<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/html4/strict.dtd"><html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" class="pinned"><head><meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8" /><title>Heeralal v Kalyan Maland Others | Westlaw India</title><!--
      Copyright 2010 Thomson Reuters Global Resources AG. All Rights Reserved.
      Proprietary and Confidential information of TRGR.
      Disclosure, Use or Reproduction without the written authorization of TRGR is prohibited.
    --><meta content="text/html; charset=UTF-8" http-equiv="Content-Type" /><meta content="en-gb" http-equiv="Content-Language" /><link type="image/x-icon" rel="shortcut icon" href="/wlin/favicon.ico" /><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/base.css?14-3-11" /><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/token-input-india.css?14-3-11" /><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/minimal.css?14-3-11" /><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/jquery.selectBox.css?14-3-11" /><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/jquery-ui.css?14-3-11" /><style media="screen, print" type="text/css">
			@import "/wlin/css/advanced.css?14-3-11";
		</style>
			<!--[if lte IE 6]>
		<link href="/wlin/css/ie.css?14-3-11" type="text/css" rel="stylesheet"><script type="text/javascript">
				try {document.execCommand("BackgroundImageCache", false, true);}
				catch(e) {}
			</script>
			<![endif]-->
		
			<!--[if IE 7]>
		<link href="/wlin/css/ie7.css?14-3-11" type="text/css" rel="stylesheet">
			<![endif]-->
		
			<!--[if IE 8]>
		<link href="/wlin/css/ie8.css?14-3-11" type="text/css" rel="stylesheet">
			<![endif]-->
		<script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.dimensions.pack.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.cookie.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.dimensions.pack.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/jqueryui.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jsTree/jquery.jstree.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jqueryforms/jquery.forms.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/blockUI/jquery.blockUI.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquerycookie/jquery.cookie.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.scrollTo/jquery.scrollTo-min.1.4.2.js">//</script><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/jqueryui/jquery-ui.css" /><link href="/wlin/css/rspace/rspace.css" type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" /><link href="/wlin/css/rspace/rspace.growl.css" type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" /><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery-ui.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.icheck.min.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.selectBox.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jqmodal.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/classes/UpdateNoteProcessor-bk.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/classes/InlineImageProcessor.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript">
        	var brand="wlin";
        	
        	var iip = new InlineImageProcessor("TABULAR OR GRAPHIC MATERIAL SET FORTH AT THIS POINT IS NOT DISPLAYABLE"); 
            $(window).load(iip.init);
            
    		jQuery.curCSS = jQuery.css;
        </script>
			<!--[if IE 7]>
		<script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/ie7.js?14-3-11">//</script>
			<![endif]-->
		<link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/document.css?14-3-11" /><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/document-plus.css?14-3-11" /><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/general.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.icheck.min.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/timeout.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.timers-1.2.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/jquery.selectBox.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/classes/FootnoteViewer.js?14-3-11">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/classes/InlineDocLoader.js?14-3-11">//</script><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/jqueryui/jquery-ui.css" /><!--[if lte IE 7]><link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="/wlin/css/rspace/ie67.css"><![endif]--><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/maf.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/maf/wlin/app/folders/scripts/rspace_params_constants.js?no-context=true">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/btree.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/rspace.growl.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/rspace.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/rspace_init.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/search_results.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/lazyload-min.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/doc_view.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript">
				var isRSActions = true;
			</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/rspace/doc_view_init.js">//</script><script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/document.js?14-3-11">//</script>
			<!--[if IE 7]>
		<script type="text/javascript" src="/wlin/js/ie7.js?14-3-11">//</script>
			<![endif]-->
		<style type="text/css">.jstree ul, .jstree li { display:block; margin:0 0 0 0; padding:0 0 0 0; list-style-type:none; } .jstree li { display:block; min-height:18px; line-height:18px; white-space:nowrap; margin-left:18px; } .jstree-rtl li { margin-left:0; margin-right:18px; } .jstree &gt; ul &gt; li { margin-left:0px; } .jstree-rtl &gt; ul &gt; li { margin-right:0px; } .jstree ins { display:inline-block; text-decoration:none; width:18px; height:18px; margin:0 0 0 0; padding:0; } .jstree a { display:inline-block; line-height:16px; height:16px; color:black; white-space:nowrap; text-decoration:none; padding:1px 2px; margin:0; } .jstree a:focus { outline: none; } .jstree a &gt; ins { height:16px; width:16px; } .jstree a &gt; .jstree-icon { margin-right:3px; } .jstree-rtl a &gt; .jstree-icon { margin-left:3px; margin-right:0; } li.jstree-open &gt; ul { display:block; } li.jstree-closed &gt; ul { display:none; } </style><style type="text/css">#vakata-dragged { display:block; margin:0 0 0 0; padding:4px 4px 4px 24px; position:absolute; top:-2000px; line-height:16px; z-index:10000; } </style><style type="text/css">#vakata-dragged ins { display:block; text-decoration:none; width:16px; height:16px; margin:0 0 0 0; padding:0; position:absolute; top:4px; left:4px; } #vakata-dragged .jstree-ok { background:green; } #vakata-dragged .jstree-invalid { background:red; } #jstree-marker { padding:0; margin:0; line-height:12px; font-size:1px; overflow:hidden; height:12px; width:8px; position:absolute; top:-30px; z-index:10000; background-repeat:no-repeat; display:none; background-color:silver; } </style><style type="text/css">#vakata-contextmenu { display:none; position:absolute; margin:0; padding:0; min-width:180px; background:#ebebeb; border:1px solid silver; z-index:10000; *width:180px; } #vakata-contextmenu ul { min-width:180px; *width:180px; } #vakata-contextmenu ul, #vakata-contextmenu li { margin:0; padding:0; list-style-type:none; display:block; } #vakata-contextmenu li { line-height:20px; min-height:20px; position:relative; padding:0px; } #vakata-contextmenu li a { padding:1px 6px; line-height:17px; display:block; text-decoration:none; margin:1px 1px 0 1px; } #vakata-contextmenu li ins { float:left; width:16px; height:16px; text-decoration:none; margin-right:2px; } #vakata-contextmenu li a:hover, #vakata-contextmenu li.vakata-hover &gt; a { background:gray; color:white; } #vakata-contextmenu li ul { display:none; position:absolute; top:-2px; left:100%; background:#ebebeb; border:1px solid gray; } #vakata-contextmenu .right { right:100%; left:auto; } #vakata-contextmenu .bottom { bottom:-1px; top:auto; } #vakata-contextmenu li.vakata-separator { min-height:0; height:1px; line-height:1px; font-size:1px; overflow:hidden; margin:0 2px; background:silver; /* border-top:1px solid #fefefe; */ padding:0; } </style><style type="text/css">.jstree .ui-icon { overflow:visible; } .jstree a { padding:0 2px; }</style></head><body class="pinned"><script type="text/javascript">
									if(wluk.doc!=null){
										wluk.doc.setPinState();
									}
								</script><div class="hide"><a accesskey="s" href="#container" title="Skip Navigation">Skip Navigation</a></div><div id="mainNav"><p class="bold">Let us know what you think about the new Westlaw India. <a href="mailto:feedback@westlawindia.com">Site Feedback</a></p><div id="globNav"><ul id="navLinksAthens"><li id="navWli"><a href="/maf/wlin/api/sourceLink/signon" class="externalLink" title="International Materials - This link will open in a new window">International Materials</a></li><li id="navTools"><a class="navMenuLink" id="toolsLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/preferences?crumb-action=reset&amp;crumb-label=Services,%20Settings%20%26%20Tools">Settings &amp; Tools</a><ul class="navMenu" id="toolsMenu" style="display: none;"><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/authentication/clientid/change?crumb-action=reset&amp;crumb-label=Change%20Client%20ID&amp;linktype=menuitem&amp;context=9678">Change Client ID</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/preferences/change?crumb-action=reset&amp;crumb-label=Options%20%26%20Preferences&amp;linktype=menuitem&amp;context=9678">Options</a></li></ul></li><li id="navHelp"><a href="/maf/wlin/app/help?docguid=I0ade985e000001259243de65c2f671e0&amp;crumb-label=Westlaw%20India%20Help&amp;crumb-action=reset&amp;linktype=menuitem&amp;context=9678" accesskey="h" title="Help | access key: h">Help</a></li><li class="lastLink" id="navSignoff"><a id="signoffLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/authentication/signoff?" accesskey="l" title="Log Out | access key: l">Log Out</a></li></ul></div><ul class="wlin" id="serviceTabs"><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true" accesskey="1" title="Home | access key: 1" id="tabHome">Home</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;ao=o.IC0236E00251211DE8352005056C00008&amp;ndd=1&amp;linktype=tab&amp;context=9678" accesskey="2" title="Cases | access key: 2" id="tabCases" class="selected">Cases</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;ao=o.IC057C470251211DE80C6005056C00008&amp;ndd=2&amp;linktype=tab&amp;context=9678" accesskey="3" title="Legislation | access key: 3" id="tabLegislation">Legislation</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;ao=o.IF5851F70BC5111E0BDDCF06BF48BF15F&amp;ndd=2&amp;linktype=tab&amp;context=9678" accesskey="4" title="Journals | access key: 4" id="tabJournals">Journals</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;ao=o.I6E0509FF62C94CA89C4072C7C69A53E0&amp;ndd=2&amp;linktype=tab&amp;context=9678" accesskey="5" title="Forms &amp; Reports | access key: 5" id="tabFR">Forms &amp; Reports</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;ao=o.IC0E35E01251211DE8352005056C00008&amp;ndd=2&amp;linktype=tab&amp;context=9678" accesskey="6" title="Current Awareness | access key: 6" id="tabCA">Current Awareness</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;ao=o.I591A72C0609611DEB19400123FC97614&amp;ndd=2&amp;linktype=tab&amp;context=9678" accesskey="7" title="UK Materials | access key: 7" id="tabUKMaterials">UK Materials</a></li><li><a href="/maf/wlin/app/tocectory?sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;ao=o.ICBD2DB1CD4F04329BB3D6FED02A00000&amp;ndd=2&amp;linktype=tab&amp;context=9678" accesskey="8" title="EU Materials | access key: 8" id="tabEUMaterials">EU Materials</a></li></ul></div><div id="container"><div id="sectionTitleSplit"><h1>Cases</h1><ul id="docDeliveryLinks"><li></li><li><a rel="print" class="deliveryLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/delivery/document?docguid=I0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;srguid=&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;crumb-label=Delivery Options&amp;context=9678&amp;altview=&amp;title=&amp;title=&amp;deliveryTarget=print"><img title="Print" alt="print icon" src="/wlin/images/iconPrint.gif" /></a> <a title="Print" rel="print" class="deliveryLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/delivery/document?docguid=I0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;srguid=&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;crumb-label=Delivery Options&amp;context=9678&amp;altview=&amp;title=&amp;deliveryTarget=print">Print</a></li><li><a rel="save" class="deliveryLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/delivery/document?docguid=I0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;srguid=&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;crumb-label=Delivery Options&amp;context=9678&amp;altview=&amp;deliveryTarget=save&amp;deliveryFormat="><img title="Save" alt="save icon" src="/wlin/images/iconSave.gif" /></a> <a title="Save" rel="save" class="deliveryLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/delivery/document?docguid=I0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;srguid=&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;crumb-label=Delivery Options&amp;context=9678&amp;altview=&amp;deliveryTarget=save&amp;deliveryFormat=">Save</a></li><li><a rel="email" class="deliveryLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/delivery/document?docguid=I0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;srguid=&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;crumb-label=Delivery Options&amp;context=9678&amp;altview=&amp;deliveryTarget=email&amp;deliveryFormat="><img title="E-mail" alt="email icon" src="/wlin/images/iconEmail.gif" /></a> <a title="E-mail" rel="email" class="deliveryLink" href="/maf/wlin/app/delivery/document?docguid=I0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;srguid=&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;crumb-label=Delivery Options&amp;context=9678&amp;altview=&amp;deliveryTarget=email&amp;deliveryFormat=">E-mail</a></li></ul></div><script type="text/javascript">
			var facetsCrumbPost = {};
		</script><p id="crumbNav"><a href="/maf/wlin/api/tocectory?tocguid=IBFFAD760251211DEB932005056C00008&amp;ndd=2&amp;stnew=true&amp;context=1">Home</a>
				 	&gt;
					<a href="/maf/wlin/api/tocectory?tocguid=IC0236E00251211DE8352005056C00008&amp;ndd=1&amp;sttype=stdtemplate&amp;stnew=true&amp;context=2">Cases</a>
				 	&gt;
					<a href="/maf/wlin/api/tocectory?tocguid=I6FDFDCD04A2D11DF96C1A49DA6EE4E28&amp;ndd=2&amp;sttype=stdtemplate&amp;context=3">Supreme Court Judgments</a>
				 	&gt;
					<a href="/maf/wlin/api/tocectory?tocguid=IBCEA94E04A3011DF96C1A49DA6EE4E28&amp;ndd=2&amp;sttype=stdtemplate&amp;context=4">Full Text Judgments</a>
				 	&gt;
					<a href="/maf/wlin/api/tocectory?tocguid=IEE2D18B04A3111DF96C1A49DA6EE4E28&amp;ndd=1&amp;sttype=stdtemplate&amp;context=9246">By Year: 1997</a>
				 	&gt;
					<a href="/maf/wlin/api/tocectory?tocguid=I07CF7B324A3E11DF96C1A49DA6EE4E28&amp;ndd=1&amp;sttype=stdtemplate&amp;context=9677">K</a>
				 	&gt;
					<span class="currentCrumb">Document</span></p></div><div id="docContainer"><div class="growlContainer" style="display: none;"><div class="growl success"><span class="growlContent">Success!</span></div></div><div id="relInfoWrapper"><div id="docRelatedInfo" style="height: 530px;"><h1>Documents on Westlaw India</h1><p><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?&amp;src=ri&amp;docguid=I0BEA20E2006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;refer=%2Fmaf%2Fwlin%2Fapp%2Fdocument%3Fdocguid%3DI0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615%26src%3Dtoce%26crumb-action%3Dappend%26context%3D9677&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9678" class="">1997 Indlaw SC 1673</a></p><p title="Document Currently Selected" class="selected">Case Analysis</p><p class="subSelected"><a href="#bench">Bench</a></p><p class="subSelected"><a href="#wherereported">Where Reported</a></p><p class="subSelected"><a href="#casedigest">Case Digest</a></p><p class="subSelected"><a href="#casescited">All Cases Cited</a></p><p class="subSelected"><a href="#casesciting">Cases Citing this Case</a></p><p class="subSelected"><a href="#legiscited">Legislation Cited</a></p></div><div id="recDoc" style="left: 270px; top: 222px; display: none;"><h2>Recent Documents</h2><ol><li class="recDocCases">Pathuma and Others v Kallara K. Mohammed and Others - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I0C00B622006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9672">1997 Indlaw SC 1947</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Pathuma and Others v Kallara K. Mohammed and Others - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I0C00B621006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9667">Case Analysis</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Kali Charan and Others v H. S. E. Board and Other - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I65FDAB11006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9662">1997 Indlaw SC 2387</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Kali Charan and Others v H. S. E. Board and Other - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I65FDAB10006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9657">Case Analysis</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Punjab Dairy Development Corporation Limited and Another v Kala Singh - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I66302CC1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9652">1997 Indlaw SC 3113</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Punjab Dairy Development Corporation Limited and Another v Kala Singh - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I0BC35F00006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9647">Case Analysis</a></li><li class="recDocCases">A.P.S.R.T.C. and Others v Kaiser Begum - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I0BBA3740006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9642">1997 Indlaw SC 1251</a></li><li class="recDocCases">A.P.S.R.T.C. and Others v Kaiser Begum - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I0BBA1031006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9637">Case Analysis</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation v Kailash Nath Kothari and Others - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I0BC003A1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9632">1997 Indlaw SC 1312</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation v Kailash Nath Kothari and Others - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I0BC003A0006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9627">Case Analysis</a></li><li class="recDocCases">Victoria v K.V. Naik and Others - <a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=toce&amp;docguid=I65F8A202006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615&amp;crumb-action=append&amp;context=9622">1997 Indlaw SC 2322</a></li></ol></div></div><div id="docHeader"><p id="docNavigation"><span title="Pin" class="on rspaceBarWrap" id="viewLinks"> <span id="fontSizeControls"><span id="fontUp"><img src="/maf/static/images/document/fontUp.png" title="Increase Font Size" /></span><span id="fontDown"><img src="/maf/static/images/document/fontDown.png" title="Reduce Font Size" /></span></span><span class="groupInner"><strong id="pinType">Scroll: </strong><span id="docPin" title="Scroll document text only (fixed navigation)">Document</span><span id="pinSeperator"><span class="inner"> | </span></span><span id="pagePin" title="Scroll entire page" class="active">Page</span></span></span><span id="recDocLink"><!----><a href="#"><img id="recDocIcon" src="/wlin/images/document/recDocOpen.gif" alt="recent documents icon" title="Recent Documents" /></a></span>  </p></div><div id="docBody" style="height: 510px;"><p><strong>FOR EDUCATIONAL USE ONLY</strong></p><div class="docContent" style="font-size: 12.8px;"><h1 class="center">Heeralal v Kalyan Maland Others</h1><p class="center">Supreme Court of India</p><p class="center">19 November 1997</p><h2 class="center">Case Analysis</h2><div class="locatorSection"><h3 id="bench">Bench</h3><p>S.B. Majmudar, M. Jagannadha Rao</p></div><div class="locatorSection"><h3 id="wherereported">Where Reported</h3><p>1997 Indlaw SC 1673; (1998) 1 SCC 278; AIR 1998 SC 618; 1998 (32) ALR 442; 1998 (32) ALR 582; 1998 (1) CalLT 45; 1998 (1) CalLT(SC) 45; 1998 (1) GLH 605; JT 1997 (9) SC 267; 1998 (1) MLJ 101; 1998 (89) RD 140; 1997(7) SCALE 196; 1998 (5) SLT 395; 1998 (Supp) RD 347; [1997] Supp5 S.C.R. 277; 1997 (10) Supreme 56</p></div><div class="locatorSection"><h3 id="casedigest">Case Digest</h3><p><strong>Subject:</strong> Civil Procedure; Constitution</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong> Family &amp; Personal - Civil Procedure - Partition - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, O. 15, r. 1 - Constitution of India, 1950 - Appellant had filed a civil suit for partition of 10 items of immovable properties mentioned in Sch. A and also for partition of other properties listed in Sch. B of plaint - In Written Statement a definite stand was taken by defendants that out of listed properties in Sch. A only three properties at Items 4, 9 and 10 were exclusively belonging to contesting defendants and were not joint family properties of plaintiff and Defendants - Meaning thereby that other seven properties listed in Sch. A were admitted to be joint family properties - Not only that but in para 11 of written statement it was submitted that 'the plaintiff is only entitled for partition regarding properties of Sch. A except Items 4, 9 and 10 and all properties mentioned in Sch. B' - On basis of aforesaid stand taken by defendants issues were framed by Trial Court - The issue No. 2 was whether property mentioned in Items 4, 9 and 10 of Sch. 'Aa' attached with plaint is property of Hindu Undivided Family - In the later stage of suit defendant 1 came forward with an amendment application to amend his written statement - In application it was submitted that because of incomplete information supplied by him to his counsel Written Statement came to contain so-called admissions regarding 5 out of 7 items of properties in Schedule A and that he had suffered a heart attack and therefore when Written Statement was moved this error crept in Defendant 1 also wanted to insert a further averment in written statement regarding Schedule B properties that they had ceased to remain in possession of Defendant I and were in possession of trespassers - Trial Judge took view that application for amendment was not a bona fide one and it was moved only with a view to protract proceedings as suit was at stage of trial by then - Judge was not inclined to accept reasons put forward for moving such an amendment application at such a late stage and dismissed application - Defendant 1 carried matter in revision u/s. 115 of CPC, 1908 before High Court - This application was allowed by HC - Whether the order of HC is sustainable in law? - Held, order passed by HC cannot be sustained - Reason is so far as Sch. A properties were concerned, a clear admission was made by Defendants 1 and 2 in their joint written statement that 7 properties out of 10 were joint family properties wherein plaintiff had 1/3 rd share and they had 2/3rds undivided share - Once such a stand was taken, naturally it must be held that there was no contest between parties regarding 7 items of suit properties in Schedule A - Trial Judge, therefore, was perfectly justified in framing Issue No. 2 concerning only remaining three items for which there was dispute between parties - In such a situation under O. 15, r. 1 of CPC, 1908 plaintiff even would have been justified in requesting Court to pass a preliminary decree forthwith qua these 7 properties - Therefore, on facts of this case no case was made out by respondents, contesting defendants, for amending written statement and thus attempting to go behind their admission regarding 5 out of 7 remaining items out of 10 listed properties in Schedule A of plaint - However, so far as Schedule B properties are concerned, from very inception defendants' case qua those properties was that plaintiff had no interest therein - By proposed amendment they wanted to introduce an event with reference to those very properties by submitting that they had been in possession of trespassers - Such amendment could not be said to have in any way adversely or prejudicially affected case of plaintiff or displaced any admission on their part qua Sch. B properties which might have resulted into any legal right in favour of plaintiff - Therefore, so far as Sch. B properties were concerned, amendment could not be found fault with - Appeal partly allowed.</p></div><div class="locatorSection"><h3 id="casescited">All Cases Cited</h3><p><strong>Relied On</strong></p><p>Akshaya Restaurant v P. Anjanappa and Another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0BEA47F1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615">1995 Indlaw SC 1641, (1995) Supp2 SCC 303, AIR 1995 SC 1498, AIR 1995 SCW 2277, 1995 (3) AWC 1872, 1996 (2) BC 209, 1996 (3) CLT 187, 1996 (1) HLR 85, JT 1995 (6) SC 269, 1996 (1) MLJ(SC) 43, 1995(2) SCALE 698, [1995] 2 S.C.R. 1154</a></p><p><strong>Referred</strong></p><p>Basavan Jaggu Dhobi v Sukhnandan Ramdas Chaudhary (Dead) Through Lrs. and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0BEA47F0006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615">1994 Indlaw SC 1376, (1995) Supp3 SCC 179, 1996 (2) RentLR 672</a></p><p>Panchdeo Narain Srivastava v Km. Jyoti Sahay and Another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0BEA47F2006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615">1983 Indlaw SC 395, (1984) Supp SCC 594, AIR 1983 SC 462, 1983(1) SCALE 719, 1983 UJ 406</a></p><p>Messrs Modi Spinning and Weaving Mills Company v Messrs Ladha Ram and Company<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I01C84971006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615">1976 Indlaw SC 465, (1976) 4 SCC 320, AIR 1977 SC 680, [1977] 1 S.C.R. 728</a></p></div><div class="locatorSection"><h3 id="casesciting">Cases Citing this Case</h3><p>Dilip Kumar Singh v State of Jharkhand, through Education Commissioner-Cum-Secretary, Department of Education, Government of Jharkhand and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I029772F0986811E7992DAC95990613CC">2017 Indlaw JHKD 692</a></p><p>Calvin Rodrigues S/o Late Vincent Rodrigues and another v Maria Amberta Fernandes W/o Alexandre Hermenegildo Fernandes and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I5126BCF0445D11E789EA9616F4964E79">2017 Indlaw MUM 693</a></p><p>Abdul Ahmad v Haq Nawaz Ahmad<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0742D6D0703411E6A5D1B1F9351CECB1">2016 Indlaw ALL 396, 2016 (8) ADJ 176, 2016 (118) ALR 445, 2016 (5) AWC 4578</a></p><p>Hari Charan Pal v Dhananjoy Ghosh and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IDDA78220558611E68E38D8E9B644713F">2016 Indlaw CAL 600</a></p><p>Doodh Nath (Objection Filed) v Board of Revenue Uttar Pradesh Lucknow, through Its (Member Judicial) and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I4FB5D0D0662811E78023F3E53A56FB14">2016 Indlaw ALL 1667, 2016 (133) RD 371</a></p><p>Ganganna S/o Late Puttagangaiah v B. G. Thimmappaiah S/o Late Byra Hanumaiah and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I98EB33B007A811E6BB30D041D35EBB4D">2016 Indlaw KAR 2488</a></p><p>Simi Salim W/o Salim Hameed and another v Tip Top Furniture Industries, Represented by Its Managing Partner, K. T. Saidalavi, Malappuram and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I09435670F37511E6B96BF75269D0DB68">2016 Indlaw KER 1399, 2016 (2) KLT 719</a></p><p>Bijith International Builders, Represented by its Proprietor Balan Thachappully, Bangalore v Dias Varghese C. S/o Late Varghese and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I390FF901BF5D11E58ECC9984DDFF4392">2016 Indlaw KAR 76, 2016 (2) KarLJ 448</a></p><p>Larsen and Toubro Limited v State of Andhra Pradesh, represented by its Principal Secretary (Revenue), Hyderabad and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I07F3CBE0236011E79222B1D1D57F2008">2015 Indlaw HYD 515, 2016 (4) ALT 685</a></p><p>Jyotsna Bala Maity and others v Hansibala Pramanik and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IFA27D150943111E5AF37E07606CB0425">2015 Indlaw CAL 974, 2015 (4) CalLT 187</a></p><p>Duryodhan and others v Collector/D. D. C. Basti and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I8D602530FFDA11E5AA5A8DBD64D10571">2015 Indlaw ALL 1913, 2015 (112) ALR 87, 2015 (128) RD 329</a></p><p>Ramswaroop, (since Deceased) through His Lrs Gyandar and others v Manna Lal and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=ID79DD2F0739711E7A76E98DFE9D26B13">2015 Indlaw RAJ 2294, 2016 (2) WLN 417</a></p><p>Kasturibai @ Lakkavva W/o Basangouda Patil v Subhas @ Subhash Reddi S/o Siddappa Sataraddi and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I71208E1055A211E5918AC75D67E434B3">2015 Indlaw KAR 5382</a></p><p>Jhang Biradari Housing Residents Society v Bharat Bhushan Sachdeva and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=ID49A70E03F4611E5BF41BB205B2C14FB">2015 Indlaw DEL 2621, 2015 (1) CLT 480, 2015 (217) DLT 507</a></p><p>Narahari Kirana Shop, represented by its Prop. B. Bharathi, Nizamabad v K. Kishore Reddy and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I883C70C0A66C11E6BF7A901044788C02">2014 Indlaw HYD 1444, 2016 (1) ALT 27</a></p><p>Educare Limited and another v S. K. Sachdev and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I82299D00845511E5971DD030459FD092">2014 Indlaw DEL 4115, 2015 (61) PTC 307</a></p><p>Hari Shanker and others v Bhagwati Prasad Mishra<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I3C647BB0049311E59D3DB3D938FAEB1C">2014 Indlaw ALL 4233, 2015 (108) ALR 561</a></p><p>Pramod Kumar Prusty and others v Aina Prusty (since dead), represented by her legal heirs and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I5B7C57C0CBCC11E49D03BB6049BB19C0">2014 Indlaw ORI 456, 2014 (2) ILR(Cut) 760, 2014 (2) OLR 1035</a></p><p>Izhaar Ali and another v Prescribed Authority/Judge Small Causes Court, Sitapur and others<br />2014 Indlaw ALL 3926, 2014 (107) ALR 88</p><p>State of Uttar Pradesh and others v Ashok Kumar and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IBB0F59C037F811E4B07AFA0B267EA4C2">2014 Indlaw ALL 2707, 2014 (8) ADJ 251, 2014 (106) ALR 573, 2015 (2) AWC 1549, 2015 (1) CLT 308, 2014 (125) RD 690</a></p><p>Jagdish Asarpota and another v Jagdish Damodardas Asarpota and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I7FBA45F00BF311E480CDC1003044B97D">2014 Indlaw MUM 794, 2015(4) ALL MR 142, 2015 (1) MahLJ 127</a></p><p>Bhramara Nayak v Satya Badi and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IC7074660D67411E3931DAF676A4A8E04">2014 Indlaw ORI 266</a></p><p>Prem Nath Chopra Deceased through Lrs. v Arun Chopra and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0127C510A81511E38CBF9830039B3888">2014 Indlaw DEL 706, 2014 (209) DLT 144</a></p><p>Amit Johri v Deepak Johri and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I044EF3309FA511E3BEA981CDE067DC0F">2014 Indlaw DEL 601</a></p><p>Delhi Development Authority v Mathura Singh<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I055F76007DBD11E38C998BF228DA4170">2014 Indlaw DEL 54</a></p><p>Hindu College Committee, Represented By Its Secretary and Correspondent, G. T. Road, Guntur and another v Shaik Subhani<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0A1DCDC06EDD11E3B2079F3C48B6E8AE">2013 Indlaw AP 107, 2013 (4) ALD 361</a></p><p>Beti Devi v Ist Additional District Judge Hardoi and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I30815D6166BE11E2BD83AEC34689F3F6">2013 Indlaw ALL 58</a></p><p>Shumita Didi Sandhu v Sanjay Singh Sandhu and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I354A98D0F76E11E1B51EF2001723F305">2012 Indlaw DEL 1549, 2013 (1) ILR(Del) 56</a></p><p>Krishna Kilaru and another v Maytas Properties Limited Represented, by its Managing Director, Hyderabad<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=ID184F4B0A05611E38BF0F6D8774B2CA9">2012 Indlaw AP 615, 2013 (2) CompLJ 322</a></p><p>C. K. Narendranath S/o Keshavamurthy v Muniyamma W/o Late Chikkamuniswamyappa and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I7617F282CF5B11E191A8A5E34CFA168B">2012 Indlaw KAR 548</a></p><p>Rajesh Kumar and others v Chaman Lal and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IF8BEC41058EA11E38466E1D2754A84FD">2012 Indlaw ALL 3701, 2012 (4) AWC 3522</a></p><p>S. Radhika D/o N. Srinivasaraghavan v V. Vijayaprakash S/o S. Vasudevan<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IE2D9D7809F8A11E79A78E1D680A79A34">2011 Indlaw MAD 1405, 2012 (1) MLJ 269</a></p><p>Jhulla Sahoo (Dead) His Legal Heirs Sabitri Sahoo and others v Minatibala Behera and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IAEB933401E8611E2AD6990FC4454EEA2">2010 Indlaw ORI 368, 2011 (4) CLT 60, 2011 (1) ILR(Cut) 277</a></p><p>Chittaranjan Jana v Pankaj Nayek and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=ICC5AE640D6B811DFABE1E320BFC04F1F">2010 Indlaw CAL 695</a></p><p>Sheo Prakash Kajaria and another v Shreelal Kajaria and Shreeram Kajaria and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IBE7BDBB0235711E0BED4B8CAA24F4600">2010 Indlaw CAL 876, 2011 (2) CalLT 328, 2011 (3) CLT 423</a></p><p>Barendra Biswal v Rama Roy @ Das and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IFFA136E0447611E0BBC3D3865866742D">2010 Indlaw ORI 205, 2010 (2) OLR 871</a></p><p>Dass Estate Private Limited v Karar and Company<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0AEC7801A98811DF8C7F82B08604B4A9">2010 Indlaw CAL 515</a></p><p>P. S. Karunakaran and another v Madras Race Club, Represented by Aruna, Officer In-Charge (Legal)<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I166C14326ADE11DF9F23D505586DC304">2010 Indlaw MAD 1330</a></p><p>Pramod Khanna and another v Subod Khanna and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I9DDE50E0693511DFAC22EA11E1632910">2010 Indlaw DEL 1209, 2010 (169) DLT 62</a></p><p>Vivek Narayan Pal v Sumitra Pal<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I6C41B2A0428611DF9C969CD5F41C898C">2010 Indlaw DEL 516, 2010 (169) DLT 443, 2010 (4) ILR(Del) 499</a></p><p>Adarsh Kaur Gill v Surjit Kaur Gill and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I71A7AFB0428611DF9C969CD5F41C898C">2010 Indlaw DEL 333</a></p><p>Pothula Venkata Reddy @ Pothula Venkata Reddy Arya (died) per L.Rs. v B. Suseela and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IFF3A7630849111DF8787F5F7CFC8AD33">2009 Indlaw AP 501, 2010 (3) ALD 374, 2010 (3) ALT 478</a></p><p>Revajeetu Builders And Developers v Narayanaswamy And Sons And Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IA5C2E4E0006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2009 Indlaw SC 1213, (2009) 10 SCC 84, 2009 (77) ALR 654, 2009 (4) AWC 4002, JT 2009 (13) SC 366, 2010 (1) KarLJ 1, 2009 (8) MLJ(SC) 907, 2010 (1) RCR(Civil) 27, 2009 (2) RCR(Rent) 568, 2010 (109) RD 12, 2010 (1) RLW 322, 2009(13) SCALE 241, [2009] 15 S.C.R. 103</a></p><p>Anwar and others v District Judge, Ghazipur and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I4F7E696046AC11E29EE1D40499A26F99">2009 Indlaw ALL 2414, 2009 (7) ADJ 573, 2009 (77) ALR 459, 2010 (1) AWC 148, 2009 (108) RD 603</a></p><p>Armando Pereira and Another v Jude D'Souza and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB118A870006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2009 Indlaw MUM 855, 2009(4) ALL MR 233, 2009 (3) Bom.C.R. 147, 2009 (4) MahLJ 893, 2010 (5) RCR(Civil) 26</a></p><p>Sagar Singh Slathia v Surinder Pal Singh<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I1E6E63403D6C11E3896B977B22235B23">2009 Indlaw PNH 2367, 2009 (1) RCR(Rent) 535</a></p><p>Reveira Institute of Education Private Limited v Mantri Real Estate Private Limited and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1188161006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2008 Indlaw MUM 1079, 2009(1) ALL MR 896, 2009 (2) Bom.C.R. 687, 2009 (2) MahLJ 953</a></p><p>Emaculate Conception Church, Bangalore v Director General, Export Promotion Council, New Delhi and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IAE211351006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2008 Indlaw KAR 398, 2009 (3) KarLJ 260</a></p><p>Gautam Sarup v Leela Jetly and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IBAB567F0544D11DFA8C1DEF118F6F9C4">2008 Indlaw SC 2615, (2008) 7 SCC 85, AIR 2009 SC (Supp) 363, 2008 (3) AWC 2844, 2008 (3) Law Herald (P&amp;H) 2141, 2008 (4) MLJ(SC) 468, 2008 (4) MPLJ 113, 2008 (1) RCR(Rent) 487, 2008(4) SCALE 459, [2008] 4 S.C.R. 523, 2008 (1) UC 613</a></p><p>Sushil Kumar Kanungo and others v M. P. Rajya Sahkari Bank Maryadit and others<br />2008 Indlaw MPLJ 126</p><p>Jagram Shakya and others v Gokul Prasad<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I42AE47B1474C11E1AE58BF9AD4A7266D">2007 Indlaw MP 250, 2008 (2) CGLJ(MP) 6, 2008 (1) JabLJ 356, 2008(1) M.P.H.T. 504, 2008 (1) MPLJ 517</a></p><p>Jagram Shakya and others v Gokul Prasad<br />2007 Indlaw MPLJ 350</p><p>Ajit Kumar v Kiran Kumari and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I204625F0695D11E3A0E9DFC3F88086EF">2007 Indlaw PNH 1266, 2007 (148) PLR 634</a></p><p>Usha Balashaheb Swami and Others v Kiran Appaso Swami and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I56F93761006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615">2007 Indlaw SC 390, (2007) 5 SCC 602, AIR 2007 SC 1663, 2007 (5) ALD(SC) 79, 2007 (68) ALR 166, 2007 (3) AWC 2728, 2007 (3) CTC 400, JT 2007 (5) SC 476, 2007 (4) MLJ(SC) 99, 2007 (4) MPLJ 311, 2007 (2) RCR(Civil) 830, 2007(5) SCALE 831, 2007 (6) SCJ 83, [2007] 5 S.C.R. 306, 2007 (2) UC 878</a></p><p>Pfizer Inc v Pifer Pharmaceuticals Private Limited<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1188160006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2007 Indlaw DEL 286, 2007 (34) PTC 660</a></p><p>Uttam Chand Kothari v Gauri Shankar Jalan and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I973045D0006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2006 Indlaw GUW 65, AIR 2007 GAU 20</a></p><p>Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited v Precious Finance Investment Private Limited<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0752CC1066C611E1B19AB00358940555">2006 Indlaw MUM 1179, 2006 (6) Bom.C.R. 510, 2007 (1) MahLJ 331</a></p><p>Budhan Devi and others v IVth Addl. District Judge, Jaunpur and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I55D598B2492711E2BAB3F93DAD38FB8B">2006 Indlaw ALL 956, 2007 (66) ALR 276, 2007 (5) AWC 5369</a></p><p>Steel Authority of India Limited v Union of India and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I3B23D1D0006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615">2006 Indlaw SC 525, (2006) 12 SCC 233, (2007) 1 SCC (L&amp;S) 630, AIR 2006 SC 3229, 2006 (6) AWC 5574, 2006 (111) FLR 483, 2007 (1) JhrCR(SC) 36, 2006(9) SCALE 597, 2006 (6) SLR 8, [2006] Supp6 S.C.R. 663</a></p><p>Gtl Limited v Maharashtra Rajya Rashtriya Kamgar Sangh and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I1427285263B011E1AB18D7EF41A0E505">2006 Indlaw MUM 1139, 2006 (3) MahLJ 646</a></p><p>Sadiq Ali alias Sadaq Ali and another v Murti Devi and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I3673780172AA11E28031BC797C83F17F">2005 Indlaw ALL 1585, 2005 (61) ALR 112, 2006 (1) AWC 343</a></p><p>Rasiklal Manikchand Dhariwal and Others v Kishore Washwani and Nitesh Ashok Wadhwani<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB117E520006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2005 Indlaw MUM 250, 2005 (3) Bom.C.R. 104, 2005 (2) MahLJ 611, 2005 (31) PTC 401</a></p><p>Sangramsinh P. Gaekwad and Others v Shantadevi P. Gaekwad (Dead)Through Lrs. and<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I3B09E131006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615">2005 Indlaw SC 58, (2005) 11 SCC 314, AIR 2005 SC 809, 6 CLC 277, [2005] 123 Comp Cas 566, 2005 (3) CompLJ 385, JT 2005 (1) SC 581, 2005 (1) RCR(Civil) 561, 2005(1) SCALE 493, [2005] 1 S.C.R. 624</a></p><p>Devendra Mohan and others v State of Uttar Pradesh and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I68EE5BE038AF11E29916ACF77B7F7D84">2004 Indlaw ALL 674, 2004 (2) AllCJ 968, 2004 (55) ALR 623, 2004 (3) AWC 2162, 2004 (2) ESC 800, 2004 (97) RD 108</a></p><p>State Bank of Patiala v Bank For Foreign Economic Affairs of USSR<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1183341006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2002 Indlaw DEL 344</a></p><p>Srinivasa Raj Kamal and others v Neelamsetty Kataji Rao and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I52406A50E68C11E3BED6E7728D1EF3B3">2002 Indlaw AP 548, 2002 (5) ALD 740</a></p><p>Shantibai and others v Ganpat Rao Gujar and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I783AE4014BFD11E1B3E9D7D21777C87F">2001 Indlaw MP 612, 2002 (1) JabLJ 17, 2001 (3) MPLJ 439</a></p><p>Shantibai and others v Ganpat Rao Gujar and others<br />2001 Indlaw MPLJ 491</p><p>Janu Laxman Kumbhar v Pandurang Laxman Kumbhar<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I4094D88071C811E198EBCCC848E78DA1">2001 Indlaw MUM 876, 2002 (1) Bom.C.R. 212, 2001 (4) MahLJ 159</a></p><p>Shalini Vyankatesh Puntambekar v Jayaprakash R. Agarwal<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I11E09DC06C4211E1AA48FEA94C21E7E6">2001 Indlaw MUM 806, 2002 (1) MahLJ 925, 2002 (Supp) Bom.C.R. 484</a></p><p>Hansa Devi Sahu v Bachchalal Jaisinghani and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I04810E503C5C11E1A8C19927CB888009">2001 Indlaw MP 331, 2001(5) M.P.H.T. 116, 2002 (1) MPLJ 122</a></p><p>Hansa Devi Sahu v Bachchalal Jaisinghani and another<br />2001 Indlaw MPLJ 203</p><p>Chandrasen Jain v Suresh Chand Jain and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I047B69013C5C11E1A8C19927CB888009">2001 Indlaw MP 326, 2001(3) M.P.H.T. 486, 2001 (3) MPLJ 191</a></p><p>Chandrasen Jain v Suresh Chand Jain and others<br />2001 Indlaw MPLJ 200</p><p>Surendra Bhatia and Etc. v Smt. Punam Bhatia and Others Etc..<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I987AA020006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2001 Indlaw RAJ 431, AIR 2001 RAJ 338</a></p><p>Hukumchand (Dead) through L.rs. v Mahant Ramcharan Dass Chela and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IE07D6D403D0611E19945CAC1C42BD479">2001 Indlaw MP 425, 2001(4) M.P.H.T. 170, 2001 (3) MPLJ 319</a></p><p>Hukumchand (Dead) through L.rs. v Mahant Ramcharan Dass Chela and others<br />2001 Indlaw MPLJ 238</p><p>Claridges Hotel Pvt. Ltd. v M/s. M.M. Bhagat and Company<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1185A52006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2001 Indlaw DEL 883, 2001 (4) AD(Del) 790, 2001 (92) DLT 61, 2001 (59) DRJ 23, 2001 RLR 459</a></p><p>Mudra Salt And Chemical Industries v Collector, Thane and others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I9F57C7A1729111E19413FAA308CD7D58">2001 Indlaw MUM 912, 2001 (3) MahLJ 151, 2001 (Supp) Bom.C.R. 803</a></p><p>Balu Appaji Sangonkar v Rangrao Dattoba Palkar<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I19FE45A05EED11E18DF0D4239F6A233E">2001 Indlaw MUM 721, 2001 (3) Bom.C.R. 249, 2001 (2) MahLJ 709</a></p><p>Mr.Ved Mehta and Ors v Commander Ashok Mehta<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1183340006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2000 Indlaw DEL 723, 2000 (87) DLT 469, 2000 (56) DRJ 233, 2001 (1) RCR(Civil) 151</a></p><p>Swarnjeet Singh v Asharam Gamne<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I99D55E823DC311E1BEC9D6DD2CAE268F">2000 Indlaw MP 649, 2001(1) M.P.H.T. 396, 2001 (4) MPLJ 6</a></p><p>Swarnjeet Singh v Asharam Gamne<br />2000 Indlaw MPLJ 281</p><p>Tertuliano Renato De Silva and another v Francisco Lourenco Bettencourt De Silva and another<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I4081779171C811E198EBCCC848E78DA1">2000 Indlaw MUM 635, 2000 (3) Bom.C.R. 29, 2000 (2) MahLJ 812</a></p><p>Ashish Das Gupta v Satvinder Singh and Another and Parwanoo Enterprises Private Limited and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1183343006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">2000 Indlaw CLB 2, 2000 (1) CLC 1225</a></p><p>Shri Krishan Swarup Bhatnagar v Shri Chander Mohan Rewal and Another.<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1183342006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">1999 Indlaw HP 99, AIR 2000 HP 53</a></p><p>Mitra of Archdiocese of Goa And Daman v K. Vijayadharan<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I9EED6D10729111E19413FAA308CD7D58">1999 Indlaw MUM 680, 2000 (1) Bom.C.R. 857, 2000 (1) MahLJ 615</a></p><p>Narendra Nath Sen v Broadway Centre.<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1180C30006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">1999 Indlaw CAL 300, AIR 2000 CAL 214, 1999 (2) CalLT 425</a></p><p>Baldev Singh v Godran Rubber Plastic Industries<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1180C32006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">1999 Indlaw DEL 11177, 1999 (3) AD(Del) 817, 1999 (2) ARBLR 557, 2000 (1) CLC 531, 1999 (79) DLT 513</a></p><p>Baldev Singh v Godran Rubber Plastic Industries<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1185A51006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">1999 Indlaw DEL 616, 1999 (19) PTC 365</a></p><p>A. B. L. Limited, Durgapur, Burdwan v Radha Gobinda Ghatak and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1180C31006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">1999 Indlaw CAL 62, 2000 (2) CalLT 302, 2000 (3) CLR 691, 2000 (1) LLJ 686</a></p><p>Ashalata Sadashiv Mahajan v State of Maharashtra and Others<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1003E70006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">1998 Indlaw MUM 8670, AIR 1999 BOM 84, 1998 (3) Bom.C.R. 693</a></p><p>Vaidhya Shyam Sunder Joshi v Jain Vishwa Bharti Ladnu and Others.<br /><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=IB1185A50006E11DF8DDDB6CBBF184CCF">1998 Indlaw RAJ 263, AIR 1998 RAJ 227, 1998 (2) RLW 705</a></p></div><div class="locatorSection"><h3 id="legiscited">Legislation Cited</h3><p><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I0116D3C0006E11DFA9B79C2097992CEB">Code of Civil Procedure, 1908</a></p><p><a href="/maf/wlin/app/document?src=doc&amp;linktype=ref&amp;&amp;context=9678&amp;crumb-action=replace&amp;docguid=I013901C1006E11DFA9B79C2097992CEB">Constitution of India, 1950</a></p></div><p class="small center">© 2015 Thomson Reuters South Asia Private Limited</p><p id="disclaimer" class="small center">This database contains editorial enhancements that are not a part of the original material. The database may also have mistakes or omissions. Users are requested to verify the contents with the relevant original text(s) such as, the certified copy of the judgment, Government Gazettes, etc. Thomson Reuters bears no liability whatsoever for the adequacy, accuracy, satisfactory quality or suitability of the content.</p></div><div id="docFooter"><div id="docBottomLeft"><div id="docBottomRight"><!----></div></div><div id="footer"><a title="Thomson Reuters - This link will open in a new window" class="externalLink" href="http://www.thomsonreuters.com/">Thomson Reuters homepage</a><p class="bold">Customer support 1800 266 0288</p><p class="small">© 2018 Thomson Reuters South Asia Private Limited</p></div></div></div></div><div id="researchSpaceHiddenForm"><form id="docValues"><input id="document_title" name="document_title" value="Heeralal v Kalyan Maland Others - Supreme Court of India, 19 November 1997 | Case Analysis" type="hidden" /><input id="novus_document_id" name="novus_document_id" value="I0BEA20E1006E11DFBEF1C9F02835E615" type="hidden" /><input id="document_court" name="document_court" value="Supreme Court of India" type="hidden" /><input name="citation" value="Case Analysis" type="hidden" /><input id="date_of_hearing" name="date_of_hearing" value="19 November 1997 " type="hidden" /><input id="currentFolderInput" name="destinationFolderId" value="" type="hidden" /><input id="document_content_type" name="document_content_type" value="Cases" type="hidden" /></form></div><script type="text/javascript">
			if(wluk.doc!=null){
				wluk.doc.loadFontSizeFromPref('12.8px');
			};		
		</script><div id="jstree-marker" style="display: none;"></div><div id="vakata-contextmenu"></div></body></html>
{'avg_line_length': 898.8032786885246, 'max_line_length': 39327, 'alphanum_fraction': 0.7552483265544349, 'licenses': ['MIT'], 'repository_name': 'athityakumar/harvey', 'path': 'datafiles/CaseAnalysis/1997/1997_K_55.html', 'size': 54836, 'lang': 'HTML'}