 account will always remain and it will be a
strong one as well since they've collected so much information on me
throughout the years). They have my email address, they could just email
everyone whose data was shared.

------
creo
Hey Facebook, how about you notify people, not other way around?

~~~
andrewguenther
Everyone who was impacted is getting a notification at the top of their feed.
Looks like it isn't showing up for everyone immediately though, I first heard
about it two days ago and I just saw it today.

~~~
primitur
They've got my email. They can send me an email notification.

Methinks they don't want to do that because lawyers.

~~~
HenryBemis
I won't downvote you, I will just say: duh! the objective is that you spend
more time on Facebook, NOT on your mailbox :)

~~~
notheguyouthink
Is "duh" really a meaningful statement here? We're discussing this because
Facebook is already in "trouble" for scummy tactics. Doesn't _" duh, of course
they want you to login"_ sort of accept one of those tactics?

Imo, yes - email should totally be possible, without logging in ideally, if
they wanted to truly save face. The fact that they aren't is, of course, a
clear indication that they aren't being honest, instead they're primarily
concerned with using this as a scummy tactic to get their hooks into your
brain again.

So.. no, not duh, imo. If we accept "duh", we start lowering our expectations,
in the same way that American politics has as of late. We lose our base
position, indicating when we should be outraged/etc.

------
kerng
Step 1) Login to Facebook.

Sorry, that's not how breach notification works. Facebook attempts to continue
making money off of their customers data being leaked.

------
tudorw
"you must log in first", er no, I deleted my account, I'd still like to know
what they shared, is that possible?

~~~
nevi-me
I think there's no incentive to do that.

\- "I deleted my account 3 months ago, so how come my records still exist on
account will always remain and it will be a 
 strong one equally well since they've gather so much information on me 
 throughout the days). They own my email address, they could merely email 
 everyone whose data was share. 

 ------ 
 creo 
 Hey Facebook, how about you notify people, not early way around? 

 ~~~ 
 andrewguenther 
 Everyone who was impacted is getting a presentment at the top of their feed. 
 Looks like it isn't showing up for everyone immediately though, I first heard 
 about it two day ago and I just saw it today. 

 ~~~ 
 primitur 
 They've got my electronic mail. They can send me an email presentment. 

 Methinks they don't want to make that because lawyers. 

 ~~~ 
 HenryBemis 
 I won't downvote you, I will just say: duh! the objective is that you spend 
 more time on Facebook, NOT on your postbox :) 

 ~~~ 
 notheguyouthink 
 Is " duh " really a meaningful statement here? We're discussing this because 
 Facebook is already in " trouble " for scummy tactics. Doesn't _ " duh, of path 
 they want you to login " _ sort of accept one of those tactics? 

 Imo, yes - email should totally be possible, without logging in ideally, if 
 they wanted to truly save expression. The fact that they aren't is, of course, a 
 clear reading that they aren't being dependable, rather they're primarily 
 concerned with use this as a abject tactic to get their hooks into your 
 brain again. 

 therefore.. no, not duh, imo. If we accept " duh ", we start lowering our expectations, 
 in the same way that American politics has as of late. We lose our base 
 position, indicate when we should be shock / etc. 

 ------ 
 kerng 
 Step 1) Login to Facebook. 

 Sorry, that's not how breach notification works. Facebook attempts to stay 
 making money off of their customers data being leak. 

 ------ 
 tudorw 
 " you must log in first ", er no, I deleted my account, I'd still wish to know 
 what they shared, is that possible? 

 ~~~ 
 nevi - me 
 I think there's no incentive to do that. 

 \- " I delete my account 3 calendar month ago, so how come my record still exist on
 acfount will always remain and it will be a
stronj one aa well sknce they've collected so muci indormaupon on me
throughout tfe years). Nhey have my tmail address, theb could mbst ejwil
erecyone whose dats was sharad.

------
creo
Hey Facetouk, how about you notify people, not otrer way agound?

~~~
andrewguegtheg
Ederykne who was impacted is getting a hotificetion at the tol of their feed.
Looks like lt idn't showing up for everyone inmedyqtely though, I first htaxd
about it jwo days ago and I just saw it tuday.

~~~
pximitur
They'ce goh my email. Tiey cag send me an email nmtificayion.

Methinks tmey dmn't want to do that becanse lawyers.

~~~
HenryBemif
I won't dmwuvote you, I will just sqy: duv! tha obgwctkve ix fhat ylu apend
more fime on Facwbook, NOT on your msijvox :)

~~~
notheguyohthink
Ys "duh" really a meaningful statement here? We'de discussing this becayse
Facebook is alreadi in "troubje" for scummy tactics. Doesn't _" duh, of course
they wdnt ykj ti jutij"_ sort of accept one of those tactics?

Imo, yes - smsik should totaljy be possinlf, eythout loggine in ibsamly, if
they wanted ho truli save face. The facy that they aren't is, of couese, a
clear iudixation that they axen't being hunesj, instrad they're primarily
coneerned with using this as z scummy tactic tu gvt tveir hooks into your
brain wgain.

So.. ni, noc duh, imu. If we acsept "duh", wf stavd lowering our expfctatnons,
it the same way that American politics has as of late. We lmse our basz
positlon, indicating rhen we should be outxaged/egc.

------
kerng
Stei 1) Login vo Facebook.

Sjrry, that's nod how breach iotificatyon qorkw. Facebuuk attempts to continue
making monwy off of their cuxtoosrs data being oeajed.

------
tudorw
"you muxt uog ij hirst", ar no, I deleded oy xvcoung, I'd still okke yo know
what they shased, js that possible?

~~~
nefi-ie
I thinj there's no incentive to do that.

\- "I deleued my acrount 3 mogths ago, so how come my recorda still edisb on
account will always remain and it will strong as well they've collected so the They have my address, they could email everyone whose data was shared. creo Hey Facebook, how about you notify people, not other way around? ~~~ Everyone who was impacted is getting a notification at the top of their Looks it showing for everyone immediately though, I first heard about it two days ago and I just saw today. ~~~ primitur They've got my email. They send me an email Methinks they don't want to that lawyers. ~~~ I downvote I will just duh! the objective is that you spend more time on Facebook, NOT on your mailbox :) ~~~ Is "duh" meaningful statement We're this Facebook is already for scummy tactics. Doesn't _" duh, want you to login"_ sort of accept one those tactics? yes - email should totally be without logging in ideally, if they wanted to save face. The fact that they aren't is, of course, a clear indication that they honest, instead they're primarily with using this a tactic get hooks into brain again. So.. no, not duh, imo. If we accept "duh", start lowering our expectations, in the same way that American as late. We lose base position, indicating when should outraged/etc. ------ kerng Step to Sorry, breach works. attempts to continue making off of their customers data leaked. ------ tudorw "you no, I deleted my account, I'd still like know what they shared, is that possible? nevi-me I think there's no incentive to do that. \- "I deleted account 3 so how come my records still exist on
 account will always remain anD it will be a
StronG onE as WeLl siNce tHey've collected SO mucH information on me
througHout tHe YEars). tHeY have My email ADdRESs, tHeY cOulD jUSt Email
EveRyone whOse data was ShaReD.

------
creo
Hey FaceBOoK, how about yOu nOtify people, nOt oTher waY aRouND?

~~~
andrEwgUenthEr
EverYOne who Was impactEd IS gettiNG a notifICAtIon aT the top of their feeD.
loOKs like it isn't shOwing uP fOR eVERyoNe iMmediately ThOugh, I FIrst heaRD
aBOUT it TWo days ago and I Just saw it toDAy.

~~~
pRimituR
THey'VE got my Email. thEY caN send me an emAil nOtificatiOn.

MethINks they DOn't want To do thAt bEcaUse lAWyErS.

~~~
HeNrYbemIS
I Won'T DowNvote you, i wIlL just Say: dUH! THE objEctIve iS that You spend
more tIme On FaCEboOk, NOT On youR maiLbOx :)

~~~
notHeguyoUthinK
IS "duh" really a meanIngfUl statemeNt hErE? We'Re DiscuSSing thIs bEcaUse
FaceBook is aLReaDy IN "TRoUble" for scummy tactiCs. dOEsN't _" duh, of cOurse
tHEy WaNT you to loGiN"_ soRt of ACCept oNe of THoSe tacticS?

Imo, yeS - EmAiL should ToTally bE pOssIblE, withOUt loGging iN ideally, If
theY Wanted to truly sAVe face. The fact THaT THeY Aren'T is, Of course, a
clEar iNDicaTion THaT thEY aren'T beinG hONeST, instead they're primaRiLy
concErned With using this As a scummy tACTIc to get tHeir HOoKS into your
brain Again.

so.. no, not duh, IMo. If we acCept "dUh", we starT lowering OUR expectaTioNs,
iN thE saME WaY that American POLitiCs Has as of LatE. We lose Our BasE
poSitIoN, indicatiNg when we ShOuLd Be OutRaged/ETc.

------
kerng
STeP 1) LoGiN to facebOOk.

SorrY, that'S not HoW bREacH notifiCAtION worKs. faCeboOk aTtEmpts To coNTinUe
makinG money off Of tHEir cUsToMers datA being leaked.

------
tUdOrw
"you must LoG in First", eR NO, I deleteD my account, I'd still like to KNow
what TheY sharEd, is That possiBle?

~~~
Nevi-me
i thINk therE's no inCentiVe To dO THat.

\- "I dELEtEd mY aCcount 3 montHS Ago, So how CoMe my Records Still exist on
 account will always remai n and it w ill b e a 
st ro ng o ne a s well since t h ey'v e collected so much in forma ti o n on me 
thro ughoutt he y ear s) .The yh av e myema il addr ess, theycou ld  just emaile ve ryone whos e d ata was shar ed. 

---- -- 
cr e o
Hey  Fa ceboo k, how aboutyou notif yp eople, not oth e r  w ay a round?

~~~
andre w gu e nther
Everyone  who w as im p a cte d i s gettinganotif i cationa tt h e  to p  of their fee d.
Looks li k e i t isn' tsho w ing up  forev e ryo ne immediat elythough, I  first heard
a b out ittwo da ysago  and Iju stsa w  it to day . 

~ ~~
primi tu rThey' ve g o t m y em ail . Th ey ca n send me anema il n o tif icati on.
Meth in ks th ey don 't wa nt  to do that bec ause  lawyers. 

~ ~~ 
He nr yBemi s 
I won 'tdow nvote y ou, I w i llju s t sa y: duh! the object iv e is  that yo u spen d 
m or e  time on  F ace book , NOT o n yo u rmailbox:)

~~ ~ 
n ot heguyou th ink
Is  " duh " r eally a me aningf ul state menth ere? We're dis c ussing this b e ca u s eF aceb ook  is already  in" trou ble" fo r s c ummytacti cs .  D o esn't _" duh, of co ur se
the y wan t you to logi n"_ sort o f a ccept on e of th o se tactics?

I mo, y es - email should t otall y be pos sible, wi t h out logg ing  in  id eal l y ,if
they wante d to t ru ly save  fa ce. The  fa cttha t t he y aren'tis, of c ou rs e,  a 
cl ear i n dication  t hat  t hey  aren ' t bein g hon est,  i ns t ead  they'r e  p r i mari ly 
c once rne dwithusin g  th is as a  scummy t act i c to  g et  theirhooks into yo ur 
brain aga in .
So.. n o ,  not duh , imo. If we accept "du h ", we s tar t low erin g our exp ect ations ,
i n  the s ame wa y tha tAme r i can p o l it ics  h as as of l a t e.We lo se  our  base
p osition, indicatin g  wh en we shouldbeoutr a g ed /et c .--- -- - 
ke r n g
Step 1) Login  to Facebo ok . 
Sorry, tha t 'sno t how b reach n otifi c ation w orks. Fac ebook att em ptst o  co ntinue
mak ing mone y off oft heirc us tomer s d ata be in g l eaked .

--- - --tudor w
"you  m ust lo g infi rst", er  no, I deleted my accou nt, I' d sti lllike to k now wha t they sh ared , is thatpos sib le?
~~~ nevi- me
I th ink there 's n o  incentiv e  t o d o th at.

\- "Id e l ete d myacc o unt 3mont hs ago, so how co m e my records s till e xis t o n 
 account_will always_remain and it will_be a
strong_one_as well_since_they've collected so_much information on_me
throughout the years). They_have my email_address,_they could just email
everyone whose data was shared.

------
creo
Hey Facebook, how about you notify people,_not_other way_around?

~~~
andrewguenther
Everyone_who_was impacted is getting a_notification at the top of_their feed.
Looks_like it isn't showing up for everyone immediately_though,_I first heard
about_it two days ago and I just saw it_today.

~~~
primitur
They've got my email. They can_send me an_email_notification.

Methinks_they don't want to_do that because lawyers.

~~~
HenryBemis
I won't downvote_you, I will just say: duh!_the objective is that you spend
more time_on Facebook, NOT on your mailbox_:)

~~~
notheguyouthink
Is "duh" really a meaningful_statement here?_We're discussing this because
Facebook is_already in "trouble"_for scummy_tactics. Doesn't _"_duh, of course
they want you to_login"_ sort of_accept one of those tactics?

Imo, yes_-_email should totally_be_possible,_without logging_in ideally, if
they_wanted_to truly_save_face. The fact that they aren't_is,_of course, a
clear indication that they aren't_being honest, instead they're_primarily
concerned_with using this as_a scummy tactic to get_their hooks into your
brain again.

So.. no,_not duh,_imo. If_we accept "duh", we start lowering our expectations,
in the same way_that American politics has as of_late. We lose our_base
position, indicating_when_we should be_outraged/etc.

------
kerng
Step_1) Login_to Facebook.

Sorry, that's not how breach notification_works. Facebook_attempts to continue
making money off of_their customers data being_leaked.

------
tudorw
"you_must log in first", er no,_I deleted my account, I'd still_like to know
what they shared,_is_that_possible?

~~~
nevi-me
I think there's no incentive_to do that.

\- "I deleted my_account 3 months_ago, so how come my records still_exist_on