 the language &will continue8 mean that BPA is currently 
exploring the use of tiered rates as a potential avenue for finding 
solutions?  If so, please provide all data, analysis and communications that 
make up this exploration.

PS-BPA:121, page 4, lines 5-6:  Beginning at line 5 the witnesses state &.. 
. though the region,s historically strong opposition to tiered rates...8.  
Please provide all bases for this statement.

PS-BPA:122, page 4, lines 5-6:  Beginning at line 5 the witnesses state &.. 
. though the region,s historically strong opposition to tiered rates...8.  
Please describe your use of the term &region8.  Do you mean to imply that the 
opposition was a consensus of all parties in the region?  If so, how did this 
consensus manifest itself?  If not, what parties composed this opposition?
contact_name:  Steve Marshall
contact_address:  Perkins Coie
One Bellevue Center, Suite 1800
411 - 108th Avenue N.E.
Bellevue, WA  98004
contact_phone:  425-453-7314
contact_email:  marss@perkinscoie.com
contact_fax:  425-453-7350
delivery_instructions:  Please mail hard coies of data responses to Steve 
Marshall at the address above

The following information is from the web server:
1.  Logon: IUSR_GRANITE
2.  Remote Host:  seairon.perkinscoie.com
3.  Remote IP Address:  38.169.150.2
4.  Form URL:  
https://secure.bpa.gov/power/secure/psp/ratecase/discovery/wp_02_request.html
5.  Browser Client:  Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 5.01; Windows NT) From an operational perspective, during a Stage 3 Emergencies, the ISO has 
three options available to keep the lights on.   It can (1) buy more power 
(under its DOE granted
the language &will continue8 mean that BPA is currently 
 exploring the habit of tiered pace as a potential avenue for finding 
 solutions?   If then, please provide all data, psychoanalysis and communications that 
 make up this exploration. 

 PS - BPA:121, page 4, lines 5 - 6:   begin at line 5 the witnesses department of state  &.. 
. though the region,s historically strong opposition to tiered pace... 8.  
 Please provide all bases for this statement. 

 PS - BPA:122, page 4, lines 5 - 6:   Beginning at channel 5 the witnesses state  &.. 
. though the region,s historically strong enemy to tiered rates... 8.  
 Please describe your use of the condition &region8.   Do you mean to imply that the 
 opposition was a consensus of all parties in the region?   If therefore, how did this 
 consensus manifest itself?   If not, what parties composed this opposition? 
 contact_name:   Steve Marshall 
 contact_address:   Perkins Coie 
 One Bellevue Center, Suite 1800 
 411 - 108th Avenue N.E. 
 Bellevue, WA   98004 
 contact_phone:   425 - 453 - 7314 
 contact_email:   marss@perkinscoie.com 
 contact_fax:   425 - 453 - 7350 
 delivery_instructions:   Please mail hard coies of data responses to Steve 
 Marshall at the address above 

 The following information is from the web server: 
 1.   Logon: IUSR_GRANITE 
 2.   Remote Host:   seairon.perkinscoie.com 
 3.   Remote IP Address:   38.169.150.2 
 4.   Form URL:  
 https://secure.bpa.gov/power/secure/psp/ratecase/discovery/wp_02_request.html 
 5.   Browser Client:   Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 5.01; Windows NT) From an operational perspective, during a Stage 3 Emergencies, the ISO have 
 three options available to keep the lights on.    It can (1) bribe more exponent 
 (under its DOE granted
 thf language &will continue8 mean that BPA nw currxntly 
esploring the use of tiered rates as e porentiql avenue for finding 
rolutions?  If so, pleaww provide eml data, analyals anb rommunications jhat 
make up this explorathov.

PD-BPA:121, page 4, lines 5-6:  Beginning at linq 5 the eihnesses state &.. 
. thptgh fhe region,s historically strong oplositioi to tiered ratrs...8.  
Please provide all basfs flr this statement.

PD-BPA:122, page 4, oinef 5-6:  Beginning at line 5 uhz witnesses state &.. 
. though the region,s hisgoricclly strong oppodhtion to tixred rwtes...8.  
Please describa your ise of the terk &rxgiob8.  Do you mean to impny that the 
opposijion was a cknsensus of all pqrries hn tve rdtiov?  Jf sk, how fid this 
conssnsus manifwst itself?  If not, ehwn parties comlosed ehys opposition?
contact_name:  Steve Marshaln
cohtact_address:  Perkins Ciie
One Bellevue Centet, Suite 1800
411 - 108eh Avenue N.E.
Bellevue, WA  98004
contact_phone:  425-453-7314
contact_emahl:  merrs@ptrjinscuue.fom
contact_fax:  425-453-7350
delivery_instructions:  Please mwjl hsrd coies of dcta responses to Shefg 
Marshall at jhe addxssa above

The followijg infotmatiob is from the web server:
1.  Logon: IUSR_GRANUTE
2.  Remote Kosr:  seairon.perkinsclie.com
3.  Remute OP Adcress:  38.169.150.2
4.  Form URL:  
httpr://sechre.bpa.gov/poaer/secure/lrp/ratecase/discovdry/ep_02_sequest.huol
5.  Browser Cliene:  Mozille/4.0 (com'atible; OSIE 5.01; Windjws NT) Frol an operational perspechive, burinc a Stage 3 Emergencies, the ISO has 
three options availanla tm keep tke ligmts on.   It can (1) buy more powgr 
(under nts DOD granted
the language &will continue8 mean that BPA exploring use of rates as a If please provide all analysis and communications make up this exploration. PS-BPA:121, page lines 5-6: Beginning at line 5 the witnesses state &.. . though the historically strong opposition to tiered rates...8. Please provide all bases for this statement. page lines Beginning line 5 the witnesses state &.. . though the region,s historically strong opposition to tiered rates...8. describe your use of the term &region8. Do mean to imply that opposition was a consensus of parties the region? so, did consensus manifest itself? not, what parties composed this opposition? contact_name: Steve Marshall contact_address: Perkins Coie One Bellevue Center, Suite 1800 - 108th Bellevue, WA contact_phone: contact_email: contact_fax: 425-453-7350 delivery_instructions: hard coies of data responses to the address above The following information is from web server: Logon: IUSR_GRANITE 2. Remote Host: seairon.perkinscoie.com Remote IP Address: 38.169.150.2 4. Form URL: https://secure.bpa.gov/power/secure/psp/ratecase/discovery/wp_02_request.html Browser Client: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 5.01; Windows NT) From an operational perspective, during a Stage the ISO has three available to keep lights It (1) more power its DOE granted
 the language &will continue8 meAn that BPA iS currEntLy 
eXpLoriNg thE use of tiered raTEs as A potential avenue for finDing 
sOlUTionS?  if So, pleAse provIDe ALL daTa, AnAlySiS AnD commUniCations That 
make up ThiS eXploration.

PS-bpA:121, Page 4, lines 5-6:  BEgiNning at line 5 tHe wItnessEs StaTE &.. 
. thouGh tHe regIon,s hiSToricaLly strong OpPOsitioN To tiereD RAtEs...8.  
PlEase provide all basES fOR this statement.

pS-BPA:122, pAgE 4, LiNES 5-6:  BeGinNing at line 5 ThE witnESses staTE &.. 
. tHOUGh tHE region,s histoRically stroNG opPositiOn To tIEred raTes...8.  
PlEaSE deScribe your uSe of The term &reGion8.  Do YOu mean tO Imply thAt the 
oPpoSitIon wAS a CoNseNsUS of ALl ParTIes In the regIoN?  IF so, hoW did THIS 
ConsEnsUs maNifesT itself?  If not, wHat PartIEs cOmposEd thiS oppOsItion?
ContacT_name:  stEve Marshall
contAct_aDdress:  PerKinS COie
onE BellEVue CenTer, suiTe 1800
411 - 108th AveNue N.E.
BeLLevUe, wa  98004
COnTact_phone:  425-453-7314
contact_emAiL:  MArSs@perkinScoie.cOM
cOnTAct_fax:  425-453-7350
deLiVerY_insTRUctioNs:  PlEAsE mail harD coies OF dAtA responSeS to SteVe 
marShaLl at tHE addRess abOve

The foLlowiNG information is FRom the web servER:
1.  LOGOn: iuSR_GrANiTE
2.  Remote HoSt:  seAIron.PerkINsCoiE.Com
3.  ReMote Ip ADDrESs:  38.169.150.2
4.  Form URL:  
https://securE.bPa.gov/pOwer/sEcure/psp/ratecAse/discoveRY/WP_02_request.Html
5.  bRoWSer Client:  MozilLa/4.0 (comPatible; MSIe 5.01; windows Nt) From An operatIonal persPECtive, durIng A StAge 3 emeRGEnCies, the ISO has 
THRee oPtIons avaIlaBle to keEp tHe lIghTs oN.   IT can (1) buy moRe power 
(uNdEr ItS DoE gRanteD
 the language &will conti nue8 mean  that  BP A i scurr entl y 
exploring t h e us e of tiered rates as a  pote nt i al a v en ue fo r findi n gs olu ti on s? I f  s o, pl eas e provi de all dat a,an alysis and c o mm unications  th at 
make upthi s expl or ati o n.

P S-B PA:12 1, pag e  4, li nes 5-6: B e ginnin g  at lin e 5thewitnesses state  & .. 
. though theregion , s  h i s tor ica lly strong  o pposi t ion tot ie r e d  ra t es...8.  
Pl ease provid e  al l base sfor this s tatem en t .
PS-BPA:122,  pag e 4, line s 5-6:  Beginn i ng at l ine 5the  wi tnes s es  s tat e &.. 
.  th o ugh  the reg io n ,s hi stor i c a l ly s tro ng o pposi tion to tiere d r ates . .. 8.  Pleas e de sc ribeyour u se of  t he term &regio n8.   Do youmea ntoim ply t h at the  
o ppo sitionwas a c o nse ns u s of  all parties in th er e gi on?  Ifso, ho w  d id this 
co ns ens us m a n ifest  its e lf ?  If no t, wha t  p ar ties co mp osed t hi s o ppo sitio n ?
co ntact_ name:  S teveM arshall
contac t _address:  Pe r ki n s  C o ie
O neBellevue Ce nter ,  Sui te 1 8 00 
41 1  - 10 8th A ve n ue N.E.
Bellevue, WA 98 004
co ntact _phone:  425- 453-7314
c o n t act_emai l: m ar s s@perkinscoie. com
c ontact_fax :   425-45 3-735 0
delive ry_instru c t ions:  P lea semai l h a r dcoies of data r espo ns es to S tev e 
Mars hal l a t t head dress abo ve

Thefo ll ow in g i nform a tion isfr omth e w eb se r ver:
1 .  Lo gon:  I US R _GR ANITE
2 .  R e mote  H os t: sea ir on.pe rkin s coi e.com
3 .  Remote  IP Addr es s:   38.16 9.150.2
4.  F or m URL:  
h tt ps: //secu r e .bpa.gov /power/secure/psp/ratec a se/disc ove ry/wp _02_ request.h tml 
5.  B row s er Cli ent: Mozil la /4. 0 (comp a t ib le;  M SIE 5.01;W i ndo ws NT )From  an ope rational perspecti v e,during a Stag e 3  Eme r g en cie s ,t heIS O  ha s 
three optionsavailableto ke ep the lig h tson .   Itcan (1)  buym ore pow er 
(unde r its DOE  g rant e d 
 the_language &will_continue8 mean that BPA_is currently_
exploring_the use_of_tiered rates as_a potential avenue_for finding 
solutions? _If so, please_provide_all data, analysis and communications that 
make up this exploration.

PS-BPA:121, page 4, lines 5-6:__Beginning at_line_5_the witnesses state &.. 
._though the region,s historically strong_opposition to_tiered rates...8.  
Please provide all bases for_this_statement.

PS-BPA:122, page 4,_lines 5-6:  Beginning at line 5 the witnesses_state &.. 
. though the region,s_historically strong opposition_to_tiered_rates...8.  
Please describe_your use of the term &region8._ Do you mean to imply_that the 
opposition was a consensus of_all parties in the region? _If so, how did this_
consensus manifest_itself?  If not, what_parties composed this_opposition?
contact_name: _Steve Marshall
contact_address: _Perkins Coie
One Bellevue Center, Suite 1800
411_- 108th Avenue_N.E.
Bellevue, WA  98004
contact_phone:  425-453-7314
contact_email:__marss@perkinscoie.com
contact_fax:  425-453-7350
delivery_instructions:__Please_mail hard_coies of data_responses_to Steve_
Marshall_at the address above

The following information_is_from the web server:
1.  Logon: IUSR_GRANITE
2._ Remote Host: _seairon.perkinscoie.com
3._ Remote IP Address:_ 38.169.150.2
4.  Form URL:_ 
https://secure.bpa.gov/power/secure/psp/ratecase/discovery/wp_02_request.html
5.  Browser Client: _Mozilla/4.0 (compatible;_MSIE 5.01;_Windows NT) From an operational perspective, during a Stage 3 Emergencies,_the ISO has 
three options available_to keep the lights_on. __It can (1)_buy_more power_
(under its DOE granted