Debuting as part of The New 52, Barton Mathis, the third character to use the "Dollmaker" alias, went on several "hunting trips" with his father Wesley as a child.
Upon tracking Ray Quimby, a serial killer associated with Wesley Mathis, to a location while believing Quimby kidnapped Commissioner James Gordon, Batman is ambushed by the members of the Dollmaker's "family" (members including Matilda Mathis, Bentley, Jack-in-the-Box, Sampson, Olivia Carr, and Orifice).