 multiplying the second row by the scalar $x^{N-1}+x^{N-2}+\cdots+x+1\in R$ yields the zero element $(0,0) \in R^2$.

Acknowledgment {#acknowledgment.unnumbered}
==============

The authors gratefully acknowledge contributions to the proofs by Pascal Vontobel and Lance Small. The authors would also like to thank Dariush Divsalar for useful discussions.

[^1]: This work was presented in part at the IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory, Austin, Texas, June 2010.

[^2]: The authors are with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of California, San Diego (UCSD), La Jolla, CA 92093 USA (e-mail: butler@ieee.org, psiegel@ucsd.edu).

[^3]: This work was supported in part by the Center for Magnetic Recording Research at UCSD and by the National Science Foundation (NSF) under Grant CCF-0829865 and Grant CCF-1116739.

[^4]: The proof holds no matter which row is chosen for removal; however, the row removal process terminates more rapidly if a dependent row is chosen.
 ---
abstract: 'The large-scale circulation of planetary atmospheres like that of the Earth is traditionally thought of in a dynamical framework. Here, we apply the statistical mechanics theory of turbulent flows to a simplified model of the global atmosphere, the *quasi-geostrophic* model, leading to non-trivial equilibria. Depending on a few global parameters, the structure of the flow may be either a solid-body rotation (zonal flow) or a dipole. A second order phase transition occurs between these two phases, with associated spontaneous symmetry-breaking in the dipole phase. This model allows us to go beyond the general theory of marginal ensemble equivalence through the notion of Goldstone modes.'
author:
- 'C. Herbert'
- 'B. Dubrulle'
- 'P.H. Chavanis'
- 'D. Paillard'
title: |
    Phase transitions and marginal ensemble equivalence for freely evolving flows\
    on a rotating sphere
---

Introduction
============

It is well known that two-dimensional (2D) turbulent flows develop large-scale coherent structures [@McWilliams1984], and widely believed that the existence of these structures is related to the existence of
multiplying the second row by the scalar $ x^{N-1}+x^{N-2}+\cdots+x+1\in R$ yields the zero element $ (0,0) \in R^2$. 

 Acknowledgment { # acknowledgment.unnumbered } 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 The writer appreciatively acknowledge contributions to the proofs by Pascal Vontobel and Lance Small. The generator would also like to thank Dariush Divsalar for utilitarian discussions. 

 [ ^1 ]: This work was presented in region at the IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory, Austin, Texas, June 2010. 

 [ ^2 ]: The authors are with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of California, San Diego (UCSD), La Jolla, CA 92093 USA (e - chain mail: butler@ieee.org, psiegel@ucsd.edu). 

 [ ^3 ]: This work was supported in part by the Center for Magnetic Recording Research at UCSD and by the National Science Foundation (NSF) under Grant CCF-0829865 and Grant CCF-1116739. 

 [ ^4 ]: The proof hold no matter which row is chosen for removal; however, the row removal procedure terminates more rapidly if a dependent rowing is chosen. 
  --- 
 abstract:' The large - scale circulation of planetal atmospheres like that of the Earth is traditionally thought of in a dynamical framework. Here, we apply the statistical automobile mechanic theory of turbulent flows to a simplified model of the global atmosphere, the * quasi - geostrophic * model, leading to non - trivial equilibria. Depending on a few global parameters, the structure of the flow may be either a solid - body rotation (zonal stream) or a dipole. A second order phase transition occur between these two phases, with associated spontaneous symmetry - breaking in the dipole phase. This exemplar allows us to go beyond the general theory of bare ensemble equivalence through the notion of Goldstone modes.' 
 author: 
 -' C. Herbert' 
 -' B. Dubrulle' 
 -' P.H. Chavanis' 
 -' D. Paillard' 
 title: | 
     Phase transitions and borderline ensemble equivalence for freely evolving flows\ 
     on a rotating sphere 
 --- 

 initiation 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 It is well known that two - dimensional (2D) turbulent stream develop large - scale coherent structures [ @McWilliams1984 ], and widely believe that the existence of these structures is related to the existence of
 muptiplying the second row by the scalar $r^{B-1}+x^{N-2}+\cdovs+x+1\in R$ yields ghe zero element $(0,0) \in R^2$.

Acknowpeegmenu {#acknowledgment.unnjmbered}
==============

Thv authors grauefully acknowledjs contrlyutiohd to vhe proofs by Psscal Vontmbel and Lance Soapl. The authors would also like to trank Datiksh Divsalar fjr uxqful discussions.

[^1]: This work was presentsd in pert at the IEEE International Symposium oj Invormation Theory, Akstin, Texas, Junq 2010.

[^2]: The authorr are with the Departmgnt of Electrical and Computer Evginezring, Univetsjtj of Califoriia, Sag Diego (UCSD), La Jolld, CA 92093 UXA (e-mail: butlev@ieee.mrg, psiegel@ucsd.edu).

[^3]: This xork was supported ig part by tke Center for Magnetix Eecorging Resdqrcf au URSD and bj tie National Science Foyndation (NSF) under Brwbt CCF-0829865 and Grznt CCS-1116739.

[^4]: Ehe proof holds no matter which row is bhossn for removal; however, rhe row removal proceds terminwtes more rapidly if a dependent row is chosen.
 ---
abvtracv: 'Ghe lwfte-dcale circulation of planetary atmospheres lihs uhan of the Earth is traditionaklj yrought of in x dynamiczl framework. Here, ae appli the wtatisticwl mrchanics theory of turbulenr flows to a wimplified model oy the global atmpsphete, the *quasi-geostrophic* modsl, leading ho non-tribkal equilibria. Ddpekditg on a few global parametqrs, the svructbre of tfe fkow mar be eitheg a solid-body rotation (zlnal ylow) mr a dipolf. A second order phase transition occurs betwgen thvse two pkases, eith associatqd spontaneous symmetxy-breaying in thv dipole 'hase. This mjdel allows uv to go beyonv the genqral theiry of oxrginal ensembke equivalence throygh the notion of Noldsjohe modes.'
author:
- 'E. Yerbert'
- 'B. Dubrukle'
- 'P.H. Cjatanis'
- 'G. Paillard'
tidle: |
    Lhase transiunonw and marginal ensemble exuivzlence for freely rvjlving foows\
    jn a rotating sphere
---

Introductioj
============

It iv wxll knpwn that two-dimensional (2D) turbuleht flows fevclop large-scaje ciherent struetures [@McWilliams1984], and widely believed thet the existence of thgse structures is relcttd to the exixtencq of
multiplying the second row by the scalar yields zero element \in R^2$. Acknowledgment acknowledge to the proofs Pascal Vontobel and Small. The authors would also like thank Dariush Divsalar for useful discussions. [^1]: This work was presented in part the IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory, Austin, Texas, June 2010. [^2]: The are the of and Computer Engineering, University of California, San Diego (UCSD), La Jolla, CA 92093 USA (e-mail: butler@ieee.org, [^3]: This work was supported in part by Center for Magnetic Recording at UCSD and by the Science (NSF) under CCF-0829865 Grant [^4]: The proof no matter which row is chosen for removal; however, the row removal process terminates more rapidly if dependent row --- abstract: large-scale of atmospheres like that Earth is traditionally thought of in Here, we apply the statistical mechanics theory of flows to simplified model of the global atmosphere, *quasi-geostrophic* model, leading to non-trivial equilibria. Depending on few global parameters, the structure of the flow may be either a solid-body rotation (zonal a dipole. A second phase transition occurs these phases, associated symmetry-breaking in dipole phase. This model allows us to go beyond the general of marginal ensemble equivalence through the notion of Goldstone modes.' 'C. - 'B. Dubrulle' 'P.H. Chavanis' - 'D. title: Phase transitions and marginal for evolving rotating --- ============ It is well that two-dimensional (2D) turbulent flows large-scale coherent structures [@McWilliams1984], existence of these structures is related to the of
 multiplying the second row by The scalar $x^{n-1}+x^{N-2}+\cdOts+X+1\in r$ yIeldS the Zero element $(0,0) \in R^2$.

aCknoWledgment {#acknowledgmenT.unnuMbERed}
==============

THE aUthorS gratefULlY ACknOwLeDge CoNTrIbutiOns To the prOofs by PascAl VOnTobel and LancE smAll. The authOrs Would also likE to Thank DArIusH divsaLar For usEful diSCussioNs.

[^1]: This worK wAS preseNTed in paRT At The IeEE International SYMpOSium on InformatIon TheOrY, auSTIn, TExaS, June 2010.

[^2]: The auThOrs arE With the dEpARTMenT Of Electrical aNd Computer ENGinEering, unIveRSity of califOrNIa, SAn Diego (UCSD), la JoLla, CA 92093 USA (e-Mail: buTLer@ieee.ORg, psiegEl@ucsd.Edu).

[^3]: thiS worK WaS sUppOrTEd iN PaRt bY The center foR MAgNetic recoRDING ResEarCh at uCSD aNd by the NationAl SCienCE FoUndatIon (NSf) undEr grant cCF-0829865 and grant cCf-1116739.

[^4]: The proof holds nO matTer which rOw iS cHosEn For reMOval; hoWevEr, tHe row reMoval prOCesS tERMInAtes more rapidly if a DePENdEnt row is Chosen.
 ---
ABsTrACt: 'The larGe-ScaLe ciRCUlatiOn of PLaNetary atMospheREs LiKe that oF tHe EartH iS trAdiTionaLLy thOught oF in a dynaMical FRamework. Here, we APply the statisTIcAL MeCHaniCs tHeory of turbUlenT FlowS to a SImPliFIed moDel of ThE GlOBal atmosphere, the *quaSi-GeostrOphic* Model, leading tO non-triviaL EQUilibria. depeNDiNG on a few global pArameTers, the strUCture of tHe floW may be eiTher a soliD-BOdy rotatIon (ZonAl fLow) OR A dIpole. A second oRDEr phAsE transiTioN occurs BetWeeN thEse TwO phases, wiTh associAtEd SpOnTanEous sYMmetry-brEaKinG iN thE dipoLE phase. this mOdel AlLoWS us To go beyONd THE genErAl TheoRy oF mArginAl enSEmbLe equivAlence thrOugH The nOtIoN of GoldStone modes.'
autHoR:
- 'C. Herbert'
- 'B. duBruLle'
- 'P.H. CHAVanis'
- 'D. PaIllard'
title: |
    Phase transitIOns and mArgInal eNsemBle equivaLenCe for fReeLY evolvIng floWs\
    on a RoTatING spheRE
---

inTroDuCtion
============

It is wELL knOwn thAt Two-dImensioNal (2D) turbulent flows DEveLop large-scale CohErenT STrUctUReS [@mcWIlLIamS1984], ANd widely believeD that the exIsTEnCe of these sTRucTuRes is reLated to The exIStence oF
 multiplying the second ro w by the s calar  $x ^{N -1 }+x^ {N-2 }+\cdots+x+1\i n  R$yields the zero elemen t $(0 ,0 )  \in R^ 2$.
Acknowl e dg m e nt{# ac kno wl e dg ment. unn umbered }
======== === == =

The autho r sgratefully  ac knowledge co ntr ibutio ns  to the p roo fs by  Pasca l  Vonto bel and L an c e Smal l . The a u t ho rs w ould also like to th a nk Dariush Div salarfo r  u s e ful  di scussions. 
[^1]: This wo r kw a s  pr e sented in par t at the IE E E I nterna ti ona l  Sympo siumon Inf ormation Th eory , Austin,  Texas ,  June 2 0 10.

[^ 2]: Th e a uth orsa re  w ith  t h e D e pa rtm e ntof Elect ri ca l and  Com p u t e r En gin eeri ng, U niversity ofCal ifor n ia,  SanDiego  (UC SD ), La  Jolla , CA92 093 USA (e-mail : bu tler@ieee .or g,  ps ie gel@u c sd.edu ).
[^ 3]: Thi s workw assu p p o rt ed in part by theCe n t er  for Mag neticR ec or d ing Rese ar chat U C S D and  byt he  Nationa l Scie n ce  F oundati on  (NSF)  u nde r G rantC CF-0 829865  and Gra nt CC F -1116739.

[^4 ] : The proof h o ld s no matt erwhich row i s ch o senforr em ova l ; how ever,  t h er ow removal processte rminat es mo re rapidly if  a depende n t row is c hose n .---
abstract:'Thelarge-scal e  circula tionof plane tary atmo s p heres li ketha t o f t h e  E arth is tradi t i onal ly  though t o f in adyn ami cal  fr am ework. He re, we a pp ly  t he  st atist i cal mech an ics  t heo ry of turbul ent f lows  t oa  si mplifie d  m o d el o fth e gl oba latmos pher e , t he *qua si-geostr oph i c* m od el , leadi ng to non-tri vi al equilib ri a.Depend i n g on a f ew global parameters, t h e struc tur e oftheflow maybeeither  as olid-b ody ro tatio n(zo n a l flo w )  o r a  d ipole. A s e c ond  orde rphas e trans ition occurs betwe e n t hese two phas es,  wit h as soc i at e d s po n tan e o us symmetry-bre aking in t he di pole phase .  Th is  modelallowsus to go beyo nd the ge neral the or y of m arg inal ensem ble equi valence t h rough th e not ion  of Go ld sto ne mo des.'a uth or:
-  'C. H er bert'- 'B.  D ubrulle' 
- 'P.H. Chavanis'
- 'D . Pail lard' 
ti tle: |
   P h ase  transiti onsand margin alens emble  eq u ivale ncef or  fr e ely e volv i ng flows\    o n arotating sp h e r e
- --

I ntr o ductio n
== ==========

It is well known tha t tw o - dim ens i onal  ( 2D) turbulentflo ws d evelop l ar ge-scale co herent s tr u cture s [@Mc Willia ms1984] , an d  widel y be lie ved thatthe  e x istence  o ft hese s truc tu res is  relat e d to t he existence of
 multiplying_the second_row by the scalar_$x^{N-1}+x^{N-2}+\cdots+x+1\in R$_yields_the zero_element_$(0,0) \in R^2$.

Acknowledgment_{#acknowledgment.unnumbered}
==============

The authors gratefully_acknowledge contributions to the_proofs by Pascal_Vontobel_and Lance Small. The authors would also like to thank Dariush Divsalar for useful_discussions.

[^1]:_This work_was_presented_in part at the IEEE_International Symposium on Information Theory,_Austin, Texas,_June 2010.

[^2]: The authors are with the Department_of_Electrical and Computer_Engineering, University of California, San Diego (UCSD), La Jolla,_CA 92093 USA (e-mail: butler@ieee.org, psiegel@ucsd.edu).

[^3]:_This work was_supported_in_part by the Center_for Magnetic Recording Research at UCSD_and by the National Science Foundation_(NSF) under Grant CCF-0829865 and Grant CCF-1116739.

[^4]:_The proof holds no matter which_row is chosen for removal;_however, the_row removal process terminates more_rapidly if a_dependent row_is chosen.
 ---
abstract:_'The large-scale circulation of planetary atmospheres_like that of_the Earth is traditionally thought of_in_a dynamical framework._Here,_we_apply the_statistical mechanics theory_of_turbulent flows_to_a simplified model of the global_atmosphere,_the *quasi-geostrophic* model, leading to non-trivial equilibria._Depending on a few_global_parameters, the structure of_the flow may be either_a solid-body rotation (zonal flow) or_a dipole._A second_order phase transition occurs between these two phases, with associated spontaneous_symmetry-breaking in the dipole phase. This_model allows us to_go beyond_the_general theory of_marginal_ensemble equivalence_through the notion of Goldstone modes.'
author:
- 'C._Herbert'
- 'B._Dubrulle'
- 'P.H. Chavanis'
- 'D. Paillard'
title: |
_   Phase_transitions_and marginal ensemble equivalence for freely_evolving flows\
    on_a rotating sphere
---

Introduction
============

It is well_known_that_two-dimensional (2D) turbulent flows develop_large-scale coherent structures [@McWilliams1984], and widely_believed that the_existence of these structures is related to_the_existence of