 space: $$\notag
{\rm tr}[\,(Q\Psi)\,\phi\,]+{\rm tr}[\,\Psi\Psi\,\phi\,]=0.$$

The Ellwood invariant {#el}
---------------------

In [@Ellwood:2008jh], Ellwood conjectured that there exists a relation between the gauge-invariant observables of open string field theory which were discovered in [@HI; @GRSZ], and the closed string tadpole on a disk.[^12] In this paper, we call these gauge-invariant observables the Ellwood invariant.

The Ellwood invariant for a classical solution $\Psi$ is defined by $$\notag
\mathcal W(\Psi,\, \phi_{\text{closed}})=
\Big\langle\, \phi_{\text{closed}}(i)\ f_I\circ \Psi(0)\,\Big
\rangle_{\text{UHP}}\,.$$ Here, $\phi_{\text{closed}}$ is a closed string vertex operator of weight (1,1) and ghost number 2; $\Psi(0)$ is the operator corresponding to the classical solution $\Psi$, and $f_I\circ \Psi(0)$ is the conformal transformation of $\Psi(0)$ under the map associated with the identity state, $$\notag
f_I(\xi)\equiv\frac{2\xi}{1-\xi^2}\,.$$ Ellwood conjectured that $\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})$ is equivalent to the difference of two tadpole diagrams, $$\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})= \mathcal A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed}})
-\mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})\,.$$ Here $\mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ denotes the closed string tadpole on a disk with the original boundary condition, and $\mathcal A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ denotes the closed string tadpole with the boundary condition corresponding to the classical solution $\Psi$.

In [@Murata:2011ex; @Murata:2011ep], Murata and Schnabl calculated the Ellwood invariant for the Okawa-type solution . Simply applying their formula to the solution, we find that the Ellwood invariant for the solution is zero, $$\notag
\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})=-\lim_{\epsilon\to 0}\left(
\lim_{z\to 0}\frac{d F_\epsilon(
space: $ $ \notag 
 { \rm tr}[\,(Q\Psi)\,\phi\,]+{\rm tr}[\,\Psi\Psi\,\phi\,]=0.$$ 

 The Ellwood invariant { # el } 
 --------------------- 

 In [ @Ellwood:2008jh ], Ellwood conjectured that there exist a relation back between the gauge - invariant observables of open drawstring field theory which were discover in [ @HI; @GRSZ ], and the shut string tadpole on a disk.[^12 ] In this paper, we call these gauge - invariant observables the Ellwood changeless. 

 The Ellwood invariant for a classical solution $ \Psi$ is defined by $ $ \notag 
 \mathcal W(\Psi,\, \phi_{\text{closed}})= 
 \Big\langle\, \phi_{\text{closed}}(i)\ f_I\circ \Psi(0)\,\Big 
 \rangle_{\text{UHP}}\,.$$ Here, $ \phi_{\text{closed}}$ is a closed string vertex hustler of weight (1,1) and ghost numeral 2; $ \Psi(0)$ is the operator corresponding to the authoritative solution $ \Psi$, and $ f_I\circ \Psi(0)$ is the conformal transformation of $ \Psi(0)$ under the map associated with the identity state, $ $ \notag 
 f_I(\xi)\equiv\frac{2\xi}{1-\xi^2}\,.$$ Ellwood speculate that $ \mathcal{W } (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})$ is equivalent to the difference of two tadpole diagrams, $ $ \mathcal{W } (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})= \mathcal A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed } }) 
 -\mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})\,.$$ Here $ \mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ denotes the closed string tadpole on a phonograph record with the original boundary condition, and $ \mathcal A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ denotes the closed string tadpole with the boundary condition correspond to the classical solution $ \Psi$. 

 In [ @Murata:2011ex; @Murata:2011ep ], Murata and Schnabl calculated the Ellwood invariant for the Okawa - type solution  . Simply applying their formula to the solution, we find that the Ellwood invariant for the solution is zero, $ $ \notag 
 \mathcal{W } (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})=-\lim_{\epsilon\to 0}\left (
 \lim_{z\to 0}\frac{d F_\epsilon (
 spwce: $$\notag
{\rm tr}[\,(Q\Psi)\,\phi\,]+{\rm ur}[\,\Psi\Psi\,\phi\,]=0.$$

The Ellwood iivarianf {#el}
---------------------

In [@Eulwood:2008jh], Ellwood conjectured tyat tyere exists a relation between nhe gauge-unvaciant observables of opek strjkg fizlv theory which eere discoeered in [@HI; @GRVZ], aud the closed string tadpole on a difk.[^12] In tnid paper, we calj thtse gaufv-ikvariant observables the Ellwood invarient.

The Ellwood onvariant for a classical doluhion $\Psi$ is definef by $$\notag
\mqthcwo W(\Psi,\, \phi_{\tebt{closed}})=
\Big\langle\, \phi_{\tgxt{closed}}(i)\ f_I\circ \Psi(0)\,\Big
\rangle_{\tebt{UHP}}\,.$$ Here, $\phi_{\tgrr{cllved}}$ is a clised ftring vertew operador of eeight (1,1) and ghpst nunber 2; $\Psi(0)$ is the operetor corresponding tj the clavsncal solution $\Psi$, and $f_U\circ \Psi(0)$ is gye zonrocmam trandfocmation of $\Lsi(0)$ under tye map associated wotr the identity state, $$\njtag
f_I(\xi)\equiv\frac{2\xi}{1-\xi^2}\,.$$ Ellwood conjecturtd thzt $\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{coosed}})$ is equivalent tl the difserence of two tadpole diagrams, $$\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\teft{cloadd}})= \nabhcau A_\Osi(\phi_{\text{closed}})
-\mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})\,.$$ Here $\mwfhvak A_0(\phi_{\text{closcd}})$ denotes the cloxef xjring tadpole un a dnak with the original boundaty coneition, anq $\mayhcal A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ denites the clofwd string tadpole cith the bouudary vondiyion corresponding to tke claasical soluhion $\Psi$.

Ih [@Murata:2011ex; @Murata:2011dp], Kusata and Schnabl calculateq the Ellxood nnvariang fot the Ohawa-type sllution . Simply applying hheir fmrmula to hhe solution, we find that the Ellwood invariamt fog the solbtion ls zero, $$\notag
\maehcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\tgxt{closed}})=-\jim_{\eprilon\to 0}\lert(
\lim_{z\tm 0}\frac{d F_\epfilon(
space: $$\notag {\rm tr}[\,(Q\Psi)\,\phi\,]+{\rm tr}[\,\Psi\Psi\,\phi\,]=0.$$ The Ellwood --------------------- [@Ellwood:2008jh], Ellwood that there exists observables open string field which were discovered [@HI; @GRSZ], and the closed string on a disk.[^12] In this paper, we call these gauge-invariant observables the Ellwood The Ellwood invariant for a classical solution $\Psi$ is defined by $$\notag \mathcal \phi_{\text{closed}})= \phi_{\text{closed}}(i)\ \Psi(0)\,\Big Here, $\phi_{\text{closed}}$ is a closed string vertex operator of weight (1,1) and ghost number 2; $\Psi(0)$ the operator corresponding to the classical solution $\Psi$, $f_I\circ \Psi(0)$ is the transformation of $\Psi(0)$ under the associated the identity $$\notag Ellwood that $\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})$ equivalent to the difference of two tadpole diagrams, $$\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})= \mathcal A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed}}) -\mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})\,.$$ Here $\mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ the closed on a with original condition, and $\mathcal the closed string tadpole with the to the classical solution $\Psi$. In [@Murata:2011ex; @Murata:2011ep], and Schnabl the Ellwood invariant for the Okawa-type . Simply applying their formula to the solution, find that the Ellwood invariant for the solution is zero, $$\notag \mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})=-\lim_{\epsilon\to 0}\left( \lim_{z\to
 space: $$\notag
{\rm tr}[\,(Q\Psi)\,\phi\,]+{\rm tr}[\,\psi\Psi\,\phi\,]=0.$$

THe EllWooD inVaRianT {#el}
---------------------

IN [@Ellwood:2008jh], EllwOOd coNjectured that there exisTs a reLaTIon bETwEen thE gauge-iNVaRIAnt ObSeRvaBlES oF open StrIng fielD theory whiCh wErE discovered iN [@hI; @gRSZ], and the CloSed string tadPolE on a diSk.[^12] in tHIs papEr, wE call These gAUge-invAriant obsErVAbles tHE EllwooD INvAriaNt.

The Ellwood invarIAnT For a classical sOlutioN $\PSI$ iS DEfiNed By $$\notag
\matHcAl W(\PsI,\, \Phi_{\text{CLoSED}})=
\big\LAngle\, \phi_{\text{cLosed}}(i)\ f_I\cirC \psi(0)\,\big
\ranGlE_{\teXT{UHP}}\,.$$ HeRe, $\phi_{\TeXT{clOsed}}$ is a closEd stRing verteX operaTOr of weiGHt (1,1) and ghOst numBer 2; $\psi(0)$ Is thE OpErAtoR cORreSPoNdiNG to The classIcAl SolutIon $\PSI$, AND $f_I\cIrc \psi(0)$ iS the cOnformal transForMatiON of $\psi(0)$ unDer thE map AsSociaTed witH the iDeNtity state, $$\notag
F_I(\xi)\Equiv\frac{2\Xi}{1-\xI^2}\,.$$ ELlwOoD conjECtured ThaT $\maThcal{W} (\PSi,\,\phi_{\teXT{clOsED}})$ IS eQuivalent to the diffErENCe Of two tadPole diAGrAmS, $$\Mathcal{W} (\psI,\,\phI_{\texT{CLosed}})= \MathCAl a_\Psi(\phi_{\tExt{cloSEd}})
-\MaThcal A_0(\pHi_{\Text{clOsEd}})\,.$$ HEre $\MathcAL A_0(\phI_{\text{cLosed}})$ denOtes tHE closed string tADpole on a disk wITh THE oRIginAl bOundary condItioN, And $\mAthcAL A_\psi(\PHi_{\texT{closEd}})$ DEnOTes the closed string tAdPole wiTh the Boundary condiTion corresPONDing to thE claSSiCAl solution $\Psi$.

IN [@MuraTa:2011ex; @Murata:2011EP], Murata aNd SchNabl calcUlated the eLLwood invAriAnt For The oKAwA-type solution . sIMply ApPlying tHeiR formulA to The SolUtiOn, We find thaT the EllwOoD iNvArIanT for tHE solutioN iS zeRo, $$\NotAg
\matHCal{W} (\PsI,\,\phi_{\tExt{cLoSeD}})=-\Lim_{\Epsilon\TO 0}\lEFT(
\lim_{Z\tO 0}\fRac{d f_\epSiLon(
 space: $$\notag
{\rm tr}[ \,(Q\Psi)\ ,\phi \,] +{\ rm  tr} [\,\ Psi\Psi\,\phi\ , ]=0. $$

The Ellwood invari ant { #e l }
-- - -- ----- ------- - -- - 
In  [ @E llw oo d :2 008jh ],Ellwood  conjectur edth at there exi s ts  a relatio n b etween the g aug e-inva ri ant obser vab les o f open string  field th eo r y whic h  were d i s co vere d in [@HI; @GRSZ] ,  a n d the closed s tringta d po l e  on  adisk.[^12]  I n thi s  paper, we c a llt hese gauge-in variant obs e rva bles t he  El l wood i nvari an t .
The Ellwood  inv ariant fo r a cl a ssicals olution  $\Psi $ i s d efin e dby  $$ \n o tag \m ath c alW(\Psi,\ ,\p hi_{\ text { c l o sed} })= 
\Bi g\lan gle\, \phi_{\ tex t{cl o sed }}(i) \ f_I \cir c\Psi( 0)\,\B ig
\r an gle_{\text{UHP} }\,. $$ Here,$\p hi _{\ te xt{cl o sed}}$  is  aclosedstringv ert ex o p er ator of weight (1, 1) a nd  ghost n umber2 ;$\ P si(0)$ i sthe  ope r a tor c orre s po nding to  the c l as si cal sol ut ion $\ Ps i$,  an d $f_ I \cir c \Psi (0)$ isthe c o nformal transf o rmation of $\ P si ( 0 )$ unde r t he map asso ciat e d wi th t h eide n titystate ,$ $\ n otag
f_I(\xi)\equiv \f rac{2\ xi}{1 -\xi^2}\,.$$Ellwood co n j e ctured t hat$ \m a thcal{W} (\Psi ,\,\p hi_{\text{ c losed}}) $ isequivale nt to the d ifferenc e o f t wotad p o le  diagrams, $$ \ m athc al {W} (\P si, \,\phi_ {\t ext {cl ose d} })= \math cal A_\P si (\ ph i_ {\t ext{c l osed}})-\ mat hc alA_0(\ p hi_{\t ext{c lose d} }) \ ,.$ $ Here$ \m a t hcal  A _0 (\ph i_{ \t ext{c lose d }}) $ denot es the cl ose d  str in gtadpole  on a disk wi th  the origi na l b oundar y conditio n, and $\mathcal A_\Psi ( \phi_{\ tex t{clo sed} })$ denot esthe cl ose d  strin g tadp ole w it h t h e  boun d a ry  co nd ition corr e s pon dingto  the  classi cal solution $\Psi $ .
In [@Murata:2 011 ex;@ M ur ata : 20 1 1ep ], Mur a t a and Schnabl c alculatedth e  E llwood inv a ria nt  for th e Okawa -type solutio n . Simpl y applyin gthei r for mula to th e soluti on, we fi n d tha t  t he El lwo od inv ar ian t for  the s o lut ion i s zero ,$$\not ag
\m at hcal{W}(\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{clo sed}}) =-\li m_{ \epsilon\ to0 }\l eft(
\lim _{z\ to 0}\frac {dF_\ epsil on( 
 space:_$$\notag
{\rm tr}[\,(Q\Psi)\,\phi\,]+{\rm_tr}[\,\Psi\Psi\,\phi\,]=0.$$

The Ellwood invariant {#el}
---------------------

In_[@Ellwood:2008jh], Ellwood_conjectured_that there_exists_a relation between_the gauge-invariant observables_of open string field_theory which were_discovered_in [@HI; @GRSZ], and the closed string tadpole on a disk.[^12] In this paper,_we_call these_gauge-invariant_observables_the Ellwood invariant.

The Ellwood invariant_for a classical solution $\Psi$_is defined_by $$\notag
\mathcal W(\Psi,\, \phi_{\text{closed}})=
\Big\langle\, \phi_{\text{closed}}(i)\ f_I\circ \Psi(0)\,\Big
\rangle_{\text{UHP}}\,.$$ Here,_$\phi_{\text{closed}}$_is a closed_string vertex operator of weight (1,1) and ghost number_2; $\Psi(0)$ is the operator corresponding_to the classical_solution_$\Psi$,_and $f_I\circ \Psi(0)$ is_the conformal transformation of $\Psi(0)$ under_the map associated with the identity_state, $$\notag
f_I(\xi)\equiv\frac{2\xi}{1-\xi^2}\,.$$ Ellwood conjectured that $\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})$_is equivalent to the difference of_two tadpole diagrams, $$\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})=_\mathcal A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed}})
-\mathcal_A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})\,.$$ Here $\mathcal A_0(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ denotes_the closed string_tadpole on_a disk with_the original boundary condition, and $\mathcal_A_\Psi(\phi_{\text{closed}})$ denotes the_closed string tadpole with the boundary_condition_corresponding to the_classical_solution_$\Psi$.

In [@Murata:2011ex;_@Murata:2011ep], Murata and_Schnabl_calculated the_Ellwood_invariant for the Okawa-type solution . Simply_applying_their formula to the solution, we find_that the Ellwood invariant_for_the solution is zero,_$$\notag
\mathcal{W} (\Psi,\,\phi_{\text{closed}})=-\lim_{\epsilon\to 0}\left(
\lim_{z\to 0}\frac{d F_\epsilon(