1/c^{2})\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{E} &=&\mu (\mathbf{H}-\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{D}),  \label{de}\end{aligned}$$Eqs. (C) and (D) in Sec. 8.$^{1}$ From that time, the equations (\[de\]) are considered to be the fundamental constitutive equations for moving media in the whole physics community. They are subsequently derived in different ways and used in numerous papers and textbooks on the electromagnetism.

**5.1 Comparison with Minkowski’s constitutive relations that are**

**obtained by means of the 3-vectors**$^{24}$ **and**

**in the covariant approach**$^{25}$****

One way of the derivation of Eqs. (\[de\]) is presented in Ref. 24. There, these equations, i.e. Eqs. (7),$^{24}$ are derived using Minkowski’s crucial hypothesis that the relations with the 3-vectors $\mathbf{D}=\varepsilon \mathbf{E}$, $\mathbf{H}=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}$, which correspond to (\[dh1\]), retain their form in the moving frame $S^{\prime
} $ with the same $\varepsilon $ and $\mu $, i. e., $\mathbf{D}^{\prime
}=\varepsilon \mathbf{E}^{\prime }$, $\mathbf{H}^{\prime }=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}^{\prime }$. Then, in Ref. 24, *the UT* (\[JCB\]) *and the similar UT for* $\mathbf{D}^{\prime }$ *and* $\mathbf{H}^{\prime }$ (Eqs. (3)$^{24}$) *are used to obtain Minkowski’s constitutive equations* (\[de\]). Furthermore, in Ref. 24, the constitutive relations, which explicitly express $\mathbf{D}$ and $\mathbf{H}$ in terms of $\mathbf{E}$ and $\mathbf{B}$, are derived (Eqs. (10)$^{24}$) from (\[de\]). Introducing $\mathbf{D}=\varepsilon _{0}\mathbf{E}+\mathbf{P}$ and $\mathbf{H}=(1/\mu _{0})\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{M}$ into Eqs. (10)$^{24}$ we find the constitutive equations which explicitly express $\mathbf{P}$ as a function of $\mathbf{E}$ and $\mathbf{B}$ $$\begin{aligned}
\mathbf{P
1 / c^{2})\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{E } & = & \mu (\mathbf{H}-\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{D }),   \label{de}\end{aligned}$$Eqs. (C) and (D) in Sec. 8.$^{1}$ From that time, the equations (\[de\ ]) are considered to be the fundamental constituent equation for moving media in the solid purgative community. They are subsequently derived in different way and used in numerous papers and textbook on the electromagnetism. 

 * * 5.1   Comparison with Minkowski ’s constituent relations that are * * 

 * * obtained by mean of the 3 - vectors**$^{24}$ * * and * * 

 * * in the covariant approach**$^{25}$ * * * * 

 One way of the derivation of Eqs. (\[de\ ]) is stage in Ref. 24. There, these equations, i.e. Eqs. (7),$^{24}$ are derived using Minkowski ’s crucial hypothesis that the relations with the 3 - vector $ \mathbf{D}=\varepsilon \mathbf{E}$, $ \mathbf{H}=(1/\mu) \mathbf{B}$, which correspond to (\[dh1\ ]), retain their form in the moving skeletal system $ S^{\prime 
 } $ with the same $ \varepsilon $ and $ \mu $, i. e., $ \mathbf{D}^{\prime 
 } = \varepsilon \mathbf{E}^{\prime } $, $ \mathbf{H}^{\prime } =( 1/\mu) \mathbf{B}^{\prime } $. Then, in Ref. 24, * the UT * (\[JCB\ ]) * and the similar UT for * $ \mathbf{D}^{\prime } $ * and * $ \mathbf{H}^{\prime } $ (Eqs. (3)$^{24}$) * are used to obtain Minkowski ’s constituent equations * (\[de\ ]). Furthermore, in Ref. 24, the constituent relations, which explicitly express $ \mathbf{D}$ and $ \mathbf{H}$ in terms of $ \mathbf{E}$ and $ \mathbf{B}$, are derived (Eqs. (10)$^{24}$) from (\[de\ ]). introduce $ \mathbf{D}=\varepsilon _ { 0}\mathbf{E}+\mathbf{P}$ and $ \mathbf{H}=(1/\mu _ { 0})\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{M}$ into Eqs. (10)$^{24}$ we find the constitutive equations which explicitly express $ \mathbf{P}$ as a function of $ \mathbf{E}$ and $ \mathbf{B}$ $ $ \begin{aligned } 
 \mathbf{P
1/c^{2})\mahhbf{U}\times \mathbf{E} &=&\mu (\mauhbf{H}-\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{V}),  \labem{de}\end{alkgned}$$Eqs. (C) and (D) in Sec. 8.$^{1}$ Frol rhat upme, the equations (\[de\]) xre consifered to be uhe fundamental constitutlre eqhwtious for moving mecia in the whole physics cumlunity. They are subsequently deriveq in digffrent ways and usec in hlmtrous papers and textbooks on the electrmmagnetism.

**5.1 Comlarison with Minkowski’s cojstihutive relations tjat are**

**obtauned vy means of ghe 3-vectors**$^{24}$ **and**

**in the dovariant approach**$^{25}$****

One way of thd dernvation of Gqa. (\[fg\]) is presentxd in Gef. 24. There, thcxe equdtions, o.e. Eqs. (7),$^{24}$ are devived usung Minkowski’s crucian hypothesis that jhe relatimna with the 3-vectorw $\nathbx{D}=\vasepskoon \mauhbh{E}$, $\jathbf{J}=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}$, wgich correspond to (\[dh1\]), retain tneyg form in the movind srame $S^{\prime
} $ with the same $\varepsilon $ ans $\mu $, i. e., $\mathbf{D}^{\prime
}=\vqrepsilon \mathbf{E}^{\primg }$, $\mathbf{H}^{\[rime }=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}^{\prime }$. Then, in Ref. 24, *the UT* (\[JCB\]) *ang the rimnoar UG flr* $\mathbf{D}^{\prime }$ *and* $\mathbf{H}^{\prime }$ (Eqs. (3)$^{24}$) *are ufsd tp obtain Minkocski’s constitutife eaoations* (\[de\]). Furjhermorz, ih Ref. 24, the constitktive rglatiobs, which txplivitly express $\mathbf{D}$ and $\mqthbf{H}$ in tegms if $\mathbf{E}$ and $\matkbf{B}$, are dernved (Eas. (10)$^{24}$) ftom (\[de\]). Introducing $\mathyf{D}=\varspsilon _{0}\matjbf{E}+\mathbr{O}$ and $\mathbf{H}=(1/\mu _{0})\oatmbf{T}-\mathbf{M}$ into Eqs. (10)$^{24}$ we find the consvitutnve equagionx whicr explicitpy exisess $\mathbf{P}$ as a vunctnon ox $\mathbf{E}$ wnd $\mathbf{B}$ $$\begin{aligned}
\mathbf{P
1/c^{2})\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{E} &=&\mu (\mathbf{H}-\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{D}), \label{de}\end{aligned}$$Eqs. (C) in 8.$^{1}$ From time, the equations the constitutive equations for media in the physics community. They are subsequently derived different ways and used in numerous papers and textbooks on the electromagnetism. **5.1 with Minkowski’s constitutive relations that are** **obtained by means of the 3-vectors**$^{24}$ **and** the approach**$^{25}$**** way the derivation of Eqs. (\[de\]) is presented in Ref. 24. There, these equations, i.e. Eqs. (7),$^{24}$ derived using Minkowski’s crucial hypothesis that the relations the 3-vectors $\mathbf{D}=\varepsilon \mathbf{E}$, )\mathbf{B}$, which correspond to (\[dh1\]), their in the frame } with the same $ and $\mu $, i. e., $\mathbf{D}^{\prime }=\varepsilon \mathbf{E}^{\prime }$, $\mathbf{H}^{\prime }=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}^{\prime }$. Then, in Ref. *the UT* the similar for* }$ $\mathbf{H}^{\prime }$ (Eqs. used to obtain Minkowski’s constitutive equations* Ref. 24, the constitutive relations, which explicitly express and $\mathbf{H}$ terms of $\mathbf{E}$ and $\mathbf{B}$, are (Eqs. (10)$^{24}$) from (\[de\]). Introducing $\mathbf{D}=\varepsilon _{0}\mathbf{E}+\mathbf{P}$ and _{0})\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{M}$ into Eqs. (10)$^{24}$ we find the constitutive equations which explicitly express $\mathbf{P}$ as a $\mathbf{E}$ and $\mathbf{B}$ $$\begin{aligned}
1/c^{2})\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{E} &=&\mu (\matHbf{H}-\mathbf{u}\timeS \maThbF{D}),  \LabeL{de}\eNd{aligned}$$Eqs. (C) aND (D) in sec. 8.$^{1}$ From that time, the equaTions (\[De\]) ARe coNSiDered To be the FUnDAMenTaL cOnsTiTUtIve eqUatIons for Moving mediA in ThE whole physicS CoMmunity. TheY arE subsequentlY deRived iN dIffERent wAys And usEd in nuMErous pApers and tExTBooks oN The elecTROmAgneTism.

**5.1 Comparison witH miNKowski’s constitUtive rElATiONS thAt aRe**

**obtained By Means OF the 3-vecTOrS**$^{24}$ **AND**

**in THe covariant apProach**$^{25}$****

One waY Of tHe deriVaTioN Of Eqs. (\[dE\]) is prEsENteD in Ref. 24. There, ThesE equationS, i.e. Eqs. (7),$^{24}$ ARe derivED using MInkowsKi’s CruCial HYpOtHesIs THat THe RelATioNs with thE 3-vEcTors $\mAthbF{d}=\VARepsIloN \matHbf{E}$, $\mAthbf{H}=(1/\mu )\mathbF{B}$, wHich COrrEsponD to (\[dh1\]), RetaIn Their Form in The moViNg frame $S^{\prime
} $ wiTh thE same $\varePsiLoN $ anD $\mU $, i. e., $\maTHbf{D}^{\prIme
}=\VarEpsilon \Mathbf{E}^{\PRimE }$, $\mATHBf{h}^{\prime }=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}^{\priMe }$. tHEn, In Ref. 24, *the uT* (\[JCB\]) *aND tHe SImilar UT FoR* $\maThbf{d}^{\PRime }$ *aNd* $\maTHbF{H}^{\prime }$ (EQs. (3)$^{24}$) *are uSEd To Obtain MInKowski’S cOnsTitUtive EQuatIons* (\[de\]). furthermOre, in rEf. 24, the constitutIVe relations, whICh EXPlICitlY exPress $\mathbf{d}$ and $\MAthbF{H}$ in TErMs oF $\MathbF{E}$ and $\MaTHbF{b}$, are derived (Eqs. (10)$^{24}$) from (\[dE\]). INtroduCing $\mAthbf{D}=\varepsiLon _{0}\mathbf{E}+\MATHbf{P}$ and $\mAthbF{h}=(1/\mU _{0})\Mathbf{B}-\mathbf{M}$ Into EQs. (10)$^{24}$ we find thE ConstituTive eQuations Which explICItly exprEss $\MatHbf{p}$ as A FUnCtion of $\mathbf{e}$ ANd $\maThBf{B}$ $$\begiN{alIgned}
\maThbF{P
1/c^{2})\mathbf{U}\times \ mathbf{E}&=&\m u ( \ma th bf{H }-\m athbf{U}\times \mat hbf{D}),  \label{de}\e nd{al ig n ed}$ $ Eq s. (C ) and ( D )i n  Se c.  8 .$^ {1 } $Fromtha t time,  the equat ion s(\[de\]) are co nsidered t o b e the fundam ent al con st itu t ive e qua tions  for m o ving m edia in t he wholep hysicsc o mm unit y. They are subse q ue n tly derived in  diffe re n tw a ysand  used in n um erous papersa nd t e xtb o oks on the el ectromagnet i sm. 

**5. 1Com p arison  with  M i nko wski’s cons titu tive rela tionst hat are * *

**ob tained  by  me anso fth e 3 -v e cto r s* *$^ { 24} $ **and* *
* *in t he c o v a r iant  ap proa ch**$ ^{25}$****

O newayo f t he de rivat ionof  Eqs.  (\[de \]) i spresented in Re f. 2 4. There,  th es e e qu ation s , i.e.  Eq s.(7),$^{ 24}$ ar e  de ri v e d  u sing Minkowski’s c ru c i al  hypothe sis th a tth e  relatio ns  wi th t h e  3-ve ctor s  $ \mathbf{ D}=\va r ep si lon \ma th bf{E}$ ,$\m ath bf{H} = (1/\ mu )\m athbf{B} $, wh i ch correspondt o (\[dh1\]),r et a i nt heir  fo rm in the m ovin g  fra me $ S ^{ \pr i me
}$ wit ht he same $\varepsilon $  a nd $\m u $,i. e., $\math bf{D}^{\pr i m e 
}=\vare psil o n\ mathbf{E}^{\pr ime } $, $\mathb f {H}^{\pr ime } =(1/\mu)\mathbf{ B } ^{\prime  }$ . T hen , i n Re f. 24, *the U T *  (\[ JC B\]) *a ndthe sim ila r U T f or*  $ \mathbf{D }^{\prim e}$  * an d*$\mat h bf{H}^{\ pr ime  } $ ( Eqs.( 3)$^{2 4}$)*are  u se d  to  obtain Mi n k owsk i’ scons tit ut ive e quat i ons * (\[de \]). Furt her m ore,  i nRef. 24 , the constit ut ive relati on s,whiche x plicitly  express $\mathbf{D}$ a n d $\mat hbf {H}$in t erms of $ \ma thbf{E }$a nd $\m athbf{ B}$,ar e d e r ived( E qs . ( 10 )$^{24}$)f r om(\[de \] ). I ntroduc ing $\mathbf{D}=\v a rep silon _{0}\ma thb f{E} + \ ma thb f {P } $ a nd $\m a t hbf{H}=(1/\mu _ {0})\mathb f{ B }- \mathbf{M} $  in to  Eqs. ( 10)$^{2 4}$ w e  find t he consti tutive eq ua tion s whi ch explici tly expr ess $\mat h bf{P} $  a s a f unc tion o f$\m athbf {E}$ a n d $ \math bf{B}$  $ $\begi n{ali gn ed}
\mat hbf{P
1/c^{2})\mathbf{U}\times \mathbf{E}_&=&\mu (\mathbf{H}-\mathbf{U}\times_\mathbf{D}),  \label{de}\end{aligned}$$Eqs. (C)_and (D)_in_Sec. 8.$^{1}$_From_that time, the_equations (\[de\]) are_considered to be the_fundamental constitutive equations_for_moving media in the whole physics community. They are subsequently derived in different ways_and_used in_numerous_papers_and textbooks on the electromagnetism.

**5.1 Comparison_with Minkowski’s constitutive relations that_are**

**obtained by_means of the 3-vectors**$^{24}$ **and**

**in the covariant approach**$^{25}$****

One_way_of the derivation_of Eqs. (\[de\]) is presented in Ref. 24. There,_these equations, i.e. Eqs. (7),$^{24}$ are_derived using Minkowski’s_crucial_hypothesis_that the relations with_the 3-vectors $\mathbf{D}=\varepsilon \mathbf{E}$, $\mathbf{H}=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}$,_which correspond to (\[dh1\]), retain their_form in the moving frame $S^{\prime
} $_with the same $\varepsilon $ and_$\mu $, i. e., $\mathbf{D}^{\prime
}=\varepsilon_\mathbf{E}^{\prime }$,_$\mathbf{H}^{\prime }=(1/\mu )\mathbf{B}^{\prime }$. Then,_in Ref. 24,_*the UT*_(\[JCB\]) *and the_similar UT for* $\mathbf{D}^{\prime }$ *and*_$\mathbf{H}^{\prime }$ (Eqs._(3)$^{24}$) *are used to obtain Minkowski’s_constitutive_equations* (\[de\]). Furthermore,_in_Ref._24, the_constitutive relations, which_explicitly_express $\mathbf{D}$_and_$\mathbf{H}$ in terms of $\mathbf{E}$ and_$\mathbf{B}$,_are derived (Eqs. (10)$^{24}$) from (\[de\]). Introducing_$\mathbf{D}=\varepsilon _{0}\mathbf{E}+\mathbf{P}$ and $\mathbf{H}=(1/\mu__{0})\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{M}$_into Eqs. (10)$^{24}$ we_find the constitutive equations which_explicitly express $\mathbf{P}$ as a function_of $\mathbf{E}$_and $\mathbf{B}$_$$\begin{aligned}
\mathbf{P