 OD/OH fluorescence efficiency ratio (cf. figure 1 of A’Hearn et al. [@AHearn]). This opens the possibility to routinely measure both the [$^{16}$O/$^{18}$O]{} and D/H ratios from the ground, together with the [$^{12}$C/$^{13}$C]{} and [$^{14}$N/$^{15}$N]{} ratios, for a statistically significant sample of comets of different types (e.g. Oort-cloud, Halley-type, and hopefully Jupiter-family comets although the latter are usually fainter). The measurement of D/H is especially important since it allows to limit the contribution of comets to the terrestrial water, the high D abundance implying that no more than about 10 to 30% of Earth’s water can be attributed to comets (e.g. Eberhardt et al. [@Eberhardt], Dauphas et al. [@Dauphas], Morbidelli et al. [@Morbidelli]). However, only a full census of D/H in comets could answer this question. In particular, if Jupiter-family comets, thought to have formed in farther and colder places in the Solar System, are characterized by an even higher D/H, closer to the ratio measured in the interstellar medium water, then the fraction of cometary H$_2$O brought onto the Earth could be even smaller.

We thank the referee, Dominique Bockelée-Morvan, for comments which helped to significantly improve the manuscript. We are also grateful to Paul Feldman and Hal Weaver for useful discussions.

Abrams, M.C., Davis, S.P., Rao, M.L.P., Engleman Jr, R. 1994, J. Mol. Spec. 165, 57 A’Hearn, M.F., Ohlmacher, J.T., Schleicher, D.G. 1983, Technical Report TR AP83-044 (College Park: University of Maryland) A’Hearn, M.F., Schleicher, D.G., West, R.A. 1985,, 297, 826 Arpigny, C., Jehin, E., Manfroid, J., et al. 2003, Science, 301, 1522 Ayres, T.R., Plymate, C., Keller, C.U. 2006,,165, 618 Ball
OD / OH fluorescence efficiency ratio (cf. figure   1 of A’Hearn et al. [ @AHearn ]). This opens the hypothesis to routinely quantify both the [ $ ^{16}$O/$^{18}$O ] { }   and D / H proportion from the ground, in concert with the [ $ ^{12}$C/$^{13}$C ] { }   and [ $ ^{14}$N/$^{15}$N ] { }   ratios, for a statistically meaning sample of comets of unlike types (e.g. Oort - cloud, Halley - type, and hopefully Jupiter - class comets although the latter are usually fainter). The measurement of D / H is specially important since it allows to specify the contribution of comet to the terrestrial water, the eminent D abundance implying that no more than about 10 to 30% of Earth ’s body of water can be attributed to comets (e.g. Eberhardt et al. [ @Eberhardt ], Dauphas et al. [ @Dauphas ], Morbidelli et al. [ @Morbidelli ]). However, entirely a full census of D / H in comets could answer this question. In especial, if Jupiter - family comets, thought to have formed in farther and cold places in the Solar System, are characterized by an even higher D / H, closer to the ratio measure in the interstellar medium water, then the fraction of cometary H$_2$O brought onto the Earth could be even smaller. 

 We thank the referee, Dominique Bockelée - Morvan, for comments which helped to significantly improve the manuscript. We are also grateful to Paul Feldman and Hal Weaver for utilitarian discussion. 

 Abrams, M.C., Davis, S.P., Rao, M.L.P., Engleman Jr, R. 1994, J. Mol. Spec. 165, 57 A’Hearn, M.F., Ohlmacher, J.T., Schleicher, D.G. 1983, Technical Report TR AP83 - 044 (College Park: University of Maryland) A’Hearn, M.F., Schleicher, D.G., West, R.A. 1985, , 297, 826 Arpigny, C., Jehin, E., Manfroid, J., et al. 2003, Science, 301, 1522 Ayres, T.R., Plymate, C., Keller, C.U. 2006,,165, 618 Ball
 OD/LH fluorescence efficiengy ratio (cf. figute 1 of A’Hxarn et al. [@AHeafn]). This opens the possibilitb to routunely measure both the [$^{16}$O/$^{18}$O]{} and D/H ratios drom rhe ground, togethev witg the [$^{12}$R/$^{13}$C]{} and [$^{14}$N/$^{15}$N]{} ratios, nor a stativtically signixizaut sample of comets of different typqs (e.g. Oprh-cloud, Halley-tipe, amq holvfmlly Jupiter-family comets althoufh the natter are usially fainter). The measuremfnt lf D/H is especiallj important sinsw it allows go limit the contributjon of comets to the terrestriau watzr, the high D abktdance implbing trat no more bnan abmut 10 to 30% of Earth’s waber cen bw attributed to cometv (e.g. Eberhardt et wl. [@Eberhasdc], Dauphas et al. [@Dauphqs], Morbhdelni eg al. [@Modbmdemli]). Hoaevxr, only a fhll census if D/H in comets coukd qnswer this qhestiog. Yn particular, if Jupiter-family comets, tvoufht to have formed in fqrther and colder plafes in thq Solar System, are characterized by an even highes D/H, rlusex to tfw gatio measured in the interstellar medium watqd, uhek the fraction on cometary H$_2$O broubhh pgto the Earth could be even smaller.

We thwnk the refeeee, Dominyque Bockelée-Morvan, for comments which helpeb ti significantly im'rove the mauuscrikt. We sre also grateful to Pabl Felsman and Hap Weaver rur useful discusrioks.

Atrams, M.C., Davis, S.P., Rao, M.L.P., Qngleman Or, R. 1994, J. Mol. Rpec. 165, 57 A’Hewrn, M.F., Ohllachev, J.T., Schleicher, D.G. 1983, Techuical Report TR AP83-044 (College Park: University of Maryland) A’Hearm, K.F., Vchleichzr, D.G., Eest, R.A. 1985,, 297, 826 Ar[igny, C., Jehin, G., Manfroib, J., et al. 2003, Scienbe, 301, 1522 Ayrev, T.R., Plymatq, C., Keller, C.U. 2006,,165, 618 Ball
OD/OH fluorescence efficiency ratio (cf. figure 1 et [@AHearn]). This the possibility to and ratios from the together with the and [$^{14}$N/$^{15}$N]{} ratios, for a statistically sample of comets of different types (e.g. Oort-cloud, Halley-type, and hopefully Jupiter-family comets the latter are usually fainter). The measurement of D/H is especially important since allows limit contribution comets to the terrestrial water, the high D abundance implying that no more than about 10 30% of Earth’s water can be attributed to (e.g. Eberhardt et al. Dauphas et al. [@Dauphas], Morbidelli al. However, only full of in comets could this question. In particular, if Jupiter-family comets, thought to have formed in farther and colder places in Solar System, by an higher closer the ratio measured interstellar medium water, then the fraction brought onto the Earth could be even smaller. thank the Dominique Bockelée-Morvan, for comments which helped significantly improve the manuscript. We are also grateful Paul Feldman and Hal Weaver for useful discussions. Abrams, M.C., Davis, S.P., Rao, M.L.P., Engleman 1994, J. Mol. Spec. 57 A’Hearn, M.F., J.T., D.G. Technical TR AP83-044 Park: University of Maryland) A’Hearn, M.F., Schleicher, D.G., West, R.A. 1985,, 826 Arpigny, C., Jehin, E., Manfroid, J., et al. 2003, 1522 T.R., Plymate, C., C.U. 2006,,165, 618 Ball
 OD/OH fluorescence efficiencY ratio (cf. fiGure 1 oF A’HEarN eT al. [@AhearN]). This opens the pOSsibIlity to routinely measurE both ThE [$^{16}$o/$^{18}$O]{} anD d/H RatioS from thE GrOUNd, tOgEtHer WiTH tHe [$^{12}$C/$^{13}$C]{} aNd [$^{14}$N/$^{15}$n]{} ratios, For a statisTicAlLy significanT SaMple of comeTs oF different tyPes (E.g. Oort-ClOud, hAlley-TypE, and hOpefulLY JupitEr-family cOmETs althOUgh the lATTeR are Usually fainter). The MEaSUrement of D/H is eSpeciaLlY ImPORtaNt sInce it alloWs To limIT the conTRiBUTIon OF comets to the tErrestrial wATer, The higH D AbuNDance iMplyiNg THat No more than aBout 10 To 30% of Earth’S water CAn be attRIbuted tO cometS (e.g. ebeRharDT eT aL. [@EbErHArdT], daUphAS et Al. [@DauphaS], MOrBidelLi et AL. [@mORbidEllI]). HowEver, oNly a full censuS of d/H in COmeTs couLd ansWer tHiS quesTion. In PartiCuLar, if Jupiter-famIly cOmets, thouGht To HavE fOrmed IN farthEr aNd cOlder plAces in tHE SoLaR sYStEm, are characterized By AN EvEn higher d/H, closER tO tHE ratio meAsUreD in tHE InterStelLAr Medium waTer, theN ThE fRaction Of CometaRy h$_2$O bRouGht onTO the earth cOuld be evEn smaLLer.

We thank the rEFeree, DominiquE boCKElÉE-MorVan, For comments WhicH HelpEd to SIgNifICantlY imprOvE ThE Manuscript. We are also GrAteful To PauL Feldman and HaL Weaver for USEFul discuSsioNS.

ABRams, M.C., Davis, S.P., RAo, M.L.P., engleman Jr, r. 1994, j. Mol. Spec. 165, 57 a’HearN, M.F., OhlmaCher, J.T., SchLEIcher, D.G. 1983, TEchNicAl REpoRT tR aP83-044 (College Park: uNIverSiTy of MarYlaNd) A’HearN, M.F., schLeiCheR, D.g., West, R.A. 1985,, 297, 826 ArPigny, C., JeHiN, E., maNfRoiD, J., et aL. 2003, science, 301, 1522 AYrEs, T.r., PLymAte, C., KELler, C.U. 2006,,165, 618 ball
 OD/OH fluorescence effici ency ratio  (cf.  fi gur e1 of  A’H earn et al. [@ A Hear n]). This opens the po ssibi li t y to ro utine ly meas u re b oth  t he  [$ ^{ 1 6} $O/$^ {18 }$O]{}and D/H ra tio sfrom the gro u nd , together  wi th the [$^{1 2}$ C/$^{1 3} $C] { } and  [$ ^{14} $N/$^{ 1 5}$N]{ } ratios,  f o r a st a tistica l l ysign ificant sample of co m ets of differe nt typ es (e . g . O ort -cloud, Ha ll ey-ty p e, andh op e f u lly Jupiter-famil y comets al t hou gh the  l att e r areusual ly fai nter). Themeas urement o f D/Hi s espec i ally im portan t s inc e it al lo wsto lim i tthe con tributio nof  come ts t o t h e te rre stri al wa ter, the high  Dabun d anc e imp lying  tha tno mo re tha n abo ut  10 to 30% of E arth ’s watercan  b e a tt ribut e d to c ome ts(e.g. E berhard t  et  a l . [@ Eberhardt], Daupha se t  a l. [@Dau phas], Mo rb i delli et  a l.[@Mo r b idell i]). Ho wever, o nly af ul lcensusof  D/H i ncom ets  coul d  ans wer th is quest ion.I n particular,i f Jupiter-fam i ly c om e ts,tho ught to hav e fo r medin f a rt her and c older  p l ac e s in the Solar Syst em , arechara cterized by a n even hig h e r  D/H, cl oser to the ratio meas uredin the int e rstellar  medi um water , then th e fraction  of  co met ary H $_ 2$O brought o n t o th eEarth c oul d be ev ensma lle r.
W e thank t he refer ee ,Do mi niq ue Bo c kelée-Mo rv an,  f orcomme n ts whi ch he lped  t os ign ificant l yi m prov eth e ma nus cr ipt.We a r e a lso gra teful toPau l  Fel dm an  and Ha l Weaver forus eful discu ss ion s.

Ab r a ms, M.C. , Davis, S.P., Rao, M.L . P., Eng lem an Jr , R.  1994, J.  Mo l. Spe c.1 65, 57  A’Hea rn, M .F .,O h lmach e r ,J.T .,  Schleiche r ,  D. G. 19 83 , Te chnical  Report TR AP83-04 4  (C ollege Park:Uni vers i t yofM ar y lan d) A’H e a rn, M.F., Schle icher, D.G ., We st, R.A. 1 9 85, ,297, 82 6 Arpig ny, C . , Jehin , E., Man froid, J. ,et a l .  20 03, Scienc e, 301,1522 Ayre s , T.R . ,Plyma te,  C., K el ler , C.U . 2006 , ,16 5, 61 8 Ball 
 OD/OH_fluorescence efficiency_ratio (cf. figure 1 of_A’Hearn et_al._[@AHearn]). This_opens_the possibility to_routinely measure both_the [$^{16}$O/$^{18}$O]{} and D/H ratios_from the ground,_together_with the [$^{12}$C/$^{13}$C]{} and [$^{14}$N/$^{15}$N]{} ratios, for a statistically significant sample of comets of different types_(e.g._Oort-cloud, Halley-type,_and_hopefully_Jupiter-family comets although the latter_are usually fainter). The measurement_of D/H_is especially important since it allows to limit_the_contribution of comets_to the terrestrial water, the high D abundance implying_that no more than about 10_to 30% of_Earth’s_water_can be attributed to_comets (e.g. Eberhardt et al. [@Eberhardt],_Dauphas et al. [@Dauphas], Morbidelli et_al. [@Morbidelli]). However, only a full census_of D/H in comets could answer_this question. In particular, if_Jupiter-family comets,_thought to have formed in_farther and colder_places in_the Solar System,_are characterized by an even higher_D/H, closer to_the ratio measured in the interstellar_medium_water, then the_fraction_of_cometary H$_2$O_brought onto the_Earth_could be_even_smaller.

We thank the referee, Dominique Bockelée-Morvan,_for_comments which helped to significantly improve the_manuscript. We are also_grateful_to Paul Feldman and_Hal Weaver for useful discussions.

Abrams,_M.C., Davis, S.P., Rao, M.L.P., Engleman_Jr, R._1994, J._Mol. Spec. 165, 57 A’Hearn, M.F., Ohlmacher, J.T., Schleicher, D.G. 1983,_Technical Report TR AP83-044 (College Park:_University of Maryland) A’Hearn,_M.F., Schleicher,_D.G.,_West, R.A. 1985,,_297,_826 Arpigny,_C., Jehin, E., Manfroid, J., et al._2003, Science,_301, 1522 Ayres, T.R., Plymate, C.,_Keller, C.U. 2006,,165, 618_Ball