( CNN ) -- Did Andi Dorfman choose wisely with her final rose ? At the very least she chose geographically , as the Atlanta-based former assistant district attorney selected former baseball player Josh Murray , who also lives in her city . No long-distance romance for this pair , but plenty of speculation about whether their engagement will actually result in a marriage . Left holding his heart in his hand was Chicago-based businessman Nick Viall , who was dumped in a very nontraditional `` Bachelorette '' way . Instead of waiting for the final rose ceremony , Dorfman went to his room and broke the news to him . `` Honestly , the last date , I wanted to just have fun and relax , and hard as I tried I could n't do that with you . ... With you I overanalyze everything , '' Dorfman told him . `` A life with you would be overanalyzing every single moment . '' That left Murray to receive the final rose after a few minutes of `` suspense . '' But the real drama came during the live `` After the Rose '' show , in which Viall questioned Dorfman 's decision in light of some of the moments fans did n't see on camera . `` If you were n't in love with me , '' he said , `` I 'm just not sure why you made love to me . '' Thus went another `` Bachelor/Bachelorette '' unspoken `` tradition '' in that much can be hinted at -- but contestants are never , ever to spill the sexual beans . Viall kept it classy on social media , tweeting about Dorfman and Murray , `` Congratulations to @ AndiDorfman and @ jmurbulldog on their engagement . Wishing you both incredible happiness . # TheBachelorette # Bachelorette . '' Despite the sighs heard round the world by Viall fans , there is speculation that the next `` Bachelor '' will be fan favorite Iowa farmer Chris Soules , who won many in the audience over with his sweetness and good looks . What do you think ? Are Dorfman and Murray meant to be ? Will they go the distance ?
She had to choose between Nick Murray and Nick Murray . She broke one 's arm before the actual ceremony . There is speculation about the next ` ` Bachelor ''