 combining measurements of the temperature and polarization anisotropies of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), future experiments will tightly constrain the expansion rate of the universe during recombination. A change in the expansion rate modifies the way in which the recombination of hydrogen proceeds, altering the shape of the acoustic peaks and the level of CMB polarization. The proposed test is similar in spirit to the examination of abundances of light elements produced during Big Bang Nucleosynthesis and it constitutes a way to study possible departures from standard recombination. For simplicity we parametrize the change in the Friedmann equation by changing the gravitational constant $G$. The main effect on the temperature power spectrum is a change in the degree of damping of the acoustic peaks on small angular scales. The effect can be compensated by a change in the shape of the primordial power spectrum. We show that this degeneracy between the expansion rate and the primordial spectrum can be broken by measuring CMB polarization. In particular we show that the MAP satellite could obtain a constraint for the expansion rate $H$ during recombination of $\delta H/H \simeq 0.09$ or $\delta G/G \simeq 0.18$ after observing for four years, whereas Planck could obtain $\delta H/H \leq 0.014$ or $\delta G/G \leq 0.028$ within two years, even after allowing for further freedom in the shape of the power spectrum of primordial fluctuations.'
address:
- '$^1$Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität, Geschwister-Scholl-Platz 1, 80799 München'
- '$^2$Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, P.O. Box 1317, 85741 Garching'
- '$^3$Dept. of Physics, New York University, 4 Washington Pl., New York, NY 10003'
- |
    $^4$Institute for Advanced Study, Einstein Drive, Princeton NJ 08540\
    [(Received 16 December 2002; revised manuscript received 19 February 2003; published 18 March 2003)]{}
author:
- 'Oliver Zahn$^{1,2,3}$[^1] and Matias Zaldarriaga$^{3,4}$[^2]'
title: Probing the Friedmann equation during recombination with future CMB experiments
---

Introduction\[introduction\]
============================

The parameters of our cosmological model will be determined with great accuracy by upcoming data
combining measurements of the temperature and polarization anisotropies of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), future experiments will tightly restrain the expansion pace of the universe during recombination. A change in the expansion pace modifies the room in which the recombination of hydrogen proceeds, altering the form of the acoustic peaks and the level of CMB polarization. The propose test is similar in heart to the examination of abundances of easy element produced during Big Bang Nucleosynthesis and it constitutes a way to study possible departure from standard recombination. For simplicity we parametrize the change in the Friedmann equation by switch the gravitational constant $ G$. The main effect on the temperature power spectrum is a variety in the degree of dampen of the acoustic peaks on small angular scales. The consequence can be compensated by a change in the shape of the primordial power spectrum. We show that this degeneracy between the expansion rate and the primordial spectrum can be broken by measuring CMB polarization. In particular we show that the MAP satellite could obtain a constraint for the expansion rate $ H$ during recombination of $ \delta H / H \simeq 0.09 $ or $ \delta G / G \simeq 0.18 $ after observing for four old age, whereas Planck could obtain $ \delta H / H \leq 0.014 $ or $ \delta G / G \leq 0.028 $ within two years, even after give up for further exemption in the condition of the power spectrum of primordial fluctuations.' 
 address: 
 -' $ ^1$Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig - Maximilians - Universität, Geschwister - Scholl - Platz 1, 80799 München' 
 -' $ ^2$Max - Planck - Institut für Astrophysik, P.O. Box 1317, 85741 Garching' 
 -' $ ^3$Dept. of Physics, New York University, 4 Washington Pl. , New York, NY 10003' 
 - | 
     $ ^4$Institute for Advanced Study, Einstein Drive, Princeton NJ 08540\ 
     [ (Received 16 December 2002; revised manuscript received 19 February 2003; publish 18 March 2003) ] { } 
 author: 
 -' Oliver Zahn$^{1,2,3}$[^1 ] and Matias Zaldarriaga$^{3,4}$[^2 ]' 
 title: Probing the Friedmann equation during recombination with future CMB experiments 
 --- 

 Introduction\[introduction\ ] 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 The parameters of our cosmologic model will be determined with great accuracy by upcoming datum
 colbining measurements of uhe temperature aue polacizatioh anisotfopies of the Cosmic Microwate Bqckgriund (CMB), future experioents wilp tightlt coistrain the expaiaion rabz of fme unnvxrse during recpmbination. A change in tve erpansion rate modifies the way in whych the rfcombination os hycwogeh proceeds, altering the shape of tge acouvtic peaks anc the level of CMB polarizwtioj. The proposed tesh is similat in wpirit to thd examinatpmn of abunsances of light elements producdd duxing Big Babg Nufneosynthesiw and it constitubvs a waf to stidy possible dcpartnres from standard recombmnation. For simplicijy we parakecrize the change in tye Friegmant eqjqtiun gy cganginh tie gravitatjonal constqnt $G$. The main effevt in the temperzture [orer spectrum is a change in the degree mf samping of the acoustic peaks on small angulwr scales. The effect can be compensated by a change in the shapx uf uhc oeilordial power spectrum. We show that this degegsrscj between the expcnsion rate and yhf ltimordial specjrum cau bs broken by measurlng CMB polaeization. Yn psrticular we show that the NAP satellitv coyld obtain a constxaint for thz expamsion rate $H$ during recombinction kf $\delta H/H \simeq 0.09$ od $\delta G/G \simeq 0.18$ afner mbserving for four years, wrereas Plenck eould obgain $\delta H/H \leq 0.014$ og $\delbd G/G \leq 0.028$ within tao yecrs, eeen after wllowing for further freedom in the shape of jhe pofer speccrum on primordial fltctuations.'
addrgss:
- '$^1$Fakulcät für Ohysik, Ludsig-Maxikilians-Univqrsität, Geschwhdter-Scholl-Pletz 1, 80799 Müncren'
- '$^2$Nax-Poanck-Inrgitut für Astrolhysik, P.O. Box 1317, 85741 Garxhing'
- '$^3$Dept. of Physlcs, Ngw York Universitv, 4 Washington Pl., Mew Yowk, NB 10003'
- |
    $^4$Institute fmr Aavavved Sgudy, Einsteln Arivr, Princeton NJ 08540\
    [(Raceibed 16 December 2002; revoscd manusctipt receyved 19 Februaru 2003; published 18 Marcj 2003)]{}
autior:
- 'Olmver Zshn$^{1,2,3}$[^1] and Matias Zaldarriaga$^{3,4}$[^2]'
title: Pdobing thf Fviedmann equaeion during recokbination with future CMB experiments
---

Invroduction\[introduction\]
============================

Jhe parameters of our gosmological modej will be determined with greqt accuracy by upgoming data
combining measurements of the temperature and polarization the Microwave Background future experiments will of universe during recombination. change in the rate modifies the way in which recombination of hydrogen proceeds, altering the shape of the acoustic peaks and the of CMB polarization. The proposed test is similar in spirit to the examination abundances light produced Big Bang Nucleosynthesis and it constitutes a way to study possible departures from standard recombination. For we parametrize the change in the Friedmann equation changing the gravitational constant The main effect on the power is a in degree damping of the peaks on small angular scales. The effect can be compensated by a change in the shape of primordial power show that degeneracy the rate and the can be broken by measuring CMB we show that the MAP satellite could obtain constraint for expansion rate $H$ during recombination of H/H \simeq 0.09$ or $\delta G/G \simeq 0.18$ observing for four years, whereas Planck could obtain $\delta H/H \leq 0.014$ or $\delta G/G within two years, even allowing for further in shape the spectrum of fluctuations.' address: - '$^1$Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität, Geschwister-Scholl-Platz 1, 80799 München' '$^2$Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, P.O. Box 1317, 85741 Garching' - '$^3$Dept. New University, 4 Washington New York, NY 10003' | for Advanced Study, Einstein NJ [(Received revised received February 2003; published 18 2003)]{} author: - 'Oliver Zahn$^{1,2,3}$[^1] Matias Zaldarriaga$^{3,4}$[^2]' title: Probing with future CMB experiments --- Introduction\[introduction\] ============================ The of our cosmological model will be determined great accuracy by upcoming data
 combining measurements of thE temperatuRe and PolAriZaTion AnisOtropies of the COSmic microwave Background (CMB), FuturE eXPeriMEnTs wilL tightlY CoNSTraIn ThE exPaNSiOn ratE of The univErse during RecOmBination. A chaNGe In the expanSioN rate modifieS thE way in WhIch THe recOmbInatiOn of hyDRogen pRoceeds, alTeRIng the SHape of tHE AcOustIc peaks and the leveL Of cmB polarization. the proPoSEd TESt iS siMilar in spiRiT to thE ExaminaTIoN OF AbuNDances of light Elements proDUceD durinG BIg BANg NuclEosynThESis And it constiTuteS a way to stUdy posSIble depARtures fRom staNdaRd rEcomBInAtIon. foR SimPLiCitY We pArametriZe ThE chanGe in THE fRiedManN equAtion By changing the GraVitaTIonAl conStant $g$. The MaIn effEct on tHe temPeRature power specTrum Is a change In tHe DegReE of daMPing of The AcoUstic peAks on smALl aNgULAR sCales. The effect can bE cOMPeNsated by A changE In ThE Shape of tHe PriMordIAL poweR speCTrUm. We show That thIS dEgEneracy BeTween tHe ExpAnsIon raTE and The priMordial sPectrUM can be broken by MEasuring CMB poLArIZAtIOn. In ParTicular we shOw thAT the mAP sATeLliTE coulD obtaIn A CoNStraint for the expansIoN rate $H$ DurinG recombinatioN of $\delta H/H \SIMEq 0.09$ or $\deltA G/G \sIMeQ 0.18$ After observing For foUr years, wheREas PlancK coulD obtain $\dElta H/H \leq 0.014$ OR $\Delta G/G \lEq 0.028$ wIthIn tWo yEARs, Even after alloWINg foR fUrther fReeDom in thE shApe Of tHe pOwEr spectruM of primoRdIaL fLuCtuAtionS.'
Address:
- '$^1$FAkUltÄt Für physiK, ludwig-maximIliaNs-unIVerSität, GeSChWISter-scHoLl-PlAtz 1, 80799 müNchen'
- '$^2$max-PLAncK-InstitUt für AstrOphYSik, P.o. BOx 1317, 85741 garchinG'
- '$^3$Dept. of PhysicS, NEw York UnivErSitY, 4 WashiNGTon Pl., New york, NY 10003'
- |
    $^4$Institute for AdvanCEd Study, einStein drivE, PrincetoN NJ 08540\
    [(receivEd 16 DECember 2002; ReviseD manuScRipT REceivED 19 feBruArY 2003; published 18 mARch 2003)]{}
AuthoR:
- 'OLiveR Zahn$^{1,2,3}$[^1] anD Matias Zaldarriaga$^{3,4}$[^2]'
TItlE: Probing the FrIedMann EQUaTioN DuRIng ReCOmbINAtion with future cMB experimEnTS
---

INtroductioN\[IntRoDuction\]
============================

the paraMeterS Of our coSmologicaL model wilL bE detERMinEd with greaT accuracY by upcomiNG data
 combining measurements of  the tempe ratur e a ndpo lari zati on anisotropie s  ofthe Cosmic Microwave B ackgr ou n d (C M B) , fut ure exp e ri m e nts  w il l t ig h tl y con str ain the  expansion  ra te  of the univ e rs e during r eco mbination. A  ch ange i nthe expan sio n rat e modi f ies th e way inwh i ch the recombi n a ti on o f hydrogen procee d s, altering the s hape o ft he a cou sti c peaks an dthe l e vel ofC MB p o lar i zation. The p roposed tes t  is  simil ar  in spirit  to t he exa mination of  abu ndances o f ligh t  elemen t s produ ced du rin g B ig B a ng  N ucl eo s ynt h es isa ndit const it ut es awayt o s tudy  po ssib le de partures from  st anda r d r ecomb inati on.Fo r sim plicit y wepa rametrize the c hang e in theFri ed man nequat i on bycha ngi ng thegravita t ion al c o ns tant $G$. The main  e f f ec t on the  tempe r at ur e  power s pe ctr um i s a cha ngei nthe degr ee ofd am pi ng of t he  acous ti c p eak s ons mall  angul ar scale s. Th e  effect can be compensated b y  a c ha n ge i n t he shape of  the prim ordi a lpow e r spe ctrum .W es how that this degen er acy be tween  the expansio n rate and t h e primor dial sp e ctrum can be b roken  by measur i ng CMB p olari zation.In partic u l ar we sh owtha t t heM A Psatellite cou l d  obt ai n a con str aint fo r t heexp ans io n rate $H $ during  r ec om bi nat ion o f  $\delta  H /H\s ime q 0.0 9 $ or $ \delt a G/ G\s i meq  0.18$a ft e r  obs er vi ng f orfo ur ye ars, whe reas Pl anck coul d o b tain  $ \d elta H/ H \leq 0.014$  o r $\deltaG/ G \ leq 0. 0 2 8$ withi n two years, even after allowin g f or fu rthe r freedom  in  the s hap e  of th e powe r spe ct rum o f pri m o rd ial  f luctuation s . '
a ddres s: 
- ' $^1$Fak ultät für Physik,L udw ig-Maximilian s-U nive r s it ät, Ge s chw is t er- S c holl-Platz 1, 8 0799 Münch en ' 
-  '$^2$Max- P lan ck -Instit ut fürAstro p hysik,P.O. Box1317, 857 41  Gar c h ing '
- '$^3$D ept. ofPhysics,N ew Yo r kUnive rsi ty, 4Wa shi ngton  Pl.,N ewYork,  NY 10 00 3'
- | 
   $^ 4$Instit ute for Advanced Study,  Einst ein D riv e, Prince ton NJ08540\
   [( Received 1 6 D ece mber200 2 ; rev ised ma nus c riptrece i ved 19 Fe b ru ary 2 00 3; publishe d 1 8 M arch200 3 )]{}
a utho r:
- 'Oliver Zahn $ ^{1,2,3}$[^1]andM a tia s Z a ldar ri aga$^{3,4}$[^2 ]'ti t l e: Probi ng  the Friedm ann equa ti o n dur ing re combin ation w i t hf utureCMBexp eriments--- 
I ntroduc ti on \ [intro duct io n\]
== ====== = ==== = = =============

T he pa r a meter s  of  ourco smologi c al m odel willbe determin ed wit h gr eat a ccuracy  b y upco min gdata
 combining_measurements of_the temperature and polarization_anisotropies of_the_Cosmic Microwave_Background_(CMB), future experiments_will tightly constrain_the expansion rate of_the universe during_recombination._A change in the expansion rate modifies the way in which the recombination of_hydrogen_proceeds, altering_the_shape_of the acoustic peaks and_the level of CMB polarization._The proposed_test is similar in spirit to the examination_of_abundances of light_elements produced during Big Bang Nucleosynthesis and it constitutes_a way to study possible departures_from standard recombination._For_simplicity_we parametrize the change_in the Friedmann equation by changing_the gravitational constant $G$. The main_effect on the temperature power spectrum is_a change in the degree of_damping of the acoustic peaks_on small_angular scales. The effect can_be compensated by_a change_in the shape_of the primordial power spectrum. We_show that this_degeneracy between the expansion rate and_the_primordial spectrum can_be_broken_by measuring_CMB polarization. In_particular_we show_that_the MAP satellite could obtain a_constraint_for the expansion rate $H$ during recombination_of $\delta H/H \simeq_0.09$_or $\delta G/G \simeq_0.18$ after observing for four_years, whereas Planck could obtain $\delta_H/H \leq_0.014$ or_$\delta G/G \leq 0.028$ within two years, even after allowing for_further freedom in the shape of_the power spectrum of_primordial fluctuations.'
address:
-_'$^1$Fakultät_für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität,_Geschwister-Scholl-Platz_1, 80799_München'
- '$^2$Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, P.O. Box 1317,_85741 Garching'
-_'$^3$Dept. of Physics, New York University,_4 Washington Pl., New_York,_NY 10003'
- |
   _$^4$Institute for Advanced Study, Einstein Drive,_Princeton NJ 08540\
  __[(Received_16 December 2002; revised manuscript_received 19 February 2003; published 18_March 2003)]{}
author:
- 'Oliver_Zahn$^{1,2,3}$[^1] and Matias Zaldarriaga$^{3,4}$[^2]'
title: Probing the Friedmann_equation_during recombination with future CMB experiments
---

Introduction\[introduction\]
============================

The_parameters_of our cosmological model will be_determined_with_great accuracy by upcoming data