Jamie, you have an absolutely awesome vanity chair. It is a beauty. I hate that there are issues with the upholstery because I love the print but then it probably isn’t “you” and so it may be a good thing.
Back in the Dark Ages when I was a teenager there were a lot of vanities like the kind you have described that were sent to the Salvation Army. My best friend and I each got one. We totally loved them. I hope that you find one for yourself and wish that you would be able to get it for the prices that we paid for ours. That probably won’t happen but I can hope it on your behalf. You might also try estate sales to look for one. That may be your best bet to get one at a decent price.
My family has been in the flea market business for more that 20 years so we have been to many such sales. Of course, we are in Arkansas so things may be different up there.
Again, your chair is a beauty and I wish you luck in finding your vanity.