DynamicFeedback2018; @hauswirthTimescaleSeparationAutonomous2019] which stipulate that the interconnection of *fast decaying* plant dynamics and *slow* optimization dynamics is asymptotically stable. The results in this section can be generalized to a dynamic plant accordingly.

[^11]: The penalty $d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ is illustrative in the context of autonomous optimization, however, it is not generally practical for numerical optimization, because evaluating $\nabla d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ requires computing $P_{\mathcal{U}}$. Instead, in numerical applications, it is more common to use a penalty $\| \max \{ A_u u - b_u, 0 \}\|^2$.
 Since the discovery of high-temperature superconductivity, doped antiferromagnets (AF) have been studied intensively. The pseudo-gap behavior observed in the high-$T_c$ cuprates has stimulated great interest in systems with spin gaps. Several new one- and two-dimensional spin gap systems have been found experimentally. These materials are characterized by a disordered singlet ground state and a finite gap to all spin excitations. Some of the compounds which have two-dimensional (2d) character include the coupled spin ladder systems, SrCu$_2$O$_3$[@srcu2o3], CaV$_2$O$_5$[@cav2o5], (VO$_2$)P$_2$O$_7$[@vopo], Cu$_2$(C$_5$H$_{12}$N$_2$)$_2$Cl$_4$[@cuHpCl], and the plaquette RVB system, CaV$_4$O$_9$[@cav4o9].

Recently the two-dimensional spin gap system [[SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$]{}]{} has been found by Kageyama [*et al.*]{}[@kag98]. It has a spin-singlet ground state with a spin gap $\sim 30$ K. The substance has additional interesting features, e.g., the high-field magnetization was observed to have two plateaus at 1/4 and 1/8 of the full moment. Recent work [@miy98] suggests that the underlying physics can be understood on the basis of a two-dimensional $S={1\over 2}$ Heisenberg model with antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor ($J_1$, on links $A$) and next-nearest-neighbor ($J_2
DynamicFeedback2018; @hauswirthTimescaleSeparationAutonomous2019 ] which stipulate that the interconnection of * fast decaying * plant dynamics and * slow * optimization dynamics is asymptotically static. The result in this section can be generalized to a active plant accordingly. 

 [ ^11 ]: The punishment $ d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ is illustrative in the context of autonomous optimization, however, it is not generally virtual for numeral optimization, because evaluating $ \nabla d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ necessitate computing $ P_{\mathcal{U}}$. Instead, in numeral applications, it is more common to practice a penalty $ \| \max \ { A_u u - b_u, 0 \}\|^2$. 
  Since the discovery of high - temperature superconductivity, doped antiferromagnets (AF) have been studied intensively. The pseudo - gap behavior observe in the high-$T_c$ cuprates has stimulated great interest in system with spin gaps. Several new one- and two - dimensional tailspin gap system have been found experimentally. These materials are characterized by a perturb singlet ground state and a finite gap to all spin excitations. Some of the compounds which have two - dimensional (2d) character include the coupled spin ladder systems, SrCu$_2$O$_3$[@srcu2o3 ], CaV$_2$O$_5$[@cav2o5 ], (VO$_2$)P$_2$O$_7$[@vopo ], Cu$_2$(C$_5$H$_{12}$N$_2$)$_2$Cl$_4$[@cuHpCl ], and the plaquette RVB system, CaV$_4$O$_9$[@cav4o9 ]. 

 Recently the two - dimensional spin gap system [ [ SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2 $ ] { } ] { } has been determine by Kageyama [ * et al.*]{}[@kag98 ]. It has a spin - singlet ground department of state with a spin gap $ \sim 30 $ K. The substance have additional interesting features, e.g., the high - airfield magnetization was observed to have two plateaus at 1/4 and 1/8 of the full moment. late work [ @miy98 ] suggests that the underlying physics can be understood on the basis of a two - dimensional $ S={1\over 2}$ Heisenberg model with antiferromagnetic nearest - neighbor ($ J_1 $, on connection $ A$) and next - near - neighbor ($ J_2
DynwmicFeedback2018; @hauswirthTioescaleSeparationAutonmmous2019] shich stkpulate that the interconnecvion of *fqst decaying* plant dynxmics and *slow* oprimieation dynamics is asymptoticalmn staylx. The results ik this secthon can be genarxlnzed to a dynamic plant accordingly.

[^11]: Ehe penslhy $d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ if ilktstrzniye in the context of autonomous kptimizetion, however, iy is not generally practicwl flr numerical optimlzation, becquse wvaluating $\nxbla d^2_{\mathbcl{U}}$ requirea computing $P_{\mathcal{U}}$. Instead, iv numzrical applucqtilts, it is moce comion to use a penalty $\| \max \{ S_u u - b_u, 0 \}\|^2$.
 Singe thx diwcovery of high-tempereture superconductivyty, doped autiferromagnets (AF) hace been stugied untdnsjvxly. The pdeuvo-gap behavjor observee in the high-$T_c$ cuptaevx has stimulzted gwewt interest in systems with spin gaps. Stveram new one- and two-dimensuonal spin gap systemd have beqn found experimentally. These materials are charawterivea bv a dirirfered singlet ground state and a finite gap tj akl spin excitatijns. Some of tje sompounds whizh havz tso-dimensional (2d) chwracter inclyde the cjuplrd spin ladder systems, SrCu$_2$I$_3$[@srcu2o3], CaV$_2$O$_5$[@ccv2o5], (VO$_2$)P$_2$O$_7$[@vopo], Cu$_2$(C$_5$H$_{12}$N$_2$)$_2$Cl$_4$[@cbHpCl], and thz plaqoette TVB system, CaV$_4$O$_9$[@cav4o9].

Receutly tge two-dimendional spjv gap system [[SrCj$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$]{}]{} hds been found by Kageyama [*qt al.*]{}[@kag98]. Mt hax a spiv-sinblet gwound statf witm a spin gap $\sim 30$ K. The dutstance had additional interesting featurxx, e.g., the hign-fhelg magnetnzatiok was observed eo have two plcteaus ac 1/4 and 1/8 of the flll momenv. Recent worh [@miy98] suggestv that the unverlying [hysucs xan be jvderstood on tne basis of a two-dinensional $S={1\over 2}$ Hcisencsrg model with cutuferromagnetic meafese-nvigibor ($T_1$, on links $A$) dnd vexg-mearert-neighbor ($M_2
DynamicFeedback2018; @hauswirthTimescaleSeparationAutonomous2019] which stipulate that the interconnection decaying* dynamics and optimization dynamics is this can be generalized a dynamic plant [^11]: The penalty $d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ is illustrative the context of autonomous optimization, however, it is not generally practical for numerical because evaluating $\nabla d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ requires computing $P_{\mathcal{U}}$. Instead, in numerical applications, it is common use penalty \max \{ A_u u - b_u, 0 \}\|^2$. Since the discovery of high-temperature superconductivity, doped antiferromagnets have been studied intensively. The pseudo-gap behavior observed the high-$T_c$ cuprates has great interest in systems with gaps. new one- two-dimensional gap have been found These materials are characterized by a disordered singlet ground state and a finite gap to all spin Some of which have (2d) include coupled spin ladder CaV$_2$O$_5$[@cav2o5], (VO$_2$)P$_2$O$_7$[@vopo], Cu$_2$(C$_5$H$_{12}$N$_2$)$_2$Cl$_4$[@cuHpCl], and the plaquette Recently the two-dimensional spin gap system [[SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$]{}]{} has found by [*et al.*]{}[@kag98]. It has a spin-singlet state with a spin gap $\sim 30$ K. substance has additional interesting features, e.g., the high-field magnetization was observed to have two plateaus and 1/8 of the moment. Recent work suggests the physics be understood the basis of a two-dimensional $S={1\over 2}$ Heisenberg model with antiferromagnetic ($J_1$, on links $A$) and next-nearest-neighbor ($J_2
DynamicFeedback2018; @hauswirthTImescaleSeParatIonautOnOmouS2019] whiCh stipulate thaT The iNterconnection of *fast deCayinG* pLAnt dYNaMics aNd *slow* oPTiMIZatIoN dYnaMiCS iS asymPtoTically Stable. The rEsuLtS in this sectiON cAn be generaLizEd to a dynamic PlaNt accoRdIngLY.

[^11]: The pEnaLty $d^2_{\mAthcal{u}}$ Is illuStrative iN tHE conteXT of autoNOMoUs opTimization, however, IT iS Not generally prActicaL fOR nUMEriCal OptimizatiOn, BecauSE evaluaTInG $\NABla D^2_{\Mathcal{U}}$ requiRes computinG $p_{\maThcal{U}}$. inSteAD, in numEricaL aPPliCations, it is More Common to uSe a penALty $\| \max \{ A_U U - b_u, 0 \}\|^2$.
 SincE the diScoVerY of hIGh-TeMpeRaTUre SUpErcONduCtivity, dOpEd AntifErroMAGNEts (Af) haVe beEn stuDied intensiveLy. THe psEUdo-Gap beHavioR obsErVed in The higH-$T_c$ cuPrAtes has stimulatEd grEat intereSt iN sYstEmS with SPin gapS. SeVerAl new onE- and two-DImeNsIONAl Spin gap systems have BeEN FoUnd experImentaLLy. thESe materiAlS arE chaRACteriZed bY A dIsordereD singlET gRoUnd statE aNd a finItE gaP to All spIN excItatioNs. Some of The coMPounds which havE Two-dimensionaL (2D) cHARaCTer iNclUde the couplEd spIN ladDer sYStEms, sRCu$_2$O$_3$[@sRcu2o3], CAV$_2$o$_5$[@CaV2O5], (VO$_2$)P$_2$O$_7$[@vopo], Cu$_2$(C$_5$H$_{12}$N$_2$)$_2$Cl$_4$[@cuHPCL], and thE plaqUette RVB systeM, CaV$_4$O$_9$[@cav4o9].

RECENtly the tWo-diMEnSIonal spin gap syStem [[SRCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$]{}]{} has beEN found by kageyAma [*et al.*]{}[@kAg98]. It has a sPIN-singlet GroUnd StaTe wITH a Spin gap $\sim 30$ K. ThE SUbstAnCe has adDitIonal inTerEstIng FeaTuRes, e.g., the hIgh-field MaGnEtIzAtiOn was OBserved tO hAve TwO plAteauS At 1/4 and 1/8 oF the fUll mOmEnT. recEnt work [@MIy98] SUGgesTs ThAt thE unDeRlyinG phySIcs Can be unDerstood oN thE BasiS oF a Two-dimeNsional $S={1\over 2}$ HEiSenberg modEl WitH antifERRomagnetIc nearest-neighbor ($J_1$, on linKS $A$) and neXt-nEaresT-neiGhbor ($J_2
DynamicFeedback2018; @haus wirthTimes caleS epa rat io nAut onom ous2019] which stip ulate that the interco nnect io n  of* fa st de caying* pl a n t d yn am ics  a n d*slow * o ptimiza tion dynam ics  i s asymptotic a ll y stable.The  results inthi s sect io n c a n begen erali zed to a dyna mic plant  a c cordin g ly.

[^ 1 1 ]:  The  penalty $d^2_{\m a th c al{U}}$ is ill ustrat iv e  i n the  co ntext of a ut onomo u s optim i za t i o n,h owever, it is  not genera l lypracti ca l f o r nume rical  o p tim ization, be caus e evaluat ing $\ n abla d^ 2 _{\math cal{U} }$req uire s  c om put in g  $P _ {\ mat h cal {U}}$. I ns te ad, i n nu m e r i calapp lica tions , it is morecom mont o u se apenal ty $ \|  \max  \{ A_ u u -  b _u, 0 \}\|^2$. Sin ce the di sco ve ryof  high - temper atu resuperco nductiv i ty,  d o p e dantiferromagnets ( AF ) ha ve beenstudie d  i nt e nsively.  T hepseu d o -gapbeha v io r observ ed int he  h igh-$T_ c$  cupra te s h asstimu l ated  great  interes t ins ystems with sp i n gaps. Sever a ln e wo ne-and  two-dimens iona l  spi n ga p  s yst e ms ha ve be en fo u nd experimentally.Th ese ma teria ls are charac terized by a disorder ed s i ng l et ground stat e and  a finiteg ap to al l spi n excita tions. So m e  of thecom pou nds  wh i c hhave two-dime n s iona l(2d) ch ara cter in clu dethe  co up led spinladder s ys te ms ,SrC u$_2$ O $_3$[@sr cu 2o3 ],  Ca V$_2$ O $_5$[@ cav2o 5],(V O$ _ 2$) P$_2$O$ _ 7$ [ @ vopo ],  C u$_2 $(C $_ 5$H$_ {12} $ N$_ 2$)$_2$ Cl$_4$[@c uHp C l],an dthe pla quette RVB sy st em, CaV$_4 $O $_9 $[@cav 4 o 9].

Rec ently the two-dimension a l spingap  syst em [ [SrCu$_2$ (BO $_3$)$ _2$ ] {}]{}has be en fo un d b y Kagey a m a[*e tal.*]{}[@k a g 98] . Itha s aspin-si nglet ground state wit h a spin gap$\s im 3 0 $  K . T h es ubs ta n ceh a s additional in terestingfe a tu res, e.g., the  h igh-fie ld magn etiza t ion was  observed  to havetw o pl a t eau s at 1/4 a nd 1/8 o f the ful l  mome n t.  Rece ntwork [ @m iy9 8] su ggests tha t the  under ly ing ph ysics  c an be un derstood on the basis o f a tw o-dim ens ional $S= {1\ o ver  2}$ Heis enbe rg model w ith  an tifer rom a gneti c ne a re st- n eighb or ( $ J_1$, onl in ks$ A $)  and next-n e a r est -neig hbo r  ($J_2 
DynamicFeedback2018; @hauswirthTimescaleSeparationAutonomous2019]_which stipulate_that the interconnection of_*fast decaying*_plant_dynamics and_*slow*_optimization dynamics is_asymptotically stable. The_results in this section_can be generalized_to_a dynamic plant accordingly.

[^11]: The penalty $d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ is illustrative in the context of autonomous_optimization,_however, it_is_not_generally practical for numerical optimization,_because evaluating $\nabla d^2_{\mathcal{U}}$ requires_computing $P_{\mathcal{U}}$._Instead, in numerical applications, it is more common_to_use a penalty_$\| \max \{ A_u u - b_u, 0 \}\|^2$.
_Since the discovery of high-temperature superconductivity,_doped antiferromagnets (AF)_have_been_studied intensively. The pseudo-gap_behavior observed in the high-$T_c$ cuprates_has stimulated great interest in systems_with spin gaps. Several new one- and_two-dimensional spin gap systems have been_found experimentally. These materials are_characterized by_a disordered singlet ground state_and a finite_gap to_all spin excitations._Some of the compounds which have_two-dimensional (2d) character_include the coupled spin ladder systems,_SrCu$_2$O$_3$[@srcu2o3],_CaV$_2$O$_5$[@cav2o5], (VO$_2$)P$_2$O$_7$[@vopo], Cu$_2$(C$_5$H$_{12}$N$_2$)$_2$Cl$_4$[@cuHpCl],_and_the_plaquette RVB_system, CaV$_4$O$_9$[@cav4o9].

Recently the_two-dimensional_spin gap_system_[[SrCu$_2$(BO$_3$)$_2$]{}]{} has been found by Kageyama_[*et_al.*]{}[@kag98]. It has a spin-singlet ground state_with a spin gap_$\sim_30$ K. The substance_has additional interesting features, e.g.,_the high-field magnetization was observed to_have two_plateaus at_1/4 and 1/8 of the full moment. Recent work [@miy98] suggests_that the underlying physics can be_understood on the basis_of a_two-dimensional_$S={1\over 2}$ Heisenberg_model_with antiferromagnetic_nearest-neighbor ($J_1$, on links $A$) and next-nearest-neighbor_($J_2