We pit ` ` MLB 11 The Show '' against ` ` MLB2K11 '' in a 12 - inning contest . But overall , smoother animation and player renderings make `` MLB 11 Both games do a great job rendering realistic major league players and teams . Each game allows you to select a fictional player and advance them from there to the Hall of Fame . It was close , but one of the games emerged as our favorite .
We pit ` ` MLB 11 The Show '' against ` ` MLB2K11 '' in a 12 - inning contest . Both games do a great job rendering realistic major league players and teams . Each game allows you to select a fictional player and advance them from there to the Hall of Fame . It was close , but one of the games emerged as our favorite .