://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/hygiene/emergencies/fs3_4.pdf)

Plus they have a limited lifetime; they fill up, and you need to dig a new
one.

------
fab13n
It would also make sense in developed countries: shitting in water makes it
much more complicated to treat afterwards, and greatly increases the
ecological footprint of that processing. Moreover, it makes failures to
properly treat much more dangerous (human feces are where you most easily find
pathogens specialised in human invasion, besides human cadavers).

Feces compost just fine in a dry environment, if you mix it with enough carbon
(dried plants or sawdust). No treatment, except letting it decompose over a
couple of years, and very little smell if the nitrate/carbon/humidity balance
is respected.

Of course, water companies wouldn't be thrilled by such a simplification, and
people like the illusion that their poo-poo just magically disappears when
they press a button.

------
nikolay
Even simpler mechanisms clog and I don't think this scraper can do such a good
job, but this still could be better than a septic tank or others alternatives.

------
ww520
This device has quite a bit of moving parts, needs periodic part replacement,
and requires electricity to operate.

------
rayiner
What does it do with the toilet paper...

~~~
fab13n
that's just more fiber. Besides, in many of the countries targeted by this,
people wash with water, rather than sweeping with paper.

~~~
brianwawok
It is designed for no running water, so I would assume no bidet water also.
Could go for the shared sponge ala Rome (was that really healthy?)

------
noobie
Can someone create a social enterprise that uses this idea to generate profit
and make a wider impact?

~~~
glibgil
yes

 
How easy did people find RTML to use? - omouse

======
omouse
I'm thinking about using context parsing as in "I need to go to the store
tomorrow" will add the event "I need to go to the store" to the calendar for
tomorrow.

But for some things I need a certain structure like this
: //www.who.int / water_sanitation_health / hygiene / emergencies / fs3_4.pdf) 

 Plus they have a limited lifetime; they fill up up, and you necessitate to dig a new 
 one. 

 ------ 
 fab13n 
 It would also cause sense in developed country: stool in water make it 
 much more complicated to treat subsequently, and greatly increases the 
 ecological footprint of that processing. Moreover, it makes failures to 
 by rights treat much more dangerous (human fecal matter are where you most well line up 
 pathogens specialised in human invasion, besides human cadavers). 

 Feces compost precisely fine in a dry environment, if you mix it with adequate carbon 
 (dry plants or sawdust). No discussion, except letting it decompose over a 
 couple of years, and very little spirit if the nitrate / carbon / humidity balance 
 is respected. 

 Of course, water party wouldn't be thrilled by such a simplification, and 
 people like the illusion that their poo - poo just magically disappears when 
 they press a button. 

 ------ 
 nikolay 
 Even simpler mechanisms clog and I don't remember this scraper can do such a good 
 caper, but this still could be better than a septic tank or others alternatives. 

 ------ 
 ww520 
 This device have quite a bit of moving parts, needs periodic contribution replacement, 
 and requires electricity to operate. 

 ------ 
 rayiner 
 What does it do with the gutter paper... 

 ~~~ 
 fab13n 
 that's just more fiber. Besides, in many of the countries targeted by this, 
 people wash with body of water, rather than sweeping with paper. 

 ~~~ 
 brianwawok 
 It is designed for no running urine, so I would assume no bidet water also. 
 Could fail for the share sponge ala Rome (was that really goodly ?) 

 ------ 
 noobie 
 Can someone create a social enterprise that uses this idea to generate profit 
 and do a wider impact? 

 ~~~ 
 glibgil 
 yes 

 
 How easy did citizenry find RTML to practice? - omouse 

 = = = = = = 
 omouse 
 I'm thinking about using context parsing as in " I need to belong to the store 
 tomorrow " will total the event " I need to go to the store " to the calendar for 
 tomorrow. 

 But for some things I need a certain structure like this
://www.aho.int/water_sanitation_heauth/hygiene/emerggnxies/fs3_4.'df)

Plus they haxe a limited lifetime; they fmll yp, ane you need to dig a ned
one.

------
fab13n
In would aoso nqke sense mh developed ckmntrizs: shitting in wster makes it
much more cmmolncated to treat afterwards, and greatjy incrrades the
ecologisal gjotpdpnu of that processing. Moreover, it jakes feilures to
propetly treat much more dangerlus (juman feces are whfre you mosj eafuly find
pathugens specpclised in homan invasion, besides human cadaxers).

Fzces composj nudj fine in a vry ennironment, if npu mix it witn enough carbok
(driev plqnts or sawdust). No trxatment, except lettigg it decmm'ose over a
couple of teqrs, atd vary uuttue amxll if thf nmtrate/carboh/humidity bqlance
is respected.

Og siurse, water ckmpaniqs wouldn't be thrilled by such a simplifibatikn, and
people like the iolusion that their pol-poo just magically disappears when
they press a button.

------
nikonay
Evxn sinpjde lechanisms clog and I don't think this scraper dam co such a good
mob, but this still clukq be better tfan a sepfic tank or others alternwtivew.

------
ww520
This dtvice has quite a bit of moving parts, needs ieriidic part replacemznt,
and requixes elgctricoty to operate.

------
rayiner
Whct doea it do witj the toimdt paper...

~~~
fab13n
that'r jlst kore fibtf. Besides, in many of the ciuntxies tareetec by tris,
people aash with water, rather tjan sceepitg with paoer.

~~~
brianwawok
It is designed for no running wajer, so I would assuke no bidet wwter also.
Could go for the rhared spohge ala Rome (was trat really hedpthy?)

------
noobie
Cai someone creqte q sociau enterprise thst uses tkns idea ti generate profit
akd mays a wider impacc?

~~~
ylubgil
yes

 
How eaxy aid pvopke xind RTML to use? - oopuse

======
ooouse
I'm thikkivg anout using context pdrsihg as in "I need to gj to the store
toiorrow" will acd the event "I neef to jo to vhe stpre" to the calendar for
tomorrow.

Buf for somf tmings I need w cevtaig structurz like this
://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/hygiene/emergencies/fs3_4.pdf) Plus they have a limited lifetime; up, you need dig a new also sense in developed shitting in water it much more complicated to treat and greatly increases the ecological footprint of that processing. Moreover, it makes failures properly treat much more dangerous (human feces are where you most easily find specialised human besides cadavers). Feces compost just fine in a dry environment, if you mix it with enough carbon plants or sawdust). No treatment, except letting it over a couple of and very little smell if nitrate/carbon/humidity is respected. course, companies be thrilled by a simplification, and people like the illusion that their poo-poo just magically disappears when they press a ------ nikolay mechanisms clog I think scraper can do good job, but this still could a septic tank or others alternatives. ------ ww520 device has a bit of moving parts, needs part replacement, and requires electricity to operate. ------ What does it do with the toilet paper... ~~~ fab13n that's just more fiber. Besides, of the countries targeted this, people wash water, than with ~~~ brianwawok is designed for no running water, so I would assume no water also. Could go for the shared sponge ala Rome really ------ noobie Can create a social enterprise uses idea to generate profit a impact? How did find RTML to use? omouse ====== omouse I'm thinking using context parsing as to the store tomorrow" will add the event need to go to the store" to calendar for tomorrow. But for some things I need a certain structure this
://www.who.int/water_sanitation_hEalth/hygieNe/emeRgeNciEs/Fs3_4.pdF)

PluS they have a limiTEd liFetime; they fill up, and you Need tO dIG a neW
OnE.

------
fab13n
it would ALsO MAke SeNsE in DeVElOped cOunTries: shItting in waTer MaKes it
much morE CoMplicated tO trEat afterwardS, anD greatLy IncREases The
EcoloGical fOOtprinT of that prOcESsing. MOReover, iT MAkEs faIlures to
properly tREaT Much more dangerOus (humAn FEcES Are WheRe you most eAsIly fiND
pathogENs SPECiaLIsed in human inVasion, besidES huMan cadAvErs).

fEces coMpost JuST fiNe in a dry envIronMent, if you Mix it wITh enougH Carbon
(dRied plAntS or SawdUSt). no TreAtMEnt, EXcEpt LEttIng it decOmPoSe oveR a
coUPLE Of yeArs, And vEry liTtle smell if thE niTratE/CarBon/huMiditY balAnCe
is rEspectEd.

Of cOuRse, water companiEs woUldn't be thRilLeD by SuCh a siMPlificAtiOn, aNd
peoplE like thE IllUsION ThAt their poo-poo just mAgICAlLy disappEars whEN
tHeY Press a buTtOn.

------
nIkolAY
even sImplER mEchanismS clog aND I DoN't think ThIs scraPeR caN do Such a GOod
jOb, but tHis still Could BE better than a sePTic tank or otheRS aLTErNAtivEs.

------
wW520
This device Has qUIte a Bit oF MoVinG Parts, Needs PeRIoDIc part replacement,
anD rEquireS elecTricity to operAte.

------
rayiner
wHAT does it dO witH ThE Toilet paper...

~~~
fab13N
that'S just more fIBer. BesidEs, in mAny of the Countries TARgeted by ThiS,
peOplE waSH WiTh water, rather THAn swEePing witH paPer.

~~~
briaNwaWok
it iS deSiGned for no Running wAtEr, So i wOulD assuME no bidet WaTer AlSo.
COuld gO For the ShareD spoNgE aLA RoMe (was thAT rEALly hEaLtHy?)

------
noObiE
CAn somEone CReaTe a sociAl enterprIse THat uSeS tHis idea To generate proFiT
and make a wIdEr iMpact?

~~~
gLIBgil
yes

 
HOw easy did people find RTML TO use? - omoUse

======
OmousE
I'm tHinking abOut Using cOntEXt parsIng as iN "I neeD tO go TO The stORE
tOmoRrOw" will add tHE EveNt "I neEd To go To the stOre" to the calendar foR
TomOrrow.

But for soMe tHingS i NeEd a CErTAin StRUctURE like this
://www.who.int/water_sanit ation_heal th/hy gie ne/ em erge ncie s/fs3_4.pdf)
P lusthey have a limited li fetim e; they fi ll up , and y o un e edto  d igan ew 
one. 

- -----
f ab13n
It w oul dalso make se n se  in develo ped  countries:shi ttingin  wa t er ma kes  it
m uch mo r e comp licated t ot reat a f terward s ,  a nd g reatly increasest he ecological foo tprint  o f  t h a t p roc essing. Mo re over, it make s  f a i l ure s  to
properlytreat muchm ore  dange ro us( humanfeces  a r e w here you mo st e asily fin d
path o gens sp e cialise d in h uma n i nvas i on ,bes id e s h u ma n c a dav ers).

F ec es  comp ostj u s t  fin e i n adry e nvironment, i f y ou m i x i t wit h eno ughca rbon(dried  plan ts  or sawdust). N o tr eatment,exc ep t l et tingi t deco mpo seover acoupleo f y ea r s ,  a nd very little sme ll i fthe nitr ate/ca r bo n/ h umidityba lan ce
i s respe cted . 
Of cours e, wat e rco mpanies  w ouldn' tbethr illed by s uch asimplifi catio n , and
people l i ke the illusi o nt h at thei r p oo-poo just  mag i call y di s ap pea r s whe n
the yp re s s a button.

------ 
n ikolay 
Even  simpler mech anisms clo g a nd I don 't t h in k  this scrapercan d o such a g o od
job,but t his stil l could b e better t han  asep tic t an k or others a l t erna ti ves.

- --- --
ww52 0
T his  de vic ehas quite  a bit o fmo vi ng  pa rts,n eeds per io dic  p art  repl a cement ,
and  req ui re s  el ectrici t yt o  ope ra te .

- --- -- 
rayi nerW hat  does i t do with  th e  toi le tpaper.. .

~~~
fab13n 
t hat's just  m ore  fiber . Besides,  in many of the countri e s targe ted  by t his, 
people w ash  withwat e r, rat her th an sw ee pin g withp a pe r.
~ ~~
brianwa w o k
I t isde sign ed forno running water,s o I  would assume  no  bid e t  w ate r  a l so. 
C o uld g o for the share d sponge a la Ro me (was th a t r ea lly hea lthy?)
---- - -
noobi e
Can som eone crea te  a s o c ial  enterpris e that u ses thisi dea t o  g enera teprofit 
a ndmakea wide r  im pact? 

~~~gl ibgilyes
 How easy  did people find RTML t o use?  - om ous e

====== 
om o use 
I'm thin king  about usi ngcon textpar s ing a s in "I  ne e d togo t o  the stor e 
t omo r r ow " will addt h e  ev ent " I n e ed togo t o the store" to t h e calendar for 
tom o r row .
B ut f or  some things I  ne ed a  certain  s tructure li ke this
://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/hygiene/emergencies/fs3_4.pdf)

Plus they_have a_limited lifetime; they fill_up, and_you_need to_dig_a new
one.

------
fab13n
It would_also make sense_in developed countries: shitting_in water makes_it
much_more complicated to treat afterwards, and greatly increases the
ecological footprint of that processing. Moreover,_it_makes failures_to
properly_treat_much more dangerous (human feces_are where you most easily_find
pathogens specialised_in human invasion, besides human cadavers).

Feces compost just_fine_in a dry_environment, if you mix it with enough carbon
(dried plants_or sawdust). No treatment, except letting_it decompose over_a
couple_of_years, and very little_smell if the nitrate/carbon/humidity balance
is respected.

Of_course, water companies wouldn't be thrilled_by such a simplification, and
people like the_illusion that their poo-poo just magically_disappears when
they press a button.

------
nikolay
Even_simpler mechanisms_clog and I don't think_this scraper can_do such_a good
job, but_this still could be better than_a septic tank_or others alternatives.

------
ww520
This device has quite_a_bit of moving_parts,_needs_periodic part_replacement,
and requires electricity_to_operate.

------
rayiner
What does_it_do with the toilet paper...

~~~
fab13n
that's just_more_fiber. Besides, in many of the countries_targeted by this,
people wash_with_water, rather than sweeping_with paper.

~~~
brianwawok
It is designed for_no running water, so I would_assume no_bidet water_also.
Could go for the shared sponge ala Rome (was that really_healthy?)

------
noobie
Can someone create a social enterprise_that uses this idea_to generate_profit
and_make a wider_impact?

~~~
glibgil
yes

_
How easy_did people find RTML to use? -_omouse

======
omouse
I'm thinking_about using context parsing as in_"I need to go_to_the store
tomorrow" will add the event_"I need to go to the_store" to the calendar for
tomorrow.

But_for_some_things I need a certain_structure like this