In [@N-Z Problem 5.1] it was asked whether the combinatorial $(2k-1)$-spheres $\Delta^{2k-1}_n$ are shellable for all $k\geq 2$ and $n\geq2k$. Here we answer this question in the $3$-dimensional case: we verify that the spheres $\Delta^3_n$ are shellable, by showing that they possess a symmetric shelling. A shelling order of a cs simplicial complex is called [*symmetric*]{} if it is the form $(F_1, F_2,\dots, F_m, -F_m, -F_{m-1},\dots,-F_1)$.

\[thm:shellable\] Let $n\geq 4$. There exists a symmetric shelling order of $\Delta^{3}_n$.

Our strategy is as follows: use equation (\[eq:decomposition\]) to separate one half of the facets of $\Delta^{3}_n$ in the $n-2$ blocks described below; list these blocks in the shelling we are about to construct in the following order:

-   The facets of $B^{3,1}_{n}$.

-   The facets of $\partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that are not in $\pm B^{3,1}_{k}$. Here $5\leq k\leq n$. These $n-4$ blocks will be listed in the decreasing order of $k$, i.e., from $k=n$ to $k=5$;

-   Three of the six facets of $\Delta^{3}_4\backslash\pm B^{3,1}_4$ (which three will be specified later).

We will now discuss the order inside each of these blocks. Then we will list the other half of the facets to make the ordering symmetric.

The ball $B^{3,1}_n$ is a stacked ball, hence shellable. We list its facets in any shelling order of $B^{3,1}_n$. Now, for $k=n, n-1, \dots, 5$, the facets of $\partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that are not in $\pm B^{3,1}_{k}$ are described in Lemma \[lm: facets\]: they consist of $$F_{k,1}:=(-k+3)(-
In [ @N - Z Problem 5.1 ] it was asked whether the combinatorial $ (2k-1)$-spheres $ \Delta^{2k-1}_n$ are shellable for all $ k\geq 2 $ and $ n\geq2k$. Here we answer this question in the $ 3$-dimensional case: we control that the sphere $ \Delta^3_n$ are shellable, by showing that they possess a symmetric barrage. A shelling order of a cs simplicial complex is call [ * symmetric * ] { } if it is the form $ (F_1, F_2,\dots, F_m, -F_m, -F_{m-1},\dots,-F_1)$. 

 \[thm: shellable\ ] permit $ n\geq 4$. There exists a symmetric shell order of $ \Delta^{3}_n$. 

 Our strategy is as follow: use equation (\[eq: decomposition\ ]) to separate one half of the facets of $ \Delta^{3}_n$ in the $ n-2 $ blocks describe below; list these blocks in the barrage we are about to construct in the following order: 

 -    The aspect of $ B^{3,1}_{n}$. 

 -    The facets of $ \partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that are not in $ \pm B^{3,1}_{k}$. Here $ 5\leq k\leq n$. These $ n-4 $ block will be listed in the decreasing order of $ k$, i.e., from $ k = n$ to $ k=5 $; 

 -    Three of the six facets of $ \Delta^{3}_4\backslash\pm B^{3,1}_4 $ (which three will be assign later). 

 We will now discuss the order inside each of these blocks. Then we will list the other half of the facets to make the ordering symmetric. 

 The ball $ B^{3,1}_n$ is a stacked ball, hence shellable. We list its facets in any blast order of $ B^{3,1}_n$. Now, for $ thousand = n, n-1, \dots, 5 $, the facet of $ \partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that are not in $ \pm B^{3,1}_{k}$ are described in Lemma   \[lm: facets\ ]: they consist of $ $ F_{k,1}:=(-k+3)(-
In [@J-Z Problem 5.1] it was asked whether the combinatocial $(2k-1)$-slheres $\Ddlta^{2k-1}_n$ are shellable for all $k\teq 2$ qnd $n\geq2k$. Here we answdr this qlestion ib tht $3$-dimensional casx: we verlyy thzb the wpheres $\Delta^3_n$ are shelldble, by showinc ghct they possess a symmetric shelling. A shelkijg order of a ss spm[licjal complex is called [*symmetric*]{} if it is uhe form $(F_1, F_2,\dots, F_k, -F_m, -F_{m-1},\dots,-F_1)$.

\[thm:shellable\] Lft $n\heq 4$. There exists w symmetric shejoing order ow $\Delta^{3}_n$.

Oug strategy js as follows: use equation (\[eq:dezompoxition\]) to weparwje one half if thv facets of $\Dckta^{3}_n$ it the $n-2$ blocks descrined bxlow; list these blocks in the shelling we ate about tm eonstruct in the folliwung otder:

-   Thd fazeta pf $B^{3,1}_{n}$.

-   Hhe facets of $\partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*j$ that are not in $\pk F^{3,1}_{j}$. Here $5\leq k\lsq n$. Trefe $n-4$ blocks will be listed in the decredsihg order of $k$, i.e., from $k=b$ to $k=5$;

-   Three of the six facees of $\Delta^{3}_4\backslash\pm B^{3,1}_4$ (which three will be spechfied uattr).

Qe wiuo jow discuss the order inside each of these bljdkx. Nhen we will list the other napf jf the facets to make fhe ordering symmehric.

The ball $B^{3,1}_n$ is a ftacled ball, hence shellable. We list its fabets in any shelling oxder of $B^{3,1}_n$. Nuw, fpr $k=n, n-1, \dots, 5$, the facets of $\'artiam B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that wre not ih $\pm B^{3,1}_{k}$ are descrkbec hn Lemma \[lm: facets\]: they confist of $$F_{j,1}:=(-k+3)(-
In [@N-Z Problem 5.1] it was asked combinatorial $\Delta^{2k-1}_n$ are for all $k\geq answer question in the case: we verify the spheres $\Delta^3_n$ are shellable, by that they possess a symmetric shelling. A shelling order of a cs simplicial is called [*symmetric*]{} if it is the form $(F_1, F_2,\dots, F_m, -F_m, -F_{m-1},\dots,-F_1)$. Let 4$. exists symmetric shelling order of $\Delta^{3}_n$. Our strategy is as follows: use equation (\[eq:decomposition\]) to separate one of the facets of $\Delta^{3}_n$ in the $n-2$ described below; list these in the shelling we are to in the order: The of $B^{3,1}_{n}$. - facets of $\partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that are not in $\pm B^{3,1}_{k}$. Here $5\leq k\leq n$. These $n-4$ blocks be listed decreasing order $k$, from to $k=5$; - the six facets of $\Delta^{3}_4\backslash\pm B^{3,1}_4$ be specified later). We will now discuss the inside each these blocks. Then we will list other half of the facets to make the symmetric. The ball $B^{3,1}_n$ is a stacked ball, hence shellable. We list its facets in order of $B^{3,1}_n$. Now, $k=n, n-1, \dots, the of B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ are not $\pm B^{3,1}_{k}$ are described in Lemma \[lm: facets\]: they consist of
In [@N-Z Problem 5.1] it was asked whetHer the combInatoRiaL $(2k-1)$-sPhEres $\deltA^{2k-1}_n$ are shellablE For aLl $k\geq 2$ and $n\geq2k$. Here we anSwer tHiS QuesTIoN in thE $3$-dimensIOnAL CasE: wE vEriFy THaT the sPheRes $\DeltA^3_n$ are shellAblE, bY showing that THeY possess a sYmmEtric shellinG. A sHellinG oRdeR Of a cs SimPliciAl compLEx is caLled [*symmeTrIC*]{} if it iS The form $(f_1, f_2,\DoTs, F_m, -f_m, -F_{m-1},\dots,-F_1)$.

\[thm:shellABlE\] let $n\geq 4$. There exIsts a sYmMEtRIC shEllIng order of $\deLta^{3}_n$.

OUR strateGY iS AS FolLOws: use equatioN (\[eq:decomposITioN\]) to sepArAte ONe half Of the FaCEts Of $\Delta^{3}_n$ in tHe $n-2$ bLocks descRibed bELow; list THese bloCks in tHe sHelLing WE aRe AboUt TO coNStRucT In tHe followInG oRder:

-   THe faCETS Of $B^{3,1}_{n}$.

-   the FaceTs of $\pArtial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that Are Not iN $\Pm B^{3,1}_{K}$. Here $5\Leq k\lEq n$. THeSe $n-4$ blOcks wiLl be lIsTed in the decreasIng oRder of $k$, i.e., FroM $k=N$ to $K=5$;

-   THree oF The six FacEts Of $\Delta^{3}_4\BackslaSH\pm b^{3,1}_4$ (wHICH tHree will be specifieD lATEr).

we will noW discuSS tHe ORder insiDe EacH of tHESe bloCks. THEn We will liSt the oTHeR hAlf of thE fAcets tO mAke The OrderINg syMmetriC.

The ball $b^{3,1}_n$ is a STacked ball, hencE Shellable. We liST iTS FaCEts iN anY shelling orDer oF $b^{3,1}_n$. NoW, for $K=N, n-1, \DotS, 5$, The faCets oF $\pARtIAl B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that are not in $\pm b^{3,1}_{k}$ Are desCribeD in Lemma \[lm: facEts\]: they conSIST of $$F_{k,1}:=(-k+3)(-
In [@N-Z Problem 5.1] it w as asked w hethe r t heco mbin ator ial $(2k-1)$-s p here s $\Delta^{2k-1}_n$ ar e she ll a blef or  all$k\geq2 $a n d $ n\ ge q2k $. He re we  an swer th is questio n i nthe $3$-dime n si onal case:  we  verify that  th e sphe re s $ \ Delta ^3_ n$ ar e shel l able,by showin gt hat th e y posse s s  a  sym metric shelling.A  s h elling order o f a cs  s i mp l i cia l c omplex isca lled[ *symmet r ic * ] { } i f  it is the fo rm $(F_1, F _ 2,\ dots,F_ m,- F_m, - F_{m- 1} , \do ts,-F_1)$.
\[t hm:shella ble\]L et $n\g e q 4$. T here e xis tsa sy m me tr icsh e lli n gord e r o f $\Delt a^ {3 }_n$. 

Ou r s t rate gyis a s fol lows: use equ ati on ( \ [eq :deco mposi tion \] ) tosepara te on ehalf of the fac etsof $\Delt a^{ 3} _n$  i n the $n-2$blo cks  descri bed bel o w;li s t th ese blocks in thesh e l li ng we ar e abou t  t oc onstruct  i n t he f o l lowin g or d er :

-   T he fac e ts  o f $B^{3 ,1 }_{n}$ .
-  T he fa c etsof $\p artial B ^{3,1 } _{k-1}*k$ that are not in $\ p mB ^ {3 , 1}_{ k}$ . Here $5\l eq k \ leqn$.T he se$ n-4$block sw il l  be listed in the d ec reasin g ord er of $k$, i. e., from $ k = n $ to $k= 5$;- Three of thesix f acets of $ \ Delta^{3 }_4\b ackslash \pm B^{3, 1 } _4$ (whi chthr eewil l be  specified la t e r).
W e willnow  discus s t heord erin side each  of thes ebl oc ks . T hen w e  will li st  th eoth er ha l f of t he fa cets  t om ake  the or d er i n g sy mm et ric. 

T he  ball  $B^ { 3,1 }_n$ is  a stacke d b a ll,he nc e shell able. We list  i ts facetsin  an y shel l i ng order  of $B^{3,1}_n$. Now, f o r $k=n,  n- 1, \d ots,  5$, thefac ets of  $\ p artial  B^{3, 1}_{k -1 }*k $ thata r enot  i n $\pm B^{ 3 , 1}_ {k}$ar e de scribed  in Lemma \[lm: fa c ets \]: they cons ist  of$ $ F_ {k, 1 }: = (-k +3 ) (-
In [@N-Z_Problem 5.1]_it was asked whether_the combinatorial_$(2k-1)$-spheres_$\Delta^{2k-1}_n$ are_shellable_for all $k\geq_2$ and $n\geq2k$._Here we answer this_question in the_$3$-dimensional_case: we verify that the spheres $\Delta^3_n$ are shellable, by showing that they possess_a_symmetric shelling._A_shelling_order of a cs simplicial_complex is called [*symmetric*]{} if_it is_the form $(F_1, F_2,\dots, F_m, -F_m, -F_{m-1},\dots,-F_1)$.

\[thm:shellable\] Let_$n\geq_4$. There exists_a symmetric shelling order of $\Delta^{3}_n$.

Our strategy is as_follows: use equation (\[eq:decomposition\]) to separate_one half of_the_facets_of $\Delta^{3}_n$ in the_$n-2$ blocks described below; list these_blocks in the shelling we are_about to construct in the following order:

-_  The facets of $B^{3,1}_{n}$.

-_  The facets of_$\partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$_that are not in $\pm_B^{3,1}_{k}$. Here $5\leq_k\leq n$._These $n-4$ blocks_will be listed in the decreasing_order of $k$,_i.e., from $k=n$ to $k=5$;

- __Three of the_six_facets_of $\Delta^{3}_4\backslash\pm_B^{3,1}_4$ (which three_will_be specified_later).

We_will now discuss the order inside_each_of these blocks. Then we will list_the other half of_the_facets to make the_ordering symmetric.

The ball $B^{3,1}_n$ is_a stacked ball, hence shellable. We_list its_facets in_any shelling order of $B^{3,1}_n$. Now, for $k=n, n-1, \dots, 5$,_the facets of $\partial B^{3,1}_{k-1}*k$ that_are not in $\pm_B^{3,1}_{k}$ are_described_in Lemma \[lm: facets\]:_they_consist of_$$F_{k,1}:=(-k+3)(-