based schools want to continue their traditional faith education, they are permitted to do so, however it must be in addition to but separate from the ERC. This is viewed by the law's opponents as closed secularism, as opposed to open secularism, and a perversion of the proper understanding of pluralism and, of most concern, a breach of their right to teach the faith. A Quebec Superior Court agreed with the school's position in 2010, but in 2012 an appellate court sided with the government. On further appeal the Supreme Court of Canada held that the Minister's decision to force the teaching of Catholicism from a neutral standpoint unreasonably violated religious freedom, and was sent back to the Minister for reconsideration.Loyola High School v Quebec (Attorney General), 2015 SCC 12, [2015] 1 SCR 613. See also Human rights in Canada History of freedom of religion in Canada Multiculturalism in Canada Office of Religious Freedom History of Seventh-day Adventist freedom of religion in Canada Trinity Western University § Controversies and court cases Act respecting the laicity of the State Artur Pawlowski References Further reading Ross, Malcolm (1991). A Paper on Religious Freedom ... contain[ing] the complete text of the address given on September 6, 1991 at the Crystal Palace, Dieppe, N.B.'' ... sponsored by the Canadian Free Speech League. Moncton, N.B.: Stronghold Publishing Co. 18 p. Without ISBN External links Religious Freedom in Canada (Evangelical Fellowship of Canada) Human rights in Canada