29869


In episode 16, what appears to be a Japanese translation of ["Dona
Dona"](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donna_Donna) plays twice -- once where
Nanami has a dream where she, like the calf in the song, is sent away to her
death, and once right after Utena removes the cowbell.

I know that there are translations of this song (which seems to originally
have been in Yiddish) -- there's a recording of Joan Baez singing it in
English on YouTube, and Wikipedia lists a bunch of other languages.

Given that I doubt Japan has a particularly large Jewish presence compared to
the other countries indicated by the languages listed on Wikipedia, I'm
wondering about the Japanese translation: who did the translation, and when
did a translated version of the song first appear? Did a translation exist
before Utena?


CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-04-03T04:46:56.647
20578
2016-02-17T16:25:17.647
2604
question
music revolutionary-girl-utena
Where is the translation of "Dona Dona" from?


From an internet search for `dona dona japanese translation`, which I ran
after it occurred to me that there might be a quick answer out there, I found
[this blog](https://ejtranslations.wordpress.com/2012/08/02/revolutionary-
girl-utena-dona-dona/) that mentioned a 1966 translation by **Yasui Kazumi**.
An MIT's [Jewish A Capella](http://techiya.mit.edu/repertoire/) site also
gives the same translator.

Just to further double-check things, I ended up on the Japanese Wikipedia page
for both
[Yasui](http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%AE%89%E4%BA%95%E3%81%8B%E3%81%9A%E3%81%BF#.E8.A8.B3.E8.A9.9E.EF.BC.88.E3.81.BF.E3.83.8A.E3.81.BF.E3.82.AB.E3.82.BA.E3.81.BF.E5.90.8D.E7.BE.A9.E3.82.92.E5.90.AB.E3.82.80.EF.BC.89)
and [the
song](http://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E3%83%89%E3%83%8A%E3%83%89%E3%83%8A). My
Japanese knowledge is somewhat lacking, but I can read katakana and hiragana,
and they also list the same year and translator, although the Wikipedia page
lists an earlier instance of the song being performed in Japan (which may not
have been in Japanese).

So the song translation definitely appeared before the anime (which, if I'm
not mistaken, was in the 1990's), and it wasn't anime-specific.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-04-03T04:46:56.647
20579
2015-04-03T04:46:56.647
2604
20578
answer


Somewhat belatedly, from the research I did for the blog post you mention,
this is what I understand the sequence of events to be:

  * Song is written in Yiddish, fails to gain mainstream popularity even when the songwriter produces an English version, sinks into obscurity.

  * Teddi Schwartz and Arthur Kevess dig it up in the 1950s and translate it into English; this version gains moderate popularity in the United States.

  * In the 1960s, Joan Baez and some other mainstream popular artists record versions. It becomes _very_ popular in the United States, and translated versions start popping up in other countries, including Japan.

  * The original Japanese translation, as you note, is by the Peanuts and may have played a role in popularizing the song there, but their version becomes pretty thoroughly overshadowed by the 1966 Yasui Kazumi translation, which passes into the general cultural consciousness. For some reason it remains one of those bits of common knowledge/things you can reference and expect pretty much everyone to understand in Japan even when that's no longer the case in its home country. (At least, I grew up listening to folk music and had not actually heard the song before Utena.)

  * Some thirty years later, when planning the cow episode, one of the creators of Utena remarks that it seems like a "Dona Dona" kind of situation. (This is from a translated interview that I don't remember where I found, sorry.) Everyone else goes "hey, that's a good idea, actually," and they decide to use the song (with the well-known 1966 translation) in the show. (They probably didn't sit down and go "Hmm, which translation should we use? Or should we do our own?" and eventually settle on that one; as far as I understand, that's just _the_ version of the song that most people will automatically think of when you mention it.)


CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-02-17T16:25:17.647
29869
2016-02-17T16:25:17.647
22159
20578
answer