/\psi\omega$ (P wave) is observed, the heavy quark spin symmetry implies that it is not a $c\bar{c}$ meson and the $J^{PC}$ are very likely to be $3^{-+}$.'
author:
- 'W. Zhu, T. Yao, Yan-Rui Liu'
title: 'Possibility of a $J^{PC}=3^{-+}$ state'
---

Introduction {#sec1}
============

Mesons with exotic properties play an important role in understanding the nature of strong interactions. The observation of the so called XYZ states in the heavy quark sector has triggered lots of discussions on their quark structures, decays, and formation mechanisms. It also motivates people to study new states beyond the quark model assignments.

The X(3872), first observed in the $J\psi\pi^+\pi^-$ invariant mass distribution by Belle collaboration in 2003 [@X3872-belle], is the strangest heavy quark state. Even now, its angular momentum is not determined. Since its extreme closeness to the $D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold, lots of discussions about its properties are based on the molecule assumption. However, it is very difficult to identify the X(3872) as a shallow bound state of $D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ since there are no explicitly exotic molecule properties.

A charged charmonium- or bottomonium-like meson labeled as $Z$ is absolutely exotic because its number of quarks and antiquarks must be four or more. Such states include the $Z(4430)$ observed in the $\psi'\pi^\pm$ mass distribution [@Z4430-belle], the $Z_1(4050)$ and $Z_2(4250)$ observed in the $\chi_{c1}\pi^+$ mass distribution [@Z1Z2-belle], and the $Z_b(10610)$ and $Z_b(10650)$ in the mass spectra of the $\Upsilon(nS)\pi^\pm$ ($n$=1,2,3) and $\pi^\pm h_b(mP)$ ($m$=1,2) [@Zb-belle]. They are all observed by Belle Collaboration. Though BABAR has not confirmed them [@Z4430-babar; @Z1Z2-babar], the existence signal of multiquark states is still
/\psi\omega$ (P wave) is observed, the heavy quark spin isotropy entail that it is not a $ c\bar{c}$ meson and the $ J^{PC}$ are very likely to be $ 3^{-+}$.' 
 author: 
 -' W. Zhu, T. Yao, Yan - Rui Liu' 
 claim:' hypothesis of a $ J^{PC}=3^{-+}$ state' 
 --- 

 Introduction { # sec1 } 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 Mesons with exotic property play an important function in understanding the nature of strong interaction. The observation of the so call XYZ states in the heavy quark sector has triggered lots of discussions on their quark structure, decays, and formation mechanisms. It besides motivates people to analyze new state beyond the quark model assignments. 

 The X(3872), first observed in the $ J\psi\pi^+\pi^-$ invariant aggregate distribution by Belle collaboration in 2003 [ @X3872 - belle ], is the strangest heavy quark state. Even now, its angular momentum is not determined. Since its extreme meanness to the $ D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold, lots of discussions about its properties are based on the molecule assumption. However, it is very difficult to identify the X(3872) as a shallow bound state of matter of $ D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ since there are no explicitly exotic atom place. 

 A charge charmonium- or bottomonium - like meson labeled as $ Z$ is absolutely alien because its number of quark and antiquarks must be four or more. Such states admit the $ Z(4430)$ observed in the $ \psi'\pi^\pm$ mass distribution [ @Z4430 - belle ], the $ Z_1(4050)$ and $ Z_2(4250)$ observed in the $ \chi_{c1}\pi^+$ mass distribution [ @Z1Z2 - belle ], and the $ Z_b(10610)$ and $ Z_b(10650)$ in the mass spectra of the $ \Upsilon(nS)\pi^\pm$ ($ n$=1,2,3) and $ \pi^\pm h_b(mP)$ ($ m$=1,2) [ @Zb - belle ]. They are all observed by Belle Collaboration. Though BABAR has not confirmed them [ @Z4430 - babar; @Z1Z2 - babar ], the existence signal of multiquark states is still
/\psi\lmega$ (P wave) is observed, the heavy quark spin vymmetdy implids that it is not a $c\bar{c}$ medob and the $J^{PC}$ are very likeuy to be $3^{-+}$.'
wuthor:
- 'W. Zhu, R. Yao, Yan-Rnj Liu'
tibje: 'Pkdsibnlmty of a $J^{PC}=3^{-+}$ stste'
---

Introduwtion {#sec1}
============

Mesonv dich exotic properties play an importagt role ij understandind tht nwturs of strong interactions. The obserbation mf the so calked XYZ states in the heavj quwrk sector has trihgered lots of quscussions ov their quark structurgs, decays, and formation mechanisos. It also moticares keople to stndy ner states beyond the xuark mpdel assignmenbs.

The X(3872), dirst observed in the $J\psi\pi^+\pi^-$ invarianj mass disdrnbution by Belle collqbiratimn it 2003 [@X3872-cwlld], ia vhe stranhesv heavy quadk state. Evwn now, its angular koivmtum is not setermynqd. Since its extreme closeness to the $D^0\tar{S}^{*0}$ threshold, lots of disxussions about its prlperties wre based on the molecule assumption. However, it iv verb aifylgult ro identify the X(3872) as a shallow bound state of $D^0\fzr{C}^{*0}$ xince there arc no explicitly exptlc iolecule propgrties.

A chzrged charmonium- og bottoioniun-like mesjn lsbeled as $Z$ is absolutely ezotic becausv itw number of quarks and antiqucrks most be four or more. Such statzs incmude the $Z(4430)$ lbserved jv the $\psi'\pi^\pm$ mars civtribution [@Z4430-belle], the $Z_1(4050)$ anq $Z_2(4250)$ obserted iu the $\chk_{c1}\pi^+$ mass qistributiln [@Z1Z2-nalle], and the $Z_b(10610)$ anf $Z_b(10650)$ nn tha mass speftra of the $\Upsilon(nS)\pi^\pm$ ($n$=1,2,3) and $\pi^\pm h_b(mP)$ ($m$=1,2) [@Zn-ballv]. They arz all pbserved by Bqlle Collaborajion. Thouyh BABXR has not confirked them [@Z4430-bwbar; @Z1Z2-babar], dje existence signal jf myltiwuark sgxtes is still
/\psi\omega$ (P wave) is observed, the heavy symmetry that it not a $c\bar{c}$ very to be $3^{-+}$.' - 'W. Zhu, Yao, Yan-Rui Liu' title: 'Possibility of $J^{PC}=3^{-+}$ state' --- Introduction {#sec1} ============ Mesons with exotic properties play an important in understanding the nature of strong interactions. The observation of the so called states the quark has triggered lots of discussions on their quark structures, decays, and formation mechanisms. It also motivates to study new states beyond the quark model The X(3872), first observed the $J\psi\pi^+\pi^-$ invariant mass distribution Belle in 2003 is strangest quark state. Even its angular momentum is not determined. Since its extreme closeness to the $D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold, lots of discussions its properties on the assumption. it very difficult to X(3872) as a shallow bound state there are no explicitly exotic molecule properties. A charmonium- or meson labeled as $Z$ is absolutely because its number of quarks and antiquarks must four or more. Such states include the $Z(4430)$ observed in the $\psi'\pi^\pm$ mass distribution [@Z4430-belle], and $Z_2(4250)$ observed in $\chi_{c1}\pi^+$ mass distribution and $Z_b(10610)$ $Z_b(10650)$ the mass of the $\Upsilon(nS)\pi^\pm$ ($n$=1,2,3) and $\pi^\pm h_b(mP)$ ($m$=1,2) [@Zb-belle]. They are observed by Belle Collaboration. Though BABAR has not confirmed them the signal of multiquark is still
/\psi\omega$ (P wave) is observed, thE heavy quarK spin SymMetRy ImplIes tHat it is not a $c\baR{C}$ mesOn and the $J^{PC}$ are very likeLy to bE $3^{-+}$.'
aUThor:
- 'w. zhU, T. Yao, yan-Rui LIU'
tITLe: 'POsSiBilItY Of A $J^{PC}=3^{-+}$ sTatE'
---

IntrodUction {#sec1}
============

MEsoNs With exotic prOPeRties play aN imPortant role iN unDerstaNdIng THe natUre Of strOng intERactioNs. The obseRvATion of THe so calLED XyZ stAtes in the heavy quaRK sECtor has triggerEd lots Of DIsCUSsiOns On their quaRk StrucTUres, decAYs, AND ForMAtion mechanisMs. It also motIVatEs peopLe To sTUdy new StateS bEYonD the quark moDel aSsignmentS.

The X(3872), fIRst obseRVed in thE $J\psi\pI^+\pi^-$ InvAriaNT mAsS diStRIbuTIoN by bEllE collaboRaTiOn in 2003 [@X3872-BellE], IS THe stRanGest Heavy Quark state. EveN noW, its ANguLar moMentuM is nOt DeterMined. SInce iTs Extreme closenesS to tHe $D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ thResHoLd, lOtS of diSCussioNs aBouT its proPerties ARe bAsED ON tHe molecule assumptiOn. hOWeVer, it is vEry difFIcUlT To identiFy The x(3872) as a SHAllow BounD StAte of $D^0\baR{D}^{*0}$ sincE ThErE are no eXpLicitlY eXotIc mOlecuLE proPertieS.

A chargeD charMOnium- or bottomoNIum-like meson lABeLED aS $z$ is aBsoLutely exotiC becAUse iTs nuMBeR of QUarks And anTiQUaRKs must be four or more. SUcH stateS inclUde the $Z(4430)$ observEd in the $\psi'\PI^\PM$ mass disTribUTiON [@Z4430-belle], the $Z_1(4050)$ and $z_2(4250)$ obseRved in the $\cHI_{c1}\pi^+$ mass DistrIbution [@Z1z2-belle], and THE $Z_b(10610)$ and $Z_b(10650)$ In tHe mAss SpeCTRa Of the $\Upsilon(ns)\PI^\pm$ ($n$=1,2,3) AnD $\pi^\pm h_b(MP)$ ($m$=1,2) [@zb-belle]. theY arE alL obSeRved by BelLe CollabOrAtIoN. THouGh BABar has not cOnFirMeD thEm [@Z4430-baBAr; @Z1Z2-baBar], thE exiStEnCE siGnal of mULtIQUark StAtEs is StiLl
/\psi\omega$ (P wave) is o bserved, t he he avy  qu ar k sp in s ymmetry implie s  tha t it is not a $c\bar{c }$ me so n  and th e $J^ {PC}$ a r ev e ryli ke lyto be  $3^{ -+} $.'
aut hor:
- 'W.  Zh u,  T. Yao, Yan - Ru i Liu'
tit le:  'Possibilit y o f a $J ^{ PC} = 3^{-+ }$state '
---Introd uction {# se c 1}
=== = ======= = 
M eson s with exotic pro p er t ies play an im portan tr ol e inund erstanding  t he na t ure ofs tr o n g  in t eractions. Th e observati o n o f theso  ca l led XY Z sta te s  in  the heavyquar k sectorhas tr i ggeredl ots ofdiscus sio nson t h ei rqua rk str u ct ure s , d ecays, a nd  f ormat ionm e c h anis ms.  Italsomotivates peo ple  tos tud y new  stat es b ey ond t he qua rk mo de l assignments.
The  X(3872),  fi rs t o bs erved in the  $J \ps i\pi^+\ pi^-$ i n var ia n t ma ss distribution by  B e l le  collabo ration in  2 0 03 [@X38 72 -be lle] , is th e st r an gest hea vy qua r kst ate. Ev en  now,it s a ngu lar m o ment um isnot dete rmine d . Since its ex t reme closenes s  t o th e  $D^ 0\b ar{D}^{*0}$  thr e shol d, l o ts  of discu ssion sa bo u t its properties ar ebasedon th e molecule as sumption.H o w ever, it  isv er y  difficult toident ify the X( 3 872) asa sha llow bou nd stateo f  $D^0\ba r{D }^{ *0} $ s i n ce  there are no e xpli ci tly exo tic  molecu lepro per tie s. 

A charg ed charm on iu m-  o r b ottom o nium-lik emes on  la beled as $Z$  is a bsol ut el y  ex otic be c au s e  its  n um berofqu arksanda nti quarksmust be f our or m or e.  Such s tates include  t he $Z(4430 )$  ob served i n the $\ psi'\pi^\pm$ mass distr i bution[@Z 4430- bell e], the $ Z_1 (4050) $ a n d $Z_2 (4250) $ obs er ved i n the $ \c hi_ {c 1}\pi^+$ m a s s d istri bu tion  [@Z1Z2 -belle], and the $ Z _b( 10610)$ and $ Z_b (106 5 0 )$  in th e  ma ss spe c t ra of the $\Ups ilon(nS)\p i^ \ pm $ ($n$=1,2 , 3)an d $\pi^ \pm h_b (mP)$ ($m$=1, 2) [@Zb-b elle]. Th ey  are a llobserved b y BelleCollabora t ion.T ho ugh B ABA R hasno t c onfir med th e m [ @Z443 0-baba r;  @Z1Z2 -baba r] , the ex istence signal of multi quarkstate s i s still
/\psi\omega$ (P_wave) is_observed, the heavy quark_spin symmetry_implies_that it_is_not a $c\bar{c}$_meson and the_$J^{PC}$ are very likely_to be $3^{-+}$.'
author:
-_'W._Zhu, T. Yao, Yan-Rui Liu'
title: 'Possibility of a $J^{PC}=3^{-+}$ state'
---

Introduction {#sec1}
============

Mesons with exotic properties_play_an important_role_in_understanding the nature of strong_interactions. The observation of the_so called_XYZ states in the heavy quark sector has_triggered_lots of discussions_on their quark structures, decays, and formation mechanisms. It_also motivates people to study new_states beyond the_quark_model_assignments.

The X(3872), first observed_in the $J\psi\pi^+\pi^-$ invariant mass distribution_by Belle collaboration in 2003 [@X3872-belle],_is the strangest heavy quark state. Even_now, its angular momentum is not_determined. Since its extreme closeness_to the_$D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ threshold, lots of discussions_about its properties_are based_on the molecule_assumption. However, it is very difficult_to identify the_X(3872) as a shallow bound state_of_$D^0\bar{D}^{*0}$ since there_are_no_explicitly exotic_molecule properties.

A charged_charmonium-_or bottomonium-like_meson_labeled as $Z$ is absolutely exotic_because_its number of quarks and antiquarks must_be four or more._Such_states include the $Z(4430)$_observed in the $\psi'\pi^\pm$ mass_distribution [@Z4430-belle], the $Z_1(4050)$ and $Z_2(4250)$_observed in_the $\chi_{c1}\pi^+$_mass distribution [@Z1Z2-belle], and the $Z_b(10610)$ and $Z_b(10650)$ in the mass_spectra of the $\Upsilon(nS)\pi^\pm$ ($n$=1,2,3) and_$\pi^\pm h_b(mP)$ ($m$=1,2) [@Zb-belle]._They are_all_observed by Belle_Collaboration._Though BABAR_has not confirmed them [@Z4430-babar; @Z1Z2-babar], the_existence signal_of multiquark states is still