46302


I just finished reading the first volume of Nausicaa of the Valley of the
Wind. There was a scene that confused me in an earlier part of the book. I
don't remember the page numbers.

When Princess Kushana lands her gunship in the Valley of the Wind, Nausicaa
rushes in and challenges one of the soldiers to a duel (essentially). After
the situation is defused by Master Yupa, Kushana asks if she can see
Nausicaa's sword. Nausicaa hands over her sword, Kushana admires it for a
moment and then cuts it to pieces with her own sword. There doesn't seem to be
much of a reaction from Nausicaa or her people when this happens and the fact
that Kushana destroyed the sword is never mentioned again.

What I don't understand is, why is the act of Kushana breaking the sword not
more significant? Apparently the sword was made of ohmu shell, which is
supposed to be tougher than the ceramic blades used by most soldiers
(evidenced when Nausicaa chips her ceramic blade on an ohmu shell in one of
the first scenes of the book). Furthermore, ohmu shell swords must be
incredibly rare, considering that Kushana (who is the _princess of a large
empire_ ) would be carrying an "inferior" ceramic blade. Wouldn't that sword
be like a family heirloom or something?

The only explanation that I can think of is that the scene is purely intended
to set up what a badass Kushana is and that Nausicaa is not upset because it
is a small price to pay to get the Torumekian forces to leave peacefully.

Note: I have only read the first volume, which ends shortly after Asbel gets
shot down by Kushana's gunship. I don't care about spoilers if you need them
in your answers, so fire away. I have not watched the anime either.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-01-20T20:33:32.783
38516
2018-03-29T08:51:21.197
30436
question
nausicaa-of-the-valley-of-the-wind
What is the significance (or lack thereof) of Nausicaa's broken sword?


To understand it, you also need to think that nausica killed a person in
kushana's team.

As kushana's aspect, she shoud be angry about that. Because she is good
manager. If she is not enough smart, she may revenge like kill nausica. But if
she do it, it means the war will start between kushana's side vs nausica's
side. That's not good strategy for her because her only have small team in
here. Then she doesn't start the war. But she is still very angry, then she
brake the sword instead.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-04-01T09:55:05.843
39663
2017-04-02T04:47:55.713
2017-04-02T04:47:55.713
3557
3557
38516
answer


First off, I think your instinct is generally correct: This scene is meant to
establish that Kushana is a very physically strong character with excellent
martial skills. This becomes more relevant later, especially when more is
revealed about Kushana's physical body.

There's also truth in @kumagoro's answer. Breaking the sword is a partially
symbolic act, of breaking the will of the conquered.

That said, I don't agree that "There doesn't seem to be much of a reaction
from Nausicaä" to the sword's destruction. Kushana drops the sword in one
panel and breaks it in another; the panel between the two shows Nausicaä's
reaction, which does indeed look like shock to me. We don't particularly get
to see the reactions of other Valley natives, but Nausicaä's seems appropriate
to me.

I think we can combine that reaction with the above concepts to formulate the
following **hypothesis** :

Nausicaä attacks Kushana's soldiers, and Uncle Mito defuses the situation by
forcing both sides to stop.

Kushana appears and is faced with a delicate situation. On the one hand,
_someone just killed her own soldiers_ , and even though that's paused for the
moment, the rest of her soldiers aren't necessarily going to be satisfied if
Kushana just brushes it off with no consequences. Justice needs to be seen to
be done. On the other, she doesn't want her soldiers slaughtering everyone in
the Valley; she needs their manpower to handle the God Warrior egg.

So, Kushana destroys the weapon used to kill her soldiers. This demonstrates
her role power -- she can destroy things in the Valley at will and nobody in
the Valley can stop her -- as well as her physical power to break such a
strong blade. It's an act of dominance.

Nausicaä is dismayed, but to the regular people of the Valley, that sword is a
tool used by royals more than a historically or culturally significant
artifact, as far as it seems to me. Yes, it's a rare object, but the people of
the Valley are going through a pretty darned traumatic day; Kushana destroying
a royal sword is a relatively minor incident.

All that said, this scene also involves Nausicaä demonstrating a psychokinetic
power that never shows up again, either, so Hayao Miyazaki may have just been
making stuff up and seeing what stuck. :-)


CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-03-28T22:44:12.463
46302
2018-03-29T08:51:21.197
2018-03-29T08:51:21.197
172
172
38516
answer