-wave interactions require $k \neq k'$. When including wavenumber dependence, these nonlinear terms will necessarily grow at less than twice the peak growth rate. On the other hand, stable modes near $k=0$ can be driven by $D_1\beta_1\beta_1$ terms where one of the driving modes is near $k=0.4$ and the other is near $k=-0.4$. Thus, our inclusion of the wavenumber dependence of $\omega_j$ causes $\beta_2$ to grow large enough that Eq.  becomes invalid before saturation time. This makes the precise value of $P_t$ less meaningful, as the stable modes have grown so large that the approximations made in obtaining $P_t$ are invalid. However, the size of $\beta_2$ relative to $\beta_1$ and the comparable amplitudes of $C_2$ and $C_1$ imply $P_t \gtrsim 1$, and therefore $P_t \gtrsim 0.3$ is still well satisfied.

The above nonlinear analysis demonstrates that energy transfer to stable modes is significant relative to energy transfer to smaller scales, modifying the usual understanding of instability saturation by a cascade to small scales. The analysis employs approximations, hence it is instructive to consider a second, complementary form of approximate nonlinear analysis based on a three-wavenumber truncation of Eqs.  and. Such a calculation complements the $P_t$ analysis because it makes different assumptions. The $P_t$ analysis makes parametric instability approximations when considering the evolution of $\beta_2$ (c.f. Eq. ), but samples a broad continuum of wavenumbers. On the other hand, a three-wavenumber truncation makes no assumptions about the evolution of the modes, and instead limits the system to only three wavenumbers that are evolved according to Eqs.  and.

![Time evolution of $|\beta_j(k,t)|$ for a three-wavenumber truncation with $k=0.3, k'=0.9$, and $k-k'=-0.6$. As expected from the $P_t$ analysis, the stable mode decays linearly, then is nonlinearly pumped to an amplitude that is comparable to the unstable mode.[]{data-label="ThreeModePlot"}](Fig5.eps){width="16cm"}

The result of a three-wavenumber truncation is plotted
-wave interactions require $ k \neq k'$. When including wavenumber addiction, these nonlinear term will necessarily originate at less than twice the flower growth rate. On the early hand, stable modes near $ k=0 $ can be drive by $ D_1\beta_1\beta_1 $ terms where one of the driving mood is near $ k=0.4 $ and the other is near $ k=-0.4$. Thus, our inclusion of the wavenumber addiction of $ \omega_j$ causes $ \beta_2 $ to grow big enough that Eq.    becomes invalid before saturation clock time. This makes the precise value of $ P_t$ less meaningful, as the stable mood have grown so large that the approximations construct in obtaining $ P_t$ are invalid. However, the size of $ \beta_2 $ relative to $ \beta_1 $ and the comparable amplitudes of $ C_2 $ and $ C_1 $ imply $ P_t \gtrsim 1 $, and therefore $ P_t \gtrsim 0.3 $ is however well satisfied. 

 The above nonlinear analysis demonstrates that energy transfer to stable modes is significant relative to energy transfer to smaller scales, modifying the usual understanding of instability saturation by a shower to minor scales. The psychoanalysis use approximation, hence it is instructive to consider a second, complemental form of approximate nonlinear psychoanalysis based on a three - wavenumber truncation of Eqs.    and. Such a calculation complements the $ P_t$ psychoanalysis because it makes different assumptions. The $ P_t$ analysis makes parametric instability approximation when considering the evolution of $ \beta_2 $ (c.f.   Eq.  ), but samples a broad continuum of wavenumbers. On the early hand, a three - wavenumber shortness makes no assumptions about the evolution of the modes, and instead limits the arrangement to only three wavenumbers that are evolved according to Eqs.    and. 

! [ Time development of $ |\beta_j(k, t)|$ for a three - wavenumber truncation with $ k=0.3, k'=0.9 $, and $ potassium - k'=-0.6$. As expected from the $ P_t$ analysis, the static mode decays linearly, then is nonlinearly pumped to an amplitude that is comparable to the unstable mode.[]{data - label="ThreeModePlot"}](Fig5.eps){width="16 cm " } 

 The consequence of a three - wavenumber truncation is plot
-wavf interactions require $k \neq k'$. When including xavenumger depevdence, these nonlinear terms wull ntbessarily grow at lesr than twpce the pwak jrowth rate. On tis other hand, abable nodes near $k=0$ csn be drivan by $D_1\beta_1\betd_1$ gexms where one of the driving modes if near $l=0.4$ wnd the other ys ntar $k=-0.4$. Tgls, our inclusion of the wavenumger deptndence of $\omega_j$ vauses $\beta_2$ to grow large fnouhh that Eq.  becomes invalid bedore waturation tkme. This makes the predise value of $P_t$ less meaningfuu, as che stable noees vave grown wo lagge that the approximdtions kade in obtainlng $P_v$ arw invalid. However, the size of $\beta_2$ relajive to $\beda_1$ and the comparaboe amplhtudas ow $C_2$ xnd $C_1$ ijply $P_h \gvrsim 1$, and fherefore $P_r \gtrsim 0.3$ is still eejo satisfied.

Ths abovq gonlinear analysis demonstrates that entrgy fransfer to stable modew is significant relajive to enqrgy transfer to smaller scales, modifying the usudl unvefstckqkbg of instability saturation by a cascade to smwml sbales. The analysif employs alpgocymations, hencg it is inatructive to consifer a sgcond, xomplemenuary gorm of approximate nonlineqr analysis yaswd on a three-wavenbmber truncacion og Eqs.  and. Such a calculation comllements thf $P_t$ analgris because it mxkex gifferenu assumptions. The $[_t$ analysms males parxmettic inseability aoproxlkations when consiferiny the evolution of $\beta_2$ (c.f. Eq. ), but samples a broev continuum og favvnumbers. Jn thc other hand, a ehree-wavenumbet truncatnon mayes no asslmptions ebout the evjlution of tha modes, and iistead liiits the system go only three eavenumbegs thar are evolved accovding fo Eqs.  and.

![Time zrooution of $|\beta_j(l,t)|$ wor a tiree-wweenumber trutcatkon eith $y=0.3, k'=0.9$, and $k-k'=-0.6$. Cs exprcted from the $P_t$ andlysjs, the stable mode dccays lingarly, theg is nonlineatly pumped to an alplitnde thet is vomkarable to the unstable mode.[]{datz-label="ThrfeMjdePlot"}](Fig5.epf){widbh="16cm"}

Jhe result pf a three-wavenumber truncation is plotved
-wave interactions require $k \neq k'$. When dependence, nonlinear terms necessarily grow at growth On the other stable modes near can be driven by $D_1\beta_1\beta_1$ terms one of the driving modes is near $k=0.4$ and the other is near Thus, our inclusion of the wavenumber dependence of $\omega_j$ causes $\beta_2$ to grow enough Eq. invalid saturation time. This makes the precise value of $P_t$ less meaningful, as the stable modes have so large that the approximations made in obtaining are invalid. However, the of $\beta_2$ relative to $\beta_1$ the amplitudes of and imply \gtrsim 1$, and $P_t \gtrsim 0.3$ is still well satisfied. The above nonlinear analysis demonstrates that energy transfer to stable is significant energy transfer smaller modifying usual understanding of by a cascade to small scales. approximations, hence it is instructive to consider a complementary form approximate nonlinear analysis based on a truncation of Eqs. and. Such a calculation complements $P_t$ analysis because it makes different assumptions. The $P_t$ analysis makes parametric instability approximations when evolution of $\beta_2$ (c.f. ), but samples broad of On other hand, three-wavenumber truncation makes no assumptions about the evolution of the modes, instead limits the system to only three wavenumbers that are to and. ![Time evolution $|\beta_j(k,t)|$ for a three-wavenumber with k'=0.9$, and $k-k'=-0.6$. As the analysis, decays then nonlinearly pumped to an that is comparable to the mode.[]{data-label="ThreeModePlot"}](Fig5.eps){width="16cm"} The result of
-wave interactions require $k \nEq k'$. When incLudinG waVenUmBer dEpenDence, these nonlINear Terms will necessarily grOw at lEsS Than TWiCe the Peak groWTh RATe. ON tHe OthEr HAnD, stabLe mOdes neaR $k=0$ can be driVen By $d_1\beta_1\beta_1$ terMS wHere one of tHe dRiving modes iS neAr $k=0.4$ and ThE otHEr is nEar $K=-0.4$. Thus, Our incLUsion oF the wavenUmBEr depeNDence of $\OMEgA_j$ caUses $\beta_2$ to grow larGE eNOugh that Eq.  becoMes invAlID bEFOre SatUration timE. THis maKEs the prECiSE VAluE Of $P_t$ less meaniNgful, as the sTAblE modes HaVe gROwn so lArge tHaT The ApproximatiOns mAde in obtaIning $P_T$ Are invaLId. HowevEr, the sIze Of $\bEta_2$ rELaTiVe tO $\bETa_1$ aND tHe cOMpaRable ampLiTuDes of $c_2$ and $c_1$ IMPLy $P_t \GtrSim 1$, aNd theRefore $P_t \gtrsiM 0.3$ is StilL WelL satiSfied.

the aBoVe nonLinear AnalySiS demonstrates thAt enErgy transFer To StaBlE modeS Is signIfiCanT relatiVe to eneRGy tRaNSFEr To smaller scales, modIfYINg The usual UndersTAnDiNG of instaBiLitY satURAtion By a cAScAde to smaLl scalES. THe AnalysiS eMploys ApProXimAtionS, HencE it is iNstructiVe to cONsider a second, cOMplementary foRM oF APpROximAte Nonlinear anAlysIS basEd on A ThRee-WAvenuMber tRuNCaTIon of Eqs.  and. Such a calCuLation ComplEments the $P_t$ anAlysis becaUSE It makes dIffeREnT Assumptions. The $p_t$ anaLysis makes PArametriC instAbility aPproximatIONs when coNsiDerIng The EVOlUtion of $\beta_2$ (c.f. eQ. ), But sAmPles a brOad ContinuUm oF waVenUmbErS. On the othEr hand, a tHrEe-WaVeNumBer trUNcation mAkEs nO aSsuMptioNS about The evOlutIoN oF The Modes, anD InSTEad lImItS the SysTeM to onLy thREe wAvenumbErs that arE evOLved AcCoRding to eqs.  and.

![Time evoLuTion of $|\beta_J(k,T)|$ foR a threE-WAvenumbeR truncation with $k=0.3, k'=0.9$, and $k-k'=-0.6$. AS ExpecteD frOm the $p_t$ anAlysis, the StaBle modE deCAys linEarly, tHen is NoNliNEArly pUMPeD to An Amplitude tHAT is CompaRaBle tO the unsTable mode.[]{data-label="tHreEModePlot"}](Fig5.ePs){wIdth="16CM"}

thE reSUlT Of a ThREe-wAVEnumber truncatiOn is plotteD
-wave interactions require  $k \neq k '$. W hen  in cl udin g wa venumber depen d ence , these nonlinear term s wil ln eces s ar ily g row atl es s tha ntw ice  t h epeakgro wth rat e. On theoth er  hand, stabl e  m odes near$k= 0$ can be dr ive n by $ D_ 1\b e ta_1\ bet a_1$termsw here o ne of the  d r ivingm odes is n ea r $k =0.4$ and the oth e ri s near $k=-0.4 $. Thu s, ou r inc lus ion of the  w avenu m ber dep e nd e n c e o f  $\omega_j$ c auses $\bet a _2$  to gr ow  la r ge eno ugh t ha t  Eq .  becomesinva lid befor e satu r ation t i me. Thi s make s t heprec i se  v alu eo f $ P _t $ l e ssmeaningf ul ,as th e st a b l e  mod eshave  grow n so large th atthea ppr oxima tions  mad ein ob tainin g $P_ t$  are invalid. H owev er, the s ize  o f $ \b eta_2 $  relat ive  to  $\beta _1$ and the  c o m p ar able amplitudes of  $ C _ 2$  and $C_ 1$ imp l y$P _ t \gtrsi m1$,  and t heref ore$ P_ t \gtrsi m 0.3$ is  s till we ll  satis fi ed. 

T he ab o ve n online ar analy sis d e monstrates tha t  energy trans f er t os tabl e m odes is sig nifi c antrela t iv e t o  ener gy tr an s fe r  to smaller scales,  m odifyi ng th e usual under standing o f i nstabili ty s a tu r ation by a cas cadeto small s c ales. Th e ana lysis em ploys app r o ximation s,hen ceiti s  i nstructive to c onsi de r a sec ond , compl eme nta ryfor mof approx imate no nl in ea rana lysis based on  a  th re e-w avenu m ber tr uncat ionof  E q s. and. S u ch a  cal cu la tion  co mp lemen ts t h e $ P_t$ an alysis be cau s e it  m ak es diff erent assumpt io ns. The $P _t $ a nalysi s makes pa rametric instability ap p roximat ion s whe n co nsidering  th e evol uti o n of $ \beta_ 2$ (c .f . E q .  ), b u t  s amp le s a broadc o nti nuumof  wav enumber s. On the other ha n d,a three-waven umb er t r u nc ati o nm ake sn o a s s umptions aboutthe evolut io n  o f the mode s , a nd  instea d limit s the systemto only t hree wave nu mber s tha t are evol ved acco rding toE qs. a nd .

![ Tim e evol ut ion  of $ |\beta _ j(k ,t)|$  for a  t hree-w avenu mb er trunc ation with $k=0.3, k'=0 .9$, a nd $k -k' =-0.6$. A s e x pec ted fromthe$P_t$ anal ysi s,the s tab l e mod e de c ay s l i nearl y, t h en is non l in ear l y  p umped to an a m pli tudetha t  is co mpar able to the unsta b le mode.[]{dat a-la b e l=" Thr e eMod eP lot"}](Fig5.ep s){ wi d t h="16cm" }
The result  of a th re e -wave number  trunc ation i s pl o tted
-wave interactions_require $k_\neq k'$. When including_wavenumber dependence,_these_nonlinear terms_will_necessarily grow at_less than twice_the peak growth rate._On the other_hand,_stable modes near $k=0$ can be driven by $D_1\beta_1\beta_1$ terms where one of the_driving_modes is_near_$k=0.4$_and the other is near_$k=-0.4$. Thus, our inclusion of_the wavenumber_dependence of $\omega_j$ causes $\beta_2$ to grow large_enough_that Eq.  becomes_invalid before saturation time. This makes the precise value_of $P_t$ less meaningful, as the_stable modes have_grown_so_large that the approximations_made in obtaining $P_t$ are invalid._However, the size of $\beta_2$ relative_to $\beta_1$ and the comparable amplitudes of_$C_2$ and $C_1$ imply $P_t \gtrsim_1$, and therefore $P_t \gtrsim_0.3$ is_still well satisfied.

The above nonlinear_analysis demonstrates that_energy transfer_to stable modes_is significant relative to energy transfer_to smaller scales,_modifying the usual understanding of instability_saturation_by a cascade_to_small_scales. The_analysis employs approximations,_hence_it is_instructive_to consider a second, complementary form_of_approximate nonlinear analysis based on a three-wavenumber_truncation of Eqs.  and._Such_a calculation complements the_$P_t$ analysis because it makes_different assumptions. The $P_t$ analysis makes_parametric instability_approximations when_considering the evolution of $\beta_2$ (c.f. Eq. ), but samples a broad continuum_of wavenumbers. On the other hand,_a three-wavenumber truncation makes_no assumptions_about_the evolution of_the_modes, and_instead limits the system to only three_wavenumbers that_are evolved according to Eqs.  and.

![Time_evolution of $|\beta_j(k,t)|$ for_a_three-wavenumber truncation with $k=0.3, k'=0.9$, and_$k-k'=-0.6$. As expected from the $P_t$_analysis, the stable mode decays_linearly,_then_is nonlinearly pumped to an_amplitude that is comparable to the_unstable mode.[]{data-label="ThreeModePlot"}](Fig5.eps){width="16cm"}

The result_of a three-wavenumber truncation is plotted