to find microscopic lagrangians which provide nondiagonal boundary conditions for these other models , similar to the ones presented here , also depending on one free parameter .
another problem that arises naturally is to find the exact form of the function @xmath140 , which is , in general quite hard ( as for example , in the case of the boundary sine - gordon model ) .
a related problem is to perform a large-@xmath36 expansion for the reflection matrices ( diagonal and nondiagonal ) as a check of their validity .
unfortunately a framework of how to perform boundary perturbation theory is yet to be developed .
finally , the study of the thermodynamics of the boundary model would be an interesting , if somewhat challenging , problem .
i would like to thank t. becher , a. de martino , p. fendley , t. jayaraman , a. petrov , v. sahakian , and g. thompson for discussions .
the hospitality of the abdus salam ictp , george thompson , and sissa are gratefully acknowledged .
this work is in part supported by the nsf .
s. ghoshal and a. zamolodchikov , _ `` boundary @xmath12-matrix and boundary state in two - dimensional integrable quantum field theory '' _ , int . j. mod .
phys . a * 9 * , 3841 - 3886 ( 1994 ) , [ hep - th/9306002 ] .
p. bowcock , e. corrigan , p. e. dorey and r. h. rietdijk , _
`` classically integrable boundary conditions for affine toda field theories '' _ , nucl .
b * 445 * , 469 - 500 ( 1995 ) [ hep - th/9501098 ] .
m. moriconi and a. de martino ,
_ `` quantum integrability of certain boundary conditions '' _ , phys . lett .
b * 447 * , 292 - 297 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9809178 ] .
m. ameduri , c. j. efthimiou and b. gerganov , _
`` on the integrability of the bukhvostov - lipatov model '' _ mod .
a * 14 * , 2341 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9810184 ] .
n. j. mackay , _ `` the so(n ) principal chiral field on a half - line '' _ , j. phys .
aa * 32 * , l189-l193 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9903137 ] .
n. j. mackay and b. j. short , _ `` boundary scattering , symmetric spaces and the principal chiral model on the half - line '' _ , [ hep - th/0104212 ] .
a. m. polyakov , _ `` hidden symmetry of the two - dimensional chiral fields '' _ , phys .
b * 72 * , 224 ( 1977 ) .
e. witten , _
`` some properties of the @xmath180 model in two dimensions '' _ , nucl . phys .
b * 142 * , 285 ( 1978 ) .
y. y. goldschmidt and e. witten , _
`` conservation laws in some two - dimensional models '' _ , phys . lett .
b * 91 * , 392 - 396 ( 1980 ) .
m. mintchev , e. ragoucy and p. sorba , _ `` spontaneous symmetry breaking in the gl(n)-nls hierarchy on the half line '' _ , [ hep - th/0104079 ] .
a. zamolodchikov and a. zamolodchikov , _
`` factorized s - matrices in two dimensions as the exact solutions of certain relativistic quantum field models '' _ , annals phys . *
120 * , 253 - 291 ( 1979 ) .
a. de martino and m. moriconi ,
_ `` tricritical ising model with a boundary '' _ , nucl .
b * 528 * , 577 - 594 ( 1998 ) [ hep - th/9803136 ] .
a. b. zamolodchikov and a. b. zamolodchikov , _
`` relativistic factorized s matrix in two - dimensions having o(n ) isotopic symmetry '' _ , nucl .
b * 133 * , 525 - 535 ( 1978 ) [ jetp lett .
* 26 * , 457 ( 1978 ) ] .
e. corrigan and z. sheng , _ `` classical integrability of the o(n ) nonlinear sigma model on a half - line '' _ int .
j. mod .
a * 12 * , 2825 - 2834 ( 1997 ) [ hep - th/9612150 ] .
a. de martino and m. moriconi , _ `` boundary s - matrix for the gross - neveu model '' _ , phys .
b * 451 * , 354 - 364 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9812009 ] .
s. ghoshal , _ `` boundary s matrix of the o(n ) symmetric nonlinear sigma model '' _ phys .
b * 334 * , 363 - 368 ( 1994 ) [ hep - th/9401008 ] .
j. abad and m. rios , _
`` nondiagonal solutions to reflection equations in su(n ) spin chains '' _ , phys .
b * 352 * , 92 - 95 ( 1995 ) [ hep - th/9502129 ] . | we find new integrable boundary conditions , depending on a free parameter @xmath0 , for the @xmath1 nonlinear @xmath2 model , which are of nondiagonal type , that is , particles can change their `` flavor '' through scattering off the boundary .
these boundary conditions are derived from a microscopic boundary lagrangian , which is used to establish their integrability , and exhibit integrable flows between diagonal boundary conditions investigated previously .
we solve the boundary yang - baxter equation , connect these solutions to the boundary conditions , and examine the corresponding integrable flows .
= -0.7 in h l o p
s c # 1#2#3#4#1 * # 2 * , ( # 4 ) # 3 clns 01/1750 + + [ multiblock footnote omitted ] + _ newman laboratory of nuclear studies , cornell university _ + _ ithaca , new york 14853 , usa _ + |
in order to obtain a more profound understanding of the interactions between baryons with and without strangeness the major goal of hypernuclear physics is to explore the spectral properties of @xmath0 hyperons in a nucleus .
the experimentally well confirmed existence of @xmath0 single particle states @xcite indicates the importance of static mean - field interactions .
while the overall features are reasonably well reproduced by non - relativistic @xcite and relativistic approaches @xcite open questions exist on finer details of hypernuclear spectra . in light nuclei ,
@xmath4 , the smallness of the spin - orbit splitting and other fine structures of @xmath0 single particle spectra are well described by multi - configuration shell model calculations with empirical matrix elements @xcite .
these calculations emphasize the importance of residual interactions and configuration mixing .
theoretical studies of dynamical self - energies in @xmath0 nuclei , predicting rather strong contributions from the coupling of the @xmath0 to excitations of the nuclear core , point in a similar direction @xcite .
this , however , is not fully complying with recent observations of well separated and relatively sharp @xmath0 single particle structures in the medium - mass @xmath5v and @xmath6y hypernuclei @xcite .
the measured spectra are compatible with a much stronger spin - orbit strength than expected from the low mass region , amounting to spin - orbit interaction energies of 1 to 2 mev , but the data do not indicate a strong damping of the @xmath0 single particle states .
the conclusion to be drawn from these - partly conflicting - findings is that there is a clear necessity for more precise measurements and an enlarged body of data . for more decisive results on @xmath0-nucleus interactions
medium and heavy mass nuclei can be expected to be much better suited . in light nuclei threshold effects from the weak binding of @xmath0 states and finite size effects contribute strongly to the observed spin - orbit splitting , thus not giving direct access to the wanted information on the genuine @xmath7 interaction strengths @xcite .
the calculations in ref .
@xcite indicate that these effects decrease rapidly beyond the silicon mass region .
a standard tool for spectral investigations is @xmath8-spectroscopy , detecting the photons from the hypernuclear transitions of the @xmath0 particle after it was created in an excited state e.g. in a @xmath9 reaction . in a recent @xmath10 experiment on @xmath11c at bnl
/ ags progress has been made by achieving a much better energy resolution than before @xcite .
these measurements , by the way , confirm the small @xmath0 spin - orbit splitting in light nuclei . by technical reasons
@xmath8-spectroscopy is not applicable in medium and heavy mass nuclei .
a promising alternative for spectroscopy in medium and heavy mass hypernuclei is the observation of auger neutrons , emitted during the de - excitation of the hypernucleus after the initial creation of a @xmath0 in an excited state .
the hypernuclear auger process was discussed first by likar _
more recently , the idea has been revived and worked out in much more detail for an experiment proposal at jlab @xcite .
hyperon is de - excited into a lower single particle level , thereby transferring energy and momentum to a valence neutron which is emitted through this process . ]
the hypernuclear auger effect is the direct de - excitation of an excited @xmath0 single - particle state in a hypernucleus by the emission of a neutron .
the process is analogous to the well known atomic auger effect where the de - excitation of an electron kicks out another less bound one . in the case of the hypernuclear auger effect
the energy spectrum of the emitted neutrons reflects the @xmath0 singe - particle level structure , but folded with the neutron single - particle spectrum .
the mechanism of the hypernuclear auger effect is schematically shown in figure [ fig : auger_scheme ] . in order to occur
the separation energy of at least the @xmath0 1s - orbit must be larger than the separation energy of the valence neutron .
therefore , because of the much weaker @xmath0 binding , the hypernuclear auger effect appears with a strength sufficient for measurements only in intermediate and heavy mass nuclei where neutron and @xmath0 separation energies of comparable magnitude are available .
already from this simplified picture it is clear that a single transition of the @xmath0 will yield a wealth of peaks in the neutron s energy distribution , requiring a very careful analysis . for the proposed jlab experiment @xcite a neutron energy resolution of better than 50 kev
is envisaged .
as nuclei to be studied in the experiment @xmath12 and @xmath13 are proposed . in this mass region it can yield valuable information about the @xmath0 single particle spectra , possibly even resolving finer details as the spin - orbit splitting .
one purpose of this paper is to investigate in a realistic model predictions for spectral distributions which may be used to estimate constraints on future measurements . in this paper
we report on our calculations of the hypernuclear auger spectra within the density dependent relativistic hadron field theory ( ddrh ) . in section [ xec : aug ] we describe the theoretical description of the hypernuclear auger effect in the relativistic ddrh approach with density dependent meson - baryon vertices .
we shortly sketch the main features of ddrh and the numerical realization . in section [ sec : results ] results are presented and possibilities to extract information from the extremely complex spectra are discussed . in section [ sec : conclusions ] we summarize , discuss our results and draw some conclusions .
the emission of a neutron by the @xmath0 de - excitation of the hypernucleus is described as a decay of an initial @xmath0 single particle state into a 2 particle-1 hole configuration where the @xmath0 is coupled to a neutron particle - hole core excitation with an energy above the particle emission threshold .
the nucleon and hyperon single particle states are obtained in relativistic mean - field ( rmf ) approximation .
residual interactions among the neutron particle - hole configurations are neglected , i.e. an uncorrelated quasiparticle description is used . for the transition operator @xmath14 the one - boson - exchange parametrization of the full dirac - brueckner ( db ) g - matrix with density dependent vertex functionals @xmath15 @xcite is used .
it is the same interaction as applied in the structure calculation . since the @xmath0 hyperon is electrically neutral and an iso - scalar particle only the @xmath16 and the @xmath17 mesons
contribute : @xmath18 taking @xmath19 to be our many - body ground state , assumed here as the @xmath20 ground state of a spherical nucleus , the initial state is in second quantization formulation given by @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the creation operator for a @xmath0 state with the set of quantum numbers @xmath23 . in the final state
the hyperon is attached to a particle - hole excited nuclear core .
the excess energy and momentum is carried away by the emitted neutron occupying an unbound single particle continuum state in the nuclear mean - field potential : @xmath24 _ { j_\beta m_\beta } \left| 0 \right > = \sum_{m_{\lambda_\beta}m_{n_\beta}}\left < j_{\lambda_\beta}m_{\lambda_\beta } j_{n_\beta}m_{n_\beta } \right|\left .
j_\beta m_\beta \right > a^\dag_{\lambda_\beta } a^\dag_{n_\beta}(j_{n_\beta}j_{n^{-1}_\beta } ) \left| 0 \right>\ ] ] @xmath25 is the particle - hole excitation operator with angular momentum @xmath26 defined through : @xmath27 where @xmath28 denotes a hole creation operator . in eq.[eq : final - state ] the @xmath29 and @xmath25 are coupled to total angular momentum @xmath30 , @xmath31 .
the differential widths @xmath32 describing the decay of an initial @xmath23 state is determined by the transition matrix elements of the @xmath7 interaction @xmath14 : @xmath33_{j_\beta m_\beta } v a^\dag_{\lambda_\alpha } \left| 0 \right > \right|^2 \frac{|\vec k|}{m^2}d\omega,\ ] ] where @xmath34 indicates the incoherent summation over degenerate initial and final sub - states , including the appropriate phase space factors @xcite due to the neutron emerging with momentum @xmath35 .
@xmath36 is the mass of the initial hypernucleus .
the orthogonality and completeness relations of the clebsch - gordan coefficients @xcite allow to convert this expression into the equivalent form of an incoherent sum over matrix elements of uncoupled states : @xmath37 where @xmath38 . from equations
( [ eq : differential - width1 ] ) and ( [ eq : differential - width2 ] ) it is seen that the auger process is determined by nucleonic particle - hole fluctuations of the nuclear mean - field absorbing the energy - momentum transfer from the @xmath0 transition .
this structure becomes even more obvious by expressing the matrix elements in terms of the appropriate non - diagonal elements of @xmath0 and nucleon one - body density matrices in momentum space : @xmath39 here , the transition densities @xmath40 are given by : @xmath41 @xmath42 is either @xmath43 or @xmath44 for @xmath16- and @xmath17-exchange , respectively .
@xmath45 are the single particle energies of the states @xmath46 . in the second line the spatial part of the plane wave
is expanded into partial waves .
a more detailed description of the evaluation of the matrix elements is given in appendix [ asec : matrixel ] .
the wave functions and single particle energies @xmath45 are taken from a ddrh calculation which is described in section [ ssec : model ] . the density dependent relativistic hadron field theory
( ddrh ) @xcite is a relativistic lagrangian field theory with baryons and mesons interacting by density dependent coupling functionals .
the meson - baryon interaction part of the ddrh - lagrangian used here is chosen as in @xcite : @xmath47 including isoscalar interactions from the scalar @xmath16 and the vector @xmath17 meson and isovector vector interactions given by the @xmath48-meson .
the last term accounts for the electromagnetic interaction where @xmath49 is the charge operator .
the density dependence of the baryon - meson vertices is determined self - consistently in mean - field approximation from dirac - brueckner @xmath50 self - energies by first solving the bethe - salpeter equation for the in - medium two - particle scattering amplitude and then extracting the medium modified vertices by expanding the db hartree - fock self - energies in terms of the meson - exchange self - energies obtained from equation ( [ eq : l_int ] ) @xcite .
medium modifications contribute at various levels , e.g. the dressing of the baryon propagators by self - energies and the pauli - blocking of intermediate states .
a lorentz invariant and thermodynamically consistent field theory is retained by expressing the density dependent vertices in terms of functionals of lorentz scalar combinations @xmath51 of the baryon field operators @xmath52 @xcite .
the description of infinite nuclear matter and pure isospin nuclei within ddrh theory has been shown to be very good using the bonn a and the groningen nn - potentials @xcite .
in @xcite the extension of the ddrh theory to the strangeness sector and applications to hypernuclear structure calculations were discussed .
since db calculations describing the in - medium interactions of the complete baryon octet are not available we follow here the approximation scheme discussed also in @xcite .
the essential step is obtained from the diagrammatic analysis of db hyperon self - energies , showing that the coupling functionals of nucleons and hyperons are related in leading order by a simple scaling law given by the ratio of the free space meson - nucleon and meson - hyperon born - term coupling constants @xmath53 and @xmath54 , respectively @xcite : @xmath55 the scalar scaling factor @xmath56 was taken from the jlich - model ( @xmath57 ) @xcite , including explicitly @xmath58 and @xmath59 dynamical correlations in the @xmath20 scalar - isoscalar meson channel . the scaling factor for the @xmath60 vector vertex
is obtained phenomenologically from a least - square fit to @xmath0 separation energies , resulting in @xmath61 @xcite . however , in ref.@xcite it was noticed that the binding energies in the light nuclei below oxygen seem to behave differently from the systematics obtained from @xmath62 .
the @xmath0 separation energies in the light nuclei are described with the same accuracy only if the repulsion from the @xmath17 meson is reduced by about 5% to @xmath63 .
ddrh results for single @xmath0 hypernuclei are compared to the presently available set of world data in @xcite .
an agreement on the percent level is obtained , being at least of the same quality as those of purely phenomenological mean - field models .
in this work we consider the hypernucleus @xmath1pb as representative for the heavy mass hypernuclei ( it is one of the nuclei that are going to be studied in the jlab experiment ) .
the wave functions and single particle energies used for the evaluation of the matrix elements are calculated self - consistently by solving the ddrh field equations in relativistic mean - field ( rmf ) approximation .
details of the numerical approach and the model parameters are given in @xcite .
for the present application we need information on knocked - out , unbound neutron states . for that purpose
the single particle continuum was discretized by enclosing the system in a huge box of size @xmath64 .
since the spacing of the discretrized continuum levels behaves as @xmath65 the use of such a large quantization volume ensures quasi - continuous energy spectra for the neutron scattering states , allowing to resolve single particle resonances and other continuum structures resulting from the calculations .
the continuum wave functions are calculated in the self - consistently obtained ground state mean - field potentials .
thus , final state interactions are taken into account on the level of static mean - field self - energies .
the approach assures orthogonality of bound and unbound wave functions thus avoiding the unphysical non - orthogonality contributions inherent to phenomenological approaches .
since the previous applications of the ddrh theory show that the experimental @xmath0 spectra are reproduced especially accurate in heavy nuclei our approach is well suited for the calculation of the auger neutron spectra from @xmath1pb .
numerical values of the single particle energies for occupied neutron states and bound @xmath0 states are displayed in table [ tab : single - particle - energies ] .
.ddrh results for @xmath0 and neutron single particle energies in @xmath1pb entering into the auger - calculations .
the standard set of interaction parameters was used @xcite . [ cols="<,>,<,>",options="header " , ] because of the high level density and moderate separation energies heavy hypernuclei are most suitable for the auger effect .
however , at the same time these apparent advantages are , unfortunately , a potential source of problems for experimental work .
the huge amount of combinatorial possibilities for transitions , illustrated in table [ tab:1g - trans ] and indicated in figure [ fig : auger-1g - levels ] for the case of initially populating the @xmath66-shell in @xmath1pb , leads to auger spectra of a rather complicated shape making in many cases an unambiguous identification of transitions and assignment of quantum numbers almost impossible .
the problem is apparent from figure [ fig : full - spec ] where the complete neutron emission spectrum from the @xmath67 hypernucleus is displayed , summed over all energetically open @xmath0 levels .
experimentally , spectra of a similar structure have to be expected .
in addition , state - dependent weighting factors from the production vertex of the initial @xmath0 state will be superimposed . from figure [ fig : full - spec ] and figure [ fig : auger-1g - levels ] it is obvious that experiments will be confronted with spectra of high complexity . before observables of physical interest can be accessed the data will have to be analyzed in a more selective approach . from the discussion it is obvious that much of the structure will be produced by incoherent superpositions of contributions from the variety of orbitals in which the @xmath0 was inititally produced . by a precise energy tagging of the produced kaon and the outgoing electron ( for the case of electromagnetic production of hypernuclei , as will be the case at jlab ) it might be possible to determine the initial @xmath0-state accurately enough and that only the auger - neutrons related to the de - excitation of that specific state can be recorded selectively in a coincidence measurement . with an initial 1f @xmath0 state . ] in this context , it is of interest to consider the auger transitions on the limits of the energetically accessible range of states .
assuming energetically sharp states , i.e. the @xmath0 and neutrons are in good quasiparticle configurations and damping effects are negligible , the present calculation predicts that the auger process can only take place if the @xmath0 initially is produced in the @xmath68-orbit or above ( see table [ tab : single - particle - energies ] ) , because otherwise the @xmath0 transition energies are less than the lowest neutron separation energy . next to the @xmath68-orbit we find the doublet of @xmath69 states which is of interest because it allows to observe the @xmath0 spin - orbit splitting , at least in principle . since the energy window available from populating the @xmath69-orbits is still rather narrow the resulting auger neutron spectrum is of a comparatively simple structure . in figure [ fig:1f - spec ] results for the auger spectra produced by the @xmath70 and
@xmath71 states are compared .
it is seen that in both cases only a small number of final states occurs .
even more , only the transitions to the @xmath72 neutron - hole final state yield a significant strength .
thus it is even possible to clearly obtain the spin - orbit splitting of the @xmath69-shell .
the prominent strength of this doublet is also fairly model independent .
considering the kinematically allowed phase space of this transition only , one might expect that wave function effects which are sensitive to the details of the interaction could strongly influence the relative strengths between the emission of the @xmath73- or @xmath74-shell neutrons , which are in energy almost degenerate ( see table [ tab : single - particle - energies ] ) .
nevertheless , due to the high degeneracy of the @xmath72 neutron - orbitals the multiplicity of these neutrons will be greatly enhanced .
therefore one can expect to observe in the de - excitation spectrum of a @xmath69-state a clear line doublet belonging to the two spin - orbit partners of the @xmath69 shell falling down to the 1s orbital and thereby knocking out the @xmath72 neutron .
single particle energy spectra in @xmath1pb for the three different sets of coupling constants discussed in the text . ] shell for interactions with different spin - orbit splittings .
the auger transition widths @xmath75 are shown as functions of energy @xmath76 of the outgoing neutron .
the upper and lower arrows indicate transitions from the 1g@xmath77 to the 1p@xmath78 and 1p@xmath79 final states , respectively . ]
the general case is , however , more ambiguous .
the doublet structure which one might expect as the signature of the @xmath0 spin - orbit splitting does not always show up in the spectral distribution since in many cases the matrix elements depend sensitively on binding energies and other wave function effects . as a representative case , we study the influence of the spin - orbit interaction strength on the auger neutron spectra in more detail for the @xmath66 shell .
this case is well suited , since the spin - orbit splitting is sufficiently large and the spectrum offers already some complexity .
the possible transitions for this configuration together with the corresponding transition rates are shown in table [ tab:1g - trans ] .
the dependence of the @xmath66-shell spectra on variations of the spin - orbit strength of the @xmath0-nucleus potential is investigated by changing the relative and the absolute coupling strength of the @xmath16 and the @xmath17 meson to the @xmath0 , keeping the overall single particle structure of the @xmath0 spectrum fixed .
numerically , this is realized by observing that in our relativistic mean - field theory with scalar and vector self - energies @xmath80 and @xmath81 , respectively , the leading order non - relativistic schroedinger - type central potential is given by @xmath82 and the strength of the spin - orbit potential is determined by @xmath83 .
hence , we can relate spectral effects from variations of the spin - orbit strength by a factor c to a scaling of the scalar and vector self - energies @xmath80 and @xmath81 , respectively , according to @xmath84 we preserve the self - consistency between the nuclear mean - field and the underlying baryon - baryon interactions by scaling the @xmath2 and @xmath3 vertices , equation ( [ eq : pot ] ) , by the same factors @xmath85 and @xmath86 , respectively .
choosing @xmath87 as our external parameter and using always @xmath88 as a constraint , the spin - orbit splittings of the @xmath0 levels can be varied over wide ranges while keeping the changes in the overall structure of the @xmath0 single particle spectrum on a minimal level .
the @xmath0 single particle spectra obtained for @xmath89 ( corresponding to @xmath90 , respectively , ) are compared to the results for @xmath91 in figure [ fig : coupling - comp ] . for @xmath92
the spin - orbit splittings are reduced by about a factor of 2 and an increase of about the same size is found for @xmath93 .
these ( strong ) variations will surely cover the full range of uncertainties about the @xmath0 spin - orbit potential .
the spectral distributions of auger transitions widths @xmath75 , obtained by putting the initial @xmath0 in @xmath94 orbits are displayed in figure [ fig : coupling - comp ] .
compared to the standard case @xmath91 the spectral structures and transition strengths are changed drastically when using @xmath92 and @xmath93 . as an overall feature
the calculations show a concentration of strength in a few states for @xmath91 and @xmath93 while a more equilibrated distribution is found for @xmath92 .
the apparent pile - up of strength at low neutron energies for the normal and strong coupling cases are related to the variations in the values of overlap matrix elements due to changes in binding energies and single particle wave functions . analyzing the dynamical content of the response functions by calculating sum rules for various moments of the excitation energy one finds a disappointing small sensitivity on the spin - orbit interaction strength .
hence , it is unlikely that spin - orbit effects will contribute significantly and on an observable level to the total spectral strength .
on the level of individual transitions there are , however , signals for spin - orbit effects visible . in figure
[ fig : coupling - comp ] the transitions @xmath95 are indicated by the upper arrows while lower arrows denote @xmath96 .
the length of the arrows corresponds to the @xmath97 energy splitting which obviously depends directly on the spin - orbit interaction strength .
in addition , details of the spectral distributions , e.g. the clustering of strength in certain energy regions , also depends on the overlap of wave functions by which the transition matrix elements and therefore the transition widths @xmath75 are determined ( see equations ( [ eq : differential - width2 ] ) and ( [ eq : mat_el ] ) ) .
it might seem somewhat disadvantageous to start out doing auger experiments with a system of the complexity of a heavy nucleus like lead .
however , aiming at resolving the @xmath0 spin - orbit structure in heavy hypernuclei , which is still a controversial question as was mentioned in the introduction , one needs to find hypernuclei that provide a core nucleus of very low spin . in the ideal case
this should be j@xmath98 in order to eliminate - or at least to suppress - effects from @xmath0 angular momentum - core nucleus spin interactions leading to an additional splitting superimposed on the pure @xmath0 spin - orbit splitting . in this respect the frequently used @xmath99y and @xmath100v hypernuclei are very unfavorable cases because the @xmath101y and @xmath102v core nuclei carry ground state spins of 4@xmath103 and 6@xmath104 , respectively !
the broadening of the l - orbits observed in these nuclei [ 1 ] does not exhibit a proper @xmath105 systematics which might be related to contribution from residual interactions involving the huge core spins [ 25 ] .
hyperisotopes matching the requirements of having a 0@xmath104 core ground state and appearing with at least around 10% natural abundancy would be @xmath106zr and @xmath107sn .
lighter isotopes will gradually cease to exhibit auger de - excitations .
the auger - neutron transition rates for the de - excitation of single @xmath0 hypernuclei on the example of @xmath1pb have been calculated in relativistic ddrh theory .
the initial state was represented by a ground state @xmath108pb core with an attached @xmath0 single particle state , the final state as a neutron particle - hole excited @xmath108pb where the @xmath0 hyperon occupies a lower lying single particle level and the neutron of the particle - hole pair being unbound .
hence the process corresponds to a decay of the initial single @xmath0 configuration into a @xmath0-neutron - particle - hole configuration . due to the fact that the hypernuclear auger effect appears mainly in heavy and intermediate mass hypernuclei
the spectral distribution of the emitted neutrons is extremely complex .
for this reason a very detailed reconstruction of each event will have to be done in possible experimental measurements . by focusing on initial states with the @xmath0 in the @xmath69-orbit
our calculations predict a clean doublet structure in the auger neutron spectrum from which the @xmath69 spin - orbit splitting can be directly read off , assuming sufficient energy resolution . for a general @xmath0 orbit no definite signature of the spin - orbit
splitting will appear due to the huge amount of transitions and the additional broadening of peaks when deeply bound neutrons are involved .
the effect of a finite width of the neutron states , increasing with the distance from the fermi - surface has not been considered in our calculations .
for the least bound neutrons it will have almost no effect , but going deeper in binding energy the broadening of the states can no longer be neglected . as described in the previous paragraphs the neutron spectra in which the deeply bound neutrons are also involved
are already fairly complex .
an additional broadening of the neutron levels will thus wash out most of the spectral structure there .
however , in the case of the @xmath69-shell de - excitation only the valence neutrons close to the fermi - level are involved so that the spin - orbit splitting signal is going to survive in realistic spectra . for the spectroscopy in the intermediate and heavy mass region the hypernuclear auger effect provides a promising complementary tool to @xmath8 spectroscopy , although special care must be taken on the choice of transitions and tagging the energy . for the @xmath1pb hypernucleus
the @xmath69 shell is such a well suited case
. this technique might be the only way to achieve high resolution information on the hypernuclear fine structure in heavy nuclei since for @xmath8 transitions it will be even harder to assign the detected photons to specific transitions .
we would like to thank amour margarian for exciting our interest in the hypernuclear auger effect and for useful discussions on this topic .
we would also like to thank simona briganti for useful discussions on the general features of the atomic auger effect .
this work was supported by the european graduate school gieen copenhagen and dfg - contract le439/4b .
for the evaluation of the matrix elements the transition form - factors , eq .
( [ eq : trans_ff ] ) , are evaluated in the spherical basis of dirac wave functions : @xmath109 @xmath42 is either the four by four unit matrix or @xmath110 , depending whether the scalar or the vector potential is evaluated . @xmath111 and @xmath112 denotes the unit vectors in direction of @xmath113 and @xmath114 , respectively .
the spinors are the usual total angular momentum eigenstates of the dirac equation with the generalized spin - angle spherical harmonics @xmath115 obtained by coupling spin and orbital angular momenta @xcite .
the numerical solution of the radial dirac equation was discussed e.g. in @xcite .
the orbital angular momenta @xmath116 and @xmath117 are determined by @xmath118 and the parity @xmath119 : @xmath120 for the scalar vertex we get then @xmath121 \left [ \int d\omega\ ; \omega^*_{j_1l_1m_1}y_{\lambda\mu } \omega_{j_2l_2m_2}\right ] \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left .
- \left [ \int dr\;r^2\;f_1(r)f_2(r)j_\lambda(qr ) \right ] \left [ \int d\omega\ ; \omega^*_{j_1\tilde l_1m_1}y_{\lambda\mu } \omega_{j_2\tilde l_2m_2}\right ] \right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the radial matrix element is evaluated numerically .
the angular integral can be performed analytically . by means of the wigner - eckhardt theorem @xcite
it can be expressed by clebsch - gordan coefficients and reduced matrix elements @xmath122 for the vector transition form factor we have to evaluate @xmath123 \left [ \int d\omega\ ; \omega^*_{j_1l_1m_1}y_{\lambda\mu } \omega_{j_2l_2m_2}\right ] \right . \nonumber\\ & & + \left [ \int dr\;r^2\;f_1(r)f_2(r)j_\lambda(qr ) \right ] \left [ \int d\omega\ ; \omega^*_{j_1\tilde l_1m_1}y_{\lambda\mu } \omega_{j_2\tilde l_2m_2}\right ] , \nonumber\\ & & { \bm i } \left [ \int dr\;r^2\;g_1(r)f_2(r)j_\lambda(qr ) \right ] \left [ \int d\omega\ ; \omega^*_{j_1l_1m_1}y_{\lambda\mu } \vec\sigma\;\omega_{j_2\tilde l_2m_2}\right ] \nonumber\\ & & \left .
+ \left [ \int dr\;r^2\;f_1(r)g_2(r)j_\lambda(qr ) \right ] \left [ \int d\omega\ ; \omega^*_{j_1\tilde l_1m_1}y_{\lambda\mu } \vec\sigma\;\omega_{j_2l_2m_2}\right ] \right\}^\nu\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath16 are the usual pauli matrices .
the reduced matrix element for the angular @xmath124 matrix element is identical to equation ( [ eq : reduced - mat - el - scalar ] ) , for the spatial components it is given by @xmath125_{in } \left| j'l'm'\right > \nonumber\\ & = & \sum_{in}(-)^{j - m } \left<\lambda\mu 1 m\right|\left .
in\right > \left ( \begin{array}{rrrrrr } j&i&j ' \\ m&n&m ' \end{array } \right ) \left<\left .
l \frac{1}{2}j\right|\right| \left[y_\lambda \sigma_1 \right]_i \left|\left| l'\frac{1}{2 } j'\right>\right.\nonumber\\ & = & \sum_{in}(-)^{j - m } \left<\lambda\mu 1 m\right|\left .
in\right > \left ( \begin{array}{rrrrrr } j&i&j ' \\ m&n&m ' \end{array } \right ) \left\ { \begin{array}{rrrrrrrrr } l&\frac{1}{2}&j \\ l&\frac{1}{2}&j ' \\
\lambda&1&i \end{array } \right\ } \left<\left .
l \right|\right| y_\lambda \left|\left| l ' \right>\right .
\frac{1}{2}\right|\right|\sigma\left|\left|\frac{1}{2}\right>\right.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the pauli matrices @xmath126 , @xmath127 , are used here in the spherical basis @xcite .
explicit expessions for the reduced matrix elements are found e.g. in ref .
. 10 h. hotchi _ et al .
_ , phys .
c * 64 * , 044302 ( 2001 ) .
t. nagae , nucl.phys.a * 691 * , 76c ( 2001 ) _ and _ h. hotchi , kek report 2000 - 3 , april 2000 m. may _ et al .
lett . * 78 * , 4343 ( 1997 ) t. hasegawa _ et al . _ , phys .
c * 53 * , 1210 ( 1996 ) .
s. ajimura _ et al .
_ , nucl .
a * 585 * , 173c ( 1995 ) .
h. pile _ et al .
_ , phys .
* 66 * , 2585 ( 1991 ) .
m. hjorth - jensen , a. polls , a. ramos and h. muther , nucl .
a * 605 * , 458 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9604028 ] .
i. vidana , a. polls , a. ramos and m. hjorth - jensen , nucl .
a * 644 * , 201 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9805032 ] .
m. rufa , h. stocker , j. a. maruhn , w. greiner and p. g. reinhard , j. phys .
g * 13 * , l143 ( 1987 ) .
m. rufa , j. schaffner , j. maruhn , h. stoecker , w. greiner and p. g. reinhard , phys .
c * 42 * , 2469 ( 1990 ) .
n. k. glendenning , d. von - eiff , m. haft , h. lenske and m. k. weigel , phys .
c * 48 * , 889 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9211012 ] .
d. j. millener , nucl .
a * 691 * , 93 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0103017 ] . c. keil and h. lenske , aps conf.proc * 603 * ( mesons and light nuclei 2001 ) , 433 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0107068 ] . c. m. keil , f. hofmann and h. lenske , phys .
c * 61 * , 064309 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9911014 ] .
h. kohri _ et al . _
[ ags - e929 collaboration ] , phys .
c * 65 * , 034607 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : nucl - ex/0110007 ] .
a. likar , m. rosina and b. povh , z. phys .
a * 324 * , 35 ( 1986 ) .
a. margaryan , l. tang , s. majewski , o. hashimoto , v. likachev , _ auger neutron spectroscopy of nuclear matter at cebaf _
, letter of intent to jlab pac 18 , loi-00 - 101 , 2000 see e.g. particle data book , sect . 34 , p. 211
, europhys.j . * c * 15 ( 2000 ) 1 p.j .
brussaard , p.w.m .
glaudemans , _ shell - model applications in nuclear spectroscopy _ , north - holland , 1977 .
c. fuchs , h. lenske and h. h. wolter , phys .
c * 52 * , 3043 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9507044 ] , h. lenske and c. fuchs , phys.lett.b * 345 * 355 ( 1995 ) .
f. hofmann , c. m. keil and h. lenske , phys .
c * 64 * , 034314 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0007050 ] .
f. de jong , h. lenske , phys .
c * 57 * , 3099 ( 1997 ) j. haidenbauer , w. melnitchouk and j. speth , arxiv : nucl - th/9805014 .
bjorken , s.d .
grell , relativistic quantum mechanics , mcgraw - hill , new york , 1964 .
this has been found analysing the assumed spin - orbit splittings of @xcite within ddrh and phen .
publication in preparation . | the hypernuclear auger effect , given by the de - excitation of a @xmath0 hypernucleus by means of the transition of a @xmath0 hyperon from an initial to a lower lying final single particle state in conjunction with neutron emission from the core nucleus is studied in relativistic ddrh field theory .
baryonic interactions are obtained from the bonn nn potential by dirac - brueckner theory and theoretically derived scaling laws for the meson - hyperon vertices .
the model is applied to the @xmath1pb hypernucleus . @xmath0 and
nucleon bound states as well as scattering states are calculated self - consistently in mean - field approximation .
the auger spectra of the emitted neutrons are of complex structure due to a huge combinatorial number of possible hypernuclear transitions .
the sensitivity of the neutron auger spectra to changes in the @xmath2 and @xmath3 vertices is investigated .
the theoretical results show that experimental applications of the hypernuclear auger effect will require special efforts , e.g. by tagging on the energy of the initially created hyperon . |
as the hadrons with the largest gluon content ( despite probably sizeable quarkonium admixtures ) , glueballs provide a privileged source of information on how glue manifests itself in hadronic bound states ( in their rest frame ) .
progress in understanding glueball structure may therefore even help to unravel the elusive gluonic component of the classical hadrons .
the intricacies of hadronic glue are exemplified by the problems encountered when implementing various effective , gluonic degrees of freedom , such as constituent gluons , strings , or flux tubes , into hadron models .
the resulting effects are generally less prominent and more ambiguous than those of the quark substructure , for which phenomenologically rather successful effective degrees of freedom are provided , e.g. , by constituent quarks .
the problems in modeling the gluon sector are partially related to the fact that gluons , unlike quarks , do not carry internal , global quantum numbers ( like flavor or charge ) to which external probes can couple .
unambiguous and transparent gluonic effects in hadrons are therefore much harder to identify . model - independent and more directly qcd - based approaches are thus called upon to clarify the structure of hadronic glue and to identify potentially dominant gluon field configurations .
promising candidates for the latter , especially in the @xmath0 glueball channel , are instantons @xcite ( i.e. the strong , coherent gluon fields which , by mediating tunneling processes , give rise to the @xmath1-angle of the qcd vacuum ) , as qualitative arguments @xcite and instanton - liquid model results @xcite suggest . in the following
, we will give a brief summary of work in an analytical approach to the scalar glueball correlator at short distances @xcite , based on an instanton - improved operator product expansion ( iope ) and qcd sum - rule techniques , in which these issues can be addressed , and glueball properties calculated , in a largely model - independent fashion .
consider the correlation function @xmath2 where the interpolating field @xmath3 carries the quantum numbers of the scalar ( @xmath0 ) glueball .
the standard ope separates this correlator into contributions from hard field modes ( with typical momenta @xmath4 gev ) , contained in perturbative wilson coefficients , and from soft ( @xmath5 ) modes contained in the vacuum expectation values of composite qcd operators , the so - called condensates .
the perturbative wilson coefficients of the low - dimensional operators can be found to @xmath6 in @xcite .
remarkably , the nonperturbative power ( i.e. condensates ) corrections to this conventional ope turn out to be small and are , except for the lowest - dimensional gluon condensate contribution , negligible .
the bulk of the nonperturbative physics reponsible for the strong binding in the scalar glueball channel should therefore manifest itself in the wilson coefficients , i.e. predominantly via direct instantons @xcite which are neglected in the standard analyses @xcite .
this expectation is strengthened by the fact that instantons couple particularly strongly to the gluonic @xmath0 interpolators . in ref .
@xcite , we have evaluated the direct - instanton contributions and implemented them into the corresponding iope sum rules , which are based on the borel - transformed moments @xmath7 \label{momdef}\ ] ] ( for the explicit form of the borel operator @xmath8 see , e.g. @xcite ) with @xmath9 .
besides the standard ope contributions @xmath10 of ref .
@xcite , the iope includes the instanton contributions @xcite
@xmath11 -2\right\ } , \label{ri } \end{aligned}\ ] ] ( @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) .
the semiclassical result ( [ ri ] ) neglects @xmath14 corrections ( which are suppressed by the large instanton action @xmath15 ) and multi - instanton correlations ( since @xmath16 fm is small compared with the average instanton separation @xmath17 fm ) .
we have also removed the soft subtraction term @xmath18 to avoid double - counting with the condensates .
below , the average instanton size @xmath19 fm and density @xmath20 @xmath21 will be fixed at the values obtained ( approximately ) from instanton vacuum model @xcite and lattice @xcite simulations . to obtain sum rules ,
the iope expressions are matched to their `` phenomenological '' counterparts , which are derived from the borelized dispersive representation @xmath22 where the spectral function @xmath23 contains a glueball pole contribution and an effective continuum from the dispersive cut of the iope , starting at an effective threshold @xmath24 .
this corresponds to @xmath25 \left ( s\right ) \theta \left ( s - s_{0}\right ) .
\label{specdens}\ ] ] the instanton continuum contributions @xmath26 ( @xmath27 ( @xmath28 ) are bessel ( neumann ) functions ) , introduced in @xcite , will play an essential role in the subsequent analysis .
the iope sum rules can then be written as @xmath29 the subtraction constant @xmath30 in the @xmath31 sum rule ( regularized by removing the high - momentum contributions ) is related to the gluon condensate by the low - energy theorem @xcite @xmath32 this relation provides an important consistency check for the sum - rule analysis , as discussed below .
the quantitative analysis of the sum rules ( [ iopesrs ] ) amounts to determining those values of the glueball parameters and @xmath33 in eq .
( [ specdens ] ) for which both sides optimally match in the fiducial @xmath34 domain ( determined such that the approximations on both sides of the sum rules are expected to be reliable @xcite ) .
the previously neglected instanton contributions turn out to be dominant and render ( [ iopesrs ] ) the first overall consistent set of qcd sum rules in the scalar glueball channel . in particular
, the iope resolves two long - standing flaws of the earlier sum rules @xcite : the mutual inconsistency between different borel moments and the inconsistency with the low - energy theorem ( [ let ] ) .
even the previously deficient and usually discarded lowest - moment ( @xmath31 ) sum rule is rendered consistent both with the higher - moment sum rules and the low - energy theorem .
( a subsequent analysis of the related gaussian variant of these sum rules can be found in ref .
@xcite . ) no evidence for a low - lying ( @xmath35 gev ) gluonium state ( or any state strongly coupled to gluonic interpolators ) , which had been argued for on the basis of this sum rule @xcite , remains .
all four iope sum rules show an unprecedented degree of consistency and allow for a simultaneous 3-parameter fit to the glueball mass , its coupling , and the continuum threshold @xmath24 . in fig .
1 the glueball pole contribution ( solid line ) to the optimized @xmath36 sum rule is compared with the remaining components ( ope with subtracted ope - continuum ( dash - double - dotted ) , instanton contribution ( dashed ) , instanton continuum ( dash - dotted ) , and their sum ( dotted ) ) . both parts match almost perfectly over the whole fiducial region , mostly due to the dominant instanton contributions .
the remaining sum rules ( including the @xmath31 sum rule ) show a similarly high degree of stability . together with the mutual agreement of all four iope sum rules ( in the typical range of uncertainty ) and their consistency with the low - energy theorem
, this indicates that the iope provides a sufficiently complete description of the short - distance glueball correlator .
the most dramatic quantitative effect of the direct instantons is to increase the residuum of the glueball pole , @xmath37 , by about a factor of five . from the @xmath38 sum rule ( likely to be the most reliable one since it receives the strongest relative pole contribution ) we obtain @xmath39 gev and @xmath40 gev .
the instanton continuum contributions , eq .
( [ icont ] ) , are indispensable for the overall consistency and stability of the sum rules and shed new light on the spectral content of the glueball correlator .
for once , they compensate , together with the perturbative terms , the pole contribution and thereby lead to an improved description of the correlator towards low momenta .
this reconciles the sum rules with the low - energy theorem in the @xmath41 limit . in the opposite limit ,
i.e. for @xmath42 , the instanton part of the continuum remains effective despite the suppression incurred by funnelling a sizeable momentum through a coherent field .
this indicates that small - instanton physics accounts for part of the higher - lying strength in ( [ corr ] ) and may play a rather prominent role in excited glueball states .
in contrast to previously studied iope sum rules @xcite , built on quark - based correlators , those for the scalar glueball are the first where i ) the instanton contributions do not enter via topological quark zero - modes and where ii ) the sum rules reach a satisfactory ( though not excellent ) level of consistency even without any perturbative and soft contributions , i.e. with the instanton terms alone .
the latter result explains why instanton models find scalar glueball properties similar to those obtained above @xcite .
it also illustrates that the quantitative impact of the instanton contributions can be judged only if all contributions are consistently taken into account . at present
, the iope seems to be the only controlled and analytical framework in which this is possible .
the predominance and approximate self - sufficiency of the instanton contributions indicates that instantons may generate the bulk of the forces which bind the scalar glueball .
a further , striking consequence of the exceptionally strong instanton contributions is that the scales of the predicted @xmath0 glueball properties are approximately set by the bulk features of the instanton size distribution .
more specifically , neglecting the standard ope contributions , one finds @xmath43 conceptually , the main virtue of these scaling relations lies in establishing an explicit link between fundamental vacuum and hadron properties .
they could also be of practical use , e.g. for the test of instanton vacuum models , to provide constraints for glueball model building , or generalized to finite temperature and baryon density , where the instanton distribution changes .
if the glueball size @xmath44 scales like its compton wavelength , one furthermore has @xmath45 , in agreement with the lattice calculations @xcite which find @xmath46 fm .
h. forkel and m.k .
banerjee , phys .
* 71 , * 484 ( 1993 ) ; e.v .
shuryak , nucl . phys . *
b214 * , 237 ( 1983 ) ; h. forkel and m. nielsen , phys . lett .
b * 345 , * 55 ( 1995 ) ; phys .
d * 55 , * 1471 ( 1997 ) ; m. aw , m.k . banerjee and h. forkel , phys .
b * 454 , * 147 ( 1999 ) . | we investigate the impact of instantons on scalar glueball properties in a largely model - independent analytical approach based on the instanton - improved operator product expansion ( iope ) of the @xmath0 glueball correlator .
the instanton contributions turn out to be dominant , to substantially improve the consistency of the correponding qcd sum rules , and to increase the glueball residue about fivefold . * instantons and glueballs * + h. forkel + _ institut fr theoretische physik , universitt heidelberg , + philosophenweg 19 , d-69120 heidelberg , germany + _ |
the presence of the softly broken sector in the mssm introduces a large number of new physical parameters . in particular , compared to the standard model ( sm ) , we have additional 36 mixing angles and 40 phases that give rise to flavor and cp violation .
the requirement that the supersymmetric and the sm contributions to physical observables agree with the experimental data , gives strong constraints on the flavor - breaking structure of the soft terms in the mssm .
in particular at least one of the following conditions is needed in order to suppress large supersymmetric contribution to a generic fcnc process : * _ degeneracy . _ the masses of the sfermions present in the loop have almost the same values * _ alignment . _
the assumption is that quark and squark mass matrices are nearly simultaneously diagonalized by a supersymmetric field rotation , either in the down or in the up sector @xcite . * _ irrelevancy . _
the suppressions is obtained if the particles in the loop are very heavy .
we study flavor physics in the framework of hierarchical soft terms , in which the first two generations of squarks and sleptons are heavier than the rest of the supersymmetric spectrum .
the flavor structure of the first and second generation squarks is tightly constrained by @xmath0 physics . on the other hand ,
the upper bounds on the masses of the first two generations of squarks are much looser than for the other supersymmetric particles
. therefore one can relax the flavor constraints , without compromising naturalness , by taking the first two generations of squarks much heavier than the third @xcite .
this procedure alleviates , but does not completely solve , the flavor problem and a further suppression mechanism for the first two generations must be present .
however , it is not difficult to conceive the existence of such a mechanism which operates if , for instance , the soft terms respect an approximate u(2 ) symmetry acting on the first two generations @xcite . in the case of hierarchy
@xcite , the small expansion parameter describing the flavor violation is the mismatch between the third - generation quarks identified by the yukawa coupling and the third - generation squarks identified by the light eigenstates of the soft - term mass matrix .
this small mismatch can be related to the hierarchy of scales present in the squark mass matrix and to ckm angles . however , for the phenomenological implications we are interested in , we do not have to specify any such relation and we can work in an effective theory where the first two generations of squarks have been integrated out .
their only remnant in the effective theory is the small mismatch between third - generation quarks and squarks .
let us consider the gluino contribution to a @xmath1 process in the left - handed down quark sector , @xmath2 , neglecting for simplicity chirality changes .
the amplitude of such a process is proportional to @xmath3 here @xmath4 is a loop function , @xmath5 is the gluino mass and @xmath6 is the unitary matrix diagonalizing the 6@xmath76 down squark squared mass matrix @xmath8 in a basis in which the down quark mass matrix is diagonal
. we can simplify eq .
( [ eq : ampl ] ) by using a perturbative expansion in the small off - diagonal entries of the squark mass matrix .
the `` degenerate '' case is obtained in the limit in which the squark masses in the loop function coincide : @xmath9 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 is the @xmath12-th derivative of the function .
the @xmath13 parameters are in this case normalized to the universal scalar mass @xmath14 . in the `` hierarchical '' limit , the contribution to the loop function in eq .
( [ eq : ampl ] ) from the heavy squarks is negligible .
therefore eq .
( [ eq : ampl ] ) becomes @xmath15 here @xmath16 as before , where now @xmath14 is interpreted as the third - generation squark mass .
we have defined @xmath17 .
note that @xmath18 , so that @xmath19 is again a normalized mass insertion .
also , @xmath20 .
for @xmath21 the difference between the two schemes , the degenerate and the hierarchical one , is given by the order one difference between a function and its derivative .
however , this difference becomes larger when we consider @xmath22 : @xmath23 g^{(1)}(x ) ( \hat\delta^{ll}_{ij})^2 & \text{(hierarchical case ) . }
\end{cases}\ ] ] therefore , if @xmath14 is the same in the two cases we find that the amplitudes for @xmath24 and @xmath25 processes satisfy the relation @xmath26
^ 2}\right|_{\text{degenerate } } = \frac{g^{(3)}}{6g^{(1 ) } } \left(\frac{f}{f^{(1)}}\right)^2 \left.\frac{a(\delta f = 2)}{[a(\delta f = 1)]^2}\right|_{\text{hierarchical}}.\ ] ] in general the ratio @xmath27 is typically small . as a consequence , the bounds on the @xmath25 processes inferred from @xmath24 , or viceversa , may be significantly different in the two frameworks .
the bounds on the flavor - violating parameters @xmath28 are summarized in table [ tab : bounds ] and compared with the bounds obtained in the case of degeneracy .
an early analysis of the hierarchical case was presented in ref .
it is plausible to expect that the size of the parameters @xmath29 , @xmath30 can not be smaller than the corresponding ckm angles , @xmath31 , @xmath32 respectively @xcite .
thus , it is particularly interesting to probe experimentally flavor processes up to the level of @xmath33 , @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
the present constraints on the @xmath36 transitions and on @xmath37 are at the edge of probing this region .
an interesting conclusion is that hierarchical soft terms predict that new - physics effects in @xmath38 transitions can be expected just beyond the present experimental sensitivity .
@xmath39 another interesting point regarding the phenomenology of the hierarchical framework is the fact that the new - physics effects in @xmath40 transitions are particularly promising .
for example recent measurements from the cdf @xcite and d0 @xcite collaborations have shown a mild tension between the experimental value and the sm prediction for the @xmath41 mixing phase , at the @xmath42 level @xcite .
the hierarchical case allows values of the phase @xmath41 about three times larger than in the degenerate case , in agreement with the generic expectation from eq .
( [ eq:2vs1 ] ) .
the range of @xmath41 presently favored by the experiment is shown in fig . [
fig : bs ] .
( left , blue ) and @xmath29 ( right , red ) from the measurements of @xmath43 ( lighter shading ) and @xmath44 ( darker shading ) for @xmath45 and @xmath46 . in the background ,
the contour lines of the phase @xmath41 are shown . ]
i thank andrea romanino and gian giudice for all the physics i learned from them , and the organizers for the opportunity to come and speak at moriond ew09 .
9 y. nir and n. seiberg , phys .
b * 309 * ( 1993 ) 337 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9304307 ] .
s. dimopoulos and g. f. giudice , phys .
b * 357 * ( 1995 ) 573 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9507282 ] .
a. g. cohen , d. b. kaplan and a. e. nelson , phys .
b * 388 * ( 1996 ) 588 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9607394 ] .
a. pomarol and d. tommasini , nucl .
b * 466 * , 3 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9507462 ] .
r. barbieri , g. r. dvali and l. j. hall , phys .
b * 377 * ( 1996 ) 76 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9512388 ] ; g. f. giudice , m. nardecchia and a. romanino , nucl .
b * 813 * ( 2009 ) 156 [ arxiv:0812.3610 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. g. cohen , d. b. kaplan , f. lepeintre and a. e. nelson , phys .
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 2300 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9610252 ] .
t. aaltonen _ et al . _
[ cdf collaboration ] , phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 161802 [ arxiv:0712.2397 [ hep - ex ] ] .
v. m. abazov _ et al . _
[ d0 collaboration ] , arxiv:0802.2255 [ hep - ex ] .
e. barberio _ et al .
_ [ heavy flavor averaging group ] , arxiv:0808.1297 [ hep - ex ] ; | naturalness arguments do not forbid the possibility that the first two families of squarks and sleptons are heavier than the rest of the supersymmetric spectrum . in this framework
, we study the phenomenology related to the flavor physics and we give bounds on the flavor violating parameters that we compare with the case of nearly degenerate squarks . the peculiar structure of the hierarchical scheme allows us to make definite predictions and suggests also a natural size for the flavor violating parameters . |
the recent growth in mobile and media - rich applications continuously increases the demand for wireless bandwidth , and puts a strain on wireless networks @xcite , @xcite .
this dramatic increase in demand poses a challenge for current wireless networks , and calls for new network control mechanisms that make better use of scarce wireless resources .
furthermore , most existing , especially low - cost , wireless devices have a relatively rigid architecture with limited processing power and energy storage capacities that are not compatible with the needs of existing theoretical network control algorithms .
one important problem , and the focus of this paper , is that low - cost wireless interface cards are built using first - in , first - out ( fifo ) queueing structure , which is not compatible with the per - flow queueing requirements of the optimal network control schemes such as backpressure routing and sheduling @xcite .
the backpressure routing and scheduling paradigm has emerged from the pioneering work @xcite , @xcite , which showed that , in wireless networks where nodes route and schedule packets based on queue backlogs , one can stabilize the queues for any feasible traffic .
it has also been shown that backpressure can be combined with flow control to provide utility - optimal operation @xcite . yet
, backpressure routing and scheduling require each node in the network to construct per - flow queues .
the following example demonstrates the operation of backpressure .
let us consider a canonical example in fig .
[ fig : example_fifo_v1](a ) , where a transmitter node @xmath3 , and two receiver nodes @xmath4 , @xmath5 form a one - hop downlink topology .
there are two flows with arrival rates @xmath6 and @xmath7 destined to nodes @xmath4 and @xmath5 , respectively .
the throughput optimal backpressure scheduling scheme , also known as max - weight scheduling , assumes the availability of per - flow queues @xmath8 and @xmath9 as seen in fig .
[ fig : example_fifo_v1](a ) , and makes a transmission decision at each transmission opportunity based on queue backlogs , _
@xmath8 and @xmath9 .
in particular , the max - weight scheduling algorithm determines @xmath10 , and transmits from queue @xmath11 .
it was shown in @xcite , @xcite that if the arrival rates @xmath6 and @xmath7 are inside the stability region of the wireless network , the max - weight scheduling algorithm stabilizes the queues .
on the other hand , in some devices , per - flow queues can not be constructed . in such a scenario , a fifo queue ,
say @xmath12 is shared by flows @xmath4 and @xmath5 as shown in fig .
[ fig : example_fifo_v1](b ) , and the packets are served from @xmath12 in a fifo manner .
@xmath13 constructing per - flow queues may not be feasible in some devices especially at the link layer due to rigid architecture , and one fifo queue is usually shared by multiple flows .
for example , although current wifi - based devices have more than one hardware queue @xcite , their numbers are restricted ( up to 12 queues according to the list in @xcite ) , while the number of flows passing through a wireless device could be significantly higher .
also , multiple queues in the wireless devices are mainly constructed for prioritized traffic such as voice , video , etc .
, which further limits their usage as per - flow queues .
on the other hand , constructing per - flow queues may not be preferable in some other devices such as sensors or home appliances for which maintaining and handling per - flow queues could introduce too much processing and energy overhead .
thus , some devices , either due to rigid architecture or limited processing power and energy capacities , inevitably use shared fifo queues , which makes the understanding of the behavior of fifo queues over wireless networks very crucial .
_ example 1 - continued : _ let us consider fig .
[ fig : example_fifo_v1 ] again . when a fifo queue is used instead of per - flow queues , the well - known head - of - line ( hol ) blocking phenomenon occurs . as an example
, suppose that at transmission instant @xmath14 , the links @xmath15 and @xmath16 are at `` on '' and `` off '' states , respectively .
in this case , a packet from @xmath8 can be transmitted if per - flow queues are constructed . yet , in fifo case , if hol packet in @xmath17 belongs to flow @xmath5 , no packet can be transmitted and wireless resources are wasted .
@xmath13 although hol blocking in fifo queues is a well - known problem , achievable throughput with fifo queues in a wireless network is generally not known . in particular , stability region of a wireless network with fifo queues as well as resource allocation schemes to achieve optimal operating points in the stability region are still open problems . in this work ,
we investigate fifo queues over wireless networks .
we consider a wireless network model presented in fig .
[ fig : main - example ] with multiple fifo queues that are in the same transmission and interference range .
( note that this scenario is getting increasing interest in practice in the context of device - to - device and cooperative networks @xcite . )
our first step towards understanding the performance of fifo queues in such a setup is to characterize the stability region of the network .
then , based on the structure of the stability region , we develop efficient resource allocation algorithms ; _ deterministic fifo - control _ ( @xmath0 ) and _ queue - based fifo - control _ ( @xmath1 ) .
the following are the key contributions of this work : * we characterize the stability region of a general scenario where an arbitrary number of fifo queues are shared by an arbitrary number of flows . *
the stability region of the fifo queueing system under investigation is non - convex .
thus , we develop a convex inner - bound on the stability region , which is provably tight for certain operating points . *
we develop a resource allocation scheme ; @xmath0 , and a queue - based stochastic flow control and scheduling algorithm ; @xmath1 .
we show that @xmath1 achieves optimal operating point in the convex inner bound . * we evaluate our schemes via simulations for multiple fifo queues and flows .
the simulation results show that our algorithms significantly improve the throughput as compared to the well - known queue - based flow control and max - weight scheduling schemes .
the structure of the rest of the paper is as follows .
section [ sec : system ] gives an overview of the system model .
section [ sec : stability_region ] characterizes the stability region with fifo queues .
section [ sec : ofc_qfc ] presents our resource allocation algorithms ; @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
section [ sec : performance ] presents simulation results .
section [ sec : related ] presents related work .
section [ sec : conclusion ] concludes the paper .
_ wireless network setup : _ we consider a wireless network model presented in fig .
[ fig : main - example ] with @xmath18 fifo queues .
let @xmath19 be the set of fifo queues , @xmath20 be the @xmath21th fifo queue , and @xmath22 be the set of flows passing through @xmath20 .
also , let @xmath23 and @xmath24 denote the cardinalities of sets @xmath20 and @xmath22 , respectively .
we assume in our analysis that time is slotted , and @xmath14 refers to the beginning of slot @xmath14 . _
flow rates : _ each flow passing through @xmath20 and destined for node @xmath25 is generated according to an arrival process @xmath26 at time slot @xmath14 .
the arrivals are i.i.d . over the time slots such that for every @xmath27 and @xmath28 , we have @xmath29 $ ] and @xmath30<\infty$ ] , where @xmath31 $ ] denotes the expected value . _ channel model : _ in our setup in fig .
[ fig : main - example ] , as we mentioned earlier , we assume that all fifo queues are in the same transmission and interference range , _
i.e. , _ only one fifo queue could be served by a shared wireless medium at time @xmath14 . on the other hand ,
a channel state from a fifo queue to a receiver node may vary .
in particular , at slot @xmath14 , @xmath32 is the channel state vector , where @xmath33 is the state of the link at time @xmath14 from the @xmath21th queue @xmath34 to receiver node @xmath25 such that @xmath28 .
the link state @xmath33 takes values from the set @xmath35 according to a probability distribution which is i.i.d . over time slots .
if @xmath36 , packets can be transmitted to receiver node @xmath25 with rate @xmath37 .
we assume , for the sake of simplicity in this paper , that @xmath38 , and @xmath39 packet can be transmitted at time slot @xmath14 if @xmath36 .
if @xmath40 , no packets are transmitted .
the @xmath41 and @xmath42 probabilities of @xmath33 are @xmath43 and @xmath44 , respectively .
note that @xmath33 only determines the channel state ; _ i.e. , _ the actual transmission opportunity from @xmath20 depends on the hol packet as explained next .
_ queue structure and evolution : _ suppose that the head - of - line ( hol ) packet of @xmath34 at time @xmath14 is @xmath45 .
the hol packet together with the channel state defines the state of @xmath34 .
in particular , let @xmath46 be the state of @xmath34 at time @xmath14 such that @xmath47 .
the state of @xmath34 is @xmath41 , _
i.e. , _ @xmath48 if @xmath49 at time @xmath14 . otherwise , @xmath50 .
we define @xmath51 @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 @xmath55 @xmath56 @xmath57 @xmath54 @xmath58 @xmath59 @xmath60 as the set of the states of all fifo queues .
let us now consider the evolution of the hol packet .
if the state of queue @xmath34 is @xmath41 at time @xmath14 , _
@xmath61 , the hol packet can be transmitted ( depending on the scheduling policy ) .
if we assume that hol packet is transmitted according to the scheduling policy , then a new packet is placed in the hol position in @xmath34 . the probability that this new hol packet belongs to the @xmath25th flow is @xmath62 and it depends on the arrival rates via @xmath63
now , we can consider the evolution of @xmath34 . at time @xmath14
, @xmath64 packets arrive to @xmath34 , and @xmath65 packets are served according to the fifo manner .
thus , queue size @xmath66 evolves according to the following dynamics .
@xmath67 + \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } \lambda_{n , k}(t).\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath65 depends on the states of the queues ; @xmath68 at time @xmath14 , which characterize the stability region of the wireless network .
note that @xmath68 depends on arrival rates of flows to each fifo queue ; _ i.e. , _ @xmath69 as well as the @xmath41-@xmath42 probability of each link , _ i.e. , _ @xmath44 . in the next section , by taking into account @xmath69 and @xmath44 , we characterize the stability region of the wireless network .
in this section , our goal is to characterize the stability region of a wireless network where an arbitrary number of fifo queues are served by a wireless medium .
we first begin with the single - queue case shown in fig .
[ fig : fifo_one_queue_fig ] to convey our approach for a canonical scenario , then we extend our stability region analysis for arbitrary number of fifo queues and flows .
we study the special case of a single fifo queue @xmath70 where @xmath71 with @xmath72 . for this special case , we thus drop the queue index @xmath21 from the notation in section [ sec : system ] for brevity . in other words
, we write @xmath73 instead of @xmath74 , @xmath75 instead of @xmath33 , and so on .
our main result in this context is then the following theorem .
[ theorem1 ] for a fifo queue @xmath76 shared by @xmath77 @xmath52 @xmath78 @xmath79 @xmath80 flows , if the channel states @xmath75 and arrival rates @xmath81 are i.i.d . over time slots ,
the stability region @xmath82 includes all arrival rates satisfying @xmath83 in other words , the stability region of the single - fifo queue system is @xmath84 ( [ eq : stab_one_queue])@xmath85 . _
proof : _ the state of the fifo queue @xmath76 takes values from @xmath35 depending the hol packet and the states of the wireless links .
now , let us take a closer look at the fifo states .
the @xmath42 state occurs if for some @xmath86 we have @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
let @xmath89 be the state that @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
we denote the probability of @xmath89 as @xmath90 = p[h = k,\,c_k = off]$ ] .
also , let @xmath91 be the state that fifo queue is at @xmath41 state for some hol packet .
the state @xmath91 happens precisely when the channel corresponding to the hol packet is in the @xmath41 state .
therefore , the probability of @xmath91 is @xmath92 = p [ c_h = on]$ ] .
having defined the queue state probabilities , we can observe that the packets from the fifo queue could be served only at state @xmath91 .
it is also clear that the sum of the arrival rates to the queue @xmath76 should be less than the service rate , which is @xmath92 $ ] . noting that we assumed @xmath93 , we conclude that @xmath94 $ ] .
let us now calculate @xmath92 $ ] and @xmath90,\,k \in { \mathcal{k}}$ ] using a markov chain with states ; @xmath91 and @xmath95 .
we first show that the state transition probability from @xmath91 to @xmath89 is @xmath96 , where @xmath97 .
since we consider only one fifo queue , when the queue is at state @xmath91 , the hol packet is always transmitted .
the new hol packet in the next state will belong to the @xmath25th flow with probability @xmath98 , and @xmath88 with probability @xmath99 .
therefore , the state transition probability from @xmath91 to @xmath89 is @xmath100 , as claimed .
the probability of moving from state @xmath89 to @xmath91 is @xmath101 as we can move to the unblocking state @xmath91 from the blocking state @xmath89 if the channel is @xmath41 ( with probability @xmath102 . ) . on the other hand ,
staying in the blocking state @xmath89 is the @xmath42 probability of the channel @xmath103 .
thus , @xmath104 . note that the expressions for @xmath105 and @xmath106 do not involve the quantity @xmath98 .
the reason is that @xmath89 is the blocking state , so when we move from @xmath89 to another state ( or staying at state @xmath89 ) , the hol packet is not transmitted and does not change ( because @xmath107 at state @xmath89 ) .
for any given @xmath108 with @xmath109 , the state transition probability from @xmath110 to @xmath111 is @xmath112 .
this follows since it is not possible to move from a blocking state to another ( the hol packet can not be transmitted . ) .
finally , the probability of staying at state @xmath91 is @xmath113 as the condition @xmath114 should be satisfied .
the state transition probabilities are as shown in fig .
[ fig : markov_chain_single_fifo ] .
now that we know the state transition probabilities of our markov chain , we can calculate the balance equations , and these yield @xmath92 = \frac{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } \lambda_{k } } { \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } \lambda_{k}/\bar{p}_{k}}$ ] .
the calculations are provided in the following .
let @xmath115 = \begin{bmatrix } p[z_0 ] & p[z_1 ] & \ldots & p[z_k ] \end{bmatrix}^{t}$ ] . in the steady the state , the following set of equations are satisfied for the markov chain shown in fig .
[ fig : markov_chain_single_fifo ] .
@xmath116^{t } \begin{bmatrix } 1 - \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } \alpha_kp_k & \alpha_1p_1 & \ldots & \alpha_kp_k \\
\bar{p}_1 & p_1 & \ldots & 0 \\
\bar{p}_2 & 0 & \ldots & 0 \\ \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & \vdots \\ \bar{p}_{k } & 0 & \ldots & p_k \end{bmatrix } = p[\boldsymbol z]\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we combine the @xmath117th equation in ( [ eq : ststmatrix ] ) , which is @xmath90 = p[z_0 ] \frac{\alpha_kp_k}{\bar{p}_{k}}$ ] , and the fact that @xmath92 + \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } p[z_k ] = 1 $ ] , we have @xmath118 = \frac{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } \lambda_{k}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } \lambda_{k}/\bar{p}_{k}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can then obtain @xmath94 = \frac{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } \lambda_{k } } { \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k } } } \lambda_{k}/\bar{p}_{k}}$ ] which is equivalent to ( [ eq : stab_one_queue ] ) .
this concludes the proof .
@xmath119 now suppose that single - fifo queue @xmath76 is shared by two flows with rates @xmath120 and @xmath121 . according to theorem [ theorem1 ]
, the arrival rates should satisfy @xmath122 for stability .
this stability region is shown in fig .
[ fig : fifo_one_queue_fig](b ) . in the same figure
, we also show the stability region of per - flow queues , @xcite . as seen , the fifo stability region is smaller as compared to per - flow capacity region .
yet , we still need flow control and scheduling algorithms to achieve the optimal operating point in this stability region . this issue will be discussed later in section [ sec : ofc_qfc ] .
@xmath13 we now consider a wireless network with arbitrary number of fifo queues and flows as shown in fig .
[ fig : main - example ] .
the main challenge in this setup is that packet scheduling decisions affect the stability region .
for example , if both @xmath123 and @xmath20 in fig .
[ fig : main - example ] are at @xmath41 state , a decision about which queue to be served should be made .
this decision affects future transmission opportunities from the queues , hence the stability region . in this paper
, we consider a scheduling policy where the packet transmission probability of each queue depends only on the queue states .
in other words , if the state of the fifo queues is @xmath124 , a packet from queue @xmath21 is transmitted with probability @xmath125 .
we call this scheduling policy the _ queue - state _ policy . note that as @xmath126 @xmath127 @xmath54 @xmath55 is the transmission probability from queue @xmath34 , we have the obvious constraint @xmath128 our main result is then the following theorem .
[ theorem2 ] for a wireless network with @xmath18 fifo queues , if a queue - state policy @xmath126 is employed , then the stability region consists of the flow rates that satisfy @xmath129}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } \lambda_{n , k}/\bar{p}_{n , k } }
\nonumber \\ & \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}-\{n\ } } \biggr ( \frac{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \lambda_{m , k } \rho_{m , k}(s_m)}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \lambda_{m , k}/\bar{p}_{m , k } } \biggl ) \tau_{n } ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) \biggr \ } , \nonumber \\ &
\forall n \in { \mathcal{n } } , k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath130 } & = \left\{\begin{array}{rl}1 , & s_n = on \\ 0 , & s_{n } = off\end{array}\right . , \\
\rho_{m , k}(s_m ) & = \left\{\begin{array}{rl } 1 , & s_m = on \\
{ p_{m , k}}/{\bar{p}_{m , k } } , & s_m = off \end{array } \right .. \end{aligned}\ ] ] _ proof : _ the proof is provided in appendix a. @xmath119 the stability region of a fifo queue system with @xmath18 fifo queues served by a wireless medium is characterized by @xmath82 @xmath52 @xmath131 ( [ eq : lamdba_nk ] ) , ( [ eq : sum_tau])@xmath132 @xmath69 @xmath133 @xmath21 @xmath59 @xmath134 @xmath25 @xmath59 @xmath135 @xmath136 @xmath54 @xmath55 @xmath137 @xmath138 @xmath139 @xmath21 @xmath140 .
now let us consider two fifo queues @xmath34 and @xmath141 which are shared by three flows with rates ; @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 ( fig .
[ fig : two_queue](a ) ) . according to theorem [ theorem2 ]
, the stability region @xmath82 should include arrival rates satisfying inequalities in ( [ eq : lamdba_nk ] ) and ( [ eq : sum_tau ] ) . in this example , with two queues and three flows , these inequalities are equivalent to @xmath145 with @xmath146 @xmath147 @xmath148 @xmath149 , and @xmath150 @xmath151 @xmath39 .
the stability region corresponding to these inequalities is the region below the surface in fig .
[ fig : two_queue](b ) .
@xmath13 in general , we wish to find the optimal operating points on the boundary of the stability region @xmath82 . however , the stability region may not be convex for arbitrary number of queues and flows . developing a convex
inner bound on the stability region is crucial for developing efficient resource allocation algorithms for wireless networks with fifo queues .
we thus next propose a convex inner bound on the stability region .
let us consider a flow with arrival rate @xmath69 to the fifo queue @xmath34 .
if there are no other flows and queues in the network , then the arrival rate should satisfy @xmath152 according to theorem [ theorem2 ] . in this formulation
, @xmath153 is the total amount of wireless resources that should be allocated to transmit the flow with rate @xmath69 . for multiple - flow , single - fifo case ,
the stability region is @xmath154 .
similar to the single - flow case , @xmath155 term is the amount of wireless resources that should be allocated to the @xmath25th flow .
finally , for the general stability region for arbitrary number of queues and flows , let us consider ( [ eq : lamdba_nk ] ) again .
assuming @xmath156 , we can write @xmath157 from ( [ eq : lamdba_nk ] ) as ; @xmath158}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } \lambda_{n , k}/\bar{p}_{n , k } } \nonumber \\ & \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}-\{n\ } } \psi_{m}(s_m ) \tau_{n } ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) \biggr \ } , \forall n \in { \mathcal{n } } , k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which , assuming that @xmath159 , is equivalent to @xmath160 } \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}-\{n\ } } \psi_{m}(s_m ) \nonumber \\ & \tau_{n } ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) , \forall
n \in { \mathcal{n } } , k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n}\end{aligned}\ ] ] intuitively speaking , the right hand side of ( [ eq : gec_v2 ] ) corresponds to the amount of wireless resources that is allocated to the @xmath21th queue @xmath34 .
thus , similar to the single - fifo queue , we can consider that @xmath155 term corresponds to the amount of wireless resources that should be allocated to the @xmath25th flow .
our key point while developing an inner bound on the stability region is to provide rate fairness across competing flows in each fifo queue . since each flow requires @xmath155 amount of wireless resources ; it is intuitive to have the following equality @xmath161 , @xmath109 to fairly allocate wireless resources across flows .
more generally , we define a function @xmath162 , @xmath163 where @xmath164 , and we develop a stability region for @xmath165 instead of @xmath69 .
the role of the exponent @xmath166 is to provide flexibility to the targeted fairness .
for example , if we want to allocate more resources to flows with better channels , then @xmath166 should be larger .
now , by the definition of @xmath165 , we have the equivalent form @xmath167}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta-1 } } \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}- \{n\ } } \omega_{m}(s_{m } ) \nonumber \\ & \tau_{n}(s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) , \forall n \in { \mathcal{n}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] of ( [ eq : lamdba_nk ] ) , where @xmath168 .
as seen , ( [ eq : an ] ) is a convex function of @xmath165 .
thus , we can define the region @xmath169 ( [ eq : an ] ) , ( [ eq : sum_tau ] ) , @xmath170 , which is clearly an inner bound on the actual stability region @xmath82 . despite the fact that @xmath171 is only inner bound on @xmath82 , for some operating points , _
i.e. , _ at the intersection of @xmath161 , @xmath109 lines , the two stability regions ( @xmath171 and @xmath82 ) coincide .
thus , for some utility functions , optimal operating points in both @xmath171 and @xmath82 coincide . in the next section ,
we develop resource allocation schemes ; @xmath0 and @xmath1 that achieve utility optimal operating points in @xmath171 .
in this section , we develop resource allocation schemes ; _ deterministic fifo - control _ ( @xmath0 ) , and a _ queue - based fifo control _ ( @xmath1 ) . in general , our goal is to solve the optimization problem @xmath172 and to find the corresponding optimal rates , where @xmath173 is a concave utility function assigned to flow with rate @xmath69 . although the objective function @xmath174 in ( [ eq : main_opt ] ) is concave , the optimization domain @xmath82 ( _ i.e. , _ the stability region ) may not be convex .
thus , we convert this problem to a convex optimization problem based on the structure of the inner bound we have developed in section [ sec : stability_single_innerbound ] . in particular , setting @xmath162 , the problem in ( [ eq : main_opt ] ) reduces to @xmath175 @xmath176 , @xmath177 .
this is our deterministic fifo - control scheme ; @xmath0 and expressed explicitly as ; @xmath178}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta-1 } } \nonumber \\ & \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}- \{n\ } } \omega_{m}(s_m ) \tau_{n}(s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) , \forall
n \in { \mathcal{n}}\nonumber \\ & \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \tau_{n } ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) \leq 1 , \forall ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) \in { \mathcal{s}}\nonumber \\ & a_n \geq 0 , \forall n \in { \mathcal{n } } , ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) \in { \mathcal{s}}\nonumber \\ & \tau_{n } ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) \geq 0 , \forall n \in { \mathcal{n } } , ( s_1 , \ldots , s_n ) \in { \mathcal{s}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath0 optimizes @xmath165 and @xmath179 . after the optimal values are determined , packets are inserted into the fifo queue @xmath34 depending on @xmath180 and served from the fifo queue @xmath34 depending on @xmath179 .
although @xmath0 gives us optimal operating points in the stability region ; @xmath171 , it is a centralized solution , and its adaptation to varying wireless channel conditions is limited .
thus , we also develop a more practical and queue - based fifo - control scheme @xmath1 , next .
* _ flow control : _ at every slot @xmath14 , the flow controller attached to the fifo queue @xmath34 determines @xmath181 according to ; @xmath182 - q_{n}(t)a_{n}(t ) \nonumber \\ \mbox{s.t . } \mbox { } & a_n(t ) \leq r_{n}^{max } , a_n(t ) \geq 0 \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath183 is a large positive number , and @xmath184 is a positive value larger than the maximum outgoing rate from fifo queue @xmath20 ( which is @xmath185 as we assume that the maximum outgoing rate from a queue is 1 packet per slot ) .
after @xmath181 is determined according to ( [ eq : flow_control ] ) , @xmath26 is set as @xmath26 @xmath52 @xmath186 @xmath187 .
then , @xmath26 packets from the @xmath25th flow are inserted in @xmath34 . * _ scheduling : _ at slot @xmath14 , the scheduling algorithm determines the fifo queue from which a packet is transmitted according to ; @xmath188}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } } \tau_{n}(s_1(t ) , \ldots , s_n(t ) ) \nonumber \\ \mbox{s.t . }
\mbox { } & \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \tau_{n } ( s_1(t ) , \ldots , s_n(t ) ) \leq 1 , \nonumber \\ & \tau_{n } ( s_1(t ) , \ldots , s_n(t ) ) \geq 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] after @xmath189 is determined , the outgoing traffic rate from queue @xmath34 is set to @xmath65 @xmath52 @xmath126 @xmath190 @xmath54 @xmath191 @xmath192}$ ] , and @xmath65 packets ( which is 1 or 0 in our case ) are transmitted from @xmath34 . thus , the queue dynamics change according to ( [ eq : queue_qn ] ) and based on ( [ eq : flow_control ] ) and ( [ eq : scheduling ] ) .
such queue dynamics lead to the following result .
[ theorem_lyap ] if the channel states are i.i.d . over time slots ,
the traffic arrival rates are controlled by the rate control algorithm in ( [ eq : flow_control ] ) , and the fifo queues are served by the scheduling algorithm in ( [ eq : scheduling ] ) , then the admitted flow rates converge to the utility optimal operating point in the stability region @xmath171 with increasing @xmath183 .
_ proof : _ the proof is provided in appendix b. @xmath13
in this section , we evaluate our @xmath0 and @xmath1 algorithms as compared to the baselines ; ( i ) _ optimal _ solution , and ( ii ) _ max - weight _ algorithm for different number of fifo queues and flows .
next , we briefly explain our baselines .
the _ optimal _ solution is a solution to ( [ eq : main_opt ] ) , and we compared @xmath0 and @xmath1 with the _ optimal _ solution for some scenarios where the stability region @xmath82 is convex . on the other hand , _ max - weight _ algorithm is a queue - based flow control and max - weight scheduling scheme .
our baseline _ max - weight _ algorithm mimics the structure of the solution provided in @xcite , and it is summarized briefly in the following . * _ flow control : _ at every time slot @xmath14 , the flow controller attached to the fifo queue @xmath34 determines @xmath26 according to ; @xmath193 - q_{n , k}(t)\lambda_{n , k}(t ) \nonumber \\ \mbox{s.t . }
\mbox { } & \lambda_{n , k}(t ) \leq r_{n , k}^{max } , \forall k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath183 and @xmath194 are positive large constants similar to ( [ eq : flow_control ] ) , and @xmath195 is the number of packets that belong to the @xmath25th flow in queue @xmath34 . *
_ scheduling : _ at slot @xmath14 , the scheduling algorithm determines the fifo queue from which a packet is transmitted according to ; @xmath196 } \tau_{n}(s_1(t ) , \ldots , s_n(t ) ) \nonumber \\ \mbox{s.t . } \mbox { } & \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \tau_{n } ( s_1(t ) , \ldots , s_n(t ) ) \leq 1 \nonumber \\ & \tau_{n } ( s_1(t ) , \ldots , s_n(t ) ) \geq 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] after @xmath126 @xmath190 @xmath54 @xmath197 is determined , a packet from the queue @xmath34 is transmitted if @xmath126 @xmath190 @xmath54 @xmath191 @xmath52 @xmath39 ; no packet is transmitted , otherwise .
next , we present our simulation results for single and multiple fifo queues . in this section ,
we consider a single fifo queue @xmath198 .
similar to section [ sec : stability_single_queue ] , we drop the queue index @xmath199 from the notation for brevity . in other words , we write @xmath200 instead of @xmath201 , @xmath99 instead of @xmath202 , and so on . fig .
[ fig : sim_1 ] presents simulation results for a single queue and two flows for @xmath203 , @xmath204 , and @xmath205 .
[ fig : sim_1](a ) shows per - flow rates ; @xmath206 and @xmath207 when @xmath208 is increasing .
as seen , @xmath206 is the same for all algorithms ; optimal , @xmath0 , and @xmath1 .
this also holds for @xmath207 .
these results show that our algorithms @xmath0 and @xmath1 are as good as the optimal solution , and achieve the optimal operating points in @xmath82 in this scenario .
the simulations results also show that our algorithms reduce the second flow rate @xmath207 when @xmath208 increases while @xmath206 and @xmath209 do not change .
this means that our algorithms do not penalize a flow ( flow 1 ) when the channel of another competing flow ( flow 2 ) deteriorates , which shows the effectiveness of our algorithms to provide fairness .
[ fig : sim_1](b ) shows the total rate @xmath210 versus @xmath208 for the same setup .
as seen , our algorithms improves throughput over max - weight significantly .
this is expected as our algorithms are designed to reduce the hol blocking and to allocate wireless resources fairly among multiple flows .
[ fig : sim_2 ] shows simulation results for a single queue shared by multiple flows . in this setup , @xmath211 is selected randomly between @xmath212 $ ] , @xmath213 , @xmath205 .
the simulations are repeated for 1000 different seeds , and the average values are reported .
[ fig : sim_2](a ) shows average flow rate versus number of flows for our algorithms as well as max - weight . as seen , @xmath0 and @xmath1 are as good as the optimal solution , and they improve over max - weight significantly . fig . [
fig : sim_2](b ) shows the same simulation results , but reports the improvement of @xmath1 over max - weight .
this figure shows that the improvement of our algorithms increases with increasing number of flows .
indeed , the improvement is up to 100% when @xmath214 , which is significant .
the improvement is higher for large number of flows , because our algorithm allocates resources to the flows based on the quality of their channels and reduces the flow rate for the flows with bad channel conditions .
however , max - weight does not have such a mechanism , and when there are more flows in the system , the probability of having a flow with bad channel condition increases , which reduces the overall throughput . in this section ,
we consider two fifo queues @xmath141 and @xmath34 .
there are four flows in the system and each queue carries two flows , _
@xmath34 carries flows with rates @xmath142 , @xmath143 and @xmath141 carries flows with rates @xmath144 , @xmath215 .
( [ fig : sim_3])(a ) shows the total flow rate versus @xmath166 for the scenario of two - fifo queues with four flows when @xmath216 , @xmath217 , @xmath218 , @xmath219 , and @xmath220 utility is employed , _
i.e. , _ @xmath221 .
( we do not present the results of the optimal solution as the stability region @xmath82 is not convex in this scenario . ) as seen , @xmath0 and @xmath1 have the same performance and improve over max - weight .
the improvement increases with increasing @xmath166 as @xmath0 and @xmath1 penalize flows with bad channel conditions more when @xmath166 increases , which increases the total throughput .
( [ fig : sim_3])(b ) shows the total rate versus @xmath222 for two - fifo queues with four flows when @xmath223 and @xmath224 .
as seen , @xmath0 and @xmath1 improve significantly over max - weight .
furthermore , they achieve almost maximum achievable rate @xmath39 all the time .
the reason is that @xmath0 and @xmath1 penalizes the queues with with bad channels .
for example , when @xmath225 , the total rate is @xmath39 , because they allocate all the resources to @xmath142 and @xmath144 as there is no point to allocate those resources to @xmath143 and @xmath215 since their channels are always @xmath42 . on the other hand , max - weight
does not arrange the flow and queue service rates based on the channel conditions , so the total rate reduces to @xmath226 when @xmath225 , _
i.e. , _ it is not possible to transmit any packets when max - weight is employed in this scenario .
[ fig : sim_4 ] further demonstrates how our algorithms treat flows with bad channel conditions .
in particular , fig . [
fig : sim_4 ] presents per - flow rate versus @xmath227 for the scenario of two - fifo queues with four flows when @xmath228 and @xmath224 for ( a ) @xmath0 and @xmath1 and ( b ) max - weight .
as seen , when @xmath227 increases , @xmath215 decreases in fig .
[ fig : sim_4](a ) since its channel is getting worse . yet
, this does not affect the other flows .
in fact , @xmath144 even increases as more resources are allocated to it when @xmath227 increases . on the other hand , both @xmath144 and @xmath215 decrease with increasing @xmath227 in max - weight ( fig .
[ fig : sim_4](b ) ) .
this is not fair , because @xmath144 decreases with increasing @xmath227 although its channel is always @xmath41 as @xmath229 . in the same scenario ( fig .
[ fig : sim_4](b ) ) , the rates of the @xmath21th queue ( @xmath142 and @xmath143 ) increase with increasing @xmath227 as they use available resource opportunistically .
this makes the total rate the same for @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and max - weight . yet , as we discussed , max - weight is not fair to flow @xmath144 in this scenario .
in this work , our goal is to understand fifo queues in wireless networks and develop efficient flow control and scheduling policies for such a setup . in the seminal paper @xcite ,
the authors analyze fifo queues in an input queued switch .
they show that the use of fifo queues in that context limits the throughput to approximately 58% of the maximum achievable throughput . however , in the context of wireless networks , similar results are in general not known .
backpressure routing and scheduling framework has emer - ged from the pioneering work @xcite , which has generated a lot of research interest @xcite ; especially for wireless ad - hoc networks @xcite .
furthermore , it has been shown that backpressure can be combined with flow control to provide utility - optimal operation guarantee @xcite .
such previous work mainly considered per - flow queues .
however , fifo queueing structure , which is the focus of this paper , is not compatible with the per - flow queueing requirements of these routing and scheduling schemes .
the strengths of backpressure - based network control have recently received increasing interest in terms of practical implementation .
multi - path tcp scheme is implemented over wireless mesh networks in @xcite for routing and scheduling packets using a backpressure based heuristic . at the link layer ,
@xcite propose , analyze , and evaluate link layer backpressure - based implementations with queue prioritization and congestion window size adjustment .
backpressure is implemented over sensor networks @xcite and wireless multi - hop networks @xcite . in these schemes ,
either last - in , first - out queueing is employed @xcite or link layer fifo queues are strictly controlled @xcite to reduce the number of packets in the fifo queues , hence hol blocking . in backpressure
, each node constructs per - flow queues .
there is some work in the literature to stretch this necessity .
for example , @xcite , @xcite propose using real per - link and virtual per - flow queues .
such a method reduces the number of queues required in each node , and reduces the delay , but it still needs to construct per - link queues .
similarly , @xcite constructs per - link queues in the link layer , and schedule packets according to fifo rule from these queues .
such a setup is different than ours as per - link queues do not introduce hol blocking .
the main differences in our work are : ( i ) we consider fifo queues shared by multiple flows where hol blocking occurs as each flow is transmitted over a possibly different wireless link , ( ii ) we characterize the stability region of a general scenario where an arbitrary number of fifo queues , which are served by a wireless medium , are shared by an arbitrary number of flows , and ( iii ) we develop efficient resource allocation schemes to exploit achievable rate in such a setup .
we investigated the performance of fifo queues over wireless networks and characterized the stability region of this system for arbitrary number of fifo queues and flows .
we developed inner bound on the stability region , and developed resource allocation schemes ; @xmath0 and @xmath1 , which achieve optimal operating point in the convex inner bound .
simulation results show that our algorithms significantly improve throughput in a wireless network with fifo queues as compared to the well - known queue - based flow control and max - weight scheduling schemes .
cisco visual networking index : global mobile data traffic forecast update , 2010 - 2015 .
ericsson mobility report , november 2013 .
l. tassiulas and a. ephremides , `` stability properties of constrained queueing systems and scheduling policies for maximum throughput in multihop radio networks , '' _ ieee trans . autom .
19361948 , dec . 1992 .
l. tassiulas and a. ephremides , `` dynamic server allocation to parallel queues with randomly varying connectivity , '' _ ieee trans .
inf . theory _ ,
2 , pp . 466478 , mar .
m. j. neely , e. modiano , and c. li , `` fairness and optimal stochastic control for heterogeneous networks , '' _ ieee / acm trans .
2 , pp . 396409 , apr . 2008 . http://madwifi-project.org/wiki/chipsets .
l. keller , a. le , b. cici , h. seferoglu , c. fragouli , a. markopoulou , `` microcast : cooperative video streaming on smartphones , '' _ acm mobisys _ , june 2012 .
m. j. karol , m. g. hluchyj , and s. p. morgan , `` input versus output queueing on a space - division packet switch , '' _ ieee trans .
13471356 , dec . 1987 .
m. j. neely , _
stochastic network optimization with application to communication and queueing systems _ ,
morgan & claypool , 2010 .
l. tassiulas , `` scheduling and performance limits of networks with constantly changing topology , '' _ ieee trans .
inf . theory _ ,
3 , pp . 10671073 , may 1997 .
n. kahale and p. e. wright , `` dynamic global packet routing in wireless networks , '' _ ieee infocom _ , apr .
m. andrews , k. kumaran , k. ramanan , a. stolyar , p. whiting , and r. vijaykumar , `` providing quality of service over a shared wireless link , '' _ ieee commun . mag .
2 , pp . 150154 , feb . 2001 .
m. j. neely , e. modiano , and c. e. rohrs , `` dynamic power allocation and routing for time varying wireless networks , '' _ ieee j. select .
areas commun .
1 , pp . 89103 , jan .
a. l. stolyar , `` greedy primal dual algorithm for dynamic resource allocation in complex networks , '' _ queuing systems _ , vol .
3 , pp . 203220 , 2006 .
j. liu , a. l. stolyar , m. chiang , and h. v. poor , `` queue backpressure random access in multihop wireless networks : optimality and stability , '' _ ieee trans .
inf . theory _ ,
9 , pp . 40874098 , sept . 2009 .
b. radunovic , c. gkantsidis , d. gunawardena , and p. key , `` horizon : balancing tcp over multiple paths in wireless mesh network , '' _ acm mobicom _
, sept . 2008 .
a. warrier , s. janakiraman , s. ha , i. rhee , `` diffq : practical differential backlog congestion control for wireless networks , '' _ ieee infocom _ , apr .
u. akyol , m. andrews , p. gupta , j. hobby , i. saniee , and a. stolyar , `` joint scheduling and congestion control in mobile ad - hoc networks , '' _ ieee infocom _ , apr .
a. sridharan , s. moeller , b. krishnamachari , `` making distributed rate control using lyapunov drifts a reality in wireless sensor networks , '' _ ieee wiopt _ , apr .
s. moeller , a. sridharan , b. krishnamachari , and o. gnawali , `` routing without routes : the backpressure collection protocol , '' _ acm ipsn _
r. laufer , t. salonidis , h. lundgren , and p. l. guyadec , `` xpress : a cross - layer backpressure architecture for wireless multi - hop networks , '' _ acm mobicom _ , sept . 2011 .
e. athanasopoulou , l. x. bui , t. ji , r. srikant , and a. stolyar , `` backpressure - based packet - by - packet adaptive routing in communication networks , '' _ ieee / acm trans .
1 , pp . 244257 , feb . 2013 .
l. x. bui , r. srikant , and a. stolyar , `` a novel architecture for reduction of delay and queueing structure complexity in the back - pressure algorithm , '' _ ieee / acm trans .
19 , no . 6 , pp .
15971609 , dec . 2011 .
h. seferoglu , e. modiano , `` diff - max : separation of routing and scheduling in backpressure - based wireless networks , '' _ ieee infocom _ , apr .
in this section , we provide a proof of theorem [ theorem2 ] for arbitrary number of fifo queues and flows .
let us first consider @xmath69 , which should satisfy the following inequality .
1_{[s_n ] } \nonumber \\ & \tau_{n}(s_1,\ldots , s_n ) , \forall n \in { \mathcal{n } } , k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath231 $ ] is the probability that the states of the queues are @xmath232 and @xmath233 , which is required as we can transmit a packet from the @xmath25th flow only when the hol packet belongs to the @xmath25th flow . in this equation , we can calculate @xmath231 $ ] as @xmath234 = \sum_{l_1 \in { \mathcal{k}}_{1 } } \ldots \sum_{l_{n-1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n-1 } } \sum_{l_{n+1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n+1 } } \ldots \nonumber \\ & \sum_{l_n \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } p[s_{1 } , \ldots , s_{n } , h_{n}=k , h_1=l_1 , \ldots , h_{n-1}=l_{n-1 } , \nonumber \\ & h_{n+1}=l_{n+1 } , \ldots , h_{n}=l_{n } ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath234 = \sum_{l_1 \in { \mathcal{k}}_{1 } } \ldots \sum_{l_{n-1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n-1 } } \sum_{l_{n+1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n+1 } } \ldots \nonumber \\ & \sum_{l_n \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } \underbrace{p[s_1 | h_1=l_1]}_{\triangleq \xi_{1,l_1}(s_1 ) } \ldots \underbrace{p[s_{n-1 } | h_{n-1}=l_{n-1}]}_{\triangleq \xi_{n-1,l_{n-1}}(s_{n-1 } ) } \nonumber \\ & \underbrace{p[s_{n } | h_{n}=k]}_{\triangleq \xi_{n , k}(s_{n } ) } \underbrace{p[s_{n+1 } | h_{n+1 } = l_{n+1}]}_{\triangleq \xi_{n+1,l_{n+1}}(s_{n+1 } ) } \ldots \underbrace{p[s_{n } | h_{n } = l_{n}]}_{\triangleq \xi_{n , l_{n}}(s_{n } ) } \nonumber \\
& p[h_{n}=k , h_{1}=l_{1 } , \ldots , h_{n-1}=l_{n-1 } , h_{n+1}=l_{n+1 } , \ldots , \nonumber \\ & h_{n}=l_{n}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we have @xmath235 = \sum_{l_1 \in { \mathcal{k}}_{1 } } \ldots \sum_{l_{n-1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n-1 } } \sum_{l_{n+1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n+1 } } \ldots \nonumber \\ & \sum_{l_n \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } { \xi_{1,l_1}(s_1 ) } \ldots { \xi_{n-1,l_{n-1}}(s_{n-1 } ) } { \xi_{n , k}(s_{n } ) } \nonumber \\ & { \xi_{n+1,l_{n+1}}(s_{n+1 } ) } \ldots { \xi_{n , l_{n}}(s_{n } ) } p[h_{n}=k , h_{1}=l_{1 } , \ldots , \nonumber \\ & h_{n-1}=l_{n-1 } , h_{n+1}=l_{n+1 } , \ldots , h_{n}=l_{n } ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] now , we should calculate @xmath236 $ ] .
we claim that @xmath237 @xmath238 @xmath54 @xmath239 @xmath240 @xmath54 @xmath241 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath242 $ ] @xmath79 @xmath243 $ ] @xmath244 $ ] @xmath245 $ ] @xmath79 @xmath246 $ ] . to prove this claim , we should show , without loosing generality , that the following conditions hold .
@xmath247 = p[h_{n}=k ] \nonumber \\
\mbox{c2 : } & p[h_{n}=k | h_1=l_1 , \ldots , h_{n-1}=l_{n-1 } , h_{n+1}=l_{n+1 } , \nonumber \\ & \ldots , h_{n-1}=l_{n-1 } ] = p[h_{n}=k ] \nonumber \\ & \mbox { } \vdots \nonumber \\ \mbox{cn : } & p[h_{n}=k | h_1=l_1 ] = p[h_{n}=k ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] we can calculate the conditional probabilities in the left hand side of the conditions ; c1 , c2 , @xmath79 , cn in ( [ eq : app_cond_prob ] ) by using a markov chain . for c1 , we can write a state transition probability of going from state @xmath248 to @xmath249 as @xmath250 @xmath240 @xmath54 @xmath241 $ ] , which is equal to @xmath251 .
_ i.e. , _ @xmath252 @xmath239 @xmath253 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath251 . similarly , if we write the state transition probabilities for the other conditions c2 ,
@xmath79 , cn , we have @xmath254 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath255 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath79 @xmath52 @xmath256 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath257 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath257 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath258 .
therefore , in all markov chains we can create for c1 , c2 , @xmath79 , cn , we have the same transition probabilities , so we have @xmath259 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath260 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath261 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath262 $ ] .
this proves our claim that @xmath263 @xmath239 @xmath264 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath242 $ ] @xmath79 @xmath243 $ ] @xmath244 $ ] @xmath245 $ ] @xmath79 @xmath246 $ ] .
now that we have shown that @xmath263 @xmath239 @xmath264 $ ] @xmath52 @xmath242 $ ] @xmath79 @xmath243 $ ] @xmath244 $ ] @xmath245 $ ] @xmath79 @xmath246 $ ] holds , ( [ eq : states_v1 ] ) is expressed as @xmath265 = \sum_{l_1 \in { \mathcal{k}}_{1 } } \ldots \sum_{l_{n-1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n-1 } } \sum_{l_{n+1 } \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n+1 } } \ldots \nonumber \\ & \sum_{l_n \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } { \xi_{1,l_1}(s_1)}p[h_1=l_1 ] \ldots { \xi_{n-1,l_{n-1}}(s_{n-1 } ) } \nonumber \\ & p[h_{n-1}=l_{n-1 } ] { \xi_{n , k}(s_{n } ) } p[h_{n}=k ] { \xi_{n+1,l_{n+1}}(s_{n+1 } ) } \nonumber \\ & p[h_{n+1}=l_{n+1 } ] \ldots { \xi_{n , l_{n}}(s_{n } ) } p[h_{n}=l_{n } ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which leads to @xmath266 = \xi_{n , k}(s_n)p[h_n = k ] \nonumber \\ & \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}-\{n\ } } \left ( \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \xi_{m , k}(s_{m } ) p[h_{m}=k ] \right ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] now , we should calculate @xmath267 $ ] in ( [ eq : states_v4 ] ) .
the state transition diagram for the states @xmath268 , @xmath269 and for the @xmath270th queue is shown in fig .
[ fig : app_km_flows ] . we can write the global balance equations for the state @xmath271 as @xmath272 \bar{p}_{m,1}\pi_{m}\alpha_{m , k } + \ldots + p[h_m = k][1 - \bar{p}_{m , k}\pi_{m } \nonumber \\ & + \bar{p}_{m , k}\pi_{m}\alpha_{m , k } ] + \ldots + p[h_m = k_m ] \bar{p}_{m , k_m}\pi_{m}\alpha_{m , k } = \nonumber \\ & p[h_m = k ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which is expressed as @xmath273 + \ldots + \bar{p}_{m , k } p[h_m = k ] + \ldots + \nonumber \\ & \bar{p}_{m , k_m } p[h_m = k_m ] ) = p[h_m = k ] \bar{p}_{m , k } \pi_{m } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which leads to @xmath274 = p[h_m = k ] \bar{p}_{m , k}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , the global balance equations for state @xmath275 leads to @xmath276 = p[h_m = l ] \bar{p}_{m , l}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] from ( [ eq : app_state_mk ] ) and ( [ eq : app_state_ml ] ) , we have @xmath277\bar{p}_{m , k}}{p[h_m = l]\bar{p}_{m , l}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we have @xmath278 = \frac{\alpha_{m , l}}{\bar{p}_{m , l } } \frac{p[h_m = k]}{\alpha_{m , k } } \bar{p}_{m , k}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath279 = 1 $ ] should be satisfied , we have @xmath280 = \frac{\lambda_{m , k}/\bar{p}_{m , k}}{\sum_{l \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \lambda_{m , l } / \bar{p}_{m , l}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] when ( [ eq : app_prob_hm_k ] ) is substituted in ( [ eq : states_v4 ] ) , we have @xmath281 = \xi_{n , k}(s_n ) \frac{\lambda_{n , k}/\bar{p}_{n ,
k}}{\sum_{l \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \lambda_{n , l } / \bar{p}_{n , l } } \nonumber \\ & \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}-\{n\ } } \frac{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \xi_{m , k}(s_m)\lambda_{m , k}/\bar{p}_{m , k}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \lambda_{m , k}/\bar{p}_{m , k}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath282 , we have @xmath283 = \xi_{n , k}(s_n ) \frac{\lambda_{n , k}/\bar{p}_{n , k}}{\sum_{l \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \lambda_{n , l } / \bar{p}_{n , l } } \nonumber \\ & \prod_{m \in { \mathcal{n}}-\{n\ } } \frac{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \rho_{m , k}(s_m)\lambda_{m , k}}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{m } } \lambda_{m , k}/\bar{p}_{m , k}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] when we substitute ( [ eq : states_v6 ] ) into ( [ eq : appa_1 ] ) , we have ( [ eq : lamdba_nk ] ) .
this concludes the proof .
let define a lyapunov function as ; @xmath284 , and the lyapunov drift as ; @xmath285 $ ] , where @xmath286 .
then , the lyapunov drift is expressed as ; @xmath287 \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that we have , from eq .
( [ eq : queue_qn ] ) and the assumption @xmath288 that , @xmath289 + a_{n}(t ) \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n}}(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq .
( [ eq : appb_queue_qn ] ) in eq .
( [ eq : appb_drift1 ] ) , and using the fact that @xmath290 , we have @xmath291\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is expressed as @xmath292\end{aligned}\ ] ] there always exist a finite and positive @xmath5 satisfying ; @xmath293 $ ] .
thus , eq . ( [ eq : appb_drift2 ] ) is expressed as ; @xmath294\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that if the flow arrival rates @xmath295 are inside the capacity region @xmath171 , then the minimizing the right hand side of the drift inequality in eq .
( [ eq : appb_drift3 ] ) corresponds to the scheduling part of @xmath1 in eq .
( [ eq : scheduling ] ) .
now , let us consider again the stability region constraint in eq .
( [ eq : appa_1 ] ) , which is @xmath69 @xmath151 @xmath296 1_{[s_n ] } \tau_{n}(s_1,\ldots , s_n ) , \forall
n \in { \mathcal{n } } , k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n}$ ] , and expressed as ; @xmath297 \bigr ) 1_{[s_n ] } \nonumber \\ & \tau_{n}(s_1 \ldots s_n)\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is equal to @xmath298 1_{[s_n ] } \tau_{n}(s_1 \ldots s_n)\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath299 , we have @xmath300 1_{[s_n ] } \tau_{n}(s_1 \ldots s_n)\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath301 1_{[s_n ] } \tau_{n}(s_1 \ldots s_n)\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath302 \frac{1_{[s_n]}\tau_{n}(s_1 \ldots s_n)}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath303}\tau_{n}(s_1 \ldots s_n)$ ] .
then , eq . ( [ eq : appb_gec1 ] ) is expressed as ; @xmath304 \frac{g_n}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] there exists a small positive value @xmath305 satisfying @xmath306 \frac{g_n}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we can find a randomized policy satisfying @xmath307 \leq -\epsilon\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , let us consider eq .
( [ eq : appb_drift3 ] ) again , which is expressed as ; @xmath308\end{aligned}\ ] ] we minimize the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq : appb_drift3 ] ) , so the following inequality satisfies ; @xmath309 \leq e \bigl [ { { \mathop{a}\limits^{\vbox to -.5\ex@{\kern-\tw@\ex@ \hbox{\scriptsize * } \vss}}}}_{n}(t ) - \frac{{{\mathop{g}\limits^{\vbox to -.5\ex@{\kern-\tw@\ex@ \hbox{\scriptsize * } \vss}}}}_{n}(t)}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } } \nonumber \\ & | \boldsymbol q(t)\bigr]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath310 and @xmath311 are the solutions of a randomized policy . incorporating eq . ( [ eq : appb_randep ] ) in eq . ( [ eq : appb_drift4 ] ) , we have @xmath312 the time average of eq .
( [ eq : appb_drift5 ] ) leads to @xmath313\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath314 this concludes that the time average of the queues are bounded if the arrival rates are inside the capacity region @xmath171 .
now , let us focus on the original claim of theorem [ theorem2 ] .
let us consider a drift+penalty function as ; @xmath315 \leq \nonumber \\ & b + e \bigl
[ \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } q_{n}(t ) \bigl(a_{n}(t ) - \frac{g_{n}(t)}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } } \bigr ) | \boldsymbol q(t)\bigr ] - \nonumber \\ & \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } m e[u_{n , k } ( \lambda_{n , k}(t ) ) | \boldsymbol q(t ) ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] since we set @xmath295 , we have @xmath316 \nonumber \\ &
\leq b + \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } e \bigl [ q_{n}(t ) \bigl(a_{n}(t ) - \frac{g_{n}(t)}{\sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } } \bigr ) | \boldsymbol q(t)\bigr ] - \nonumber \\ & \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } m e[u_{n , k } ( a_{n}(t ) ( \bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } ) | \boldsymbol q(t ) ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that minimizing the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq : appb_dpp1 ] ) corresponds to the flow control and scheduling algorithms of @xmath1 in eq .
( [ eq : flow_control ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : scheduling ] ) , respectively . since there exists a randomized policy satisfying eq .
( [ eq : appb_randep ] ) , eq .
( [ eq : appb_dpp1 ] ) is expressed as @xmath317 \nonumber \\ & \leq b - \epsilon \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } q_{n}(t ) - \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } m u_{n , k}(a_n(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } + \delta ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath318 is the maximum time average of the sum utility function that can be achieved by any control policy that stabilizes the system .
then , the time average of eq .
( [ eq : appb_dpp2 ] ) becomes @xmath319 \biggr \ }
\leq \nonumber \\ & \limsup_{t \rightarrow \infty } \frac{1}{t } \sum_{\tau = 0}^{t-1 } \biggl \ { b - \epsilon \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } q_{n}(\tau ) - \nonumber \\ &
\sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } m u_{n , k } ( a_n(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } + \delta ) \biggr \}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , let us first consider the stability of the queues . if both sides of eq . (
[ eq : appb_dpp3 ] ) is divided by @xmath305 and the terms are arranged , we have @xmath320 \bigr \ } - \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } \frac{m}{\epsilon } u_{n , k } ( a_n(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } + \delta)\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the right hand side is a positive finite value , this concludes that the time averages of the total queue sizes are bounded .
now , let us consider the optimality . if both sides of eq .
( [ eq : appb_dpp3 ] ) are divided by @xmath183 , we have @xmath321 \leq \nonumber \\ & \limsup_{t \rightarrow \infty } \frac{1}{t } \sum_{\tau = 0}^{t-1 } \bigl \ { \frac{b}{m } - \frac{\epsilon}{m } \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } q_{n}(\tau ) - \nonumber \\
& \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } u_{n , k } ( a_n(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } + \delta ) \bigr \}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by arranging the terms , we have @xmath322 \geq \nonumber \\ & \limsup_{t \rightarrow \infty } \frac{1}{t } \sum_{\tau = 0}^{t-1 } \bigl \ { \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } u_{n , k } ( a_n(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } + \delta ) - \frac{b}{m } \nonumber \\ & + \frac{\epsilon}{m } \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } q_{n}(\tau ) \bigr \}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath323 is positive for any @xmath324 , we have @xmath322 \geq \nonumber \\ & \limsup_{t \rightarrow \infty } \frac{1}{t } \sum_{\tau = 0}^{t-1 } \bigl \ { \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } u_{n , k } ( a_n(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } + \delta ) - \frac{b}{m } \bigr \}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which leads to @xmath322 \geq \nonumber \\ & \sum_{n \in { \mathcal{n } } } \sum_{k \in { \mathcal{k}}_{n } } u_{n , k } ( a_n(\bar{p}_{n , k})^{\beta } + \delta ) - \frac{b}{m } \end{aligned}\ ] ] this proves that the admitted flow rates converge to the utility optimal operating point with increasing @xmath183 .
this concludes the proof . | we investigate the performance of first - in , first - out ( fifo ) queues over wireless networks .
we characterize the stability region of a general scenario where an arbitrary number of fifo queues , which are served by a wireless medium , are shared by an arbitrary number of flows . in general
, the stability region of this system is non - convex .
thus , we develop a convex inner - bound on the stability region , which is provably tight in certain cases .
the convexity of the inner bound allows us to develop a resource allocation scheme ; @xmath0 .
based on the structure of @xmath0 , we develop a stochastic flow control and scheduling algorithm ; @xmath1 .
we show that @xmath1 achieves optimal operating point in the convex inner bound .
simulation results show that our algorithms significantly improve the throughput of wireless networks with fifo queues , as compared to the well - known queue - based flow control and max - weight scheduling . |
one of the first steps in any research work is to group objects with common properties ( e.g. shape , weight , color , ... ) .
this taxonomy is a powerful tool in order to understand the physics behind the formation and evolution of the studied objects .
probably the most popular classification of galaxies is based on the shapes or morphologies ( started with * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this first order classification has survived over time since the different morphological classes of galaxies have also different physical properties and probably different evolutionary tracks . in general ,
galaxies can be divided into two main classes : early - types ( hereafter et ) and late - types ( hereafter lt ) .
ets include elliptical and lenticular galaxies , while lts include spirals and irregular galaxies .
ets appear to be a family of objects showing old stellar populations , spheroidal - like dynamical properties and a small fraction of cold gas whereas lts are more gas - rich objects , present younger stellar populations , and are mainly rotation supported .
visual inspection is the traditional way to classify galaxies . by definition , it is subjective and not reproducible , but for bright and extended objects there is a general good agreement between different observers .
they are however time consuming . in the past ,
galaxy samples contained from dozens up to hundreds of galaxies while present galaxy surveys have up to millions of galaxies .
this makes impossible to give detailed morphological classifications unless a large amount of classifiers are involved ( see the galaxy zoo project ; * ? ? ?
* ) . over the past years
, different automated methods of morphological classification of galaxies have been developed .
automated classifications resolve the two main problems raised above .
they provide indeed reproducible information , and the errors can be fully understood by using extensive simulations ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in addition , modern galaxy classification algorithms are able to classify large samples of galaxies in a reasonable amount time .
we usually distinguish between three broad groups of automated galaxy classifications : parametric based on galaxy physical parameters , non - parametric , and parametric based on mathematical parameters .
parametric classifications use parametric models in order to reproduce some galaxy measurements .
one of the most popular parametric methods based on galaxy physical parameters classifies galaxies according to some properties of their structural parameters obtained by fitting the surface brightness ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . on the other side , non - parametric galaxy classifications are based on the measurements of a set of galaxy parameters that correlate with the morphological types .
these methods have the advantage that they assume non - parametric models and can hence classify regular and irregular objects .
several galaxy parameters have been used to discriminate between different morphological types , i.e colours ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , spectral properties ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) , or light distribution ( e.g. * ? ?
? * ; * ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
current works are led to more complex fitting models , using orthonormal mathematical bases to decompose the galaxies , and then correlating the physical properties of the objects with the coefficients of the decomposition by means of a principal component analysis .
this is the case of the shapelets @xcite , or future works with the sersiclets @xcite , and the chefs @xcite .
the main advantage of these latter methods with regard to the former is their flexibility and reliability to reproduce every feature in the galaxies , and then to efficiently model every kind of morphology , including irregular objects .
moreover , they do not need any a priori knowledge and they do not impose any profile to fit the galaxies .
however , these mathematical models are computationally more expensive and the parameters of the final decomposition do not provide any physical information .
alh data will be used for further development of the chefs method ( jimnez et al .
, in preparation ) .
galsvm @xcite provides a generalization of the non - parametric classifications by using an unlimited number of dimensions and providing a probabilistic output following a bayesian approach ( see also @xcite for a similar approach ) .
the algorithm has been shown to be specially useful when dealing with low - resolution and high - redshift data@xcite and has been successfully applied to several large samples at low and high redshift @xcite , including the cosmological evolution survey ( cosmos ; * ? ? ? * ) and sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ?
* ) samples .
+ in this paper we present the morphological classification of a large sample of galaxies from the advanced large homogeneous area medium band redshift astronomical , alhambra survey ( hereafter alh ; see * ? ? ?
* ) , located at different redshifts . taking into account the resolution of alh data ( @xmath01arcsec ) and all the advantages of galsvm code mentioned above , we used this method for our morphological classification .
alh survey imaged @xmath04deg@xmath1 of the sky through 23 optical and near - infrared ( nir ) filters .
the large number of filters provide accurate photometric redshifts by fitting the spectral energy distributions ( hereafter sed ) of the galaxies for about one million sources .
this galaxy sample is ideal in order to study evolutionary properties of galaxies in the last 8 gyr @xcite .
the alhambra survey , data , and sample selection are introduced in sec . [ sec_observations ] .
the methodology used for morphological classification is described in sec .
[ sec_morph_class ] , and the main results are discussed in sec .
[ sec_class_reliability ] , [ sec_final_class ] , and [ sec_prop ] .
finally , appendix [ appendixa_cat ] describes the content of the first published morphological catalogue of galaxies in the alhambra survey .
we assumed the following cosmological parameters throughout the paper : @xmath6=0.7 , @xmath7=0.3 , and h@xmath8=70 km s@xmath9 mpc@xmath9 .
unless otherwise specified , all magnitudes are given in the ab system @xcite .
the alhambra observations were carried out at the calar alto german - spanish astronomical center ( caha ) , under the spanish guaranteed time of 110 nights .
eight fields were observed in the northern hemisphere sky , having a seeing lower than 1.6arcsec ( ranging mainly between 0.8 and 1.2arcsec ) . all fields ( except alh-1 ) have the multiwavelength information available from other ( deep ) extragalactic surveys ( see @xcite and table [ tab_alhambra_obs ] ) .
each alh detection was observed in 23 bands , with 20 optical and three standard @xmath2 nir filters .
optical range is covered in a continuous way from 340 nm to 970 nm , with non - overlapping and equal 30 nm width medium bands @xcite .
this set of optical filters was specially designed for the alh survey to achieve a good accuracy of photometric redshifts of @xmath0@xmath10z/(1+z)=0.015 for galaxies brighter than [email protected] , three times better than the one achieved when using the 4 - 5 filter systems ( for more information see * ? ? ? * ) .
figure [ fig_alh_example ] shows the example of two galaxies observed in all alh bands . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] * [email protected] + * * 22.0@[email protected] we measured the k - corrections by means of the idl routine ` kcorrect ` @xcite .
we implemented all 23 alh filters and their response files into the code , fitting our 23 point sed with about 500 available spectral templates ( see * ? ? ? * for more information about the templates and sed fitting ) .
91% , 98% , and 93% of sources have the difference between the original magnitudes and those recovered from the final kcorrect fits below 0.3 , 0.2 , and 0.2 in three observed bands , respectively ( or 98% , 100% , and 100% if the difference is @xmath50.5 ) , showing a good quality of our k - corrections .
+ we then obtained the rest - frame magnitudes , absolute magnitudes , rest - frame colours , and luminosities of all sources presented in the catalogue we described above .
moreover , from the ` kcorrect ` sed fits we obtained the stellar masses and star - formation histories , using the @xcite stellar initial mass function .
we do not have any mid - infrared ( mir ) nor far - infrared ( fir ) data as an input information for sed fitting , the reddest band we have is @xmath11 .
this means that , following the well known mathematical relation between the observed and rest - frame wavelengths ( 1+z=@xmath12@xmath13/@xmath12@xmath14 ) , we can count with our k - corrections and measured absolute magnitudes and stellar masses down to redshifts @xmath01.3 in all 20 optical bands , and down to @xmath00.8 and @xmath00.4 in the @xmath15 and @xmath16 nir bands , respectively . we compared obtained stellar masses with those measured with bpz code .
the typical scatter between masses is 0.22dex for all @xmath17 classified galaxies , or 0.17dex for ets and 0.21dex for lts .
stellar masses in all alh survey measured with bpz will be released in a companion paper @xcite .
figure [ fig_absmag_stmass_z_morph ] shows the f613w band absolute magnitude - redshift ( left panel ) and stellar mass - redshift ( right panel ) relations of et and lt galaxies ( with [email protected] ) .
notice the lack of ets at higher redshifts which is a consequence of the selection effects discussed in section [ subsec_sel_effects ] .
compared to cosmos / hst data , we trace the same population of late - type galaxies ( see fig . 1 and 2 in tasca et al .
2009 , and fig . 2 in pannella
et al . 2009 ) . however , for et galaxies we are incomplete including lower redshifts .
we can not distinguish et sources from lts fainter than -18.0 or -20.0 in the f613w band at redshifts 0.2 or 0.5 , respectively . in fig .
[ fig_cmr_csmr_morph ] we tested the distributions of our p10 [email protected] et ( red diamonds and solid - lines ) and lt ( blue triangles and dashed - lines ) selected galaxies on standard colour - magnitude and colour - stellar mass diagrams .
we measured the rest - frame colour between the f458w and f892w alh bands , which corresponds to approximately central wavelengths of standard johnson @xmath18 and sdss @xmath19 bands .
this colour is compared with the absolute magnitude in the f458w band ( left panel ) and stellar mass ( right panel ) .
we also present , for both morphological types , the histograms with normalised distributions of corresponding parameters , including also the p10 lt galaxies selected in the magnitude range 22.0@[email protected] . in all diagrams
, we can see a clear bimodal distribution between the red sequence and blue cloud galaxies , widely discussed in the literature ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* are only some of them ) , where the majority of et and lt galaxies are located , respectively .
this bimodal distribution of galaxies on both colour - magnitude and colour - stellar mass diagrams is sometimes used to distinguish between the early- and late - type populations of galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
however , it was showed that a fraction of spirals and irregulars with high extinctions or quenched stellar formations can reside in the red sequence , or earlier - types with bursts of star formation in the blue cloud ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
black horisontal line in fig .
[ fig_cmr_csmr_morph ] shows the regions where 70% of our [email protected] et and lt p10 galaxies lie in the red sequence ( [email protected] ) and in the blue cloud ( [email protected] ; 85% of lt galaxies selected with magnitudes 22.0@[email protected] ) , respectively . through the colour - stellar mass relation in fig .
[ fig_cmr_csmr_morph ] ( left panel ) , we defined the locus where @xmath060% of our et galaxies are located , having b458-z892 colour @xmath31.12 and stellar masses logm / m@[email protected] . on the other side ,
@xmath025% and @xmath010% of [email protected] and 22.0@[email protected] lt galaxies reside in this region .
we presented the morphological classification of @xmath340,000 galaxies in the alhambra survey ( in seven fields ) , classifying all galaxies in two broad morphological classes : early- and late - types . with this paper
we release the low - contamination catalogue of 22,051 galaxies classified with the contamination lower than 10% .
we classified 1,640 and 10,322 early- ( down to redshifts @xmath00.5 ) and late - type ( down to redshifts @xmath01.0 ) galaxies , respectively , with magnitudes [email protected] .
in addition , for magnitude range 22.0@[email protected] we classified other 10,089 late - type galaxies with redshifts @xmath41.3 .
alhambra is a photometric survey , having for all detections observations in 23 optical and nir bands . with a large number of detected sources ( @xmath3670,000 ) down to photometric completeness of sdss @[email protected] , large covered area , and precisely measured photometric redshifts ( obtained through sed fittings of 23 point spectra )
, alhambra is an ideal survey for tracing the cosmic variance and cosmic evolution .
however , morphological properties and classification of galaxies are crucial for any kind of galaxy formation and evolution studies .
low - contamination , high - populated morphological catalogue presented in this paper , together with the precise measured photometric redshifts and photometric properties of the alh survey , present an important addition to other datasets for studying the morphological properties of extragalactic sources and their evolution ( taking into account the variety of covered alh fields ) .
some of these studies include : the evolution of ets and lts down to redshifts @xmath00.5 and @xmath01.3 , respectively , their star - formation histories , morphological properties and evolution of active galaxies and their comparison with non - active galaxies , as well as statistical comparisons between the morphological and sed fitting classifications . using the ground based data , galaxy zoo survey classified morphologicaly @xmath0900,000 galaxies down to redshifts @xmath00.25 @xcite . on the other side ,
cosmos survey provides morphological classification of @xmath3200,000 galaxies @xcite at high - redshifts . with this work we provide the astronomical society with the additional morphological information of @xmath322,000 high - redshift galaxies , but observed in seven different fields which may have an important constraints on cosmic variance and galaxy evolution studies .
+ to select the sample for morphological classification , we first separated galaxies from point - like sources , then we selected sources with good photo - z measurements ( observed in all filters and with bpz_odds parameter @xmath30.2 ) , and finally , we selected sources photometrically , considering only detections with magnitudes @xmath423.0 in the f613w band and photometric errors @xmath50.5 ( to make sure to deal with reliable extended vs. point - like source selections , photometric , and photo - z measurements ) .
the final selected sample has 43,665 sources .
+ we used the galsvm code in our classification , testing the morphology through a sample of 3,000 visually classified local galaxies .
we redshifted these galaxies and scaled them in luminosity , to reproduce the redshift and magnitude distributions of our alh sources .
morphological classification was carried out in the f613w band , the most efficient one of all 20 optical bands , and for six magnitude cuts , down to 23.0 .
for each alh galaxy we measured 7 morphological parameters and the averaged @xmath22 probability that the galaxy is et ( probability that the galaxy is lt is then @xmath23=1-@xmath22 ) , obtained through 15 monte - carlo simulations . +
our classification is calibrated against the cosmos field , using the hst / acs images .
we used this calibration to determine the probability cuts ( in each of six magnitude cuts ) to select et and lt galaxies with the contamination lower than 10% . with the obtained probability cuts
, we can recover @xmath070% of et galaxies down to magnitudes 20.0 , 30 - 40% down to 21.5 , and 20 - 30% down to 22.0 in the f613w band . on the other side , for lt galaxies
, we recover @xmath070% down to magnitudes 22.0 , @xmath060 - 70% , down to 22.5 , and @xmath030% down to 23.0 .
we tested our classification in whole alh survey through different morphological diagrams and general et and lt relations ( e.g. , colour - magnitude and colour - stellar mass diagrams ) , obtaining the expected distributions in all of analysed relations .
+ the complete , low - contamination ( @xmath510% ) catalogue of 22,051 galaxies provides all measured morphological parameters , averaged probabilities , morphological types , magnitudes , physical sizes , and redshifts .
the catalogue is available in the electronic version of this paper and through the alhambra webpage http://alhambrasurvey.com/ , while the description of columns and the small example of five sources are presented in the appendix .
we thank the referee chris lintott for constructive comments which improved the paper significantly .
this research was supported by the junta de andaluca through projects po8-tic-03531 and tic114 , the spanish ministry of economy and competitiveness ( mineco ) through projects aya2006 - 14046 , aya2010 - 15169 , aya2010 - 22111-c03 - 02 , aya2011 - 29517-c03 - 01 , and the generalitat valenciana through project gv / prometeo 2009/064 .
mp acknowledge financial support from jae - doc program of the spanish national research council ( csic ) , co - funded by the european social fund .
based on observations collected at the centro astronmico hispano alemn ( caha ) at calar alto , operated jointly by the max - planck institut fur astronomie and the instituto de astrofsica de andaluca ( csic ) .
the cefca is funded by the fondo de inversiones de teruel , supported by both the government of spain ( 50% ) and the regional government of aragn ( 50% ) . in this work
, we made use of virtual observatory tool for operations on catalogues and tables ( topcat ) .
we thank the developers of ubuntu , python , numpy , scipy , and matplotlib for making their work public and available to all scientific community .
99 abraham , r. g. , van den bergh , s. , nair , p. , 2003 ,
apj , 588 , 218 abraham , r. g. , van den bergh , s. , glazebrook , k. , et al . , 1996 , apjs , 107 , 1 abraham , r. g. , valdes , f. , yee , h. k. c. , & van den bergh , s. 1994 , apj , 432 , 75 aguerri , j. a. l. , iglesias - pramo , j. , vlchez , j. m. , muoz - tun , c. , & snchez - janssen , r. 2005 , aj , 130 , 475 aguerri , j. a. l. , iglesias - paramo , j. , vilchez , j. m. , & muoz - tun , c. 2004 , aj , 127 , 1344 andrae , r. , jahnke , k. , & melchior , p. 2011 , mnras , 411 , 385 andrae , r. , melchior , p. , & jahnke , k. 2011 , mnras , 417 , 2465 aparicio - villegas , t. , et al .
2010 , aj , 139 , 1242 baillard , a. , et al .
2011 , a&a , 532 , 74 baldwin , j. a. , phillips , m. m. , & terlevich , r. 1981 , pasp , 93 , 5 bell , e. f. , et al .
2008 , apj , 682 , 355 bell , e. f. , et al .
2003 , apjs , 149 , 289 bentez , n. , et al .
2013 , in preparation bentez , n. , et al .
2009 , apj , 692l , 5 bentez , n. , et al .
2004 , apjs , 150 , 1 bentez , n. , et al .
2000 , apj , 536 , 571 bershady , m. a. , jangren , a. , & conselice , c. j. 2000 , aj , 119 , 2645 bertin , e. & arnouts , s. , 1996 , a&as , 117 , 393 bertin , e. , sextractor v.13 user s manual blanton , m. r. , et al .
2007 , aj , 133 , 734 casata , p. , et al . 2007 , apjs , 172 , 270 castander , f. j.1998 , ap&ss , 263 , 91 chabrier , g. 2003 , pasp , 115 , 763 coe , d. , bentez , n. , snchez , s. f. , et al .
2006 , aj , 132 , 926 conselice , c. j. , bershady , m. a. , dickinson , m. , & papovich , c. , 2000 , apj , 529 , 886 cristbal - hornillos , d. , et al .
2009 , apj , 696 , 1554 de la torre , s. , et al .
2011 , mnras , 412 , 825 de souza , r. e. , gadotti , d. a. , & dos anjos , s. 2004 , apjs , 153 , 411 de vaucouleurs , g. 1948 , annales dastrophysique , 11 , 247 faber , s. m. , et al .
2007 , apj , 665 , 265 fasano , g. , vanzella , e. , dressler , a. , et al .
2012 , mnras , 420 , 926 fioc , m. & rocca - volmerange , b. , 1997 , a&a , 326 , 950 folkes , s. r. , lahav , o. , & maddox , s. j. 1996 , mnras , 283 , 651 franzetti , p. , et al .
2007 , a&a , 465 , 711 hogg , d. w. , et al .
2003 , apj , 585 , 5 holwerda , b. w. , source extractor for dummies hubble , e.p .
1936 , realm of the nebulae , by e.p .
hubble .
new haven : yale university press , 1936 .
hubble , e.p .
1926 , apj , 64 , 321 huertas - company , m. , et al .
2011 , a&a , 525 , 157 huertas - company , m. , et al .
2009 , a&a , 497 , 743 huertas - company , m. , et al .
2008 , a&a , 478 , 971 huertas - company , m. , rouan , d. , soucail , g. , et al .
2007 , a&a , 468 , 937 humason , m. l. 1931 , apj , 74 , 35 husillos , c. , et al .
2013 , in preparation ilbert , o. , et al .
2010 , apj , 709 , 644 jimnez - teja , y. & bentez , n. 2012 , apj , 745 , 150 kelly , b.c .
& mckay , t.a .
2004 , apj , 127 , 625 kelly , b.c . & mckay , t.a .
2005 , aj , 129 , 1287 labb , i. , et al .
2003 , aj , 125 , 1107 lintott , c. j. , schawinski , k. , slosar , a. , et al .
2008 , mnras , 389 , 1179 lintott , c. j. , schawinski , k. , slosar , a. , et al .
2011 , mnras , 410 , 166 lotz , j. m. , primack , j. , madau , p. , 2004 ,
aj , 128 , 163 matute , i. et al .
2012 , a&a , 542 , 20 melbourne , j. et al .
2007 , apj , 660 , 81 mndez - abreu , j. , aguerri , j. a. l. , corsini , e. m. , & simonneau , e. 2008 , a&a , 478 , 353 moles , m. , et al .
2008 , aj , 136 , 1325 molino , a. , et al .
2013 , submitted to mnras ( astro - ph1306.4968 ) morgan , w. w. , & mayall , n. u. 1957 , pasp , 69 , 291 nair , p. b. & abraham , r. , 2010 , apjs , 186 , 427 ngan , w. et al .
, 2009 , mnras , 396,1211 oke , j. b. & gunn , j. e. 1983 , apj , 266 , 713 oteo , i. , et al . 2013 , arxiv1302.2327o oteo , i. , et al .
2013 , submitted to mnras pannella , m. , et al .
2009 , apj , 701 , 787 peng , c. j. , et al .
2010 , aj , 139 , 2097 peng , c. j. , et al .
2002 , aj , 124 , 266 povi , m. , et al .
2012 , a&a , 541 , 118 prieto , m. , aguerri , j. a. l. , varela , a. m. , & muoz - tun , c. 2001 , a&a , 367 , 405 prieto , m. , gottesman , s. t. , aguerri , j .- a .
l. , & varela , a .- m .
1997 , aj , 114 , 1413 reynolds , j. h. 1920 , mnras , 80 , 746 snchez almeida , j. , aguerri , j. a. l. , muoz - tun , c. , & de vicente , a. 2010 , apj , 714 , 487 scarlata , c. , carollo , c. m. , lilly , s. , et al .
2007 , apjs , 172 , 406 scoville , n. , et al .
2007 , apjs , 172 , 1 srsic , j. l. , 1963 , baaa , 6 , 41 simard , l. , et al .
2011 , apjs , 196 , 11 simard , l. , willmer , c. n. a. , vogt , n. p. , et al .
2002 , apjs , 142 , 1 strateva , i. , et al .
2001 , aj , 122 , 1861 tasca , l. a. m. , et al .
2009 , a&a , 503 , 379 trujillo , i. , aguerri , j. a. l. , gutirrez , c. m. , & cepa , j. 2001 , aj , 122 , 38 vogt , n. p. , et al .
2005 , apjs , 159 , 41 williams , r. j. , et al .
2009 , apj , 691 , 1879 wuyts , s. , et al .
2008 , apj , 682 , 985
in this section , we describe the high - quality , two - class morphological catalogue in the alhambra survey , with the total contamination lower than 10% .
catalogue contains morphological , photometric , size , and photometric redshift information of 22,051 galaxies . of those , 1,640 and 20,411
were classified as early- and late - types , down to magnitudes 22.0 and 23.0 and photometric redshifts of @xmath00.5 and @xmath01.3 , respectively .
table [ tab_general_morph ] shows an example of the format and content of the catalogue for five sources .
the catalogue is available in the electronic addition of this paper or through the alhambra website http://alhambrasurvey.com/. the column entries are as follows : c c c c c c c * id*&*field_p_ccd*&*id_phot*&*id_zphot*&*ra ( degrees)*&*dec ( degrees)*&*flags * + * m@xmath24*&*errm@xmath24*&*m@xmath25*&*errm@xmath25*&*m@xmath26*&*errm@xmath26*&*logr50 ( kpc ) * + * logr90 ( kpc)*&*mumean*&*ellipticity*&*asym*&*cabr*&*gini*&*smooth * + * m20*&*ccon*&*@xmath22_avg*&*err@xmath22_avg*&*class*&*redshift * & + 1 & alh2_p1_ccd1 & 8895&81421100234&37.43648 & 1.264531&0 + 23.0&0.098&22.04&0.022&21.067 & 0.084&0.723 + 0.985&24.5309&0.2143&0.2686&0.3075&0.532&0.0 + -1.2281&2.1533&0.3034&0.0417<&0.666 & + & & & & & + 2 & alh2_p1_ccd1 & 9202&81421100256&37.523216&1.263539&2 + 23.565&0.231&22.411 & 0.04 & 21.052 & 0.125&0.971 + 1.356&25.5367&0.4043&0.8212&0.2458&0.4558&0.633 + -0.9595&2.3292&0.4649&0.1535<&0.598 & + & & & & & + 3 & alh2_p1_ccd1 & 9353&81421100262&37.532192&1.263552&2 + 23.033&0.122&22.323 & 0.032&21.524 & 0.16&0.879 + 1.125&25.3686&0.1158&0.0211&0.2054&0.4731&0.0 + -0.9625&1.8086&0.3041&0.0437<&0.681 & + & & & & & + 4 & alh2_p1_ccd1 & 9453&81421100274&37.582558&1.262976&0 + 22.042&0.069&20.741 & 0.012&19.914 & 0.056&0.749 + 1.094&24.1509&0.1518&0.1118&0.3918&0.5719&0.1679 + -1.4883&2.6371&0.8955&0.0948&et&0.421 & + & & & & & + 5 & alh2_p1_ccd1 & 8568&81421100275&37.398445&1.263138&2 + 22.036&0.051&21.104 & 0.012&20.657 & 0.079&0.564 + 0.876&24.0459&0.4405&0.053&0.3176&0.5584&0.1136 + -1.5274&2.2498&0.138&0.0389<&0.258 & + * column 1 ( i d ) : identification number . *
column 2 ( field_p_ccd ) : alhambra field , pointing , and ccd
. * column 3 ( id_phot ) : identification number in the photometric catalogue @xcite ; equal to number parameter in the original catalogue . *
column 4 ( id_zphot ) : identification number in the photometric redshift catalogue @xcite ; equal to i d parameter in the original catalogue . * columns 5 and 6 ( ra , dec ) : equinox j2000.0 right ascension and declination in degrees of the centroid .
* column 7 ( flags ) : sextractor flag parameter @xcite contained in the photometric catalogue . *
columns 8 and 9 ( m@xmath24 , errm@xmath24 ) : apparent magnitude in the f458w band and its error . * columns 10 and 11 ( m@xmath25 , errm@xmath25 ) : apparent magnitude in the f613w band and its error .
* columns 12 and 13 ( m@xmath26 , errm@xmath26 ) : apparent magnitude in the f892w band and its error .
* column 14 ( logr50 ) : logarithm of radius at 50% of flux in kpc .
* column 15 ( logr90 ) : logarithm of radius at 90% of flux in kpc .
* column 16 ( mumean ) : mean surface brightness measured by galsvm .
* column 17 ( ellipticity ) : ellipticity parameter measured by sextractor .
* column 18 ( asym ) : asymmetry index measured by galsvm , defined as in @xcite .
* column 19 ( cabr ) : abraham concentration index , measured by galsvm and defined as in @xcite .
* column 20 ( gini ) : gini coefficient measured by galsvm and defined as in @xcite .
* column 21 ( smooth ) : smoothness of the source , measured by galsvm and defined as in @xcite .
* column 22 ( m20 ) : moment of light at 20% , measured by galsvm and defined as in @xcite . *
column 23 ( ccon ) : conselice - bershady concentration index , measured by galsvm and defined as in @xcite . * columns 24 and 25 ( @xmath22_avg and err@xmath22_avg ) : averaged probability that the galaxy is et , and its error .
the probability is measured from other 15 probabilities ( see sec .
[ subsec_galsvm_config_classifiaction ] ) .
it takes values from 0 to 1 , where small values indicate that the galaxy is lt .
we measure @xmath23 probability as @xmath23=1-@xmath22 .
* column 26 ( class ) : final morphological class , after applying the probability cuts described in sec .
[ sec_class_reliability ] . *
column 27 ( redshift ) : photometric redshift @xcite | alhambra is a photometric survey designed to trace the cosmic evolution and cosmic variance .
it covers a large area of @xmath04deg@xmath1 in 8 fields , where 7 fields overlap with other surveys , allowing to have complementary data in other wavelengths .
all observations were carried out in 20 continuous , medium band ( 30 nm width ) optical and 3 near - infrared ( @xmath2 ) bands , providing the precise measurements of photometric redshifts .
in addition , morphological classification of galaxies is crucial for any kind of galaxy formation and cosmic evolution studies , providing the information about star formation histories , their environment and interactions , internal perturbations , etc .
we present a morphological classification of @xmath340,000 galaxies in the alhambra survey .
we associate to every galaxy a probability to be early - type using the automated bayesian code galsvm . despite of the spatial resolution of the alhambra images ( @xmath01arcsec ) , for 22,051 galaxies we obtained the contamination by other type of less than 10% . of those ,
1,640 and 10,322 galaxies are classified as early- ( down to redshifts @xmath00.5 ) and late - type ( down to redshifts @xmath01.0 ) , respectively , with magnitudes [email protected] .
in addition , for magnitude range 22.0@[email protected] we classified other 10,089 late - type galaxies with redshifts @xmath41.3 .
we show that the classified objects populate the expected regions in the colour - mass and colour - magnitude planes .
the presented dataset is especially attractive given the homogeneous multi wavelength coverage available in the alhambra fields , and is intended to be used in a variety of scientific applications .
the low - contamination catalogue ( @xmath510% ) is made publicly available with the present paper .
[ firstpage ] surveys ; galaxies : fundamental parameters ; galaxies : statistics ; |
the number of candidates for tidal disruption events ( tdes ) , in which stars are tidally disrupted by a massive black hole , has been rapidly increasing ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) .
various stellar types can be considered , including a main sequence star , a red giant star , and a white dwarf ( wd ) .
so far , several high energy transients have been proposed to be tdes of wds ( wd tdes ) @xcite . among various implications ,
finding wd tdes is of special importance to address the existence of an intermediate mass black hole ( imbh ) a black hole ( bh ) disrupting a wd can be an imbh .
this is because a supermassive bh ( smbh ) with more than @xmath6 just swallows a wd rather than disrupts it .
wd tdes can thus be an important probe to imbhs , since a large number of wd tdes may be detected with the aid of current transient surveys ( e.g. , intermediate palomar transient factory ) and next - generation transient surveys ( e.g. the zwicky transient facility and the large synoptic survey telescope ) . in the future , the detections of wd tdes could constrain the abundance of imbhs in the universe , although just a few imbh candidates have ever been discovered by x - ray observatories , e.g. , m82 x-1 @xcite and hlx-1 @xcite . the abundance of imbhs will place constraints on the formation scenarios of smbhs .
a wd tde can probably be observed as various types of transients .
we focus on the possibility of the wd tde observed as an optical transient resulting from its thermonuclear explosion , although there are many studies for possible signatures of wd tdes as other types of transients @xcite . in a wd
tde , the wd is heated by compression in the direction perpendicular to the orbital plane .
hereafter , the direction perpendicular to the orbital plane is called the @xmath7-direction
. then , the wd could undergo explosive nuclear burning , yielding radioactive nuclei such as @xmath8ni . .
@xcite studied wd tdes and their nucleosynthesis signatures .
using rosswog et al.s data of @xmath9 carbon - oxygen ( co ) wd , @xcite predicted the light curve and spectrum of the wd tde . to initiate explosive nuclear burning in a wd tde , not only an adiabatic compression but also a shock heating are required in order to reach high temperature .
as seen in figure [ fig : dens - entr ] , a material consisting of helium ( he ) , co , or oxygen - neon - magnesium ( onemg ) needs to be adiabatically compressed by more than four orders of magnitude to rise its temperature from @xmath4 k to @xmath10 k ( he ) , or @xmath11 k ( co and onemg ) , above which the explosive nuclear burning is triggered .
however , it is difficult to compress a wd by more than four orders of magnitude . as seen from figure 1 of @xcite , @xmath12 , which is the ratio of the tidal radius of the wd to a pericenter distance between the wd and imbh ,
is permitted up to about @xmath13 .
the scale height of the wd in the @xmath7-direction , @xmath14 , is estimated as @xmath15 at the pericenter , where @xmath16 is the original radius of the wd .
therefore , the wd is compressed by at most a factor of @xmath17 .
furthermore , we overestimate the compression of the wd in the above discussion , since the wd is not only compressed in the @xmath7-direction , but also elongated in the direction of the orbital plane . an additional heating by the shock wave is therefore required for initiating the nuclear reactions , however it is not clear whether previous simulations have high resolution enough to detect such a shock wave . @xcite
have performed smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) simulations with up to @xmath18 million particles . since more than
@xmath19 particles are aligned in the @xmath7-direction , these simulations seem to resolve the shock wave
. however , the wd is elongated in the direction of the orbital plane , and the number of particles in the @xmath7-direction should be fewer than @xmath19 , where the shock front should be perpendicular to the @xmath7-direction @xcite . @xcite
have performed mesh - based simulations for a wd tde of @xmath9 co wd encountered by a @xmath20 imbh with @xmath21 , and have suggested that explosive nuclear burning is triggered at the pericenter passage .
if the original radius of the wd is @xmath22 cm , the scale height of the wd in the @xmath7-direction , @xmath14 should be @xmath23 cm .
on the other hand , the finest mesh size of their simulation is about @xmath2 cm , larger than @xmath14 . in this paper , we perform high - resolution simulations of wd tdes .
we aim to investigate whether these simulations accurately follow a thermonuclear explosion in wd tdes , and what is numerically required to follow the explosion .
this paper is structured as follows . in section [
sec : method ] , we describe our simulation method . in section [ sec : result ] , we present the simulation results . in section [ sec : discussion ] , we discuss in detail the reason why the nuclear burning falsely occurs in 3d sph simulations with low resolution . in sections [ sec : summary ] , we summarize this paper .
in this section , we describe our simulation method .
we overview our sph code in section [ sec : code ] .
we then describe setup of 3d sph simulations in section [ sec:3dinit ] , and of 1d simulations in section [ sec:1dinit ] .
our sph code solves the vanilla ice sph equations .
we adopt wendland @xmath24 kernel for the sph kernel interpolation @xcite .
our sph code is applicable to 3d and 1d planar geometry .
the number of neighbor particles of a given particle is about @xmath25 ( 3d ) and about @xmath26 ( 1d ) unless otherwise specified .
neighbor particles are defined as particles which are inside a sphere centered at a given particle with its kernel - support radius , where the sph kernel function reaches zero at the kernel - support radius .
we choose artificial viscosity proposed by @xcite .
the artificial viscosity is dependent on the strength of a shock wave @xcite .
the viscosity from shear motion is suppressed by balsara switch @xcite .
we calculate self gravity among sph particles with adaptive gravitational softening @xcite .
we optimize the sph and self - gravity calculations on distributed - memory systems , using fdps @xcite and explicit avx instructions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we use the helmholtz equation of state ( eos ) with ( or without ) coulomb corrections @xcite , which considers partially relativistic and partially degenerate electrons including electron - positron pairs , ions , radiation , and coulomb interactions .
we include nuclear reactions with aprox13 @xcite which solves @xmath27 and @xmath28 links as well as the @xmath29-chain reaction network .
the nuclear reactions are solved implicitly if a particle has high density ( @xmath30 g @xmath31 ) and high temperature ( @xmath32 k ) , and otherwise solved explicitly .
we can avoid overheating and overcooling with this implicit method , even if we use a large timestep , say @xmath33 s s in the explicit method , in order to avoid the overcooling of photo disintegration . ] .
we adopt the routines to calculate the helmholtz eos and aprox13 developed by the center for astrophysical thermonuclear flashes at the university of chicago .
we follow the evolution of wd tdes by means of our sph code coupled with the nuclear reaction network .
we adopt sph modeling for the wds , and use a fixed potential to model the imbh gravity . for the imbh potential ,
we adopt three kinds of models : newtonian potential ( np ) , the paczyski - wiita ( pw ) potential with the modification by @xcite , and a generalized newtonian potential obtained by @xcite , hereafter called tr potential , for the treatment of a bh with no spin ( see also @xcite for the treatment of a spinning bh ) . the imbh is located on the coordinate origin .
none of them considers the imbh spin .
our initial conditions are summarized in table [ tab : initial ] .
we relax the configurations of particles for these wds in the same way as @xcite ( see also * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these wds have no spin .
we change the number of particles for the wds , @xmath0 , from a few @xmath1 up to a few @xmath2 .
the parameter set of model co1 is the same as run 8 of @xcite .
however , the wd radii might be different between theirs and ours due to different ways to make initial conditions .
this might make a difference between the pericenter distance of wds in rosswog s run 8 and in our model co1 , although @xmath34 in both models . additionally , we investigate three models .
the first and second ones are the same as models onemg and co1 , respectively , except without solving a nuclear reaction network .
we call these models `` onemg w / o nuc '' and `` co1 w / o nuc ''
. the third one is the same as model onemg , except that the number of neighbor particles is set to be proportional to @xmath35 , which is called `` onemg - h '' .
this proportionality means that the kernel - support radii of particles are equal among different @xmath0 models if the density of the particles is equal .
note the kernel - support radii are proportional to @xmath36 if the number of neighbor particles is fixed .
the wd in each simulation approaches the imbh on a parabolic orbit .
the initial separation between the wd and imbh is set at 8 times the tidal radius of the wd , where the tidal radii are @xmath37 cm for models co , @xmath38 cm for model he , and @xmath39 cm for model onemg .
our simulations follow the evolution of these wd tdes for @xmath40 s for models co , @xmath41 s for model he , and @xmath42 s for model onemg . at the end of the simulations ,
nuclear reactions have already ceased .
llllllllllll onemg & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & @xmath19 & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & @xmath47o @xmath40% @xmath48ne @xmath49% @xmath50 mg @xmath26% & w/ & pw & up to @xmath51 m + co1 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57c @xmath58% @xmath47o @xmath58% & w / o & np & up to @xmath59 m & rosswog s run 8 + co2 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57c @xmath58% @xmath47o @xmath58% & w/ & tr & up to @xmath59 m + co3 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57c @xmath58% @xmath47o @xmath58% & w/ & pw & up to @xmath60 m + he & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath63 & @xmath64he @xmath19% & w/ & pw & up to @xmath60 m + we construct 1d initial conditions , by extracting 1d flow structure in the @xmath7-direction from the results of model onemg w / o nuc in the 3d sph simulations .
details are described in section [ sec:1d ] .
using these initial conditions , we perform 1d sph simulations , and flash simulations . since the 1d sph numerical methods are the same as the 3d sph simulations except for the dimension , we overview the flash simulations here .
the flash code @xcite is an eulerian code .
we adopt uniform mesh , although the flash code supports adaptive mesh refinement .
we choose the piecewise parabolic method @xcite for the gas hydrodynamic solver .
we use the helmholtz eos and nuclear reactions with aprox13 , which are also used for our sph simulations .
the timestep is chosen to be the minimum value of the hydrodynamics timestep and nuclear reaction timestep .
the hydrodynamics timestep is 10 % of the courant - friedrichs - lewy number , and the nuclear reaction timestep is 1 % of the ratio of the specific internal energy to the specific nuclear energy - generation rate .
we describe the 1d initial conditions in section [ sec:1d ] .
note that we make the 1d initial conditions , based on the results of the 3d sph simulations ( which is described in section [ sec:3d ] ) .
in section [ sec:3d ] , we present the results of our 3d sph simulations .
the results show that the amount of the materials experiencing explosive nuclear burning is decreased with increasing @xmath0 , and that the explosive nuclear burning found in these simulations is a numerical artifact due to low resolution , not physical effects .
furthermore , we do not find shock waves in our 3d sph simulations .
the absence of the shock waves may be also due to low mass resolution , even if @xmath3 . in order to fix this problem ,
we perform 1d simulations with high resolution , by extracting data from the 3d sph simulations .
we show the results in section [ sec:1d ] . in figure [
fig : n - element ] , we summarize the masses of the original , si group , and fe group elements at the time just after nuclear reactions have ceased .
mass accreted by an imbh at this time is negligible .
the difference in the nuclear burning products does not come from mass accretion , but comes from the nuclear reactions . in model onemg ,
the amount of original ( unburned ) elements increases , and the amounts of si and fe group elements decrease , with increasing @xmath0 . in models
co , the amount of si group elements decreases monotonically with increasing @xmath0 .
although the amount of the original elements decreases first , it finally increases from some @xmath0 .
the dependence of fe group on @xmath0 is opposite to that of the original elements . in model
he , the dependence of each element on @xmath0 is similar to those of models co , although the dependence is smaller .
overall , the amount of unburned materials increases at large @xmath0 ( say @xmath65 ) regardless of the wd masses and compositions .
since the nucleosynthesis of model onemg indicates the strongest dependence on @xmath0 , we show thermodynamical quantities of model onemg in figure [ fig : xyplane_onemg ] . at the time , nuclear reactions are still in progress .
the density of particles is not sensitive to @xmath0 ( see the top panels ) . on the other hand ,
their temperature strongly depends on @xmath0 ( see the second top panels ) . high - temperature ( say @xmath66 k ) region becomes smaller as @xmath0 increases .
as the high - temperature region becomes smaller , the amount of the unburned materials increases ( see the second bottom panels ) , and the amount of @xmath8ni decreases ( see the bottom panels ) , since the materials consisting of onemg experience explosive nuclear burning at a temperature above @xmath67 k. figure [ fig : xzplane_onemg ] shows the structure of model onemg on a plane perpendicular to the orbital plane . although most of the materials are burned out for @xmath68 m , the kernel - support radius is comparable to the scale height of the structure in the @xmath7-direction . for @xmath69 m , only a small portion of the wd experiences nuclear reactions .
however , the scale height of the small portion is comparable to the kernel - support radius .
a large portion of the wd , where the scale height is much larger than the kernel - support radius , is not burned .
overall , the kernel - support radius becomes sufficiently smaller than the scale height as @xmath0 increases .
instead , nuclear reactions become inactive .
the nuclear reactions occur only when the sph simulations do not resolve the scale height of the structure in the @xmath7-direction .
therefore , we conclude that nuclear reactions artificially occur due to numerical effects , not due to physical effects , even if @xmath0 is a few @xmath2 .
we investigate model onemg w / o nuc in order to confirm that nuclear reactions falsely occur , not due to any errors in our nuclear reaction network , but due to the resolution effect of our sph simulations .
figure [ fig : xyplane_onemg.wonuc ] shows thermodynamical quantities of model onemg w / o nuc on the orbital plane .
the density distributions are similar to those in model onemg .
the temperature distributions are different from those in model onemg .
overall , the temperature in this model is lower than in model onemg , since the nuclear reaction network is turned off .
the distribution of the maximum temperature each particle experiences from @xmath70 s to @xmath71 s is a good indicator for where explosive nuclear burning would occur from @xmath70 s to @xmath71 s if the nuclear reaction network was turned on .
materials which reach a temperature of @xmath67 k experience explosive nuclear burning if their density is more than several @xmath72 g @xmath31 .
therefore , explosive nuclear burning would occur in red regions .
these red regions are almost coincident with the regions where original components are burned out and a large amount of @xmath8ni is produced in model onemg ( see figure [ fig : xyplane_onemg ] ) .
moreover , these red regions shrink as @xmath0 increases , which is consistent with the results in model onemg .
figure [ fig : xzplane_onemg.wonuc ] shows the temperature distributions on cross sections in model onemg w / o nuc .
the locations of the cross sections are the same as those in model onemg . in @xmath68 m
, temperature is more than @xmath67 k almost in the region .
therefore , explosive nuclear burning would occur .
the kernel - support radii are comparable to the scale heights over all the range of @xmath73-coordinate . as @xmath0 increases ,
the kernel - support radii becomes smaller , and the temperature becomes lower . in @xmath69 m , the kernel - support radii at @xmath74 cm are smaller than the scale height by a factor of a few , and the temperature is lower than @xmath22 k. explosive nuclear burning would not occur there . at @xmath75 cm ,
the kernel - support radii are comparable to the scale height , and the temperature is more than @xmath76 k. explosive nuclear burning would occur .
these results are consistent with those in model onemg .
therefore , explosive nuclear burning in model onemg occurs when sph simulations fail to resolve the scale heights of wd tdes .
in other words , nuclear reactions seen in the low - resolution runs are a numerical artifact due to spurious heating of sph simulation .
we comment the reasons why a leading part of the wd remains high temperature with increasing @xmath0 , and why a trailing part of the wd gets lower temperature with increasing @xmath0 ( see the bottom panels of figure [ fig : xyplane_onemg.wonuc ] ) . at the pericenter passage ,
the leading part is closer to an imbh than the trailing part .
the leading part has smaller scale height than the trailing part .
our sph simulations almost resolve the scale height of the trailing part unless @xmath77 ( see figure [ fig : xzplane_onemg.wonuc ] ) .
however , our sph simulations fail to resolve the scale height of the leading part , even if @xmath3 .
consequently , the leading part gets high temperature , even if @xmath3 .
there is another evidence that the nuclear reactions occur only when the kernel - support radii of particles are comparable to the scale height of the structure . in model onemg - h ,
the kernel - support radii do not become smaller by design even if @xmath0 increases .
figure [ fig : n - element ] shows that the nucleosynthesis of model onemg - h is much less sensitive to @xmath0 than that of model onemg . finally , we search for shock waves in model onemg w / o nuc , focusing on regions where the sph kernel is smaller than the scale height .
however we find no shock wave .
if the shock waves were generated , temperature would increase discontinuously in the @xmath7-direction .
however , we do not find such a temperature structure , for example in the right panel of figure [ fig : xzplane_onemg.wonuc ] .
we do not find shock waves in model onemg w / o nuc , despite the fact that sph kernel - support radii are smaller than the scale height ( see the right panel of figure [ fig : xzplane_onemg.wonuc ] ) .
we suspect that the absence of the shock waves is due to the low resolution of our simulations , even with @xmath78 . in order to clarify the issue , we perform 1d planar simulations with high resolution , by extracting local flow structures from model onemg w / o nuc with @xmath69 m . for the 1d planar simulations ,
we use our 1d sph code and flash code .
we make initial conditions for the 1d simulations as follows .
we re - perform 3d sph simulations in order to record physical quantities of particles at every timestep .
the recorded particles are located at regions pointed by white crosses in the rightmost panel of figure [ fig : xyplane_onemg.wonuc ] . from bottom to top , particles get higher temperature .
so , we call these regions `` low - t region '' , `` middle - t region '' , and `` high - t region '' from bottom to top . from the recorded data in each region , we extract physical quantities at the moment when @xmath7-direction relative velocities between the outermost particle and a particle on the orbital plane reaches a peak .
based on distribution of density and velocity of the extracted data along the @xmath7-direction , we map particles for 1d simulations , and assign physical quantities for 1d mesh .
we fix the temperature to be @xmath2 k. for the flash simulations , we put atmosphere with a constant density of @xmath79 g @xmath31 if there is no wd material .
the total mass of atmosphere is negligible , ( @xmath80 % of the total mass of wd materials ) .
we describe the recipe of the 1d sph and flash simulations in the following .
we consider only hydrodynamics for both 1d sph and flash simulations .
we do not solve nuclear reactions unless otherwise specified .
furthermore , neither do we consider self gravity among particles , nor the imbh gravity .
the number of particles we use is @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath1 for the 1d sph simulations .
the number of grids we use is @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
note that the space resolution in the largest @xmath0 and @xmath86 is @xmath87 cm and @xmath88 cm for the 1d sph and flash simulations , respectively . in some cases of @xmath89 , we perform additional simulations , solving hydrodynamics coupled with the nuclear reaction network . in the cases of the low - t and high - t regions ,
we perform additional 1d sph simulations with @xmath90 and flash simulations with @xmath89 . in these simulations
, we change the initial @xmath7-direction velocity by increasing the @xmath7-direction velocity for the low - t region , and by decreasing the @xmath7-direction velocity for the high - t region , so that density at @xmath91 in 1d simulations is equal to that in 3d simulations when materials are most compressed .
the reason for this additional setups is the following .
we underestimate and overestimate the compression of materials in the low - t and high - t regions , respectively , without the correction of the @xmath7-direction velocity ( hereafter , @xmath92 correction ) .
these underestimate and overestimate come from the facts that we do not consider an imbh and self gravity , and that materials are not elongated in the direction of the orbital plane in these 1d simulations , respectively .
figure [ fig : sim1d ] shows the results of the 1d simulations .
we set the initial time ( i.e. @xmath70 s ) to be the time when these 1d simulations are started .
for the low - t region with @xmath81 , the temperature on the orbital plane becomes high due to the spurious heating .
actually , the spurious heating is seen in the results of low - resolution simulations , i.e. the 1d sph simulations with @xmath81 and the flash simulations with @xmath83 ( see figure [ fig : flash ] ) , regardless of the regions .
this is consistent with our 3d sph simulations in section [ sec:3d ] .
as seen in figure [ fig : sim1d ] , the results of the 1d sph simulations are in good agreement with those of flash simulations , if the simulations have high resolution , i.e. the 1d sph simulations with @xmath90 and the flash simulations with @xmath89 . for this comparison , atmosphere should be ignored .
furthermore , we investigate the convergence of these results against @xmath0 and @xmath86 . comparing the results of @xmath93 and @xmath1 in the 1d sph simulations , and those of @xmath94 and @xmath85 in the flash simulations , we find these results are quite similar .
therefore , these results are converged against @xmath0 and @xmath86 . as seen in the high - resolution results of figure [ fig : sim1d ] , in all the regions ,
shock waves are observed . in order to investigate whether these shock waves trigger detonation waves , we perform flash simulations coupled with the nuclear reaction network for the middle - t region .
we consider two cases where materials consist of co and onemg .
fluid motion for the co and onemg cases is the same as fluid motion for the case without considering nuclear reactions until a shock wave emerges at @xmath95 s. the middle - t panels of figure [ fig : sim1d ] show the fluid motion in the case without considering nuclear reactions . at @xmath70
s , all the materials shrink . at @xmath96 s , materials at @xmath97 cm bounce back . at @xmath95
s , a shock wave is generated at @xmath98 cm . at this time , materials at @xmath99 cm are expanding , and the rest are shrinking .
the fraction of the expanding materials is @xmath100 % .
we emphasize that the shrinking materials ( i.e. @xmath101 % of materials ) are not atmosphere .
figure [ fig : det_extt ] shows the time evolution of @xmath7-direction velocity , density , temperature , and mass fractions of nuclear elements for the two cases after the shock wave emerges at @xmath102 s. for both the cases , the shock waves which emerges at @xmath103 s proceed in the positive @xmath7-direction ( see panels ( a ) and ( b ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) .
hereafter , a shock wave proceeding in the positive @xmath7-direction is referred as `` forward shock wave '' . only for the co case
, a reverse shock wave emerges at @xmath104 cm , which can be seen as the discontinuous decrease of @xmath7-direction velocity ( see figure [ fig : det_extt_zoom ] and panel ( a ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) .
the reverse shock wave is formed , such that materials behind the reverse shock wave experience explosive nuclear burning ( see panels ( g ) and ( i ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) , get high temperature ( see panel ( e ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) , rapidly expand , and push back materials in front of the reverse shock wave .
the forward shock wave for the co case has higher velocity than for the onemg case , since the former is energized by more active nuclear reactions than the latter . in the following three reasons ,
we conclude that the reverse shock wave accompanies a detonation wave standing at @xmath105 cm .
first , upstream materials flow across @xmath105 cm at a speed of @xmath106 cm s@xmath107 ( see panel ( a ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) , which is larger than the sound velocity of the upstream materials ( @xmath108 cm s@xmath107 ) .
second , co elements are burned out , and si and fe group elements are synthesized just behind @xmath109 cm ( see panels ( g ) and ( i ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) .
third , this fluid structure is long - lived .
it does not decay during the simulation , although we only perform the simulation until @xmath110 s due to high calculation cost of the nuclear reaction network . from @xmath95
s to @xmath111 s , @xmath112 % of materials flow across @xmath105 cm .
after they experience explosive nuclear burning , they consist of @xmath113 % fe group elements , @xmath13 % si group elements , and @xmath18 % he .
if we continue the simulation , the detonation wave will be sustained until at least @xmath114 s in the following reason .
materials flow supersonically across @xmath109 cm from @xmath102 s to @xmath114 s in the case without considering nuclear reactions
. this should be also true in the co case if the detonation wave stands at @xmath109 cm during this time .
this is because upstream materials of the detonation wave should not receive the influence of nuclear reactions due to their supersonic motions .
then , for the co case , materials should flow supersonically into the detonation wave , experience explosive nuclear burning , and sustain the detonation wave as fuels . during this time
, more than @xmath58 % of materials should flow across the detonation wave .
we expect a large amount of radioactive nuclei is synthesized .
there is only the single detonation wave at @xmath105 cm ; the forward shock wave at @xmath115 s and @xmath116 cm does not accompany a detonation wave ( see the left panels of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) .
we explain the reason for the formation of only the single detonation wave at @xmath105 cm .
the forward shock wave creates a hotspot at @xmath102 s and @xmath117 cm .
the hotspot may possibly initiates double detonation waves initially ; one is the detonation wave standing at @xmath118 cm after @xmath95 s , and the other may be a detonation wave which follows the forward shock wave creating the hotspot .
the former detonation wave is sustained by high - density fuels ( @xmath119 g @xmath31 ) , while the latter detonation wave may soon decay due to the supply of only low - density fuels ( @xmath120 g @xmath31 ) , as seen in panel ( c ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] . for the convergence check of a space resolution
, we also perform flash simulations with a space resolution of @xmath121 cm to @xmath122 cm for the middle - t region in the co case .
we find the same detonation wave as in a space resolution of @xmath88 cm only when the space resolution is @xmath5 cm .
therefore , we need simulation with a space resolution of @xmath5 cm in order to follow such a detonation wave . for the onemg case , the forward shock wave raises the temperature of materials to @xmath123 k ( see panel ( f ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) , and triggers nuclear reactions slightly ( see panels ( h ) and ( j ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) .
however , the nuclear reactions cease soon
. the forward shock wave does not excite explosive nuclear burning triggering a reverse shock wave and a detonation wave ( see panel ( b ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] )
. a forward shock wave does not always excite explosive nuclear burning triggering a reverse shock wave and a detonation wave even when materials consist of co. we also perform a flash simulation coupled with the nuclear reaction network for the low - t region with @xmath92 correction in which materials consist of co. figure [ fig : det_lowt ] shows the time evolution . at @xmath124 s , a forward shock wave emerges at @xmath125 cm ( see the top panel of figure [ fig : det_lowt ] ) .
the forward shock wave raises the temperature of the materials ( see the bottom panel of figure [ fig : det_lowt ] ) .
it triggers nuclear reactions , however does not initiate a reverse shock wave nor a detonation wave as seen in the top panel of figure [ fig : det_lowt ] .
this is quite similar to the onemg case in the middle - t region ( see panels ( b ) and ( f ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) .
the initiation of a detonation wave strongly depends on where a forward shock wave emerges .
figure [ fig : diff_lowt - extt ] shows density and temperature in the low - t region with @xmath92 correction and in the middle - t region when forward shock waves emerge .
the forward shock wave emerges at density @xmath121 and @xmath126 g @xmath31 for the former and latter cases , respectively .
according to table 6 in @xcite , spontaneous initiation of a detonation wave requires a hotspot with size of @xmath126 and @xmath88 cm for density @xmath121 and @xmath126 g @xmath31 , respectively .
since a mesh size is @xmath127 cm , the hotspot is too small to generate a detonation wave for the former case , and is sufficiently large for the latter case .
our results about the initiation of the detonation wave are consistent with the criteria in @xcite .
as seen in table 8 , 9 , 10 , and 11 of @xcite , the hotspot size to generate a detonation wave becomes rapidly larger as carbon fraction becomes smaller .
even when the carbon fraction decreases from @xmath58 % to @xmath128 % , a hotspot size required to generate a detonation wave becomes larger by a factor of @xmath129 .
therefore , the reason why no detonation wave occurs for the onemg case in the middle - t region ( see the right panels of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) is that a hotspot is too small to generate a detonation wave in onemg compositions . from the above , we find two implications .
first , the resolution of 3d sph simulations is too low to resolve a forward shock wave even if @xmath130 .
second , the forward shock wave does not always initiate a detonation wave even if materials consist of co. finally , we discuss the reliability of the initiation of a detonation wave for the co case in the middle - t region . in this case ,
the forward shock wave occurs , and create the hotspot generating the detonation wave where the density gradient is steep . as seen in figure [ fig : diff_lowt - extt ] , the hotspot has density of @xmath2 g @xmath31 , however a mesh near the hotspot has density of @xmath121 g @xmath31 .
if the forward shock wave emerges at a bit outer region , it can not trigger a detonation wave , since the forward shock wave propagates outward ( see panel ( a ) of figure [ fig : det_extt ] ) .
our 1d initial conditions lack accuracy to precisely determine where a forward shock wave occurs .
therefore , the initiation of a detonation wave may be unreliable . in order to follow the initiation of a detonation wave accurately ,
we should perform 3d simulations with a space resolution of @xmath5 cm .
note that the detonation wave in the middle - t region occurs only when a space resolution is @xmath5 cm .
in this section , we discuss why materials are falsely heated in 3d sph simulation with low resolution , using model co1 which is similar to model of rosswog s run 8 .
model co1 provides a solid basis for the comparison , since this parameter set is the same as that of rosswog s run 8 , and @xcite have investigated the observational features of this model . in our model ,
the wds yield @xmath131 and @xmath132 of fe group elements for @xmath133 m and @xmath134 m , respectively . on the other hand , rosswog s run 8 has @xmath135 for @xmath136 m . our results are consistent with those of rosswog s run 8 from the view point of the nucleosynthesis .
figure [ fig : xyplane_co1 ] shows thermodynamical quantities of model co1 in the same way as in figure [ fig : xyplane_onemg ] . as seen in the bottom panels , the amount of @xmath8ni increases from @xmath68 m to @xmath133 m , and decreases from @xmath137 m to @xmath69 m , which is consistent with the amount of @xmath8ni drawn in figure [ fig : n - element ] .
the increase from @xmath68 m to @xmath133 m comes from the increase of the density of particles with increasing @xmath0 ( see the top panels ) .
note that @xmath8ni is more synthesized ( while artificially ) at higher density if materials experience explosive nuclear burning . the low density in @xmath68 m results in the lower temperature and larger unburned mass in @xmath68 m than those in @xmath133 m .
since the density is low , the nuclear reactions are not active so much .
the dependence of the density on @xmath0 can be explained as follows .
as @xmath0 becomes smaller , a particle on the orbital plane has a larger kernel - support radius .
sph simulation calculates the density of the particle , considering more distant particles from the orbital plane .
particles are distributed more sparsely with increasing distance from the orbital plane .
therefore , the density of the particle becomes smaller with a larger kernel - support radius ( smaller @xmath0 ) .
the decrease of @xmath8ni from @xmath137 m to @xmath69 m is also due to the same reason as the decrease in model onemg .
figure [ fig : xzplane_co1 ] shows the structure of model co1 on a plane perpendicular to the orbital plane
. in @xmath69 m , the kernel - support radii of the particles are smaller than the scale height , except around @xmath138 cm where explosive nuclear burning occurs . in @xmath68 m ,
@xmath139 m , and @xmath140 m , the kernel - support radii seem smaller than the scale height , even where explosive nuclear burning occurs .
however , the kernel - support radius is comparable to the scale height at the time earlier than @xmath141 s. in the following , we clarify the reason why the nuclear reactions occur if the kernel - support radius is comparable to the scale height in the @xmath7-direction . for this purpose
, we follow the time evolution of particles located at the crosses in figure [ fig : xyplane_co1 ] . in order to focus on whether the nuclear reactions start or not , we adopt model co1 w / o nuc . figure [ fig : dens - temp_co1 ] shows the density and temperature of these particles in @xmath133 m and @xmath59 m .
since the @xmath57c + @xmath57c timescale is shorter than the local dynamical timescale in a part of particles in both @xmath0 , they would experience the explosive nuclear burning if the nuclear reaction network was turned on .
we can see the trajectories of these particles in figure [ fig : x - z_co1 ] .
the trajectories are independent of @xmath0 from @xmath142 cm to @xmath143 cm .
the particles are in the range of @xmath144 cm at @xmath142 cm , and in the range of @xmath145 cm at @xmath143 cm . at @xmath146 cm ,
the particles in @xmath69 m are distributed slightly more densely than those in @xmath133 m .
since these particles approach the orbital plane , the scale height of the structure shrinks in the @xmath7-direction . on the other hand ,
the kernel - support radii of these particles keep nearly constant ; the density of the structure does not grow .
this is because the structure is compressed in the @xmath7-direction , but is extended in the direction of the orbital plane .
the entropy of these particles grows from some point .
although their entropy increases , no shock wave is found out . if there is a shock wave , the trajectories of these particles
should be changed discontinuously . moreover
, their entropy in @xmath133 m grows at smaller @xmath73 ( i.e. earlier ) than those in @xmath69 m .
these behaviours of their entropy are clearly not converged against @xmath0 .
we investigate why the entropy increases despite the absence of a shock wave .
figure [ fig : x - vz_co1 ] shows the velocities in the @xmath7-direction and sound velocities of these particles . particles distant from the orbital plane approach the orbital plane supersonically from @xmath147 cm to @xmath148 cm , while particles near the orbital plane have small velocities in the @xmath7-direction .
therefore , the relative velocities between the outermost and innermost particles from the orbital plane are supersonic .
since all these particles have the kernel - support radii comparable to the scale height , the innermost particles interact supersonically with the outermost particles .
then , the particles obtain entropy .
the reason why particles in smaller @xmath0 obtain entropy earlier is as follows .
the kernel - support radii of particles are larger in smaller @xmath0 .
therefore , in smaller @xmath0 , the innermost particles start interacting with the outermost particles when the scale height is still larger .
as @xmath0 becomes larger , the kernel - support radii become smaller . each of the innermost and outermost particles interacts only with their adjacent particles .
their relative velocities are subsonic .
consequently , these particles do not gain entropy in large @xmath0 . in summary , particles on the orbital plane
are heated and gain entropy , interacting with the outermost particles from the orbital plane due to their kernel - support radii comparable to the scale height .
such interactions should not happen in reality , and the heating is spurious .
the spurious heating triggers explosive nuclear burning falsely .
eventually , our 3d sph simulations fail to follow the nucleosynthesis in wd tdes , even if our simulations have unprecedentedly high resolution .
this should also be the case for previous simulations with lower resolution .
we perform 3d sph simulations with @xmath3 to follow the tdes of he wds , co wds , and onemg wds by imbhs .
we observe that the explosive nuclear burning occurs in all the wds .
however , the final compositions are strongly dependent on @xmath0 .
we find that the amount of unburned materials increases with increasing @xmath0 .
the nucleosynthesis of these wds is not converged against @xmath0 , although our simulations contain unprecedentedly large @xmath0 , up to a few @xmath2 particles .
the reason why the explosive nuclear burning occurs in small-@xmath0 simulations is as follows . in such small-@xmath0 simulations ,
the scale height of a wd in the @xmath7-direction becomes comparable to the kernel - support radii of particles at the pericenter passage around an imbh . on the other hand
, a particle at the surface of the wd approaches the orbital plane supersonically .
then , the particle interacts with other particles on the orbital plane .
their interactions generate spurious heating , and trigger explosive nuclear burning falsely . if @xmath0 is sufficiently large , these particles do not interact with each other , since the kernel - support radius is sufficiently small . by means of mesh - based simulations ,
@xcite have suggested that a wd tde can experience explosive nuclear burning .
however , we conjecture that their mesh - based simulations have not either resolved the scale height of the wd in the @xmath7-direction at the pericenter passage .
they have investigated tdes with @xmath9 co wds which orbit around a @xmath149 imbh with @xmath21 .
this model is similar to our model co. in our model , the scale height in the @xmath7-direction is about @xmath150 cm at the pericenter passage when @xmath34 .
if the scale height is almost equal to those in @xcite , their simulations can not resolve the scale height , since their finest mesh size is about @xmath2 cm .
we find no shock wave generation in 3d sph simulations with @xmath151 .
so , we perform 1d sph and flash simulations with higher resolution than the 3d sph simulations in order to examine whether the absence of shock waves results from the low resolution of the 3d sph simulations . eventually , we find the following two insights .
first , a shock wave emerges in both 1d sph and flash simulations . in other words ,
the resolution of the current 3d sph simulations is not enough to resolve the shock wave , even if @xmath78 .
second , the shock wave can trigger a detonation wave , only when it makes a hotspot large enough to generate a detonation wave . for the case of materials consisting of onemg
, no shock wave triggers a detonation . for the case of materials consisting of co ,
if the shock wave occurs in a low - density region ( @xmath5 g @xmath31 ) , a hotspot formed by the shock wave is too small to generate a detonation wave .
although a detonation wave occurs in a part of our 1d simulations , the initiation of the detonation wave may be unreliable for the following reason .
the shock wave triggering the detonation wave occurs where the density gradient is steep .
if the shock wave occurs at a bit outer region , it can not trigger the detonation wave , since it occurs in much lower density region by a factor of @xmath42 .
our 1d modeling lacks accuracy to precisely determine where the shock wave occurs . in order to conclude that wd tdes become optical transients powered by radioactive nuclei
, we need to perform 3d simulations with a space resolution of @xmath5 cm .
sph simulation with @xmath152 seems to satisfy this requirement .
however , this may not be true in the following reason .
a shock wave emerges at the surface of a wd .
generally , sph simulation has lower space resolution at the surface of an object than inside .
therefore , sph simulation may need @xmath153 particles .
a. tanikawa thanks k. kawana , n. yoshida , y. guo , and k. sugiura for fruitful discussions .
numerical computations were carried out on cray xc30 at center for computational astrophysics , national astronomical observatory of japan , and on cray xc40 at yukawa institute for theoretical physics , kyoto university . the software used in this work was in part developed by the doe nnsa - asc oascr flash center at the university of chicago . this research has been supported in part by world premier international research center initiative ( wpi initiative ) , mext , japan , by mext program for the development and improvement for the next generation ultra high - speed computer system under its subsidies for operating the specific advanced large research facilities , and by grants - in - aid for scientific research ( 24540227 , 26400222 , 26800100 , 16h02168 , 16k17656 ) from the japan society for the promotion of science .
finally , we thank the anonymous referee for helpful advice .
iwasawa , m. , tanikawa , a. , hosono , n. , et al .
2015 , in proceedings of the 5th international workshop on domain - specific languages and high - level frameworks for high performance computing , wolfhpc 15 ( new york , ny , usa : acm ) , 1:11:10 | we investigate nucleosynthesis in tidal disruption events ( tdes ) of white dwarfs ( wds ) by intermediate mass black holes ( imbhs ) .
we consider various types of wds with different masses and compositions by means of 3 dimensional ( 3d ) smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) simulations .
we model these wds with different numbers of sph particles , @xmath0 , from a few @xmath1 to a few @xmath2 , in order to check mass resolution convergence , where sph simulations with @xmath3 ( or a space resolution of several @xmath4 cm ) have unprecedentedly high resolution in this kind of simulations .
we find that nuclear reactions become less active with increasing @xmath0 , and that these nuclear reactions are excited by spurious heating due to low resolution .
moreover , we find no shock wave generation . in order to investigate the reason for the absence of a shock wave , we additionally perform 1 dimensional ( 1d ) sph and mesh - based simulations with a space resolution ranging from @xmath1 to @xmath2 cm , using characteristic flow structure extracted from the 3d sph simulations .
we find shock waves in these 1d high - resolution simulations .
one of these shock waves triggers a detonation wave .
however , we have to be careful of the fact that , if the shock wave emerged at a bit outer region , it could not trigger the detonation wave due to low density .
note that the 1d initial conditions lack accuracy to precisely determine where a shock wave emerges .
we need to perform 3d simulations with @xmath5 cm space resolution in order to conclude that wd tdes become optical transients powered by radioactive nuclei . |
mott variable range hopping is a fundamental mechanism at the basis of low temperature electron conduction in disordered solids ( e.g. doped semiconductors ) in the regime of anderson localization ( see @xcite ) . by localization , and using a mean field approximation , mott
variable range hopping can be described by a suitable random walk @xmath0 in a random environment @xmath1 .
the environment @xmath1 is given by a marked simple point process @xmath2 with law @xmath3 .
the sites @xmath4 correspond to the points in the disordered solid around which the conduction electrons are localized , and @xmath5 $ ] is the ground energy of the associated localized wave function .
the random walk @xmath6 has state space @xmath7 and can jump from a site @xmath8 to any other site @xmath9 with probability rate @xmath10 @xmath11 being the inverse temperature .
we refer to @xcite for rigorous results on the random walk @xmath6 , including the stretched exponential decay of the diffusion matrix as @xmath12 in accordance with the physical mott law for @xmath13 . here
we focus on the one - dimensional case , i.e. @xmath14 ( we order the sites @xmath8 s in increasing order , with @xmath15 ) , and study the effect of applying an external field .
this corresponds to modifying the above jump rates @xmath16 by a factor @xmath17 , where @xmath18 has to be interpreted as the intensity of the external field .
moreover , we generalize the form of the jump rates , finally taking @xmath19 with @xmath20 a symmetric bounded function . for simplicity
, we keep the same notation @xmath6 for the resulting random walk starting at the origin . under rather weak assumptions on the environment
, we will show that @xmath6 is a.s .
transient for almost every environment @xmath1 ( cf . theorem [ teo1](i ) ) . in the rest of theorem [ teo1 ]
we give two conditions in terms of the exponential moments of the inter
point distances , both assuring that the asymptotic velocity @xmath21 is well defined and almost surely constant , that is , it does not depend on the realization of @xmath1 .
call @xmath22 the expectation with respect to @xmath3 . the first condition , namely @xmath23<\infty\,$ ] and @xmath20 continuous , implies ballisticity , i.e. @xmath24 .
the second condition , namely @xmath25=\infty\,$ ] , implies sub - ballisticity , i.e. @xmath26 . in particular ,
if the points @xmath27 are given by a renewal process , our two conditions give a sharp dichotomy ( when @xmath20 is continuous ) .
we point out that there are cases in which @xmath28 is not continuous in @xmath29 ( see example [ sorpresa ] in subsection [ esaedro ] ) . under the condition leading to ballisticity
we also show that the markov process given by the environment viewed from the walker admits a stationary ergodic distribution @xmath30 , which is mutually absolutely continuous to the original law @xmath3 of the environment .
moreover we give upper and lower bounds on the radon nikodym derivative @xmath31 , showing that it is in @xmath32 , and we characterize the asymptotic velocity as the expectation of the local drift with respect to the measure @xmath30 ( cf .
theorem [ teo2 ] ) .
the study of ballisticity for the mott random walk is the first fundamental step towards proving the einstein relation , which states the proportionality of diffusivity and mobility of the process ( see e.g. @xcite ) . among other important applications ,
the einstein relation would allow to conclude the proof of the physical mott law , which was originally stated for the mobility of the process and has only been proved for its diffusivity ( see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite ) .
the einstein relation will be addressed in future work .
the techniques used to prove ballisticity and sub - ballisticity are different . in order to comment them it is convenient to refer to the discrete time random walk and @xmath33 @xmath34 on @xmath35 such that @xmath36 if after @xmath37 jumps the random walk @xmath6 is at site @xmath8 .
due to our assumptions on the environment , the ballistic / sub - ballistic behavior of @xmath0 is indeed the same as that of @xmath34 , and therefore we focus on the latter .
we first comment the ballistic regime .
considering first a generic random walk on @xmath35 starting at the origin and a.s .
transient to the right , ballisticity is usually derived by proving a law of large numbers ( lln ) for the hitting times @xmath38 , where @xmath39 is the first time the random walk reaches the half - line @xmath40 . in the case of nearest
neighbor random walks , @xmath41 is simply the hitting time of @xmath37 , and considering an ergodic environment one can derive the lln for @xmath38 by showing that the sequence @xmath42 is stationary and mixing for the annealed law as in @xcite .
this technique can not be applied in the present case , since our random walk has infinite range and much information about the environment to the right is known , when a site in @xmath40 is visited for the first time .
a very useful tool is the method developed in @xcite where the authors have studied ballisticity for a class of random walks on @xmath35 with arbitrarily long jumps .
their strategy is as follows .
first one introduces for any positive integer @xmath43 a truncated random walk obtained from the original one by forbidding all jumps of length larger than @xmath43 .
the ergodicity of the environment and the finite range of the jumps allow to introduce a regenerative structure related to the times @xmath44 , and to analyze the asymptotic behavior of the @xmath43truncated random walk .
in particular , one proves that the environment viewed from the @xmath43truncated random walk admits a stationary ergodic distribution @xmath45 which is mutually absolutely continuous to the original law of the environment .
a basic ingredient here is the theory of cycle stationarity and cycle ergodicity ( cf .
* chapter 8) and @xcite for an example in a simplified setting ) .
finally , one proves that the sequence @xmath46 converges weakly to a probability distribution @xmath30 , which is indeed a stationary and ergodic distribution for the environment viewed from the random walker @xmath47 and is also mutually absolutely continuous to the law of the environment @xmath3 .
since , as usual , the random walk can be written as an additive functional of the environment viewed from the random walker , one can apply birkhoff s ergodic theorem and use the ergodicity of @xmath30 to get the strong lln for the random walk ( hence its asymptotic velocity ) for @xmath30a.e . environment .
using the fact that @xmath48 , the above strong lln holds for @xmath3a.e .
environment , too .
finally , since the velocities of the @xmath43truncated walks are uniformly bounded from below by a strictly positive constant and since they converge to the velocity of @xmath47 when @xmath49 , we obtain a ballistic behavior . to analyze ballisticity
we have used the same method as in @xcite , although one can not apply ( * ? ? ?
* theorems 2.3 , 2.4 ) directly to the present case , since some hypotheses are not satisfied in our context . in particular , in @xcite three conditions ( called e , c , d ) are assumed , and only condition @xmath50 is satisfied by our model . by means of estimates based on capacity theory , we are able to extend the method developed in @xcite to the present case .
we now move to sub - ballisticity ( the regime of zero velocity is not covered in @xcite and our method could be in principle applied to random walks on @xmath35 with arbitrarily long jumps ) .
we define a coupling between the random walk @xmath51 , a sequence of suitable @xmath52valued i.i.d .
random variables @xmath53 with finite mean , and an ergodic sequence of random variables @xmath54 with the following properties : fix @xmath55 and call now @xmath56 the first time the random walk overjumps the point @xmath57 .
@xmath58 is a geometric random variable of parameter @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is the usual shift and @xmath61 a deterministic function .
the coupling guarantees that @xmath62 does not exceed @xmath63 and also ensures that the time @xmath64 is larger than @xmath58 .
notice that @xmath65 and therefore the sub - ballisticity of @xmath66 follows from the lln for @xmath67 and the lln for @xmath68 , since our assumption @xmath25=\infty\,$ ] implies that @xmath69 = + \infty$ ] . in section [ notazione ]
we rigorously introduce the ( perturbed ) mott random walk in its continuous and discrete - time versions .
theorem [ teo1 ] states the transience to the right and gives conditions implying ballisticity or subballisticity .
theorem [ teo2 ] , deals with the radon - nikodym derivative of the invariant measure for the environment viewed from the walker with respect to the original law @xmath3 of the environment and gives a characterization of the limiting speed of the walk .
subsection [ domenica ] comments the assumptions we made for the theorems , while two important ( counter-)examples can be found in subsection [ esaedro ] . in section [ zetino ]
we collect results on the @xmath43truncated walks .
estimates of the effective conductances induced by these walks and of the time they spend on a given interval are carried out in subsections [ condottiero ] and [ ecd ] , respectively . in subsection
[ subsec : hit ] we show that the probability for them to hit a specific site to the right is uniformly bounded from below . section [ rigenero ] introduces the regenerative structure for the @xmath43truncated random walks and in subsection [ subsec : regeneration ] we give estimates on the regeneration times . the existence and positivity of the limiting speed for the truncated walks
is proven in subsection [ veloce ] . in section [ tronco ]
we characterize the density of the invariant measure for the process viewed from the @xmath43truncated walker with respect to the original law of the environment .
in subsection [ up_bound ] we bound the radon - nikodym derivative from above by an @xmath70 function , while in subsection [ lo_bound ] we give a uniform lower bound . in subsection [ deboluccio ] we finally pass to the limit @xmath49 and obtain an invariant measure for the environment viewed from the non - truncated walker and show that it is also absolutely continuous with respect to @xmath3 ( see lemma [ chiave ] ) . to conclude , in sections [ proof_transience ] , [ ballistic_part ] and [ submarine ] we prove , respectively , parts ( i ) , ( ii ) and ( iii ) of theorem [ teo1 ] .
some technical results are collected in the appendixes [ ape ] , [ appendix : ergodic ] and [ app_nn ] .
one - dimensional mott random walk is a particular random walk in a random environment .
the environment @xmath1 is given by a double sided sequence @xmath71 of random variables , with @xmath72 and @xmath73 for all @xmath74 .
we denote by @xmath75 the space of all environments , by @xmath3 and @xmath22 the law of the environment and the associated expectation , respectively . given @xmath76 , we define the shifted environment @xmath77 as @xmath78 . our main assumptions on the environment are the following : * the sequence @xmath79 is stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts ; * @xmath80 $ ] is finite ; * @xmath81 for all @xmath76 ; * there exists @xmath82 satisfying @xmath83 .
we postpone to subsection [ domenica ] some comments on the above assumptions .
it is convenient to introduce the sequence @xmath84 of points on the real line , where @xmath15 and @xmath85 .
then the environment @xmath1 can be thought also as the marked simple point process @xmath86 , which will be denoted again by @xmath1 ( with some abuse of notation ) . in this case
, the @xmath87shift reads @xmath88 . for physical reasons ,
@xmath89 is called the energy mark associated to point @xmath90 , while @xmath91 is the interpoint distance ( between @xmath92 and @xmath90 ) .
fix now a symmetric and bounded ( from below by @xmath93 and from above by @xmath94 ) measurable function @xmath95 .
given an environment @xmath1 , the mott random walk @xmath0 is the continuous time random walk on @xmath96 with probability rate @xmath97 for a jump from @xmath8 to @xmath98 . for convenience , we set @xmath99 .
note that the mott walk is well defined for @xmath3a.a .
indeed , since the interpoint distance is a.s .
at least @xmath100 and the function @xmath20 is uniformly bounded , the holding time parameter @xmath101 can be bounded from above by a constant @xmath102 uniformly in @xmath103 , hence explosion does not take place .
we now introduce a bias @xmath104 which corresponds to the intensity of the external field . for a fixed @xmath105 , the biased mott random walk
@xmath0 with environment @xmath1 is the continuous time random walk on @xmath96 with probability rates @xmath106 for a jump from @xmath107 to @xmath108 . for convenience
, we set @xmath109 and denote the holding time parameter by @xmath110 .
when @xmath111 , one recovers the original mott random walk . since , for @xmath112 , we have a.s .
@xmath113 , the biased mott random walk with environment @xmath1 is well defined for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 .
we can consider also the jump chain @xmath114 associated to the biased mott random walk ( we call it the _ discrete time mott random walk _ ) .
given the environment @xmath1 , @xmath115 is the discrete time random walk on @xmath96 with jump probabilities @xmath116 a similar definition holds for the unbiased case ( @xmath111 ) .
the following result concerns transience , sub - ballisticity and ballisticity : [ teo1 ] fix @xmath117 . then , for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 , the continuous time mott random walk @xmath0 with environment @xmath1 , bias @xmath104 and starting at the origin satisfies the following properties : * transience to the right : @xmath118 a.s . *
ballistic regime : if @xmath119 < + \infty $ ] and @xmath120 is continuous , then the asymptotic velocity @xmath121 exists a.s . , it is deterministic , finite and strictly positive ( an integral representation of @xmath122 is given in section [ ballistic_part ] , see and ) .
* sub ballistic regime : if @xmath123=\infty\,,\ ] ] then @xmath124 in particular , if @xmath125\leq c$ ] for some constant @xmath50 which does not depend on @xmath1 and @xmath126=\infty$ ] , then condition is satisfied and @xmath127 .
in addition , for @xmath3a.a . @xmath1 the above properties remain valid ( restricting to integer times @xmath128 ) for the discrete time mott random walk @xmath114 with environment @xmath1 , bias @xmath104 and starting at the origin , and its velocity @xmath129 . in the case
@xmath111 the mott random walks @xmath6 and @xmath130 are recurrent and have a.s .
zero velocity .
recurrence follows from ( * ? ? ?
1.2(iii ) ) and the recurrence of the spatially homogeneous discrete time random walk on @xmath35 with probability to jump from @xmath107 to @xmath131 proportional to @xmath132 . to see that the velocity is zero , set @xmath133 } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb p } } } ( d \o)$ ] .
@xmath134 is a reversible and ergodic distribution for the environment viewed from the discrete time mott random walker @xmath130 ( see @xcite ) . by writing @xmath130 as an additive function of the process
environment viewed from the walker " and using the ergodicity of @xmath134 , one gets that @xmath135 is zero a.s .
, for @xmath134a.a .
@xmath1 and therefore for @xmath3a.a .
similarly , @xmath136 a.s .
, for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 ( use that @xmath3 is reversible and ergodic for the environment viewed from @xmath6 , see @xcite ) .
if the random variables @xmath91 are i.i.d .
( or even when only @xmath137 are independent for every @xmath138 ) and @xmath20 is continuous , the above theorem implies the following dichotomy : @xmath24 if and only if @xmath119 < + \infty $ ] , otherwise @xmath26 .
the same holds for @xmath139 .
we point out that , if the @xmath91 s are correlated , @xmath119 = + \infty $ ] does not imply in general zero velocity ( see example [ velocino ] in section [ esaedro ] ) .
theorem [ teo1 ] shows that there are cases in which the limiting speed @xmath140 is not continuous in @xmath29 .
see example [ sorpresa ] in section [ esaedro ] . [
remark : nearest ] when considering the nearest neighbor random walk on @xmath141 with probability rate for a jump from @xmath107 to a neighboring site @xmath131 given by , the random walk is ballistic if and only if @xmath142 a proof of this fact is given in appendix [ app_nn ] .
as outlined in remark [ estensione ] , one can indeed weaken the condition @xmath119
< + \infty $ ] to prove ballisticity , albeit at the cost of dealing with rather ugly formulas having some analogy with .
one of the most interesting technical results we use in the proof of theorem [ teo1 ] , part ( ii ) , concerns the invariant measure for the environment seen from the point of view of the walker : [ teo2 ] suppose that @xmath143 < + \infty $ ] and @xmath120 is continuous
. then the following holds : * the environment viewed from the discrete time mott random walker @xmath144 , i.e. the process @xmath145 where @xmath146 , admits an invariant and ergodic distribution @xmath30 absolutely continuous to @xmath3 such that @xmath147 for a suitable universal constant @xmath148 and a function @xmath149 ( defined in ) . * by writing @xmath150 for the expectation with respect to @xmath30 , the velocities @xmath140 , @xmath139 can be expressed as @xmath151\,,\label{adsl1 } \\ & v_y(\l)= { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ z_0 ] { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^\infty \big [ \sum _ { k \in { { \ensuremath{\mathbb z } } } } k \,p_{0,x_k}^\l ( \o ) \big]\,,\label{adsl2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and the expectations in , are finite and positive ( recall that @xmath152 ) .
theorem [ teo2](i ) is part of proposition [ digiuno ] given at the end of section [ tronco ] .
the proof of theorem [ teo2](ii ) is part of section [ ballistic_part ] , more precisely and are an immediate consequence of , and the observation just after . by assumption ( a1 ) both random sequences @xmath153 and @xmath154 are stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts .
the physically interesting case is given by two independent random sequences @xmath153 and @xmath154 , the former stationary and ergodic , while the latter given by i.i.d .
random variables . in this case assumption ( a1 )
is satisfied ( see lemma [ indi ] in appendix [ appendix : ergodic ] ) .
assumption ( a3 ) ensures that a.s .
the environment is not periodic .
if the energy marks @xmath89 are i.i.d . and non - constant , as in the physically interesting case , then ( a3 ) is automatically fulfilled .
note that the sequence @xmath153 could be periodic , without violating our assumptions ( e.g. take @xmath155 for all @xmath74 ) .
assumption ( a4 ) , corresponding to interpoint distances which are uniformly bounded from below , is not restrictive from a physical viewpoint and @xmath100 can be taken of the angstrom order .
on the other hand , ( a4 ) plays a crucial role in our proofs . in this section
we give two examples highlighting the importance of the assumptions in theorem [ teo1 ] and showing some of its consequences .
[ velocino ] @xmath119 = \infty $ ] does in general _ not _ imply that @xmath26 , @xmath156 .
we set @xmath157 and take @xmath158 .
we choose @xmath153 as the reversible markov chain with values in @xmath159 for some @xmath160 and with transition probabilities defined as follows : @xmath161 the equilibrium distribution is given by @xmath162 for @xmath163 , @xmath164 being the normalizing constant .
hence , @xmath165 , for each @xmath166 .
notice that @xmath119 = c \sum_{k\geq1 } e^{(1-\l)k \g } \bigl(p/(1-p)\bigr)^k$ ] is infinite if and only if @xmath167 we now show that we can choose the parameters such that @xmath119 = \infty$ ] and @xmath168 for each @xmath55 , the latter implying that @xmath169 due to theorem [ teo2](ii ) and the definition of @xmath170 in .
+ if @xmath171 , for some @xmath172 , the local drift @xmath173 can be bounded from below by the drift of the configuration with longer and longer interpoint distances to the right and shorter and shorter interpoint distances to the left : @xmath174 for all @xmath175 and @xmath176 for all @xmath177 .
note that in this case @xmath178 & \text { if } k \geq 1\,,\\ x_{-k } = - \g \big [ kj - \frac{k(k+1)}{2 } \big ] & \text { if } 1\leq k \leq j-1\,,\\
x_{-k } = - \g \big [ \frac{j(j-1)}{2 } + k - j+1\big ] & \text { if } k \geq j \ , .
\end{cases}\ ] ] hence we can write @xmath179 where @xmath180 , @xmath181 and @xmath182 . we bound @xmath183 from below with its first summand @xmath184 and prove that @xmath185\exp\{(1-\l)\g j\}<1,\end{aligned}\ ] ] since this will imply the positivity of the local drift @xmath186 for any possible @xmath1 , for @xmath148 big enough .
using that @xmath187 we bound @xmath188 and , using that @xmath189 , we bound @xmath190 for some constant @xmath191 independent of @xmath104 and @xmath148 ( recall that @xmath192 ) . with these bounds we see that holds as soon as @xmath193 , for @xmath148 big enough .
on the other hand , by we can choose @xmath194 close enough to @xmath195 so that @xmath119 $ ] is infinite .
[ sorpresa ] the velocities @xmath196 , @xmath197 are not continuous in general .
take @xmath198 .
let the @xmath91 be i.i.d .
random variables larger than @xmath199 such that @xmath200 has probability density @xmath201 , with @xmath202 and @xmath164 is the normalizing constant . since
, for @xmath203 , @xmath204 , the constant @xmath164 is well defined and @xmath205= \int_e^\infty \frac{c x^{1-\l } } { x^{\g } ( \ln x)^2}dx < \infty $ ] if and only if @xmath206 .
note that @xmath207 .
then the above observations and theorem [ teo1 ] imply that @xmath208 are zero for @xmath209 and are strictly positive for @xmath210 .
take @xmath105 . given @xmath212 we replace , with a slight abuse of notation , @xmath213 and the associated conductance @xmath214 ( note that in @xmath215 the dependence on @xmath104 has been omitted ) .
hence we have @xmath216 and @xmath217 given @xmath218 we introduce the discrete time random walk @xmath219 with environment @xmath1 as the markov chain on @xmath35 such that the @xmath1dependent probability to jump from @xmath220 to @xmath221 in one step is given by @xmath222 [ attenzione ] when the markov chain @xmath223 starts at @xmath224 , we write @xmath225 for its law and @xmath226 for the associated expectation . in order to make the notation lighter ,
inside @xmath227 and @xmath228 $ ] we will usually write @xmath229 instead of @xmath230 . it is convenient to introduce the random bijection @xmath231 defined as @xmath232 , and also the continuous time random walk @xmath233 on @xmath35 with probability rate @xmath234 for a jump from @xmath220 to @xmath221 . since @xmath235
we conclude that realizations of @xmath236 and @xmath237 can be obtained as @xmath238 in particular , when the denominators are nonzero , we can write @xmath239 by assumptions ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) , @xmath240<\infty $ ] , @xmath3a.s .. by this limit , together with and , we will see in sections [ ballistic_part ] , [ submarine ] that in order to prove theorem [ teo1 ] it is enough to show the same properties for @xmath241 instead of @xmath242 . in what follows
, we write @xmath243 if , for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 , @xmath244 @xmath245a.s .. a similar meaning is assigned to @xmath246 .
we take again @xmath247 and @xmath248 . for @xmath249 disjoint subsets of @xmath35
, we introduce the effective conductance between @xmath250 and @xmath251 as @xmath252 we also set @xmath253 and define @xmath254 as the escape probability of @xmath255 from @xmath224 , i.e. @xmath256 it is known ( see the discussion before theorem 2.3 in ( * ? ? ?
* section 2.2 ) and formula ( 2.4 ) therein ) that @xmath257\cup[i+n,\infty))}{\pi^ { \infty}(i)}\ ] ] ( recall that the probability for @xmath258 to jump from @xmath220 to @xmath221 ( for @xmath259 ) is given by @xmath260 , cf . ) .
we will see ( cf .
corollary [ cor : p_esc ] ) that the escape probability of each @xmath43random walk can be uniformly bounded from below and above by the escape probability of the nearest neighbor walk times constants .
[ carnevale]note that @xmath261 , @xmath262 and @xmath263 depend on the environment @xmath1 , although we have omitted @xmath1 from the notation .
[ prop : effconductance_bound ] there exists a constant @xmath264 not depending on @xmath265 and @xmath251 such that @xmath266 since @xmath267 is increasing in @xmath43 , it is enough to show the second inequality for @xmath268 . to this aim
take any valid @xmath269 and note that @xmath270,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the cauchy - schwarz inequality for the second step .
define the new conductances @xmath271 now we are left to show that @xmath272 for some @xmath273 and this will conclude the proof . using the fact that @xmath274 we have @xmath275 , we have @xmath276 since
the last double sum is bounded for each @xmath277 , we obtain the claim .
[ lorenzo ] there exists a constant @xmath191 which does not depend on @xmath278 such that @xmath279 since @xmath280 is increasing in @xmath43 it is enough to prove that @xmath281 for all @xmath282 .
we easily see that @xmath283 analogously , @xmath284 as a byproduct of , prop .
[ prop : effconductance_bound ] and lemma [ lorenzo ] , we get : [ cor : p_esc ] there exist constants @xmath285 which do not depend on @xmath278 such that @xmath286 the following lemma is well known and corresponds to formula ( 2.1.4 ) in @xcite : [ lemma : effconductance_nn ] let @xmath287 be any system of strictly positive conductances on the nearest neighbor bonds of @xmath35 .
let @xmath288 be the first hitting time of the set @xmath289 for the associated discrete time nearest neighbor random walk among the conductances @xmath287 , which jumps from @xmath138 to @xmath290 with probability @xmath291 .
take @xmath292 , with @xmath293 and write @xmath294 for @xmath295 .
then @xmath296)}{c_{\rm eff}^{n.n.}(x\leftrightarrow ( -\infty , m]\cup[n,\infty))},\ ] ] where @xmath297 is the probability for the nearest - neighbor random walk starting at @xmath107 , and @xmath298 is the effective conductance of the nearest - neighbor walk between @xmath250 and @xmath251 .
we state another technical lemma which will be frequently used when dealing with conductances : [ goldie ] @xmath299 . by assumption ( a1 ) , @xmath300 is a stationary ergodic sequence . by writing @xmath301 , the ergodic theorem implies that @xmath302 $ ] , @xmath303a.s . as a consequence we get that @xmath304 < 0\ , , \qquad { { \ensuremath{\mathbb p } } } \text{--a.s.}\ ] ] since @xmath305 , the claim follows .
we conclude this section with a simple estimate leading to an exponential decay of the transition probabilities : [ pierpaolo ] there exists a constant @xmath273 which does not depend on @xmath306 , such that @xmath3a.s .
@xmath307 the first inequality follows from the definitions . to prove the second one
, we can estimate @xmath308 @xmath309 the second bound in now follows from , and lemma [ lorenzo ] .
we fix some notations which will be frequently used below . for @xmath310 and @xmath289 , we denote by @xmath311 the time spent by the random walk @xmath230 in the set @xmath250 during the time interval @xmath312 : @xmath313 if @xmath314 we simply write @xmath315 and if @xmath316 we write @xmath317 .
[ att1 ] when appearing inside @xmath318 or @xmath319 , @xmath320 will usually replace @xmath321 .
we can state our main result on the expected number of visits to a site @xmath138 for a given environment : [ prop : function_g ] there exists a constant @xmath322 , not depending on @xmath323 , such that the function @xmath324 , defined as @xmath325 satisfies @xmath326\leq g_\o ( |k| ) \
, , \qquad \forall k \leq 0\,.\ ] ] we recall that @xmath327 for all @xmath74 . moreover , we point out that the series in is finite , since it can be bounded by @xmath328 , while @xmath329 for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 ( see the argument in the proof of lemma [ goldie ] ) .
we remark that estimate is not uniform in the environment @xmath1 , and in general one can not expect a uniform bound .
this technical fact represents a major difference with the setting of @xcite , where the existence of an @xmath1-independent upper bound of the expected number of visits is required ( cf
. condition d therein ) .
fix @xmath330 .
starting from @xmath331 , the random variable @xmath332 is equal to @xmath333 where @xmath334 is a geometric random variable whose parameter is the escape probability @xmath335 from @xmath138 ( recall warning [ carnevale ] ) .
therefore @xmath336= \frac{1}{p^ { \rho}_{\rm esc}(k ) } p^{\o,\rho}_0(\mbox { $ x_\cdot$ eventually reaches $ k$ } ) .\ ] ] let us start by giving an upper bound for the probability of reaching @xmath138 in finite time : @xmath337 $ } ) \nonumber\\ & = \lim_{n\to\infty}p^{\o,\rho}_0(h_{b_n } > h_a ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath338 and the @xmath339 s are the hitting times of the respective sets . by a well - known formula ( see ( * ? ?
* proof of fact 2 ) ) @xmath340 using now proposition [ prop : effconductance_bound ] we have that there exists a @xmath273 such that @xmath341 where @xmath342 .
call @xmath343\cup[n+k,\infty)$ ] . by corollary [ cor : p_esc ] and equation , we know that @xmath344 where @xmath345 . since we have conductances in series , we can write @xmath346 we claim that @xmath347 indeed , the first series diverges a.s . since , for @xmath348 , @xmath349 ( note that @xmath350 ) .
the second series is finite a.s . due to lemma [ goldie ] .
due to , , , and we can write @xmath351 & \leq \bar k\,\frac{\pi^{1}(k)}{c_{\rm eff}^{1}(k\leftrightarrow c_\infty ) } \cdot\frac{c_{\rm eff}^{1}(0\leftrightarrow a ) } { c_{\rm eff}^{1}(0\leftrightarrow a\cup b_\infty ) } \nonumber\\ & = \bar k \,\frac{\pi^1(k ) } { \big(\displaystyle{\sum_{j=-\infty}^{k-1}}\tfrac{1}{c_{j , j+1}}\big)^{-1 } + \big(\displaystyle{\sum_{j = k}^{\infty}}\tfrac{1}{c_{j , j+1}}\big)^{-1 } } \cdot\frac{\big(\displaystyle{\sum_{j = k}^{-1}}\tfrac{1}{c_{j , j+1}}\big)^{-1 } } { \big(\displaystyle{\sum_{j = k}^{-1}}\tfrac{1}{c_{j , j+1}}\big)^{-1 } + \big(\displaystyle{\sum_{j=0}^{\infty}}\tfrac{1}{c_{j , j+1}}\big)^{-1}}\nonumber\\ & = \bar k\ , \pi^1(k ) \big(\displaystyle{\sum_{j=0}^{\infty}}\tfrac{1}{c_{j , j+1}}\big ) \leq k_0 \pi^1(k ) \,\sum_{j=0}^{\infty } { \rm e}^{-\l(x_j+x_{j+1})+(x_{j+1}-x_j ) } \leq g_\o ( |k|)\ , .
\label{riposino}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now consider the case @xmath352 . by , and we have @xmath353 & = \frac{1}{p^ { \rho}_{\rm esc}(0)}\leq k \frac{\pi^{1}(0)}{c_{\rm eff}^{1}(0\leftrightarrow c_\infty ) } = k \pi^{1}(0 ) \displaystyle{\sum_{j=0}^{\infty}}\tfrac{1}{c_{j , j+1 } } \end{split}\ ] ] and we can conclude as in .
we now collect some properties of the function @xmath354 : [ piccolino ] there exist constants @xmath355 which do not depend on @xmath356 , such that @xmath357 \leq k _ * \frac{{\rm e}^{-2\l dk}}{1-e^{-2\l d}}{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr]\ , , \qquad k \geq 0\,,\label{spring1}\\ & g_\o(k ) \geq g_{\t_\ell \o } ( k + \ell)\ , , \qquad k , \ell \geq 0\,,\label{spring2}\\ & { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } e_k^{\o , \rho } [ n_\infty ( { { \ensuremath{\mathbb z } } } _ - ) ] \leq k _ * \left ( \frac{1 } { ( 1-e^{-2\l d})^2}+ \frac{|k|}{1-e^{-2\l d } } \right ) { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr ] \ , , \qquad k \leq 0 \ , .
\label{spring3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] trivially , the first and fourth estimates are effective when @xmath358 < \infty$ ] .
we first prove .
recall @xmath359 .
given @xmath360 we have @xmath361 , implying @xmath362 . by the same argument , for @xmath363 one
gets @xmath364 and , for @xmath365 , @xmath366 .
is obtained noting that , by , @xmath367 \leq k _ * e^{-2 \l d k } \sum_{j=0}^\infty e^{- 2 \l j d } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr]$ ] .
to get we first observe that @xmath368 and @xmath369 for all @xmath370 . as a consequence , we get @xmath371= { \rm e } ^ { - 2 \l x_\ell } \pi^1 ( -k)$ ] ( the r.h.s
. refers to the environment @xmath1 ) .
therefore , using also that @xmath372 and that @xmath373 , we have @xmath374 thus completing the proof of . finally , for , we write , thanks to proposition [ prop : function_g ] , @xmath375 & = \sum_{z\leq k } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } e_k^{\o , \rho } [ n_\infty ( z)]+\sum_{k < z\leq 0}{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } e_k^{\o,\rho}[n_\infty(z ) ] \nonumber\\ & \leq\sum_{z\leq k}{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } e_k^{\o , \rho}[n_\infty ( z)]+\sum_{k < z\leq 0}{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } e_z^{\o , \rho } [ n_\infty ( z ) ] \qquad \mbox{(markov property)}\nonumber\\ & \leq \sum_{i\geq 0 } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ g _ { \tau_k\o}(i ) ] + |k|\,{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ g_\o(0)]\ , , \ ] ] and the claim then follows from .
[ estensione ] in the spirit of remark [ remark : nearest ] , we point out that we could consider weaker conditions than @xmath376 < + \infty$ ] , at the cost of dealing with rather involved formulas .
take for simplicity @xmath198 . in our case , @xmath376 < + \infty$ ] guarantees , by lemma [ piccolino ] , that @xmath367 $ ] is finite and summable over @xmath377 .
but what is actually required is that @xmath378 bounds from above the quantity @xmath379 ( see the proof of prop .
[ prop : function_g ] ) . by stationarity
, one has @xmath380 = { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ e^{-(1+\l ) z_0 -2 \l ( z_1 + \dots+ z_{i-1 } ) + ( 1-\l ) z_i } ] .\ ] ] this identity allows to provide conditions for @xmath381 $ ] to be finite , which are weaker than @xmath376 < + \infty$ ] .
one could go on in weakening conditions , also inside prop .
[ aereo ] , and still get the ballisticity of the mott random walks @xmath6 and @xmath130 .
[ cor : comparison_number_visits ] there exist constants @xmath285 which do not depend on @xmath382 such that @xmath383 \leq k_1 \
, e^{\o,1}_0[n_\infty ( k ) ] \leq k_2\ , g_\o(|k| ) & \forall k \leq 0\,,\label{venezia1}\\ & e^{\o,\rho}_0[n_\infty ( k ) ] \leq k_1 \,e^{\o,1}_0[n_\infty ( k ) ] & \forall k > 0\,.\label{venezia2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] first we consider .
its second inequality is a restatement of prop .
[ prop : function_g ] . for the first inequality
we distinguish the cases @xmath330 and @xmath352 . when @xmath330 note that and lemma [ lemma : effconductance_nn ] imply that @xmath384 then put together equation ( and its analogous version for @xmath385 ) , equation and corollary [ cor : p_esc ] . for @xmath352 use
that @xmath386 = \frac{1}{p^ { \rho}_{\rm esc}(0)}$ ] ( also in the case @xmath385 ) and use corollary [ cor : p_esc ] .
let us now consider equation . start with . due to corollary [ cor : p_esc ] and the fact that @xmath387 for each @xmath388 ( cf .
lemma [ sicilia ] below ) it is simple to conclude .
following @xcite , given @xmath389 , we set @xmath390 note that the dependence of @xmath1 has been omitted .
again ( see warnings [ attenzione ] and [ att1 ] ) , we simply write @xmath391 , @xmath392 inside @xmath393 , @xmath394 . [ sicilia ] for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 and for each @xmath395 it holds that @xmath396 without loss of generality we take @xmath397 and prove that @xmath398 . as in , setting @xmath399 $ ] and @xmath400 , we can bound @xmath401 we observe that @xmath402 , while ( recall ) @xmath403 together with proposition [ prop : effconductance_bound ] , this allows to conclude that @xmath404 .
our next result , lemma [ lemma : epsilon ] , is the analog of lemma 3.1 in @xcite .
our proof follows a different strategy in order to avoid to deal with conditions d , e of @xcite , which are not satisfied in our context .
[ lemma : epsilon ] there exists @xmath405 which does not depend on @xmath356 such that , @xmath3a.s .
, @xmath406 for all @xmath407 and for all @xmath408 .
we just make a pathwise analysis . by the markov property
we get @xmath409 we claim that there exists @xmath410 such that , for all @xmath221 and @xmath1 , @xmath411 in fact , given @xmath221 with @xmath412 , we can write @xmath413 coming back to , using the markov property and the fact that @xmath414 a.s . , we get @xmath415
in this section we take @xmath417 .
we recall the regenerative structure of @xcite for the @xmath43-truncated random walk with @xmath43 finite .
[ olanda ] in order to avoid heavy notation , in this section @xmath43 is fixed once and for all in @xmath52 and we write @xmath418 , @xmath419 , @xmath392 , @xmath229 , ... instead of @xmath420 , @xmath421 , @xmath422 , @xmath230 ,
... the whole section refers to the @xmath43-truncated random walk . only in subsection
[ veloce ] , in which we collect the main conclusions , we will indicate @xmath43 explicitly according to the usual notation . consider a sequence of i.i.d .
bernoulli r.v.s @xmath423 with parameter @xmath424 ( the same @xmath425 as in lemma [ lemma : epsilon ] ) which does not depend on the environment @xmath1 .
@xmath426 and @xmath427 denote the probability law and the expectation of the @xmath428 s .
we couple the sequence @xmath429 with the random walk @xmath430 in such a way that @xmath431 implies @xmath432 . to this aim
we construct the quenched measure @xmath433 of the random walk starting at @xmath331 once both @xmath1 and @xmath428 are fixed .
recall lemma [ lemma : epsilon ] .
first , the law of @xmath434 is defined by @xmath435.\ ] ] then , given @xmath436 and @xmath437 , the law of @xmath438}$ ] is @xmath439 .
\end{split}\ ] ] one can check that , by averaging @xmath440 over @xmath441 , one obtains the law @xmath442 of the original random walk @xmath443 .
we introduce by iteration the sequence @xmath444 as follows : @xmath445 note that by construction we have @xmath446 .
given @xmath377 let @xmath447
. as in @xcite one can prove the following result ( cf .
* lemma 3.2 ) and the corresponding proof ) : [ lemma : cycle_stationary ] let @xmath448 .
then the sequence of random pieces @xmath449 is stationary and ergodic under the measure @xmath450 . in particular , @xmath451 has the same law @xmath3 as @xmath1 for all @xmath452 . as in @xcite , the fact that @xmath453 is
stationary and ergodic can be restated as follows : under @xmath450 the random path @xmath454 with time points @xmath455 is _ cycle stationary and ergodic_. this is the regenerative structure pointed out in @xcite . in what follows
, we will consider also the random walk @xmath51 starting at @xmath107 and with law @xmath456 .
this random walk is built as follows .
fix @xmath457 such that @xmath458 .
then , the law of @xmath459 is defined by with @xmath221 replaced by @xmath457 and @xmath131 replaced by @xmath107 .
note that @xmath460 .
given @xmath461 and @xmath437 , the law of @xmath438}$ ] is then given by .
again , the average over @xmath441 of @xmath456 gives @xmath462 .
as in @xcite we set @xmath463 = e\left [ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ \cdot ] \right]\,.\ ] ] in what follows we assume that @xmath464 < \infty$ ] .
[ gnocchi ] let @xmath417 .
there exist constants @xmath285 not depending on @xmath465 such that @xmath466 \geq k_1 \rho \,,\label{basso}\\ & { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ' [ e^{\o,\zeta } _ 0[t _ { \ell_1\rho}]]\leq k_2 \big(\frac 1 { ( 1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d})^2 } + \frac{\rho}{1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d}}\big){{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr]\,.\label{eq : regeneration_bound}\end{aligned}\ ] ] take a sequence @xmath467 of i.i.d . positive random variables with @xmath468 for @xmath469 integer , @xmath273 being the constant appearing in lemma [ pierpaolo ] . due to this lemma , under @xmath470 , @xmath471 is stochastically dominated by @xmath472 for any @xmath473 .
hence , one can prove as in the derivation of the first inequality of ( 19 ) in @xcite .
we concentrate on . exactly like on page 731 , formulas ( 21 ) and ( 22 ) of @xcite , we also have that for any @xmath428 and for all @xmath474 @xmath475\leq\frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } e^{\o}_y[t_{(j+1)\rho}]\ ] ] for all @xmath476 .
when @xmath477 we can write @xmath478 now for each @xmath172 we have @xmath479 & = \sum_{y\in[j\rho,(j+1)\rho ) } e^{\o,\zeta}_y[t_{(j+1)\rho } ] \ , p^{\o,\zeta}_0(x_{t_{j\rho } } = y)\nonumber\\ & \leq \frac{1}{\varepsilon(1-\varepsilon)}\sum_{y\in[j\rho,(j+1)\rho)}e^{\o}_y[t_{(j+1)\rho}]\ , p^{\o,\zeta}_0(x_{t_{j\rho}}=y)\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used .
now we see that , for any @xmath480 , @xmath481 & \leq e^{\o}_y[n_\infty((-\infty,(j+1)\rho ] ) ] \nonumber\\ & \leq k\,e^{\o,1}_y[n_\infty((-\infty,(j+1)\rho ] ) ] \nonumber\\ & \leq k\,e^{\o,1}_{j\rho}[n_\infty((-\infty,(j+1)\rho ] ) ] \nonumber , \ ] ] where the second inequality is due to corollary [ cor : comparison_number_visits ] .
hence @xmath482 & \leq k\ , \frac{1}{\varepsilon(1-\varepsilon ) } e^{\o,1}_{j\rho}[n_\infty((-\infty,(j+1)\rho])]\nonumber\\ & \leq k\,\frac{1}{\varepsilon(1-\varepsilon)}\big(\sum_{z\leq j\rho } e^{\o,1}_{j\rho}[n_\infty(z ) ] + \sum_{j\rho < z\leq ( j+1)\rho } e^{\o,1}_{j\rho}[n_\infty(z)]\big)\nonumber\\ & = k\ , \frac{1}{\varepsilon(1-\varepsilon)}\big(\sum_{z\leq j\rho } e^{\o,1}_{j\rho}[n_\infty(z ) ] + \sum_{j\rho < z\leq ( j+1)\rho } e^{\o,1}_{z}[n_\infty(z)]\big)\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the results of lemma [ piccolino ] and corollary [ cor : comparison_number_visits ] we obtain for every @xmath172 @xmath483 & \leq k\,\frac{1}{\varepsilon(1-\varepsilon)}\big(\sum_{k\geq 0}{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ g_{\tau_{j\rho}\o}(k ) ] + \sum_{j\rho <
z\leq ( j+1)\rho}{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ g_{\tau_{z}\o}(0)]\big)\nonumber\\ & \leq k\,\frac{1}{\varepsilon(1-\varepsilon ) } \big(\frac 1 { ( 1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d})^2 } + \frac{\rho}{1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d}}\big){{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr]\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and hence @xmath484 \leq k\,\frac{k}{\varepsilon(1-\varepsilon ) } \big(\frac 1 { ( 1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d})^2 } + \frac{\rho}{1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d}}\big){{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr]\,.\ ] ] since @xmath485 , we obtain @xmath486\big ] & \leq k\ , \big(\frac 1 { ( 1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d})^2 } + \frac{\rho}{1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d}}\big){{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr ] \sum_{k=1}^\infty k\,(1-\varepsilon)^{k-2 } \nonumber\\ & = \bar k\ , \big(\frac 1 { ( 1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d})^2 } + \frac{\rho}{1-{\rm e}^{-2\l d}}\big ) { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl [ e^{(1-\l)x_1}\bigr]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall the definition of the function @xmath354 given in prop .
[ prop : function_g ] .
[ carnevale1 ] let @xmath416 . given @xmath487
it holds @xmath488 \leq \frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } \sum_{j=0}^\infty g_{\t_{j \rho } \o } ( |k|+j\rho)\,.\ ] ] as for the derivation of ( 33 ) in @xcite one can prove that , if @xmath489 , then @xmath490\leq \frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } e^\o_y \left [ n _ { [ t_{j \rho } , t_{(j+1 ) \rho } ) } ( k ) \right].\ ] ] on the other hand , by applying prop .
[ prop : function_g ] , we get @xmath491\leq e^\o_y \left [ n_\infty ( k ) \right]= e^{\t_y \o}_0 \left [ n_\infty ( k - y ) \right ] \leq g_{\t_y\o } ( |k|+y)\ , . \ ] ] at this point we write @xmath131 as @xmath492 and set @xmath493 . then , by applying in lemma [ piccolino ] , we get @xmath494 as a byproduct of , and we conclude that @xmath495\leq \frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } g_{\tau_{j \rho } \o } ( |k|+ j \rho)\,.\ ] ] the above bound and the strong markov property applied at time @xmath496 ( which holds by construction of @xmath497 ) imply that @xmath498 = e^{\o , \z}_0 \left [ e^{\o , \z } _ { x_{t_{j\rho } } } \left [ n _ { [ t_{j \rho } , t_{(j+1 ) \rho } ) } ( k ) \right ] \right ] \leq \frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } g_{\tau_{j \rho } \o } ( |k|+ j \rho)\,.\ ] ] since @xmath499 , the above bound implies .
recall that @xmath416 is fixed and recall warning [ olanda ] .
here we follow the usual notation , indicating explicitly @xmath43 , and we also write @xmath500 instead of @xmath440 to stress the dependence on @xmath43 .
[ prop_vel ] fix @xmath501 . for @xmath3a.a . @xmath502
it holds @xmath503}{{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ' [ e^{\o,\zeta}_0[t_{\ell_{1}\rho}^\rho ] ] } = \frac{\rho } { \e { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ' [ e^{\o,\zeta}_0[t_{\ell_{1}\rho}^\rho ] ] } \qquad p^{\o , \rho}_0\text{--a.s.}\ ] ] where @xmath425 is the same as in lemma [ lemma : epsilon ] .
moreover , @xmath504 does not depend on @xmath1 and @xmath505 for strictly positive constants @xmath506 , which do neither depend on @xmath55 nor on @xmath43 .
we work on the probability space @xmath507 where @xmath508 .
for @xmath509 we have @xmath510 ( note in particular that @xmath230 has to be thought as a function on @xmath511 ) .
it then follows @xmath512 due to the cycle stationarity and ergodicity stated in lemma [ lemma : cycle_stationary ] , we let @xmath513 in and obtain that the limit in holds @xmath514a.s . on the other hand @xmath515 . hence , by the dominated convergence theorem , @xmath516 $ ] converges to @xmath517}/{{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ' [ e^{\o,\zeta}_0[t_{\ell_{1}\rho}^\rho ] ] } $ ] . to conclude the proof of
, it is enough to recall that , by averaging @xmath518 over @xmath441 , one obtains the law @xmath519 of the original random walk @xmath520 .
finally , we observe that @xmath521 does not depend on @xmath1 since the last term in does nt , and that @xmath522 due to and .
in this section we assume that @xmath523 < \infty$ ] and we fix @xmath524 .
we consider the process _
environment viewed from the @xmath43walker _ , which is the markov chain @xmath525 on the space of environments @xmath526 with transition mechanism induced by @xmath527 .
when starting with initial distribution @xmath528 , we denote by @xmath529 its law as probability distribution on @xmath530 .
lemma [ lemma : cycle_stationary ] and bound in lemma [ gnocchi ] guarantee ( cf .
* sec . 4 , chapter 8) ) the existence of a stationary distribution @xmath45 of the process _
environment viewed from the @xmath43walker _ , such that @xmath45 is absolutely continuous with respect to @xmath3 . from @xcite[eq .
( 4.14 ) , chapter 8 ] , @xmath45 can be characterized by its expectation : @xmath531=\frac{1}{{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ' [ e_0^{\o,\zeta , \rho } [ t_{\ell_1\rho}]]}{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ' \big [ e^{\o,\zeta , \rho } _ 0\big[\sum_{k=1}^{t _ { \ell_1\rho}}f(\tau_{x_k } \o)\big]\big].\ ] ] as in @xcite[prop .
3.4 ] one can prove that @xmath45 is absolutely continuous to @xmath3 with radon nikodym derivative @xmath532}\sum _ { k \in { { \ensuremath{\mathbb z } } } } e e^{\t_{-k } \o , \z , \rho}_0 \left [ n_{t_{\ell_1 \rho } } ( k)\right]\,.\ ] ] note that the denominator in the r.h.s . is finite due to and the numerator is positive . as a consequence , @xmath3 is also absolutely continuous to @xmath45 .
[ lemma : ergodicity_q_rho ] fix @xmath533
. then @xmath45 is ergodic with respect to shifts for the environment seen from the @xmath43-walker .
[ caffettino]the above ergodicity means that any borel subset of the path space @xmath534 , which is left invariant by shifts , has @xmath535probability equal to @xmath331 or @xmath199 . due to theorem 6.9 in @xcite ( cf . also ( * ? ? ?
* chapter iv ) ) , the above ergodicity is equivalent to the following fact : @xmath536 whenever @xmath537 is an invariant borel set , in the sense that `` @xmath538 for any @xmath539 '' holds @xmath540a.s . on @xmath541 and
`` @xmath542 for any @xmath539 '' holds @xmath540a.s . on @xmath543 . as usual
, @xmath540 is the probability measure on @xmath544 such that the expectation of a function @xmath545 is given by @xmath546 $ ] .
the proof can be obtained as in @xcite .
the only difference is that in @xcite the authors use their formula ( 29 ) , which is not satisfied in our case .
more precisely , they use their formula ( 29 ) to argue that @xmath547 for any @xmath45nontrivial set @xmath250 . on the other hand
, this claim follows simply from the absolute continuity of @xmath548 to @xmath303 .
the rest of this section is devoted to the proof of the following result : [ digiuno ] suppose @xmath523 < \infty$ ] and that @xmath95 is continuous .
then the sequence @xmath549 converges weakly to a unique measure @xmath550 as @xmath49 .
@xmath550 is absolutely continuous to @xmath3 and , @xmath3a.s .
, @xmath551 ( cf . ) .
furthermore , @xmath30 is invariant and ergodic for the dynamics from the point of view of the @xmath552walker . on the path space
@xmath553 is ergodic with respect to shifts ( cf .
remark [ caffettino ] ) . ] having lemma [ pierpaolo ] and lemma [ chiave ] below , proposition [ digiuno ] can be proved by the same arguments used in @xcite , with some slight modifications . for completeness , we give the proof in appendix [ ape ] .
[ aereo ] suppose @xmath555 < \infty$ ] .
then , uniformly in @xmath556 , @xmath557 where @xmath558 for some constant @xmath191 .
moreover , @xmath559<\infty$ ] . before proving prop .
[ aereo ] we state a technical result : [ tennis ] let @xmath560 , with @xmath322 as in proposition [ prop : function_g ] . then @xmath561 the first inequality in is trivial .
we prove the second one . by and we can write @xmath562 we can now prove prop .
[ aereo ] : due to and we can bound , for some constant @xmath102 , @xmath563\ ] ] where @xmath564\ , , \qquad h_-(\o):= \sum _ { k \leq 0 } e e^{\t_{-k } \o , \z , \rho}_0 \left [ n_{t_{\ell_1 \rho } } ( k)\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a byproduct of lemma [ carnevale1 ] and lemma [ tennis ] it holds ( see the proof of for the equality below ) @xmath565
f_*(\t_{-k } \o)=\frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } \pi^1(0 ) \sum _ { k \leq 0 } { \rm e}^{- 2 \l x_{-k } } f_*(\t_{-k } \o ) \ , . \ ] ] let us bound @xmath566 .
we can write @xmath567 = \sum _ { m = 0 } ^\infty \sum _ { k \in [ m \rho , ( m+1 ) \rho ) } \sum_{i=1}^\infty e\ , \left [ \mathds{1}_{\ell_1=i } e^{\t_{-k } \o , \z,\rho}_0 \left [ n _ { t_{i \rho } } ( k ) \right ] \right]\\ & = \sum _ { m = 0 } ^\infty \sum _ { k \in [ m \rho , ( m+1 ) \rho ) } \sum_{i=1}^\infty \sum
_ { j=0}^i e\,\left [ \mathds{1}_{\ell_1=i } e^{\t_{-k } \o , \z,\rho}_0 \left [ n _ { [ t_{j\rho } , t_{(j+1 ) \rho } ) } ( k ) \right ] \right]\ , .
\end{split}\ ] ] note that , given @xmath568 and @xmath569 , it holds @xmath570 , hence in the last expression of we can restrict to @xmath571 .
moreover note that ( cf . )
@xmath572 \leq \frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } e^{\t_{-k } \o , \rho}_0 \left [ n _ { [ t_{j\rho } , t_{(j+1 ) \rho } ) } ( k ) \right]\,.\ ] ] consider then the case @xmath573 with @xmath571 .
note that @xmath574 due to the maximal length of the jump .
fix @xmath575 .
then , for any environment @xmath1 , we have @xmath576= e^ { \o , \rho}_y\left [ n _ { t_{(j+1 ) \rho } } ( k ) \right ] \leq \begin{cases } g _
{ \t_k \o } ( 0 ) & \text { if } j = m\,,\\ g_{\t_{j\rho}\o } ( j\rho - k ) & \text { if } j > m\ , .
\end{cases}\ ] ] indeed , consider first the case @xmath577 .
then @xmath578 and by prop .
[ prop : function_g ] @xmath579 \leq e^ { \o , \rho}_y\left [ n _ { t_\infty } ( k ) \right]= e^ { \t_y\o , \rho}_0\left [ n _ { t_\infty } ( k - y ) \right ] \leq g_{\t_y \o } ( y - k)\ ] ] write @xmath580 and @xmath581
. then we have @xmath582 ( in the last step we have used ) .
this proves for @xmath577 . if @xmath583 we bound ( by the markov property at the first visit of @xmath138 ) @xmath584 \leq e^ { \o , \rho}_y\left [ n _ { t_\infty } ( k ) \right]\leq
e^ { \o , \rho}_k \left [ n _ { t_\infty } ( k ) \right ] = e^ { \t_k\o , \rho}_0 \left [ n _ { t_\infty } ( 0 ) \right]\,.\ ] ] at this point for @xmath583 follows from prop .
[ prop : function_g ] .
the above bound , the markov property and imply @xmath585 \leq \frac{1}{\e(1-\e ) } \cdot \begin{cases } g _
{ \o } ( 0 ) & \text { if } j = m\,,\\ g_{\t_{j\rho - k}\o } ( j\rho - k ) & \text { if } j > m\ , .
\end{cases}\ ] ] coming back to and due to the above observations we can bound @xmath586 \leq a(\o)+b(\o)\,,\ ] ] where ( distinguishing the cases @xmath587 and @xmath588 ) @xmath589 g_\o(0 ) = \rho \left ( e(\ell_1)+1\right ) g_\o(0)\ , , \\ & b(\o):=\sum_{i=1}^\infty \sum _ { j=1 } ^i \sum _ { m = 0 } ^{j-1 } \sum _ { k \in [ m \rho , ( m+1 ) \rho ) } e\ , \left [ \mathds{1}_{\ell_1=i}\right ] g_{\t_{j\rho - k}\o } ( j\rho - k ) \,.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] for what concerns @xmath590 observe that @xmath591 = ( 1-\e)^{j-1}$ ] , hence@xmath592 since , by , @xmath593 , we get that @xmath594 . combining this estimate with
we conclude that @xmath595 .
coming back to and we have @xmath596 since @xmath597 , by definition of @xmath598 ( and setting @xmath599 ) we can write @xmath600 as byproduct of and we get . finally , by using and that @xmath601 for @xmath602 , we can bound @xmath559 \leq c \sum _ { j\geq 0 } ( j+2)^2 { \rm e}^{-2 \l j } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ { \rm e } ^{(1-\l ) x_1 } ] $ ] . since by assumption @xmath603 < \infty$ ] , we conclude that @xmath559 < \infty$ ] .
we remark that , following the proof of proposition 3.4 in @xcite , we could easily obtain a lower bound on @xmath554 which is independent of @xmath43 , but which would in principle depend on the particular argument @xmath1 . here
we will do more : we will exhibit a lower bound that is uniform in both @xmath43 and @xmath1 ( see corollary [ cor : rn_lower_bound ] below ) . for fixed @xmath502 ,
we denote by @xmath604 the empirical measure at time @xmath37 for the environment viewed from the @xmath43walker .
more precisely , @xmath604 is a random probability measure on @xmath75 defined as @xmath605 averaging over the paths of the walk we obtain the probability @xmath606 $ ] . for fixed @xmath502 , we define another probability measure on @xmath526 , given by @xmath607 where @xmath608 and @xmath521 is the positive limiting speed of the truncated random walk given in ( we are omitting the dependence on @xmath104 ; the @xmath195 could be replaced by any other constant smaller than 1 ) .
we remark that @xmath609 and @xmath606 $ ] can be thought of as random variables on @xmath610 with values in @xmath611 , the space of probability measures on @xmath75 endowed with the weak topology .
note also that @xmath612 .
furthermore , @xmath604 can be thought of as a random variable on the probability space @xmath613 with values in @xmath611 .
[ prop : convergences ] for @xmath3almost every @xmath502 we have that @xmath614 and @xmath615\rightarrow { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\rho$ ] weakly in @xmath611 .
moreover , @xmath616-a.s .
, we have that @xmath617 weakly in @xmath611 . the a.s .
convergence of @xmath618 to @xmath3 comes directly from the ergodicity of @xmath3 with respect to shifts .
we claim that @xmath617 weakly in @xmath611 , @xmath619-a.s .
this follows from birkhoff s ergodic theorem applied to the markov chain @xmath620 starting from the ergodic distribution @xmath45 ( cf .
lemma [ lemma : ergodicity_q_rho ] ) . as already observed after equation
, @xmath3 is absolutely continuous to @xmath45 .
hence , due to the above claim , @xmath617 weakly in @xmath611 also @xmath616-a.s . finally , the last a.s . convergence and the dominated convergence theorem imply that @xmath621\rightarrow { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\rho$ ] weakly in @xmath611 , @xmath3a.s .
[ lemma : finite_n_derivative ] there exists @xmath622 , depending neither on @xmath55 nor on @xmath43 , such that the following holds : for @xmath3-almost every @xmath55 , there exists an @xmath623 such that , @xmath624 , @xmath625 } { r^\o_n(\tau_k\o)}>\gamma\ , , \qquad k=1, ... ,m(n)\,.\ ] ] for all @xmath626 , we have @xmath627 \geq \frac 1n p^{\o,\rho}_0 ( \exists j\leq n:\,x_j = k ) \d_{\tau_k\omega}\ , .\ ] ] we claim that , for @xmath37 big enough and @xmath626 , it holds @xmath628 where @xmath405 is the same as in lemma [ lemma : epsilon ] . to prove our claim , we bound @xmath629 where in the last line
we have used lemma [ lemma : epsilon ] . on the other hand ,
we also know , by the definition of the limiting speed , that for almost every @xmath630 , there exists an @xmath623 such that , @xmath631 , @xmath632 .
this completes the proof of the claim . hence ,
putting together and , for all @xmath633 and @xmath626 , we have @xmath634 \geq \frac \varepsilon n \d_{\tau_k\omega}\ , .\ ] ] on the other hand , by definition , @xmath635 for all @xmath626 and for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 ( since periodic environments have @xmath3measure zero by assumption ( a3 ) ) .
it then follows that , for all @xmath626 and for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 , @xmath636 } { r^\o_n(\tau_k\o)}\geq \frac{\tfrac \varepsilon n}{\tfrac 1{m(n)}}=\frac{\varepsilon { v_{{}_{x^\rho } } } } 2 \geq \frac{\varepsilon c_1 } 2 = : \gamma>0,\ ] ] where @xmath637 is from .
note that @xmath638 does not depend on @xmath55 .
we finally need to show that the lower bound extends also to the radon - nikodym derivative of the limiting measures .
[ cor : rn_lower_bound ] the radon - nikodym derivative @xmath639 is uniformly bounded from below : @xmath640 , where @xmath638 is from .
take any @xmath641 continuous and bounded .
lemma [ lemma : finite_n_derivative ] and the fact that @xmath642 has support in @xmath643 guarantee that , for all @xmath37 large enough , @xmath644 \geq \gamma r^\o_n(f ) \qquad \text{for $ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb p } } } $ --a.e.~}\o\,.\ ] ] passing to the limit @xmath513 , and observing that , by proposition [ prop : convergences ] , @xmath645\to { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\rho(f)$ ] and @xmath646 for @xmath3a.e .
@xmath1 , we have that @xmath647 .
the claim follows from the arbitrariness of @xmath545 .
recall the definition of the function @xmath649 given in and of the constant @xmath148 given in corollary [ cor : rn_lower_bound ] .
[ chiave ] suppose @xmath523 < \infty$ ] .
then the following holds : * the family of probability measures @xmath650 is tight ; * any subsequential limit @xmath550 of @xmath650 is absolutely continuous to @xmath3 and @xmath651 for proving part ( i ) , fix an increasing sequence of compact subsets @xmath652 exhausting all of @xmath75 . thanks to proposition [ aereo ] we have @xmath653 \leq { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \left [ f \mathds{1 } _
{ k_n^c } \right]\,.\ ] ] setting @xmath654 we have that @xmath655 and @xmath656 everywhere . by the dominated convergence theorem , given @xmath410
we conclude that @xmath657 eventually in @xmath37 , hence the tightness .
we turn now to ( ii ) . by prohorov s theorem
there exists a sequence @xmath658 such that @xmath659 converges weakly to some probability measure @xmath30 .
we want to prove the absolute continuity of @xmath30 with respect to @xmath3 .
to this aim fix a measurable set @xmath537 with @xmath660 .
we need to show that @xmath661 . due to @xcite[thm .
1.1 ] , for each integer @xmath662 there exists an open subset @xmath663 with @xmath664 and @xmath665 . due to the portmanteau theorem ( cf .
@xcite[thm . 2.1 ] ) we conclude that @xmath666 \leq { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \left[f \mathds{1 } _ { g_m } \right ] \,.\ ] ] since the sequence of subsets @xmath667 can be taken decreasing and since @xmath668 ( cf
. prop .
[ aereo ] ) , we derive that the r.h.s .
of goes to zero as @xmath669 by the dominated convergence theorem .
this proves that @xmath661 , thus implying that @xmath670 .
let us prove that @xmath671 , @xmath3a.s . to this aim
we take @xmath672 open . by the portmanteau theorem
, we have @xmath673 . on the other hand , @xmath674 \leq { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ f \mathds{1}_g]$ ] . hence @xmath675 -{{\ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\infty(g ) = { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \big [ \big(f- \frac{d { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\infty}{d { { \ensuremath{\mathbb p } } } } \big ) \mathds{1}_g\big ] \geq 0\ ] ] for any @xmath676 open
. suppose by contradiction that @xmath677 where @xmath678 .
by @xcite[thm .
1.1 ] there exists a decreasing sequence @xmath679 of open subsets such that @xmath680 and @xmath681 for any @xmath682 .
the last bound implies that @xmath683 in @xmath684 as @xmath669 , hence at the cost of extracting a subsequence we can assume that @xmath683 @xmath3a.s .
as @xmath669 . by applying now the dominated convergence theorem we conclude that @xmath685 = { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ ( f- \frac{d { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\infty } { d { { \ensuremath{\mathbb p } } } } ) \mathds{1}_a ] $ ] . by definition of @xmath250 and since @xmath686 , it must be @xmath687<0 $ ] .
on the other hand , due to , @xmath688 \geq 0 $ ] , thus leading to a contradiction .
the proof that @xmath689 , @xmath3a.s .
, follows similar arguments .
in particular , by the portmanteau theorem , one gets that @xmath690 for all @xmath691 closed .
moreover , by @xcite[thm .
1.1 ] , for any @xmath537 borel there exists an increasing sequence @xmath692 of closed sets such that @xmath693 and @xmath694 .
by the discussion at the end of section [ zetino ] , it is enough to show the a.s .
transience to the right of @xmath695 and @xmath696 . since the former is the jump chain associated to the latter , we only need to derive the a.s .
transience to the right of @xmath695 . to this aim , it is sufficient to show that , for any @xmath697 , there exists some @xmath698 such that @xmath699 for all @xmath700 .
first of all notice that , by proposition [ prop : function_g ] , for @xmath3almost every @xmath701 and @xmath702 we have @xmath703 ) ] & \leq \sum_{k=0}^\infty g _ { \t_i \o}(k ) \nonumber\\ & = k_0 \big ( \sum_{k=0}^\infty k_0 \pi^1 ( -k ) [ \t_i \o ] \big ) \cdot \big ( \sum _ { j=0}^\infty e^{-2\l x_j ( \t_i \o ) + ( 1-\l)(x_{j+1}(\t_i\o ) -x_j(\t_i\o ) ) } \big ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is @xmath704almost surely finite ( see and the discussion after prop . [ prop : function_g ] ) . hence @xmath705)<\infty)=1.\ ]
] now fix @xmath697 and consider @xmath706 , the first time the random walk is larger or equal than @xmath682 . applying the markov property at time @xmath706 and using one
gets the claim .
in this section we assume that @xmath707 < + \infty$ ] and that @xmath708 is continuous . recall that @xmath709 and @xmath144 denote the continuous time mott random walk and the associated jump process , respectively .
recall also the definition of the markov chains @xmath710 and @xmath711 , given in section [ zetino ] and that @xmath529 is the law of the process _ environment viewed from the @xmath43walker _
@xmath525 when started with some initial distribution @xmath528 . given @xmath247 , by writing @xmath712 as a functional of @xmath525 and using the ergodicity of @xmath45 ( cf .
lemma [ lemma : ergodicity_q_rho ] and proposition [ digiuno ] ) we get that the asymptotic velocity of @xmath713 exists @xmath535a.s . and therefore @xmath714a.s .
since @xmath45 and @xmath3 are mutually absolutely continuous : @xmath715 moreover , @xmath716 does not depend on @xmath1 and can be characterized as @xmath717\big]={{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^\rho\big[\sum_{m\in{{\ensuremath{\mathbb z } } } } m\,p^{\o,\rho}_0(x_1=m)\big],\qquad \forall \rho \in { { \ensuremath{\mathbb n } } } _ + \cup \{+\infty\}\,.\ ] ] here , @xmath718 denotes the expectation with respect to @xmath45 .
recall that for @xmath417 we have also an alternative representation for @xmath719 ( see proposition [ prop_vel ] ) .
we now prove that @xmath720 by the exponential decay of the jump probabilities ( see ) , for all @xmath721 there exists @xmath722 such that , for all @xmath43 , @xmath723 we now observe that , for @xmath724 , we have @xmath725 and the r.h.s . of is continuous in @xmath1 due to the continuity assumption on @xmath20 and since @xmath726 .
since @xmath727 , it is now simple to get . finally , we also have that @xmath728 $ ] because of the limit and since , by proposition [ prop_vel ] , @xmath729 for suitable strictly positive constants @xmath506 . by the previous observations and by the second identity in , we also obtain that the limit @xmath730 exists @xmath731a.s . and
equals @xmath80 v_{x^\infty } ( \l ) $ ] . as a consequence , @xmath197 is deterministic , finite and strictly positive . by a suitable time change
we can recover the lln for @xmath732 from the lln for @xmath733 as follows . by enlarging the probability space @xmath734 with a product space ,
we introduce a sequence of i.i.d .
exponential random variables @xmath735 of mean one , all independent from the process _
environment viewed from the @xmath552walker _ @xmath736 .
we call @xmath737 the resulting probability space
. note that @xmath738 is stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts .
on @xmath737 we define the random variable @xmath739= \sum _ { k \in { { \ensuremath{\mathbb z } } } } c_{0,k } ( \o ) \,.\ ] ] we note that @xmath740 coincides with @xmath741 of section [ notazione ] . by the ergodicity of @xmath738 we have @xmath742 \qquad \bar { \ensuremath{\mathcal p}}^\infty _ { { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\infty}\text{--a.s.}\ ] ] since , by proposition [ digiuno ] , @xmath743 and @xmath744 with @xmath649 defined in , using lemma [ lorenzo ] , assumption ( a4 ) and the hypothesis
@xmath745 < + \infty$ ] we get @xmath746 & \leq k \,{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \big[\frac { \pi^1(0)}{r } \sum_{j=0}^\infty ( j + 2)^2{\rm e}^{-2\l x_j + ( 1-\l ) ( x_{j+1}-x_{j } ) } \big]\\ & \leq k ' \sum _ { j=0}^\infty ( j+2)^2 e^{- 2 \l d } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ { \rm e}^{(1-\l ) z_0 } ] < + \infty\ ,
. \end{split}\ ] ] for any @xmath747 we define @xmath748 on @xmath737 as the only integer @xmath37 such that @xmath749 . by and we get that @xmath750 as @xmath751 , @xmath752 as a byproduct of the above limit , of and the bound @xmath753 we conclude that @xmath754 } \qquad \bar { \ensuremath{\mathcal p}}^\infty _ { { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\infty}\text{--a.s.}\ ] ] by writing @xmath755 , from and we get that @xmath756}\ , , \qquad \bar { \ensuremath{\mathcal p}}^\infty _ { { { \ensuremath{\mathbb q } } } ^\infty}\text{--a.s.}\ ] ] at this point it is enough to observe that the process @xmath757 defined on the probability space @xmath737 has the same law as the process @xmath732 .
using also and the fact that @xmath758 , we conclude that @xmath759}\in ( 0,+\infty)\ ] ] holds @xmath760a.s .
, for @xmath3a.e .
@xmath1 . finally , using
, we conclude that @xmath761 } v_{x ^\infty}(\l ) \in ( 0,+\infty)\ ] ] holds for almost all trajectories of the mott random walk , for @xmath3a.e . @xmath1 . as already observed , the r.h.s .
of is deterministic and this concludes the proof of theorem [ teo1](ii ) and its counterpart for the jump process @xmath144 ( cf . ) .
first we point out that it will be sufficient to prove that @xmath762 a.s . , for @xmath3a.e .
realization of the environment @xmath1 : recall the identities and of section [ zetino ] . by assumptions ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) , @xmath240<\infty $ ] , @xmath3a.s .. on the other hand , as proved in section [ proof_transience ] , the random walks @xmath695 and @xmath696 are a.s .
transient to the right . as a byproduct , due to and , we have @xmath763 , @xmath127 whenever @xmath762 , @xmath764 , respectively .
but we also have that @xmath762 implies @xmath765 . indeed ,
the continuous time random walk @xmath766 is obtained from the discrete time random walk @xmath733 by the rule that , when site @xmath138 is reached , @xmath767 remains at @xmath138 for an exponential time with parameter @xmath768 . since @xmath769 ( cf .
section [ notazione ] ) , we can speed up @xmath767 by replacing all parameters @xmath768 by @xmath50 .
the resulting random walk can be realized as @xmath770 where @xmath771 is a poisson process with intensity @xmath50 .
hence , its velocity is zero whenever @xmath762 .
we first show in proposition [ scarola ] a sufficient condition for @xmath762 . in corollary [ cor:0_speed ]
we prove that this condition is equivalent to the hypothesis of theorem [ teo1](iii ) and in corollary [ cor : iid_0_speed ] we discuss some stronger conditions corresponding to the last statement in theorem [ teo1](iii ) .
[ scarola ] suppose that @xmath772=\infty.\ ] ] then @xmath773 . a basic tool in the proof of the above proposition will be the following coupling : [ cicoria ] for a distribution function @xmath774 and a value @xmath775 $ ] , define the function @xmath776 let @xmath649 and @xmath777 be two distribution functions such that @xmath778 for all @xmath779 . take @xmath780 to be a uniform random variable on @xmath781 $ ] and let @xmath782 and @xmath783 then @xmath237 is distributed according to @xmath649 , @xmath784 is distributed according to @xmath777 and @xmath785 almost surely .
the proof of the above fact can be found in @xcite .
usually , as in @xcite , the quantile coupling is defined with @xmath786 instead of @xmath787 , where @xmath786 is the quantile function @xmath788 .
one can easily prove that @xmath789 a.s .
call @xmath790 the distribution function of the random variable @xmath791 , where @xmath792 is some constant such that @xmath793 and @xmath774 is a geometric random variable with parameter @xmath794 . note that given an integer @xmath457 it holds @xmath795 in particular , given an integer @xmath796 , due to we have @xmath797 we will now inductively construct a sequence of probability spaces @xmath798^n , p^{(n)})$ ] , on which we will define some random variables . .
we first consider the space @xmath799 $ ] , the generic element of which is denoted by @xmath800 .
we introduce a probability @xmath801 on @xmath799 $ ] by the following rules .
the marginal of @xmath801 on @xmath802 is @xmath3 , its marginal on @xmath781 $ ] is the uniform distribution and , under @xmath801 , the coordinate functions @xmath803 and @xmath804 are independent random variables .
finally , we require that @xmath805 for any measurable set @xmath806 , where @xmath807 is the second coordinate function @xmath808 and @xmath809 from now on we consider the space @xmath799 $ ] endowed with the probability @xmath801 .
it is convenient to introduce the random variables @xmath810 defined as follows , without introducing a new symbol . ]
: @xmath811 note that , by the quantile coupling ( cf .
lemma [ cicoria ] ) , @xmath812 is distributed as @xmath813 and @xmath814 under @xmath815 is distributed as @xmath816 under @xmath760 . the interpretation to keep in mind is the following : @xmath807 plays the role of our initial random walk in environment @xmath1 ; @xmath814 is the overshoot at time @xmath817 , i.e. how far from @xmath331 the random walk will land the first time it jumps beyond the point @xmath331 ; @xmath812 is a positive random variable that dominates @xmath814 ( see claim [ strazietto ] ) and that is distributed like @xmath813 .
[ adriana ] for any integer @xmath818 it holds @xmath819 given @xmath436 and integers @xmath820 we denote by + @xmath821 the event @xmath822 .
note that , by the markov property , @xmath823 by the above identity we can write @xmath824 [ strazietto ] the following holds : * @xmath825 ; * @xmath812 is independent of @xmath55 under @xmath801 ; * @xmath826 for each measurable set @xmath827 . in order to show ( i ) , we just have to prove that @xmath828 for all @xmath502 and @xmath779 ( in fact , it is enough to prove it for all @xmath829 ) thanks to lemma [ cicoria ] .
to this aim , recall the definition of @xmath830 ( see ) and notice that for all @xmath630 and all integers @xmath796 , one has @xmath831 where in the first line we have used claim [ adriana ] and in the last bound we have used and the fact that @xmath796 .
this proves that @xmath832 for all @xmath833 with @xmath834 .
the same inequality trivially holds also for @xmath835 since in this case @xmath836 ( because @xmath837 ) .
part ( ii ) is clear since @xmath812 is determined only by @xmath838 , while @xmath838 and @xmath1 are independent by construction .
for part ( iii ) take some measurable set @xmath827 and notice that ( recalling and the independence of @xmath55 and @xmath839 ) @xmath840}p^{(1)}(x^{(1)}_\cdot \in b|\,\o,\,u_1=u_1 ) p^{(1)}(u_1\in{\rm d}u_1)\\ & = \int_{[0,1]}p^{\o,\infty } _ 0(x_\cdot \in b|\,x_{t_1}=\phi(f^{(1)}_\o , u_1 ) ) \,{\rm d}u_1\\ & = \sum_{j=1}^\infty p^{\o,\infty}_0(x_\cdot \in b|\,x_{t_1}=j)p^{\o,\infty } _
0(x_{t_1}=j)=p^{\o,\infty}_0(x_\cdot \in b)\ , . \qedhere\end{aligned}\ ] ] .
suppose now we have achieved our construction up to step @xmath138 . in particular , we have built the probability @xmath841 on the space @xmath799^{k}$ ] and several random variables on @xmath842^{k } , p^{(k)})$ ] that we list : * @xmath843 are independent and uniformly distributed random variables such that @xmath844 is the projection function on @xmath781^k$ ] ; * @xmath845 is defined as @xmath846 , @xmath847 ; * @xmath848 , defined as the projection function on @xmath849 , whose law under @xmath850 is @xmath851 ; * @xmath852 such that @xmath853 .
( 5,5)(0,1 ) ( -2,0 ) is the first time the random walk overjumps the point @xmath854 .
the overshoot @xmath855 is dominated by @xmath856 by construction .
_ , title="fig : " ] ( 0.5,2.7)@xmath857 ( 3.9,2.7)@xmath62 ( -1.7,2.7)@xmath858 ( 1.6,2.7)@xmath859 ( 4.65,2.7)@xmath860 ( 2.8,1.9)@xmath855 ( 3.3,1.1)@xmath856 we introduce a probability @xmath861 on @xmath799^{k+1}$ ] by the following rules .
the marginal of @xmath861 on @xmath802 is @xmath3 , its marginal on @xmath781^{k+1}$ ] is the uniform distribution and , under @xmath861 , the projection functions @xmath862 and @xmath863 are independent random variables . finally , we require that @xmath864 for any measurable set @xmath806 , where @xmath865 note that @xmath866 is a random variable on @xmath867^{k } , p^{(k)})$ ] .
we stress that the conditional probability in the r.h.s . of
has to be thought of as the regular conditional probability @xmath868 further conditioned on the event @xmath869 .
[ strazio1 ] the marginal of @xmath861 on @xmath799^{k}$ ] is exactly @xmath841 .
since the marginal of @xmath861 along the coordinate @xmath870 is the uniform distribution , by integrating over @xmath870 , we get @xmath871 above we have used lemma [ cicoria ] to deduce that @xmath872 has integer values .
applying again lemma [ cicoria ] and the definition of @xmath873 we have @xmath874 plugging into , we get @xmath875 on the other hand , the projections of @xmath876 and @xmath841 on @xmath877^k$ ] , i.e. along the coordinates @xmath878 , are equal by construction , thus concluding the proof of our claim . due to the above claim , any random variable @xmath237 defined on @xmath879^{k } , p^{(k)})$ ] can be thought of as a random variable on @xmath879^{k+1 } , p^{(k+1)})$ ] , by considering the map @xmath880 . with some abuse of notation ,
we denote by @xmath237 also the last random variable . as a consequence
, @xmath881 can be thought as random variables on @xmath879^{k+1 } , p^{(k+1)})$ ] .
finally , we introduce the new random variables @xmath882 on @xmath879^{k+1 } , p^{(k+1)})$ ] defined as @xmath883 the interpretation is similar as in step 1 : @xmath884 is the overshoot at time @xmath56 , i.e. how far from @xmath859 the random walk will land the first time it jumps beyond that point ; @xmath885 is a positive random variable that dominates @xmath884 ( see claim [ mega_strazio ] ) and that is distributed as @xmath813 . [ mega_strazio ] the following three facts hold true : * @xmath886 ; * @xmath885 is independent of @xmath887 under @xmath861 ; * for each measurable set @xmath827 , @xmath888 the three facts can be proved in a similar way as claim [ strazietto ] .
we give the proof for completeness . for part ( i )
we want to show that @xmath889 for all @xmath796 , with @xmath890 .
in fact , as for claim [ strazietto ] , this inequality can easily be extended to all @xmath891 and the conclusion follows .
first of all we notice that , by iteratively applying and using claim [ strazietto](iii ) , we have @xmath892 where we have used the shortened notation @xmath893 and @xmath894 is the event @xmath895 for convenience we call@xmath896 we also note that @xmath897 @xmath841a.s .
( see the list of properties at the beginning of step @xmath898 ) .
coming back to , by using the strong markov property , we obtain ( see also the proof of claim [ adriana ] ) @xmath899 the last inequality follows by conditioning to the position of the random walk at time @xmath900 . knowing this
, we can proceed as in getting that the last term in is bounded from above by @xmath901 .
this concludes the proof of part ( i ) .
part ( ii ) is clear by the construction of @xmath885 .
finally , we prove part ( iii ) . since the projections of @xmath876 and of @xmath841 on @xmath781^k$ ] , i.e. along the coordinates @xmath902 , are both the uniform distribution on @xmath781^k$ ] , integrating over @xmath902 we get @xmath903 .
the claim then follows by the induction hypothesis ( see the discussion at the beginning of step @xmath904 ) . due to the results discussed above , the list of properties at the beginning of step @xmath898 is valid also for @xmath861 .
: by the ionescu - tulcea extension theorem , there exists a measure @xmath905 on the space @xmath906^{{\ensuremath{\mathbb n } } } $ ] , random variables @xmath907 , @xmath908 , @xmath909 and a random walk @xmath910 , such that : for all measurable @xmath911 , @xmath912 ; the @xmath913 s are i.i.d .
, distributed like @xmath813 and independent of @xmath1 ; @xmath914 ; @xmath915 ; for all measurable @xmath916 , @xmath917 .
we are now ready to finish the proof .
notice that , under @xmath918 , the differences @xmath919 have a rather complicated structure , but they stochastically dominate a sequence of pretty simple objects , call them @xmath920 .
each @xmath58 is a geometric random variable of parameter @xmath921 in fact , due to lemma [ lemma : epsilon ] , we can imagine that for each @xmath922 the random walk `` attempts '' to overjump @xmath854 and manages to do so with a probability that is clearly smaller than @xmath923 .
by strassen s theorem , on an enlarged probability space with new probability @xmath924 , we can couple each @xmath58 with @xmath925 so that @xmath926 almost surely .
moreover , due to the strong markov property of the random walk , all the @xmath58 s can be taken independent once we have fixed the parameters @xmath923 s .
now note the key fact that , since the @xmath927 s are independent of the environment and that the gcd of the values attained with positive probability by the @xmath927 s is @xmath199 , the shifts @xmath928 form a stationary ergodic sequence under @xmath905 .
we refer to appendix [ appendix : ergodic ] for a proof of this fact ( see lemma [ pasquetta ] ) .
this observation allows to prove that @xmath929 is a stationary ergodic sequence with respect to shifts under @xmath924 ( see lemma [ luce ] in appendix [ appendix : ergodic ] ) .
we now take @xmath930 such that @xmath931 @xmath932a.s .
( which holds for @xmath3a.a . @xmath1 by theorem [ teo1](i ) ) .
this implies that @xmath933 , @xmath932a.s .
we can bound ( see ) @xmath934 let us concentrate on the last line .
the arithmetic mean of @xmath935 converges almost surely to @xmath936 , the mean of @xmath813 , by the law of large numbers .
the arithmetic mean of @xmath937 converges instead to @xmath938 $ ] because of the ergodic theorem ( for simplicity , we write simply @xmath22 for the expectation with respect to @xmath939 ) . since @xmath938={{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ s_0|s_0]]={{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ \tfrac 1{s_0}]=\infty$ ] by assumption , we obtain that @xmath940 for almost all @xmath941 .
taking into account that @xmath933 , @xmath932a.s .
, we get that @xmath942 , @xmath932a.s .
[ cor:0_speed ] condition is equivalent to @xmath943=\infty\,.\ ] ] we want to show that condition implies .
first of all , we claim that for all @xmath701 and @xmath944 we have @xmath945 in fact , @xmath946 and @xmath947 hence , is satisfied if @xmath948 which is true if and only if @xmath949 simplifying the expression ( the terms with @xmath172 cancel out ) , the last display is equivalent to @xmath950 and the last inequality clearly holds since the l.h.s .
terms dominate one by one the r.h.s . ones . shows that @xmath951 for a constant @xmath50 which does not depend on @xmath1 . on the other hand , using estimates and , @xmath952 for constants @xmath953 , @xmath954 , @xmath955 , @xmath956 which do not depend on @xmath1 .
hence , we have @xmath957=\infty \ , \longleftrightarrow \ , { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ { \rm e}^{(1-\l)z_0-(1+\l)z_{-1 } } ] = \infty$ ] .
[ cor : iid_0_speed ] suppose that @xmath125\leq c$ ] for some constant which does not depend on @xmath1 ( e.g. if the @xmath958 are i.i.d . ) and that @xmath959=\infty$ ] .
then condition is satisfied and in particular @xmath960 .
conditioning on @xmath961 and using jensen s inequality , we get @xmath962 & = { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl[{\rm e}^{(1-\l)z_0 } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ { \rm e}^{-(1+\l)z_{-1}}| z_0]\bigr]\geq { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } \bigl[{\rm e}^{(1-\l)z_0 } { \rm e}^{-(1+\l){{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ z_{-1 } | z_0 ] } \bigr ] \\ & \geq { \rm e } ^{-(1+\l ) c } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } [ { \rm e}^{(1-\l)z_0 } ] = \infty\,.\qedhere \end{split}\ ] ]
by the tightness stated in lemma [ chiave ] , @xmath963 admits some limit point and any limit point @xmath30 is absolutely continuous to @xmath3 , with radon nikodym derivative @xmath964 bounded by @xmath649 from above and by @xmath148 from below .
we now show that any limit point is an invariant distribution of the process given by the environment viewed from the walker without truncation @xmath965 . to this end , let @xmath966 be a subsequence weakly converging to some probability @xmath30 on @xmath75 .
we take a bounded continuous function @xmath545 on @xmath526 ( without loss of generality we assume @xmath967 ) and we write @xmath968-{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^\infty e^{\o,\infty}_0[f(\tau_{x_1 } \omega)]\big| \leq & \,\big|{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^\infty[f(\omega)]-{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\rho_k}[f(\omega)]\big|\nonumber\\ & + \big|{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\rho_k } e^{\o,\rho_k}_0[f(\tau_{x_1}\omega ) ] -{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\infty}e^{\o,\rho_k } _ 0[f(\tau_{x_1}\omega)]\big|\nonumber\\ & + \big|{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\infty}e^{\o,\rho_k}_0[f(\tau_{x_1}\omega ) ] - { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\infty}e^{\o,\infty } _ 0[f(\tau_{x_1}\omega)]\big|\nonumber\\ = : & b_1+b_2+b_3\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] above , @xmath969 is the expectation with respect to the measure @xmath30 and in the second line we have used the fact that @xmath970 , the expectation with respect to the measure @xmath659 , is invariant for the process @xmath971 .
the term @xmath972 goes to zero as @xmath973 since @xmath974 . to deal with term @xmath975
we observe that , by lemma [ pierpaolo ] , for any @xmath721 there exists @xmath976 such that , for any @xmath977 , @xmath978 then , for @xmath979 , we write @xmath980- { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\infty}\big[\sum_{|j|\leq h_0}p^{\o,\rho_k}_0(x_1=j)f(\tau_{j}\omega ) \big ] \big| + 2\delta\\ \leq & \big |{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\rho_k}\big[\sum_{|j|\leq h_0}p^{\o,\infty}_0(x_1=j)f(\tau_{j}\omega ) \big]- { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\infty}\big[\sum_{|j|\leq h_0}p^{\o,\infty}_0(x_1=j)f(\tau_{j}\omega)\big ] \big| \\ & + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\rho_k}\big [ p^{\o,\infty}_0(|x_1|>h_0)\big ] + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\infty}\big [ p^{\o,\infty}_0(|x_1|>h_0 ) \big ] + 2\delta\\ \leq & \big |{{\ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\rho_k}\big[\sum_{|j|\leq h_0}p^{\o,\infty}_0(x_1=j)f(\tau_{j}\omega ) \big]- { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } ^{\infty}\big[\sum_{|j|\leq h_0}p^{\o,\infty}_0(x_1=j)f(\tau_{j}\omega)\big ] \big|+4\d\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that we have used in the first and third estimates .
for the second bound we have used that @xmath981 , @xmath982 for @xmath983 , while @xmath984 and @xmath985 ( cf . ) . by the continuity assumption on @xmath20 and since @xmath986 ,
the map @xmath987 is continuous .
hence , using that @xmath659 converges to @xmath30 as @xmath988 , we can choose @xmath138 large enough so that @xmath989 .
@xmath990 is also smaller than @xmath991 for @xmath138 big enough , again by .
altogether , letting @xmath992 , implies that @xmath30 is invariant for @xmath993 with transition mechanism induced by @xmath994 . having that @xmath670 , the ergodicity of @xmath30 can be proved in the same way as lemma [ lemma : ergodicity_q_rho ] .
it remains to prove uniqueness of the limit point . to this aim ,
take two limit points @xmath550 and @xmath995 of @xmath996 . recall that we write @xmath997 and @xmath998 for the law on the path space @xmath999 of the markov chains @xmath1000 , induced by @xmath760 , with initial distributions @xmath30 and @xmath995 , respectively . as proved above , @xmath997 and @xmath998 are stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts
. in particular , they must be either singular or the same .
they can not be singular , since @xmath30 and @xmath1001 are both mutually absolutely continuous with respect to @xmath3 by lemma [ chiave ] and therefore absolutely continuous with respect to each other .
hence , @xmath997 and @xmath998 are equal , and therefore @xmath1002 .
in lemmas [ pasquetta ] and [ luce ] we prove the results we used in the proof of proposition [ scarola ] , see the discussion after equation . in lemma [ indi ]
we prove instead an assertion on assumption ( a1 ) made in subsection [ domenica ] .
for the first technical result , we slightly change the notation to make it lighter : take @xmath1003 , the space of two - sided sequences with real values , and let @xmath1004 be a stationary measure on @xmath526 , ergodic with respect to the usual shift @xmath1005 for sequences .
we indicate by @xmath1 an element in @xmath526 .
let @xmath1006 and @xmath426 be a probability measure on it .
@xmath1007 is an i.i.d
. sequence of natural numbers under the measure @xmath426 .
we assume that the @xmath1008 s are independent of the @xmath1 s . on the space @xmath1009 endowed with the product measure @xmath1010
, we define the transformation @xmath1011 , with @xmath1012 .
[ pasquetta ] assume that the greatest common divisor of @xmath1013 equals @xmath199 . assume also ( just for simplicity ) that the @xmath1008 s have finite expectation .
then , the transformation @xmath1014 is ergodic .
the statement is not true in general without the gcd condition .
indeed , take the very simple space with only two elements , @xmath1015 and @xmath1016 , and take @xmath1004 putting @xmath195 probability to each of the two elements
. then @xmath1004 is ergodic with respect to @xmath1005 .
but , if we take @xmath1008 s that can attain only even values , then the sequence @xmath1017 is not ergodic under @xmath1018 .
take a function @xmath1019 which is invariant under @xmath1014 and bounded .
we are going to show that @xmath545 is constant , @xmath1020-almost surely , hence proving the claim .
assume we have , for two sequences @xmath1021 , @xmath1022 for some @xmath37 and @xmath1023 .
then @xmath1024 and hence @xmath1025 .
we define @xmath1026 as the @xmath1027algebra generated by @xmath1028 . by the above observation we get @xmath1029 ( \o , \eta ^{(1)})= { { \ensuremath{\mathbb e } } } _
\mathbb l\bigl [ f \,|\ , { \ensuremath{\mathcal f}}_n \bigr ] ( \o , \eta ^{(2)})\ ] ] if holds true for some @xmath37 ( where @xmath1030 denotes the expectation with respect to the measure @xmath1020 ) . on the other hand , @xmath1031 $ ] @xmath1032a.s . as a byproduct
, we get that @xmath1025 for @xmath1033 a.e .
@xmath1034 such that happens for infinitely many @xmath37 ( note that this event has probability one due to the chung
fuchs theorem @xcite applied to the random walk @xmath1035 ) .
hence , @xmath1036 we now claim that for @xmath1004a.e .
@xmath1 the function @xmath1037 is constant @xmath426a.s . to this aim , it is enough to show that for @xmath1004a.e .
@xmath1 the @xmath426variance of @xmath1037 is zero , and this follows from and the identity @xmath1038 ^ 2\,.\ ] ] now let @xmath1039 .
since @xmath545 is invariant under @xmath1014 , @xmath1040 for @xmath1041 .
if @xmath1042 , we conclude that @xmath1043 @xmath426-almost surely , for @xmath1004a.e . @xmath1
since the greatest common divisor of @xmath1013 equals @xmath199 , we conclude that there is some finite @xmath830 such that @xmath1044 for all @xmath1045 , for @xmath1004a.e .
since the law of @xmath55 is ergodic with respect to @xmath1005 , this implies easily that @xmath1046 is constant @xmath1032-almost surely .
now recall the definition of the random sequence @xmath1047 introduced at the end of the proof of prop .
[ scarola ] , and the notation therein .
[ luce ] the random sequence @xmath1048 is stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts .
we first show that the sequence @xmath1049 ( see ) is stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts , under @xmath905 . indeed , writing in a compact form as @xmath1050 , it holds @xmath1051
. then stationarity and ergodicity of @xmath1049 under @xmath905 follow from the stationarity and ergodicity of @xmath1052 under @xmath905 as in lemma [ pasquetta ] .
we move to @xmath1047 .
since @xmath1049 , under @xmath905 , is stationary , one gets easily the stationarity of @xmath1047 under @xmath924 .
take now a shift invariant borel set @xmath1053 ( i.e. @xmath1054 ) .
we claim that @xmath1055 we define @xmath1056 as the borel function such that @xmath1057 since @xmath250 is shift invariant , @xmath250 belongs to the tail @xmath1027algebra of @xmath1058 . by kolmogorov s 01 law and due to the independence of @xmath1059 under @xmath1060 , we get that @xmath545 has values in @xmath1061 .
below , for the sake of intuition we condition to events of zero probability although all can be formalized by means of regular conditional probabilities .
using that @xmath1062 due to the shift invariance of @xmath250 and using the definition of @xmath1047 , we get @xmath1063 hence @xmath545 is shift invariant . by the ergodicity of @xmath1049 , we conclude that the @xmath1064function @xmath1065 is constant @xmath905a.s .
an integration over @xmath1066 allows to get .
[ indi ] consider two independent random sequences @xmath153 and @xmath154 , the former stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts , the latter given by i.i.d
. random variables .
then the random sequence @xmath1067 is stationary and ergodic with respect to shifts .
call @xmath426 the law of @xmath1068 , which is a probability measure on the space @xmath1069 , whose generic element will be denoted by @xmath1070 .
we write @xmath1014 for the shift @xmath1071_k= ( z_{k+1 } , e _ { k+1 } ) $ ] .
let @xmath250 be a shift
invariant borel subset of @xmath1069 .
we want to show that @xmath1072 .
we first claim that , given @xmath1073 , @xmath250 is independent of any set @xmath251 in the @xmath1027algebra generated by @xmath1074 with @xmath1075 . to this aim , given @xmath410 , we fix a borel set @xmath1076 belonging to the @xmath1027-algebra generated by @xmath1077 with @xmath1078 , and such that @xmath1079 .
we take @xmath682 large enough so that @xmath1080 \cap [ -n + m , n+m]= \emptyset$ ] .
we observe that @xmath1081 indeed , the first identity in follows from the shift invariance of @xmath250 , while the second identity follows from the shift stationarity of @xmath426 implying that @xmath1082 . to get the third identity in we observe that @xmath1083 belongs to the @xmath1027algebra generated by @xmath1077 with @xmath1084 $ ] . by our choice of @xmath682 and due to the properties of @xmath426 , we get that @xmath1085 and @xmath251 are independent , thus implying the third identity . as a byproduct of and and the fact that @xmath1086 , we get that @xmath1087 . by the arbitrariness of @xmath1088 we conclude the proof of our claim . due to our claim , @xmath1089 , @xmath1090 being the @xmath1027algebra generated by @xmath1091 , @xmath370
. we can think of @xmath1092 as function of @xmath1093 . due to the shift invariance of @xmath250 , @xmath1094 is shift invariant in @xmath1095 except on an event of probability zero .
due to the ergodicity of the marginal of @xmath426 along @xmath1096 , we conclude that @xmath1094 is constant a.s .
since @xmath1089 , @xmath1097 is constant a.s .
, hence @xmath1072 .
the biased mott random walk @xmath1099 can be compared to the nearest neighbor random walk obtained by considering only nearest neighbor jumps on @xmath1100 with probability rate for a jump from @xmath107 to @xmath131 given by when @xmath1101 are nearest neighbors . by the same arguments as in section [ ballistic_part ] , it is simple to show that this random walk is ballistic / subballistic if and only if the same holds for @xmath1102 , @xmath385 .
the latter can be easily analyzed and the following holds : the limit @xmath1103 exists @xmath1104a.s . for @xmath3a.a .
@xmath1 , and it does not dependent on @xmath1 .
moreover , the velocity @xmath1105 is positive if and only if condition is fulfilled , otherwise it is zero .
we apply theorem 2.1.9 in @xcite using the notations therein .
since @xmath1106 we get that @xmath1107 . therefore , @xmath1108 if and only if @xmath1109 . the last condition is equivalent to since the energy marks are bounded . on the other hand @xmath1110 . hence , @xmath1111 if and only if @xmath1112 . since , when @xmath198 , @xmath1113 , by assumption ( a4 ) it follows that @xmath1114 always .
the claim then follows since , by theorem 2.1.9 in @xcite , @xmath1115 if @xmath1116 , while @xmath1117 if @xmath1118 and @xmath1119 .
* acknowledgements*. the authors are very much indepted to noam berger and thank him for many useful and inspiring discussions .
kindly acknowledges the short visit grant of the european science foundation ( esf ) in the framework of the esf program `` random geometry of large interacting systems and statistical physics '' , and the department of mathematics of the technical university munich for the kind hospitality . m.s .
thanks the department of mathematics of university la sapienza in rome for the kind hospitality , the department of mathematics of the technical university munich where he has started to work on this project as a post doc , and the funding received from the european union s horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the marie sklodowska - curie grant agreement no 656047 .
e. cski , m. csrg , _ on additive functionals of markov chains_. j. theoret .
probab . 8 , 905919 ( 1995 ) .
daley , d. vere jones .
_ an introduction to the theory of point processes_. new york , springer , 1988 a. de masi , p.a .
ferrari , s. goldstein , w.d . wick . _ an invariance principle for reversible markov processes .
applications to random motions in random environments .
* 55 * , 787855 ( 1989 ) . | mott variable range hopping is a fundamental mechanism for low temperature electron conduction in disordered solids in the regime of anderson localization . in a mean field approximation , it reduces to a random walk ( shortly , mott random walk ) on a random marked point process with possible long - range jumps .
we consider here the one - dimensional mott random walk and we add an external field ( or a bias to the right ) .
we show that the bias makes the walk transient , and investigate its linear speed .
our main results are conditions for ballisticity ( positive linear speed ) and for sub - ballisticity ( zero linear speed ) , and the existence in the ballistic regime of an invariant distribution for the environment viewed from the walker , which is mutually absolutely continuous with respect to the original law of the environment .
if the point process is a renewal process , the aforementioned conditions result in a sharp criterion for ballisticity .
interestingly , the speed is not always continuous as a function of the bias .
_ keywords _ : random walk in random environment , disordered media , ballisticity , environment viewed from the walker , electron transport in disordered solids . _ ams subject classification _ : 60k37 , 82d30 , 60g50 , 60g55 . |
in his seminal work on the reaction - rate theory in the diffusion - controlled limit smoluchowski established a quantitative connection between thermal fluctuations in the form of molecular diffusion and a macroscopically observable time evolution of the concentration of reactants and products @xcite .
some 60 years later berg and purcell @xcite showed that thermal diffusion also limits the accuracy of biochemical receptors and hence sets physical bounds to the precision of cellular signalling .
namely , cellular signalling typically involves low copy numbers of messenger molecules and is thereby inevitably subjected to appreciable fluctuations in the count of molecular binding events at biochemical receptors @xcite . in a similar way counting noise limits the precision and sensitivity of modern microscopic diagnostic devices @xcite .
state - of - the - art single particle tracking techniques indeed highlight the inherent stochasticity of such molecular signalling events @xcite . however , despite the significant sample - to - sample fluctuations cellular signalling operates at remarkable precision @xcite . inside living cells
some signalling molecules , typically entrapped in vesicles , do not only move by thermal diffusion alone but may also be actively transported along cellular filaments by molecular motors @xcite causing intermittent ballistic excursions @xcite .
free molecules , such as messenger rna , may as well attach to motors @xcite , or proteins may move in a directed fashion due to cytoplasmic drag @xcite . enhanced spreading
may finally be facilitated by cytoplasmic streaming @xcite .
a practical way to incorporate active motion in the stochastic dynamics of signalling molecules is the model of random intermittent search @xcite which was recently used to analyse reaction kinetics in active media @xcite and the speed and precision of receptor signalling in 3-dimensional media @xcite . .
when the particle reaches the receptor ( orange sphere ) it binds / dissociates with rates @xmath0 and @xmath1 . due to the specific geometry
the system is effectively 1-dimensional . ] in a mean field picture of receptor signalling at equilibrium , developed by bialek and setayeshgar @xcite , signalling molecules diffuse in space and reversibly bind to the receptor in a markovian fashion ( fig .
[ schm ] ) . the central object of the theory is the so - called receptor - noise correlation time @xmath2 @xcite .
namely , in a setting where the receptor measures the concentration over a period @xmath3much longer than any correlation time in the system the noise in the receptor occupancy statistic will be poissonian , and the concentration estimate will improve with the number @xmath4 of independent measurements . the correlation time is set by the thermal noise in the binding to the receptor and the thermal diffusion of the signalling molecules @xcite but can be altered by certain details of the transport , such as intermittent sliding along dna in the so - called facilitated diffusion model of gene regulation @xcite and intermittent active excursion by hitchhiking molecular motors @xcite .
in addition , @xmath2 depends on the dimensionality of the cell or domain in which it occurs @xcite .
moreover , when molecules explore their surrounding space in a compact manner the motion is recurrent in the sense of returning to already visited sites @xcite such as the one observed in 1-dimensional diffusion , the recurrences prolong @xmath2 and thus reduce @xmath5 within a given fixed @xmath3 @xcite .
conversely , the interaction with a confining domain disrupts the positional correlations at long times @xcite and thereby truncates @xmath2 , causing an improvement of the sensing precision especially in low dimensions @xcite .
it was shown in the case of chemical reactions coupled to active transport that the effect of active excursions is most pronounced in low dimensions since they act by disrupting the recurrence of 1-dimensional brownian motion @xcite . here
we demonstrate that the effect of intermittent active motion in 1-dimensional diffusive systems is even stronger when it comes to the sensing precision .
we compute analytically the accuracy limit for receptor mediated concentration measurements in dimension 1 and argue that active excursions allow for enhanced precision of signalling in neurons .
we consider a signalling molecule ( mrna or protein ) diffusing on the real line and randomly switching between a passive diffusion phase @xmath6 with diffusivity @xmath7 and an active ballistic phase @xmath8 with velocity @xmath9 , see fig .
[ schm ] and @xcite .
the duration of active / passive phases is exponentially distributed with mean @xmath10 .
the concentrations of freely diffusing and motor - bound signalling molecules are @xmath11 and @xmath12 and @xmath13 denotes motor - bound signalling molecules moving to the left / right , respectively .
in addition , while passively diffusing the signalling molecule can reversibly bind to a receptor at @xmath14 in a markov fashion . in a mean field description the fractional occupancy @xmath15 with on / off rates
@xmath16 evolves according to the coupled equations [ eqs ] @xmath17-k_{\mathrm{off}}n(t ) , \label{governing}\\ \frac{\partial c_{p}(x , t)}{\partial t}&=&d\partial^2_xc_p+\frac{c_a^+(x , t ) + c_a^-(x ,
t)}{\tau_a}-\frac{c_p(x , t)}{\tau_p}-\delta(x - x_0)\frac{dn(t)}{dt } , \label{governing2}\\ \frac{\partial c_a^{\pm}(x , t)}{\partial t}&=&\mp v \partial_x c_a^{\pm}(x , t ) -\frac{c_a^{\pm}(x , t)}{\tau_a}+\frac{c_p(x , t)}{2\tau_p } , \label{governing3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where detailed balance is fulfilled for the binding @xmath18 involving the binding free energy @xmath19 .
( [ governing])-([governing3 ] ) describe the motion of a molecule randomly switching between phases of passive diffusion and ballistic motion with rates @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
once the molecule locates the receptor at @xmath14 while being in the passive phase , it can bind to it .
the total binding rate is proportional to the intrinsic rate @xmath22 , the probability @xmath23 to find the molecule at @xmath14 in the passive phase , and the probability @xmath24 that the receptor is unoccupied .
once being bound to the receptor the molecule unbinds with a first order rate proportional to the intrinsic unbinding rate @xmath25 and the probability @xmath15 to find the receptor occupied .
note that since @xmath26 has units of 1/length and @xmath15 is dimensionless , the rates @xmath16 have different units , i.e. @xmath0 has the units of length / time and @xmath1 has units of 1/time . to obtain a closed equation for the dynamics of @xmath15 close to equilibrium , we linearise eqs .
( [ governing])-([governing3 ] ) around the respective equilibrium values @xmath27 , and @xmath28 @xcite to obtain , in terms of small fluctuations , @xmath29 and @xmath30 , and @xmath31 .
moreover , the detailed balance condition imposes the constraint @xmath32 on the free energy fluctuations . by fourier transforming in time and in space , @xmath33=\int_0^{\infty}\mathrm{e}^ { i\omega t}(\cdot)dt$ ] , @xmath34=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty } \mathrm{e}^{-ikx}(\cdot ) dx$ ] , and solving the resulting system of ordinary equations we arrive at an exact generalised langevin equation for the fluctuations around the equilibrium receptor occupancy within the linear regime @xcite @xmath35 here @xmath36 denotes the correlation time of two - state markov switching , @xmath37 , and the noise in the form of the free energy fluctuations @xmath38 has zero mean @xmath39 and obeys the fluctuation - dissipation theorem @xmath40 @xcite .
the memory kernel @xmath41 in terms of an inverse fourier transform operator reads @xmath42,\ ] ] and the contribution due to the intermittent active excursions is @xmath43 the limit in eq .
( [ memory ] ) is to be understood as a finite receptor size taken to zero after the integral is evaluated in order for the integral to converge . the memory term in the langevin equation ( [ langevin ] ) reflects the fact that it takes a finite time before the receptor feels the effect of @xmath38 because the signalling molecule moves throughout space before ( re)binding .
according to linear response theory @xcite we can write @xmath44 where the generalised susceptibility becomes @xmath45=\hat { \mathcal{f}}^{-1}_t\left[\frac{\delta\tilde{n}(\omega)}{\delta\tilde{f}(\omega ) } \right],\ ] ] and the power spectrum of @xmath46 is in turn obtained according to the fluctuation - dissipation theorem from the imaginary part of @xmath47 , @xmath48.\ ] ] since the receptor s sensitivity is limited to frequencies @xmath49 , the uncertainty in measuring the occupation fraction will be @xmath50 moreover , a change in concentration is equivalent to a change in @xmath19 , @xmath51 .
using this one can also show that @xcite @xmath52 and use this to relate the uncertainty in @xmath53 to the precision at which the receptor can determine @xmath54 .
we split the signalling process in an equilibration phase , during which the system equilibrates to a new concentration , and the measurement phase , during which the receptor reads out this equilibrium concentration .
moreover , we assume that the equilibration time corresponds to the time during which the signalling molecules move a distance @xmath55 of the order of the size of the cell or a cellular compartment .
the equilibration time @xmath56 is then defined implicitly by the mean squared displacement via @xmath57 .
we here neglect the binding to the receptor given by eq .
( [ governing ] ) and adopt a probabilistic interpretation of eqs .
( [ governing2 ] ) and ( [ governing3 ] ) , which we solve by laplace transforming in time and fourier transforming in space .
the mean squared displacement for a particle starting at the origin in the passive phase is obtained from the laplace transform @xmath58_{k=0}$ ] and after laplace inversion reads @xmath59 eq .
( [ msd ] ) is a transcendental equation for @xmath56 and depends only on three parameters : the typical distance covered in the active and passive phases , @xmath60 and @xmath61 , and the dimensionless pclet number @xmath62 .
moreover , it states that over a period of duration @xmath63 the directional persistence in the active phase causes a nonlinear time dependence of @xmath64 . upon this transient regime
an effective diffusive regime @xmath65 is established with an effective diffusion coefficient @xmath66 ^ 2)/ ( \tau_p+\tau_a)$ ] . to estimate the equilibration rate of active transport with respect to diffusion we compare @xmath56 with the purely passive equilibration time @xmath67 .
[ rate]a)-c ) shows results for various biologically relevant pclet numbers . of equilibration times for passive diffusion ( subscript @xmath68 ) and intermittent active motion ( subscript @xmath69 ) as a function of the typical lengths of active ( @xmath70 ) and passive ( @xmath71 ) displacements for various pclet numbers @xmath62 .
the yellow line corresponds to @xmath72 . whenever @xmath73 active motion leads to faster equilibration . ] from fig .
[ rate ] we find that active transport is more efficient for larger @xmath74 values .
more precisely , the required typical displacement in the active phase needed to enhance the equilibration with respect to bare diffusion is smaller for larger @xmath74 . in the biologically relevant setting
the molecular motor speed @xmath75 is widely independent of the particle size @xcite and the values for the diffusion coefficients span a scale between @xmath76 corresponding to large cargo such as vesicles , and @xmath77 corresponding to smaller proteins .
conversely , the dimension of effectively linear cells such as neurons or their sub - structures ( i.e. dendrites ) falls between @xmath78 and @xmath79 , which means that @xmath80 values are in fact robustly expected .
therefore , according to fig . [ rate ] it is quite plausible that intermittent active motion indeed enhances signalling speed in vivo .
the physical principle underlying the enhancement is rooted in the fundamental difference in the time scaling of diffusive and active motion , @xmath81 versus @xmath82 .
for example , comparing only purely passive and active motion we find that for @xmath83 active motion is more efficient . in the intermittent case
the motion has a transient period of duration @xmath84 , which corresponds to a parameter dependent combination of both regimes .
after this transient period the effective diffusive regime is established with diffusivity @xmath85 , which may or may not be larger than the bare @xmath7 .
@xmath56 can therefore be smaller or larger than @xmath86 .
shuttling of large cargo therefore almost universally profits from active motion , whereas active motion of smaller proteins will only be more efficient over sufficiently large distances .
the observed features thus provide a simple explanation why experimentally active transport is observed mostly in the trafficking of larger particles @xcite
. similarly , active diagnostics @xcite can also be faster and hence could enable for a higher diagnostic throughput .
we now address the signalling precision and focus first on the situation , where molecules move in space by thermal diffusion alone . in this case @xmath87 and the @xmath88-integral in eq .
( [ memory ] ) is evaluated exactly , after taking the limit @xmath89 yielding @xmath90.\ ] ] using eq .
( [ mem_p ] ) in eqs .
( [ fdt ] ) to ( [ uncc ] ) we arrive at the power spectrum of concentration fluctuations experienced by the receptor , @xmath91 where @xmath92 denotes the principal value of the argument .
integrating over the frequency range @xmath93 we obtain the final result for the variance of the concentration measured by the receptor , @xmath94 where the first part describes the noise due to the two - state markov switching ( i.e. the binding alone ) and the second term stands for the noise due to diffusion .
note that for the recurrent nature of 1-dimensional diffusion and the fact that the receptor is point - like , we _ can not _ approximate the precision at which the receptor can determine @xmath54 with @xmath95 as in the 3-dimensional case ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
more precisely , in contrast to the lorentzian shape of @xmath96 in the 3-dimensional case , @xmath97 diverges as @xmath98 .
the integral over @xmath99 nevertheless converges and leads to eq .
( [ unc_p ] ) .
moreover , in contrast to the 3-dimensional case where the squared measurement error @xmath100 decreases as @xmath101 , for 1-dimensional diffusion we find the much slower decay @xmath102 .
that is , @xmath103 and the receptor measurement is thus much less efficient in 1-dimension .
as we are interested in the signalling precision at equilibrium and hence consider @xmath3 values which are much longer than any correlation time in the motion @xcite such that @xmath104 , we may take the limit in @xmath105 as well as in eq .
( [ memory ] ) . this way we recover , after performing the integral over @xmath88 in eq .
( [ memory ] ) and taking the limit @xmath89 , an effective white noise asymptotic on the slow time scale @xmath106 , @xmath107^{-1}+[v\tau_a]^{-2}\right)^{3/2}}\right],\ ] ] and correspondingly an effectively lorentzian fluctuation spectrum @xmath108 at small frequencies ( see @xcite ) . from eq .
( [ uncc ] ) we obtain also the low frequency region of the power spectrum concentration fluctuations , @xmath109 for @xmath110 , where we introduced the typical distance the signalling molecule moves in the passive @xmath61 and motor bound phases @xmath60 .
as before , the first term in eq .
( [ unca ] ) corresponds to the two - state switching noise and the second term to the noise due to spatially extended intermittent dynamics .
note that in contrast to the 3-dimensional setting , where the active excursions merely rescale the correlation time @xcite , we here find a qualitative change in the properties of the noise , compare eqs .
( [ unc_p ] ) and ( [ unca ] ) .
using eq .
( [ unca ] ) we can now approximate the precision at which the receptor can determine @xmath54 with @xmath111 and obtain our main result @xmath112 here we are interested in the transport - controlled sensing @xcite . comparing the noise due to the spatially extended motion for passive and active intermittent motion we find that that active motion allows for more precise absolute concentration measurements as soon as the inequality @xmath113 holds such that in the limit of long active excursions @xmath114 we end up with the condition @xmath115 .
note that the right hand side of this inequality is essentially the characteristic time of the asymptotic exponential decay of the first passage time density of a 1-dimensional random walk in a domain of length @xmath55 if we set @xmath116 @xcite .
in other words , for active signalling to be more precise in 1-dimension the receptor needs to measure long enough for the particle to find the target in the passive phase , which is an intuitive result . in order to be more concrete
we compare the scaled variances of measurement errors for active @xmath117 and passive @xmath118 motion . in the transport - controlled regime
we have @xmath119 for intermittent active motion and @xmath120 , where @xmath121 denotes the total concentration of molecules .
note that here and throughout the entire paper we implicitly assume that the number of molecules exceeds the number of receptors @xcite .
the relative precision ratio reads @xmath122
^ 2\right)^{3/2 } } , \label{prec_rat}\ ] ] where we introduced dimensionless times @xmath123 and @xmath124 as well as @xmath125 , the dimensionless ratio between the squared typical lengths of passive @xmath126 versus active @xmath127 displacements during the measurement time @xmath3 .
the results for various values of @xmath128 are presented in fig .
[ precision ] .
with @xmath129 for active intermittent ( subscript @xmath69 ) versus passive ( subscript @xmath68 ) transport as a function of the relative duration of active ( @xmath130 ) and passive ( @xmath130 ) phases with respect to the measurement time @xmath3 for various values of dimensionless ratio between the squared typical length of passive @xmath131 versus active @xmath132 displacements during the measurement time @xmath3 .
whenever @xmath133 active motion leads to more precise signalling . note that @xmath134 and @xmath135 in order to assure equilibrium sensing conditions . ]
we find that the minimal value of @xmath136 that is required for improved sensing precision with respect to bare diffusion ( i.e. for @xmath133 , which corresponds to the region to the left of the yellow curve in fig .
[ precision ] ) decreases with decreasing @xmath128 .
in other words , for large particles with a smaller @xmath7 the active displacements can become arbitrarily short . given that the typical measurement times lie between @xmath137 sec and @xmath137 min @xcite the conditions for improved signalling accuracy appear to be robustly satisfied .
to understand this we need to recall that , while larger @xmath136 monotonically leads to lower absolute read - out errors ( see eq .
( [ uncc_a ] ) ) , it simultaneously decreases @xmath138 and hence renormalises @xmath139 .
the improved accuracy in fig . [ precision ] is thus a result of a trade - off between a decreases of the absolute concentration fluctuations and a lower equilibrium probability to be at the receptor site .
this result is striking as it suggests that even the slightest active displacements can disrupt the recurrence and improve the read - out precision as long as their length is larger than the receptor size . physically , this observation is due to the fact that the receptor collects new information only from statistically independent binding events .
correlations between consecutive measurements arise due to a finite markov binding time @xmath36 and due to the return and rebinding of a previously bound molecule . moreover , we assume that only freely diffusing molecules can bind to the receptor
. therefore , the receptor necessarily experiences the binding of those molecules , which are ballistically swept towards the binding site over a distance larger than the receptor size , as statistically independent . in turn ,
molecules which are ballistically flushed away from the receptor after unbinding will also contribute statistically independent binding events , regardless of how they return to the receptor .
the non - existence of a lower - bound on @xmath136 is thus an artefact of assuming a point - like receptor .
note that in an alternative setting , in which we compare the precision to determe the same concentration of passively moving molecules , which corresponds to a higher @xmath121 in the intermittent active case ( i.e. @xmath140 @xcite ) , the signalling precision would be improved unconditionally .
therefore , in contrast to the 3-dimensional case , where active motion only improves sensing precision for certain values of parameters @xcite , active transport can robustly and much more efficiently improve sensing accuracy in 1-dimensional systems for sufficiently long measurement times .
the degree of recurrence of spatial exploration is essential for random target search processes @xcite . for example , in the facilitated diffusion model of gene regulation the topological coupling of 1- and 3-dimensional diffusion allows for a more efficient search ( e.g. @xcite ) . in a similar manner
intermittent active excursions can significantly speed up random search @xcite .
in contrast , the topological coupling of 1- and 3-dimensional diffusion does not appreciably improve the signalling precision @xcite .
in addition , we showed previously that in a 3-dimensional setting active motion only conditionally improves the signalling accuracy , by decreasing the correlation time of the counting noise in a process called active focusing @xcite .
here we find , strikingly , that active excursions effect qualitative changes in the power spectrum of concentration fluctuations experienced by the receptor in 1-dimensional systems such as neurons . by adding the active component the power spectrum changes from @xmath141 for thermal diffusion alone to a lorentzian shape with a finite plateau .
this lorentzian shape is also observed for passive signalling in 3-dimensions @xcite .
therefore , active excursions disrupt the recurrent nature of 1-dimensional diffusion .
existing studies provide insight into how receptor clustering @xcite and cooperativity @xcite , dimensionality @xcite , spatial confinement @xcite , receptor diffusion @xcite and active transport @xcite affect the precision of receptor signalling .
the overall dependence of the counting noise on the manner the signalling molecules explore their surrounding space suggests that a heterogeneous diffusivity profile @xcite and spatial disorder @xcite would alter the signalling precision as well . both have been observed in experiments @xcite .
in addition , signalling molecules or transport versicles often exhibit anomalous diffusion @xcite , both in the form of passive @xcite and active @xcite motion
. it would therefore be interesting to investigate the impact of these features on the sensing precision in the future .
ag acknowledges funding through an alexander von humboldt fellowship and arrs project z1 - 7296 .
99 endres r g and wingreen n s 2008 _ proc .
natl . acad .
usa _ * 105 * , 15749 ; + rappel w - j and levine h 2008 _ phys .
lett . _ * 100 * , 228101 ; + hu b , kessler d a , rappel w - j , and levine h 2011 _ phys .
lett . _ * 107 * , 148101 ; + govern c and ten wolde p r 2012 _ phys .
lett . _ * 109 * , 218103 ; + kaizu c et al .
2014 _ biophys .
j. _ * 106 * , 976 ; + tkaik g , gregor t , and bialek w 2008 _ plos one _ * 3 * , e2774 .
salman h et al .
, _ biophys .
j. _ * 89 * , 2134 ( 2005 ) ; + huet s , karatekin e , tran v s , cribier s and henry j p 2006 _ biophys .
j. _ * 91 * , 3542 ; + vermehren - schmaedick a et al .
2014 _ plos one _ * 9 * , e95113 ; + arcizet d , meier b , sackmann e , rdler j o , and heinrich d 2008 _ phys .
lett . _ * 101 * , 248103 .
hippel ph and berg og 1989 j. biol . chem . *
264 * , 675 ; + sheinman o , bnichou o , kafri y , and voituriez r 2012 _ rep .
phys . _ * 75 * , 026601 ; + pulkkinen
o and metzler r 2013 _ phys .
* 110 * , 198101 ; + bauer m and metzler r 2012 _ biophys .
j. _ * 102 * , 2321 ; + bauer m and metzler r 2013 _ plos one _ * 8 * , e53956 ; + koslover e f , daz de la rosa m a d , and spakowitz a j 2011 _ biophys .
j. _ * 101 * , 856 ; + kolomeisky a 2011 _ phys . chem .
* 13 * , 2088 ; + wunderlich z and mirny l a 2008 _ nucleic acids res . _ * 36 * , 3570 .
godec a and metzler r 2015 _ phys .
e _ * 91 * , 052134 ; + viccario g , antoine c , and talbot j 2015 _ phys . rev .
* 115 * , 240601 ; + cherstvy a g , chechkin a v , and metzler r 2014 _ j. phys .
theor . _ * 47 * , 485002 .
sabhapandit s , majumdar s n , and comtet a 2006 _ phys .
e _ * 73 * 051102 ; + majumdar s n , and comtet a 2002 _ phys .
lett . _ * 89 * 060601 ; + burov s and barkai e 2007 _ phys .
lett . _ * 98 * 250601 ; + dean d s , gupta s , oshanin g , rosso a , and schehr g 2014 _ j. phys . a : math .
* 47 * , 372001 ; + krsemann h , godec a , and metzler r. 2014 _ phys .
e _ * 89 * , 040101(r ) ; + krsemann h , godec a , and metzler r. 2015 _ j. phys . a : math .
theor . _ * 48 * , 285001 ; + godec a , chechkin a v , barkai e , kantz h and metzler r 2014 _ j. phys .
a : math . theor . _ * 47 * , 492002 english b p , hauryliuk v , sanamrad a , tankov s , dekker n h , and elf j 2011 _ proc . natl .
* 108 * , e365 ; + cutler p j , malik m d , liu s , byars j s , lidke d s , and lidke k a 2013 _ plos one _ * 8 * , e64320 ( 2013 ) .
di rienzo c , piazza v , gratton e , beltram f , and cardarelli f 2014 _ nature commun . _ * 5 * , 5891 . ;
+ jeon j - h , tejedor v , burov s , barkai e , selhuber - unkel c , berg - srensen k , oddershede l and metzler r 2011 _ phys .
lett . _ * 106 * , 048103 ; + golding i and cox e c 2006 _ phys .
_ 96 , 098102 .
caspi a , granek r , and elbaum m 2002 _ phys .
e _ * 66 * , 011916 ; + gal n and weihs d 2010 _ phys . rev .
e _ * 81 * , 020903(r ) ; + goychuk i , kharchenko v o , and metzler r 2014 _ phys .
* 16 * , 16524 ( 2014 ) ; + seisenberger g , ried mu , endre t , bning h , hallek m and bruchle c 2001 _ science _ * 294 * , 1929 . | molecular signalling in living cells occurs at low copy numbers and is thereby inherently limited by the noise imposed by thermal diffusion .
the precision at which biochemical receptors can count signalling molecules is intimately related to the noise correlation time .
in addition to passive thermal diffusion , messenger rna and vesicle - engulfed signalling molecules can transiently bind to molecular motors and are actively transported across biological cells .
active transport is most beneficial when trafficking occurs over large distances , for instance up to the order of 1 metre in neurons .
here we explain how intermittent active transport allows for faster equilibration upon a change in concentration triggered by biochemical stimuli .
moreover , we show how intermittent active excursions induce qualitative changes in the noise in effectively one - dimensional systems such as dendrites .
thereby they allow for significantly improved signalling precision in the sense of a smaller relative deviation in the concentration read - out by the receptor . on the basis of linear response theory
we derive the exact mean field precision limit for counting actively transported molecules .
we explain how intermittent active excursions disrupt the recurrence in the molecular motion , thereby facilitating improved signalling accuracy .
our results provide a deeper understanding of how recurrence affects molecular signalling precision in biological cells and novel diagnostic devices . |
while spontaneous decay is a fundamental ingredient for many physical processes , many applications have been proposed recently where spontaneous processes are amongst the main limiting factors @xcite .
these schemes usually rely on the persistence of either population trapped in a specific state or of coherences on timescales long as compared to typical atomic timescales such as the lifetime of an atomic state . a well - known example for
this restriction is the construction of a high frequency laser , where it is hard to reach a population inversion as the spontaneous decay is considerable on high frequency transitions . for the storage and the processing of quantum information ,
spontaneous emission is a major limitation , because it is necessary to avoid all possible sources of decoherence in these schemes .
the same holds for the secure information transmission using quantum effects . because of the great interest in these applications , various schemes to modify the spontaneous dynamics of an atomic system have been proposed @xcite .
one ansatz is the quantum zeno effect @xcite . according to the measurement postulate
, a system is projected into one of its eigenstates upon a measurement . if the measurements are repeated rapidly , the system evolution may effectively be stopped , because each measurement projects the system back into the initial state . the technical conditions on the brevity of the pulses though may not always be easily fulfilled for every transition , especially in the free vacuum .
another possibility is a modification of the vacuum surrounding the given atomic system , e.g. by an optical cavity @xcite .
if the vacuum is modified such that the mode density at the frequency of an atomic transition is decreased , spontaneous processes on the given transition may be suppressed . here
the control of the environmental modes with cavities is rather challenging in reality and not suitable to all schemes .
thirdly it is possible to find superpositions of more than one upper state which are stable @xcite or almost stable @xcite against spontaneous decay .
the suppression of the spontaneous decay here is due to quantum interference effects such as the cancellation of the amplitudes of several possible pathways between two system states @xcite . in spite of the conceptual beauty ,
the disadvantage here often is the difficulty to provide convenient atomic systems which fulfill all conditions such as parallel transition dipole moments for interference to be present .
finally , a system driven by an electromagnetic field periodic in time is somewhat related to systems exhibiting spacial periodicity such as crystals .
thus schemes relying on spacial periodicity which involve a change of the probability for incoherent processes such as the borrmann effect @xcite or the suppression of nuclear reactions @xcite may be transferred to laser - driven atomic systems @xcite .
recently , this idea has also been applied to modify the decay of a three level system in v - configuration @xcite . in @xcite ,
a scheme was proposed to slow down the spontaneous decay of the upper state population of an effective atomic two - level system considerably .
this scheme makes use of an intense low - frequency laser field of constant frequency and intensity which is applied to the two - level system such that the frequency of the low - frequency field is lower than the decay width of the atomic transition .
this additional field induces multiphoton transitions between the two atomic states under consideration , thus allowing for alternative pathways between the two states in addition to spontaneous transitions . in the literature ,
hamiltonians describing two - photon processes have been discussed to a great extend @xcite .
however these mainly apply to systems involving dipole - forbidden transitions .
as our aim is to inhibit spontaneous decay , it is not sufficient to look at the spontaneous emission on dipole - forbidden transitions as these rates are very low naturally . for dipole - allowed transitions ,
two- and four - photon pathways vanish due to parity reasons .
therefore it is necessary to extend the analysis to third - order processes @xcite .
the leading - order corrections are five - photon processes , which we neglect as these have a low probability in the discussed parameter range . thus in this paper
, we derive the hamiltonian describing the interaction of the two - level system with both the vacuum modes and the additional low - frequency field mode including up to three - photon processes from first principles by adiabatically removing the intermediate atomic states of the multiphoton processes .
we calculate the coupling constants which were taken as free parameters in @xcite in terms of the properties of the atom and the laser field .
furthermore , the hamiltonian includes stark shift effects not discussed in @xcite , which however will turn out to be of no importance for the suppression scheme .
this hamiltonian is then applied to a quantum mechanical simulation of the decay dynamics of the two - level system . as it will turn out
, the spontaneous decay may be slowed down considerably due to the additional transition pathways induced by the intense low - frequency field . in the final part , this is demonstrated using numerical results of this simulation based on rubidium atoms .
the derivation starts from the usual hamiltonian for an atomic system coupled to quantized electromagnetic fields @xcite .
the atomic system consists of two atomic states ( typically of opposite parity ) which are considered as the ground state @xmath0 and the excited state @xmath1 of an two - level atom , which we will denote as the effective two - level system throughout this paper . to model possible multiphoton transitions between the two effective atomic levels , unspecified auxiliary states @xmath2 ( @xmath3 )
are required , which will be adiabatically eliminated throughout the analysis . which will be adiabatically removed in the derivation of the multiphoton hamiltonian .
the auxiliary states are show schematically ; their relative position is not restricted to be above the two main atomic states .
after the adiabatic elimination , the effective two - level system exhibits multiphoton processes as symbolized in the figure . here , the short arrows depict interactions with the intense low - frequency field and the long arrows interactions with the vacuum field . ,
height=170 ] these states might even be part of the continuum ; the only condition on them is that they are sufficiently far away from the two main atomic states as will be explained in more detail below . since there are no isolated two - level atomic systems , the presence of this states is always guaranteed .
the auxiliary states are necessary as in starting from first principles , i.e. the interaction hamiltonian @xmath4 , we only allow for one - photon transitions between the two effective atomic states .
multiphoton processes are then introduced by considering series of one - photon processes from one of the two effective states to the other effective state via one or more of the auxiliary states , which within the adiabatic approximation occur simultaneously .
the result will be a hamiltonian involving the states of the effective two - level system only , which will turn out to be a generalization of the one used in @xcite .
the applied field consists of the low frequency field of frequency @xmath5 and the vacuum field modes .
the following analysis is similar to the one in @xcite , and the notation is close to @xcite .
the system hamiltonian is given by @xmath6 here , @xmath7 and @xmath8 ( @xmath3 ) are the energies of state @xmath9 and auxiliary state @xmath2 , respectively .
@xmath10 is a multi index over all polarization modes and vacuum frequencies @xmath11 . throughout the analysis
, we denote sums over all auxiliary states excluding the two effective atomic states @xmath9 by the sum subscript @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the summation index .
@xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) is a low - frequency field annihilation ( creation ) operator , @xmath16 @xmath17 ) annihilates ( creates ) a vacuum photon of mode @xmath10 , @xmath18 is the total atomic dipole operator , and @xmath19 is the electric field given by @xmath20 the @xmath21 are polarization vectors , while the @xmath22 are field amplitudes .
the frequency corresponding to the low - frequency field operators @xmath23 is assumed to be different from the relevant frequencies for the vacuum photons , which are close to the atomic transition frequency of the effective two - level system , such that the low - frequency field operators commute with the relevant vacuum field operators . in the following analysis , we make use of the approximation that no multiphoton transitions involving two or more spontaneous photons with _
different _ frequencies are included . as in our system
spontaneous one - photon transitions are possible , transitions involving more than one spontaneous photon are highly suppressed ; see the processes considered and observed in @xcite
. however we include multiple spontaneous photons with the _ same _ frequency to account for stark shifts , which arise from interactions of the atom with the electromagnetical field as a sequence of an absorption and an emissions ( or vice versa ) which does not change the state of the atomic system .
also we consider all possible combinations of interactions with the low - frequency field as it is intense .
the interaction part of the hamiltonian may be expanded as follows : @xmath24 @xmath25 is the atomic transition operator , @xmath26 is the dipole moment corresponding to transition @xmath27
. some of these dipole moments may be zero due to symmetry reasons , however as this depends on the configuration of the auxiliary states , we keep this most general form of the hamiltonian .
a specific example for this will be given in section [ rubidium ] where we discuss rubidium as a model system .
in this expansion , the first part in equation ( [ order3 ] ) corresponds to direct transitions between the ground and the excited state by dipole coupling to one of the electric field components ( i.e. one - photon transitions ) .
the second addend couples both the ground and the excited state to one of the auxiliary states . after an adiabatic elimination of these intermediate states , this part will turn out to represent multiphoton transitions . obviously
n - photon transitions with @xmath28 require transitions amongst the auxiliary states ; thus these effects are accounted for by the last part in equation ( [ order3 ] ) .
these last two parts together with the intense low - frequency field lead to a system evolution which qualitatively differs from the well - known mollow - type evolution for two - level systems resonantly driven by a laser field @xcite .
it is important to note that a higher order multiphoton treatment based on the above hamiltonians involves operator ordering issues , as in the following analysis the atomic transition operators involving auxiliary states will be represented by expressions containing photon operators . if these issues are not taken into account , the resulting hamiltonians are not self - adjoint . thus strictly speaking ,
expressions like @xmath29 in the above hamiltonians are understood to be read as @xmath30 as the above equation equation ( [ order3 ] ) is difficult to solve exactly , we use a perturbative approach which consists of an expansion in the number of interactions with the auxiliary levels .
the lowest order hamiltonian thus does not include any interactions with the auxiliary levels and may therefore be written as @xmath31 this hamiltonian simply describes the coupling of the vacuum- and the low - frequency field to the effective two - level atom and does not contain contributions of the auxiliary states . to account for two - photon processes
, we have to consider transitions from the ground or the excited state into and out of the auxiliary states , but no transitions amongst the auxiliary states .
for this we introduce the transition operators @xmath32 and their conjugates , where the super index @xmath33 denotes the lowest order approximation whose equations of motion do not include any contribution of the auxiliary states . only the operators involving the auxiliary states are approximated , as the operators connecting only the ground and the excited state contain the main evolution of the system and therefore have to be taken into account to all orders .
thus the two - photon hamiltonian is given by @xmath34 as it will be shown in section [ transops ] , the transition operators @xmath32 and their conjugates consist of sums of products of a transition operator @xmath35 ( @xmath36 ) and a photon annihilation or creation operator .
thus it may easily be seen that contributions to the hamiltonian in equation ( [ h2 ] ) containing transition operators to one of the auxiliary states describe two - photon processes . including up to three - photon processes
, a transition from one of the two effective atomic levels to one of the auxiliary levels may be followed by a transition to another auxiliary state . thus the three - photon hamiltonian may be expressed in terms of the first order transition operators @xmath37 and their conjugates , whose equations of motion contain either lowest - order transition operators to the auxiliary state or transitions between the two effective atomic states .
also , transition operators between two auxiliary states are possible in lowest order @xmath38 ( @xmath39 ) , i.e. with no reference to the auxiliary states in the equations of motion .
this yields @xmath40 as the three - photon hamiltonian . here , the operator ordering was not applied to the term containing a double sum over @xmath41 for notational simplicity as it will turn out to be irrelevant for the present analysis . for higher order processes , @xmath42 with @xmath43
may be obtained similarly . introducing the coupling constants @xmath44 where
the transition dipole moments are assumed to be real , the hamiltonians may be written as @xmath45 the equations of motion for the various operators involved may be obtained using the heisenberg equation @xmath46\ ] ] where @xmath47 is an operator in the heisenberg picture .
for the transition operator @xmath35 with @xmath48 - which is one of the elements that occurs in the above hamiltonians in equations ( [ twophot ] , [ threephot ] ) - this may be expanded as follows to the lowest two orders in the interaction with the auxiliary states : @xmath49 where @xmath50 ( @xmath51 ) .
the zeroth order equation does not include references to the auxiliary states , while the first order includes operators connecting one of the main atomic states with an auxiliary state in zeroth order .
note that for simplicity we omitted an addend containing the transition operator @xmath52 in the first - order equation , as it will turn out to be zero ( see equation ( [ aux - pop ] ) ) .
higher order expressions may be obtained similarly . for @xmath53
, we have : @xmath54 for @xmath55 the corresponding expression in lowest order simply becomes @xmath56 the basic tool to eliminate the auxiliary states from the equation of motion is the adiabatic integration . for this , the equations of motion are written in terms of slowly varying operators which are denoted by the corresponding symbol with a tilde and which may be seen as an interaction picture representation of the operator : @xmath57 the adiabatic approximations with superscripts @xmath58 are transferred as their full counterparts .
the definition of the slowly varying operators is chosen as in @xcite to allow for a comparison of the results .
this for example yields using equations ( [ field ] ) , ( [ coupling ] ) and ( [ s1j_zero ] ) @xmath59 now we integrate over time , using the partial integration rule . for simplicity ,
only the first addend of equation ( [ adiab - example ] ) is shown to illustrate the basic idea of adiabatic integration : @xmath60 in the adiabatic integration one now assumes that the time evolution of the slowly changing operators @xmath61 ( which is typically of the order of the atomic decay rate or the rabi frequencies involved ) is low as compared to the oscillation of the exponential function .
this is fulfilled if the rabi frequencies involved are not too large and if the intermediate states @xmath2 ( @xmath12 ) are sufficiently far away from the atomic ground and excited state , which we assume in the following .
therefore the integral on the right hand side of equation ( [ partint ] ) may be dropped , yielding using ( [ trans ] ) and including all addends : @xmath62 as the lowest order adiabatic approximation for this atomic transition operator .
a similar calculation yields @xmath63 from equation ( [ eom_ij ] ) , we obtain for @xmath55 in the slowly varying operator frame : @xmath64 as the auxiliary states are far from resonance with the applied frequencies , in lowest order of the adiabatic approximation we thus have @xcite @xmath65 for @xmath55 .
another way of seeing this is that due to the vanishing time derivative , in this order of approximation the populations of the auxiliary states remain constant . as these populations are zero if the population initially is distributed over the ground and the excited state , they are empty at all times .
these results are sufficient to calculate the effective two - photon hamiltonian equation ( [ h2 ] ) and to obtain the first order expressions for the transition operators in equations ( [ s1j_one ] ) and ( [ s2j_one ] ) . as the expressions in equations ( [ s1j_one_int ] ) and ( [ s2j_one_int ] ) only contain transition operators involving the ground and the excited state , the elimination of the auxiliary states both from the two - photon hamiltonian and from the first order expressions for the transition operators is obvious .
note however that the dipole moments connecting the ground and the excited atomic state to the auxiliary states remain in the equations influencing the various coefficients or coupling parameters .
to calculate the first order transition operators , we we insert the lowest - order transition operators equations ( [ s1j_one_int ] ) and ( [ s2j_one_int ] ) and their conjugates in the equations of motion for the first order operators equations ( [ s1j_one ] ) and ( [ s2j_one ] ) . then the equations are transferred to the slowly changing operator picture using the transformation rules equations ( [ trans ] ) . the resulting expression for @xmath66 , @xmath67 and their conjugates may again be adiabatically integrated yielding @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
in addition to the corresponding operator of zeroth order , each of these operators contains 56 addends as first order contribution , 28 of which depend on a sum over auxiliary intermediate atomic states @xmath70 .
for example , we have @xmath71 the operators @xmath72 , which are proportional to @xmath35 , and the other first order transition operators may be found in [ anhang - trans - op ] . in this section
, we will use the transition operators derived in the last section to give an explicit representation of the two - photon and the three - photon hamiltonian in equations ( [ h2 ] ) and ( [ h3 ] ) .
the resulting hamiltonian will turn out to be equivalent to the hamiltonian used in @xcite .
however here we obtain expressions for the coupling constants @xmath73 introduced as free parameters in the hamiltonian in @xcite and extend the analysis to include stark shift contributions to the hamiltonian .
the role of the stark shifts for the decay dynamics of the effective two - level atom will be discussed in section [ decay ] . using the rotating - wave approximation , we drop all terms oscillating with frequencies of the order of @xmath11 or higher in the two - photon hamiltonian in equation ( [ h2 ] ) .
thus we neglect counter - rotating interactions with the vacuum field , but do not apply the rotating - wave approximation to the interaction of the atom with the low - frequency field . transferring the resulting expression back to the heisenberg picture adopted in the initial equations equation ( [ order3 ] ) using the transformation rules in equations ( [ trans ] )
, we obtain @xmath74 where the coefficients are given by @xmath75 , @xmath76 @xmath77 and the detunings are defined as @xmath78 here , the terms proportional to @xmath79 are the usual one - photon hamiltonian parts .
the next addends including @xmath80 are two - photon transitions which will turn out to be of most interest for the following analysis .
terms with @xmath81 may be interpreted as stark shifts due to the presence of the two electromagnetic field modes .
this hamiltonian is an extension to the one obtained in @xcite in that it includes more transitions such as direct one - photon transitions due to the vacuum and also field ordering effects .
these ordering effects are the reason why for example @xmath82 and @xmath83 here are not the same other than in @xcite .
the addends proportional to @xmath84 are somewhat generalized stark shifts in that they involve the population operators @xmath85 and @xmath86 .
usually they do not appear in effective multiphoton hamiltonians as they may be dropped in a rotating wave approximation if the frequency of the involved photons is large enough .
for example , the addend with @xmath87 stems from a transition @xmath88 followed by a transition @xmath89 , one of which is counter - rotating .
but here @xmath14 represents a low - frequency photon such that these terms may not be dropped a priori .
however as discussed later the numerical simulations indicate that they do not disturb the effects described in @xcite .
one hint that may help to understand this is that from a quantum mechanical point of view , these contributions account for a distribution of the system state over the various fock states of the low - frequency field without inducing atomic transitions .
the trapping effect however does not rely on a specific configuration of the low - frequency field modes such as a concentration of the states to only few of the fock states .
the interpretation of the general structure of this hamiltonian is straightforward . in each addend of the @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) ,
the number of @xmath92 coefficients is equal to the number of photons exchanged .
the various processes involved may also be read off from the @xmath92 coefficients , as for example in @xmath93 in equation ( [ alpha1 ] ) , which describes a transition of the effective atom from the ground state @xmath0 to the excited state @xmath1 together with the absorption of both a low - frequency and a spontaneous photon ( @xmath94 in hamiltonian equation ( [ ham2_ad ] ) ) .
the first addend stems from a transition between @xmath0 and an intermediate state @xmath2 via a vacuum - induced transition ( @xmath95 ) and a low frequency field photon absorption between @xmath2 and @xmath1 ( @xmath96 ) .
the third addend is due to a transition between @xmath0 and an intermediate state @xmath2 via a low frequency field photon absorption ( @xmath97 ) and a vacuum - induced transition between @xmath2 and @xmath1 ( @xmath98 ) . using the results of section [ higher - order ] in the expression for the three - photon hamiltonian equation ( [ h3 ] ) yields after a calculation as in section [ sec - two - photon ] for the two - photon hamiltonian the following three - photon hamiltonian : @xmath99 thus as expected the one- and two - photon processes of this hamiltonian are identical to the ones in the two - photon hamiltonian equation ( [ ham2_ad ] ) .
all additional terms in equation ( [ ham3_ad ] ) are three - photon processes .
the terms with @xmath100 are corrections to @xmath79 in the two - photon hamiltonian , as they effectively induce the same transition . @xmath101 and @xmath102 are coefficients to the three - photon transition parts , which will be of most interest in the simulation of the decay dynamics .
third - order stark effects vanish due to symmetry reasons . introducing the detuning @xmath103 ,
the explicit expressions for the @xmath104 coefficients are given as follows ( note that the sums over @xmath13 and @xmath105 have been omitted for notational simplicity ; all occurrences of these indices are summed over all auxiliary states in these coefficients ) : @xmath106 the first four transitions involved in the coupling constant @xmath101 corresponding to the transition @xmath107 .
the solid lines denote interactions with the low - frequency field , the dashed line denotes a vacuum photon emission .
all paths start in state @xmath1 and end in state @xmath0 .
the lengths of the arrows are not related to the frequencies of the involved photons.,height=188 ] the structure of the coefficients is similar to the one in the two - photon hamiltonian , and the contributing transition pathways may be read off each addend .
figure [ transition ] shows the first four processes contributing to @xmath101 .
this coefficient corresponds to the transition @xmath107 in the hamiltonian equation ( [ ham3_ad ] ) .
for example , the first addend in @xmath101 in equation ( [ beta3 ] ) describes a path starting by a transition from the excited state @xmath1 to the auxiliary state @xmath70 induced by a low - frequency field absorption , followed by a transition to the auxiliary state @xmath2 induced by a low - frequency field absorption , and then a vacuum photon emission with a transition to the ground state @xmath0 .
the other transition pathways may be read off the addends accordingly .
it is important to note that the frequency of the spontaneous photon emitted or absorbed in the multiphoton processes is always close to the atomic transition frequency , because the sum of the frequencies of all photons ( with a relative sign between emitted and absorbed photons ) is required to be close to the atomic transition frequency for a spontaneous emission to occur .
this will be shown using a wigner - weisskopf - like calculation in section [ decay ] .
for any application of the above hamiltonian equation ( [ ham3_ad ] ) , it is important to be able to decide which intermediate states need to be taken into account in the analysis .
first of all , the number of exchanged photons restricts the atomic level space .
for example in a three - photon transition from a @xmath108 ( angular momentum @xmath109 ) to a @xmath110 ( @xmath111 ) state , states with @xmath112 are not possible as intermediate states .
the two important parameters which decide about the relevance of the remaining intermediate states are the transition dipole moments which connect the state in question to other relevant states , and the frequency separation to the other states .
a reasonable parameter involving these quantities is e.g. the ratio @xmath113 ( @xmath114 ) , i.e. , the coupling strength of the multiphoton transitions relative to the single photon transition strength . by evaluating the expression for @xmath115 for each combination of the intermediate states @xmath13 and @xmath105 separately , it is possible to compare the relative weights of the various pathways as e.g. shown in figure [ transition ] .
then the states which give rise to pathways with small relative contribution can be neglected . for this , it is not necessary to evaluate all possible combinations . if @xmath116 is the principal quantum number of an intermediate state which is higher than the principal quantum numbers of the ground and the excited state , then the contribution of the corresponding intermediate state with principal quantum number @xmath117 can be expected to be lower than the contribution of the state with quantum number @xmath116 due to the larger frequency separation and due to a lower transition dipole moment
to further understand the various contributions in the derived hamiltonian , and to analyze the modification of the decay dynamics due to the additional multiphoton transition pathways we apply the three - photon hamiltonian equation ( [ ham3_ad ] ) in a quantum mechanical simulation of the effective two - level atom subject to an intense low - frequency field and the vacuum modes .
for this , we rearrange the free and the interaction part of the three - photon hamiltonian as follows : @xmath118 @xmath119 is the effective free hamiltonian , including the stark shifts of the two atomic levels .
@xmath120 describes the interaction with the vacuum field , i.e. the spontaneous decay .
the contributions involving operators @xmath14 and @xmath15 in this part account for multiphoton transitions consisting of one interaction with the vacuum field and one or more interactions with the low - frequency field .
@xmath121 contains terms due to the low frequency field alone which drive the effective system . in order to calculate the system evolution
we notice that @xmath121 contains multiphoton processes only such that its coupling constants @xmath122 ( @xmath123 ) are moderate even for an intense low - frequency field .
thus in the regime where the previous approximations such as the adiabatic elimination are valid , the evolution which gives rise to the damping of the system ( i.e. the coupling to the vacuum ) may be evaluated separately from external driving fields as it is common practice in quantum optical calculations , see e.g. chapter 8.6.1 in @xcite .
thus in our case , we evaluate the system with @xmath124 alone and then combine the resulting equations of motion with the ones resulting from the driving part @xmath121 .
this approximation holds if @xmath125 , which means that coupling constants in @xmath121 have to be low as compared to the atomic transition frequency of the effective two - level system .
first , we transfer the vacuum interaction part of the hamiltonian @xmath120 to the interaction picture with respect to the free part @xmath119 . to understand the stark shift contribution , we transfer the partial hamiltonian @xmath126 as an example : @xmath127 with @xmath128 as the stark shift contributions due to spontaneous photons @xmath129 and due to coherent low - frequency photons @xmath130 . the two exponential functions in each of the contributions describe the stark shift of the upper level @xmath1 and of the lower level @xmath0 , respectively .
as expected , the shifts are proportional to the number of photons in the respective modes .
the difference in the photon number factors for the two states ( e.g. @xmath131 as compared to @xmath132 ) is due to the fact that the example hamiltonian part induces changes in the photon numbers . to evaluate their importance
, these contributions have to be compared to the exponential factor in equation ( [ example - ham ] ) .
there is at most one photon in the vacuum modes @xmath133 , thus @xmath129 may be safely neglected . for the low - frequency field , it is reasonable to assume a coherent state with a large mean number of photons @xmath134 , as this represents an intense laser field . as the relative photon number distribution width decreases as @xmath135 for coherent states , and as @xmath136 in the vacuum part of the three - photon hamiltonian , we approximate @xmath137 and thus have @xmath138 as the stark shift contribution .
it is important to note that the simulated model system does not loose its quantum character in adopting these approximations , which are less inspired by physical than by numerical reasoning , as we keep the photon operators and the distinguishable fock states for the electromagnetical fields .
the above argument holds for all terms in @xmath120 with the same result , thus these shifts may be taken care of by introducing an effective atomic transition frequency @xmath139 then the vacuum interaction part becomes @xmath140 this expression is equivalent to the interaction hamiltonian in @xcite , while we do not introduce the generalized ladder operators @xmath141 and @xmath142 ( @xmath143 ) here which were used in the semiclassical approximation in @xcite .
we proceed with the ansatz for the wavefunction @xmath144 here the first index in the kets denotes the atomic state , the second slot represents the number of photons in the low - frequency field , and the last entry is either @xmath145 for the vacuum without photons or @xmath10 for a single photon in mode @xmath10 .
as described earlier , we first derive an equation of motion for the state amplitudes due to the vacuum part of the hamiltonian @xmath146 , which we denote by @xmath147 and @xmath148 . in a second step ,
we calculate the equations corresponding to the driving part of the hamiltonian @xmath149 with amplitudes @xmath150 .
these two sets of equations of motion are then summed to give the equations for the full amplitudes @xmath151 and @xmath152 . inserting the ansatz equation ( [ ansatz ] ) in the schrdinger equation with hamiltonian @xmath146 yields as vacuum part of the equations of motion for the state amplitudes @xmath153
formally integrating ( [ eom - gkn ] ) and inserting the result in ( [ eom - en ] ) allows to obtain an equation of motion for the upper state amplitudes @xmath154 of the form @xmath155 where @xmath156 are time dependent coefficients depending on the coupling constants @xmath122 and @xmath157 .
expanding equation ( [ wigner ] ) , it turns out that all addends on the right hand side are of the form @xmath158 here , @xmath159 and @xmath160 are integers depending on the specific addend . @xmath161 and @xmath162 are one of the coefficients @xmath122 ( @xmath163 ) or @xmath157 ( @xmath164 ) respectively , written as products of the dipole moment corresponding to the spontaneous transition @xmath165 and @xmath166 and of the remaining factors @xmath167 and @xmath168 . in a wigner - weisskopf - like calculation , this generic contribution
may be evaluated to give @xmath169 here @xmath170 is the spontaneous decay rate of transition @xmath171 with transition frequency modified to @xmath172 , i.e. @xmath173 where @xmath174 is the spontaneous decay rate of transition @xmath171 with transition frequency @xmath175 , and @xmath176 is a prefactor describing the amount of quantum interference possible between transition @xmath177 and transition @xmath178 .
it is zero if the dipole moments are orthogonal and reaches its maximum value of 1 ( -1 ) for parallel ( antiparallel ) dipole moments .
thus we find the usual form of a square root of the product of the two corresponding spontaneous decay rates as characteristic for vacuum induced interference effects @xcite .
the @xmath179 and @xmath108 merely are prefactors which are present because the corresponding process is a multiphoton process . assuming as for the stark shift contributions that the photon number distribution width of the low - frequency field is negligible as compared to the number of photons @xmath134 , i.e. @xmath180 , one may introduce the low - frequency field rabi frequency in equation ( [ wigner ] ) given by @xmath181 for transition @xmath171 .
this finally leads to a system of equations for the upper state populations given by @xmath182 where the @xmath183 ( @xmath184 ) are constant coefficients , whose specific form which may be obtained by expanding equation ( [ wigner ] ) and ( [ specific ] ) is omitted here as e.g. @xmath185 contains of several hundred addends in its most general form .
the generalized stark shift contributions in the driving part @xmath149 of the hamiltonian give rise to an equation of motion for the upper atomic state amplitude which is given by @xmath186 with constant coefficients @xmath187 ( @xmath188 ) .
thus the total equation of motion of the upper atomic state amplitude @xmath151 is given by the sum of the right hand side of the two contributions of equations ( [ vac - part ] ) and ( [ driving - part ] ) upon replacement of the amplitudes @xmath154 and @xmath189 by @xmath151 : @xmath190 these equations are a generalization of equations ( 3 ) in @xcite , which means that they have the same structure , but different coefficients @xmath183 ( @xmath191 ) and @xmath187 ( @xmath188 ) than in @xcite . the difference is due to the fact that here we include stark shifts and do not use the semiclassical sum over all possible low - frequency photon numbers as in @xcite . some effects of these differences will be discussed in section [ results ] . in particular
, it will turn out later that the driving terms which may be interpreted as generalized stark shift terms do not change the decay dynamics of the simulated system in a notable manner . to simulate the system behavior
, one has to choose an initial number of photons @xmath134 in the low - frequency mode and a possible range of deviations @xmath192 from this number .
the set of state amplitudes considered in the analysis is then chosen as @xmath193 . in the equations of motion for these state amplitudes according to equation ( [ simul - eom ] )
all references to states outside the chosen set are neglected .
thus @xmath192 has to be chosen large enough such that the outermost states are barely populated during the calculated evolution time to avoid numerical artefacts due to the artificially added borders of the simulated level space . as initial condition
we choose @xmath194 thus the atom is in the excited state , the vacuum is assumed empty and the low frequency field is in a coherent state @xmath195 which simulates a strong quantized laser field .
the field parameter @xmath196 is given by @xmath197 as @xmath198 is the expectation value of the photon number in a coherent state .
the phase @xmath199 accounts for the possible complexity of @xmath196 . as only upper state amplitudes @xmath200 with @xmath201
are considered in the analysis , also the initial photon number distribution of the coherent state has to be restricted .
thus @xmath202 is a cutoff of the photon number distribution width chosen such that @xmath203 .
again , this avoids population losses at the borders of the simulated hilbert space .
@xmath110 is a normalization constant such that @xmath204 , which is required because of the cutoff width @xmath202 . as a rough consistency check , the range parameters @xmath192 and
@xmath202 must be chosen large enough for the specific system parameters such that increasing these values does not affect the result .
after solving this set of ( @xmath205 ) coupled ordinary differential equations the total upper state population may be obtained as @xmath206 this population may then be compared to the exponential decay for the two - state system without an additional low - frequency field .
partial level scheme of rubidium taken as the simulated model system .
the spontaneous emission of transition @xmath207 is to be slowed down by the discussed scheme .
the figure is not drawn to scale.,height=188 ] to demonstrate the feasibility of the scheme , we use rubidium as our model system .
the simulated atomic levels are shown in figure [ pic - rubidium ] .
the population is assumed to be in the @xmath208 state initially . without additional fields
, this state decays to the @xmath209 state with a decay rate of @xmath210 @xcite . as discussed in the previous section , within the adiabatic approximation the intermediate states
are never populated , see equation ( [ aux - pop ] ) .
thus it is possible to include states even if there are decay channels leading out of the simulated level space . also , low spontaneous decay rates do not in general mean that the corresponding transitions do not need to be taken into account , as the low rates may be due to the small energy spacing between two states .
the dipole moments however which are important for the low - frequency field may be comparable to the other transition dipole moments . in the simulation ,
only dipole - allowed transitions are considered .
this amounts to a simplification of the equation of the upper state amplitudes equation ( [ simul - eom ] ) by e.g. eliminating @xmath211 and @xmath212 which rely on dipole - forbidden transitions , as in addition to the spontaneous photon a second photon is exchanged with the low - frequency field .
the energies of the various states are given by @xcite @xmath213 the energy separation @xmath214 is about 55 mhz ; the main transition has a frequency of @xmath215 .
we consider decay rates as obtained by theoretical calculations in @xcite , where also the required branching ratios of the various decay pathways from the excited states are given : @xmath216 for the transitions which are listed in @xcite , the above values are in reasonable agreement with the data reported there .
the system parameters for the figures are chosen as @xmath217 , @xmath218 , @xmath219 , @xmath220 , @xmath221 mhz and @xmath222 if not stated otherwise .
dependence of the total upper state population on @xmath223 .
the chosen values are @xmath224 $ ] .
the graph order corresponds to the rabi frequency where the highest graph corresponds to the largest driving strength .
the graph for @xmath225 is almost on top of the dashed reference curve.,height=188 ] here @xmath134 only affects the initial population of the low - frequency fock states .
it is chosen independent of the field strength of the low - frequency field in order to estimate the dependence of the population dynamics on the initial conditions .
the value @xmath222 has been chosen for simplicity , but is not required to for our scheme to work . a calculation with a @xmath226-value of 0.5 reduces the trapping duration e.g. of the top curve in figure [ pic - om ] by less than a factor of 3 , such that the remaining effect is still considerable .
for this one should note that other than in most previously studied systems exhibiting quantum interference effects @xcite , in our setup non - zero values for @xmath227 can be found in any atomic system , which is due to the fact that here the two transitions do not need to have a similar transition frequency or a common atomic state . to speed up the numerical calculations , the driving terms in equation ( [ driving - part ] )
are suppressed by the replacement @xmath228 in equation ( [ simul - eom ] ) , where we choose @xmath229 in the following calculations . for
this one should note that for the above parameters the simulation consists of @xmath230 coupled complex differential equations .
the validity of this suppression is discussed in section [ results ] . in the following figures [ pic - om]-[pic - check ] , dashed lines
are reference curves given by @xmath231 .
dependence of the population trapping on the low - frequency field frequency @xmath5 .
chosen values are @xmath232 .
( a ) @xmath233 ; ( b ) @xmath234 ; ( c ) @xmath235 and ( d ) @xmath236 .
the two curves in ( d ) can be distinguished as the one corresponding to the lower frequency @xmath5 slightly wiggles .
the dashed curve is the reference.,height=188 ] the first figure [ pic - om ] shows the total upper state population @xmath237 for different values of @xmath223 .
the chosen values for this rabi frequency are @xmath224 $ ] . as expected an increasing rabi frequency of the low - frequency field increases the amount of trapping .
the reason for this is that the relative probability of low - frequency - field - assisted transitions increases with an increasing field strength .
however the rabi frequency must not be chosen too high as otherwise the adiabatic approximation is not valid any longer . also higher - order processes with more than three exchanged photons have to be considered if the rabi - frequency is chosen too large .
the rabi frequency @xmath238 chosen in most of the figures is about 1/40 of the atomic transition frequency @xmath239 , which is well within the validity range of the applied approximations .
figure [ pic - frequenz ] shows the role of the low - frequency field frequency @xmath5 .
the chosen values are @xmath232 , while the other parameters are chosen as in figure [ pic - om ] with @xmath240 .
as long as @xmath5 is low as compared to the natural decay width @xmath241 , the result is independent of @xmath5 and the population plots are on top of each other . for higher frequencies , the population trapping decreases until the oscillation due to @xmath5 is visible for @xmath242 .
the behavior of the system in the limit of small frequencies @xmath5 is somewhat different from the behavior found in @xcite . there
the trapping was found to improve with decreasing @xmath5 until in the limit @xmath243 the decay was completely stopped . as already discussed in @xcite ,
this is the expected behavior for the system simulated in @xcite which is equivalent to a system with near - degenerate upper states @xcite .
but while in our model in @xcite all other parameters were kept constant in changing @xmath5 , in the present analysis other parameters such as the various coupling strengths also change with @xmath5 , thus leading to a different behavior .
still the slowing down of the spontaneous emission is most pronounced for low values of @xmath5 .
however this is a key ingredient of all similar quantum interference effects @xcite which may be depicted as follows : the smaller the field frequency is , the harder is it to distinguish between the various interference pathways , which leads to stronger quantum interference effects . as the scheme relies on the fact that photons with nonzero frequency may be exchanged during atomic transitions , the singular case of zero frequency , i.e. a static field ,
is excluded from our analysis as in @xcite . in figure
[ pic - phase ] , the phase @xmath244 of the initial low - frequency field coherent state in equation ( [ initial ] ) is varied .
dependence of the population trapping on the phase of the initial low - frequency field coherent state .
the chosen values are @xmath245 $ ] .
plots are ( a ) for @xmath246 and the dashed reference , ( b ) for @xmath247 , ( c ) for @xmath248 , and ( d ) for @xmath249.,height=188 ] the chosen values are @xmath245 $ ] ; the other parameters are chosen as in figure [ pic - om ] with @xmath240 .
the phase of the initial coherent state crucially influences the decay dynamics of the effective two - level system . by choosing the phase
, the effective spontaneous decay varies between the usual decay rate @xmath250 and the maximum trapping for @xmath251 .
this may be understood from equation ( [ simul - eom ] ) which shows that the decay dynamics of the state amplitude @xmath151 depends on the neighboring amplitudes @xmath252 ( @xmath253 ) which change relative to @xmath151 with varying phase @xmath244 .
figure [ pic - check ] ( a ) shows that the initial photon distribution width of the coherent low - frequency laser field does not influence the result of the numerical calculation notably .
this is a consistency check of the approximate coherent state in the ansatz for the wavefunction equation ( [ initial ] ) .
the chosen values are @xmath254 ; the other parameters are chosen as in figure [ pic - om ] with @xmath240 .
figure [ pic - check ] ( b ) shows that the number of photons of the coherent low - frequency laser field does not visibly influence the result of the numerical simulation . to evaluate the influence of the initial conditions , this value was chosen independent from the intensity of the low - frequency field .
consistency checks of the simulation .
( a ) dependence of the population trapping on the initial laser distribution width @xmath202 .
the chosen values are @xmath254 .
( b ) dependence of the population trapping on the number of photons in the low - frequency mode considered in the simulation .
the chosen values are @xmath255 .
( c ) dependence of the population trapping on the driving strength considered in the simulation .
the chosen values are @xmath256 .
( d ) dependence of the population trapping on the number of simulated photon number states .
the chosen values are @xmath257 . in all subfigures , all plots but
the dashed reference are on top of each other .
, height=188 ] the chosen values are @xmath255 ; the other parameters are chosen as in figure [ pic - om ] with @xmath240 . increasing @xmath134 broadens the initial photon number distribution .
however if @xmath134 is large enough , neighboring photon number states have similar amplitudes up to a possible phase .
this does not change notably for increasing @xmath134 , and as the equation of motion for state amplitude @xmath151 depends on the neighboring amplitudes @xmath252 ( @xmath253 ) as discussed before , the results are independent of @xmath134 if it is not too small .
figure [ pic - check ] ( c ) shows the dependence of the population trapping on the damping factor @xmath258 of the driving terms which was introduced in equation ( [ damping ] ) to speed up the numerical calculations .
the chosen values are @xmath256 ; the other parameters are chosen as in figure [ pic - om ] with @xmath240 .
the figure does not show a dependence on the damping of the driving strength .
this may be explained along the lines of the interpretation of figures [ pic - check ] ( a ) and ( b ) , as these driving terms merely account for a broadening of the photon number distribution of the low - frequency field .
the trapping mechanism however does not rely on a specific distribution width .
also , the driving terms are due to the same interactions as the ones which lead to the stark shift discussed before .
the last consistency check is shown in figure [ pic - check ] ( d ) , where the number of simulated photon number states @xmath192 is varied .
the chosen values are @xmath257 ; the other parameters are chosen as in figure [ pic - om ] with @xmath240 .
again , there is no visible dependence on @xmath192 for the chosen values which shows that @xmath218 is large enough to eliminate errors due to border losses .
in summing up , we have derived an explicit expression for the multiphoton hamiltonian describing the interaction of an atomic two - level system with both the vacuum field and an additional intense low - frequency laser field including up to three - photon processes .
this hamiltonian was used in a quantum mechanical simulation of the decay dynamics of a two level atom subject to the intense low - frequency laser field and the vacuum field modes . using this simulation
it was shown that the usual spontaneous decay found on one of the transitions in rubidium may be decelerated considerably by a suitably chosen low - frequency field .
support by the german national academic foundation for je and funding by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( sfb 276 ) is gratefully acknowledged .
we thank u.d .
jentschura for helpful discussions related to the parameters of the chosen model system .
in this appendix explicit expressions for the first - order transition operators calculated in section [ higher - order ] are given .
these transition operators may be written as @xmath259 the corresponding operators @xmath260 and @xmath69 may be obtained by conjugation .
the operators @xmath261 ( @xmath262 ) are proportional to @xmath263 .
they are given by 99 scully m o and zubairy m s 1997 _ quantum optics _
, cambridge university press agarwal g s , scully m o and walther h 2001 _ phys .
lett . _ * 86
* 4271 + kofman a g and kurizki g 2001 _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 87 * 270405 purcell e m 1946 _ phys .
_ * 69 * 681 + haroche s and kleppner d 1989 _ phys .
_ * 42 * 24 zhu s y and scully m o 1996 _ phys
lett . _ * 76 * 388 + zhu s y , narducci l m and scully m o 1995 _ phys .
* 4791 + huang h , zhu s y and zubairy m s 1997 _ phys . rev . a _ * 55 * 744 + scully m o and zhu s y 1998 _ science _ * 281 * 1973 + frishman e and shapiro m 2001 _ phys .
lett . _ * 87 * 253001 knight p l 1979 3297 + knight
p l and milonni p 1980 _ phys .
rep . _ * 66 * 21 + coleman p e , knight p l and burnett k 1982 _ opt
. comm . _ * 42 * 171 + narducci l m , scully m o , oppo g l , ru p and tredicce j r 1990 _ phys .
rev . a _ * 42 * 1630 + manka a s , doss h m , narducci l m , ru p , oppo g l 1991 _ phys . rev . a _ * 43 * 3748 + gauthier d j , zhu y and mossberg t w 1991 _ phys .
lett . _ * 66 * 2460 + zhou p and swain s 1996 _ phys .
lett . _ * 77 * 3995 +
paspalakis e and knight p l 1998 _ phys .
lett . _ * 81 * 293 + keitel c h 1999 _ phys . rev .
* 83 * 1307 + agarwal g s 2000 _ phys .
lett . _ * 84 * 5500 cardimona d a , raymer m g and stroud jr . c r 1982 65 ficek z 2001 _ advances in chemical physics _ , * 119 * , wiley , new york , part 1 and references therein + swain s and ficek z 2002 _ j. mod
. opt . _ * 49 * 1 + evers j , bullock d and keitel c h 2002 _ opt .
comm . _ * 209 * 173 feranchuk i d 1981 _ phys .
lett . _ * 83a * 126 feranchuk i d , komarov l i and ulyanenkov a 2002 3957 evers j and keitel c h 2002 _ phys .
* 89 * 163601 berman p r 2004 _ phys .
lett . _ * 92 * 159301 + kofman a g 2004 _ phys .
lett . _ * 92 * 159302 + evers
j and keitel c h 2004 _ phys .
lett . _ * 92 * 159303 kocharovskaya o , mandel p and scully m o 1995 _ phys .
lett . _ * 74 * 2451 borrmann g 1950 _ z. phys . _ * 127 * 297 + decamp m f _ et . al .
_ 2001 _ nature _ * 413 * 825 afanasev a m and kagan yu m 1965 _ zh . exsp .
fiz . _ * 48 * 327 + voitovetskii v k , korsunskii
i l , novikov a i and pazhin yu f 1970 _ pisma zh .
* 11 * 149 cardimona d a , kovanis v and sharma m p 1993 _ phys . rev .
a _ * 47 * , 1227 allen l and stroud c r 1982 _ phys . rep . _ * 91 * , 1 + zhu s y and li x s 1987 _ phys .
rev . a _ * 36 * 3889 + alsing p and zubairy m s 1987 _ j. opt .
b _ * 4 * 177 + zhu s y and scully m o 1988 _ phys . rev . a _ * 38 * 5433 + puri
r r and bullough r k 1988 _ j. opt .
b _ * 5 * 2021 + lugiato l a , galatola p and narducci l m 1990 _ opt . commun . _
* 76 * 276 + toor a h and zubairy m s 1992 _ phys . rev .
a _ * 45 * 4951 + harris s e 1994 _ opt .
* 19 * 2018 zubairy m s and yeh j j 1980 _ phys . rev .
* 21 * 1624 + sellin p b , yu c c , bochinski j r and mossberg t w , 1997 _ phys .
lett . _ * 78 * 1432 mollow b r 1969 _ phys . rev . _
* 188 * 1969 bochinsky j r , yu c c , loftus t , mossberg t w 2001 _ phys . rev .
a _ * 63 * 051402(r ) puri r r 2001 _ mathematical methods of quantum optics _
, springer series in optical sciences , berlin heavens o s 1961 _ j. opt .
* 51 * 1058 nist atomic spectra database + theodosiou e 1984 _ phys . rev . a _ * 30 * 2881 zhu s y , chan r c f and lee c p 1995 _ phys .
a _ * 52 * 710 | the spontaneous emission is investigated for an effective atomic two - level system in an intense coherent field with frequency lower than the vacuum - induced decay width . as this additional low - frequency field is assumed to be intense , multiphoton processes may be induced , which can be seen as alternative transition pathways in addition to the simple spontaneous decay .
the interplay of the various interfering transition pathways influences the decay dynamics of the two - level system and may be used to slow down the spontaneous decay considerably .
we derive from first principles an expression for the hamiltonian including up to three - photon processes .
this hamiltonian is then applied to a quantum mechanical simulation of the decay dynamics of the two - level system .
finally , we discuss numerical results of this simulation based on a rubidium atom and show that the spontaneous emission in this system may be suppressed substantially . |
modern experiments in atomic and molecular physics often use widely tunable lasers and require both large tunability and precise frequency stabilization . in many cases , spectroscopy has to be performed with stable lasers in a large frequency range to find and characterize initially unknown atomic or molecular states , for example for the production of molecules from ultracold atoms@xcite or magneto - optical trapping of molecules@xcite .
furthermore , it can be beneficial to address different known transitions spaced several ghz or even tens of ghz sequentially with a single laser .
for example , we use a mid - infrared optical parametric oscillator ( opo ) to excite a number of rovibrational transitions spaced more than 10ghz in cold molecules held in an electrostatic trap@xcite .
frequency switching on a millisecond timescale allows us to perform motional cooling , rotational - state preparation , and state detection with a single laser in the same run of an experiment@xcite .
self - referenced optical frequency combs ( ofc)@xcite which are now available commercially have become a common tool for stabilizing lasers in a wide bandwidth by stabilizing the radiofrequency beat note between the laser and a mode of the ofc .
a number of methods have been developed to achieve both absolute frequency stability and large tunability over many comb modes of a continuous - wave ( cw ) laser or opo referenced to an ofc . for tuning , the comb@xcite , the cw laser@xcite , or both@xcite can be scanned .
tuning over 10ghz without changing the frequency lock has been demonstrated by adding an external electro - optic modulator@xcite .
further , phase - stable tuning over almost 30ghz in about a second has been achieved by shifting the carrier - envelope offset frequency of the ofc between subsequent pulses of the ofc@xcite .
the objective of this work was to build a device tuning our frequency - comb - referenced opo over tens of ghz in a couple of milliseconds , yet stabilizing the opo to sub - mhz precision on single frequencies .
these requirements were set because we wanted to drive several rovibrational transitions in polyatomic molecules quasi - simultaneously for optical pumping , demanding frequency switching in a time shorter than the typical decay time of vibrational excitations .
additionally , the ofc s spectrum should remain unchanged during frequency tuning of the opo such that several independent lasers can be stabilized to the same ofc . in this paper , we demonstrate fast , precise and widely tunable frequency control of the idler wave of a singly - resonant opo by controlling the frequencies of pump and signal which are referenced to the ofc .
we show tuning over more than , with ramps performed in less than .
although not actively stabilized during a ramp , the opo frequencies are instantly relocked to the ofc at the end of each ramp .
sequences of fast ramps to any idler frequency within the mode - hop free tuning range can be performed hands - free and reliably .
when the laser frequency is ramped relative to the frequency of a certain comb mode . if the laser frequency lies about midway between two comb modes , the lowest and next to lowest beat frequencies are close to each other which is indicated by the dashed extensions of the tooth structure . ] the frequency control mechanism is based on beating the laser with an ofc and using the lowest beat note for frequency tracking during tuning and for precise stabilization .
the principle is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : beat ] .
the lowest `` signed '' beat frequency @xmath0 determines the laser frequency with respect to the nearest comb mode .
`` signed '' refers to @xmath0 being positive ( negative ) if the closest comb mode has a smaller ( larger ) optical frequency .
@xmath0 is confined by the repetition rate @xmath1 of the mode - locked laser generating the ofc : @xmath2 .
consequently , tuning the frequency of the laser results in a regular tooth structure of @xmath3 as shown .
we start with the laser being locked to the ofc at a known absolute optical frequency . to perform a frequency ramp ,
the lock is switched off and the frequency is swept while continuously measuring @xmath0 and counting the comb modes passed . once the target frequency is reached , the ramp is stopped and the laser is instantly relocked to the ofc by stabilizing @xmath0 at a value of choice .
the main difficulty of controlling the beat frequency during tuning over many comb lines lies in correct handling of the frequency ranges in which the laser frequency coincides with a comb mode or lies midway between two modes . in
the former case @xmath0 is zero , in the latter the lowest and next higher beat frequencies are degenerate and can be mixed up ( see fig .
[ fig : beat]b ) . demonstrated solutions to this problem include sudden jumps to a beat note of opposite sign via a sudden step of a control voltage@xcite or the use of an acousto - optic modulator@xcite to avoid such regions of the spectrum . in both cases , a lock to the ofc
was maintained during frequency tuning @xcite possibly limiting the speed .
our frequency tracking approach allows for fast ramping to a target frequency independent of the locking electronics .
we can simply ignore frequency measurements in the delicate parts of the spectrum and interpolate the frequency there without losing track of it . to ensure sufficient suppression of beat frequencies of higher order near @xmath4 and block low - frequency noise we chose to filter the beat note with a pass band of 10 to 115 mhz ( points of filters ) .
this permits clean measurements of @xmath0 inside the pass band .
an example of a measurement for the signal wave of the opo during a linear ramp is shown in fig .
[ fig : signalramp ] .
the data was directly obtained with the control electronics ( see sec . [
sec : electronics ] ) and its quality already suggests that tracking of the optical frequency will be possible . ) .
the dashed lines mark the points of the radio - frequency filters . outside the pass band
the frequency counter measures noise . ] due to the unavoidable filtering , the parts of the beat spectrum outside the pass band of the filters are not directly accessible to frequency measurement and locking . if one wanted to control the frequency of a single laser beam and demanded locking of the laser to an arbitrary optical frequency inside the tuning range , an additional frequency shifter , e.g. , an electro- or acousto - optic modulator , would have to be introduced@xcite .
it would shift the frequency by , e.g. , 20mhz if the desired lock frequency lies in the clipped areas of the beat spectrum .
we note that this shift would have to be applied once per ramp , independent of the number of comb modes crossed for that ramp .
we apply the frequency control scheme to the idler wave of a singly - resonant opo ( see sec . [
sec : setup ] and fig .
[ fig : opo ] ) . in our case
the aforementioned filtering does not pose any restrictions .
the idler frequency @xmath5 can be changed by independently tuning the pump laser ( @xmath6 ) or the signal frequency @xmath7 which is resonant to the opo cavity and we reference the latter two to the ofc .
the optical frequency of each comb mode @xmath8 of a self - referenced ofc is @xmath9 with the carrier - envelope offset frequency @xmath10 .
then , we find @xmath11 , where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the signed beat frequencies of pump and signal with the comb .
thus , the idler frequency can be expressed as @xmath14 note that @xmath10 cancels here . for reasons which will be explained later , the final lock point of the pump beam @xmath12
is always set to be well separated from the filter cut - off , @xmath15 .
the idler frequency can then be ramped to arbitrary values without employing additional frequency shifters by choosing @xmath13 appropriately inside the pass band of the filters .
a simple sketch of the optical part of the experimental apparatus is shown in fig . [
fig : opo ] . the commercially available cw opo ( lockheed martin aculight , argos 2400-sf-15 , module c ) , which has been described in detail elsewhere@xcite , is pumped with up to at and generates an idler wave in the range of to .
coarse wavelength tuning of idler and signal is realized by varying the position of the periodically poled nonlinear crystal and the tilt angle of an intracavity etalon with a free spectral range of .
although it has been shown before that both elements can be tuned with a computer - controlled algorithm@xcite , for us a manual adjustment of those two components suffices .
a piezo - electric transducer ( pzt ) varying the cavity length allows mode - hop - free tuning of the signal frequency over more than one free spectral range of the cavity which is about .
the pump frequency can be tuned continuously over by strain variation of the seed laser fiber length via another pzt element , which is the main tuning mechanism used to adjust the idler frequency during experiments .
the setup provides two complementary modes of frequency measurement .
first , fast and precise frequency measurements relative to a known initial frequency are obtained with the ofc .
therefore , we beat a few mw of pump and signal light with radiation from a self - referenced ofc synthesizer ( menlo systems , fc1500 ) , which provides a frequency comb with @xmath16 mode spacing at and about 1510 to . repetition rate and offset frequency are stabilized to a stable reference obtained from an h@xmath17-maser .
the resulting beat notes of pump and signal beams are measured with high speed ingaas photodiodes ( thorlabs , det01cfc ) and processed further by the electronics .
second , the idler frequency can be determined with an absolute accuracy of @xmath18 with a calibrated wavemeter ( bristol instruments , 621a - ir ) .
however , wavemeter measurements can be performed with a maximum rate of and after large frequency ramps the device needs up to about to adjust to the new frequency and display correct results .
the wavemeter is used to fix the absolute optical frequency once before fast ramps can be performed .
the structure of the custom - built electronics controlling the two beat frequencies and hence the optical frequencies of the opo reflects the fact that the opo system can basically be in two states : performing a frequency ramp or being locked to frequencies of choice .
ramps are controlled by a microcontroller that measures and adjusts all relevant parameters .
the microcontroller is an atmel at91sam7xc256 with 32bit arm - based architecture which runs custom software programmed in c. the software is specialized to our opo and our experimental sequences but it is available from the authors upon request . for precise stabilization to a single frequency between two ramps
we use an analog proportional - integral ( pi ) regulation circuit@xcite . except for the microcontroller
all components exist twice as we have to control the pump and the signal beam of the opo .
a schematic of the electronics is displayed in fig .
[ fig : electronics ] . the beat signal recorded by the photo diode is filtered ( pass band ) and amplified ( red box in the figure ) . for frequency
ramping and tracking ( green box ) the beat signal is digitized by a frequency counter with a high sampling rate of . based on the frequency measurement the microcontroller applies voltage ramps to the pzt element of the laser ( via a high precision , low - noise dac and a fast , low - noise high voltage amplifier ) and
thus ramps the laser frequency .
once the laser is at the desired frequency , the pi regulation circuit stabilizes the beat frequency ( blue box in schematic ) .
a reference frequency in the range of is generated via direct digital synthesis . comparing the recorded beat signal and the reference
, a custom - built phase - frequency detector produces an error signal that is fed to the pi controller .
the output voltage of the pi controller is scaled such that the frequency range covered by the pi regulation loop is rather small , on the order of .
the total voltage applied to the pzts via the high voltage amplifiers is a sum of two contributions , the output of the dac set by the microcontroller and the output of the pi controller .
consequently , for both pump and signal the microcontroller sets the optical frequency approximately by adjusting the dac voltage during a ramp , which can span many ghz . on top of that , precise frequency stabilization is realized with the analog control loop .
when the laser is locked to a fixed frequency , the microcontroller measures the output voltage of the pi controller with a built - in adc and adjusts the dac voltage if the pi voltage approaches a border of the regulation range due to long - term drifts .
note that the microcontroller also controls the reference frequency for the beat lock , can switch the pi controller on and off and receives measurements from the wavemeter .
thus , it is capable of controlling the frequencies of the opo fully automatized during ramps and while being locked to the ofc .
in this section , we explain in detail the implementation of fast frequency ramps of the idler starting with the opo being locked to the ofc at a known absolute frequency @xmath19 ( cf .
[ sec : basics ] ) . as mentioned before ,
the only optical frequency of interest for us is the idler frequency .
furthermore , idler tuning is mainly accomplished by tuning the pump laser , whereas the signal frequency is ramped only for fine tuning . for internal bookkeeping
, we therefore process the frequencies in a simplified manner as @xmath20 , with the contributions from the pump @xmath21 and from the signal beam @xmath22 .
our basic protocol for a frequency ramp is the following .
first , the target frequencies ( lock frequencies ) @xmath23 and @xmath24 are calculated with the boundary conditions @xmath25 and @xmath26 . the latter condition is just given by the pass band of the radio - frequency filters .
note again that these conditions do not restrict the idler frequency to specific values .
second , the pi controllers are switched off , i.e. , the lock to the ofc is released .
in fact , we only switch off the integral parts for technical reasons .
this ensures that the controllers are in well - defined states at the time of relock .
third , the reference frequencies for the final beat lock are set .
fourth , the optical frequencies of pump and signal are ramped towards the target values , and @xmath27 and @xmath28 are tracked by repeatedly measuring the beat frequencies .
the voltage applied to the pzts and the frequency counter measurements are updated every .
finally , the opo is relocked to the ofc as soon as the target frequencies are reached by reactivating the pi controllers .
special attention has to be paid to the frequency ramping and tracking part for two reasons .
first , the tracking algorithm has to discard beat frequency measurements in the clipped areas of the beat spectrum ( see fig . [
fig : signalramp ] ) and interpolate the frequency there .
second , many piezo - electric crystals show a nonlinear response to an applied voltage ramp . in particular , for the pzt in our pump laser we observe a delayed response of the piezo to an applied voltage and drifts of the laser frequency after the end of a fast voltage ramp . even for a fixed step size ,
the delay and further drift depend on the direction of the voltage ramp , the amplitude , the slew rate , and the starting voltage .
this precludes the use of any kind of look - up table relating an applied voltage to a particular frequency and is one of the main reasons for implementing the frequency tracking with `` live '' feedback .
frequency tracking is identical for both pump and signal . in every step of the ramp ( every ) a predicted laser frequency @xmath29 and
a predicted frequency change for the next step @xmath30 are calculated as follows . a preliminary value @xmath31 is obtained from @xmath32 .
to compare the predicted value with measurement , the signed beat frequency @xmath33 is computed from @xmath31 modulo @xmath1 .
@xmath34 , if @xmath35 ; @xmath36 , if @xmath37 . ] .
only if @xmath33 lies in a frequency range where good counter measurements are expected , i.e. , in the pass band of the filters , we calculate the deviation of the measured value @xmath38 from the predicted frequency as @xmath39 finally , the two parameters of interest are corrected as @xmath40 with numerical factors @xmath41 and @xmath42 . to be less sensitive to single measurement errors we continuously average over a few consecutive steps of the calculation by choosing these factors smaller than unity . as a result ,
this frequency tracking approach is quite insensitive to single corrupted measurements .
moreover , it requires only a few data points per slope of the beat frequency tooth structure to work properly .
we perform all ramps starting with a fixed voltage change per step . consequently , the initial values for the expected frequency change @xmath43 are not changing and can be predetermined experimentally for each of the two beams .
the ramp speed and the frequency span , however , differ quite significantly for pump and signal .
ramps of the signal frequency are always much shorter than , as they are used for fine tuning only .
consequently , the duration of a signal ramp does not limit the overall performance of the system and we can ramp with relatively low speed . we chose a constant step size of 1v/16s which translates to a ramp speed of about 188mhz / ms .
for these settings we do not observe any significant delays in response or further drifts of the frequency after the end of the ramp .
the signal can be directly locked to the ofc by switching on the pi controller , if the measured beat frequency is close to the target frequency .
in contrast , the ramp has to be optimized more carefully for the pump beam , because ramps span many ghz , the response of the pzt has to be taken into account , and speed matters in this case as it sets the timescale of the entire frequency ramp .
we start the ramp with a step size of 0.1v/16s which corresponds to about 3ghz / ms in the middle of a frequency ramp . to prevent an overshoot , we significantly slow down the ramp at its end and regulate the applied voltage .
the slowdown of the pump ramp and the regulation at its end have two contributions , ensuring effective compensation of the delayed response and further drifts of the pzt and hence the optical frequency .
both are applied once the target frequency is closer than 2ghz .
first , the voltage change @xmath44 applied to the pzt per step is decreased from initially 0.1v to zero approximately proportional to the square root of the frequency difference to the target .
this would ideally lead to a linear decrease of ramp speed in time , if the pzt would not show hysteresis . to compensate the overshoot of the pzt
we additionally apply a correction to the voltage change @xmath44 which is proportional to the difference between the expected linear decrease and the actual frequency change @xmath45 . during the very last part of the ramp , when the pump frequency is less than 20mhz away from the target , an effective proportional - differential regulation is implemented by adjusting @xmath44 as @xmath46 with numerical factors @xmath47 . as a result , the actual laser frequency @xmath48 quickly settles to its target value @xmath49 .
this final regulation in the frequency interval of @xmath50mhz around the target frequency is the reason for restricting the target beat frequency of the pump laser to a narrower band than the pass band of the radio - frequency filters ( see above ) . for the pump beam
we simply need some `` frequency space '' to slow the ramp down .
the aforementioned details of the frequency ramping procedure are also visible in data recorded with the control electronics .
figure [ fig : rampanalysis ] shows a ramp of the pump laser spanning almost 14ghz . in part
( a ) we plot frequency vs. time , in particular the measured beat frequency @xmath51 and the predicted value @xmath52 calculated by the tracking algorithm .
the agreement is excellent .
additionally , the predicted frequency change per step @xmath53 is shown . from the curves
it is evident that the ramp starts slowly due to the delayed response of the pzt , but accelerates quite quickly as a constant @xmath44 per step is applied ( fig .
[ fig : rampanalysis](b ) ) .
the slowdown of the ramp is also apparent in both the beat frequency tooth structure and @xmath53 . during the final regulation towards the target
beat frequency of 60mhz there are some oscillations visible .
we believe that further optimization of the ramp parameters can eliminate the oscillations , but did not find that the effort is necessary at the moment . in the figure ,
the vertical dashed lines mark the switch - on of the pi controller after 8.4ms of ramp time .
as expected the beat frequency is stable from that point on .
we plot the output voltage of the pi controller during the whole frequency ramp ( see fig .
[ fig : rampanalysis](c ) ) .
the fact that the voltage stays close to zero , i.e. in the center of the regulation range of @xmath54\,\mathrm{v}$ ] , all the time demonstrates the instant relock of the opo to the ofc after the ramp .
to this point , we only described the control of the idler frequency via fast ramps starting from a known value . in this section ,
we outline how we fix and determine the opo frequency initially and verify it during experiments . for the precise determination of the absolute idler frequency we use the wavemeter in conjunction with the beat frequencies of pump and signal . for the determination of the initial idler frequency @xmath19
the following protocol is employed .
starting from a random point , we slowly ramp the frequencies of pump and signal until the corresponding beat frequencies are equal to @xmath55 and @xmath56 and beat - lock the opo to the ofc . then , the wavemeter is read out and @xmath57 in the above equation is determined from the reading . as @xmath57 is a multiple of 250mhz in our setup , a wavemeter with an accuracy on the order of 100mhz would suffice to determine the idler frequency to sub - mhz precision . from there , fast frequency ramps to any frequency within the tuning range can be performed .
this initial frequency determination which is fully automated takes a couple of seconds . during our experiments with cold molecules
we verify the idler frequency at least once per experimental sequence .
we therefore reserve a couple of seconds in which no frequency ramps are performed and the opo is locked to a fixed frequency for the wavemeter readout . in single experimental sequences
we often perform a couple of thousand frequency ramps . checking the absolute frequency
only once assumes that the system does not perform multiple ramps with errors of @xmath58250mhz which exactly cancel each other .
however , after months of experiments with more than @xmath59 ramps performed on some days we have no indication that such errors occur in practice .
all other errors , e.g. , a lock to a beat frequency of wrong sign or a pi controller running at a limit of the regulation range , are detected by the control software or during verification with the wavemeter . in the case of an error ,
the data obtained in this sequence is discarded , the opo is relocked automatically , and the measurement is resumed .
in the final section of the paper we want to discuss the performance of the system .
in particular , we evaluate the accessible frequency range and the duration of frequency ramps with different amplitude .
our approach of frequency control allows tuning over a broad range , limited by the mode - hop free tuning range of the laser . for our pump laser a tuning range of 100ghz
is specified .
however , we are limited to about 70ghz by our high - voltage amplifier at the moment . to demonstrate the tuning capability we perform a sequence of frequency ramps spanning tens of mhz up to more than 60ghz . the data is displayed in fig .
[ fig : rampseq ] and consists of ramps to 22 target idler frequencies and back to the initial value of 88920ghz . here ,
the frequency is verified by reading out the wavemeter after every ramp . the programmed sequence and the measured frequency
are shown in fig .
[ fig : rampseq](a ) .
the wavemeter sometimes needs up to 2s to adjust to the new frequency and display a correct result . apart from that we observe a perfect overlap . to demonstrate not only wide ramps but also precise locking anywhere inside the tuning range we chose target idler frequencies with random offsets to the ofc .
as these offsets are not visible in part ( a ) , we show them in fig .
[ fig : rampseq](b ) where we plot the target frequencies modulo @xmath16 . to verify the instant relock to the ofc after each ramp we recorded the output voltages of the pi controllers with an oscilloscope ( fig .
[ fig : rampseq](c ) ) .
figure [ fig : ramptime ] shows the ramp duration vs. the amplitude of a ramp . the time was measured with an oscilloscope during the sequence discussed in the previous paragraph . for ramps spanning more than 2ghz we observe a ramp speed of 2.9ghz / ms plus about 3ms offset for the slowdown of the ramp and the relock to the ofc .
shorter ramps are performed in about 3ms . with these values
we did not reach the maximum tuning speed of our pump laser yet .
we are rather limited by the repetition rate of the frequency counter , because we need a couple of frequency measurements on each slope of the beat frequency tooth structure ( see fig .
[ fig : rampanalysis](a ) ) for correct frequency tracking . consequently , faster tuning could be easily achieved with faster electronics .
we note that the time needed for short frequency ramps could be lowered substantially with some further optimization of ramp parameters .
we have demonstrated a method for frequency control of lasers referenced to an optical frequency comb .
our approach allows for fast and wide tuning of the laser over many ghz and within milliseconds and grants frequency stabilization to sub - mhz precision .
we implemented the technique for an opo , but it is suitable for any widely tunable continuous wave laser which can be referenced to an ofc .
the frequencies of the ofc are not manipulated and , thus , the ofc can be shared among different laboratories and for control of many lasers .
we developed the system and optimized the ramping algorithm in order to address several rovibrational transitions in trapped molecules in the same experimental sequence and with a single opo .
frequency ramping over many ghz on a millisecond timescale allows us to address molecules in many rotational states shortly after each other .
we use this to control the internal molecular state by performing optical pumping on several transitions quasi - simultaneously .
flexible frequency tuning additionally permits us to use one opo as a multi - purpose laser performing cooling , state preparation , and depletion spectroscopy in the same run of an experiment@xcite .
using the system described here , we demonstrated rotational cooling of methyl fluoride ( ch@xmath60f ) @xcite ( idler wave of opo at wavelength of 3.4 m ) and optoelectrical cooling@xcite of formaldehyde ( h@xmath17co ) to the ultracold regime@xcite ( idler wave at 3.6 m ) . to facilitate experiments , the software running on the microcontroller can perform sequences of ramps and stabilize the opo to many different frequencies autonomously .
additionally , the opo can be controlled ( within its electrical tuning range ) remotely from a computer via the microcontroller .
our control software also relocks the opo automatically whenever an error is detected and resumes any running experimental sequence .
this allows for around - the - clock , hands - free measurements in the present setup . with a properly aligned system , we routinely perform more than @xmath59 frequency ramps without a single error . 31ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1163861 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/17/7/075016 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.116.063004 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jms.2015.07.009 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.263003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.115.233001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/17/5/055022 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.84.5102 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.31.003594 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.22.032429 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.10.000515 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.30.002323 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.38.000555 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ao.53.007476 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.40.004372 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.17.004890 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ao.45.004910 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.21.005793 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.39.004080 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.20.009178 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/opex.14.000767 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s00340 - 006 - 2342 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4776179 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.77.783 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.80.041401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.116.063005 [ * * , ( ) ] | optical frequency combs ( ofc ) provide a convenient reference for the frequency stabilization of continuous - wave lasers .
we demonstrate a frequency control method relying on tracking over a wide range and stabilizing the beat note between the laser and the ofc .
the approach combines fast frequency ramps on a millisecond timescale in the entire mode - hop free tuning range of the laser and precise stabilization to single frequencies .
we apply it to a commercially available optical parametric oscillator ( opo ) and demonstrate tuning over more than 60ghz with a ramping speed up to 3ghz / ms .
frequency ramps spanning 15ghz are performed in less than 10ms , with the opo instantly relocked to the ofc after the ramp at any desired frequency .
the developed control hardware and software is able to stabilize the opo to sub - mhz precision and to perform sequences of fast frequency ramps automatically . |
let @xmath1 be the projective plane over the galois field @xmath11 .
an @xmath12 -arc is a set of @xmath12 points no three of which are collinear .
an @xmath12-arc is called complete if it is not contained in an @xmath13-arc of @xmath1 . for an introduction in projective geometries over finite fields ,
see @xcite,@xcite,@xcite . in @xcite,@xcite the close relationship between the theory of @xmath12-arcs , coding theory and mathematical statistics
is presented . in particular , a complete arc in a plane @xmath14 points of which are treated as 3-dimensional @xmath15-ary columns , defines a parity check matrix of a @xmath15-ary linear code with codimension 3 , hamming distance 4 , and covering radius 2 .
arcs can be interpreted as linear maximum distance separable ( mds ) codes @xcite,@xcite and they are related to optimal coverings arrays @xcite and to superregular matrices @xcite .
one of the main problems in the study of projective planes , which is also of interest in coding theory , is finding of the spectrum of possible sizes of complete arcs .
in particular , the value of @xmath0 , the smallest size of a complete arc in @xmath14 is interesting .
finding an estimation of the minimum size @xmath0 is a hard open problem .
this work is devoted to _
upper bounds _ on @xmath0 .
surveys of results on the sizes of plane complete arcs , methods of their construction and comprehension of the relating properties can be found in @xcite-@xcite,@xcite,@xcite-@xcite,@xcite-@xcite .
problems connected with small complete plane arcs are considered in @xcite-@xcite,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite , @xcite-@xcite,@xcite,@xcite , @xcite-@xcite,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite , see also the references therein .
the exact values of @xmath0 are known only for @xmath16 see @xcite and recent work @xcite where the equalities @xmath17 are proven . also , there are the following lower bounds ( see @xcite,@xcite ) : @xmath18 let @xmath19 be the size of the smallest complete arc in any ( not necessarily galois ) projective plane @xmath20 of order @xmath15
. in @xcite , for _ sufficiently large _
@xmath15 , the following result is proved ( we give it in the form of ( * ? ? ? * tab.2.6 ) ) : @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are constants independent of @xmath15 ( i.e. universal constants ) .
the logarithm basis is not noted as the estimate is asymptotic . following to @xcite
, we denote the aggregates of @xmath15 values : @xmath24 let @xmath25 be the smallest _ known _ size of a complete arc in @xmath1 . for @xmath26 the values of @xmath25 ( up to june 2009 )
are collected in ( * ? ? ?
* tab.1 ) whence it follows that @xmath27 for @xmath26 . in @xcite , see also @xcite , complete @xmath28-arcs are obtained for @xmath29 odd , @xmath30 or @xmath31 . in @xcite,@xcite
complete @xmath28-arcs are obtained for even @xmath32 in this work we showed that @xmath33 so , it holds that @xmath34 for @xmath35 and @xmath36 the values of @xmath37 ( up to june 2011 ) are collected in where the following results are obtained : @xmath38 @xmath39 moreover , in @xcite the following conjectures were proposed : [ conj1 _ ln0.75 ] _
@xcite _ in @xmath14 @xmath40 [ conj1_5sqrt_q ] _
@xcite _ in @xmath14 @xmath41 in this work we obtained many new small arcs and extended and improved results of @xcite .
we have proved conjecture [ conj1_5sqrt_q ] , see theorem [ th1_<4.5_5 ] .
results of this work allow us to hope that conjectures [ conj1 _ ln0.75 ] is true .
we denote the aggregates of @xmath15 values : @xmath42 in this paper we obtained complete arcs with sizes smaller than in @xcite ( i.e. we improved upper bounds on @xmath0 ) for @xmath43 ( in the region @xmath44 for @xmath45 ( in the region @xmath46 , and for @xmath47 ( in the region @xmath48 .
[ th1_<4.5_5 ] in @xmath14 the following holds .
@xmath49 [ th1_ln0.75 ] in @xmath14 @xmath50 in whole , this work can be considered as development of work @xcite .
throughout the paper , in all tables we denote @xmath53 where @xmath54 also , in all tables , @xmath55 is a superior approximation of @xmath56 for @xmath26 , the values of @xmath25 ( up to june 2011 ) are collected in ( * ? ? ?
* tab.1 ) . in this work we obtained small arcs with new sizes for @xmath57 the new arcs
are obtained by computer search , based on the randomized greedy algorithms .
the current values of @xmath25 for @xmath26 are given in table 1 .
the data for @xmath58 improving results of ( * ? ? ?
* tab.1 ) are written in table 1 in bold font .
the exact values @xmath59 are marked by the dot @xmath60 .
in particular , due to the recent result @xcite we noted the values @xmath61 from table 1 and the results of @xcite , on complete @xmath62-arcs for @xmath63 ( see introduction ) we obtain theorem [ th3_4sqroot(q ) ] improving and extending the results of ( * ? ? ? * th.3.1 ) . * table 1 . * the smallest known sizes @xmath64 of complete arcs in planes
@xmath65 @xmath66 @xmath67 , @xmath68 @xmath69 [ th3_4sqroot(q ) ] in @xmath14 the following holds .
@xmath70 also , @xmath71 for @xmath72 , the values of @xmath25 ( up to june 2011 ) are collected in ( * ? ? ?
* tabs2,3 ) . in this work we obtained small arcs with new sizes for @xmath73 the new arcs
are obtained by computer search , based on the randomized greedy algorithms .
the current values of @xmath74 for @xmath75 are given in table 2 .
the data for @xmath45 improving results of ( * ? ? ?
* tabs2,3 ) are written in table 2 in bold font .
the data for @xmath63 with @xmath76 @xcite and for @xmath77 with @xmath78 are written in italic font . from table 2 and
the results of @xcite , on complete @xmath62-arcs for @xmath63 ( see introduction ) we obtain theorem [ th3_4.5sqroot(q ) ] improving and extending the results of ( * ? ? ?
* th.3.2 ) .
* table 2 . * the smallest known sizes @xmath79 of complete arcs in planes
@xmath14 @xmath80 @xmath81 , @xmath82 @xmath83 * table 2 * ( continue ) @xmath84 [ th3_4.5sqroot(q ) ] in @xmath14 the following holds .
@xmath85 also , @xmath86 for @xmath87 and for a few sporadic @xmath88 , the values of @xmath89 ( up to june 2011 ) are collected in ( * ? ? ?
* tabs3,4 ) . in this work we obtained small arcs with new sizes for @xmath90 the new arcs
are obtained by computer search , based on the randomized greedy algorithms .
the current values of @xmath91 for @xmath92 are given in table 3 .
the data for @xmath47 and other data ( obtained in this work ) improving and extending results of ( * ? ? ?
* tabs3,4 ) are written in table 3 in bold font .
the data for @xmath4 with @xmath93 are written in italic font .
* table 3 . *
the smallest known sizes @xmath94 of complete arcs in planes @xmath14 @xmath92 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 @xmath95 * table 3 * ( continue ) @xmath96 the current values of @xmath25 for @xmath97 and @xmath98 are given in tables 4 and 5 , respectively .
all results in these tables are new and they have been obtained in this work by computer search , based on the randomized greedy algorithms .
data for @xmath99 with @xmath100 are written in table 4 in italic font . from tables 3 - 5
we obtain theorem [ th3_5sqroot(q ) ] improving and extending the results of ( * ? ? ?
* th.3.3 ) .
[ th3_5sqroot(q ) ] in @xmath14 the following holds .
@xmath101 also , @xmath102 * table 4 . * the smallest known sizes @xmath103 of complete arcs in planes @xmath14 @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath68 @xmath106 * table 4 * ( continue ) @xmath107 * table 5 . * the smallest known sizes @xmath103 of complete arcs in planes @xmath14 @xmath108 , @xmath105 , @xmath68 @xmath109
we look for upper estimates of the collection of @xmath25 values from tables 1 - 5 in the form ( [ eq1_kimvu_c=300 ] ) , see @xcite , ( * ? ? ?
* tab.2.6 ) , and ( * ? ? ?
* sec.4 ) . for definiteness , we use the natural logarithms .
let @xmath22 be a constant independent of @xmath15 .
we introduce @xmath110 and @xmath111 as follows : @xmath112 we denote @xmath131 one can treat @xmath132 as a _ predicted _ value of @xmath133 . then @xmath134 is the difference between the smallest known size @xmath25 of complete arcs and the predicted value . finally , @xmath135 is this difference in percentage terms of the smallest known size . by ( [ eq4_delta_q ] ) and ( [ eq4_percent ] ) ,
see also fig .
3 and 4 , the upper bounds of @xmath134 and @xmath135 are relatively small .
moreover , the upper bound of @xmath135 decreases when @xmath15 grows . therefore the values of @xmath134 and @xmath139 are useful for computer search of small arcs .
[ rem4 ] by above , @xmath140 seems to be a reasonable upper bound on the current collection of @xmath25 values .
it gives some reference points for computer search and foundations for conjecture [ conj1 _ ln0.75 ] on the upper bound for @xmath0 . in principle , the constant @xmath141 can be sightly reduced to move the curve @xmath142 near to the curve of @xmath25 , see fig . 2 and ( * ? ? ?
* th.4.3 ) .
davydov , g. faina , s. marcugini , f. pambianco , on the spectrum of sizes of complete caps in projective spaces @xmath143 of small dimension , in proc .
workshop on algebraic and combin .
coding theory , acct2008 , pamporovo , bulgaria , 2008 , 5762 .
math.bas.bg/acct2008/b10.pdf a.a .
davydov , g. faina , s. marcugini , f. pambianco , new sizes of complete arcs in @xmath1 , in proc .
xii int .
workshop on algebraic and combin .
coding theory , acct2010 , novosibirsk , russia , 2010 , 103108 .
hirschfeld , maximum sets in finite projective spaces . in : lloyd ,
( ed . ) : surveys in combinatorics , london math .
lecture note ser .
82 , cambridge university press , cambridge , 1983 , pp .
5576 .
hirschfeld , l. storme , the packing problem in statistics , coding theory and finite geometry : update 2001 , in : _ _
a. blokhuis , j.w.p .
hirschfeld , d. jungnickel , j.a .
thas ( eds . ) , finite geometries , developments of mathematics 3 ( proc . of the fourth isle of thorns conf .
, chelwood gate , 2000 ) kluwer , 2001 , pp . 201246 . | new upper bounds on the smallest size @xmath0 of a complete arc in the projective plane @xmath1 are obtained for @xmath2 from these new bounds it follows that for @xmath3 and @xmath4 , the relation @xmath5 holds .
also , for @xmath6 and @xmath7 we have @xmath8 finally , for @xmath9 it holds that @xmath10 the new upper bounds are obtained by finding new small complete arcs with the help of a computer search using randomized greedy algorithms .
_ keywords : _ projective plane , complete arcs , small complete arcs |
we have known light and fermions for many years .
but we still can not give a satisfactory answer to the following fundamental questions : what are light and fermions ?
where light and fermions come from ? why light and fermions exist ? at moment , the standard answers to the above fundamental questions appear to be `` light is the particle described by a gauge field '' and `` fermions are the particles described by anti - commuting fields '' . here , we like to argue that there is another possible answer to the above questions : our vacuum is filled with string - like objects that form network of arbitrary sizes and those string - nets form a quantum condensed state . according to the string - net picture ,
the light ( and other gauge bosons ) is a vibration of the condensed string - nets and fermions are ends of strings ( or nodes of string - nets ) .
the string - net condensation provides a unified origin of light and fermions . before discussing the above fundamental questions in more detail
, we would like to clarify what do we mean by `` light exists '' and `` fermions exist '' . we know that there is a natural mass scale in physics the planck mass .
planck mass is so large that any observed particle have a mass at least factor @xmath0 smaller than the planck mass .
so all the observed particles can be treated as massless when compared with planck mass .
when we ask why some particles exist , we really ask why those particles are massless ( or nearly massless when compared with planck mass ) .
so the real issue is to understand what makes certain excitations ( such as light and fermions ) massless .
we have known that symmetry breaking is a way to get gapless bosonic excitations .
we will see that string - net condensation is another way to get gapless excitations .
however , string - net condensations can generate massless gauge bosons and massless fermions .
second , we would like to clarify what do we mean by `` origin of light and fermions '' .
we know that everything has to come from something .
so when we ask `` where light and fermions come from '' , we have assumed that there are some things simpler and more fundamental than light and fermions . in the section [ lbm ] , we define local bosonic models which are simpler than models with gauge fields coupled to fermions .
we will regard local bosonic models as more fundamental ( the locality principle ) .
we will show that light and fermions can emerge from a local bosonic model if the model contains a condensation of nets of string - like object in its ground state . after the above two clarifications , we can state more precisely the meaning of `` string - net condensation provides another possible answer to the fundamental questions about light and fermions '' .
when we say gauge bosons and fermions originate from string - net condensation , we really mean that ( nearly ) _ massless _ gauge bosons and fermions originate from string - net condensation in a _ local bosonic model_. before considering the origin of massless photon and massless fermions , let us consider a simpler massless ( or gapless ) excitation phonon .
we can ask three similar questions about phonon : what is phonon ? where phonon comes from ?
why phonon exists ? we know that those are scientific questions and we know their answers .
phonon is a vibration of a crystal .
phonon comes from a spontaneous translation symmetry breaking .
phonon exists because the translation - symmetry - breaking phase actually exists in nature .
in particular , the gaplessness of phonon is directly originated from and protected by the spontaneous translation symmetry breaking.@xcite many other gapless excitations , such as spin wave , superfluid mode , also come from condensation of point - like objects that break certain symmetries .
it is quite interesting to see that our understanding of a gapless excitation - phonon - is rooted in our understanding of phases of matter .
according to landau s theory,@xcite phases of matter are different because they have different broken symmetries .
the symmetry description of phases is very powerful .
it allows us to classify all possible crystals .
it also provides the origin for gapless phonons and many other gapless excitations .
until a few years ago , it was believed that the condensations of point - like objects , and the related symmetry breaking and order parameters , can describe all the orders ( or phases ) in nature .
knowing light as a massless excitation , one may wonder maybe light , just like phonon , is also a nambu - goldstone mode from a broken symmetry .
however , experiments tell us that a @xmath1 gauge boson , such as light , is really different from a nambu - goldstone mode in 3 + 1 dimensions .
therefore it is impossible to use landau s symmetry breaking theory and condensation of point - like objects to understand the origin and the masslessness of light . also
, nambu - goldstone modes are always bosonic , thus it is impossible to use symmetry breaking to understand the origin and the ( nearly ) masslessness of fermions .
it seems that there does not exist any order that can give rise to massless light and massless fermions .
because of this , we put light and electron into a different category than phonon .
we regarded them as elementary and introduced them by hand into our theory of nature .
however , if we believe light and electrons , just like phonon , exist for a reason , then such a reason must be a certain order in our vacuum that protect the masslessness of light and electron .
( here we have assumed that light and electron are not something that we place in an empty vacuum .
our vacuum is more like an `` ocean '' which is not empty .
light and electron are collective excitations that correspond to certain patterns of `` water '' motion . )
now the question is that what kind of order can give rise to light and electron , and protect their masslessness .
if we really believe in the equality between light , electron and phonon , then the very existence of light and fermions indicates that our understanding of states of matter is incomplete
. we should deepen and expand our understanding of the states of matter .
there should be new states of matter that contain new kind of orders .
the new orders will produce light and electron , and protect their masslessness .
after the discovery of fractional quantum hall ( fqh ) effect,@xcite it became clear that the landau s symmetry breaking theory can not describe different fqh states , since those states all have the _ same _ symmetry .
it was proposed that fqh states contain a new kind of order - topological order.@xcite topological order is new because it can not be described by symmetry breaking , long range correlation , and local order parameters .
non of the usual tools that we used to characterize phases applies to topological order . despite of this ,
topological order is not an empty concept .
topological order can be characterized by a new set of tools , such as the number of degenerate ground states , quasiparticle statistics , and edge states .
it was shown that the ground state degeneracy of a topological ordered state is a universal property since the degeneracy is robust against any perturbations.@xcite such a topological degeneracy demonstrates the existence of topological order .
it can also be used to perform fault tolerant quantum computations.@xcite recently , the concept of topological order was generalized to quantum order.@xcite quantum order is used to describe new kinds of orders in gapless quantum states .
one way to understand quantum order is to see how it fits into a general classification scheme of orders ( see fig .
[ clorder ] ) .
first , different orders can be divided into two classes : symmetry breaking orders and non - symmetry breaking orders .
the symmetry breaking orders can be described by a local order parameter and can be said to contain a condensation of point - like objects .
all the symmetry breaking orders can be understood in terms of landau s symmetry breaking theory .
the non - symmetry breaking orders can not be described by symmetry breaking , neither by the related local order parameters and long range correlations .
thus they are a new kind of orders .
if a quantum system ( a state at zero temperature ) contains a non - symmetry breaking order , then the system is said to contain a non - trivial quantum order .
we see that a quantum order is simply a non - symmetry breaking order in a quantum system .
quantum order can be further divided into many subclasses .
if a quantum state is gapped , then the corresponding quantum order will be called topological order .
the low energy effective theory of a topological ordered state will be a topological field theory.@xcite the second class of quantum orders appear in fermi liquids ( or free fermion systems ) .
the different quantum orders in fermi liquids are classified by the fermi surface topology.@xcite in this paper , we will concentrate on the third class of quantum orders the quantum orders from condensation of nets of strings , or simply , string - net condensation.@xcite this class of quantum orders shares some similarities with the symmetry breaking orders of `` particle '' condensation . we know that different symmetry breaking orders can be classified by symmetry groups . using group theory
, we can classify all the 230 crystal orders in three dimensions .
the symmetry also produces and protects gapless nambu - goldstone bosons .
similarly , as we will see later in this paper , different string - net condensations ( and the corresponding quantum orders ) can be classified by a mathematical object called projective symmetry group ( psg).@xcite using psg , we can classify over 100 different 2d spin liquids that all have the same symmetry.@xcite just like symmetry group , psg can also produce and protect gapless excitations .
however , unlike symmetry group , psg produces and protects gapless gauge bosons and gapless fermions.@xcite because of this , we can say light and massless fermions can have a unified origin .
they can come from string - net condensations .
we used to believe that to have light and fermions in our theory , we have to introduce by hand a fundamental @xmath1 gauge field and anti - commuting fermion fields , since at that time we did not know any collective modes that behave like gauge bosons and fermions .
now , we know that gauge bosons and fermions appear commonly and naturally in quantum ordered states , as fluctuations of condensed string - nets and ends of open strings .
this raises an issue : do light and fermions come from a fundamental @xmath1 gauge field and anti - commuting fields as in the 123 standard model or do they come from a particular quantum order in our vacuum ? clearly it is more natural to assume light and fermions come from a quantum order in our vacuum . from the connection between string - net condensation , quantum order , and massless
gauge / fermion excitations , it is very tempting to propose the following answers to the fundamental questions about light and ( nearly ) massless fermions : had our vacuum chosen to have a `` particle '' condensation , there would be only nambu - goldstone bosons at low energies . such a universe would be very boring .
string - net condensation and the resulting light and ( nearly ) massless fermions provide a much more interesting universe , at least interesting enough to support intelligent life to study the origin of light and massless fermions .
the string - net picture of fermions explains why there is always an even number of fermions in our universe .
the string - net picture for gauge bosons and fermions also has an experimental prediction : all fermions must carry certain gauge charges.@xcite at first sight , this prediction appears to contradict with the known experimental fact that neutron carry no gauge charges .
thus one may think the string - net picture of gauge bosons and fermions has already been falsified by experiments . here
we would like to point out that the string - net picture of gauge bosons and fermions can still be correct if we assume the existence of a new discrete gauge field , such as a @xmath2 gauge field , in our universe . in this case ,
neutrons and neutrinos carry a non - zero charge of the discrete gauge field .
therefore , the string - net picture of gauge bosons and fermions predict the existence of discrete gauge excitations ( such as gauge flux lines ) in our universe .
we would like to remark that , despite the similarity , the above string - net picture of gauge bosons and fermions is different from the picture of standard superstring theory . in standard superstring theory , closed strings correspond to gravitons , and open string correspond to gauge bosons .
all the elementary particles correspond to different vibration modes of small strings in the superstring theory .
also , the fermions in the standard superstring theory come from the fermion fields on the world sheet . in our string - net picture ,
the vacuum is filled with large nets of strings .
the massless gauge bosons correspond to the fluctuations of large closed string - nets ( nets of closed strings ) and fermions correspond to the ends of open strings in string nets .
anti - commuting fields are not needed to produce ( nearly ) massless fermions .
massless fermions appear as low energy collective modes in a purely bosonic system .
the string - net picture for gauge theories have a long history .
the closed - string description of gauge fluctuations is intimately related to the wilson loop in gauge theory.@xcite the relation between dynamical gauge theory and a dynamical wilson - loop theory was suggested in . studied the hamiltonian of a non - local model - lattice gauge theory .
it was found that the lattice gauge theory contains a string - net structure and the gauge charges can be viewed as ends of strings . in various duality relations between lattice gauge theories and theories of extended objects
were reviewed .
in particular , some statistical lattice gauge models were found to be dual to certain statistical membrane models.@xcite this duality relation is directly connected to the relation between gauge theory and closed - string - net theory@xcite in quantum models .
emerging fermions from local bosonic models also have a complicated history . the first examples of emerging fermions / anyons were the fractional quantum hall states,@xcite where fermionic / anyonic excitations were obtained theoretically from interacting bosons in magnetic field.@xcite in 1987
, fermion fields and gauge fields were introduced to express the spin-1/2 hamiltonian in the slave - boson approach.@xcite however , writing a bosonic hamiltonian in terms of fermion fields does not imply the appearance of well defined fermionic quasiparticles . emerging fermionic excitations can appear only in deconfined phases of the gauge field .
constructed several deconfined phases where the fermion fields do describe well defined quasiparticles . however , depending on the property of deconfined phases , those quasiparticles may carry fractional statistics ( for the chiral spin states)@xcite or fermi statistics ( for the @xmath2 deconfined states).@xcite also in 1987 , in a study of resonating - valence - bond ( rvb ) states , emerging fermions ( the spinons ) were proposed in a nearest neighbor dimer model on square lattice.@xcite but , according to the deconfinement picture , the results in are valid only when the ground state of the dimer model is in the @xmath2 deconfined phase .
it appears that the dimer liquid on square lattice with only nearest neighbor dimers is not a deconfined state,@xcite and thus it is not clear if the nearest neighbor dimer model on square lattice@xcite has the fermionic quasiparticles or not.@xcite however , on triangular lattice , the dimer liquid is indeed a @xmath2 deconfined state.@xcite therefore , the results in are valid for the triangular - lattice dimer model and fermionic quasiparticles do emerge in a dimer liquid on triangular lattice .
all the above models with emerging fermions are 2 + 1d models , where the emerging fermions can be understood from binding flux to a charged particle.@xcite recently , it was pointed out in that the key to emerging fermions is a string structure .
fermions can generally appear as ends of open strings .
the string picture allows a construction of a 3 + 1d local bosonic model that has emerging fermions . comparing with those previous results ,
the new features discussed in this paper are : ( a ) _ massless _ gauge bosons and fermions can emerge from _ local bosonic models _ as a result of string - net condensation .
( b ) massless fermions are protected by the string - net condensation ( and the associated psg ) .
( c ) string - net condensed states represent a new kind of phases which can not be described landau s symmetry breaking theory .
different string - net condensed states are characterized by different psg s .
( d ) qed and qcd can emerge from a local bosonic model on cubic lattice .
the effective qed and qcd has @xmath3 families of leptons and quarks .
each family has one lepton and two flavors of quarks .
the bottom line is that , within local bosonic models , massless fermions do not just emerge by themselves .
emerging massless fermions , emerging massless gauge bosons , string - net condensations , and psg are intimately related .
they are just different sides of same coin - quantum order . according to the picture of quantum order , elementary particles ( such as photon and electron )
may not be elementary after all .
they may be collective excitations of a local bosonic system below planck scale .
since we can not do experiments close to planck scale , it is hard to determine if photon and electron are elementary particles or not . in this paper
, we would like to show that the string - net picture of light and fermions is at least self consistent by studying some concrete local boson models which produce massless gauge bosons and massless fermions through string - net condensations .
the local boson models studied here are just a few examples among a long list of local boson models that contain emerging fermions and gauge fields . here
we would like to stress that the string - net picture for the actual gauge bosons and fermions in our universe is only a proposal at moment .
although string - net condensation can produce and protect massless photons , gluons , quarks , and other charged leptons , we do not know at moment if string - net condensations can produce neutrinos which are chiral fermions , and the weak - interaction @xmath4 gauge field which couples chirally to the quarks and the leptons . also , we do not know if string - net condensation can produce an odd number of families of quarks and leptons .
the qed and qcd produced by the known string - net condensations all contain an even number of families so far .
the correctness of string - net condensation in our vacuum depend on resolving the above problems .
nature has four fascinating and somewhat strange properties : gauge bosons , fermi statistics , chiral fermions , and gravity .
the string - net condensation picture provides a natural explanation for the first two properties .
two more to go . on the other hand ,
if we concern about a condensed matter problem : how to use bosons to make artificial light and artificial fermions , then the string - net picture and quantum order do provide an answer . to make artificial light and artificial fermions
, we simply let certain string - nets to condense . in some recent work , quantum orders and their connection to emerging gauge bosons and fermions were studied using psg s , without realizing their connection to string - net condensation.@xcite in this paper , we will show that the quantum ordered states described by psg s are actually string - net condensed states .
the gauge bosons and fermions produced and protected by the psg s have a very natural string - net interpretation.@xcite quantum order , psg , and string - net condensation are different parts of the same story . here
we will summarize and expand those previous work and try to present a coherent picture for quantum order , psg , and string - net condensation , as well as the associated emerging gauge bosons and fermions .
section [ sec : z2 ] reviews the work in
. we will study an exactly soluble spin-1/2 model on square lattice@xcite .
the model was solved using slave - boson approach.@xcite this allowed us to identify the psg that characterizes the non - trivial quantum order in the ground state.@xcite here , following , we will solve the model from string - net condensation point of view .
since the ground state of the model can be described by both string - net condensation and psg , this allows us to demonstrate the direct connection between string - net condensation and psg in section [ psgstring ] .
the model is also one of the simplest models that demonstrates the connection between string - net condensation and emerging gauge field and fermions.@xcite however , the above exact soluble model does not contain gapless gauge boson and gapless fermions . if we regard the lattice scale as the planck scale , then gauge bosons and fermions do not `` exist '' in our model in the sense discussed in section [ fq ] . in section [ masslessferm ] , we will discuss an exact soluble local bosonic model that contain massless dirac fermions . in sections [ qed ] and [ secqcd ]
, we will discuss local bosonic models that give rise to massless electrons , quarks , gluons , and photons .
gauge bosons and fermions `` exist '' in those latter models .
in this paper , we will only consider local bosonic models .
local bosonic models are important since they are really local .
we note that a fermionic model are in general non local since the fermion operators at different sites do not commute , even when the sites are well separated . due to their intrinsic locality ,
local bosonic models are natural candidates for the fundamental theory of nature . in the following
we will give a detailed definition of local bosonic models . to define a physical system , we need to specify ( a ) a total hilbert space , ( b ) a definition of a set of local physical operators , and ( c ) a hamiltonian . with this understanding
, a local bosonic model is defined to be a model that satisfies : ( a ) the total hilbert space is a direct product of local hilbert spaces of finite dimensions .
( b ) local physical operators are local bosonic operators . by definition , _ local bosonic operators _ are operators acting within a local hilbert space or finite products of those operators for nearby local hilbert spaces . those operators are called local bosonic operators since they all commute with each other when far apart .
( c ) the hamiltonian is a sum of local physical operators .
a spin-1/2 system on a lattice is an example of local bosonic models .
the local hilbert space is two dimensional which contains @xmath5 and @xmath6 states .
local physical operators are @xmath7 , @xmath8 , , where @xmath9 , @xmath10 are the pauli matrices .
a free spinless fermion system ( in 2 or higher dimensions ) is not a local bosonic model despite it has the same total hilbert space as the spin-1/2 system .
this is because the fermion operators @xmath11 on different sites do not commute and are not local bosonic operators .
more importantly , the fermion hoping hamiltonian in 2 and higher dimensions can not be written as a sum of local bosonic operators .
( note in higher dimensions , we can not write all the hoping terms @xmath12 as product of local bosonic operators .
however , due to the jordan - wigner transformation , a 1d fermion hoping @xmath13 can be written as a local bosonic operators .
hence , a 1d fermion system can be a local bosonic model if we exclude @xmath11 from our definition of local physical operators . )
the bosonic field theory without cut - off is not a local bosonic model .
this is because the local hilbert space does not have a finite dimension .
a lattice gauge theory is not a local bosonic model .
this is because its total hilbert space can not be a direct product of local hilbert spaces .
another counter example of local bosonic model is a quantum closed - string - net model . a quantum closed - string - net model on lattice
can be defined in the following way .
let us consider only strings that cover nearest neighbor links
. a closed - string configuration may have many closed strings with or without overlap .
we will call a closed - string configuration a closed string - net . for every closed string - net , we assign a quantum state .
all those quantum states form a basis of the total hilbert space of the closed - string - net model . just like lattice gauge theory , the closed - string - net model is not a local bosonic model since the total hilbert space can not be a direct product of local hilbert spaces .
it turns out that closed - string - net models and lattice gauge model are closely related .
in fact some closed - string - net models ( or statistical membrane models ) are equivalent to lattice gauge models.@xcite
let us first consider an arbitrary spin-1/2 model on a square lattice .
the first question that we want to ask is what kind of spin interaction can given rise to a low energy gauge theory . if we believe the connection between gauge theory and closed - string - net theory,@xcite then one way to obtain a low energy gauge theory is to design a spin interaction that allow strong fluctuations of large closed string - nets , but forbid other types of fluctuations ( such as local spin flip , open string - net fluctuations , ) .
( note that closed string - nets are nets of strings formed by intersecting / overlapping closed strings , while open string - nets are nets of strings containing at least an open string . )
we hope the presence of strong fluctuations of large closed - strings will lead to condensation of closed strings of arbitrary sizes , which in turn gives rise to a low energy gauge theory . .
, width=240 ] let us start with @xmath14 where @xmath15 labels the lattice sites , @xmath16 are the pauli matrices , and @xmath17 ( or @xmath18 ) is a sum over even sites with @xmath19 ( or over odd sites with @xmath20 ) .
the ground state of @xmath21 , @xmath22 , has spins pointing to @xmath23-direction on even sites and to @xmath24-direction on odd sites ( see fig .
[ string ] ) .
such a state will be defined as a state with no string . to create a string excitation
, we first draw a string that connect nearest neighbor _ even _ plaquettes ( see fig .
[ string ] ) .
we then flip the spins in the string .
such a string state is created by the following string creation operator ( or simply , string operator ) : @xmath25 where the product @xmath26 is over all the sites on the string , @xmath27 if @xmath28 is even and @xmath29 if @xmath28 is odd .
a generic string state has a form @xmath30 where @xmath31 , @xmath32 , ... are strings with no overlapping ends .
such a state will be called a string - net state and @xmath33 will be called a string - net operator .
the state @xmath34 is an open - string - net state if at least one of @xmath35 is an open string .
the corresponding operator @xmath36 will be called an open - string - net operator .
if all @xmath35 are closed loops , then @xmath34 is an closed - string - net state and @xmath36 an closed - string - net operator .
the hamiltonian has no string - net condensation since its ground state @xmath22 contains no string - nets . to obtain a hamiltonian with closed - string - net condensation
, we need to first find a hamiltonian whose ground state contains a lot of closed string - nets of arbitrary sizes and do not contain open string - nets .
let us first write down a hamiltonian such that closed strings cost no energy and any open strings cost a large energy .
one such hamiltonian has a form @xmath37 we find the no - string state @xmath22 is one of the ground state of @xmath38 ( assuming @xmath39 ) with energy @xmath40 .
all the closed - string - net states , such as @xmath41 , are also ground state of @xmath38 since @xmath42=0 $ ] .
an open - string state @xmath43 is also an eigenstate of @xmath38 but with energy @xmath44 .
we see that each end of open string cost an energy @xmath45 .
we also note that the energy of closed strings does not depend on the length of closed strings .
thus the closed strings in @xmath38 have no tension .
we can introduce a string tension by adding the @xmath21 to our hamiltonian .
the string tension will be @xmath46 per site ( or per segment ) .
we note that , any string - net state @xmath34 is an eigenstate of @xmath47 .
thus , string - nets in the model described by @xmath47 do not fluctuate and hence can not condense . to make string - nets to fluctuate , we need a @xmath48-term @xmath49 where @xmath50 labels the odd plaquettes and @xmath51 is the closed string around the plaquette @xmath50 .
in fact @xmath52 this way , we obtain the hamiltonian of our spin-1/2 model @xmath53 when @xmath54 in , the model is exactly soluble since @xmath55=0$].@xcite all the eigenstates of @xmath56 can be obtained from the common eigenstates of @xmath57 . since @xmath58 ,
the eigenvalues of @xmath57 are simply @xmath59 .
thu s all the eigenstates of @xmath56 are labeled by @xmath59 on each plaquette .
( note , this is not true for finite systems where the boundary condition introduce additional complications.@xcite ) the energies of those eigenstates are sum of eigenvalues of @xmath57 weighted by @xmath45 and @xmath48 . model .
@xmath60 is assumed to be positive .
the four string - net condensed phases are characterized by a pair of psg s @xmath61 .
mo marks an magnetic ordered state .
, width=192 ] from the results of exact soluble model , we suggest a phase diagram of our model as sketched in fig .
[ phase ] .
we will show that the phase diagram contains four different string - net condensed phases and one phase with no string condensation .
all the phases have the same symmetry and are distinguished only by their different quantum orders .
let us first discuss the phase with @xmath62 .
we will assume @xmath54 and @xmath63 .
in this limit , all states containing open strings will have an energy of order @xmath45 .
the low energy states contain only closed strings ( or more generally closed string - nets ) and satisfy @xmath64 for infinite systems , the different low energy states are labeled by the eigenvalues of @xmath57 on odd plaquettes : @xmath65 in particular , the ground state is given by @xmath66 all the closed - string - net operators @xmath36 commute with @xmath56 .
hence the ground state @xmath67 of @xmath56 satisfies @xmath68 thus the @xmath62 ground state has a closed - stringi - net condensation .
the low energy excitations above the ground state can be obtained by flipping @xmath57 from @xmath69 to @xmath70 on some odd plaquettes .
if we view @xmath57 on odd plaquettes as the flux in @xmath2 gauge theory , we find that the low energy sector of model is identical to a @xmath2 lattice gauge theory , at least for infinite systems .
this suggests that the low energy effective theory of our model is a @xmath2 lattice gauge theory .
however , one may object this result by pointing out that the low energy sector of our model is also identical to an ising model with one spin on each the odd plaquette .
thus the the low energy effective theory should be the ising model .
we would like to point out that although the low energy sector of our model is identical to an ising model for infinite systems , the low energy sector of our model is different from an ising model for finite systems .
for example , on a finite even by even lattice with periodic boundary condition , the ground state of our model has a four - fold degeneracy.@xcite the ising model does not have such a degeneracy .
also , our model contains an excitation that can be identified as @xmath2 charge ( see below ) .
therefore , the low energy effective theory of our model is a @xmath2 lattice gauge theory instead of an ising model .
the @xmath71 excitations on odd plaquettes can be viewed as the @xmath2 vortex excitations in the @xmath2 lattice gauge theory .
charge around four nearest neighbor even plaquettes .
, width=211 ] what is the @xmath2 charge excitations ?
we note that , in the closed - string - net condensed state , the action of the closed - string operator on the ground state is trivial .
this suggests that the action of the open - string operators on the ground state only depend on the ends of strings , since two open strings with the same ends only differ by a closed string .
therefore , an open - string operator create two particles at its ends when acting on the string condensed state . since the strings in only connect even plaquettes , the particle corresponding to the ends of the open strings always live on the even plaquettes .
we will call such a string t1 string . form the commutation relation between @xmath57 and the open - string operators , we find that the open - string operators flip the sign of @xmath57 at its ends . thus each particle created by the open - string operators
has an energy @xmath72 .
now , let us consider the hopping of one such particle around four nearest neighbor even plaquettes ( see fig .
[ hop ] ) .
we see that the product of the the four hopping amplitudes is given by the eigenvalue of @xmath73 on the odd plaquette in the middle of the four even plaquettes.@xcite this is exactly the relation between charge and flux .
thus if we identify @xmath57 on odd plaquettes as @xmath2 flux , then the ends of strings on even plaquettes will correspond to the @xmath2 charges .
we note that , due to the closed - string condensation , the ends of open strings are not confined and have only short ranged interactions between them .
thus the @xmath2 charges behave like quasiparticles with no string attached . just like the @xmath2 charges ,
a pair @xmath2 vortices is also created by an open string operator .
since the @xmath2 vortices correspond to flipped @xmath74 on _ odd _ plaquettes , the open - string operator that create @xmath2 vortices is also given by , except now the product is over a string that connect _ odd _ plaquettes .
we will call such a string t2 string .
( the strings connecting _ even _ plaquettes were called t1 strings . )
we would like to point out that the reference state ( the no string state ) for the t2 string is different from that of the t1 string .
the no - t2-string state is given by @xmath75 with spin pointing in @xmath24-direction on even sites and @xmath23-direction on odd sites .
since the t1 and t2 strings have different reference state , we can not have a dilute gas of the t1 strings and the t2 strings at the same time .
one can easily check that the t2 string operators also commute with @xmath56 .
therefore , the ground state @xmath67 , in addition to the t1 closed - string condensation , also has a t2 closed - string condensation .
the hopping of a @xmath2 vortex is induced by a short t2 open - string . since the t2 open - strings operators all commute with each other , the @xmath2 vortex behave like bosons .
similarly , the @xmath2 charges also behave like bosons . however , t1 open - string operators and t2 open - string operators do not commute . as a result ,
the ends of t1 string and the ends of t2 string have nontrivial mutual statistics . as we have already shown that moving a @xmath2 charge around a @xmath2 vortex generate a phase @xmath76 , the @xmath2 charges and the @xmath2 vortices have a semionic mutual statistics .
the t3 strings are defined as bound states of t1 and t2 strings .
the t3 string operator has a form @xmath77 .
where @xmath78 is a string connecting the mid - points of the neighboring links ( see fig . [ fhop ] ) , and @xmath79 are sites on the string .
@xmath80 if the string does not turn at site @xmath81 ( see fig .
[ fhop ] ) .
@xmath82 or @xmath24 if the string makes a turn at site @xmath81 .
@xmath82 if the turn forms a upper - right or lower - left corner .
@xmath83 if the turn forms a lower - right or upper - left corner .
( see fig .
[ fhop ] . )
the ground state also has a condensation of t3 closed - strings .
the ends of t3 string , as bound states of the @xmath2 charges and the @xmath2 vortices , are _
the bound state is formed by a @xmath2 charge and a @xmath2 vortex on the two plaquettes on the two side of a link ( @xmath84 on the two sides of the link ) .
thus the fermions live on the links .
it is interesting to see that string - net condensation in our model directly leads to @xmath2 gauge structure and three new type of quasiparticles : @xmath2 charge , @xmath2 vortex , and fermions .
fermions , as ends of open t3 strings , emerge from our purely bosonic model .
since ends of t1 string are @xmath2 charges , the t1 string can be viewed as strings of @xmath2 `` electric '' flux .
similarly , the t2 string can be viewed as strings of @xmath2 `` magnetic '' flux .
as we have seen in last section that when @xmath39 , @xmath85 , and @xmath54 , the ground state of our model is given by @xmath86 we will call such a phase @xmath2 phase to stress the low energy @xmath2 gauge structure . in the @xmath2 phase , the t1 string operator @xmath87 and the t2 string operator @xmath88 have the following expectation values @xmath89
when @xmath39 , @xmath90 , and @xmath54 , the ground state is given by @xmath91 we see that there is @xmath76-flux through each odd plaquette .
we will call such a phase @xmath2-flux phase .
the t1 string operator and the t2 string operator have the following expectation values @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the number of odd - plaquettes enclosed by the t1 string @xmath31 . when @xmath94 , @xmath85 , and @xmath54 , the ground state is @xmath95 the ground state has a @xmath2 charge on each even plaquette .
we will call such a phase @xmath2-charge phase .
the t1 string operator and the t2 string operator have the following expectation values @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the number of even - plaquettes enclosed by the t2 string @xmath32 .
note that the @xmath2-flux phase and the @xmath2-charge phase , different only by a lattice translation , are essentially the same phase . when @xmath94 , @xmath90 , and @xmath54 , the ground state becomes @xmath98 there is a @xmath2 charge on each even plaquette and @xmath76-flux through each odd plaquette .
we will call such a phase @xmath2-flux - charge phase .
the t1 string operator and the t2 string operator have the following expectation values @xmath99 from the different @xmath100 and @xmath101 , we see that the above four phases have different string - net condensations . however , they all have the same symmetry .
this raises an issue . without symmetry breaking , how do we know the above four phases are really different phases ?
how do we know that it is impossible to change one string - net condensed state to another without a phase transition ? in the following , we will show that the different string - net condensations can be described by different psg s ( just like different symmetry breaking orders can be described by different symmetry groups of ground states . ) in , different quantum orders were introduced via their different psg s .
the connection between string - net condensation and psg allows us to connect string - net condensation to the quantum order introduced in .
in particular , the psg s are shown to be a universal property of a quantum phase , which can be changed only by phase transitions .
thus the different psg s for the different string - net condensed states indicate that those different string - net condensed states belong to different quantum phases . when closed - string - nets condense , the ends of open strings behave like independent particles .
let us consider two particles states @xmath102 described by the two ends of a t1 string .
note that the ends of the t1 strings , and hence the @xmath2 charges , only live on the even plaquettes . here
@xmath103 and @xmath104 label the even plaquettes . for our model @xmath56
, @xmath105 is an energy eigenstate and the @xmath2 charges do not hop .
here we would like to add a term @xmath106 to the hamiltonian .
the @xmath107-term @xmath108 makes the @xmath2 charges to hop among the even plaquettes with a hopping amplitude of order @xmath107 .
the dynamics of the two @xmath2 charges is described by the following effective hamiltonian in the two - particle hilbert space @xmath109 where @xmath110 describes the hopping of the first particle @xmath103 and @xmath111 describes the hopping of the second particle @xmath104 .
now we can define the psg in a string - net condensed state .
the psg is nothing but the symmetry group of the hopping hamiltonian @xmath112 . due to the translation symmetry of the underlying model @xmath113
, we may naively expect the hopping hamiltonian of the @xmath2 charge @xmath112 also have a translation symmetry @xmath114 the above implies psg = translation symmetry group .
it turns out that is too strong .
the underlying spin model can have translation symmetry even when @xmath112 does not satisfy .
however , the possible symmetry groups of @xmath112 ( the psg s ) are strongly constrained by the translation symmetry of the underlying spin model . in the follow
, we will explain why the psg can be different from the symmetry group of the physical spin model , and what conditions that the psg must satisfy in order to be consistent with the translation symmetry of the spin model .
we note that a string always has two ends .
thus a physical state always has an even number of @xmath2 charges .
the actions of translation on a two - particle state are given by @xmath115 and @xmath116 come from the ambiguity of the location of the string that connect @xmath117 and @xmath104 .
the phases can be different if the string connecting the two @xmath2 charges has different locations . @xmath118 and @xmath119 satisfy the algebra of translations @xmath120 @xmath118 and @xmath119 are direct products of translation operators on the single - particle states .
thus , in some sense , the single - particle translations are square roots of two - particle translations .
the most general form of single - particle translations is given by @xmath121 and @xmath122 , where the actions of operators @xmath123 and @xmath124 are defined as @xmath125 in order for the direct product @xmath126 and @xmath127 to reproduce the translation algebra , we only require @xmath121 and @xmath122 to satisfy @xmath128 or @xmath129 the operators @xmath121 and @xmath122 generate a group . such a group is the psg introduced in .
the two different algebra and generate two different psg s , both are consistent with the translation group acting on the two - particle states .
we will call the psg generated by @xmath130 psg and the psg generated by @xmath131 psg .
let us give a more general definition of psg .
a psg is a group .
it is a extension of symmetry group ( sg ) , a psg contain a normal subgroup ( called invariant gauge group or igg ) such that @xmath132 for our case , the sg is the translation group @xmath133 . for every element in sg , @xmath134 , there are one or several elements in psg , @xmath135 , such that @xmath136 .
the igg in our psg is formed by the transformations @xmath137 on the singe - particle states that satisfy @xmath138 .
we find that igg is generated by @xmath139 @xmath137 , @xmath121 and @xmath122 generate the @xmath130 and @xmath131 psg s .
now we see that the underlying translation symmetry does not require the single - particle hopping hamiltonian @xmath112 to have a translation symmetry .
it only require @xmath112 to be invariant under the @xmath130 psg or the @xmath131 psg .
when @xmath112 is invariant under the @xmath130 psg , the hopping hamiltonian has the usual translation symmetry .
when @xmath112 is invariant under the @xmath131 psg , the hopping hamiltonian has a magnetic translation symmetry describing a hopping in a magnetic field with @xmath76-flux through each odd plaquette .
after understand the possible psg s for the hopping hamiltonian of the ends of strings , now we are ready to calculate the actual psg s .
let us consider two ground states of our model @xmath113 .
one has @xmath140 ( for @xmath85 ) and the other has @xmath141 ( for @xmath90 ) .
both ground states have the same translation symmetry in @xmath142 and @xmath143 directions .
however , the corresponding single - particle hopping hamiltonian @xmath112 has different symmetries . for the @xmath140 state , there is no flux through odd plaquettes and @xmath112 has the usual translation symmetry .
it is invariant under the @xmath130 psg . while for the @xmath141 state , there is @xmath76-flux through odd plaquettes and @xmath112 has a magnetic translation symmetry .
its psg is the @xmath131 psg .
thus the @xmath144 state and the @xmath145 state have different orders despite they have the same symmetry . the different quantum orders in the two states can be characterized by their different psg s . model .
@xmath146 is assumed to be positive .
the four string - net condensed phases are characterized by a pair of psg s @xmath61 .
fm marks a ferromagnetic phase .
, width=192 ] the above discussion also apply to the @xmath2 vortex and t2 strings .
thus the quantum orders in our model are described by a pair of psg s @xmath147 , one for the @xmath2 charge and one for the @xmath2 vortex .
the psg pairs @xmath148 allows us to distinguish four different string - net condensed states of model @xmath149.(see fig .
[ phaseugt ] . )
now let us assume @xmath150 in our model : @xmath151 the new physical spin model has a larger translation symmetry generated by @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( see fig . [ phaseugt ] ) .
due to the enlarged symmetry group , the quantum orders in the new system should be characterized by a new psg . in the following
, we will calculate the new psg .
the single - particle states are given by @xmath154 .
when @xmath50 is even , @xmath155 corresponds to a @xmath2 charge and when @xmath50 is odd , @xmath154 corresponds to a @xmath2 vortex .
we see that a translation by @xmath156 ( or @xmath157 ) will change a @xmath2 charge to a @xmath2 vortex or a @xmath2 vortex to a @xmath2 charge .
therefore the effective single - particle hopping hamiltonian @xmath112 only contain hops between even plaquettes or odd plaquettes .
the single - particle hamiltonian @xmath112 is invariant under the following two transformations @xmath137 and @xmath158 : @xmath159 we note that @xmath160 .
therefore both @xmath137 and @xmath158 correspond to the identity element of the symmetry group of two - particle states .
@xmath161 generate the igg of the new psg .
the new igg is @xmath162 .
the translations of single - particle states by @xmath156 and by @xmath157 are generated by @xmath163 and @xmath164 .
the translation by @xmath165 and by @xmath143 are given by @xmath166 since @xmath121 and @xmath122 are the translations of the @xmath2 charge and the @xmath2 vortex discussed above , we find @xmath167 where @xmath168 for the @xmath169 state with @xmath170 and @xmath171 for the @xmath172 state with @xmath71 .
also @xmath163 and @xmath164 must satisfy @xmath173 since on the two - particle states @xmath174 therefore , @xmath175 may take the following possible values @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath176 , and @xmath177
. only choices @xmath178 and @xmath179 are consistent with and we have @xmath180 we like to point out that the different choices of @xmath181 do not lead to different psg s .
this is because if @xmath163 is a symmetry of the @xmath182 , then @xmath183 is also a symmetry of the @xmath182 .
however , the change @xmath184 will change the sign of @xmath185 .
thus @xmath186 and @xmath187 will lead to the same psg .
but the different signs of @xmath188 will lead to different psg s .
@xmath161 and @xmath189 generate the new psg .
the single - particle hamiltonian @xmath112 is invariant under such a psg . @xmath190 and @xmath191 correspond to two different psg s that characterize two different quantum orders .
the ground state for @xmath192 and @xmath193 ( see ) is described by the @xmath190 psg .
the ground state for @xmath194 and @xmath193 is described by the @xmath191 psg .
the two ground states have different quantum orders and different string - net condensations . in this section
we still assume @xmath150 and consider only the translation invariant model . in the above we discussed the psg for the ends of one type of condensed strings in different states . in this section ,
we will concentrate on only one ground state .
we know that the ground state of our spin-1/2 model contain condensations of several type of strings .
we like to calculate the the different psg s for the different condensed strings .
the psg s for the condensed t1 and t2 strings were obtained above . here
we will discuss the psg for the t3 string .
since the ends of the t3 strings live on the links , the corresponding single - particle hopping hamiltonian @xmath195 describes fermion hopping between links .
clearly , the symmetry group ( the psg ) of @xmath196 can be different from that of @xmath112 .
let us consider fermion hopping around some small loops .
the four hops of a fermion around a site @xmath28 ( see fig . [ fhop ] ) are generated by @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 , and @xmath198 .
the total amplitude of a fermion hopping around a site is @xmath200 .
the fermion hopping around a site always sees @xmath76-flux .
the four hops of a fermion around a plaquette @xmath50 ( see fig .
[ fhop ] ) are generated by @xmath201 , @xmath202 , @xmath203 , and @xmath204 , where @xmath205 is the lower left corner of the plaquette @xmath50 .
the total amplitude of a fermion hopping around a plaquette is given by @xmath206 .
when @xmath192 , the ground state has @xmath207 .
however , since site @xmath205 is next to the end of t3 string , we have @xmath208 . in this case
, the fermion hopping around a plaquette sees @xmath76-flux . for @xmath194 ground state , we find that fermion hopping around a plaquette sees no flux .
let us define the fermion hopping @xmath209 as the combination of two hops @xmath210 and the fermion hopping @xmath211 as the combination of @xmath212 ( see fig .
[ fhop ] ) .
under such a definition , a fermion hopping around a square @xmath213 correspond to a fermion hopping around a site and a fermion hopping around a plaquette discussed above ( see fig . [ fhop ] ) .
therefore , the total amplitude for a fermion hopping around a square is given by the sign of @xmath214 : @xmath215 .
we find the translation symmetries @xmath189 of the fermion hopping @xmath196 satisfies @xmath216 which is different from the translation algebra for @xmath112 .
@xmath196 is also invariant under @xmath137 : @xmath217 @xmath218 generate the symmetry group - the fermion psg - of @xmath196 .
we will call the fermion psg for @xmath219 the @xmath130 psg and the fermion psg for @xmath220 the @xmath131 psg .
we see that the quantum orders in the ground state can also be characterized using the fermion psg .
the quantum order in the @xmath192 ground state is characterized by the @xmath130 psg and the quantum order in the @xmath194 ground state is characterized by the @xmath131 psg . in
, the spin-1/2 model ( with @xmath221 ) was viewed as a hardcore boson model .
the model was solved using slave - boson approach by splitting a boson into two fermions .
then it was shown the fermion hopping hamiltonian for @xmath192 and @xmath194 states have different symmetries , or invariant under different psg s . according to the arguments in ,
the different psg s imply different quantum orders in the @xmath192 and @xmath194 ground state states .
the psg s obtained in for the @xmath192 and @xmath194 phases agrees exactly with the fermion psg s that we obtained above .
this example shows that the psg s introduced in are the symmetry groups of the hopping hamiltonian of the ends of condensed strings . the psg description and the string - net - condensation description of quantum orders
are intimately related . here
we would like to point out that the psg s introduced in are all fermion psg s .
they are only one of many different kinds of psg s that can be used to characterize quantum orders . in general
, a quantum ordered state may contain condensations of several types of strings .
the ends of each type of condensed strings will have their own psg .
in , it was pointed out that psg can protect masslessness of the emerging fermions , just like symmetry can protect the masslessness of nambu - goldstone bosons . in this section
, we are going to study an exact soluble spin-@xmath222 model with string - net condensation and emerging massless fermions . through this soluble model ,
we demonstrate how psg that characterizes the string - net condensation can protect the masslessness of the fermions .
the exact soluble model that we are going to study is motivated by kitaev s exact soluble spin-1/2 model on honeycomb lattice.@xcite the exact soluble model is a local bosonic model on square lattice . to construct the model , we start with four majorana fermions @xmath223 , @xmath224 and one complex fermion @xmath225 . @xmath223
satisfy @xmath226 we note that @xmath227 form a commuting set of operators .
using such a commuting set of operators , we can construct the following exact soluble interacting fermion model @xmath228 where @xmath229 , @xmath230 , @xmath231 , and @xmath107 is real .
we will call @xmath57 a @xmath2 flux operator . to obtain the hilbert space within which the hamiltonian @xmath232 acts , we group @xmath233 into two complex fermion operators @xmath234 on each site .
the complex fermion operators @xmath235 and @xmath225 generate an eight dimensional hilbert space on each site .
since @xmath236 commute with each other , we can find the common eigenstates of the @xmath236 operators : @xmath237 , where @xmath238 is the eigenvalue of @xmath239 , and @xmath240 labels different degenerate common eigenstates .
since @xmath241 and @xmath242 , @xmath238 satisfies @xmath243 and @xmath244 . within the subspace with a fixed set of @xmath238 : @xmath245
, the hamiltonian has a form @xmath246 which is a free fermion hamiltonian .
thus we can find all the many - body eigenstates of @xmath247 : @xmath248 and their energies @xmath249 in each subspace . this way we solve the interacting fermion model exactly .
we note that the hamiltonian @xmath232 can only change the fermion number on each site by an even number .
thus the @xmath232 acts within a subspace which has an even number of fermions on each site .
we will call the subspace physical hilbert space .
the physical hilbert space has only four states per site .
when defined on the physical space , @xmath232 becomes a local bosonic system which actually describes a spin @xmath250 system ( with no spin rotation symmetry ) .
we will call such a system spin-@xmath222 system . to obtain an expression of @xmath232 within the physical hilbert space , we introduce two majorana fermions @xmath251 and @xmath252 to represent @xmath247 : @xmath253 .
we note that @xmath254 , @xmath224 , act within the four dimensional physical hilbert space on each site , and thus are 4 by 4 matrices .
also @xmath255 , thus the four 4 by 4 matrices @xmath254 satisfy the algebra of dirac matrices
. therefore we can express @xmath254 in terms of dirac matrices @xmath256 : @xmath257 we can also define the @xmath258 @xmath259 where we have used @xmath260 and @xmath261 for states with even numbers of fermions . with the above definition of @xmath256 and @xmath258 , we find that @xmath262 and @xmath263 we also have @xmath264 the above relations allows us to write @xmath232 in terms of 4 by 4 dirac matrices .
for example @xmath265 and @xmath266 the physical states in the physical hilbert space are invariant under local @xmath2 gauge transformations generated by @xmath267 where @xmath268 is an arbitrary function with only two values @xmath59 and @xmath269 the number of fermions on site @xmath28 .
we note that the @xmath2 gauge transformations change @xmath270 .
the projection into the physical hilbert space with even fermion per site makes our theory a @xmath2 gauge theory .
since the hamiltonian @xmath232 in is @xmath2 gauge invariant : @xmath271=0 $ ] , eigenstate of @xmath232 within the physical hilbert space can be obtained from @xmath272 by projecting into the physical hilbert space : @xmath273 .
the projected state @xmath274 ( or the physical state ) , if non - zero , is an eigenstate of the spin-@xmath222 model with energy @xmath275 .
the @xmath2 gauge invariance implies that @xmath276 if @xmath238 and @xmath277 are @xmath2 gauge equivalent @xmath278 let us count the states to show that the projected states @xmath279 generate all states in the physical hilbert space .
let us consider a periodic lattice with @xmath280 sites .
first there are @xmath281 choices of @xmath238 .
we note that there are @xmath282 different @xmath2 gauge transformations .
but the constant gauge transformation @xmath283 does not change @xmath238 .
thus there are @xmath284 different @xmath285 s in each @xmath2 gauge equivalent class .
therefore , there are @xmath286 different @xmath2 gauge equivalent classes of @xmath238 s .
we also note that @xmath287 thus , among the @xmath286 different classes of @xmath238 s , @xmath282 of them satisfy @xmath288 and have even numbers of @xmath289 and @xmath290 fermions .
the other @xmath282 of them satisfy @xmath291 and have odd numbers of @xmath289 and @xmath290 fermions . for each fixed @xmath238
, there are @xmath282 many - body states of the @xmath247 fermions , @xmath240 in @xmath272 runs from 1 to @xmath282 . among those @xmath282 many - body states , @xmath284 of them have even numbers of @xmath247 fermions and @xmath284 of them have odd numbers of @xmath247 fermions . in order for the projection @xmath292 to be non - zero , the total number of fermions must be even .
a physical state has even numbers of @xmath293 fermions and even numbers of @xmath247 fermions , or it has odd numbers of @xmath293 fermions and odd numbers of @xmath247 fermions .
thus there are @xmath294 distinct physical states that can be produced by the projection .
thus the projection produces all the states in the physical hilbert space .
let us define a closed - string operator to be @xmath295 where @xmath296 is an closed oriented string @xmath297 formed by nearest neighbor links .
since @xmath296 can intersect with itself , @xmath296 can also be viewed as a closed string - net .
we will also call @xmath298 a closed - string - net operator .
the closed - string - net operators act within the physical hilbert space and commute with the hamiltonian .
thus there is a string - net condensation since @xmath299 in the ground state of .
the above strings correspond to the t3 string discussed in section [ 3type ] . unlike the spin-1/2 model , we do not have condensed t1 and t2 closed strings in the spin-@xmath222 model .
we can also define open - string operators that act within the physical hilbert space @xmath300 where @xmath301 is an open oriented string @xmath302 formed by nearest neighbor links .
@xmath303 correspond to the open t3 string defined in section [ 3type ] . just like the spin-1/2 model
, the ends of such strings correspond to gapped fermions ( if @xmath304 strings by a local bosonic operator .
thus the ends of @xmath305 strings are also fermions . .
, width=192 ] to really prove the ends of @xmath305 strings are fermions , we need to show the hopping of the ends of @xmath305 strings satisfy the fermion hopping algebra introduced in : @xmath306= & 0,\ \
\hbox{if $ i , j , k , l$ are all different,}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath307 describes the hopping from site @xmath308 to site @xmath309 .
it was shown that the particles are fermions if their hopping satisfy the algebra .
we note that the ends of the @xmath305 strings live on the sites . the labels @xmath310 in the above equation correspond to lattice sites @xmath311 .
the hops between sites @xmath312 in fig .
[ 2dhop ] are given by @xmath313 note that the hops between nearest neighbors are taken from the hamiltonian . since @xmath236 commute with each other , the algebra of the above hopping operators is just that of fermion hopping operators . in particular ,
the above hopping operators satisfy the fermion hopping algebra .
hence , the ends of the @xmath305 strings are fermions . for each fixed configuration @xmath238 , there are @xmath284 different states ( with even or odd numbers of total @xmath225 fermions ) .
their energy are given by the fermion hopping hamiltonian .
let @xmath314 be the ground state energy of .
the ground state and the ground state energy of our spin-@xmath222 model is obtained by choosing a configuration @xmath238 that minimize @xmath314 .
we note that @xmath314 is invariant under the @xmath2 gauge transformation . when @xmath315 , the ground state of has @xmath71 which minimize the dominating @xmath316 term .
the ground state configuration is given by @xmath317 the @xmath247 fermion hopping hamiltonian for the above configuration describes fermion hopping with @xmath76-flux per plaquette .
the fermion spectrum has a form @xmath318 the low energy excitations of such a hopping hamiltonian are described by two two - component massless dirac fermions in 2 + 1d .
we see that the ends of the @xmath305 strings are massless dirac fermions .
our model also contain @xmath2 gauge excitations .
the @xmath2 vortices are created by flipping @xmath71 to @xmath170 in some plaquettes .
the @xmath2 vortex behaves like a @xmath76-flux to the gapless fermions .
thus the gapless fermions carry a unit @xmath2 charge .
the low energy effective theory of our model is massless dirac fermions coupled to a @xmath2 gauge field .
we know that symmetry breaking can produce and protect gapless nambu - goldstone modes .
in , it was proposed that , in addition to symmetry breaking , quantum order can also produce and protect gapless excitations .
the gapless excitations produced and protected by quantum order can be gapless gauge bosons and/or gapless fermions . in this paper
we show that the quantum orders discussed in are due to string - net condensations .
therefore , more precisely it is string - net condensations that produce and protect gapless gauge bosons and/or gapless fermions .
the string - net condensations and gapless excitations are connected in the following way .
let us consider a hamiltonian that has a symmetry described by a symmetry group @xmath319 .
we assume the ground state has a string - net condensation .
then , the hopping hamiltonian for the ends of condensed string will be invariant under a larger group - the projective symmetry group @xmath320 , as discussed in section [ psgend ] .
@xmath320 is an extension of the symmetry group @xmath319 , @xmath320 contain a normal subgroup @xmath321 such that @xmath322 .
the relation between @xmath320 and gapless gauge bosons is simple .
let @xmath323 be the maximum continuous subgroup of @xmath321 .
then the gapless gauge bosons are described by a gauge theory with @xmath323 as the gauge group.@xcite some times the ends of strings are fermions . however , the relation between gapless fermions and @xmath320 is more complicated . through a case by case study of some @xmath320s@xcite
, we find that certain @xmath320 s indeed guarantee the existence of gapless fermions . in this section
, we are going to study a large family of exact soluble local bosonic models which depends on many continuous parameters .
the ground states of the local bosonic models have a string - net condensation and do not break any symmetry .
we will show that the projective symmetry of the ends of condensed strings protects a massless fermion . as a result
, our exact soluble model always has massless fermion excitations regardless the value of the continuous parameters ( as long as they are within a certain range ) .
this puts the results of , which were based on mean - field theory , on a firmer ground .
the exact soluble local bosonic models are the spin-@xmath222 model @xmath324 where @xmath325 and @xmath326 are given in and .
we will discuss a more general hamiltonian later .
the hamiltonian is not invariant under @xmath327 parity @xmath328 .
but it has a @xmath327 parity symmetry if @xmath328 is followed by a spin rotation @xmath329 .
that is @xmath330 with @xmath331 similarly for @xmath332 parity @xmath333 , we have @xmath334 with @xmath335 in the fermion representation @xmath336 and @xmath337 generate the following transformations @xmath338 now let us study how the symmetries @xmath339 and @xmath340 are realized in the hopping hamiltonian for the ends of condensed strings . as discussed in section [ psgend ] , the hopping hamiltonian may not be invariant under the symmetry transformations @xmath339 and @xmath340 directly .
the hopping hamiltonian only has a projective symmetry generated by a symmetry transformation followed by a @xmath2 gauge transformation @xmath341 .
since the @xmath76-flux configuration does not break any symmetries , we expect the hopping hamiltonian for the @xmath76-flux configuration to be invariant under @xmath342 , @xmath343 , @xmath344 , and @xmath345 , where @xmath346 and @xmath347 are the corresponding gauge transformations .
the action of @xmath339 and @xmath340 on the @xmath225 fermion are given by @xmath348 for the @xmath76-flux configuration , we need to choose the following @xmath346 and @xmath347 in order for the combined transformation @xmath349 and @xmath350 to be the symmetries of the hopping hamiltonian @xmath351 the hopping hamiltonian is also invariant under a global @xmath2 gauge transformation @xmath352 the transformations @xmath353 generate the psg of the hopping hamiltonian . to show that the above psg protects the masslessness of the fermions , we consider a more general hamiltonian by adding @xmath354 to @xmath355 , where @xmath356 is an open string connecting site @xmath28 and site @xmath357 and @xmath358 is given in .
the new hamiltonian is still exactly soluble .
we will choose @xmath359 such that the new hamiltonian has the translation symmetries and the @xmath360 parity symmetries .
in the following , we would like to show that the new hamiltonian with those symmetries always has massless dirac fermion excitations ( assuming @xmath361 is not too big comparing to @xmath48 ) .
when @xmath361 is not too large , the ground state is still described by the @xmath76-flux configuration .
the new hopping hamiltonian for @xmath76-flux configuration has a more general form @xmath362 the symmetry of the physical spin-@xmath222 hamiltonian requires that the above hopping hamiltonian to be invariant under the psg discussed above .
such an invariance will guarantee the existence of massless fermions .
the invariance under @xmath342 and @xmath343 require that @xmath363 in the momentum space , @xmath364 where @xmath365 we note that @xmath366 and @xmath367 are periodic function in the brillouin zone .
they also satisfy @xmath368 where @xmath369 and @xmath370 . in the momentum space ,
we can rewrite @xmath232 as @xmath371 where @xmath372 .
the sum @xmath373 is over the reduced brillouin zone : @xmath374 and @xmath375 .
@xmath376 has a form @xmath377 note that the transformation@xmath336 : @xmath378 changes @xmath379 to @xmath380 with @xmath381 .
thus the invariance under @xmath344 requires that @xmath382 or @xmath383 in the momentum space , the above becomes @xmath384 similarly , the invariance under @xmath345 requires that @xmath385 or @xmath386 in the momentum space @xmath387 we see that the translation @xmath339 and @xmath327 parity @xmath388 symmetries of the spin-@xmath222 hamiltonian require that @xmath389 and hence @xmath390 .
similarly , the translation @xmath339 and @xmath332 parity @xmath391 symmetries require that @xmath392 .
thus @xmath339 and @xmath340 symmetries require that @xmath393 .
using , we find that @xmath394 implies that @xmath395 .
the spin-@xmath222 hamiltonian has ( at least ) two two - component massless dirac fermions if it has two translation @xmath339 and two parity @xmath340 symmetries .
we see that string - net condensation and the associated projective symmetry produce and protect massless dirac fermions .
the above calculation and the 2d model can be generalized to 3d cubic lattice .
we introduce six majorana fermions @xmath396 , where @xmath397 .
one set of commuting operators on square lattice has a form @xmath398 using @xmath399 and a complex fermion @xmath247 , we can construct an exact soluble interacting hamiltonian on cubic lattice @xmath400 where @xmath401 sum over all the square faces of the cubic lattice .
@xmath402 , @xmath403 , @xmath404 , and @xmath405 label the four corners of the square @xmath50 .
the hilbert space of system is generated by complex fermion operators @xmath247 and @xmath406 and there are 16 states per site .
a physical hilbert space is defined as a subspace with even numbers of fermions per site .
the physical hilbert space has 8 states per site .
when restricted in the physical hilbert space , @xmath407 defines our spin-@xmath408 system , which is a _ local bosonic system_. when @xmath315 , our spin-@xmath408 model has two four - component massless dirac fermions as its low lying excitations .
the model also has a @xmath2 gauge excitations and the massless dirac fermions carry unit @xmath2 gauge charge .
again , the model has a string - net condensation in its ground state .
both the @xmath2 gauge excitation and the massless fermion are produced and protected by the string - net condensation and the associated psg .
in this section , we are going to combine the above 3d model and the rotor model discussed in and to obtain a quasi - exact soluble local bosonic model that contains massless dirac fermions coupled to massless @xmath1 gauge bosons .
a rotor is described by an angular variable @xmath409 .
the angular momentum of @xmath409 , denoted as @xmath410 , is quantized as integers .
the 3d rotor model under consideration has one rotor on every link of a cubic lattice .
we use @xmath411 to label the nearest neighbor links . @xmath412 and @xmath413
label the same links . for convenience
, we will define @xmath414 and @xmath415 .
the 3d rotor hamiltonian has a form @xmath416 here @xmath417 label the sites of the cubic lattice , and @xmath418 .
the @xmath401 sum over all the square faces of the cubic lattice .
@xmath402 , @xmath403 , @xmath404 , and @xmath405 label the four corners of the square @xmath50 . when @xmath419 and @xmath39 , the state with all @xmath420 is a ground state .
such a state will be regarded as a state with no strings .
we can create a string or a string - net from the no - string state using the following string ( or string - net ) operator @xmath421 where @xmath78 is a string ( or a string - net ) formed by the nearest neighbor links , and @xmath26 is a product over all the nearest neighbor links @xmath412 on the string ( or string - net ) . since the closed - string - net operator @xmath422 commute with @xmath423 when @xmath419 , @xmath422 generate a large set of degenerate ground states .
the degenerate ground states are described by closed string - nets .
there is another way to generate the degenerate ground states .
we note that all the degenerate ground states satisfy @xmath424 .
let @xmath425 be the common eigenstate of @xmath426 : @xmath427 .
then the projection into @xmath424 subspace : @xmath428 give us a degenerate ground state .
we note that @xmath429 generate a @xmath1 gauge transformation @xmath430 , where @xmath431 thus two @xmath1 gauge equivalent configurations @xmath432 and @xmath433 give rise to the same projected state @xmath434 we find that the degenerate ground states are described by @xmath1 gauge equivalent classes of @xmath432 .
the degenerate ground states also have a @xmath1 gauge structure . when @xmath54 but @xmath435 , the degeneracy in the ground states are lifted .
one can show that , in this case , @xmath428 is an energy eigenstate with an energy @xmath436 .
clearly two @xmath1 gauge equivalent configurations @xmath432 and @xmath433 have the same energy .
the non - zero @xmath437 makes the closed string - nets to fluctuate and vanishing @xmath60 means that the strings in the string - nets have no tension .
thus @xmath54 ground state has strong fluctuations of large closed string - nets , and the ground state has a closed - string - net condensation.@xcite when @xmath438 , @xmath428 is no longer an eigenstate .
the fluctuations of @xmath432 describe a dynamical @xmath1 gauge theory with @xmath432 as the gauge potential.@xcite to obtain massless dirac fermions and @xmath1 gauge bosons from a local bosonic model , we mix the spin-@xmath408 model and the rotor model to get @xmath439 where @xmath440 . if we restrict ourselves within the physical hilbert space with even numbers of fermions per site , the above model is a local bosonic model .
let us first set @xmath54 . in this case
, the above model can be solved exactly .
first let us also set @xmath441 . in this case
@xmath442 and @xmath443 commute with @xmath444 and commute with each other .
let @xmath445 be the common eigenstates of @xmath446 and @xmath447 , where @xmath448 labels different degenerate common eigenstates .
within the subspace expanded by @xmath445 , @xmath448 , the @xmath444 reduces to @xmath449 which is a free fermion hopping model .
let @xmath450 be the many - fermion eigenstate of the above fermion hopping model and let @xmath451 be its energy . then @xmath452 is also an eigenstate of @xmath453 with energy @xmath451 .
we note that @xmath454 commute with each other and commute with @xmath444 .
thus the eigenstates of @xmath455 can be obtained from the eigenstates of @xmath453 by projecting into the subspace with @xmath456 : @xmath457 the above state is an eigenstate of @xmath455 with an energy @xmath458 and are our exact solution of @xmath455 .
( we have implicitly assumed that @xmath459 also perform the projection into the physical hilbert space of even numbers of fermions per site . )
when @xmath45 is positive and large , the low energy excitations only appear in the sector @xmath460 .
those low energy eigenstates are given by @xmath461 where @xmath462 is the projection into the @xmath460 subspace and the even - fermion subspace .
their energy is @xmath451 .
let us further assume that @xmath463 and @xmath315 . in this limit , the ground state have @xmath464 and @xmath465 .
we can choose @xmath466 to describe such a configuration .
for such a configuration , describes a staggered fermion hamiltonian.@xcite the ground state wave function @xmath467 is an eigenstate of the @xmath1 closed - string - net operator @xmath422 with eigenvalue @xmath69 .
it is also a eigenstate of the @xmath2 closed - string - net operator @xmath298 with eigenvalue @xmath468 where @xmath469 is the number of the square plaquettes enclosed by @xmath296 .
we see that there is a condensation of closed @xmath1 and @xmath2 string - nets in the @xmath54 ground state .
in such a string - net condensed state , there are gapless fermionic excitations , which are described by fermion - hopping in @xmath76-flux phase . in the momentum space
, the fermion hopping hamiltonian for the @xmath76-flux configuration has a form @xmath470 where @xmath471 and @xmath472 , @xmath473 , and @xmath474 .
here @xmath475 are the pauli matrices and @xmath476 is the 2 by 2 identity matrix .
the momentum summation @xmath477 is over a range @xmath478 , @xmath479 , and @xmath480 . since @xmath481 , @xmath482 , we find the fermions have a dispersion @xmath483 we see that the dispersion has two nodes at @xmath484 and @xmath485
. thus , will give rise to 2 massless four - component dirac fermions in the continuum limit .
after including the @xmath1 gauge fluctuations described by @xmath432 and the @xmath2 gauge fluctuations described by @xmath238 , the massless dirac fermions interact with the @xmath1 and the @xmath2 gauge fields as fermions with unit charge .
therefore the total low energy effective theory of our model is a qed with 2 families of dirac fermions of unit charge ( plus an extra @xmath2 gauge filed ) .
we will call those fermions artificial electrons .
the continuum effective theory has a form @xmath486 where @xmath487 is the lattice constant , @xmath488 , @xmath489 , @xmath490 , @xmath491 , @xmath492 are @xmath493 dirac matrices , and @xmath494 .
we like to pointed out the constant @xmath78 is is of order @xmath69 .
thus the coefficient of the @xmath495 term @xmath496 when @xmath54 . for a finite @xmath60
, the @xmath1 gauge field will have a non - trivial dynamics .
we also like to point out that , without fine tuning , the speed of artificial light , @xmath497 , and the speed of artificial electrons , @xmath498 , do not have to be the same in our model . thus the lorentz symmetry is not guaranteed .
we would like to remark that , for finite @xmath60 , the @xmath1 closed - string operators no longer condense .
a necessary ( but not sufficient ) condition for closed strings to condense is that the ground state expectation value of the closed - string operator satisfy the perimeter law @xmath499 where @xmath500 is the length of the closed string and @xmath501 are constants for large closed strings .
we note that the closed - string operators are the wilson loop operator of the @xmath1 gauge field .
if the 3 + 1d @xmath1 gauge theory is in the coulomb phase where the artificial light is gapless , it was found that@xcite @xmath502 where @xmath503 depend on the shape of the closed string @xmath296 even in the large - string limit .
thus the closed strings in our model do not exactly condense .
the @xmath1 coulomb phase is , in some sense , similar to the algebraic - long - range order phase of 1 + 1d interacting boson model where the bosons do not exactly condense but the boson operator has an algebraic - long - range correlation
. describes the low energy dynamics of the ends of open strings ( the fermion @xmath225 ) and the `` condensed '' closed string - nets ( the @xmath1 gauge field ) .
the fermions and gauge boson are massless and interact with each other . here
we would like to address an important question : after integrating out high energy fermions and gauge fluctuations , do fermions and gauge boson remain to be massless ? in general , interaction between massless excitations will generate a mass term for them , unless the masslessness is protected by symmetry or some other things . we know that due to the @xmath1 gauge invariance , the radiative corrections can not generate counter term that break the @xmath1 gauge invariance .
thus radiative corrections can not generate mass for the @xmath1 gauge boson .
for the fermions , if the theory has a chiral symmetry @xmath504 , @xmath505 , then the radiative corrections can not generate counter terms that break the chiral symmetry and thus can not generate mass for fermions .
although the low energy effective theory appears to have the chiral symmetry , in fact it does not .
this is because that is derived from a lattice model .
it contains many other higher order terms summarized by the @xmath506 in .
those higher order terms do not have the chiral symmetry . to see this
, we note that the action of @xmath258 on @xmath507 is realized by a 4 by 4 matrix @xmath508 .
we also note that the periodic boundary conditions of @xmath507 in the reduced brillouin zone are given by @xmath509 we find that the action of @xmath258 is incompatible with the periodic boundary conditions since @xmath258 does not commute with @xmath510 and @xmath511 . therefore the chiral symmetry generated by @xmath258 can not be realized on lattice . due to the lack of chiral symmetry
, it appears that the radiative corrections can generate a mass term @xmath512 which is allowed by the symmetry .
the lack of chiral symmetry on lattice makes it very difficult to study massless fermions / quarks in lattice gauge theory . in
last a few years , this problem was solved using the ginsparg - wilson relation.@xcite in the following , we would like to show that there is another way to solve the massless - fermion / chiral - symmetry problem . we will show that our model has an emerging chiral symmetry that appear only at low energies .
the low energy chiral symmetry comes from the non - trivial quantum order and the associated psg in the string - net condensed ground state.@xcite the dirac operator in our model satisfies a linear relation @xmath513 in contrast to the non - linear ginsparg - wilson relation @xmath514 because of the low energy chiral symmetry , all the @xmath515 families of dirac fermions remain massless even after we include the radiative corrections from the interaction with the @xmath1 gauge bosons . to see how the string - net condensation and the related psg protect the massless fermions ,
we follow closely the discussion in section [ psgmassless ] .
the hamiltonian is a mixture of the rotor model and the spin-@xmath408 model .
the symmetry properties of the rotor part is simple . here
, we will concentrate on the spin-@xmath408 part .
is not invariant under the six parity transformations : @xmath516 and @xmath517 that generate @xmath518 , @xmath519 , @xmath520 , @xmath521 , @xmath522 , and @xmath523 .
but it is invariant under parity @xmath516 and @xmath517 followed by spin rotations @xmath524 and @xmath525 respectively . in the fermion representation @xmath524 and
@xmath525 generate the following transformations @xmath526 the symmetries @xmath339 , @xmath527 , and @xmath528 are realized in the hopping hamiltonian through psg .
the hopping hamiltonian is invariant only under the symmetry transformations followed by proper @xmath2 gauge transformations @xmath529 .
since the @xmath76-flux configuration @xmath238 of the spin-@xmath408 sector and the zero - flux configuration @xmath530 of the rotor sector do not break any symmetries , we expect the hopping hamiltonian to be invariant under @xmath531 , @xmath532 , and @xmath533 .
the action of @xmath339 and @xmath528 on the @xmath225 fermion are standard coordinate transformations .
the action of @xmath527 on the @xmath225 fermion are given by @xmath534 for the @xmath76-flux configuration , we need to choose the following @xmath535 , @xmath536 , and @xmath537 in order for the combined transformation @xmath349 , @xmath350 , and @xmath533 to be the symmetries of the hopping hamiltonian @xmath538 the hopping hamiltonian is also invariant under a global @xmath2 gauge transformation @xmath352 the transformations @xmath539 , @xmath532 , @xmath540 generate a psg ( a part of the full psg ) of the hopping hamiltonian . to study the robustness of massless fermions , we consider a more general hamiltonian by adding @xmath541 to @xmath444 , where @xmath356 is an open string connecting site @xmath28 and site @xmath357 and @xmath542 an open - string operator @xmath543 the new hamiltonian is still exactly soluble , when @xmath54 .
we will choose @xmath361 such that the new hamiltonian has the translation symmetries and the @xmath516 parity symmetries .
we find that the resulting projective symmetry imposes enough constraint on the hopping hamiltonian for the ends of condensed strings such that the hamiltonian always has massless dirac fermions ( assuming @xmath361 is not too big comparing to @xmath48 and @xmath437 ) . despite the psg transformations @xmath533 are not needed for the existence of the massless fermions
, we will still include them in the following discussion . for small @xmath361 ,
the ground state is still described by the @xmath76-flux configuration .
the new hopping hamiltonian for @xmath76-flux configuration has a more general form @xmath362 the symmetry of the generalized @xmath444 requires that the above hopping hamiltonian to be invariant under the psg generated by @xmath544 , @xmath545 , @xmath546 .
the invariance under @xmath531 require that @xmath547 in the momentum space , @xmath548 where @xmath549 we note that @xmath550 are periodic function in the lattice brillouin zone @xmath551 .
they also satisfy @xmath552 the @xmath376 in now has a form @xmath553 just as discussed in section [ psgmassless ] , the invariance under @xmath344 requires that @xmath382 or @xmath554 in the momentum space , the above becomes @xmath555 where @xmath556 .
similarly , the invariance under @xmath345 requires that @xmath557 in the momentum space @xmath558 the invariance under @xmath559 requires that @xmath560 in the momentum space @xmath561 the invariance under @xmath562 requires that @xmath563 or @xmath564 in the momentum space @xmath565 the invariance under @xmath566 requires that @xmath567 or @xmath568 the invariance under @xmath569 requires that @xmath570 or @xmath571 we see that require that @xmath572 and @xmath573 .
require that @xmath574 and @xmath575 .
thus the @xmath576 .
when combined with , , and , we find @xmath577 therefore @xmath578 when @xmath579 .
the two translation @xmath339 and the three parity @xmath527 symmetries of @xmath444 guarantee the existence of at least 2 four - component massless dirac fermions . or
more precisely , no symmetric local perturbations in the local bosonic model @xmath444 can generate mass terms for the two massless dirac fermions in the unperturbed hamiltonian .
since the mass term in the continuum effective field theory is not allowed by the underlying lattice psg , we say that our model has an emerging chiral symmetry .
the masslessness of the dirac fermion is protected by the quantum order and the associated psg .
in this section , we are going to generalize the results in and and use a bosonic model on cubic lattice to generate qed and qcd with @xmath580 families of massless quarks and leptons . to describe the local hilbert space on site @xmath28 in our bosonic model , it is convenient to introduce fermions @xmath396 and @xmath581 , where @xmath582 , @xmath583 and @xmath584 .
@xmath396 is in the fundamental representation of a @xmath585 group .
@xmath581 is in the fundamental representation of a @xmath586 color group and a @xmath587 group .
the hilbert space of fermions is bigger than the hilbert space of our boson model .
only a physical subspace of the fermions hilbert space becomes the hilbert space of our boson model .
the physical states on each site is formed by color singlet states that satisfy @xmath588 where @xmath589 is assumed to be even .
once restricted within the physical hilbert space , the fermion model becomes our local bosonic model . in the fermion representation ,
the local physical operators in our bosonic model are given by @xmath590 we note that by definition @xmath591 .
the hamiltonian of our boson model is given by @xmath592\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us assume , for the time being , @xmath593 . in terms of fermions , the above hamiltonian can be rewritten as @xmath594 using path integral , we can rewrite the above model as @xmath595 \psi^{n}_{\v i } - \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } ( \psi^{n \dag}_{\v i } u_{\v i\v j } \psi^{n}_{\v j } + h.c . )
\nonumber\\ & + \la^{a \dag}_{\v i}i[\prt_t+i \tr a_0(\v i ) ] \la^{a}_{\v i } - \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } ( \la^{a \dag}_{\v i } \chi_{\v i\v j } \la^{a}_{\v j } + h.c . )
\nonumber\\ & - \frac{n_f}{j_1 } \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } \tr(u_{\v i\v j } u_{\v i\v j}^\dag ) - \frac{n_f}{j_2 } \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } \chi_{\v i\v j } \chi_{\v i\v j}^\dag\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath596 , and @xmath597 and @xmath598 are @xmath599 complex matrices that satisfy @xmath600 when @xmath601 , the lagrangian may contain terms that mix @xmath602 and @xmath598 : @xmath603 \psi^{n}_{\v i } - \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } ( \psi^{n \dag}_{\v i } u_{\v i\v j } \psi^{n}_{\v j } + h.c . )
\nonumber\\ & + \la^{a \dag}_{\v i}i[\prt_t+i \tr a_0(\v i ) ] \la^{a}_{\v i } - \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } ( \la^{a \dag}_{\v i } \chi_{\v i\v j } \la^{a}_{\v j } + h.c . ) \nonumber\\ & - \frac{n_f}{j_1 } \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } \tr(u_{\v i\v j } u_{\v i\v j}^\dag ) - \frac{n_f}{j_2 } \sum_{\<\v i\v j\ > } \chi_{\v i\v j } \chi_{\v i\v j}^\dag \nonumber\\ & + c n_f \sum_{\<\v i\v j\>}[\chi_{\v i\v j}\det(u_{\v j\v i})+h.c.]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 is a @xmath604 constant
. we note that the above lagrangian describes a @xmath605 lattice gauge theory coupled to fermions .
the field @xmath597 in the lagrangian is introduced to enforce the constraint @xmath606 as in standard gauge theory , the above constraint really means a constraint on physical states .
all physical states must satisfy @xmath607 the above is the needed constraint to obtain the hilbert space of our bosonic model . here
we would like to stress that writing a bosonic model in terms of gauge theory does not imply the existence physical gauge bosons at low energy . using projective construction ,
we can write any model in terms of a gauge theory of any gauge group.@xcite the existence of low energy gauge fluctuations is a property of ground state .
it has nothing to do with how we write the hamiltonian in terms of this or that gauge theory .
certainly , if the ground state is known to have certain gauge fluctuations , then writing hamiltonian in term of a particular gauge theory that happen to have the same gauge group will help us to derive the low energy effective theory .
even when we do not know the low energy gauge fluctuations in the ground state , we can still try to write the hamiltonian in a form that contains certain gauge theory and try to derive the low energy effective gauge theory .
most of the times , we find the gauge fluctuations in the low energy effective theory is so strong that the gauge theory is in the confining phase . this indicates that we have chosen a wrong form of hamiltonian .
however , if we are lucky to choose the right form of hamiltonian with right gauge group , then the gauge fluctuations in the low energy effective theory will be weak and the gauge fields @xmath608 , @xmath602 and @xmath598 will be almost like classical fields . in this case , we can say that the ground state of the hamiltonian contains low energy gauge fluctuations described by @xmath608 , @xmath602 and @xmath598 . in the following
, we will show that the @xmath605 fermion model is the right form for us to write the hamiltonian of our bosonic model . after integrating out the fermions ,
we obtain the following effective theory for @xmath597 , @xmath602 and @xmath598 @xmath609 where @xmath610 does not depend on @xmath589 .
we see that , in the large @xmath589 limit , @xmath602 , @xmath598 and @xmath608 indeed becomes classical fields with weak fluctuations . in the semi - classical limit , the ground state of the system is given by the ansatz @xmath611 that minimize the energy @xmath612 .
we will assume that such an ansatz have @xmath76 flux on every plaquette and takes a form @xmath613 ( if the @xmath76-flux ansatz does not minimize the energy , we can always modify the hamiltonian of our bosonic model to make the @xmath76-flux ansatz to have the minimal energy . ) despite the @xmath28 dependence , the above ansatz actually describe translation , rotation , parity , and charge conjugation symmetric states .
this is because the symmetry transformed ansatz , although not equal to the original ansatz , is gauge equivalent to the original ansatz .
the mean - field hamiltonian for fermions has a form @xmath614 the fermion dispersion has two nodes at @xmath484 and @xmath485 .
thus there are @xmath615 massless four - component dirac fermions in the continuum limit .
they correspond to quarks and leptons of @xmath580 different families .
each family contains six quarks ( two flavors times three colors ) that carry @xmath586 colors and charge @xmath616 for the @xmath1 gauge field , and one lepton that carry no @xmath586 colors and charge @xmath69 for the @xmath1 gauge field . including the collective fluctuations of the ansatz , the @xmath617 fermion theory has a form @xmath618 where @xmath619 are @xmath599 hermitian matrices , describing @xmath1 and @xmath586 gauge fields . in the continuum limit ,
the above becomes @xmath620 with @xmath621 , @xmath622 , @xmath623 , @xmath624 , @xmath488 , and @xmath625 are @xmath493 dirac matrices.@xcite @xmath626 and @xmath627 are dirac fermion fields .
@xmath627 form a fundamental representation of color @xmath586 .
if we integrate out @xmath608 and @xmath619 in first , we will recover the bosonic model .
if we integrating out the high energy fermions first , the @xmath605 gauge field @xmath628 will acquire a dynamics .
we obtain the following low energy effective theory in continuum limit @xmath629 + ... \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the velocity of the @xmath630 gauge bosons is @xmath631 , and @xmath506 represents higher derivative terms and the coupling constant @xmath632 is of order @xmath633 . in the large @xmath589 limit ,
fluctuations of the gauge fields are weak .
the model describes a @xmath605 gauge theory coupled weakly to @xmath580 families of massless fermions .
therefore , our bosonic model can generate massless artificial quarks and artificial leptons that couple to artificial light and artificial gluons . as discussed in
, the psg of the ansatz protects the masslessness of the artificial quarks and the artificial leptons .
our model has an emerging chiral symmetry .
in this paper , we studied a new class of ordered states - string - net condensed states - in local bosonic models .
the new kind of orders does not break any symmetry and can not be described by landau s symmetry breaking theory .
we show that different string - net condensation can be characterized ( and hopefully , classified ) by the projective symmetry in the hopping hamiltonian for ends of condensed strings .
similar to symmetry breaking states ( or `` particle '' condensed states ) , string - net condensed states can also produce and protect gapless excitations .
however , unlike symmetry breaking states which can only produce and protect gapless scaler bosons ( or nambu - goldstone modes ) , string - net condensed states can produce and protect gapless gauge bosons and gapless fermions .
it is amazing to see that gapless fermions can even appear in local bosonic models . motivated by the above results , we propose the following locality principle : _ the fundamental theory for our universe is a local bosonic model . _ using several local bosonic models as examples
, we try to argue that the locality principle is not obviously wrong , if we assume that there is a string - net condensation in our vacuum .
the string - net condensation can naturally produce and protect massless photons ( as well as gluons ) and ( nearly ) massless electrons / quarks .
however , to really prove the string - net condensation in our vacuum , we need to show that string - net condensation can generate chiral fermions . also , the above locality principle has not taken quantum gravity into account .
it may need to be generalized to include quantum gravity . in any case
, we can say that we have a plausible understanding where light and fermions come from .
the existence of light and fermions is no longer mysterious once we realize that they can come from local bosonic models via string - net condensations .
the string - net condensation and the associated psg also provide a new solution to the chiral symmetry and the fermion mass problem in lattice qed and lattice qcd .
we show that the symmetry of a lattice bosonic model leads to psg of the hopping hamiltonian for the ends of condensed strings .
if the ends of condensed strings are fermions , then psg can some times protect the masslessness of the fermions , even though the chiral symmetry in the continuum limit can not be generalized to the lattice .
thus psg can lead to an emerging chiral symmetry that protect massless dirac fermions . in this paper , we have been stressing that string - net condensation and the associated psg can protect the masslessness of fermions . however , most fermions in nature do have masses , although very small comparing to the planck mass .
one may wonder where those small masses come from . here
we would like to point out that the psg argument for masslessness only works for radiative corrections .
in other words , the fermions protected by string - net condensation and psg can not gain any mass from additive radiative corrections caused by high energy fluctuations .
however , if the model has infrared divergence , then infrared divergence can give the would - be - massless fermions some masses .
the acquired masses should have the scale of the infrared divergence .
the 3 + 1d qed model studied in this paper do not have any infrared divergence .
thus , the artificial electrons in the model are exactly massless .
but in the bosonic model discussed in section [ secqcd ] , the @xmath586 gauge coupling @xmath632 runs as @xmath634 where @xmath635 is the cut - off scale .
thus when @xmath636 , @xmath632 has a logarithmic infrared divergence . in general , for models with @xmath1 and @xmath586 gauge interactions and a right content of fermions , the @xmath586 gauge interactions can have a weak logarithmic infrared divergence in 3 + 1d.@xcite this weak divergence could generate mass of order @xmath637 , where @xmath638 is the planck mass or the gut scale ( the cut - off scale of the lattice theory ) , @xmath639 and @xmath640 is the dimensionless gauge coupling constant at the planck scale .
an @xmath641 can produce a desired separation between the planck mass / gut scale and the masses of observed fermions .
it is interesting to see that , in order to use string - net condensation picture to explain the origin of gauge bosons and nearly massless fermions , it is important to have a four dimensional space - time .
when space - time has five or more dimensions , the gauge - fermion interaction do not have any infrared divergence . in this case , if a string - net condensation produces massless fermions , those fermions will remain to be massless down to zero energy . in 2 + 1d ,
the gauge interaction between massless fermions is so strong that one can not have fermionic quasiparticles at low energies.@xcite it is amazing to see that 3 + 1 is the only space - time dimension that the gauge bosons and fermions produced by string - net condensation have weak enough interaction so that they can be identified at low energies and , at same time , have strong enough interaction to have a rich non - trivial structure at low energies . | recently , it was pointed out that quantum orders and the associated projective symmetry groups can produce and protect massless gauge bosons and massless fermions in local bosonic models . in this paper
, we demonstrate that a state with such kind of quantum orders can be viewed as a string - net condensed state . the emerging gauge bosons and fermions in local bosonic models
can be regarded as a direct consequence of string - net condensation .
the gauge bosons are fluctuations of large closed string - nets which are condensed in the ground state .
the ends of open strings ( or nodes of open string - nets ) are the charged particles of the corresponding gauge field . for certain types of strings ,
the nodes of string - nets can even be fermions . according to the string - net picture , fermions always carry gauge charges .
this suggests the existence of a new discrete gauge field that couples to neutrinos and neutrons .
we also discuss how chiral symmetry that protects massless dirac fermions can emerge from the projective symmetry of quantum order . |
in astronomy , raw ccd images from telescopes can not be directly used for scientific purposes .
firstly , several instrumental effects must be removed . generally speaking
, data reduction is the transformation of raw data into a form suitable for analysis .
the following processes are required to achieve this goal : * removal of instrumental signatures , such as bias offset , dark currents , field curvature ( caused by projecting the spherical sky onto a flat ccd plane ) , and fringe patterns ; * masking of unwanted signals , such as cosmic rays , stellar halos and satellite tracks ; * photometric and astrometric calibration ; * co - addition of individual frames .
the theli ( transforming heavenly light into image ) pipeline was initially developed for wfi cameras ( it consists of 8 ccd chips of 2k@xmath34k each ) mounted on the eso 2.2 meter max planck telescope .
it has a modular design allowing it to be adapted to other single- or multi - chip cameras with considerable ease .
the primary goal of developing the theli pipeline was to reduce weak lensing data ; therefore , more emphasis was laid on the accurate alignment of galaxies for each exposure ( precise astrometry , rather than photometry ) , acquiring the highest possible resolution and accurate noise mapping .
through the course of the data reduction process the theli pipeline uses well - tested astronomical software .
this allows for easy exchange whenever a new algorithm or a better implementation becomes available .
the preliminary tools in the theli pipeline are the ldac software @xcite , the terapix software @xcite , eclipse and qfits tools and imcat utilities .
next , the processing a set of optical images in the eso bands b , r , and i is described .
our initial data set consisted of @xmath4 gigabytes of raw exposures : science frames of 7 different galaxy groups and calibration frames taken in 3 successive nights with wfi at eso 2.2 m .
prior to the reduction procedure all objects are treated in the same manner , i.e. we suppose the same calibration frames for all of the science frames .
algorithms in the pipeline which remove instrument effects ( such as bad ccd pixels and fringe patterns ) and which can be considered constant during the period of our observation ( 3 nights ) , are described further .
firstly , each file s header is updated with the necessary keywords for the pipeline .
the image is then divided into the number of chips in the ccd ( which constitutes 8 ccd chips in a wfi mosaic ) . from this step on
, the pipeline works on individual chips rather than whole images , thereby enhancing the speed and enabling us to do multi - chip processing on multi cpus . in the first step , following a preliminary inspection of all exposures of a given type ( bias , flat field ) , the pipeline identifies a typical count level and rejects outliers , e.g. darks with too - short exposure time or over - saturated skyflats .
the acceptable range is defined by the user . since eso wfi
is constantly cooled to a stable temperature of 167k @xcite and dark current is negligible , many observers do not take dark frames .
we will describe their usage when appropriate , however it should be noted that we have not had or processed dark frames .
each frame is overscan - corrected ( oc ) and trimmed : overscan region is trimmed off the image .
master bias and master dark frames are created by ( median or arithmetic ) averaging of individual bias and dark frames . the pipeline uses master dark to identify bad pixels . in general ,
the sensitivity and the illumination of a ccd is not homogeneous .
sensitivity can change from pixel to pixel , while the shift in illumination is considerable only at larger scales of distance . to make surface brightness homogeneous , we utilise a flat - field pattern . due to the dependence of the flux of radiation of astronomical objects and the sky background on the filter used , the tasks described below need to be carried out separately for each filter .
an 8@xmath38 binned mosaic of corrected science frames is created to check the run process . at this stage
, we looked at binned mosaics to check if pre - reduction was performed correctly .
using ds9 software , we manually omitted out - of - focus data , and masked extended defects like satellite tracks and bright star reflections .
the pipeline creates a weight frame for each science frame .
hot / cold pixels are detected by studying the master dark , saturated pixels are identified by thresholding the science frames ; cosmic rays are discovered by sextractor @xcite in connection with eye @xcite , and manual masks are added using the ldac utilities .
global weight and flag frames are made for each ccd chip .
flag frames are integer fits in which 0 denotes good pixels and every other value denotes a certain defect .
the values are used when producing weights .
global weights contain information about bad pixels of all images from that chip .
we group science frames into sets , depending on the objects they contain .
our pointings are : hcg48 , hcg62 , hcg67 , ngc3557 , ngc3923 , ngc4697 and rx - j2114.3 - 6800 .
we run the reduction process on each pointing and subsequently add the reduced individual frames .
the initial step in astrometery is to detect high s / n objects using sextractor and to generate a catalogue of non - saturated stars . by comparing this catalogue to the usno - b1 catalogue , a zero - order
, single shift astrometric solution is calculated for each image .
the ccds in multi - chip cameras can be rotated unintentionally with respect to each other .
in addition , due to a large field of view , the sky must be considered to be a spherically curved surface .
the next step is to estimate third - order polynomials for the astrometric solution for each chip , using the scamp package @xcite developed by terapix .
exposures are taken under varying conditions : parameters such as airmass and background radiation differ from one night of observation to another .
therefore , during the first part of photometric calibration , images should be calibrated relatively .
this is done by the ldac relphotpm program .
relphotom takes tables of overlapping exposures as input and calculates the mean deviation of magnitudes : @xmath5 where @xmath6 and @xmath7 @xmath8
are fields , @xmath9 denotes objects present in both exposures , and @xmath10 are measurement errors of the magnitude , and finds the relative zero point magnitude by @xmath11 minimisation : @xmath12 ^ 2.\ ] ] in this case we neglect variant photometric conditions which affect each spectral type in a different way .
sky background is calculated using sextractor background check image for every large - object - subtracted frame , and is subtracted from all science images .
a re - sampled image is made using the astrometric solution polynomials calculated in astrometry step and stored in each chip s header .
offers two tools for image co - adding : swarp and eis drizzle .
our tool of choice is the former . using all input images ( which are related to a single output pixel ) in our sample
, swarp calculates the final results using the weighted mean method .
a weight image is also produced , as well as a flag image .
weight image plays a key role in source detection of the final image @xcite , for a comparison between weighted and un - weighted source detection .
as described above , we need to match object information from different channels .
generally there are two cases when it is necessary to consult two or more catalogues : 1 . when there is given a catalogue in a particular filter and it is desired to cross - match it with a reference catalogue , like a standard star magnitude catalogue .
2 . when there are multiple observations of a source in different filters . in this case , one needs to deal with multiple channels ( in our case : b , r and i ) .
since sextractor s detection is not perfect in terms of source coordinates , one has to take one catalogue as a reference catalogue and treat the others as search catalogues ; therefore , for each object in a certain channel , information from the other channels will be found and added , as to make a `` matched and merged '' catalogue .
with the final coadd images along with their weights in hand in b , r and i filters , one would produce several plots to show the qualification of data reduction . throughout this ,
two of them are very important : mag - count histogram and mag - error in mag scatter plot . as shown in fig.[fig1a ] we have plotted the mag - count histogram for ngc3923 field of galaxies ( note that stars have been separated from galaxies using sextractor s class_star parameter larger than 0.95 as a criteria .
seven outliers have been removed , since they were only round - shaped galaxies ) .
as seen , the count drops from magnitude 22.5 ; this is called completeness limit .
it shows that our data obtained with this instrument is trustworthy up to this completeness limit ( note that the count should be raised with respect to the fainter objects ) . the other plot , which is important in astronomical data reduction , is the mag - error in mag scatter plot as we showed in fig.[fig1b ] .
this plot reveals which data is trustworthy and which data is not based on our scientific goal .
it demonstrates that for objects with magnitude around 22.5 the error in magnitudes increase very fast ; therefore objects fainter than 22.5 are not suitable for this kind of investigation . as a fundamental parameter in astronomy photometric data , seeing associated with the individual pointings ( in r band ) ranged from 0.75 to 1.1 arcsec , and
the average seeing of the co - added image has been measured to be 0.89 arcsec .
the authors acknowledge ipm for providing computational facilities and also appreciate reza mansouri , habib g. khosroshahi and alireza molaeinezhad for useful discussions and guidance . 7 bertine .
2001 , in _ mining the sky : proceedings of the mpa / eso / mpe workshop held at garching , germany , july 31 august 4 , 2000 , eso astrophysics symposia _ , eds . : bandaya.j .
, zaroubis . & bartelmannm . , springer - verlag , 353 bertine .
2006 , asp conf .
series , 351 , 112 bertine .
& arnoutss .
1996 , a&as , 117 , 393 bertine .
, melliery . ,
2002 , asp conf .
series , 281 , 228 deul , e.w . , 1999 .
ldac pipeline v 1.3 documentation ( draft version ) erbent .
, schirmerm . ,
2005 , astronomische nachrichten , 326 , 432 the wide - field imager handbook , issue 2.0 , may 4th 2005 | in this paper we review theli ( erben & schrimer , 2005 ) , an image processing pipeline developed to reduce multi - pointing optical images taken by mosaic ccd cameras .
this pipeline works on raw images by removing several instrumental contaminations , implementing photometric calibration and astrometric alignment , and constructing a deep co - added mosaic image complemented by a weight map .
we demonstrate the procedure of reducing ngc3923 images from raw data to the final results .
we also demonstrate the quality of our data reduction strategy using mag - count and mag - error in mag plots . emphasis is mainly placed on photometric calibration which is of great interest to us due to our scientific case . based on the cross - association of the extracted catalogue against a reference catalogue of stellar magnitudes ,
zero - point calibration is performed . our data reduction strategy and the method employed for cross - correlating large catalogues
is also presented . + * key words : * methods : data analysis techniques : image processing @xmath0physics department , sharif university of technology , azadi ave . ,
tehran , iran + @xmath1school of astronomy , institute for research in fundamental sciences , opposite araj , artesh highway , tehran , iran + @xmath2physics and astronomy department , university of california riverside , 900 university ave . ,
riverside , ca 92521 , usa + |
the cahn - hilliard equation was proposed by cahn and hilliard in @xcite , @xcite as a simple model of the phase separation process , where at a fixed temperature the two components of a binary fluid spontaneously separate and form domains that are pure in each component .
let @xmath0 denote a self - adjoint extension of a laplace operator .
then the cahn - hilliard equation may be stated in the following form @xmath1 global existence for solutions to the cahn - hilliard equation has been established by elliott and songmu @xcite , and caffarelli and muler @xcite . in the setup of singular manifolds
however , there is still a question of asymptotics of solutions at the singular strata .
this aspect has been studied by the recent work of roidos and schrohe @xcite in the context of manifolds with isolated conical singularities , which has motivated the present discussion here . using the notion of maximal regularity ,
they establish short time existence of solutions to the cahn - hilliard equation in certain weighted mellin - sobolev spaces which then yields regularity and asymptotics of solutions near the conical point . in this paper
we study the cahn - hilliard equation in the geometric setup of spaces with incomplete edges , which generalizes the notion of isolated conical singularities .
our method is different from @xcite and uses the microlocal construction of the heat kernel for the bi - laplacian .
precise analysis of the asymptotic behaviour of the heat kernel allows for a derivation of the mapping properties of the heat operator and a subsequent argument on the short time existence for certain semi - linear equations of fourth order , in analogy to @xcite and @xcite .
existence and asymptotics for solutions to the cahn - hilliard equation comes as an application of the general results .
the microlocal analysis of the biharmonic heat kernel on edge spaces also allows for derivation of schauder estimates and ultimately leads to short time existence results for fourth order pde s , including the bock flow @xcite on singular spaces
. this will be the subject of forthcoming analysis .
we also point out that our approach is not limited to squares of laplacians on functions , but yields similar results for general powers of hodge laplacians on differential forms along the same lines .
our main result may be summarized briefly as follows .
let @xmath2 be a riemannian manifold with an admissible riemannian incomplete edge metric @xmath3 .
then the biharmonic heat kernel @xmath4 for the friedrichs self - adjoint extension of the laplace - beltrami operator @xmath5 lifts to a polyhomogeneous distribution on a blowup of @xmath6 and defines a biharmonic heat operator with various mapping properties , such that certain semi - linear fourth order equations , among then the cahn - hilliard equation , admit a short time solution of a certain regularity .
this paper is organized as follows .
we first introduce the basic geometry of incomplete edge spaces in [ edge - section ] .
we then provide a microlocal construction of the heat kernel for a certain self - adjoint extension of the bi - laplacian in [ heat - section ] .
we proceed with with establishing mapping properties of the biharmonic heat operator in [ mapping - section ] .
we conclude with a short time existence result for certain semi - linear equations of fourth order and apply the analysis to the particular example of the cahn - hilliard equation in [ short - section ] .
the author would like to thank elmar schrohe , rafe mazzeo and eric bahuaud for insightful discussions and gratefull acknowledges the support by the hausdorff research institute at the university of bonn .
we introduce the fundamental geometric aspects of spaces with incomplete edge singularities , described in detail in @xcite , compare also @xcite .
let @xmath7 be a compact stratified space with a single top - dimensional stratum @xmath8 and a single lower dimensional stratum @xmath9 by the definition of stratified spaces , @xmath9 is a smooth closed manifold .
moreover there is an open neighbourhood @xmath10 of @xmath9 and a radial function @xmath11 , such that @xmath12 is a smooth fibre bundle over @xmath9 with fibre @xmath13 , a finite open cone over a compact smooth manifold @xmath14 .
the restriction of @xmath15 to each fibre is the radial function of that cone .
the singular stratum @xmath9 in @xmath7 may be _ resolved _ and defines a compact manifold @xmath16 with boundary @xmath17 , where @xmath17 is the total space of a fibration @xmath18 with the fibre @xmath14 .
the resolution process is described in detail for instance in @xcite .
the neighborhood @xmath19 lifts to a collar neighborhood @xmath20 of the boundary , which is a smooth fibration of cylinders @xmath21 over @xmath9 with the radial function @xmath15 .
[ d - edge ] a riemannian manifold @xmath22 has an incomplete edge singularity at @xmath9 if over @xmath20 the metric @xmath3 equals @xmath23 , where @xmath24 as @xmath25 and @xmath26 with @xmath27 being a riemannian metric on the closed manifold @xmath9 , and @xmath28 a symmetric 2-tensor on the fibration @xmath17 which restricts to a riemannian metric on each fibre @xmath14 .
we set @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
clearly , @xmath31 .
we assume henceforth @xmath32 .
otherwise the incomplete edge manifold reduces to a compact manifold with boundary , where our discussion below is no longer applicable . similarly to other discussions in the singular edge setup , see @xcite , @xcite,@xcite and @xcite , we additionally require @xmath33 to be a riemannian submersion . if @xmath34 , then the tangent bundle @xmath35 splits into vertical and horizontal subspaces as @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the tangent space to the fibre of @xmath38 through @xmath39 and @xmath40 is the orthogonal complement of this subspace .
@xmath38 is said to be a riemannian submersion if the restriction of the tensor @xmath28 to @xmath40 vanishes .
we say that an incomplete edge metric @xmath3 is _ feasible _ if @xmath38 is a riemannian submersion and in addition the laplacians associated to @xmath28 at each @xmath41 are isospectral .
the reasons behind the feasibility assumptions are as follows .
let @xmath42 be the local coordinates on @xmath9 lifted to @xmath17 and then extended inwards .
let @xmath43 restrict to local coordinates on @xmath14 along each fibre .
then @xmath44 are the local coordinates on @xmath45 near the boundary .
consider the laplace beltrami operator @xmath0 associated to @xmath2 and its normal operator @xmath46 , defined as the limiting operator with respect to the local family of dilatations @xmath47 and acting on functions on the model edge @xmath48 with incomplete edge metric @xmath49 . under the first admissibility assumption , @xmath46 is naturally identified with @xmath50 times the laplacian for that model metric .
the second condition on isospectrality is imposed to ensure polyhomogeneity of the associated heat kernels when lifted to the corresponding parabolic blowup space .
more precisely we only need that the eigenvalues of the laplacians on fibres are constant in a fixed range @xmath51 $ ] , though we still make the stronger assumption for a clear and convenient representation .
[ def - feasible ] let @xmath2 be a riemannian manifold with a feasible edge metric .
this metric @xmath23 is said to be admissible if in addition to feasibility 1 .
the lowest non - zero eigenvalue @xmath52 of the laplace - beltrami operator @xmath53 associated to @xmath54 for any @xmath41 , satisfies @xmath55 .
@xmath56 vanishes to second order at @xmath57 , i.e. @xmath58 as @xmath59 .
the reasons behind the admissibility assumptions are of technical rather than geometric nature and somewhat less straightforward to explain
. however we point out that condition ( i ) is satisfied by a rescaling of @xmath28 which geometrically corresponds to decreasing the cone angle uniformly along the edge .
condition ( ii ) in particular holds for _ even _ metrics which depend on @xmath60 instead of @xmath15 .
the admissibility assumptions yield particular information on the heat kernel expansion , which is then used in proposition [ heat ] .
an important ingredient in the analysis of singular edge spaces is the vector space @xmath61 of _ edge _ vector fields smooth in the interior of @xmath16 and tangent at the boundary @xmath17 to the fibres of the fibration .
this space @xmath61 is closed under the ordinary lie bracket of vector fields , hence defines a lie algebra .
its description in local coordinates is as follows .
consider the local coordinates @xmath44 on @xmath7 near the boundary .
then the edge vector fields @xmath61 are locally generated by @xmath62 we may now define the banach space of continuous sections @xmath63 , continuous on @xmath16 up to the boundary and fibrewise constant at @xmath57 .
this is precisely the space of continuous sections with respect to the topology on @xmath45 induced by the riemannian metric @xmath3 .
banach spaces of higher order are defined as follows , compare @xcite .
[ defn : norms ] let @xmath2 be a riemannian manifold with an incomplete edge metric .
let @xmath64 denote a collection of @xmath0 and a choice of derivatives in @xmath65 , which will be specified later .
then for each @xmath66 we define a banach space @xmath67
let @xmath0 denote the laplace beltrami operator acting on functions on an incomplete edge space @xmath2 with a feasible incomplete edge metric @xmath3 . as a first step we fix a self - adjoint extension of the bi - laplacian @xmath68 .
consider the space of square - integrable forms @xmath69 , with respect to @xmath3 .
maximal _ and _ minimal _ closed extensions of @xmath0 are defined by the domains @xmath70 where @xmath71 is a priori understood in the distributional sense . under the unitary rescaling transformation in the singular edge neighborhood @xmath72 the laplacian @xmath0 takes the form @xmath73 [ max ] let @xmath2 be an incomplete edge space with a feasible edge metric . consider the increasing sequence of eigenvalues @xmath74 of @xmath75 , counted with their multiplicities , such that @xmath76 .
the associated indicial roots are given by @xmath77 .
then any @xmath78 expands under the rescaling as @xmath59 @xmath79 \psi_j^+(x , z;y ) + c^-_j[u ] \psi_j^-(x , z;y ) \right ) + \phi \tilde{u } , \
\tilde{u } \in \mathcal{d}_{\min}(\delta),\ ] ] where the leading order term of each @xmath80 is the corresponding solution of the indicial operator .
more precisely , let @xmath81 denote the normalized @xmath82-eigenfunctions of of @xmath75 .
then @xmath83 with @xmath84 uniquely determined by @xmath0 .
the coefficients @xmath85 $ ] are of negative regularity in @xmath86 and the asymptotic expansion holds only in a weak sense , i.e. there is an expansion of the pairing @xmath87 for any test function @xmath88 . the friedrichs self - adjoint extension of @xmath0 has been identified in @xcite as @xmath89=0\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the sequence of eigenvalues @xmath74 of @xmath75 starts with @xmath90 for @xmath91 .
the corresponding indicial roots compute to @xmath92 and the coefficient are constant in @xmath93 .
consequently , in view of the explicit form of the rescaling transformation in , the friedrichs domain contains precisely those elements in the maximal domain whose leading term in the weak expansion as @xmath59 is given by @xmath94 with fibrewise constant coefficients .
in particular @xmath95 we fix a self - adjoint extension of the bi - laplacian as the square of @xmath96 @xmath97 in the second step we construct the heat kernel for @xmath98 .
we begin with studying the homogeneity properties of the heat kernel for the bi - laplacian in the model case of an exact edge @xmath99 where @xmath100 is an exact unbounded cone over a closed riemannian manifold @xmath101 .
the laplacian @xmath102 on the exact edge is then a sum of the laplacian on @xmath103 and the euclidean laplacian on @xmath104 .
consider the scaling operation ( @xmath105 ) @xmath106 under the scaling operation we find @xmath107 consequently , given the heat kernel @xmath108 for the friedrichs extension of @xmath109 ( or at that stage any other self - adjoint extension ) , any multiple of @xmath110 still solves the heat equation and also maps into the domain of @xmath109 . for the initial condition we obtain substituting @xmath111 @xmath112 by uniqueness of the heat kernel we obtain @xmath113 in addition to the homogeneity properties of @xmath108 , we also require a full asymptotic expansion of the biharmonic heat kernel as @xmath114 .
we accomplish this by establishing an explicit integral representation of @xmath108 . under the unitary rescaling and a spectral decomposition of @xmath115 into @xmath116-eigenspaces of @xmath117 , we may write for the rescaled model edge laplacian @xmath118 where @xmath119 and @xmath120 is defined on @xmath121 . the friedrichs extension of @xmath122
is compatible with the decomposition , compare a similar discussion in ( @xcite , proposition 4.9 ) .
as a special case of lemma [ max ] , @xmath123 has unique self - adjoint extension @xmath124 in @xmath125 for @xmath126 , and in case of @xmath127 , solutions @xmath128 admit a partial asymptotic expansion as @xmath129 @xmath130 \ , s^{\nu+1/2 } + c^-[u ] \left\ { \begin{split } & s^{-\nu+1/2 } , \ \nu \in ( 0,1 ) , \\ & \sqrt{s}\log(s ) , \
\nu = 0 , \end{split}\right .
\qquad \widetilde{u } \in \dom ( l_{\nu , \min}).\ ] ] then the friedrichs extension @xmath124 of @xmath123 is defined , similar to , by requiring @xmath131=0 $ ] , and moreover , identifying @xmath132 with its unique self - adjoint extension in @xmath133 , we may write @xmath134 consequently , it suffices to construct the biharmonic heat kernel for @xmath135 in @xmath136 .
denote by @xmath137 the @xmath138-th bessel function of first kind and consider the hankel transform of order @xmath139 @xmath140 by ( @xcite , chapter iii ) and also by ( @xcite , proposition 2.3.4 ) , the hankel transform extends to a self - adjoint isometry on @xmath125 .
we denote by @xmath141 the fourier transform on @xmath104 , which extends to an isometric automorphism of @xmath133 .
consequently , @xmath142 defines an isometric automorphism of @xmath136 such that @xmath143 .
applying ( @xcite , proposition 2.3.5 ) , we arrive at the following [ diag ] the isometric automorphism @xmath144 diagonalizes @xmath145 .
more precisely , @xmath146 where @xmath147 denote multiplication operators by @xmath148 and @xmath149 , respectively .
similary , the isometry @xmath144 diagonalizes the squared operator @xmath150 , identifying its action with @xmath151 .
consequently we may express the biharmonic heat kernel of @xmath150 as an integral in terms of bessel functions .
for @xmath152 we find @xmath153 denote by @xmath154 the normalized @xmath116-eigenfunction of @xmath117 , where we count the eigenvalues @xmath155 with their multiplicities .
then , as a consequence of , we finally obtain for the @xmath156-rescaled biharmonic heat kernel on a model edge @xmath157 the @xmath138-th bessel function of first kind admits an asymptotic expansion for small arguments @xmath158 , as @xmath159 .
this yields an asymptotic expansion of @xmath160 as @xmath114 and consequently , rescaling back , we obtain as @xmath129 @xmath161 where the summation is over all @xmath162 with @xmath163 , counted with multiplicity , and each coefficient @xmath164 lies in the corresponding @xmath116-eigenspace .
we summarize the properties of @xmath108 , established above , in a single proposition for later reference .
[ model - heat ] consider the model edge @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is an exact unbounded cone over a closed riemannian manifold @xmath165 .
fix the friedrichs self - adjoint extension of the associated laplace beltrami operator @xmath122 .
then the biharmonic heat kernel @xmath108 of @xmath109 is homogeneous of order @xmath166 under the scaling operation ( @xmath105 ) @xmath106 moreover , @xmath108 admits an asymptotic expansion as @xmath167 with the index set given by @xmath168 , where @xmath169 uniformly in other variables and with coefficients taking value in the corresponding @xmath116-eigenspace .
we can now proceed from the analysis of the heat kernel on the model edge to the construction of the heat kernel @xmath4 for the bi - laplacian on a space @xmath2 with an incomplete feasible edge metric .
the heat kernel construction here follows ad verbatim the discussion in @xcite for the edge laplacian , with the only difference that for the bi - laplacian now rather @xmath170 instead of @xmath171 is treated as a smooth variable .
the heat kernel is a function on @xmath172 .
let @xmath44 and @xmath173 be the coordinates on the two copies of @xmath45 near the edge
. then the local coordinates near the corner in @xmath174 are given by @xmath175 .
the kernel @xmath176 has a non - uniform behaviour at the submanifolds @xmath177 exactly as in the case of the hodge laplacian on edges , see @xcite , we introduce an appropriate blowup of the heat space @xmath174 , such that the corresponding heat kernel lifts to a polyhomogeneous distribution in the sense of the definition below .
this procedure has been introduced by melrose in @xcite . for self - containment of the paper we repeat the definition of polyhomogeneity as well as the blowup process here . [ phg ] let @xmath178 be a manifold with corners , with all boundary faces embedded , and @xmath179 an enumeration of its boundaries and the corresponding defining functions .
for any multi - index @xmath180 we write @xmath181 .
denote by @xmath182 the space of smooth vector fields on @xmath178 which lie tangent to all boundary faces .
a distribution @xmath183 on @xmath178 is said to be conormal , if @xmath184 for some @xmath185 and @xmath186 for all @xmath187 and for every @xmath188 .
an index set @xmath189 satisfies the following hypotheses : 1 .
@xmath190 accumulates only at plus infinity , 2 . for each @xmath191
there is @xmath192 , such that @xmath193 if and only if @xmath194 , 3 . if @xmath195 , then @xmath196 for all @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
an index family @xmath199 is an @xmath200-tuple of index sets .
finally , we say that a conormal distribution @xmath183 is polyhomogeneous on @xmath178 with index family @xmath201 , we write @xmath202 , if @xmath183 is conormal and if in addition , near each @xmath203 , @xmath204 with coefficients @xmath205 conormal on @xmath203 , polyhomogeneous with index @xmath206 at any @xmath207 . the homogeneity property contains the information how precisely the submanifolds @xmath208 need to be blown up such that the heat kernel becomes polyhomogeneous . to get the correct blowup of @xmath174 we first bi - parabolically ( @xmath170 is viewed as a coordinate function ) blow up the submanifold @xmath209 the resulting heat - space @xmath210 $ ] is defined as the union of @xmath211 with the interior spherical normal bundle of @xmath212 in @xmath174 .
the blowup @xmath210 $ ] is endowed with the unique minimal differential structure with respect to which smooth functions in the interior of @xmath174 and polar coordinates on @xmath174 around @xmath212 are smooth .
as in @xcite , this blowup introduces four new boundary hypersurfaces ; we denote these by ff ( the front face ) , rf ( the right face ) , lf ( the left face ) and tf ( the temporal face ) .
the actual heat - space blowup @xmath213 is obtained by a bi - parabolic blowup of @xmath210 $ ] along the diagonal @xmath214 , lifted to a submanifold of @xmath210 $ ] .
the resulting blowup @xmath213 is defined as before by cutting out the submanifold and replacing it with its spherical normal bundle .
it is a manifold with boundaries and corners , visualized in figure below .
( 0,0.7 )
( 0,2 ) ; ( -0.7,-0.5 ) ( -2,-1 ) ; ( 0.7,-0.5 )
( 2,-1 ) ; ( 0,0.7 ) .. controls ( -0.5,0.6 ) and ( -0.7,0 ) .. ( -0.7,-0.5 ) ; ( 0,0.7 ) .. controls ( 0.5,0.6 ) and ( 0.7,0 ) .. ( 0.7,-0.5 ) ; ( -0.7,-0.5 ) .. controls ( -0.5,-0.6 ) and ( -0.4,-0.7 ) .. ( -0.3,-0.7 ) ; ( 0.7,-0.5 ) .. controls ( 0.5,-0.6 ) and ( 0.4,-0.7 ) .. ( 0.3,-0.7 ) ; ( -0.3,-0.7 ) .. controls ( -0.3,-0.3 ) and ( 0.3,-0.3 ) .. ( 0.3,-0.7 ) ; ( -0.3,-1.4 ) .. controls ( -0.3,-1 ) and ( 0.3,-1 ) .. ( 0.3,-1.4 ) ; ( 0.3,-0.7 ) ( 0.3,-1.4 ) ; ( -0.3,-0.7 ) ( -0.3,-1.4 ) ; at ( 1.2,0.7 ) ; at ( -1.2,0.7 ) ; at ( 1.1 , -1.2 ) ; at ( -1.1 , -1.2 ) ; at ( 0 , -1.7 ) ; at ( 0,0.1 ) ; at ( -3,-1 ) @xmath213 ; ( 5,0 ) ( 5,2 ) ; at ( 5.6,1.7 ) @xmath170 ; ( 5,0 )
( 3,-1 ) ; at ( 3.2,-0.5 ) @xmath15 ; ( 5,0 ) ( 7,-1 ) ; at ( 6.8,-0.5 ) @xmath215 ; at ( 5,-1 ) @xmath174 ; at ( 2.5,0.7 ) @xmath216 ; at ( 2.5,1 ) @xmath217 ; [ figure - incomplete ] the projective coordinates on @xmath213 are then given as follows .
near the top corner of the front face ff , the projective coordinates are given by @xmath218 where in these coordinates @xmath219 are the defining functions of the boundary faces ff , rf and lf respectively . for the bottom corner of the front face near the right hand side
projective coordinates are given by @xmath220 where in these coordinates @xmath221 are the defining functions of tf , rf and ff respectively .
for the bottom corner of the front face near the left hand side projective coordinates are obtained by interchanging the roles of @xmath15 and @xmath222 .
projective coordinates on @xmath213 near temporal diagonal are given by @xmath223 in these coordinates tf is the face in the limit @xmath224 , ff and td are defined by @xmath225 , respectively .
the blowdown map @xmath226 is in local coordinates simply the coordinate change back to @xmath227 . in case
the edge manifold is an exact edge @xmath99 where @xmath228 , proposition [ model - heat ] implies that @xmath108 lifts to a polyhomogeneous conormal distribution on the heat space blowup , of order @xmath229 at the front and the temporal diagonal faces , vanishing to infinite order at @xmath230 , and with the index set at @xmath231 and @xmath232 given by @xmath168 , where @xmath233 in the general case of a feasible edge space @xmath2 , @xmath108 is only an initial parametrix and solves the heat equation only to first order .
repeating almost ad verbatim the heat kernel construction in case of the edge laplacian in @xcite , we arrive at the following [ heat ] let @xmath234 be an incomplete edge space with a feasible edge metric @xmath3 .
then the lift @xmath235 is polyhomogeneous on @xmath213 of order @xmath236 at @xmath237 and @xmath238 , vanishing ot infinite order at @xmath230 , and with the index set at @xmath231 and @xmath232 given by @xmath239 where @xmath240 more precisely , if @xmath241 denotes the boundary defining function of @xmath231 , we obtain @xmath242 where the coefficients @xmath243 are of order @xmath244 at the front face and lie in their corresponding @xmath75 eigenspaces .
the higher coefficients @xmath245 are of order @xmath246 at ff .
recall the heat kernel construction in @xcite , which we basically follow here .
denote by @xmath0 the laplace beltrami operator on @xmath2 .
we write @xmath247 for the heat operator .
the restriction of the lift @xmath248 to @xmath237 is called the normal operator @xmath249 at the front face ( at the fibre over @xmath250 ) and is given in projective coordinates explicitly as follows @xmath251 @xmath252 does not involve derivatives with respect to @xmath253 and hence acts tangentially to the fibres of the front face .
consequently in our choice of an initial parametrix @xmath254 we note that the equation @xmath255 is the heat equation for the bi - laplace operator on the model edge @xmath256 .
consequently , the initial parametrix @xmath254 is defined by choosing @xmath257 to equal the fundamental solution for the heat operator @xmath258 , and extending @xmath257 trivially to a neighbourhood of the front face .
more precisely , consider the biharmonic heat kernel @xmath259 on the model edge @xmath260 with the parameter @xmath250 . then in projective coordinates @xmath261 near the right corner of @xmath237 , where @xmath215 is the defining function of the front face , we set @xmath262 where @xmath38 is a smooth cutoff function , @xmath263 in an open neighborhood of @xmath264 , and with compact support in @xmath265 . by proposition
[ model - heat ] , our initial parametrix @xmath254 is polyhomogeneous on @xmath174 and solves the heat equation to first order at the front face ff of @xmath213 .
moreover proposition [ model - heat ] asserts @xmath266 with each coefficient @xmath267 lying in the corresponding @xmath268 eigenspace .
the error of the initial parametrix @xmath254 is given by @xmath269 the leading order term in the expansion of @xmath248 at @xmath238 does not depend on the edge geometry and corresponds to the bi - laplacian on a closed manifold .
consequently , classical arguments allow to refine the initial parametrix such that the error term @xmath270 is vanishing to infinite order at @xmath238 , compare the corresponding discussion in ( @xcite , section 3.2 ) .
we need to understand the explicit structure of the asymptotic expansion of @xmath270 at @xmath237 and @xmath231 . by definition
[ def - feasible ] ( ii ) we find @xmath271 where @xmath272 is comprised of the derivatives @xmath273 and @xmath274 consists of edge derivatives @xmath275 .
consequently , we obtain after taking squares @xmath276 we now apply each of the summands above to the asymptotic expansion of @xmath254 . note that @xmath277 annihilates each @xmath278 , and lowers the @xmath241-order of @xmath279 by @xmath280 , if @xmath281 .
consequently , we obtain as @xmath129 @xmath282 the next step in the construction of the heat kernel involves adding a kernel @xmath283 to @xmath254 , such that the new error term is vanishing to infinite order at rf . in order to eliminate the term @xmath284 in the asymptotic expansion of @xmath270 at rf
, we only need to solve @xmath285 this is because all other terms in the expansion of @xmath286 at rf lower the exponent in @xmath241 by at most one , while the indicial part lowers the exponent by two .
the variables @xmath287 enter the equation only as parameters .
the equation is solved by mellin transform as well as spectral decomposition over @xmath14 .
the solution is polyhomogeneous in all variables , including parameters and is of leading order @xmath288 .
consequently , the correcting kernel @xmath283 must be of leading order @xmath280 at rf and of leading order @xmath246 at ff , since @xmath270 is of order @xmath289 at rf and @xmath246 at ff and the defining function @xmath215 of the front face enters only as a parameter .
hence @xmath290 where the coefficients @xmath291 each lie in the corresponding @xmath268 eigenspace . in
the following correction steps the exact heat kernel is obtained from @xmath292 by an iterative correction procedure , adding terms of the form @xmath293 , where @xmath294 is vanishing to infinite order at rf and td .
this leads to an expansion @xmath295 where the coefficients @xmath243 still lie in their corresponding @xmath268 eigenspaces , and are of order @xmath244 at the front face .
the higher coefficients @xmath245 are of order @xmath246 at ff .
note that in the construction above , we have only used feasibility of the edge metric and definition [ def - feasible ] ( ii ) .
the assumption of definition [ def - feasible ] ( i ) for admissible edge metrics is not required there , but plays an essential role in the argument that @xmath4 indeed takes values in @xmath296 . first note that @xmath4 indeed takes values in @xmath297 , since the expansion satisfies the characterization of maximal solutions in lemma [ max ] and also the condition in under the rescaling @xmath156 .
the conclusion that @xmath298 also takes values in @xmath297 is more intricate .
it is easily checked from that @xmath299 indeed takes values in @xmath297 without any further assumptions .
application of @xmath300 to @xmath4 preserves the expansion , however the coefficients in the expansion need not lie in the correct @xmath268 eigenspaces , and hence we can not deduce that @xmath301 maps into @xmath297 in general . by condition ( i ) of definition [ def - feasible ] , any @xmath302 is automatically @xmath303 , and hence it then suffices to check whether the @xmath304 coefficient in the expansion of @xmath301 lies in the zero - eigenspace of @xmath117 , in other words is harmonic on fibres and hence constant in @xmath305 .
the leading term @xmath306 in the expansion of @xmath235 is annihilated by @xmath307 and is increased by @xmath308 .
consequently , @xmath301 admits no @xmath304 term and hence trivially maps into @xmath297 . the kernels @xmath4 and @xmath298 thus both map into @xmath297 and hence by definition , @xmath4 indeed maps into @xmath309 and thus is the biharmonic heat kernel associated to @xmath98 .
in this section we prove boundedness and strong continuity of the biharmonic heat operator with respect to banach spaces introduced in definition [ defn : norms ] .
[ bounded ] let @xmath234 be an incomplete edge space with a feasible edge metric @xmath3 .
fix the friedrichs extension @xmath96 of the corresponding laplace beltrami operator . put @xmath310 and @xmath311 , where @xmath312 consists locally of all edge vector fields where @xmath313 is weighted with functions that are fibrewise constant .
then the associated biharmonic heat operator @xmath314 is a bounded map between the ( weighted ) banach spaces @xmath315 first we prove the statement for @xmath316 .
the explicit structure of the heat kernel expansion in proposition [ heat ] implies that for any @xmath317 applied to the biharmonic heat kernel @xmath4 , the lift @xmath318 admits the following behaviour near the front face of the heat space @xmath213 @xmath319 where @xmath320 denotes a defining function of a boundary face @xmath321 .
consider the lift of the volume form in the various projective coordinates near @xmath237 .
we explify the transformation rules for the volume form near the lower left , lower right and the top corner of the front face @xmath322 the projective coordinates and the transformation rule for the volume form where the front and the temporal diagonal faces meet , is as follows @xmath323 when we combine the asymptotics of @xmath324 in with the behaviour of the volume form in the various projective coordinates and , we find that @xmath325 has a singular behaviour of @xmath326 .
consequently , we may estimate for @xmath317 and any continuous function , in particular for any @xmath327 @xmath328 for some constant @xmath329 independent of @xmath330 .
furthermore , by proposition [ heat ] , @xmath331 , as @xmath332 for @xmath333 , where @xmath334 is fibrewise constant , i.e. independent of @xmath93 . here
the fact that for @xmath335 its @xmath336 component is weighted with a fibrewise constant function , is essential .
hence , indeed @xmath337 .
this proves the statement for @xmath316 .
the general statement follows from the fact that due to , @xmath338 and for any @xmath339 , @xmath340 , by uniqueness of solutions to the biharmonic heat equation with fixed initial condition .
finally note that while @xmath341 is continuous even for @xmath342 , it need not remain fibrewise constant at @xmath57 since in general @xmath343 may include vector fields weighted with @xmath305-dependent functions . hence @xmath344 is replaced by @xmath345 in @xmath64 , where @xmath346 consists locally of linear combinations of @xmath347 , weighted with functions that are fibrewise constant .
a particular property of @xmath348 with @xmath349 is worth noticing . in the singular neighborhood of the edge ,
the distance defined by the riemannian edge metric @xmath3 is equivalent to @xmath350 in local coordinates near the edge we find @xmath351 consequently we obtain @xmath352 in other words , @xmath348 is automatically lipschitz with respect to @xmath353 .
our argument on existence of solutions to certain semi - linear fourth order equations in the section below crucially depends on the strong continuity property of the biharmonic heat operator with respect to the banach space @xmath354 .
this is the content of the next theorem .
note that for strong continuity we will choose a different space @xmath355 of allowable operators , smaller than in theorem [ bounded ] .
beforehand we note the following well - known function analytic result .
[ funkana ] let @xmath214 be a self - adjoint non - negative unbounded operator in a hilbert space @xmath4 .
then the following is true . 1 .
the continuously differentiable solution to @xmath356 , with @xmath357 for @xmath358 and @xmath359 is unique , for any given @xmath360 .
2 . for any @xmath361 , we have @xmath362 .
\(i ) for @xmath363 $ ] we compute @xmath364 consequently , @xmath365 is constant for @xmath363 $ ] .
since @xmath366 converges to i d in the hilbert space norm as @xmath367 and , by assumption , @xmath368 is continuous at @xmath369 , we find that @xmath365 is constant for @xmath370 $ ] . considering the limit of @xmath365 as @xmath371 and as @xmath129 proves for any @xmath360 @xmath372 ( ii ) consider @xmath373 in the resolvent set of @xmath374 .
then for any @xmath361 , the resolvent @xmath375 and we compute @xmath376 the statement now follows by closedness of @xmath214 and definition of the heat operator as the strong limit @xmath377 [ strong ] let @xmath234 be an incomplete edge space with a feasible edge metric @xmath3 . fix the friedrichs extension @xmath96 of the corresponding laplace - beltrami operator .
put @xmath378 .
then the associated biharmonic heat operator @xmath314 is a strongly continuous bounded map between banach spaces @xmath379 by , we have @xmath380 and hence for any @xmath381 we infer by the previous lemma [ funkana ] , @xmath340 .
this reduces the statement to @xmath382 and @xmath316 .
proof of both cases requires stochastic completeness of the biharmonic heat kernel , which we explain below .
solutions to the initial value problem @xmath383 are unique and in fact given by @xmath384 .
we have observed in subsection [ friedrichs - subsection ] that , reversing eventual rescaling , the friedrichs domain contains precisely those elements in the maximal domain whose leading term in the weak expansion as @xmath59 is given by @xmath94 , with a fibrewise constant coefficient , cf . .
consequently , the constant function @xmath385 . moreover , @xmath386 and consequently @xmath387 .
the constant function @xmath388 solves the heat equation and hence we deduce by uniqueness of solutions the _ stochastic completeness _
@xmath389 this reduces the case to @xmath390 .
we can now prove the statement for @xmath316 , basically repeating the arguments in ( @xcite ) where the classical proof of strong continuity of the heat operator on closed ( non - singular ) manifolds is adapted to the present setup .
using stochastic completeness we find @xmath391 consider the distance function @xmath392 induced by the incomplete edge metric @xmath3 . in the singular neighborhood of the edge ,
the distance is equivalent to @xmath350 note that @xmath393 is continuous with respect to the topology induced by the riemannian metric @xmath3 and hence by the distance function @xmath353 .
hence for any @xmath394 there exists some @xmath395 , such that for @xmath396 one has @xmath397 . for
any given @xmath394 we separate the integration region into @xmath398 employing continuity of @xmath330 we find @xmath399 it may be checked in the various projective coordinates around the front face in the heat space @xmath213 , that @xmath400 and @xmath401 is bounded . since @xmath402 is vanishing to infinite order at @xmath230 , we find that both integrals above are bounded uniformly in @xmath403 .
therefore we obtain @xmath404 thus , for any given @xmath394 we can estimate @xmath405 for @xmath406 .
this proves strong continuity of the biharmonic heat operator on @xmath407 .
it remains to prove the case @xmath382 .
strong continuity of the biharmonic heat operator with respect to @xmath408 means @xmath409 as @xmath367 , for @xmath410 and @xmath411 . if @xmath412 , this follows from the case @xmath316 , since @xmath413 for @xmath414 . for @xmath415 the leading order of @xmath235 at the front face
is preserved under @xmath343 , so that away from @xmath238 , the estimates reduce to the case @xmath316 .
near @xmath238 , a priori @xmath343 leads to @xmath416 singular behaviour .
however , integration by parts , exactly as worked out in detail in @xcite allows to pass @xmath343 to @xmath330 , so that the estimates again reduce to the case @xmath316 .
we write down the argument for completeness .
the edge vector fields obey the following transformation rules in projective coordinates near the temporal diagonal @xmath417 by proposition [ heat ] @xmath418 where @xmath419 is bounded in its entries , and in fact infinitely vanishing as @xmath224 , and @xmath420 is a bounded distribution on @xmath213 .
we consider @xmath421 .
using stochastic completeness of the heat kernel , we find @xmath422 = : f_1-f_2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] next we transform to projective coordinates and integrate by parts in @xmath423 , where the boundary terms lie away from the diagonal and hence are vanishing to infinite order for @xmath367 by the asymptotic behaviour of the heat kernel . omitting these irrelevant terms , we obtain @xmath424 \\ & \times u\left(x(1-\eta s ) , y - x\eta u , z-\eta z\right ) h ( x\eta)^m ( 1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz \\ & = \int \left[(-\eta \partial_{\eta } + z \partial_z + x\partial_x ) ( x\eta)^{-m } g\right ] \cdot u \ , h(x\eta)^m ( 1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz \\ & - \int g \left[\left(\frac{1}{\eta}\partial_s\right ) u \right ] h(1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz\\ & - \int ( x\eta)^{-m } g \cdot u \left[\left(\frac{1}{\eta}\partial_s \right ) h(x\eta)^m(1-\eta s)^f\right ] ds\ , du\ , dz.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we perform similar computations for @xmath425 : @xmath426\wx^f d\wx \dvb(\wx)\\ & = \int \left(\left[-\eta \partial_{\eta } + \frac{1}{\eta}\partial_s+z\partial_z + x\partial_x\right ] ( x\eta)^{-m}g\right ) u\cdot h(x\eta)^m ( 1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz \\ & + \int g(\eta , s , u , z , x , y , z ) ( x\partial_xu(x , y , z ) ) h ( 1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz \\ & = \int \left[(-\eta \partial_{\eta } + z \partial_z + x\partial_x ) ( x\eta)^{-m}g\right ] \cdot u\ , h(x\eta)^m ( 1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz\\ & - \int ( x\eta)^{-m}g \cdot u \left[\left(\frac{1}{\eta}\partial_s \right ) h(x\eta)^m(1-\eta s)^f\right ] ds\ , du\ , dz\\ & + \int g(\eta , s , u , z , x , y , z ) ( x\partial_xu(x , y , z ) ) h ( 1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath427 becomes @xmath428 h(x\eta)^m ( 1-\eta s)^f \\ & \times ( u(x(1-\eta s ) , y - x\eta u , z-\eta z)-u(x , y , z ) ) ds\ , du\ , dz \\
& - \int g(\eta , s , u , z , x , y , z ) \left[\left(\frac{1}{\eta}\partial_s\right ) h \cdot ( 1-\eta s)^f\right ] \\ & \times ( u(x(1-\eta s ) , y - x\eta u , z-\eta z)-u(x , y , z ) ) ds\ , du\ , dz \\ & - \int
g \left[\frac{1}{\eta}\partial_s u(x(1-\eta s ) , y - x\eta u , z-\eta z ) + x\partial_x u(x , y , z ) \right ] h(1-\eta s)^f ds\ , du\ , dz.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , each of the three integrals is estimated as above for @xmath316 by separating the integration region into @xmath429 and @xmath430 for any given @xmath394 .
note that in the final integral we use the fact that @xmath431 so that @xmath432 and @xmath433 are bounded .
higher order and other edge derivatives may be estimated in a similar way .
this proves strong continuity in general and as a trivial consequence boundedness of the biharmonic heat operator .
we point out that theorem [ bounded ] holds also when the basic space @xmath434 is replaced by the banach space of sections continuous up to @xmath57 , without the requirement of being fibrewise constant at @xmath17 .
also , we may set @xmath435 .
the use of the refined space @xmath434 and the restriction of @xmath436 to @xmath437 in @xmath64 becomes however crucial in theorem [ strong ] .
in this section we explain how the mapping properties of the biharmonic heat operator and its strong continuity yields short - time existence of solutions to certain semilinear equations of fourth order .
the underlying idea is based on the following theorem .
[ taylor ] ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 15.1.1 ) let @xmath438 be some , possibly unbounded , linear operator in a hilbert space @xmath4 , bounded from below .
suppose that @xmath439 are banach spaces , such that @xmath440 is bounded and moreover then for any @xmath446 , the initial value problem @xmath447 has a unique solution @xmath448 , \mathscr{c}^{2(k+1)}_{\textup{ie}}(m , \mathcal{d}))$ ] , for some @xmath449 , where @xmath450 may be estimated from below in terms of @xmath451 .
the solution @xmath330 is the fixed point of the operator @xmath452 with @xmath453 let @xmath2 be an incomplete edge space with a feasible edge metric @xmath3 .
put @xmath378 and @xmath311 , where @xmath312 consists locally of linear combinations of @xmath347 , where @xmath313 is weighted with functions that are fibrewise constant .
assume @xmath454 is locally lipschitz .
then the semilinear equation @xmath455 has a unique solution @xmath448 , \mathscr{c}^{2(k+1)}_{\textup{ie}}(m , \mathcal{d}))$ ] , for some @xmath449 , where @xmath450 may be estimated from below in terms of @xmath456 .
consider first a slightly smaller set of operators @xmath378 and set @xmath457 . in view of theorem
[ bounded ] and theorem [ strong ] , the heat operator associated to @xmath458 satisfies the conditions of theorem [ taylor ] with @xmath459 .
consequently , by theorem [ taylor ] the unique solution @xmath330 exists and lies in @xmath460 .
this solution is the fixed point of the map @xmath461 with @xmath462 however , by theorem [ bounded ] , @xmath14 actually maps @xmath463 to @xmath464 .
consequently , @xmath465 , with a slightly better regularity , as claimed .
we now apply this general existence result to the example of the cahn - hilliard equation on an incomplete edge manifold .
we define @xmath466 the mapping @xmath467 is indeed locally lipschitz , since for any @xmath468 @xmath469 we hence arrive at our final result .
let @xmath2 be an incomplete edge space with a feasible edge metric @xmath3 .
put @xmath378 and @xmath311 , where @xmath312 consists locally of linear combinations of @xmath347 , where @xmath313 is weighted with functions that are fibrewise constant .
then the cahn - hilliard equation @xmath470 has a unique solution @xmath448 , \operatorname{\mathscr{c}^{2k+2}_{\textup{ie}}(m , \mathcal{d})})$ ] , for some @xmath449 .
it should be noted that in correspondence with @xcite our approach leads to an explicit identification of the asymptotics of the cahn - hilliard solution at @xmath57 .
indeed , @xmath471 , which yields a partial asymptotics of @xmath330 to higher and higher order , depending on @xmath66 , by an iterative application of lemma [ max ] for @xmath472 steps .
m. lesch , _ operators of fuchs type , conical singularities , and asymptotic methods _ , teubner - texte zur mathematik [ teubner texts in mathematics ] , vol . 136 , b. g. teubner verlagsgesellschaft mbh , stuttgart , 1997 . | we construct the biharmonic heat kernel of a suitable closed self - adjoint extension of the bi - laplacian on a manifold with incomplete edge singularities .
we establish mapping properties of the biharmonic heat operator and derive short time existence for certain semi - linear equations of fourth order .
we apply the analysis to a class of semi - linear partial differential equations in particular the cahn - hilliard equation and obtain asymptotics of the solutions near the edge singularity . + |
in the inflationary scenario the universe initially expands quasi - exponentially in a vacuum - like state with vanishing entropy and particle number densities . at the stage of inflation ,
all energy is concentrated in a classical slowly moving inflaton field @xmath0 .
consider a simple chaotic inflation .
the fundamental lagrangian @xmath4 contains the inflaton part with the potential @xmath5 and other fields @xmath6 which give subdominant contributions to gravity . the friedmann equation for a scalar factor @xmath7 : @xmath8 ( with @xmath9 ) and the klein - gordon equation for @xmath10 : @xmath11 define the evolution of the background fields .
soon after the end of inflation , an almost homogeneous inflaton field @xmath10 coherently oscillates with a very large amplitude of the order of the planck mass @xmath12 .
this scalar field can be considered as a coherent superposition of @xmath0-quasiparticles with zero momenta , _ inflatons _ at rest .
the amplitude of oscillations gradually decreases not only because of the expansion of the universe , but also because of the energy transfer to particles created by the oscillating field . at this stage
we shall invoke the rest of the fundamental lagrangian @xmath4 which includes the other bosons and fermions and their interactions with the inflaton field , as well as the self - interaction of the inflaton field .
these interactions lead to the creation of many ultra - relativistic particles from inflatons . in this scenario
all the matter constituting the universe would be created from this process of reheating . a toy model describing the interaction between inflatons and other massless bose particles @xmath13 will be @xmath14 .
gradually , the inflaton field decays and transfers all of its energy non - adiabatically to the created particles .
if the creation of particles is sufficiently slow , the particles would simultaneously interact with each other and come to a state of thermal equilibrium at the reheating temperature @xmath15 .
this gradual reheating can be treated with the perturbative theory of particle creation and thermalization . that elementary theory of reheating was developed long ago with the first models of inflation .
consider the heisenberg representation of the quantum scalar field @xmath16 , with the eigenfunctions @xmath17 with comoving momenta @xmath18 .
the temporal part of the eigenfunction obeys the equation @xmath19 with the vacuum - like initial condition @xmath20 in the far past .
the coupling to the curvature @xmath21 will not be important .
let us seek the solutions of eq .
( [ 2 ] ) in the adiabatic wkb approximation @xmath22 where the time - dependent frequency is @xmath23 plus a small correction @xmath24 ; initially @xmath25 . for @xmath26 ,
an iterative solution + @xmath27 gives the standard result of the perturbative theory for the particle occupation number @xmath28 .
this can be interpreted as a pair of inflatons decaying independently into a pair of @xmath13-particles , @xmath29 . the largest total decay rate in the perturbative reheating is @xmath30 ; the upper bound on the perturbative reheating temperature is @xmath31 gev .
recently it was found , however , that in many versions of chaotic inflation reheating begins with a stage of parametric resonance@xmath32 . indeed , in eq .
( [ 2 ] ) inflatons act not as separate particles , but as a the coherently oscillating field @xmath10 .
the smallness of @xmath33 alone does not necessarily correspond to small @xmath34 .
the oscillating effective frequency @xmath35 can result in a broad parametric amplification of @xmath36 . in this case
the energy is rapidly transferred from the inflaton field to other bose fields interacting with it .
this process occurs far away from thermal equilibrium , and therefore we called it _ preheating_. because of the non - perturbative character of the particle creation , the theory of preheating is rather complicated .
+ reheating is an intermediate stage between inflation and the hot radiation dominated universe .
therefore , during or around reheating one can expect initial conditions for many parameters of the big bang to be settled : the initial temperature @xmath15 , baryogenesis , relic monopoles and others topological defects , primordial black holes , dark matter relics , etc .
recent developments in the theory of reheating show that the stage of preheating can significantly change the way we think about these problems . among many exciting topics in preheating ,
i have selected a particular issue for these proceedings : how diverse the character of the parametric resonance can be in different models of @xmath5 , and how it can be unified .
this information is vital for finding the leading channel of the inflaton decay .
the answers are based on a study done in collaboration with andrei linde ( stanford ) , alexei starobinsky ( moscow ) and patrick greene ( hawaii)@xmath37 . this work was supported by nsf grant no .
ast95 - 29 - 225 .
it turns out that the character of the parametric resonance for the general equation ( [ 2 ] ) depends on the character of the classical oscillations @xmath10 , i.e. , on the shape of the effective inflaton potential @xmath5 .
we begin with the quadratic potential @xmath39 .
the background solution corresponds to sinusoidal oscillations @xmath40 , with the amplitude @xmath41 decreasing as the universe expands with the scalar factor @xmath42 .
+ for a the toy model the expansion of the universe is neglected ( @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 ) , the equation for the fluctuations takes the form of a mathieu equation @xmath46 with a new time variable @xmath47 and the essential dimensionless coupling parameter @xmath48 .
the properties of the solutions of the mathieu equation are well represented by its stability / instability chart ; see fig . 1 .
= 5.6 cm + there is an exponential instability @xmath49 within the set of resonance bands .
this instability corresponds to an exponential growth in the occupation number of created particles @xmath50 . since @xmath51
, it is expected that @xmath52 , the parametric resonance is broad .
the simple standard methods for finding the characteristic exponent @xmath53 in the narrow resonance regime @xmath54 do not work here .
however , we made the following observation@xmath55 : for large @xmath56 the eigenfunction @xmath57 is changing adiabatically between the moments @xmath58 , @xmath59 , where the inflaton field is equal to zero @xmath60 .
the non - adiabatic changes of @xmath57 occur only in the vicinity of @xmath58 .
therefore , we expect that the semiclassical solution ( [ 3 ] ) is valid everywhere but around @xmath58 .
let the wave @xmath57 have the form of the wkb solution with the pair of coefficients @xmath61 before the scattering at the point @xmath58 ; and the pair @xmath62 after the scattering at @xmath58 .
the interaction term around all the points @xmath58 is parabolic @xmath63 .
therefore , the outgoing amplitudes @xmath64 can be expressed through the incoming amplitudes @xmath65 with help of the well - known reflection @xmath66 and transmission @xmath67 amplitudes for scattering from a parabolic potential at @xmath58 : @xmath68 where @xmath69 , the phase accumulated by the moment @xmath70 is @xmath71 , and a scaled momentum @xmath72 .
the growth index @xmath53 is defined by the formula @xmath73 . ifrom ( [ 7 ] ) , one finds the characteristic exponent in the large occupation number limit @xmath74 for the mathieu eq .
( [ 6 ] ) there is a simple solution of the matrix equation ( [ 7 ] ) for an arbitrary @xmath75 , which allows us to find the resonance band @xmath76 and to fix the phase @xmath77 , @xmath78 .
the crucial expression here is the phase @xmath79 accumulating between two successive zeros of @xmath10 , @xmath80 , so that @xmath81 .
= 5.2 cm + the function @xmath53 derived with the formulas ( [ 8 ] ) is independent of @xmath75 and is plotted in fig . 2 ( left panel ) , which is a slice of the mathieu stability / instability chart for given ( large ) @xmath56 . that transparently shows the presence of a sequence of stability / instability bands as a function of @xmath82 . typical half - width of a resonance band is @xmath83 .
the effect of parametric resonance crucially depends on the interference of the wave functions , i.e. , the phase correlation / anticorrelation between successive scatterings at the parabolic potentials . the maximal value of @xmath84 is reached for the positive interference when @xmath85 and is equal to @xmath86 .
the typical value of @xmath84 corresponds to @xmath87 and is equal to @xmath88 . for the negative interference
when @xmath89 there is no resonance .
the angle @xmath90 is mainly controlled by the phase @xmath91 .
let us consider now an expanding universe . at first glance ,
the resonant solution here is more complicated than the mathieu equation , which for @xmath92 has only a heuristic meaning for our problem .
the most important change is the time - dependence of the parameter @xmath93 : @xmath94 ; @xmath95 is the number of inflaton oscillations . for the broad resonance case
this parameter significantly varies within a few inflaton oscillations ; hence , the concept of the static stability / instability chart and the results for the mathieu equation can not be utilized here .
surprisingly , the most interesting case , when the parameter @xmath56 is large _ and _ time - varying , can also be treated analytically by the method of successive parabolic scatterings .
indeed , the matrix mapping ( [ 7 ] ) for the @xmath96 and @xmath97 is also valid in the case of an expanded universe .
the phase accumulating between two successive zeros of the inflaton field is now @xmath98 . for large initial values of @xmath56 , the phase rotation between successive scatterings
@xmath99 is much larger than @xmath100 for all relevant @xmath82 .
therefore , the phase @xmath90 in formula ( [ 8 ] ) can be considered to be random numbers . since there is no memory of the phases ,
each mapping ( [ 7 ] ) can be considered as independent of the previous ones . as a result
the number of particles @xmath101 and the exponent @xmath53 are random variables .
the functional form of @xmath53 for the stochastic resonance is different from that for the broad parametric resonance , in ( [ 8 ] ) one has substitute a random phase @xmath102 in the interval @xmath103 $ ] instead of @xmath90 .
an example of a stochastic @xmath53 is plotted in fig . 2 .
+ contrary to the regular resonance , the stochastic resonance is much broader , there are no distinguished stability / instability bands , and for certain values of momenta the function @xmath104 is negative . during the stochastic resonance regime
, this function changes dramatically with every half period of the inflaton oscillations .
[ fig8 ] shows that it is incorrect to use the structure of the resonance bands of the static mathieu equation for investigation of the stage of stochastic resonance , unless the parameter @xmath56 drops to a value @xmath105 .
in the theory with the potential @xmath107 it is convenient to use the conformal field @xmath108 and conformal time variable @xmath109 .
then ( without decay ) the amplitude of @xmath110 is constant , @xmath111 .
the background solution is given by an elliptic function @xmath112 , @xmath113 .
( [ 2 ] ) for quantum fluctuations @xmath36 can be simplified in this theory .
indeed , the physical momentum , @xmath114 is redshifted in the same manner as the background field amplitude
. the conformal transformation of the mode function @xmath115 allows one to rewrite eq .
( [ 2 ] ) as @xmath116 where @xmath117 .
the equation for fluctuations does not depend on the expansion of the universe and is completely reduced to the similar problem in minkowski space - time .
this is a special feature of the conformal theory @xmath118 .
the mode equation ( [ 10 ] ) belongs to the class of lam equations . since the coefficients of the lam equation ( [ 10 ] )
are time - independent , we can numerically construct the stability / instability chart in the variables @xmath119 , plotted in fig .
1 . the combination of parameters @xmath120 ultimately defines the structure of the parametric resonance in this theory .
this means that the condition of a broad parametric resonance does not require a large initial amplitude of the inflaton field , as for the quadratic potential .
the strength of the resonance depends non - monotonically on this parameter .
preheating in the theory @xmath121 is efficient only if @xmath122 .
the inflaton amplitude @xmath123 is extremely large immediately after inflation , @xmath124 , and later it decreases as @xmath125 . the parameter @xmath56 , which controls the resonance , rapidly changes . as a result ,
the broad parametric resonance regime in this theory is a stochastic process . in the theory
@xmath126 the inflaton field @xmath0 also decreases in an expanding universe , but it does not make the resonance stochastic because all variables scale in the same way as @xmath0 due to the conformal invariance of the model .
the parameter which controls the strength of the resonance is @xmath127 .
what is the relation between these two theories ?
neither of these two theories is completely general . in the theory of the massive scalar field
one may expect terms @xmath128 to appear because of radiative corrections . on the other hand , in many realistic theories
the effective potential is quadratic with respect to @xmath0 near the minimum of the effective potential .
let us consider the theory @xmath129 which embraces both limits .
= 5.4 cm + one may expect that for @xmath130 the mass term @xmath131 does not affect the frequency of oscillations of the inflaton field @xmath0 , and the parametric resonance in this theory occurs in the same way as in the conformal theory , whereas for @xmath132 the resonance develops as in the massive theory .
therefore , a naive thought would be that as the amplitude @xmath123 decreases from @xmath133 to @xmath134 , the parametric resonance can be described with the lam stability / instability chart .
it turns out that the actual criterion for the regular , stable resonance is that the phase of the @xmath36-wave between two zeros of inflaton oscillations , @xmath135 is not rotating . the phase rotation within an inflaton half - period is @xmath136 .
this means that despite the subdominant contribution of the mass term , for large @xmath137 its presence can modify the nature of the lam resonance by turning it into stochastic process if @xmath138 .
different regimes of parametric resonance are shown in fig .
[ resranges ] . immediately after inflation
the amplitude @xmath123 is greater than @xmath134 . if @xmath139 , the @xmath13-particles are produced in the regular resonance regime until @xmath140 decreases to @xmath141 , after which the resonance occurs as in the theory @xmath142 .
the resonance never becomes stochastic .
if @xmath143 , the resonance originally develops as in the conformal theory , but with a decrease of @xmath140 the resonance becomes stochastic .
again , for @xmath144 the resonance occurs as in the theory @xmath145 .
there is a transient regime of intermittancy between regular ( stable ) and stochastic resonances . in all cases
the resonance eventually disappears when the field @xmath140 becomes sufficiently small and is replaced by the perturbative decay .
perturbative reheating can be complete only if there is symmetry breaking in the theory , or additional interactions with fermions@xmath146 .
kofman , l. , linde , a. & starobinsky , a. 1994 , _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 73 * , 3195 .
kofman , l. , linde , a. & starobinsky , a. 1997 , _ phys .
rev . _ * d56 * , 3258 .
3 . greene , p. , kofman , l. , linde , a. , & starobinsky , a. 1997 , _ phys .
rev._*d56 * , 6175 .
kofman , l. in : _ relativistic astrophysics : novikov s 60th birthday .
cambridge univer .
press 1997 , p.133 .
* full name : lev kofman * first name : lev * middle name : * surname : kofman * initialized name : l. kofman * affiliation : ifa , honolulu , hawaii , usa * e - mail : [email protected] * ship the proceedings to : honolulu , hawaii , usa | it is assumed that during inflation , all energy was contained in a slow - rolling inflaton field @xmath0 .
the particles constituting the universe are created due to interactions with the field @xmath0 coherently oscillating after inflation .
the leading channel of the particle production would be the non - perturbative regime of parametric resonance , _
preheating_. some of the recent developments in the theory of preheating are briefly reviewed . as a prototype we use the model @xmath1 in an expanding universe . in different domains of parameters the character of preheating
@xmath2 or @xmath3 is different , ranging from regular lam to stochastic parametric resonances .
fortunately , in many important cases simple analytic resonant solutions are found . eventually , a picture which unifies the different regimes emerges . |
extending lattice qcd calculations to non - zero baryon - chemical potential or , equivalently , to non - zero net baryon number density is known to be difficult in general . however
, important information on the qcd phase diagram can be deduced for small values of the chemical potential by using well established numerical techniques such as reweighting @xcite , analytic continuation @xcite or taylor expansion @xcite .
we will concentrate here on the latter approach .
not only do taylor expansions of thermodynamic observables provide information on qcd thermodynamics at small but non - zero chemical potential , the expansion coefficients themselves also are sensitive indicators for critical behavior in the vicinity of the chiral phase transition at vanishing chemical potential . as the chemical potential couples to the quark number current , which does not break chiral symmetry
, it acts to leading order like a temperature variable .
derivatives with respect to chemical potentials lead to susceptibilities which exhibit critical behavior similar to that of thermal susceptibilities @xcite .
we will show here that a calculation of the leading order taylor expansion coefficient of the chiral order parameter , which defines a mixed susceptibility , allows to perform quantitative studies of the phase boundary between low and high temperature phases of qcd close to @xmath4 . at non - zero values of the chemical potential a phase boundary in the temperature and chemical potential parameter space of qcd
is well defined only in the heavy quark limit or for vanishing quark masses . in the former case
the phase transition line corresponds to the first order deconfinement transition in the pure gauge theory . at infinite values of the quark mass
this transition is independent of the chemical potential and defines a straight line in the @xmath5-@xmath6 plane . for a large range of quark mass values
the transition line is not unique .
it characterizes a region of ( rapid ) crossover in thermodynamic quantities and a pseudo - critical temperature extracted from these observables may differ somewhat , depending on the observable that is used . in the chiral limit , however , the transition line is again well defined . for sufficiently large strange quark mass
it defines a line of second order phase transitions in the universality class of three dimensional @xmath7 symmetric spin models @xcite .
taylor expansions , analytic continuation as well as reweighting techniques have been used to locate the crossover line @xmath8 in the @xmath5-@xmath6 plane for small values of the chemical potential @xcite .
these calculations , which have been performed for different flavors and various values of the quark masses , suggest that the curvature is small , _
i.e. _ @xmath9 decreases only by a few percent at @xmath10 .
however , so far most lattice qcd calculations performed to determine the transition line have been performed on coarse lattices , _
i.e. _ lattices with only four sites in the temporal direction for which the lattice spacing in units of the temperature thus equals @xmath1 . better control over the extrapolation to the continuum limit and the quark mass dependence of the transition line clearly is needed .
so far studies of the transition line concentrated on its dependence on a single chemical potential , taken to be either identical for the light up ( @xmath11 ) and down ( @xmath12 ) quarks or of opposite sign .
the former is the light quark chemical potential , @xmath13 and latter is the isospin chemical potential , @xmath14 for which direct numerical calculations are possible . in order to make contact to the situation met in heavy ion collisions
@xcite one eventually wants to analyze the influence of non - zero charge ( @xmath15 ) and strangeness ( @xmath16 ) chemical potentials on the curvature of the transition line , _ i.e. _ , one should allow for non- vanishing up- , down- and strange - quark chemical potentials .
for small values of the chemical potential this is possible in the framework we will outline here . at present
we will , however , restrict our discussion to the case of vanishing strange quark and isospin ( electric charge ) chemical potentials .
we concentrate on an analysis of the phase transition line in the chiral limit ( @xmath17 , @xmath18 ) where its dependence on @xmath19 is expected to be largest . we will present a calculation of the critical line for small values of the light quark masses in the scaling regime of the finite temperature chiral phase transition .
this allows to use scaling relations to extract the curvature of the phase transition line in the chiral limit of qcd .
the scaling relations naturally relate the curvature of the critical line as function of @xmath19 to the magnitude of a mixed susceptibility .
we will perform our numerical calculations for ( 2 + 1)-flavor qcd keeping the heavier strange quark mass close to its physical value and decreasing the two degenerate light quark masses towards the massless limit . on coarse lattice with temporal extent @xmath20 we will make use of a recently performed scaling analysis @xcite of the chiral order parameter performed with an improved staggered fermion action .
this study showed that the chiral order parameter is well described by a universal scaling function characteristic for a three dimensional , @xmath21 universality class .
as we are using a staggered fermion discretization scheme for our scaling analysis we expect that the transition in the chiral limit , performed at non - zero lattice spacing , is controlled by the @xmath22 rather than @xmath7 universality class .
we thus will analyze our numerical results in terms of @xmath22 scaling functions .
we will comment on the application of @xmath7 scaling relations later on .
this paper is organized as follows . in the next section
we will extend the scaling analysis of the chiral order parameter to lattices with temporal extent @xmath23 .
this provides the basic parameters needed for a calculation of the curvature of the chiral phase transition line which will be discussed in section iii .
we give a discussion of our results and an outlook in section iv .
in the vicinity of a critical point regular contributions to the partition functions become negligible in higher order derivatives and the singular behavior of response functions will generally be dominated by contributions arising from the singular part of the free energy density or @xmath7 universality classes this does not hold for the thermal response function ( specific heat ) as the relevant critical exponent @xmath24 is negative in these cases . ]
@xmath25 in addition to the temperature @xmath5 , light ( @xmath26 and strange ( @xmath27 ) quark masses we also allow for a dependence of the free energy density on the quark chemical potentials .
close to the chiral phase transition temperature at vanishing chemical potential the singular part @xmath28 will give rise to universal scaling properties of response functions .
this has been exploited to analyze basic universal features of the qcd phase diagram close to criticality @xcite .
the singular part of the free energy density depends on the parameters of the qcd lagrangian , e.g. the quark masses , and the external control parameters , temperature and chemical potentials , only through two relevant couplings .
these scaling variables , @xmath29 and @xmath30 , control deviations from criticality , @xmath31 , along the two relevant directions , which in the case of qcd characterize fluctuations of the energy and chiral condensate , respectively . to leading order
the scaling variable @xmath30 depends only on parameters that break chiral symmetry in the light quark sector , while @xmath29 depends on all other couplings .
in particular , @xmath29 will depend on the light quark chemical potential while @xmath30 remains unaffected by these in leading order , @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the phase transition temperature in the chiral limit and @xmath34 , @xmath35 are non - universal scale parameters ( as is @xmath33 ) . while the combination @xmath36 is unique for a given theory , the values of @xmath34 and @xmath35 will change under rescaling of the order parameter @xcite .
note also that they depend on the definition of the parameter introduced to control symmetry breaking , _
i.e. _ the fact that we choose the strange quark mass to normalize the symmetry breaking light quark mass parameter . for the rest of this chapter we will not need to refer any further to the contribution of chemical potentials to the reduced temperature @xmath29 .
we will come back to it in the next chapter .
the singular part of the free energy , @xmath28 , is a homogeneous function of its arguments .
this can be used to rewrite it in terms of the scaling variable @xmath37 as @xmath38 where @xmath39 are critical exponents of the three dimensional @xmath21 universality class @xcite , @xmath40 and @xmath41 for three dimensional @xmath22 models and @xmath42 and @xmath43 for @xmath7 , respectively .
all parameters entering the definition of @xmath29 and @xmath30 , _ i.e. _ @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath33 may depend on the strange quark mass , but are otherwise unique in the continuum limit of ( 2 + 1)-flavor qcd . just like the transition temperature @xmath33 , however , also @xmath34 and @xmath35 are cut - off dependent and will need to be extrapolated to the continuum limit .
the universal critical behavior of the order parameter , @xmath44 , is controlled by a scaling function @xmath45 that arises from the singular part of the free energy density after taking a derivative with respect to the light quark mass , @xmath46 the scaling function @xmath47 is well - known for the @xmath22 and @xmath7 universality classes through studies of three dimensional spin models @xcite .
this so - called magnetic equation of state , eq .
[ order ] , has been analyzed recently for ( 2 + 1)-flavor qcd using an improved staggered fermion formulation ( p4-action ) on lattices with temporal extent @xmath48 @xcite and light quark masses as small as @xmath49 , which corresponds to a pion mass that is about half its physical value .
it could be shown that the chiral order parameter can be mapped onto a universal @xmath21 scaling curve and the scale parameters @xmath50 could be extracted .
as the calculations had been performed with staggered fermions the scaling analysis has been performed by comparing results with the magnetic equation of state for a @xmath22 universality class rather than @xmath7 as one should find in the continuum limit for two massless quark flavor . however , as has been argued in @xcite both scaling curves are similar in the limited range of z values , where this scaling analysis has been performed , and the scaling analysis could have been performed with @xmath7 scaling functions as well . at least on these coarse @xmath48 lattices violations of scaling have been found to be small also for physical values of the light quark mass , _
i.e. _ @xmath51 .
of course , it is to be expected that the scale parameters , extracted on coarse lattices with temporal extent @xmath48 , are subject to cut - off effects .
we therefore extend the analysis of ref .
@xcite to smaller lattice spacings .
we perform calculations on lattices with temporal extent @xmath52 .
we follow here the discussion presented in ref .
@xcite and introduce two order parameters , that are multiplicatively renormalized by multiplying the chiral condensate with the strange quark mass , but differ in handling additive divergences , linear in the quark mass , @xmath53 we use in our study data for the chiral condensate which have been collected by the hotqcd @xcite and rbc - bielefeld @xcite collaborations in their studies of the ( 2 + 1)-flavor equation of state on lattices of size @xmath54 as well as in the course of analyzing the transition temperature in ( 2 + 1)-flavor qcd @xcite .
these calculations have been performed with the p4-action @xcite for three different quark mass ratios @xmath55 and @xmath56 , respectively .
we use subsets of these data samples which cover a small temperature interval close to the transition region , but covering also the region of the transition temperature in the chiral limit . for the smallest quark mass ratio this includes a set of 16 values of the gauge coupling which cover a temperature interval @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) .
typically ( 20.000 - 30.000 ) trajectories of 0.5 time - units have been generated for each set of quark masses and gauge couplings .
the temperature scale used in our scaling analysis is based on calculations of the scale parameter @xmath59 that has been determined from calculations of the heavy quark potential performed on lattices of size @xmath60 @xcite .
the basic approach for the scaling analysis on @xmath52 lattices is identical to that described in ref .
however , as the calculations on the @xmath52 lattices have not been performed for as small light quark masses as in the @xmath48 analysis @xcite , where the smallest ratio was @xmath49 , we did not perform a separate analysis for the determination of scaling parameters in the small mass regime and a determination of scaling violating terms for larger values of the quark masses , as it has been done in ref .
we perform a simultaneous analysis of data obtained for all three quark mass ratios and include scaling violating regular terms in the ansatz for scaling fits , @xmath61 with @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
this includes all the scaling violating terms also used on @xmath20 lattices . in our final analysis ,
however , we will set @xmath64 .
we verified that this approach , applied to the @xmath48 data set , and restricted to the same mass range available now on @xmath23 lattices , _
i.e. _ @xmath65 , leads to results compatible with our earlier findings .
we extract values for @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath33 which are similar to those obtained previously .
in fact , results for fit parameters obtained from the analysis of different order parameters , @xmath66 and @xmath67 , turn out to be in even better agreement . results of this new scaling analysis for the @xmath20 data set is shown in the upper half of fig .
[ fig : scalingnt8 ] .
all fit parameter are summarized in table [ tab : parameter ] . using the approach described above for the analysis of our @xmath23 data set we find good agreement of fit parameters extracted from an analysis of @xmath67 and @xmath66 , respectively .
results of this scaling analysis are shown in the lower half of fig .
[ fig : scalingnt8 ] .
all fit parameter are summarized in table [ tab : parameter ] . as already noted in the analysis performed on lattices with temporal extent @xmath48 @xcite
, we observe also for @xmath23 that scaling violations are small for @xmath68 .
this confirms that physical quark mass values , corresponding to @xmath69 , are in the scaling region .
the constants @xmath35 , @xmath34 determined for @xmath23 take on values different from those for @xmath48 . the invariant combination of scale parameters , @xmath70 changes by about 50% which shows that its continuum extrapolation is not yet possible .
this also is the case for @xmath34 and @xmath35 separately .
@xmath34 & @xmath35 & @xmath71 [ mev ] & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 + + 4 & @xmath67 & 0.0037(2 ) & 0.0022(3 ) & 194.5(4 ) & - & - & 6.8(5 ) + & @xmath66 & 0.0048(5 ) & 0.0048(2 ) & 195.6(4 ) & - & - & 8.5(8 ) + + 4 & @xmath67 & 0.00407(9 ) & 0.00295(22 ) & 194.9(2 ) & 3.8(21 ) & 2.1(1 ) & 7.5(3 ) + & @xmath66 & 0.00401(9 ) & 0.00271(20 ) & 194.8(2 ) & 11.2(21 ) & -2.4(1 ) & 7.2(3 ) + 8 & @xmath67 & 0.00271(21 ) & 0.00048(9 ) & 174.1(8 ) & -10.1(16 ) & 3.3(5 ) & 3.8(5 ) + & @xmath66 & 0.00302(22 ) & 0.00059(10 ) & 175.1(8 ) & -0.9(15 ) & -4.6(4 ) & 3.8(4 ) + when comparing results obtained for @xmath48 and @xmath23 one also has to take into account the dependence of the scale parameters on the strange quark mass .
in fact , as the scaling analysis has been performed at bare strange quark mass values @xmath27 , fixed in lattice units , the corresponding physical value in the chiral limit at @xmath75 is only determined a posteriori , once @xmath33 has been determined .
it turns out that the physical values of the strange quark mass in the @xmath48 and @xmath76 calculations differ at @xmath33 by about 10% .
one may account for this mismatch by reweighting the results for the chiral condensates in the light and strange quark masses @xcite . however , we will not attempt to do this here .
the main outcome of the @xmath23 scaling analysis , aside from confirming the good scaling properties of the order parameter at a twice smaller value of the lattice spacing , is a determination of the scale parameters and the transition temperature @xmath33 in the chiral limit , needed in the definition of the scaling variable @xmath77 , _ i.e. _ the determination of @xmath78 and @xmath33 .
we summarize these results in table [ tab : parameter ] . in the next section
we will make use of these scale parameters to determine the curvature of the phase transition line for small values of the quark chemical potential .
as outlined in the beginning of the previous section at leading order the light quark chemical potential only enters the reduced temperature @xmath29 , as introduced in eq .
[ scalingfields ] . also at non - vanishing values of the quark chemical potential
the phase transition point is located at @xmath75 .
the variation of the transition temperature with chemical potential therefore is parametrized in terms of the constant @xmath79 introduced in eq .
[ scalingfields ] , @xmath80 to determine the chiral phase transition line in the @xmath5-@xmath6 plane we thus need to determine the proportionality constant @xmath79 .
this is , in fact , the only left over free parameter in universal scaling functions that needs to be determined .
all other parameters ( @xmath81 ) have already been determined in the scaling analysis of the order parameter discussed in the previous section .
the constant @xmath79 can be determined by analyzing the dependence of the chiral condensate on the light quark chemical potential . of course ,
at vanishing light quark mass one would simply determine the temperature at which @xmath82 vanishes . at non - zero but small values of the quark mass this information is encoded in scaling functions . to extract information about the dependence of the scaling variable @xmath29 on @xmath79 it suffices to consider the leading order taylor expansion coefficient of the chiral condensate , @xmath83 where @xmath84 the mixed susceptibility @xmath85 is proportional to the leading order coefficient of the taylor expansion of the chiral condensate , which has been introduced in @xcite .
it may also be viewed as the quark mass derivative of the light quark number susceptibility ( @xmath86 ) .
details of its definition in terms of inverses of the staggered fermion matrix and its derivatives with respect to the quark chemical potential are given in appendix a of ref .
we have summarized the formulas relevant for our current analysis in an appendix . in the massless
limit the chiral order parameter vanishes at @xmath33 and varies as @xmath87 .
its derivative with respect to @xmath29 thus will diverge at @xmath33 like @xmath88 . the same singular behavior will thus show up in a derivative of the chiral condensate with respect to temperature as well as the second derivative with respect to @xmath89 .
the pre - factors of the singularity in @xmath90 and @xmath91 , however , will differ by a factor @xmath92 .
we will make use of this relation to determine the curvature of the critical line at @xmath93 . in the vicinity of the critical point
the mixed susceptibility can be expressed in terms of the scaling function @xmath94 , @xmath95 the scaling function @xmath96 is easily obtained from @xmath47 by using the implicit parametrization for the latter given in ref .
we also note that @xmath85 diverges as function of the light quark mass at @xmath75 , _
i.e. _ at the chiral phase transition temperature .
in contrast to the chiral susceptibility , @xmath97 , which stays finite in the chiral limit only for @xmath98 , the mixed susceptibility is finite for all @xmath99 ; for @xmath100 it scales like @xmath101 while for @xmath98 it behaves like @xmath102 . for small values of the light quark mass numerical results for the mixed susceptibilities @xmath85 may be compared to the right hand side of eq .
[ mixedscaling ] . here
all parameters that enter @xmath96 are known and the only undetermined parameter is @xmath79 . as we did for the analysis of the magnetic equation of state , we should consider the influence of scaling violations induced by non - zero values of the light quark masses on the determination of the curvature of the phase transition line .
the leading quark mass corrections identified in the analysis of the magnetic equation of state will not contribute to @xmath85 as they do not depend on the chemical potential .
the first scaling violating term would arise from a regular term that gives corrections to the order parameter of the form @xmath103 .
this would give rise to corrections to the scaling relation given in eq .
[ mixedscaling ] @xmath104 as we do not know the pre - factor @xmath105 we need to check in the analysis of the mixed susceptibilities whether corrections to scaling play a role .
we note , however , that in the case of the magnetic equation of state the dominant corrections arise from the term @xmath106 , which is ultraviolet divergent in the continuum limit .
this term drops out in the analysis of @xmath107 .
moreover , scaling violating terms are further suppressed by a factor @xmath108 ( or @xmath109 in @xmath7 symmetric models ) as the dominant scaling term itself is divergent at @xmath31 .
we thus expect scaling violations to be small .
using a subset of the data samples described in the previous section , we calculated the mixed susceptibility @xmath85 on lattices with temporal extent @xmath48 for several values of the quark mass .
for this analysis we used data sets separated by 50 trajectories .
for the lightest quark mass ratio , @xmath49 , we selected 4 and for the three heavier quark mass ratios , @xmath110 , we choose 6 values of the gauge coupling in a narrow temperature interval close to the chiral phase transition temperature @xmath33 , _ i.e. _ @xmath111 . typically this involved about 500 to 950 gauge field configurations per parameter set , except for the lightest quark mass ratio where we analyzed about 350 gauge field configuration . on each gauge field configuration
we calculated the various operators necessary to construct @xmath85 .
explicit expression for them are given in the appendix ( see also appendix a of @xcite ) .
the calculation of the various operators required inversions of the staggered fermion matrix with a large set of random noise vectors .
we used 500 noise vectors on each gauge field configuration and constructed unbiased estimators for the various traces that need to be calculated .
all these calculations could be performed very efficiently on a gpu cluster .
results obtained for the mixed light quark number susceptibility , @xmath85 , on lattices with temporal extent @xmath48 are shown in fig .
[ fig : c2pbpiq ] .
we clearly see that @xmath85 increases in the transition region with decreasing values of @xmath112 . using the scaling relation given in eq .
[ mixedscaling ] we can re - scale the data and obtain a unique scaling curve .
this scaling curve can be mapped onto the @xmath22 scaling function @xmath96 with a simple multiplicative rescaling factor , @xmath113 .
the resulting scaling plot is shown in fig .
[ fig : c2pbp ] . to check for possible contributions from scaling violating terms
we have analyzed the data separately for quark mass ratios @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
these fits agree within statistical errors .
we then determine the curvatures @xmath79 from fits to the complete data set .
results of these fits are summarized in table [ tab : fit ] .
.determination of the curvature of the critical surface of the chiral phase transition in @xmath116-flavor qcd as function of the light quark chemical potential @xmath19 .
the table summarizes fits performed separately for two lighter and two heavier quark mass sets as well as the combined data set .
[ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the scaling analysis performed for the mixed susceptibility on lattices with temporal extent @xmath20 suggests that the determination of the curvature parameter @xmath117 can be reliably performed with quark masses @xmath118 .
this is in accordance with the scaling analysis of the order parameter itself , which we have discussed in the previous section .
it thus seems to be safe to extract the curvature parameter also at smaller values of the lattice spacing , _ i.e. _ from our @xmath52 data set , by using the smallest quark mass ratio available there , @xmath119 .
we have performed calculations at five values of the temperature using gauge field configurations on @xmath54 lattices generated by the hotqcd collaboration @xcite . for these parameter sets
we have analyzed 300 to 600 gauge field configurations , which were separated by 100 trajectories .
again we used 500 noise vectors for the calculation of all relevant operators on each of the gauge field configurations .
the result of this analysis is shown in fig .
[ fig : c2pbpiq ] and fig .
[ fig : c2pbp ] with filled symbols .
as can be seen they agree well with results obtained on coarser lattices . when rescaling data obtained for @xmath85 to the @xmath22 scaling curve @xmath96 we need to take into account errors on the scaling parameters @xmath34 and @xmath74 ( or @xmath35 ) .
this leads to a 10% error for the determination of the curvature terms . performing a combined fit to all results obtained for different quark mass values and lattice spacings we obtain @xmath120 this result for the curvature of the critical line is about a factor two larger than the reweighting results obtained in ( 2 + 1)-flavor qcd @xcite .
it is however consistent with results obtained in calculations with imaginary chemical potentials .
in fact it lies inbetween the 2-flavor @xcite and 3-flavor @xcite simulations performed with the standard staggered fermion formulation and also is consistent with results reported from ( 2 + 1)-flavor simulations with imaginary chemical potential performed with the action used also in this study ( p4-action ) @xcite .
with this analysis we have established a systematic way to determine the curvature of the qcd phase transition line in the chiral limit for small values of the light quark chemical potential . we have determined the curvature for two values of the cutoff using an improved staggered fermion action ( p4-action ) . within our present statistical accuracy
we did not observe any significant quark mass dependence of the scaled mixed susceptibilities .
the result observed for the curvature of the second order phase transition line in the chiral limit thus also is a good estimate for the crossover line at physical values of the light quark masses .
although the final result for the curvature term seems to show little cutoff dependence , one has to be cautious as the other three scale parameters that enter this analysis ( @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath33 ) all vary significantly as the lattice spacing is reduced by a factor of two .
clearly more work is needed to extrapolate safely to the continuum limit we will do so in the future by repeating the analysis with a discretization scheme that also suppresses cut - off effects arising from taste symmetry violation in the staggered fermion action more efficiently ( hisq action ) . in our current analysis we have kept the strange quark and isospin chemical potentials equal to zero .
a direct comparison to the situation met in heavy ion collisions on the freeze - out curve thus should be done with caution . however , at least for large energies , _
i.e. _ , small values of the baryon chemical potential experimental results for the freeze - out curve correspond to electric charge chemical potentials , which are more than an order of magnitude smaller than @xmath121 . as susceptibilities obtained by derivatives with respect to strange quark chemical potentials rather than light quark chemical potentials
are generally smaller , one may also expect that the curvature in the @xmath16 direction will turn out to be smaller .
it thus seems that the curvature of the critical surface along the @xmath122 direction is most relevant for a comparison of lattice qcd results with the experimentally determined freeze - out curve .
the phenomenological parametrization of the freeze - out curve given in @xcite yields @xmath123 .
the curvature of the freeze - out curve thus is about a factor 4 larger than that determined here for the chiral phase transition curve .
this suggests that the freeze - out curve may not follow the chiral phase transition or crossover line at non - zero values of the chemical potential . with increasing @xmath89
the hadronic freeze - out seems to happen further away from criticality . at the largest value of the light quark chemical potential currently explored in the low energy scan at rhic @xcite , @xmath124
, the freeze - out temperature may be about 15% below the crossover temperature .
nonetheless , as pointed out above , one still needs to improve the current lattice calculations .
results closer to the continuum limit with further improved fermion discretization schemes are needed and one should also get control over the influence of non - vanishing strange quark chemical potentials in order to firmly establish the separation of the freeze - out curve from the chiral transition line as advocated above .
this work has been supported in part by contracts de - ac02 - 98ch10886 with the u.s .
department of energy , the bmbf under grant 06bi401 , the gesellschaft fr schwerionenforschung under grant bilaer , the extreme matter institute under grant ha216/emmi and the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft under grant grk 881 .
cs has been partially supported through the helmholtz international center for fair which is part of the hessian loewe initiative .
numerical simulations have been performed on the bluegene / l at the new york center for computational sciences ( nyccs ) which is supported by the u.s .
department of energy and by the state of new york , the gpu cluster of usqcd at jefferson laboratory , the gpu cluster scout at the center for scientific computing ( csc ) at frankfurt university , as well as the john von neumann supercomputer center ( nic ) at fz - jlich , germany .
we thank m. bach for his help in developing the cuda based programs used for our data analysis on gpu clusters .
we summarize here the operators entering a calculation of the mixed susceptibility @xmath85 introduced in eq . [ mixed ] .
this susceptibility is proportional to the second order taylor expansion coefficient of the chiral condensate in terms of the light quark chemical potentials . using appendix a of ref .
@xcite ) we introduce the expectation value of the light quark chiral condensate as @xmath125 and obtain for the mixed susceptibility , @xmath126 where we have introduced the shorthand notation @xmath127 for the chemical potential expressed in units of the lattice spacing . here
@xmath128 and @xmath129 denote n - th derivatives of the trace of the inverse fermion matrix ( @xmath130 ) and logarithms of its determinant , respectively , @xmath131 where the derivatives are defined with respect to the flavor chemical potential @xmath132 for the quark flavor @xmath133 . the factors @xmath134 and @xmath135 arise because we define the mixed susceptibility as a derivative of the 1-flavor light quark chiral condensate with respect to the light quark chemical potential @xmath19 which is identical for the two light flavor components of the fermion action , _
i.e. _ a flavor factor @xmath136 arises only in derivatives of the logarithm of the fermion matrix .
99 z. fodor and s. d. katz , jhep * 0203 * , 014 ( 2002 ) ; + z. fodor and s.d . katz , jhep * 0404 * , 050 ( 2004 ) .
p. de forcrand and o. philipsen , nucl .
b * 642 * , 290 ( 2002 ) .
m. delia and m. lombardo , phys .
d * 67 * , 014505 ( 2003 ) c. r. allton , s. ejiri , s. j. hands , o. kaczmarek , f. karsch , e. laermann , and c. schmidt , phys .
d * 68 * , 014507 ( 2003 ) .
r. v. gavai and s. gupta , phys .
d * 68 * , 034506 ( 2003 ) .
s. ejiri , f. karsch and k. redlich , phys .
b * 633 * , 275 ( 2006 ) .
r. pisarski and f. wilczek , phys .
d * 29 * , 338 ( 1984 ) . for a summary of earlier results on the curvature of the transition line see : + o. philipsen , prog .
. suppl . * 174 * , 206 ( 2008 ) .
g. endrodi , z. fodor , s. d. katz and k. k. szabo , pos * lattice2008 * , 205 ( 2008 ) .
a. andronic , p. braun - munzinger and j. stachel , nucl .
a * 772 * , 167 ( 2006 ) .
j. cleymans , h. oeschler , k. redlich and s. wheaton , phys .
c * 73 * , 034905 ( 2006 ) .
y. hatta and t. ikeda , phys .
d * 67 * , 014028 ( 2003 ) .
s. ejiri _ et al .
_ , phys . rev .
d * 80 * , 094505 ( 2009 ) .
j. engels , s. holtmann , t. mendes and t. schulze , phys .
b * 514 * , 299 ( 2001 ) .
j. engels , l. fromme and m. seniuch , nucl .
b * 675 * [ fs ] , 533 ( 2003 ) . j. engels , s. holtmann , t. mendes and t. schulze , phys . lett .
b * 514 * , 299 ( 2001 ) .
a. bazavov _ et al .
_ ( hotqcd collaboration ) , phys . rev .
d * 80 * , 014504 ( 2009 ) .
m. cheng _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 81 * , 054504 ( 2010 ) .
a. bazavov , _ et al .
_ ( hotqcd collaboration ) , in preparation .
f. karsch , e. laermann and a. peikert , phys .
b * 478 * , 447 ( 2000 ) .
s. gupta and r. ray , phys .
d * 70 * , 114015 ( 2004 ) c. r. allton _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 71 * , 054508 ( 2005 ) .
w. unger , the chiral phase transition of qcd with 2 + 1 flavors , phd thesis , bielefeld , september 2010 .
p. de forcrand and o. philipsen , jhep * 0701 * , 077 ( 2007 ) .
r. falcone , pos lattice 2010 , 183 ( 2010 ) .
m. m. aggarwal _ et al .
_ [ star collaboration ] , arxiv:1008.3133 [ nucl - ex ] . | we determine the chiral phase transition line in ( 2 + 1)-flavor qcd for small values of the light quark chemical potential . we show that for small values of the chemical potential the curvature of the phase transition line can be deduced from an analysis of scaling properties of the chiral condensate and its susceptibilities .
to do so we extend earlier studies of the magnetic equation of state in ( 2 + 1)-flavor qcd to finer lattice spacings , @xmath0 .
we use these universal scaling properties of the chiral order parameter to extract the curvature of the transition line at two values of the cut - off , @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
we find that cut - off effects are small for the curvature parameter and determine the transition line in the chiral limit to leading order in the light quark chemical potential .
we obtain @xmath3 . |
psr j1713 + 0747 was discovered in a survey for millisecond pulsars ( msps ) with the 305 m areceibo radio telescope ( foster , wolszczan & camilo 1993 ) .
it has been found that the pulsar has a spin period of 4.57 ms .
systematic changes in the apparent pulsar period have indicated the binary nature of this object .
foster et al .
( 1993 ) made the first determination of the binary model parameters of psr j1713 + 0747 .
they found a nearly circular , 67.8 day binary orbit with a low mass white dwarf ( wd ) companion .
they estimated the companion mass via the mass function . assuming the canonical value for the mass of the ns ( @xmath4 ) they set a lower limit of for the companion mass of @xmath5 .
clearly , psr j1713 + 0747 belongs to the family of neutron stars ( nss ) recycled by mass and angular momentum transfer from its normal ( donor ) companion ( alpar et al .
this process leads to the formation of a msp together with a cool wd companion .
for a recent review on this kind of binary systems see stairs ( 2004 ) . psr j1713
+ 0747 has been continuously observed with an increasing degree of accuracy , which has been large enough to reveal the general relativistic effect known as shapiro delay .
this occurs due to a slight change in the arrival time of pulsar radiation due to the curvature of space near the wd companion of the msp . according to general relativity ,
pulses are retarded as they propagate through the gravitational potential well of the wd .
the first detection of shapiro delay in psr j1713 + 0747 is due to camilo , foster , & wolszczan ( 1994 ) .
they were able to set lower limits of the masses of the wd ( @xmath6 0.27 ) and ns ( @xmath7 1.2 ) . in a very recent work ,
splaver et al .
( 2005 ) have reported the results of twelve years of observations of psr j1713 + 0747 .
the timing data yielded a large improvement in the measurements of the shapiro delay that allowed for the determination of the individual masses for both components of the system . in principle shapiro delay yields @xmath8 and @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the inclination angle . in practice ,
unless @xmath11 , shapiro delay is highly covariant with @xmath12 is the orbital semi - major axis . ] in the timing model fit and hence difficult to measure .
nevertheless , as shown by splaver et al ( 2005 ) , in the case of psr j1713 + 0747 shapiro delay can be clearly distinguished .
these high - precision detections allow for the masses of the pulsar and the companion star to be separately measured , being @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
these authors repeat the statistical analysis of timing solutions , now combined with the theoretical orbital period - core mass relation , and they obtain a larger mass for the ns : @xmath15 ( 68 % confidence ) .
the pulsar masses in systems that evolve into pulsar - wd binaries are expected to be larger that those in ns - ns binaries ( in this last case , the pulsar masses are expected within the range 1.25 - 1.44 ) .
this is because the systems that evolve into pulsar - wd systems undergo extended periods of mass transfer . in a binary population study performed by thorsett & chakrabarty ( 1999 )
, the authors find a narrow gaussian distribution with a mean of 1.35 and a width of 0.04 .
the mass derived when the orbital period - core mass relation is imposed in psr j1713 + 0747 implies a significantly heavier ns . apart from psr j1713 + 0747
there are other msp + wd systems for which it has been possible to measure the shapiro delay and the masses of each component of the pair .
one of them is psr j0437 - 4715 ( van straten et al . 2001 ) for which @xmath16 , and @xmath17 .
the other is psr b1855 + 09 for which @xmath18 and @xmath19 for the pulsar mass ( kaspi et al .
the uncertainties on all these measurements are large and the question of the distribution of pulsars masses in these systems remains open .
one very important parameter is the characteristic age of the pulsar @xmath20 .
the age of a spin - down powered pulsar is given by @xmath21\ ] ] where @xmath22 is the pulsar period , @xmath23 the temporal derivative of the period , @xmath24 is the initial period and @xmath25 the braking index . for magnetic dipole radiation
we have @xmath26 , and if we assume @xmath27 , the pulsar spin - down age is given by @xmath28 , the `` characteristic age '' of the pulsar .
the uncertainty in the pulsar age is caused by @xmath25 and @xmath24 .
on the other hand , the transverse velocity of the pulsar causes an apparent acceleration that contributes to the observed period derivative . ignoring this latter effect can lead to erroneous estimations of the characteristic pulsar age .
splaver et al .
( 2005 ) found for psr j1713 + 0747 , @xmath29 gyr .
using the restrictions for the mass of the wd in this system , hansen & phinney ( 1998 ) obtain cooling ages in the range 6.3 - 6.8 gyr , but if they consider the dispersion measure distance estimates , they can obtain cooling ages up to 13.2 gyr .
if the pulsar has a close companion wd , we expect the cooling age for the wd to approximately match the age of the pulsar . for the kind of systems we are here interested in
, @xmath20 should correspond to the age of the helium wd ( hereafter he wd ) counted since the end of the main ( initial ) roche lobe overflow ( rlof ) episode .
this is so because the initial rlof is the only one able to transfer the amount of matter needed to spin up the ns ( probably @xmath30 ) . as we shall show below , models of normal stars leading to the formation of the wd companion suffer from at least one hydrogen thermonuclear flash leading to a supplementary rlof
however , these flash - driven rlofs are not relevant in spinning up the ns because of the tiny amount of transferred matter ( benvenuto & de vito 2004 ) .
because of these reasons , the wd in psr j1713 + 0747 should have spent a time of @xmath31 gyr since the end of the main rlof episode .
the aim of this work is to test the present status of the theory of stellar evolution in binary systems by computing a set of evolutionary tracks in order to reproduce the main characteristics of the psr j1713 + 0747 system , particularly the masses of the components , the orbital period and the characteristic timescale for the cooling of the wd . in our opinion
this is an interesting problem because of the high precision of the measurements performed for the system we are dealing with .
the wd companion of psr j1713 + 0747 has been detected by lundgren , foster & camilo ( 1996 ) with hubble space telescope observations ( see table [ table : observa ] ) .
this fact provides us with the interesting possibility of confronting theory with observations . in doing
so we shall employ the available observational data of the wd in psr j1713 + 0747 as a test of the accuracy of our evolutionary calculations and _ not _ as the main data to account for .
we shall do so because of two reasons .
first , we judge that the accuracy of the radioastronomical measurements of the system is so high that they should be considered as the fundamental quantities for this problem .
second , this procedure is interesting in order to gauge the ability of the binary stellar evolution theory combined with atmosphere models in predicting the characteristics of a wd and to evaluate the possibility of helping for a first optical detection of wds as companions of msps .
.[table : observa ] main characteristics of the wd component of the psr j1713 + 0747 system , taken from lundgren et al .
the numbers in parentheses represent the uncertainty in the last digits quoted . [ cols="<,^",options="header " , ]
in this paper we have computed a set of binary evolutionary tracks in order to account for the main characteristics of the psr j1713 + 0747 system .
we did so with a binary stellar evolution code including a non - grey treatment of the atmospheric layers .
thanks to the high accuracy of the timing of this millisecond pulsar , it has been possible to measure the general relativistic shapiro delay effect to derive separate values for the masses of the white dwarf ( wd ) and the neutron star ( ns ) .
starting out from this fact , we performed a numerical experiment in which we computed the full evolution of the system in order to account for the masses and orbital period of the system and _ then _ considered the evolutionary status of the wd .
notice that the pulsar should have a characteristic age equal to the age of the wd counted since the end of the initial roche lobe overflow ( see section [ sec : intro ] for further details ) .
thus , at the characteristic age of the pulsar , the wd should resemble the object observed by lundgren et al .
( 1996 ) .
we found that a system with initial masses of @xmath32 , @xmath33 for the normal ( donor ) star and nss ( respectively ) in which the ns is able to accrete a fraction @xmath34 of the transferred mass ( the mass lost from the system is assumed to carry away a specific angular momentum equal to that of the ns ) accounts for the psr j1713 + 0747 system if @xmath3 and @xmath35 d or @xmath36 and @xmath37 d. we did not try to compute detailed models with lower initial masses , because in such a case , the wd would need to spend a time in excess of the age of the universe in evolving to the observed configuration . also , at longer initial periods models would undergo a common envelope episode because of the very deep outer convective zone of the donor star at the onset of the roche lobe overflow . in our opinion , it is remarkable that the model with @xmath38 accounts for the masses , the orbital period of the system and the brightness of the wd observed by lundgren et al .
( 1996 ) at the correct age .
we consider it as a successful fit which , in turn , indicates that the stellar evolution processes relevant for the present system are fairly well known .
notice that we would have been able to predict the absolute magnitude of the wd in psr j1713 + 0747 system with a reasonable accuracy .
our models fit the main characteristics of the wd at the age corresponding to @xmath39 gyr given by splaver et al .
consequently , we do not find evidence for a faster cooling as in hansen & phinney ( 1998 ) .
however , as our models predict pure hydrogen atmospheres , they are unable to reproduce the colours measured by lundgren et al .
( 1996 ) within the error bars of the observations . in any case
, we should remark that this discrepancy is moderate since theory and observations differ in less than @xmath40 .
moreover , the available photometric data is not yet accurate enough to determine a precise effective temperature and atmospheric chemical composition of the wd companion of the pulsar . in order to get a deeper understanding of the evolution of this system
it would be essential to perform new spectroscopic and photometric observations .
particularly , infra - red observations can offer much extra information and may help to constrain this binary further .
ogb has been supported by fondap center for astrophysics 1501003 .
rdr acknowledges partial support from secyt - unc 123/04 and conicet 691/04 . | recently splaver and coworkers have measured the masses of the white dwarf and the neutron star components of the psr j1713 + 0747 binary system pair by means of the general relativistic effect known as shapiro delay with very high accuracy . employing this data we attempt to find the original configuration that evolved to the observed system . for this purpose
we perform a set of binary evolution calculations trying to simultaneously account for the masses of both stars and the orbital period . in doing so , we considered normal ( donor ) stars with an initial mass of 1.5 , while for the neutron star companion we assumed a mass of 1.4 .
we assumed two metallicity values for the donor star ( @xmath0 and @xmath1 ) and that the initial orbital period was near 3 days . in order to get a good agreement between the masses of the models and observations we had to assume that the neutron star is only able to retain @xmath2 of the matter transferred by the donor star .
calculations were performed employing the binary hydro code developed by benvenuto & de vito ( 2004 ) , that handles the mass transfer rate in a fully implicit way together with state - of - the - art physical ingredients and diffusion processes .
now our code also includes a detailed non - grey treatment for the atmospheres of white dwarfs .
we compare the structure of the resulting white dwarfs with the characteristic age of psr j1713 + 0747 finding a nice agreement with observations by lundgren et al . especially for the case of a donor star with @xmath3 .
this result indicates that , at least for the purposes of this paper , the evolution of this kind of binary system is fairly well understood .
the models predict that , due to diffusion , the atmosphere of the white dwarf is an almost hydrogen - pure one .
we find that such structures are unable to account for the colours measured by lundgren et al . within their error bars .
thus , in spite of the very good agreement of the model with the main characteristics of the system , we find that some discrepances in the white dwarf emergent radiation remain to be explained .
[ firstpage ] stars : evolution - stars : binary - stars : white dwarfs |
since anderson s pioneering work @xcite , where the concept of localization of an electron moving in a random potential was introduced , propagation of electromagnetic waves through disordered media have been attracting a lot of interest ( see , for example , ref . @xcite and references therein ) .
one of the reasons for such interest is the possibility of observing weak localization effects in disordered systems .
most of the papers were devoted to the backscattering peak where weak localization effects are manifest ( see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite and for a recent experiment @xcite ) .
the influence of polarization effects on the backscattering peak was investigated in ref .
@xcite . along with the transport properties of disordered media , magneto - optical effects in such systems capture broader attention .
particularly , in ref .
@xcite , the light backscattering peak in parity - non conserving disordered media was investigated .
in such a medium rotation of the polarization plane is possible .
a faraday rotation is a magneto - optical phenomenon that rotates the polarization of light .
it occurs as an internal property of medium as well as under the external magnetic field . in both cases
the dielectric permittivity tensor of the system becomes anisotropic .
for example , in _ gaas _ crystal large faraday rotation @xcite origins because of the spin - orbit coupling .
faraday rotation is observed in astronomy .
there it is used for measurement of magnetic fields @xcite . in the past decade many experimental papers @xcite-@xcite have been devoted to the faraday rotation in disordered media . in refs .
@xcite attention was drawn to the fact , that a large enhancement of the faraday rotation can be obtained in nanomaterials incorporating several nanoparticles and their composites .
a garnet composite film ( mostly a bi - substituted yttrium iron garnet ( bi : yig ) ) incorporating gold nanoparticles or a nanoparticles solution with gold coated @xmath6 @xcite show a change in the sign of the faraday rotation at the wavelengths corresponding to the surface plasmon absorption peak of the gold nanoparticles . around the local surface plasmon resonance wavelengths a resonant transmittance attenuation and a large resonant enhancement of the faraday rotation with a narrow bandwidth
was obtained in ref @xcite . recently a large faraday rotation was observed @xcite in a ultrathin graphene film . the analogy with the hall effect
is revealed . the standard effective medium approximations ( maxwell - garnet and bruggeman theories ) @xcite describe the macroscopic properties of a medium using the average dielectric constant determined by the relative fractions of its components .
these theories show only qualitative agreement with the experimental data of refs.@xcite .
many of the questions that have been raised during the experiments are still waiting for answers .
for example , no corresponding analytical calculation has been available so far for a discrepancy in the bandwidth between the transmission attenuation and the resonant faraday rotation ( ref .
@xcite ) . of particular importance is the influence of the disorder , induced by the presence of the impurities , on the faraday angle and on several related quantities . in the present paper
we develop a theoretical approach for investigating the faraday rotation for transmitted and backscattered waves in three - dimensional disordered media .
we show that the maximum faraday rotation angle of the transmitted wave is achieved at the frequencies where the photon elastic mean free path is minimal . in the backscattered wave the maximally crossed diagrams contribution to
the faraday rotation angle is very important .
it leads to an ellipticity of the backscattered wave in the localized regime .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii we formulate the problem .
the coherent potential approximation is discussed in sec .
iii and appropriate contribution to the faraday angle is calculated . in sec .
iv we present result for the diffusional contribution to the faraday rotational angle .
diffusional and maximally crossed diagrams contributions are taken into account for kerr effect in sec .
v. obtained analytical results are compared with experimental data in sec .
finally , the main conclusions are summarized in sec .
the paper contains two appendices , which present some technical details useful for the understanding of diffusional and maximally crossed diagrams contributions to the kerr effect .
let us consider the incidence of a linearly polarized electromagnetic wave on the optically active medium , see fig.1 . .
after transmission through a slab the polarization vector rotates.,width=340 ] we assume that the incident field is polarized on @xmath7 , the plane of incidence is @xmath8 , wave vector is directed on @xmath9 . because of the scattering transmitted field contains all the directions of wave vector . in order to determine the faraday angle one should separate the coherent part that is the one directed on @xmath9 , see fig.1 .
faraday rotation angle is determined as follows @xmath10 where @xmath11 are the components of transmitted coherent wave and @xmath12 means averaging over the realizations of randomness .
the phases of electric field components are strongly fluctuating in contrary to intensities .
therefore for a weakly scattering medium one can approximately take @xmath13 maxwell equation for the electric field has the form @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the source term and the dielectric tensor is determined as follows @xmath16 here @xmath17 is the antisymmetric tensor , @xmath18 is the gyration vector directed on the magnetic field direction when external field is applied . in the opticaly active medium without external field @xmath19 and is parallel to the direction of photon propagation .
@xmath20 is the random part which is assumed gaussian distributed with @xmath21-correlation function @xmath22 in order to carry out averaging over the randomness it is convenient to express all the quantities through the green s functions @xmath23 as was mentioned , the faraday rotation angle in eqs .
( [ angle ] ) and ( [ inten ] ) is determined by the coherent intensity .
hence , to separate the coherent intensities let introduce the intensity tensor at observation point @xmath24 and in the direction of unit vector @xmath25 following @xcite @xmath26 using eq.([inttens ] ) the faraday angle , eq.([inten ] ) , can be represented in terms of a intensity tensor @xmath27 @xmath28 here @xmath29 is the unit vector on @xmath30 and @xmath31 is the thickness of the slab . because of the symmetry the intensities depend only on the @xmath30 coordinate .
averaged green s functions take into account the fact that the right - hand and the left - hand circular polarized lights see different refractive indexes in the medium @xcite @xmath32 where @xmath33 , @xmath34 is a unit vector on @xmath35 , @xmath36 is the photon elastic mean free path .
the superscripts r and a denote retarded and advanced green s functions , respectively .
faraday angle consists of two main contributions .
one comes from the coherent potential approximation and another from the diffusional scattering of photon .
coherent potential contribution reads @xmath37 where @xmath38 the source term @xmath39 is chosen in such a way that the coherent part of transmitted electric field for @xmath40 be equal @xmath41 using eqs.([avgreen ] ) and ( [ chpart ] ) , provided that @xmath42 , one finds @xmath43 substituting this expression into eq.([bare ] ) and eq.([cohap ] ) in the limit @xmath44 and @xmath42 , we obtain @xmath45 , \label{cohan}\ ] ] where @xmath46 .
it follows from eq.([cohan ] ) that coherent potential approximation contribution , under the conditions @xmath44 and @xmath42 , becomes inessential because contains strongly oscillating term @xmath47 when @xmath48 .
hence , any averaging over the wavelength of incident photon will make this contribution negligible .
therefore below we concentrate our attention on the diffusional contribution to the faraday rotation angle .
using eq.([inttens ] ) , we have @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the sum of ladder diagrams ) and the solid lines are the photon retarded and advanced averaged green s functions eq.([avgreen ] ) .
, width=340 ] which was found in innumerable papers , see for example , @xcite . we will calculate the intensity tensor in the limit @xmath51 .
therefore , it is enough to calculate the diffusion propagator for @xmath40 . the main contribution to the integrals in eq.([difcon ] ) gives the term containing the diffusion pole .
the corresponding mode has the form ( see for example , ref .
@xcite ) @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 here @xmath2 is the inelastic mean free path of a photon in the medium and it is assumed that @xmath55 .
fourier transforming eq.([difcon ] ) , substituting the expression @xmath56 into it , and using eq.([bare ] ) , one obtains @xmath57 where @xmath58 the integral over @xmath59 can be calculated exactly closing the integral contour in the complex @xmath59 plane in the upper half ( @xmath60 ) .
note that the contributions from the poles @xmath61 and @xmath62 in the sum over polarizations cancel each other in the limit @xmath51 and @xmath42 . substituting eq.([greenz ] ) into eq.([intens ] ) and subsequently calculating the integrals over @xmath59 and @xmath63 , we obtain @xmath64 in deriving this expression we assume that @xmath65 , however @xmath42 .
the quantity @xmath66 can be calculated in the same way as @xmath67 . in this case
the @xmath40 approximation can be used , because @xmath67 is already proportional to @xmath68 . substituting eq.([bare ] ) into eq.([intens ] ) , one has @xmath69 using the above calculated expressions for @xmath67 , @xmath66 and eq.([angten ] ) , we finally obtain the desired result for the faraday rotation angle with the diffusional contribution @xmath70 equation ( [ final ] ) with eq .
( [ diffcross ] ) ( see below ) represent the central results of this work .
@xmath71 presents the asymptotically exact ( @xmath72 , @xmath42 ) expression for the faraday rotation in 3d disordered systems . comparing the two formulae , @xmath73 and @xmath71
, we see that the latter oscillates less , due to the fact that @xmath51 in the argument of the @xmath74 function .
therefore , the diffusion contribution to the faraday rotation , eq.([final ] ) , will dominate compared to the coherent potential approximation contribution , eq.([cohan ] ) .
this is valid provided that diffusional scattering is realized in the disordered system .
we remind that eq.([final ] ) has been derived assuming that @xmath75 however @xmath76 is not necessarily small .
it is worth noticing that the ratio @xmath77 is the average number of scatterings of the photon in the medium .
if the thickness @xmath31 of a slab is thinner than the length @xmath78 then the diffusional trajectories are cut on the system size and the above mentioned number of scatterings becomes equal to @xmath79 ( see refs .
@xcite ) . in this particular case , eq.([final ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath80 taking into account that in the diffusional regime the transmission coefficient @xmath81 of a disordered slab is of order @xmath82 .
it follows from eqs.([final ] ) and ( [ final1 ] ) that the maximum of the faraday angle is achieved at the frequencies where the photon elastic mean free path @xmath3 is minimal . in the case of eq .
( [ final1 ] ) ( @xmath83 ) , it is obvious that the maximum of the faraday rotation corresponds to the minimum of the transmission coefficient and in its proximity .
this type of dependence was confirmed experimentally in refs .
however the faraday rotation peak will be steeper because of stronger dependence on @xmath84 ( see below for more details ) .
another pecularity of our result , eq.([final ] ) , is that it implies an oscillating dependence of the rotation on @xmath68 , that is on a magnetic field , or the medium s internal properties .
note that the non - monotonous dependence of the faraday rotation on the magnetic field is observed in ref.@xcite .
for completeness , we now turn to the discussion of the faraday rotation angle for the backscattered wave using the procedure outlined above . the main difference now is that one should take into account the contribution of the maximally - crossed diagrams ( ref .
@xcite ) in fig.2 , which goes beyond the ladder diagram approximation , ( i.e. , regular diffusion ) . another important point to mention also is that in the kerr effect the boundary conditions at @xmath85 are important . for a brief sketch of the derivation of the backscattering peak note , that the diffusion propagator @xmath86 should fulfill the boundary condition at @xmath85 .
therefore , instead of the former @xmath87 , we , based on the method of images , use a modified @xmath88 . here
@xmath89 is a two dimensional vector in the @xmath90 plane and we assume that the following inequalities are met : @xmath44 , @xmath42 and @xmath91 the details of the calculations of the backscattering rotation is given in appendices a and b. the final result ( @xmath92 , i.e. no absorption ) reads @xmath93 where @xmath94 are the diffusional and maximally crossed diagrams contribution to the faraday rotation angle of the backscattered light , respectively . note that maximally - crossed diagrams leads to a pure imaginary faraday angle which indicates the onset of ellipticity for the backscattered wave . as is seen from eq.([diffcross ] )
the diffusional contribution is dominant in the diffusion regime @xmath42 in contrary to the maximally crossed diagrams contribution which becomes relatively large in the localized regime @xmath95 . in this regime ,
@xmath95 , the diffusional and maximally crossed diagrams contributions are of the same order and maximum of rotation angle is achieved .
physically , such a behavior can be understood within the existing relation between the faraday rotation angle and the time spent by the light in a medium @xcite ( see below ) .
indeed , in the diffusive regime the backscattering time is larger for low scatterer concentration ( or for larger photon mean free path ) . with increasing the scatterer concentration ( the photon mean free path becomes smaller ) the backscattering time increases because of the localization effects ( or because of the ellipticity of the polarization of the reflected wave ) .
this transparent picture serves as a basis for qualitative understanding of asymptotic behavior of backscattered wave in two regimes .
thus , the onset of ellipticity in the backscattered wave can serve as a precursor of light weak localization . note , that in the limit @xmath96 the diffusional and maximally crossed diagrams contributions to the rotation angle of backscattering wave are very small ( see eqs .
( [ idfinal ] ) and ( [ maxcontr ] ) ) .
hence for the backscattered wave the maximal rotation is achieved for @xmath97 . in concluding this section ,
let us estimate the traversal time of an electromagnetic wave in 3d disordered media .
according to ref .
@xcite the interaction time in a slab is closely related to the faraday rotation .
hence , one might expect , that the traversal time , @xmath98 , of an electromagnetic wave through a 3d disordered slab will be larger compared with the time , @xmath99 , spent in a dielectric with open boundaries . following ref .
@xcite and expanding eq .
( [ final ] ) in powers of @xmath68 , and keeping linear terms only we get an estimated value for time @xmath100 thus , the disorder enhanced the traversal time @xmath98 by an additional factor @xmath77 , in comparison with a free light propagation time @xmath101 .
most of the experiments on faraday rotation in disordered media @xcite-@xcite are carried out with the films of thicknesses much less than the light wavelengths .
our approach can not be directly applied to these systems because the randomness in this case is nearly two - dimensional contrary to our @xmath102 randomness .
we will compare our results with the experimental data of the work ref .
@xcite , where the sample has @xmath102 randomness .
first let us estimate the dimensionless constant @xmath68 for a water noting that in ref .
@xcite nanoparticles are randomly embedded in the water .
it follows from ( [ greenz ] ) that @xmath103 and @xmath104 . @xmath105 and @xmath106 are dielectric constants and refraction indexes of right - hand and left - hand circularly polarized light at @xmath107 wavelength , respectively . the difference @xmath108 is related to the verdet constant @xmath109 : @xmath110 . taking @xmath111 , one has @xmath112 . for a water at @xmath113,@xmath114 and @xmath115 ,
see for example , @xcite .
therefore @xmath116 .
we see that for a water at @xmath111 , @xmath68 is extremely small and the limit @xmath72 in our theory is justified .
the elastic photon mean free path @xmath3 in a system of randomly embedded in a dielectric host medium of metallic spheres can be estimated as @xmath117 , where @xmath118 is the volume of a single sphere and @xmath119 is the volume fraction of spheres in the medium @xcite .
we take @xmath120 , where @xmath121 is the average size of particles coated with gold in an aggregate state and @xmath122 @xcite . substituting these values and @xmath113 into expression of @xmath3 ,
one gets @xmath123 .
now let us estimate the inelastic mean free path @xmath2 , which is defined as @xmath124 @xcite ( @xmath125 is the imaginary part of the maxwell - garnett effective dielectric constant and @xmath126 , @xmath127 are the real and imaginary parts of the dielectric constant of gold at incident wavelength @xmath113 , respectively ) . taking @xmath128 and @xmath129 , ref.@xcite , one has @xmath130 and it is easy to convince oneself that the conditions for photon diffusion @xmath131 are realized in the experiment @xcite . in this case
the additional large multiplier @xmath132 arises in the verdet constant calculated within the effective maxwell - garnett theory .
this additional factor could explain the discrepancy between the theoretical calculations and the experimental data , mentioned in ref .
@xcite . multiplying the verdet constant of water @xmath133 by @xmath132 and subtracting the water value , for the verdet constant of solution
, one gets @xmath134 which is in a very good agreement with the corresponding experimental value @xcite .
we have investigated the faraday rotation in a disordered medium . the rotation angle is calculated to leading order of parameters @xmath135 , @xmath136 .
it is shown that in the diffusive regime faraday rotation is proportional to the ratio of the inelastic mean free path @xmath2 to the mean free path @xmath3 , that is to the average number of photon scatterings in the medium .
for the faraday angle the magnetic field oscillating dependence is predicted . if the thickness @xmath31 of a slab is thinner than the length @xmath78 then the faraday rotation is inverse proportional to the square of the transmission coefficient .
the maximum rotation is achieved at frequencies where the photon elastic mean free path is minimal .
we have calculated the faraday rotation of backscattered waves .
maximally - crossed diagrams lead to an ellipticity of backscattered wave . in the localized regime
@xmath95 the diffusional and maximally crossed diagrams contributions eq.([diffcross ] ) to the rotation angle are of the same order . therefore appearing of ellipticity in the backscattered wave
can serve as a precursor of a weak localization of the light . in the backscattered wave maximal rotation
is achieved for @xmath137 . beyond this critical value rotation angle
rapidly disappears .
the traversal time of an electromagnetic wave through the slab is estimated in a diffusive regime .
comparison with the experimental data is carried out . to summarize , although the main result for faraday rotation , eq .
( [ final ] ) , is approximate , it nevertheless predicts correctly many of the peculiar features of most experimental results @xcite-@xcite , discussed in this paper .
* acknowledgments .
* we are grateful to t. meyer , a. akopian and o. del barco for helpful comments and discussions .
v.g . acknowledges partial support by feder and the spanish dgi under project no .
fis2010 - 16430 .
we derive first the diffusional contribution to the kerr effect .
i.e. , @xmath138 of eq .
( [ diffcross ] ) . to do this ,
let us note that the diffusional contribution to the intensity tensor , see fig.2 , takes the form @xmath139 where @xmath140 here @xmath89 is the projection of @xmath141 in the @xmath90 plane .
@xmath142 is determined by three dimensional fourier transform of eq.([difprop ] ) and the coherent field @xmath143 is determined by eq.([chpart ] ) .
going through fourier transforms in eq.([ker ] ) , one gets @xmath144 where @xmath145 and @xmath146 here we assume that @xmath147 . substituting eqs.([difprop ] ) and ( [ image ] ) into eq.([pzet ] ) , we obtain @xmath148 .
\label{furimage}\ ] ] note that the expression ( [ furimage ] ) was derived ignoring the absorption and assuming that @xmath92 . substituting eq.([furimage ] ) into eq.([ikz ] ) , one has @xmath149 note , that in order to arrive to eq .
( [ finikz ] ) , we cut the diverging integral on the upper limit at the system thickness @xmath31 . for the backscattered direction @xmath150 and for @xmath151 the intensity @xmath152 , eq.([fur ] ) , can be written in the form @xmath153 substituting the green s functions , eq.([avgreen ] ) , into eq.([intenback ] ) and keeping only linear terms on @xmath59 , one has @xmath154 where @xmath155 we will integrate eq.([iplusge ] ) over @xmath59 closing integral contour in the bottom half of complex plane where the function @xmath156 has no poles . the contributions to the integral come from the poles @xmath157 and @xmath158 . using eqs.([finikz ] ) and ( [ ige ] ) and taking integral over @xmath59 in the limit @xmath51 , we find @xmath159\left[(q^2-k_0 ^ 2(1+g))^2+k_0 ^ 2/l^2\right]}+\nonumber\\ & + \frac{24g\gamma k_0 ^ 3}{l}\int_0^{\infty}\frac{q^2dq}{\left[(q^2-k_0 ^ 2(1-g))^2 + 4k_0 ^
2/l^2\right]\left[(q^2-k_0 ^ 2(1+g))^2 + 4k_0 ^ 2/l^2\right]}. \label{idfin}\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking in eq.([idfin ] ) the remaining integrals over @xmath63 in the limit @xmath42 we finally obtain @xmath160 in the final step using eq.([angten ] ) and dividing @xmath161 by backscattered intensity at @xmath40 , @xmath162 @xcite , we arrive at @xmath163 of eq .
( [ diffcross ] ) in the limit @xmath65 .
in this section we derive the maximally crossed diagrams contribution to the kerr effect .
i.e. , @xmath164 of eq .
( [ diffcross ] ) . to this end , let us represent the maximally crossed diagrams contribution , see fig.2 , to the intensity tensor in the form @xmath165 it follows from the symmetry , see fig.2 , that @xmath166 note that throughout the paper we consider the maximally crossed and diffusion propagators @xmath167 at @xmath40 .
the reason is that in the weak scattering limit @xmath42 the main contribution gives the pole term which is unaffected by faraday rotation or optical activity @xcite . using eqs.([difmod ] ) and ( [ symm ] ) , one has from eq.([max ] ) @xmath168 going over to the two and three dimensional fourier transforms in eq.([max2 ] ) and using eq.([chpart ] ) , we have @xmath169 . \label{maxfur}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we remind that @xmath170 is the projection of the unit vector @xmath25 on the @xmath90 plane . in the backscattered direction @xmath171 and @xmath150 . integrating the equation ( [ maxfur ] ) consequentially over @xmath172 and @xmath173
, we obtain @xmath174 where @xmath175 substituting eqs .
( [ avgreen ] ) and ( [ fpz ] ) into eq.([aftint ] ) , one has @xmath176 where @xmath177 and @xmath178 the square roots from the complex numbers are implied in the sense of arithmetic root . in the next step
we expand these roots on @xmath68 and @xmath136 up to the linear terms @xmath179 and @xmath180 we calculate the integral over @xmath181 closing the integral contour in the bottom half of a complex plane .
the contribution for @xmath182 comes from the residues of the following two poles @xmath183 the result reads @xmath184 eq.([i1geintq ] ) was derived taking into account the fact , that the main contribution to the integral on @xmath68 gives the values that are close to @xmath185 . calculating the integral eq.([i1geintq ] ) in the pole approximation which is justified provided that @xmath42 , one has @xmath186
correspondingly @xmath187 in analogous manner one can show that @xmath188 . therefore using eqs.([ige ] ) and ( [ i1gemin ] ) , one finds @xmath189 similarly to what was done in appendix a , where the @xmath163 was calculated , one readily sees that dividing @xmath190 by backscattered intensity at @xmath40 , @xmath162 @xcite yields @xmath191 of eq .
( [ diffcross ] ) in the limit @xmath65 .
p. w. anderson , phys . rev .
* 109 * , 1493 ( 1958 ) .
m.c.w . van rosum and th.m .
nieuwenhuizen , rev . of mod .
physics * 71*,313,(1999 ) . y.kuga and a.ishimaru , j.opt.soc.am .
a , * 1 * , 831,(1984 ) .
vanalbada and a.lagendijk , phys .
* 55 * , 2692,(1985 ) .
p.e.wolf and g.maret , phys .
lett . * 55 * , 2696,(1985 ) .
m. kaveh , m. rosenbluh , i. edrei , and i. freund , phys .
. lett . * 57 * , 2049,(1986 ) .
s. gevorkian , and yu .
e. lozovik , physica scripta .
* 56 * , 208 , ( 1997 ) matteo burresi , vivekananthan radhalakshmi , romolo savo , jacopo bertolotti , kevin vynck and diedrik s.wiersma * 108*,110604,(2012 ) .
michael j. stephen and gabriel cwilich , phys .
b * 34*,7564,(1986 ) .
f.c . mackintosh and sajeev john , phys .
b * 37 * , 1884 , ( 1988 ) .
e.prati , j. of electr .
appl.*17 , 8 * , 1177,(2003 ) .
malcolm longair , high energy astrophysics , cambridge university press,(1992 ) .
s.tomita , t. kato , s.tsunashima , s. iwata , m. fujii , s .
hayashi , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 167402,(2006 ) .
r.fujikawa , a.v.baryshev , j.kim , h. uchida , m. inoue , j. appl . phys . * 103*,07d301,(2008 ) .
h.uchida , y.masuda , r.fujikawa , a.v.baryshev , m.inoue , journal of mag . and magnetic materials * 321*,843,(2009 ) .
h. uchida , y. mazutani , y. nakai , a.a .
fedyanin , and m. inoue , j. phys .
d : appl . phys . * 44 * 064014 ( 2011 ) s. tkachuk , g. lang , c. kraft , o. rabin and i. mayergoyz , journal of applied physics , * 109 * , 07b717,(2011 ) .
raj kumar dani , hongwang wang , stefan h.bossman , gary wysh and viktor chikan , the journal of chem.phys . , * 135 * , 224502 , ( 2011 ) .
iris grassee , julien levallois , andrew l. walker , marus ostler , aaron bostwick , eli rotenberg , thomas seyller , dirk van der maret and alexey kuzmenko , nature physics , * 7 * , 48,(2011 ) . tuck c.choy , effective medium theory .
oxford : clarendon press ( 1999 ) .
p. w.anderson , philosophical magazine b , * 52 * , 505 , ( 1985 ) .
s. gevorkian , phys .
e * 57 * , 2338 ( 1998 ) .
j.s.langer and t.neal , phys .
* 16 * , 984,(1965 ) .
v. gasparian , m. ortuo , j. ruiz , e. cuevas , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 2312 ( 1995 ) . v. gasparian , t. christen , and m. bttiker , phys .
a * 54 * , 4022 ( 1996 ) .
aloke jain , jayant kumar , fumin zhou , lian li , sukant tripathy , am.j.phys,*67*(8),714,(1999 ) .
sajeev john , phys .
b , * 31 * , 304,(1985 ) .
k. arya , z.b .
su and joseph l. birman , phys .
, * 57*,2725,(1986 ) .
p.b.johnson and r.w.chersty , phys . rev .
b , * 6 * , 4370,(1972 ) . | the faraday rotation angle @xmath0 is calculated in a diffusive regime in a three dimensional disordered slab .
it is shown that @xmath1 is ( i ) an oscillating function of the magnetic field or the medium s internal properties , and ( ii ) proportional to the ratio of the inelastic mean free path @xmath2 to the mean free path @xmath3 , that is to the average number of photon scatterings .
the maximum rotation is achieved at frequencies when the photon s elastic mean free path is minimal .
we have obtained the rotation angle of polar backscattered light taking into account the maximally crossed diagrams .
the latter leads to an ellipticity in the backscattered wave that can serve as precursor of weak localization .
the critical strength of magnetic field @xmath4 beyond which rotation in backscattered wave disappears .
the traversal time of an electromagnetic wave through the slab is estimated in a diffusive regime .
the disorder enhanced the traversal time by an additional factor @xmath5 , in comparison with a free light propagation time .
comparison with the experimental data is carried out . |
over the last five years the rotation curves of low surface brightness ( lsb ) galaxies and the constraints they impose on cosmological theories have received much attention in the literature .
an lsb galaxy is usually defined as a disk galaxy with an extrapolated central disk surface brightness @xmath1 mag arcsec@xmath2 fainter than the typical value for `` normal '' high surface brightness ( hsb ) spiral galaxies @xcite .
colors , metallicities , gas - fractions , and extensive population synthesis modelling all support the idea that lsb galaxies are unevolved galaxies with low ( current and past ) star formation rates ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
see @xcite for a review .
the observation that lsb and hsb galaxies follow the same tully - fisher ( tf ) relation requires ( in the conventional picture ) that lsb galaxies are dominated by dark matter ( dm ) @xcite . for reasonable stellar mass - to - light ratios @xmath3 low surface brightness implies low stellar density . yet , the extended , low surface density stellar disks can not be the major contributors to the dynamics in lsb galaxies , as no shift in the zero - point of the tf relation with surface brightness is observed .
this contrasts with the dominance of the stellar population in hsb galaxies of similar luminosity .
the modest @xmath3 values as implied by the blue colors and the ( baryonic ) tf relation , together with the diffuseness of the stellar disks make analyses of the dm distribution in lsb galaxies less ambiguous than in hsb galaxies where the stellar component can be significant even for fairly low @xmath3 values .
lsb galaxies are therefore ideal laboratories for measuring the distribution of dark matter for comparison with predictions of theories of galaxy formation .
for example , one of the results of numerical cold dark matter ( cdm ) simulations is a so - called `` universal halo mass density profile '' @xcite , commonly known as a `` nfw profile . ''
nfw ( and all cdm ) mass density profiles are characterized by steep central cusps .
this is in contrast with the other commonly used `` classic '' pseudo - isothermal sphere halo model which is characterized by a constant density core .
the parameters of the nfw mass density distribution are related to the mass of the halo and the density of the universe at the time of collapse and are therefore set by the cosmology . as these parameters can be determined from observations ,
this opens the possibility of testing the nfw cdm model as well its underlying assumptions . a first analysis of lsb galaxy hi rotation curves by @xcite indicated that they did not rise as steeply as their hsb counterparts of similar luminosity , contrary to cdm predictions .
the mass distribution in lsb galaxies is more extended and of lower density than in hsb galaxies @xcite .
other results also indicate that the steep rotation curves implied by cdm are hard to reconcile with the observed shallow rotation curves of dwarf galaxies @xcite .
to explain this discrepancy the possibility of redistribution of the ( cuspy ) dm due to violent star - formation ( thus creating the observed cores ) was sometimes raised , but this has been shown to be inconsistent with other observational data @xcite .
@xcite argued that the shapes of rotation curves of lsb galaxies were inconsistent with those predicted by the nfw prescription .
this could not be explained by the effects of star formation as the larger masses of lsb galaxies would require large bursts in order to redistribute matter on large scales .
their quiescent evolutionary history argues strongly against this @xcite . this comparison with the cdm model is often dismissed because of the limited resolution of the observed hi curves .
the early hi lsb rotation curves were obtained using the vla and wsrt radio synthesis telescopes .
the relatively large beams of these instruments resulted in rotation curves with only a limited resolution .
@xcite did however show that for the best resolved cases the effects of beam smearing were not strong enough to explain the observed shallow curve as simply the result of a steep nfw model curve affected by beam - smearing .
similar results were found for more fashionable cosmologies , such as @xmath0cdm ( @xmath4 ) , though with smaller discrepancies .
even so , the theoretical debate now seems to have settled on halos with cusps even steeper than nfw halos @xcite , thus worsening the possible conflict between the data and the simulations . from the observational point of view
the easiest and least ambigous way to test the reality of these discrepancies is to measure high - resolution rotation curves .
optical h@xmath5 rotation curves of five lsb galaxies from the sample of @xcite ( bmh ) were presented in @xcite ( smt ) . though smt found that for two of the five galaxies the inner slopes of the rotation curves were steeper than derived from the hi observations , this difference does not affect the bmh conclusion that lsb rotation curves have shallower slopes than hsb rotation curves of similar amplitude .
because of these steeper slopes , smt derive higher maximum - disk @xmath3 values ( in some cases @xmath6 ) , strengthening one of the conclusions from @xcite that the maximum @xmath3values in lsb galaxies are too large to be accommodated by reasonable star formation histories and initial mass functions .
such high values are inconsistent with the existence of a baryonic tf - relation @xcite .
a different approach was taken by @xcite .
they attempted to apply a rigorous correction for beamsmearing to the bmh hi data , and thus to derive the true `` infinite resolution '' rotation curve .
they conclude that the data are not of high enough resolution to accept or reject the nfw hypothesis with any significance . however , as they use a modified nfw profile with the inner slope of the mass - density distribution as an ( additional ) free parameter , it is not clear how significant this conclusion is .
the usual 3-parameter rotation curve fits are already under - constrained ; adding another parameter does not improve the significance of the results .
furthermore , in some cases they find such low values for the inner slope that their nfw - halos effectively become core - dominated .
these halos do of course fit the data , but do not occur in cdm simulations .
the general picture as derived from early observations of rotation curves of lsb galaxies therefore still holds : lsb galaxies are unevolved , low density galaxies , dominated by dm .
their rotation curves have shallower slopes than those of hsb galaxies of similar amplitude , and the shape of the best - resolved lsb curves are not necessarily consistent with the nfw rotation curve shapes . in this paper
we present an analysis of high - resolution high - quality hybrid h@xmath5/hi rotation curves of a sample of 30 lsb galaxies . of this sample
26 curves were taken from the large sample of 50 lsb galaxies presented in mcgaugh , rubin & de blok ( 2001 ) ( herafter paper i ) . in that paper an extensive description is given of the data , the sample and reduction method .
we also refer to that paper for a comparison of the new h@xmath5 data with the bmh hi curves .
we also re - analyse the data for an additional 5 curves taken from @xcite . in this paper
we derive mass models under various assumptions for @xmath3 and fit these models both with nfw halos and pseudo - isothermal halos .
a similar analysis for a different set of rotation curves of dwarf and lsb galaxies is given in de blok & bosma ( 2001 ) .
in section 2 we discuss the sample , and discuss the derivation of the rotation curves .
we also show internal and external comparisons of the data and discuss possible systematics . in section 3
we discuss the various mass models .
section 4 contains the results of the model fitting .
section 5 discusses the implications for the various halo models . in section 6
we turn our attention to the maximum disk and a summary is given in section 7 .
when using absolute distances we have used a hubble constant @xmath7 km s@xmath8 mpc@xmath8 .
the data and reduction methods have been extensively described in paper i. in summary , we use long - slit major axis spectra taken with the 4-m telescope at kitt peak in june 1999 and february 2000 and the 100@xmath9 telescope at las campanas in november 1998 .
velocities were derived from the intensity weighted centroid of the h@xmath5 and [ nii ] lines . as the aim of this excercise is to derive mass models which can yield significant constraints on the distribution of dm we select only the 26 high quality galaxies from paper i. we split this high - quality sample in two sub - samples .
sample i contains lsb galaxies from bmh and @xcite for which a full set of photometry and hi data is available . in sample
i we also include the five galaxies presented in smt . for these galaxies hi and optical photometry
are taken from bmh .
tables [ fgalsample ] and [ esosample ] contain a full list of the galaxies analysed here , along with some of their global parameters .
sample ii consists of eso - lv and ugc lsb galaxies , for which an optical rotation curve is available but no optical or hi photometry . for the galaxies in sample i , hi observations are available which often extend to larger radii than the h@xmath5 data .
to make the best use of both types of data , we have constructed hybrid rotation curves .
these consist of the h@xmath5 data over the range of radii where available , and 21-cm data to define the outermost points .
no attempt has been made to `` average '' the different types of data : h@xmath5 is given precedence over the range of radii where it is available .
one of the main assumptions made when deriving mass models from rotation curves is that the gas and stars trace circular orbits in an axisymmetric potential .
though the shape of the optical rotation curves in paper i is well - defined , the scatter between individual datapoints means we can not simply use the raw rotation curves to estimate the radial run of the gravitational potential . for this one needs a smooth curve which retains real small - scale details , but without the observational scatter .
the method most often used to produce these smooth curves is to fit splines to the data .
here we use have used a robust version of this procedure ( local regression , see loader 1999 ) .
the smooth curves were rebinned to a bin width of 2@xmath9 .
the error bars in the rebinned data points consist of two components : one due to observational errors caused by the measurement uncertainties in the individual raw datapoints ( for this we use the average weighted measurement error in each bin ) , and an additional component caused by differences between approaching and receding sides and non - circular motions ( which we define as the difference between the weighted mean raw velocity and the velocity implied by the spline fit at that radius ) . for the final error estimate
these two uncertainties were added quadratically .
for some high s / n data points the error bars become unrealistically small ( sometimes less than 1 km s@xmath8 ) .
this has no physical significance and simply tells us that the profile centroids were well - determined .
these small error bars can however easily dominate any model fit and can severely bias @xmath10 values or goodness - of - fit parameters .
for this reason , and as the observational and physical uncertainties ( slit position , streaming motions ) make it difficult to determine a physically meaningful rotation velocity with an accuracy of more than a few km s@xmath8 , we have imposed a minimum error on each point of 4 km s@xmath8 ( before inclination correction ) . the curves were corrected for inclination using the values given in tables [ fgalsample ] and [ esosample ] . the end result is a smooth representation of the data , which is reproducible and as objective as possible , to use as input for the mass models .
figure [ smoraw ] show overlays of both the raw hybrid curves and the smooth versions .
it is easy to verify that no systematic differences in slope or shape have been introduced .
the error bars in the smooth curves are also a good representation of the uncertainties in the underlying raw data .
table [ electable ] contains the hybrid smooth rotation curves . for each galaxy
we list the radii in arcsec , as well as in kpc , together with the observed rotation velocities and the uncertainties in these values .
also included are the rotation curves for the gas component ( already included is the factor 1.4 mass scaling for he ) , the disk component ( values listed assume @xmath11 ) , and where applicable the bulge component ( also for @xmath11 .
as noted above , we have included the five lsb galaxies presented in smt in our sample i. as smt show their raw data and derived smooth curves , we can compare both sets of smooth rotation curves to investigate possible systematics in our respective methods .
this is done in fig .
[ swcomp ] .
it is clear that the correspondence between both velocities and errorbars is good and the differences are minor . in most cases ( f568 - 1 , f568-v1 and f574 - 1 ) both sets agree at ( better than ) the 1@xmath12 level .
small remaining differences are usually caused by a slightly different estimate of the velocities in sparsely sampled parts ( f563-v2 and f568 - 3 ) .
the smt curve for f563-v2 ( fig .
[ swcomp ] , top - left ) is slightly higher than our curve in the inner parts , but falls below ours in the outer parts .
the sparseness of optical data points in the outer parts and different interpretations of the continuity between hi and optical data are probably the main cause of this difference . for f568 - 3 ( fig .
[ swcomp ] , bottom ) we find a small ( @xmath13 ) systematic difference between both smooth curves .
this galaxy has been measured independently by smt and by us ( paper i ) .
these raw data sets agree in detail , and the difference must therefore be due to a slightly different interpretation of the sparse raw data . in summary , the smooth curves we present here give a good and reproducable representation of the data .
in order to find the signature of the dark halo one needs to model the observed rotation curve using a number of separate dynamical components , described below . to model the stellar disk , the @xmath14-band photometry presented in @xcite was used .
the rotation curve of the disk was computed following @xcite and @xcite .
the disk was assumed to have a vertical sech@xmath15 distribution with a scale height @xmath16 @xcite .
the rotation curves of the stellar component were resampled at the same radii as the smooth curves .
we assume @xmath3 is constant with radius .
while one expects some modest variation in @xmath17 with radius @xcite , the color gradients in lsb galaxies tend to be small , so this effect is not likely to be significant .
the hi surface density profiles presented in bmh and @xcite were used .
they were scaled by a factor of 1.4 to take the contribution of helium and metals into account .
their rotation curve was derived assuming the gas was distributed in a thin disk .
the gas rotation curves were resampled at the radii of the smooth observed rotation curve .
the dark halo component differs from the previous two in that we are interested in parametrizing this component assuming some fiducial model .
the choice of this model is the crux of most of the dm analyses in the literature , and many models exist .
these can be broadly distinguished in two groups : halo models with a core , and halo models with a cusp .
an example of the first category is the pseudo - isothermal halo , an example of the latter the cdm nfw halo . as one of the goals of this paper is to assess the relevance of either category to the high - resolution lsb galaxy rotation curves , we will present models derived using both models .
we do realize there are many intermediate models described in the literature that probably can fit our data equally well .
however , our goal here is simply to see where the data lead us : is there a preference for models with a core or with a cusp ?
we now describe the details of both models .
the spherical pseudo - isothermal halo has a density profile @xmath18^{-1},\ ] ] where @xmath19 is the central density of the halo , and @xmath20 the core radius of the halo .
the corresponding rotation curve is given by @xmath21 } .\ ] ] the asymptotic velocity of the halo , @xmath22 , is given by @xmath23 to characterize this halo only two of the three parameters @xmath24 are needed , as equation ( 3 ) determines the value of the third parameter .
the nfw mass density distribution takes the form @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the characteristic radius of the halo and @xmath27 is related to the density of the universe at the time of collapse .
this mass distribution gives rise to a halo rotation curve @xmath28}\right]^{1/2},\ ] ] where @xmath29 .
it is characterized by a concentration parameter @xmath30 and a radius @xmath31 .
these are directly related to @xmath26 and @xmath27 , but are used instead as they are a convenient way to parametrize the rotation curve .
the radius @xmath31 is the radius where the density contrast exceeds 200 , roughly the virial radius @xcite .
the characteristic velocity @xmath32 of the halo is defined in the same way as @xmath31 .
these parameters are not independent and are set by the cosmology .
one of largest uncertainties in any mass model is the value of @xmath3 .
though broad trends in @xmath3 have been measured and modelled ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the precise value for an individual galaxy is not well known , and depends on extinction , star formation history , initial mass function , etc .
rotation curve fitting is a problem with too many free parameters @xcite and some assumptions regarding @xmath3 must be made .
we therefore present disk - halo decompositions using four different assumptions for @xmath17 for the galaxies in sample i. for the galaxies in sample ii only the minimum - disk model is presented . * minimum disk . *
this model assumes that the observed rotation curve is due entirely to dm .
this gives an upper limit on how concentrated the dark mass component can actually be and is the version of minimum disk preferred in the cdm literature .
* minimum disk + gas . *
the contribution of the atomic gas ( hi and he ) is taken into account , but @xmath3 is assumed to be zero .
this is the classical definition of minimum disk as used in the hi rotation curve literature .
* constant @xmath3 .
* here @xmath3 is set equal to a constant value based on an initial mass function and a star formation history appropriate for lsb galaxies . for the range in color @xmath33 which lsb galaxies normally exhibit
@xcite a value @xmath34 is a good estimate .
for example , using the @xcite model with constant star formation rate and salpeter imf , we find that @xmath35 corresponds to @xmath36 . the pegase2 model ( rocca - volmerange , priv .
comm . ) gives a value @xmath37 , whereas the model by @xcite yields @xmath38 .
the models by @xcite give values around @xmath39 .
the value @xmath40 is thus actually at the `` light - weight '' end of the plausible range , but this was deliberately chosen in order to give maximum opportunity for the cuspy nfw models to fit the data .
we realize that the values derived here should not be regarded as definitive : changes in the imf model used or different estimates for internal extinction can lead to different values .
however , here we attempt to derive a conservative estimate for @xmath3 based on the observed properties of the stellar population .
further ( upward ) refinement of the @xmath17 value is thus more likely to cause more problems for nfw fits .
* maximum disk .
* the rotation curve of the stellar component is scaled to the maximum value allowed by the ( smooth ) rotation curve , but with the restriction that the dm density is required to be positive at all radii ( thus avoiding a so - called `` hollow halo '' ) @xcite . because of the different dm distributions that we test ( core and cusp ) this can ocassionally lead to maximum disk values that differ slightly for each of the two models .
a more extensive description is given in 6 .
each of the rotation curves was fitted using the gipsy task rotmas .
the program determines the best - fitting combination of @xmath20 and @xmath22 ( for the pseudo - isothermal halo ) or @xmath41 and @xmath32 ( for the nfw halo ) , using a least squares fitting routine .
we assigned weights to the data points inversely proportional to the square of their uncertainty .
additional checks were made with other fitting programs to check the results of the fits ( discussed in sect .
4.1 below ) .
we also refitted the smooth rotation curves presented in smt and were able to reproduce the numbers given in their table 2 .
tables [ nfwtable ] and [ nfwesotable ] give the results of the model fitting using the nfw halo model .
tables [ isotable ] and [ isoesotable ] show the results for the pseudo - isothermal halo .
figure [ nfwiso ] presents the results of the nfw halo and pseudo - isothermal halo mass modelling for each galaxy side - by - side .
the two leftmost columns show the results for nfw halo fitting .
the two rightmost columns show the pseudo - isothermal halo fitting results .
the first and third columns show the best - fitting models .
the rotation curves of the gas are shown as dotted lines , those of the stellar disk component as short - dashed lines . in two cases ( u6614 and f571 - 8 ) a significant bulge was present
which was modelled separately ; this is shown as the dot - dashed line ( see also section 4.3 ) .
the resulting halo rotation curve is shown as the long - dashed line .
the final total model curve is drawn as the full line . in each of the model panels we also give the reduced @xmath10 of the fit and the chance @xmath42 that the data and the model could result from the same parent distribution .
this probability was derived using a simple @xmath10 test ; it is an indicator for the compatibility of the data and the model chosen to describe it .
values @xmath43 indicate that the data and the model are a good match .
values @xmath44 indicate that the model is incompatible with the data , and that better models can be found .
we show two best - fitting values .
one as found by the linear fit of the gipsy rotmas task ( indicated as a `` plus''-cross ( + ) ) , and one found by finding the minimum in the plotted logarithmic parameter space ( indicated by a `` times''-cross @xmath45 ) .
these two are identical , except when extreme parameter values occur ( usually during maximum disk fits ) and numerical precision of the fitting routine starts to play a role .
this effect is visible in the bottom - right corners of the nfw contour plots , where the very large values of @xmath32 in combination with the small values of @xmath41 cause increasingly ragged contours .
a large difference between these two best values therefore indicates that the fit should not be regarded as definitive .
indeed , in a number of these cases ( indicated in the tables as italic numbers ) the fitting routine was unable to determine a valid solution , and an indicative value had to be chosen by hand .
this happened mostly with the nfw models .
one of the reasons for this is that the inner parts of the rotation curves can be well described by @xmath46 , whereas the nfw model has the form @xmath47 . to accommodate the model , the fit tries to stretch out the nfw curve ( resulting in small @xmath41 and high @xmath32 ) in order to make it _ look _ linear .
the second and fourth columns of panels in fig .
[ nfwiso ] show the 1@xmath12 ( thick contour ) and @xmath48 ( thin contours ) probability contours of the halo parameters in logarithmic space .
the reason for choosing a logarithmic representation is that the @xmath10 distributions for the nfw halo parameters often show extended tails towards very small @xmath41 and/or large @xmath32 . for comparison ,
[ linchi2 ] shows a representative example of the @xmath12-contours for the minimum disk model of f583 - 4 plotted in linear @xmath41-@xmath32 space .
it is important to realize that the @xmath12 contours are plotted _ with respect to the minimum @xmath10_. that is , existence of a narrow distribution only means that the minimum @xmath10 is well defined .
it does _ not _ imply that the fit is good in an absolute sense .
for that one needs to refer to the value of the reduced @xmath10 itself or the probability @xmath42 that the data and model are compatible .
there are many cases where the nfw model is not a good fit , making it difficult to plot absolute likelihood contours .
finally , in the nfw contour plots in the second column we show the range of @xmath41 and @xmath32 values for the currently popular @xmath0cdm cosmology as derived from numerical models @xcite ( see 5.3 ) .
the cross - hatched and single hatched grey areas shows the expected 1@xmath12 and 2@xmath12 logarithmic scatter in @xmath41 ( where @xmath49 ) as found in numerical models by @xcite .
independent simulations by @xcite find a much smaller logarithmic scatter of @xmath50 .
the latter do of course put much stronger constraints on the nfw results .
for the sake of clarity , however , and to give the nfw model as much chance as possible we adopt the larger estimate of the scatter in @xmath41 of @xcite . for the pseudo - isothermal halo
we show contours of constant central density @xmath19 .
the contours represent from top to bottom @xmath51 0.1 ( dotted ) , 1 ( dashed ) , 10 , 100 , 1000 ( dotted ) @xmath52 pc@xmath53 . to investigate how stable the derived halo parameters are with respect to the precise definition of the errorbars
, we have re - derived the models assigning uniform and equal weights to all data points .
though we do not list the latter values here , we show in fig .
[ compweightunif ] a comparison between the two sets of parameters .
it is clear that these agree well , showing that the results presented here are robust against the precise definition of the errorbars .
has the procedure used to derive the smooth rotation curves affected some of the model results ?
we established in sect .
2.4 that this procedure introduced no systematic differences between the smooth curves and the raw data . here
we test this again by checking whether the smooth curves give the same fit results as the raw data . as the nfw model is more sensitive to changes in the inner slope than the pseudo - isothermal model we will use the former in our checks .
we first fit nfw minimum disk models to the smooth and the raw curve of f583 - 1 , as a representation of the data from paper i. both fits are presented in fig
. [ f5831comp ] , where we have imposed a minimum error of 4 km s@xmath8 on the raw data to make the errorbars consistent with the smooth curve .
it is clear that the two fits are identical within the errorbars .
similar results are obtained using other curves from paper i. as a second test we evaluate the smt data . we have fitted several minimum disk nfw models to each of the smt galaxies .
we have fitted the smt raw data , the smooth curve presented in smt , and our smooth curve derived from the raw smt data .
these fits were done independently by two of us using independent fit codes on the smoothed ( db ) and unsmoothed ( mcg ) data .
table [ comptable ] lists the derived parameter values . for comparison
, we also list the results for our own independent observation of f568 - 3 from paper i. in fig .
[ nfwswaters ] we compare the @xmath41 values derived for each galaxy . we see that the galaxies for which our smooth curves and the ones presented in smt agree , also have similar model parameters , which agree with those derived from the raw data ( f574 - 1 and f568-v1 ) . in the other three cases ( f563-v2 , f568 - 1 , f568 - 3 ) the @xmath41-values derived from our version of the smooth curves agree with those derived from the raw data , whereas the smt @xmath41-values are higher .
it is important to keep in mind that even though the formal fit values show a large discrepancy , the rotation curves themselves only show very subtle differences ( fig . [ swcomp ] ) .
this illustrates the importance of having high - accuracy rotation curves of a large sample . in the following we only consider our smooth versions of the smt data . in summary , we believe that the results from our smooth curves are not systematically different from the raw data . as stated before , we prefer to use the smooth curves as these are more evenly sampled , and prevent the occurence of imaginary halo masses which can arise when the occasional ( raw ) data point happens to scatter below the rotation velocity of the disk alone .
* f563 - 1 * for this galaxy independent observations are available from de blok & bosma ( 2001 ) .
see paper i for a comparison .
note that the observed curve differs significantly from the `` beam - smearing corrected '' model presented in @xcite .
the model presented there shows an almost flat rotation curve over most of the radial range , which clearly disagrees with the new data .
beam - smearing corrections are not infallible .
* f563-v2 * this is our version of one of the smt curves .
this curve does significantly worse at fitting nfw than a pseudo - isothermal halo .
the systematics seen here are typical for many of the nfw fits : the inner parts are overestimated ; the model then underestimates the middle parts , and shoots up again in the outer parts .
for this galaxy no @xmath14-band photometry is available and we have used @xmath54 band photometry from @xcite .
assuming @xmath55 , which is the typical color for an lsb , this yields a value for the constant @xmath17 case of @xmath56 .
the maximum disk nfw model fits significantly better than the other nfw models .
it is however not compatible with cosmological predictions from the numerical models .
* f568 - 1 * this is another of the curves presented in smt .
the systematics of overestimating the inner part , underestimating the middle , and overestimating the outer velocities again are also present here .
again maximum disk is the best of the nfw models , which is another way of saying that the shapes of the ( inner ) rotation curves are more like that expected for the stars ( albeit with the wrong @xmath17 ) .
* f568 - 3 * this is a well determined curve , for which there are several consistent independent measurements ( see paper i ) .
* f571 - 8 * this is the only edge - on galaxy in sample i , so we are concerned about optical depth and projection effects in the optical data .
( the hi data are not used for this galaxy . ) these effects could cause us to measure the rotation velocity at a ring where the optical depth becomes unity .
recently , @xcite have used radiative transfer models to investigate optical depth effects on rotation curves in edge - on lsb galaxies , and they conclude that these effect are likely to be small due to the low dust content in lsb galaxies .
@xcite , in a comparison of the optical and hi curves of the edge - on galaxy n100 , also finds that late - type galaxies tend to be transparant , even when seen edge - on .
nevertheless , we can not exclude the possibility that the shape of the optical curve is affected .
if this is so then _ in this case _ the mass model will change . for the constant @xmath3 and maximum disk cases
we have added an exponential bulge with @xmath57 .
see bmh for a description of the bulge - disk decomposition .
* f574 - 1 * another smt curve .
while the pseudo - isothermal halo fits for this galaxy are good , the nfw fits show the by now familiar discrepancy : too steep in the inner part , underestimating the middle , and rising too quickly in the outer parts .
maximum disk nfw provides a good fit , albeit with low @xmath41 and high @xmath3 .
f574 - 1 was the worst case of beam - smearing from the hi sample , but the increase in the initital rate of rise of the rotation curve found optically does not really help nfw .
the optical data imply a ` cusp ' slope ( @xmath58 ) of @xmath59 @xcite , still well short of the nfw value @xmath60 .
this is the limit in the minimum disk case ; if allowance is made for stellar mass , a value even closer to a constant density core is required .
* f583 - 1 * a well resolved and well - observed curve that shows the nfw over / under / over - fit discrepancy . for all assumptions about stellar mass , @xmath61 .
this galaxy strongly prefers a halo with a constant density core over one with a cusp , a conclusion which has not changed from @xcite .
only a substantial change in the shape of the rotation curve would alter this conclusions , which would require a large _ systematic _ error .
beam smearing can no longer be invoked as the cause of such a systematic error now that this object has been resolved to sub - kpc scales . *
u5750 * this curve was observed both by us and de blok & bosma ( 2001 ) , and the two data sets show good agreement ( see paper i ) .
this curve is difficult to model with a standard nfw profile , but the pseudo - isothermal model provides a good fit .
the outermost point is taken from the hi curve , and provides an important constraint for the nfw model . without this point
the fit produces @xmath62 and an impossibly large @xmath32 , a result of the fitting program trying to make @xmath63 look like @xmath64 .
* u6614 * this is the only giant lsb in sample i. the analysis is complicated by the presence of a dominant bulge , which we have modelled as an exponential spherical bulge with @xmath65 and @xmath66 mag arcsec@xmath2 .
the disk has parameters @xmath67 and @xmath68 mag arcsec@xmath2 .
the rapid rise and subsequent dip in the rotation velocity at small radii clearly suggest the dominance of the bulge in this giant lsb galaxy . we have assumed the bulge to be maximal at @xmath69 .
as the bulge accounts for most of the rotation velocity in the inner parts , this seems to argue against cuspy halos in giant lsb galaxies .
the pseudo - isothermal halos generally provide better fits than the nfw halos . in fig .
[ compchi2 ] we compare the reduced @xmath10 values for the four different @xmath3 cases . for the minimum disk case we plot samples i and ii , for the other cases only sample i is plotted .
it is clear that the large majority of the curves presented here is best fitted by a pseudo - isothermal halo .
this holds true even in the maximum disk case where one might naively expect the dominance of the optical disk to wipe out any discrepancies of a particular halo model ( though perhaps not for lsb galaxies ) . another way of comparing the models is given in table [ veratable ] .
this lists the number of galaxies in sample i that have good ( @xmath43 ) or bad ( @xmath44 ) fits for each of the two models . here
again it is clear that the pseudo - isothermal model performs much better , for every assumption of @xmath3 .
these statements do not depend on the errors .
if we double ( or halve ) the size of the error bars , @xmath10 will change for both halo cases , but will always remain less for the pseudo - isothermal case . to alter this result would require systematic changes to the shapes of all the rotation curves .
[ residuals ] shows the residuals of the best - fitting minimum disk models versus the observed data .
residuals are plotted against halo scale size ( @xmath31 for nfw and @xmath20 for pseudo - isothermal halos ) , radius in kpc , number of optical disk scale lengths and fraction of maximum radius of the rotation curve . as described in the previous section
, the nfw fits that fail do so in a systematic way : the inner velocity is overestimated , then the model drops below the observed velocities in the middle and in the outer parts it once again overpredicts the velocity .
the nfw residuals are most pronounced when plotted against @xmath70 .
the majority of the residuals change sign at @xmath71 and @xmath72 . as the radius @xmath73 does not have any physical significance , but is determined by the observations ( slit angle , presence of h@xmath5 , etc . )
this indicates that the systematics are due to the choice of model , rather than being associated with any particular length scale in the galaxies .
similar conclusions are reached when the residuals are plotted for the min+gas , constant @xmath3 and maximum disk cases . though this is not readily apparent in fig .
[ nfwiso ] , the residuals for the pseudo - isothermal halo model also show a systematic behaviour , though at a much lower level than the nfw model . here
the residuals do not increase towards the center , and as the typical size of the residuals is smaller than the uncertainty in the individual data points , this just shows us that the rotation curve shape is subtly different from that of a pure pseudo - isothermal halo .
this should come as no surprise given the simplifying assumptions of e.g.minimum disk that we have made . of the two models investigated ,
the pseudo - isothermal halo best describes the data .
here we briefly explore some correlations between the pseudo - isothermal halo model parameters and the parameters describing the luminous components of the galaxies . to increase the range of the parameters we also consider the samples of @xcite of ( mainly ) luminous hsb galaxies , and @xcite of late - type dwarf galaxies . from these samples we only select bulge - less galaxies brighter than @xmath74 to be consistent with the range of luminosities found in our sample .
[ isocor ] presents the results for the three samples .
we show the min+gas case , which the two comparison samples refer to as their `` minimum disk '' .
the most obvious correlation visible in fig .
[ isocor ] is that between @xmath20 and @xmath19 . this is a reflection of the fact that these two are correlated through the asymptotic velocity @xmath22 ( see eq . 3 ) .
lines of constant @xmath22 have a slope of @xmath75 in the @xmath76 diagram , and the diagram therefore just reflects the limited range in @xmath77 in the samples .
there is an indication that that @xmath20 increases towards lower surface brightnesses , and that @xmath19 decreases ( as one would expect if lsb galaxies inhabited lower density halos ) .
the large scatter in these figures sheds little light on galaxy formation or the details of pseudo - isothermal halos .
how the observed regularities of galaxy kinematics ( like the tully - fisher relation ) can emerge from this scatter remains a mystery .
a further analysis is presented in @xcite where the mass density distributions that give rise to the observed rotation curves are presented .
they show that the minimum disk mass density distributions at small radii can be parametrized by a power law @xmath78 where for the lsb galaxies @xmath79 , clearly different from @xmath80 as predicted by cdm .
these minimum disk slopes are upper limits . when stars are properly taken into account , assuming some reasonable value for @xmath17 , the slopes decrease , and become even more consistent with constant density cores .
succesfull theories of galaxy formation and evolution that attempt to model lsb galaxies should thus be able to produce halos dominated by constant - density cores . as noted earlier ,
the @xmath41 and @xmath32 halo parameters are related .
here we compare the derived @xmath41 and @xmath32 values with those predicted by @xmath0cdm with the @xcite prescription for @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 with a cobe normalized power spectrum .
the values of @xmath41 depend on the assumed @xmath17 , which , as discussed before , is uncertain .
minimum disk however gives strong upper limits on the values of @xmath41 : when @xmath17 is increased the halo needs to compensate by becoming less concentrated @xcite .
minimum disk models with @xmath41 values higher than found in simulations can usually be reconciled with these observations by increasing @xmath17 or introducing a bulge to bring the @xmath41-values down , as one can see from the progressive decrease in @xmath41 values from minimum disk to maximum disk .
explaining minimum disk models with concentrations lower than the simulated values is more difficult .
it indicates one or more of three problems : failure of the model , failure of the assumption of circular motion in deriving rotation curves , or a dramatic ( non - cosmological ) re - distribution of dm .
this last option is not really understood , and potentially removes any of the predictive power that the cdm theory has .
we will not discuss it here , except to note that the most plausible effect , adiabatic contraction , further concentrates the dm , making the problem worse .
as an aside we note here that the min+gas case sometimes gives slightly higher @xmath41-values than the simple minimum disk case .
in most cases this is due to a central depression in the hi surface density that gives rises to imaginary rotation velocities , which have to be compensated for by the halo . also some of the outer rotation velocity is explained by the gas rotation curve , yielding a halo curve that bends more at small radii .
consequently the halo model tends to be slightly more concentrated .
[ csumm ] shows the derived @xmath41 and @xmath32 values and compares them with the @xmath0cdm predictions . for the minimum disk case
we show both samples i and ii , for the other three @xmath17 values only sample i is shown .
the data points are coded to indicate their significance level @xmath42 .
several points can be made about fig.[csumm ] .
firstly , the bottom - right plot clearly shows that maximum disk is inconsistent with the nfw halos expected to arise in @xmath0cdm .
secondly , there is some correlation between the significance of the fits and their position in the @xmath84 diagram . in the minimum disk case
the majority ( 11 out of 14 ) of the @xmath43 points are found at @xmath85 km s@xmath8 .
most ( 17 out of 19 ) of the @xmath86 points are found to the right of this line .
this division becomes more clear in the minimum disk+gas and constant @xmath3 plots .
as the high @xmath32 values tend to occur at lower @xmath41 , this is likely to be the effect of a nfw halo trying to fit a solid - body - like curve , by hiding its curvature outside the visible galaxy , i.e. , by decreasing @xmath41 and increasing @xmath32 .
thirdly , the distribution of points does not agree with that predicted by the numerical models @xcite .
there are more points above , but more importantly , below the 1@xmath12 lines than expected .
this low-@xmath41 tail consists of fits that have a high to reasonable significance @xmath42 associated with them .
we show the distribution again in fig .
[ cdist ] .
the two histograms are for minimum disk ( open histogram , samples i and ii ) and constant @xmath3 ( filled histogram , sample i ) .
over - plotted are log - normal distributions showing the distribution derived from numerical simulations .
unfortunately , these simulations do not agree on the value of the dispersion .
the @xmath0cdm model by @xcite gives a logarithmic dispersion @xmath87 , while the distribution for relaxed @xmath0cdm halos as found by @xcite has a logarithmic dispersion of @xmath88 .
the observed distribution is clearly wider than either theoretical one . by changing the cosmology of the model
one can change the mean of the distribution ( e.g. ocdm has a mean @xmath89 ) @xcite , but the width hardly changes . thus one can possibly shift the model to higher @xmath41 to fit the high-@xmath41 end of the distribution , but it is impossible to explain the large observed low-@xmath41 tail with the kind of log - normal distribution one derives from the simulations .
rotation curves have the implicit assumption of circular motion .
can non - circular motions affect the rotation curves ? as the nfw models show the largest residuals in the centers of some of the lsb galaxies , it is possible that they could be affected by non - circular motions due to non - axisymmetric components .
we will investigate the matter here by comparing the morphology of our galaxies with the quality of the fits .
table [ morphtable ] contains a short description of the morphology of the galaxies , where we have focussed on the central parts . in the table `` core '' refers to a galaxy whose central light distribution can best be described by an axisymmetric model , presumably implying negligible non - circular motions in the inner part .
the word `` core '' is used very loosely here . it does not necessarily indicate the presence of a bulge or massive central component , but is just an indication of the ( deprojected ) round shape of the isophotes in the inner part of the galaxy .
`` bar '' indicates a central morphology dominated by a bar - like structure , usually magellanic , that may indicate the presence of non - circular motions .
the results are summarized in table [ morphstattable ] ( for the minimum disk assumption ) .
the conclusion is that there is no clear dependence of residual velocity on morphology .
there is thus no indication that the failure of nfw to fit some galaxy rotation curves can be attributed to the presence of bars or non - circular motions .
as noted in the introduction , the inner rotation curves of hsb galaxies can usually be well explained by scaling up the rotation curve derived from the light distribution .
this maximum disk procedure results in @xmath3 values that are reasonably consistent with those derived from stellar population synthesis models @xcite .
furthermore , bars seem to demand near - maximal disks in hsb galaxies @xcite the matter of maximum disk in lsb galaxies was first discussed by @xcite who noted that from a stellar population point of view maximum disk demanded unreasonably high @xmath17 values . substantial amounts of dm were still needed within the optical disk to explain the observed hi curves .
smt revisited the subject and noted that the slightly steeper slopes they found using their h@xmath5 curves , enabled them to scale up the disk rotation curve by an even larger factor .
the maximum disk @xmath3value is extremely sensitive to the inner slope , and only a very small increase is needed to change it by a significant factor . in lsb galaxies ,
the maximum disk @xmath3 values are thus much larger than expected on the basis of colors , metallicities and star formation histories .
the higher @xmath3 values as found by smt worsened this problem ( a consequence already noted in @xcite ) , despite the fact that their maximum disk models could slightly better reproduce the observed inner curve . though it seems unlikely that the maximum disk results can be explained using `` reasonable '' stellar populations , given what we know about the star formation history , dust content and metallicity of lsb galaxies , the matter is still relevant for exploring possible baryonic disk dm scenarios . to explain maximum disk in lsb galaxies purely in terms of baryons one has to assume a large amount of unseen material in the form of e.g. cold molecular gas , optically thick neutral hydrogen , low mass stars or non - standard initial mass functions .
it should be noted though that many of these hypothetical mass components would however violate constraints imposed by disk stability @xcite , near - infra red colors @xcite , and would possibly introduce a surface brightness segregation in the baryonic tf - relation @xcite in fig .
[ mlhisto ] we compare the maximum disk @xmath54-band @xmath3ratios - band values using the @xmath90 color .
we converted our data to @xmath54-band , rather than converting the hsb data to @xmath14-band , as the colors of lsb galaxies are better determined than those of the broeils hsb galaxies .
the color gradients in lsb galaxies are small , so systematic effects are negligible . ] for sample i , with those derived by @xcite for a sample of mostly hsb galaxies and by @xcite for a sample of dwarfs .
we again show only bulge - less galaxies brighter than @xmath91
. also indicated are @xmath3 values from @xcite , who tabulate stellar mass - to - light ratios for various star formation histories and population synthesis models as a function of color . here
we show representative values ( assuming a simple salpeter imf ) spanning the color range exhibited by late - type hsb galaxies , gas - rich dwarfs and lsb galaxies .
the @xmath3 values for hsb galaxies agree to within a factor of 3 and can be considered to be ( close to ) maximum disk .
the values found for lsb galaxies and dwarfs are less easily reconciled with the model values .
observationally values up to @xmath92 are found , while the typical model value ( again for a simple salpeter imf ) is @xmath93 for @xmath94 ( the average color for a dwarf / lsb ) .
this discrepancy can not be explained with extinction or population effects .
extinction in dwarfs and lsb galaxies is less than in hsb galaxies @xcite , and a factor of @xmath95 ( 3.0 mag ) extinction is hard to reconcile with the known properties of lsb galaxies .
line - of - sight extinctions observed towards hii regions in lsb galaxies are never as large @xcite .
apart from changing the imf in an _ ad hoc _ way it is hard to see how such high @xmath3 values can be reached given the constraints imposed by what we know about the star formation history ( low sfr in past and at present ) and the blue ( optical and nir ) colors of lsb galaxies @xcite .
it is likely that the maximum disk values as found in lsb galaxies are not representative of the evolutionary stage of these galaxies .
while the maximum disk prescription now has somewhat greater success in predicting the inner shape of the rotation curves of lsb galaxies , it requires stellar mass - to - light ratios which are too large for the stellar populations in these galaxies .
the mass discrepancies are still large ; all this does is move the dm from halo to disk . just as the minimum disk assumption gives us an upper limit on the amount of dm implied by rotation curves , the maximum disk hypothesis gives us an upper limit on the amount of mass that could potentially be hidden in a disk .
it is therefore still useful to ask ourselves what these maximum disk upper limits imply for the stellar disks .
maximum disk means maximum surface density ( luminous surface density times @xmath3 ) , and therefore gives an absolute upper limit on the mass surface density in stellar disks ( for mass components that are distributed like the stars ) .
figure [ maxdisk ] summarizes the maximum disk results for the sample i lsb galaxies as well as the @xcite and @xcite hsb and dwarf samples .
we plot the maximum disk @xmath3 values , as well as the luminosity , rotation velocity , surface brightness , and maximum disk surface density .
the data are divided into three surface brightness bins .
as already shown in @xcite , at fixed @xmath77 lsb galaxies have higher maximum @xmath3 values than hsb galaxies .
figure [ maxdisk ] also shows the maximum surface density @xmath12 . as
the decrease in surface brightness is faster than the increase in maximum disk @xmath17 , towards low surface brightnesses the maximum surface density @xmath12 in a disk decreases with surface brightness .
the @xmath96 panel suggests that there is a well - defined upper limit to the maximum surface density disks can attain . even under maximum disk ,
lsb galaxy disks have on average lower surface densities than hsb galaxy disks , again putting limits on the amount of baryonic mass one can hide in these disk .
figure [ nfwiso ] shows that even in the maximum disk case most lsb galaxies have @xmath77(disk ) @xmath97(observed ) .
therefore , even in the maximum disk case a moderate amount of dm is still required in the optical disk .
it is therefore hard to explain the tf relation for lsb galaxies in the context of maximum disk : the stellar disk then needs to provide the luminosity , _ and _ the necessary rotation velocity .
lsb galaxies would deviate systematically from the hsb tf relation , which is evidently not the case @xcite .
this is illustrated in the inset panel in fig .
[ maxdisk ] ( lower - right ) . using the arguments in @xcite we find that @xmath98 needs to be constant for galaxies to obey a tf relation independent of surface brightness .
if all galaxies were truly maximum disk ( in the sense that @xmath77(disk ) @xmath99(observed ) , one could replace this by the requirement that @xmath100 needs to be constant .
the lower - right panel shows that this is not the case : at fixed @xmath77 there is a substantial scatter which would translate in @xmath101 mag scatter in tf .
clearly the observed scatter is much smaller , and this shows the clear need for an additional mass component to make tf work . in other words , maximum disk for _ all _ galaxies and tf are incompatible .
the most important conclusion from this work is that the large majority of the high - resolution rotation curves presented here prefer the pseudo - isothermal core - dominated halo model . for a small number of galaxies neither the pseudo - isothermal nor the nfw models are an adequate description of the data
this should not come as a surprise as the true dm distribution is likely to be more complex than the models presented here .
nevertheless , the general trend is that for almost all galaxies discussed here the relative quality of the fits using the pseudo - isothermal model is better than those for the nfw model . for a small numer of galaxies
the nfw model provides a good fit , but generally the concentrations derived from the observed rotation curves are lower than predicted by the simulations .
this is hard to fix : the most likely effect which may alter the initial cosmological nfw halo is adiabatic contraction , but this has the effect of making the final ( observed ) halo _ more _ concentrated , so one would have to start off with ( cosmologically relevant ) halos that are even _ less _ concentrated .
it is worrying that for one or two extreme cases the difference between `` cdm does work '' or `` cdm does nt work '' depends on subtle differences in data , data handling , or analysis .
figure [ nfwswaters ] illustrates that opposite claims can sometimes be made from the same data .
hence we re - iterate the need for the highest quality data of a large sample , in order to minimize these effects .
we refer to @xcite where it is shown that _ all _ data presented here are consistent with a core - dominated model ; the good nfw fits that are found for a number of lsb galaxies can be attributed to resolution effects .
* pseudo - isothermal halos are a better description of the data than nfw halos . *
the number of galaxies that can not be fit with nfw halos is significantly larger than the number of galaxies that can not be fitted with the pseudo - isothermal model . *
the quality of the fit is not obviously related to morphology , luminosity , or surface brightness . *
a larger number of low-@xmath41 nfw halos is found than one would expect based on the distribution derived from cdm simulations . *
if one were to construct models that would have the correct @xmath41-@xmath32 values as predicted by cosmology , then the resulting @xmath3 values would be too low to be consistent with stellar population numbers .
the shape of the curves would still be wrong .
* the maximum disk prescription works to predict the inner rotation curve shape to some extent , but gives mass - to - light ratios which are too high to be accounted for by stellar population synthesis models .
* applying the maximum disk values yields absolute upper limits on the disk mass surface density that is strongly correlated with surface brightness .
we thank roelof bottema and rob swaters for their helpful comments on early drafts of this paper .
we thank the anonymous referee for a thorough examination of the data .
the work of ssm is supported in part by nsf grant ast9901663 .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
this research has made use of nasa s astrophysics data system abstract service .
athannasoula , e. , bosma , a. , papaioannou , s. , 1987 , , 179 , 23 begeman , k. , 1987 , phd thesis , university of groningen bell , e.f . ,
de jong , r.s . ,
2000 , , 312 , 497 bell , e. f. , & de jong , r. s. 2001 , apj , submitted bell , e.f . , barnaby , d. , bower , r.g . ,
de jong , r.s . ,
harper , d.a . ,
hereld , m. , loewenstein , r.f . ,
rauscher , b.j . , 2000 , , 312 , 470 blais - ouellette , s. , amram , p. , carignan , c. , 2001 , , in press ( astro - ph/0006449 ) bosma a. , byun y. , freeman k.c .
, athanassoula e. , 1992 , , 400 , 21 bothun g.d . ,
impey c.d . ,
mcgaugh s.s . , 1997 , , 109 , 745 bottema , r. , 1997 , , 328 , 517 broeils , a.h . , 1992 , phd thesis , university of groningen bruzual , a.g . , charlot , s , , 405 , 538 bullock , j.s . ,
kolatt , t.s . ,
sigad , y. , somerville , r.s . ,
kravtsov , a.v . ,
klypin , a.a . ,
primack , j.r . , & dekel , a. 1999 ( astro - ph/9908159 ) , , submitted casertano , s. 1983 , , 203 , 735 cole , s. , lacey , c.g . ,
baugh , c.m . ,
frenk , c.s . , 2000 ( astro - ph/0007281 ) , , in press ct , s. , carignan , c. & freeman , k.c . 2000 , , 120 , 3027 de blok w.j.g . , van der hulst j.m . , 1998 , , 335 , 421 de blok w.j.g . , van der hulst j.m . ,
bothun g.d .
, 1995 , , 274 , 235 de blok , w.j.g . , mcgaugh , s.s .
1996 , , 469 , l89 de blok , w.j.g . ,
mcgaugh , s.s , bosma , a. , rubin , v. , 2001 , , in press de blok w.j.g .
, mcgaugh s.s . , van der hulst j.m . , 1996 , , 283 , 18 de blok , w.j.g . ,
mcgaugh , s.s . , 1997 , , 290 , 533 de jong , r.s . , 1996 , , 313 , 377 debattista , v.p . ,
sellwood , j.a . , 2000 ( astro - ph/0006275 ) flores , r.a . ,
primack , j.r . , 1994 , , 427 , l1 freeman k.c . , 1970 , , 160 , 811 jing , y.p . 1999 ( astro - ph/9901340 ) lake , g. , feinswog , l. 1989 , , 98 , 166 loader , c. , 1999 ,
_ local regression and likelihood _ , springer - verlag : new york mac low , m .-
m . , ferrara , a. , 1998 , , 513 , 142 mateo , m.l .
, 1998 , , 36 , 435 matthews , l.d . ,
wood , k. , 2000 , astro - ph/0010033 mcgaugh s.s . , 1994 , , 426 , 135 mcgaugh s.s .
, bothun g.d . , 1994 , , 107 , 530 mcgaugh , s.s . , de blok , w.j.g . , 1997 , , 481 , 689 mcgaugh , s.s .
, de blok , w.j.g . , 1998 , , 499 , 41 mcgaugh , s.s . ,
rubin , v. , de blok , w.j.g . , 2000 , , submitted mcgaugh , s.s . , schombert , j.m . ,
bothun , g.d . ,
de blok , w.j.g . , 2000 , , 533 , l99 mihos , j.c . ,
mcgaugh , s.s .
, de blok , w.j.g . , 1997 , , 477 , l79 moore , b. 1994 , , 370 , 629 moore , b. , quinn , t. , governato , f. , stadel , j. , lake , g. , 1999 , , 310 , 1147 navarro , j.f . , frenk , c.s . ,
white , s.d.m .
1996 , , 462 , 563 navarro , j.f . ,
frenk , c.s .
, & white , s.d.m .
1997 , , 490 , 493 palunas , p. , williams , t.b .
, 2000 ( astro - ph/0009161 ) persic m. , salucci p. , stel . , f. , 1996 , , 281 , 27 pickering , t.e . ,
impey , c.d . , van gorkom , j.h . ,
bothun , g.d . , 1997 , , 114 , 1858 sprayberry d. , impey c.d . ,
bothun g.d .
, irwin m. , 1995 , 109 , 558 swaters , r.a . , 1999 , phd thesis , university of groningen swaters , r.a . , madore , b.f . , trewhella , m. , 2000 , , 531 , l107 tully , r.b . ,
verheijen , m.a.w . , 1997 , , 484 , 145 van albada , t.s , sancisi , r. , 1986 , phil .
a , 320 , 447 van den bosch , f.c . , robertson , b.e . , dalcanton , j.j .
, de blok , w.j.g . , 2000 , , 119 , 1579 van den hoek , l.b . ,
de blok , w.j.g . , van der hulst , j.m . ,
de jong , t. , 2000 , , 357 , 397 van der hulst j.m . , skillman e.d . , smith t.r . , bothun g.d .
, mcgaugh s.s .
, de blok w.j.g . , 1993 , , 106 , 548 van der kruit , p.c . ,
& searle , l. 1981 , , 95 , 105 verheijen , m.a.w .
, phd thesis , university of groningen weiner , b.j . ,
sellwood , j.a . ,
williams , t.b . , 2000 ( astro - ph/0008205 ) zwaan m.a . , van der hulst j.m .
, de blok w.j.g . ,
mcgaugh s.s . , 1995 , 273 , l35 lrcccccccc f563 - 1 & 45 & 23.6 & 2.8 & -17.3 & 17.7 & 112 & 3502 & 25 + f563-v2 & 61 & 22.1 & 2.1 & -18.2 & 9.2 & 118 & 4312 & 29 + f568 - 1 & 85 & 23.8 & 5.3 & -18.1 & 14.9 & 142 & 6524 & 26 + f568 - 3 & 77 & 23.1 & 4.0 & -18.3 & 16.5 & 105 & 5913 & 40 + f568-v1 & 80 & 23.3 & 3.2 & -17.9 & 19.0 & 118 & 5768 & 40 + f571 - 8 & 48 & 23.9 & 5.2 & -17.6 & 15.6 & 144 & 3768 & 90 + f574 - 1 & 96 & 23.3 & 4.3 & -18.4 & 15.4 & 100 & 6889 & 65 + f579-v1 & 85 & 22.8 & 5.1 & -18.8 & 17.3 & 114 & 6305 & 26 + f583 - 1 & 32 & 24.1 & 1.6 & -16.5 & 14.6 & 87 & 2264 & 63 + f583 - 4 & 49 & 23.8 & 2.7 & -16.9 & 10.0 & 70 & 3617 & 55 + u5750 & 56 & 23.5 & 5.6 & -18.7 & 21.8 & 79 & 4177 & 64 + u6614 & 85 & 23.4 & 8.1 & -20.3 & 62 & 204 & 6371 & 36 lrrrrrr f730-v1 & 144 & 10714 & & 11.9 & 145 & 50 + u4115 & 3.2 & 343 & -12.4 & 1.0 & 40 & 74 + u11454 & 91 & 6628 & -18.6 & 11.9 & 152 & 64 + u11557 & 22 & 1390 & -20.0 & 6.2 & 95 & 36 + u11583 & 5 & 128 & -14.0 & 1.5 & 36 & 83 + u11616 & 73 & 5244 & -20.3 & 9.6 & 143 & 60 + u11648 & 48 & 3350 & -21.0 & 12.7 & 145 & 90 + u11748 & 73 & 5265 & -22.9 & 21.0 & 242 & 78 + u11819 & 60 & 4261 & -20.3 & 11.7 & 153 & 66 + e0140040 & 212 & 16064 & -21.6 & 29.2 & 263 & 35 + e0840411 & 80 & 6200 & -18.1 & 8.9 & 61 & 90 + e1200211 & 15 & 1314 & -15.6 & 3.5 & 25 & 70 + e1870510 & 18 & 1410 & -16.5 & 3.0 & 40 & 58 + e2060140 & 60 & 4704 & -19.2 & 11.6 & 118 & 39 + e3020120 & 69 & 5311 & -19.1 & 11.0 & 86 & 55 + e3050090 & 11 & 1019 & -17.3 & 4.8 & 54 & 53 + e4250180 & 86 & 6637 & -20.5 & 14.4 & 145 & 33 + e4880049 & 22 & 1800 & -16.8 & 6.0 & 97 & 63 + f583 - 1 & & & & & & & + & 0.3 & 0.1 & -0.1 & 0.4 & 0 & 1.1 & 11.1 + & 2.8 & 0.4 & -0.9 & 4.0 & 0 & 10.0 & 7.0 + & 5.0 & 0.7 & -1.5 & 6.7 & 0 & 17.4 & 9.6 + & 6.9 & 1.0 & -2.2 & 8.5 & 0 & 23.5 & 11.2 + & 9.0 & 1.4 & -2.8 & 10.1 & 0 & 31.0 & 5.2 + lllrrrrrrrrrrr f563-v2 & smt & smt & 16.2 & 3.4 & 84.5 & 10.4 & 2.516 + f563-v2 & smt & dbmr & 7.5 & 3.7 & 153.1 & 70.5 & 1.391 + f563-v2 & smt & data & 5.9 & 2.2 & 192.3 & 76.4 & 3.42 + f568 - 1 & smt & smt & 13.4 & 1.1 & 112.1 & 6.3 & 0.265 + f568 - 1 & smt & dbmr & 6.4 & 2.5 & 194.6 & 71.9 & 0.804 + f568 - 1 & smt & data & 8.3 & 1.1 & 154.5 & 18.5 & 3.49 + f568 - 3 & smt & smt & 5.1 & 2.9 & 160.3 & 88.0 & 2.147 + f568 - 3 & smt & dbmr & _ 1.17 _ & & _ 591.0 _ & & 3.551 + f568 - 3 & smt & data & 1.71 & 0.5 & 400.4 & 94.8 & 13.9 + f568 - 3 & paper i & dbmr & 3.2 & 3.7 & 214.6 & 233.9 & 2.239 + f568 - 3 & paper i & data & 4.6 & 0.5 & 168.4 & 17.7 & 8.01 + f568-v1 & smt & smt & 14.2 & 0.7 & 91.5 & 2.3 & 0.239 + f568-v1 & smt & dbmr & 14.6 & 1.2 & 92.1 & 4.9 & 0.197 + f568-v1 & smt & data & 15.8 & 1.1 & 85.7 & 3.8 & 12.7 + f574 - 1 & smt & smt & 9.4 & 0.7 & 91.2 & 4.3 & 0.421 + f574 - 1 & smt & dbmr & 8.3 & 1.3 & 98.3 & 10.4 & 1.595 + f574 - 1 & smt & data & 8.2 & 0.4 & 99.3 & 3.4 & 3.84 + lrrrrrrrrrrrrrr f563 - 1 & 10.7 & 1.2 & 93.1 & 4.3 & 0.092 & 0.999 & & 11.3 & 1.3 & 87.5 & 3.9 & 0.089 & 0.999 & + f568 - 3 & 3.2 & 3.7 & 214.6 & 233.9 & 2.239 & 0.017 & & 4.2 & 3.3 & 161.3 & 118.9 & 2.386 & 0.011 & + f571 - 8 & 7.8 & 1.1 & 163.8 & 20.2 & 1.501 & 0.123 & & 7.8 & 1.1 & 163.3 & 20.1 & 1.477 & 0.132 & + f579-v1 & 20.9 & 1.5 & 78.4 & 2.6 & 0.211 & 0.998 & & 22.1 & 1.6 & 75.1 & 2.5 & 0.217 & 0.998 & + f583 - 1 & 5.1 & 1.0 & 106.6 & 17.0 & 0.740 & 0.746 & & 6.2 & 1.1 & 86.6 & 12.4 & 0.827 & 0.648 & + f583 - 4 & 5.7 & 1.4 & 89.5 & 19.0 & 0.322 & 0.944 & & 6.1 & 1.4 & 82.2 & 15.5 & 0.321 & 0.945 & + u5750 & 2.6 & 1.5 & 123.1 & 58.8 & 1.243 & 0.262 & & 2.9 & 1.6 & 105.8 & 47.7 & 1.203 & 0.288 & + u6614 & 10.3 & 2.0 & 169.8 & 17.7 & 4.626 & 0.000 & & 11.0 & 2.2 & 163.9 & 17.1 & 4.712 & 0.000 & + f563-v2 & 7.5 & 3.7 & 153.1 & 70.5 & 1.391 & 0.195 & & 8.3 & 3.8 & 133.1 & 54.1 & 1.484 & 0.157 & + f568 - 1 & 6.4 & 2.4 & 194.6 & 71.9 & 0.804 & 0.625 & & 7.5 & 2.4 & 160.1 & 46.7 & 0.869 & 0.562 & + f568 - 3 & _ 1.2_&&_591.1_&&3.551&0.000&&_1.2_&&_552.6_&&3.573&0.000 + f568-v1 & 14.6 & 1.2 & 92.0 & 4.9 & 0.197 & 0.999 & & 15.7 & 1.5 & 87.2 & 5.0 & 0.242 & 0.997 & + f574 - 1 & 8.3 & 1.3 & 98.3 & 10.4 & 1.595 & 0.085 & & 9.0 & 1.5 & 91.1 & 9.4 & 1.806 & 0.041 & + & & & + + galaxy&@xmath41&@xmath102&@xmath32&@xmath103&@xmath104&@xmath42&&@xmath41&@xmath102&@xmath32&@xmath103&@xmath104&@xmath42&@xmath105 + f563 - 1 & 9.9 & 1.2 & 88.8 & 4.6 & 0.089 & 0.999 & & 4.0 & 1.2 & 110.0 & 20.1 & 0.098 & 0.999 & 6.9 + f568 - 3 & 2.3 & 4.9 & 218.6 & 410.9 & 2.127 & 0.024 & & 0.4 & 19.5 & 595.0&@xmath106 & 2.015 & 0.024 & 2.2 + f571 - 8 & 1.6 & 5.7 & 591.4 & & 3.776 & 0.012 & & _ 1.0_&&_500.0_&&7.060 & 0.000 & 4.2 + f579-v1&23.2 & 1.9 & 67.9 & 2.4 & 0.215 & 0.998 & & 43.4 & 14.6 & 31.6 & 3.9 & 0.671 & 0.781 & 7.9 + f583 - 1 & 5.4&1.1&90.6 & 14.7&0.767&0.716&&2.2 & 1.5&145.5&78.7&0.680&0.804&6.5 + f583 - 4&5.9&1.4&76.0 & 14.5&0.271&0.965&&11.4 &
6.1&12.9 & 3.3&0.196&0.986&9.6 + u5750&1.9 & 1.7 & 116.9 & 80.4 & 1.105&0.354&&1.9 & 1.7 & 116.9 & 80.4 & 1.105&0.354&1.4 + u6614&1.7&1.8&303.0&206.5&4.005&0.001&&_0.4 _ & & _ 145.6 _ & & 7.828&0.737&7.7 + f563-v2&6.5&3.8&136.0&73.3&1.047&0.397&&_1.0 _ & & _ 350.0 _ & & 0.449&0.878&4.1 + f568 - 1&6.7&2.5&163.8 & 56.1&0.803&0.626&&_0.6 _ & & _ 669.2 _ & & 0.636&0.898&9.0 + f568 - 3&_1.0 _ & & _ 519.4 _ & & 3.595&0.000&&_1.0 _ & & _ 467.8 _ & & 3.624&0.000&1.8 + f568-v1&14.6&1.4&88.8 & 5.3&0.228&0.998&&3.3 & 1.5&125.8 & 45.7&0.222&0.998&14.0 + f574 - 1&8.2&1.4&87.1 & 9.5&1.391&0.162&&1.5 & 1.6&69.7 & 43.9&0.204&0.998&8.1 + lrrrrrr f730-v1 & 11.8 & 1.9 & 131.4 & 16.2 & 0.995 & 0.426 + u4115 & _ 5.0 _ & & _ 133.4_&&0.777&0.591 + u11454 & 10.4 & 2.0 & 152.6 & 23.3 & 3.334 & 0.000 + u11557 & _ 1.0 _ & & _ 425.1_&&1.367&0.093 + u11583 & _ 5.0 _ & & _ 93.3_&&0.676&0.641 + u11616 & 12.7 & 1.8 & 124.4 & 14.3 & 1.254 & 0.244 + u11648 & 8.0 & 0.7 & 146.2 & 10.9 & 0.964 & 0.498 + u11748 & 52.5 & 4.5 & 125.2 & 3.8 & 3.325 & 0.000 + u11819 & 6.4 & 1.9 & 252.9 & 77.6 & 1.348 & 0.177 + e0140040 & 16.8 & 0.8 & 203.3 & 5.8 & 0.152 & 0.989 + e0840411 & _ 1.0 _ & & _ 181.0_&&1.608 & 0.077 + e1200211 & 6.4 & 2.1 & 27.5 & 6.9 & 0.246 & 0.996 + e1870510 & 3.8 & 1.5 & 93.6 & 38.6 & 0.059 & 1.000 + e2060140 & 15.2 & 1.3 & 92.7 & 4.4 & 0.425 & 0.962 + e3020120 & 6.6 & 1.5 & 98.5 & 18.4 & 0.333 & 0.965 + e3050090 & _ 1.0 _ & & 323.6 & & 0.208 & 0.999 + e4250180 & 3.1 & 0.9 & 301.6 & 77.8 & 0.014 & 1.000 + e488 - 049 & 4.9 & 1.9 & 209.6 & 90.1 & 0.170 & 0.999 + lrrrrrrrrrrrrrr f563 - 1 & 1.72 & 0.23 & 91.9 & 21.6 & 0.085 & 1.000 & & 1.55 & 0.22 & 102.0 & 25.2 & 0.078 & 1.000 + f568 - 3 & 2.92 & 0.36 & 36.6 & 5.4 & 0.522 & 0.860 & & 2.71 & 0.39 & 38.3 & 6.8 & 0.676 & 0.731 + f571 - 8 & 2.12 & 0.19 & 106.9 & 14.0 & 1.525 & 0.114 & & 2.12 & 0.19 & 106.3 & 14.0 & 1.512 & 0.118 + f579-v1 & 0.67 & 0.02 & 574.8 & 37.3 & 0.026 & 1.000 & & 0.63 & 0.03 & 630.8 & 50.2 & 0.037 & 1.000 + f583 - 1 & 2.44 & 0.06 & 33.0 & 1.1 & 0.037 & 1.000 & & 2.08 & 0.11 & 37.7 & 2.5 & 0.117 & 1.000 + f583 - 4 & 1.10 & 0.13 & 85.5 & 15.8 & 0.329 & 0.941 & & 1.06 & 0.11 & 88.2 & 15.1 & 0.267 &
0.967 + u5750 & 4.25 & 0.39 & 10.6 & 1.0 & 0.154 & 0.998 & & 3.96 & 0.49 & 10.4 & 1.3 & 0.214 & 0.993 + u6614 & 1.86 & 0.49 & 218.4 & 102.5 & 1.942 & 0.021 & & 1.73 & 0.44 & 244.7 & 111.6 & 1.777 & 0.040 + f563-v2 & 1.69 & 0.17 & 131.2 & 19.4 & 0.283 & 0.972 & & 1.58 & 0.20 & 135.3 & 24.7 & 0.393 & 0.925 + f568 - 1 & 2.22 & 0.10 & 97.2 & 6.2 & 0.066 & 1.000 & & 2.03 & 0.12 & 104.6 & 8.9 & 0.106 & 1.000 + f568 - 3 & 3.93 & 0.75 & 30.2 & 5.6 & 1.256 & 0.245 & & 3.75 & 0.78 & 30.8 & 6.3 & 1.383 & 0.173 + f568-v1 & 1.45 & 0.11 & 153.0 & 18.2 & 0.110 & 1.000 & & 1.33 & 0.14 & 170.0 & 27.8 & 0.172 & 1.000 + f574 - 1 & 1.83 & 0.06 & 71.5 & 3.7 & 0.100 & 1.000 & & 1.70 & 0.09 & 76.9 & 6.3 & 0.232 & 0.997 + & & & + + galaxy&@xmath20&@xmath107&@xmath19&@xmath108&@xmath104&@xmath42&&@xmath20&@xmath107&@xmath19&@xmath108&@xmath104&@xmath42&@xmath109 + f563 - 1 & 1.72 & 0.26 & 79.0 & 21.3 & 0.083 & 1.000 & & 4.09 & 1.01 & 13.2 & 4.9 & 0.124 & 0.998 & 6.9 + f568 - 3 & 3.07 & 0.63 & 25.7 & 6.3 & 0.793 & 0.623 & & 3.36 & 0.88 & 19.7 & 5.9 & 0.89 & 0.536 & 2.2 + f571 - 8 & 4.19 & 0.28 & 34.4 & 2.7 & 0.405 & 0.954 & & 9.97 & 3.43 & 9.8 & 2.3 & 2.639 & 0.002 & 4.2 + f579-v1 & 0.55 & 0.04 & 694.4 & 84.0 & 0.06 & 1.000 & & 0.17 & 0.16 & 1970 & 3234 & 1.032 & 0.415 & 7.9 + f583 - 1 & 2.26 & 0.11 & 31.5 & 2.0 & 0.103 & 1.000 & & 3.41 & 0.24 & 14.3 & 1.2 & 0.121 & 1.000 & 6.5 + f583 - 4 & 1.02 & 0.12 & 80.6 & 15.2 & 0.249 & 0.972 & & 0.23 & 0.15 & 103.4 & 114.1 & 0.188 & 0.988 & 9.6 + u5750 & 4.67 & 0.74 & 7.1 & 1.1 & 0.262 & 0.984 & & 4.67 & 0.74 & 7.1 & 1.1 & 0.262 & 0.984 & 1.4 + u6614 & 12.18 & 2.87 & 6.3 & 1.9 & 1.938 & 0.022 & & 112.0 & 506.7 & 0.4 & 0.4 & 4.762 & 0.000 & 7.4 + f563-v2 & 1.70 & 0.24 & 96.6 & 19.8 & 0.298 & 0.967 & & 2.32 & 0.63 & 30.8 & 11.5 & 0.191 & 0.992 & 4.1 + f568 - 1 & 2.11 & 0.15 & 90.7 & 9.0 & 0.120 & 1.000 & & 3.08 & 0.73 & 27.6 & 8.5 & 0.270 & 0.988 & 9.0 + f568 - 3 & 4.35 & 1.31 & 21.5 & 6.0 & 1.709 & 0.065 & & 4.54 & 1.52 & 19.4 & 5.9 & 1.815 & 0.046 & 1.8 + f568-v1 & 1.41 & 0.15 & 146.1 & 23.0 & 0.153 & 1.000 & & 3.80 & 0.58 & 14.8 & 2.6 & 0.120 & 1.000 & 14.0 + f574 - 1 & 1.74 & 0.09 & 63.1 & 5.4 & 0.182 &
0.999 & & 3.30 & 0.83 & 4.6 & 1.6 & 0.108 & 1.000 & 8.1 + lrrrrrr f730-v1 & 1.46 & 0.06 & 215.8 & 14.2 & 0.097 & 0.997 + u4115 & 0.94 & 0.03 & 148.2 & 2.4 & 0.004 & 1.000 + u11454 & 1.95 & 0.10 & 146.9 & 11.8 & 0.423 & 0.927 + u11557 & 5.48 & 0.55 & 15.2 & 0.9 & 0.052 & 1.000 + u11583 & 0.63 & 0.08 & 117.8 & 16.5&0.103 & 0.999 + u11616 & 1.45 & 0.05 & 208.9 & 11.6 & 0.140 & 1.000 + u11648 & 1.95 & 0.25 & 104.9 & 20.7 & 3.792 & 0.000 + u11748 & 0.36 & 0.15 & 8540 & 6661 & 5.402 & 0.000 + u11819 & 2.93 & 0.14 & 88.2 & 5.2 & 0.303 & 0.991 + e0140040 & 2.55 & 0.18 & 249.5 & 27.0 & 0.176 & 0.982 + e0840411 & 6.41 & 0.56 & 5.2 & 0.3 & 0.067 & 0.999 + e1200211 & 0.57 & 0.08 & 45.5 & 9.2 & 0.082 & 1.000 + e1870510 & 0.97 & 0.05 & 53.5 & 3.2 & 0.028 & 1.000 + e2060140 & 1.17 & 0.05 & 231.1 & 16.9 & 0.106 & 1.000 + e3020120 & 1.90 & 0.09 & 53.6 & 3.4 & 0.035 & 1.000 + e3050090 & 2.09 & 0.14 & 27.3 & 1.8 & 0.048 & 1.000 + e4250180 & 4.41 & 0.75 & 30.0 & 6.6 & 0.088 & 0.997 + e488 - 049 & 1.63 & 0.04 & 101.1 & 3.1 & 0.016 & 1.000 + lllll f563 - 1 & + & & + & mag .
+ f563-v2 & 0 & & + & mag .
bar + f568 - 1 & 0 & + & & spiral + f568 - 3 & & & + & spiral with mag .
bar + f568-v1 & + & + & & spiral + f571 - 8 & 0 & + & ? & edge - on + f574 - 1 & & + & & disk + f579-v1 & + & + & & core , flocc . arms + f583 - 1 & 0 & + & & mag . irr .
+ f583 - 4 & + & + ?
& + ? & fuzzy + f730-v1 & 0 & + & & spiral + u4115 & 0 & + ? & & fuzzy + u5750 & 0 & & + & mag .
bar + u6614 & & + & & faint , with bulge + u11454 & & + & & fuzzy spiral , small core + u11557 & 0 & + & & fuzzy spiral , small core + u11583 & 0 & & + & faint mag .
bar + u11616 & 0 & + & & fuzzy , irr + u11648 & 0 & & + & irr + u11748 & & + & + ? & irr , bright core / bar ?
+ u11819 & 0 & + & & fuzzy + e0140040 & + & + & & spiral + e0840411 & & & ? & edge - on + e1200211 & + & & + & fuzzy mag .
bar + e1870510 & + & & + & irr .
spiral , flocc .
+ e2060140 & + & + & & spiral + e3020120 & + & + & + ? & spiral , hint of bar ?
+ e3050090 & + & + & + & barred spiral + e4250180 & + & + & & spiral + e488 - 049 & + & & + & inclined mag . | we present mass models for a sample of 30 high - resolution rotation curves of low surface brightness ( lsb ) galaxies .
we fit both pseudo - isothermal ( core - dominated ) and cold dark matter ( cdm ) ( cusp - dominated ) halos for a wide variety of assumptions about the stellar mass - to - light ratio .
we find that the pseudo - isothermal model provides superior fits .
cdm fits show systematic deviations from the data , and often have a small statistical likelihood of being the appropriate model .
the distribution of concentration parameters is too broad , and has too low a mean , to be explained by @xmath0cdm .
this failing becomes more severe as increasing allowance is made for stellar mass : nfw fits require uncomfortably low mass - to - light ratios .
in contrast , the maximum disk procedure does often succeed in predicting the inner shape of the rotation curves , but requires uncomfortably large stellar mass - to- light ratios .
the data do admit reasonable stellar population mass - to - light ratios if halos have cores rather than cusps . |
aquila x1(=v1333 aquilae ) is a soft x - ray transient source that shows type i x - ray bursts ( koyama et al . 1981 ; czerny , czerny & grindlay 1987 ) , thereby indicating that the compact object is a neutron star . from quiescent observations the companion star has been identified to be a v=19.2 k1@xmath5 star ( see shahbaz , casares & charles and references within ) .
aql x1 is known to undergo regular x - ray and optical outbursts on a timescale of @xmath61 year ( kaluzienski et al .
1977 ; priedhorsky & terrell 1984 ; charles et al . 1980 ) much more frequently than the other neutron star transient cen x4 ( mcclintock & remillard 1990 ) .
attempts to find the orbital period have revealed many modulations .
watson ( 1976 ) reported an unconfirmed 1.3 day x - ray periodicity during the 1975 outburst .
chevalier & ilovaisky ( 1991 ) have obtained an 18.97 hr periodicity from optical photometry during its active state , which they interpret as being the orbital period .
recently the rxte all sky monitor showed aql x1 to have undergone an x - ray outburst between late january and early march 1997 ( levine & thomas 1997 ) .
ilovaisky & chevalier ( 1997 ) reported that aql x1 was optically in quiescence by 30 march 1997 . in this letter
we report on our @xmath0-band photometry of aql x1 obtained in june 1997 , when the source was in quiescence .
we are able to confirm the periodicity detected by chevalier & ilovaisky ( 1991 ) and determine the binary inclination .
we monitored aql x1 on the nights of 1997 june 20 , 23 , 24 , 25 , and 26 ut , using the 1.3 m mcgraw - hill telescope at michigan - dartmouth - mit ( mdm ) observatory and a direct ccd camera equipped with a @xmath7 thinned tektronix chip which yielded 0.51 pixel@xmath1 at @xmath8 .
the nights of june 21 and 22 were clear , but the source was too close to the bright moon to observe . to suppress scattered moonlight and to obtain maximum sensitivity to the cool secondary star
, an interference filter approximating the kron - cousins @xmath0-band was used for all the exposures , which were generally 480 s long . except for a very few thin clouds on june 20 , conditions were entirely photometric .
the seeing was variable but generally usable ( fwhm @xmath9 ) .
occasional focus changes and tracking problems spoiled a few frames . in order to obtain maximum leverage in the time series analysis we observed aql x1 for as long as we could each night . for flatfield division we used median - filtered exposures of the twilight sky taken the same nights as the data .
the flatfield pictures agreed very well from night to night , except for occasional @xmath10 per cent changes in the shadows cast by dust particles on the ccd window .
bias subtraction was accomplished using overscan regions of the picture . for all reductions we used iraf routines .
we measured eight stars ( table 1 ) in each picture using the apphot package ; of a variety of software apertures , a @xmath11 radius gave the lowest scatter among the _ differential _ magnitudes , the averages of which are listed in table 1 .
photometric standardization was not attempted .
the coordinates in table 1 are derived from a fit of eight stars from the hst guide star catalog v1.2 in a single good - seeing frame , and are estimated accurate to @xmath12 from the scatter of the fit .
the mean differential @xmath0 magnitudes were computed by averaging over all frames and rejecting points more than three standard deviations from the median . for the local standard ( @xmath13 north of aql x1 ) , only the standard deviation of the instrumental magnitudes is given .
cccl ra & dec & @xmath14 & comments + ( j2000 ) & ( j2000 ) & ( mags ) & + + 19 11 16.06 & + 0 35 05.6 & [email protected] & aql x1 + 19 11 16.11 & + 0 35 13.9 & ( @xmath20.108 ) & local standard + 19 11 15.61 & + 0 35 01.0 & [email protected] & comparison star + 19 11 13.99 & + 0 34 39.9 & [email protected] & + 19 11 17.03 & + 0 35 30.5 & [email protected] & + 19 11 17.00 & + 0 35 22.0 & [email protected] & + 19 11 18.63 & + 0 35 24.0 & [email protected] & + 19 11 16.83 & + 0 34 55.9 & [email protected] & + +
we expect the quiescent optical modulation in aql x1 to arise primarily from the ellipsoidal variations of the secondary star , as it does in other sxts .
these variations arise since the observer sees differing aspects of the gravitationally distorted star as it orbits the compact object ( van paradijs & mcclintock 1995 ) . in theory
the modulation should have two maxima and minima .
the two minima may be unequal depending on the binary inclination , but the maxima should be equal
. however , in practice , the light from the accretion disc ( especially in the optical ) contaminates the ellipsoidal variations of the secondary star , making detailed interpretations of the optical light curves difficult ( see shahbaz , naylor & charles 1993 ) . therefore , we first analysed the optical light curve of aql x1 using the phase dispersion minimization algorithm ( stellingwerf 1975 ) .
this technique is insensitive to the shape of the modulation , but does not remove the effects of the window function .
the method groups the data in phase bins and seeks to minimize the dispersion within the bins .
the deepest minimum of the statistic is the best estimate of the period .
the pdm spectrum was computed in the frequency range 0.1 to 4.0 c d@xmath1 at a resolution of 0.01c d@xmath1 with 20 phase bins .
the common method of computing a discrete fourier transform ( dft ) and halving the estimate of the period is equivalent to assuming that the maxima and/or minima are of equal depths .
this may not be the case , as the observed ellipsoidal modulation may contain unequal maxima and/or minima depending on the binary inclination and the contamination by the accretion disc .
a lomb - scargle periodogram ( lomb 1976 ; scargle 1982 ) of the data set was then computed with the same resolution and frequency range as was used for the pdm periodogram .
figure 1 shows the pdm and lomb - scargle periodgrams , with three frequencies present at 0.524 c d@xmath1 , 1.509 c d@xmath1 and 2.487 c d@xmath1 .
the suggested orbital period of chevalier & ilovaisky ( 1991 ) is marked at 18.97@xmath15 hr .
if this is the orbital period , then it should appear in the lomb - scargle periodogram as a peak at twice the frequency , _
i.e. _ at 2.530 c d@xmath1 . in
both the pdm and lomb - scargle periodograms a periodicity at 2.487 c d@xmath1 in present .
chevalier & ilovaisky s period should also appear in the pdm periodogram , since the method is insensitive to the shape of the modulation in the light curve ; a periodicity at 1.242 c d@xmath1 is present .
we note that no periodicity at 1.242 c d@xmath1 or 2.487 c d@xmath1 is present in the light curves of the comparison stars .
we therefore assume the peak in the lomb - scargle periodogram at 2.487 c d@xmath1 with a power of 31 to be real . in figure 1
we also show the 99 per cent confidence level which allows us to demonstrate the significance on the peaks detected in the lomb - scargle periodogram .
the level was calculated from a monte carlo simulation , which calculates the maximum power in 10 000 sets of gaussian noise with mean and variance equal to that of aql x1 .
random peaks reaching a power of 7.8 are only found in 1 per cent of the artificial data sets , hence this defines our 99 per cent confidence level .
thus we conclude that the power level of the 2.487 c d@xmath1 peak is substantially greater than 99 per cent level significant . in order to estimate the uncertainty in the 2.487 c d@xmath1 peak position we created an artificial data set . with a mean , variance , semi - amplitude , amplitude difference between the minima and baseline equal to that in aql x1 . the observed ellipsoidal modulation is well represented by a sinusoid of frequency @xmath16 which lags 90 degrees in phase , relative to sinusoid at frequency @xmath17 .
the amplitude of the sinusoid at frequency @xmath17 determines the difference between the minima in the final light curve .
since this difference is small ( 0.01 mags ) , the ellipsoidal light curve is very similar to a single sinusoid of frequency @xmath16 . using a monte carlo simulation we recorded the peak power in the lomb - scargle periodogram near the peak of interest , for the artificial data set .
this was repeated 10 000 times to produce good statistics , giving a mean peak at 2.487 @xmath20.005c d@xmath1 ( 1-@xmath18 uncertainty ) .
since this peak corresponds to twice the orbital frequency , the orbital period is then [email protected] c d@xmath1 ( = [email protected] h ) .
chevalier & ilovaisky ( 1991 ) were taken over a 3 month baseline , when aql x1 was in its active state .
the @xmath19-band modulation they observe is probably due to a combination of x - ray heating of the secondary star , and of the accretion disc .
modulations of this kind are probably not coherent , due to the highly variable nature of the accretion disc , even more so in the @xmath19-band ( van paradijs & mcclintock 1995 ) .
our observations of aql x1 were taken when the source was in quiescence , and where in the @xmath0-band the accretion disc contribution is negligible ( shahbaz , casares & charles 1997 ) .
therefore , what we see in the @xmath0-band is the characteristic double humped modulation per orbital cycle , due to the ellipsoidal shape of the secondary star .
we therefore take the orbital period to be [email protected] h ( = [email protected]
d ) . from table 1
it can be seen that the scatter in the aql x1 data is similar to stars of comparable brightness .
this may suggest that the modulation we have detected is not real .
however , it should be noted that we can still use the largest amplitude of an ellipsoidal modulation that could conceivably be hidden within the noise in the data , to constrain the inclination of the system .
using an orbital period @xmath20=19.30 h ( = 0.804 d ) we folded the aql x1 and comparison star data .
as there is no spectroscopic ephemeris defining phase 0.0 ( i.e. superior conjunction of the secondary star ) we used an arbitrary value for t@xmath21 .
we then shifted the light in phase so that the deeper minima corresponded to phase 0.0 .
[ note that the choice is arbitrary . in the fitting procedure ( see later ) , one of the free parameters is a phase shift . ]
the data were then binned into 15 phase bins , and the standard error and mean were then calculated for each bin after discarding the data points which were more than 3-@xmath18 away from the mean of each bin .
this process removed 4 and 12 discrepant data points from the aql x-1 and comparison star data respectively ; the total number of data points was 152 .
figure 2 shows the resulting light curves for aql x1 and a comparison star .
we fitted the orbital @xmath0-band light curve of aql x1 with an ellipsoidal model , similar to that used for the other objects in our programme ( see shahbaz , naylor & charles 1997 and references within ) .
the model describes the light curve generated by a roche lobe filling star , where each element of area on the surface of the star is assumed to emit blackbody radiation .
the temperature distribution over its surface is assumed to vary according to von zeipel s ( 1924 ) gravity darkening law and a linear limb darkening law is used . for
a detailed description of the model see shahbaz , naylor & charles ( 1993 ) .
the model parameters were the binary mass ratio ( @xmath22 = m@xmath23 where m@xmath24 and m@xmath25 are the mass of the compact object and secondary star respectively ) , the inclination ( @xmath26 ) and the effective temperature of the secondary star ( t@xmath27 ) . a bright spot , _
i.e. _ the region where the accretion stream hits the accretion disc was also included .
the free parameters of the model were a phase shift , the normalisation of the bright spot and the normalisation of the light curve .
thus the fitting procedure is not dependent on the choice for t@xmath21 .
we performed least - squares fits to the data using this model , grid searching @xmath22 in the range 110 and @xmath26 in the range 5@xmath350@xmath3 .
a t@xmath28 of 4620 k , appropriate for a k1@xmath5 star was used .
we used a gravity darkening exponent of 0.05 ; sarna ( 1989 ) finds the gravity darkening exponent for convective stars with [email protected] to be 0.05 .
the limb darkening coefficient for the @xmath0-band ( 9000 ) and the varying temperature around the surface of the secondary star was interpolated from the tables given by al - naimiy ( 1978 ) .
the best fit gives a of 1.45 at @xmath30 , @xmath31 , with a phase shift of 0.0033@xmath32(=0.027 d ) .
this fit is plotted in figure 2 as the dashed line .
the phase shift allows us to estimate t@xmath21 to be hjd [email protected] .
figure 3 shows the resulting ( @xmath33 ) diagram with the 68 and 90 per cent confidence regions marked , calculated according to lampton , margon & bowyer ( 1976 ) for three parameters ( the phase shift , bright spot normalisation and the light curve normalisation ) , after the error bars had been rescaled to give a fit with a of 1 .
as one can see , the ellipsoidal variation is only weakly dependent on @xmath22 .
the 68 and 90 per cent confidence regions for the binary inclination are 21@xmath330@xmath3 and 20@xmath331@xmath3 respectively .
shahbaz , casares & charles ( 1997 ) determine the fraction of light arising from the accretion disc to be 6@xmath23 per cent at 6000 .
with increasing wavelength the disc contamination decreases ( see mcclintock & remillard 1986 ; shahbaz , et al . 1996 and references within ) , therefore the @xmath0-band disc contamination should be lower . if we assume a 95 per cent upper limit of 9 per cent for the disc contamination , the effect of this on the binary inclination is to increase it by at most 1@xmath3 . from figure 2
it can be seen that there seems to be some systematic trend in the data of the comparison star . as noted earlier
the scatter in the comparison star data is comparable to that in the aql x1 data ( see also table 1 ) .
if we assume that the modulation we observe in the aql x1 data is not due to the ellipsoidal modulation of the secondary star , and what we have fitted is the maximum possible modulation that could be present , then our fits allow us to determine a 95 percent upper limit of 31@xmath3 to the binary inclination .
the quiescent period ( 19.30 h ) we find is slightly different ( @xmath6 2 per cent ) from the outburst period ( 18.97 h ) obtained by chevalier & ilovaisky .
outburst and quiescent period differences are observed in sxts ( see odonoghue & charles 1996 ) , but the outburst modulation ( caused by the precession of the accretion disc ; whitehurst 1988 ) is usually a few per cent _ longer _ than the orbital period . if we interpret chevalier & ilovaisky s outburst period as being due to the superhump phenomenon , then the superhump period is shorter than the orbital period by 2 per cent , _
i.e. _ we have a `` negative '' superhump .
this may seem unusual , but negative superhumps have previously been observed in cataclysmic variables , _
e.g. _ in v503 cyg the superhump period is shorter than the orbital period by 3 per cent ( harvey , skillman , patterson & ringwald 1995 ) .
we can compare aql x1 to the other long period neutron star sxt cen x4 .
assuming that our inclination is correct , and that both systems have similar mass neutron stars , then one can estimate @xmath34 , the semi - amplitude of the radial velocity curve for aql x1 ( @xmath34 scales with @xmath36 ) . using @xmath34=146 @xmath4km@xmath4s@xmath1(mcclintock & remillard 1990 ) and @xmath37 for cen x4 and @xmath38 for aql x1 , we find @xmath39@xmath4km@xmath4s@xmath1(95 per cent upper limit ) for aql x1 we can also determine the upper limit to the rotational broadening of the secondary star ( @xmath35 ) assuming that the secondary star fills its roche lobe and its spin is tidally locked to the binary period . eliminating @xmath34 from the mass function and the equation which relates the rotational broadening to the radial velocity semi - amplitude and mass ratio ( wade & horne 1986 ) ,
we obtain the expression @xmath40 the secondary star must be less massive than a main sequence star of the same spectral type , 0.8 . then using equation ( 1 ) with @xmath20=19.3 hr and @xmath38 gives @xmath41@xmath4km@xmath4s@xmath1(95 per cent upper limit ) .
this value for @xmath35 is consistent with the limits obtained by shahbaz , casares & charles ( 1997 ) .
using @xmath0-band photometry of aql x1 taken during quiescence , we have detected a periodicity at 2.487 c d@xmath1 , which we interpret as twice the orbital frequency .
folding the data on the orbital period ( [email protected] hr ) , we fit the ellipsoidal modulation of the secondary star .
we determine 95 per cent upper limits to the binary inclination , radial velocity semi - amplitude and rotational broadening of the secondary star to be 31@xmath3 , 117@xmath4km@xmath4s@xmath1and 50@xmath4km@xmath4s@xmath1respectively .
the data analysis was carried out on the oxford starlink node using the @xmath42 and starlink software . | we have obtained @xmath0-band photometry of the neutron star x - ray transient aql x1 during quiescence .
we find a periodicity at 2.487 c d@xmath1 , which we interpret as twice the orbital frequency ( [email protected] h ) .
folding the data on the orbital period , we model the light curve variations as the ellipsoidal modulation of the secondary star .
we determine the binary inclination to be 20@xmath331@xmath3 ( 90 per cent confidence ) and also 95 per cent upper limits to the radial velocity semi - amplitude and rotational broadening of the secondary star to be 117@xmath4km@xmath4s@xmath1and 50@xmath4km@xmath4s@xmath1respectively .
binaries : close stars : individual : aquila x1 stars : neutron x - rays : stars . |
from the appearance of the quantum mechanics many attempts have been made to recover the laws of the classic mechanics through some classic limit .
the more common scheme of this type includes the _ _ quantum decoherence__. this process is in charge to erase the terms of interference of the density matrix , that are classically inadmissible , since they prevent the use of a classical ( boolean ) logic .
in addition , decoherence leads to the rule that selects the candidates for classic states .
as it is pointed out in the brief historical summary of paper @xcite , three periods can be schematically identified in the development of the general program of decoherence @xcite . a first period , when the arrival to the equilibrium of irreversible systems was studied .
during this period , authors as van kampen , van hove , daneri , et al__. _ _ developed a formalism for explaining the decoherence phenomenon that was not successful at the time but it established the bases of this study .
the main problem of this period was that too long decoherence times were found , if compared with the experimental ones . in a second period
the decoherence in open systems was studied , the main characters of this period were zeh and zurek . in their works ,
the decoherence is an interaction process between an open quantum system and its environment .
this process , called _ environment - induced decoherence _ ( eid ) , determines , case by case , which is the privileged basis , usually called _ moving preferred basis _ where decoherence takes place in a _ decoherence time _ @xmath0 and it defines the observables that acquire classic characteristics and they could be interpreted in some particular cases as properties that obey a boolean logic .
this is the orthodox position in the subject @xcite .
the decoherence times in this period were much smaller , solving the problem of the first period . recently , in a third period it becomes evident that dissipation was not a necessary condition for decoherence @xcite and the study of the arrival to equilibrium of closed systems was also considered .
we will not discuss closed systems in this paper but for the sake of completeness we will make only some comments .
closed system will be discussed at large elsewhere . in this work
we focus the attention on eid , which is a well known theory , with well established experimental verifications , which makes unnecessary any further explanation . on the contrary other formalisms
are not so well established , but they must be taken into account for the sake of completeness ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . in this paper , we will introduce a tentative definition ( for eid and other formalisms ) of moving preferred basis where the state decoheres in a very short time @xmath0 , so the main problem of the first period is solved in a convenient and general way .
our main aim is to present a new conceptual perspective that will clarify some points that still remain rather obscure in the literature on the subject , e. g. the definition of the moving preferred basis . in previous works
we have resumed the common characteristics of the different approaches of decoherence , which suggest the existence of a general framework for decoherence within which these approaches can all be framed ( see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite ) . according to this general framework , that was developed in @xcite and
will be completed in future papers , decoherence is just a particular case of the general problem of irreversibility in quantum mechanics .
since the quantum state @xmath1 follows a unitary evolution , it can not reach a final equilibrium state for @xmath2 .
therefore , if the non - unitary evolution towards equilibrium is to be accounted for , a further element has to be added to this unitary evolution .
the way to introduce this non - unitary evolution must include the splitting of the whole space of observables @xmath3 into the relevant subspace @xmath4 and the irrelevant subspace .
once the essential role played by the selection of the relevant observables is clearly understood , the phenomenon of decoherence can be explained in four general steps : 1 .
* first step : * the space @xmath5 of relevant observables is defined .
* second step : * the expectation value @xmath6 , for any @xmath7 , is obtained .
this step can be formulated in two different but equivalent ways : * a coarse - grained state @xmath8 is defined by @xmath9 for any @xmath10 , and its non - unitary evolution ( governed by a master equation ) is computed ( this step is typical in eid ) . *
@xmath11 is computed and studied as the expectation value of @xmath12 in the state @xmath1 .
this is the generic case for other formalisms .
* third step : * it is proved that @xmath13 reaches a final equilibrium value @xmath14 , then @xmath15 + this also means that the coarse - grained state @xmath8 evolves towards a final equilibrium state:@xmath16 + the characteristic time for these limits is the @xmath17 , the _ relaxation time .
* fourth step : * also a _ moving preferred basis
_ @xmath18 must be defined as we will see in section i.b .
this basis is the eigen basis of certain state @xmath19 such that@xmath20 the characteristic time for this limit is the @xmath0 , the _ decoherence time . _
the final equilibrium state @xmath21 is obviously diagonal in its own eigenbasis , which turns out to be the final preferred basis .
but , from eqs .
( [ int-01 ] ) or ( [ int-02 ] ) we can not say that @xmath22 or @xmath23 then , the mathematicians say that the unitarily evolving quantum state @xmath1 of the whole system _ only has a _ _ weak limit , _ symbolized as : @xmath24 equivalent to eq .
( [ int-01 ] ) . as a consequence
, the coarse - grained state @xmath8 also has a weak limit , as follows from eq.([int-02 ] ) : @xmath25 equivalent to eq .
( [ int-02 ] ) . also@xmath26 these weak limits mean that , although the off - diagonal terms of @xmath1 never vanish through the unitary evolution , the system decoheres _ from an observational point of view _ , that is , from the viewpoint given by any relevant observable @xmath7 . from this general perspective , the phenomenon of destructive interference , that produced the decoherence phenomenon , is relative because the off - diagonal terms of @xmath1 and @xmath8 vanish only from the viewpoint of the relevant observables * * @xmath7 , and the superselection rule that precludes superpositions only retains the states defined by the corresponding decoherence bases as we will see .
the only difference between eid and other formalisms for decoherence is the selection of the relevant observables ( see @xcite for details ) : .
: : in eid the relevant observables are those having the following form:@xmath27 where @xmath28 are the observables of the system and @xmath29 is the identity operator of the environment
. then eq .
( [ 0 ] ) reads@xmath30 .
: : in the other formalisms other restriction in the set of observables are introduced the moving preferred basis was introduced , case by case in several papers ( see @xcite ) in a non systematic way . on the other hand in references @xcite and @xcite roland omns introduces a rigorous and almost general definition of the moving preferred basis based in a reasonable choice of the relevant observables , and other physical considerations . in this paper
we will introduce an alternative general definition to define this basis : as it is well known the eigen values of the hamiltonian are the inverse of the characteristic frequencies of the unitary evolution of an oscillatory system .
analogously , for non - unitary evolutions , the poles of the complex extension of the hamiltonian are the _ catalogue _ of the decaying modes of these non - unitary evolutions towards equilibrium ( see @xcite )
. this will be the main idea to implement the definition of our moving preferred basis .
i. e. we will use these poles .
we will compare and try to unify these two methods in the future .
really we already began this approach with omns in section iii . in section
i we have introduced a general framework for decoherence . a general candidate for moving decoherence basis is introduced in section [ gendefmovdecbas ] , which is implemented in three toy models and the time of decoherence and the relaxation time in these approaches are defined . in principle
these definitions can be used in eid and probably for generic formalisms . in section iii
we will present the paradigmatic eid : omns ( or lee - friedrich ) model . and show that the pole method yields the same results .
finally in section [ conclusions ] we will draw our conclusions .
one appendix completes this paper .
in this section we will try to introduce a very general theory for the moving preferred basis for _ any relevant observable space _ @xmath31
then it is necessary to endow the coordinates of observables and states in the hamiltonian basis @xmath32 ( i.e. the functions @xmath33 and @xmath34 with extra analytical properties in order to find the definition of a moving preferred basis in the most , general , convincing , and simplest way
. it is well known that this move is usual in many chapters of physic e. g. in the scattering theory ( see @xcite ) .
it is also well known that evolution towards equilibrium has two phases .
i.- a exponential dumping phase that can be described studying the analytical continuation of the hamiltonian into the complex plane of the energy ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) , a fact which is also well known in the scattering theory .
ii.- a final polynomial decaying in @xmath35 known as the long time of khalfin effect ( see @xcite , @xcite ) , which is very weak and difficult to detect experimentally ( see @xcite )
. these two phases will play an important role in the definition of the moving preferred basis .
they can be identified by the theory of analytical continuation of vectors , observables and states . to introduce the main equation we will make a short abstract of papers @xcite and @xcite .
we begin reviewing the analytical continuation for pure states .
let the hamiltonian be @xmath36 where the free hamiltonian @xmath37 satisfies ( see @xcite .
( 8) or @xcite ) @xmath38 and ( see @xcite .
( 9))@xmath39 then ( see @xcite .
( 10 ) ) @xmath40 and ( see @xcite .
( 11 ) ) @xmath41 where the @xmath42 are the eigenvectors of @xmath43 , that also satisfy eq .
( [ i ] ) .
the eigen vectors of @xmath43 are given by the lippmann - schwinger equations ( see @xcite .
( 12 ) and ( 13))@xmath44 let us now endow the function of @xmath45 with adequate analytical properties ( see @xcite ) . e.g.
let us consider that the state @xmath46 ( resp .
@xmath47 is such that it does not create poles in @xmath48 ( resp . in @xmath49 and therefore this function is analytic in the whole complex plane .
this is a simplification that we will be forced to abandon in realistic cases as we will see .
moreover we will consider that the function @xmath50 ( resp .
@xmath51 is analytic but with just one simple pole at @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 in the lower halfplane ( resp .
another pole @xmath55 on the upper halfplane@xmath56 ( see @xcite for details of figure 1 . ] ) .
there can be many of such poles but , by now , we will just consider one pole for simplicity , being the generalization straightforward
. then we make an analytic continuation of the positive @xmath45 axis to the curve @xmath57 of the lower half - plane as in figure 1 .
then ( see @xcite .
( 29 ) ) we can define@xmath58 and ( see @xcite .
( 31))@xmath59 where @xmath60 means analytic continuation .
finally it can be proved that ( see @xcite ) @xmath61 a simple extension of the eigen - decomposition of @xmath43 to the complex plane we could repeat what we have said about the pure states and the hamiltonian with the states , observables , and the liouvillian operator @xmath62 ( see a review in @xcite ) .
but we prefer to follow the line of @xcite and keep the hamiltonian framework and discuss the analytical continuation of @xmath63 that we will also symbolize as @xmath64 .
in fact from section i.a we know that this scalar is the main character so we will study its analytical properties ad nauseam .
so let us call ( see @xcite .
( 42 ) ) @xmath65 then a generic relevant observable is @xmath7 ( see @xcite eq .
( 42 ) or @xcite .
( 42))@xmath66 and the generic states is ( @xcite eq .
( 45 ) or @xcite .
( 45 ) ) @xmath67 where @xmath68 @xmath69 are defined those of eqs .
( [ 53 ] ) and ( [ 54 ] ) in the case @xmath70 ( see also @xcite eq . ( 44 ) or @xcite .
( 45))@xmath71 we will keep the treatment as general as possible , i.e. @xmath12 would be any observable such that @xmath7 and @xmath72 any state @xmath73 . and
more general than those of other formalisms .
this is why we can find the moving preferred basis in a general case containing eid as particular case .
anyhow the analyticity conditions must also be satisfied . in the case of eid
we can substitute @xmath12 by @xmath28 and @xmath8 by @xmath74 in fact , in the next subsection we will only consider the generic mean value @xmath75 for three paradigmatic model below .
model 1 with just one pole and the khalfin effect .
model 2 with two poles and model 3 with @xmath76 poles .
it can be proved ( cf .
( @xcite ) eq .
( 67 ) ) that the evolution equation of the mean value @xmath64 is @xmath77 i.e. this real mean value reads @xmath78 where @xmath79 @xmath80 @xmath81 @xmath82 these @xmath83 vectors are defined in eqs .
( [ 53 ] ) and ( [ 54 ] ) . then
, if we endow the functions with analytical properties of subsection c and there is just one pole @xmath52 in the lower halfplane , we can prove ( @xcite eq . (
70 ) ) that@xmath84 where @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 and where @xmath85 and @xmath86 are the analytical continuation in the lower half - plane of ( see ( @xcite eq .
( 54))@xmath87 and@xmath88(\widetilde{\varepsilon}|+\int d\varepsilon\int d\varepsilon^{\prime}\langle\omega^{+}|\varepsilon\rangle\langle\varepsilon^{\prime}|\omega ^{\prime+}\rangle\widetilde{(\varepsilon,\varepsilon^{\prime}}| \label{54}\ ] ] and where @xmath52 is the simple pole of figure 1 in the lower half - plane . @xmath85 and @xmath86 can be defined as in the case of eq .
( [ l.1 ] ) and ( [ l.2 ] ) .
the @xmath85 and @xmath89 can also be defined as a simple generalization of the vectors @xmath90 @xmath91 @xmath92 and @xmath93 ( @xcite . eq .
. then the eqs .
( [ 53 ] ) and ( [ 54 ] ) allow us to compute the limits ( [ int-01 ] ) and ( [ int-02 ] ) for any @xmath94 therefore we can conclude than the last four terms of equation ( [ 70 ] ) vanish with characteristic times@xmath95 respectively .
let us observe that i- .
the vanishing of the second , third , and fourth therms of eq .
( [ 70 ] ) are _ exponential decaying_. this will also be the case in more complicated models with many poles .
ii.- the @xmath96 means that the evolution of the last term of this equation corresponds to a polynomial decaying in @xmath35 , i. e. to the _ khalfin evolution_. this is a very weak effect detected in 2006 @xcite .
if there is a finite number of poles the khalfin term corresponds to the integral along the curve @xmath57 and contains the contribution of all the poles placed bellow @xmath57 with imaginary part @xmath97 such that @xmath98 , then we can choose a curve @xmath99below the poles a @xmath100 .
then the integral along the curve @xmath101 contains the effect of the poles @xmath102 thus we can choose the curve @xmath99 in such a way hat the decaying times corresponding to these poles , @xmath103 would be so small that can be neglected . ] . a closed system model for khalfin effect can be found in @xcite , section 6 , and an eid - like model in @xcite , section 5 .
now for times @xmath104 @xmath105 , eq . ( [ 70 ] ) reads@xmath106 since for @xmath104 @xmath105 the poles term has vanished is just an order of magnitude we consider that the three first imaginary parts of eqs .
( [ tc ] ) and ( [ tc ] ) are essentially equivalent . ] .
let us diagonalize @xmath8 as or the initial conditions may just choose a discrete basis ( see below).]@xmath107 where @xmath108 is the moving eigenbasis of @xmath8 .
then let us define a state @xmath109 the _ preferred state _
, such that , _ for all times , _ it would be@xmath110 so @xmath19 is a state that evolves in a model with no poles and with only the khalfin term .
these evolutions exist and can be found using an adequate interaction .
proton state in a woods - saxon potential ( see @xcite figure 3 ) .
] so we can plot @xmath111 and @xmath112 in figure 2 .
it is quite clear that for @xmath113 @xmath114 @xmath19 while for @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath19 and that for @xmath117 @xmath118 @xmath19 and also all their derivatives .
the eigen states of the @xmath19 are those that we will choose for the moving decoherence basis .
in fact , diagonalizing @xmath19 we have @xmath119 and when @xmath120 @xmath105 we have that @xmath121 so from eqs .
( [ asterisco ] ) and ( [ asterisco-b ] ) we see that the eigenbasis of @xmath1 and @xmath19 also converge @xmath122 namely the basis @xmath123 converge to @xmath124 and therefore @xmath8 becomes diagonal in @xmath125 .
thus @xmath125 is our definition for the _ moving preferred basis_. since @xmath8 becomes diagonal in the just defined preferred basis @xmath124 when @xmath117 and @xmath126 is the definition of decoherence time . in this model
the relaxation time @xmath17 is the corresponding to the khalfin term , i.e. an extremely long time so@xmath127
the khalfin term is so small ( see @xcite ) that can be neglected in most of the experimental cases .
so let us consider the case of two poles @xmath52 and @xmath128 ( and no relevant khalfin term ) where eq .
( [ 70 ] ) reads : @xmath129@xmath130 where @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 , @xmath128 @xmath131 @xmath132 and we will also consider that @xmath133 ( see @xcite section 3 , for details ) .
then the four characteristic times ( [ tc ] ) now read@xmath134 now for times @xmath104 @xmath135 , eq .
( [ 700 ] ) reads@xmath136 and we can define a state @xmath137 such that , for _ all times _ , it would be@xmath138 repeating the reasoning of eqs .
( [ 700 ] ) to ( [ asterisco-c ] ) we can see that , diagonalizing this last equation , we obtain the moving preferred basis .
then in this case we see that the relaxation is obtained by an exponential dumping ( not a khalfin term ) and @xmath139 again , in this case when @xmath120 @xmath105 we have that @xmath140 so once more we reach eq .
( [ asterisco-c ] ) .
namely @xmath1 becomes diagonal in the moving preferred basis in a time @xmath0 . before considering the many poles case
let us make some general remarks .
i.- let us observe that some @xmath141 @xmath142 @xmath143 and @xmath144 may be zero , depending in the observable @xmath145 so , in the case of many poles , may be some poles can be detected by @xmath12 and others may not be detected and disappear from the formulae ( see appendix ) .
this also is the cases for the initial conditions : @xmath146 @xmath147 @xmath148 and @xmath149 may be zero .
but also the @xmath12 or the @xmath150 may create some poles .
so some poles may be eliminated or created by the observables or the initial conditions while others may be retained .
but in general we will choose @xmath12 and @xmath150 in such a way that they would neither create or eliminate poles .
ii.- from what we have learned in both models ( see eqs .
( [ nuevo-0 ] ) and ( [ nuevo ] ) ) we always have@xmath151 let us now sketch the case of a system with @xmath76 poles located at @xmath152 these poles are the ones that remain after @xmath12 and @xmath150 have eliminated ( or created ) some poles ( see remark i ) .
in this case it is easy to see that eq .
( [ 70 ] ) ( with no khalfin term ) becomes:@xmath153 where @xmath154 is the final equilibrium value of @xmath155 in the most general case the @xmath156 will be placed either at random or not . anyhow in both cases they can be ordered as@xmath157 so in the case of @xmath158 poles , we can plot @xmath159 , @xmath160 and @xmath161 in figure 3
. then if @xmath162 it is quite clear that the relaxation time is @xmath163 so the relaxation time is defined with no ambiguity .
this is not the case for the decoherence time .
really each pole @xmath156 defines a decaying mode with characteristic time@xmath164 these poles contain the essence of the decaying phenomenon and the definition of the decoherence time depends on their distribution and other data like the initial condition .
precisely i.- for a completely random distribution clearly the best choice is@xmath165 then @xmath166 and the moving preferred basis is @xmath167 i.e. the basis that diagonalizes @xmath168 ii.- but for other kinds of distributions , if the distribution of poles obey certain law or have some patterns , we may chose something like@xmath169 as we will see in the example in the next section .
the choice of @xmath170 is based on the _ initial conditions _ and usually also introduces the concept of _ _ macroscopicity _ _ ) and variable @xmath171 .
example of this choice are the omns model and the toy models in the final remake i of the next section . once the decoherence time @xmath172is chosen the definition ( [ def ] ) changes to@xmath173 where the sum contains all the terms such that @xmath174 then the poles in evolution ( [ ev ] ) are those that produces the slowest decaying modes that we will call the _
p - relevant poles , _
i. e. those that have influence in the period @xmath175 _ _ the remaining poles such that @xmath176 that we will can the _ p - irrelevant poles _ , and have no influence in the period @xmath177 once the decoherence time is chosen the moving preferred basis is univocally defined .
it is @xmath125 , the basis that diagonalize @xmath19 , a state that evolves only influenced by the p - relevant poles , and such that @xmath178 when @xmath179 @xmath125 is our candidate for a general definition of moving preferred basis .
our more complete and simplest example of decoherence in open systems is the omns pendulum ( i. e. oscillator ) in a bath of oscillators , that we will compare with the poles theory in the following subsections .
in fact the omns model could be considered a poles model if we retain the poles and neglect the khalfin term .
moreover in the omns philosophy the moving preferred basis must be related to some collective variables in such a way that they would be experimentally accessible . in this case
this variable is the center of mass of the pendulum , i. e. the mean value of the position of a coherent state . in @xcite page 285 a one dimensional `` pendulum '' ( the system ) in a bath of oscillators ( the environment ) is considered .
the hamiltonian reads ) and equation ( [ pre ] ) .
in fact , in some stages of the treatment omns is forced go to the continuos spectrum .
a complete treatment of this continuous model can be found in @xcite.]@xmath180 where @xmath181 is the creation ( annihilation ) operator for the system , @xmath182 are the creation ( annihilation ) operator for each mode of the environment , @xmath45 and @xmath183 are the energies of the system and each mode of the environment and @xmath184 are the interaction coefficients .
then let consider a state@xmath185 where @xmath186 are _ coherent _ states for the `` system '' corresponding to the operator @xmath187 and @xmath188 @xmath189 are a coherent state for the environment corresponding to the operator @xmath190 let the initial condition be@xmath191 then @xmath192 moreover it can be shown , under reasonable hypotheses and approximations ( that correspond to the elimination of the khalfin terms , see below ) , that evolution of the @xmath193 is given by @xmath194+\text{small fluctuations } \label{rt-01}\ ] ] where @xmath195 is a shift and @xmath196 a dumping coefficient that produces that the system arrives at a state of equilibrium at @xmath197 , the _ relaxation time _ of the system , ( the small fluctuations are usually neglected ) in the next subsections using the concepts of the previous section we will prove that the omns model is a particular case of our general scheme .
let us now consider the condition of _ experimentally accessibility .
_ in fact , in the model under consideration , the initial states corresponds to the linear combination of two coherent , macroscopically different states @xmath186 that evolve to @xmath198 .
now the diagonal part of @xmath8 reads @xmath199 and , it can easily be shown @xcite that , with the choice of initial conditions of eqs .
( [ ci-17 ] ) and ( [ ci-18 ] ) , that the non diagonal part of @xmath8 is @xmath200\ ] ] then if @xmath201 ( that will be the case if @xmath202 is very big ) we have@xmath203 \label{om}\ ] ] where @xmath204 are the initial mean value of the position of the two coherent states @xmath193 .
this decaying structure is obviously produced by the combination of the initial states and the particular evolution of the system according to the discussion in the final part of the last section .
then , since @xmath205 when @xmath206 @xmath8 decoheres in the decoherence basis \{@xmath207 , which is the moving preferred basis , and the decoherence time of the system is @xmath208^{-1}t_{r } \label{131'}\ ] ] where @xmath209@xmath210@xmath211 in the next subsection we will see that we are dealing with a many poles model where the effect of decoherence is produced by these poles and the particular coherent states initial conditions , which produce a `` new collective pole mode '' with @xmath212 @xmath213 in the case of the `` pendulum '' the moving preferred basis \{@xmath214 is clear experimentally accessible since , in principle , the mean value of the position @xmath215 of the two coherent states @xmath193 can be measured and the @xmath216 and @xmath217 turn out to be two `` collective variables '' ( since they are mean values ) .
in fact , in this formalism , the main characteristic of the moving preferred basis is to be related to the `` collective variables '' .
moreover the decoherence time @xmath0 depends on the initial distance @xmath218
so we can have different decoherence times depending on the initial conditions .
let us now consider that @xmath219 , \text { \ \ \ } \phi=\operatorname{im}(\alpha_{1}\alpha_{2}^{\ast}-\alpha_{1}^{\ast}\alpha _ { 2})\ ] ] where @xmath220^{\frac{1}{2}}\ ] ] so : i.- @xmath221 even if in general @xmath222 .
ii.- when @xmath223 or @xmath224 we have @xmath225 thus when the distance between the two centers of the coherent states is very big we have a small @xmath0 and the basis \{@xmath226would be almost orthonormal .
these are the main characteristics of the experimental accessible decoherence basis of omns .
but it is important to insist that , generally , @xmath227 is only a _
non - orthonormal moving preferred basis _ , that we can approximately suppose orthonormal only in the macroscopic case , that is to say , when @xmath216 and @xmath217 are far apart . in conclusion , in this macroscopic case @xmath227 becomes a orthonormal _ moving preferred basis _ where @xmath8 becomes diagonal in a very small time .
this will be the case of the decoherence basis in @xcite , chapter 17 , and in a many examples that we can find in the bibliography ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . without this macroscopic property
it is difficult to find any trace of a boolean logic in the moving decoherence basis context of the general case or in this section .
in fact , omns obtains the boolean logic in a complete different way ( see chapter 6 of @xcite ) .
anyhow in this particular model the moving preferred basis has a perfect example for the macroscopic case .
let us now present the relation of this formalism with the poles theory .
particular important models can be studied , like the one in @xcite , with hamiltonian @xmath228 i.e. a continuous version of ( [ 1 ] ) . in this continuous version
we are forced to endow the scalar @xmath75 with the some analyticity conditions .
precisely function @xmath229 ( where @xmath230 is chosen in such a way that@xmath231 which does not vanish for @xmath232 and its analytic extension @xmath233 to the lower half plane only has a simple pole at @xmath52 .
this fact will have influence on the poles of @xmath75 as in section ii and we know that the study of @xmath75 is the essential way to understand the whole problem ( see section i a ) .
the hamiltonian ( [ pre ] ) is sometimes called the lee - friedrich hamiltonian and it is characterized by the fact that it contains different _ number of modes sector _ ( number of particle sectors in qft ) .
in fact , @xmath187 and @xmath234 are creation operators that allow to define these numbers of mode sectors .
e. g. the one mode sector will contain states like @xmath235 and @xmath236 ( where @xmath237 @xmath238 then the action of @xmath239 ( or simple the one of @xmath240 will conserve the number of modes of this sector in just one mode , since in ( [ pre ] ) all the destruction operators are preceded by a creation operator .
this also is the case for the @xmath241mode sector .
the hamiltonian of the one mode sector , is just the one of the so called friedrich model i. e. @xmath242 ( expressed just in variable @xmath243the one that it is analytically continued@xmath244 as a consequence of the analyticity condition above this simple friedrich model just shows one resonance .
in fact , th is resonance is produced in @xmath52 .
let @xmath245 be the hamiltonian of the complex extended friedrich model , then as in section ii.]:@xmath246 where @xmath247 is the only pole and @xmath248 . the lee - friedrich model , describing the interaction between a quantum oscillator and a scalar field , is extensively analyzed in the literature .
generally , this model is studied by analyzing first the one excited mode sector , i.e. the friedrich model .
then , if we compute the pole , of this last model , up to the second order in @xmath184 we obtain that @xmath249 so the pole ( that will corresponds to the pole closest to the real axis in the lee - friedrich model ) can be calculated ( see @xcite eq .
these results coincide ( mutatis mutandis ) with the one of omns book @xcite page 288 , for the pole corresponding the relaxation time .
in fact : @xmath250 where @xmath251 symbolizes the principal part , so@xmath252 then if @xmath253 we have@xmath254 namely the results of @xcite page 288 , and the one contained in eq .
( [ rt-01]).:@xmath255 so the omns result for the decoherence time _ coincides _ , as we have already said , with the one obtained by the pole theory , so @xmath256 in both frameworks .
let us now consider the lee - friedrich hamiltonian ( [ pre ] ) for the many modes sector , e. g. , as an example , for the three mode sector .
then we have that:@xmath257@xmath258@xmath259@xmath260@xmath261@xmath262@xmath263@xmath264 where @xmath265
so in the real complex plane the spectrum of @xmath43 is 1.- from the eigenvalue @xmath266 three points of the curve @xmath57 2.- from the eigenvalue @xmath267
@xmath268 @xmath269 , a pole at @xmath270and two points of the curve @xmath57 3.- from the eigenvalue @xmath271
@xmath272 @xmath273 a pole at @xmath274 and one point of the curve @xmath57 4.- from the eigenvalue a pole at @xmath275 see figure 4 : of course in the general case @xmath276 and as a consequence the spectrum is @xmath277 the curves @xmath57 , @xmath278 .
@xmath158 , ... in fact@xmath279 then if we neglect the khalfin term , since it corresponds to extremely long times , the @xmath57 disappears and we simply have@xmath280 then under this approximation the system has an effective ( non hermitian ) hamiltonian@xmath281 where @xmath282 are the creation and annihilation operators for the mode corresponding to the pole @xmath52 and @xmath76 is the corresponding number of poles operator . now
the hamiltonian of the harmonic oscillator is@xmath283 thus we see that in the no khalfin terms approximation , and taking @xmath284 ( or the last equation ) and if @xmath285 is very large only affects the real part of the pole and not the imaginary one that produces the time scales . ]
so , in this approximation , the effective lee - friedrich hamiltonian @xmath287 simply is a ( non hermitian ) version of @xmath288 with a dumping term @xmath289 moreover the basis of @xmath287 and @xmath288 are the same one , i. e.@xmath290 the probability amplitude that a pure state @xmath291 would be in the pure state @xmath292 at time @xmath35 is:@xmath293 the most general linear superposition of the eigenvectors of @xmath287 , in basis @xmath294 is:@xmath295 and the time evolution for @xmath291 must be:@xmath296 then @xmath297 we can compute @xmath298 , then @xmath299 where from eqs .
( [ rt-01 ] ) and ( [ omnes ] ) , or eq .
4.47 of @xcite we have : @xmath300 then if we neglect the khalfin term the `` energy '' levels are multiples of the fundamental `` energy '' i. e.@xmath301 where @xmath302 and the coefficients @xmath303 and @xmath304 depend in the initial conditions ( according to eq . 4.26 of @xcite ) . with the expression ( [ cuac-15 ] ) eq .
( [ ci-05 ] ) becomes @xmath305 the same recipe could be used in the fundamental scalar @xmath75 instead of @xmath306 with similar results but with more difficult calculations . as initial conditions , @xmath307
@xmath308 it is possible to choose any linear combination of the elements @xmath309 with @xmath310 . .
so we can choose the coherent states @xmath311 but we can also choose as the boundary condition an approximated version where the number modes is @xmath76 and we take @xmath312 namely an approximated quasi - coherent states or quasi - gaussian ( that becomes a coherent state when @xmath313 as we will consider below@xmath314 thus @xmath315 then let us choose the initial conditions as the sum of two quasi - gaussian functions , namely:@xmath316 where @xmath317 and @xmath318 are quasi - coherent states , precisely@xmath319 and@xmath320 thus the initial state is:@xmath321 therefore the time evolved state is@xmath322 where @xmath323 is the diagonal part ( in the basis @xmath324 ) of @xmath1 @xmath325 and @xmath326 is the non - diagonal part of @xmath1@xmath327 we choose the two quasi - gaussian ( [ ci-11 ] ) and ( [ ci-12 ] ) with center at @xmath328 , ( see @xcite eq .
( 7.15 ) page 284 ) and@xmath329@xmath330 so @xmath331 and @xmath332 are real numbers . without loss of generality (
since with a change of coordinates we can shift @xmath216 and @xmath333 we can consider that the @xmath331 and @xmath332 are both positive .
for this reason we will interchange @xmath334 and @xmath335 below .
let us not consider @xmath336 in the basis of the initial condition @xmath337then we have@xmath338 we will prove that for macroscopic initial conditions , i.e. when the peaks of the two gaussians are far from each other , the states @xmath339 are quasi - orthogonal basis , i.e.@xmath340 and indeed this is the macroscopicity condition . in fat@xmath341 so using the cauchy product and the binomial theorem we have@xmath342 and again using the cauchy product and the binomial theorem we have@xmath343 then@xmath344 so for @xmath210@xmath345 we have orthogonality as we have promised to demonstrate .
now we can consider the limit @xmath313 .
thus the last scalar product is equal to the truncated taylor series of exponential function
. then we may introduce @xmath346 the difference with the complete taylor series , and we obtain@xmath347 where @xmath348 is a correction of order @xmath349 @xmath350 with @xmath351 $ ] , then we have@xmath352 thus we have two the orthogonality conditions : 1 . to eliminate the first term of ( [ ci-21f])@xmath353 i.e. @xmath354 2 . to eliminate the second term of ( [ ci-21f ] ) , @xmath355 , then@xmath356 i.e.@xmath357 ^{\frac{1}{2\left ( n+1\right ) } } \tag{ci-21l}\ ] ] + this expression
can be simplified by a huge @xmath76 using the stirling s approximation@xmath358 in fact these are the two _ macroscopicity _ condition : that @xmath359 and @xmath76 should be large .
we will consider that @xmath360 and @xmath349 always satisfy these macroscopicity conditions .
then from ( [ ci-21f ] ) the basis @xmath361 is quasi - orthogonal and we have @xmath362 then from eq .
( [ ci-16 ] ) we have@xmath363 we can compute these products with eq .
( [ ci-09 ] ) .
for @xmath364 we have that @xmath365 and @xmath366 , then from ( [ ci-11 ] ) and since @xmath367 is a real number @xmath368 then we have@xmath369 for @xmath370 we have that @xmath365 and @xmath371 , then from ( [ ci-11 ] ) , ( [ ci-12 ] ) and since @xmath367 and @xmath372 are real numbers @xmath373 then@xmath374 for @xmath375 we have that @xmath376 and @xmath366 , then from ( [ ci-11 ] ) , ( [ ci-12 ] ) and since @xmath367 and @xmath372 are real numbers @xmath377
then@xmath378 for @xmath379 we have that @xmath376 and @xmath371 , then from ( [ ci-12 ] ) and since @xmath372 is a real number @xmath380 then@xmath381 now if we consider eqs .
( [ ci-17 ] ) and ( [ ci-18 ] ) and remember that the initial centers of the gaussians are given by eqs .
( [ ci-11 ] ) and ( [ ci-12 ] ) , with no lost of generality we can choose : @xmath382 and@xmath383 remember that we have imposed a macroscopic condition to the initial conditions , i.e. @xmath384 and @xmath385 ^{\frac{1}{2\left ( n+1\right ) } } $ ] .
so in the case given by ( [ ci-32 ] ) and ( [ ci-33 ] ) we have@xmath386 ^{\frac{1}{2\left ( n+1\right ) } } \label{ci-34}\ ] ] i.e.@xmath387 ^{\frac{1}{2\left ( n+1\right ) } } \gg \text{\ } \frac{m\omega}{\sqrt{2m\hbar^{2}\omega}}l_{0 } \label{ci-34b}\ ] ] then if we substitute ( [ ci-32 ] ) , ( [ ci-33 ] ) and ( [ ci-34 ] ) in eq . ( [ ci-25 ] ) , ( [ ci-27 ] ) , ( [ ci-29 ] ) and ( [ ci-31 ] ) and we take into account ( [ ci-34])@xmath388@xmath389@xmath390@xmath391 then if we substitute ( [ ci-35 ] ) , ( [ ci-36 ] ) , ( [ ci-37 ] ) and ( [ ci-38 ] ) in eq . ( [ ci-23 ] ) we have@xmath392 we see that in the last equation there is an exponential of an exponential , and if we develop the second exponential and substituting @xmath52 for its value according to eq . ( [ ci-07 ] ) , we have from eq .
( [ ci-20 ] ) and eq .
( [ ci-33])@xmath393 so a simple decaying time @xmath394 is given by the original pole of eq .
( [ cuac-03 ] ) but a new decaying pole appears with an imaginary part@xmath395 so , the new decaying time is @xmath396 or @xmath397 the same time was found by omns in @xcite or ( [ 131 ] ) and corresponds to the definition ( [ 34 ] ) .
in fact , we can recover the same result . in @xcite
the result is valid for small @xmath35 . in the general case , and considering that @xmath398 , from eqs .
( [ ci-20 ] ) and ( [ ci-39 ] ) we have:@xmath399 \label{ci-43}\ ] ] the same expression that can be found on page 290 of @xcite .
so the coincidence of both formalisms is completely proved .
[ [ final - remarks . ] ] final remarks .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + i.- as we have said in the macroscopic case the basis \{@xmath210@xmath400 is orthogonal and it is the one defined in section ii.f .
in fact for @xmath113 the evolution of @xmath8 is produced by the p - relevant poles while for @xmath115 the evolution is produced by all the poles , either p - relevant and p - irrelevant .
moreover the corresponding @xmath8 and @xmath19 coincide at @xmath401 with all their derivatives .
ii.- let us see what happens if we change the two gaussian initial condition by @xmath402 then it can be proved that if @xmath403 the decoherence times are @xmath404 .
therefore these times change with @xmath285 .
these example shows that the initial condition chooses and the relevant poles define @xmath0 as explained in section ii.f nevertheless in any case we always have that @xmath405 these results coincide with those of zurek spin model @xcite where we also have an initial condition dependence .
this examples shows that there are many candidates decoherence times and that the initial conditions choose among them .
in this paper we have : i.- discussed a general scheme of decoherence , that in principle can be used by many formalisms .
ii.- we have given a quite general definition of a moving preferred basis @xmath125 and of the relaxation time iii.- we have introduced different characteristic ( decaying evolution ) times , and also how the decoherence time is chosen by the initial conditions .
we hope that these general results will produce some light in the general problem of decoherence .
the omns formalism , of references @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , contains the most general definition of moving preferred basis of the literature on the subject .
our basis have another conceptual frame : the catalogue of decaying modes in the non - unitary evolution of a quantum system .
but since the omns formalism is the best available it is very important for us to show the coincidence of both formalisms , as we have done in one model , at least ( see section iii ) .
of course we realize that , to prove our proposal , more examples must be added , as we will do elsewhere .
but we also believe that we have a good point of depart .
in fact , probably the coincidences that we have found in the omns model could be a general feature of the decoherence phenomenon .
essentially because , being the poles catalogue the one that contains _ all the possible decaying modes _ of the non unitary evolutions , since relaxation and decoherence are non - unitary evolutions , necessarily they must be contained within this catalogue , .
we are very grateful to roberto laura , olimpia lombardi , roland omns and maximilian schlosshauer for many comments and criticisms .
this research was partially supported by grants of the university of buenos aires , the conicet and the foncyt of argentina .
in this appendix we will introduce a particular example of observables , of the same system , such that some observables would see some poles while other would see other ones .
essentially it is a bi - friedrich - model .
let us consider a system @xmath406 with hamiltonian:@xmath407 where@xmath408 and @xmath409 d\omega+\int_{b}^{\infty}v_{\omega^{\prime } } ^{(2)}\left [ |\omega^{\prime}\rangle\langle2|+|2\rangle\langle \omega^{\prime}|\right ] d\omega\ ] ] where @xmath410 and @xmath411 this hamiltonian can also reads:@xmath412 where@xmath413 d\omega^{\prime}\ ] ] then it is easy to prove that@xmath414=0\ ] ] and that@xmath415 let us now decompose the system as @xmath416 where part @xmath417 is related with hamiltonian @xmath418 and part @xmath419 related with hamiltonian @xmath420 .
let us observe that these two parts are not independent since they share a common continuous spectrum , i. e. @xmath421 .
moreover let the corresponding relevant observable spaces be @xmath422 for @xmath417 and @xmath423 for @xmath424 where @xmath425 has basis \{@xmath426 and @xmath427 has basis \{@xmath428 while @xmath429 has basis \{@xmath430 and @xmath431 basis \{@xmath432 moreover let us consider the two relevant observables of system @xmath416 @xmath433 where the @xmath434 are the corresponding unit operators
. then @xmath435@xmath436 and therefore @xmath437 only sees the evolution in part @xmath417 while @xmath438 only sees the evolution in part @xmath439 then , since the poles of part @xmath417 correspond to the decaying modes of the evolution of this part ( and we know that the friedrich model of this subsystem generically do have poles ) @xmath437 only sees the poles of part @xmath417 .
respectively @xmath438 only sees the poles of part @xmath439 q. e. d. now we can consider that the poles of part @xmath417 define a relaxation time @xmath440while the poles of part @xmath419 define a relaxation time @xmath441 if @xmath442part @xmath417 decoheres and becomes classical in a short time @xmath443while
part @xmath419 remains quantum for a large time @xmath444 then for @xmath35 such that @xmath445 part @xmath417 behaves classically while part @xmath419 remains quantum .
precisely : system @xmath406 observed by @xmath446 seems classical while observed by @xmath447 seems quantum .
in fact this is the behavior of a generic physical system . | there are many formalisms to describe quantum decoherence .
however , many of them give a non general and ad hoc definition of pointer basis or moving preferred basis , and this fact is a problem for the decoherence program . in this paper
we will consider quantum systems under a general theoretical framework for decoherence and present a very general definition of the moving preferred basis .
in addition , this definition is implemented in a well known model and the time of decoherence and the relaxation time are defined and compared with those of this model . |
study of the cool neutral gas over various redshifts gives insight into the evolution of the star forming reservoir and is a science goal of the forthcoming square kilometre array ( ska , @xcite ) .
the distribution of cool neutral hydrogen ( ) with galactocentric radius in external galaxies is crucial in interpreting the data from the forthcoming surveys of 21-cm absorption with the ska and its pathfinders . , @xcite ) .
] to this end , we @xcite have undertaken a survey of 21-cm absorption of background radio sources at various impact parameters in the disks of intervening , nearby galaxies ( @xmath3 , fig .
[ distbn ] ) . for impact parameters of @xmath4 kpc ,
the detection rate is approximately 50 per - cent @xcite .
however , @xcite find a significantly lower detection rate ( 4 per - cent ) , which they attribute to the unbiased nature of their sample .
that is , no target pre - selection based upon impact parameter nor the nature of the background source . for a given sight - line
, a background radio galaxy could result in a lower covering factor , reducing the observed optical depth in comparison to a quasar ( see sect .
[ ebss ] ) .
although the gas density in a galaxy is known to decrease with galactocentric radius ( e.g. @xcite ) , none of the previous surveys have found convincing evidence of a decrease in 21-cm absorption strength with impact parameter ( @xcite ) .
this is despite evidence of an anti - correlation between the lyman- and civ equivalent widths and the impact parameter being well established in the optical / uv bands ( e.g. @xcite ) . by adding the latest results @xcite to the previously published data and incorporating the limits , obtained from the non - detections , here we report the first clear evidence of an anti - correlation between the 21-cm absorption strength and the impact parameter .
there are now 90 spectral line observations of radio source sight - lines through the disks of galaxies ( summarised in table [ table1 ] ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,>,^,>,^,^ " , ] references : h75 @xcite , b88
@xcite , c90
@xcite , c92
@xcite , k02 @xcite , h04
@xcite , b10
@xcite , g10
@xcite , b11
@xcite , g13
@xcite , s13
@xcite , b14
@xcite , r15
@xcite , z15
@xcite , d16
@xcite , r16 @xcite . +
notes : @xmath5also observed by @xcite .
@xmath6obtained from the quoted integrated flux density of the emission or the quoted mass . in order to fully utilise these data
, we include the upper limits to the optical depths ( from the non - detections ) , via the _ astronomy survival analysis _
( asurv ) package @xcite .
these are added to the 16 detected sight - lines as censored data points . for the bivariate data ,
a generalised non - parametric kendall - tau test gives a probability of @xmath7 of the observed @xmath8@xmath9 anti - correlation correlation arising by chance , which is significant at @xmath10 , assuming gaussian statistics ( fig .
[ n - impact ] , top panel ) .
as seen from table [ table1 ] , only 14 of the 90 sight - lines were originally targetted as known metal - line absorbers , although these drive the correlation giving a @xmath11 significance from just 14 data points . however , this is due to the metal - line absorbers constituting 11 of the 16 detections , which define the parent population against which the limits are quantified , thus requiring their inclusion . the limits may also be included in the binned univariate data to give the mean @xmath12 value of each bin , via the kaplan
meier estimator which gives a maximum - likelihood estimate based upon the parent population @xcite . presenting the data thus , it is visually apparent that the absorption strength does decrease with increasing impact parameter ( fig .
[ n - impact ] , bottom panel ) .
in addition to the generalised kendall - tau test and the kaplan meier estimates , we split the data in half via the median impact parameter : at @xmath13 kpc , there are 14 detections and 31 non - detections , that is a 31.1 per - cent detection rate .
applying this to the @xmath14 kpc bin , gives a binomial probability of @xmath15 of obtaining two detections or fewer out of 45 sight - lines , which is significant at @xmath16 .
although by the inclusion of the limits , we see a decrease in absorption strength with impact parameter , the sample is heterogeneous , comprising a variety of background source classifications ( discussed in sect .
[ ebss ] ) , in addition to potential differences in the foreground absorbing galaxies .
these may arise from the search strategy of each individual survey , whether an unbiased survey towards galaxy quasar pairs or the selection of _ known _ metal - line absorbers .
the detection rate of the former is just 7% , compared to 79 per - cent for the latter , with these also tending to be at low impact parameters ( fig .
[ n - impact ] ) .
such metal - line absorbers also comprise the foreground galaxies in the optical surveys which exhibit an equivalent width
impact parameter anticorrelation ( sect .
[ intro ] ) . until all of the sample is observed and their metallicities quantified ,
this possible bias can not be directly removed .
however , both metallicity and equivalent width appear to be correlated with galaxy size ( @xcite ) and so a potentially wide range of metallicities is expected to reflect a large range of galaxy sizes .
this could have the effect of a given impact parameter , which lies well within the disk for an @xmath17 ( high metallicity ) galaxy , being located well outside the disk of a dwarf galaxy . in order to account for this ,
we normalise each impact parameter by the luminosity of the galaxy : as described in @xcite , for each galaxy we obtain the photometry from nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ) and the two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ) , correcting each value for galactic extinction @xcite before fitting to the required wavelength in the galaxy rest - frame .
we summarise the derived blue - band luminosities in fig .
[ l - blue ] . using these to normalise the impact parameter , via the same @xmath18 correction as @xcite
, we find the absorption strength
impact parameter anti - correlation retains a similar significance , although with 16 fewer data points . as before , we can also compare detection rates above and below the median ( normalised ) impact parameter : at @xmath19 kpc , there are 9 detections and 28 non - detections , that is a 24.3 per - cent detection rate .
applying this to the @xmath20 kpc bin , gives a binomial probability of @xmath21 of obtaining two or fewer detections out of 37 sight - lines , which is significant at @xmath22 .
@xcite also normalise the impact parameter by the near - infrared luminosity , since this is less susceptible to extinction and irregularities caused by star formation , providing a better tracer of the total stellar mass . normalising the impact parameter , the significance of the anti - correlation increases ( fig .
[ l - k ] ) and , again comparing detection rates above and below the median ( normalised ) impact parameter : at @xmath23 kpc , there are 10 detections and 21 non - detections , that is a 30.5 per - cent detection rate . applying this to the @xmath24 kpc bin , gives a binomial probability of @xmath25 of obtaining one detection or fewer out of 33 sight - lines , which is significant at @xmath26 .
since we have both the blue and near - infrared luminosities for many of the galaxies , we can verify that the observed decrease in @xmath12 with impact parameter is not dominated by a colour bias , where the redder ( and presumably , dustier ) galaxies are more hospitable to the presence of cool gas . in fig .
[ colour ] we plot the 21-cm absorption strength against the @xmath27 colour , where no correlation is apparent , leaving the decrease in gas density with impact parameter the major most likely cause .
we also note that the known metal - line systems do exhibit some reddening ( @xmath28 ) , which is consistent with the metallicity dust ( and molecular fraction ) relation ( see @xcite and references therein ) . as mentioned in sect .
[ intro ] , in addition to the impact parameter , it is believed that the extent of the background source can have an effect on the 21-cm detection rate .
specifically , for a given absorption cross section pc @xcite .
] different background source sizes will have different observed optical depths , @xmath29 , according to @xmath30 in the optically thin regime @xcite . ] , where the observed optical depth is defined as the ratio of the line depth to the continuum ( @xmath31 ) .
given that the covering factor ranges over @xmath32 for zero to full coverage of the background flux , larger background sources could give systematically lower observed optical depths .
that is , we may expect the more compact quasar sight - lines to give a higher detection rate than those of radio galaxies . addressing this , from the ned classifications , contrary to our expectations , we find a higher ( @xmath33 per - cent ) detection rate towards radio galaxies compared to the quasars ( @xmath34 per - cent , fig .
[ sl ] ) . performing a pearson @xmath35statistic test and applying yates s correction for continuity gives a significance of @xmath36 .
thus , the null hypothesis that the detection rates are the equal for radio galaxies and quasars can not be rejected .
it is generally accepted that the turnover frequency of a radio source is anti - correlated with its extent ( e.g. @xcite ) , with flat spectral indices arising from radio emission projected along our line - of - sight , thus also appearing more compact .
therefore , in the absence of high resolution radio images , we can use any clustering of either or both the turnover frequency / spectral index to gauge whether an unclassified background source is likely to be a quasar or a radio galaxy .
we therefore compiled the photometry of each background source and , using the methods described in @xcite , determined the rest - frame turnover frequency , @xmath37 , and spectral index at a rest frequency of 1.4 ghz , @xmath38 .
from this ( fig .
[ to - si ] ) , we see that both the radio galaxies and unclassified sources , for which both @xmath37 and @xmath38 could be determined , are too few in number to exhibit any clustering , which is absent from the sources classified as qsos in any case .
thus , at least at present , this method is of little use in predicting the nature of the background source . based upon this limited sample ,
however , we see that , while there is a large overlap in the spectral indices ( although the detections are more `` flat '' , @xmath39 ) , the detections and non - detections have distinct mean turnover frequencies ( @xmath40 and @xmath41 hz , respectively ) . since the turnover frequency is anti - correlated with the source size ( e.g. @xcite ) , this is consistent with a detection bias towards the more compact radio sources , indicating that the covering factor is important . in the optically thin regime ( equ .
[ tau_eq ] ) , the neutral hydrogen column density , @xmath0 [ ] , is related to the absorption strength via @xmath42 where @xmath43 [ k ] is the spin temperature of the gas and @xmath44 [ ] the velocity integrated optical depth of the absorption . the comparison of @xmath44 with @xmath0 , from lyman- ( @xmath45 ) observations , has shown an increase in @xmath46 with redshift , possibly suggesting an evolution in the spin temperature ( e.g. @xcite ) . however , the effect can adequately be accounted for by a decrease in @xmath47 with redshift , due to the geometry effects of an expanding universe @xcite .
for this near - by sample we have the opportunity to determine whether @xmath46 generally varies with galactocentric radius , which could possibly introduce a beam - filling effect , where the mean value of @xmath46 within the beam could also contribute to a redshift dependence . given that the gas is optically thin , for the low redshifts of the sample ( fig . [ distbn ] ) , where 21-cm emission can be detected ( @xmath48 , @xcite ) , the column density can be obtained directly from the brightness temperature of the line emission , @xmath49 [ k ] , via @xmath50 which in conjunction with equ .
[ n_eq ] yields @xmath46 . plotting this ( fig .
[ toverf ] ) , we see no evidence of a variation in @xmath46 with the normalised impact parameter over @xmath51 kpc , which corresponds to the inner @xmath52 kpc of galactocentric radius . this is consistent the result of @xcite , who find remarkably little variation in the spin temperature over radii of 825 kpc in the milky way , despite both the 21-cm emission and absorption strengths varying by two orders of magnitudes . by assuming the known column density distribution of the milky way
, we can estimate the approximate orientation of the average absorbing disk , based upon the @xmath8@xmath9 relationship : the galactic volume density of the neutral gas exhibits an exponential decrease with galactocentric radius according to @xmath53 , where @xmath54 and the scale - length @xmath55 kpc @xcite .
the column density at each value of @xmath9 is obtained from the volume density via @xmath56 , where @xmath57 for a face - on ( @xmath58 ) disk , is given by the flare factor , @xmath59 , which describes the flaring of the gas with galactocentric radius @xcite . ] and @xmath60 for an edge - on ( @xmath61 ) disk ( fig .
[ model ] ) . from this , the face - on galactic disk appears to better trace the binned integrated optical depth values , again with @xmath62 k remaining approximately consistent with galactocentric radius out to @xmath63 kpc , beyond which this falls to @xmath64 k ( fig . [ toverf ] ) .
applying the edge - on galactic disk would give much larger values of @xmath46 , due either to very high spin temperatures and/or very low covering factors , the latter of which would be expected from a low inclination disk presenting a much smaller absorbing cross - section .
we thus suggest that the targetted galaxies tend to have face - on inclinations , which is consistent with the observations of @xcite , who , from the azimuthal profiles of the emission , suggest that the intervening galaxies could be highly inclined ( or highly asymmetric ) .
one of the goals of current surveys for 21-cm absorption at various impact parameters is to determine the expected detection rate of cool , neutral gas in distant galaxies with the next generation of large radio telescopes .
an important aspect of this is the determination of the expected detection rate of 21-cm absorption at redshifts where the detection of 21-cm emission will not be possible . here
we demonstrate a clear anti - correlation between the integrated optical depth and the impact parameter , where previously only weak correlations were apparent at best ( significance levels of @xmath65 , @xcite ) .
also , investigating the hypothesis that 21-cm absorption is more readily detected towards quasars in comparison to radio galaxies , we find that the statistics are insufficient to draw any conclusions .
however , we do find that the mean detection occurs towards a radio source with a higher turnover frequency than a non - detection . since the turnover frequency is anti - correlated with source size ,
this suggests that the coverage of the background emission is important and thus we would expect a higher detection rate towards quasars in comparison to radio galaxies .
lastly , using the neutral hydrogen column density obtained from the 21-cm emission , we find no statistical evidence for a variation of the spin temperature ( degenerate with the covering factor ) over the inner @xmath66 kpc of the disk , similar to the consistency in spin temperature observed across the milky way @xcite . by using @xmath67 obtained from the distribution of the milky way , the observed @xmath8@xmath9 correlation may suggest that the intervening galactic disks have high inclinations ( close to face - on ) .
this is consistent with the emission maps of @xcite , who suggest that galaxies which intercept background sources may be highly inclined .
we wish to thank the anonymous referee for their helpful and detailed comments and the _ radio galaxy morning tea _ group at the university of sydney for useful discussion .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration and nasa s astrophysics data system bibliographic service .
this research has also made use of nasa s astrophysics data system bibliographic service and asurv rev 1.2 @xcite , which implements the methods presented in @xcite .
c. , 2000 , in evn symposium 2000 , proceedings of the 5th european vlbi network symposium , conway j. e. , polatidis a. g. , booth r. s. , pihlstrm y. m. , eds .
, onsala space observatory , chalmers technical university , gteborg , sweden , p. 73 | by combining the data from surveys for 21-cm absorption at various impact parameters in near - by galaxies , we report an anti - correlation between the 21-cm absorption strength ( velocity integrated optical depth ) and the impact parameter . also , by combining the 21-cm absorption strength with that of the emission , giving the neutral hydrogen column density , @xmath0 , we find no evidence that the spin temperature of the gas ( degenerate with the covering factor ) varies significantly across the disk .
this is consistent with the uniformity of spin temperature measured across the galactic disk .
furthermore , comparison with the galactic @xmath0 distribution suggests that intervening 21-cm absorption preferentially arises in disks of high inclinations ( near face - on ) .
we also investigate the hypothesis that 21-cm absorption is favourably detected towards compact radio sources . although there is insufficient data to determine whether there is a higher detection rate towards quasar , rather than radio galaxy , sight - lines , the 21-cm detections intervene objects with a mean turnover frequency of @xmath1 hz , compared to @xmath2 hz for the non - detections .
since the turnover frequency is anti - correlated with radio source size , this does indicate a preferential bias for detection towards compact background radio sources .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : structure galaxies : ism radio lines : galaxies quasars : absorption lines |
in einsteinian gravity , when quantum corrections are taken into account the determination of the cosmological constant ( cc ) , @xmath0 , is very much related with vacuum fluctuations and , eventually , the casimir effect @xcite , in one way or other @xcite .
the problem of the cc is one of the most important and intriguing in modern cosmology and qft .
the traditional way to understand why @xmath0 is so small ( @xmath4 in planck units ) is ordinarily based on the anthropic principle @xcite . up to now
one has no reasonable alternative way to explain this fact in einsteinian gravity , unless one moves on to extended models with dynamical dark energy or modified gravities @xcite . recently
barrow and shaw @xcite suggested a non - anthropic solution to the problem : by making @xmath0 into a field and restricting the variations of the action with respect to it by causality , they managed to obtain an additional einstein constraint equation .
one can say that this approach is based on a different _ interpretation _ of the cosmological constant , notably to consider the cosmological constant to be a field variable . in the present work we use a somehow similar procedure to calculate the value of @xmath0 , namely to interpret it as an eigenvalue of a sturm - liouville problem , rather than as an integration constant .
our approach is in fact more conservative than the method in @xcite since we use the standard einstein - friedmann equations _ without _ any additional constraint equation .
instead , we consider one of friedmann s equations as a spectral problem and look for a class of boundary conditions which may allow us to actually calculate the corresponding eigenvalues ( in this way , our procedure is closely related to standard investigations of the casimir effect @xcite by spectral methods ) .
a most simple condition is to impose that eigenfunctions be elements of @xmath1 .
as we will show , this choice results in the following interesting consequence : if the universe is filled up with a matter field , @xmath5 ( except for @xmath0 ) , such that all the strong energy conditions are satisfied , then one gets a point spectrum for positive values of the cosmological constant , and a continuous spectrum for negative ones .
the next step will be to consider models which actually result in a positive discrete spectrum with just one _ single _ point .
this idea is inspired in the conceptual approach developed in the paper by linde and vanchurin @xcite : one can fix all the parameters in the landscape , including the value of the cosmological constant , without using any anthropic considerations , what `` will give us a chance to return to einstein s dream of a final theory , which may allow us to make sharp and unambiguous predictions despite the abundance of choices '' . clearly , this case of a one - point spectrum is a good example of a possible realization of this cherished dream .
an additional bonus of our approach is the surprising connection that will be uncovered between the steinhardt - turok cyclic models @xcite and barrow s sudden singularity @xcite or singularity of type ii according to the classification in @xcite . in short , on one hand , models with steinhardt - turok - like cyclic potentials may indeed have much to do with those singularities , and on the other hand , such models exhibit a single - point positive spectrum for @xmath0 in the framework of our approach .
this striking connection will be a crucial issue in this article .
a method for constructing and analyzing exact cosmological solutions of the einstein equations based on representing them as a second - order linear equation ( we call this the linearization method , in what follows ) was discussed in @xcite ( other methods for constructing exact solutions in cosmology can be found in @xcite-@xcite ) .
indeed , it is easy to see that , in the case of the flat friedmann metric , the third power of the scale factor @xmath6 satisfies the equation @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the density and @xmath9 the pressure of the matter filling the universe . in this paper
we use the system of units with @xmath10 . in the case when a minimally coupled scalar field , @xmath5 , with the self - interaction potential @xmath11 , is dominant , and in the presence of a cosmological constant with density @xmath0 , eq .
( [ a3 ] ) formally coincides with the schrdinger equation @xmath12 where the potential is @xmath13 , and the spectral parameter is @xmath14 . in ( [ schr ] ) , the quantity @xmath15 is assumed to be a function of time : @xmath16 , which has been called _ the history _ of the potential in @xcite .
giving an explicit form @xmath17 together with the corresponding boundary conditions allows to find the general solution of eq .
( [ schr ] ) . an important consequence of this investigation is that the regime is independent of , or just weakly dependent on the type of the potential , what is quite significant for the whole theory .
unfortunately , the ubiquitous problem of the end of inflation turns out to be substantially more difficult here , and solving it in the framework of the approach described above apparently involves additional assumptions .
( the authors of @xcite proposed modifying the potentials to make them depend on the temperature . stablishing a friedmann regime can then be described as a phase transition in the matter state of the early universe ) .
the study of eq .
( [ schr ] ) in its applications to cosmology was continued in @xcite and @xcite , where the darboux transformation was used to construct new exact solutions ( a similar technique was used in @xcite to obtain exact solutions on the brane and on the encompassing space carrying an orbifold structure ) .
we consider the einstein equations in the friedmann metric , @xmath18 and assume that @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 is a solution of these equations , for @xmath22 .
then , the function @xmath23 is a solution of the schrdinger equation @xmath24 where the `` potential '' is @xmath25 if the universe is filled up with a scalar field @xmath5 with the lagrangian @xmath26 , then @xmath27 the effectiveness of the method presented in @xcite ( and developed in @xcite and @xcite ) , precisely consists in reducing a complex nonlinear problem into a linear equation .
this allows to obtain a complete set of two - parameter solutions , which exhibit inflationary behavior under very general assumptions .
the fact that @xmath28 basically coincides with @xmath15 was not used anywhere in those papers and consequently played no role there . in a similar way
, we here consider a generalization of this method to arbitrary @xmath29 .
further to this point , the physical meaning of the `` potential '' @xmath30 is clear only for a universe filled with a scalar field .
indeed , if we consider a universe in which , for instance , electromagnetic radiation is dominant , the physical meaning of the quantity @xmath30 becomes again ambiguous .
we note that if a solution of ( [ schr ] ) is known , then we can use eqs .
( [ ein1 ] ) and ( [ schr ] ) to find the scalar field @xmath31 and the potential @xmath32 . \label{vt}\ ] ] in principle we can obtain the dependence @xmath33 from these expressions , although it is clearly not always possible to do this explicitly . for example , if @xmath34 and @xmath35 then @xmath36 and @xmath37 after performing the bogoliubov transformation @xmath38 . in the general case ,
a solution of ( [ 2 ] ) has the form @xmath39 where @xmath40 is a linearly independent solution with the same potential : @xmath41 equation ( [ general ] ) allows to prove the following statement .
* assertion*. let @xmath19 be a solution of ( [ ein1 ] ) and ( [ ein2 ] ) for @xmath22 and the corresponding @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
then , the three - parameter function @xmath42 , of the form @xmath43 is a solution of eqs .
( [ ein1 ] ) and ( [ ein2 ] ) for the new energy density @xmath44 and pressure @xmath45 satisfying the condition @xmath46 finally , if we assume that the universe contains a nonzero vacuum energy with density @xmath47 , in addition to the matter fields , then eq .
( [ 2 ] ) takes the form of the spectral problem @xmath48 where the spectral parameter is @xmath49 . just as for eq .
( [ schr ] ) , we can consider a problem for the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of eq .
( [ scr-11 ] ) , if we specify homogeneous initial conditions . as
noted in @xcite , eq .
( [ schr ] ) has the form of a quantum mechanical problem with a discrete spectrum .
the fact that each solution of this kind only admits a bounded or countable set of allowed values of the cosmological constant ( if we specify homogeneous initial conditions ) may help a lot to clarify the question of the actual value of the cosmological constant .
it is clear that , in the case @xmath34 , the sec results in the condition @xmath50 . if one would like to obtain the discrete spectrum of @xmath0 for such potentials
, one would need to suggest @xmath51 at @xmath52 and this readily means that one can get the discrete spectrum for positive values of @xmath0 only .
this leads one to ask the following question : is it possible to obtain models with a discrete spectrum containing just one single point ? for answer one
need to use some boundary condition on @xmath53 . in this article
we suggested that @xmath54 is element of square - integrable functional space @xmath55 .
this is just the hypotheses about boundary condition .
therefore , our aim looks as follows : to investigate the class of cosmologies which results in just one allowed value of vacuum energy , on conditions that @xmath54 is element of @xmath55 .
we d like to understand rather physical ground which may results in this picture . in the issue , we have obtained two results , two cosmologies which admits the possibility under consideration : \1 ) the universe with some new form of sudden future singularity ( sec .
\2 ) the universe without exact sudden future singularity ( rather with `` smoothed singularity '' ) but filled with scalar field @xmath5 with deep narrow self - acting potential @xmath11 ( sec .
such potential is very similar with cyclic potential of steinhardt - turok ( st ) except that the st cyclic potential @xmath11 has a different asymptotic behavior at @xmath56 .
therefore , to obtain st potential ( and breathe the life into our formal model ! ) one need to modified the model from the sec .
we do it in the sec .
thus , we have two cosmologies which allows one to obtain the extreme form of non - anthropic solution of the problem of cosmological constant .
remarkably , these cosmologies are not absolutely new , speculative models ; vice versa , these cosmologies are connected with two well known and popular ( at present ) models ; barrow sudden future singularities and steinhardt - turok cyclic models . and last , but not least : these two models are connected to each other by the following way - the sudden model ( sec .
3 ) may be obtained from the `` st '' models by the limiting process .
we assume that the matter field contains baryons , that there is also radiation and dark matter , and that the dark matter leads to a sudden future singularity at @xmath57 , namely @xmath58 for the realization ( [ sfs ] ) , let us choose the dark matter pressure to be of the form : @xmath59 hence , @xmath60 is the `` regular '' part of the function @xmath61 , while @xmath62 is a positive constant . from the equation of state for the dark matter ,
@xmath63 , in which @xmath64 , it follows that @xmath65 .
then , for the energy density and pressure , we have @xmath66 the contribution of the dark matter decreases with time for @xmath67 . for @xmath68 , @xmath69 and we can neglect @xmath70 in the equations .
therefore , eq . ( [ scr-11 ] ) can be written in the form @xmath71 let us now assume that the function @xmath72 is continuous at the point @xmath57 .
the first derivative of the scale factor has a gap at the time of occurrence of the sudden future singularity , and @xmath73 where @xmath74 and @xmath75 . from the physical point of view
, this gap corresponds to a density jump in the singularity .
one gets , @xmath76 for simplicity one can set @xmath77 . therefore ,
if the universe expands before the time @xmath57 , then at time @xmath57 contraction begins .
it is clear that the solutions for @xmath67 and @xmath78 can not be connected .
but it is interesting to investigate this model further .
the condition ( [ jump-1 ] ) at @xmath77 leads to @xmath79 therefore , the density at the time of sfs is given by @xmath80 .
one notes that for the open universe the following condition should be satisfied @xmath81 solving ( [ 8 ] ) with the conditions @xmath82 and @xmath83 yields @xmath84 therefore , the value of @xmath0 is unique and , for the vacuum energy density , we have @xmath85 condition ( [ condopen ] ) can be written as follows @xmath86
strictly speaking , the model in the previous section has no physical sense .
this is because one had to consider two different universes ( with positive and negative hubble roots , respectively ) separated by the singularity .
one needs to involve a smoothed `` singularity '' , such that @xmath87 , but @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
let us take @xmath90 if @xmath91 , we have @xmath92 and taking into account that @xmath93 one concludes that @xmath94 the potential as a function of time , for various values of @xmath95 , is depicted on fig .
1 . therefore , for @xmath96 the potential ( [ ssfs ] ) leads to a sudden future singularity , as considered above .
we assume that @xmath97 but @xmath98 .
the solution of ( [ scr-11 ] ) , for the potential ( [ ssfs ] ) , can be written in the form @xmath99 here @xmath100 is the hypergeometric function , and we have used the following definitions : @xmath101 the condition @xmath102 corresponds to @xmath103 .
finiteness of the function requires that @xmath104 and , therefore , for the spectrum @xmath105 for @xmath91 , one can easily show that @xmath106 but there is the condition that @xmath107 ( as for @xmath108 the function ( [ psi - ssfs ] ) diverges at @xmath109 ) .
therefore , @xmath110 and from eq .
( [ spectrum ] ) one has @xmath111 for sufficiently large @xmath112 this inequality can be satisfied for @xmath113 only .
the remaining single eigenvalue is given by @xmath114 and , in this limit , one gets for the cosmological constant this same value . for the eigenfunctions ( [ psi - ssfs ] ) @xmath115 and the hubble parameter is @xmath116 for the matter pressure and density , we get @xmath117 the evolution of the scalar field can be obtained from the condition @xmath118 , @xmath119 for simplicity , we choose the `` + '' sign in ( [ phissfs ] ) and set @xmath120 .
the potential of the scalar field is similar to the sine - gordon potential : @xmath121 the potential of scalar field as function of @xmath5 is depicted on fig .
2 . for large @xmath112 the scalar field changes sufficiently
the corresponding potential at @xmath122 , for @xmath123 , has a deep well : @xmath124 .
the depth of the well grows , while its width decreases , with @xmath95 . ] .
the scalar field rolls up from 0 to @xmath125 ]
the potential considered in previous section is very similar with cyclic potential except that the steinhardt - turok cyclic potential @xmath11 has a different asymptotic behavior at @xmath56 .
one can easily construct this potential starting from an appropriate @xmath17 .
let us here investigate the case when the potential @xmath17 is taken with the form of a potential well @xmath126 @xmath127 @xmath128 here @xmath129 , and @xmath130 are positive constants
. one can perform the parametrization @xmath131 , @xmath132 , where @xmath133 and @xmath134 are new constants , and write the solution ( [ scr-11 ] ) in the form \1 ) @xmath135 : @xmath136 2)@xmath137 : @xmath138 \3 ) @xmath139 : @xmath140 here @xmath141 and @xmath142 are constants .
we consider the solutions which are finite at @xmath143 .
the function @xmath72 and its first derivative should be continuous at the points @xmath144 and @xmath122 .
these conditions can be written as @xmath145 the first condition yields @xmath146 , and the second @xmath147 . solving these equations for @xmath148 and @xmath142
, one gets @xmath149 and @xmath150 we now take the limits @xmath151 , @xmath152 , and assume that @xmath153 where @xmath154 .
this limit corresponds to increasing the depth of the potential well at @xmath155 and narrowing it so that its area remains constant .
we also assume , for simplicity , that @xmath156 . then , the condition ( [ cond ] ) can be written as @xmath157 from the condition @xmath158 , that is @xmath159 , the corresponding one on the value of @xmath148 follows : @xmath160 thus , the value of the cosmological constant is unique and it is completely determined by the width and the depth of the well , and by the parameter @xmath134 , too . using eqs .
( [ phit ] ) , ( [ vt ] ) we can obtain the evolution of the scalar field @xmath161 and potential @xmath11 . for simplicity
we assume that @xmath22 . for @xmath162 , from these equations
we have , in the case of flat spacetime \(i ) @xmath135 : @xmath163 \(ii ) @xmath155 : @xmath164 \(iii ) @xmath139 : @xmath165 in fact we have here used an unphysical sharp - cornered potential well . in a more realistic situation one needs use a potential well with `` rounded edges '' . in this case
, the potential of the scalar field @xmath11 becomes a smooth function of @xmath5 .
now , let us consider eqs .
( [ solution2 ] ) and put that @xmath166 then @xmath167 . since , at @xmath168 , @xmath169 and , at @xmath122 , @xmath170 , one must conclude that @xmath171 therefore , in the interval @xmath155 the potential exhibits a very narrow and deep peak , of width @xmath172 and depth @xmath173 .
it is our conclusion that in a more realistic case one will obtain a potential for the scalar field similar to the potentials in cyclic models .
it is interesting to consider the conditions ( [ cond ] ) and ( [ cond-2 ] ) for a well with finite depth and width .
the parameters @xmath133 and @xmath134 can be expressed through the spectral parameter , the depth of the well and the height of the barrier .
the width of the well , @xmath130 , can be written as @xmath174 , where @xmath175 is a new parameter .
then , eq . ( [ cond ] ) turns into @xmath176 where @xmath177 . for @xmath178 , eq .
( [ trancend ] ) has only one solution .
the root exists provided the condition @xmath179 is fulfilled . for illustration ,
choose @xmath180 , @xmath181 , and @xmath182 , in which case @xmath183 .
the numerical solution ( [ trancend ] ) yields @xmath184 and , therefore , @xmath185 . the parameters @xmath133 and @xmath134 are equal to 3.319 and 2.522 , respectively . from eq .
( [ cond ] ) it follows that @xmath186 .
the main result of the present paper is the proof that , considering the cosmological constant @xmath0 as an eigenvalue of a sturm - liouville problem allows one to obtain a set of admissible values for @xmath0 . in the special case of a situation with discrete spectrum containing only one point , there is the possibility to strictly determine the cosmological conditions leading to this value of @xmath0 without recurring to the anthropic principle .
we have shown in detail that this possibility is indeed realized in cyclic cosmological models when the potential of the matter field is similar to the potential of the scalar field .
the dynamics of the universe in this case contains a sudden future singularity . as a byproduct
we have also demonstrated that there is a remarkable connection between the steinhardt - turok cyclic models and sudden future singularity ones . *
acknowledgments . *
the work by avy has been supported by the esf , project 4868 `` the cosmological constant as eigenvalue of sturm - liouville problem '' , and the work by ava has been supported by the esf , project 4760 `` dark energy landscape and vacuum polarization account '' , both within the european network `` new trends and applications of the casimir effect '' . ee s research has been partly supported by micinn ( spain ) , contract pr2011 - 0128 and projects fis2006 - 02842 and fis2010 - 15640 , by the cpan consolider ingenio project , and by agaur ( generalitat de catalunya ) , contract 2009sgr-994 .
ee s research was partly carried out while on leave at the department of physics and astronomy , dartmouth college , 6127 wilder laboratory , hanover , nh 03755 , usa .
e. elizalde , s.d .
odintsov , a. romeo , a. bytsenko and s. zerbini , _ zeta - regularization with applications _
( world sci . ,
singapore , 1994 ) ; e. elizalde , _ ten physical applications of spectral zeta functions _
, 2nd ed . ,
lecture notes in physics ( springer - verlag , berlin , 2012 ) .
e. elizalde , j. phys .
* a39 * , 6299 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0607185 ] ; phys . lett . *
b516 * , 143 ( 2001 ) ; e. elizalde , s. nojiri , s.d . odintsov and p.
wang , phys . rev . *
d71 * , 103504 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0502082 ] ; e. elizalde , s. nojiri , s.d .
odintsov and s. ogushi , phys . rev . * d67 * , 063515 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0209242 ] .
s. weinberg , phys .
* 59 * , 2607 ( 1987 ) ; a.d .
linde , rept .
. phys . * 47 * , 925 ( 1984 ) ; a.d .
sakharov , sov .
jetp * 60 * , 214 ( 1984 ) .
[ zh . eksp .
87 , 375 ( 1984 ) ] ; t. banks , nucl . phys . *
b249 * , 332 ( 1985 ) ; a.d .
linde , `` inflation and quantum cosmology '' , in : three hundred years of gravitation .
cambridge univ .
press , eds . hawking , s.w . and israel , w. , 604 ( 1987 ) .
barrow and d.j .
shaw , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 101302 ( 2011 ) ( arxiv:1007.3086 [ gr - qc ] ) ; d.j . shaw and j.d .
barrow , phys . rev . *
d83 * , 043518 ( 2011 ) ( arxiv:1010.4262 [ gr - qc ] ) ; j.d . barrow and d.j .
shaw , gen .
rel . and grav .
* 43 * , 2555 ( 2011 ) ( arxiv:1105.3105 [ gr - qc ] ) .
m. bordag , u. mohideen , v.m .
mostepanenko , phys . rept . * 353 * , 1 ( 2001 ) ( arxiv : quant - ph/0106045 ) ; e. elizalde , s.d .
odintsov , and a.a .
saharian , phys . rev . *
d79 * , 065023 ( 2009 ) arxiv:0902.0717 [ hep - th ] ; e. elizalde , a.a .
saharian , and t.a .
vardanyan , phys . rev . *
d81 * , 124003 ( 2010 ) arxiv:1002.2846 [ hep - th ] .
steinhardt , n. turok , phys . rev . *
d65 * , 126003 ( 2002 ) ( arxiv : hep - th/0111098 ) ; p.j .
steinhardt , n. turok , phys . rev . *
d66 * , 101302 ( 2002 ) ( arxiv : astro - ph/0112537 ) ; p.j .
steinhardt , n. turok , nucl .
suppl . * 124 * , 38 ( 2003 ) ( arxiv : astro - ph/0204479 ) ; j. khoury , p.j .
steinhardt , n. turok , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 161301 ( 2003 ) ( arxiv : astro - ph/0302012 ) ; j. khoury , p.j .
steinhardt , n. turok , phys .
lett . * 92 * , 031302 ( 2004 ) ( arxiv : hep - th/0307132 ) ; p.j .
steinhardt , n. turok , phys .
scripta * t117 * , 76 ( 2005 ) ( arxiv : hep - th/0403020 ) ; p.j .
steinhardt , n. turok , new astron . rev . * 49 * , 43 ( 2005 ) ( arxiv : astro - ph/0404480 ) .
barrow , class .
* 21 * , l79 ( 2004 ) ( arxiv : gr - qc/0403084 ) ; j.d .
barrow , class.quant.grav .
* 21 * , 5619 ( 2004 ) ( arxiv : gr - qc/0409062 ) ; j.d .
barrow , c.g .
tsagas , class .
* 22 * , 1563 ( 2005 ) ( arxiv : gr - qc/0411045 ) ; j.d .
barrow , a.b .
batista , j.c .
fabris , s. houndjo , phys .
* d78 * , 123508 ( 2008 ) ( arxiv:0807.4253 [ gr - qc ] ) ; j.d . barrow , s.z.w .
lip , phys .
rev . * d80 * , 043518 ( 2009 ) ( arxiv:0901.1626[gr - qc ] ) ; j.d .
barrow , s. cotsakis , a. tsokaros , class .
* 27 * , 165017 ( 2010 ) ( arxiv:1004.2681[gr - qc ] ) ; s. nojiri and s.d .
odintsov , arxiv : hep - th/0405078 , arxiv : hep - th/0408170 ; a. astashenok et al , arxiv:1203.1976[astro - ph ] .
zhuravlev , s.v .
chervon , and v.k .
shchigolev , jetp * 87 * , 223 ( 1998 ) .
barrow , phys . rev . *
d49 * , 3055 ( 1994 ) .
r. maartens , d.r .
taylor , and n. roussos , phys .
d52 * , 3358 ( 1995 ) .
ellis and m. s. madsen , class .
quant grav .
* 8 * , 667 ( 1991 ) .
lidsey , class .
* 8 * , 923 ( 1991 ) .
barrow and p. saich , class .
quant grav .
* 10 * , 279 ( 1993 ) . p. parson and j.d .
barrow , class .
* 12 * , 1715 ( 1995 ) .
yurov , eur .
j. plus * 126 * , 132 ( 2011 ) , ( arxiv : astro - ph/0305019 ) .
s.d . vereshchagin and a.v .
yurov , theor .
139 * , 787 ( 2004 ) .
yurov , v.a .
yurov , phys . rev .
* d72 * , 026003 ( 2005 ) . | it is observed that one of einstein - friedmann s equations has formally the aspect of a sturm - liouville problem , and that the cosmological constant , @xmath0 , plays thereby the role of spectral parameter ( what hints to its connection with the casimir effect )
. the subsequent formulation of appropriate boundary conditions leads to a set of admissible values for @xmath0 , considered as eigenvalues of the corresponding linear operator .
simplest boundary conditions are assumed , namely that the eigenfunctions belong to @xmath1 space , with the result that , when all energy conditions are satisfied , they yield a discrete spectrum for @xmath2 and a continuous one for @xmath3 .
a very interesting situation is seen to occur when the discrete spectrum contains only one point : then , there is the possibility to obtain appropriate cosmological conditions without invoking the anthropic principle .
this possibility is shown to be realized in cyclic cosmological models , provided the potential of the matter field is similar to the potential of the scalar field .
the dynamics of the universe in this case contains a sudden future singularity .
= cmr12 scaled0 pacs : 04.20.-q , 98.80.-k |
casimir and related effects , where quantum effects depend upon the existence of boundary conditions for a quantum field , have been extensively studied @xcite .
many different points of view and approaches to this kind of problem have been followed , under quite different sets of assumptions regarding the system ; i.e. , its intrinsic properties , and the conditions under which one wants to evaluate the casimir force . in particular , there has been much interest in studying the casimir effect at a finite temperature ( @xmath3 ) , a study that can be undertaken at different levels , distinguished by the way of taking into account all the possible @xmath3 effects .
one could , for example , include thermal effects in the description of the matter on the mirrors ( a very active research topic @xcite ) , or rather for the physical description of the vacuum field @xcite , or for both . in this article , we shall assume perfect ( at any temperature ) mirrors , with thermal effects restricted to the vacuum field .
it has been noted that thermal and casimir - like effects share some similarities ; this should hardly be surprising , since both may be regarded , essentially , as finite - size effects , the former in the euclidean time interval @xmath4 $ ] ( with periodicity / antiperiodicity conditions ) , and the latter for a spacial coordinate with dirichlet or neumann conditions . even though the nature of the boundary conditions is different , it should be expected that , when both effects are present , interesting relations ( ` dualities ' ) will arise between the dependence on the inverse temperaure @xmath5 and the distance between the mirrors . in this article , we present an approach to the calculation of the casimir free energy for a scalar field at finite temperature in @xmath0 dimensions , subject to dirichlet boundary conditions , including self - interactions .
this approach is based on the use of a path - integral formulation , whereby the @xmath0-dimensional problem is mapped to a dimensionally reduced one , with fields living on the boundaries .
for all the cases considered we analyze the high and low temperature expansions , computing also perturbative corrections to the casimir free energy due to the non - interacting fields .
this work is organized as follows : in section [ sec : method ] we present our approach , introducing conventions and definitions . in section
[ sec : scalarfree ] we deal with the calculations and the corresponding results for a free real scalar field .
interactions are introduced in [ sec : scalarint ] and , in [ sec : concl ] , we present our conclusions .
the main object we shall be interested in is the free energy @xmath6 for a real scalar field @xmath7 in @xmath0 spacetime dimensions , which is subject to dirichlet boundary conditions on two plane mirrors , separated by a distance @xmath2 along the direction corresponding to the @xmath8 coordinate . in terms of the corresponding partition function @xmath9 ,
@xmath6 is given by : @xmath10 while for @xmath9 we shall use its standard functional integral representation : @xmath11 \
, e^{- s(\varphi)}\;,\ ] ] where @xmath12 is the euclidean action at @xmath3 ; i.e. , with an imaginary time variable restricted to the @xmath4 $ ] interval @xcite and periodic boundary conditions for the fields with respect to this coordinate are implicitly assumed . in this work
, we consider an action @xmath12 such that , with the free part of the action , @xmath13 , is given by : @xmath14 while the interaction part , @xmath15 , is given by : @xmath16 ^ 4 \;.\ ] ] we have used brackets in @xmath17 $ ] to indicate that the path - integral measure includes only those field configurations satisfying dirichlet boundary conditions on the locii of the mirrors , which correspond to two parallel planes .
accordingly , we use a coordinate system such that , if the euclidean coordinates are denoted by ( @xmath18 ) , the mirrors then correspond to the regions : @xmath19 and @xmath20 , and will be parametrized as follows : @xmath21 where @xmath22 .
then we have : @xmath23 \;=\ ; { \mathcal d}\varphi \ ; \delta\big[\varphi(\tau,{\mathbf x}_\parallel,0)\big ] \ ; \delta\big[\varphi(\tau,{\mathbf x}_\parallel , a)\big ] \;,\ ] ] where the @xmath24 s with braketed arguments are understood in the functional sense ; for example : @xmath25 \;=\ ; \prod_{\tau,{\mathbf x}_\parallel } \ , \delta\big(\varphi(\tau,{\mathbf x}_\parallel , a)\big ) \;\;,\ ] ] while the ones on the right hand side are ordinary ones . besides
, we assume that the ( @xmath1-dependent ) factor that comes from the integration over the canonical momentum has been absorbed into the definition of @xmath26 , so that performing the integral over @xmath7 does indeed reproduce the partition function ( without any missing factors ) .
following @xcite , the functional @xmath24-functions are exponentiated by means of two auxiliary fields , @xmath27 and @xmath28 , living in @xmath29 spacetime dimensions : @xmath30 where we introduced the singular current : @xmath31 whose support is the region occupied by the mirrors .
since we shall treat interactions in a perturbative approach , it is convenient to deal first with the free theory , as a necessary starting point to include the interactions afterwards .
when the theory is free ( @xmath32 ) , @xmath33 , and the integral over @xmath7 becomes gaussian .
the resulting partition function , denoted by @xmath34 is then : @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the ( free ) partition function in the absence of the mirrors , and : @xmath37 where @xmath38 , and @xmath39 \;,\ ] ] where @xmath40 is the free , imaginary - time , propagator .
it may be written explicitly as follows : @xmath41 with .
we have used the notation , and denotes the matsubara frequencies .
@xmath40 is the inverse , in the space of @xmath42-periodic functions , of @xmath43 .
expression ( [ eq : zint1 ] ) allows one to extract from the free energy the term that would correspond to a free field in the absence of mirrors , @xmath44 , plus another contribution , which we shall denote by @xmath45 : @xmath46 @xmath47 \;,\ ] ] which clearly contains the casimir effect information ( including thermal corrections ) .
however , it also carries information that is usually unwanted , associated to the ever - present self - energy of the mirrors .
indeed , we see that it includes a divergent contribution to the free energy , which can be neatly identified , for example , by noting that , when @xmath48 : @xmath49 ^ 2 \;,\ ] ] where @xmath50 is the contribution corresponding to one mirror : @xmath51 we then identify @xmath52\ ] ] as the free energy term that measures a mirror s self - interaction .
it is , of course , independent of @xmath2 . extracting also this contribution
, we have the following decomposition for @xmath44 @xmath53 where @xmath54 has a vanishing limit when .
we can produce a more explicit expression for the interesting term @xmath55 , starting from its defining properties above .
indeed , we have : @xmath56 ^ 2 } \big\}\;,\ ] ] which , by integrating out the auxiliary fields , may be written in terms of the matrix kernel @xmath57 : @xmath58 where @xmath59 and the trace is over both spacetime coordinates and @xmath60 indices . assuming that an uv regularization is introduced in order to make sense of each one of the traces above , and using ` reg ' to denote uv regularized objects
, we see that : @xmath61_{reg } \,-\ , \frac{1}{2 \beta } \big[{\rm tr } \ln \omega_\infty \big]_{reg } \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{2 \beta } \big[{\rm tr } \ln\big(\omega_\infty^{-1 } \omega \big ) \big]_{reg } \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as we shall see , the trace on the second line is finite , and has a finite limit when the regulator is removed . using some algebra we may reduce the trace to one where only continuous indices appear : @xmath62 where a ` reduced ' kernel @xmath63 which is given by : @xmath64 with : @xmath65^{-1}(x_\parallel , z_\parallel ) \omega_{12}(z_\parallel , w_\parallel)\nonumber\\ & \times & [ \omega_{22}]^{-1}(w_\parallel , u_\parallel)\omega_{21}(u_\parallel , y_\parallel ) \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] has been introduced . finally note that , due to translation invariance along the mirrors , the free energy shall be proportial to @xmath66 , the area of the mirrors
. then , to absorbe this divergence we shall rather consider the corresponding free energy _
, obtained by dividing the extensive quantity by @xmath66 .
in particular , @xmath67\ ] ] where @xmath68 on the right hand side is evaluated for a system with a finite parallel volume .
moreover , taking advantage of the translation invariance along the parallel coordinates , we may use a fourier transformation to write : @xmath69 where @xmath70 with : @xmath71^{-1 } \,{\widetilde\omega}_{12}^{(n)}({\mathbf k}_\parallel ) \ , [ { \widetilde\omega}_{22}^{(n)}({\mathbf k}_\parallel ) ] ^{-1 } \ , { \widetilde\omega}_{21}^{(n)}({\mathbf k}_\parallel ) \;.\ ] ] where the tilde denotes fourier transformation in both @xmath42 and @xmath72 . note the appearance of the reciprocals of the matrix elements of @xmath73 ( not to be confused with the matrix elements of the inverse of that matrix ) .
the explicit form of the objects entering in ( [ eq : deft ] ) may be obtained from ( [ eq : omega ] ) : @xmath74 so that : @xmath75 it is then evident that the sum and the integral in ( [ eq : denercas ] ) converge , since the integrand falls off exponentially for large values of the momenta / indices .
this behaviour should be expected , since we have constructed this object subtracting explicitly the would - be self - energy parts , the possible source of uv divergences .
thus , the main result of the previous calculations is a ( finite ) expression for the free energy , which can be written as follows : @xmath76 \;.\ ] ] it is worth noting that the expression above has been obtained subtracting the free energy corresponding to a situation where the mirrors are separated by an infinite distance ; on the other hand , we note that , when the @xmath77 limit is taken , the sum is replaced by an integral , and we obtain : @xmath78 which is the casimir energy per unit area . with this in mind , one may introduce yet another quantity ; the _ temperature dependent _ part of the free energy , whose area density we will denote by @xmath79 , and , from the discussion above , it is given by : @xmath80 by using a rather simple rescaling it the integral in the second term , we may write : @xmath81 \nonumber\\ & - & \int_{-\infty}^\infty d\nu \ , \ln\big [ 1 \,-\ , e^ { - \frac{2 a}{\beta } \sqrt{(2 \pi \nu)^2 + ( \beta { \mathcal e}({\mathbf k}_\parallel))^2}}\big ] \big\ } \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which yields the casimir free energy as a difference between a series and an integral , although the for the thermal part , since the sum over energy modes has already been ( implicitly ) performed . before evaluating the free energy for different numbers of spacetime dimensions , we explore below some consequences of a duality between @xmath1 and @xmath2 . the dual role played by @xmath1 and @xmath2 in the free energy
may be understood , for example , by attempting to calculate that object by following an alternative approach , based on the knowledge of the exact energies of the field modes , emerging from the existence of dirichlet boundary conditions .
the energies @xmath82 of the stationary modes are : @xmath83 since each one of these modes behaves as a harmonic oscillator degree of freedom , its free energy @xmath84 $ ] has the following form : @xmath85&= & -\frac{1}{\beta } \,\ln \big [ \sum_{n=0}^\infty e^{-\beta w_l({\mathbf k}_\parallel ) ( n+\frac{1}{2 } ) } \big ] \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{2 } w_l({\mathbf k}_\parallel ) + \frac{1}{\beta } \ , \ln \big [ 1 \ , - \ , e^{-\beta w_l({\mathbf k}_\parallel ) } \big]\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we consider @xmath79 , the _ temperature dependent _ part of the free energy density , obtained by summing the second term in the expression above over all the degrees of freedom , and dividing by the parallel area : @xmath86 \;.\ ] ] this may also be written as follows : @xmath87 \nonumber\\ & - & \frac{1}{\beta } \ , \int \frac{d^{d-1}{\mathbf k}_\parallel}{(2\pi)^{d-1 } }
\ln \big [ 1 \ , - \ , e^{-\beta { \mathcal e}({\mathbf k}_\parallel ) } \big ] \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now recall that we are considering the free energy for one and the same system , albeit with different normalizations : subtraction at @xmath48 in ( [ eq : freexact ] ) , and at @xmath77 in ( [ eq : freet ] ) .
then we may write : @xmath88 or : @xmath89 where @xmath90 is an @xmath2-independent object , which corresponds to the free energy of a free field .
thus , if we are going to be concerned with temperature and @xmath2-dependent quantities , for example , to study the temperature dependence of the casimir force , we only need derivatives with respect to @xmath1 and @xmath2 of the expression above , and we see that : @xmath91 \,=\,\frac{\partial^2}{\partial \beta \partial a } \big [ { \mathcal f}_t^{(0)}(\beta , a ) \big]\;,\ ] ] or : @xmath92 where the tildes denote subtraction of any term which has a vanishing mixed second partial derivative . on the other hand , from the explicit form of the free energy density as sum over modes ( matsubara or casimir ) , we find the identity : @xmath93 ( 2 a , \beta/2 ) \,=\ , \big [ \beta \widetilde{\mathcal f}_c^{(0)}\big ] ( \beta , a ) \;,\ ] ] which , combined with ( [ eq : aux1 ] ) yields a duality between @xmath2 and @xmath1 : @xmath94 to proceed , we make the simplifying assumption that @xmath95 , and transform variables in the integral over @xmath96 to have a dimensionless integral , obtaining @xmath97 where @xmath98 is given by @xmath99 where @xmath100 and @xmath101 is a constant factor that depends solely on the dimension @xmath29 . now , using the duality formula ( @xmath102 ) , we obtain the an interesting relation involving @xmath103 : @xmath104 where @xmath105 ( or @xmath106 ) .
note that this relation has immediate relevance to relate the low and high temperature regimes .
indeed , writing the expression above more explicitly , we see that : @xmath107 this duality relation had been pointed out , for the @xmath108 case , by balian and duplantier @xcite . in the remainder of this section
, we apply the previous results and study some particular properties of the free energy corresponding the the free scalar field , firstly for the @xmath109 case , which we single out since it can be exactly solved , and then for @xmath110 .
the free energy ( neglecting an irrelevant constant ) is given by the expression : @xmath111 which may be written as an infinite product : @xmath112 where @xmath113 , and @xmath114 < 1 for @xmath3 .
using standard properties of ellipthic functions , we get a more explicit results for the free energy : @xmath115,\ ] ] where @xmath116 is dedekind s eta function .
although it has been obtained for @xmath3 , one can verify that it also yields the proper results for , namely , . besides , the @xmath117-function satisfies the property : which , in this context , is tantamount to the duality relation .
now , we exploit the duality relation to extract the high and low temperature behavior of the casimir energy , for @xmath118 . in a high temperature expansion , formula ( @xmath119 ) can be expanded for small @xmath120 .
the infinite - temperature limit corresponds to @xmath121 , thus @xmath122 yields the leading contribution in this expansion , with the @xmath123 terms producing higher - order corrections .
the explicit form of the leading high temperature term is : @xmath124 whereas aplying the duality formula ( [ eq : duality ] ) @xmath125 , we have the first order contribution in the low temperature regime , @xmath126 which is @xmath2 independent . the sub - leading contributions ( @xmath127 ) include more involved integrals ; nevertheless , when @xmath108 and @xmath121 , it reduces to terms like @xmath128 .
thus , the most significant contribution for @xmath129 is : @xmath130 therefore , the duality formula implies that , when @xmath131 , @xmath132 collecting these results for @xmath108 , we see that , for high temperatures : @xmath133 @xmath134 while , for low temperatures the corresponding behaviour is : @xmath135\,.\ ] ]
let us now consider the theory that results from turning on the quartic self - interaction term , studying the corresponding corrections to the free energy .
this can be done in ( at least ) two different ways .
we shall consider first the would - be more straightforward approach , which amounts to expanding the interaction term in powers of the coupling constant first , postponing the integration over the scalar field until the end of the calculation .
we call it ` perturbative ' since it is closer in spirit to standard perturbation theory
. we have to evaluate : @xmath136 \,e^{-s_i(\varphi ) } \ , e^{-s_0(\varphi ) } \nonumber\\ & = & { \mathcal z}^{(0)}(\beta , a ) \;\ ; \langle e^{-s_i(\varphi ) } \rangle \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath137 to denote functional averaging with the free ( matsubara ) action and the scalar - field integration measure satisfying dirichlet boundary conditions .
namely , @xmath138
\ldots e^{-s_0(\varphi)}}{\int [ { \mathcal d}\varphi ] \ , e^{-s_0(\varphi ) } } \;.\ ] ] thus , the different terms in the perturbative expansion are obtained by expanding in powers of the coupling constant , @xmath139 .
for example , the first order term , @xmath140 , may be written as follows : @xmath141 ^ 4 \rangle \;,\ ] ] which may be expressed ( via wick s theorem ) , in terms of the average of just two fields . indeed ,
the generating functional for these averages , @xmath142 , is simply : @xmath143 \ , e^{- s_0(\varphi ) + \int d^{d+1}x \ ,
j(x ) \varphi(x)}\;.\ ] ] we again introduce the auxiliary fields to impose the periodicity constraints on the measure , so that : @xmath144 + \int d^{d+1}x [ i j_p(x)+j(x)]\varphi ( x)}\,.\ ] ] integrating out the scalar field @xmath7 , and using a simplified notation for the integrals , we obtain : @xmath145 \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where : @xmath146 , with @xmath147 , @xmath148 .
integrating now the auxiliary fields , we see that : @xmath149 where @xmath150 , the ( free ) thermal correlation function in the presence of the mirrors , may be written more explicitly as follows : @xmath151_{\alpha\beta}(x'_\parallel , y'_\parallel ) \delta(y'_\parallel , a_\beta ; y_\parallel , y_d ) \big\ } \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and this is the building block for all the perturbative corrections .
it is quite straightforward to check that the propagator above does verify the dirichlet boundary conditions , when each one of its arguments approaches a mirror .
for example : @xmath152_{\alpha\beta}(x'_\parallel , y'_\parallel ) \delta(y'_\parallel , a_\beta ; y_\parallel , y_d ) \big\ } \nonumber\\ & = & \delta(x_\parallel , a_\gamma;y ) \;-\ ; \int_{y'_\parallel } \delta_{\gamma \beta } \delta(x_\parallel , y'_\parallel ) \delta(y'_\parallel , a_\beta ; y_\parallel , y_d ) \nonumber\\ & = & \delta(x_\parallel , a_\gamma;y ) \,-\ , \delta(x_\parallel ,
a_\gamma;y ) \;=\;0 \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and analogously for the second argument .
the thermal correlation function @xmath153 above is composed of two contributions : one is the usual free thermal propagator in the absence of boundary conditions and the other come from reflexions on the surface boundaries . in this way
we write @xmath154 where @xmath155 is given by : @xmath156 with @xmath157 equal to : @xmath158 where @xmath159 .
we apply now the previous approach to the calculation of the first - order correction to the free energy ( in fact , to the force ) and the self - energy function : we want to evaluate thermal corrections to casimir energy in the interacting theory , in particular , to understand how its divergences should be dealt with . to automatically subtract @xmath2-independent contributions , we work with the derivative of the free energy with respect to @xmath2 .
obviously , this is a force , and it has the same amount of information as an energy which has been subtracted to avoid @xmath2-independent infinities .
indeed , it can be integrated over any finite range of distances to obtain de energy difference . using @xmath160 to denote these derivatives
, we have : @xmath161 where the term @xmath162 is the first - order correction to free casimir force @xmath163 .
there is a term where only @xmath164 appears ; this can be renormalized as usual in finite - temperature field theory , by a zero - temperature subtraction plus the inclusion of the first - order ( temperature - dependent ) mass counterterm contribution @xcite . then , keeping temperature _ and
_ @xmath2 dependent terms only , we see that @xmath165 where : @xmath166 and @xmath167 using the notation @xmath168 and @xmath169 for the corresponding area densities ( we omit super and subscripts ) : @xmath170 and @xmath171 and the first - order correction to the casimir force will be given by : @xmath172 the term @xmath173 can be obtained from ( [ eq : mpropagfourier ] ) ; after changing variables from @xmath174 ( to obtain a symmetrized form ) , we perform an integration over @xmath0-dimensional spacetime , obtaining : @xmath175 the @xmath176-dependent function @xmath177 is given by @xmath178 where @xmath179 is the bose distribution function , with @xmath180 .
@xmath168 may be expressed in yet another way , using the definition of the bose distribution function but with @xmath1 replaced by @xmath181 while @xmath182 is replaced by @xmath183 , i.e. , @xmath179 is replaced by @xmath184 then @xmath185\,\,,\ ] ] which is clearly a convergent quantity . for the remaining term , we proceed in a similar way , where now the @xmath186 represent @xmath187 @xmath188 where @xmath189 which is also convergent .
we conclude the application of this method with the calculation of the tadpole diagram contribution to the self - energy .
there is here a surface divergence due to the @xmath190 contribution : @xmath191 as before , it is convenient to separate from the self - energy the contribution which is present even when the mirrors are infinitely distant ; namely , @xmath192 where @xmath193 and @xmath194 which contain the contribution to the selfenergy coming from the dirichlet boundary conditions .
the term @xmath195 has uv and ir divergences , which are usually analyzed in standard finite temperature calculations .
on the other hand , the @xmath196 term has no uv divergences , although it is ir divergent in low dimensions .
moreover , it presents surface divergences when the @xmath8 coordinate tends to @xmath19 or @xmath20 .
we will classify these divergences according to the dimension of the theory .
when @xmath109 and @xmath95 , we obtain , @xmath197 where @xmath198 . then we see that @xmath199 where @xmath200 and @xmath201 .
the sum for @xmath202 and @xmath203 can be performed .
for @xmath202 , the selfenergy is proportional to @xmath204 , which diverges for @xmath205 , regardless of the temperature . for @xmath206 , it is convenient to separate the self - energy part which into two pieces , one coming from @xmath122 , and the other coming from the remaining modes : @xmath207 and @xmath208 @xmath209 again , the zero mode contribution @xmath210 has an ir divergent behaviour for low momenta , while there is a divergence on the mirrors .
for instance , for @xmath202 the selfenergy is proportional to @xmath211 .
the @xmath212 term can be analized in the high and low temperature limits , i.e. @xmath213 and @xmath214 , respectively .
the divergence of the function @xmath215 is logarithmic in @xmath216 , thus surface divergences also are logarithmic .
moreover , we see that @xmath217 . for @xmath218 ,
the ir divergences are absent , and the surface diverces appear explicity .
the two contributions are given by : @xmath219 @xmath220 the integral for @xmath202 or @xmath203 can be performed @xmath221 in the case of @xmath108 dimension we have a simple expression @xmath222 by the above results we conclude that the surface divergences of the @xmath223 term are polynomial : @xmath224 , whereas the term @xmath212 which has the sum of non - zero modes presents a more severe divergence proportional to @xmath225 .
this has just been shown explicity for the @xmath108 case . in figures 1 , 2 , 3 and 4
, we plot the self - energy for 1 , 2 , and 3 dimensions , for different values of the parameters .
let us conclude this section by considering a second , alternative procedure to the one just explained .
it amounts to integrating out , albeit formally , the scalar field _ before _ the perturbative expansion .
indeed , introducing , from the very beginning , the auxiliary fields used to impose the dirichlet conditions , we see that the partition function becomes @xmath226 } \ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath227 denotes the generating functional of connected correlation functions , at finite temperature , and with an unconstrained ( no dirichlet conditions ) scalar field integration measure : @xmath228 } \;\equiv\ ; \int { \mathcal d}\varphi \ , e^{-s[\varphi ] + \int d^{d+1}x j(x ) \varphi(x ) } \;.\ ] ] of course , the arbitrary current @xmath229 in the definition above must be replaced by @xmath230 , which does depend on the auxiliary fields and on @xmath2 , the distance between the two mirrors . besides , we assume that , in the course of evaluating @xmath227 , a renormalization procedure has been used to make sense of the possible infinites , in the usual way .
to proceed , we recall that @xmath231 $ ] does have a functional expansion : @xmath232 \;=\ ; { \mathcal w}_0 \ , + \ , \frac{1}{2 } \int d^{d+1}x \int d^{d+1}y \ ; { \mathcal w}_2(x , y ) j(x ) j(y ) \,+\ , \ldots\ ] ] where @xmath233 correponds to the connected @xmath234-point correlation functions .
odd terms are , for the quartic perturbation , absent from the expansion .
then one may invoque some approximation that allows one to truncate the functional expansion . of course
, it can not be a naive perturbative expansion in the coupling constant ; one should rather use , for example , a mean field or large-@xmath235 expansion .
then the leading term will be just the quadratic one : @xmath236 where @xmath237 is the thermal partition function in the absence of mirrors , while @xmath238 depends on @xmath239 , the full renormalized thermal propagator . using the explicit form of @xmath230
, we see that the integral is a gaussian : @xmath240 where @xmath241 and @xmath242 \;,\ ] ] where @xmath243 is the _ full _ imaginary - time propagator .
it may be written quite generally as follows : @xmath244 with a generally complicated function of its arguments .
however , we note that some non perturbative corrections do produce a simple result . for example
, considering the ir resummed version of the massless scalar field , yields an expression of the form : @xmath245^{-1}\ ] ] where @xmath246 is the thermal mass .
for example , the first two non - trivial contributions correspond to a term which is linear in @xmath139 plus a non - analytic term : @xmath247 \;.\ ] ] upon insertion of this expression , we see that the corresponding contribution to the casimir free energy becomes : @xmath248 \;,\ ] ] where the @xmath48 contribution has already been subtracted .
we have obtained exact results for the free energy in a casimir system in @xmath249 dimensions and well as low and high temperature expansions for @xmath118 , based on a duality relation between inverse temperatures and distances between mirrors , in @xmath0 spacetime dimensions . for the interacting theory ,
we have derived two different approaches . in the first approach , perturbative expansion has been used to obtain the first order corrections to thermal casimir force , showing that it is finite once the standar renormalization of thermal field theory in the absence of mirrors is performed . on the other hand
, we also studied the selfenergies , showing that they have surface divergences in their coordinate dependence , and that those divergences are of a polynomial type , with a degree which depends on the dimension .
finally , we have shown that a variation in the order used to integrate the auxiliary fields yields a different method , whereby the one particle irreducible functions naturally appear .
c.c.t and c.d.f . thank conicet , anpcyt and uncuyo for financial support .
bib g. plunien , b. mller , and w. greiner , phys . rep . * 134 * , 87 ( 1986 ) ; p. milonni , _ the quantum vacuum _ ( academic press , san diego , 1994 ) ; v. m. mostepanenko and n. n. trunov , _ the casimir effect and its applications _ ( clarendon , london , 1997 ) ; m. bordag , _ the casimir effect 50 years later _
( world scientific , singapore , 1999 ) ; m. bordag , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
rep . * 353 * , 1 ( 2001 ) ; k. a. milton , _ the casimir effect : physical manifestations of the zero - point energy _
( world scientific , singapore , 2001 ) ; s. reynaud _
_ , c. r. acad .
paris * iv-2 * , 1287 ( 2001 ) ; k. a. milton , j. phys . a : math
. gen . * 37 * , r209 ( 2004 ) ; s.k .
lamoreaux , rep .
. phys . * 68 * , 201 ( 2005 ) ; special issue _ `` focus on casimir forces '' _ , new j. phys . * 8 * ( 2006 ) .
see , for example : + g. bimonte , j. phys .
a * 41 * , 164013 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0801.2832 [ quant - ph ] ] ; i. brevik and k. a. milton , arxiv:0802.2542 [ quant - ph ] ; b. e. sernelius , j. phys .
a * 39 * ( 2006 ) 6741 ; v. b. bezerra _ et al .
_ , phys .
e * 73 * , 028101 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : quant - ph/0503134 ] .
s. c. lim and l. p. teo , arxiv:0808.0047 [ hep - th ] ; s. c. lim and l. p. teo , arxiv:0804.3916 [ hep - th ] .
j. i. kapusta and c. gale , _ cambridge , uk : univ . pr .
( 2006 ) 428 p_. m. kardar and r. golestanian , rev .
phys . * 71 * , 1233 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : cond - mat/9711071 ] .
r. balian and b. duplantier , to appear in the proceedings of 15th sigrav conference on general relativity and gravitational physics , rome , italy , 9 - 12 sep 2002 .
[ arxiv : quant - ph/0408124 ] . f. ravndal and d. tollefsen , phys .
d * 40 * , 4191 ( 1989 ) l.s .
brown and g.j .
maclay , phys . rev . * 184 * 1272 ( 1969 ) c.a .
lutken and f. ravndal , j. phys . a**21 * * l792 ( 1988 ) s.a .
gundersen and f. ravndal , ann . of phys . *
182 * , 90 ( 1988 ) n. graham , r. l. jaffe , v. khemani , m. quandt , o. schroeder and h. weigel , nucl .
b * 677 * , 379 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0309130 ] .
p. sundberg and r. l. jaffe , annals phys .
* 309 * , 442 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0308010 ] .
see , for example , j. zinn - justin , _ quantum field theory and critical phenomena _
, oxford science publications , 4th . ed . , ( 2002 ) . * * figure 1 : * self - energy in @xmath249 dimensions , for three values of @xmath250 : upper curve : @xmath251 ; middle curve : @xmath252 and lower curve : @xmath253 . * * figure 2 : * self - energy in @xmath254 dimensions , for three values of @xmath250 : upper curve : @xmath251 ; middle curve : @xmath252 and lower curve : @xmath253 . * * figure 3 : * self - energy in @xmath255 dimensions , zero mode contribution . * * figure 4 : * self - energy in @xmath255 dimensions , for three values of @xmath250 : upper curve : @xmath251 ; middle curve : @xmath252 and lower curve : @xmath253 . | we use a functional approach to evaluate the casimir free energy for a self - interacting scalar field in @xmath0 dimensions , satisfying dirichlet boundary conditions on two parallel planes .
when the interaction is turned off , exact results for the free energy in some particular cases may be found , as well as low and high temperature expansions based on a duality relation that involves the inverse temperature @xmath1 and the distance between the mirrors , @xmath2 . for the interacting theory ,
we derive and implement two different approaches .
the first one is a perturbative expansion built with a thermal propagator that satisfies dirichlet boundary conditions on the mirrors .
the second approach uses the exact finite - temperature generating functional as a starting point . in this sense
, it allows one to include , for example , non - perturbative thermal corrections into the casimir calculation , in a controlled way .
we present results for calculations performed using those two approaches . |
in deep inelastic lepton scattering ( dis , see e.g. @xcite ) ( with 4momenta @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) on hadron ( @xmath4 with @xmath5 ) the inclusive differential cross section for @xmath6 in the hadron rest frame is given by @xmath7 with the standard notations @xmath8 @xmath9 ( with @xmath10 ) is the momentum transfer in the scattering process , @xmath11 the azimuthal scattering angle of the outgoing lepton , @xmath12 ( with @xmath13 ) the initial lepton polarisation vector and @xmath14 denotes the initial hadron polarisation ( @xmath15 for spin 1/2 target ) .
all information about the cross section is contained in the leptonic and hadronic tensors @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
while @xmath16 is known , the hadronic tensor @xmath18 | p , \lambda \rangle\ ] ] with the electromagnetic hadronic currents @xmath19 contains the strong interaction effects which are not completely accessible to perturbative qcd .
the most general hadronic tensor for polarised dis from spin @xmath20 targets is usually written in the form @xmath21 here @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the structure functions and @xmath24 the polarisation vector of the nucleon with @xmath25 . in a parton model interpretation
the structure functions @xmath22 contain information about the overall density of quarks ( and gluons ) in the nucleon and @xmath26 probes the distribution of quarks of given helicity in a longitudinally polarised nucleon ( @xmath27 is the quark charge , @xmath28 denotes the distribution function of quark ( antiquark ) with momentum fraction @xmath29 and helicity parallel / antiparallel to its parent nucleon ) @xmath30 the structure function @xmath31 has no simple interpretation in the parton model
. one can derive sum rules ( moments ) for the structure functions directly from qcd using the operator product expansion ( ope ) .
the starting point is the time ordered product of two hadronic currents @xmath32 the matrix element of which gives the well known compton amplitude .
this amplitude is related to the hadronic tensor @xmath17 via the optical theorem @xmath33 to calculate the compton amplitude in qcd one relies on ope which allows to write the product of two local operators @xmath34 and @xmath35 for vanishing distance @xmath36 as an expansion in local operators . in the fourier transform version of ope one has @xmath37 the wilson coefficients @xmath38 ( in general singular at @xmath39 ) are independent of the matrix elements , provided @xmath40 is much larger than the characteristic momentum in any of the external states .
the local operators in ope for qcd are quark and gluon operators with arbitrary dimension @xmath41 and spin @xmath42 .
it can be shown that the contribution of any operator to @xmath43 is of the order @xmath44 with the twist introduced as @xmath45 .
therefore , the most important operators in ope at @xmath46 are those with twist two contributing to @xmath22 and @xmath26 .
the structure function @xmath31 involves twist three operators allowing a direct measurement of higher twist matrix elements . for unpolarised dis we use as conventional basis for twist two quark and gluon operators @xmath47 where @xmath48 denote the quark fields ,
@xmath49 is the gluon field strength tensor and the covariant derivatives @xmath50 and @xmath51 . taking into account polarisation
, the following towers of operators have to be added @xmath52 with the dual field strength tensor @xmath53 .
the moments of nucleon structure functions are then written at large @xmath54 in the form @xmath55 and @xmath56 due to the symmetry of the structure functions under charge conjugation only even @xmath42 contribute to @xmath22 and @xmath23 . in the so called quenched approximation of lattice qcd ,
however , also operators with odd @xmath42 are relevant .
the coefficient functions @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 are calculable in qcd perturbation theory , the measured scaling violations are usually described by their @xmath54 evolution . on the other hand the computation of structure functions themselves ( at a given low momentum scale @xmath61 ) requires nonperturbative methods ab initio .
note that @xmath61dependence in the matrix elements @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 arising from the @xmath61dependence of the renormalisation constants defined below should be cancelled by the corresponding @xmath61dependence in the coefficient functions .
the matrix elements are defined from the operators as follows @xmath65 \dots \mu_n\}}^{5(f ) } } \frac{1}{n+1 } { d_n^{(f)}}\ ( s_{[\sigma } p_{\mu_1]}p_{\mu_2}\dots p_{\mu_n}+\dots - { \mathrm{traces } } ) \ , .
\label{13c } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath66 denotes symmetrisation and @xmath67 $ ] antisymmetrisation .
the traceless and symmetric operators @xmath68 and @xmath69 transform irreducibly under the lorentz group . the r.h.s . of eqs .
( [ 13a ] ) and ( [ 13b ] ) are the only traceless , symmetric tensors of maximum spin
i.e. @xmath42 and @xmath70 , respectively
one can build from a single momentum vector and the polarisation vector @xmath24 .
both operators have twist two .
the operator @xmath71 \cdots \mu_n\}}^{5(f)}$ ] , which is also traceless but of mixed symmetry , transforms irreducibly as well and has spin @xmath42 and twist three . besides the operators ( [ 9a]-[10b ] ) used in dis also point quark operators are of interest to calculate e.g. masses or decay constants : @xmath72 with @xmath73 the matrix elements for the lowest spins are calculable on the theoretical basis of lattice qcd using numerical simulation techniques which allow in principle to define the structure functions as physical observables on one common theoretical basis qcd
a lot of results for the matrix elements has been obtained by our qcdsf collaboration , part of them are discussed in the talk of g. schierholz @xcite at this workshop .
to reduce systematic discretisation errors in realistic lattice calculations to @xmath74 , an improved action , proposed by sheikholeslami and wohlert @xcite can be used . in their approach a higher dimensional operator
is added to the wilson action @xmath75 which is restricted by the same symmetries as the original unimproved action ( @xmath76 is the lattice spacing , @xmath77 the wilson coefficient ) @xmath78 @xmath79 denotes the clover leaf form of the lattice field strength , @xmath80 . the constant @xmath81 which gives the strength of the higher dimensional operator
is given in a perturbative expansion as @xmath82 @xcite .
the coefficient can be tuned to obtain on shell improved green s functions .
the extra action piece adds a vertex contribution to the lattice feynman rules . in euclidean space - time
the lorentz group is replaced by the orthogonal group @xmath83 , which on the lattice reduces to the hypercubic group @xmath84 .
accordingly , the lattice operators are classified by their transformation properties under the hypercubic group and charge conjugation . in ref .
@xcite we have identified all irreducible representations of the operators @xmath85 and @xmath86 up to rank four . in the ( wick rotated )
operators the covariant derivatives are replaced by the lattice covariant derivatives ( with the link matrix @xmath87 ) @xmath88 to be consistent in an improvement program , besides of an improved action , the operators under discussion have to be improved , too .
we have constructed the fundamental bases necessary to achieve full @xmath1 improvement of point and one link quark operators .
this is achieved by adding higher dimensional operators with the same symmetry properties ( parity , charge conjugation ) as the original unimproved ones .
the bases for point and one link operators are listed in the following : + @xmath89 @xmath90 @xmath91 @xmath92 @xmath93 @xmath94 @xmath95 @xmath96 @xmath97 @xmath98 @xmath99 for the drell - yan process @xmath100 @xmath101 @xmath102\psi \nonumber \\ & -&\frac{1}{4 } \,a \,c_2 \bar{\psi}\left\{{\stackrel{\leftrightarrow}{d}}_\mu,{\stackrel{\leftrightarrow}{d}}_\nu\right\}\psi + \frac{1}{2}\,a \,i\,c_3 \partial_\lambda\big(\bar{\psi}\sigma_{\mu\lambda } { \stackrel{\leftrightarrow}{d } } _ \nu\psi\big ) \
, , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath103 @xmath104\psi \nonumber \\ & -&\frac{1}{4}\,a \,i \,c_2 \ , \bar{\psi}\sigma_{\mu\lambda}\gamma_5 \left\{{\stackrel{\leftrightarrow}{d}}_\lambda,{\stackrel{\leftrightarrow}{d}}_\nu\right\}\psi + \frac{1}{2}\,a \,i\,c_3 \partial_\mu\big(\bar{\psi}\gamma_5 { \stackrel{\leftrightarrow}{d}}_\nu\psi\big ) \label{32 } \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] due to @xmath105^{\rm lattice } = 4 \,i \,g \ , f_{\mu\nu}^{\rm clover } + o(a^2 )
$ ] two prescriptions for the improved one link lattice operators are possible . inserting the improved operators into forward matrix elements the surface term @xmath106 ( where @xmath85 is any operator ) vanishes due to momentum conservation . using the equation of motion it is possible for each improved operator to eliminate one base operator .
for the coefficients @xmath107 the perturbative expansion is not known , @xmath108 and @xmath109 are different quantities for every operator considered .
in order to relate the matrix elements computed on the lattice to continuum matrix elements the so called @xmath0 factors have to be calculated . a consistent way would be to do this also nonperturbatively , e.g. on the lattice@xcite . here
we present one loop perturbative calculations ( using totally anticommuting @xmath110 ) which can be used as a first step to control the nonperturbative result .
we present the @xmath0 factors with coefficients @xmath108 and @xmath81 kept arbitrary .
this allows to define the perturbative contributions of the various terms and their relative magnitudes .
moreover , this will allow to implement tadpole improved perturbation theory .
there are several possibilities to determine renormalised quantities which can be compared to data obtained in experiments .
we use the projection onto the tree structure ( cf .
e.g. @xcite ) .
the finite quark operators renormalised at finite scale @xmath61 with their multiplicative renormalisation factors are given by the relations @xmath111 @xmath112 is the amputated green s function .
@xmath113 is the wave function renormalisation factor determined either via the quark propagator or via the conserved vector current@xcite @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the amputated green s function of the conserved vector current .
the definition ( [ renscheme1 ] ) corresponds to the momentum subtraction scheme .
the calculation basically amounts to the computation of integrals of the form @xmath116 where @xmath117 contains lattice quark and gluon propagators and @xmath118 of lattice momenta @xmath119 and @xmath120 , the integration is over the first brillouin zone @xmath121 .
the calculation of the loop integrals @xmath122 is performed in two parts .
we decompose ( [ 34 ] ) @xcite @xmath123 where @xmath124 and the order of the expansion @xmath125 is determined by the degree of ultraviolet ( uv ) divergences of @xmath126 in the limit @xmath127 .
therefore , @xmath128 is rendered uv finite and is computed in the continuum .
the taylor expansion of the lattice integral ( the first term ) will in general create an infrared ( ir ) divergence . to regularise the integrals dimensional regularisation
the ir poles of @xmath129 cancel those of @xmath128 .
uv divergent contributions ( @xmath130 ) of the lattice integrals will cancel in the operator representations which we are interested in .
let us summarise some of the basic features of the developed program code . * the program package written in _
mathematica_. * symbolic feynman rules used as input , the program computes one loop forward matrix elements of bilinear quark and gluon operators on a hyper - cubic lattice including @xmath1 contributions and in the continuum in symbolic form .
* special features of the program : * * dimensional regularisation * * symmetrisation tables are used to accelerate the momentum integration over the brillouin zone * * general index handling in the complicated case of hyper - cubic @xmath131 symmetry ( non - lorentz covariant structures ) * * algebraic isolation of the infrared poles which leads to an exact cancellation of the divergences * * results given with general index structure what allows an easy generation of all group representations * * all _ finite _ lattice integrals represented by symbols which are accurately calculated numerically a part of the results has been checked in a completely independent calculation based on a code in _
first we discuss the one loop self energy for quarks which contributes to almost all matrix elements of the operators discussed below . to transform between various renormalisation schemes both lattice and
continuum contributions are listed .
the bare fermion propagator is given by @xmath132 where we present the self energy in the standard form @xmath133 with @xmath134 for su(3 ) .
the bare mass @xmath135 is defined by @xmath136 the perturbative calculation is performed by expanding the massive fermion propagator in the mass parameter up to order @xmath137 for @xmath138 .
for @xmath139 we obtain in covariant gauge @xmath140 with @xmath141 @xmath142 is the gauge parameter ( @xmath143 for feynman ( landau ) gauge ) , @xmath144 , @xmath145 the renormalisation factors @xmath146 in the momentum subtraction scheme are given in the form @xmath147 where @xmath148 is the anomalous dimension and @xmath149 the finite part of @xmath146 .
as can be seen from ( [ renscheme1 ] ) @xmath149 receives contributions from the one loop amputated green s function and the self energy diagrams ( wave function renormalisation ) @xmath150 with @xmath151 since the wilson coefficients are usually computed in the ms or @xmath152 scheme , one has to present the renormalisation constants in these schemes , too .
the transformations between the different schemes are @xcite @xmath153 where @xmath148 and @xmath154 are given in table [ tab:1 ] .
[ anomdimtab ] .anomalous dimensions and finite contributions of continuum integrals to @xmath149 [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the matrix element of point quark operator @xmath155 to order @xmath157 up to @xmath1 is given by the form @xmath158 as result for the amputated green s functions we find @xmath159 note that @xmath1 terms do not contribute to the tree
level structure , what is valid in general .
therefore , no dangerous @xmath160 or @xmath161 terms are present for massless quarks in @xmath0 factors defined in this momentum subtraction scheme .
the finite contribution to the @xmath0 factor in @xmath162 is then found as @xmath163 the calculation in the case of link operators including improved action and operators is much more cumbersome .
the @xmath1 contributions are still not known yet , however , they will also not contribute to the tree level structure .
the @xmath0 factors have to be calculated in a special representation . choosing the representation @xmath164 ,
only terms @xmath165 contribute , and the two prescriptions ( [ 31]-[32 ] ) coincide @xmath166
it is known that many results from ( naive ) lattice perturbation theory are in poor agreement with their numerically determined counterparts .
one of the reasons is that tadpoles ( lattice artifacts ) spoil the expansion .
lepage and mackenzie@xcite proposed a rearrangement in the perturbative series in order to get rid of the numerically large tadpole contributions .
these contributions are included in an essentially nonperturbative way using e.g. the measured value of the plaquette . in lattice theory tadpole corrections
renormalise the link operator so that the vev is considerably smaller than one . as a recipe ones scales the link variables with @xmath167 measured in monte carlo @xmath168 this leads to the consequences ( @xmath169 renormalised at some physical scale ) of rescaling the variables @xmath170 here @xmath171 denotes the number of covariant derivatives in the higher dimensional operator part ( proportional to @xmath108 ) and @xmath172 the number of covariant derivatives ( links ) of the original operator .
in that case one obtains a tadpole improved perturbative expansion of @xmath0 @xmath173 with the improved perturbative expansion @xmath174 which implies @xmath175 for the representation @xmath164 we get @xmath176 to demonstrate the influence of tadpole improvement and addition of higher dimensional operators we show in fig .
[ fig:2 ] @xcite the dependence of the critical hopping parameter @xmath177 on @xmath178 and the gauge coupling .
the nonperturbative determination of @xmath178 is taken from the alpha
collaboration @xcite .
the tadpole improved perturbation theory describes the monte carlo data ( crosses , circles ) significantly better , however a nonperturbatively determined improvement coefficient @xmath178 is favoured . in figs .
[ fig:3 ] a and b ( 180,80 ) ( 0,0 ) ( 80,0 ) perturbative predictions in @xmath179 scheme without and with tadpole improvement are shown for the renormalisation factor of the operator @xmath180 as function of @xmath181 and @xmath182 .
note the significant difference in the predictions .
\1 . we have developed an algebraic computer package to perform one loop calculations in lattice qcd perturbation theory based on _
mathematica_. part of the results have been checked by a completely independent code in _ form_. + 2 .
the fundamental bases are constructed which are necessary to remove completely @xmath1 effects for all bilinear operators up to spin 2 .
the @xmath0 factors are calculated in one loop for arbitrary coefficients of the counterterms to the operators and to the action .
the contributions including @xmath1 have been calculated for operators without derivatives .
it is planned to determine all renormalisation constants nonperturbatively .
gives an overview over the calculated renormalisation factors of lattice bilinear operators .
we would like to mention that in @xcite and @xcite the coefficients @xmath183 and @xmath108 ( for another basis of local point quark operators ) have been obtained using the schrdinger functional approach . | some basic concepts are discussed to derive renormalisation factors of local lattice operators relevant to deep inelastic structure functions and to other measurable quantities .
these @xmath0 factors can be used to relate matrix elements measured by lattice techniques to their continuum counterparts .
we discuss the @xmath1 improvement of point and one link lattice quark operators .
suitable bases of improved operators are derived .
tadpole improvement is applied to get more reliable perturbative results . |
lattice field theory with the @xmath0 term suffers from the sign problem . a conventional technique to circumvent it is to perform the fourier transform of the topological charge distribution @xmath2 in order to calculate the partition function @xmath3 @xcite .
the distribution @xmath2 is calculated with real positive boltzmann weight .
however , this still causes flattening of the free energy , which misleads to a fictitious signal of a first order phase transition . to overcome
this problem requires exponentially increasing statistics with lattice volume .
we consider the issue of flattening in terms of the maximum entropy method ( mem ) @xcite . in our previous paper
@xcite ( referred to as ( i ) hereafter ) , we used mock data constructed by the gaussian @xmath2 whose corresponding free energy is analytically known to have no singular structure at values of @xmath0 for @xmath4 and tested whether the mem would be effective in the case with flattening as well as without flattening . in the case without flattening , the results of the mem agree with the exact results . in the case with flattening
, the mem gives smoother @xmath1 than that of the fourier transform . in the present work ,
we consider an opposite case to the above , i.e. , consider a model that causes real flattening , which will be explained later .
this mimics a case where non trivial phase structure occurs at finite value of @xmath0 @xmath5 .
we generate mock data based on the model and apply the mem to them .
our aim is to study ( i ) whether flattening would be properly reproduced in this model and ( ii ) how true and fictitious flattening are distinguished in the mem analysis .
the partition function @xmath3 can be obtained by fourier - transforming the topological charge distribution @xmath2 : @xmath6e^{-s+i\theta\hat{q}(\bar{z},z ) } } { \int[d\bar{z}dz]e^{-s}}\equiv\sum_{q}e^{i\theta q}p(q ) , \label{eqn : partitionfunction}\ ] ] where @xmath7 is the action , and @xmath8 is the topological charge described by lattice fields @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
the distribution @xmath2 obtained from mc simulations can be decomposed into two parts , a true value and an error of @xmath2 .
when the error at @xmath11 dominates , the free energy density could develop a flat region in the large @xmath0 region , which misleads one into identifying flattening as a signal of a first order phase transition at a finite value of @xmath0 @xcite . instead of dealing with eq .
( [ eqn : partitionfunction ] ) , we consider @xmath12 the mem is based on bayes theorem . in our formulation , in order to calculate @xmath3 , we maximize the conditional probability , called the posterior probability @xmath13 where the probability is determined by @xmath14 and the shannon - jaynes entropy @xmath7 which includes the default model @xmath15 @xmath16 .
\label{eqn : sjentropy}\ ] ] information @xmath17 plays the important role that enforces @xmath3 to be positive .
the parameter @xmath18 determines the relative weights of @xmath7 . the best image of @xmath3 for a fixed @xmath18 is then given by @xmath19 this is followed by the successive procedures in order to obtain @xmath18-independent final image @xmath20 @xcite : ( i ) averaging @xmath21 : @xmath22 and ( ii ) error estimation . in ( i )
, we used the gaussian @xmath2 for the mem analysis , which is parameterized as @xmath23 , \label{eqn : pqparametrize}\ ] ] where @xmath24 is a constant ( = 7.42 ) and @xmath25 is regarded as the lattice volume . in order to address a question whether flattening is due to the statistical error or due to the characteristic of the data themselves , and a question whether these two are distinguished in terms of the mem
, we consider a simple model .
suppose in some lattice theory that calculated @xmath2 were slightly deviated from the gaussian one only at @xmath11 : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is a constant .
the partition function is analytically obtained by use of the poisson sum formula as @xmath28 + p_0 .\label{eqn : poissonsum}\ ] ] because the first term in eq .
( [ eqn : poissonsum ] ) is monotonically decreasing function of @xmath0 in the region @xmath29 , the second one gives a flat distribution at large values of @xmath0 .
we generate mock data based on @xmath2 in eq .
( [ eqn : pqtoy ] ) by adding gaussian noise with the variance @xmath30 for each value of @xmath31 .
figure [ fig : zv50c0 & ] displays the behavior of @xmath3 calculated by the numerical fourier transform of eq .
( [ eqn : pqtoy ] ) for @xmath32 and various values of @xmath27 ; @xmath33 , @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
the parameter @xmath36 is chosen to be @xmath37 .
figure [ fig : zv50c0 & ] also displays @xmath3 for @xmath32 and @xmath38 , which was studied in ( i ) in detail .
clear flattening is observed in all the cases . when noise is added , the partition function for eq .
( [ eqn : pqtoy ] ) is given by @xmath39 where @xmath40 is a normalization constant .
when the constant term dominates in the large @xmath0 region , @xmath41 . for @xmath32 and @xmath33 , @xmath40
is numerically estimated as 4.45 and thus @xmath42 . for other choice of @xmath27 , @xmath34 and @xmath35 ,
@xmath43 becomes @xmath44 and @xmath45 , respectively .
these values agree with those of flattening observed in fig .
[ fig : zv50c0 & ] , and we thus find that flattening for these @xmath46 is not caused by the error in @xmath2 but is due to the additional term in eq .
( [ eqn : pqtoy ] ) . on the other hand ,
flattening for the @xmath38 case in fig .
[ fig : zv50c0 & ] is due to the errors in @xmath2 as investigated in ( i ) .
having distinguished two kinds of flattening , we test whether the mem can properly reproduce the true one .
we employ the case for @xmath33 , as an example .
figure [ fig : zv50c4e-2 ] displays @xmath47 for various values of @xmath18 , which is calculated by eq . ( [ eqn : maximumcondition ] ) .
the default model is chosen to be the constant one , @xmath48 .
we find that @xmath47 are independent of the values of @xmath18 .
they show clear flattening , which are in agreement with the result of the fourier transform and also with that of the poisson sum formula , eq . ( [ eqn : poissonsum ] ) .
the probability @xmath49 shows a narrow peak located at @xmath50 .
thus @xmath51 agrees with @xmath52 in fig .
[ fig : zv50c4e-2 ] , and the mem yields true flattening . with other choice of the value of @xmath27 , we repeat the same procedure . for @xmath53 ,
the mem yields true flattening as in the case @xmath33 .
this is plotted in fig .
[ fig : zv50c4e-3 ] . for @xmath54 , however , this is not the case .
we find that the critical value of @xmath27 above which flattening is properly reproduced is @xmath55 .
this critical value of @xmath27 is associated with the magnitude of the error in @xmath2 . in summary
, we have applied the mem to mock data with true flattening and found that flattening is well reproduced .
this is in contrast to the case of fictitious flattening studied in ( i ) , where the mem could predict no fictitious flattening @xcite .
applicability of the mem associated with the magnitude of the errors in @xmath2 will be reported elsewhere .
wiese , nucl .
* b318 * ( 1989 ) , 153 .
r. k. bryan , eur .
j. * 18 * ( 1990 ) , 165 .
m. asakawa , t. hatsuda and y. nakahara , prog .
nucl . phys .
* 46 * ( 2001 ) , 459 .
m. imachi , y. shinno and h. yoneyama , prog .
* 111 * ( 2004 ) , 387 .
j. c. plefka and s. samuel , phys .
* d56 * ( 1997 ) , 44 . m. imachi , s. kanou and h. yoneyama , prog .
* 102 * ( 1999 ) , 653 .
r. burkhalter , m. imachi , y. shinno and h. yoneyama , prog .
* 106 * ( 2001 ) , 613 . | we study the sign problem in lattice field theory with a @xmath0 term , which reveals as flattening phenomenon of the free energy density @xmath1 .
we report the result of the mem analysis , where such mock data are used that ` true ' flattening of @xmath1 occurs .
this is regarded as a simple model for studying whether the mem could correctly detect non trivial phase structure in @xmath0 space .
we discuss how the mem distinguishes fictitious and true flattening . |
the hubble flow just outside the local group is _ dynamically cold _ , as indicated by the small scatter in the velocity - distance diagram of nearby galaxies .
this was first pointed out by sandage , tammann & hardy ( 1972 ) .
the peculiar line - of - sight velocity dispersion @xmath3 ( see eq .
[ eq : hf ] for a definition ) of galaxies within @xmath7 mpc lies in the range @xmath8 km s@xmath9 ( giraud 1986 , schlegel et al .
1994 , sandage 1999 , ekholm et al .
2001 , karachentsev et al .
this low value is likely linked to the properties of the energy - matter density field around the local group and it can be used to constrain cosmological models .
interestingly , cosmological cold dark matter ( cdm ) simulations of hierarchical structure formation have so far not been able to produce values of the velocity dispersion around simulated galaxy groups as low as the observed one .
the three models tested in the works of schlegel et al .
( 1994 ) and governato et al .
( 1997 , hereafter g97 ) all showed substantially larger velocity dispersions and failed to recover a significant number of binary systems with the properties of our local group .
typical values of @xmath3 ranged from 200 km / sec ( for the open model ) to 500 km / sec ( for the old standard " cdm model with @xmath10 ) , several times higher than the observational estimates . since these early works ,
substantial progress has been made in the determination of the main cosmological parameters .
observations indicate the presence of a significant component of smooth energy with large negative pressure ( observations of high - redshift supernovae by perlmutter et al .
1999 , riess et al .
1999 ; analysis of fluctuations of the cosmic microwave background combined with data on the large - scale structure of galactic distribution by balbi et al .
2000 , tegmark , zaldarriaga & hamilton 2001 , netterfield et al .
2002 , spergel et al .
2003 , verde et al .
2003 , dai , liang & xu 2004 ) .
this component has been dubbed dark energy , and the most appealing candidate is einstein s cosmological constant @xmath1 ( see peebles & ratra 2003 for a recent review ) . on theoretical grounds , baryshev , chernin & teerikorpi ( 2001 ) ( but see also chernin 2001 ) suggested that a dark energy ( de ) component would cause peculiar velocities to cool adiabatically in regions of the universe where dark energy overcomes the gravity of the local dark matter concentration .
in such regions , the usually growing mode of the density perturbation is decaying ( @xmath11 and @xmath12 ) .
when dark energy dominates , new structures do not condensate and linear perturbations of density and peculiar velocities field decay ( this effect was also considered for vacuum - dominated regions by chernin et al .
they have shown that for a milky - way like halo the de starts to be dominant on a scale of few mpc and that the strength of this effect is related to the equation of state of the de .
their idea was developed further by karachentsev , chernin & teerikorpi ( 2003 ) and chernin et al .
( 2004 ) , using a numerical approach to trace the trajectories of the radially expanding galaxies back in time in different cosmological models to see the effect of a cosmological constant on the evolution of the flow . in a more general frame the importance of de on cluster and galaxy scales was also pointed out by mota & van de bruck ( 2004 ) and nunes & mota ( 2004 ) using linear theory and spherical collapse model and extended to model beyond the standard frw model by teerikorpi , gromov , baryshev ( 2003 ) .
recently , klypin et al . ( 2003a ) simulated the evolution of a cosmic region resembling the real universe around 100 mpc from the local group .
the density field was mapped using the markiii survey ( willick et al .
1997 ) and a @xmath1cdm power spectrum was assumed .
the authors report a peculiar line - of - sight velocity dispersion of @xmath13 60 km / sec around the local group in their simulation , which is a significant improvement compared to previous studies .
we have extended their work on a bigger sample of simulated lgs to test if the low value of @xmath3 reflects the specific geometry of the mass distribution , or / and is a general characteristic of the cosmology used .
the possibility that the observational estimate of @xmath3 adopted in previous works be incorrect or biased can not be dismissed entirely , as the @xmath14 based on tully - fisher ( tf ) distances suffers likely from large distance errors ( which should however increase @xmath3 ) while the lower value estimated by ekholm et al .
( 2001 ) was based on a sample of only 9 galaxies . moreover , the galaxies in the tf sample used by schlegel et al .
( 1994 ) had been `` regrouped '' .
this was necessary in order to avoid inflating @xmath3 with the internal velocity dispersion of small virialised galaxy associations .
no detail , however , was given on how the procedure was carried out .
if , for example , the velocities of loose , non virialised associations of galaxies are averaged , the @xmath3 could be effectively `` cooled '' by removing the peculiar motion of infalling galaxies .
all considered , the existing literature raises interesting questions but leaves them partially unanswered : is the low value of @xmath3 a generic problem of all cdm models or does it depend on the cosmology adopted ?
how important is the influence of the local environment and/or the surrounding large scale structure ? is the addition of a cosmological constant important ? how robust is the observational estimate of @xmath3 around our own lg ? motivated by the growing success of flat @xmath1-dominated models and the availability of more accurate distance estimates , we embarked on a new analysis of the problem . in this paper
, we present a new sample of distances and velocities of nearby galaxies combined with results from other authors on the very local ( @xmath15 mpc ) hubble flow .
we compare these observational data with new high resolution simulations , considering de models with a constant equation of state parameter @xmath16 different from @xmath17 in order to test the impact of de on the cooling of the local hubble flow .
to obtain a robust estimate of the coldness of the hubble flow around the local group , it is essential to use accurate distances to nearby galaxies . as noted above , previous measures of @xmath3
were based on tf distances , which suffer from fairly large relative errors , especially for small , poorly resolved galaxies and/or viewed at unfavourable angles . to this purpose
we have gathered data from different sources : cepheid - based distances taken from the hubble space telescope ( hst ) key project to measure the hubble constant ( freedman et al .
2001 ) , distance estimates based on the surface brightness fluctuation method ( sbf , tonry et al .
2001 ) and , mainly as a comparison , tf distances ( tully et al .
1992 ) . for galaxies common to several samples
we have kept the cepheid - based distances .
the final sample contains 28 galaxies within 10 mpc from the sun ( 11 with cepheid - based distances ; 17 early type galaxies with distances measured using the sbf method : 37 with tf distances ) .
we have converted heliocentric distances into distances relative to the barycenter of the local group , taken 2/3 of the way on the line between m 31 and the milky way ( hereafter denoted as @xmath18 ) . as for the heliocentric distance to m 31 , we used the cepheid derived value of 870 kpc ( ekholm et al .
the observed heliocentric velocities , taken from the nasa extragalactic database , were corrected to the values they would have if measured from an observer in our galaxy at rest relative to the centroid of the local group , according to yahil et al .
( 1977 ) . with this sample of 28 galaxies
it is also possible to measure how @xmath3 changes with radius as larger and larger volumes ( with radius up to 10 mpc ) are included .
[ fig : flow ] shows a velocity - distance plot , where the distances are relative to the barycenter of the lg and the velocities have been corrected for the solar motion toward the centroid of the local group .
the crosses show the tf points , the black dots the cepheid - based values and the filled squares are from the sbf sample .
the straight line corresponds to @xmath19 km s@xmath9 mpc@xmath9 .
measures of @xmath3 including the tf sample proved to be systematically higher by 3040% than those using only galaxies with cepheid- or sbf - based distances independent of the particular sky quadrant they were selected , showing that tf galaxies are not tracing different ( hotter ) structures , but are rather subject to larger distance errors .
we then decided to not use the tf sample .
we regrouped galaxies in regions with a number overdensity larger than 64 .
this overdensity threshold corresponds roughly to virialised region ( eke et al .
each group was assigned the mean position and velocity of its members . only a smaller number ( @xmath20% ) of galaxies were linked together , mostly into binary and triple systems .
result obtained using our regrouping scheme , do not differ substantially from those using galaxy sample without regrouping .
the velocity dispersion increases with the size of the sphere within which galaxies are included .
it varies from 52 km s@xmath9 within 3 mpc to 135 km s@xmath9 within 10 mpc .
this is in agreement with previous results of ekholm et al .
( 2001 ) based on 7 galaxies within 7 mpc and those of schlegel et al .
( 1994 ) , based on a sample of galaxies between 3 and 7 mpc .
our estimate of @xmath3 is a bit higher than the one obtained by karachentsev et al .
( 2003b ) who found @xmath21 km / sec inside a sphere of 5 mpc using distances from luminosity of the tip of the red giant branch stars of 16 dwarf galaxies , but the results are compatible at the @xmath22 level .
for @xmath3 measured using hst and sbf galaxies in spheres centered on the lg with growing radius @xmath23 we obtained the following fit : @xmath24 the final results of the relation @xmath3 vs enclosing radius are shown in fig .
[ fig : rho ] , where we also include the results of karachentsev et al .
( 2002 ) for the very local ( @xmath25 mpc ) hubble flow .
in this section , we very briefly review the analytical work done on the subject of cold flows in the context of the local group hubble flow . specifically baryshev et al .
( 2001 ) and axenides & perivolaropoulos ( 2002 ) had already suggested on the basis of simple dynamical arguments that dark energy could appear as a cooler of peculiar motions in the local group environment . what is the expected trend as the constant @xmath16 in the equation of state of dark energy changes ? a first fundamental difference between the quintessence and the @xmath1 ( @xmath26 ) models is the epoch at which dark energy dominates over the gravitational attraction of the matter .
the expansion of a flat universe with dark energy is governed by the friedmann equation @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the scale factor .
the dark energy term dominates over the gravitational attraction of the matter at redshifts lower than @xmath29 : @xmath30 for @xmath26 , this gives @xmath31 and for @xmath2 @xmath32 .
it has been argued from linear perturbation theory that dark energy has little effect on the local dynamics ( lahav et al .
1991 , wang & steinhardt 1998 ) . in linear perturbation theory ,
the peculiar velocity field associated with a spherical mass concentration with density contrast @xmath33 averaged over proper radius @xmath23 is @xmath34 , where @xmath35 ; @xmath36 with @xmath37 ( peebles 1980 ) .
wang & steinhardt ( 1998 ) have provided an approximation to @xmath38 in quintessence models , which showed that the difference between the linear peculiar velocities in models with different @xmath16 is negligible , as the growth factor depends mainly on @xmath39 and dark energy dominates only at late times .
however , it has been later recognized that peculiar velocities can be cooled locally for galaxies located in a `` dark energy dominated zone '' ( baryshev et al .
2001 ) . considering a shell enclosing a mass @xmath40 evolving in an expanding background
, one can calculate a zero - mass " radius beyond which the dark energy dominates over the gravitational attraction of the matter ( @xmath41 ) .
the equation of motion of the shell is : @xmath42 baryshev et al .
( 2001 ) have argued that peculiar velocities are cooled adiabatically for galaxies situated beyond the zero - mass surface , where dark energy dominates the dynamics . for @xmath26 ,
the zero - mass radius is independent of the redshift : @xmath43 using @xmath44 m@xmath45 for the local group ( van den bergh 1999 ) and our adopted cosmological parameters . for @xmath46
, we have @xmath47 for @xmath48 ( which is equivalent to an open model with the same matter energy content ) , @xmath49 . for @xmath2 , @xmath50 .
this gives @xmath51 mpc .
note that the relative importance of dark energy on the dynamics of galaxies around a mass concentration varies in time , depending on the local density contrast .
the zero - mass radius is larger around high - density regions , and for a given region it increases with cosmic time .
so a galaxy which is now close to the local group and within the matter dominated zone could have been in the dark energy dominated zone in the past ( even if the dynamics of the universe as a whole was not dark energy dominated ) and have had its peculiar velocity cooled during a period of time .
numerical simulations make it possible to see the integrated effect of the dynamical evolution of galaxies around concentrations of mass , which can not be calculated easily analytically as galaxies could move in and out of dark energy dominated zones .
if a galaxy has been in the dark energy dominated zone at @xmath52 from redshift @xmath29 until now , then its peculiar velocity will have cooled adiabatically : @xmath53 as an upper limit for the peculiar velocity , one can take the hubble expansion velocity @xmath54 : @xmath55 for @xmath26 , one obtains @xmath56 for @xmath2 one has @xmath57 this upper limit on the peculiar velocity is lower by about 9% in the quintessence model with @xmath2 than in the cosmological constant case . as pointed out by baryshev et al .
( 2001 ) , when @xmath58 both linear modes are decaying ( the second , usually growing mode , decays as @xmath59 for @xmath60 ) . both density perturbations and peculiar velocities decay .
the lower the value of @xmath16 the faster is the decay , so we would expect to have a colder hubble flow in the @xmath1cdm model than in the qcdm one , compensating for the earlier dominance of de that we have in models with @xmath61 .
these two contrary effects make hard to predict which dark energy model will present a colder hubble flow in a given environment .
the only way to test this scenario is via numerical simulations , that we will present in the next section . in cosmologies with no dark energy component like the open cdm model ( equivalent to @xmath48 ) , the zero - mass surface
is pushed to infinity and there are no decaying modes so peculiar velocities ca nt be cooled , which is consistent with the high peculiar velocities seen in simulation of the ocdm model by governato et al .
( 1997 ) .
finally , axenides & perivolaropoulos ( 2002 ) have calculated the growth suppression factor of velocity fluctuations in a dark energy model compared to the einstein - de sitter model and concluded that the presence of dark energy is not sufficient to explain the coldness of the local flow .
however , this holds true for cosmological models with different @xmath16 _ and _ the same high redshift normalization of the density field perturbations
. however , realistic models must be normalized to match the observed value of @xmath62 at @xmath63 . from the above analysis it seems plausible that cosmologies with a dark energy component would present colder flows around cosmic haloes .
however the magnitude of this effect , the dependence on @xmath16 and on the local properties of the density field remain poorly constrained by simple analytical arguments based on linear extrapolations .
these considerations make resorting to numerical @xmath0body simulations necessary .
we present results from four simulations , performed using two different codes : @xmath1cdm : two simulations , both with @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66=0.7 , @xmath67 but with different resolutions ( see details below ) ; @xmath1wdm : a flat model similar to the low resolution @xmath1cdm but with a sterile neutrino mass of 2 kev as a warm dark matter candidate ; qcdm : a quintessence model with the same parameter of the previous two simulations @xmath1c(w)dm model but with a constant equation of state parameter for the dark energy @xmath68 .
the @xmath1 simulations were performed using pkdgrav , a parallel , multistepping tree - code with periodic boundary conditions ( stadel 2001 ) . for the quintessence simulation
, we used the parallel adaptive refinement tree code art ( courtesy of a. klypin , kravtsov , klypin & khokhlov 1997 ) .
qcdm models with @xmath69 are now disfavored by cmb observation ( kogut et al .
2003 , verde et al .
nevertheless we have used this value for @xmath16 in order to try to maximize the influence of dark energy on @xmath3 ( so it will be used as a limiting case ) . according to theoretical expectation ( baryshev et al .
( 2001 ) and section [ sec : theo ] ) the strength of this effect depends on the epoch when the de becomes the dominant component of the universe : the earlier the de period begins , the stronger the cooling . in our qcdm model
the de period starts earlier than in the @xmath1cdm model , and so we would expect a larger effect of dark energy ( but see discussion in earlier paragraph ) . to calculate the power spectrum @xmath70 for the @xmath1wdm model and the qcdm used the cmbfast code to generate transfer functions ( seljak & zaldarriaga , 1996 ) .
sterile neutrinos are a popular candidate for warm dark matter ( dodelson & widrow 1994 , dolgov & hansen 2002 ) .
though formation mechanisms for sterile neutrinos are likely to produce a non - thermal energy spectrum , the filtering effect may still be modeled accurately using thermal neutrinos with adjusted masses ( hansen et al .
2001 ) . the @xmath1wdm model can be characterized in terms of the reduction in fluctuations on dwarf galaxy scales . for 2 kev
neutrinos the fluctuations on the scale of @xmath71 m@xmath45 ( @xmath72 ) are down by 10% over @xmath1cdm .
the power spectrum at @xmath73 mpc is lower by 2 orders of magnitude and thus contribution of small objects to @xmath72 is vastly reduced .
fluctuations on the scale of @xmath74 m@xmath45 haloes are only marginally affected ( @xmath75 down by 3% ) .
each @xmath1c(w)dm simulation cube is 100 mpc on a side with both using 144@xmath76 particles and a spline kernel softening of 60 kpc ( the spline kernel is completely newtonian at 2 softening lengths ) the qcdm simulation has a box size of 90 mpc with 128@xmath76 particles , which gives roughly the same mass resolution as the low resolution @xmath1 run . since our goal is to identify galactic sized dark haloes , not to resolve their internal structure , this combination of mass / force resolution is adequate .
each simulation used at least 512 steps for every particle , and many more ( up to a few thousands ) for particles with large accelerations as those at the center of dense haloes .
the mass resolution is such that a well resolved halo ( 30 particles ) at redshift zero has a circular velocity of 95 km / s . we can therefore resolve isolated haloes that are associated with galaxies that have luminosities as low as a few % of an @xmath77 galaxy ( cole et al . 2001 ) .
we have also analysed a very high resolution simulation for the @xmath1cdm model , with @xmath78 dark matter particles simulated from a starting redshift @xmath79 .
the employed volume is 50 @xmath80mpc , which gives a particle mass of @xmath81 m@xmath82 allowing us to resolve haloes down to less than @xmath83m@xmath82 with 75 particles .
the force resolution is 5 @xmath84 kpc and the particles in the highest density region undergo 20 000 timesteps ( this simulation is described in more details in reed et al .
2003a ) . in this run
, we are able to resolve the substructure inside haloes corresponding to galaxy groups , allowing us to evaluate the effect of substructure within larger haloes in velocity dispersion measurements . the results of a comparison with the low resolution run are shown in fig .
[ fig : resol ] .
our @xmath1cdm model has parameters very close to those currently suggested by observational results .
this model has been successful on an extended number of crucial tests on scales down to a few mpc .
however , recent results pointed out a possible flaw of @xmath1cdm at galactic and subgalactic scales , like steeper density profiles than those implied by galaxy rotation curves ( moore et al .
1998 , de block & bosma 2002 , swaters et al .
2003 , reed et al .
2003b , diemand et al .
2004a ) and an excess of substructure ( i.e. small satellites ) in galactic haloes ( moore et al . 1999 ,
klypin et al
. 1999 , ghigna et al .
2000 , de lucia et al .
2004 , diemand et al . 2004b ; klypin et al .
( 2003b ) for qcdm model ) .
both problems may be linked to an excess of power at small scales .
hence , as a cure to the above mentioned problem a wdm rather than cdm component reduces the amount of density fluctuation and subgalactic scale and may prove useful in cooling the hubble flow around the local group . to boost its possible effects we used for the mass of the wdm a value of 2 kev ,
this is close to the minimum allowed from constraints based on satellites abundance and the abundance of absorption systems ( bode , ostriker & turok 2000 ) .
a lower wdm mass would likely underproduce both of them .
recently yoshida et al . ( 2003 ) put strong constraints on wdm candidates lighter than 10kev based on the abundance of haloes at the epoch of reionization .
our simulations only follow the evolution of the dark matter component .
it is expected that baryons condense and form galaxies at the centers of the dark matter haloes ( white & rees 1978 ; cen & ostriker 1992,1993a , b ; katz , hernquist & weinberg 1992 ) . for our purpose of locating lg halo candidates ( not resolving their internal structure )
, we resorted to two algorithms : so and skid ( skid is publicly available at http://www-hpcc.astro.washington.edu ) .
our version of so ( lacey & cole 1995 ) uses skid halo centers ( based on the density maxima ) as a start , then a sphere is grown around this center until the enclosed density drops below some threshold which is chosen to be that associated with the average density inside a spherical virialised halo in that given cosmology ( values were @xmath85 and @xmath86 for lc(w)dm and qcdm respectively ( mainini et al .
2003 ) ; at difference with skid , so imposes a spherical symmetry to the haloes and , perhaps more importantly , regroups substructure within larger virialized structures .
we verify that this does not affect our results in subsection 6.2 .
we verified that our results were largely independent on which halo finder we used and decided to show results only from so . in this paper
we assume that a galaxy with a certain circular velocity would be found in a dark halo that has a similar circular velocity ( cole et al .
2001 ) .
following g97 , from the halo catalogs obtained we selected `` local groups '' , i.e. binary haloes with the following criteria : 1 . a generic sample of binary haloes with separations @xmath87 mpc and circular velocities @xmath88 km / sec .
a lg sample defined such that @xmath89 mpc , circular velocities @xmath88 km / sec , negative radial velocities and no neighbors within 3 mpc with circular velocity larger than either of the two group members .
3 . a lg sample defined as ( 2 ) but with the additional requirement that the binary haloes must lie close ( 512@xmath84mpc ) to a virgo sized cluster with @xmath90 km / sec . in the @xmath1cdm cosmology ,
about 30 local groups satisfy criteria 1 ) and 2 ) , and about 15 satisfy point 3 ) as well .
as we will show later there are no significant differences between samples 2 and 3 ( and actually with the global field halo population , see fig .
[ fig : all ] ) , and we will refer to our local group sample as systems identified using criterion 2 ) .
we define the peculiar line - of - sight velocity dispersion from the hubble flow for a set of haloes within a sphere of radius @xmath23 ( in mpc ) centered on the center of mass of each simulated lg as : @xmath91}^2 } \label{eq : hf}\ ] ] where @xmath92 where a local hubble constant h@xmath93 is fit to each dataset of haloes .
we have used the same procedure also to analyse the data points shown in fig . [
fig : rho ] . comparing the results from this new set of simulations to the ones obtained by g97 ( see fig . [
fig : overd ] ) , it is evident that the new , dark energy dominated models fare better , expecially when compared to the new observational estimate of @xmath3 .
the velocity dispersion is down by at least a factor of two compared to the classical , but outdated scdm model for a large range of overdensities .
= @xmath1cdm and @xmath1wdm give almost the same @xmath3 for the whole range of overdensities .
the qcdm model produces a colder hubble flow , as better shown in fig .
[ fig : cfr ] . in fig .
[ fig : resol ] we show the comparison between low and high resolution simulations .
as expected , the high resolution run has a higher value of @xmath3 at small scales , due to the fact that we are able to resolve the inner structure of the more massive haloes ( corresponding to galaxy groups ) around the lgs .
the velocity dispersion is lower on scales @xmath94 mpc .
this could be related to the smaller box size that reduces the effect of the large - scale structure . nevertheless , both simulations agree within the 1@xmath95 error bars showing that the effect of substructure is small .
as shown by g97 , the velocity dispersion around the hubble flow depends strongly on the local overdensity .
this can be determined for the local group using the complete catalogue of iras galaxies .
the current best estimate based on iras galaxies is @xmath96 for a top - hat sphere of radius 500 km / s ( strauss 1996 , private communication ) .
hudson ( 1993 ) uses a compilation of optical galaxy surveys to study the local density field and within the same volume he finds an overdensity of @xmath97 .
the agreement between the optical and iras surveys is encouraging and indicates that the local group resides in a region of the universe of almost average density .
= = = if simulated lgs are selected in regions with a local overdensity between @xmath98 , both the normalization and the shape of the @xmath3 vs @xmath23 relation are well reproduced ( see fig . [
fig : rho ] ) a remarkable success for flat , @xmath1-dominated models .
the @xmath1wdm performs equally well ( cf fig .
[ fig : cfr ] , the higher value of @xmath3 at very small scales is of small statistical significance ) , indicating that it is the presence of a cosmological constant , which is the most important ingredient , rather than the details of the power spectrum at subgalactic scales .
this is further supported by the qcdm simulation , which produces a hubble flow colder than in both @xmath1 models at all scales .
that seems to indicate that a longer period of dark energy dominance has the capability to produce a colder hubble flow , in agreement with the theoretical expectations by baryshev et al .
( 2001 ) and section [ sec : theo ] ) .
comparing our analysis to the results of g97 , it appears that only de - dominated models are able to satisfy at the same time small and large scale structure constraints _ and _ generate a substantial number of simulated lgs with @xmath3 comparable to the observed values .
also , lgs in lc(w)dm cosmologies fail to have @xmath3 in the correct range if their local overdensity is too high or too low , as shown in fig .
[ fig : rho ] .
how are important the details of the mass distribution around the lg other than the average density on a few mpc scale ?
klypin et al .
( 2003a ) obtained a cold hubble flow around a simulated region that replicated the mass distribution inferred from a redshift survey of the local universe .
their simulation assumed a @xmath1cdm cosmology .
their work was based on one constrained simulation of our local environment , our lg samples were selected using some simple selection environment criteria like the absence of nearby massive groups or the presence of a rich cluster within 512 mpc .
however , no substantial difference was found between the typical @xmath3 in the different subsamples depending on the presence of nearby clusters . to further test the hypothesis that a special local mass distribution is necessary for a cold hubble flow
, we repeated our analysis for a much larger sample of milky way ( mw ) sized field haloes , with no special selection criteria .
results are shown in fig .
[ fig : all ] .
a generic sample of mw - sized field haloes shows values of @xmath3 in the correct range if the local environment density is around average .
this shows that the local group environment and details of its mass distribution are not special in any significant way and that in de - dominated cosmologies a small @xmath3 is a general characteristic of the environment around field galaxies .
observational evidence at large and intermediate scale points to a flat , @xmath1-dominated cdm universe .
the coldness of the hubble flow provides another , independent test at intermediate scales , where different kinds of dark matter and energy could play a significant role in shaping the local dynamics . in this paper
we have tested the predictions from cosmological models now strongly supported by observational evidence against a new , robust estimate of the local group @xmath3 in spheres of increasing radius up to 10 mpc based on a sample of nearby galaxies .
we have shown that simulations are able to successfully reproduce the observed cold hubble flow around field galaxies only in a flat , de ( @xmath99 ) dominated cosmology and only in environments where the local density measured on a scale of a few mpc is close to the average one .
the inclusion of a warm dark matter component does not change this result significantly , as removal of small - scale power does not play a major role .
we have also shown that @xmath61 ( quintessence models ) where the era dominated by dark energy begins earlier , produce an hubble flow marginally colder than @xmath1cdm .
this is in agreement with the theoretical expectation ( see section [ sec : theo ] and also baryshev et al .
2001 , chernin et al . 2004 ) that the coldness of the local hubble flow follows from the fact that a galaxy s peculiar velocity decreases via adiabatic cooling if it spends a sufficient time in the dark energy dominated region where linear perturbations decay .
the presence of a dark energy field is then the key ingredient to explain the observed coldness of the local hubble flow . while the right cosmology and environmental density are crucial , the local dynamical criteria do not single out the lg from the generic population of field galaxies .
a cold hubble flow around milky way sized galaxies is equally common as in our lg subsample .
this implies that the details of the mass distribution in our local environment , like the vicinity to larger clusters and/or voids and filamentary structures , do not play a major role in shaping its velocity field .
the environment of our local group provides a new , independent evidence for the existence of dark energy on scales of just few mpcs , corroborating the evidence gathered from observations of distant objects and the early universe .
the authors thank jeff gardner for the use of his so halo finder and anatoly klypin for the use of the art code for the qcdm run .
we also thank tom quinn , ben moore , joachim stadel , james wadsley and vandana desai for useful discussions .
fg is brooks fellow .
fg was supported in part by nsf grant ast-0098557 .
computations were carried out at cineca and arsc supercomputing centers .
ch acknowledges financial support from the swedish research council _
vetenskapsrdet_. axenides , m. & perivolaropoulos l. 2002 , phrvd 6517301a balbi , a. et al .
2000 , apjl , 545 , l1 baryshev , yu.v . ,
chernin , a.d .
& teerikorpi , t. 2001 , a&a 378 , 279 bode , p. , ostriker , j. p. , & turok , n. 2001 , apj , 556 , 93 cole , s. , lacey , c. g. , baugh , c. m. , & frenk , c. s. 2000 , mnras , 319 , 168 chernin , a.d .
2001 , physics - uspekhi 44 , 1153 chernin , a.d . , teerikorpi , p. & baryshev , y. 2003 adspr , 31 , 459 chernin , a.d .
2004 , a&a , 419 , 19 dai , z. g. , liang , e. w. & xu , d. 2004 , apjl , 612 , 110 davis , m. , efstathiou g. , frenk , c.s .
, white s. d. m. 1985 , apj , 292 , 371 de bernardis , p. , et al .
2000 , nature , 404 , 955 de block , j.g . & bosma , a. 2002 , a&a , 385 , 816 de lucia g. , kauffmann g. , springel v. , white s. d. m. , lanzoni b. , stoehr f. , tormen g. , yoshida n. , 2004 , mnras , 348 , 333 diemand , j. , moore , b. & stadel , j. 2004a , mnras , 533 , 624 diemand , j. , moore , b. & stadel , j. 2004b , mnras , 352 , 535 dodelson , s. & widrow , l. 1994 phrevl .
72 , 17d dolgol , a.d .
, & hansen , s.h .
2002 aph , 16 , 339 d eke , v. , cole , s. & frenk , c.s , 1996 , mnras , 282 , 263 ekholm , t. , baryshev , y. , teerikorpi , p. , et al . , 2001 , a&a 368 , l17 freedmann , w.l . , madore , b. , gibson , b.k . , et al . 2001 , apj 553 , 47 ghigna s. , moore b. , governato f. , lake g. , quinn t. , stadel j. , 2000 , apj , 544 , 616 giraud e. , 1986 , a&a 170 , 1 governato , f. , moore , b. , cen , r. , stadel , j. , lake , g. & quinn , t. 1997 , newa , 2 , 91 hansen , s.h . , lesgourgues j. , pastor , s. & silk , j. 2002 , mnras , 333 , 544 jenkins , a. et al 1998 , apj , 499 , 201 karachentsev , i.d .
2002 , a&a , 389 , 812 karachentsev , i.d . ,
chernin , a.d .
& teerikorpi , p. 2003a
, ap , 46 , 399 karachentsev , i.d .
2003b , a&a , 389 , 479 klypin a. , gottl " ober s. , kravtsov a. v. , khokhlov a. m. , 1999 , apj , 516 , 530 klypin , a. , hoffman , y. , kravtsov . , a. & gottloeber , s. 2003a apj , 596 , 19 klypin , a. , macci a.v .
, mainini r. , & bonometto s.a .
2003b apj , 599 , 31 kogut , a. et al .
2003 , apjs , 148 , 161 kravtsov , a. , klypin , a. & khokhlov a. , 1997 apj , 111 , 73 lahav o. , lilje p.b .
, primack j.r .
, rees m.j . , 1991 ,
mnras 251 , 128 mainini r. , macci a.v . &
bonometto s.a .
2003 newa , 8 , 173 moore , b. , governato , f. , quinn , t. , stadel , j. & lake , g. ( 1998 ) , apjl , 499 , l5 moore b. , ghigna s. , governato f. , lake g. , quinn t. , stadel j. , tozzi p. , 1999 ,
apj , 524 , l19 mota , d.f . &
van de bruck , c. 2004 a&a , 421 , 71 nunes , n. & mota , d.f .
2004 , mnras submitted , astro - ph/0409481 peebles , p.j.e . & ratra , b. 2003 rvmp , 75 , 559p peebles , p.j.e . , 1980 , the large scale structure of the universe .
princeton university press , princeton , nj perlmutter , s. , et al .
1999 , apj , 440 , l41 press , w. h. & schechter , p. 1974 , apj , 187 , 425 reed , d. et al .
2003a , mnras 346 , 565 reed , d. et al .
2003b , mnras submitted , astro - ph/0312544 riess , a. g. , et al .
1998 , aj , 114 , 722 sandage , a. , 1986 , apj 307 , 1 sandage , a. , tamman , g.a .
& hardy , e. 1972 apj , 172 , 253 schlegel , d , davis , m. , summers , f. , holtzman , j.a . , 1994 , apj 427 , 527 seljak , u. & zaldarriaga , m. , 1996 apj , 469 , 437 spergel , d.n .
2003 , apjs , 148 , 175s stadel , j. 2001 , phd thesis , univ .
washington swaters r.a , madore , b.f .
, van den bosh , f.c . & balcells , m. 2003 , apj 583 , 732 tegmark , m , zaldarriaga , m. & hamilton , a. 2001 phrvd 63d3007 teerikorpi , p. , gromov , a. & baryshev , yu .
( 2003 ) a&a 407 , l9 tonry , j.l . , dressler , a. , blakeslee , j.p .
, et al . , 2001 ,
apj , 546 , 681 tully , r.b . ,
shaya , e.j . ,
pierce , m.j .
, 1992 , apjs 80 , 479 van den bergh , s. , 1999 , a&arv , 9 , 273 verde , l. et al .
2003 , apjs , 148 , 195 wang l. , steinhardt p.j . , 1998 , apj 508 , 483 willick , j.a , courteau , s. , faber , s. m. , burstein , d.,dekel .
a. & strauss , m. , a. 1997 , apjs , 109 , 333 yahil , a. , tammann , g.a . ,
sandage , a. , 1977 , apj 217 , 903 yoshida n. , sokasian a. , hernquist l. , springel v. , 2003 , apj , 591 , l1 | using @xmath0-body simulations of flat , dark energy dominated cosmologies , we show that galaxies around simulated binary systems resembling the local group ( lg ) have low peculiar velocities , in good agreement with observational data .
we have compared results for lg - like systems selected from large , high resolution simulations of three cosmologies : a @xmath1cdm model , a @xmath1wdm model with a 2 kev warm dark matter candidate and a quintessence model ( qcdm ) with an equation of state parameter @xmath2 .
the hubble flow is significant colder around lgs selected in a flat , @xmath1 dominated cosmology than around lgs in open or critical models , showing that a dark energy component manifests itself on the scales of nearby galaxies , cooling galaxy peculiar motions .
flows in the @xmath1wdm and qcdm models are marginally colder than in the @xmath1cdm one . the results of our simulations have been compared to existing data and a new data set of 28 nearby galaxies with robust distance measures ( cepheids and surface brightness fluctuations ) .
the measured line - of - sight velocity dispersion is @xmath3 = 88@xmath4 20 km / sec @xmath5 ( r/7 mpc ) .
the best agreement with observations is found for lgs selected in the @xmath1cdm cosmology in environments with @xmath6 on scales of 7 mpc , in agreement with existing observational estimates on the local matter density .
these results provide new , independent evidence for the presence of dark energy on scales of few mpc , corroborating the evidence gathered from observations of distant objects and the early universe .
= = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupeurmn @mathgroup@bold@groupeurbn @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupmsamn @mathgroup@bold@groupmsamn = `` 019 = ' ' 016 = `` 040 = ' ' 336 = " 33e = = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 = = = = = = = = cosmology : theory dark matter
large - scale structure of the universe galaxies : clusters galaxies : haloes methods : numerical |
supesymmetric extension is a good candidate for physics beyond the standard model ( sm ) .
the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) is the simplest extension .
the mssm is quite interesting because of its minimality and its detailed studies have been done for several aspects .
however , the mssm has the fine - tuning problem . within the framework of the mssm , the @xmath4-boson mass , @xmath5 ,
is obtained as @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the soft supersymmetry ( susy ) breaking scalar mass squared of the up - sector higgs field and @xmath1 is the supersymmetric mass . the radiative corrections on @xmath7 are obtained as @xmath8 , where @xmath9 and @xmath10 denote the stop and gluino masses , respectively . in
most of cases , the stop and the gluino masses are much larger than @xmath5 .
thus , we need fine - tuning between @xmath7 and @xmath11 to realize the correct value of @xmath5 .
furthermore , it is required that @xmath12 tev or larger in order to obtain the higgs mass such as @xmath13 gev which is recently reported by atlas and cms collaborations@xcite .
the mirage mediation is one of the interesting mediation mechanisms of susy breaking @xcite .
the mirage mediation is a mixture of the modulus mediation @xcite and the anomaly mediation @xcite with a certain ratio .
in particular , it was pointed out that the tev - scale mirage mediation can ameliorate the above fine - tuning problem of the mssm @xcite . in the tev - scale mirage mediation , the above radiative corrections on @xmath7 and
the anomaly mediation contributions are canceled each other .
then , the value of @xmath14 at the electroweak scale can be smaller than stop and gluino masses .
the tev scale mirage mediation also leads several phenomenologically interesting aspects @xcite because its susy particle spectrum is quite compressed .
the next - to - minimal supersymmetric standard model ( nmssm ) is the extension of the mssm by adding a singlet @xmath15 @xcite ( see for review e.g. @xcite ) .
here , we also impose the @xmath16 symmetry .
the nmssm does not have the @xmath1-term , @xmath17 , in the superpotential , where @xmath18 and @xmath19 denote the up and the down - sector higgs superfields , respectively . on the other hand ,
the term @xmath20 is allowed in the nmssm superpotential .
after @xmath15 develops its vacuum expectation value ( vev ) , the effective @xmath1-term is generated .
that gives us a solution for the so - called @xmath1-problem @xcite .
the nmssm is also interesting in the light of the recent indication of the relatively heavy higgs boson reported by atlas and cms , endowed with an additional higgs self - coupling . in the higgs sector , the doublet higgs and singlet fields mix each other .
then , the higgs sector in the nmssm has a quite rich structure .
the nmssm also leads the same relation as ( [ eq : mz - hu ] ) , and the nmssm has the fine - tuning problem similar to the one in the mssm .
thus , it is interesting to apply the tev - scale mirage mediation to the nmssm . in this paper
, we study the nmssm with the soft susy breaking terms induced through the tev - scale mirage mediation @xcite .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we give a brief review on the mirage mediation , and the tev scale mirage mediation . in section 3 , we apply the tev scale mirage mediation to the nmssm , and study its spectrum .
section 4 is devoted to conclusion and discussion . in appendix
a , we show explicitly initial conditions of soft parameters , which are induced through the mirage mediation in the nmssm .
here , we review briefly the mirage mediation @xcite . the mirage mediation is the mixture between the modulus mediation and the anomaly mediation .
then , the gaugino masses are obtained as @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the gauge couplings and their @xmath24 function coefficients , and @xmath25 denotes the gravitino mass .
the first and the second terms in the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : gaugino - mass ] ) correspond to the contributions due to the modulus mediation and the anomaly mediation , respectively .
similarly , we obtain the so - called @xmath26-terms corresponding to the yukawa couplings , @xmath27 , and the soft scalar masses @xmath28 as @xmath29 where @xmath30 here , @xmath31 denotes the quadratic casimir corresponding to the representation of the matter field @xmath32 .
in addition , @xmath33 and @xmath34 parametrize the a - term and the scalar mass squared generated through the modulus mediation in the unit of the universal gaugino mass , @xmath35 .
these coefficients are determined by modulus - dependence of the khler metric as well as the yukawa coupling .
one can write @xmath34 as @xmath36 here , @xmath37 is calculated from the tree - level khler metric of the matter field @xmath32 and they are ratios of small integers including @xmath38 and @xmath39 @xcite .
in addition , @xmath40 is obtained with the one - loop khler metric of the matter field , but such a loop correction to the khler metric depends on the detail of the ultraviolet - model and is hard to calculate ( see e.g. ref .
that is , @xmath34 is ambiguous at the one - loop level , although such ambiguity is subdominant and less important in most of cases . here , we consider the case with @xmath41 we input the values of @xmath34 at @xmath42 gev .
it is convenient to use the following parameter @xcite , @xmath43 to represent the ratio of the anomaly mediation to the modulus mediation . here
@xmath44 is the reduced planck scale .
one of the interesting aspects in the mirage mediation is that the above spectrum and has a special energy scale , that is , the mirage scale , @xmath45 at this scale , the gaugino masses are obtained as @xcite , @xmath46 that is , the anomaly mediation contribution and the radiative corrections cancel each other , and the pure modulus mediation appears at the mirage scale .
furthermore , the @xmath26-terms and the scalar masses squared also satisfy and @xmath47 are chosen .
however , such a modification is small and can be included in ambiguities of @xmath34 if couplings are small .
see @xcite for detailed discussions .
we include this contribution in our numerical analysis . ]
@xmath48 if the corresponding yukawa couplings are small enough or if the following conditions are satisfied , @xmath49 for non - vanishing yukawa couplings , @xmath27 @xcite . when @xmath50 , the mirage scale @xmath51 is around @xmath39 tev
. then , the above spectrum ( [ eq : gaugino - mir ] ) and ( [ eq : a - m - mir ] ) is obtained at the tev scale .
that is the tev scale mirage mediation scenario . in particular
, there would appear a large gap between @xmath35 and the scalar mass @xmath28 with @xmath52 .
we will apply the tev scale mirage scenario to the nmssm in the next section . in the tev scale mirage scenario ,
the stop mass squared becomes negative at high energy @xcite , while it is positive at low energy below @xmath53 gev .
thus , the vacuum which breaks the electroweak symmetry at the electroweak scale might be a local minimum , but instead there would be a color and/or charge breaking vacuum with field values larger than @xmath53 gev . here , we assume the thermal history of the universe such that field values remain around the origin until the temperature reaches the electroweak scale .
in addition , we need to confirm that the tunnelling rate is small enough , i.e. less than the hubble expansion rate . in refs .
@xcite , it has been shown that such a rate is small enough , as long as the squark / slepton masses squared are vanishing or positive around @xmath54 gev .
this condition is satisfied in our tev scale mirage mediation scenario .
in this section , we apply the tev scale mirage mediation scenario to the nmssm . here , we briefly review on the nmssm , in particular its higgs sector before we apply the tev scale mirage mediation scenario to the nmssm . in the nmssm , we extend the mssm by adding a singlet chiral multiplet @xmath15 and imposing a @xmath16 symmetry .
then , the superpotential of the higgs sector is written as @xmath55 here and hereafter , for @xmath15 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 we use the convention that the superfield and its lowest component are denoted by the same letter .
the full superpotential also includes the yukawa coupling terms between the matter fields and the higgs fields , which are the same as those in the mssm .
the following soft susy breaking terms are induced in the higgs sector , @xmath56 then , the scalar potential of the neutral higgs fields is given as @xmath57 with @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 denote the gauge couplings of u(1)@xmath61 and su(2 ) .
the minimum of the potential is obtained by analyzing the stationary conditions of the higgs potential , @xmath62 [ eq:1 ] where @xmath63 . here , we denote vevs as @xmath64 using the above stationary conditions , we obtain the @xmath4 boson mass @xmath65 as @xmath66 where @xmath67 . for @xmath68 ,
this equation becomes @xmath69 this relation is the same as the one in the mssm .
indeed , when we neglect the second term in the right - hand side , the above relation is nothing but eq .
( [ eq : mz - hu ] ) .
thus , the natural values of @xmath70 and @xmath71 would be of @xmath72 gev .
furthermore , the natural value of @xmath73 would be of @xmath72 gev or smaller .
alternatively , @xmath71 and @xmath73 could be larger than @xmath72 gev when @xmath74 and @xmath75 are canceled each other in the above relation at a certain level .
even in such a case , @xmath70 would be naturally of @xmath72 gev .
on the other hand , other sfermion masses as well as gaugino masses must be heavy as the recent lhc results suggested . to realize such a spectrum , we apply the tev scale mirage mediation in the next section , where we take @xmath76 to realize a suppressed value of @xmath70 compared with @xmath35 . here , we study the tev scale mirage mediation scenario in the nmssm .
soft susy breaking terms are obtained through the generic formulas ( [ eq : gaugino - mass ] ) and ( [ eq : a - m ] ) with taking @xmath50 . for concreteness ,
we give explicit results of all the soft susy breaking terms for the nmssm in appendix [ app : soft ] .
we concentrate on the higgs sector as well as gauginos and stops .
we consider the following values of @xmath34 , @xmath77 for @xmath19 , @xmath18 , @xmath15 , and left and right - handed ( s)top fields , respectively .
this is the same assignment as the pattern ii in ref .
@xcite for the mssm except for @xmath78 .
then , the soft parameters due to only modulus mediation contribution are given by @xmath79 when we neglect @xmath40 .
the above assignment of @xmath34 ( [ eq : ci ] ) satisfies the condition , ( [ eq : mir - condition ] ) for the top yukawa coupling and the coupling @xmath80 , but not for the coupling @xmath81 .
however , we do not consider a large value of @xmath81 to avoid the blow - up of @xmath81 and @xmath80 as will be shown later .
thus , we obtain the following values , @xmath82 up to @xmath83 at the tev scale .
note that @xmath40 has negligible effects for these values .
similarly , we can obtain the values of @xmath84 , @xmath70 and @xmath85 at the tev scale , however those are suppressed compared with @xmath35 . for such suppressed values , sub - leading corrections e.g. the one - loop correction on the khler metric are not negligible anymore .
that introduces one - loop ambiguity into the model . including such corrections , at the tev scale we obtain @xmath86 with @xmath87 .
note that similar to eq.([eq : soft - at - mirage-1 ] ) , eq.([eq : soft - at - mirage-2 ] ) also includes corrections of @xmath88 due to the violation of the mirage unification by @xmath81 .
that is , we obtain @xmath89 up to @xmath90 at the tev scale .
similarly , at the tev scale we can obtain , @xmath91 up to @xmath92 .
because of such ambiguity , we use @xmath84 as a free parameter , which must be small compared with @xmath35 . in addition , we determine the values of @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath95 at the electroweak scale from the stationary conditions , ( [ eq:1 ] ) , where we use the experimental value @xmath96 gev and @xmath97 as a free parameter . through the above procedure , the parameters , @xmath7 , @xmath98 and @xmath1 , at the electroweak scale are expressed by @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 as follows , @xmath102 where , @xmath103 for @xmath104 , these parameters are approximated as , @xmath105 [ eq : app ] when @xmath106 , the values of @xmath1 , @xmath70 and @xmath107 are smaller than @xmath35 by the factor @xmath97 because @xmath108 .
thus , the values of @xmath1 and @xmath70 could be of @xmath72 gev while the other masses of the superpartners are of @xmath109 tev . then , the fine - tuning problem can be ameliorated .
furthermore , one can see that the first and the second terms in the last equation cancel each other for our choice of @xmath34 .
the next leading contributions are of @xmath110 or @xmath111 .
thus , @xmath112 is almost determined by @xmath7 alone and insensitive to the value of @xmath1 .
this means that actually @xmath113 is enough to obtain the fine - tuning of @xmath114% for @xmath115 tev . in this case
, @xmath1 can be as heavy as @xmath116 gev without deteriorating the fine - tuning .
the origin of this cancellation is easily understood by examining the doublet mass matrix , @xmath117 where @xmath118 the modulus mediated contribution @xmath35 cancels in the determinant of the mass matrix , @xmath119 .
the heavy mode has mass of @xmath120 , then the mass of the light mode is suppressed as @xmath121 and a flat direction appears along @xmath122 .
this mechanism was previously observed in @xcite in the context of the mssm . in the nmssm ,
the relation @xmath123 is well controlled up to the leading contribution of the modulus mediation , in contrast to the @xmath124-term ( in place of @xmath101 ) in the mssm , which is a remnant of the fine - tuned cancellation between the terms of @xmath125 and subject to uncontrolled corrections . in the following section ,
we show numerically the spectrum of our model . here
, we study numerically the spectrum of our model . before showing numerical results ,
we recall our parameters . in our analysis ,
the free parameters are @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath97 and @xmath84 given at the susy scale and @xmath35 given at @xmath126 . as the susy scale
, we choose @xmath127 . using them , we determine all of the soft susy breaking parameters except for @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath1 , which are determined by using the stationary condition of the higgs potential .
note that in the following numerical analysis we include corrections from the 1-loop effective potential , @xmath128 , \label{eq:1-loop - corr}\ ] ] in the stationary conditions ( [ eq:1 ] ) , where @xmath129 represents the mass matrix of our model and @xmath130 denotes the supertrace . in all of the following numerical analysis , we use @xmath131 gev as a typical value of @xmath84 .
when @xmath80 and/or @xmath81 are large at the electroweak scale , they blow up below the gut scale .
thus , we have constrains on large values of @xmath80 and @xmath81 by requiring that those do not blow up below the gut scale .
figure @xmath39 shows the lightest cp - even higgs mass @xmath132 , soft scalar masses of @xmath18 and @xmath15 , @xmath133 and @xmath134 , and @xmath1 for @xmath135 gev and @xmath136 , in panels ( a ) , ( c ) , ( d ) and ( e ) , respectively .
the panel ( b ) in the figure shows the coupling squared between the lightest cp - even higgs and the z bosons , @xmath137 , as the ratio to the one in the sm , i.e. @xmath138 . the second lightest cp - even higgs mass @xmath139 is also plotted in panel ( f ) . in the figure
, the red curve corresponds to the values of @xmath80 and @xmath81 at the electroweak scale , which blow up at the gut scale .
thus , we exclude the outside of this curve .
the gray region around @xmath140 corresponds to the region where the tachyonic mode appears in the higgs sector .
the yellow region is excluded because the higgs potential has the false vacua studied in ref .
@xcite , deeper than the realistic vacuum . from these constraints ,
the region with small @xmath141 is disfavored .
the gray region around the red curve indicates the region where the tree level higgs mass becomes tachyonic and the iterative procedure we employed does not work to estimate the stationary conditions .
the quantum corrections could lift the tachyonic mass , however , we do not calculate it because the region has already been excluded by the lepii bound ( @xmath142 gev ) .
the value of @xmath1 is around @xmath143 gev , which is consistent with the rough estimation in eq .
( [ eq : app-1 ] ) , i.e. @xmath144 . obviously the expansion in eq .
( [ eq : app-1 ] ) becomes worse for @xmath145 , while the expansion holds well for @xmath146 where the value of @xmath70 is around @xmath147 gev . in this region
the fine - tuning of the parameters for the electroweak symmetry breaking is of @xmath148 , even though most of the superpartners have heavy masses of @xmath120 .
a large value of @xmath149 gev potentially degrades the fine - tuning , however the cancellation renders @xmath1 irrelevant to @xmath5 at the leading order of the expansion by @xmath150 .
the value of @xmath107 is roughly estimated as @xmath151 in eq .
( [ eq : app-2 ] ) .
thus , it is found that @xmath152 gev for @xmath153 and @xmath107 increases ( decreases ) as @xmath154 increases ( decreases ) .
the value of @xmath107 is expected to be suppressed in the tev scale mirage scenario .
however , a large value of @xmath141 leads large @xmath107 through the stationary condition like @xmath155 gev . such a large value would not be realized in our tev scale mirage mediation scenario , because @xmath98 must be suppressed compared with @xmath156 .
thus , the region with large @xmath141 and @xmath157 is disfavored . in the panel ( d ) , the region with @xmath158 is filled in pink .
it is interesting that the region favored by the tev scale mirage mediation exactly corresponds to the region where the fine - tuning is ameliorated .
note that the condition ( [ eq : mir - condition ] ) also holds well for this region . in fig .
1.(a ) , the lightest cp - even higgs boson , which dominantly consists of the doublet scalar here , has a mass @xmath159 around @xmath160@xmath161 gev .
we estimated @xmath159 using nmhdecay in the nmssmtools package @xcite .
we calculated the minimum of the effective potential renormalized at @xmath162 by the iteration starting from the tree - level minimum .
then we used the resultant @xmath1 as an input of the nmssmtools .
the pole mass @xmath163 gev was used in our calculation .
the qualitative behavior of the mass of the sm - like higgs boson is given by @xmath164 for @xmath165 in @xcite .
the first term and the fourth term are the tree - level contribution and the radiative correction in the mssm , respectively .
the second term comes from the new quartic higgs couplings in the nmssm , and the third term comes from the mixing of the doublet scalars with the singlet .
the third term is always negative because the mixing reduces the lightest eigenvalue of the mass matrix .
although the above approximation does not apply in the figure , the behavior of the higgs mass can be understood in terms of the mixing .
the effect of the mixing undermines that of the additional quartic coupling @xmath166 and suppresses the higgs mass except for the narrow region @xmath167 .
the lhc observation , @xmath168 gev , is satisfied only around @xmath169 where the mixing vanishes .
such a region may be realized as a quasi - infrared fixed point if @xmath80 has a strong dynamics origin at the gut scale , while @xmath81 is suppressed due to the approximate peccei - quinn symmetry .
it is important to stress again that this region is favored by the tev scale mirage mediation and the fine - tuning .
the mixing of the doublet and the singlet higgs scalars in the lagrangian is obtained by rotating the doublet higgs by @xmath170 @xmath171 h \delta s_r , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath172 and @xmath173 denote dynamical degree of freedom of the corresponding higgs fields . since our tev scale mirage mediation scenario leads @xmath174 and @xmath175 , the above term is approximated as , @xmath176 h \delta s_r.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the mixing is automatically suppressed by @xmath177 in our scenario .
the coupling of the lightest cp - even higgs boson to the @xmath4 boson , @xmath178 , is almost the same as the one in the standard model in most of the parameter space as expected .
we show the ratio @xmath179 in the figure , where @xmath180 denotes the higgs coupling to the z boson in the standard model .
the mixing between the doublet and the singlet is minimized around @xmath168 gev , where @xmath178 also approaches to its sm value .
table 1 shows examples of spectra and @xmath179 for @xmath181 , @xmath182 and @xmath183 . in the table ,
@xmath184 for @xmath185 and @xmath186 for @xmath187 denote three cp - even higgs masses and two cp - odd higgs masses , respectively .
also , @xmath188 denote two eigenvalues of stop masses .
other squark and slepton masses depend on their values of @xmath34 , and they are of @xmath120 unless @xmath189 .
the second lightest cp - even higgs boson @xmath190 is lighter for @xmath191 and @xmath183 than the one for @xmath181 .
its dominant component is the singlet higgs boson @xmath15 .
its mass decreases as @xmath141 decreases .
then , the above behavior of @xmath192 occurs . on the other hand , the dominant component of the heaviest cp - even higgs boson
@xmath193 is the down - type higgs boson @xmath19 .
its mass is heavy and almost equal to @xmath35 , independent of @xmath80 and @xmath81 . by the same reason , the mass of the heavier cp - odd higgs boson @xmath194 is almost the same as @xmath195 as well as @xmath35 .
the lightest cp - odd higgs boson @xmath196 is lighter for small @xmath81 due to the approximate peccei - quinn symmetry .
also , three gaugino masses are almost the same as @xmath35 .
it might be challenging but interesting subject to observe these light extra - higgs bosons through the small mixing with the doublets in lhc and ilc .
l @ r and @xmath197 .
for detail of the shaded regions , see the text .
the tev scale mirage mediation disfavors the region @xmath198 gev ( pink shaded ) .
, title="fig:",height=207 ] & and @xmath197 . for detail of the shaded regions ,
see the text .
the tev scale mirage mediation disfavors the region @xmath198 gev ( pink shaded ) .
, title="fig:",height=207 ] + ' '' '' & + and @xmath197 . for detail of the shaded regions ,
see the text .
the tev scale mirage mediation disfavors the region @xmath198 gev ( pink shaded ) .
, title="fig:",height=207 ] & and @xmath197 .
for detail of the shaded regions , see the text .
the tev scale mirage mediation disfavors the region @xmath198 gev ( pink shaded ) .
, title="fig:",height=207 ] + ' '' '' & + and @xmath197 . for detail of the shaded regions , see the text .
the tev scale mirage mediation disfavors the region @xmath198 gev ( pink shaded ) .
, title="fig:",height=207 ] & and @xmath197 . for detail of the shaded regions ,
see the text .
the tev scale mirage mediation disfavors the region @xmath198 gev ( pink shaded ) .
, title="fig:",height=207 ] .spectra for @xmath199 , @xmath200 and @xmath201 with @xmath202 and @xmath203gev . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] when we increase @xmath97 , @xmath71 decreases as expected from the rough estimation , @xmath204 in eq .
( [ eq : app-1 ] ) .
for example , the value @xmath205 leads @xmath206 gev or less for @xmath207 tev , which is excluded by the chargino mass bound by lepii .
the value of @xmath107 also decreases as @xmath97 increases .
in opposite view , this means that tuning of @xmath107 ( or @xmath208 ) increases to obtain large @xmath99 for fixed @xmath209 and small @xmath99 is favored in our scenario .
finally we comment on the fermionic sector .
the singlino mass is estimated as @xmath210 .
since we have @xmath1 around @xmath211 gev , the singlino can also be light .
note that the region with small @xmath141 is excluded by the appearance of the tachyonic modes and/or the false vacua .
thus , we can not lead the singlino much lighter than the higgsino .
also , large @xmath141 leads large @xmath107 , which could not be derived in our tev scale mirage scenario .
thus , singlino much heavier than the higgsino is disfavored .
thus , both masses of the higgsino and singlino would be of the same order .
since all of gaugino masses as well as squark and slepton masses are much heavier , the lightest superparticle would be a linear combination between the higgsino and singlino , depending on @xmath141 .
the gravitino is quite heavy such as @xmath212 , as already known in the mirage mediation mechanism @xcite .
the lightest neutralino in this model behaves like the linear combination between the higgsino and bino in the mssm and could reproduce the observed abundance of the cold dark matter assuming the thermal relic saturates it @xcite . while the extra higgs bosons play an important role in the direct detection of them , which could be significantly different from the results in the mssm @xcite .
the detailed study of the phenomenology of the tev scale mirage mediation in the nmssm is interesting for its distinct mass spectrum , however , beyond the scope of this work @xcite .
we have studied the nmssm with the tev scale mirage mediation .
the region with large @xmath141 requires a large value of @xmath107 to satisfy the stationary conditions of the higgs potential .
such a large value could not be realized in our tev scale mirage scenario and therefore such parameter region is disfavored . in the favored region
, it is found that we can realize @xmath213 gev , while other masses are heavy such as @xmath39 tev .
then , the fine - tuning problem is ameliorated .
the cancellation between the effective @xmath1-term and the down - type higgs soft mass reduces the sensitivity of @xmath1 to @xmath5 and @xmath2 gev is possible without significantly deteriorating the fine - tuning .
the mixing between the light doublet and the singlet is suppressed by @xmath214 . for small @xmath99 the lightest cp - even higgs
is mainly the doublet and its mass reaches @xmath161 gev without suppression by the mixing .
when we increase @xmath35 , the higgs mass @xmath159 slowly increases , and also the value of @xmath71 increases .
however , the required fine - tuning is still mild e.g. for @xmath215 gev .
the coupling between the lightest cp - even higgs boson and the @xmath4 boson is almost the same as one in the standard model for small @xmath99 , however , can decrease to @xmath216 % for moderate @xmath99 where the lightest cp - even higgs is mainly singlet .
if the lightest cp - even higgs escapes the lepii bound , the second lightest cp - even higgs boson could be the boson observed in lhc .
the mass of the second lightest cp - even higgs boson depends on @xmath81 and @xmath80 , and it can be light in the parameter region favored in our scenario .
the heaviest cp - even higgs mass as well as the heaviest cp - odd and charged ones is of @xmath120 .
the lightest cp - odd higgs can also be light .
thus , the higgs sector has a rich structure . in our scenario ,
the higgsino is light compared with three gauginos . in addition , the singlino is also light .
both masses of the higgsino and the singlino are of the same order .
then , the lightest superparticle is a linear combination between the higgsino and singlino . such a neutralino sector and higgs sector would lead to several phenomenologically interesting aspects . while this work was being completed , we received ref .
@xcite , which also considered relevant aspects .
t. k. is supported in part by a grant - in - aid for scientific research no .
20540266 and the grant - in - aid for the global coe program `` the next generation of physics , spun from universality and emergence '' from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology of japan .
k. o. is supported in part by a grant - in - aid for scientific research no .
21740155 and no .
18071001 from the mext of japan .
t. s. is a yukawa fellow and his work is partially supported by the yukawa memorial foundation , a graint - in - aid for young scientists ( b ) no .
23740190 and the sasakawa scientific research grant from the japan science society .
numerical computation in this work was partly carried out at the yukawa institute computer facility .
here we give explicitly soft susy breaking terms induced by the mirage mediation mechanism in the nmssm . in the mirage mediation , the soft parameters at the scale just below @xmath126 are given by @xmath217 where @xmath218 here , @xmath219 and @xmath220 denote dynkin indices of the adjoint representation and the representation of matter fields @xmath32 .
we have assumed @xmath221 to be diagonal . where @xmath225 here , @xmath226 and @xmath227 denote left - handed quark , right - handed up - sector quark , right - handed down - sector quark , left - handed lepton , and right - handed lepton fields , respectively , and the index @xmath228 denotes the generation index .
we have included effects due to yukawa couplings , @xmath229 and @xmath230 , only for the third generations .
k. choi , a. falkowski , h. p. nilles , m. olechowski and s. pokorski , jhep * 0411 * , 076 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0411066 ] ; k. choi , a. falkowski , h. p. nilles and m. olechowski , nucl .
b * 718 * , 113 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0503216 ] .
k. choi , k. s. jeong and k. i. okumura , jhep * 0509 * , 039 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0504037 ] .
m. endo , m. yamaguchi and k. yoshioka , phys .
d * 72 * , 015004 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0504036 ] .
v. s. kaplunovsky and j. louis , phys .
b * 306 * , 269 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9303040 ] ; a. brignole , l. e. ibanez and c. munoz , nucl .
b * 422 * , 125 ( 1994 ) [ erratum - ibid .
b * 436 * , 747 ( 1995 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - ph/9308271 ] ; t. kobayashi , d. suematsu , k. yamada and y. yamagishi , phys .
b * 348 * , 402 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9408322 ] ; l. e. ibanez , c. munoz and s. rigolin , nucl .
b * 553 * , 43 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9812397 ] .
a. falkowski , o. lebedev and y. mambrini , jhep * 0511 * , 034 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0507110 ] ; h. baer , e. -k . park , x. tata and t. t. wang , jhep * 0608 * , 041 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0604253 ] ; jhep * 0706 * , 033 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0703024 ] ; r. kitano and y. nomura , phys .
d * 73 * , 095004 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0602096 ] ; k. kawagoe and m. m. nojiri , phys .
d * 74 * , 115011 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0606104 ] ; h. abe , y. g. kim , t. kobayashi and y. shimizu , jhep * 0709 * , 107 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0706.4349 [ hep - ph ] ] .
p. fayet , nucl .
b * 90 * , 104 ( 1975 ) ; phys .
b * 64 * , 159 ( 1976 ) ; phys .
b * 69 * , 489 ( 1977 ) ; phys .
b * 84 * , 416 ( 1979 ) ; h. p. nilles , m. srednicki and d. wyler , phys .
b * 120 * , 346 ( 1983 ) ; j. m. frere , d. r. t. jones and s. raby , nucl .
b * 222 * , 11 ( 1983 ) ; j. p. derendinger and c. a. savoy , nucl .
b * 237 * , 307 ( 1984 ) ; j. r. ellis , j. f. gunion , h. e. haber , l. roszkowski and f. zwirner , phys .
d * 39 * , 844 ( 1989 ) ; m. drees , int .
j. mod .
phys . a * 4 * , 3635 ( 1989 ) .
u. ellwanger , c. hugonie and a. m. teixeira , phys .
rept . * 496 * , 1 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0910.1785 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. e. kim and h. p. nilles , phys .
b * 138 * , 150 ( 1984 ) .
o. lebedev , h. p. nilles and m. ratz , arxiv : hep - ph/0511320 .
a. riotto and e. roulet , phys .
b * 377 * , 60 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9512401 ] ; a. kusenko , p. langacker and g. segre , phys . rev .
d * 54 * , 5824 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9602414 ] ; a. kusenko and p. langacker , phys .
b * 391 * , 29 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ph/9608340 ] .
y. kanehata , t. kobayashi , y. konishi , o. seto and t. shimomura , prog .
phys . * 126 * , 1051 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1103.5109 [ hep - ph ] ] ; t. kobayashi , t. shimomura and t. takahashi , arxiv:1203.4328 [ hep - ph ] .
u. ellwanger and c. hugonie , comput .
commun . * 175 * , 290 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0508022 ] ; g. belanger , f. boudjema , c. hugonie , a. pukhov and a. semenov , jcap * 0509 * , 001 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0505142 ] ; u. ellwanger , j. f. gunion and c. hugonie , jhep * 0502 * , 066 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0406215 ]
. g. belanger , u. ellwanger , j. f. gunion , y. jiang , s. kraml and j. h. schwarz , arxiv:1210.1976 [ hep - ph ] ; u. ellwanger , eur .
j. c * 71 * , 1782 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1108.0157 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. f. king , m. muhlleitner and r. nevzorov , nucl .
b * 860 * , 207 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1201.2671 [ hep - ph ] ] ; d. a. vasquez , g. belanger , c. boehm , j. da silva , p. richardson and c. wymant , phys .
d * 86 * , 035023 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.3446 [ hep - ph ] ] ; u. ellwanger and c. hugonie , adv .
high energy phys . * 2012 * , 625389 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.5048 [ hep - ph ] ] .
g. belanger , f. boudjema , c. hugonie , a. pukhov and a. semenov , jcap * 0509 * , 001 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0505142 ] .
d. g. cerdeno , c. hugonie , d. e. lopez - fogliani , c. munoz and a. m. teixeira , jhep * 0412 * , 048 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0408102 ]
. t. kobayashi , h. makino , k. i. okumura , t. shimomura and t. takahashi in progress . | we study the next - to - minimal supersymmetric standard model .
we consider soft supersymmetry breaking parameters , which are induced by the mirage mediation mechanism of supersymmetry breaking .
we concentrate on the mirage mediation , where the so - called mirage scale is the tev scale . in this scenario
, we can realize the up - type higgs soft mass of @xmath0 gev , while other masses such as gaugino masses and stop masses are heavy such as 1 tev or more .
cancellation between the effective @xmath1-term and the down - type higgs soft mass ameliorates the fine - tuning in the electroweak symmetry breaking even for @xmath2 gev .
the mixing between the doublet and singlet higgs bosons is suppressed by @xmath3 .
then the lightest doublet higgs mass naturally reaches 125 gev lifted by the new quartic coupling .
the higgsino and singlino are light and their linear combination is the lightest superparticle . |
the majority of the extragalactic sources observed by the large area telescope ( lat ) on the _ fermi _ gamma - ray space telescope are blazars ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , the type of active galactic nuclei ( agns ) in which one of the jets is aligned with our line of sight ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . among agn
only blazars frequently feature prominent gamma - ray emission , and the gamma - ray emission is an essential observational tool for contstraining the physics of the central engines of agns ( e.g. * ? ? ?
understanding the characteristics of blazars is also crucial for evaluating their contribution as a source class to the extragalactic gamma - ray background ( egb ) radiation . in @xcite
hereafter bp1 we explored the source counts ( the so - called log@xmath1log@xmath2 relation ) of _ fermi_-lat blazars , using those detected with a greater than approximately seven sigma detection threshold in the first - year _
fermi_-lat catalog , and determined their contribution to the egb . estimating the total contribution of blazars to the egb required an extrapolation of the source counts to lower fluxes , below those detected by the _
however , in the presence of luminosity and/or density evolution with redshift , a more accurate estimate of the integrated flux from blazars requires determining and factoring in the evolution of blazars with redshift .
@xcite provide spectroscopically - determined redshifts for almost all of the fsrq blazars from the _
fermi_-lat first year catalog . with the inclusion of these redshifts
, we can apply our techniques to determine the evolutions of the luminosity and photon index with redshift , the density evolution , and the distributions of luminosity and photon index for fsrqs .
fluxes for _ fermi_-lat sources are measured and reported for a given photon energy range . the lower limit flux for detection of blazars by the
_ fermi_-lat depends strongly on a source s gamma - ray spectrum , such that objects with harder spectra are able to be detected above the background level at lower fluxes than those with softer spectra @xcite .
this means that for determination of the luminosity distribution one needs both a measure of the flux and the photon index @xmath3 , and that then one deals with a bi - variate distribution of fluxes and indexes , which is truncated because of the this observational bias in the flux - index plane ( as seen in figure [ lumsandsis ] ) , often referred to as malmquist bias .
additionally , of course , there is a truncation in the luminosity - redshift plane arising because of the relationship between flux and luminosity .
obtaining a bias free determination of the distributions of luminosity and photon index is therefore necessarily quite a bit more complicated than a simple counting of sources .
@xcite use simulated data to account for the detection biases in analyzing this data .
here we use non - parametric methods to determine the luminosity and density distributions directly from the observational data .
when dealing with a multivariate distribution , the first required step is the determination of the correlation ( or statistical dependence ) between the variables , which can not be done by simple procedures when the data is truncated ( e.g. * ? ? ?
we use the procedures developed by efron and petrosian ( ep , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and extended by @xcite to account reliably for the complex observational selection biases to determine first the intrinsic correlations ( if any ) between the variables .
these techniques have been proven useful for application to many sources with varied characteristics , including to the log@xmath1log@xmath2 relation for blazars in bp1 , and to radio and optical luminosity in quasars in @xcite and @xcite , where references to earlier works are presented . in this paper
we apply these methods to determine the luminosity and photon index evolutions of _
fermi_-lat blazars , as well as the density evolution , and local ( @xmath4=0 ) gamma - ray luminosity function . in [ datasec ]
we discuss the data used , and in [ evs ] we explain the techniques used and present the results for the luminosity and photon index evolution . in [ dev ] and [ ll ] we present the density evolution and local luminosity function and photon index distribution . in [ bgnd ] we calculate the total contribution of fsrqs to the extragalactic gamma - ray background ( egb ) radiation .
this paper assumes the standard cosmology throughout .
for this analysis we use the fsrq blazars reported in the _
fermi_-lat first year extragalactic source catalog ( e.g * ? ? ? * ) that have a detection test statistic @xmath5 and which lie at galactic latitude @xmath6 .
the test statistic is defined as @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the likelihood of the source being not actually present and the flux being due only to the background in that location ( null hypothesis ) and @xmath9 is the likelihood of the the hypothesis being tested , which is that the source is present along with the background in that location .
the significance level of a given detection is approximately @xmath10 . of 425 total of such extragalactic sources ,
325 are identified as blazars .
spectroscopically determined redshifts are provided for 184 of the fsrq - type blazars in @xcite , which is all or nearly all of the fsrq - type blazars in the @xmath5 and @xmath6 sample , making the sample complete for spectroscopic redshifts . and
@xmath6 sample as fsrqs , @xcite spectroscopically classify 23 additional blazars in this sample as fsrqs which were identified in the _
fermi_-lat catalog as being of unknown type . ]
@xmath11 50 and @xmath12 and known spectroscopic redshifts provided by @xcite .
it is seen that there is a selection bias against soft spectrum sources at fluxes below @xmath13 photons @xmath14 sec@xmath15 .
we also show the line used for the truncation boundary in this analysis , as discussed in [ datasec ] and determined in bp1 .
, width=336 ] the 184 fsrq blazars used here range in gamma - ray flux in the range from 100 mev to 100 gev from @xmath16 to @xmath17 photons @xmath14 sec@xmath15 , and the flux in this range is designated as @xmath18 .
the photon index @xmath3 is defined such the number of photons as a function of photon energy is given by @xmath19 ( or the @xmath20 ) , and is obtained by fitting a simple power - law to the spectra in the above energy interval .
the photon index is reported directly in the _ fermi - lat _ source catalog and in the present sample ranges from 2.03 to 3.04 .
we recover @xmath18 from the reported flux density ( @xmath21 ) , pivot energy ( @xmath22 ) , and photon index with @xmath23 the bias mentioned above , stemming from the dependence of the _ fermi_-lat point spread function ( psf ) with energy , is apparent , as there is a strong selection against soft spectrum sources at fluxes below @xmath24 photons @xmath14 sec@xmath15 .
each source has an associated @xmath25 as discussed above , and the sources ts values vary in part because the background flux is a function of position on the sky , as discussed in @xcite .
the approximate limiting flux for inclusion in the survey , then , is given by @xmath26 , where @xmath25 is a function of the position on the sky and the photon index @xmath3 .
however , as discussed in bp1 , because the limiting flux as determined in this way is not the optimal estimate , we use a more conservative truncation as shown by the straight line in figure [ lumsandsis ] . in bp1
we derive the optimal location of this truncation line for a @xmath5 sample from the _ fermi_-lat first year extragalactic source catalog . with the present fsrq sample , applying the truncation line excludes 33 sources from the analysis . as discussed in bp1 , the optimal location for the truncation line may exclude some sources leading to increased statistical uncertainty , but provides increased accuracy of results .
the fsrqs in the sample range in redshift from 0.001 to 3.197 . to convert between photon flux @xmath18 and the gamma - ray luminosity @xmath27
, one must first convert from @xmath18 to energy flux ( @xmath28 ) with @xmath29 ( except for @xmath30 and @xmath31 for which @xmath32 and @xmath33 respectively ) and then from energy flux to luminosity with @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the luminosity distance determined from the standard cosmological model , and @xmath36 is the k - correction factor given by @xmath37 .
the gamma - ray luminosities of fsrqs in the sample range from 1.95@xmath3810@xmath39 erg sec@xmath15 to 6.32@xmath3810@xmath40 erg sec@xmath15 .
a nearly identical sample has been analyzed by @xcite which finds agreement with the major conclusions of this work .
the lf expresses the number of objects per unit comoving volume @xmath41 per unit source luminosity , so that , if there are no other correlated parameters , the number density of objects is @xmath42 and the total number is @xmath43 . to provide for luminosity and density evolution , without loss of generality , we can write a lf in some waveband @xmath44 as @xmath45 where @xmath46 describes the luminosity evolution with redshift and @xmath47 describes the comoving density evolution with redshift , and @xmath48 stands for parameters that describe the shape ( e.g. power law indices and break values ) of the @xmath44 band lf . if the parameters @xmath48 have some redshift dependence this is equivalent to having luminosity dependent density evolution , and if @xmath48 have some luminosity dependence this is equivalent to luminosity dependent luminosity evolution . the methods used here for determining intrinsic correlations and distributions have been demonstrated through previous works and analysis of simulated data sets for the case where the parameters @xmath48 are constant in redshift , i.e. the luminosity function is modeled with only luminosity evolution and density evolution . in principle the methods could be extended to allow for evolving parameters @xmath48 with redshift or with luminosity dependence .
here we start with the simpler model where there is only luminosity evolution and density evolution to capture the most important features of the evolution of the luminosity function , and find that it is adequate to do so .
we consider this form of the lf for the gamma - ray luminosity , and a similar form for the photon index distribution
. showing the location of the minimum region where the favored values of @xmath49 and @xmath50 lie , for the forms of the evolutions given by equation [ levolutionold ] .
, width=336 ] contours of @xmath51 for the simultaneous best fit values of @xmath49 and @xmath50 for the forms of the evolutions given by equation [ levolutionold ] .
, width=336 ] once the luminosity evolution @xmath46 is determined using the ep method we can obtain the mono - variate distributions of the independent variables @xmath52 and @xmath4 , namely the density evolution @xmath47 and local ( @xmath4=0 ) lf @xmath53 .
the total number of observed objects seen is then @xmath54 in this case , because @xmath55 has some dependence on @xmath3 , an integral over the distribution of @xmath3 must be performed as well , leading to @xmath56 where the distribution @xmath57 should have a norm of 1 .
is only strictly true if @xmath57 is independent of redshift and luminosity .
the former is seen in [ evsec ] while the later is discussed in [ bgnd ] . ] because the sample at hand has a mean redshift of around @xmath4=1 , we can assume a simple power law for the evolutions within this redshift range @xmath58 we have also considered a more complicated parameterization which allows a non - monotonic form with a turnover at a critical redshift @xmath59 however , the form of equation [ levolutionold ] provides an valid fit to the data as determined by the methods of [ evsec ] , so we choose the simpler parameterization .
we discuss the determination of the evolution factors @xmath60 with the ep method , which in this parameterization becomes a determination of @xmath61 , in
[ evsec ] .
the density evolution function @xmath47 is determined by the method discussed in [ dev ] .
once these are determined we construct the local ( de - evolved ) lf @xmath62 , shown in
[ ll ] . here
we first give a brief summary of the algebra involved in the ep method .
this method finds the best - fit values of parameters describing correlations between variables by removing the correlation with some function and testing for independence .
we utilize a modified version of the kendall tau test to estimate the best - fit values of parameters describing the correlation functions between variables , using the test statistic @xmath63 to quantify the independence of two variables in a dataset , say ( @xmath64 ) for @xmath65 . here
@xmath66 is the dependent variable ( @xmath67 ) rank of the data point @xmath68 in a set associated with it .
the expectation value of the rank is @xmath69 and the variance is @xmath70 .
for untruncated data ( i.e. data truncated parallel to the axes ) the set associated with point @xmath68 includes all of the points with a lower ( or higher ) independent variable value ( @xmath71 ) .
if the data is truncated the unbiased set is then the _ associated set _ consisting only of those points of lower ( or higher ) independent variable ( @xmath72 ) value that would have been observed if they were at the @xmath72 value of point @xmath68 given the truncation .
a very simple example of an associated set is discussed in the appendix .
if ( @xmath64 ) are uncorrelated then the ranks of all of the points @xmath66 in the dependent variable within their associated set should be distributed uniformly between 1 and the number of points in the set @xmath73 , with the rank uncorrelated with their independent variable value .
then the points contributions to @xmath74 will tend to sum to zero .
on the other hand , if the indepenent and dependent verables are correlated , then the rank of a point in the dependent variable will be correlated with its independent variable , and because the set to be ranked against consists of points with a lower independet variable value , the contributions to @xmath74 will not sum to zero .
independence of the variables is rejected at the @xmath75 level if @xmath76 , and this can be considered the same standard deviation as would be calculated from another method such as least - squares fitting , as discussed in @xcite . if the variables are not independent , to find the best fit correlation the @xmath67 data are then adjusted by defining @xmath77 and the rank test is repeated , with different values of parameters of the function @xmath78 . in this case
@xmath79 would be the luminosity or photon index evolution factors , @xmath80 and @xmath81 , with the forms specified by equation [ levolutionold ] .
the procedure for determining simultaneously the best fit @xmath49 and @xmath50 is more complicated because we now are dealing with a three dimensional distribution ( @xmath27 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 ) and two correlation functions ( @xmath82 and @xmath83 ) .
the associated set for any object @xmath84 then consists of only those objects which would still be present in the survey if they were located at the redshift of object @xmath84 , given the luminosity and photon index evolution factors and in light of the truncation boundary in the @xmath18-@xmath3 plane .
we form a combined test statistic @xmath85 where @xmath86 is that calculated with equation [ tauen ] with @xmath27 as the independent variable and @xmath4 as the dependent variable , and @xmath87 is that calculated with @xmath3 as the independent variable and @xmath4 as the dependent variable . because the luminosity corresponding to a given measured flux and redshift is dependent on the photon index , adjusting the luminosity or the photon index by a redshft dependent factor ( i.e. performing the @xmath88 and @xmath89 ) affects the other variable . therefore
, @xmath86 and @xmath87 must be evaluated simultaneously for every @xmath90 and @xmath91 combination .
we perform the evaluations on a grid of @xmath92 and @xmath91 values , i.e. a grid of @xmath49 and @xmath50 values with spacing as small as 0.05 . as with the one dimensional case , the best fit values of @xmath49 and @xmath50 are those that minimize @xmath51 .
since @xmath51 is a geometric average and can not be negative , the @xmath75 ranges of the best - fit values of @xmath49 and @xmath50 are those that lead to @xmath93 .
the favored values of @xmath49 and @xmath50 are those that simultaneously give the lowest @xmath51 and , again , we take the @xmath94 limits as those in which @xmath95 . for visualization ,
figure [ tauass ] shows a surface plot of @xmath51 .
figure [ alphas ] shows the best fit values of @xmath49 and @xmath96 taking the 1 , 2 , and 3 @xmath0 contours .
we have verified this general method with a simulated monte carlo datasets as discussed in @xcite and bp1 .
we see that strongly positive evolution in gamma - ray luminosity is favored , along with no evolution of the photon index . versus @xmath97 for the set of objects where @xmath98 photons @xmath14 and truncation in the @xmath18-@xmath3 plane is unimportant
, so determination of the luminosity evolution reduces to a simpler 2-dimensional correlation .
the best - fit 1@xmath0 range of @xmath97 is where @xmath99 , and this results in @[email protected] , in good agreement with the results when the full 3-dimensional case is considered with the whole data set ( e.g. figure [ alphas ] ) .
, width=336 ] the result for the luminosity evolution can be checked by considering only those objects with @xmath98 photons @xmath14 sec@xmath15 , where the truncation in the @xmath18-@xmath3 plane is not relevant ( see figure [ lumsandsis ] ) .
the determination of the luminosity evolution in this case reduces to a simpler 2-dimensional determination of the correlation between @xmath27 and @xmath4 .
the associated set for each object @xmath84 is then those objects which would still be present in the survey if they were located at the redshift of object @xmath84 given the luminosity evolution factor and a simple limiting flux of @xmath98 photons @xmath14 sec@xmath15 .
figure [ simpcase ] shows @xmath74 versus @xmath97 for this subset , and the results indicate that @[email protected] , in good agreement with the results when the full 3-dimensional case is considered with the whole data set .
@xcite also derive quite strong fsrq luminosity evolution with redshift , although with a more complicated parameterization .
we note in passing that , as can be seen from the contours in [ alphas ] , a complete lack of luminosity evolution is not ruled out at the 3 @xmath0 level .
however the results from considering the untruncated subset , along with those in other works , strongly favors positive luminosity evolution .
we turn now to the density evolution @xmath47 .
the cumulative density function is @xmath101 which , following the procedure in @xcite based on @xcite , can be calculated by lcccccccc[tizzable ] & @xmath102 & @xmath103 + c & + 8.9x10@xmath104 & @xmath1056.0x10@xmath106 + @xmath107 & @xmath1054.4x10@xmath104 & + 3.4x10@xmath108 + @xmath109 & + 3.0x10@xmath108 & @xmath1053.0x10@xmath110 + @xmath111 & @xmath1052.5x10@xmath108 & + 6.5x10@xmath104 + @xmath112 in this case @xmath68 runs over all objects with a redshift lower than or equal to @xmath4 , and @xmath113 is the number of objects with a redshift lower than the redshift of object @xmath68 _ which are in object j s associated set_. the associated set for object @xmath68 consists of those objects which would still be in the survey if they had object @xmath68 s luminosity . then the differential density evolution @xmath47 is @xmath114 if @xmath115 is expressed in number of objects less than redshift @xmath4 per solid angle ( n@xmath116 sr@xmath117 ) , then @xmath47 here is expressed in n / dz mpc@xmath118 .
however , to determine the density evolution , the previously determined luminosity evolution must be factored out of each objects luminosity .
thus , the luminosities for determining inclusion in the associated sets for each object in the calculation of @xmath0 by equation [ sigmaeqn ] are scaled by taking out factors of @xmath82 and @xmath119 , determined as above .
vs. redshift for fsrq blazars .
the normalization of @xmath115 is determined as described in [ dev ] .
a polynomial fit to @xmath120 is used to determine @xmath121 by equation [ rhoeqn ] .
we also show the cumulative number of observed fsrqs for redshift bins of size 0.1 for comparison .
it is seen that the raw data is significantly biased and the reconstructed intrinsic redshift distribution for fsrqs is very different than the observed one .
, width=336 ] vs. redshift for fsrq blazars .
@xmath47 is defined such that @xmath122 .
the normalization of @xmath47 is determined as described in [ dev ] , and polynomial fits of @xmath47 to @xmath4 are given there . at redshifts greater than 2.5
, the smaller number of objects renders the determination of @xmath47 with errors too large to be meaningfully plotted .
, width=336 ] the normalization of @xmath47 is determined by equation [ inteq2 ] , with the customary choice of @xmath123 .
figures [ sigma ] and [ rholog ] show the cumulative and differential density evolutions , respectively . the number density of fsrq is seen to peak at around redshift 0.75 .
this can be compared with the more complicated parameterization used in @xcite where the number density as a function of luminosity can be calculated . for the median luminosity of objects in the sample ( 5.89@xmath3810@xmath124 erg sec@xmath15 )
the peak would be at @xmath4=0.8 , while for the mean luminosity ( 2.47@xmath3810@xmath125 erg sec@xmath15 ) the peak is at @xmath4=1.7 .
we see from figure [ sigma ] that the raw data is significantly biased and the reconstructed intrinsic redshift distribution for fsrqs is very different than the observed one .
the density evolution @xmath47 can be fit quite well with a broken third - order polynomial in @xmath4 , with coefficients shown in table 1 .
one can use the local ( redshift evolution taken out , or de - evolved ) luminosity to determine the local cumulative distribution @xmath126 , where the prime indicates that the redshift evolutions have been taken out .
the cumulative distribution is related to the differential lf @xmath62 by = 0 ) gamma - ray luminosity function @xmath126 for fsrq blazars , as determined in [ ll ] .
, width=336 ] = 0 ) gamma - ray luminosity function @xmath62 for fsrq blazars , as determined in [ ll ] ( stars ) .
the error bars result from a propagation of the 1@xmath0 variation in @xmath49 and the uncertainty in the differentiation of @xmath126 .
we overplot the @xmath4=0 fsrq luminosity function as reported by @xcite ( solid line ) with 1@xmath0 errors ( dashed lines ) . ,
width=336 ] = 1 gamma - ray luminosity function @xmath127 for fsrq blazars , as given by equation [ lumeq ] ( stars ) .
the error bars result from a propagation of the 1@xmath0 variation in @xmath49 and the uncertainty in the differentiation of @xmath126 .
we overplot the @xmath4=1 fsrq luminosity function as reported by @xcite ( solid line ) with 1@xmath0 errors ( dashed lines ) , and as reported by @xcite ( dash - dot line ) . ,
width=336 ] @xmath128 following @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite , @xmath129 can be calculated by @xmath130 where @xmath131 runs over all objects with a luminosity greater than or equal to @xmath132 , and @xmath133 is the number of objects with a luminosity higher than the luminosity of object @xmath131 which are in object @xmath131 s associated set , determined in the same manner as in [ evsec ] .
as before , the objects luminosities , as well as the luminosity limits for inclusion in the associated set for given redshifts , are scaled by taking out factors of @xmath82 , with @xmath49 determined in [ evs ] .
we use the notation @xmath134 . for the local distribution functions , we use the customary normalization involving the differential distribution @xmath135 .
this normalization may be biased by around 10% due to variability as discussed in bp1 .
figure [ phi ] shows the local cumulative lf for fsrq blazars .
we can compute the differential local ( @xmath4=0 ) gamma - ray lf @xmath62 , and combining it and the density evolution , we can compute the lf at any redshift @xmath136 , and these can be compared to other determinations in the literature . figure [ z0 ]
shows the differential local ( @xmath4=0 ) gamma - ray lf along with that reported by @xcite .
it is seen that the determinations agree in the region of @xmath90 where they overlap .
we see that the results here access the @xmath4=0 lf for lower values of @xmath90 than reported in @xcite .
this follows from the rapid luminosity evolution seen here , where an object at redshift 1 will have its luminosity de - evolved by a factor of around 45 to redshift 0 , uniform across luminosities . in the luminosity - dependent density evolution scenario modeled in @xcite
low luminosity sources are found to evolve slower and thus get de - evolved by a smaller factor . in principle
different methods should find the same solution and this means sampling very similar de - evolved luminosities . in practice
this rarely happens if the number of sources is small .
the results are somewhat complimentary in this manner , and show a flattening of the @xmath4=0 lf at lower luminosities
. the lf at an arbitrary redshift @xmath136 can be computed by equation [ lumeq ] . in figure [ z1 ]
we plot the @xmath4=1 gamma - ray lf as determined here , along with those reported by @xcite and @xcite .
it is seen that the determination of the lf here closely matches that in @xcite in spite of the different models considered ( luminosity and density evolution versus luminosity dependent density evolution ) .
it is interesting to note that in both the @xmath4=1 lf and the integrated luminosity of fsrqs over the history of the universe see [ bgnd ] the results are consistent . since in [ evsec ] we found that there is no redshift evolution in the photon index @xmath3 ( i.e. @xmath96=0 ) , the distribution we found for @xmath3 in bp1 averaged over redshifts is also valid at any individual redshift . from bp1 , the distribution of @xmath3 for fsrqs
can be well described a gaussian with a mean of [email protected] and a 1 @xmath0 width of [email protected] , a result in agreement with @xcite .
given the luminosity and photon index evolutions as determined in [ evs ] , the density evolution as determined in [ dev ] , and the cumulative local lf as determined in [ ll ] , we can calculate the integrated contribution of fsrqs of given redshifts and luminosities to the extragalactic gamma - ray background ( egb )
. the contribution will be @xmath137 where @xmath57 is the differential distribution of @xmath3 for fsrqs discussed in
[ ll ] and determined in bp1 .
@xmath138 here is the luminosity part of the overall lf , including the redshift evolution of the luminosity ( equivalent to @xmath139 in equation [ lumeq ] ) .
we note that because @xmath3 is uncorrelated or only very weakly correlated with flux as determined in bp1 , and that @xmath57 is independent of reshift while @xmath140 is strongly redshift dependent , @xmath57 is likely , or can be well approximated by , an independent distribution . ] .
we integrate @xmath141 by parts , noting that @xmath142 to obtain the dependence on the cumulative lf @xmath143 @xmath144 \ , h(\gamma ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] stating this in terms of the local cumulative lf @xmath145 @xmath146 \ , h(\gamma ) \label{bgndcont}\end{aligned}\ ] ] because we obtain the cumulative local lf @xmath147 and photon index distribution directly from the data , this technique allows us to calculate the cumulative total output of fsrqs directly , non - parametrically .
specifically , we can approximate the integral directly by performing a reimann sum with bins of luminosity and redshift , with the values of @xmath147 and @xmath47 at any value of @xmath27 and @xmath4 available via simple interpolation of the distribution functions that are the direct output of the methods .
it is simpler to use logarithmic bins of luminosity , in which case @xmath148 .
if one is integrating over fsrqs of all luminosities the surface term @xmath149 is zero because @xmath150 and one is left with @xmath151 we note that at as @xmath4 approaches large values @xmath152 , and also that as @xmath27 approaches large values @xmath153 , so the contributions from high very high redshifts and very large luminosities is vanishing . integrating over all redshifts and luminosities , we find that @xmath154=7.6 ( + 4.0/-1.1 ) @xmath3810@xmath110 mev @xmath14 sec@xmath15 sr@xmath15 .
the uncertainty results primarily from uncertainty in the value of @xmath49 , as well as uncertainty in the mean value of the photon index distribution for fsrqs .
this value of this total @xmath154 can be compared with the total energy density of the egb , i.e. the total gamma - ray output of the universe in the range from 100 mev to 100 gev , which was determined by _ fermi _ in @xcite to be @xmath155=4.72 ( + 0.63/-0.29)@xmath3810@xmath118 mev @xmath14 sec@xmath15 sr@xmath15 , assuming a photon index for the background of @xmath3=2.4 .
we see that fsrq blazars in toto contribute 16 ( + 10/-4)% of the total egb , emphasizing that the egb as defined here is the total gamma - ray output of the universe in the range from 100 mev to 100 gev .
this is consistent with the result we obtained in bp1 where we estimated the contribution of _ all _ blazars ( both fsrqs and bl lacs ) to be between 39% and 100% of the egb if extrapolated to zero flux , and between 39% and 66% if extrapolated to a more reasonable lower limit flux of 10@xmath156 photons @xmath14 sec@xmath15 .
the result here for fsrqs is also in agreement to within errors with the result of @xcite who find the contribution of all fsrqs to the total egb to be 21.7 ( + 2.5/-1.7)% . the larger uncertainty presented here results from the uncertainty discussed above , as well as considering the full uncertainty range in @xmath157 reported by @xcite .
some authors have suggested that blazars could be the primary source of the egb ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the results of bp1 did not rule this out , while the results presented in @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite favor blazars being one of several important classes of sources .
other possible source populations for the egb include starforming galaxies , which have been proposed as a possible significant contributor to the egb by e.g. @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite , although this is countered by @xcite , radio galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , and non - blazar agn ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we have used a rigorous method to calculate non - parametrically and directly from the data the redshift evolutions of the gamma - ray luminosity and photon index , as well as the density evolution , gamma - ray lf , and contribution to the egb of fsrq blazars .
we use a data set consisting of the fsrqs in the _
fermi_-lat first year extragalactic source catalog with @xmath5 and which lie at galactic latitude @xmath6 , with spectroscopically determined redshifts provided by @xcite .
the method employed accounts robustly for the pronounced data truncation introduced by the selection biases inherent in the _ fermi_-lat observational catalog . the reliability of the methods employed has been demonstrated and discussed in @xcite , @xcite , and the appendix of bp1 .
we note that since spectroscopic redshifts are available for virtually all of the fsrqs in the _
fermi_-lat first year extragalactic source catalog , there is not a relevant limiting optical flux which must be considered , and the only relevant truncation in the data is that arising from gamma - ray flux and photon index . in 3.3 of bp1
we discuss the sources of error that may affect these determinations , including measurement uncertainties , blazar variability , and source confusion .
as discussed there , in the determination of the contribution of fsrqs to the egb , these will be sub - dominant to the uncertainty resulting from the range of mean values of the photon index distribution that we consider , as well as the high redshift end of the density evolution function .
subtler issues affecting the derived distributions may arise because of the finite bandwidth of the _ fermi_-lat and lack of complete knowledge of the objects spectra over a large energy range and deviations from simple power laws .
this has the greatest potential to effect determinations of the photon index distribution , which we do not determine in this work but carry over from bp1 .
however the bandwidth 100 mev to 100 gev is wide enough that the contribution of sources which peak outside of this range to the lf and evolution , density evolution , and the egb in this energy range will be small .
we find that fsrqs have a strong luminosity evolution with redshift , well characterized ( at low redshifts ) by the evolution factor ( 1+@xmath4)@xmath158 with @[email protected] .
this , along with positive evolutions in other wavebands such as optical and radio ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and x - ray ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , favors models in which at higher redshifts agn systems featured on average more massive black hole and accretion disk systems , and/or more rapidly rotating black holes .
we find that fsrqs do not exhibit appreciable photon index evolution with redshift , indicating that the mean spectrum of accelerated high energy particles from agn central engines has remained constant over the history of the universe . given these evolutions , the density evolution , and the local lf and photon index distribution , we determine that the total energy density from fsrqs at all redshifts and luminosities is @xmath154=7.6 ( + 4.0/-1.1 ) @xmath3810@xmath110 mev @xmath14 sec@xmath15 sr@xmath15 , which is 16 ( + 10/-4)% of the total egb .
this indicates that fsrq blazars are a significant , but not dominant , component of the egb . in order to illustrate the general concept of an associated set applied to truncated data , in figure [ f10 ] we show the simplest case of two - dimensional luminosity - redshift data truncated by a universal flux limit for the survey .
suppose one were performing a statistical test to determine correlation among the variables , with luminosity as the dependent variable and redshift as the independent variable .
in order to form an unbiased set for comparison with object @xmath68 for this test , one should take only those objects that would be in the sample if they were at object @xmath68 s redshift . with the kendall tau test ,
one ranks objects in the dependent variable against those with either a higher or lower value of the independent variable . in this case
, the ranking would have to be against those with a lower value of redshift , in order for the associated sets themselves to be unbiased .
the associated sets for an object will be more complicated if there are additional variables , and/or if the truncation limit is not universal .
both are the case in this work , where both luminosity and photon index are important , and where the truncation is a function in the flux - index plane .
abazajian , k. , branchet , s. , & harding , j. 2012 , , 85 , 043509 abdo , a. , et al .
2010a , , 188 , 405 abdo , a. , et al .
2010b , , 715 , 429 abdo , a. , et al .
2010c , , 720 , 435 abdo , a. , et al .
2010d , , 104 , 101101 abdo , a. , et al .
2010e , , 710 , 1271 aird , j. , et al .
2010 , `` the evolution of the hard x - ray luminosity function of agn . '' , 401 , 2531 ajello , m. , shaw , m. , romani , r. , dermer , c. , costamonte , l. , king , g. , & max - moerbeck , w. 2012 , , 751 , 108 atwood , a. , et al .
2009 , , 697 , 1071 blandford , r. & konigl , a. 1979 , , 416 , 450 caditz , d. & petrosian , v. 1993 , , 399 , 345 dermer , c. 2007 , , 654 , 958 eddington , a. 1940 , , 100 , 35 efron , b. & petrosian , v. 1992 , , 399 , 345 efron , b. & petrosian , v. 1999 , jasa , 94 , 447 fields , b. , pavildou , v. , & prodanovi , t. 2010 , , 722 , l199 inoue , y. 2011 , , 733,66 inoue , y. & totani , t. 2011 , , 728 , 73 inoue , y. & totani , t. 2009 , , 702 , 523 inoue , y. totani , t. , & mori , m. 2010 , , 62 , 1005 lacki , b. , thompson , t. , quataert , e. , loeb , a. , & waxman , e. 2011 , , 734 , 107 lynden - bell , d. 1971 , , 155 , 95 makiya , r. , totani , t. , kobayashi , m. 2011 , , 728 , 158 malyshev , d. & hogg , d. 2011 , , 738 , 181 petrosian , v. 1992 , in statistical challenges in modern astronomy , ed .
feigelson & g.h . babu ( new york : springer ) , 173 shaw , m. , et al .
2012 , , 748 , 49 singal , j. , petrosian , v. , j. , lawrence , a. , & stawarz , .
2011 , , 743 , 104 singal , j. , petrosian , v. , & ajello , m. 2012 , , 753 , 45 singal , j. , petrosian , v. , stawarz , . , & lawrence , a. 2013 , , 764 , 43 stecker , f. & venters , t. 2011 , , 736 , 40 venters , t. , & pavildou , v. 2011 , , 737 , 80 | we present the redshift evolutions and distributions of the gamma - ray luminosity and photon spectral index of flat spectrum radio quasar ( fsrq ) type blazars , using non - parametric methods to obtain the evolutions and distributions directly from the data .
the sample we use for analysis consists of almost all fsrqs observed with a greater than approximately 7@xmath0 detection threshold in the first year catalog of the _ fermi _ gamma - ray space telescope s large area telescope , with redshfits as determined from optical spectroscopy by shaw et al .
we find that fsqrs undergo rapid gamma - ray luminosity evolution , but negligible photon index evolution , with redshift
. with these evolutions accounted for we determine the density evolution and luminosity function of fsrqs , and calculate their total contribution to the extragalactic gamma - ray background radiation , resolved and unresolved , which is found to be 16(+10/-4)% , in agreement with previous studies . |
the scarcity of cellular frequency for achieving the 1,000x higher data rate in 5 g brings about exploiting the millimeter - wave ( mmwave ) frequency band having hundreds times more spectrum amount @xcite .
this approach however has two major drawbacks .
firstly , mmwave signals are vulnerable to physical blockages , yielding severe distance attenuation .
secondly , the use of extremely wide mmwave bandwidth makes uplink mmwave transmissions at mobiles demanding due to high peak - to - average - ratio ( papr ) @xcite , leading to significant rate difference between uplink and downlink . to compensate both drawbacks , we consider base station ( bs ) ultra - densification .
it is another promising way to enhance the data rate by increasing per - user available resource amount @xcite and even by improving per - user average spectral efficiency @xcite .
this study combines such complementary two methods , and thereby proposes a mmwave overlaid ultra - dense cellular network .
the proposed network in distinction from other existing heterogeneous networks is the asymmetric uplink and downlink structure where mmwave band only operates for downlink transmissions ( see fig .
the reason is even the state - of - the - art mmwave supporting power amplifiers are low energy efficient , so uplink mmwave transmissions are demanding of mobile users @xcite .
uplink communication therefore solely resorts to the current micro - wave ( @xmath0wave ) cellular frequency band . due to the scarcity of the @xmath0wave spectrum
, the uplink data rate can not keep up with the rising ample downlink data rate as mmwave resource and bs densification grow , which may hinder consistent user experiences .
this uplink / downlink asymmetry motivates to turn our attention toward assuring the minimum uplink average rate , and engenders the mmwave overlaid cellular network design problem : _ how to maximize the downlink average rate while guaranteeing a target uplink average rate_. we answer this question from the radio resource management and cell planning perspectives . exploiting stochastic geometry and the technique proposed in our preliminary work @xcite
, we derive downlink mmwave and uplink / downlink @xmath0wave spectral efficiencies in closed forms . utilizing these tractable results
, we analyze the impacts of resource management and cell planning on downlink and uplink average rates .
such results provide the design guidelines of the mmwave overlaid ultra - dense cellular networks .
the main contributions of this paper are listed as follows . 1 .
_ most of the @xmath0wave resource should be dedicated to uplink transmissions _ in order to guarantee the uplink average rate by at least @xmath1 of the downlink rate in a practical scenario where @xmath0wave and mmwave resource amounts respectively are @xmath2 mhz and @xmath3 mhz @xcite ( see proposition 3 and fig .
this runs counter to the current resource allocation trend that is likely to allocate more resource to downlink transmissions @xcite .
2 . to achieve the ever - growing downlink average rate while guaranteeing uplink average rate , _ densifying @xmath0wave bs can not be a sole remedy in practice _
( see proposition 4 ) , _ but should be in conjunction with procuring more @xmath0wave spectrums _ ( see corollary 2 ) .
the reason behind is more spectrum amount linearly increases the uplink average rate while bs densification logarithmically increases the rate ( see proposition 1 ) .
the spectral efficiencies in uplink / downlink @xmath0wave ( see proposition 1 ) and downlink mmwave bands ( see proposition 2 ) under an ultra - dense environment are derived in closed forms via a lower bound approximation , which reveals _ bs densification logarithmically increases the spectral efficiency_. due to the lack of the space , the omitted proofs of propositions and lemmas are deferred to : _
http://tiny.cc / jhparkgc15pf_. wave bands whereas the uplink only via @xmath0wave band .
indoor region is not penetrated by mmwave but @xmath0wave signals .
users associate with the nearest non - blocked mmwave bss ( outdoor user 1 associates with a farther mmwave bs than the nearest indoor bs ) as well as with the nearest @xmath0wave bss without any restriction ( indoor user 2 associates with the outside nearest @xmath0wave bs ) .
the bss having no serving users are turned - off.,width=340 ]
the proposed network comprises : ( i ) mmwave bss whose locations follow a two - dimensional homogeneous poisson point process ( ppp ) @xmath4 with density @xmath5 ; and ( ii ) @xmath0wave bss whose coordinates follow a homogeneous ppp @xmath6 with density @xmath7 , independent of @xmath4 . due to the implementational difficulty of mmwave transmissions at mobile users , mmwave bs only supports downlink mode whereas @xmath0wave bs provides both downlink and uplink modes .
uplink transmissions are therefore resort to solely depend on @xmath0wave bss .
a bs having no serving user is turned off ( see the transparent bss in fig .
1 ) . mobile user coordinates independently follow a homogeneous ppp @xmath8 with density @xmath9 . without loss of generality , @xmath8 represents both downlink and uplink users .
users receive downlink signals via both mmwave and @xmath0wave simultaneously @xcite while transmitting uplink signals only via @xmath0wave . specifically , downlink users associate with their nearest non - blocked mmwave bss , and also independently with their nearest @xmath0wave bss as in @xcite .
uplink users associate with the nearest @xmath0wave bss that are identical with their @xmath0wave downlink associated bss but the mmwave associated bss .
such associations are visually shown by fig . 1 .
consider indoor regions whose boundaries are mmwave impenetrable walls
. followed by a boolean model @xcite , the indoor regions are regarded as uniformly distributed circles having radius @xmath10 with density @xmath11 . for simplicity without loss of generality , assume the indoor regions always guarantee line - of - sight ( los ) communications .
additionally , we neglect the overlapping indoor regions that can be compensated by a sufficiently large network .
note that @xmath0wave signals are not affected by the indoor walls thanks to their high diffraction and penetration characteristics .
the indoor complementary regions are outdoor regions .
our channel model is three - fold in order to capture the different propagation behaviors of outdoor / indoor mmwave and @xmath0wave signals .
a mmwave antenna array directionally transmits a downlink signal with unity power to its associated user , and the signal experiences path loss attenuation with the exponent @xmath12 as well as rayleigh fading with unity mean .
the transmitted directional beam has the main lobe angle @xmath13 ( radian ) , and the received signal powers at the same distances within @xmath13 are assumed to be identical .
users are able to receive mmwave signals only if there exist no indoor walls along the paths to their associated bss . to specify this event , consider a typical user @xmath14 located at the origin and an arbitrary bs at @xmath15 with distance @xmath16 .
let @xmath17 denote the opposite unit direction vector of the signal transmission direction from @xmath15 , defined as @xmath18 .
define @xmath19 as the non - blockage distance indicating the line length from @xmath14 with the direction @xmath17 to the point when the line firstly intersects an impenetrable indoor wall .
a user then can receive a transmitted signal if the condition @xmath20 holds . for interfering links
, we consider the interferers as the undesired active bss whose serving directions , the main lobe centers , pointing to @xmath14 .
it leads to @xmath21 antenna gain , which is an increasing function of @xmath13 as well as the number of the bs s serving users . at @xmath14 when located outside the indoor regions , the corresponding mmwave signal - to - interference - plus - noise ( @xmath22 ) is represented as : @xmath23where @xmath24 indicates active non - blocked mmwave interfering outdoor bss , @xmath25 fading power , and @xmath26 noise power .
path loss exponent is set as @xmath27 since there is no mmwave blockages within indoor regions as described in section [ sect : inout ] .
the rest of the settings are the same as in the case of the outdoor mmwave . at @xmath14
when located within indoor regions , the mmwave @xmath22 is given as : @xmath28where @xmath29 denotes active mmwave interfering indoor bss . a transmitted signal with unity power experiences path loss attenuation with the exponent @xmath30 as well as rayleigh fading , resulting in the fading gain @xmath31 that follows an exponential distribution with mean @xmath32 . at @xmath14 , the @xmath0wave @xmath22
is given as : @xmath33where @xmath34 represents active @xmath0wave interfering bss .
this section derives closed - form mmwave and @xmath0wave spectral efficiencies , defined as ergodic capacity @xmath35 $ ] in units of nats / sec / hz ( 1bit @xmath36 0.693 nats ) , to be utilized for resource allocation in section [ sect : rsccell ] . for brevity
, we consider a downlink network in this section unless otherwise noted . throughout this study ,
an ultra - dense environment is of our interest .
the ultra - densification implies bs density is much larger than user density such that the distance to an interfering bs at a typical receiver can be approximated by the distance to the interfering bs s nearest user . to be more rigorous , define active probability @xmath37 that an arbitrary @xmath0wave bs is turned - on , i.e. serving at least a single user within its coverage .
according to proposition 1 in @xcite , @xmath38 where @xmath39 follows from taylor expansion for @xmath40 .
this tendency in ultra - dense networks results in the active bs density @xmath41 converging to @xmath9 .
the result implies ultra - densification enables to increase the received signal power without incurring any interference increment since interference is delimited by user density independent of the bs densification .
the same tendency applies to the mmwave bs active probability , so @xmath37 henceforth denotes both @xmath0wave and mmwave active probabilities .
wave user for path loss exponents @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 where user density @xmath9 is set as @xmath45 . compared to the simulation curve when @xmath46 , the analytic curve achieves : 81.75% , 90.9% , and 97.96% for @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath32 respectively.,width=340 ] this section derives the tractable but accurate lower bounds of uplink and downlink @xmath0wave spectral efficiencies .
firstly , consider uplink spectral efficiency that is deemed difficult to be analyzed in a stochastic geometric point of view . to specify the difficulty , we compare downlink and uplink scenarios . in a downlink case at @xmath14 , all interfering bss are farther than the associated bs . in an uplink case at a typical bs @xmath49 , on the other hand , interfering users may be located closer than the associated user @xmath14 since the nearest association is not determined by @xmath49 but users .
this distance disorder of uplink interferers and @xmath14 makes the uplink aggregate interference analysis complicated .
ultra - dense environment however allows to detour the distance disorder problem by enabling an uplink - downlink reciprocity thanks to short user - to - active bs distances , which leads to the following lemma . _ _ ( uplink downlink reciprocity ) _ for @xmath40 , uplink and downlink @xmath0wave spectral efficiencies are identical . + _ secondly , consider downlink @xmath0wave spectral efficiency .
its closed - form result has been derived in our preliminary work @xcite , but is restated here for the integrity of this study in the following proposition .
_ _ ( uplink / downlink @xmath0wave ) _ at @xmath14 for @xmath40 , uplink ( or downlink ) @xmath0wave spectral efficiency @xmath50 is lower bounded as follows .
@xmath51^{\alpha_\mu/2}\)\ ] ] where @xmath52 + _ the result indicates that increasing bs density logarithmically improves the @xmath0wave spectral efficiency .
the tightness of the proposed lower bound is numerically verified by fig .
the figure also illustrates increasing path loss exponent enhances the spectral efficiency since its resultant interference reduction dominates the desired signal attenuation under an interference - limited regime as expected in @xcite .
@xcite where user density @xmath53 , indoor region density @xmath54 , and main lobe beam width @xmath55.,width=340 ] this section derives the downlink mmwave spectral efficiencies under outdoor and indoor environments .
a notable mmwave characteristic in distinction from the preceding @xmath0wave analysis is indoor wall impenetrability .
its impact on the mmwave spectral efficiency is captured by a single indoor region area @xmath56 defined as @xmath57 .
we confine to considering a large outdoor region compared to indoor region , i.e. small @xmath56 . specifically , @xmath56 is sufficiently small in such a way that each indoor region contains at most a single user , leading to a noise - limited indoor environment and conversely an interference - limited outdoor environment .
firstly , in an interference - limited outdoor region , mmwave spectral efficiency @xmath58 is analytically represented in the following lemma . _ _ ( downlink outdoor mmwave ) _ at @xmath14
when located outside indoor regions for @xmath59 , downlink outdoor mmwave spectral efficiency @xmath60 is lower bounded as follows .
@xmath61^{\frac{\alpha_\text{m}}{2 } } \)^{1 - \sqrt{\frac{s}{\lambda_\text{m } } } } \label{eq : lemma3}\ ] ] where @xmath62 + _ the result implies bs densification not only improves @xmath63 , but also overcomes indoor wall blockages ( see the logarithm function s exponent in ) , leading to the spectral efficiency enhancement .
increasing indoor area @xmath56 decreases outdoor interference while increasing desired signal blockage effect .
the latter can be fully compensated by bs densification , so larger @xmath56 ensures better outdoor spectral efficiency under an ultra - dense environment .
the tightness of the analytic result is numerically validated , and visualized in fig .
3 . , and user density @xmath64.,width=340 ] secondly , in a noise - limited indoor region , mmwave spectral efficiency @xmath65 is given in the following proposition .
_ _ ( downlink indoor mmwave ) _ at @xmath14 when located within indoor regions for @xmath59 , downlink indoor mmwave spectral efficiency @xmath65 is lower bounded as follows .
@xmath66 + _ the relationship between bs density @xmath5 and received power intuitively interprets the result above . the received power scales with @xmath67 for indoor mmwave path loss exponent @xmath27 while @xmath68 $ ] in @xcite scales with @xmath69 , resulting in the linear scaling of @xmath70 with @xmath5 .
the tightness of the analysis is numerically verified as shown in fig .
4 . combining the outdoor and indoor mmwave spectral efficiencies ( lemmas 3 and 4 )
, the following result provides the overall downlink mmwave spectral efficiency @xmath71 as below . _
_ ( downlink mmwave )
_ at @xmath14 for @xmath59 , downlink mmwave spectral efficiency @xmath71 at @xmath14 is lower bounded as follows .
@xmath72^{e^{-\lambda_g s } } \ ) \label{eq : prop2}\ ] ] _ the result indicates mmwave downlink spectral efficiency is a logarithmic function of bs density @xmath5 .
the exponent of @xmath5 shows densification is more effective when 1 ) outdoor mmwave attenuation is severe ( large @xmath73 ) and/or 2 ) users are more likely to be in outdoor region ( small @xmath74 ) . in addition , sharper beam ( small @xmath13 ) increases the spectral efficiency . on the other hand , the spectral efficiency decreases with user density since more users bring about larger interference .
this section analyzes @xmath0wave resource allocation behaviors , and consequently provides the mmwave overlaid cellular network design guidelines in the perspectives of resource allocation and cell planning .
define downlink and uplink average rates @xmath75 and @xmath76 as follows .
@xmath77 let @xmath78 denote the minimum ratio of uplink to downlink rates .
we consider the following problem : @xmath79 & \underset{w_\mu } { \text{max } } \ ; r_{\text{d } } \notag\\ \end{aligned } \notag\\ & \text{subject to } \notag \\ & \quad r_{\text{u}}/r_{\text{d } } \geq t \label{eq : uplinkqos } \\ & \quad w_{\mu.\text{d } } + w_{\mu.\text{u } } = w\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 respectively denote downlink , uplink , and entire bandwidths .
the objective function is maximized when the equality in holds , leading to the following @xmath0wave downlink resource allocation . _ _ ( @xmath0wave resource allocation ) _ if @xmath83 , the following @xmath0wave downlink resource allocation maximizes the average rate while guaranteeing the minimum uplink rate : @xmath84 where @xmath85 ; otherwise , the minimum uplink rate requirement can not be satisfied .
_ increasing mmwave downlink rate ( @xmath5 and/or @xmath86 ) leads to less downlink @xmath0wave allocation @xmath87 and more uplink @xmath0wave allocation @xmath88 .
the reason is because the mmwave band provides most of the downlink transmissions without the aid of @xmath0wave band , and thus all the @xmath0wave band becomes dedicated to the uplink transmissions to assure the minimum uplink rate requirement .
in addition , increasing @xmath0wave resource @xmath82 allows more @xmath87 and @xmath88 , but the latter increases faster ( notice @xmath89 for @xmath78 ) .
such uplink biased @xmath0wave resource allocation tendency is the opposite way of the current resource management trend seeking more downlink resources , to be further elucidated under practical scenarios in section v. increasing @xmath0wave bs density @xmath7 , on the other hand , makes the resource more prone to be allocated to downlink transmissions .
recalling @xmath0wave uplink - downlink reciprocity in lemma 2 , increasing @xmath7 identically improves both uplink and downlink rates . in spite of such identical increments , the uplink / downlink ratio increases since the uplink rate is no larger than downlink rate .
this results in increasing @xmath80 until the equality in holds . wave resource allocations with mmwave bandwidth @xmath3 mhz ( @xmath53 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath54 , @xmath92 , @xmath93 , @xmath94).,width=340 ] applying the resource allocation results to yields the following uplink rate requirement guaranteeing maximized downlink average rate .
_ _ ( downlink average rate with minimum uplink rate requirement ) _
if @xmath83 for @xmath95 , maximized downlink average rate while guaranteeing the minimum uplink rate is given as : @xmath96 } { \lambda_\mu}^{\frac{w \alpha_\mu}{2 } } \)\]]where @xmath97^{w_\text{m}\ ( 1-\sqrt{\frac{s}{\lambda_\text{m}}}\ ) } \hspace{-10pt } \
( \rho_\mu \lambda_\text{u}\)^{-\frac{\alpha_\mu w}{2 } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] otherwise , the rate can not satisfy the uplink rate requirement . _
the result reveals bs densification logarithmically increases the downlink rate while @xmath0wave and mmwave resource amounts and path loss exponents linearly increases the rate .
larger indoor region area under @xmath98 exponentially decreases the rate .
additionally , increasing the minimum uplink rate target decreases the downlink rate .
this result is visually elucidated by fig . 6 in section v.
this section provides resource management and cell planning guidelines based on the closed - form @xmath0wave uplink / downlink ( see proposition 1 ) and mmwave downlink ( see proposition 2 ) spectral efficiency lower bounds derived in sections [ sect : muwavese ] and d. as fig . 3 and 4
numerically validate the tightness of the lower bounds , we henceforth regard these lower bounds as approximations . to simplify our exposition , we focus on the asymptotic behaviors as @xmath99 .
consider the uplink requirement feasible condition @xmath83 from proposition 3 , leading to the minimum number of the required @xmath0wave bss along with increasing mmwave bss .
_ _ ( required @xmath0wave bs ) _ for @xmath99 , guaranteeing the minimum uplink rate requires the following @xmath0wave and mmwave bs density relation : @xmath100}}\ ) \ ] ] _ to achieve the ever - growing downlink average rate while guaranteeing the minimum uplink average rate , the result shows the required @xmath0wave bs density should be increased with much higher order of the mmwave bs density in practical scenarios where @xmath101 .
the reason is the logarithmic spectral efficiency improvement by @xmath0wave bs densification ( see proposition 1 ) can not overtake the linearly increased mmwave downlink rate .
ameliorating this situation in practice therefore requires to procure additional @xmath0wave resource as fig .
7 visualizes in section v. the following corollary investigates how much amount of @xmath0wave resource is required to achieve the goal when @xmath0wave bs densification is linearly proportional to the mmwave bs s .
_ _ ( required @xmath0wave resource ) _ for @xmath102 and @xmath103 for a constant @xmath104 , the minimum uplink average rate constraint requires @xmath0wave resource amount as follows .
@xmath105\ ] ] _ the result insists that even when the number of @xmath0wave bss increases with the same order of the mmwave bss , it is imperative to procure additional @xmath0wave resource in order to increase downlink average rate with assuring the minimum uplink rate .
it is visually elaborated by fig . 5 in section v. under @xmath0wave bandwidth
@xmath2 mhz and mmwave bandwidth @xmath3 mhz ( @xmath53 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath54 , @xmath92 , @xmath93).,width=340 ] wave bs density as mmwave bs density increases for @xmath0wave bandwidths @xmath2 mhz and @xmath106 mhz under mmwave bandwidth @xmath3 mhz ( @xmath107 , @xmath53 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath54 , @xmath108 , @xmath92 , @xmath93).,width=340 ]
this section visualizes the resource management and cell planning guidelines proposed in section iv under practical scenarios . according to @xcite ,
path loss exponents are set as : @xmath90 , @xmath109 .
the indoor mmwave path loss exponent is set as 2 as assumed in section [ sect : channel ] .
additionally , user density @xmath64 , indoor region density @xmath54 , main lobe beam width @xmath110 , and noise power @xmath26 is fixed as @xmath32 . the radio resource amount for @xmath0wave
is set as @xmath2 mhz as default , and the amount for mmwave as @xmath3 mhz @xcite .
5 illustrates proposition 3 and corollary 2 that shows the uplink ( thick blue ) and downlink ( thin green ) @xmath0wave resource allocations . for the given environment , guaranteeing the uplink average rate by @xmath1 of the downlink rate requires at least @xmath111 mhz uplink @xmath0wave bandwidth . considering the current @xmath2 mhz @xmath0wave bandwidth , it implies implies even achieving such low uplink / downlink ratio requires to dedicate most of the @xmath0wave bandwidth to the uplink due to severe uplink / downlink rate asymmetry .
this contradicts with the current resource allocation tendency that is likely to allocate more resource to downlink @xcite . focusing on the curve slopes
once the minimum uplink rate requirement is achieved , it shows the surplus @xmath0wave bandwidths are mostly allocated to the downlinks so as to maximize the downlink rates .
6 corresponds to corollary 1 that illustrates the maximized downlink rate with assuring the minimum uplink / downlink rate ratio @xmath112 along with increasing mmwave bs density @xmath5 .
the figure compares the effect of the uplink rate requirement on the resultant downlink rate ( solid versus dashed ) , capturing the downlink rate is pared down to the point achieving the minimum uplink rate .
moreover , the figure revels the effect of the indoor region area @xmath56 ( blue versus green ) that larger @xmath56 leads to the lower downlink rate as expected in the discussion of corollary 1 .
in addition , the figure reveals that @xmath32 gbps downlink average rate is achieved when mmwave bs density is @xmath113 times larger than the user density for @xmath114 and when it is @xmath115 times larger for @xmath116 .
fig . 7 visualizes proposition 4 that validates the proposed resource management and cell planning guidelines .
it shows @xmath0wave bs densification can not independently cope with the uplink rate requirement problem , but requires the aid of procuring more @xmath0wave spectrum .
the impact of procuring more @xmath0wave spectrum is observed by the curve increasing tendencies in the figure .
the @xmath0wave bs density for @xmath0wave bandwidth @xmath2 mhz ( dotted green ) shows power - law increase while the density for @xmath106 mhz ( solid blue ) does sub - linear increase .
these different required @xmath0wave bs increasing rates corroborate the necessity of the additional @xmath0wave spectrum .
the figure in addition reveals that the effect of indoor region area @xmath56 that decreases the minimum required @xmath0wave bs density due to its downlink rate reduction discussed in corollary 1 and visualized in fig .
in this paper we propose a mmwave overlaid ultra - dense cellular network operating downlink transmissions via both mmwave and @xmath0wave bands whereas uplink transmissions only via @xmath0wave band due to its technical implementation difficulty at mobile users . regarding this asymmetric uplink and downlink structure ,
we provide the resource management and cell planning guidelines so as to maximize downlink average rate while guaranteeing the minimum uplink rate ( see propositions 3 and 4 as well as corollary 2 ) .
such results are calculated on the basis of the closed - form mmwave ( see proposition 1 ) and @xmath0wave ( see proposition 2 ) spectral efficiencies derived by using stochastic geometry .
the weakness of this study is the use of an arbitrary indoor region ( or blockage ) area @xmath56 when calculating mmwave spectral efficiencies , which may alter the network design results .
moreover , the blockage modeling in this paper is necessary to be compared with the recent mmw blockage analysis such as @xcite .
further extension should therefore contemplate more realistic building statistics as well as a rigorous comparison with the preceding works .
t. s. rappaport , s. sun , r. mayzus , h. zhao , y. azar , k. wang , g. n. wong , j. k. schulz , m. sammi , and f. gutierrez , `` milimeter wave mobile communications for 5 g cellular : it will work !
, '' _ ieee access _ ,
vol . 1 , pp . 335349 , 2013 .
j. park , s .- l .
kim , and j. zander , `` asymptotic behavior of ultra - dense cellular networks and its economic impact , '' _ in proc .
ieee global communications conference ( globecom 2014 ) , austin , united sates _
, december 2014 .
t. kim , j. park , j .- y .
seol , s. jeong , j. cho , and w. roh , `` tens of gbps support with mmwave beamforming systems for next generation communications , '' _ proc .
ieee global communications conference ( globecom 2014 ) _ , pp . 36853690 , 2013 .
m. n. kulkarni , s. singh , and j. g. andrews , `` coverage and rate trends in dense urban mmwave cellular networks , '' _ in proc .
ieee global communications conference ( globecom 2014 ) , austin , united sates _ , december 2014 . | this paper proposes a cellular network exploiting millimeter - wave ( mmwave ) and ultra - densified base stations ( bss ) to achieve the far - reaching 5 g aim in downlink average rate .
the mmwave overlaid network however incurs a pitfall that its ample data rate is only applicable for downlink transmissions due to the implementation difficulty at mobile users , leading to an immense difference between uplink and downlink rates .
we therefore turn our attention not only to maximize downlink rate but also to ensure the minimum uplink rate . with this end
, we firstly derive the mmwave overlaid ultra - dense cellular network spectral efficiencies for both uplink and downlink cases in closed forms by using stochastic geometry via a lower bound approximation . in a practical scenario ,
such tractable results of the proposed network reveal that incumbent micro - wave ( @xmath0wave ) cellular resource should be mostly dedicated to uplink transmissions in order to correspond with the mmwave downlink rate improvement . furthermore ,
increasing uplink rate via @xmath0wave bs densification can not solely cope with the mmwave downlink / uplink rate asymmetry , and thus requires additional @xmath0wave spectrum in 5 g cellular networks .
ultra - dense cellular networks , millimeter - wave , heterogeneous cellular networks , radio resource management , cell planning , stochastic geometry , coverage process , boolean model . |
the origins of the languages have been an issue of investigation and broad interest since ancient times , and recent advances in archeology , genetics and linguistics have been important to a better comprehension of the linguistic diversification @xcite . however , there is not a universal consensus concerning the evolution of this diversity @xcite .
some similarities among distinct groups of languages suggest that they must have a common ancestor . by comparing languages that belong to a same family
, linguists try to construct the hypothetical ancestor language . according to the _ out of africa hypothesis _ , the modern human beings originated in africa about 100,000 years ago and substituted all the populations outside africa .
this hypothesis receives strong confirmation from the family tree based on a sampling of nuclear dna from a number of living populations @xcite .
molecular genetics can also give us some insights regarding to the distribution of languages on the earth .
cavalli - sforza @xcite compared the family tree which one obtains from molecular genetic data at a world level with a family tree established using only linguistic data and his results indicate a fair degree of overlap .
the future of languages is a matter of interest and concern as well @xcite .
it is estimated that at least @xmath0 of the existing languages may be extinct in the next century @xcite .
while one hundred of languages are spoken by about @xmath1 of the world population , most languages are present in a single or in a few small regions .
the loss of linguistic diversity is a subject of worry not only by the linguists , because languages provide an important way to better understand the past of our species .
even more , since some languages possess a very elaborated vocabulary to describe the world , the loss would imply also the loss of ecological knowledge . by analyzing all the approximately 6,700 languages on earth
, gomes et al @xcite showed that ( i ) the language diversity scales with area according to a power law @xmath2 , where @xmath3 , over almost six decades , and ( ii ) the number of languages @xmath4 spoken by a population of size larger than @xmath5 , @xmath6 , also display a power law behaviour : @xmath7 .
the critical exponent @xmath8 is comparable to the ones we observe in ecology for the relationships between species diversity and area , which are usually in the range 0.1 to 0.45 @xcite .
here we study the evolution of the linguistic diversity by introducing a spatial model which considers the underlying diffusion mechanisms that generate and sustain this diversity .
the model is used to describe the occupation of a given area by populations speaking various languages . in the process of colonization of regions , language mutation or differentiation and
language substitution can take place , and so increase the linguistic diversity . in the context of language dynamics , mutations are variations of languages with respect to a common ancestor language .
the probability of producing reverse mutations is zero , that is , the language generated by a mutation is always different of the previous ones .
our model is defined on a two - dimensional lattice composed by @xmath9 sites with periodic boundary conditions .
each lattice site @xmath10 represents a region that can be occupied by a population speaking just one language .
we ascribe to each site a given capability @xmath11 , whose value we estimate from a uniform distribution , in the range 0 - 1 .
this capability means the amount of resources available to the population which will colonize that place .
it is expected that the population size in each cell is proportional to the capability @xmath11 .
therefore , the populations are distributed in a heterogeneous environment . in the first step of the dynamics , we randomly choose one site of the lattice to be colonized by a population that speaks the ancestor language .
to each language , we assign a fitness value @xmath12 which is defined as the sum of the capabilities of the sites containing populations which speak that specific language . therefore , the initial fitness of the ancestor language is the capability of the initial site . in the second step ,
one of the four nearest neighbors of this site will be chosen to be colonized with probability proportional to its capability .
we assume that regions containing larger amount of resources are more likely to be colonized faster than poor regions . the referred site is then occupied by a population speaking the ancestor language or a mutant version of it .
the assumption of mutations mimics the situation at which one language is initially spoken by populations in different regions , and after some time , modifications of this initial language emerge in one or both populations and the language split into two different languages .
the probability of occurrence of a mutation in the process of propagation of the language is @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is a constant , and so the mutation probability is inversely proportional to the fitness of the language .
this rule for the mutation procedure , we borrow from population genetics .
we observe that small populations are more vulnerable to genetic drift and the rate of drift is inversely proportional to the population size @xcite .
genetic drift is a mechanism of evolution that acts to change the characteristics of species over time .
it is a stochastic effect that arises due the random sampling in the reproduction process . in the subsequent steps , we check what are the empty sites which are on the boundary of the colonized cluster , and we choose one of those empty sites according to their capabilities .
those ones with higher capabilities have a higher likelihood to be occupied .
we then choose the language to occupy the cell among their neighboring sites .
the languages with higher fitness have a higher chance to colonize the cell .
this process will continue up to all sites be colonized . at this point
, we verify the total number of languages @xmath15 . in order to give to the reader some insight about our model , in figure 1
we present the snapshot for a typical realization of the dynamics at the first moment of colonization of all sites . in this figure
each color represent a different language domain .
the color bar shows the label for each language .
and @xmath16,width=340,height=340 ] in figure 2 , we show @xmath15 as a function of the area @xmath17 ( total number of sites in the lattice ) for two different values of the constant @xmath14 .
we obtain each point by taking averages over 100 independent simulations for @xmath18 , over 50 for @xmath19 , 400 and 500 and over 20 for @xmath20 .
we notice from this figure the existence of two distinct scaling regions , where @xmath2 . when @xmath21 , we estimate the exponent @xmath22 for @xmath23 , whereas @xmath24 for @xmath25 .
when @xmath26 , we find @xmath27 for @xmath28 , and @xmath29 when @xmath30 . for both values of @xmath14 , we obtain exponents in agreement with those observed for the distribution of languages on earth @xcite .
each power law extends over approximately two or more decades . for small and intermediate sized areas ,
the language diversity increases more quickly with the area , when compared to large areas . when @xmath31 , it is not possible to distinguish the two scaling regimes and in this case we estimate @xmath32 .
as the simulation is very time consuming for lattices of size @xmath33 , it is not perfectly clear for us if the second regime is a true scaling or a transient regime with @xmath15 going to a constant value as @xmath17 increases or perhaps with @xmath15 growing logarithmically with @xmath17 for very large values of area . as a function of the area @xmath17 for two values of mutation probability @xmath34 : @xmath21 , 0.73 ( from bottom to top ) .
the exponents obtained for @xmath21 are @xmath35 for @xmath36 , and @xmath24 for @xmath37 .
for @xmath26 we have @xmath27 for @xmath28 , and @xmath29 for @xmath30.,width=340,height=340 ] in order to characterize the diffusion in this process we investigate the time evolution of the average area @xmath38 occupied by the typical language . in our model , one time step represents the process of colonization of just one site by one language .
the average area is @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the area occupied by the language @xmath41 in time @xmath42 and @xmath43 is the diversity of languages in time @xmath42 .
by the end of the process of colonization we have @xmath44 , and @xmath45 since the total area is equal to @xmath46 and the diversity is proportional to @xmath47 .
@xmath48 is a measure of the capacity of the languages to diffuse or to spread across the entire territory .
thus , the diffusion exponent @xmath49 can be introduced using the relation @xcite @xmath50 from ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) we conclude that @xmath51 , and thus @xmath49 assumes the standard brownian value @xmath52 if @xmath53 . for @xmath54
we have anomalous diffusion and @xmath55 , indicating a progressive difficulty for language diffusion . for the current distribution of languages on earth
this exponent is @xmath56 , reflecting the geographical limitations that languages have to face in their process of expansion .
this particular anomalous value is close to those obtained for diffusion in two - dimensional percolation below the percolation threshold @xcite .
we compare our previous estimative ( eq .
( 3 ) ) with the value of @xmath49 obtained by observing the evolution of @xmath57 in the simulations and verify a good agreement between them . in figure 3
we illustrate the evolution of @xmath38 for one run where @xmath21 and @xmath58 . for this particular situation we obtained @xmath59 , i. e. an exponent close to the brownian value . for @xmath21 and @xmath58 .
for this curve , we have @xmath60.,width=340,height=340 ] ( o ) and @xmath49 @xmath61 as a function of @xmath14 for ( a ) small and intermediate areas and ( b ) large areas.,width=340,height=340 ] number of languages with population greater than @xmath5 , @xmath6 , as a function of @xmath5 .
@xmath62 with @xmath63 for @xmath64.,width=340,height=340 ] number of languages @xmath15 as a function of the area @xmath17 for @xmath26 after the process of interaction among populations .
the distinct curves show the cases where the fitness of the language that occupy the site is multiplied by 1 , 10 and 100 ( from bottom to top).,width=340,height=340 ] figure 4 displays the dependence of the exponents @xmath8 and @xmath49 on the parameter @xmath14 : we observe that for small and intermediate areas , @xmath8 scales with @xmath14 as @xmath65 , which means that a small increment of the mutation probability results in a fast increasing of the diversity . for large areas
@xmath8 is approximately constant for @xmath66 and quickly grows for @xmath67 ( this sudden increase in @xmath8 possibly reflects the finite size of the lattice ) . in figure 5
we plot the number of languages with population size greater than @xmath5 , @xmath6 , as a function of @xmath5 . in order to obtain the curves
, we assume that each site contributes with 1 person to the population .
the data points were estimated over 10 independent runs with @xmath58 and @xmath26 . in close analogy with the distribution of languages on earth @xcite , we find the scaling regime @xmath7 where @xmath63 , along almost three decades in @xmath5 .
after the populations have filled up the lattice , we initiate the second part of our analysis , which consider the process of interaction among populations . this interaction represents the flow of people that speak different languages among nations or even the people using new technologies which permit their communication throughout the world .
now , each time step corresponds to visit all cells on the lattice . in the visit to a given cell
we compare the fitness of its language with the fitness values of languages which are spoken in its neighborhood .
one of the five languages will be chosen to invade ( or to stay ) in that site with probability proportional to their fitness .
the probability of mutation is , as before , proportional to the inverse of the fitness of the invading or staying language .
after the stabilization , we estimate the average of the number of languages over a given time interval . in figure 6
we plot the number of languages as a function of the area after considering the process of interaction .
we obtain each point taking averages over 10 independent simulations .
we also show the cases where the fitness of the language that is already in the site is increased by a factor 10 and 100 in order to compete with the neighbors .
the purpose of this augment in the fitness is to increase the selective advantage of the population that already colonizes the site .
when this selective advantage is small , the number of languages presents a linear growth and then decreases with the area up to reaching an asymptotic value .
when the selective advantage is high , the number of languages initially presents a linear growth with the area , followed by a regime of fluctuation of the diversity and above a given area threshold it decreases abruptly . for small areas ,
the fitnesses of populations are not high when compared to those one which can be obtained by populations in large areas .
therefore , in order to compete with the populations which already colonize the sites ( and possess a selective advantage ) , languages need to colonize large areas .
this is the reason why we observe the initial linear growth of language diversity for small area when we consider a high selective advantage . above a certain area ,
some populations have a very high fitness in order to compete with other languages and dominate .
thus , the diversity drastically decreases and only a few languages survive .
we have introduced in this work a simple computer model to simulate some aspects of the linguistic diversity on earth .
surprisingly , this model is able to generate important scaling laws ( figs . 2 and 5 ) in close resemblance to those observed in the actual distribution of languages @xcite .
we verified that the mutation probability of languages displays a decisive role for the maintenance of the linguistic diversity . on the other hand ,
the diffusion exponent @xmath49 is very large for values of @xmath14 close to 1 ( fig .
4 ) , that is , in the situation in which we have a high diversity per area , indicating that languages do not have much facility to diffuse and remain essentially localized in linguistic niches . we do not discard the possibility that the presence of two scaling regimes for the linguistic diversity in our simulations may be a consequence of the regular structure of the lattice . in order to investigate the role of the topology in this model
, we are currently studying the process of diffusion of languages in a percolation cluster .
after the process of interaction among languages we observed the surviving of just a few languages with a very high fitness ( fig .
6 ) . from this
, we can ascertain how important is for linguistic diversity to have well stablished languages spoken by a large number of people . | here we describe how some important scaling laws observed in the distribution of languages on earth can emerge from a simple computer simulation .
the proposed language dynamics includes processes of selective geographic colonization , linguistic anomalous diffusion and mutation , and interaction among populations that occupy different regions .
it is found that the dependence of the linguistic diversity on the area after colonization displays two power law regimes , both described by critical exponents which are dependent on the mutation probability .
most importantly for the future prospect of world s population , our results show that the linguistic diversity always decrease to an asymptotic very small value if large areas and sufficiently long times of interaction among populations are considered .
departamento de fsica , universidade federal de pernambuco , 50670 - 901 , recife , pe , brazil |
over the course of the past 140 years , the field of professional pure mathematics ( analysis in particular ) , and to a large extent also its professional historiography , have become increasingly dominated by a particular philosophical disposition .
we argue that such a disposition is akin to nominalism , and examine its ramifications . in 1983 , j. burgess proposed a useful dichotomy for analyzing nominalistic narratives .
the starting point of his critique is his perception that a philosopher s job is not to rule on the ontological merits of this or that scientific entity , but rather to try to understand those entities that are employed in our best scientific theories . from this viewpoint ,
the problem of nominalism is the awkwardness of the contortions a nominalist goes through in developing an alternative to his target scientific practice , an alternative deemed ontologically better " from his reductive perspective , but in reality amounting to the imposition of artificial strictures on the scientific practice . burgess introduces a dichotomy of _ hermeneutic _ versus _ revolutionary _ nominalism .
hermeneutic nominalism _ is the hypothesis that science , properly interpreted , already dispenses with mathematical objects ( entities ) such as numbers and sets . meanwhile , _ revolutionary nominalism _ is the project of replacing current scientific theories by alternatives dispensing with mathematical objects , see burgess @xcite and burgess and rosen @xcite .
nominalism in the philosophy of mathematics is often understood narrowly , as exemplified by the ideas of j. s. mill and p. kitcher , going back to aristotle .
however , the burgessian distinction between hermeneutic and revolutionary reconstructions can be applied more broadly , so as to include nominalistic - type reconstructions that vary widely in their ontological target , namely the variety of abstract objects ( entities ) they seek to challenge ( and , if possible , eliminate ) as being merely conventional , see @xcite .
burgess quotes at length yu .
manin s critique in the 1970s of mathematical nominalism of constructivist inspiration , whose ontological target is the classical infinity , namely , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ abstractions which are infinite and do not lend themselves to a constructivist interpretation @xcite . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ this suggests that burgess would countenance an application of his dichotomy to nominalism of a constructivist inspiration .
the ontological target of the constructivists is the concept of cantorian infinities , or more fundamentally , the logical principle of the law of excluded middle ( lem ) .
coupled with a classical interpretation of the existence quantifier , lem is responsible for propelling the said infinities into a dubious existence .
lem is the abstract object targeted by bishop s constructivist nominalism , which can therefore be called an anti - lem nominalism .
may be found in section [ two ] , see footnote [ root ] . ]
thus , anti - lem nominalism falls within the scope of the burgessian critique , and is the first of the nominalistic reconstructions we wish to analyze .
the anti - lem nominalistic reconstruction was in fact a _ re_-reconstruction of an earlier nominalistic reconstruction of analysis , dating from the 1870s .
the earlier reconstruction was implemented by the great triumviratec .
boyer refers to cantor , dedekind , and weierstrass as `` the great triumvirate '' , see @xcite .
] of cantor , dedekind , and weierstrass .
the ontological target of the triumvirate reconstruction was the abstract entity called the _
, a basic building block of a continuum , according to a line of investigators harking back to the greek antiquity.see also footnote [ cauchy ] on cauchy . ] to place these historical developments in context , it is instructive to examine felix klein s remarks dating from 1908 .
having outlined the developments in real analysis associated with weierstrass and his followers , klein pointed out that _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the scientific mathematics of today is built upon the series of developments which we have been outlining .
but an essentially different conception of infinitesimal calculus has been running parallel with this [ conception ] through the centuries @xcite . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ such a different conception , according to klein , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ harks back to old metaphysical speculations concerning the _ structure of the continuum _ according to which this was made up of [ ... ] infinitely small parts @xcite [ emphasis added
authors ] .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the significance of the triumvirate reconstruction has often been measured by the yardstick of the extirpation of the infinitesimal.thus , after describing the formalisation of the real continuum in the 1870s , on pages 127 - 128 of his retiring presidential address in 1902 , e. hobson remarks triumphantly as follows : `` it should be observed that the criterion for the convergence of an aggregate [ i.e. an equivalence class defining a real number ] is of such a character that no use is made in it of _ infinitesimals _ ''
@xcite [ emphasis added authors ] .
hobson reiterates : `` in all such proofs [ of convergence ] the only statements made are as to relations of finite numbers , no such entities as _ infinitesimals _ being recognized or employed .
such is the essence of the @xmath0[@xmath1 proofs with which we are familiar '' @xcite [ emphasis added
authors ] .
the tenor of hobson s remarks is that weierstrass s fundamental accomplishment was the elimination of infinitesimals from foundational discourse in analysis . ]
the infinitesimal ontological target has similarly been the motivating force behind a more recent nominalistic reconstruction , namely a nominalistic re - appraisal of the meaning of cauchy s foundational work in analysis .
we will analyze these three nominalistic projects through the lens of the dichotomy introduced by burgess .
our preliminary conclusion is that , while the triumvirate reconstruction was primarily revolutionary in the sense of burgess , and the ( currently prevailing ) cauchy reconstruction is mainly hermeneutic , the anti - lem reconstruction has combined elements of both types of nominalism .
we will examine the effects of a nominalist disposition on historiography , teaching , and research .
a traditional view of 19th century analysis holds that a search for rigor inevitably leads to epsilontics , as developed by weierstrass in the 1870s ; that such inevitable developments culminated in the establishment of ultimate set - theoretic foundations for mathematics by cantor ; and that eventually , once the antinomies sorted out , such foundations were explicitly expressed in axiomatic form by zermelo and fraenkel .
such a view entails a commitment to a specific destination or ultimate goal of scientific devepment as being pre - determined and intrinsically inevitable .
the postulation of a specific outcome , believed to be the inevitable result of the development of the discipline , is an outlook specific to the mathematical community .
challenging such a _ belief _ appears to be a radical proposition in the eyes of a typical professional mathematician , but not in the eyes of scientists in related fields of the exact sciences .
it is therefore puzzling that such a view should be accepted without challenge by a majority of historians of mathematics , who tend to toe the line on the mathematicians belief .
could mathematical analysis have followed a different path of development ?
related material appears in alexander @xcite , giordano @xcite , katz and tall @xcite , kutateladze @xcite , mormann @xcite , sepkoski @xcite , and wilson @xcite .
[ two ] this section is concerned with e. bishop s approach to reconstructing analysis .
bishop s approach is rooted in brouwer s revolt against the non - constructive nature of mathematics as practiced by his contemporaries .
is there meaning after lem ?
the brouwer
hilbert debate captured the popular mathematical imagination in the 1920s .
brouwer s crying call was for the elimination of most of the applications of lem from meaningful mathematical discourse .
burgess discusses the debate briefly in his treatment of nominalism in @xcite .
we will analyze e. bishop s implementation of brouwer s nominalistic project . for more details .
this could not be otherwise , since a verificational interpretation of the quantifiers necessarily results in a clash with classical mathematics . as a matter of presentation
, the conflict with classical mathematics had been de - emphasized by bishop .
bishop finesses the issue of brouwer s theorems ( e.g. , that every function is continuous ) by declaring that he will only deal with uniformly continuous functions to begin with . in bishopian mathematics
, a circle can not be decomposed into a pair of antipodal sets .
a counterexample to the classical extreme value theorem is discussed in @xcite , see footnote [ lpo ] for details . ]
it is an open secret that the much - touted success of bishop s implementation of the intuitionistic project in his 1967 book @xcite is due to philosophical compromises with a platonist viewpoint that are resolutely rejected by the intuitionistic philosopher m. dummett @xcite .
thus , in a dramatic departure from both kronecker , in the main text around footnote [ boniface ] . ] and brouwer , bishopian constructivism accepts the completed ( actual ) infinity of the integers @xmath2.intuitionists view @xmath3 as a potential totality ; for a more detailed discussion see , e.g. , @xcite . ]
bishop expressed himself as follows on the first page of his book : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in another universe , with another biology and another physics , [ there ] will develop mathematics which in essence is the same as ours @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ since the sensory perceptions of the human _ body _ are physics- and chemistry - bound , a claim of such trans - universe invariance amounts to the positing of a _
disembodied _ nature of the infinite natural number system , transcending physics and chemistry .. bishop s disembodied integers illustrate the awkward philosophical contorsions which are a tell - tale sign of nominalism .
an alternative approach to the problem is pursued in modern cognitive science .
bishop s disembodied integers , the cornerstone of his approach , appear to be at odds with modern cognitive theory of _ embodied _ knowledge , see tall @xcite , lakoff and nez @xcite , sfard @xcite , yablo @xcite .
reyes @xcite presents an intriguing thesis concerning an allegedly rhetorical nature of newton s attempts at grounding infinitesimals in terms of _ moments _ or _ nascent and evanescent quantities _ , and leibniz s similar attempts in terms of `` a general heuristic under [ the name of ] the principle of continuity '' @xcite .
he argues that what made these theories vulnerable to criticism is the reigning principle in 17th century methodology according to which abstract objects must necessarily have empirical counterparts / referents .
d. sherry points out that `` formal axiomatics emerged only in the 19th century , after geometry embraced objects with no empirical counterparts ( e.g. , poncelet s points at infinity ... ) '' @xcite .
see also s. feferman s approach of conceptual structuralism @xcite , for a view of mathematical objects as mental conceptions . ]
what type of nominalistic reconstruction best fits the bill of bishop s constructivism ?
bishop s rejection of classical mathematics as a `` debasement of meaning '' @xcite would place him squarely in the camp of revolutionary nominalisms in the sense of burgess ; yet some elements of bishop s program tend to be of the hermeneutic variety , as well . as an elementary example , consider bishop s discussion of the irrationality of the square root of @xmath4 in @xcite .
irrationality is defined constructively in terms of being quantifiably apart from each rational number .
the classical proof of the irrationality of @xmath5 is a proof by contradiction .
namely , we _ assume _ a hypothesized equality @xmath6 , examine the parity of the powers of @xmath4 , and arrive at a contradiction .
at this stage , irrationality is considered to have been proved , in classical logic.the classical proof showing that @xmath5 is _ not rational _ is , of course , acceptable in intuitionistic logic . to pass from this to the claim of its _ irrationality _ as defined above , requires lem ( see footnote [ root ] for details ) .
] however , as bishop points out , the proof can be modified slightly so as to avoid lem , and acquire an enhanced _
numerical meaning_. thus , _ without _ exploiting the equality @xmath6 , one can exhibit effective positive lower bounds for the difference @xmath7 in terms of the denominator @xmath8 , resulting in a constructively adequate proof of irrationality.such a proof may be given as follows .
for each rational @xmath9 , the integer @xmath10 is divisible by an odd power of @xmath4 , while @xmath11 is divisible by an even power of @xmath4 .
hence @xmath12 ( here we have applied lem to an effectively decidable predicate over @xmath2 , or more precisely the law of trichotomy ) . since the decimal expansion of @xmath5 starts with @xmath13 , we may assume @xmath14 .
it follows that @xmath15 yielding a numerically meaningful proof of irrationality , which is a special case of liouville s theorem on diophantine approximation of algebraic numbers , see @xcite .
] such a proof is merely a modification of a classical proof , and can thus be considered a hermeneutic reconstruction thereof .
a number of classical results ( though by no means all ) can be reinterpreted constructively , resulting in an enhancement of their numerical meaning , in some cases at little additional cost .
this type of project is consistent with the idea of a hermeneutic nominalism in the sense of burgess , and related to the notion of _ liberal constructivism _ in the sense of g. hellman ( see below ) .
the intuitionist / constructivist opposition to classical mathematics is predicated on the the philosophical assumption that meaningful " mathematics is mathematics done without the law of excluded middle .
e. bishop ( following brouwer but surpassing him in rhetoric ) is on record making statements of the sort _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ `` very possibly classical mathematics will cease to exist as an independent discipline '' @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ( to be replaced , naturally , by constructive mathematics ) ; and _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ `` brouwer s criticisms of classical mathematics were concerned with what i shall refer to as ` the debasement of meaning ' '' @xcite . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ such a stance posits intuitionism / constructivism as an _ alternative _ to classical mathematics , and is described as _
radical constructivism _ by g. hellman @xcite .
radicalism is contrasted by hellman with a _ liberal _ brand of intuitionism ( a _ companion _ to classical mathematics ) .
liberal constructivism may be exemplified by a. heyting @xcite , who was brouwer s student , and formalized intuitionistic logic . to motivate the long march through the foundations occasioned by a lem - eliminative agenda
, bishop @xcite goes to great lengths to dress it up in an appealing package of a _ theory of meaning _ that first conflates meaning with numerical meaning ( a goal many mathematicians can relate to ) , and then numerical meaning with lem extirpation .. ] rather than merely rejecting lem or related logical principles such as trichotomy which sound perfectly unexceptionable to a typical mathematician , bishop presents these principles in quasi metaphysical garb of principles of omniscience".[multiblock footnote omitted ] bishop retells a creation story of intuitionism in the form of an imaginary dialog between brouwer and hilbert where the former completely dominates the exchange .
indeed , bishop s imaginary brouwer - hilbert exchange is dominated by an unspoken assumption that brouwer is the only one who seeks meaning " , an assumption that his illustrious opponent is never given a chance to challenge .
meanwhile , hilbert s comments in 1919 reveal clearly his attachment to meaning which he refers to as _ internal necessity _ : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we are not speaking here of arbitrariness in any sense .
mathematics is not like a game whose tasks are determined by arbitrarily stipulated rules .
rather , it is a conceptual system possessing internal necessity that can only be so and by no means otherwise @xcite ( cited in corry @xcite ) . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ a majority of mathematicians ( including those favorable to constructivism ) feel that an implementation of bishop s program does involve a significant complication of the technical development of analysis , as a result of the nominalist work of lem - elimination .
bishop s program has met with a certain amount of success , and attracted a number of followers .
part of the attraction stems from a detailed lexicon developed by bishop so as to challenge received ( classical ) views on the nature of mathematics .
a constructive lexicon was a _
sine qua non _ of his success .
a number of terms from bishop s constructivist lexicon constitute a novelty as far as intuitionism is concerned , and are not necessarily familiar even to someone knowledgeable about intuitionism _ per se_.
it may be helpful to provide a summary of such terms for easy reference , arranged alphabetically , as follows .
@xmath16 _ debasement of meaning _ is the cardinal sin of the classical opposition , from cantor to keisler , but see footnote [ keisler2 ] . ]
committed with _
( see below ) .
the term occurs in bishop s _ schizophrenia _ @xcite and _ crisis _
@xcite texts .
@xmath16 _ fundamentalist excluded thirdist _ is a term that refers to a classically - trained mathematician who has not yet become sensitized to implicit use of the law of excluded middle ( i.e. , _ excluded third _ ) in his arguments , see @xcite.this use of the term `` fundamentalist excluded thirdist '' is in a text by richman , not bishop .
i have not been able to source its occurrence in bishop s writing . in a similar vein ,
an ultrafinitist recently described this writer as a `` choirboy of infinitesimology '' ; however , this term does not seem to be in general use .
see also footnote [ rich2 ] . ]
@xmath16 _ idealistic mathematics _ is the output of platonist mathematical sensibilities , abetted by a metaphysical faith in _
( see below ) , and characterized by the presence of merely a _ peculiar pragmatic content _ ( see below ) .
@xmath16 _ integer _ is the revealed source of all _ meaning _ ( see below ) , posited as an alternative foundation displacing both formal logic , axiomatic set theory , and recursive function theory .
the integers wondrously escape . ] the vigilant scrutiny of a constructivist intelligence determined to uproot and nip in the bud each and every platonist fancy of a concept _ external _ to the mathematical mind .
@xmath16 _ integrity _ is perhaps one of the most misunderstood terms in errett bishop s lexicon .
pourciau in his _ education _
@xcite appears to interpret it as an indictment of the ethics of the classical opposition . yet in his _ schizophrenia _ text , bishop merely muses : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ ... ] i keep coming back to the term `` integrity '' . @xcite
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ note that the period is in the original .
bishop describes _
integrity _ as the opposite of a syndrome he colorfully refers to as _ schizophrenia _ , characterized 1 . by a rejection of common sense in favor of formalism , 2 . by _ debasement of meaning _ ( see above ) , 3 . as well as by a list of other ills but _ excluding _ dishonesty .
now the root of @xmath17 is identical with that of _ integer _ ( see above ) , the bishopian ultimate foundation of analysis .
bishop s evocation of _ integrity _ may have been an innocent pun intended to allude to a healthy constructivist mindset , where the _ integers _ are uppermost.[multiblock footnote omitted ] @xmath16 _ law of excluded middle ( lem ) _ is the main source of the non - constructivities of classical mathematics . and footnote [ lpo ] for some examples . ]
every formalisation of _ intuitionistic logic _ excludes _ lem _ ; adding _ lem _ back again returns us to _ classical logic_. @xmath16 _ limited principle of omniscience ( lpo ) _ is a weak form of _ lem _ ( see above ) , involving _
lem_-like oracular abilities limited to the context of integer sequences . for a discussion of lpo . ]
the _ lpo _ is still unacceptable to a constructivist , but could have served as a basis for a _ meaningful _ dialog between brouwer and hilbert ( see @xcite ) , that could allegedly have changed the course of 20th century mathematics .
@xmath16 _ meaning _ is a favorite philosophic term in bishop s lexicon , necessarily preceding an investigation of _ truth _ in any coherent discussion . in bishop
s writing , the term _ meaning _ is routinely conflated with _ numerical meaning _ ( see below ) .
@xmath16 _ numerical meaning _ is the content of a theorem admitting a proof based on intuitionistic logic , and expressing computationally meaningful facts about the integers .
appears in footnote [ root ] . ]
the conflation of _ numerical meaning _ with _ meaning _ par excellence in bishop s writing , has the following two consequences : 1 .
it empowers the constructivist to sweep under the rug the distinction between pre - lem and post - lem numerical meaning , lending a marginal degree of plausibility to a dismissal of classical theorems which otherwise appear eminently coherent and meaningful ; for a discussion of the classical extreme value theorem and its lemless remains . ] and 2 .
it allows the constructivist to enlist the support of _ anti - realist _ philosophical schools of thought ( e.g. michael dummett ) in the theory of meaning , inspite of the apparent tension with bishop s otherwise _ realist _ declarations ( see entry _
realistic mathematics _ below ) .
@xmath16 _ peculiar pragmatic content _ is an expression of bishop s @xcite that was analyzed by billinge @xcite .
it connotes an alleged lack of empirical validity of classical mathematics , when classical results are merely _ inference tickets _
@xcite used in the deduction of other mathematical results .
@xmath16 _ realistic mathematics_. the dichotomy of `` realist '' _ versus _ `` idealist '' ( see above ) is the dichotomy of `` constructive '' _ versus _ `` classical '' mathematics , in bishop s lexicon .
there are two main narratives of the intuitionist insurrection , one _ anti - realist _ and one _ realist_. the issue is discussed in the next section .
the _ anti - realist _ narrative , mainly following michael dummett @xcite , traces the original sin of classical mathematics with _
lem _ , all the way back to aristotle.the entry under _ debasement of meaning _ in section [ glossary ] would read , accordingly , `` the classical opposition from aristotle to keisler '' ; see main text at footnote [ keisler1 ] . ]
the law of excluded middle ( see section [ glossary ] ) is the mathematical counterpart of geocentric cosmology ( alternatively , of phlogiston , see @xcite ) , slated for the dustbin of history.following kronecker and brouwer , dummett rejects actual infinity , at variance with bishop . ]
the anti - realist narrative dismisses the quine - putnam indispensability thesis ( see feferman ( * ? ? ?
* section iib ) ) on the grounds that a _ philosophy - first _ examination of first principles is the unique authority empowered to determine the correct way of doing mathematics.in hellman s view , `` any [ ... ] attempt to reinstate a ` first philosophical ' theory of meaning prior to all science is doomed '' @xcite .
what this appears to mean is that , while there can certainly be a philosophical notion of meaning before science , any attempt to _ prescribe _ standards of meaning _ prior _ to the actual practice of science , is _
doomed_. ] generally speaking , it is this narrative that seems to be favored by a number of philosophers of mathematics .
dummett opposes a truth - valued , bivalent semantics , namely the notion that truth is one thing and knowability another , on the grounds that it violates dummett s _ manifestation requirement _ , see shapiro @xcite .
the latter requirement , in the context of mathematics , is merely a _
restatement _ of the intuitionistic principle that truth is tantamount to verifiability ( necessitating a constructive interpretation of the quantifiers ) .
thus , an acceptance of dummett s manifestation requirement , leads to intuitionistic semantics and a rejection of lem . in his 1977 foundational text @xcite originating from 1973 lecture notes ,
dummett is frank about the source of his interest in the intuitionist / classical dispute in mathematics @xcite : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ this dispute bears a * strong resemblance * to other disputes over realism of one kind or another , that is , concerning various kinds of subject - matter ( or types of statement ) , including that over realism about the physical universe [ emphasis added authors ] _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ what dummett proceeds to say at this point , reveals the nature of his interest : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ but intuitionism represents the only sustained attempt by the opponents of a * realist view * to work out a coherent embodiment of their philosophical beliefs [ emphasis added
authors ] _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ what interests dummett here is his fight against the _ realist view_. what endears intuitionists to him , is the fact that they have succeeded where the phenomenalists have not @xcite : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ phenomenalists might have attained a greater success if they had made a remotely comparable effort to show in detail what consequences their interpretation of material - object statements would have for our employment of our language . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ however , dummett s conflation of the mathematical debate and the philosophical debate , could be challenged .
we hereby explicitly sidestep the debate opposing the realist ( as opposed to the super - realist , see w. tait @xcite ) position and the anti - realist position . on the other hand
, we observe that a defense of indispensability of mathematics would necessarily start by challenging dummett s `` manifestation '' .
more precisely , such a defense would have to start by challenging the extension of dummett s manifestation requirement , from the realm of philosophy to the realm of mathematics . while dummett chooses to pin the opposition to intuitionism , to a belief @xcite in an _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ interpretation of mathematical statements as referring to an independently existing and objective reality [ , ] _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ( i.e. a platonic world of mathematical entities ) , j. avigad @xcite memorably retorts as follows : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we do not need fairy tales about numbers and triangles prancing about in the realm of the abstracta.[multiblock footnote omitted ] _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ meanwhile , the _ realist _ narrative of the intuitionist insurrection appears to be more consistent with what bishop himself actually wrote . in his foundational essay , bishop expresses his position as follows : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ as pure mathematicians , we must decide whether we are playing a game , or whether our theorems describe an external reality @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the right answer , to bishop , is that they do describe an external reality .
the dichotomy of `` realist '' _ versus _ `` idealist '' is the dichotomy of `` constructive '' _ versus _ `` classical '' mathematics , in bishop s lexicon ( see entry under _
idealistic mathematics _ in section [ glossary ] ) .
bishop s ambition is to incorporate `` such mathematically oriented disciplines as physics '' @xcite as part of his constructive revolution , revealing a recognition , on his part , of the potency of the quine - putnam indispensability challenge .
category '' . ] n. kopell and g. stolzenberg , close associates of bishop , published a three - page _ commentary _
@xcite following bishop s _ crisis _ text .
their note places the original sin with _ lem _ at around 1870 ( rather than greek antiquity ) , when the `` flourishing empirico - inductive tradition '' began to be replaced by the `` strictly logico - deductive conception of pure mathematics '' .
kopell and stolzenberg do nt hesitate to compare the _ empirico - inductive tradition _ in mathematics prior to 1870 , to physics , in the following terms @xcite : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ mathematical ] theories were theories about the phenomena , just as in a physical theory .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ similar views have been expressed by d. bridges @xcite , as well as heyting @xcite .
w. tait @xcite argues that , unlike intuitionism , constructive mathematics is part of classical mathematics . in fact , it was frege s revolutionary logic @xcite ( see gillies @xcite ) and other foundational developments that created a new language and a new paradigm , transforming mathematical foundations into fair game for further investigation , experimentation , and criticism , including those of constructivist type .
the philosophical dilemmas in the anti - lem sector discussed in this section are a function of the nominalist nature of its scientific goals .
a critique of its scientific methods appears in the next section .
we would like to analyze more specifically the constructivist dilemma with regard to the following two items : 1 . the extreme value theorem , and 2 .
the hawking - penrose singularity theorem .
concerning ( 1 ) , note that a constructive treatment of the extreme value theorem ( evt ) by troelstra and van dalen @xcite brings to the fore the instability of the ( classically unproblematic ) maximum by actually constructing a counterexample .
such a counterexample relies on assuming that the principle @xmath18 fails .. ] this is a valuable insight , if viewed as a companion to classical mathematics .
if viewed as an alternative , we are forced to ponder the consequences of the loss of the evt .
kronecker is sometimes thought of as the spiritual father of the brouwer / bishop / dummett tendency .
kronecker was active at a time when the field of mathematics was still rather compartmentalized .
thus , he described a 3-way partition thereof into ( a ) analysis , ( b ) geometry , and ( c ) mechanics ( presumably meaning mathematical physics ) .
kronecker proceeded to state that it is only the analytic one - third of mathematics that is amenable to a constructivisation in terms of the natural numbers that `` were given to us , etc . '' , but readily conceded that such an approach is inapplicable in the remaining two - thirds , geometry and physics.see boniface and schappacher @xcite .
] nowadays mathematicians adopt a more unitary approach to the field , and kronecker s partition seems provincial , but in fact his caution was vindicated by later developments , and can even be viewed as visionary . consider a field such as general relativity , which in a way is a synthesis of kronecker s remaining two - thirds , namely , geometry and physics .
versions of the extreme value theorem are routinely exploited here , in the form of the existence of solutions to variational principles , such as geodesics , be it spacelike , timelike , or lightlike . at a deeper level , s.p .
novikov @xcite wrote about hilbert s meaningful contribution to relativity theory , in the form of discovering a lagrangian for einstein s equation for spacetime .
hilbert s deep insight was to show that general relativity , too , can be written in lagrangian form , which is a satisfying conceptual insight .
a radical constructivist s reaction would be to dismiss the material discussed in the previous paragraph as relying on lem ( needed for the evt ) , hence lacking numerical meaning , and therefore meaningless .
in short , radical constructivism ( as opposed to the liberal variety ) adopts a theory of meaning amounting to an ostrich effectsuch an effect is comparable to a traditional educator s attitude toward students nonstandard conceptions studied by ely @xcite , see main text in section [ seven ] around footnote [ ostrich2 ] .
] as far as certain significant scientific insights are concerned . a quarter century ago , m. beeson already acknowledged constructivism s problem with the calculus of variations in the following terms : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ calculus of variations is a vast and important field which lies right on the frontier between constructive and non - constructive mathematics @xcite . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ an even more striking example is the hawking - penrose singularity theorem , whose foundational status was explored by hellman @xcite .
the theorem relies on fixed point theorems and therefore is also constructively unacceptable , at least in its present form .
however , the singularity theorem does provide important scientific insight . roughly speaking
, one of the versions of the theorem asserts that certain natural conditions on curvature ( that are arguably satisfied experimentally in the visible universe ) force the existence of a singularity when the solution is continued backward in time , resulting in a kind of a theoretical justification of the big bang .
such an insight can not be described as `` meaningless '' by any reasonable standard of meaning preceding nominalist commitments .
this section analyzes a nominalistic reconstruction successfully implemented at the end of the 19th century by cantor , dedekind , and weierstrass .
the rigorisation of analysis they accomplished went hand - in - hand with the elimination of infinitesimals ; indeed , the latter accomplishment is often viewed as a fundamental one .
we would like to state from the outset that the main issue here is not a nominalistic attitude on the part of our three protagonists themselves .
such an attitude is only clearly apparent in the case of cantor ( see below ) . rather , we argue that the historical context in the 1870s favored the acceptance of their reconstruction by the mathematical community , due to a certain philosophical disposition .
some historical background is in order .
as argued by d. sherry @xcite , george berkeley s 1734 polemical essay @xcite conflated a logical criticism and a metaphysical criticism.robinson distinguished between the two criticisms in the following terms : `` the vigorous attack directed by berkeley against the foundations of the calculus in the forms then proposed is , in the first place , a brilliant exposure of their logical inconsistencies . but in criticizing infinitesimals of all kinds , english or continental , berkeley also quotes with approval a passage in which locke rejects the actual infinite ... it is in fact not surprising that a philosopher in whose system perception plays the central role , should have been unwilling to accept infinitary entities '' @xcite . ] in the intervening centuries , mathematicians have not distinguished between the two criticisms sufficiently , and grew increasingly suspicious of infinitesimals .
the metaphysical criticism stems from the 17th century doctrine that each theoretical entity must have an empirical counterpart / referent before such an entity can be used meaningfully ; the use of infinitesimals of course would fly in the face of such a doctrine .. ] today we no longer accept the 17th century doctrine .
however , in addition to the metaphysical criticism , berkeley made a poignant logical criticism , pointing out a paradox in the definition of the derivative .
the seeds of an approach to resolving the logical paradox were already contained in the work of fermat , .
robinson modified the definition of the derivative by introducing the standard part function , which we refer to as the fermat - robinson standard part in sections [ rival1 ] and [ rival2 ] . ] but it was robinson who ironed out the remaining logical wrinkle .
thus , mathematicians throughout the 19th century were suspicious of infinitesimals because of a lingering influence of 17th century doctrine , but came to reject them because of what they felt were logical contradictions ; these two aspects combined into a nominalistic attitude that caused the triumvirate reconstruction to spread like wildfire . the tenor of hobson s remarks , .
] as indeed of a majority of historians of mathematics , is that weierstrass s fundamental accomplishment was the elimination of infinitesimals from foundational discourse in analysis .
infinitesimals were replaced by arguments relying on real inequalities and multiple - quantifier logical formulas .
the triumvirate transformation had the effect of a steamroller flattening a b - continuum .
] into an a - continuum .
even the ardent enthusiasts of weierstrassian epsilontics recognize that its practical effect on mathematical discourse has been appalling " ; thus , j. pierpont wrote as follows in 1899 : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the mathematician of to - day , trained in the school of weierstrass , is fond of speaking of his science as ` die absolut klare wissenschaft . ' any attempts to drag in _ metaphysical speculations _
are resented with _
indignant energy_. with almost _ painful emotions _ he looks back at the sorry mixture of metaphysics and mathematics which was so common in the last century and at the beginning of this @xcite [ emphasis added authors ] . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ pierpont concludes : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the analysis of to - day is indeed a transparent science .
built up on the simple notion of number , its truths are the most solidly established in the whole range of human knowledge .
it is , however , not to be overlooked that the price paid for this clearness is _ appalling _ , it is total separation from the world of our senses @xcite [ emphasis added authors ] . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ it is instructive to explore what form the indignant energy " referred to by pierpont took in practice , and what kind of rhetoric accompanies the `` painful emotions '' .
a reader attuned to 19th century literature will not fail to recognize _ infinitesimals _ as the implied target of pierpont s epithet metaphysical speculations " . thus , cantor _ published _ a `` proof - sketch '' of a claim to the effect that the notion of an infinitesimal is inconsistent . by this time , several detailed constructions of non - archimedean systems had appeared , notably by stolz and du bois - reymond . when stolz published a defense of his work , arguing that technically speaking cantor s criticism does not apply to his system , cantor responded by artful innuendo aimed at undermining the credibility of his opponents . at no point did cantor vouchsafe to address their publications themselves . in his 1890 letter to veronese ,
cantor specifically referred to the work of stolz and du bois - reymond .
cantor refers to their work on non - archimedean systems as not merely an abomination " , but a self contradictory and completely useless " one .
p. ehrlich @xcite analyzes the errors in cantor s `` proof '' and documents his rhetoric .
the effect on the university classroom has been pervasive . in an emotionally charged atmosphere ,
students of calculus today are warned against taking the apparent ratio @xmath19 literally . by the time one reaches the chain rule @xmath20 , the awkward contorsions of an obstinate denial are palpable throughout the spectrum of the undergraduate textbooks .. ] who invented the real number system ? according to van der waerden , simon stevin s _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ general notion of a real number was accepted , tacitly or explicitly , by all later scientists @xcite . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ d. fearnley - sander writes that _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the modern concept of real number [ ... ] was essentially achieved by simon stevin , around 1600 , and was thoroughly assimilated into mathematics in the following two centuries @xcite . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ d. fowler points out that _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ stevin [ ... ] was a thorough - going arithmetizer : he published , in 1585 , the first popularization of decimal fractions in the west [ ... ] ; in 1594 , he desribed an algorithm for finding the decimal expansion of the root of any polynomial , the same algorithm we find later in cauchy s proof of the intermediate value theorem @xcite . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the algorithm is discussed in more detail in ( * ? ? ?
* , p. 475 - 476 ) .
unlike cauchy , who _ halves _ the interval at each step , stevin subdivides the interval into _ ten _ equal parts , resulting in a gain of a new decimal digit of the solution at every iteration of the algorithm . at variance with these historical judgments , the mathematical community tends overwhelmingly to award the credit for constructing the real number system to the great triumvirate , for the origin of this expression . ] in appreciation of the successful extirpation of infinitesimals as a byproduct of the weierstrassian epsilontic formulation of analysis . to illustrate the nature of such a reconstruction , consider cauchy s notion of continuity . h. freudenthal notes that `` cauchy invented our notion of continuity '' @xcite .
cauchy s starting point is a description of perceptual continuity of a function in terms of `` varying by imperceptible degrees '' .
such a turn of phrase occurs both in his letter to coriolis of 1837 , and in his 1853 text @xcite .
cauchy transforms perceptual continuity into a mathematical notion by exploiting his conception of an infinitesimal as being generated by a null sequence ( see @xcite ) . both in 1821 and in 1853
, cauchy defines continuity of @xmath21 in terms of an infinitesimal @xmath22-increment resulting in an infinitesimal change in @xmath23 .
the well - known nominalistic residue of the perceptual definition ( a residue that dominates our classrooms ) would have @xmath24 be continuous at @xmath22 if for every positive epsilon there exists a positive delta such that if @xmath25 is less than delta then @xmath26 is less than epsilon , namely : @xmath27 lord kelvin s technician , wishing to exploit the notion of continuity in a research paper , is unlikely to be interested in 4-quantifier definitions thereof .
regardless of the answer to such a question , the revolutionary nature of the triumvirate reconstruction of the foundations of analysis is evident .
if one accepts the thesis that elimination of ontological entities called infinitesimals " does constitute a species of nominalism , then the triumvirate recasting of analysis was a nominalist project .
we will deal with cantor and dedekind in more detail in section [ cd ] .
cantor is on record describing infinitesimals as the cholera bacillus of mathematics " in a letter dated 12 december 1893 , quoted in meschkowski @xcite ( see also dauben @xcite and @xcite ) .
cantor went as far as publishing a purported proof " of their logical inconsistency , as discussed in section [ triumvirat ] .
cantor may have extended numbers both in terms of the complete ordered field of real numbers and his theory of infinite cardinals ; however , he also passionately believed that he had not only given a logical foundation to real analysis , but also simultaneously eliminated infinitesimals ( the cholera bacillus ) .
dedekind , while admitting that there is no evidence that the true " continuum indeed possesses the property of completeness he championed ( see m. moore @xcite ) , at the same time formulated his definition of what came to be known as dedekind cuts , in such a way as to rule out infinitesimals .
s. feferman describes dedekind s construction of an complete ordered line @xmath28 as follows : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ dedekind s construction of such an @xmath29 is obtained by taking it to consist of the rational numbers together with the numbers corresponding to all those cuts @xmath30 in @xmath31 for which @xmath32 has no largest element and @xmath33 has no least element , ordered in correspondence to the ordering of cuts @xmath34 when @xmath32 is a proper subset of @xmath35 .
dedekind himself spoke of this construction of @xmath36 a[s ] individual cuts in @xmath31 for which @xmath32 has no largest element and @xmath33 no least element as _ the creation of an irrational number _ , though he did not identify the numbers themselves with those cuts @xcite . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in this way the `` gappiness '' of the rationals is overcome , in dedekind s terminology . now requiring that an element of the continuum should induce a partition of @xmath31 does not yet rule out infinitesimals
however , requiring that a given partition of @xmath31 should correspond to a _
unique _ element of the continuum , does have the effect of ruling out infinitesimals . in the context of an infinitesimal - enriched continuum ,
it is clear that a pair of quantities in the cluster ( halo ) infinitely close to @xmath37 , for example , will define the _ same _ partition of the rationals .
therefore the clause of only one " forces a collapse of the infinitesimal cluster to a single quantity , in this case @xmath37 . was rigor linked to the elimination of infinitesimals ?
e. hobson in his retiring presidential address @xcite in 1902 summarized the advances in analysis over the previous century , and went on explicitly to make a connection between the foundational accomplishments in analysis , on the one hand , and the elimination of infinitesimals , on the other , by pointing out that an equivalence class defining a real number `` is of such a character that no use is made in it of infinitesimals , '' for more details on hobson . ] suggesting that hobson viewed them as logically inconsistent ( perhaps following cantor or berkeley ) .
the matter of rigor will be analyzed in more detail in the next section .
in criticizing the nominalistic aspect of the weierstrassian elimination of infinitesimals , does one neglect the mathematical reasons why this was considered desirable ? the stated goal of the triumvirate program was mathematical rigor .
let us examine the meaning of mathematical rigor . conceivably rigor could be interpreted in at least the following four ways , not all
of which we endorse : 1 . it is a shibboleth that identifies the speaker as belonging to a clan of professional mathematicians ; 2 .
it represents the idea that as the field develops , its practitioners attain greater and more conceptual understanding of key issues , and are less prone to error ; 3 .
it represents the idea that a search for greater correctness in analysis inevitably led weierstrass to epsilontics in the 1870s ; 4 .
it refers to the establishment of ultimate foundations for mathematics by cantor , eventually explicitly expressed in axiomatic form by zermelo and fraenkel.it would be interesting to investigate the role of the zermelo
frankel axiomatisation of set theory in cementing the nominalistic disposition we are analyzing .
keisler points out that `` the second- and higher - order theories of the real line depend on the underlying universe of set theory [ ... ] thus the _ properties _ of the real line are not uniquely determined by the axioms of set theory '' @xcite [ emphasis in the original the authors ] .
he adds : `` a set theory which was not strong enough to prove the unique existence of the real line would not have gained acceptance as a mathematical foundation '' @xcite .
edward nelson @xcite has developed an alternative axiomatisation more congenial to infinitesimals . ]
item ( 1 ) may be pursued by a fashionable academic in the social sciences , but does not get to the bottom of the issue .
meanwhile , item ( 2 ) could apply to any exact science , and does not involve a commitment as to which route the development of mathematics may have taken .
item ( 2 ) could be supported by scientists in and outside of mathematics alike , as it does not entail a commitment to a specific destination or ultimate goal of scientific devepment as being pre - determined and intrinsically inevitable . on the other hand ,
the actual position of a majority of professional mathematicians today corresponds to items ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) .
the crucial element present in ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) and absent in ( 2 ) is the postulation of a specific outcome , believed to be the inevitable result of the development of the discipline .
challenging such a _ belief _ appears to be a radical proposition in the eyes of a typical professional mathematician , but not in the eyes of scientists in related fields of the exact sciences .
it is therefore particularly puzzling that ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) should be accepted without challenge by a majority of historians of mathematics , who tend to toe the line on the mathematicians _ belief_. it is therefore necessary to examine such a belief , which , as we argue , stems from a particular philosophical disposition akin to nominalism .
could mathematical analysis have followed a different path of development ? in an intriguing text published a decade ago , pourciau @xcite examines the foundational crisis of the 1920s and the brouwer
hilbert controversy , and argues that brouwer s view may have prevailed had brouwer been more of an@xmath38 errett bishop .. ] while we are sceptical as to pourciau s main conclusions , the unmistakable facts are as follows : 1 .
a real struggle did take place ; 2 .
some of the most brilliant minds at the time did side with brouwer , at least for a period of time ( e.g. , hermann weyl ) ; 3 .
the battle was won by hilbert not by mathematical means alone but also political ones , such as maneuvering brouwer out of a key editorial board ; 4 .
while retroactively one can offer numerous reasons why hilbert s victory might have been inevitable , this was not at all obvious at the time .
we now leap back a century , and consider a key transitional figure , namely cauchy . in 1821 ,
cauchy defined continuity of @xmath21 in terms of `` an infinitesimal @xmath22-increment corresponding to an infinitesimal @xmath23-increment . '' for more details on cauchy s definition . ]
many a practicing mathematician , brought up on an alleged `` cauchy - weierstrass @xmath39 '' tale , will be startled by such a revelation .
the textbooks and the history books routinely obfuscate the nature of cauchy s definition of continuity .
fifty years before weierstrass , cauchy performed a hypostatisation by encapsulating a variable quantity tending to zero , into an individual / atomic entity called `` an infinitesimal '' . was the naive traditional definition " of the infinitesimal blatantly self - contradictory ?
we argue that it was not .
cauchy s definition in terms of null sequences is a reasonable definition , and one that connects well with the sequential approach of the ultrapower construction . for more details . ]
mathematicians viewed infinitesimals with deep suspicion due in part to a conflation of two separate criticisms , the logical one and the metaphysical one , by berkeley , see sherry @xcite .
thus , the emphasis on the elimination of infinitesimals in the traditional account of the history of analysis is misplaced .
could analysis could have developed on the basis of infinitesimals ? .
] continuity , as all fundamental notions of analysis , can be defined , and were defined , by cauchy in terms of infinitesimals .
epsilontics could have played a secondary role of clarifying whatever technical situations were too awkward to handle otherwise , but arguably they need nt have _ replaced _ infinitesimals .
as far as the issue of rigor is concerned , it needs to be recognized that gauss and dirichlet published virtually error - free mathematics before weierstrassian epsilontics , while weierstrass himself was not protected by epsilontics from publishing an erroneous paper by s. kovalevskaya ( the error was found by volterra , see @xcite ) .
as a scientific discipline develops , its practitioners gain a better understanding of the conceptual issues , which helps them avoid errors . but
assigning a singular , oracular , and benevolent role in this to epsilontics is philosophically naive . the proclivity to place
the blame for errors on infinitesimals betrays a nominalistic disposition aimed agaist the _ ghosts of departed quantities _ , already dubbed `` _ charlatanerie _ '' by dalembert @xcite in 1754 .
the following seven questions were formulated by r. hersh , who also motivated the author to present the material of section [ hersh ] , as well as that of section [ six ] . was a nominalistic viewpoint motivating the triumvirate project ?
we argue that the answer is affirmative , and cite two items as evidence : 1 .
dedekind s cuts and the essence of continuity " , and 2 .
cantor s tooth - and - nail fight against infinitesimals .
concerning ( 1 ) , mathematicians widely believed that dedekind discovered such an essence .
what is meant by the essence of continuity in this context is the idea that a pair of cuts " on the rationals are identical if and only if the pair of numbers defining them are equal . now
the if " part is unobjectionable , but the almost reflexive only if " part following it has the effect of a steamroller flattening the b - continuum . ] into an a - continuum .
namely , it collapses each monad ( halo , cluster ) to a point , since a pair of infinitely close ( adequal ) points necessarily define the same cut on the rationals ( see section [ cd ] for more details ) .
the fact that the steamroller effect was gladly accepted as a near - axiom is a reflection of a nominalistic attitude .
concerning ( 2 ) , cantor not only published a proof - sketch " of the non - existence of infinitesimals , he is on record calling them an abomination " as well as the cholera bacillus " of mathematics .
when stolz meekly objected that cantor s proof " does not apply to his system , cantor responded by the abomination " remark ( see section [ cd ] for more details ) .
now cantor s proof contains an error that was exhastively analyzed by ehrlich @xcite .
as it stands , it would `` prove '' the non - existence of the surreals !
incidentally , ehrlich recently proved that
maximal " surreals are isomorphic to maximal " hyperreals .
can cantor s attitude be considered as a philosophical predisposition to the detriment of infinitesimals ?
it has been written that cauchy s concern with clarifying the foundations of calculus was motivated by the need to teach it to french military cadets .
cauchy did have some tensions with the management of the _ ecole polytechnique _ over the teaching of infinitesimals between 1814 and 1820 . in around 1820
he started using them in earnest in both his textbooks and his research papers , and continued using them throughout his life , well past his teaching stint at the _
ecole_. thus , in his 1853 text @xcite he reaffirms the infinitesimal definition of continuity he gave in his 1821 textbook @xcite .
does nt reasoning by infinitesimals require a deep intuition that is beyond the reach of most students ?
kathleen sullivan s study @xcite from 1976 shows that students enrolled in sections based on keisler s textbook end up having a better conceptual grasp of the notions of calculus than control groups following the standard approach .
two years ago , i taught infinitesimal calculus to a group of 25 freshmen .
i also had to train the ta who was new to the material . according to persistent reports from the ta
, the students have never been so excited about learning calculus . on the contrary , it is the multiple - quantifier weierstrassian epsilontic logical stunts that our students are dressed to perform ( on pretense of being taught infinitesimal calculus ) that are beyond their reach . in an ironic commentary on the nominalistic ethos reigning in our departments , not only
was i relieved of my teaching this course the following year , but the course number itself was eliminated .
it may true that epsilontics " is in practice repugnant to many students .
but the question is whether an issue that is really a matter of technical mathematics related to pedagogy is being misleadingly presented as a question of high metaphysics
. answer .
berkeley turned this into a metaphysical debate .
generations of mathematicians have grown up thinking of it as a metaphysical debate .
such a characterisation is precisely what we contest .
is nt a positive number smaller than all positive numbers " self - contradictory ? is a phrase such as i am smaller than myself " , intelligible ?
both carnot and cauchy say that an infinitesimal is generated by a variable quantity that becomes smaller than any fixed quantity .
no contradiction here .
the otherwise excellent study by ehrlich @xcite contains a curious slip with regard to poisson .
poisson describes infinitesimals as being `` less than any given magnitude of the same nature '' @xcite ( the quote is reproduced in boyer @xcite ) .
ehrlich inexplicably omits the crucial modifier `` given '' when quoting poisson in footnote 133 on page 76 of @xcite .
based on the incomplete quote , ehrlich proceeds to agree with veronese s assessment ( of poisson ) that [ t]his proposition evidently contains a contradiction in terms " @xcite .
our assessment is that poisson s definition is in fact perfectly consistent .
infinitesimals were one thorny issue . did nt it take the modern theory of formal languages to untangle that ?
not exactly .
a long tradition of technical work in non - archimedean continua starts with stolz and du bois - reymond , levi - civita , hilbert , and borel , see ehrlich @xcite .
the tradition continues uninterruptedly until hewitt constructs the hyperreals in 1948 .
then came o s theorem whose consequence is a transfer principle , which is a mathematical implementation of the heuristic law of continuity " of leibniz ( what s true in the finite domain should remain true in the infinite domain " ) .
what o and robinson untangled was the transfer principle .
non - archimedean systems had a long history prior to these developments .
there is still a pedagogical issue .
i do understand that keisler s calculus book is teachable .
but this says nothing about the difficulty of teaching calculus in terms of infinitesimals back around 1800 .
keisler has robinson s non - standard analysis available , as a way to make sense of infinitesimals .
cauchy did not .
do you believe that cauchy used a definition of infinitesimal in terms of a null sequence of rationals ( or reals ) in teaching introductory calculus ?
the historical issue about cauchy is an interesting one .
most of his course notes from the period 1814 - 1820 have been lost .
his predecessor at the _ ecole polytechnique _ , l. carnot , defined infinitesimals exactly the same way as cauchy did , but somehow is typically viewed by historians as belonging to the old school as far as infinitesimals are concerned ( and criticized for his own version of the `` cancellation of errors '' argument originating with berkeley ) . as far as cauchy
s textbooks from 1821 onward indicate , he declares at the outset that infinitesimals are an indispensable foundational tool , defines them in terms of null sequences ( more specifically , a variable quantity becomes an infinitesimal " ) , defines continuity in terms of infinitesimals , defines his dirac " delta function in terms of infinitesimals ( see @xcite ) , defines infinitesimals of arbitrary _ real _ order in @xcite , anticipating later work by stolz , du bois - reymond , and others . the following eight questions were posed by martin davis . how would you answer the query : how do you define a
null sequence " ?
are nt you back to epsilons ?
not necessarily .
one could define it , for example , in terms of `` only finitely many terms outside each given separation from zero '' .
while epsilontics has important applications , codifying the notion of a null sequence is not one of them .
epsilontics is helpful when it comes to characterizing a cauchy sequence , _ if one does not yet know the limiting value_. if one does know the limiting value , as in the case of a null sequence , a multiple - quantifier epsilontic formulation is no clearer than saying that all the terms eventually get arbitrarily small . to be more specific , if one describes a cauchy sequence by saying that `` terms eventually get arbitrarily close to each other '' , the ambiguity can lead and has led to errors , though not in cauchy ( the sequences are rightfully named after him as he was aware of the trap ) .
such an ambiguity is just not there as far as null sequences are concerned .
giving an epsilontic definition of a null sequence does not increase understanding and does not decrease the likelihood of error .
a null sequence is arguably a notion that s no more complex than multiple - quantifier epsilontics , just as the natural numbers are no more complex than the set - theoretic definition thereof in terms of @xmath40 which requires infinitely many set - theoretic types to make the point .
is nt a natural number a more primitive notion ?
you evoke cauchy s use of variable quantities .
but whatever is a
variable quantity " ?
the concept of variable quantity was not clearly defined by mathematicians from leibniz and lhopital onwards , and is today considered a historical curiosity .
cauchy himself sometimes seems to think they take discrete values ( in his 1821 text @xcite ) and sometimes continuous ( in his 1823 text @xcite ) .
many historians agree that in 1821 they were discrete sequences , and cauchy himself gives explicit examples of sequences .
now it is instructive to compare such variable quantities to the procedures advocated by the triumvirate .
in fact , the approach can be compared to cantor s construction of the real numbers .
a real number is a cauchy sequence of rational numbers , modulo an equivalence relation .
a sequence , which is not an individual / atomic entity , comes to be viewed as an atomic entity by a process which in triumvirate lexicon is called an equivalence relation , but in much older philosophical terminology is called _ hypostatisation_. in education circles , researchers tend to use terms such as _ encapsulation _ , _ procept _ , and _ reification _ , instead .
as you know , the ultrapower construction is a way of hypostatizing a hyperreal out of sequences of reals . as far as cauchy s
competing views of a variable quantity as discrete ( in 1821 ) or continuous ( in 1823 ) , they lead to distinct implementations of a b - continuum in hewitt ( 1948 ) , when a `` continuous '' version of the ultrapower construction was used , and in luxemburg ( 1962 ) , where the discrete version was used ( a more recent account of the latter is in goldblatt @xcite ) .
is nt the notion of a variable quantity a pernicious notion that makes time an essential part of mathematics ?
i think you take zeno s paradoxes too seriously .
i personally do nt think there is anything wrong with involving time in mathematics .
it has not led to any errors as far as i know , _ pace _
zeno . given what
relativity has taught us about time , is it a good idea to involve time in mathematics ?
what did relativity teach us about time that would make us take time out of mathematics ?
that time is relative ? but you may be confusing metaphysics with mathematics .
time that s being used in mathematics is not an exact replica of physical time .
we may still be influenced by 17th century doctrine according to which every theoretical entity must have an empirical counterpart / referent .
this is why berkeley was objecting to infinitesimals ( his metaphysical criticism anyway ) .
i would put time back in mathematics the same way i would put infinitesimals back in mathematics .
neither concept is under any obligation of corresponding to an empirical referent .
did nt the triumvirate show us how to prove the existence of a complete ordered field ?
simon stevin had already made major strides in defining the real numbers , represented by decimals .
some essential work needed to be done , such as the fact that the usual operations are well defined .
this was done by dedekind , see fowler @xcite . but stevin numbers themselves were several centuries older , even though they go under the soothing name of numbers so _ real _ .. ] my nsa book @xcite does it by forming the quotient of the ring of finite hyper - rational numbers by the ideal of infinitesimals@xmath38 the remarkable fact is that this construction is already anticipated by kstner ( a contemporary of euler s ) in the following terms : `` if one partitions @xmath41 without end into smaller and smaller parts , and takes larger and larger collections of such little parts , one gets closer and closer to the irrational number without ever attaining it '' .
kstner concludes : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ `` therefore one can view it as an infinite collection of infinitely small parts '' @xcite , cited by cousquer @xcite . in section [ rival2 ] . ]
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ @xmath38 but that construction was not available to the earlier generations .
but stevin numbers were .
they kept on teaching analysis in france throughout the 1870s without any need for constructing " something that had already been around for a century before leibniz , see discussion in laugwitz @xcite .
are nt you conflating the problem of rigorous foundation with how to teach calculus to beginners ?
as far as rigorous foundations are concerned , alternative foundations to zf have been developed that are more congenial to infinitesimals , such as edward nelson s @xcite .
mathematicians are accustomed to thinking of zf as the foundations " .
it needs to be recognized that this is a philosophical assumption .
the assumption can be a reflection of a nominalist mindframe .
the example of a useful application of infinitesimals analyzed at the end of this section is quite elementary .
a more advanced example is the elegant construction of the haar measure in terms of counting infinitesimal neighborhoods , see goldblatt @xcite .
even more advanced examples such as the proof of the invariant subspace conjecture are explained in your book @xcite . for an application to the bolzmann equation ,
see arkeryd @xcite . as a concrete example of what consequences
a correction of the nominalistic triumvirate attitude would entail in the teaching of the calculus , consider the problem of the _ unital evaluation _ of the decimal @xmath42 , i.e. , its evaluation to the _ unit _ value @xmath41 .
students are known overwhelmingly to believe that the number @xmath43 falls short of @xmath41 by an infinitesimal amount .
a typical instructor believes such student intuitions to be erroneous , and seeks to inculcate the unital evaluation of @xmath44 .
an alternative approach was proposed by ely @xcite and katz & katz @xcite . instead of refuting student intuitions
, an instructor could build upon them to calculate the derivative of @xmath45 at @xmath46 by choosing an infinitesimal @xmath47 and showing that @xmath48 is infinitely close ( adequal ) to @xmath4 , yielding the desired value without either epsilontics , estimates , or limits , see figure [ jul10 ] . here
@xmath44 is interpreted as an extended decimal string with an infinite hypernatural s worth of @xmath49s , see @xcite . instead of building upon student intuition
, a typical calculus course seeks to flatten it into the ground by steamrolling the b - continuum into the a - continuum , see katz and katz @xcite .
a nominalist view of what constitutes an allowable number system has produced an ostrich effectsuch an effect is comparable to a constructivist s reaction to the challenge of meaningful applications of a post - lem variety , see main text in section [ hersh ] around footnote [ ostrich1 ] . ] whereby mathematics educators around the globe have failed to recognize the legitimacy , and potency , of students nonstandard conceptions of @xmath42 , see ely @xcite for details .
this section analyzes the reconstruction of cauchy s foundational work in analysis usually associated with j. grabiner , and has its sources in the work of c. boyer .
a critical analysis of the traditional approach may be found in hourya benis sinaceur s article @xcite from 1973 . to place such work in a historical perspective , a minimal chronology of commentators on cauchy s foundational work in analysis would have to mention f. klein s observation in 1908 that _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ since cauchy s time , the words _ infinitely small _
are used in modern textbooks in a somewhat changed sense .
one never says , namely , that a quantity _ is _ infinitely small , but rather that it _ becomes _ infinitely small
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ indeed , cauchy s starting point in defining an infinitesimal is a null sequence ( i.e. , sequence tending to zero ) , and he repeatedly refers to such a null sequence as _ becoming _ an infinitesimal . p. jourdain s detailed 1913 study @xcite of cauchy is characterized by a total _ absence _ of any claim to the effect that cauchy may have based his notion of infinitesimal , on limits .
c. boyer quotes cauchy s definition of continuity as follows : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the function @xmath24 is continuous within given limits if between these limits an infinitely small increment @xmath50 in the variable @xmath22 produces always an infinitely small increment , @xmath51 , in the function itself @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ next , boyer proceeds to _ interpret _ cauchy s definition of continuity as follows : `` the expressions infinitely small _ are here to be understood _ [ ... ] in terms of [ ... ] limits : i.e. , @xmath52 is continuous within an interval if the limit of the variable @xmath52 as @xmath22 approaches @xmath44 is @xmath53 , for any value of @xmath44 within this interval '' [ emphasis added authors ] .
boyer feels that infinitesimals _ are to be understood _ in terms of limits .
or perhaps they are to be understood otherwise ? in 1967 , a. robinson discussed the place of infinitesimals in cauchy s work .
he pointed out that `` the assumption that [ infinitesimals ] satisfy the same laws as the ordinary numbers , which was stated explicitly by leibniz , was rejected by cauchy as unwarranted '' . yet , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ cauchy s professed opinions in these matters notwithstanding , he did in fact treat infinitesimals habitually as if they were ordinary numbers and satisfied the familiar rules of arithmetic @xcite , @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ t. koetsier remarked that , had cauchy wished to extend the domain of his functions to include infinitesimals , he would no doubt have mentioned how exactly the functions are to be so extended . beyond the observation that cauchy did , in fact ,
make it clear that such an extension is to be carried out term - by - term , at it by applying @xmath24 to each term in the sequence .
brting @xcite analyzes cauchy s use of the particular sequence @xmath54 in @xcite . ]
koetsier s question prompts a similar query : had cauchy wished to base his calculus on limits , he would no doubt have mentioned something about such a foundational stance . instead , cauchy emphasized that in founding analysis he was unable to avoid elaborating the fundamental properties of _ infinitely small quantities _ , see @xcite .
no mention of a foundational role of limits is anywhere to be found in cauchy , unlike his would - be modern interpreters .
l. sad _ et al _ have pursued this matter in detail in @xcite , arguing that what cauchy had in mind was a prototype of an ultrapower construction , where the equivalence class of a null sequence indeed produces an infinitesimal , in a suitable set - theoretic framework .. ] to summarize , a post - jourdain nominalist reconstruction of cauchy s infinitesimals , originating no later than boyer , reduces them to a weierstrassian notion of limit . to use burgess terminology borrowed from linguistics , the boyer - grabiner interpretation _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ becomes the hypothesis that certain _ noun phrases _ [ in the present case , infinitesimals ] in the surface structure are without counterpart in the deep structure @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ meanwhile , a rival school of thought places cauchy s continuum firmly in the line of infinitesimal - enriched continua .
the ongoing debate between rival visions of cauchy s continuum echoes felix klein s sentiment reproduced above.see discussion of klein in the main text around footnote [ klein ] .
the two rival views of cauchy s infinitesimals have been pursued by historians , mathematicians , and philosophers , alike .
the bibliography in the subject is vast .
the most detailed statement of boyer s position may be found in grabiner @xcite .
robinson s perspective was developed most successfully by d. laugwitz @xcite in 1989 , and by k. brting @xcite in 2007 . ]
viewed through the lens of the dichotomy introduced by burgess , it appears that the traditional boyer - grabiner view is best described as a hermeneutic , rather than revolutionary , nominalistic reconstruction of cauchy s foundational work .
cauchy s definition of continuity in terms of infinitesimals has been a source of an on - going controversy , which provides insight into the nominalist nature of the boyer - grabiner reconstruction .
many historians have interpreted cauchy s definition as a proto - weierstrassian definition of continuity in terms of limits .
thus , smithies ( * ? ? ?
* , footnote 20 ) cites the _ page _ in cauchy s book where cauchy gave the infinitesimal definition , but goes on to claim that the concept of _ limit _ was cauchy s `` essential basis '' for his concept of continuity @xcite .
smithies looked in cauchy , saw the infinitesimal definition , and went on to write in his paper that he saw a limit definition .
such automated translation has been prevalent at least since boyer @xcite .
smithies cites chapter and verse in cauchy where the latter gives an infinitesimal definition of continuity , and proceeds to claim that cauchy gave a modern one .
such awkward contortions are a trademark of a nominalist . in the next section
, we will examine the methodology of nominalistic cauchy scholarship .
the view of the history of analysis from the 1670s to the 1870s as a 2-century triumphant march toward the yawning heights of the rigor of weierstrassian epsilontics has permeated the very language mathematicians speak today , making an alternative account nearly unthinkable .
a majority of historians have followed suit , though some truly original thinkers differed .
these include c. s. peirce , felix klein , n. n. luzin @xcite , hans freudenthal , robinson , lakatos @xcite , laugwitz , teixeira @xcite , and brting @xcite .
meanwhile , j. grabiner offered the following reflection on the subject of george berkeley s criticism of infinitesimal calculus : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ s]ince an adequate response to berkeley s objections would have involved recognizing that an equation involving limits is a shorthand expression for a sequence of inequalities a subtle and difficult idea no eighteenth century analyst gave a fully adequate answer to berkeley @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ this is an astonishing claim , which amounts to reading back into history , feedback - style , developments that came much later.[multiblock footnote omitted ] such a claim amounts to postulating the inevitability of a triumphant march , from berkeley onward , toward the radiant future of weierstrassian epsilontics ( `` sequence of inequalities a subtle and difficult idea '' ) .
the claim of such inevitability in our opinion is an assumption that requires further argument .
berkeley was , after all , attacking the coherence of _
infinitesimals_. he was not attacking the coherence of some kind of incipient form of weierstrassian epsilontics and its inequalities .
is nt there a simpler answer to berkeley s query , in terms of a distinction between `` variable quantity '' and `` given quantity '' already present in lhpital s textbook at the end of the 17th century ?
the missing ingredient was a way of relating a variable quantity to a given quantity , but that , too , was anticipated by pierre de fermat s concept of adequality , as discussed in section [ rival1 ] .
we will analyze the problem in more detail from the 19th century , pre - weierstrass , viewpoint of cauchy s textbooks . in cauchy s world , a variable quantity @xmath55 can have a `` limiting '' fixed quantity @xmath56 , such that the difference @xmath57 is infinitesimal . consider cauchy s decomposition of an arbitrary infinitesimal of order @xmath8 as a sum @xmath58 ( see @xcite ) , where @xmath56 is fixed nonzero , whereas @xmath0 is a variable quantity representing an infinitesimal . if one were to set @xmath59 in this formula , one would obtain a representation of an an arbitrary finite quantity @xmath55 , as a sum @xmath60 if we were to suppress the infinitesimal part @xmath61 , we would obtain `` the standard part '' @xmath56 of the original variable quantity @xmath55 . in the terminology of section [ rival1 ] we are dealing with a passage from a finite point of a b - continuum , to the infinitely close ( adequal ) point of the a - continuum , namely passing from a variable quantity to its
limiting constant ( fixed , given ) quantity .
cauchy had the means at his disposal to resolve berkeley s query , so as to solve the logical puzzle of the definition of the derivative in the context of a b - continuum . while he did not resolve it
, he did not need the subtle and difficult idea of weierstrassian epsilontics ; suggesting otherwise amounts to feedback - style ahistory .
this reader was shocked to discover , upon his first reading of chapter 6 in schubring @xcite , that _ schubring is not aware of the fact that robinson s non - standard numbers are an extension of the real numbers_. consider the following three consecutive sentences from schubring s chapter 6 : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ a ] [ giusti s 1984 paper ] spurred laugwitz to even more detailed attempts to banish the error and confirm that cauchy had used hyper - real numbers .
[ b ] on this basis , he claims , the errors vanish and the theorems become correct , or , rather , they always were correct ( see laugwitz 1990 , 21 ) .
[ c ] in contrast to robinson and his followers , laugwitz ( 1987 ) assumes that cauchy did not use nonstandard numbers in the sense of nsa , but that his _ infiniment petits _ were infinitesimals representing an extension of the field of real numbers
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ these three sentences , which we have labeled [ a ] , [ b ] , and [ c ] , tell a remarkable story that will allow us to gauge schubring s exact relationship to the subject of his speculations . what interests us are the first sentence [ a ] and the last sentence [ c ] . their literal reading yields the following four views put forth by schubring : ( 1 ) laugwitz intepreted cauchy as using hyperreal numbers ( from sentence [ a ] ) ; ( 2 ) robinson assumed that cauchy used
nonstandard numbers in the sense of nsa " ( from sentence [ c ] ) ; ( 3 ) laugwitz disagreed with robinson on the latter point ( from sentence [ c ] ) ; ( 4 ) laugwitz interpreted cauchy as using an extension of the field of real numbers ( from sentence [ c ] )
. taken at face value , items ( 1 ) and ( 4 ) together would logically indicate that ( 5 ) laugwitz interpreted cauchy as using the hyperreal extension of the reals ; moreover , if , as indicated in item ( 3 ) , laugwitz disagreed with robinson , then it would logically follow that ( 6 ) robinson interpreted cauchy as _ not _ using the hyperreal extension of the reals ; as to the question what number system robinson _ did _ attribute to cauchy , item ( 2 ) would indicate that ( 7 ) robinson used , not laugwitz s hyperreals , but rather nonstandard numbers in the sense of nsa " .
we hasten to clarify that all of the items listed above are incoherent . indeed ,
robinson s non - standard numbers " and the hyperreals are one and the same number system ( see section [ rival2 ] for more details ; robinson s approach is actually more general than hewitt s hyperreal fields ) .
meanwhile , laugwitz s preferred system is a different system altogether , called omega - calculus .
we gather that schubring literally does not know what he is writing about when he takes on robinson and laugwitz . a reader interested in an introduction to popper and fallibilism need look no further than chapter 6 of schubring @xcite , who comments on _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the enthusiasm for revising traditional beliefs in the history of science and reinterpreting the discipline from a theoretical , epistemological perspective generated by thomas kuhn s ( 1962 ) work on the structure of scientific revolutions . applying popper
s favorite keyword of fallibilism , the statements of earlier scientists that historiography had declared to be false were particularly attractive objects for such an epistemologically guided revision .
the philosopher imre lakatos ( 1922 - 1972 ) was responsible for introducing these new approaches into the history of mathematics .
one of the examples he analyzed and published in 1966 received a great deal of attention : cauchy s theorem and the problem of uniform convergence .
lakatos refines robinson s approach by claiming that cauchy s theorem had also been correct at the time , because he had been working with infinitesimals @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ one might have expected that , having devoted so much space to the philosophical underpinnings of lakatos interpretation of cauchy s sum theorem , schubring would actually devote a thought or two to that interpretation itself . instead , schubring presents a misguided claim to the effect that robinson acknowledged the incorrectness of the sum theorem .. for a summary of the controversy over the sum theorem , see section [ sum ] . ]
schubring appears to feel that calling lakatos a popperian and a fallibilist is sufficient refutation in its own right .
similarly , schubring dismisses laugwitz s reading of cauchy as solipsistic " @xcite ; accuses them of interpreting cauchy s conceptions as _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ some hermetic closure of a _ private _ mathematics @xcite [ emphasis in the original the authors ] ; _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ as well as being `` highly anomalous or isolated '' @xcite .
now common sense would suggest that laugwitz is interpreting cauchy s words according to their plain meaning , and takes his infinitesimals at face value .
is nt the burden of proof on schubring to explain why the triumvirate interpretation of cauchy is not `` solipsistic '' , `` hermetic '' , or `` anomalous '' ? schubring does nothing of the sort .
why are lakatos and laugwitz demonized rather than analyzed by schubring ?
the issue of whether or not schubring commands a minimum background necessary to understand either robinson s , lakatos , or laugwitz s interpretation was discussed above .
more fundamentally , the act of contemplating for a moment the idea that cauchy s infinitesimals can be taken at face value is unthinkable to a triumvirate historian , as it would undermine the nominalistic cauchy - weierstrass tale that the received historiography is erected upon .
the failure to appreciate the potency of the robinson - lakatos - laugwitz interpretation is symptomatic of an ostrich effect conditioned by a narrow a - continuum vision . , and in the educational context , see footnote [ ostrich2 ] . ]
the robinson - lakatos - laugwitz interpretation of cauchy s sum theorem is considered in more detail in section [ sum ] .
chapter 6 in schubring @xcite is entitled `` cauchy s compromise concept '' .
which compromise is the author referring to ?
the answer becomes apparent on page 439 , where the author quotes cauchy s `` reconciliation '' sentence : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ my main aim has been to _ reconcile _ rigor , which i have made a law in my cours danalyse , with the simplicity that comes from the direct consideration of infinitely small quantities ( cauchy 1823 , see @xcite ) [ emphasis added
authors ] .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ cauchy s choice of the word `` reconcile '' does suggest a resolution of a certain tension .
what is the nature of such a tension ?
the sentence mentions `` rigor '' and `` infinitely small quantities '' in the same breath . this led schubring to a conclusion of cauchy s alleged perception of a `` disagreement '' between them : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in his next textbook on differential calculus in 1823 , cauchy points out expressly that he has adopted a compromise concept and that the `` simplicity of the infinitely small quantities '' [ ... ] disagrees with the rigor " that he wished to achieve in his 1821 textbook @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ schubring s conclusion concerning such an alleged `` disagreement '' , as well as the `` compromise '' of his title , both hinge essentially on a single word _ concilier _
( reconcile ) in cauchy .
let us analyze its meaning .
if it refers to a disagreement between rigor and infinitesimals , how do we account for cauchy s attribution , in 1821 , of a fundamental foundational role of infinitesimals in establishing a rigorous basis for analysis ?
had cauchy changed his mind sometime between 1821 and 1823 ?
to solve the riddle we must place cauchy s `` reconciliation '' sentence in the context where it occurs . in the sentence immediately preceding it , cauchy speaks of his break with the earlier texts in analysis : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ les mthodes que jai suivies diffrent plusieurs gards de celles qui se trouvent exposes dans les ouvrages du mme genre @xcite . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ could he be referring to his own earlier text ? to answer the question
, we must read on what cauchy has to say .
immediately following the `` reconciliation '' sentence , cauchy unleashes a sustained attack against the flawed method of divergent power series .
cauchy does not name the culprit , but clearly identifies the offending treatise .
it is the _ mcanique analytique _ , see ( cauchy 1823 , p. 11 ) .
the second edition of lagrange s treatise came out in 1811 , when cauchy was barely out of his teens . here
lagrange writes : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ lorsquon a bien conu lesprit de ce systme , et quon sest convaincu de lexactitude de ses rsultats par la mthode gomtrique des premires et dernires raisons , ou par la mthode analytique des fonctions drives , on peut employer les infiniment petits comme un instrument sr et commode pour abrger et simplifier les dmonstrations @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ lagrange s ringing endorsement of infinitesimals in 1811 is as unambivalent as that of johann bernoulli , lhopital , or varignon . in rejecting lagrange s flawed method of power series , as well as his principle of the `` generality of algebra '' ,
cauchy was surely faced with a dilemma with regard to lagrange s infinitesimals , which had stirred controversy for over a century .
we argue that it is the context of a critical re - evaluation of lagrange s mathematics that created a tension for cauchy vis - a - vis lagrange s work of 1811 : can he sift the chaff from the grain ?
s great accomplishment was his recognition that , while lagrange s flawed power series method and his principle of the generality of algebra do not measure up to the standard of rigor cauchy sought to uphold in his own work , the infinitesimals can indeed be reconciled with such a standard of rigor .
the resolution of the tension between the rejection of lagrange s conceptual framework , on the one hand , and the acceptance of his infinitesimals , on the other , is what cauchy is referring to in his `` reconciliation '' sentence .
cauchy s blending of rigor and infinitesimals in 1823 is consistent with his approach in 1821 .
cauchy s sentence compromises schubring s concept of a cauchyan ambivalence with regard to infinitesimals , and pulls the rug from under schubring s nominalistic and solipsistic reading of cauchy .
in this section , we summarize the controversy over the sum theorem , recently analyzed by brting @xcite .
the issue hinges on two types of convergence . to clarify the mathematical issues involved
, we will first consider the simpler distinction between continuity and uniform continuity .
let @xmath22 be in the domain of a function @xmath24 , and consider the following condition , which we will call _ microcontinuity _ at @xmath22 : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ if @xmath62 is in the domain of @xmath24 and @xmath62 is infinitely close to @xmath22 , then @xmath63 is infinitely close to @xmath52 " . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ then ordinary continuity of @xmath24 is equivalent to @xmath24 being microcontinuous on the archimedean continuum ( a - continuum for short ) , i.e. , at every point @xmath22 of its domain in the a - continuum .
meanwhile , uniform continuity of @xmath24 is equivalent to @xmath24 being microcontinuous on the bernoulian continuum ( b - continuum for short ) , i.e. , at every point @xmath22 of its domain in the b - continuum .. ] thus , the function @xmath64 for positive @xmath22 fails to be uniformly continuous because microcontinuity fails at a positive infinitesimal @xmath22 .
the function @xmath65 fails to be uniformly continuous because of the failure of microcontinuity at a single infinite member of the b - continuum . a similar distinction exists between pointwise convergence and uniform convergence .
the latter condition requires convergence at the points of the b - continuum in addition to the points of the a - continuum , see e.g. goldblatt ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 7.12.2 , p. 87 ) .
which condition did cauchy have in mind in 1821 ?
this is essentially the subject of the controversy over the sum theorem .
abel interpreted it as convergence on the a - continuum , and presented `` exceptions '' ( what we would call today counterexamples ) in 1826 .
after the publication of additional such exceptions by seidel and stokes in the 1840s , cauchy clarified / modified his position in 1853 . in his text @xcite , he specified a stronger condition of convergence on the b - continuum , including at @xmath66 .
the latter entity is explicitly mentioned by cauchy as illustrating the failure of the error term to tend to zero .
the stronger condition bars abel s counterexample .
see our text @xcite for more details .
@xmath67 \ar@{-}@<-0.5pt>[rr ] \ar@{-}@<0.5pt>[rr ] & { } \ar@{->}[d]^{\hbox{st } } & \hbox{\quad b - continuum } \\ { } \ar@{-}[rr ] & { } & \hbox{\quad a - continuum } } \ ] ] a leibnizian definition of the derivative as the infinitesimal quotient @xmath68 whose logical weakness was criticized by berkeley , was modified by a. robinson by exploiting a map called _ the standard part _ , denoted `` st '' , from the finite part of a b - continuum ( for `` bernoullian '' ) , to the a - continuum ( for `` archimedean '' ) , as illustrated in figure [ 31 ] .
to the real point st@xmath69 infinitely close to @xmath22 . in other words ,
the map `` st '' collapses the cluster ( halo ) of points infinitely close to a real number @xmath22 , back to @xmath22 .
] here two points of a b - continuum have the same image under `` st '' if and only if they are equal up to an infinitesimal .
this section analyzes the historical seeds of robinson s theory , in the work of fermat , wallis , as well as barrow.while barrow s role is also critical , we will mostly concentrate on fermat and wallis . ] the key concept here is that of _ adequality _ ( see below ) .
it should be kept in mind that fermat never considered the local slope of a curve .
therefore one has to be careful not to attribute to fermat mathematical content that could not be there . on the other hand ,
barrow did study curves and their slope . furthermore , barrow exploited fermat s adequality in his work @xcite , as documented by h. breger @xcite .
the binary relation of `` equality up to an infinitesimal '' was anticipated in the work of pierre de fermat .
fermat used a term usually translated into english as `` adequality . ''
andr weil writes as follows : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ fermat [ ... ] developed a method which slowly but surely brought him very close to modern infinitesimal concepts .
what he did was to write congruences between functions of @xmath22 modulo suitable powers of @xmath70 ; for such congruences , he introduces the technical term _
adaequalitas , adaequare _ , etc . , which he says he has borrowed from diophantus .
as diophantus v.11 shows , it means an approximate equality , and this is indeed how fermat explains the word in one of his later writings @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ weil ( * ? ? ? * , footnote 5 ) then supplies the following quote from fermat : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ adaequetur , ut ait diophantus , , see weil @xcite . ]
aut fere aequetur _ ; in mr .
mahoney s translation : adequal , or almost equal " ( p. 246 ) .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ here weil is citing mahoney @xcite ( cf .
mahoney similarly mentions the meaning of `` approximate equality '' or `` equality in the limiting case '' in ( * ? ? ?
* , end of footnote 46 ) .
mahoney also points out that the term `` adequality '' in fermat has additional meanings .
the latter are emphasized in a recent text by e. giusti @xcite , who is sharply critical of breger @xcite . while the review @xcite by weil is similarly sharply critical of mahoney ,
both agree that the meaning of `` approximate equality '' , leading into infinitesimal calculus , is at least _
one of the meanings _ of the term _ adequality _ for fermat .
this meaning was aptly summarized by j. stillwell .
stillwell s historical presentation is somewhat simplified , and does not sufficiently distinguish between the seeds actually present in fermat , on the one hand , and a modern interpretation thereof , on the other , above for a discussion of barrow s role , documented by h breger . ] but he does a splendid job of explaining the mathematical background for the uninitiated .
thus , he notes that @xmath71 is not equal to @xmath72 ( see figure [ jul10 ] ) , and writes : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ instead , the two are connected by a looser notion than equality that fermat called adequality .
if we denote adequality by @xmath73 , then it is accurate to say that @xmath74 and hence that @xmath19 for the parabola is adequal to @xmath72 .
meanwhile , @xmath71 is not a number , so @xmath72 is the only number to which @xmath19 is adequal .
this is the true sense in which @xmath19 represents the slope of the curve @xcite . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ stillwell points out that _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ fermat introduced the idea of adequality in 1630s but he was ahead of his time .
his successors were unwilling to give up the convenience of ordinary equations , preferring to use equality loosely rather than to use adequality accurately .
the idea of adequality was revived only in the twentieth century , in the so - called non - standard analysis @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we will refer to the map from the ( finite part of the ) b - continuum to the a - continuum as the fermat - robinson standard part , see figure [ fermatwallis ] . as far as the logical criticism formulated by rev .
george is concerned , fermat s adequality had pre - emptively provided the seeds of an answer , a century before the bishop ever lifted up his pen to write _ the analyst _
@xcite .
fermat s contemporary john wallis , in a departure from cavalieri s focus on the geometry of indivisibles , emphasized the arithmetic of infinitesimals , see j. stedall s introduction in @xcite .
to cavalieri , a plane figure is made of lines ; to wallis , it is made of parallelograms of infinitesimal altitude .
wallis transforms this insight into symbolic algebra over the @xmath75 symbol which he introduced .
he exploits formulas like @xmath76 in his calculations of areas .
thus , in proposition 182 of _ arithmetica infinitorum _ , wallis partitions a triangle of altitude @xmath77 and base @xmath78 into a precise number @xmath75 of parallelograms " of infinitesimal width @xmath79 , see figure [ wallis ] ( copied from @xcite ) .
he then computes the combined length of the bases of the parallelograms to be @xmath80 , and finds the area to be @xmath81 wallis used an actual infinitesimal @xmath82 in calculations as if it were an ordinary number , anticipating leibniz s law of continuity .
wallis s area calculation is reproduced by j. scott , who notes that wallis _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ treats infinity as though the ordinary rules of arithmetic could be applied to it @xcite . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ such a treatment of infinity strikes scott as something of a blemish , as he writes : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ but this is perhaps understandable . for many years
to come the greatest confusion regarding these terms persisted , and even in the next century they continued to be used in what appears to us an amazingly reckless fashion @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ what is the source of scott s confidence in dismissing wallis s use of infinity as `` reckless '' ?
scott identifies it on the preceding page of his book ; it is , predictably , the triumvirate `` modern conception of infinity '' @xcite .
scott s tunnel a - continuum vision blinds him to the potential of wallis s vision of infinity .
but this is perhaps understandable .
many years separate scott from robinson s theory which in particular empowers wallis s calculation .
the lesson of scott s condescending steamrolling of wallis s infinitesimal calculation could be taken to heart by historians who until this day cling to a nominalistic belief that robinson s theory has little relevance to the history of mathematics in the 17th century .
nominalism in the narrow sense defines its ontological target as the ordinary numbers .
burgess in his essay @xcite suggests that there is also a nominalism in a broader sense .
thus , he quotes at length manin s criticism of constructivism , suggesting that lem - elimination can also fall under the category of a nominalism understood in a broader sense . in a later text @xcite
, burgess discusses brouwer under a similar angle .
infinitesimals were largely eliminated from mathematical discourse starting in the 1870s through the efforts of the great triumvirate .. ] the elimination took place under the banner of striving for greater rigor , . ] but the roots of the triumvirate reconstruction lay in a failure to provide a solid foundation for a b - continuum ( see section [ rival1 ] ) . had actually useful mathematics been sacrificed on the altar of mathematical rigor " during the second half of the 19th century ? today we can give a precise sense to c.s .
peirce s description of the real line as a _ pseudo - continuum_. the totality of real values , rational and irrational '' @xcite ( see cp 6.176 , 1903 marginal note . here , and below , cp x.y stands for collected papers of charles sanders peirce , volume x , paragraph y ) .
peirce used the word pseudo - continua " to describe real numbers in the syllabus ( cp 1.185 ) of his lectures on topics of logic .
thus , peirce s intuition of the continuum corresponded to a type of a b - continuum ( see section [ rival1 ] ) , whereas an a - continuum to him was a pseudo - continuum . ]
cantor s revolutionary advances in set theory went hand - in - hand with his emotional opposition to infinitesimals as an `` abomination '' and the `` cholera bacillus '' of mathematics .
cantor s interest in eliminating infinitesimals is paralleled nearly a century later by bishop s interest in eliminating lem , and by a traditional nominalist s interest in eliminating platonic counting numbers .
the automatic infinitesimal - to - limit translation as applied to cauchy by boyer and others is not only reductionist , but also self - contradictory , see @xcite .
this section summarizes a 20th century implementation of the b - continuum , not to be confused with incipient notions of such a continuum found in earlier centuries .
an alternative implementation has been pursued by lawvere , john l. bell @xcite , and others .
we illustrate the construction by means of an infinite - resolution microscope in figure [ fermatwallis ] .
we will denote such a b - continuum by the new symbol ( `` thick - r '' ) .
such a continuum is constructed in formula .
we will also denote its finite part , by @xmath83 so that we have a disjoint union @xmath84 where @xmath85 consists of unlimited hyperreals ( i.e. , inverses of nonzero infinitesimals ) .
the map `` st '' sends each finite point @xmath86 , to the real point st@xmath69 infinitely close to @xmath22 , as follows : . ]
@xmath87^{{\rm st } } \\ { { \mathbb r}}}\ ] ] robinson s answer to berkeley s _ logical criticism _ ( see d. sherry @xcite ) is to define the derivative as @xmath88 instead of @xmath89 .
note that both the term `` hyper - real field '' , and an ultrapower construction thereof , are due to e. hewitt in 1948 , see @xcite . in 1966 , robinson referred to the _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ theory of hyperreal fields ( hewitt [ 1948 ] ) which ... can serve as non - standard models of analysis @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the _ transfer principle _ is a precise implementation of leibniz s heuristic _ law of continuity _ : `` what succeeds for the finite numbers succeeds also for the infinite numbers and vice versa '' , see @xcite .
the transfer principle , allowing an extention of every first - order real statement to the hyperreals , is a consequence of the theorem of j. o in 1955 , see @xcite , and can therefore be referred to as a leibniz - o transfer principle .
a hewitt - o framework allows one to work in a b - continuum satisfying the transfer principle . to elaborate on the ultrapower construction of the hyperreals ,
let @xmath90 denote the ring of sequences of rational numbers .
let @xmath91 denote the subspace consisting of cauchy sequences .
the reals are by definition the quotient field @xmath92 where @xmath93 contains all null sequences .
meanwhile , an infinitesimal - enriched field extension of @xmath31 may be obtained by forming the quotient @xmath94 here a sequence @xmath95 is in @xmath96 if and only if the set of indices @xmath97 is a member of a fixed ultrafilter .
see figure [ helpful ] .
@xmath98^ { } \ar@{->>}[d]^{\rm st } & & { { \mbox{i\!i\!r}}}_{<\infty } \ar@{->>}[d]^{\rm st } \\ { { \mathbb q}}\ar[rr ] \ar@{^{(}- > } [ urr ] & & { { \mathbb r}}\ar[rr]^{\simeq } & & { { \mathbb r}}}\ ] ] to give an example , the sequence @xmath99 represents a nonzero infinitesimal , whose sign depends on whether or not the set @xmath100 is a member of the ultrafilter . to obtain a full hyperreal field ,
we replace @xmath31 by @xmath36 in the construction , and form a similar quotient @xmath101 we wish to emphasize the analogy with formula defining the a - continuum .
note that , while the leftmost vertical arrow in figure [ helpful ] is surjective , we have @xmath102 a more detailed discussion of this construction can be found in the book by m. davis @xcite .
see also baszczyk @xcite for some philosophical implications .
more advanced properties of the hyperreals such as saturation were proved later , see keisler @xcite for a historical outline . a helpful `` semicolon '' notation for presenting an extended decimal expansion of a hyperreal was described by a. h. lightstone @xcite .
see also p. roquette @xcite for infinitesimal reminiscences .
a discussion of infinitesimal optics is in k. stroyan @xcite , j. keisler @xcite , d. tall @xcite , and l. magnani and r. dossena @xcite , and bair & henry @xcite .
applications of the b - continuum range from aid in teaching calculus @xcite ( see illustration in figure [ jul10 ] ) to the bolzmann equation ( see l. arkeryd @xcite ) ; modeling of timed systems in computer science ( see h. rust @xcite ) ; mathematical economics ( see anderson @xcite ) ; mathematical physics ( see albeverio _
@xcite ) ; etc .
we are grateful to martin davis , solomon feferman , reuben hersh , david sherry , and steve shnider for invaluable comments that helped improve the manuscript .
hilton kramer s influence is obvious throughout .
albeverio , s. ; hegh - krohn , r. ; fenstad , j. ; lindstrm , t. : nonstandard methods in stochastic analysis and mathematical physics . _ pure and applied mathematics _ , * 122*. academic press , inc . ,
orlando , fl , 1986 .
beeson , m. : foundations of constructive mathematics .
metamathematical studies .
ergebnisse der mathematik und ihrer grenzgebiete ( 3 ) [ results in mathematics and related areas ( 3 ) ] , 6 .
springer - verlag , berlin , 1985 .
bishop , e. : the crisis in contemporary mathematics .
proceedings of the american academy workshop on the evolution of modern mathematics ( boston , mass . , 1974 ) .
_ historia math .
_ * 2 * ( 75 ) , no . 4 , 507 - 517 .
bishop , e. : schizophrenia in contemporary mathematics [ published posthumously ; originally distributed in 1973 ] . in errett bishop : reflections on him and his research ( san diego , calif . , 1983 ) , 132 , _ contemp .
_ * 39 * , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 1985 .
boniface , j. ; schappacher , n. : `` sur le concept de nombre en mathmatique '' : cours indit de leopold kronecker berlin ( 1891 ) .
[ `` on the concept of number in mathematics '' : leopold kronecker s 1891 berlin lectures ] _ rev .
histoire math .
_ textbf7 ( 2001 ) , no . 2 , 206275 .
brting , k. : a new look at e. g. bjrling and the cauchy sum theorem . _
exact sci . _ * 61 * ( 2007 ) , no . 5 , 519535 .
breger , h. : the mysteries of adaequare : a vindication of fermat .
exact sci . _ * 46 * ( 1994 ) , no . 3 , 193219 .
cauchy , a. l. ( 1823 ) : rsum des leons donnes lecole royale polytechnique sur le calcul infinitsimal ( paris : imprimrie royale , 1823 ) . in oeuvres compltes , series 2 , vol .
paris : gauthier - villars , 1899 .
cauchy , a. l. ( 1853 ) note sur les sries convergentes do nt les divers termes sont des fonctions continues dune variable relle ou imaginaire , entre des limites donnes . in _
oeuvres compltes _ , series 1 , vol .
12 , pp .
paris : gauthier villars , 1900 .
corry , l. : axiomatics , empiricism , and anschauung in hilbert s conception of geometry : between arithmetic and general relativity .
the architecture of modern mathematics , 133156 , oxford univ . press , oxford , 2006 .
dauben , j. : conceptual revolutions and the history of mathematics : two studies in the growth of knowledge ( 1984 ) . in revolutions in mathematics , 4971 , oxford sci .
, oxford univ .
press , new york , 1992 .
dauben , j. : arguments , logic and proof : mathematics , logic and the infinite .
history of mathematics and education : ideas and experiences ( essen , 1992 ) , 113148 , _ stud .
_ , * 11 * , vandenhoeck & ruprecht , gttingen , 1996
. davis , m. : applied nonstandard analysis .
pure and applied mathematics .
wiley - interscience [ john wiley & sons ] , new york - london - sydney , 1977 . reprinted : dover , ny , 2005 , see http://store.doverpublications.com/0486442292.html feferman , s. : conceptions of the continuum [ le continu mathmatique .
nouvelles conceptions , nouveaux enjeux ] .
_ intellectica _ * 51 * ( 2009 ) 169 - 189 .
see also http://math.stanford.edu/@xmath103feferman/papers/conceptcontin.pdf hilbert , d. ( 1919 - 20 ) , natur und mathematisches erkennen : vorlesungen , gehalten 1919 - 1920 in gttingen .
nach der ausarbeitung von paul bernays ( edited and with an english introduction by david e. rowe ) , basel , birkhuser ( 1992 ) .
hobson , e. w. : on the infinite and the infinitesimal in mathematical analysis . _ proceedings london mathematical society _ ,
volume s1 - 35 ( 1902 ) , no . 1 , pp . 117 - 139 ( reprinted in real numbers , generalizations of the reals , and theories of continua , 326 , synthese lib . , 242 , kluwer acad .
dordrecht , 1994 ) .
katz , m. ; tall , d. : the tension between intuitive infinitesimals and formal mathematical analysis .
chapter in crossroads in the history of mathematics and mathematics education .
bharath sriraman , editor . soon to be available at http://www.infoagepub.com/products/crossroads-in-the-history-of-mathematics klein , f. : elementary mathematics from an advanced standpoint .
i. arithmetic , algebra , analysis .
translation by e. r. hedrick and c. a. noble [ macmillan , new york , 1932 ] from the third german edition [ springer , berlin , 1924 ] originally published as elementarmathematik vom hheren standpunkte aus ( leipzig , 1908 ) .
kopell , n. ; stolzenberg , g. : commentary on e. bishop s talk ( historia math . 2 ( 1975 ) , 507517 ) .
proceedings of the american academy workshop on the evolution of modern mathematics ( boston , mass . , 1974 ) .
_ historia math .
_ * 2 * ( 1975 ) , no . 4 , 519521 .
luzin , n. n. ( 1931 ) two letters by n. n. luzin to m. ya . vygodskii . with an introduction by s. s. demidov .
translated from the 1997 russian original by a. shenitzer .
monthly _ * 107 * ( 2000 ) , no . 1 , 6482 . lakatos , imre : cauchy and the continuum : the significance of nonstandard analysis for the history and philosophy of mathematics .
intelligencer 1 ( 1978 ) , no .
3 , 151161 ( originally published in 1966 ) . novikov , s. p. : the second half of the 20th century and its results : the crisis of the society of physicists and mathematicians in russia and in the west .
( russian ) istor .- mat
7(42 ) ( 2002 ) , 326356 , 369 .
novikov , s. p. : the second half of the 20th century and its conclusion : crisis in the physics and mathematics community in russia and in the west .
ser . 2 , 212 , geometry , topology , and mathematical physics , 124 , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 2004 .
( translated from istor .- mat
7(42 ) ( 2002 ) , 326356 , 369 ; by a. sossinsky . )
robinson , a. : selected papers of abraham robinson .
nonstandard analysis and philosophy . edited and with introductions by w. a. j. luxemburg and s. krner .
yale university press , new haven , conn . ,
1979 .
schubring , g. : conflicts between generalization , rigor , and intuition .
number concepts underlying the development of analysis in 1719th century france and germany . sources and studies in the history of mathematics and physical sciences .
springer - verlag , new york , 2005 .
stevin , simon : the principal works of simon stevin . vols .
iia , iib : mathematics .
edited by d. j. struik c. v. swets & zeitlinger , amsterdam 1958 .
iia : v+pp .
1455 ( 1 plate ) .
iib : 1958 iv+pp .
459976 .
stroyan , k. : uniform continuity and rates of growth of meromorphic functions .
contributions to non - standard analysis ( sympos . ,
oberwolfach , 1970 ) , pp .
_ studies in logic and foundations of math .
69 , north - holland , amsterdam , 1972 .
tall , d. : the psychology of advanced mathematical thinking , in _ advanced mathematical thinking_. edited by d. o. tall , mathematics education library , 11 .
kluwer academic publishers group , dordrecht , 1991 .
taylor , r. g. : review of real numbers , generalizations of the reals , and theories of continua , edited by philip ehrlich [ see item @xcite above ] .
_ modern logic _ * 8 * , number 1/2 ( january 1998april 2000 ) , 195212 .
veronese , g. : fondamenti di geometria a pi dimensioni e a pi specie di unit rettilinee esposti in forma elementare , lezioni per la scuola di magistero in matematica .
padova , tipografia del seminario , 1891 .
wallis , j. : the arithmetic of infinitesimals . translated from the latin and with an introduction by jaequeline a. stedall . _
sources and studies in the history of mathematics and physical sciences_. springer - verlag , new york , 2004 . | we analyze the developments in mathematical rigor from the viewpoint of a burgessian critique of nominalistic reconstructions .
we apply such a critique to the reconstruction of infinitesimal analysis accomplished through the efforts of cantor , dedekind , and weierstrass ; to the reconstruction of cauchy s foundational work associated with the work of boyer and grabiner ; and to bishop s constructivist reconstruction of classical analysis .
we examine the effects of an ontologically limitative disposition on historiography , teaching , and research . |
it was shown recently how to calculate the cross section for exclusive production of heavy quarkonia in the @xmath5 @xcite as well as in @xmath6 @xcite collisions within the @xmath7-factorization approach .
the same formalism was also used recently to calculate exclusive production of the @xmath8 boson @xcite . in the latter case
the corresponding cross section is however very small and can not be measured at present luminosities . in order to describe the photoproduction process in a strict pqcd framework ,
at least a hard scale must be present , which could be for example either a quark mass for heavy quarkonia , or a large photon virtuality for deep inelastic diffractive processes .
the @xmath7factorization formalism described in @xcite allows , however , a smooth continuation from the hard to soft regime , and therefore can be also used to model the photoproduction of light vector mesons .
this derives from the fact that the @xmath7factorization is a momentum space version of the color
dipole approach , where the soft region is modelled by the behaviour of the dipole cross section at large dipole sizes @xcite .
the zeus collaboration at hera has measured exclusive production of @xmath4 mesons in the @xmath0 reaction @xcite and in @xmath9 reaction @xcite . here
we wish to test the results of the approach against the hera data as well as to make predictions for the @xmath10 reaction for the tevatron and the @xmath11 reaction for rhic and lhc .
a sketch of the amplitude for exclusive photoproduction @xmath0.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] the amplitude for the reaction is shown schematically in fig.[vm_amplitude_photo ] .
this amplitude has been derived for the first time in ref.@xcite,@xcite .
the imaginary part of the amplitude can be writen as : @xmath12 where @xmath13 have the form : @xmath14 \psi_v(z , k ) \phi_{2 } \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath15 ( \psi_v(z , k ) { \mbox{\boldmath $ k$}}{\mbox{\boldmath $ \phi$}}_{1})+ \\
\nonumber \frac { m_{q}}{m+2m_{q } } \big [ ( k^{2 } \psi_v(z , k ) ) \phi_{2}-(2z-1)^{2}({\mbox{\boldmath $ k$}}{\mbox{\boldmath $ \phi$}}_{1 } ) \psi_v(z , k ) \big ] \ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the expressions above @xmath16 is the meson light - cone wave function and @xmath17 , @xmath18 are given by ( ref .
@xcite ) : @xmath19 @xmath20 where : @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
the quantity @xmath23 is the off - diagonal unintegrated gluon distribution , which for small @xmath24 , within the diffraction cone can be approximated as : @xmath25 where @xmath26 = 0.41 and the forward unintegrated gluon distribution is taken from ref.@xcite where it was found in the analysis of the deep - inelastic scattering data . in the forward scattering limit , i.e. for @xmath27
azimuthal integrations can be performed analytically ( see @xcite ) , and one obtains the following representation for the imaginary part of the amplitude for the transverse photons : @xmath28 where @xmath29 \ , \frac{k^2}{k^2 + \epsilon^{2 } } \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath30 the imaginary part of the amplitude for longitudinal photons is given as : @xmath31 where @xmath32 @xmath33 in our calculation we choose the scale of the qcd running coupling constant at : + @xmath34 .
the full amplitude , at finite @xmath24 , for transverse and longitudinal polarization can be written as : @xmath35 @xmath36 where @xmath37 is a ratio of real to imaginary part of the amplitude @xmath38 above @xmath39 is a slope parameter which in general depends on the photon - proton center - of - mass energy and is parametrized in the present analysis as : @xmath40 with:@xmath41 gev@xmath42 , @xmath43 gev@xmath42 , @xmath44 gev ( @xcite ) .
assuming exponential dependence of the amplitude on @xmath24 ( see eq.([full_amp ] ) ) the total cross section for transverse and longitudinal polarization can be writen as : @xmath45 @xmath46 the full cross section is a sum of these two components : @xmath47 in hera kinematics , @xmath48 .
let us collect now the main formulas involving the @xmath49 light
cone wave - function of the vector meson the electronic decay width depends on the model of the @xmath4 meson wave function as : @xmath50 in our calculation we use leading - order approximation , i.e. we neglect a possible nlo @xmath51-factor .
the parameter @xmath52 can be expressed in terms of the @xmath4 - meson wave function as @xcite @xmath53 following @xcite we use two types of the wave function , the gaussian one , representing a standard harmonic oscillator type quark model : @xmath54 and a coulomb wave function , representative of models in which the wave function has a long high momentum tail : @xmath55 the parameters of the wave function are obtained by fitting to the decay width into @xmath56 @xmath57 and imposing the normalization condition : @xmath58
a sketch of the bare exclusive @xmath0 amplitude.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] a sketch of the exclusive @xmath0 amplitude with absorptive corrections.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] the bare amplitude ( when absorption effects are ignored ) can be written schematically @xcite as : @xmath61 because of the presence of the proton from factors only small @xmath62 and @xmath63 enter the amplitude for the hadronic process .
this means that in practise one can put @xmath64 the full amplitude for the @xmath59 @xmath65 @xmath66 , reaction which includes elastic rescatterings reads : @xmath67 where @xmath68 in practical evaluations we take @xmath69 gev@xmath42 , @xmath70 mb for the rhic energy @xmath71 = 200 gev , @xmath72 gev@xmath42 , @xmath73 mb @xcite for the tevatron energy @xmath71 = 1.96 tev and @xmath74 gev@xmath42 , @xmath75 mb for the lhc energy @xmath71 = 14 tev . the absorptive correction to the amplitude can be written as the following convolution of the bare amplitude @xmath76 and the amplitude for elastic @xmath77 or @xmath60 scattering as : @xmath78 the differential cross section is expressed in terms of the amplitude @xmath79 as @xmath80 this formula is used below to calculate several differential distributions in @xmath11 and @xmath10 reactions .
process as a function of the photon - proton center - of - mass energy . in this calculation
the gaussian wave function is used .
the curves are described in the text.,title="fig:",height=166 ] process as a function of the photon - proton center - of - mass energy . in this calculation
the gaussian wave function is used .
the curves are described in the text.,title="fig:",height=181 ] let us start review of our results with the @xmath0 reaction . in fig.[sigma_tot_mass ]
we show the total cross section for @xmath0 as a function of photon - proton center of - mass energy @xmath71 for @xmath81 .
our results are compared with the corresponding hera data @xcite . in order to describe experimental data we treat the mass of the strange quark as a free parameter , although it was fixed at @xmath82 = 0.37 gev in ref .
we show results for three different values of the strange quark mass .
the red solid ( upper ) line is for @xmath82 = 0.37 gev , blue ( lower ) line for @xmath82 = 0.50 gev and the black line ( which goes through the data points ) for @xmath82 = 0.45 gev .
we can see that the result for @xmath82 = 0.45 gev gives the best description of the experimental data , so below we shall present results only for this value of the strange quark mass .
our results for @xmath83-dependence look consistent with the ones previously obtained by ivanov in his phd thesis.@xcite = 0.45 gev .
the solid line is for transverse and longitudinal cross section and the dashed line is only for transverse cross section.,title="fig:",height=181 ] = 0.45 gev .
the solid line is for transverse and longitudinal cross section and the dashed line is only for transverse cross section.,title="fig:",height=181 ] in fig.[sigma_tot_q2 ] we show the total cross section as a function of photon virtuality for photon - proton center - of - mass energy @xmath71 = 75 gev .
the data points are taken from ref.@xcite .
the solid line is for the sum of longitudinal and transverse cross sections ( @xmath2 + @xmath3 ) and the dashed line is for transverse cross section ( @xmath3 ) alone .
it is important that both these components are included in the calculation . in the left panel
we show results for the gaussian wave function and in the right panel for the coulomb wave function .
we can see that the gaussian wave function much better describes the experimental data than the coulomb wave function .
/@xmath3 as a function of photon virtuality .
the red solid line is for the gaussian wave function and the black solid line is for the coulomb wave function . here
@xmath84 = 0.45 gev.,height=181 ] in fig.[ratio ] we show the ratio of the longitudinal cross section ( @xmath2 ) to the transverse cross section ( @xmath3 ) as a function of photon virtuality , again for @xmath71 = 75 gev .
the red solid line is for the gaussian and the black line is for the coulomb wave function .
our results are compared with the hera data from ref.@xcite .
production at rhic ( left ) , tevatron ( middle ) and lhc ( right ) energies .
the thin black lines are without , the thick red lines with absorption included . in this calculation
gaussian wave function was used and @xmath84 = 0.45 gev.,title="fig:",height=136 ] production at rhic ( left ) , tevatron ( middle ) and lhc ( right ) energies .
the thin black lines are without , the thick red lines with absorption included . in this calculation
gaussian wave function was used and @xmath84 = 0.45 gev.,title="fig:",height=136 ] production at rhic ( left ) , tevatron ( middle ) and lhc ( right ) energies .
the thin black lines are without , the thick red lines with absorption included . in this calculation
gaussian wave function was used and @xmath84 = 0.45 gev.,title="fig:",height=136 ] let us come now to the presentation of our results for exclusive production of @xmath4 meson in hadronic reactions . in fig.[rapidity_absorption ] we show distributions in rapidity for the @xmath85 ( tevatron ) and @xmath11 ( rhic , lhc ) reactions without ( black thin solid ) and with ( grey thick solid ) absorption effects .
the absorption effects are rather small and will be not included in calculations of other observables .
= 0.45 gev and absorptive corrections are not included.,title="fig:",height=136 ] = 0.45 gev and absorptive corrections are not included.,title="fig:",height=136 ] = 0.45 gev and absorptive corrections are not included.,title="fig:",height=136 ] in fig.[rapidity_gppg ] we show separate contributions of photon - pomeron and pomeron - photon fusion mechanisms in rapidity distribution of @xmath4 in @xmath60 ( middle panel ) and @xmath59 ( left and right panels ) collisions . here
we have shown only results without absorptive corrections .
the green line is for photon - pomeron , the blue line is for pomeron - photon fusion mechanism and the red most upper line is a sum of the two components . in rapidity
distribution the two contributions add incoherently @xcite . in fig.[transverse_momentum ]
we show distribution in transverse momentum of the exclusively produced meson @xmath4 . in the left panel we present results for rhic energy , in the middle panel for tevatron energy and in the right panel for the lhc energy .
finally in fig.[angle ] we show the distribution in relative azimuthal angle between outgoing protons .
quite different distributions are obtained for the rhic , lhc ( @xmath77 collisions ) and tevatron ( @xmath86 collisions ) .
this effect is of the interference nature and was already discussed for the exclusive production of @xmath87 @xcite .
in the present analysis we have performed the calculation of the cross section for the @xmath0 process as well as for exclusive production of @xmath4 meson in the @xmath11 reaction .
the cross section for the first process depends strongly on the model of the @xmath4 meson wave function as well as on the strange quark mass .
both gaussian and coulomb wave functions were used with parameters adjusted to reproduce the electronic decay width of @xmath4 .
the strange quark mass was adjusted to reproduce the @xmath0 cross section measured by the zeus collaboration at hera in the gaussian model of the wave function .
so - fixed parameters were used to make predictions for the @xmath88 and @xmath11 reactions .
we have presented distributions in the @xmath4 meson rapidity , in the @xmath4 meson transverse momentum and in the relative azimuthal angle between outgoing protons .
the azimuthal angle dependence found here is of purely interference nature .
quite different distributions have been predicted for the tevatron and lhc due to the different sign of the interference term ( different electric charge of proton and antiproton ) .
the cross sections found in the present analysis are fairly large . in practice
one could measure the @xmath4 meson either in the lepton - antilepton or in kaon - antikaon decay channels .
the later method could be used by the alice collaboration at the lhc where even small transverse momenta of charged kaons can be registered @xcite .
a feasibility of the measurements requires , however , detailed monte carlo studies .
i. p. ivanov , n. n. nikolaev and a. a. savin , phys .
nucl . * 37 * , 1 ( 2006 ) .
i. p. ivanov , `` diffractive production of s and d wave vector mesons in deep inelastic scattering , '' arxiv : hep - ph/9909394 , diploma thesis , bonn u. and `` diffractive production of vector mesons in deep inelastic scattering within k(t)-factorization approach , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0303053 , phd thesis , bonn u. w. schfer and a. szczurek , phys .
rev . * d76 * , 094014 ( 2007 ) .
a. rybarska , w. schfer and a. szczurek , phys .
* b668 * ( 2008 ) 126 a. cisek , w. schfer and a. szczurek , phys .
rev . * d80 * , 074013 ( 2009 ) .
n. n. nikolaev , comments nucl .
* 21 * ( 1992 ) 41 .
m. derrick _ et al .
_ ( zeus collaboration ) , phys .
b * 377 * 259 - 272 ( 1996 ) s. chekanov _ et al . _
( zeus collaboration ) , nucl .
b * 718 * 3 - 31 ( 2005 ) i. p. ivanov and n. n. nikolaev , phys .
d * 65 * , 054004 ( 2002 ) .
a. aktas _ et al . _
( h1 collaboration ) , eur .
j. c * 46 * , 585 ( 2006 ) .
f. abe _ et al . _
[ cdf collaboration ] , phys .
d * 50 * , 5518 ( 1994 ) .
alice collaboration , physics performance report , volume ii , part 1 , cern / lhcc 2005 - 030 , december 2005 . | the amplitude for @xmath0 is calculated in a pqcd @xmath1 - factorization approach . the total cross section for this process
is compared with hera data .
total cross section , as a function of photon - proton energy and photon virtuality , is calculated .
we also discuss the ratio of @xmath2/@xmath3 and the dependence on the mass of the strange quark .
the amplitude for @xmath0 is used to predict the cross section for exclusive photoproduction of @xmath4 meson in proton - proton collisions .
absorption effects are included .
the results for rhic , tevatron and lhc energies are presented . |
the one - body dirac density matrix for a system of @xmath2 non - interacting fermions at zero temperature can be expanded on the single - particle wavefunctions @xmath3 as @xmath4 . by using the representation of the translation operator
this becomes @xmath5 showing how distant points are correlated through the momentum operator @xmath6 .
expansion in powers of the relative coordinate @xmath7 yields physical observables such as the particle density profile @xmath8 , @xmath9 and the kinetic pressure @xmath10 , @xmath11 this is twice the kinetic energy density .
the main idea of this letter is to rewrite eqs .
( [ ndef ] ) and ( [ pdef ] ) as the imaginary part of the ground - state average of suitable operators related to the green s function in coordinate space @xmath12 .
we have @xmath13 and @xmath14 @xmath15 can then be treated by methods analogous to those used for treating green s functions in the energy domain . the equivalence between expressions ( [ ndef ] ) and ( [ ndefnoi ] ) is easily proved in the coordinate representation , where the density profile in eq .
( [ ndefnoi ] ) reads @xmath16 .
the equivalence between expressions ( [ pdef ] ) and ( [ pdefnoi ] ) for @xmath10 is similarly proved .
evidently , this method can be applied to all 1d systems which may be described by single - particle orbitals : one only needs to know the representation of the position and momentum operators on such a basis .
hence , interactions could also be included in evaluating the particle density through the use of kohn - sham single - particle orbitals .
models of displacement fields ( such as those induced by impurities ) may also be studied directly without previous evaluation of orbitals .
as already noted , a 1d fermi model is relevant to the spin - polarized fermionic vapors in magnetic confinement @xcite , where it is possible to realize experimentally a 1d configuration by making use of very anisotropic axially symmetric traps . at low temperature only the transverse ground state of the trap
is populated and the vapor can be described by an effective 1d harmonic hamiltonian . an analytic expression for the particle density of this system has been given by husimi @xcite in terms of the wavefunction of the @xmath2-th fermion in the trap . however , a calculation of the density profile and the kinetic pressure by his approach is limited to small values of @xmath2 and has been reported only for @xmath17 1 and 2 @xcite .
our method allows us to efficiently evaluate these ground state properties even for quite large numbers of particles .
of course , the simplicity of the representation of the position and momentum operators in this system makes it a favorable example .
we start with the calculation of the particle density . for a linear harmonic oscillator
the position operator is represented as @xmath18 on the basis @xmath19 of the eigenvectors of the hamiltonian . as usual , the creation and destruction operators satisfy the relations @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
a straightforward procedure for evaluating the profile ( [ ndefnoi ] ) is to invert the matrix @xmath22 and to calculate its trace on the submatrix of its first @xmath23 block ( tr@xmath24 ) .
we employ the relation @xmath25/\partial\lambda|_{\lambda=0}$ ] , where @xmath26 is a diagonal semi - infinite matrix with its first @xmath2 eigenvalues equal to 1 and null elsewhere @xcite , to obtain @xmath27_{\lambda=0}. \label{dens}\ ] ] the calculation of the determinant in eq .
( [ dens ] ) is conveniently performed by the recursive algorithm developed in @xcite .
renormalization of the tridiagonal operator @xmath28 allows us to write @xmath29 with @xmath30 , @xmath31 for @xmath32 and @xmath33 for @xmath34 . the scheme given in eqs .
( [ dens ] ) and ( [ prod1 ] ) is easily implemented numerically . in practice
we have performed the calculation of the determinant ( [ prod1 ] ) up to the product of its first @xmath35 terms , which corresponds to inverting an @xmath36 matrix .
we have checked the convergence of this approximation by increasing the dimension @xmath35 and correspondingly decreasing the value of @xmath37 . in fig .
[ fig1 ] we report the density profile @xmath8 for @xmath38 , 10 and 20 fermions , with @xmath39 and @xmath40 .
the exact profiles are also compared with those given by the thomas - fermi approximation ( lda ) , @xmath41 ( in units such that @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 ) .
the exact profiles contain @xmath2 oscillations , which become smaller in relative amplitude as @xmath2 increases . without any special numerical efforts
we have evaluated the exact density profile up to @xmath0 : this would otherwise require the calculation of hermite polynomials up to the 1000@xmath45 degree . for large @xmath2
the oscillations are so small in relative amplitude that their smoothing in the lda profile becomes reasonably accurate , except for the region of the tails .
the particle density profile that we have evaluated above is the analogue of the density of single - particle states in the energy domain . in the space domain
other single - particle quantities acquire physical interest , as is the case for the kinetic pressure in eq .
( [ pdef ] ) .
we show how also for this function one can profitably resort to a renormalization technique .
taking @xmath46 , eq .
( [ pdefnoi ] ) can be written as @xmath47_{\lambda=0}. \label{penta}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath48 appearing in eq .
( [ penta ] ) is pentadiagonal on the first @xmath2 rows , owing to the form of the operators @xmath49 and @xmath50 in the basis of the energy eigenstates @xmath19 .
the calculation of the determinant of such a matrix can again be performed by the recursive algorithm given in @xcite .
renormalization of the operator @xmath51 is made on blocks of dimension 2 for the pentadiagonal part and on blocks of dimension 1 for the tridiagonal part .
this allows us to write @xmath52 \prod_{j=1}^{(n+3)/2}\det(x-\tilde{a}_j+i\varepsilon ) \prod_{k = n+4}^{\infty}(x-\tilde{a}_k+i\varepsilon ) \qquad ( { \rm odd}\ ; n)\;.\\ \end{array}\right . \label{ricorr}\ ] ] the renormalized @xmath53 blocks @xmath54 satisfy the recursion relation @xmath55 for @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the matrices @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 are submatrices of the operator @xmath61 , which are defined as follows : @xmath62 @xmath63 and @xmath64 with @xmath65 for @xmath66 and @xmath67 otherwise .
the recursion relation for the elements @xmath68 is again @xmath69 , the first elements being @xmath70_{22}- [ \tilde a_{k/2}]_{21}\cdot [ \tilde a_{k/2}]_{12 } /(x+i\varepsilon-[\tilde a_{k/2}]_{11})\}^{-1}$ ] with @xmath71 for even @xmath2 and @xmath72 for odd @xmath2 .
we have studied the convergence of the determinant in eq .
( [ ricorr ] ) as for the case of the particle density profile . in fig .
[ fig2 ] the kinetic pressure @xmath10 is plotted for @xmath38 , 10 and 20 with @xmath39 and @xmath40 , together with the profiles @xmath73 evaluated in the thomas - fermi approximation , @xmath74 the exact kinetic pressure shows @xmath2 oscillations and has the peculiarity of being negative in the tails .
this microscopic quantum effect , which is missing in the local density description , reflects the fact that in the low density region the kinetic energy decreases with increasing density .
we have checked that our results agree with those reported in @xcite for @xmath75 and 2 , and carried out the calculation of @xmath10 up to @xmath0 . the kinetic pressure profile for n=1000 , as shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] , looks almost indistinguishable from the lda prediction but stills presents a region of negative kinetic pressure in the tails ( inset in fig .
[ fig3 ] ) . in conclusion ,
in this letter we have given a general formula for the exact particle density and kinetic pressure profiles of a 1d many - fermions system in terms of a green s operator in coordinate space .
we have made use of the decimation / renormalization procedure and of other recursive techniques , originally developed to evaluate the spectral properties of quasi-1d systems in solid state physics , to efficiently calculate the exact density profiles of a harmonically confined non - interacting fermi gas . within the same general scheme the particle density could also be evaluated by employing a suitable kirkman - pendry relation @xcite , as will be reported elsewhere .
we have verified that for large number of atoms ( @xmath0 ) the local density approximation reproduces reasonably well the exact profiles except for the region of the tails , where the exact kinetic pressure is negative .
we believe that the present method opens the way for a novel approach to the equilibrium properties of spatially inhomogeneous 1d systems .
the expressions here derived can be extended to finite temperature and to calculate partial density profiles for subgroups of atoms . the kinetic energy density functional
can be studied through the calculation of the function @xmath76/2 $ ] where @xmath77 is obtained by local inversion of the exact profile @xmath8 .
pressure fluctuations will become accessible to study through the evaluation of higher moments of the one - body density matrix .
the density profiles of the harmonically trapped fermi gas in 1d , showing a prominent shell structure as displayed in our calculations , could become observable in experiments on alkali vapours .
it is a pleasure to thank professor n. h. march for useful discussions on fermi vapors and for drawing our attention to the work published in refs .
one of us ( p. v. ) would like to thank professor g. grosso and dr r. farchioni for fruitful discussions .
m. h. anderson , j. r. ensher , m. r. matthews , c. e. wieman , and e. a. cornell , science * 269 * , 198 ( 1995 ) . k. b. davis , m. o. mewes , m. r. andrews , n. j. van druten , d. s. durfee , d. m. kurn , and w. ketterle , phys . rev . lett . * 75 * , 3969 ( 1995 ) . c. c. bradley , c. a. sackett , and r. g. hulet , phys .
* 78 * , 985 ( 1997 ) .
d. g. fried , t. c. killian , l. willmann , d. landhuis , s. c. moss , d. kleppner , and t. j. greytak , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 3811 ( 1998 )
. b. demarco and d.s .
jin , science * 285 * , 1703 ( 1999 ) .
lieb and d.c .
mattis , _ mathematical physics in one dimension _
( academic , new york , 1966 ) .
e. h. lieb and w. liniger , phys . rev . *
130 * , 1605 ( 1963 ) ; e. h. lieb , phys . rev .
* 130 * , 1616 ( 1963 ) .
r. de l. kronig and w. g. penney , proc .
( london ) * a130 * , 499 ( 1931 ) r. haydock , v. heine , and m. j. kelly , j. phys . *
c5 * , 2845 ( 1972 ) ; * c8 * , 2591 ( 1975 ) . e. n. economou , _
green s functions in quantum physics _
( springer , berlin , 1983 ) .
r. farchioni , g. grosso , g. pastori parravicini , phys .
b * 53 * , 4294 ( 1996 ) .
k. nikoli and a. mackinnon , phys .
b * 50 * , 11008 ( 1994 ) .
g.grosso and g. pastori parravicini , adv .
phys . * 62 * , 81 ( 1986 ) ; * 62 * , 131 ( 1986 ) .
p. giannozzi , g. grosso , and g. pastori parravicini , appl .
num . math . * 4 * , 273 ( 1988 ) .
j. schneider and h. wallis , phys .
a * 57 * , 1253 ( 1998 ) .
g. m. bruun and k. burnett , phys .
a * 58 * , 2427 ( 1998 ) .
k. husimi , proc .
phys . math .
jpn * 22 * , 264 ( 1940 ) .
g. p. lawes and n. h. march , j. chem . phys . *
71 * , 1007 ( 1979 ) .
this relation can be proved as follows : @xmath78/\partial\lambda|_{\lambda=0}= \partial \left [ { \rm tr } \ln ( q^{-1}+\lambda{\bbb{i}}_n ) \right]/\partial\lambda|_{\lambda=0}={\rm tr } \left[(q^{-1}+\lambda{\bbb{i}}_n)^{-1}{\bbb{i}}_n \right]_{\lambda=0}={\rm tr}(q{\bbb{i}}_n)={\rm
tr}_n q$ ] r. farchioni , g. grosso and p. vignolo , to appear in phys .
b. p. d. kirkman and j. b. pendry , j. phys .
c * 17 * , 4327 ( 1984 ) . | we propose a new method for the evaluation of the particle density and kinetic pressure profiles in inhomogeneous one - dimensional systems of non - interacting fermions , and apply it to harmonically confined systems of up to @xmath0 fermions .
the method invokes a green s function operator in coordinate space , which is handled by techniques originally developed for the calculation of the density of single - particle states from green s functions in the energy domain .
in contrast to the thomas - fermi ( local density ) approximation , the exact profiles under harmonic confinement show negative local pressure in the tails and a prominent shell structure which may become accessible to observation in magnetically trapped gases of fermionic alkali atoms . the techniques which have led to the achievement of bose - einstein condensation in vapors of bosonic atoms @xcite are currently being used to trap and cool dilute gases of fermionic alkali atoms @xcite . under magnetic confinement the @xmath1-wave collisions between pairs of fermions in a single hyperfine level are suppressed by the pauli principle , and the geometry of the trap can be adapted to have cylindrical symmetry with a transverse confinement which may be hundreds of times stronger than the longitudinal one .
it is thus possible to experimentally realize quasi - onedimensional inhomogeneous systems of almost non - interacting fermions at very low temperature and high purity .
a number of one - dimensional ( 1d ) physical models can be solved exactly @xcite and their solution serves as a test of approximate theories and contributes to the understanding of real systems .
some important examples are the determination of the ground state and excitation spectrum of a hard - core bose gas in 1d @xcite and the solution of the kronig - penney model for the electron energy bands in a 1d crystal lattice @xcite .
the spectral and transport properties of other 1d systems of non - interacting electrons have been studied as models for polymers and quantum wires , using green s function methods @xcite for which ingenious techniques such as a decimation / renormalization procedure @xcite have been developed . in this work we present a new method for the exact evaluation of the ground - state particle density profile in a spin - polarized 1d system of up to large numbers of non - interacting fermions in arbitrary spatial confinement .
in essence we show that , just as the single - particle density of states in the energy domain can be obtained by powerful green s function methods , similar techniques yield the particle density in the 1d space domain .
in fact , our method also allows the evaluation of higher moments of the one - body density matrix : we focus here on its second moment , which is simply proportional to the kinetic energy density and to the kinetic pressure . as an application of the general method we give results for the particle density and kinetic pressure profiles of a degenerate fermi gas in harmonic confinement .
this model is directly relevant to the current experiments on atomic fermi gases and we show that the shell structure noticed for the particle density in earlier theoretical studies in 3d @xcite is greatly enhanced in 1d .
we also use our exact results to test the thomas - fermi ( local density ) approximation in dependence of the number of fermions in the confined gas . |
the last few years have seen the emergence of a standard @xmath1cdm model of cosmology motivated by and consistent with a wide range of observations , including the cosmic microwave background , distant supernovae , big - bang nucleosynthesis , large - scale structure , the abundance of rich galaxy clusters , and local measurements of the hubble constant ( e.g. @xcite ) . the power spectrum of fluctuations ( of temperature , density , flux , shear , etc . )
is the primary statistic used to constrain cosmological parameters from observations of the cosmic microwave background ( @xcite ) , of galaxies ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , of the lyman alpha forest ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , and of weak gravitational lensing ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . from a cosmological standpoint ,
the most precious data lie at large , linear scales , where fluctuations preserve the imprint of their primordial generation .
a generic , albeit not universal , prediction of inflation is that primordial fluctuations should be gaussian . at large , linear scales , observations are consistent with fluctuations being gaussian @xcite .
however , much of the observational data , especially those involving galaxies , lies in the translinear or nonlinear regime .
it remains a matter of ongoing research to elucidate the extent to which nonlinear data can be used to constrain cosmology .
we recently began @xcite a program to measure quantitatively , from cosmological simulations , the fisher information content of the nonlinear matter power spectrum ( specifically , in the first instance , the information about the initial amplitude of the linear power spectrum ) .
for gaussian fluctuations , the power spectrum contains all possible information about cosmological parameters . at nonlinear scales , where fluctuations are non - gaussian
, it is natural to start by measuring information in the power spectrum , although it seems likely that additional information resides in the 3-point and higher order correlation functions ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . measuring the fisher information in the power spectrum involves measuring the covariance matrix of power . for gaussian fluctuations ,
the expected covariance of estimates of power is known analytically , but at nonlinear scales the covariance of power must be estimated from simulations . a common way to estimate the covariance matrix of a quantity is to measure its covariance over an ensemble of computer simulations ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
however , a reliable estimate of covariance can be computationally expensive , requiring many , perhaps hundreds ( @xcite ; @xcite ) of realizations . on the other hand
it is physically obvious that the fluctuations in the values of quantities over the different parts of a single simulation must somehow encode the covariance of the quantities .
if the covariance could be measured from single simulations , then it would be possible to measure covariance from fewer , and from higher quality , simulations . in any case
, the ability to measure covariance from a single simulation can be useful in identifying simulations whose statistical properties are atypical .
a fundamental difficulty with estimating covariances from single simulations in cosmology is that the data are correlated over all scales , from small to large . as described by @xcite ,
such correlations invalidate some of the `` jackknife '' and `` bootstrap '' schemes suggested in the literature . in jackknife , variance is inferred from how much a quantity varies when some segments of the data are kept , and some deleted .
bootstrap is like jackknife , except that deleted segments are replaced with other segments . as part of the work leading to the present paper , we investigated a form of the bootstrap procedure , in which we filled each octant of a simulation cube with a block of data selected randomly from the cube
unfortunately , the sharp edges of the blocks introduced undesirable small scale power , which seemed to compromise the effort to measure covariance of power reliably . such effects can be mitigated by tapering @xcite .
however , it seemed to us that bootstrapping , like jackknifing , is a form of re - weighting data , and that surely the best way to re - weight data would be to apply the most slowly possible varying weightings . for a periodic box , such weightings
would be comprised of the largest scale modes , the fundamentals . in the present paper , [ estimate ]
, we consider applying an arbitrary weighting to the density of a periodic cosmological simulation , and we show how the power spectrum ( and its covariance , and the covariance of its covariance ) of the weighted density are related to the true power spectrum ( and its covariance , and the covariance of its covariance ) . we confirm mathematically the intuitive idea that weighting with fundamentals yields the most reliable estimate of covariance of power . multiplying the density in real space by some weighting is equivalent to convolving the density in fourier space with the fourier transform of the weighting .
this causes the power spectrum ( and its covariance , and the covariance of its covariance ) to be convolved with the fourier transform of the square ( and fourth , and eighth powers ) of the weighting .
the convolution does least damage when the weighting window is as narrow as possible in fourier space , which means composed of fundamentals . in [ weightings ]
we show how to design a best set of weightings , by minimizing the expected variance of the resulting estimate of covariance of power .
these considerations lead us to recommend a specific set of @xmath0 weightings , each consisting of a combination of fundamental modes .
this paper should have stopped neatly at this point .
unfortunately , numerical simulations , described in a companion paper @xcite , revealed an unexpected ( one might say insidious ) , substantial discrepancy at nonlinear scales between the variance of power estimated by the weightings method and the variance of power estimated by the ensemble method . in
[ beatcoupling ] we argue that this discrepancy arises from beat - coupling , a nonlinear gravitational coupling to the large - scale beat mode between closely spaced nonlinear wavenumbers , when the power spectrum is measured from fourier modes at anything other than infinitely sharp sets of wavenumbers .
surprisingly , in cosmologically realistic simulations , the covariance of power is dominated at nonlinear scales by this beat - coupling to large scales .
we discuss the beat - coupling problem in
[ discussion ] .
beat - coupling is relevant to observations because real galaxy surveys yield fourier modes in finite bands of wavenumber @xmath2 , of width @xmath3 where @xmath4 is a chararacteristic linear size of the survey .
section [ summary ] summarizes the results .
the fundamental idea of this paper is to apply an ensemble of weightings to a ( non - gaussian , in general ) density field , and to estimate the covariance of the power spectrum from the scatter in power between different weightings .
this section derives the relation between the power spectrum of a weighted density field and the true power spectrum , along with its expected covariance , and the covariance of its covariance .
it is shown , equations ( [ piapprox ] ) , ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) , and ( [ dphati2dphatj2 g ] ) , that the expected ( ( covariance of ) covariance of ) shell - averaged power of weighted density fields is simply proportional to the true ( ( covariance of ) covariance of ) shell - averaged power , provided that two approximations are made .
the two approximations are , firstly , that the power spectrum and trispectrum are sufficiently slowly varying functions of their arguments , equations ( [ papprox ] ) and ( [ tapprox ] ) , and , secondly , that power is estimated in sufficiently broad shells in @xmath2-space , equation ( [ broadshellapprox ] ) .
the required approximations are most accurate if the weightings contain only the largest scale fourier modes , such as the weightings containing only fundamental modes proposed in [ weightings ] . as will be discussed in
[ beatcoupling ] , the apparently innocent assumption , equation ( [ tapprox ] ) , that the trispectrum is a slowly varying function of its arguments , is incorrect , because it sets to zero some important beat - coupling contributions . however , it is convenient to pretend in this section and the next , [ estimate ] and [ weightings ] , that the assumption ( [ tapprox ] ) is true , and then to consider in [ beatcoupling ] how the results are modified when the beat - coupling contributions to the trispectrum are included .
ultimately we find , [ largescale ] , that the weightings method remains valid when beat - couplings are included , and , [ notquiteweightings ] , that the minimum variance weightings derived in [ weightings ] , while no longer exactly minimum variance , should be close enough to remain good for practical application .
this section is necessarily rather technical , because it is necessary to distinguish carefully between various flavours of power spectrum : estimated versus expected ; unweighted versus weighted ; non - shell - averaged versus shell - averaged .
subsections [ p ] to [ ddp ] present expressions for the various power spectra , their covariances , and the covariances of their covariances .
subsections [ subtractmeanp ] and [ subtractmeanddp ] show how the expressions are modified when , as is usually the case , deviations in power must be measured relative to an estimated rather than an expected value of power .
let @xmath5 denote the density of a statistically homogeneous random field at position @xmath6 in a periodic box .
choose the unit of length so that the box has unit side .
the density @xmath5 might represent , perhaps , a realization of the nonlinearly evolved distribution of dark matter , or of galaxies
. the density could be either continuous or discrete ( particles ) .
expanded in fourier modes @xmath7 , the density @xmath5 is is used in both real and fourier space .
the justification for this notation is that @xmath8 is the same vector in hilbert space irrespective of the basis with respect to which it is expanded .
see for example @xcite for a pedagogical exposition . ]
@xmath9 thanks to periodicity , the sum is over an integral lattice of wavenumbers , @xmath10 with integer @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 .
the expectation value @xmath14 of the density defines the true mean density @xmath15 , which without loss of generality we take to equal unity @xmath16 the deviation @xmath17 of the density from the mean is @xmath18 the expectation values of the fourier amplitudes vanish , @xmath19 , except for the zeroth mode , whose expectation value equals the mean density , @xmath20 .
the fourier amplitude @xmath21 of the zeroth mode is the actual density of the realization , which could be equal to , or differ slightly from , the true mean density @xmath15 , depending on whether the mean density of the realization was constrained to equal the true density , or not . because the density field is by assumption statistically homogeneous
, the expected covariance of fourier amplitudes @xmath7 is a diagonal matrix @xmath22 here @xmath23 denotes the discrete delta - function , @xmath24 and @xmath25 is the power spectrum .
note that there would normally be an extra factor of @xmath26 on the left hand side of equation ( [ drhokdrhok ] ) , but it is fine to omit the factor here because the mean density is normalized to unity , equation ( [ rhobar ] ) .
the reason for dropping the factor of @xmath26 is to maintain notational consistency with equation ( [ pi ] ) below for the power spectrum of weighted density ( where the deviation in density is necessarily _ not _ divided by the mean ) .
the symmetry @xmath27 in equation ( [ drhokdrhok ] ) expresses pair exchange symmetry .
below , [ shell ] , we will assume that the density field is statistical isotropic , in which case the power is a function @xmath28 only of the scalar wavenumber @xmath29 , but for now we stick to the more general case where power is a function @xmath25 of vector wavenumber @xmath30 .
let @xmath31 denote the @xmath32th member of a set of real - valued weighting functions , and let @xmath33 denote the density weighted by the @xmath32th weighting @xmath34 the fourier amplitudes @xmath35 of the weighted density are convolutions of the fourier amplitudes of the weighting and the density : @xmath36 reality of the weighting functions implies @xmath37 the expected mean @xmath38 of the weighted density is proportional to the weighting , @xmath39 in which a factor of @xmath15 on the right hand side has been omitted because the mean density has been normalized to unity , equation ( [ rhobar ] ) .
the deviation @xmath40 of the weighted density from the mean is @xmath41 in fourier space the expected mean @xmath42 of the weighted density is @xmath43 and the deviation @xmath44 of the weighted density from the mean is @xmath45 the deviations @xmath44 in the fourier amplitudes of the weighted density are convolutions of the weighting and the deviation in the density @xmath46 similarly to equation ( [ rhoik ] ) . the expected covariance between two weighted densities @xmath47 and @xmath48 at wavenumbers @xmath49 and @xmath50 is , from equations ( [ drhokdrhok ] ) and ( [ drhoik ] ) , @xmath51 the weighting breaks statistical homogeneity , so the expected covariance matrix of fourier amplitudes @xmath35 , equation ( [ rhoikrhojk ] ) , is not diagonal .
nevertheless we _ define _ the power spectrum @xmath52 of the @xmath32th weighted density by the diagonal elements of the covariance matrix , the variance @xmath53 note that this definition ( [ pi ] ) of the power spectrum @xmath52 differs from the usual definition of power in that the deviations @xmath44 on the right are fourier transforms of the deviations @xmath40 _ not _ divided by the mean density @xmath54 ( dividing by the mean density would simply unweight the weighting , defeating the whole point of the procedure ) .
the power spectrum @xmath52 defined by equation ( [ pi ] ) is related to the true power spectrum @xmath25 by , equation ( [ rhoikrhojk ] ) , @xmath55 now make the approximation that the power spectrum @xmath56 at the wavenumber @xmath57 displaced by @xmath58 from @xmath30 is approximately equal to the power spectrum @xmath25 at the undisplaced wavenumber @xmath30 @xmath59 this approximation is good provided that the power spectrum @xmath25 is slowly varying as a function of wavenumber @xmath30 , and that the displacement @xmath58 is small compared to @xmath30 . in
[ weightings ] we constrain the weightings @xmath60 to contain only fundamental modes , @xmath61 with @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 = @xmath65 , so that the displacement @xmath58 is as small as it can be without being zero , and the approximation ( [ papprox ] ) is therefore as good as it can be .
the approximation ( [ papprox ] ) becomes exact in the case of a constant , or shot noise , power spectrum @xmath25 , except at @xmath66 . under approximation ( [ papprox ] ) , the power spectrum of the @xmath32th weighted density is @xmath67 which is just proportional to the true power spectrum @xmath25 . without loss of generality
, let each weighting @xmath60 be normalized so that the factor on the right hand side of equation ( [ piapproxw ] ) is unity @xmath68 then the power spectrum @xmath52 of the weighted density is approximately equal to the true power spectrum @xmath25 @xmath69 thus , in the approximation ( [ papprox ] ) and with the normalization ( [ wnorm ] ) , measurements of the power spectrum @xmath52 of weighted densities provide estimates of the true power spectrum @xmath25 . the plan is to use the scatter in the estimates of power over a set of weightings to estimate the covariance matrix of power .
let @xmath70 denote the power spectrum of unweighted density at wavevector @xmath30 measured from a simulation , the hat distinguishing it from the true power spectrum @xmath25 : @xmath71 below , [ shell ] , we will invoke statistical isotropy , and we will average over a shell in @xmath2-space , but in equation ( [ phat ] ) there is no averaging because there is just one simulation , and just one specific wavenumber @xmath30 . because of statistical fluctuations , the estimate @xmath70 will in general differ from the true power @xmath25 , but by definition the expectation value of the estimate equals the true value , @xmath72 .
the deviation @xmath73 in the power is the difference between the measured and expected value : @xmath74 the expected covariance of power involves the covariance of the covariance of unweighted densities @xmath75 } & & \nonumber \\ & \times & \bigl [ \delta\rho({{\bmath k}}_3 ) \delta\rho({{\bmath k}}_4 ) - 1_{{{\bmath k}}_3 + { { \bmath k}}_4 } p({{\bmath k}}_3 ) \bigr ]
\bigr\rangle \nonumber \\ & = & \left ( 1_{{{\bmath k}}_1 + { { \bmath k}}_3 } 1_{{{\bmath k}}_2 + { { \bmath k}}_4 } + 1_{{{\bmath k}}_1 + { { \bmath k}}_4 } 1_{{{\bmath k}}_2 + { { \bmath k}}_3 } \right ) p({{\bmath k}}_1 ) p({{\bmath k}}_2 ) \nonumber \\ & & \mbox { } + 1_{{{\bmath k}}_1 + { { \bmath k}}_2 + { { \bmath k}}_3 + { { \bmath k}}_4 } t({{\bmath k}}_1 , { { \bmath k}}_2 , { { \bmath k}}_3 , { { \bmath k}}_4 ) \label{eta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is a sum of a reducible , gaussian part , the terms proportional to @xmath76 , and an irreducible , non - gaussian part , the term involving the trispectrum @xmath77 .
equation ( [ eta ] ) essentially defines what is meant by the trispectrum @xmath78 .
exchange symmetry implies that the trispectrum function is invariant under permutations of its 4 arguments .
the momentum - conserving delta - function @xmath79 in front of the trispectrum @xmath78 expresses translation invariance .
it follows from equation ( [ drhokdrhokdrhokdrhok ] ) that the expected covariance of estimates of power is @xmath80 similarly to equations ( [ phat ] ) and ( [ dphat ] ) , let @xmath81 denote the power spectrum of the @xmath32th weighted density at wavevector @xmath30 measured from a simulation @xmath82 and let @xmath83 denote the deviation between the measured and expected value @xmath84 the expected covariance between the power spectra of the @xmath32th and @xmath85th weighted densities is , from equations ( [ drhoik ] ) and ( [ drhokdrhokdrhokdrhok ] ) , @xmath86 \ . } & & \end{aligned}\ ] ] assume now that the unweighted density field @xmath87 is statistically isotropic , so that the true power spectrum @xmath28 is a function only of the absolute value @xmath29 of its argument . in estimating the power @xmath28 from a simulation , one would typically average the measured power over a spherical shell @xmath88 of wavenumbers in @xmath2-space .
actually the arguments below generalize immediately to the case where the power is not isotropic , in which case @xmath88 might be chosen to be some localized patch in @xmath2-space . however , we shall assume isotropy , and refer to @xmath88 as a shell .
let @xmath89 denote the measured power averaged over a shell @xmath88 about scalar wavenumber @xmath2 ( the estimated shell - averaged power @xmath89 is written in lower case to distinguish it from the estimate @xmath70 of power at a single specific wavevector @xmath30 ) : @xmath90 here @xmath91 is the number of modes @xmath7 in the shell @xmath88 .
we count @xmath7 and its complex conjugate @xmath92 as contributing two distinct modes , the real and imaginary parts of @xmath7 .
the expectation value of the estimates @xmath89 of shell - averaged power equals the true shell - averaged power @xmath93 @xmath94 the deviation @xmath95 between the measured and expected value of shell - averaged power is @xmath96 the expected covariance of shell - averaged estimates of power is , from equations ( [ dphat ] ) and ( [ dphatdphat ] ) , @xmath97 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the usual case , the shells @xmath98 would be taken to be non - overlapping , in which case the intersection @xmath99 in equation ( [ dphatdphat ] ) is equal either to @xmath100 if @xmath100 and @xmath101 are the same shell , or to the empty set if @xmath100 and @xmath101 are different shells . similarly to equation ( [ phat ] ) , let @xmath102 denote the measured shell - averaged power spectrum of the @xmath32th weighted density at wavenumber @xmath2 @xmath103 the expectation value of the estimates @xmath102 is ( compare eq .
( [ p ] ) ) @xmath104 in the approximation ( [ papprox ] ) of a slowly varying power spectrum , and with the normalization ( [ wnorm ] ) , the expected shell - averaged power spectrum @xmath105 of the weighted density is approximately equal to the shell - averaged power spectrum @xmath93 of the unweighted density ( compare eq .
( [ piapprox ] ) ) @xmath106 the deviation @xmath107 between the measured and expected values is ( compare eq .
( [ dphat ] ) ) @xmath108 the expected covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities is , from equations ( [ dphati ] ) and ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) , @xmath109 \ . } & & \end{aligned}\ ] ] assume , analogously to approximation ( [ papprox ] ) for the power spectrum , that the trispectrum function @xmath110 in equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) is sufficiently slowly varying , and the displacements @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 sufficiently small , that @xmath115 in [ beatcoupling ] we will revisit the approximation ( [ tapprox ] ) , and show that in fact it is not true , in a way that proves to be interesting and observationally relevant . in this section and
the next ,
[ weightings ] , however , we will continue to assume that the approximation ( [ tapprox ] ) is valid . in the approximations
( [ papprox ] ) and ( [ tapprox ] ) that the power spectrum and trispectrum are both approximately constant for small displacements of their arguments , the covariance of shell - averaged power spectra , equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) , becomes @xmath116 \ .
} & & \end{aligned}\ ] ] consider the gaussian ( @xmath117 ) part of this expression ( [ dphatidphatjapprox ] ) . in the true covariance of shell - averaged power ,
equation ( [ dphatdphat ] ) , the gaussian part of the covariance is a diagonal matrix , with zero covariance between non - overlapping shells . by contrast , the gaussian part of the covariance of power of weighted densities , equation ( [ dphatidphatjapprox ] ) , is not quite diagonal . in effect , the gaussian variance in each shell is smeared by convolution with the weighting function , causing some of the gaussian variance near the boundaries of adjacent shells to leak into covariance between the shells . in [ weightings ] , we advocate restricting the weightings @xmath118 to contain only fundamental modes , which keeps smearing to a minimum .
whatever the case , if each shell @xmath88 is broad compared the extent of the weightings @xmath118 in @xmath2-space , then the smearing is relatively small , and can be approximated as zero .
mathematically , this broad - shell approximation amounts to approximating @xmath119 in the broad - shell approximation ( [ broadshellapprox ] ) , the expected covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities , equation ( [ dphatidphatjapprox ] ) , simplifies to @xmath120 where the factor @xmath121 is @xmath122 in real ( as opposed to fourier ) space , the factor @xmath121 is @xmath123 equation ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) is the most basic result of the present paper .
it states that the expected covariance between estimates of power from various weightings is proportional to the true covariance matrix of power .
the nice thing about the result ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) is that the constant of proportionality @xmath121 depends only on the weightings @xmath118 and @xmath124 , and is independent both of the power spectrum @xmath25 and of the wavenumbers @xmath125 and @xmath126 in the covariance @xmath127 .
equation ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) provides the formal mathematical justification for estimating the covariance of power from the scatter in estimates of power over an ensemble of weightings of density . in [ weightings ] we will craft the weightings @xmath118 so as to minimize the expected variance of the estimated covariance of power .
the resulting weightings are `` best possible '' , within the framework of the technique . to determine the minimum variance estimator , it is necessary to have an expression for the ( co)variance of the covariance of power , which we now derive .
the expected covariance between estimates @xmath128 of covariance of power is a covariance of covariance of covariance of densities , an 8-point object .
this object involves , in addition to the 8-point function , a linear combination of products of lower - order functions adding to 8 points .
the types of terms are ( cf . @xcite ) @xmath129 in which @xmath130 signifies a product of four 2-point functions , @xmath131 signifies a product of a 2-point function with two 3-point functions , and so on , up to @xmath132 , which signifies the 8-point function .
we do not pause to write out all the terms explicitly , because in the same slowly - varying and broad - shell approximations that led to equation ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) , the covariance of covariance of power spectra of weighted densities simplifies to @xmath133 } & & \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}_j(k_4 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}_j(k_4 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \bigr\rangle \nonumber \\ & \approx & g_{ij } \bigl\langle \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}(k_1 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_2 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}(k_1 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_2 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_4 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_4 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \bigr\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath134 is , analogously to equation ( [ fij ] ) , @xmath135 in real ( as opposed to fourier ) space , the factors @xmath134 are @xmath136 equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 g ] ) states , analogously to equation ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) , that the expected covariance of covariance of power spectra of weighted densities is proportional to the true covariance of covariance of power . as with the factors @xmath121 , equation ( [ fij ] ) , the constants of proportionality @xmath134 , equation ( [ gij ] ) , depend only on the weightings @xmath118 and @xmath124 , and are independent of the power spectrum @xmath25 or of any of the higher order functions , and are also independent of the wavenumbers @xmath125 , ... , @xmath137 in the covariance , a gratifyingly simple result .
the deviation @xmath107 of the shell - averaged power spectrum of the @xmath32th weighted density was defined above , equation ( [ dphati ] ) , to be the difference between the measured value @xmath102 and the expected value @xmath105 of shell - averaged power .
however , the expected power spectrum @xmath105 ( the true power spectrum ) is probably unknown .
even if the true power spectrum is known in the linear regime ( because the simulation was set up with a known linear power spectrum ) , the true power spectrum in the non - linear regime is not known precisely , but must be estimated from the simulation .
in practice , therefore , it is necessary to measure the deviation in power not from the true value , but rather from some estimated mean value .
two strategies naturally present themselves .
the first strategy is to take the mean power spectrum to be the measured power spectrum @xmath89 of the unweighted density of the simulation . in this case
the deviation @xmath138 between the measured shell - averaged power spectra of the weighted and unweighted densities is ( the deviation @xmath138 is primed to distinguish it from the deviation @xmath107 , eq .
( [ dphati ] ) ) @xmath139 the second strategy is to take the mean power spectrum to be the average over weightings of the measured power spectra of weighted densities , @xmath140 . in this case
the deviation @xmath138 between the measured shell - averaged power spectra and their average is ( with the same primed notation for the deviation @xmath138 as in eq .
( [ dphati1 ] ) ; it is up to the user to decide which strategy to adopt ) @xmath141 the advantage of the first strategy , equation ( [ dphati1 ] ) , is that the power spectrum @xmath89 of the unweighted density is the most accurate ( by symmetry ) estimate of the power spectrum that can be measured from a single simulation .
its disadvantage is that measurements of power spectra of weighted densities yield ( slightly ) biassed estimates of the power spectrum of unweighted density , because the approximation ( [ papprox ] ) can lead to a slight bias if , as is typical , the power spectrum @xmath25 is not constant . in other words ,
the approximation @xmath142 , equation ( [ piapprox ] ) , is not an exact equality .
although the bias is likely to be small , it contributes systematically to estimates of deviations of power , causing the covariance of power to be systematically over - estimated .
the second strategy , equation ( [ dphati2 ] ) , is unaffected by this bias , but the statistical uncertainty is slightly larger . probably the sensible thing to do
is to apply both strategies , and to check that they yield consistent results . to allow a concise expression for the covariance of power to be written down , it is convenient to introduce @xmath143 , defined to be the fourier transform of the squared real - space weighting , @xmath144 , @xmath145 the normalization condition ( [ wnorm ] ) on the weightings @xmath118 is equivalent to requiring @xmath146 in terms of @xmath143 , the factors @xmath121 , equation ( [ fij ] ) , relating the expected covariance matrix of power spectra of weighted densities to the true covariance matrix of power are @xmath147 an expression is desired for the covariance of power in terms of the deviations @xmath138 , equations ( [ dphati1 ] ) or ( [ dphati2 ] ) , instead of @xmath107 . for this ,
a modified version of @xmath143 is required . for strategy one ,
equation ( [ dphati1 ] ) , @xmath148 whereas for strategy two , equation ( [ dphati2 ] ) , @xmath149 in either case , the expected covariance @xmath150 of estimates of shell - averaged power spectra is related to the true covariance @xmath151 of shell - averaged power by ( compare eq .
( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) ) @xmath152 where the factors @xmath153 are ( compare eq .
( [ fijv ] ) ) @xmath154 the approximation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) is valid under the same assumptions made in deriving the approximation ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) , namely the slowly - varying approximations ( [ papprox ] ) and ( [ tapprox ] ) , and the broad - shell approximation ( [ broadshellapprox ] ) . the expression ( [ gij ] ) for the covariance of covariance of power must likewise be modified to allow for the fact that the deviations in power must be measured as deviations not from the true power spectrum but from either ( strategy 1 ) the power spectrum of the unweighted density , or ( strategy 2 ) the averaged power spectrum of the weighted densities . for this purpose
it is convenient to define @xmath155 to be the fourier transform of the fourth power of the real - space weighting , @xmath156 , @xmath157 in terms of @xmath155 , the factors @xmath134 , equation ( [ gij ] ) , relating the expected covariance of covariance of power spectra of weighted densities to the true covariance of covariance of power are @xmath158 to write down an expression for the covariance of the covariance of the deviations @xmath138 instead of @xmath107 , define a modified version @xmath159 of @xmath155 by @xmath160 which is the same as equation ( [ ui ] ) but with primed @xmath161 , equations ( [ vpi1 ] ) or ( [ vpi2 ] ) , in place of @xmath143
. then the covariance of the covariance of the deviations @xmath138 is related to the true covariance of covariance of shell - averaged power by ( compare eq .
( [ dphati2dphatj2 g ] ) ) @xmath162 } & & \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_4 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_4 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \bigr\rangle \nonumber \\ & \approx & g^\prime_{ij } \bigl\langle \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}(k_1 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_2 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}(k_1 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_2 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_4 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_4 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \bigr\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the factors @xmath163 are ( compare eq .
( [ giju ] ) ) @xmath164 equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gp ] ) gives the expected covariance of the difference between the estimate of covariance @xmath165 and its expectation value @xmath166 , but this latter expectation value is again an unknown quantity .
what can actually be measured is the difference between the estimate @xmath165 and its average over weightings @xmath167 . to write down an expression for the covariance of the covariance relative to the weightings - averaged covariance rather than the expected covariance ,
define a modified version @xmath168 of @xmath159 , equation ( [ upi ] ) , by @xmath169 then the covariance of the covariance of the deviations @xmath138 is related to the true covariance of covariance of shell - averaged power by ( compare eqs .
( [ dphati2dphatj2 g ] ) and ( [ dphati2dphatj2gp ] ) ) @xmath170 } & & \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_4 ) - \frac{1}{n } \sum_l \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_l(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_l(k_4 ) \bigr ] \bigr\rangle \nonumber \\ & \approx & g^{\prime\prime}_{ij } \bigl\langle \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}(k_1 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_2 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}(k_1 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_2 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_4 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}(k_4 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \bigr\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the factors @xmath171 are ( compare eqs .
( [ giju ] ) and ( [ gpiju ] ) ) @xmath172 approximations ( [ dphati2dphatj2gp ] ) and ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpp ] ) are valid under the same approximations as approximations ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) and ( [ dphati2dphatj2 g ] ) , namely the slowly - varying approximations ( [ papprox ] ) and ( [ tapprox ] ) , and the broad - shell approximation ( [ broadshellapprox ] ) .
it was shown in [ estimate ] that the expected covariance between shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities is proportional to the true covariance of shell - average power , equation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) .
it follows that the scatter in estimates of power from different weightings can be used to estimate the true covariance of power . in this section
we use minimum variance arguments to derive a set of @xmath0 weightings , equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) , which we recommend , [ recommend ] , for practical application . in this section as in the previous one ,
[ estimate ] , we continue to ignore the beat - coupling contributions to the ( covariance of ) covariance of power .
these beat - couplings are discussed in
[ beatcoupling ] , which in [ notquiteweightings ] concludes that the minimum variance weightings derived in the present section , although no longer precisely minimum variance , should be satisfactory for practical use . in the first place
, we choose to use weightings @xmath118 that contain only combinations of fundamental modes , that is , @xmath10 with @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 running over @xmath65 . by restricting the weightings to fundamental modes
only , we ensure that the two approximations required for equation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) to be valid are as good as can be .
the first approximation was the slowly - varying approximation , that both the power spectrum @xmath25 and the trispectrum @xmath173 remain approximately constant , equations ( [ papprox ] ) and ( [ tapprox ] ) , when their arguments are displaced by the extent of the weightings @xmath60 , that is , by amounts @xmath58 for which @xmath60 is non - zero .
the second approximation was the broad - shell approximation , that the shells @xmath88 over which the estimated power @xmath102 is averaged are broad compared to the extent of the weightings @xmath60 , which reduces the relative importance of smearing of gaussian variance from the edges of adjacent shells into covariance between the shells .
in the second place , we choose to use weightings that are symmetrically related to each other , which seems a natural thing to do given the cubic symmetry of a periodic box . choosing a symmetrically related set of weightings not only simplifies practical application of the procedure , but also simplifies the mathematics of determining a best set of fourier coefficients @xmath118 , as will be seen in [ minvar ] below .
there are @xmath174 rotational and reflectional transformations of a cube , corresponding to choosing the @xmath175-axis in any of 6 directions , then the @xmath176-axis in any of 4 directions perpendicular to the @xmath175-axis , and finally the @xmath177-axis in either of the 2 directions perpendicular to the @xmath175- and @xmath176-axes . to the rotational and reflectional transformations we adjoin the possibility of translations by a fraction ( half , quarter , eighth ) of a box along any of the 3 axes , for a net total of @xmath178 possible transformations .
in practice , however , the minimum variance weightings @xmath118 presented in [ theweightings ] prove to possess a high degree of symmetry , greatly reducing the number of distinct weightings . for brevity ,
let @xmath179 denote an estimate of the covariance of shell - averaged power from the @xmath32th weighted density ( the arguments @xmath125 and @xmath126 on @xmath179 are suppressed , since they play no role in the arguments that follow ) @xmath180 the quantity @xmath181 here is any diagonal element @xmath182 of the matrix of factors @xmath153 defined by equation ( [ fpijv ] ) ; the diagonal elements @xmath183 are identically equal for all @xmath32 because the weightings @xmath118 are by assumption symmetrically related .
the factor @xmath184 in equation ( [ xhati ] ) ensures that @xmath179 is , in accordance with equation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) , an estimate of the true covariance of shell - averaged power , which we abbreviate @xmath185 , @xmath186 the approximation ( [ xi ] ) is valid under the assumptions made in deriving equation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) , namely the slowly - varying approximations ( [ papprox ] ) and ( [ tapprox ] ) , and the broad - shell approximation ( [ broadshellapprox ] ) .
let @xmath187 denote the number of weightings .
because the weightings are by assumption symmetrically related , it follows immediately that the best estimate of the true covariance of shell - averaged power @xmath151 will be a straight average over the ensemble of weightings @xmath188 it remains to determine the best fourier coefficients @xmath118 for a representative weighting @xmath32 .
the best set is that which minimizes the expected variance @xmath189 of the estimate ( [ xhat ] ) . according to equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gp ] ) ,
this expected variance @xmath190 is approximately proportional to a factor that depends on the weightings @xmath191 \sim \end{array}\ ! } \frac{1}{(f^\prime n)^2 } \sum_{ij } g^\prime_{ij}\ ] ] multiplied by another factor that is independent of weightings , namely the true covariance of covariance of power , the expression to the right of the coefficient @xmath163 in equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gp ] ) .
note that the variance @xmath192 is the expected variance @xmath193 about the true value @xmath185 , so it is @xmath163 , equation ( [ gpiju ] ) , not @xmath171 , equation ( [ gppiju ] ) , that appears in equation ( [ dxhat2 ] ) . equation ( [ dxhat2 ] ) shows that minimizing the variance @xmath190 with respect to the coefficients @xmath118 of the weightings is equivalent to minimizing the quantity on the right hand side of the proportionality ( [ dxhat2 ] ) . from equations ( [ fpijv ] ) , ( [ upi ] ) , and ( [ gpiju ] )
it follows that this factor can be written @xmath194 where @xmath195 denotes the average of @xmath159 , equation ( [ upi ] ) , over weightings @xmath196 note that @xmath197 .
equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) shows that minimizing the variance @xmath190 involves computing @xmath195 , equation ( [ up ] ) .
we evaluate @xmath195 using an algebraic manipulation program ( mathematica ) as follows . a representative weighting @xmath118 contains @xmath198 non - zero fourier coefficients , since by assumption it contains only combinations of fundamental modes . the coefficients @xmath118 and @xmath199 , which are complex conjugates of each other , effectively contribute two coefficients , the real and imaginary parts of @xmath118 .
first , evaluate @xmath143 , equation ( [ vi ] ) , in terms of the coefficients @xmath118 of the representative weighting .
the @xmath143 are non - zero for 125 values of @xmath30 , those whose components @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 run over @xmath200 .
each @xmath143 is a quadratic polynomial in the @xmath198 fourier coefficients .
next , modify @xmath143 to get @xmath161 , equation ( [ vpi1 ] ) , by setting the coefficient for @xmath201 to zero .
again , each @xmath161 is a quadratic polynomial in the @xmath198 fourier coefficients . for definiteness , we adopt strategy one , equation ( [ vpi1 ] ) , rather than strategy two , equation ( [ vpi2 ] ) . that is , we assume that the deviation @xmath138 in the power spectrum of the @xmath32th weighting of density is being measured relative to the power spectrum of the unweighted density , rather than relative to the average of the power spectra of the weighted densities . in the end it turns out , [ theweightings2 ] , that the minimum variance solution is the same for both strategies , so there is no loss in restricting to strategy one .
next , evaluate @xmath159 , equation ( [ upi ] ) .
the @xmath159 are non - zero for 729 values of @xmath30 , those whose components @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 run over @xmath202 .
each @xmath159 is a quartic polynomial in the @xmath198 fourier coefficients . next ,
evaluate @xmath195 , equation ( [ up ] ) , the average of @xmath159 over weightings @xmath32 .
consider first averaging @xmath159 over the 48 different rotational and reflectional transformations of the weighting .
the averaged result @xmath195 possesses rotational and reflectional symmetry , so that @xmath195 is equal to its value at @xmath30 with components permuted and reflected in such a way that @xmath203 , of which there are @xmath204 distinct cases .
the rotationally and translationally symmetrized function @xmath195 can be computed by averaging the values of @xmath159 at @xmath205 values of @xmath30 into @xmath204 distinct bins .
the symmetrized function satisfies @xmath206 , so is necessarily real .
thus the absolute value sign around @xmath207 in equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) can be omitted .
now consider averaging the @xmath159 over translations by half a box in each dimension .
there are @xmath208 such translations , and each translation is characterized by a triple @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 giving the number of half boxes translated in each dimension , either zero or one for each component .
the effect of the translation is to multiply each coefficient @xmath118 by @xmath212 , that is , by @xmath213 according to whether @xmath214 is even or odd .
the sign change carries through the definitions ( [ vi ] ) of @xmath143 and ( [ vpi1 ] ) of @xmath161 to the definition ( [ upi ] ) of @xmath159 , and thence to the definition ( [ up ] ) of @xmath195 .
that is , the effect of a translation by half a box is to multiply @xmath195 by @xmath212 .
it follows that , after averaging over translations , @xmath195 vanishes if any component of @xmath30 is odd , leaving only cases where all components of @xmath30 are even .
consequently , @xmath159 need be evaluated only at the @xmath215 wavevectors @xmath30 all of whose components are even .
the symmetrized function @xmath195 can be computed by averaging the values of @xmath159 at the @xmath215 values of @xmath30 into the @xmath216 distinct bins with even @xmath203 .
it is amusing that increasing the number of weightings ( by a factor @xmath132 , if all translations yield distinct weightings ) actually decreases the computational work required to find the best fourier coefficients @xmath118 .
adjoining translations by a quarter of a box simplifies the problem of finding the minimum variance solution for the coefficients @xmath118 even further .
there are @xmath217 such translations , and each translation is characterized by a triple @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 , each component running over @xmath218 to @xmath219 , giving the number of quarter boxes translated in each dimension .
the effect of the translation is to multiply each coefficient @xmath118 by @xmath220 .
the effect propagates through to the symmetrized function @xmath195 , which is therefore non - zero only for the @xmath198 wavevectors @xmath30 all of whose components are multiples of @xmath221
. the symmetrized function @xmath195 can be computed by averaging the values of @xmath159 at the @xmath198 values of @xmath30 into the @xmath221 distinct bins with @xmath203 and each component a multiple of @xmath221 .
one more step , adjoining translations by an eighth of a box , reduces the problem of finding the minimum variance solution to a triviality . after adjoining translations by an eighth of a box ,
the symmetrized function @xmath195 vanishes except at @xmath201 .
the function to be minimized , the right hand side of equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) , is therefore identically equal to @xmath222 , and any arbitrary weighting therefore yields a minimum variance solution .
though amusing , the result is not terribly useful , because it involves a vast number , @xmath178 , of weightings .
physically , if there are enough weightings , then together they exhaust the information about the covariance of power , however badly crafted the weightings may be . as will be seen in
[ theweightings ] , there are much simpler solutions that achieve the absolute minimum possible variance , for which the right hand side of equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) equals @xmath222 , with far fewer weightings . the argument above has shown that the problem of finding the minimum variance solution for @xmath118 attains its simplest non - trivial form if the weightings are generated from a representative weighting by rotations , reflections , and translations by quarter of a box , a total of @xmath223 symmetries . in this case , the weighting - dependent factor in the variance of covariance of power , the right hand side of equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) , becomes a rational function , a ratio of two @xmath132th order polynomials in the @xmath198 fourier coefficients @xmath118 , the numerator being a sum @xmath224 of squares of @xmath221 quartics , and the denominator @xmath225 the square of a quartic .
it is this function that we minimize in [ theweightings ] to find a best set of weightings .
the minimum variance solution is independent of the overall normalization of the coefficients @xmath118 , since the quantity being minimized , the ratio on the right hand side of equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) , is independent of the normalization of @xmath118 .
once the minimum variance solution for the coefficients @xmath118 has been found , the coefficients can be renormalized to satisfy the normalization condition ( [ wnorm ] ) that ensures that the estimates @xmath102 of the shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities are estimates of the true shell - averaged power @xmath93 , equations ( [ pi ] ) and ( [ piapprox ] ) . the previous subsection , [ minvar ] , described how to obtain the coefficients @xmath118 that minimize the expected variance of the estimate of covariance of shell - averaged power that comes from averaging over an ensemble of weightings that contain only combinations of fundamental modes , and that are symmetrically related to each other by rotations , reflections , and translations by quarter of a box .
representative minimum variance weightings @xmath31 , equation ( [ wrminvar ] ) , for the cases ( top ) @xmath226 , and ( bottom ) @xmath227 .
they are just single fourier modes , appropriately scaled and phased .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] representative minimum variance weightings @xmath31 , equation ( [ wrminvar ] ) , for the cases ( top ) @xmath226 , and ( bottom ) @xmath227 .
they are just single fourier modes , appropriately scaled and phased .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] numerically , we find not one but three separate sets of minimum variance weightings ( with hindsight , the sets are simple enough that they might perhaps have been found without resort to numerics ) .
each set consists of symmetrical transformations of a weighting generated by a single mode , namely @xmath228 , @xmath229 , and @xmath230 respectively for each of the three sets .
because each individual weighting has a rather high degree of symmetry , each set has far fewer than the @xmath223 weightings expected if all symmetrical transformations yielded distinct weightings .
each of the three sets is generated by the weighting @xmath231 where @xmath232 is one of the three possibilities @xmath233 in real space , the weighting @xmath31 corresponding to @xmath118 of equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) is @xmath234 \ .\ ] ] the complete set of @xmath235 ( @xmath236 , @xmath237 ) weightings for each set is obtained as follows .
in set one ( two , three ) , a factor of @xmath238 ( @xmath235 , @xmath132 ) comes from the cubic ( dodecahedral , octohedral ) symmetry of permuting and reflecting the components @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 of @xmath30 , or equivalently the components @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 of @xmath6 .
a further factor of @xmath239 comes from multiplying @xmath240 by @xmath241 , equivalent to translating by quarter of a box , or @xmath242 in equation ( [ wrminvar ] ) .
the three minimum variance solutions are absolute minimum variance , in the sense that each set not only minimizes the expression on the right hand side of equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) , but it solves @xmath243 for @xmath244 .
this means that it is impossible to find better solutions in which all the weightings are symmetrically related to each other , which is the condition under which equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) was derived . with the minimum variance solutions in hand , it is possible to go back and examine the covariance @xmath245 , equation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) , between estimates of power from different weightings @xmath32 and @xmath85 , either within the same set , or across two different sets .
estimates of power between two different sets are uncorrelated : the covariance @xmath245 is zero if @xmath32 and @xmath85 are drawn from two different sets .
if on the other hand the weightings @xmath32 and @xmath85 are drawn from the same set , then it turns out that only half of the weightings , the @xmath238 ( @xmath235 , @xmath132 ) weightings related by the cubic ( dodecahedral , octohedral ) symmetry of permuting and reflecting @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , yield distinct estimates of deviation in power .
the covariance matrix @xmath245 of estimates of power between the @xmath238 ( @xmath235 , @xmath132 ) cubically ( dodecahedrally , octohedrally ) related weightings is proportional to the unit matrix .
however , translating a weighting by quarter of a box , @xmath246 , yields an estimate of deviation of power that is minus that of the original weighting , @xmath247 .
actually , this is exactly true only if the slowly - varying and thick - shell approximations are exactly true ( of course , the thick - shell approximation is never exactly true ) . thus translating a weighting by quarter of a box
should yield an estimate of deviation in power that is highly anti - correlated with the original ; which should provide a useful check of the procedure . translating a weighting by half
a box simply changes its sign , @xmath248 .
this yields an estimate of deviation of power that equals exactly ( irrespective of approximations ) that of the original weighting , so yields no distinct estimate of deviation in power .
these redundant translations by half a box have already been omitted from the set of @xmath235 ( @xmath236 , @xmath237 ) weightings .
the value of @xmath181 , the factor that converts , equation ( [ xhati ] ) , estimates @xmath179 of the covariance of power from a weighted density field to an estimate of the true covariance of power is @xmath249 the same factor for each of the three sets .
the expected covariance matrix @xmath250 of estimates of covariance of power equals @xmath163 times the true covariance of covariance of power , according to equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 g ] ) .
the factors @xmath163 , equation ( [ gpiju ] ) , are @xmath251 equation ( [ gpijminvar ] ) is valid for weightings @xmath32 , @xmath85 both within the same set and across different sets .
the case @xmath252 in equation ( [ gpijminvar ] ) occurs not only when @xmath253 , but also when the weightings @xmath32 and @xmath85 are related by translation by quarter of a box .
the case @xmath254 in equation ( [ gpijminvar ] ) occurs not only when the weightings @xmath32 and @xmath85 are parity conjugates of each other , but also when they are parity confugates translated by quarter of a box .
the factors @xmath171 , equation ( [ gppiju ] ) , which relate the covariance @xmath255 of estimates @xmath179 relative to their measured mean @xmath256 , equation ( [ xhat ] ) , as opposed to their expected mean @xmath185 , equation ( [ xi ] ) , are @xmath257 an estimate of the uncertainty in the estimate @xmath256 can be deduced by measuring the variance @xmath258 in the fluctuations about the measured mean @xmath256 .
there is of course no point in attempting to estimate the uncertainty from @xmath259 , which is identically zero .
the true variance @xmath190 can be estimated from the measured variance @xmath258 by @xmath260 in which the factor of @xmath239 comes from ( but note the caveat at the end of [ notquiteweightings ] ) @xmath261 which corrects for the neglected covariance in the measured variance .
the minimum variance weightings derived above assumed , for definiteness , strategy one , in which the deviation @xmath262 in power is taken to be relative to the power spectrum of the unweighted density , equation ( [ dphati1 ] ) , an alternative strategy , strategy two , is to take the deviation @xmath262 in power to be relative to the average of the power spectra of the weighted densities , equation ( [ dphati2 ] ) .
strategy two yields an estimate of covariance of power that has potentially less systematic bias , but potentially greater statistical uncertainty .
as it happens , the minimum variance solution for strategy one , [ theweightings ] , proves also to solve the minimum variance problem for strategy two .
thus the minimum variance solution weightings are the same for both strategies .
mathematically , expectation values of covariances for the two methods differ in that @xmath161 is given for strategy one by equation ( [ vpi1 ] ) , and for strategy two by equation ( [ vpi2 ] ) .
however , for the minimum variance weightings @xmath118 of strategy one , equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) and its symmetrical transformations , it turns out that @xmath263 , the term subtracted from @xmath143 in strategy two , equation ( [ vpi2 ] ) , is equal to @xmath264 if @xmath201 , and zero otherwise .
this is exactly the same as the term subtracted from @xmath143 in strategy one , equation ( [ vpi1 ] ) .
it follows that @xmath161 is the same for the two strategies .
although the minimum variance set of weightings is the same for both strategies , the two strategies will in general yield different estimates of the covariance of power .
the three minimum variance sets of weightings found ( numerically ) in [ theweightings ] all take the same form , equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) , differing only in that they are generated by a different single mode , with wavevectors @xmath228 , @xmath229 , and @xmath230 respectively .
one can check that the result generalizes to higher order weightings , in which the wavevector @xmath232 in equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) is any wavevector with integral components ( such as @xmath265 , @xmath266 , and so on ) .
that is , for any wavevector @xmath232 with integral components , the weightings generated from the weighting of equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) by rotations , relections , and translations by quarter of a box , form a minimum variance set .
all the results of [ theweightings ] ( and [ theweightings2 ] ) carry through essentially unchanged .
in particular , all equations ( [ wrminvar])([ggminvar ] ) remain the same .
the disadvantage of including higher order weightings is that the estimates @xmath179 of the covariance of power become increasingly inaccurate as the wavenumber @xmath267 of the weighting increases , because the slowly - varying approximations ( [ papprox ] ) and ( [ tapprox ] ) , and the broad - shell approximation ( [ broadshellapprox ] ) , become increasingly poor as @xmath267 increases .
the advantage of including higher order weightings is that the more weightings , the better the statistical estimate , at least in principle .
however , the gain from more weightings is not as great as one might hope .
the cramr - rao inequality ( @xcite ; see e.g. @xcite for a pedagogical derivation ) states that the inverse variance of the best possible unbiassed estimate @xmath256 of the parameter @xmath185 must be less than or equal to the fisher information @xmath268 ( see @xcite ) in the parameter @xmath185 @xmath269 where @xmath270 is the likelihood function .
to the extent that the estimates @xmath179 are gaussianly distributed ( that is , the likelihood function is a gaussian in the estimates @xmath179 @xmath271 \sim \end{array}\ ! } \exp \bigl [ - \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{ij } \langle \delta{\widehat{x}}_i \delta{\widehat{x}}_j \rangle^{-1 } ( { \widehat{x}}_i - x ) ( { \widehat{x}}_j - x ) \bigr]\ ] ] with covariance @xmath250 independent of @xmath185 ) , which could be a rather poor approximation , the fisher information @xmath268 in the parameter @xmath185 approximates the sum of the elements of the inverse covariance matrix , @xmath272 in the present case , the covariance matrix @xmath250 is proportional to @xmath163 , so in approximation that @xmath179 are gaussianly distributed , the fisher information @xmath268 is proportional to @xmath273 \sim \end{array}\ ! } \sum_{ij } { g^\prime_{ij}}^{-1 } \ .\ ] ] with the coefficients @xmath163 given by equation ( [ gpijminvar ] ) , the quantity on the right hand side of equation ( [ fisherg ] ) proves to be a constant , independent of the number of estimates @xmath179 @xmath274 this constancy of the fisher information @xmath268 with respect to the number of estimates suggests that there is no gain at all in adjoining more and more estimates . however , this conclusion is true only to the extent , firstly , that the slowly - varying and broad - shell approximations are good , and , secondly , that the estimates @xmath179 are gaussianly distributed , neither of which assumptions necessarily holds .
all one can really conclude is that the gain in statistical accuracy from including more estimates is likely to be limited .
there is however another important consideration besides the accuracy of the estimate of the covariance matrix of power : it is desirable that the estimated covariance matrix be , like the true covariance matrix , strictly positive definite , that is , it should have no zero ( or negative ) eigenvalues . as noted by @xcite ,
if a matrix is estimated as an average over @xmath187 estimates , then its rank can be no greater than @xmath187 .
thus , to obtain a positive definite covariance matrix of power for @xmath187 shells of wavevector , at least @xmath187 distinct estimates @xmath179 are required . in [ recommend ] below
we recommend estimating the covariance of power from an ensemble of @xmath275 weightings .
this will yield a positive definite covariance matrix only if the covariance of power is estimated over no more than @xmath0 shells of wavenumber .
since , as noted in [ theweightings ] , weightings related by translation by quarter of a box yield highly anti - correlated estimates of power , hence highly correlated estimates of covariance of power , a more conservative approach would be to consider that the @xmath0 weightings yield only @xmath276 effectively distinct estimates of covariance of power , so that the covariance of power can be estimated over no more than @xmath276 shells of wavenumber .
if ( strategy two ) the deviation of power is measured relative to the measured mean over symmetrically related weightings , a ( slightly ) different mean for each of the @xmath219 sets of weightings , then @xmath219 degrees of freedom are lost , and the covariance of power can be estimated over no more than @xmath277 shells of wavenumber , or more conservatively over no more than @xmath278 shells of power . here is a step - by - step recipe for applying the weightings method to estimate the covariance of power from a periodic simulation . 1 .
select the weightings @xmath279 .
we recommend the minimum variance sets of weightings given by equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) and its symmetrical transformations .
if the weightings are restricted to contain only combinations of fundamental modes , then there are three such sets of weightings , equation ( [ kminvar ] ) , and the three sets together provide @xmath280 distinct weightings .
2 . for each weighting ,
measure the shell - averaged power spectrum @xmath102 of the weighted density field , equations ( [ phati ] ) and ( [ phati ] ) .
3 . for each weighting , evaluate the deviation @xmath107 in the shell - averaged power as the difference between @xmath102 and , either ( strategy one ) the shell - averaged power @xmath89 of the unweighted density , or ( strategy two ) the mean @xmath140 over symmetrically related weightings .
the advantage of strategy one is that the statistical error is potentially smaller , whereas the advantage of strategy two is that the systematic bias is potentially smaller . in strategy two
, it makes sense to subtract the mean separately for each symmetrically related set of weightings , because the systematic bias is ( slightly ) different for each set .
we recommend trying both strategies one and two , and checking that they yield consistent results .
4 . estimate the covariance matrix of shell - averaged power from the average over all @xmath187 ( @xmath0 ) weightings @xmath281 the factor of @xmath239 in equation ( [ xest ] ) is @xmath282 , equation ( [ fpminvar ] ) , necessary to convert the average over weightings to an estimate of the true covariance of power , equation ( [ xhati ] ) .
comparison between the normalized variance of power measured from 25 art @xmath1cdm simulations by ( symbols with error bars , indicating median and quartiles ) the weightings method , and ( plain symbols ) the ensemble method .
the two methods disagree substantially at nonlinear scales .
lines show the normalized variance predicted by perturbation theory both with ( solid line ) , and without ( dashed line ) the large - scale beat - coupling contribution .
the dotted line shows the expected gaussian contribution to the variance .
this figure is a condensed version of figure 5 of @xcite .
, width=312 ]
this paper should have ended at this point . unfortunately , numerical tests , described in detail in the companion paper @xcite revealed a serious problem .
figure [ vartwofig ] shows the problem .
it shows the median and quartiles of variance of power measured by the weightings method in each of 25 art @xmath1cdm simulations of @xmath283 box size , compared to the variance of power measured over the ensemble of the same 25 simulations .
although the two methods agree at linear scales , the weightings method gives a systematically larger variance at nonlinear scales .
the discrepancy reaches almost an order of magnitude at the smallest scales measured , @xmath284 .
the reader is referred to @xcite for details of the simulations and their results .
this section diagnoses and addresses the problem .
the next section , [ discussion ] , discusses the problem and its relevance to observations . the physical cause of the problem illustrated in figure [ vartwofig ] traces to a nonlinear coupling of products of fourier modes closely spaced in wavenumber to the large - scale beat mode between them .
this beat - coupling , as we refer to it , occurs only when power is measured from fourier modes with a finite spread in wavevector , and therefore appears in the weightings method ( and in observations
see [ observation ] below ) but not in the ensemble method .
the beat - coupling is surprisingly large , to the point that , as seen in figure [ vartwofig ] , it actually dominates the variance of power at nonlinear scales .
more specifically , in the ensemble method , the power spectrum of a periodic simulation is measured from the variance @xmath285 of fourier modes . in the weightings method on the other hand
, the power spectrum receives contributions not only from the variance , but also from the covariance @xmath286 between modes a small wavevector @xmath287 apart .
this covariance vanishes in the mean , but it couples to large - scale modes @xmath288 through quadratic nonlinearities .
that is , the correlation between the product @xmath286 and the large - scale mode @xmath288 is the bispectrum @xmath289 the bispectrum is zero for gaussian fluctuations , but is driven away from zero by nonlinear gravitational growth .
the place where , prior to this section , we inadvertently discarded the large - scale beat - coupling , is equation ( [ tapprox ] ) , where we made the seemingly innocent approximation that the trispectrum @xmath77 is a slowly varying function of what appears to be its arguments , @xmath49 to @xmath290 .
this assumption is false , as we now show . for a statistically isotropic field ( as considered in this paper ) , the trispectrum depends on six scalar arguments .
this follows from the fact that a spatial configuration of four points is determined by the six lengths of the sides of the tetrahedron whose vertices are the four points . in fourier space ,
the configuration is an object four of whose sides are equal to the wavevectors @xmath49 to @xmath290 .
the object forms a closed tetrahedron ( because @xmath291 ) , whose shape is determined by the six lengths of the sides of the tetrahedron .
four - point configuration of wavevectors for the trispectrum in equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) , which describes the covariance of power spectra of weighted densities .
the short leg @xmath287 , equation ( [ epsilon ] ) , produces a beat - coupling to large scales .
, width=192 ] figure [ tetrahedronfig ] illustrates the configuration of interest in the present paper , that for the trispectrum in equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) .
rewritten as a function of six scalar arguments , the trispectrum of equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) is @xmath292 where the wavevector @xmath287 is defined by @xmath293 which is small but not necessarily zero .
the invalid approximation ( [ tapprox ] ) is equivalent to approximating @xmath294 the problem with this approximation is apparent . although primed wavenumbers are small compared to unprimed ones , so that the approximation in the first five arguments is reasonable , in the last argument it is not valid to approximate a finite wavenumber @xmath295 , however small , by zero .
a valid approximation is , rather , @xmath296 as an example of the large - scale beat - coupling contributions to the trispectrum that arise from the beat wavevector @xmath287 , consider perturbation theory . in perturbation theory ( pt ) , the trispectrum can be split into snake and star contributions ( @xcite ; @xcite ) @xmath297 \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\ ! \
\mbox { } + \mbox{cyclic ( 4 star terms)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath298 , and the second - order pt kernel @xmath299 is given by @xmath300 with @xmath301 .
in the case of interest , where the trispectrum is that of equation ( [ tsix ] ) , 4 of the 12 snake terms produce a coupling to large scales , those where the beat wavenumber @xmath302 in equation ( [ tab ] ) is small . in the ( valid ) approximation ( [ tapprox2 ] ) , the pertinent pt trispectrum is @xmath303 in which the term on the last line represents the large - scale beat - coupling contribution incorrectly ignored by the approximation ( [ tapprox1 ] ) . in equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) for the covariance of shell - averaged power , this trispectrum , equation ( [ tapproxpt ] ) , is angle - averaged over the directions of @xmath49 and @xmath50 .
the angle - averaged second - order pt kernel is @xmath304 and it follows that the last line of equation ( [ tapproxpt ] ) , when angle - averaged , is @xmath305 . following the same arguments that led from equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) to equation ( [ dphatidphatjf ] ) , and then to equation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) , but with the beat - coupling term now correctly retained in the trispectrum , one finds that equation ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) for the expected covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities is modified to @xmath306 where @xmath161 is defined by equations ( [ vi ] ) and ( [ vpi1 ] ) or ( [ vpi2 ] ) , and the constant @xmath307 is @xmath308 the reason for writing equation ( [ dphatidphatjflpt ] ) in this form , with the constant @xmath307 separated out , is that , as will be seen in [ hierarchical ] , the same expression remains valid in the hierarchical model , but with @xmath307 the 4-point hierarchical snake amplitude .
figure [ vartwofig ] includes lines showing the predicted pt result for the variance of shell - averaged power of weighted density , equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) , both with ( solid lines ) and without ( dashed lines ) beat - coupling . the pt variance with beat - coupling
was obtained by numerically integrating the pt expression ( [ tab ] ) for the trispectrum ( [ tsix ] ) in equation ( [ dphatidphatj ] ) ( that is , without making the approximations ( [ tapprox2 ] ) or ( [ dphatidphatjflpt ] ) ) , with the minimum variance weightings ( [ wkminvar ] ) , and then multiplying by the factor @xmath282 , equation ( [ fpminvar ] ) . from this
the pt variance without beat - coupling was obtained by setting @xmath309 .
the variance without beat - coupling agreed well with a direct pt evaluation of equation ( [ dphatdphat ] ) .
figure [ vartwofig ] shows that the beat - coupling contribution predicted by perturbation theory seems to account reasonably well for the extra variance that appears at nonlinear scales in the weightings versus the ensemble method .
we will return to equation ( [ dphatidphatjflpt ] ) in [ largescale ] below , but first consider the hierarchical model as a prototype of the trispectrum beyond perturbation theory .
perturbation theory is valid only in the translinear regime .
the behaviour of the trispectrum in the fully nonlinear regime is less well understood .
available observational and @xmath187-body evidence ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) is consistent with a hierarchical model of higher order correlations . in the hierarchical model @xcite ,
the trispectrum is a sum of snake and star terms @xmath310 \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\ !
\mbox { } + r_b \bigl [ p(k_1 ) p(k_2 ) p(k_3 ) + \mbox{cyclic~(4 star terms ) } \bigr ] \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the pt trispectrum , equation ( [ tab ] ) , shows a hierarchical structure with hierarchical amplitudes @xmath307 and @xmath311 that are not constant , but rather depend on the shape of the trispectrum tetrahedron . at highly nonlinear scales ,
scoccimarro & frieman ( 1999 ) suggested an ansatz , dubbed hyperextended perturbation theory ( hept ) , that the hierarchical amplitudes go over to the values predicted by perturbation theory for configurations collinear in fourier space .
for power law power spectra @xmath312 , hept predicts 4-point amplitudes @xmath313 as pointed out by @xcite and @xcite , hept is not entirely consistent because it predicts a covariance of power @xmath314 that violates the schwarz inequality when @xmath315 . in the hierarchical model with constant hierarchical amplitudes ,
4 of the 12 snake terms produce a coupling to large scales in the trispectrum of interest , equation ( [ tsix ] ) . in
the ( valid ) approximation ( [ tapprox2 ] ) , the hierarchical trispectrum is @xmath316 in which the term on the last line represents the large - scale beat - coupling contribution .
the hierarchical trispectrum ( [ tapproxhier ] ) looks similar to ( slightly simpler than ) the pt trispectrum ( [ tapproxpt ] ) .
following the same arguments as before , one recovers the same expression ( [ dphatidphatjflpt ] ) for the expected covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities .
suppose that either perturbation theory , [ pt ] , or the hierarchical model , [ hierarchical ] , offers a reliable guide to the coupling of the nonlinear trispectrum to large scales , so that equation ( [ dphatidphatjflpt ] ) is a good approximation to the expected covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities .
make the further assumption that the power spectrum is approximately constant over the large - scale wavevectors represented in @xmath161 @xmath317 where @xmath318 is the wavenumber at the box scale .
the factor @xmath239 in @xmath319 in equation ( [ papproxl ] ) appears as a reminder that the wavevectors @xmath30 in @xmath161 are , equations ( [ vi ] ) and ( [ vpi1 ] ) or ( [ vpi2 ] ) , sums of pairs of wavenumbers @xmath58 represented in the weighting @xmath60 . for example , if the weightings are taken to be the minimum variance weightings given by equation ( [ wkminvar ] ) , then @xmath320 where @xmath321 is the wavenumber of the weighting .
approximation ( [ papproxl ] ) is in the same spirit as , but distinct from , the earlier approximation ( [ papprox ] ) that the power spectrum is a slowly varying function .
note that equation ( [ papproxl ] ) does _ not _ require that @xmath322 ( which would certainly not be correct , because @xmath323 ) , because @xmath324 is zero , which is true a priori in strategy one , equation ( [ vpi1 ] ) , and ends up being true a posteriori in strategy two , equation ( [ vpi2 ] ) , by the argument in [ theweightings2 ] . in the approximation ( [ papproxl ] ) ,
the summed expression on the right hand side of equation ( [ dphatidphatjflpt ] ) is @xmath325 and equation ( [ dphatidphatjflpt ] ) reduces to @xmath326\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the term on the last line being the large - scale beat - coupling contribution .
equation ( [ dphatidphatjfl ] ) provides the fundamental justfication for the weightings method when beat - coupling is taken into account .
it states that the covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities is proportional to the sum of the true covariance @xmath151 of shell - averaged power , and a beat - coupling term @xmath327 proportional to power at ( twice ) the box wavenumber @xmath318 .
the crucial feature of equation ( [ dphatidphatjfl ] ) is that the constant of proportionality @xmath153 , equation ( [ fpijv ] ) , depends only on the weightings @xmath118 , and is independent either of the power spectrum @xmath28 or of the wavenumbers @xmath125 and @xmath126 . in the limit of infinite box size
, the beat - coupling contribution to the covariance of power spectra of weighted densities in equation ( [ dphatidphatjfl ] ) goes to zero , @xmath328 as @xmath329 , and the covariance becomes proportional to the true covariance @xmath151 of power . however , in cosmologically realistic simulations , such as illustrated in figure [ vartwofig ] and discussed further in
[ discussion ] , the beat - coupling contribution , far from being small , is liable to dominate at nonlinear scales . beyond perturbation theory or the hierarchical model ,
the weightings method remains applicable just so long as the hierarchical amplitude @xmath307 in equation ( [ dphatidphatjfl ] ) is independent of the weightings @xmath330 .
in general , @xmath307 could be any arbitrary function of @xmath125 , @xmath126 , and the box wavenumber @xmath318 .
section [ weightings ] derived sets of minimum variance weightings valid when the covariance , and the covariance of covariance , of power spectra of weighted densities took the separable forms given by equations ( [ dphatidphatjfp ] ) and ( [ dphati2dphatj2gp ] ) .
when beat - scale coupling is included , the covariance of power , equation ( [ dphatidphatjfl ] ) , still takes the desired separable form ( as long as the hierarchical amplitude @xmath307 is independent of the weightings @xmath330 ) , but the covariance of covariance of power ( eq . ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) of appendix [ minvarl ] ) does not . in appendix
[ minvarl ] , we discuss what happens to the minimum variance derivation of [ weightings ] when beat - coupling is included .
we argue that the minimum variance weightings of [ theweightings ] are no longer exactly minimum variance , but probably remain near minimum variance , and therefore fine to use in practice .
the factor @xmath239 on the right hand side of equation ( [ dxhat2est ] ) is no longer correct when beat - coupling is included , but may remain a reasonable approximation .
as shown in [ beatcoupling ] , the covariance of nonlinear power receives beat - coupling contributions from large scales whenever power is measured from fourier modes @xmath7 that have a finite spread in wavevector @xmath30 , as opposed to being delta - functions at single discrete wavevectors .
physically , the large - scale beat - coupling arises because a product @xmath286 of fourier amplitudes of closely spaced wavevectors couples by nonlinear gravitational growth to the beat mode @xmath288 between them .
the beat - coupling contribution does not appear when covariance of power is measured from ensembles of periodic box simulations , because in that case power is measured from products of fourier amplitudes @xmath285 at single discrete wavevectors . here
the `` beat '' mode is the mean mode , @xmath331 , whose fluctuation is by definition always zero , @xmath332 .
there is on the other hand a beat - coupling contribution when covariance of power is measured by the weightings method , because the fourier modes of weighted density are spread over more than one wavevector . for weightings constructed from combinations of fundamental modes , as recommended in [ weightings ] , the covariance of power spectra of weighted densities receives beat - coupling contributions from power near the box fundamental @xmath318 .
the beat - coupling and normal contributions to the variance @xmath333 of nonlinear power are in roughly the ratio @xmath334 of power at the box scale to power at the nonlinear scale , according to equation ( [ dphatidphatjfl ] ) . in cosmologically realistic simulations ,
box sizes are typically around the range @xmath335@xmath336 .
this is just the scale at which the power spectrum goes through a broad maximum .
for example , in observationally concordant @xmath1cdm models , power goes through a broad maximum at @xmath337 ( e.g. @xcite ) , corresponding to a box size @xmath338 .
power at the maximum is about @xmath339 times greater than power at the onset @xmath340 of the translinear regime , @xmath341 , and the ratio @xmath342 of power increases at more nonlinear wavenumbers @xmath2 .
it follows that in cosmologically realistic simulations the beat - coupling contribution to the covariance of power is liable to dominate the normal contribution .
this is consistent with the numerical results illustrated in figure [ vartwofig ] and discussed by @xcite , which show that the variance of power measured by the weightings method ( which includes beat - coupling contributions ) substantially exceeds , at nonlinear scales , the variance of power measured by the ensemble method ( which does not include beat - coupling contributions ) . in real galaxy surveys ,
measured fourier modes inevitably have finite width @xmath343 , where @xmath4 is a characteristic linear size of the survey .
the characteristic size @xmath4 varies from @xmath344 to a few @xmath345 ( an upper limit is set by the comoving horizon distance , which is about @xmath346 in the concordant @xmath1cdm model ) .
it follows that the covariance of nonlinear power measured in real galaxy surveys is liable to be dominated not by the `` true '' covariance of power ( the covariance of power in a perfect , infinite survey ) , but rather by the contribution from beat - coupling to power at the scale of the survey .
this means that one must take great care in using numerical simulations to estimate or to predict the covariance of nonlinear power expected in a galaxy survey .
the scatter in power over an ensemble of periodic box simulations will certainly underestimate the covariance of power by a substantial factor at nonlinear scales , because of the neglect of beat - coupling contributions .
a common and in principle reliable procedure is to estimate the covariance of power of a galaxy survey from mock surveys `` observed '' with the same selection rules as the real survey from numerical simulations large enough to encompass the entire survey ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
it is important that numerical simulations be genuinely large enough to contain a mock survey .
one should be wary about estimating covariance of power from mock surveys extracted from small periodic boxes replicated many times ( e.g. @xcite ) , since such boxes are liable to be missing power at precisely those wavenumbers , the inverse scale size of the mock survey , where beat - coupling should in reality be strongest .
beat - coupling arises from a real gravitational coupling to large scale modes , and the simulation from which a mock survey is extracted must be large enough to contain such modes .
further , it would be wrong to take , say , a volume - limited subsample of a galaxy survey , and then to estimate the covariance of power from an ensemble of periodic numerical simulations whose size is that of the volume - limited subsample .
a volume - limited subsample of observational data retains beat - coupling contributions to the covariance of power , whereas periodic box simulations do not .
this paper falls into two parts . in the first part , [ estimate ] and [ weightings ]
, we proposed a new method , the weightings method , that yields an estimate of the covariance of the power spectrum of a statistically homogeneous and isotropic density field from a single periodic box simulation .
the procedure is to apply a set of weightings to the density field , and to measure the covariance of power from the scatter in power over the ensemble of weightings . in
[ estimate ] we developed the formal mathematical apparatus that justifies the weightings method , and in [ weightings ] we derived sets of weightings that achieve minimum variances estimates of covariance of power .
section [ recommend ] gives a step - by - step recipe for applying the weightings method .
we recommend a specific set of 52 minimum variance weightings containing only combinations of fundamental modes . in the second part of this paper , [ beatcoupling ] and [ discussion ]
, we discuss an unexpected glitch in the procedure , that emerged from the periodic box numerical simulations described in the companion paper @xcite .
the numerical simulations showed that , at nonlinear scales , the covariance of power measured by the weightings method substantially exceeded that measured over an ensemble of independent simulations . in [ beatcoupling ]
we argue from perturbation theory that the discrepancy between the weightings and ensemble methods arises from `` beat - coupling '' , in which products of closely spaced fourier modes couple by nonlinear gravitational growth to the large - scale beat mode between them .
beat - coupling is present whenever nonlinear power is measured from fourier modes that have a finite spread in wavevector , as opposed to being delta - functions at single discrete wavevectors .
beat - coupling affects the weightings method , because fourier modes of weighted densities have a finite width , but not the ensemble method , because the fourier modes of a periodic box are delta - functions of wavevector . as discussed in
[ discussion ] , beat - coupling inevitably affects real galaxy surveys , whose fourier modes necessarily have a finite width of the order of the inverse scale size of the survey . surprisingly , at nonlinear scales , beat - coupling is liable to dominate the covariance of power of a real survey .
one would have thought that the covariance of power at nonlinear scales would be dominated by structure at small scales , but this is not true .
rather , the covariance of nonlinear power is liable to be dominated by beat - coupling to power at the largest scales of the survey . a common and valid procedure for estimating the covariance of power from a real survey is the mock survey method , in which artificial surveys are `` observed '' from large numerical simulations , with the same selection rules as the real survey .
it is important that mock surveys be extracted from genuinely large simulations , not from many small periodic simulations stacked together , since stacked simulations miss the large - scale power essential to beat - coupling .
finally , it should be remarked that , although this paper has considered only the covariance of the power spectrum , it is likely that , in real galaxy surveys and cosmologically realistic simulations , beat - coupling contributions dominate the nonlinear variance and covariance of most other statistical measures , including higher order @xmath347-point spectra such as the bispectrum and trispectrum , and @xmath347-point correlation functions in real space , including the @xmath239-point correlation function .
we thank nick gnedin , matias zaldarriaga and max tegmark for helpful conversations , and anatoly klypin and andrey kravtsov for making the mpi implementation of art available to us and for help with its application .
grafic is part of the cosmics package , which was developed by edmund bertschinger under nsf grant ast-9318185 .
the simulations used in this work were performed at the san diego supercomputer center using resources provided by the national partnership for advanced computational infrastructure under nsf cooperative agreement aci-9619020 .
this work was supported by nsf grant ast-0205981 and by nasa atp award nag5 - 10763 .
baugh c. m. et al .
( 29 authors ; 2dfgrs team ) , 2004 , mnras , 351 , l44 blaizot j. , wadadekar y. , guiderdoni b. , colombi s. , bertin e. , bouchet f. r. , devriendt j. e. g. , hatton s. , 2005 , mnras , 360 , 159 coil a. l. , davis m. , szapudi i. , 2001 , pasp , 113 , 1312 cole s. et al .
( 31 authors ; 2dfgrs team ) , 2005 , mnras , 362 , 505 colombi s. , bouchet f. r. , hernquist l. , 1996 , apj , 465 , 14 cooray a. , 2004 , mnras , 348 , 250 croton d. j. et al .
( 29 authors ; 2dfgrs team ) , 2004 , mnras , 352 , 1232 eisenstein d. j. et al .
( 48 authors ; sdss collaboration ) , 2005 , apj , 633 , 560 frith w. j. , shanks t. , outram p. j. , 2005 , mnras , 361 , 701 hamilton a. j. s. , 2000 , mnras , 312 , 257 hamilton a. j. s. , 2005 , in data analysis in cosmology " , v. martinez , ed , proceedings of an international summer school , 6 - 10 september , valencia , spain , springer verlag lecture notes in physics , 17 pages , to appear ( astro - ph/050360 ) hoekstra h. , yee y. , gladders m. , 2002 , apj , 577 , 595 hui l. , gaztaaga e. , 1999 , apj , 519 , 622 komatsu e. et al .
( 15 authors ; wmap team ) , 2003 , apjs , 148 , 119 knsch h. r. , 1989 , ann .
17(3 ) , 1217 lidz a. , heitmann k. , hui l. , habib s. , rauch m. , sargent w. l. w. , 2005 , apj , submitted ( astro - ph/0505138 ) kendall m. g. , stuart a. , 1967 , the advanced theory of statistics ( hafner publishing , new york ) meiksin a. , white m. , 1999 , mnras , 308 , 1179 padilla n. d. , baugh c. m. , 2003 , mnras , 343 , 796 pan j. , szapudi i. , 2005 , mnras , 362 , 1363 park c. , choi y .- y .
, vogeley m. , gott j. r. iii , kim j. , hikage c. , matsubara t. , park m .-
g . , suto y. , weinberg d. h. ( sdss collaboration ) , 2005 , apj , 633 , 11 peebles p. j. e. , 1980 , the large scale structure of the universe ( princeton university press ) pen u .-
l . , lu t. , van waerbeke l. , mellier y. , 2003 , mnras , 346 , 994 rimes c. d. , hamilton a. j. s. , 2005 ,
mnras , 360 , l82 rimes c. d. , hamilton a. j. s. , 2006 , mnras , submitted ( companion paper ) sanchez a. g. , baugh c. m. , percival w. j. , peacock j. a. , padilla n. d. , cole s. , frenk c. s. , norberg p. , 2005
, mnras , submitted ( astro - ph/0507583 ) scoccimarro r. , frieman j. a. , 1999 , apj , 520 , 35 scoccimarro r. , zaldarriaga m. , hui l. , 1999 , apj , 527 , 1 sefusatti e. , scoccimarro r. , 2005 , phys . rev .
d , 71 , 063001 seljak u. et al .
( 21 authors ; sdss team ) , 2005 , phys . rev .
d , 71 , 103515 sheldon e. s. , johnston d. e. , frieman j. a. , scranton r. , mckay t. a. , connolly a. j. , budavari t. , zehavi i. , bahcall n. , brinkmann j. , fukugita m. , 2004 , aj , 127 , 2544 spergel d. n. et al .
( 17 authors ; wmap team ) , 2003 , apjs , 148 , 175 takada m. , jain b. , 2004 , mnras , 348 , 897 tegmark m. et al . ( 62 authors ; sdss collaboration ) , 2004a , apj , 606 , 702 tegmark m. et al . ( 64 authors ; sdss collaboration ) , 2004b , phys . rev .
d , 69 , 103501 tegmark m. , taylor a. , heavens a. , 1997 , apj , 480 , 22 yan r. , white m. , coil a. l. , 2004 , apj , 607 , 739 verde l. , heavens a. f. , 2001 , apj , 553 , 14 viel m. , haehnelt m. g. , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/0508177 ) yang x. , mo h. j. , jing y. p. , van den bosch f. c. , chu y. , 2004 , mnras , 350 , 1153 white m. , hu w. , 2000 , apj , 537 , 1 zhan h. , eisenstein d. , 2005 , mnras , 357 , 1387 zhan h. , dav r. , eisenstein d. , katz n. , 2005 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/0504419 )
this appendix describes how the beat - coupling contributions to covariance of power discussed in [ beatcoupling ] modify the minimum variance arguments in [ weightings ] .
the conclusion is that the minimum variance weightings given in [ theweightings ] are no longer exact minimum variance , but are probably near minimum variance , and therefore fine to use in practice . with no approximations at all , the covariance of covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities ( with the deviations @xmath138 in power being taken relative to the measured rather than the expected mean power , eqs .
( [ dphati1 ] ) or ( [ dphati2 ] ) ) , takes the generic form @xmath348 } & & \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_4 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_4 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \bigr\rangle \nonumber \\ & = & \sum_{\bvarepsilon_1 + \bvarepsilon_2 + \bvarepsilon_3 + \bvarepsilon_4 = { { \bmath 0 } } } v^\prime_i(\bvarepsilon_1 ) v^\prime_i(\bvarepsilon_2 ) v^\prime_j(\bvarepsilon_3 ) v^\prime_j(\bvarepsilon_4 ) \\
\nonumber \lefteqn { \ \ \sum_{{{\bmath k}}_1 \in v_{k_1 } , ... , \ { { \bmath k}}_4 \in v_{k_4 } } e({{\bmath k}}_1 { - } { { \bmath k}}_1^\prime , -{{\bmath k}}_1 { - } { { \bmath k}}_1^{\prime\prime } , ... , { { \bmath k}}_4 { - } { { \bmath k}}_4^\prime , -{{\bmath k}}_4 { - } { { \bmath k}}_4^{\prime\prime } ) } & & \ ] ] where @xmath161 is defined by equations ( [ vi ] ) and ( [ vpi1 ] ) or ( [ vpi2 ] ) , the wavevectors @xmath349 are defined by @xmath350 and @xmath351 is an 8-point object , a sum of products of @xmath347-point functions adding up to 8 points , as enumerated in equation ( [ eightpt ] )
. eight - point configuration of wavevectors contributing to the covariance of covariance of power spectra of weighted densities , equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 ] ) .
the central tetrahedron of short legs produces beat - couplings to large scales .
, width=192 ] figure [ eightpointfig ] illustrates the configuration of the @xmath132-point function that contributes to the @xmath132-point object @xmath351 in equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 ] ) .
the short legs @xmath352 , ... , @xmath353 of the configuration constitute a tetrahedron , whose 6 sides generate beat - couplings to large scale . none of the legs @xmath349 is zero , because a zero leg would make zero contribution to equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 ] ) , since @xmath354 , equation ( [ vpi1 ] ) or , a posteriori , equation ( [ vpi2 ] ) ; but it is possible for the sum of a pair of the short legs to be zero . it is these configurations , where the sum of a pair of short legs is zero , that prevent equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 ] ) from being separated , as in equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gp ] ) , into a product of a factor @xmath163 that depends only on the weightings and a factor that is independent of the weightings .
note that it is only the 8-point function itself , not lower - order functions , that prevent separability : lower - order functions depend on at most three of the four @xmath349 , and a triangle with three non - zero sides has ( of course ) no zero sides . in either perturbation theory or the hierarchical model , and in the various valid approximations made in this paper ( firstly , that @xmath347-point spectra are slowly varying functions of their arguments _ except _ that small arguments @xmath287
are _ not _ replaced by zero , and secondly , that shells are broad ) , the covariance of covariance of shell - averaged power spectra of weighted densities , equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 ] ) , reduces to @xmath355 } & & \nonumber \\ & & \times \bigl [ \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_4 ) - \left\langle \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_3 ) \delta{\hat{p}}^\prime_j(k_4 ) \right\rangle \bigr ] \bigr\rangle \nonumber \\ & \approx & \lambda g^\prime_{ij } - \mu f^\prime_{ii } f^\prime_{jj } - \nu f^{\prime \ , 2}_{ij}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath153 and @xmath163 are given by equations ( [ fpijv ] ) and ( [ gpiju ] ) .
the quantities @xmath356 , @xmath357 , @xmath358 in equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) are each functions of @xmath359 , and the box wavenumber @xmath318 , but , importantly , are independent of the weightings @xmath330 . the @xmath360 ( respectively @xmath361 ) term in equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) arises from terms where @xmath362 ( respectively @xmath363 or @xmath364 ) in equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 ] ) .
all three terms on the right hand side of equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) contain large - scale beat - coupling contributions , proportional to one , two , or three factors of large - scale power .
the second ( @xmath357 ) and third @xmath365 terms in equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2 ] ) are written with negative signs because their effect is such as to cancel some of the beat - coupling terms appearing in the first ( @xmath356 ) term ( that is , some of the beat - coupling terms proportional to @xmath366 in @xmath356 should really be proportional to @xmath323 ; the @xmath357 and @xmath358 terms remove these terms ) .
it is to be expected that @xmath356 , @xmath367 , and @xmath368 are all positive . at linear scales , where fluctuations are gaussian , the beat - couplings generated by nonlinear evolution are small , so that @xmath369 . at nonlinear scales ,
however , @xmath357 and @xmath358 could be an appreciable fraction of @xmath356 . the derivation of minimum variance weightings in [ weightings ] involved summing over weighings @xmath330 , equation ( [ dxhat2 ] ) .
consider the corresponding double sum over @xmath330 of equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) .
the sum over @xmath163 yields the same result as before , equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) . adjoining the sum over @xmath360 from equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) modifies equation ( [ dxhat2u ] ) to @xmath370 } \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{u^\prime({{\bmath 0}})^2 } \left [ \left ( 1 - \frac{\mu}{\lambda } \right ) u^\prime({{\bmath 0}})^2 + \sum_{{{\bmath k}}\neq { { \bmath 0 } } } \left| u^\prime({{\bmath k } } ) \right|^2 \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] because @xmath371 for all @xmath32 .
the minimum variance weightings given in [ theweightings ] were absolute minimum variance in the sense that @xmath243 for @xmath244 .
the same minimum variance weightings continue to achieve absolute minimum variance for equation ( [ dxhat2ul ] ) , reducing its right hand side to the irreducible minimum @xmath372 .
thus the minimum variance weightings of [ theweightings ] remain minimum variance as long as only the first two terms ( @xmath356 and @xmath357 ) of equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) are considered .
the third ( @xmath358 ) term breaks the minimum variance derivation .
however , this third term is likely to be subdominant compared to the first two .
the quantity @xmath153 in the third term of equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) is proportional to the covariance of power between weightings @xmath32 and @xmath85 , equation ( [ dphatidphatjfl ] ) , and the schwarz inequality guarantees that @xmath373 so that there is a natural tendency for the third term of equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) to be dominated by the second . the only way for the third term to be large is for the power spectra from different weightings
@xmath330 to be highly correlated with each other .
physically , however , the most accurate estimate of covariance of power should come from averaging over many uncorrelated weightings , in which case @xmath374 for most weightings @xmath375 .
thus , as just stated , it is to be expected that the third term should be subdominant compared to the first two . in summary , to the extent that either perturbation theory or the hierarchical model provide a reliable guide to the behaviour of high - order correlations , and to the extent that the third term of equation ( [ dphati2dphatj2gpl ] ) is subdominant , as it should be
, the minimum variance weightings of [ theweightings ] should remain near minimum variance , good enough for practical application . | we show how to estimate the covariance of the power spectrum of a statistically homogeneous and isotropic density field from a single periodic simulation , by applying a set of weightings to the density field , and by measuring the scatter in power spectra between different weightings . we recommend a specific set of @xmath0 weightings containing only combinations of fundamental modes , constructed to yield a minimum variance estimate of the covariance of power .
numerical tests reveal that at nonlinear scales the variance of power estimated by the weightings method substantially exceeds that estimated from a simple ensemble method .
we argue that the discrepancy is caused by beat - coupling , in which products of closely spaced fourier modes couple by nonlinear gravitational growth to the beat mode between them .
beat - coupling appears whenever nonlinear power is measured from fourier modes with a finite spread of wavevector , and is therefore present in the weightings method but not the ensemble method .
beat - coupling inevitably affects real galaxy surveys , whose fourier modes have finite width . surprisingly , the beat - coupling contribution dominates the covariance of power at nonlinear scales , so that , counter - intuitively , it is expected that the covariance of nonlinear power in galaxy surveys is dominated not by small scale structure , but rather by beat - coupling to the largest scales of the survey .
large - scale structure of universe methods : data analysis |
first we define _ complex lagrangian fibration_. let @xmath5 be a khler manifold with a holomorhpic symplectic two form @xmath6 and @xmath7 a smooth manifold .
a proper flat surjective morphism @xmath8 is said to be a complex lagrangian fibration if a general fibre @xmath0 of @xmath9 is a lagrangian submanifold with respect to @xmath6 , that is , the restriction of 2-form @xmath10 is identically zero and @xmath11 . remark .
a general fibre @xmath0 of a complex lagrangian fibration is a complex torus by leauville s theorem .
the plainest example of a complex lagrangian fibration is an elliptic fibration of @xmath12 surface over @xmath13 . in higher dimension ,
such a fibre space naturally occurs on a fiber space of an irreducible symplectic manifold ( ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2 ) and ( * ? ? ? * theorem 1 ) ) .
when the dimension of fibre is one , a complex lagrangian fibration is a minimal elliptic fibration and whose singular fibre is completely classified by kodaira ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 6.2 ) . in this note
, we investigate singular fibres of a projective complex lagrangian fibration whose fibre is 2-dimensional .
[ main ] let @xmath8 be a complex lagrangian fibration on 4 dimensional symplectic manifold and @xmath14 the discriminant locus of @xmath9 .
assume that @xmath9 is projective .
for a general point @xmath15 of @xmath14 , @xmath16 is the following one : 1 .
there exists an tale finite covering @xmath17 and @xmath18 is isomorphic to the product of an elliptic curve and a kodaira singular fibre of type @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 or @xmath26 .
@xmath16 is isomorphic to a normal crossing variety consisting of a minimal elliptic ruled surface .
the dual graph of @xmath16 is the dynkin diagram of type @xmath1 , @xmath2 @xmath4 or @xmath3 . if the dual graph is of type @xmath2 or @xmath3 , each double curve is a section of the ruling . in the other cases ,
the double curve on each edge components is a bisection or a section and other double curve is a section .
( see figures [ figure_tilde_a_n ] and [ figure_a_n ] ( pp ) . )
combining theorem [ main ] with ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) , we obtain the following corollary .
let @xmath27 be a fibre space of a projective irreducible symplectic manifold .
assume that @xmath28 .
then , for a general point @xmath15 of the discriminat locus of @xmath9 , @xmath16 satisfies the properties of theorem [ main ] ( 1 ) or ( 2 ) .
let @xmath7 be a @xmath12 surface and @xmath29 an elliptic fibration .
the induced morhpism @xmath30 gives examples of singular fibres above except whose dual graphs are @xmath1 or @xmath4 .
the author does not know whether a normal crossing variety whose dual graph is @xmath1 or @xmath4 occur as a singular fibre of a fibre space of an irreducible symplectic manifold .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we set up the proof of theorem [ main ] .
the key proposition is stated and proved in section 3 .
section 4 and 5 are devoted to the proof of theorem [ main ] .
the author express his thanks to professors a. fujiki , y. miyaoka , s. mori and n. nakayama for their advice and encouragement .
( 2.1 ) in this section , we collect definitions and some fundamental materials which are necessary for the proof of theorem [ main ] .
let @xmath31 be a proper surjective morphism from algebraic variety to an unit disk .
@xmath9 is said to be _ semistable degeneration _ if @xmath9 satisfies the following two properties : 1 .
@xmath9 is smooth over @xmath32 .
2 . @xmath33 is a reduced normal crossing divisor .
let @xmath34 and @xmath35 be proper surjective morphisms from algebraic varieties to unit disks .
we call @xmath9 is isomorphic to @xmath36 ( resp
. birational ) if there exists an isomorphism ( resp . a birational map )
@xmath37 such that @xmath38 .
( 2.2 ) we refer the fundamental properties of an abelian fibration . [ basic_properties ]
let @xmath39 be a projective complex lagrangian fibration . 1 .
the discriminant locus of @xmath9 is pure codimension one .
2 . let @xmath0 be an irreducible component of a fibre of @xmath9 and @xmath40 a resolution of @xmath0
. then @xmath41 . proof . 1 .
let @xmath42 be a projective flat morphism over a two dimensional polydisk .
assume that a general fibre of @xmath43 is an abelian variety and @xmath43 is smooth over @xmath44 .
for the proof of lemma [ basic_properties ] ( 1 ) , it is enough to prove that @xmath43 is smooth morphism .
let @xmath45 .
since @xmath43 is smooth over @xmath44 and projective , there exists an tale finite cover @xmath46 and a smooth abelian fibration @xmath47 with a section .
since @xmath44 is simply connected , @xmath48 has a level @xmath49 structure .
we put @xmath50 $ ] the moduli space of @xmath51-dimensional abelian varieties with level @xmath49-structure .
there exists a morphism from @xmath52 $ ] and we extend @xmath53 on @xmath54 by hartogs theorem .
the moduli @xmath50 $ ] has the universal family @xmath55 \to { \mathcal m}_{g}[n]$ ] .
considering the pull back of @xmath55 $ ] by @xmath53 , we obtain a smooth abelian morphism @xmath56 which is the extension of @xmath47 . since @xmath57 is a finite morphism ,
we extend this morhpsim to a finite morphism @xmath58 .
the codimension of @xmath59 is two . by purity of branch loci
, @xmath60 is tale .
hence @xmath61 is a smooth abelian fibration . by construction
, @xmath62 is isomorphic to @xmath63 in codimension one .
let @xmath64 be a @xmath43-ample divisor on @xmath63 and @xmath65 a proper transform on @xmath62 . since every fibre of @xmath66 is an abelian variety , @xmath65 is @xmath66-ample .
thus we obtain that @xmath63 is isomorphic to @xmath62 and @xmath43 is smooth .
2 . let @xmath64 be an @xmath9-ample divisor .
we consider the following function : @xmath67 where @xmath68 @xmath69 .
since @xmath9 is flat , @xmath70 is a continuous function on @xmath7 by ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 3.2 ) .
thus @xmath71 on @xmath7 and @xmath72 since @xmath0 and @xmath73 is birational , @xmath74 on @xmath73 .
@xmath75 ( 2.3 ) we review basic properties of the mixed hodge structure on a simple normal crossing variety . [ restriction ] let @xmath76 be a simple normal crossing variety . then @xmath77 proof
let @xmath78 } : = \cup_{i_0 < \cdots < i_k } x_{i_0 } \cap \cdots \cap x_{i_k } \quad \mbox{(disjoint union)}.\ ] ] for an index set @xmath79 , we define an inclusion @xmath80 @xmath81 we consider the following spectral sequence ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 4 ) : @xmath82 } , { \mathbb c } ) \longrightarrow e^{p+q } = h^{p+q}(x,{\mathbb c}),\ ] ] where @xmath83 is defined by the @xmath84 since this spectral sequence degenerates at @xmath85 level ( @xcite ) , we deduce @xmath86 moreover @xmath87 , @xmath88 .
thus we obtain the assertion of lemma [ restriction ] from the definition of @xmath89 .
@xmath75 [ birationa_invariance ] let @xmath90 be a birational morphism between smooth algebraic varieties .
assume the following two conditions : 1 .
there exists a simple normal crossing divisor @xmath91 on @xmath92 such that @xmath9 is isomorphic on @xmath93 .
2 . @xmath94 is a simple normal crossing divisor . then @xmath95 . proof .
we consider the following exact sequence of morphisms of mixed hodge structures .
@xmath96 note that each morphism has weight @xmath97 .
since @xmath98 carries pure hodge structure of weight @xmath99 , @xmath100 and @xmath101 are @xmath102-map .
moreover @xmath103 .
thus we deduce that @xmath95 . @xmath75
( 3.1 ) in this section , we prove the key proposition of the proof of theorem [ main ] .
first we refer the the folloing theorem due to kulikov , morrison ( * ? ? ?
* classification theorem i ) and persson ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3.3.1 ) .
[ kulikov ] let @xmath104 be a semistable degeneration whose general fibre is an abelian surface .
then there exists a semistable degeneration @xmath105 such that @xmath106 and @xmath107 is birational and @xmath108 .
moreover , exactly one of the following cases occurs : 1 .
@xmath109 is an abelian surface .
@xmath109 consists of a cycle of minimal elliptic ruled surfaces , meeting along disjoint sections .
every selfintersection number of double curve is @xmath102 .
@xmath109 consists of a collection of rational surfraces , such that the double curves on each component form a cycle of rationall curves ; the dual graph @xmath110 of @xmath111 is a triangulation of @xmath112 .
we call @xmath113 a kulikov model of type i , ii or iii according the case occurs ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) or ( 3 ) . ( 3.2 ) we state the key propositon . [ key ] let @xmath114 be a projective complex lagrangian fibration on 4-dimensional symplectic manifold and @xmath14 the discriminant locus of @xmath9 .
if we take a general point @xmath15 of @xmath14 and an unit disk @xmath115 on @xmath7 such that @xmath115 and @xmath14 intersects transversally at @xmath15 and @xmath116 is smooth , then 1 .
@xmath117 is birational to the quotient of kulikov model @xmath113 of type i or type ii by a cyclic group @xmath118 .
2 . there exists a nonzero @xmath118-equivariant element of @xmath119 .
( 3.3 ) for the proof of proposition [ key ] , we need the following lemmas .
[ nonzero_lemma ] let @xmath120 be a birational morphism such that @xmath121 is a simple normal crossing divisor .
then for a general point @xmath15 of the discriminant locus @xmath14 of @xmath9 , @xmath122 where @xmath123 .
let @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
we take an open set @xmath126 of @xmath7 which satisfies the following two conditions : 1 .
@xmath127 is a smooth curve .
2 . @xmath128 } \to d |_{u}$ ] is a smooth morphism for every @xmath106 .
we consider the following exact sequences : @xmath129 @xmath130 since @xmath6 is nondegenerate , @xmath131 on @xmath132 on a non @xmath60-exceptional divisor @xmath132 . by lemma [ basic_properties ]
( 2 ) , the restriction of @xmath6 on every irreducible component of a fibre of @xmath9 is zero .
thus @xmath133 in @xmath134 .
on the contrary , @xmath135 , we deduce @xmath136 for non @xmath60-exceptional divisor @xmath132 .
therefore , for a general point @xmath15 of @xmath14 , @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the fibre of @xmath139 over @xmath15 .
we denote by @xmath140 the restriction @xmath141 to @xmath142 . if @xmath143 , @xmath144 on @xmath145 by the construction . by lemma [ restriction ]
, we deduce that @xmath146 .
@xmath75 [ uniqueness_of_kulikov_model ] let @xmath147 be a kulikov model of type i or type ii .
assume that @xmath106 is birational to a projective abelian fibration @xmath148
. then 1 .
@xmath106 is a projective morphism .
every birational map @xmath149 is birational morphism .
we may assume that @xmath150 is a relatively minimal model over @xmath115 .
then @xmath150 and @xmath113 is isomorphic in codimension one , since @xmath150 and @xmath113 have only terminal singularities and @xmath151 is @xmath152-nef .
let @xmath65 be a @xmath152-ample divisor on @xmath150 and @xmath64 a proper transform on @xmath113 .
since @xmath150 and @xmath113 is isomorhpic in codimension one , @xmath64 is @xmath106-big .
if @xmath64 is @xmath106-nef , we conclude that @xmath150 is isomorhpic to @xmath113 by relative base point free theorem ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3 - 1 - 2 ) then @xmath106 is projective , @xmath113 is the unique relative minimal model and every birational map @xmath149 is birational morphism .
thus we will prove that @xmath64 is @xmath106-nef .
since every big divisor on abelian surface is ample , @xmath64 is @xmath106-nef if @xmath113 is of type i. in the case that @xmath113 is of type ii , we investigate the nef cone of each component of the central fibre of @xmath113 .
let @xmath153 be a component of the central fibre .
then @xmath154 , where @xmath155 is a double curve .
since @xmath155 is a section and @xmath156 , the nef cone of @xmath153 is spaned by @xmath155 and a fibre @xmath157 of the ruling of @xmath153 .
we deduce that every effective divisor on @xmath153 is nef .
therefore @xmath64 is @xmath106-nef in the case that @xmath113 is of type ii .
@xmath75 ( 3.4 ) proof of proposition [ key ] .
let @xmath120 be a birational morphism such that @xmath158 is a simple normal crossing divisor .
we define @xmath159 . if we choose @xmath15 generally , @xmath160 by lemma [ nonzero_lemma ] . by semistable reduction theorem (
* theorem @xmath161 ) , there exists a generically finite surjective morphism @xmath162 such that @xmath163 is a semistable degeneration . by theorem [ kulikov ]
, there exists the kulikov model @xmath147 which is birational to @xmath152 .
we denote by @xmath109 the central fibre of @xmath113 .
then @xmath164 since @xmath165 due to lemma [ birationa_invariance ] and @xmath166 .
thus @xmath113 is of type i or type ii .
let @xmath118 be the galois group of a cyclic extension @xmath167 and @xmath51 a generator of @xmath118 .
since @xmath106 is birational to @xmath152 , there exists a biratinal map @xmath168 correponding to @xmath51 . by lemma [ uniqueness_of_kulikov_model ] , @xmath169 is a birational morphism and @xmath118 acts on @xmath113 holomorphically .
therefore @xmath170 is birational to the quotient @xmath171 .
we claim that @xmath172 carries a nonzero @xmath118-equivariant element .
let @xmath173 be a @xmath118-equivariant resolution of indeterminancy of @xmath174
. then @xmath175 by lemma [ birationa_invariance ] .
let @xmath100 be a nonzero element of @xmath176 .
the pull back of @xmath100 in @xmath177 is non zero @xmath118-equivariant element .
thus there exists a nonzero @xmath118-equivariant element in @xmath172 .
( 4.1 ) in this section , we prove the following proposition .
[ classification_i ] let @xmath117 be an abelian fibration which is birational to the quotient of a kulikov model @xmath113 of type i by a cyclic group @xmath118 .
assume that 1 .
@xmath170 is smooth .
2 . @xmath178 .
3 . there exists a nonzero @xmath118-equivariant element of @xmath172 .
then the representation @xmath179 is faithful and the central fibre @xmath180 of @xmath170 satisfies the properties of theorem [ main ] ( 1 ) ( 4.2 ) we need the following lemma to prove proposition [ classification_i ] .
[ equivariant_fibration ] the central fibre @xmath109 admits an @xmath118-equivariant elliptic fibration over an elliptic curve .
since @xmath109 is an abelian surface , it is enough to prove that @xmath109 admits a @xmath118-equivariant fibration .
let @xmath51 be a generator of @xmath118 .
we consider the following morphism : @xmath181 since @xmath118 is a cyclic group , the kernel of @xmath182 is @xmath118-invariant .
moreover this kernel is nonzero by proposition [ key ] .
therefore @xmath183 has a @xmath118-equivariant sub hodge structure and we conclude that @xmath109 admits a @xmath118-equivariant fibration .
@xmath75 ( 4.3 ) proof of proposition [ equivariant_fibration ] .
we will construct a suitable resolution @xmath173 of @xmath171 and the unique relative minimal model @xmath184 of @xmath173 over @xmath115 . by lemma [ equivariant_fibration ]
, there exists a @xmath118-equivariant elliptic fibration on the central fibre @xmath109 of @xmath113 .
we denote this fibration by @xmath185 . by construction ,
the action of @xmath118 on @xmath186 is translation .
let @xmath187 be the kernel of the representation @xmath188 . since the action of @xmath187 on @xmath189 is a translation , @xmath190 is smooth .
it is enough to consider the action of @xmath191 on @xmath190 for the investigation of the singularities of @xmath171 .
if the action of @xmath191 on @xmath192 is translation , then @xmath171 is smooth .
moreover @xmath171 is the unique relative minimal model over @xmath115 since it has no rational curves . on the contrary
, @xmath170 is a relative minimal model over @xmath115 , @xmath193 . by construction
, the central fibre of the quotient @xmath171 is an hyperelliptic surface .
since every hyperelliptic surface is the tale quotient of the product of elliptic curves , @xmath194 satisfies the property of theorem [ main ] .
we claim that the representation @xmath188 is faithful .
if @xmath187 is not trivial , then @xmath113 is not @xmath118-invariant and @xmath195 . since @xmath196 and @xmath197
, @xmath187 is trivial . in the following ,
we assume that the action of @xmath191 on @xmath192 is trivial . since @xmath198 is @xmath191-equivariant , the singularites of @xmath171 consists of several copies the product of a surface quotient singularity and an elliptic curve .
the list of surface quotient singularities which occur above is found in ( * ? ? ?
* table 5 ( p157 ) ) .
we construct the relative minimal resolution @xmath173 of @xmath171 by the minimal resolution of surface quotient singularities . if the singularities of @xmath171 consists of the product of du val singularities and an elliptic curve only , then @xmath173 is a relative minimal model over @xmath115 and we put @xmath199 . in other cases ,
we obtain a relative minimal model @xmath184 after birational contractions of @xmath173 ( cf .
* pp 156158 ) ) . in both cases
, @xmath184 is the unique minimal model by the similar argument in lemma [ uniqueness_of_kulikov_model ] .
since @xmath184 is birational to @xmath170 and @xmath170 is a relative minimal model over @xmath115 , @xmath200 . by construction ,
the central fibres @xmath201 admit a fibration over @xmath192 .
note that the fibre of @xmath202 is a kodaira singular fiber of type @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 or @xmath26 .
since @xmath203 forms multi sections of @xmath202 , there exists an tale finite cover @xmath204 and the base change @xmath205 is isomorphic to the product of a kodaira singular fibre and an elliptic curve . finally , we prove that the representation @xmath179 is faithful .
we derive a contradiction assuming that @xmath187 is not trivial .
if @xmath199 , then there exists a morphism @xmath206 such that @xmath207 .
since the action of @xmath187 on @xmath109 is translation , @xmath208 is not @xmath118-equivariant and @xmath195 .
however , @xmath209 and @xmath210 , that is a contradiction .
if @xmath211 we consider the base change @xmath212 . since @xmath173 is obtained by blowing up along singular locus of @xmath171 ( cf
* pp 158 ) ) and the singular locus of @xmath171 consists of elliptic curves , @xmath213 is smooth . let @xmath214 , @xmath215 and @xmath216 .
we denote by @xmath0 the central fibre of @xmath217 with reduced structure .
note that @xmath218 , where @xmath219 is the order of @xmath187 .
then @xmath220 by adjunction formula , @xmath221 .
thus @xmath222 .
however , this is a contradiction because @xmath210 . @xmath75
( 5.1 ) in this section , we prove the following proposition and theorem [ main ] .
[ cyclic_case ] let @xmath51 be a generator of @xmath118 and @xmath219 the smallest positive interger such that every component is stable under the action of @xmath224 .
we denote by @xmath187 the subgroup of @xmath118 generated by @xmath224
. then 1 .
by proposition [ birationa_invariance ] , there exists a @xmath118-equivariant element in @xmath172 .
since @xmath226 , every element of @xmath172 is @xmath118-invariant .
2 . from the assumption
there exists an action of @xmath224 on each component of the central fibre of @xmath113 .
let @xmath153 be a component of the central fibre and @xmath227 a ruling .
since every fibre of @xmath228 is @xmath13 and @xmath186 is an elliptic curve , @xmath224 maps a fibre of @xmath228 to a fibre of @xmath228 , that is , @xmath228 is @xmath224-equivariant . from lemma [ cyclic_case ] ( 1 ) and lemma [ restriction ] ,
holomorphic one forms on @xmath153 is invariant under the action of @xmath224 .
thus , the action of @xmath224 on @xmath186 is translation .
therefore @xmath229 is a minimal elliptic ruled surface . from the assumption that each component is stable under the action of @xmath224 ,
the central fibre of the quotient @xmath190 is a cycle of minimal elliptic ruled surfaces .
@xmath75 ( 5.3 ) proof of proposition [ classification_ii ] . from lemma [ cyclic_case ] ,
@xmath230 is smooth and the central fibre of @xmath190 is a cycle of minimal elliptic ruled surfaces .
let @xmath110 be the dual graph of the central fibre of @xmath113 and @xmath51 a generator of @xmath118 .
considering @xmath190 in stead of @xmath113 , we may assume that the action of @xmath231 is trivial if the action of @xmath231 on @xmath110 is trivial .
( 5.3.1 ) if the action of @xmath118 is free , @xmath171 is smooth and this is a relative minimal model over @xmath115 .
every component of the central fibre of @xmath171 is the minimal elliptic ruled surface @xmath153 which has a section @xmath155 such that @xmath154 and @xmath156 .
thus we show that @xmath193 by similar argument as in the proof of lemma [ uniqueness_of_kulikov_model ] .
we claim that the representation @xmath232 is faithful
. if @xmath233 is not trivial , then @xmath208 is not @xmath118-equivariant and @xmath195 .
however @xmath197 , we obtain @xmath233 is trivial . since @xmath110 is a dynkin diagram of type @xmath2 and @xmath118
is a cyclic group , the action of @xmath118 on @xmath110 is either rotation or reflection . 1 .
if the action of @xmath118 on @xmath110 is rotation , the central fibre of @xmath171 is a cycle of minimal elliptic ruled surfaces .
each double curve is a section of a minimal elliptic ruled surface .
2 . if the action of @xmath118 on @xmath110 is reflection , the central fibre @xmath234 of @xmath171 is a chain of minimal elliptic ruled surfaces .
let @xmath153 be the edge component of the central fibre and @xmath235 the component such that @xmath236 .
note that @xmath237 . by adjunction formula ,
@xmath238 therefore , the double curve @xmath239 is a bisection of the ruling of @xmath153 .
every other double curve is a section . if the action of @xmath118 has fixed points , then the action of @xmath118 on @xmath110 is reflection and it preserves two vertices .
the fixed locus of the central fibre consists of sections or bisections of the ruling of components corresponding to the fixed vertices . assuming this lemma , the central fibre of the quotient @xmath171 is a chain of minimal elliptic ruled surfaces .
the singularities of @xmath171 consists of several copies of the product of @xmath240 singlarity and an elliptic curve .
thus the unique relative minimal model @xmath184 over @xmath115 is obtained by blowing up along singlar locus . since @xmath170 is a relative minimal model over @xmath115 , @xmath241 .
the dual graph of the central fibre of @xmath184 is @xmath1 , @xmath4 or @xmath3 .
the double curve on the edge component is a bisection or a section .
every other double curve is section .
we claim that the representation @xmath179 is faithful .
if @xmath187 is not trivial , @xmath208 is not @xmath118-equivariant .
since @xmath242 is the pull back of @xmath243 is crepant , @xmath222 if @xmath187 is not trivial .
however , @xmath197 , that is a contradiction .
( 5.4 ) proof of lemma [ cyclic_case ] .
if the action of @xmath118 on @xmath110 is rotation , there exists no fixed points . thus the action of @xmath118 on @xmath110 is reflection .
we derive the contradiction assuming that @xmath118 fixes one of edges of @xmath110 .
let @xmath186 be the elliptic curve corresponding to the edge which is fixed by @xmath118 .
from lemma [ restriction ] and lemma [ cyclic_case ] , the action of @xmath118 on @xmath186 preserves holomorphic one form on @xmath186 . therefore @xmath186
is fixed locus of the action of @xmath118 .
the singularities of the quotient @xmath171 consist of several copies of the product of @xmath240 singularity and an elliptic curve .
let @xmath244 be the blowing up along @xmath186 .
we denote by @xmath245 each components of @xmath246 .
let @xmath247 be the exceptional divisor coming from the blowing up along @xmath186 .
since the central fibre @xmath246 of @xmath184 is a chain of minimal ellitic ruled surfaces , there exists componets @xmath248 and @xmath249 such that @xmath250 , @xmath251 and @xmath252 @xmath253 . then @xmath254 . since @xmath184 is smooth along @xmath248 , @xmath255 by adjunction formula .
let @xmath157 be a fibre of ruling of @xmath248 .
then @xmath256 since every double curve of @xmath246 is a section , @xmath257 .
however this is a contradiction because @xmath258 .
therefore @xmath118 fixes two vertices .
let @xmath153 be one of the component correponding to the fixed vertices and @xmath227 the ruling of @xmath153 .
since @xmath186 is an elliptic curve and every fibre @xmath228 is @xmath13 , @xmath228 is @xmath118-equivariant . by lemma [ cyclic_case ] ( 1 ) , the action of @xmath118 on @xmath153 preserves one form on @xmath153 .
since the action of @xmath118 is not free , @xmath118 acts on @xmath186 tirivially .
there exist two fixed points on each fibre of the ruling of @xmath153 .
thus we obtain the rest of assertion of lemma [ cyclic_case ] .
@xmath75 ( 5.5 ) proof of theorem [ main ] .
we take a general point @xmath15 of the discriminant locus of @xmath9 and an unit disk @xmath259 such that @xmath260 is smooth . by proposition
[ key ] , the abelian fibraton @xmath261 satisfies assumptions of proposition [ classification_i ] or [ classification_ii ] .
then @xmath180 satisfies the assertions of theorem [ main ] by proposition [ classification_i ] and [ classification_ii ] .
99 w .barth , c .peters and van de ven , _ compact complex surface _ , elgebnisse der mathematik und ihrer grenzgebiete ( 3 ) , 4 , springer verlag , berlin - new york , ( 1984 ) . x+304
. a. fujiki , _ closedness of the douady spaces of complex khler spaces _ ,
inst . math .
, * 14 * , 1978 , 152 . f .griffith and w. schmid , _ recent developments in hodge theory : a discussion of techniques and results _ , in _ discrete subgroups of lie groupes _ , bombay , oxford university press , ( 1973 )
. k. kodaira , _ on compact complex analytic surfaces ii _ , ann .
, * 77 * ( 1963 ) , 563626
. y. kawamata , k. matsuda and k. matsuki , _ introduction to the minimal model problem _ , in _ algebraic geometry , sendai , 1985 _ , adv .
pure math . * 10 * , t. oda ed . , kinokuniya and north - holland ( 1987 ) , 283360 . f. kempf , g. knudsen , d. mumford and b. saint - donat , _ toroidal embeddings i _ , lecture notes in mathematics , * 339 * , springer verlag , berlin - new york , ( 1973 ) . viii+209
d. matsushita , _ on fibre space structures of a projective irreducibe symplectic manifold _ ,
topology , * 38 * ( 1999 ) , 79 - 81 .
d. matsushita , _ addendum to : on fibre space structures of a projective irreducible symplectic manifold _ , to appear topology .
d. morrison , _ the birational geometry of degenerations : an overview _ , in _ the birational geometry of degenerations _ , robert friedman and david r. morrison ed .
, progress in mathematics , * 29 * ( 1981 ) , 132 .
u. persson , _ on degenerations of algebraic surfaces _
11 ( 1977 ) , no | we classify singular fibres over general points of the discriminant locus of projective complex lagrangian fibrations on 4-dimensional holomorphic symplectic manifolds .
the singular fibre @xmath0 is the following either one : @xmath0 is isomorphic to the product of an elliptic curve and a kodaira singular fibre up to finite unramified covering or @xmath0 is a normal crossing variety consisting of several copies of a minimal elliptic ruled surface of which the dual graph is dynkin diagram of type @xmath1 , @xmath2 @xmath3 or @xmath4 . |
the electrostatic interpretation of the zeros of the classical orthogonal polynomials is probably one of the most elegant results in the theory of special functions , linked in the first instance to such a distinguished name as stieltjes ( although studied also by bcher , heine , van vleck , and polya ) .
although this topic has remained `` dormant '' for almost a century , a renewed interest has appeared recently , partially motivated by the connection of this topic with modern powerful techniques from the theory of logarithmic potentials , as well as by an increasing interest on the study of new classes of special functions with roots in physics , combinatorics , number theory , etc .
this paper is a short and light survey on these topics .
our intention is to provide not a comprehensive list of results , but more to convey the `` flavor '' of techniques and ideas behind the electrostatic model and its direct implications in the asymptotic theory . with this purpose , in section [ sec2 ]
we derive the classical electrostatic interpretation of the zeros of jacobi polynomials , found originally by stieltjes , and we describe some of its new and still - in - progress direct generalizations ( section [ sec3 ] ) .
next we discuss a recent progress by ismail in connecting electrostatics with orthogonality in section [ secorthogonality ] . seeking for a model for complex zeros in section [ secmaxmin ] we formulate an alternative model , not constrained to the real line , as well as discuss some further generalizations and applications of the electrostatic model in section [ secfurther ] .
we conclude the paper with some examples of applications of these models to the study of the asymptotic distribution of zeros in the semiclassical limit .
let us begin with a classical and very well - known result , found by stieltjes in 1885 , about the electrostatic interpretation of the zeros of jacobi polynomials @xmath0 .
the definitions and basic properties of these polynomials can be found in chapter iv of the classical monograph by szeg @xcite ; we will mention here only those that will be needed further .
jacobi polynomials can be given explicitly by @xmath1 nevertheless , this formula is not the most useful one , at least for what we are looking for .
another equivalent characterization is the rodrigues formula @xmath2\ ] ] ( cf .
section 4.3 of @xcite ) .
in particular , these expressions show that jacobi polynomials @xmath0 are analytic functions of the parameters @xmath3 and that @xmath4 .
a third characterization of these polynomials , which will play the leading role in the sequel , is that they are the only polynomial solutions ( up to a constant factor ) of the linear differential equation @xmath5 where @xmath6 .
this is a second order linear differential equation of hypergeometric type .
the setting is considered `` classical '' when @xmath7 and @xmath8 . in this case , as we see from ( [ edjac2 ] ) , the residues of the rational coefficient of @xmath9 in the differential equation are both positive .
moreover , we know that with this assumption the jacobi polynomials are orthogonal on @xmath10 $ ] with respect the weight function @xmath11 , i. e. @xmath12 if both @xmath7 and @xmath8 , then the weight is integrable on @xmath10 $ ] , and a well known consequence of is that all the zeros of @xmath0 are simple and lie on the interval @xmath13 .
apparently , it was stieltjes @xcite who observed first that it is possible to give a nice interpretation of the location of these zeros as follows .
put two positive fixed charges of mass @xmath14 and @xmath15 at @xmath16 and @xmath17 , respectively , and allow @xmath18 positive _ unit _ charges @xmath19 to move freely in @xmath13 .
if the interaction obeys the logarithmic potential law ( that is , the force is inversely proportional to the relative distance ) , then in order to find the total energy @xmath20 of this system we have to add to the energy of the mutual interaction of these charges , @xmath21 the component given by the `` external field '' @xmath22 created by the fixed charges , @xmath23 in other words , the total energy is @xmath24 there is a unique configuration @xmath25 , @xmath26 , providing the ( strict ) global minimum of @xmath20 in @xmath10^n$ ] , corresponding to the unique equilibrium position for our free charges . there uniqueness of the global minimum is not obvious , but there is an elegant proof in @xcite , based on the inequality between the arithmetic and geometric means .
however , it is also a consequence of the following statement ( stieltjes theorem ) : _ points @xmath27 are precisely the zeros of the polynomial @xmath0 .
_ the proof is quite straightforward and uses the differential equation . indeed , since @xmath28 as @xmath29 approaches any boundary point of @xmath10^n$ ] , we conclude that @xmath30
. then @xmath31 is also a critical point for the energy functional @xmath20 , and as a consequence , every @xmath27 is a critical point of @xmath32 as a function of @xmath33 ( fixing the rest of @xmath34 s ) .
thus , the following necessary conditions must be satisfied : @xmath35 let us consider the monic polynomial vanishing at @xmath27 s : @xmath36 ; it is easy to check that @xmath37 so that implies @xmath38 for the external field it means that @xmath39 however , the left hand side in is a rational function of the type @xmath40 $ ] with poles at @xmath41 , so , up to a constant factor , it is equal to @xmath42 , which yields ( [ edjac2 ] ) and shows that @xmath43
. observe that we started from the strongest requirement of the _ global _ minimum of @xmath20 ( that we refer to as a _ stable equilibrium _ ) which implied that @xmath31 is also a point of _ local _ minimum , and in consequence , we have a _ `` nash - type '' equilibrium _ ( each function @xmath44 attains its minimum at @xmath45 ) , yielding that each @xmath27 is a _ critical point _ of @xmath46 .
precisely this last statement turned out to be equivalent to the characterizing differential equation ( [ edjac2 ] ) .
the reader should take note of this clear hierarchy of equilibria in this problem .
interesting enough , in the situation we are considering all the equilibria are equivalent . in order to prove it we can consider the hessian matrix @xmath47 of @xmath20 .
straightforward computations show that @xmath48 it is easy to observe that matrix @xmath49 is real , symmetric , strictly diagonally dominant , and its diagonal entries are positive , from which we conclude that @xmath49 is positive definite . in particular ,
every critical point of @xmath32 must be a point of a local minimum .
its uniqueness was observed above , hence it is in fact the point of the global minimum .
stieltjes considered also similar electrostatic models for other two classical orthogonal polynomials : laguerre and hermite . since in this situation the free charges can move on an unbounded set , what ca nt prevent them from escaping to infinity ?
stieltjes found a clever solution in putting a constraint on either the first ( laguerre ) or second ( hermite ) moment of their zero counting measures ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
namely , if for @xmath50 we fix one charge of mass @xmath15 at the origin , and allow @xmath18 positive unit charges @xmath51 to move in @xmath52 with an additional constraint that their arithmetic mean is uniformly bounded , @xmath53 for some positive constant @xmath54 , then again the unique configuration providing the global minimum of the total energy of the system of interacting particles coincides with the rescaled zeros of the laguerre polynomial @xmath55 , where @xmath56 . in a similar way ,
allowing @xmath51 to move freely on the whole @xmath57 , but limiting the arithmetic mean of their _ squares _
, @xmath58 for some constant @xmath54 , the unique configuration providing the global minimum of the total energy of the system of interacting particles coincides with the rescaled zeros of the hermite polynomial @xmath59 , where @xmath60 .
the proof for these both cases is similar to the jacobi case , except that now we are dealing with a constrained minimum , so that the lagrange multipliers corresponding to the restrictions when looking for a necessary condition of a critical point will become part of the characterizing differential equation .
it is strange enough that stieltjes himself did not realize that the unbounded cases ( laguerre and hermite ) could have been put in the same framework that the jacobi one if we allow for an external field not necessarily generated by positive fixed charges .
it was probably ismail @xcite who observed first that the zeros of these polynomials still provide the global minimum of the total energy without any additional constraint or rescaling , if assuming for the laguerre polynomials that @xmath61 is generated by a fixed charge of mass @xmath15 at the origin _ plus _ another term , equal to @xmath62 ; analogously , for the hermite polynomials it is sufficient to take @xmath63 .
reviewing the electrostatic models above several natural questions arise , such as : * are there generalizations of these models to other families of polynomials ? * why necessarily the global minimum of the energy should be considered ?
which other types of equilibria described above could be linked to the zeros of the polynomials ? * what is the appropriate model for the complex zeros ( when they exist ) ?
* what kind of applications can these models have beyond their clear aesthetical value ? in the following sections we will try to give at least some partial answers or to formulate conjectures related to these questions .
in fact , stieltjes studied a more general situation . the _
generalized lam differential _ equation ( in an algebraic form ) is @xmath64 where @xmath65 is a polynomial of degree @xmath66 ( in the sequel we use the notation @xmath67 ) .
the case @xmath68 corresponds to the hypergeometric differential equation , such as ( [ edjac2 ] ) , whyle for @xmath69 we obtain the heun s equation ( see @xcite ) .
heine @xcite proved that for every @xmath70 there exist at most @xmath71 different polynomials @xmath65 in ( [ lame1 ] ) such that this equation has a polynomial solution of degree @xmath18 .
these coefficients @xmath65 are called _ van vleck polynomials _ and the corresponding polynomial solutions @xmath32 are known as _ heine - stieltjes polynomials_. stieltjes studied the problem under the following two assumptions , generalizing the classical situation for the jacobi polynomials : _ ( i ) _ the zeros @xmath72 of @xmath73 are assumed to be simple and real , so without loss of generality we can take @xmath74 _ ( ii ) _ the residues of the coefficients of @xmath75 are all positive : @xmath76 ( cf .
equation ( [ edjac2 ] ) with assumptions @xmath77 , @xmath78 ) .
observe that zeros @xmath79 s define @xmath80 intervals @xmath81 of the real line , and the combinatorial number @xmath82 defined in coincides with the number of different ways of placing @xmath18 balls in @xmath80 boxes .
this is not a mere coincidence . according to stieltjes @xcite , for each vector @xmath83 such that @xmath84 there exists a unique heine - stieltjes polynomial @xmath85 and the unique corresponding van vleck polynomial @xmath86 such that precisely @xmath87 zeros of @xmath85 belong to the interval @xmath81 , @xmath88 .
moreover , these zeros provide the _ unique global minimum _ for the total energy under the _ additional restriction _ of the number of zeros in each interval mentioned above , with the external field created by @xmath89 positive charges fixed at @xmath90 s : @xmath91 this electrostatic model has been used in @xcite in order to study the semiclassical limit @xmath92 ( see section [ sec5 ] ) , and in a number of papers @xcite in describing the probabilistic distribution of these zeros as the number of intervals ( that is , @xmath80 ) grows large together with @xmath18 .
further generalizations of the work by heine and stieltjes followed several paths ; we will mention only some of them .
first , under assumptions ( [ simplezeros])([lame2 ] ) van vleck @xcite and bcher @xcite proved that the zeros of @xmath65 belong to @xmath93 $ ] .
a refinement of this result is due to several works of shah @xcite .
furthermore , plya @xcite showed that , allowing complex zeros of @xmath73 , condition ( [ lame2 ] ) is sufficient to assure that the zeros of @xmath32 are located in the convex hull of @xmath79 s .
marden @xcite and later on , alam , al - rashed , and zaheer ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) established further results on location of the zeros of the heine - stieltjes polynomials under weaker conditions on the coefficients @xmath73 and @xmath94 of ( [ lame1 ] ) .
going back to configuration , not much can be said if we drop the condition of positivity of the residues @xmath94 in ( [ lame2 ] ) ; the situation then becomes much more difficult to handle .
the first attempt was made by grnbaum @xcite , and later on by dimitrov and van assche @xcite .
in particular , in @xcite the case of @xmath95 is analyzed when the positive and negative residues do not interlace : basically , the two cases considered are depicted in figure [ fig : cases ] . [ cols="^,^ " , ] dimitrov and van assche proved that under certain restrictions on the degree of the polynomial and the residues @xmath96 , for every @xmath70 there exists a unique pair @xmath97 of respectively van vleck and heine - stieltjes polynomials with @xmath98 .
all zeros of @xmath99 belong to the interval enclosed by @xmath90 s with @xmath100 ( denoted by @xmath101 in figure [ fig : cases ] ) , and they are in the equilibrium position , given by the global minimum of the discrete energy with the external field . as far as we know , no further studies in this direction exist .
interestingly enough , a similar situation appears when we study a special class of polynomials of multiple orthogonality ( when the orthogonality conditions are distributed among several measures ) , which are object of an intensive study in the last years .
kaliaguine @xcite ( see also the more recent papers by aptekarev @xcite and kaliaguine and ronveaux @xcite ) considered the system of polynomials @xmath102 , @xmath103 , satisfying @xmath104 with @xmath105 , @xmath106 . it is a real case : @xmath107 has exactly @xmath18 zeros in each interval @xmath108 and @xmath109 . the asymptotic analysis ( using the tools of the potential theory )
suggests that a reasonable model for these zeros might be that each of these sets of @xmath18 zeros is the equilibrium position of the positive unit charges , which besides the mutual interaction are subject to the external field generated by the three fixed charges @xmath110 , @xmath111 , @xmath112 at @xmath113 , respectively , and by the @xmath18 charges of the weight @xmath114 on the other subinterval .
nevertheless , this is an open problem . in a recent paper grinshpan
@xcite considered a configuration of zeros on the unit circle .
he characterized the stable equilibrium of the @xmath18 positive unit charges on @xmath115 in the field generated by @xmath18 negative unit charges in @xmath116 and showed that they are zeros of a heine - stieltjes polynomial satisfying a generalized lam differential equation with coefficients symmetric with respect to @xmath117 .
although it might give an impression that here we are dealing with complex zeros , the symmetry of the problem makes it essentially `` real '' .
a more recent paper @xcite extends the problem of stable equilibrium studied in @xcite to the case of a field generated by @xmath118 negative charges in @xmath119 with values @xmath120 , where @xmath121 are the residues of @xmath122 in the zeros @xmath123 of @xmath124 that lie in the open unit disc , and @xmath124 , @xmath125 are polynomials of degree @xmath126 , @xmath127 , respectively , such that , @xmath128 and @xmath129 are the coefficients of the corresponding generalized lam differential equation @xmath130 .
stieltjes theorem is beautiful , and also useful for proving some monotonicity properties of the zeros with respect to the parameters of the system . but is the existence of such a description a mere accident ? why should an electrostatic interpretation of the zeros of general orthogonal polynomials exist at all ?
one fact ( known from the 80 ) that makes us expect further developments is that the appropriate description of the asymptotic behavior ( as @xmath131 ) of the zeros of orthogonal polynomials is given in terms of some _ equilibrium measures _ , that is , measures minimizing certain logarithmic potentials , eventually in presence of an external field ( see @xcite ) . if we go back to the ismail s electrostatic model for the laguerre and hermite polynomials , then it is easy to recognize in the corresponding external field the influence of the weight of orthogonality of these polynomials .
it was definitely an interesting problem to find out if this is a regular fact , tackled by ismail in a series of papers @xcite .
we have noticed that so far the characterizing differential equation has been the cornerstone of the model , and it was a reasonable line of attack .
thus , generalizing some pioneering works of bauldry @xcite , and bonan and clark @xcite , ismail deduced a second order linear differential equation satisfied by a sequence of _ general _ orthogonal polynomials , after which he suggested a model for the zeros .
let us outline briefly his results .
let @xmath132 be polynomials orthonormal with respect to a unit weight function @xmath133 supported on an interval @xmath134\subset { { \mathbb{r}}}$ ] , finite or infinite : @xmath135 then sequence @xmath136 satisfies a three - term recurrence relation @xmath137 with @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
moreover , it has been shown in @xcite , @xcite , and also @xcite , @xcite , that under certain assumptions on @xmath140 the orthonormal polynomials @xmath141 satisfy also the difference - differential relation @xmath142 where the coefficients @xmath143 and @xmath144 are explicitly given in terms of @xmath140 , the recurrence coefficients @xmath145 , and the values of @xmath141 at the endpoints @xmath146 and @xmath147 .
a direct consequence of this is that @xmath141 satisfies also the second order linear differential equation @xmath148 with @xmath149 + \frac{a_n } { a_{n-1}}\ , a_n(x ) a_{n - 1}(x)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , if @xmath150 is the ordered set of zeros of @xmath141 , then @xmath151 comparing it with can associate @xmath152 , and it is natural to consider an electrostatic model for @xmath31 with logarithmic interaction between particles and an external field @xmath153 ( @xmath154 is any appropriate normalization constant , taken in @xcite equal to @xmath155 ) . observe that this external field has two components : the first term in the right hand side of has its origin in the orthogonality weight @xmath133 , and ismail called it the _ long range potential_. the second term , which received the name of the _ short range potential _ , is a bit mysterious , but explains several features of the classical models considered in section [ sec2 ] , and at the same time , allows to give a further generalization of the electrostatic interpretation .
the main result of ismail @xcite states that , assuming @xmath156 on @xmath157 , both @xmath158 and @xmath159 in @xmath160 , and the external field convex , the total energy has a unique point of global minimum , which is precisely @xmath31 ( that is , the zeros of the orthogonal polynomial @xmath141 ) . obviously , what is used here is in fact the relation equivalent to the fact that @xmath31 is just a critical point for @xmath20 , and convexity assures that this is the unique point of minimum .
the proof is in general very similar to the arguments for the jacobi polynomials from section [ sec2 ] . beside some restrictions on the weight of orthogonality
, one drawback of this model in application to general weights is that usually the short range potential can not be explicitly computed in terms of @xmath140 .
this is not the case of the classical polynomials and some of their generalizations .
for instance , for jacobi polynomials , @xmath161 in other words , @xmath140 is responsible for the fields generated by two positive charges of mass @xmath162 and @xmath163 at @xmath16 and @xmath17 , respectively , while the short range potential adds the missing charges of size @xmath114 at @xmath41 .
analogously , for laguerre polynomials we have @xmath164 so that the @xmath165 factor in @xmath140 plus the short range potential are responsible for the fixed charge of size @xmath166 at @xmath167 , and the exponential factor of the weight @xmath140 generates the remaining component @xmath62 of the external field @xmath61 , as described at the end of section [ sec2 ] .
so far the only role played by the short range component was adding some extra weight to the charges fixed by the weight .
however , @xmath143 can be responsible for a creation of `` ghost '' movable charges ( either positive or negative ) in the picture , as it was shown first by grnbaum @xcite ( work that in fact predates @xcite ) or by ismail himself when analyzing the case of the so - called freud weight , @xmath168 .
let us consider here a little bit more general situation .
a generalized weight function ( or measure ) is _ semiclassical _ ( see e.g. @xcite ) if it satisfies the _ pearson equation _
@xmath169 where @xmath170 , @xmath171 are polynomials , with degree of @xmath172 , and @xmath173 is the `` derivative '' operator ( in the usual , but also possibly in a distributional sense ) .
it is well known that for such a weight the corresponding orthogonal polynomials ( called also _ semiclassical _ ) satisfy a differential equation of the type ( [ diff_eq ] ) , where the coefficients @xmath125 and @xmath174 are rational functions .
the classical - type orthogonal polynomials considered by grnbaum @xcite are an example of a semiclassical family , but there are many more ( for instance , the so - called sieved orthogonal polynomials @xcite , among others ) .
the systematic study of the semiclassical orthogonal polynomials from the point of view of the electrostatic interpretation of their zeros has started in the works of garrido and collaborators @xcite , @xcite .
for instance , they consider a perturbation of the freud weight function ( @xmath168 ) by the addition of a fixed charged point of mass @xmath175 at the origin ; the corresponding orthogonal polynomials are known as freud - type polynomials .
the resulting orthogonality measure is semiclassical , and it was proved in @xcite that these polynomials satisfy a second order linear differential equation of the form , and the electrostatic model is in sight .
in fact , in the situation considered , and following ismail s terminology , the long range potential is , as expected , @xmath176 , while the short range potential depends on the degree @xmath18 and has the following structure : @xmath177 where @xmath178 has two real roots @xmath179 and two simple conjugate complex roots @xmath180 .
their asymptotic behavior is @xmath181 in fact , in the odd case , both real zeros coalesce at the origin : @xmath182 canceling out the denominator in the argument of the logarithm in . in other words ,
the short range potential is given by one unit positive charge fixed at the origin , plus 4 floating negative charges of weight @xmath183 on @xmath184 situated symmetrically with respect to the origin .
however , in the odd case two of these negative charges annihilate with the fixed positive one , paving the way to a zero of the orthogonal polynomial to take the origin , position it must occupy due to the symmetry of the problem .
this annihilation has as a consequence that for odd @xmath18 s the freud and the freud - type polynomials are identical .
moreover , shows that also for the even case they are asymptotically identical ( as @xmath92 ) .
one of the main results of @xcite , @xcite is that the zeros of the freud - type polynomials provide a _ critical configuration _ for the total energy @xmath20 ( in other words , that for these zeros @xmath31 equations are satisfied ) .
but can we assure that they are in a stable equilibrium , that is , that @xmath185 ?
the complete answer is not clear yet . by computing the hessian matrix @xmath49 it was proved that for small values of the correction charge @xmath186 this is really the case , but there are some evidences that make it possible to conjecture the existence of a critical value @xmath187 such that for @xmath188 the zeros of the orthogonal polynomials attain the minimum of the total energy , but for @xmath189 the equilibrium is no longer stable .
is still any other type of equilibria discussed in section [ sec2 ] preserved in this case ( beside the critical point of the energy ) ?
this is also an open question .
from potential theory it is well known that many of energy minimization problems have in fact a min - max ( or max - min ) characterization .
let us analyze again , but from this point of view , the classical models of stieltjes , and in passing , address the issue why the real line should be present in the model .
this question is not trivial : let us go back to the jacobi polynomials @xmath0 with @xmath190 .
why their zeros should be real ?
a standard explanation is that these polynomials satisfy the orthogonality conditions , but where the real line is present in that integral ?
observe that the integrand in is an analytic function , so we perfectly can obtain the same result integrating along any reasonable curve joining @xmath16 with @xmath17 . the real line is also built in the electrostatic model of stieltjes as an a priori constraint .
however , we may put forward an alternative model free from this restriction . as in the stieltjes setting we fix two positive charges of mass @xmath14 and @xmath15 at @xmath16 and @xmath17 , respectively , and denote again by @xmath20 the total energy of a discrete system @xmath191 , given by formulas
( assuming that in case of coincidence of any two points , @xmath192 ) .
denote by @xmath193 the family of compact continua on @xmath184 containing both @xmath194 and @xmath17 . for any @xmath195 set @xmath196 and consider the following extremal problem : @xmath197 [ theorem1 ] @xmath198 , and this value is attained at a unique @xmath18-tuple @xmath199 , characterized by the fact that @xmath200 are precisely the zeros of the jacobi polynomial @xmath201 .
let @xmath51 be any configuration of @xmath18 distinct points on the interval @xmath13 ( the case of coalescence of some points is trivial ) , and let @xmath202 be any other continuum .
since @xmath203 , we can assure that there exists a discrete set of points @xmath204 of the form @xmath205 ( that is , any vertical line passing through an @xmath206 must intersect @xmath54 ) .
it is straightforward to check that @xmath207 .
hence , @xmath208 ) \geq m(k)\,,\ ] ] and since @xmath54 was arbitrary , we obtain that @xmath209)$ ] . but from stieltjes theorem
it follows that there exists a unique @xmath210 such that @xmath211)$ ] , and the points of @xmath31 are the zeros of @xmath212 , which concludes the proof .
obviously , a similar result is possible to formulate for laguerre and hermite polynomials .
the value of the min - max model we have described is that it allows to consider easily complex zeros of these classical families , which appear when the parameters involved become no longer `` classical '' ( see for instance figure [ fig2 ] with two examples of zeros of jacobi polynomials ) .
in fact , as it follows from the rodrigues formula , if we allow for arbitrary real @xmath213 and @xmath214 , the jacobi polynomials constitute a very rich object exhibiting several types of orthogonalities : hermitian , non - hermitian , and even multiple , depending on the values of the parameters and the degree ( see the classification of all cases obtained @xcite ) .
we conjecture that theorem [ theorem1 ] is valid in all these situations after a suitable modification of the family of continua @xmath193 .
for instance , if @xmath215 ( see figure [ fig2 ] , left ) , the appropriate class @xmath193 would include all continua extending to infinity , and _ separating _ @xmath16 and @xmath17 . from the results of @xcite
a rule of the thumb follows : if @xmath216 ( resp .
, if @xmath217 ) then the continua from @xmath193 must contain @xmath17 ( resp . , @xmath16 ) .
moreover , if @xmath218 , then the continua from @xmath193 must include the infinity . and @xmath219 . , title="fig : " ] and @xmath219 .
, title="fig : " ] all these facts have been conjectured by one of this authors some time ago , but their proof still remains an open problem . a general approach to such kind of theorems would allow also to tackle other kind of problems not linked directly to the real line or exhibiting non - real zeros .
typical examples are those related to the multiple ( or hermite - pad ) orthogonality , when the orthogonality conditions are distributed among several measures , or of non - hermitian orthogonality , when the path of integration is , in fact , not fixed a priori . in many situations
these polynomials exhibit complex zeros , whose _ asymptotic _
distribution has been studied by several authors . from the pioneering works of stahl
@xcite it is known that the limiting location of the zeros is usually described by some trajectories of a quadratic differential , which in turn have a min - max description .
this gives an additional evidence to our conjecture , that in fact says that this behavior is not exclusive of large @xmath18 s ( a kind of `` discrete version '' of stahl s theorem ) .
many new interesting problems related to the electrostatic models have their origin either in some non - standard orthogonality conditions ( such as non - hermitian or multiple orthogonality mentioned above ) , or in physical applications . in this section
we will briefly review some of them . exactly solvable or quasi -
exactly solvable multi - particle quantum mechanical systems have many remarkable properties .
especially , those of the calogero - sutherland - moser ( csm ) systems @xcite and their integrable deformation called the ruijsenaars - schneider - van diejen ( rsvd ) systems @xcite have been well studied .
a classical result is that the equilibrium positions of the csm systems are described by the zeros of the classical orthogonal polynomials ; the hermite , laguerre , and jacobi polynomials @xcite ( see also @xcite for a comprehensive review and bibliography therein ) . following this analogy
the authors of @xcite proved recently that the equilibrium positions of the rsvd systems with rational and trigonometric potentials coincide again with zeros of polynomials from the askey tableau of hypergeometric orthogonal polynomials ; namely , they found connections with the meixner - pollaczek , continuous hahn , continuous dual hahn , and the askey - wilson polynomials . hence , an electrostatic model for the zeros of hypergeometric polynomials in all their generality could have several interesting applications for exactly solvable quantum - mechanical systems .
another interesting model was considered by loutsenko @xcite , who studied a system @xmath220 of @xmath18 positive and @xmath221 negative _ moving _ charges in @xmath184 of masses 1 and @xmath222 , respectively ( with @xmath223 ) , interacting again according to the logarithmic law .
he proved in particular that if @xmath224 is a critical configuration of the mutual energy @xmath225 , @xmath80 is the monic polynomial vanishing at the points of @xmath31 , and @xmath226 is the monic polynomial vanishing at those of @xmath227 , then @xmath228 are solutions of a _ bilinear _ differential equation @xmath229 regarding the lam equation , once we depart from the classical setting considered by stieltjes , the description of the heine - stieltjes polynomials is not apparent .
it is clear however that we can hardly expect that their zeros provide a stable equilibrium ; instead , we must concentrate on the least restrictive condition of configuration providing critical values of the energy functional .
this study has again some physical applications .
the @xmath230 elliptic inozemtsev model is a quantum integrable system with @xmath18-particles whose potential is given by elliptic functions . for the case @xmath231
, finding eigenstates of its hamiltonian is equivalent to solving the heun equation ( see e.g.@xcite . in this sense
, the @xmath230 inozemtsev model is a generalization of the heun equation .
there are also connections of some problems in physics and representation theory with multiple orthogonal polynomials .
it is known that zeros of the jacobi polynomial @xmath201 satisfy a system of algebraic equations , which is known as the _ bethe ansatz equation _ of the gaudin model associated to @xmath232 and two irreducible modules with highest weights @xmath233 . in @xcite
the authors generalized this connection , studying sequences of @xmath234 polynomials whose zeros constitute the unique solution of the bethe ansatz equation associated with two highest weight @xmath235 irreducible modules , with the restriction that the highest weight of one of the modules is a multiple of the first fundamental weight . as a result , they show that the first polynomial in the sequence coincides with the well known jacobi - pieiro multiple orthogonal polynomial , and others are given by wronskian type determinants of jacobi - pieiro polynomials . in @xcite
they derived a linear differential equation ( alas , of order @xmath234 ) for these polynomials , paving a way to the electrostatic interpretation of their zeros .
finally , we can mention the matrix orthogonal polynomials , whose non - trivial connections with ( matrix ) differential equations is being studied .
duran and grnbaum gave in @xcite some examples of matrix orthogonal polynomials @xmath236 satisfying the second order linear ode of the form @xmath237 where ( as in the scalar hypergeometric case ) coefficients @xmath238 are matrix polynomials that do not depend on @xmath18 , of degrees @xmath239 , @xmath240 , and @xmath241 , respectively , and @xmath242 are hermitian matrices .
these @xmath236 look like a natural generalization of the families of classical polynomials in the scalar case ; likewise , they exhibit a rich variety of structural properties ( see @xcite ) .
furthermore , they might have some relevance in the analysis of the dirac equation ( relativistic analogue of the schrodinger equation ) .
however , a study of the electrostatic interpretation of the zeros of the orthogonal matrix polynomials remains completely open .
assume we have an electrostatic model of @xmath18 positive charges moving in an external field , and we are interested to analyze what happens when @xmath92 ( the so - called thermodynamic or semiclassical limit ) .
in many situations this information can be extracted directly from the characterizing second order linear differential equation , using either the wkb approach ( cf.@xcite@xcite , @xcite@xcite , @xcite@xcite ) , or reducing the ode to a riccati form , a method that we outline below . but first we should introduce some notation and agree in the meaning of the `` global '' asymptotics of the zeros . in the sequel , @xmath243 denotes the support of a measure @xmath244 , and @xmath245 is its stieltjes ( or cauchy ) transform . with a function @xmath246 we can associate its _ zero counting measure _ @xmath247 , defined by @xmath248 where @xmath249 is the unit mass ( dirac delta ) at @xmath250 , and the sum goes along all the zeros of @xmath251 taking into account their multiplicity .
equivalently , for each borel set @xmath252 the number of zeros of @xmath251 in @xmath101 is @xmath253 an important observation is that if @xmath80 is a polynomial and @xmath254 is the associated zero - counting measure , then the logarithmic derivative of @xmath80 is the stieltjes transform of @xmath255 : @xmath256 which can be evaluated away from the zeros of @xmath80 .
the `` global '' behavior of the zeros of polynomials @xmath257 , @xmath258 , is described by the limit of the sequence of _ normalized _ measures @xmath259 as @xmath260 , in the sense of the weak- * topology .
recall ( cf .
* section 2 ) ) that a sequence of borel measures @xmath261 converges to a measure @xmath262 in the weak- * topology ( which we denote as @xmath263 ) if @xmath264 another important fact is that the set of unit measures with uniformly bounded supports is compact in the weak- * topology .
hence , if we know for instance that all the zeros of the sequence of polynomials @xmath136 , @xmath258 , belong to the same compact set @xmath265 , then there always exists a unit measure @xmath244 supported on @xmath54 and a subsequence @xmath266 such that @xmath267 for @xmath268 ( where @xmath269 are the normalized zero counting measures defined above ) . in consequence , and taking into account , we have that @xmath270 the method of reduction of the original second order ode to the riccati form is based on the previous observation .
this idea appears in a work of saff , ullman , and varga @xcite , although its roots can be traced back to the famous perron s monograph @xcite , who in turn gives credit to some original works of euler .
recently it has been successfully applied in a variety of problems ( see , e. g. @xcite ) .
let us see how it works in the simplest case of jacobi polynomials @xmath271 with @xmath272 .
the first step is to rewrite equation ( [ edjac2 ] ) in terms of the normalized logarithmic derivative of the polynomial solution , @xmath273 which yields @xmath274 since all the zeros of @xmath141 are in @xmath10 $ ] , by the argument explained above we can assure the existence of a unit measure @xmath244 supported on @xmath10 $ ] and a subsequence @xmath266 such that ( see ) @xmath275 , @xmath276 , uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath277 $ ] , where @xmath278 are also uniformly bounded . taking limits in ( [ beforelimits ] ) when @xmath268 we arrive at an _ algebraic _ equation for @xmath279 : @xmath280 , so that @xmath281 and the appropriate branch of the square root in @xmath282 $ ] is fixed by the condition @xmath283 .
furthermore , since @xmath284 is independent on @xmath285 , we can claim that @xmath244 is in fact the weak- * limit of @xmath261 along @xmath92 .
it remains only to recover @xmath244 from its stieltjes transform . since we know ( important fact
that @xmath286 $ ] , this task is just a straightforward application of the sokhotsky - plemelj s formulas ( that allow to find @xmath244 from the boundary values of @xmath287 on @xmath13 ) , that yield that the limit measure @xmath244 is absolutely continuous and its density is @xmath288 ( fact that we do not claim that was discovered by us ; probably , it is at least 150 years old ) . in some more difficult situations
the described elementary method becomes technically involved , and we have to turn to other resources .
one of the advantages of the electrostatic interpretation of the zeros of a sequence of polynomials is that it allows us to guess what happens in the thermodynamic limit .
for instance , if for each @xmath18 the configuration of zeros is a global minimizer of the total energy , then it is natural to expect ( and can be proved ) that the asymptotics in a `` global sense '' should be well described ( at least , in the first approximation ) by a continuous distribution which is solution of the corresponding extremal problem for the logarithmic potential energy in the class of all probability measures ( including the absolutely continuous ones ) .
this distribution is known as the equilibrium measure , probably , in an external field ( see @xcite for details and definitions ) .
let us consider for example the generalized lam equation ( [ lame1 ] ) under the assumptions ( [ simplezeros])([lame2 ] ) .
we are interested in the limit @xmath92 with the extra assumptions @xmath289 ( see section [ sec3 ] for notation ) . since for every @xmath290
the zeros minimize the total discrete energy of the system , we can expect that any weak- * limit @xmath291 of the zero - counting unit measures of the heine - stieltjes polynomials @xmath85 solves a similar , but continuous , extremal problem .
indeed , it was proved in @xcite that if @xmath292 denotes the class of all probability measures @xmath293 on @xmath294 $ ] such that @xmath295 then @xmath244 is the minimizer of the logarithmic energy in the class @xmath296 .
existence and uniqueness of this minimizer is proved by standard methods of potential theory . at this stage
we can apply the reduction to the riccati form method described above to get the full description of @xmath244 .
let us summarize briefly some results from @xcite .
for any system of @xmath297 points @xmath298 we define the functions @xmath299 then there exist @xmath297 points ( [ puntosbeta ] ) uniquely determined by the following system of equations : @xmath300 where we take the limit values of @xmath49 from the upper half plane . if we introduce the counting function @xmath301\bigg ( ( -\infty , x]\bigg)\,,\ ] ] then @xmath302 and it consists of at most @xmath297 disjoint intervals in @xmath10 $ ] . 1 .
if we have no a priori information on the location of the zeros , then the reduction of the ode to the riccati form will give us at most an expression of the cauchy transform @xmath284 of the limit distribution @xmath244 in the domains ( unknown ) disjoint with @xmath243 ( and @xmath243 could be , eventually , a subset of @xmath184 of positive plane measure ) .
does this information determine @xmath244 ?
it is not clear , although for some specific expressions of @xmath284 this should be really the case .
if we are analyzing heine - stieltjes polynomials whose zeros provide a critical configuration for the total energy @xmath20 ( but not the global minimum ! ) , then what measure @xmath244 should we expect in the semiclassical limit ?
clearly , @xmath244 is not necessarily an equilibrium measure , but rather a _ critical measure _ , that on the real line can be characterized by the fact that its potential ( plus the external field , if exists ) is constant on each connected component of @xmath243 , but unlike in the equilibrium case , these constants need not to be the same . however , in this description two open problems remain : _ ( i ) _ to prove that discrete critical measures converge in the thermodynamic limit to continuous critical measures , and that all continuous critical measures can be obtained this way ; _ ( ii ) _ to find a feasible description of the multi - parametric family of continuous critical measures in the given class .
this research was supported , in part , by a grant of direccin general de investigacin ( ministerio de ciencia y tecnologa ) of spain , project code bfm200306335c0302 ( fm ) , a grant from the ministry of education and science of spain , project code mtm2005 - 08648-c02 - 01 ( amf , pmg ) , by junta de andaluca , grupo de investigacin fqm 0229 ( amf , pmg ) , by `` research network on constructive complex approximation ( necca ) '' , intas 03 - 51 - 6637 ( fm , amf ) , and by nato collaborative linkage grant `` orthogonal
polynomials : theory , applications and generalizations '' , ref .
pst.clg.979738 ( amf ) .
f. calogero , solution of the one - dimensional @xmath306-body problems with quadratic and/or inversely quadratic pair potentials , j. math
* 12 * ( 1971 ) , 419436 .
erratum in j. math
. phys . * 37*(7 ) ( 1996 ) , 3646 .
d. k. dimitrov and w. van assche , lam differential equations and electrostatics , proc .
amer . math .
, * 128 * ( 2000 ) , 36213628 and erratum to `` lam differential equations and electrostatics '' , proc .
* 131 * ( 2003 ) , 23032303 .
p. maroni , une thorie algbrique des polynmes orthogonaux .
application aux polynmes orthogonaux semi - classiques . in : _
orthogonal polynomials and their applications ( erice , 1990 ) _ , imacs ann .
appl . math . * 9 * , 95130 , baltzer , basel , 1991 .
a. martnez - finkelshtein , p. martnez - gonzlez , and r. orive , zeros of jacobi polynomials with varying non - classical parameters , in : _ proceedings of the international workshop on special functions : asymptotics , harmonic analysis and mathematical physics_. ch .
dunkl , m. ismail , and r. wong , eds .
city university of hong kong , world scientific , 2000 , 98113 .
a. martnez - finkelshtein , p. martnez - gonzlez , and r. orive , on asymptotic zero distribution of laguerre and generalized bessel polynomials with varying parameters , j. comput .
appl . math .
* 133 * ( 2001 ) , 477487 .
a. martnez - finkelshtein , p. martnez - gonzlez , and r. orive , asymptotics of polynomial solutions of a class of generalized lam differential equations , electron .
* 19 * ( 2005 ) , 1828 .
a. martnez , a. zarzo , and r. j. yez , two approaches to the zero asymptotics of a class of hypergeometric type polynomials , mat .
sbornik * 185 * ( 1994 ) , 6578 ; russian acad .
sb . math .
* 83 * ( 1995 ) , 483494 .
a. martnez - finkelshtein , p. martnez - gonzlez , and a. zarzo , wkb approach to zero distribution of solutions of linear second order differential equations , j. comput .
* 145 * ( 2002 ) , 167182 .
e. b. saff , j. l. ullman , and r. s. varga .
incomplete polynomials : an electrostatics approach , collection : _ approximation theory iii _ ( proc .
texas ) , e. w. cheney , ed .
, academic press , new york - london , ( 1980 ) , 769782 . a. zarzo and j. s. dehesa , spectral properties of solutions of hypergeometric type differential equations , in : _ proc . of the v international congress on computational and applied mathematics _ , f. broeckx et al .
eds . , j. comput .
appl . math .
* 50 * ( 1994 ) , 613623 .
a. zarzo , _ ecuaciones diferenciales de tipo hipergeomtrico : propiedades algebraicas y espectrales de sus soluciones .
aplicaciones mecano - cunticas _ , doctoral dissertation , universidad de granada , granada , 1995 ( in spanish ) . | we give a survey concerning both very classical and recent results on the electrostatic interpretation of the zeros of some well - known families of polynomials , and the interplay between these models and the asymptotic distribution of their zeros when the degree of the polynomials tends to infinity . the leading role is played by the differential equation satisfied by these polynomials .
some new developments , applications and open problems are presented .
dedicated to nico temme on the occasion of his 65th birthday .
second order differential equation , orthogonal polynomials , zeros , asymptotics , electrostatic model , logarithmic potential |
the well - known regular bartnik - mckinnon ( bm ) solutions @xcite and the corresponding non - abelian black hole solutions @xcite , are asymptotically flat , static spherically symmetric solutions of su(2 ) einstein - yang - mills ( eym ) theory .
they are unstable solutions , sphalerons @xcite , and are characterized by the number of nodes of the gauge field . besides the bm solutions there are also asymptotically flat , static , only axially symmetric regular and black hole solutions @xcite .
these are characterized by two integers , the node number of their gauge field function(s ) , and the winding number with respect to the azimuthal angle , denoted @xmath2 .
the spherically symmetric solutions have winding number @xmath5 , while the axially symmetric solutions have winding number @xmath6 . in su(2 )
einstein - yang - mills - higgs ( eymh ) theory , with a triplet higgs field , gravitating monopole solutions arise @xcite .
while gravitating monopoles with unit magnetic charge are spherically symmetric , the known gravitating multimonopoles possess axial symmetry @xcite . as in eym theory ,
these eymh solutions are characterized by two integers , the node number of the gauge field and the azimuthal winding number @xmath2 , which corresponds to the topological charge of the monopoles .
but eymh theory allows for further static axially symmetric solutions , representing gravitating monopole - antimonopole pair , chain and vortex solutions @xcite .
these solutions can be characterized by the azimuthal winding number @xmath2 , and by a second integer @xmath7 , related to the polar angle . for the monopole - antimonopole chains , which in flat space arise for @xmath5 and 2
, the integer @xmath7 corresponds to the number of nodes of the higgs field ( and thus the number of poles on the symmetry axis ) @xcite . in vortex solutions , on the other hand , which in flat space arise for winding number @xmath8 ,
the higgs field vanishes ( for even @xmath7 ) on @xmath9 rings centered around the symmetry axis @xcite .
the existence of monopole - antimonopole pair , chain and vortex solutions in eymh theory @xcite immediately leads to the question , whether there might be analogous solutions in eym theory , even though there would be no higgs field participating in the subtle interplay of attraction and repulsion . in this letter
we report the existence of one such new type of solution , related to vortex solutions in eymh theory . in section
ii we present the eym action , the axially symmetric ansatz and the boundary conditions . in section iii
we discuss the properties of the new axially symmetric solutions , and we present our conclusions in section iv .
we consider the su(2 ) eym action @xmath10 with ricci scalar @xmath11 , field strength tensor @xmath12 \ , \label{fmn}\ ] ] gauge potential @xmath13 , and gravitational and yang - mills coupling constants @xmath14 and @xmath15 , respectively .
variation of the action ( [ action ] ) with respect to the metric @xmath16 leads to the einstein equations , variation with respect to the gauge potential @xmath17 to the gauge field equations . in isotropic coordinates the static axially symmetric metric reads @xcite @xmath18 where the metric functions @xmath19 , @xmath7 and @xmath20 are functions of the coordinates @xmath21 and @xmath22 , only .
the @xmath23-axis ( @xmath24 , @xmath25 ) represents the symmetry axis .
regularity on the @xmath23-axis requires @xmath26 there . for the gauge field
we employ the ansatz @xcite @xmath27 \ . \label{gf1}\ ] ] here the symbols @xmath28 , @xmath29 and @xmath30 denote the dot products of the cartesian vector of pauli matrices , @xmath31 , with the spatial unit vectors @xmath32 respectively .
the gauge field functions @xmath33 , @xmath34 , depend on the coordinates @xmath21 and @xmath22 , only . for @xmath35 and @xmath36 , @xmath37 the bm solutions @xcite are recovered , while for @xmath3 , @xmath6 , one obtains the axially symmetric solutions of @xcite .
the new solutions reported here are obtained for @xmath4 .
they are related to eymh solutions with @xmath38 in the limit of vanishing higgs field @xcite .
the ansatz is form - invariant under the abelian gauge transformation @xcite @xmath39 we fix the gauge by choosing the gauge condition @xcite @xmath40 to obtain asymptotically flat solutions which are globally regular and possess the proper symmetries , we need to impose appropriate boundary conditions @xcite . at the origin
we impose the boundary conditions @xmath41 at infinity we impose @xmath42 and on the @xmath23-axis we impose @xmath43 we further introduce the dimensionless coordinate @xmath44 , and the dimensionless mass @xmath45 , @xmath46
subject to the above boundary conditions , we solve the system of seven coupled non - linear partial differential equations numerically . to map spatial infinity to the finite value @xmath47 , we employ the radial coordinate @xcite @xmath48 the numerical calculations are based on the newton - raphson method , and are performed with help of the program fidisol @xcite .
the equations are discretized on a non - equidistant grid in @xmath49 and @xmath22 .
typical grids used have sizes @xmath50 , covering the integration region @xmath51 and @xmath52 . for the method , it is essential to have a good first guess , to start the iteration procedure . for the @xmath3 eym solutions ,
the @xmath5 bm solutions serve as a first guess , and then the ` parameter ' @xmath2 is varied ( via unphysical noninteger values ) to obtain solutions with higher winding number @xmath2 @xcite . for the @xmath53 solutions we employ the @xmath54 eymh vortex solution with ( almost ) vanishing higgs field as a first guess @xcite , and then again vary @xmath2 .
similarly , for the @xmath55 solutions we start from the @xmath56 eymh vortex solution . in eymh theory , the monopole - antimonopole pair ( map ) solution is obtained , when @xmath57 , @xmath5 . here a monopole and an antimonopole are located symmetrically on the @xmath23-axis .
similarly , one might try to find a sphaleron - antisphaleron pair ( sap ) solution in eym theory .
the boundary conditions of such a sap solution , however , do not differ from those of a bm solution . consequently , when the eymh coupling constant @xmath58 ( where @xmath59 is the higgs field expectation value ) is varied , the gravitating map solution starts from the flat space solution , reaches a critical solution at a maximal value of @xmath60 , and then with decreasing @xmath60 smoothly reaches the bm solution in the limit @xmath61 ( after rescaling of the radial coordinate ) @xcite . consequently , we do not find a sap solution in eym theory , and similarly , we do not find new solutions , when @xmath57 , @xmath6 , since their boundary conditions agree with those of the axially symmetric solutions of @xcite .
when @xmath62 , however , the boundary conditions eq .
( [ bc ] ) for the gauge field differ from those of the known solutions @xcite .
we therefore may expect the existence of new eym solutions , subject to these boundary conditions .
indeed , for @xmath63 , @xmath64 , for instance , when @xmath60 is varied again , the gravitating eymh vortex solution starts from the flat space solution @xcite , reaches a critical solution at a maximal value of @xmath60 , and then with decreasing @xmath60 smoothly reaches a new eym solution in the limit @xmath61 ( after rescaling of the radial coordinate ) @xcite .
let us in the following refer to the solutions characterized by the integers @xmath1 and @xmath2 as @xmath0 solutions . in fig .
1a we exhibit the energy density of the new @xmath65 eym solution .
its energy density has a pronounced maximum on the @xmath66-axis , thus the energy density is torus - like .
the energy density of this @xmath65 solution is thus similar to the energy density of the ( lowest mass ) known @xmath67 eym solution @xcite , exhibited in fig .
but the maximum of the @xmath65 solution is smaller than the maximum of the @xmath67 solution , and it is shifted slightly inwards .
in addition , the @xmath65 solution has a small saddle point on the @xmath66-axis , located further outwards . on the other hand comparison with the corresponding eymh solution @xcite shows ,
that the energy density of the eym solution differs significantly from the energy density of the flat space @xmath65 eymh solution , whose energy density exhibits two tori , located symmetrically with respect to the @xmath68-plane @xcite .
the existence of a @xmath53 eym solution with winding number @xmath64 , immediately suggests that analogous solutions with winding number @xmath69 should exist as well .
indeed , by increasing @xmath2 , a whole set of such new solutions is obtained numerically , one for each integer @xmath2 .
on the other hand , a decrease of @xmath2 does not lead to new solutions .
instead a bifurcation at the non - integer and thus unphysical value of @xmath70 is obtained , where a second branch of solutions with higher mass appears .
consequently there is a second solution for @xmath64 , and also for each higher integer @xmath2 , but there are no such solutions for integer @xmath71 .
this is illustrated in fig .
2a , where we exhibit the mass of these @xmath72 eym solutions .
only the integer values of @xmath2 in the figure correspond to physical solutions . in fig .
2b we illustrate the value of the metric function @xmath19 at the origin .
we note , that for @xmath73 solutions ( with a single node ) we find only one branch , which is also exhibited in figs . 2 .
to illustrate the dependence of the solutions on @xmath2 , we exhibit the energy density of the @xmath72 solutions with @xmath74 on the lower ( mass ) branch in fig .
3a and on the upper branch in fig .
3b . with increasing @xmath2 the maximum of the energy density decreases and moves outwards for the solutions on both branches .
for the same @xmath2 , the maximum of the upper mass solutions is higher and located further inwards than the maximum of the lower mass solutions .
the small saddle point turns into a small maximum on the upper branch , thus the energy density of the solutions on the upper branch has a more complicated structure as seen in fig . 4 , where a surface of constant energy density is shown for the @xmath65 solution .
we exhibit the gauge field function @xmath75 for the same set of solutions in figs . 5 . for @xmath55
we obtain a similar pattern of solutions .
but the new type of solutions appears only for @xmath76 .
the mass and the value of the metric function @xmath19 at the origin of these @xmath77 solutions are also shown in figs .
the energy density for @xmath77 solutions with @xmath78 and the gauge field function @xmath75 are shown in figs . 6 and 7 , respectively .
based on these results , we conjecture the existence of @xmath0 solutions with @xmath79 , but expect that they will appear only for still larger values of @xmath2 .
we have constructed numerically new static regular solutions of eym theory with axial symmetry .
these solutions are characterized by the integers @xmath0 , related to the azimuthal and polar angles , respectively . in particular , we have obtained solutions for @xmath53 , @xmath80 , and @xmath55 , @xmath81 .
like the previously known @xmath73 solutions @xcite , the @xmath72 and @xmath77 solutions on the lower branch have a torus - like shape . on the upper branch of the @xmath77 solutions
double tori appear for larger @xmath2 . the @xmath73 solutions ( with one node )
most likely exist for any integer @xmath82 and form a single branch .
the new @xmath72 and @xmath77 solutions have lower bounds on @xmath2 , @xmath83 , which imply the existence of two branches of solutions for both values of @xmath1 .
we expect , that the @xmath72 and @xmath77 solutions represent only the first sequences of new solutions , and conjecture the existence of @xmath0 solutions also for higher values of @xmath1 .
the @xmath3 bm solutions are unstable @xcite , and there is all reason to believe , that the new @xmath0 solutions are also unstable .
having constructed the regular axially symmetric solutions it appears straightforward to construct analogous black hole solutions , and , in particular , to look for rotating solutions @xcite .
n. straumann and z. h. zhou , phys .
b237 ( 1990 ) 353 ; b243 ( 1990 ) 33 ; +
m. s. volkov and d. v. galtsov , phys .
b341 ( 1995 ) 279 ; + g. lavrelashvili , and d. maison , phys .
b343 ( 1995 ) 214 ; + m. s. volkov , o. brodbeck , g. lavrelashvili and n. straumann , phys . lett .
b349 ( 1995 ) 438 .
b. kleihaus and j. kunz , phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 3704 ; + b. kleihaus , j. kunz , and f. navarro - lrida , phys
* d66 * ( 2002 ) 104001 ; phys .
* 90 * ( 2003 ) 171101 ; phys . rev . *
d69 * ( 2004 ) 064028 ; phys . lett .
* b599 * ( 2004 ) 294 . | we construct new regular solutions in einstein - yang - mills theory .
they are static , axially symmetric and asymptotically flat .
they are characterized by a pair of integers @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is related to the polar angle and @xmath2 to the azimuthal angle .
the known spherically and axially symmetric eym solutions have @xmath3 .
for @xmath4 new solutions arise , which form two branches .
they exist above a minimal value of @xmath2 , that increases with @xmath1 .
the solutions on the lower mass branch are related to certain solutions of einstein - yang - mills - higgs theory , where the nodes of the higgs field form rings . |
finite dimensional integrable systems have been a rarity for a very long time ; up to few decades ago , they could be easily enumerated : harmonic oscillators , the kepler system , a few spinning tops .
apart from harmonic oscillators which give linear equations and are the prototype of integrability these are integrated by exploiting their symmetries and the associated integrals of motion to reduce the problem to a lower dimensional one ; thus , we have _ symmetry reduction_. the situation changed radically in the seventies , when entire classes of new integrable systems appeared , integrable by the lax pair construction @xcite . among these a prominent role also due to priority is taken by the calogero system @xcite . in this case
, one has an arbitrary number @xmath2 of points on the line , interacting via a certain pair potential ; thus the system is described by a natural hamiltonian @xmath3 .
calogero showed that there is an invertible map from @xmath4 to @xmath5 , mapping the vector @xmath6 to a matrix @xmath7 , such that the evolution of @xmath8 results in an evolution of @xmath9 $ ] governed by lax equations ; thus one integrates @xmath10 and obtains @xmath11 .
as pointed out by kazhdan , kostant and sternberg @xcite , this also initiated a new way of integrating systems ( which they studied geometrically ) : indeed , rather than trying to reduce the dimension of the system , calogero passed to consider a system of _ higher dimension_. in this note we want to show that this approach is fruitful also beyond the realm of integrable hamiltonian systems .
the key observation made by kazhdan , kostant and sternberg @xcite , see also @xcite , in the context of hamiltonian systems is that given a differential equation @xmath12 in dimension @xmath13 , in some cases it may be helpful to increase its dimension : this is in particular the case when it is possible to describe @xmath12 as originating from either the symmetry reduction or the projection to an @xmath13-dimensional manifold of a simpler ( e.g. linear ) equations @xmath14 in dimension @xmath15 .
it was remarked in @xcite that this approach does apply also to non - hamiltonian systems , and in particular to systems in poincar - dulac normal form @xcite ( a remark to this effect was already contained in @xcite ) .
essentially , a system in normal form with only a finite number of resonances can always be mapped to a linear system , and is equivalent to the latter on a certain invariant manifold . as observed there ,
such a procedure is geometrically interesting , but equivalent to a classical technique already known to dulac @xcite , and abscribed by him to horn and lyapounov . in more general terms
, i.e. outside the scope of normal forms theory , this corresponds to the situation of a finite dimensional centralizer for a certain algebra associated to the vector field @xcite . in the present note ,
we show how `` dimension increasing '' nicely combines with a `` splitting '' ( in a sense to be described below ) approach @xcite in the case of an infinite number of resonances ; this case can not be tackled by the horn lyapounov
dulac approach .
roughly speaking , the procedure presented in this note combines the two approaches mentioned above , i.e. describing a nonlinear system as projection of a linear one and symmetry reduction in the sense described in @xcite .
a more abstract ( and general ) treatment is given elsewhere @xcite ; in the present note we adopt an approach and notation aimed at applications , and discuss a number of concrete applications .
we focus on systems in normal form ( sect.2 ) and in particular on the embedding and splitting of systems with infinitely many resonances ( sect.3 ) .
some simple examples are discussed in sect.4 , while sect.5 is devoted to ( in general non - hamiltonian ) nonlinearly perturbed oscillators , and sect.6 to bifurcation problems .
we consider an ode in @xmath16 with a fixed point in the origin and expanded around this in a power series ; we write this in the form @xmath17 where @xmath18 is polynomial with @xmath19 , and we have singled out the linear part @xmath20 . we also write @xmath21 for the nonlinear part of @xmath22 , i.e. @xmath23 . as well known , the matrix @xmath24 can be uniquely decomposed into its semisimple and nilpotent parts , which commute with each other and hence with @xmath24 : @xmath25 = 0 .\ ] ] in the following , we will use the following vector fields ( @xmath26 ) : @xmath27 let us denote by @xmath28 the eigenvalues of @xmath24 ; take a basis @xmath29 in @xmath16 consisting of generalized eigenvectors of @xmath24 , i.e. eigenvectors of @xmath30 : @xmath31 .
we will use @xmath6 coordinates in this basis , and the multiindex notation @xmath32 we say that the vector monomial @xmath33 is _ resonant _ with @xmath24 if @xmath34 the relation @xmath35 is said to be a _ resonance relation _ related to the eigenvalue @xmath36 , and the integer @xmath37 is said to be the _ order _ of the resonance . in our context it is useful to include order one resonances in the definition ( albeit the _ trivial _ order one resonances given by @xmath38 are of little interest ) . note that here one could as well consider @xmath30 rather than @xmath24 .
the space of vectors resonant with ( the semisimple part of ) @xmath24 is defined as the linear span of the vectors @xmath39 defined above .
we say ( see e.g. @xcite ) that ( 1 ) is in poincar - dulac normal form if its nonlinear part @xmath40 is resonant with @xmath24 .
this implies that @xmath41 \
= \ 0 \ . \eqno(3)\ ] ] it should be mentioned that the presence of a nilpotent part @xmath42 in @xmath24 introduces some subtleties . if ( 3 ) holds , then both @xmath43 and @xmath44 commute with @xmath45 , and therefore @xmath46 \
= \ 0 \ , \eqno(4)\ ] ] i.e. the system has a symmetry described by a semisimple matrix .
as well known , starting from any dynamical system ( or vector field ) of the form ( 1 ) , we can arrive at a dynamical system ( or vector field ) in poincar - dulac normal form by means of a sequence ( in general , infinite ) of near - identity transformations obtained by means of the poincar algorithm ; these combine into a near - identity transformation @xmath47 defined by a series which is in general only formal .
* remark 1 .
* we may reformulate the definition of systems in normal form by saying that @xmath22 is is normal form if and only if @xmath44 is in the centralizer of @xmath45 .
@xmath48 * remark 2 . *
if the system is required to have some symmetry , say @xmath49 = 0 $ ] with ( in an obvious notation ) @xmath50 , then @xmath51 = 0 $ ] as well , i.e. @xmath44 is in the centralizers of both @xmath45 and @xmath52 .
more generally , if @xmath53 is an element of some lie algebra @xmath54 , then under suitable conditions , see @xcite , it can be put in joint normal form , i.e. ( again with obvious notations ) @xmath55 = 0 $ ] .
@xmath48 let us consider again the resonance equation ( 2 ) .
it is clear that if there are non - negative integers @xmath56 ( some of them nonzero ) such that @xmath57 then we always have infinitely many resonances .
the monomial @xmath58 will be called a _
resonant scalar monomial_. it is an invariant of @xmath45 , and any multiindex @xmath59 with @xmath60 provides a resonance relation @xmath61 related to the eigenvalue @xmath36 ; in other words , any monomial @xmath62 is resonant , and so is any vector @xmath63 .
therefore , we say that ( 5 ) identifies a _
invariance relation_. the presence of invariance relations is the only way to have infinitely many resonances in a finite dimensional system ( see @xcite ) .
any nontrivial resonance ( 2 ) such that there is no @xmath64 with @xmath65 ( for all @xmath66 ) providing an invariance relation , is said to be a _
sporadic resonance_. sporadic resonances are always in finite number ( if any ) in a finite dimensional system @xcite .
any invariance relation ( 5 ) such that there is no @xmath67 with @xmath68 ( and of course @xmath69 ) providing another invariance relation , is said to be an _ elementary invariance relation_. every invariance relation is a linear combination ( with nonnegative integer coefficients ) of elementary ones .
elementary invariance relations are always in finite number ( if any ) in a finite dimensional system @xcite .
in this section we will discuss how the procedure described in @xcite generalizes , in connection with a `` splitting '' of the system described by @xmath70 @xcite , in the presence of invariance relations .
we should preliminarily identify all sporadic resonances @xmath71 and elementary invariance relations @xmath72 .
we associate resonant monomials @xmath73 and resonant vectors @xmath39 to the former ones , and invariant monomials @xmath74 to the latter ones .
we then introduce two set of new coordinates : these will be the coordinates @xmath75 in correspondence with sporadic resonances ( as in @xcite ) , and other new coordinates @xmath76 in correspondence with elementary invariance relations .
we should also assign evolution equations for the @xmath77 and @xmath78 coordinates ; these will be given in agreement with ( 1 ) itself .
that is , the equations for the @xmath77 will be @xmath79 and as for the @xmath78 s we assign @xmath80 we will thus consider the enlarged space @xmath81 , and in this the vector field @xmath82 note that some ambiguity is present here , in that we can write the coefficients of this vector field in different ways as a function of the @xmath83 . indeed , the vector field @xmath70 is uniquely defined only on the manifold identified by @xmath84 , @xmath85 .
* lemma 1 . * _ the @xmath86-dimensional manifold @xmath87 identified by @xmath88 is invariant under the flow of @xmath70 . _
* obvious by construction .
@xmath89 * lemma 2 . * _ the functions @xmath90 defined in ( 7 ) can be written in terms of the @xmath78 variables alone , i.e. @xmath91 . _ * proof . *
every analytic invariant of @xmath45 can be represented as a convergent series in the @xmath90 ( see @xcite ) ; their evolution is also invariant under the @xmath45 action , hence can also be written in terms of invariants , hence of the @xmath90 themselves . @xmath89 * corollary 1 . * _ the evolution of the @xmath78 variables is described by a ( nonlinear ) equation in the @xmath78 variables only .
_ * proof .
* this is merely a restatement of lemma 2 above .
note that the equations for @xmath6 and @xmath77 depend on @xmath78 and are therefore nonautonomous .
@xmath89 * proposition 3 . * _ the analytic functions @xmath92 and @xmath93 defined above can be written as linear in the @xmath6 and @xmath77 variables , the coefficients being functions of the @xmath78 variables . _ * proof . * recall each @xmath94 is a monomial @xmath95 with @xmath96 for some @xmath97 ; with reference to this integer @xmath98 , we add a label to @xmath99 , i.e. write @xmath100 . by construction and by the results above
, each @xmath101 can be written in the form @xmath102 , with analytic @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
so the assertion for the @xmath101 is obvious .
the time derivative of @xmath100 under the flow of ( 1 ) will be @xmath105 .
therefore it is sufficient to show that @xmath106 is zero or a multiple of @xmath107 or of some @xmath108 with a suitable resonant scalar monomial as a factor .
but the above operation just means to replace one factor @xmath107 by @xmath109 , and the resulting linear combination of the eigenvalues still yields a resonance relation ( 2 ) with @xmath110 on the right hand side .
see @xcite for a different approach to the proof . @xmath89 * corollary 2 . * _ the evolution of the @xmath6 and @xmath77 variables is described by nonautonomous linear equations , obtained by inserting the solution @xmath111 of the equations for @xmath78 in the general equations @xmath112 , @xmath113 . _ * proof . *
* remark 3 .
* we will also say that the vector field @xmath70 is quasi - linear , meaning by this that it is linear in the @xmath6 and @xmath77 variables . in this way we recover as a special case the situation discussed in @xcite as well as the terminology used there . @xmath48 * remark 4 .
* the results obtained here extend and unify those given in @xcite ; see also @xcite . as the @xmath78 identify group orbits for the group @xmath114 generated by the lie algebra ,
we interpret @xmath115 as an equation in orbit space , and the equation for @xmath116 as an equation on the lie group @xmath114 .
methods for the solution of the latter are discussed in @xcite , see also @xcite . @xmath48 * remark 5 . * if no invariance relations are present , hence no @xmath78 variables are introduced , then the system describing the time evolution of the @xmath117 variables is linear ; this is the situation studied in @xcite .
note that in this case we have exactly the interpretation of normal forms as projection of a linear system to an invariant manifold , without symmetry reduction .
@xmath48 * remark 6 .
* if there are no sporadic resonances of order greater than one then proposition 3 yields a linear system for the @xmath92 , with functions of the @xmath78 variables as coefficients .
therefore , upon solving the reduced equation for the @xmath78 variables one obtains a non - autonomous linear system . moreover , if all eigenvalues are distinct then we have a product system of one - dimensional equations . @xmath48 * remark 7 .
* finally , we note that if @xmath118 converges to some @xmath119 ( this is always the case if the @xmath78 space is one - dimensional and @xmath120 does not escape to infinity ) , the asymptotic evolution of the system is governed by a linear autonomous equation for @xmath6 and @xmath77 ( see @xcite for the behavior of asymptotically autonomous equations ) .
similarly , if there is a periodic solution @xmath121 with @xmath122 , the asymptotic evolution of the system is governed by a linear equation with periodic coefficients for @xmath6 and @xmath77 . @xmath48
* example 1 . * ( see @xcite ) . for @xmath123 , @xmath124 ,
the only resonant vector is @xmath125 , corresponding to a sporadic resonance , and there is no invariance relation .
systems in normal form correspond to @xmath126 with @xmath127 a real constant . according to our procedure
, we define @xmath128 , and obtain @xmath129 the invariant manifold @xmath130 is given by @xmath131 . the solution to the system in @xmath132 for initial data
@xmath133 is @xmath134 , @xmath135 , @xmath136 ; for initial data on @xmath130 , i.e. @xmath137 , the solution remains on @xmath130 and its projection to @xmath138 is @xmath139 , @xmath140 e^{kt } $ ] .
* example 2 . *
consider the matrix @xmath141 with eigenvalues @xmath142 .
there is one elementary invariance relation , @xmath143 , and no sporadic resonance .
the linear centralizer is spanned by @xmath24 itself and by matrices @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
the ring of invariants is generated by @xmath146 .
systems in normal forms are written as @xmath147 where @xmath148 are arbitrary power series .
following our procedure , we introduce one further variable @xmath149 ; for this we have @xmath150 .
hence the system in @xmath151 is written as @xmath152 * example 3 . *
consider the matrix @xmath153 ( @xmath124 , @xmath154 ) with eigenvalues @xmath155 .
there is one sporadic resonance , @xmath156 , and one elementary invariance relation , @xmath143 .
the linear centralizer is spanned the matrices @xmath157 , @xmath158 , @xmath159 together with @xmath160 systems in normal forms are written as @xmath161 where @xmath146 and @xmath162 are arbitrary power series . following our procedure we introduce @xmath149 , for which @xmath150 , and @xmath163 for which @xmath164 .
hence the system in @xmath165 is written as @xmath166
* example 4 .
perturbation of oscillators in 1:1 resonance . * consider the matrix @xmath167 which we also write in block form as @xmath168 with eigenvalues @xmath169 .
there are no sporadic resonances of order greater than one , and four elementary invariance relations : @xmath170 all other resonances can be described in terms of these .
we stress that the equations describing these invariance relations are linearly dependent ; however they should be considered , according to our definition , as different elementary ones .
corresponding to this , the associated invariant quantities will not be functionally independent ( obviously , we can not have more than three independent invariants for a flow in @xmath171 ) .
the linear centralizer of @xmath24 is an eight - dimensional algebra , spanned by the following matrices ( in two by two block notation ) : @xmath172 note here we have chosen a basis with @xmath173 , @xmath174 .
the linear system @xmath175 describes two oscillators in 1:1 resonance ; the normal form will correspond to a perturbation of these , generically breaking the exchange symmetry among the two oscillators .
systems in normal form are compactly written as @xmath176 where @xmath177 are arbitrary power series in the elementary invariants @xmath178 note that @xmath179 , with @xmath180 the scalar product .
we abbreviate the above evolution equation as @xmath181 the evolution equations for the @xmath78 , as required by our procedure , are simply ( only the selfadjoint matrices defined in ( 9 ) appear ) @xmath182 * example 5 .
perturbation of oscillators in @xmath183 resonance . *
consider the matrix @xmath184 ( with @xmath124 , @xmath154 ) with eigenvalues @xmath185 .
this is put in diagonal form passing to variables @xmath186 which we use in intermediate computations below .
we also write @xmath187 , @xmath188 , with @xmath189 there are four sporadic resonances : @xmath190 moreover , there are four elementary invariance relations : @xmath191 all other resonances can be described in terms of these .
systems in normal forms are written as @xmath192 where @xmath193 are arbitrary power series in the invariants of the linear flow .
following our procedure , we introduce variables @xmath194 related to sporadic resonances .
we also introduce variables related to elementary invariance relations , given by @xmath195 we must then introduce evolution equations for the @xmath77 and @xmath78 variables according to our procedure , i.e. according to ( 6 ) and ( 7 ) above . as for the @xmath77 , we get @xmath196 w_3 + [ ( k-1 ) \vth_2 \phi_1^{k-2 } \phi_2 + \vth_3 \phi_1^{k-1 } ] \xi_1 \\ \.w_4 = [ \a_4 + ( k-1 ) \a_2 ] w_4 + [ ( k-1 ) \vth_1 \phi_1^{k-2 }
\phi_2 + \vth_4 \phi_1^{k-1 } ] \xi_2 \ . \end{array}\ ] ] let us now consider the equations for the @xmath78 ; we easily get @xmath197 summarizing , all systems of the form ( 10 )
i.e. in normal form with respect to the linear part @xmath175 are written as the autonomous system ( 11 ) for the @xmath78 variables , plus a linear nonautonomous system , which introducing the notation @xmath198 can be written as @xmath199 where @xmath200 is a matrix which we write as @xmath201 , where @xmath202 and @xmath203 is an off - diagonal sparse matrix with nonzero terms @xmath204 \ , \
l_{82 } = [ ( k-1 ) \vth_1 \phi_1^{k-2 } \phi_2 + \vth_4 \phi_1^{k-1 } ] \ . \end{array}\ ] ]
* example 6 .
perturbation of two oscillators with no resonance . *
consider the matrix @xmath205 with eigenvalues @xmath206 .
now there are no sporadic resonances of order greater than one , and two elementary invariance relations : @xmath207 note that now we have only two invariants , @xmath208 and @xmath209 : this is easily understood as we have irrational flow on the two - torus @xmath210 .
the centralizer of @xmath24 corresponds to matrices @xmath211 thus systems in normal form will be written as @xmath212 with @xmath213 being power series in @xmath214 .
following our procedure we introduce variables @xmath215 and @xmath216 , whose evolution is given by @xmath217 * example 7 .
perturbation of oscillators in 1:1:1 resonance .
* consider the six - dimensional matrix written in block form as @xmath218 passing to coordinates @xmath219 , this reads @xmath220 the eigenvalues are @xmath221 , hence there is no sporadic resonance of order greater than one resonance ( with integers @xmath222 ) . ] and nine invariance relations : @xmath223 the invariants corresponding to these are of course @xmath224 going back to the original coordinates , expressions for these are recovered from ( no sum on repeated indices ) @xmath225 and is thus more convenient to pass to a different basis for invariant functions , i.e. @xmath226 the centralizer @xmath227 of @xmath24 in @xmath228 is an algebra spanned by eighteen matrices ; these are written in @xmath229 block form as @xmath230 where the @xmath231 are two - dimensional matrices written as ( @xmath232 and @xmath233 real constants ) @xmath234 it is easy to extract from these a basis made of nine selfadjoint matrices @xmath235 and nine antiselfadjoint ones @xmath236 . with @xmath237 , and @xmath180 the standard scalar product in @xmath238 these can be chosen so that @xmath239 . in this compact notation
the @xmath240 resonant three - dimensional oscillator is described by @xmath241 .
we write the normal form of evolution equations for perturbation of this as @xmath242 with @xmath243 an arbitrary matrix in @xmath244 .
* example 8 .
hopf bifurcation . *
consider the matrix @xmath245 with eigenvalues @xmath246 , @xmath247 .
there is no sporadic resonance , and one elementary invariance relation , @xmath143 , with associated invariant @xmath248 .
the most general system in normal form is therefore @xmath249 , @xmath250 .
according to our procedure , the evolution equation for the new coordinate @xmath78 will be @xmath251 .
as the linear part of the system is given by @xmath24 , we must require @xmath252 , @xmath253 . in applications ,
one is interested in the case where the system does also depend on an external ( `` control '' ) parameter @xmath59 , which usually does not evolve in time , the linear part being given by @xmath24 at the critical value . in this case the normal form and the @xmath78 evolution equation read @xmath254 in the standard model of hopf bifurcation , @xmath255 , and we write @xmath256 with @xmath257 .
this corresponds to the normal form @xmath258 which in our approach reads @xmath259 note that the space of invariants is one - dimensional ( with the additional constraint @xmath260 ) ; thus , either @xmath118 is unbounded for @xmath261 , or it approaches one of the zeroes of the function @xmath262 , say @xmath119 . in this case
, the system reduces asymptotically to a linear one : @xmath263 the standard analysis of hopf bifurcation is readily recovered in this way .
note that we can also look at hopf bifurcation in a slightly different way , i.e. include the @xmath59 variable from the beginning . in this case
the matrix @xmath24 is given by @xmath264 with eigenvalues @xmath265 and invariance relations @xmath266 and @xmath267 ; the associated invariants are @xmath78 and @xmath59 .
the linear centralizer of @xmath24 is spanned by matrices @xmath268 and correspondingly the normal form will be @xmath269 the equation for @xmath78 is just the one given above , and we are led to the same system ; interpreting @xmath59 as an external control parameter forces @xmath270 ( if not , there is a feedback of the system on the control parameter ) .
* example 9 .
hamiltonian hopf bifurcation .
* consider the matrix @xmath271 with eigenvalues @xmath272 , @xmath273 , @xmath274 , @xmath275 .
we assume @xmath276 ( so it could be rescaled to @xmath277 ) and @xmath278 ; the case @xmath279 corresponds to example 4 . in applications ,
one considers the case where @xmath59 is an external control parameter and studies the changes as this is varied ; @xmath279 is a critical value .
the matrix @xmath24 is diagonalized , for all @xmath59 , passing to variables @xmath280 as in example 5 above . the evolution @xmath281 preserves the symplectic structure @xmath282 .
it is easy to check , for generic @xmath59 , that there is no sporadic resonance and that there are two elementary invariance relations , given by @xmath283 and @xmath284 .
the corresponding invariants will be @xmath285 , @xmath286 ; they are complex conjugate , and correspond to real invariants @xmath287 and @xmath288 .
these are also written for later reference as @xmath289 , with @xmath290 obvious four - dimensional symmetric matrices .
the linear centralizer of @xmath24 ( for @xmath291 ) is given by matrices written in block form , with @xmath292 and @xmath293 real constants , as @xmath294 correspondingly , systems in normal form will be given by @xmath295 where now @xmath296 will be functions of the invariants @xmath297 .
note that such systems in general do not preserve the symplectic form @xmath298 , unless @xmath299 and @xmath300 .
the evolution of the @xmath78 is given by @xmath301 .
it is convenient to write the system in terms of the two - dimensional vectors @xmath302 , @xmath303 and @xmath304 .
moreover , we single out the linear part in the functions @xmath292 and @xmath293 , writing @xmath305 , @xmath306 with @xmath307 ; the smooth functions are @xmath308 , @xmath309 are arbitrary apart from this constraint , and can also depend on the parameters @xmath59 and @xmath310 .
the system is hence described in our approach by the following equations : @xmath311 \ , \eta_1 \ , \\
{ \dot \eta}_2 = & ( - \mu i + \om j ) \ , \eta_2 \
+ \ [ a_2 ( \phi ) \cdot i \ , - \ , b_2 ( \phi ) \cdot j ] \ , \eta_2 \ , \\ { \dot \phi } = & \ [ \ ( a_1 ( \phi ) + a_2 ( \phi ) \ ) \cdot i \ , + \ , \
( b_2 ( \phi ) - b_1 ( \phi ) \ ) \cdot j \ ] \
\phi \ . \end{array}\ ] ] if @xmath312 are such that the system is hamiltonian , the @xmath78 are always strictly invariant , and we are reduced to a linear system on each level set of @xmath78 ; if the @xmath313 are such that the system is not hamiltonian but the ( two - dimensional ) equation for the @xmath78 satisfies the condition for the existence of a limit cycle , as is often the case in bifurcation problems , then remark 7 applies .
let us look more closely to the perturbation of the case @xmath279 ; as recalled above , the analysis of this case can be recovered from example 4 .
more precisely , we can rescale time so that @xmath277 , and allow the arbitrary functions appearing in the analysis of example 4 to also depend on the parameter @xmath59 .
alternatively , we can proceed as at the end of the previous example , and include the @xmath59 variable from the beginning . with a @xmath314 block notation
, we have now @xmath315 with linear centralizer @xmath316 in the normal form , going back to the original time parametrization , we have @xmath317 \ , \eta_1 \ , \\ { \dot \eta}_2 = & ( - \mu i + \om j ) \ , \eta_2 \ + \ [ \a_2 ( \phi,\mu ) \cdot i \ , - \ , \b_2 ( \phi,\mu ) \cdot j ] \ , \eta_2 \ , \\ { \dot \phi } = & \ [ \ ( \a_1 ( \phi,\mu ) + \a_2 ( \phi,\mu ) \ ) \cdot i \ , + \ , \
( \b_2 ( \phi,\mu ) - \b_1 ( \phi,\mu ) \ ) \cdot j \ ] \
\phi \ , \\ { \dot \mu } = & \gamma ( \phi,\mu ) \ . \end{array}\ ] ] again , interpreting @xmath59 as an external control parameter requires @xmath270 .
this work was started by discussions during a visit by sw in the department of mathematics of universit di milano , and while gg was a guest at the dfg - graduiertenkolleg `` hierarchie und symmetrie in mathematischen modellen '' at rwth aachen .
we would like to thank these institutions for support to our work .
gg also acknowledges partial support by fondazione cariplo and by gnfm - indam .
f. calogero , `` solution of the one - dimensional n - body problems with quadratic and/or inversely quadratic pair potentials '' , _ j. math
* 12 * ( 1971 ) , 419 - 436 ; `` exactly solvable one - dimensional many - body problems '' , _ lett .
_ * 13 * ( 1975 ) , 411 - 416 j.f .
cariena , j. grabowski and g. marmo , `` lie - scheffers systems : a geometric approach '' , bibliopolis , napoli 2000 ; j.f .
cariena and a. ramos , `` a new geometric approach to lie systems and physical applications '' , _ acta appl .
_ * 70 * ( 2002 ) , 43 - 69 a.i .
neishtadt , `` on calculation of stability loss delay time for dynamical bifurcations '' , in : _ xith international congress of mathematical physics _ , d. iagolnitzer ed . , international press , cambridge ( ma - usa ) 1995 j. wei and e. norman , `` lie algebraic solution of linear differential equations '' , _ j. math
. phys . _ * 4 * ( 1963 ) , 575 - 581 ; `` on global representations of the solutions of linear differential equations as a product of exponentials '' , _ proc . a.m.s . _ * 15 * ( 1964 ) , 327 - 334 p. yanguas , `` lowering the dimension of polynomial vector fields in @xmath319 and @xmath320 '' , _ chaos _ * 11 * ( 2001 ) , 306 - 318 ; j. palacian , `` invariant manifolds of an autonomous ordinary differential equation from its generalized normal forms '' , _ chaos _ * 13 * ( 2003 ) , 1188 - 1204 | integration of nonlinear dynamical systems is usually seen as associated to a symmetry reduction , e.g. via momentum map . in lax integrable systems , as pointed out by kazhdan , kostant and sternberg in discussing the calogero system , one proceeds in the opposite way , enlarging the nonlinear system to a system of greater dimension . we discuss how this approach is also fruitful in studying non integrable systems , focusing on systems in normal form . @xmath0 ) @xmath1 ] .#1#1
^#1#1 # 1#1 |
this research was supported by the division of nuclear physics , doe , under contract no .
de - ac05 - 96or21400 managed by lockheed martin energy research corp .
es acknowledges support from the doe under grant de - fg02 - 96er40944 and doe contract de - ac05 - 84er40150 under which the southeastern universities research association operates the thomas jefferson national accelerator facility .
tb acknowledges additional support from the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft dfg under contract bo 56/153 - 1 . the authors would also like to thank d. b. blaschke , c. m. ko , g. rpke and s. sorensen for useful discussions .
t. barnes and e. s. swanson , phys . rev .
d46 , 131 ( 1992 ) ; a more general set of interactions and meson - meson t - matrices is given in t. barnes , n. black , d. j. dean and e. s. swanson , phys .
c60 , 045202 ( 1999 ) . | we evaluate the cross sections for the dissociation of @xmath0 and @xmath1 by @xmath2 and @xmath3 at low collision energies , using the quark - interchange model of barnes and swanson . the dissociation cross section for @xmath0 by @xmath2
is found to be relatively small with a maximum of about 1 mb and a kinetic energy threshold of 0.65 gev .
the pion - induced @xmath1 dissociation cross section is found to be much larger , with a maximum of about 5 mb and a lower threshold .
dissociation cross sections for @xmath0 and @xmath1 by @xmath3 mesons are also evaluated and are found to be large near threshold .
the suggestion by matsui and satz @xcite that @xmath0 production might be suppressed in a quark - gluon plasma has led to many experimental and theoretical studies of @xmath0 production in high - energy heavy - ion collisions .
the experimental observation by na50 @xcite of anomalous @xmath0 suppression in pb+pb collisions in particular has been studied by many authors @xcite .
the evolution of a @xmath0 or @xmath1 produced in a heavy - ion collision depends sensitively on charmonium dissociation cross sections , which arise from processes such as low - energy inelastic scattering of the @xmath4 state on @xmath2 or @xmath3 into open - charm final states .
small @xmath0 dissociation cross sections by @xmath2 or @xmath3 may favor an interpretation of the pb+pb data in terms of the production of a new phase of matter , possibly the quark - gluon plasma .
in contrast , a large @xmath3+@xmath0 dissociation cross section might imply that @xmath3+@xmath0 inelastic scattering may be an important part of the pb+pb anomaly because the density of @xmath3 mesons increases approximately quadratically as the density of pions increases . in view of the importance of these dissociation cross sections for the interpretation of heavy - ion collisions ,
they should be evaluated and incorporated in monte carlo simulations before any final conclusions are reached regarding the underlying physics .
the dissociation of @xmath0 by light mesons has been considered previously by several groups @xcite .
unfortunately , the numerical cross sections quoted in these references span a considerable range , due largely to different assumptions regarding the dominant scattering mechanism .
kharzeev , satz , and collaborators @xcite used the parton model and perturbative qcd `` short - distance '' approach of of bhanot and peskin @xcite , and found remarkably small low - energy cross sections for @xmath0 on light hadrons .
for example , their @xmath0+@xmath5 cross section at @xmath6 gev is only about @xmath7 @xcite .
a finite - mass correction increases this cross section by about a factor of two @xcite .
however , in high - energy heavy - ion reactions , the collisions between the produced @xmath2 and @xmath3 with @xmath0 and @xmath1 occur at low energies ( of the order of a few hundred mev to about 1 gev relative kinetic energies ) .
the applicability of the parton model and pqcd for reactions at this low energy region is open to question .
matinyan and mller @xcite , haglin@xcite , and lin@xcite recently reported results for these dissociation cross sections in meson exchange models .
they use effective meson lagrangians and assume @xmath8-channel @xmath9 and @xmath10 meson exchange , which leads to numerical results for @xmath2+@xmath0 and @xmath3+@xmath0 dissociation cross sections .
matinyan and mller found that these cross sections are rather small ; both are @xmath11-@xmath12 mb at @xmath13 gev . including form factors ( arbitrarily chosen to be gaussian with a width set to 1.5 gev )
would reduce the cross section by an order of magnitude .
haglin obtained a very different result , with much larger cross sections , by treating the @xmath10 and @xmath14 mesons as non - abelian gauge bosons in a minimally - coupled yang - mills meson lagrangian .
form factors were introduced in later calculations and the mb - scale cross sections are sensitive to the choices of the form factors @xcite .
of course the use of a yang - mills lagrangian for charmed mesons has no _ a priori _ justification , so the crucial initial assumption made in these references would require independent confirmation . in any case , the assumption of @xmath8-channel exchange of a heavy meson such as a @xmath9 or @xmath10 between @xmath2 and @xmath0 with point - like couplings is difficult to justify because the range of these exchanges ( @xmath15 fm ) is much smaller than the physical sizes of the initial @xmath2 and @xmath0 mesons .
charmonium dissociation processes can presumably be described in terms of the fundamental quark and gluon interactions , but are of greatest phenomenological interest at energy scales in the resonance region .
for this reason , we advocate the use of the known quark - gluon forces to specify the underlying scattering amplitude , which must then be convolved with explicit nonrelativistic quark model hadron wavefunctions for the initial and final mesons .
martins , blaschke , and quack @xcite previously reported dissociation cross section calculations using essentially the approach we describe .
the short - distance interaction used by these authors in particular is quite similar to the form we employ . for the confining interaction ,
however , they used a simplified color - independent gaussian potential between quark - antiquark pairs only , rather than the now well - established linear @xmath16 form .
they found a rather large @xmath2+@xmath0 dissociation cross section which reached a maximum of about 7 mb at the kinetic energy in the center - of - mass system @xmath17 of about 0.85 gev .
although our approach is very similar to that of martins _ et al . _
, our final numerical results differ significantly , due mainly to the modeling of the confining interaction .
in this paper we use the approach discussed above to evaluate the dissociation cross sections of @xmath0 by @xmath2 and @xmath3 , and compare our results to other theoretical cross sections reported in the literature @xcite .
we also calculate cross sections for the dissociation of @xmath1 by @xmath2 and @xmath3 , which have not been evaluated elsewhere .
we employ the barnes - swanson quark - interchange model @xcite to determine these dissociation amplitudes .
this approach uses the nonrelativistic quark potential model and its interquark hamiltonian to describe hadron - hadron interactions and therefore implicitly incorporates the successes of the quark model in describing the hadron spectrum and many static properties of hadrons .
the model parameters are fixed by fits to the meson spectrum , so there is little additional freedom in determining scattering amplitudes and cross sections .
one proceeds by calculating the scattering amplitude for a given process at born order in the interquark hamiltonian . in the case of meson - meson scattering ,
this scattering amplitude is given by the sum of the four quark line diagrams shown in fig .
1 .
these are evaluated as overlap integrals of quark model wavefunctions , using the feynman rules " given in app .
c of ref.@xcite .
this method has previously been applied successfully to the closely related no - annihilation scattering channels @xmath18 @xmath19 @xcite , @xmath20 @xmath21 @xcite , @xmath22 s - wave @xmath23 scattering @xcite and the short - range repulsive nn interaction @xcite .
following ref.@xcite , the interaction between each pair of constituents @xmath24 and @xmath25 is taken to be @xmath26 this hamiltonian is derived in the coulomb gauge , which is the most convenient gauge for bound states and low - energy phenomena .
the model parameter @xmath27 is the strong coupling constant , @xmath28 is the string tension , @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the interacting quark or antiquark masses , and @xmath31 is a range parameter in the gaussian - smeared spin - spin hyperfine interaction .
a constant shift @xmath32 is also included in the interaction . for antiquarks the generator @xmath33 is replaced by @xmath34 . *
fig .
1*. born - order quark line diagrams .
+ for example , a specific channel is @xmath35 , @xmath36 , + @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
4truemm the model parameters we employed were @xmath39 , @xmath40 gev@xmath41 , @xmath42 gev , @xmath43 gev , @xmath44 gev and @xmath45 gev .
this set of parameters gives masses within 0.08 gev of experiment for the @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath0 , and @xmath1 mesons and also provides a very good description of the @xmath18 s - wave @xmath19 phase shift .
an alternative set of parameters , found by fitting a large set of experimental masses , is @xmath48 , @xmath49 gev@xmath41 , @xmath42 gev , @xmath50 gev and @xmath51 gev .
this second set , with a flavor - dependent @xmath32 , was used to test the sensitivity of our results to parameter variations . before proceeding to our results , we note that the well - known post - prior ambiguity " arises in calculations of bound state scattering amplitudes involving rearrangement collisions @xcite . since the hamiltonian which describes the scattering process @xmath52 can be separated into free and interaction parts in two ways , @xmath53 or @xmath54 , there is an ambiguity in the choice of @xmath55 or @xmath56 as the interaction hamiltonian .
the first version is known as the
prior " form and leads to the scattering diagrams of fig . 1 ,
in which the interactions occur before quark interchange .
the second choice is the post " form , which leads to diagrams in which the interactions occur after quark interchange .
one may show that the post and prior expressions for the scattering amplitude are equal , provided that exact eigenfunctions of the free hamiltonians are used for the asymptotic states @xcite .
( the relevance of this to time reversal invariance is demonstrated numerically in ref.@xcite . ) in our calculations we employ numerically determined hamiltonian eigenfunctions for each of the external meson states considered ; in the nonrelativistic case this would suffice to eliminate the post - prior discrepancy . in the processes considered here
we have used relativistic kinematics and phase space , but use galilean boosts for the states , as appropriate for a nonrelativistic quark model calculation . in consequence
we find that the post and prior scattering amplitudes differ slightly .
( we note in passing that one could carry out a relativised version of this calculation , although the full relativistic boosts would induce small additional effects due to wigner rotations and creation of quarks and gluons . ) in this paper we use the mean of the post and prior results as our theoretical cross section , and the estimated errors due to the post - prior discrepancy and parameter variations are indicated by bands in the figures .
the cross sections we obtain for the dissociation of @xmath0 and @xmath1 by @xmath2 are shown in fig . 2 as a function of the kinetic energy in the center of mass system , @xmath57 , where @xmath58 and @xmath59 are the rest masses of the colliding particles in the initial channel .
the lowest - lying allowed final states are @xmath60 , @xmath61 , and @xmath62 , and the total dissociation cross section is taken to be the sum of these three channel cross sections ; this is shown as a solid line in the figure .
( the reactions @xmath2+@xmath63 and @xmath2+@xmath64 are @xmath65 transitions allowed in qcd but have zero transition matrix elements in our hamiltonian ( 1 )
. these transition amplitudes would be nonzero for example if we included spin - orbit terms in ( 1 ) .
the relatively weak process @xmath2+@xmath66 has been considered in a dyson - schwinger formalism by blaschke @xmath67 @xcite , who find a maximum cross section of about 0.1 mb near threshold .
note that the s - wave to s - wave transition is absolutely forbidden , so although @xmath2+@xmath68 is actually exothermic , it does not lead to a divergent cross section at threshold . )
the @xmath2+@xmath0 dissociation process is endothermic and requires an initial kinetic energy of 0.65 gev .
the cross section shows a rapid rise above threshold ( as expected for an s - wave process ) and has a broad maximum of about 1 mb not far above threshold ( fig .
2@xmath69 ) .
this is somewhat smaller than the @xmath70 mb estimated by martins @xmath67 , which we discuss below .
fig .
2 . cross sections for pion - induced dissociation of @xmath0 ( fig .
2@xmath69 ) and @xmath1 ( fig .
2@xmath28 ) .
the solid curves give the total dissociation cross section . estimated systematic errors due to parameter uncertainties and the post - prior discrepancy
are shown as bands .
the cross section for dissociation of the @xmath1 by @xmath2 is rather larger in part because this reaction is only weakly endothermic ; the initial @xmath2+@xmath1 kinetic energy in @xmath2+@xmath71 and @xmath72 is only about 0.05 gev at threshold .
the total cross section reaches a maximum of about 6.2(0.8 ) mb at the kinetic energy of about 0.1 gev and has a secondary maximum of 4.6(1.8 ) mb at the kinetic energy of about @xmath73 gev due to the opening of the @xmath74 channel .
notice that the ratio of the peak values of the @xmath2+@xmath1 and @xmath2+@xmath0 cross sections is roughly 6 ; this should be contrasted with the prediction of @xmath75 given in ref .
[ 17 ] .
the minimum in the cross section near the kinetic energy of 0.4 gev is due to the complete destructive interference between transfer ( t1 and t2 ) and capture ( c1 and c2 ) diagrams .
we next calculate the @xmath3+@xmath0 and @xmath3+@xmath1 dissociation cross sections .
the allowed low - lying final states are @xmath76 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) , and @xmath80 ( @xmath81 ) .
these cross sections are shown in fig .
3 .
since the reaction @xmath82 is exothermic , this cross section diverges as @xmath83 near threshold . for other channels
the thresholds occur at higher energies , so those subprocesses are endothermic .
the total dissociation cross section is shown as a solid line in fig .
3 .
it is numerically about 11(3 ) mb at a kinetic energy of 0.1 gev , decreasing to 6(2 ) mb at a kinetic energy of 0.2 gev . *
fig .
3*. total and individual channel cross sections @xmath0 dissociation by @xmath3 .
4truemm in the case of @xmath3+@xmath1 dissociation , all the channels we consider are exothermic , so the low - energy divergence is quite pronounced .
our numerical results for these cross sections are shown in fig .
4 .
the total cross section decreases from 15(2 ) mb to 6(2 ) mb as the kinetic energy increases from 0.1 to 0.2 gev . *
fig .
4*. total and individual channel cross sections for @xmath1 dissociation by @xmath3 .
4truemm we previously noted that our @xmath2+@xmath0 cross section is considerably smaller than the estimate of ref.@xcite , although we use a similar approach .
there are several differences between the two approaches which lead to this discrepancy .
martins _
et al .
_ assumed that the confining interaction is an attractive gaussian potential which acts only between quark - antiquark pairs .
the neglect of the quark - quark and antiquark - antiquark confining interaction amounts to discarding the transfer diagrams ( t1 and t2 ) for the confining potential .
since we find that the transfer and capture diagram confinement contributions are similar in magnitude but opposite in sign ( due to color factors ) , martins _
et al .
_ did not include an important destructive interference .
their use of a gaussian rather than a linear potential will obviously lead to quantitatively different cross sections .
furthermore , the cross section values are quite sensitive to the parameters used when t1 and t2 are not included .
all these factors contribute to the differences between our results and those of martin @xmath67 for @xmath2+@xmath0 collisions . the destructive interference between transfer and capture diagrams with spin - independent forces ( color coulomb and confinement ) has been noted previously ( see , for example , refs.@xcite and references cited in @xcite ) .
this interference explains the well - known spin - spin hyperfine dominance in light hadron scattering in channels such as @xmath18 @xmath19 and @xmath84 . in the presence of heavy quarks , however ,
most hyperfine interaction diagrams are suppressed by the large charm quark mass ; this is the reason we included the color coulomb and confining interactions in the present analysis .
it is interesting in retrospect to examine the different channels and determine which of the various interactions dominates the amplitude .
we find that the hyperfine interaction still dominates the @xmath2+@xmath0 dissociation amplitude , whereas the linear confining interaction dominates @xmath2+@xmath1 , @xmath3+@xmath85 , and ( for the kinetic energy less than 0.3 gev ) @xmath3+@xmath1 . above @xmath12 gev , the color coulomb interaction dominates @xmath3+@xmath1 scattering .
( we caution the reader that this decomposition depends on the choice of the post or prior form for the t - matrix ; the results we quote are for the prior form , involving the diagrams of fig . 1 . )
there is no direct experimental measurement of these cross sections to which we can compare our results .
we found a small @xmath2+@xmath0 cross section which starts at a high threshold and a large @xmath2+@xmath1 cross section which starts at a low threshold .
if these cross sections are folded with a distribution of pions with an average kinetic energy of about 200 mev , we would obtain @xmath86 , which is consistent with earlier observation in a model of @xmath0 and @xmath1 suppression in o+a , and s+u collisions @xcite .
hopefully , future monte carlo simulations of the dynamics of charmonium in heavy - ion collisions will lead to a more direct comparison .
the large @xmath3+@xmath0 and @xmath3+@xmath1 cross sections we have found imply that both the @xmath0 and @xmath1 will be quickly dissociated if there is a significant @xmath3 meson population in the medium . since our results on the divergence of @xmath3+@xmath0 and @xmath3+@xmath1 dissociation
cross sections at threshold follow directly from simple kinematics , these results must be qualitatively correct . the normalization of these cross sections , however , required detailed calculation and should also be compared to experiment if possible . since dissociations of @xmath0 by @xmath2 and
@xmath3 populate different states ( for example @xmath2+@xmath0 doe not lead to @xmath76 but @xmath3+@xmath0 does ) , it may be possible to separate these processes and their associated cross sections by studying the relative production of @xmath87 , @xmath88+@xmath89 and @xmath74 if the expected open charm background can be subtracted .
in the future it may be useful to carry out detailed simulations of @xmath0 absorption in heavy - ion collisions using the cross sections obtained here to test the accuracy of our results . if our cross sections do prove to be reasonably accurate , it will clearly be useful to incorporate them in simulations of @xmath0 suppression in pb+pb collisions and in other processes that use charmonium as a signature of the quark - gluon plasma in order to subtract the effects of @xmath0 suppression due to its interaction with hadron matter . |
we solve two algorithmic problems about pseudo - anosov elements in the mapping class group of punctured surfaces with at least one fixed puncture .
[ th:1.1 ] let @xmath0 be a surface with @xmath1 marked points @xmath2 and @xmath3 $ ] a pseudo - anosov mapping class fixing @xmath4 and @xmath5 setwise .
+ there exists a finite algorithm to decide whether @xmath3 $ ] is a power and in this case the root is computed .
+ there exists a finite algorithm to decide whether @xmath3 $ ] commutes with a finite order element fixing @xmath4 and which computes it if it exists .
the combinatorial tools that are developed for these questions give also , as a by product , a new solution to the conjugacy problem among pseudo - anosov elements .
+ the restriction to the class that fixes a marked point is certainly not optimal but it makes the description of the solution and the arguments much simpler .
the conjugacy problem for pseudo - anosov elements in the mapping class group is known from hemion @xcite , another solution was given later by mosher @xcite .
a general solution for the mapping class group , ie including reducible elements , has been given in keil s thesis @xcite .
the solution proposed here is easily computable .
theorem [ th:1.1 ] is based on a structure theorem ( theorem [ th:5.1 ] ) that describes a canonical subset of the set of _ efficient representatives _ of @xmath3 $ ] as developed by bestvina and handel @xcite for surface automorphisms and based on the free group train track representatives the same authors introduced in @xcite , with some previous weak versions by franks and misiurewicz @xcite and los @xcite .
the structure theorem [ th:5.1 ] describes a canonical set associated to @xmath3 $ ] called _ single cut ( sc ) representatives _ of @xmath3 $ ] as a union of `` cycles '' .
this set is a complete conjugacy invariant .
most of the paper is about defining , characterising and computing these cycles .
the structure of these cycles is closely related with the local property of the pseudo - anosov homeomorphism @xmath6 around the fixed marked point @xmath4 .
questions about roots of pseudo - anosov homeomorphisms have attracted some attention lately , see for instance gonzales - meneses @xcite in the case of the punctured discs and bonatti and paris @xcite for more general surfaces .
this paper is a rewriting , with complements , of a part of the first author s thesis @xcite , defended in 1998 and advised by the second author .
the second author would like to thank luis paris and bert wiest who motivated him to start the rewriting .
we consider a pseudo - anosov homeomorphism @xmath6 on a compact surface @xmath0 with @xmath7 marked points @xmath8 among which @xmath4 is fixed . in this section we review definitions and properties of _ efficient representatives _ for @xmath3 $ ] the isotopy class of @xmath6 on @xmath9 . for a more detailed presentation and examples ,
the reader is referred to bestvina and handel @xcite , and for an implementation of the algorithm to brinkmann @xcite .
we start with some preliminary and general definitions .
a _ topological representative _ of @xmath3 $ ] is a triple @xmath10 where : + - @xmath11 is a graph without valence one vertices , + - @xmath12 is an embedding that induces an homotopy equivalence , + - @xmath13 is a combinatorial map that represents @xmath6 .
let us make this definition more explicit .
in all the paper graphs will be considered from several point of views .
combinatorially a finite graph is given by a collection of vertices and oriented edges , that are denoted respectively @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
the reverse of the edge @xmath16 is denoted @xmath17 .
graphs will also be considered as topological or metric spaces depending on the context . + a pair @xmath18
is called an _ embedded graph _ , it contains the following data : + ( a ) the embedding implies the existence of a cyclic ordering for the edges that are incident at a vertex @xmath19 , ie the star @xmath20 .
+ ( b ) the fundamental groups @xmath21 and @xmath22 are isomorphic .
+ ( c ) a regular neighbourhood @xmath23 $ ] is homeomorphic to the surface : @xmath24 , where the @xmath25 are small disjoint discs centred at the marked points .
+ the map @xmath13 is an endomorphism that satisfies : + - @xmath26 , + - for every edge @xmath27 is an edge path in @xmath11 , it is represented by a word in the alphabet @xmath28 .
+ the action of @xmath29 on @xmath11 is homotopic , through @xmath30 , to the action of @xmath6 on @xmath31 , ie : + @xmath32 to any topological representative @xmath33 is associated an _ incidence matrix _
@xmath34 whose entries are labelled by the edge set @xmath15 . the entry in place
@xmath35 is the number of occurrences of the letters @xmath36 or @xmath37 in the word @xmath38 .
this matrix depends only on the pair @xmath39 . _
remark : _ a given isotopy class @xmath3 $ ] admits many topological representatives . for instance take a base point @xmath40 on @xmath31 and choose a set of generators for @xmath41
this set is topologically represented by a bouquet of circles embedded in @xmath31 , it defines a pair @xmath18 .
now consider any induced map @xmath42 on this set of generators , this is a map @xmath29 such that @xmath10 is a topological representative of @xmath6 .
the definitions are given in the general case ( @xmath43 ) and will be specified in the particular case @xmath44 .
these two situations are quite different at the group automorphism point of view .
indeed the induced map @xmath45 is an automorphism of the free group @xmath46 that is reducible when @xmath47 and irreducible if @xmath48 , following the terminology of bestvina and handel @xcite .
+ two edges @xmath35 of @xmath11 that are incident at a vertex @xmath49 and adjacent , according to the cyclic ordering ( property ( a ) above ) , is a _
turn_. a turn is _ illegal _ if there is an integer @xmath50 such that @xmath51 and @xmath52 have a non trivial initial common edge path , where initial is understood with the orientation so that @xmath49 is the initial vertex .
the smallest such @xmath53 is called the _ order _ of the illegal turn .
turns are also cyclically ordered and a maximal set of consecutive illegal turns is a _
gate_. a triple @xmath33 is an _ efficient representative _ of @xmath3 $ ] if the following conditions ( g1)(g5 ) are satisfied .
( g1 ) @xmath33 is a topological representative of @xmath3 $ ] .
+ ( g2 ) for every edge @xmath16 and every integer @xmath54 the edge path @xmath55 does not backtrack .
+ this means that all the words @xmath55 are reduced , ie no occurrences of subwords @xmath56 . since @xmath57 is homotopy equivalent to @xmath31 , each distinguished point @xmath58
is contained in a disc bounded by a loop in @xmath57 .
each such loop is represented by a closed edge path @xmath59 in @xmath11 .
the edges that belongs to the @xmath60 are called _
peripheral_. the union of the peripheral edges is a subgraph @xmath61 of @xmath11 .
the _ pre - peripheral _ edges are the edges of @xmath11 that are eventually mapped to a path included in @xmath61 by @xmath29 .
we denote @xmath62 the union of these pre - peripheral edges and by @xmath63 the complementary graph : @xmath64 .
( g3 ) the loops @xmath65 are permuted under @xmath29 and @xmath66 is a simplicial homeomorphism ( the image of each edge in @xmath61 is a single edge in @xmath61 ) .
if condition ( g3 ) is satisfied then an illegal turn can not consists of two peripheral or pre - peripheral edges .
in addition the incidence matrix has the following form : @xmath67 where the block @xmath68 corresponds to the peripheral edges and is a permutation matrix .
the block @xmath69 corresponds to the pre - peripheral edges , it is a nilpotent matrix .
the block @xmath70 corresponds to the edges of @xmath63 .
( g4 ) the matrix @xmath70 is irreducible .
+ ( g5 ) if the turn @xmath35 is illegal of order one then the first letter of @xmath71 ( and @xmath38 ) is an edge of @xmath63 . _
remark : _ if @xmath72 ie @xmath31 has only one marked point then the set of peripheral and pre - peripheral edges is empty , thus conditions ( g3 ) and ( g5 ) are vacuous and the incidence matrix is @xmath70 . two efficient representatives @xmath73 and @xmath74 are _ equivalent _ if there exists a simplicial homeomorphism @xmath75 and a homeomorphism @xmath76 , isotopic to the identity so that : + ( eq1 ) @xmath77 and , + ( eq2 ) @xmath78
. + the homeomorphism @xmath69 induces a relabelling of the edges and ( eq1 ) states that after this relabelling the two maps are identical .
the second condition requires that the relabelling respects the cyclic ordering , and that after the relabelling the two embeddings are isotopic on the surface . in the previous notion of equivalence
if @xmath79 is not required to be isotopic to the identity , we obtain a notion of equivalence for the pairs @xmath80 and @xmath81 that is called _
combinatorial equivalence_. the mapping class group @xmath82 acts on the set of efficient representatives as follows : + if @xmath73 is an efficient representative of @xmath3 $ ] and @xmath83\in mod(s_x)$ ] then we denote @xmath84 , it is an efficient representative of @xmath85 $ ] .
the goal of this section is to construct a flat surface together with a pair of measured foliations from the combinatorial data contained in an efficient representative @xmath73 of @xmath3 $ ] .
this construction provides all the geometric invariants of the pseudo - anosov class @xmath3 $ ] : dilatation factor , stable and unstable invariant measured foliations .
the very first metric properties comes from the incidence matrix @xmath86 . from property ( g4 ) and perron - frobenius theorem
, @xmath34 has a unique real maximal eigenvalue @xmath87 , together with an eigenvector @xmath88 and another eigenvector @xmath89 for the transpose matrix @xmath90 .
these vectors are unique up to scale , @xmath89 has positive entries , the entries of @xmath88 are nonnegative and the entries of @xmath88 labelled by @xmath63 are positive .
+ fix @xmath88 and @xmath89 in their projective classes .
the edge @xmath16 of @xmath11 has an orientation , say from a vertex @xmath91 to @xmath92 .
we associate to @xmath16 a pair of non negative numbers @xmath93 and a bifoliated rectangle @xmath94 of length @xmath95 and width @xmath96 .
the orientation of @xmath16 induces an orientation of @xmath94 , with two opposite sides @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
note that some rectangles are degenerate , ie have positive width and zero length .
the corresponding edges are called _
infinitesimal_. the graph @xmath99 is embedded in @xmath31 and , around each vertex @xmath100 , there is a cyclic ordering of the edges @xmath101 incident at @xmath100 , this set of edges of @xmath11 is the star @xmath20 . a small disc neighbourhood @xmath102 of @xmath100 is considered as a planar chart .
the rectangles @xmath103 are disjointly embedded into @xmath31 under @xmath104 so that @xmath105 are cyclically ordered as the @xmath101 for @xmath106 .
+ the next goal is to find an identification of the sides @xmath107 in the chart @xmath102 .
but some metric informations are missing : which proportion of the side @xmath108 has to be identified with the adjacent sides ? this is the goal of the next paragraph .
the idea is to construct a williams - thurston train tracks representative out of an efficient representative ( see for instance harer and penner @xcite for details about train tracks ) .
what is missing is the so called `` switch condition '' at each vertex and this forces us to change the graph structure as well as the map in order to impose a `` 2-sides '' condition .
this is achieved by _ blowing up _
each vertex of the graph @xmath11 , keeping track of the gate structure given by the map @xmath29 .
the details can be found in bestvina and handel @xcite , we review here the constructions and the results .
+ ( 1 ) replace each vertex @xmath100 by a small disc @xmath109 in each chart @xmath102 .
+ ( 2 ) along the boundary @xmath110 identify all the points @xmath111 when the corresponding edges @xmath112 belong to the same gate ( given by @xmath29 ) . if @xmath113 is the number of distinct gates at @xmath49 we obtain @xmath113 points @xmath114 along @xmath110 that are cyclically ordered as the gates of @xmath33 at @xmath49 .
+ ( 3 ) two points @xmath115 are connected by an edge @xmath116 within @xmath109 if there is an edge @xmath117 and an iterate @xmath55 that crosses a turn @xmath118 where @xmath119 belongs to the gate @xmath120 and @xmath121 to the gate @xmath122 . these ( local ) operations define a new graph @xmath123 , an embedding @xmath124 and a new map @xmath125 that are well defined .
let us express what are the conclusions when @xmath73 is an efficient representative of a pseudo - anosov homeomorphism .
\(i ) the graph @xmath123 is connected .
+ ( ii ) the subgraphs @xmath126 are either @xmath113-gones , or @xmath113-gone minus one side .
+ ( iii ) the map @xmath125 is well defined , it permutes the @xmath127 edges and each vertex of @xmath128 has exactly two sides : the @xmath127-edges inside @xmath109 and one gate outside @xmath109 .
+ ( iv ) the incidence matrix for @xmath129 is defined exactly as for any topological representative and has the following form : @xmath130 where the block @xmath131 corresponds to the @xmath127-edges and is thus a permutation matrix by ( iii ) .
exactly as for the matrix @xmath86 , this new matrix @xmath132 has the same largest eigenvalue @xmath87 and two corresponding eigenvectors @xmath133 .
+ ( v ) the graph @xmath123 together with the weight function @xmath134 is a _ measured train track _ , ie it satisfies at each vertex a _ switch condition _ :
each vertex has two sides by ( iii ) and the sum of the weights on one side equals the sum of the weights on the other side . by ( iv ) the newly introduced edges @xmath127 are infinitesimal : @xmath135 , which imply that the length structure has not changed between @xmath11 and @xmath128 .
the width structure @xmath136 is exactly the information that was missing in the preliminary naive construction : it gives the exact position of the singularities inside the discs @xmath102 , with respect to the transverse measure given by @xmath134 .
[ fig:1 ] the construction is now essentially the classical `` highway construction '' of thurston , see harer and penner @xcite , obtained by gluing rectangles with specific width satisfying switch conditions .
the difference is that our rectangles have both width and length .
for the rectangles with non zero length the identification is just the obvious one .
for the rectangles of length zero , coming from the infinitesimal edges , the identification is done in two steps .
first we fix for these ( infinitesimal ) rectangles an arbitrary small length @xmath137 and we construct a surface @xmath138}_{\delta}$ ] together with a pair of measured foliations
. then we let @xmath137 goes to zero and we obtain a surface @xmath138}$ ] with a pair of measured foliations ( see figures 1 , 2 , 3 ) .
[ fig:2 ] the surface @xmath138}$ ] has @xmath139 marked points , one boundary component and is homeomorphic to @xmath140 .
the map @xmath13 ( or @xmath125 ) induces a map @xmath141 } \rightarrow \mathcal{r}^{[{\cal e}]}$ ] that is a homeomorphism in the neighbourhood of any interior point .
[ fig:3 ] by the gluing construction , each illegal turn @xmath142 of @xmath143 ( or of @xmath144 ) gives rise to a cusp @xmath145 of @xmath138}$ ] because of the condition ( g5 ) and part ( 2 ) of the train track construction .
the map @xmath141 } \rightarrow \mathcal{r}^{[{\cal e}]}$ ] maps the boundary curve to itself , up to homotopy , is uniformly expanding along this curve and thus has periodic points on the boundary @xmath146}$ ] with the following features : + - the periodic points alternate along @xmath146}$ ] , with the cusps @xmath145 .
+ - the path between two consecutive periodic points , passing through a cusp is a periodic _ nielsen path _ , see jiang @xcite .
+ the surface @xmath147}$ ] has a flat metric given by the length and width structure of the constitutive rectangles . similarly
the graph @xmath11 together with the vector @xmath88 is a metric graph .
furthermore the rectangle partition of @xmath147}$ ] is , by construction , a _ markov partition _ for the map @xmath148 ( see for instance fathi _
@xcite ) from which a symbolic dynamics is well defined ( see for instance alseda _ et al . _ @xcite , shub @xcite ) .
this symbolic dynamics , together with the metric structure on @xmath147}$ ] ( or on @xmath11 ) enables to give the exact metric location of the periodic points on @xmath146}$ ] and thus of the nielsen paths between them .
let @xmath149 be an illegal turn of @xmath143 and @xmath145 the corresponding cusp on @xmath146}$ ] .
from the previous discussion there are 2 periodic points @xmath150 on @xmath146}$ ] adjacent to @xmath145 .
let @xmath151 $ ] and @xmath152 $ ] be the paths from @xmath145 to @xmath153 ( resp .
@xmath154 ) along @xmath146}$ ] .
these paths have the same length : @xmath155 .
the path @xmath156 is the nielsen path between @xmath153 and @xmath154 passing through @xmath145 , and @xmath157}$ ] ( see figure 4 ) .
[ fig:4 ] if we identify isometrically @xmath158 with @xmath159 for each illegal turn @xmath160 , then all the periodic points along @xmath146}$ ] are identified to a single point that we identify with @xmath4 , the quotient surface is identified with @xmath0 , ie there is a map @xmath161 } \rightarrow s $ ] . the pair of measured foliations on @xmath147}$ ] induces a pair @xmath162 on @xmath0 and the identified arcs give rise to segments of length @xmath155 along unstable leaves starting from the marked point @xmath4 .
there is thus a mapping from the set of illegal turns of the efficient representative @xmath163 to a subset of the unstable leaves issued from the marked point @xmath4 ( the separatrices ) .
the map @xmath148 passes to the quotient @xmath164 and the quotient map @xmath6 is a homeomorphism .
the resulting homeomorphism is thus the pseudo - anosov homeomorphism @xmath6 : it fixes @xmath4 , leaves invariant the pair of measured foliations @xmath162 with dilatation factor @xmath87 .
the previous construction has been given from a specific efficient representative @xmath165 that is a combinatorial object .
it allows to reconstruct @xmath166 and its pair of invariant measured foliations @xmath162 , recall that the dilatation factor @xmath167 has been computed during the process as the largest eigenvalue of the matrix @xmath86 .
it also gives an injective map from the set of illegal turns to a subset of the unstable separatrices at the fixed marked point @xmath4 .
the possible missing separatrices are obtained as follows . in the construction of the train track @xmath168 , the set of infinitesimal edges @xmath127 in a disc @xmath102
can only have two shapes : a @xmath79-gone or a @xmath79-gone minus one side , by ( ii ) of paragraph 2.2.2 .
in the first case the corresponding singularity is interior to @xmath147}$ ] . in the second case
, a turn between two infinitesimal edges is called an _ infinitesimal turn _ , it is crossed by a boundary loop @xmath59 , @xmath169 .
if the infinitesimal turn is crossed by a loop @xmath59 then it defines a separatrix at the marked point @xmath58 .
in particular those infinitesimal turns that are crossed by @xmath170 define separatrices at @xmath4 ( see figure 3 ) .
we just described a one - to - one correspondence between the unstable separatrices at @xmath4 and some turns of @xmath129 that are well defined from the efficient representative @xmath171 .
let @xmath171 be an efficient representative of a pseudo - anosov element @xmath3 $ ] and @xmath172 the associated train track map .
there is a well defined bijective map @xmath173 , where @xmath174 is the set of unstable separatrices at the fixed marked point @xmath4 and @xmath175 is the union of the illegal turns and the infinitesimal turns that are crossed by @xmath170 in @xmath172 .
there is another well defined map @xmath176 given by @xmath177 if @xmath178 is an illegal turn and @xmath179 otherwise , where @xmath180 is the nielsen path between two consecutive boundary periodic points associated with the illegal turn @xmath160 .
the goal of this section is to prove a converse of the previous lemma , ie starting from the geometric invariants of the pseudo - anosov homeomorphism @xmath6 together with a length vector as above and satisfying some additional properties , we construct an efficient representative of @xmath3 $ ] .
the construction is similar to the one in fathi _
@xcite used to prove the existence of a markov partition for pseudo - anosov homeomorphisms .
in addition it proves the existence of efficient representatives without appealing to the train track algorithm .
first we fix once and for all the invariant measured foliations in their respective projective classes , in other words the measures @xmath182 and @xmath183 are fixed . recall that the pseudo - anosov @xmath6 fixes the marked point @xmath4 and induces a permutation @xmath184 of the unstable separatrix indexes at @xmath4 .
let @xmath185 be a non zero vector in @xmath186 , called a _ cut length _ vector .
the unstable separatrices @xmath187 are cyclically indexed and we consider the initial segment @xmath188_{u_i}$ ] along @xmath189 of @xmath182-measure @xmath190 for @xmath191 , called a _ cut line _ along @xmath189 .
we denote by @xmath192 the union of the cut lines .
there is a one - to - one correspondence between the cut length vector @xmath193 and the cut lines @xmath194 . .
] [ fig:5 ] the surface @xmath0 together with @xmath195 and the cut lines @xmath192 defines two types of special points : + - the _ true singularities _ are the singularities of the foliations @xmath196 and @xmath197
. + - the _ artificial singularities _ are the end points of the cut lines ( with non zero cut length ) .
+ consider the following set of segments : @xmath198 ( resp .
@xmath199 ) , that are the union of the stable separatrices starting from all the singularities ( resp .
true singularities ) up to the first intersection with @xmath192 .
this set is a finite union of compact segments by minimality of @xmath196 , see fathi _ et al .
_ @xcite .
a cut length vector @xmath200 is _ admissible _ ( for the pseudo anosov homeomorphism @xmath6 with dilatation factor @xmath167 ) if the following conditions are satisfied : + ( i ) there is one orbit @xmath201 of @xmath202 such that : @xmath203 if and only if @xmath204 . + there exists @xmath205 such that : + ( ii ) @xmath206 if @xmath207 .
+ ( iii ) @xmath208 . admissible cut length vectors exist .
let @xmath201 be one orbit of @xmath202 .
define @xmath209 such that @xmath210 if @xmath204 and @xmath211 otherwise ( of course this is non admissible ) .
the set of true singularities is non empty so at least one segment @xmath212_{u_{i_0}}$ ] contains a point @xmath213 .
define then @xmath214 if @xmath215 , @xmath216_{u_{i_0}})$ ] and @xmath217 for @xmath218 where @xmath219 is the order of @xmath202 .
the first two conditions are satisfied by construction .
next we observe that @xmath220 for all @xmath221 , hence @xmath222 , this implies that @xmath223 and therefore @xmath224 . the goal of this section is to prove the existence of a canonical subclass among efficient representatives of @xmath3 $ ] satisfying some additional properties .
this subclass is called the _ single cut representatives _ and the study of their properties is the main focus of this paper .
let @xmath225 be an admissible cut length vector and let @xmath226 , @xmath227 be the associated segments defined above .
_ claim : _ @xmath228 is a disjoint union of bifoliated rectangles . by definition ,
all the singularities of the foliations @xmath229 belongs to @xmath230 .
so each connected component of @xmath231 is bifoliated by restriction of @xmath229 and has no singularity in its interior .
therefore it is a rectangle @xmath232 .
the closure @xmath233 of each component @xmath232 has two sides that are segments in @xmath226 and two sides in @xmath227 .
each @xmath233 is embedded in @xmath0 .
@xmath181 + we define a graph @xmath11 and an embedding @xmath30 as follows
. there are 3 types of edges : + ( 1 ) one edge for each rectangle @xmath233 of @xmath231 , they are called _ h - edges_. + ( 2 ) one edge for each segment of @xmath234 issued from a distinguished point @xmath235 , they are called _ peripheral_. + ( 3 ) one edge for each pair of segments of @xmath234 issued from an artificial singularity that does not contain a true singularity and are eventually mapped under @xmath6 to a segment of @xmath234 issued from a distinguished point .
these edges are called _ preperipheral _ ( see figure 6 ) .
[ fig:6 ] we consider the segments of @xmath234 issued from the distinguished points @xmath235 in ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) as degenerate rectangles ( with zero length ) .
the edges just defined are identified at their extreme points if the corresponding rectangles share a common @xmath234 segment .
these identifications define the vertices of the graph denoted @xmath11 . each rectangle is embedded in @xmath0 and the identification of the extreme points respects the embedding , in other words
there is an embedding @xmath12 that is well defined up to isotopy .
in addition there is a retraction @xmath236 obtained by contracting each segment of the stable foliation inside each rectangle to a point on @xmath11 .
this retraction is a homotopy inverse of @xmath30 and thus @xmath18 is an embedded graph .
_ in the case with only one distinguished point , the previous construction is much simpler : no peripheral and preperipheral edges are necessary .
the segments of @xmath237 belong to one @xmath6-orbit of unstable separatrices at @xmath4 and @xmath234 is the union of all the segments of stable separatrices starting at the singularities .
this implies @xmath238 and @xmath239 .
thus the image under @xmath6 of each rectangle @xmath232 of @xmath240 is a rectangle in @xmath241 , starting at a @xmath234-component and ending at another @xmath234-component .
this is a markov partition property , see fathi _
let @xmath232 be such a rectangle and @xmath242 the corresponding edge in @xmath11 .
any maximal unstable segment @xmath243 in @xmath232 , is mapped to an unstable segment @xmath244 that crosses a finite collection of rectangles and @xmath234-components issued from the marked points .
this sequence of rectangles is independent of the choice made for the segment @xmath243 in @xmath232 . from the definition of @xmath11 ,
the sequence of rectangles and @xmath234-components that are crossed by @xmath244 defines an edge path @xmath245 in @xmath11 .
a special case is when @xmath244 start or end at a @xmath234-components @xmath246 issued from a marked point or at an artificial singularity giving rise to a peripheral or preperipheral edge in @xmath11 . in this case
we make the choice that the edge path @xmath245 does not start or end with the corresponding peripheral or preperipheral edge .
this ensures condition ( g5 ) .
this defines the image of the @xmath63-edges . a peripheral edge @xmath247 is associated to a stable segment @xmath246 issued from a distinguished point .
its image is the peripheral edge corresponding to the segment containing @xmath248 .
the image of a preperipheral edge associated to a stable segment @xmath249 is either the preperipheral or peripheral edge associated to @xmath250 .
all together this defines a map @xmath13 .
the triple @xmath251 constructed above is an efficient representative of @xmath3 $ ] .
it satisfies the following additional properties : + ( sc1 ) there is exactly one illegal turn of order one , between two @xmath63-edges at a vertex with more than two gates .
+ ( sc2 ) every vertex that is crossed by a loop @xmath252 around a distinguished point has exactly 3 gates .
+ an efficient representative satisfying these additional properties is called a _
sc - representative_.
if the leaf segment associated to the illegal turn of order one is @xmath253 we add : _ relative to @xmath253_. we already proved that @xmath18 is an embedded graph .
the map @xmath29 is continuous since connected components of @xmath234 are mapped to connected components of @xmath234 under @xmath6 so vertices are mapped to vertices under @xmath29 and continuity comes from the continuity of @xmath6 on the rectangles .
next we check that @xmath29 represents @xmath3 $ ] . to this end
we already defined a retraction @xmath254 by contracting the rectangles along the stable segments .
the definition of @xmath29 via the action of @xmath6 on the unstable segments in each rectangle implies that @xmath255 is homotopic to @xmath256 .
the retraction @xmath257 being an homotopy inverse of @xmath30 , we obtain that : @xmath258 .
let us now prove the other properties : + ( g1 ) the graph @xmath11 has no valency one vertices , because every rectangle is glued to rectangles at both of its @xmath234 sides .
the other properties of a topological representative were proved above .
+ ( g2 ) the peripheral and preperipheral edges are mapped by @xmath29 to peripheral or preperipheral edges , in particular words have combinatorial length one .
no cancellation can occur when iterating these edges .
the iterates @xmath55 of an @xmath63-edge is defined by iterating an unstable segment .
the corresponding edge path can not backtrack by invariance of the unstable foliation @xmath259 under @xmath260 .
+ ( g3 ) comes from the definition of peripheral edges .
+ ( g4 ) the matrix @xmath70 is irreducible .
indeed any sufficiently long unstable segment crosses every rectangle by minimality of @xmath259 and for each maximal unstable segment in any rectangle a large enough iterate under @xmath6 is as long as we wish and therefore crosses every rectangle .
+ ( g5 ) comes from our choice of the image of @xmath63-edges .
+ ( sc1 ) illegal turns only occurs between @xmath63-edges by construction .
two @xmath63-edges define an illegal turn when the corresponding rectangles are on both sides of a cut line along @xmath189 and are glued together by a corner .
this corner is thus the end point of a cut line @xmath261 . when the leaf satisfies
@xmath262 then the image under @xmath6 of the corner @xmath261 is exactly the corner @xmath263 .
the image under @xmath29 of the turn corresponding to @xmath261 is thus the turn corresponding to @xmath263 and this turn is of order greater than one .
there is only one leaf @xmath253 so that @xmath264 by the admissibility property .
the corresponding turn is illegal of order one .
the fact that the vertex at which this specific illegal turn arises has more than two gates comes from property ( iii ) of definition 3.1 .
+ ( sc2 ) comes from the definition of the peripheral edges and their images .
let @xmath225 be an admissible cut length vector and @xmath265 the sc - representative obtained by the above construction .
then @xmath266 , where @xmath267 is the map defined in lemma 2.2 .
the stable leaf segments from @xmath4 up to the first intersection with @xmath237 belong to @xmath234 .
these segments are permuted under @xmath6 in cycles of period @xmath219 ( the order of the permutation @xmath202 ) .
the definition of the map @xmath29 from @xmath6 implies that these segments are retracted to @xmath219 points on @xmath11 under the retraction @xmath257 , and are permuted in a cycle of period @xmath219 under @xmath29 . from the train track construction of paragraph 2.2.2 , these periodic points belong to the boundary component of the surface @xmath268 that is identified with @xmath237 .
therefore these points are exactly the boundary periodic points that are nielsen equivalent .
the length of the nielsen path , measured with @xmath269 , between two consecutive such points and crossing the illegal turn @xmath270 is by construction @xmath271 , where the index of the turn and the index of the corresponding unstable separatrix are identified .
it remains to check that the @xmath269 length coincides with the eigenvector length given by perron - frobenius s theorem .
let @xmath272 be a rectangle of the partition given by @xmath273 and let @xmath274 be its @xmath269 length which is well defined since all the maximal unstable segments in @xmath272 have the same @xmath269 length .
the image under @xmath6 of any maximal unstable segment in @xmath272 has @xmath269 length @xmath275 .
this length is also the sum of the @xmath269 length of the rectangles crossed by this unstable segment ( no back - tracks ) .
therefore the vector @xmath88 is an eigenvector of the incidence matrix @xmath86 for the eigenvalue @xmath167 .
the following is a converse of lemma 3.4 .
let @xmath265 be a sc - representative of @xmath3 $ ] .
then @xmath266 is an admissible cut length vector .
if @xmath270 is an illegal turn of order greater than one then it is mapped exactly to another turn @xmath276 .
the turn being illegal means that some of its iterate is degenerate , ie the beginning of the two edges are mapped to a non trivial common edge path . from paragraph 2.2.3 , for each illegal turn @xmath270 there is a pair of periodic points on the boundary of the surface @xmath268 that are nielsen equivalent for some iterate .
the corresponding periodic nielsen path has length @xmath277 .
if the turn is illegal of order greater than one then the image of @xmath278 is a nielsen path between the image periodic points , it crosses the illegal turn @xmath276 and has length @xmath279 . the construction of the surface @xmath268 and its pair of measured foliations associates to an illegal turn an unstable separatrix by the map @xmath280 of lemma 2.2 .
therefore if @xmath189 is associated to @xmath270 then @xmath281 is associated to the image turn @xmath276 and the above equality reads : @xmath282 for all illegal turns in its orbit except the one of order one for which : @xmath283 . since there is only one illegal turn of order one then only one such orbit exists and it is associated to a single orbit of unstable separatrices . the fact that the illegal turn @xmath284 of order one is located at a vertex with more than 3 gates implies , from the construction of the surface @xmath268 , that the cusp of the surface corresponding to @xmath284 is the extremity of a cut line and belongs to @xmath285 .
note that lemma 3.4 and proposition 3.5 imply the existence of a bijection between admissible cut lengths and sc - representatives .
in this paragraph we define an operation on the set of sc - representatives , using the bijection between sc - representatives and admissible cut length vectors that was proved in the previous section .
this operation is defined on cut lengths and in section 6 it will be translated in the combinatorial setting .
let us start with some preliminary observations .
let @xmath286 be a sc - representative with cut lengths @xmath225 .
the _ total length _ ( also called the volume in other contexts ) of @xmath286 is @xmath287 . for sc - representatives
this length is also given by @xmath288 .
+ * observation 1 : * if @xmath286 is a sc - representative relative to the separatrix @xmath253 then : + @xmath289 , where @xmath219 is the period of the separatrix @xmath253 ( the order of the permutation @xmath202 ) .
+ this obvious computation implies that sc - representatives relative to @xmath189 are parametrised by the length @xmath290 . + * observation 2 : * the image , under @xmath291 , of any artificial singularity belongs to @xmath285 .
+ this is just the observation that an artificial singularity of a sc - representative is the end point of a cut line with positive cut length , together with : @xmath292 and @xmath293 .
let @xmath286 be a sc - representative relative to @xmath253 of cut length @xmath225 and let @xmath294 be such that @xmath295 .
the _ sc - folding of length @xmath296 _ is given on cut lengths by the map @xmath297 , where : + @xmath298 and @xmath299 for @xmath300 and + @xmath301 if @xmath302 does not belongs the the @xmath202-orbit of @xmath303 .
if @xmath304 is obtained from an admissible cut length @xmath225 by a sc - folding of length @xmath305 then @xmath304 is admissible .
we will say that the corresponding sc - representative @xmath306 is obtained from @xmath286 by a sc - folding of length @xmath296 .
its total length is + @xmath307 . by definition of @xmath296 :
@xmath308 and , since @xmath309 for all @xmath221 , then @xmath310 , proving admissibility .
first we prove that sc - foldings do exist for each admissible cut length .
let @xmath286 be a sc - representative relative to the leaf @xmath253 of cut lengths @xmath311 .
there is a point of @xmath312 on the interior of the cut line @xmath313_{u_{i_0}}$ ] .
the set of singularities is non empty and the number of separatrices is larger than one , so there is at least a cut line @xmath221 so that : @xmath314_{u_{i } } \neq \emptyset$ ] .
if the index @xmath207 then the @xmath6-image of the cut line along @xmath189 is the cut line along @xmath315 , and @xmath293 , so @xmath315 also contains a point of @xmath285 .
iterating this argument shows that the cut line along @xmath253 contains a point of @xmath285 .
this lemma shows that a given sc - representative @xmath286 always admits a sc folding .
since the cut line is totally ordered there is a first point @xmath316 of @xmath285 along @xmath313_{u_{i_0}}$ ] starting from @xmath317 and we denote @xmath318_{u_{i_0 } } > 0 $ ] .
the sc - folding of length @xmath319 is called an _ elementary sc - folding_. by definition , @xmath319 is the smallest possible length for which a sc - folding can be applied to @xmath286 .
observe that @xmath319 is a @xmath269-length of a maximal unstable segment in @xmath320 therefore it is larger than the minimal edge length : @xmath321 , where the minimum is taken among edges of positive length , ie among @xmath63-edges .
let @xmath286 be a sc - representative relative to @xmath253 and @xmath319 the length of the elementary sc - folding at @xmath286 .
then no point of @xmath285 belong to the segments + @xmath322}$ ] for @xmath300 .
this follows from the proof of lemma 4.3 and the definition of @xmath319 .
we defined in 2.1.3 a natural action of the mapping class group on the set of efficient representatives of @xmath3 $ ] given by @xmath323 , for @xmath324 \in mod(s_x)$ ] .
@xmath325 is an efficient representative of @xmath326 $ ] .
when @xmath324 $ ] belongs to the centraliser of @xmath3 $ ] then @xmath325 is another efficient representative of @xmath3 $ ] , this is in particular the case when @xmath324 = [ f^k ] , k \in \mathbb{z}$ ] . by definition of the combinatorial equivalence in 2.1.3 this provides an infinite sequence of efficient representatives that are all combinatorially equivalent .
in the particular case of sc - representatives we have , by lemma 3.4 and proposition 3.5 , a bijection between sc - representatives and admissible cut lengths .
the @xmath327$]-action is described in term of cut lengths as follows : let @xmath265 be a sc - representative of @xmath3 $ ] , relative to the leaf @xmath253 of admissible cut length @xmath328 .
then for all @xmath329 , @xmath330 is admissible , with corresponding sc - representative @xmath331 , relative to @xmath332 .
the fact that @xmath330 is admissible is immediate by iterating @xmath3 $ ] on the surface .
the @xmath269-length of a rectangle @xmath333 is @xmath167 times the @xmath269-length of @xmath334 for all rectangles .
the boundary periodic points are the same and the length of the periodic nielsen paths have all been multiplied by @xmath167 . in this section
we prove the main technical result that sc - representatives of @xmath3 $ ] are organised in cycles whose structure will be studied in the next sections .
we consider sequences of elementary sc - foldings .
the first observation is that if @xmath335 is obtained from @xmath286 by a sequence of elementary sc - foldings then the total length is strictly decreasing : @xmath336 by proposition 4.2 .
the next lemma is necessary to prove that the total length converges to zero when an infinite sequence of elementary sc - foldings is applied .
let @xmath337 and @xmath338 be two sc - representatives relative to the same separatrix , say @xmath339 , and @xmath219 the order of the permutation @xmath202 .
assume that @xmath340 and let @xmath341 be the positive integer so that : @xmath342 . then the minimal edge length of @xmath338 ( of positive length ) is at least @xmath343 times the minimal edge length of @xmath344 ( of positive length ) .
we denote as above @xmath345 , @xmath346 and @xmath347 for @xmath348 the cut lines and the stable segments of the two sc - representatives .
_ case @xmath349 _ : first we claim that @xmath350 . + the cut lengths of @xmath351 are @xmath352 times those of @xmath344 and , by assumption : @xmath353 .
therefore the cut lengths of @xmath351 are smaller than those of @xmath338 .
this implies that @xmath354 and the @xmath291 images of the artificial singularities of @xmath355 belongs to @xmath356 by observation 2 , thus @xmath357 which completes the proof of the claim .
an edge @xmath16 of @xmath358 with positive length defines a rectangle in @xmath359 , its length is the @xmath269-length of a maximal unstable segment in the complement of @xmath360 .
the above claim implies that this unstable segment is longer than a maximal unstable segment in the complement of @xmath361 and thus : @xmath362 .
this completes the case @xmath349 .
_ case @xmath363 . _
the preceding argument is applied to the representatives @xmath364 and @xmath365 .
let @xmath366 be a sc - representative of @xmath3 $ ] and @xmath367 the sequence of sc - representatives obtained from @xmath286 by successive elementary sc - foldings .
the sequence @xmath368 is strictly decreasing and converges to zero .
the strict decreasing property is obvious from proposition 4.2 .
definition 4.4 and the observation that follows implies that the total length @xmath368 drops by at least the minimal edge length of @xmath369 .
let @xmath370 , lemma 4.7 implies that if @xmath371 then the sc - elementary folding applied to @xmath372 makes the total length decreases by at least @xmath373 and thus @xmath374 .
[ th:4.9 ] let @xmath366 be a sc - representative of @xmath3 $ ] and @xmath367 the sequence of sc - representatives obtained from @xmath286 by the successive sequence of elementary sc - foldings .
there exists a sc - representative @xmath375 in this sequence so that : @xmath376 and thus @xmath377 .
since the sequence @xmath378 is decreasing and converges to zero there is a @xmath379 so that @xmath380 .
we want to prove that @xmath381 .
if this is the case then @xmath382 and , by lemma 4.6 , @xmath377 .
let us assume by contradiction that the inequality is strict .
we denote by @xmath383 and @xmath384 . by assumption @xmath385 .
+ we assume also that @xmath386 is a sc - representative relative to the leaf @xmath339 , therefore all the sc - representatives in the sequence are relative to the same leaf , by definition of the elementary sc - folding .
we denote by @xmath387 the admissible cut lengths of @xmath388 . from observation 1 the cut length along the leaf
@xmath339 is @xmath389 for @xmath386 and @xmath390 for @xmath391 .
the definition of @xmath296 gives @xmath392 and therefore @xmath393 , for @xmath394 .
these are admissible cut lengths since @xmath395 is a sc - representative . by assumption @xmath294 and @xmath396 , where @xmath397 is the length of the elementary sc - folding at @xmath398 ,
this is a contradiction with proposition 4.5 .
specific properties of the set of sc - representatives are studied in this section .
[ th:5.1 ] let @xmath6 be a pseudo - anosov homeomorphism fixing @xmath4 , let @xmath399 be the set of unstable separatrices at @xmath4 that are permuted by @xmath6 and let @xmath202 be the induced permutation of order @xmath219 of @xmath400 .
+ ( 1 ) there exists a sc - representative @xmath401 relative to @xmath339 .
+ ( 2 ) the sequence of elementary sc - foldings @xmath402 defines a combinatorial cycle @xmath403 : there exists @xmath404 such that @xmath405 is combinatorially equivalent to @xmath406 if @xmath407 modulo @xmath408 $ ] .
+ ( 3 ) every sc - representative relative to @xmath339 is combinatorially equivalent to a sc - representative in the cycle @xmath403 . + ( 4 ) if the separatrix @xmath409 belongs to the @xmath202-orbit of @xmath339 then each sc - representative in the cycle @xmath410 is combinatorially equivalent to a sc - representative in the cycle @xmath403 .
items ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) are already proved .
+ ( 3 ) let @xmath411 denote the combinatorial cycle of theorem [ th:4.9 ] .
if @xmath286 is a sc - representative relative to @xmath339 then there is an integer @xmath341 so that @xmath412 .
the sequence @xmath413 represents the same combinatorial cycle .
the proof of theorem [ th:4.9 ] implies that @xmath286 belongs to this sequence .
+ ( 4 ) let @xmath414 be a sc - representative relative to @xmath339 and @xmath403 the cycle obtained from @xmath414 .
let @xmath415 be a sc - representative relative to @xmath409 with @xmath416 .
then by lemma 4.6 the sc - representative @xmath417 is a sc - representative relative to @xmath339 and the result comes from ( 3 ) .
theorem [ th:5.1 ] describes a very simple structure on the set of sc - representatives of @xmath3 $ ] up to combinatorial equivalence : it is a union of cycles , one for each orbit of separatrices .
the cycles in theorem [ th:5.1 ] are defined up to combinatorial equivalence . in this paragraph
we use the existence of a combinatorial equivalence to extract informations about the mapping class element .
recall , from lemma 2.2 , that the unstable separatrices with non zero cut length are in one - to - one correspondence with the illegal turns of any sc - representative so the illegal turns are indexed via the name of the corresponding separatrix .
[ transition map ] let @xmath418 ( resp .
@xmath419 ) be a sc - representative relative to the separatrix @xmath409 ( resp .
@xmath189 ) . if @xmath286 and @xmath335 are combinatorially equivalent under a map @xmath75 then this map is unique . moreover the map @xmath69 induces a unique homeomorphism @xmath420 that satisfies : + ( i ) @xmath421 . + ( ii ) @xmath79 leaves invariant the pair of foliations @xmath422 , it rescales @xmath423 by a factor @xmath424 and @xmath269 by a factor @xmath425 and it commutes with @xmath6 .
+ ( iii ) @xmath79 maps the separatrix @xmath409 to @xmath426 and induces locally a rotation of angle @xmath427 .
there are two integers @xmath428 and @xmath429 so that @xmath430 , where @xmath219 is the local order of @xmath6 at @xmath4 and @xmath431 the local order of @xmath79 at @xmath4 . +
the homeomorphism @xmath79 is called the transition map .
note that ( iii ) implies that if the integer @xmath428 is zero then the homeomorphism @xmath79 is a finite order ( a symmetry of @xmath6 ) and if @xmath432 then it is a root of a power of @xmath6 .
+ by definition , the combinatorial equivalence satisfies @xmath433 therefore it carries the unique illegal turn of order one of @xmath29 to the unique illegal turn of order one of @xmath434 .
the image of the other edges is thus uniquely defined since @xmath11 and @xmath435 are embedded graphs and @xmath69 respects the cyclic ordering at each vertex .
the map @xmath69 induces a homeomorphism @xmath436 } \rightarrow \mathcal{r}^{[\mathcal{e ' } ] } $ ] , by mapping each rectangle @xmath437 to the rectangle @xmath438 .
each rectangle is equipped with a length and width structure , ie a pair of measured foliations , therefore @xmath439 carries the pair of measured foliations of @xmath440}$ ] to the pair of measured foliations of @xmath441}$ ] .
the length of the rectangle @xmath94 is @xmath442 and the length of the rectangle @xmath438 is @xmath443 .
the map @xmath439 is chosen to be linear in each rectangle and it induces a rescaling of the unstable measured foliation by the factor @xmath444 .
we defined in paragraph 2.2.3 a quotient map @xmath445 } \rightarrow s$ ] by isometric identification of the boundary @xmath446}$ ] along the periodic nielsen paths connecting two consecutive boundary periodic points of the map @xmath447 } \rightarrow \mathcal{r}^{[\mathcal{e } ] } $ ] .
the homeomorphism @xmath439 is , by construction , a conjugacy between @xmath448 and @xmath449 , therefore the boundary periodic points of @xmath448 are mapped to boundary periodic points of @xmath449 and periodic nielsen paths are mapped to periodic nielsen paths .
the homeomorphism @xmath439 together with the maps @xmath445 } \rightarrow s$ ] and @xmath450 } \rightarrow s$ ] defines a homeomorphism @xmath451 , via the commutative diagram : @xmath452 } & \stackrel{\widetilde{c}}{\longrightarrow } & { \cal r}^{[\mathcal{e } ' ] } \\ { { } _ { \cal{in } } } { \downarrow } & & { \downarrow } { { } _ { \mathcal{in ' } } } \\ s & \stackrel{g}{\longrightarrow } & s \end{array}\ ] ] that satisfies : + ( 1 ) @xmath453 . + ( 2 ) @xmath421 .
+ ( 3 ) @xmath79 leaves invariant the two foliations @xmath454 and @xmath455 .
+ ( 4 ) @xmath79 is unique because of ( 3 ) , see fathi _ et al .
+ since both foliations are invariant under @xmath6 and @xmath79 then these two homeomorphisms commute , ie @xmath79 belongs to the centraliser of @xmath6 . in paragraph 4.1.2
we described the action of @xmath327 $ ] on the set of sc - representatives of @xmath3 $ ] .
the very same discussion applies to the action of the centraliser and we shall denote @xmath456 .
the surface @xmath0 together with the pair of measured foliations @xmath454 and @xmath455 is equipped with an area form defined by the product of the measures @xmath269 and @xmath423 . the homeomorphism @xmath79 preserves the total area and , since it rescales the measures @xmath423 by a factor @xmath424 so it rescales the measure @xmath269 by the factor @xmath425 .
this completes the proof of ( i ) and ( ii ) .
our indexing convention of the illegal turns of @xmath457 and @xmath458 by the index of the corresponding unstable separatrix of @xmath259 at @xmath4 implies that the cusp of @xmath459 } $ ] labelled @xmath302 is mapped under @xmath439 to the cusp labelled @xmath221 in @xmath460 } $ ] .
in addition @xmath164 maps the periodic nielsen path labelled @xmath302 to an initial segment of the separatrix @xmath409 and @xmath461 maps the periodic nielsen path labelled @xmath221 to an initial segment of the separatrix @xmath426 .
so condition ( 1 ) above implies that @xmath79 maps @xmath409 to @xmath426 .
in addition @xmath79 fixes the marked point @xmath4 and is an orientation preserving homeomorphism on @xmath0 so it acts locally like a rotation around @xmath4 sending @xmath409 to @xmath426 .
this is a @xmath462 rotation of order @xmath431 in @xmath463 .
finally we observed that @xmath79 belongs to the centraliser of @xmath6 , it has order @xmath464 locally around @xmath4 whereas @xmath6 has local order @xmath219 .
therefore it satisfies @xmath465 , where @xmath428 and @xmath466 are integers and @xmath467 .
from theorem [ th:5.1 ] and proposition 5.2 the set @xmath468 $ ] of sc - representatives of @xmath3 $ ] is a union of cycles @xmath469 , one for each @xmath6-orbit of unstable separatrices at the marked fixed point @xmath4 . each cycle is obtained from any of its representative by a finite sequence of sc - elementary folding operation
. two types of situations could simplify this set of cycles : + - a cycle could be shorter than expected ( see propositions [ prop:5.3 ] and [ prop:5.5 ] ) .
+ - two a priori different cycles could be equivalent ( see propositions [ prop:5.4 ] and [ prop:5.6 ] ) .
+ these simplifications reflect the existence of a combinatorial equivalence that is different from the one we use to prove the existence of cycles , namely the fact that @xmath457 is equivalent to @xmath470 .
proposition 5.2 then implies the existence of a homeomorphism in the centraliser of @xmath3 $ ] that is not at power of @xmath6 .
the permutation @xmath202 induced by @xmath6 on the set @xmath471 of unstable separatrices at @xmath4 acts like a rotation of angle @xmath472 for some @xmath473 , called the _ rotation number _ of @xmath6 at @xmath4 .
if @xmath457 is a sc - representative of @xmath3 $ ] relative to @xmath189 , the combinatorial cycle @xmath474 of sc - representatives relative to @xmath189 of @xmath3 $ ] is defined by @xmath475 .
if there exists an integer @xmath245 smaller than @xmath476 such that @xmath477 is combinatorially equivalent to @xmath478 , let @xmath479 be the smallest such integer .
one says that @xmath474 admits a _ combinatorial primitive subcycle _ @xmath480 . in this case
, @xmath479 divides @xmath476 and the cycle @xmath474 is obtained by looping several times around the primitive subcycle @xmath481 .
observe that if @xmath79 is a @xmath482-root of @xmath6 fixing @xmath4 , then it has the same invariant foliations as @xmath6 , and the permutation @xmath483 induced by @xmath79 on the separatrices @xmath484 satisfies @xmath485 .
the following four results give necessary and sufficient conditions for the map @xmath6 to admit roots fixing @xmath4 .
we distinguish different cases , according to the rotation number of @xmath6 and its roots at the point @xmath4 .
[ prop:5.3 ] the notations are like in theorem [ th:5.1 ] .
we assume @xmath486 ( @xmath6 has rotation number zero at @xmath4 ) .
the following conditions are equivalent : + i ) there exists a pseudo - anosov homeomorphism @xmath79 fixing @xmath4 and an integer @xmath487 such that @xmath488 and the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 is zero .
+ ii ) for every separatrix @xmath409 at @xmath4 , the cycle @xmath489 admits a primitive subcycle @xmath490 .
+ iii ) for some separatrix @xmath409 , the cycle @xmath489 admits a primitive subcycle @xmath490 . +
when iii ) is satisfied and @xmath491 , then a root of @xmath6 is the inverse of the transition map from @xmath492 to @xmath493 .
@xmath494 if @xmath488 then @xmath79 is pseudo - anosov and its growth rate is @xmath495 . let @xmath492 be a sc - representative relative to some leaf @xmath409 .
the cycle @xmath489 is given by @xmath496 .
then @xmath497 is a sc - representative relative to @xmath409 , since @xmath79 has rotation number @xmath498 at @xmath4 and its total length is @xmath499 .
it follows from theorem [ th:5.1 ] @xmath500 that @xmath501 is equivalent to @xmath502 for some @xmath245 . since @xmath503 then @xmath504 ( see the proof of theorem [ th:4.9 ] ) and @xmath489 admits a subcycle .
since @xmath302 was arbitrary , ii ) is proved .
@xmath505 is obvious .
@xmath506 assume that condition @xmath507 is satisfied and denote by @xmath79 the transition map from @xmath492 to @xmath493 . as observed above , the cycle @xmath489 is a multiple of the subcycle @xmath490 several times .
hence there is an integer @xmath508 such that @xmath509 .
this proves @xmath510 .
[ prop:5.4 ] the notations are like in theorem [ th:5.1 ] .
assume @xmath486 ( @xmath6 has rotation number zero at @xmath4 ) .
the following conditions are equivalent : + i ) there exists a pseudo - anosov homeomorphism @xmath79 fixing @xmath4 such that @xmath488 and the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 is non - zero . moreover @xmath6 is not the power of a map with zero rotation number .
+ ii ) for every @xmath221 , the cycle @xmath474 relative to @xmath189 has no combinatorial subcycles
. there exists @xmath511 such that the cycle @xmath489 is combinatorially equivalent to the cycle @xmath474 and for two equivalent representatives @xmath512 and @xmath513 ,
the lengths satisfy : @xmath514 .
the transition map @xmath79 from @xmath515 to some @xmath516 is a root of @xmath6 .
+ @xmath517 since @xmath474 is equivalent to @xmath489 and has no subcycle there is only one @xmath518 that is equivalent to @xmath519 .
the cycle @xmath474 might be equivalent to several @xmath489 .
the transition map @xmath520 from @xmath492 to @xmath306 maps @xmath189 to @xmath409 and @xmath521 is of order @xmath522 . by proposition 5.2 ( iii )
@xmath523 , and thus there are @xmath49 and @xmath53 relatively prime so that @xmath524 .
let @xmath525 and @xmath40 be such that @xmath526 and let @xmath527 then @xmath528 , this map @xmath79 is a transition map as a composition of such .
@xmath494 let @xmath79 be a root of @xmath6 fixing @xmath4 with non - zero rotation number at @xmath4 , so that @xmath488 .
the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 has exactly order @xmath53 , for if it was smaller than @xmath53 then @xmath6 would have a root with zero rotation number .
let @xmath492 be a sc - representative relative to @xmath189 and @xmath529 , then @xmath530 is a sc - representative for @xmath6 relative to @xmath409 and the transition map from @xmath492 to @xmath501 is @xmath79 .
the length condition is given by proposition 5.2 ( ii ) .
we now treat the cases when @xmath6 has non - zero rotation number at @xmath4 .
[ prop:5.5 ] the notations are like in theorem [ th:5.1 ] .
assume that @xmath6 has non - zero rotation number at @xmath4 .
the following conditions are equivalent : + i ) there exists a pseudo - anosov map @xmath79 fixing @xmath4 such that @xmath488 and the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 is the same as @xmath6 .
+ ii ) for every @xmath302 , the cycle @xmath489 relative to @xmath409 has a subcycle .
moreover if @xmath492 is any sc - representative relative to @xmath409 , let @xmath520 be the transition map from @xmath492 to the first representative equivalent to @xmath492 in the primitive subcycle @xmath490 starting from @xmath492 .
let @xmath508 be the integer such that @xmath531 .
there exists @xmath532 such that the map @xmath533 admits a @xmath534th root fixing @xmath4 with non - zero rotation number that is also a root of @xmath535 .
@xmath494 the map @xmath536 is a root of @xmath291 and has rotation number zero .
hence if @xmath492 is a sc - representative relative to @xmath409 , then @xmath537 is a sc - representative relative to @xmath409 and its total length satisfies @xmath538 .
the cycle relative to @xmath409 has a subcycle , and the map @xmath539 is a power of the transition map @xmath520 from @xmath492 to the first representative equivalent to @xmath492 .
it is of the form @xmath533 with @xmath532 ( in fact @xmath428 divides @xmath466 ) .
@xmath517 the @xmath219-th root of a map with zero rotation number has a rotation number whose order divides @xmath219 . but a root of @xmath535 has rotation number whose order is a multiple of @xmath219 .
[ prop:5.6 ] the notations are like in theorem [ th:5.1 ] .
assume that @xmath6 has non - zero rotation number with order @xmath219 at @xmath4 .
the following conditions are equivalent : + i ) there exists a pseudo - anosov map @xmath79 fixing @xmath4 such that @xmath488 and the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 has order @xmath540 with @xmath541 .
+ ii ) let @xmath542 , the cycle @xmath543 is combinatorially equivalent to @xmath544 .
let @xmath492 be a sc- representative relative to @xmath339 .
there exists an integer @xmath53 relatively prime with @xmath540 such that one transition map from @xmath492 to a representative in the cycle relative to @xmath545 is a root of @xmath6 . for the practical determination of a root , it is useful to note the following .
assume that the property @xmath546 above is satisfied .
let @xmath79 be the transition map from @xmath492 to some sc - representative relative to @xmath547 , let @xmath520 be the transition map from @xmath492 to the first sc - representative equivalent to @xmath492 in the cycle @xmath548 .
there exist integers @xmath428 and @xmath466 such that @xmath549 and @xmath550 .
any transition map from @xmath492 to another sc - representative relative to some leaf @xmath545 is of the form @xmath551 .
the roots of @xmath6 are to be searched among such maps , with the restriction @xmath552 .
furthermore the value of @xmath553 can only take finitely many values since the growth rate of a root @xmath79 is smaller than the growth rate of @xmath6 .
@xmath494 the element @xmath554 is a multiple of the rotation number of @xmath79 , hence there exists @xmath555 such that @xmath556 has rotation number @xmath302 .
then @xmath557 is a sc- representative relative to @xmath547 and is combinatorially equivalent to @xmath492 .
this proves the first part of @xmath546 .
the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 is of the form @xmath558 , @xmath53 prime with @xmath540 .
hence @xmath559 is a sc - representative relative to @xmath545 .
@xmath517 is similar to the previous proofs .
when a finite order orientation preserving homeomorphism @xmath79 fixing @xmath4 satisfies @xmath560 , we say that the pair of foliations @xmath561 and the homeomorphism @xmath6 _ admit the symmetry _ @xmath79 . in this case , the foliations are invariant under @xmath79 and the dilatation factor of @xmath79 is @xmath562 . in the previous paragraph
, we studied all the possible cases when a transition map @xmath79 between two sc - representatives for @xmath6 is a root of @xmath6 .
this happens when the dilatation factor of @xmath79 is @xmath563 , and the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 is a `` @xmath53-th root '' of the rotation number of @xmath6 . here , we show that when @xmath564 and the rotation number of @xmath79 at @xmath4 is non - zero , then @xmath6 admits the symmetry @xmath79 .
the following conditions are equivalent : + i ) there exists a non trivial finite order homeomorphism @xmath79 fixing @xmath4 such that @xmath565 .
+ ii ) for every leaf @xmath409 and every sc - representative of @xmath6 relative to @xmath409 , there exists @xmath566 and a sc - representative relative to @xmath567 that is combinatorially equivalent to @xmath492 and has the same total length .
+ iii ) for some @xmath568 and some sc - representative of @xmath6 relative to @xmath409 , there exists @xmath566 and a sc- representative relative to @xmath567 that is combinatorially equivalent to @xmath492 and has the same total length .
+ if condition @xmath507 is satisfied , then a finite order homeomorphism commuting with @xmath6 is given by the transition map from @xmath492 to @xmath501 .
@xmath494 if @xmath79 is a finite order homeomorphism that commutes with @xmath6 then @xmath530 is a sc - representative for @xmath6 .
it has the same total length : @xmath569 .
the homeomorphism @xmath79 permutes the separatrices at @xmath4 in a non trivial fashion , since otherwise @xmath79 would be the identity . hence @xmath501 is a sc - representative of @xmath6 relative to the leaf @xmath570 and @xmath566 .
@xmath505 is obvious .
@xmath506 let @xmath79 be the transition map from @xmath492 to @xmath501 .
let @xmath53 be such that @xmath571 $ ] .
then @xmath572 is a sc - representative relative to @xmath409 and it has the same total length as @xmath492 .
hence @xmath573 by observation 1 of paragraph 4.1 , that is @xmath574 .
theorem [ th:5.1 ] yields another solution to the conjugacy problem among pseudo - anosov elements of the mapping class group , in the particular case when one marked point is fixed .
let @xmath575 denote the set of _ combinatorial sc - representatives _ of @xmath3 $ ] , ie the set of sc - representatives up to combinatorial equivalence .
the set @xmath575 is a complete conjugacy invariant .
this set is a union of cycles that is computable . if @xmath3 $ ] and @xmath324 $ ] are conjugate then the sets @xmath575 and @xmath576 are the same . indeed
if @xmath577 and @xmath286 is a sc - representative of @xmath3 $ ] then @xmath578 is a sc - representative of @xmath324 $ ] and @xmath578 is combinatorially equivalent to @xmath286 , thus @xmath579 and by symmetry @xmath580 .
conversely if @xmath581 then @xmath3 $ ] and @xmath324 $ ] are conjugate .
the computability of the cycle structure is given in the next section .
_ in los @xcite the principle for solving the conjugacy problem ( for irreducible free group outer automorphisms ) was similar but using the whole set of combinatorial efficient representatives as a complete invariant rather than the small subset of sc - representatives .
the computability was stated as a `` connectedness '' property saying that any two efficient representatives are connected by a sequence of folding , collapsing or the converse of a folding . here
the set of complete invariant is much smaller and describing each cycle is quite simple since only foldings are necessary and in a specific ordering .
furthermore there is a strong connectedness result , that will appear in the next section .
it states the existence of one combinatorial efficient representative , say @xmath582 , that is not in general a sc - representative so that , for each element @xmath583 , @xmath582 is connected to @xmath286 by a well defined sequence of folding operations .
from theorem [ th:5.1 ] and propositions 5.35.7 we know how to solve the roots and the symmetry problems .
the goal is to obtain an effective algorithmic solution , it remains to show that all the quantities described in the previous paragraphs are computable .
first we know from bestvina and handel @xcite that an efficient representative is obtained after a finite algorithm , called the _ train track algorithm _ , starting from any topological representative of the mapping class @xmath3 $ ] .
the train track algorithm provides also a way to check whether @xmath3 $ ] is a pseudo - anosov class and admits a marked fixed point .
the initial data here is an efficient representative @xmath584 of @xmath3 $ ] . in order to use theorem [ th:5.1 ] and the propositions 5.35.7 , several new transformations are necessary to describe completely the cycles of sc - representatives . to this end
we describe how to perform the following steps : + - transform any efficient representative into a sc - representative , relative to a separatrix @xmath409 .
+ - describe one cycle @xmath585 .
+ - describe all the cycles @xmath586 .
+ - compare the cycles .
+ the first step is a preliminary algorithm that requires a new operation : _ glueing a @xmath202-orbit_. the second step only requires the sc - folding operations , but we have to define this operation combinatorially rather than metrically as in section 4 .
the third step needs a transformation from one cycle @xmath585 to another cycle @xmath587 and this requires also a new operation , called _ splitting an infinitesimal turn_. the final step requires checking the combinatorial equivalence on the one hand and the length on the other hand .
the combinatorial equivalence is easy to check ( in principle ) . for the length
we define a `` based efficient representative '' that is not a sc - representative but has the property that all cycles are obtained from this single `` based point '' only by glueing and folding operations .
the glueing operation introduced in this paragraph is new .
the principle is quite simple : starting from an efficient representative @xmath588 of @xmath3 $ ] we want to glue an orbit of periodic nielsen paths in order to find a sc - representative .
a priori @xmath492 has several orbits of nielsen paths associated to orbits of illegal turns , some of these turns are tangencies of order one . the goal is to transform all of these orbits but one into an orbit of infinitesimal turns . we assume first that a length function is given on @xmath11 as in section 2.2 .
the cut lengths @xmath200 associated to @xmath492 are given by the map @xmath589 of lemma 2.2 from the orbits of periodic nielsen paths .
we denote by @xmath202 the permutation of the indexes of the periodic nielsen paths ( under @xmath29 ) as well as the permutation ( under @xmath6 ) of the corresponding indexes of the separatrices at the fixed marked point @xmath4 .
we denote by @xmath201 one @xmath202-orbit for which @xmath590 and we assume that @xmath202 is not transitive .
` step 1 . `
the first combinatorial step is to find the periodic orbits on the boundary , as well as all the associated periodic nielsen paths @xmath591 .
those are in a one - to - one correspondence with the illegal turns @xmath270 , as described in paragraph 2.2.3 .
the nielsen path @xmath591 is considered either as a path between two consecutive boundary periodic points along the boundary @xmath592 and passing through the cusp @xmath593 associated to the illegal turn @xmath270 or as the corresponding edge path in @xmath11 .
recall also that the nielsen path is the concatenation @xmath594 , where @xmath595 and @xmath596 are the paths starting at the cusp @xmath593 toward the boundary periodic points along @xmath592 .
we assume that @xmath492 has more than one orbit of nielsen paths .
we subdivide the two paths @xmath595 and @xmath596 at a finite collection of points @xmath597 .
the two paths @xmath595 and @xmath596 have the same length , by definition .
a point @xmath598 belongs to @xmath599 either if @xmath525 is a vertex or if the distance from @xmath525 to @xmath270 along @xmath595 ( resp .
@xmath596 ) is the same than the distance from a vertex @xmath40 to @xmath270 along @xmath600 ( resp .
@xmath601 ) .
the boundary periodic points at the end of @xmath595 and @xmath596 also belong to @xmath599 . this metric description of the set @xmath599 is replaced in practise by an easy combinatorial description using the map @xmath29 and it s iterates . `
we subdivide @xmath11 at each point @xmath602 for all @xmath270 in one @xmath202-orbit @xmath201 .
the resulting graph is denoted @xmath603 .
` step 3 . ` the map @xmath13 induces a well defined map @xmath604 . by definition of the subdivision
we obtain : the map @xmath604 satisfies the following property : for every illegal turn @xmath270 in the @xmath202-orbit @xmath201 and each edge @xmath605 on the path @xmath601 , there is an edge @xmath606 on the path @xmath596 , at the same distance from @xmath270 so that @xmath607 and @xmath608 are either equal or are subarcs @xmath609 , @xmath610 along @xmath611 and @xmath612 at the same distance from the illegal turn @xmath613 .
@xmath181 ` step 4 . `
let @xmath614 be the above subdivided efficient representative of @xmath3 $ ] .
we define a new graph @xmath435 by identifying all the pairs @xmath615 of lemma 6.1 .
the embedding @xmath616 induces a well defined embedding @xmath617 .
let @xmath618 denote the quotient map .
we observe , by lemma 6.1 , that if @xmath619 for two edges @xmath620 of @xmath603 then either @xmath621 or @xmath622 .
therefore there is a well defined map @xmath623
so that : @xmath624 .
the triple @xmath625 is an efficient representative of @xmath3 $ ] , obtained from @xmath492 by _ glueing _ the @xmath202-orbit @xmath201 .
the cut length @xmath626 satisfies @xmath627 if @xmath204 and @xmath628 if @xmath629 . the fact that @xmath501 is efficient is clear from the construction .
indeed no new illegal turn has been created .
the properties of the cut length is also clear : the periodic nielsen paths corresponding to the orbit @xmath201 has been replaced by a periodic orbit of infinitesimal turns , therefore of length zero .
the length of the other periodic nielsen paths has not been affected , although the paths themselves might be very different .
@xmath181 in practise , this operation can be performed as a sequence of ( classical ) folding operations of illegal turns @xmath270 that belong to the orbit @xmath201 .
let us describe the sc - folding operation in a combinatorial setting .
we assume that a sc - representative with respect to a separatrix , say @xmath339 , is given .
let @xmath630 be the illegal turn of order one that is associated with @xmath339 .
we consider as above the nielsen path @xmath631 .
along one of the paths @xmath632 or @xmath633 , there is a first vertex @xmath634 with at least 3 gates by lemma 4.3 and the construction of paragraph 2.2 .
let @xmath319 denote the length of the arc @xmath635 $ ] along @xmath632 or @xmath633 .
we apply a first sequence of standard folding operations , as described by bestvina and handel @xcite , until the illegal turn of order one associated to @xmath339 is based at the corresponding vertex with at least 3 gates . the number of such operations is uniformly bounded , in term of the combinatorial length of @xmath632 and @xmath633 .
we obtain an efficient representative @xmath636 which , in general , is not a sc - representative .
indeed , if @xmath637 then the turn @xmath638 associated to @xmath639 is now of order one .
we apply next a sequence of standard foldings at @xmath640 until it becomes of order greater than one and we iterate the sequence for @xmath641 , until all of these turns are of order greater than one .
each of these sequences at @xmath642 has a uniformly bounded number of elementary folding operations .
observe that the above sequence of foldings is uniquely defined by the initial sc - representative .
the resulting efficient representative satisfies : the above sequence of standard folding operations : @xmath643 results in a sc - representative relative to @xmath339 . the number of standard folding operations in this sequence is uniformly bounded .
the global operation @xmath644 is the elementary sc - folding at @xmath286 of length @xmath319.@xmath181 in this paragraph we define a transformation that can be applied when an efficient representative @xmath286 has an orbit @xmath201 of separatrices whose cut length is zero .
it only makes sense if the permutation @xmath202 is not transitive .
the goal is to obtain another efficient representative for which the orbit @xmath201 has non zero cut length . from lemma 2.2
the zero cut length property arises when a vertex @xmath634 with more than 3 gates is a boundary periodic point . in this case
the separatrices of the orbit @xmath201 are in bijection with some infinitesimal turns obtained by the train track construction of paragraph 2.2.2 at the orbit of @xmath634 . in what follows
we will either discuss the efficient representative @xmath286 or the corresponding train track map @xmath645 .
the zero cut length situation corresponds for @xmath286 to a periodic orbit of vertices @xmath646 with more than 3 gates .
for the train track map @xmath645 there is also a periodic orbit of vertices @xmath647 with exactly 3 gates . at each @xmath648
there is an infinitesimal turn @xmath649 ( l /r stands for left and right ) on one side and one gate @xmath650 on the other side .
` step 1 : preliminary foldings .
` if each gate @xmath120 is reduced to a single edge then @xmath648 has valency 3 and the next transformations are easier to apply . if some of the gates has more than one edge then we apply some foldings leading to the previous simple situation with valency 3 at each vertex .
the periodicity assumption on the infinitesimal turns @xmath651 implies that one edge of the gates @xmath120 has periodic initial segment under @xmath652 ( the same is also true for @xmath29 ) , ie : + @xmath653 , + where the @xmath654 are oriented from the @xmath648 see figure 7 .
some of the edge paths @xmath655 might be trivial but not all of them since @xmath652 is a strict dilatation on each non infinitesimal edge .
+ we choose one gate ( with more than one edge ) , say @xmath656 , and we consider the first index @xmath221 , in the above sequence ordered by the orbit , for which @xmath655 is non trivial .
let @xmath49 be the initial vertex of @xmath655 , we subdivide @xmath657 at the preimages of @xmath49 .
this defines vertices @xmath658 of valency 2 on @xmath659 .
then we apply a standard folding of all the edges in the gate @xmath656 , up to @xmath660 and then at all the preimage gates . note
that several other choices of subdivisions and preliminary folding operations are possible here .
our choice is made to obtain a periodic orbit of valency 3 vertices .
after this sequence of preliminary foldings we obtain a new train track map @xmath661 and a new efficient representative @xmath306 so that the gates @xmath662 corresponding to @xmath120 are all reduced to a single edge @xmath663 . the infinitesimal turns @xmath664 has not been affected by these foldings and are still periodic , ie : @xmath665 , under @xmath666 .
+ similarly the edges @xmath663 have periodic initial segments : @xmath667 . `
step 2 : splitting . `
the topological idea is to `` cut along @xmath668 '' . in practise , in the simple situation obtained after the preliminary foldings , ie when all the vertices @xmath669 have valency 3 , this operation is nothing else than a collapsing " . let @xmath670 be the graph obtained from @xmath671 by collapsing the edge @xmath668 and we assume that the edges of @xmath672 keeps the same name and orientation than in @xmath671 .
this graph is embedded in the surface and the embedding @xmath673 is induced by the embedding @xmath674 .
we define a new map @xmath675 on @xmath670 as follows : @xmath676 , @xmath677 and @xmath678 , for all other edges , where @xmath679 is the word , representing an edge path in @xmath672 , obtained from the word @xmath89 representing an edge path in @xmath671 by removing all occurrences of the letter @xmath668 .
the labelling and the orientation of the edges are given in figure 7 .
let us make a couple of observations : + - the edges @xmath680 are not infinitesimal anymore .
+ - all turns @xmath681 are now illegal and @xmath682 is of order one .
+ - the new map @xmath683 is a train track map .
+ indeed no edge @xmath16 of @xmath672 is mapped across any of the new illegal turns @xmath681 .
[ fig:7 ] the other orbits of infinitesimal edges of @xmath671 remains infinitesimal for @xmath684 .
collapsing the infinitesimal edges of @xmath672 that bounds @xmath53-gones or @xmath53-gones with one side missing to a point leads to an efficient representative @xmath685 so that the construction of paragraph 2.2 , applied to @xmath686 leads back to @xmath684 .
the operation that transforms @xmath286 to the efficient representative @xmath686 is called a _ splitting at the separatrix @xmath339 _ , where @xmath339 corresponds to the infinitesimal turn @xmath682 of @xmath687 , under the map @xmath280 of lemma 2.2 . in addition
the cut length @xmath688 is non zero for all separatrices for which @xmath267 is non zero and the separatrices in the orbit @xmath201 of @xmath339 .
the fact that @xmath686 is efficient was proved during the construction .
the cut length properties come from the the following observations : + each non trivial periodic nielsen path of @xmath286 has a non trivial image in @xmath686 , therefore with non zero length .
the lengths are a priori different in @xmath286 and in @xmath686 because of the preliminary foldings .
+ the paths @xmath689 are periodic nielsen paths in @xmath686 of non zero length which proves the last statement .
@xmath181 _
remark : _ a notion that is similar to this _ splitting at a separatrix _ has been defined in the context of free group automorphisms , for instance in los and lustig @xcite , such an operation is called `` unfolding nielsen paths '' .
we have now defined all the necessary tools to make explicit an algorithm that produces all the cycles of sc - representatives relative to one separatrix in each @xmath202-orbits and to identify combinatorially and/or metrically the a priori different cycles .
these algorithms altogether with the results of section 5 give our solution to the roots and the symmetry problems . `
step 0 : find one efficient representative . `
+ from the train track algorithm of bestvina and handel @xcite we find one efficient representative @xmath386 for @xmath3 $ ] .
` step 1 : identify the orbits of separatrices . ` + the map @xmath690 of lemma 2.2 defines an identification of the separatrices @xmath691 with some of the illegal turns and some of the infinitesimal turns , ie the set @xmath692 .
we label these turns with the corresponding label of the separatrices and we compute the permutation @xmath202 , in particular its order @xmath219 . `
step 2 : split all orbits of separatrices . `
+ if some @xmath202-orbit @xmath201 has cut length zero then we apply a splitting operation ( paragraph 6.3 ) at @xmath693 .
observe that the zero cut length property of a @xmath202-orbit does not require to compute a length function .
after splitting all the orbits with zero cut length we obtain an efficient representative @xmath694 where all orbits @xmath201 of @xmath202 have positive cut length .
this subclass of efficient representatives has been called `` principal blow up class '' in los and lustig @xcite .
we consider this particular representative @xmath694 as a `` base point '' for the next steps .
in particular we fix on @xmath694 a length function from which all the other length functions will be derived .
the length function is ( see paragraph 2.2 ) an eigenvector of the incidence matrix .
` step 3 : find one sc - representative . ` + fix one @xmath202-orbit @xmath695 and then apply the glueing operation of paragraph 6.1 at all the @xmath202-orbits @xmath696 except @xmath697 .
we obtain an efficient representative @xmath698 that satisfies , by proposition 6.2 : @xmath699 iff @xmath700 but is not necessarily a sc - representative . from the proof of lemma 4.3 there is a vertex with at least 3 gates along one of the nielsen paths that are associated with the orbit of non zero cut length .
in addition such a vertex @xmath701 exists on a nielsen path @xmath702 , where @xmath160 is illegal of order one .
we apply a sequence of standard folding operations at @xmath160 up to the vertex @xmath701
. then we fold at the possible other illegal turns of order one in this orbit until all of them are of order greater than one . property
( sc1 ) of proposition 3.3 is then satisfied .
property ( sc2 ) is obvious to obtain on boundary loops by blowing up a vertex if it has more than 3 gates .
+ after this step 3 we obtain one sc - representative @xmath703 , ... ,
@xmath704 , relative to @xmath705 , ... ,
@xmath706 . _
remark : _ all sc - representatives @xmath707 are obtained from the base point @xmath694 by a sequence of operations that only consists in gluing and folding .
all these elementary operations induce a well defined length function .
therefore all the @xmath707 have a well defined length function ( not up to rescaling ) .
` step 4 : find the cycles . `
+ for each @xmath708 we apply the elementary sc - folding operations of paragraph 6.2 : @xmath709 , up to the first sc - representative that is combinatorially equivalent to the initial sc - representative : @xmath710 . at the end of this step 4
we obtain the collection of all the primitive cycles : @xmath711 , one for each orbit @xmath712 of @xmath202 .
_ the combinatorial equivalence @xmath713 is easy to verify .
first we check that the two graphs are homeomorphic and then that the two maps are identical after the graph homeomorphism that induces a renaming .
we just have to be careful that the graph homeomorphism preserves the surface structure , ie that the cyclic ordering at each vertex is preserved . `
step 5 : comparisons of cycles . `
+ we check whether two primitive cycles @xmath714 where @xmath189 and @xmath409 belong to different @xmath202-orbits .
this is quite easy by the previous remark . `
step 6 : length comparisons . `
+ fixing a length function at step 2 for the efficient representative @xmath694 is a normalisation .
all sc - representatives in the cycles @xmath715 are obtained from @xmath694 by a sequence of foldings and glueings . by the remark in step 3
all length functions are then well defined .
@xmath716 for one cycle @xmath717 : an elementary sc - folding is a composition of standard foldings and the total length is changed according to proposition 4.2 and lemma 6.3 . at the end of the primitive cycle @xmath717 , ie when @xmath710 , and @xmath718 is minimal , we compute the total length @xmath719 and we compare it with @xmath720 , as in theorem 4.9 .
observe that @xmath87 and @xmath219 are known and , since @xmath87 , only a finite precision is sufficient for the comparison .
this enables to check whether the cycle @xmath715 of theorem 5.1 is primitive or not . if not then @xmath715 is a finite concatenation of the primitive cycle @xmath717 leading to the existence of a root via one of the propositions 5.3 , 5.5
. + @xmath716 if step 5 gives two equivalent cycles @xmath714 then we need to compare the lengths between two equivalent sc - representatives @xmath721 and @xmath722 .
the equality of the length function implies the existence of a symmetry by proposition 5.7 .
the non equality shows the existence of a root via one of the propositions 5.4 or 5.6 . as above the precision required for checking
the equality / non equality is finite .
now all the ingredients are computed to check which of the propositions 5.35.7 applies .
therefore we have decided if our element @xmath3 $ ] admits or not a root or a symmetry . `
step 7 : compute a root or a symmetry . ` + @xmath716 the symmetry given by proposition 5.7 is easier to make explicit .
it is induced by the combinatorial equivalence @xmath723 of proposition 5.7 between two sc - representatives in different cycles .
+ @xmath716 from proposition 5.2 , a root is given by the transition map between two equivalent sc - representatives .
in practise this means to follow , along the cycles , how the embedding @xmath30 changes .
this is possible but not very simple since it would require to express the embedding in a combinatorial way .
there is a much simpler way with the tools we already have .
the most complicated situation is when two primitive cycles are equivalent .
we start at some sc - representative @xmath724 and then apply the uniquely defined sequence of foldings given by the primitive cycle followed by the ( unique ) equivalence homeomorphism obtained by @xmath725 .
this sequence of foldings followed by a graph homeomorphism defines a unique efficient representative @xmath726 of @xmath324 $ ] that is a root of @xmath3 $ ] .
this completes the proof of the main theorem.@xmath181
in this section we present only one simple example in the mapping class group of the punctured disc that is classically given as the braid group modulo the centre .
more complicated examples would require much more space and even for this simple example we give only a few steps . consider the braid @xmath727 , given with the classical braid generators by @xmath728 .
it defines a pseudo - anosov element in the mapping class group of the 4th punctured disc .
an efficient representative is given on the graph presented in figure 8 , by the following combinatorial map : @xmath729 it is not a single cut representative since there are 2 fixed illegal turns : @xmath730 and @xmath731 , corresponding to 2 unstable separatrices that are fixed under the homeomorphism , respectively @xmath339 and @xmath732 .
this efficient representative will be our `` base '' representative @xmath694 of step 2 above .
* glueing the separatrix @xmath339 * ( turn @xmath731 ): + this glueing operation will be presented as a sequence of classical foldings .
+ step 1 - folding @xmath733 , then @xmath734 , then @xmath735 . + after this sequence of foldings we obtain the following graph , embedding and map : then we apply four similar steps that are uniquely defined since there is only one turn to be folded at each step .
after these four steps we obtain the graph , embedding and map as shown in the next figure . * glueing the separatrix @xmath732 * ( at the turn @xmath730 ) .
+ analogous operations show that a single cut representative relative to the other separatrix is given on the following graph and embedding : @xmath738 the two graphs of figure 10 and 11 are obviously homeomorphic and the two representatives are combinatorially equivalent under the map : @xmath739 .
we check that this equivalence is realised by a homeomorphism of the punctured disc that is induced by the braid : @xmath740 .
it follows from the main theorem that @xmath741 this equality is easy to check directly . since @xmath742 , where @xmath743 is the classical garside braid generating the centre ,
then @xmath341 is finite order .
observe that for this example we did nt compute the whole cycles of theorem 5.1 since the first sc - representatives relative to each fixed separatrix were already equivalent . | an algorithm is proposed that solves two decision problems for pseudo - anosov elements in the mapping class group of a surface with at least one marked fixed point .
the first problem is the root problem : decide if the element is a power and in this case compute the roots .
the second problem is the symmetry problem : decide if the element commutes with a finite order element and in this case compute this element .
the structure theorem on which this algorithm is based provides also a new solution to the conjugacy problem . |
the formation process of low- to intermediate - mass stars is divided into several stages , ranging from the deeply embedded protostellar stage to the period when a young star is dispersing its protoplanetary disk in which planets may have formed . during the protostellar phase , which is estimated to last @xmath1 0.5 myr @xcite , the growing central source accretes dust and gas from a collapsing envelope .
the material from the envelope is most likely accreted through a disk , feeding the growing star .
a fraction of the mass is ejected in outflows , which carve openings into the envelope along the outflow axis . despite our understanding of the basic processes operating in low - mass protostars ,
fundamental questions remain ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
in particular , it is not understood how the processes of infall , feedback from outflows , disk accretion , as well as the surrounding birth environment , affect mass accretion and determine the ultimate stellar mass .
the luminosity of protostars , which can be dominated by accretion , is observed to span more than three orders of magnitude , yet the underlying physics of this luminosity range is also not understood @xcite .
it is in this protostellar phase that disks are formed , setting the stage for planet formation , yet how infall , feedback , accretion , and environment influence the properties of disks and of planets that eventually form from them is unknown .
the large samples of well - characterized protostars identified from surveys with _ spitzer _ and _ herschel _ now provide the means to systematically study the processes controlling the formation of stars and disks ; the goal of this work is to provide such a characterization for the protostars found in the orion a and b clouds , the largest population of protostars for any of the molecular clouds within 500 pc of the sun @xcite . in protostars , dust in the disk and envelope reprocesses the shorter - wavelength radiation emitted by the central protostar and the accretion shock on the stellar surface and reemits it prominently at mid- to far - infrared wavelengths . as a result , the combined emission of most protostellar systems ( consisting of protostar , disk , and envelope ) peaks in the far - ir .
young , deeply embedded protostars have spectral energy distributions ( seds ) with steeply rising slopes in the infrared , peaking around 100 , and large fractional submillimeter luminosities ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
near 10 and 18 , absorption by sub - micron - sized silicate grains causes broad absorption features ; in addition , there are several ice absorption features across the infrared spectral range @xcite .
these absorption features are indicative of the amount of material along the line of sight , with the deepest features found for the most embedded objects .
in addition , due to the asymmetric radiation field , the orientation of a protostellar system to the line of sight , whether through a dense disk or a low - density cavity , plays a role in the appearance of the sed .
it influences the near- to far - ir slope , the depth of the silicate feature , the emission peak , and the fraction of light emitted at the longest wavelengths ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . to classify young stellar objects ( ysos ) into observational classes , the near- to mid - infrared spectral index @xmath2 ( @xmath3 ) from about 2 to 20 @xmath0 m has traditionally been used @xcite .
this index is positive for a class 0/i protostar , between @xmath4 and 0.3 for a flat - spectrum source , and between @xmath5 and @xmath6 for a class ii pre - main - sequence star .
class 0 protostars are distinguished from class i protostars as having @xmath7 ratios larger than 0.5% , according to the original definition by @xcite .
other values for this threshold that have recently been used are 1% @xcite and even 3% @xcite .
another measure for the evolution of a young star is the bolometric temperature ( @xmath8 ) , which is the temperature of a blackbody with the same flux - weighted mean frequency as the observed sed @xcite . a class 0 protostar has @xmath9 k , a class i protostar 70 k @xmath10 650 k , and a class ii pre - main - sequence star 650 k @xmath10 2800 k @xcite .
these observational classes are inferred to reflect evolutionary stages , with the inclination angle to the line of sight being the major source of uncertainty in translating classes to `` stages '' @xcite .
also the accretion history , which likely includes episodic accretion events and thus temporary increases in luminosity , adds to this uncertainty @xcite .
protostars with infalling envelopes of gas and dust correspond to stages 0 and i , with the transition from stage 0 to i occurring when the stellar mass becomes larger than the envelope mass @xcite .
young stars that have dispersed their envelopes and are surrounded by circumstellar disks correspond to stage ii . by modeling the seds of protostars , properties of their envelopes , and to some extent of their disks ,
can be constrained .
the near - ir is particularly sensitive to extinction and thus constrains the inclination angle and cavity opening angle , as well as the envelope density .
mid - ir spectroscopy reveals the detailed emission around the silicate absorption feature and thus provides additional constraints for both disk and envelope properties ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . at longer wavelengths ,
envelope emission starts to dominate .
thus , photometry in the far - ir is necessary to determine the peak of the sed and constrain the total luminosity and envelope properties .
here we present 1.2870 @xmath0 m seds and radiative transfer model fits of 330 ysos , most of them protostars , in the orion star formation complex .
this is the largest sample of protostars studied in a single , nearby star - forming region ( distance of 420 pc ; @xcite ) and therefore significant for advancing our understanding of protostellar structure and evolution .
these protostars were identified in _
spitzer space telescope _
@xcite data by @xcite and were observed at 70 and 160 with the photodetector array camera and spectrometer ( pacs ; * ? ? ?
* ) on the _ herschel space observatory _
@xcite as part of the herschel orion protostar survey ( hops ) , a _
herschel _ open - time key program ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* w. j. fischer et al . 2016 , in preparation ; b. ali et al .
2016 , in preparation ) . to extend the seds into the sub - mm , most of the ysos
were also observed in the continuum at 350 and 870 @xmath0 m with the atacama pathfinder experiment ( apex ) telescope @xcite .
our sample also includes 16 new protostars identified in pacs data obtained by the hops program ( @xcite ; see section [ sample ] ) .
we use a grid of 30,400 protostellar model seds to find the best fit to the sed for each object and constrain its protostellar properties . as mentioned above , the far - infrared data add crucial constraints for the model fits , given that for most protostars the sed peaks in this wavelength region , and therefore , within the framework of the model grid , our sed fits yield the most reliable protostellar parameters to date for these sources .
the 488 protostars identified in _ spitzer _
data by @xcite represent the basis for the hops sample ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
they have 3.6 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral indices @xmath11 @xmath4 and thus encompass flat - spectrum sources . to be included in the target list for the pacs observations , the predicted flux of a protostar in the 70 @xmath0 m pacs band had to be at least 42 mjy as extrapolated from the _ spitzer _ sed . since targets were required to have a 24 @xmath0 m detection , protostars in the orion nebula where the _ spitzer _ 24 @xmath0 m data are saturated are excluded .
in addition , after the pacs data were obtained , several new point sources that were very faint or undetected in the _ spitzer _ bands were discovered in the _ herschel _ data @xcite .
fifteen of them were found to be reliable new protostars .
one more protostar , which was not included in the sample of @xcite due to its more spatially extended appearance at 70 @xmath0 m , was recently confirmed by @xcite .
we have added these 16 protostars to the hops sample for this work ( see table d[new_proto ] in the appendix ) .
most of these new protostars have very red colors and are thus potentially the youngest protostars identified in orion ( see * ? ? ?
each object in the target list was assigned a `` hops '' identification number , resulting in 410 objects with such numbers ; hops 394 to 408 are the new protostars identified by @xcite , and hops 409 is the new protostar from @xcite .
four of the 410 hops targets turned out to be duplicates , and 31 are likely extragalactic contaminants ( see appendix [ exgal_not_modeled ] for details ) .
some objects in the hops target list were not observed by pacs ; of these 33 objects , 16 are likely contaminants , while the remaining objects were originally proposed but were not observed since they were too faint to have been detected with pacs in the awarded observing time . in addition
, 35 hops targets were not detected at 70 ( see appendices [ ysos_not_modeled ] and [ exgal_not_modeled ] ) ; eight of these are considered extragalactic contaminants , while two of them ( hops 349 and 381 ) have only two measured flux values each , making their nature more uncertain .
one more target , hops 350 , also has just two measured flux values ( at 24 and 70 @xmath0 m ) and is therefore also excluded from the analysis of this paper .
similarly , we excluded hops 352 , since it was only tentatively detected at 24 ( it lies on the airy ring of hops 84 ) and in none of the other data sets . to summarize , starting from the sample of 410 hops targets , but excluding likely contaminants and objects not observed or detected by pacs , there are 330 remaining objects that have _ spitzer _ and _ herschel _ data and are considered protostars ( based on their _ spitzer _ classification from @xcite ) .
they form the sample studied in this work .
their seds are presented in the next section , and in later sections we show and discuss the results of sed fits for these targets .
their coordinates , sed properties , and classification , as well as their best - fit model parameter values , are listed in table a[bestfit ] .
the 41 likely protostars that lack pacs data ( either not observed or not detected ) are presented in appendix [ ysos_not_modeled ] .
lcccccccccccblcccccc hops 1 & 0.000e+00 & 0.000e+00 & 3 & & 3.697e+00 & 1.850e-01 & 1 & & 6.354e-01 & 1.271e-01 & 2 & hops 1 & 8.631e-03 & 6.069e-04 & & 1.185e+00 & 6.460e-02 & 1.17 + hops 2 & 2.770e-04 & 5.000e-05 & 1 & & 5.188e-01 & 2.617e-02 & 1 & & 3.865e-01 & 7.730e-02 & 2 & hops 2 & 4.360e-02 & 3.757e-03 & & 3.704e-01 & 3.035e-02 & 1.00 + hops 3 & 2.198e-03 & 8.900e-05 & 1 & & 3.187e-01 & 1.622e-02 & 1 & & 1.201e-01 & 2.402e-02 & 1 & hops 3 & 4.460e-02 & 7.925e-03 & & 4.050e-01 & 2.443e-02 & 1.66 + hops 4 & 3.820e-04 & 5.300e-05 & 1 & & 6.116e-01 & 3.083e-02 & 1 & & 1.840e-01 & 3.680e-02 & 2 & hops 4 & 2.055e-02 & 1.240e-03 & & 4.943e-01 & 3.484e-02 & 1.00 + hops 5 & 0.000e+00 & 0.000e+00 & 3 & & 7.103e-01 & 3.573e-02 & 1 & & 6.973e-02 & 1.395e-02 & 2 & hops 5 & 1.475e-02 & 2.695e-03 & & 3.077e-01 & 4.484e-03 & 1.00 + hops 6 & 0.000e+00 & 0.000e+00 & 3 & & 9.110e-02 & 5.523e-03 & 1 & & 2.311e-01 & 4.622e-02 & 2 & hops 6 & 1.271e-03 & 3.935e-04 & & 5.350e-02 & 5.244e-03 & 1.00 + hops 7 & 0.000e+00 & 0.000e+00 & 3 & & 1.342e+00 & 6.728e-02 & 1 & & 3.577e-01 & 7.154e-02 & 2 & hops 7 & 6.459e-04 & 3.090e-04 & & 3.258e-01 & 2.114e-02 & 1.00 + in order to construct seds for our sample of 330 ysos , we combined our own observations with data from the literature and existing catalogs .
for the near - infrared photometry , we used @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 data from the two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ; * ? ? ? * ) . for the mid - infrared spectral region
, we used _
data from @xcite and @xcite : the infrared array camera ( irac ; * ? ? ?
* ) provided 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 , and 8.0 photometry , while the multiband imaging photometer for spitzer ( mips ; * ? ? ?
* ) provided 24 photometry .
in addition , most of the ysos in the hops sample were also observed with the infrared spectrograph ( irs ; * ? ? ?
* ) on _ spitzer _ using the short - low ( sl ; 5.2 - 14 ) and long - low ( ll ; 14 - 38 ) modules , both with a spectral resolution of about 90 ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a description of irs data reduction ) .
_ herschel _ pacs data at 70 , 100 , and 160 yielded far - infrared photometric data points ( b. ali et al .
2016 , in preparation ; the 100 @xmath0 m data are from the gould belt survey ; e.g. , @xcite ) .
most ysos were also observed at 350 and 870 ( see @xcite ) by the apex telescope using the saboca and laboca instruments ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* respectively ) .
thus , our seds have well - sampled wavelength coverage from 1.2 to 870 @xmath0 m ; we did not include additional data from the literature in order to preserve a homogeneous data set for all the objects in our sample .
the aperture radius used for the photometry varies depending on the instrument and wave band .
the photometry in the 2mass catalog was derived from point - spread function ( psf ) fits using data from 4 apertures around each object ( see the explanatory supplement to the 2mass all sky data release and extended mission products ) .
@xcite used an aperture radius of 24 for irac and psf photometry for mips 24 @xmath0 m data .
we used aperture radii of 96 and sky annuli of 96 - 192 for pacs 70 and 100 images ; we then applied aperture correction factors of 0.7331 and 0.6944 to the 70 and 100 fluxes , respectively . for pacs 160
, we used an aperture radius of 128 , a sky annulus of 128 - 256 , and an aperture correction factor of 0.6602 . in some cases ( background contamination , close companions ) we used psf photometry at 70 and 160 @xmath0 m instead ( see b. ali et al . 2016 , in preparation , for details ) .
finally , we adopted beam fluxes at 350 and 870 @xmath0 m ( with fwhms of 734 and 19 , respectively ) .
the irs sl module has a slit width of 36 , while the ll module is wider , with a slit width of 105 .
sometimes the flux level of the two segments did not match at 14 @xmath0 m ( due to slight mispointings or more extended emission from surrounding material measured in ll ) , and in these cases usually the sl spectrum was scaled by at most a factor of @xmath1 1.4 ( typically 1.1 - 1.2 ) . in a few cases , especially when the ll spectrum included substantial amounts of extended emission or flux from a nearby object , the ll spectrum was scaled down to match the flux level of the sl spectrum at 14 @xmath0 m , typically by a factor of 0.8 - 0.9 .
we discuss how the different aperture sizes are accounted for in the model fluxes in section [ model_ap ] .
the seds of our hops sample are shown in figure a[bestseds ] together with their best - fit models from our model grid ( see sections below ) ; the data are listed in table [ sed_data ] .
many objects display a deep silicate absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m and ice features in the 5 - 8 @xmath0 m region , as expected for protostars . those objects with very deep 10 @xmath0 m features and steeply rising seds are likely deeply embedded protostars , often seen at high inclination angles . a large fraction ( 203 out of 330 ) of the young stars in our sample
have at least one _ spitzer_-detected source within a radius of 15 ; in most cases , this `` companion '' is faint in the infrared and likely a background star or galaxy .
thus , the emission at far - ir and sub - mm wavelengths is expected to be dominated by the protostar or pre - main - sequence star , and we can assume that the seds are representative of the ysos even if the nearby sources can not be separated at these wavelengths .
there are a few ysos that have objects separated by just 1 - 3 and are only resolved in one or two irac bands ( hops 22 , 78 , 108 , 184 , 203 , 247 , 293 , 364 ) ; in these cases we used the flux at the irac position that most closely matched those at longer wavelengths .
we note that some of these very close `` companions '' are likely outflow knots .
there are also unresolved binaries , which appear as single sources even in the irac observations @xcite ; in these cases our seds show the combined flux in all wave bands . if two point sources are not fully resolved and the resulting blended source is elongated , no irac photometry was extracted . in such cases ,
a protostar may not have irac fluxes even though it was detected in the _ spitzer _ images .
there are also several protostars that lie close to other protostars : hops 66 and 370 ( @xmath15=14.9 ) , hops 76 and 78 ( @xmath15=14.1 ) , hops 86 and 87 ( @xmath15=12.1 ) , hops 117 and 118 ( @xmath15=13.7 ) , hops 121 and 123 ( @xmath15=7.6 ) , hops 124 and 125 ( @xmath15=9.8 ) , hops 165 and 203 ( @xmath15=13.3 ) , hops 175 and 176 ( @xmath15=8.0 ) , hops 181 and 182 ( @xmath15=10.2 ) , hops 225 and 226 ( @xmath15=9.2 ) , hops 239 and 241 ( @xmath15=12.4 ) , hops 262 and 263 ( @xmath15=6.3 ) , hops 316 and 358 ( @xmath15=6.9 ) , hops 332 and 390 ( @xmath15=11.2 ) , hops 340 and 341 ( @xmath15=4.7 ) , and hops 386 and 387 ( @xmath15=9.9 )
. hops 105 lies 8.7 to the north of an infrared - bright source , identified by @xcite as a young star with a protoplanetary disk .
this source is brighter than hops 105 in all _ spitzer _ bands and at 70 @xmath0 m , but it is well separated at all wavelengths .
a similar situation applies to hops 128 , which has a disk - dominated source 6.3 to the southeast . hops 108 is 6.6 from hops 64 , which is brighter than hops 108 out to 8 @xmath0 m , but not detected in the far - ir and sub - mm .
hops 108 also lies 16.6 from hops 369 and 28.2 from hops 370 . hops 140 has two neighboring sources , at 9.6 and 13.9 , that are likely surrounded by protoplanetary disks ; they are both brighter than hops 140 out to 8 @xmath0 m , but at 70 @xmath0 m and beyond hops 140 dominates .
hops 144 lies 7.9 from hops 377 ; there is also a somewhat fainter , red source 11.7 to the northeast , which is not detected beyond 24 @xmath0 m .
this source also lies 9.7 to the southwest of hops 143 .
hops 173 forms a small cluster with hops 174 ( at 7.1 ) and hops 380 ( at 11.4 ) ; hops 174 is the brightest source out to 24 @xmath0 m , but at 70 @xmath0 m hops 173 takes on this role . also hops 322 , 323 , and 389 form a group of protostars ; hops 322 lies 13.4 from hops 389 and 20.1 from hops 323 , while hops 323 and 389 are 10.2 apart .
hops 323 is the brightest source .
thus , there are 45 targets in our sample that have an object within 15that is bright in the mid- or far - ir and that is resolved with irac and mips . given that @xcite used psf photometry for the mips 24 @xmath0 m observations , they obtained reliable fluxes even for companions separated by less than 6 , the typical psf fwhm . for fluxes at 70 and 160 @xmath0 m
, we also used psf photometry for objects that were point sources , but too close for aperture photometry . in cases
where the fluxes could not be determined even with psf photometry , we had to adopt upper limits instead .
similarly , we performed psf photometry on protostars without companions , but contaminated by extended or filamentary emission ; if the psf photometry did not return a good fit , we used the flux value from aperture photometry as an upper limit .
since most of our targets have an irs spectrum , in addition to data points from irac at 5.8 and 8 and from mips at 24 , we can detect discrepancies if flux values at similar wavelengths , but from different instruments , do not agree .
they might be due to calibration or extraction problems in the irs spectrum ( for example , some extended emission around the target or a close companion ) , but also to variability .
we assumed the former scenario if the flux deviations between irs and irac and between irs and mips were similar ( and more than 10% , a conservative estimate for the typical calibration uncertainty ) , and in such cases scaled the irs spectrum to the mips 24 flux .
even though this scaling could mask actual variability , it creates a representative sed for the yso and yields an estimate of the protostellar parameters from model fits of the sed . in appendix [ variability ]
we identify potentially variable hops targets based on their mid - ir fluxes and find that about 5% of the protostars with irs , irac , and mips data could be variable . the young stellar object variability ( ysovar )
program , which monitored large samples of protostars and pre - main - sequence stars in nearby star - forming regions with _ spitzer _ at 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath0 m
@xcite , found that up to @xmath1 90% of flat - spectrum and class i ysos
are variable on a timescale of days , with typical changes in brightness of 10%-20% . on longer timescales ( years as opposed to days ) ,
20%-40% of members of young clusters show long - term variability , with the highest fraction for those clusters with more class i protostars @xcite . in orion ,
the fraction of variable class i protostars is @xmath1 85% @xcite . using a larger sample of protostars in orion and irac data at 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 , and 8.0 @xmath0 m
, @xcite found that , on a timescale of about 6 months , 60%-70% of orion protostars show brightness variabilities of @xmath1 20% , with some as high as a factor of four . thus , given that our seds consist of noncontemporaneous data sets , small flux discrepancies
should be common , but we also expect some protostars with large mismatches . one protostar with a large discrepancy between various data sets is hops 223 .
it is an outbursting protostar ( also known as v2775 ori ; @xcite ) , and for its sed we had 2mass , irac , and mips data from the pre - outburst phase available , while the irs spectrum , pacs , and apex data are from the post - outburst period .
thus , its sed does not represent an actual state of the object , and the derived @xmath8 and @xmath16 values are unreliable .
pre- and post - outburst seds and model fits for this protostar can be found in @xcite .
hops 223 is the only protostar with an sed affected by extreme variability .
a few more protostars , hops 71 , 132 , 143 , 228 , 274 , and 299 , show notable discrepancy between the irac and irs fluxes , and to a minor extent between mips 24 @xmath0 m and irs , and thus have somewhat unreliable seds and sed - derived parameters .
hops 383 , which was identified as an outbursting class 0 protostar by @xcite , does not appear variable in the sed presented here , since we adopted post - outburst irac 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath0 m fluxes obtained by the ysovar program @xcite to construct a representative post - outburst sed for this object .
the seds provide the means to determine @xmath16 , @xmath8 , and the 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral indices for our sample of protostars .
for measuring the near- to mid - ir sed slope ( @xmath17 ) , we chose a spectral index between 4.5 and 24 @xmath0 m to minimize the effect of extinction on the short - wavelength data point ; also , the irac 4.5 @xmath0 m fluxes for our hops targets are more complete than the irac 3.6 @xmath0 m fluxes due to the lower extinction at this wavelength . for calculating @xmath16 and @xmath8 , we used all available fluxes for each object , including the irs spectrum , assumed a distance of 420 pc , and used trapezoidal summation ; for @xmath8 , we applied the equation from @xcite .
figure [ hops_n_tbol_lbol_histo ] shows the distribution of @xmath18 , @xmath8 , and @xmath16 values for our targets . there is a peak in the distribution of spectral indices around 0 , while the distribution of @xmath8 values is relatively uniform from about 30 k to 800 k.
the bolometric luminosities cover a wide range , with a broad peak around 1 @xmath19 .
the median @xmath16 , @xmath8 , and @xmath18 values are 1.1 @xmath19 , 146 k , and 0.68 , respectively .
our distribution of @xmath16 values is very similar to the observed luminosity function of orion protostars presented in @xcite ; both distributions peak around 1 @xmath19 and include values from @xmath1 0.02 @xmath19 up to several hundred @xmath19 .
some differences between the two distributions are expected , given that @xcite only had _ spitzer _ 3.6 - 24 @xmath0 m data available and thus had to extrapolate @xmath16 from the measured near- to mid - infrared luminosity .
the main difference is a somewhat larger number of protostars with @xmath20 0.5 @xmath19 for the @xcite orion sample ; our median @xmath16 value amounts to 1.1 @xmath19 , while their value is 0.8 @xmath19 .
however , with the contaminating sources removed from their sample ( which tend to have lower luminosities ; see @xcite for details ) , their median bolometric luminosity and our value match .
overall , given that orion is considered a region of high - mass star formation , its luminosity function is similar to that of other regions where massive star forms @xcite , and it is different from that of low - mass star - forming regions such as taurus and ophiuchus @xcite . compared to the sample of 230 protostars in 18 different molecular clouds studied by @xcite , the observed ( i.e. , not extinction - corrected ) @xmath16 values of those protostars span from 0.01 to 69 @xmath19 , with a median value of 0.9 @xmath19 . however , given that almost half the protostars in the @xcite sample lack far - ir and sub - mm data , the true luminosities are likely higher , which would bring the median closer to the orion value .
finally , we note that the distribution of observed @xmath8 values from @xcite is similar to our distribution for orion protostars ; the median @xmath8 of their and our sample is 160 k and 146 k , respectively , and the bulk of their protostars also has @xmath8 values between 30 k and 1000 k , with a tail down to temperatures of @xmath1 10 k and another tail up to @xmath8=2700 k. m spectral index versus the bolometric temperature for the 330 ysos in our sample .
the dashed lines delineate the regions that define the various sed classes ( see text for details ) .
[ hops_n_tbol ] ] to separate our targets into class 0 , class i , class ii , and flat - spectrum sources , we used the 4.5 to 24 spectral index ( @xmath18 ) and/or bolometric temperature ( @xmath8 ) : class 0 protostars have @xmath21 and @xmath9 k , class i protostars have @xmath21 and @xmath22 k , flat - spectrum sources have @xmath23 , and class ii pre - main - sequence stars have @xmath24 .
based on this , we identify 92 targets as class 0 protostars , 125 as class i protostars , 102 as flat - spectrum sources , and 11 as class ii pre - main - sequence stars ( see table a[bestfit ] and figure [ hops_n_tbol ] ) .
there are nine protostars with @xmath8 values between 66.5 and 73.5 k ( which corresponds to a @xmath25 5% range around the class 0i boundary of 70 k ) ; six of them have @xmath8 @xmath26 70 k ( hops 1 , 18 , 186 , 256 , 322 , 370 ) , and the other three have @xmath8 values just below 70 k ( hops 75 , 250 , 361 ) .
these protostars classification is less firm than for the other hops targets .
there are also a few flat - spectrum sources whose classification is more uncertain : hops 45 , 183 , 192 , 194 , 210 , 264 , and 281 should be class i protostars based on their 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral index , but when considering the irs spectrum ( specifically , the 5 - 25 @xmath0 m spectral index ) , they fall into the flat - spectrum regime ( @xmath27 ) . also , for hops 45 and 194 the @xmath8 values are relatively high ( @xmath26 500 k ) .
similarly , hops 33 , 134 , 242 , 255 , and 284 should be class ii pre - main - sequence stars based on their 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral index , but the spectral slope over the irs wavelength range suggests that they are flat - spectrum sources . in these cases where the @xmath18 and @xmath28 spectral indices were somewhat discrepant , we adopted the latter , and thus these objects were classified as flat - spectrum sources .
there are five objects with @xmath8 @xmath29 70 k and @xmath18 @xmath29 0 ( hops 164 , 340 , 341 , 373 , 405 ) ; despite their negative 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m sed slopes , their seds either show or imply a deep silicate absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m , rise steeply in the mid- to far - ir , and their long - wavelength emission is strong .
thus , their @xmath8 values are low , and we identify them as class 0 protostars , even though they have 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral indices not typical of embedded protostars
. in particular , hops 341 , 373 , and 405 are likely young protostars with dense envelopes ( @xcite ; see also section [ class0 ] ) . in the case of hops 373 ,
the 4.5 @xmath0 m flux may be contaminated by bright h@xmath30 emission from an outflow shock , rendering the @xmath18 value more unreliable .
this might also explain the negative 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral index for the other four protostars .
finally , the few class ii objects in our sample were thought to be potential protostars prior to their observations with _
their 4.5 - 24 sed slopes are usually just slightly more negative than the cutoff for a flat - spectrum source ( @xmath4 ) ; three class ii pre - main - sequence stars ( hops 22 , 184 , 201 ) have seds that are typical of disks with inner holes , displaying a 10 @xmath0 m silicate emission feature and a rising sed from 12 to about 20 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the seds of the other class ii objects are similar to those of flat - spectrum sources ; thus , they could have ( remnant ) envelopes that contribute to their long - wavelength emission .
our hops sample is mostly complete in the number of class 0 , class i , and flat - spectrum sources in the areas of orion surveyed by _
spitzer _ excluding the orion nebula ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
of the 357 unique ysos originally identified in _ spitzer _
data that were included in the hops sample and observed with pacs , 322 were detected at least at 70 @xmath0 m , which amounts to a fraction of 90% .
we removed likely contaminants and added 16 new protostars discovered in pacs data to get to our sample of 330 ysos , most of which are protostars .
our lowest @xmath16 source is hops 208 , with @xmath16= 0.017 @xmath19 .
this protostar also has the lowest pacs 70 @xmath0 m flux in our sample ( 8.2 mjy ) .
overall , our sample has 27 protostars with @xmath31 0.1 @xmath19 , which places them in the luminosity range of very low luminosity objects ( vellos ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the number of vellos in our sample is likely larger , given that vellos are defined as having internal luminosities less than 0.1 @xmath19 , and the bolometric luminosity has contributions from both the internal luminosity and that due to external heating ( see * ? ? ?
in addition , our sample could miss fainter flat - spectrum sources and class 0 and class i protostars .
in fact , there are several faint ysos without pacs data that were excluded from our sample , but do have _ spitzer _ detections ( see appendix section [ ysos_not_modeled ] ) .
to characterize the seds of our hops sample in a uniform manner , we fit the data to simple but physically plausible models . in this way
we can assess how well such simple models can fit the data , and how the quality of the fits changes with evolutionary class .
we can also determine the full range of physical parameters implied by the fits and the range of parameters for each protostellar class .
there are degeneracies and biases in the fits , and the uncertainties in model parameters will vary from object to object , but our results represent a first step in estimating physical parameters that describe the protostars in our sample .
we use a large model grid calculated using the 2008 version of the @xcite monte carlo radiative transfer code ( see * ? ? ?
* ) ; an early version of the grid was presented in @xcite .
each model consists of a central protostar , a circumstellar disk , and an envelope ; the radiation released by the star and the accretion is reprocessed by the disk and envelope . the density in the disk
is described by power laws in the radial and vertical directions , while the density distribution in the envelope corresponds to that of a rotating , collapsing cloud core with constant infall rate ( the so - called tsc model , after @xcite ; see also @xcite ) .
the envelope also contains an outflow cavity , whose walls are assumed to follow a polynomial shape . at favorable inclination angles , this evacuated cavity allows radiation from the inner envelope and disk regions to reach the observer directly .
also , radiation is scattered off the cavity walls and can increase the near - ir emission from a protostellar system .
years of coagulation with a gas density of 10@xmath32 @xmath33 from @xcite ( _ orange _ ) ; case a model of carbon and silicate dust for r@xmath34=5.5 from @xcite ( _ green _ ) ; two extinction curves derived for star - forming regions by @xcite , one for @xmath35 ( _ blue _ ) , and one for @xmath36 ( _ purple _ ) .
[ opacities ] ] we used dust opacities from @xcite to account for larger , icy grains ( as opposed to the small grains made of amorphous silicates typically found in the interstellar medium ) .
we adopted their dust model that includes graphite grains without ice coating and ice - coated silicates , with a size distribution that assumes growth of aggregates for @xmath37 years , when grains have grown up to 3 @xmath0 m in size ( `` icsgra3 '' ) .
particle sizes range from 0.1 to 3 @xmath0 m , with a number density that is roughly proportional to @xmath38 ( where @xmath39 is the particle radius ) .
figure [ opacities ] shows our adopted opacities compared to different ones found in the literature .
the opacities from @xcite assume a mixture of small carbonaceous and amorphous silicate grains .
including larger and icy grains broadens the 10 @xmath0 m silicate feature ( which is mostly due to the libration mode of water ice ) and causes additional absorption at 3 @xmath0 m and in the 40 - 60 @xmath0 m range ( all mostly due to the presence of water ice ) .
the mid - ir opacities of the `` icsgra3 '' dust model are similar to the ones determined by @xcite for star - forming regions and also to those used by @xcite to model an edge - on class 0 protostar ; in the mid- to far - ir , they resemble the opacities of @xcite , which are often used to model embedded sources . in figure
[ opacities ] , we show model ` oh5 ' from @xcite , which is listed as the fifth model in their table 1 and corresponds to grains with thin ice mantles after 10@xmath40 years of coagulation and a gas density of 10@xmath32 @xmath33 .
we could not use the ` oh5 ' opacities for our model grid , since that opacity law does not include scattering properties ( which are required by the whitney monte carlo radiative transfer code ) .
other authors have modified the ` oh5 ' dust to include the scattering cross section and extend the opacities to shorter and longer wavelengths @xcite .
there are 3040 models in the grid ; they cover 8 values for the total ( i.e. , intrinsic ) luminosity , 4 disk radii , 19 envelope infall rates ( which correspond to envelope densities ) , and 5 cavity opening angles .
each model is calculated for 10 different inclination angles , from 18.2 to 87.2 , in equal steps in @xmath41 ( starting at 0.95 and ending at 0.05 ) , resulting in 30,400 different model seds .
the values for the various model parameters are listed in table [ modelpars ] . since there are a large number of parameters that can be set in the whitney radiative transfer models , we focused on varying those parameters that affect the sed the most , leaving the other parameters at some typical values .
for example , we assumed a stellar mass of 0.5 @xmath42 , a disk mass of 0.05 @xmath42 , and an envelope outer radius of 10,000 au .
the stellar mass enters the code in two ways .
first , it is needed to relate the density of the envelope to the infall rate ( see equation 1 below ) .
since we fit the density of the envelope , the infall rate plays no role in the best - fit envelope parameters ; any stellar mass can be chosen to determine the infall rate for a given best - fit envelope density .
second , the stellar mass is combined with the stellar radius and disk accretion rate to set the disk accretion luminosity . given that the accretion luminosity is the actual parameter that influences the sed , it does not matter which of the three factors is varied . for simplicity and reasons described below
, we varied the disk accretion rate and the stellar radius , but left the stellar mass constant , to achieve different values for this component of the luminosity .
the total luminosity for each system consists of the stellar luminosity ( derived from a 4000 k stellar atmosphere model ) , the accretion luminosity resulting from material accreting through the disk down to the disk truncation radius , and the accretion luminosity from the hot spots on the stellar surface , where the accretion columns , which start at the magnetospheric truncation radius , land ( these columns are not included in the modeled density distribution , since they do not contain dust and do not have a source of opacity in the radiative transfer models ) .
typically , the accretion luminosity from the hot spots is much larger than the disk accretion luminosity ; in our models , the former is about a factor of 9 larger than the latter .
we chose three different stellar radii , 0.67 , 2.09 , and 6.61 @xmath43 ( with the same stellar temperature ) , resulting in three different stellar luminosities .
since both components of the accretion luminosity depend on the disk accretion rate , choosing a total of eight different disk accretion rates ( three for the 0.67 @xmath43 star , two for the 2.09 @xmath43 star , and three for the 6.61 @xmath43 star ) results in eight values for the total luminosity used in the grid ( see table [ modelpars ] ) . the input spectrum produced by the central protostar depends on the relative contributions from the intrinsic stellar luminosity ( which peaks at 0.7 @xmath0 m ) and the accretion luminosity ( which is radiated primarily in the uv ) . in the models
, it can be altered to some degree by choosing different combinations of the disk accretion rate and stellar radius ( the former affects only the accretion luminosity , while the latter affects both the stellar and accretion luminosity ) .
however , the effect of the input spectrum on the output sed is negligible .
consequently , we can not reliably measure the relative contributions of stellar and accretion luminosity through our sed fits .
instead , we adjusted the particular values for the stellar radius and disk accretion rate to set the values of the total luminosity . for our model grid , we chose four values for the disk outer radius , which we set equal to the centrifugal radius ( @xmath44 ) . in a tsc model ,
the centrifugal radius is the position in the disk where material falling in from the envelope accumulates ; due to envelope rotation , material from the envelope s equatorial plane lands at @xmath44 , while material from higher latitudes falls closer to the star .
the disk could extend beyond @xmath44 , but in our models it ends at @xmath44 . in this work ,
we use the terms `` disk ( outer ) radius '' and `` centrifugal radius '' interchangeably .
the primary effect of @xmath44 is to set the rotation rate of the infalling gas and thereby determine the density structure of the envelope @xcite .
clcc + @xmath45 & stellar mass & 0.5 & @xmath42 + @xmath46 & stellar effective temperature & 4000 & k + @xmath47 & stellar radius & 0.67 , 2.09 , 6.61 & @xmath43 + + @xmath48 & disk mass & 0.05 & @xmath42 + @xmath49 & disk outer radius & 5 , 50 , 100 , 500 & au + a & radial exponent in disk density law & 2.25 & + b & vertical exponent in disk density law & 1.25 & + @xmath50 & disk - to - star accretion rate for @xmath51=0.67 @xmath43 & 0 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 & @xmath42 yr@xmath54 + @xmath55 & disk - to - star accretion rate for @xmath51=2.09 @xmath43 & @xmath56 , @xmath57 & @xmath42 yr@xmath54 + @xmath58 & disk - to - star accretion rate for @xmath51=6.61 @xmath43 & @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 & @xmath42 yr@xmath54 + @xmath62 & magnetospheric truncation radius@xmath63 & 3 & @xmath47 + @xmath64 & fractional area of the hot spots on the star@xmath65 & 0.01 & + + @xmath66 & envelope outer radius@xmath67 & 10,000 & au + @xmath68 & envelope density at 1000 au@xmath69 & 0.0 , 1.19 @xmath70 , 1.78 @xmath70 , 2.38 @xmath70 , & g @xmath33 + & & 5.95 @xmath70 , 1.19 @xmath71 , 1.78 @xmath71 , & g @xmath33 + & & 2.38 @xmath71 , 5.95 @xmath71 , 1.19 @xmath72 , & g @xmath33 + & & 1.78 @xmath72 , 2.38 @xmath72 , 5.95 @xmath72 , & g @xmath33 + & & 1.19 @xmath73 , 1.78 @xmath73 , 2.38 @xmath73 , & g @xmath33 + & & 5.95 @xmath73 , 1.19 @xmath74 , 1.78 @xmath74 & g @xmath33 + @xmath44 & centrifugal radius of tsc envelope & @xmath75 & au + @xmath76 & cavity opening angle & 5 , 15 , 25 , 35 , 45 & degrees + @xmath77 & exponent for cavity shape@xmath78 ( polynomial ) & 1.5 & + @xmath79 & vertical offset of cavity wall & 0 & au + + @xmath80 & stellar luminosity@xmath81 & 0.1 , 1 , 10 & @xmath19 + @xmath82 & total luminosity ( star + accretion)@xmath83 & 0.1 , 0.3 , 1.0 , 3.1 , 10.1 , 30.2 , 101 , 303 & @xmath19 + + @xmath84 & inclination angle & 18.2 , 31.8 , 41.4 , 49.5 , 56.7 , & degrees + & & 63.3 , 69.5 , 75.6 , 81.4 , 87.2 & degrees + & aperture radii for model fluxes@xmath85 & 420 , 840 , 1260 , 1680 , ... , 10080 & au + the largest number of parameter values in our grid is for the envelope infall rate . the envelope infall rate used as an input in the whitney code sets the density of the envelope for a given mass of the protostar . since the sed depends on the density of the envelope ( and not directly on the infall rate , which is only inferred from the density and the acceleration due to gravity from the central protostar ) , in this work we report a reference envelope density instead of the envelope infall rate as one of our model parameters .
for the tsc model , the envelope infall rate @xmath86 and the reference density at 1 au in the limit of no rotation ( @xmath44=0 ) are related as follows ( see * ? ? ?
* ) : @xmath87 where @xmath45 is the mass of the central protostar , which is assumed to be 0.5 @xmath42 in our model grid .
the density distribution in the envelope follows a power law , @xmath88 , at radii larger than the centrifugal radius , @xmath44 , but then flattens as a result of the rotation of the envelope .
the density reported by @xmath89 assumes a spherically symmetric envelope with a @xmath90 power - law exponent valid down to the smallest radii , and it is higher than the angle - averaged density of a rotating envelope at 1 au . to quote densities that are closer to actual values found in the modeled rotating envelopes ( which have @xmath44 values ranging from 5 to 500 au )
, we report @xmath68 , the density at 1000 au for a @xmath88 envelope with a 0.5 @xmath42 protostar : @xmath91 thus , the range of reference densities probed in our model grid , from @xmath92 to @xmath93 g @xmath33 ( see table [ modelpars ] ) , would correspond to envelope infall rates from @xmath94 to @xmath95 @xmath42 yr@xmath54 , assuming @xmath45=0.5 @xmath42 ( this does not account for a reduction of the infalling mass due to clearing by outflow cavities ) . in figure [ rho_env_profiles ]
, we show the radial density profiles for two tsc models with 5 au and 500 au centrifugal radii .
the density profiles are azimuthally symmetric and show the flattening of the density distribution inside @xmath44 due to envelope rotation .
these plots demonstrate that the density @xmath89 is much higher than the angle - averaged density at 1 au ; @xmath68 seems to yield more physical values for the density in the envelope at 1000 au , even for @xmath44 values of 500 au . as can be seen from the values of the envelope density in table [ modelpars ] ,
there is one set of models with an envelope density of 0 .
these are models that do not contain an envelope component ; the entire excess emission is caused by the circumstellar disk .
if an object is best fit by such a model , it would indicate that it is more evolved , having already dispersed its envelope .
: 5 , 25 , and 45 ( from left to right ) .
the cavity walls are defined as a polynomial with exponent 1.5 ( @xmath96 ) , with @xmath97 , and are shown as solid lines .
the outer envelope radius ( @xmath66 ) at 10,000 au is shown with a short - dashed line .
the dotted lines show a different definition of the cavity size , where @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
[ cavity_shape ] ] the cavities in our models range from 5 to 45 and are defined such that @xmath96 , where @xmath100 and @xmath101 are the cylindrical coordinates for the radial and vertical direction , respectively , and @xmath102 , with @xmath76 defined as the cavity opening angle that is specified in the parameter file of the whitney radiative transfer code . in this code , @xmath103 is set to the envelope outer radius .
thus , a polynomial - shaped cavity , which is wider at smaller @xmath100 values and then converges toward the specified opening angle , is somewhat larger than this opening angle at the outer envelope radius ( see figure [ cavity_shape ] ) .
this effect is most noticeable at larger cavity opening angles , but negligible for small cavities . a different definition of the cavity size , where @xmath98 and @xmath99 ( with @xmath66 as the envelope outer radius ) , results in @xmath101 values that are a factor of @xmath104 larger , and thus the cavity reaches the specified opening angle at the outer envelope radius .
for this work , the adopted definition of the cavity opening angle is inconsequential , but it becomes relevant when comparing the results of sed modeling to scattered light images that reveal the actual cavity shape and size .
we also note that in our models the cavities are evacuated of material , so there is no dust and gas inside the cavity ; in reality , there might be some low - density material left that would add to the scattered light ( see * ? ? ?
figures [ models_inc ] to [ models_ltot ] display a few examples of model seds from our grid to show the effect of changing those model parameters that influence the resulting sed the most .
the inclination angle has a strong effect on the near- and mid - infrared sed ( figure [ models_inc ] ) .
while a low inclination angle results in an overall flat sed in this wavelength region , increasing the inclination angle causes a deeper silicate absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m and a steep slope beyond it .
the far - infrared to millimeter sed is not affected by the inclination angle , since emission at these wavelengths does not suffer from extinction through the envelope .
= 10.1 @xmath19 , @xmath44=50 au , @xmath68=@xmath105 g @xmath33 , @xmath76=15 , and is seen at inclination angles 18 , 32 , 41 , 49 , 57 , 63 , 69 , 76 , 81 , and 87 ( from top to bottom ) . [ models_inc ] ] = 10.1 @xmath19 , @xmath44=50 au , @xmath68=@xmath105 g @xmath33 , i=63 , but each has a different cavity opening angle : 5 ( _ red _ ) , 15 ( _ yellow _ ) , 25 ( _ green _ ) , 35 ( _ blue _ ) , 45 ( _ purple _ ) . [ models_cavity ] ] ) on the sed . the models have @xmath82=10.1 @xmath19 , @xmath68=@xmath105 g @xmath33 , @xmath76=5 , i=63 , but different disk radii : 5 au ( _ red _ ) , 50 au ( _ yellow _ ) , 100 au ( _ green _ ) , 500 au ( _ purple _ ) . [ models_rdisk ] ] the cavity opening angle affects the sed shape at all wavelengths ( figure [ models_cavity ] ) .
a small cavity only minimally alters the sed compared to a case without a cavity ; there is still a deep silicate absorption at 10 @xmath0 m and steep sed slope , but the cavity allows some scattered light to escape in the near - ir . a larger cavity results in higher emission at near- and mid - infrared wavelengths and reduced emission in the far - infrared .
the effect of the cavity on the sed would change if a different shape for the cavity walls were adopted .
for example , cavities where the outer wall follows the streamlines of the infalling gas and dust evacuate less inner envelope material than our polynomial - shaped cavities , resulting in deeper silicate absorption features and steeper mid - infrared sed slopes for the same cavity opening angle ( see * ? ? ? * ) .
thus , our cavity opening angles are tied to our assumed cavity shape .
= 10.1 @xmath19 , @xmath44=50 au , @xmath76=15 , i=63 , but different reference densities @xmath68 : 0 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , @xmath108 , @xmath105 , @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 g @xmath33 ( the peak of the sed moves to longer wavelengths as @xmath68 increases ) . [ models_density ] ] = 50 au , @xmath68= @xmath105 g @xmath33 , @xmath76=15 , i=63 , but different values for the total luminosity : 0.1 , 0.3 , 1.0 , 3.1 , 10.1 , 30.2 , 101 , and 303 @xmath19 ( from bottom to top ) . [ models_ltot ] ] the effect of the centrifugal radius is somewhat similar to those of the cavity opening angle and inclination angle , but less pronounced ( figure [ models_rdisk ] ) .
small disk radii imply more slowly rotating , less flattened envelopes and depress the near- and mid - infrared fluxes more than larger disk radii , but even with large disk radii ( and more flattened envelopes ) there is still sufficient envelope material along the line of sight to cause a pronounced 10 @xmath0 m absorption feature .
overall , our models do not directly constrain the size of the disk ; the opacity is dominated by the envelope .
furthermore , the flattening of the envelope that is determined by @xmath44 has a similar effect on the sed as changing the outflow cavity opening angle .
changing the envelope density causes shifts in the sed in terms of both wavelength and flux level : the higher the envelope density , the less flux is emitted at shorter wavelengths , and the more the peak of the sed shifts to longer wavelengths ( figure [ models_density ] ) . deeply embedded protostars have seds that peak at @xmath113 100 @xmath0 m , steep mid - ir sed slopes , and deep silicate absorption features .
the effect of the envelope density on the sed is different from that of the inclination angle , especially in the far - ir : while the sed is not very sensitive to the inclination angle in this wavelength region , the ratio of , e.g. , 70 and 160 @xmath0 m fluxes changes considerably depending on the envelope density .
the total luminosity of the source has an effect on the overall emission level of the protostar , but does not strongly affect the sed shape .
the main effect is that the peak of the sed shifts to longer wavelengths as the luminosity decreases ( @xmath114 ; @xcite ) .
especially when comparing models with @xmath82 values that differ by a factor of a few , the sed shapes are similar ( figure [ models_ltot ] ) .
thus , one could scale a particular model by a factor between @xmath1 0.5 and 2 and get a good representation of a protostar that is somewhat fainter or brighter , without having to rerun the model calculation with the different input luminosity .
the model fluxes are computed for 24 different apertures , ranging from 420 to 10,080 au in steps of 420 au ( which corresponds to 1 at the assumed distance of 420 pc to the orion star - forming complex ) . for these sed fluxes , no convolution with a psf
is done , and therefore the spatial distribution of the flux is solely due to the extended nature of protostars .
since the envelope outer radius is chosen to be 10,000 au , the largest aperture encompasses the entire flux emitted by each protostellar system .
however , most of the near- and mid - infrared emission comes from smaller spatial scales , so an aperture of about 5000 au will already capture most of the flux emitted at these wavelengths . for a more accurate comparison of observed and model fluxes , in each infrared photometric band where we have data available , we interpolate model fluxes from the two apertures that bracket the aperture used in measuring the observed fluxes ( 4 for 2mass , 24 for irac , psf photometry for mips 24 , with a typical fwhm of 6 , 96 for pacs 70 and 100 , 128 for pacs 160 ) . for the irs data points , we use fluxes interpolated for a 53 aperture , since the spectra
are composed of two segments , sl ( 5.2 - 14 ; slit width of 36 ) and ll ( 14 - 38 , slit width of 105 ) , and , if any flux mismatches were present , the sl segment was typically scaled to match the ll flux level at 14 ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
so , fluxes measured in an aperture with a radius of 53 roughly correspond to fluxes from a 106-wide slit .
m fluxes versus aperture radius derived for a model ( @xmath115 @xmath19 , @xmath116 au , @xmath117 g @xmath33 , @xmath76=15 , @xmath118 ) using different methods .
the black symbols represent fluxes from the model sed , the blue symbols fluxes derived using aperture photometry on the model image convolved with the pacs 160 @xmath0 m psf , and the red symbols fluxes derived from the convolved model image and then corrected for psf losses ( see text for details ) .
the maximum flux from the model sed was used to normalize all other fluxes .
the dotted line indicates an aperture radius of 128 .
[ model_fluxes_pacs160 ] ] given that our targets are typically extended and that the near- to mid - infrared data have relatively high spatial resolution , measuring fluxes in small apertures ( a few arcseconds in radius ) will truncate some of the object s flux , so it is important to choose similar apertures for the model fluxes . from about 30 to 100 @xmath0 m , the model fluxes calculated for smaller apertures are not very different from the total flux ( i.e. , the flux from the largest aperture ) , which is a result of the emission profile in the envelope and the lower spatial resolution at longer wavelengths .
to check whether extended source emission in the far - infrared might affect the flux we measure in our models , we calculated a small set of model images at 160 @xmath0 m , convolved them with the pacs 160 @xmath0 m psf , and compared the fluxes from the model images to those written out for the model seds ( which we refer to as `` sed fluxes '' ; these are the fluxes from the models in the grid ) .
model images would be the most observationally consistent way to measure the flux densities , but they are too computationally expensive and would not represent a significant gain .
m ) fluxes versus aperture radius derived for the same model as in figure [ model_fluxes_pacs160 ] using different methods .
the black symbols represent fluxes from the model sed , the blue symbols fluxes derived using aperture photometry on the model image convolved with a gaussian psf , and the red dot - dashed line the beam flux ( assuming a beam with a fwhm of 73 ) .
the maximum flux from the model sed was used to normalize all other fluxes .
the dotted line indicates an aperture radius of 365 .
[ model_fluxes_saboca ] ] in figure [ model_fluxes_pacs160 ] we show the fluxes derived for a particular model at 160 @xmath0 m using different methods .
the fluxes measured in the convolved model image are lower than the sed fluxes ; this is caused by the wide pacs 160 @xmath0 m psf , which spreads flux to very large radii .
since the shape of the psf is known , we can correct for these psf losses ( assuming a point source and using standard aperture corrections ) .
the fluxes corrected for these psf losses are very similar to the sed fluxes , typically within @xmath1 5 - 10% at apertures larger than 5 .
since our observed fluxes correspond to these psf - corrected fluxes ( we apply aperture corrections to our fluxes measured in a 128 aperture to account for psf losses ) , adopting the sed fluxes from the largest aperture would yield model fluxes that are somewhat too high .
thus , we chose to adopt the sed flux measured in a 128 aperture as a good approximation for the model flux we would get if we had model images available for all models in the grid and measured aperture - corrected fluxes in these images .
we note that in our pacs data , the 160 @xmath0 m sky annulus , which extends from 128 to 256 ( see b. ali et al .
2016 , in preparation ) , can include extended emission from surrounding material and also some envelope emission . in these cases ,
we often used psf photometry to minimize contamination from nearby sources and nebulosity ; however , psf fitting was not used for more isolated sources since the envelopes can be marginally resolved at 160 @xmath0 m and thus deviate slightly from the adopted psf shape . , but for the laboca ( 870 @xmath0 m ) fluxes .
the dotted line indicates an aperture radius of 95 .
[ model_fluxes_laboca ] ] for the saboca and laboca data , beam fluxes were adopted ; the fwhm of the saboca beam is 73 , while for the laboca beam it is 19 .
in order to determine which aperture radius corresponds best to beam fluxes , we created a similar set of model images as above at 350 and 870 @xmath0 m , convolved them with gaussian psfs , and measured fluxes in the model images using different apertures ( see figures [ model_fluxes_saboca ] and [ model_fluxes_laboca ] , where we show the results for one model ) .
fluxes measured in the convolved model image are smaller than the sed fluxes , especially at aperture radii smaller than the fwhm of the beam .
we find that the beam fluxes for saboca and laboca are best matched by sed fluxes from apertures with radii half the size of the fwhm of the beam , i.e. , 365 for saboca and 95 for laboca ( thus , the aperture sizes are the same as the beam fwhm ) .
this is again an idealized situation , since the measured saboca and laboca beam fluxes also include extended emission ( if the source lies on top of background emission ) , and thus they could be higher than those from the model . in our models ,
the luminosity is determined by the central protostar and the accretion ; no external heating is included .
the interstellar radiation field ( isrf ) could increase the temperature in the outer envelope regions , thus causing an increase in the longer - wavelength fluxes .
it is expected that external heating has a noticeable effect only on low - luminosity sources ( @xmath119 1 @xmath19 ) , while objects with strong internal heating are not affected by the isrf . moreover , the strength of the isrf varies spatially @xcite , and thus its effect on each individual protostar is uncertain . nonetheless , in the following we estimate the effect of external heating on model fluxes by using a different set of models . for this model calculation
, we used the 2012 version of the whitney radiative transfer code @xcite , which allows for the inclusion of external illumination by using the isrf value in the solar neighborhood from @xcite ; to vary the isrf strength , the adopted value can be scaled by a multiplicative factor and extinguished by a certain amount of foreground extinction .
we calculated a small number of models with and without external heating and then compared their far - infrared and submillimeter fluxes .
one set of models has @xmath82=0.1 @xmath19 , @xmath44=100 au , @xmath76=15 , and four different reference densities @xmath68 , ranging from 2.4 @xmath73 g @xmath33 to 2.4 @xmath70 g @xmath33 .
the other set has the same parameters except for @xmath82 , which is 1.0 @xmath19 .
we calculated models without external heating , with heating from an isrf equal to that in the solar neighborhood , and with isrf heating 10 times the solar neighborhood value .
for these models , we did not include any foreground extinction for the isrf ; thus , the isrf heating in these models can be considered an upper limit especially the 10-fold increase over the isrf in the solar neighborhood represents an extreme value .
figure [ models_ext_heat ] shows a few examples of model seds with and without external heating .
external heating results in flux increases in the far - ir and sub - mm ; as expected , it affects low - luminosity sources more , and its effects are also more noticeable for higher - density envelopes . for a more quantitative comparison of model fluxes in the far - ir and sub - mm , we computed the fluxes for each model in six different bands , those of mips 24 @xmath0 m , pacs 70 , 100 , and 160 @xmath0 m , and saboca ( 350 @xmath0 m ) and laboca ( 870 @xmath0 m ) , using apertures as described in section [ model_ap ] .
the model fluxes are affected by poorer signal - to - noise ratios at the longest wavelengths , so the 870 @xmath0 m fluxes are less reliable .
we subtracted the fluxes of the models without external heating ( @xmath120 ) from those with external heating ( @xmath121 ) to determine the flux excess due to external heating .
the ratios of these excess fluxes and the model fluxes with external heating ( @xmath122 ) are shown in figure [ models_ext_heat_ratios ] .
given that these ratios depend on the inclination angle to the line of sight , we show them as average values for all 10 inclination angles as well as the range subtended by all inclination angles .
we note overall smaller flux ratios at 350 @xmath0 m due to the smaller aperture size chosen in this wave band ( see section [ model_ap ] ) .
our analysis shows that heating by the isrf results in flux increases in the far - ir and sub - mm that are about a factor of 2 - 3 higher for envelopes of low - luminosity sources ( @xmath82=0.1 @xmath19 ) than for those with higher luminosity .
also , the effect of external heating is more noticeable at longer wavelengths ( where apertures / beams are also larger ) than at shorter ones ; given our chosen apertures , the largest effect occurs at 160 and 870 @xmath0 m .
we also note that the flux increases due to heating by the isrf are smallest for the lowest @xmath68 value probed , 2.4 @xmath70 g @xmath33 ; at 160 @xmath0 m , the flux increase is largest for intermediate envelope densities .
finally , the flux increases in the far - ir and sub - mm are far larger for a solar - neighborhood isrf scaled by factor of 10 than for an unscaled isrf ; for the @xmath82=0.1 @xmath19 models , an unscaled isrf increases the fluxes from a few percent ( at @xmath119 100 @xmath0 m ) to 50% ( at 870 @xmath0 m ) , while an isrf scaled by a factor of 10 increases these fluxes by 30%-75% .
thus , for low - luminosity protostars , up to @xmath1 75% of a protostar s 870 @xmath0 m flux could be due to external heating , if the environment is dominated by an extremely strong isrf . to estimate how the contribution of external heating would modify derived model parameters , in figures [ ext_heat_sed1 ] and [ ext_heat_sed2 ] we compare model seds that include external heating by an isrf 10 times stronger than in the solar neighborhood and model seds without this additional heating . for the latter , we used models from our model grid and tried to reproduce the seds with external heating . for the models with @xmath82=0.1 @xmath19
, the effect of external heating can be reproduced by increasing the luminosity by factors of a few , increasing @xmath68 by up to an order of magnitude , and increasing the cavity opening angle and inclination angle by a small amount . for the @xmath82=1.0 @xmath19 models , just increasing the reference density by a factor of 2.5 results in a good match to the long - wavelength emission of our externally heated models ; however , the shorter - wavelength flux is either under- or overestimated .
a better match is achieved with models having the same reference density as the externally heated models , but with slightly larger cavity opening angles and inclination angles , and luminosities about a factor of 2 larger .
thus , if the far - ir and sub - mm fluxes were contaminated by emission resulting from extremely strong external heating , a model fit using models from our grid ( which does not include external heating ) could overestimate the envelope density by up to an order of magnitude and the luminosity by a factor of 2 - 5 .
the cavity opening and inclination angles would also be more uncertain , but not by much . for
a more realistic scenario with more modest external heating ( which would also include the effect of local extinction ) , the effect on model parameters would be smaller .
= 0.1 @xmath19 , @xmath44=100 au , @xmath76=15 , @xmath68=2.4 @xmath72 g @xmath33 , @xmath84=63 , without external heating ( _ black _ ) , with external heating by an isrf 10 times stronger than in the solar neighborhood ( _ orange _ to _ brown _ , _ dashed lines _ ) and different amounts of extinction applied to the isrf ( from @xmath123 to @xmath124 , _ top _ to _ bottom _ ) .
[ models_ext_heat_av ] ] for the latter point , we explored the effect of extinction on the isrf by calculating a few more models with @xmath82=0.1 @xmath19 , @xmath44=100 au , @xmath76=15 , @xmath125 g @xmath33 , an isrf 10 times stronger than that in the solar neighborhood , and @xmath126 values for the isrf of 2.5 , 10 , 20 , and 50 .
the model seds are shown in figure [ models_ext_heat_av ] .
compared to isrf heating without any foreground extinction , already @xmath127 causes a decrease by a factor of 1.5 - 2 in the overall emission at far - ir wavelengths . with @xmath126 of 10 and 20 , the far - ir emission decreases by factors of up to @xmath1 3.5 and 4 , respectively , compared to a strong isrf that is not extinguished .
the fraction of excess emission due to external heating at 160 @xmath0 m decreases from an average of 0.8 for @xmath126=0 ( see figure [ models_ext_heat_ratios ] ) to 0.6 , 0.3 , and 0.2 for @xmath126=2.5 , 10 , and 20 , respectively .
therefore , considering that typical @xmath126 values in orion are @xmath1 10 - 20 mag @xcite , it is likely that the effect of external heating on model parameters of low - luminosity sources does not exceed a factor of @xmath1 2 in luminosity and @xmath1 5 in envelope density .
a customized fitting routine determines the best - fit model from the grid for each object in our sample of 330 ysos ( see sections [ sample ] and [ seds ] ) using both photometry and , where available , irs spectroscopy .
ideally , an object has 2mass , irac , irs , mips , pacs , and saboca and laboca data ; in many cases , no submillimeter data are available , and in a few cases the object is too faint to be detected by 2mass . of the 330 modeled objects , 40 do not have irs spectra . as a minimum ,
objects have some _ spitzer _ photometry and a measured flux value in the pacs 70 @xmath0 m band .
no additional data from the literature were included in the fits to keep them homogeneous . in order to reduce the number of data points contained in the irs spectral wavelength range ( such that the spectrum does not dominate over the photometry ) and to exclude ice absorption features in the 5 - 8 region and at 15.2 that are usually observed , but not included in the model opacities , we rebin each irs spectrum to fluxes at 16 wavelengths .
these data points trace the continuum emission and the 10 and 20 silicate features .
also , when rebinning the spectrum , we smooth over its noisy regions , and we scale the whole spectrum to match the mips 24 flux if a similar deviation is also seen at the irac 5.8 and 8 bands and is larger than 10% . figure [ irs_rebin ] shows three examples of our irs spectra with the rebinned fluxes overplotted .
our selection of 16 irs data points in addition to at most 13 photometric points spread from 1.1 to 870 puts more emphasis on the mid - ir spectral region in the fits .
this wavelength region is better sampled by observations , most of the emission is thermal radiation from the protostellar envelope and disk ( as opposed to some possible inclusion of scattered light or thermal emission from surrounding material at shorter and longer wavelengths , respectively ) , and it contains the 10 silicate feature , which crucially constrains the sed fits . as a result , most models are expected to reproduce the mid - ir fluxes well and might fit more poorly in the near - ir and sub - mm . ] to directly compare observed and model fluxes , we create model seds with data points that correspond to those obtained from observations , from both photometry and irs spectroscopy . for the former ,
the model fluxes are not only derived from the same apertures as the data ( see section [ model_ap ] ) , but also integrated over the various filter bandpasses , thus yielding model photometry . for the latter
, the model fluxes are interpolated at the same 16 wavelength values as the irs spectra .
since the model grid contains a limited number of values for the total luminosity ( eight ) , but the objects we intend to fit have luminosities that likely do not correspond precisely to these values , we include scaling factors for the luminosity when determining the best - fit model .
as long as these scaling factors are not far from unity , they are expected to yield seds that are very similar to those obtained from models using the scaled luminosity value as one of the input parameters .
the scaling factor can also be related to the distance of the source ; for all model fluxes , a distance of 420 pc is assumed , but in reality the protostars in our sample span a certain ( presumably small ) range of distances along the line of sight . for example , a 10% change in distance would result in a @xmath1 20% change in flux values ( scaling factors of 0.83 or 1.23 ) . here
we report luminosities assuming a distance of 420 pc .
in addition to scaling factors , each model sed can be extinguished to account for interstellar extinction along the line of sight .
we use two foreground extinction laws from @xcite that were derived for star - forming regions : one applies to @xmath128 ( or @xmath129 ) , and the other one to @xmath130 ( or @xmath131 ) . for @xmath132
, we use a spline fit to the mathis @xmath133 curve @xcite .
since the three laws apply to different extinction environments , we use a linear combination of them to achieve a smooth change in the extinction law from the diffuse interstellar medium to the dense regions within molecular clouds .
thus , to find a best - fit model for a certain observed sed , the model fluxes @xmath134 are scaled and extinguished as follows : @xmath135 where @xmath136 and @xmath134 are the observed and model fluxes , respectively , @xmath137 is the luminosity scaling factor , and @xmath138 is the extinction at wavelength @xmath139 .
we use three reddening laws , @xmath140 ; by denoting them with the subscripts 1 , 2 , and 3 , @xmath138 in the above equation becomes @xmath141 thus , equation [ f_scaled_ext ] can be written as @xmath142 these are linear equations in @xmath143 , with the left - hand side of the equations as the dependent variables and @xmath144 as the independent variable .
for each regime of @xmath143 values , a best - fit line can be determined that yields @xmath143 and @xmath145 from the slope and intercept , respectively , for each model that is compared to the observations . for each set of model fluxes and observed fluxes , we calculate three linear fits ( using linear combinations of the three different extinction laws , as explained above ) , thus yielding three values for scaling factors and three for the extinction value .
if each extinction value is within the bounds of the extinction law that was used and smaller than a certain maximum @xmath143 value ( which will be discussed below ) , and the scaling factor is in the range from 0.5 to 2.0 , then the result with the best linear fit will be used .
however , if some of the values are not within their boundaries , then combinations of their limiting values are explored , and the set of scaling factor and extinction with the best fit is adopted .
for example , if a model has fluxes that are much higher than all observed fluxes , the linear fit described above will likely yield very large extinction values and small scaling factors . in this case
the fitter would only accept the smallest possible scaling factor ( 0.5 ) and the maximum allowed @xmath143 value as a solution ( which will still result in a poor fit ) . for each object
, we allowed the model fluxes to be extinguished up to a maximum @xmath143 value derived from column density maps of orion ( @xcite ; see also @xcite for the methodology of deriving n@xmath146 from 160 - 500 maps ) .
we converted the total hydrogen column density from these maps to @xmath126 values ( @xmath126=3.55 @xmath143 ) by using a conversion factor of @xmath147 @xmath148 mag@xmath54 @xcite . for objects for which no column density could be derived
, we set the maximum @xmath143 value to 8.45 ( which corresponds to @xmath149 ) . after returning a best - fit scaling factor and extinction value for each model , each data point
is assigned a weight , and the goodness of the fit is estimated with @xmath150 where @xmath151 are the weights , @xmath152 and @xmath153 are the observed and the scaled and extinguished model fluxes , respectively , and n is the number of data points ( see * ? ? ?
thus , @xmath154 is a measure of the average , weighted , logarithmic deviation between the observed and model sed .
it was introduced by @xcite since the uncertainty of the fit is dominated by the availability of models in the grid ( i.e , the spacing of the models in sed space ) and not by the measurement uncertainty of the data , making the standard @xmath155 analysis less useful .
also , a statistic that measures deviations between models and data in log space more closely resembles the assessment done by eye when comparing models and observed seds in log(@xmath156 ) vs. @xmath139 plots .
we set the weights @xmath151 to the inverse of the estimated fractional uncertainty of each data point ; so , for photometry at wavelengths below 3 they are equal to 1/0.1 , between 3 and 60 they are 1/0.05 , at 70 and 100 they are 1/0.04 , at 160 the weight is 1/0.07 , and for photometry at 350 and 870 they are 1/0.4 and 1/0.2 , respectively . for fluxes from irs spectra the weights are 1/0.075 for wavelength ranges 8 - 12 and 18 - 38 , while they are 1/0.1 for the 5 - 8 and 12 - 18 regions .
these irs weights are also multiplied by 1.5 for high signal - to - noise spectra and by 0.5 for noisy spectra . in this way those parts of the irs spectrum that most constrain the sed , the 10 silicate absorption feature and slope beyond 18 @xmath0 m , are given more weight ; for high - quality spectra , the weights in these wavelength regions are the same as for the 3 - 60 photometry . for small values
, @xmath154 measures the average distance between model and data in units of the fractional uncertainty .
in general , the smaller the @xmath154 value , the better the model fit , but protostars with fewer data points can have small @xmath154 values , while protostars with some noisy data can have larger @xmath154 values ( but still an overall good fit ) .
we find a best - fit model for each object , but we also record all those models that lie within a certain range of @xmath154 values from the best - fit @xmath154 .
these models give us an estimate on how well the various model parameters are constrained ( see section [ deltar ] ) .
our model grid is used to characterize the parameters that best describe the observed sed of each object ; the @xmath154 values rank the models for each object and thus can be used to derive best - fit parameters , as well as estimates of parameter ranges . in several instances , better fits could be achieved if the model parameters were further adjusted , for example by testing more values of cavity opening angle or shape , or even changing the opacities ( see , e.g. , hops 68 @xcite , hops 223 @xcite , hops 59 , 60 , 66 , 108 , 368 , 369 , 370 @xcite , hops 136 @xcite , and hops 108 @xcite ) .
however , for protostars that are well fit with one of the models from the grid or for which the grid yields a narrow range of parameter values , it is unlikely that a more extended model grid would yield much different best - fit parameters .
overall , our model fits yield good estimates of envelope parameters for a majority of the sample , and thus we can analyze the protostellar properties of our hops targets in a statistical manner .
the best - fit parameters resulting from our models can be found in table a[bestfit ] , and figure a[bestseds ] shows the seds and best fits for our sample . in this section
we give an overview of the quality of the fits , the distributions of the best - fit model parameters , both for the sample as a whole and separated by sed class , the parameter uncertainties , and the various degeneracies between model parameters .
values of the best fits of the 330 ysos in the hops sample that have _ spitzer _ and _ herschel _ detections .
[ r_histo ] ] figure [ r_histo ] displays the histogram of @xmath154 values of the best model fits for the 330 objects in our hops sample that have _ spitzer _ and _ herschel _ data ( more than two data points at different wavelengths ) and are not contaminants ( see section [ sample ] ) .
the median @xmath154 value is 3.10 , while the mean value is 3.29 .
fitting a gaussian to the histogram at @xmath154 @xmath157 7 yields 3.00 and 2.24 as the center and fwhm of the gaussian , respectively .
the distribution of @xmath154 values implies that , on average , the model deviates by about three times the average fractional uncertainty from the data .
this is not unexpected , given that we fit models from a grid to observed seds that span almost three orders of magnitude in wavelength range , with up to 29 data points .
the fewer the data points , the easier it is to achieve a good fit ; in fact , the eight protostars with @xmath158 , hops 371 , 391 , 398 , 401 , 402 , 404 , 406 , and 409 , have seds with measured flux values at only 4 - 5 points .
starting at @xmath154 values of about 1 , @xmath154 can be used as an indicator of the goodness of fit . however , in some cases a noisy irs spectrum can increase the @xmath154 value of a fit that , judged by the photometry alone , does not deviate much from the observed data points . in other cases , mismatches between different data sets , like offsets between the irac fluxes and the irs spectrum , can result in larger @xmath154 values .
these might be interesting protostars affected by variability and are thus ideal candidates for follow - up observations .
when looking at the sed fits in figure a[bestseds ] ( and the corresponding @xmath154 values in table a[bestfit ] ) , we estimate that an @xmath154 value of up to @xmath1 4 can identify a reliable fit ( with some possible discrepancies between data and model in certain wavelength regions ) .
when @xmath154 gets larger than about 5 , the discrepancy between the fit and the observed data points usually becomes noticeable ; the fit might still reproduce the overall sed shape but deviate substantially from most measured flux values . in figure
[ r_histo_by_class ] , we show the histogram of @xmath154 values separately for the three main protostellar classes in our sample . the median @xmath154 value decreases from 3.27 for the class 0 protostars to 3.18 for the class i protostars to 2.58 for the flat - spectrum sources
. there are 4 class 0 protostars and 4 class i protostars with @xmath154 values between 1.0 and 2.0 , but 17 flat - spectrum sources in this @xmath154 range .
these numbers translate to 17% of the flat - spectrum sources in our sample , 4% of the class 0 protostars , and 3% of the class
i protostars .
when examining objects @xmath154 values between 2.0 and 4.0 , there are 51 class 0 protostars ( 55% of class 0 protostars in the sample ) , 91 class i protostars ( 73% of the class i sample ) , and 74 flat - spectrum sources ( 73% of the flat - spectrum sample ) .
thus , close to 90% of flat - spectrum sources are fit reasonably well ( @xmath154 values @xmath29 4 ) , representing the largest fraction among the different classes of objects in our sample .
this could be a result of their source properties being well represented in our model grid , but also lack of substantial wavelength - dependent variability ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , which , if present , would make their seds more difficult to fit .
about three - quarters of class i protostars also have best - fit models with @xmath159 ; this fraction drops to about two - thirds for the class 0 protostars .
the latter group of objects often suffers from more uncertain seds due to weak emission at shorter wavelengths ( which , e.g. , results in a noisy irs spectrum ) ; they might also be more embedded in extended emission , such as filaments , which can contaminate the far - ir to submillimeter fluxes .
another factor that could contribute to poor fits is their presumably high envelope density , which places them closer to the limit in parameter space probed by the model grid .
overall , 75% of the best - fit models of the protostars in our sample have @xmath159 .
when examining the sed fits of objects with @xmath154 values larger than 5.0 , several have very noisy irs spectra ( hops 19 , 38 , 40 , 95 , 164 , 278 , 316 , 322 , 335 , 359 ) . in a few cases the measured pacs 100 and 160 @xmath0 m fluxes seem too high compared to the best - fit model ( e.g. , hops 189 ) , which could be an indication of contamination by extended emission surrounding the protostar . of particular interest
are objects where variability likely plays a role in a poor fit . as mentioned in section [ seds ] , variability among protostars
is common ; we found in appendix [ variability ] that about 5% of our targets display noticeable ( @xmath160 50% ) mismatches between the irs , irac , and mips fluxes that could be due to intrinsic variability .
the sed fits of objects for which the flux mismatches between irs and irac and between irs and mips are different are particularly affected , since in that case we did not scale the irs spectrum to match the mips 24 @xmath0 m flux .
hops 228 exemplifies such a case : there is a clear discrepancy between the irac and irs fluxes ( a factor of 2.1 - 2.7 ) and also between mips 24 @xmath0 m and irs ( a factor of 0.8 ) ; even though the fit gives more weight to the irs data , they are not fit well , especially the silicate absorption feature .
the @xmath154 value of 5.74 for the fit of hops 228 reflects the discrepant data sets and poor fit .
hops 223 is another case where the irs fluxes do not match the shorter - wavelength data ( they are more than an order of magnitude larger ) ; however , it is a known fu ori source ( see * ? ? ?
* ) , and the sed presented here contains both pre- and post - outburst data .
the model fit is very poor , which can also be gauged by the @xmath154 value of 8.41 .
there are also objects with overall good fits whose seds show discrepancies that may be signs of variability or contamination .
for example , for the class i protostar hops 71 the irac fluxes are a factor of 1.8 - 2.4 lower than the irs fluxes in the 5 - 8 @xmath0 m region , and also the mips flux is about 20% lower .
the best - fit model ( @xmath161 ) fits the sed extremely well beyond about 6 @xmath0 m , with some discrepancy at shorter wavelengths .
there is a source just 11 from hops 71 that is detected in 2mass and _ spitzer _ data , but not by pacs ; this object , hops 72 , is likely an extragalactic object ( see appendix [ exgal_not_modeled ] ) that could contaminate the irs fluxes .
thus , in this case , wavelength - dependent contamination by a companion could explain the discrepancies observed in the sed .
another example is hops 124 , which is a deeply embedded class 0 protostar .
for this object , the mismatch between irs and irac and mips fluxes decreases with increasing wavelength ( from a factor of 2.5 to a factor of 1.4 ) ; for the sed fit , the irs spectrum was scaled by 0.7 to match the mips 24 @xmath0 m flux .
as with hops 71 , there is a nearby source that could contaminate some of the fluxes , especially at shorter wavelengths : hops 125 , a flat - spectrum source , lies 9.8 from hops 124 and is brighter than hops 124 out to @xmath1 20 @xmath0 m , but then much fainter at longer wavelengths .
the best - fit model of hops 124 ( @xmath162 ) matches the mid- to far - ir photometry and also most of the irs spectrum well . as an example of a probably variable flat - spectrum source , hops 132 has irac fluxes that lie a factor of 1.3 - 1.7 above those of irs and a mips 24 @xmath0 m flux that is a factor of 0.6 lower .
it does not have a close companion ; the nearest hops source , hops 133 , is 27 away .
the irs spectrum was not scaled , and since the sed fitter gave more weight to the spectrum , it is fit well , but the irac photometry is underestimated and the mips photometry overestimated .
nonetheless , the @xmath154 value of the best fit is 2.87 .
overall , the sed fits of objects that are likely variable or suffer from some contamination are less reliable , but it is not always clear from the @xmath154 value of the best fit .
the sed fitting procedures assume that the protostars are not variable , so when large mismatches between different data sets are present , the fit will appear discrepant with at least some of the observed data points , but the @xmath154 value would not end up particularly high if , e.g. , the irs spectrum was fit exceptionally well .
however , given the data sets we have for these protostars , our sed fits will still yield the best possible estimate for the protostellar parameters describing these systems .
the histogram of best - fit @xmath68 values ( which is the density of the envelope at 1000 au ; see section [ model_parameters ] ) is shown in figure [ rho1000_histo ] .
the median value of the distribution amounts to @xmath163 g @xmath33 ; this corresponds to a @xmath89 value of @xmath164 g @xmath33 .
there is a spread in values : 69 objects have densities @xmath68 smaller than @xmath165 g @xmath33 ( 6 of them have actually no envelope ) , 89 fall in the @xmath166 to @xmath167 g @xmath33 range , 96 are between @xmath167 and @xmath168 g @xmath33 , 60 between @xmath168 and @xmath169 g @xmath33 , and 16 have @xmath68 values larger than @xmath170 g @xmath33 . of the best fits for the 330 targets in our sample .
[ rho1000_histo ] ] ] we also calculated the envelope mass ( @xmath171 ) within 2500 au for the best - fit models ( see figure [ menv_histo ] for their distribution ) . the 2500 au radius is close to half the fwhm of the pacs 160 @xmath0 m beam at the distance of orion ( i.e. , @xmath1 6 ) , and thus roughly represents the spatial extent over which we measure the seds .
this envelope mass is determined from the integrated envelope density of our best - fit models , with allowances made for outflow cavities , and thus only valid in the context of our models .
the median envelope mass within 2500 au amounts to 0.029 @xmath42 .
the majority of protostars have model - derived masses in the inner 2500 au of their envelopes around 0.1 @xmath42 ; just 22 objects have @xmath171 ( @xmath29 2500 au ) larger than 1.0 @xmath42 . of the 330 modeled objects ,
291 have @xmath171 ( @xmath29 2500
au ) smaller than 0.5 @xmath42 ( 6 of these 291 objects have no envelope ) . ] ] ] figure [ ltot_histo ] contains the histogram of the total luminosities derived from the best - fit models .
these luminosities consist of the stellar , disk accretion , and accretion shock components .
the median total luminosity amounts to 3.02 @xmath19 , while the values cover four orders of magnitude , from 0.06 @xmath19 ( for hops 336 ) to 607 @xmath19 ( for hops 288 and 361 ) .
since the minimum and maximum values for the total luminosity in our grid amount to 0.1 and 303.5 @xmath19 , respectively , and our scaling factors range from 0.5 to 2.0 , our fitting procedure can return best - fit luminosities that range from 0.05 to 607 @xmath19 .
thus , two protostars are reaching the upper limit allowed for total luminosities in our grid ; it is possible that even better fits could be achieved by increasing the luminosity further . from the distribution of best - fit outer disk radii in figure [ rdisk_histo ]
, it is apparent that most protostars are fit by small disks whose radius is only 5 au . since the outer disk outer radius is the centrifugal radius in our models , infalling material from the envelope tends to accumulate close to the star for most sources .
thus , the disk radius is tied to the envelope structure ; a small centrifugal radius implies higher envelope densities at smaller radii and a less flattened envelope structure .
the median disk radius is 50 au , but the number of objects with disk radii @xmath11 50 au is roughly evenly split among the values of 50 , 100 , and 500 au . the distribution of best - fit cavity opening angles is displayed in figure [ cav_histo ] .
most protostars seem to have either very small ( 5 ) or very large ( 45 ) cavities ; the median value is 25 . when dividing the envelope densities by cavity opening angle ( see figure [ pars_cav_histo ] , left column ) , differences emerge : the distributions of @xmath68 values are significantly different when comparing objects with @xmath76=5 and @xmath17235 , objects with @xmath76=15 and @xmath76 @xmath11 25 , and objects with @xmath76=25 and @xmath76=45 .
the kolmogorov - smirnov ( k - s ) tests yield significance levels that these subsamples are drawn from the same parent population of @xmath119 0.015 .
thus , there seems to be a difference in the distribution of envelope densities among the best - fit models with smaller cavity opening angles and those with larger cavities .
protostars with larger cavities ( @xmath11 35 ) tend to have higher envelope densities ( their median @xmath68 values are about an order of magnitude larger compared to objects with cavities @xmath157 15 ) .
figure [ pars_cav_histo ] ( middle column ) also shows the distribution of total luminosities for the different cavity opening angles .
the only significant difference can be found for the @xmath76=5 histogram as compared to the histograms for larger @xmath76 values ( k - s test significance level @xmath119 0.03 ) ; the luminosities of models with @xmath76=5 have a different distribution , and also their median value is 1.45 @xmath19 , as compared to @xmath1 3 - 5 @xmath19 for the models with larger cavities .
so , protostars with small cavities seem to have lower total luminosities . ]
the distribution of centrifugal radii for different cavity opening angles ( right column in figure [ pars_cav_histo ] ) shows that , independent of cavity size , most objects have @xmath49 = 5 au .
however , the distribution among the four different disk radii becomes flatter for the largest cavity opening angles ; the histograms for @xmath76=35 and @xmath76=45 are very similar ( k - s test significance level of 0.98 ) .
there is also no significant difference ( k - s test values @xmath26 0.075 ) between the @xmath76=15 and @xmath76=25 histograms and between the @xmath76=5 and @xmath173 35 histograms .
the distributions of disk radii for the other cavity opening angles are all different from one another ( k - s test significance levels @xmath29 0.015 ) .
overall , figure [ pars_cav_histo ] shows that protostars best fit by models with large cavity opening angles are also fit by models with higher envelope densities and larger centrifugal radii . ] in figure [ inc_histo ] , we show the distribution of the inclination angles for the best - fit models .
there is a clear concentration of models in the 60@xmath17470 range ; the median inclination angle is 63 .
this median value is close to 60 , which is where the probability for isotropically distributed inclination angles reaches 50% ( i.e. , the probability of observing an inclination angle less than 60 is the same as the probability of observing i@xmath2660 ) .
however , the details of the distributions differ .
the cumulative probability of finding an inclination angle less than a certain value , @xmath175 , is @xmath176 , assuming a random distribution of inclination angles . for inclination angles @xmath177 and @xmath178 , the probability for @xmath179 is @xmath180 .
thus , since the inclination angles in our model grid were chosen to be equally spaced in @xmath41 ( there are five values @xmath2960 and five values @xmath2660 ) , one would expect a flat distribution in figure [ inc_histo ] if the best - fit inclination angles were randomly distributed ( see the green dashed histogram ) .
however , we find a distribution peaked at 63 and 70 .
this can also be seen in figure [ inc_cdf ] , where we compare our observed cumulative distribution of inclination angles to that of randomly distributed ones .
our distribution shows a deficit at inclination angles below 60 and is just slightly higher at large inclination angles .
a k - s test of the two distributions yields a 5.6% chance that they are drawn from the same parent distribution . to examine
whether the distribution of envelope parameters changes with inclination angle ( which could imply a degeneracy ) , figure [ pars_inc_histo ] shows the reference envelope density @xmath68 , the total luminosity , and the cavity opening angle binned by three ranges of inclination angles .
none of the three model parameters show a significantly different distribution for any of the inclination bins ( k - s test significance levels are @xmath160 0.1 , except for the cavity opening angles for the lowest and middle inclination range , for which the k - s test significance value is 0.02 ) .
the median @xmath68 values for the @xmath1811841 , 4963 , and 6987 inclination bins are all @xmath163 g @xmath33 . even though not shown in figure [ pars_inc_histo ] , the objects whose best - fit model does not include an envelope
are only found at @xmath182 49 .
it is noteworthy that protostars with the highest envelope densities do not have inclination angles in the 6987 range ; it is not clear whether this is an observational bias , whether our observed sample does not contain high - density , edge - on protostars , or whether this is due to biases in the fitting procedure and/or model grid .
the median values for the total luminosity do not differ by much for the different bins of inclination angle , increasing from 2.9 to 4.1 @xmath19 from the lowest to the middle inclination range and then decreasing to 2.0 @xmath19for the highest inclination angles .
the few protostars with very high @xmath82 values have large inclination angles ( @xmath182 49 ) . finally , the distribution of cavity opening angles is quite similar for different ranges in inclination , except for a somewhat larger number of @xmath183 45values at intermediate inclination angles .
half the objects in the @xmath1811841 and 6987 inclination bins have @xmath184 15 ( with the most common value 5 ) , while almost half the objects at intermediate inclination angles have @xmath173 35 ( the most common value is 45 ) . in figure
[ ltot_lbol ] , we show ratios of the total and bolometric luminosities as a function of inclination angle and foreground extinction ( @xmath84 and @xmath126 are adopted from the best model fits ) .
the total luminosity is the intrinsic luminosity from the best - fit model of each object , while the bolometric luminosity is derived by integrating the fluxes of the observed sed .
it is expected that @xmath82 is higher than @xmath16 for objects seen at higher inclination angles , since for these objects a large fraction of the emitted flux is not directed toward the observer ( and thus deriving bolometric luminosities from observed fluxes will underestimate the intrinsic source luminosity ) .
conversely , objects seen more face - on should have lower @xmath82 values compared to @xmath16 .
our data and model fits yield @xmath82 values that are usually higher than the @xmath16 values measured from the sed ; the discrepancy is larger for the more highly inclined sources .
the median @xmath185 ratio is 1.5 for protostars with inclination angles in the 1841 range , 2.5 for the i=4963 range , and 3.5 for inclination angles @xmath11 69 .
the fact that @xmath186 even for @xmath1811841 could be related to the typically smaller cavity opening angles for this range of inclination angles ( see figure [ pars_inc_histo ] ) ; less flux , especially at shorter wavelengths , is detected since the opacity along the line of sight is still high due to the small cavities .
foreground extinction also plays a role in increasing the @xmath82/@xmath16 ratio .
the median ratio of these luminosities increases from 1.8 for the @xmath126= 0 - 5 mag range to 5.0 for @xmath126=25 - 30 ; it decreases somewhat for the next @xmath126 bin , but reaches 5.9 at @xmath126=40 - 50 ( the 23 objects with @xmath187 50 , not shown in figure [ ltot_lbol ] , have a median @xmath82/@xmath16 ratio of 8.2 ) . among the 22 objects with best - fit @xmath126 values of 0 - 5 mag and inclination angles @xmath157 50
, only four have @xmath185 ratios that are larger than 1.5 ( they are hops 57 , 147 , 199 , and 201 ; in most cases the model overestimates the near - ir emission ) .
figures [ rho_class_histo][av_class_histo ] divide the histograms of the best - fit reference density @xmath68 , inclination angle , cavity opening angle , total luminosity , disk radius , and foreground extinction , respectively , by protostar class . as explained in section [ seds ] , we divided our targets into class 0 , class i , flat - spectrum , and class ii objects based on their mid - infrared ( 4.5 - 24 ) spectral index and bolometric temperature ( see also table a[bestfit ] ) .
thus , class 0 and i protostars have a spectral index @xmath26 0.3 , and class 0 protostars have @xmath8 values @xmath29 70 k , but , as mentioned in section [ seds ] , there are a few protostars whose spectral index or @xmath8 value places them very close to the transition region between class 0 and i or between class i and flat spectrum . given that our sample contains just eleven class ii pre - main - sequence stars , we did not include them in the following histograms ; they will be discussed in section [ disk_sources ] .
the distributions of reference densities ( figure [ rho_class_histo ] ) are different for all sed classes ; none are consistent with being drawn from the same parent population ( k - s test significance level @xmath29 0.01 )
. overall , class 0 protostars have higher envelope densities than class i and flat - spectrum sources ; the median @xmath68 values decrease from 5.9 @xmath72 g @xmath33 to 2.4 @xmath71 g @xmath33 to 1.2 @xmath71 g @xmath33 for these three groups .
the lower and upper quartiles for @xmath68 are 1.8 @xmath72 and 1.8 @xmath73 g @xmath33 for the class 0 protostars , and 2.4 @xmath70 and 1.2 @xmath72 g @xmath33 for the class i and flat - spectrum objects .
we will discuss some implications of these differences in derived envelope densities in section [ sed_class_properties ] .
for the inclination angles ( figure [ inc_class_histo ] ) , the distributions are significantly different for all protostellar classes , too ( k - s test significance level @xmath188 0.01 ) . as was shown in figure [ inc_histo ] , a random distribution of inclination angles would result in equal numbers of protostars at each value ; there is a deficit of class 0 and class i protostars at @xmath189 60 , and there are also few class i protostars and hardly any flat - spectrum sources at the highest inclination angles .
the median inclination angle is highest for class 0 protostars ( 70 ) , then decreases somewhat for class i protostars ( 63 ) and even more for flat - spectrum sources ( 57 ) .
similar to the envelope density , the median inclination angle decreases as one progresses from class 0 to flat - spectrum sources . in the distributions of cavity opening angles ( figure [ cav_class_histo ] ) , significant differences can be found between class 0 and class i protostars and between class i protostars and flat - spectrum sources ( k - s test significance level @xmath188 0.01 ) .
the median cavity opening angle is 15 for the class i protostars , but 25 for the other two classes .
about 40% of class i protostars have @xmath76=5 , while the distribution among the different cavity opening angles is flatter for the other two object classes .
the large fraction of class i protostars with small cavities could be the result of degeneracy in model parameters ( see section [ sed_class_properties ] ) or our assumptions on envelope geometry ( see section [ model_problems ] ) .
there are notably few flat - spectrum sources with a 5 cavity opening angle ; most of them have cavity opening angles of 15 or 45 .
when comparing the total luminosities for the different sed classes ( figure [ ltot_class_histo ] ) , the distribution of @xmath82 values is different for the class 0 protostars when compared to the other two classes ( k - s test significance level @xmath29 0.015 ) , but similar for class i protostars and flat - spectrum sources .
the median total luminosity for class 0 protostars is 5.5 @xmath19 , compared to 2.0 @xmath19 for class i protostars and 3.0 @xmath19 for flat - spectrum sources .
both class 0 and i protostars cover close to the whole range of @xmath82 values in the model grid ( @xmath1 0.06 - 600 @xmath19 ) , while flat - spectrum sources span a more limited range , from 0.1 to 316 @xmath19 .
the distribution of centrifugal radii for the whole sample showed a preference for 5 au ( see figure [ rdisk_histo ] ) .
when separating the best - fit disk radii by protostellar class ( figure [ rdisk_class_histo ] ) , it is clear that the trend for small centrifugal radii is driven by the flat - spectrum sources and also class i protostars .
the fraction of class 0 protostars with @xmath49= 5 au is 17% ; it increases to 46% and 73% for class i protostars and flat - spectrum sources , respectively .
the median disk radius decreases from 100 au for class 0 protostars to 50 au for class i protostars to 5 au for flat - spectrum sources .
all three histograms are significantly different from one another ( k - s test significance level @xmath188 0.001 ) . the unexpectedly small centrifugal radii for class i protostars and flat - spectrum sources could point to parameter degeneracies ( see section [ sed_class_properties ] ) or the need to revise certain model assumptions ( see section [ model_problems ] ) .
finally , the distribution of best - fit foreground extinction values ( figure [ av_class_histo ] ) is similar for all three object classes ( k - s test significance level @xmath26 0.03 ) .
even the median values are close : @xmath126=9.2 for class 0 protostars , @xmath126=8.9 for class i protostars , and @xmath126=10.1 for flat - spectrum sources .
most objects are fit with relatively low foreground extinction values .
as can be seen from figure [ av_models_maps ] , the majority of protostars have best - fit @xmath126 values well below the maximum @xmath126 values determined from column density maps , which were used as the largest allowed @xmath126 values for the sed fitter .
the ratio of model - derived @xmath126 to observationally constrained maximum @xmath126 is lower than 0.5 for about 60% of the sample . from the best - fit models versus the maximum @xmath126 value determined from column density maps of orion .
the dashed line indicates where the two @xmath126 values are equal .
[ av_models_maps ] ] in figure [ rho_av_class ] , we plot the reference densities @xmath68 versus the foreground extinction for class 0 , class i , and flat - spectrum sources . as was already seen in figure [ av_class_histo ]
, the extinction along the line of sight is similar for all three classes , with most objects in the @xmath190 0 - 30 regime .
class 0 protostars , which have higher envelope densities , tend to have lower @xmath126 values from foreground extinction ; the highest - density envelopes are spread among a wide range of @xmath126 values .
the result is similar for class i protostars .
flat - spectrum sources display a range in envelope densities at various foreground extinction values ; the lowest - density envelopes typically have @xmath191 .
thus , foreground extinction does not seem to affect the classification of protostars . this result
is also supported by the statistical analysis of @xcite , who found that , for @xmath126 values up to 35 , the misclassification of a class i protostar as a class 0 protostar due to foreground extinction ( which results in a lower @xmath8 ) is low .
l|ccc @xmath82 & 5.5 @xmath19 & 2.0 @xmath19 & 3.0 @xmath19 + @xmath68 & 5.9 @xmath72 g @xmath33 & 2.4 @xmath71 g @xmath33 & 1.2 @xmath71 g @xmath33 + @xmath76 & 25 & 15 & 25 + @xmath49 & 100 au & 50 au & 5 au + @xmath84 & 70 & 63 & 57 + @xmath126 & 9.2 & 8.9 & 10.1 + we found differences in the best - fit envelope densities and inclination angles for the various protostellar classes .
the result that class 0 protostars tend to have larger inclination angles and envelope densities compared to class i and flat - spectrum objects can also be seen in figure [ rho_inc_class ] .
there are very few class 0 protostars with low inclination angles ; most have relatively high density and @xmath19260 .
class i protostars are best fit by somewhat lower inclination angles than class 0 protostars and also lower @xmath68 values . the best - fit reference density for class i protostars decreases as the inclination angle increases ; thus , higher - density protostars are typically classified as class i protostars only if they are not seen at close to edge - on orientations .
flat - spectrum sources are spread out in density inclination space , but intermediate inclination angles and low envelope densities are common .
there is a relatively large number of objects at @xmath18118 and a deficit of objects at high inclination angles .
the highest - density flat - spectrum sources are seen at inclination angles @xmath29 50 , while the lower - density objects cover almost the full range of inclination angles .
the median parameter values we determined from the best fits for the class 0 , class i , and flat - spectrum sources ( see table [ median_par ] ) can be used to show representative median seds for each protostellar class . in figure [ median_seds ]
, we show model seds whose parameter values are equal to the median values found for each of the three protostellar classes .
it is apparent that the large envelope density and higher inclination angle for class 0 protostars cause a deep absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m and a steeply rising sed in the mid- and far - ir , with a peak close to 100 @xmath0 m . in class
i protostars , the sed is less steep and peaks at a shorter wavelength than the median sed of class 0 protostars .
flat - spectrum sources show the strongest near - ir emission of the three protostellar classes ; their median sed is very flat out to 70 @xmath0 m , but at longer wavelengths it is very similar in shape and flux level to that of class i protostars . given that the @xmath154 values are a measure of the goodness of fit in units of the fractional uncertainty , we can use models that lie within a certain range of the best - fit @xmath154 value to estimate uncertainties for the various model parameters .
for each modeled hops target , we tabulated the model parameters for all those models that lie within a difference of 0.5 , 1.0 , 1.5 , and 2.0 of the best - fit @xmath154 .
we then computed the mode ( i.e. , the value with the highest frequency ) for the inclination angle , total luminosity , @xmath68 , cavity opening angle , outer disk radius , and @xmath126 in each of the @xmath193 bins for each object . for
any given protostar , the models in each @xmath193 bin span certain ranges in parameter values ; while the modes do not capture the full extent of these ranges , they convey the most common value within each parameter range .
the farther away a mode is from the best - fit value , the more poorly constrained the model parameter .
conversely , if a mode of a certain parameter is close to or matches the best - fit value , especially for @xmath194 1.5 or 2 , that particular model parameter is well constrained . in figures [ inc_modes ] to [ av_modes ]
we plot the mode versus the best - fit value for six model parameters and four @xmath193 bins for all 330 targets in our sample .
the larger @xmath193 , the larger the spread in modes is expected to be for each parameter value . for example , figure [ inc_modes ] shows that even when considering all models with an @xmath154 value of up to 2 larger than the best - fit @xmath154 ( @xmath194 2 ) , the inclination angle for objects with a best - fit @xmath84 of 18 is well constrained ; most modes lie at @xmath181 18 , too , and only a few modes can be found at larger inclination angles .
however , objects with best - fit @xmath84 values of 32 or 41 typically can also be fit by models with lower inclination angles ( the majority of modes lies below the line where mode and best - fit value are equal ) .
inclination angles @xmath160 63 are better constrained , since their modes mostly lie at high inclination angle values , but there are protostars with modes of @xmath18118 , too .
the modes for the total luminosity ( figure [ lum_modes ] ) show a small spread for models within @xmath193=0.5 , but the spread increases as @xmath154 increases , with some objects displaying up to an order of magnitude in variation of @xmath82 . as illustrated in figure [ rho1000_modes ] ,
the reference density @xmath68 is usually well constrained ; however , as @xmath154 increases , the modes of the @xmath68 values are often lower than the best - fit values . for the cavity opening angle ( figure [ cavity_modes ] ) , many models up to @xmath193=2 have modes of @xmath76=45 , independent of the best - fit value .
similarly for the centrifugal radius ( figure [ rdisk_modes ] ) , @xmath49=500 au is a common mode .
for all four disk radii , the modes tend to be larger than the best - fit values ; in particular , objects with a best - fit @xmath49 of 5 au have a very uncertain disk radius .
in general , it looks like our models do not constrain the disk radius and cavity opening angle well . the foreground extinction ( figure [ av_modes ] ) displays a certain range of modes for each best - fit value , but objects with @xmath195 20 typically have more reliable @xmath126 values from their model fits .
figures [ inc_modes ] to [ av_modes ] allow us to gauge general trends between best - fit values and modes for different model parameters . for results on individual objects , we refer to appendix [ models_unc ] , where we show plots of the difference between the modes and the best - fit values of the major model parameters for all modeled hops targets .
in this way it is possible to estimate which models are better constrained and thus which objects have more reliable sed fits . in addition , in appendix [ models_unc ] we also include contour plots of @xmath154 values for different pairs of model parameters for a few targets to illustrate typical parameter degeneracies , which also contribute to parameter uncertainties .
we compared a grid of tsc models to each target by ranking the models using a statistic , @xmath154 , which measures the deviation between observed and model fluxes in logarithmic space .
we did not model each source by further adjusting the model parameters , but instead identified the best - fit sed from our model grid .
thus , we are bound by the range and sampling of parameters chosen for the grid , and while we constructed the grid with the aim of covering the typical parameter space for protostars , it is limited to discrete values .
it is likely that many protostars have best - fit parameters that would fall between those sampled by the grid , and a few objects could have parameter values that lie beyond the limits set by the grid .
in addition , tsc models are axisymmetric and have mostly smooth density and temperature profiles , and they do not include external heating .
they assume a rotating , infalling envelope with constant infall rate and with the gravitational force dominated by the central protostar , but the true envelope structure is likely more complex .
the models would not apply to the collapse of a cloud in an initial filamentary or sheet - like geometry or to multiple systems with , e.g. , more than one outflow cavity ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
despite the relatively simple models that we use , many of the observed seds are fit remarkably well : 75% of the fits have @xmath196 .
in those cases , the continuum traced by the irs spectrum , the silicate absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m , and the pacs fluxes are all accurately reproduced by the model .
even many flat - spectrum sources , which often do not display any spectral features in the mid - infrared and have an overall flat sed out to 30 or 70 @xmath0 m , often have models that fit them very well . about 75% of class i protostars and @xmath1 70% of class
0 protostars have @xmath159 , while close to 90% of flat - spectrum sources have @xmath154 values in this range .
this validates the choice of parameter values for our model grid .
additional constraints , like limits on foreground extinction or information on the inclination and cavity opening angles from scattered light images or mapping of outflows , would allow us to further test and refine the models . we have used limits on the extinction in our analysis . although _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ scattered light images have been used to constrain models for one hops protostar @xcite , scattered light images are not available for many of our targets .
we therefore chose to focus on fitting the seds of all of our targets in a uniform way to a well - defined set of models .
future studies will incorporate scattered light images and compare the results to those from the sed fits ( j. booker et al .
2016 , in preparation ) .
the best - fit models from our grid for the hops targets both reproduce the seds and yield estimates for their protostellar parameters , mostly envelope properties . however , these are not necessarily unique fits to the data for three reasons
. first , there are degeneracies in the model parameters ; increasing the envelope density or inclination angle , or decreasing the cavity opening angle or disk radius , results in a steeper mid - ir sed slope and deeper silicate features .
each of these parameters affects the sed differently ( just the general trends are the same ) , and the best fit for each object tries optimizing them .
the next best fit , however , could be a different combination of these parameters , especially if the sed is not well constrained by observations ( see section [ deltar ] ) .
second , although the tsc models reproduce the observed seds , other models with different envelope geometries may also be able to fit the same seds .
the modeling presented here is only valid in the context of the tsc models of single stars , and the resulting derived properties are only valid within that framework .
last , neglecting external heating could result in overestimated envelope densities and luminosities , with the most noticeable effects ( @xmath68 and @xmath82 too large by factors of a few ) on low - luminosity sources exposed to strong radiation fields ( see section [ model_ext_heat ] ) . from the distribution of best - fit @xmath82 values
, we estimate that @xmath1 20% of hops targets in our sample could be affected by external heating . even though we do not know the strength of external heating for each protostar , it is likely that external heating would only result in relatively small changes in the derived envelope parameters for these protostars .
when comparing envelope parameters sorted by sed classes , we found that envelope densities and inclination angles decrease from the sample of class 0 protostars through that of class i protostars to that of flat - spectrum objects .
the former is likely an evolutionary effect , while the latter confirms the results of previous work ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) that the inclination angle has an important effect on the sed and that the evolutionary state of an object can not be derived from sed slopes alone .
thus , there is a difference between the `` stage '' and `` class '' of an object @xcite ; stage 0 and i objects are characterized by substantial envelopes , stage ii objects are surrounded by optically thick disks , with possibly some remnant infalling envelopes , and stage iii objects have optically thin disks . in general ,
the trends we see among model parameters are a consequence of the definition of a protostar based on its sed : in order to be classified as a class 0 or i object , a protostar is required to have a near- to mid - infrared sed slope larger than 0.3 .
a protostellar model with a small cavity opening angle , small centrifugal radius , and/or high inclination angle will generate such an sed , since it increases the optical depth along the line of sight .
models with a large cavity will only yield a rising sed in the 2@xmath17440 @xmath0 m spectral range if their envelope density is large or the inclination angle is relatively high .
we find that class 0 protostars can be best fit not only by very high envelope densities but also moderately high envelope densities and large inclination angles .
the bolometric temperature , which is used to separate class 0 from class i protostars , is inclination dependent ; some class i protostars are shifted to the class 0 regime if they are viewed more edge - on .
the higher - density class i protostars tend to have lower inclination angles ( but still @xmath26 50 ) ; thus , their evolutionary stage could be similar to more embedded protostars that are seen edge - on and classified as class 0 protostars .
conversely , some class 0 objects with large inclination angles , but lower envelope densities , could be in a later evolutionary stage than typical class 0 protostars .
similarly , class i protostars with large @xmath84 and low @xmath68 values could be edge - on stage ii objects ( whose infrared emission is dominated by a disk ) . finally , low - inclination stage 0 and i protostars can appear as a flat - spectrum sources @xcite .
nevertheless , the observed trend in envelope densities suggests that the variations in the observed seds track , in great part , an evolution toward lower envelope densities and lower infall rates . assuming a certain mass for the central star , the reference density in our models can be used to infer an envelope infall rate ( @xmath197 ) . as mentioned in section [ model_parameters ] , this infall rate is model dependent and therefore tied to the assumptions of the models . with this in mind
, the median @xmath68 values for the class 0 , class i , and flat - spectrum protostars in our sample correspond to envelope infall rates of @xmath198 , @xmath199 , and @xmath200 @xmath42 yr@xmath54 , respectively , for a 0.5 @xmath42 star . using a more realistic assumption of larger stellar mass for more evolved protostars ,
the infall rates for class i and flat - spectrum protostars would be larger than these values by a factor of a few .
however , just larger stellar masses can not explain the large decrease of a factor of 50 in the median envelope density from class 0 to flat - spectrum protostars ; to achieve such a decrease with a constant infall rate of @xmath198 @xmath42 yr@xmath54 , the stellar mass would have to increase by a factor of 2500 .
thus , within the context of our model fits , we can conclude that , as envelopes become more tenuous , the infall rates also decrease .
other trends are also apparent . class
0 protostars and flat - spectrum sources show a relatively flat distribution of cavity opening angles . on the other hand , the best fit for a large fraction of class i protostars ( 40% ) results in @xmath76=5 .
this could point to a degeneracy in the models , since protostars with small cavity opening angles tend to have lower envelope densities ( and also lower total luminosities ) ; thus , the smaller cavity partly compensates for the lower opacity resulting from the lower envelope density ( see also figure [ rho1000_inc_cavity ] ) . even though our models do not yield reliable disk properties
, we can make a statement about the difference in the best - fit centrifugal radii ( or @xmath49 ) , which are tied to the structure of the rotating envelope given by the model fits .
it should be noted that the centrifugal radii set a lower limit to the disk radii , since disks may spread outward due to viscous accretion .
most class i protostars and flat - spectrum sources are fit with a centrifugal radius of just 5 au . since the smallest centrifugal radius in our model grid is 5 au and the next value is 50 au , we can state that , except for class 0 protostars , most protostars in our sample have @xmath201 au , and some might even have @xmath202 5 au .
small disks of those sizes have been observed ; radio interferometry of the multiple protostellar system l1551 irs 5 shows disks whose semi - major axes are @xmath119 20 au @xcite .
however , there is a degeneracy between the centrifugal radius and the envelope density ; for protostars with low envelope densities , the small centrifugal radius can compensate the decrease in opacity by concentrating more material closer to the star .
as can be seen in figure [ rho1000_inc_rdisk ] , most protostars with @xmath203 5 au also have lower envelope densities .
inclination angle also plays a role ; protostars seen at @xmath192 80 typically have larger centrifugal radii . in addition , our envelope models include outflow cavities , which allow some of the mid - ir radiation to escape . in order to generate model seds with silicate absorption features and steep mid - ir slopes at low to intermediate inclination angles ,
a lower @xmath49 value is needed .
we will discuss the potential implications of the small cavity sizes and @xmath44 values for class i protostars and flat - spectrum sources in section [ model_problems ] . among the class
0 protostars , there are protostars in the earliest evolutionary stages , when the envelope is massive and the protostar still has to accrete most of its mass .
@xcite identified 18 protostars with very red mid- to far - infrared colors ( @xmath204 @xmath26 1.65 ) , of which 11 were newly identified ( see table d[new_proto ] ) .
@xcite added an additional object .
these protostars were named pacs bright red sources ( pbrs ) by @xcite ; they are hops 169 , 341 , 354 , 358 , 359 , 372 , 373 , 394 , 397 - 405 , 407 , and 409 . based on their steep 24 - 70 @xmath0 m seds and large submillimeter luminosities ,
they were interpreted as the youngest protostars in orion with very dense envelopes . from our best - fit models to the seds of the pbrs , we derive a median @xmath68 value of 1.2 @xmath205 10@xmath206 g @xmath33 , which is twice as high as the median value of all the class 0 protostars in our sample
. these fits also result in a median envelope mass within 2500 au of 0.66 @xmath42 for the pbrs , but the individual objects cover a large range , from 0.07 to 1.83 @xmath42 . the median total luminosity amounts to 5.6 @xmath19 ( with a range from 0.6 to 71.0 @xmath19 ) , which is very similar to the median @xmath82 value for the class 0 protostars in our sample .
most pbrs ( 14 out of 19 protostars ) are fit by models with large inclination angles ( @xmath182 70 ) , but , as shown in @xcite , high inclination alone can not explain the redness of the pbrs .
thus , our models confirm the results of @xcite that the pbrs are deeply embedded and thus likely among the youngest protostars in orion . a particularly interesting group of protostars that are not easy to categorize are the flat - spectrum sources .
they are thought to include objects in transition between stages i and ii , when the envelope is being dispersed @xcite . in particular , those with low envelope densities could be more evolved protostars , or they could be protostars that started out with more tenuous envelopes .
on the other hand , flat - spectrum sources could also be highly inclined disk sources ( see * ? ? ? * ) , or protostars surrounded by dense envelopes , but seen close to face - on @xcite .
this type of misclassification could have a large effect on the lifetimes of the earlier protostellar stages and thus on the timeline of envelope dispersal . among the 330 hops targets in our sample
, we identified 102 flat - spectrum sources based on their flat ( @xmath4 to @xmath207 ) spectral index from 4.5 to 24 @xmath0 m ( or 5 - 25 @xmath0 m in a few cases ) .
thus , they compose a fairly large fraction of our protostellar sample . of these 102 objects ,
47 have a negative spectral index and 55 have one between 0 and @xmath207 ; 41 have a spectral index between @xmath208 and 0.1 , which results in a very flat mid - infrared sed . despite a flat sed slope between 4.5 and 24 @xmath0 m
, many flat - spectrum sources display a weak silicate emission or absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m , which may indicate the presence of a very tenuous infalling envelope or may be the result of the viewing geometry .
some seds are very flat out to 100 @xmath0 m , others have negative spectral slopes beyond 40 @xmath0 m , and again others a rising sed from the mid- to the far - ir .
there are also objects with more pronounced absorption features due to not only silicates but also ices , as are typically found in class 0 and i protostars , but also edge - on disks ( see hops 82 , 85 , 89 , 90 , 92 , 129 , 150 , 200 , 210 , 211 , 281 , 304 , 331 , and 363 ) .
only two flat - spectrum sources have prominent silicate emission features , and their seds are reminiscent of protoplanetary disks ( see hops 187 and 199 ) .
thus , flat - spectrum sources likely include objects of a variety of evolutionary stages .
values at each inclination angle for the class 0 and i protostars ( _ squares _ ) and the flat - spectrum sources ( _ circles _ ) in our sample .
[ rho_inc_flat - spectrum ] ] the latter conclusion can also be drawn when analyzing the distribution of envelope reference densities and inclination angles for flat - spectrum sources . in figure
[ rho_inc_class ] , we showed that flat - spectrum sources typically have intermediate inclination angles and lower envelope densities . to compare their properties more directly to class 0 and i protostars , in figure [ rho_inc_flat - spectrum ]
we show the median best - fit @xmath68 value at each best - fit inclination angle ; it is larger for class 0 and i protostars than for flat - spectrum sources at all inclination angles . for class 0 and i protostars ,
the median @xmath68 value is highest at intermediate inclination angles , decreases at larger inclination angles , and then increases again for @xmath192 80 . for flat - spectrum sources ,
the median @xmath68 value is relatively flat over the 1863region but has its peak value at @xmath18141 ; it decreases for larger inclination angles .
the only flat - spectrum source with a best - fit inclination angle of 81 , hops 357 , has a very low envelope density ( the lowest value for this parameter in the model grid ) , and its spectrum displays a deep silicate absorption feature .
overall , this shows that , while a range of envelope densities and inclination angles can explain flat - spectrum sources , their envelope densities are typically lower than for class 0 and i protostars .
the higher - density objects are seen at low to intermediate inclination angles , while only the lowest - density objects are seen closer to edge - on
. some of the high - density flat - spectrum sources could actually be more embedded protostars ( stage 0 objects ) seen face - on ( which would be classified as class 0 objects if seen at larger inclination angles ) .
thus , in terms of envelope evolution , they include a diverse group of objects .
we note that even though we find that flat - spectrum sources have in general lower envelope densities than class 0 and class i objects , their best fit does include an envelope in almost all cases ; just 3 of the 102 flat - spectrum sources are best fit without an envelope .
this seems to contradict recent findings by @xcite , who found that only about 50% of flat - spectrum sources were actually protostars surrounded by envelopes .
this could be partly explained by different criteria used to select flat - spectrum sources ; in the @xcite sample , flat - spectrum sources are selected by their extinction - corrected 2 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral index ( see also @xcite ) , while our sample uses a flat 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral index .
moreover , in their study @xcite detected the presence of an envelope via hco@xmath209 emission , and they found that almost all sources detected in the sub - mm are also detected in hco@xmath209 ( but the opposite does not always hold ) . for our sample of orion protostars , we find that 75% of class 0+i protostars observed with saboca ( 350 @xmath0 m ) are detected , while only 47% of flat - spectrum sources have detections . for laboca observations ( 870 @xmath0 m )
, these two fractions amount to 41% and 21% , respectively .
thus , we find that flat - spectrum sources have a @xmath1 50% lower sub - mm detection rate than class 0+i protostars .
flat - spectrum sources without sub - mm detections would likely also not display hco@xmath209 emission and thus would be considered as protostars without envelopes by @xcite . to compare how our submillimeter detections correlate with the presence of an envelope , in figures [ rho_f350 ] and [ rho_f870 ] we show the derived best - fit reference envelope densities as a function of 350 or 870 @xmath0 m fluxes for the combined class 0+i sample and the flat - spectrum sources .
we also differentiate the distribution of envelope densities between measured flux values and upper limits ; at 870 @xmath0 m , the upper limits are often cases where the sources are not detected due to confusion with bright , spatially varying emission .
we find that even protostars with upper limits at 350 and 870 @xmath0 m are best fit with an envelope ; however , the envelope density is lower for objects with upper limits in the sub - mm .
this is especially evident for class 0+i protostars ; for flat - spectrum sources , the distributions of envelope densities for sub - mm detections and upper limits show significant overlap .
four times as many flat - spectrum sources have upper limits instead of detections at 870 @xmath0 m , but their derived @xmath68 values span almost the full range of values .
furthermore , the median @xmath68 value of 1.19 @xmath210 g @xmath33 for sources without detections is relatively close to the median value of 5.95 @xmath71 g @xmath33 for the sources with 870 @xmath0 m detections .
thus , our model fits do not rely on sub - mm detections to yield a best fit with an envelope ; in most cases the near- to far - ir sed is sufficient to constrain the properties of the envelope . among the six objects
whose best - fit sed required no envelope ( @xmath68 value of 0 ) , three are flat - spectrum sources ( hops 47 , 187 , 265 ) , two are class ii pre - main - sequence stars ( hops 113 , 293 ) , and one is a class i protostar ( hops 232 ) .
the low 70 @xmath0
m fluxes of hops 47 and 265 constrained the best model to one without an envelope .
the sed of hops 187 looks like that of a transitional disk , which are disks with gaps or holes in their inner regions ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
if hops 187 were a transitional disk , it would not have an envelope .
hops 232 has a rising sed over the mid - ir spectral range ; its best fit requires no envelope , but an edge - on disk with a high accretion luminosity .
it would be expected that the seds of class ii objects can be best fit by a model that does not include an envelope .
this is the case for hops 113 and 293 .
of the nine remaining class ii objects in our sample , four have very low envelope densities ( @xmath211 g @xmath33 ; hops 22 , 26 , 98 , 283 ) , while five have @xmath68 between @xmath212 and @xmath213 g @xmath33 ( hops 184 , 201 , 222 , 272 , 277 ) .
the seds of hops 22 , 184 , and 201 are similar to those of transitional disks , with some silicate emission at 10 @xmath0 m and a rising sed between about 13 and 20 @xmath0 m .
the best - fit models require some envelope emission to fit the long - wavelength data .
hops 222 , 272 , and 277 lie close to the border between a class ii pre - main - sequence star and a flat - spectrum source based on their 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral index , and therefore they could have some envelope material left , despite being classified as class ii objects .
overall , of the 330 ysos in our sample , 319 were classified as either class 0 , class i , or flat - spectrum protostars based on their seds . however , four of them are best fit without an envelope .
conversely , of the 11 class ii objects in our sample , nine are best fit with an envelope ; however , three of these might be transitional disks . thus , based on our model
fits and seds , 321 of our 330 ysos are protostars with envelopes , and nine are likely pre - main - sequence stars with disks .
the luminosity distribution of protostars is a significant constraint on protostellar evolution , and it is important to understand the effect of the envelope on the observed luminosity ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the bolometric luminosity distribution of the hops protostars is very similar to that determined for the _ spitzer_-identified protostars by @xcite with a peak near 1 @xmath19 ( fig . [ hops_n_tbol_lbol_histo ] ) . in contrast , the distribution of the total luminosities from the models shows a peak near 2.5 @xmath19 ( fig . [ ltot_class_histo ] ) , indicating that the luminosities of protostars may be systematically underestimated by the bolometric luminosities , which do not take into account the inclination angle ( and thus beaming of the radiation along the outflow cavities ) as well as foreground extinction ( see fig .
[ ltot_lbol ] in section [ results_overview ] ) .
higher intrinsic luminosities for protostars could help address the `` luminosity problem '' first pointed out by @xcite , who found that the luminosities of protostars are lower by about an order of magnitude than a simple estimate of the expected accretion luminosity .
however , an increase in the luminosity by a factor of 2.5 - 3 would not solve the problem ; solutions proposed by other authors , such as mass - dependent accretion rates @xcite or episodic accretion events @xcite , are still needed .
our best - fit models also suggest that class 0 protostars have a different distribution of @xmath82 values compared to class i protostars or flat - spectrum sources .
their median total luminosity is higher , which could be an indication of larger accretion luminosities for younger protostars .
we must bear in mind the caveats and degeneracies mentioned above ; in particular , in some cases the higher luminosity could be related to the adoption of an overly large inclination angle , which results in most of the emitted radiation not reaching the observer . nevertheless , these differences have potentially important implications for protostellar evolution , which will be discussed in a future publication ( w. fischer et al .
2016 , in preparation ) .
although the tsc models provide impressive fits to the seds , some of the observed trends suggest problems with the models .
first , the distribution of inclination angles ( fig .
[ inc_histo ] ) deviates from what we expect from a randomly oriented sample of protostars .
although this could result from unintentional selection biases in our sample of protostars , it may also be the effect of applying the wrong envelope model to the data .
furthermore , our data show flat distributions in cavity opening angles for class 0 and flat - spectrum sources , but an excess of small cavities for the class i protostars ( figure [ cav_class_histo ] ) .
we also find that protostars with large cavities often have high envelope densities ( figure [ rho1000_inc_cavity ] ) .
for example , models with high envelope densities viewed more edge - on require large cavity opening angles and high @xmath82 values to generate sufficient mid - ir flux ; this is the case for a few of our highest - luminosity objects ( hops 87 , 108 , and 178 ) .
these trends do not support the notion of increasing cavity size with later evolutionary stage , which would be expected if outflows play a major role in dispersing envelopes @xcite .
this may suggest that cavity sizes are not growing with time ; however , this may also imply a deviation from spherical symmetry for the initial configuration of the collapsing envelopes .
such a deviation may result if the envelope collapses from the fragmentation of a flattened sheet or elongated filament .
finally , we find an excess of small values of @xmath49 , and therefore small centrifugal radii , for class i and flat - spectrum protostars ( figure [ rdisk_class_histo ] ) .
this is contrary to the expectation from the tsc model , in which the late stages of protostellar evolution are characterized by the infall of high angular momentum material from large radii and hence larger values of @xmath44 .
this may imply that disks sizes are small , but it may also be the result of incorrect assumptions about the distribution of angular momentum in the tsc model . in total , these `` conundrums '' that arise from our model fits hint that the current models do not realistically reproduce the structure of collapsing envelopes .
future high - resolution observations at submillimeter and longer wavelengths that resolve the structure and motions of envelopes may provide the means to develop more refined models that can fit the seds with more realistic envelope configurations .
we have presented seds and model fits for 330 young stellar objects in the orion a and b molecular clouds .
the seds include data from 1.2 to 870 @xmath0 m , with near - infrared photometry from 2mass , mid - infrared photometry and spectra from the _ spitzer space telescope _ , far - infrared photometry at 70 , 100 , and 160 @xmath0 m from the _ herschel space observatory _ , and submillimeter photometry from the apex telescope .
we calculated bolometric luminosities ( @xmath16 ) , bolometric temperatures ( @xmath8 ) , and 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral indices ( @xmath18 ) for all 330 sources in our sample . from the distributions of these three parameters , we find that @xmath16 has a broad peak near 1 @xmath19 and extends from 0.02 to several hundred @xmath19 , while the distribution of @xmath8 values is broad and flat from about 30 k to 800 k , with a median value of 146 k. the 4.5 - 24 @xmath0 m spectral indices range from -0.75 to 2.6 , with a peak near 0 . based on traditional classification schemes involving @xmath18 and @xmath8 ,
we have identified 92 sources as class 0 protostars ( @xmath214 and @xmath215 k ) , 125 as class i protostars ( @xmath214 and @xmath216 k ) , and 102 as flat - spectrum sources ( @xmath23 ) .
the remaining 11 sources are class ii pre - main - sequence stars with @xmath217 ; most of them just missed the flat - spectrum cutoff , and three have seds typical of disks with inner holes . considering these transitional disks and ysos whose best fit does not require an envelope , we find that 321 of the 330 hops targets in our sample are protostars with envelopes . class 0 and i protostars often display a deep silicate absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m due to the presence of the envelope , while many flat - spectrum sources have a weak silicate emission or absorption feature at that wavelength .
we have used a grid of 30,400 protostellar model seds , calculated using the 2008 version of the @xcite monte carlo radiative transfer code , to find the best - fit models for each observed sed .
the grid is limited to discrete values for protostellar parameters , and their ranges were chosen to represent typical protostars . within the framework of these models , we find the following : * about 70% of class 0 protostars , 75% of class i protostars , and close to 90% of flat - spectrum sources have reliable sed fits ( @xmath159 , where @xmath154 is a measure of the average distance between model and data in units of the fractional uncertainty ) .
thus , our model grid can reproduce most of the observed seds of orion protostars . *
our results show a clear trend of decreasing envelope densities as we progress from class 0 to class i and then to flat - spectrum sources : we find that the median @xmath68 values decrease from 5.9 @xmath72 g @xmath33 to 2.4 @xmath71 g @xmath33 to 1.2 @xmath71 g @xmath33 .
the decrease in densities implies a decrease in the infall rates of the protostars as they evolve .
we find that the pacs bright red sources ( pbrs ) have median @xmath68 values twice as high as the median value of the class 0 protostars in our sample , supporting the interpretation that they are likely the youngest protostars in orion .
* there are degeneracies in the parameters for models that reproduce the observed seds .
for example , increasing the mid - ir sed slope and deepening the silicate absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m of a model protostar can be done by increasing the envelope density or inclination angle , decreasing the cavity opening angle or centrifugal radius , or even increasing the foreground extinction .
hence , the properties of a specific source may be fit by a wide range of parameters .
the best - fit model parameters are particularly uncertain for objects whose sed is not well constrained by observations . because of these degeneracies , the observed classes contain a mixture of evolutionary stages . * we find that flat - spectrum sources are particularly well fit by our models .
they have , on average , lower envelope densities and intermediate inclination angles , so many flat - spectrum sources are likely more evolved protostars , but this group also includes protostars with higher envelope densities ( and sometimes larger cavity opening angles ) seen at lower inclination angles .
flat - spectrum sources seen at @xmath192 65 have very tenuous envelopes .
thus , the sample of flat - spectrum sources includes protostars at different stages in their envelope evolution .
all but three of the flat - spectrum sources in our sample have envelopes in their best - fit models , indicating that , with a small number of exceptions , these objects are protostars with infalling gas . * the luminosity function for the model luminosities peaks at a higher luminosity than that for the observed bolometric luminosities as a result of beaming along the outflow cavities .
furthermore , the total luminosity determined by the models is higher for class 0 protostars : the median total luminosities are 5.5 , 2.0 , and 3.0 @xmath19 for class 0 , class i , and flat - spectrum sources , respectively . * since heating by external radiation fields is not included in our model grid , we assessed its influence by adding an interstellar radiation field to a set of models .
we find that an isrf ten times that typical of the solar neighborhood can substantially change the seds of sources with internal luminosities of 0.1 @xmath19 .
however , when we incorporate the effect of extinction on the external radiation field , the effect on the protostellar seds is smaller ; the best - fit luminosities and envelope densities would be overestimated by factors of a few for @xmath1 0.1 @xmath19 prototars and much less for higher - luminosity protostars .
we estimate that the best - fit parameters ( in particular , @xmath82 , @xmath68 ) of @xmath1 20% of the hops sources could be affected by external heating . *
although the adopted tsc models reproduce the observed seds well , there are trends that suggest inadequacies with these models .
first , the distribution of best - fit inclination angles does not reproduce that expected for randomly oriented protostars .
second , although the distribution of outflow cavity sizes for flat - spectrum and class 0 sources is flat , there is an excess of small cavities for class i sources .
this is in contradiction to the typical picture that outflow cavities grow as protostars evolve .
finally , the distribution of outer disk radii set by the rotation of the envelope is concentrated at small values ( @xmath29 50 au ) for the class i and flat - spectrum sources but is slightly tilted toward large values ( @xmath26 50 au ) for class 0 protostars .
again , this trend contradicts the expected growth of disks as the infall region in protostellar envelopes expands .
these findings suggest that either the envelope structure of the adopted models is incorrect , or our understanding of the evolution of protostars needs to be revised substantially .
our work provides a large sample of protostars in one molecular cloud complex for future , more detailed studies of protostellar evolution .
for example , using additional constraints , such as from scattered light imaging , the structure of envelope cavities and thus the role of outflows can be better understood .
in addition , the detailed structure of the envelope and the disk embedded within , as well as multiplicity of the central source , can be studied with high spatial resolution imaging such as alma can provide . with the analysis of their seds presented in this work
, the hops protostars constitute an ideal sample to derive a better understanding of the early evolution of young stars , when the assembly of the stellar mass and the initial stages of planet formation likely take place .
support for this work was provided by nasa through awards issued by jpl / caltech .
the work of w.j.f . was supported in part by an appointment to the nasa postdoctoral program at goddard space flight center , administered by oak ridge associated universities through a contract with nasa .
acknowledges support provided by nasa through hubble fellowship grant # hst - hf-51300.01-a awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 .
j.j.t acknowledges further support from grant 639.041.439 from the netherlands organisation for scientific research ( nwo ) .
the work of a.m.s . was supported by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft priority program 1573 ( `` physics of the interstellar medium '' ) .
m.o . acknowledges support from mineco ( spain ) aya2011 - 3o228-co3 - 01 and aya2014 - 57369-c3 - 3-p grants ( co - funded with feder funds ) .
we thank thomas robitaille for helpful discussions regarding the model grid and model parameters . this work is based on observations made with the _
spitzer space telescope _ , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory ( jpl ) , california institute of technology ( caltech ) , under a contract with nasa ; it is also based on observations made with the _ herschel space observatory _
, a european space agency cornerstone mission with significant participation by nasa .
spacecraft was designed , built , tested , and launched under a contract to esa managed by the _
herschel / planck _ project team by an industrial consortium under the overall responsibility of the prime contractor thales alenia space ( cannes ) , and including astrium ( friedrichshafen ) responsible for the payload module and for system testing at spacecraft level , thales alenia space ( turin ) responsible for the service module , and astrium ( toulouse ) responsible for the telescope , with in excess of a hundred subcontractors .
we also include data from the atacama pathfinder experiment , a collaboration between the max - planck institut fr radioastronomie , the european southern observatory , and the onsala space observatory .
this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / caltech , funded by nasa and the nsf .
adams , f. c. , & shu , f. h. 1986 , , 308 , 836 adams , f. c. , lada , ch .
j. , & shu , f. h. 1987 , , 312 , 788 adams , j. d. , herter , t. l. , osorio , m. , et al .
2012 , apjl , 749 , l24 ali , b. , tobin , j. j. , fischer , w. j. , et al .
2010 , , 518 , l119 andr , p. , ward - thompson , d. , & barsony , m. 1993 , , 406 , 122 andr , p. , & montmerle , t. 1994 , , 420 , 837 andr , p. , menshchikov , a. , bontemps , s. , et al .
2010 , , 518 , l102 arce , h. g. , & sargent , a. i. 2006 , , 646 , 1070 billot , n. , morales - caldern , m. , stauffer , j. r. , et al .
2012 , apjl , 753 , l35 boogert , a. c. a. , pontoppidan , k. m. , knez , c. , et al .
2008 , , 678 , 985 calvet , n. , hartmann , l. , kenyon , s. j. , & whitney , b. a. 1994 , , 434 , 330 caratti o garatti , a. , garcia lopez , r. , scholz , a. , et al .
2011 , , 526 , l1 cassen , p. , & moosman , a. 1981 , , 48 , 353 chen , h. , myers , p. c. , ladd , e. f. , & wood , d. o. s. 1995 , , 445 , 377 cody , a. m. , stauffer , j. , baglin , a. , et al .
2014 , , 147 , 82 cohen , m. , wheaton , w. a. , & megeath , s. t. 2003 , , 126 , 1090 crapsi , a. , van dishoeck , e. f. , hogerheijde , m. r. , et al .
2008 , , 486 , 245 di francesco , j. , evans , n. j. , ii , caselli , p. , et al .
2007 , in protostars & planets v , reipurth b. , jewitt d. , keil k. ( eds . ) , univ .
arizona , tucson , p. 17
draine , b. t. 2003 , , 41,241 dunham , m. m. , crapsi , a. , evans , n. j. , ii , et al .
2008 , , 179 , 249 dunham , m. m. , evans , n. j. , ii , terebey , s. , et al .
2010 , , 710 , 470 dunham , m. m. , & vorobyov , e. i. 2012 , , 747 , 52 dunham , m. m. , arce , h. g. , allen , l. e. , et al .
2013 , , 145 , 94 dunham , m. m. , stutz , a. m. , allen , l. e. , et al .
2014 , in protostars & planets vi , beuther h. , klessen r. s. , dullemond c. p. , henning t. ( eds . ) , univ .
arizona , tucson , p. 195 dunham , m. m. , allen , l. e. , evans , n. j. , ii , et al .
2015 , , 220 , 11 engelbracht , c. w. , blaylock , m. , su , k. y. l. , et al .
2007 , , 119 , 994 enoch , m. , evans , n. j. , ii , sargent , a. i. , & glenn , j. 2009 , , 692 , 973 espaillat , c. , muzerolle , j. , najita , j. , et al .
2014 , in protostars & planets vi , beuther h. , klessen r. s. , dullemond c. p. , henning t ( eds . ) , univ .
arizona , tucson , p. 497
evans , n. j. , ii , rawlings , j. m. c. , shirley , y. l. , & mundy , l. g. 2001 , , 557 , 193 evans , n. j. , ii , dunham , m. m. , jrgensen , j. k. , et al . 2009 , , 181 , 321 fazio , g. g. , hora , j. l. , allen , l. e. , et al .
2004 , , 154 , 10 fischer , w. j. , megeath , s. t. , ali , b. , et al .
2010 , , 518 , l122 fischer , w. j. , megeath , s. t. , tobin , j. j. , et al .
2012 , , 756 , 99 fischer , w. j. , megeath , s. t. , stutz , a. m. , et al .
2013 , an , 334 , 53 fischer , w. j. , megeath , s. t. , tobin , j. j. , et al .
2014 , , 781 , 123 furlan , e. , mcclure , m. , calvet , n. , et al .
2008 , , 176 , 184 furlan , e. , megeath , s. t. , osorio , m. , et al .
2014 , , 786 , 26 greene , t. p. , wilking , b. a. , andr , p. , et al .
1994 , , 434 , 614 gnther , h. m. , cody , a. m. , covey , k. r. , et al .
2014 , , 148 , 122 hartmann , l. , calvet , n. , & boss , a. , 1996 , , 464 , 387 heiderman , a. , & evans , n. j. , ii 2015 , , 806 , 231 houck , j. r. , roellig , t. l. , van cleve , j. , et al .
2004 , , 154 , 18 kenyon , s. j. , hartmann , l. w. , strom , k. m. , & strom , s. e. 1990 , , 99 , 869 kenyon , s. j. , calvet , n. , & hartmann , l. 1993 , , 414 , 676 kim , m. k. , hirota , t. , honma , m. , et al .
2008 , , 60 , 991 kim , k. h. , watson , d. m. , manoj , p. , et al .
2013 , , 769 , 149 kim , k. h. , watson , d. m. , manoj , p. , et al .
2016 , , submitted kounkel , m. , megeath , s. t. , poteet , c. a. , et al .
2016 , , in press , arxiv:1602.07635 kryukova , e. , megeath , s. t. , gutermuth , r. a. , et al .
2012 , , 144 , 31 kryukova , e. , megeath , s. t. , hora , j. l. , et al .
2014 , , 148 , 11 lada , ch .
j. 1987 , in star forming regions , proceedings of the iau symposium no .
m. peimbert & j. jugaku , dordrecht : reidel , 1 launhardt , r. , stutz , a. m. , schmiedeke , a. , et al .
2013 , , 551 , a98 lim , j. , & takakuwa , s. 2006 , , 653 , 425 manoj , p. , watson , d. m. , neufeld , d. a. , et al .
2013 , , 763 , 83 mathis , j. s. , mezger , p. g. , & panagia , n. 1983 , , 128 , 212 mathis , j. s. 1990 , , 28 , 37 maury , a. j. , andr , p. , menshchikov , a. , et al .
2011 , , 535 , a77 mcclure , m. 2009 , apjl , 693 , l81 megeath , s. t. , gutermuth , r. , muzerolle , j. , et al .
2012 , , 144 , 192 menten , k. m. , reid , m. j. , forbrich , j. , & brunthaler , a. 2007 , , 474 , 515 morales - caldern , m. , stauffer , j. r. , hillenbrand , l. a. , et al .
2011 , , 733 , 50 myers , p. c. , & ladd , e. f. 1993 , apjl , 413 , l47 offner , s. s. r. , & mckee , c. f. 2011 , , 736 , 53 ormel , c. w. , min , m. , tielens , a. g. g. m. , dominik , c. , & paszun , d. 2011 , , 532 , a43 ossenkopf , v. , & henning , t. 1994 , , 291 , 943 pilbratt , g. l. , riedinger , j. r. , passvogel , t. , et al .
2010 , , 518 , l1 pillitteri , i. , wolk , s. j. , megeath , s. t. , et al .
2013 , , 768 , 99 poglitsch , a. , waelkens , c. , geis , n. , et al .
2010 , , 518 , l2 pontoppidan , k. m. , boogert , a. c. a. , fraser , h. j. , et al .
2008 , , 678 , 1005 poppenhaeger , k. , cody , a. m. , covey , k. r. 2015 , , 150 , 118 poteet , c. a. , megeath , s. t. , watson , d. m. , et al .
2011 , apjl , 733 , l32 reach , w. t. , megeath , s. t. , cohen , m. , et al .
2005 , , 117 , 978 rebull , l. m. , cody , a. m. , covey , k. r. , et al .
2014 , , 148 , 92 rebull , l. m. , stauffer , j. r. , cody , a. m. , et al .
2015 , , 150 , 175 rieke , g. h. , young , e. t. , engelbracht , c. w. , et al .
2004 , , 154 , 25 robitaille , t. p. , whitney , b. a. , indebetouw , r. , et al .
2006 , , 167 , 256 rodrguez , l. f. , dalessio , p. , wilner , d. j. , et al . 1998 , nature , 395 , 355 sadavoy , s. i. , di francesco , j. , andr , p. , et al . 2014 ,
apjl , 787 , l18 safron , e. j. , fischer , w. j. , megeath , s. t. , et al .
2015 , apjl , 800 , l5 shirley , y. l. , evans , n. j. , ii , & rawlings , j. m. c. 2002 , , 575 , 337 siringo , g. , kreysa , e. , de breuck , c. , et al .
2010 , the messenger , 139 , 20 siringo , g. , kreysa , e. , kovcs , a. , et al .
2009 , , 497 , 945 skrutskie , m. f. , cutri , r. m. , stiening , r. , et al .
2006 , , 131 , 1163 stanke , t. , stutz , a. m. , tobin , j. j. , et al .
2010 , , 518 , l94 stutz , a. m. , launhardt , r. , linz , h. , et al .
2010 , , 518 l87 stutz , a. m. , tobin , j. j. , stanke , t. , et al .
2013 , , 767 , 36 stutz , a. m. , & kainulainen 2015 , , 577 , l6 terebey , s. , shu , f. h. , & cassen , p. 1984
, , 286 , 529 tobin , j. j. , hartmann , l. , calvet , n. , & dalessio , p. 2008
, , 679 , 1364 tobin , j. j. , hartmann , l. , bergin , e. , et al .
2012 , , 748 , 16 tobin , j. j. , stutz , a. m. , megeath , s. t. , et al .
2015 , , 798 , 128 ulrich , r. k. 1976 , , 210 , 377 werner , m. w. , roellig , t. l. , low , f. j. , et al .
2004 , , 154 , 1 whitney , b. a. , wood , k. , bjorkman , j. e. , & wolff , m. j. 2003a , , 591 , 1049 whitney , b. a. , wood , k. , bjorkman , j. e. , & cohen , m. 2003b , , 598 , 1079 whitney , b. a. , robitaille , t. p. , bjorkman , j. e. , et al .
2013 , , 207 , 30 winston , e. , megeath , s. t. , wolk , s. j. , et al .
2010 , , 140 , 266 wolk , s. j. , gnther , h. m. , poppenhaeger , k. , et al .
2015 , , 150 , 145 young , c. h. , shirley , y. l. , evans , n. j. , ii , & rawlings , j. m. c. 2003 , , 145 , 111 young , c. h. , & evans , n. j. , ii 2005 , , 627 , 293
lrrclllccccccccl[h ] hops 1 & 88.5514 & 1.7099 & i & 1.517 & 72.6 & 1.469 & 3.0 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0133 & 5 & 63 & 23.2 & 0.99 & 2.319 + hops 2 & 88.5380 & 1.7144 & i & 0.542 & 356.5 & 0.455 & 1.3 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 32 & 13.1 & 1.30 & 2.476 + hops 3 & 88.7374 & 1.7156 & flat & 0.553 & 467.5 & 0.260 & 0.820 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 50 & 3.0 & 0.81 & 3.331 + hops 4 & 88.7240 & 1.7861 & i & 0.422 & 203.3 & 1.243 & 0.600 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0099 & 5 & 63 & 2.5 & 2.00 & 4.139 + hops 5 & 88.6340 & 1.8020 & i & 0.390 & 187.1 & 0.626 & 1.6 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0096 & 35 & 63 & 12.4 & 0.52 & 2.459 + hops 6 & 88.5767 & 1.8176 & i & 0.055 & 112.5 & 1.308 & 0.210 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0010 & 5 & 76 & 8.0 & 2.00 & 4.091 + hops 7 & 88.5835 & 1.8452 & 0 & 0.528 & 58.0 & 1.707 & 6.1 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0010 & 15 & 81 & 18.7 & 2.00 & 2.981 + hops 10 & 83.7875 & -5.9743 & 0 & 3.330 & 46.2 & 0.787 & 5.4 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.135 & 5 & 70 & 0.0 & 1.77 & 3.168 + hops 11 & 83.8059 & -5.9661 & 0 & 8.997 & 48.8 & 2.200 & 33.2 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.115 & 25 & 63 & 39.8 & 1.10 & 3.385 + hops 12 & 83.7858 & -5.9317 & 0 & 7.309 & 42.0 & 1.815 & 5.8 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.332 & 5 & 32 & 0.0 & 1.91 & 2.207 + hops 13 & 83.8523 & -5.9260 & flat & 1.146 & 383.6 & 0.208 & 2.4 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 18 & 15.2 & 0.78 & 2.149 + hops 15 & 84.0792 & -5.9237 & flat & 0.171 & 342.0 & 0.116 & 0.600 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0745 & 45 & 63 & 9.0 & 2.00 & 3.329 + hops 16 & 83.7534 & -5.9238 & flat & 0.682 & 361.0 & 0.019 & 3.0 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0548 & 45 & 18 & 25.4 & 0.99 & 2.464 + hops 17 & 83.7799 & -5.8683 & i & 0.299 & 341.3 & 0.389 & 1.5 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0080 & 35 & 63 & 0.0 & 0.50 & 5.279 + hops 18 & 83.7729 & -5.8651 & i & 1.419 & 71.8 & 0.743 & 5.2 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0851 & 25 & 76 & 1.1 & 0.51 & 4.915 + hops 19 & 83.8583 & -5.8563 & flat & 0.188 & 101.6 & -0.098 & 0.150 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath74 & 6.53 & 15 & 18 & 3.7 & 0.50 & 5.445 + hops 20 & 83.3780 & -5.8447 & i & 1.231 & 94.8 & 2.226 & 1.6 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0329 & 5 & 76 & 7.3 & 0.54 & 5.333 + hops 22 & 83.7522 & -5.8172 & ii & 0.100 & 238.2 & 0.494 & 0.290 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 63 & 7.5 & 0.97 & 3.049 + hops 24 & 83.6956 & -5.7475 & i & 0.095 & 288.9 & 0.438 & 0.150 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0099 & 5 & 57 & 3.2 & 0.50 & 3.998 + hops 26 & 83.8223 & -5.7040 & ii & 0.484 & 1124.9 & -0.400 & 1.1 & 5 & 1.78
@xmath70 & 0.0007 & 35 & 70 & 0.0 & 1.10 & 3.291 + hops 28 & 83.6971 & -5.6989 & 0 & 0.494 & 46.3 & 1.342 & 2.6 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0731 & 35 & 76 & 2.4 & 0.84 & 3.327 + hops 29 & 83.7044 & -5.6950 & i & 1.916 & 148.2 & 0.687 & 6.1 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0044 & 45 & 63 & 3.8 & 0.60 & 4.113 + hops 30 & 83.6836 & -5.6905 & i & 3.791 & 81.2 & 1.836 & 21.2 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.381 & 45 & 57 & 39.5 & 0.70 & 2.494 + hops 32 & 83.6477 & -5.6664 & 0 & 2.011 & 58.9 & 0.937 & 3.0 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0937 & 15 & 70 & 7.7 & 0.97 & 3.527 + hops 33 & 83.6884 & -5.6658 & flat & 0.120 & 777.6 & -0.397 & 0.400 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0071 & 35 & 70 & 5.3 & 1.34 & 3.797 + hops 36 & 83.6101 & -5.6279 & flat & 1.024 & 374.6 & 0.005 & 2.2 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 18 & 16.4 & 0.71 & 3.552 + hops 38 & 83.7697 & -5.6201 & 0 & 0.246 & 58.5 & 0.935 & 2.0 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath74 & 5.48 & 45 & 18 & 80.0 & 1.96 & 7.198 + hops 40 & 83.7855 & -5.5998 & 0 & 2.694 & 38.1 & 1.247 & 6.1 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 0.974 & 35 & 41 & 82.6 & 2.00 & 5.459 + hops 41 & 83.6227 & -5.5952 & i & 1.939 & 82.3 & 1.546 & 7.9 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0957 & 35 & 63 & 27.2 & 0.78 & 3.663 + hops 42 & 83.7710 & -5.5946 & i & 0.276 & 200.9 & 0.767 & 1.0 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0126 & 15 & 70 & 4.5 & 0.99 & 2.776 + hops 43 & 83.7688 & -5.5873 & i & 3.261 & 75.0 & 0.527 & 6.6 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 0.957 & 35 & 41 & 40.9 & 0.65 & 3.493 + hops 44 & 83.7941 & -5.5851 & 0 & 1.748 & 43.8 & 0.714 & 2.0 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath74 & 7.18 & 35 & 41 & 8.4 & 0.65 & 2.774 + hops 45 & 83.7769 & -5.5598 & flat & 8.496 & 517.8 & 0.354 & 7.4 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.572 & 45 & 18 & 2.1 & 0.73 & 1.506 + hops 47 & 83.4411 & -5.5495 & flat & 0.112 & 558.4 & -0.152 & 0.500 & 5 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 5 & 70 & 4.0 & 0.50 & 4.794 + hops 49 & 83.7037 & -5.5294 & i & 0.716 & 356.8 & 1.136 & 6.2 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 15 & 76 & 0.0 & 0.61 & 2.538 + hops 50 & 83.6704 & -5.5290 & 0 & 4.200 & 51.4 & 1.438 & 25.9 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0656 & 45 & 81 & 3.3 & 0.86 & 3.251 + hops 53 & 83.4891 & -5.3918 & 0 & 26.424 & 45.9 & 2.112 & 50.5 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.326 & 15 & 87 & 15.2 & 0.50 & 3.030 + hops 56 & 83.8311 & -5.2591 & 0 & 23.323 & 48.1 & 1.310 & 60.4 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.803 & 35 & 50 & 52.7 & 2.00 & 2.808 + hops 57 & 83.8326 & -5.2524 & flat & 3.223 & 421.2 & 0.263 & 5.1 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0312 & 15 & 50 & 0.0 & 0.50 & 2.524 + hops 58 & 83.8271 & -5.2273 & flat & 4.509 & 620.0 & -0.073 & 5.8 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 41 & 4.8 & 1.91 & 1.484 + hops 59 & 83.8339 & -5.2210 & flat & 49.447 & 528.4 & -0.189 & 30.3 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.125 & 15 & 18 & 2.5 & 1.00 & 2.566 + hops 60 & 83.8472 & -5.2009 & 0 & 21.926 & 54.1 & 1.175 & 78.7 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.113 & 25 & 81 & 8.3 & 0.78 & 4.395 + hops 65 & 83.8398 & -5.1607 & i & 0.352 & 545.7 & 0.417 & 0.570 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 32 & 7.3 & 1.89 & 4.431 + hops 66 & 83.8618 & -5.1568 & flat & 20.954 & 264.9 & 0.074 & 315.6 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0028 & 25 & 76 & 22.4 & 1.04 & 3.156 + hops 68 & 83.8513 & -5.1418 & i & 5.675 & 100.6 & 0.752 & 15.1 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 0.958 & 35 & 50 & 9.0 & 0.50 & 3.761 + hops 70 & 83.8434 & -5.1347 & flat & 6.905 & 619.3 & -0.109 & 5.7 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath74 & 4.37 & 45 & 41 & 1.2 & 0.56 & 2.334 + hops 71 & 83.8567 & -5.1326 & i & 5.602 & 277.5 & 0.936 & 18.3 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0013 & 15 & 63 & 0.0 & 1.81 & 3.628 + hops 73 & 83.8654 & -5.1176 & 0 & 1.697 & 43.0 & 1.778 & 5.5 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0974 & 35 & 70 & 0.0 & 1.79 & 3.650 + hops 74 & 83.8536 & -5.1059 & flat & 1.143 & 516.5 & 0.043 & 2.6 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 45 & 50 & 14.9 & 0.86 & 3.486 + hops 75 & 83.8611 & -5.1029 & 0 & 4.025 & 67.9 & 0.909 & 20.2 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 0.762 & 45 & 57 & 47.1 & 2.00 & 3.366 + hops 76 & 83.8573 & -5.0994 & i & 1.855 & 135.5 & -0.428 & 8.6 & 5 & 1.78
@xmath72 & 0.0548 & 45 & 63 & 40.1 & 0.85 & 4.428 + hops 77 & 83.8814 & -5.0965 & flat & 12.877 & 550.3 & -0.171 & 18.6 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0062 & 15 & 18 & 9.4 & 0.62 & 2.196 + hops 78 & 83.8576 & -5.0955 & 0 & 8.930 & 38.1 & 1.246 & 60.4 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.244 & 35 & 81 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 3.764 + lrrclllccccccccl hops 80 & 83.8549 & -5.0860 & flat & 0.079 & 275.3 & 0.016 & 0.330 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.373 & 45 & 57 & 0.9 & 1.08 & 2.328 + hops 81 & 83.8665 & -5.0828 & 0 & 1.238 & 40.1 & 0.851 & 6.1 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 87 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 2.740 + hops 82 & 83.8322 & -5.0818 & flat & 2.404 & 116.4 & 0.180 & 18.7 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0548 & 45 & 41 & 59.9 & 1.85 & 2.307 + hops 84 & 83.8607 & -5.0653 & i & 49.112 & 90.8 & 1.492 & 60.4 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0337 & 5 & 57 & 6.1 & 2.00 & 3.319 + hops 85 & 83.8674 & -5.0614 & flat & 16.277 & 174.2 & 0.253 & 133.1 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.373 & 45 & 50 & 62.3 & 1.32 & 3.129 + hops 86 & 83.8485 & -5.0279 & i & 3.273 & 112.7 & 1.487 & 46.1 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0013 & 5 & 70 & 58.1 & 1.53 & 3.704 + hops 87 & 83.8478 & -5.0246 & 0 & 36.488 & 38.1 & 1.915 & 562.9 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0975 & 35 & 87 & 51.1 & 1.85 & 4.977 + hops 88 & 83.8435 & -5.0206 & 0 & 15.814 & 42.4 & 2.541 & 124.9 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.437 & 45 & 70 & 49.1 & 1.24 & 3.958 + hops 89 & 83.8332 & -5.0174 & flat & 1.582 & 158.3 & -0.075 & 18.1 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 57 & 65.9 & 0.60 & 4.477 + hops 90 & 83.8936 & -5.0145 & flat & 2.782 & 417.7 & -0.056 & 6.3 & 5 & 1.19
@xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 57 & 10.6 & 0.62 & 7.127 + hops 91 & 83.8288 & -5.0141 & 0 & 4.146 & 41.7 & 1.894 & 50.5 & 50 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 1.86 & 45 & 57 & 68.8 & 0.50 & 2.863 + hops 92 & 83.8263 & -5.0092 & flat & 20.112 & 186.3 & 0.046 & 151.7 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath74 & 5.59 & 45 & 50 & 48.6 & 0.50 & 2.370 + hops 93 & 83.8126 & -5.0023 & i & 0.420 & 107.3 & 1.033 & 1.5 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0126 & 15 & 70 & 13.9 & 1.52 & 3.177 + hops 94 & 83.8173 & -5.0006 & i & 6.552 & 123.0 & 0.857 & 5.1 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0675 & 5 & 41 & 7.8 & 1.67 & 4.431 + hops 95 & 83.8925 & -4.9978 & 0 & 0.780 & 41.8 & 1.046 & 1.5 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0731 & 35 & 70 & 7.7 & 1.49 & 5.435 + hops 96 & 83.8738 & -4.9802 & 0 & 6.187 & 35.6 & 2.308 & 60.4 & 50 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 1.86 & 45 & 57 & 88.3 & 2.00 & 3.729 + hops 98 & 83.8305 & -4.9292 & ii & 2.110 & 587.5 & -0.429 & 8.1 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0009 & 15 & 63 & 14.9 & 0.81 & 1.766 + hops 99 & 83.6229 & -4.9252 & 0 & 1.332 & 48.9 & 1.021 & 9.4 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0535 & 35 & 87 & 11.4 & 0.92 &
2.057 + hops 100 & 83.5891 & -4.9208 & i & 0.046 & 605.1 & 0.457 & 0.120 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 70 & 6.8 & 1.14 & 6.227 + hops 102 & 83.6466 & -4.8716 & i & 0.533 & 479.2 & 0.455 & 1.6 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 70 & 1.6 & 0.52 &
2.259 + hops 105 & 83.8845 & -4.7801 & flat & 0.113 & 520.3 & 0.055 & 0.370 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0219 & 45 & 63 & 0.7 & 1.21 & 3.382 + hops 107 & 83.8473 & -4.6696 & flat & 5.071 & 472.0 & -0.051 & 7.4 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0239 & 35 & 57 & 3.6 & 0.73 & 2.195 + hops 108 & 83.8628 & -5.1668 & 0 & 38.321 & 38.5 & & 402.1 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 0.762 & 45 & 70 & 19.0 & 1.33 & 4.119 + hops 113 & 84.9922 & -7.4448 & ii & 0.120 & 583.8 & -0.749 & 151.7 & 5 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 5 & 87 & 64.2 & 0.50 & 6.993 + hops 114 & 85.0057 & -7.4274 & i & 0.047 & 117.3 & 1.790 & 0.500 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 81 & 9.0 & 0.50 & 3.220 + hops 115 & 84.9854 & -7.4310 & flat & 0.313 & 461.3 & -0.227 & 2.7 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0008 & 25 & 63 & 32.7 & 0.89 & 3.431 + hops 116 & 84.9912 & -7.4203 & flat & 0.295 & 411.1 & -0.113 & 1.9 & 5 & 1.78
@xmath70 & 0.0009 & 15 & 63 & 29.1 & 0.62 & 3.686 + hops 117 & 84.9810 & -7.4054 & flat & 0.112 & 277.0 & -0.002 & 0.220 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.190 & 45 & 57 & 4.9 & 0.72 & 2.660 + hops 118 & 84.9774 & -7.4041 & flat & 0.277 & 552.8 & -0.131 & 1.4 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0005 & 45 & 70 & 11.7 & 1.42 & 2.727 + hops 119 & 84.9610 & -7.3918 & flat & 1.053 & 573.8 & 0.187 & 1.8 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0056 & 45 & 57 & 8.9 & 0.59 & 1.668 + hops 120 & 84.8930 & -7.4365 & flat & 0.321 & 455.3 & -0.013 & 1.7 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0018 & 45 & 63 & 16.1 & 1.71 & 2.761 + hops 121 & 84.8904 & -7.3839 & 0 & 0.288 & 34.8 & 0.776 & 1.2 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0731 & 35 & 81 & 9.0 & 1.16 & 2.180 + hops 122 & 84.9380 & -7.3204 & i & 0.024 & 246.0 & 0.801 & 0.500 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0037 & 45 & 76 & 14.0 & 0.50 & 2.630 + hops 123 & 84.8887 & -7.3826 & 0 & 0.412 & 50.1 & 0.662 & 1.1 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0803 & 35 & 70 & 1.9 & 1.08 & 4.270 + hops 124 & 84.8333 & -7.4364 & 0 & 58.294 & 44.8 & 1.766 & 177.7 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.287 & 25 & 70 & 27.9 & 1.76 & 2.434 + hops 125 & 84.8317 & -7.4386 & flat & 9.580 & 110.5 & 0.235 & 6.6 & 5 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 3.12 & 15 & 18 & 10.1 & 0.65 & 1.936 + hops 127 & 84.7539 & -7.3396 & i & 0.394 & 133.3 & 1.364 & 1.6 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0572 & 45 & 63 & 7.5 & 0.54 & 2.590 + hops 128 & 84.7167 & -7.3517 & flat & 0.808 & 469.2 & -0.050 & 4.5 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0024 & 35 & 70 & 8.5 & 1.48 & 2.515 + hops 129 & 84.7994 & -7.1764 & flat & 1.675 & 191.3 & -0.022 & 6.7 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0112 & 25 & 18 & 40.2 & 0.66 & 4.627 + hops 130 & 84.7623 & -7.2145 & i & 1.475 & 156.7 & 0.854 & 1.5 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0331 & 5 & 50 & 3.0 & 0.50 & 2.676 + hops 131 & 84.7815 & -7.1811 & i & 0.157 & 82.3 & 1.852 & 1.5 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 81 & 28.5 & 0.50 & 3.917 + hops 132 & 84.7723 & -7.1848 & flat & 1.698 & 616.3 & -0.222 & 2.6 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0010 & 5 & 63 & 3.9 & 0.86 & 2.873 + hops 133 & 84.7743 & -7.1776 & i & 3.302 & 74.6 & 2.547 & 27.5 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.190 & 45 & 63 & 29.2 & 0.91 & 3.114 + hops 134 & 84.6783 & -7.2122 & flat & 7.767 & 781.9 & -0.356 & 10.3 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 57 & 0.8 & 1.02 & 2.251 + hops 135 & 84.6888 & -7.1822 & i & 1.137 & 130.3 & 0.740 & 2.0 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0625 & 15 & 63 & 2.7 & 0.67 & 4.876 + hops 136 & 84.6939 & -7.0937 & i & 0.693 & 161.7 & 0.192 & 0.990 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0315 & 15 & 70 & 0.0 & 0.99 & 6.733 + hops 137 & 84.7248 & -7.0426 & 0 & 0.153 & 43.7 & 0.640 & 0.290 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 76 & 0.0 & 0.96 & 3.975 + hops 138 & 84.7014 & -7.0454 & 0 & 0.116 & 42.8 & 0.556 & 0.08 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 0.958 & 35 & 41 & 9.4 & 0.74 & 3.237 + hops 139 & 84.7067 & -7.0216 & i & 2.882 & 84.3 & 1.467 & 10.8 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0033 & 5 & 63 & 34.1 & 1.07 &
3.398 + hops 140 & 84.6928 & -7.0315 & i & 0.591 & 137.2 & 0.493 & 1.8 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0097 & 35 & 50 & 33.0 & 1.75 & 2.210 + hops 141 & 84.7001 & -7.0137 & flat & 0.152 & 741.6 & -0.061 & 0.180 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 18 & 4.6 & 0.60 & 4.047 + hops 142 & 84.6990 & -7.0075 & i & 0.039 & 231.8 & 0.446 & 0.200 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.186 & 45 & 63 & 5.1 & 0.66 & 2.904 + hops 143 & 84.6924 & -7.0135 & i & 4.290 & 242.1 & 0.245 & 18.4 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0066 & 5 & 41 & 39.4 & 0.61 & 4.399 + hops 144 & 84.6876 & -7.0171 & i & 2.156 & 99.2 & 1.436 & 163.8 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0009 & 15 & 87 & 64.5 & 0.54 & 2.731 + hops 145 & 84.6827 & -7.0203 & i & 2.090 & 133.7 & 1.588 & 7.8 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0062 & 15 & 76 & 12.0 & 0.77 & 3.062 + hops 147 & 84.7292 & -6.9385 & flat & 0.116 & 619.6 & -0.107 & 0.220 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0004 & 45 & 18 & 4.6 & 0.73 & 3.525 + hops 148 & 84.6646 & -6.9918 & i & 0.421 & 262.9 & 0.327 & 1.0 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 63 & 13.3 & 1.02 & 2.733 + hops 149 & 84.6687 & -6.9727 & flat & 11.469 & 484.6 & -0.090 & 20.2 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 41 & 9.1 & 2.00 & 1.904 + lrrclllccccccccl hops 150 & 84.5314 & -7.1414 & flat & 3.769 & 245.2 & 0.139 & 8.3 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0957 & 35 & 57 & 12.6 & 0.82 & 3.728 + hops 152 & 84.4948 & -7.1237 & 0 & 0.700 & 53.8 & 2.204 & 2.0 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 70 & 59.1 & 2.00 & 4.006 + hops 153 & 84.4875 & -7.1157 & 0 & 4.433 & 39.4 & 1.695 & 33.2 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.219 & 45 & 87 & 2.7 & 1.10 & 5.470 + hops 154 & 84.5837 & -6.9847 & i & 0.105 & 166.7 & 0.565 & 0.110 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0066 & 5 & 32 & 0.1 & 1.10 & 2.812 + hops 156 & 84.5142 & -6.9711 & i & 0.266 & 90.1 & 1.139 & 0.320 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0331 & 5 & 63 & 0.2 & 1.06 & 2.578 + hops 157 & 84.4857 & -6.9442 & i & 3.824 & 77.6 & 1.744 & 22.4 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.381 & 45 & 57 & 43.7 & 0.74 & 3.127 + hops 158 & 84.3519 & -6.9758 & flat & 2.672 & 591.6 & -0.063 & 5.9 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 50 & 9.0 & 1.95 & 1.809 + hops 159 & 84.4739 & -6.7880 & flat & 0.449 & 498.4 & 0.265 & 2.8 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0009 & 35 & 70 & 9.0 & 0.92 & 2.169 + hops 160 & 84.4627 & -6.7890 & i & 1.365 & 80.4 & 1.111 & 2.0 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0133 & 5 & 70 & 0.5 & 2.00 & 4.238 + hops 163 & 84.3220 & -6.6051 & i & 0.900 & 432.3 & 0.357 & 3.3 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 70 & 3.7 & 1.07 & 2.155 + hops 164 & 84.2519 & -6.6196 & 0 & 0.583 & 50.0 & -0.270 & 1.5 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.112 & 25 & 81 & 0.0 & 0.50 & 5.294 + hops 165 & 84.0981 & -6.7707 & i & 3.409 & 96.1 & 0.468 & 151.7 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0009 & 15 & 76 & 68.1 & 0.50 & 3.393 + hops 166 & 84.1047 & -6.7449 & flat & 15.466 & 457.1 & 0.011 & 15.9 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.219 & 45 & 41 & 7.3 & 1.58 & 2.081 + hops 167 & 84.0825 & -6.7669 & flat & 0.176 & 568.6 & 0.296 & 0.360 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0028 & 25 & 18 & 8.3 & 1.19 & 1.349 + hops 168 & 84.0789 & -6.7563 & 0 & 48.068 & 54.0 & 1.863 & 77.1 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.312 & 15 & 87 & 0.0 & 0.76 & 2.213 + hops 169 & 84.1505 & -6.6477 & 0 & 3.910 & 32.5 & 0.427 & 5.6 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.337 & 5 & 87 & 13.0 & 1.84 & 3.826 + hops 170 & 84.1722 & -6.5667 & flat & 2.521 & 832.5 & 0.112 & 2.5 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 32 & 0.1 & 0.83 & 1.962 + hops 171 & 84.0717 & -6.6338 & 0 & 1.854 & 61.8 & 1.282 & 4.9 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0332 & 5 & 87 & 12.4 & 1.59 & 2.695 + hops 172 & 84.0810 & -6.4852 & i & 0.659 & 149.8 & 1.531 & 14.3 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 15 & 81 & 18.8 & 1.41 & 3.366 + hops 173 & 84.1085 & -6.4181 & 0 & 0.940 & 60.2 & 1.575 & 2.0 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0066 & 5 & 70 & 20.7 & 2.00 & 3.811 + hops 174 & 84.1077 & -6.4163 & flat & 1.994 & 350.3 & 0.100 & 5.1 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath74 & 5.59 & 45 & 50 & 13.3 & 0.50 & 2.908 + hops 175 & 84.1003 & -6.4153 & i & 0.335 & 104.3 & 0.556 & 1.1 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0037 & 45 & 70 & 0.2 & 1.05 & 4.243 + hops 176 & 84.0983 & -6.4143 & flat & 1.521 & 312.2 & -0.282 & 4.2 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.366 & 45 & 57 & 2.7 & 1.37 & 3.397 + hops 177 & 83.9584 & -6.5815 & i & 0.425 & 84.7 & 1.263 & 0.980 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0331 & 5 & 81 & 3.4 & 0.98 & 3.549 + hops 178 & 84.1025 & -6.3781 & i & 20.025 & 155.1 & 0.808 & 393.4 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0746 & 45 & 57 & 67.9 & 1.30 & 2.860 + hops 179 & 84.0910 & -6.3916 & flat & 1.847 & 467.5 & -0.164 & 3.1 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0112 & 25 & 57 & 7.8 & 1.01 & 1.764 + hops 181 & 84.0813 & -6.3701 & i & 6.208 & 131.3 & 0.330 & 359.3 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 76 & 71.4 & 1.18 & 5.161 + hops 182 & 84.0785 & -6.3695 & 0 & 71.116 & 51.9 & 2.355 & 139.1 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.326 & 15 & 76 & 4.6 & 1.38 & 3.250 + hops 183 & 84.0744 & -6.3745 & flat & 0.297 & 224.5 & 0.326 & 1.1 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0080 & 35 & 18 & 26.7 & 1.09 & 2.389 + hops 184 & 84.0539 & -6.3918 & ii & 0.190 & 201.3 & -0.364 & 0.930 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0071 & 35 & 70 & 15.8 & 0.92 & 4.081 + hops 185 & 84.1541 & -6.2494 & i & 1.039 & 96.9 & 0.567 & 2.0 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0560 & 25 & 76 & 0.0 & 0.65 & 4.642 + hops 186 & 83.9470 & -6.4374 & i & 0.484 & 72.3 & 1.126 & 5.1 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0011 & 35 & 81 & 8.1 & 0.50 & 3.104 + hops 187 & 83.9622 & -6.3787 & flat & 0.257 & 1210.9 & 0.024 & 0.450 & 5 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 5 & 63 & 0.0 & 1.50 & 4.660 + hops 188 & 83.8743 & -6.4495 & i & 18.812 & 103.3 & 1.573 & 20.7 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0664 & 5 & 57 & 3.2 & 0.69 & 3.050 + hops 189 & 83.8787 & -6.4422 & i & 1.246 & 133.1 & 1.232 & 1.6 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0099 & 5 & 70 & 0.5 & 1.62 & 5.320 + hops 190 & 83.8687 & -6.4505 & i & 0.390 & 385.3 & 0.595 & 1.5 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 70 & 8.4 & 0.50 & 3.578 + hops 191 & 84.0719 & -6.1864 & i & 0.582 & 196.7 & 0.773 & 1.9 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0239 & 35 & 63 & 9.0 & 0.61 & 2.038 + hops 192 & 84.1352 & -6.0212 & flat & 1.407 & 202.5 & 0.312 & 2.3 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath74 & 4.37 & 45 & 41 & 20.6 & 0.74 & 2.340 + hops 193 & 84.1261 & -6.0215 & i & 1.151 & 226.7 & 0.628 & 5.1 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.559 & 45 & 57 & 14.3 & 0.50 & 3.069 + hops 194 & 83.9667 & -6.1672 & flat & 12.716 & 645.0 & 0.358 & 9.3 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0731 & 35 & 32 & 0.0 & 0.92 & 2.023 + hops 197 & 83.5662 & -6.5757 & flat & 0.204 & 506.6 & 0.049 & 0.520 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 15 & 50 & 9.0 & 1.73 & 3.439 + hops 198 & 83.8424 & -6.2184 & 0 & 0.851 & 61.4 & 0.987 & 2.0 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0332 & 5 & 76 & 9.2 & 1.94 & 2.305 + hops 199 & 83.6661 & -6.4206 & flat & 0.181 & 576.7 & 0.090 & 0.290 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 18 & 2.7 & 0.97 & 3.559 + hops 200 & 83.8884 & -6.1027 & flat & 0.288 & 244.4 & 0.299 & 1.0 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 32 & 23.4 & 1.00 & 2.949 + hops 201 & 83.5289 & -6.5356 & ii & 0.137 & 1249.8 & 0.013 & 0.210 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 18 & 0.6 & 2.00 & 3.683 + hops 203 & 84.0952 & -6.7684 & 0 & 20.439 & 43.7 & & 52.2 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.287 & 25 & 70 & 6.9 & 1.73 & 4.348 + hops 204 & 85.7924 & -8.7689 & i & 1.341 & 85.4 & 1.119 & 2.4 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0937 & 15 & 63 & 2.9 & 0.80 & 3.929 + hops 206 & 85.7803 & -8.7420 & 0 & 2.298 & 65.1 & 1.076 & 3.5 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0661 & 5 & 70 & 0.0 & 1.16 & 4.183 + hops 207 & 85.6607 & -8.8385 & flat & 0.547 & 446.2 & 0.075 & 2.0 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0055 & 45 & 50 & 15.1 & 2.00 & 2.882 + hops 208 & 85.7197 & -8.7369 & flat & 0.017 & 373.5 & -0.042 & 0.100 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0548 & 45 & 70 & 0.0 & 0.99 & 2.748 + hops 209 & 85.7204 & -8.6948 & i & 0.264 & 554.1 & 0.182 & 0.580 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 45 & 63 & 9.0 & 1.93 & 3.994 + hops 210 & 85.7428 & -8.6348 & flat & 1.310 & 204.9 & 0.316 & 5.2 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0062 & 15 & 57 & 33.1 & 0.51 & 4.183 + hops 211 & 85.7432 & -8.6287 & flat & 0.250 & 87.9 & 0.113 & 0.350 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0630 & 15 & 57 & 0.0 & 1.14 & 4.687 + hops 213 & 85.7004 & -8.6690 & flat & 1.469 & 534.9 & 0.024 & 4.7 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 63 & 12.9 & 1.54 & 2.277 + hops 214 & 85.6968 & -8.6102 & flat & 0.139 & 360.8 & 0.111 & 0.580 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 25 & 50 & 17.6 & 1.91 & 2.803 + hops 215 & 85.7899 & -8.4909 & i & 0.545 & 195.5 & 1.112 & 0.590 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 50 & 2.4 & 1.94 & 2.747 + hops 216 & 85.7314 & -8.5467 & i & 0.668 & 117.7 & 1.867 & 12.6 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0004 & 45 & 81 & 6.8 & 1.25 & 3.179 + hops 219 & 85.3719 & -8.7178 & i & 2.042 & 90.0 & 1.643 & 3.0 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0332 & 5 & 63 & 9.0 & 0.99 & 2.774 + lrrclllccccccccl hops 220 & 85.3741 & -8.7128 & i & 0.267 & 193.6 & 0.829 & 0.600 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0013 & 5 & 18 & 24.9 & 2.00 & 2.115 + hops 221 & 85.6961 & -8.2853 & i & 8.363 & 172.3 & 0.684 & 14.4 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0312 & 15 & 63 & 9.0 & 1.42 & 2.935 + hops 222 & 85.3612 & -8.7068 & ii & 0.849 & 738.2 & -0.647 & 2.0 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 63 & 9.0 & 0.66 & 3.237 + hops 223 & 85.7019 & -8.2762 & i & 19.252 & 247.5 & 1.078 & 151.7 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0746 & 45 & 63 & 14.5 & 0.50 & 8.410 + hops 224 & 85.3834 & -8.6694 & 0 & 2.988 & 48.6 & 0.780 & 4.1 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.131 & 15 & 63 & 9.7 & 1.34 & 3.941 + hops 225 & 85.3764 & -8.6715 & flat & 0.835 & 432.5 & -0.118 & 5.4 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0024 & 35 & 57 & 27.3 & 1.76 & 1.668 + hops 226 & 85.3753 & -8.6693 & flat & 0.855 & 350.2 & 0.015 & 4.3 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0028 & 25 & 50 & 27.4 & 1.40 & 3.390 + hops 227 & 85.3847 & -8.6321 & flat & 0.335 & 371.0 & -0.078 & 1.9 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 15 & 70 & 20.4 & 1.93 & 2.576 + hops 228 & 85.3924 & -8.5910 & i & 10.972 & 293.0 & -0.127 & 20.2 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0125 & 15 & 63 & 10.8 & 2.00 & 5.736 + hops 229 & 85.6974 & -8.1691 & flat & 0.344 & 471.6 & -0.064 & 1.5 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0073 & 45 & 57 & 17.5 & 0.50 & 2.126 + hops 232 & 85.3977 & -8.1396 & i & 1.093 & 187.9 & 1.875 & 50.5 & 50 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 5 & 87 & 13.8 & 0.50 & 2.832 + hops 233 & 85.4680 & -8.0228 & i & 0.045 & 106.2 & 1.256 & 1.5 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 45 & 87 & 0.0 & 0.50 & 3.406 + hops 234 & 85.4581 & -8.0240 & i & 2.293 & 79.8 & 2.389 & 15.1 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.190 & 45 & 63 & 19.0 & 0.50 & 2.594 + hops 235 & 85.3556 & -8.0986 & flat & 4.774 & 680.1 & 0.144 & 5.1 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 18 & 0.9 & 1.67 & 2.372 + hops 236 & 85.3759 & -8.0615 & flat & 4.862 & 332.8 & -0.104 & 20.0 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0056 & 25 & 57 & 24.2 & 1.97 & 2.658 + hops 237 & 85.3707 & -8.0572 & i & 0.263 & 177.7 & 0.816 & 1.4 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0075 & 45 & 70 & 6.3 & 1.43 & 2.640 + hops 238 & 85.3610 & -8.0535 & i & 0.367 & 269.1 & 0.518 & 3.5 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 15 & 70 & 23.6 & 1.15 & 2.132 + hops 239 & 85.3627 & -8.0152 & i & 0.250 & 116.2 & 0.552 & 0.840 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0094 & 35 & 32 & 35.8 & 0.84 & 2.437 + hops 240 & 85.3582 & -8.0211 & i & 0.072 & 191.0 & 0.570 & 0.320 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 18 & 32.6 & 1.07 & 2.189 + hops 241 & 85.3600 & -8.0173 & i & 0.699 & 100.3 & 1.871 & 2.5 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0099 & 5 & 70 & 37.0 & 0.81 & 3.527 + hops 242 & 85.2021 & -8.1858 & flat & 0.625 & 836.7 & -0.355 & 1.5 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 25 & 63 & 7.7 & 0.50 & 1.515 + hops 243 & 85.2569 & -8.1124 & 0 & 0.430 & 50.8 & 1.509 & 6.0 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0572 & 45 & 81 & 3.5 & 1.97 & 2.554 + hops 244 & 85.2583 & -8.1005 & i & 1.380 & 127.3 & 1.233 & 2.0 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0332 & 5 & 63 & 1.9 & 0.64 & 2.685 + hops 245 & 85.3453 & -7.9822 & flat & 0.275 & 302.1 & 0.042 & 4.2 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0005 & 35 & 57 & 49.1 & 1.37 & 3.501 + hops 246 & 85.1963 & -8.1633 & i & 0.379 & 95.6 & 1.777 & 0.820 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 76 & 17.6 & 0.82 & 2.804 + hops 247 & 85.3593 & -7.9477 & 0 & 3.094 & 42.8 & 1.410 & 5.1 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.326 & 15 & 63 & 4.6 & 0.50 & 3.886 + hops 248 & 85.3421 & -7.9675 & flat & 2.085 & 484.3 & -0.093 & 7.3 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0009 & 15 & 41 & 18.8 & 0.72 & 2.252 + hops 249 & 85.2202 & -8.0969 & flat & 0.072 & 268.5 & -0.288 & 0.180 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0235 & 35 & 70 & 5.1 & 1.77 & 4.144 + hops 250 & 85.2035 & -8.1159 & 0 & 6.793 & 69.4 & 1.776 & 21.6 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0332 & 5 & 87 & 26.2 & 0.71 & 3.015 + hops 251 & 85.2251 & -8.0870 & flat & 0.630 & 345.7 & -0.004 & 3.2 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 50 & 28.2 & 1.03 & 2.489 + hops 252 & 85.2080 & -8.1023 & flat & 1.834 & 329.2 & -0.128 & 4.4 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0062 & 15 & 63 & 14.1 & 1.44 & 3.645 + hops 253 & 85.3699 & -7.8975 & flat & 0.620 & 321.1 & 0.027 & 1.0 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0004 & 45 & 41 & 11.4 & 1.01 & 2.553 + hops 254 & 85.3521 & -7.9187 & i & 5.942 & 114.7 & 1.185 & 48.1 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.186 & 45 & 57 & 46.6 & 1.59 & 2.057 + hops 255 & 85.2107 & -8.0969 & flat & 0.632 & 572.0 & -0.334 & 3.5 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0055 & 45 & 63 & 19.0 & 1.13 & 2.562 + hops 256 & 85.1886 & -8.1117 & 0 & 0.110 & 72.4 & 0.857 & 0.08 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0661 & 5 & 18 & 11.9 & 0.79 & 2.708 + hops 257 & 85.3328 & -7.9296 & flat & 0.323 & 292.6 & -0.178 & 3.1 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 63 & 39.7 & 1.02 & 2.478 + hops 258 & 85.3530 & -7.9023 & flat & 1.065 & 385.7 & -0.118 & 6.5 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0183 & 45 & 41 & 30.9 & 0.64 & 2.070 + hops 259 & 85.0870 & -8.2320 & flat & 0.766 & 410.3 & -0.242 & 5.1 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 70 & 14.2 & 0.50 & 3.577 + hops 260 & 85.0808 & -8.2379 & flat & 1.689 & 600.1 & -0.120 & 2.6 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0062 & 15 & 63 & 1.7 & 0.84 & 2.245 + hops 261 & 85.3287 & -7.9247 & i & 2.320 & 149.5 & 0.547 & 4.2 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0287 & 25 & 57 & 17.7 & 1.39 & 1.393 + hops 262 & 85.3499 & -7.8950 & flat & 0.868 & 202.4 & 0.164 & 2.0 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0745 & 45 & 50 & 18.7 & 2.00 & 2.593 + hops 263 & 85.3487 & -7.8963 & i & 0.715 & 145.1 & 0.357 & 15.1 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0073 & 45 & 18 & 73.9 & 1.49 & 3.504 + hops 264 & 85.2463 & -8.0040 & flat & 0.057 & 402.3 & 0.337 & 0.150 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 70 & 6.0 & 0.50 & 3.433 + hops 265 & 85.3347 & -7.8863 & flat & 0.135 & 635.1 & -0.003 & 0.600 & 5 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 5 & 63 & 12.8 & 2.00 & 2.023 + hops 266 & 85.2992 & -7.8933 & flat & 0.033 & 190.7 & 0.050 & 0.150 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0028 & 25 & 41 & 27.5 & 0.51 & 3.164 + hops 267 & 85.3319 & -7.8447 & i & 1.052 & 186.2 & 1.084 & 1.1 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 18 & 16.4 & 1.12 & 1.630 + hops 268 & 85.1597 & -8.0100 & i & 1.064 & 113.9 & 0.970 & 3.7 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0004 & 45 & 63 & 8.3 & 1.21 & 3.219 + hops 270 & 85.1689 & -7.9111 & i & 0.279 & 96.6 & 1.509 & 0.480 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 70 & 10.2 & 1.60 & 3.416 + hops 271 & 85.1832 & -7.8251 & i & 0.072 & 108.4 & 1.532 & 0.150 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0066 & 5 & 76 & 0.0 & 1.41 & 2.502 + hops 272 & 85.0855 & -7.9443 & ii & 8.303 & 559.2 & -0.376 & 16.4 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 32 & 11.3 & 0.54 & 2.849 + hops 273 & 85.0870 & -7.9402 & i & 2.222 & 243.3 & 0.653 & 5.5 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.381 & 45 & 57 & 6.9 & 0.54 & 1.897 + hops 274 & 85.0863 & -7.9166 & flat & 1.932 & 546.5 & -0.117 & 2.9 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0056 & 25 & 32 & 8.6 & 0.95 & 2.815 + hops 275 & 85.1514 & -7.8186 & i & 0.123 & 146.4 & 1.612 & 0.510 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 76 & 8.4 & 1.67 & 2.621 + hops 276 & 85.1788 & -7.7505 & i & 0.152 & 303.8 & 0.895 & 1.7 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0004 & 45 & 76 & 6.2 & 1.73 & 3.767 + hops 277 & 85.1848 & -7.7380 & ii & 0.092 & 953.7 & -0.369 & 0.240 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0024 & 35 & 70 & 3.3 & 0.79 & 3.179 + hops 278 & 85.0848 & -7.8541 & i & 0.213 & 96.3 & 2.604 & 1.7 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0745 & 45 & 70 & 9.0 & 0.56 & 5.676 + hops 279 & 85.0741 & -7.8072 & flat & 5.956 & 382.0 & 0.027 & 15.1 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0033 & 5 & 57 & 17.1 & 0.50 & 1.747 + hops 280 & 85.0622 & -7.8135 & i & 3.290 & 121.2 & 1.559 & 5.1 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0331 & 5 & 63 & 8.7 & 0.50 & 2.379 + lrrclllccccccccl hops 281 & 85.1026 & -7.7190 & flat & 1.281 & 189.3 & 0.335 & 3.0 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0009 & 45 & 41 & 28.7 & 0.99 & 2.204 + hops 282 & 85.1087 & -7.6256 & i & 0.816 & 95.1 & 1.864 & 1.9 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 70 & 25.7 & 1.90 & 2.769 + hops 283 & 85.1861 & -7.4985 & ii & 1.115 & 807.9 & -0.382 & 2.5 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0011 & 25 & 63 & 6.5 & 0.83 & 1.935 + hops 284 & 84.7145 & -8.0243 & flat & 0.699 & 913.9 & -0.316 & 1.5 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0008 & 25 & 70 & 1.0 & 1.51 & 1.561 + hops 285 & 85.0246 & -7.4925 & 0 & 0.141 & 66.5 & 1.229 & 0.520 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath71 & 0.0084 & 25 & 76 & 22.9 & 0.52 & 4.026 + hops 286 & 84.9946 & -7.5200 & i & 0.586 & 123.7 & 0.442 & 0.930 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0312 & 15 & 70 & 0.0 & 0.92 & 3.999 + hops 287 & 85.0366 & -7.4577 & i & 0.755 & 117.8 & 0.850 & 0.600 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0331 & 5 & 41 & 3.7 & 2.00 & 2.477 + hops 288 & 84.9831 & -7.5078 & 0 & 135.474 & 48.6 & 2.587 & 606.9 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0979 & 15 & 76 & 74.6 & 2.00 & 2.981 + hops 290 & 84.9892 & -7.4926 & 0 & 1.849 & 47.3 & 2.535 & 13.9 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.572 & 45 & 63 & 46.2 & 1.38 & 3.319 + hops 291 & 84.9915 & -7.4826 & flat & 0.094 & 340.1 & 0.204 & 0.410 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0047 & 35 & 50 & 18.1 & 1.37 & 1.559 + hops 293 & 85.2454 & -7.8006 & ii & 0.161 & 1023.9 & -0.723 & 0.350 & 5 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 5 & 70 & 1.9 & 1.16 & 6.129 + hops 294 & 85.2155 & -2.4468 & flat & 2.795 & 606.8 & 0.040 & 3.6 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0112 & 25 & 32 & 5.3 & 1.18 & 2.402 + hops 295 & 85.3706 & -2.3887 & i & 0.319 & 86.6 & 1.617 & 1.8 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.191 & 45 & 63 & 21.1 & 0.60 & 3.094 + hops 297 & 85.3470 & -2.2933 & i & 0.200 & 274.9 & 0.604 & 0.590 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 41 & 19.3 & 0.59 & 2.848 + hops 298 & 85.4049 & -2.2881 & i & 31.111 & 169.3 & 1.217 & 50.5 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0329 & 5 & 70 & 1.0 & 0.50 & 2.835 + hops 299 & 85.4358 & -2.2684 & i & 19.663 & 277.0 & 0.744 & 58.8 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0010 & 5 & 57 & 16.0 & 0.58 & 3.187 + hops 345 & 86.9124 & 0.6434 & i & 0.470 & 219.4 & 1.183 & 0.600 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0066 & 5 & 63 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 2.937 + hops 346 & 86.9291 & 0.6826 & flat & 0.267 & 649.5 & -0.259 & 0.910 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0018 & 45 & 70 & 7.6 & 0.90 & 3.004 + hops 347 & 86.8162 & 0.3566 & 0 & 0.536 & 33.5 & & 0.900 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.101 & 5 & 87 & 0.0 & 0.90 & 4.273 + hops 354 & 88.6011 & 1.7387 & 0 & 6.567 & 34.8 & & 32.6 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 1.07 & 35 & 70 & 0.0 & 1.08 & 3.615 + hops 355 & 84.3212 & -6.8304 & 0 & 1.177 & 44.9 & & 6.1 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0803 & 35 & 76 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 2.948 + hops 357 & 85.4129 & -1.8687 & flat & 15.011 & 628.2 & 0.147 & 161.9 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0006 & 15 & 81 & 0.8 & 0.53 & 2.854 + hops 358 & 86.5301 & -0.2250 & 0 & 24.960 & 41.7 & & 60.4 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.121 & 25 & 87 & 14.7 & 2.00 & 5.616 + hops 359 & 86.8534 & 0.3500 & 0 & 9.998 & 36.7 & & 9.4 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.664 & 5 & 41 & 15.0 & 0.93 & 5.834 + hops 361 & 86.7699 & 0.3619 & 0 & 478.987 & 69.0 & 1.888 & 606.9 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.317 & 15 & 50 & 9.0 & 2.00 & 2.950 + hops 300 & 85.3509 & -2.2685 & i & 0.763 & 93.7 & 1.448 & 1.2 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 76 & 8.9 & 1.15 & 3.453 + hops 303 & 85.5109 & -2.1294 & 0 & 1.486 & 43.2 & 0.873 & 3.5 & 50 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 2.39 & 35 & 41 & 56.0 & 1.14 & 3.271 + hops 304 & 85.4414 & -1.9406 & flat & 4.242 & 354.9 & 0.091 & 50.5 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0031 & 15 & 63 & 40.3 & 0.50 & 2.077 + hops 305 & 85.4391 & -1.8658 & flat & 0.992 & 300.7 & -0.175 & 2.9 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0840 & 25 & 63 & 0.0 & 0.96 & 3.292 + hops 310 & 85.6153 & -1.3336 & 0 & 13.830 & 51.8 & 2.128 & 93.6 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.219 & 45 & 70 & 29.9 & 0.93 & 3.024 + hops 311 & 85.7627 & -1.2747 & flat & 2.829 & 383.0 & 0.196 & 4.8 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0572 & 45 & 50 & 13.0 & 1.55 & 2.418 + hops 312 & 85.7738 & -1.2651 & 0 & 0.748 & 46.7 & 0.886 & 1.8 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0303 & 25 & 70 & 18.7 & 1.76 & 3.177 + hops 315 & 86.5151 & -0.2470 & i & 6.219 & 180.3 & 0.417 & 9.9 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.244 & 35 & 50 & 9.3 & 0.98 & 2.977 + hops 316 & 86.5304 & -0.2231 & 0 & 4.192 & 55.2 & 0.394 & 8.9 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0675 & 5 & 81 & 0.0 & 0.88 & 5.468 + hops 317 & 86.5358 & -0.1774 & 0 & 4.757 & 47.5 & 0.956 & 10.6 & 500 & 1.19 @xmath74 & 5.35 & 35 & 41 & 41.5 & 1.05 & 3.242 + hops 318 & 86.5563 & -0.1487 & flat & 0.147 & 312.6 & -0.002 & 0.300 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0186 & 45 & 63 & 9.0 & 1.00 & 2.779 + hops 319 & 86.5542 & -0.1375 & i & 0.039 & 464.2 & 1.076 & 0.360 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0037 & 45 & 76 & 0.0 & 1.19 & 2.795 + hops 320 & 86.5592 & -0.0908 & i & 0.443 & 87.0 & 1.561 & 0.750 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0133 & 5 & 70 & 9.0 & 0.75 & 4.424 + hops 321 & 86.6382 & 0.0006 & i & 3.739 & 78.6 & 1.182 & 6.1 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0133 & 5 & 63 & 17.1 & 2.00 & 3.386 + hops 322 & 86.6937 & 0.0045 & i & 0.481 & 71.3 & 1.345 & 1.5 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0312 & 15 & 76 & 14.2 & 0.50 & 5.330 + hops 323 & 86.6987 & 0.0070 & i & 9.871 & 82.9 & 0.959 & 42.8 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.244 & 35 & 50 & 55.8 & 1.42 & 3.031 + hops 324 & 86.6564 & 0.0094 & i & 2.242 & 89.9 & 1.354 & 1.4 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0988 & 5 & 18 & 14.2 & 1.38 & 3.261 + hops 325 & 86.6636 & 0.0208 & 0 & 6.202 & 49.2 & 1.194 & 37.4 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.107 & 35 & 81 & 1.6 & 1.24 & 4.189 + hops 326 & 86.6649 & 0.0713 & 0 & 0.543 & 58.8 & 1.516 & 2.0 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.190 & 45 & 70 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 4.357 + hops 329 & 86.7567 & 0.2997 & i & 2.440 & 89.2 & 1.312 & 4.2 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0664 & 5 & 63 & 0.0 & 1.39 & 3.514 + hops 331 & 86.6180 & 0.3304 & flat & 0.343 & 82.5 & 0.248 & 0.570 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0634 & 15 & 63 & 0.0 & 1.88 & 3.936 + hops 333 & 86.8454 & 0.3495 & flat & 0.233 & 240.9 & -0.098 & 0.210 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.112 & 25 & 41 & 1.2 & 2.00 & 2.163 + hops 334 & 86.7022 & 0.3578 & flat & 0.077 & 506.7 & 0.208 & 0.290 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0005 & 45 & 50 & 11.6 & 0.95 & 2.387 + hops 335 & 86.7744 & 0.3775 & i & 0.441 & 81.1 & 0.825 & 0.600 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0132 & 5 & 81 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 5.193 + hops 336 & 86.5095 & 0.3919 & i & 0.027 & 164.6 & 0.505 & 0.06 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0112 & 25 & 18 & 11.0 & 0.60 & 4.750 + hops 337 & 86.7296 & 0.3929 & i & 0.890 & 128.8 & 0.807 & 3.0 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 45 & 63 & 5.6 & 0.99 & 4.076 + hops 338 & 86.7389 & 0.3973 & 0 & 0.213 & 53.7 & 1.254 & 0.210 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0996 & 5 & 32 & 15.9 & 2.00 & 4.101 + hops 340 & 86.7554 & 0.4393 & 0 & 1.850 & 40.6 & -0.136 & 3.3 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0840 & 25 & 81 & 0.0 & 1.07 & 3.109 + hops 341 & 86.7541 & 0.4395 & 0 & 2.067 & 39.4 & -0.280 & 26.7 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.0731 & 45 & 87 & 9.0 & 0.88 & 5.893 + hops 342 & 86.9879 & 0.5909 & i & 0.331 & 312.6 & 0.321 & 0.600 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0010 & 5 & 50 & 7.6 & 2.00 & 3.847 + hops 343 & 86.9960 & 0.5925 & i & 3.927 & 82.1 & 1.749 & 6.1 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0331 & 5 & 63 & 18.0 & 2.00 & 2.998 + hops 344 & 86.8530 & 0.6264 & i & 0.093 & 408.2 & 0.486 & 0.180 & 5 & 1.19 @xmath70 & 0.0007 & 5 & 50 & 9.0 & 0.59 & 3.581 + hops 363 & 86.6797 & 0.0146 & flat & 22.452 & 367.6 & 0.197 & 32.9 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0312 & 15 & 57 & 3.6 & 1.09 & 4.603 + lrrclllccccccccl hops 364 & 86.9024 & 0.3350 & i & 33.025 & 96.7 & 1.154 & 59.3 & 100 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.115 & 25 & 57 & 0.0 & 1.96 & 2.784 + hops 365 & 86.7942 & 0.3539 & i & 19.300 & 160.3 & 0.367 & 23.4 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0937 & 15 & 50 & 1.4 & 0.78 & 3.163 + hops 366 & 86.7666 & 0.3696 & i & 6.445 & 292.2 & 0.373 & 151.7 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath70 & 0.0012 & 15 & 76 & 30.0 & 0.50 & 2.955 + hops 367 & 88.6511 & 1.8983 & i & 0.046 & 249.4 & 1.946 & 0.08 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0033 & 5 & 76 & 3.8 & 0.79 & 4.497 + hops 368 & 83.8530 & -5.1751 & i & 68.852 & 137.5 & 0.985 & 48.3 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0664 & 5 & 18 & 18.9 & 1.60 & 2.025 + hops 369 & 83.8624 & -5.1714 & flat & 35.318 & 379.2 & 0.254 & 199.4 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath70 & 0.0010 & 5 & 70 & 15.0 & 1.97 & 1.079 + hops 370 & 83.8651 & -5.1593 & i & 360.859 & 71.5 & 1.389 & 564.8 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.135 & 5 & 87 & 1.9 & 1.86 & 2.793 + hops 371 & 83.7934 & -5.9280 & 0 & 0.571 & 31.6 & & 1.9 & 5 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 1.83 & 45 & 57 & 16.3 & 1.91 & 0.426 + hops 372 & 85.3598 & -2.3056 & 0 & 4.805 & 37.3 & 0.599 & 6.2 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 1.12 & 25 & 18 & 120.3 & 0.62 & 2.130 + hops 373 & 86.6279 & -0.0431 & 0 & 5.319 & 36.9 & -0.672 & 6.1 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath72 &
0.280 & 25 & 76 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 6.751 + hops 374 & 85.3561 & -7.9219 & 0 & 0.210 & 56.9 & 0.565 & 0.590 & 50 & 1.19 @xmath72 & 0.0479 & 35 & 50 & 50.5 & 1.95 & 2.362 + hops 375 & 84.8265 & -7.3399 & i & 0.023 & 695.2 & 1.022 & 0.180 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0073 & 45 & 76 & 0.0 & 1.74 & 6.081 + hops 376 & 84.5756 & -7.0406 & flat & 217.879 & 492.0 & & 194.7 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0287 & 25 & 41 & 6.8 & 1.93 & 1.302 + hops 377 & 84.6898 & -7.0173 & 0 & 3.835 & 53.7 & 1.442 & 4.2 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0992 & 5 & 70 & 0.0 & 1.39 & 3.130 + hops 378 & 84.1068 & -6.7879 & i & 0.327 & 170.4 & & 0.670 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath71 & 0.0063 & 15 & 70 & 0.0 & 0.67 & 3.823 + hops 379 & 84.2821 & -6.5327 & i & 0.019 & 114.2 & 1.200 & 0.150 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0236 & 35 & 76 & 8.1 & 0.50 & 3.728 + hops 380 & 84.1054 & -6.4174 & 0 & 0.633 & 36.6 & & 0.690 & 100 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 3.32 & 5 & 18 & 10.6 & 0.69 & 1.058 + hops 382 & 83.8403 & -5.6327 & i & 0.103 & 204.4 & 1.117 & 0.210 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath71 & 0.0113 & 25 & 70 & 0.0 & 0.70 & 4.051 + hops 383 & 83.8742 & -4.9975 & 0 & 7.826 & 45.8 & 0.991 & 55.5 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.548 & 45 & 70 & 14.0 & 1.84 & 1.627 + hops 384 & 85.4337 & -1.9125 & 0 & 1477.9 & 51.9 & & 202.1 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 1.35 & 5 & 18 & 40.9 & 2.00 & 3.226 + hops 385 & 86.5199 & -0.2379 & flat & 11.770 & 377.1 & 0.177 & 15.1 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.239 & 35 & 41 & 10.2 & 0.50 & 1.985 + hops 386 & 86.5354 & -0.1674 & i & 22.620 & 147.4 & 0.801 & 46.8 & 100 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.244 & 35 & 50 & 22.7 & 1.55 & 2.343 + hops 387 & 86.5327 & -0.1669 & i & 5.394 & 118.3 & 0.637 & 6.1 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0910 & 25 & 57 & 4.9 & 2.00 & 1.955 + hops 388 & 86.5547 & -0.1013 & flat & 26.661 & 321.9 & 0.133 & 50.5 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.239 & 35 & 41 & 17.7 & 0.50 & 3.980 + hops 389 & 86.6959 & 0.0075 & 0 & 5.963 & 42.8 & 1.295 & 14.1 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.239 & 35 & 70 & 2.7 & 1.40 & 6.477 + hops 390 & 86.8852 & 0.3394 & 0 & 3.247 & 54.3 & & 5.2 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0944 & 15 & 76 & 1.9 & 1.69 & 2.462 + hops 391 & 86.8211 & 0.3481 & 0 & 0.092 & 58.1 & & 0.150 & 5 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0840 & 25 & 57 & 0.7 & 1.45 & 0.576 + hops 392 & 86.5687 & 0.3600 & 0 & 0.062 & 62.4 & 0.591 & 0.08 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0944 & 15 & 57 & 1.2 & 0.77 & 2.850 + hops 393 & 86.6770 & 0.3837 & i & 0.068 & 250.5 & 1.075 & 0.180 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath70 & 0.0033 & 5 & 76 & 2.0 & 1.75 & 4.549 + hops 394 & 83.8497 & -5.1315 & 0 & 6.557 & 45.5 & & 32.3 & 5 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.183 & 45 & 87 & 0.0 & 1.07 & 10.285 + hops 395 & 84.8208 & -7.4074 & 0 & 0.496 & 31.7 & & 2.0 & 50 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 1.86 & 45 & 87 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 15.067 + hops 396 & 84.8048 & -7.2199 & 0 & 0.027 & 58.7 & 0.377 & 0.09 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath71 & 0.0303 & 25 & 70 & 0.0 & 0.88 & 4.940 + hops 397 & 85.7036 & -8.2696 & 0 & 1.657 & 46.1 & & 2.0 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath72 & 0.0803 & 35 & 87 & 12.7 & 2.00 & 2.625 + hops 398 & 85.3725 & -2.3547 & 0 & 1.012 & 23.0 & & 1.3 & 50 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 1.32 & 5 & 50 & 56.4 & 1.27 & 0.254 + hops 399 & 85.3539 & -2.3024 & 0 & 6.339 & 31.1 & & 20.2 & 500 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.802 & 35 & 76 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 7.176 + hops 400 & 85.6885 & -1.2706 & 0 & 2.943 & 35.0 & 0.772 & 5.2 & 500 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.303 & 25 & 70 & 40.6 & 1.70 & 3.742 + hops 401 & 86.5319 & -0.2058 & 0 & 0.606 & 26.0 & & 0.750 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 1.35 & 5 & 41 & 35.8 & 0.75 & 0.615 + hops 402 & 86.5415 & -0.2047 & 0 & 0.553 & 24.2 & & 0.600 & 50 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.992 & 5 & 32 & 0.0 & 2.00 & 0.365 + hops 403 & 86.6156 & -0.0149 & 0 & 4.139 & 43.9 & & 5.3 & 100 & 1.78 @xmath73 & 0.731 & 35 & 76 & 0.0 & 1.74 & 1.942 + hops 404 & 87.0323 & 0.5641 & 0 & 0.951 & 26.1 & & 1.5 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.664 & 5 & 76 & 29.0 & 1.45 & 0.631 + hops 405 & 85.2436 & -8.0934 & 0 & 1.599 & 35.0 & -0.549 & 2.0 & 500 & 2.38 @xmath72 & 0.121 & 25 & 87 & 9.0 & 2.00 & 4.088 + hops 406 & 86.9307 & 0.6396 & 0 & 0.475 & 24.6 & & 0.580 & 100 & 1.19 @xmath73 & 0.664 & 5 & 57 & 10.2 & 1.92 & 0.349 + hops 407 & 86.6177 & 0.3242 & 0 & 0.710 & 26.8 & & 1.1 & 5 & 2.38 @xmath73 & 1.32 & 5 & 76 & 0.0 & 1.08 & 1.821 + hops 408 & 84.8781 & -7.3998 & 0 & 0.520 & 37.9 & & 1.9 & 50 & 5.94 @xmath72 & 0.186 & 45 & 87 & 0.0 & 1.89 & 4.839 + hops 409 & 83.8392 & -5.2215 & 0 & 8.180 & 28.4 & & 71.0 & 5 & 5.95 @xmath73 & 1.83 & 45 & 87 & 30.0 & 0.70 & 0.832 + ]
the data sets used for the seds presented in this work were taken with different instruments and telescopes and are not contemporaneous , yet we know that the majority of protostars are variable at a @xmath1 20% level
. therefore , different data sets are snapshots of the emission of the protostar at particular times of its unknown duty cycle of variability .
indeed , in some cases we observe large mismatches between different data sets ; an extreme example , the outbursting protostar hops 223 , was studied by @xcite .
another hops protostar that recently experienced an outburst , hops 383 @xcite , does not have a mismatched sed , since the photometry used here is representative of the post - outburst sed . in general , variability that is wavelength - dependent or has a long duty cycle is more difficult to determine .
m versus those at 5.8 @xmath0 m are shown , while in the right panel the 24 @xmath0 m flux ratios are plotted versus the 8.0 @xmath0 m flux ratios .
a ratio of 0 for a certain band means that for that particular object , the irs spectrum was not available over the wavelength region of that band . [ flux_ratios ] ] since 290 of the 330 objects in the hops sample that were modeled have an irs spectrum and measurements with irac or mips , we compared fluxes measured in the same wave bands , but at different times , to see whether there are discrepancies .
we used the spitzer science center s
_ spitzer_synthphot _ code to calculate irac 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath0 m and mips 24 @xmath0 m synthetic photometry from the irs fluxes . in figure b[flux_ratios ] , we show the flux ratios of irac or mips photometry and the synthetic photometry using the irs spectrum for the protostars in our hops sample . if there were no mismatches , the flux ratios of irac or mips and irs photometry would be close to one .
however , we find that they are typically somewhat less than 1 ; the median ratios at 5.8 , 8.0 , and 24 @xmath0 m are 0.89 , 0.95 , and 0.83 , respectively . for small mismatches ,
calibration uncertainties are a plausible explanation .
in addition , since we are dealing with objects that are not necessarily point sources and often embedded in extended emission , differences in aperture sizes between different measurements ( irac vs. mips vs. irs ) could also account for flux mismatches .
lcccc [ hops_variables ] hops 3 & flat & 1.681 & 1.906 & 1.656 + hops 7 & 0 & 1.121 & 3.176 & 1.061 + hops 11 & 0 & 0.444 & 0.405 & 0.510
+ hops 12 & 0 & 0.553 & 0.888 & 0.485 + hops 19 & flat & 1.296 & 1.059 & 1.648 + hops 20 & i & 2.543 & 2.059 & 2.329 + hops 24 & i & 0.329 & 0.953 & 0.824 + hops 32 & 0 & 1.575 & 1.988 & 1.041 + hops 38 & 0 & 3.566 & 2.478 & 2.468 + hops 41 & i & 0.788 & 0.586 & 0.495 + hops 65 & i & 0.191 & 1.275 & 0.969 + hops 71 & i & 0.416 & 0.547 & 0.825 + hops 78 & 0 & 0.097 & & 0.664 + hops 85 & flat & 1.728 & 1.445 & 1.418 + hops 91 & 0 & 0.511 & 0.446 & 0.711 + hops 95 & 0 & 2.450 & 2.106 & 1.001 + hops 108 & 0 & & 0.867 & 0.525 + hops 114 & i & 0.102 & 0.132 & 0.850 + hops 121 & 0 & & & 0.357 + hops 124 & 0 & 0.402 & 0.601 & 0.697 + hops 131 & i & 0.341 & 0.270 & 0.714 + hops 132 & flat & 1.717 & 1.264 & 0.622 + hops 138 & 0 & 0.354 & 0.485 & 0.935 + hops 141 & flat & 0.393 & 1.418 & 1.086 + hops 143 & i & 1.793 & 1.862 & 1.039 + hops 154 & i & 2.252 & 1.856 & 0.814 + hops 177 & i & 1.740 & 2.279 & 0.863 + hops 181 & i & 1.301 & 1.194 & 0.492 + hops 182 & 0 & 0.772 & 0.705 & 1.390 + hops 183 & flat & 0.466 & 0.502 & 0.486 + hops 186 & i & 1.062 & 1.999 & 0.872 + hops 187 & flat & 0.321 & 1.155 & 0.664 + hops 203 & 0 & & 0.481 & 0.737 + hops 206 & 0 & 1.106 & 1.295 & 0.487 + hops 222 & ii & 0.496 & 0.604 & 0.526 + hops 223 & i & 0.070 & 0.065 & 0.575 + hops 228 & i & 2.098 & 2.749 & 0.766 + hops 239 & i & 0.682 & 0.905 & 1.325 + hops 270 & i & 1.729 & 1.560 & 0.928 + hops 271 & i & 0.948 & 1.679 & 1.538 + hops 272 & ii & 1.660 & 1.732 & 1.420 + hops 278 & i & 0.651 & 2.287 & 2.306 + hops 290 & 0 & 2.198 & 2.263 & 1.301 + hops 297 & i & 2.083 & 1.263 & 0.777 + hops 299 & i & 0.454 & 0.412 & 0.722 + hops 305 & flat & 0.424 & 0.423 & 0.422 + hops 316 & 0 & 2.279 & 1.662 & 0.432 + hops 319 & i & 0.218 & 0.520 & 0.796 + hops 321 & i & 0.769 & 0.518 & 0.662 + hops 322 & i & 0.128 & 0.494 & 0.680 + hops 338 & 0 & 1.552 & 1.683 & 1.376 + hops 340 & 0 & 1.192 & 0.863 & 0.522 + hops 358 & 0 & & & 0.514 + hops 359 & 0 & & & 0.517 + hops 363 & flat & 1.169 & 1.242 & 1.616 + hops 388 & flat & 1.058 & 1.896 & 1.479 + to identify outliers , in table b[hops_variables ] , we list those flux ratios that lie in the lower or upper 5% of values . they represent a conservative list of potentially variable sources in our sample .
of the 290 objects for which we calculated flux ratios , 5 have flux mismatches larger than a factor of 2 between irs and both irac bands at 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath0 m .
three objects have similarly large mismatches between irs and mips .
the overlap between these two samples contains two objects , hops 20 and 38 ( the other objects are hops 95 , 228 , 278 , and 290 ) . for most of these objects ,
the large mismatches can be attributed to noisy irs spectra , especially in the 5 - 8 @xmath0 m region , making the comparison between irac and irs less reliable .
eight objects have irac - irs mismatches smaller than a factor 0.5 ; one of these objects and seven different objects have such small mismatches between mips and irs ( see table b[hops_variables ] ) .
slightly over one - third of these objects have noisy irs spectra . of the 21 objects that have either large ( @xmath26 factor of 2 ) or small ( @xmath29 factor of 0.5 )
mismatches , 9 are class 0 protostars , 10 are class i protostars , and 2 are flat - spectrum sources . in cases where the irs flux is too high relative to the mips 24 @xmath0
m photometry , the mismatch could be due to more extended emission or flux from a nearby companion being included in the irs measurement ( sl and ll slit widths of 36 and 105 , respectively , versus the typical fwhm of the mips 24 @xmath0 m psf of @xmath1 6 ) . for a few sources ,
the discrepancies between irs fluxes and irac or mips can be attributed to the scaling factors applied to different parts of the irs spectrum .
as mentioned in section [ seds ] , we typically scaled the sl spectrum to match the flux of the ll spectrum at 14 @xmath0 m , given that the latter has a larger slit width .
however , in the case of hops 38 , where the irac 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath0 m and the mips 24 @xmath0 m fluxes are about a factor of 2.5 - 3.5 higher than the irs fluxes , the ll spectrum was scaled by 0.4 to match the sl flux at 14 @xmath0 m . given the irac and mips measurements , it would have been more appropriate to scale the sl spectrum up . for hops 124 ,
the sl spectrum was scaled by 2.5 ; if instead the ll spectrum had been scaled down , the discrepancies between irs and irac and mips would be less than 50% .
overall , in cases where the irs spectrum has sufficient signal - to - noise ratio and its fluxes seem lower than the photometric measurements or the discrepancies in irac - irs and mips - irs fluxes are quite different , intrinsic source variability could be a likely explanation . among the sample shown in table b[hops_variables ]
, this would apply to hops 24 , 71 , 131 , 132 , 141 , 143 , 154 , 187 , 206 , 223 , 228 , 299 , 363 , and 388 .
hops 223 is indeed variable ( see * ? ? ?
* ) , but the other objects still require confirmation .
thus , about 5% of the 290 protostars in our hops sample that have irs , irac , and mips data may reveal variability to some degree .
these objects are prime candidates for follow - up observations regarding their variability .
in section [ deltar ] we discussed how modes can be used to assess how well model parameters are constrained . here
we analyze the spread of mode values for individual hops targets . in figure set c1 ( see fig .
c[inc_modes_bf ] for an example ) we show the difference between the modes and the best - fit values of the major model parameters ( @xmath218 ) for all modeled hops targets . as in section [ deltar ] , we use models in certain @xmath193 bins , starting at a range of 0.5 from the best - fit @xmath154 up to a range of 2.0 from the best - fit @xmath154 . for parameters with discrete values , such as the inclination and cavity opening angles ,
we plot the difference between the indices of modes and best - fit values . for example , if the best - fit inclination angle has a value of 41 and the mode a value of 57 , the difference in indices would be 2 ( since the discrete values in our model grid are 18 , 32 , 41 , 50 , 57 , etc . ) .
similarly , if the best - fit cavity opening angle is 5 but the mode is 45 , the difference in indices would be 4 .
for the total luminosity and foreground extinction , we plotted instead the difference between the parameter values of the best fit and the modes .
objects that are not particularly well fit by their best - fit model from the grid often have modes that are quite different from the best - fit value once @xmath193 reaches 2 .
for example , for hops 181 , whose best - fit model has @xmath154=5.16 , the mode of the inclination angle for models within @xmath193=0.5 ( i.e. , models with @xmath219 ) is the same as the best - fit value , but then the difference increases as @xmath193 becomes larger .
for @xmath193=2.0 , the mode is seven discrete values away from the best fit ( @xmath18118 for the mode , 76 for the best fit ) .
several other model parameters are also not well constrained .
there are also objects that have a relatively good fit , but a larger spread in certain parameters .
an example is hops 70 , whose best - fit model has an @xmath154 value of 2.33 ; its total luminosity and inclination angle are very well constrained , while its reference envelope density is quite uncertain .
certain protostars are sufficiently well constrained by the available data and well fit by our grid of models that their parameters do not change much from @xmath193=0.5 to @xmath193=2.0 .
for example , the modes of the inclination angle of hops 1 are the same as the best - fit value even for all models within @xmath193=2 , and the other model parameters show a small spread
. there are 37 protostars with small differences between their best - fit values and modes for models within @xmath193=2 ( @xmath29 factor of two for @xmath68 and @xmath82 , @xmath29 50 au for the disk radius , @xmath29 10 for the cavity opening angle , @xmath29 30% difference in inclination angle ) .
these protostars are well characterized by our model fits .
the mean and median @xmath154 values for their best - fit models are 3.48 and 3.17 , respectively .
this validates our estimate of @xmath220 4 as the boundary between a reliable and a less reliable fit . .
_ the remaining plots for the other five model parameters are available in figure set c1 . _
[ inc_modes_bf ] ] part of the parameter uncertainties can be attributed to degeneracies between model parameters . to illustrate some of these degeneracies , in figure
set c2 ( see fig .
c[hops24_contour1 ] for an example ) we show contour plots of @xmath154 values for sets of two model parameters each ( we plot the lowest @xmath154 value of models with these two parameter values ) resulting from the model fits of hops 24 , hops 107 , and hops 149 .
the plots for hops 24 show that the inclination angle is somewhat degenerate with the envelope density , with higher inclination angles being accommodated by lower @xmath68 values ( fig
. c[hops24_contour1 ] ) .
a similar situation applies to the disk radius , with larger disk radii requiring higher envelope densities .
the inclination angle and the cavity opening angle are degenerate , too ; for higher inclination angles the cavity is larger .
the @xmath154 contour plots for hops 107 suggest that a certain range of inclination angles and reference densities can fit the sed , while the disk radius and cavity opening angles are not well constrained .
however , the plots clearly show that high - density , high - inclination models fit very poorly .
finally , we can deduce from the @xmath154 contour plots for hops 149 that also here certain parameter values can be excluded ; lower inclination angles and reference densities in the 10@xmath22110@xmath222 g @xmath33 range yield the best fits , with larger densities accompanied by larger disk radii and larger cavity opening angles .
contour plot for the models that fit hops 24 . for each combination of inclination angle and reference density ,
the lowest @xmath154 values of models with these two parameter values are shown . _
the remaining @xmath154 contour plots are available in figure set c2 . _ [ hops24_contour1 ] ]
llrr[h ] hops 394 & 019003 & 83.8497 & -5.1315 + hops 395 & 026011 & 84.8208 & -7.4074 + hops 396 & 029003 & 84.8048 & -7.2199 + hops 397 & 061012 & 85.7036 & -8.2696 + hops 398 & 082005 & 85.3725 & -2.3547 + hops 399 & 082012 & 85.3539 & -2.3024 + hops 400 & 090003 & 85.6885 & -1.2706 + hops 401 & 091015 & 86.5319 & -0.2058 + hops 402 & 091016 & 86.5415 & -0.2047 + hops 403 & 093005 & 86.6156 & -0.0149 + hops 404 & 097002 & 87.0323 & 0.5641 + hops 405 & 119019 & 85.2436 & -8.0934 + hops 406 & 300001 & 86.9307 & 0.6396 + hops 407 & 302002 & 86.6177 & 0.3242 + hops 408 & 313006 & 84.8781 & -7.3998 + hops 409 & 135003 & 83.8392 & -5.2215 + among our hops sample , there are 41 targets that are likely ysos , but they lack pacs measurements at 70 and 160 @xmath0 m and were therefore not included in the modeling sample .
there are four additional targets with hops numbers that were not modeled ; they are hops 109 , 111 , 212 , and 362 , and they are duplicates of hops 40 , 60 , 211 , and 169 , respectively .
table d[hops_no_model_ysos ] lists the 41 likely ysos in the hops catalog that were not part of the modeling sample ; their seds are shown in figure d[non_model_ysos ] . among them , 17 were not observed by pacs at 70 @xmath0 m , while 24 were observed , but not detected at 70 @xmath0 m .
the majority of these targets are class i protostars or flat - spectrum sources ; only one is a class 0 protostar , and five are class ii pre - main - sequence stars .
most of these ysos have very faint fluxes in the near- to mid - ir .
they could be deeply embedded protostars , like hops 307 , or just very low - mass protostars with weak envelope emission .
objects with little excess emission out to about 8 @xmath0 m , a 10 @xmath0 m silicate emission feature , and a more or less steeply rising sed beyond 12 @xmath0 m are likely transitional disks ( see * ? ? ?
* ) ; good examples are hops 51 and 54 .
it is possible that some of the ysos in this sample are actually extragalactic contaminants , in particular objects with flat seds ( see more about this subset of our hops sample in the next subsection ) .
lrrrrrrc [ hops_no_model_ysos ] hops 0 & 88.6171 & 1.6264 & i & 0.011 & 652.2 & 0.514 & -1 + hops 8 & 83.8880 & -5.9851 & i & 0.013 & 329.8 & 0.419 & 0 + hops 9 & 83.9550 & -5.9843 & i & 0.006 & 281.5 & 0.858 & -1 + hops 14 & 84.0799 & -5.9251 & flat & 0.042 & 464.0 & 0.246 & 0 + hops 23 & 84.0745 & -5.7818 & i & 0.012 & 346.8 & 0.539 & 0 + hops 25 & 83.8443 & -5.7415 & flat & 0.045 & 646.6 & 0.165 & 0 + hops 31 & 83.8219 & -5.6741 & flat & 0.024 & 634.7 & 0.304 & 0 + hops 34 & 83.7954 & -5.6585 & i & 0.013 & 235.5 & 0.762 & 0 + hops 35 & 83.8331 & -5.6503 & i & 0.044 & 305.2 & 0.884 & 0 + hops 37 & 83.6986 & -5.6237 & flat & 0.016 & 913.4 & 0.230 & 0 + hops 51 & 83.8160 & -5.5015 & ii & 0.518 & 130.2 & & 0 + hops 52 & 83.8180 & -5.4924 & flat & 0.641 & 610.8 & -0.163 & 0 + hops 54 & 83.3437 & -5.3841 & ii & 0.097 & 1879.3 & -0.37 & -1 + hops 62 & 83.8524 & -5.1916 & flat & 0.660 & 1154.1 & 0.043 & 0 + hops 63 & 83.8538 & -5.1671 & flat & 0.516 & 544.5 & 0.004 & 0 + hops 64 & 83.8625 & -5.1650 & i & 15.347 & 29.7 & 0.503 & 0 + hops 69 & 83.8551 & -5.1400 & flat & 2.778 & 31.3 & -0.189 & 0 + hops 79 & 83.8662 & -5.0934 & flat & 0.086 & 666.2 & -0.137 & 0 + hops 103 & 83.5508 & -4.8353 & flat & 0.142 & 1484.3 & -0.032 & 0 + hops 104 & 83.7782 & -4.8338 & i & 0.044 & 337.3 & 0.837 & 0 + hops 110 & 84.0093 & -5.0472 & i & 0.014 & 244.0 & & -1 + hops 126 & 85.0408 & -7.1650 & flat & 0.132 & 1865.3 & -0.136 & -1 + hops 151 & 84.6787 & -6.9447 & ii & 0.061 & 799.4 & -0.505 & 0 + hops 155 & 84.3160 & -7.2972 & flat & 0.013 & 393.8 & 0.133 & -1 + hops 162 & 84.1291 & -6.8780 & ii & 0.015 & 909.9 & 0.352 & -1 + hops 180 & 84.2475 & -6.1710 & ii & 0.011 & 1493.5 & 0.578 & -1 + hops 195 & 84.0002 & -6.1206 & flat & 0.032 & 659.7 & 0.399 & 0 + hops 217 & 85.7965 & -8.4056 & i & 0.008 & 323.8 & 0.773 & -1 + hops 230 & 85.6283 & -8.1515 & flat & 0.267 & 1260.2 & -0.104 & -1 + hops 231 & 85.1189 & -8.5486 & flat & 0.024 & 386.0 & -0.239 & -1 + hops 269 & 85.3625 & -7.7094 & flat & 0.025 & 230.2 & 0.023 & -1 + hops 289 & 84.9865 & -7.5017 & i & 0.095 & 331.1 & 0.868 & 0 + hops 296 & 85.3215 & -2.3021 & i & 0.022 & 326.0 & 0.931 & 0 + hops 302 & 85.0934 & -2.2610 & flat & 0.383 & 1367.2 & -0.032 & -1 + hops 307 & 85.3077 & -1.7844 & 0 & 0.748 & 57.1 & 1.506 & -1 + hops 314 & 86.6505 & -0.3414 & i & 0.015 & 276.2 & 1.112 & -1 + hops 327 & 86.6139 & 0.1477 & flat & 0.020 & 991.0 & 0.145 & -1 + hops 328 & 86.5561 & 0.1759 & i & 0.012 & 326.3 & 0.868 & -1 + hops 330 & 86.7140 & 0.3298 & flat & 0.121 & 385.2 & 0.285 & 0 + hops 332 & 86.8821 & 0.3391 & flat & 0.249 & 145.5 & 0.045 & 0 + hops 360 & 86.8629 & 0.3425 & i & 1.017 & 43.2 & & 0 + our hops sample contains 29 targets that turned out to be likely extragalactic contaminants .
these objects are listed in table d[hops_contaminants ] , and their seds are shown in figure d[non_model_exgal ] .
most galaxies were identified based on the presence of pah features or emission lines in their irs spectra ( in particular , the 515 @xmath0 m region ) , the absence of a silicate absorption feature at 10 @xmath0 m , and an overall flat or slightly rising mid - infrared continuum .
clear examples are hops 21 , 27 , 46 , 48 , 55 , 61 , 72 , 106 , 161 , and 301 .
two objects , hops 202 and hops 205 , have a tentative 10 @xmath0 m silicate emission feature and a steep rise of their sed beyond 12 @xmath0 m , but also pah emission features in their irs spectrum ; they could be transitional disks and not galaxies
. in some cases , e.g. , hops 308 , targets classified as extragalactic contaminants are very faint in the near- to mid - infrared ; instead of galaxies , they could be very low - mass or deeply embedded protostars .
the mid - ir sed of hops 339 is mostly flat but displays a sharp 10 @xmath0 m absorption feature ; based on the sed alone , it would not necessarily be classified as a galaxy , but high - resolution near - ir _ hst _ images resolve its extended emission and reveal a spiral galaxy ( j. booker et al .
2016 , in preparation ) . finally , hops 349 , 350 , 352 , 353 , 356 , and 381 have poorly sampled seds ( just one or two flux measurements ) , so their nature is quite uncertain .
we list their coordinates in table d[hops_uncertain_obj ] .
lrrrrr [ hops_contaminants ] hops 21 & 84.0421 & -5.8356 & 0.074 & 584.5 & 0.824 + hops 27 & 84.0905 & -5.6995 & 0.102 & 118.2 & 0.458 + hops 39 & 84.0934 & -5.6069 & 0.100 & 159.4 & 1.010 + hops 46 & 83.6758 & -5.5509 & 0.141 & 1081.9 & -0.083 + hops 48 & 83.7773 & -5.5477 & 0.608 & 611.0 & 0.252 + hops 55 & 83.4754 & -5.3638 & 0.316 & 101.5 & 1.732 + hops 61 & 83.3579 & -5.2007 & 0.045 & 721.4 & -0.031 + hops 67 & 83.8445 & -5.1428 & 0.044 & 278.7 & 0.900 + hops 72 & 83.8571 & -5.1296 & 0.545 & 693.0 & 0.068 + hops 83 & 83.9822 & -5.0771 & 0.131 & 293.9 & -0.119 + hops 97 & 83.8704 & -4.9608 & 0.190 & 403.8 & 0.125 + hops 101 & 83.7843 & -4.9027 & 3.355 & 481.2 & -0.207 + hops 106 & 84.0518 & -4.7544 & 0.016 & 359.7 & 0.943 + hops 112 & 85.1833 & -7.3786 & 0.014 & 390.2 & 0.093 + hops 146 & 84.6840 & -7.0112 & 0.053 & 519.7 & -0.178 + hops 161 & 84.1448 & -7.1871 & 0.062 & 179.1 & 0.458 + hops 196 & 83.8371 & -6.3062 & 0.065 & 165.5 & -0.042 + hops 202 & 83.4330 & -6.2295 & 0.018 & 736.3 & 0.534 + hops 205 & 85.7620 & -8.7971 & 0.067 & 427.8 & 0.549 + hops 218 & 85.7912 & -8.2232 & 0.007 & 332.5 & 0.653 + hops 292 & 84.4787 & -7.6890 & 0.068 & 280.5 & 0.421 + hops 301 & 85.4366 & -2.2654 & 2.955 & 518.8 & 0.271 + hops 306 & 85.7630 & -1.8013 & 0.038 & 310.8 & 0.060 + hops 308 & 85.8082 & -1.7195 & 0.042 & 156.0 & 0.791 + hops 309 & 85.6973 & -1.4131 & 0.041 & 111.9 & -0.168 + hops 313 & 85.2532 & -1.1529 & 0.030 & 154.1 & 1.039 + hops 339 & 86.4733 & 0.4243 & 0.128 & 398.3 & 0.246 + hops 348 & 86.7511 & 0.3438 & 0.286 & 84.0 & + hops 351 & 83.8809 & -5.0797 & 0.016 & 217.1 & + lrr[!h ] [ hops_uncertain_obj ] hops 349 & 83.8592 & -5.1426 + hops 350 & 83.8758 & -5.1386 + hops 352 & 83.8617 & -5.0675 + hops 353 & 88.5556 & 1.7175 + hops 356 & 85.5341 & -1.4438 + hops 381 & 83.7816 & -5.6986 + | we present key results from the herschel orion protostar survey ( hops ) : spectral energy distributions ( seds ) and model fits of 330 young stellar objects , predominantly protostars , in the orion molecular clouds .
this is the largest sample of protostars studied in a single , nearby star formation complex . with near - infrared photometry from 2mass , mid- and far - infrared data from _
spitzer _ and _ herschel _ , and submillimeter photometry from apex , our seds cover 1.2 870 @xmath0 m and sample the peak of the protostellar envelope emission at @xmath1 100 @xmath0 m . using mid - ir spectral indices and bolometric temperatures , we classify our sample into 92 class 0 protostars , 125 class i protostars , 102 flat - spectrum sources , and 11 class ii pre - main - sequence stars .
we implement a simple protostellar model ( including a disk in an infalling envelope with outflow cavities ) to generate a grid of 30,400 model seds and use it to determine the best - fit model parameters for each protostar .
we argue that far - ir data are essential for accurate constraints on protostellar envelope properties .
we find that most protostars , and in particular the flat - spectrum sources , are well fit . the median envelope density and median inclination angle decrease from class 0 to class i to flat - spectrum protostars , despite the broad range in best - fit parameters in each of the three categories .
we also discuss degeneracies in our model parameters .
our results confirm that the different protostellar classes generally correspond to an evolutionary sequence with a decreasing envelope infall rate , but the inclination angle also plays a role in the appearance , and thus interpretation , of the seds . |
current cmb experiments are sensitive enough to measure the primordial fluctuations which have an amplitude in the range of @xmath6k over the @xmath7-range @xmath8 which corresponds to angular scales of @xmath9 arcmin ( hanany et al .
2000 ; mauskopf et al .
2000 ; padin et al . 2001 ; halverson et al . 2002 ; scott et al . 2002 ) . the angular power spectrum of these fluctuations
contains a wealth of cosmological information .
one of the crucial factors in determining an accurate power spectrum of these fluctuations is understanding and removing the foreground contamination .
the amplitude of the foreground signal depends on frequency , angular scale and region of sky being observed .
cmb foregrounds comprise point sources and diffuse galactic foregrounds .
point sources are a particular problem at smaller angular scales ( @xmath10 arcmin ) , while diffuse foreground structures become dominant on larger angular scales . here
we concentrate on the problem of diffuse galactic foregrounds at frequencies below @xmath11 ghz , a frequency range which is used in current and upcoming cmb experiments such as the _ map _ and _ planck _ satellites .
the diffuse galactic foreground has 3 ( possibly 4 ) components .
i ) _ synchrotron _ emission from relativistic electrons spiralling in the galactic magnetic field dominates at frequencies below 1 ghz with a spectral index ( @xmath12 ) of @xmath13 ( davies et al . 1996 ) .
it is traced by low - frequency surveys such as those of haslam et al .
( 1982 ) , reich & reich .
( 1988 ) and jonas et al .
( 1998 ) where it is seen to extend well above the plane - e.g. the north polar spur which extends to galactic latitude @xmath14 .
ii ) _ free - free _ bremsstrahlung emission from thermal electrons has a flatter spectral index of @xmath15 .
it is the dominant foreground at frequencies between @xmath16 ghz , where microwave cmb experiments operate ( e.g. dasi , cbi , vsa , _ map _ , _ planck _ ) . the optical h@xmath0line is a good tracer of free - free emission although it requires corrections for dust absorption .
iii ) the _ vibrational _ emission from thermal dust is dominant at frequencies above @xmath17 ghz .
this is thermal emission from warm dust and is well - traced at @xmath18 m where it has its peak .
iv ) an _ anomalous _ component has recently been discovered ( kogut et al .
1996 ; leitch et al .
1997 ; de oliveira - costa et al .
1997,1998,1999,2000,2002 ; finkbeiner et al .
draine & lazarian ( 1998 ) proposed that this could be due to @xmath19 dust grains emitting in a 1 - 2 octave band centred at @xmath20 ghz .
it was first believed to be due to free - free emission ( kogut 1996 ) , but this has been ruled out primarily by the lack of associated h@xmath0emission .
the separation and quantifying of the individual cmb foreground components is a continuing challenge .
each component is of interest in its own right ; its angular distribution and spectrum are basic parameters .
they all contribute as foregrounds to the cmb and their removal is necessary to realize the full potential of current high sensitivity cmb surveys where @xmath21 values are to be measured to an accuracy of a few percent .
such separations are best made using templates for each component . with the advent of the h@xmath0survey ,
such a template is now available for each of the 4 proposed components .
although some approaches to separation of components are being made which reduce the assumptions about the template parameters ( e.g. baccigalupi et al .
2000 ; vielva et al .
2001 ) they still face difficulties where the components are correlated . for example
all the foregrounds are quasi - correlated as they increase strongly towards the galactic plane .
also , the h@xmath0and ( spinning ) dust emissions show considerable correlation over most of the sky ( see section [ discussion ] ) ; this was at the root of the original misunderstanding of the anomalous component
. if one has a good free - free template as we derive here , the other 3 foreground components can be well - characterized except possibly at the lowest galactic latitudes .
extensive filamentary h@xmath0emission regions , of galactic origin , were first found by meaburn ( 1965 , 1967 ) extending to high galactic latitudes ; sivan ( 1974 ) demonstrated the wealth of h@xmath0emission at low - intermediate latitudes but at a relatively low sensitivity of @xmath22 ; we note that 1 rayleigh @xmath23 photons s@xmath24 @xmath25 sr@xmath26 erg s@xmath24 @xmath25 sr@xmath27 for @xmath28 k gas .
several large and very sensitive h@xmath0surveys are now well under way .
the most relevant surveys are listed in table [ halpha_surveys.table ] . [
cols="<,<,^,^,^,^ " , ] higher frequency maps will necessarily have higher fractions of free - free emission .
the widely used maps at 1420 mhz ( reich & reich 1988 ) and 2326 mhz ( jonas 1998 ) are used for estimating the galactic contribution at higher frequencies . using the estimate of @xmath29 per cent at 408 mhz ,
the free - free fluctuations at 1420 mhz will contribute @xmath30 per cent compared to the synchrotron component at intermediate latitudes , while at 2326 mhz this increases to @xmath31 per cent . by correcting the 408 mhz map for free - free emission , a better synchrotron map can be made .
this is particularly important for cross - correlation analyses which assume that the templates are not correlated . with h@xmath0data alone
it is not possible to construct a free - free correction template at lower galactic latitudes .
[ ha_map.fig ] shows regions along the galactic plane where the dust absorption is too large to estimate an accurate dust - free h@xmath0intensity .
we plan to use multi - frequency maps of the galactic plane to separate the free - free and synchrotron components at low latitudes .
the narrow free - free latitude distribution along the plane has a peak brightness at 408 mhz which varies from 40 to 80 per cent that of the broader synchrotron distribution at @xmath32 to @xmath33 ( large , mathewson & haslam 1961 ) .
accordingly , the correction of the 408 mhz map for free - free emission is important at low latitudes .
the other factor in constructing a template at @xmath34 resolution from the low frequency radio maps is the effect of the main - beam to full - beam ratio ( @xmath35 ) on angular scales of a few degrees ; we note that the brightness temperature scale of the published maps is on the full - beam scale ( @xmath36 ) .
the result is that temperatures on the main - beam scale ( @xmath37 ) should be multiplied by a factor @xmath35 to bring them to the correct brightness temperature scale .
this procedure has been considered in sections [ scans ] and [ subtract ] and clearly needs to be taken into account for accurate free - free and synchrotron predictions .
this scale - dependence to true brightness temperature has been noted before ( e.g. jonas et al . 1998 ) and is currently under review when applying it to existing full - sky maps .
the h@xmath0intensities given by wham and shassa have quoted calibration accuracies of 10 and 9 per cent respectively .
the corresponding zero level uncertainties are approximately 0.2 and 0.5 @xmath38 .
the accuracy is likely to be improved as these surveys are refined .
the largest uncertainty in the h@xmath0intensity is in the dust absorption correction as discussed in section [ dust_absorption ] . at intermediate and higher galactic latitudes where @xmath39 mag ,
the error in the corrected @xmath40 is @xmath41 per cent ; this error increases to @xmath42 per cent where @xmath43 is 1 mag nearer the galactic plane .
on converting the dust - corrected @xmath44 to @xmath45 , the free - free brightness temperature , a further uncertainty is introduced by the spread in @xmath46 , the electron temperature , in the local region of the galaxy covered by the h@xmath0maps . for @xmath47 k , the @xmath45 uncertainty is @xmath48 per cent as derived from equation ( [ tb_ha.eqn ] ) . as far as the emission theory used in section [ halpha_conversion ]
is concerned , we believe that the gaunt factor and the analytical relations given are accurate to 1 - 2 per cent . it is assumed throughout that the h@xmath0emission is given by the case b emission formulae
; the observed radio @xmath45 values are consistent with this assumption .
( 80,60 ) ( 0,0 ) a radio - independent method of determining a free - free template has a significant benefit in establishing the other galactic foreground templates for cmb studies .
we have already shown in section [ full_synch ] that an improved synchrotron template can be derived from the 408 mhz map by correcting for the known free - free emission .
this method breaks down for the small area along the galactic plane where the dust absorption of the h@xmath0becomes too high ; other methods of determining the free - free emission are available here . spinning dust radiating in the region 10 - 40 ghz
is proposed as a galactic foreground ( draine & lazarian 1998 ) ; observations appear to confirm this scenario ( kogut et al .
1996 ; leitch et al .
1997 ; de oliveira - costa et al .
1997 , 1998 , 1999 , 2000 , 2002 ; finkbeiner et al .
a strong confirmation of the presence of spinning dust radio emission correlated with the sfd98 dust template requires a clean separation of the free - free component beforehand .
this is important because the dust and h@xmath0are generally thought of as being correlated .
an example of a region of the galaxy where the correlation is relatively strong is @xmath49 .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ tt_plots.fig](a ) which shows the correlation between h@xmath0and ( @xmath50 ) from sfd98 at @xmath34 resolution .
the relation between @xmath44 and @xmath50 for the region in orion @xmath51 to @xmath52 is given in fig .
[ tt_plots.fig ] ( b ) where it is seen that the correlation is less strong .
the distribution of h@xmath0and dust for the orion region is shown in fig .
[ correlations.fig ] .
the situation is clearly complex on the scale of @xmath34 as would be expected for a star - forming region and underscores the necessity of removing the free - free emission before investigating spinning dust .
( 80,80 ) ( 0,0 ) we will now estimate the free - free contribution to the cmb foregrounds at @xmath42 ghz .
if not subtracted from the data , the foreground signal will add in quadrature to the cmb signal in the power spectrum since they will be uncorrelated on the sky .
the free - free template allows statistical estimates to be made of the free - free component on angular scales @xmath53 compared to the primordial cmb fluctuations . at angular scales of @xmath34 ( @xmath54 ) ,
the cmb has r.m.s .
fluctuations of @xmath55k , falling to @xmath56k at smaller and larger angular scales . over a large portion of the higher latitude sky ( @xmath57 ) ,
the average contribution of free - free emission is @xmath58k at 30 ghz on scales of @xmath34 .
this amounts to a @xmath59 per cent increase in the power spectrum at @xmath60 .
however , individual regions may be contaminated at a much higher level depending on their position . at higher frequencies ( @xmath61 ghz ) ,
the free - free contribution will be @xmath62k and will be negligible at high latitudes .
we can also compare the estimates for specific regions of the sky where cmb observations have been made .
the vsa has observed three regions of the sky measuring angular scales of @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) covering a total area of 101 square degrees at a frequency of 34 ghz ( taylor et al .
the contamination from free - free emission using the free - free template is estimated to give an r.m.s .
temperature of @xmath65k at the @xmath34 scale and hence the free - free contamination is negligible in these selected regions .
the north celestial pole ( ncp ) region has been studied by the saskatoon group ( wollack et al .
the saskatoon data show an anomalous component which can not be explained on conventional grounds . using the free - free template , the r.m.s .
variations are @xmath66k in a @xmath67-diameter circle centred on the ncp on smoothing the h@xmath0map to a resolution of @xmath68 and assuming a conversion factor of @xmath69k@xmath70 .
simonetti et al .
( 1996 ) use their h@xmath0data to estimate an upper limit of @xmath71k at 27.5 ghz in this region .
these values of @xmath72k can be compared with the @xmath73k r.m.s .
variations in the saskatoon data .
it therefore seems clear , that the anomalous emission is not in the form of free - free emission from gas at @xmath74 k. the current view is that it may be due to spinning dust emission as proposed by draine & lazarian ( 1998 ) .
the recent publication of h@xmath0surveys covering the majority of the sky has provided a break - through in obtaining a free - free galactic foreground template of importance for cmb and ism studies .
having derived the free - free template it is then possible to determine a better synchrotron template and to make real progress in constructing a spinning dust template .
the free - free template has many other applications which include a re - analysis of the _ cobe - dmr _ data ( banday et al .
, in preparation ) and a free - free power spectrum analysis ( dickinson et al . , in preparation ) . we can look forward to an improved all - sky free - free template at higher resolution than the @xmath34 used in the present work .
a combination of the high resolution ( arcmin scale ) narrow - band filter surveys such as shassa and vtss combined with the high sensitivity fabry - perot survey at a @xmath34 scale would be ideal . at lower galactic latitudes where the dust absorption of the h@xmath0emission is significant
, multi - frequency continuum surveys should be able to separate the strong synchrotron and free - free components .
recombination line surveys such as those being undertaken with hipass in the south ( barnes et al .
2001 ) and hijass in the north ( kilborn 2002 ) will provide a confirmation of the low latitude free - free template and distinguish it from spinning dust which will have a very similar latitude distribution .
the recombination line data will also lead to a kinematic 2-dimensional picture of the ionized gas distribution in the galaxy using kinematic distances since they contain velocity information .
cd acknowledges a pparc research grant .
wham is funded by the national science foundation ( nsf ) . the southern h - alpha sky survey atlas ( shassa )
is supported by the national science foundation .
we thank the wham / shassa teams for making their surveys available and answering our queries .
we also thank david valls - gabaud for verifying the calculation of the gaunt factor . | a full - sky template map of the galactic free - free foreground emission component is increasingly important for high sensitivity cmb experiments .
we use the recently published h@xmath0data of both the northern and southern skies as the basis for such a template .
the first step is to correct the h@xmath0maps for dust absorption using the 100 @xmath1 m dust maps of schlegel , finkbeiner & davis ( 1998 ) .
we show that for a range of longitudes , the galactic latitude distribution of absorption suggests that it is 33 per cent of the full extragalactic absorption .
a reliable absorption - corrected h@xmath0map can be produced for @xmath2 per cent of the sky ; the area for which a template can not be recovered is the galactic plane area @xmath3 , @xmath4 and some isolated dense dust clouds at intermediate latitudes .
the second step is to convert the dust - corrected h@xmath0data into a predicted radio surface brightness .
the free - free emission formula is revised to give an accurate expression ( 1 per cent ) for the radio emission covering the frequency range 100 mhz to 100 ghz and the electron temperature range 3000 to 20000 k. the main uncertainty when applying this expression is the variation of electron temperature across the sky .
the emission formula is verified in several extended hii regions using data in the range 408 to 2326 mhz .
a full - sky free - free template map is presented at 30 ghz ; the scaling to other frequencies is given .
the haslam et al .
all - sky 408 mhz map of the sky can be corrected for this free - free component , which amounts to a @xmath5 per cent correction at intermediate and high latitudes , to provide a pure synchrotron all - sky template .
the implications for cmb experiments are discussed .
[ firstpage ] cosmic microwave background - radio continuum : ism - dust , extinction - hii regions - radiation mechanisms : thermal |
in an external magnetic field , due to the cyclotron motion of charge carriers , the conductivity tensor acquires non - diagonal components @xmath74 in case of rather low energies , @xmath75 , the main contribution to the graphene conductivity arises for intraband transitions . for such energies the boltzmann s transport theory is valid , so that neglecting temperature effects in the fermi distribution , the two independent components ( @xmath76 and @xmath77 ) of the conductivity tensor can be expressed as : @xmath78 here @xmath79 , @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is a scattering energy , and @xmath8 is a relaxation time .
the quantity @xmath82 is the cyclotron resonance energy normalized to the chemical potential @xmath83 where @xmath0 is the magnetic field , @xmath84 is the fermi velocity , and @xmath85 is the fermi energy that we set equal to the chemical potential , @xmath86 .
let as assume an arbitrary polarized monochromatic plane wave impinging onto a periodic array of graphene ribbons , in the presence of a static perpendicular magnetic field @xmath0 .
we chose the coordinate system so that the ribbon array is located at @xmath87 , between two semi - spaces dielectrics characterized by electrical permittivities @xmath88 and @xmath89 , respectively .
we chose the @xmath90 axis so that it coincides with the conductivity modulation direction .
then , for the conductivity tensor we have @xmath91 , where @xmath5 is the array period .
we present the conductivity tensor of the ribbons array as the fourier expansion , @xmath92 with the fourier coefficients @xmath93 at the patterned graphene layer , @xmath87 , it is convenient to introduce the polarization unit - vectors and the corresponding plane wave eigenfunctions of the incident , reflected and transmitted waves . for the incident wave the polarization unit vectors @xmath94 and @xmath95 can be presented as @xmath96 and the corresponding eigenfunctions @xmath97 here @xmath98 , @xmath99 , and @xmath100 so that @xmath101 . to write the eigenfunctions of reflected and
transmitted waves let us introduce tangential and normal to graphene components of their wavevectors @xmath102 with @xmath103 . then
, the polarization unit vectors can be written as @xmath104 so the corresponding plane wave eigenfunctions are @xmath105 here @xmath106 stands for `` @xmath107 '' ( reflected ) and `` @xmath108 '' ( transmitted ) , and @xmath109 , @xmath110 . the electric fields in the upper and lower semi - spaces can be written as @xmath111 where @xmath112 .
let us also introduce the normalized in - plane polarization unit - vectors @xmath113 , @xmath114 : @xmath115 and in - plane modes @xmath116 , @xmath117 which contain only tangential components of the fields @xmath118 and which do not depend on surrounding media since they do not contain @xmath119 .
the relations between @xmath120 , @xmath121 and @xmath122 are following : @xmath123 where @xmath124 , and @xmath125 the boundary conditions at the patterned graphene layer @xmath87 read @xmath126 = \frac{4\pi}{c}\hat{\sigma } \mathbf{e}_{2t}. \end{split } \right.\ ] ] substituting here the expressions for the fields ( [ 7 ] ) and taking into account that , from maxwell equations , it follows @xmath127,\ ] ] then , we obtain that the boundary conditions can be written as @xmath128 introducing the surface impedances , @xmath129 \right ] & = c_{1}^\alpha~z_{1}^\alpha |\alpha_0\rangle , \\
\frac{1}{k } \left [ \mathbf{e}_z \times \left [ \mathbf{k}_n^r \times |\alpha_n^r\rangle \right ] \right ] & = - c_{1n}^\alpha~z_{1n}^\alpha |\alpha_n\rangle , \\ \frac{1}{k } \left [ \mathbf{e}_z \times \left [ \mathbf{k}_n^t \times |\alpha_n^t\rangle \right ] \right ] & = c_{2n}^\alpha~z_{2n}^\alpha |\alpha_n\rangle , \end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath130 the boundary conditions become @xmath131 projecting these two equations on @xmath132 and integrating the expression over the structure period we obtain : @xmath133 let us now define the transformation coefficients of the diffracted waves @xmath134 substituting ( [ 19 ] ) into ( [ 18 ] ) we obtain @xmath135 where @xmath136 here , one should not confuse the components of the tensor @xmath137 with the polarization index @xmath138 . from the first equation of we
have @xmath139 substituting into the second expression of we obtain @xmath140 rearranging the expression we have @xmath141 expanding the expression with the polarization indexes @xmath138 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 , we obtain the infinite system of equations for the reflected waves amplitudes @xmath144 which can be presented as @xmath145 where @xmath146 , \\ & d_{nm}^{sp } = c_{1m}^p f_{nm}^{sp } , \\ & d_{nm}^{ps } = c_{1m}^s f_{nm}^{ps } , \\ & d_{nm}^{pp } = c_{1n}^{p } \left [ \delta_{nm } \left ( z_{1n}^p + z_{2n}^p \right ) + f_{nm}^{pp } \right ] .
\end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath147 , \\ & v_{n}^{sp } = - d_{n0}^{sp } , \\ & v_{n}^{ps } = - d_{n0}^{ps } , \\ & v_{n}^{pp } = c_{1}^p \left [ \delta_{n,0 } \left ( z_{1n}^p - z_{2n}^p \right ) - f_{n0}^{pp } \right ] , \end{split}\ ] ] or in a compact form @xmath148 then , the matrix @xmath149 containing the reflected waves amplitudes is @xmath150_{nm } \widehat{v}_n.\ ] ] by definition , the diffraction efficiencies of reflected and transmitted waves , @xmath151 and @xmath152 , are as follows , @xmath153 where @xmath154 from we have @xmath155 consequently , for the s - polarized wave the diffraction efficiencies are @xmath156 and for the p - polarized wave @xmath157
in case of the continuous graphene sheet the problem becomes substantially simplified .
namely , from ( [ 21 ] ) it follows @xmath158 where @xmath159 so that the system ( [ 30 ] ) @xmath160 becomes @xmath161 @xmath162 here @xmath163 , @xmath164 . taking into account that @xmath165 , the determinant of the matrix @xmath166 in ( [ i2 ] ) is @xmath167.\ ] ] the corresponding cofactors are @xmath168 , \\ & \delta_{sp } = ( c_{1}^p)^2 \alpha_2 z_{1}^p , \\ & \delta_{ps } = - \alpha_2 z_{1}^s , \\ & \delta_{pp } = c_{1}^p \left [ ( z_{1}^s + z_{2}^s + \alpha_1 ) ( z_{1}^p - z_{2}^p - \alpha_1 ) - \alpha_2 ^ 2 \right ] , \\ \end{split}\ ] ] then , the reflection coefficients are @xmath169 or explicitly , @xmath170 } , \quad r^{pp } = \frac { ( z_{1}^s + z_{2}^s + \alpha_1 ) ( z_{1}^p - z_{2}^p - \alpha_1 ) - \alpha_2 ^ 2 } { ( z_{1}^s + z_{2}^s + \alpha_1 )
( z_{1}^p + z_{2}^p + \alpha_1 ) + \alpha_2 ^ 2 } .
\end{split}\ ] ] from the expression it follows that @xmath171 or explicitly , @xmath172 } , \quad t^{pp } = \frac{2 c_1^p z_1^p ( z_{1}^s + z_{2}^s + \alpha_1 ) } { c_{2}^p \left [ ( z_{1}^s + z_{2}^s + \alpha_1 ) ( z_{1}^p
+ z_{2}^p + \alpha_1 ) + \alpha_2 ^ 2 \right ] } . \\ \end{split}\ ] ] for the free - standing graphene @xmath34 , and thus @xmath173 , @xmath174 , @xmath175 . then , the reflection coefficients are @xmath176 } , \quad r^{pp } = - \frac { \alpha_1 ( z^s + \alpha_1 ) + \alpha_2 ^ 2 } { ( z^s + \alpha_1 ) ( z^p + \alpha_1 ) + \alpha_2 ^ 2 } .
\end{split}\ ] ] while the transmission coefficients have the expression @xmath177 } , \quad t^{pp } = \frac{z^p ( z^s + \alpha_1 ) } { \left [ ( z^s + \alpha_1 ) ( z^p + \alpha_1 ) + \alpha_2 ^ 2 \right ] } .
\end{split}\ ] ] if the wave is normally incident on a free - standing continuous graphene sheet , @xmath178 , @xmath179 and thus : @xmath180 @xmath181 from we can find the maximal value for cross - polarization coefficients , @xmath182 , @xmath183 , @xmath184 , @xmath185 . let @xmath186 , where @xmath187 is a fine - structure constant . then , substituting the explicit expressions for @xmath188 and @xmath189 into the expression for @xmath190 we obtain @xmath191 and thus @xmath192 this expression reaches its maximum at @xmath193 i.e. not strictly at the cyclotron resonance @xmath194 , but slightly shifted to lower frequencies . for not very low cyclotron frequencies we can rewrite as @xmath195 and in the first - order approximation @xmath196 . substituting back to the
we obtain @xmath197 if losses are absent , i.e. @xmath198 , we have @xmath199 we recall that this condition has been found by an explicit calculation for a translationally - invariant graphene sheet . however , there is a more general proof for the statement that , in an infinitesimally thin film , the squared modulus of any cross - polarization zero - order scattering coefficient can not exceed @xmath200 .
we start by the following condition , which arises from current conservation : @xmath201 from eq .
, for free - standing graphene in case of normal incidence we have @xmath202 substituting eq . into eq .
we obtain @xmath203 if the incident wave is @xmath21-polarized ( @xmath204 ) from eq .
we have @xmath205 from where @xmath206 if we present @xmath207 as a complex variable @xmath208 , we may introduce the function @xmath209 in the complex plane @xmath210 the function @xmath211 has the maximum at the point @xmath212 where @xmath213 .
though @xmath90 and @xmath214 are not independent but @xmath215 , @xmath216 , and we can not guarantee that @xmath217 can reach @xmath218 , it still sets a restriction on @xmath184 : it can not exceed @xmath200 , which is in accordance with the particular case stated in .
the relations allow derivation of @xmath188 and @xmath189 from the any two independent field components @xmath219 , @xmath220 .
let it be @xmath190 and
@xmath221 , then @xmath222 and , therefore , from it follows that @xmath223 treating the ribbons array as a continuous layer with a certain effective conductivity , we may equate @xmath224 and @xmath225 . from the expressions we readily obtain @xmath226 and @xmath227 : @xmath228 finally , the two independent components of the effective conductivity are @xmath229 , \quad \quad \widetilde\sigma_2 = \frac{c}{4\pi}\frac{t_0^{sp}}{(t_0^{sp})^2 + ( t_0^{pp})^2}.\ ] ]
in this section we will study the polarization rotation of the zeroth - order transmitted wave .
we are interested only in the case when the incident wave is normally impinging the array of graphene ribbons . according to ( [ 32 ] ) , in case of the @xmath21-polarized incident wave with the unity amplitude ( @xmath230 ) the amplitude of the zeroth - order transmitted wave is @xmath231 which means that after passing through the ribbons array in a non - zero magnetic field , the zeroth - order transmitted wave becomes elliptically polarized , see fig .
[ supfig1 ] . in terms of linearly polarized waves the polarization rotation angle @xmath3
is given by the expression : @xmath232 with @xmath233 note that here @xmath234 is a four quadrant arctangent function , @xmath235 which takes into account not the final sign of the quotient @xmath236 , but the signs of @xmath237 and @xmath238 separately .
let @xmath239 , and @xmath240 , then from it follows that @xmath241 @xmath242 then , substituting and into we obtain @xmath243 in case of a low conductivity , i.e. when @xmath244 , we can keep only the linear in the conductivity terms and obtain the widely adopted expression for the faraday rotation angle @xmath245 in terms of circularly polarized transmitted waves @xmath246 the faraday angle is defined as @xmath247 from we can find the maximal possible faraday rotation angle for a continuous graphene sheet .
let @xmath248 then , substituting here the expressions we obtain @xmath249 plugging in the explicit expressions for @xmath188 , @xmath189 ( see and ) and employing the notation @xmath186 , we obtain @xmath250 in the limit @xmath198 @xmath251 analytical analysis of the function @xmath252 is rather time - consuming , so we present the result : @xmath253 @xmath254 \quad \text{at } \quad \omega = \omega_{\text{c}}-0,\ ] ] where @xmath138 is the fine - structure constant .
it is seen that with growth of the magnetic field , both values tend to @xmath255 .
interestingly , with magnetic field decrease @xmath256 whereas @xmath257 .
it then follows that if we apply a very low magnetic field to a high - quality graphene sheet and then illuminate it at the frequency @xmath258 , the transmitted wave s polarization will be strongly rotated with almost no losses ( of course , if the conductivity model works at such frequencies ) . at zero magnetic field
no polarization rotation can be obtained because we can not go below @xmath259 .
this result seems erroneous , however the first work by crassee _ et .
_ does indeed show strong a asymmetry of faraday rotation at low magnetic fields . | a single graphene sheet , when subjected to a perpendicular static magnetic field provides faraday rotation that , per atomic layer , greatly surpasses that of any other known material .
this giant faraday rotation originates from the cyclotron resonance of massless electrons , which allows dynamical tuning through either external electrostatic or magnetostatic setting .
furthermore , the rotation direction can be controlled by changing the sign of the carriers in graphene , which can be done by means of an external electric field . however , despite these tuning possibilities , the requirement of large magnetic fields hinders application of the faraday effect in real devices , especially for frequencies higher than few thz . in this work
we demonstrate that , for a given value of the static external magnetic field , giant faraday rotation can be achieved in arrays of graphene microribbons at frequencies much higher than the corresponding cyclotron frequency .
the main feature in the magneto - optical response of graphene ribbons is not associated with the cyclotron resonance but rather with the fundamental magnetoplasmon excitation of a single ribbon .
the magnetoplasmon nature of faraday rotation in graphene ribbons opens great possibilities , as the resonance frequency can be locally selected by appropriately choosing the width of the ribbon while still preserving the tuning capability through a ( smaller ) external magnetic field .
= 1 the polarization of a plane wave is rotated when light passes through a transparent media in the presence of a perpendicular static magnetic field @xmath0 .
this phenomenon , known as faraday rotation , has important applications in optical diodes @xcite , sensing and magnetic microscopy @xcite , etc .
recently , it has been found that a single graphene sheet provides a giant faraday angle ( @xmath1 at @xmath2)@xcite , which has given a strong impulse for further investigations on graphene exposed to an external magnetic field . on top of its potential practical applications ,
faraday rotation is a powerful practical tool for studying the intrinsic properties of graphene samples .
faraday rotation in a 2d graphene sheet arises from the excitation of the cyclotron resonance , originated from the circular motion of conducting electrons . even though the cyclotron frequency is much larger for dirac fermions than for massive ones , large faraday rotation in graphene even at thz frequencies still requires magnetic fields of the order of a few teslas .
it would be desirable both to extend the spectral range to higher frequencies and to lower the magnetic field at which substantial rotation occurs .
it has been demonstrated that opening periodically small gaps in a graphene sheet introduces capacitive effects , which modify the effective impedance of graphene , providing an additional ( geometrical ) handle on the faraday effect@xcite .
a related but different possibility , which will be explored in this paper , is to involve the resonant excitation of collective electron modes known as surface plasmons . at zero magnetic field
, this process strongly enhances the coupling between graphene and incident radiation.@xcite . in the presence of a static magnetic field ,
applied perpendicularly to graphene , plasmons and cyclotron excitations hybridize , leading to the formation of graphene magnetoplasmons ( gmp).@xcite these gmp modes are known to significantly modify the magneto - optical response of graphene structures.@xcite .
here we show that patterned graphene can be used to obtain plasmon - assisted giant faraday rotation .
it must be noted that similar schemes have been studied in the optical regime by combination of a plasmonic grating and a magneto - optically active thin film ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
graphene plasmonic gratings , which combine giant faraday rotation in graphene with the strong coupling between radiation and graphene plasmons , may provide an exciting prospect of dynamically tunable ultra - thin devices in both thz and infrared regimes , by employing solely the magneto - optical properties of graphene .
schematic representation of the studied system : a plane monochromatic wave is normally incident on the array of graphene ribbons , in the presence of a static perpendicular magnetic field @xmath0 .
@xmath3 is the faraday rotation angle . ] in this paper , for proof of principle , we consider a periodic array of graphene ribbons ( with the width @xmath4 and period @xmath5 ) , illuminated at normal incidence by a monochromatic plane wave .
a static magnetic field @xmath0 is applied perpendicularly to the ribbons ( see fig . [ fig1 ] for a scheme of the considered geometry ) .
the incident electric field is chosen to lie perpendicularly to the axis of the ribbon ( p - polarization ) . in this way ,
any deviation in the direction of the transmitted electric field is due to the effect in the magnetic field , and not to a `` filtering '' effect arising from the different transmittances for s- and p - polarized waves , which would occur even at zero field .
@xcite graphene is represented by its semi - classical conductivity tensor:@xcite @xmath6[2 ] where @xmath7 is a fermi energy , @xmath8 is a relaxation time , and @xmath9 is the cyclotron frequency .
here @xmath10 is the fermi velocity of the dirac fermions in graphene ( @xmath11 m / s ) . throughout this paper
we consider that the system is at room temperature @xmath12 k , and take a the representative value for the fermi energy @xmath13
ev .
our main conclusions are independent on this choice , but it must be noticed that the semiclassical expression for the conductivity incorporates only intraband transitions@xcite , _ i.e. _ is thus valid for frequencies @xmath14 .
the spectral range we study in this paper is consistent with this restriction .
we will consider two values for the relaxation time : @xmath15 ps ( corresponding to the mobility of about @xmath16 ) which is typical for experimentally studied graphene ribbons , and @xmath17 ps ( corresponding to the mobility of @xmath18 ) which is expected to be achievable for suspended graphene at room temperatures if intrinsic disorder is eliminated.@xcite in order to find the scattering coefficients , we expand the total electromagnetic field in the conventional form of the fourier - floquet plane waves expansion , in both upper and lower semi - spaces . matching appropriately the fields at the ribbon array yields an infinite set of equations for the amplitudes of these waves .
details of the method can be found in the supplementary information .
the numerical calculation the amplitudes from the truncated system converges slowly ( and what is worse , non - uniformly ) with the number of diffraction orders considered .
we have validated that results obtained by this method have converged by comparing them with those obtained by finite element calculations@xcite ( which are more time consuming ) , performed regularly for representative sets of parameters . when only the zero - order diffraction mode is radiative ( i.e , when @xmath19 , which is the situation analyzed in this paper ) , the faraday rotation angle can be computed from the amplitudes on the @xmath20 and @xmath21 transmitted plane waves , @xmath22 and @xmath23 , respectively , as:@xcite @xmath24 for zero magnetic field ,
the dependence of transmission , reflection , and absorption spectra of such structures on both period and width of the ribbons has been extensively studied theoretically and experimentally.@xcite in particular , it was found that the main resonance in the scattering coefficients is associated with the excitation of a hybridized mode , which is a linear combination of the two edge modes of the ribbon.@xcite additionally , there also exists an infinite set of weaker resonances which emerge due to coupling to waveguide - like graphene plasmons .
as we will discuss below , in a perpendicular magnetic field the ribbon plasmon modes transform into magnetoplasmon excitations but the number of modes and their field structure remains the same .
panels ( a ) and ( b ) : absorption spectra of two different ribbon arrays ( continuous lines ) , with geometrical parameters specified in each panel , and a uniform graphene sheet ( dashed curves ) , in a magnetic field @xmath25 .
two different relaxation times have been considered : @xmath26 ps ( orange curves ) and @xmath27 ps ( black curves ) .
green dot - dashed curves show the absorption cross - section for a single ribbon , for @xmath27 ps .
the structure of @xmath28 at the first three resonances indicated with `` 1 '' , `` 2 '' , `` 3 '' is shown in the inset of ( a ) .
panels ( c ) and ( d ) show the absorption of the arrays a and b ( geometrical parameters specified in panels ( a ) and ( b ) , respectively ) as a function of both frequency and magnetic field @xmath0 .
white dashed lines indicate the position of the cyclotron resonance ( cr ) in a uniform graphene sheet .
orange solid lines indicate the position of the `` cross - sections '' shown in panels ( a ) and ( b ) . ] in what follows we study the magnetoresponse of two structures , representative of those used in recent experiments ( performed at @xmath29).@xcite : array `` a '' , defined by ribbon width @xmath30 and period @xmath31 and array `` b '' , with @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
let us first analyze the absorption of radiation by the free - standing ribbon arrays ( @xmath34 ) . in fig .
[ fig2 ] ( a ) and ( b ) and for the case @xmath25 , we show the absorption for a continuous graphene sheet and the arrays considered .
this figure also renders the absorption cross - section of the corresponding single free - standing graphene ribbons showing that , for the geometrical parameters considered , the absorption resonances are essentially due to the gmps of individual ribbons . in the array , the inter - ribbon coupling results only in a slight red - shifting of the main absorption line . in the considered frequency range , where the conductivity is given by a drude term , the ribbon gmp modes are similar to those studied in stripes in two - dimensional electron gases arising in gaas heterostructures .
@xcite those studies showed that the frequencies of the magnetoplasmon modes @xmath35 are given by a simple expression @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the set of plasmon frequencies in the ribbon at zero magnetic field .
each eigenfrequency @xmath38 scales with the ribbon width as @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is a number of the mode , @xmath41.@xcite ( in the considered geometry , only the odd orders are excited ) .
the dependence of the absorption spectra with dc magnetic field for both arrays is rendered in fig .
[ fig2 ] ( c ) and ( d ) , reflecting clearly the evolution of the gmp frequencies .
panels ( a ) and ( b ) in fig .
[ fig3 ] show the spectra for the faraday rotation angle for the two ribbon arrays considered , and for different dc magnetic fields ( solid lines ) . for comparison , in the same panels we present the faraday rotation angle for a continuous graphene sheet ( dashed lines ) .
as mentioned above , in continuous graphene the main resonance feature is associated to the cyclotron resonance .
therefore , giant faraday rotation is restricted to rather low frequencies , less than @xmath42 thz , even at high magnetic fields ( see white dashed lines in lower panels in fig .
[ fig2 ] ) . as seen from fig .
[ fig3 ] , graphene ribbon arrays , despite being a diluted one - atom thick material , still present values of @xmath3 of the order of a few degrees
. moreover , the frequency at which maximum @xmath3 occurs is , in ribbon arrays , are strongly blue shifted with respect to the one in a continuous graphene sheet .
this difference is especially significant for low magnetic fields ( less than a few tesla ) . in the ribbon array ,
the maximum of faraday rotation occurs at the the resonance excitation of gmps , which is determined by both ribbon width and magnetic field . at high magnetic fields , for which the fundamental gmp mode approaches the cyclotron resonance , the ribbon arrays have no obvious advantage over continuous graphene , producing even a slightly weaker faraday effect .
fig .
[ fig3](c ) and ( d ) show the corresponding transmittance spectra .
notice that minimum transmittance occurs approximately at the spectral position when @xmath3 changes the sign .
importantly , the transmittance is at maximum @xmath3 is of the order of @xmath43 , which allows increasing of the faraday rotation by stacking vertically several layers of ribbon arrays , yet maintaining an appreciable transmitted field . when the lattice parameter is much smaller than the free - space wavelength we can use a metamaterial approach and , for the computation of the scattering coefficients , represent the graphene ribbon array as a continuous monolayer with an effective conductivity tensor @xmath44 .
the two independent components of the effective conductivity tensor , namely @xmath45 and @xmath46 , can be uniquely derived from the zero - order transmission coefficients @xmath22 and @xmath23 . in particular , for the free - standing ribbons array we obtain ( see supplementary information for the derivation ) : @xmath47,\\ & \widetilde\sigma_{xy}= \frac{c}{4\pi } \ , \frac{t_{0xy}}{t_{0xx}^2+t_{0xy}^2}. \end{split}\ ] ] the lower panels of fig .
[ fig3 ] show the frequency dependence of both @xmath48 ( for the two considered arrays ) and @xmath49 ( continuous graphene ) .
notice that the relation between the faraday angle and non - diagonal component of the conductivity tensor , valid for low relaxation times , @xmath50 can be still applied in the case of ribbon arrays ( in which case @xmath51 ) , as can be seen by comparing fig .
[ fig3](e ) and ( f ) with fig .
[ fig3](a ) and ( b ) .
effective magnetic field ( a ) and effective chemical potential ( b ) , defined as those at which a continuous graphene sheet would produce maximum giant faraday rotation at the same frequency as the ribbon array at a given magnetic field @xmath0 ( with other parameters unchanged ) . the bottom panels render the ratio between the maximal faraday angle of graphene ribbon arrays and that of the continuous sheet at the corresponding effective parameters ( panel ( c ) for @xmath52 and panel ( d ) for @xmath53 ) . ] in order to better illustrate the magneto - optical response of the ribbon arrays , we define the effective magnetic field , @xmath52 , such that the spectral position of the maximum faraday angle is the same for a _ continuous _ graphene sheet under the presence of @xmath52 and for the ribbon array under the actual @xmath0 ( with all other parameters , like @xmath54 , @xmath55 , etc .
, remaining the same ) .
fig .
[ fig4 ] ( a ) renders the dependence of the computed @xmath52 with @xmath0 , for different arrays of ribbons , showing clearly that sub - micrometer graphene ribbons produce maxima in the faraday rotation at frequencies that would only be achievable in a continuous graphene sheet at much larger magnetic fields . if these large magnetic field are achievable , a continuous sheet would produce a larger faraday angle .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig4 ] ( c ) , which shows the ratio between @xmath56 in a graphene sheet and @xmath57 in the ribbon , @xmath58 , evaluated at the resonant frequency .
this figure shows that the decrease in magnetic field needed to obtain high faraday angles in ribbons , with respect to the situation in a continuous sheet , comes at a decrease in the maximum faraday angle ( @xmath59 ) . as the magnetic field increases ,
so does @xmath60 and , when the magnetic field is high enough ( so that the magnetoplasmons frequency in ribbons tend to the cyclotron frequency ) , @xmath61 is limited by the filling fraction @xmath62 .
another way to obtain faraday rotation at higher frequencies in a continuous graphene sheet is by reducing the chemical potential . in order to compare the response of 2d graphene and the ribbon array , we define an effective chemical potential @xmath63 such that the spectral position of maximum @xmath3 is the same for a _ continuous _ graphene sheet at @xmath63 and for the ribbon array under the actual @xmath55 ( with all other parameters , like @xmath54 , @xmath0 , etc .
, remaining the same ) . figure [ fig4 ] ( b ) renders the @xmath63 for several ribbons arrays , for @xmath64 .
notice however , that the strategy of increasing the frequency of resonant faraday rotation in a continuous sheet by decreasing the chemical potential is limited by the condition @xmath65 . in fig .
[ fig4 ] ( c ) this is reflected in the fact that the different curves have end - points at the lower chemical potentials that fulfill the previous condition .
notice also that , as shown in fig .
[ fig4 ] ( d ) , ribbon arrays can provide , at a given magnetic field and a given frequency , a substantially larger faraday rotation than a continuous graphene sheet .
this occurs at magnetic fields such that @xmath66 , i.e. , when the resonance is magnetoplasmonic , rather than cyclotronic , in character .
the results for ribbon arrays ( solid curves ) and continuous graphene ( dashed curves ) for the ultrahigh relaxation time @xmath26 ps .
( a ) faraday rotation at various magnetic fields . ( b ) zeroth - order transmission . ] up to now we have considered a value for the carrier mobility in graphene that is routinely produced nowadays . however , in view of the recent advances in producing high - quality graphene samples , it is interesting to consider which faraday rotation would be achievable at ultrahigh mobilities . for that , it is valuable to know whether there are physical limits to what can be achievable .
a well - known example of these limits is that the maximum possible absorption by a free standing infinitely thin sheet is @xmath67@xcite . concerning the change in polarization
, we find that in a free - standing infinitely thin sheet , characterized by a local conductivity , the modulus each of the zero - order cross - polarization amplitudes have a maximum value of 1/2 ( see supplementary information ) .
this is , @xmath68 by structuring graphene , we can not increase this limiting value .
however , we can largely improve the resonance q - factor ( the gmp resonance is less absorptive , see fig .
[ fig2](a),(b ) ) .
this has implications for the faraday rotation . in a continuous translational - invariant sheet
it can be shown ( ( see supplementary information ) that the maximal faraday angle is @xmath69 which , of course , is already an impressive result , even more so for a one - atom - thick layer . remarkably ,
faraday rotation on graphene ribbon arrays can exceed this value .
as was previously shown,@xcite the transmission coefficient @xmath22 be very low .
if we set @xmath70 in eq . , we immediately obtain @xmath71 .
these properties are illustrated in fig .
[ fig5 ] , which shows the computed transmittance and faraday angle , for both arrays a and b , for the case @xmath26 ps .
this figure shows that the faraday angle strongly depends on scattering time and that in ribbons it may even exceed that of a continuous graphene sheet ( and , as stated above , at larger frequencies ) . the results for ribbon arrays ( solid curves ) and continuous graphene ( dashed curves ) placed on top of the substrate with @xmath72 .
( a ) faraday rotation at various magnetic fields . ( b ) zeroth - order transmission .
the relaxation time is @xmath27 ps . ] in all the previous calculations , we have considered free - standing graphene ( @xmath34 ) because the fundamental physics we were discussing ( the influence of excitation of gsp on the faraday rotation ) was already present in this simple configuration .
nevertheless , in practice , graphene is usually produced on a substrate .
one consequence of this is that carrier mobility is reduced , due to scattering with phonons and charged impurities .
additionally , although the presence of a substrate does not significantly affect the polarization rotation in a continuous graphene sheet , this may not be the case for graphene ribbons , as plasmon excitations are very sensitive to the surrounding medium .
the influence of a substrate on the gsp - enhanced faraday rotation of graphene ribbons is exemplary illustrated in fig .
[ fig6 ] , for one of the ribbon arrays considered in this work placed on a semi infinite substrate characterized by a non - dispersive dielectric permittivity @xmath73 . as the figure shows , the blue shifts of the maximum in the faraday angle occurring when graphene is patterned are still present , although they are reduced by the presence of the dielectric substrate ( as can be seen by the comparison with fig [ fig3](b ) ) . in conclusion
, we have shown that , for a given magnetic field and chemical potential , structuring graphene periodically can produce strong faraday rotation at larger frequencies than what would occur in a continuous graphene sheet . alternatively , at a given frequency , graphene ribbons produce giant faraday rotation at much smaller magnetic fields than in continuous graphene .
we have demonstrated that this enhancement of faraday rotation in arrays of graphene ribbons is produced by the resonant coupling of radiation to graphene magnetoplasmons .
the possibility to control the graphene magnetoplasmon frequency through both geometry and magnetic field , combined with the possibility to modify the carrier density by an external gate voltage , holds an exciting promise for designing dynamically tunable devices employing solely the magneto - optical properties of graphene . 20 supplementary information |
turbulence , be it classical or quantum , remains as a fundamental problem in the dynamics of fluids .
its high complexity makes it a very difficult , yet a fascinating state of matter in which one of the challenges is to describe it in simple terms .
while there does not exist a clear definition or specification of what turbulence should be , there are several aspects or signatures that indicate whether or not one is facing a turbulent flow .
most notorious is the cascade of energy @xcite through vortices or eddies , in the classical case , or by a tangle of vortices @xcite in the quantum version . among the relevant questions one must deal with , specially in the quantum regime , is the initiation or generation of such a complex state@xcite and its characterization .
@xcite these issues motivate the study presented in this article .
we point out that there are already experimental realizations of quantum turbulence@xcite as well of studies of the route to turbulence.@xcite in this work , through the gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) model@xcite of an ultracold quantum gas , and assuming that arbitrary phase - imprinted states can be generated@xcite we present here a survey of macroscopic excitations that lead a bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) , confined in an external harmonic potential , to stationary agitated or chaotic states that , under appropriate conditions , may be considered to pass through turbulent transients or remain as such .
although the details of the model and of the different excitations that we explore are presented below , we want to advance here a general result that we find may be of relevance in a more complete study .
this is the fact that the gp model is capable of showing a clear transfer of energy , initiated with the large scale imprinted excitation by external means , and ending up in an effective stationary " state , sometimes with a stable array of vortices with large scale collective excitations@xcite , and other times without traces of the initial excitation , but with the presence of bogoliubov phonons.@xcite the former shows spectra close to kolmogorov law @xmath1 , while the latter a spectral law with a positive exponent .
we analyze the numerical solution of gp equation in terms of the spectra of the kinetic energy and in terms of power spectra of the time evolution of the steady state . while we do not claim that such an analysis permits discerning the presence of turbulence , we find that those spectra do serve as signatures of the reached stationary states as well of the evolution towards it .
the mentioned decay into a stationary or steady state is not a true irreversible@xcite behavior of gp but actually a complicated non - linear dephasing effect , since gp obeys time - reversal invariance .
the evolution appears as irreversible " but this is due to numerical rounding errors .
we present a detailed study of such an effect in order to understand these stationary states .
we believe it is relevant to take these aspects into account since dephasing contributions will compete with true irreversible development induced by actual dissipative effects - not considered in the present study . in this work ,
we limit ourselves to the numerical solutions of the time - reversal invariant gp equation , valid for temperatures as close as possible to absolute zero , but we recognize that in order to make a direct comparison with actual experiments , being these at finite temperature , one must take into account dissipative effects .
there are already efforts along these lines @xcite including the effects of the thermal cloud that surrounds a confined bec .
true stationary states , of course , are found in those cases
our model is summarized in the gross - pitaevskii equation@xcite for a three dimensional , one - component bec confined by an external potential , @xmath2 the mean - field interaction coupling term @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the number of bosonic atoms of mass @xmath5 , and @xmath6 is the @xmath7-wave scattering length , assumed positive throughout .
the gp wave function @xmath8 is normalized to one .
although our numerical analysis will be limited to an isotropic harmonic potential @xmath9 , there are several comments and aspects that should be generic for any potential .
in particular , due to the problem at hand , we are interested in also posing relevant questions in terms of a hydrodynamic formulation@xcite .
this is done as follows .
using the transformation @xmath10 and the identification @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the particle density and @xmath13 may be interpreted as the fluid velocity field , one finds the following hydrodynamic equations , @xmath14 and @xmath15 where the stress tensor is , @xmath16 and with the additional condition that the fluid is irrotational @xmath17 .
it is of interest to note that the stress tensor has a hydrostatic pressure @xmath18 , due to the interatomic interactions , and other volumetric and shear stresses of pure quantum origin , namely , all those proportional to @xmath19 .
the above hydrodynamic equations have been also previously derived by grant.@xcite as it is known , and we discuss and review it here , there is a ground stationary state , @xmath20 , with @xmath21 the chemical potential and @xmath22 the ground state macroscopic wave function , solution to , @xmath23 for @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath5 given , the chemical potential @xmath21 and @xmath26 are uniquely given .
the wave function @xmath22 can be accurately found numerically.@xcite this is our starting point for all the forthcoming calculations . from the hydrodynamic point of view , this fluid has an inhomogenous density @xmath27 and zero velocity field everywhere , @xmath28 .
any macroscopic excitation on top of the state @xmath26 will necessarily evolve in time ( except perhaps a line vortex at an axis , but this is unstable@xcite ) . while there may be many more excitations , we consider for the moment three of them , vortices , collective modes , such as breathing or scissors modes,@xcite and sound waves , or bogoliubov phonons,@xcite and their interactions .
the line vortex , for @xmath29 , is the actual solution given by gross@xcite and pitaevskii@xcite , with zero density at the vortex and the velocity field yielding a non - zero circulation , @xmath30 with @xmath31 the topological charge . on the other extreme , we have that any small perturbation is composed of bogoliubov sound waves , as we now briefly review .
let us assume a stationary solution to the equations , which is a uniform one @xmath32 if @xmath29 , and the non - uniform solution @xmath27 for the harmonic trap , discussed above . in both cases , the velocity field is zero everywhere , @xmath28 .
let us now consider a perturbation in the free - field case , @xmath29 , @xmath33 then , a simple linearization of the hydrodynamic equations , eqs .
( [ nfield ] ) and ( [ vfield ] ) , yields , @xmath34 this is a fourth - order wave equation whose solution is @xmath35 , with @xmath36 an arbitrary complex amplitude , yielding , @xmath37 which , as expected , is bogoliubov dispersion relation for the elementary excitations in a weakly - interacting bose gas @xcite .
the velocity field is , in turn , found as @xmath38 , which shows that the waves ( phonons ) are longitudinal , also as expected .
the third important excitation are those that are referred as collective , namely , excitations that involve the whole cloud , and that occur from such a length scale down to perhaps the vortex size , such as breathing or scissors modes .
these can be studied in the thomas - fermi limit , namely , neglecting the kinetic energy in gp equation .
a clear exposition of these modes may be found in the works of stringari and coworkers.@xcite suffice to say here that these are not uncoupled to the other excitations , vortices and phonons , as we will exemplify below .
in this section we study the time evolution of several initial states , described in detail below . we analyze their decay to their respective
stationary " states as well as the time evolution of frequency and wavenumber spectra of the different energy components of the motion .
the different initial states are prepared , first , by allowing the system achieve its ground state @xmath22 ( for an isotropic harmonic potential of frequency @xmath39 ) and then by imprinting different types of vortex perturbations . in a typical case ,
the initial state is @xmath40 where the imposed phase functions @xmath41 are equivalent to the generation of a velocity field representing a given vortex excitation .
@xmath42 is the vortex topological charge .
we study the crossing of two orthogonal vortices ( 3.1 ) ; the collision of two anti - vortices ( 3.2 ) ; an off - center vortex ring ( 3.3 ) ; a vortex of charge @xmath0 ( 3.4 ) ; and a tangle of 4 vortices ( 3.5 ) . in the parenthesis we have indicated the section below in which we analyze them .
our calculations are performed using parallel computing with graphic processors units ( gpu ) , which allows us to develop large and fast calculations ; details of the numerical methods and programming will be reported elsewhere .
we use a spatial grid of size @xmath43 , in double - precision and with time steps of @xmath44 , in dimensionless units @xmath45 , and with a coupling @xmath46 .
this corresponds fairly well to a gas of @xmath47 atoms of @xmath48rb in an isotropic trap of frequency @xmath49 hz with a scattering length @xmath50 , and with a dimensionless equilibrium chemical potential of @xmath51 19.63 .
the unit of time corresponds to 0.00159 seconds .
while we monitor wave function normalization , energy and angular momentum conservation in order to partially ensure numerical convergence of our calculations , we have also used a further dynamical criterion since we are interested in time evolution behavior rather than in static properties .
this criterion arises from the observation that the prepared initial states all do seem to relax " to stationary " states .
this is an important aspect to analyze since the lack of dissipation in gp equation should prevent the system from truly relaxing to a thermal equilibrium state . in the present case ,
given that gp is time - reversal invariant , one faces a _ dephasing _ mechanism rather than a dissipative relaxing one .
this is the more important for non - linear equations solved by numerical means which , because of their concomitant round - off errors , very commonly give rise to a loss of the intrinsic reversibility of the dynamical equation , thus yielding an apparent irreversible behavior . to be more precise , gp as well as schrdinger equation , are time - reversal invariant under the transformation @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
hence , if at any time @xmath54 we change @xmath8 to @xmath55 , the system returns to its initial state at a time @xmath56 . on the one hand
, one expects that if time @xmath54 is very large , due to rounding errors , eventually the state will not return to its original one .
that is , for long times we can no longer assert that the observed evolution does correspond to the original initial state . on the other hand , however , due to the non - linearity of the equation , and aided by numerical errors , the state of the system can reach what one may call basins of attractions",@xcite such that , once the state enters one of those , it does not leave them anymore .
we call these states _ stationary_. we further find that , once the system reaches one of these states , time - reversal invariance is numerically restored .
this is just an indication that those states are very stable , even against round off errors .
this study is performed as follows .
let @xmath57 be any of the initial states at time @xmath58 , and let @xmath59 its gp solution at time @xmath54 . at time
@xmath60 we make the transformation @xmath61 , and evolve @xmath62 for another interval of time @xmath63 .
time reversal invariance demands that @xmath64 .
thus , for different times @xmath63 we calculate the so - called fidelity @xmath65 if there were no loss of time reversal invariance , @xmath66 for all times @xmath63 . in fig .
[ fidelity0all ] we show such a calculation for all the cases we study for up to time @xmath67 .
we see that case ( 3.1 ) is the most stable , followed by ( 3.3 ) , while ( 3.2 ) , ( 3.4 ) and ( 3.5 ) loose their time - reversal invariance for times longer than @xmath68 .
interestingly , all relax to a clear stable stationary state , as we now show .
however , while in the first two cases one can affirm that the stationary state corresponds to the initial state , for the latter three we can only say that the initial state is _ close _ to the basin of attraction of the reached stationary state . in order to verify the stability of the stationary state , we first let the system achieve it .
those states are typically reached by time @xmath69 .
therefore , we now calculate the fidelity at times @xmath70 with @xmath71 as the initial or reference state , that is , @xmath72 the result is shown in fig .
[ fidelity200all_v1 ] . with the exception of ( 3.4 ) that looses a bit of fidelity ,
the rest appear very stable . as part of the statistical analysis of both the time evolution and the stationary state properties , we present the spectra of the incompressible part of
the kinetic energy.@xcite the spectra is calculated as @xmath73 of particular interest is the search for situations whether the incompressible spectra shows a kolmogorov law @xmath1 or not .
in addition to the time evolution of the spectra , and in order to obtain a better understanding of the stationary state , we calculate the time evolution and the frequency spectrum of the modulus of the overlap between the state at the time @xmath71 and later times @xmath74 .
this is @xmath75 we denote its fourier transform as @xmath76 $ ] .
as we shall see , this function samples the contribution of different excitations in the stationary state .
this information can be correlated with the spectra @xmath77 to elucidate whether the excitations are vortices , collective modes and/or phonons . in this case , the initial state is given by two line vortices at orthogonal directions , see fig .
[ cruzados ] , one with @xmath78 parallel to the @xmath79-axis at @xmath80 and @xmath81 , the other with @xmath82 parallel to the @xmath83 axis at @xmath84 and @xmath85 , @xmath86 as one may expect , see the set of snapshots for the magnitude of the velocity field in fig .
[ cruzados ] , the vortices join and reconnect few times .
we have observed three of these reconnections within a time interval of 50 units of time .
then , the vortices stop crossing and become almost but not quite parallel and keep orbiting around each other , in a stationary state .
this late state shows , on top of the orbiting vortices , an agitated fluid that appears to be a superposition of collective modes at different lenght scales , with the presence of few phonons .
very interestingly , its incompressible energy espectra shows a scaling law quite close to kolmogorov law .
this is the most stable case since it reaches its stationary state preserving its time - reversal invariance , showing a stable fidelity times much longer than 200 units of time .
[ ene - cruzados ] shows the time evolution of the incompressible kinetic energy spectrum .
the compressible part is not shown being one order of magnitude smaller .
the spectrum does not show complicated features in its evolution , varying very little in time and showing that although the initial state is somewhat unstable , it does not differ much from the stationary one .
one sees that the spectra is quite parallel to the @xmath1 line in the segment of the spectrum between the thomas - fermi and the vortex size wavenumbers , @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
the average slope is @xmath89 , very close to @xmath90 .
as discussed further below , this appears as a signature of an algebraic cascade of energy between the vortices and collective excitations , with very little presence of phonons .
the above conclusion may be further understood from the overlap evolution @xmath91 and its fourier transform , see eq .
( [ overtime ] ) , as shown in fig .
[ overlapcross ] .
the largest peak corresponds to rotation frequency of the two vortices ( @xmath92 ) , while the other frequencies are collective modes .
the peaks in @xmath93 correspond also to motion of the whole cloud in the harmonic potential ; we have verified this by studying the center of mass motion of the cloud ( not shown here ) . as we shall verify below
, there seems not be an important contribution of phonons in this case .
[ collision ] shows the evolution of the collision of two parallel vortices , along the @xmath94-axis , one with topological charge @xmath95 , at @xmath85 , and the other with @xmath82 at @xmath80 , namely , @xmath96 the behavior of this case is quite the opposite of the two orthogonal vortices .
referring to fig .
[ collision ] , first , the vortices approach each other and reconnect ( @xmath97 ) forming two vortices at directions orthogonal to the original ones ( @xmath98 ) , but because they have opposite circulations , eventually join at their extrema forming a twisted vortex ring ( @xmath99 ) that further folds into itself .
then , it appears to break into smaller rings that eventually become what appears to be a very agitated state with excitations and phonons at all length scales and in all directions .
while this case seems similar to the crow instability in uniform systems,@xcite the presence of the trap may affect its evolution .
this case has the shortest dephasing time , see fig .
[ fidelity0all ] , yet , once it enters the stationary state remains there , see fig .
[ fidelity200all_v1 ] .
[ ene - collision ] shows the time evolution of the energy spectrum of the collision of two anti - vortices .
the figure shows that the system quickly evolves towards a stationary state , which for late times @xmath100 , is composed by a collective oscillation of the cloud , with the first peak about @xmath87 followed by phonons excitations .
the latter can be verified by the line indicated by @xmath101 which is the dispersion relation of bogolubov phonons , see eq .
( [ bogo ] ) ; that is , the kinetic energy spectra is essentially composed of phonons in this case .
compressible _ contribution of the kinetic energy ( not shown here ) is quite similar to the incompressible one of fig .
[ ene - collision ] , corroborating that the excitations are compressible , namely , acoustic excitations .
the overlap function @xmath102 in the stationary state , fig .
[ overlapcoll ] , shows no presence of collective excitations , except for two peaks at @xmath93 and @xmath103 , which are motions of the center of mass , as directly verified from the numerical solution .
this case corresponds to the evolution of a single vortex ring , shown in fig .
[ ring ] , initially placed at @xmath104 and @xmath105 , with @xmath106 we find that , due to its circulation , the ring starts to move to one of the poles of the condensate , see fig .
[ ring ] , expanding at the surface of the cloud ( @xmath107 ) , returning to the inside but then breaking into internal excitations and what appears to be a vortex at the edge of the condensate ( @xmath108 and @xmath109 ) . referring to fig .
[ fidelity0all ] , we find that this excitation does not loose completely its time - reversal invariance , but again , once it enters the stationary state remains there , see fig .
[ fidelity200all_v1 ] .
as we see below , the stationary state is composed of oscillations of the whole cloud , some collective excitations and certainly with the presence of phonons .
this can be concluded from the incompressible kinetic energy spectra and the overlap function , eq .
( [ overtime ] ) , see figs .
[ ene - ring ] and [ overlapringnc ] .
this stationary state appears to be close to the previous one of two colliding anti vortices , with a strong presence of phonons , yet with collective modes playing a role .
we now analyze the case in which the initial excitation is one that corresponds a single line vortex with topological charge @xmath0 , parallel to @xmath94 , at @xmath110 and @xmath111 , see fig .
[ q2 ] . as it is known,@xcite vortices of charge @xmath112 are unstable and decay into two vortices of the same charge @xmath95 .
this situation is exemplified in the snapshots of times @xmath113 , 25.0 and 40.0 of fig .
it is very interesting to see that right after its creation , the vortex separates into two braid - entangled vortices , then these unwind until two stable parallel vortices are formed .
the evolution dephases after 50 units of time , see fig .
[ fidelity0all ] , yet , as with the other cases , it enters a stationary state .
this stationary state , however , is the least stable , as can be seen from fig .
[ fidelity200all_v1 ] , where the fidelity appears to be lossing about 5 % of its value , and thus , for longer times the system may migrate to a different stationary state .
this remains to be verified . in any case , judging from figs .
[ q2 ] and [ overlapq2 ] , the stationary state shows mainly vortex excitations with collective excitations of the cloud , similar to the case of crossed vortices .
the large peak in the overlap spectrum in fig .
[ overlapq2 ] corresponds the fast orbiting of the two vortices around each other .
here we study a tangle " of 4 vortices , two anti - vortices parallel to the @xmath94-axis at random positions @xmath114 and @xmath115 , with @xmath116 and @xmath117 ; and two cross vortices , one parallel to the @xmath79-axis at @xmath118 with @xmath119 , and the other parallel to the @xmath120-axis at @xmath121 with @xmath122 , see fig .
this would be the simplest tangle of vortices that may lead to turbulence , as originally suggested by tsubota et al.@xcite and also already treated by white et al.@xcite the evolution of this case is very harsh , similarly to the case of the colliding anti - vortices ; here we see that by @xmath123 there have been several reconnections and there remain two vortices only .
then the system enters a very agitated flow , perhaps turbulent for times @xmath124 to @xmath125 .
unfortunately , the dephasing time is about 50 units of time , and therefore the true evolution is lost for longer times . nevertheless , after this agitated state , one of the vortices disappears , and the system enters a stable stationary state .
these stages can also be observed in the evolution of the incompressible kinetic energy spectrum , fig .
[ ene - tangle ] : the slope changes from nearly @xmath90 to @xmath126 to settle about @xmath127 .
this last stage corresponds to the stationary state which , from observing the overlap @xmath102 and its fourier transform in fig .
[ overlaprnd4 ] , appears to be composed of a fast vortex , the largest peak , with collective excitations and motion of the whole cloud , but with very few phonons .
in this article we have analyzed the evolution of several representative vortex states in an otherwise equilibrium bose - einstein condensate , using gross - pitaevskii equation as a model for a gas at very low temperatures .
our goal is to add to the understanding of evolution of complicated states in the search for different way to approach a quantum turbulent state . since the dynamics observed show different evolutions in wide time scales , and these types of studies can only be realized numerically
, one must elucidate the role of rounding errors in determining the fate of the evolution .
we have found that , depending on the initial state , the evolved state indeed looses its time - reversal invariance but it does so at different late times .
moreover , the system reaches a stationary state in which time - reversal invariance is robust . referring to the particular initial states considered in the present article
, we can say that they are widely divided in two types : ( i ) those that at the stationary state have one vortex or an array of vortices with collective excitations of different sizes , and ( ii ) one with an agitated state that appears dominated by bogoliubov phonons . in case ( i ) one can include the initial states with two crossed vortices ( 3.1 ) , the vortex of charge two ( 3.4 ) and the tangle of 4 vortices ( 3.5 ) ; in case ( ii ) , we find the two vortex - antivortex system ( 3.2 ) and the off - center ring vortex ( 3.3 ) .
this wide classification is based both on the spectra of the incompressible kinetic energy and in the overlap function in the stationary state , eq .
( [ overtime ] ) . in the relevant wavenumber range , from @xmath87 to @xmath88 ,
one corresponding to the size of the cloud , the other to the vortices cores , the kinetic energy spectra in case ( i ) appears to be close to the kolmogorov law @xmath1 , while in ( ii ) the spectra is very different even with positive power law , but that matches very well the bogoliubov phonon dispersion relation . while finding a similarity with kolmogorov law @xmath1
does not necessarily implies the presence of turbulence , it nevertheless suggests that there is a transfer or interchange of energy between excitations of different sizes , without a characteristic length scale , namely , with a scaling algebraic law .
we recall that kolmogorov derivation of his law@xcite involves two parts , one in which a scaling law is assumed for the velocity flow , and a second one , the elucidation of the energy transfer rate between excitations of different sizes .
the exponent @xmath90 is a consequence of the scaling , independent of the energy transfer mechanism .
thus , we hypothesize that the observed similarity with kolmogorov law in some cases , essentially the same for the two crossed vortices , indicates the presence of energy transfer among excitations at different length scales : typically a single vortex , that while rotates and orbits around the cloud , interacts with collective cloud excitations .
this gives rise clearly to a complicated , agitated flow . whether this may be considered turbulence " remains to be fully elucidated .
it is , therefore , the more important to better understand why colliding antivortices and ring vortices appear to be destroyed , with the accompanying creation of acoustic phonons , yielding also a chaotic state , but with a completely spectral law .
j. a. seman , e. a. l. henn , r. f. shiozaki , g. roati , f. j. poveda - cuevas , k. m. f. magalhaes , v. i. yukalov , m. tsubota , m. kobayashi , k. kasamatsu and v. s. bagnato , _ laser phys .
* 8 * , 691 ( 2011 ) . | we present a survey of macroscopic excitations of harmonically confined bose - einstein condensates ( bec ) , described by gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) equation , in search of routes to develop quantum turbulence .
these excitations can all be created by phase imprinting techniques on an otherwise equilibrium bose - einstein condensate .
we analyze two crossed vortices , two parallel anti - vortices , a vortex ring , a vortex with topological charge @xmath0 , and a tangle of 4 vortices . since gp equation is time - reversal invariant , we are careful to distinguish time intervals in which this symmetry is preserved and those in which rounding errors play a role .
we find that the system tends to reach stationary states that may be widely classified as having either an array of vortices with collective excitations at different length scales or an agitated state composed mainly of bogoliubov phonons .
pacs numbers : 67.85.fg , 03.75.lm,05.30.jp |
the problem of separating the two components of the radio continuum emission , free - free ( thermal ) and synchrotron ( nonthermal ) emission , dates back to the beginnings of radio astronomy .
the usually applied technique is based on the assumption of a constant nonthermal spectral index .
although this assumption may be reasonable for global studies , it does not lead to a correct thermal / nonthermal distribution in detailed studies , and it is not possible to investigate the origin and energy - loss processes of the electron component of cosmic rays ( crs ) .
the dust color temperature obtained between mips 70@xmath0 m and 160@xmath0 m ( tabatabaei et al .
2007a ) shows variations between 19k and 28k with a most probable value at 21.5k .
using the 160@xmath0 m column density and the dust temperature maps , we mapped the dust optical depth at 160@xmath0 m and then at h@xmath1 wavelength ( @xmath2 ) . in the extended central region and in the two main arms in and is , @xmath3 0.5 and between 0.2 and 0.4 in other arms .
we found a radial gradient for the mean extinction in rings given by : @xmath4 . assuming a homogeneous distribution of the emitting and attenuating medium in the line of sight ( for @xmath50.4kpc spatial resolution ) , we de - reddened the observed h@xmath1 emission ( tabatabaei et al .
we found that less than 25% of the total h@xmath1 emission is obscured by dust in m33 . the intrinsic h@xmath1 emission measure converted to the thermal radio emission ( assuming recombination case - b , e.g. dickinson et al .
2003 ) . subtracting the thermal emission from the observed 3.6 cm and 20 cm emission ( tabatabaei et al . ,
2007b ) , the nonthermal maps were derived .
we obtained a total thermal fraction of @xmath617% at 20 cm and @xmath650% at 3.6 cm for galactocentric radii [email protected] .
the nonthermal emission is more smoothly distributed than the thermal emission .
furthermore , the structure of the nonthermal emission is smoother at 20 cm than at 3.6 cm , indicating a stronger diffuse component of the synchrotron emission ( in the form of a diffuse disk or halo ) at 20 cm ( see also tabatabaei et al .
using the nonthermal maps at 20 and 3.6 cm , the nonthermal spectral index map was obtained . in the star forming regions ,
the nonthermal spectrum is relatively flat with an average value of [email protected] , the typical spectral index of supernova remnants , but it increases to [email protected] in the interarm regions and outer parts of the galaxy .
this indicates energy losses of the relativistic electrons while they diffuse away from their origin in starforming regions towards the interarm regions and the outer parts of the galaxy .
for the first time , a nonthermal spectral index map can be used to achieve more realistic models for the propagation of cr electrons . figure .
1 shows that the total radio emission is mostly nonthermal at [email protected] kpc in m33 , where the spectral index is dominated by synchrotron and inverse compton loss .
dickinson , c. , davis , r. d. , & davis , r. j. 2003 , mnras , 341 , 369 tabatabaei , f. s. , beck , r. , krause , m. , et al .
2007a , a&a , 466 , 509 tabatabaei , f. s. , krause , m. , & beck , r. 2007b , a&a , 472 , 785 tabatabaei , f. s. , beck , r. , krgle , e. , et al .
2007c , a&a , 475 , 133 | we determine the variation in the nonthermal radio spectral index in the nearby spiral galaxy m33 .
we separate the thermal and nonthermal components of the radio continuum emission without the assumption of a constant nonthermal spectral index . using the spitzer fir data at 70 and 160@xmath0 m and a standard dust model , we de
- redden the h@xmath1 emission .
the extinction - corrected h@xmath1 emission serves as a template for the thermal free - free radio emission . subtracting from the observed 3.6 and 20 cm emission ( effelsberg and the vla ) this free - free emission , we obtain maps of the nonthermal intensity and spectral index . |
since the launch of the infrared astronomical satellite ( iras ; * ? ? ?
* ) , astronomers have frequently used far - infrared emission to trace star formation in extragalactic sources .
far - infrared emission has been very popular to use for estimating star formation rates because it is not as strongly affected by dust extinction as ultraviolet and optical tracers of star formation and because many surveys , particularly surveys of high - redshift sources , have detected a multitude of galaxies in the far - infrared .
several equations have been derived to calculate star formation rates either from far - infrared measurements by themselves or from far - infrared data combined with optical or ultraviolet data @xcite . while it is commonly assumed in the use of these equations that dust is primarily if not solely heated by star forming regions , the heating source for the dust producing far - infrared emission has been widely debated for decades . following the completion of the iras surveys
, several papers showed that iras 60 and 100 @xmath0 m emission was strongly correlated with star formation activity ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , while others argued that a significant fraction of dust emission originated from dust heated by evolved stars ( e.g * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
additionally , analyses performed by @xcite and @xcite on iras data combined with 160 or 170 @xmath0 m data from the kuiper airborne observatory indicated that emission at @xmath1100 @xmath0 m also originated from dust heated by star formation .
later observations of nearby spiral galaxies with the _ spitzer _ space telescope @xcite demonstrated that optical and ultraviolet star formation tracers were very strongly correlated with 24 @xmath0 m dust emission @xcite or with total infrared emission @xcite .
however , similar analyses showed that the correlation between optical / ultraviolet star formation tracers and either 70 or 160 @xmath0 m emission was weaker @xcite , which implied that not all of the far - infrared emission originated from dust heated by star formation .
additionally , @xcite demonstrated that large scale 160 @xmath0 m emission from m33 qualitatively appeared more similar to large scale k - band emission than to large scale h@xmath3 , 24 @xmath0 m , or 70 @xmath0 m emission , implying that the dust emitting at 160 @xmath0 m was at least partly heated by the evolved stellar population .
furthermore , some dust models applied to iras , infrared space observatory @xcite , _ spitzer _ , and ground - based submillimetre data for nearby galaxies have suggested that heating by evolved stars was needed to reproduce the observed spectral energy distributions for these galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . the first results from the _ herschel _ space observatory @xcite brought attention back to this issue mainly because the telescope provided data at longer wavelengths than what had been provided by either iras or _
spitzer _ and at a higher signal - to - noise than what was possible with ground - based instrumentation .
@xcite demonstrated that colours between 160 and 500 @xmath0 m in m81 , an sab galaxy @xcite , were more strongly dependent on galactocentric radius than on far - infrared surface brightness , which implies that the dust was heated primarily by the evolved stars in the galaxy ( which have a surface brightness that varies primarily with radius ) rather than by star forming regions ( which are primarily found in the infrared - bright regions ) .
in contrast , @xcite and @xcite found that 100 - 250 @xmath0 m emission from compact sources in m33 , an scd galaxy @xcite , were strongly correlated with star formation as measured using h@xmath3 emission , 24 @xmath0 m emission , or a combination of the two .
the goal of this paper is to follow - up these early _ herschel _ results using three nearby face - on spiral galaxies with differing hubble types taken from the very nearby galaxies survey , a _
herschel _ guaranteed - time photometric and spectroscopic survey of 13 galaxies with the photodetector array camera and spectrometer ( pacs ; * ? ? ? * ) and spectral and photometric imaging receiver ( spire ; * ? ? ? * ) .
we will primarily compare surface brightness ratios between two _ herschel _ bands to both stellar surface brightness and to star formation rate .
surface brightnesses measured in single bands may be correlated to star formation through dust heating , in which the dust is heated by the star forming regions and becomes more luminous , or through the schmidt law @xcite , in which star formation is correlated to the amount of dust present . in contrast ,
surface brightness ratios are advantageous to use in that they are largely independent of the total dust surface density . instead
, surface brightness ratios will primarily depend only on the average temperature of the dust emitting at those wavelengths , with temperature variations caused either by variations in the amount of a warmer dust component relative to a colder dust component or variations in the overall temperature of a single dust component .
this is similar to the approach used by @xcite , but the advantage of the analysis in this paper is that we will not rely upon galactocentric radius as a proxy for the surface brightness of the evolved stellar population and that we will use a better tracer of star formation .
section [ s_sample ] describes the three galaxies in our sample ( m81 , m83 , and ngc 2403 ) and why they are well - suited for this analysis .
section [ s_data ] provides an overview of the data from _ herschel _ and from other sources as well as details on the preparation of the data for the analysis .
the analysis itself is presented in section [ s_analysis ] , the implications of the results is discussed in section [ s_discussion ] , and a summary is provided in section [ s_conclusions ] .
as stated above , the three galaxies used for this analysis were all galaxies selected from the very nearby galaxies survey ( pi : c. wilson ) , a guaranteed - time survey of 13 well - studied nearby galaxies with a diverse range of properties .
the galaxies for the analysis in this paper were selected because they are all spiral galaxies with inclinations of @xmath4 from face - on , they have optical discs larger than 10 arcmin , and they are at distances of less than 5 mpc , so sub - kpc structures can be easily studied within the galaxies .
the galaxies are also roughly representative of early- , mid- , and late type spiral galaxies .
details on the three galaxies used in this analysis are given in table [ t_sample ] .
the images used in the analysis are shown in figures [ f_map_ngc3031]-[f_map_ngc2403 ] . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] @xmath5 these parameters correspond to the ones in equation [ e_efinal ] .
+ @xmath6 the units of @xmath7 are ( erg @xmath8 s@xmath9 arcsec@xmath10 ) ( mjy sr@xmath9)@xmath9
. + @xmath11 this is relative fraction of dust heating from star forming regions as given by equation [ e_efrac ] .
the value is calculated with the data for all 36 arcsec square regions used when fitting equation [ e_efinal ] to the data .
+ @xmath12 these are correlation coefficients for the relations between the right and left sides of equation [ e_efinal ] .
+ @xmath13 these fits were performed excluding the central @xmath14 36 arcsec square regions .
see the text for details .
+ @xmath15 instead of reporting the result from the fit to equation [ e_efit ] here , we instead report the result of the fit of a power law relation between the 70/160 @xmath0 m surface brightness ratio and the h@xmath3 intensity .
see the text for details .
+ we encountered two problems with fitting equation [ e_efit ] to the data . in fitting the 70/160 @xmath0 m surface brightness data for m83 , we found that the difference between the ratio and the resulting fit was significantly high around the nucleus , and the reconstructed colour temperature map in figure [ f_mapfrac_ngc5236 ] did not look like the observed colour temperature map .
additionally , the fractional contribution of star formation to dust heating seemed abnormally low ; when the nucleus is included , the fractional contribution of star formation to dust heating is @xmath16 .
this implies that the nucleus does not follow the same 70/160 @xmath0 m dust heating relation as the rest of the disc , for reasons that are unclear but that could be related to hot ( @xmath17 k ) dust heated by the nuclear starburst that is visible in the 70 @xmath0 m band .
therefore , we excluded the central @xmath14 regions ( @xmath18 arcsec ) of m83 for the analysis on the 70/160 @xmath0 m ratio .
( excluding the same central region when fitting equation [ e_efit ] to the 160/250 , 250/350 , or 350/500 @xmath0 m data did not affect the fits signficantly . ) in fitting equation [ e_efit ] to the 70/160 @xmath0 m data for ngc 2403 , we found that the @xmath19 term was negligible compared to the @xmath20 term , which caused convergance problems when trying to perform a nonlinear least squares fit .
we therefore report results in which the 70/160 @xmath0 m ratio is a function of only the h@xmath3 intensities ( which is consistent with the interpretation that variations in dust heating traced by this ratio depend primarily on star formation ) . after dealing with these two exceptions ,
the resulting fits are generally very good .
the correlation coefficients in table [ t_colorvsmult ] for the relations between the logarithm of the surface brightness ratios and the expression on the right side of equation [ e_efinal ] are generally higher than the corresponding correlation coefficients in either tables [ t_colorvsstar ] or [ t_colorvsha ] for fits to either the 1.6 @xmath0 m or h@xmath3 emission , although in many cases , the improvement in the correlation coefficients is marginal .
moreover , most correlation coefficients in table [ t_colorvsmult ] are above 0.7 , indicating that at least 50% of the variance in the data can be accounted for by the relations .
the only exceptions are the 70/160 @xmath0 m ratio for ngc 2403 , which we identified as problematic up above , and the 350/500 @xmath0 m ratio for m83 , which is very noisy in general .
the reconstructed colour temperature maps based on equation [ e_efinal ] in figures [ f_mapfrac_ngc3031]-[f_mapfrac_ngc2403 ] look qualitatively similar to the colour temperature maps based on the observed surface brightness ratios .
the reconstructed maps generally match the overall radial gradients in temperature seen in many of the observed maps , and the reconstructed maps also show that we could reproduce the colour temperatures of many of the individual star forming regions within the spiral structures of each galaxy .
however , the temperatures of the reconstructed star forming regions do not always precisely match the colour temperatures in the observed map .
this could be because of variable extinction among individual star forming regions , which could cause the relation between star formation ( as traced by h@xmath3 emission ) and dust heating to vary .
we also occasionally see some residual structures in temperature that show features that are not quite described by the reconstructed map . in m81
, the nucleus ( excluded from the fits ) appears notably cold in the residual maps because of the synchrotron emission from the agn .
the nucleus of m83 , which caused problems in the fits and was excluded , appears as a hot spot in the residual 70/160 @xmath0 m map .
residual spiral structure is seen in the 160/250 @xmath0 m and 250/350 @xmath0 m residual maps , which could be indicative of dust heating gradients across the spiral arms that are inadequately described by equation [ e_efinal ] and show the limitations of using this approach to reproducing dust colour temperature variations .
foyle et al .
( in preparation ) found a similar offset between dust temperatures and star formation in the spiral arms . finally , we see residual structure in the 70/160 @xmath0 m map of ngc 2403 that is clearly a result of latent image effects in the 70 @xmath0 m data .
the main purpose of these fits was to determine the relative contributions of star forming regions and the total stellar populations to dust heating .
the results in table [ t_colorvsmult ] generally show a decrease in the relative contribution of dust heating from star formation as wavelength increases . in m83 and ngc 2403
, star forming regions contribute @xmath21% of the total heating of the dust traced by the @xmath22 @xmath0 m bands , although in m81 , the dust heating up to 70 @xmath0 m appears to still be dominated by the total stellar population . at longer wavelengths ,
the relative contribution of star forming regions decreases signficantly .
star forming regions appear to contribute only @xmath23% of the energy for heating the dust traced by the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m bands in all three galaxies .
the relation for the 350/500 @xmath0 m ratio for ngc 2403 seems anomalous in that it implies that @xmath24% of the energy for the dust heating originates from star forming regions , which is higher than what is implied by the fit to the 250/350 @xmath0 m ratio for that galaxy .
however , we suspect that this is because the 350/500 @xmath0 m data are on the rayleigh - jeans side of the sed and are strongly affected by noise .
hence , colour variations related to dust heating are not detected at a high signal - to - noise level in ngc 2403 , and so the methods we are using may not be effective in this one case .
overall , the results here are consistent with the interpretations we have provided for the results in sections [ s_analysis_stars ] and [ s_analysis_sf ] . at wavelengths shorter than 160 @xmath0 m , most of the dust appears to be heated by star forming regions in these galaxies , which is why the 70/160 @xmath0 m ratios appear more closely dependent on the h@xmath3 surface brightnesses . at
wavelengths longer than 250 @xmath0 m , the dust appears to be primarily heated by the total stellar populations , and so the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m ratios are more strongly related to the 1.6 @xmath0 m surface brightness .
the results here have demonstrated that the total stellar population , including evolved stars and not just stars in star forming regions , plays a significant role in heating dust in nearby galaxies .
the fraction of observed dust emission that is heated by the total stellar population varies as a function of the wavelength . while star forming regions are the dominant heating source for dust observed at @xmath25 @xmath0 m , the total stellar population , including evolved stars , become the dominant heating source for the dust observed at @xmath26 @xmath0 m .
we have been able to demonstrate that dust is heated by the total stellar populations in spite of the fact that the dust emission itself tends to be correlated with h@xmath3 emission , which should bias our results towards finding dust heated by star formation .
moreover , we have shown that significant dust heating by the total stellar population can be seen even in late - type spiral galaxies .
the results here validate the original conclusions drawn from iras data by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite as well as the conclusions drawn from _ spitzer _
data by @xcite and @xcite that evolved stellar populations play an increasingly important role in heating dust towards longer infrared wavelengths .
additionally , the differences between the results for m81 , where we were able to demonstrate that the bulge stars were heating dust even at 70 @xmath0 m , and the results for ngc 2403 , where the dust emitting at 70 @xmath0 m did not appear to be influenced at all by the bulge stars , corroborates results from @xcite , who found that bulges influenced dust heating in nearby galaxies .
furthermore , the results here corroborate the findings from radiative transfer models ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) as well as other dust emission models ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) that had suggested that dust absoprtion and emission can only be accurately modelled if it contains a dust component heated by star formation and a dust component heated by the total stellar population .
both our results and the radiative transfer analyses suggest that the @xmath25 @xmath0 m emission originates from dust that is heated by star forming regions located within clouds ( or clumps ) that are optically thick at ultraviolet and blue wavelengths . in these models ,
only a relatively small fraction of the dust is heated by the star forming regions , but the dust appears significantly brighter than the dust outside the centres of the regions , leading to higher 70/160 @xmath0 m surface brightness ratios in these regions .
most of the dust mass in the ism , however , is shielded from the ultraviolet and blue photons from the star forming regions .
this dust is heated by the diffuse interstellar radiation field , which would include light from evolved stars , and has lower temperatures .
none the less , because a much greater fraction of the dust mass is heated this way , the colder dust is the predominant source of emission at @xmath26 @xmath0 m .
also , if the mean free path of light in the diffuse interstellar medium is similar to or smaller than the resolution elements in our analysis , the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m ratios can be expected to be very well correlated with the stellar surface brightnesses in those resolution elements .
the v - band optical depths and the dust vertical scale heights derived in the analyses of edge - on galaxies by @xcite and @xcite imply that the mean free paths of v - band photons through the discs of spiral galaxies should be roughly between 0.1 and 1 kpc . in comparison ,
the binned data that we used correspond to physical sizes of @xmath27 - 800 pc , and so the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m ratios should be very well correlated with tracers of the total stellar population in these binned data , which is exactly what we see .
while we do produce observational results that are generally consistent with many previously - published dust models , we do find a inconsistency when comparing our results for m81 and ngc 2403 with the dust models for these specific galaxies from @xcite .
@xcite did predict from their sed fitting to m81 that most of the dust emission at @xmath28 @xmath0 m is from a diffuse component , which is largely consistent with the results from our surface brightness ratio variations .
however , their sed fitting to ngc 2403 also predicted that most of the dust emission at @xmath28 @xmath0 m from that galaxy was from diffuse dust , whereas the surface brightness variations we observed imply that the star forming regions should be the predominant heating source at @xmath25 @xmath0 m .
this demonstrates that , while the general ideas being applied in dust models are still valid , further refinement is needed if the models are not only going to replicate the overall seds of galaxies but also replicate colour variations within the galaxies . even though many authors have argued that a significant fraction of the dust in nearby spiral galaxies is heated by evolved stellar populations , other authors have shown that total infrared dust emission can be correlated with star formation in nearby spiral galaxies @xcite , and even some of the early results from _ herschel _ suggest that emission in individual wave bands ( i.e. the 100 , 160 , and 250 @xmath0 m bands ) can be correlated with other star formation tracers in m33 @xcite , a galaxy with the same hubble type as ngc 2403 .
we think the apparent contradictions between the correlations between far - infrared emission and star formation found by other authors and the relation between dust heating and the total stellar populations that we find can be explained in two ways .
first of all , some of the correlations between far - infrared emission and star formation are based on either the far - infrared fluxes traced by the iras 60 - 100 @xmath0 m data or on the total dust emission as computed from the _ spitzer _ 24 - 160 @xmath0 m bands , both of which strongly sample emission from dust on the wien side of the thermal dust emission in a regime where we also found that star formation strongly influenced dust heating .
moreover , iras - based studies simply did not have data at @xmath1100 @xmath0 m wavelengths , which we found were dominated by emission from dust heated by the total stellar population .
second , it is possible that far - infrared emission could be linked to star formation indirectly through the schmidt law @xcite rather than directly through dust heating .
dust emission at far - infrared wavelengths is a function of both dust temperature and dust surface density . since dust
should implicitly be a tracer of the total surface density of gas in the interstellar medium , and since the schmidt law suggests that star formation is a function of the amount of gas available to fuel it , we expect dust emission to be correlated with star formation to some degree even if the dust is not directly heated by the star formation .
the dust colours , however , are strongly affected by dust temperature but are independent of dust surface density and therefore will depend more on dust heating sources than the emission observed in a single wave band .
this is probably why we are able to show that far - infrared surface brightness in the 250 - 500 @xmath0 m bands is correlated with h@xmath3 intensity even though we have demonstrated that the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m surface brightness ratios are more strongly correlated with 1.6 @xmath0 m surface brightness .
additionally , in the case of m81 , the 1.6 @xmath0 m emission is poorly correlated with the 250 , 350 , and 500 @xmath0 m surface brightness , and yet the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m ratios are clearly being heated mostly by the stellar population traced by the 1.6 @xmath0 m band . in this case
the infrared surface brightness can only be correlated with the h@xmath3 emission if the dust surface density is correlated with the star formation surface density .
we believe that this may also be a possible reason why @xcite and @xcite can show that the 100 - 250 @xmath0 m emission is correlated with h@xmath3 and 24 @xmath0 m emission , although a comparison of the infrared colour variations in m33 to tracers of star formation or the total stellar population would be needed to confirm this . aside from the use of surface brightness ratios instead of surface brightnesses or flux densities in our analysis
, we think that the choice of galaxies that we used in this analysis was critical to demonstrating that the total stellar populations ( including evolved stars ) play a significant role in dust heating .
m81 and ngc 2403 are both special in that the stellar emission traces different structures than either the dust emission or the star formation .
this has been critically important for allowing us to disentangle the relative contributions from the two different heating sources .
m83 is a good example of a `` typical '' spiral galaxy in which the starlight , dust emission , and star formation all trace similar structures .
our analysis demonstrates that it is difficult to disentangle whether the total stellar population or star formation is a greater contributor to dust heating in such cases .
other authors working with m83 or similar galaxies will probably encounter similar problems .
we emphasize that we have only found that these results apply to spiral galaxies .
@xcite demonstrated that the 250/500 @xmath0 m surface brightness ratio depends on 24 @xmath0 m surface brightness in the dwarf irregular galaxy ngc 6822 , thus demonstrating that the dust emitting at submillimetre wavelengths was significantly affected by star forming regions .
this is probably a result of the galaxy containing relatively few evolved stars that could heat dust , although it is conceivable that , in the low metallicity environment , the interstellar medium would contain less dust , and so diffuse dust would be less shielded from star forming regions .
we anticipate that similar results would be obtained for other dwarf irregular galaxies with ongoing star formation .
in contrast , we may expect that the @xmath170 @xmath0 m emission seen in elliptical galaxies ( when the elliptical galaxies produce any far - infrared emission at all ) will originate from dust predominantly heated by evolved stars , just as the dust from the central 3 kpc of m81 appears to be heated primarily by evolved stars .
how our results for spiral galaxies apply to luminous infrared galaxies ( with total infrared luminosities between @xmath29 and @xmath30 l@xmath31 ) and ultraluminous galaxies ( with total infrared luminosities above @xmath30 l@xmath31 ) is unclear , as the galaxies contain strong star formation and agn emission but also have large stellar populations and may have large reservoirs of dust that is shielded from the star forming and agn regions .
additional analyses on the dust heating mechanisms in these classes of galaxies is warranted .
for m81 , m83 , and ngc 2403 , we have demonstrated that the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m surface brightness ratios are more strongly correlated with 1.6 @xmath0 m emission , which traces the starlight from the total stellar populations including evolved stars , than with h@xmath3 emission from star - forming regions . at shorter wavelengths , the total stellar population may continue to be influential in dust heating , particularly in early - type spiral galaxy m81 , but heating by star formation becomes more important , particularly in the late - type spiral galaxy ngc 2403 . none the less ,
these results imply that , in each of these galaxies as well as other spiral galaxies in general , the total stellar populations are a significant if not dominant heating source for the dust observed at @xmath1160 @xmath0 m in all spiral galaxies , including late - type spiral galaxies . in some cases , virtually all of the emission may originate from dust heated by the total stellar populations , including evolved stars in the bulges and discs .
the results here have strong implications for modeling dust in spiral galaxies .
first of all , dust models need to include separate thermal components for the dust heated by star forming regions and dust heated by the total stellar populations . when fitting single modified blackbodies to data , it may be inappropriate to force the function to fit 70 @xmath0 m or shorter wavelength data , particularly by varying the index of the power law that describes the dust emissivity ( see , for example , @xcite , but also note the additional analysis in @xcite ) .
models based on more complex dust physics need to include components heated by red stellar radiation fields that only become predominant at longer wavelengths , as is already done in some cases , and these models also need to be tuned so that they replicate not only the global seds of galaxies but also the colour variations within galaxies .
template - based sed models need to include an additional component based on dust heated by a quiescent stellar population , as is done by @xcite , although these cold dust templates should be calibrated using observations of nearby galaxies where the dust emission can be studied on kpc scales rather than inferred from observations of unresolved sources .
also , dust extinction corrections that rely upon infrared flux to estimate extinction corrections , as is commonly done for ultraviolet data ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , need to account for dust heating by evolved stellar populations and not just star forming regions , as is also suggested by @xcite and @xcite .
finally , we are going to suggest caution when using far - infrared emission as a star formation tracer for both nearby and more distant galaxies .
dust emission in individual wave bands at @xmath1160 @xmath0 m is probably related to star formation indirectly through the schmidt law rather than directly through dust heating .
using , for example , 250 @xmath0 m flux density measurements to determine star formation rates is akin to using co measurements to determine star formation rates .
while this may still be an accurate way to measure star formation rates under certain circumstances , it will be necessary to understand the caveats that affect such analyses .
g.j.b . thanks simone bianchi and the reviewer for helpful comments on this paper .
g.j.b . was funded by the stfc .
the reserach of c.d.w . and k.f .
is supported by grants to c.d.w . from the canadian space agency and the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada .
pacs has been developed by a consortium of institutes led by mpe ( germany ) and including uvie ( austria ) ; ku leuven , csl , imec ( belgium ) ; cea , lam ( france ) ; mpia ( germany ) ; inaf - ifsi / oaa / oap / oat , lens , sissa ( italy ) ; iac ( spain ) . this development has been supported by the funding agencies bmvit ( austria ) , esa - prodex ( belgium ) , cea / cnes ( france ) , dlr ( germany ) , asi / inaf ( italy ) , and cicyt / mcyt ( spain ) .
spire has been developed by a consortium of institutes led by cardiff university ( uk ) and including univ .
lethbridge ( canada ) ; naoc ( china ) ; cea , lam ( france ) ; ifsi , univ .
padua ( italy ) ; iac ( spain ) ; stockholm observatory ( sweden ) ; imperial college london , ral , ucl - mssl , ukatc , univ .
sussex ( uk ) ; and caltech , jpl , nhsc , univ .
colorado ( usa ) .
this development has been supported by national funding agencies : csa ( canada ) ; naoc ( china ) ; cea , cnes , cnrs ( france ) ; asi ( italy ) ; mcinn ( spain ) ; snsb ( sweden ) ; stfc ( uk ) ; and nasa ( usa ) .
hipe is a joint development by the herschel science ground segment consortium , consisting of esa , the nasa herschel science center , and the hifi , pacs and spire consortia .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
allen r. j. , knapen j. h. , bohlin r. , stecher t. p. , 1997
, apj , 487 , 171 arendt r. g. et al . , 1998 , apj , 508 , 74 bendo g. j. et al . , 2007 , mnras , 380 , 1313 bendo g. j. et al . , 2008 , mnras , 389 , 629 bendo g. j. et al . ,
2010a , mnras , bendo g. j. et al .
, 2010b , a&a , 518 , l65 bianchi s. , 2007 , a&a , 471 , 765 bianchi s. , 2008 , a&a , 490 , 461 bohlin r. c , cornett r. h. , hill j. k. , smith a. m. , stecher t. p. , 1983 , apj , 274 , l53 boissier s. e al .
, 2005 , apj , 619 , l83 boquien m. et al . , 2010 ,
a&a , 518 , l70 boselli a. , gavazzi g. , 2002 , a&a , 386 , 124 buat v. , xu c. , 1996 , a&a , 306 , 61 calzetti d. et al . , 2005 , apj , 633 , 871 calzetti d. et al . , 2007 , apj , 666 , 870 calzetti d. et al . , 2010 ,
apj , 714 , 1256 comte g. , 1981 , a&as , 44 , 441 condon j. j. , condon m. a. , gisler g. , puschell j. j. , 1982 , apj , 252 , 102 cortese l. , boselli a. , franzetti p. , decarli r. , gavazzi g. , boissier s. , buat v. , 2008 , mnras , 386 , 1157 da cunha e. , charlot s. , elbaz d. , 2008 , mnras , 388 , 1595 dale d. a. et al . , 2007 , apj , 655 , 863 davies j. i. et al . , 2010 , mnras , 409 , 102 de blok w. j. g. , walter f. , brinks e. , trachternach c. , oh . s .-
, kennicutt r. c. , jr , 2008 , aj , 136 , 2648 de vaucouleurs g. , de vaucouleurs a. , corwin h. g. , buta r. j. , paturel g. , fouque p. , 1991
, third reference catalogue of bright galaxies , springer - verlag , berlin devereux n. a. , jacoby g. , ciardullo r. , 1995 , aj , 110 , 1115 devereux n. a. , young j. s. , 1990 , apj , 350 , l25 devereux n. a. , young j. s. , 1992 , aj , 103 , 1536 devereux n. a. , young j. s. , 1993 , aj , 106 , 948 dowell c. d. et al .
, 2009 , in oschmann j. m. jr .
clampin m. c. , macewen h. a. , eds , proceedings of the spie , space telescopes and instrumentation 2010 : optical , infrared , and millimeter wave .
spie , bellingham , p. 773136
draine b. t. et al . , 2007 , apj , 663 , 866 drissen l. , roy j .-
, moffat a. f. j. , shara m. m. , 1999 , aj , 117 , 1249 dunne l. , eales s. a. , 2001 , mnras , 327 , 697 dunne l. , eales s. , edmunds m. , ivison r. , alexander p. , clements d. l. , 2000 , mnras , 315 , 115 elmegreen d. m. , elmegreen b. g. , 1982 , 201 , 1021 elmegreen d. m. , elmegreen b. g. , 1987 , 314 , 3 engelbracht c. w. , gordon k. d. , rieke g. h. , werner m. w , dale d. a. , latter w. b. , 2005 , apj , 628 , l29 engelbracht c. w. et al . , 2010 , a&a , 518 , l56 flagey n. , boulanger f. , verstraete l. , miville deschnes m. a. , noriego cespo a. , reach w. t. , 2006 , a&a , 453 , 969 freedman w. l. et al .
, 2001 , apj , 553 , 47 galametz m. et al .
, 2010,a&a , 518 , l55 garnett d. r. , shields g. a. , 1987 , apj , 317 , 82 gordon k. d. et al . , 2005 , pasp , 117 , 50 gordon k. d. et al .
, 2007 , pasp , 119 , 1019 gordon k. d. , engelbracht c. w. , rieke g. h. , misselt k. a. , smith j .- d . t. , kennicutt r. c. jr . , 2008 , apj , 682 , 336 griffin m. j. et al . , 2009 , in oschmann j. m. jr . de graauw m. w. m. , macewen h. a. , eds , proceedings of the spie , space telescopes and instrumentation 2008 : optical , infrared , and millimeter .
spie , bellingham , p. 70102
griffin m. j. et al . , 2010 , a&a , 518 , l3 herschel space observatory , 2010a , pacs observer s manual , version 2.1 , esa , noordwijk herschel space observatory , 2010b , spire observer s manual , version 2.2 , esa , noordwijk hinz j. l. et al . , 2004 , apjs , 154 , 259 hodge p. w. , kennicutt r. c. jr . , 1983 , aj , 88 , 296 jarrett t. h. , chester t. , cutri r. , schneider s. e. , huchra j. p. , 2003
, aj , 125 , 525 karachentsev i. d. et al . , 2002 ,
a&a , 383 , 125 kennicutt r. c. jr .
, 1998a , ara&a , 36 , 189 kennicutt r. c. jr .
, 1998b , apj , 498 , 541 kennicutt r. c. jr .
et al . , 2003 ,
pasp , 115 , 928 kennicutt r. c. jr .
et al . , 2007 ,
apj , 671 , 333 kennicutt r. c. jr .
et al . , 2009 ,
apj , 703 , 1672 kessler m.f .
1996 , a&a , 315 , l27 kong x. , charlot s. , brinchmann j. , fall s. m. , 2004 , mnras , 349 , 769 li a. , draine b. , 2001 , apj , 554 , 778 lonsdale persson c. j. , helou g. , 1987 , apj , 314 , 513 lutz d. , 2010 , pacs photometer point spread function , version 1.01 , esa , noordwijk markoff s. et al .
, 2008 , apj , 681 , 905 mentuch e. et al . , 2009 , apj , 706 , 1020 mentuch e. , abraham r. g. , zibetti s. , 2010 , apj , 725 , 1971 meurer g. r. , heckman t. m. , calzetti d. , 1999 , apj , 521 , 64 meurer g. r. et al . , 2006 , apjs , 165 , 307 moustakas j. , kennicutt r. c. jr . , tremonti c. a. , dale d. a. , smith j .- d . t. , calzetti d. , 2010 , apjs , 190 , 233 neugebauer g. et al . , 1984 ,
apj , 278 , l1 ott s. , 2010 , in mizumoto y. , ed .
, asp conf .
434 , astronomical data analysis software and systems xix .
pac . , san francisco , p. 139
pilbratt g. et al . , 2010 , a&a , 518 , l1 poglitsch a. et al . , 2010 , a&a , 518 , l2 popescu c. c. , tuffs r. j. , dopita m. a. , fischera j. , kylafis n. d. , madore b. f. , 2011 , a&a , 527 , a109 prescott m. k. m. et al . , 2007 , apj , 668 , 182 rieke g. h. et al . , 2004 , apjs , 154 , 25 rowan - robinson m. et al
. , 2010 , mnras , 409 , 2 sauvage m. , thuan t. x. , 1992 , apj , 396 , l69 schlegel d. j. , finkbeiner d. p. , davis m. , 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 schmidt m. , 1959 , apj , 129 , 243 scoville n. , young j. s. , 1983 , apj , 265 , 148 smith b. j. , hancock m. , 2009 , aj , 138 , 130 stansberry j. a. et al .
, 2007 , pasp , 119 , 1038 talbot r. j. jr . , jensen e. b. , dufour r. j. , 1979 , apj , 229 , 91 telesco c. m. , harper d. a. , 1980 , apj , 235 , 392 thim f. , tammann g. a. , dolphin a. , sandage a. , tolstoy e. , labhardt l. , 2003 , apj , 590 , 256 trinchieri g. , fabbiano g. , palumbo g. g. c. , 1985 , apj , 290 , 96 turner j. l. , ho p. t. p. , beck s. c. , 1987 , ap , 313 , 644 verley s. et al . , 2010 , a&a , 518 , l68 vron p. , sauvayre a. , 1965 , anap , 28 , 698 walterbos r. a. m. , greenawalt b. , 1996 , apj , 460 , 696 walterbos r. a. m. , schwering p. b. w. , 1987 , a&a , 180 , 27 werner m. w. et al .
, 2004 , apjs , 154 , 1 xilouris e. m. , byun y. i. , kylafis n. d. , paleologou e. v. , papamastorakis j. , 1999 , a&a , 344 , 868 young l. m. , bendo g. j. , lucero d. , 2009 , aj , 137 , 3053 zhu y .- n . , wu h. , cao c. , li h .- n . , 2008 , apj , 686 , 155 | we use _ spitzer _ space telescope and _ herschel _ space observatory far - infrared data along with ground - based optical and near - infrared data to understand how dust heating in the nearby face - on spiral galaxies m81 , m83 , and ngc 2403 is affected by the starlight from all stars and by the radiation from star forming regions .
we find that 70/160 @xmath0 m surface brightness ratios tend to be more strongly influenced by star forming regions .
however , the 250/350 @xmath0 m and 350/500 @xmath0 m surface brightness ratios are more strongly affected by the light from the total stellar populations , suggesting that the dust emission at @xmath1250 @xmath0 m originates predominantly from a component that is colder than the dust seen at @xmath2160 @xmath0 m and that is relatively unaffected by star formation activity .
we conclude by discussing the implications of this for modelling the spectral energy distributions of both nearby and more distant galaxies and for using far - infrared dust emission to trace star formation .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : ism , galaxies : spiral , infrared : galaxies , galaxies : individual : m81 , galaxies : individual : m83 , galaxies : individual : ngc 2403 , |
the need for a comprehensive survey of the warm ionized medium in the local universe can hardly be overstated .
this gas phase may contribute significantly to the local baryon budget ( e.g. , fukugita , hogan , & peebles 1998 ) , but very little is known about its distribution . while an important fraction of this material is almost certainly in the form of intergalactic clouds not related to any individual galaxy , some may inhabit the dark matter halos of galaxies ( e.g. , rauch 1998 ) .
this gas phase is a key witness to galaxy formation and evolution . in a hierarchical cdm universe ( e.g. , jenkins et al . 1998 )
most of the activity associated with galaxy formation takes place at @xmath3 @xmath1 1 , except perhaps in the outer reaches of galaxies where `` primordial '' gas may still be accreting today
. some of this material will necessarily be ionized by the metagalactic ionizing radiation , and possibly also by local sources of ionizing radiation such as active galactic nuclei ( agn ) and starbursting stellar populations . in this picture , the warm ionized gas on the outskirts of galaxies represents left - over debris associated with galaxy formation ( e.g. , bland - hawthorn 1999 ; blitz et al .
1999 ) .
the warm ionized gas is also an excellent probe of the feedback processes taking place in galaxies .
ionizing radiation and mechanical energy from star - forming regions and quasars may severely limit the amount of star formation and affect galaxy evolution .
the emerging radiation field defines regions where gas is warm and ionized ( e.g. , `` proximity effect '' in quasars and lyman - break galaxies and `` ionization cones '' in nearby active and starburst galaxies ; e.g. , bajtlik , duncan , & ostriker 1988 ; steidel , pettini , & adelberger 2001 ; wilson & tsvetanov 1994 ) . galactic winds may blow out through the gaseous halos of galaxies and into the igm , enriching and heating the intergalactic environment in the process .
these winds may be responsible for the well - known mass - metallicity relation in galaxies ( e.g. , larson & dinerstein 1975 ; vader 1986 ; franx & illingworth 1990 ) .
the discovery of h@xmath4 filaments and diffuse soft x - ray emission out to 11.6 kpc from the prototypical starburst / superwind galaxy m82 ( devine & bally 1999 ; lehnert , heckman , & weaver 1999 ; stevens , read , & bravo - guerrero 2003 ) emphasizes the need for surveying large areas around superwind galaxies to constrain the size , energetics , and impact of these superwinds .
the large `` cavities '' in the x - ray surface brightness of several cooling flow clusters with radio - loud cd galaxies ( e.g. , bhringer et al .
1993 ; fabian et al .
2000 ; mcnamara et al .
2000 ; fabian 2001 ; quilis , bower , & balogh 2001 ; heinz et al .
2002 ) point to equally large zones of influence for agn - driven outflows
. galactic winds in the early universe are likely to have had an even stronger influence on the environment ( e.g. , alderberger et al .
2003 ; shapley et al .
2003 ) .
the present paper describes the results from a pilot survey of 10 nearby starburst and active galaxies with the taurus tunable filter ( ttf ) on the anglo - australian and william herschel telescopes .
the main goals of this survey are to search for warm ( t @xmath5 10@xmath6 k ) line - emitting gas on the outskirts of these galaxies , and study the properties of this gas to constrain its origin and overall importance .
the names , redshifts , and nuclear types of the galaxies in the sample are listed in table 1 along with a summary of the findings from the ttf survey .
these galaxies were selected based on the fact that they all present ionization cones and/or galactic winds on @xmath2 kpc scale .
this method of selection and the small number of galaxies in the sample imply that this sample is probably not representative of the local population of starburst / active galaxies , and therefore should not be used for statistical purposes .
nevertheless , the results from this pilot survey should provide important clues on the range of phenomena taking place in the general local galaxy population .
this paper is organized as follows . in 2
, we discuss the methods of observations .
the results are described individually for each object in 3 . in 4 , we summarize the results and discuss future avenues of research .
the present discussion complements recent fabry - perot searches for warm ionized gas on the outskirts of `` normal '' galaxies including our own galaxy ( e.g. , bland - hawthorn et al .
1998 ; putman et al .
2003 ) and several dwarf , spiral , and elliptical galaxies ( e.g. , bland - hawthorn , freeman , & quinn 1997a ; meurer et al .
1999 ; ferguson , van der hulst , & van gorkom 2001 ; miller & veilleux 2003a , 2003b ) , as well as in isolated extragalactic h i clouds ( e.g. , weymann et al . 2001 ) and a few active galaxies with collimated jet outflows ( e.g. , cecil et al . 2000 ; tadhunter et al .
the results in the present paper supersede those from veilleux ( 2002 ) .
the results for two of the galaxies in the sample have already been presented elsewhere ( ngc 1482 : veilleux & rupke 2002 ; mr 2251178 : shopbell , veilleux , & bland - hawthorn 1999 ) , but are discussed again in the present paper for the sake of completeness and to add to the discussion ( e.g. , a new unpublished x - ray map of ngc 1482 are presented here along with a deeper reprocessed h@xmath4 + [ n ii ] @xmath76583 image of this object ) .
the ttf on the 3.9-meter anglo - australian telescope ( aat ) was used for all but one of the observations reported in the present paper .
the ttf on the 4.2-meter william herschel telescope ( wht ) was used for ngc 1068 .
the ttf is described in detail in bland - hawthorn & jones ( 1998 ) and bland - hawthorn & kedziora - chudczer ( 2003 ) .
the data acquisition and reduction techniques used to reach low flux levels with the ttf have already been discussed in several papers ( e.g. , shopbell et al .
1999 ; glazebrook & bland - hawthorn 2001 ; veilleux & rupke 2002 ; jones , shopbell , & bland - hawthorn 2002 ; miller & veilleux 2003a ) .
the ttf is uniquely suited to carry out deep searches for emission - line gas on the outskirts of galaxies , combining wide field of view ( @xmath2 10@xmath8 ) with outstanding narrow - band imaging capabilities over a broad range in wavelength ( 3500
1.0 @xmath9 m ) and bandpass ( 10 100 ) .
a summary of the ttf observations is given in tables 2 and 3 .
nearly all of the aat observations were carried out in the `` charge shuffling / frequency switching '' mode , where the charges are moved up and down within the detector at the same time as switching between two discrete frequencies with the tunable filter .
the charges were generally moved every minute and the chip was read after typically spending 32 minutes of integration time ( 16 minutes on - band and 16 minutes off - band ) . as a result , the continuum and emission - line images are produced nearly simultaneously , therefore averaging out temporal variations associated with atmospheric lines and transparency , seeing , instrument and detector instabilities .
most of the aat images were obtained in a straddle mode , where the off - band image is made up of a pair of images that `` straddle '' the on - band image in wavelength ( e.g. , @xmath10 = 6500 and @xmath11 = 6625 for rest - frame h@xmath4 ) ; this greatly improves the accuracy of the continuum removal since it corrects for slopes in the continuum and underlying absorption features .
the charge shuffling and frequency switching capabilities were not available at the wht .
the flux levels reached by the ttf observations are listed in the last column of table 3 .
long - slit optical spectra were also obtained for some of the objects to clarify the origin and source of ionization of the warm ionized material .
tables 2 and 4 summarize the details of these observations .
these spectra were reduced using standard iraf routines .
when available , complementary x - ray and radio maps were used to track the hot ( x - rays ) , relativistic ( 20-cm ) and neutral ( hi ) gas phases in the sample galaxies and allow us to draw a more complete picture of these objects .
ngc 1068 is arguably the best studied active galaxy in the local universe .
it is a sb galaxy which is nearly face - on ( @xmath12 ; de vaucouleurs et al .
1991 ) and shows evidence for a @xmath2 3-kpc bar ( e.g. , scoville et al . 1988 ; thronson et al . 1989 ; helfer & blitz 1995 ) .
signs of the agn in the core of this galaxy are evident at nearly all wavelengths .
it was one of the six objects originally studied by seyfert ( 1943 ) with bright optical `` emission lines similar to those in planetary nebulae . ''
four decades later , spectropolarimetry of ngc 1068 revealed the presence of broad ( fwhm @xmath5 4,500 km s@xmath13 ) recombination lines in scattered light , suggesting for the first time that the @xmath14 pc - scale broad line region in this object is obscured by an optically thick torus ( e.g. , miller & antonucci 1983 ; antonucci & miller 1985 ; miller , goodrich , & mathews 1991 ) .
indirect evidence for a inner disk structure in ngc 1068 comes from the presence of bright cones of photoionized gas detected at optical wavelengths ( e.g. , baldwin , wilson , & whittle 1987 ; pogge 1988a ; macchetto et al . 1994 ; kraemer , ruiz , & crenshaw 1998 ) and also in x - rays ( e.g. , young , wilson , & shopbell 2001 ; kinkhabwala et al .
the ionization cones are roughly aligned with the inner radio jet and large - scale radio structure ( e.g. , wilson & ulvestad 1987 ; gallimore et al .
most of the inner line - emitting clouds originally discovered by walker ( 1968 ) are taking part in a large - scale outflow event ( e.g. , cecil , bland , & tully 1990 ; arribas , mediavilla , & garcia - lorenzo 1996 ; crenshaw & kraemer 2000 ) .
some of the line - emitting material near the nucleus is outflowing at velocities of up to @xmath2 3200 km s@xmath13 ( cecil et al .
2002b ) ; this material appears to be accelerated radiatively by the agn ( dopita et al .
uv line ratios are inconsistent with shock excitation ( groves et al .
, in prep . ) . the anisotropic radiation field from the agn in ngc 1068 is already known to affect the inner @xmath2 10 kpc diameter disk of the host galaxy ( bland - hawthorn , sokolowski , & cecil 1991 ; sokolowski , bland - hawthorn , & cecil 1991 ) .
our new data on ngc 1068 now show that the ionization cone extends even further .
figure 1 presents deep h@xmath4 and [ o iii ] @xmath75007 images obtained with the ttf .
a complex of knots and filaments are detected out to @xmath15 11 kpc along p.a .
@xmath5 15 70@xmath16 . another fainter complex is seen out to @xmath2 10 kpc in the opposite direction at p.a .
@xmath5 200 260@xmath16 .
there is a deficit of filaments in all other directions .
figure 2 compares the locations of the filaments with an unpublished h i 21-cm map graciously provided to us by e. brinks ( 2003 ; private communication ) .
some of the optical filaments ( especially those to the south - west ) lie slightly beyond the sharp h i `` edge '' of ngc 1068 . as in the case of ngc 253 ( bland - hawthorn et al .
1997a ) , the filaments are too bright to be photoionized solely by the metagalactic ionizing radiation another source of ionization is needed .
the surprisingly bright h@xmath4 emission beyond the h i edge of ngc 253 is probably due to photoionization by hot young stars in the inner disk ( bland - hawthorn et al .
we suspect a different origin for the filaments in ngc 1068 .
as is clearly apparent in figure 1 , these filaments are contained within a biconical region which is roughly aligned with the nuclear outflow / jets and the optical ionization cone seen on smaller scales .
figure 2 also shows that there is a good ( though not perfect ) match in p.a . between the x - ray emission and the optical filaments on large scale
this biconical geometry on small and large scales strongly suggests that the agn is responsible for the ionization of the gas on both scales . the large [ o iii]/h@xmath4 ratios ( @xmath1 1 ; fig .
1 ) observed in the gas within the large - scale cones seem to support this scenario ( i.e. the hard radiation field from the agn contributes to the high ionization level of the gas in this region ) .
deep mssso and aat long - slit spectra of the north - east filament at @xmath15 6 11 kpc confirm the role of the agn .
the line ratios measured along this filament are plotted in figure 3 .
using the diagnostic tools of veilleux & osterbrock ( 1987 ) , we find that most of the line ratios are seyfert - like .
no obvious systematic gradient in the line ratios is detected along the brighter portion of the filament .
the @xmath2 100 km s@xmath13 blueshift and slight velocity gradient apparent in the data ( particularly in the higher s / n data obtained at mssso ; see fig .
4 ) are consistent with gas in rotation in the p.a .
@xmath5 79@xmath16 galactic disk ( e.g. , galletta & recillas - cruz 1982 ; kaneko et al .
1992 ; sofue 1997 ; sofue et al .
the narrow line widths in the brighter portion of the filament ( fwhm @xmath17 200 km s@xmath13 ) suggest that quiescent gas from the disk is being photoionized by the central agn .
the apparent broadening in the emission - line profiles extracted from the fainter ( southern ) portion of the filament ( fwhms reach @xmath2 300 400 km s@xmath13 in some locations and maybe accompanied by line splitting ; see fig .
4 ) may indicate that shocks become important or the agn is photoionizing a spray of gas with a broader range of line - of - sight velocities .
the elevated [ n ii]/h@xmath4 and [ s ii]/h@xmath4 ratios in this region ( not shown in fig . 3 because [ o iii]/h@xmath18 is poorly constrained ) could be due to either shocks or agn photoionization with low ionization parameter (= ratio of the density of ionizing photons to that of electrons ) .
intervening disk material may explain the slightly fainter emission in the south - west cone since the radiation field emerges above the disk in the north - east quadrant and below the disk in the south - west quadrant ( e.g. , cecil et al .
1990 ; bland - hawthorn et al .
1997b ) .
ngc 1365 is a giant barred sb galaxy in the fornax cluster , host to a beautiful grand design spiral structure and a seyfert 1.5 nucleus .
it has been the subject of several spectroscopic studies , including the pioneering work of burbidge & burbidge ( 1960 ) who were the first to point out the possibility of a large - scale outflow in this object .
line splitting of the [ o iii ] profiles observed by phillips et al .
( 1983 ) and jrster , lindblad , & boksenberg ( 1984 ) confirmed the complex velocity field of the gas in the nuclear region , and revealed the highly ionized state of the outflowing material .
subsequent studies have traced the extent and geometry of the highly ionized outflowing material ( e.g. , edmunds et al . 1988 ; storchi - bergmann & bonatto 1991 ; hjelm & lindblad 1996 ; kristen et al .
an accelerated outflow in a hollow biconical structure with opening angle @xmath2 100@xmath16 has been suggested ( hjelm & lindblad 1996 ) .
this structure is roughly aligned with a jet - like radio feature observed by sandqvist , jrster , & lindblad ( 1995 ) and morganti et al .
( 1999 ) .
ttf h@xmath4 , [ n ii ] @xmath76583 , and [ oiii ] @xmath75007 images were obtained of ngc 1365 ; they are presented in figures 5 8 .
the [ o iii ] data confirm the presence of the bright south - east plume of [ o iii]-emitting material seen in previous studies , but also show for the first time fainter plumes of material on the opposite side of the nucleus .
the fainter [ o iii ] emission in the ttf data extends over @xmath2 1@xmath8 , and is much less conical than the bright se plume .
the [ o iii ] @xmath75007/h@xmath4 ratios in this region are larger than unity , suggesting photoionization by the agn .
strings of bright h ii regions and complex dust lanes bisect the [ o iii ] structure and lowers the [ o iii]/h@xmath4 ratios along a diagonal line passing immediately north of the nucleus .
the [ n ii]/h@xmath4 line ratio maps shown in figures 6 and 8 indicate that the zone of influence of the agn in ngc 1365 extends further than suspected .
[ n ii ] @xmath76583/h@xmath4 ratios in excess of unity are seen out to @xmath2 1@xmath8 ( @xmath2 5 6 kpc ) from the nucleus .
surprisingly , the high-[n ii]/h@xmath4 region appears to be almost rectangular rather than biconical , although the axis of symmetry is the same as that of the high [ o iii]/h@xmath4 structure ( p.a .
@xmath5 45@xmath16 ) .
it is not clear at present whether this fainter material is also taking place in the bright outflow studied by hjelm & lindblad ( 1996 ) , or is simply ambient disk material being illuminated by the central agn .
the results from our ttf imaging and optical long - slit spectroscopy of ngc 1482 have already been published in veilleux & rupke ( 2002 ) .
these data reveal a starburst - driven wind extending 1.5 kpc above and below the disk of the host galaxy with expansion velocities on the order of @xmath2 250 km s@xmath13 and kinetic energy of at least 2 @xmath19 10@xmath20 ergs .
the ttf data are presented again in figure 9 .
the [ n ii ] @xmath76583/h@xmath4 ratio map derived from these data shows that the entrained wind material has [ n ii ] @xmath76583/h@xmath4 ratios in excess of unity while the disk material is characterized by h ii region - like line ratios indicative of the starburst .
shock ionization is suspected to be responsible for the liner - like line ratios of the entrained material .
the new x - ray map presented in figure 9 brings credence to this scenario .
this map is based on the unpublished archived 28.56 ks exposure ( p.i .
d. strickland ) with the acis - s3 detector on the _ chandra x - ray observatory_. high - background data were filtered out of the original image ; the effective exposure time is 24.40 ks .
a fixed gaussian kernel with @xmath21 = 3 pixels ( 1@xmath225 ) was used for smoothing .
the energy range of the data is 0.2 3 kev .
the x - ray emission ( especially at low energies ) is elongated along the minor axis of the galaxy and shows a remarkably good match with some of the extraplanar optical filaments . a tight spatial correlation between x - ray emitting material and optical emission - line gas
is also observed in two other well - known galactic winds studied in detail with _ chandra _ : ngc 253 ( strickland et al . 2000 ) and ngc 3079 ( cecil et al . 2001 ; cecil , bland - hawthorn , & veilleux 2002a ) . in both of these cases ,
the data suggest that the superwind has driven cool disk gas into the halo , with x - rays being emitted either as upstream , standoff bow shocks or by cooling at cloud / wind conductive interfaces .
the same phenomenon appears to be taking place in ngc 1482 ( and ngc 6240 ; see 3.6 ) .
good correlations between extraplanar h@xmath4 and x - ray emission have been known to exist in a number of star - forming galaxies ( e.g. , dahlem et al .
2003 and references therein ) , but the new @xmath23 data now show that this correlation extends down to @xmath2 1 scale .
reprocessing of the ttf data now reveals that the galactic wind in this galaxy extends much further than first suspected by veilleux & rupke ( 2002 ; see fig .
10 ) . the summed h@xmath4 +
[ n ii ] @xmath76583 image now clearly shows the presence of a filament that extends out to @xmath2 7 kpc north - west of the nucleus .
another filament extending out to @xmath2 11 kpc north - east of the nucleus is visible in figure 10 , although scattered light from a bright star in the field makes the detection of this filament uncertain .
diffuse emission near the detection limit of our data also appears to be present @xmath2 10 kpc south of the nucleus . a high - velocity ( @xmath2 + 400 km s@xmath13 ) emission - line knot located @xmath2 3 kpc north of the nucleus is also visible in [ n ii ] @xmath76583 in the aat long - slit spectrum ( fig . 11 ; this knot is also present at h@xmath4 but is near the detection limit of the data ) .
the discovery of these knots and filaments will necessarily increase the energetics involved in the outflow , although the kinematics of the gas on large scale are not yet fully constrained .
ngc 1705 is a blue compact dwarf ( bcd ) galaxy located at 6.2 mpc ( meurer et al .
it is host to a starburst - driven wind which is responsible for the multiple emission - line loops and arcs seen out to the holmberg radius , @xmath2 2.1 kpc ( meurer et al 1992 ; hunter , hawley , & gallagher 1993 ) . line splitting indicative of expansion velocities of order @xmath2 100 km s@xmath13 is seen over most of the line - emitting gas ( e.g. , meurer et al .
1992 ; marlowe et al .
the detection of blueshifted uv absorption lines has confirmed the presence of the wind in this object ( heckman & leitherer 1997 ; sahu & blades 1997 ) .
recent @xmath24 far - uv spectroscopy has revealed outflowing coronal - phase gas at a few @xmath19 10@xmath25 k , possibly created at the interface of the warm ( @xmath2 @xmath26 k ) optical line - emitting material and the hot outrushing gas in a blownout superbubble ( heckman et al .
2001 ) .
the line - emitting loops and arcs seen by previous authors are easily detected with the ttf in both h@xmath4 and [ n ii ] @xmath76583 ( fig .
surprisingly , the [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ratio map shows very little structure across these structures .
the [ n ii ] @xmath76583/h@xmath4 line ratio peaks at a value of @xmath2 0.3 near the location of the bright central star cluster ( indicated by an arrow in fig .
12 ; this star cluster is ngc 1705 - 1 in the nomenclature of melnick , moles , & terlevich 1985 ) .
[ n ii]/h@xmath4 generally stays below @xmath2 0.1 across the remainder of the line - emitting nebula , except perhaps in a few features where the s / n is low and the line ratio less reliable .
this line ratio map is very different from that of ngc 1482 , even though both objects host similar starburst - driven winds . as discussed in the previous section ,
the large [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ratios detected in the outflowing gas of ngc 1482 are almost certainly due to shock excitation .
the fact that we do not detect significant enhancement in the [ n ii]/h@xmath4 map of ngc 1705 may be due to the fact that the expansion velocities in this dwarf galaxy are considerably smaller than in ngc 1482 , so that shock excitation ( @xmath27 ) is less important than photoionization by the starburst itself .
this result emphasizes an important limitation of the excitation technique suggested by veilleux & rupke ( 2002 ) to search for galaxies with starburst - driven winds : the results from this search technique will necessarily be biased toward powerful , shock - excited wind structures which show a sharp contrast in excitation properties relative to the star - forming hosts .
winds in dwarf galaxies will be harder to detect with this technique . ngc 4388 is a well - known seyfert 2 galaxy located near the center of the virgo cluster ( e.g. , phillips & malin 1982 ) .
the agn is responsible for driving a loosely collimated outflow out of the disk of this edge - on galaxy , visible in the radio ( stone , wilson , & ward 1988 ; hummel & saikia 1991 ; kukula et al . 1995 ; falcke , wilson , & simpson 1998 ; irwin , english , & sorathia 1999 ) and optical ( e.g. , veilleux et al .
1999 and references therein ) . a recent @xmath23 study of ngc 4388 by iwasawa et al .
( 2003 ) now shows direct support for the galactic outflow in the x - rays .
their map is reproduced in figure 13 along with the h@xmath4 and [ n ii ] @xmath76583 images obtained with the ttf .
note in table 3 that the ttf was tuned to a wavelength of 6605 near the nucleus of the galaxy 13 below the wavelength of h@xmath4 at systemic velocity to map the blueshifted gas complex north of ngc 4388 .
part of the soft x - ray emission is clearly produced in the disk , while the extraplanar emission is directly associated with the outflowing line - emitting material .
this material is highly ionized and therefore presents only modest [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ratios ( @xmath14 0.7 ; pogge 1988b ; colina 1992 ; petitjean & durret 1993 ) . a recent study by yoshida et al . ( 2002 ) has revealed emission - line filaments extending out to @xmath2 35 kpc from the center of ngc 4388 . although the origin of these filaments is still uncertain , stripping of the interstellar medium of ngc 4388 by the ram pressure of the virgo intracluster medium is likely to be responsible for some of these features ( see also veilleux et al .
the recent discoveries of an isolated h ii region and extended h i gas in the vicinity of ngc 4388 by gerhard et al .
( 2002 ) and vollmer & huchtmeier ( 2003 ) bring additional support to the ram - pressure stripping scenario .
the wide field of view of the ttf allows us to confirm the detection of the filaments ( fig .
14 ) and provide additional information on the excitation and kinematics of the line - emitting material .
the [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ratios in the brighter line - emitting knots beyond a galactocentric distance of @xmath2 7 kpc stay below @xmath2 0.7 but show no obvious monotonic gradient with distance ( fig .
these line ratios do not allow us to identify unambiguously the source of ionization of the gas ( low - velocity shocks , agn with low ionization parameter , or in - situ hot stars ) , but indicate that the ionization and excitation properties of the brighter line - emitting knots at these large distances are affected by complex variations in the ionization parameter or shock velocity rather than only the distance from the nucleus .
the fact that nearly all of the emission features seen in the data of yoshida et al .
( 2002 ) are also detected in our ( slightly blueshifted ) ttf images suggests that most of these features have velocities @xmath14 + 100 km s@xmath13 near the nucleus of the galaxy and @xmath14 + 250 km s@xmath13 in the outer filaments .
ngc 6240 is often considered the archetype of luminous infrared galaxies ( log[l@xmath28/l@xmath29 = 11.8 ) ; it has been studied thoroughly at all wavelengths .
ngc 6240 is an early merger with two nuclei separated by @xmath2 1@xmath228 or @xmath2 1.28 kpc ( e.g. , carral , turner , & ho 1990 ; beswick et al .
2001 ; fried & schultz 1983 ; keel 1990 ; bland - hawthorn , wilson , & tully 1991 ; tacconi et al . 1999 ; scoville et al .
2000 ; tezca et al .
unambiguous signs of an agn in this system have been detected in the hard x - rays ( iwasawa & comastri 1998 ; vignati et al .
recent high - resolution images obtained with @xmath23 show that both nuclei are x - ray emitters ( lira et al .
2002 ) and that both appear to be agn ( komossa et al . 2003 ) . surrounding the nuclei is a large - scale soft x - ray nebula possibly powered by a superwind ( schulz et al . 1998 ; komossa , schulz , & greiner 1998 ; kolaczyk & dixon 2000 ) .
signs for a superwind are also seen at optical wavelengths in the form of a complex of line - emitting filaments and arcs extending over 50 @xmath19 60 kpc ( heckman , armus , & miley 1987 ) and often showing violent gas motion and liner - like line ratios ( e.g. , heckman et al .
1987 ; heckman , armus , & miley 1990 ; keel 1990 ) .
deep h@xmath4 and [ n ii ] @xmath76583 images of this object were obtained with the ttf ( figs .
16 and 17 ) .
h@xmath4 emission is detected over an area @xmath2 70 @xmath19 80 kpc centered on the nuclei .
the distribution of the [ n ii ] emission differs considerably from that of h@xmath4 .
the incomplete loop and filament located at p.a . @xmath5 265 275@xmath16 and @xmath30 kpc
are clearly detected in the [ n ii ] image but are hardly visible in h@xmath4 ; these features have [ n ii ] @xmath76583/h@xmath4 @xmath1 1.4 and stand out in the excitation map shown in figure 16 .
this large - scale , high-[n ii]/h@xmath4 structure is roughly aligned with a 5-kpc x - ray loop detected by komossa et al .
figure 17 also shows that the brighter portion of this loop coincides with a emission - line knot with strongly enhanced ( @xmath31 1 ) liner - like [ n ii]/h@xmath4 line ratios .
these results bring further support to the galactic outflow scenario .
the line - emitting gas is entrained in the starburst - driven wind .
shocks associated with the interaction between the fast wind and the slow - moving ambient gas contribute to the heating and ionization of the line - emitting material .
the good match between optical line emission and x - ray emission suggests once again ( see 3.3 and references therein ) that the x - rays from this galactic wind are produced either by cooling at the conductive interfaces between the line - emitting clouds and the wind or as upstream , standoff bow shocks .
ngc 7213 is a nearby ( 22.0 mpc ; @xmath32 = 75 km s@xmath13 mpc@xmath13 ; tully 1988 ) face - on sa galaxy which is host to a bright seyfert 1 nucleus with broad h@xmath4 and strong hard x - ray emission ( e.g. , phillips 1979 ; filippenko & halpern 1984 ) .
the nuclear spectrum also exhibits narrow liner - like emission lines produced by the diffuse gas around the seyfert nucleus .
figure 18 shows deep h@xmath4 and [ n ii ] @xmath76583 images of this object obtained with the ttf .
the ttf data recover the ring of h ii regions known to exist around the bright active nucleus of this galaxy ( storchi - bergmann et al .
the ttf image also reveals the presence of a line - emitting filament located @xmath2 19 kpc from the nucleus , well outside the optical radius of this galaxy .
this filament was independently discovered by hameed et al .
( 2001 ) , who argues that it is the ionized portion of tidal debris from a recent merger .
the ttf data suggest that the [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ratios in the filament are unlike those typically seen in h ii regions ( e.g. , ring of h ii regions near the nucleus ) .
the line ratios measured from a deep long - slit spectrum obtained with the mssso 2.3-meter telescope confirm this result and indicate that the emission in the filament is liner - like , based on the locations of the line ratios in diagnostic diagrams ( fig .
dilute photoionization by a faint and distant agn with ionization parameter log @xmath33 @xmath5 3 ( i.e. the density of ionizing photon is 10@xmath34 that of electron ) could explain these line ratios ( e.g. , ferland & netzer 1983 ) , although shock ionization can not be formally excluded ( dopita & sutherland 1995 ) .
the kinematics of this filament can be used to distinguish between these two scenarios .
multi - line imaging slightly shifted in velocity space suggests that the line - emitting gas is blueshifted by @xmath2 150 200 km s@xmath13 with respect to systemic velocity .
the mssso spectrum of the filament confirms this small blueshift ( fig .
these measurements indicate that the optical filament coincides not only spatially with the h i feature of hameed et al .
( 2001 ) but also kinematically .
moreover , the narrow line widths ( @xmath2 80 200 km s@xmath13 ) measured in the optical filament indicate that the gas must not be affected significantly by shocks .
this strongly suggests that the line - emitting filament simply represents tidal debris which are being ionized by the agn in ngc 7213 .
only a small fraction of the h i tidal complex is visible in h@xmath4 because the radiation field from ngc 7213 is not isotropic .
according to the unified model of seyfert galaxies , our line of sight to the seyfert 1 nucleus has to lie within the opening angle of the inner torus / accretion disk .
given the face - on orientation of the host galaxy , this would imply that both our line of sight and the line - emitting filament lie within the ionizing cone of the accretion disk and above the galactic disk of ngc 7213 . the circinus galaxy ( freeman et al . 1977 ) is host to a well - known ionization cone and large - scale outflow visible in the radio ( e.g. , elmouttie et al .
1998a ) , optical ( e.g. , marconi et al . 1994
; lehnert & heckman 1995 ; veilleux & bland - hawthorn 1997 ; elmouttie et al .
1998b ; wilson et al .
2000 ) , near - infrared ( maiolino et al . 1998 ; ruiz et al . 2000 ) , and x - rays ( sambruna et al .
2001a , 2001b ; smith & wilson 2001 ) .
the source of the ionization and outflow appears to be the central seyfert nucleus , although a circumnuclear starburst is also present in this object ( e.g. , veilleux & bland - hawthorn 1997 ; elmouttie et al .
1998b ) a new ttf [ o iii ] @xmath75007 image of the circinus galaxy is presented in figure 21 .
this image reaches fainter flux levels than the fabry - perot data presented in veilleux & bland - hawthorn ( 1997 ) .
the new data confirm the presence of the bright high - ionization filaments within 0.5 kpc of the nucleus .
but the deeper ttf image also reveals unsuspected [ o iii ] emission which extends @xmath2 1 kpc west and north - west of the nucleus .
very faint , filamentary emission appears to extend out to @xmath2 1.2 kpc from the nucleus along p.a .
@xmath5 315@xmath16 , but this needs to be confirmed with deeper images .
the ttf image also shows a few additional knots of emission in the northern / northwestern quadrant and to the south .
the southernmost of these features appears to coincide with @xmath23 source f in smith & wilson ( 2001 ) , located @xmath2 500 pc due south from the nucleus .
this is shown in the lower left panel of figure 21 , where the @xmath23 data are superposed on the ttf [ o iii ] image .
eso484-g036 is an edge - on sb galaxy from the @xmath35 bright galaxy sample ( soifer et al .
1989 ; f043352514 ) .
the optical classification of the nucleus of this galaxy is ambiguous due to weak h@xmath18 and [ o iii ] emission ( kim et al . 1995 ; veilleux et al .
long - slit spectroscopy by lehnert & heckman ( 1995 ) indicates the presence of large positive gradients in [ n ii]/h@xmath4 , [ s ii]/h@xmath4 and [ o i]/h@xmath4 along the minor axis of this galaxy .
+ [ n ii ] narrowband imaging of this object by these same authors reveals a cross - like structure aligned along the major and minor axes of the disk .
the ttf data confirm the cross - like morphology of the line emission in eso484-g036 ( especially visible in [ n ii ] ; fig .
the [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ratio map also confirms the steep excitation gradient along the minor axis of the galaxy .
the disk emission presents a h ii region - like [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ratios of @xmath2 0.5 ( but note that [ n ii]/h@xmath4 reaches a minimum @xmath2 1 kpc south - west of the nucleus ) , while the emission 1 kpc above and below the disk have [ n ii]/h@xmath4 that are in the range @xmath36 .
this line ratio map is reminiscent of that of ngc 1482 , but the larger distance of eso484-g036 ( @xmath2 60 mpc instead of 20 mpc for ngc 1482 ) makes the extraplanar emission more difficult to resolve in this object .
the new ttf data add strong support to the idea that eso484-g036 is indeed host to a starburst - driven wind ( lehnert & heckman 1996 ) , and also show the promise of using excitation maps for systematic searches for starburst - driven winds in the local universe ( veilleux & rupke 2002 ) .
in the course of our ttf study , the radio - quiet quasar mr 2251178 was imaged at h@xmath4 .
this is the most distant ( @xmath37 ) object in the sample .
the results on this object have already been published by shopbell , veilleux , & bland - hawthorn ( 1999 ) ; the ttf images are reproduced for the sake of completeness in figure 23 .
the ttf data reveal a very extended nebula centered on and photoionized by this quasar .
the spiral - like complex is seen extending more or less symmetrically over @xmath2 200 kpc .
narrow - band images obtained at slightly different wavelengths reveal a large - scale rotation pattern which is in the opposite sense as that seen in the inner region of the galaxy ( see also bergeron et al . 1983 ; nrgaard - nielsen et al .
1986 ) . as discussed in detail in shopbell et al . , the large and symmetric morphology of the gaseous envelope and its smooth large - scale rotation suggest that the envelope did not originate with a cooling flow , a past merger event , or an interaction with any of the galaxies in the field .
shopbell et al .
favor a model in which the extended ionized nebula resides within a large complex of h i gas centered on the quasar .
slightly blueshifted ( @xmath2 300 km s@xmath13 ) uv and warm x - ray absorbers are seen in hst and asca / rosat spectra of mr 2251178 ( reynolds 1997 ; komossa 2001 ; monier et al .
2001 ; ganguly , charlton , & eracleous 2001 ) , but they are presumed to arise from nuclear material near the agn rather than from gas extending on galactic scale .
an error of a factor of 2.25 was recently found in the flux calibration of the ttf data .
all fluxes listed in shopbell et al .
( 1999 ) should be scaled down by this factor .
this correction does not affect the conclusions of the paper .
we have presented the results from a deep emission - line imaging survey of 10 nearby starburst and active galaxies using the ttf on the aat and wht .
the topology and projected cross - section of the line - emitting gas varies widely among the galaxies in the sample .
very large ( @xmath1 80 kpc ) ionized complexes are discovered around ngc 6240 and mr 2251178 .
emission - line knots and wispy filaments are confirmed to be present in the halo of ngc 4388 at distances of up to @xmath2 30 kpc from the active nucleus .
diffuse and filamentary gas associated with large - scale ( 10 20 kpc ) ionization cones or outflows are detected for the first time in ngc 1068 , ngc 1365 , and ngc 1482 and confirmed in ngc 7213 .
emission - line structures on @xmath1 kpc scale are revealed in the galactic winds of ngc 1705 , circinus galaxy , and eso484-g036 .
multi - line imaging and long - slit spectroscopy of the gas found on large scale reveal line ratios which are generally not h ii region - like .
shocks often contribute significantly to the ionization of the outflowing gas on the outskirts of starburst galaxies .
as expected from shock models ( e.g. , dopita & sutherland 1995 ) , the importance of shocks over photoionization by ob stars appears to scale with the velocity of the outflowing gas ( e.g. , ngc 1482 , ngc 6240 , or eso484-g036 versus ngc 1705 ; ngc 3079 is an extreme example of a shock - excited wind nebula ; veilleux et al .
1994 ) , although other factors like the starburst age , star formation rate , and the dynamical state of the outflowing structure ( e.g. , pre- or post - blowout ) must also be important in determining the excitation properties of the gas at these large radii ( e.g. , see discussion in shopbell & bland - hawthorn 1998 and veilleux & rupke 2002 ) . when an active nucleus is present , the radiation field from the agn appears to be the primary source of ionization for the filaments within @xmath2 10 20 kpc of the nucleus , but the impact of the agn tapers off at larger distances ( e.g. , @xmath1 30 kpc in ngc 4388 ) , unless the source of radiation is a powerful quasar ( mr 2251178 ) .
given the small sample size and methods of selection of the sample , no statistical statement can be made on the frequency of occurrence of large - scale nebulae around starburst and active galaxies in general .
the objects in our sample were specifically selected to host ionization cones and/or galactic winds on @xmath2 kpc scale .
the high discovery rate of @xmath1 10-kpc nebulae in our sample may not be typical of the local population of starburst and active galaxies .
it is also not clear at present whether the power and type of agn ( type 1 _ versus _ type 2 ) is important in determining the amount of ionized gas detectable with the ttf . in the matter - bounded scenario ( e.g. , infinite reservoir of h i gas surrounding the active nucleus in all directions ) , one would expect a correlation between agn ionizing power and the detected mass of ionized material this may be why the largest nebula is found around the most powerful agn in our sample ( mr 2251178 ) . in this simple scenario , the orientation of the agn accretion disk to our line of sight ( nearly face - on in type 1s _ versus _ nearly edge - on in type 2s ) should to first order determine the geometry of the ionized material : biconical in seyfert 2s ( e.g. , ngc 1068 ) and more isotropic in seyfert 1s ( e.g. , mr 2251178 ; see detailed predictions in mulchaey , wilson , & tsvetanov 1996 ) .
however , this simple scenario clearly does not apply to all agns in our sample ( e.g. , ngc 7213 ) .
the topology and projected cross - section of the warm ionized gas in agn necessarily also depend on the properties of the host galaxy ( e.g. , morphological type , gas content ) and immediate environment ( e.g , presence of a tidal complex as in the case of ngc 7213 ) .
our pilot survey raises similar questions for starburst galaxies .
there is a clear need to expand the starburst sample to look for possible dependence on the age and power of the starburst and the dynamical state of the outflow
. these data will provide the material to test the idea of using excitation maps ( e.g. , [ n ii]/h@xmath4 ) to detect superwind galaxies ( veilleux & rupke 2002 ) .
if found to be successful at low redshifts , this method could be used in the future to more efficiently identify distant galaxies hosting powerful starburst - driven winds .
the advent of tunable filters on 8-meter class telescopes [ e.g. , osiris on the grantecan ( cepa et al . 2000 ) and the maryland - magellan tunable filter on the baade 6.5-m telescope ] should improve the sensitivity of emission - line galaxy surveys at least tenfold .
measurements with this second generation of tunable filters will provide direct quantitative constraints on the gaseous cross - section of active and star - forming galaxies , and the importance of mass exchange between galaxies and their environment .
the detection of warm ionized complexes that extend several tens of kpc over wide opening angles would make them likely candidates for the higher column density ly@xmath4 cloud population detected in quasar spectra ( e.g. , bergeron et al .
1994 ; lanzetta et al . 1995 ; norman et al . 1996 ; steidel et al . 2002 ) .
the kinematic information derived from these data will constrain the origin of the gas : is it taking part in an outflow or is it an extension of the hi disk , remnant accreting gas from galaxy formation , or debris from a recent galaxy interaction or ram - pressure stripping episode ?
we are grateful to e. brinks for providing the h i map of ngc 1068 prior to publication and to k. iwasawa and a. wilson for the @xmath23 x - ray data of ngc 4388 .
we thank the referee , matthias ehle , for constructive comments .
this article was written while s.v .
was on sabbatical at the california institute of technology and the observatories of the carnegie institution of washington ; s.v .
thanks both of these institutions for their hospitality .
s.v . acknowledges partial support of this research by a cottrell scholarship awarded by the research corporation , nasa / ltsa grant nag 56547 , and nsf / career grant ast-9874973 .
was also supported in part by nsf / career grant ast-9874973 .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) ) , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
adelberger , k. l. , steidel , c. c. , shapley , a. e. , & pettini , m. 2003 , , 584 , 45 antonucci , r. r. j. , & miller , j. s. 1985 , , 297 , 621 arribas , s. , mediavilla , e. , & garcia - lorenzo , b. 1996 , , 463 , 509 bajtlik , s. , duncan , r. c. , & ostriker , j. p. 1988 ,
apj , 327 , 570 baldwin , j. , wilson , a. s. , & whittle , m. 1987 , , 319 , 84 bergeron , j. , boksenberg , a. , dennefeld , m. , & tarenghi , m. 1983 , , 202 , 125 bergeron , j. , et al .
1994 , , 436 , 33 beswick , r. j. , pedlar , a. , mundell , c. g. , & gallimore , j. f. 2001 , , 325 , 151 bland - hawthorn , j. 1999 , nature , 400 , 220 bland - hawthorn , j. , freeman , k. c. , & quinn , p. j. 1997a , , 490 , 143 bland - hawthorn , j. , lumsden , s. l. , voit , g. m. , cecil , g. n. , & weisheit , j. c. 1997b , ap&ss , 248 , 177 bland - hawthorn , j. , & jones , d. h. 1998 , pasa , 15 , 44 bland - hawthorn , j. & kedziora - chudczer , l. 2003 , pasa , in press ( astro - ph/0305032 ) bland - hawthorn , j. , lumsden , s. l , voit , g. m. , cecil , g. n. , & weisheit , j. c. 1997 , ap&ss , 248 , 177 bland - hawthorn , j. , sokolowski , j. , & cecil , g. 1991 , , 375 , 78 bland - hawthorn , j. , veilleux , s. , cecil , g. n. , putman , m. e. , gibson , b. k. , & maloney , p. r. 1998 , , 299 , 611 bland - hawthorn , j. , wilson , a. s. , & tully , r. b. 1991 , , 371 , l19 blitz , l. , spergel , d. n. , teuben , p. j. , hartmann , d. , burton , w. b. 1999 , , 514 , 818 bhringer , h. , voges , w. , fabian , a. c. , edge , a. c. , & neumann , d. m. 1993 , mnras , 264 , l25 burbidge , e. m. , & burbidge , g. r. 1960 , , 132 , 30 carral , p. , turner , j. l. , & ho , p. t. p. 1990
, , 362 , 434 cecil , g. , bland , j. , & tully , r. b. 1990 , , 355 , 70 cecil , g. , bland - hawthorn , j. , veilleux , s. , & filippenko , a. v. 2001 , , 555 , 338 cecil , g. , bland - hawthorn , j. , & veilleux , s. 2002a , , 576 , 745 cecil , g , et al .
2000 , , 536 , 675 cecil , g. , et al .
2002b , , 568 , 627 cepa , j. , et al .
1990 , in optical and ir telescope instrumentation and detectors , eds .
m. iye and a. f. moorwood , proc .
spie , 4008 , 623 colina , l. 1992 , , 386 , 59 crenshaw , d. m. , & kraemer , s. b. 2000 , , 532 , l101 dahlem , m. , ehle , m. , jansen , f. , heckman , t. m. , weaver , k. a. , strickland , d. k. 2003 , , 403 , 547 dahlem , m. , lazendic , j. s. , haynes , r. f. , ehle , m. , lisenfeld , u. 2001 , , 374 , 42 dahlem , m. , petr , m. g. , lehnert , m. d. , heckman , t. m. , ehle , m. 1997 , , 320 , 731 de vaucouleurs , g. , de vaucouleurs , a. , corwin , h. g. jr . , & buta , r. j. , paturel , g. , & fouqu , p. 1991
, third reference catalogue of bright galaxies ( new york , springer - verlag ) devine , d. , & bally , j. 1999 , , 510 , 197 dopita , m. a. , groves , b. a. , sutherland , r. s , binette , l. , & cecil , g. 2002 , , 572 , 753 dopita , m. a. , & sutherland , r. s. 1995 , , 455 , 468 edmunds , m. g. , taylor , k. , & turtle , a. j. 1988 , , 234 , 155 elmouttie , m. , haynes , r. f. , jones , k. l. , sadler , e. m. , & ehle , m. 1998a , , 297 , 1202 elmouttie , m. , et al .
1998b , , 297 , 49 fabian , a. c. , et al .
2000 , mnras , 318 , l65 fabian , a. c. 2001 , mnras , 321 , l20 falcke , h. , wilson , a. s. , & simpson , c. 1998 , , 502 , 199 ferguson , a. , van der hulst , t. , & van gorkom , j. 2001 , aao newsletter , 96 , 4 ferland , g. j. , & netzer , h. 1983 , , 264 , 105 filippenko , a. v. , & halpern , j. p. 1984
, , 285 , 458 franx , m. , & illingworth , g. 1990 , , 359 , l41 freeman , k. c. , et al .
1977 , , 55 , 445 fried , j. w. , & schulz , h. 1983 , , 118 , 166 fukugita , m. , hogan , c. j. , & peebles , p. j. e. 1998 , , 503 , 518 galletta , g. , & recillas - cruz , e. 1982 , , 112 , 361 gallimore , j. , et al .
1996 , , 464 , 198 ganguly , r. , charlton , j. c. , & eracleous , m. 2001 , , 556 , l7 gerhard , o. , arnaboldi , m. , freeman , k. c. , & okamura , s. 2002 , , 580 , l121 glazebrook , k. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 2001 , , 113 , 197 hameed , s. , blank , d. l. , young , l. m. , & devereux , n. 2001 , , 546 , l97 heckman , t. m. , armus , l. , & miley , g. k. 1987 , , 93 , 276 . 1990 , , 74 , 833 heckman , t. m. , & leitherer , c. 1997 , , 114 , 69 heckman , t. m. , et al .
2001 , , 554 , 1021 heinz , s. , choi , y .- y . , reynolds , c. s. , & begelman , m. c. 2002 , , 569 , l79 helfer , t. t. , & blitz , l. 1995 , , 450 , 90 hjelm , m. , & lindblad , p. o. 1996 , , 305 , 727 hummel , e. , & saikia , d. j. 1991 , , 249 , 43 hunter , d. a. , hawley , w. n. , & gallagher , j. s. iii 1993 , , 106 , 1797 irwin , j. a. , english , j. , & sorathia , b. 1999 , , 117 , 2102 iwasawa , k. , & comastri , a. 1998 , , 297 , 1219 iwasawa , k. , wilson , a. s. , fabian , a. c. , & young , a. j. 2003 , , submitted jenkins , a. , et al .
1998 , , 499 , 20 jrster , s. , lindblad , p. o. , & boksenberg , a. 1984 , , 140 , 288 jones , d. h. , shopbell , p. l. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 2002 , , 329 , 759 kaneko , n. , et al .
1992 , aj , 103 , 422 keel , w. c. 1990 , , 100 , 356 kim , d .- c . , sanders , d. b. , veilleux , s. , mazzarella , j. m. , & soifer , b. t. 1995 , , 98 , 129 kinkhabwala , a. , et al .
2002 , , 575 , 732 kolaczyk , e. d. , & dixon , d. d. 2000 , , 534 , 490 komossa , st .
2001 , , 367 , 801 komossa , st . , schulz , h. , & greiner , j. 1998 , , 334 , 110 komossa , st . , et al .
2003 , , 582 , l15 kraemer , s. b. , ruiz , j. r. , & crenshaw , d. m. 1998 , , 508 , 232 kristen , h. , jrsater , s. , lindblad , p. o. , & boksenberg , a. 1997 , , 328 , 483 kukula , m. j. , pedlar , a. , baum , s. a. , & odea , c. p. 1995 , , 276 , 1262 lanzetta , k. m. , bowen , d. v. , tytler , d. , & webb , j. k. 1995 , , 442 , 538 larson , r. b. , & dinerstein , h. l. 1975 , , 87 , 911 lehnert , m. d. , & heckman , t. m. 1995 , , 97 , 89 . 1996 , , 462 , 651 lehnert , m. d. , heckman , t. m. , & weaver , k. a. 1999 , , 523 , 575 lira , p. , ward , m. j. , zezas , a. , & murray , s. s. 2002 , , 333 , 709 macchetto , f. , capetti , a. , sparks , w. b. , axon , d. j. , & boksenberg , a. 1994 , , 435 , l15 maiolino , r. , krabbe , a. , thatte , n. , & genzel , r. 1998 , , 493 , 650 marconi , a. , moorwood , a. f. m. , origlia , l. , & oliva , e. 1994 , messenger , 78 , 20 marlowe , a. t. , heckman , t. m. , wyse , r. f. g. , & schommer , r. 1995 , , 438 , 285 mcnamara , b. r. , et al .
2000 , apj , 534 , l135 melnick , j. , moles , m. , & terlevich , r. 1985 , , 149 , l24 meurer , g. r. , et al . 1999 ,
baas , 194 , 501 meurer , g. r. , freeman , k. c. , dopita , m. c. , & cacciari , c. 1992 , , 103 , 60 meurer , g. r. , et al .
1995 , , 110 , 2665 miller , j. s. , & antonucci , r. r. j. 1983 , , 271 , l7 miller , j. s. , goodrich , r. w. , & mathews , w. g. 1991 , , 378 , 47 miller , s. t. , & veilleux , s. 2003a , apjs , 148 , 000 . 2003b , apj , 592 , 000 monier , e. m. , mathur , s. , wilkes , b. , & elvis , m. 2001 , , 559 , 675 morganti , r. , tsvetanov , z. i. , gallimore , j. , & allen , m. g. 1999 , a&as , 137 , 457 mulchaey , j. s. , wilson , a. s. , & tsvetanov , z. 1996 , , 467 , 197 nrgaard - nielsen , h. u. , hansen , l. , jrgesen , h. e. , & christensen , p. r. 1986 , , 169 , 49 norman , c. a. , bowen , d. v. , heckman , t. m. , blades , c. , & danly , l. 1996 , , 472 , 73 petitjean , p. , & durret , f. 1993 , , 277 , 365 phillips , m. m. 1979 , , 227 , l121 phillips , m. m. , & malin , d. f. 1982 , , 199 , 205 phillips , m. m. , turtle , a. j. , edmunds , m. g. , & pagel , b. e. j. 1983 , , 203 , 759 pogge , r. w. 1988a , , 328 , 519 . 1988b , , 332 , 702 putman , m. e. , bland - hawthorn , j. , veilleux , s. , gibson , b. k. , freeman , k. c. , & maloney , p. r. 2003 , , submitted quilis , v. , bower , r. g. , & balogh , m. l. 2001 , mnras , 328 , 1091 rauch , m. 1998 , ara&a , 36 , 267 reynolds , c. j. 1997 , , 286 , 513 ruiz , m. , et al .
2000 , , 316 , 49 sahu , m. s. , & blades , j. c. 1997 , , 484 , l125 sambruna , r. m. , et al . 2001a , , 546 , l9 .
2001b , , 546 , l13 sandqvist , aa . , jrster , s. , & lindblad , p. o. 1995 , , 295 , 585 schulz , h. , komossa , s. , berghfer , t. , & boer , b. 1998 , , 330 , 823 scoville , n. z. , et al .
2000 , , 119 , 991 scoville , n. z. , matthews , k. , carico , d. p. , & sanders , d. b. 1988 , , 327 , l61 seyfert , c. k. 1943 , , 97 , 28 shapley , a. e. , steidel , c. c. , pettini , m. , & adelberger , k. l. 2003 , , 588 , 65 shopbell , p. l. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 1998 , , 493 , 129 shopbell , p. l. , veilleux , s. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 1999 , , 524 , l83 smith , d. a. , & wilson , a. s. 2001 , , 557 , 180 sofue , y. 1997 , pasj , 49 , 17 sofue , y. , et al . 1999 ,
apj , 523 , 136 soifer , b. t. , boehme , l. , neugebauer , g. , & sanders , d. b. 1989 , , 98 , 766 sokolowski , j. , bland - hawthorn , j. , & cecil , g. 1991 , , 375 , 583 steidel , c. c. , et al .
2002 , apj , 576 , 653 steidel , c. c. , pettini , m. , adelberger , k. l. 2001 , apj , 546 , 665 stevens , i. r. , read , a. m. , & bravo - guerrero , j. 2003 , , preprint ( astro - ph/0306334 ) stone , j. l. , wilson , a. s. , & ward , m. j. 1988 , , 330 , 105 storchi - bergmann , t. , & bonatto , c. 1991 , , 250 , 138 storchi - bergmann , t. , rodriguez - ardila , a. , schmitt , h. r. , wilson , a. s. , & baldwin , j. a. 1996 , , 472 , 83 strickland , d. k. , heckman , t. m. , weaver , k. a. , & dahlem , m. 2000 , , 120 , 2965 tacconi , l. , et al .
1999 , , 524 , 732 tadhunter , c. , villar - martin , m. , morganti , r. , bland - hawthorn , j. , & axon , d. 2000 , , 314 , 849 tezca , m. , et al .
2000 , , 537 , 178 tully , r. b. 1988 , nearby galaxies catalog , cambridge university press thronson , h. a. , et al .
1989 , , 343 , 158 vader , p. 1986
, , 305 , 669 veilleux , s. 2002 , in extragalactic gas at low redshift , asp conf .
proc . vol .
254 , eds .
j. s. mulchaey and j. stocke , san francisco : astronomical society of the pacific , 313 veilleux , s. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 1997 , , 479 , l105 veilleux , s. , bland - hawthorn , j. , cecil , g. , tully , r. b. , & miller , s. t. 1999 , , 520 , 111 veilleux , s. , cecil , g. , bland - hawthorn , j. , tully , r. b. , filippenko , a. v. , & sarger , w. l. w. 1994 , , 433 , 48 veilleux , s. , kim , d .-
c . , sanders , d. b. , mazzarella , j. m. , & soifer , b. t. 1995 , , 98 , 171 veilleux , s. , & osterbrock , d. e. 1987 , , 63 , 295 veilleux , s. , & rupke , d. s. 2002 , , 565 , l63 vignati , p. , et al . 1999 , , 349 ,
l57 vollmer , b. , & huchtmeier , w. 2003 , , in press ( astro - ph/0303531 ) walker , m. 1968 , , 151 , 71 weymann , r. j. , vogel , s. n. , veilleux , s. , epps , h. w. 2001 , apj , 561 , 559 wilson , a. s. , et al .
2000 , , 120 , 1325 wilson , a. s. , & tzvetanov 1994 , , 107 , 1227 wilson , a. s. , & ulvestad , j. 1987 , , 319 , 105 yoshida , m. , et al .
2002 , , 567 , 118 young , a. j. , wilson , a. s. , & shopbell , p. l. 2001 , , 556 , 6 llll ngc 1068 & 0.0038 & agn & ionization cone detected over @xmath2 20-kpc scale + ngc 1365 & 0.0055 & agn & ionization cone detected over @xmath2 12-kpc scale + ngc 1482 & 0.0064 & starburst & galactic wind detected over @xmath2 20-kpc scale + ngc 1705 & 0.0021 & starburst & featureless [ n ii]/h@xmath4 map of @xmath2 3-kpc wind region + ngc 4388 & 0.0084 & agn & complex of filaments detected over @xmath2 35-kpc scale + ngc 6240 & 0.0245 & agn / starburst & complex of loops and filaments extending @xmath2 70 @xmath19 80 kpc + ngc 7213 & 0.0060 & agn & ionized tidal filament at @xmath2 19 kpc from nucleus + circinus galaxy & 0.0015 & agn / starburst & highly ionized filaments out to @xmath2 1.2 kpc from nucleus + eso 484-g036 & 0.0162 & starburst & cross - like [ n ii]/h@xmath4 map indicative of wind + mr 2251178 & 0.0640 & qso & spiral - like nebula detected over @xmath2 200-kpc scale + clccccc 1i & 1998 aug 30 , sep 03 & aat & rttf & mitll2 & 14 , 47 & 13 + 2i & 1999 mar 04 - 06 & wht & rttf & tek2 & 14 & 06 - 18 + 3i & 2000 feb 05 - 07 , 14 - 16 & aat & bttf & mitll3 & 22 , 99 & 15 + 4i & 1999 nov 28 & aat & rttf & mitll2 & 43 & 10 - 15 + 5i & 2000 feb 17 - 20 & aat & bttf & mitll3 & 0 - 6 & 13 - 28 + 6i & 2000 jul 28 & aat & rttf & mitll2a & 91 & 13 - 16 + 7i & 2000 dec 15 - 17 & aat & bttf & mitll2a & 24 - 45 & 15 - 25 + 8i & 2002 may 16 - 20 & aat & bttf & eev2 & 41 - 83 & 15 - 40 + & + 1s & 2001 sep 18 - 20 & mssso 2.3 m & dbs & site & 86 - 98 & 14 - 15 + 2s & 2001 dec 19 & aat & rgo 25cm&eev2 & 79 & 17 + lccccccclccl ngc 1068 & 2i & h@xmath4&i0/10 & 3600 & 6588 & 6588 & ( i0/i1 ) & 11.0 & n & n & 3.0 + & 3i & [ oiii ] & b4/0 & 3663 & 5028 & 5026 & 4908 & 17.1 & y & n & 15 + ngc 1365 & 7i & [ oiii ] & b4/0 & 2@xmath19976 & 5034 & 5034 & 4994,5075 & 20.5 & y & y & 69 + & & h@xmath4&r0/15 & 1@xmath19976 & 6600 & 6599 & 6554,6647 & 13.9 & y & y & 8.5 + & & [ nii ] & r0/15 & 1@xmath19976 & 6620 & 6619 & 6555,6647 & 15.7 & y & y & 16 + ngc 1482 & 7i & h@xmath4&r0/15 & 2@xmath19976 & 6606 & 6605 & 6561,6653 & 14.0 & y & y & 5.3 + & & [ nii ] & r0/15 & 2@xmath19976 & 6627 & 6626 & 6562,6664 & 13.9 & y & y & 4.5 + ngc 1705 & 7i & h@xmath4&r0/15 & 3@xmath19976 & 6578 & 6577 & 6533,6625 & 16.8 & y & y & 8.3 + & & [ nii ] & r0/15 & 2@xmath19976 & 6597 & 6598 & 6533,6625 & 16.7 & y & y & 8.4 + ngc 4388 & 8i & h@xmath4&r0/15 & 4@xmath19976 & 6605 & 6618 & 6551,6652 & 15.5 & y & y & 5.2 + & & [ nii ] & r0/15 & 6@xmath19976 & 6628 & 6639 & 6554,6655 & 17.1 & y & y & 4.6 + ngc 6240 & 8i & h@xmath4&r0/0 & 6@xmath19976 & 6724 & 6723 & 6670,6772 & 15.5 & y & y & 4.0 + & & [ nii ] & r0/0 & 4@xmath19976 & 6743 & 6745 & 6669,6770 & 16.6 & y & y & 5.7 + ngc 7213 & 4i & h@xmath4/[nii]&r0/0 & 6@xmath19611 & & 6602,6623&&27.1 & y & n & 12 + & 6i & h@xmath4/[nii]&r0/0 & 6@xmath19300 & & 6602,6623&&8.3 & n & n & 10 + circinus galaxy & 5i & [ oiii ] & b4/0 & 6@xmath19976 & 5017 & 5014 & 4987,5048 & 19.5 & y & y & 39 + eso 484-g036 & 7i & h@xmath4&r0/0 & 1@xmath19976 & 6670 & 6669 & 6624,6718 & 15.9 & y & y & 12 + & & [ nii ] & r0/0 & 1@xmath19976 & 6692 & 6690 & 6624,6719 & 15.9 & y & y & 11 + mr 2251178&1i & h@xmath4&r1/16 & 2@xmath19600 & 6983 & 6983 & ( ldss
i ) & 12.4 & n & n & 2.5 + & & h@xmath4&r1/16 & 2@xmath19600 & 6986 & 6983 & ( ldss
i ) & 12.4 & n & n & 2.5 + lcrlrl ngc 1068 & 1s & 8@xmath191800 & 2@xmath1967 & 6 & along filament in ne ionization cone + & 2s & 3@xmath191800 & 2@xmath19100&3 & along filament in ne ionization cone + ngc 1482 & 1s & 15@xmath191200&2@xmath1967 & 103 & 15 north - 16 south of disk + & & 1@xmath19 600 & 2@xmath1967 & 103 & 5 south of disk + & & 1@xmath19 900 & 2@xmath1967 & 103 & nucleus + & & 2@xmath19 300 & 2@xmath1967 & 103 & nucleus + & & 6@xmath191200 & 2@xmath1967 & 13 & nucleus + & 2s & 1@xmath191800 & 2@xmath19100&13 & nucleus + & & 1@xmath191800 & 2@xmath19100&13 & 5 west of nucleus + ngc 7213 & 1s & 6@xmath191800 & 2@xmath1967 & 110 & along southern filament + | we report the results from a pilot study of 10 nearby starburst and active galaxies conducted with the taurus tunable filter ( ttf ) on the anglo - australian and william herschel telescopes .
the main purpose of this imaging survey is to search for warm emission - line gas on the outskirts ( galactocentric distances @xmath0 @xmath1 10 kpc ) of galaxies to provide direct constraints on the size and geometry of the `` zone of influence '' of these galaxies on their environment .
gaseous complexes or filaments larger than @xmath2 20 kpc are discovered or confirmed in six of the galaxies in the sample ( ngc 1068 , ngc 1482 , ngc 4388 , ngc 6240 , ngc 7213 , and mr 2251178 ) .
slightly smaller structures are seen for the first time in the ionization cones and galactic winds of ngc 1365 , ngc 1705 , circinus galaxy , and eso484-g036 .
the ttf data are combined with new optical long - slit spectra as well as published and archived radio and x - ray maps to constrain the origin and source of ionization of these filaments .
a broad range of phenomena is observed , including large - scale ionization cones and galactic winds , tidal interaction , and ram - pressure stripping by an intracluster medium .
the source of ionization in this gas ranges from shock ionization to photoionization by the central agn or in - situ hot young stars .
the sample is too small to draw statistically meaningful conclusions about the extent and properties of the warm ionized medium on large scale and its relevance to galaxy formation and evolution .
the next generation of tunable filters on large telescopes promises to improve the sensitivity to faint emission - line fluxes at least tenfold and allow systematic surveys of a large sample of emission - line galaxies . |
one of the earliest numerical indications of the possibility that an on - site electron - electron interaction @xmath1 might play a role in superconducting materials was the observation of a negative binding energy " in exact diagonalization studies of the hubbard hamiltonian on 2x2 clusters . in this geometry , the ground state energy of two holes doped together into a half - filled system was shown to be lower than if the two holes were on separate clusters : @xmath8 here @xmath9 is the ground state energy of @xmath10 holes .
the observation that the @xmath11 and @xmath12 ground states have @xmath13- and @xmath14-wave symmetry , respectively , and hence are connected by a @xmath14-wave pair creation operator , suggested the possible relevance of models involving such 2x2 clusters with cuprate superconductors.@xcite pair binding was also studied on larger hubbard clusters,@xcite and on other geometries , e.g. , on one dimensional chains of varying length,@xcite with three electronic bands,@xcite models with intersite interactions,@xcite and the strong coupling @xmath0-@xmath15 limit.@xcite following these small cluster studies , a considerable amount of analytic and numeric attention has been focused on the plaquette hubbard model " which consists of a periodic array of 2x2 plaquettes with hopping @xmath0 and repulsion @xmath1 connected by a weaker hybridization @xmath16 .
it was suggested that the plaquettes act as centers of attraction , which then drive superconductivity in the extended lattice .
this picture provides a ` local ' counterpart to theories of pairing which focus qualitatively on the exchange of magnetic fluctuations .
perhaps unsurprisingly , the presence of inhomogeneous hoppings introduces phases to the mott insulator , antiferromagnetic , and @xmath14-wave superconductor typically discussed in the uniform @xmath17 case .
specifically , the quantum numbers and symmetries of the 2x2 plaquette can evolve into a wide variety of ground states when @xmath16 is made nonzero.@xcite an additional diagonal hopping can also change the ground state of the 2x2 plaquette building block@xcite and induce types of crystalline insulators .
the effects of both chemical potential and hopping disorder on pair binding have been examined,@xcite and were shown to be less damaging to superconductivity when there is a plaquette structure compared to the uniform case .
a key conceptual question concerns the existence of an ` optimal inhomogeneity'.@xcite as pointed out by tsai and kivelson,@xcite pairing which exists at very weak @xmath16 is expected to exhibit a critical temperature @xmath18 which increases as @xmath16 grows .
if it were the case that @xmath18 is small or zero in the homogeneous model @xmath19 , this necessarily implies a maximal @xmath18 at an intermediate value @xmath20 .
early work relevant to this issue looked at pair binding energies when two plaquettes were linked in different geometries @xcite . for the cubic ( fully connected ) configuration ,
a maximum binding was found for @xmath21 at @xmath3 and for @xmath22 when @xmath23 .
exact diagonalization of 4x4 clusters@xcite indicated that the overall maximum occurs at @xmath22 and @xmath24 .
additional evidence for an optimal inhomogeneity in the plaquette hubbard model is provided by a contractor - renormalization ( core ) study@xcite where the pair binding energy was found to be maximized in the range @xmath25 and @xmath26 . in related work
, the density matrix renormalization group method has been used to study a collection of 2x2 plaquettes connected to form a two leg ladder.@xcite it was found that , close to half - filling , @xmath27 and @xmath28 gives the optimal pair binding energy .
although there can be no finite temperature transition in such one - dimensional ladder geometries , an interchain mean field theory suggests that the critical temperature again exhibits an ` optimal degree of inhomogeneity ' with a maximum occurring at @xmath29 .
there have also been several methods which challenge the idea of an optimal inhomogeneity at intermediate @xmath5 .
the central result of a dynamical cluster approximation ( dca ) analysis@xcite was that the critical temperature @xmath18 for @xmath14-wave pairing is maximal for @xmath30 for interaction strengths @xmath1 of the order of the bandwidth and lattice fillings @xmath31 .
that is , inhomogeneity monotonically suppresses superconductivity .
the qualitative physical picture behind this conclusion was that inhomogeneities reduce the magnetic contributions to the pairing interaction.@xcite cellular dynamical mean field theory ( cdmft ) is another approach with which the plaquette hubbard hamiltonian has been analyzed.@xcite at weak coupling , inhomogeneity reduces the order parameter for small to intermediate doping , but enhances it at larger doping . for strong coupling
, inhomogeneity suppresses pairing for all doping .
overall , the cdmft results seem generally consistent with those of the dca , namely that for inhomogeneity in the nearest - neighbor hopping such as is present in the plaquette hubbard model , the superconducting order parameter does not exceed that of the uniform system .
the contrasting results between the dmrg interchain mft , core , and exact diagonalization treatments , and other cases in which optimal inhomogeneity occurs , on one hand , and the dca , cdmft methods on the other , provide the motivation for the work described in this manuscript - a study of the plaquette hubbard hamiltonian@xcite using the determinant quantum monte carlo method.@xcite after presenting our results , we will discuss some of the possible origins of the range of conclusions concerning the underlying physics of this model .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : in sec .
ii we write down the plaquette hubbard hamiltonian and discuss the measurements we use to monitor @xmath14-wave pairing .
we also provide a brief summary of the dqmc algorithm and its limitations . in sec .
iii we discuss our results at half - filling and in the doped case .
our central conclusion is that an optimal degree of inhomogeneity does occur in the plaquette hubbard model , although the largest pairing signal appears to occur at @xmath4 for @xmath3 , a bit less than that reported in other work .
this optimal @xmath5 increases with @xmath6 at half - filling .
the sign problem restricts us to higher temperatures than those accessible in the dca@xcite and cdmft@xcite approaches .
section iv discusses the effect on pairing of another form of inhomogeneity in which the site energies are varied periodically across the lattice , and sec .
v concerns the sign problem .
the paper concludes with a summary of our findings .
the plaquette hubbard hamiltonian is @xmath32 here @xmath33 are the usual creation(destruction ) operators for fermions of spin @xmath34 on lattice site @xmath35 .
the designations @xmath36 and @xmath37 in the kinetic energy terms convey the fact that hopping @xmath0 between near neighbor sites @xmath38 on the same plaquette is different from the hopping @xmath16 for sites @xmath38 on different plaquettes . this geometry is illustrated in fig . [
fig : geometries ] . we have written the interaction term in particle - hole symmetric form , so that @xmath39 corresponds to half - filling .
( note that the hubbard hamiltonian with near - neighbor hopping on a bipartite lattice is particle - hole symmetric for _ any _ pattern of intersite hoppings @xmath40 , and hence , in particular , for the case considered here . )
although we have referred to @xmath16 as the ` interplaquette hopping ' , so that @xmath41 is the limit of independent 2x2 clusters , we note that setting @xmath42 also results in a collection of decoupled 2x2 @xmath16 clusters . more generally , the hamiltonian is invariant@xcite under the interchange of @xmath0 and @xmath16 . as a consequence , there is no need to explore the physics of @xmath43 .
the hamiltonian is also invariant when the values of @xmath0 and @xmath16 are interchanged only on the horizontal links , or only on the vertical links .
our numerical approach preserves all these symmetries . in the determinant quantum monte carlo ( dqmc ) algorithm @xcite , the expectation values of observables @xmath44 for fermonic hamiltonians like eq .
[ eq : plaquetteham ] are evaluated by discretizing the inverse temperature @xmath45 and rewriting the partition function as a path integral .
replacing the exponential of the interaction terms in the hamiltonian by a coupling of quadratic fermion operators to a hubbard - stratonovich field allows the fermions to be integrated out analytically , leaving a product of fermion determinants ( one determinant for each spin species ) as the weight to sample the hubbard - stratonovich field .
each operator @xmath46 can then be measured by accumulating appropriate combinations of green s functions , the inverse of the matrices whose determinants form the boltzmann weight . as described further below , the flexibility to alter the order in which the monte carlo average is performed and
in which the green s functions are multiplied can be used to control which many body effects are included in the expectation value , and hence to isolate the pairing vertex .
the discretization of @xmath45 introduces a ` trotter error ' .
we have used @xmath47 in the work reported here@xcite . in practice , unless one examines a local quantity like the energy or double occupancy which can be obtained to very high accuracy , the systematic trotter errors with this choice of @xmath48 are less than the statistical errors in the measurements we present .
the central limitation to the dqmc algorithm is the sign problem@xcite which arises when the product of determinants becomes negative .
this will restrict the temperatures accessible in the study reported here , and , as a consequence , temper our ability to make conclusive statements about the effect of inhomogeneity in the case when the system is doped . at
half - filling , because spatial variations in the hopping do not destroy particle - hole symmetry , there is no sign problem and dqmc can better access the ground state for any @xmath5 . off half - filling data for the average sign @xmath49 are given in fig .
[ fig : signrho0774rho0875l8 ] .
@xmath49 is relatively weakly dependent on @xmath5 .
the lowest accessible temperature is around @xmath50 for the entire range @xmath20 , although simulations become somewhat more difficult as @xmath5 decreases .
it is possible to get accurate data for certain quantities , like the density , for quite small values of @xmath49 .
however for more complex quantities like magnetic and pair correlations at large distances , if reasonable accuracy ( statistical error bars less than 10% ) is desired , then @xmath51 is needed .
@xmath49 is roughly the same for the two densities @xmath52 and @xmath53 shown . for @xmath54 , however , @xmath49 is better behaved ( not shown ) and reliable averages can be obtained for temperatures as low as @xmath55 , for several values of @xmath5 .
the spectrum of the @xmath56 hopping hamiltonian for an isolated 2x2 plaquette consists of four energy levels , @xmath57 .
as @xmath16 is turned on , these discrete levels broaden until they finally merge into the 2d square lattice density of states @xmath58 at @xmath19 . this evolution
is shown in fig .
[ fig : noninteractingdos ] . at half - filling , where @xmath59 , and for small dopings , @xmath60 is enhanced by inhomogeneity . in principle
this might lead to a greater tendency to ordered phases , including superconducting ones , although the possibly competing effect of inhomogeneity on the interaction vertex must also be considered.@xcite for large inhomogeneity ( @xmath61 ) the discrete 2x2 eigen - levels are not sufficiently broadened by @xmath16 to coalesce into a single band , and the noninteracting system is a band insulator at @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
figure [ fig : rhovsmutp02l8 ] shows qmc data for @xmath64 at interaction strengths @xmath65 and @xmath3 and weakly coupled plaquettes @xmath66 .
there is a band gap evident at @xmath62 ( and also , due to particle - hole symmetry at @xmath63 , not shown ) .
non - zero @xmath6 is also seen to cause an insulating gap to develop at half - filling , @xmath67 .
this is a dramatic change from the noninteracting limit , since it represents the suppression of the large peak in @xmath58 at @xmath68 in fig .
[ fig : noninteractingdos ] .
the development of this gap , even though @xmath6 is much less than the bandwidth , is associated with the onset of long range antiferromagnetic order , as we shall see in the next section .
notice that reasonable data can be obtained for the density even at @xmath69 .
this , however , is not true for more complicated spin and pair correlations . the equal time spin correlation function and magnetic structure factor are given by , @xmath70 with an analogous expression for @xmath71 .
in the homogeneous system it is known that at @xmath72 and at half - filling the 2d hubbard hamiltonian possesses long range magnetic order.@xcite that is , the spin - spin correlations @xmath73 in real space approach a nonzero value asymptotically as @xmath74 . on finite sized lattices ,
this is established by an appropriate scaling of the structure factor with lattice size .
@xcite as with magnetic order , a tendency to @xmath14-wave pairing can be examined via the asymptotic behavior of equal time correlations , @xmath75 however , a more sensitive measurement , and one which makes better contact with previous dca work,@xcite is the @xmath14-wave pairing susceptibility , @xmath76 @xmath77 is a preferred diagnostic of superconductivity , especially if the sign problem precludes going to low temperatures , because it allows for a comparison between the fully dressed susceptibility and the uncorrelated susceptibility @xmath78 , and hence an indication of pairing even when only short range order is present.@xcite the technical distinction between @xmath77 and @xmath78 in a dqmc simulation is that when the expectation value of the four fermion terms in eq .
[ eq : pairsusc ] is evaluated , the green s functions obtained by the wick contractions are first multiplied together and then averaged to obtain @xmath77 , whereas for @xmath78 , the green s functions are first averaged and then multiplied . in @xmath78 the effect of the interactions is only to dress the individual single particle propagators , while @xmath77 includes all interaction effects@xcite .
this distinction allows us to extract the interaction vertex @xmath79 from @xmath77 and @xmath78 : @xmath80 if @xmath81 , the associated pairing interaction is attractive .
more precisely , eq . [ vertex ] can be re - written as , @xmath82 so that @xmath83 signals a superconducting instability .
our central interest is in the doped lattice , where antiferromagnetism might potentially give way to @xmath14-wave pairing .
however , we begin by briefly showing results at @xmath67 , which , as we shall see , are not qualitatively so dissimilar to @xmath84 . due to the spatial inhomogeneity , spin and pair correlations
are not the same on all pairs of near - neighbor ( nn ) links . in fig .
[ fig : spinandcharge ] ( a ) we show the nn spin correlations @xmath85 along an intraplaquette ( @xmath0 ) bond and along an interplaquette ( @xmath16 ) bond .
we also show the next - near neighbor ( nnn ) correlation @xmath86 across the internal diagonal of a plaquette .
the nn values are negative , indicating ( short - range ) antiferromagnetic order .
as expected , the interplaquette value vanishes at @xmath87 and the two nn correlations become degenerate when @xmath30 .
the nnn correlations are positive , in agreement with antiferromagnetic behavior .
figure [ fig : spinandcharge](b ) shows the analogous short - range @xmath14-wave pair correlations @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
the value of @xmath88 along an interplaquette ( @xmath16 ) bond does not vanish at @xmath87 owing to the finite spatial size of the @xmath14-wave operator ( eq . [ eq : pairsusc ] ) .
short - ranged pairing correlations change very smoothly with @xmath5 .
we will therefore turn to the more sensitive magnetic and pairing structure factors and susceptibilities .
the left panel of fig .
[ fig : u4mu0 ] shows the product @xmath90 of the pairing vertex and the uncorrelated susceptibility .
@xmath90 becomes closest to @xmath91 , where a superconducting instability would occur , at an intermediate value @xmath92 .
the tendency to pairing becomes greater as @xmath93 is increased ( lower temperature ) .
finite size effects are small , with data for 8x8 and 16x16 lattices largely coinciding .
[ fig : u4mu0 ] ( b ) shows the antiferromagnetic structure factor @xmath94 .
we emphasize that @xmath67 is privileged from the point of the view of the dqmc algorithm , since there is no sign problem and hence very low temperatures can be simulated .
the large values of @xmath95 evident in fig .
[ fig : u4mu0](b ) arise from the development of longer ranged correlations at the low temperatures accessible at @xmath67 , so that the spatial sum in eq .
[ eq : saf ] receives contributions from all lattice separations . in principle ,
@xmath96 , the lattice volume , but there are significant finite size corrections and a careful scaling analysis@xcite is required to establish long range order . nevertheless , the growth in @xmath95 from @xmath97 to @xmath98 in fig .
[ fig : u4mu0](b ) is certainly suggestive .
the sharp onset at @xmath99 is similar to results reported in [ ] , as we shall discuss further below .
@xmath100 appears to have a maximum at intermediate @xmath5 on the 8x8 lattice , an effect which is even more pronounced in the largest size , 16x16 . to understand this result better we show , in fig.[fig : c_spin_real_space_comp ] , the normalized difference of the spin correlations , @xmath101 panel ( a ) has @xmath102 along the ( 1,0 ) direction , and panel ( b ) along the ( 1,1 ) direction . with the exception of the correlation for spins which are first neighbors in different plaquettes , all values of @xmath102
show an increase , @xmath103 .
what this tells us is that the enhancement in @xmath95 comes from an increase in the real - space spin correlations for all separations , and is not simply from an enhancement at short ( or long ) distances .
the fact that @xmath104 is small further informs us that the effect is not just due to a trivial change in the local moment .
we conclude this section by showing half - filled results for different interaction strength @xmath6 . in fig .
[ fig : u8mu0](left panel ) , the evolution with @xmath5 of the product of the @xmath14-wave superconducting vertex and the no - vertex susceptibility , @xmath105 , is given for @xmath23 and several temperatures .
as the temperature is lowered , a clear minimum in @xmath106 indicates an optimal inhomogeneity , at a larger @xmath5 than for @xmath3 . in fig .
[ fig : u8mu0](right panel ) , the antiferromagnetic structure factor is given .
as the temperature decreases , the antiferromagnetic structure factor becomes larger .
similar to the case of @xmath3 , @xmath107 has an onset at @xmath99 .
figure [ fig : beta16mu0 ] shows @xmath108 and @xmath107 for four different @xmath6 values at fixed inverse temperature @xmath109 . in fig .
[ fig : beta16mu0](a ) , an optimal inhomogeneity is present for all @xmath6 , shifting systematically to larger @xmath5 as @xmath6 increases .
we note this trend is generally consistent with what is shown in fig . 4 of ref .
[ ] , fig . 2 of ref .
[ ] , and figs . 2,5 of ref .
the maximum in @xmath110 is most evident at @xmath3 , for this fixed inverse temperature @xmath109 .
comparison of @xmath107 data for 8x8 and 16x16 lattices shows that the structure factor is growing roughly proportional to the volume , as expected in an ordered nel phase .
the magnetic structure factor also increases with @xmath6 as double occupancy is suppressed .
after this brief synopsis of results at @xmath67 , we turn to the case when the filling is incommensurate , the situation of most interest to understanding cuprate superconductivity .
[ fig : spincorrmerged - dopedl8 ] shows the same spin correlations as in fig .
[ fig : spinandcharge](a ) , but for @xmath54 ( a ) , @xmath53 ( b ) and @xmath111 ( c ) .
the nn spin correlations exhibit the expected evolution with density- they are largest at @xmath112 ( fig .
[ fig : spinandcharge](a ) ) , and decrease as we move away from half - filling .
similar to what happens at half - filling , the nnn spin correlation inside a plaquette is positive for @xmath52 , again as expected for antiferromagnetism , but decreases with growing @xmath16 . with decreasing density the behavior for this quantity changes : for @xmath53 , @xmath113 is essentially zero for all @xmath5 . for @xmath54 , however , it is _ negative _ and increases in magnitude as the connection between the plaquettes is reduced .
this later result can be understood when we recall that at this density the system has two fermions in every plaquette on average .
the configuration which minimizes the kinetic energy and the local repulsive interaction is a singlet state with spins residing on nnn neighbors . in this case
the nnn correlation becomes negative .
this effect is enhanced as @xmath5 is smaller .
figure [ fig : c - dpairmerged - dopedl8 ] shows short - range @xmath14-wave pair correlations for the same densities as fig . [ fig : spincorrmerged - dopedl8 ] .
contrary to what is observed for spin correlations , nn and nnn pairing correlations do not decrease with doping .
having described the short range , real space correlations , we now turn to more sensitive magnetic and pairing structure factors and susceptibilities .
the latter especially has an enhanced signal since it is sensitive to the build - up of correlations in the imaginary time direction .
the magnetic structure factor dependence on @xmath5 and @xmath114 for three different dopings on an 8x8 lattice at inverse temperature @xmath115 is shown in fig . [
fig : sqxqybeta5 ] . near
half - filling ( @xmath116 ) @xmath117 is peaked at @xmath118 , indicating the dominance of antiferromagnetic correlations . at @xmath52
the af peak substantially increases as @xmath119 , with a concomitant reduction in @xmath120 at other momenta .
presumably these effects would become larger at lower @xmath121 .
however , @xmath122 is the limit accessible to dqmc owing to the sign problem . for lower densities
, @xmath117 is rather insensitive to @xmath16 .
there is a substantial difference in scale of the antiferromagnetic structure factor : @xmath123 in the doped lattice , whereas at half - filling , @xmath124 ( fig . [ fig : u4mu0 ] ) .
this arises both from the rapid suppression of antiferromagnetic order with doping in the square lattice hubbard model@xcite , and also because of the lower temperatures that can be reached at @xmath67 ( @xmath125 ) compared to @xmath126 ( @xmath127 ) . despite the absence of long range order in the doped model , the short range spin correlations
do grow as @xmath121 is lowered . at @xmath52 the overall evolution with @xmath5 of the antiferromagnetic structure factor @xmath128 in fig .
[ fig : sqxqybeta5 ] is consistent with that found in [ ] .
that is , @xmath128 increases monotonically with @xmath5 and is maximal at @xmath30 .
however , the two results appear to differ in the finer details . specifically , the core study indicates that the staggered magnetic order parameter is roughly constant for @xmath129 , and then increases rather abruptly at @xmath130 this is mirrored in an increase in the number of magnons , a phenomenon to which the appearance of a maximum in the pair binding energy is attributed .
in contrast , our dqmc data appear to indicate a more immediate rise in @xmath128 as @xmath16 grows from zero .
a possible origin of the difference is that our work is at finite temperature , whereas the core study is in the ground state .
indeed , at half - filling it is known that @xmath128 does not reach its low @xmath121 values until @xmath131 , temperatures which are not accessible when the system is doped , due to the sign problem .
that finite temperature is a likely explanation of the difference and is substantiated by examining the @xmath67 data in fig .
[ fig : u4mu0 ] .
interestingly , the rapid rise in @xmath95 occurs at the same @xmath132 obtained from core . note that in [ ] the number of holes is @xmath133 on a 6x6 cluster , corresponding to @xmath134 .
the latter value is comparable to that of fig .
[ fig : sqxqybeta5](c ) .
figure [ fig : gammapdnvvstbeta5u48x8 ] extends the pairing results of fig . [ fig : u4mu0](a ) to the doped case .
although the sign problem currently prevents simulations at low @xmath121 , all densities shown exhibit a maximum in @xmath135 away from the uniform limit @xmath30 . for @xmath53 and @xmath52 , the sign is fairly small for @xmath115 and small @xmath5 ( see fig .
we have thus done a very large number of runs ( up to 100 runs with 50000 sweeps each ) , to decrease the error bars and push the limits of the qmc method . for @xmath62 , where the sign is higher
, we were able to reach @xmath136 ( open symbols ) .
similar to what is seen in fig .
[ fig : u4mu0](a ) , for @xmath67 , the signal for optimal inhomogeneity indeed increases as @xmath121 is lowered .
it is reasonable to assume that the same trend will hold for @xmath53 and @xmath52 .
almost all of the work presented in this paper is for @xmath3 .
the sign problem in dqmc becomes dramatically worse as @xmath6 increases . in order to study the @xmath6 evolution and
still reach reasonably low temperatures , we can reduce the density to @xmath62 which restores the sign even though @xmath137 .
even so , it is not possible for us to assess accurately claims@xcite that @xmath138 is optimal for pairing
. the choice @xmath62 does however improve the average sign enough to see the @xmath5 evolution of @xmath14-wave pairing , which we established to have an optimal inhomogeneity at half - filling .
[ fig : gammapdnvvst ] ( a ) shows @xmath108 versus @xmath139 for different @xmath5 . as at @xmath67 , there is evidence for an optimal inhomogeneity : in the uniform case @xmath108 versus @xmath139 is almost temperature independent and is also small , @xmath140 .
as inhomogeneity is turned on to @xmath141 , @xmath135 increases by almost an order of magnitude ( although it is still far from the @xmath142 criterion for a transition ) .
further increase of the inhomogeneity to @xmath61 decreases @xmath135 .
the same optimum @xmath141 can be seen for @xmath53 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : gammapdnvvst](b ) .
early in dqmc studies of the homogeneous square lattice it was established that @xmath14-wave pairing is the dominant superconducting instability .
this conclusion is not altered by @xmath143 .
[ fig : gammapsandpsx ] shows the same quantities as fig .
[ fig : gammapdnvvstbeta5u48x8 ] for @xmath13 and _ extended _ @xmath13 ( @xmath144 ) symmetry channels .
the correlations are obtained in a similar fashion as in the @xmath14-wave case but the associated phases in eq .
[ eq : pairsusc ] are positive . for the @xmath13 symmetry
the pairs are created and destroyed locally @xmath145 , whereas in the extended one they all enter with the same phase sign @xmath146 . while @xmath13-wave symmetry produces only repulsive interactions , some parameters in the @xmath144-wave case exhibit attraction .
nonetheless it is smaller in magnitude than @xmath14-wave symmetry .
the nature of pairing in models with other sorts of inhomogeneities , e.g. built of two site dimers rather than four site clusters,@xcite modulated by different site potentials@xcite or consisting of lines of different chemical potentials , alternating between half - filled antiferromagnetic stripes and doped stripes has also been explored.@xcite in this section we examine the effects on pairing of an inhomogeneity pattern in which the local energies on a regular pattern of sites is raised by an amount @xmath147 .
that is , we add a term @xmath148 to the hubbard hamiltonian eq . [ eq : plaquetteham ] with @xmath19 .
the collection @xmath149 consists of a fraction @xmath150 of the lattice sites .
this geometry is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : checker ] , for @xmath151 ( a ) and @xmath152 ( b ) , the two cases analyzed here .
one motivation for considering this particular pattern with @xmath151 is that in the limit @xmath153 the lattice maps onto the ` three band ' hamiltonian sometimes used to model the cuo@xmath7 plane of the cuprate superconductors ( with , however , the choice of equal copper @xmath14 and oxygen @xmath154 energies . ) the red sites without any blue neighbors are like the cu atoms , while the red sites with two blue neighbors represent the o sites which link the cu .
thus this model makes partial contact with earlier studies of binding on cuo@xmath7 clusters in the limit @xmath155.@xcite another point of contact of this model is to other inhomogeneity patterns which share an @xmath151 proportion of sites with raised on - site energy , for example [ ] in which a pattern of stripes was shown to enhance @xmath14-wave pairing away from half - filling .
results for this site - energy inhomogeneous geometry ( @xmath151 ) are shown in fig .
[ fig : gammapdnvrho0774and0875p4](a ) . in stark contrast to the plaquette model and to the _
@xmath147 model,@xcite @xmath108 becomes positive when @xmath147 is turned on : the @xmath14-wave pairing vertex is made repulsive . as with the plaquette hamiltonian of the previous sections , we are interested in how the dependence of pairing on inhomogeneity is affected by the density . to this end we show , in fig .
[ fig : gammapdnvrho0774and0875p4](b ) , the same quantity but with @xmath52 .
this data is consistent with the previous density , and we conclude that this form of site energy inhomogeneity competes destructively with superconductivity . finally , we consider a pattern of inhomogeneity with @xmath152 .
( see fig .
[ fig : checker](b ) . ) fig .
[ fig : gammapdnvrho0774p2 ] . demonstrates the effect of @xmath147 is monotonic and again inimical to superconductivity .
we return here briefly to the sign problem which is the fundamental limitation to using dqmc to study lattice fermion hamiltonians @xcite . in generic situations ( that is , in the absence of particle - hole or some other symmetry which makes the sign positive )
the fermion sign @xmath156 is well - behaved down to some temperature scale @xmath157 , where @xmath158 depends , in the single band hubbard model , on @xmath1 and @xmath159 .
below this temperature , @xmath156 decays exponentially with @xmath160 so that simulations are feasible only in a very narrow range of temperatures below the point at which some of the fermion determinants begin to go negative .
@xmath156 also decays exponentially with spatial volume @xmath161 , but in practice the @xmath45 dependence is usually more problematic .
the behavior of @xmath156 with @xmath159 and spatial geometry is also affected by ` shell effects',@xcite so that the sign can remain close to unity for fillings for which multiple @xmath162 points have the same non - interacting energy @xmath163 .
the plaquette hubbard hamiltonian offers a window into this @xmath161 dependence , since it must be rigorously true at @xmath87 that @xmath164 .
it is interesting , then , to understand how the coupling of independent plaquettes with @xmath165 modifies this manifestly exponential decay .
we show results in fig . [
fig : sign ] . when @xmath87 ( top panel ) the average sign ( symbols ) precisely follows the prediction ( dashed lines ) based on the sign of an elemental @xmath166 cluster
however , when the clusters are coupled , @xmath167 ( bottom panel ) , the average sign is increased .
while the improvement in the behavior of @xmath156 is not sufficient to allow ground state properties to be obtained , it is nevertheless intriguing , and non - trivial , that the entanglement of the clusters by hopping @xmath16 here reduces the sign problem : the coefficient @xmath168 of the exponential decay @xmath169 changes from @xmath170 , at @xmath171 , to @xmath172 , at @xmath167 .
study of the effect of inhomogeneities on superconductivity has been a focus of much computational effort on the hubbard and @xmath173 models over the last decade .
one branch of effort has explored models where inhomogeneity is included in the hamiltonian itself .
other work concerns the question of inhomogeneity which arises spontaneously in a translationally invariant hamiltonian .
the plaquette hubbard model has been a natural candidate of interest since it seems to contain the nascent element , a substantial binding energy , in its building blocks .
we have shown here that dqmc indicates that a sensitive measurement of @xmath14-wave pairing yields an ` optimal degree of inhomogeneity ' .
that is @xmath90 is closer to @xmath91 at @xmath92 when @xmath3 than at @xmath174 or @xmath175 .
larger @xmath6 lead to larger optimal @xmath5 for the @xmath176 range studied .
this result agrees qualitatively with some past numeric work ( differing in the precise optimal @xmath5 ) , but is in disagreement with several of the most powerful computational methods available for these sorts of problems .
when simulations are conducted directly on doped lattices , our work clearly shows the existence of an optimal inhomogeneity , which develops further as @xmath121 is lowered .
while the sign problem prevents us from going to very low temperatures , we can further infer what happens for small doping through our results at half - filling , where there is little limitation on the accessible temperature . here , as white _ et.al .
_ have emphasized@xcite the pair correlation function @xmath177 probes the insertion and propagation of a pair of fermions in the half - filled lattice , resulting in an effective doping @xmath178 . on an 8x8 lattice , for example
, this corresponds to @xmath179 .
direct simulations of the doped system would , of course , be preferable , especially since this effective doping is system size dependent .
nevertheless , comparisons of data for different @xmath180 and ( large ) @xmath93 on lattices of _ fixed _ size are possible . in this way ,
our low temperature , half - filled results speak to the issue of the role of inhomogeneity .
simulations of an alternative ` checkerboard hubbard model ' show that the attractive d - wave vertex is not generic .
a different pattern of spatial inhomogeneity produced a repulsive vertex for most parameter regimes of this second hamiltonian .
we have also exploited the ability to decouple the model spatially to obtain data on the sign problem as independent ( @xmath87 ) spatial clusters are coupled .
we find that the average sign is increased by finite @xmath5 .
we conclude this paper with a few remarks concerning the results from different numerical methods .
our dqmc results are most consistent with the exact diagonalization@xcite , dmrg@xcite , and core@xcite treatments , indicating the existence of an optimal degree of inhomogeneity . as is well known , what makes the problem of strong correlation so challenging is the competition between different possible ordered ( or disordered ) states at low temperature which are close in energy .
even small approximations in analytic and numeric treatments can tip the balance in these near - degeneracies .
dqmc treats the correlated electron problem exactly on lattices of finite size . here
, we are exploring a superconducting mechanism which explicitly attributes pairing to a spatially local attraction , as opposed to the exchange of lattice vibrations or spin waves .
in such a situation it is plausible that finite size effects , while still present , might be less strong .
0.15 in * acknowledgements : * this work was supported by the national key basic research program of china , grant no . 2013cb328702 , by doe de - na0001842 - 0 , and by the office of the president of the university of california .
support from cnpq and faperj ( tp and rm ) is gratefully acknowledged .
it is worth noting that there is a considerable literature on another model sometimes also referred to as the checkerboard hubbard hamiltonian " ( or 2d pyrochlore " hamiltonian).@xcite in this model , hopping is present along the diagonal of alternating plaquettes of the square lattice hubbard hamiltonian .
one key question is whether a spin liquid phase in which there is no symmetry breaking emerges due to the frustration , or whether the ground state retains some sort of translation - invariance - breaking or exotic pairing order .
the model considered in [ ] contains elements both of a hamiltonian built up of linked plaquettes and the frustrating effects of diagonal hopping . | determinant quantum monte carlo ( dqmc ) is used to determine the pairing and magnetic response for a hubbard model built up from four - site clusters - a two - dimensional square lattice consisting of elemental 2x2 plaquettes with hopping @xmath0 and on - site repulsion @xmath1 coupled by an inter - plaquette hopping @xmath2 .
superconductivity in this geometry has previously been studied by a variety of analytic and numeric methods , with differing conclusions concerning whether the pairing correlations and transition temperature are raised near half - filling by the inhomogeneous hopping or not . for @xmath3 , dqmc indicates an optimal @xmath4 at which the pairing vertex is most attractive . the optimal @xmath5 increases with @xmath6 .
we then contrast our results for this plaquette model with a hamiltonian which instead involves a regular pattern of site energies whose large site energy limit is the three band cuo@xmath7 model ; we show that there the inhomogeneity rapidly , and monotonically , suppresses pairing . |
the observed high rate of incidence of binary pulsars among the population of low - magnetic field pulsars indicates a field decay mechanism in a neutron star which is linked with its evolution in a binary system ( eg . ,
phinney & kulkarni 1994 ) .
this is also supported by even lower field strengths of the millisecond pulsars which are generally believed to be the end products of the binary evolution of pulsars in systems with low - mass main - sequence companions ( eg . , van den heuvel 1994 ) .
a model for the evolution of the magnetic field in neutron stars has been proposed which indeed relates it to the spin evolution of the star , in an intimate way .
the model predicts that the magnetic flux is transported out of the core , at the same rate as that of the spin - down of the star , into the crust where it undergoes ohmic decay subsequently ( srinivasan et al .
this field decay mechanism has been already tested in a study of the spin evolution of pulsars in binary systems .
the distribution of the final field strengths against the orbital periods was found to be in good agreement with that of the observed wide - orbit low - mass binary pulsars ( jahan - miri & bhattacharya 1994 ) .
also , implications of the model for the evolution of single pulsars as well as those processed in massive binaries were shown to be consistent with , and provide new insights into , the existing observational data on the radio and x - ray pulsars ( jahan - miri 1996a ) .
the above flux expulsion model ( the so - called model of spin - down - induced flux expulsion , hereafter the sif model ) assumes that , as the star spins down , the outward moving ( neutron ) vortices pull the fluxoids ( the proton - vortices ) along with them because of their interpinning .
however , given the finite strength of the pinning interaction energy and also the presence of resistance against the motion of both the fluxoids and the vortices the two might be , in general , expected to move with different radial velocities , while `` cutting '' or `` creeping '' through each other .
a more refined treatment of the flux expulsion , therefore , requires the dynamics of fluxoid motion to be considered explicitly , as is attempted here .
a further improvement , not addressed here , would be to solve simultaneously for the dynamics of the fluxoids and the vortices , self - consistently .
our treatment is , however , justified for the steady - state spin - down periods when the core superfluid spins down at a given rate which determines the radial velocity of the vortices . in the following ,
we discuss the various forces which act on the fluxoids in the interior of a neutron star , including _
i ) _ a force due to their pinning interaction with the moving vortices .
the other forces which we take into account are _ ii ) _ viscous drag force due to magnetic scattering of electrons , _ iii ) _ buoyancy force , and _
iv ) _ curvature force .
the velocity of the outward motion of the fluxoids could be then determined , for a given steady - state spin - down rate of the star , from a solution of the magnus equation requiring a balance of the forces acting radially on a fluxoid .
the derived radial velocity of the fluxoids at the core - crust boundary would in turn determine the rate of the flux expulsion out of the core .
our approach here is analogous to that of ding , cheng & chau ( 1993 , hereafter dc93 ) in their study of the field evolution of single normal pulsars ( see also muslimov & tsygan 1985 ; harvey , ruderman & shaham 1986 ; jones 1987 , 1991 ) . the original motivation for the present work was to investigate the results of such a treatment of the flux expulsion scenario for the magnetic evolution of _ binary pulsars _ for which the spin - down history of the neutron star is quite different than that of the single pulsars addressed in dc93 .
furthermore , we have also explored other possibilities different than those assumed by dc93 about the nature and magnitude of the various forces acting on the fluxoids .
the resulting alternative models for calculating the rate of flux expulsion could , in principle , probe the physics of the interior of neutron stars in more details .
predictions of these models for the magnetic evolution of binary as well as single pulsars are compared and tested against the available observational data .
superconductivity of the protons in the interior of a neutron star and the presence of a lattice of fluxoids carrying the magnetic flux in the core form the underlying premise for the field decay mechanism under study . as it is the case also with the assumed superfluidity of neutrons in a neutron star ,
the protons are speculated to form a ( type ii ) superconductor based on the microscopic calculations of the associated energy gap in the bcs theory ( ruderman 1972 ) .
the corresponding transition temperature for the proton - superconductivity , though smaller than that of the neutron - superfluidity in the crust , is similar to that of the neutron - superfluidity in the core ( se , eg . ,
sauls 1989 ) and much larger than the expected interior temperatures for the observed pulsars ( pines & alpar 1992 ) .
doubts against superconductivity of the protons have been , however , raised because the earlier calculated core coupling time scale ( alpar & sauls 1988 ) , for the case of superconductor protons , could not successfully accommodate the observed post - glitch recovery of the vela pulsar ( pines & alpar 1992 ) .
this difficulty does not exists anymore since a necessary correction in the calculation of the coupling time scale results in more than an order of magnitude reduction in its value and makes it much smaller than the inferred observational upper limit ( jahan - miri 1998 ) .
moreover , the velocity relaxation time scale of the vortices for the case of normal protons in the core would be much larger than , or at the best ( for the very cool neutron stars ) similar to , the case of superconducting protons ( see , eg .
, sauls 1989 ) .
hence normal protons may not offer any solution to the problem .
on the other hand , the additional coupling mechanism due to an interpinning of the fluxoids and the vortices could result in a reduction in the velocity relaxation time of the vortices as well as in the coupling time for the superfluid bulk matter ( estimates of the predicted time scales may be found in jahan - miri 1998 ) .
thus superconductivity of the protons is rather favored by the above observational restriction on the core coupling time scale . given a superfluid - superconductor mixture in the interior of a neutron star with the associated ( neutron ) vortices and ( proton ) fluxoids , we further assume that both families of the vortex lines form regular uniform lattices parallel to the spin and magnetic axes , respectively
. a stabilizing toroidal field component might be also present in the core fluid , should the crystalization of the crust does not take place early enough after the birth of a neutron star ( flowers & ruderman 1977 ) .
the toroidal component , if it is assumed to be ( @xmath0 g ) much larger than the observable dipolar field would quench the superconductivity of the protons in the core , altogether . otherwise , and
if it is frozen , along with the dipolar field , within the superconducting core it would result in a complicated distorted geometry of the fluxoids .
such ditorted geometries of lines , which is neglected here for simplicity , would affect our following treatment of the flux expulsion in two ways .
the effective total length of the fluxoids would be more than in the case of a regular parallel lattice assumed here . and
, the entanglement of the fluxoids with the neutron vortices would be realized more effectively even in the cases when the rotation and magnetic axes of the star are nearlly parallel .
the case of nearly parallel axes are indeed preferred in our models ( see the next paragraph ) thus the introduction of a distorted fluxoid geometry would have points for and against the following analysis .
the rate of the ohmic decay of the expelled flux in the crust is subject to uncertainties about the correct value of the conductivity of the crust matter as well as the geometry and transport behavior of the expelled flux due to other possible processes , namely the hall drift and the turbulent cascade mechanism ( see , eg . , jones 1988 ;
goldreich & reisenegger 1992 ; bhattacharya & datta 1996 ) .
different values for the effective decay time scale of the field in the crust are therefore tested in our model computations , to bypass these complications . throughout
, we will be considering the motion of the fluxoids only in the region close to the core - crust boundary that also lies in the magnetic equatorial plane .
the strength of the average field of the stellar core is decreased by the transport of these boundary fluxoids out of the core ; the fluxoids in the interior regions are assumed to adjust their positions accordingly to maintain a uniform density .
we will be referring to a cylindrical coordinate system aligned with the fluxoids in considering the radial and azimuthal directions , which coincide with their counterparts in a spherical system for the above region of interest .
the radial velocities of the neutron vortices , in the same region , would however be co - linear with that of the fluxoids only for the vortex segments located near the spin equator of the star as well .
the fractional size of such a region ( of coincidence of the magnetic and spin equators ) would be larger , hence our treatment of the radial velocities and forces for the fluxoids and the vortices would be more accurate , for the smaller inclination angles .
it has been suggested ( sauls 1989 ; jones 1991 ) that , since the pinning interaction energy is independent of a displacement of a pinned neutron vortex parallel to itself , the vortices might be able to slide along the fluxoids without producing a large scale movement of the fluxoids .
it is noted , however , that such a sliding might be realized only for the vortices in some parts of the spin equator , namely for those lying at large magnetic latitudes . moreover
, this possibility does not by itself violate our following assumption of a radial reactive force acting on the fluxoids even in the regions where sliding might occur .
the magnus force on a sliding vortex would have the same magnitude and direction as for the non - sliding vortices and its component in the direction perpendicular to the fluxoid has to be balanced in any case with a force due to the pinning which will exert a reaction force on the fluxoid .
furthermore , since the assumed sliding can not be realized for all of the vortices , for any assumed geometry of the lines , its partial occurrence , if at all , seems to be further questionable on the account that it would result in an azimuthally non - uniform distribution of the vortex density . in the steady - state ,
the vortices in the core of a neutron star are expected to be co - rotating with the charged component of the star , including the lattice of the proton fluxoids , at a given rate @xmath1 ( sauls 1989 ) . however , the superfluid bulk matter has to rotate faster at a rate @xmath2 , maintaining a rotational lag @xmath3 with its vortices , in order to follow the spinning down of the star at a rate @xmath4 .
the corresponding radial velocity @xmath5 of the vortex outward motion , at the core boundary , would be @xmath6 where @xmath7 cm is the assumed radius of the core of a neutron star , and @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the spin period and its time derivative in units of s and @xmath10 , respectively .
the superfluid spins down as the number of vortices is decreased due to their outward motion .
the rotational lag @xmath11 , in a spinning down superfluid , results in an outward radial magnus force @xmath12 on the vortices , per unit length at the core boundary , where @xmath13 is the neutron - superfluid density , and @xmath14 is the vorticity of a vortex line . the magnus force is usually assumed to be balanced by the viscous force against the motion of the vortices which is primarily caused by the scattering of electrons off the magnetized cores of neutron vortices in the interior of a neutron star ( sauls 1989 ) . * the pinning force on the neutron vortices :* + on the other hand , if a pinning interaction is associated with an intersecting fluxoid - vortex pair the corresponding pinning force on the vortex could be , in principle , in either ( inward or outward ) radial directions . the force direction is decided by the direction of the relative motion of the interacting vortex and fluxoid , and is independent of the actual direction of motion of the vortices .
that is , the pinning force could contribute to the viscous forces against the outward motion of the vortices if they move faster than the fluxoids .
however , in the opposite case it would act as a `` driving '' force for the spinning down of the superfluid , being in the same direction as the outward motion of the vortices .
moreover , the viscous force due to the electron scattering is expected to be many orders of magnitudes smaller than the pinning force , even for the largest spin - down rates of interest and hence for the largest possible values of @xmath5 .
typically , the pinning force , per unit length of a vortex , is expected to be @xmath15 dyn @xmath16 , while the viscous force of the electron scattering ( alpar & sauls 1988 ) is @xmath17 dyn @xmath16 ( and the buoyancy force on the magnetized neutron - vortices is even smaller than this ) .
therefore , for the vortices the pinning forces exerted by the fluxoids have to be balanced by the magnus force on them .
an interesting consequence of such a balance of forces for the vortices is that the superfluid might be rotating _
slower _ than its vortices ( @xmath18 ) while it is _ spinning down_. this is in contrast to the usual conditions during a spin - down phase of a superfluid , in general and , particularly when pinning is present and larger values of the lag are the case .
as indicated , a spinning down superfluid must be rotating faster than its vortices ( @xmath19 ) , so that the viscous force ( as well as the pinning force if it is present ) on the outward moving vortices is balanced by an outward driving magnus force .
however , since for the above assumed case the pinning force is itself directed _ outward _ it could as well play the role of the driving force , which in turn requires the balancing magnus force to be directed inward .
thus , a negative rotational lag , hence an inward magnus force , during a spin - down phase of the superfluid in the core of a neutron star is realized when the fluxoids move _ faster _ than the vortices . in any case , a pinning force of the same magnitude as , and in the opposite direction to , that exerted _ by _ the fluxoids will be also exerted by the vortices _ on _ the fluxoids . considering the above discussed balance of the forces on vortices , and equating the forces communicated between the two lattices of the vortices and the fluxoids , per unit volume , the pinning force @xmath20 acting on a fluxoid , per unit length ,
is derived as @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the number densities per unit cross section area of the vortices and the fluxoids , respectively , @xmath24 is the magnetic flux carried by a fluxoid , @xmath25 is the strength of the core field in units of g , and @xmath26 is the superfluid lag @xmath27 in units of @xmath28 .
notice that the sign of @xmath27 determines the sign of @xmath20 for which , as well as for the other forces discussed below , the outward direction will be reckoned as the positive sense .
the above derivation of @xmath20 assumes that the total magnus force acting _ continuously on all _ the vortices is communicated instantaneously to _ all _ the fluxoids .
in contrast , it might be argued that in general only a small fraction of the vortices would be directly interacting with the fluxoids at any instant of time .
the remaining much greater fraction of them ( of the order of the ratio of an inter - fluxoid spacing to the size of a pinning interaction region ) should reside in the inter - fluxoid spacings .
also , the assumed total force on the fluxoids has been divided equally among all in spite of the similar expectation that at any given time a majority of them would be located in the inter - vortex regions , far from any pinning site . nevertheless , the motion of the fluxoids ( as well as the vortices ) is further constrained due to their mutual repulsive forces , which would require a uniform density of the lines to be maintained , in a steady state . consequently , the fluxoids ( whether being in an interaction region or in a free region ) are forced to move always together ( on scales of , at least , an inter - vortex spacing ) which requires that the force acting on some of them to be shared equally among all , instantaneously , as is assumed in eq . 2 .
the same argument fails however for the vortices since their displacements on scales of the order of an inter - fluxoid spacing ( which is many orders of magnitudes smaller than the inter - vortex spacing ) is not prohibited by the above requirement of having a uniform density . on the other hand , and for the same reason , any assumed vortex which is not interacting with a fluxoid at a given time is expected to move relative to the rest of the neighboring vortices and rapidly adjust its position ( within a distance of an inter - fluxoid spacing ) until it also is located within a pinning interaction zone .
that is all the vortices would be continuously interacting with the fluxoids , which completes the justification of the above derivation of @xmath20 .
hence , eq . 2 is valid during a vortex - fluxoid _ co - moving _ phase which was ( implicitly ) assumed in the above arguments .
however , should the ( radial ) velocities of vortices and fluxoids be different , the above restriction on the vortex positions might not be fulfilled steadily since , in this case , they have to continually move through the inter - fluxoids spacings as well .
the effective instantaneous force per unit length of a fluxoid , @xmath20 , during such a state would be smaller than that given in eq . 2 , and
could be estimated as the time averaged force acting on the fluxoids ( or equivalently by using the fractional number of the vortices interacting with the fluxoids at any time ) .
therefore , during a phase of _ unequal _ velocities of the vortices and fluxoids one derives ( in contrast to eq . 2 for a co - moving phase )
@xmath29 where @xmath30 cm is the inter - fluxoid spacing , and @xmath31 is the effective size of a pinning interaction region around each fluxoid . a value of @xmath32 fm has been used for the assumed magnetic pinning mechanism ( see below ) , where @xmath33 is the effective london length of the proton superconductor , being also a length scale for the spread of the magnetic field of a neutron vortex line ( sauls 1989 ) . the `` averaged '' value of @xmath20 as given in eq .
3 assumes that the velocity of a vortex while it is crossing through an interaction region is the same as in the interaction - free space between the fluxoids ; equal weights have been accordingly assigned to the corresponding time periods . realistically , however , the vortices might be expected to move much faster in the free regions than in the pinning regions because of the large difference in the effective resisting forces acting on them in the two environments ( as discussed above ) . as a consequence , they might tend to spend most of their time within the pinning zones which would require an almost zero weight to be assigned to the crossing times of the inter - fluxoid spacings .
that is , their dynamics would resemble the case of the co - moving phase and , @xmath20 as in eq . 2 would be applicable even when there is a relative motion between the fluxoids and the vortices .
thus , while for a co - moving phase @xmath20 is uniquely determined by eq . 2 , when velocities are different one is faced with two different possibilities as given by eq . 2 and eq .
the two derivations represent , in fact , two extreme possibilities regarding the relative behavior of the different pinned segments of a vortex during its motion .
if each pinned segment of a vortex could creep independently ( over the length scales of about an inter - fluxoid spacing ) then the above argument to justify eq . 2 applies to the phase of nonequal velocities as well .
in contrast , for a vortex line of infinite rigidity the whole line moves always as a single piece and @xmath20 as in eq .
3 would be appropriate .
we will test both possibilities in the alternative models which we use , in order to distinguish the relevant approximation for the behavior of the vortices in the core of neutron stars . *
the `` critical lag '' : * + the magnitude of the force which could be exerted _ at each intersection _ by a vortex on a fluxoid , and vice versa , is limited by a maximum value @xmath34 corresponding to the given strength of the pinning energy @xmath35 and the finite length scale of the interaction @xmath31 ; namely @xmath36 . the magnus force on the vortices , which has to be balanced by the pinning force , ( and hence @xmath20 ) can not therefore exceed a corresponding limit .
this , in turn , implies a maximum critical lag @xmath37 , which is determined by equating the magnus force with the maximum available pinning force , per unit length of a vortex . the pinning energy , in the magnetic interaction mechanism , arises because of the difference in the free energies of a fluxoid - vortex pair when they overlap at an intersection or are separated . for a fluxoid with an average field
@xmath38 and a vortex having an average field @xmath39 , the magnetic energy density in the overlapping case would include a term @xmath40 , in addition to the sum of their individual contributions , @xmath41 , when they are separated . the pinning energy , per intersection , is therefore estimated by multiplying the interaction overlap volume @xmath42 with the above additional term of the energy density , which results in @xmath43 ergs ( see jones 1991 for a more refined derivation ) .
the critical lag @xmath37 may be then calculated , as indicated above , to be @xmath44 where we have used the same parameter values as in dc93 in order for the further comparison of the results .
the critical lag is the magnitude of the lag when velocities are different ; or when the vortices move faster or slower than the fluxoids , respectively .
however , during a co - moving phase when the force communicated between a vortex and a fluxoid at each pinning point is less than its maximum value , @xmath34 , the lag might have any value within the range .
we note that a different estimate for the pinning energy due to the proton density perturbation gives a smaller value of @xmath45 ergs .
the pinning energy in this case arises because of a difference in the condensation energy between the pinned and the free configurations , as a result of the change in the proton density induced by the large velocity of the neutrons close to the core of a neutron vortex ( sauls 1989 ) .
the interaction volume for this mechanism is @xmath46 , and the change in the free energy density is estimated as , where @xmath47 is the condensation energy gap , @xmath48 is the fermi energy , @xmath49 is the coherence length , @xmath50 is the number density , and the subscripts `` p '' and `` n '' refer to the protons and neutrons , respectively .
the larger values of @xmath35 in the case of the density perturbation is , however , associated with an interaction length , @xmath51 , which is smaller than for the magnetic interaction , @xmath52 , by about the same ratio as the inverse of the pinning energies .
thus , similar values of @xmath34 , and hence @xmath53 , are expected for the both pinning mechanisms , as has been indicated earlier ( bhattacharya and srinivasan 1991 ) .
nevertheless , since the magnetic interaction depends on the angle between fluxoids and vortices the pinning caused by the density perturbation might indeed have the dominant effect in a neutron star with a nearly parallel geometry of the vortices and fluxoids .
in addition to the pinning force , the fluxoids in the interior of a neutron star are also subject to the following radial forces . * the drag force : * + an isolated fluxoid moving through the normal degenerate electron gas in the core of a neutron star is subject to the viscous drag force of the electrons scattering off its magnetic field .
the viscous drag force , per unit length of a fluxoid , is estimated ( jones 1987 ) to be @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the velocity of the outward radial motion of the fluxoids in units of @xmath56 , @xmath57 is the number density of the electrons , and @xmath58 mev is the electron fermi energy , corresponding to a total density @xmath59 , and a neutron number density @xmath60 in the core . the expression for @xmath61 in eq .
5 is derived based on the assumption of independent motions for single fluxoids . however
, for the typical conditions in the interior of a neutron star the lattice of fluxoids might be , as a whole ( or at least as bundles consisting of not less than ten million fluxoids ) , `` frozen - in '' the electron gas ( harvey et al .
this is because the mean free path of the electrons turns out to be many orders of magnitudes larger than the mean distance between their successive scattering events , and also the deflection angle at each event is very small .
a treatment of the coherent electron scattering by the fluxoid lattice has been shown to indeed require an almost zero relative velocity between the electrons and the lattice ( jones 1987 ) .
therefore , the flux expulsion out of the core might be prohibited except for the presence of electron - current loops across the core - crust boundary .
uncertainties about the true distribution of the magnetic flux and the correct value of the conductivity in the crust , and also the possibility of a mechanical failure of the solid crust due to a build - up of the magnetic stresses , however , obscure any definite conclusion to be drawn .
moreover , there are other reasons to suspect the suggested frozen - in approximation for the fluxoids as a whole ( see also dc93 ; ruderman 1995 ) , in the core of a neutron star . for example
, the finite volume of the fluxoid lattice and also the influence of the superconductor boundary effects on the motion of the fluxoids which have not been included in the previous studies of the coherent scattering could as well have significant new consequences .
in addition , the motion of the incompressible electron fluid in the interior of a neutron star has been argued to be divergence free ( goldreich & reisenegger ( 1992 ) . the above permitted motion of the fluxoids , along with the electrons in the frozen - in approximation , must be , therefore , of the same ( divergence free ) nature .
this is however impossible for the uniform lattice of fluxoids during its outward motion since its lattice constant keeps changing .
hence , a compromise between the flux freezing and the divergence free motion of the electrons has to be worked out if any flux expulsion is to be accounted for . given the above uncertainties as well as the lack of any other definite prescription for calculating the drag force due to the electron scattering
, we use a value of @xmath61 as given by eq . 5 in our models .
this choice is also supported by noticing that a tentative expulsion time scale derived for the case of coherent scattering , as implied by the hall drift of the flux in the base of the crust ( jones 1988 , 1991 ) , turns out to be similar to that based on the single fluxoid approximation . on the other hand ,
a maximum velocity for the outward motion of the fluxoids has been suggested for the case of coherent electron scattering ( jones 1991 ) . also , in some of our models ( models b1 and b2 , described below ) a similar value for the maximum possible velocity of the fluxoids is adopted , eventhough for a different reason .
the same models might be therefore viewed also as models representing the frozen - in approximation due to the coherent electron scattering . *
the buoyancy force : * + the buoyancy force on fluxoids in a neutron star arises for reasons analogous to the case of macroscopic flux tubes in ordinary stars . because flux tubes are in pressure equilibrium with their surrounding the excess magnetic pressure causes a deficit in the thermal pressure , and hence in the density , of the plasma inside a flux tube which make the tube to become buoyant .
the radially outward buoyancy force @xmath62 on a fluxoid , per unit length , can be expressed as ( muslimov & tsygan 1985 ; jones 1987 ) @xmath63 where values of @xmath64 fm and @xmath65 have been used .
harrison ( 1991 ) has raised objection against the relevance of the buoyancy force for the motion of single fluxoids in the core of neutron stars , assuming the _ whole _ lattice of the fluxoids to be frozen in the electron - proton plasma within the star .
he argues that the buoyancy force would rather contribute to the gradient of the macroscopic magnetic stresses supporting the hydrostatic equilibrium of the plasma within the star , instead of acting on the fluxoids individually .
his argument is not , however , applicable if a relative motion between the fluxoids and the plasma is allowed to take place , as he also makes it clear ( see , in particular , the last paragraph before 3.2 , p. 422
, in harrison 1991 ) .
thus , for our model calculations , having assumed a drag force corresponding to the single fluxoid motion , we also take into account the buoyancy force on the fluxoids , for self - consistency . in this context , ding et al .
( dc93 ) have argued that the above harrison s objection against the buoyancy force might be irrelevant because the fluxoids motion could be fast enough such that the conditions of hydrostatic equilibium of the star is not satisfied during their motion .
such an argument is apparently missing the point , given that the independent motions of single fluxoids has been also assumed in dc93 .
the decision whether the buoyancy force acts on the fluxoid lattice as a whole , hence contributing to the hydrostatic pressure support , or else on each flux line individually is independent of , and would be equally effective in , the presence or absence of the equilibrium . even if hydrostatic equilibrium within a neutron star is assumed ,
as is speculated in dc93 , to be approached on timescales @xmath66 myr , corresponding to the largest fluxoid velocities @xmath67 cm s@xmath68 , the buoyancy force could be still acting on the whole lattice , should a relative motion between the fluxoids and the plasma being prohibited due to the requirements of the electron scattering orbits off fluxoids . *
the curvature force :* + the tension of a vortex line ( such as a fluxoid ) implies that a curved geometry of the line would result in a restoring force , the curvature force , which tries to bring the line back to its minimum energy straight configuration .
the concavely directed curvature force @xmath69 , per unit length , on a vortex having a tension @xmath70 and a curvature radius @xmath71 is given as @xmath72 ( harvey et al . 1986 ) .
thus , for a fluxoid in a neutron star , having a tension @xmath73 , the magnitude of the curvature force would be @xmath74 where we have used eq .
6 to express the absolute value of @xmath69 in terms of the ( positive ) buoyancy force .
moreover , the end points of a fluxoid , where its magnetic flux spouts out and joins the almost uniform field of the crust , are expected to be frozen in at the bottom of the crust due to the large conductivity of the matter .
an outward moving fluxoid might be therefore expected to bend outward and becomes subject to an inward curvature force , per unit length , @xmath75 using eq . 6 , and a value of @xmath76 for the assumed spatially uniform distribution of the fluxoids ( dc93 ) .
the currents at the bottom of the crust are however subject to diffusion processes , the rate of which would set a maximum limiting speed @xmath77 for the motion of the end points of the fluxoids .
we , therefore , assume that whenever @xmath78 the fluxoids remain straight and _ no _ curvature force will be acting on them ( @xmath79 ) , since their end points are also able to move with the same speed . in the opposite case , when @xmath80 , the fluxoids would be bent outward and the force @xmath69 as in eq .
8 will be used .
we note that a self - consistent solution of the equation of motion ( eq . 12 below ) requires further that during a transition between the above two regimes @xmath69 should change gradually ( see fig . 3 below ) .
we have allowed for such a smooth variation of @xmath69 at and around @xmath81 , in the models which , otherwise , use the above prescription for calculating @xmath69 .
the above maximum drift velocity @xmath77 of the magnetic flux in the crust is estimated , based on the ohmic diffusion alone , as @xmath82 where @xmath83 cm is the radius of a neutron star , and @xmath84 is the assumed time scale , in units of yr , for the decay of the magnetic field in the crust .
a larger value for @xmath77 may be expected if the hall drift of the magnetic flux at the bottom of the crust is also taken into account . also , the mechanical failure , and the plate tectonic motion , of the crust ( ruderman 1991 ) may require a larger value of @xmath77 , provided the plates motion is driven by some other cause rather than the pull of the fluxoids on the crust .
in contrast to the above _ velocity _ based criterion for deciding the sense of the bending of the fluxoids , dc93 assume that the fluxoids would be bent outward , and become subject to the same inward force @xmath69 as in eq . 8 , throughout the period of _ time _ @xmath85 .
they also assume that for times an outward force of a comparable magnitude would be effective .
the latter ( outward ) force will be however ignored in our new models , since it implies an spontaneous motion of the end points of a fluxoid at a speed faster than the fluxoid itself which we do nt find it to be justified .
the tendency of a flux tube for decreasing its length under the effect of its tension ( harvey et al .
1986 ) , which could result in an inward bending , might be of no consequence in the present case . because , given the negligible radius of a fluxoid as compared to the radius of curvature of the core - crust boundary surface , a fluxoid might not be subject to any _ instantaneous _ force pulling it out to a position with a shorter length ; it may remain in its `` meta - stable '' state being `` unaware '' of the possible gain in its free energy upon an outward displacement . on the other hand , the value of @xmath69 as given by eq .
8 , for conditions of @xmath86 , might be an underestimate .
it has been argued that the repulsive force between the fluxoids should ensure that the lattice response to a deformation is determined , to a first approximation , by their collective rigidity ( jones 1991 ) .
the force @xmath69 associated with even a piece of the lattice of a size of an inter - vortex spacing ( including some @xmath87 flux lines ) would be , in this approximation , so large that any bending of the lattice is effectively prohibited .
the velocity of the fluxoids would be therefore constrained at all times by the condition @xmath88 . in order to implement this latter assumption we , therefore , construct models which use the following prescription for calculating @xmath69 .
if a value of results in deriving @xmath89 ( see below ) then @xmath81 is assumed ( otherwise , we set , and the derived value for @xmath55 is used , as before ) , and @xmath69 is calculated from @xmath90 where the right hand side is evaluated using @xmath91 , together with @xmath92 , whichever may be the case . as indicated earlier , these latter models might be alternatively viewed as representatives of the case of coherent electron scattering .
the steady - state radial motion of a fluxoid , in the region of interest , is thus determined from the balance equation for all the radial forces acting on it , per unit length , that is : @xmath93 substituting in the above equation for the different forces from eqs 2 or 3 , 5 , 6 , and 8 or 10 , respectively , it may be rewritten in the form @xmath94 where parameters @xmath95 , @xmath96 , and @xmath97 are given below for the different models , and @xmath98 is the fluxoid velocity @xmath55 in units of @xmath99 cm s@xmath68 . recall that @xmath26 , which is the value of @xmath27 in units of @xmath100 , might have either positive or negative values , as is also the case with @xmath101 in some of the models .
this single equation includes two unknown variables @xmath27 and @xmath55 , and represents the _ azimuthal _ component of the magnus equation of motion ( sonin 1987 ) for the proton vortices .
no radial magnus force acts on the fluxoids , hence the right hand side is set to zero , because of the assumed co - rotation of the fluxoids with the proton superconductor .
there exist however additional restrictions on the motion of the fluxoids which can be used to fix the value of one of the variables and solve eq . 12 for the other .
namely , for a co - moving state @xmath102 is given and @xmath27 could be determined .
in contrast , when @xmath103 is unknown @xmath27 is given as @xmath104 or @xmath105 for @xmath106 or @xmath107 , respectively . furthermore , inspection of eq .
12 indicates that it admits _ one and only one _ of the three different solutions , for the given values of @xmath108 and @xmath8 at any time , namely [ cols="<,<,^ " , ] the rate of the flux expulsion out of the core , @xmath109 , and the evolution of the stellar surface field @xmath110 ( with a decay rate @xmath111 ) are hence uniquely determined from the above force balance equation , given the spin evolution of the star which determines ( eq . 1 ) the vortex velocity @xmath5 at any time .
we construct four separate models , labeled a1 , a2 , b1 , and b2 , based on the two alternative estimates discussed earlier for the pinning force @xmath20 and also for the curvature force @xmath69 , by permutation .
the models are summarized below by indicating to which of the four distincting physical assumptions they relate , and also giving their associated values of the parameters in the force equation ( eq . 12 ) .
* model a1 : @xmath112 + @xmath113 , + @xmath114 + * model a2 : @xmath115 + @xmath116 , + @xmath117 same as for a1 * model b1 : @xmath118 + @xmath119 same as for a1 , + @xmath120 + * model b2 : @xmath121 + @xmath122 same as for a2 , + @xmath117 same as for b1 while @xmath123 is the same for all the models + these four models together with the model adopted by dc93 ( the dcc model ) will be referred to collectively as the fbe models ( those which employ a force balance equation ) , in contrast to the sif model which has a different approach for calculating the rate of flux expulsion .
table 1 compares all the six models by indicating how the forces and the fluxoid velocity are determined in each of them .
spin and magnetic evolution of the single as well as binary pulsars are calculated according to the requirements of each of the six models , separately , and the results are discussed in the following sections .
& @xmath20 & @xmath62 and @xmath124 & & @xmath55 and @xmath27 + & dcc & & & as in eq . 8 & if @xmath85 & + & & & & @xmath125 & if @xmath126 & from eq . 12 , + & a1 & as in eq . 2 & as in & @xmath127 & if @xmath128 & subject to : + & & & & as in eq . 8 & if @xmath129 & + & b1 & & eqs & @xmath127 & if @xmath128 & @xmath130 iff @xmath131 + fbe & & & & as in eq . 10 & if @xmath132 & + & b2 & & 5 and 6 & & @xmath133 iff @xmath134 + & & as in eq . 2 if @xmath130 & & & & + & a2 & as in eq . 3
if @xmath135 & & @xmath127 & if @xmath128 & @xmath136 iff @xmath137 + & & & & as in eq . 8 & if @xmath129 & + & +
the spin evolution of a solitary pulsar driven by its electromagnetic torque has a rate , where @xmath110 is the surface field in units of g , and @xmath8 is in units of seconds . from the instantaneous value of the spin - down rate
one finds the velocity @xmath5 of the outward motion of the neutron vortices ( eq . 1 ) . also , the critical lag @xmath37 may be determined , from eq . 4 , for any given value of the core field strength @xmath138 . the solution of eq . 12 , for each model , given the values of @xmath5 and @xmath37 at a time @xmath139
, then determines the corresponding values of the fluxoids outward radial velocity @xmath55 and the lag @xmath27 between the rotation rates of the vortices and the neutron superfluid in the core of the evolving solitary pulsar .
the coupled evolution of the spin period and the magnetic field , in the core and at the surface , are thus followed over a period of @xmath140 yr in order to cover both the young and the very old neutron stars in the galaxy .
the computed time evolution of @xmath55 and @xmath27 are shown in fig . 1 , together with @xmath5 and @xmath37 , as is predicted in the a1 model
. characteristically similar results as in fig .
1 are obtained for the other fbe models as well .
the evolution of the lag @xmath27 although is not directly of interest for our present analysis of the field evolution nevertheless bears significant consequences for an understanding of the rotational dynamics of neutron stars , to be discussed elsewhere . the fluxoids motion in fig .
1 is seen to follow three evolutionary phases in which they move slower , together , and faster than the vortices , successively .
these will be referred to as _ forward _ creep , _ co - moving _ , and _ reverse _ creep phases , respectively ( we use the terminology of dc93 ) .
transitions between these successive evolutionary phases occur because of the reduction in @xmath5 ( @xmath141 ) as well as the increase in @xmath8 , and a final co - moving phase might also occur for some choices of the initial conditions .
note that @xmath27 changes sign from positive to negative and remains so in the later parts of the co - moving phase , as well as during the reverse creep phase .
also note that @xmath142 during both the forward and the reverse creeping phases .
the predicted evolution of the core and surface fields for a single neutron star according to the a1 model is given in fig . 2 ; the other fbe models produce similar results .
the two panels in fig
. 2 are for two different assumed values of the decay time scale @xmath143 in the crust , where fig .
2a corresponds to the results in fig . 1 .
a substantial decrease in the core field occurs at a time @xmath144 yr , which is expected for the typical average values of @xmath145 during the earlier times , because @xmath146 implies that a time period @xmath147 is needed for a major reduction in the core field to occur .
however , because of the very small magnitude of @xmath55 ( although @xmath148 ) and also the reduced value of @xmath138 at later times @xmath138 does not change , substantially , afterwards .
the surface field @xmath110 responds to the change in @xmath138 on the assumed decay time scale @xmath143 of the crust .
the nontrivial role of the stellar crust in these field evolution models may be seen by comparing fig .
2a with fig . 2b , where values of @xmath149 , and @xmath150 yr have been used , respectively .
a larger value of @xmath143 tends to maintain the initial @xmath110 , hence a larger @xmath151 as well as a larger @xmath5 , over a more extended period of time .
consequently , smaller final values of @xmath138 and @xmath110 are predicted for the larger assumed values of @xmath143 , as is seen in fig . 2 .
2a might seem to suggest that @xmath138 stops decaying once @xmath110 starts to decline , as is also concluded by dc93 .
however , this is but an artifact of the assumed value of @xmath143 which happens to be close to the saturation time of the core field decay .
the spurious nature of such a correlation , that a decrease in the strength of the crustal field results in a halt in the decay of the core field , may be confirmed by using tentatively smaller values of @xmath152 yr .
as we have verified , in such cases the core and the surface fields are seen to decay simultaneously ( see fig . 3.3 in jahan - miri 1996b ) , in contrast to the above unreal correlation .
the decay of the core field , according to the present models , does not have a direct and one - to - one dependence on that of the crust ; instead they are coupled through the influence of many factors ( see the preceeding paragraph ) .
this statement may be also appreciated by contrasting the predicted field evolution under distinct intial conditions for the relative fields of the core and that of the crust , @xmath153 . for this purpose , the results in fig . 2 with an assumed intial condition @xmath154
may be compared with that in dc93 where @xmath155 and also @xmath156 have been used ( their figs 2 and 3 ) .
the initial crustal field in our case compares with a very late stage of evolution in dc93 when the crustal field has been almost completely decayed .
hence , the initial core field in fig
. 2 should have not decayed , from the very beginning , if the above effect were real .
the above differecnce in the adopted initial fields might deserve a further note .
for an initially uniform distribution of the magnetic flux within the star , which is assumed in dc93 as well as here , the initial condition @xmath155 implies a relative radial size for the crust larger than the currently used values ( eg . , sauls 1989 ; pines & alpar 1992 ) .
it is particularly questionable that the same condition has been used in dc93 for their various choices of eos that have different predictions for the relative size of the crust .
the time evolution of the radial forces acting on the fluxoids is shown in fig . 3 , for the a1 model ( corresponding to the results in fig . 1 and fig .
one should note that a fluxoid , being a vortex , responds to a force by moving in a direction perpendicular to the force ; a radial force does _ not _ affect its radial motion , directly .
however , because of the dependence on @xmath55 in eq . 12 ( which originally describes the azimuthal motion of the fluxoids ) a `` driving '' , or a `` braking '' role in flux expulsion might be assigned to an outward directed ( positive ) , or an inward directed ( negative ) force , respectively . as is seen in fig .
3 , the pinning force @xmath20 is negative ( directed inward ) during the reverse creep phase and also the later part of the co - moving phase . nevertheless , the major predicted flux expulsion does occur ( see fig . 1 and fig .
2a ) during the co - moving and , particularly , the reverse creep phases .
this means that the dominant `` driving '' force for the flux expulsion is the buoyancy force which is positive throughout the evolution . and , that the overall role of the pinning force in the field decay of solitary pulsars is more like a `` brake '' _ preventing the flux to be expelled too rapidly_. we have further verified this conclusion , which seems to be obvious from the results in figs 13 , by other tests of the model calculations where we have tentatively set either of the two forces equal to zero .
our conclusion about the braking role of the pinning force is , however , in contradiction with that of dc93 who attribute a driving role to this force throughout their paper , and make further statements which are not hence justified .
the braking role of the pinning force is also in sharp contrast with the view adopted by srinivasan et al .
( 1990 ) about the flux expulsion mechanism , eventhough comparison with their ( sif ) model , in this regards , might be misleading and unjustified since their treatment does not address the dynamics to begin with .
the opposing role of the pinning force against the fluxoids outward migration , at late times ( @xmath157 yr ) , is indeed true for all the fbe models adopted here . except for including the pinning force these models
are , otherwise , similar to the earlier dynamical studies of flux expulsion ( muslimove & tsygan 1985 ; harvey et al .
1986 ) in having the buoyancy force as the driving cause of the flux expulsion , as verified above .
it is for the role of the pinning force that the predicted field of a neutron star , for all of the fbe models , may never decay to very small values ( @xmath158 g ) even after very long times ( @xmath159 yr ) .
this is a fundamental difference which is much needed to account for the low field pulsars ( to be discussed in the next section ) that could not be possibly explained by the earlier flux expulsion scenarios which neglected the pinning .
we hoped to be able to comment about the relevance of the alternative physical assumptions discussed for the fbe models by comparing their predictions .
however the predicted field evolution behaves very similarly in the different models , hence no further conclusions may be drawn .
the reason for this rather unfortunate finding may be retraced to the braking role of the pinning force , @xmath20 , as well as the effective period of the core field expulsion ; both discussed earlier .
models a1 , b1 , and dcc differ from the other two ( see 3 ) in their prescription for calculating the magnitude of @xmath20 . due to the dependence of @xmath20 on @xmath138 and @xmath8 its predicted value for the two classes of models is markedly different only during the early short phase of forward creeping ( see , also , fig . 3.4 in jahan - miri 1996b ) .
however , the major field expulsion occurs during the later prolonged phases , ie .
when @xmath20 acts as a brake and its predicted value is not much different for the different models .
hence , the distinction among the models with respect to @xmath20 is , in effecte , washed out .
a second distinction among the models ( models a versus b ) relates to their different prescriptions for calculating the curvature force , @xmath69 , which differ only when the fluxoid velocity is large ( @xmath160 ) .
large fluxoid velocities , which occurs only when neutron vortices too move fast , hence large differences between the value of @xmath69 among the models takes place again only during the early phase of rapid spinning down of a single pulsar .
thus , in short , for the spin - down history of single pulsars the calculated forces on fluxoids at times @xmath161 myr are not much different for the different models treated here , hence resulting in similar field evolutions .
the distinction among the predicted field evolutions due to the different fbe models could however be , in principle , quite significant as is encountered in the case of spin histories of neutron stars in close binaries which is discussed below . * pulsar distribution : * + the evolutionary tracks for single pulsars on the spin - magnetic field diagram as predicted by sif and dcc ( the latter being typical for all the fbe models ) are plotted in fig . 4 , for the different assumed initial field strengths .
points corresponding to the given ages of the neutron star are also marked along each track . as is seen in fig .
4 , the predicted final strength of @xmath110 , for fbe models , is found to depend sensitively , and inversely , on its initial value .
this is a consequence of the direct correlation between the total expelled flux and the initial value of @xmath110 , which is expected because larger values of @xmath8 are achieved for larger initial @xmath110 values , as indicated earlier .
however the final value of @xmath110 is insensitive ( not shown in fig .
4 ) to the assumed initial values of @xmath8 and @xmath138 , for changes in these quantities by almost two orders of magnitudes .
in contrast , for the sif model the final value of @xmath110 is found to depend on the initial values of @xmath8 and @xmath138 , as well as on the initial @xmath110 ( fig .
4 ) eventhough having a direct correlation in this case .
these correlations , for the sif model , are in accord with the assumed relation @xmath162 , corresponding to @xmath163 at all times . a further point to note in fig .
4 , is the power - law time behavior of the field evolution of single pulsars at late times , which is realised for the lower initial fields .
this feature which is common among the sif and the fbe models , and was also pointed out by srinivasan et al .
( 1990 ) , has new observational implications which have been previously highlighted ( jahan - miri 1996a ) .
* very old neutron stars :*
+ in spite of the recent discovery of large redshifts for some @xmath164-ray burst sources the association of a sub - class of them with a galactic population of highly magnetic old neutron stars ( see , eg . , blandford 1992 ) may still be viable .
while such an identification of the @xmath164-ray bursters does not seem to be consistent with the predictions of fbes for the field strengths of very old single neutron stars , it could be however accommodated by the sif model . according to sif very old neutron stars ( with ages @xmath165 )
are expected to have rather large magnetic fields in the range @xmath166 g , while the fbe models predict values of @xmath167 g for such stars ( see fig .
the fbe - predicted upper limit for the final fields is even smaller than above , @xmath168 g at an age @xmath169 yr , for the large initial values of @xmath170 g. furthermore , while the above results from fig .
4 are for a value of @xmath171 yr , still smaller final fields would be the case for larger values of @xmath143 ( compare fig .
2a with fig .
in contrast , dc93 suggested that for a neutron star having a magnetic axis aligned with its rotation axis the core field , according to the dcc model , would not be expelled even on large time scales ( @xmath172 yr ) , unlike the general case presented in fig . 4 .
thus , they concluded that the earlier proposed model of ruderman & cheng ( 1988 ) for the burst sources being aligned neutron stars is consistent with a field evolution according to their ( dcc ) model .
however , their conclusion has to be dismissed since it is based on the unusual assumption that the spin - down torque of a pulsar is only due to its magnetic dipole radiation .
the usual and long lived consensus which is commonly adopted also for an observational determination of the strengths of the surface fields of pulsars is that the spin - down torque , due to combined effects of dipole radiation and outflow of relativistic particles , is independent of the inclination angle ( see , eg . , manchester & taylor 1977 , pp .
176 - 180 ; srinivasan 1989 ) . nevertheless , since a discussion of the predicted field decay by the fbe models for a _
tentatively _ assumed case of little spin - down torque acting on a neutron star serves to further elucidate the nature of the models we will pursue the discussion .
indeed , if the spin - down rate of a neutron star is assumed to be small the core field according to the fbe models would not be expelled much , as suggested by dc93 .
this happens mainly because a reverse creep phase does not occur in this case since the associated value of @xmath173 would be too large .
the large value of @xmath20 follows from its inverse proportionality on @xmath8 ( see eq . 2 ) , and the fact that the assumed small spin - down torque result in small final values of @xmath8
. however , ding et al
. argued ( see the last equation in dc93 ) that the large value of @xmath20 in this case is a consequence of the direct proportionality of @xmath37 on @xmath138 , and the large value of @xmath138 .
we argue that the dependence of @xmath37 on @xmath138 is irrelevant since @xmath174 , which implies a smaller @xmath175 for the assumed larger @xmath138 .
in fact the reverse creep phase starts always at a large value of @xmath138 even in ( the non - aligned ) cases where a substantial field decay does occur , as might be expected from the above dependence of @xmath20 on @xmath138 .
we conclude that the fbe - predicted little flux expulsion for the `` aligned '' case is only because @xmath8 could retain its assumed small initial value , as the following test verifies .
the two cases of field evolution presented in fig
. 5 are both for an assumed very small spin - down torque ( ie . that expected due only to the dipole radiation for an inclination angle of @xmath176 deg ) but for two different initial values of @xmath8 .
eventhough in both cases @xmath138 is large before the transition to the reverse creep phase , however substantial flux expulsion does takes place in the case where @xmath8 is large .
note that in this latter case the reverse creep phase starts from the very beginning and persists throughout the evolution of the star .
this clearly verifies the above mentioned role of @xmath8 in determining the conditions for occurrence of a reverse creep phase .
in addition , the above arguments indicate a potential possibility for having very old neutron stars with strong magnetic fields , in the context of the fbe models too .
this may be achieved provided the star is not spun down to large periods @xmath177 s , independent of whether or not the surface field is aligned with the rotation axis of the star , as it also happens to some extent for the low field pulsars shown in fig . 4 . * active lifetimes of pulsars :* + the radio - active lifetimes ( defined by the condition @xmath178 ) of pulsars , calculated for the predicted spin - field evolution in the different fbe models , are shown in fig . 6 against the initial field strengths , for the two values of @xmath179 yr , separately .
corresponding curves for the case of exponential field decay model , labeled as `` exp . '' , ( which assumes the total surface field decays exponentially , with no constraint , on the given time scale @xmath143 ) are also included , for comparison .
the predicted lifetimes by the different fbe models are very similar as can be seen in fig .
6 ( this is true also for the a2 and b2 models which have been omitted for the clarity ) , again making any attempt for a selection among the five fbe models fruitless . nevertheless , there exist a marked difference ( in fig
. 6 ) between the results of fbes , as well as sif , in contrast to those of `` exp . ''
, in particular for values of @xmath180 yr . this difference should , in principle , have testable consequences for studies of pulsar statistics to decide between the flux expulsion scenario , in general , and the exponential model , for the single pulsars ( see jahan - miri , 1996a , for further discussion ) .
the spin evolution of a neutron star in a binary system with a mainsequence star is expected to be different from that of a single pulsar .
the interaction of the neutron star magnetosphere with the stellar wind of the companion star could result in final large values of @xmath181
@xmath182 s , in contrast to the much smaller values achieved in the case of single pulsars . magnetic evolution of binary neutron stars as predicted by the flux expulsion models ( fbes and sif ) is therefore expected to be , in principle , quite different than that of the single pulsars . in this section
we employ the fbe models , for the first time , in a study of the field evolution of neutron stars in binaries .
we consider models for the orbital and spin evolution of a neutron star , of a mass @xmath183 , born in a binary with an orbital period @xmath184 , corresponding to an orbital separation @xmath185 .
the binary companion of the neutron star is a mainsequence star of mass @xmath186 which loses mass in the form of a spherical uniform stellar wind at a rate @xmath187 . in the picture of flux expulsion models the evolutions of the spin period and the magnetic field of the neutron star in such a binary
would be intimately coupled . while the spin - down process would tend to reduce the field strength , the reduced field strength ( together with the increased spin period )
will in turn affect the rate and the direction of the spin variations .
we follow this coupled evolution of the surface magnetic field and the spin period of the neutron star for a time of the oreder of the expected mainsequence lifetime of the companion star .
the orbital and spin evolutions for the expected roche - lobe overflow phase is not however simulated .
nevertheless , it should be noted that the computed field evolution of the recycled pulsars is not affected by this omission of the roche - lobe phase of the binary evolution .
the latter spin - up phase of a recycled pulsar would have no direct effect on the flux expulsion , hence no consequences for the field evolution , except for the general decay of the crustal field which is accounted for in our computations .
thus our simulations are complete , within the limitations of the models , as far as the field evolution of recycled pulsars is concerned ; a point which has been overlooked by some authors ( urpin et .
al . 1998 ) in referring to the earlier cited binary evolution simulations based on the sif model .
we assume that the first phase of the binary evolution , namely the active - pulsar phase with a dipole spin - down ( during which the neutron star spins down due only to the dipolar radiation torque on it ) , lasts till the ram pressure of the stellar wind overcomes the pressure of the `` pulsar wind '' at the accretion radius ( see , e.g. , illarionov & sunyaev 1975 ; davies & pringle 1981 ) . during this period
the stellar wind will have no dynamical effect on the neutron star .
the pulsar s core magnetic field will undergo an expulsion determined by the dipole spin - down rate , according to the fbe models .
in the subsequent two phases where the accreted wind matter interacts directly with the magnetosphere we assume that a steady keplerian disk is formed by the accretion flow outside the magnetosphere , with the same sense of rotation as that of the neutron star . this is the least efficient configuration for angular momentum extraction from the neutron star which we have considered , in addition to the more efficient geometries such as a spherically symmetric radial infall .
the accretion flow interacts with the magnetosphere at its characteristic boundary radius @xmath188 , which is defined by the condition of balance between the magnetic pressure and the ram pressure of infalling flow ( davidson & ostriker 1973 ) : @xmath189 where @xmath190 is the rate of capture of wind matter , in units of solar masses per year , as defined in jahan - miri & bhattacharya ( 1994 ; eq . 4 therein ) .
this interaction spins the neutron star up or down depending on the sign of the quantity @xmath191 evaluated at the boundary of the magnetosphere . here , @xmath192 is the speed of co - rotation with the neutron star at a given distance from it , and @xmath193 is the keplerian speed at the same distance . in the limiting case
when the co - rotation velocity @xmath192 becomes equal to the keplerian velocity @xmath193 the neutron star will conserve its spin period while accretion onto the star will continue .
the rate @xmath194 of transfer of angular momentum between the stellar wind and the neutron star is assumed to be equal to @xmath195 times a specific angular momentum corresponding to the difference between the co - rotation velocity with the neutron star and the keplerian velocity evaluated at a distance @xmath188 from the neutron star . in general , then , @xmath196 will be used , where @xmath197 is the efficiency factor included to take into account the uncertainties due to the detailed geometry of the interaction and the actual value of the specific angular momentum carried by the accreted wind just before and after the interaction .
different rates of angular momentum transfer are thus tested by assuming different values for @xmath197 while @xmath198 corresponds to the case of disk - accretion with a mechanical torque acting at @xmath188 .
jahan - miri ( 1996a ) found that in order to account for the properties of binary pulsars evolved in both massive as well as low - mass systems , simultaneously and self - consistently , larger values of @xmath199 were preferred .
hence , and in contrast to the adopted range of values between @xmath200@xmath201 for the efficiency factor in jahan - miri & bhattacharya ( 1994 ) , here we use the larger values of @xmath197 ; see below .
the following coupled differential equations for the time evolution of @xmath183 , @xmath185 , @xmath8 , along with those for @xmath138 and @xmath110 discussed before ( 3 ) , are solved numerically , for the various combinations of parameter values indicated below .
@xmath202\right \ } \\ & \ & \nonumber
\\ \frac{{\rm d}m_{\rm n}}{{\rm d}t } & = & \cases { \dot{m}_{\rm acc } \hskip 1 cm \mbox{$\ldots \ldots \ldots \ldots$ \hskip 0.5 cm \rm accretion phase}\cr 0.0 \hskip 1.2 cm \mbox { $ \ldots \ldots \ldots \ldots $ \hskip 0.5 cm \rm propeller phase}\cr } \\ & \ & \nonumber \\ \frac{{\rm d}p_{\rm s}}{{\rm d}t } & = & 3.18\times10^{-3 } \ ; \eta \left(\frac{\dot{m}_{\rm acc}}{m_\odot{\rm yr}^{-1 } } \right)\left({r_{\rm mag}\over{\rm km } } \right)\left(\frac{p_{\rm s}}{\rm s}\right)^2\left ( \frac{v_{\rm dif}}{{\rm km \
s}^{-1 } } \right ) \ \mbox{\rm s yr}^{-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath203 is the orbital angular momentum , @xmath204 is the rate of change in @xmath203 except for the contribution due to the escaping matter from the system which is already taken into account , @xmath205 is the total mass of the binary , @xmath95 is the ratio of the mass loss rate from the system to that from the secondary , and @xmath96 is the ratio of the effective specific angular momentum of the escaping matter to that in the companion star . as indicated earlier , a spin - up phase of the neutron star would have no effect on the flux expulsion out of its core , and the core field remains constant during such a period of time .
also , note that during the active pulsar phase @xmath151 will be given by the relation indiacted earlier ( 4 ) for the single pulsars , instead of eq .
17 which is applicable for the other two phases of magnetospheric interaction with the accreted matter ; see jahan - miri & bhattacharya ( 1994 ) , and jahan - miri ( 1996a ) , for more details of the binary evolution models .
the computations were repeated using different combinations of the following values of the parameters and the initial conditions , for each of the fbe models , separately : the evolution of a neutron star in a binary with a low - mass companion ( @xmath206 ) is followed for a period of @xmath140 yr and its final surface field is determined , in order to be compared with the observed fields of low mass binary , and millisecond , pulsars .
the general features of the computed evolution for the outward velocities of the fluxoids and the vortices , as well as the rotational lag , are similar to that descibed earlier in the case of single pulsars .
a new feature is the rapid increase in the fluxoids velocity during the reverse creep phase , which is expected because of the enhanced spinning down of the star in a close binary .
the distribution of the final surface field strengths versus the initial orbital periods are plotted in fig . 7 , as predicted by two of the fbe models , for the given parameter values . fig .
7 shows that the observed magnetic field strengths of the low - mass recycled pulsars , and millisecond , pulsars may be successfully reproduced by the fbe models .
in addition , the observational data on eight low - mass binary pulsars , which are expected to have been recycled in low - mass binary systems , are also presented in fig .
the measured orbital periods for these systems have been corrected for the expected change in the period during a final roche - lobe overflow mass transfer phase in the binary to infer the corresponding intial values of @xmath184 , listed in table 1 , for use in fig .
cccccc + psr & @xmath8 & @xmath184 & @xmath186 & @xmath207 & initial-@xmath184 + & ( msec ) & ( day ) & @xmath208 & ( g ) & ( day ) + 0820 + 02 & 864 & 1232 & 0.20.4 & 11.48 & 300 + 1953 + 29 & 6.13 & 117 & 0.20.4 & 8.63 & 12 + 1855 + 09 & 5.36 & 12.3 & 0.20.4 & 8.48 & 1 + j1713 + 0747 & 4.57 & 67.83 & 0.30.5 & 8.28 & 6 + j2019 + 2425 & 3.93 & 76.51 & 0.30.5 & 8.26 & 7 + j1643@xmath2091224 & 4.6 & 147 & 0.14 & 8.6 & 24 + j1455@xmath2093330 & 8.0 & 76 & 0.3 & 8.3 & 10 + b1800@xmath20927 & 334.4 & 406.8 & 0.15 & 10.9 & 60 + & foster , wolszczan and camilo 1993 ; + & johnston et al .
1995 ; lorimer et al . 1995 .
+ within the uncertainties associated with the value of @xmath210 , which could be also varying with time , and the other unknown parameters of the binary pulsars , the computed curves in fig . 7 seem to agree with the data points .
it is also understood that while the curves in fig .
7 represent a particular choice of the values for the pulsar - binary parameters however the true value of each of them might have been quite different among the corresponding eight systems . qualitatively similar agreement with the data , as in fig . 7 ,
is obtained also for many other choices of the parameter values , as well as for the other fbe models , namely a2 , b1 , and b2 .
nevertheless , and in contrast to the case of single pulsars , the predicted field evolution of a given binary pulsar is found to be quite different according to the different fbe models .
this is promissing , in the sense that it offers a potential possibility not accessible from the application of the models to single pulsars .
one might hope to distinguish among the models and gain insight into the interior physics of neutron stars , based on a comparison of the predicted spin - field evolution with the observational data on the recycled systems .
however , we have not been able to pinpoint any preferences among the various flux expulsion models , at this stage , because of the uncertainities due to the free and unknown parameters ( ie .
@xmath197 , @xmath210 , @xmath143 , etc . ) which are encountered even in a simplified treatment of the binary evolution that we have used .
that is , within the indicated ranges for the parameter values , all fbe models merit the same success in comparison to the existing observational data on the recycled pulsars .
nevertheless , the above general success of fbe , and sif , models which has not been so far reported for any other field decay model of neutron stars , provides a strong support for the flux expulsion scenario .
it is further noted that the sif model was shown previously to be consistent with the data also in the case of pulsars recycled in binaries with _ massive _ companion stars ( jahan - miri 1996a ) .
thus , judging on the overall agreement seen here between the predictions of sif with that of fbe models , in the case of single and low - mass binary pulsars , it might be justified to generalize the success of sif for the case of massive binaries to fbe models as well . on the other hand , the other existing field evolution model of neutron stars , which assumes
the total magnetic flux to be confined to the crust , has been also shown to result in the case of binary pulsars to a decay of the field down to values similar to that of the recycled pulsar ( geppert et .
al . 1996 ; urpin et .
al . 1998 ) .
however , the spin - orbital binary evolution have not been really followed in these studies in all its details , and instead general estimated values for the rate and duration of accretion of matter onto the neutron star have been used .
more importantly , the dependence of the final fields on the orbital periods which is shown in fig . 7 for the fbe models and is also compared with the observational data remains to be demonstrated for the model of crustal field decay due to accretion .
as in the case of single pulsars , for neutron stars evolved in many of the binary systems which we have simulated , again the pinning force on fluxoids acts as an obstacle against an otherwise more rapid and enhanced flux expulsion .
indeed , we have verified that setting @xmath211 in the models , namely having @xmath20 as the only existing driving force , results in a much smaller flux expulsion than otherwise .
in contrast , if @xmath212 is adopted practically zero final field values are obtained , which further demonstrate the braking role of @xmath20 . nevertheless , the essential role played by the pinning force in the field evolution of recycled old pulsars may not be overlooked .
a model which discards the pinning force and relies only on the buoyancy is obviously unable to account for any flux to be present in the cores of such old pulsars .
in contrast , the fbe ( and sif ) models not only account for the observed fields of the old binary and millisecond pulsars , they also predict a correlation between the final field strength of a recycled pulsar and its spin period history , by virtue of the role of the pinning force .
we have studied a scenario for the evolution of the magnetic fields of neutron stars , assuming that the magnetic flux resides in the proton superconductor core of the star and is carried by the fluxoids .
we have employed a dynamical treatment for the flux expulsion trying to improve our earlier studies based on the original model which adopted an expulsion rate equal to the spin - down rate of the star . in the present work ,
the rate of expulsion of the flux out of the core is determined by explicitly calculating the radial velocity of the fluxoids which are subject to various forces .
we have included forces due to pinning between the fluxoids and the neutron superfluid vortices , buoyancy , scattering of electrons , and tension of the flux lines .
alternative possibilities for evaluation of these forces were considered .
the predictions of the various corresponding field decay models for the evolution of single and binary pulsars were discussed , and our conclusions are further summarized below . * the explored flux expulsion models predict a restricted decay of the magnetic field of pulsars that also accounts for the residual fields of the very old neutron stars .
the pinning force plays two opposite and essential roles in the magnetic evolution of the star .
the success of the models in predicting the residual fields of the recycled binary and millisecond pulsars is because of the braking role of this force against the fluxoids outward motion .
this effect also result in a long - lived slowly evolving phase , hence an increased radio - active lifetime , for some of the single pulsars .
however , the pinning force also has a positive role in driving the fluxoids out of the core which is revealed in the predicted dependence of the final field strengths of the recycled pulsars on the binary parameters that determine the spin history of the star .
* flux expulsion under the influence of the buoyancy force alone , in the absence of the pinning force , leads to vanishing field strengths in old binary and millisecond pulsars , hence it is definitely ruled out .
in contrast , a ( tentative ) model which invokes the pinning force and neglects the buoyancy would result , in general , in larger final fields than in the presence of the both forces ; however , for some choices of the parameters the final fields might be small as well . * the alternative dynamical models , which we have considered for the motion of fluxoids and vortices in the core of neutron stars , result in similar predicted spin - magnetic evolutions for the single pulsars .
for the binary pulsars , eventhough the predictions of the models are quite different in many of the cases , however similar acceptable results are still obtained for each of them , albeit for the different plausible values of the parameters .
hence , the underlying assumptions in these models remain observationally equivalent .
the ideas which we entertained in these models are _ a ) _ a neutron vortex remains straight while moving , versus , its pinned segments might creep independently , _
b ) _ a fluxoid may bend and be reacted by its tension , versus , the collective rigidity of the lattice prevents any bending , _
c ) _ fluxoids are bent outward ( inward ) at all times smaller ( larger ) than the field decay time scale in the crust , versus , fluxoids are bent outward when moving faster than the permitted motion of their end points due to diffusion of the flux in the crust and remain straight otherwise . *
the role of the coherent scattering of the electrons by the fluxoid lattice does not seem to be fully understood .
flux expulsion in the presence of the coherent scattering might depend on the electron currents across the core - crust boundary .
assuming that the associated maximum radial velocity of the electrons is similar to the limiting velocity of the fluxoids in the case of collective rigidity of their lattice , we speculated that our models for the case of collective rigidity would represent the case of coherent scattering too . * in contrast to the dynamical models which we used to determine the time evolution of the fluxoids velocity , the original spin - down induced flux expulsion model assumes equal velocities for the fluxoids and the vortices , at all times .
the close agreement between its predictions and those of the dynamical models is largely because a substantial flux expulsion occurs during a co - moving phase of the two families of the vortices , even according to the latter models .
this model , which offers a much simpler approach for a calculation of the field evolution compared to that employed here , might be further justified on the dynamical grounds .
the co - moving phase corresponds to a less energy dissipation for the coupled system of the two families of vortices , than their crossing through each other which costs energy .
it is feasible , though need to be demonstrated , that the more economical co - moving phase is preferred , and maintained at all times , by the magnetohydrodynamics of the interior quantum liquid ; noticing also that the fluxoids as well as the vortices are both magnetized and are rooted in the same highly conductive medium at the bottom of the crust .
* finally , an effective time scale in the range @xmath87@xmath150 yr for the decay of the magnetic field in the crust of a neutron star is suggested , based on the preferred results of the model calculations presented here .
the author is grateful to the referee for the very useful comments and suggestions which helped to improve the text largely .
i wish to thank g. srinivasan for reading a separate earlier report of this work and making useful suggestions .
i am in debt to d. bhattacharya for use of the binary evolution code which was developed for our earlier work .
i am grateful to raman research institute for their kind hospitality , and for using their computing facilities in carrying out this study .
alpar m. a. , sauls j. a. , 1988 , apj , 327 , 723 bhattacharya d. , srinivasan g. , 1991 , in ventura j. , pines d. , eds , proc .
nato asi 344 , neutron stars : theory and observation .
kluwer , dordrecht , p. 219
bhattacharya d. , van den heuvel e. p. j. , 1991 , phys .
, 203 , 1 bhattacharya d. , datta b. , 1996 , mnras , 282 , 1059 blandford r. , 1992 , in pines d. , tamagaki r. , tsuruta s. , eds , proc .
us - japan sens 90 , the structure and evolution of neutron stars .
addison - wesley pub . , p. 104
davidson k. , ostriker j. p. , 1973
, apj , 179 , 585 davies r. e. , pringle j. e. , 1981 , mnras , 196 , 209 ding k. y. , cheng k. s. , chau h. f. , 1993 , apj , 408 , 167 flowers e. , ruderman m. a. , 1977 , apj , 215 , 302 foster r. s. , wolszczan a. , camilo f. , 1993 , apj , 410 , l91 geppert u. , urpin v. , konenkov d. , 1996 , a&a , 307 , 807 goldreich p. , reisenegger a. , 1992 , apj , 395 , 250 harrison e. , 1991 , mnras , 248 , 419 harvey j. a. , ruderman m. a. , shaham j. , 1986 , phys .
d , 33 , 2084 jahan - miri m. , 1996a , mnras , 283 , 1214 jahan - miri m. , 1996b , phd thesis , indian institute of science , bangalore jahan - miri m. , 1998 , apj , 501 , l185 jahan - miri m. , bhattacharya d. , 1994 , mnras , 269 , 455 johnston s. , manchester r. n. , lyne a. g. , kaspi v. m. , damico n. , 1995 , a&a , 293 , 795 jones p. b. , 1987 , mnras , 228 , 513 jones p. b. , 1988 , mnras , 233 , 875 jones p. b. , 1991 , mnras , 253 , 279 illarionov a. f. , sunyaev r. a. , 1975 , a&a , 39 , 185 manchester r. n. , taylor j. h. , 1977 , pulsars .
w. h. freeman & company , san francisco lorimer d. r. , nicastro l. , lyne a. g. , bailes m. , manchester r. n. , johnston s. , bell j. f. , damico n. , harrison p. a. , 1995 , apj , 439 , 933 muslimov a. g. , tsygan a. i. , 1985 , ap&ss , 115 , 43 nice d. j. , taylor j. h. , fruchter a. s. , 1993 , apj , 402 , l49 phinney e. s. , kulkarni s. r. , 1994 , ara&a , 32 , 591 pines d. , alpar m. a. , 1992 , in pines d. , tamagaki r. , tsuruta s. , eds , proc .
us - japan sens 90 , the structure and evolution of neutron stars .
addison - wesley pub .
, p. 7 ruderman m. , 1972 , ara&a , 10 , 427 ruderman m. , 1991 , apj , 366 , 261 ruderman m. , 1995 , in fruchter a. s. , tavani m. , backer d. c. , eds , proc .
aspen conference on millisecond pulsars : a decade of surprises .
asp conference series vol .
72 , p. 276
ruderman m. a. , cheng k. s. , 1988 , apj , 335 , 306 sauls j. a. , 1989 , in gelman h. , van den heuvel e. p. j. , eds , proc .
nato asi 262 , timing neutron stars .
kluwer , dordrecht , p. 457 sonin e. b. , 1987 , rev .
, 59 , 87 srinivasan g. , 1989 , astron . ap .
, 1 , 209 srinivasan g. , bhattacharya d. , muslimov a. g. , tsygan a. i. , 1990 , curr .
, 59 , 31 urpin v. , geppert u. , konenkov d. , 1998 , mnras , 295 , 907 van den heuvel e. p. j. , 1994 , in nussbaumer h. , orr a. , eds , proc .
saas - fee advanced course 22 , interacting binaries .
springer - verlag , heidelberg , p. 263 | models for the evolution of magnetic fields of neutron stars are constructed , assuming the field is embedded in the proton superconducting core of the star .
the rate of expulsion of the magnetic flux out of the core , or equivalently the velocity of outward motion of flux - carrying proton - vortices is determined from a solution of the magnus equation of motion for these vortices . a force due to the pinning interaction between the proton - vortices and the neutron - superfluid vortices
is also taken into account in addition to the other more conventional forces acting on the proton - vortices .
alternative models for the field evolution are considered based on the different possibilities discussed for the effective values of the various forces .
the coupled spin and magnetic evolution of single pulsars as well as those processed in low - mass binary systems are computed , for each of the models .
the predicted lifetimes of active pulsars , field strengths of the very old neutron stars , and distribution of the magnetic fields versus orbital periods in low - mass binary pulsars are used to test the adopted field decay models .
contrary to the earlier claims , the buoyancy is argued to be the dominant driving cause of the flux expulsion , for the single as well as the binary neutron stars .
however , the pinning is also found to play a crucial role which is necessary to account for the observed low field binary and millisecond pulsars . |
in the context of holography , ryu and takayanagi @xcite proposed a remarkably simple prescription to compute entanglement entropy ( ee ) for the field theory dual to einstein gravity .
one computes the minimal area for the entangling surface which extends into the bulk from an area functional .
when the corresponding area functional is evaluated on a black hole horizon it gives the black hole entropy .
if the entangling surface is spherical , there exists an independent derivation of holographic entanglement entropy due to casini , huerta and myers @xcite .
this derivation holds quite generally since it maps the calculation of the entanglement entropy of spherical regions to the wald entropy of hyperbolic black holes @xcite .
unfortunately this generalization is not known for more general entangling surfaces . in field
theory one frequently uses the replica trick @xcite namely , s_ee=_n1
s_n=_n1 ^n , where @xmath0 is the reduced density matrix .
the @xmath1 s are the renyi entropies . from the holographic side
, this entails being able to do calculations for general @xmath2 and then doing an analytic continuation to @xmath3 .
fursaev suggested a derivation @xcite of the ryu - takayanagi prescription which appeared to have some problems since it led to the wrong renyi entropies @xcite ( there is a proposed resolution to this in @xcite ) . until recently , it was not clear if the implementation of this on the gravity side was consistent as it appeared to give rise to singularities in the bulk leading to inconsistencies ( see @xcite for a solution to this problem in ads@xmath4 ) . unlike black hole entropy where for a general theory of gravity there exists the wald formula @xcite , there is no such elegant generalization for holographic entanglement entropy .
the only case where there are arguments to extend the ryu - takayanagi minimization prescription is that of lovelock theories @xcite .
it is not known for instance if for an arbitrary theory of gravity the minimization prescription holds .
it is thus of interest and importance to extend the holographic entanglement entropy prescription to general higher derivative theories of gravity .
recently , lewkowycz and maldacena @xcite have proposed a way to set up the calculation of entanglement entropy in what appears to be a self - consistent manner .
they introduced the concept of a generalized gravitational entropy which is an extension of the usual euclidean methods applicable to black hole entropy calculation to solutions where there is no @xmath5 symmetry .
they observed that when one considers @xmath6 with @xmath7 in the gravity solutions , quite generally there would be singularities in the equations of motion which can be shown to vanish if the minimal area conditition is satisfied .
we ask what happens if their procedure is extended to higher derivative theories . we will consider four derivative theories of gravity .
in particular we will consider gauss - bonnet gravity as this is the simplest higher derivative theory with nice properties .
we will also consider more general four derivative theories and show that the above method only works for gauss - bonnet gravity .
furthermore , recently it was observed @xcite in the context of einstein gravity that if the brown - york tensor @xcite is evaluated on the co - dimension one entangling surface ( not setting @xmath8 ) , then setting the time - time component of this tensor to zero gives identical equations for the surface as what follows from the ryu - takayanagi prescription .
the simple reason for this is that for static surfaces , the co - dimension one extrinsic curvature trivially decomposes : @xmath9 .
thus @xmath10 leads to @xmath11 which is the same as the minimal surface condition for the @xmath12 slice used in the ryu - takayanagi calculation .
but the combination @xmath13 is nothing but the @xmath14 component of the usual brown - york tensor evaluated on the co - dimension one slice in @xmath15-dimensions .
this equivalence is of course certainly not guaranteed for higher derivative theories .
thus it is interesting to ask what happens in the gauss - bonnet theory where the gibbons - hawking surface term is known @xcite .
the primary questions of interest in this paper are : 1 . in higher derivative theories ,
does the equation for the entangling surface derived from the generalized gravitational entropy prescription agree with existing proposals ? 2 .
what role does the area functional play in euclidean gravity calculations ? 3 .
for general four derivative theories , is there an extension to the ryu - takayanagi area functional ?
the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 ,
we summarize the proposals for entanglement entropy in gauss - bonnet gravity .
we also show what the equation for the entangling surface is if we set @xmath16 on the co - dimension one entangling surface . in section 3 we extend the derivation of the minimal area due to lewkowycz and maldacena to gauss - bonnet gravity .
we also consider more general four derivative gravity . in section 4 , we show that the area functional in gauss - bonnet gravity is a suitable counterterm to remove power law divergences in an euclidean gravity calculation .
we conclude in section 5 .
there are several appendices with more calculational details .
the five dimensional bulk action ( euclidean ) supplemented by the appropriate surface and counterterms is given by : [ totact ] i_tot = i_bulk+i_gh+i_ct .
[ bulk ] i_bulk= - d^5x .
+ @xmath17 is the gauss - bonnet coupling , @xmath18 and @xmath19 is the determinant of the bulk metric .
surface terms are needed for imposing dirichlet boundary condition on the metric .
@xmath20 is the usual surface term for gauss - bonnet gravity @xcite [ surface1 ] i_gh=- d^4x . + here
@xmath21 and @xmath22 .
@xmath23 is the determinant of the four dimensional boundary slice .
@xmath24 is the extrinsic curvature , @xmath25 , @xmath26 is the projection operator , @xmath27 is the normal for the surface .
we will use greek letters for the bulk indices . for a four dimensional slice we will use @xmath28 and @xmath29 for the indices used for a three dimensional slice . [ metric ] ds^2=(dz^2+dt^2+h_ijdx^idx^j ) where , @xmath30 is the @xmath31 radius and @xmath32 is a three dimensional metric given below . for the calculation of ee for a spherical entangling surface we write
the boundary @xmath32 in spherical polar coordinates as , ^sphereh_ijdx^idx^j=
d^2+^2d_2 ^ 2 , where @xmath33 is the metric of a unit two - sphere and @xmath34 $ ] and @xmath35\,.$ ] + for a cylindrical entangling surface , ^cylinderh_ijdx^idx^j = du^2+d^2+^2d^2 .
@xmath36 is coordinate along the direction of the length of the cylinder .
for a cylinder of length @xmath37 , @xmath38\,.$ ] here @xmath39 where @xmath40 satisfies the following equation @xmath41 we will take the smallest positive root which is continuously connected to @xmath42 for the einstein ( @xmath43 ) case .
the counterterm action @xmath44 is needed for the cancellation of the power law divergences in @xmath45 when the boundary is @xmath46 . for our case
this works out to be @xcite i_ct= d^4x , where @xmath47 is the four dimensional ricci scalar and @xmath48 and @xmath49 there are two trace anomaly coefficients given by @xcite @xmath50 if the entangling surface is a sphere then the universal part of the holographic entanglement entropy is proportional to @xmath51 while if the surface is a cylinder then it is proportional to @xmath52 @xcite .
this can be taken to be tests that any proposal for entanglement entropy in four dimensions should satisfy . for gauss - bonnet gravity
, it was argued that the following area functional rather than @xmath52 as the proportionality constant in the universal term . ] would give rise to the correct universal parts of the entanglement entropy for spherical and cylindrical entangling surfaces@xcite : [ jm ] s_jm= d^3 x , + where @xmath54 is the scalar curvature defined for the @xmath55 dimensional surface obtained by putting @xmath56 and @xmath57 in eq.([metric ] ) to obtain a co - dimension two surface .
@xmath58 is the determinant of the metric of this three dimensional slice .
one has to extremize @xmath53 which will determine @xmath59 .
let us begin with a general analysis independent of the actual form of the entangling surface to derive the minimal surface condition from eq.([jm ] ) along the lines of @xcite .
for the co - dimension two surface we have the pullback metric @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 are respectively bulk and the boundary coordinates .
next we consider a general action @xmath63 constructed out of @xmath64 . in order to extremize this , we vary @xmath65 with respect to @xmath64 where the variation of @xmath64 comes from the variation of @xmath61 .
@xmath66\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we drop the surface term assuming that an appropriate gibbons - hawking term exists . at this stage , following @xcite , we choose the following coordinate system @xmath67 where @xmath68 denotes the two transverse directions to the surface .
we have , @xmath69 using @xmath70 and @xmath71 we get @xmath72 contracting with the normal labels the component and @xmath73 labels the transverse directions . ]
@xmath74 , @xmath75 in this coordinate system @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the 3 dimensional extrinsic curvature .
so when @xmath78 we get the following condition for the minimal surface , [ condition1 ] + l^2(-2_ij^ij)=0 .
we have also checked this by explicitly computing the surface equations for cylinder , sphere and slab geometries .
we will use the metric in ( [ metric ] ) with @xmath79 as @xmath32 .
the equation of motion for the entangling surface can be found either using eq.([condition1 ] ) or by directly extremizing @xmath53 .
this yields @xmath80+z\big [ 6f_{\infty}\lambda z\big ( z + 2 f(z ) f'(z)\big)\\&+f(z)^2 ( 1 - 2 f_{\infty } \lambda + ( 1 + 4 f_{\infty } \lambda ) f'(z)^2)\big ] f''(z)=0\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the solution of ( [ myerssphere ] ) is , f(z ) = , where @xmath81 is the radius of the entangling surface . the surface closes off when @xmath82 .
then evaluating @xmath53 one gets the universal @xmath83 term as , s_ee=- 4 a ( ) . + starting with the metric in ( [ metric ] ) and with @xmath84 as @xmath32 and proceeding similarly as before we can determine @xmath59 .
the equation satisfied by @xmath59 is given by @xmath85)\big]\\&+z [ 6 f_{\infty } \lambda z f'(z)+f(z)(1 - 2 f_{\infty } \lambda + ( 1 + 4 f_{\infty } \lambda ) f'(z)^2 ) ] f''(z)=0\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the solution of ( [ myerscyl ] ) is , f(z)= z_0(1-+f_4z^4 + z^4z)+ where @xmath86 can be determined numerically . then evaluating @xmath53 one gets the universal @xmath83 term for entanglement entropy as , s_ee=- ( ) .
+ in this case the surface closes off when @xmath87 .
as explained above @xcite , the minimal surface condition in einstein gravity is identical to setting the @xmath14 component of the brown - york tensor on the co - dimension one @xmath56 surface to zero . a heuristic explanation for this finding is given in fig.1 .
if we want an analogy with mera @xcite , then we need to note that at each level in mera we are in the ground state .
@xmath88 on the co - dimension one slice is a condition that will guarantee this .
determines the shape which also implies the ground state of the configuration .
this has a similarity with the mera procedure in which all the states in a particular level are in the ground state.,width=672,height=211 ] we wish to ask if setting @xmath88 in the gauss - bonnet case gives rise to the same equations or not .
the stress tensor expression is given by @xcite , [ sstress ] t^by_ab=[k_ab-_abk+l^2 ( q_ab-_abq ) ] , where @xmath89 we will set @xmath88 and see what the equations are . in order to compare with the covariant expression in eq.([condition1 ] ) , we need to do a 3 + 1 split as shown in appendix a. after this @xmath90 splitting , we get quantities only made up of @xmath55- extrinsic and @xmath55-intrinsic curvatures .
the resulting condition is given by [ condition2 ] + l^2=0 .
+ here @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
if the extrinsic curvature is small compared to the intrinsic curvatures , then the @xmath93 terms can be ignored and we will get precisely eq.([condition1 ] ) .
for the spherical entangling surface we find that @xmath88 leads to @xmath94 + 2 z f(z ) \big[(1 - 2f_{\infty}\lambda ) + ( 1 + 2f_{\infty}\lambda ) f'(z)^2)\big]\\&-z\big[4 \lambda f_\infty z\big(z + 2 f(z ) f'(z)\big)+f(z)^2 \big((1 - 2f_{\infty}\lambda)\\&+(1 + 2 f_{\infty}\lambda ) f'(z)^2\big)\big ] f''(z)\,.\\ \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath95 is an exact solution to the above equation .
however the equations ( [ ttsphere ] ) and ( [ myerssphere ] ) are not the same .
the difference is given by 2 f _
( z+f(z ) f(z ) ) ( f(z)+f(z)^3-z f(z ) ) .
this extra contribution comes precisely due to the @xmath96 terms in @xmath97 . for a general surface
, we have @xmath98 .
so in the large @xmath99 limit , the @xmath93 terms are subleading compared to the @xmath100 ones .
the @xmath93 difference in the equations is to be noted since we will find a similar difference using the generalized gravitational entropy method as well .
for the cylinder we find @xmath101\big)\big]-z\big [ 4 f_{\infty }
\lambda z f'(z)+f(z ) \big((1 - 2f_{\infty}\lambda ) \\&+(1 + 2 f_{\infty}\lambda ) f'(z)^2\big)\big ] f''(z)\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] solving ( [ ttcyl ] ) we get , f(z)=z_0(1- z^2+f_4 z^4 + z^4z)+ , where as before @xmath86 can be determined numerically .
this is the same solution as what arises from eq.([myerscyl ] ) .
however the equations for the surface are not the same .
the difference between eq.([ttcyl ] ) and eq.([myerscyl ] ) is [ diff ] 2 f _
f(z ) ( z+f(z ) f(z ) ) ( f(z)+f(z)^3-z f(z ) ) . again
if we throw away the @xmath96 term assuming a large @xmath99 , we get the same equation eq.([myerscyl ] ) . here
we must emphasize the fact that the solution coming from @xmath88 method in this case agrees with that of coming from @xmath53 upto @xmath102 term around @xmath103 but not in the neighbourhood of @xmath104 .
in a recent work , lewkowycz and maldacena @xcite have shown that one can find the minimal surface condition by demanding that the @xmath6 solution satisfies the linearized equations of motion near the conical singularity . in this section
we will derive the equation for @xmath59 for a general entangling surface for four derivative gravity following @xcite .
we start with the following five dimensional metric in the form used in gaussian normal coordinates , ds^2=l^2(e^2 ( dx_1 ^ 2+dx_2 ^ 2)+g_ijdx^idx^j)= l^2(e^2 ( dr^2+r^2 d^2)+g_ijdx^idx^j ) , where @xmath105
when @xmath106 this corresponds to a local solution of the equations of motion in the neighbourhood of @xmath107 . in these coordinates @xmath108 are the extrinsic curvatures for the co - dimension two surface @xmath107 .
we have put in the @xmath109 term as well since it will turn out to play a role in the general four derivative calculation .
both @xmath77 and @xmath110 can be expressed in terms of @xmath111 .
namely in radial coordinates @xmath112 while @xmath113 .
the @xmath114 will involve higher powers of @xmath115 s . to extract the leading singular behaviour these will not be needed .
when @xmath6 we put @xmath116 going to the complex coordinates , @xmath117 we have @xmath118 for @xmath119 , we have @xmath120 next we consider a general bulk lagrangian , i_bulk = d^5x . for gauss - bonnet gravity , @xmath121 the equations of motion ( these can be found in many places , eg @xcite ) are , [ eomfull ] g_-g_-h_=t _ where,@xmath122 and @xmath123 @xmath124 @xmath125 here @xmath126 is the usual covariant derivative made of the full five dimensional metric . for the gauss - bonnet case , it is easy to see that all the @xmath127 terms cancel out . in order to satisfy the linearized equations of motion
, we generally have to consider metric perturbations @xmath128 such that @xmath129 in the equations of motion , there will be divergences of the type @xmath130 , @xmath131 etc as we will show explicitly below .
these divergences need to be canceled .
since the metric perturbation is periodic , we will need to argue that the contribution from the perturbations are zero @xcite .
thus we will set to zero all the divergent terms .
this will give us the equation for the surface .
in the following all the curvature quantities are constructed using @xmath32 and raising and lowering will be done through @xmath32 .
first we list the all possible divergences in the equations of motion for gauss - bonnet gravity .
: @xmath132\ , . \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that if we wanted to set this to zero , the condition would be similar to what follows from @xmath88 with precisely the same combination of the @xmath93 terms except for an overall factor of @xmath133 .
there are no @xmath93 terms from minimizing @xmath53 .
this mismatch will be addressed very shortly .
+ : @xmath134\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] : @xmath135\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath136 etc are made up of the metric @xmath32 .
the metric fluctuation will contribute @xmath137 using transverse traceless gauge but this is zero using the periodicity argument as in @xcite .
now to get the minimal surface condition we have to set all the divergences in the equation of motion to zero ( the divergences in the @xmath138 , @xmath139 components are the same form as the @xmath140 and @xmath141 since we have set @xmath119 ) .
now notice the following : * unlike the einstein - hilbert case in @xcite , in the gauss - bonnet case , there are divergences in the @xmath142 , @xmath143 components as well . *
if we assume that @xmath144 where @xmath145 , then the @xmath142 , @xmath143 components go to zero .
* in this case @xmath146 so the @xmath147 terms can be dropped .
* the @xmath148 term proportional to @xmath110 does not enter the calculation . now setting the remaining @xmath149 component of the equation of motion to zero we get , ^(w)+ l^2=0 .
thus for gauss - bonnet we get exactly the condition ( [ condition1 ] ) which follows from @xmath53 !
in fact since we are in a regime where @xmath146 , this is also in agreement with what follows from @xmath88 on the co - dimension one surface .
now we turn to the more general four derivative case . in this case , the contribution from the fluctuation of the metric is four derivative . in order to simplify our discussion
, we will restrict our attention to the case where the four derivative terms are a combination of the weyl - squared @xmath150 and the gauss - bonnet . in this case the contribution from the fluctuation in the transverse traceless gauge can be shown @xcite is obtained by considering @xmath151 . ] to be proportional to @xmath152 .
then we can use the periodicity argument to set this to zero . to begin with
, we will ignore the contribution from the second order terms in the metric proportional to @xmath110 .
several problems in this general case will become apparent without introducing this .
first let us list out the various divergences .
: @xmath153\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] : @xmath154\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that it is evident from this expression that for the gauss - bonnet case , the divergences in the @xmath155 component vanishes . :
@xmath156\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] : @xmath157\,.\\ \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] : as we noted earlier , if we add a term of the form @xmath158 to the metric @xmath111 our gauss - bonnet results remain unaffected . for the general case
the structures of the divergences due to @xmath110 in the equation of motion are shown schematically below ( the actual forms will not be needed in our discussion ) . :
@xmath159\,.\ ] ] : @xmath160 here we note the following : * for the weyl - squared combination we need to set @xmath161 and @xmath162 .
* unlike the gauss - bonnet case , there are @xmath163 terms in the @xmath149 component .
these arise due to @xmath164 terms .
there is no such divergence in the other components except the one proportional to @xmath110 .
the logic in the previous case was to make an approximation such that the divergences in the other components of the equations vanish .
thus unless we make further assumptions , the @xmath165 terms will be the leading terms leading to wrong equations for the surface .
if @xmath166 then the @xmath167 .
so to be able to ignore these terms we need @xmath168 . making this assumption already appears problematic .
* to be able to drop the terms proportional to @xmath110 we will need to make yet further assumptions . if we demand @xmath169 , only then can the additional terms be dropped .
* we can drop the rest of the divergences in the other components if we make the same weak extrinsic curvature assumption as in the gauss - bonnet case .
if we make all the above assumptions , then we can set the @xmath149 component to zero to see what the equation for the surface is for the weyl - squared case and @xmath170 terms in eq.(35 ) had typos . ]
^(w)+ l^2=0 .
we have not been able to find an area functional leading to the above equation .
it is unlikely that one exists .
this is because if we construct one out of a function of @xmath171 and/or @xmath172 , we will generally get terms that are proportional to @xmath172 ( see section 2.1 ) . thus the @xmath173 term will be problematic . only for the gauss - bonnet case
is it possible to get an area functional as in that case the @xmath174 term vanishes and we get the combination @xmath175 . in this case
the functional is @xmath53 as shown in section 2.1 .
in this section we will show that adding @xmath53 as a counterterm in gauss - bonnet gravity and evaluating the euclidean action by integrating outside a spherical entangling surface , the power law divergences will cancel out and the final result will be simply the universal part of the entanglement entropy .
the analogous calculation for the cylinder case is given in the appendix .
we will compute the onshell euclidean action outside the entangling region .
this will need us to add several contributions which we will list out one by one . the total boundary in this example comprises of the @xmath56 co - dimension one entangling surface and the @xmath46 surface which is the usual boundary where the field theory lives .
we start by evaluating the bulk action around @xmath103 we get @xmath176 here @xmath177 is a cut - off on the @xmath0 integral .
it will cancel out in the end .
@xmath20 is the surface term for @xmath46 slice leading to , @xmath178 @xmath44 is the counterterm for @xmath46 , @xmath179 @xmath180 is the surface term on the @xmath56 slice .
expanding @xmath180 we get , @xmath181 it is evident here that after performing the @xmath182 integral and identifying @xmath183 , @xmath180 has precisely the same structure as that of the entanglement entropy @xcite with an overall negative sign : i_gh=-+4 a()+ . at this stage
if we add up the contributions , we find that the @xmath184 terms have cancelled out as expected but we are still left with @xmath185 terms .
it is evident that to have a local counterterm with leading divergence @xmath185 we will need a three dimensional one .
since @xmath53 has a leading divergence @xmath186 we can add this piece to see what we get . to keep things a little general ,
let us add @xmath187\ ] ] evaluated on the co - dimension two surface @xmath188 , with the coefficients @xmath189 and @xmath190 arbitrary for now .
evaluating this we get , @xmath191 adding them together , if we demand that all the power law divergences should cancel out we get @xmath192 .
so we see that the counterterm @xmath193 needed to remove the power law divergences turns out to be @xmath194 thus we get the total action to be [ tot ] i_tot= ( ) + if we use @xmath195 in an analogy with black hole thermodynamics ( and identify @xmath196 as the unruh temperature ) , then @xmath197 will be the universal piece of the entanglement entropy .
thus it appears that the area functional can be thought of as a suitable counterterm to remove power law divergences in euclidean gravity calculation .
in this paper we set out to examine holographic entanglement entropy in higher derivative gravity .
we used the procedure recently proposed by lewkowycz and maldacena to derive the equations for the entangling surface .
we compared the result obtained for a general four derivative theory of gravity with existing results in the literature . in doing
so we find answers to the following : 1 . * in higher derivative theories
, does the equation for the entangling surface derived from the generalized gravitational entropy prescription agree with existing proposals ? *
+ it turned out that the derivation for the entangling surface proposed by lewkowycz and maldacena works when the @xmath93 terms could be neglected compared to the @xmath100 terms . in this regime ,
the equations agreed with those in the literature .
in particular they were in agreement with @xcite .
further in this regime they also agreed with the @xmath16 condition @xcite .
one motivation for seeking such a condition is to see if the surface equations can arise from arguments which do not rely on the replica trick .
current methods rely crucially on the replica trick .
* what role does the area functional play in euclidean gravity calculations ? *
+ by considering the spherical entangling surface as an example , we found that the area functional regularizes the total euclidean action of gauss - bonnet gravity by removing power law divergences in accordance with the findings in @xcite .
the action was evaluated outside the entangling surface in a naive analogy with the black hole entropy . whether this was a coincidence or not needs further investigation ( see also @xcite ) . the main motivation in thinking
that @xmath53 could be a counterterm is the following observation : it is known from @xcite that the difference between what arises from the area functional arising from wald entropy and @xmath53 is that the latter has no 3-extrinsic curvature terms .
when we consider counterterms in ads / cft in a setup where we are imposing dirichlet boundary conditions on the metric , there can not be any extrinsic curvature terms in the counterterm action .
* for general four derivative theories , is there an extension to the ryu - takayanagi area functional ? * + this question of course is of great interest and relevance since the wald formula for black holes is meant to work for an arbitrary theory with higher derivative corrections .
our investigations in this paper seem to suggest that the answer is no . at four derivative order , only for
gauss - bonnet theory does there appear to be an area functional .
this conclusion was reached by assuming the generalized gravitational entropy approach used in @xcite to be valid .
also , we did not treat the higher derivative coupling perturbatively . in this case ( which is of course more natural in the context of string theory ) , it may be possible to see the existence of an area functional perturbatively .
for example , it is always possible in a perturbative framework , to perform a field redefinition and recast four derivative terms into gauss - bonnet ( where there is an area functional ) . + another point we should make is suppose we considered more general corrections of the form @xmath198 . in this case
, it appears that the form for @xmath199 would affect the equations for the minimal surface .
thus the area functional , assuming one exists , can not be purely geometrical this of course could have been anticipated from the wald formula for black hole entropy .
there are several open questions .
the most important one is to see if a modification of the lewkowycz - maldacena method can work for arbitrary extrinsic curvatures unlike what we found here where the extrinsic curvatures needed to be small .
the implications for the ( non ) existence of an area functional for arbitrary theories of gravity also need to be investigated . of course
, entanglement entropy should satisfy strong subadditivity and it is not guaranteed that arbitrary theories of gravity with holographic duals ( assuming they exist ) should satisfy this property . in type iib string theory , there is a well known @xmath200 correction @xcite .
it will be interesting to extend the derivation to this case . in quasi - topological gravity @xcite ,
the radial equations are two derivative similar to gauss - bonnet .
one can try to see if an area functional exists in this case .
it will also be interesting to consider excited states @xcite from a first principles approach .
: we thank janet hung , gautam mandal and shiraz minwalla for discussions . as acknowledges support from a ramanujan fellowship , govt . of india .
in this section , we will present some details of the @xmath90 split of the @xmath14 component of the stress tensor for the gauss - bonnet gravity .
the @xmath14 component of @xmath201 can be split as , @xmath202\big)\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then we split all the quantities along time and the rest .
@xmath203 similarly , @xmath204 using this relations in @xmath205 @xmath206 now , @xmath207 - 2\r_{ij}\k^{ij}\\&-(2r^{t}_{t}+\r^{i}_{i})k^{t}_{t}-2r^{t}_{t}(k^{t}_{t}+\k^{i}_{i})+4 k^{t}_{t}r^{t}_{t}+2r^{t}{}_{itj}\k^{ij}\\ & = \r\,\k-2 \r_{ij}\k^{ij}\ , .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here our metric is diagonal . @xmath208 and @xmath172 are the scalar and extrinsic curvature on the co - dimension two slice . also after decomposition , k^2k^t_t-2kk^ctk_tc - k^t_tk_2 + 2k^t _
t=0 and ^t_t(-k^3 + 3kk_2 - 2 k_3)=^t_t(-^3 + 3_2 - 2_3 ) .
so finally , t^t_t=(- -l^2 ) .
we will proceed here just like the sphere case and demonstrate the fact that @xmath53 arises as a counterterm to remove all the power law divergences from the euclidean action .
@xmath209 we will quote the results for the different parts of the action after expanding around small @xmath182 .
@xmath210 @xmath211 now , i_gh=+ + and , i_ct=-+ + and the last piece , @xmath212 adding them together we get , @xmath213 now when we solved for @xmath59 around @xmath103 , the @xmath214 term came as @xmath215 . but here @xmath182 is dimensionful so @xmath216 should actually be @xmath217 where @xmath218 is some arbitrary scale . at this level , we can not determine what this scale is .
so we do not have to set it to @xmath219 . on the other hand , the @xmath220 terms that lead to @xmath221
must be replaced with @xmath222 where the @xmath219 comes from the lower limit of the integral .
thus the @xmath223 and these terms can be distinguished .
now since this is a conformal field theory , it can not matter what we choose the scale to be .
so it must be possible to remove these terms by choosing some scheme .
one convenient way to choose a scheme is to set @xmath224 so that the @xmath225 terms are zero . in this scheme , i_tot= ( )
+ note that there is no power law divergences in @xmath45 .
as before , @xmath226 where @xmath227 is a @xmath228 number yet to be determined and @xmath229 . unlike the sphere case @xmath45
is dependent on the temperature .
f = i_tott= ( ) + .
then , @xmath230 identifying @xmath231 we get , s_ee= - ( ) + which is the universal term for a cylinder . the key missing link in this computation is an independent reason for the choice of @xmath227 . in the sphere case note that @xmath232 worked out to be the same temperature in the map from the entanglement entropy of the sphere to the thermal entropy of a hyperboloid @xcite .
we list here the curvature tensors required for the calculations in section 3 in an expansion in both @xmath219 and @xmath233 .
also we have used @xmath238 in the expression of @xmath239 @xmath240 from here on all the indices are lowered and raised using @xmath241 the @xmath242 s and @xmath243 here are constructed using @xmath241 the curvature tensors in section 3 involve @xmath171 s which are made of @xmath32 .
these are obtained from the @xmath243 s listed below .
s. ryu and t. takayanagi , `` aspects of holographic entanglement entropy , '' jhep * 0608 * , 045 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0605073 ] .
+ t. nishioka , s. ryu and t. takayanagi , `` holographic entanglement entropy : an overview , '' j. phys .
a * 42 * , 504008 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0905.0932 [ hep - th ] ] r. c. myers and a. sinha , `` seeing a c - theorem with holography , '' phys . rev .
d * 82 * , 046006 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1006.1263 [ hep - th ] ] .
+ r. c. myers and a. sinha , `` holographic c - theorems in arbitrary dimensions , '' jhep * 1101 * , 125 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.5819 [ hep - th ] ] .
p. calabrese and j. l. cardy , `` entanglement entropy and quantum field theory , '' j. stat .
mech . * 0406 * , p06002 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0405152 ] .
+ h. casini and m. huerta , `` entanglement entropy in free quantum field theory , '' j. phys .
a * 42 * , 504007 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0905.2562 [ hep - th ] ] .
v. balasubramanian and p. kraus , `` a stress tensor for anti - de sitter gravity , '' commun .
* 208 * , 413 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9902121 ] .
+ s. de haro , s. n. solodukhin and k. skenderis , `` holographic reconstruction of space - time and renormalization in the ads / cft correspondence , '' commun .
phys . * 217 * , 595 ( 2001 ) [ hep - th/0002230 ] . t. s. bunch , surface terms in higher derivative gravity , " j. phys .
a : math . gen .
* 14 * l139 .
+ r. c. myers , `` higher derivative gravity , surface terms and string theory , '' phys .
d * 36 * , 392 ( 1987 ) .
a. yale , `` simple counterterms for asymptotically ads spacetimes in lovelock gravity , '' phys .
d * 84 * , 104036 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1107.1250 [ gr - qc ] ] .
+ y. brihaye and e. radu , `` black objects in the einstein - gauss - bonnet theory with negative cosmological constant and the boundary counterterm method , '' jhep * 0809 * , 006 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0806.1396 [ gr - qc ] ] .
s. i .
nojiri and s. d. odintsov , `` on the conformal anomaly from higher derivative gravity in ads / cft correspondence , '' int . j. mod .
a * 15 * , 413 ( 2000 ) [ hep - th/9903033 ] .
+ a. buchel , j. escobedo , r. c. myers , m. f. paulos , a. sinha and m. smolkin , `` holographic gb gravity in arbitrary dimensions , '' jhep * 1003 * , 111 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0911.4257 [ hep - th ] ] .
b. swingle , `` constructing holographic spacetimes using entanglement renormalization , '' arxiv:1209.3304 [ hep - th ] .
+ m. nozaki , s. ryu and t. takayanagi , `` holographic geometry of entanglement renormalization in quantum field theories , '' arxiv:1208.3469 [ hep - th ] .
y. kats and p. petrov , `` effect of curvature squared corrections in ads on the viscosity of the dual gauge theory , '' jhep * 0901 * , 044 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0712.0743 [ hep - th ] ] .
+ a. sinha , `` on higher derivative gravity , @xmath52-theorems and cosmology , '' class .
* 28 * ( 2011 )
085002 [ arxiv:1008.4315 [ hep - th ] ] .
d. j. gross and e. witten , `` superstring modifications of einstein s equations , '' nucl .
b * 277 * , 1 ( 1986 ) .
+ m. b. green and c. stahn , `` d3-branes on the coulomb branch and instantons , '' jhep * 0309 * , 052 ( 2003 ) [ hep - th/0308061 ] .
+ m. f. paulos , `` higher derivative terms including the ramond - ramond five - form , '' jhep * 0810 * , 047 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0804.0763 [ hep - th ] ] .
+ s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. a. tseytlin , `` coupling constant dependence in the thermodynamics of n=4 supersymmetric yang - mills theory , '' nucl . phys .
b * 534 * , 202 ( 1998 ) [ hep - th/9805156 ] .
+ a. buchel , j. t. liu and a. o. starinets , `` coupling constant dependence of the shear viscosity in n=4 supersymmetric yang - mills theory , '' nucl .
b * 707 * , 56 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0406264 ] .
+ r. c. myers , m. f. paulos and a. sinha , `` quantum corrections to eta / s , '' phys .
d * 79 * , 041901 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0806.2156 [ hep - th ] ] .
+ w. h. baron and m. schvellinger , `` quantum corrections to dynamical holographic thermalization : entanglement entropy and other non - local observables , '' arxiv:1305.2237 [ hep - th ] . r. c. myers and b. robinson , `` black holes in quasi - topological gravity , '' jhep * 1008 * , 067 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1003.5357 [ gr - qc ] ] .
+ r. c. myers , m. f. paulos and a. sinha , `` holographic studies of quasi - topological gravity , '' jhep
* 1008 * , 035 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1004.2055 [ hep - th ] ] . j. bhattacharya , m. nozaki , t. takayanagi and t. ugajin , `` thermodynamical property of entanglement entropy for excited states , '' phys .
110 , * 091602 * ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1212.1164 [ hep - th ] ] .
+ m. nozaki , t. numasawa , a. prudenziati and t. takayanagi , `` dynamics of entanglement entropy from einstein equation , '' arxiv:1304.7100 [ hep - th ] .
+ g. wong , i. klich , l. a. p. zayas and d. vaman , `` entanglement temperature and entanglement entropy of excited states , '' arxiv:1305.3291 [ hep - th ] .
+ d. allahbakhshi , m. alishahiha and a. naseh , `` entanglement thermodynamics , '' arxiv:1305.2728 [ hep - th ] . | we consider holographic entanglement entropy in higher derivative gravity theories . recently
lewkowycz and maldacena @xcite have provided a method to derive the equations for the entangling surface from first principles .
we use this method to compute the entangling surface in four derivative gravity .
certain interesting differences compared to the two derivative case are pointed out . for gauss - bonnet gravity , we show that in the regime where this method is applicable , the resulting equations coincide with proposals in the literature as well as with what follows from considerations of the stress tensor on the entangling surface .
finally we demonstrate that the area functional in gauss - bonnet holography arises as a counterterm needed to make the euclidean action free of power law divergences . |
it has long been supposed that a type iia string suitably compactified on a threefold is dual to a heterotic string suitably compactified on a product of a k3 surface and a 2-torus @xcite .
the resulting physics in four dimensions consists of a theory with @xmath3 supersymmetry .
at least locally , the moduli space for these theories is a product of a special khler manifold corresponding to moduli in the vector supermultiplets , and a quaternionic khler manifold corresponding to moduli in the hypermultiplets .
the vector moduli space has been fairly well understood for some time now ( see , for example , @xcite and references therein ) .
the hypermultiplet space has been somewhat more awkward to understand ( although some progress has been made , see for example @xcite ) .
an almost equivalent problem arises in f - theory .
if one compactifies f - theory on a threefold it can be dual to the heterotic string compactified on a k3 surface .
our resulting theory is now an n=1 theory in six dimensions .
there is still a quaternionic khler moduli space corresponding to the moduli in the hypermultiplets . indeed ,
if this six - dimensional theory is compactified on a 2-torus , we recover the @xmath3 theory in four dimensions above with an unchanged hypermultiplet moduli space .
let us consider the type iia string compactified on a particular threefold , @xmath4 .
the hypermultiplet moduli space is then composed of deformations of the complex structure of @xmath4 , together with ramond - ramond moduli living in the `` intermediate jacobian '' of @xmath4 , and the dilaton and axion . on the other hand , in the heterotic string picture
the hypermultiplet moduli space consists of deformations of a particular bundle on the k3 surface together with deformations of the underlying k3 surface itself .
the central question in understanding the moduli space of hypermultiplets is to know exactly how to match this data between the type iia and heterotic picture .
thus somehow given a threefold together with its intermediate jacobian , we should be able to `` derive '' some k3 surface with a particular bundle .
this is not a property of known classical geometry .
a very similar statement could be made concerning mirror symmetry . in this case
a type iia string compactified on a threefold @xmath4 is dual to a type iib string compactified on the mirror threefold @xmath5 .
again one did not know classically how to `` derive '' @xmath5 given @xmath4 .
the key idea in mirror symmetry was to think in terms of large radius limits and `` large complex structure '' limits .
similarly this paper will dwell on the analogous boundary in the hypermultiplet moduli space .
this latter question is much more interesting than that of mirror symmetry . indeed
this whole subject of exploring the moduli space of hypermultiplets looks like a much richer version of the story of mirror symmetry . the main purpose of the paper is to identify an integer structure on the type iia side , coming from @xmath6 , with an integer structure on the heterotic side coming from @xmath7 and the bundle data .
this is a very useful handle for picturing how the moduli space of hypermultiplets is mapped between the type iia string and the heterotic string . in section [ s : sd ]
we will discuss the boundary of the moduli space we need to study to remove all quantum effects .
this includes a discussion of the @xmath8-field on the heterotic k3 surface . in section [ s : bun ]
we will discuss the moduli space of bundles on a k3 surface in the language of string duality .
much of this section follows from the work of friedman , morgan and witten @xcite but we explain the construction in detail for a few examples .
finally in section [ s : disc ] we discuss the integral structure and some of its consequences .
the type iia string compactified on a threefold , @xmath4 , has the following moduli : 1 .
the dilaton , which governs the string coupling , and the axion coming from dualizing a two - form in four dimensions .
together these form a complex field , @xmath9 .
we assert that @xmath10 is the weakly - coupled limit of this type iia string theory .
2 . a metric which is determined by the complex structure of @xmath4 and the cohomology class of its khler form . when all length scales in @xmath4 are large with respect to the string tension , this metric is ricci - flat .
3 . a @xmath8-field which takes values in @xmath11 ( at least when @xmath4 is large ) .
ramond - ramond fields , @xmath12 .
for some integer @xmath13 .
this may cause the rr moduli to live in @xmath14 . if this is the case then some of the statements in this paper need to be modified to take this isogeny into account . ]
the khler form modulus and the @xmath8-field pair up to form the `` complexified khler form '' . the moduli space of vector moduli , @xmath15 , is parametrized by this complexified khler form .
there are world - sheet instanton corrections to this moduli space however and the complexified khler form is only a valid coordinate near the large radius limit of @xmath4
. we will also refer to these world - sheet instantons as @xmath16 corrections as their scale is determined by the string tension .
@xmath15 is a special khler manifold ( at least where it is smooth away from any boundary points ) .
the other fields , namely @xmath9 , @xmath17 , and the complex structure of @xmath4 parameterize the hypermultiplet moduli space .
again this moduli space is subject to corrections except that this time the corrections are due to string coupling .
the above parameters are only good coordinates when we are near the limit of a weakly - coupled string , @xmath10 .
the moduli space built from these parameters is a quaternionic khler manifold and we denote it @xmath18 .
now let us consider the heterotic string .
there are two types of heterotic strings which we label by @xmath19 .
@xmath19 is either equal to @xmath20 or @xmath21 , where the latter case is usually referred to as the @xmath0 heterotic string .
arises as the possibility of exchanging the two @xmath22 s .
it is essential to include this possibility in order to understand duality between the two heterotic strings correctly @xcite . ]
the heterotic string compactified on a product of a k3 surface , @xmath23 , and a 2-torus , @xmath24 , has the following moduli : 1 .
the dilaton , which governs the string coupling , and the axion coming from dualizing a two - form in four dimensions .
together these form a complex field , @xmath25 .
we assert that @xmath26 is the weakly - coupled limit of this heterotic string theory .
2 . a ricci - flat metric on @xmath27 .
3 . a @xmath8-field which takes values in @xmath28 ( at least when @xmath23 and @xmath24 are large ) .
4 . a @xmath19-bundle on @xmath27 with a connection satisfying the yang - mills equation . in order to proceed
further we need to make a restriction on the type of this bundle .
let @xmath29 and assume that the @xmath19-bundle on @xmath27 may be viewed as a product of a @xmath30-bundle on @xmath23 and a @xmath31-bundle on @xmath24 .
the vector multiplet moduli space , @xmath15 , can now be viewed as being parametrized by @xmath25 , the moduli of the @xmath31-bundle on @xmath24 and by the deformations of the metric and @xmath8-field on @xmath24 .
this moduli space is subject to corrections from the string coupling and identifications from t - dualities for @xmath24 .
the above parameters are only seen as good coordinates when @xmath26 and the area of @xmath24 is large .
the hypermultiplet moduli space , @xmath18 , can be viewed as being parametrized by the moduli of the @xmath30-bundle on @xmath23 and by the deformations of the metric and @xmath8-field on @xmath23 .
the corrections to this moduli space are , as yet , not fully understood but we will see that this picture is probably prone to @xmath16 corrections . what is clear is that the above parameters are good coordinates when the volume of @xmath23 is large .
the main purpose of this paper will be to try to match the type iia ( or f - theory ) picture of the moduli space @xmath18 with that of the heterotic string .
going to the limits in which we remove the quantum corrections , we may match our coordinate systems and obtain a map between a threefold , @xmath4 and a bundle on a k3 surface , @xmath23 . in order to do this
we need to take @xmath10 and @xmath23 to have a large volume . the first thing we should worry about are geometrical restrictions on @xmath4 for the above duality to be possible .
we want to impose the conditions that 1 .
we do have a heterotic string dual to the type iia string on @xmath4 which can be recognized as such in a simple way .
2 . the @xmath19-bundle does indeed factorize nicely as a @xmath30-bundle and a @xmath31-bundle as desired .
it can be shown ( see , for example , @xcite ) that these conditions amount to asking that @xmath4 has a dual fibration firstly a k3-fibration @xmath32 and as an elliptic fibration @xmath33 . here
@xmath8 is @xmath34 , @xmath35 is a ruled rational surface and @xmath36 has at least one section .
now we concern ourselves with the question of how to go to the right boundary in the moduli space to remove the quantum corrections .
first let us deal with @xmath9 .
let @xmath37 be a 2-torus in @xmath23 which is a smoothly embedded elliptic curve for a suitable choice of complex structure on @xmath23 .
let @xmath38 be a 2-form which is dual to the 2-cycle which is poincar dual to @xmath37 .
@xmath38 is a ( 1,1)-form for suitable complex structure on @xmath23 .
we may now expand the khler form on @xmath23 in terms of a basis of 2-forms on @xmath23 one of which is @xmath38 .
that is @xmath39 we claim that the limit @xmath10 is equivalent to taking @xmath40 .
this is much simpler to state in the case that @xmath23 is an elliptic fibration with a section , @xmath41 .
now taking @xmath10 is equivalent to taking the area of the section ( or base ) to be very large .
this may be proven by using a fibre - wise duality argument much along the lines of @xcite .
in @xcite it was argued that taking the heterotic string to be weakly - coupled is the same as taking the section of @xmath4 as a k3-fibration to be very large .
here we are arguing the converse the weakly - coupled type iia string is dual to the heterotic string on an elliptically - fibred k3 surface with a big section .
the fibre - wise duality argument of @xcite works equally well in this case .
to proceed further we will assume that the heterotic k3 surface , @xmath23 , is an elliptic fibration with a section .
note that this will reduce the number of moduli we are allowed to probe not all k3 surfaces are elliptic with a section .
fortunately we will still be able to reach a boundary where all quantum corrections disappear .
we have argued above that this section of @xmath23 is very large .
if we assume that this k3 is generic ( i.e. , all fibres are of kodaira type @xmath42 ) then we may take the volume of @xmath23 to be very large by making sure that the elliptic fibres have large area .
again we may let fibre - wise duality suggest an interpretation of such a limit in the type iia picture .
we follow an idea first explained in @xcite following the work of @xcite .
consider a dual pair of a heterotic string compactified on @xmath43 and a type iia string compactified on a k3 surface .
the map between the moduli describing these two compactifications is completely known @xcite .
we may thus ask what happens on the type iia side if we take a 2-torus within the 4-torus on the heterotic side to have very large area .
the result is that the k3 surface undergoes a `` stable degeneration '' . precisely what the stable degeneration is depends upon whether we wish to describe the @xmath0 heterotic string or the @xmath20 heterotic string on a large @xmath44 .
the @xmath20 case was described in @xcite .
we will focus on the @xmath0 case which was described in @xcite .
the result is that the k3 surface becomes a union of two rational elliptic surfaces intersecting along an elliptic curve .
we will describe the geometry of the rational elliptic surface in more detail later . in terms of an elliptic fibration
this union may be viewed as an elliptic fibration over two @xmath34 s touching at a point .
see @xcite for a more detailed description of this .
now let us return to the case of a threefold , @xmath4 , which is a k3-fibration .
the type iia string on this space is dual to the @xmath0 heterotic string on @xmath27 . in order to take the elliptic fibre of @xmath23 to large area
the above argument suggests that we should let each k3-fibre of @xmath4 undergo the corresponding stable degeneration .
that is , @xmath4 becomes a fibration over @xmath8 where each fibre is now the union of two rational elliptic surfaces joining along an elliptic curve . we also want to view @xmath4 as an elliptic fibration over a surface , @xmath35 . in figure [
fig : deg ] we depict our stable degeneration in terms of this elliptic fibration .
we need to introduce quite a lot of notation to describe various aspects of this degeneration . before the degeneration @xmath35 is a ruled surface . to be specific
, @xmath35 is a @xmath34-bundle over @xmath34 .
we depict these @xmath34-fibres by vertical dotted lines in figure [ fig : deg ] .
we label a generic vertical line by @xmath45 . in the simplest case
we may assume that @xmath35 is the hirzebruch surface @xmath46 along the lines of @xcite .
viewing @xmath46 as a @xmath34-fibration , we can always find a section of self - intersection @xmath47 .
we will denote a generic such section by @xmath48 and we also denote it by a dotted line in figure [ fig : deg ] . note that if @xmath49 then this section is unique .
the elliptic fibration @xmath33 is not smooth . over a discriminant locus , @xmath50
, the fibres degenerate .
we depict this locus by a solid line in figure [ fig : deg ] .
let @xmath51 denote the degenerated version of @xmath4 .
when we go to the stable degeneration , every @xmath45-line will break into two lines intersecting at a point .
thus , the base of our elliptic fibration becomes a bundle over @xmath8 with generic fibre given by _ two _ lines .
restricting the elliptic fibration to either of these two lines will give us a rational elliptic surface .
thus @xmath51 is a fibration over @xmath8 with fibre given by two rational elliptic surfaces intersecting along an elliptic curve .
equally , @xmath51 is the union of two spaces , @xmath52 and @xmath53 , intersecting along a surface which is an elliptic fibration .
we denote this surface @xmath54 ( and thus @xmath55 ) .
meanwhile @xmath35 has become the union of two ruled surfaces , @xmath56 and @xmath57 , intersecting along a @xmath34 .
we denote this @xmath34 by @xmath58 .
@xmath54 is then the restriction of the elliptic fibration , @xmath59 , to @xmath58 .
one may show @xcite that if @xmath35 was given by @xmath46 then each of @xmath56 and @xmath57 are isomorphic to @xmath46 and @xmath58 is a section of both @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
with respect to @xmath56 we may chose @xmath48 to be disjoint from the section @xmath58 . in this case @xmath58
becomes a section in the class of @xmath48 within @xmath57 .
the discriminant locus will divide itself between @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
note that if the discriminant within @xmath56 intersects @xmath58 then the elliptic fibration of @xmath54 will contain a bad fibre .
for consistency the discriminant within @xmath57 must intersect @xmath58 at the same point , and with the same degree . now that we know the way that @xmath4 degenerates at the boundary of the moduli space we wish to consider how we can address the question as to how well the type iia string ( or f - theory ) picture and the @xmath0 heterotic picture agree . to do this
we will focus on the ramond - ramond fields in the type iia string which live in @xmath60 .
assuming @xmath61 this reduces to @xmath62 .
let us assume that @xmath63 is torsion free .
contains torsion , the ramond - ramond moduli may include discrete degrees of freedom .
this can lead to interesting problems in duality which are not fully understood at this time .
these were discussed in @xcite . ]
this means that the ramond - ramond fields live in the `` intermediate jacobian '' of @xmath4 given by @xmath64 .
we would therefore like to see how @xmath6 behaves as we perform the degeneration @xmath65 .
formally one may analyze this degeneration in terms of the clemens - schmid exact sequence @xcite . roughly speaking the following happens .
consider first a 3-cycle @xmath66 which does not intersect @xmath54 .
clearly this should contribute to @xmath67 .
when counting these contributions the only worry might be that a 3-cycle in @xmath52 may be homologically the same as a 3-cycle in @xmath53 .
actually this can not happen since such an equivalence would imply the existence of an element of @xmath68 , but @xmath69 .
thus @xmath70 .
the other contribution to @xmath67 arises in a more interesting way .
suppose we have a 2-cycle @xmath37 in @xmath71 .
there are natural maps @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
let us suppose that @xmath37 lies in the kernel of both of these maps .
this means that @xmath54 is the boundary of a 3-chain that lives in @xmath52 and another 3-chain that lives in @xmath53 .
thus we may build an element of @xmath67 as shown in figure [ fig : h3 ] .
let us assume that @xmath54 is in the form of an generic elliptic fibration with a section .
the elements of @xmath74 generated by the section and the generic fibre will not be in the kernel of @xmath75 and @xmath76 as they map to the section and fibre of @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
the other 20 two - cycles of @xmath54 will be in the kernel .
let us denote this ( self - dual ) lattice of cycles by @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the root lattice of @xmath22 , taken with a negative signature , and @xmath79 is the hyperbolic plane .
@xmath80 can be thought of as the lattice of cycles in @xmath54 which are not algebraic .
it is known as the `` transcendental lattice '' .
( note that if @xmath54 is not generic then we may expect fewer than 20 cycles to contribute to the kernel and the transcendental lattice will fall in rank . )
we have now argued that @xmath81 on the type iia side therefore , our torus of ramond - ramond moduli has factorized itself nicely into a product of three tori .
what do these three tori correspond to in the heterotic picture ?
firstly we have the heterotic k3 surface itself , @xmath23 .
we know the complex structure of @xmath23 is given by the complex structure of @xmath54 . since we have taken the volume of @xmath23 to be infinite it would be unreasonable to assume we have anything left of the khler form data of @xmath23 .
what remains then is the @xmath8-field .
the obvious thing to do is to associate @xmath80 with part of the moduli space of @xmath8-fields .
this is natural since @xmath80 was derived from @xmath82 .
note that we only see the @xmath8-fields associated to the 20 transcendental cycles we have `` lost '' two of the degrees of freedom in the @xmath8-field associated to the section and fibre of @xmath23 .
next we have the two @xmath22-bundles . as we shall see in the next section , and has been noted in @xcite , the remaining moduli of @xmath52 taken together with the torus @xmath83 produces the hyperkhler moduli space of one @xmath22 bundle while the corresponding data on @xmath53 produces the other .
we have therefore achieved our goal . by going to this boundary in the moduli space of theories
we have been able to identify the moduli space of theories exactly with the type iia interpretation and exactly with the heterotic interpretation .
this has been at a price of course . on the type iia side
we have lost some of the deformations of @xmath4 and some of @xmath84 resulting in a loss of ramond - ramond moduli . on the heterotic string side
we have lost the khler moduli of @xmath23 and we have lost some deformations of complex structure by demanding that @xmath23 be elliptic with a section .
we also have only 20 of the original 22 @xmath8-field degrees of freedom .
the boundary we have reached has real codimension 24 .
in this section we will discuss the @xmath22-bundle moduli of the heterotic string in the type iia language .
the ideas we present in this section are essentially contained in friedman , morgan , and witten s work @xcite as well as @xcite .
we present here some explicit construction methods and we discuss some examples to show how easily the duality map can be seen .
we also need to introduce an important lattice , @xmath85 , for section [ s : disc ] .
our method will focus on the relationship between the associated spectral curve of the bundle and the group of rational elliptic surfaces .
@xmath52 is an elliptic fibration over @xmath86 .
deformations of this threefold , together with its intermediate jacobian , will give the moduli space of one of the @xmath22-bundles .
again we denote by @xmath48 a section of @xmath46 with self - intersection @xmath47 .
@xmath58 is another section , disjoint from @xmath48 , with self - intersection @xmath87 .
we denote a generic @xmath34-fibre of @xmath46 by @xmath45 .
we thus have the intersection relations @xmath88.[c_0]=-n$ ] , @xmath88.[f]=1 $ ] , and @xmath89.[f]=0 $ ] .
now write @xmath52 in weierstrass form @xmath90 where @xmath91 and @xmath92 are sections of line bundles over @xmath56 .
let @xmath93 and @xmath8 denote the divisor classes corresponding to these bundles .
the discriminant is given by @xmath94 .
let us denote the class of the discriminant by @xmath95
. sometimes we will be sloppy with our notation and refer to the discriminant locus itself by @xmath95 .
one may show that @xcite @xmath96 & = [ c_0 ] + n[f]\\ a & = 4[c_0 ] + 8[f]\\ b & = 6[c_0 ] + 12[f]\\ \delta & = 12[c_0 ] + 24[f ] .
\end{split } \label{eq : classes}\ ] ] in the generic case , @xmath95 collides with @xmath45 transversely at 12 points .
this means that , as expected , we obtain an rational elliptic surface by restricting the elliptic fibration to @xmath45 . in kodaira language
this corresponds to building a rational elliptic surface by an elliptic fibration with twelve @xmath42 fibres .
there are many ways of building a rational elliptic surface in weierstrass form .
indeed , persson has listed all 289 ways explicitly @xcite .
of central importance to us will be the notion of the group of this surface i.e. , the group of sections taking our given section as the identity .
the group of all the possible rational elliptic surfaces was also determined in @xcite .
one may show that the homology of 2-cycles of the rational elliptic surface naturally decomposes into three parts : 1 .
the identity section and the fibre .
components of fibres not touching the identity section .
elements generated from the group .
the picard lattice of the rational elliptic surface is isomorphic to @xmath97 of which the first part accounts for @xmath79 .
this , the components of fibres not touching the 0-section and the group must account for @xmath78 .
components of fibres missing the 0-section arise when we have bad fibres in the kodaira classification other than @xmath42 and ii .
these are the two - cycles which are shrunk down to zero size to generate enhanced gauge symmetries in the f - theory limit as in @xcite . alternatively in type iia language ,
these are the two - cycles which are shrunk down to zero size in order to switch off the wilson lines around the heterotic 2-torus , @xmath24 , again generating an enhanced gauge symmetry .
since these 2-cycles which miss the 0-section are associated to ( perturbative ) enhanced gauge symmetry , their existence must correspond to the actual structure group of our supposed @xmath22-bundle actually being less than we thought . to be precise ,
let the actual structure group of the bundle be @xmath98 .
then the observed gauge symmetry is given by the centralizer of @xmath99 .
note that the contribution towards @xmath100 is the complement of this enhanced gauge symmetry contribution within @xmath78 .
this tells us that the group part of the contribution must be closely associated to @xmath98 .
indeed we shall now see how the group of each rational elliptic surface is key in constructing the heterotic bundles .
in the generic case we have twelve @xmath42 fibres and no enhanced gauge symmetry . in this case
the group is rank 8 and the structure group really is @xmath101 . as this is the hardest to visualize
let us try something a little more manageable . at the other extreme of the bundle with a structure group given by the complete @xmath22
, we may try to build a bundle with a trivial structure group .
this may be done and corresponds to `` point - like instantons '' .
this case is somewhat subtle and we postpone it for a while .
instead we try to build an su(2)-bundle .
since @xmath102 is a maximal subalgebra of @xmath103 , the centralizer of su(2)@xmath104 is @xmath105.su(2 ) is _ not _ a subgroup of @xmath22 however ! ]
thus if the heterotic string is compactified on an su(2)-bundle , there will be an unbroken @xmath105 gauge symmetry .
the rational elliptic curve we desire as our generic fibre over a point in @xmath8 is given by @xmath106{$\mathrm{iii}^*$ } } \put(420,548){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(460,568){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(380,541){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(155,600){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$f$ } } \end{picture}\ ] ] this has mordell - weil group isomorphic to @xmath107 , i.e. , of rank 1 .
this means that there is another section , @xmath108 , of this rational elliptic surface which generates the group .
the difference between this section and our zero section , @xmath109 , generates part of @xmath100 of the surface ( see , for example , @xcite ) , @xmath110\in h_2 $ ] .
remember that we are building @xmath52 as a rational elliptic surface fibration over @xmath8 .
there can be monodromy in this fibration such that our 2-cycle @xmath110 $ ] is not an invariant homology cycle .
it is possible that parallel transport along a closed loop in @xmath8 may map @xmath110 $ ] to @xmath111=[\sigma_{-1}-\sigma_0]$ ] , where @xmath112 is another section in the group . under the group law
, @xmath112 is the inverse of @xmath108 .
now this rational elliptic surface intersects @xmath54 along an elliptic curve .
this elliptic curve is the elliptic fibre over the point in @xmath56 given by the collision of @xmath58 with the @xmath45-line we have taken to build our rational elliptic surface .
the sections @xmath108 and @xmath112 will each intersect this elliptic curve at two points , @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
consider now the whole family of rational elliptic surfaces over @xmath8 .
transporting @xmath113 and @xmath114 around the whole of @xmath8 will build a double cover @xmath115 .
this curve , @xmath116 , is the _
spectral curve_. ( 365,210)(140,575 ) ( 140,600 ) ( 1 , 0)360 ( 330,780)(0.00000,-8.03922)26 ( 0,-1 ) 4.020 ( 230,580)(0.00000,8.03922)26 ( 0 , 1 ) 4.020 ( 420,780)(0.00000,-7.84314)26 ( 0,-1 ) 3.922 ( 160,740)(8.00000,0.00000)43 ( 1 , 0 ) 4.000 ( 165,580)(0.00000,8.03922)26 ( 0 , 1 ) 4.020 ( 140,580 ) ( 165,680 ) ( 425,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath76 ( 505,590)(0,0)[lb]@xmath48 ( 505,735)(0,0)[lb]@xmath58 ( 450,605)(0,0)[lb]iii@xmath117 ( 235,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath75 ( 335,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath45 ( 170,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath118 ( 365,640)(0,0)[lb]i@xmath119 globally , in terms of @xmath56 , our picture for this elliptic fibration looks like figure [ fig : a1 ] . over the generic @xmath45-line ,
labelled by @xmath45 in the figure , we have one iii@xmath117 fibre and three i@xmath119 fibres as desired for our generic rational elliptic surface . in the generic case
there are three things that can happen to spoil this for some particular @xmath45-lines . in the following recall that @xmath120 refers to the geometry of @xmath121 .
a. the curve of i@xmath119 s may collide with the line @xmath48 of iii@xmath117 fibres .
this does not occur transversely each collision has multiplicity 3 .
one may also show from intersection theory that such a collision occurs @xmath122 times @xcite .
when the elliptic fibration is restricted to an @xmath45-line through this collision ( labelled @xmath75 in the figure ) we obtain a rational elliptic surface with one ii@xmath117 fibre and two i@xmath119 fibres .
b. the curve of i@xmath119 s may be tangential to the @xmath45 direction .
when the elliptic fibration is restricted to such an @xmath45-line ( labelled @xmath76 in the figure ) we obtain a rational elliptic surface with one iii@xmath117 fibre , one i@xmath123 fibre and one i@xmath119 fibre .
c. the curve of i@xmath119 s may have a cusp .
an @xmath45-line passing through such a point is labelled by @xmath118 in the diagram .
now the resulting rational elliptic surface has one iii@xmath117 fibre , one ii fibre and one i@xmath119 fibre . in the case ( a )
, the group becomes trivial .
this must mean that the sections @xmath108 and @xmath112 must coincide with @xmath109 at this point over @xmath8 . in case
( b ) , the group becomes @xmath124 .
for this surface both @xmath108 and @xmath112 pass through a 2-torsion point in the elliptic fibre over @xmath58 .
in both of these cases , @xmath108 and @xmath112 coincide and we have a branch point of @xmath115 . in case ( c ) , the group remains equal to @xmath107 and @xmath115 is not branched .
we may calculate the genus of @xmath116 from the number of branch points . as mentioned earlier , the are @xmath122 collisions from case ( a ) .
to count case ( c ) we look for collisions between @xmath93 and @xmath8 given by ( [ eq : classes ] ) . for a similar computation see the computation in section 6.6 of @xcite .
the result is @xmath125 . to calculate ( b ) we need to write our discriminant more explicitly .
let @xmath126 and @xmath127 be affine coordinates on @xmath121 .
we let @xmath126 be a coordinate in the `` fibre '' direction and @xmath127 be in the `` base '' direction .
the curve of i@xmath119 fibres in figure [ fig : a1 ] is in the class @xmath128=3[c_0]+24[f]$ ] .
this means that the polynomial , @xmath129 , whose zero gives the curve of i@xmath119 fibres can be written in the form @xmath130 where @xmath131 represents some generic polynomial of degree @xmath132 in @xmath127 .
similar equations appeared in @xcite .
the discriminant of @xmath129 with respect to @xmath126 is a polynomial of degree @xmath133 in @xmath127 .
this measures the number of points over the base where the three solutions of the cubic equation given by ( [ eq : cuba1 ] ) coincide .
this occurs for cases ( b ) and ( c ) .
it is easy to show that a generic cusp of type ( c ) will contribute 3 towards the above discriminant while the tangency of type ( b ) will contribute only 1 .
thus the number of occurrences of case ( b ) is @xmath134 .
the number of branch points is therefore given by @xmath135 from which is it follows that @xmath116 has genus @xmath136 .
we wish to claim that there is a natural identification of the jacobian of @xmath116 , @xmath137 , with the moduli space of ramond - ramond fields @xmath138 .
this is easy given our construction of the spectral curve .
first let us ask how we see @xmath139 in terms of the fibration @xmath140 .
such 3-cycles are built from transporting 2-cycles within fibre around non - contractable 1-cycles in @xmath8 .
these 2-cycles must be non - monodromy - invariant to build a homologically nontrivial element of @xmath139 .
these 2-cycles come exactly from the group of the fibre of @xmath141 .
we may now ask how we build elements of @xmath142 in terms of the fibration @xmath115 .
the answer is very similar except now we transport the points in the fibre around loops in @xmath8 . by construction
however we identify points in the fibre of @xmath143 with the 2-cycles coming from the group in the fibre of @xmath141 .
thus @xmath144 and so @xmath145 .
actually we may do a little better than this .
the jacobian of a curve is not only a torus but an _ abelian variety_. that is , it is a torus which admits a complex structure and can be embedded in some complex projective space .
one can argue that the same is true for the intermediate jacobian for @xmath52 .
one can then show that the jacobian of @xmath116 , @xmath146 , is isomorphic to the intermediate jacobian of @xmath52 as an algebraic variety ( for example , see the abel - jacobi map of @xcite ) .
we may also phrase our construction more formally by using the leray spectral sequence of a fibration and noting that @xmath147 .
we are done once we note that an su(2)-bundle on @xmath23 is specified uniquely by a given spectral curve , @xmath148 , and a line bundle ( of a particular degree ) @xmath149 .
this was shown in @xcite .
the deformations of the spectral curve are given by the deformations of @xmath52 and the moduli space of the line bundle @xmath150 are given by the jacobian of @xmath116 and thus the ramond - ramond fields .
as a final check let us compute the dimensions of the moduli space .
the moduli space of su(2)-bundles on a k3 surface is a hyperkhler space whose quaternionic dimension is given by hirzebruch - riemann - roch as @xmath151 .
similarly the moduli space of @xmath150 together with its jacobian forms a hyperkhler space as in hitchin s construction @xcite .
the quaternionic dimension of this moduli space is given by the genus of @xmath150 which is @xmath152 .
thus we are in agreement if @xmath153 as expected @xcite .
having explicitly mapped the moduli space of su(2)-bundles on @xmath23 to its type iia dual picture in terms of @xmath52 , we may try to do the same for a larger structure group , @xmath98 .
the obvious thing to do is to slightly relax our constraint above that we have an unbroken @xmath105 gauge symmetry . as the next case we use the generic rational elliptic surface in the fibre of @xmath140 of the following form : @xmath154{$\mathrm{iv}^*$ } } \put(420,548){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(460,568){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(380,541){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(340,541){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(155,600){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$f$ } } \end{picture}\ ] ] the type iv@xmath117 fibre is associated to an @xmath155 singularity and so one might at first suppose that we are going to see an unbroken @xmath155 gauge symmetry .
this is not the case however thanks to monodromy @xcite .
in fact there is more than one way in which this case will be quite a bit more subtle than the su(2 ) case above .
( 365,210)(140,575 ) ( 140,600 ) ( 1 , 0)360 ( 330,780)(0.00000,-8.03922)26 ( 0,-1 ) 4.020 ( 230,580)(0.00000,8.03922)26 ( 0 , 1 ) 4.020 ( 420,780)(0.00000,-7.84314)26 ( 0,-1 ) 3.922 ( 160,740)(8.00000,0.00000)43 ( 1 , 0 ) 4.000 ( 165,580)(0.00000,8.03922)26 ( 0 , 1 ) 4.020 ( 440,640 ) ( 165,655 ) ( 425,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath76 ( 505,590)(0,0)[lb]@xmath48 ( 505,735)(0,0)[lb]@xmath58 ( 235,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath75 ( 335,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath45 ( 170,755)(0,0)[lb]@xmath118 ( 450,605)(0,0)[lb]iv@xmath117 ( 365,650)(0,0)[lb]i@xmath119 in figure [ fig : g2 ] we draw the discriminant locus of the elliptic fibration @xmath156 again .
now we have the following collisions : a. the curve of i@xmath119 s may collide with the line @xmath48 of iv@xmath117 fibres .
this does not occur transversely each collision has multiplicity 2 .
one may also show from intersection theory that such a collision occurs @xmath157 times .
when the elliptic fibration is restricted to an @xmath45-line through this collision ( labelled @xmath75 in the figure ) we obtain a rational elliptic surface with one iii@xmath117 fibre and three i@xmath119 fibres .
b. the curve of i@xmath119 s may be tangential to the @xmath45 direction .
when the elliptic fibration is restricted to such an @xmath45-line ( labelled @xmath76 in the figure ) we obtain a rational elliptic surface with one iv@xmath117 fibre , one i@xmath123 fibre and two i@xmath119 fibres . c. the curve of i@xmath119 s may have a cusp .
an @xmath45-line passing through such a point is labelled by @xmath118 in the diagram .
now the resulting rational elliptic surface has one iv@xmath117 fibre , one ii fibre and two i@xmath119 fibres . over a generic @xmath45 ,
the rational elliptic surface has a group equal to @xmath158 . over @xmath75 and @xmath76 in cases ( a ) and ( b ) the group becomes @xmath107 .
thus we again have some kind of branched curve over @xmath8 with branch points at the locations of @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
what kind of monodromy will we get for these two - cycles coming from the group ?
we may address this question from our knowledge that the total lattice of cycles generated by the group and the reducible fibres is @xmath78 as explained earlier . over the generic curve @xmath45 in figure [ fig : g2 ]
we have the type iv@xmath117 fibre which contributes an @xmath159 root lattice of cycles to the picard lattice .
thus the group must contribute the orthogonal complement of this @xmath159 root lattice which is the @xmath160 root lattice .
the monodromy around the @xmath76 fibre in figure [ fig : g2 ] leaves the @xmath159 root lattice alone and so we may obtain an element of the weyl group of @xmath160 acting on the part .
the monodromy around the @xmath75 line is more interesting .
it is known that the monodromy around this line is not trivial on the iv@xmath117 fibre and thus not trivial on the @xmath159 root lattice .
actually the monodromy acts as an outer automorphism of @xmath159 .
since the full @xmath78 lattice of cycles must be mapped to itself by this monodromy we need to know how such an outer automorphism acts within the context of the @xmath103 root lattice .
let us label the simple roots of @xmath103 as follows : @xmath161{$\alpha_1 $ } } \put(250,770){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\alpha_2 $ } } \put(170,690){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\alpha_3 $ } } \put(230,690){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\alpha_4 $ } } \put(290,690){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\alpha_5 $ } } \put(350,690){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\alpha_6 $ } } \put(410,690){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\alpha_7 $ } } \put(470,690){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\alpha_8 $ } } \end{picture}\ ] ] now introduce some more roots @xmath162 we may draw a dynkin - like diagram representing the angles between some of these roots as follows : @xmath163 0 setdash 0.600 setlinewidth stroke } } \put(5461,-1021){\special { " 0 0 moveto 17.280 -17.280 lineto [ 2.160 ] 0 setdash 0.600 setlinewidth stroke } } \put(1951,-1336){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{3}$ } } } \put(2881,-1336){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{4}$ } } } \put(3691,-601){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{5}$ } } } \put(4381,119){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{6}$ } } } \put(4141,-2551){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{11}$ } } } \put(5281,-1366){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{7}$ } } } \put(6151,-451){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{8}$ } } } \put(6151,-1681){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{10}$ } } } \put(3511,-1981){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{\smash{$\alpha_{2}$ } } } \end{picture } \label{eq : g2f4}\ ] ] here a dotted line indicates that the inner product is negative that of a solid line .
clearly this diagram shows that we have a symmetry of the root system by reflecting ( [ eq : g2f4 ] ) about a horizontal line and taking @xmath164 .
this symmetry of the root system is an element of the weyl group of @xmath103 .
the subdiagram to the left of @xmath165 in ( [ eq : g2f4 ] ) is the dynkin diagram of @xmath159 and this symmetry corresponds to the outer automorphism .
the subdiagram to the right of @xmath165 in ( [ eq : g2f4 ] ) is the dynkin diagram of @xmath160
. it must be then that the monodromy around @xmath75 exchanges the two simple roots of @xmath160 .
this is not in the weyl group of @xmath160 .
it is in the weyl group of @xmath166 however . indeed ,
if @xmath167 is the weyl group of the lie algebra @xmath168 then @xmath169 where this latter @xmath124 is precisely the exchange generated above by the monodromy . from the heterotic language we can argue that the bundle we are constructing here is indeed a @xmath2-bundle and not an su(3)-bundle
this is because the monodromy causes the effective gauge group to be observed to be @xmath170 rather than @xmath155 @xcite . since there is a maximal subgroup @xmath171 we should expect an @xmath170 gauge symmetry to be preserved by a @xmath2-bundle . indeed
the way that one can demonstrate the maximal embedding of ( [ eq : e8g2 ] ) is via an argument along the lines of the diagram in ( [ eq : g2f4 ] ) .
this example shows a rule ( which follows from donagi s construction @xcite ) that the weyl group of the structure group , @xmath98 , of the bundle is generated by the monodromy on the part of the picard lattice of the rational elliptic surfaces .
we also see that if the @xmath157 collisions of the type along @xmath75 in figure [ fig : g2 ] coalesce into pairs then we lose any monodromy of this type and reduce the monodromy group to that of su(3 ) .
this is in agreement with the similar statement that such a pairing results in an @xmath155 unbroken gauge symmetry .
take one of the generators of the mordell - weil group , @xmath158 , of the rational elliptic surface in a generic fibre .
this has an orbit of six elements via the monodromy around @xmath8 .
we may therefore build a six - fold branched cover @xmath115 .
this again we may call the `` spectral curve '' as in section [ ss : a1 ] .
it is important to note however that this spectral cover for the @xmath2 case is not quite as simple as that for the su(2 ) case .
it is now untrue that @xmath147 and so we can not identify the ramond - ramond moduli of the type iia string with the jacobian of the spectral curve . this story is familiar one in the theory of branched covers and has been studied extensively by donagi in the current context @xcite .
the general idea is that one may identify a `` prym '' which is a subspace of the jacobian of the spectral curve .
this prym is also an abelian variety .
one can then show that this prym matches the ramond - ramond moduli in terms of the type iia theory and that it correctly reproduces the moduli space of the bundle on the heterotic side .
the former was shown by kanev @xcite and the latter by donagi @xcite .
the basic construction of the prym is as follows .
let @xmath172 be the weyl group of @xmath98 .
the spectral curve may be thought of as an @xmath17-cover of @xmath8 where @xmath17 is some representation of @xmath172 .
that is to say , the point - like fibres of the map @xmath115 form a representation of @xmath172 under monodromy .
the problem with @xmath2 that we did not have with @xmath1 in the last section , is that to find the agreement @xmath147 we have the _ wrong _ representation . in order to find agreement , we need the natural representation of the weyl group on the root space i.e. , the representation with dimension equal to @xmath173 .
thus we replace one cover of @xmath8 with another one and try to take the latter s jacobian .
we can not do this literally as the root space representation of the weyl group is not a permutation representation .
thus the supposed spectral curve for this representation can not actually be thought of as a branched cover .
instead consider the `` cameral cover '' .
this is a ( @xmath172-galois ) cover where the representation is given by weyl chambers .
this is a @xmath174-fold cover of @xmath8 where @xmath174 is the number of elements in @xmath175 .
let @xmath176 be the cameral cover .
let @xmath177 be the root lattice of @xmath98 and let @xmath178 be the jacobian of @xmath176 .
clearly @xmath172 has an action on both @xmath177 and @xmath178 .
the prym we desire may be written as @xmath179 where the @xmath172 subscript means that @xmath180 for all @xmath181 , @xmath182 , @xmath183 . in general this
is a disconnected set of abelian varieties .
it is an interesting question how to deal with the cases where there is more than one component in this prym . here
we will assume we are dealing with the component connected to the identity if there is more than one component .
in other words there is an @xmath184 such that @xmath185 where @xmath85 is a lattice of dimension @xmath186 .
a little algebra shows that @xmath187 in the simplest case of @xmath188 , the weyl group is the symmetric group on @xmath189 objects , the spectral curve is an @xmath189-fold cover of @xmath8 , the prym is equal to the jacobian of the spectral cover on the roots of @xmath98 rather than the @xmath189-dimensional permutation representation .
these two spectral curves happened to coincide for @xmath190 . ] and @xmath191 .
for general @xmath98 life is more complicated .
if the situation is sufficiently generic that each monodromy corresponds to a weyl reflection in one root then @xmath184 may be determined .
let there be @xmath92 branch points .
we show in the appendix that @xmath192 applying this formula to our @xmath2-bundle , we have @xmath157 collisions of type ( a ) and it is straight - forward to show that there are @xmath193 collisions of type ( b ) .
thus @xmath194 and @xmath195 .
this value of @xmath184 agrees with the quaternionic dimension of the moduli space of @xmath2-bundles on a k3 with @xmath153 again .
it is a simple matter now to extend this construction to @xmath196 .
if we allow the collisions of type ( a ) to pair up , we lose the monodromy which elevated @xmath197 to @xmath2 .
thus we should only have an @xmath197-bundle .
now we only count the type ( b ) collisions as branch points and so @xmath198 and @xmath199 again in agreement with the direct bundle computation .
now we want to try to build a bundle with no structure group at all .
this suggests picking the generic rational elliptic surface in @xmath52 to have a trivial group .
this forces the rational elliptic surface to be of the form @xmath200{$\mathrm{ii}^*$ } } \put(420,550){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(460,570){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$\mathrm{i}_1 $ } } \put(155,600){\makebox(0,0)[lb]{$f$ } } \end{picture}\ ] ] or by letting the two @xmath42 s coalesce to form a type ii fibre .
if every @xmath45 is of this form within @xmath56 then we will have a whole curve of type @xmath201 fibres . by the usual f - theory recipe this means we have an unbroken @xmath22 gauge symmetry .
this is most reasonable if our bundle has no structure group ! of course , what we are talking about here are the `` point - like instantons '' of @xcite .
( 10887,3543)(889,-3673 ) ( 901,-3061 ) ( 1 , 0)4500 ( 3601,-661 ) ( 5701,-1711 ) ( 1 , 0)1200 ( 1501,-961 ) ( 7501,-3286 ) ( 1 , 0)4125 ( 9601,-811 ) ( 7651,-436 ) ( 9226,-1336 ) ( 1351,-2611 ) ( 1576,-3211 ) ( 7801,-2161 ) ( 7876,-2836 ) ( 3676,-811)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5476,-3211)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4576,-2611)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4951,-3586)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4951,-2986)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5401,-1111)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11701,-1936)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11551,-2686)(0,0)[lb ] ( 8776,-3211)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11776,-3436)(0,0)[lb ] ( 10726,-286)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11401,-661)(0,0)[lb ] the geometry of @xmath0 point - like instantons in f - theory or type iia language has been explained in great length in various places ( for example , @xcite ) .
the key point is that within @xmath56 , there are collisions between the curve of @xmath201 fibres and the curve of remaining @xmath42 fibres within @xmath95 .
a simple calculation in intersection theory shows this happens at @xmath202 points .
the resulting threefold , @xmath52 , produced by this fibration is highly singular over each of these @xmath202 points .
it may be smoothed out by blowing up each such collision in @xmath56 .
each such collision and the resulting blow - up in shown in figure [ fig : sm ] . in f - theory language
these blow - ups give tensor multiplets .
each of the @xmath202 collisions is associated to a point - like instanton for the heterotic string on a k3 surface where each instanton has @xmath203 .
thus we have a total @xmath204 given by @xmath202 yet again .
what we would like to consider now is whether we actually have the correct moduli space for these @xmath202 points .
each point - like instanton should presumably have as its moduli space the k3 surface , @xmath23 , itself .
we may restrict attention to such a single instanton by fixing @xmath205 . to achieve the configuration of the discriminant locus in figure [ fig : sm ] we are required to restrict the forms of the polynomials @xmath91 and @xmath92 in equation ( [ eq : wei ] ) . a type @xmath201 fibre requires @xmath91 to vanish order at least 4 and @xmath92 to vanish order 5 .
the divisors class @xmath8 therefore divides into two parts @xmath206 $ ] , where @xmath207 + 12[f]$ ] .
the collisions in figure [ fig : sm ] occur at collisions between @xmath208 and @xmath48 .
we are free to move these collisions around by varying @xmath92 .
it was argued in @xcite that the location of these collisions corresponded to the point - like instantons . to be more precise ,
consider the elliptic fibration of @xmath209 given by @xmath41 .
we also have the fibration @xmath210 .
if a point - like instanton lives at a point @xmath211 and the collision in the left of figure [ fig : sm ] occurs at a point @xmath212 then @xmath213 .
thus by varying the complex structure of @xmath52 we may move the point - like instanton around in the `` base '' direction of @xmath23 . in order to show that the moduli space of this point - like instanton is given by @xmath23 we need to be able to vary its position in the `` fibre '' direction of @xmath23 .
this degree of freedom is provided by the ramond - ramond degrees of freedom over @xmath52 as we now show . on the right - hand side of figure [ fig : sm ] the dotted line @xmath214 denotes the proper transform of the @xmath45-curve which had passed through the collision point on the left - hand side .
as can be seen from the figure , @xmath214 does not touch the discriminant locus of the resulting elliptic fibration .
thus , the elliptic fibration restricted to @xmath214 has no bad fibres .
this can only happen if the fibre is constant .
let us refer to this constant elliptic curve as @xmath215 .
thus @xmath216 .
wedging by the generator of @xmath217 gives an injective map @xmath218 .
thus @xmath215 contributes 2 real degrees of freedom to the ramond - ramond moduli .
we may rephrase this in terms of spectral curves again . as the group of our generic rational elliptic surface is now trivial
, one might at first think that the spectral curve has simply collapsed to the zero section of @xmath41 .
let us instead say that the spectral curve , @xmath116 , has degenerated in this case and has become reducible , @xmath219 .
now the jacobian of the spectral curve is isomorphic to the jacobian of @xmath215 .
one can map this jacobian into the intermediate jacobian of @xmath52 .
again , this is essentially the abel - jacobi mapping of @xcite .
now let us construct the moduli space of one instanton , @xmath220 . as argued above
, there is a fibration @xmath221 where the degree of freedom in @xmath8 is generated by moving around the point of collision of @xmath95 within @xmath48 .
the fibre of this map is @xmath222 .
however , since @xmath215 is constant all along @xmath214 , @xmath215 is actually the elliptic fibre of @xmath41 over the same point in @xmath8 .
thus we construct @xmath220 by replacing each elliptic fibre in @xmath41 by its jacobian .
given that @xmath223 has a section , one may show that the resulting fibration has the same complex structure as the original ( for example , see proposition 5.3.2 of @xcite ) . _
thus we see that @xmath224 as desired . _
actually this fibration of @xmath220 is a little more subtle than first meets the eye .
we have assumed that @xmath215 is a smooth elliptic curve .
that is , we have assumed that our point - like instanton lives in a smooth fibre of @xmath41 .
it is quite possible however that it lives in a bad fibre , such as an i@xmath119 fibre . in this case
the story of the discriminant locus is given in figure [ fig : smi1 ] .
( 10887,3543)(889,-3673 ) ( 901,-3061 ) ( 1 , 0)4500 ( 3601,-661 ) ( 0,-1)2775 ( 5701,-1711 ) ( 1 , 0)1200 ( 1501,-961 ) ( 7501,-3286 ) ( 1 , 0)4125 ( 9601,-811 ) ( 7651,-436 ) ( 9226,-1336 ) ( 6 , 5)1350 ( 1576,-3211 ) ( 7876,-2836 ) ( 4379,-3128 ) ( 1590,-653 ) ( 8015,-158 ) ( 4086,-2866 ) ( 3676,-811)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5476,-3211)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4576,-2611)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4951,-3586)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4951,-2986)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5401,-1111)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11701,-1936)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11551,-2686)(0,0)[lb ] ( 8776,-3211)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11776,-3436)(0,0)[lb ] ( 10726,-286)(0,0)[lb ] ( 11401,-661)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3654,-1921)(0,0)[lb ] ( 10231,-850)(0,0)[lb ] in this case @xmath215 is a degenerate elliptic curve as one might expect .
what is interesting is how we now have a transverse intersection of two curves of i@xmath119 fibres in the discriminant .
such a collision produces a singularity in @xmath52 which generically can not be resolved .
that is , _
@xmath52 degenerates when we move the point - like instanton onto a bad fibre of @xmath23 .
_ this is the only way that we could have @xmath224 .
when we are on a bad fibre , the intermediate jacobian must degenerate and so @xmath52 must degenerate . for more than one instanton
we let @xmath225 where the @xmath226 are the constant elliptic curves coming from the scrolls formed by each of the blow - ups required .
it is not hard to see that our construction above will produce a hilbert scheme of @xmath202 points in @xmath23 as expected . in the language above , our prym is the product of the jacobians of @xmath226 and so @xmath227 it is known that there is a close relationship between point - like instantons on bad fibres and the very subtle case where the bundle on @xmath23 in question is the tangent bundle .
this has been discussed in @xcite .
it was also explicitly seen in @xcite in terms of a construction from toric geometry that the spectral curve degenerated in precisely the way we have described here in the tangent bundle case .
let @xmath228 and @xmath229 be the lattices introduced in the last section from the two @xmath22-bundles or sub - bundles thereof and let @xmath80 be the transcendental lattice of the k3 on which the heterotic string is compactified .
let @xmath230 be the monodromy - invariant part of @xmath6 as we go around the stable degeneration discussed in section [ s : sd ] .
the boundary of the moduli space corresponding to this degeneration of either the heterotic string or the type iia string is of the following form .
it acquires a fibration structure @xmath231 where the complex dimension of @xmath232 equals the quaternionic dimension of @xmath233 and the generic fibre is an abelian variety @xmath234 for some @xmath235 and some lattice @xmath150 . in identifying the moduli spaces
, we must identify these abelian varieties and thus the description of the lattice @xmath150 in the heterotic picture and the type iia picture .
this leads to the key claim that @xmath236 this equation is essential to the notion of duality between the heterotic string on a k3 surface and the type iia string ( or f - theory ) on a threefold . as well as automatically identifying the abelian fibres of the moduli space , ( [ eq : yes ] )
also indicates how to naturally identify the bases , @xmath232 , as follows . and
the type iia picture of @xmath232 can be identified locally .
it is possible that type iia @xmath232 may map many - to - one to the heterotic @xmath232 .
it is reasonable to expect this to happen when the prym has more than one component . ]
recall that in the type iia string @xmath232 represents the moduli space of complex structures on @xmath4 and in the heterotic string @xmath232 represents the moduli space of complex structures on @xmath23 and the moduli of the spectral curve for the bundle .
this map shows how the variation of hodge structure on @xmath4 , in terms of periods of the holomorphic 3-form on elements of @xmath237 , may be reduced into a statement about the variation of hodge structure on @xmath23 , in terms of periods of the holomorphic 2-form on this k3 surface on elements of the transcendental lattice , @xmath80 .
the bundle data becomes encoded in a variation of hodge structure of a one dimensional object the spectral curve . in the case of @xmath188 , @xmath85 is simply @xmath238 and we recover the full moduli space of @xmath116 . in general we only have a sub - variation of hodge structure for the spectral curve .
thus the duality between the heterotic string and the type iia string appears to be encapsulated by relating the 3-dimensional structure of the type iia compactification to a 2-dimensional and a 1-dimensional structure for the heterotic string .
that is , the threefold is related to a k3 surface and a bundle .
it is interesting to compare this situation to mirror symmetry .
one of the simplest ways of describing the mirror symmetry principal for a threefold is the exchange of the even ( or vertical ) integral cohomology with the odd ( or horizontal ) integral cohomology .
this picture was first suggested in the work of @xcite and then spelt out more clearly in section 5 of @xcite and @xcite .
the way that these integral cohomologies can be identified requires one to go to the `` large complex structure '' of one of the threefolds .
this was explained in @xcite . only at this boundary _
point _ in the moduli space did one expect the two mirror theories to be exactly equivalent .
away from this boundary point the mirror equivalence becomes complicated by world - sheet instanton effects which come from rational curves .
heterotic / type iia duality has a much richer structure than mirror symmetry .
firstly our boundary where the two theories agree exactly is no longer a point but has a fairly large dimension .
secondly one can see that _ both _ the heterotic string and the type iia string are prone to instanton effects .
each of these can be probed individually by moving away from the boundary in a certain direction .
for example , in order to probe the heterotic string world - sheet instanton effects .
] we need to move away from the boundary without changing the dilaton in the type iia string . in effect
we need to keep the section of @xmath23 infinitely large but we may let the elliptic fibres become finite in size . clearly this moves us away from the stable degeneration discussed in section [ s : sd ] .
it is also evident that the exact correspondence between our moduli spaces will break down .
indeed we may go around a closed loop in the moduli space of @xmath4 producing a highly non - trivial monodromy on @xmath237 .
if there were no quantum corrections to this moduli space then such a monodromy would have to correspond to some sort of t - duality on the moduli space of heterotic strings .
this would imply that the moduli space of complex structures on @xmath4 would be globally _ exactly _ in the form of some teichmller space divided out by this t - duality group .
this is not true for a generic threefold .
thus the periods in our heterotic string on a k3 surface must generically become `` mixed '' between the variation of hodge structure of @xmath23 and the variation of hodge structure of the spectral curve .
that is , the notion of a k3 surface and the notion of a bundle will become somewhat confused .
this is analogous to the way that the notion of a 0-cycle and a 2-cycle can be confused by mirror symmetry away from the large radius limit .
this confusion in the heterotic string is presumably accounted for by some world - sheet instanton effect just as rational curves appeared in mirror symmetry
. it would be very interesting to study this further .
another amusing fact in this picture is that we know that world - sheet instanton effects must vanish for the heterotic string on a k3 surface if `` the spin connection if embedded in the gauge group '' . in other words , when our bundle becomes the tangent bundle .
if this can be understood in the language of this paper then it should be quite a potent weapon in understanding the global structure of the moduli space further .
it implies that there is a whole @xmath239 exact subspace of the moduli space coming from deformations of the k3 surface .
this probes deeply into regions of the moduli space where the type iia string becomes strongly coupled .
thus we may calculate instanton effects on the type iia side too .
we should emphasize that there is a big difference between mirror symmetry and the map ( [ eq : yes ] ) .
the map given in ( [ eq : yes ] ) does not include the whole of @xmath6 and it does not contain the whole of @xmath240 .
in fact given the nature of the moduli space of strings on k3 surfaces @xcite one might hope that such a map should include the total cohomology @xmath241 .
it would be very satisfying , as well as useful , if we could enlarge the identification of ( [ eq : yes ] ) to include these larger integral structures . in conclusion
, the moduli space of hypermultiplets of @xmath3 theories in four dimensions coming from compactifications of the type iia string or the heterotic string contains some beautiful structures .
these structures are similar to those of mirror symmetry but appear to be much more powerful .
as well as providing insight into the nonperturbative properties of @xmath3 theories in four dimensions we may also learn some lessons about nonperturbative effects in general in string theory .
much of the earlier stages of this work were done in collaboration with d. morrison .
i am also particularly grateful to r. donagi and r. hain for explaining the mathematics of the appendix to me .
it is a pleasure to thank m. gross , d. reed and e. witten for useful conversations .
we wish to prove the following : let @xmath172 be the weyl group of some given lie group @xmath98 and let @xmath177 be the root lattice of @xmath98 .
let @xmath242 be a @xmath172-galois cameral cover , @xmath176 be irreducible and @xmath8 be a curve of genus 0 .
then in the generic case @xmath243 where @xmath92 is the number of branch points .
consider the _ representation ring _ of @xmath172 denoted @xmath244 .
an element of this ring is a formal sum of the form @xmath245,\ ] ] where @xmath246 and @xmath247 is an irreducible representation .
there is an augmentation map @xmath248 given by @xmath249)=\dim(v_\alpha)$ ] .
let us denote the simplicial chain complex of @xmath176 by @xmath250 and the simplicial chain complex of @xmath8 by @xmath251 .
we may regard @xmath250 and @xmath251 as @xmath252-modules ( where the action of @xmath172 on @xmath251 is trivial ) .
the fibre of the covering @xmath253 is a set of points corresponding to the weyl chambers of @xmath172 except over the points @xmath254 , @xmath255 , where the covering is branched . at each @xmath256
there is a monodromy action on the fibres given by an element of the weyl group which we denote @xmath257 .
one may show from standard methods that the euler characteristic of the curve @xmath176 is equal to the euler characteristic of the chain complex @xmath250 . regarding @xmath250 as a chain complex of @xmath252-modules
we may define @xmath259 as a refinement of the usual euler characteristic .
the object @xmath260 reduces to the usual euler characteristic under the map @xmath261 . by the same argument as above @xmath262 .
thus @xmath263 - b[\c(w ) ] + \sum_{j=1}^b\left[\c(w/\langle\sigma_j\rangle)\right].\ ] ] it is now a straight - forward matter of using the representation theory of groups to determine @xmath184 .
firstly one can show that @xmath264 .
the statement that our cameral cover is generic amounts to the statement that the monodromy about any @xmath256 corresponds to a simple weyl reflection in a single root .
then @xmath265 is the dimension of the root space of @xmath98 invariant under such a reflection which is @xmath266 . | a type iia string ( or f - theory ) compactified on a threefold is believed to be dual to a heterotic string on a k3 surface times a 2-torus ( or on a k3 surface ) .
we consider how the resulting moduli space of hypermultiplets is identified between these two pictures in the case of the @xmath0 heterotic string . as examples we discuss @xmath1-bundles and @xmath2-bundles on the k3 surface and the case of point - like instantons .
we are lead to a rather beautiful identification between the integral cohomology of the threefold and some integral structures on the heterotic side somewhat reminiscent of mirror symmetry .
we discuss the consequences for probing nonperturbative effects in the both the type iia string and the heterotic string . 0 |
Subsets and Splits