 the Kitaev case has been steadily increasing over the past 20 years encompassing Mott-Hubbard organic materials and deep Mott insulators in various two and three dimensional geometries [@Lacroix-Springer; @Balents; @Mendels-JPSJ; @Mendels-academy; @Zhou-KanodaRMP]. Among them, the kagome lattice is a prominent 2D example where frustrated triangles only share corners. This reduced lattice connectivity, the frustration generated by nearest neighbor Heisenberg antiferromagnetic interactions, and the quantum character of $S=1/2$ spins indeed conspire to stabilize such a highly entangled QSL state in herbertsmithite [@Shores], ZnCu$_3$(OH)$_6$Cl$_2$ (fig. 1). It emerged as the first kagome based antiferromagnet featuring a perfect equilateral triangular geometry, dominant nearest neighbor Heisenberg antiferromagnetic interactions, $J\sim180-190$ K, and not showing any ordering [@Mendels-musr] but rather an unconventional excitations continuum [@Han-neutrons]. It is recognized as the kagome spin liquid candidate approaching so far the best the ideal model of an Heisenberg AntiFerromagnetic Hamiltonian on the Kagome lattice (KHAF) [@Norman], now available in single crystal form. Its discovery triggered a burst of experimental activity, on one hand with the materials search for Cu$^{2+}$-based $S=1/2$ variants obtained either from a change of anions [@Barlowite; @BarlowiteNMR; @Brochantite] or replacement of Zn$^{2+}$ cations [@PuphalGa; @PuphalY; @ChineseY; @BartelemyY] and Li$^+$ intercalation in view of charge doping [@McQueen], and on the other hand with V$^{4+}$-based $S=1/2$ [@VOF; @Orain] QSL candidates.

On the theory side which was also revived by the discovery of herbertsmithite, the issue of the ground state of the KHAF, despite its apparently simple form, has been lacking for long a definite conclusion. The main reason lies in the existence of a proliferation of states close-by in energy which have led to theoretical proposals spanning from valence bond crystals [@Singh] - made of local spin dimers- to spin liquids,
the Kitaev case has been steadily increasing over the past 20 years encompassing Mott - Hubbard constituent fabric and deep Mott insulators in diverse two and three dimensional geometry   [ @Lacroix - Springer; @Balents; @Mendels - JPSJ; @Mendels - academy; @Zhou - KanodaRMP ]. Among them, the kagome lattice is a prominent 2D example where defeated triangles entirely share corner. This reduced lattice connectivity, the frustration beget by nearest neighbor Heisenberg antiferromagnetic interactions, and the quantum quality of $ S=1/2 $ tailspin indeed conspire to stabilize such a highly embroiled QSL state in herbertsmithite   [ @Shores ], ZnCu$_3$(OH)$_6$Cl$_2 $ (figure.   1). It emerge as the first kagome based antiferromagnet featuring a arrant equilateral triangular geometry, dominant nearest neighbor Heisenberg antiferromagnetic interaction, $ J\sim180 - 190 $   K, and not showing any order   [ @Mendels - musr ] but rather an improper excitations continuum   [ @Han - neutrons ]. It is recognized as the kagome spin fluent candidate approaching so far the best the ideal model of an Heisenberg AntiFerromagnetic Hamiltonian on the Kagome wicket (KHAF)   [ @Norman ], nowadays available in single crystal form. Its discovery triggered a burst of experimental activity, on one hand with the materials search for Cu$^{2+}$-based $ S=1/2 $ variants obtain either from a change of anions   [ @Barlowite; @BarlowiteNMR; @Brochantite ] or substitute of Zn$^{2+}$ cation   [ @PuphalGa; @PuphalY; @ChineseY; @BartelemyY ] and Li$^+$ intercalation in view of charge doping   [ @McQueen ], and on the other hand with V$^{4+}$-based $ S=1/2 $   [ @VOF; @Orain ] QSL candidates. 

 On the theory slope which was also revived by the discovery of herbertsmithite, the issue of the ground state of the KHAF, despite its apparently bare form, has been lacking for long a definite conclusion. The main rationality lies in the being of a proliferation of states close - by in energy which have led to theoretical proposals cross from valence bond crystals   [ @Singh ] - made of local spin dimers- to spin liquids,
 thf Kitaev case has been sueadily increasiny over vhe pasf 20 years encompassing Mott-Hubbard orjanix mattgials and deep Mott ivsulators in variius uwo and three dimxhsional geomefvies [@Lcccoix-Springer; @Bakents; @Mendals-JPSJ; @Mendelv-azabemy; @Zhou-KanodaRMP]. Among them, the kadome laytlce is a promigent 2Q exzmple where frustrated triangles ohly shage corners. This rrduced lattice connectivitj, thf frustration genegated by neqrese neighbor Heksenberg antiferromagngtic interactions, and the quantuo chaxacter of $S=1/2$ spind indeed conwpire to stabilizc such d highlu entangled QSK svate in herbertsmithite [@Shmres], ZnCu$_3$(OH)$_6$Cl$_2$ (fig. 1). Yt emergeg cs the first kagome bqswd anjifersomaebet feztnrihg a pfrfxct equilatsral triangylar geometry, dominsne nearest neiggbor Hqifenberg antiferromagnetic interactions, $B\sij180-190$ K, and not showing any irdering [@Mendels-musr] bot rather wn unconventional excitations continuum [@Han-neutronv]. It ms reeignizde ws the kagome spin liquid candidate approachigf xo far the best bhe ideal model of aj Ngisenberg AntiWerromcfnstic Hamiltonian oj the Kwgome lattice (HHAF) [@Morman], now available in sintle crystal yorn. Its discovery trnggered a buxst of expetimental activity, on onz hand with the mwterials adarch for Cu$^{2+}$-basea $S=1/2$ vdriants obtained either frjm a chanje of anions [@Carlpwite; @FarlowiteNLR; @Brochantite] or replacfment ox Zn$^{2+}$ catiojs [@PuphalGa; @PuphalY; @ChineseY; @BarvxlemyY] and Li$^+$ ittegcalation in vlew of charge djping [@McQueen], aud on thz othef hand witg V$^{4+}$-basev $S=1/2$ [@VOF; @Orain] QSL candidatad.

On the theocy side wrich was also rdxived by the doscovery of herbertwmithite, the issue of fhe ground statz if the KHAF, deslitd ies a'paregdly simple fmrm, fas neen uacking for uong a definite conclusimn. Tge main reason liex ln the exustence jf a proliferstion of states cllse-by in enerby rhich have led to theoretical lroposals spwnning from dalekce fond crystcls [@Singh] - made of local spin dimers- to s'in liquids,
the Kitaev case has been steadily increasing past years encompassing organic materials and two three dimensional geometries @Balents; @Mendels-JPSJ; @Mendels-academy; Among them, the kagome lattice is prominent 2D example where frustrated triangles only share corners. This reduced lattice connectivity, frustration generated by nearest neighbor Heisenberg antiferromagnetic interactions, and the quantum character of spins conspire stabilize a highly entangled QSL state in herbertsmithite [@Shores], ZnCu$_3$(OH)$_6$Cl$_2$ (fig. 1). It emerged as the first based antiferromagnet featuring a perfect equilateral triangular geometry, nearest neighbor Heisenberg antiferromagnetic $J\sim180-190$ K, and not showing ordering but rather unconventional continuum It is recognized the kagome spin liquid candidate approaching so far the best the ideal model of an Heisenberg AntiFerromagnetic on the (KHAF) [@Norman], available single form. Its discovery burst of experimental activity, on one materials search for Cu$^{2+}$-based $S=1/2$ variants obtained either a change anions [@Barlowite; @BarlowiteNMR; @Brochantite] or replacement Zn$^{2+}$ cations [@PuphalGa; @PuphalY; @ChineseY; @BartelemyY] and Li$^+$ in view of charge doping [@McQueen], and on the other hand with V$^{4+}$-based $S=1/2$ [@VOF; candidates. On the theory which was also by discovery herbertsmithite, issue of ground state of the KHAF, despite its apparently simple form, has lacking for long a definite conclusion. The main reason lies existence a proliferation of close-by in energy which led theoretical proposals spanning from crystals - spin to liquids,
 the Kitaev case has been steadIly increasIng ovEr tHe pAsT 20 yeaRs enCompassing Mott-hUbbaRd organic materials and dEep MoTt INsulAToRs in vArious tWO aND ThrEe DiMenSiONaL geomEtrIes [@LacrOix-SpringeR; @BaLeNts; @Mendels-JPsj; @MEndels-acadEmy; @zhou-KanodaRMp]. AmOng theM, tHe kAGome lAttIce is A promiNEnt 2D exAmple wherE fRUstratED triangLES oNly sHare corners. This reDUcED lattice connecTivity, ThE FrUSTraTioN generated By NeareST neighbOR HEISEnbERg antiferromaGnetic interACtiOns, and ThE quANtum chAractEr OF $S=1/2$ sPins indeed cOnspIre to stabIlize sUCh a highLY entangLed QSL StaTe iN herBErTsMitHiTE [@ShOReS], ZncU$_3$(OH)$_6$cl$_2$ (fig. 1). It eMeRgEd as tHe fiRST KAgomE baSed aNtifeRromagnet featUriNg a pERfeCt equIlateRal tRiAngulAr geomEtry, dOmInant nearest neiGhboR HeisenbeRg aNtIfeRrOmagnETic intEraCtiOns, $J\sim180-190$ k, and not SHowInG ANY oRdering [@Mendels-musr] BuT RAtHer an uncOnventIOnAl EXcitatioNs ConTinuUM [@han-neUtroNS]. IT is recogNized aS ThE kAgome spIn Liquid CaNdiDatE apprOAchiNg so faR the best The idEAl model of an HeiSEnberg AntiFerROmAGNeTIc HaMilTonian on the kagoME latTice (khAf) [@NoRMan], noW avaiLaBLe IN single crystal form. ITs DiscovEry trIggered a burst Of experimeNTAL activitY, on oNE hANd with the materIals sEarch for Cu$^{2+}$-BAsed $S=1/2$ varIants Obtained Either froM A Change of AniOns [@barLowITE; @BArlowiteNMR; @BrOCHantItE] or replAceMent of ZN$^{2+}$ caTioNs [@PUphAlga; @PuphalY; @chineseY; @baRtElEmYY] aNd Li$^+$ iNTercalatIoN in ViEw oF charGE dopinG [@McQuEen], aNd On THe oTher hanD WiTH v$^{4+}$-basEd $s=1/2$ [@VoF; @OrAin] qSl candIdatES.

On The theoRy side whiCh wAS alsO rEvIved by tHe discovery of HeRbertsmithItE, thE issue OF The grounD state of the KHAF, despite iTS appareNtlY simpLe foRm, has been LacKing foR loNG a defiNite coNclusIoN. ThE MAin reASOn LieS iN the existeNCE of A prolIfEratIon of stAtes close-by in energY WhiCh have led to thEorEticAL PrOpoSAlS SpaNnINg fROM valence bond cryStals [@Singh] - MaDE oF local spin DImeRs- To spin lIquids,
 the Kitaev case has beensteadily i ncrea sin g o ve r th e pa st 20 years en c ompa ssing Mott-Hubbard org anicma t eria l sand d eep Mot t  i n s ula to rs  in  v a ri ous t woand thr ee dimensi ona lgeometries [ @ La croix-Spri nge r; @Balents;  @M endels -J PSJ ;  @Men del s-aca demy;@ Zhou-K anodaRMP] .A mong t h em, the k ag omelattice is a prom i ne n t 2D example w here f ru s tr a t edtri angles onl yshare corners .  T h i s  re d uced latticeconnectivit y , t he fru st rat i on gen erate db y n earest neig hbor  Heisenbe rg ant i ferroma g netic i nterac tio ns,  and th equa nt u m c h ar act e r o f $S=1/2 $sp ins i ndee d c o nspi reto s tabil ize such a hi ghl y en t ang led Q SL st atein  herb ertsmi thite  [ @Shores], ZnCu$ _3$( OH)$_6$Cl $_2 $(fi g.  1).I t emer ged  as  the fi rst kag o meba s e d  a ntiferromagnet fea tu r i ng  a perfe ct equ i la te r al trian gu lar  geo m e try,domi n an t neares t neig h bo rHeisenb er g anti fe rro mag netic inte ractio ns, $J\s im180 - 190$ K, and no t  showing anyo rd e r in g  [@M end els-musr] b ut r a ther  anu nc onv e ntion al ex ci t at i ons continuum [@Han -n eutron s]. I t is recogniz ed as thek a g ome spin  liq u id candidate appr oachi ng so fart he bestthe i deal mod el of anH e isenberg  An tiF err oma g n et ic Hamiltonia n on t he  Kagome  la ttice ( KHA F)[@N orm an ], now av ailablein  s in gl e c rysta l  form. I ts  di sc ove ry tr i ggered  a bu rstof  e x per imental ac t i vity ,on  one  ha nd  with  the mat erialssearch fo r C u $^{2 +} $- based $ S=1/2$ varian ts  obtainedei the r from a  changeof anions [@Barlowite;@ Barlowi teN MR; @ Broc hantite]orreplac eme n t of Z n$^{2+ }$ ca ti ons [ @Puph a l Ga ; @ Pu phalY; @Ch i n ese Y; @B ar tele myY] an d Li$^+$ intercala t ion  in view of c har ge d o p in g [ @ Mc Q uee n] ,  an d on the other ha nd with V$ ^{ 4 +} $-based $S = 1/2 $[@VOF;@Orain]  QSLc andidat es.

On t he theory  s idew h ich  was alsorevivedby the di s cover y  o f her ber tsmith it e,the i ssue o f  th e gro und st at e of t he KH AF , despit e its apparently simple  form,  hasbee n lacking  fo r  lo ng a defi nite  conclusio n.The  main  re a son l iesi nthe exist ence of a prol i fe rat i o nof states c l o s e-b y inene r gy whi ch h ave led to theore t ical proposals  spa n n ing  fr o m va le nce bond cryst als  [ @ S ingh] -ma de of local  spin di me r s- to  spinliquid s,
 the_Kitaev case_has been steadily increasing_over the_past_20 years_encompassing_Mott-Hubbard organic materials_and deep Mott_insulators in various two_and three dimensional_geometries [@Lacroix-Springer;_@Balents; @Mendels-JPSJ; @Mendels-academy; @Zhou-KanodaRMP]. Among them, the kagome lattice is a prominent 2D example_where_frustrated triangles_only_share_corners. This reduced lattice connectivity,_the frustration generated by nearest_neighbor Heisenberg_antiferromagnetic interactions, and the quantum character of $S=1/2$_spins_indeed conspire to_stabilize such a highly entangled QSL state in herbertsmithite [@Shores],_ZnCu$_3$(OH)$_6$Cl$_2$ (fig. 1). It emerged as the_first kagome based_antiferromagnet_featuring_a perfect equilateral triangular_geometry, dominant nearest neighbor Heisenberg antiferromagnetic_interactions, $J\sim180-190$ K, and not showing any_ordering [@Mendels-musr] but rather an unconventional excitations continuum [@Han-neutrons]._It is recognized as the kagome_spin liquid candidate approaching so_far the_best the ideal model of_an Heisenberg AntiFerromagnetic_Hamiltonian on_the Kagome lattice_(KHAF) [@Norman], now available in single crystal_form. Its discovery_triggered a burst of experimental activity,_on_one hand with_the_materials_search for_Cu$^{2+}$-based $S=1/2$ variants_obtained_either from_a_change of anions [@Barlowite; @BarlowiteNMR; @Brochantite] or_replacement_of Zn$^{2+}$ cations [@PuphalGa; @PuphalY; @ChineseY; @BartelemyY] and_Li$^+$ intercalation in view_of_charge doping [@McQueen], and on_the other hand with V$^{4+}$-based_$S=1/2$ [@VOF; @Orain] QSL candidates.

On the theory_side which_was also_revived by the discovery of herbertsmithite, the issue of the ground_state of the KHAF, despite its_apparently simple form, has_been lacking_for_long a definite_conclusion._The main_reason lies in the existence of a_proliferation of_states close-by in energy which have_led to theoretical proposals_spanning_from valence bond crystals [@Singh] - made_of local spin dimers- to spin_liquids,