nityathakkar commited on
Commit
2db8fa1
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 69ec6ca

critic now too strict

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. app.py +3 -4
app.py CHANGED
@@ -359,15 +359,14 @@ Here are step-by-step instructions:
359
  2. Evaluate every piece of feedback in the feedback list:
360
  - For each feedback item, it is imperative that you evaluate the correctness of the feedback. If there is a quote in the feedback, ensure that the quote appears VERBATIM in the paper. You need to check every quote and factual claim in the feedback and edit for correctness, as it is imperative all the feedback is correct.
361
  - For each feedback item, evaluate if it is clear. You should make sure it would not confuse or frustrate the reviewer who reads it.
362
- - Make sure every comment-feedback pair addresses an issue with the review. If it does not, remove it.
363
 
364
  3. Edit comments based on evaluations:
365
- - Do NOT ADD any new points unless the previous feedback OBVIOUSLY missed something important.
366
  - For each comment that needs editing, re-write the feedback concisely in the following format:
367
  - Comment: {{the comment of interest}}
368
  - Feedback: {{your short feedback}}
369
- - If you do not identify any issues with a comment-feedback pair, do not modify it.
370
- - If the review has no issues at all, simply respond with: "Thanks for your hard work!"
371
 
372
  Remember:
373
  - Be concise, limiting your feedback for each comment to 1-2 sentences.
 
359
  2. Evaluate every piece of feedback in the feedback list:
360
  - For each feedback item, it is imperative that you evaluate the correctness of the feedback. If there is a quote in the feedback, ensure that the quote appears VERBATIM in the paper. You need to check every quote and factual claim in the feedback and edit for correctness, as it is imperative all the feedback is correct.
361
  - For each feedback item, evaluate if it is clear. You should make sure it would not confuse or frustrate the reviewer who reads it.
362
+ - Make sure every comment-feedback pair addresses an issue with the review, otherwise remove it.
363
 
364
  3. Edit comments based on evaluations:
365
+ - Do not add any new points unless the previous feedback obviously missed something important.
366
  - For each comment that needs editing, re-write the feedback concisely in the following format:
367
  - Comment: {{the comment of interest}}
368
  - Feedback: {{your short feedback}}
369
+ - If you do not identify any issues with a comment-feedback pair, do not edit it.
 
370
 
371
  Remember:
372
  - Be concise, limiting your feedback for each comment to 1-2 sentences.