Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 1 of 9




               Exhibit E
               (REDACTED)
      Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 2 of 9




                   <A F;8 GA<F87 EF4F8E 7<EFD<6F 6BGDF
                      EBGF;8DA 7<EFD<6F B9 A8I KBD>




OEIK DKH@EJCO+ EJ?-+

     Plaintiff,                                       ?bobe =\mbhg Jh- 07,\o,4316,(FON)

o-

DKJC GKJC Q?HKQ@HEJG JAPSKNG                          8JC8DF D8CBDF B9
PA?DJKHKCU HEIEPA@ =J@                                6;D<EFBC;8D 4' @4DF<A8L
Q?HKQ@HEJG (=IANE?=)+ HP@-                            I<F; D8EC86F FB 74@4:8E
     Defendants.




                   N^li^\m_neer ln[fbmm^] mabl 03ma ]Zr h_ FZgnZkr+ 1/08




                   YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
                              ?akblmhia^k =- IZkmbg^s



                   6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA :BH8DA87

                              5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D
         Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 3 of 9




?ZgZ]Z+ Eg\- (zHAO{)1 Zg] ma^ ?^kmb_b^] LZm^gm RZenZmbhg =gZerlm (z?LR={)2 ]^lb`gZmbhg _khf
Pa^ >nlbg^ll @^o^ehif^gm =\Z]^fr (z>@={)+3 bg Z]]bmbhg mh ^Zkgbg` ma^ ]^lb`gZmbhg Zl Z
?^kmb_b^] Ln[eb\ =\\hngmZgm (z?L={) _khf ma^ lmZm^ h_ ?Zeb_hkgbZ-

        = \hir h_ fr \nkk^gm \nkkb\nenf obmZ^+ pab\a lnffZkbs^l fr jnZeb_b\Zmbhgl Zg]
ikh_^llbhgZe ^qi^kb^g\^+ bl ZmmZ\a^] Zl EOTQPaXQ *- =mmZ\a^] Zl EOTQPaXQ + bl Z eblmbg`+ mh ma^
[^lm h_ fr k^\hee^\mbhg+ h_ fr ]^ihlbmbhg+ Zk[bmkZmbhg Zg] mkbZe m^lmbfhgr ho^k ma^ ik^\^]bg` _hnk
r^Zkl- E aZo^ \h,Znmahk^] hg^ Zkmb\e^ pbmabg ma^ eZlm m^g r^Zkl- Pa^ mbme^ h_ maZm Zkmb\e^ bl
z?Ze\neZmbg` Zg] Lkhobg` @ZfZ`^l bg BkZg\abl^ P^kfbgZmbhg ?Zl^l{ Zg] bm pZl in[ebla^] Zl iZkm
h_ ma^ =>= 20lm =ggnZe Bhknf hg BkZg\ablbg` bg 1//7-

        Omhg^Pnkg \aZk`^l $484 i^k ahnk _hk mbf^ E li^g] \hglnembg`+ Zll^llbg` ]ZfZ`^l Zg]
mbf^ maZm fZr [^ li^gm m^lmb_rbg` k^eZm^] mh fr ]ZfZ`^l ZgZerlbl- J^bma^k fr+ ghk fr lmZ__}l+
ghk Omhg^Pnkg}l \hfi^glZmbhg bl Z__^\m^] bg Zgr pZr [r ^bma^k ma^ \hg\enlbhgl E aZo^ k^Z\a^] hk
ma^ hnm\hf^ h_ mabl eZplnbm-


<<'     4EE<:A@8AF
        E aZo^ [^^g k^mZbg^] Zl Zg ^qi^km bg mabl fZmm^k [r G&H CZm^l HHL+ \hngl^e _hk LeZbgmb__
OEIK Dhe]bg`l+ Eg\- (a^k^Z_m^k zOEIK{ hk zLeZbgmb__{)+ mh ^oZenZm^ ma^ ^\hghfb\ ]ZfZ`^l
lnlmZbg^] [r LeZbgmb__ Zl Z k^lnem h_ Dhg` Ghg` n?ehn]ebgd J^mphkd P^\agheh`r Hbfbm^] (zQ?H
Dhg` Ghg`{) Zg] n?ehn]ebgd (=f^kb\Z)+ Hm]-}l (zQ?H =f^kb\Z{) (\hee^\mbo^er+ zn?ehn]ebgd{ hk
z@^_^g]Zgm{) Zee^`^] bg_kbg`^f^gm h_ Q-O- LZm^gm Jh- 8+625+578 (zma^ }578 LZm^gm{ hk ma^
zLZm^gm,bg,Onbm{)- Ohe^er _hk ma^ inkihl^ h_ i^k_hkfbg` Z ]ZfZ`^l ZgZerlbl bg mabl fZmm^k+ E aZo^
Zllnf^] maZm ma^ LZm^gm,bg,Onbm bl oZeb]+ ^g_hk\^Z[e^ [r OEIK+ Zg] bg_kbg`^] [r @^_^g]Zgm-


bgoheo^f^gm bg iZm^gmbg`+ fZkd^mbg`+ oZenZmbhg+ EL eZp+ g^`hmbZmbhg+ Zg] bgm^ee^\mnZe Zll^m fZgZ`^f^gm-{
(ppp-eb\^glbg`\^kmb_b\Zmbhg-hk`)
1
  AlmZ[ebla^] bg 0854+ ma^ HAO bl Z ikh_^llbhgZe lh\b^mr \hfikbl^] h_ g^Zker 4+/// f^f[^kl ^g`Z`^] bg ma^ mkZgl_^k+
nl^+ ]^o^ehif^gm+ fZgn_Z\mnk^ Zg] fZkd^mbg` h_ bgm^ee^\mnZe ikhi^kmr- HAO bl Z f^f[^k lh\b^mr h_ ma^ Hb\^glbg`
Aq^\nmbo^l Oh\b^mr Egm^kgZmbhgZe+ Eg\-+ pbma Z phke]pb]^ f^f[^klabi h_ ho^k 8+/// f^f[^kl bg 2/ gZmbhgZe
lh\b^mb^l+ k^ik^l^gmbg` ho^k 8/ \hngmkb^l- (ppp-e^lnlZ\ZgZ]Z-hk`)
2
  Pa^ ?LR= ikh`kZf \nkkb\nenf zbl ]^lb`g^] mh ik^iZk^ _bgZg\bZe ZgZerlml+ m^\agheh`r mkZgl_^k ikh_^llbhgZel+
bgm^ee^\mnZe ikhi^kmr fZgZ`^kl+ eb\^glbg` fZgZ`^kl+ bgo^gmhkl+ iZm^gm eZpr^kl Zg] hma^k [nlbg^ll ]^o^ehif^gm
^q^\nmbo^l pbma ma^ ldbee l^m g^\^llZkr mh oZen^ iZm^gml-{ (ppp-\ioZ-bg_h)
3
  Pa^ >@= zbl \hffbmm^] mh ikhob]bg` ngiZkZee^e^] ^]n\ZmbhgZe hiihkmngbmb^l mh ma^ [nlbg^ll \hffngbmr-{ Eml
fbllbhg zbl mh ]^o^ehi Z \nkkb\nenf Zg] k^\knbm ma^ bglmkn\mhkl maZm pbee [^lm l^ko^ hnk f^f[^kl bg ]^o^ehibg` ma^
\kbmb\Ze mabgdbg` ldbeel g^\^llZkr mh `khp ma^bk [nlbg^ll^l-{ (ppp-[]Z\Z]^fr-\hf)

                                                         7
8JC8DF D8CBDF B9 6' 4' @4DF<A8L                                                6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA
6<H<? 46F<BA AB' *1&6H&.-+0&#=ED$                                          :BH8DA87 5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D
         Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 4 of 9




        OdrkhZf QO Zelh l^eel @ZriZll \k^]bml makhn`a Zg hgebg^ ihkmZe+ pab\a l^ko^l Zl
OdrkhZf}l ^q\enlbo^ lhnk\^ _hk \hglnf^k lZe^l h_ ma^l^ l^kob\^l-04 =l ^qieZbg^] bg ln[l^jn^gm
l^\mbhgl+ ma^l^ Zk^ \k^]bml mh Z nl^k}l Z\\hngm Zg] Zk^ ghm Zllh\bZm^] pbma Z mZg`b[e^ \Zk] ebd^
OdrkhZf}l @ZriZll \Zk]l-05

                             (1)    OdrkhZf Cf[D
        Hh\Zm^] bg >^kebg+ C^kfZgr+ OdrkhZf Cf[D bl Z paheer,hpg^] ln[lb]bZkr h_ OdrkhZf
QO-06 OdrkhZf Cf[D pZl _hkf^] bg 1/06 Zg] ]blmkb[nm^l @ZriZll \Zk]l Zg] fh[be^ ahmlihml bg
Ankhi^-07 Pabl ln[lb]bZkr l^eel @ZriZll \Zk]l mh [hma ]blmkb[nmhkl Zg] ^g] nl^kl [nm ]h^l ghm l^ee
@ZriZll \k^]bml makhn`a ma^ OdrkhZf hgebg^ ihkmZe-08



                           (2)   OdrkhZf O^kob\^l+ Hbfbm^]
        >Zl^] bg Dhg` Ghg`+ OdrkhZf O^kob\^l bl Z paheer,hpg^] ln[lb]bZkr h_ OEIK Zg] Z
lblm^k \hfiZgr h_ OdrkhZf QO-10 OdrkhZf O^kob\^l fZkd^ml+ l^eel+ Zg] ]blmkb[nm^l OdrkhZf}l
ikh]n\ml Zg] l^kob\^l

        OdrkhZf O^kob\^l Zelh phkdl ]bk^\mer pbma \hgmkZ\m fZgn_Z\mnk^kl bg ?abgZ mh ikh]n\^
@ZriZll \Zk]l Zg] fh[be^ ahmlihml Zg] l^eel ma^f _hk Z lfZee fZkdni mh [hma OdrkhZf QO Zg]
OdrkhZf Cf[D-12

                         [)      Business Model
        OdrkhZf zZ``k^`Zm^l ]ZmZ l^kob\^l _khf mhi \Zkkb^kl Zkhng] ma^ phke]wWZg] ikhob]^lX Z
_neer fZgZ`^] `eh[Ze pbk^e^ll ]ZmZ l^kob\^-{13 Eg fhk^ lbfieblmb\ m^kfl+ ma^ \hfiZgr ink\aZl^l
ln[l\kb[^k b]^gmbmr fh]ne^ (zOEI{) \Zk]l _khf fh[be^ g^mphkd hi^kZmhkl (zIJKl{) bg ma^


04
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 07,08+ 11,13-
05
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 11,12-
06
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 17+ 63+ 0/8,00/-
07
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 03+ 08-
08
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 07,08+ 10+ 12-
1/
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 12- Pa^l^ k^o^gn^l \hgmkZlm pbma @ZriZll \k^]bml ink\aZl^] [r OdrkhZf Cf[D \nlmhf^kl
]bk^\mer makhn`a OdrkhZf}l hgebg^ ihkmZe- Pa^l^ k^o^gn^l Zk^ k^ihkm^] hg OdrkhZf Cf[D bg\hf^ lmZm^f^gml Zg]
nl^] mh iZr bml ^qi^gl^l- N^o^gn^l _hk ma^l^ @ZriZll^l Zk^ k^ihkm^] hg OdrkhZf}l bg\hf^ lmZm^f^gm-
10
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 17+ 0/2-
11
   @bl\nllbhg pbma Akb\ LeZf Zg] NZr Mbg-
12
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 0/2+ 0/6,0/7-
13
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Aqab[bm 0/ (OEIKY//30876,1//7 Zm 878)-

                                                     01
8JC8DF D8CBDF B9 6' 4' @4DF<A8L                                            6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA
6<H<? 46F<BA AB' *1&6H&.-+0&#=ED$                                      :BH8DA87 5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D
         Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 5 of 9




\hngmkb^l pa^k^ bm ikhob]^l fh[be^ ]ZmZ l^kob\^ Zg] k^l^eel maZm l^kob\^ _hk nl^ pbma \hfiZmb[e^
ahmlihml-14 OdrkhZf h__^kl _hk^b`g fh[be^ ]ZmZ l^kob\^ mh bml \nlmhf^kl Zm ikb\^l maZm Zk^ ehp^k
maZg Zk^ mrib\Zeer h__^k^] [r IJKl _hk khZfbg` hnmlb]^ h_ ma^ \nlmhf^kl} ahf^ \hngmkb^l-15
OdrkhZf \hgg^\ml Zg] ikhob]^l ma^ ]ZmZ l^kob\^ hg ma^l^ eh\Ze OEI \Zk]l [r \hgg^\mbg` ma^
\Zk]l makhn`a ma^ \hfiZgr}l iZm^gm^] obkmnZe OEI (zoOEI{) l^ko^kl nlbg` bml oOEI m^\agheh`r-16

        OdrkhZf l^eel fh[be^ ahmlihml maZm Zk^ k^jnbk^] mh \hgg^\m pbma ma^bk oOEI l^ko^kl Zg]
ma^ \hkk^lihg]bg` eh\Ze OEI \Zk]l-17 Pa^l^ ahmlihml Zk^ \hfiZmb[e^ hger pbma OdrkhZf}l oOEI
g^mphkd+ Zg] bml \nlmhf^kl \hgg^\m hg^ hk fhk^ ]^ob\^l mh ma^l^ ahmlihml nlbg` Sb,Bb-18 Pa^l^
ahmlihml Zk^ mrib\Zeer [ng]e^] pbma Z lbg`e^ @ZriZll Z_m^k pab\a Z]]bmbhgZe ]Zrl h_ l^kob\^ fnlm
[^ ink\aZl^]-2/ Bhk ^qZfie^+ ma^ Ohebl ahmlihm bl [ng]e^] pbma hg^ _k^^ @ZriZll-20

        OdrkhZf ]h^l ghm l^ee ]^ob\^l pbmahnm Z \hkk^lihg]bg` \hffbmf^gm mh nl^ ma^ l^kob\^
                                                                      Bhk ^qZfie^+ pa^g OdrkhZf l^eel
]^ob\^l mh Z k^gmZe \hfiZgr+ ma^ lZe^ bg\en]^l lhf^ Zfhngm h_ ]ZmZ l^kob\^ ]^i^g]bg` nihg ma^
\hgmkZ\m-22 Eg lhf^ \Zl^l+


         OdrkhZf ikbfZkber ikhfhm^l bml ikh]n\ml Zg] l^kob\^l bl makhn`a hgebg^ Z]o^kmblbg`-24 Eg
ma^ Qgbm^] OmZm^l+ ^,\hff^k\^ bl                                        makhn`a pab\a OdrkhZf l^eel bml
ikh]n\ml Zg] l^kob\^l-25 ?aZgg^el ]b__^k bg ma^bk k^eZmbo^ bfihkmZg\^ bg hma^k \hngmkb^l- Bhk
^qZfie^+ k^gmZe iZkmg^kl Zk^                                                                  Eg Z]]bmbhg mh


14
   @bl\nllbhg pbma Akb\ LeZf Zg] NZr Mbg-
15
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 05/,050 Aqab[bml 0/ (OEIKY//30876,1//7 Zm 886) Zg] 04 (OEIKY//4/635,652 Zm 635-
16
   @bl\nllbhg pbma LZne ?eZkd+ @O\-
17
   @bl\nllbhg pbma Akb\ LeZf Zg] NZr Mbg-
18
   @bl\nllbhg pbma LZne ?eZkd+ @O\-: LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Aqab[bm 0/ (OEIKY//30876,1//7 Zm 884,886)-
2/
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 08-
20
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 45-
21
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 5/+ 1/0)-
22
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 45-
23
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 46-
24
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 001,002: OEIKY/15304/- Eg ma^ QO+ OdrkhZf nl^l Z]l hg BZ\^[hhd+ EglmZ`kZf Zg] Chh`e^
=]phk]l-
25
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 001,002-
26
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Aqab[bm 7 (OEIKY//057/8,707 Zm 701)- N^gmZe iZkmg^kl Zk^ \hfiZgb^l maZm ink\aZl^ ahmlihml
Zg] ]ZmZ l^kob\^ _khf OdrkhZf hk n?ehn]ebgd Zg] ma^g k^gm ma^f mh ^g] nl^kl-

                                                     02
8JC8DF D8CBDF B9 6' 4' @4DF<A8L                                            6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA
6<H<? 46F<BA AB' *1&6H&.-+0&#=ED$                                      :BH8DA87 5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D
         Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 6 of 9




f^k\aZgm `Zm^pZrl+ OdrkhZf Zelh phkdl pbma                                h_ hgebg^ mkZo^e Z`^g\b^l (zKP={)+
Zbkebg^l+ ahm^el+ k^mZbe^kl Zg] hma^k Z__bebZm^l mh ikhfhm^ lZe^l Zg] k^gmZel h_ ma^ \hfiZgr}l
]^ob\^l Zg] \hkk^lihg]bg` l^kob\^l-27 Bhk ^qZfie^+ OdrkhZf aZl k^eZmbhglabil pbma
                                                                                                   Zfhg` hma^kl-28

                           \)       Skyroam Products
                             (0)    Dhmlihm @^ob\^l
         Obg\^ 1/03+ OdrkhZf aZl lhe] _hnk ]b__^k^gm `eh[Ze ahm lihml- Pa^ _bklm o^klbhg h_ ma^bk
`eh[Ze ahmlihm+ ma^ 2CIZm^+ pZl _bklm lhe] bg ma^ Q-O- bg 1/03-3/ Pa^ 2CIZm^ pZl lhe] _hk Z[hnm
gbg^ fhgmal ngmbe OdrkhZf eZng\a^] Zg bfikho^] o^klbhg h_ ma^ 2CIZm^-30 Pabl bfikho^]
o^klbhg+ bgm^kgZeer dghpg Zl ma^                 pZl k^[kZg]^] bg ma^ Q-O- Zg] Ankhi^ Zl ma^ OdrkhZf
Dhmlihm Zg] ma^ 2CIZm^* bg =lbZ-31 =emahn`a ma^                       bl lmbee [^bg` lhe]+ OdrkhZf bl gh ehg`^k
aZobg` mabl ikh]n\m fZgn_Z\mnk^]-32

         OdrkhZf eZng\a^] ma^ mabk],`^g^kZmbhg ahmlihm+ ma^ Ohebl+ (lhe] Zl ma^ Shke]Bb bg =lbZ
pbma Z ]b__^k^gm laZi^)+ bg ma^ mabk] jnZkm^k h_ 1/06-33 Pa^ Ohebl bl ma^ eZm^lm ]ZmZ ahmlihm Zg] bl
\nkk^gmer lhe] bg ma^ Q-O-+ =lbZ+ Zg] Ankhi^-34

         @blmkb[nm^] [r OdrkhZf O^kob\^l+ ma^ _hnkma OdrkhZf ahmlihm bl dghpg Zl ma^ 3CIZm^
Zg]+ pbma hg^ ^q\^imbhg+ bl hger ZoZbeZ[e^ _hk k^gm makhn`a OdrkhZf k^gmZe iZkmg^kl bg =lbZ-35
Pa^ 3CIZm^ bl ghm ZoZbeZ[e^ makhn`a Zgr ^,\hff^k\^ lZe^l \aZgg^e hk ^el^pa^k^ bg ma^ Qgbm^]
OmZm^l-36 FMNXQ * [^ehp bl Z lnffZkr h_ OdrkhZf}l ahmlihm fh]^el _khf 1/03 mh ]Zm^-




27
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Aqab[bml 7 (OEIKY//057/8,707 Zm 700,02) Zg] 03 (OEIKY//85864,888 Zm 870):
OEIKY//03045,054 Zm 046: OEIKY//05764,783 Zm 774-
28
   OEIKY//03045,054 Zm 046-
3/
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 2/- Pa^ OdrkhZf bgm^kgZe \h]^ _hk ma^ 2CIZm^ pZl ma^
30
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 2/-
31
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 2/- Pa^           _hkf _Z\mhk pZl ma^ lZf^ Zl ma^      [nm bm bg\en]^] Zg bfikho^] \abil^m maZm
Zeehp^] _hk _Zlm^k li^^]l _khf DOL= mh DOL= Lenl-
32
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 20,21+ 43- OdrkhZf lmbee k^_nk[bla^l ma^          pa^g ma^r Zk^ k^mnkg^] [r iZkmg^kl+ Zg] ma^
      bl lmbee ZoZbeZ[e^ _hk k^gm [r lhf^ h_ OdrkhZf}l k^gmZe iZkmg^kl-
33
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 21-
34
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 25: @bl\nllbhg pbma Akb\ LeZf Zg] NZr Mbg-
35
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 43,44- = Dhg` Ghg` ]blmkb[nmhk lhe] lhf^ 3CIZm^ ahm lihml mh Z k^mZbe^k bg Dhg` Ghg`-
36
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 43,44-

                                                          03
8JC8DF D8CBDF B9 6' 4' @4DF<A8L                                                  6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA
6<H<? 46F<BA AB' *1&6H&.-+0&#=ED$                                            :BH8DA87 5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D
        Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 7 of 9




\nkk^gmer h__^kl mak^^ ]b__^k^gm ikb\bg` fh]^el bg\en]bg` (b) $8 i^k @ZriZll (bb) $8 i^k `b`Z[rm^
hk (bbb) $88 i^k fhgma-48

                bb-      n?ehn]ebgd
        Bhng]^] bg Dhg` Ghg` bg 1//8+ Dhg` Ghg` n?ehn]ebgd J^mphkd P^\agheh`r Hm]- bl ma^
iZk^gm \hfiZgr h_ [hma Q?H =f^kb\Z Zg] Q?H Dhg` Ghg`-5/ Bhk ]bl\nllbhg inkihl^l+ E aZo^
k^_^kk^] mh Zee n?ehn]ebgd ^gmbmb^l \hee^\mbo^er Zl zn?ehn]ebgd{ pa^g ghm ]^l\kb[bg` Z li^\b_b\
^gmbmr- n?ehn]ebgd aZl ho^k            ^fiehr^^l Zg] ho^k 1/ h__b\^l bg ?abgZ+ Dhg` Ghg`+ Ankhi^
Zg] ma^ Q-O-+ bg\en]bg` Z k^l^Zk\a Zg] ]^o^ehif^gm _Z\bebmr pbma ZiikhqbfZm^er                ^fiehr^^l-50
Pa^ Q-O- ln[lb]bZkr _hk n?ehn]ebgd aZl e^ll maZg           ^fiehr^^l bg J^p Uhkd maZm Zk^ k^lihglb[e^
_hk ma^ \hfiZgr}l lZe^l Zg] k^gmZe [nlbg^ll^l bg ma^ Qgbm^] OmZm^l-51

                         Z)      Business Model
        n?ehn]ebgd}l [nlbg^ll fh]^e bl obkmnZeer b]^gmb\Ze mh OdrkhZf}l-                   Hbd^ OdrkhZf+
n?ehn]ebgd ink\aZl^l OEI \Zk]l _khf IJKl bg ma^ \hngmkb^l pa^k^ bm ikhob]^l l^kob\^ Zg]
k^l^eel maZm l^kob\^ _hk nl^ pbma \hfiZmb[e^ ahmlihml-52 n?ehn]ebgd \hgg^\ml Zg] ikhob]^l ma^
]ZmZ l^kob\^ hg ma^l^ eh\Ze OEI \Zk]l [r \hgg^\mbg` ma^ \Zk]l makhn`a ma^ \hfiZgr}l z?ehn]
OEI{ l^ko^kl-53

        n?ehn]ebgd Zelh l^eel fh[be^ ahmlihml maZm \hgg^\m pbma ma^bk l^ko^kl Zg] ma^
\hkk^lihg]bg` eh\Ze OEI \Zk]l-54 Pa^l^ ahmlihml Zk^ \hfiZmb[e^ pbma obkmnZe OEI g^mphkdl
hi^kZm^] [r n?ehn]ebgd}l ?ehn] OEI g^mphkd+ Zg] bml \nlmhf^kl \hgg^\m hg^ hk fhk^ fh[be^
]^ob\^l mh ma^l^ ahmlihml nlbg` Sb,Bb-55


47
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 026-
48
   LeZf @^ihlbmbhg Zm 026,027-
5/
   @^ihlbmbhg h_ S^g CZh+ Jho^f[^k 02+ 1/07 (zCZh @^ihlbmbhg{) Zm 40,42+ 46,47+ 53,56+ 6/: @^ihlbmbhg h_ DnZ
S^b+ Jho^f[^k 5+ 1/07 (zS^b @^ihlbmbhg{) Zm 34+ 37 Zg] Aqab[bml 1/ (Q?HKQ@HEJG//0263/,648 Zm 633) Zg] 14
(Q?HKQ@HEJG//02511,545 Zm 517)- Ik- CZh m^lmb_b^] maZm a^ _hkf^] ma^ \hfiZgr bg 1/00 [nm Aqab[bml 1/ Zg]
14 lmZm^ maZm n?ehn]ebgd pZl _hng]^] bg 1//8- n?ehn]ebgd QO Zg] DG Zk^ lblm^k \hfiZgb^l-
50
   S^b @^ihlbmbhg Aqab[bml 1/ (Q?HKQ@HEJG//0263/,648 Zm 632+ 635) Zg] 14 (Q?HKQ@HEJG//02511,545 Zm
516,517)-
51
   S^b @^ihlbmbhg Zm 12: CZh @^ihlbmbhg Zm 21+ 27-
52
   S^b @^ihlbmbhg Aqab[bm 1/ (Q?HKQ@HEJG//0263/,648 Zm 638,64/)
53
   S^b @^ihlbmbhg Aqab[bm 14 (Q?HKQ@HEJG//02511,545 Zm 524,525): Q?HKQ@HEJG/233703,715 Zm 706-
54
   Q?HKQ@HEJG/233608,61/ Zm 608): Q?HKQ@HEJG/233701,702 Zm 701- Pa^ z?hg]bmbhgl{ h_ ma^l^ ieZgl _hk
\nlmhf^kl bl zink\aZl^ Ceh\ZeI^ ]^ob\^l{ Zg] ^gm^k bgmh Z ]ZmZ l^kob\^ ieZg _hk 01 hk 13 fhgmal-
55
   @bl\nllbhg pbma LZne ?eZkd+ @O\-

                                                    05
8JC8DF D8CBDF B9 6' 4' @4DF<A8L                                           6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA
6<H<? 46F<BA AB' *1&6H&.-+0&#=ED$                                     :BH8DA87 5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D
         Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 8 of 9




        @ZmZ l^kob\^l Zk^ mrib\Zeer ikhob]^] bg bg\k^f^gml h_ hg^ ]Zr h_ ngebfbm^] l^kob\^+ Zg]
ebd^ OdrkhZf+ n?ehn]ebgd k^_^kl mh ^Z\a h_ ma^l^ ngbml Zl Z z@ZrLZll{ hk z@Zr LZll{ (a^k^Z_m^k
z@ZriZll{)-56 n?ehn]ebgd Zelh h__^kl ln[l\kbimbhgl maZm bg\en]^ ngebfbm^] ]ZmZ ho^k Z \^kmZbg
mbf^_kZf^ (^-`-+ fhgmaer)-57 =elh ebd^ OdrkhZf+ n?ehn]ebgd l^ml ebfbml _hk ma^ ohenf^ h_ ab`a
li^^] ]ZmZ bm pbee ikhob]^ i^k @ZrLZll+ Zg] ma^g makhmme^l ma^ ]ZmZ li^^]l hg\^ ma^ ]Zber mak^lahe]
bl ^q\^^]^]-58

        n?ehn]ebgd Zelh h__^kl lhf^ ]ZmZ iZ\dZ`^l maZm Zk^ ]bllbfbeZk _khf OdrkhZf}l @ZriZll
fh]^e- Oi^\b_b\Zeer+ n?ehn]ebgd h__^kl lhf^ ]ZmZ iZ\dZ`^l maZm bg\en]^ Z l^m ohenf^ h_ ]ZmZ maZm
fZr [^ nl^] Zm Zgr mbf^ ho^k Z l^m gnf[^k h_ ]Zrl (^-`-+ 0C> ho^k 4 ]Zrl)-6/ Eg Z]]bmbhg+ E
ng]^klmZg] maZm n?ehn]ebgd l^eel l^kob\^ bg ]heeZk bg\k^f^gml Zg] ]^]n\ml _khf ma^ [ZeZg\^ bg
Zfhngml i^k f^`Z[rm^ (^-`-+ $/-/5.I>)-60

        =elh+ ebd^ OdrkhZf+ n?ehn]ebgd h__^kl ln[l\kbimbhg ieZgl _hk ^gm^kikbl^l Zg] [nlbg^ll
mkZo^e^kl-61 Pa^l^ ln[l\kbimbhgl Zk^ iZ\dZ`^] Zl ]Zber hk fhgmaer ieZgl hk Zl z_e^qb[e^ ]ZmZ
iZ\dZ`^l-{62

                          [)       GlocalMe Products and Services
        n?ehn]ebgd l^eel mak^^ fh]^el h_ `eh[Ze ahmlihm Zg] hg^ fh[be^ m^e^iahg^ ng]^k ma^
[kZg] gZf^ Ceh\ZeI^-63 Ceh\ZeI^ bl ma^ [kZg] gZf^ maZm n?ehn]ebgd nl^l _hk Zee ikh]n\ml lhe]
]bk^\mer mh bg]bob]nZe nl^kl-64 =ee _hnk ]^ob\^l Zk^ \ZiZ[e^ h_ ikhob]bg` ma^ lZf^ n?ehn]ebgd
@ZmZ O^kob\^l Zg] Zk^ [kZg]^] Zl ma^ Ceh\ZeI^ C1+ C2+ Q1 (ahmlihml) Zg] O0 (fh[be^ iahg^)-65
Pa^l^ ]^ob\^l Zk^ Zelh \ZiZ[e^ h_ phkdbg` pbma fnembie^ IJKl bg\en]bg`


56
    Q?HKQ@HEJG/233608,61/ Zm 608): Q?HKQ@HEJG/233701,702 Zm 701- Bhk ]bl\nllbhg inkihl^l+ E aZo^ nl^]
ma^ m^kf z@ZriZll{ _hk [hma OdrkhZf Zg] n?ehn]ebgd mh ]^l\kb[^ Z hg^,]Zr \k^]bm _hk ngebfbm^] _hk^b`g ]ZmZ l^kob\^-
57
   ammil9..ppp-`eh\Zef^-\hf.l^kob\^.^gm^kikbl^<eZg`;^g,QO&`blh;QO -
58
    Q?HKQ@HEJG/233608,61/ Zm 608): Q?HKQ@HEJG/233701,702 Zm 701: OEIKY//05466,481 Zm 473,474:
OEIKY//05710,725 Zm 717- Pa^ ]Zber ieZgl oZkr z[r ]Zber mak^lahe]{ h_+ _hk ^qZfie^+ 4// I> hk 0 C>.]Zr- @ZmZ
li^^]l fZr [^ makhmme^] ]hpg mh 017G[il mh 145G[il-
6/
    CZh 00.17.07 @^ihlbmbhg Zm 068,07/ Zg] Aqab[bm 77 (Q?HKQ@HEJG//272317):
ammil9..ppp-`eh\Zef^-\hf.]ZmZYiZ\dZ`^<eZg`;^g,QO&`blh;QO
60
   ammil9..ppp-`eh\Zef^-\hf.-
61
    Q?HKQ@HEJG/233608,61/ Zm 608-
62
    Q?HKQ@HEJG/233608,61/ Zm 608-
63
    S^b @^ihlbmbhg Zm 43 Zg] Aqab[bm 16 (Q?HKQ@HEJG//01658): CZh @^ihlbmbhg Zm 78,8/-
64
    S^b @^ihlbmbhg Zm 001,002 Zg] Aqab[bm 1/ (Q?HKQ@HEJG//0263/,648 Zm 632)-
65
    S^b @^ihlbmbhg Zm 17,18+ 43,44 Zg] Aqab[bm 14 (Q?HKQ@HEJG//02511,545 Zm 530,31+ 533)-

                                                        06
8JC8DF D8CBDF B9 6' 4' @4DF<A8L                                               6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA
6<H<? 46F<BA AB' *1&6H&.-+0&#=ED$                                         :BH8DA87 5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D
         Case 1:18-cv-05427-JSR Document 153-5 Filed 04/24/19 Page 9 of 9




         6'       DQM_[ZMNXQ D[eMX`e 7MYMSQ_
         = k^ZlhgZ[e^ khrZemr bl `^g^kZeer ]^m^kfbg^] [r ^oZenZmbg` ^\hghfb\ \hg]bmbhgl Zg]
oZkbhnl _Z\mhkl maZm phne] aZo^ [^^g \hglb]^k^] [r ma^ iZkmb^l b_ ma^r aZ] pbeebg`er g^`hmbZm^] Z
eb\^gl^ Z`k^^f^gm Zm ma^ mbf^ h_ _bklm bg_kbg`^f^gm- Eg Georgia-Pacific v. United States Plywood
Corp-+ ma^ \hnkm b]^gmb_b^] _b_m^^g _Z\mhkl mh \hglb]^k bg ]^m^kfbgbg` Z k^ZlhgZ[e^ khrZemr bg ma^
\hgm^qm h_ Z arihma^mb\Ze eb\^gl^ g^`hmbZmbhg-057 Em lahne] [^ ghm^] maZm ma^ _b_m^^g Georgia-
Pacific _Z\mhkl Zk^ ghm ^q\enlbo^ h_ hma^k _Z\mhkl+ ghm ^jnZeer p^b`am^]+ Zg] mh ma^ ^qm^gm
\hglb]^k^]+ g^^] mh [^ `khng]^] bg ma^ \hgm^qm h_ ^Z\a lbmnZmbhg-058

         =l iZkm h_ mabl arihma^mb\Ze g^`hmbZmbhg+ bm bl Zelh bfihkmZgm mh \hglb]^k Zgr g^\^llZkr
Ziihkmbhgf^gm+ pab\a k^eZm^l mh ma^ ^ll^gmbZe k^jnbk^f^gm maZm zma^ nembfZm^ k^ZlhgZ[e^ khrZemr
ZpZk] fnlm [^ [Zl^] hg ma^ bg\k^f^gmZe oZen^ maZm ma^ iZm^gm^] bgo^gmbhg Z]]l mh ma^ ^g]
ikh]n\m{06/ Zg] zpa^k^ fnemb,\hfihg^gm ikh]n\ml Zk^ bgoheo^]+ ma^ `ho^kgbg` kne^ bl maZm ma^
nembfZm^ \hf[bgZmbhg h_ khrZemr [Zl^ Zg] khrZemr kZm^ fnlm k^_e^\m ma^ oZen^ Zmmkb[nmZ[e^ mh ma^
bg_kbg`bg` _^Zmnk^l h_ ma^ ikh]n\m-{060 =iihkmbhgf^gm h_ k^ZlhgZ[e^ khrZemr ]ZfZ`^l bl Zelh
_k^jn^gmer ]bl\nll^] bg k^eZmbhg mh ma^ Agmbk^ IZkd^m RZen^ Nne^ (zAIRN{)+ pab\a bg
LaserDynamics v. Quanta Computer ma^ B^]^kZe ?bk\nbm Z]]k^ll^] lmZmbg`9061
         Pa^ ^gmbk^ fZkd^m oZen^ kne^ bl ]^kbo^] _khf Onik^f^ ?hnkm ik^\^]^gm k^jnbkbg` maZm "ma^
         iZm^gm^^ - - - fnlm bg ^o^kr \Zl^ `bo^ ^ob]^g\^ m^g]bg` mh l^iZkZm^ hk Ziihkmbhg ma^ ]^_^g]Zgm'l
         ikh_bml Zg] ma^ iZm^gm^^'l ]ZfZ`^l [^mp^^g ma^ iZm^gm^] _^Zmnk^ Zg] ma^ ngiZm^gm^] _^Zmnk^l+ Zg]
         ln\a ^ob]^g\^ fnlm [^ k^ebZ[e^ Zg] mZg`b[e^+ Zg] ghm \hgc^\mnkZe hk li^\neZmbo^-{wEg ^__^\m+ ma^
         ^gmbk^ fZkd^m oZen^ kne^ Z\ml Zl Z \a^\d mh ^glnk^ maZm ma^ khrZemr ]ZfZ`^l [^bg` lhn`am ng]^k 24
         Q-O-?- u 173 Zk^ bg _Z\m "k^ZlhgZ[e^" bg eb`am h_ ma^ m^\agheh`r Zm blln^-




057
    Georgia-Pacific v. United States Plywood Corp-+ 207 B- Onii- 0005+ 001/,10 (O-@- J-U- 086/)+ modified and
aff’d+ 335 B-1] 184 (1] ?bk-)+ cert. denied+ 3/3 Q-O- 76/ (0860) (zGeorgia-Pacific{)-
058
    E Zelh ng]^klmZg] maZm ma^ \hnkm z]hW^lX ghm k^jnbk^ maZm pbmg^ll^l nl^ Zgr hk Zee h_ ma^ Georgia-Pacific_Z\mhkl
pa^g m^lmb_rbg` Z[hnm ]ZfZ`^l bg iZm^gm \Zl^l- E_ ma^r \ahhl^ mh nl^ ma^f+ ahp^o^k+ k^\bmbg` ^Z\a _Z\mhk Zg] fZdbg`
Z \hg\enlhkr k^fZkd Z[hnm bml bfiZ\m hg ma^ ]ZfZ`^l \Ze\neZmbhg [^_hk^ fhobg` hg ]h^l gh fhk^ maZg m^ee ma^ cnkr
paZm _Z\mhkl Z ]ZfZ`^l ZgZerlbl \hne] mZd^ bgmh \hglb]^kZmbhg- Aqi^km pbmg^ll^l lahne] \hg\^gmkZm^ hg _neer
ZgZersbg` ma^ Ziieb\Z[e^ _Z\mhkl+ ghm \nklhkber k^\bmbg` Zee _b_m^^g- =g]+ pabe^ fZma^fZmb\Ze ik^\blbhg bl ghm k^jnbk^]+
lhf^ ^qieZgZmbhg h_ [hma par Zg] `^g^kZeer mh paZm ^qm^gm ma^ iZkmb\neZk _Z\mhk bfiZ\ml ma^ khrZemr \Ze\neZmbhg bl
g^^]^]-{ (Whitserve, LLC v. Computer Packages, Inc. 583 B-2] 0/+ 16 (B^]- ?bk- 1/01)-)
06/
    Ericsson, Inc. v. D-Link Sys., Inc., 662 B-2] 01/0+ 0115 (B^]- ?bk- 1/03)-
060
    Ericsson, Inc. v. D-Link Sys., Inc., 662 B-2] 01/0+ 0115 (B^]- ?bk- 1/03)-
061
    LaserDynamics, Inc. v. Quanta Computer, Inc., 1/00,033/+ 1/01 SH 2647/82 (B^]- ?bk- =n`- 2/+ 1/01)-

                                                          18
8JC8DF D8CBDF B9 6' 4' @4DF<A8L                                                   6BA9<78AF<4? <A9BD@4F<BA
6<H<? 46F<BA AB' *1&6H&.-+0&#=ED$                                             :BH8DA87 5K CDBF86F<H8 BD78D

{'dataset': 'courtlistener_docket_entry_documents'}