premise: Elisha Cuthbert stars in The Quiet.
hypothesis: He Was a Quiet Man is a 2007 drama film , written and directed by Frank Cappello and film stars Christian Slater , Elisha Cuthbert , Jamison Jones and William H. Macy . The Quiet is a 2005 American drama thriller film directed by Jamie Babbit and starring Camilla Belle and Elisha Cuthbert . It focuses on a deaf-mute teenage girl , Dot ( Camilla Belle ) who goes to live with her godparents ( played by Martin Donovan and Edie Falco ) after her father dies , where she slowly learns the disturbing secrets of the family , primarily concerning their teenage daughter , Nina ( Elisha Cuthbert ) .