ðə sˈɪɾi ɐpˈiːld dʒˈʌdʒ wˈɔːɹənz ɹˈuːlɪŋ, bˌʌt lˈɔst baɪ ɐ juːnˈænɪməs dᵻsˈɪʒən fɹʌmðə θɹˈiː dʒˈʌdʒ pˈænəl ɪnðə kˈoːɹt ʌv ɐpˈiːlz ˈɪʃuːd ˌɔn dʒˈænjuːˌɛɹi nˈaɪn, tˈuː θˈaʊzənd ˈeɪt.
The City appealed Judge Warren's ruling, but lost by a unanimous decision from the three judge panel in the Court of Appeals issued on January 9, 2008.