Johnson's loyalty to Everton was rewarded with another two Cup finals in 2010: a 3-1 defeat by Leeds Carnegie in the Premier League Cup, in which Fara Williams scored Everton's consolation,[REF] followed by a memorable extra-time win over Arsenal in the FA Women's Cup [REF].
When the 2014 season culminated in Everton's relegation, Johnson postponed her plans to retire and decided to play on for another season in FA WSL 2. In October 2015, she confirmed that Everton's match against Oxford United would be her last.