42325


The show requires us to suspend disbelief to the point where Roy Mustang can
alter densities of gases or induce some chemical reactions, but not
necessarily change elements themselves. It argues the energy required to
generate 'real' transmutations is much higher, so you need something like the
philosophers stone.

Now, the animes claim he generates explosions by altering oxygen density
profiles in the air and triggering a reaction by creating a spark. See under
'Abilities' here: <http://fullmetal-alchemist-
database.wikia.com/wiki/Roy_Mustang>

However, while oxygen assists combustion, it is not flammable by itself.
Hence, the flame needs to travel along a path of oxygen _and_ combustible
material from Mustang to his target. The show offers no explanation for where
this combustible material comes from.

Perhaps flammable gases or water vapor (that could be converted to hydrogen)
in air could be utilized to create explosions. However, these gases are
present at levels lower than 1% in the atmosphere, and concentrating them
sufficiently to create an explosive needs volumes several orders of magnitude
larger than what Mustang has access to in the show. (intuitively, the
atmospheric water vapor in the volume contained by a large living room will
not fill a glass of water).

Given what I have argued so far, and without having to suspend disbelief
further, how does Mustang's flame alchemy even work? It feels like the authors
of the show are (erroneously) assuming oxygen is combustible.


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-09-12T17:02:09.713
42294
2017-09-14T20:48:19.387
2017-09-14T18:16:28.477
35604
35604
question
fullmetal-alchemist-series fullmetal-alchemist-brotherhood fullmetal-alchemist-2003
Why does Roy Mustang's flame alchemy work?


All we know about how Flame alchemy works is described in the question. As you
note the description is incomplete.

That being said, we do know that creating flames in this way is a very
complicated process and is a closely guarded secret. This secret was tattooed
on the Hawkeye's back by its creator and entrusted by Hawkeye only to Mustang.
A full explanation in-universe would, therefore, not make much sense.

**We might never know what the exact mechanism is and it is not necessary to
understand the story.**

I can come up with several head-canons to justify this physics:

  * The mechanism does not necessarily involve chemistry. The Crimson Alchemist creates explosions by combining contradictory alchemical symbols.
  * An unstable explosive such as tetranitromethane or nitroglycerin could be formed in gaseous state.
  * My preferred one is for Mustang to produce large quantities of nitric oxide (NO). There is a slow reaction where 2NO -> N2 + O2 which is exothermic but NO is considered non-flammable. This is because the reaction is slow without a catalyst because the NO molecules have to collide to react. At very high concentrations with other chemicals, a spark, and magic (alchemy), I like to imagine Mustang can induce a suitable violent reaction which I couldn't get to working in a lab. The actual difficulty is finding a high heat of formation molecule containing only N, O, and C stable enough to disperse harmlessly without decomposing if he can't ignite it. Several such compounds probably exist but it isn't necessarily something that if familiar or can even has been synthesized in the real world. I suspect NO is too stable but is a starting point. NO (nitric oxide) explosions have been observed and require a spark to get started but also require some other fuel to be present.

Further speculation would constitute a fan theory so would be off topic on
this site. I hope, however, this is enough to show you that an explanation is
conceptually possible if not available (or possibly even known by the
creator).


CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-09-14T20:42:48.483
42325
2017-09-14T20:48:19.387
2017-09-14T20:48:19.387
3561
3561
42294
answer