 \alpha_\textsc{qed}\varepsilon^2 |U_{\alpha 4}|^2$, dominated by $|U_{\mu 4}|$ since all current accelerator neutrino beams are composed mainly of muon neutrinos. This production can happen off the whole nucleus in a coherent way or off individual nucleons. For $m_{Z^\prime} \lesssim 100$ MeV, the production will be mainly coherent, but for heavier masses, such as the ones considered in [@Ballett:2018ynz], incoherent upscattering dominates. In Fig. \[fig:cross\_section\], we show the NP cross section at the benchmark point of [@Bertuzzo:2018itn] and compare it with the quasi-elastic cross section. By superimposing the cross section on the neutrino fluxes of and MiniBooNE, we make it explicit that the larger energies at and CHARM-II are ideal to produce $\nu_4$. Once produced, $\nu_4$ predominantly decays into a neutrino and a dielectron pair, $\nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha e^+ e^-$, either via an on-shell [@Bertuzzo:2018itn] or off-shell [@Ballett:2018ynz] $Z^\prime$ depending on the choice of $m_4$ and $m_{Z^\prime}$. In this work, we restrict our discussion to the $m_4 > m_{Z^\prime}$ case, where the upscattering is mainly coherent and is followed by a chain of prompt two body decays $\nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha (Z^\prime \to e^+ e^-)$. The on-shell $Z^\prime$ is required to decay into an overlapping $e^+e^-$ pair, setting a lower bound on its mass of a few MeV. Experimentally, however, $m_{Z^\prime} > 10$ MeV for $e \epsilon \sim 10^{-4}$ to avoid beam dump constraints [@Bauer:2018onh]. Increasing $m_{Z^\prime}$ increases the ratio of incoherent to coherent events and makes the electron pair less overlapping. Even though we focus on overlapping $e^+e^-$ pairs, we note that a significant fraction of events would appear as well-separated showers or as a pair of showers with large energy asymmetry, similarly to neutral current (NC) $\pi^0$ events. The asymmetric events also contribute to the MiniBooNE excess and offer a different
\alpha_\textsc{qed}\varepsilon^2 |U_{\alpha 4}|^2 $, dominated by $ |U_{\mu 4}|$ since all current accelerator neutrino beams are composed chiefly of muon neutrino. This output can happen off the solid lens nucleus in a coherent way or off individual nucleons. For $ m_{Z^\prime } \lesssim 100 $ MeV, the output will be chiefly coherent, but for heavier masses, such as the ones considered in   [ @Ballett:2018ynz ], incoherent upscattering dominates. In Fig.   \[fig: cross\_section\ ], we show the NP hybridization section at the benchmark point of   [ @Bertuzzo:2018itn ] and compare it with the quasi - elastic hybridization section. By superimposing the cross section on the neutrino fluxes of and MiniBooNE, we lay down it explicit that the larger energy at and CHARM - II are ideal to produce $ \nu_4$. Once produced, $ \nu_4 $ predominantly decays into a neutrino and a dielectron pair, $ \nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha e^+ e^-$, either via an on - carapace   [ @Bertuzzo:2018itn ] or off - shell   [ @Ballett:2018ynz ] $ Z^\prime$ depending on the choice of $ m_4 $ and $ m_{Z^\prime}$. In this work, we restrict our discussion to the $ m_4 > m_{Z^\prime}$ shell, where the upscattering is mainly coherent and is followed by a chain of prompt two body decays $ \nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha (Z^\prime \to e^+ e^-)$. The on - shell $ Z^\prime$ is required to decay into an overlapping $ e^+e^-$ pair, setting a lower bound on its mass of a few MeV. Experimentally, however, $ m_{Z^\prime } > 10 $ MeV for $ e \epsilon \sim 10^{-4}$ to avoid beam shit constraint   [ @Bauer:2018onh ]. Increasing $ m_{Z^\prime}$ increase the proportion of incoherent to coherent consequence and makes the electron pair less imbrication. Even though we focus on overlap $ e^+e^-$ pairs, we note that a meaning fraction of events would appear as well - separated showers or as a pair of showers with large energy asymmetry, similarly to neutral current (NC) $ \pi^0 $ events. The asymmetric event also lend to the MiniBooNE excess and offer a different
 \aloha_\textsc{qed}\varepsilon^2 |U_{\xlpha 4}|^2$, dominateb by $|U_{\mn 4}|$ sincs all cufrent accelerator neutrino bxams are xomposed mainly of muov neutrinls. This prodnction can happei off thc whomc nucnxus in a coherekt way or oxf individual tuzlzons. For $m_{Z^\prime} \lesssim 100$ MeV, the prjductiom aill be mainly cohtregt, bhn nor heavier masses, such as the ohes convidered in [@Balkett:2018ynz], incoherent upscattfrinh dominates. In Fig. \[vig:cross\_secjjon\], qe show the VP cross stccion at the benchmark point of [@Bertuzzo:2018itn] xnd cpmpare it qirh hve quasi-elawtic bross section. By supesimposimg the cross scctioi on the neutrino fluxes mf and MiniBooNE, wg make it ax'licit that the largee wnerghes dt ave CFARJ-IM ade idewl vo produce $\hu_4$. Once proeuced, $\nu_4$ predominanuly eecays into a neutrynj and a dielectron pair, $\nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha e^+ e^-$, sither via an on-shell [@Beetuzzo:2018itn] or off-shell [@Hallett:2018yns] $Z^\prime$ depending on the choice of $m_4$ and $m_{Z^\prime}$. In tiir wirh, qe restrict our discussion to the $m_4 > m_{Z^\prime}$ cafs, ehvre the upscatterlng is mainly cohetejt wnd is followgd by a chzin of prompt two hody desays $\bu_4 \to \nu_\ajpha (Z^\prime \to e^+ e^-)$. The on-shell $Z^\prime$ is rezyired to decay intl an overla'ping $g^+e^-$ pait, setting a lower bound on jts mass of a few MeB. Experimentally, fowvver, $m_{Z^\prime} > 10$ MeV for $e \epsiljn \sim 10^{-4}$ ti avpid beao dukp conftraints [@Baker:2018onm]. Increasing $m_{Z^\primf}$ incteases the ratio of incoherent to coherent evenvx and makes jhe elvctron panr lesx overlapping. Even though wg focus ou overuapping $e^+e^-$ pairs, xe note that a significand fraction of events roule appear as dell-separated xhowers og cs a pair of showers with lerge snergy asymmetrv, wimilarly to neitrxl sugreit (NC) $\[i^0$ events. Tha ashmmdyric dvents also zonttibute to the MiniBomNE sxcess and offer a dlfferent
\alpha_\textsc{qed}\varepsilon^2 |U_{\alpha 4}|^2$, dominated by $|U_{\mu 4}|$ current neutrino beams composed mainly of happen the whole nucleus a coherent way off individual nucleons. For $m_{Z^\prime} \lesssim MeV, the production will be mainly coherent, but for heavier masses, such as ones considered in [@Ballett:2018ynz], incoherent upscattering dominates. In Fig. \[fig:cross\_section\], we show the cross at benchmark of [@Bertuzzo:2018itn] and compare it with the quasi-elastic cross section. By superimposing the cross section on neutrino fluxes of and MiniBooNE, we make it that the larger energies and CHARM-II are ideal to $\nu_4$. produced, $\nu_4$ decays a and a dielectron $\nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha e^+ e^-$, either via an on-shell [@Bertuzzo:2018itn] or off-shell [@Ballett:2018ynz] $Z^\prime$ depending on the of $m_4$ In this we our to the $m_4 case, where the upscattering is mainly followed by a chain of prompt two body $\nu_4 \to (Z^\prime \to e^+ e^-)$. The on-shell is required to decay into an overlapping $e^+e^-$ setting a lower bound on its mass of a few MeV. Experimentally, however, $m_{Z^\prime} > for $e \epsilon \sim to avoid beam constraints Increasing increases ratio of to coherent events and makes the electron pair less overlapping. Even we focus on overlapping $e^+e^-$ pairs, we note that a of would appear as showers or as a of with large energy asymmetry, neutral (NC) asymmetric also to the MiniBooNE excess offer a different
 \alpha_\textsc{qed}\varepsilon^2 |U_{\Alpha 4}|^2$, dominAted bY $|U_{\mU 4}|$ siNcE all CurrEnt accelerator NEutrIno beams are composed maiNly of MuON neuTRiNos. ThIs produCTiON Can HaPpEn oFf THe Whole NucLeus in a Coherent waY or OfF individual nUClEons. For $m_{Z^\pRimE} \lesssim 100$ MeV, tHe pRoductIoN wiLL be maInlY coheRent, buT For heaVier masseS, sUCh as thE Ones conSIDeRed iN [@Ballett:2018ynz], incoheREnT Upscattering doMinateS. IN fiG. \[FIg:cRosS\_section\], we ShOw the np cross sECtION At tHE benchmark poiNt of [@BertuzzO:2018Itn] And comPaRe iT With thE quasI-eLAstIc cross sectIon. BY superimpOsing tHE cross sECtion on The neuTriNo fLuxeS Of AnD MiNibOoNe, We MakE It eXplicit tHaT tHe larGer eNERGIes aT anD CHArM-II aRe ideal to prodUce $\Nu_4$. OnCE prOduceD, $\nu_4$ prEdomInAntly Decays Into a NeUtrino and a dieleCtroN pair, $\nu_4 \to \Nu_\aLpHa e^+ E^-$, eIther VIa an on-SheLl [@BErtuzzo:2018Itn] or ofF-SheLl [@bALLeTt:2018ynz] $Z^\prime$ dependiNg ON ThE choice oF $m_4$ and $m_{z^\PrImE}$. in this woRk, We rEstrICT our dIscuSSiOn to the $m_4 > M_{Z^\primE}$ CaSe, Where thE uPscattErIng Is mAinly COherEnt and Is followEd by a CHain of prompt twO Body decays $\nu_4 \tO \Nu_\ALPhA (z^\priMe \tO e^+ e^-)$. The on-sheLl $Z^\pRIme$ iS reqUIrEd tO Decay Into aN oVErLApping $e^+e^-$ pair, setting A lOwer boUnd on Its mass of a few meV. ExperimENTAlly, howeVer, $m_{z^\PrIMe} > 10$ MeV for $e \epsilOn \sim 10^{-4}$ To avoid beaM Dump consTrainTs [@Bauer:2018oNh]. IncreasING $m_{Z^\prime}$ IncReaSes The RATiO of incoherent TO CoheReNt eventS anD makes tHe eLecTroN paIr Less overlApping. EvEn ThOuGh We fOcus oN OverlappInG $e^+e^-$ PaIrs, We notE That a sIgnifIcanT fRaCTioN of evenTS wOULd apPeAr As weLl-sEpArateD shoWErs Or as a paIr of showeRs wITh laRgE eNergy asYmmetry, similaRlY to neutral CuRreNt (NC) $\pi^0$ EVEnts. The aSymmetric events also contRIbute to The miniBOoNE Excess and OffEr a difFerENt
 \alpha_\textsc{qed}\varep silon^2 |U _{\al pha  4} |^ 2$,domi nated by $|U_{ \ mu 4 }|$ since all currentaccel er a torn eu trino  beamsa re c omp os ed  ma in l yof mu onneutrin os. This p rod uc tion can hap p en  off the w hol e nucleus in  acohere nt  wa y  or o ffindiv idualn ucleon s. For $m _{ Z ^\prim e } \less s i m100$  MeV, the product i on will be mainly  coher en t ,b u t f orheavier ma ss es, s u ch as t h eo n e s c o nsidered in [ @Ballett:20 1 8yn z], in co her e nt ups catte ri n g d ominates. I n Fi g. \[fig: cross\ _ section \ ], we s how th e N P c ross se ct ion  a t  th e  b enc h mar k pointof  [ @Bert uzzo : 2 0 1 8itn ] a nd c ompar e it with the  qu asi- e las tic c rosssect io n. By  super impos in g the cross sec tion  on the n eut ri nofl uxeso f andMin iBo oNE, we  make i t  ex pl i c i tthat the larger en er g i es  at andCHARM- I Iar e  ideal t opro duce $ \nu_4 $. O n ce  produce d, $\n u _4 $predomi na ntly d ec ays  in to an eutr ino an d a diel ectro n  pair, $\nu_4\ to \nu_\alpha e^ + e^ - $, e ith er via an o n-sh e ll [ @Ber t uz zo: 2 018it n] or  o f f- s hell [@Ballett:2018 yn z] $Z^ \prim e$ dependingon the cho i c e  of $m_4 $ an d  $ m _{Z^\prime}$.In th is work, w e  restric t our  discuss ion to th e $m_4 > m _{Z ^\p rim e}$ c as e, where theu p scat te ring is  ma inly co her ent  an d i sfollowedby a cha in  o fpr omp t two body dec ay s $ \n u_4  \to\ nu_\al pha ( Z^\p ri me \to  e^+ e^ - )$ . Theon -s hell  $Z ^\ prime $ is req uired t o decay i nto an o ve rl apping$e^+e^-$ pair ,setting alo wer  bound o n its ma ss of a few MeV. Experi m entally , h oweve r, $ m_{Z^\pri me}  > 10$  Me V  for $ e \eps ilon\s im1 0 ^{-4} $ to  av oi d beam dum p con strai nt s [@ Bauer:2 018onh]. Increasin g  $m _{Z^\prime}$inc reas e s  t her at i o o fi nco h e rent to coheren t events a nd ma kes the el e ctr on  pair l ess ove rlapp i ng. Eve n thoughwe focuson  ove r l app ing $e^+e^ -$ pairs , we note thata  s ignif ica nt fra ct ion  of e ventsw oul d app ear as  w ell-se parat ed  showers  or as a pair of shower s with  larg e e nergy asy mme t ry,  similarl y to  neutral c urr ent  (NC)  $\ p i^0$even t s.  Th e  asym metr i c eventsa ls o c o n tr ibute to th e M ini BooNE  ex c ess an d of fer a different
 \alpha_\textsc{qed}\varepsilon^2_|U_{\alpha 4}|^2$,_dominated by $|U_{\mu 4}|$_since all_current_accelerator neutrino_beams_are composed mainly_of muon neutrinos._This production can happen_off the whole_nucleus_in a coherent way or off individual nucleons. For $m_{Z^\prime} \lesssim 100$ MeV, the_production_will be_mainly_coherent,_but for heavier masses, such_as the ones considered in [@Ballett:2018ynz],_incoherent upscattering_dominates. In Fig. \[fig:cross\_section\], we show the NP cross_section_at the benchmark_point of [@Bertuzzo:2018itn] and compare it with the quasi-elastic cross_section. By superimposing the cross section_on the neutrino_fluxes_of_and MiniBooNE, we make_it explicit that the larger energies_at and CHARM-II are ideal to_produce $\nu_4$. Once produced, $\nu_4$ predominantly decays_into a neutrino and a dielectron_pair, $\nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha e^+_e^-$, either_via an on-shell [@Bertuzzo:2018itn] or off-shell [@Ballett:2018ynz]_$Z^\prime$ depending on_the choice_of $m_4$ and_$m_{Z^\prime}$. In this work, we restrict_our discussion to_the $m_4 > m_{Z^\prime}$ case, where_the_upscattering is mainly_coherent_and_is followed_by a chain_of_prompt two_body_decays $\nu_4 \to \nu_\alpha (Z^\prime \to_e^+_e^-)$. The on-shell $Z^\prime$ is required to_decay into an overlapping_$e^+e^-$_pair, setting a lower_bound on its mass of_a few MeV. Experimentally, however, $m_{Z^\prime}_> 10$_MeV for_$e \epsilon \sim 10^{-4}$ to avoid beam dump constraints [@Bauer:2018onh]. Increasing $m_{Z^\prime}$_increases the ratio of incoherent to_coherent events and makes_the electron_pair_less overlapping. Even_though_we focus_on overlapping $e^+e^-$ pairs, we note that_a significant_fraction of events would appear as_well-separated showers or as_a_pair of showers with large energy_asymmetry, similarly to neutral current (NC)_$\pi^0$ events. The asymmetric events_also_contribute_to the MiniBooNE excess and_offer a different