. The acceptance cuts are $p_T(W)>25$ GeV and $|y(W)|<1.5$ or 2. The second column shows the total cross section without cuts. The third column corresponds to tagging at least one of the $W$’s, and the last column corresponds to tagging both. The percentages in the parentheses are the efficiencies.
 ---
abstract: 'We investigate two approaches to derive the proper Floquet-based quantum-classical Liouville equation (F-QCLE) for laser-driven electron-nuclear dynamics. The first approach projects the operator form of the standard QCLE onto the diabatic Floquet basis, then transforms to the adiabatic representation. The second approach directly projects the QCLE onto the Floquet adiabatic basis. Both approaches yield a form which is similar to the usual QCLE with two modifications: 1. The electronic degrees of freedom are expanded to infinite dimension. 2. The nuclear motion follows Floquet quasi-energy surfaces. However, the second approach includes an additional cross derivative force due to the dual dependence on time and nuclear motion of the Floquet adiabatic states. Our analysis and numerical tests indicate that this cross derivative force is a fictitious artifact, suggesting that one cannot safely exchange the order of Floquet state projection with adiabatic transformation. Our results are in accord with similar findings by Izmaylov *et al*., who found that transforming to the adiabatic representation must always be the last operation applied, though now we have extended this result to a time-dependent Hamiltonian. This paper and the proper derivation of the F-QCLE should lay the basis for further improvements of Floquet surface hopping.'
author:
- 'Hsing-Ta Chen'
- Zeyu Zhou
- 'Joseph E. Subotnik'
bibliography:
- 'ZoteroLibrary.bib'
title: 'On the Proper Derivation of the Floquet-based Quantum Classical Liouville Equation Describing a Molecule or Material Subject to an External Field'
---

Introduction\[sec:Introduction\]
================================

A computational understanding light-matter interactions for a molecular system in a laser field is useful key for interpreting spectroscopy and photochemistry, where the dynamical interplay between electronic non-adiabatic transitions and photon excitation plays an important role for many exciting phenomena, such as molecular photodissociation[@regan_ultraviolet_1999; @franks_orientation_1999; @hilsabeck_photon_
. The acceptance cuts are $ p_T(W)>25 $   GeV and $ |y(W)|<1.5 $ or 2. The second column shows the total hybridization incision without cuts. The third column corresponds to tagging at least one of the $ W$ ’s, and the final column corresponds to tagging both. The share in the digression are the efficiencies. 
  --- 
 abstract:' We investigate two approach to derive the proper Floquet - based quantum - authoritative Liouville equation (F - QCLE) for laser - driven electron - nuclear dynamics. The first overture projects the operator form of the standard QCLE onto the diabatic Floquet basis, then transforms to the adiabatic theatrical performance. The second approach directly projects the QCLE onto the Floquet adiabatic footing. Both approaches yield a form which is similar to the usual QCLE with two alteration: 1. The electronic degrees of freedom are expanded to infinite dimension. 2. The nuclear apparent motion follows Floquet quasi - energy surfaces. However, the second approach includes an additional cross derivative force due to the dual dependence on time and nuclear motion of the Floquet adiabatic states. Our analysis and numerical tests indicate that this cross derivative military unit is a fictitious artifact, suggesting that one cannot safely commute the decree of Floquet state projection with adiabatic transformation. Our results are in agreement with similar findings by Izmaylov * et al *. , who found that transforming to the adiabatic theatrical performance must always be the last operation applied, though now we have extended this result to a time - dependent Hamiltonian. This paper and the proper derivation of the F - QCLE should lay the footing for further improvements of Floquet airfoil hopping.' 
 writer: 
 -' Hsing - Ta Chen' 
 - Zeyu Zhou 
 -' Joseph E. Subotnik' 
 bibliography: 
 -' ZoteroLibrary.bib' 
 title:' On the Proper Derivation of the Floquet - based Quantum Classical Liouville Equation Describing a Molecule or Material Subject to an External Field' 
 --- 

 Introduction\[sec: Introduction\ ] 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 A computational reason light - matter interactions for a molecular arrangement in a laser field is useful key for interpreting spectroscopy and photochemistry, where the dynamic interplay between electronic non - adiabatic transitions and photon excitation plays an important role for many exciting phenomenon, such as molecular photodissociation[@regan_ultraviolet_1999; @franks_orientation_1999; @hilsabeck_photon _
. Thf acceptance cuts are $p_T(D)>25$ GeV and $|y(W)|<1.5$ or 2. The serond comumn shods the total cross section wmthoyt cuuf. The third column correspojds to tqggiig at least one of the $W$’s, and fme lavv column correskonds to tagcing both. The [efczntages in the parentheses are the esficienvifs.
 ---
abstract: 'We invtstygats two approaches to derive the proler Floxuet-based quamtum-classical Liouville eqkatiln (F-QCLE) for laser-friven elecjdon-gyclear dynamkcs. The figvt approacg projects the operator form of the xtandard QXLW ojjo the diabavic Fljquet basis, bnen trdnsformx to the adiabstir representation. The secoid approach directly projects tke QCLE onto the Floqyer adidbathc bxwis. Bouh eppdoached ymeld a form which is sumilar to the usual QSOE with two mkdificwtyons: 1. The electronic degrees of freedom ars expanded to infinite eimension. 2. The nucleat motion fjllows Floquet quasi-energy surfaces. However, the sacond xppxiach kbcpudes an additional cross derivative force duq tp nhe dual dependenge on time and nuckewr iotion of the Floquzf zdiabatic states. Okr analisis abd numerisal yests indicate that this criss derivatine firce is a fictitiobs artifact, rugggsting that one cannot safely excgange the ogder of Fmuquet state projdctpon fith adiabatic transformatyon. Our rxsultx are iv acvord wyth similag findings by Izmaylov *eh al*., cho fmund that hransforming to the adiabatic rx'resentation kuvt dlways bz the kast operatiog applied, thouyh now wz have extended nhis resunt to a timq-dependent Haklltonian. Thiv paper wnd rhe proper adrivation of tne F-QCLE should lay the basis for furbher kjprovements of Yuiquet surface hpppkng.'
wunhoc:
- 'Hsigc-Ta Chen'
- Zeyg Zhuu
- 'Gpseph E. Subouuik'
nibuiogtaphy:
- 'ZoteroLibrary.bhb'
tifle: 'On the Proper Cevivation if the Fjoquet-based Qiantum Classical Llouvinle Equayiog Describing a Molecule or Matsrial Subuecb to an Extergal Nielq'
---

Introductnon\[sec:Introduction\]
================================

A computational undersvanding light-matter injeractions for a moleeukar system mn a lwser fielg is useful key for unterpreting specuroscopy and photochemiatry, wvere hhe dynamical interplay between electronic non-adiabatic transitions and pyoton xxsitation plzys sn imiorcanc role sor leny exciting phenpmena, such as molecular photodirsociatimn[@xegan_ultraviolet_1999; @franks_orientstkon_1999; @hilsabeck_khoton_
. The acceptance cuts are $p_T(W)>25$ GeV or The second shows the total third corresponds to tagging least one of $W$’s, and the last column corresponds tagging both. The percentages in the parentheses are the efficiencies. --- abstract: 'We two approaches to derive the proper Floquet-based quantum-classical Liouville equation (F-QCLE) for laser-driven dynamics. first projects operator form of the standard QCLE onto the diabatic Floquet basis, then transforms to the adiabatic The second approach directly projects the QCLE onto Floquet adiabatic basis. Both yield a form which is to usual QCLE two 1. electronic degrees of are expanded to infinite dimension. 2. The nuclear motion follows Floquet quasi-energy surfaces. However, the second approach an additional force due the dependence time and nuclear the Floquet adiabatic states. Our analysis indicate that this cross derivative force is a artifact, suggesting one cannot safely exchange the order Floquet state projection with adiabatic transformation. Our results in accord with similar findings by Izmaylov *et al*., who found that transforming to the must always be the operation applied, though we extended result a time-dependent This paper and the proper derivation of the F-QCLE should lay basis for further improvements of Floquet surface hopping.' author: - - Zhou - 'Joseph Subotnik' bibliography: - 'ZoteroLibrary.bib' 'On Proper Derivation of the Classical Equation or Subject an External Field' --- ================================ A computational understanding light-matter for a molecular system useful key for interpreting spectroscopy and photochemistry, where dynamical interplay between electronic non-adiabatic transitions and excitation plays an important role for many exciting phenomena, such as molecular @franks_orientation_1999; @hilsabeck_photon_
. The acceptance cuts are $p_T(W)>25$ Gev and $|y(W)|<1.5$ or 2. ThE secoNd cOluMn ShowS the Total cross sectIOn wiThout cuts. The third columN corrEsPOnds TO tAgginG at leasT OnE OF thE $W$’S, aNd tHe LAsT coluMn cOrrespoNds to taggiNg bOtH. The percentaGEs In the parenTheSes are the effIciEncies.
 ---
AbStrACt: 'We iNveStigaTe two aPProachEs to derivE tHE propeR floquet-BASeD quaNtum-classical LiouVIlLE equation (F-QCLE) For lasEr-DRiVEN elEctRon-nuclear DyNamicS. the firsT ApPROAch PRojects the opeRator form of THe sTandarD QcLE ONto the DiabaTiC floQuet basis, thEn trAnsforms tO the adIAbatic rEPresentAtion. THe sEcoNd apPRoAcH diReCTly PRoJecTS thE QCLE ontO tHe floquEt adIABATic bAsiS. BotH apprOaches yield a fOrm WhicH Is sImilaR to thE usuAl qCLE wIth two ModifIcAtions: 1. The electrOnic Degrees of FreEdOm aRe ExpanDEd to inFinIte DimensiOn. 2. The nuCLeaR mOTIOn Follows Floquet quasI-eNERgY surfaceS. HowevER, tHe SEcond appRoAch InclUDEs an aDditIOnAl cross dErivatIVe FoRce due tO tHe dual DePenDenCe on tIMe anD nucleAr motion Of the fLoquet adiabatiC States. Our analYSiS ANd NUmerIcaL tests indicAte tHAt thIs crOSs DerIVativE forcE iS A fICtitious artifact, sugGeSting tHat onE cannot safely Exchange thE ORDer of FloQuet STaTE projection witH adiaBatic transFOrmation. our reSults are In accord wITH similar FinDinGs bY IzMAYlOv *et al*., who founD THat tRaNsformiNg tO the adiAbaTic RepResEnTation musT always bE tHe LaSt OpeRatioN Applied, tHoUgh NoW we Have eXTended This rEsulT tO a TIme-DependeNT HAMIltoNiAn. this PapEr And thE proPEr dErivatiOn of the F-QcLE SHoulD lAy The basiS for further imPrOvements of flOquEt surfACE hopping.'
Author:
- 'Hsing-Ta Chen'
- Zeyu ZhOU
- 'Joseph e. SuBotniK'
bibLiography:
- 'zotEroLibRarY.Bib'
titLe: 'On thE PropEr derIVAtion OF ThE FlOqUet-based QuANTum classIcAl LiOuville equation Describing A molEcule or MateriAl SUbjeCT To An EXTeRNal fiELd'
---

INTRoduction\[sec:IntRoduction\]
================================

A CoMPuTational unDErsTaNding liGht-mattEr intERactionS for a moleCular systEm In a lASEr fIeld is usefUl key for InterpretINg speCTrOscopY anD photoChEmiStry, wHere thE DynAmicaL interPlAy betwEen elEcTronic noN-adiabatic transitions anD photoN exciTatIon plays aN imPOrtAnt role foR manY exciting pHenOmeNa, sucH as MOlecuLar pHOtOdiSSociaTion[@REgan_ultraVIoLet_1999; @FRAnKs_orientatiON_1999; @HIlsAbeck_PhoTOn_
. The acceptance cuts are$p_T(W)>25 $ GeV  an d $ |y (W)| <1.5 $ or 2. The se c ondcolumn shows the total  cros ss ecti o nwitho ut cuts .  T h e  th ir dcol um n  c orres pon ds to t agging atlea st  one of the$ W$ ’s, and th e l ast column c orr espond stot aggin g b oth.The pe r centag es in the  p a renthe s es aret h eeffi ciencies.
 ---
ab s tr a ct: 'We invest igatetw o  a p p roa che s to deriv ethe p r oper Fl o qu e t - bas e d quantum-cla ssical Liou v ill e equa ti on( F-QCLE ) for  l a ser -driven ele ctro n-nuclear  dynam i cs. The first a pproac h p roj ects th eope ra t orf or m o f  th e standa rd  Q CLE o ntot h e diab ati c Fl oquet  basis, thentra nsfo r msto th e adi abat ic  repr esenta tion.  T he second appro achdirectlypro je cts  t he QC L E onto  th e F loquetadiabat i c b as i s .  B oth approaches yie ld a  f orm whic h is s i mi la r  to theus ual  QCL E withtwom od ificatio ns: 1. Th eelectro ni c degr ee s o f f reedo m  are  expan ded to i nfini t e dimension. 2 .  The nuclearm ot i o nf ollo wsFloquet qua si-e n ergy  sur f ac es. Howev er, t he se c ond approach includ es  an ad ditio nal cross der ivative fo r c e  due tothed ua l  dependence on  time  and nucle a r motion  of t he Floqu et adiaba t i c states . O urana lys i s  a nd numericalt e stsin dicatetha t thiscro ssder iva ti ve forceis a fic ti ti ou sart ifact ,  suggest in g t ha t o ne ca n not sa felyexch an ge the  ordero fF l oque tst atepro je ction  wit h  ad iabatic  transfor mat i on.Ou rresults  are in accor dwith simil ar  fi ndings b y Izmayl ov *et al*., who foundt hat tra nsf ormin g to  the adia bat ic rep res e ntatio n must  alwa ys  be t he la s t  o per at ion applie d ,  th oughno w we  have e xtended this resul t  to  a time-depen den t Ha m i lt oni a n. Thi sp ape r and the properderivation  o f  t he F-QCLEs hou ld  lay th e basis  forf urtherimproveme nts of Fl oq uets u rfa ce hopping .'
autho r:
- 'Hsi n g-TaC he n'
-Zey u Zhou 
-  'J oseph  E. Su b otn ik'
b ibliog ra phy:
-  'Zot er oLibrary .bib'
title: 'On the Pr oper D eriva tio n of theFlo q uet -based Qu antu m Classica l L iou ville  Eq u ation  Des c ri bin g  a Mo lecu l e or Mate r ia l S u b je ct to an Ex t e r nal  Fiel d'- --

In trod uction\[sec:Intro d uction\]
===== ==== = = === === = ==== == ========

A co mpu ta t i onal und er standing li ght-matt er inter action s fora molec u l ar system  ina l aser fiel d i su seful k ey  f o r inte rpre ti ng spe ctrosc o py a n d  photochemistry,  wher e the d y nam icalin terplay betw een electr onic non-ad iabati c tr ansit ions an dphoton  ex ci tation pla y s an impo rtant  role f or  man y e xcitin g ph e n omena , su ch  as  molecula r ph o to di s soc iati on[@r eg an_u ltraviole t _1999; @ fra n ks_orie nt ati o n _1999; @h i l sabeck_pho ton _
. The_acceptance cuts_are $p_T(W)>25$ GeV and $|y(W)|<1.5$_or 2._The_second column_shows_the total cross_section without cuts._The third column corresponds_to tagging at_least_one of the $W$’s, and the last column corresponds to tagging both. The percentages_in_the parentheses_are_the_efficiencies.
 ---
abstract: 'We investigate two_approaches to derive the proper_Floquet-based quantum-classical_Liouville equation (F-QCLE) for laser-driven electron-nuclear dynamics. The_first_approach projects the_operator form of the standard QCLE onto the diabatic_Floquet basis, then transforms to the_adiabatic representation. The_second_approach_directly projects the QCLE_onto the Floquet adiabatic basis. Both_approaches yield a form which is_similar to the usual QCLE with two_modifications: 1. The electronic degrees of_freedom are expanded to infinite_dimension. 2._The nuclear motion follows Floquet_quasi-energy surfaces. However,_the second_approach includes an_additional cross derivative force due to_the dual dependence_on time and nuclear motion of_the_Floquet adiabatic states._Our_analysis_and numerical_tests indicate that_this_cross derivative_force_is a fictitious artifact, suggesting that_one_cannot safely exchange the order of Floquet_state projection with adiabatic_transformation._Our results are in_accord with similar findings by_Izmaylov *et al*., who found that_transforming to_the adiabatic_representation must always be the last operation applied, though now we_have extended this result to a_time-dependent Hamiltonian. This paper_and the_proper_derivation of the_F-QCLE_should lay_the basis for further improvements of Floquet_surface hopping.'
author:
-_'Hsing-Ta Chen'
- Zeyu Zhou
- 'Joseph E._Subotnik'
bibliography:
- 'ZoteroLibrary.bib'
title: 'On the_Proper_Derivation of the Floquet-based Quantum Classical_Liouville Equation Describing a Molecule or_Material Subject to an External_Field'
---

Introduction\[sec:Introduction\]
================================

A_computational_understanding light-matter interactions for a_molecular system in a laser field_is useful key_for interpreting spectroscopy and photochemistry, where the_dynamical_interplay between electronic non-adiabatic transitions and_photon_excitation plays an important role for_many_exciting_phenomena, such as molecular photodissociation[@regan_ultraviolet_1999;_@franks_orientation_1999; @hilsabeck_photon_