|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) d\mathcal{H}^{n-1} =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) \sqrt{1 + (\tan \theta)^2} dx = \int_{x}^{z} (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) \frac{1}{|\cos \theta|} dx =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} (1 + |\tan \theta|) dx = |z - x| + \int_{x}^{z} |g'| dx \geq |z - x| + |t - y|,$$

where the inequality becomes equality iff $g$ is monotone (remember we assumed it to be $C^1$). Thus there are multiple functions minimizing this integral.

4\. Now we allow $\partial E_t$ to contain vertical intervals. The difference is purely technical, as we have to divide our integral into two parts. Let us suppose that the (orientated) length of $i-$th vertical interval equals $\lambda_i$, then we have

$$\int_{\text{graph part of } \partial E_t} (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) dl + \int_{\text{vertical part of } \partial E_t} (1 + 0) dl = \int_{x}^{z} (1 + |g'|) dx + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty} |\lambda_i| =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} |g'| dx + |z - x| + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty} |\lambda_i| \geq |t - y - \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty} \lambda_i| + |z - x| + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty} |\lambda_i| \geq |z - x| + |t - y|,$$

where the inequality becomes equality iff $g$ is monotone (remember we assumed it to be $C^1$) and all the vertical intervals are orientated in the same direction as $g'$. Thus there are multiple functions minimizing this integral. We have proved that in a class containing all smooth functions the problem of minimizing perimeter of a set $E_t$ doesn’t have a unique solution.

5\. Let us
|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) d\mathcal{H}^{n-1 } = $ $ 

 $ $ = \int_{x}^{z } (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) \sqrt{1 + (\tan \theta)^2 } dx = \int_{x}^{z } (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) \frac{1}{|\cos \theta| } dx = $ $ 

 $ $ = \int_{x}^{z } (1 + |\tan \theta|) dx = |z - x| + \int_{x}^{z } |g'| dx \geq |z - x| + |t - y|,$$ 

 where the inequality becomes equality iff $ g$ is monotone (remember we assumed it to be $ C^1 $). therefore there be multiple functions minimizing this built-in. 

 4\. Now we admit $ \partial E_t$ to contain erect intervals. The difference is purely technical, as we suffer to divide our integral into two parts. lease us suppose that the (orientated) duration of $ i-$th vertical interval equals $ \lambda_i$, then we have 

 $ $ \int_{\text{graph part of } \partial E_t } (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) dl + \int_{\text{vertical region of } \partial E_t } (1 + 0) dl = \int_{x}^{z } (1 + |g'|) dx + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty } |\lambda_i| = $ $ 

 $ $ = \int_{x}^{z } |g'| dx + |z - x| + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty } |\lambda_i| \geq |t - y - \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty } \lambda_i| + |z - x| + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty } |\lambda_i| \geq |z - x| + |t - y|,$$ 

 where the inequality becomes equality iff $ g$ is monotone (remember we bear it to be $ C^1 $) and all the vertical intervals are orientated in the same guidance as $ g'$. Thus there are multiple functions minimizing this integral. We have prove that in a class containing all smooth functions the problem of minimize perimeter of a set $ E_t$ does n’t have a unique solution. 

 5\. Let us
|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) d\mathcxl{H}^{n-1} =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \tgeta|) \sqrg{1 + (\tan \theta)^2} dx = \int_{x}^{z} (|\sin \tieta| + |\cos \theta|) \frac{1}{|\cos \theta|} db =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} (1 + |\tan \thwta|) vx = |z - x| + \int_{x}^{z} |j'| dx \geq |z - x| + |b - y|,$$

wkece the inequalijy becomes exuality iff $g$ hs mlnotone (remember we assumed it to bq $C^1$). Thux hhere are multyple suncfpoks minimizing this integral.

4\. Now se allox $\partial E_t$ to contain vertical intervald. Thf difference is pugely technixal, ww we have to divide oug integral jnto two parts. Let us suppose tfat tke (orientatgb) lejcth of $i-$th terticwl interval cauals $\nambda_i$, then we have

$$\ikt_{\texv{graph part of } \partial E_v} (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theja|) dl + \int_{\dert{vertical part of } \pqrrial G_t} (1 + 0) dl = \unt_{b}^{z} (1 + |j'|) ds + \sum_{l = 1}^{\mnfty} |\lambdz_i| =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} |g'| dx + |z - x| + \sum_{i = 1}^{\ingtr} |\lambda_i| \geq |f - y - \fui_{i = 1}^{\infty} \lambda_i| + |z - x| + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty} |\lakbdz_i| \geq |z - x| + |t - y|,$$

where rhe inequality becomed equalitr iff $g$ is monotone (remember we assumed it to be $W^1$) and xll tme vdetlcal intervals are orientated in the same dirqdtook as $g'$. Thus therc are multiple funvtlomf minimizing jhis incsgdal. We have proved that ig a coass contwinimg all smooth functions the problem of iunimizing perimetex of a set $E_c$ doesm’t hafe a unique solution.

5\. Lec us
|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) d\mathcal{H}^{n-1} =$$ (|\sin + |\cos \sqrt{1 + (\tan \theta| |\cos \theta|) \frac{1}{|\cos dx =$$ $$= (1 + |\tan \theta|) dx = - x| + \int_{x}^{z} |g'| dx \geq |z - x| + |t - where the inequality becomes equality iff $g$ is monotone (remember we assumed it be Thus are functions minimizing this integral. 4\. Now we allow $\partial E_t$ to contain vertical intervals. The difference purely technical, as we have to divide our into two parts. Let suppose that the (orientated) length $i-$th interval equals then have part of } E_t} (|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) dl + \int_{\text{vertical part of } \partial E_t} (1 + 0) = \int_{x}^{z} |g'|) dx \sum_{i 1}^{\infty} =$$ $$= \int_{x}^{z} + |z - x| + \sum_{i \geq |t - y - \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty} + |z x| + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty} |\lambda_i| |z - x| + |t - y|,$$ where inequality becomes equality iff $g$ is monotone (remember we assumed it to be $C^1$) and vertical intervals are orientated the same direction $g'$. there multiple minimizing this We have proved that in a class containing all smooth functions problem of minimizing perimeter of a set $E_t$ doesn’t have solution. Let us
|\sin \theta| + |\cos \theta|) d\mathcal{H}^{N-1} =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} (|\sin \tHeta| + |\cOs \tHetA|) \sQrt{1 + (\tAn \thEta)^2} dx = \int_{x}^{z} (|\sin \tHEta| + |\cOs \theta|) \frac{1}{|\cos \theta|} dx =$$

$$= \iNt_{x}^{z} (1 + |\tAn \THeta|) DX = |z - X| + \int_{x}^{Z} |g'| dx \geq |Z - X| + |t - Y|,$$

WHerE tHe IneQuALiTy becOmeS equaliTy iff $g$ is moNotOnE (remember we aSSuMed it to be $C^1$). thuS there are mulTipLe funcTiOns MInimiZinG this IntegrAL.

4\. Now we Allow $\partIaL e_t$ to coNTain verTICaL intErvals. The differenCE iS Purely technicaL, as we hAvE To DIVidE ouR integral iNtO two pARts. Let uS SuPPOSe tHAt the (orientatEd) length of $i-$TH veRtical InTerVAl equaLs $\lamBdA_I$, thEn we have

$$\int_{\Text{Graph part Of } \partIAl E_t} (|\sin \THeta| + |\cos \Theta|) dL + \inT_{\teXt{veRTiCaL paRt OF } \paRTiAl E_T} (1 + 0) Dl = \iNt_{x}^{z} (1 + |g'|) dx + \sUm_{I = 1}^{\iNfty} |\lAmbdA_I| =$$

$$= \INT_{x}^{z} |g'| Dx + |z - X| + \sum_{I = 1}^{\inftY} |\lambda_i| \geq |t - y - \Sum_{I = 1}^{\infTY} \laMbda_i| + |Z - x| + \sum_{I = 1}^{\infTy} |\LambdA_i| \geq |z - X| + |t - y|,$$

whErE the inequality bEcomEs equalitY ifF $g$ Is mOnOtone (REmembeR we AssUmed it tO be $C^1$) and ALl tHe VERTiCal intervals are oriEnTATeD in the saMe direCTiOn AS $g'$. Thus thErE arE mulTIPle fuNctiONs MinimiziNg this INtEgRal. We haVe Proved ThAt iN a cLass cONtaiNing alL smooth fUnctiONs the problem of MInimizing periMEtER Of A Set $E_T$ doEsn’t have a unIque SOlutIon.

5\. LET uS
|\sin \theta| + |\cos \the ta|) d\mat hcal{ H}^ {n- 1}  =$$ 

$$ = \int_{x}^{z} (|\s in \theta| + |\cos \th eta|)  \ s qrt{ 1  +  (\ta n \thet a )^ 2 }  dx  =  \ int _{ x }^ {z} ( |\s in \the ta| + |\co s \ th eta|) \frac{ 1 }{ |\cos \the ta| } dx =$$

$$ = \ int_{x }^ {z} (1 +|\t an \t heta|) dx = | z - x| +\i n t_{x}^ { z} |g'| d x\geq  |z - x| + |t - y | ,$ $ 

where the in equali ty be c o mes  eq uality iff  $ g$ is monoton e  ( r e m emb e r we assumedit to be $C ^ 1$) . Thus  t her e  are m ultip le fun ctions mini mizi ng this i ntegra l .

4\.N ow we a llow $ \pa rti al E _ t$  t o c on t ain ve rti c alinterval s.  T he di ffer e n c e  ispur elytechn ical, as we h ave  tod ivi de ou r int egra lintotwo pa rts.Le t us suppose th at t he (orien tat ed ) l en gth o f  $i-$t h v ert ical in tervale qua ls $ \ la mbda_i$, then we h av e 
$ $\int_{\ text{g r ap hp art of }  \ par tial E _t} ( |\si n  \ theta| +  |\cos \t he ta|) dl  +  \int_ {\ tex t{v ertic a l pa rt of} \parti al E_ t } (1 + 0) dl = \int_{x}^{z}( 1+ |g ' |) d x +  \sum_{i =1}^{ \ inft y} | \ la mbd a _i| = $$

$ $= \i n t_{x}^{z} |g'| dx +  | z - x|  + \s um_{i = 1}^{\ infty} |\l a m b da_i| \g eq | t  - y - \sum_{i =1}^{\ infty} \la m bda_i| +  |z -  x| + \s um_{i = 1 } ^ {\infty}  |\ lam bda _i| \ ge q |z - x| + | t - y| ,$ $

wher e t he ineq ual ity  be com es  equality  iff $g$  i smo no ton e (re m ember we  a ssu me d i t tob e $C^1 $) an d al lth e  ve rticali nt e r vals  a re  ori ent at ed in  the sam e direc tion as $ g'$ .  Thu sth ere are  multiple fun ct ions minim iz ing  thisi n tegral.We have proved that ina  classcon taini ng a ll smooth  fu nction s t h e prob lem of  mini mi zin g perim e t er  of  a  set $E_t$ d oes n’t h av e auniquesolution.

5\. Let us
|\sin \theta|_+ |\cos_\theta|) d\mathcal{H}^{n-1} =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z}_(|\sin \theta|_+_|\cos \theta|)_\sqrt{1_+ (\tan \theta)^2}_dx = \int_{x}^{z}_(|\sin \theta| + |\cos_\theta|) \frac{1}{|\cos \theta|}_dx_=$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z} (1 + |\tan \theta|) dx = |z - x| + \int_{x}^{z} |g'|_dx_\geq |z_-_x|_+ |t - y|,$$

where the_inequality becomes equality iff $g$_is monotone_(remember we assumed it to be $C^1$). Thus_there_are multiple functions_minimizing this integral.

4\. Now we allow $\partial E_t$ to_contain vertical intervals. The difference is_purely technical, as_we_have_to divide our integral_into two parts. Let us suppose_that the (orientated) length of $i-$th_vertical interval equals $\lambda_i$, then we have

$$\int_{\text{graph_part of } \partial E_t} (|\sin_\theta| + |\cos \theta|) dl_+ \int_{\text{vertical_part of } \partial E_t}_(1 + 0)_dl =_\int_{x}^{z} (1 +_|g'|) dx + \sum_{i = 1}^{\infty}_|\lambda_i| =$$

$$= \int_{x}^{z}_|g'| dx + |z - x|_+_\sum_{i = 1}^{\infty}_|\lambda_i|_\geq_|t -_y - \sum_{i_=_1}^{\infty} \lambda_i|_+_|z - x| + \sum_{i =_1}^{\infty}_|\lambda_i| \geq |z - x| + |t_- y|,$$

where the inequality_becomes_equality iff $g$ is_monotone (remember we assumed it_to be $C^1$) and all the_vertical intervals_are orientated_in the same direction as $g'$. Thus there are multiple functions_minimizing this integral. We have proved_that in a class_containing all_smooth_functions the problem_of_minimizing perimeter_of a set $E_t$ doesn’t have a_unique solution.

5\._Let us