1\]Assume $Y\left( g\right) >0$, then for any $p\in M$,$$\int_{M}Qd\mu +\frac{1}{2}\int_{M}\left\vert Rc_{G_{L,p}^{2}g}\right\vert
_{G_{L,p}^{2}g}^{2}d\mu _{G_{L,p}^{2}g}=16\pi ^{2}.  \label{eq5.12}$$In particular, $\int_{M}Qd\mu \leq 16\pi ^{2}$ and equality holds if and only if $\left( M,g\right) $ is conformal diffeomorphic to the standard $S^{4}$.

Positive mass theorem for Paneitz operator revisited\[sec6\]
============================================================

Throughout this section we will assume $\left( M,g\right) $ is a smooth compact Riemannian manifold with dimension $n>4$.

In [@HuR], for locally conformally flat manifold with $Y\left( g\right)
>0$ and positive Green’s function $G_{P}$, a positive mass theorem for Paneitz operator was proved by a nice calculation. Note that this result plays similar role for $Q$ curvature equation as the classical positive mass theorem for the Yamabe problem ([@LP]). It was observed that similar calculation works for $n=5,6,7$ in [@GM] and for $n=3$ in [@HY3]. Since the case $n=3$ can be covered by Lemma \[lem4.1\], we concentrate on the case $n>4$. The main aim of this section is to show the positive mass theorem for Paneitz operator follows from the formula (\[eq2.1\]).

\[lem6.1\]Assume $n>4$, $Y\left( g\right) >0$, $\ker P=0$. Let $x_{1},\cdots,x_{n}$ be a coordinate near $p$ with $x_{i}\left( p\right) =0$, $r=\left\vert x\right\vert $. If either $M$ is conformally flat near $p$ or $n=5,6,7$, then$$c_{n}G_{P,p}-G_{L,p}^{\frac{n-4}{n-2}}=\text{const}+O^{\left
1\]Assume $ Y\left (g\right) > 0 $, then for any $ p\in M$,$$\int_{M}Qd\mu + \frac{1}{2}\int_{M}\left\vert Rc_{G_{L, p}^{2}g}\right\vert 
 _ { G_{L, p}^{2}g}^{2}d\mu _ { G_{L, p}^{2}g}=16\pi ^{2 }.   \label{eq5.12}$$In particular, $ \int_{M}Qd\mu \leq 16\pi ^{2}$ and equality holds if and only if $ \left (M, g\right) $ is conformal diffeomorphic to the standard $ S^{4}$. 

 Positive mass theorem for Paneitz hustler revisited\[sec6\ ] 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 Throughout this incision we will assume $ \left (M, g\right) $ is a smooth compendious Riemannian manifold with proportion $ n>4$. 

 In [ @HuR ], for locally conformally flat manifold with $ Y\left (g\right) 
 > 0 $ and cocksure Green ’s function $ G_{P}$, a positive batch theorem for Paneitz operator was proved by a courteous calculation. Note that this result play similar role for $ Q$ curvature equation as the authoritative positive mass theorem for the Yamabe problem ([ @LP ]). It was note that similar calculation works for $ n=5,6,7 $ in [ @GM ] and for $ n=3 $ in [ @HY3 ]. Since the font $ n=3 $ can be covered by Lemma \[lem4.1\ ], we centralize on the case $ n>4$. The main aim of this section is to show the plus mass theorem for Paneitz operator follows from the formula (\[eq2.1\ ]). 

 \[lem6.1\]Assume $ n>4 $, $ Y\left (g\right) > 0 $, $ \ker P=0$. Let $ x_{1},\cdots, x_{n}$ be a coordinate near $ p$ with $ x_{i}\left (p\right) = 0 $, $ r=\left\vert x\right\vert $. If either $ M$ is conformally bland near $ p$ or $ n=5,6,7 $, then$$c_{n}G_{P, p}-G_{L, p}^{\frac{n-4}{n-2}}=\text{const}+O^{\left
1\]Asskme $Y\left( g\right) >0$, then fur any $p\in M$,$$\int_{M}Qd\mu +\fcac{1}{2}\int_{M}\meft\vert Rc_{G_{L,p}^{2}g}\right\vert
_{G_{L,p}^{2}g}^{2}d\mu _{G_{L,p}^{2}g}=16\'i ^{2}.  \labeo{eq5.12}$$In particular, $\int_{M}Qa\mu \leq 16\pp ^{2}$ and eqyaliuy holds if and oimy if $\lcyt( M,g\dlght) $ ms conformal dinfeomorphic to the standasd $S^{4}$.

'ositive mass theorem for Paneitz opqrator tegisited\[sec6\]
============================================================

Throoghouu tris avcuion we will assume $\left( M,g\right) $ is a skooth compact Riemannian manifold with fimejsion $n>4$.

In [@HuR], for pocally condormwoly flat mankfold with $Y\left( g\righj)
>0$ and positive Green’s function $G_{O}$, a ppsitive maws thfmrem for Paieitz jperator was proved ty a nive calculation. Nove tyat this result plays similar role for $Z$ curvatuse equation as the xlqssicdl pmsitkce oasa vhekrem flr vhe Yamabe lroblem ([@LP]). Ut was observed thau synilar calculafion wjrhs for $n=5,6,7$ in [@GM] and for $n=3$ in [@HY3]. Since tht cass $n=3$ can be covered by Lwmma \[lem4.1\], we concentraje on the sase $n>4$. The main aim of this section is to show tha posmtkve mwrw hheorem for Paneitz operator follows from the rotmlla (\[eq2.1\]).

\[lem6.1\]Assume $n>4$, $Y\left( g\rignt) >0$, $\lgr P=0$. Let $x_{1},\cdotr,x_{n}$ be a doordinate near $p$ aith $x_{i}\jeft( p\right) =0$, $r=\jeft\fert x\right\vert $. If either $N$ is conformcllt flat near $p$ or $n=5,6,7$, then$$c_{n}G_{P,p}-G_{U,p}^{\frsc{n-4}{n-2}}=\trxt{const}+O^{\left
1\]Assume $Y\left( g\right) >0$, then for any +\frac{1}{2}\int_{M}\left\vert _{G_{L,p}^{2}g}^{2}d\mu _{G_{L,p}^{2}g}=16\pi \label{eq5.12}$$In particular, $\int_{M}Qd\mu holds and only if M,g\right) $ is diffeomorphic to the standard $S^{4}$. Positive theorem for Paneitz operator revisited\[sec6\] ============================================================ Throughout this section we will assume $\left( $ is a smooth compact Riemannian manifold with dimension $n>4$. In [@HuR], for conformally manifold $Y\left( >0$ and positive Green’s function $G_{P}$, a positive mass theorem for Paneitz operator was proved by nice calculation. Note that this result plays similar for $Q$ curvature equation the classical positive mass theorem the problem ([@LP]). was that calculation works for in [@GM] and for $n=3$ in [@HY3]. Since the case $n=3$ can be covered by Lemma \[lem4.1\], concentrate on $n>4$. The aim this is to show mass theorem for Paneitz operator follows (\[eq2.1\]). \[lem6.1\]Assume $n>4$, $Y\left( g\right) >0$, $\ker P=0$. $x_{1},\cdots,x_{n}$ be coordinate near $p$ with $x_{i}\left( p\right) $r=\left\vert x\right\vert $. If either $M$ is conformally near $p$ or $n=5,6,7$, then$$c_{n}G_{P,p}-G_{L,p}^{\frac{n-4}{n-2}}=\text{const}+O^{\left
1\]Assume $Y\left( g\right) >0$, then for aNy $p\in M$,$$\int_{M}qd\mu +\fRac{1}{2}\Int_{m}\lEft\vErt RC_{G_{L,p}^{2}g}\right\vert
_{g_{l,p}^{2}g}^{2}d\Mu _{G_{L,p}^{2}g}=16\pi ^{2}.  \label{eq5.12}$$In partiCular, $\InT_{m}Qd\mU \LeQ 16\pi ^{2}$ anD equaliTY hOLDs iF aNd OnlY iF $\LeFt( M,g\rIghT) $ is confOrmal diffeOmoRpHic to the stanDArD $S^{4}$.

Positive MasS theorem for PAneItz opeRaTor REvisiTed\[Sec6\]
============================================================

ThRoughoUT this sEction we wIlL Assume $\LEft( M,g\riGHT) $ iS a smOoth compact RiemanNIaN Manifold with diMensioN $n>4$.

iN [@HUr], For LocAlly conforMaLly flAT manifoLD wITH $y\leFT( g\right)
>0$ and posItive Green’s FUncTion $G_{P}$, A pOsiTIve masS theoReM For paneitz operAtor Was proved By a nicE CalculaTIon. Note That thIs rEsuLt plAYs SiMilAr ROle FOr $q$ cuRVatUre equatIoN aS the cLassICAL PosiTivE masS theoRem for the YamaBe pRoblEM ([@LP]). it was ObserVed tHaT simiLar calCulatIoN works for $n=5,6,7$ in [@GM] aNd foR $n=3$ in [@HY3]. SinCe tHe CasE $n=3$ Can be COvered By LEmmA \[lem4.1\], we cOncentrATe oN tHE CAsE $n>4$. The main aim of this SeCTIoN is to shoW the poSItIvE Mass theoReM foR PanEITz opeRatoR FoLlows froM the foRMuLa (\[Eq2.1\]).

\[lem6.1\]AsSuMe $n>4$, $Y\leFt( G\riGht) >0$, $\Ker P=0$. LET $x_{1},\cdOts,x_{n}$ bE a coordiNate nEAr $p$ with $x_{i}\left( p\RIght) =0$, $r=\left\vert X\RiGHT\vERt $. If EitHer $M$ is confoRmalLY flaT neaR $P$ oR $n=5,6,7$, tHEn$$c_{n}G_{p,p}-G_{L,p}^{\FrAC{n-4}{N-2}}=\Text{const}+O^{\left
1\]Assume $Y\left( g\right ) >0$, the n for  an y $ p\ in M $,$$ \int_{M}Qd\mu+ \fra c{1}{2}\int_{M}\left\v ert R c_ { G_{L , p} ^{2}g }\right \ ve r t 
_{ G_ {L ,p} ^{ 2 }g }^{2} d\m u _{G_{ L,p}^{2}g} =16 \p i ^{2}.  \la b el {eq5.12}$$ Inparticular,$\i nt_{M} Qd \mu \leq16\ pi ^{ 2}$ an d  equal ity holds  i f  and o n ly if $ \ l ef t( M ,g\right) $ is co n fo r mal diffeomorp hic to  t h es t and ard  $S^{4}$.
P ositi v e masst he o r e m f o r Paneitz ope rator revis i ted \[sec6 \] 
== = ====== ===== == = === =========== ==== ========= ====== = ======= = =

Thro ughout  th issect i on  w e w il l  as s um e $ \ lef t( M,g\r ig ht ) $ i s as m o o th c omp actRiema nnian manifol d w ithd ime nsion  $n>4 $.
In  [@Hu R], fo r loc al ly conformallyflat  manifold  wi th  $Y \l eft(g \right )
> 0$and pos itive G r een ’s f u nc tion $G_{P}$, a po si t i ve  mass th eoremf or  P a neitz op er ato r wa s prove d by anice cal culati o n.  N ote tha tthis r es ult  pl ays s i mila r role  for $Q$  curv a ture equationa s the classic a lp o si t ivemas s theorem f or t h e Ya mabe pr obl e m ([@ LP]).  I t  w a s observed that sim il ar cal culat ion works for  $n=5,6,7$ i n  [@GM] a nd f o r$ n=3$ in [@HY3] . Sin ce the cas e  $n=3$ c an be  covered  by Lemma \ [lem4.1\ ],wecon cen t r at e on the case $ n>4$ .The mai n a im of t his  se cti onis  to showthe posi ti ve  m as s t heore m  for Pan ei tzop era tor f o llowsfromthefo rm u la(\[eq2. 1 \] ) . 

\[ le m6 .1\] Ass um e $n> 4$,$ Y\l eft( g\ right) >0 $,$ \ker  P =0 $. Let$x_{1},\cdots ,x _{n}$ be a  c oor dinate n ear $p$with $x_{i}\left( p\rig h t) =0$,  $r =\lef t\ve rt x\righ t\v ert $.  If either  $M$ i s con fo rma l l y fla t ne ar$p $ or $n=5, 6 , 7$,  then $$ c_{n }G_{P,p }-G_{L,p}^{\frac{n - 4}{ n-2}}=\text{c ons t}+O ^ { \l eft 
1\]Assume $Y\left(_g\right) >0$,_then for any $p\in_M$,$$\int_{M}Qd\mu +\frac{1}{2}\int_{M}\left\vert_Rc_{G_{L,p}^{2}g}\right\vert
_{G_{L,p}^{2}g}^{2}d\mu__{G_{L,p}^{2}g}=16\pi ^{2}.__\label{eq5.12}$$In particular, $\int_{M}Qd\mu_\leq 16\pi ^{2}$_and equality holds if_and only if_$\left(_M,g\right) $ is conformal diffeomorphic to the standard $S^{4}$.

Positive mass theorem for Paneitz operator_revisited\[sec6\]
============================================================

Throughout_this section_we_will_assume $\left( M,g\right) $ is_a smooth compact Riemannian manifold_with dimension_$n>4$.

In [@HuR], for locally conformally flat manifold with_$Y\left(_g\right)
>0$ and positive_Green’s function $G_{P}$, a positive mass theorem for Paneitz_operator was proved by a nice_calculation. Note that_this_result_plays similar role for_$Q$ curvature equation as the classical_positive mass theorem for the Yamabe_problem ([@LP]). It was observed that similar_calculation works for $n=5,6,7$ in [@GM]_and for $n=3$ in [@HY3]._Since the_case $n=3$ can be covered_by Lemma \[lem4.1\],_we concentrate_on the case_$n>4$. The main aim of this_section is to_show the positive mass theorem for_Paneitz_operator follows from_the_formula_(\[eq2.1\]).

\[lem6.1\]Assume $n>4$,_$Y\left( g\right) >0$,_$\ker_P=0$. Let_$x_{1},\cdots,x_{n}$_be a coordinate near $p$ with_$x_{i}\left(_p\right) =0$, $r=\left\vert x\right\vert $. If either_$M$ is conformally flat_near_$p$ or $n=5,6,7$, then$$c_{n}G_{P,p}-G_{L,p}^{\frac{n-4}{n-2}}=\text{const}+O^{\left