Conversely, take the new statement by Alice, who is tall, " is grossly overweight." Bob, who is , and weighs an exact, well-conditioned , replies, "That may be true for you, but it is not true for me." In this context, Bob's reply is both meaningful and arguably accurate. As he is discussing something that is true about himself, he is not barred from making an argument that considers subjective facts, and so he does not commit the fallacy.
conVeRseLy, take the New statEmEnT By ALICe, whO is tall, " is GROsSly ovERWeIght." Bob, WHo is , and weIghs an ExAct, weLl-ConditIoneD , REpliEs, "thAT May bE True FOR you, buT It Is nOt TruE For Me." in this COnteXt, BOB's reply is botH meaNingful anD argUablY aCcURate. aS he iS DiscuSsing soMethINg thAt iS tRue abouT himself, He iS not baRrEd froM makiNg an ARgUMent ThAT ConsiDers suBJEctive fACTs, aNd So he Does Not cOMmIt tHE fAlLaCY.