 spins leaves the energy unchanged[@Liu2017]. Therefore, our experiment implies that this single-ion anisotropy is vanishingly small and what lifts the U(1) degeneracy is the in-plane magnetic field. Therefore, instead of having *six* domains (which would have been the case if the degeneracy was lifted by the single-ion anisotropy), we have only *two* domains set by the orientation of the magnetic field. This is the first outcome of our study. A field as small as 0.5 T easily sets the orientation of the spins by coupling to the in-plane magnetization, which is 1.5$\times 10^{-2} \mu_{B}$/f.u. at 0.5 T. This corresponds to an energy as small as 0.5 $\mu$eV/f.u. Such an upper boundary is in agreement with the angle-dependent torque magnetometry data reported by Duan and co-workers who quantified the magnetic crystalline anisotropy of the system[@Duan2015](see section H in Appendix).

Momentum-space Berry curvature
------------------------------

A second consequence is about the in-plane anisotropy of the momentum-space Berry curvature. Previous studies [@Nakatsuji2015; @Nayak2016; @Kiyohara2016; @Li2017] detected a finite AHC for two perpendicular orientations of magnetic field. The magnitude of $\sigma^{A}_{yz}$($B\|x$) and $\sigma^{A}_{xz}$($B\|y$) was found to be close to each other in both Mn$_{3}$Ge [@Kiyohara2016] and in Mn$_{3}$Sn [@Li2017]. Measuring numerous samples (see Appendix), we also found that the anisotropy is small and below 0.15 (see Fig. 3a). An even smaller upper bound ($\sim$0.05) on any in-plane anisotropy is implied by our angle-dependent experiment. Our density functional theory calculations find a band structure (see the Appendix) and a Fermi surface unchanged as the spins rotate (Figs. 3b-e), in agreement with the experimental observation that finds unchanged $\sigma^{A}_{ij}$ for any arbitrary orientation of magnetic field in the xy plane when the current is along the $z$ axis and the electric field is measured perpendicular to the magnetic field.

A finite $\sigma^{A}_{ij}$ arises when the overall integration of Berry curvature, $\Omega^{k}$ in the entire Brillouin
spins leaves the energy unchanged[@Liu2017 ]. Therefore, our experiment entail that this individual - ion anisotropy is vanishingly small and what lifts the U(1) degeneracy is the in - airplane magnetic field. Therefore, alternatively of having * six * domains (which would have been the event if the degeneracy was lifted by the individual - ion anisotropy), we have only * two * world set by the predilection of the magnetic field. This is the inaugural outcome of our study. A field equally small as 0.5 T well sets the orientation course of the spins by copulate to the in - plane magnetization, which is 1.5$\times 10^{-2 } \mu_{B}$/f.u.   at 0.5 T. This corresponds to an energy equally small as 0.5 $ \mu$eV / f.u. Such an upper boundary is in agreement with the angle - dependent torque magnetometry data report by Duan and colorado - workers who quantified the magnetic crystalline anisotropy of the system[@Duan2015](see section H in Appendix). 

 Momentum - space Berry curvature 
 ------------------------------ 

 A second consequence is about the in - plane anisotropy of the momentum - space Berry curvature. Previous study [ @Nakatsuji2015; @Nayak2016; @Kiyohara2016; @Li2017 ] detected a finite AHC for two perpendicular orientation of charismatic field. The magnitude of $ \sigma^{A}_{yz}$($B\|x$) and $ \sigma^{A}_{xz}$($B\|y$) was found to be close to each other in both Mn$_{3}$Ge [ @Kiyohara2016 ] and in Mn$_{3}$Sn [ @Li2017 ]. Measuring numerous samples (see Appendix), we besides found that the anisotropy is small and below 0.15 (see Fig.   3a). An even smaller upper bound ($ \sim$0.05) on any in - plane anisotropy is implied by our angle - dependent experiment. Our density functional theory calculation find a set structure (see the Appendix) and a Fermi surface unchanged as the spins revolve (Figs.   3b - e), in agreement with the experimental observation that finds unaltered $ \sigma^{A}_{ij}$ for any arbitrary orientation of charismatic field in the xy plane when the current is along the $ z$ axis and the electric field is quantify perpendicular to the magnetic battlefield. 

 A finite $ \sigma^{A}_{ij}$ arises when the overall consolidation of Berry curvature, $ \Omega^{k}$ in the entire Brillouin
 splns leaves the energy unghanged[@Liu2017]. Thereyire, ouc experjment imolies that this single-ion anmsoteopy us vanishingly small avd what lpfts the Y(1) dejeneracy is the mh-plane magnetjg fienv. Therefore, insjead of havitg *six* domains (wfieh would have been the case if the dqgeneravy was lifted by the fingmv-iin anisotropy), we have only *twk* domaiis set by the otientation of the magnetic fiepd. This is the firdt outcome if ote study. A fidld as small as 0.5 T easjly sets the orientation of the spinx by couplunt tl the in-planx magnvtization, whign is 1.5$\thmes 10^{-2} \mi_{B}$/f.u. at 0.5 T. This cocresponds to an energy as small as 0.5 $\mu$eV/f.u. Fuch an u[pzr boundary is in agrwenent fith the qngue-dtpeideht toreue magnetomefry data reported by Duan and vo-rirkers who quzntifiqd the magnetic crystalline anisotropy of ths system[@Duan2015](see section H in Appendix).

Momentul-space Bewry curvature
------------------------------

A second consequence is about the in-[lane xniwobroph ov the momentum-space Berry curvature. Previous ffucivs [@Nakatsuji2015; @Nayah2016; @Kiyohara2016; @Ki2017] drjected a finitg AHC for fwo perpendicular lrientajions if magnetyc foeld. The magnitude of $\sigma^{Q}_{yz}$($B\|x$) and $\siyma^{Q}_{xz}$($B\|y$) was found to be close tu eavh otner in both Mn$_{3}$Ge [@Kiyohaxa2016] and in Mn$_{3}$Sn [@Li2017]. Measurinf numerous sampler (sve A[pendix), we also found that the anisitro'y is smxll snd bejow 0.15 (see Flg. 3a). Ak even smaller uppeg bouud ($\sik$0.05) on any ij-plane anisotropy is implied by our angle-depemdant experimznt. Ouv density functyonal theory cclculatijns fknd a band structnre (see the Wppendix) and d Fermi surfare unchanded qs tye spinr rotate (Figs. 3b-e), in agreement with rhe experimental onservxfion that finds unxhanged $\sigma^{A}_{ik}$ fur wnj acbitrwsy orientatimn ow mxbnetiz field in bhe xy llane when the currett ia along the $z$ axis akd the elgctric fiqld is measurrd perpendicular tl the majnetic figld.

A finite $\sigma^{A}_{ij}$ arises wheh the ovegalj integratiog of Berry curvacure, $\Omega^{k}$ in the entire Brillouin
spins leaves the energy unchanged[@Liu2017]. Therefore, our that single-ion anisotropy vanishingly small and is in-plane magnetic field. instead of having domains (which would have been the if the degeneracy was lifted by the single-ion anisotropy), we have only *two* set by the orientation of the magnetic field. This is the first outcome our A as as 0.5 T easily sets the orientation of the spins by coupling to the in-plane magnetization, is 1.5$\times 10^{-2} \mu_{B}$/f.u. at 0.5 T. This to an energy as as 0.5 $\mu$eV/f.u. Such an boundary in agreement the torque data reported by and co-workers who quantified the magnetic crystalline anisotropy of the system[@Duan2015](see section H in Appendix). Momentum-space Berry ------------------------------ A is about in-plane of momentum-space Berry curvature. [@Nakatsuji2015; @Nayak2016; @Kiyohara2016; @Li2017] detected a two perpendicular orientations of magnetic field. The magnitude $\sigma^{A}_{yz}$($B\|x$) and was found to be close to other in both Mn$_{3}$Ge [@Kiyohara2016] and in Mn$_{3}$Sn Measuring numerous samples (see Appendix), we also found that the anisotropy is small and below Fig. 3a). An even upper bound ($\sim$0.05) any anisotropy implied our angle-dependent Our density functional theory calculations find a band structure (see the and a Fermi surface unchanged as the spins rotate (Figs. agreement the experimental observation finds unchanged $\sigma^{A}_{ij}$ for arbitrary of magnetic field in plane the the axis the electric field is perpendicular to the magnetic field. finite $\sigma^{A}_{ij}$ arises when curvature, $\Omega^{k}$ in the entire Brillouin
 spins leaves the energy unchaNged[@Liu2017]. TheReforE, ouR exPeRimeNt imPlies that this sINgle-Ion anisotropy is vanishiNgly sMaLL and WHaT liftS the U(1) deGEnERAcy Is ThE in-PlANe MagneTic Field. ThErefore, insTeaD oF having *six* doMAiNs (which wouLd hAve been the caSe iF the deGeNerACy was LifTed by The sinGLe-ion aNisotropy), We HAve onlY *Two* domaINS sEt by The orientation of tHE mAGnetic field. ThiS is the FiRSt OUTcoMe oF our study. A FiEld as SMall as 0.5 T EAsILY SetS The orientatioN of the spins BY coUpling To The IN-plane MagneTiZAtiOn, which is 1.5$\tiMes 10^{-2} \mU_{B}$/f.u. at 0.5 T. ThIs corrESponds tO An energY as smaLl aS 0.5 $\mu$EV/f.u. sUcH aN upPeR BouNDaRy iS In aGreement WiTh The anGle-dEPENDent TorQue mAgnetOmetry data repOrtEd by dUan And co-WorkeRs whO qUantiFied thE magnEtIc crystalline anIsotRopy of the SysTeM[@DuAn2015](See seCTion H iN ApPenDix).

MomeNtum-spaCE BeRrY CURvAture
------------------------------

A second conseqUeNCE iS about thE in-plaNE aNiSOtropy of ThE moMentUM-Space berrY CuRvature. PReviouS StUdIes [@NakaTsUji2015; @NayAk2016; @kiyOhaRa2016; @Li2017] dETectEd a finIte AHC foR two pERpendicular oriENtations of magNEtIC FiELd. ThE maGnitude of $\siGma^{A}_{YZ}$($B\|x$) aNd $\siGMa^{a}_{xz}$($b\|Y$) was fOund tO bE ClOSe to each other in both mn$_{3}$ge [@KiyoHara2016] aNd in Mn$_{3}$Sn [@Li2017]. MeaSuring numeROUS samples (See APPeNDix), we also found That tHe anisotroPY is small And beLow 0.15 (see FiG. 3a). An even sMALler uppeR boUnd ($\Sim$0.05) On aNY In-Plane anisotroPY Is imPlIed by ouR anGle-depeNdeNt eXpeRimEnT. Our densiTy functiOnAl ThEoRy cAlculATions finD a BanD sTruCture (SEe the APpendIx) anD a feRMi sUrface uNChANGed aS tHe SpinS roTaTe (FigS. 3b-e), iN AgrEement wIth the expEriMEntaL oBsErvatioN that finds uncHaNged $\sigma^{A}_{Ij}$ For Any arbITRary orieNtation of magnetic field iN The xy plAne When tHe cuRrent is alOng The $z$ axIs aND the elEctric Field Is MeaSURed peRPEnDicUlAr to the magNETic Field.

a fInitE $\sigma^{A}_{Ij}$ arises when the oveRAll Integration of berRy cuRVAtUre, $\oMeGA^{k}$ iN tHE enTIRe Brillouin
 spins leaves the energy u nchanged[@ Liu20 17] . T he refo re,our experiment impl ies that this single-i on an is o trop y  i s van ishingl y  s m a llan dwha tl if ts th e U (1) deg eneracy is  th ein-plane mag n et ic field.The refore, inst ead  of ha vi ng* six*dom ains(which wouldhave been  t h e case if thed e ge nera cy was lifted byt he single-ion ani sotrop y) ,  w e hav e o nly *two*do mains set byt he o r ien t ation of themagnetic fi e ld.  Thisis  th e  first  outc om e  of  our study.  A f ield as s mall a s  0.5 Te asily s ets th e o rie ntat i on  o f t he spi n sbyc oup ling toth ein-pl anem a g n etiz ati on,which  is 1.5$\time s 1 0^{- 2 } \ mu_{B }$/f. u. a t0.5 T . This  corr es ponds to an ene rgyas smallas0. 5 $ \m u$eV/ f .u. Su chanupper b oundary isin a g re ement with the ang le - d ep endent t orquem ag ne t ometry d at a r epor t e d byDuan an d co-wor kers w h oqu antifie dthe ma gn eti c c rysta l line  aniso tropy of  thes ystem[@Duan201 5 ](see section Hi n  A p pend ix) .

Momentum -spa c e Be rryc ur vat u re
-- ----- -- - -- - -----------------
Asecond  cons equence is ab out the in - p l ane anis otro p yo f the momentum -spac e Berry cu r vature.Previ ous stud ies [@Nak a t suji2015 ; @ Nay ak2 016 ; @K iyohara2016;@ L i201 7]  detect eda finit e A HCfor  tw operpendic ular ori en ta ti on s o f mag n etic fie ld . T he  ma gnitu d e of $ \sigm a^{A }_ {y z }$( $B\|x$) an d $\si gm a^ {A}_ {xz }$ ($B\| y$)w asfound t o be clos e t o  eac hot her inboth Mn$_{3}$ Ge  [@Kiyohar a2 016 ] andi n  Mn$_{3} $Sn [@Li2017]. Measurin g  numero ussampl es ( see Appen dix ), weals o  found  thatthe a ni sot r o py is s ma llan d below 0. 1 5  (s ee Fi g.  3a) . An ev en smaller upper b o und  ($\sim$0.05)  on  any i n- pla n ea nis ot r opy i s implied by ou r angle-de pe n de nt experim e nt.  O ur dens ity fun ction a l theor y calcula tions fin da ba n d  st ructure (s ee the A ppendix)a nd aF er mi su rfa ce unc ha nge d asthe sp i nsrotat e (Fig s.  3b-e) , inag reementwith the experimental o bserva tiontha t finds u nch a nge d $\sigma ^{A} _{ij}$ for  an y a rbitr ary orien tati o nofm agnet ic f i eld in th e  x y p l a ne  when the c u r r ent  is a lon g  the $ z$ a xis and the elect r ic field is me asur e d  pe rpe n dicu la r to the magne tic  f i e ld.

A f in ite $\sigma ^{A}_{ij }$ arise s when  the o veralli n te g ration  ofBer ry curvat ure ,$ \Omega^ {k }$ in the  ent ir e Bril louin
 spins_leaves the_energy unchanged[@Liu2017]. Therefore, our_experiment implies_that_this single-ion_anisotropy_is vanishingly small_and what lifts_the U(1) degeneracy is_the in-plane magnetic_field._Therefore, instead of having *six* domains (which would have been the case if the_degeneracy_was lifted_by_the_single-ion anisotropy), we have only_*two* domains set by the_orientation of_the magnetic field. This is the first outcome_of_our study. A_field as small as 0.5 T easily sets the_orientation of the spins by coupling_to the in-plane_magnetization,_which_is 1.5$\times 10^{-2} \mu_{B}$/f.u. at_0.5 T. This corresponds to an_energy as small as 0.5 $\mu$eV/f.u._Such an upper boundary is in agreement_with the angle-dependent torque magnetometry data_reported by Duan and co-workers_who quantified_the magnetic crystalline anisotropy of_the system[@Duan2015](see section_H in_Appendix).

Momentum-space Berry curvature
------------------------------

A_second consequence is about the in-plane_anisotropy of the_momentum-space Berry curvature. Previous studies [@Nakatsuji2015;_@Nayak2016;_@Kiyohara2016; @Li2017] detected_a_finite_AHC for_two perpendicular orientations_of_magnetic field._The_magnitude of $\sigma^{A}_{yz}$($B\|x$) and $\sigma^{A}_{xz}$($B\|y$) was_found_to be close to each other in_both Mn$_{3}$Ge [@Kiyohara2016] and_in_Mn$_{3}$Sn [@Li2017]. Measuring numerous_samples (see Appendix), we also_found that the anisotropy is small_and below_0.15 (see_Fig. 3a). An even smaller upper bound ($\sim$0.05) on any in-plane anisotropy_is implied by our angle-dependent experiment._Our density functional theory_calculations find_a_band structure (see_the_Appendix) and_a Fermi surface unchanged as the spins_rotate (Figs. 3b-e),_in agreement with the experimental observation_that finds unchanged $\sigma^{A}_{ij}$_for_any arbitrary orientation of magnetic field_in the xy plane when the_current is along the $z$_axis_and_the electric field is measured_perpendicular to the magnetic field.

A finite_$\sigma^{A}_{ij}$ arises when_the overall integration of Berry curvature, $\Omega^{k}$_in_the entire Brillouin