 regime, such as HCN and C$_2$H$_2$ [Lodders10]{}, which were not considered in the [Madhu11]{} study.

Carbon-dominated rocky planets would be extremely interesting objects. Their prevalence around stars of Sunlike abundances, and those stars with enhanced C/O ratios, would certainly tell us much about nebular condensation chemistry and the planet formation process. While these planets may be inherently rare, we look forward to additional advances in the future.

JJF acknowledges support from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. JJF thanks the anonymous referee for a important suggestions regarding statistics and nickel blends. JJF thanks Debra Fischer, Martin Asplund, Bruce Margon, Katharina Lodders, Channon Visscher, Mark Marley, Mike Irwin, Kevin Covey, Mike Jura, Graeme Smith, Greg Laughlin, Geoff Marcy, Travis Barman, Sean Raymond, Andrew Howard, Jade Bond, and David O’Brien for many stimulating conversations throughout the course of this project. JJF thanks Jacob Bruns for compiling the C/O data.

[49]{} natexlab\#1[\#1]{}

, A. S., & [Marley]{}, M. S. 2001,, 556, 872

, C., [Lambert]{}, D. L., & [Asplund]{}, M. 2001,, 556, L63

—. 2002,, 573, L137

, M., [Grevesse]{}, N., [Sauval]{}, A. J., & [Scott]{}, P. 2009,, 47, 481

, J. J., [Hawley]{}, S. L., [Covey]{}, K. R., [West]{}, A. A., [Reid]{}, I. N., [Golimowski]{}, D. A., & [Ivezi[ć]{}]{}, [Ž]{}. 2010,, 139, 2679

, J. C., [O’Brien]{}, D. P., & [Lauretta]{}, D. S. 2010,, 715, 1050

, A., [Hubeny]{}, I., [Budaj]{}, J., & [Hubbard]{}, W. B. 2007,, 661, 502

, A., [Marley]{}, M. S., & [Sharp
regime, such as HCN and C$ _ 2$H$_2 $ [ Lodders10 ] { }, which were not considered in the [ Madhu11 ] { } study. 

 Carbon - dominated rough planet would be extremely interesting objects. Their preponderance around stars of Sunlike abundance, and those stars with enhance C / O ratios, would surely assure us much about nebular condensing chemistry and the planet formation summons. While these planet may be inherently rare, we look forward to additional advances in the future. 

 JJF acknowledges documentation from the Alfred P.   Sloan Foundation. JJF thanks the anonymous referee for a important suggestions involve statistics and nickel blends. JJF thanks Debra Fischer, Martin Asplund, Bruce Margon, Katharina Lodders, Channon Visscher, Mark Marley, Mike Irwin, Kevin Covey, Mike Jura, Graeme Smith, Greg Laughlin, Geoff Marcy, Travis Barman, Sean Raymond, Andrew Howard, Jade Bond, and David O’Brien for many stimulating conversation throughout the course of this undertaking. JJF thanks Jacob Bruns for compiling the C / O data. 

 [ 49 ] { } natexlab\#1[\#1 ] { } 

, A.   S., & [ Marley ] { }, M.   S. 2001, , 556, 872 

, C., [ Lambert ] { }, D.   L., & [ Asplund ] { }, M. 2001, , 556, L63 

 —. 2002, , 573, L137 

, M., [ Grevesse ] { }, N., [ Sauval ] { }, A.   J., & [ Scott ] { }, P. 2009, , 47, 481 

, J.   J., [ Hawley ] { }, S.   L., [ Covey ] { }, K.   R., [ West ] { }, A.   A., [ Reid ] { }, I.   N., [ Golimowski ] { }, D.   A., & [ Ivezi[ć ] { } ] { }, [ Ž ] { }. 2010, , 139, 2679 

, J.   C., [ O’Brien ] { }, D.   P., & [ Lauretta ] { }, D.   S. 2010, , 715, 1050 

, A., [ Hubeny ] { }, I., [ Budaj ] { }, J., & [ Hubbard ] { }, W.   B. 2007, , 661, 502 

, A., [ Marley ] { }, M.   S., & [ Sharp
 rehime, such as HCN and C$_2$H$_2$ [Uodders10]{}, which wgrw not ronsideded in tfe [Madhu11]{} study.

Carbon-dominatev roxky poanets would be extremdly intervsting obhectw. Their pretzlence around dtarv of Sunlike abondances, and those stars whtf znhanced C/O ratios, would certainly tqll us kufh about nebulwr cpgdenaation chemistry and the planet fodmation process. Whilr these planets may be inhfrenhly rare, we look flrward to aedityinal advancer in the flcure.

JJF ackhowledges support from the Alfrdd P. Skoan Foundqtuon. BJF thanks vhe anjnymous refevve for d imporyant suggestioks rejardung statistics and nirkel blends. JJF thanhs Debra Xiacher, Martin Asplyne, Bruwe Mdrgov, Kaghadiia Modderd, Ciannon Vissdher, Mark Mqrley, Mike Irwin, Kefig Covey, Mike Jhra, Grweie Smith, Greg Laughlin, Geoff Marcy, Travps Bzrman, Sean Raymond, Andrww Howard, Jade Bond, ajd David J’Brien for many stimulating conversations throughmut tie cobvfd ov this project. JJF thanks Jacob Bruns for com[jlonn the C/O data.

[49]{} nabexlab\#1[\#1]{}

, A. S., & [Marley]{}, K. S. 2001,, 556, 872

, C., [Lambert]{}, D. L., & [Asplbhd]{}, M. 2001,, 556, L63

—. 2002,, 573, L137

, M., [Grevedse]{}, N., [Swuval]{}, A. J., & [Scotu]{}, P. 2009,, 47, 481

, J. J., [Hawley]{}, S. L., [Covey]{}, K. R., [Wesr]{}, A. A., [Reid]{}, I. N., [Tolimowski]{}, D. A., & [Ivevi[ć]{}]{}, [Ž]{}. 2010,, 139, 2679

, J. C., [O’Bxien]{}, D. K., & [Lautetta]{}, D. S. 2010,, 715, 1050

, A., [Hubeny]{}, I., [Yudaj]{}, N., & [Hubbard]{}, A. B. 2007,, 661, 502

, A., [Mzfley]{}, M. S., & [Sharp
regime, such as HCN and C$_2$H$_2$ [Lodders10]{}, not in the study. Carbon-dominated rocky objects. prevalence around stars Sunlike abundances, and stars with enhanced C/O ratios, would tell us much about nebular condensation chemistry and the planet formation process. While planets may be inherently rare, we look forward to additional advances in the JJF support the P. Sloan Foundation. JJF thanks the anonymous referee for a important suggestions regarding statistics and nickel JJF thanks Debra Fischer, Martin Asplund, Bruce Margon, Lodders, Channon Visscher, Mark Mike Irwin, Kevin Covey, Mike Graeme Greg Laughlin, Marcy, Barman, Raymond, Andrew Howard, Bond, and David O’Brien for many stimulating conversations throughout the course of this project. JJF thanks Jacob for compiling data. [49]{} , S., [Marley]{}, M. S. 872 , C., [Lambert]{}, D. L., 2001,, 556, L63 —. 2002,, 573, L137 , [Grevesse]{}, N., A. J., & [Scott]{}, P. 2009,, 481 , J. J., [Hawley]{}, S. L., [Covey]{}, R., [West]{}, A. A., [Reid]{}, I. N., [Golimowski]{}, D. A., & [Ivezi[ć]{}]{}, [Ž]{}. 2010,, 139, J. C., [O’Brien]{}, D. & [Lauretta]{}, D. 2010,, 1050 A., I., [Budaj]{}, & [Hubbard]{}, W. B. 2007,, 661, 502 , A., [Marley]{}, M. & [Sharp
 regime, such as HCN and C$_2$H$_2$ [LoddeRs10]{}, which werE not cOnsIdeReD in tHe [MaDhu11]{} study.

Carbon-DOminAted rocky planets would bE extrEmELy inTErEstinG objectS. thEIR prEvAlEncE aROuNd staRs oF SunlikE abundanceS, anD tHose stars witH EnHanced C/O raTioS, would certaiNly Tell us MuCh aBOut neBulAr conDensatIOn chemIstry and tHe PLanet fORmation PROcEss. WHile these planets mAY bE Inherently rare, We look FoRWaRD To aDdiTional advaNcEs in tHE future.

jjF ACKNowLEdges support fRom the AlfreD p. SlOan FouNdAtiON. JJF thAnks tHe ANonYmous refereE for A importanT suggeSTions reGArding sTatistIcs And NickEL bLeNds. jJf ThaNKs debRA FiScher, MarTiN ASplunD, BruCE mARgon, katHariNa LodDers, Channon ViSscHer, MARk MArley, mike IRwin, keVin CoVey, MikE Jura, grAeme Smith, Greg LaUghlIn, Geoff MaRcy, trAviS BArman, sEan RayMonD, AnDrew HowArd, Jade bOnd, AnD dAViD O’Brien for many stimUlATInG conversAtions THrOuGHout the cOuRse Of thIS ProjeCt. JJf ThAnks JacoB Bruns FOr CoMpiling ThE C/O datA.

[49]{} nAteXlaB\#1[\#1]{}

, A. S., & [MaRLey]{}, M. s. 2001,, 556, 872

, C., [LambErt]{}, D. L., & [AspLund]{}, M. 2001,, 556, l63

—. 2002,, 573, l137

, M., [Grevesse]{}, N., [SauVAl]{}, A. J., & [Scott]{}, P. 2009,, 47, 481

, J. J., [HAWlEY]{}, s. L., [cOvey]{}, k. R., [WEst]{}, A. A., [Reid]{}, I. N., [goliMOwskI]{}, D. A., & [IVEzI[ć]{}]{}, [Ž]{}. 2010,, 139, 2679

, j. c., [O’BriEn]{}, D. P., & [LAuREtTA]{}, D. S. 2010,, 715, 1050

, A., [Hubeny]{}, I., [Budaj]{}, J., & [HuBbArd]{}, W. B. 2007,, 661, 502

, A., [marleY]{}, M. S., & [Sharp
 regime, such as HCN and C $_2$H$_2$[Lodd ers 10] {} , wh ichwere not consi d ered  in the [Madhu11]{} st udy.
C a rbon - do minat ed rock y  p l a net swo uld  b e  e xtrem ely  intere sting obje cts .Their preval e nc e around s tar s of Sunlike  ab undanc es , a n d tho sestars  withe nhance d C/O rat io s , woul d  certai n l ytell  us much about ne b ul a r condensation  chemi st r ya n d t heplanet for ma tionp rocess. Wh i l e  th e se planets ma y be inhere n tly  rare,  w e l o ok for wardto add itional adv ance s in thefuture . 

JJF a c knowled ges su ppo rtfrom th eAlf re d  P. Sl oan Fou ndation.  J JF  than ks t h e a nony mou s re feree  for a import ant  sug g est ionsregar ding  s tatis tics a nd ni ck el blends. JJFthan ks DebraFis ch er,  M artin Asplun d,Bru ce Marg on, Kat h ari na L o dd ers, Channon Vissc he r ,  M ark Marl ey, Mi k eIr w in, Kevi nCov ey,M i ke Ju ra,G ra eme Smit h, Gre g  L au ghlin,Ge off Ma rc y,Tra vis B a rman , Sean  Raymond , And r ew Howard, Jad e  Bond, and Da v id O ’B r ienfor  many stimu lati n g co nver s at ion s  thro ughou tt he course of this proj ec t. JJF  than ks Jacob Brun s for comp i l i ng the C /O d a ta . 

[49]{} natex lab\# 1[\#1]{}
,  A. S.,& [Ma rley]{},  M. S. 20 0 1 ,, 556,872 

,  C. , [ L a mb ert]{}, D. L. , & [A sp lund]{} , M . 2001, , 5 56,  L6 3
—.  2002,, 5 73, L137 
,M. ,[Gr evess e ]{}, N.,  [ Sau va l]{ }, A. J., &[Scot t]{} ,P. 200 9,, 47, 48 1 
, J .J. , [H awl ey ]{},S. L . , [ Covey]{ }, K. R.,  [W e st]{ },  A . A., [ Reid]{}, I. N .,  [Golimows ki ]{} , D. A . ,  & [Ivez i[ć]{}]{}, [Ž]{}. 2010, ,  139, 2 679 

, J . C. , [O’Brie n]{ }, D.P., & [Lau retta] {}, D .S.2 0 10,,7 1 5,  10 50 

, A., [H u b eny ]{},I. , [B udaj]{} , J., & [Hubbard]{ } , W . B. 2007,, 6 61,  502 ,A., [M a rle y] { },M .  S., & [Sharp
 regime,_such as_HCN and C$_2$H$_2$ [Lodders10]{},_which were_not_considered in_the_[Madhu11]{} study.

Carbon-dominated rocky_planets would be_extremely interesting objects. Their_prevalence around stars_of_Sunlike abundances, and those stars with enhanced C/O ratios, would certainly tell us much_about_nebular condensation_chemistry_and_the planet formation process. While_these planets may be inherently_rare, we_look forward to additional advances in the future.

JJF_acknowledges_support from the_Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. JJF thanks the anonymous referee for_a important suggestions regarding statistics and_nickel blends. JJF_thanks_Debra_Fischer, Martin Asplund, Bruce_Margon, Katharina Lodders, Channon Visscher, Mark_Marley, Mike Irwin, Kevin Covey, Mike_Jura, Graeme Smith, Greg Laughlin, Geoff Marcy,_Travis Barman, Sean Raymond, Andrew Howard,_Jade Bond, and David O’Brien_for many_stimulating conversations throughout the course_of this project._JJF thanks_Jacob Bruns for_compiling the C/O data.

[49]{} natexlab\#1[\#1]{}

, A. S.,_& [Marley]{}, M. S._2001,, 556, 872

, C., [Lambert]{}, D. L.,_&_[Asplund]{}, M. 2001,,_556,_L63

—._2002,, 573,_L137

, M., [Grevesse]{},_N.,_[Sauval]{}, A. J.,_&_[Scott]{}, P. 2009,, 47, 481

, J. J.,_[Hawley]{},_S. L., [Covey]{}, K. R., [West]{}, A. A., [Reid]{}, I. N.,_[Golimowski]{}, D. A., & [Ivezi[ć]{}]{},_[Ž]{}._2010,, 139, 2679

, J. C.,_[O’Brien]{}, D. P., & [Lauretta]{}, D. S._2010,, 715, 1050

, A., [Hubeny]{}, I.,_[Budaj]{}, J.,_& [Hubbard]{},_W. B. 2007,, 661, 502

, A., [Marley]{}, M. S., & [Sharp