question: Who lived longer, Carl Rattray or Stiv Bators?
context: [["Stiv Bators", ["Steven John Bator( October 22, 1949 \u2013 June 4, 1990), better known by his stage name Stiv Bators, was an American punk rock vocalist and guitarist from Girard, Ohio.", "He is best remembered for his bands Dead Boys and The Lords of the New Church."]], ["R. Charlton (poet/songwriter)", ["R. Charlton, who lived in the early nineteenth century, was a Tyneside poet/ songwriter."]], ["Maximus of Tyre", ["Maximus of Tyre( fl. late 2nd century AD), also known as Cassius Maximus Tyrius, was a Greek rhetorician and philosopher who lived in the time of the Antonines and Commodus, and who belongs to the trend of the Second Sophistic.", "His writings contain many allusions to the history of Greece, while there is little reference to Rome; hence it is inferred that he lived longer in Greece, perhaps as a professor at Athens.", "Although nominally a Platonist, he is really an Eclectic and one of the precursors of Neoplatonism."]], ["Carl Rattray", ["Raphael Carl Rattray QC( 18 September 1929 \u2013 14 March 2012) was a Jamaican jurist and politician.", "Rattray was born in 1929 in St. Elizabeth.", "He began his career in law in England before being called to the Jamaica Bar in 1958.", "In 1969, he was appointed a Queen's Counsel.", "He was also a founder of the law firm of Rattray, Patterson, Rattray."]], ["Justin (historian)", ["Justin( century) was a Latin writer who lived under the Roman Empire."]], ["Danny Nordahl", ["Danny Nordahl is a bass guitarist who currently plays in the bands Faster Pussycat and Motochrist.", "He has also played in the bands The Throbs, Stiv Bators And His Evil Boys, N.Y. Loose, The Newlydeads, Tracii Guns' version of L.A. Guns, and Hollywood Roses."]], ["Gaius Julius Aquila", ["Gaius Julius Aquila was the name of a number of people who lived during the Roman Empire."]], ["Fred H. Frank", ["Fred H. Frank was a member of the Wisconsin State Assembly who lived in Appleton."]], ["Mubarak Khwaja", ["Mubarak Khwaja was the khan of White Horde between 1320- 1344.", "He succeeded his brother, Ilbasan, with the assistance of Uzbeg, Khan of the Golden Horde and the House of Batu.", "However, he declared his independence from Sarai.", "The Khan sent his son Tini Beg to overthrow him.", "Thus, he was replaced by Chimtay, son of Ilbasan.", "He may have lived longer after his dethronement, occupying some lands."]], ["Henryk Derczy\u0144ski", ["Henryk Derczy\u0144ski( 1906- 1981) was a photographer, who lived in Poland."]]]
supporting_facts: [["Carl Rattray", 0], ["Stiv Bators", 0]]
evidences: [["Carl Rattray", "date of birth", "18 September 1929"], ["Carl Rattray", "date of death", "14 March 2012"], ["Stiv Bators", "date of birth", "October 22, 1949"], ["Stiv Bators", "date of death", "June 4, 1990"]]
answer: Carl Rattray