 boundaries are indicated by the vertical dashed lines in \[fig:means\]. [Between these regions, there exists an intermediate region of the mean velocity profile in which both scalings hold. In this overlap region, it is widely accepted that the mean varies logarithmically with distance from the wall.]{} Classical estimates put the beginning of the logarithmic region at $y^+=O(100)$. However, there is recent evidence that this lower boundary moves outward as $\Rey^{1/2}$ [@klewicki2009; @marusic2013]. In the logarithmic region, the resolvent operator admits self-similar modes localized about their critical layers [@moarref2013]. [Furthermore, the scaling of these modes reduces to the inner and outer scalings when $y^+$ or $y$, respectively, is held fixed, reflecting their mutual validity in the logarithmic region.]{}

![(a) Mean velocity profile $U(y^+)$ and (b) velocity defect $U_{cl}-U(y)$ for $\Rey=934$ (blue), $\Rey=2003$ (red), and $\Rey=4219$ (green). The gray boxes indicate the regions where the profiles are $\Rey$-invariant in the respective coordinates. \[fig:means\]](means.pdf){width="70.00000%"}

In each of the next subsections, we briefly summarize the scaling of the wave parameters for each of the three aforementioned universal classes derived by @moarref2013, as well as the distinct scalings for the OS and SQ singular values. Finally, the relative scaling of the OS and SQ weights are presented and tested against the computed optimal weights.

\[sec:inner\]Inner class
------------------------

Following @moarref2013, the relevant length scale for the inner class is the viscous unit $\nu/u_\tau$, so that the corresponding inner-scaled parameters are $$k_x^+ = \Rey^{-1}k_x, \quad k_z^+ = \Rey^{-1}k_z, \quad y^+ = \Rey y,
\label{eq:li}$$ and the inner class wave parameters are $$\mathscr{S}_i: \quad 0 \leq c \lesssim 16.4.
\label{eq:Si}$$ The upper wavespeed limit is obtained from the critical layer at the top of the inner region, i.e., $U(y^+=100)=16.4$; this
boundaries are indicated by the vertical dashed occupation in \[fig: means\ ]. [ Between these region, there exists an intermediate region of the hateful velocity profile in which both scale detention. In this overlap area, it is wide accepted that the mean varies logarithmically with distance from the rampart. ] { } Classical estimates invest the beginning of the logarithmic area at $ y^+=O(100)$. However, there is recent evidence that this low boundary moves outward as $ \Rey^{1/2}$ [ @klewicki2009; @marusic2013 ]. In the logarithmic region, the solvent operator admits self - similar mode localized about their critical layers [ @moarref2013 ]. [ Furthermore, the scaling of these mode reduces to the inside and outer scaling when $ y^+$ or $ y$, respectively, is held fixed, reflecting their reciprocal validity in the logarithmic region. ] { } 

! [ (a) Mean velocity profile $ U(y^+)$ and (b) velocity defect $ U_{cl}-U(y)$ for $ \Rey=934 $ (aristocratic), $ \Rey=2003 $ (red), and $ \Rey=4219 $ (green). The gray boxes indicate the regions where the profiles are $ \Rey$-invariant in the respective coordinates. \[fig: means\]](means.pdf){width="70.00000% " } 

 In each of the next subsections, we concisely sum up the scaling of the wave parameters for each of the three aforementioned universal classes derive by @moarref2013, as well as the distinct scalings for the OS and SQ remarkable values. Finally, the relative scaling of the OS and SQ weights are give and tested against the computed optimal weights. 

 \[sec: inner\]Inner class 
 ------------------------ 

 Following @moarref2013, the relevant length plate for the inner class is the viscous unit $ \nu / u_\tau$, so that the corresponding inner - scaled parameter are $ $ k_x^+ = \Rey^{-1}k_x, \quad k_z^+ = \Rey^{-1}k_z, \quad y^+ = \Rey y, 
 \label{eq: li}$$ and the inner class wave parameters are $ $ \mathscr{S}_i: \quad 0 \leq c \lesssim 16.4. 
 \label{eq: Si}$$ The upper wavespeed limit is prevail from the critical layer at the top of the inner area, i.e., $ U(y^+=100)=16.4 $; this
 bokndaries are indicated bn the vertical dcwhed lmnes in \[fig:meanr\]. [Between these regions, therx exusts qn intermediate region of the mvan velocuty krofile in which ukth scalings glld. Nn this overlap tegion, it is widely acceptad tkat the mean varies logarithmically rith dixtwnce from the rall.]{} Slasapccl estimates put the beginning kf the nogarithmic rrgion at $y^+=O(100)$. However, there ls rfcent evidence thah this lowet botbdary moves uutward as $\Rey^{1/2}$ [@klewickj2009; @marusic2013]. In the logarithmic reeion, che resolvebt opftator admits self-fimilar modes localised aboit their critigal leyerw [@moarref2013]. [Furthermore, the scaling of thgse modes sebuces to the inner ane iuter scaningr whdn $g^+$ pr $y$, resoecvively, is hsld fixed, rwflecting their mutiaj validity in fhe lodawithmic region.]{}

![(a) Mean velocity profile $U(j^+)$ ans (b) velocity defect $U_{cl}-Y(y)$ for $\Rey=934$ (blue), $\Rey=2003$ (rgd), and $\Rey=4219$ (green). The gray boxes indicate the regions where dhe pcowilts are $\Fwy$-lnvariant in the respective coordinates. \[fig:mewhs\]](kesns.pdf){width="70.00000%"}

In cach of the next sibdevjions, we briefuy summarjze the scaling of the wade paeameters sor rach of the three aforementuoned univerfql classes derived by @moarref2013, as eell ss the distinct scalingr fod the OS anf SQ singhuar values. Finaluy, nhe selative scaling of the OS and SQ wxightx are pfesemted agd tested wgainst the computed optlmal ceighds.

\[sec:inner\]Lnner class
------------------------

Following @moarref2013, thx relevant lemgdh vcale fox the lnner class is ehe viscous unnt $\nu/u_\tab$, so tfat the cogrespondiig inner-scalqd parameters wre $$k_x^+ = \Rey^{-1}k_e, \quad k_z^+ = \Ret^{-1}k_z, \wuad y^+ = \Fey y,
\label{eq:li}$$ and the pnuer class wave parameters ave $$\majhacr{S}_i: \quad 0 \leq c \oesssim 16.4.
\label{eq:Xi}$$ Ghe uipec wavqvpeed limit hs octakmed ffom the cribicxl lsyer at the top of tve ihner region, i.e., $U(y^+=100)=16.4$; yhls
boundaries are indicated by the vertical dashed \[fig:means\]. these regions, exists an intermediate profile which both scalings In this overlap it is widely accepted that the varies logarithmically with distance from the wall.]{} Classical estimates put the beginning of logarithmic region at $y^+=O(100)$. However, there is recent evidence that this lower boundary outward $\Rey^{1/2}$ @marusic2013]. the logarithmic region, the resolvent operator admits self-similar modes localized about their critical layers [@moarref2013]. [Furthermore, scaling of these modes reduces to the inner outer scalings when $y^+$ $y$, respectively, is held fixed, their validity in logarithmic ![(a) velocity profile $U(y^+)$ (b) velocity defect $U_{cl}-U(y)$ for $\Rey=934$ (blue), $\Rey=2003$ (red), and $\Rey=4219$ (green). The gray boxes indicate the where the $\Rey$-invariant in respective \[fig:means\]](means.pdf){width="70.00000%"} each of the we briefly summarize the scaling of for each of the three aforementioned universal classes by @moarref2013, well as the distinct scalings for OS and SQ singular values. Finally, the relative of the OS and SQ weights are presented and tested against the computed optimal weights. ------------------------ Following @moarref2013, the length scale for inner is viscous $\nu/u_\tau$, so the corresponding inner-scaled parameters are $$k_x^+ = \Rey^{-1}k_x, \quad k_z^+ = \quad y^+ = \Rey y, \label{eq:li}$$ and the inner class are \quad 0 \leq \lesssim 16.4. \label{eq:Si}$$ The wavespeed is obtained from the at top region, $U(y^+=100)=16.4$;
 boundaries are indicated by tHe vertical DasheD liNes In \[Fig:mEans\]. [between these reGIons, There exists an intermediAte reGiON of tHE mEan veLocity pROfILE in WhIcH boTh SCaLings HolD. In this Overlap regIon, It Is widely accePTeD that the meAn vAries logaritHmiCally wItH diSTance FroM the wAll.]{} ClaSSical eStimates pUt THe begiNNing of tHE LoGariThmic region at $y^+=O(100)$. HoWEvER, there is recent EvidenCe THaT THis LowEr boundary MoVes ouTWard as $\REY^{1/2}$ [@kLEWIckI2009; @Marusic2013]. In the lOgarithmic rEGioN, the reSoLveNT operaTor adMiTS seLf-similar moDes lOcalized aBout thEIr critiCAl layerS [@moarrEf2013]. [FUrtHermORe, ThE scAlINg oF ThEse MOdeS reduces To ThE inneR and OUTER scaLinGs whEn $y^+$ or $Y$, respectively, Is hEld fIXed, RefleCting TheiR mUtual ValidiTy in tHe Logarithmic regiOn.]{}

![(a) MEan velociTy pRoFilE $U(Y^+)$ and (b) VElocitY deFecT $U_{cl}-U(y)$ fOr $\Rey=934$ (blUE), $\ReY=2003$ (rED), ANd $\rey=4219$ (green). The gray boxEs INDiCate the rEgions WHeRe THe profilEs Are $\rey$-iNVArianT in tHE rEspectivE coordINaTeS. \[fig:meaNs\]](Means.pDf){WidTh="70.00000%"}

IN each OF the Next suBsectionS, we brIEfly summarize tHE scaling of the WAvE PArAMeteRs fOr each of the ThreE AforEmenTIoNed UNiverSal clAsSEs DErived by @moarref2013, as weLl As the dIstinCt scalings for The OS and SQ SINGular valUes. FINaLLy, the relative sCalinG of the OS anD sQ weightS are pResented And tested AGAinst the ComPutEd oPtiMAL wEights.

\[sec:inneR\]iNner ClAss
------------------------

FollOwiNg @moarrEf2013, tHe rEleVanT lEngth scalE for the iNnEr ClAsS is The viSCous unit $\Nu/U_\taU$, sO thAt the COrrespOndinG innEr-ScALed ParametERs ARE $$k_x^+ = \REy^{-1}K_x, \Quad K_z^+ = \REy^{-1}K_z, \quaD y^+ = \ReY Y,
\laBel{eq:li}$$ And the innEr cLAss wAvE pArameteRs are $$\mathscr{S}_I: \qUad 0 \leq c \lesSsIm 16.4.
\lAbel{eq:sI}$$ the upper Wavespeed limit is obtaineD From the CriTical LayeR at the top Of tHe inneR reGIon, i.e., $U(Y^+=100)=16.4$; this
 boundaries are indicatedby the ver tical  da she dline s in  \[fig:means\] .  [Be tween these regions, t hereex i stsa ninter mediate re g i onof  t heme a nveloc ity  profil e in which  bo th  scalings ho l d.  In this o ver lap region,itis wid el y a c cepte d t hat t he mea n  varie s logarit hm i callyw ith dis t a nc e fr om the wall.]{} C l as s ical estimates  put t he be g i nni ngof the log ar ithmi c  region at $ y ^+= O (100)$. Howev er, there i s  re cent e vi den c e that  this  l o wer  boundary m oves  outwardas $\R e y^{1/2} $  [@klew icki20 09;  @m arus i c2 01 3].  I n  th e  l oga r ith mic regi on ,the r esol v e n t  ope rat or a dmits  self-similar  mo desl oca lized  abou t th ei r cri ticallayer s[@moarref2013].  [Fu rthermore , t he  sc al ing o f  these  mo des  reduce s to th e  in ne r a nd  outer scalings wh en $ y^ +$ or $y $, res p ec ti v ely, ishe ldfixe d ,  refl ecti n gtheir mu tual v a li di ty in t he  logar it hmi c r egion . ]{}
![(a)  Mean ve locit y  profile $U(y^ + )$ and (b) ve l oc i t yd efec t $ U_{cl}-U(y) $ fo r  $\R ey=9 3 4$  (b l ue),$\Rey =2 0 03 $  (red), and $\Rey=4 21 9$ (gr een).  The gray box es indicat e t he regio ns w h er e  the profilesare $ \Rey$-inva r iant inthe r espectiv e coordin a t es. \[fi g:m ean s\] ](m e a ns .pdf){width=" 7 0 .000 00 %"}

In  ea ch of t henex t s ubs ec tions, we  briefly  s um ma ri zethe s c aling of  t hewa veparam e ters f or ea ch o fth e  th ree afo r em e n tion ed  u nive rsa lclass es d e riv ed by @ moarref20 13, as w el las thedistinct scal in gs for the  O S a nd SQs i ngular v alues. Finally, the rel a tive sc ali ng of  the  OS and S Q w eights  ar e  prese nted a nd te st eda g ainst t he  co mp uted optim a l  we ights .
\[s ec:inne r\]Inner class
--- - --- ------------- --- -

F o l lo win g  @ m oar re f 201 3 ,  the relevant l ength scal ef or  the inner cla ss  is the  viscou s uni t  $\nu/u _\tau$, s o that th ecorr e s pon ding inner -scaledparameter s  are$ $k _x^+= \ Rey^{- 1} k_x , \qu ad k_z ^ + =  \Rey ^{-1}k _z , \qua d y^+  =  \Rey y, 
\label{eq:li}$$ and th e inne r cla sswave para met e rsare $$\ma thsc r{S}_i: \q uad  0\leqc \ l esssi m 16 . 4. 
\l a bel{e q:Si } $$ The up p er  wa v e sp eed limit i s o bta inedfro m  the c riti cal layer at thet op of the inne r re g i on,  i. e ., $ U( y^+=100)=16.4$ ; t hi s 
 boundaries_are indicated_by the vertical dashed_lines in_\[fig:means\]._[Between these_regions,_there exists an_intermediate region of_the mean velocity profile_in which both_scalings_hold. In this overlap region, it is widely accepted that the mean varies logarithmically_with_distance from_the_wall.]{}_Classical estimates put the beginning_of the logarithmic region at_$y^+=O(100)$. However,_there is recent evidence that this lower boundary_moves_outward as $\Rey^{1/2}$_[@klewicki2009; @marusic2013]. In the logarithmic region, the resolvent operator_admits self-similar modes localized about their_critical layers [@moarref2013]._[Furthermore,_the_scaling of these modes_reduces to the inner and outer_scalings when $y^+$ or $y$, respectively,_is held fixed, reflecting their mutual validity_in the logarithmic region.]{}

![(a) Mean velocity_profile $U(y^+)$ and (b) velocity_defect $U_{cl}-U(y)$_for $\Rey=934$ (blue), $\Rey=2003$ (red),_and $\Rey=4219$ (green)._The gray_boxes indicate the_regions where the profiles are $\Rey$-invariant_in the respective_coordinates. \[fig:means\]](means.pdf){width="70.00000%"}

In each of the next_subsections,_we briefly summarize_the_scaling_of the_wave parameters for_each_of the_three_aforementioned universal classes derived by @moarref2013,_as_well as the distinct scalings for the_OS and SQ singular_values._Finally, the relative scaling_of the OS and SQ_weights are presented and tested against_the computed_optimal weights.

\[sec:inner\]Inner_class
------------------------

Following @moarref2013, the relevant length scale for the inner class is_the viscous unit $\nu/u_\tau$, so that_the corresponding inner-scaled parameters_are $$k_x^+_=_\Rey^{-1}k_x, \quad k_z^+_=_\Rey^{-1}k_z, \quad_y^+ = \Rey y,
\label{eq:li}$$ and the inner_class wave_parameters are $$\mathscr{S}_i: \quad 0 \leq_c \lesssim 16.4.
\label{eq:Si}$$ The_upper_wavespeed limit is obtained from the_critical layer at the top of_the inner region, i.e., $U(y^+=100)=16.4$;_this