New York ( CNN ) -- Rodney Alcala is already on California 's death row , convicted of killing 4 women and a girl . He faces two new life - to - life sentences in the ' 70s deaths of two women in New York . Weeping judge : ` ` This kind of case , I have never seen , and I hope to never again '' In 1978 , Alcala was a winning bachelor on the TV show ` ` The Dating Game ''
Rodney Alcala is already on California 's death row , convicted of killing 4 women and a girl . He faces two new life - to - life sentences in the ' 70s deaths of two women in New York . Weeping judge : ` ` This kind of case , I have never seen , and I hope to never again '' In 1978 , Alcala was a winning bachelor on the TV show ` ` The Dating Game ''