diff --git a/src/presenters/Whip_WPMessagePresenter.php b/src/presenters/Whip_WPMessagePresenter.php
index <HASH>..<HASH> 100644
--- a/src/presenters/Whip_WPMessagePresenter.php
+++ b/src/presenters/Whip_WPMessagePresenter.php
@@ -48,12 +48,12 @@ class Whip_WPMessagePresenter implements Whip_MessagePresenter {
 
 		/* translators: 1: is a link to dismiss url 2: closing link tag */
 		$dismissButton = sprintf(
-			__( '<p>%1$sRemind me again after 4 weeks.%2$s</p>', 'wordpress' ),
+			__( '%1$sRemind me again in 4 weeks.%2$s', 'wordpress' ),
 			'<a href="' . $dismissListener->getDismissURL() . '">',
 			'</a>'
 		);
 
-		printf( '<div class="error">%1$s<p>%2$s</p></div>', $this->kses( $this->message->body() ), $dismissButton );
+		printf( '<div class="error"><p>%1$s</p><p>%2$s</p></div>', $this->kses( $this->message->body() ), $dismissButton );
 	}
 
 	/**
Move the paragraph out of the translation

Change the `after` to an `in`