He had spells in Honduras with Victoria, in El Salvador with Luis Ángel Firpo,[REF] in Mexico with UA Tamaulipas[REF] but spent the majority of his career abroad in Guatemala, playing for Comunicaciones,[REF] Antigua,[REF] Suchitepéquez and Petapa [REF].
In March 2001, Guthrie returned to Herediano[REF] and later played for Pérez Zeledón before moving back to Guatemala.