 system weakly bound (1.475 MeV) to breaking up as $\alpha$+d, it is not obvious that a two-body Lee-Suzuki transformation would treat the relevant Jacobi coordinate responsible for the dominant energy dependence. This should be explored.\
$\bullet$ I believe the conclusions about the CG expansion will apply to other effective interactions. For example, V-low-k [@achim], a soft potential obtained by integrating out high-momentum states, is derived in a plane-wave basis, where $T$ is diagonal. Thus it should be analogous to our CG interaction, requiring a similar renormalization when embedded into a HO SM space. It would be interesting to test this conclusion.

Summary
=======

These results show that the effective interaction in the HO SM must have a very sharp dependence on the binding energy, defined as the energy of the bound state relative to the first open channel. This is typically 0 to 10 MeV for the bound states of most nuclei (and 2.22 MeV for the deuteron ground state explored here). Once this energy dependence is identified, the set of effective interaction matrix elements can be represented quite well by a CG expansion, and the results for successive LO, NLO, and NNLO calculations improve systematically.

This result suggests that the explicit energy dependence of the BH equation is almost entirely due to $QT$ – though this inference, based on the behavior of matrix elements between states with different number of HO quanta, must be tested in a case where multiple bound states exist.

We also presented a simple redefinition of the gradients associated with CG expansions, viewing the expansion as one around a momentum scale $\sim 1/b$. This definition removes operator mixing, making NNLO and higher-order fits very simple. The expansion then becomes one in nodal quantum numbers, with the coefficients of the expansion related to Talmi integrals, generalized for nonlocal interactions.

While our exploration here has been based on “data" obtained from an exact BH calculation of the effective interaction for the $av18$ potential, this raises the question, is such a potential necessary to the SM? That is, now that the success of an NNLO description of $Q$-space contributions is established, could one start with $PHP$ and determine the coefficients for such a potential directly from data, without knowledge of matrix elements of $H$ outside of $P$? I believe the answer is yes, even in cases (like the deuteron) when insufficient information is available from
system weakly bound (1.475 MeV) to breaking up as $ \alpha$+d, it is not obvious that a two - body Lee - Suzuki transformation would regale the relevant Jacobi coordinate creditworthy for the dominant energy addiction. This should be explored.\ 
 $ \bullet$ I believe the conclusion about the CG expansion will apply to other effective interaction. For example, V - abject - k [ @achim ], a soft electric potential obtained by integrating out high - momentum states, is derive in a plane - wave footing, where $ T$ is diagonal. therefore it should be analogous to our CG interaction, want a similar renormalization when embedded into a HO SM distance. It would be interesting to test this conclusion. 

 Summary 
 = = = = = = = 

 These consequence show that the effective interaction in the HO samarium must have a very sharp dependence on the binding energy, define as the energy of the bound state relative to the first clear channel. This is typically 0 to 10 MeV for the bound states of most nuclei (and 2.22 MeV for the deuteron ground state explored here). Once this energy dependence is identified, the stage set of effective interaction matrix elements can be represented quite well by a CG expansion, and the resultant role for consecutive LO, NLO, and NNLO calculation improve systematically. 

 This result suggests that the explicit energy dependence of the BH equation is about entirely due to $ QT$ – though this inference, based on the behavior of matrix elements between states with different number of HO quanta, must be tested in a case where multiple bound country exist. 

 We also salute a simple redefinition of the gradients associated with CG expansions, viewing the expansion as one around a momentum plate $ \sim 1 / b$. This definition removes operator mixing, making NNLO and higher - order fits very simple. The expansion then becomes one in nodal quantum number, with the coefficients of the expansion relate to Talmi integrals, generalize for nonlocal interactions. 

 While our exploration here has been establish on “ data " obtain from an exact bohrium calculation of the effective interaction for the $ av18 $ potential, this raises the question, is such a likely necessary to the SM? That is, now that the success of an NNLO description of $ Q$-space contributions is established, could one start with $ PHP$ and determine the coefficients for such a potential directly from data, without knowledge of matrix component of $ H$ outside of $ P$? I believe the answer is yes, even in case (like the deuteron) when insufficient information is available from
 sydtem weakly bound (1.475 MeV) tu breaking up as $\alpha$+v, it is not obvkous that a two-body Lee-Suzukm trqnsfoemation would treat thd relevann Jacobi xoorvinate responsible for tmz domjkant znxrgy dependence. This shound be explored.\
$\tuulzt$ I believe the conclusions about tre CG ecpwnsion will apkly tp othsg tffective interactions. For exampls, V-low-k [@achim], a soft potential obtained by intfgrahing out high-momenhum states, us dqeived in a puane-wave basis, where $T$ is diagonal. Thus it should be xnaloyous to our CT ijjeraction, rewuirigg a similar renormanizatiom when embeddec iito q HO SM space. It woulv be interesting to jest this wouclusion.

Summary
=======

These eewults shof thxr tfe tffxctjve inherection in tge HO SM muwt have a very shark dqirndence on tge binqigg energy, defined as the energy of the touhd state relative to thw first open channel. Jhis is ty[ically 0 to 10 MeV for the bound states of most nucnei (aid 2.22 MtV for gye deuteron ground state explored here). Once thif emeggy dependence is identified, tje fet of effectkve incsrzction matrix elemfnts cag be eepresenttd quote well by a CG expansion, qnd the resujrs for successive PO, NLO, and UNLO cslculstions improve systematncally.

Fhis result suggests ghat the explicig ekercy dependence of the BH eqtation is almpst entkreli due tj $QT$ – thouhh thlv inference, based ln thg behaeior of mahrix elements between states wivi different nombar mf HO qucnta, mmst be tested ig a case where multipje bojnd states exist.

Wx also presegted a simple tedefinition mf the gwadiwnts associxged with CG exlansions, nitwing the wxpansion as one avound z momentum scalz $\wim 1/b$. This defimitkon rvmotes o[arator mixinc, mayine NNLO and higher-ifder fits very simple. Tha exlansion then becomrs one in bodal quwntum numbers, with the coefficitnts oh the xxpansoon related to Talmi integrals, geheralized fov nonlocal ineeragtiogs.

While oux exploration here has been based on “date" obtained from an exacr BH calculation of uhe effective intewaction fmr the $av18$ potential, rhis raises the qmestion, is such a potehtial tecesdary to the SM? That is, now that the success of an NNLO description of $Q$-spqce coitwibutions ia esyablivhzd, eould oge svact with $PHP$ and dvtermine the coefficients for surh a potendicl directly from data, without kvowledge of mxtrix elements of $H$ outsjde of $P$? I believe the answer is yes, evrn in cases (like the deuberon) wheb inshfficivht information is avsilablz from
system weakly bound (1.475 MeV) to breaking $\alpha$+d, is not that a two-body relevant coordinate responsible for dominant energy dependence. should be explored.\ $\bullet$ I believe conclusions about the CG expansion will apply to other effective interactions. For example, [@achim], a soft potential obtained by integrating out high-momentum states, is derived in plane-wave where is Thus it should be analogous to our CG interaction, requiring a similar renormalization when embedded into HO SM space. It would be interesting to this conclusion. Summary ======= results show that the effective in HO SM have very dependence on the energy, defined as the energy of the bound state relative to the first open channel. This is 0 to for the states most (and 2.22 MeV deuteron ground state explored here). Once is identified, the set of effective interaction matrix can be quite well by a CG expansion, the results for successive LO, NLO, and NNLO improve systematically. This result suggests that the explicit energy dependence of the BH equation is due to $QT$ – this inference, based the of elements states with number of HO quanta, must be tested in a case where bound states exist. We also presented a simple redefinition of associated CG expansions, viewing expansion as one around momentum $\sim 1/b$. This definition mixing, NNLO very The then becomes one in quantum numbers, with the coefficients the expansion related to interactions. While our exploration here has been based “data" obtained from an exact BH calculation the effective interaction for the $av18$ potential, this raises the question, is a potential the SM? That is, now that the success an NNLO description of contributions is established, could one start with $PHP$ and the for such potential directly from without knowledge of elements of $H$ $P$? I the is cases (like the deuteron) when insufficient is from
 system weakly bound (1.475 MeV) to breAking up as $\aLpha$+d, It iS noT oBvioUs thAt a two-body Lee-SUZuki Transformation would treAt the ReLEvanT jaCobi cOordinaTE rESPonSiBlE foR tHE dOminaNt eNergy dePendence. ThIs sHoUld be exploreD.\
$\BuLlet$ I belieVe tHe conclusionS abOut the cG ExpANsion WilL applY to othER effecTive interAcTIons. FoR Example, v-LOw-K [@achIm], a soft potential oBTaINed by integratiNg out hIgH-MoMENtuM stAtes, is deriVeD in a pLAne-wave BAsIS, WHerE $t$ is diagonal. ThUs it should bE AnaLogous To Our cg interActioN, rEQuiRing a similaR renOrmalizatIon wheN EmbeddeD Into a HO sM spacE. It WouLd be INtErEstInG To tESt ThiS ConClusion.

SUmMaRy
=======

TheSe reSULTS shoW thAt thE effeCtive interactIon In thE hO Sm must Have a Very ShArp dePendenCe on tHe Binding energy, deFineD as the eneRgy Of The BoUnd stATe relaTivE to The firsT open chANneL. THIS Is Typically 0 to 10 MeV for tHe BOUnD states oF most nUClEi (ANd 2.22 MeV for ThE deUterON GrounD staTE eXplored hEre). OncE ThIs Energy dEpEndencE iS idEntIfied, THe seT of effEctive inTeracTIon matrix elemeNTs can be represENtED QuITe weLl bY a CG expansiOn, anD The rEsulTS fOr sUCcessIve LO, nLo, AnD nNLO calculations impRoVe systEmatiCally.

This resuLt suggests THAT the explIcit ENeRGy dependence of The BH Equation is ALmost entIrely Due to $QT$ – tHough this INFerence, bAseD on The BehAVIoR of matrix elemENTs beTwEen statEs wIth diffEreNt nUmbEr oF Ho quanta, muSt be testEd In A cAsE whEre muLTiple bouNd StaTeS exIst.

We ALso preSenteD a siMpLe REdeFinitioN Of THE graDiEnTs asSocIaTed wiTh CG EXpaNsions, vIewing the ExpANsioN aS oNe arounD a momentum scaLe $\Sim 1/b$. This deFiNitIon remOVEs operatOr mixing, making NNLO and hiGHer-ordeR fiTs verY simPle. The expAnsIon theN beCOmes onE in nodAl quaNtUm nUMBers, wITH tHe cOeFficients oF THe eXpansIoN relAted to TAlmi integrals, generALizEd for nonlocal IntEracTIOnS.

WhILe OUr eXpLOraTIOn here has been baSed on “data" oBtAInEd from an exACt Bh cAlculatIon of thE effeCTive intEraction fOr the $av18$ poTeNtiaL, THis Raises the qUestion, iS such a potENtial NEcEssarY to The SM? THaT is, Now thAt the sUCceSs of aN NNLO dEsCriptiOn of $Q$-SpAce contrIbutions is established, coUld one Start WitH $PHP$ and deTerMIne The coeffiCienTs for such a PotEntIal diRecTLy froM datA, WiThoUT knowLedgE Of matrix eLEmEntS OF $H$ Outside of $P$? I BELIevE the aNswER is yes, Even In cases (like the deuTEron) when insuffIcieNT InfOrmATion Is Available from
 system weakly bound (1.47 5 MeV) tobreak ing  up  a s $\ alph a$+d, it is no t  obv ious that a two-body L ee-Su zu k i tr a ns forma tion wo u ld t rea tth e r el e va nt Ja cob i coord inate resp ons ib le for the d o mi nant energ y d ependence. T his  shoul dbee xplor ed. \
$\b ullet$ I beli eve the c on c lusion s  aboutt h eCG e xpansion will app l yt o other effect ive in te r ac t i ons . F or example ,V-low - k [@ach i m] , a  so f t potential o btained byi nte gratin gout high-m oment um sta tes, is der ived  in a pla ne-wav e  basis, where $ T$ isdia gon al.T hu sitsh o uld be  an a log ous to o ur  C G int erac t i o n , re qui ring  a si milar renorma liz atio n  wh en em bedde d in to  a HO  SM sp ace.It  would be inter esti ng to tes t t hi s c on clusi o n.

Su mma ry======= 

These res ul t s sh ow that the effect iv e in teractio n in t h eHO SM mustha vea ve r y  shar p de p en dence on  the b i nd in g energ y,  defin ed  as  th e ene r gy o f thebound st ate r e lative to thef irst open cha n ne l .  T h is i s t ypically 0to 1 0  MeV  for th e b o und s tates  o f  m o st nuclei (and 2.22  M eV for  thedeuteron grou nd state e x p l ored her e).O nc e  this energy d epend ence is id e ntified,  theset of e ffectivei n teractio n m atr ixele m e nt s can be repr e s ente dquite w ell  by a C G e xpa nsi on,  a nd the re sults fo rsu cc es siv e LO, NLO, and  N NLO  c alc ulati o ns imp rovesyst em at i cal ly.

Th i sr e sult  s ug gest s t ha t the  exp l ici t energ y depende nce of t he  B H equat ion is almost  e ntirely du eto$QT$ – t hough th is inference, based ont he beha vio r ofmatr ix elemen tsbetwee n s t ates w ith di ffere nt  nu m b er of H Oqua nt a, must be t est ed in  a  cas e where  multiple bound st a tes  exist.

We a lso  pre s e nt eda  s i mpl er ede f i nition of the g radients a ss o ci ated withC G e xp ansions , viewi ng th e  expans ion as on e aroundamome n t umscale $\si m 1/b$.This defi n ition re moves  op erator  m ixi ng, m akingN NLO  andhigher -o rder f its v er y simple . The expansion then be comesone i n n odal quan tum num bers, wit h th e coeffici ent s o f the  ex p ansio n re l at edt o Tal mi i n tegrals,g en era l i ze d for nonlo c a l  in terac tio n s.

Wh ileour exploration h e re has been ba sedo n  “d ata "  obt ai ned from an ex act  B H calculat io n of the ef fectivein t eract ion fo r the$av18$p o te n tial,this  ra ises theque st i on, issu ch a pote ntia lnecess ary to theS M ? That is, now t hat t h e  succ e ssof an  N NLO des c ript ion of $Q$ -space cont ributi onsis es tablish ed , coul d o ne  start wit h  $PHP$ an d det ermineth e co eff icient s fo r sucha po te nti al direct l y  f r om  d a ta,  wit houtkn owle dge of ma t rix elem ent s  of $H$  o uts i d e of $ P $? I  believe t heanswe r is yes, ev e n in ca s es (l ike th e deut eron) w h enin suffici ent i nformatio n is avai l abl efrom 
 system_weakly bound_(1.475 MeV) to breaking_up as_$\alpha$+d,_it is_not_obvious that a_two-body Lee-Suzuki transformation_would treat the relevant_Jacobi coordinate responsible_for_the dominant energy dependence. This should be explored.\
$\bullet$ I believe the conclusions about the_CG_expansion will_apply_to_other effective interactions. For example,_V-low-k [@achim], a soft potential_obtained by_integrating out high-momentum states, is derived in a_plane-wave_basis, where $T$_is diagonal. Thus it should be analogous to our_CG interaction, requiring a similar renormalization_when embedded into_a_HO_SM space. It would_be interesting to test this conclusion.

Summary
=======

These_results show that the effective interaction_in the HO SM must have a_very sharp dependence on the binding_energy, defined as the energy_of the_bound state relative to the_first open channel._This is_typically 0 to_10 MeV for the bound states_of most nuclei_(and 2.22 MeV for the deuteron_ground_state explored here)._Once_this_energy dependence_is identified, the_set_of effective_interaction_matrix elements can be represented quite_well_by a CG expansion, and the results_for successive LO, NLO,_and_NNLO calculations improve systematically.

This_result suggests that the explicit_energy dependence of the BH equation_is almost_entirely due_to $QT$ – though this inference, based on the behavior of_matrix elements between states with different_number of HO quanta,_must be_tested_in a case_where_multiple bound_states exist.

We also presented a simple redefinition_of the_gradients associated with CG expansions, viewing_the expansion as one_around_a momentum scale $\sim 1/b$. This_definition removes operator mixing, making NNLO_and higher-order fits very simple._The_expansion_then becomes one in nodal_quantum numbers, with the coefficients of_the expansion related_to Talmi integrals, generalized for nonlocal interactions.

While_our_exploration here has been based on_“data"_obtained from an exact BH calculation_of_the_effective interaction for the $av18$_potential, this raises the question, is_such a potential necessary to the SM? That is,_now that the_success of an NNLO description_of_$Q$-space_contributions is established, could one start with $PHP$ and determine_the coefficients_for such a_potential directly from data, without knowledge of matrix elements of_$H$ outside of $P$? I believe the_answer is yes, even in cases (like the deuteron) when insufficient_information is available from