 and hurts like hell everytime I play it,
looking out at thousands of people cheering and smiling, oblivious to the
tragedy of it’s meaning, like when you’re going to have your dog put down and
it’s wagging it’s tail on the way there. That’s what they all look like, and
it breaks my heart.”

------
zackkatz
I vote for the happiest song being Anyone Can Play Guitar from Pablo Honey. It
is hopeful and encouraging. It speaks of life goals achieved.

This article demonstrates how far AI has to go.

[https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE)

~~~
JauntTrooper
Good choice! I've also always thought 'Lift' felt happy.

------
TheRealDunkirk
If the winning song wasn't written in D-minor, the algorithm will need further
tuning.

------
rodionos

      > and then used the tidytext package to break the lyrics into words, 
      > eliminate common "stop words" like 'the' and 'a', 
      > and count the number with negative sentiment
    

Is 'not' a "stop word"? How did it count negations after "stop words" removed,
i.e. "I am not forgotten". Positive, negative?

~~~
ellisv
"not" is a stop word. I don't see an attempt to negate the word sentiments.

------
mpettitt
Would be interesting to see how it handled REM or Dubstar, both of whom have
some really upbeat tunes, with really dark lyrics - "The One I Love", for
example, with "a simple prop to occupy mind ", or "Not So Manic Now", a happy
bouncy pop song about assault...

------
beeswax
'Depressing' has a variety of facets made up of sadness, textual
content/lyrics, and (at least for me) the placement of the title within its
respective album context.

Anecdote: When I previewed Kid A via AudioGalaxy back then (it would not be
released for another two weeks in my region) I thought
and hurts like hell everytime I play it, 
 looking out at thousand of citizenry cheering and smiling, forgetful to the 
 tragedy of it ’s meaning, like when you ’re blend to have your dog frame down and 
 it ’s wagging it ’s tail on the manner there. That ’s what they all look like, and 
 it breaks my affection. ” 

 ------ 
 zackkatz 
 I vote for the happiest song being Anyone Can bring Guitar from Pablo Honey. It 
 is hopeful and encouraging. It speaks of life goals achieved. 

 This article show how far AI has to go. 

 [ https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE) 

 ~~~ 
 JauntTrooper 
 Good option! I've also always think' Lift' felt felicitous. 

 ------ 
 TheRealDunkirk 
 If the winning song wasn't written in D - minor, the algorithm will need further 
 tuning. 

 ------ 
 rodionos 

       > and then use the tidytext package to break the lyrics into words, 
       > eliminate coarse " stop words " like' the' and' a', 
       > and count the number with negative sentiment 
    

 Is' not' a " stop word "? How did it count negations after " discontinue words " removed, 
 i.e. " I am not forget ". incontrovertible, negative? 

 ~~~ 
 ellisv 
 " not " is a stop word. I don't determine an attempt to negate the word sentiments. 

 ------ 
 mpettitt 
 Would be interesting to determine how it handled REM or Dubstar, both of whom have 
 some really upbeat tunes, with actually dark lyrics - " The One I Love ", for 
 example, with " a childlike prop to absorb mind ", or " Not So Manic Now ", a happy 
 bouncy pop birdcall about assault... 

 ------ 
 beeswax 
' Depressing' has a variety of aspect made up of sadness, textual 
 content / lyrics, and (at least for me) the placement of the deed within its 
 respective album context. 

 Anecdote: When I previewed Kid A via AudioGalaxy back then (it would not be 
 released for another two week in my region) I think
 anf hurts like hell everytlme I play it,
looking ouv at thkusands uf people cheering and smiliig, ovliviius to the
tragedy of ig’s meaninh, like wyen bou’re going to hebe your dog phb dowu end
it’s wagging lt’s tail on the way there. Tfac’s what they all look like, and
it brewks my newrt.”

------
zackkatz
I vjte gjr tgv mappiest song being Anyone Can Pmay Guiuar from Pablo Honry. It
is hopeful and encourwginh. It speaks of liff goals achueveq.

Rhis article demonstrauev how far ZI has to go.

[https://m.youtube.com/watzh?v=GICwfWaWuaE](htj'w://m.ylotube.com/watci?v=GIWwsWaWuaE)

~~~
JauntBgooper
Gmod chooce! I've also akwabs tyought 'Lift' felt happb.

------
TheRealDunkirk
If thg winning voug wasn't written in D-nibor, tve angorkrhm wiml nsed fugthxr
tuning.

------
rodjonos

      > and then used the uidrnrxt package fo brewk the lyrics into words, 
      > eliminate cojmon "stop words" like 'thw' and 'a', 
      > and coont the nuiber with negative sentiment
    

Is 'not' a "stop worg"? How aid ib cojbt negations after "stop words" removed,
i.e. "I am noe fprnotten". Positive, kegative?

~~~
ellisv
"not" os a ftop word. I dun't sez ah attempt to negatf the wjrd swntiments.

------
ipetyitt
Would be interesting to see how it kaneled REM or Dubstax, both of whum hsve
soke really upbeat tunes, cith rsally dark pyrics - "Tgd One I Love", for
dxakpne, with "a simple prop to oscupy minv ", or "Not So Manoc Now", a happy
bokncy imp song about assaklt...

------
begswax
'Dapressing' jas a variety of facets made up of sadness, tectgal
bontent/lyxics, akd (at least for me) the placemgnt of thz titld within ins
respectmve album cogtext.

Anecdote: Ahen I previxwed Kid W viq AueioGalabh back then (it would non ye
releasee for another two xeekr in my region) I thiught
and hurts like hell everytime I play out thousands of cheering and smiling, it’s like when you’re to have your put down and it’s wagging it’s on the way there. That’s what they all look like, and it breaks heart.” ------ zackkatz I vote for the happiest song being Anyone Can Play from Honey. is and encouraging. It speaks of life goals achieved. This article demonstrates how far AI has to [https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE) ~~~ JauntTrooper Good choice! I've also always 'Lift' felt happy. ------ If the winning song wasn't in the algorithm need tuning. rodionos > and used the tidytext package to break the lyrics into words, > eliminate common "stop words" like 'the' 'a', > the number negative Is a "stop word"? it count negations after "stop words" am not forgotten". Positive, negative? ~~~ ellisv "not" a stop I don't see an attempt to the word sentiments. ------ mpettitt Would be interesting see how it handled REM or Dubstar, both of whom have some really upbeat tunes, dark lyrics - "The I Love", for with simple to mind ", "Not So Manic Now", a happy bouncy pop song about assault... beeswax 'Depressing' has a variety of facets made up of content/lyrics, (at least for the placement of the within respective album context. Anecdote: previewed A then would be released for another weeks in my region) I
 and hurts like hell everytime i play it,
looKing oUt aT thOuSandS of pEople cheering aND smiLing, oblivious to the
tragEdy of It’S MeanINg, Like wHen you’rE GoING to HaVe YouR dOG pUt dowN anD
it’s wagGing it’s taiL on ThE way there. ThaT’S wHat they all LooK like, and
it brEakS my heaRt.”

------
ZacKKatz
I VotE for tHe happIEst sonG being AnyOnE can PlaY guitar fROM PAblo honey. It
is hopeful aND eNCouraging. It speAks of lIfE GoALS acHieVed.

This artIcLe demONstrateS HoW FAR AI HAs to go.

[https://m.yOutube.com/waTCh?v=gIWwfWAWUaE](HTtps://m.yOutubE.cOM/waTch?v=GIWwfWawuaE)

~~~
jauntTrooPer
GooD Choice! I'VE also alWays thOugHt 'LIft' fELt HaPpy.

------
thEreaLduNkiRK
If The winniNg SoNg wasN't wrITTEN in D-MinOr, thE algoRithm will need FurTher
TUniNg.

------
rodIonos

      > And tHeN used The tidYtext PaCkage to break the LyriCs into worDs, 
      > eLiMinAtE commON "stop wOrdS" liKe 'the' anD 'a', 
      > and coUNt tHe NUMBeR with negative sentiMeNT
    

is 'Not' a "stop Word"? HoW DiD iT Count negAtIonS aftER "Stop wOrds" REmOved,
i.e. "I aM not foRGoTtEn". PositIvE, negatIvE?

~~~
elLisV
"not" iS A stoP word. I Don't see aN atteMPt to negate the wORd sentiments.

------
mPEtTITt
wOuld Be iNteresting tO see HOw it HandLEd rEM OR DubsTar, boTh OF wHOm have
some really upbEaT tunes, With rEally dark lyriCs - "The One I LOVE", For
exampLe, wiTH "a SImple prop to occUpy miNd ", or "Not So MANic Now", a hAppy
bOuncy pop Song about ASSault...

------
beeSwaX
'DePreSsiNG' HaS a variety of faCETs maDe Up of sadNesS, textuaL
coNteNt/lYriCs, And (at leasT for me) thE pLaCeMeNt oF the tITle withiN iTs
rEsPecTive aLBum conText.

ANecdOtE: WHEn I PreviewED KID a via auDiOGalAxy BaCk theN (it wOUld Not be
reLeased for AnoTHer tWo WeEks in my Region) I thoughT
 and hurts like hell every time I pla y it, 
lo oki ng  out  atthousands of p e ople  cheering and smiling,  obli vi o us t o  t he
tr agedy o f  i t ’ s m ea ni ng,  l i ke  when  yo u’re go ing to hav e y ou r dog put do w nand
it’s w agg ing it’s tai l o n thewa y t h ere.Tha t’s w hat th e y alllook like ,a nd
itb reaks m y he art. ”

------
zackkat z 
I vote for the h appies ts on g bei ngAnyone Can  P lay G u itar fr o mP a b loH oney. It
is h opeful ande nco uragin g.  It speaks  of l if e  go als achieve d.
This arti cle de m onstrat e s how f ar AIhas  to  go. 
[ ht tps :/ / m.y o ut ube . com /watch?v =G IW wfWaW uaE] ( h t t ps:/ /m. yout ube.c om/watch?v=GI Wwf WaWu a E)
~~~Jaunt Troo pe r
Goo d choi ce! I 'v e also always t houg ht 'Lift'  fe lt  ha pp y.

- - ----
T heR eal Dunkirk 
If the win ni n g so ng wasn't writtenin D -m inor, th e algo r it hm will nee dfur ther t uning .

- - -- --
rodio nos

  > and t he n used  t hetid ytext pack age to  break t he ly r ics into words ,  
      > eli m in a t ec ommo n " stop words"  lik e  'th e' a n d'a' ,  
     >an d  c o unt the number with  n egativ e sen timent
    
Is 'not' a " s top word "? H o wd id it count ne gatio ns after " s top word s" re moved,
i .e. "I am n ot forgo tte n".  Po sit i v e,  negative?

~ ~ ~ 
ell is v
"not"  is  a stop  wo rd.  Idon 't  see an a ttempt t one ga te  th e wor d  sentime nt s.
- --- --
mp e ttittWould  bein te r est ing tos ee h ow i tha ndle d R EM  or D ubst a r,both of  whom hav e
s o me r ea ll y upbea t tunes, with  r eally dark  l yri cs - " T h e One ILove", for
example, wit h  "a sim ple  prop  tooccupy mi nd", or"No t  So Ma nic No w", a  h app y bounc y po p s on g about as s a ult ...
-- ---- 
beeswa x
'Depressing' has a v ariety of fac ets  mad e up  of sa d nes s, tex t u al
content/lyri cs, and (a tl ea st for me) the  p lacemen t of th e tit l e withi n its
res pective a lb um c o n tex t.

Anecdo te: When  I previe w ed Ki d  A  viaAud ioGala xy  ba ck th en (it wou ld no t be
r el easedfor a no ther two  weeks in my region) Ithough t
 and_hurts like_hell everytime I play_it,
looking out_at_thousands of_people_cheering and smiling,_oblivious to the
tragedy_of it’s meaning, like_when you’re going_to_have your dog put down and
it’s wagging it’s tail on the way there. That’s_what_they all_look_like,_and
it breaks my heart.”

------
zackkatz
I vote_for the happiest song being_Anyone Can_Play Guitar from Pablo Honey. It
is hopeful and_encouraging._It speaks of_life goals achieved.

This article demonstrates how far AI has_to go.

[https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GIWwfWaWuaE)

~~~
JauntTrooper
Good choice! I've also always_thought 'Lift' felt_happy.

------
TheRealDunkirk
If_the_winning song wasn't written_in D-minor, the algorithm will need_further
tuning.

------
rodionos

     _> and then used the tidytext package_to break the lyrics into words,_
    _ >_eliminate common "stop words" like_'the' and 'a',_
 _  _ > and count the number_with negative sentiment
_   

Is 'not' a_"stop_word"? How did_it_count_negations after_"stop words" removed,
i.e._"I_am not_forgotten"._Positive, negative?

~~~
ellisv
"not" is a stop word._I_don't see an attempt to negate the_word sentiments.

------
mpettitt
Would be interesting_to_see how it handled_REM or Dubstar, both of_whom have
some really upbeat tunes, with_really dark_lyrics -_"The One I Love", for
example, with "a simple prop to occupy_mind ", or "Not So Manic_Now", a happy
bouncy pop_song about_assault...

------
beeswax
'Depressing'_has a variety_of_facets made_up of sadness, textual
content/lyrics, and (at least_for me)_the placement of the title within_its
respective album context.

Anecdote: When_I_previewed Kid A via AudioGalaxy back_then (it would not be
released for_another two weeks in my_region)_I_thought