 if $$Y+\left( T_{k} \pm aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2} \quad \text{ and } \quad
Y-\left( T_{k} \pm aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}$$ with $\gcd \left( b_{1}, b_{2} \right)=1$ and $2b_{1}b_{2}=b$, then $$2Y=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2 \left( b/ \left( 2b_{1} \right) \right)^{2}r_{1}^{2}.$$

Differentiating this expression with respect to $b_{1}$, we find that the derivative is only zero for $b_{1}$ positive if $b_{1}=\sqrt{r_{1}b/\left( 2s_{1} \right)}$. Here we have $2Y=2r_{1}s_{1}b \geq 2b$.

If $b_{1}=1$, then we have $2Y=2s_{1}^{2}+b^{2}r_{1}^{2}/2$. Since $b$ is even, we have $b \geq 2$ and so $2Y \geq b^{2}/2+2 \geq 2b$. Similarly, if $b_{1}=b/2$, then we also have $2Y \geq 2b$.

Furthermore, if $b=p^{m}$ is a prime power, then either $b_{1}=b/2$ or $b_{2}=b/2$. Here we obtain $2Y>2b^{2}/4$.

This completes the proof for $k=1$.

Now we consider $k>1$. If $a=U_{1}=1$, then we have $T_{1}^{2}-\left( 1+b^{2} \right) =-4$. This is only possible if $T_{1}=1$ and $b=2$. Using Magma, we find that there are no integer solutions of $X^{2}-5Y^{4}=-4$ with $Y>1$. Hence we
if $ $ Y+\left (T_{k } \pm aU_{k } \right)/2=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2 } \quad \text { and } \quad 
 Y-\left (T_{k } \pm aU_{k } \right)/2=2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}$$ with $ \gcd \left (b_{1 }, b_{2 } \right)=1 $ and $ 2b_{1}b_{2}=b$, then $ $ 2Y=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2 \left (b/ \left (2b_{1 } \right) \right)^{2}r_{1}^{2}.$$ 

 Differentiating this expression with respect to $ b_{1}$, we find that the derived function is merely zero for $ b_{1}$ positive if $ b_{1}=\sqrt{r_{1}b/\left (2s_{1 } \right)}$. Here we have $ 2Y=2r_{1}s_{1}b \geq 2b$. 

 If $ b_{1}=1 $, then we have $ 2Y=2s_{1}^{2}+b^{2}r_{1}^{2}/2$. Since $ b$ is even, we own $ b \geq 2 $ and so $ 2Y \geq b^{2}/2 + 2 \geq 2b$. Similarly, if $ b_{1}=b/2 $, then we besides have $ 2Y \geq 2b$. 

 Furthermore, if $ b = p^{m}$ is a prime ability, then either $ b_{1}=b/2 $ or $ b_{2}=b/2$. Here we obtain $ 2Y>2b^{2}/4$. 

 This completes the validation for $ k=1$. 

 Now we consider $ k>1$. If $ a = U_{1}=1 $, then we have $ T_{1}^{2}-\left (1+b^{2 } \right) = -4$. This is only potential if $ T_{1}=1 $ and $ b=2$. Using Magma, we find that there be no integer solutions of $ X^{2}-5Y^{4}=-4 $ with $ Y>1$. Hence we
 if $$Y+\left( T_{k} \pm aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2} \quad \text{ and } \quad
Y-\lxft( T_{k} \lm aU_{k} \rkght)/2=2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}$$ with $\gcd \left( b_{1}, b_{2} \rigit)=1$ abd $2b_{1}b_{2}=v$, then $$2Y=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2 \left( b/ \ueft( 2b_{1} \rihht) \righr)^{2}r_{1}^{2}.$$

Dihferentiating thma expression slth rzs'ect to $b_{1}$, we fikd that the derivative is ovlv zero for $b_{1}$ positive if $b_{1}=\sqrt{r_{1}b/\left( 2s_{1} \righy)}$. Jere we have $2Y=2t_{1}s_{1}b \gtq 2f$.

If $g_{1}=1$, then we have $2Y=2s_{1}^{2}+b^{2}r_{1}^{2}/2$. Since $b$ is eveh, we hane $b \geq 2$ and so $2U \geq b^{2}/2+2 \geq 2b$. Similarly, if $b_{1}=b/2$, hhen we also have $2J \geq 2b$.

Furtyermjee, if $b=p^{m}$ is a prime power, then eijher $b_{1}=b/2$ or $b_{2}=b/2$. Here we obtain $2Y>2b^{2}/4$.

Tfis cpmpletes tye prlmf for $k=1$.

Now we cjnsider $k>1$. If $a=U_{1}=1$, then we havr $T_{1}^{2}-\left( 1+b^{2} \righb) =-4$. Thms iw only possible if $T_{1}=1$ end $b=2$. Using Magma, we find thad chere are no integer wooutiots ox $X^{2}-5Y^{4}=-4$ qitf $Y>1$. Hxncs we
if $$Y+\left( T_{k} \pm aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2} \quad } Y-\left( T_{k} aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}$$ with and then $$2Y=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2 \left( \left( 2b_{1} \right) Differentiating this expression with respect to we find that the derivative is only zero for $b_{1}$ positive if $b_{1}=\sqrt{r_{1}b/\left( \right)}$. Here we have $2Y=2r_{1}s_{1}b \geq 2b$. If $b_{1}=1$, then we have $2Y=2s_{1}^{2}+b^{2}r_{1}^{2}/2$. $b$ even, have \geq 2$ and so $2Y \geq b^{2}/2+2 \geq 2b$. Similarly, if $b_{1}=b/2$, then we also have \geq 2b$. Furthermore, if $b=p^{m}$ is a prime then either $b_{1}=b/2$ or Here we obtain $2Y>2b^{2}/4$. This the for $k=1$. we $k>1$. $a=U_{1}=1$, then we $T_{1}^{2}-\left( 1+b^{2} \right) =-4$. This is only possible if $T_{1}=1$ and $b=2$. Using Magma, we find that are no of $X^{2}-5Y^{4}=-4$ $Y>1$. we
 if $$Y+\left( T_{k} \pm aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2} \quad \Text{ and } \quaD
Y-\lefT( T_{k} \Pm au_{k} \RighT)/2=2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}$$ wIth $\gcd \left( b_{1}, b_{2} \riGHt)=1$ anD $2b_{1}b_{2}=b$, then $$2Y=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2 \left( b/ \leFt( 2b_{1} \riGhT) \RighT)^{2}R_{1}^{2}.$$

DIfferEntiatiNG tHIS exPrEsSioN wITh RespeCt tO $b_{1}$, we finD that the deRivAtIve is only zerO FoR $b_{1}$ positive If $b_{1}=\Sqrt{r_{1}b/\left( 2s_{1} \rIghT)}$. Here wE hAve $2y=2R_{1}s_{1}b \geQ 2b$.

IF $b_{1}=1$, theN we havE $2y=2s_{1}^{2}+b^{2}r_{1}^{2}/2$. SiNce $b$ is eveN, wE Have $b \gEQ 2$ and so $2Y \GEQ b^{2}/2+2 \Geq 2b$. similarly, if $b_{1}=b/2$, then WE aLSo have $2Y \geq 2b$.

FurThermoRe, IF $b=P^{M}$ Is a PriMe power, theN eIther $B_{1}=B/2$ or $b_{2}=b/2$. HeRE wE OBTaiN $2y>2b^{2}/4$.

This completEs the proof fOR $k=1$.

NOw we coNsIdeR $K>1$. If $a=U_{1}=1$, tHen we HaVE $T_{1}^{2}-\lEft( 1+b^{2} \right) =-4$. ThIs is Only possiBle if $T_{1}=1$ ANd $b=2$. UsinG magma, we Find thAt tHerE are NO iNtEgeR sOLutIOnS of $x^{2}-5y^{4}=-4$ wiTh $Y>1$. Hence We
 if $$Y+\left( T_{k} \pm a U_{k} \rig ht)/2 =2b _{1 }^ {2}s _{1} ^{2} \quad \te x t{ a nd } \quad
Y-\left( T_ {k} \ pm aU_{ k }\righ t)/2=2b _ {2 } ^ {2} r_ {1 }^{ 2} $ $with$\g cd \lef t( b_{1},b_{ 2}  \right)=1$a nd  $2b_{1}b_ {2} =b$, then $$ 2Y= 2b_{1} ^{ 2}s _ {1}^{ 2}+ 2b_{2 }^{2}r _ {1}^{2 }=2b_{1}^ {2 } s_{1}^ { 2}+2 \l e f t(  b/\left( 2b_{1} \ri g ht )  \right)^{2}r_ {1}^{2 }. $ $D iff ere ntiating t hi s exp r essionw it h r esp e ct to $b_{1}$ , we find t h atthe de ri vat i ve isonlyze r o f or $b_{1}$posi tive if $ b_{1}= \ sqrt{r_ { 1}b/\le ft( 2s _{1 } \ righ t )} $.  He re weh av e $ 2 Y=2 r_{1}s_{ 1} b\geq2b$. I f  $b_ {1} =1$,  then  we have $2Y= 2s_ {1}^ { 2}+ b^{2} r_{1} ^{2} /2 $. Si nce $b $ isev en, we have $b\geq  2$ and s o $ 2Y  \g eq  b^{2 } /2+2 \ geq  2b $. Simi larly,i f $ b_ { 1 } =b /2$, then we alsoha v e  $ 2Y \geq2b$.
F ur th e rmore, i f$b= p^{m } $  is a  pri m epower, t hen ei t he r$b_{1}= b/ 2$ or$b _{2 }=b /2$.H erewe obt ain $2Y> 2b^{2 } /4$.

This com p letes the pro o ff o r$ k=1$ .
Now we cons ider $k>1 $. I f  $ a=U _ {1}=1 $, th en we have $T_{1}^{2}-\le ft ( 1+b^ {2} \ right) =-4$.This is on l y possible  if$ T_ { 1}=1$ and $b=2 $. Us ing Magma, we findthatthere ar e no inte g e r soluti ons  of  $X ^{2 } - 5Y ^{4}=-4$ with $ Y>1$ .Hence w e
 if_$$Y+\left( T_{k}_\pm aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2} \quad_\text{ and_}_\quad
Y-\left( T_{k}_\pm_aU_{k} \right)/2=2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}$$ with_$\gcd \left( b_{1},_b_{2} \right)=1$ and $2b_{1}b_{2}=b$,_then $$2Y=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2b_{2}^{2}r_{1}^{2}=2b_{1}^{2}s_{1}^{2}+2 \left(_b/_\left( 2b_{1} \right) \right)^{2}r_{1}^{2}.$$

Differentiating this expression with respect to $b_{1}$, we find that the_derivative_is only_zero_for_$b_{1}$ positive if $b_{1}=\sqrt{r_{1}b/\left( 2s_{1}_\right)}$. Here we have $2Y=2r_{1}s_{1}b_\geq 2b$.

If_$b_{1}=1$, then we have $2Y=2s_{1}^{2}+b^{2}r_{1}^{2}/2$. Since $b$ is_even,_we have $b_\geq 2$ and so $2Y \geq b^{2}/2+2 \geq 2b$._Similarly, if $b_{1}=b/2$, then we also_have $2Y \geq_2b$.

Furthermore,_if_$b=p^{m}$ is a prime_power, then either $b_{1}=b/2$ or $b_{2}=b/2$._Here we obtain $2Y>2b^{2}/4$.

This completes the_proof for $k=1$.

Now we consider $k>1$. If_$a=U_{1}=1$, then we have $T_{1}^{2}-\left( 1+b^{2}_\right) =-4$. This is only_possible if_$T_{1}=1$ and $b=2$. Using Magma,_we find that_there are_no integer solutions_of $X^{2}-5Y^{4}=-4$ with $Y>1$. Hence we