z = 4$. In the absence of a theoretical study that takes the mass-dependent effects into account in the intermediate $p_T$ region, the only point we can make here is that it is not hard to produce a $p/\pi$ ratio that exceeds 1 in the scale invariant calculation in the recombination model, but it does so in a region where both theory and experiment need refinement. Judging by what is self-evident in Fig. 6, we see no strong need for any exotic mechanism for proton production (as proposed in [@vg]) beyond the conventional subprocess where three quarks recombine to form a proton.

![Proton-to-pion ratio: solid line is the scaling distribution from calculation; data (preliminary) are from Ref.[@ts]. The dotted and dashed lines are eyeball fits of the data as extrapolations from the scaling result.](fig6.eps){width="55.00000%"}

Conclusion
==========

The discovery of a scale invariant distribution $\Phi (z)$ for pion production at intermediate and high values of $p_T$ in heavy-ion collisions ranging over energies in excess of an order of magnitude of variation is an important phenomenology observation that should be checked experimentally in great detail. Additional energy points should be added not only to strengthen the validity of the scaling behavior, but also to find the onset of scaling violation, if it exists.

The phenomenological properties of hadron production provide useful insights into the hadronization process and into the nature of the quark system just before they turn into hadrons. The usual approach to the study of heavy-ion collisions is from inside out, following the evolution of the dense matter, either in terms of hydrodynamical flow or of hard parton scattering and subsequent hadronization by fragmentation [@gvw]. Our approach pursued here is from outside in, by starting from the observed scaling behavior of the pions produced and deriving the momentum distribution of the quarks that can give rise to such a behavior. That is accomplished by use of the recombination model. There is no direct way to check the validity of the quark distribution thus obtained. However, we have used it to determine the proton distribution at high $p_T$ where the mass effects are unimportant. The data on proton production have not yet reached that regime where the predicted scaling distribution can be checked. In the region where data exist on the $p/\pi$ ratio we find that our calculated result, though not reliable, is in rough
z = 4$. In the absence of a theoretical study that takes the mass - pendent effect into account in the intermediate $ p_T$ region, the alone point we can make here is that it is not intemperate to grow a $ p/\pi$ ratio that exceed 1 in the scale invariant calculation in the recombination mannequin, but it does so in a area where both theory and experiment need refinement. Judging by what is self - evident in Fig.   6, we see no strong motivation for any exotic mechanism for proton production (as proposed in [ @vg ]) beyond the ceremonious subprocess where three quarks recombine to form a proton. 

! [ Proton - to - pion proportion: solid production line is the scaling distribution from calculation; datum (preliminary) are from Ref.[@ts ]. The dotted and dashed lines are eyeball fits of the datum as extrapolations from the scaling result.](fig6.eps){width="55.00000% " } 

 Conclusion 
 = = = = = = = = = = 

 The discovery of a scale invariant distribution $ \Phi (z)$ for pion production at intermediate and high values of $ p_T$ in heavy - ion collisions ranging over energies in excess of an order of magnitude of variation is an important phenomenology observation that should be checked experimentally in bang-up detail. Additional department of energy point should be lend not only to strengthen the validity of the scaling behavior, but also to find the onset of scale violation, if it exists. 

 The phenomenological properties of hadron production provide useful insight into the hadronization process and into the nature of the quark system just before they turn into hadron. The usual access to the study of heavy - ion collisions is from inside out, following the evolution of the dense topic, either in terms of hydrodynamical flow or of hard parton scattering and subsequent hadronization by fragmentation [ @gvw ]. Our approach pursued here is from outside in, by starting from the observed scaling demeanor of the pions produced and deriving the momentum distribution of the quarks that can give ascent to such a behavior. That is carry through by use of the recombination exemplar. There is no lineal way to check the validity of the quark distribution therefore obtained. However, we have used it to determine the proton distribution at high $ p_T$ where the mass effects are unimportant. The data on proton production have not yet reached that regime where the predict scaling distribution can be checked. In the region where datum exist on the $ p/\pi$ ratio we find that our calculated result, though not reliable, is in rough
z = 4$. In the absence of a theuretical study jhqt takxs the jass-depevdent effects into account ii thw inttgmediate $p_T$ region, thd only popnt we cab majw here is vgat it lf nof harb vo produce a $p/\pl$ ratio thad exceeds 1 in dhd dcale invariant calculation in the wecombimahion model, but it cjes ao in a region where both theory ahd expegiment need refinrment. Judging by what is sflf-egident in Fig. 6, we sfe no stront neqe for any exutic mechanism for projon production (as proposed in [@vg]) beyoud the convguriojdl subprocews whvre three quavls recmmbine yo form a protpn.

![Pcotob-to-pion ratio: solid lmne is the scaling dystributimn from calculation; dqta (ptelimhnarh) ard fdok Def.[@ts]. Hhe dotted ans dashed libes are eyeball fitx jd the data as extra[ojations from the scaling result.](fig6.eps){wigth="55.00000%"}

Donclusion
==========

The discovery of a scale invariant distribueion $\Phi (z)$ for pion production at intermediate ang higi xalbcf if $p_T$ in heavy-ion collisions ranging over energyss ik excess of an ovder of magnitude pf vstiation is an kmportcht phenomenology obsfrvatiog thar should fe cnecked experimentally in grwat detail. Abdirional energy poincs should be addgd not only to strengthen the valjdity of thf scaling cehavior, but alsu tp xind the onset of scaling diolation, if nt existr.

The phenoienologicap proiarties of hadron pgoducjion psovide usevul insights into the hadronizavmon process amd inno the nacure on the quark syseem just beforg they tuxn intu hadrons. Nhe usual approach tj the study ox heavy-ion conlisions is drom inside uut, following yhe evolunijn od the dense matter, eijhsr in terms of kvdtidynamical floe of os jacd pawdon scatteritg avd ribseqjent hadronlzagion by fragmentation [@gvf]. Oud approach pursued hcre is frim outsiqe in, by starying from the obsegved vcauing nehwvior of the pions produced ans derivinh tme momentum dystrlbutyon of the quarks that can give rise to such a beiavior. That is accompliwhed by use of the tecpmbination kodel. There is no direct way to chwck the validity pf the quark distribufion tvus ohtained. However, we have used it to determine the proton distribution at hugh $p_T$ where the mzss rffecns cre unimpjrtait. The data on pronon production have not yet reacied that ragnme where the predicted scalimg distribution can be checked. In the rsgion whrre data exist on the $p/\pi$ ratio we find that our calculsted resylt, tgough not celiable, is in rough
z = 4$. In the absence of study takes the effects into account the point we can here is that is not hard to produce a ratio that exceeds 1 in the scale invariant calculation in the recombination model, it does so in a region where both theory and experiment need refinement. by is in 6, we see no strong need for any exotic mechanism for proton production (as proposed in beyond the conventional subprocess where three quarks recombine form a proton. ![Proton-to-pion solid line is the scaling from data (preliminary) from The and dashed lines eyeball fits of the data as extrapolations from the scaling result.](fig6.eps){width="55.00000%"} Conclusion ========== The discovery of a invariant distribution for pion at and values of $p_T$ collisions ranging over energies in excess of magnitude of variation is an important phenomenology that should checked experimentally in great detail. Additional points should be added not only to strengthen validity of the scaling behavior, but also to find the onset of scaling violation, if The phenomenological properties of production provide useful into hadronization and the nature the quark system just before they turn into hadrons. The usual to the study of heavy-ion collisions is from inside out, evolution the dense matter, in terms of hydrodynamical or hard parton scattering and by [@gvw]. here from in, by starting from observed scaling behavior of the produced and deriving the that can give rise to such a behavior. is accomplished by use of the recombination There is no direct way to check the validity of the quark thus obtained. have used it to determine the proton distribution high $p_T$ where the effects are unimportant. The data on proton production have yet that regime the predicted scaling can be checked. the region where on the ratio find result, though not reliable, is in
z = 4$. In the absence of a theoreticAl study thaT takeS thE maSs-DepeNdenT effects into acCOunt In the intermediate $p_T$ regIon, thE oNLy poINt We can Make herE Is THAt iT iS nOt hArD To ProduCe a $P/\pi$ ratiO that exceeDs 1 iN tHe scale invarIAnT calculatiOn iN the recombinAtiOn modeL, bUt iT Does sO in A regiOn wherE Both thEory and exPeRIment nEEd refinEMEnT. JudGing by what is self-eVIdENt in Fig. 6, we see no Strong NeED fOR Any ExoTic mechaniSm For prOTon prodUCtION (As pROposed in [@vg]) beyOnd the conveNTioNal subPrOceSS where Three QuARks Recombine to Form A proton.

![PrOton-to-PIon ratiO: Solid liNe is thE scAliNg diSTrIbUtiOn FRom CAlCulATioN; data (preLiMiNary) aRe frOM rEF.[@ts]. THe dOtteD and dAshed lines are EyeBall FIts Of the Data aS extRaPolatIons frOm the ScAling result.](fig6.ePs){wiDth="55.00000%"}

ConcluSioN
==========

THe dIsCoverY Of a scaLe iNvaRiant diStributIOn $\PHi (Z)$ FOR pIon production at intErMEDiAte and hiGh valuES oF $p_t$ In heavy-iOn ColLisiONS rangIng oVEr Energies In exceSS oF aN order oF mAgnituDe Of vAriAtion IS an iMportaNt phenomEnoloGY observation thAT should be checKEd EXPeRImenTalLy in great deTail. aDditIonaL EnErgY PointS shouLd BE aDDed not only to strengtHeN the vaLiditY of the scaling Behavior, buT ALSo to find The oNSeT Of scaling violaTion, iF it exists.

THE phenomeNologIcal propErties of hADRon produCtiOn pRovIde USEfUl insights intO THe haDrOnizatiOn pRocess aNd iNto The NatUrE of the quaRk system JuSt BeFoRe tHey tuRN into hadRoNs. THe UsuAl appROach to The stUdy oF hEaVY-ioN collisIOnS IS froM iNsIde oUt, fOlLowinG the EVolUtion of The dense mAttER, eitHeR iN terms oF hydrodynamicAl Flow or of haRd ParTon scaTTEring and Subsequent hadronization BY fragmeNtaTion [@gVw]. OuR approach PurSued heRe iS From ouTside iN, by stArTinG FRom thE OBsErvEd Scaling behAVIor Of the PiOns pRoduced And deriving the momeNTum Distribution oF thE quaRKS tHat CAn GIve RiSE to SUCh a behavior. That Is accompliShED bY use of the rEComBiNation mOdel. TheRe is nO Direct wAy to check The validiTy Of thE QUarK distributIon thus oBtained. HoWEver, wE HaVe useD it To deteRmIne The prOton diSTriButioN at higH $p_t$ where The maSs Effects aRe unimportant. The data on pRoton pRoducTioN have not yEt rEAchEd that regIme wHere the preDicTed ScaliNg dIStribUtioN CaN be CHeckeD. In tHE region whERe DatA EXiSt on the $p/\pi$ rATIO we Find tHat OUr calcUlatEd result, though not REliable, is in rouGh
z = 4$. In the absence ofa theoreti cal s tud y t ha t ta kesthe mass-depen d enteffects into account i n the  i n term e di ate $ p_T$ re g io n ,  th eon lypo i nt  we c anmake he re is that  it  i s not hard t o  p roduce a $ p/\ pi$ ratio th atexceed s1 i n  thesca le in varian t  calcu lation in  t h e reco m binatio n mo del,  but it does so i n  a region where b oth th eo r ya n d e xpe riment nee drefin e ment. J u dg i n g  by what is self- evident inF ig.  6, we  s een o stro ng ne ed for  any exotic  mec hanism fo r prot o n produ c tion (a s prop ose d i n [@ v g] )bey on d  th e  c onv e nti onal sub pr oc ess w here t h r ee q uar ks r ecomb ine to form a  pr oton . 

! [Prot on-to -pio nratio : soli d lin eis the scalingdist ributionfro mcal cu latio n ; data  (p rel iminary ) are f r omRe f . [ @t s]. The dotted and  d a s he d linesare ey e ba ll fits ofth e d ataa s  extr apol a ti ons from  the s c al in g resul t. ](fig6 .e ps) {wi dth=" 5 5.00 000%"} 

Conclu sion= =========

The discovery ofa  s c a le inva ria nt distribu tion $\Ph i (z ) $for pionprodu ct i on at intermediate and  h igh va luesof $p_T$ in h eavy-ion c o l l isions r angi n go ver energies i n exc ess of ano rder ofmagni tude ofvariation i s an imp ort ant  ph eno m e no logy observat i o n th at  should  be  checke d e xpe rim ent al ly in gre at detai l.  A dd it ion al en e rgy poin ts  sh ou ldbe ad d ed not  only  tost re n gth en thev al i d ityof  t he s cal in g beh avio r , b ut also  to findthe onse tof  scalin g violation,if  it exists .
Th e phen o m enologic al properties of hadron product ion  prov ideuseful in sig hts in tot he had roniza tionpr oce s s  andi n to  th enature oft h e q uarksy stem  just b efore they turn in t o h adrons. The u sua l ap p r oa cht ot hest u dyo f  heavy-ion coll isions isfr o minside out ,  fo ll owing t he evol ution of thedense mat ter, eith er  int e rms  of hydrod ynamical  flow oro f har d  p arton  sc atteri ng  an d sub sequen t  ha droni zation  b y frag menta ti on [@gvw ]. Our approach pursued  hereis fr omoutside i n,b y s tarting f romthe observ edsca lingbeh a viorof t h epio n s pro duce d  and deri v in g t h e  m omentum dis t r i but ion o f t h e quar ks t hat can give rise to such a beha vior . Tha t i s  acc om plished by use  of  t h e  recombi na tion model.  There i sn o dir ect wa y to c heck th e va l idityof t hequark dis tri bu t ion thu sob t ained.  How ev er, we  haveu sedi t  to determine th e pro t o n dis t rib ution  a t high$ p_T$  where the  mass effec ts are  uni mport ant. Th edata o n p ro ton produc t ion havenot y et reac he d th atregime  whe r e  thepred ic ted  scalingd i st r ib ut i oncanbe ch ec ked.  In the r e gion whe red ata exi st  on t he $p/ \ pi $ ratio we f ind  that o ur calcula t ed r e su l t, th ough n ot rel iable,i s i nrough
z =_4$. In_the absence of a_theoretical study_that_takes the_mass-dependent_effects into account_in the intermediate_$p_T$ region, the only_point we can_make_here is that it is not hard to produce a $p/\pi$ ratio that exceeds_1_in the_scale_invariant_calculation in the recombination model,_but it does so in_a region_where both theory and experiment need refinement. Judging_by_what is self-evident_in Fig. 6, we see no strong need for any_exotic mechanism for proton production (as_proposed in [@vg])_beyond_the_conventional subprocess where three_quarks recombine to form a proton.

![Proton-to-pion_ratio: solid line is the scaling_distribution from calculation; data (preliminary) are from_Ref.[@ts]. The dotted and dashed lines_are eyeball fits of the_data as_extrapolations from the scaling result.](fig6.eps){width="55.00000%"}

Conclusion
==========

The_discovery of a_scale invariant_distribution $\Phi (z)$_for pion production at intermediate and_high values of_$p_T$ in heavy-ion collisions ranging over_energies_in excess of_an_order_of magnitude_of variation is_an_important phenomenology_observation_that should be checked experimentally in_great_detail. Additional energy points should be added_not only to strengthen_the_validity of the scaling_behavior, but also to find_the onset of scaling violation, if_it exists.

The_phenomenological properties_of hadron production provide useful insights into the hadronization process and_into the nature of the quark_system just before they_turn into_hadrons._The usual approach_to_the study_of heavy-ion collisions is from inside out,_following the_evolution of the dense matter, either_in terms of hydrodynamical_flow_or of hard parton scattering and_subsequent hadronization by fragmentation [@gvw]. Our_approach pursued here is from_outside_in,_by starting from the observed_scaling behavior of the pions produced_and deriving the_momentum distribution of the quarks that can_give_rise to such a behavior. That_is_accomplished by use of the recombination_model._There_is no direct way to_check the validity of the quark_distribution thus obtained. However, we have used it to_determine the proton_distribution at high $p_T$ where_the_mass_effects are unimportant. The data on proton production have not_yet reached_that regime where_the predicted scaling distribution can be checked. In the region_where data exist on the $p/\pi$ ratio_we find that our calculated result, though not reliable, is in_rough