 that have already been introduced unless he is forced to use a new color. Of course, $\chi_g^{\infty*}(G) \leq \chi_g^{\infty}(G)$. $K_3$ is an example where $\chi_g^{\infty*}(G) < 2\chi_g^*(G)$ and $P_4$ is an example where $\chi_g^{\infty*}(P_4) = 4 = 2\chi_g^*(P_4)$. We shall consider stars again and begin by noting that $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 3})=3$ and $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 4})=4$. Interestingly, we shall see in next result that it may take Bob several rounds to force the number of colors needed. The next result is also a good example of the power Bob gets when the number of vertices is odd.

Then (a) if $n$ is odd then $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n})=3$ and (b) if $n \geq 4$ is even then $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n}) =  \frac{n}{2}+2$.

\[Note: does this proof need work?\]

[*Proof:*]{} Part (a) is easy to see, noting that Alice can choose the center vertex of the star on the first turn in each round, coloring it with the smallest color possible. For part(b), note that two colors are used in round 1. Bob can then force colors 3 and 4 to be used during round 2: he does so by choosing a leaf on his first turn and the center vertex on his second turn. Subsequent to that, for the next several rounds, Bob can force an additional color to be used on either each round or every other round by coloring the leaves with as many different colors as possible during each round, eventually forcing the center vertex to use a new color – it may need to wait until a round in which Bob goes first for each new color to be introduced (as in round 2). Bob can eventually force the use of $\frac{n}{2}$ different colors on the leaves, once that many colors have brought into play. At which point the game is the same as the A-game and thus the result follows as in Theorem \[lb\]. $\Box$

One could also consider a more restrictive version of this game in which Bob
that have already been introduced unless he is forced to use a new semblance. Of naturally, $ \chi_g^{\infty*}(G) \leq \chi_g^{\infty}(G)$. $ K_3 $ is an example where $ \chi_g^{\infty*}(G) < 2\chi_g^*(G)$ and $ P_4 $ is an example where $ \chi_g^{\infty*}(P_4) = 4 = 2\chi_g^*(P_4)$. We shall think ace again and begin by noting that $ \chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 3})=3 $ and $ \chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 4})=4$. Interestingly, we shall experience in adjacent result that it may take Bob several rounds to wedge the number of colors want. The future result is also a good example of the power Bob get when the number of vertices is odd. 

 Then (a) if $ n$ is leftover then $ \chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n})=3 $ and (b) if $ n \geq 4 $ is even then $ \chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n }) =   \frac{n}{2}+2$. 

 \[Note: does this proof need work?\ ] 

 [ * Proof :* ] { } Part (a) is easy to understand, noting that Alice can choose the center vertex of the star on the first turn in each beat, coloring it with the smallest color possible. For part(b), note that two color are used in round 1. Bob can then force colors 3 and 4 to be used during round 2: he does so by choosing a leaf on his first bend and the center vertex on his second turn. Subsequent to that, for the future several rounds, Bob can force an additional semblance to be used on either each round or every other round by discolor the leaves with as many different colors as possible during each circle, eventually forcing the center vertex to use a newfangled color – it may necessitate to wait until a round in which Bob goes first for each new semblance to be introduced (as in round 2). Bob can eventually push the use of $ \frac{n}{2}$ different colors on the leaves, once that many color have brought into looseness. At which point the game is the like as the A - game and thus the result follow as in Theorem \[lb\ ]. $ \Box$ 

 One could also consider a more restrictive version of this game in which Bob
 thwt have already been intvoduced unless hg us forred to hse a ned color. Of course, $\chi_g^{\infty*}(G) \lwq \chu_g^{\infty}(G)$. $K_3$ is an exampue where $\bhi_g^{\infty*}(T) < 2\cii_g^*(G)$ and $P_4$ is an example where $\ghi_g^{\iufvy*}(P_4) = 4 = 2\chi_g^*(P_4)$. We shall convider stars agdiv cnd begin by noting that $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 3})=3$ and $\cho_g^{\lnfty*}(K_{1, 4})=4$. Intereftinbjy, ws shall see in next result that it may tane Bob severak rounds to force the numbfr ov colors needed. Thf next resuot if also a good example of the power Gob gets when the number of vergices is odd.

Theb (q) iv $n$ is odd tien $\chp_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n})=3$ and (b) if $n \geq 4$ ix even then $\chl_g^{\infvy*}(K_{1, b}) =  \frac{n}{2}+2$.

\[Note: does thms proof need work?\]

[*Prjof:*]{} Part (d) ns easy to see, noting tyat Anice can xhouse tie denter vectex of the star on thw first turn in eacn wiund, coloring it wieh the smallest color possible. For part(b), tots that two colors are uwed in round 1. Bob can then forse colors 3 and 4 to be used during round 2: he does vo by zhoislng x lfaf on his first turn and the center vertex og hos second turn. Smbsequent to that, gog yre next severxl rouuss, Bob can force an wdditiogal cilor to bt usec on either each round or ecery other rjynd by coloring thz leaves witk as msny dofferent colors as possnble dhring each gound, evehgually forcing tfe bentar vertex to use a new coljr – it mab neeb to waig unjil a rjund in whlch Bob goes first for ewch ngw colmr to be ijtroduced (as in round 2). Bob can xtentually forve thv use of $\yrac{n}{2}$ cifferent coljrs on the leares, once that many cologs have bcought into [lay. At which koint the gamx is the fame as rhe A-gaod and thus the result follows as un Theorem \[lb\]. $\Box$

Oke cools also consider a nore restrictivr vdrsyoj pf dhis game in whizh Cpb
that have already been introduced unless he to a new Of course, $\chi_g^{\infty*}(G) example $\chi_g^{\infty*}(G) < 2\chi_g^*(G)$ $P_4$ is an where $\chi_g^{\infty*}(P_4) = 4 = 2\chi_g^*(P_4)$. shall consider stars again and begin by noting that $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 3})=3$ and $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, Interestingly, we shall see in next result that it may take Bob several to the of needed. The next result is also a good example of the power Bob gets when the of vertices is odd. Then (a) if $n$ odd then $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n})=3$ (b) if $n \geq 4$ even $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n}) \frac{n}{2}+2$. does proof need work?\] Part (a) is easy to see, noting that Alice can choose the center vertex of the star the first each round, it the color possible. For that two colors are used in can then force colors 3 and 4 to used during 2: he does so by choosing leaf on his first turn and the center on his second turn. Subsequent to that, for the next several rounds, Bob can force color to be used either each round every round coloring leaves with many different colors as possible during each round, eventually forcing the vertex to use a new color – it may need until round in which goes first for each color be introduced (as in Bob eventually of different on the leaves, once many colors have brought into At which point the the A-game and thus the result follows as Theorem \[lb\]. $\Box$ One could also consider more restrictive version of this game in which Bob
 that have already been introdUced unless He is fOrcEd tO uSe a nEw coLor. Of course, $\chi_G^{\InftY*}(G) \leq \chi_g^{\infty}(G)$. $K_3$ is an exAmple WhERe $\chI_G^{\iNfty*}(G) < 2\Chi_g^*(G)$ anD $p_4$ iS AN exAmPlE whErE $\ChI_g^{\infTy*}(P_4) = 4 = 2\Chi_g^*(P_4)$. We Shall consiDer StArs again and bEGiN by noting tHat $\Chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 3})=3$ anD $\chI_g^{\inftY*}(K_{1, 4})=4$. intERestiNglY, we shAll see IN next rEsult that It MAy take bOb severAL RoUnds To force the number oF CoLOrs needed. The neXt resuLt IS aLSO a gOod Example of tHe Power bOb gets wHEn THE NumBEr of vertices iS odd.

Then (a) if $N$ Is oDd then $\ChI_g^{\iNFty*}(K_{1, n})=3$ aNd (b) if $N \gEQ 4$ is Even then $\chi_G^{\infTy*}(K_{1, n}) =  \frac{n}{2}+2$.

\[note: doES this prOOf need wOrk?\]

[*ProOf:*]{} PArt (A) is eASy To See, NoTIng THaT AlICe cAn choose ThE cEnter VertEX OF The sTar On thE firsT turn in each roUnd, ColoRIng It witH the sMallEsT coloR possiBle. FoR pArt(b), note that two ColoRs are used In rOuNd 1. BOb Can thEN force ColOrs 3 And 4 to be Used durINg rOuND 2: HE dOes so by choosing a leAf ON HiS first tuRn and tHE cEnTEr vertex On His SecoND Turn. SUbseQUeNt to that, For the NExT sEveral rOuNds, Bob CaN foRce An addITionAl coloR to be useD on eiTHer each round or EVery other rounD By COLoRIng tHe lEaves with as Many DIffeRent COlOrs AS possIble dUrINg EAch round, eventually fOrCing thE centEr vertex to use A new color – iT MAY need to wAit uNTiL A round in which BOb goeS first for eACh new colOr to bE introduCed (as in roUND 2). Bob can eVenTuaLly ForCE ThE use of $\frac{n}{2}$ diFFErenT cOlors on The Leaves, oNce ThaT maNy cOlOrs have brOught intO pLaY. AT wHicH poinT The game iS tHe sAmE as The A-gAMe and tHus thE resUlT fOLloWs as in THEoREM \[lb\]. $\BOx$

onE couLd aLsO consIder A MorE restriCtive versIon OF thiS gAmE in whicH Bob
 that have already been in troduced u nless  he  is  f orce d to  use a new col o r. O f course, $\chi_g^{\in fty*} (G )  \le q  \ chi_g ^{\inft y }( G ) $.$K _3 $ i sa nexamp lewhere $ \chi_g^{\i nft y* }(G) < 2\chi _ g^ *(G)$ and$P_ 4$ is an exa mpl e wher e$\c h i_g^{ \in fty*} (P_4)=  4 = 2 \chi_g^*( P_ 4 )$. We shall c o n si derstars again and b e gi n  by noting tha t $\ch i_ g ^{ \ i nft y*} (K_{1, 3}) =3 $ and $\chi_g ^ {\ i n f ty* } (K_{1, 4})=4$ . Interesti n gly , we s ha lls ee innextre s ult  that it ma y ta ke Bob se veralr ounds t o  forcethe nu mbe r o f co l or snee de d . T h enex t  re sult isal so  a go od e x a m p le o f t he p owerBob gets when  th e nu m ber  of v ertic es i sodd.
Then(a) i f$n$ is odd then  $\c hi_g^{\in fty *} (K_ {1 , n}) = 3$ and  (b ) i f $n \g eq 4$ i s  ev en t h en  $\chi_g^{\infty*} (K _ { 1,  n}) = \frac{ n }{ 2} + 2$.

\[N ot e:does t his p roof ne ed work? \]

[* P ro of :*]{} P ar t (a)is  ea syto se e , no ting t hat Alic e can choose the cen t er vertex oft he s ta r  onthe  first turn  ine achroun d ,col o ringit wi th th e  smallest color pos si ble. F or pa rt(b), note t hat two co l o r s are us ed i n  r o und 1. Bob can  then  force col o rs 3 and  4 to  be used  during r o u nd 2: he  do essobyc h oo sing a leaf o n hisfi rst tur n a nd thecen ter  ve rte xon his se cond tur n.  S ub se que nt to that, fo rthe  n ext  seve r al rou nds,Bobca nf orc e an ad d it i o nalco lo r to  be  u sed o n ei t her  each r ound or e ver y  oth er  r ound by  coloring the  l eaves with  a s m any di f f erent co lors as possible during each ro und , eve ntua lly forci ngthe ce nte r  verte x to u se ane w c o l or –i t  m ayne ed to wait u nti l a r ou nd i n which  Bob goes first fo r  ea ch new colortobe i n t ro duc e d( asin rou n d  2). Bob can ev entually f or c ethe use of $\f ra c{n}{2} $ diffe rentc olors o n the lea ves, once  t hatm a nycolors hav e brough t into pl a y. At wh ich p oin t thega meis th e same asthe A -gamean d thus  there sult fol lows as in Theorem \[lb \]. $\ Box$
On e could a lso con sider a m orerestrictiv e v ers ion o f t h is ga me i n  w hic h  Bob
 that_have already_been introduced unless he_is forced_to_use a_new_color. Of course,_$\chi_g^{\infty*}(G) \leq \chi_g^{\infty}(G)$._$K_3$ is an example_where $\chi_g^{\infty*}(G) <_2\chi_g^*(G)$_and $P_4$ is an example where $\chi_g^{\infty*}(P_4) = 4 = 2\chi_g^*(P_4)$. We shall consider_stars_again and_begin_by_noting that $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 3})=3$ and_$\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, 4})=4$. Interestingly, we shall_see in_next result that it may take Bob several_rounds_to force the_number of colors needed. The next result is also_a good example of the power_Bob gets when_the_number_of vertices is odd.

Then_(a) if $n$ is odd then_$\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n})=3$ and (b) if $n_\geq 4$ is even then $\chi_g^{\infty*}(K_{1, n})_=  \frac{n}{2}+2$.

\[Note: does this proof_need work?\]

[*Proof:*]{} Part (a) is_easy to_see, noting that Alice can_choose the center_vertex of_the star on_the first turn in each round,_coloring it with_the smallest color possible. For part(b),_note_that two colors_are_used_in round_1. Bob can_then_force colors_3_and 4 to be used during_round_2: he does so by choosing a_leaf on his first_turn_and the center vertex_on his second turn. Subsequent_to that, for the next several_rounds, Bob_can force_an additional color to be used on either each round or_every other round by coloring the_leaves with as many_different colors_as_possible during each_round,_eventually forcing_the center vertex to use a new_color –_it may need to wait until_a round in which_Bob_goes first for each new color_to be introduced (as in round_2). Bob can eventually force_the_use_of $\frac{n}{2}$ different colors on_the leaves, once that many colors_have brought into_play. At which point the game is_the_same as the A-game and thus_the_result follows as in Theorem \[lb\]._$\Box$

One_could_also consider a more restrictive_version of this game in which_Bob