 the extended family? It's hard to explain to them that you can't just say no. You can't just say no to giving money to 18 family members. That's a financial obligation that [some are] expected to live up to,” Nair says.
The Western assumption that someone would immediately want to say no to these duties is inaccurate, too. Wendy, 23, tells me that she and her mum are best friends. The pair constantly FaceTime, take walks around the block before dinnertime together and bicker lovingly.
For the past few years, she and her younger brother Rory, 21, have been helping to financially support their mum. All the utility bills — wifi, phone, water, gas and electricity — as well as their share of rent (which is higher than their mum’s portion) are taken on by the Gen Z siblings.
“If we're out with our mum, we don't feel comfortable letting her pay for things, so we usually take that on. We're like, ‘No, no, let us pay’. She's like, ‘no, no, it's OK’. But we're like, ‘No, it's alright. Save your money. We got you’,” she tells Refinery29 Australia.
“Our parents have given us so much and, especially if you’re a child of an immigrant, you've seen them work so hard. My mum’s a single mum, so she's done pretty much for herself. I know I have to give back.”
Wendy, 23
There was never a conversation about the passing on of the household costs. After seeing the stressful toll that paying bills was taking on their mum, Wendy and Rory instinctively took over. It hasn’t been an easy road — far from it, we both tear up a bit on the phone — but it’s a journey she’s proud to be on.
“Our parents have given us so much and, especially if you’re a child of an immigrant, you've seen them work so hard. My mum’s a single mum, so she's done pretty much everything for herself. I know I have to give back.”
“Sometimes it's a lot though. But then you really have to face reality and just be like, ‘OK, this is what I’ve got to do’. Growing up and knowing how much my mum’s done for [us], I just want her to live a good life.”
The rags-to-not-really-riches story is customary, especially when you remember that Australia has a migrant majority (over 50% of residents were either born overseas or have a parent who was born overseas).
“There's a lot of pressure to either provide for parents or provide for extended family who are back home [and] who might not even be [in the country],” Nair shares, pointing particularly to working professionals aged between 20 and 45 who she sees as clients grappling with this exact issue.
While financial pressures can be mandated by parents — one person tells us that the first thing her mum said in response to her travel plans was, "What about my retirement?” — other times, the sense of responsibility is self-led. “I put my own burdens on myself. I'm like, these are the expectations I need to meet and I have no idea like where these expectations have come from,” Wendy admits.
The complicated truth is that being financially responsible for your parents isn’t a bad thing. It’s not black-and-white, unlike some discourse around the topic would want you to believe. “Children should not be responsible for their parents' bad decisions," comments one Instagram user on a recent R29 post, with others adding, “Expecting these adult children to now care for them feels very shocking.” and “We do not owe our parents for doing their jobs as parents.”
Financially supporting your parents and extended family can imbue some with a sense of purpose and happiness. “It can be healthy when there is transparent communication, and no guilt [and] emotional blackmailing involved,” Nair says, adding that preexisting communication and conflict resolution skills will flow over into financial conversations.
“[If] you have a healthy connection with your extended family [and] your culture, and you believe that by participating in family and being a part of something bigger than [yourself], [you might] love it and get something great out of it, [like] a sense of connection [and] inclusion.”
Perhaps it’s because these values are familial and traditional, but some turn their noses up at these responsibilities in the name of feminism and the patriarchy. But as Rafia Zakaria wrote in Against White Feminism of her Pakistani mother, grandmother and aunts, “Their resilience, their sense of responsibility, their empathy, and their capacity for hope, are also feminist qualities, but not ones that the current feminist arithmetic will permit.”
The burden of financially caring for others can weigh immensely heavy, make no mistake. "If somebody is not able to meet those obligations, it can result in guilt or shame,” Nair says. “Then you [might] see the external manifestations of these internal unresolved conflicts."
“You might see them completely avoiding their family, then completely pretending that their name is not their name, their culture is not their culture. You might be someone [who becomes] a people pleaser [with] zero boundaries; [someone who] tries to make more money, says yes to everybody, [then] runs themselves down.”
“Don't plan for them, have a plan including them."
Smruthy Nair
I ask Wendy how she cares for her mental health. “I don't think I've ever thought about that,” she answers. “I don't know… I think that just the fact that I'm helping makes me feel good. I don't like to think about things too much because then I get sad. Maybe that's good… that’s probably really bad,” she laughs.
Though it’s antithetic to the ‘sweep it under the rug’ approach that’s often taken with money and mental health conversations in Asian communities, Nair recommends being transparent about worries and starting open conversations with your parents.
“Don't plan for them, have a plan including them. Don’t just sit and kind of think about the doom and gloom and get anxious because that's not going to help you. You have to have a plan that involves all parties you're thinking about,” they say. Practically speaking, seeking out financial education and culturally-sensitive support spaces can also be important tools in your kit.
In the same vein that receiving a massage isn’t the universal self-care fix for all, the insistence of caring financially for your parents isn’t a reality for every child of immigrants. It doesn’t make you a bad child, son or daughter, it makes you one that’s figuring out how best to honour yourself and your family at the same time.
If you are struggling with debt and don't know where to turn, call the free National Debt Helpline on 1800 007 007. The helpline is open Monday to Friday, 9:30am to 4:30pm.
Losing My Career Ambition Hits Different As A WOC
Financial Self-Care Is Key For First Nations Women
The Burden Of Financially Supporting Your Parents
Living • Work and Money
Illustrated by Rel Pham.Live like a local among some of Hollywood’s biggest stars with this studio apartment in Manhattan’s Upper East Side. With neighbors such as Woody Allen, Mariah Carey, Spike Lee and Madonna, what more can you ask for?
This modernly furnished studio abode on 81st Street between 1st and 2nd Avenue is located on the 3rd floor (considered 2nd in Europe) of a 5-story walk-up prewar building. For assured privacy and convenient guest entry, a buzz-in intercom security system is in place.
Highlights of this New York City apartment include hard wood floors, efficient closet space, a charming decorative fireplace, and two windows facing a residential street. One queen-sized bed is provided for comfortable sleeping, and additional bedding is supplied in the form of a queen-sized convertible sofa bed. Other modern amenities include a flat-screen cable television with triple play, DVD player, and contemporary artwork.
A fully equipped kitchen allows tenants to cook their favorite homemade meals with ease! This tiled room provides cabinetry, most essential cooking appliances, and a wooden dining table for four.
Central Park: A must-visit in NYC, this world-famous park includes its own lake, zoo, and many green lawns. Free events are always going on here in the summer months, so be sure to look up upcoming affairs on the central park website! 0.6mi/1km. Accessible via foot.
Metropolitan Museum of Art: Take a tour through this highly influential museum (known as the Met), which holds large collections of various ancient art. 0.7mi/1.1km. Accessible via foot.
Roosevelt Island: Take a tram to this often-overlooked island, which was once home to spooky insane asylums and hospitals (some of the ruins still remain). While here, visit the Southpoint Park and north point lighthouse. 1.3mi/2km. Accessible via foot or bus.
For easy public transportation around Manhattan walk to 77 Street / Lexington Avenue, serving the 6 line. 0.5mi/850m.
[{"id":40600,"idParent":40598,"namaWilayah":"JREBENGKEMBANG","tingkatWilayah":4,"idPro":32676,"id