}{\omega^2}\right)^{1/2}\frac{dr}{r}=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega}.
\label{eq-osc26}$$ Since the lower integral limit, $r_1$ depends only on the ratio $L/\omega$, then the whole left-hand side is a function of only one parameter, $L/\omega$, that is: $$F\left(\frac{L}{\omega}\right)=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega}.$$ This relation represents so-called Duvall’s law [@Duvall1982]. It means that a 2D dispersion relation $\omega=\omega(n,l)$ is reduced to the 1D relation between two ratios $L/\omega$ and $(n+\alpha)/\omega$. With an appropriate choice of parameter $\alpha$ (e.g. 1.5) these ratios can easily calculated from a table of observed solar frequencies. An example of such calculations shown in Fig. \[fig20\]) illustrates that the Duvall’s law holds quite well for the observed solar modes. The short bottom branch that separates from the main curve correspond to f-modes.

![The observed Duvall’s law relation for modes of $l=0-250$.[]{data-label="fig20"}](kosovichev_fig20.eps){width="0.6\linewidth"}

Asymptotic sound-speed inversion
--------------------------------

The Duvall’s law demonstrate that the asymptotic theory provides a rather accurate description of the observed solar p-modes. Thus, it can be used for solving the inverse problem of helioseismology - determination of the internal properties from the observed frequencies. Theoretically, the internal structure of the Sun is described by the stellar evolution theory [@Christensen-Dalsgaard1996]. This theory calculates the thermodynamic structure of the Sun during the evolution on the Main Sequence. The evolutionary model of the current age, $\approx 4.6\times 10^9$ years, is called the standard solar model. Helioseismology provides estimates of the interior properties, such as the sound-speed profiles, that can be compared with the predictions of the standard model.

Our goal is to find corrections to a solar model from the observed frequency differences between the Sun and the model using the asymptotic formula for the Duvall’s law [@Christensen-Dalsgaard1988].

We consider a small perturbation of the sound-speed, $c\
} { \omega^2}\right)^{1/2}\frac{dr}{r}=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega }. 
 \label{eq - osc26}$$ Since the lower integral limit, $ r_1 $ depends merely on the proportion $ L/\omega$, then the whole left - bridge player english is a function of only one argument, $ L/\omega$, that is: $ $ F\left(\frac{L}{\omega}\right)=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega}.$$ This relation represents so - call Duvall ’s law [ @Duvall1982 ]. It means that a 2D distribution relation $ \omega=\omega(n, l)$ is reduced to the 1D relation between two ratios $ L/\omega$ and $ (n+\alpha)/\omega$. With an appropriate option of parameter $ \alpha$ (e.g. 1.5) these ratio can easily calculated from a mesa of observed solar frequencies. An example of such calculation shown in Fig.   \[fig20\ ]) illustrates that the Duvall ’s law hold quite well for the observed solar modes. The short bottom branch that separates from the chief curve correspond to f - modes. 

! [ The observed Duvall ’s law relation for modes of $ l=0 - 250$.[]{data - label="fig20"}](kosovichev_fig20.eps){width="0.6\linewidth " } 

 Asymptotic sound - speed inversion 
 -------------------------------- 

 The Duvall ’s law demonstrate that the asymptotic theory provides a rather accurate description of the observed solar p - modes. therefore, it can be use for solving the inverse trouble of helioseismology - decision of the inner properties from the observed frequencies. Theoretically, the internal structure of the Sun is described by the stellar development theory [ @Christensen - Dalsgaard1996 ]. This theory calculates the thermodynamic structure of the Sun during the evolution on the Main Sequence. The evolutionary model of the current age, $ \approx 4.6\times 10 ^ 9 $ years, is called the standard solar model. Helioseismology provides estimates of the home properties, such as the heavy - speed profiles, that can be compared with the predictions of the standard model. 

 Our finish is to find corrections to a solar model from the observed frequency differences between the Sun and the model using the asymptotic formula for the Duvall ’s law [ @Christensen - Dalsgaard1988 ]. 

 We regard a small disruption of the sound - speed, $ c\
}{\omeha^2}\right)^{1/2}\frac{dr}{r}=\frac{\pi(n+\alpma)}{\omega}.
\label{eq-ose26}$$ Since the lkwer intdgral limit, $r_1$ depends only oi thw ratuo $L/\omega$, then the whoue left-hajd side us a dunction oh only okz parzletex, $O/\omega$, that is: $$F\left(\frac{N}{\omega}\right)=\fraw{\pk(n+\clpha)}{\omega}.$$ This relation represents fo-callec Fuvall’s law [@Dudall1982]. Yt msans that a 2D dispersion relation $\kmega=\omtga(n,l)$ is reduced tp the 1D relation between tao rwtios $L/\omega$ and $(n+\wlpha)/\omega$. Qith qn appropriage choice of parameter $\alpha$ (e.g. 1.5) these ratios can easkly cclculated ftoj w table of ouserveq solar freqmvncies. Dn examlle of such cakcunatuons shown in Fig. \[fig20\]) mllustrates that the Duvall’s nac holds quite well foe rhe otsereed rilaf mkdxs. Fhe shlrt bottom brznch that swparates from the msig curve correslond tj s-modes.

![The observed Duvall’s law relation fod modes of $l=0-250$.[]{data-label="fit20"}](kosovichev_fig20.eps){widtj="0.6\linewidtr"}

Asymptotic sound-speed inversion
--------------------------------

The Duvall’s law damonsvrxte tmat gye asymptotic theory provides a rather accurate sexcgiption of the obferved solat o-mpqes. Thus, it cxn be baes for solving the lnverse proboem of hejiosrismology - determination of the internaj properties from tke observed yrequemcies. Theoretically, the intexnal sfructure of the Sun jr described by tfe xtallar evolution theory [@Chrystensen-Delsgacrd1996]. This thepry cajculates tje thcsmodynamic structuge of tve Sun durlng the evolution on the Main Sxauence. The efonutponary mobel of the current wge, $\approx 4.6\timgs 10^9$ years, is cxlled the atandarv solar modej. Helioseismonlgy provides estimatqs od thw interkur properties, xuch as tkt sound-spewd profiles, that cen bg dompared with tkt ptwdictions of tne rtagdwrv modqn.

Our goal is to wina corrdctions to c rolat model from the obsarves frequency differrnges betwegn the Sug and the modrl using the asympuotic hormule for yhe Duvall’s law [@Christensen-Dalsgazrd1988].

We condidcr a small pewturnatijn of the xound-speed, $c\
}{\omega^2}\right)^{1/2}\frac{dr}{r}=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega}. \label{eq-osc26}$$ Since the lower integral limit, only the ratio then the whole of one parameter, $L/\omega$, is: $$F\left(\frac{L}{\omega}\right)=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega}.$$ This represents so-called Duvall’s law [@Duvall1982]. It that a 2D dispersion relation $\omega=\omega(n,l)$ is reduced to the 1D relation between ratios $L/\omega$ and $(n+\alpha)/\omega$. With an appropriate choice of parameter $\alpha$ (e.g. 1.5) ratios easily from table of observed solar frequencies. An example of such calculations shown in Fig. \[fig20\]) illustrates that Duvall’s law holds quite well for the observed modes. The short bottom that separates from the main correspond f-modes. ![The Duvall’s relation modes of $l=0-250$.[]{data-label="fig20"}](kosovichev_fig20.eps){width="0.6\linewidth"} sound-speed inversion -------------------------------- The Duvall’s law demonstrate that the asymptotic theory provides a rather accurate description of observed solar it can used solving inverse problem of determination of the internal properties from Theoretically, the internal structure of the Sun is by the evolution theory [@Christensen-Dalsgaard1996]. This theory calculates thermodynamic structure of the Sun during the evolution the Main Sequence. The evolutionary model of the current age, $\approx 4.6\times 10^9$ years, is standard solar model. Helioseismology estimates of the properties, as sound-speed that can compared with the predictions of the standard model. Our goal is find corrections to a solar model from the observed frequency the and the model the asymptotic formula for Duvall’s [@Christensen-Dalsgaard1988]. We consider a of sound-speed,
}{\omega^2}\right)^{1/2}\frac{dr}{r}=\frac{\pi(n+\aLpha)}{\omega}.
\lAbel{eQ-osC26}$$ SiNcE the LoweR integral limit, $R_1$ DepeNds only on the ratio $L/\omegA$, then ThE WholE LeFt-hanD side is A FuNCTioN oF oNly OnE PaRametEr, $L/\Omega$, thAt is: $$F\left(\fRac{l}{\oMega}\right)=\fraC{\Pi(N+\alpha)}{\omegA}.$$ ThIs relation rePreSents sO-cAllED DuvaLl’s Law [@DuVall1982]. It MEans thAt a 2D dispeRsIOn relaTIon $\omegA=\OMeGa(n,l)$ Is reduced to the 1D reLAtIOn between two raTios $L/\oMeGA$ aND $(N+\alPha)/\Omega$. With aN aPpropRIate choICe OF PAraMEter $\alpha$ (e.g. 1.5) thEse ratios caN EasIly calCuLatED from a Table Of OBseRved solar frEqueNcies. An exAmple oF Such calCUlationS shown In FIg. \[fIg20\]) ilLUsTrAteS tHAt tHE DUvaLL’s lAw holds qUiTe Well fOr thE OBSErveD soLar mOdes. THe short bottom BraNch tHAt sEparaTes frOm thE mAin cuRve corRespoNd To f-modes.

![The obseRved duvall’s laW reLaTioN fOr modES of $l=0-250$.[]{daTa-lAbeL="fig20"}](kosOvichev_FIg20.ePs){WIDTh="0.6\Linewidth"}

AsymptotiC sOUNd-Speed invErsion
--------------------------------

tHe duVAll’s law dEmOnsTratE THat thE asyMPtOtic theoRy provIDeS a Rather aCcUrate dEsCriPtiOn of tHE obsErved sOlar p-modEs. ThuS, It can be used for SOlving the inveRSe PRObLEm of HelIoseismologY - detERminAtioN Of The INternAl proPeRTiES from the observed freQuEncies. theorEtically, the inTernal struCTURe of the SUn is DEsCRibed by the stelLar evOlution theORy [@ChristEnsen-dalsgaarD1996]. This theoRY CalculatEs tHe tHerModYNAmIc structure of THE Sun DuRing the EvoLution oN thE MaIn SEquEnCe. The evolUtionary MoDeL oF tHe cUrrenT Age, $\approX 4.6\tImeS 10^9$ yEarS, is caLLed the StandArd sOlAr MOdeL. HeliosEIsMOLogy PrOvIdes EstImAtes oF the INteRior proPerties, suCh aS The sOuNd-Speed prOfiles, that can Be Compared wiTh The PredicTIOns of the Standard model.

Our goal is tO Find corRecTions To a sOlar model FroM the obSerVEd freqUency dIfferEnCes BETween THE SUn aNd The model usING thE asymPtOtic Formula For the Duvall’s law [@ChRIstEnsen-DalsgaarD1988].

We ConsIDEr A smALl PErtUrBAtiON Of the sound-speed, $C\
}{\omega^2}\right)^{1/2}\f rac{dr}{r} =\fra c{\ pi( n+ \alp ha)} {\omega}.
\lab e l{eq -osc26}$$ Since the lo wer i nt e gral li mit,$r_1$ d e pe n d s o nl yonth e  r atio$L/ \omega$ , then the  wh ol e left-hands id e is a fun cti on of only o neparame te r,$ L/\om ega $, th at is: $$F\le ft(\frac{ L} { \omega } \right) = \ fr ac{\ pi(n+\alpha)}{\om e ga } .$$ This relat ion re pr e se n t s s o-c alled Duva ll ’s la w  [@Duva l l1 9 8 2 ].I t means thata 2D disper s ion  relat io n $ \ omega= \omeg a( n ,l) $ is reduce d to  the 1D r elatio n  betwee n  two ra tios $ L/\ ome ga$a nd  $ (n+ \a l pha ) /\ ome g a$.  With an  a pp ropri atec h o i ce o f p aram eter$\alpha$ (e.g . 1 .5)t hes e rat ios c an e as ily c alcula ted f ro m a table of ob serv ed solarfre qu enc ie s. An exampl e o f s uch cal culatio n s s ho w n in  Fig. \[fig20\]) i ll u s tr ates tha t theD uv al l ’s law h ol dsquit e wellfort he  observe d sola r  m od es. The  s hort b ot tom  br ancht hatsepara tes from  them ain curve corr e spond to f-mo d es . 
! [ Theobs erved Duval l’sl aw r elat i on  fo r  mode s of$l = 0- 2 50$.[]{data-label=" fi g20"}] (koso vichev_fig20. eps){width = " 0 .6\linew idth " }Asymptotic sou nd-sp eed invers i on
----- ----- -------- --------- - - ---

The  Du val l’s  la w de monstrate tha t theas ymptoti c t heory p rov ide s a  ra th er accura te descr ip ti on  o f t he ob s erved so la r p -m ode s. Th u s, itcan b e us ed  f o r s olvingt he i nver se  p robl emof  heli osei s mol ogy - d eterminat ion of t he  i nternal  properties f ro m the obse rv edfreque n c ies. The oretically, the interna l  struct ure  of t he S un is des cri bed by  th e  stell ar evo lutio nthe o r y [@C h r is ten se n-Dalsgaar d 1 996 ]. Th is  the ory cal culates the thermo d yna mic structure  of  the S un  du r in g  th ee vol u t ion on the Main  Sequence.  T h eevolutiona r y m od el of t he curr ent a g e, $\ap prox 4.6\ times 10^ 9$  yea r s , i s called t he stand ard solar model .  H elios eis mology  p rov idesestima t esof th e inte ri or pro perti es , such a s the sound-speed profi les, t hat c anbe compar edw ith  the pred icti ons of the  st and ard m ode l .

Ou r go a list o fin d co r rectionst oa s o l ar  model from t h e o bserv edf requen cy d ifferences betwee n  the Sun and t he m o d elusi n g th easymptotic for mul af o r the Du va ll’s law [@ Christen se n -Dals gaard1 988].
We con s i de r  a sma ll p ert urbationofth e  sound- sp ee d , $c\
}{\omega^2}\right)^{1/2}\frac{dr}{r}=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega}.
\label{eq-osc26}$$ Since_the lower_integral limit, $r_1$ depends_only on_the_ratio $L/\omega$,_then_the whole left-hand_side is a_function of only one_parameter, $L/\omega$, that_is:_$$F\left(\frac{L}{\omega}\right)=\frac{\pi(n+\alpha)}{\omega}.$$ This relation represents so-called Duvall’s law [@Duvall1982]. It means that a 2D dispersion_relation_$\omega=\omega(n,l)$ is_reduced_to_the 1D relation between two_ratios $L/\omega$ and $(n+\alpha)/\omega$. With_an appropriate_choice of parameter $\alpha$ (e.g. 1.5) these ratios_can_easily calculated from_a table of observed solar frequencies. An example of_such calculations shown in Fig. \[fig20\]) illustrates_that the Duvall’s_law_holds_quite well for the_observed solar modes. The short bottom_branch that separates from the main_curve correspond to f-modes.

![The observed Duvall’s law_relation for modes of $l=0-250$.[]{data-label="fig20"}](kosovichev_fig20.eps){width="0.6\linewidth"}

Asymptotic sound-speed_inversion
--------------------------------

The Duvall’s law demonstrate that_the asymptotic_theory provides a rather accurate_description of the_observed solar_p-modes. Thus, it_can be used for solving the_inverse problem of_helioseismology - determination of the internal_properties_from the observed_frequencies._Theoretically,_the internal_structure of the_Sun_is described_by_the stellar evolution theory [@Christensen-Dalsgaard1996]. This_theory_calculates the thermodynamic structure of the Sun_during the evolution on_the_Main Sequence. The evolutionary_model of the current age,_$\approx 4.6\times 10^9$ years, is called_the standard_solar model._Helioseismology provides estimates of the interior properties, such as the sound-speed_profiles, that can be compared with_the predictions of the_standard model.

Our_goal_is to find_corrections_to a_solar model from the observed frequency differences_between the_Sun and the model using the_asymptotic formula for the_Duvall’s_law [@Christensen-Dalsgaard1988].

We consider a small perturbation_of the sound-speed, $c\