credits) there is a silhouette of Geezer Butler playing in the moonlight. Personnel 1969-1979 Disc One tracks 1-16; Disc Two tracks 1-13 The albums that this line-up is featured on are Black Sabbath, Paranoid, Master of Reality, Vol. 4, Sabbath Bloody Sabbath, Sabotage, Technical Ecstasy, and Never Say Die!. Ozzy Osbourne - vocals, harmonica (only track 2 on disc I) Tony Iommi - guitars, piano, synthesizer Geezer Butler - bass Bill Ward - drums Rodger Bain - producer (Black Sabbath, Paranoid, and Master of Reality) Patrick Meehan - producer (Vol. 4) Mike Butcher - co-producer (Sabotage, Technical Ecstasy, Never Say Die!) Robin Black - co-producer (Sabotage, Technical Ecstasy, Never Say Die!) 1980 Disc Two track 14 The album that this line-up is featured on is Heaven and Hell. Ronnie James Dio - vocals Tony Iommi - guitars Geezer Butler - bass Bill Ward - drums 1981-1982 Disc Two track 15 The album that this line-up is featured on is Mob Rules. Ronnie James Dio - vocals Tony Iommi - guitars Geezer Butler - bass Vinny Appice - drums 1983-1984 Disc Two track 16 The album that this line-up is featured on is Born Again. Ian Gillan - vocals Tony Iommi - guitars Geezer Butler - bass Bill Ward - drums Charts Certifications References Black Sabbath compilation albums Best of Black Sabbath, The Sanctuary Records compilation albums