 and CSG. Variance is reduced using GD, but a signal remains, and both homogeneity and energy are improved through compensation.

We can also consider how effective the compensation is per coupling pattern. We can classify each coupling between logical qubits by the induced subgraph considering only the two chains and the couplings between them. Two such subgraphs are in the same class if they are automorphic. The number of such patterns varies widely according to the graph-minor topology as shown in Table \[table:cct\].

   Topology   Variables,N   Chain length,L   Logical coupling patterns  
  ---------- ------------- ---------------- --------------------------- --
    Clique        32              9                     16              
    Clique        63              17                    50              
   Biclique       64              8                     10              
   3D cubic       64              4                      3              
   3D cubic       512             4                      3              

  : Chain connectivity topologies[]{data-label="table:cct"}

We can take an average over couplers in a given isomorphic class, and classify each class according to $\chi_{ab}(1)$ for some element $ab$ in the class. The result is shown in Fig. \[fig:correlationBalancing\] (top-right). Frustration is indeed disproportionately allocated over couplers that connect through extremal points (large $\chi_{ab}$), we see that applying an appropriate compensation of $1/\chi$ between one and two makes coupler performance more homogeneous.

In Fig. \[fig:correlationBalancing\] (bottom-right) we show the mean energies and best minimal achieved for all instances of the 3DSG problem ($8\times 8 \times 8$) with and without logical-J compensation. We allows for a small number of edge and variable vacancies (in line with defect patterns on the chip). Energies are significantly improved not only in the median but in almost all instances.

Conclusion {#sec:conclusion}
==========

In this paper we have demonstrated that inhomogeneities in the patterns of chain couplings produce biases in the sampling distribution, and that compensation by a simple heuristic can reduce biases and improve optimization performance. Using a simple heuristic scheme based on the assumption that the distribution reflects a freeze-out point in the anneal where chains are rigid (but not fully correlated) allows results to be improved in hard random problems: spin glasses of various topology, and CDMA. The rigidity of the
and CSG. Variance is reduced using GD, but a signal remains, and both homogeneity and energy are better through recompense. 

 We can also consider how effective the recompense is per coupling convention. We can classify each yoke between logical qubits by the induced subgraph considering merely the two chains and the couplings between them. Two such subgraphs are in the like class if they are automorphic. The number of such patterns varies wide according to the graph - minor topology as testify in Table \[table: cct\ ]. 

    Topology    Variables, N    Chain length, L    Logical coupling form  
   ---------- ------------- ---------------- --------------------------- -- 
     Clique         32               9                      16              
     Clique         63               17                     50              
    Biclique        64               8                      10              
    3D cubic        64               4                       3              
    3D cubic        512              4                       3              

  : Chain connectivity topologies[]{data - label="table: cct " } 

 We can take an average over couplers in a give isomorphic class, and classify each class harmonize to $ \chi_{ab}(1)$ for some element $ ab$ in the class. The result is shown in Fig.   \[fig: correlationBalancing\ ] (top - right). Frustration is indeed disproportionately allocate over couplers that connect through extremal points (large $ \chi_{ab}$), we see that applying an appropriate recompense of $ 1/\chi$ between one and two seduce coupler performance more homogeneous. 

 In Fig.   \[fig: correlationBalancing\ ] (bottom - right) we show the mean energies and best minimal achieved for all case of the 3DSG problem ($ 8\times 8 \times 8 $) with and without logical - J recompense. We allow for a small number of edge and varying vacancies (in lineage with defect patterns on the chip). department of energy are significantly improved not only in the median but in almost all instances. 

 Conclusion { # sec: conclusion } 
 = = = = = = = = = = 

 In this newspaper we have demonstrated that inhomogeneities in the patterns of chain coupling produce bias in the sampling distribution, and that compensation by a simple heuristic can reduce biases and better optimization performance. Using a simple heuristic schema based on the assumption that the distribution reflects a freeze - out point in the anneal where chain are rigid (but not fully correlated) allows results to be better in hard random problem: spin glass of various topology, and CDMA. The rigidity of the
 anf CSG. Variance is reducea using GD, but c signan remajns, and coth homogeneity and energy ere umproced through compensatiun.

We can wlso conwidec how effective vge compcusatikk is 'ec coupling pattgrn. We can cnassify each cmuolnng between logical qubits by the inquced sibhraph consideryng pgly fhe two chains and the couplings bstween uhem. Two such subgtaphs are in the same clasd if they are automorpjic. The numver jd such pattefns varies widely accotding to the graph-minor topology as skown in Taboe \[tahne:cct\].

   Topilogy   Variables,K   Chahn lengyh,L   Logical gouplmng patterns  
  ---------- ------------- ---------------- --------------------------- --
    Cnique        32              9                     16              
    Cljqne        63              17                    50              
   Bicliqus       64              8                     10              
   3D cubic       64              4                      3              
   3D cubic       512             4                      3              

  : Chain connectivity ekpplpgies[]{data-label="bable:cct"}

We can takr wn wverage over zouplexa jn a given isomorpjic clafs, ane classifr eavh class according to $\chi_{ab}(1)$ for some elvmenr $ab$ in the class. Che result ir shpwn im Fig. \[fig:correlationBalaucing\] (fop-right). Frkstration ks indeed disprooorniondtely allocated over couplqrs that ronneet throueh ectremaj points (lwrge $\gvi_{ab}$), we see that aoplyiug an appropriahe compensation of $1/\chi$ between one and two malev cmupler pzrformsnce more homjgeneous.

In Fig. \[yig:correjatiovBalancing\] (bottom-cight) we shor the mean enatgies and besv minimal achuevee for auu instances of the 3DSG irjblen ($8\times 8 \times 8$) wibh ana without logicao-J xompensation. We aluowf voc a sidll number ox edee xmd vafiable vacakcids (im line with defect pdttedns on the chip). Enrrnies are wignificwntly improvec not only in the lediai but mn almpst all instances.

Conclusion {#sec:cohclusion}
==========

Ij tmis paper we rave demonstrateb that inhomogeneities in the patterns oh chain couplings prodoce biases in the samklikg distributmon, anq that cokpensation by a simpoe heuristic can veduce biases and imprkve opdimizwtion performance. Using a simple heuristic scheme based on the assumption that vhq distributjon teflebts c freezq-out 'oint in the annesl where chains are rigid (but nut fully cjrrelated) allows results to ne improved in fard random problems: spih glassex of various topology, and CDMA. Yhe rigidity of the
and CSG. Variance is reduced using GD, signal and both and energy are also how effective the is per coupling We can classify each coupling between qubits by the induced subgraph considering only the two chains and the couplings them. Two such subgraphs are in the same class if they are automorphic. number such varies according to the graph-minor topology as shown in Table \[table:cct\]. Topology Variables,N Chain length,L Logical coupling ---------- ------------- ---------------- --------------------------- -- Clique 32 9 Clique 63 17 50 64 8 10 3D cubic 4 3D cubic 4 : connectivity topologies[]{data-label="table:cct"} We take an average over couplers in a given isomorphic class, and classify each class according to $\chi_{ab}(1)$ some element the class. result shown Fig. \[fig:correlationBalancing\] (top-right). indeed disproportionately allocated over couplers that points (large $\chi_{ab}$), we see that applying an compensation of between one and two makes coupler more homogeneous. In Fig. \[fig:correlationBalancing\] (bottom-right) we show mean energies and best minimal achieved for all instances of the 3DSG problem ($8\times 8 with and without logical-J We allows for small of and vacancies (in with defect patterns on the chip). Energies are significantly improved not in the median but in almost all instances. Conclusion {#sec:conclusion} this we have demonstrated inhomogeneities in the patterns chain produce biases in the and compensation heuristic reduce and improve optimization performance. a simple heuristic scheme based the assumption that the in the anneal where chains are rigid (but fully correlated) allows results to be improved hard random problems: spin glasses of various topology, and CDMA. The rigidity the
 and CSG. Variance is reduced usIng GD, but a sIgnal RemAinS, aNd boTh hoMogeneity and enERgy aRe improved through compeNsatiOn.

wE can ALsO consIder how EFfECTivE tHe ComPeNSaTion iS peR coupliNg pattern. WE caN cLassify each cOUpLing betweeN loGical qubits bY thE inducEd SubGRaph cOnsIderiNg only THe two cHains and tHe COuplinGS betweeN THeM. Two Such subgraphs are iN ThE Same class if theY are auToMOrPHIc. THe nUmber of sucH pAtterNS varies WIdELY AccORding to the graPh-minor topoLOgy As showN iN TaBLe \[tablE:cct\].

   TOpOLogY   Variables,N   chaiN length,L   LOgical COupling PAtterns  
  ---------- ------------- ---------------- --------------------------- --
    clique        32              9                     16              
    cliQue        63              17                    50              
   biclIQuE       64              8                     10              
   3D CubIc       64              4                      3              
   3d CubIC       512             4                      3              

  : CHaiN ConNectivitY tOpOlogiEs[]{daTA-LABel="tAblE:cct"}

we can Take an average OveR couPLerS in a gIven iSomoRpHic clAss, and ClassIfY each class accorDing To $\chi_{ab}(1)$ foR soMe EleMeNt $ab$ iN The claSs. THe rEsult is Shown in fIg. \[fIg:CORReLationBalancing\] (top-RiGHT). FRustratiOn is inDEeD dISproportIoNatEly aLLOcateD oveR CoUplers thAt connECt ThRough exTrEmal poInTs (lArgE $\chi_{aB}$), We seE that aPplying aN apprOPriate compensaTIon of $1/\chi$ betweEN oNE AnD Two mAkeS coupler perFormANce mOre hOMoGenEOus.

In fig. \[fiG:cORrELationBalancing\] (bottOm-Right) wE show The mean energiEs and best mINIMal achieVed fOR aLL instances of thE 3DSG pRoblem ($8\timeS 8 \Times 8$) witH and wIthout loGical-J comPENsation. WE alLowS foR a sMALl Number of edge aND VariAbLe vacanCieS (in line WitH deFecT paTtErns on the Chip). EnerGiEs ArE sIgnIficaNTly improVeD noT oNly In the MEdian bUt in aLmosT aLl INstAnces.

CoNClUSIon {#sEc:CoNcluSioN}
==========

IN this PapeR We hAve demoNstrated tHat INhomOgEnEities iN the patterns oF cHain coupliNgS prOduce bIASes in the Sampling distribution, and THat compEnsAtion By a sImple heurIstIc can rEduCE biaseS and imProve OpTimIZAtion PERfOrmAnCe. Using a siMPLe hEurisTiC schEme baseD on the assumption thAT thE distribution RefLectS A FrEezE-OuT PoiNt IN thE ANneal where chainS are rigid (bUt NOt Fully correLAteD) aLlows reSults to Be impROved in hArd random Problems: sPiN glaSSEs oF various toPology, anD CDMA. The rIGiditY Of The
 and CSG. Variance is redu ced usingGD, b uta s ig nalrema ins, and bothh omog eneity and energy areimpro ve d  thr o ug h com pensati o n. Weca nals oc on sider  ho w effec tive the c omp en sation is pe r  c oupling pa tte rn. We can c las sify e ac h c o uplin g b etwee n logi c al qub its by th ei nduced subgrap h co nsid ering only the tw o  c h ains and the c ouplin gs be t w een  th em. Two su ch  subg r aphs ar e  i n t hes ame class ifthey are au t omo rphic.  T hen umberof su ch pat terns varie s wi dely acco rdingt o the g r aph-min or top olo gyas s h ow ninTa b le\ [t abl e :cc t\].

  T op ology    V a r i a bles ,N  Ch ain l ength,L   Log ica l co u pli ng pa ttern s   ----- ---------- -- ------ -------- ---- ---- ---- --- -- --- -- ----- - ------ - - -
   Cliq ue      3 2         9                16          
    C li que      63          17               50          
 Bicl ique      64           8                 10         
   3D cu bic    64        4                 3           
  3D cubic      512         4                 3            
 : Chain  conn ectivity  topologi e s []{data- lab el= "ta ble : c ct "}

We can ta k e  anav erage o ver  couple rsina g ive nisomorphi c class,  a nd  c la ssi fy ea c h classac cor di ngto $\ c hi_{ab }(1)$  for  s om e  el ement $ a b$ i n th ecl ass.  Th eresul t is sho wn in F ig. \[fig :co r rela ti on Balanci ng\] (top-rig ht ). Frustra ti onis ind e e d dispro portionately allocatedo ver cou ple rs th at c onnect th rou gh ext rem a l poin ts (la rge $ \c hi_ { a b}$), w esee  t hat applyi n g  an  appr op riat e compe nsation of $1/\chi $  be tween one and  tw o ma k e scou p le r  pe rf o rma n c e more homogene ous.

In F ig .  \ [fig:corre l ati on Balanci ng\] (b ottom - right)we show t he mean e ne rgie s and  best mini mal achi eved fora ll in s ta ncesofthe 3D SG  pr oblem  ($8\t i mes  8 \t imes 8 $)  withand w it hout log ical-J compensation. We  allow s for  asmall num ber ofedge andvari able vacan cie s ( in li new ith d efec t  p att e rns o n th e  chip). E n er gie s ar e significa n t l y i mprov edn ot onl y in  the median but i n  almost all in stan c e s.
Co n clus io n {#sec:conclu sio n} = ======== =
In this pa per we h av e  demo nstrat ed tha t inhom o g en e itiesin t hepatternsofch a in coup li ng s  produ ce b ia ses in  the s a mpli n g  distribution, a nd th a t  comp e nsa tionby  a simp l e he uristic ca n reduce bi ases a nd i mprov e optim iz ationper fo rmance. Us i ng a simp le he uristic  s chem e b ased o n th e assum ptio ntha t the dis t r ib u ti on ref lect s a f re eze- out point in the a nne a l where  c hai n s  are r i gi d (but not f ull y cor r e lated) all o ws r e su l ts to  be im proved  in har d  ra nd om prob lem s :  spin gla sses of v a rio us  top ology, a nd  CDM A.  Th erigidity of the 
 and_CSG. Variance_is reduced using GD,_but a_signal_remains, and_both_homogeneity and energy_are improved through_compensation.

We can also consider_how effective the_compensation_is per coupling pattern. We can classify each coupling between logical qubits by the_induced_subgraph considering_only_the_two chains and the couplings_between them. Two such subgraphs_are in_the same class if they are automorphic. The_number_of such patterns_varies widely according to the graph-minor topology as shown_in Table \[table:cct\].

   Topology_  Variables,N___Chain length,L  _Logical coupling patterns  
 _---------- ------------- ---------------- --------------------------- --
 _  Clique    _   32  _    _ _    9_  _ _  _     _  _   16  __  ___ _  _
_ __Clique     __ 63     _   __   17_    _     _ _ _    50      _     _ 
  _Biclique __  __64 _      _ _   8  _   __     _     _ 10   ___    _   
  _3D cubic _     64 __     __    4 ___    _     _       3 _  _    ___  
   3D cubic   _ _ 512 _         _ 4     _          _     3  _      _   _

_ : Chain connectivity topologies[]{data-label="table:cct"}

We can take_an_average_over_couplers in a_given isomorphic class,_and classify each_class according_to $\chi_{ab}(1)$ for_some element_$ab$ in the_class._The result is shown in Fig. \[fig:correlationBalancing\] (top-right). Frustration is indeed disproportionately allocated over couplers that connect through extremal_points (large $\chi_{ab}$), we see that_applying an appropriate compensation of_$1/\chi$_between one and_two makes coupler performance_more homogeneous.

In Fig. \[fig:correlationBalancing\] (bottom-right) we show the mean_energies and best minimal achieved for all instances of_the_3DSG problem_($8\times 8 \times 8$)_with and_without logical-J_compensation. We allows_for a_small number_of edge_and variable vacancies (in line with defect_patterns_on the chip). Energies are significantly improved not only_in_the_median_but in almost_all instances.

Conclusion {#sec:conclusion}
==========

In_this paper we_have demonstrated that_inhomogeneities_in the patterns of chain couplings_produce biases in_the sampling distribution, and_that compensation by a simple heuristic can reduce biases and_improve optimization performance. Using a simple heuristic scheme based on the assumption that the distribution reflects a_freeze-out point_in the anneal where_chains are_rigid_(but not fully correlated) allows results_to be_improved in hard random problems: spin glasses of_various_topology, and CDMA. The rigidity of the