 gravity, and see that the calculation is much simpler than the calculation based on the Hilbert-Einstein action (which involves around 100 terms). We leave higher-point scattering amplitudes for the future.

Incidentally, although the Chern-Simons theory in 3D [@Witten:1988hc] and the MacDowell-Mansouri theory in 4D [@MacDowell:1977jt] are also YM-type formulations of gravity, they are first order formulations of GR. One has to first solve the connection in terms of the vielbein before calculating any scattering amplitudes of gravitons. The calculation in those theories is not simpler than a direct computation from the Hilbert-Einstein action.

Perturbative Expansion in $A$
-----------------------------

In this section, we focus on the 3-point vertices relevant for the 3-graviton scattering. We consider 3-point vertices of the action (\[general-action\]) for the traceless part of $h_{\m\n}$.

First, using (\[FFF\]), one can easily see that the second term in the action (\[general-action\]) is (F\^[abc]{}+F\^[bca]{}+F\^[cab]{})(F\_[abc]{}+F\_[bca]{}+F\_[cab]{}) &=& H\^[(0)abc]{} H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} + [O]{}(H\^[(0)]{} A\^2) + [O]{}(A\^4), where $H^{(0)}_{abc}$ is the field strength of the anti-symmetric tensor field $B_{ab}$ defined at the lowest order: H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} \_a B\_[bc]{} + \_b B\_[ca]{} + \_c B\_[ab]{}. A vertex operator involving only external legs of $h$ appears at ${\cal O}(A^4)$ or higher. The 3-point vertices of $h_{\m\n}$ is thus independent of the parameter $\a$.

Secondly, the third term in (\[general-action\]) is the square of F\_[ab]{}\^b &=& \_a A\_b\^b - \_b A\_a\^b + [O]{}(A\^2), where the first term involves the trace of $h_{\m\n}$, and the second term vanishes if we impose the gauge-fixing condition \^b h\_[ab]{} = 0 \[dh=0\] for the graviton field. As a result, in this gauge (\[dh=0\]),
gravity, and see that the calculation is much simpler than the calculation free-base on the Hilbert - Einstein legal action (which involves around 100 terms). We entrust higher - point scatter amplitude for the future. 

 Incidentally, although the Chern - Simons theory in 3D [ @Witten:1988hc ] and the MacDowell - Mansouri theory in 4D [ @MacDowell:1977jt ] are besides YM - type formulations of gravity, they are first club formulations of GR. One take to first solve the association in terms of the vielbein before calculating any scattering amplitude of gravitons. The calculation in those theories is not simpler than a lineal computation from the Hilbert - Einstein natural process. 

 Perturbative Expansion in $ A$ 
 ----------------------------- 

 In this section, we focus on the 3 - point vertex relevant for the 3 - graviton scattering. We consider 3 - point vertices of the action (\[general - action\ ]) for the traceless share of $ h_{\m\n}$. 

 foremost, using (\[FFF\ ]), one can easily see that the second term in the action (\[general - action\ ]) is (F\^[abc]{}+F\^[bca]{}+F\^[cab]{})(F\_[abc]{}+F\_[bca]{}+F\_[cab ] { }) & = & H\^[(0)abc ] { } H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc ] { } + [ O]{}(H\^[(0) ] { } A\^2) + [ O]{}(A\^4), where $ H^{(0)}_{abc}$ is the field strength of the anti - symmetrical tensor field $ B_{ab}$ specify at the lowest decree: H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc ] { } \_a B\_[bc ] { } + \_b B\_[ca ] { } + \_c B\_[ab ] { }. A vertex hustler involving only external legs of $ h$ appears at $ { \cal O}(A^4)$ or higher. The 3 - point vertices of $ h_{\m\n}$ is thus autonomous of the parameter $ \a$. 

 Secondly, the third term in (\[general - action\ ]) is the square of F\_[ab]{}\^b & = & \_a A\_b\^b - \_b A\_a\^b + [ O]{}(A\^2), where the first term involves the trace of $ h_{\m\n}$, and the second term vanishes if we impose the gauge - fixing circumstance \^b h\_[ab ] { } = 0 \[dh=0\ ] for the graviton field. As a consequence, in this gauge (\[dh=0\ ]),
 grwvity, and see that the cxlculation is mocy simpner thzn the cxlculation based on the Hilbxrt-Eunsteun action (which involvds around 100 terms). Qe ltave higher-point scatteriky ampmltudev for the futurg.

Incidentallf, although the Cfexn-Simons theory in 3D [@Witten:1988hc] and thq MacDoeepl-Mansouri thejry pn 4D [@MzbDiwell:1977jt] are also YM-type formumations of gravity, tney are first order formulwtiojs of GR. One has tl first solce trw connection in terms of the vielbgin before calculating any scattdring amplitudew if htavitons. The calcllation in those theosies is not simpler tman a dieect computation from the Hilbert-Einsteyn action.

[exturbative Expansion un $A$
-----------------------------

In jhis vectkin, de rorus on thf 3-pkint vertides relevanr for the 3-graviton xcwnyering. We cohsider 3-pjint vertices of the action (\[general-actimn\]) ror the traceless part if $h_{\m\n}$.

First, using (\[FFF\]), one can qasily see that the second term in the action (\[genaral-artkon\]) if (D\^[ahc]{}+F\^[bca]{}+F\^[cab]{})(F\_[abc]{}+F\_[bca]{}+F\_[cab]{}) &=& H\^[(0)abc]{} H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} + [O]{}(H\^[(0)]{} A\^2) + [O]{}(A\^4), wrsrt $H^{(0)}_{sbc}$ is the fiejd strength ov yre anti-symmettic tensor field $B_{ab}$ defined at the lowewt order: R\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} \_a B\_[bc]{} + \_b B\_[ca]{} + \_c B\_[ab]{}. A vertwx operator pnvooving only externap legs of $h$ appgars ay ${\cal O}(A^4)$ or higher. The 3-'oint bertices of $h_{\m\n}$ is tgjs independent ow tme [arameter $\a$.

Secondly, the thyrd term mn (\[geueral-actkon\]) os the square of F\_[ab]{}\^b &=& \_a A\_b\^b - \_b A\_a\^b + [O]{}(A\^2), ahere tve first tfrm involves the trace of $h_{\m\n}$, aiv the second jerk vdnishes nf we lmpose the gaugq-fixing conditnon \^b h\_[ay]{} = 0 \[dh=0\] for the ggaviton fmeld. As a refult, in this cwuge (\[dh=0\]),
gravity, and see that the calculation is than calculation based the Hilbert-Einstein action We higher-point scattering amplitudes the future. Incidentally, the Chern-Simons theory in 3D [@Witten:1988hc] the MacDowell-Mansouri theory in 4D [@MacDowell:1977jt] are also YM-type formulations of gravity, they first order formulations of GR. One has to first solve the connection in of vielbein calculating scattering amplitudes of gravitons. The calculation in those theories is not simpler than a direct computation the Hilbert-Einstein action. Perturbative Expansion in $A$ ----------------------------- this section, we focus the 3-point vertices relevant for 3-graviton We consider vertices the (\[general-action\]) for the part of $h_{\m\n}$. First, using (\[FFF\]), one can easily see that the second term in the action is (F\^[abc]{}+F\^[bca]{}+F\^[cab]{})(F\_[abc]{}+F\_[bca]{}+F\_[cab]{}) H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} + A\^2) [O]{}(A\^4), $H^{(0)}_{abc}$ is the of the anti-symmetric tensor field $B_{ab}$ lowest order: H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} \_a B\_[bc]{} + \_b B\_[ca]{} \_c B\_[ab]{}. vertex operator involving only external legs $h$ appears at ${\cal O}(A^4)$ or higher. The vertices of $h_{\m\n}$ is thus independent of the parameter $\a$. Secondly, the third term in the square of F\_[ab]{}\^b \_a A\_b\^b - A\_a\^b [O]{}(A\^2), the term involves trace of $h_{\m\n}$, and the second term vanishes if we impose gauge-fixing condition \^b h\_[ab]{} = 0 \[dh=0\] for the graviton a in this gauge
 gravity, and see that the calcuLation is muCh simPleR thAn The cAlcuLation based on tHE HilBert-Einstein action (whicH invoLvES aroUNd 100 Terms). we leave HIgHER-poInT sCatTeRInG amplItuDes for tHe future.

InCidEnTally, althougH ThE Chern-SimoNs tHeory in 3D [@WittEn:1988hC] and thE MAcDOWell-MAnsOuri tHeory iN 4d [@MacDoWell:1977jt] are AlSO YM-typE FormulaTIOnS of gRavity, they are firsT OrDEr formulations Of GR. OnE hAS tO FIrsT soLve the connEcTion iN Terms of THe VIELbeIN before calculAting any scaTTerIng ampLiTudES of graVitonS. THE caLculation in ThosE theories Is not sIMpler thAN a direcT compuTatIon From THe hiLbeRt-eInsTEiN acTIon.

perturbaTiVe expanSion IN $a$
-----------------------------

iN thiS seCtioN, we foCus on the 3-point VerTiceS RelEvant For thE 3-graViTon scAtteriNg. We cOnSider 3-point vertiCes oF the actioN (\[geNeRal-AcTion\]) fOR the trAceLesS part of $H_{\m\n}$.

FirsT, UsiNg (\[fff\]), OnE can easily see that tHe SECoNd term in The actIOn (\[GeNEral-actiOn\]) Is (F\^[Abc]{}+F\^[BCA]{}+F\^[cab]{})(f\_[abc]{}+f\_[BcA]{}+F\_[cab]{}) &=& H\^[(0)abC]{} H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} + [O]{}(h\^[(0)]{} a\^2) + [O]{}(a\^4), wHere $H^{(0)}_{abC}$ iS the fiElD stRenGth of THe anTi-symmEtric tenSor fiELd $B_{ab}$ defined at THe lowest order: h\^[(0)]{}\_[AbC]{} \_A b\_[bC]{} + \_B B\_[ca]{} + \_C B\_[aB]{}. A vertex opeRatoR InvoLvinG OnLy eXTernaL legs Of $H$ ApPEars at ${\cal O}(A^4)$ or higher. thE 3-point VertiCes of $h_{\m\n}$ is thuS independeNT OF the paraMeteR $\A$.

SECondly, the third Term iN (\[general-acTIon\]) is the SquarE of F\_[ab]{}\^b &=& \_a a\_b\^b - \_b A\_a\^b + [O]{}(A\^2), WHEre the fiRst TerM inVolVES tHe trace of $h_{\m\n}$, aND The sEcOnd term VanIshes if We iMpoSe tHe gAuGe-fixing cOndition \^B h\_[Ab]{} = 0 \[Dh=0\] FoR thE gravITon field. as A reSuLt, iN this GAuge (\[dh=0\]),
 gravity, and see that the  calculati on is  mu chsi mple r th an the calcula t ionbased on the Hilbert-E inste in acti o n(whic h invol v es a rou nd  1 00te r ms ). We  le ave hig her-pointsca tt ering amplit u de s for thefut ure.

Incide nta lly, a lt hou g h the  Ch ern-S imonst heoryin 3D [@W it t en:198 8 hc] and t he  Mac Dowell-Mansouri t h eo r y in 4D [@MacD owell: 19 7 7j t ]  ar e a lso YM-typ eformu l ationso fg r a vit y , they are fi rst order f o rmu lation sofG R. One  hasto fir st solve th e co nnectionin ter m s of th e  vielbe in bef ore  ca lcul a ti ng  an ys cat t er ing amp litudesof  g ravit ons. T h e  cal cul atio n inthose theorie s i s no t  si mpler  than  a d ir ect c omputa tionfr om the Hilbert- Eins tein acti on. 
Per tu rbati v e Expa nsi onin $A$------- - --- -- - - - -- -----------

In th is s ec tion, we  focus on  t h e 3-poin tver tice s relev antf or  the 3-g ravito n  s ca ttering .We con si der  3- point vert ices o f the ac tion( \[general-acti o n\]) for thet ra c e le s s pa rtof $h_{\m\n }$.Firs t, u s in g ( \ [FFF\ ]), o ne ca n  easily see that th esecond  term  in the actio n (\[gener a l - action\] ) is (F \ ^[abc]{}+F\^[b ca]{} +F\^[cab]{ } )(F\_[ab c]{}+ F\_[bca] {}+F\_[ca b ] {}) &=&H\^ [(0 )ab c]{ } H\ ^[(0)]{}\_[ab c ] {} +  [ O]{}(H\ ^[( 0)]{} A \^2 ) +  [O ]{} (A \^4), whe re $H^{( 0) }_ {a bc }$is th e  field s tr eng th  of  thea nti-sy mmetr ic t en so r  fi eld $B_ { ab } $  def in ed  atthe  l owest  ord e r:H\^[(0) ]{}\_[abc ]{} \_aB\ _[ bc]{} +  \_b B\_[ca]{ }+ \_c B\_[ ab ]{} . A ve r t ex opera tor involving only exte r nal leg s o f $h$  app ears at $ {\c al O}( A^4 ) $ or h igher.  The3- poi n t  vert i c es  of  $ h_{\m\n}$i s  th us in de pend ent ofthe parameter $\a$ . 

S econdly, thethi rd t e r min( \[ g ene ra l -ac t i on\]) is the sq uare of F\ _[ a b] {}\^b &=&\ _aA\ _b\^b -  \_b A\ _a\^b + [O]{} (A\^2), w here thefi rstt e rminvolves t he trace  of $h_{\ m \n}$, an d the  se cond t er m v anish es ifw e i mpose  the g au ge-fix ing c on dition \ ^b h\_[ab]{} = 0 \[dh=0 \] for  thegra viton fie ld. Asa result,  inthis gauge  (\ [dh =0\]) ,
 gravity,_and see_that the calculation is_much simpler_than_the calculation_based_on the Hilbert-Einstein_action (which involves_around 100 terms). We_leave higher-point scattering_amplitudes_for the future.

Incidentally, although the Chern-Simons theory in 3D [@Witten:1988hc] and the MacDowell-Mansouri theory_in_4D [@MacDowell:1977jt]_are_also_YM-type formulations of gravity, they_are first order formulations of_GR. One_has to first solve the connection in terms_of_the vielbein before_calculating any scattering amplitudes of gravitons. The calculation in_those theories is not simpler than_a direct computation_from_the_Hilbert-Einstein action.

Perturbative Expansion in_$A$
-----------------------------

In this section, we focus on_the 3-point vertices relevant for the_3-graviton scattering. We consider 3-point vertices of_the action (\[general-action\]) for the traceless_part of $h_{\m\n}$.

First, using (\[FFF\]),_one can_easily see that the second_term in the_action (\[general-action\])_is (F\^[abc]{}+F\^[bca]{}+F\^[cab]{})(F\_[abc]{}+F\_[bca]{}+F\_[cab]{}) &=&_H\^[(0)abc]{} H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} + [O]{}(H\^[(0)]{} A\^2) +_[O]{}(A\^4), where $H^{(0)}_{abc}$_is the field strength of the_anti-symmetric_tensor field $B_{ab}$_defined_at_the lowest_order: H\^[(0)]{}\_[abc]{} \_a_B\_[bc]{}_+ \_b_B\_[ca]{}_+ \_c B\_[ab]{}. A vertex operator_involving_only external legs of $h$ appears at_${\cal O}(A^4)$ or higher._The_3-point vertices of $h_{\m\n}$_is thus independent of the_parameter $\a$.

Secondly, the third term in_(\[general-action\]) is_the square_of F\_[ab]{}\^b &=& \_a A\_b\^b - \_b A\_a\^b + [O]{}(A\^2), where_the first term involves the trace_of $h_{\m\n}$, and the_second term_vanishes_if we impose_the_gauge-fixing condition_\^b h\_[ab]{} = 0 \[dh=0\] for the_graviton field._As a result, in this gauge_(\[dh=0\]),