Nicole McDonough , of sunny Olive , New Jersey , was indicted on three counts of official misconduct in March . The 32-year - old married mother of mathematics and English teacher at West # ##dale High School was arrested December 2009 . Allegedly had improper relations with two 18-year - old male students and a ' physical sexual relationship ' with a third . she pleaded not guilty at her first court appearance in 2009 . She is now applying for Pre - Trail probation program in hopes of having her criminal record expunged .
Nicole McDonough , of Mount Olive , New Jersey , was indicted on three counts of official misconduct in March . The 32-year-old married mother of two and English teacher at West Morris Mendham High School was arrested December 30 . Allegedly had improper relations with two 18-year-old male students and a 'physical sexual relationship ' with a third . McDonough pleaded not guilty at her first court appearance in January . She is now applying for Pre-Trail Intervention program in hopes of having her criminal record expunged .