ɪn tˈuː θˈaʊzənd fˈoːɹ, ˈʌtli wʌz ᵻlˈɛktᵻd ˌɪntʊ ðə dˌʌbəljˌuːˌɛsjˈuː æθlˈɛɾɪk hˈɔːl ʌv fˈeɪm, ænd wʌz ᵻlˈɛktᵻd tə ðə kˈɑːlɪdʒ fˈʊtbɔːl hˈɔːl ʌv fˈeɪm ɪn tˈuː θˈaʊzənd sˈɪkstiːn.
In 2004, Utley was elected into the WSU Athletic Hall of Fame, and was elected to the College Football Hall of Fame in 2016.