fɪlɐdˈɛlfiə pəlˈiːs dɪtˈɛktɪv fɹˈæŋk dʒˈeɪɚɹ ɚɹˈɪdʒɪnəli θˈɔːt dʒˈɪmi kəmˈɪɾᵻd ðə mˈɜːdɚ bˌʌt ˈæftɚ dʒˈɪmiz stˈoːɹi tʃˈɛkt ˈaʊt ænd ˈɔːl ˈɛvɪdəns pˈɔɪntᵻd tə hɪz stˈɛpsʌn, hˌuː ᵻvˈɛntʃuːəli kənfˈɛst tə hɜː mˈɜːdɚ, kjˈuːɾeɪˌɑːɹ wʌz ɚɹˈɛstᵻd ænd kənvˈɪktᵻd ʌv fˈɜːst dᵻɡɹˈiː mˈɜːdɚ.
Philadelphia Police Detective Frank Geyer originally thought Jimmy committed the murder but after Jimmy's story checked out and all evidence pointed to his stepson, who eventually confessed to her murder, Cutaiar was arrested and convicted of first degree murder.