On August 4, 2022, it was announced that the entire Broadway cast would remain with the show through September 4. On September 6, married couple Stephanie J. Block and Sebastian Arcelus replaced Bareilles and James as the Baker's Wife and the Baker. Other replacements included Krysta Rodriguez as Cinderella, Katy Geraghty replacing Julia Lester as Little Red, and Jim Stanek replacing David Turner as the Steward. Montego Glover also began sharing the role of the Witch with Miller, and Andy Karl played a limited run as the Wolf/Cinderella's Prince from September 6–15, filling in for Creel. Ann Harada joined the cast reprising her role as Jack's mother from the Encores! production on September 27. During that same month, it was announced that the production was given a final extension through January 8, 2023. On September 22, it was announced that James would return to the cast as the Baker starting October 25, and Karl would also return, this time as Rapunzel's Prince, starting October 11. The cast album was released on September 30. On October 25, it was announced that Denée Benton would join the cast reprising her role as Cinderella from the Encores! production on November 21. She left the production on December 24. On November 17, it was announced that Joaquina Kalukango would start playing the Witch from December 16 to the show's closing date January 8. Karl's extended run ended December 2 for the return of Henry. That same day, the cast recording was released on CD. On December 15, it was announced that understudy Diane Phelan would take over as Cinderella on December 26 for the last two weeks of the show's run. It was also announced that Arcelus would return to the production, replacing James as the Baker, starting January 3.
on aUgust 4 2022 It was AnnouNceD tHat the entIRe BRoAdWay cast woUld remaiN wItH the sHOw thrOUgh sEptemBER 4 on septeMBEr 6 marriED COuPlE sTEphaNiE j blOcK And SeBastian ARceLUs REPlaCeD bArEiLles aND jamEs as the Baker's wiFe AND the Baker otheR REPLacements included krYsta rodriGUez AS CindeRella KaTy GERaghTY rEplaciNg Julia leSTer AS liTtLE red aNd jIM staNek REPLACing daVId turnEr as the SteWard MoNteGO glover AlsO begaN sHarIng ThE roLe oF The wiTCH with miller And andy kaRl plAyed a LimiTED run As tHE woLf/CIndERella's pRincE frOm sEpTEmbER 6–15 filLing in foR CreeL aNn HAradA JoInED thE casT rePriSInG Her role as JaCk's motheR from the EncOres ProduCtion on SePteMBeR 27 DuRinG that same MOntH iT was announced THat the proDuCTIOn was GivEn a Final eXTeNsIon ThrougH jaNuarY 8 2023 On sEPtember 22 It wAs annouNced THAt James wOuld return To thE cAst as The bakeR stArting october 25 aND KARL wOulD Also rETurn ThiS tIme aS raPunzEl's Prince stARtIng oCtobeR 11 tHe caSt ALbum was reLEAsed On septeMbEr 30 on ocTOBeR 25 iT waS AnnoUncEd ThAT denée benToN wOulD JOiN tHe caSt repRising her role aS cinDeRella from tHe EncOres ProDuctIoN on noveMbER 21 ShE LEft tHE PRoduction on deCemBer 24 On novembeR 17 it was AnnoUnced thAt joaqUina kalukangO wOULD sTart PlayiNg THe WItCH from decEmber 16 To tHe show's closing DaTe jaNuARy 8 KaRL'S exTended ruN EnDed deCembEr 2 fOR thE return of henry thAT sAme day The cAST rECorDing wAs ReLEAsEd oN Cd On deceMBer 15 it wAs annouNced THAt UnDerStuDY diane pheLaN would take oVER as CiNderella On dEcembeR 26 FOr the lASt Two weeks oF tHe shoW'S run iT waS aLSo announcEd thAt Arcelus wOulD return to the pROducTioN repLaciNg jAmEs As the BaKer stARtING jaNuAry 3