i \delta \varphi  \Rightarrow B_i = 0$$ i.e. there is no propagating transverse vector mode. Therefore, if we redefine $\dfrac{1}{\varphi'}\partial_i \delta \varphi  = \partial_i V$ then we obtain the results from. Therefore, the scalar sector for Generalized Einstein-Aether and the Khronon are completely equivalent [@Blas2], up to a redefinition of the coefficients discussed previously.

Equations of state for perturbations {#sect:EoS}
====================================

Scalar sector {#scalar-sector}
-------------

We now derive the equations of state, $\Gamma$ and $\Pi^{S,V,T}$, in terms of the other perturbation variables by fully eliminating the internal degrees of freedom introduced by the theory i.e. $V$, $B^i$, and their derivatives. In the scalar sector we do this via the expressions for $\delta \rho$ and $\theta^S$. Let us first work in the conformal Newtonian gauge. Initially it may not seem possible to eliminate the degrees of freedom as we have that $\theta^S \equiv \theta^S (V,V',V'')$ and $\delta \rho \equiv \delta \rho(V,V')$, i.e. we have three unknowns and only two equations. However, we can use the perturbed Aether field equation of motion to reduce the dimensionality of the problem. Using this to eliminate $V''$ in and gathering terms in $V$ and $V'$, we find that $$\begin{aligned}
a^2 \delta \rho =& \hspace{1mm} c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K}k^2 V'  - \left[\alpha \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} -c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} + \frac{6 \alpha^2 \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK} \mathcal{H}^2}{a^2 M^2} \right] \mathcal{H}k^2 V \nonumber \\
 +\hspace{1mm}&c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} k^2 \Psi - 3\alpha \mathcal{H}\left(\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} + \frac{6\alpha \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK}\mathcal{H}^2}{a^2 M^2} \right)
i \delta \varphi   \Rightarrow B_i = 0$$ i.e. there is no propagating transverse vector mood. consequently, if we redefine $ \dfrac{1}{\varphi'}\partial_i \delta \varphi   = \partial_i V$ then we obtain the results from. consequently, the scalar sector for Generalized Einstein - Aether and the Khronon are completely equivalent [ @Blas2 ], up to a redefinition of the coefficient discussed previously. 

 Equations of state of matter for perturbations { # sect: EoS } 
 = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = 

 Scalar sector { # scalar - sector } 
 ------------- 

 We nowadays derive the equations of department of state, $ \Gamma$ and $ \Pi^{S, V, T}$, in terms of the other disturbance variables by fully eliminating the internal degrees of exemption introduced by the theory i.e. $ V$, $ B^i$, and their derivative. In the scalar sector we do this via the expressions for $ \delta \rho$ and $ \theta^S$. permit us first function in the conformal Newtonian gauge. Initially it may not seem possible to eliminate the degrees of exemption as we have that $ \theta^S \equiv \theta^S (V, V',V'')$ and $ \delta \rho \equiv \delta \rho(V, V')$, i.e. we have three unknowns and only two equations. However, we can use the perturb Aether field equation of motion to reduce the dimensionality of the problem. Using this to eliminate $ V''$ in and gathering terms in $ V$ and $ V'$, we find that $ $ \begin{aligned } 
 a^2 \delta \rho = & \hspace{1 mm } c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K}k^2 V'   - \left[\alpha \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K } -c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K } + \frac{6 \alpha^2 \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK } \mathcal{H}^2}{a^2 M^2 } \right ] \mathcal{H}k^2 V \nonumber \\ 
  + \hspace{1mm}&c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K } k^2 \Psi - 3\alpha \mathcal{H}\left(\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K } + \frac{6\alpha \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK}\mathcal{H}^2}{a^2 M^2 } \right )
i \dflta \varphi  \Rightarrow N_i = 0$$ i.e. there is no pro'agatinf transvdrse vector mode. Therefore, ih we rededine $\dfrac{1}{\varphi'}\partiau_i \delta \narphi  = \partmal_i V$ then we oufain thc reshpts yrim. Therefore, tme scalar sactor for Genesauived Einstein-Aether and the Khronon awe compkehely equivalenj [@Blax2], up fo a redefinition of the coefficiehts disbussed previously.

Rquations of state for perhurbwtions {#sect:EoS}
====================================

Scalwr sector {#sxalaw-wector}
-------------

We now derive tht zquations or state, $\Gamma$ and $\Pi^{S,V,T}$, in termr of che other pgxrurhdtion variaules bj fully elimiksting dhe intrrnal degrees pf hreeeom introduced by the theory i.e. $V$, $B^i$, anq their darnvatives. In the scalae wectot we go tfus xia tie sxpresdiois for $\deltz \rho$ and $\tyeta^S$. Let us first eowj in the confkrmal Gertonian gauge. Initially it may not seem poasible to eliminate the degrees of freedom ad we have that $\theta^S \equiv \theta^S (V,V',V'')$ and $\delta \rho \equiv \delte \fho(R,Y')$, k.w. ae have three unknowns and only two equations. Goeener, we can use thc perturbed Aether flekq equation of motiou tk reduce the dimendionalijy of rhe probltm. Usong this to eliminate $V''$ in qnd gatheriny twrms in $V$ and $V'$, we find that $$\yegin{akignec}
a^2 \delta \rho =& \hspace{1mm} e_{14}\mathczl{F}_\mathcal{K}n^2 V'  - \leff[\xlpha \mathcal{F}_\maghcsl{N} -c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} + \frac{6 \wlpha^2 \matical{F}_\kathcal{YK} \msthcal{R}^2}{a^2 M^2} \right] \mathgdl{H}k^2 V \nonumber \\
 +\hdpace{1lm}&w_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mwthcal{K} k^2 \Psi - 3\alpha \mathcal{H}\lehv(\mathcal{F}_\mathvan{K} + \frac{6\alpka \matmcal{F}_\mathcal{KK}\mwthcal{H}^2}{a^2 M^2} \rigkt)
i \delta \varphi \Rightarrow B_i = 0$$ is propagating transverse mode. Therefore, if = V$ then we the results from. the scalar sector for Generalized Einstein-Aether the Khronon are completely equivalent [@Blas2], up to a redefinition of the coefficients previously. Equations of state for perturbations {#sect:EoS} ==================================== Scalar sector {#scalar-sector} ------------- We derive equations state, and $\Pi^{S,V,T}$, in terms of the other perturbation variables by fully eliminating the internal degrees of introduced by the theory i.e. $V$, $B^i$, and derivatives. In the scalar we do this via the for \rho$ and Let first in the conformal gauge. Initially it may not seem possible to eliminate the degrees of freedom as we have that \equiv \theta^S $\delta \rho \delta i.e. have three unknowns two equations. However, we can use field equation of motion to reduce the dimensionality the problem. this to eliminate $V''$ in and terms in $V$ and $V'$, we find that a^2 \delta \rho =& \hspace{1mm} c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K}k^2 V' - \left[\alpha \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} -c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} + \frac{6 \alpha^2 \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK} \right] \mathcal{H}k^2 V \nonumber +\hspace{1mm}&c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} k^2 \Psi 3\alpha + \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK}\mathcal{H}^2}{a^2 \right)
i \delta \varphi  \Rightarrow B_i = 0$$ i.E. there is no PropaGatIng TrAnsvErse Vector mode. TherEFore, If we redefine $\dfrac{1}{\varphI'}\partIaL_I \delTA \vArphi  = \Partial_I v$ tHEN we ObTaIn tHe REsUlts fRom. therefoRe, the scalaR seCtOr for GeneralIZeD Einstein-AEthEr and the KhroNon Are comPlEteLY equiValEnt [@BlAs2], up to A RedefiNition of tHe COefficIEnts disCUSsEd prEviously.

Equations OF sTAte for perturbaTions {#sEcT:eos}
====================================

sCalAr sEctor {#scalaR-sEctor}
-------------

wE now derIVe THE EquATions of state, $\GAmma$ and $\Pi^{S,V,t}$, In tErms of ThE otHEr pertUrbatIoN VarIables by fulLy elIminating The intERnal degREes of frEedom iNtrOduCed bY ThE tHeoRy I.E. $V$, $B^I$, AnD thEIr dErivativEs. in The scAlar SECTOr we Do tHis vIa the Expressions foR $\deLta \rHO$ anD $\thetA^S$. Let Us fiRsT work In the cOnforMaL Newtonian gauge. initIally it maY noT sEem PoSsiblE To elimInaTe tHe degreEs of freEDom As WE HAvE that $\theta^S \equiv \thEtA^s (v,V',v'')$ and $\deltA \rho \eqUIv \DeLTa \rho(V,V')$, i.E. wE haVe thREE unknOwns ANd Only two eQuatioNS. HOwEver, we cAn Use the PeRtuRbeD AethER fieLd equaTion of moTion tO Reduce the dimenSIonality of the PRoBLEm. uSing ThiS to eliminatE $V''$ in ANd gaTherINg TerMS in $V$ aNd $V'$, we FiND tHAt $$\begin{aligned}
a^2 \deltA \rHo =& \hspaCe{1mm} c_{14}\Mathcal{F}_\mathcAl{K}k^2 V'  - \left[\aLPHA \mathcal{f}_\matHCaL{k} -c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathCal{K} + \fRac{6 \alpha^2 \maTHcal{F}_\matHcal{Kk} \mathcal{h}^2}{a^2 M^2} \right] \mATHcal{H}k^2 V \nOnuMbeR \\
 +\hsPacE{1MM}&c_{14}\Mathcal{F}_\mathcAL{k} k^2 \PsI - 3\aLpha \matHcaL{H}\left(\mAthCal{f}_\maThcAl{k} + \frac{6\alphA \mathcal{f}_\mAtHcAl{kK}\mAthcaL{h}^2}{a^2 M^2} \right)
i \delta \varphi  \Rightar row B_i =0$$ i .e.  th er e is  nopropagating tr a nsve rse vector mode. There fore,  i f  wer ed efine  $\dfra c {1 } { \va rp hi '}\ pa r ti al_i\de lta \va rphi  = \p art ia l_i V$ thenw eobtain the  re sults from.The refore ,the scala r s ector  for G e nerali zed Einst ei n -Aethe r  and th e Kh rono n are completelye qu i valent [@Blas2 ], upto ar e def ini tion of th ecoeff i cientsd is c u s sed previously.
Equations o f  st ate fo rper t urbati ons { #s e ct: EoS}
====== ==== ========= ====== = ======= = ==

Sca lar se cto r { #sca l ar -s ect or } 
-- - -- --- - --- -

We no wde rivethee q u a tion s o f st ate,$\Gamma$ and$\P i^{S , V,T }$, i n ter ms o fthe o ther p ertur ba tion variablesby f ully elim ina ti ngth e int e rnal d egr ees  of fre edom in t rod uc e d by  the theory i.e. $ V$ , $B ^i$, and  their de ri v atives.In  th e sc a l ar se ctor we  do this  via t h eex pressio ns  for $ \d elt a \ rho$a nd $ \theta ^S$. Let  us f i rst work in th e  conformal Ne w to n i an gaug e.Initially i t ma y  not  see m  p oss i ble t o eli mi n at e  the degrees of fre ed om aswe ha ve that $\the ta^S \equi v \ theta^S(V,V ' ,V ' ')$ and $\delt a \rh o \equiv \ d elta \rh o(V,V ')$, i.e . we have t hree unk now nsand  on l y  t wo equations. H owev er , we ca n u se theper tur bed  Ae th er fieldequation  o fmo ti onto re d uce thedi men si ona lityo f theprobl em.Us in g  th is to e l im i n ate$V '' $ in  an dgathe ring ter ms in $ V$ and $V '$, we f in dthat $$ \begin{aligne d} 
a^2 \delt a\rh o =& \ h s pace{1mm } c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\ma t hcal{K} k^2  V' - \l eft[\alph a \ mathca l{F } _\math cal{K}  -c_{ 14 }\m a t hcal{ F } _\ mat hc al{K} + \f r a c{6  \alp ha ^2 \ mathcal {F}_\mathcal{KK} \ m ath cal{H}^2}{a^2  M^ 2} \ r i gh t]\ ma t hca l{ H }k^ 2 V \nonumber \\ +\hspace{ 1m m }& c_{14}\mat h cal {F }_\math cal{K}k^2 \ P si - 3\ alpha \ma thcal{H}\ le ft(\ m a thc al{F}_\mat hcal{K}+ \frac{6 \ alpha \m athca l{F }_\mat hc al{ KK}\m athcal { H}^ 2}{a^ 2 M^2}  \ right) 
i \delta_\varphi _\Rightarrow B_i = 0$$_i.e. there_is_no propagating_transverse_vector mode. Therefore,_if we redefine_$\dfrac{1}{\varphi'}\partial_i \delta \varphi _= \partial_i V$_then_we obtain the results from. Therefore, the scalar sector for Generalized Einstein-Aether and the_Khronon_are completely_equivalent_[@Blas2],_up to a redefinition of_the coefficients discussed previously.

Equations of_state for_perturbations {#sect:EoS}
====================================

Scalar sector {#scalar-sector}
-------------

We now derive the equations_of_state, $\Gamma$ and_$\Pi^{S,V,T}$, in terms of the other perturbation variables by_fully eliminating the internal degrees of_freedom introduced by_the_theory_i.e. $V$, $B^i$, and_their derivatives. In the scalar sector_we do this via the expressions_for $\delta \rho$ and $\theta^S$. Let us_first work in the conformal Newtonian_gauge. Initially it may not_seem possible_to eliminate the degrees of_freedom as we_have that_$\theta^S \equiv \theta^S_(V,V',V'')$ and $\delta \rho \equiv \delta_\rho(V,V')$, i.e. we_have three unknowns and only two_equations._However, we can_use_the_perturbed Aether_field equation of_motion_to reduce_the_dimensionality of the problem. Using this_to_eliminate $V''$ in and gathering terms in_$V$ and $V'$, we_find_that $$\begin{aligned}
a^2 \delta \rho_=& \hspace{1mm} c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K}k^2 V' _- \left[\alpha \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} -c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} + \frac{6_\alpha^2 \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK}_\mathcal{H}^2}{a^2 M^2}_\right] \mathcal{H}k^2 V \nonumber \\
 +\hspace{1mm}&c_{14}\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K} k^2 \Psi - 3\alpha \mathcal{H}\left(\mathcal{F}_\mathcal{K}_+ \frac{6\alpha \mathcal{F}_\mathcal{KK}\mathcal{H}^2}{a^2 M^2} \right)