Difficulties between the progressive and the conservative preachers, including Jacob Wisler (1808-1889), Daniel Brenneman, John Funk, as well as Joseph Rohrer and Joseph Holdeman, resulted in the expulsion of the conservative preachers, first Rohrer and Holdeman, and then Wisler in 1872.
After this division, the Wisler and Funk branches shared the Yellow Creek building, holding services there on alternating Sundays until 1912 [REF].