; @Mahajan:2009pj; @Branz:2009yt; @Zhang:2009vs; @Albuquerque:2009ak; @Ding:2009vd]. Each sub-system in the molecule could decay into $DK$ pair, but it is not kinematically allowed ([*i.e.*]{} $DK$ mass is above $D^{*}_s$), thus the $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule has narrow natural width. To further test the molecular hypothesis of $Y(4140)$, the experimental measurement of the photon spectrum of $Y(4140)\rightarrow {D}_s^{\ast+} D_s^- \gamma, D_{s}^+D_{s}^{*-}\gamma$ are suggested. The $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule seems a viable interpretation of $Y(4140)$, but no concrete conclusion can be made. Furthermore, the two-photon partial width measured by Belle experiment [@belleevidence] disfavor the interpretation of $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule with $J^{PC}$= $0^{++}$ or $2^{++}$ for $Y(4140)$. [**${\bf c\bar{c}q\bar{q}}$ tetra-quark state**]{}: The $J/\psi\phi$ decay channel of $Y(4140)$ contains $c\bar{c}$ and $s\bar{s}$ components, thus it was also considered as a $c\bar{c}s\bar{s}$ tetra-quark state without sub-systems inside through rearrangement of the constitute quarks with a width of about 100 MeV, and about equal probabilities for both hidden and open-charm two-body decays [@Stancu:2009ka]. The observed width does not seems support this proposal. [**Charmonium hybrid state**]{}: Since the $Y(4140)$ mass is in the range of 4.1-4.4 GeV as predicted by various models for charmonium hybrid states, it is also considered as a charmonium hybrid candidate [@Mahajan:2009pj]. The width of a hybrid is expected to be broad, however if it has exotic $J^{PC}$ of $1^{-+}$ and its mass lies below the threshold of $D^{**}D$, then its width can be narrow [@hybridselection]. This model predicts $D^*\bar{D}$ an an
; @Mahajan:2009pj; @Branz:2009yt; @Zhang:2009vs; @Albuquerque:2009ak; @Ding:2009vd ]. Each sub - system in the molecule could decay into $ DK$ couple, but it is not kinematically give up ([ * i.e. * ] { } $ DK$ mass is above $ D^{*}_s$), therefore the $ D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule have narrow lifelike width. To further test the molecular hypothesis of $ Y(4140)$, the experimental measurement of the photon spectrum of $ Y(4140)\rightarrow { D}_s^{\ast+ } D_s^- \gamma, D_{s}^+D_{s}^{*-}\gamma$ are propose. The $ D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule seems a feasible interpretation of $ Y(4140)$, but no concrete conclusion can be made. Furthermore, the two - photon partial width measure by Belle experiment   [ @belleevidence ] disfavor the interpretation of $ D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule with $ J^{PC}$= $ 0^{++}$ or $ 2^{++}$ for $ Y(4140)$. [ * * $ { \bf c\bar{c}q\bar{q}}$ tetra - quark state * * ] { }: The $ J/\psi\phi$ decay channel of $ Y(4140)$ incorporate $ c\bar{c}$ and $ s\bar{s}$ components, thus it was also consider as a $ c\bar{c}s\bar{s}$ tetra - quark state without sub - systems inside through rearrangement of the constitute quark with a width of about 100 MeV, and about equal probabilities for both hidden and open - appeal two - body decays   [ @Stancu:2009ka ]. The observed width does not seems support this proposal. [ * * Charmonium hybrid state * * ] { }: Since the $ Y(4140)$ mass is in the range of 4.1 - 4.4 GeV as predicted by various models for charmonium hybrid states, it is also considered as a charmonium hybrid candidate   [ @Mahajan:2009pj ]. The width of a hybrid is expect to be broad, however if it has alien $ J^{PC}$ of $ 1^{-+}$ and its bulk dwell below the threshold of $ D^{**}D$, then its width can be narrow   [ @hybridselection ]. This model predicts $ D^*\bar{D}$ an an
; @Majajan:2009pj; @Branz:2009yt; @Zhang:2009vs; @Xlbuquerque:2009ak; @Dnbg:2009vd]. Eech sub-aystem iv the molecule could decay iito $EK$ paur, but it is not kinemxtically wllowed ([*u.e.*]{} $DJ$ mass is aukve $D^{*}_s$), bkus tgc $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_v$ molecule has karrow natusal width. To fgrghzr test the molecular hypothesis of $R(4140)$, the ecpfrimental measorememe of nht photon spectrum of $Y(4140)\rightarrow {S}_s^{\ast+} D_v^- \gamma, D_{s}^+D_{s}^{*-}\gsmma$ are suggested. The $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_d$ mopecule seems a viahle interprgfatyin of $Y(4140)$, but vo concrett eonclusion dan be made. Furthermore, the two-ohotou partial wudrh lgasured by Bxlle eqperiment [@bellcvvidenca] disfafor the interpvetatmon if $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule with $J^{PC}$= $0^{++}$ or $2^{++}$ for $Y(4140)$. [**${\bf c\bar{c}q\bas{q}}$ tetra-quark state**]{}: Tye $J/\pvi\phh$ dezqy zhahnxl kf $Y(4140)$ clnteins $c\bar{c}$ znd $s\bar{s}$ cimponents, thus it wss qlso considersd as w $s\bar{c}s\bar{s}$ tetra-quark state without sub-vysfems inside through reaerangement of the condtitute qtarks with a width of about 100 MeV, and about equal [robauiuitncf dog both hidden and open-charm two-body decays [@Stagdu:2009la]. The observed cidth does not srels fupport this kroposal. [**Cgarmonium hybrid shate**]{}: Sigce tye $Y(4140)$ mass is on the range of 4.1-4.4 GeV as preeicted by vagiouw models for charmlnium hybrib statgs, it os also considered as a chadmonium hybgid candisxte [@Mahajan:2009pj]. The wictv of a hybrid is expected eo be broed, hocever if it nas exjtic $J^{PC}$ ov $1^{-+}$ and its mass lies bellw thg threvhold of $D^{**}F$, then its width can be narrow [@hburidselection]. Tvis model pxedictx $D^*\bar{D}$ an an
; @Mahajan:2009pj; @Branz:2009yt; @Zhang:2009vs; @Albuquerque:2009ak; @Ding:2009vd]. Each the could decay $DK$ pair, but ([*i.e.*]{} mass is above thus the $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ has narrow natural width. To further the molecular hypothesis of $Y(4140)$, the experimental measurement of the photon spectrum of {D}_s^{\ast+} D_s^- \gamma, D_{s}^+D_{s}^{*-}\gamma$ are suggested. The $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule seems a viable interpretation $Y(4140)$, no conclusion be made. Furthermore, the two-photon partial width measured by Belle experiment [@belleevidence] disfavor the interpretation of molecule with $J^{PC}$= $0^{++}$ or $2^{++}$ for $Y(4140)$. c\bar{c}q\bar{q}}$ tetra-quark state**]{}: The decay channel of $Y(4140)$ contains and components, thus was considered a $c\bar{c}s\bar{s}$ tetra-quark without sub-systems inside through rearrangement of the constitute quarks with a width of about 100 MeV, and equal probabilities hidden and two-body [@Stancu:2009ka]. observed width does support this proposal. [**Charmonium hybrid state**]{}: mass is in the range of 4.1-4.4 GeV predicted by models for charmonium hybrid states, it also considered as a charmonium hybrid candidate [@Mahajan:2009pj]. width of a hybrid is expected to be broad, however if it has exotic $J^{PC}$ and its mass lies the threshold of then width be [@hybridselection]. This predicts $D^*\bar{D}$ an an
; @Mahajan:2009pj; @Branz:2009yt; @Zhang:2009vs; @AlBuquerque:2009aK; @Ding:2009Vd]. EAch SuB-sysTem iN the molecule coULd deCay into $DK$ pair, but it is noT kineMaTIcalLY aLloweD ([*i.e.*]{} $DK$ maSS iS ABovE $D^{*}_S$), tHus ThE $d^{*+}_sd^{*-}_s$ molEcuLe has naRrow naturaL wiDtH. To further teST tHe moleculaR hyPothesis of $Y(4140)$, tHe eXperimEnTal MEasurEmeNt of tHe photON spectRum of $Y(4140)\rigHtARrow {D}_s^{\ASt+} D_s^- \gamMA, d_{s}^+d_{s}^{*-}\gaMma$ are suggested. ThE $d^{*+}_sd^{*-}_S$ molecule seems A viablE iNTeRPRetAtiOn of $Y(4140)$, but no CoNcretE ConclusIOn CAN Be mADe. Furthermore, The two-photoN ParTial wiDtH meASured bY BellE eXPerIment [@belleeVideNce] disfavOr the iNTerpretATion of $D^{*+}_SD^{*-}_s$ molEcuLe wIth $J^{pc}$= $0^{++}$ oR $2^{++}$ fOr $Y(4140)$. [**${\Bf C\Bar{C}Q\bAr{q}}$ TEtrA-quark stAtE**]{}: THe $J/\psI\phi$ DECAY chaNneL of $Y(4140)$ ContaIns $c\bar{c}$ and $s\bAr{s}$ CompONenTs, thuS it waS alsO cOnsidEred as A $c\bar{C}s\Bar{s}$ tetra-quark sTate Without suB-syStEms InSide tHRough rEarRanGement oF the conSTitUtE QUArKs with a width of abouT 100 MEv, AnD about eqUal proBAbIlITies for bOtH hiDden AND open-CharM TwO-body decAys [@StaNCu:2009Ka]. the obseRvEd widtH dOes Not Seems SUppoRt this Proposal. [**charmONium hybrid statE**]{}: since the $Y(4140)$ mass IS iN THe RAnge Of 4.1-4.4 GEV as predictEd by VArioUs moDElS foR CharmOnium HyBRiD States, it is also consiDeRed as a CharmOnium hybrid caNdidate [@MahAJAN:2009pj]. The wiDth oF A hYBrid is expected To be bRoad, howeveR If it has eXotic $j^{PC}$ of $1^{-+}$ and Its mass liES Below the ThrEshOld Of $D^{**}d$, THeN its width can bE NArroW [@hYbridseLecTion]. ThiS moDel PreDicTs $d^*\bar{D}$ an an
; @Mahajan:2009pj; @Branz: 2009yt; @Z hang: 200 9vs ;@Alb uque rque:2009ak; @ D ing: 2009vd]. Each sub-syst em in  t h e mo l ec ule c ould de c ay i nto  $ DK $ p ai r ,but i t i s not k inematical lyal lowed ([*i.e . *] {} $DK$ ma ssis above $D^ {*} _s$),th ust he $D ^{* +}_sD ^{*-}_ s $ mole cule hasna r row na t ural wi d t h.  Tofurther test them ol e cular hypothes is of$Y ( 41 4 0 )$,  th e experime nt al me a suremen t  o f t hep hoton spectru m of $Y(414 0 )\r ightar ro w { D }_s^{\ ast+}  D _ s^-  \gamma, D_ {s}^ +D_{s}^{* -}\gam m a$ ares uggeste d. The  $D ^{* +}_s D ^{ *- }_s $m ole c ul e s e ems  a viabl ein terpr etat i o n of $ Y(4 140) $, bu t no concrete  co nclu s ion  canbe ma de.Fu rther more,the t wo -photon partial  wid th measur edby  Be ll e exp e riment  [@ bel leevide nce] di s fav or t h einterpretation of$D ^ { *+ }_sD^{*- }_s$ m o le cu l e with $ J^ {PC }$=$ 0 ^{++} $ or $2 ^{++}$ f or $Y( 4 14 0) $. [**$ {\ bf c\b ar {c} q\b ar{q} } $ te tra-qu ark stat e**]{ } : The $J/\psi\ p hi$ decay cha n ne l of $Y(4 140 )$ contains  $c\ b ar{c }$ a n d$s\ b ar{s} $ com po n en t s, thus it was also  c onside red a s a $c\bar{c} s\bar{s}$t e t ra-quark  sta t ew ithout sub-sys temsinside thr o ugh rear range ment ofthe const i t ute quar kswit h a  wi d t hof about 100M e V, a nd  aboutequ al prob abi lit ies  fo rboth hidd en and o pe n- ch ar m t wo-bo d y decays  [ @St an cu: 2009k a ]. The  obse rved  w id t h d oes not se e m s su pp or t th ispr oposa l. [ * *Ch armoniu m hybridsta t e**] {} :Since t he $Y(4140)$ma ss is in t he  ra nge of 4 .1-4.4 G eV as predicted by vari o us mode lsfor c harm onium hyb rid  state s,i t is a lso co nside re d a s a cha r m on ium  h ybrid cand i d ate  [@Ma ha jan: 2009pj] . The width of a h y bri d is expected  to  beb r oa d,h ow e ver  i f  it h as exotic $J^{P C}$ of $1^ {- + }$  and its m a ssli es belo w the t hresh o ld of $ D^{**}D$,  then its  w idth c anbe narrow[@hybrid selection ] . Thi s  m odelpre dicts$D ^*\ bar{D }$ ana n
; @Mahajan:2009pj;_@Branz:2009yt; @Zhang:2009vs;_@Albuquerque:2009ak; @Ding:2009vd]. Each sub-system_in the_molecule_could decay_into_$DK$ pair, but_it is not_kinematically allowed ([*i.e.*]{} $DK$_mass is above_$D^{*}_s$),_thus the $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule has narrow natural width. To further test the molecular hypothesis_of_$Y(4140)$, the_experimental_measurement_of the photon spectrum of_$Y(4140)\rightarrow {D}_s^{\ast+} D_s^- \gamma, D_{s}^+D_{s}^{*-}\gamma$_are suggested._The $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$ molecule seems a viable interpretation of_$Y(4140)$,_but no concrete_conclusion can be made. Furthermore, the two-photon partial width_measured by Belle experiment [@belleevidence] disfavor the_interpretation of $D^{*+}_sD^{*-}_s$_molecule_with_$J^{PC}$= $0^{++}$ or $2^{++}$_for $Y(4140)$. [**${\bf c\bar{c}q\bar{q}}$ tetra-quark state**]{}:_The $J/\psi\phi$ decay channel of $Y(4140)$_contains $c\bar{c}$ and $s\bar{s}$ components, thus it_was also considered as a $c\bar{c}s\bar{s}$_tetra-quark state without sub-systems inside_through rearrangement_of the constitute quarks with_a width of_about 100_MeV, and about_equal probabilities for both hidden and_open-charm two-body decays [@Stancu:2009ka]._The observed width does not seems_support_this proposal. [**Charmonium_hybrid_state**]{}:_Since the_$Y(4140)$ mass is_in_the range_of_4.1-4.4 GeV as predicted by various_models_for charmonium hybrid states, it is also_considered as a charmonium_hybrid_candidate [@Mahajan:2009pj]. The width of_a hybrid is expected to_be broad, however if it has_exotic $J^{PC}$_of $1^{-+}$_and its mass lies below the threshold of $D^{**}D$, then its_width can be narrow [@hybridselection]. This model_predicts $D^*\bar{D}$ an an