\]) only three $p\bar{p}$ final states are possible, as a consequence of the $J^{PC}$ conservation. These differ by the internal angular momenta and spins. Close to the $p \bar{p}$ threshold a distinctly different behavior of scattering amplitudes is expected in different states. A further selection of states is possible, but one has to rely on the analyzes of the elastic and inelastic $N \bar{N}$ scattering experiments. This has been studied in Ref. [@loi05] within the Paris potential model [@par04; @par99; @par94; @par82], which is also used in the present work.

The final $p \bar{p}$ states allowed by $P$ and $C$ conservation in the $\gamma p \bar{p}$ channel are specified in Table I. These are denoted as $^{2S+1}L_{J}$ or $^{2I+1,2S+1}L_{J}$, where $S,L$ and $J$ are the spin, angular momentum and total momentum of the pair, respectively, while $I$ denotes the isospin. A unified picture and a better specification in the radiative decays is achieved, semi-quantitatively, with an effective three-gluon exchange model [@loi05]. This description indicates the final $ \gamma p \bar{p}$ state to be dominated by the $p \bar{p}$  $^{11}S_0$ partial wave. In this wave the Paris potential generates a $52$ MeV broad quasi-bound state at $4.8$ MeV below threshold. This state is named $N
\bar{N}_S(1870)$. A similar conclusion has been reached by the Jülich group although the Bonn-Jülich potential does not generate a bound state in the $p \bar{p}$ $^{11}S_0$ partial wave [@jul06].

Under the assumption that the $\pi^+,\ \pi^-$ and $\eta'$ are produced in relative $S$ waves, the reaction (\[3i\]), if attributed to an intermediate $p \bar{p}$ as suggested by the BES group, is even more restrictive than the reaction (\[1i\]). It allows only one intermediate state the $p\bar{p}$ $^{1}S_0$, which coincides with the previous findings. The presence of an intermediate $
\ ]) only three $ p\bar{p}$ final states are possible, as a consequence of the $ J^{PC}$ conservation. These disagree by the inner angular momenta and spins. near to the $ p \bar{p}$ doorsill a distinctly different demeanor of scatter amplitudes is expect in different states. A further excerpt of states is possible, but one take to rely on the analyzes of the elastic and inelastic $ N \bar{N}$ scattering experiments. This has been studied in Ref.   [ @loi05 ] within the Paris potential model   [ @par04; @par99; @par94; @par82 ], which is besides used in the present work. 

 The final $ phosphorus \bar{p}$ states allowed by $ P$ and $ C$ conservation in the $ \gamma p \bar{p}$ channel are specified in Table I. These are denote as $ ^{2S+1}L_{J}$ or $ ^{2I+1,2S+1}L_{J}$, where $ S, L$ and $ J$ are the spin, angular momentum and total momentum of the pair, respectively, while $ I$ denotes the isospin. A incorporate picture and a better specification in the radiative decays is achieved, semi - quantitatively, with an effective three - gluon exchange model   [ @loi05 ]. This description indicates the final $ \gamma p \bar{p}$ state to be dominated by the $ p \bar{p}$   $ ^{11}S_0 $ partial wave. In this wave the Paris potential generates a $ 52 $   MeV broad quasi - oblige state at $ 4.8 $   MeV below threshold. This department of state is named $ N 
 \bar{N}_S(1870)$. A similar conclusion has been reached by the Jülich group although the Bonn - Jülich electric potential does not generate a bind state in the $ p \bar{p}$   $ ^{11}S_0 $ fond wave   [ @jul06 ]. 

 Under the assumption that the $ \pi^+,\ \pi^-$ and $ \eta'$ are produced in relative $ S$ waves, the reaction (\[3i\ ]), if attributed to an intermediate $ p \bar{p}$ as suggested by the BES group, is even more restrictive than the reaction (\[1i\ ]). It allows only one average state the $ p\bar{p}$ $ ^{1}S_0 $, which coincide with the previous findings. The presence of an intermediate $
\]) onpy three $p\bar{p}$ final staues are possible, cw a coisequende of thd $J^{PC}$ conservation. These difher vy tht internal angular oomenta ajd spins. Cloww to the $p \bar{p}$ thvzshols a dnsvinctly differekt behavior of scattering aoppitudes is expected in different stwtes. A gugther selectiog of ftatss is possible, but one has to rely on the analyzes of yhe elastic and inelastic $J \bag{N}$ scattering expegiments. Thiw haf been studiea in Ref. [@lop05] within thg Paris potential model [@par04; @par99; @pxr94; @pax82], which is qlwo kved in the 'resenn work.

The final $p \bar{[}$ statex allowed by $P$ anv $C$ xonservation in the $\gemma p \bar{p}$ channel wre specixizd in Table I. These aee denojed av $^{2S+1}L_{G}$ or $^{2I+1,2S+1}M_{J}$, wgere $S,P$ aid $J$ are ths spin, anguoar momentum and toual nomentum of tge paiw, wespectively, while $I$ denotes the isospit. A unified picture and a vetter specification ln the raqiative decays is achieved, semi-quantitatively, witv an xfwecuiyc thfwe-hluon exchange model [@loi05]. This description indisztts nhe final $ \gamma i \bar{p}$ state to be dlmogated by the $k \bar{p}$  $^{11}S_0$ pzrtial wave. In thid wave jhe Paeis potenuial benerates a $52$ MeV broad quasi-vound state ct $4.8$ NeV below thresholb. This state is mamed $N
\bar{N}_S(1870)$. A similar conclbsion gas been rewched by ffe Jülich group authpuch the Bonn-Jülich potential does not genzrate a counc statq in the $p \bar{p}$ $^{11}S_0$ partial wave [@jul06].

Unfer tke asvumption tjat the $\pi^+,\ \pi^-$ and $\eta'$ are produrxd in relativg $S$ wanes, the rzactiok (\[3i\]), if attributqd to an interkediate $p \baf{p}$ as suggvsted by vhe BES grou[, is even mora restrictive than thq reqctiin (\[1i\]). It xllows only onr intermebnate statw the $p\bar{p}$ $^{1}S_0$, whicm coivdides with the 'xecious findings. Yhe prqsvncx of wt intermediade $
\]) only three $p\bar{p}$ final states are a of the conservation. These differ and Close to the \bar{p}$ threshold a different behavior of scattering amplitudes is in different states. A further selection of states is possible, but one has rely on the analyzes of the elastic and inelastic $N \bar{N}$ scattering experiments. has studied Ref. within the Paris potential model [@par04; @par99; @par94; @par82], which is also used in the present The final $p \bar{p}$ states allowed by $P$ $C$ conservation in the p \bar{p}$ channel are specified Table These are as or where $S,L$ and are the spin, angular momentum and total momentum of the pair, respectively, while $I$ denotes the isospin. unified picture better specification the decays achieved, semi-quantitatively, with three-gluon exchange model [@loi05]. This description $ \gamma p \bar{p}$ state to be dominated the $p $^{11}S_0$ partial wave. In this wave Paris potential generates a $52$ MeV broad quasi-bound at $4.8$ MeV below threshold. This state is named $N \bar{N}_S(1870)$. A similar conclusion has by the Jülich group the Bonn-Jülich potential not a state the $p $^{11}S_0$ partial wave [@jul06]. Under the assumption that the $\pi^+,\ \pi^-$ $\eta'$ are produced in relative $S$ waves, the reaction (\[3i\]), to intermediate $p \bar{p}$ suggested by the BES is more restrictive than the It only the $^{1}S_0$, coincides with the previous The presence of an intermediate
\]) only three $p\bar{p}$ final states Are possiblE, as a cOnsEquEnCe of The $J^{pC}$ conservation. tHese Differ by the internal angUlar mOmENta aND sPins. CLose to tHE $p \BAR{p}$ tHrEsHolD a DIsTinctLy dIfferenT behavior oF scAtTering amplitUDeS is expecteD in Different staTes. a furthEr SelECtion Of sTates Is possIBle, but One has to rElY On the aNAlyzes oF THe ElasTic and inelastic $N \bAR{N}$ SCattering experIments. thIS hAS BeeN stUdied in Ref. [@LoI05] withIN the ParIS pOTENtiAL model [@par04; @par99; @pAr94; @par82], which iS AlsO used iN tHe pREsent wOrk.

ThE fINal $P \bar{p}$ states AlloWed by $P$ and $c$ conseRVation iN The $\gammA p \bar{p}$ ChaNneL are SPeCiFieD iN tabLE I. theSE arE denoted As $^{2s+1}L_{j}$ or $^{2I+1,2S+1}l_{J}$, whERE $s,l$ and $j$ arE the Spin, aNgular momentuM anD totAL moMentuM of thE paiR, rEspecTively, While $i$ dEnotes the isospiN. A unIfied pictUre AnD a bEtTer spECificaTioN in The radiAtive deCAys Is ACHIeVed, semi-quantitativElY, WItH an effecTive thREe-GlUOn exchanGe ModEl [@loI05]. tHis deScriPTiOn indicaTes the FInAl $ \Gamma p \bAr{P}$ state To Be dOmiNated BY the $P \bar{p}$  $^{11}S_0$ Partial wAve. In THis wave the PariS Potential geneRAtES A $52$ MEv broAd qUasi-bound stAte aT $4.8$ meV bElow THrEshOLd. ThiS statE iS NaMEd $N
\bar{N}_S(1870)$. A similar conClUsion hAs beeN reached by the jülich grouP ALThough thE BonN-jüLIch potential doEs not Generate a bOUnd state In the $P \bar{p}$ $^{11}S_0$ paRtial wave [@JUL06].

Under thE asSumPtiOn tHAT tHe $\pi^+,\ \pi^-$ and $\eta'$ aRE ProdUcEd in relAtiVe $S$ waveS, thE reActIon (\[3I\]), iF attributEd to an inTeRmEdIaTe $p \Bar{p}$ aS SuggesteD bY thE BeS gRoup, iS Even moRe resTricTiVe THan The reacTIoN (\[1I\]). it alLoWs Only One InTermeDiatE StaTe the $p\bAr{p}$ $^{1}S_0$, which CoiNCideS wItH the preVious findings. thE presence oF aN inTermedIATe $
\]) only three $p\bar{p}$final stat es ar e p oss ib le,as a  consequence o f  the  $J^{PC}$ conservation . The se diff e rby th e inter n al a ngu la rmom en t aand s pin s. Clos e to the $ p \ ba r{p}$ thresh o ld  a distinc tly  different b eha vior o fsca t terin g a mplit udes i s  expec ted in di ff e rent s t ates. A f ur ther  selection of sta t es is possible, b ut one  h a st o  re lyon the ana ly zes o f  the el a st i c and inelastic $N\bar{N}$ sc a tte ring e xp eri m ents.Thisha s  be en studiedin R ef. [@loi 05] wi t hin the Paris p otenti almod el [ @ pa r0 4;@p a r99 ;  @ par 9 4;@par82],  w hi ch is  als o u s ed i n t he p resen t work.

Thefin al $ p  \b ar{p} $ sta tesal lowed  by $P $ and  $ C$ conservation  inthe $\gam map\ba r{ p}$ c h annelare  sp ecified  in Tab l e I .T h e se  are denoted as $^ {2 S + 1} L_{J}$ o r $^{2 I +1 ,2 S +1}L_{J} $,  wh ere$ S ,L$ a nd $ J $are thespin,a ng ul ar mome nt um and  t ota l m oment u m of  the p air, res pecti v ely, while $I$ denotes the i s os p i n. A un ifi ed pictureanda  bet ters pe cif i catio n inth e  r a diative decays is a ch ieved,  semi -quantitative ly, with a n e ffective  thr e e- g luon exchangemodel  [@loi05]. This des cript ion indi cates the f inal $ \ gam map \ bar { p }$  state to bed o mina te d by th e $ p \bar{ p}$   $ ^{1 1}S _0 $ partial  wave. I nth is  w ave  theP aris pot en tia lgen erate s  a $52 $ MeV  bro ad  q u asi -bounds ta t e  at$4 .8 $ Me V b el ow th resh o ld.  This s tate is n ame d  $N\b ar {N}_S(1 870)$. A simi la r conclusi on  ha s been r eached b y the Jülich group alth o ugh the  Bo nn-Jü lich  potentia l d oes no t g e nerate  a bou nd st at e i n the $ p \b ar{ p} $ $^{11}S_ 0 $  pa rtial  w ave[@jul06 ].

Under the assu m pti on that the $ \pi ^+,\ \ pi ^-$ an d  $\ et a '$a r e produced in r elative $S $w av es, the re a cti on  (\[3i\ ]), ifattri b uted to  an inter mediate $ p\bar { p }$as suggest ed by th e BES gro u p, is ev en mo rerestri ct ive  than  the r e act ion ( \[1i\] ).  It al lowson ly one i ntermediate state the $ p\bar{ p}$ $ ^{1 }S_0$, wh ich coi ncides wi th t he previou s f ind ings.  Th e  pres ence of  an inter medi a te $
\]) only_three $p\bar{p}$_final states are possible,_as a_consequence_of the_$J^{PC}$_conservation. These differ_by the internal_angular momenta and spins._Close to the_$p_\bar{p}$ threshold a distinctly different behavior of scattering amplitudes is expected in different states._A_further selection_of_states_is possible, but one has_to rely on the analyzes_of the_elastic and inelastic $N \bar{N}$ scattering experiments. This_has_been studied in_Ref. [@loi05] within the Paris potential model [@par04; @par99; @par94; @par82],_which is also used in the_present work.

The final_$p_\bar{p}$_states allowed by $P$_and $C$ conservation in the $\gamma_p \bar{p}$ channel are specified in_Table I. These are denoted as $^{2S+1}L_{J}$_or $^{2I+1,2S+1}L_{J}$, where $S,L$ and $J$_are the spin, angular momentum_and total_momentum of the pair, respectively,_while $I$ denotes_the isospin._A unified picture_and a better specification in the_radiative decays is_achieved, semi-quantitatively, with an effective three-gluon_exchange_model [@loi05]. This description_indicates_the_final $_\gamma p \bar{p}$_state_to be_dominated_by the $p \bar{p}$  $^{11}S_0$ partial_wave._In this wave the Paris potential generates_a $52$ MeV broad quasi-bound_state_at $4.8$ MeV below threshold._This state is named $N
\bar{N}_S(1870)$._A similar conclusion has been reached_by the_Jülich group_although the Bonn-Jülich potential does not generate a bound state in_the $p \bar{p}$ $^{11}S_0$ partial wave [@jul06].

Under the_assumption that the $\pi^+,\_\pi^-$ and_$\eta'$_are produced in_relative_$S$ waves,_the reaction (\[3i\]), if attributed to an_intermediate $p_\bar{p}$ as suggested by the BES_group, is even more_restrictive_than the reaction (\[1i\]). It allows_only one intermediate state the $p\bar{p}$_$^{1}S_0$, which coincides with the_previous_findings._The presence of an intermediate_$