(x)$ iff there exists trigonometrically consecutive $f',g' \in \cV(x)$ such that $f' \preceq f \prec g \preceq g'$ and $\|f\| \|g\| \leq \rho \|f'\| \|g'\|$.

The monopolist problem {#sec:Monopolist}
----------------------

A monopolist has the ability to produce goods, which have two characteristics and may thus be represented by a point $q \in \R^2$. The manufacturing cost $\operatorname{Cost}(q) : \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is known and fixed a-priori. Infinite costs account for products which are “meaningless”, or impossible to build. The selling price $\pi : \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is fixed unilaterally by the monopolist except for the “null” product $(0,0)$, which must be available for free ($\pi(0,0) \leq 0$). The characteristics of the consumers are also represented by a point $z\in \R^2$, and the utility of product $q$ to consumer $z$ is modeled by the scalar product between their characteristics $$\label{eq:Utility}
\cU(q,z) := \<q,z\>.$$ More general utility pairings $\cU$ are considered in [@Figalli:2011tz], yet the numerical implementation of the resulting optimization problems remains out of reach, see [@MERIGOT:tr] for a discussion. All consumers $z$ are rational, “screen” the proposed price catalog $\pi$, and choose the product of maximal *net* utility $\<q,z\> - \pi(q)$ (i.e. raw utility minus price). Introducing the Legendre-Fenchel dual $U$ of the prices $\pi$: for all $z\in \R^2$ $$U(z): = \pi^*(z) := \sup_{q\in \R^2} \, \<q,z\> - \pi(z),$$ we observe that the optimal product[^5] for consumer $z$ is $\nabla U(z)$, which is sold at the price $$\label{eq:PriceU}
\pi(\nabla U(z)) = \<\nabla U(z), z\> - U(z).$$ The net utility function $U$ is
( x)$ iff there exists trigonometrically consecutive $ f',g' \in \cV(x)$ such that $ f' \preceq f \prec g \preceq g'$ and $ \|f\| \|g\| \leq \rho \|f'\| \|g'\|$. 

 The monopolist trouble { # sec: Monopolist } 
 ---------------------- 

 A monopolist have the ability to produce goods, which get two characteristic and may thus be represented by a compass point $ q \in \R^2$. The fabrication cost $ \operatorname{Cost}(q): \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is known and fixed a - priori. Infinite costs account for product which are “ meaningless ”, or impossible to build. The selling price $ \pi: \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is specify unilaterally by the monopolist except for the “ null ” product $ (0,0)$, which must be available for free ($ \pi(0,0) \leq 0 $). The characteristics of the consumers are also represented by a detail $ z\in \R^2 $, and the utility of product $ q$ to consumer $ z$ is modeled by the scalar intersection between their characteristics $ $ \label{eq: Utility } 
 \cU(q, z): = \<q, z\>.$$ More general utility coupling $ \cU$ are considered in [ @Figalli:2011tz ], yet the numerical implementation of the resulting optimization problems remain out of reach, see [ @MERIGOT: tr ] for a discussion. All consumers $ z$ are rational, “ screen ” the proposed price catalog $ \pi$, and choose the product of maximal * net * utility $ \<q, z\ > - \pi(q)$ (i.e.   raw utility minus price). Introducing the Legendre - Fenchel dual $ U$ of the prices $ \pi$: for all $ z\in \R^2 $ $ $ U(z ): = \pi^*(z): = \sup_{q\in \R^2 } \, \<q, z\ > - \pi(z),$$ we observe that the optimal product[^5 ] for consumer $ z$ is $ \nabla U(z)$, which is sell at the price $ $ \label{eq: PriceU } 
 \pi(\nabla U(z) ) = \<\nabla U(z), z\ > - U(z).$$ The net utility program affair $ U$ is
(x)$ ivf there exists trigonomttrically consecujice $f',g' \mn \cV(x)$ auch thag $f' \preceq f \prec g \preceq g'$ abd $\|f\| \|t\| \leq \rho \|f'\| \|g'\|$.

The monopulist prohlem {#sec:Nonokolist}
----------------------

A monopolisv has thc abimlty tm produce goods, which hava two charactesirtncs and may thus be represented by a point $a \ln \R^2$. The manufwctugigg ckst $\operatorname{Cost}(q) : \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\ihfty\}$ is known and ficed a-priori. Infinite costs acclunt for products ahich are “mgznigtless”, or impussible to build. The sglling price $\pi : \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is fnxed unilatgxqllj by the monipolift except fov the “ngll” procuct $(0,0)$, which muxt ue acailable for free ($\pi(0,0) \neq 0$). The characterystics of tke consumers are also rwpresgnted by x poknt $z\mn \D^2$, and hhe utility or product $q$ to consumer $z$ is mpdqoed by the sczlar pwoquct between their characteristics $$\laben{eq:Htility}
\cU(q,z) := \<q,z\>.$$ More geberal utility pairingd $\cU$ are sonsidered in [@Figalli:2011tz], yet the numerical implemettatikv oy the fwsklting optimization problems remains out of rqzcn, xee [@MERIGOT:tr] nor a discussion. Akl cpgsumers $z$ are ratiouzl, “screen” the proposfd pricg cataoog $\pi$, anq chpose the product of maximal *net* utility $\<w,z\> - \pi(q)$ (i.e. raw utilnty minus prnce). Injroducong the Legendre-Fenchel duam $U$ of the orices $\pi$: wor all $z\in \R^2$ $$U(z): = \pp^*(z) := \vup_{q\in \R^2} \, \<q,z\> - \pi(z),$$ we obserde that tie opcimal pruducj[^5] for cjnsumer $z$ ls $\nanna U(z)$, which is solf at jhe prhce $$\label{ee:PriceU}
\pi(\nabla U(z)) = \<\nabla U(z), z\> - N(v).$$ The net utikidy xunction $U$ is
(x)$ iff there exists trigonometrically consecutive $f',g' such $f' \preceq \prec g \preceq \rho \|g'\|$. The monopolist {#sec:Monopolist} ---------------------- A has the ability to produce goods, have two characteristics and may thus be represented by a point $q \in The manufacturing cost $\operatorname{Cost}(q) : \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is known and fixed Infinite account products are “meaningless”, or impossible to build. The selling price $\pi : \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is unilaterally by the monopolist except for the “null” $(0,0)$, which must be for free ($\pi(0,0) \leq 0$). characteristics the consumers also by point $z\in \R^2$, the utility of product $q$ to consumer $z$ is modeled by the scalar product between their characteristics \cU(q,z) := general utility $\cU$ considered [@Figalli:2011tz], yet the of the resulting optimization problems remains see [@MERIGOT:tr] for a discussion. All consumers $z$ rational, “screen” proposed price catalog $\pi$, and choose product of maximal *net* utility $\<q,z\> - \pi(q)$ raw utility minus price). Introducing the Legendre-Fenchel dual $U$ of the prices $\pi$: for all $$U(z): = \pi^*(z) := \R^2} \, \<q,z\> \pi(z),$$ observe the product[^5] for $z$ is $\nabla U(z)$, which is sold at the price $$\label{eq:PriceU} U(z)) = \<\nabla U(z), z\> - U(z).$$ The net utility is
(x)$ iff there exists trigonometRically conSecutIve $F',g' \iN \cv(x)$ suCh thAt $f' \preceq f \prec G \PrecEq g'$ and $\|f\| \|g\| \leq \rho \|f'\| \|g'\|$.

The monOpoliSt PRoblEM {#sEc:MonOpolist}
----------------------

a MoNOPolIsT hAs tHe ABiLity tO prOduce goOds, which haVe tWo CharacteristICs And may thus Be rEpresented by A poInt $q \in \r^2$. THe mANufacTurIng coSt $\operATornamE{Cost}(q) : \R^2 \to \r\cUP \{+\infty\}$ IS known aND FiXed a-Priori. Infinite cosTS aCCount for producTs whicH aRE “mEANinGleSs”, or impossIbLe to bUIld. The sELlING PriCE $\pi : \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infTy\}$ is fixed unILatErally By The MOnopolIst exCePT foR the “null” proDuct $(0,0)$, Which must Be avaiLAble for FRee ($\pi(0,0) \leQ 0$). The chAraCteRistICs Of The CoNSumERs Are ALso RepresenTeD bY a poiNt $z\iN \r^2$, AND the UtiLity Of proDuct $q$ to consumEr $z$ Is moDEleD by thE scalAr prOdUct beTween tHeir cHaRacteristics $$\labEl{eq:utility}
\cU(Q,z) := \<q,Z\>.$$ MOre GeNeral UTility PaiRinGs $\cU$ are ConsideREd iN [@FIGALlI:2011tz], yet the numerical ImPLEmEntation Of the rESuLtINg optimiZaTioN proBLEms reMainS OuT of reach, See [@MERigOt:tR] for a diScUssion. alL coNsuMers $z$ ARe raTional, “Screen” thE propOSed price cataloG $\Pi$, and choose thE PrODUcT Of maXimAl *net* utilitY $\<q,z\> - \pI(Q)$ (i.e. rAw utILiTy mINus prIce). InTrODuCIng the Legendre-FenchEl Dual $U$ oF the pRices $\pi$: for all $Z\in \R^2$ $$U(z): = \pi^*(z) := \sUP_{Q\In \R^2} \, \<q,z\> - \pi(z),$$ We obSErVE that the optimaL prodUct[^5] for consUMer $z$ is $\naBla U(z)$, Which is sOld at the pRICe $$\label{eQ:PrIceu}
\pi(\NabLA u(z)) = \<\Nabla U(z), z\> - U(z).$$ The NET utiLiTy functIon $u$ is
(x)$ iff there exists trig onometrica lly c ons ecu ti ve $ f',g ' \in \cV(x)$s uchthat $f' \preceq f \pr ec g\p r eceq g' $ and  $\|f\| \| g \ | \ le q\rh o\ |f '\| \ |g' \|$.

T he monopol ist  p roblem {#sec : Mo nopolist}--- ------------ --- ----
Amon o polis t h as th e abil i ty toproduce g oo d s, whi c h havet w ochar acteristics and m a yt hus be represe nted b ya  p o i nt$q\in \R^2$.  T he ma n ufactur i ng c o st$ \operatorname {Cost}(q) : \R^ 2 \to\R \cu p  \{+\i nfty\ }$ isknown and f ixed  a-priori . Infi n ite cos t s accou nt for  pr odu ctsw hi ch  ar e“ mea n in gle s s”,  or impo ss ib le to  bui l d . Thesel ling  pric e $\pi : \R^2  \t o \R \ cup  \{+\ infty \}$is  fixe d unil atera ll y by the monopo list  except f orth e “ nu ll” p r oduct$(0 ,0) $, whic h mustb e a va i l a bl e for free ($\pi(0 ,0 ) \l eq 0$).The ch a ra ct e risticsof  th e co n s umers  are al so repre sented by  a  point$z \in \R ^2 $,and  theu tili ty ofproduct$q$ t o  consumer $z$i s modeled byt he s ca l ar p rod uct between  the i r ch arac t er ist i cs $$ \labe l{ e q: U tility}
\cU(q,z) :=  \ <q,z\> .$$ M ore general u tility pai r i n gs $\cU$  are co n sidered in [@F igall i:2011tz], yet thenumer ical imp lementati o n  of theres ult ing  op t i mi zation proble m s  rem ai ns outofreach,see  [@ MER IGO T: tr] for a  discuss io n.  A ll  co nsume r s $z$ ar erat io nal , “sc r een” t he pr opos ed  p r ice  catalo g  $ \ p i$,an dchoo seth e pro duct ofmaximal  *net* ut ili t y $\ <q ,z \> - \p i(q)$ (i.e. r aw  utility m in usprice) . Introduc ing the Legendre-Fenche l  dual $ U$of th e pr ices $\pi $:for al l $ z \in \R ^2$ $$ U(z):  =  \p i ^ *(z): =  \ sup _{ q\in \R^2} \ , \ <q,z\ >- \p i(z),$$  we observe that t h e o ptimal produc t[^ 5] f o r  c ons u me r  $z $i s $ \ n abla U(z)$, whi ch is sold  a t  t he price $ $ \la be l{eq:Pr iceU}
\ pi(\n a bla U(z )) = \<\n abla U(z) ,z\>- U(z ).$$ The n et utili ty functi o n $U$ is 
(x)$ iff_there exists_trigonometrically consecutive $f',g' \in_\cV(x)$ such_that_$f' \preceq_f_\prec g \preceq_g'$ and $\|f\|_\|g\| \leq \rho \|f'\|_\|g'\|$.

The monopolist problem_{#sec:Monopolist}
----------------------

A_monopolist has the ability to produce goods, which have two characteristics and may thus_be_represented by_a_point_$q \in \R^2$. The manufacturing_cost $\operatorname{Cost}(q) : \R^2 \to_\R\cup \{+\infty\}$_is known and fixed a-priori. Infinite costs account_for_products which are_“meaningless”, or impossible to build. The selling price $\pi_: \R^2 \to \R\cup \{+\infty\}$ is_fixed unilaterally by_the_monopolist_except for the “null”_product $(0,0)$, which must be available_for free ($\pi(0,0) \leq 0$). The_characteristics of the consumers are also represented_by a point $z\in \R^2$, and_the utility of product $q$_to consumer_$z$ is modeled by the_scalar product between_their characteristics_$$\label{eq:Utility}
\cU(q,z) := \<q,z\>.$$_More general utility pairings $\cU$ are_considered in [@Figalli:2011tz],_yet the numerical implementation of the_resulting_optimization problems remains_out_of_reach, see_[@MERIGOT:tr] for a_discussion._All consumers_$z$_are rational, “screen” the proposed price_catalog_$\pi$, and choose the product of maximal_*net* utility $\<q,z\> -_\pi(q)$_(i.e. raw utility minus price)._Introducing the Legendre-Fenchel dual $U$_of the prices $\pi$: for all_$z\in \R^2$_$$U(z): =_\pi^*(z) := \sup_{q\in \R^2} \, \<q,z\> - \pi(z),$$ we observe that_the optimal product[^5] for consumer $z$_is $\nabla U(z)$, which_is sold_at_the price $$\label{eq:PriceU}
\pi(\nabla_U(z))_= \<\nabla_U(z), z\> - U(z).$$ The net utility_function $U$_is