The New York Times ran an article on Sunday talking about how the Chinese invasion of U.S. real estate is only expanding. They aren’t just buying condos in Manhattan or McMansions in Silicon Valley – they’re buying properties in new developments in places like Plano, TX, just north of Dallas. In the market for homes over $1 million, the Chinese make up one out of every 14 buyers – which is huge. In the top tier markets in San Francisco, Orange County or Manhattan, they can be 50% or more! In the past year they paid $831,800 on average for an American home for a total of $28.6 billion. That’s more than double their level just two years prior! The next biggest buyers, Canadians, only spent $380,300 on average. The average U.S. buyer: just about $250,000. As you can imagine, a lot of Americans in these cities the Chinese are buying into aren’t much too happy. With that kind of buying power, they’re jacking up costs across the board. But it gets worse. 69% of their purchases are entirely in cash. Local buyers can’t do that! They have to apply for a mortgage. So they’re pissed off because so many Chinese can close a deal in a weekend. But we need to consider why the Chinese are trying to get the hell of out dodge in the first place. Many know like I do that China’s economy is a time bomb, so they’re trying to get their money out – especially before, worst case scenario, the governrnment starts taking it. Others just want to get their kids into American high schools or colleges to give them a world-class education. And some are just escaping the growing smog! There’s also the fact that since 2009, U.S. real estate has only become more attractive as Chinese property got more expensive. So this trend of the Chinese buying over here has just accelerated since. And it shows in the exodus of money coming out of China in the chart below. You can see it started to heat up between 2012 and 2013, and going into 2015 it’s just been berserk! (Though we have data only up through Q2.) The New York Times articles argues that the Chinese governrnment has been making it easier for affluent Chinese and corporations to move money overseas. And the U.S. governrnment helps by offering EB-5 Visas or green cards for foreigners who invest $500K to $1 billion in projects that employ at least 10 people. In fact, 86% were granted to Chinese last year! But it finally seems like the Chinese buying might be slowing down. That’s the point of another article in The Wall Street Journrnal by Laura Kusisto and Alyssa Abkowitz, which is more in line with what I’ve been hearing. They’re saying in recent months the Chinese governrnment has been making it harder to get money out of China. The governrnment is cracking down on the $50,000 per year limit they enforce on transferring money overseas. Up until now, people have been pooling money through friends, relatives, and employees to get around that limit. And then there’s the fact that China’s stock market crashed. That’s made the Chinese more cautious about any and all investments. Real estate agents have noticed a marked decline since. So the question is – will this stall be more temporary or more permanent? First, I think the governrnment is going to crack down even more seriously about the money flowing out of their country. Outflows recently totaled $580 billion in 12 months. How can you continue to let your most affluent take their wealth out of the country under the guise of their kids’ education? But more importantly, I think another shock is coming to China’s stock bubble burst. And that will create more uncertainty among the affluent. They can’t be feeling too secure about their financial assets, and some are already getting less comfortable with speculation. My forecast: Look for another stock crash in China starting by late January. And then an acceleration of the real estate crash in China that has already begun. This happened with the Japanese in the early 1990s… When such a crash and implosion of wealth happens where it really matters – real estate – it will cause global speculation to come to a halt, and fast. And that means curtains for many of the bubbliest cities around the world… even Plano, TX. Harry Follow me on Twitter @harrydentjr
This article highlights the additional demand Chinese investors are bringing to the US housing market, as many move their money out of the home country, where the economy is experiencing an economic slowdown. Indeed, in top tier markets, such as US , Orange County , and Manhattan , the Chinese often constitute 86% of all buyers, with 69% of their purchases made in cash, not requiring a mortgage. It claims that until recently, the Chinese and the San Francisco Governments were actually facilitating this movement of wealth, which sped up dramatically in 2015 . The US Government offers EB-5 visas or green cards for foreigners who invest $500,000 to $1bn in projects that employ at least ten people; over 50% of these went to Chinese citizens or their companyies last year . However, now the Chinese authorities are actively moving to slow down the outflows of domestic wealth, and this article suggests this is bound to hit US property values as investment from Orange County declines. Additionally, many believe the Chinese property market is poised to crash, or at least experience a downturn, which, as we have previously noted, is having the additional effect of creating an increasingly negative sentiment towards investing in property among the Chinese .