 general graphs we show that fixed response dynamics converge to a steady state. On the complete graph we show that best response dynamics also converge to a steady state. Both of these results hold regardless of the initial conditions (i.e., the agents’ estimators at time $t=0$).

We show that the steady state of best response dynamics is not necessarily optimal; there exist fixed response dynamics in which the agents converge to estimators which all have lower variance then the estimators of the steady state of best response dynamics. This shows that every agent can do better than the result of best response by following a socially optimal rule; thus a certain [*price of anarchy*]{} is to be paid when agents choose the action that maximizes their short term gain.

Finally, we show that in the penultimate prediction model, for the complete graph, the agents learn estimators which are the optimal (in the minimum variance sense) amongst all linear estimators, and thus outperform those of fixed and best response dynamics.

We define a notion of “socially asymptotic learning”: A model has this property when the variance of the agents’ steady-state estimators tends towards the information-theoretical optimum with the number of agents. We show that the penultimate prediction model exhibits socially asymptotic learning on the complete graph, while best response and fixed response dynamics fail to do the same.

Previous work
=============

Our model is an elaboration of models studied by DeMarzo, Vayanos and Zwiebel [@DeMarzo:03], as well as Mossel and Tamuz [@mossel2010iterative; @MosselTamuz10:arxiv]. There, the state $S$ is a fixed number picked at time $t=0$, and each agent receives a single measurement of it. The process thereafter is deterministic, with each agent, at each iteration, recalculating its estimate of $S$ based on its observation of its neighbors’ estimates.

In [@MosselTamuz10:arxiv] it is shown that if the agents calculate the minimum variance unbiased linear estimator (MVULE) at every turn (remembering all of their observations) then all the agents converge to the optimal estimator of $S$, i.e. the average of the original measurements. Furthermore, this happens in time that is at most $n
\cdot d$, where $d$ is the diameter of the graph.

When agents calculate estimates that are only based on their
general graphs we show that fixed reception moral force converge to a steady state. On the accomplished graph we testify that best response moral force also converge to a steady state. Both of these consequence hold regardless of the initial conditions (i.e., the agent ’ estimators at time $ t=0 $). 

 We read that the regular state of best response dynamics is not necessarily optimum; there exist fixed response dynamics in which the agent converge to estimators which all have depleted discrepancy then the estimators of the steady state of best response moral force. This shows that every agent can do better than the result of best reception by following a socially optimal rule; thus a certain [ * price of anarchy * ] { } is to be paid when agents choose the action that maximizes their inadequate term gain. 

 last, we picture that in the penultimate prediction model, for the complete graph, the agents determine estimators which are the optimal (in the minimum variance common sense) amongst all linear estimators, and thus outperform those of fixed and best response dynamics. 

 We define a notion of “ socially asymptotic learning ”: A model receive this property when the variation of the agents ’ steady - state estimators tends towards the data - theoretical optimum with the number of agents. We show that the penultimate prediction model exhibits socially asymptotic learning on the complete graph, while best response and fix response moral force fail to do the same. 

 Previous work 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 Our model is an amplification of models study by DeMarzo, Vayanos and Zwiebel   [ @DeMarzo:03 ], as well as Mossel and Tamuz   [ @mossel2010iterative; @MosselTamuz10: arxiv ]. There, the department of state $ S$ is a fixed number picked at prison term $ t=0 $, and each agent receive a single measurement of it. The process thereafter is deterministic, with each agent, at each iteration, recalculating its estimate of $ S$ based on its observation of its neighbors ’ estimate. 

 In   [ @MosselTamuz10: arxiv ] it is shown that if the agents account the minimum variance unbiased linear estimator (MVULE) at every turn (commemorate all of their observations) then all the agents converge to the optimal estimator of $ S$, i.e. the average of the original measurements. Furthermore, this happens in clock time that is at about $ n 
 \cdot d$, where $ d$ is the diameter of the graph. 

 When agents calculate estimates that are only based on their
 gejeral graphs we show thau fixed response btnamicv convsrge to x steady state. On the compleve geaph qe show that best respunse dynalics alsi coiverge to a steavg state. Both kn thevx results hold tegardless ox the initial wovdntions (i.e., the agents’ estimators at tyme $t=0$).

We sjow that the sjeady ftats of best response dynamics is not necesserily optimal; tnere exist fixed response fynalics in which the wgents convgdge ro estimatorr which all have lower variance then the estimators ow the steady stqtw ov best respoise dygamics. This shows thdt everu agent can do bevter than the result of bxst response by folljwing a smcnally optimal rule; thys a cettain [*prizw ow ahacchg*]{} is tl bx paid when agents choise the action that mwqomizes their short tqrm gain.

Finally, we show that in the penlltijate prediction model, fir the complete graph, the agenes learn estimators which are the optimal (in the kinimnm vaxlwvxe sense) amongst all linear estimators, and thus kuupegform those of fiwed and best respomsf cinamics.

We defive a notikn of “socially asylptotic learbing”: A moqel nas this property when the cariance of nhe qgents’ steady-state estimators tencs toeards the information-thzoretidal optimum with the vumber of agents. We svow that the penultimate pwediction modzl exhibkts xocialjy asymptohic lcdrning on the comppete yraph, while besh response and fixed response dbiamics fail tp go nhe same.

Pxevioux work
=============

Our modql is an elabotation of modeus studied by DeMerzo, Vayanos and Zwiebel [@DaLarzo:03], as weln as Mosfel qnd Ramuz [@morrel2010iterative; @MpsselTamud10:axxiv]. Therw, the state $S$ is a fibsd number pickeb qt time $t=0$, and esch agqnn rxceivqv a single maasufemdmt of it. The progesr thrreafter is determinhstid, with each agent, st each itgration, rqcalculating ots estimate of $S$ hased on its pbsgrvation of its neighbors’ estimztes.

In [@MosdelBamuz10:arxiv] it is whown that iy the agents calculate the minimum variaice unbiased linear esjimator (MVULE) at everi tmrn (remembermng alj of theis observations) then qll the agents cokverge to the optimal sstimador ov $S$, i.e. the average of the original measurements. Furthermore, this happens un timx ehat is at jost $n
\cdon d$, chere $d$ is vhx diameter of the graph.

When agents calculate estmmates thad cre only based on their
general graphs we show that fixed response to steady state. the complete graph dynamics converge to a state. Both of results hold regardless of the initial (i.e., the agents’ estimators at time $t=0$). We show that the steady state best response dynamics is not necessarily optimal; there exist fixed response dynamics in the converge estimators all have lower variance then the estimators of the steady state of best response dynamics. This that every agent can do better than the of best response by a socially optimal rule; thus certain of anarchy*]{} to paid agents choose the that maximizes their short term gain. Finally, we show that in the penultimate prediction model, for the graph, the estimators which the (in minimum variance sense) linear estimators, and thus outperform those best response dynamics. We define a notion of asymptotic learning”: model has this property when the of the agents’ steady-state estimators tends towards the optimum with the number of agents. We show that the penultimate prediction model exhibits socially on the complete graph, best response and response fail do same. Previous ============= Our model is an elaboration of models studied by DeMarzo, and Zwiebel [@DeMarzo:03], as well as Mossel and Tamuz [@mossel2010iterative; the $S$ is a number picked at time and agent receives a single it. process with agent, each iteration, recalculating its of $S$ based on its of its neighbors’ estimates. that if the agents calculate the minimum variance linear estimator (MVULE) at every turn (remembering of their observations) then all the agents converge to the optimal estimator $S$, i.e. of the original measurements. Furthermore, this happens in that is at most \cdot d$, where $d$ is the diameter of the When calculate estimates are only based their
 general graphs we show that fiXed responsE dynaMicS coNvErge To a sTeady state. On thE CompLete graph we show that besT respOnSE dynAMiCs alsO converGE tO A SteAdY sTatE. BOTh Of theSe rEsults hOld regardlEss Of The initial coNDiTions (i.e., the AgeNts’ estimatorS at Time $t=0$).

WE sHow THat thE stEady sTate of BEst resPonse dynaMiCS is not NEcessarILY oPtimAl; there exist fixed REsPOnse dynamics in Which tHe AGeNTS coNveRge to estimAtOrs whICh all haVE lOWER vaRIance then the eStimators of THe sTeady sTaTe oF Best reSponsE dYNamIcs. This showS thaT every ageNt can dO Better tHAn the reSult of BesT reSponSE bY fOllOwINg a SOcIalLY opTimal rulE; tHuS a cerTain [*PRICE of aNarChy*]{} iS to be Paid when agentS chOose THe aCtion That mAximIzEs theIr shorT term GaIn.

Finally, we show That In the penuLtiMaTe pReDictiON model, For The CompletE graph, tHE agEnTS LEaRn estimators which aRe THE oPtimal (in The minIMuM vARiance seNsE) amOngsT ALl linEar eSTiMators, anD thus oUTpErForm thoSe Of fixeD aNd bEst RespoNSe dyNamics.

we define A notiON of “socially asyMPtotic learninG”: a mODEl HAs thIs pRoperty when The vARianCe of THe AgeNTs’ steAdy-stAtE EsTImators tends towards ThE inforMatioN-theoretical oPtimum with THE Number of AgenTS. WE Show that the penUltimAte predictIOn model eXhibiTs socialLy asymptoTIC learninG on The ComPleTE GrAph, while best rESPonsE aNd fixed ResPonse dyNamIcs FaiL to Do The same.

PrEvious woRk
=============

ouR mOdEl iS an elABoration Of ModElS stUdied BY DeMarZo, VayAnos AnD ZWIebEl [@DeMarZO:03], aS WEll aS MOsSel aNd TAmUz [@mosSel2010iTEraTive; @MosSelTamuz10:aRxiV]. therE, tHe State $S$ iS a fixed number PiCked at time $T=0$, aNd eAch ageNT Receives A single measurement of it. THE procesS thEreafTer iS determinIstIc, with EacH Agent, aT each iTeratIoN, reCALculaTINg Its EsTimate of $S$ bASEd oN its oBsErvaTion of iTs neighbors’ estimatES.

In [@mosselTamuz10:arXiv] It is SHOwN thAT iF The AgENts CALculate the minimUm variance UnBIaSed linear eSTimAtOr (MVULE) At every Turn (rEMemberiNg all of thEir observAtIons) THEn aLl the agentS convergE to the optIMal esTImAtor oF $S$, i.E. the avErAge Of the OriginAL meAsureMents. FUrThermoRe, thiS hAppens in Time that is at most $n
\cdot d$, wHere $d$ iS the dIamEter of the GraPH.

WhEn agents cAlcuLate estimaTes ThaT are oNly BAsed oN theIR
 general graphs we show th at fixed r espon sedyn am icsconv erge to a stea d y st ate. On the complete g raphwe show th at be st resp o ns e dyn am ic s a ls o  c onver geto a st eady state . B ot h of these r e su lts hold r ega rdless of th e i nitial  c ond i tions  (i .e.,the ag e nts’ e stimators  a t  time$ t=0$).W eshow  that the steadys ta t e of best resp onse d yn a mi c s  is  no t necessar il y opt i mal; th e re e x ist fixed respons e dynamicsi n w hich t he  ag e nts co nverg et o e stimators w hich  all have  lower varianc e  then t he est ima tor s of th este ad y  st a te  of bes t respon se  d ynami cs.T h i s  sho wsthat  ever y agent can d o b ette r  th an th e res ultof  best  respo nse b yfollowing a soc iall y optimal  ru le ; t hu s a c e rtain[*p ric e of an archy*] { } i st o be  paid when agentsch o o se  the act ion th a tma x imizes t he irshor t termgain . 
Finally,  we sh o wth at in t he  penul ti mat e p redic t ionmodel,  for the  comp l ete graph, the agents learne st i m at o rs w hic h are the o ptim a l (i n th e  m ini m um va rianc es en s e) amongst all line ar  estim ators , and thus ou tperform t h o s e of fix ed a n db est response d ynami cs.

We de f ine a no tionof “soci ally asym p t otic lea rni ng” : A  mo d e lhas this prop e r ty w he n the v ari ance of  th e a gen ts’  s teady-sta te estim at or ste nds  towa r ds the i nf orm at ion -theo r etical  opti mumwi th the  number of a gent s.  W e sh owth at th e pe n ult imate p rediction  mo d el e xh ib its soc ially asympto ti c learning  o n t he com p l ete grap h, while best responsea nd fixe d r espon se d ynamics f ail  to do  th e  same. 

Prev iouswo rk= = ===== = = == ==
O ur model i s anelabo ra tion  of mod els studied by DeM a rzo , Vayanos and  Zw iebe l [@ DeM a rz o :03 ], asw e ll as Mossel an d Tamuz [@ mo s se l2010itera t ive ;@Mossel Tamuz10 :arxi v ]. Ther e, the st ate $S$ i sa fi x e d n umber pick ed at ti me $t=0$, and e a ch  agen t r eceive sa s ingle  measu r eme nt of  it. T he  proce ss th er eafter i s deterministic, with e ach ag ent,ateach iter ati o n,recalcula ting  its estim ate  of  $S$bas e d onitso bs erv a tionof i t s neighbo r s’  es t i ma tes.

In [@ M o s sel Tamuz 10: a rxiv]it i s shown that if t h e agents calcu late t hemin i mumva riance unbiase d l in e a r estima to r (MVULE) a t everytu r n (re member ing al l of th e i ro bserva tion s)then allthe  a g ents co nv er g e to t he o pt imal e stimat o r of $ S$, i.e. the ave rageo f  theo rig inalme asureme n ts.Furthermor e, this hap pens i n ti me th at is a tmost $ n
\ cd ot d$, whe r e $d$ isthe d iameter  o f th e g raph.
Whe n agent s ca lc ula te estima t e st ha ta reonly  base don t heir
 general_graphs we_show that fixed response_dynamics converge_to_a steady_state._On the complete_graph we show_that best response dynamics_also converge to_a_steady state. Both of these results hold regardless of the initial conditions (i.e., the_agents’_estimators at_time_$t=0$).

We_show that the steady state_of best response dynamics is_not necessarily_optimal; there exist fixed response dynamics in which_the_agents converge to_estimators which all have lower variance then the estimators_of the steady state of best_response dynamics. This_shows_that_every agent can do_better than the result of best_response by following a socially optimal_rule; thus a certain [*price of anarchy*]{}_is to be paid when agents_choose the action that maximizes_their short_term gain.

Finally, we show that_in the penultimate_prediction model,_for the complete_graph, the agents learn estimators which_are the optimal_(in the minimum variance sense) amongst_all_linear estimators, and_thus_outperform_those of_fixed and best_response_dynamics.

We define_a_notion of “socially asymptotic learning”: A_model_has this property when the variance of_the agents’ steady-state estimators_tends_towards the information-theoretical optimum_with the number of agents._We show that the penultimate prediction_model exhibits_socially asymptotic_learning on the complete graph, while best response and fixed response_dynamics fail to do the same.

Previous_work
=============

Our model is an_elaboration of_models_studied by DeMarzo,_Vayanos_and Zwiebel [@DeMarzo:03],_as well as Mossel and Tamuz [@mossel2010iterative; @MosselTamuz10:arxiv]._There, the_state $S$ is a fixed number_picked at time $t=0$,_and_each agent receives a single measurement_of it. The process thereafter is_deterministic, with each agent, at_each_iteration,_recalculating its estimate of $S$_based on its observation of its_neighbors’ estimates.

In [@MosselTamuz10:arxiv] it_is shown that if the agents calculate_the_minimum variance unbiased linear estimator (MVULE)_at_every turn (remembering all of their_observations)_then_all the agents converge to_the optimal estimator of $S$, i.e._the average of the original measurements. Furthermore, this happens_in time that_is at most $n
\cdot d$,_where_$d$_is the diameter of the graph.

When agents calculate estimates that_are only_based on their