hiː wʌz fˈaɪnəli dᵻfˈiːɾᵻd fɔːɹ ɹiːᵻlˈɛkʃən ɪn wˈʌn θˈaʊzənd ˈeɪthˈʌndɹɪd sˈɛvənti fˈoːɹ, ɡˈɑːɹnɚɹɪŋ dʒˈʌst fˈoːɹɾi fˈoːɹ pɚsˈɛnt ʌvðə vˈoʊt ɐɡˈɛnst ðə dˌɛməkɹˈæɾɪk kˈændᵻdˌeɪt, wˈɪljəm mək fˈɑːɹlənd.
He was finally defeated for reelection in 1874, garnering just 44% of the vote against the Democratic candidate, William McFarland.