question: Who was born earlier, Joshua Chamberlain or Carroll Righter?
context: [["Fanny Chamberlain", ["\" Frances Chamberlain redirects here.", "For the male version of the name, see Francis Chamberlain( disambiguation).", "For the playwright born Frances Chamberlaine, see Frances Sheridan.\"", "Frances Caroline\" Fanny\" Chamberlain, n\u00e9e Adams( August 12, 1825 \u2013 October 18, 1905) was the wife of Joshua Chamberlain."]], ["George Chamberlain (bishop)", ["George Chamberlain or Chamberlayne( 1576 \u2013 1634) was an Englishman who became the sixth bishop of Ypres."]], ["Jo\u00ebl Henry (journalist)", ["Jo\u00ebl Henry( born 1955) is a French journalist who was born in Strasbourg."]], ["Carroll Righter", ["Carroll Righter", "( February 2, 1900 \u2013 April 30, 1988) was known as the\" astrologer to the stars.\"", "He wrote a syndicated daily advice column for 166 newspapers around the world and was reputed to be an advisor to Ronald and Nancy Reagan.", "Righter, who liked to be called the\" gregarious Aquarius,' began doing charts for Hollywood notables in 1938 and became a columnist in 1950.", "Prior to that, he was a lawyer in Philadelphia.", "Righter was mentioned in President Reagan's 1965 autobiography\" Where's The Rest of Me?\" and, according to former White House Chief of Staff Donald T. Regan, Mrs. Reagan turned to astrologers to help determine the president's schedule.", "Asked specifically whether he believed in astrology, President Reagan said,\" I do n't guide my life by it\" but he added,\" I do n't know enough about it to say, is there something to it or not ... and I do n't mean to offend anyone who does believe in it, or engages in it.\"", "When Righter was asked in 1985 if he consulted with Ronald Reagan on astrology, he replied,\" No comment.\"", "Righter claimed he warned Marlene Dietrich to avoid working on a studio set one day because she might get hurt.", "His advice was not heeded, and Dietrich broke an ankle while reaching out to save a falling child.", "Word of the accident and Righter's advice led other celebrities to the astrologer, ensuring his fame.", "Among those who sought his advice were Arlene Dahl, Rhonda Fleming, Jane Withers, Hildegard Knef, Joan Fontaine and Grace Kelly.", "At one point in the late 1930s, the then- young Robert Mitchum worked as a ghost writer for Righter.", "Righter wrote several books, including\" Astrology and You,\" the\" Astrological Guide to Health and Diet\", and the\" Astrological Guide to Marriage and Family Relations\"."]], ["Richard the Qaid", ["Richard the Qaid was a senior official(\" q\u0101\u02beid\", commander) of the royal council(\" curia regis\" or\" diwan\") in the court of the Norman Kingdom of Sicily at Palermo during the latter years of the reign of William I of Sicily and during the regency of his wife, Margaret of Navarre, for their son William II.", "He was already the Great Chamberlain, or\" magister camerarius\", when William I died in 1166."]], ["Joshua Chamberlain", ["Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain( born Lawrence Joshua Chamberlain, September 8, 1828 February 24, 1914) was an American college professor from the State of Maine who volunteered during the American Civil War to join the Union Army.", "He became a highly respected and decorated Union officer, reaching the rank of brigadier general( and brevet major general).", "He is best known for his gallantry at the Battle of Gettysburg, for which he was awarded the Medal of Honor.", "Following the war, he served as Governor of Maine.", "Chamberlain was commissioned a lieutenant colonel in the 20th Maine Volunteer Infantry Regiment in 1862 and fought at the Battle of Fredericksburg.", "He became commander of the regiment in June 1863.", "On July 2, during the Battle of Gettysburg, Chamberlain's regiment occupied the extreme left of the Union lines at Little Round Top.", "Chamberlain's men withstood repeated assaults from the 15th Regiment Alabama Infantry and finally drove the Confederates away with a downhill bayonet charge.", "Chamberlain was severely wounded while commanding a brigade during the Second Battle of Petersburg in June 1864, and was given what was intended to be a deathbed promotion to brigadier general.", "In April 1865, he fought at the Battle of Five Forks and was given the honor of commanding the Union troops at the surrender ceremony for the infantry of Robert E. Lee's Army at Appomattox Court House, Virginia.", "After the war, he entered politics as a Republican and served four one- year terms of office as the 32nd Governor of Maine.", "He served on the faculty, and as president, of his\" alma mater\", Bowdoin College.", "He died in 1914 at age 85 due to complications from the wound that he received at Petersburg."]], ["Castulus", ["Saint Castulus( died 286) is venerated as a martyr.", "According to tradition, he was the chamberlain( or officer, valet) of Emperor Diocletian and the husband of Saint Irene of Rome."]], ["Robert Brandon", ["Robert Brandon( died 30 May 1591) was an English goldsmith and jeweller to Queen Elizabeth I of England.", "A prominent member of the Goldsmiths' Company, Brandon was elected Chamberlain or treasurer of the City of London in 1583, a position he held until his death in 1591."]], ["Sir Leonard Chamberlain", ["Sir Leonard Chamberlain or Chamberlayne( died 1561) was an English soldier and politician, the Governor of Guernsey from 1553."]], ["Thomas Chamberlain (soldier)", ["Thomas Davee Chamberlain( April 29, 1841 \u2013 August 12, 1896) was the Lieutenant Colonel of the 20th Maine Volunteer Infantry Regiment during the American Civil War, the brother of Union general Joshua L. Chamberlain, the Colonel of the 20th Maine Infantry."]]]
supporting_facts: [["Joshua Chamberlain", 0], ["Carroll Righter", 1]]
evidences: [["Joshua Chamberlain", "date of birth", "September 8, 1828"], ["Carroll Righter", "date of birth", "February 2, 1900"]]
answer: Joshua Chamberlain