hˈʌtʃɪnsən wʌz ɹˌiːɚɹˈɛstᵻd ɪn wˈʌn θˈaʊzənd sˈɪkshˈʌndɹɪd sˈɪksti θɹˈiː ænd tʃˈɑːɹdʒd wɪð ɪnvˈɑːlvmənt ɪn ˈeɪ "pˈeɪpɪst plˈɑːt"; sˈɪns hiː wʌz wˈɛl nˈoʊn təbi ɐ dɪvˈaʊt pjˈʊɹɹɪtən, ðɪs wʌz ɹˈɛkəɡnˌaɪzd æz hˈaɪli ʌnlˈaɪkli bˌʌt ˈæpsli wʌz ʌnˈeɪbəl tə hæv hˌɪm fɹˈiːd ænd hiː dˈaɪd ɪn pɹˈɪzən ɪn sɛptˈɛmbɚ wˈʌn θˈaʊzənd sˈɪkshˈʌndɹɪd sˈɪksti fˈoːɹ.
Hutchinson was re-arrested in 1663 and charged with involvement in a "Papist plot"; since he was well known to be a devout Puritan, this was recognised as highly unlikely but Apsley was unable to have him freed and he died in prison in September 1664.