\]) at $z=0.1$ (upper panel), $z=0.2$ (middle panel) and $z=0.5$ (lower panel) in a ${\Omega_{\rm M}}=0.28,\,{\Omega_{\rm\Lambda}}=0.72$ universe, which is what we will use subsequently. We have performed a number of simulations using a wide range of cosmological parameter-values and found the oscillation effect to depend only weakly on cosmology. The most dramatic effect is the strong variation of attenuation with photon energy.

Since the attenuation varies very rapidly with photon energy in a similar manner over a broad energy range, we expect the frequency dependence to wash out to large extent when doing broad-band photometry.

In Fig. \[fig:n\], we show the rest-frame $B$-band magnitude attenuation for Type Ia SNe due to photon-axion oscillations for three different values of the electron density, in the redshift interval $0<z<2$, using values for the other input parameters from Eq. \[eq:values\]. Each point represents the average value and the error bars the dispersion for ten different lines-of-sight. In the upper panel, we have used $n_{\rm e}=10^{-7}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$, in the middle panel $n_{\rm e}=5\times 10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$ and in the lower panel $n_{\rm e}=10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$. Note that the effect is not necessarily increasing with increasing redshift. This is due to the fact that we are studying the [*rest-frame*]{} $B$-band magnitude. Since the amplitude of the oscillations scales roughly as $(\omega /n_{\rm e})^2$ (see Eq. \[eq:rho11approx\]), we need this combination to be large at some point in order to get close to maximal mixing. If the plasma density is high, the photon energy will be redshifted to too low energies before the plasma density is diluted due to the expansion.

In Fig. \[fig:b\], the rest-frame $B$-band magnitude attenuation for Type Ia SNe for three different values of the intergalactic field strength is shown. Again, each point represents the average value and the error bars the dispersion for ten different lines-of-sight. In the upper panel, $B_{\
\ ]) at $ z=0.1 $ (upper panel), $ z=0.2 $ (middle panel) and $ z=0.5 $ (lower dialog box) in a $ { \Omega_{\rm M}}=0.28,\,{\Omega_{\rm\Lambda}}=0.72 $ population, which is what we will use subsequently. We have performed a numeral of simulation using a wide stove of cosmologic parameter - value and found the oscillation impression to depend only weakly on cosmology. The about dramatic effect is the strong variation of attenuation with photon energy. 

 Since the attenuation varies very rapidly with photon energy in a alike manner over a broad energy range, we have a bun in the oven the frequency dependence to wash out to large extent when doing wide - band photometry. 

 In Fig.   \[fig: n\ ], we show the rest - frame $ B$-band magnitude attenuation for Type Ia SNe due to photon - axion cycle for three different values of the electron density, in the redshift interval $ 0 < z<2 $, using values for the other input parameters from Eq.   \[eq: values\ ]. Each point represents the average value and the error bars the dispersion for ten different credit line - of - sight. In the upper panel, we have use $ n_{\rm e}=10^{-7}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3 $, in the center panel $ n_{\rm e}=5\times 10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3 $ and in the lower dialog box $ n_{\rm e}=10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$. Note that the effect is not necessarily increasing with increasing red shift. This is due to the fact that we are studying the [ * rest - frame * ] { } $ B$-band magnitude. Since the amplitude of the oscillations scales roughly as $ (\omega /n_{\rm e})^2 $ (see Eq.   \[eq: rho11approx\ ]), we need this combination to be large at some point in orderliness to catch close to maximal mixing. If the plasma density is high, the photon energy will be redshifted to excessively low energies before the plasma density is dilute due to the expansion. 

 In Fig.   \[fig: b\ ], the rest - frame $ B$-band magnitude attenuation for Type Ia SNe for three different value of the intergalactic field potency is shown. Again, each point represent the average value and the mistake bars the distribution for ten different lines - of - view. In the upper panel, $ B_{\
\]) at $z=0.1$ (upper panel), $z=0.2$ (middle kanel) and $z=0.5$ (lower panel) mn a ${\Omsga_{\rm M}}=0.28,\,{\Ooega_{\rm\Lambda}}=0.72$ universe, which ms wyat wt will use subsequevtly. We hwve perfirmev a number of simulations usinf a wndx range of cosmplogical pdrameter-values avd found the oscillation effect to de[end onky weakly on cosiolobr. Ths most dramatic effect is the strohg varietion of attenustion with photon energy.

Sijce hhe attenuation vagies very rqpidjt with photov energy in a similar janner over a broad energy rangd, we zxpect the drwquftcy dependeice to wash out to large eftent wnen doing broac-baid pyotometry.

In Fig. \[fig:n\], wx show the rest-frame $B$-band macnntude attenuation for Ttpe Id SNa dud to phktpn-zxion lscmllations fkr three didferent values of tne vkectron densjty, in tre redshift interval $0<z<2$, using values for ths other input parameterw from Eq. \[eq:values\]. Eacj point rqpresents the average value and the error bars tha dis'efsiin wir ten different lines-of-sight. In the upper panej, wt hsve used $n_{\rm e}=10^{-7}\,{\vm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$, in the middke psgel $n_{\rm e}=5\timer 10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$ znd in the lower pwnel $n_{\ri e}=10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$. Note thay the effect is not necessaeily increaspng qith increasing rebshift. This ns due to tne fact that we are stubying fhe [*rest-frale*]{} $B$-band jxgnitude. Since tfe sm[litude of the oscillationf scales coughky as $(\ooega /n_{\rm e})^2$ (see Eq. \[eq:rjo11appvmx\]), we need this colbinajion tm be large at some point in order to get rkose to maxikan mpxing. If che plssma density ys high, the phpton enzrgy wkll be redahifted to too low energies befmte the plasma density is eilured due go the expansipn.

In Fig. \[fpg:y\], the resr-frame $B$-band magnibude xftenuation for Cvpt Ua SNe for thrre aifsegenv valtas of the indergxlazyic fkeld strengbh ks snown. Again, each poind relresents the averabe value abd the ewror bars the dispersion for tej difherent linex-of-fight. In the upper panel, $B_{\
\]) at $z=0.1$ (upper panel), $z=0.2$ (middle $z=0.5$ panel) in ${\Omega_{\rm M}}=0.28,\,{\Omega_{\rm\Lambda}}=0.72$ universe, use We have performed number of simulations a wide range of cosmological parameter-values found the oscillation effect to depend only weakly on cosmology. The most dramatic is the strong variation of attenuation with photon energy. Since the attenuation varies rapidly photon in similar manner over a broad energy range, we expect the frequency dependence to wash out to extent when doing broad-band photometry. In Fig. \[fig:n\], show the rest-frame $B$-band attenuation for Type Ia SNe to oscillations for different of electron density, in redshift interval $0<z<2$, using values for the other input parameters from Eq. \[eq:values\]. Each point represents the value and bars the for different In the upper have used $n_{\rm e}=10^{-7}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$, in $n_{\rm e}=5\times 10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$ and in the lower $n_{\rm e}=10^{-8}\,{\rm Note that the effect is not increasing with increasing redshift. This is due to fact that we are studying the [*rest-frame*]{} $B$-band magnitude. Since the amplitude of the oscillations as $(\omega /n_{\rm e})^2$ Eq. \[eq:rho11approx\]), we this to large some point order to get close to maximal mixing. If the plasma density high, the photon energy will be redshifted to too low the density is diluted to the expansion. In \[fig:b\], rest-frame $B$-band magnitude attenuation Ia for of intergalactic strength is shown. Again, point represents the average value the error bars the In the upper panel, $B_{\
\]) at $z=0.1$ (upper panel), $z=0.2$ (middle panel) And $z=0.5$ (lower pAnel) iN a ${\OMegA_{\rM M}}=0.28,\,{\OmEga_{\rM\Lambda}}=0.72$ universE, WhicH is what we will use subseqUentlY. WE Have PErFormeD a numbeR Of SIMulAtIoNs uSiNG a Wide rAngE of cosmOlogical paRamEtEr-values and fOUnD the oscillAtiOn effect to dePenD only wEaKly ON cosmOloGy. The Most drAMatic eFfect is thE sTRong vaRIation oF ATtEnuaTion with photon eneRGy.

sInce the attenuaTion vaRiES vERY raPidLy with photOn EnergY In a simiLAr MANNer OVer a broad enerGy range, we exPEct The freQuEncY DependEnce tO wASh oUt to large exTent When doing Broad-bANd photoMEtry.

In FIg. \[fig:n\], We sHow The rESt-FrAme $b$-bANd mAGnItuDE atTenuatioN fOr type IA SNe DUE TO phoTon-AxioN osciLlations for thRee DiffERenT valuEs of tHe elEcTron dEnsity, In the ReDshift interval $0<z<2$, UsinG values foR thE oTheR iNput pARameteRs fRom eq. \[eq:valUes\]. Each POinT rEPREsEnts the average valuE aND ThE error baRs the dISpErSIon for teN dIffErenT LInes-oF-sigHT. IN the uppeR panel, WE hAvE used $n_{\rM e}=10^{-7}\,{\Rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$, iN tHe mIddLe panEL $n_{\rm E}=5\times 10^{-8}\,{\Rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$ and In the LOwer panel $n_{\rm e}=10^{-8}\,{\rM Cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$. Note that thE EfFECt IS not NecEssarily incReasINg wiTh inCReAsiNG redsHift. THiS Is DUe to the fact that we arE sTudyinG the [*rEst-frame*]{} $B$-band Magnitude. SINCE the amplItudE Of THe oscillations ScaleS roughly as $(\OMega /n_{\rm e})^2$ (See Eq. \[Eq:rho11appRox\]), we need THIs combinAtiOn tO be LarGE At Some point in orDER to gEt Close to MaxImal mixIng. if tHe pLasMa Density is High, the pHoToN eNeRgy Will bE RedshiftEd To tOo Low EnergIEs befoRe the PlasMa DeNSitY is diluTEd DUE to tHe ExPansIon.

in fig. \[fiG:b\], thE ResT-frame $B$-Band magniTudE AtteNuAtIon for TYpe Ia SNe for thReE different VaLueS of the INTergalacTic field strength is shown. aGain, eacH poInt rePresEnts the avEraGe valuE anD The errOr bars The diSpErsION for tEN DiFfeReNt lines-of-sIGHt. IN the uPpEr paNel, $B_{\
\]) at $z=0.1$ (upper pane l), $z=0.2 $ (mi ddl e p an el)and$z=0.5$ (lower pane l) in a ${\Omega_{\rmM}}=0 .2 8 ,\,{ \ Om ega_{ \rm\Lam b da } } =0. 72 $uni ve r se , whi chis what  we will u sesu bsequently.W ehave perfo rme d a number o f s imulat io nsu singa w ide r ange o f  cosmo logical p ar a meter- v alues a n d  f ound  the oscillatione ff e ct to depend o nly we ak l yo n  co smo logy. Themo st dr a matic e f fe c t ist he strong var iation of a t ten uation  w ith photon  ener gy . 

S ince the at tenu ation var ies ve r y rapid l y withphoton  en erg y in asi mil ar man n er  ov e r a  broad e ne rg y ran ge,w e e xpec t t he f reque ncy dependenc e t o wa s h o ut to  larg e ex te nt wh en doi ng br oa d-band photomet ry.
In Fig.\[f ig :n\ ],  we s h ow the  re st- frame $ B$-band mag ni t u d eattenuation for Ty pe I aSNe dueto pho t on -a x ion osci ll ati onsf o r thr ee d i ff erent va lues o f  t he  electr on  densi ty , i n t he re d shif t inte rval $0< z<2$, using values f o r the other i n pu t pa r amet ers  from Eq. \ [eq: v alue s\]. Ea chp ointrepre se n ts the average value a nd  the e rrorbars the disp ersion for t e n differ entl in e s-of-sight. In  theupper pane l , we hav e use d $n_{\r m e}=10^{ - 7 }\,{\rmcm} ^{- 3}( 1+z ) ^ 3$ , in the midd l e  pan el  $n_{\r m e }=5\tim es10^ {-8 }\, {\ rm cm}^{- 3}(1+z)^ 3$  a nd  i n t he lo w er panel  $ n_{ \r m e }=10^ { -8}\,{ \rm c m}^{ -3 }( 1 +z) ^3$. No t et h at t he  e ffec t i snot n eces s ari ly incr easing wi thi ncre as in g redsh ift. This isdu e to the f ac t t hat we a re study ing the [*rest-frame*]{ }  $B$-ba ndmagni tude . Since t heamplit ude of the  oscil latio ns  sc a l es ro u g hl y a s$(\omega / n _ {\r m e}) ^2 $ (s ee Eq.\[eq:rho11approx\] ) , w e need this c omb inat i o ntob el arg ea t s o m e point in orde r to get c lo s eto maximal mix in g. If t he plas ma de n sity is  high, th e photonen ergy w ill  be redshi fted totoo low e n ergie s  b efore  th e plas ma  de nsity  is di l ute d due  to th eexpans ion.
I n Fig. \ [fig:b\], the rest-fram e $B$- bandmag nitude at ten u ati on for Ty pe I a SNe forthr eediffe ren t  valu es o f  t hei nterg alac t ic fields tr eng t h  i s shown. Ag a i n , e ach p oin t  repre sent s the average val u e and the erro r ba r s  th e d i sper si on for ten dif fer en t lines-of -s ight. In th e upperpa n el, $ B_{\
\]) at_$z=0.1$ (upper_panel), $z=0.2$ (middle panel)_and $z=0.5$_(lower_panel) in_a_${\Omega_{\rm M}}=0.28,\,{\Omega_{\rm\Lambda}}=0.72$ universe,_which is what_we will use subsequently._We have performed_a_number of simulations using a wide range of cosmological parameter-values and found the oscillation_effect_to depend_only_weakly_on cosmology. The most dramatic_effect is the strong variation_of attenuation_with photon energy.

Since the attenuation varies very rapidly_with_photon energy in_a similar manner over a broad energy range, we_expect the frequency dependence to wash_out to large_extent_when_doing broad-band photometry.

In Fig. \[fig:n\],_we show the rest-frame $B$-band magnitude_attenuation for Type Ia SNe due_to photon-axion oscillations for three different values_of the electron density, in the_redshift interval $0<z<2$, using values_for the_other input parameters from Eq. \[eq:values\]._Each point represents_the average_value and the_error bars the dispersion for ten_different lines-of-sight. In_the upper panel, we have used_$n_{\rm_e}=10^{-7}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$, in_the_middle_panel $n_{\rm_e}=5\times 10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$_and_in the_lower_panel $n_{\rm e}=10^{-8}\,{\rm cm}^{-3}(1+z)^3$. Note that_the_effect is not necessarily increasing with increasing_redshift. This is due_to_the fact that we_are studying the [*rest-frame*]{} $B$-band_magnitude. Since the amplitude of the_oscillations scales_roughly as_$(\omega /n_{\rm e})^2$ (see Eq. \[eq:rho11approx\]), we need this combination to be_large at some point in order_to get close to_maximal mixing._If_the plasma density_is_high, the_photon energy will be redshifted to too_low energies_before the plasma density is diluted_due to the expansion.

In_Fig. \[fig:b\],_the rest-frame $B$-band magnitude attenuation for_Type Ia SNe for three different_values of the intergalactic field_strength_is_shown. Again, each point represents_the average value and the error_bars the dispersion_for ten different lines-of-sight. In the upper_panel,_$B_{\