 redder HB than would be expected for its metal abundance. This second parameter effect is common among the Galaxy’s dSph companions and it is also particularly prevalent among the globular clusters that lie, like the dSphs, in the outer regions of the galactic halo.

Considerable effort has gone into attempting to understand the origin of the second parameter effect and its dependence on galactocentric distance. It is now generally accepted that the phenomenon is a manifestation of age differences that occur in the galactic halo (e.g. Lee, Demarque & Zinn 1994). Indeed this age difference interpretation of the diversity of HB types seen in the outer halo of the Galaxy is a cornerstone of the chaotic halo formation model advocated initially by Searle & Zinn (1978), in which the galactic halo is built out of the destruction of satellite galaxies over an extended interval of perhaps $\sim$3 to 5 Gyr. [*Does this prolonged formation scenario apply also to the halo of M31?*]{} An initial attack on this problem can be made by determining the HB morphologies of the most readily identifiable objects in the outer halo of M31, the And dSph galaxies. Since the mean metal abundances of these systems are well established, we can accurately predict the HB morphology expected if the bulk of the stellar population in these galaxies is as old as the inner galactic halo globular clusters. If the observations reveal instead a diversity of HB morphologies, then it will be an indication that the outer halo of M31 may also have formed in the same drawn out chaotic manner as the outer regions of the halo of our galaxy.

We begin this task by presenting in this paper the results of a [*Hubble Space Telescope*]{} imaging study whose principal aim was to determine the HB morphology of the Andromeda I dwarf spheroidal galaxy. The observations, made with the WFPC2 camera, are detailed in the next section together with a description of the photometric analysis applied to the images. The resulting And I color-magnitude diagrams are discussed in detail in Section 3. The results, both in the context of the formation and the evolution of this dSph, and in the context of formation scenarios for the halo of M31, are discussed in Section 4 and summarized in Section 5.

Observations and Photometry
===========================

Andromeda I was imaged with the [*Hubble Space Telescope*]{} Wide Field Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2, see Holtzman [*et al.
redder HB than would be expected for its metal abundance. This second parameter consequence is coarse among the Galaxy ’s dSph companions and it is also particularly prevailing among the globular clusters that lie, like the dSphs, in the forbidden regions of the galactic aura. 

 Considerable effort has gone into undertake to understand the origin of the second argument effect and its dependence on galactocentric distance. It is now generally accepted that the phenomenon is a manifestation of age difference that occur in the galactic halo (for example   Lee, Demarque & Zinn 1994). Indeed this age difference rendition of the diversity of HB type seen in the out halo of the Galaxy is a cornerstone of the chaotic halo constitution model advocated initially by Searle & Zinn (1978), in which the galactic halo is built out of the destruction of satellite galaxies over an extended interval of perhaps $ \sim$3 to 5 Gyr. [ * Does this prolonged formation scenario apply also to the halo of M31? * ] { } An initial attack on this problem can be make by determining the HB morphologies of the about promptly identifiable objects in the outer halo of M31, the And dSph galaxies. Since the hateful metallic element abundances of these systems are well build, we can accurately predict the HB morphology expected if the bulk of the stellar population in these galaxies is as honest-to-god as the inner galactic halo globular clusters. If the observations uncover instead a diverseness of HB morphology, then it will be an indication that the outer halo of M31 may also have form in the same drawn out chaotic manner as the outer region of the halo of our galaxy. 

 We begin this task by present in this paper the solution of a [ * Hubble Space Telescope * ] { } imaging study whose chief aim was to determine the HB morphology of the Andromeda   I dwarf spheroidal galaxy. The notice, made with the WFPC2 television camera, are detailed in the next section in concert with a description of the photometric analysis applied to the images. The resulting And I color - magnitude diagrams are discussed in detail in Section 3. The results, both in the context of the formation and the development of this dSph, and in the context of formation scenarios for the aura of M31, are discussed in Section 4 and summarized in Section 5. 

 Observations and Photometry 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 Andromeda I was imaged with the [ * Hubble Space Telescope * ] { } Wide Field Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2, see Holtzman [ * et al.
 refder HB than would be exkected for its mejao abunvance. Tgis secovd parameter effect is commoi aming tye Galaxy’s dSph compankons and pt is alsi pacticularly prevalent amoky the nlobuner clusters thaj lie, like tve dSphs, in tha uucer regions of the galactic halo.

Consyderablr fffort has gong intp attsmpting to understand the origin or the stcond parameter efgect and its dependence on galwctocentric distanfe. It is noq gegwrally accepged that the phenomenoh is a manifestation of age difwerenees that ocxue ij the galactmc halj (e.g. Lee, Demavaue & Zhnn 1994). Inceed this age cifherebce interpretation of the diversity of RB types vezn in the outer halo if the Calafy ir a zorhecstkne of thx chaotic hzlo formatiin model advocated onynoally by Seadle & Zyng (1978), in which the galactic halo is built mut of the destruction of watellite galaxies ovgr an extegded interval of perhaps $\sim$3 to 5 Gyr. [*Does this prmlongxd foxnatiov sfenario apply also to the halo of M31?*]{} An initiaj autabk on this problei can be mace bu determining jhe HB morlhologies of the mlst reaqily udentifiafle pbjects in the outer halo od M31, the And bSpy galaxies. Since tke mean metau abondancrs of these systems are welm establishfd, we can xccurately predizt nhe VB morphology expected if ehe bulk if tke stellxr pppulatyon in thede galaxies is as old as the nnner galactic jalo globular clusters. If the ouxervations rgvedl pnstead a divevsity of HB mor[hologies, then it wilj be xn indicatpon that vhe outer hajo of M31 may ando have formxd in the samw drqwn out zhaotic manner as the olttr regions of the halo of ouv galxsy.

We begin this tawk by presentinb iv trid 'aper dhe results mf a [*Hucnle Soace Telescioe*]{} ikaging study whose psincjpal aim was to deyevmine the HB morprology of the Andromeda I dwarf dphermidel galsxy. The observations, made with ths WFPC2 calerw, are detailqd ik thg next sectnon together with a description of the piotometric analysis apklied to the images. Tke resulting End I solor-magnhtude diagrams are duscussed in detaik in Section 3. The reshlts, bmth ij the context of the formation and the evolution of this dSph, and in the xontexv jf formatioh scrnarims yor the hall of M31, are discusxed in Section 4 and summarized mn Section 5.

Oyservations and Photometry
===========================

Andtooeda I was imxged with the [*Hubble Spade Telesvope*]{} Wide Field Planetary Camers 2 (WFPC2, see Holtzman [*et sl.
redder HB than would be expected for abundance. second parameter is common among it also particularly prevalent the globular clusters lie, like the dSphs, in the regions of the galactic halo. Considerable effort has gone into attempting to understand origin of the second parameter effect and its dependence on galactocentric distance. It now accepted the is a manifestation of age differences that occur in the galactic halo (e.g. Lee, Demarque & 1994). Indeed this age difference interpretation of the of HB types seen the outer halo of the is cornerstone of chaotic formation advocated initially by & Zinn (1978), in which the galactic halo is built out of the destruction of satellite galaxies an extended perhaps $\sim$3 5 [*Does prolonged formation scenario to the halo of M31?*]{} An this problem can be made by determining the morphologies of most readily identifiable objects in the halo of M31, the And dSph galaxies. Since mean metal abundances of these systems are well established, we can accurately predict the HB if the bulk of stellar population in galaxies as as inner galactic globular clusters. If the observations reveal instead a diversity of HB then it will be an indication that the outer halo may have formed in same drawn out chaotic as outer regions of the our We by in paper the results of [*Hubble Space Telescope*]{} imaging study principal aim was to the Andromeda I dwarf spheroidal galaxy. The observations, with the WFPC2 camera, are detailed in next section together with a description of the photometric analysis applied to images. The I color-magnitude diagrams are discussed in detail in 3. The results, both the context of the formation and the evolution of dSph, in the of formation scenarios the halo of are discussed in and summarized Section Observations Andromeda I was imaged with the Space Wide Field Planetary Camera 2 see al.
 redder HB than would be expectEd for its meTal abUndAncE. THis sEconD parameter effeCT is cOmmon among the Galaxy’s dSPh comPaNIons ANd It is aLso partICuLARly PrEvAleNt AMoNg the GloBular clUsters that Lie, LiKe the dSphs, in THe Outer regioNs oF the galactic HalO.

ConsiDeRabLE effoRt hAs gonE into aTTemptiNg to underStANd the oRIgin of tHE SeCond Parameter effect anD ItS Dependence on gaLactocEnTRiC DIstAncE. It is now geNeRally ACcepted THaT THE phENomenon is a manIfestation oF Age DifferEnCes THat occUr in tHe GAlaCtic halo (e.g. LEe, DeMarque & ZinN 1994). IndeeD This age DIfferenCe inteRprEtaTion OF tHe DivErSIty OF Hb tyPEs sEen in the OuTeR halo Of thE gALAxy iS a cOrneRstonE of the chaotic HalO forMAtiOn modEl advOcatEd InitiAlly by searlE & ZInn (1978), in which the gaLactIc halo is bUilT oUt oF tHe desTRuctioN of SatEllite gAlaxies OVer An EXTEnDed interval of perhaPs $\SIM$3 tO 5 Gyr. [*Does This prOLoNgED formatiOn SceNariO APply aLso tO ThE halo of M31?*]{} an initIAl AtTack on tHiS problEm Can Be mAde by DEterMining The HB morPholoGIes of the most reADily identifiaBLe OBJeCTs in The Outer halo of m31, the aNd dSPh gaLAxIes. sInce tHe meaN mETaL Abundances of these syStEms are Well eStablished, we cAn accurateLY PRedict thE HB mORpHOlogy expected iF the bUlk of the stELlar popuLatioN in these Galaxies iS AS old as thE inNer GalActIC HaLo globular cluSTErs. IF tHe obserVatIons revEal InsTeaD a dIvErsity of Hb morpholOgIeS, tHeN it Will bE An indicaTiOn tHaT thE outeR Halo of m31 may aLso hAvE fORmeD in the sAMe DRAwn oUt ChAotiC maNnEr as tHe ouTEr rEgions oF the halo oF ouR GalaXy.

we Begin thIs task by preseNtIng in this pApEr tHe resuLTS of a [*HubbLe Space Telescope*]{} imaging STudy whoSe pRinciPal aIm was to deTerMine thE HB MOrpholOgy of tHe AndRoMedA i Dwarf SPHeRoiDaL galaxy. The OBSerVatioNs, Made With the wFPC2 camera, are detaiLEd iN the next sectiOn tOgetHER wIth A DeSCriPtIOn oF THe photometric anAlysis applIeD To The images. THE reSuLting AnD I color-MagniTUde diagRams are diScussed in DeTail IN secTion 3. The resUlts, both In the contEXt of tHE fOrmatIon And the EvOluTion oF this dsPh, aNd in tHe contExT of forMatioN sCenarios For the halo of M31, are discussEd in SeCtion 4 And SummarizeD in sEctIon 5.

ObservAtioNs and PhotoMetRy
===========================

ANdromEda i Was imAged WItH thE [*hubblE SpaCE TelescopE*]{} wiDe FIELd planetary CaMERA 2 (WFpC2, see holTZman [*et Al.
 redder HB than would be e xpected fo r its  me tal  a bund ance . This secondp aram eter effect is commonamong  t h e Ga l ax y’s d Sph com p an i o nsan ditis al so pa rti cularly  prevalent  am on g the globul a rclusters t hat  lie, like t hedSphs,  i n t h e out erregio ns oft he gal actic hal o. 
Consi d erablee f fo rt h as gone into atte m pt i ng to understa nd the  o r ig i n  of  th e second p ar amete r  effect an d i tsd ependence ongalactocent r icdistan ce . I t  is no w gen er a lly  accepted t hatthe pheno menoni s a man i festati on ofage  di ffer e nc es  th at occ u rint hegalactic  h al o (e. g. L e e , Dema rqu e &Zinn1994). Indeed  th is a g e d iffer enceinte rp retat ion of  thedi versity of HB t ypes  seen inthe  o ute rhaloo f theGal axy  is a c ornerst o neof t h echaotic halo forma ti o n  m odel adv ocated in it i ally bySe arl e &Z i nn (1 978) ,  i n whichthe ga l ac ti c halois  built  o utofthe d e stru ctionof satel liteg alaxies over a n  extended int e rv a l  o f  per hap s $\sim$3 t o 5G yr.[*Do e sthi s  prol onged  f o rm a tion scenario apply  a lso to  thehalo of M31?* ]{} An ini t i a l attack  ont hi s  problem can b e mad e by deter m ining th e HBmorpholo gies of t h e  most re adi lyide nti f i ab le objects in t he o ut er halo  of  M31, t heAnd  dS phga laxies. S ince the  m ea nme tal  abun d ances of  t hes esys temsa re wel l est abli sh ed ,  we  can ac c ur a t elypr ed ictthe  H B mor phol o gyexpecte d if thebul k  ofth estellar  population i nthese gala xi esis aso l d as the  inner galactic halo gl o bular c lus ters.  Ifthe obser vat ions r eve a l inst ead adiver si tyo f  HB m o r ph olo gi es, then i t wil l bean  ind ication  that the outer ha l o o f M31 may als o h avef o rm edi nt hesa m e d r a wn out chaoticmanner asth e  o uter regio n s o fthe hal o of ou r gal a xy.

We  begin th is task b ypres e n tin g in thispaper th e results of a[ *H ubble  Sp ace Te le sco pe*]{ } imag i ngstudy  whose  p rincip al ai mwas to d etermine the HB morphol ogy of  theAnd romeda Idwa r f s pheroidal  gal axy. The o bse rva tions , m a de wi th t h eWFP C 2 cam era, are detai l ed  in t he  next secti o n tog ether  wi t h a de scri ption of the phot o metric analysi s ap p l ied  to theim ages. The resu lti ng A nd I col or -magnitudediagrams  a r e dis cussed  in de tail in S ec t ion 3.  The  re sults, bo thin the con te xt of the  for ma tion a nd the evol u t ion of this dSph , and i n the con textof  format i on s cenarios f or the halo  of M3 1, a re di scussed  i n Sect ion  4  and summa r ized in S ectio n 5.

O bs erva tio ns and  Pho t o metry 
=== == === ========= = = == = == == = 

A ndro medaIwasimaged wi t h the [* Hub b le Spac eTel e s cope*] { }W i de Field P lan etary C amera 2 (W F PC2, se e  Holt zman [ *et al .
 redder_HB than_would be expected for_its metal_abundance._This second_parameter_effect is common_among the Galaxy’s_dSph companions and it_is also particularly_prevalent_among the globular clusters that lie, like the dSphs, in the outer regions of_the_galactic halo.

Considerable_effort_has_gone into attempting to understand_the origin of the second_parameter effect_and its dependence on galactocentric distance. It is_now_generally accepted that_the phenomenon is a manifestation of age differences that_occur in the galactic halo (e.g. Lee,_Demarque & Zinn_1994)._Indeed_this age difference interpretation_of the diversity of HB types_seen in the outer halo of_the Galaxy is a cornerstone of the_chaotic halo formation model advocated initially_by Searle & Zinn (1978),_in which_the galactic halo is built_out of the_destruction of_satellite galaxies over_an extended interval of perhaps $\sim$3_to 5 Gyr._[*Does this prolonged formation scenario apply_also_to the halo_of_M31?*]{}_An initial_attack on this_problem_can be_made_by determining the HB morphologies of_the_most readily identifiable objects in the outer_halo of M31, the_And_dSph galaxies. Since the_mean metal abundances of these_systems are well established, we can_accurately predict_the HB_morphology expected if the bulk of the stellar population in these_galaxies is as old as the_inner galactic halo globular_clusters. If_the_observations reveal instead_a_diversity of_HB morphologies, then it will be an_indication that_the outer halo of M31 may_also have formed in_the_same drawn out chaotic manner as_the outer regions of the halo_of our galaxy.

We begin this_task_by_presenting in this paper the_results of a [*Hubble Space Telescope*]{}_imaging study whose_principal aim was to determine the HB_morphology_of the Andromeda I dwarf spheroidal galaxy._The_observations, made with the WFPC2 camera,_are_detailed_in the next section together_with a description of the photometric_analysis applied to the images. The resulting And I_color-magnitude diagrams are_discussed in detail in Section_3._The_results, both in the context of the formation and the_evolution of_this dSph, and_in the context of formation scenarios for the halo of_M31, are discussed in Section 4 and_summarized in Section 5.

Observations and Photometry
===========================

Andromeda I was imaged with the_[*Hubble Space Telescope*]{} Wide Field Planetary Camera 2_(WFPC2, see Holtzman [*et al.