'$ in $\Gamma$. Since the vertex $v$ is not $(\epsilon, R)$-deep, by Theorem \[thm:stronglythin\] applied to $u,u', a$ (respectively $u,u',b$), we obtain a vertex $v_a$ (respectively $v_b$) on a geodesic in $\Gamma$ from $a$ (respectively $b$) to $u$ or $u'$ satisfying $|v_a,v|_S\leq D$ (respectively $|v_b,v|_S\leq D$). Consequently $|a,b|_S\leq
|a,v_a|_S+|v_a,v|_S+|v,v_b|_S+|v_b,b|_S\leq 2\rho(U)+2D\leq
4D$, as desired.

Henceforth, we assume $\rho(U)\geq D+1$. Let $\ell=|a,b|_S$. If $\ell> 4D$, then choose any $2D\leq i\leq \ell-2D$, and any geodesic $p^{ab}$ from $a$ to $b$ in $\Gamma$. If $p^{ab}_i$ is an $(\epsilon, R)$-deep vertex of $p^{ab}$ in the peripheral left coset $w$, then let $z=w$, otherwise let $z=p^{ab}_i$. We claim that for any $c\in U$ we have $|z,c|_S\leq \rho(U)-1$, contradicting the definition of $\rho(U)$, and implying $\ell\leq 4D$.

Indeed, we apply Theorem \[thm:stronglythin\] to $a,b,c,$ and any geodesics $p^{bc},p^{ac}$. Without loss of generality assume that we have $|z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D$. Note that if $i>|a,c|_S$, then $p^{ac}_i$ lies in (or is equal to) $c$, and consequently $|z,c|_S\leq |z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D\leq\rho(U)-1$, as desired. If $i\leq|a,c|_S$, then $|p^{ac}_i,a|_S=i\geq 2D$, and hence $$|z,
' $ in   $ \Gamma$. Since the vertex $ v$ is not $ (\epsilon, R)$-deep, by Theorem   \[thm: stronglythin\ ] applied to $ u, u', a$ (respectively $ u, u',b$), we receive a vertex $ v_a$ (respectively $ v_b$) on a geodesic in $ \Gamma$ from $ a$ (respectively $ b$) to $ u$ or $ u'$ meet $ |v_a, v|_S\leq D$ (respectively $ |v_b, v|_S\leq D$). Consequently $ |a, b|_S\leq 
 |a, v_a|_S+|v_a, v|_S+|v, v_b|_S+|v_b, b|_S\leq 2\rho(U)+2D\leq 
 4D$, as desired. 

 Henceforth, we assume $ \rho(U)\geq D+1$. Let $ \ell=|a, b|_S$. If $ \ell > 4D$, then choose any $ 2D\leq i\leq \ell-2D$, and any geodesic $ p^{ab}$ from   $ a$ to   $ b$ in   $ \Gamma$. If $ p^{ab}_i$ is an $ (\epsilon, R)$-deep vertex of $ p^{ab}$ in the peripheral leftover coset   $ w$, then let $ z = w$, otherwise permit $ z = p^{ab}_i$. We claim that for any $ c\in U$ we have $ |z, c|_S\leq \rho(U)-1 $, contradict the definition of $ \rho(U)$, and implying $ \ell\leq 4D$. 

 Indeed, we apply Theorem   \[thm: stronglythin\ ] to $ a, b, c,$ and any geodesic $ p^{bc},p^{ac}$. Without loss of generality assume that we have $ |z, p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D$. Note that if $ i>|a, c|_S$, then $ p^{ac}_i$ lie down in (or is equal to) $ c$, and consequently $ |z, c|_S\leq |z, p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D\leq\rho(U)-1 $, as desired. If $ i\leq|a, c|_S$, then $ |p^{ac}_i, a|_S = i\geq 2D$, and hence $ $ |z,
'$ in $\Hamma$. Since the vertex $v$ is not $(\epsilon, R)$-deep, uy Theodem \[thm:stfonglythin\] applied to $u,u', a$ (rxspextiveoy $u,u',b$), we obtain a vergex $v_a$ (redpectiveoy $v_u$) on a geodesic mh $\Gamma$ from $z$ (res'ertively $b$) to $u$ pr $u'$ satisxying $|v_a,v|_S\leq G$ (fedpectively $|v_b,v|_S\leq D$). Consequently $|a,f|_S\leq
|a,v_s|_S+|g_a,v|_S+|v,v_b|_S+|v_b,b|_S\lez 2\rhp(T)+2D\les
4D$, as desired.

Henceforth, we assume $\dho(U)\geq D+1$. Let $\ell=|a,b|_S$. If $\ell> 4D$, then choose any $2F\leq i\leq \ell-2D$, and any geodesic $p^{qb}$ fwim $a$ to $b$ in $\Gaoma$. If $p^{ab}_p$ is an $(\epsjlon, R)$-deep vertex of $p^{ab}$ in the peri'heral left ciseh $f$, then let $v=w$, othvrwise let $z=p^{ab}_i$. We cnaim thst for any $c\in U$ xe hqve $|z,c|_S\leq \rho(U)-1$, contredicting the definityon of $\rhm(U)$, and implying $\ell\oew 4D$.

Ingeed, we xpplh Tgeprsm \[thm:shroiglythin\] to $a,b,c,$ and ant geodesics $p^{bc},p^{ac}$. Eieyout loss of fenerajiey assume that we have $|z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D$. Note thzt if $i>|a,c|_S$, then $p^{ac}_i$ liws in (or is equal to) $f$, and confequently $|z,c|_S\leq |z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D\leq\rho(U)-1$, as desired. If $i\leq|e,c|_R$, tkck $|p^{az}_u,a|_D=i\geq 2D$, and hence $$|z,
'$ in $\Gamma$. Since the vertex $v$ $(\epsilon, by Theorem applied to $u,u', a $v_a$ (respectively $v_b$) a geodesic in from $a$ (respectively $b$) to $u$ $u'$ satisfying $|v_a,v|_S\leq D$ (respectively $|v_b,v|_S\leq D$). Consequently $|a,b|_S\leq |a,v_a|_S+|v_a,v|_S+|v,v_b|_S+|v_b,b|_S\leq 2\rho(U)+2D\leq 4D$, as Henceforth, we assume $\rho(U)\geq D+1$. Let $\ell=|a,b|_S$. If $\ell> 4D$, then choose any i\leq and geodesic from $a$ to $b$ in $\Gamma$. If $p^{ab}_i$ is an $(\epsilon, R)$-deep vertex of $p^{ab}$ in peripheral left coset $w$, then let $z=w$, otherwise $z=p^{ab}_i$. We claim that any $c\in U$ we have \rho(U)-1$, the definition $\rho(U)$, implying 4D$. Indeed, we Theorem \[thm:stronglythin\] to $a,b,c,$ and any geodesics $p^{bc},p^{ac}$. Without loss of generality assume that we have $|z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq Note that then $p^{ac}_i$ in is to) $c$, and |z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D\leq\rho(U)-1$, as desired. If $i\leq|a,c|_S$, and hence $$|z,
'$ in $\Gamma$. Since the vertex $v$ is nOt $(\epsilon, R)$-Deep, bY ThEorEm \[Thm:sTronGlythin\] applied TO $u,u', a$ (Respectively $u,u',b$), we obtaiN a verTeX $V_a$ (reSPeCtiveLy $v_b$) on a GEoDESic In $\gaMma$ FrOM $a$ (RespeCtiVely $b$) to $U$ or $u'$ satisfYinG $|v_A,v|_S\leq D$ (respeCTiVely $|v_b,v|_S\leQ D$). COnsequently $|a,B|_S\lEq
|a,v_a|_S+|V_a,V|_S+|v,V_B|_S+|v_b,b|_s\leQ 2\rho(U)+2d\leq
4D$, aS DesireD.

HenceforTh, WE assumE $\Rho(U)\geq d+1$. lEt $\Ell=|a,B|_S$. If $\ell> 4D$, then choosE AnY $2d\leq i\leq \ell-2D$, anD any geOdESiC $P^{Ab}$ fRom $A$ to $b$ in $\GammA$. IF $p^{ab}_i$ IS an $(\epsiLOn, r)$-DEEp vERtex of $p^{ab}$ in thE peripheral LEft Coset $w$, ThEn lET $z=w$, othErwisE lET $z=p^{Ab}_i$. We claim tHat fOr any $c\in U$ We have $|Z,C|_S\leq \rhO(u)-1$, contraDictinG thE deFiniTIoN oF $\rhO(U)$, ANd iMPlYinG $\Ell\Leq 4D$.

IndeEd, We Apply theoREM \[THm:stRonGlytHin\] to $A,b,c,$ and any geodEsiCs $p^{bC},P^{ac}$. withoUt losS of gEnEraliTy assuMe thaT wE have $|z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D$. note That if $i>|a,c|_s$, thEn $P^{ac}_I$ lIes in (OR is equAl tO) $c$, aNd conseQuently $|Z,C|_S\lEq |Z,P^{AC}_{i}|_s\leq D\leq\rho(U)-1$, as desiReD. iF $i\Leq|a,c|_S$, thEn $|p^{ac}_i,A|_s=i\GeQ 2d$, and hencE $$|z,
'$ in $\Gamma$. Since thevertex $v$  is n ot$(\ ep silo n, R )$-deep, by Th e orem  \[thm:stronglythin\]appli ed to $ u ,u ', a$  (respe c ti v e ly$u ,u ',b $) ,  w e obt ain  a vert ex $v_a$ ( res pe ctively $v_b $ )on a geode sic  in $\Gamma$  fr om $a$  ( res p ectiv ely  $b$)  to $u $  or $u '$ satisf yi n g $|v_ a ,v|_S\l e q  D $ (r espectively $|v_b , v| _ S\leq D$). Con sequen tl y  $ | a ,b| _S\ leq
|a,v_a |_ S+|v_ a ,v|_S+| v ,v _ b | _S+ | v_b,b|_S\leq2\rho(U)+2D \ leq 
4D$,as  de s ired.
Henc ef o rth , we assume  $\r ho(U)\geq  D+1$. Let $\e l l=|a,b| _S$. I f $ \el l> 4 D $,  t hen  c h oos e  a ny$ 2D\ leq i\le q\e ll-2D $, a n d a ny g eod esic  $p^{ ab}$ from $a$  to  $b$ in$\Gam ma$.If $ p^ {ab}_ i$ isan $( \e psilon, R)$-dee p ve rtex of $ p^{ ab }$in  thep eriphe ral  le ft cose t $w$,t hen  l e t $z =w$, otherwise let  $ z = p^ {ab}_i$.  We cl a im  t h at for a ny  $c \inU $  we h ave$ |z ,c|_S\le q \rho ( U) -1 $, cont ra dictin gthe  de finit i on o f $\rh o(U)$, a nd im p lying $\ell\le q  4D$.

Indeed ,  w e ap p ly T heo rem \[thm:s tron g lyth in\] to  $a , b,c,$  andan y  g e odesics $p^{bc},p^{ ac }$. Wi thout  loss of gene rality ass u m e  that we  hav e  $ | z,p^{ac}_{i}|_ S\leq  D$. Notet hat if $ i>|a, c|_S$, t hen $p^{a c } _i$ lies  in  (o r i s e q u al  to) $c$, and c onse qu ently $ |z, c|_S\le q | z,p ^{a c}_ {i }|_S\leqD\leq\rh o( U) -1 $,  as  desi r ed. If $ i\ leq |a ,c| _S$,t hen $| p^{ac }_i, a| _S = i\g eq 2D$, an d henc e$$ |z,
'$ in $\Gamma$._Since the_vertex $v$ is not_$(\epsilon, R)$-deep,_by_Theorem \[thm:stronglythin\] applied_to_$u,u', a$ (respectively_$u,u',b$), we obtain_a vertex $v_a$ (respectively_$v_b$) on a_geodesic_in $\Gamma$ from $a$ (respectively $b$) to $u$ or $u'$ satisfying $|v_a,v|_S\leq D$ (respectively_$|v_b,v|_S\leq_D$). Consequently_$|a,b|_S\leq
|a,v_a|_S+|v_a,v|_S+|v,v_b|_S+|v_b,b|_S\leq_2\rho(U)+2D\leq
4D$,_as desired.

Henceforth, we assume $\rho(U)\geq_D+1$. Let $\ell=|a,b|_S$. If $\ell>_4D$, then_choose any $2D\leq i\leq \ell-2D$, and any geodesic_$p^{ab}$_from $a$ to $b$ in $\Gamma$._If $p^{ab}_i$ is an $(\epsilon, R)$-deep vertex of $p^{ab}$_in the peripheral left coset $w$, then_let $z=w$, otherwise_let_$z=p^{ab}_i$._We claim that for_any $c\in U$ we have $|z,c|_S\leq_\rho(U)-1$, contradicting the definition of $\rho(U)$,_and implying $\ell\leq 4D$.

Indeed, we apply Theorem \[thm:stronglythin\]_to $a,b,c,$ and any geodesics $p^{bc},p^{ac}$._Without loss of generality assume_that we_have $|z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D$. Note that_if $i>|a,c|_S$, then_$p^{ac}_i$ lies_in (or is_equal to) $c$, and consequently $|z,c|_S\leq_|z,p^{ac}_{i}|_S\leq D\leq\rho(U)-1$, as_desired. If $i\leq|a,c|_S$, then $|p^{ac}_i,a|_S=i\geq 2D$,_and_hence $$|z,