vˈiː dʒˈeɪ ɚɹˈɪdʒɪnəli ɹᵻlˈiːst ɪɾ æz ðə bˈiːsˈaɪd ʌv "pˈiːnʌts" ɪn dᵻsˈɛmbɚ, bˌʌt wɛn dˈɪsk dʒˈɑːkiz stˈɑːɹɾᵻd tuː "tˈɜːn ðə sˈɪŋɡəl ˈoʊvɚ" tə plˈeɪ "stˈeɪ" ɔnðɪ ˈɛɹ, ðə ɹˈɛkɚd kˈʌmpəni sˈuːpɚsˌiːdᵻd ðə sˈɪŋɡəl wɪð ɐ nˈuː wˈʌn wɪð "stˈeɪ" æz ðɪ ˈeɪsˈaɪd ænd "ɡʊdnˈaɪt maɪ lˈʌv" æz ðə nˈuː bˈiːsˈaɪd.ɹˈɛf tˈɑːm nˈiːli, ɡˈoʊldmaɪn pɹˈaɪs ɡˈaɪd tə fˈoːɹɾi fˈaɪv ˌɑːɹpˌiːˈɛm ɹˈɛkɚdz, fˈɪfθ ᵻdˈɪʃən kˌeɪpˈiː bˈʊks, tˈuː θˈaʊzənd fˈaɪv
Vee Jay originally released it as the B-side of "Peanuts" in December, but when disc jockeys started to "turn the single over" to play "Stay" on the air, the record company superseded the single with a new one with "Stay" as the A-side and "Goodnight My Love" as the new B-side.<ref>Tom Neely, Goldmine Price Guide to 45 RPM Records, 5th edition (KP Books, 2005)