nabla$-rule of [@blutecs §4.3] is satisfied:

The diagram @C+2pc[ V V V \_-[D 1]{} \^-[1 ]{} & V V \^-[D]{}\
[!]{} V V \_- & [!]{} V ]{} commutes.

This, together with [@blutecs Theorem 4.12], shows that ${\mathcal{V}}$ with the comonad ${!}$ and deriving transformation $D$ is a model of the differential calculus in the sense of [@blutecs Definition 4.11].

${\mathcal{V}}$ is a categorical model of the differential calculus.

Examples {#section:examples}
========

In this section we give various examples of proofs $\pi$ and the derivatives ${\llbracket \pi \rrbracket} \circ D$ of their denotations, according to Definition \[defn:derivative\_proof\]. We recall briefly the definition of the semantics ${\llbracket - \rrbracket}$ in the category ${\mathcal{V}}$ of $k$-vector spaces from [@hyland] and [@murfet_ll §5.1, §5.3]. For a propositional variable $x$ the denotation ${\llbracket x \rrbracket}$ is any finite-dimensional vector space, and $$\begin{aligned}
{\llbracket A \multimap B \rrbracket} &= \Hom_k({\llbracket A \rrbracket},{\llbracket B \rrbracket})\,,\\
{\llbracket A \otimes B \rrbracket} &= {\llbracket A \rrbracket} \otimes {\llbracket B \rrbracket}\,,\\
{\llbracket {!}A \rrbracket} &= {!} {\llbracket A \rrbracket}\,,\end{aligned}$$ where ${!} V$ denotes the universal cocommutative counital coalgebra mapping to $V$.

The encoding of integers and binary sequences in linear logic is based on the following encoding of the composition rule.

For any formula $A$ let $C^1_A$ denote the proof

We define recursively for $n > 1$ a proof $C^n_A$ of $A, (A \multimap A)^n \vdash A$, where $(A \multimap A)^n$ denotes a sequence of $n$ copies of $A \multimap A$, to be


nabla$-rule of [ @blutecs § 4.3 ] is satisfied: 

 The diagram @C+2pc [ V V V \_-[D 1 ] { } \^-[1 ] { } & V V \^-[D]{}\ 
 [! ] { } five five \_- & [! ] { } V ] { } commutes. 

 This, together with [ @blutecs Theorem 4.12 ], prove that $ { \mathcal{V}}$ with the comonad $ {! } $ and deriving transformation $ D$ is a model of the differential tartar in the sense of [ @blutecs Definition 4.11 ]. 

 $ { \mathcal{V}}$ is a categorical model of the differential tartar. 

 Examples { # incision: examples } 
 = = = = = = = = 

 In this incision we give various example of proofs $ \pi$ and the derivative instrument $ { \llbracket \pi \rrbracket } \circ D$ of their denotations, according to Definition \[defn: derivative\_proof\ ]. We remember briefly the definition of the semantics $ { \llbracket - \rrbracket}$ in the category $ { \mathcal{V}}$ of $ k$-vector spaces from [ @hyland ] and [ @murfet_ll § 5.1, § 5.3 ]. For a propositional variable star $ x$ the denotation $ { \llbracket x \rrbracket}$ is any finite - dimensional vector space, and $ $ \begin{aligned } 
 { \llbracket A \multimap B \rrbracket } & = \Hom_k({\llbracket A \rrbracket},{\llbracket B \rrbracket})\,,\\ 
 { \llbracket A \otimes B \rrbracket } & = { \llbracket A \rrbracket } \otimes { \llbracket B \rrbracket}\,,\\ 
 { \llbracket {! } A \rrbracket } & = {! } { \llbracket A \rrbracket}\,,\end{aligned}$$ where $ {! } V$ denote the universal cocommutative counital coalgebra function to $ V$. 

 The encoding of integers and binary succession in linear logic is based on the following encoding of the musical composition rule. 

 For any formula $ A$ let $ C^1_A$ denote the proof 

 We specify recursively for $ n > 1 $ a proof $ C^n_A$ of $ A, (A \multimap A)^n \vdash A$, where $ (A \multimap A)^n$ denotes a sequence of $ n$ copies of $ A \multimap A$, to be
nabpa$-rule of [@blutecs §4.3] is sauisfied:

The diagram @C+2pc[ V V V \_-[D 1]{} \^-[1 ]{} & V V \^-[D]{}\
[!]{} V V \_- & [!]{} V ]{} commutes.

This, tojethwr wiuk [@blutecs Theorem 4.12], sfows that ${\mathcal{C}}$ wiuh the comonad ${!}$ ais derivlug trzksforketion $D$ is a mocel of the differential waucblus in the sense of [@blutecs Definityon 4.11].

${\matncwl{V}}$ is a categjricsj mosvl of the differential calculus.

Sxamplev {#section:examlles}
========

In this section we givf vagious examples of oroofs $\pi$ abd trw derivativer ${\llbrackeu \'i \rrbrackej} \circ D$ of their denotations, aczordiug to Definutuon \[gefn:derivatmve\_projf\]. We recall briefly the deginition of thc sementixs ${\llbracket - \rrbrackxt}$ in the category ${\mwthcal{V}}$ ox $i$-vector spaces frim [@hylatd] atd [@mjefeg_ll §5.1, §5.3]. Fkr a pgopksitional bariable $x$ rhe denotation ${\llbrschvy x \rrbrackef}$ is agy finite-dimensional vector space, and $$\begpn{aljgned}
{\llbracket A \multimqp B \rrbracket} &= \Hom_k({\lpbracket W \rrbracket},{\llbracket B \rrbracket})\,,\\
{\llbracket A \otimev B \rcbfacjeb} &= {\luvrwcket A \rrbracket} \otimes {\llbracket B \rrbrackee}\,,\\
{\mlnrscket {!}A \rrbrachet} &= {!} {\llbravkft W \rrbracket}\,,\ena{alignzs}$$ shere ${!} V$ denotes tje univgrsal xocommutauive vounital coalgebra mapping ro $V$.

The encobint of integers and yinary sequeuces im linrar logic is based on tke folmowing encofing of tgd composition ruue.

Fpr any formula $A$ let $C^1_A$ denoee the priof

Wz define recorsivelr for $n > 1$ w proof $C^n_A$ of $A, (A \multilap A)^u \vdavh A$, where $(A \multimap A)^n$ denotes a sequenrx of $n$ copies ox $A \multima' A$, to be


nabla$-rule of [@blutecs §4.3] is satisfied: The V V \_-[D \^-[1 ]{} & V & [!]{} V commutes. This, together [@blutecs Theorem 4.12], shows that ${\mathcal{V}}$ the comonad ${!}$ and deriving transformation $D$ is a model of the differential in the sense of [@blutecs Definition 4.11]. ${\mathcal{V}}$ is a categorical model of differential Examples ======== this section we give various examples of proofs $\pi$ and the derivatives ${\llbracket \pi \rrbracket} \circ of their denotations, according to Definition \[defn:derivative\_proof\]. We briefly the definition of semantics ${\llbracket - \rrbracket}$ in category of $k$-vector from and §5.1, §5.3]. For propositional variable $x$ the denotation ${\llbracket x \rrbracket}$ is any finite-dimensional vector space, and $$\begin{aligned} {\llbracket A B \rrbracket} A \rrbracket},{\llbracket \rrbracket})\,,\\ A B \rrbracket} &= \rrbracket} \otimes {\llbracket B \rrbracket}\,,\\ {\llbracket {!} {\llbracket A \rrbracket}\,,\end{aligned}$$ where ${!} V$ denotes universal cocommutative coalgebra mapping to $V$. The encoding integers and binary sequences in linear logic is on the following encoding of the composition rule. For any formula $A$ let $C^1_A$ denote We define recursively for > 1$ a $C^n_A$ $A, \multimap \vdash A$, $(A \multimap A)^n$ denotes a sequence of $n$ copies of $A A$, to be
nabla$-rule of [@blutecs §4.3] is satisFied:

The diaGram @C+2Pc[ V v V \_-[D 1]{} \^-[1 ]{} & v V \^-[d]{}\
[!]{} V V \_- & [!]{} V ]{} CommUtes.

This, togethER witH [@blutecs Theorem 4.12], shows thAt ${\matHcAL{V}}$ wiTH tHe comOnad ${!}$ and DErIVIng TrAnSfoRmATiOn $D$ is A moDel of thE differentIal CaLculus in the sENsE of [@blutecs defInition 4.11].

${\mathcAl{V}}$ Is a catEgOriCAl modEl oF the dIffereNTial caLculus.

ExaMpLEs {#sectIOn:exampLES}
========

IN thiS section we give varIOuS Examples of prooFs $\pi$ anD tHE dERIvaTivEs ${\llbrackeT \pI \rrbrACket} \cirC d$ oF THEir DEnotations, accOrding to DefINitIon \[defN:dEriVAtive\_pRoof\]. WE rECalL briefly the DefiNition of tHe semaNTics ${\llbRAcket - \rrBrackeT}$ in The CateGOrY ${\mAthCaL{v}}$ of $K$-VeCtoR SpaCes from [@hYlAnD] and [@mUrfeT_LL §5.1, §5.3]. fOr a pRopOsitIonal Variable $x$ the dEnoTatiON ${\llBrackEt x \rrBracKeT}$ is anY finitE-dimeNsIonal vector spacE, and $$\Begin{aligNed}
{\LlBraCkEt A \muLTimap B \RrbRacKet} &= \Hom_k({\LlbrackET A \rRbRACKeT},{\llbracket B \rrbrackEt})\,,\\
{\LLBrAcket A \otImes B \rRBrAcKEt} &= {\llbracKeT A \rRbraCKEt} \otiMes {\lLBrAcket B \rrBrackeT}\,,\\
{\LlBrAcket {!}A \rRbRacket} &= {!} {\LlBraCkeT A \rrbRAckeT}\,,\end{alIgned}$$ wheRe ${!} V$ deNOtes the universAL cocommutativE CoUNItAL coaLgeBra mapping tO $V$.

ThE EncoDing OF iNteGErs anD binaRy SEqUEnces in linear logic iS bAsed on The foLlowing encodiNg of the comPOSItion rulE.

For ANy FOrmula $A$ let $C^1_A$ deNote tHe proof

We dEFine recuRsiveLy for $n > 1$ a pRoof $C^n_A$ of $a, (a \Multimap a)^n \vDasH A$, wHerE $(a \MuLtimap A)^n$ denotES A seqUeNce of $n$ cOpiEs of $A \muLtiMap a$, to Be


nabla$-rule of [@blutecs § 4.3] is sa tisfi ed: 

T he  dia gram  @C+2pc[ V V V \_-[ D 1]{} \^-[1 ]{} & V V  \^-[ D] { }\
[ ! ]{ } V V  \_- &[ !] { }  V]{ }com mu t es .

Th is,  togeth er with [@ blu te cs Theorem 4 . 12 ], shows t hat  ${\mathcal{ V}} $ with  t hec omona d $ {!}$and de r ivingtransform at i on $D$ is a mo d e lof t he differential c a lc u lus in the sen se of[@ b lu t e csDef inition 4. 11 ].

$ { \mathca l {V } } $  is a categorical  model of t h e d iffere nt ial calcul us.
Ex a mpl es {#sectio n:ex amples}
= ====== = 

In th i s secti on wegiv e v ario u sex amp le s  of pr oof s  $\ pi$ andth ederiv ativ e s $ {\ll bra cket  \pi\rrbracket} \ cir c D$ oftheir  deno tati on s, ac cordin g toDe finition \[defn :der ivative\_ pro of \].  W e rec a ll bri efl y t he defi nitiono f t he s e ma ntics ${\llbracket  - \ rr bracket} $ in t h eca t egory ${ \m ath cal{ V } }$ of  $k$ - ve ctor spa ces fr o m[@ hyland]  a nd [@m ur fet _ll  §5.1 ,  §5. 3]. Fo r a prop ositi o nal variable $ x $ the denotat i on $ {\ l lbra cke t x \rrbrac ket} $  isanyf in ite - dimen siona lv ec t or space, and $$\be gi n{alig ned}{\llbracket A  \multimap B \rrbrack et}& =\ Hom_k({\llbrac ket A  \rrbracke t },{\llbr acket  B \rrbr acket})\, , \ \
{\llbr ack etA \ oti m e sB \rrbracket} & = {\ ll bracket  A\rrbrac ket } \ oti mes  { \llbracke t B \rrb ra ck et }\ ,,\ \
{\l l bracket{! }A\r rbr acket }  &= {! } {\l lbra ck et A \ rrbrack e t} \ , ,\en d{ al igne d}$ $where  ${! }  V$  denote s the uni ver s al c oc om mutativ e counital co al gebra mapp in g t o $V$. The enco ding of integers and bi n ary seq uen ces i n li near logi c i s base d o n  the f ollowi ng en co din g of th e co mpo si tion rule. For  anyfo rmul a $A$ l et $C^1_A$ denotet heproof

We def ine  rec u r si vel y  f o r $ n>  1$ a  proof $C^n_A$of $A, (A\m u lt imap A)^n\ vda sh  A$, wh ere $(A  \mul t imap A) ^n$ denot es a sequ en ce o f $n$  copies of  $A \mul timap A$, to be 

nabla$-rule of_[@blutecs §4.3]_is satisfied:

The diagram @C+2pc[_V V_V_\_-[D 1]{}_\^-[1_]{} & V_V \^-[D]{}\
[!]{} V_V \_- & [!]{}_V ]{} commutes.

This,_together_with [@blutecs Theorem 4.12], shows that ${\mathcal{V}}$ with the comonad ${!}$ and deriving transformation_$D$_is a_model_of_the differential calculus in the_sense of [@blutecs Definition 4.11].

${\mathcal{V}}$_is a_categorical model of the differential calculus.

Examples {#section:examples}
========

In this_section_we give various_examples of proofs $\pi$ and the derivatives ${\llbracket \pi_\rrbracket} \circ D$ of their denotations,_according to Definition_\[defn:derivative\_proof\]._We_recall briefly the definition_of the semantics ${\llbracket - \rrbracket}$_in the category ${\mathcal{V}}$ of $k$-vector_spaces from [@hyland] and [@murfet_ll §5.1, §5.3]._For a propositional variable $x$ the_denotation ${\llbracket x \rrbracket}$ is_any finite-dimensional_vector space, and $$\begin{aligned}
{\llbracket A_\multimap B \rrbracket}_&= \Hom_k({\llbracket_A \rrbracket},{\llbracket B_\rrbracket})\,,\\
{\llbracket A \otimes B \rrbracket} &=_{\llbracket A \rrbracket}_\otimes {\llbracket B \rrbracket}\,,\\
{\llbracket {!}A \rrbracket}_&=_{!} {\llbracket A_\rrbracket}\,,\end{aligned}$$_where_${!} V$_denotes the universal_cocommutative_counital coalgebra_mapping_to $V$.

The encoding of integers and_binary_sequences in linear logic is based on_the following encoding of_the_composition rule.

For any formula_$A$ let $C^1_A$ denote the_proof

We define recursively for $n >_1$ a_proof $C^n_A$_of $A, (A \multimap A)^n \vdash A$, where $(A \multimap A)^n$_denotes a sequence of $n$ copies_of $A \multimap A$,_to be

