30131


Take as an example the Body Replacement Technique from the Naruto series.

Using this technique, any user can replace his own body with some other
object, but most of the time ninjas replace their body with a block of wood.
This has also been seen in the Naruto series when Kakashi takes the exam of
Naruto's team.

So the thing which really bothers me is that they replace themselves with a
block of wood, and not something else. I have even seen this type of event
happen in other anime. It is quite common for ninjas to replace themselves
with a block of wood.

[![block of wood at a location presumably occupied by a ninja just moments
before](https://i.stack.imgur.com/kEe8Q.jpg)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/kEe8Q.jpg)


CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-02-29T12:51:56.123
30125
2016-03-08T21:51:24.783
2016-03-02T00:18:59.637
1908
19221
question
naruto tropes
Why do ninjas usually replace their own body with a block of wood?


In-universe, no reason is given apart from the fact that every time I can
recall this happening they were near trees and thus a chunk of wood was
convenient. The actual source is never addressed, and we never see trees
falling over because they lost a chunk of themselves.

For the real-world reason...It's a Japanese trope based on the actual legends
built up around historical Ninjas (probably also _by_ said Ninjas, for whom
misinformation was a great tactic). "Kawarimi" was a supposed technique
possessed by the ancient Ninja that used misdirection and split-second timing
to swap places with something that could easily be mistaken for the Ninja.

There may be some historical grounds for this, but not to the extent we see in
Naruto. Instead, this could easily be a trick used by historical ninja to
trick and mislead enemies, and build up the mythos they had constructed for
themselves. As an example, a Ninja may have previously prepared a wooden dummy
that was about his size and dressed it in the same clothing as he was wearing.
This dummy could be hidden somewhere convenient for later use. Then, when
fleeing pursuers, you head back to where you hid the dummy and in a moment
where your pursuers lose track of you (either with natural obstacles or a
smoke/flash explosive set off), you set the dummy in your place and go the
other direction. You could even set it up to go over a cliff. While your
pursuers are distracted by the dummy, you slip away. Thus was built up the
legend that Ninjas could 'trade places' with things, and since wooden (or
straw) dummies were convenient for those purposes, they likely got used the
most.

Over time, this morphed in Japanese culture along with a lot of the other
myths of the Ninja. For example, the myth of Ninja dressing in all black
growing out of Kabuki Theater (Stage hands dressed in all black, and so
theater goers were used to completely ignoring them...so when one of them
jumped out and drew a sword, it was as if they had appeared from
nowhere...allowing the theater to have 'super-stealthy Ninjas'). Over this
time, the idea of the Kawarimi morphed and changed until it landed on them
simply swapping places with a log. Even the particular appearance of the log
is somewhat standardized in this trope: a short round chunk of wood of about
the same thickness, either completely smooth or with a single 'stump' branch
coming off the side.

It turns up in quite a number of places, from other anime and manga to a bunch
of video games. In short, in Japanese culture, the "kawarimi log" is simply
the standard thing for a Ninja to swap places with, without regard for where
it came from. It's the same idea as how, in American culture, if something is
blindly tossed out a window, there _will_ be a cat down there that yowls and
knocks over a bunch of stuff over...or how no one questions that saying "Well,
at least it can't get any worse" will instantly make things worse...or how
someone can put on a pair of glasses, and that is considered a solid disguise.

So, while there is no in-universe explanation...the out of universe
explanation is simply "it's a standard narrative tool in Japanese culture."


CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-02-29T20:55:40.670
30131
2016-02-29T20:55:40.670
14466
30125
answer


Obviously they can't replace a body with another body. That won't be ethical
at all with ninjas also as humans. Most importantly the wooden log they use to
replace is almost proportionate to the size of ninja using that body, it is
hard to soak up any effect of kunai and also stop it's movement. And those
logs are easily forgettable and generic to emphasise more of the fact that the
ninja has used "body replacement jutsu" to successfully dodge the attack on
himself. So there is a very little chance for the viewers to ask "why only
wood" except for your case here. Now there will be more controversy if instead
of wood, ninjas use human dummies or stone because most of ninja fight scenes
settings have trees around. No dummy laying around. Also the rock of size
proportional to ninja himself will use more of chakra and rock might harm a
lot more than wood in case jutsu goes wrong.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-03-01T20:42:22.703
30143
2016-03-01T20:42:22.703
22402
30125
answer


In older ninja movies this substitution is not limited to a block of wood,
with straw dummies, nearby vases or chairs or other objects substituted in the
place of the infamous ninja log. The use of logs has simply become a cultural
norm much the way that any TV trope gets reused over and over; just like how
everyone who gets fired on TV has a convenient file box of items to carry out
as they leave, or every ghost is visible in a nearby mirror but the character
cannot see them, or my personal favourite, every abandoned car has the keys
stashed up in the visor for the protagonists to find.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-03-02T00:02:48.837
30145
2016-03-02T00:02:48.837
22396
30125
answer


It is a trope of old ninja movies to substitute oneself when aware of an
immenent attack.

As for in universe explanation, the main cast all live in the Village Hidden
in Leaves, the first Hokage grew the huge forest surrounding the village, an
abundance of wood allows for ninjas to substitute their body for a block of
wood, allowing them to avoid the attack and manuevuer behind the enemy to
strike back.

Gaara is seen using a sand decoy in Shippuden to replicate this technique as
obviously not a lot of trees in the Village Hidden in the Sand.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-03-02T09:38:38.027
30157
2016-03-02T09:38:38.027
22412
30125
answer