NEW : Police have recovered the vehicle the suspect was believed to be driving . The suspect was arrested in Niagara Falls , New York . Neighbors of Harvey 's family described their Niagara Falls neighborhood as a quiet one , where families remain for a number of years , WIVB said . The body of 23-year - old Valerie Smith was found Saturday . Her father , a police chief , issued a tearful plea bargain .
NEW : Police have recovered the vehicle the suspect was believed to be driving . The suspect was arrested in Niagara Falls , New York . The body of 23-year - old Valerie Smith was found Saturday . Her father , a police chief , issued a tearful plea bargain .