) A Treatise on the Records of the Creation and on the Moral Attributes of the Creator, London: Hatchard. • Tribe, Keith (1978) Land, Labour and Economic Discourse, Aldershot: Routledge. • Tribe, Keith (1995) Strategies of Economic Order: German Economic Discourse, 1750–1950, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Turgot, Anne-Robert-Jacques ([1776] 1914) Réflexions sur la Formation et la Distribution des Richesses, in Oeuvres de Turgot et documents le concernant, vol. 2, ed. Gustave Schelle, Paris: Alcan; Engl. transl. Reflexions on the Formation and Distribution of Riches, New York: Kelley, 1971. • Verri, Pietro ([1771] 2004) Meditazioni sull'economia politica. Edition used: Edizione Nazionale Delle Opere di Pietro Verri III: I 'Discorsi' e altri scritti degli anni Settanta, ed. Giorgio Panizza et al., Rome: Edizioni di Storia e Letteratura; Engl. transl. Reflections on Political Economy, ed. Peter D. Groenewegen, New York: Augustus M. Kelley, 1993. • Waterman, Anthony M. C. (1991) Revolution, Economics and Religion: Christian Political Economy, 1798– 1833, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Whately, Richard ([1831] 1966) Introductory Lectures on Political Economy, New York: Kelley. • Winch, Donald (1996) Riches and Poverty: An Intellectual History of Political Economy in Britain, 1750–1834, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Winch, Donald and Collini, Stephen (1983) That Noble Science of Politics: A Study in Nineteenth-Century Intellectual History, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. An Abductive Theory of Constitution∗ Michael Baumgartner†and Lorenzo Casini‡ Abstract The first part of this paper finds Craver's (2007) mutual manipulability theory (MM) of constitution inadequate, as it definitionally ties constitution to the feasibility of idealized experiments, which, however, are unrealizable in principle. As an alternative, the second part develops an abductive theory of constitution (NDC), which exploits the fact that phenomena and their constituents are unbreakably coupled via
) A Treatise on the Records of the Creation and on the Moral Attributes of the Creator, London: Hatchard. • Tribe, Keith (1978) Land, Labour and Economic Discourse, Aldershot: Routledge. • Tribe, Keith (1995) Strategies of Economic Order: German Economic Discourse, 1750–1950, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Turgot, Anne - Robert - Jacques ([ 1776 ] 1914) Réflexions sur la Formation et la Distribution des Richesses, in Oeuvres de Turgot et documents le concernant, vol. 2, ed. Gustave Schelle, Paris: Alcan; Engl. transl. Reflexions on the Formation and Distribution of Riches, New York: Kelley, 1971. • Verri, Pietro ([ 1771 ] 2004) Meditazioni sull'economia politica. Edition use: Edizione Nazionale Delle Opere di Pietro Verri III: I' Discorsi' east altri scritti degli anni Settanta, ed. Giorgio Panizza et al. , Rome: Edizioni di Storia e Letteratura; Engl. transl. Reflections on Political Economy, ed. Peter D. Groenewegen, New York: Augustus M. Kelley, 1993. • Waterman, Anthony M. C. (1991) Revolution, Economics and Religion: Christian Political Economy, 1798 – 1833, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Whately, Richard ([ 1831 ] 1966) Introductory Lectures on Political Economy, New York: Kelley. • Winch, Donald (1996) Riches and Poverty: An Intellectual History of Political Economy in Britain, 1750–1834, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Winch, Donald and Collini, Stephen (1983) That Noble Science of Politics: A report in Nineteenth - Century Intellectual History, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. An Abductive Theory of Constitution∗ Michael Baumgartner†and Lorenzo Casini‡ Abstract The first part of this newspaper receive Craver's (2007) mutual manipulability hypothesis (MM) of fundamental law inadequate, as it definitionally ties united states constitution to the feasibility of idealized experiments, which, however, are unrealizable in rationale. As an alternative, the second part develops an abductive theory of constitution (NDC), which exploits the fact that phenomena and their component are unbreakably coupled via
) A Hreatise on the Records uf the Creation and on the Mkral Attfibutes of the Creator, Londoi: Harchare. • Tribe, Keith (1978) Land, Lxbour and Economix Diwxourse, Aldxdshot: Routledfc. • Trnbx, Keith (1995) Stratenies of Ecotomic Order: Gesmxn Economic Discourse, 1750–1950, Cambridge: Cambwidge Umigersity Press. • Turbjt, Ahne-Robert-Jacques ([1776] 1914) Réflexions sur lz Formauion et la Distribition des Richesses, in Oeugres de Turgot et doculents le cobcergqnt, vol. 2, ed. Eustave Schelle, Paris: Zlcan; Engl. transl. Reflexions on the Yormation abd Didjribution of Richvs, New York: Kckley, 1971. • Verri, Lietro ([1771] 2004) Meditszimni sull'economia politice. Edition used: Edizijne Naziotame Delle Opere di Puetro Versi IKU: I 'Diacprai' e aptrm scritti dsgli anni Swttanta, ed. Giorgio Kanydaa et al., Roms: Edizyogi di Storia e Letteratura; Engl. transl. Geflsctions on Political Ecinomy, ed. Peter D. Groejewegen, Nqw York: Augustus M. Kelley, 1993. • Waterman, Anthony M. C. (1991) Revomjtiin, Dxojomics and Religion: Christian Political Econoig, 1798– 1833, Bambridge: Cambridne University Presx. • Wnwtely, Richard ([1831] 1966) Intxkdhctory Lectures on Politisal Exonomy, Ner Yotk: Kelley. • Winch, Donald (1996) Rixhes and Povvrty: An Intellectual Hnstory of Pouitival Evonomy in Britain, 1750–1834, Cambxidge: Dambridge Ujiversity Oress. • Winch, Donxld atd Collini, Stephen (1983) That Njble Scieice oy Politizs: A Study in Ninetefnth-Ccttury Intellectual Histlrf, Cambridgf: Cambridge University Press. An Abductive Theprf ox Consticution∗ Michael Baumdartner†and Lorgnzo Casiui‡ Absgract The rirst pert of this [aper finds Cswver's (2007) mutuan manipujabioity theory (OM) of constituyion inadvqbate, as ir definitionally tles cuhstitution to tkt ftawibility of idralkzeq vxpxrimegds, which, howaver, ard unrexlizablt ik pfincople. As an alternatiee, tge second part devrljps an avductive theory of comstitution (NDC), whifh ex'loits the gacj that phenomena and their consfituents wre unbreakably couiled via
) A Treatise on the Records of and the Moral of the Creator, (1978) Labour and Economic Aldershot: Routledge. • Keith (1995) Strategies of Economic Order: Economic Discourse, 1750–1950, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Turgot, Anne-Robert-Jacques ([1776] 1914) Réflexions la Formation et la Distribution des Richesses, in Oeuvres de Turgot et documents concernant, 2, Gustave Paris: Alcan; Engl. transl. Reflexions on the Formation and Distribution of Riches, New York: Kelley, 1971. Verri, Pietro ([1771] 2004) Meditazioni sull'economia politica. Edition Edizione Nazionale Delle Opere Pietro Verri III: I 'Discorsi' altri degli anni ed. Panizza al., Rome: Edizioni Storia e Letteratura; Engl. transl. Reflections on Political Economy, ed. Peter D. Groenewegen, New York: Augustus M. 1993. • M. C. Revolution, and Christian Political Economy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Whately, Introductory Lectures on Political Economy, New York: Kelley. Winch, Donald Riches and Poverty: An Intellectual History Political Economy in Britain, 1750–1834, Cambridge: Cambridge University • Winch, Donald and Collini, Stephen (1983) That Noble Science of Politics: A Study in History, Cambridge: Cambridge University An Abductive Theory Constitution∗ Baumgartner†and Casini‡ The first of this paper finds Craver's (2007) mutual manipulability theory (MM) of inadequate, as it definitionally ties constitution to the feasibility of which, are unrealizable in As an alternative, the part an abductive theory of which the and constituents unbreakably coupled via
) A Treatise on the Records of thE Creation aNd on tHe MOraL ATtriButeS of the Creator, LONdon: hatchard. • Tribe, Keith (1978) Land, labouR aND EcoNOmIc DisCourse, ALDeRSHot: roUtLedGe. • tRiBe, KeiTh (1995) STrategiEs of EconomIc ORdEr: German EconOMiC Discourse, 1750–1950, camBridge: CambriDge univerSiTy PREss. • TuRgoT, Anne-robert-jAcques ([1776] 1914) réflexionS sUR la ForMAtion et LA diStriBution des RichesseS, In oEuvres de Turgot Et docuMeNTs LE ConCerNant, vol. 2, ed. GUsTave SCHelle, PaRIs: aLCAn; ENGl. transl. RefleXions on the FORmaTion anD DIstRIbutioN of RiChES, NeW York: Kelley, 1971. • verrI, Pietro ([1771] 2004) MeDitaziONi sull'eCOnomia pOliticA. EdItiOn usED: EDiZioNe nAziONaLe DELle opere di PIeTrO VerrI III: i 'dISCorsI' e aLtri ScritTi degli anni SeTtaNta, eD. gioRgio PAnizzA et aL., ROme: EdIzioni Di StoRiA e Letteratura; EnGl. trAnsl. RefleCtiOnS on poLiticAL EconoMy, eD. PeTer D. GroEnewegeN, new yoRK: aUgUstus M. Kelley, 1993. • WatermAn, aNThOny M. C. (1991) RevOlutioN, ecOnOMics and RElIgiOn: ChRIStian poliTIcAl EconomY, 1798– 1833, CambrIDgE: CAmbridgE UNiversItY PrEss. • whateLY, RicHard ([1831] 1966) InTroductoRy LecTUres on PoliticaL economy, New YorK: keLLEy. • wInch, donAld (1996) Riches anD PovERty: AN IntELlEctUAl HisTory oF POLiTIcal Economy in BritaiN, 1750–1834, CAmbridGe: CamBridge UniversIty Press. • WiNCH, donald anD ColLInI, stephen (1983) That NobLe SciEnce of PoliTIcs: A StudY in NiNeteenth-century InTELlectual hisTorY, CaMbrIDGe: cambridge UnivERSity prEss. An AbDucTive TheOry Of COnsTitUtIon∗ MichaeL BaumgarTnEr†AnD LOreNzo CaSIni‡ AbstrAcT ThE fIrsT part OF this pAper fInds crAvER's (2007) mUtual maNIpULAbilItY tHeorY (MM) Of ConstItutIOn iNadequaTe, as it defIniTIonaLlY tIes consTitution to the FeAsibility oF iDeaLized eXPEriments, Which, however, are unrealizABle in prIncIple. AS an aLternativE, thE seconD paRT develOps an aBductIvE thEORy of cONStItuTiOn (NDC), which EXPloIts thE fAct tHat phenOmena and their constITueNts are unbreakAblY couPLEd Via
) A Treatise on the Record s of the C reati onand  o n th e Mo ral Attributes of t he Creator, London: Ha tchar d. • Tr i be , Kei th (197 8 )L a nd,  L ab our  a n dEcono mic  Discou rse, Alder sho t:  Routledge.•  T ribe, Keit h ( 1995) Strate gie s of E co nom i c Ord er:  Germ an Eco n omic D iscourse,  1 7 50–195 0 , Cambr i d ge : Ca mbridge Universit y  P r ess. • Turgot,  Anne- Ro b er t - Jac que s ([1776]19 14) R é flexion s  s u r laF ormation et l a Distribut i ondes Ri ch ess e s, inOeuvr es deTurgot et d ocum ents le c oncern a nt, vol .  2, ed.  Gusta veSch elle ,  P ar is:  A l can ;  E ngl .  tr ansl. Re fl ex ionson t h e F orma tio n an d Dis tribution ofRic hes, New  York : Kel ley,  1 971.• Verr i, Pi et ro ([1771] 2004 ) Me ditazioni  su ll 'ec on omiap olitic a.Edi tion us ed: Edi z ion eN a z io nale Delle Opere d iP i et ro Verri  III:I  ' Di s corsi' e  a ltr i sc r i tti d egli an ni Setta nta, e d .Gi orgio P an izza e tal. , R ome:E dizi oni di  Storiae Let t eratura; Engl. transl. Refle c ti o n so n Po lit ical Econom y, e d . Pe terD .Gro e neweg en, N ew Yo r k: Augustus M. Kell ey , 1993 . • W aterman, Anth ony M. C.( 1 9 91) Revo luti o n, Economics andRelig ion: Chris t ian Poli tical  Economy , 1798– 1 8 3 3, Cambr idg e:Cam bri d g eUniversity Pr e s s. •  W hately,  Ri chard ( [18 31]  19 66)  I ntroducto ry Lectu re son  P oli tical Economy,  N ewYo rk:  Kell e y. • W inch,  Don al d( 199 6) Rich e sa n d Po ve rt y: A n I nt ellec tual His tory of  Politica l E c onom yin  Britai n, 1750–1834,  C ambridge:Ca mbr idge U n i versityPress. • Winch, Donalda nd Coll ini , Ste phen  (1983) T hat  Noble  Sc i ence o f Poli tics:  A  St u d y inN i ne tee nt h-CenturyI n tel lectu al  His tory, C ambridge: Cambridg e  Un iversity Pres s.An A b d uc tiv e  T h eor yo f C o n stitution∗ Mich ael Baumga rt n er †and Loren z o C as ini‡ Ab stractThe f i rst par t of this  paper fi nd s Cr a v er' s (2007) m utual ma nipulabil i ty th e or y (MM ) o f cons ti tut ion i nadequ a te,  as i t defi ni tional ly ti es  constit ution to the feasibilit y of i deali zed  experime nts ,  wh ich, howe ver,  are unrea liz abl e inpri n ciple . As an  al t ernat ive, the secon d  p art d ev elops an ab d u c tiv e the ory of con stit ution (NDC), whic h  exploits thefact t hat  ph e nome na  and their con sti tu e n ts are u nb reakably co upled vi a
) A_Treatise on_the Records of the_Creation and_on_the Moral_Attributes_of the Creator,_London: Hatchard. •_Tribe, Keith (1978) Land,_Labour and Economic_Discourse,_Aldershot: Routledge. • Tribe, Keith (1995) Strategies of Economic Order: German Economic Discourse, 1750–1950,_Cambridge:_Cambridge University_Press._•_Turgot, Anne-Robert-Jacques ([1776] 1914) Réflexions_sur la Formation et la_Distribution des_Richesses, in Oeuvres de Turgot et documents le_concernant,_vol. 2, ed._Gustave Schelle, Paris: Alcan; Engl. transl. Reflexions on the_Formation and Distribution of Riches, New_York: Kelley, 1971._•_Verri,_Pietro ([1771] 2004) Meditazioni_sull'economia politica. Edition used: Edizione Nazionale_Delle Opere di Pietro Verri III:_I 'Discorsi' e altri scritti degli anni_Settanta, ed. Giorgio Panizza et al.,_Rome: Edizioni di Storia e_Letteratura; Engl._transl. Reflections on Political Economy,_ed. Peter D._Groenewegen, New_York: Augustus M._Kelley, 1993. • Waterman, Anthony M._C. (1991) Revolution,_Economics and Religion: Christian Political Economy,_1798–_1833, Cambridge: Cambridge_University_Press._• Whately,_Richard ([1831] 1966)_Introductory_Lectures on_Political_Economy, New York: Kelley. • Winch,_Donald_(1996) Riches and Poverty: An Intellectual History_of Political Economy in_Britain,_1750–1834, Cambridge: Cambridge University_Press. • Winch, Donald and_Collini, Stephen (1983) That Noble Science_of Politics:_A Study_in Nineteenth-Century Intellectual History, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. An Abductive Theory_of Constitution∗ Michael Baumgartner†and Lorenzo Casini‡_Abstract The first part_of this_paper_finds Craver's (2007)_mutual_manipulability theory_(MM) of constitution inadequate, as it definitionally_ties constitution_to the feasibility of idealized experiments,_which, however, are unrealizable_in_principle. As an alternative, the second_part develops an abductive theory of_constitution (NDC), which exploits the_fact_that_phenomena and their constituents are_unbreakably coupled via