18978


At the end of _A Certain Magical Index I_ episode 18, the "Replica" Sorcerer
(the one with the Obsidian Blade) asks Touma to make sure he protects Misaka.
When Touma answers, we can only see his lips moving (no sound) and then he
smiles.

Misaka is listening from behind one of the iron beams of course. Normally in
anime, it is fairly clear to me what these moments signify, but in this case,
both the Sorcerer's and Misaka's responses are (in my opinion) ambiguous.

What does he say?


CC BY-SA 4.0
2015-01-14T18:01:45.847
18534
2021-11-22T05:30:03.150
2021-11-22T05:29:55.117
2516
11165
question
a-certain-magical-index
What does Touma say to the "Replica" Sorcerer with the Obsidian Blade?


> “I have promised to protect Mikoto and her around.”

When Touma helped Kuroko, he said so, in Volume 8 of the original novel. And
perhaps in Volume 11 of the manga.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-01-30T08:26:02.267
18978
2015-10-21T01:55:50.587
2015-10-21T01:55:50.587
11083
11336
18534
answer


[![](https://i.stack.imgur.com/dbEZxl.jpg)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/dbEZx.jpg)

Manga volume 11, chapter 64, page 15

The full quote was:

> "That’s right, it's a promise. This promise is to protect Misaka Mikoto and
> the world around her. This is my agreement with a certain nameless person
> who fell in love with her so quickly."

He explains this to Shirai Kuroko regarding his promise with Etzali from
_Toaru Majutsu no Index_ light novel volume 08.

Source: [Touma's quotes on Toaru Majutsu no Index
Wikia](http://toarumajutsunoindex.wikia.com/wiki/Kamijou_Touma/Quotes)


CC BY-SA 4.0
2015-10-20T10:38:17.887
26723
2021-11-22T05:29:58.613
2021-11-22T05:29:58.613
2516
18598
18534
answer


I haven't been able to find a satisfying answer explaining Etzali's and
Misaka's reactions yet, so...

Whatever he said, it obviously confirmed the promise Etzali asked for, but it
wasn't what he had wanted to hear.

**Combined with Misaka's reaction, I have two theories. I'll start with the
one that's less likely:**

In _A Certain Magical Index II_ episode 23, Kamijo says to Kazakiri that he'd
rather chop his hand off than lose one of his friends. I am mentioning this
because it shows that he would make a statement essentially comparing the
value of body parts and people, even though it specifically makes sense in
that context because his right hand can literally kill Kazikiri.

**The idea is that maybe he said something along the lines of _" I'll protect
her like my right hand"_ or _" I'd chop off my right hand for her"_.**

The reactions would then basically be a masturbation joke. I honestly don't
find this theory very satisfying.

Luckily, there is evidence to contradict it. Here is the excerpt from the
light novel, copied from Reddit:

> Mikoto and the boy were the only ones in the alley.
>
> The words that had come out of his mouth shook her more than she let on. But
> what rocked her very core—that she did not realize. Nevertheless, she
> unconsciously understood that she’d be better off not letting it show. Or
> rather, she possessed a compelling force telling her that she mustn’t do so.
>
> However, without care, it would erupt within her. She was desperately
> holding it back, like a raging vortex of steam trying to escape her body.
>
> It was strange.
>
> She didn’t want to let it show on the surface, but she felt pained trying to
> hold it back.
>
> Would that not mean that deep down she wanted to let it show? But that
> wasn’t the case.
>
> Just thinking about letting it show nearly made her red in the face.
>
> And she didn’t even know what the essential thing was.
>
> She held everything in her throat, not understanding why.
>
> One way or another, she’d realized it.
>
> **Mikoto had always kind of thought she was a unique existence. She had
> thought that even her distance to this boy had shrunken just a little bit
> compared to everyone else. Like if he was browsing a list of a thousand
> names and saw the name Misaka, he’d at least stop for a moment.**
>
> **But no—she’d been wrong.**
>
> And that fact by itself had a big effect on her. She didn’t even understand
> why something as insignificant as this had caused her so much damage, so she
> of course couldn’t think of a way to deal with it. She wanted to run away
> right now if she could—from this unidentified pain.
>
> But she couldn’t.
>
> She didn’t want to turn tail and run away from him.
>
> It would hurt him.
>
> The pain would be much more than what she was feeling now.
>
> (…Man, I really am an idiot, if I do say so myself.)

In my opinion, the marked part sums up the meaning behind her reaction. She
realizes that to him, she's more or less just another person.

**This makes me think that he said something along the lines of _" I'll
protect her like everyone else"_ or _" I will protect everybody I can"_.**

The idea is that this would be the worst possible answer because Etzali wanted
him to commit specifically to protecting Misaka, but it still gives the
promise because it includes him protecting her.

Now, in the anime, Misaka also says that she is taking what he said the wrong
way and that he made it very misleading. The idea with that is that Kamijo is
the kind of guy who protects people wherever he can, but this doesn't actually
mean he cares about everyone equally. He still likes some people more than
others, but he protects everyone.

It should also be noted that, in the light novel, he actually realized Misaka
was close because he is so unlucky that he wouldn't have survived otherwise:

> A steel girder had fallen into the ground right between his legs as he sat
> on his butt. That wasn’t all. All around him, more of them were sticking out
> of the ground, covering them up, like a badly made hut with tons of holes in
> the roof. There was a precarious balance here that seemed so weak a breeze
> would cause the whole thing to come crashing down, but for now, at least,
> Kamijou hadn’t been buried alive.
>
> (That was lucky…wait, that’s impossible. I’m unlucky, after all. Which
> means…oh, I see. That Level 5 can use the power of electricity to manipulate
> magnetism, too, can’t she?)

However, this doesn't seem to affect what he says to Etzali at all, he either
didn't think about it much or simply didn't care if Misaka heard his answer in
the way he gave it. I do feel like this is in line with his character.


CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-11-21T21:27:56.853
65965
2021-11-22T05:30:03.150
2021-11-22T05:30:03.150
2516
63352
18534
answer