A woman 's first date with a man she met on OkCupid turned to disaster after he allegedly stole her car . The woman , who has not been named , went for dinner with Gerald Tietz , who charmed her into meeting him at a restaurant in New Jersey last month . The two later went back to the woman 's house - at which point Tietz is accusing of filching her car keys and driving off in her red Toyota , along with some of her jewelry . 'Car thief ' : Gerald Tietz , pictured above on OkCupid , allegedly tempted a New Jersey woman to a restaurant then stole her car . Police caught Tietz Saturday night after sharing his dating profile and pictures of the 2007 Solara , which had custom plates that read JSRYGRL . According to officers , Tietz lured the woman to Racks Restaurant and Sports Bar in Atco , New Jersey after posing online as a 53-year-old called Gennaro Aladena . Detectives also believe he could have tried the same trick on other women , also employing the pseudonym Mike Rossman , or his apparent nickname , Gooch . Taken : Police published this image of the woman 's 2007 Toyota Solara , which has custom plates reading JSRYGRL . Tietz , who is 5 ' 1 '' , and a bald smoker in his 50s , was arrested Saturday in Cherry Hill , New Jersey , and booked into the Camden County jail . Police did not explain what happened at the house before the car theft , and would only say that 'at some point ' during the encounter 'the male got a hold of the keys ' . Tietz said he was from Atlantic City while allegedly posing on the dating site , and officers think he has strong ties to Atlantic County and Philadelphia . First date : Tietz allegedly took the woman to Racks Restaurant and Sports Bar in Atco , New Jersey , before taking the vehicle from her house .
Gerald Tietz allegedly enticed woman to meet using fake name on dating site . Met her at restaurant in Atco , New Jersey , then came back to her house . According to police , he then stole her car keys and jewelry from inside . Thought to have escaped in red Toyota , with plates reading JSRYGRL . Tietz was arrested Saturday night after police shared dating profile photos .