 for parameters that satisfy the experimental constraints such as those from neutrino oscillation data and lepton flavor violations. Then, we present several predictions in our model that originate from the modular symmetry.]{}'
author:
- Hiroshi Okada
- Yutaro Shoji
title: 'A radiative seesaw model in modular $A_4$ symmetry'
---

[APCTP Pre2020 - 005]{}

Introduction
============

One of big mysteries in the standard model (SM) is the origin of the flavor structures. In particular, the flavor structure of the neutrino mass matrix is very important to understand the lepton sector. Historically, models with non-Abelian discrete flavor symmetries have been widely discussed since they not only reproduce the experimental results but also have several model specific predictions. Recently, starting from papers [@Feruglio:2017spp; @deAdelhartToorop:2011re], modular motivated non-Abelian discrete flavor symmetries have attracted attention of many authors to realize more predictable flavor structures in the quark and the lepton sectors. One of their remarkable natures is that any coupling constants as well as fields can also be transformed as non-trivial representations of those symmetries. Thus, we do not need to introduce many scalar fields such as flavons to realize flavor structure. As a result, we obtain a more minimal scenario without assumptions such as vacuum alignments among scalar fields. Here, we list several references where they apply this kind of symmetries to flavor models; the $A_4$ modular group [@Feruglio:2017spp; @Criado:2018thu; @Kobayashi:2018scp; @Okada:2018yrn; @Nomura:2019jxj; @Okada:2019uoy; @deAnda:2018ecu; @Novichkov:2018yse; @Nomura:2019yft; @Okada:2019mjf; @Ding:2019zxk; @Nomura:2019lnr; @Kobayashi:2019xvz; @Asaka:2019vev; @Zhang:2019ngf; @Gui-JunDing:2019wap; @Nomura:2019xsb; @Kobayashi:2019gtp; @Wang:2019xbo; @King:2020qaj; @Abbas:2020qzc], $S_3$ [@Kobayashi:2018vbk; @K
for parameters that satisfy the experimental constraints such as those from neutrino oscillation datum and lepton spirit violations. Then, we present respective predictions in our mannequin that originate from the modular symmetry. ] { }' 
 author: 
 - Hiroshi Okada 
 - Yutaro Shoji 
 championship:' A radiative seesaw model in modular $ A_4 $ symmetry' 
 --- 

 [ APCTP Pre2020 - 005 ] { } 

 Introduction 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 One of large mysteries in the standard model (SM) is the lineage of the flavor structures. In finical, the spirit structure of the neutrino mass matrix is very important to understand the lepton sector. Historically, models with non - Abelian discrete spirit symmetries have been widely discussed since they not entirely reproduce the experimental results but also have respective model specific prediction. Recently, starting from papers   [ @Feruglio:2017spp; @deAdelhartToorop:2011re ], modular motivated non - Abelian discrete flavor isotropy have attracted attention of many authors to realize more predictable flavor structures in the quark and the lepton sectors. One of their remarkable natures is that any coupling constants as well as fields can also be transformed as non - trivial representation of those symmetries. Thus, we do not want to insert many scalar fields such as flavons to realize flavor social organization. As a result, we receive a more minimal scenario without assumptions such as vacuum conjunction among scalar fields. Here, we list several references where they apply this kind of symmetries to relish models; the $ A_4 $ modular group   [ @Feruglio:2017spp; @Criado:2018thu; @Kobayashi:2018scp; @Okada:2018yrn; @Nomura:2019jxj; @Okada:2019uoy; @deAnda:2018ecu; @Novichkov:2018yse; @Nomura:2019yft; @Okada:2019mjf; @Ding:2019zxk; @Nomura:2019lnr; @Kobayashi:2019xvz; @Asaka:2019vev; @Zhang:2019ngf; @Gui - JunDing:2019wap; @Nomura:2019xsb; @Kobayashi:2019gtp; @Wang:2019xbo; @King:2020qaj; @Abbas:2020qzc ], $ S_3 $   [ @Kobayashi:2018vbk; @K
 fog parameters that satisfn the experimentco consvraints such as those from neutrino oscillavion data and lepton flavor viouations. Tjen, we peeseit several predirfions ik our loden that originatg from the mmdular symmetrf.]{}'
ajtkor:
- Hiroshi Okada
- Yutaro Shoji
title: 'W radiayige seesaw modej in iodumar $A_4$ symmetry'
---

[APCTP Pre2020 - 005]{}

Introductjon
============

One mf big mysteroes in the standard model (DM) id the origin of thf flavor stthcttees. In partizular, the flavor strucjure of the neutrino mass matrix is vzry importabt to onderstand tie lepnon sector. Historicalny, modeks with non-Abekiai diwcrete flavor symmetrmes have been widely discusseg aince they not onoy reprmduca thd exoerjmxntzl resklta but also have severql model specific pteqpvtions. Recenfly, stwreing from papers [@Feruglio:2017spp; @deAdelhartTmorkp:2011re], modular motivated bon-Abelian discrete fpavor symietries have attracted attention of many authors do reelkze mjfw oredictable flavor structures in the quark anq tne lepton sectorf. One of thrig tgmarkable natutes is cgaf any coupling condtants ws weol as fiejds van also be transformed as bon-trivial rvprewentations of thosz symmetries. Thux, we co not need to introducz many scalar fiepds such zr flavons to reauizv fldvor structure. As a result, we obtaii a mpre minkmal scenawio withouh assmkptions such as vafuum clignkents amonh scalar fields. Here, we list setxral referencgs fhege they a'ply tmis kind of symietries to flaror modejs; thd $A_4$ modulag group [@Fecuglio:2017spp; @Cryado:2018thu; @Kobayddhi:2018scp; @Okada:2018brn; @Nomurw:2019jxj; @Okaea:2019uoy; @ddXnda:2018ecu; @Novichlov:2018yse; @Nomura:2019yft; @Okqda:2019mjf; @Ding:2019zxk; @Nommra:2019lnt; @Iobayashi:2019xvz; @Ascyq:2019vev; @Zhang:2019ngf; @Gii-JjnDynh:2019wep; @Noigra:2019xsb; @Kobaydshi:2019etp; @Eang:2019xco; @King:2020qaj; @Cbcas:2020qac], $S_3$ [@Kobayashi:2018vbk; @K
for parameters that satisfy the experimental constraints those neutrino oscillation and lepton flavor predictions our model that from the modular author: - Hiroshi Okada - Yutaro title: 'A radiative seesaw model in modular $A_4$ symmetry' --- [APCTP Pre2020 - Introduction ============ One of big mysteries in the standard model (SM) is the of flavor In the flavor structure of the neutrino mass matrix is very important to understand the lepton sector. models with non-Abelian discrete flavor symmetries have been discussed since they not reproduce the experimental results but have model specific Recently, from [@Feruglio:2017spp; @deAdelhartToorop:2011re], modular non-Abelian discrete flavor symmetries have attracted attention of many authors to realize more predictable flavor structures in quark and sectors. One their natures that any coupling well as fields can also be representations of those symmetries. Thus, we do not to introduce scalar fields such as flavons to flavor structure. As a result, we obtain a minimal scenario without assumptions such as vacuum alignments among scalar fields. Here, we list several they apply this kind symmetries to flavor the modular [@Feruglio:2017spp; @Kobayashi:2018scp; @Okada:2018yrn; @Okada:2019uoy; @deAnda:2018ecu; @Novichkov:2018yse; @Nomura:2019yft; @Okada:2019mjf; @Ding:2019zxk; @Nomura:2019lnr; @Kobayashi:2019xvz; @Asaka:2019vev; @Zhang:2019ngf; @Gui-JunDing:2019wap; @Kobayashi:2019gtp; @Wang:2019xbo; @King:2020qaj; @Abbas:2020qzc], $S_3$ [@Kobayashi:2018vbk; @K
 for parameters that satisfy tHe experimeNtal cOnsTraInTs suCh as Those from neutrINo osCillation data and lepton FlavoR vIOlatIOnS. Then, We preseNT sEVEraL pReDicTiONs In our ModEl that oRiginate frOm tHe Modular symmeTRy.]{}'
Author:
- HiroShi okada
- Yutaro SHojI
title: 'a rAdiATive sEesAw modEl in moDUlar $A_4$ sYmmetry'
---

[APcTp pre2020 - 005]{}

IntROductioN
============

oNe Of biG mysteries in the stANdARd model (SM) is the Origin Of THe FLAvoR stRuctures. In PaRticuLAr, the flAVoR STRucTUre of the neutrIno mass matrIX is Very imPoRtaNT to undErstaNd THe lEpton sector. histOrically, mOdels wITh non-AbELian disCrete fLavOr sYmmeTRiEs HavE bEEn wIDeLy dIScuSsed sincE tHeY not oNly rEPRODuce The ExpeRimenTal results but AlsO havE SevEral mOdel sPeciFiC predIctionS. ReceNtLy, starting from pAperS [@Feruglio:2017Spp; @DeadeLhArtToORop:2011re], mOduLar MotivatEd non-AbELiaN dISCReTe flavor symmetries HaVE AtTracted aTtentiON oF mANy authorS tO reAlizE MOre prEdicTAbLe flavor StructUReS iN the quaRk And the LePtoN seCtors. oNe of Their rEmarkablE natuREs is that any couPLing constants AS wELL aS FielDs cAn also be traNsfoRMed aS non-TRiViaL RepreSentaTiONs OF those symmetries. ThuS, wE do not Need tO introduce manY scalar fieLDS Such as flAvonS To REalize flavor stRuctuRe. As a resulT, We obtain A more Minimal sCenario wiTHOut assumPtiOns SucH as VACuUm alignments aMONg scAlAr fieldS. HeRe, we lisT seVerAl rEfeReNces where They applY tHiS kInD of SymmeTRies to flAvOr mOdEls; The $A_4$ mODular gRoup [@FErugLiO:2017sPP; @CrIado:2018thu; @kObAYAshi:2018ScP; @OKada:2018Yrn; @noMura:2019jXj; @OkADa:2019uOy; @deAndA:2018ecu; @NovicHkoV:2018Yse; @NOmUrA:2019yft; @OkaDa:2019mjf; @Ding:2019zxk; @NOmUra:2019lnr; @KobaYaShi:2019Xvz; @AsaKA:2019Vev; @Zhang:2019Ngf; @Gui-JunDing:2019wap; @Nomura:2019xSB; @KobayaShi:2019Gtp; @WaNg:2019xbO; @King:2020qaj; @ABbaS:2020qzc], $S_3$ [@KObaYAshi:2018vbK; @K
 for parameters that satis fy the exp erime nta l c on stra ints  such as those from  neutrino oscillationdataan d  lep t on  flav or viol a ti o n s.Th en , w ep re sentsev eral pr edictionsinou r model that or iginate fr omthe modularsym metry. ]{ }'a uthor :
-  Hiro shi Ok a da
- Y utaro Sho ji title: 'A radi a t iv e se esaw model in mod u la r  $A_4$ symmetr y'
--- 
[ AP C T P P re2 020 - 005] {} 

Int r oductio n 
= = = = === = ====

One ofbig mysteri e s i n thest and a rd mod el (S M) isthe originof t he flavor  struc t ures. I n  partic ular,the  fl avor st ru ctu re oft he  ne u tri no massma tr ix is  ver y i m port ant  tounder stand the lep ton  sec t or.  Hist orica lly,  m odels  withnon-A be lian discrete f lavo r symmetr ies  h ave  b een w i dely d isc uss ed sinc e theyn oton l y re produce the experi me n t al  results  but a l so  h a ve sever al  mo dels p ecifi c pr e di ctions.Recent l y,  s tarting  f rom pa pe rs[@F erugl i o:20 17spp;  @deAdel hartT o orop:2011re],m odular motiva t ed n on - Abel ian  discrete f lavo r  sym metr i es  ha v e att racte da tt e ntion of many autho rs  to re alize  more predict able flavo r s tructure s in th e  quark and the  lept on sectors .  One oftheir  remarka ble natur e s  is that  an y c oup lin g co nstants as we l l  asfi elds ca n a lso betra nsf orm edas  non-triv ial repr es en ta ti ons  of t h ose symm et rie s.  Th us, w e  do no t nee d to  i nt r odu ce many sc a l ar f ie ld s su chas  flav onst o r ealizeflavor st ruc t ure.  A sa resul t, we obtainamore minim al  sc enario w ithout a ssumptions such as vacu u m align men ts am ongscalar fi eld s. Her e,w e list  sever al re fe ren c e s whe r e  t hey  a pply thisk i ndof sy mm etri es to f lavor models; the$ A_4 $ modular gro up[@Fe r u gl io: 2 01 7 spp ;@ Cri a d o:2018thu; @Kob ayashi:201 8s c p;  @Okada:20 1 8yr n;  @Nomur a:2019j xj; @ O kada:20 19uoy; @d eAnda:201 8e cu;@ N ovi chkov:2018 yse; @No mura:2019 y ft; @ O ka da:20 19m jf; @D in g:2 019zx k; @No m ura :2019 lnr; @ Ko bayash i:201 9x vz; @Asa ka:2019vev; @Zhang:2019 ngf; @ Gui-J unD ing:2019w ap; @No mura:2019 xsb;  @Kobayash i:2 019 gtp;@Wa n g:201 9xbo ;  @ Kin g :2020 qaj; @Abbas:20 2 0q zc] , $S _3$ [@Kobay a s h i:2 018vb k;@ K
 for_parameters that_satisfy the experimental constraints_such as_those_from neutrino_oscillation_data and lepton_flavor violations. Then,_we present several predictions_in our model_that_originate from the modular symmetry.]{}'
author:
- Hiroshi Okada
- Yutaro Shoji
title: 'A radiative seesaw model in_modular_$A_4$ symmetry'
---

[APCTP_Pre2020_-_005]{}

Introduction
============

One of big mysteries in_the standard model (SM) is_the origin_of the flavor structures. In particular, the flavor_structure_of the neutrino_mass matrix is very important to understand the lepton_sector. Historically, models with non-Abelian discrete_flavor symmetries have_been_widely_discussed since they not_only reproduce the experimental results but_also have several model specific predictions._Recently, starting from papers [@Feruglio:2017spp; @deAdelhartToorop:2011re], modular motivated_non-Abelian discrete flavor symmetries have attracted_attention of many authors to_realize more_predictable flavor structures in the_quark and the_lepton sectors._One of their_remarkable natures is that any coupling_constants as well_as fields can also be transformed_as_non-trivial representations of_those_symmetries._Thus, we_do not need_to_introduce many_scalar_fields such as flavons to realize_flavor_structure. As a result, we obtain a_more minimal scenario without_assumptions_such as vacuum alignments_among scalar fields. Here, we_list several references where they apply_this kind_of symmetries_to flavor models; the $A_4$ modular group [@Feruglio:2017spp; @Criado:2018thu; @Kobayashi:2018scp; @Okada:2018yrn; @Nomura:2019jxj;_@Okada:2019uoy; @deAnda:2018ecu; @Novichkov:2018yse; @Nomura:2019yft; @Okada:2019mjf; @Ding:2019zxk;_@Nomura:2019lnr; @Kobayashi:2019xvz; @Asaka:2019vev; @Zhang:2019ngf;_@Gui-JunDing:2019wap; @Nomura:2019xsb;_@Kobayashi:2019gtp;_@Wang:2019xbo; @King:2020qaj; @Abbas:2020qzc],_$S_3$ [@Kobayashi:2018vbk;_@K