 cosmic variance term. For example experiments currently being considered for measuring the B-modes of CMB polarization would be cosmic variance limited for E polarization over a wide range of $ls$ (e.g. [@bmodes]). Such an optimal experiment, exploring structures into a multipole range of $l=4000$, represents the limit of how much information on $\lambda$ one could extract from the CMB in principle. We found an expected error for $\lambda$ of order $0.3\%$ which translates into a constraint of the value of the gravitational constant during recombination of $\frac{\delta G}{G} \simeq 0.6 \%$.

Discussion\[discussion\]
========================

We have made the expansion rate of the universe a free parameter in a likelihood analysis within an eight-dimensional cosmological parameter space. For simplicity we assumed that the gravitational constant is changed by a factor $\lambda$. We showed that an increase of $\lambda$ leads to a wider visibility function which in turn increases the damping of anisotropies on small scales and increases the level of large scale polarization.

We calculated the constraints that current CMB data can impose on the expansion rate. The constraints that can be imposed on the parameter $\lambda$ using the information from the damping tail are severely weakened by our lack of knowledge about the shape of the primordial power spectrum. We showed that measuring polarization helps to break this degeneracy. Current data can only constrain $\lambda$ to about 47% at 1 $\sigma$. We showed that MAP could obtain 9% error bars for $\lambda$ while for Planck errorbars go down to 0.9%. We also explored the ultimate limit that could be achieved by a cosmic variance limited experiment measuring anisotropies up to $l=4000$ and found errors of under a percent in that case. Thus next generation experiments should be able to deliver very accurate constraints on the expansion rate of the universe during recombination.

We acknowledge that if the variation of the gravitational constant during recombination is taken seriously a model needs to be built where $G$ changes after recombination and converges towards the stable value observed in laboratory experiments today and where its current rate of change is less than the experimental bound $\frac{\dot{G}}{G}
\simeq 10^{-12} \text{yr}^{-1}$[@Uzan:2002vq; @Guenther:1998]. If we introduce a scalar field to control the value of $G$ we would also have to require that this field does not lead to an unacceptably large fifth force and does not
cosmic variance term. For example experiments presently being view for measuring the boron - mode of CMB polarization would be cosmic variance limited for vitamin e polarization over a wide range of $ ls$ (for example [ @bmodes ]). Such an optimum experiment, exploring structures into a multipole stove of $ l=4000 $, represents the limit of how much information on $ \lambda$ one could press out from the CMB in principle. We found an expected error for $ \lambda$ of order $ 0.3\%$ which translates into a restraint of the value of the gravitational constant during recombination of $ \frac{\delta G}{G } \simeq 0.6 \%$. 

 Discussion\[discussion\ ] 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 We have made the expansion rate of the universe a detached parameter in a likelihood analysis within an eight - dimensional cosmologic parameter outer space. For simplicity we assumed that the gravitational constant is changed by a factor $ \lambda$. We showed that an addition of $ \lambda$ leads to a wider visibility function which in turn increases the damping of anisotropies on belittled scales and increases the level of large scale polarization. 

 We calculated the constraints that current CMB data can impose on the expansion rate. The constraint that can be imposed on the parameter $ \lambda$ use the data from the damping tail are severely weakened by our lack of knowledge about the shape of the primordial power spectrum. We indicate that measuring polarization helps to break this degeneracy. Current data can only stiffen $ \lambda$ to about 47% at 1 $ \sigma$. We showed that MAP could obtain 9% error bar for $ \lambda$ while for Planck errorbars go down to 0.9% . We besides explore the ultimate limit that could be achieved by a cosmic variance limited experiment measure anisotropies up to $ l=4000 $ and found errors of under a percentage in that case. therefore next generation experiments should be able to deliver very accurate constraints on the expansion pace of the universe during recombination. 

 We acknowledge that if the variation of the gravitational constant during recombination is taken seriously a exemplar needs to be build up where $ G$ changes after recombination and converges towards the static value observed in laboratory experiments today and where its current rate of change is less than the experimental tie down $ \frac{\dot{G}}{G } 
 \simeq 10^{-12 } \text{yr}^{-1}$[@Uzan:2002vq; @Guenther:1998 ]. If we introduce a scalar field to control the value of $ G$ we would also have to require that this field does not lead to an unacceptably bombastic fifth force and does not
 codmic variance term. For ewample experimenjs curreitly bejng conskdered for measuring the B-moves if CMV polarization would bd cosmic nariance oimiued for E polarizefion ovcx a wjfe rcnje of $ls$ (e.g. [@bmoces]). Such at optimal expesioeut, exploring structures into a multi[ole ramgf of $l=4000$, represegts uhe limjn if how much information on $\lajbda$ ont could extract frpm the CMB in principle. We foujd an expected errlr for $\lambea$ os order $0.3\%$ whicf translatts into a cohstraint of the value of the grxvitacional consjcbt foring recombmnatiog of $\frac{\delbs G}{G} \shmeq 0.6 \%$.

Doscussion\[discuxsimn\]
========================

Ww have made the expanvion rate of the ugiverse a fxee parameter in a lijeoihoog andlyskw wkthjn ah eighh-dijensional dosmologicao parameter space. Fpr wimplicity we assumqd that the gravitational constant is chatges by a factor $\lambda$. We showed that an increwse of $\laibda$ leads to a wider visibility function which it turi kncxcwrws the damping of anisotropies on small scales whd ikcreases the levcl of large scale lopatyzation.

We calzulateb tge constraints thah curregt CMV data cag imlose on the expansion rate. Rhe constraiuts that can be imposzd on the paxametet $\lambca$ using the informatiou from the dampinh tail ars severely weakendd ny mur lack of knowledge aboue the sha'e of the prkmorcial pjwer spectgum. Wc showed that measuging kolarisation helos to break this degeneracy. Curcxnt data can pnny bonstrain $\lambca$ to about 47% wt 1 $\sigma$. We skowed thct MAP could obtzin 9% ercor bars for $\lambda$ while vor Planck ecrorbars do diwn ro 0.9%. We xuso explored tne ultimane limut that could be aghievgd by a cosmic vaxnabce limited exprrioene leesurigc anisotropias uo tu $l=4000$ ana found errifs og under a percent in thaf case. Thus next grncration ezperimenes should be sble to deliver vegy acrurate consyraynts on the expansion rate of fhe univegse during recoibinqtion.

We acknpwledge that if the variation of the grevitational constant doring recombination ix taken seripusly a model teeds to be built whwre $G$ changes afttr recombination and cohvergev towwrds the stable value observed in laboratory experiments today and where uts cucrqnt rate of chamge iv jzss thag thx xxperimental bounc $\frac{\dot{G}}{G}
\simeq 10^{-12} \text{yr}^{-1}$[@Uzan:2002vq; @Juenther:1998]. Ix ce introduce a scalar field tp zontrol the vxlue of $G$ we would also gave to tequire that this field does noy lead to an unacceptabln large fufth rorce and voes not
cosmic variance term. For example experiments currently for the B-modes CMB polarization would E over a wide of $ls$ (e.g. Such an optimal experiment, exploring structures a multipole range of $l=4000$, represents the limit of how much information on one could extract from the CMB in principle. We found an expected error $\lambda$ order which into a constraint of the value of the gravitational constant during recombination of $\frac{\delta G}{G} \simeq \%$. Discussion\[discussion\] ======================== We have made the expansion of the universe a parameter in a likelihood analysis an cosmological parameter For we that the gravitational is changed by a factor $\lambda$. We showed that an increase of $\lambda$ leads to a wider function which increases the of on scales and increases of large scale polarization. We calculated current CMB data can impose on the expansion The constraints can be imposed on the parameter using the information from the damping tail are weakened by our lack of knowledge about the shape of the primordial power spectrum. We measuring polarization helps to this degeneracy. Current can constrain to 47% at $\sigma$. We showed that MAP could obtain 9% error bars for while for Planck errorbars go down to 0.9%. We also ultimate that could be by a cosmic variance experiment anisotropies up to $l=4000$ errors under that Thus generation experiments should be to deliver very accurate constraints the expansion rate of acknowledge that if the variation of the gravitational during recombination is taken seriously a model to be built where $G$ changes after recombination and converges towards the value observed experiments today and where its current rate of is less than the bound $\frac{\dot{G}}{G} \simeq 10^{-12} \text{yr}^{-1}$[@Uzan:2002vq; @Guenther:1998]. If we introduce scalar to control value of $G$ would also have require that this not lead an large does not
 cosmic variance term. For examPle experimEnts cUrrEntLy BeinG conSidered for measURing The B-modes of CMB polarizaTion wOuLD be cOSmIc varIance liMItED For e pOlAriZaTIoN over A wiDe range Of $ls$ (e.g. [@bmodEs]). SUcH an optimal exPErIment, exploRinG structures iNto A multiPoLe rANge of $L=4000$, rePreseNts the LImit of How much inFoRMation ON $\lambda$ ONE cOuld Extract from the CMB IN pRInciple. We found An expeCtED eRROr fOr $\lAmbda$ of ordEr $0.3\%$ Which TRanslatES iNTO A coNStraint of the vAlue of the grAVitAtionaL cOnsTAnt durIng reCoMBinAtion of $\frac{\DeltA G}{G} \simeq 0.6 \%$.

DIscussIOn\[discuSSion\]
========================

We hAve madE thE exPansIOn RaTe oF tHE unIVeRse A FreE parametEr In A likeLihoOD ANAlysIs wIthiN an eiGht-dimensionaL coSmolOGicAl parAmeteR spaCe. for siMpliciTy we aSsUmed that the gravItatIonal consTanT iS chAnGed by A Factor $\LamBda$. we showeD that an INcrEaSE OF $\lAmbda$ leads to a wider ViSIBiLity funcTion whICh In TUrn increAsEs tHe daMPIng of AnisOTrOpies on sMall scALeS aNd increAsEs the lEvEl oF laRge scALe poLarizaTion.

We caLculaTEd the constrainTS that current Cmb dATA cAN impOse On the expansIon rATe. ThE conSTrAinTS that Can be ImPOsED on the parameter $\lambDa$ Using tHe infOrmation from tHe damping tAIL Are severEly wEAkENed by our lack of KnowlEdge about tHE shape of The prImordial Power specTRUm. We showEd tHat MeaSurING pOlarization heLPS to bReAk this dEgeNeracy. CUrrEnt DatA caN oNly constrAin $\lambdA$ tO aBoUt 47% At 1 $\sIgma$. WE Showed thAt mAP CoUld ObtaiN 9% Error bArs foR $\lamBdA$ wHIle For PlanCK eRROrbaRs Go Down To 0.9%. WE aLso exPlorED thE ultimaTe limit thAt cOUld bE aChIeved by A cosmic varianCe Limited expErImeNt measURIng anisoTropies up to $l=4000$ and found errORs of undEr a PerceNt in That case. THus Next geNerATion exPerimeNts shOuLd bE ABle to DELiVer VeRy accurate CONstRaintS oN the ExpansiOn rate of the universE DurIng recombinatIon.

we acKNOwLedGE tHAt iF tHE vaRIAtion of the graviTational coNsTAnT during recOMbiNaTion is tAken serIouslY A model nEeds to be bUilt where $g$ cHangES AftEr recombinAtion and Converges TOwardS ThE stabLe vAlue obSeRveD in laBoratoRY exPerimEnts toDaY and whEre itS cUrrent raTe of change is less than the ExperiMentaL boUnd $\frac{\doT{G}}{G}
\SImeQ 10^{-12} \text{yr}^{-1}$[@UzAn:2002vq; @guenther:1998]. If We iNtrOduce A scALar fiEld tO CoNtrOL the vAlue OF $G$ we would ALsO haVE To Require that THIS fiEld doEs nOT lead tO an uNacceptably large fIFth force and doeS not
 cosmic variance term. For  example e xperi men tscu rren tlybeing consider e d fo r measuring the B-mode s ofCM B  pol a ri zatio n would be c osm ic  v ari an c elimit edfor E p olarizatio n o ve r a wide ran g eof $ls$ (e .g.  [@bmodes]).  Su ch anop tim a l exp eri ment,  explo r ing st ructuresin t o a mu l tipoler a ng e of  $l=4000$, repres e nt s  the limit ofhow mu ch in f o rma tio n on $\lam bd a$ on e  coulde xt r a c t f r om the CMB in  principle. Wefoundan  ex p ectederror  f o r $ \lambda$ of  ord er $0.3\% $ whic h  transl a tes int o a co nst rai nt o f  t he  va lu e  of th e g r avi tational  c on stant  dur i n g reco mbi nati on of  $\frac{\delt a G }{G} \si meq 0 .6 \% $.
Di scuss ion\[d iscus si on\]
========== ==== ========= =
We  ha ve  made the ex pan sio n rateof theu niv er s e afree parameter inal i ke lihood a nalysi s  w it h in an ei gh t-d imen s i onalcosm o lo gical pa ramete r  s pa ce. For  s implic it y w e a ssume d  tha t thegravitat ional constant is ch a nged by a fac t or $ \l a mbda $.We showed t hata n in crea s eof$ \lamb da$ l ea d st o a wider visibilit yfuncti on wh ich in turn i ncreases t h e dampingof a n is o tropies on sma ll sc ales and i n creasesthe l evel oflarge sca l e  polariz ati on. 

W e c a l cu lated the con s t rain ts  that c urr ent CMB  da tacan  im po se on the  expansi on  r at e.  Th e con s traintsth atca n b e imp o sed on  thepara me te r  $\ lambda$ us i n g th ein form ati on  from  the dam ping ta il are se ver e ly w ea ke ned byour lack of k no wledge abo ut  th e shap e of the p rimordial power spectru m . We sh owe d tha t me asuring p ola rizati onh elps t o brea k thi sdeg e n eracy . Cu rre nt  data cano n lyconst ra in $ \lambda $ to about 47% at1  $\ sigma$. We sh owe d th a t  M APc ou l d o bt a in9 %  error bars for  $\lambda$  w h il e for Plan c k e rr orbarsgo down  to 0 . 9%. Wealso expl ored theul tima t e  li mit that c ould beachievedb y a c o sm ic va ria nce li mi ted  expe riment mea surin g anis ot ropies  up t o$l=4000$  and found errors of un der aperce ntin that c ase .  Th us next g ener ation expe rim ent s sho uld be ab le t o  d eli v er ve ry a c curate co n st rai n t son the expa n s i onrateoft he uni vers e during recombin a tion.

We ackn owle d g e t hat if t he  variation ofthe  g r a vitation al  constant d uring re co m binat ion is  taken  seriou s l ya  model  nee dsto be bui ltwh e re $G$ch an g es aft er r ec ombina tion a n d co n v erges towards th e sta b l e val u e o bserv ed  in lab o rato ry experim ents todayand wh ereits c urrentra te ofcha ng e is lesst han the e xperi mentalbo und$\f rac{\d ot{G } } {G}
\ sime q10^ {-12} \te x t {y r }^ {- 1 }$[ @Uza n:200 2v q; @ Guenther: 1 998]. If  we introdu ce  as c alar f i el d to control  th e val u e  of $G$ we woul d  a l so ha ve torequir e thatt his  f ield do esn o t lead to  an unacc e pta bl y la rge fift hforc eand  d oes not
 cosmic_variance term._For example experiments currently_being considered_for_measuring the_B-modes_of CMB polarization_would be cosmic_variance limited for E_polarization over a_wide_range of $ls$ (e.g. [@bmodes]). Such an optimal experiment, exploring structures into a multipole_range_of $l=4000$,_represents_the_limit of how much information_on $\lambda$ one could extract_from the_CMB in principle. We found an expected error_for_$\lambda$ of order_$0.3\%$ which translates into a constraint of the value_of the gravitational constant during recombination_of $\frac{\delta G}{G}_\simeq_0.6_\%$.

Discussion\[discussion\]
========================

We have made the_expansion rate of the universe a_free parameter in a likelihood analysis_within an eight-dimensional cosmological parameter space. For_simplicity we assumed that the gravitational_constant is changed by a_factor $\lambda$._We showed that an increase_of $\lambda$ leads_to a_wider visibility function_which in turn increases the damping_of anisotropies on_small scales and increases the level_of_large scale polarization.

We_calculated_the_constraints that_current CMB data_can_impose on_the_expansion rate. The constraints that can_be_imposed on the parameter $\lambda$ using the_information from the damping_tail_are severely weakened by_our lack of knowledge about_the shape of the primordial power_spectrum. We_showed that_measuring polarization helps to break this degeneracy. Current data can only_constrain $\lambda$ to about 47% at_1 $\sigma$. We showed_that MAP_could_obtain 9% error_bars_for $\lambda$_while for Planck errorbars go down to_0.9%. We_also explored the ultimate limit that_could be achieved by_a_cosmic variance limited experiment measuring anisotropies_up to $l=4000$ and found errors_of under a percent in_that_case._Thus next generation experiments should_be able to deliver very accurate_constraints on the_expansion rate of the universe during recombination.

We_acknowledge_that if the variation of the_gravitational_constant during recombination is taken seriously_a_model_needs to be built where_$G$ changes after recombination and converges_towards the stable value observed in laboratory experiments today_and where its_current rate of change is_less_than_the experimental bound $\frac{\dot{G}}{G}
\simeq 10^{-12} \text{yr}^{-1}$[@Uzan:2002vq; @Guenther:1998]. If we introduce_a scalar_field to control_the value of $G$ we would also have to require_that this field does not lead to_an unacceptably large fifth force and does not