question: Who is Maud Of Gloucester, Countess Of Chester's father-in-law?
context: [["Barthold A. Butensch\u00f8n Sr.", ["Hans Barthold Andresen Butensch\u00f8n( 27 December 1877 \u2013 28 November 1971) was a Norwegian businessperson.", "He was born in Kristiania as a son of Nils August Andresen Butensch\u00f8n and Hanna Butensch\u00f8n, and grandson of Nicolay Andresen.", "Together with Mabel Anette Plahte( 1877 \u2013 1973, a daughter of Frithjof M. Plahte) he had the son Hans Barthold Andresen Butensch\u00f8n Jr. and was through him the father- in- law of Ragnhild Butensch\u00f8n and grandfather of Peter Butensch\u00f8n.", "Through his daughter Marie Claudine he was the father- in- law of Joakim Lehmkuhl, through his daughter Mabel Anette he was the father- in- law of Harald Astrup( a son of Sigurd Astrup) and through his daughter Nini Augusta he was the father- in- law of Ernst Torp.", "He took commerce school and agricultural school.", "He was hired in the family company N. A. Andresen& Co, and became a co-owner in 1910.", "He eventually became chief executive officer.", "The bank changed its name to Andresens Bank in 1913 and merged with Bergens Kreditbank in 1920.", "The merger was dissolved later in the 1920s.", "He was also a landowner, owning Nedre Sk\u00f8yen farm and a lot of land in Enebakk.", "He chaired the board of Nydalens Compagnie from 1926, having not been a board member before that.", "He also chaired the supervisory council of Forsikringsselskapet Viking and Nedre Glommen salgsforening, and was a supervisory council member of Filharmonisk Selskap.", "He was a member of the gentlemen's club SK Fram since 1890, and was proclaimed a lifetime member in 1964.", "He was buried in Enebakk."]], ["Ogawa Mataji", ["Viscount was a general in the early Imperial Japanese Army.", "He was also the father- in- law of Field Marshal Gen Sugiyama."]], ["Mabel FitzRobert, Countess of Gloucester", ["Mabel FitzRobert, Countess of Gloucester( c. 1100 \u2013 29 September 1157) was an Anglo- Norman noblewoman, and a wealthy heiress who brought the lordship of Gloucester, among other prestigious honours to her husband, Robert, 1st Earl of Gloucester upon their marriage.", "He was the illegitimate son of King Henry I of England.", "Her father was Robert Fitzhamon, Lord of Gloucester and Glamorgan.", "As she was the eldest daughter of four, and her younger sisters had become nuns, Mabel inherited all of his honours and properties upon his death in 1107.", "As Countess of Gloucester, Mabel was significant politically and she exercised an important administrative role in the lordship."]], ["Margaret de Clare", ["Margaret de Clare, Countess of Gloucester, Countess of Cornwall( 12 October 1293 \u2013 9 April 1342) was an English noblewoman, heiress, and the second- eldest of the three daughters of Gilbert de Clare, 6th Earl of Hertford and his wife Joan of Acre, making her a granddaughter of King Edward I of England.", "Her two husbands were Piers Gaveston and Hugh de Audley, 1st Earl of Gloucester."]], ["Anne of Gloucester", ["Anne of Gloucester, Countess of Stafford (30 April 1383 \u2013 16 October 1438) was the eldest daughter of Thomas of Woodstock, Duke of Gloucester, and Eleanor de Bohun."]], ["John of Scotland, Earl of Huntingdon", ["John of Scotland( or John de Scotia), 9th Earl of Huntingdon and 7th Earl of Chester( c. 12076 June 1237), sometimes known as\" the Scot\", was an Anglo- Scottish magnate, the son of David of Scotland, Earl of Huntingdon by his wife Matilda of Chester, daughter of Hugh de Kevelioc.", "John married", "Elen ferch Llywelyn, daughter of Llywelyn the Great, in about 1222.", "John became Earl of Huntingdon in 1219 on the death of his father.", "On the death of John's maternal uncle, Ranulph de Blondeville, Earl of Chester, on 26 October 1232, the Earldom of Chester was inherited by John's mother Matilda( Maud) of Chester( Ranulph's eldest sister).", "Less than a month later with the consent of the King, she gave an\" inter vivos\" gift of the earldom to her son John who became Earl of Chester by right of his mother.", "He was formally invested by King Henry III as Earl of Chester on 21 November 1232.", "He became Earl of Chester in his own right six weeks later on the death of his mother in January 1233.", "John died childless on 6 June 1237, aged 30.", "He too, like his uncle Ranulph before him, left four sisters as his co-heirs.", "They agreed to share the estates between them, and to make the husband of the eldest sister Christian, William de Forz, Earl of Chester and Huntingdon by right of his wife.", "However Henry III decided that the earldoms should be annexed to the crown\" lest so fair a dominion should be divided among women\".", "In 1246, Henry bought the honour( estate) of Chester from John's four sisters.", "The earldom of Chester was recreated for Simon de Montfort in 1264, and the earldom of Huntingdon was recreated in 1337 for William de Clinton."]], ["Ranulf de Gernon, 4th Earl of Chester", ["Ranulf II (also known as Ranulf de Gernon), 4th Earl of Chester (1099\u20131153), was an Anglo-Norman baron who inherited the honour of the palatine county of Chester upon the death of his father Ranulf le Meschin, 3rd Earl of Chester.", "He was descended from the Counts of Bessin in Normandy.", "In 1136 David I of Scotland invaded England as far as Durham, which led Stephen of England to negotiate treaties that involved granting Ranulf's lands to Scotland.", "Thereafter, Ranulf allied himself to Matilda to further his cause.", "He took Lincoln Castle in 1141, which was retaken by Stephen in a siege in which Ranulf was forced to flee for his life.", "Ranulf enlisted the help of Robert, 1st Earl of Gloucester to retake the castle and succeeded when King Stephen surrendered to him at Lincoln.", "While Matilda ruled England, Stephen's queen Matilda of Boulogne managed to defeat Ranulf and his allies at Winchester, which eventually resulted in Stephen being able to resume the throne."]], ["Maud of Gloucester, Countess of Chester", ["Maud of Gloucester, Countess of Chester (died 29 July 1189), also known as Matilda, was an Anglo-Norman noblewoman and the daughter of Robert, 1st Earl of Gloucester, an illegitimate son of King Henry I of England and Mabel, daughter of Robert fitz Hamon.", "Her husband was Ranulf de Gernon, 4th Earl of Chester (died 16 December 1153)."]], ["Ludwig von Westphalen", ["Johann Ludwig von Westphalen( 11 July 1770 \u2013 3 March 1842) was a liberal Prussian civil servant and the father- in- law of Karl Marx."]], ["John Adams (merchant)", ["John Adams( 1672 or 1673 \u2013 1745) was an American- born Canadian merchant and member of the Nova Scotia Council.", "He was the father- in- law of Henry Newton( politician)."]]]
supporting_facts: [["Maud of Gloucester, Countess of Chester", 1], ["Ranulf de Gernon, 4th Earl of Chester", 0]]
evidences: [["Maud of Gloucester, Countess of Chester", "spouse", "Ranulf de Gernon, 4th Earl of Chester"], ["Ranulf de Gernon, 4th Earl of Chester", "father", "Ranulf le Meschin, 3rd Earl of Chester"]]
answer: Ranulf le Meschin, 3rd Earl of Chester