50684


When Shoya confronts Miki in the story to ask whether she told anyone about
him bullying Shoko, Miki makes the claim that she never once badmouthed Shoko,
and that she always told Shoya to stop. Miki is portrayed as manipulative, but
Shoya also admits that he might not remember things correctly:

> Miki is right... I probably altered my memories to make myself feel better.
> (Volume 5, page 112)

Could this be a case of an unreliable narrator? Can Miki's claim be validated?


CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-02-01T17:35:41.083
50683
2023-02-24T16:31:46.430
19307
question
koe-no-katachi
Did Miki really never bully Shoko?


## Points For Miki:

Having reread the first volume, Miki's claim actually does have a great deal
of credence. She is often seen helping Shoko, informing her on page 80 when
the teacher calls on Shoko, and showing her which question the teacher asked
on page 69. Bonus points for copying the homework assignment for Naoka when
Shoko's questioning caused her to miss what the teacher said (this helps
Shoko, albeit indirectly). Additionally Miki does, in fact, tell Shoya to
knock it off several times:

> Stop goofing off, boys! (Volume 1, page 100, after Shoya dumps a dustpan on
> Shoko outside)

This happens after Shoya dumps a dustpan on Shoko, who is outside the window.

> See? I told you to knock it off! (Volume 1, Page 106)

Miki says this after Shoya injures Shoko by pulling on her hearing aid
apparatus. Notably, her alleged first call to "knock it off" is suspiciously
missing from the narrative.

Miki also attempts to shield Shoko from harm in several instances. First, when
Naoka rudely asks Shoko whether she can speak Japanese, Miki says,

> Haha... That's not a nice way to put it. (Volume 1, page 73)

When Shoko asks for clarification for what Naoka said, Miki writes in Shoko's
notebook, changing the question to "Do you have a nickname?"

Second, Miki is present when Shoko sees the mean messages written on the
chalkboard by Shoya and friends. It's unclear if the message is actually
communicated to Shoko since she's deaf, but Miki says,

> It's awful, isn't it? I mean, really...(Volume 1, page 97)

In cases where her friends are badmouthing Shoko, it is actually true that
Miki does not participate. Rather, she gives diplomatic replies, such as "I
know, right?" and "I know what you mean." (Volume 1, pages 105 and 80). She
acknowledges her friends' grievances against Shoko, but does not levy any of
her own.

Shoya is also shown to be, to a degree, oblivious to the people around him,
lending credence to the idea that he might not be the most reliable narrator.
When he's doing his daredevil stunts, his two friends show a declining
interest in continuing, but Shoya doesn't notice, and it hits him like a brick
wall when they outright tell him they don't want to keep jumping off bridges.
In high school, he puts mental X's over everyone's faces, further showing that
he doesn't pay attention to other people. Since the first volume is almost
entirely told from Shoya's perspective, a case might be made that any memories
in the narrative he has of Miki being mean to Shoko are fabricated or
exaggerated. Thus one wonders whether Shoya's claim on Volume 1, page 124 can
be trusted:

> And if you count insults, the girls badmouthed her more than anyone!
> Especially Miki and Naoka!

Naoka, certainly. But Shoya may just be lumping Miki in because she was part
of the conversation.

## Points Against Miki:

Probably the most damaging point against Miki is her friendship with Naoka,
who is definitively known to have bullied Shoko. In spite of this, Miki
defends Naoka to the teacher, saying Naoka did more than anyone to keep Shoya
in line on page 123. It is possible that Miki just willfully looked the other
way when Naoka was bullying Shoko, or, less likely, that she was unaware of
the worse offenses Naoka perpetrated. But her strong association with Naoka
does lead credence to the idea that she also badmouthed Shoko, even if there
is no instance in the manga of this happening.

Secondly, Miki may have been present at the aforementioned blackboard incident
when Shoya and friends were writing the messages. On page 95, there is a panel
showing the legs of several characters. One pair of socks does resemble
Miki's. If so, then this quote would be attributed to her:

> When you get in trouble, I had nothing to do with this! (Volume 1, page 95)

She seems to be trying to discourage them, so it's unlikely she took part
directly. On the other hand, this means she could have erased the messages
before Shoko saw them.

Thirdly, Miki laughed at the Shoya's joke on page 102 about Shoko being deaf
because they forgot to write the sutras on her ears. Initially, she does give
Shoya a disapproving look, but after the teacher laughs, she laughs too. She
even contributes clarification on the joke, saying, "Hoichi the Earless?", and
thus giving it her stamp of approval (in her defense, as an honor student, she
likely couldn't resist classical/literary allusions).

## Conclusion:

I suspect that Miki really was doing her best to help Shoko. Her classmates
did have legitimate grievances against Shoko, so Miki likely didn't know what
to do or who to side with as the class turned increasingly hostile. She didn't
stick out her neck for Shoko, so as to keep a target from being put on her,
but she did her best to moderate in an impossible situation that could not be
handled by children. However, there is a great deal of ambiguity to the
character in the story, and I invite everyone to review the character's words
and actions and come to their own conclusion.

## New Information

From an author interview I read in the first volume of the collector's edition
(emphasis mine):

> Does Kawai take her glasses off [and cry when Shoya accuses her] because she
> knows she's cute?
>
> Oima: It's a natural gesture. Kawai-san is not that calculating. I'll say
> this because I want it to be clear: **The tears she cries are also 100%
> pure**.

Though it's not canonical to the main story, in the second one-shot, Miki can
be seen helping Shoko sing during the choir concert contest. She's holding her
hand and giving her some kind of signals. A commentator says:

> The girl next to her is showing her which way to adjust her pitch.

Then, when Naoka yells at Shoko and gets a response, and then everyone is
badmouthing Shoko by saying she can actually hear, Miki gives a more neutral
response:

> Well, my mom said she must be wearing a device that lets her hear.

Miki also looks more horrified than anyone when Shoya hits Shoko and causes
her to bleed (page 681 in collector's edition, though Miki's drawn kind of
strangely). She does wear a smile while the group is leaving Shoya after
pushing him in the pond, but this isn't a question about whether Miki bullied
Shoya.

The scene where Shoya accuses Miki and Naoka is present in both one-shots as
well, with some differences. This indicates Miki was probably always meant to
play the role she does in the story. The second one-shot version is
essentially the same as in the main story (though lacking Miki's "Why can't we
all be friends" line, but in the first one-shot, Shoya only says of Miki,

> You were laughing with Ueno, too!

This notably lacks the accusation of Miki badmouthing Shoko. Miki doesn't cry
here, but looks extremely nervous about the accusation and says to the
teacher,

> But sir... I'm the class representative. I would never...

In all three versions, Miki denies any wrongdoing on her part, and none of the
versions actually show her doing any badmouthing herself.


CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-02-01T17:35:41.083
50684
2023-02-24T16:31:46.430
2023-02-24T16:31:46.430
19307
19307
50683
answer


Miki definitely bullied Shoko. Even if it wasn't as direct as the others
bullying. Even in the ways Miki "protected" Shoko were all for the glory of
Miki. Miki has always been very manipulative, like when she would laugh at the
mean jokes the others would make and then turn around do something that's
somewhat nice. Or how she obviously was part of the problem, then made it look
like it was all Shoyo. Miki definitely bullied Shoko, but just in a slightly
different way


CC BY-SA 4.0
2020-03-22T22:01:21.590
57038
2020-03-22T22:01:21.590
52394
50683
answer


miki bullied shoko she defended shoko to make herself look good and laughed
with the others. She definitely didn't really do mush to bully her in the was
shoya (or the others) did but at the same time she played part in it by
laughing with the others and not doing much to stop it, (like when shoya
pulled her hearing aid out) she decide to act as if she was the 'good person'
in all of it and help her only when she was hurt she is extremely
manipulative.


CC BY-SA 4.0
2020-06-07T08:35:02.227
57828
2020-06-07T08:35:02.227
53731
50683
answer