In April 1999, an article critical of Falun Gong was published in Tianjin Normal University's Youth Reader magazine. The article was authored by physicist He Zuoxiu who, as Porter and Gutmann indicate, is a relative of Politburo member and public security secretary Luo Gan. The article cast qigong, and Falun Gong in particular, as superstitious and harmful for youth. Falun Gong practitioners responded by picketing the offices of the newspaper requesting a retraction of the article. Unlike past instances in which Falun Gong protests were successful, on 22 April the Tianjin demonstration was broken up by the arrival of three hundred riot police. Some of the practitioners were beaten, and forty-five arrested. Other Falun Gong practitioners were told that if they wished to appeal further, they needed to take the issue up with the Ministry of Public Security and go to Beijing to appeal.
in april 1999 an article critical of falun gong was published in tianjin normal university's youth reader magazine the article was authored by physicist he zuoxiu who as porter and gutmann indicate is a relative of politburo member and public security secretary luo gan the article cast qigong and falun gong in particular as superstitious and harmful for youth falun gong practitioners responded by picketing the offices of the newspaper requesting a retraction of the article unlike past instances in which falun gong protests were successful on 22 april the tianjin demonstration was broken up by the arrival of three hundred riot police some of the practitioners were beaten and forty-five arrested other falun gong practitioners were told that if they wished to appeal further they needed to take the issue up with the ministry of public security and go to beijing to appeal