How do I say "What did you hear?"


If you want to ask someone "What did you hear" in Japanese do you say
なんと聞きましたか？ or 何を聞きましたか？




Basically it depends on the context.

(Edited as per the comments)

Generally, if "what did you hear" is asking about the sounds the listener
heard, you may want to use 何が聞こえましたか. In this case, the asker has little idea
what the listener heard. 何を聞きましたか? would be more natural about e.g. music.

More specifically:

  * 何{なに} **が** 聞こえましたか if you are sure the listener heard some sound.
  * 何{なに} **か** 聞こえましたか if you aren't sure the listener heard in the first place
  * 何{なに} **を** 聞きましたか if you ask about specifically what the listener heard/listened to (E.g., _I went to a concert yesterday_ / _what did you hear?_ , though _hear_ may not be exactly right here.)

On the other hand, if you know that the listener heard something from
somebody, then 何{なん}と聞きましたか is better. In this case, the asker has some idea
what the listener heard (opinion, directions, etc.), and "what did you hear"
should be close to "what did they say?" As suggested in the comment, なんて聞きましたか
is also possible (and probably more colloquial).

FYI _what did they say?_ is なんて(と)言ってましたか.




Basically it depends on the context.

(Edited as per the comments)

Generally, if "what did you hear" is asking about the sounds the listener
heard, you may want to use 何が聞こえましたか. In this case, the asker has little idea
what the listener heard. 何を聞きましたか? would be more natural about e.g. music.

More specifically:

  * 何{なに} **が** 聞こえましたか if you are sure the listener heard some sound.
  * 何{なに} **か** 聞こえましたか if you aren't sure the listener heard in the first place
  * 何{なに} **を** 聞きましたか if you ask about specifically what the listener heard/listened to (E.g., _I went to a concert yesterday_ / _what did you hear?_ , though _hear_ may not be exactly right here.)

On the other hand, if you know that the listener heard something from
somebody, then 何{なん}と聞きましたか is better. In this case, the asker has some idea
what the listener heard (opinion, directions, etc.), and "what did you hear"
should be close to "what did they say?" As suggested in the comment, なんて聞きましたか
is also possible (and probably more colloquial).

FYI _what did they say?_ is なんて(と)言ってましたか.

