Michael Vaughan , who is favourite to become England ’ s cricket supremo , was quick to condemn the openers after West Indies got them both out early on . With Jonathan Trott out without scoring in the first over and captain Alastair Cook failing again Vaughan said : ‘ Their footwork and their mindset has been about looking to survive rather than getting on top. ’ Geoff Boycott was also critical of the pair , saying : ‘ Opening batsmen are supposed to face the new ball when it ’ s doing a little bit . If you can ’ t play that , you ’ re in the wrong job. ’ Michael Vaughan criticised the footwork and mindset of England 's top order for just looking to survive . Jonathan Trott was out for a duck on his return to the Test match side in Antigua . Alastair Cook was clean bowled by Kemar Roach for 11 as England struggled on the first morning . Former fast bowler Bob Willis said : ‘ England ’ s top three looked constipated and need a good dose of syrup of figs. ’ West Indies ’ early success after putting England into bat appeared at that stage to make a mockery of the comment by Colin Graves , the new England and Wales Cricket Board chairman , who labelled the opposition ‘ mediocre ’ .
England 's top order collapsed on the first morning in Antigua . Jonathan Trott , Alastair Cook and Gary Ballance all out cheaply . Michael Vaughan critical of footwork and mindset of the trio . Vaughan is favourite to take up role of England cricket director .