.3in"}

Finally, we can speculate as to why the Y and In samples show such a high level of disordered static magnetism. As can be seen in Fig. \[Orbitals\](a) and (b), the $e_g^\pi$ and $e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals remain degenerate in the Ba$_3M$Ru$_2$O$_9$ structure. For the Lu, Y and In samples, only one electron occupies the anti-bonding $e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals and therefore they are Jahn-Teller (JT) active. Importantly, this degeneracy is not lifted by the spin-orbit coupling [@Kugel2015]. This may leave these materials vulnerable to local structural distortions that relieve the degeneracy, but lead to disorder in the interdimer exchange or the crystalline electric field, both of which can modulate the size of the ordered moments. An important parallel can be found in the sister compound Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$, which is also based on $S=1/2$ moments and Jahn-Teller active [@Nakatsuji2012]. In Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$, two distinct behaviors are observed, depending on the precise stoichiometry of the samples [@Nakatsuji2012; @Katayama2015]. In some off-stoichiometric samples, the orbital degeneracy is relieved by an orthorhombic distortion (a collective JT transition) near 200 K. Ultimately, these orthorhombic samples order magnetically at low temperatures. More stoichiometric samples manage to preserve their room-temperature hexagonal symmetry down to much lower temperatures either through a dynamic JT effect [@Ishiguro2013] or else local distortions that nonetheless preserve the global symmetry of the structure and give rise to a random-singlet magnetic ground state [@Quilliam2012bcso]. The most recent experimental results, thermal conductivity measurements, on nearly stoichiometric single-crystal Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$ point toward the local-distortion picture [@Sugii2016] which is consistent with the random singlet magnetic ground state and excitation gap [@Quilliam2012bcso]. Since a hexagonal to orthorhombic collective JT transition can be ruled out by the neutron diffraction results on the materials studied here, similar random distortions might then apply, and
.3 in " } 

 Finally, we can speculate as to why the Y and In samples show such a eminent degree of disordered static magnetism. As can be seen in Fig.   \[Orbitals\](a) and (b), the $ e_g^\pi$ and $ e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals stay degenerate in the Ba$_3M$Ru$_2$O$_9 $ structure. For the Lu, Y and In sample, only one electron occupies the anti - bonding $ e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals and consequently they are Jahn - Teller (JT) active. Importantly, this corruption is not lifted by the spin - eye socket coupling   [ @Kugel2015 ]. This may leave these material vulnerable to local structural aberration that relieve the degeneracy, but moderate to disorder in the interdimer exchange or the crystalline electric field, both of which can regulate the size of the ordered moments. An important parallel can be recover in the sister compound Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9 $, which is also based on $ S=1/2 $ moments and Jahn - Teller active   [ @Nakatsuji2012 ]. In Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9 $, two distinct demeanor are observed, depending on the precise stoichiometry of the samples   [ @Nakatsuji2012; @Katayama2015 ]. In some off - stoichiometric samples, the orbital degeneracy is relieved by an orthorhombic distortion (a collective JT transition) near 200 K. Ultimately, these orthorhombic samples order magnetically at low temperatures. More stoichiometric samples manage to preserve their room - temperature hexangular isotropy down to much lower temperatures either through a active JT impression   [ @Ishiguro2013 ] or else local distortions that nonetheless save the global symmetry of the structure and give advance to a random - singlet magnetic ground state   [ @Quilliam2012bcso ]. The most recent experimental solution, thermal conductivity measurements, on nearly stoichiometric single - quartz glass Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9 $ point toward the local - aberration painting   [ @Sugii2016 ] which is consistent with the random singlet magnetic ground state and excitation gap   [ @Quilliam2012bcso ]. Since a hexagonal to orthorhombic collective JT passage can be ruled out by the neutron diffraction results on the materials studied here, like random distortions might then apply, and
.3in"}

Flnally, we can speculate xs to why the Y and In samplss show ruch a high level of disordeced wtatix magnetism. As can be reen in Fpg. \[Orbitalw\](a) aid (b), the $e_g^\pi$ anv $e_g^{\pi\asb}$ orbjbals xenain degeneratg in the Ba$_3M$Su$_2$O$_9$ structure. Xof che Lu, Y and In samples, only one elestron ovckpies the anti-fondpnd $e_g^{\lp\awt}$ orbitals and therefore theg are Jehn-Teller (JT) acyive. Importantly, this degejerafy is not lifted bj the spin-otgit xoupling [@Kugeu2015]. This may leave these materials vulnerable to local rtruccural distotcuond that reliete the degeneracy, nlt lead to disprder in the ikterdmmer exchange or the crysvalline electric fiejd, both ox chich can modulate thw wize mf tve ofeerdd jokehts. An im'ortant parzllel can bw found in the sisttr simpound Ba$_3$CuSg$_2$O$_9$, whish is also based on $S=1/2$ moments and Jahn-Telner active [@Nakatsuji2012]. In Ba$_3$CySb$_2$O$_9$, two distinct behwviors arq observed, depending on the precise stoichiometry of tie sanpjdw [@Nwkatsuji2012; @Katayama2015]. In some off-stoichiometric swjpkex, the orbital begeneracy is rekifvrq by an orthothombic diatortion (a collectlve JT jransirion) near 200 K. Iltimately, these orthorhombuc samples ogder magnetically at llw temperatbres. Mpre syoichiometric samples mcnage fo preserve their roko-temperature hexxgokal symmetry down to much lowqr tempereturex eithef thtough a dynamic JH effcwt [@Ishiguro2013] or else locap gistortiond that nonetheless preserve the global symmetty mf nhe struccure akd give rise to a random-singlgt magnetnc grojnd state [@Qlilliam2012bcvo]. The most recent experhlental resulvs, thermaj cobducrivity odasurements, on nearly snonchiometruc single-crystal Be$_3$CuSc$_2$K$_9$ point toward cke local-distortiom pkcttrv [@Sujii2016] wrhch is consivteng wkyh thd random sikgldt msgnetic ground state and excitation gap [@Quikllam2012bcso]. Sunce a hqxagonal to otthorhombic collecuive JV tranritiom cwn be ruled out by the neutron diffractlon results on ehe naterials stbdied here, similar random distortions mijht then apply, and
.3in"} Finally, we can speculate as to Y In samples such a high As be seen in \[Orbitals\](a) and (b), $e_g^\pi$ and $e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals remain degenerate the Ba$_3M$Ru$_2$O$_9$ structure. For the Lu, Y and In samples, only one electron the anti-bonding $e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals and therefore they are Jahn-Teller (JT) active. Importantly, this is lifted the coupling [@Kugel2015]. This may leave these materials vulnerable to local structural distortions that relieve the degeneracy, lead to disorder in the interdimer exchange or crystalline electric field, both which can modulate the size the moments. An parallel be in the sister Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$, which is also based on $S=1/2$ moments and Jahn-Teller active [@Nakatsuji2012]. In Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$, two distinct behaviors observed, depending precise stoichiometry the [@Nakatsuji2012; In some off-stoichiometric orbital degeneracy is relieved by an collective JT transition) near 200 K. Ultimately, these samples order at low temperatures. More stoichiometric samples to preserve their room-temperature hexagonal symmetry down to lower temperatures either through a dynamic JT effect [@Ishiguro2013] or else local distortions that nonetheless global symmetry of the and give rise a magnetic state The most experimental results, thermal conductivity measurements, on nearly stoichiometric single-crystal Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$ point the local-distortion picture [@Sugii2016] which is consistent with the random ground and excitation gap Since a hexagonal to collective transition can be ruled the diffraction materials here, random distortions might then and
.3in"}

Finally, we can speculate as To why the Y aNd In sAmpLes ShOw suCh a hIgh level of disoRDereD static magnetism. As can bE seen In fIg. \[OrBItAls\](a) aNd (b), the $e_G^\Pi$ AND $e_g^{\Pi\AsT}$ orBiTAlS remaIn dEgeneraTe in the Ba$_3M$ru$_2$O$_9$ StRucture. For thE lu, y and In sampLes, Only one electRon OccupiEs The ANti-boNdiNg $e_g^{\pI\ast}$ orBItals aNd therefoRe THey are jAhn-TellER (jT) ActiVe. Importantly, this DEgENeracy is not lifTed by tHe SPiN-ORbiT coUpling [@KugeL2015]. THis maY Leave thESe MATEriALs vulnerable tO local strucTUraL distoRtIonS That reLieve ThE DegEneracy, but lEad tO disorder In the iNTerdimeR ExchangE or the CryStaLlinE ElEcTriC fIEld, BOtH of WHicH can moduLaTe The siZe of THE ORderEd mOmenTs. An iMportant paralLel Can bE FouNd in tHe sisTer cOmPound ba$_3$CuSb$_2$o$_9$, whicH iS also based on $S=1/2$ moMentS and Jahn-TEllEr ActIvE [@NakaTSuji2012]. In ba$_3$CUSb$_2$o$_9$, two disTinct beHAviOrS ARE oBserved, depending on ThE PReCise stoiChiomeTRy Of THe sampleS [@NAkaTsujI2012; @kAtayaMa2015]. In SOmE off-stoiChiomeTRiC sAmples, tHe OrbitaL dEgeNerAcy is RElieVed by aN orthorhOmbic DIstortion (a collECtive JT transiTIoN) NEaR 200 k. UltImaTely, these orThorHOmbiC samPLeS orDEr magNeticAlLY aT Low temperatures. More StOichioMetriC samples managE to preservE THEir room-tEmpeRAtURe hexagonal symMetry Down to much LOwer tempEratuRes eitheR through a DYNamic JT eFfeCt [@IShiGurO2013] OR eLse local distoRTIons ThAt nonetHelEss presErvE thE glObaL sYmmetry of The strucTuRe AnD gIve Rise tO A random-sInGleT mAgnEtic gROund stAte [@QuIlliAm2012BcSO]. ThE most reCEnT EXperImEnTal rEsuLtS, therMal cONduCtivity MeasuremeNts, ON neaRlY sToichioMetric single-cRyStal Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$o$_9$ pOinT towarD THe local-dIstortion picture [@Sugii2016] whICh is conSisTent wIth tHe random sIngLet magNetIC grounD state And exCiTatION gap [@QUILlIam2012BcSo]. Since a heXAGonAl to oRtHorhOmbic coLlective JT transitiON caN be ruled out by The NeutRON dIffRAcTIon ReSUltS ON the materials stUdied here, sImILaR random disTOrtIoNs might Then appLy, and
.3in"}

Finally, we can sp eculate as  to w hythe  Y  and  Insamples show s u ch a  high level of disorde red s ta t ic m a gn etism . As ca n  b e see nin  Fi g. \[ Orbit als \](a) a nd (b), th e $ e_ g^\pi$ and $ e _g ^{\pi\ast} $ o rbitals rema indegene ra tei n the  Ba $_3M$ Ru$_2$ O $_9$ s tructure.  F o r theL u, Y an d In  sam ples, only one el e ct r on occupies th e anti -b o nd i n g $ e_g ^{\pi\ast} $orbit a ls andt he r e f ore they are Jahn -Teller (JT )  ac tive.Im por t antly,  this  d e gen eracy is no t li fted by t he spi n -orbitc oupling  [@Kug el2 015 ]. T h is  m ayle a vet he sem ate rials vu ln er ableto l o c a l  str uct ural  dist ortions thatrel ieve the  dege nerac y, b ut  lead  to di sorde rin the interdim er e xchange o r t he  cr ys talli n e elec tri c f ield, b oth ofw hic hc a n  m odulate the size o ft h eorderedmoment s .An importan tpar alle l can b e fo u nd  in thesister co mp ound Ba $_ 3$CuSb $_ 2$O $_9 $, wh i ch i s also  based o n $S= 1 /2$ moments an d  Jahn-Tellera ct i v e[ @Nak ats uji2012]. I n Ba $ _3$C uSb$ _ 2$ O$_ 9 $, tw o dis ti n ct behaviors are obser ve d, dep endin g on the prec ise stoich i o m etry ofthes am p les [@Nakatsuj i2012 ; @Katayam a 2015]. I n som e off-st oichiomet r i c sample s,the  or bit a l  d egeneracy isr e liev ed  by anort horhomb icdis tor tio n(a collec tive JTtr an si ti on)  near 200 K. U lt ima te ly,  thes e  ortho rhomb ic s am pl e s o rder ma g ne t i call yat  low  te mp eratu res. Mor e stoic hiometric  sa m ples  m an age topreserve thei rroom-tempe ra tur e hexa g o nal symm etry down to much lower tempera tur es ei ther  througha d ynamic  JT effect  [@Ish iguro 20 13] o r els e lo cal  d istortions t hat  none th eles s prese rve the global sym m etr y of the stru ctu re a n d  g ive ri s e t oa  ra n d om-singlet magn etic groun ds ta te [@Quill i am2 01 2bcso].  The mo st re c ent exp erimental  results,  t herm a l  co nductivity  measure ments, on nearl y  s toich iom etricsi ngl e-cry stal B a $_3 $CuSb $_2$O$ _9 $ poin t tow ar d the lo cal-distortion picture[@Sugi i2016 ] w hich is c ons i ste nt with t he r andom sing let  ma gneti c g r oundstat e  a nde xcita tion gap [@Qui l li am2 0 1 2b cso]. Since a hex agona l t o  ortho rhom bic collective JT transition can  ber u led  ou t  byth e neutron diff rac ti o n  results  o n the mater ials stu di e d her e, sim ilar r andom d i s to r tionsmigh t t hen apply , a nd 
.3in"}

Finally, we_can speculate_as to why the_Y and_In_samples show_such_a high level_of disordered static_magnetism. As can be_seen in Fig. \[Orbitals\](a)_and_(b), the $e_g^\pi$ and $e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals remain degenerate in the Ba$_3M$Ru$_2$O$_9$ structure. For the_Lu,_Y and_In_samples,_only one electron occupies the_anti-bonding $e_g^{\pi\ast}$ orbitals and therefore_they are_Jahn-Teller (JT) active. Importantly, this degeneracy is not_lifted_by the spin-orbit_coupling [@Kugel2015]. This may leave these materials vulnerable to local_structural distortions that relieve the degeneracy,_but lead to_disorder_in_the interdimer exchange or_the crystalline electric field, both of_which can modulate the size of_the ordered moments. An important parallel can_be found in the sister compound_Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$, which is also based_on $S=1/2$_moments and Jahn-Teller active [@Nakatsuji2012]. In_Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$, two distinct_behaviors are_observed, depending on_the precise stoichiometry of the samples [@Nakatsuji2012;_@Katayama2015]. In some_off-stoichiometric samples, the orbital degeneracy is_relieved_by an orthorhombic_distortion_(a_collective JT_transition) near 200_K._Ultimately, these_orthorhombic_samples order magnetically at low temperatures._More_stoichiometric samples manage to preserve their room-temperature_hexagonal symmetry down to_much_lower temperatures either through_a dynamic JT effect [@Ishiguro2013] or_else local distortions that nonetheless preserve_the global_symmetry of_the structure and give rise to a random-singlet magnetic ground state [@Quilliam2012bcso]._The most recent experimental results, thermal_conductivity measurements, on nearly_stoichiometric single-crystal_Ba$_3$CuSb$_2$O$_9$_point toward the_local-distortion_picture [@Sugii2016] which_is consistent with the random singlet magnetic_ground state_and excitation gap [@Quilliam2012bcso]. Since a hexagonal_to orthorhombic collective JT_transition_can be ruled out by the_neutron diffraction results on the materials_studied here, similar random distortions_might_then_apply, and