.3       28.7       40.9       49.2       43.3       36.8
              real-a     98.93       91.34       84.25       82.43       97.31       69.27       75.51       80.70       33.9     **12.5**   **12.7**   **9.1**    **19.8**     31.0       17.1       11.5
   (ResNet)    Ours    **99.37**   **94.69**   **94.56**   **93.35**   **99.10**   **93.04**   **91.49**   **91.64**   **18.5**   **12.6**   **13.0**   **10.3**     29.7     **10.9**   **11.0**   **8.9**
  ---------- -------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ----------

  ---------- ----------------------------------------------------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
    Model                            Loss                              SG          LS          SM          BA          SG          LS          SM          BA          SG         LS         SM         BA         SG         LS         SM        BA
              w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_recon\] \[eq:3dagan\_attradv\]     97.97       87.92       84.62       83.65       97.93       86.21       81.11       82.21       20.2     **10.6**   **7.8**      14.1       43.8       20.4       27.2      18.3
                         w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_recon\]                 99.28       92.95       93.17     **94.86**     98.87       90.79       89.50     **93.82**   **17.6**     17.5       13.8       11.9     **26.6**     18.1       15.0      11.4
   (ResNet)             w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_attr
.3        28.7        40.9        49.2        43.3        36.8 
               real - a      98.93        91.34        84.25        82.43        97.31        69.27        75.51        80.70        33.9      * * 12.5 * *    * * 12.7 * *    * * 9.1 * *     * * 19.8 * *      31.0        17.1        11.5 
    (ResNet)     Ours     * * 99.37 * *    * * 94.69 * *    * * 94.56 * *    * * 93.35 * *    * * 99.10 * *    * * 93.04 * *    * * 91.49 * *    * * 91.64 * *    * * 18.5 * *    * * 12.6 * *    * * 13.0 * *    * * 10.3 * *      29.7      * * 10.9 * *    * * 11.0 * *    * * 8.9 * * 
   ---------- -------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- 

   ---------- ----------------------------------------------------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- --------- 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
     Model                             Loss                               SG           LS           SM           BA           SG           LS           SM           BA           SG          LS          SM          BA          SG          LS          SM         BA 
               w/o Eq.   \[eq:3dagan\_recon\ ]   \[eq:3dagan\_attradv\ ]      97.97        87.92        84.62        83.65        97.93        86.21        81.11        82.21        20.2      * * 10.6 * *    * * 7.8 * *       14.1        43.8        20.4        27.2       18.3 
                          w/o Eq.   \[eq:3dagan\_recon\ ]                  99.28        92.95        93.17      * * 94.86 * *      98.87        90.79        89.50      * * 93.82 * *    * * 17.6 * *      17.5        13.8        11.9      * * 26.6 * *      18.1        15.0       11.4 
    (ResNet)              w/o Eq.   \[eq:3dagan\_attr
.3       28.7       40.9       49.2       43.3       36.8
              ceal-a     98.93       91.34       84.25       82.43       97.31       69.27       75.51       80.70       33.9     **12.5**   **12.7**   **9.1**    **19.8**     31.0       17.1       11.5
   (RxaNet)    Ours    **99.37**   **94.69**   **94.56**   **93.35**   **99.10**   **93.04**   **91.49**   **91.64**   **18.5**   **12.6**   **13.0**   **10.3**     29.7     **10.9**   **11.0**   **8.9**
  ---------- -------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ----------

  ---------- ----------------------------------------------------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
    Model                            Loss                              SG          LS          SM          BA          SG          OS          SM          BA          SG         LS         SM         BC         SG         JS         SM        BZ
              w/o Fq. \[eq:3dagwn\_recin\] \[eq:3dagan\_wttrsdv\]     97.97       87.92       84.62       83.65       97.93       86.21       81.11       82.21       20.2     **10.6**   **7.8**      14.1       43.8       20.4       27.2      18.3
                         w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_fecpn\]                 99.28       92.95       93.17     **94.86**     98.87       90.79       89.50     **93.82**   **17.6**     17.5       13.8       11.9     **26.6**     18.1       15.0      11.4
   (ResNet)             w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagai\_ettr
.3 28.7 40.9 49.2 43.3 36.8 real-a 84.25 97.31 69.27 80.70 33.9 **12.5** 11.5 Ours **99.37** **94.69** **93.35** **99.10** **93.04** **91.64** **18.5** **12.6** **13.0** **10.3** 29.7 **11.0** **8.9** ---------- -------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ----------------------------------------------------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- --------- Model Loss SG LS SM BA SG LS SM BA SG LS BA SG LS SM BA w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_recon\] 97.97 87.92 84.62 83.65 86.21 81.11 82.21 20.2 **10.6** 14.1 20.4 27.2 w/o \[eq:3dagan\_recon\] 92.95 93.17 **94.86** 90.79 89.50 **93.82** **17.6** 17.5 13.8 11.9 **26.6** 18.1 15.0 11.4 (ResNet) w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_attr
.3       28.7       40.9       49.2       43.3       36.8
              real-a     98.93       91.34       84.25       82.43       97.31       69.27       75.51       80.70       33.9     **12.5**   **12.7**   **9.1**    **19.8**     31.0       17.1       11.5
   (ResNet)    Ours    **99.37**   **94.69**   **94.56**   **93.35**   **99.10**   **93.04**   **91.49**   **91.64**   **18.5**   **12.6**   **13.0**   **10.3**     29.7     **10.9**   **11.0**   **8.9**
  ---------- -------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ----------

  ---------- ----------------------------------------------------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                
    Model                            Loss                              Sg          LS          SM          BA          SG          Ls          SM          BA          sG         Ls         SM         bA         sG         LS         sM        BA
              W/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_recON\] \[eq:3dAgan\_attradv\]     97.97       87.92       84.62       83.65       97.93       86.21       81.11       82.21       20.2     **10.6**   **7.8**      14.1       43.8       20.4       27.2      18.3
                         w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_Recon\]                 99.28       92.95       93.17     **94.86**     98.87       90.79       89.50     **93.82**   **17.6**     17.5       13.8       11.9     **26.6**     18.1       15.0      11.4
   (reSnet)             w/O eq. \[Eq:3dagAn\_attr
.3       28.7       40.9      49.2     43 .3    36.8 
            real -a     98.93       91. 34    84. 2 5     82.43  97 .3 1   69 .27     75.51        80. 70     33.9   ** 12.5**   * *12 .7**   **9.1 **   **1 9. 8**     3 1.0       17.1      11.5
   ( Re s Net)  Ours ** 99.3 7**   **94.69** ** 9 4.56**   **93. 35**  * * 99 . 1 0**   **93.04** **91. 4 9**   * * 91 . 6 4 ** **18.5**   * *12.6**   * * 13. 0**  ** 10. 3 **    29.7    * *10.9**   * *11. 0**   **8 .9**
------- - -- ---- ---- - --- --- ---- -- -- --- -- - - - - -- --- - ---  ------- -- --  ---- ---- - - - ---- --- ----  ---- ------- ----- --- ---- --- ----- - --- ---- -- - --- ------ - --- -- ----- --------- - -- ----------- -- --- --  ---- - -----
 --- -------  ------ - --- -- - - - -- ------------------ -- - - -- -------- ---- - - -- -- - ---- --- -- --- ---- - ----- ---- -- -------- - ---- - -- -- -- ---- -- ------- --- --- --- - - ---- ------------- -- -- - ------- ------ - --- --------- -  - - - -- - ----  -- -------- -- ---- - ------- - -- --                                                                                                                                                                                           
                                                                                                                                                                                    
   Mo del                     L o s s                    SG       LS         SM        BA           SG     LS      SM       BA         SG       L S        SM       BA       SG       LS         SM       B A
          w/o  Eq. \[e q:3dagan\ _ recon \ ]\[eq: 3da gan\_a tt rad v\]    97. 9 7     87.92     84 .62     83.65        97.93       86.2 1      81. 11      82. 21    20.2    ** 10.6**   * *7. 8**      14 . 1      4 3 .8      20 .4     27.2   1 8 . 3                  w /o Eq.  \[e q:3dagan\_recon\]                99 . 2 8    92. 95        93.17   ** 9 4 .86**   98.87      90.79    89. 50    **93. 82**  * * 17 . 6**    17 .5      13. 8    11.9  * *26.6* *   18.1      1 5 .0   11.4
   (ResNe t)        w /o Eq .\[eq:3d a gan\ _attr
.3 _ _   28.7_ __ __40.9  _  _ 49.2  _  __43.3       36.8
      __ ___  real-a  _  98.93  _ _  91.34     __84.25  _    82.43    _  97.31   _  _69.27__   _ 75.51    _  80.70   _   33.9   _ **12.5**   **12.7** _ **9.1**   _**19.8** _   31.0 _  _ _17.1  _    11.5
 _ (ResNet) _  Ours   _**99.37**_  **94.69**___**94.56** _ **93.35** __**99.10** __**93.04**   **91.49**  _**91.64**_  **18.5**   **12.6** _ **13.0**  _**10.3**_   _29.7    _**10.9**   **11.0**  _**8.9**
 _---------- --------_----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ---------- ----------_---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ----------

 _---------- ----------------------------------------------------- ----------- -----------_----------- -----------_-----------_----------- ----------- -----------_----------_---------- ----------_---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------
  _ _     _   __     _     _    ___    _     _  _      __     __     ___    _     _        _  _    ___         _ _  _         _      _          _       _      _   __      ____  _  _  _ _  _ _  __                 _     _    __  _   _       _
        __ _   _ _ _  _ _ _ _      __        ____  _  _  _  __     _  _   _         _                _ _   _ __     _ _       __           ___  __     _____     _      __    _ __   _   _          __ ____   _              __    _     __   _ 
    Model  _    _   _                Loss    _    _    _  __  _   _    SG   _      LS          SM _      _ BA _ _      SG  _       LS   _      SM       __ BA    _     SG_   _   _LS_  _ _   SM_   _    BA   _  _  SG        _LS         SM        BA
   _  __      w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_recon\] \[eq:3dagan\_attradv\]    _97.97 _     87.92   _   84.62    ___83.65   __  97.93  _   _86.21 _     81.11 _ _   82.21_    _ 20.2    _**10.6**_  **7.8**   _ _14.1_ _ __ 43.8 _ _ __20.4 _ __ _27.2 __   18.3
   _  _     _     __ _   w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_recon\]    _     _ _   _99.28   _ _ 92.95__     93.17 _   **94.86**     98.87 _ __  90.79       89.50 _   **93.82**_  **17.6** _   17.5_ _ _  13.8    ___11.9     **26.6**   _ 18.1    _  15.0_ __  11.4
_ _(ResNet)     _ __    w/o Eq. \[eq:3dagan\_attr