

As the series develops, it seems that Ergo Proxy has a growing number of
philosophical references:

  * The concept of Anamnesis in episode 11.

  * The Council/Collective figures.

  * All the events in episode 20.

  * Every discussion Vincent has with Ergo about the 'self' (especially episode 11)

  * And numerous others that I don't recall at the moment...

Which philosophical concepts/authors are referenced or portrayed in the
series?


CC BY-SA 4.0
2012-12-11T22:12:56.637
63
2021-07-17T06:00:02.317
2021-07-17T06:00:02.317
60264
49
question
tropes ergo-proxy
What philosophical concepts and/or authors are referenced in the series Ergo Proxy?


Actually funny enough some of the robots in the anime are named after
philosophers...

The Ergo Proxy Wiki states in the Production section
<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergo_Proxy>

> It is set in the future. A group of robots become infected with something
> called the Kojiro [sic] virus, and become aware of their own existence. So
> these robots, which had been tools of humans, decide to go on an adventure
> to search for themselves. They have to decide whether the virus that
> infected them created their identity, or whether they gained their identity
> through their travels. This question is meant to represent our own debate
> over whether we become who we are because of our environment, or because of
> things that are inherent in us. The robots are all named after philosophers:
> Derrida and Lacan and Husserl.

So pretty much the whole anime is about self discovery and coming to terms
with their existence. One such philosophical / socialogical debate we take
from the above mentioned quote is that of Nature vs Nurture. Are we who we are
because of "what" we are, or is our "self" formed by our actions or the things
around us. There's quite a few different philosophical undertones, the most
prominent I think is the one I quoted above.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-01-14T19:24:35.390
6905
2014-01-14T19:24:35.390
3317
63
answer


big spoilers. go away.

> Cogito refers to - Cogito Ergo Sum - I think, therefore I am. also the word
> is similar to 'Cognito' or 'Cognition', which all derive from the root for
> 'know'. there's the whole daedalus/ikaros thing... oh i can't remember any
> more ;p the whole series itself seems sort of highlander/the one-like.
> asura/ashura is commonly used in anime, based on indian beliefs. let's not
> forget 'The Rapture' lol ;p

more? decided to move stuff from other thread lol

> pino = piano, the playing card soldiers of karos (karos = diamonds), the
> russian miniatures. how everything works like 'clockwork'? - the wombs,
> vincent's plan - gods trying to kill humans, while humans are trying to kill
> the gods (at least raul).


CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-05-29T12:42:33.557
9999
2014-05-29T14:55:23.663
2014-05-29T14:55:23.663
5055
5055
63
answer


It's been a long time since I have watched the anime, but here's a quick
rundown of some of the concepts I think the anime portrayed:

**Absurdism**

The resulting conflict, called the "Absurd," to find meaning and not being
able to find any, at least, not in a humanely possible way. In other words,
meaning can be logically found, but not be achieved. This concept is shown in
Raul's mental breakdown as he slowly loses any possible source of meaning in
his life. His adopted child, for example, could have been a source of meaning,
but as he loses that and Pino, he began to create the Absurd and the way he
resolves this is through suicide. The are other examples of the Absurd, more
noticeable when they're talking about their Raison d'Etre. Others can handle
the Absurd in a different way, particularly the Proxies because they're not
(normal) humans, although those like Re-L was able to handle it as well in the
end. The way Ergo Proxy portrayed Vincent's journey can also classify this
work as an Absurdist Fiction.

For more: <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absurdism>

**Mind-Body Problem**

This is more broad and can be divided into two subcategories: dualism and
monism or physicalism (also called Identity Theory). Dualism is where the mind
is separate from the body and the latter is when the mind is the body. This
issue is addressed when the robots begins to acquire sentience on their own.
The Cogito virus, which seems to be immaterial, is what gives the robots in
the series their free will, their "mind," similar to how dualism says that the
mind is immaterial and separate from the body. Yet, the experiences each robot
has is what makes them act different, which also depends on the body. The
state of mind of an intimidating military robot is going to be different than
that of Pino, where people are more likely to treat her like a child. This
issue is also more notable between Ergo and Vincent.

For more: <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_problem>

**Social Contract**

The anime briefly touched on this, but it's there. The legitimacy of Romedau's
government is questioned. Cities can be created and destroyed easily by the
Proxies, so it seems that the council is very powerless. More than that, no
one voluntarily enters these cities. Rather, people are forced to exist inside
them, either through artificial birth or through emigration (they were either
to die in the harsh outside environment or live inside). In contrast, the
commune outside of Romedeau works the opposite, in a way. Thus the problem:
would you be willing to give up some of your freedom for comfort or would you
rather have complete freedom?

For more: <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_contract>

**Existentialism**

Very similar to absurdism. This problem is the question of where meaning comes
from, if there is at all. It also deals with the issue of where existence came
from, whether we existed without our bodies and how does it relate to our
meaning. Existentialism on its own is too broad, however, but it seems to me
that the anime touched on this as well.

For more: <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Existentialism>

There's a lot of references on the other hand, so I'll only list a few:

_Utilitarianism_ \- Society should be guided so that everyone is equally
happy. Thus everyone in Romedau is given meaning.

_Transhumanism_ \- There was a scene where a city is run completely by robots.
This seems to be more of a jab on transhumanism rather than a support for it,
as it shows there's no need for humans if everything is mechanized.

_Divine Command Theory_ \- Whatever the council says, it has to be good. Why?
Because they said so.

_Übermensch_ \- Nietzsche's idea of a perfect human and how human propagation
gives meaning. The proxies aren't perfect, but it somewhat alludes to it
considering how obscenely powerful they seem to be and that their mission is
to perpetuate human society, if I recall correctly.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-10-12T18:15:30.043
14409
2014-10-12T18:15:30.043
293
63
answer