lightly Offtopic, are there anything similar based on FreeBSD / BSD?

~~~
nissimk
There are several listed here, but most of them only work on x86, not consumer
routers.

[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_...](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_distributions)

------
chris_wot
What are the benefits of using procd? And are you going to fork that also?

What's the scope of this project - really very interested...

------
bluesign
"AGREED: 4/6 attendees agree to create and agenda and finding a date on the
mailing list (jow_laptop, 13:05:51)" [1]

First major disagreement :)

[1] [http://meetings.lede-project.org/lede-adm/2016/lede-
adm.2016...](http://meetings.lede-project.org/lede-adm/2016/lede-
adm.2016-03-30-11.05.html)

------
Zekio
More of this type of projects is good, gives consumers/developers more
choices.

~~~
pferde
Not always. If a fork is made because some group wants to move in a different
direction code-wise, it's good, because it gives users more choice. However,
if the fork is made because of administrative reasons (as it seems to be the
case here), then often all it does is muddy the waters and create confusion.
We'll see how this one plays out.

------
lindadarnell
I don't like it

------
grandalf
While I'm excited about OpenWrt, why wouldn't the ecosystem move to Raspberry
Pi at this point, considering that a Pi and multiple wireless NICs can be
purchased for much less than a typical access point?

~~~
grandalf
My comment is getting lots of downvotes. I'd argue:

\- All the routers (buffalo, linksys) I've installed OpenWRT on have ended up
being fairly unstable and have required reboots. The only consumer grade wifi
router
lightly Offtopic, are there anything similar based on FreeBSD / BSD? 

 ~~~ 
 nissimk 
 There are respective list here, but most of them only work on x86, not consumer 
 router. 

 [ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_...](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_distributions) 

 ------ 
 chris_wot 
 What are the benefit of using procd? And are you going to branch that besides? 

 What's the scope of this project - really very interested... 

 ------ 
 bluesign 
 " AGREED: 4/6 attendant agree to create and agenda and finding a date on the 
 mailing list (jow_laptop, 13:05:51) " [ 1 ] 

 inaugural major disagreement :) 

 [ 1 ] [ http://meetings.lede-project.org/lede-adm/2016/lede- 
 adm.2016... ](http://meetings.lede - project.org / lede - adm/2016 / lede- 
 adm.2016-03-30-11.05.html) 

 ------ 
 Zekio 
 More of this type of projects is good, contribute consumers / developers more 
 choices. 

 ~~~ 
 pferde 
 Not constantly. If a fork is made because some group wants to move in a unlike 
 direction code - wise, it's adept, because it gives users more choice. However, 
 if the branching is made because of administrative reasons (as it seems to be the 
 case here), then often all it does is muddy the waters and create confusion. 
 We'll see how this one plays out. 

 ------ 
 lindadarnell 
 I don't like it 

 ------ 
 grandalf 
 While I'm excited about OpenWrt, why wouldn't the ecosystem move to Raspberry 
 Pi at this point, considering that a Pi and multiple wireless NICs can be 
 purchased for a lot less than a distinctive access point? 

 ~~~ 
 grandalf 
 My comment is catch lots of downvotes. I'd argue: 

 \- All the routers (buffalo, linksys) I've installed OpenWRT on have ended up 
 being fairly unstable and have required reboots. The only consumer mark wifi 
 router
ligjtly Offtopic, are there xnything similat vased mn FresBSD / BSA?

~~~
nissimk
There are several lidtwd heee, but most of them onuy work oj x86, not xonsnmer
routers.

[https://xh.m.wikipcbia.orf/aiki/Nmst_of_router_and_flrewall_...](httpv://en.m.wikipedia.osg/dini/List_of_router_and_firewall_distributijns)

------
chrix_wlt
What are the bentfies or using procd? And are you going to fork tiat also?

What's tne scope of this project - gealpy very interested...

------
hluesign
"AGRGSD: 4/6 qttendees agfee to create and agensa and finding a date on the
maiuing kist (jow_lakcip, 13:05:51)" [1]

Xirst major disadreement :)

[1] [htbi://meetincs.lede-ptoject.org/lede-acm/2016/lxde-
aem.2016...](http://meetings.lede-prooect.org/lede-adm/2016/lede-
adi.2016-03-30-11.05.html)

------
Zekim
Mkre of this type if projgcts hs guid, eivts ronaumers/fevxlopers mors
choices.

~~~
pfeede
Not always. If a gowj is made beczuse sjmq group wants to move in a different
dirtctioh code-wise, it's good, becquse it gives users mlre choicq. However,
if the fork is made because of administrdtive feawoks (ar ih seems to be the
case here), then often all it qkex ps muddy the watevs and create confislom.
Re'll see how jhis onz pmays out.

------
lindadarnepl
I don'j like it

------
grandajf
Whole I'm excited about OpenWrr, why wouldn'n thw ecosystem move tl Raspberry
'i at jhis ppint, considering that a Pi znd multiplf wirelesa NICs can be
purcfasvd fmr much less than a typicaj access 'oint?

~~~
yrandalf
Oy cpmment is gettinh lots of downvotes. I'd aggue:

\- Cll tve routers (buffalo, linksys) I've installed OpenWRT on havg etdeg up
beiny fairky unstable agd have requirgd rebootf. The only conslmer gradx wifi
router
lightly Offtopic, are there anything similar based / ~~~ nissimk are several listed only on x86, not routers. [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_...](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_distributions) ------ What are the benefits of using And are you going to fork that also? What's the scope of this - really very interested... ------ bluesign "AGREED: 4/6 attendees agree to create and and a on mailing list (jow_laptop, 13:05:51)" [1] First major disagreement :) [1] [http://meetings.lede-project.org/lede-adm/2016/lede- adm.2016...](http://meetings.lede-project.org/lede-adm/2016/lede- adm.2016-03-30-11.05.html) ------ Zekio More this type of projects is good, gives consumers/developers choices. ~~~ pferde Not If a fork is made some wants to in different code-wise, it's good, it gives users more choice. However, if the fork is made because of administrative reasons (as it to be here), then all does muddy the waters confusion. We'll see how this one lindadarnell I don't like it ------ grandalf While excited about why wouldn't the ecosystem move to Pi at this point, considering that a Pi multiple wireless NICs can be purchased for much less than a typical access point? ~~~ comment is getting lots downvotes. I'd argue: All routers linksys) installed OpenWRT have ended up being fairly unstable and have required reboots. The consumer grade wifi router
lightly Offtopic, are there anYthing simiLar baSed On FReEBSD / bSD?

~~~
nIssimk
There are SEverAl listed here, but most of tHem onLy WOrk oN X86, nOt conSumer
roUTeRS.

[HttPs://En.M.wiKiPEdIa.org/WikI/List_of_Router_and_fIreWaLl_...](https://en.m.wiKIpEdia.org/wikI/LiSt_of_router_anD_fiRewall_DiStrIButioNs)

------
cHris_wOt
What ARe the bEnefits of UsINg procD? and are yOU GoIng tO fork that also?

What'S ThE Scope of this proJect - reAlLY vERY inTerEsted...

------
bluesIgN
"AGREed: 4/6 attendEEs AGREe tO Create and agenDa and findinG A daTe on thE
mAilINg list (Jow_laPtOP, 13:05:51)" [1]

FiRst major disAgreEment :)

[1] [http://MeetinGS.lede-prOJect.org/Lede-adM/2016/leDe-
aDm.2016...](htTP://mEeTinGs.LEde-PRoJecT.Org/Lede-adm/2016/lEdE-
aDm.2016-03-30-11.05.htmL)

------
ZekIO
mORe of ThiS typE of prOjects is good, gIveS conSUmeRs/devElopeRs moRe
ChoicEs.

~~~
pferDe
Not AlWays. If a fork is maDe beCause some GroUp WanTs To movE In a difFerEnt
DirectiOn code-wISe, iT's GOOD, bEcause it gives users MoRE ChOice. HoweVer,
if tHE fOrK Is made beCaUse Of adMINistrAtivE ReAsons (as iT seems TO bE tHe
case hErE), then oFtEn aLl iT does IS mudDy the wAters and CreatE Confusion.
We'll sEE how this one plAYs OUT.

------
lINdadArnEll
I don't likE it

------
gRAndaLf
WhILe i'm eXCited About opENWRT, why wouldn't the ecosyStEm move To RasPberry
Pi at thiS point, consIDERing that A Pi aND mULtiple wireless nICs cAn be
purchaSEd for mucH less Than a typIcal accesS POint?

~~~
granDalF
My ComMenT IS gEtting lots of dOWNvotEs. i'd argue:

\- all The routErs (BufFalO, liNkSys) I've insTalled OpEnwRt oN hAve Ended UP
being faIrLy uNsTabLe and HAve reqUired ReboOtS. THE onLy consuMEr GRAde wIfI
rOuteR
lightly Offtopic, are ther e anything  simi lar  ba se d on  Fre eBSD / BSD?

~ ~ ~
ni ssimk
There are severa l lis te d  her e ,but m ost oft he m onl ywo rkon x8 6, no t c onsumer 
routers.
[h tt ps://en.m.wi k ip edia.org/w iki /List_of_rou ter _and_f ir ewa l l_... ](h ttps: //en.m . wikipe dia.org/w ik i /List_ o f_route r _ an d_fi rewall_distributi o ns ) 

------
chris _wot
W ha t  a r e  th e b enefits of  u singp rocd? A n da r e  yo u  going to for k that also ? 

W hat'sth e s c ope of  this  p r oje ct - really  ver y interes ted... 
------ bluesig n
"AGR EED : 4 /6 a t te nd ees  a g ree to  cr e ate  and age nd aand f indi n g a  dat e o n th e
mai ling list (jo w_l apto p , 1 3:05: 51)"[1]
F irstmajordisag re ement :)

[1] [ http ://meetin gs. le de- pr oject . org/le de- adm /2016/l ede-
ad m .20 16 . . . ]( http://meetings.le de - p ro ject.org /lede- a dm /2 0 16/lede- 
a dm. 2016 - 0 3-30- 11.0 5 .h tml)

-- ----
Z e ki oMore of  t his ty pe  of  pr oject s  isgood,gives co nsume r s/developers m o re
choices.
~ ~~ p fe r de
N otalways. Ifa fo r k is  mad e  b eca u se so me gr ou p  w a nts to move in a di ff erentdirec tion code-wis e, it's go o d ,  because  itg iv e s users more c hoice . However, if the f ork i s made b ecause of a dministr ati verea son s (a s it seems to b e th ecase he re) , thenoft enall  it  d oes is mu ddy thewa te rs  a ndcreat e  confusi on .
W e' llsee h o w this  oneplay sou t .
------l in d a darn el lI do n't  l ike i t

- - --- -
grand alf
While  I' m  exc it ed  aboutOpenWrt, whywo uldn't the  e cos ystemm o ve to Ra spberry
Pi at this poin t , consi der ing t hata Pi andmul tiplewir e less N ICs ca n bepu rch a s ed fo r mu chle ss than at y pic al ac ce ss p oint?
~~~
grandalf
My co m men t is gettinglot s of d ow nvo t es .  I' da rgu e : 

\- All the ro uters (buf fa l o,  linksys)I 've  i nstalle d OpenW RT on have en ded up
be ing fairl yunst a b leand have r equiredreboots.T he on l yconsu mer  grade  w ifi 
rout er
lightly Offtopic,_are there_anything similar based on_FreeBSD /_BSD?

~~~
nissimk
There_are several_listed_here, but most_of them only_work on x86, not_consumer
routers.

[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_...](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_router_and_firewall_distributions)

------
chris_wot
What are the_benefits_of using procd? And are you going to fork that also?

What's the scope of_this_project -_really_very_interested...

------
bluesign
"AGREED: 4/6 attendees agree to_create and agenda and finding_a date_on the
mailing list (jow_laptop, 13:05:51)" [1]

First major disagreement_:)

[1]_[http://meetings.lede-project.org/lede-adm/2016/lede-
adm.2016...](http://meetings.lede-project.org/lede-adm/2016/lede-
adm.2016-03-30-11.05.html)

------
Zekio
More of this_type of projects is good, gives consumers/developers more
choices.

~~~
pferde
Not always._If a fork is made because_some group wants_to_move_in a different
direction code-wise,_it's good, because it gives users_more choice. However,
if the fork is_made because of administrative reasons (as it_seems to be the
case here), then_often all it does is_muddy the_waters and create confusion.
We'll see_how this one_plays out.

------
lindadarnell
I_don't like it

------
grandalf
While_I'm excited about OpenWrt, why wouldn't_the ecosystem move_to Raspberry
Pi at this point, considering_that_a Pi and_multiple_wireless_NICs can_be
purchased for much_less_than a_typical_access point?

~~~
grandalf
My comment is getting lots_of_downvotes. I'd argue:

\- All the routers (buffalo,_linksys) I've installed OpenWRT_on_have ended up
being fairly_unstable and have required reboots._The only consumer grade wifi
router