8de6f3f8_Read_all____Anime_News_Network__Comment__
[Read all▲▼] Punch! (manga) [Rating▲▼] So-so [Comment▲▼] 
I usually like Rie Takada, but I thought Punch! was just meh. The characterization was flimsy in this series, making it read like a teenage girl's shallow wish fulfillment fantasy. The guys were very pretty but had very little personality. All of their actions pretty much seemed focused on going out with the main character who had her moments of hilarity but was not as fun as other Takada heroines. Some of the "romantic" lines were beyond cheesy as well. I actually liked the two short stories at the end of volume 3 better than the main series. I got a few laughs out of those and the relationships while still somewhat contrived, at least made more sense. My final verdict? Skip it and read Wild Act instead.
PrettyKitty20034's Manga [Read all] - Anime News Network
Comment▲▼