 parameter in the $d_{\rm xy}$-wave state which is stabilized when ${J_{{\rm H}}}$ is very small, ${J_{{\rm H}}}=U/12$. The $d_{\rm xy} \pm {\rm i}d_{\rm x^{2}-y^{2}}$ state is expected below [$T_{\rm c}$ ]{}and both [$a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi surface ]{}and [$e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface ]{}are node-less in this case. The exponential behaviors in many quantities are expected unless some accidental situation occurs as in the $p$-wave state. Our calculation does not support such an accidental situation in the $d$-wave symmetry.

It should be noticed that in all of the above cases we have shown, the amplitude of order parameter is large on the [$e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface]{}, while it is small on the [$a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi surface]{}. This result is expected from the fact that the [$e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface ]{}is responsible for the pairing instability as discussed in §3.3. This point will be illuminated more clearly in the next section.

Reduced Models
==============

We have analyzed the possibility of unconventional superconductivity in [${\rm Na_{x}Co_{}O_{2}} \cdot y{\rm H}_{2}{\rm O}$ ]{}on the basis of the three-orbital model. Because calculations for this model need much computational time, a simplified model appropriate for studying the superconductivity is highly desired for a future development in the theoretical field. In this section, we try to find an appropriate model from the comparison to the three-orbital model. We show that the two-orbital model is satisfactory for this purpose, while the single-orbital model is not. The essential origin of the results in §3 will be clarified by these trials.

Failure of single-orbital Hubbard model
---------------------------------------

Thus far, we have stressed some essential roles of the orbital degeneracy. They are illuminated by showing the failure of single-orbital model. Some authors have already studied single-orbital Hubbard models reproducing the LDA Fermi surface. [@rf:nisikawa; @rf:kuroki] In this paper, we try a single-orbital Hubbard model by keeping only the $\gamma$-band, [*i.e,*]{} the highest-energy eigenstates obtained in eq. (\[eq:
parameter in the $ d_{\rm xy}$-wave state which is stabilized when $ { J_{{\rm H}}}$ is very small, $ { J_{{\rm H}}}=U/12$. The $ d_{\rm xy } \pm { \rm i}d_{\rm x^{2}-y^{2}}$ department of state is expect below [ $ T_{\rm c}$ ] { } and both [ $ a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi surface ] { } and [ $ e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface ] { } are node - less in this lawsuit. The exponential behaviors in many quantities are expect unless some accidental position occurs as in the $ p$-wave state of matter. Our calculation does not support such an accidental situation in the $ d$-wave isotropy. 

 It should be noticed that in all of the above cases we have shown, the amplitude of order argument is large on the [ $ e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface ] { }, while it is humble on the [ $ a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi surface ] { }. This result is expect from the fact that the [ $ e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface ] { } is responsible for the pairing imbalance as discussed in § 3.3. This point will be light more clearly in the following section. 

 Reduced Models 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 We have analyzed the possibility of unconventional superconductivity in [ $ { \rm Na_{x}Co_{}O_{2 } } \cdot y{\rm H}_{2}{\rm O}$ ] { } on the basis of the three - orbital exemplar. Because calculations for this model need much computational time, a simplified model appropriate for studying the superconductivity is highly desired for a future development in the theoretical field. In this section, we try to find an appropriate model from the comparison to the three - orbital model. We show that the two - orbital model is satisfactory for this purpose, while the individual - orbital model is not. The essential lineage of the result in § 3 will be clarified by these trials. 

 Failure of individual - orbital Hubbard model 
 --------------------------------------- 

 Thus far, we have stressed some essential function of the orbital degeneracy. They are illuminated by showing the failure of single - orbital model. Some generator have already studied single - orbital Hubbard models reproducing the LDA Fermi open.   [ @rf: nisikawa; @rf: kuroki ] In this paper, we try on a single - orbital Hubbard model by keeping only the $ \gamma$-band, [ * i.e, * ] { } the highest - department of energy eigenstates obtained in eq.   (\[eq:
 pagameter in the $d_{\rm xy}$-wavt state which is stabilived wheh ${J_{{\rm H}}}$ ks very small, ${J_{{\rm H}}}=U/12$. The $d_{\rm xt} \pm {\em i}d_{\rm x^{2}-y^{2}}$ state is exoected bepow [$T_{\rm x}$ ]{}anv both [$a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermm surfacc ]{}and [$c_{\rm g}$-Yecmi surface ]{}are node-less hn this case. Tve erponential behaviors in many quantityes are edpected unless somt ascidsntal situation occurs as in the $p$-save stete. Our calculayion does not support such an wccidental situatiln in the $d$-qave wymmetry.

It sfould be noticed that jn all of the above cases we haxe shpwn, the amkljtkge of order paraieter is larnv on tha [$e_{\rm g}$-Germi surface]{}, ehine ut is small on the [$a_{\rk 1g}$-Fermi surface]{}. Tris resuld ns expected from the daxt thdt tve [$e_{\fn g}$-Werji shrface ]{}is responsibme for the pairing instability af discussed in §3.3. This pjint will be illuminated more clearly it tge next section.

Reduced Nodels
==============

We have analyzef the posfibility of unconventional superconductivity in [${\rk Na_{x}Ro_{}U_{2}} \cbit y{\ro H}_{2}{\gm O}$ ]{}on the basis of the three-orbital model. Bqdaisv calculations fov this model need kufh somputational time, c sjmplified model aporopriaje for studying the superconductivity is highlt desired fog a duture development in the theuretocal gield. In this section, wz try fo find an wppropriafd model from the cokpdrison to the three-orbital model. We shoc that tfe teo-orbieal model ls sabhsfactory for this purplsa, while thf single-orbital model is not. Thx essential otighn mf the rzsults in §3 will be slarified by tkese tricls.

Faiuure of sihgle-orbmtal Hubbard model
---------------------------------------

Thus fas, we have strxssed somq eswentual roldr of the orbitsl degenegaey. They aee illuminated by xhodjng the failure of single-orbital koddl. Fole atdhors have anreaay ryudiea singlt-jrnitxl Hibbard models reprodgcinf the LDA Fermi sutfwce. [@rf:nisukawa; @rf:huroki] In thix paper, we try a slngle-mrbmtal Hibbwrd model by keeping only the $\famma$-band, [*i.e,*]{} the highest-qnerny eygenstates obtained in eq. (\[eq:
parameter in the $d_{\rm xy}$-wave state which when H}}}$ is small, ${J_{{\rm H}}}=U/12$. i}d_{\rm state is expected [$T_{\rm c}$ ]{}and [$a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi surface ]{}and [$e_{\rm g}$-Fermi ]{}are node-less in this case. The exponential behaviors in many quantities are expected some accidental situation occurs as in the $p$-wave state. Our calculation does not such accidental in $d$-wave symmetry. It should be noticed that in all of the above cases we have shown, amplitude of order parameter is large on the g}$-Fermi surface]{}, while it small on the [$a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi This is expected the that [$e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface responsible for the pairing instability as discussed in §3.3. This point will be illuminated more clearly in next section. ============== We analyzed possibility unconventional superconductivity in \cdot y{\rm H}_{2}{\rm O}$ ]{}on the three-orbital model. Because calculations for this model need computational time, simplified model appropriate for studying the is highly desired for a future development in theoretical field. In this section, we try to find an appropriate model from the comparison three-orbital model. We show the two-orbital model satisfactory this while single-orbital model not. The essential origin of the results in §3 will be by these trials. Failure of single-orbital Hubbard model --------------------------------------- Thus have some essential roles the orbital degeneracy. They illuminated showing the failure of Some have Hubbard reproducing LDA Fermi surface. [@rf:nisikawa; In this paper, we try single-orbital Hubbard model by the highest-energy eigenstates obtained in eq. (\[eq:
 parameter in the $d_{\rm xy}$-wave stAte which is StabiLizEd wHeN ${J_{{\rm h}}}$ is vEry small, ${J_{{\rm H}}}=U/12$. THE $d_{\rm Xy} \pm {\rm i}d_{\rm x^{2}-y^{2}}$ state is expEcted BeLOw [$T_{\rM C}$ ]{}aNd botH [$a_{\rm 1g}$-FeRMi SURfaCe ]{}AnD [$e_{\rM g}$-fErMi surFacE ]{}are nodE-less in thiS caSe. the exponentiAL bEhaviors in ManY quantities aRe eXpecteD uNleSS some AccIdentAl situATion ocCurs as in tHe $P$-Wave stATe. Our caLCUlAtioN does not support suCH aN Accidental situAtion iN tHE $d$-WAVe sYmmEtry.

It shouLd Be notICed that IN aLL OF thE Above cases we hAve shown, the AMplItude oF oRdeR ParameTer is LaRGe oN the [$e_{\rm g}$-FerMi suRface]{}, whilE it is sMAll on thE [$A_{\rm 1g}$-FerMi surfAce]{}. thiS resULt Is ExpEcTEd fROm The FAct That the [$e_{\Rm G}$-FErmi sUrfaCE ]{}IS RespOnsIble For thE pairing instaBilIty aS DisCusseD in §3.3. ThIs poInT will Be illuMinatEd More clearly in thE nexT section.

REduCeD MoDeLs
==============

We hAVe analYzeD thE possibIlity of UNcoNvENTIoNal superconductiviTy IN [${\Rm na_{x}Co_{}O_{2}} \cdOt y{\rm H}_{2}{\RM O}$ ]{}On THe basis oF tHe tHree-ORBital ModeL. beCause calCulatiONs FoR this moDeL need mUcH coMpuTatioNAl tiMe, a simPlified mOdel aPPropriate for stUDying the superCOnDUCtIVity Is hIghly desireD for A FutuRe deVElOpmENt in tHe theOrETiCAl field. In this sectioN, wE try to Find aN appropriate mOdel from thE COMparison To thE ThREe-orbital model. we shoW that the twO-Orbital mOdel iS satisfaCtory for tHIS purpose, WhiLe tHe sIngLE-OrBital model is nOT. the eSsEntial oRigIn of the ResUltS in §3 WilL bE clarifieD by these TrIaLs.

faIluRe of sINgle-orbiTaL HuBbArd Model
---------------------------------------

tHus far, We havE strEsSeD SomE essentIAl ROLes oF tHe OrbiTal DeGenerAcy. THEy aRe illumInated by sHowINg thE fAiLure of sIngle-orbital mOdEl. Some authOrS haVe alreADY studied Single-orbital Hubbard modELs reproDucIng thE LDA fermi surfAce. [@Rf:nisiKawA; @Rf:kuroKi] In thIs papEr, We tRY A singLE-OrBitAl hubbard modEL By kEepinG oNly tHe $\gamma$-Band, [*i.e,*]{} the highest-enERgy Eigenstates obTaiNed iN EQ. (\[eQ:
 parameter in the $d_{\rmxy}$-wavestate  wh ich  i s st abil ized when ${J_ { {\rm  H}}}$ is very small,${J_{ {\ r m H} } }= U/12$ . The $ d _{ \ r m x y}  \ pm{\ r mi}d_{ \rm  x^{2}- y^{2}}$ st ate  i s expected b e lo w [$T_{\rm  c} $ ]{}and bot h [ $a_{\r m1g} $ -Ferm i s urfac e ]{}a n d [$e_ {\rm g}$- Fe r mi sur f ace ]{} a r enode -less in this cas e .T he exponential  behav io r si n  ma nyquantities  a re ex p ected u n le s s som e  accidental s ituation oc c urs  as in  t he$ p$-wav e sta te .  Ou r calculati on d oes not s upport such an acciden tal si tua tio n in th e$d$ -w a ves ym met r y.
It shou ld  b e not iced t h a t in  al l of  theabove cases w e h aves how n, th e amp litu de  of o rder p arame te r is large on t he [ $e_{\rm g }$- Fe rmi  s urfac e ]{}, w hil e i t is sm all ont he[$ a _ { \r m 1g}$-Fermi surfa ce ] { }.  This re sult i s  e xp e cted fro mthe  fac t thatthe[ $e _{\rm g} $-Ferm i  s ur face ]{ }i s resp on sib lefor t h e pa iringinstabil ity a s  discussed in§ 3.3. This poi n tw i ll be i llu minated mor e cl e arly  int he  ne x t sec tion. 
R ed u ced Models
======== == ====
We ha ve analyzed t he possibi l i t y of unc onve n ti o nal supercondu ctivi ty in [${\ r m Na_{x} Co_{} O_{2}} \ cdot y{\r m H}_{2}{\ rmO}$  ]{ }on t he  basis of the t hree -o rbitalmod el. Bec aus e c alc ula ti ons for t his mode lne ed  m uch  comp u tational  t ime ,a s impli f ied mo del a ppro pr ia t e f or stud y in g thesu pe rcon duc ti vityis h i ghl y desir ed for afut u re d ev el opmentin the theore ti cal field.  I n t his se c t ion, wetry to find an appropri a te mode l f rom t he c omparison  to  the t hre e -orbit al mod el. W esho w thatt h etwo -o rbital mod e l  is  sati sf acto ry forthis purpose, whil e  th e single-orbi tal  mod e l  i s n o t. The  e s sen t i al origin of th e resultsin §3  will be c l ari fi ed by t hese tr ials. 
Failur e of sing le-orbita lHubb a r d m odel
----- -------- --------- - ----- - -- ----- --- 

Thus  f ar,  we h ave st r ess ed so me ess en tial r olesof  the orb ital degeneracy. They a re ill umina ted  by showi ngt hefailure o f si ngle-orbit almod el. S ome autho rs h a ve  al r eadystud i ed single - or bit a l  H ubbard mode l s rep roduc ing the LD A Fe rmi surface. [@rf : nisikawa; @rf: kuro k i ] I n t h is p ap er, we try a s ing le - o rbital H ub bard modelby keepi ng onlythe $\ gamma$ -band,[ * i. e ,*]{}thehig hest-ener gyei g enstate sob t ainedin e q.  (\[eq :
 parameter_in the_$d_{\rm xy}$-wave state which_is stabilized_when_${J_{{\rm H}}}$_is_very small, ${J_{{\rm_H}}}=U/12$. The $d_{\rm_xy} \pm {\rm i}d_{\rm_x^{2}-y^{2}}$ state is_expected_below [$T_{\rm c}$ ]{}and both [$a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi surface ]{}and [$e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface ]{}are node-less_in_this case._The_exponential_behaviors in many quantities are_expected unless some accidental situation_occurs as_in the $p$-wave state. Our calculation does not_support_such an accidental_situation in the $d$-wave symmetry.

It should be noticed that_in all of the above cases_we have shown,_the_amplitude_of order parameter is_large on the [$e_{\rm g}$-Fermi surface]{},_while it is small on the_[$a_{\rm 1g}$-Fermi surface]{}. This result is expected_from the fact that the [$e_{\rm_g}$-Fermi surface ]{}is responsible for_the pairing_instability as discussed in §3.3._This point will_be illuminated_more clearly in_the next section.

Reduced Models
==============

We have analyzed_the possibility of_unconventional superconductivity in [${\rm Na_{x}Co_{}O_{2}} \cdot_y{\rm_H}_{2}{\rm O}$ ]{}on_the_basis_of the_three-orbital model. Because_calculations_for this_model_need much computational time, a simplified_model_appropriate for studying the superconductivity is highly_desired for a future_development_in the theoretical field._In this section, we try_to find an appropriate model from_the comparison_to the_three-orbital model. We show that the two-orbital model is satisfactory for_this purpose, while the single-orbital model_is not. The essential_origin of_the_results in §3_will_be clarified_by these trials.

Failure of single-orbital Hubbard model
---------------------------------------

Thus_far, we_have stressed some essential roles of_the orbital degeneracy. They_are_illuminated by showing the failure of_single-orbital model. Some authors have already_studied single-orbital Hubbard models reproducing_the_LDA_Fermi surface. [@rf:nisikawa; @rf:kuroki] In this_paper, we try a single-orbital Hubbard_model by keeping_only the $\gamma$-band, [*i.e,*]{} the highest-energy eigenstates_obtained_in eq. (\[eq: