Reynolds was a four-year letterman, two years at Lake Havasu High School and two years at Bishop Gorman in Las Vegas.
As a senior, he was a USA Today first team All-American,[REF] a Parade All-American (a publication that also recognized him as the top linebacker in the country),[REF] a U.S. Army All-American,[REF] and Nevada's Gatorade player of the year [REF].