39084


I'm a bit lost in Jinbe's status and what happened with him and Big Mom. In
chapter 830, he confronts Big Mom and announces that he is planning on leaving
her alliance. In return, she demands that he as well has to lose something
valuable as well, and what will it be is decided by the roulette game.

However then in chapter 835, there is a report in the newspaper saying he
backed out, which would imply that he has withdrawn his request to leave Big
Mom's crew. This is very unlikely considering his portrayal, so I assume this
was some kind of false report because later on he also admits to Luffy that
his alliance with Big Mom is over. However, I don't know what is the reason
for such a false report in the first place, it makes no sense to me and I have
also read some theories which are suggesting that he did not lose anything at
all which is even weirder, why would Big Mom let him just go that easily?

The only plausible explanation to me is that he has spun the wheel and he lost
a bit of his lifespan (or I have missed some important detail in the story).


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-01-15T14:45:58.143
38426
2021-11-14T13:58:37.230
2018-04-25T13:57:04.857
2516
27678
question
one-piece
What did Jinbe lose in Charlotte's roulette?


I think he lost something like a bit of his lifespan or he has withdrawn his
request to leave the crew.

However, we will surely find it out in the next chapters.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-01-16T09:32:11.697
38442
2018-04-25T14:14:20.483
2018-04-25T14:14:20.483
2516
30321
38426
answer


As stated in chapter 834 afterward, Jinbe didn't go through with the roulette
because it is set up in a way that somebody who does it will probably lose his
life and that wasn't what he wanted because of his pledge to Luffy.

So he just went for the normal thing somebody would do and he betrayed her in
chapter 851 by freeing Luffy from the prison and escaping together with them
from Big Mom.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-02-22T14:26:51.020
39084
2018-04-25T14:06:42.623
2018-04-25T14:06:42.623
2516
14599
38426
answer


Jinbe didn't lose anything.

In the manga, he went through the game, but Charlotte's fruit can't activate
on people who don't fear her. Jinbe never feared her and so she couldn't take
anything away from him.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-06-11T06:46:52.133
40820
2018-04-25T14:13:59.973
2018-04-25T14:13:59.973
2516
33029
38426
answer


He originally backed down, but later revealed that he didn't spin it in fear
for himself but the spinner's crew always suffers from his choice and he
didn't want that.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-06-19T17:25:07.480
40947
2017-06-19T17:25:07.480
33174
38426
answer


For people who are confuse, the thing he will lose is the life of his friends
and comrades, he stated not only his life will be taken away but also his
friends life span too, thats why he told sun pirates to leave now


CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-11-14T13:58:37.230
65913
2021-11-14T13:58:37.230
63250
38426
answer