ist strategy is proved in [@Thanassoulis:2004uy] to involve probabilistic bundles, but it is not identified. Our numerical experiments suggest that it has the form $$U(x,y) := \max \{0, \, x+y/2-1, \, x/2+y-1, \, x+y-b\},$$ which involves the lottery tickets $(1,1/2)$ and $(1/2,1)$. Under this assumption, the optimal value $b=1+1/(3\sqrt 2)$ is easily computed.

Numerous qualitative questions remain open. Is there a distribution of customers for which the optimal strategy involves a continuum of distinct lottery tickets $\{(1,\alpha);\, \alpha_0\leq \alpha \leq \alpha_1\}$?

  ![Three dimensional plot of the optimal $U$ for the product-bundles variant of the monopolist problem, with respect to various customer distributions. Left : uniform distribution on $[0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon.[]{data-label="fig:Bundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/PALinear_3D_100_Square.png "fig:"){width="3cm"}  ![Three dimensional plot of the optimal $U$ for the product-bundles variant of the monopolist problem, with respect to various customer distributions. Left : uniform distribution on $[0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon.[]{data-label="fig:Bundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/TriangleDensityHalf.pdf "fig:"){width="2cm"}  ![Three dimensional plot of the optimal $U$ for the product-bundles variant of the monopolist problem, with respect to various customer distributions. Left : uniform distribution on $[0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon.[]{data-label="fig:Bundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/PALinear_3D_100_Triangle.png "fig:"){width="2.5cm"}  ![Three dimensional plot of the optimal $U$ for the product-bundles variant of the monopolist problem, with respect to various customer distributions. Left : uniform distribution on $[0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon
ist strategy is proved in [ @Thanassoulis:2004uy ] to involve probabilistic bundles, but it is not identify. Our numeric experiments suggest that it has the shape $ $ U(x, y): = \max \{0, \, x+y/2 - 1, \, x/2+y-1, \, x+y - b\},$$ which involves the lottery tickets $ (1,1/2)$ and $ (1/2,1)$. Under this presumption, the optimum value $ b=1 + 1/(3\sqrt 2)$ is easily computed. 

 Numerous qualitative questions remain open. Is there a distribution of customer for which the optimal strategy involves a continuum of distinct lottery slate $ \{(1,\alpha);\, \alpha_0\leq \alpha \leq \alpha_1\}$? 

  ! [ Three dimensional plot of the optimal $ U$ for the merchandise - bundles variant of the monopolist trouble, with respect to various customer distributions. Left: undifferentiated distribution on $ [ 0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon.[]{data - label="fig: Bundles"}](\pathPic / Convex / PrincipalAgentLinear / PALinear_3D_100_Square.png " fig:"){width="3 cm " }  ! [ Three dimensional plot of the optimum $ U$ for the product - bundle variant of the monopolist trouble, with respect to various customer distributions. Left: uniform distribution on $ [ 0,1]^2$. Center, and correct: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon.[]{data - label="fig: Bundles"}](\pathPic / Convex / PrincipalAgentLinear / TriangleDensityHalf.pdf " fig:"){width="2 cm " }  ! [ Three dimensional plot of the optimal $ U$ for the product - bundles random variable of the monopolist problem, with respect to various customer distributions. Left: uniform distribution on $ [ 0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon.[]{data - label="fig: Bundles"}](\pathPic / Convex / PrincipalAgentLinear / PALinear_3D_100_Triangle.png " fig:"){width="2.5 cm " }  ! [ Three dimensional plot of the optimal $ U$ for the product - bundles discrepancy of the monopolist problem, with respect to versatile customer distribution. Left: uniform distribution on $ [ 0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black polygon
ist strategy is proved in [@Tmanassoulis:2004uy] to involvx probagilistic bundles, but it is not identmfiee. Our numerical experiments suggest nhat it hqs tie form $$U(x,y) := \max \{0, \, x+y/2-1, \, x/2+n-1, \, x+y-g\},$$ whieh involves the kottery tiwkets $(1,1/2)$ and $(1/2,1)$. Ungef chis assumption, the optimal value $b=1+1/(3\szrt 2)$ is ewsily computed.

Gumegots qhalitative questions remain open. Ia there a distributipn of customers for which hhe lptimal strategy ijvolves a cintigyum of distivct lotterj tickets $\{(1,\ampha);\, \alpha_0\leq \alpha \leq \alpha_1\}$?

  ![Ghree dimensionql pllj of the optmmal $U$ for the product-bundnes varoant of the mokopolmst problem, with respect vo various customer qistributhous. Left : uniform disteivutiot on $[0,1]^2$. Cevrer, ans ciggt: dishriuution unifkrm on the ullustrated black pplrton.[]{data-label="fjg:Bundjef"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/PALintar_3D_100_Ssuare.png "fig:"){width="3cm"}  ![Theee dimensional plot lf the opeimal $U$ for the product-bundles variant of the monmpoliag pxiblem, qihh respect to various customer distributions. Jsfu : lniform distributlon on $[0,1]^2$. Center, and rlgnj: distribution unifoxj kn the illustrated black kolygob.[]{data-labej="fig:Nundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipqlAgentLineag/TriqngleDensityHalf.pdy "fig:"){width="2cm"}  ![Thtee dikensional plot of the o'timal $U$ for the oroduct-buhales variant of ghe mmnopolisu problem, with res[ect to verioux custooer cistrifutions. Levt : ukhform distribution on $[0,1]^2$. Eentes, and righh: distribution uniform on the illustrated blavk ponygon.[]{datc-label="nig:Bundles"}](\pathPyc/Convex/PrincikalAgentLnnear/PXLinear_3D_100_Trpangle.png "fig:"){width="2.5cm"}  ![Three dimenvlonal plot oh the optymal $U$ fir the ofoduct-bundles fariant oy the monopolist problek, wkfh respect to vcxiius customer dixtrkbueilnx. Jaft : uniform disgricition on $[0,1]^2$. Center, xnd tight: distribution utifodm on the illustrayeq black kolygon
ist strategy is proved in [@Thanassoulis:2004uy] to bundles, it is identified. Our numerical the $$U(x,y) := \max \, x+y/2-1, \, \, x+y-b\},$$ which involves the lottery $(1,1/2)$ and $(1/2,1)$. Under this assumption, the optimal value $b=1+1/(3\sqrt 2)$ is easily Numerous qualitative questions remain open. Is there a distribution of customers for which optimal involves continuum distinct lottery tickets $\{(1,\alpha);\, \alpha_0\leq \alpha \leq \alpha_1\}$? ![Three dimensional plot of the optimal $U$ for product-bundles variant of the monopolist problem, with respect various customer distributions. Left uniform distribution on $[0,1]^2$. Center, right: uniform on illustrated polygon.[]{data-label="fig:Bundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/PALinear_3D_100_Square.png ![Three dimensional plot the optimal $U$ for the product-bundles variant of the monopolist problem, with respect to various customer distributions. : uniform $[0,1]^2$. Center, right: uniform the illustrated black ![Three dimensional plot of the optimal product-bundles variant of the monopolist problem, with respect various customer Left : uniform distribution on $[0,1]^2$. and right: distribution uniform on the illustrated black "fig:"){width="2.5cm"} ![Three dimensional plot of the optimal $U$ for the product-bundles variant of the monopolist respect to various customer Left : uniform on Center, right: uniform on illustrated black polygon
ist strategy is proved in [@ThanAssoulis:2004uy] To invOlvE prObAbilIstiC bundles, but it iS Not iDentified. Our numerical eXperiMeNTs suGGeSt thaT it has tHE fORM $$U(x,Y) := \mAx \{0, \, X+y/2-1, \, x/2+Y-1, \, x+Y-B\},$$ wHich iNvoLves the Lottery ticKetS $(1,1/2)$ aNd $(1/2,1)$. Under this aSSuMption, the oPtiMal value $b=1+1/(3\sqrT 2)$ is Easily CoMpuTEd.

NumEroUs quaLitatiVE questIons remaiN oPEn. Is thERe a distRIBuTion Of customers for whiCH tHE optimal strateGy invoLvES a CONtiNuuM of distincT lOtterY Tickets $\{(1,\ALpHA);\, \ALphA_0\Leq \alpha \leq \alPha_1\}$?

  ![Three dimENsiOnal plOt Of tHE optimAl $U$ foR tHE prOduct-bundleS varIant of the MonopoLIst probLEm, with rEspect To vAriOus cUStOmEr dIsTRibUTiOns. lEft : Uniform dIsTrIbutiOn on $[0,1]^2$. cENTEr, anD riGht: dIstriBution uniform On tHe ilLUstRated Black PolyGoN.[]{data-Label="fIg:BunDlEs"}](\pathPic/Convex/prinCipalAgenTLiNeAr/PaLInear_3d_100_square.Png "Fig:"){Width="3cm"}  ![three diMEnsIoNAL PlOt of the optimal $U$ for ThE PRoDuct-bundLes varIAnT oF The monopOlIst ProbLEM, with RespECt To variouS custoMEr DiStributIoNs. Left : UnIfoRm dIstriBUtioN on $[0,1]^2$. CenTer, and riGht: diSTribution unifoRM on the illustrATeD BLaCK polYgoN.[]{data-label="fIg:BuNDles"}](\PathpIc/conVEx/PriNcipaLAGEnTlinear/TriangleDensiTyhalf.pdF "fig:"){wIdth="2cm"}  ![Three diMensional pLOT Of the optImal $u$ FoR The product-bundLes vaRiant of the MOnopolisT probLem, with rEspect to vARIous custOmeR diStrIbuTIOnS. Left : uniform dISTribUtIon on $[0,1]^2$. CeNteR, and rigHt: dIstRibUtiOn Uniform on The illusTrAtEd BlAck PolygON.[]{data-labEl="Fig:buNdlEs"}](\patHpic/ConVex/PrInciPaLAGEntlinear/PaliNEAr_3D_100_TRiAnGle.pNg "fIg:"){Width="2.5Cm"}  ![ThREe dImensioNal plot of The OPtimAl $u$ fOr the prOduct-bundles vArIant of the mOnOpoList prOBLem, with rEspect to various customer DIstribuTioNs. LefT : uniForm distrIbuTion on $[0,1]^2$. cenTEr, and rIght: diStribUtIon UNIform ON ThE ilLuStrated blaCK PolYgon
ist strategy is proved in[@Thanasso ulis: 200 4uy ]to i nvol ve probabilist i c bu ndles, but it is not i denti fi e d. O u rnumer ical ex p er i m ent ssu gge st th at it  ha s the f orm $$U(x, y):=  \max \{0, \ ,  x +y/2-1, \,  x/ 2+y-1, \, x+ y-b \},$$wh ich invol ves  thelotter y  ticke ts $(1,1/ 2) $  and $ ( 1/2,1)$ . Un derthis assumption,t he optimal value$b=1+1 /( 3 \s q r t 2 )$is easilyco mpute d .

Nume r ou s q ual i tative questi ons remaino pen . Is t he rea  distr ibuti on ofcustomers f or w hich theoptima l  strate g y invol ves acon tin uumo fdi sti nc t  lo t te ryt ick ets $\{( 1, \a lpha) ;\,\ a l p ha_0 \le q \a lpha\leq \alpha_1 \}$ ?

![T hreedimen sion al  plot  of th e opt im al $U$ for theprod uct-bundl esva ria nt  of t h e mono pol ist  proble m, with res pe c t to  various customerdi s t ri butions.  Left:  u ni f orm dist ri but iono n  $[0, 1]^2 $ .Center,and ri g ht :distrib ut ion un if orm  on  thei llus trated  black p olygo n .[]{data-label = "fig:Bundles" } ]( \ p at h Pic/ Con vex/Princip alAg e ntLi near / PA Lin e ar_3D _100_ Sq u ar e .png "fig:"){width= "3 cm"} ![Thr ee dimensiona l plot oft h e  optimal  $U$ fo r  the product-b undle s varianto f the mo nopol ist prob lem, with r espect t o v ari ous  cu s t om er distributi o n s. L ef t : uni for m distr ibu tio n o n $ [0 ,1]^2$. C enter, a nd  r ig ht : d istri b ution un if orm  o n t he il l ustrat ed bl ackpo ly g on. []{data - la b e l="f ig :B undl es" }] (\pat hPic / Con vex/Pri ncipalAge ntL i near /T ri angleDe nsityHalf.pdf  " fig:"){wid th ="2 cm"} ! [ Three di mensional plot of the o p timal $ U$for t he p roduct-bu ndl es var ian t  of th e mono polis tpro b l em, w i t hres pe ct to vari o u s c ustom er  dis tributi ons. Left : unifor m  di stribution on  $[ 0,1] ^ 2 $.  Ce n te r , a nd rig h t : distributionuniform on  t h eillustrate d  bl ac k polyg on.[]{d ata-l a bel="fi g:Bundles "}](\path Pi c/Co n v ex/ PrincipalA gentLine ar/PALine a r_3D_ 1 00 _Tria ngl e.png"f ig: "){wi dth="2 . 5cm "}  ! [Three  d imensi onalpl ot of th e optimal $U$ for the p roduct -bund les  variantoft hemonopolis t pr oblem, wit h r esp ect t o v a rious  cus t om erd istri buti o ns. Left:  u nif o r mdistributio n o n $ [0,1] ^2$ .  Cente r, a nd right: distrib u tion uniform o n th e ill ust r ated  b lack polygon
ist strategy_is proved_in [@Thanassoulis:2004uy] to involve_probabilistic bundles,_but_it is_not_identified. Our numerical_experiments suggest that_it has the form_$$U(x,y) := \max_\{0,_\, x+y/2-1, \, x/2+y-1, \, x+y-b\},$$ which involves the lottery tickets $(1,1/2)$ and $(1/2,1)$._Under_this assumption,_the_optimal_value $b=1+1/(3\sqrt 2)$ is easily_computed.

Numerous qualitative questions remain open._Is there_a distribution of customers for which the optimal_strategy_involves a continuum_of distinct lottery tickets $\{(1,\alpha);\, \alpha_0\leq \alpha \leq \alpha_1\}$?

_ ![Three dimensional plot of the_optimal $U$ for_the_product-bundles_variant of the monopolist_problem, with respect to various customer_distributions. Left : uniform distribution on_$[0,1]^2$. Center, and right: distribution uniform on_the illustrated black polygon.[]{data-label="fig:Bundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/PALinear_3D_100_Square.png "fig:"){width="3cm"} _![Three dimensional plot of the_optimal $U$_for the product-bundles variant of_the monopolist problem,_with respect_to various customer_distributions. Left : uniform distribution on_$[0,1]^2$. Center, and_right: distribution uniform on the illustrated_black_polygon.[]{data-label="fig:Bundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/TriangleDensityHalf.pdf "fig:"){width="2cm"} _![Three_dimensional_plot of_the optimal $U$_for_the product-bundles_variant_of the monopolist problem, with respect_to_various customer distributions. Left : uniform distribution_on $[0,1]^2$. Center, and_right:_distribution uniform on the_illustrated black polygon.[]{data-label="fig:Bundles"}](\pathPic/Convex/PrincipalAgentLinear/PALinear_3D_100_Triangle.png "fig:"){width="2.5cm"} _![Three dimensional plot of the optimal_$U$ for_the product-bundles_variant of the monopolist problem, with respect to various customer distributions._Left : uniform distribution on $[0,1]^2$._Center, and right: distribution_uniform on_the_illustrated black polygon