I really can't understand the use of に + と USED TOGETHER in this clause


I'm reading a book, and I found this:

> 二十歳のお祝い **にと** 店長がプレゼントしてくれたカメラ

Now, why are に and と used together? I can understand the function of に
(meaning "at", I suppose, if お祝い means "celebration"), but what is the meaning
of と?

I also think that the meaning of the whole sentence depends on the meaning
that we want to give to this お祝い, since it can be "celebration", but also
"celebration gift".

So, to conclude, what is the role of these に and と after お祝い? and how would
you translate this in English?




So you're essentially asking the difference between these two sentences:

  * (1) 店長が私に、二十歳のお祝い **に** カメラをプレゼントしてくれた。
  * (2) 店長が私に、二十歳のお祝い **にと** カメラをプレゼントしてくれた。

Here, the に after お祝い is a role/function marker ("as" or "for" in English).
It's the same に as in お土産に切手を買う, 彼を助手に雇う, お詫びにランチを奢る, etc. This に is _not_ a
place marker because, 1) to mark the place where some action takes place, you
have to use で, not に, and, 2) while お祝い can refer to a formal event, we
usually say お祝い会 or お祝いの席 for that purpose. (In addition, did this character
really have a party and invite the shop manager? That's not something Japanese
people commonly do...) It's not a time marker because 二十歳のお祝い does not
represent time (while 誕生日 does).

This と is a quotative-と. That is, Sentence (2) means 二十歳のお祝いに was something
actually said by the 店長. So (2) is basically the same as the following
sentence:

  * (3) 店長が私に「二十歳のお祝いに」と(言って)、カメラをプレゼントしてくれた。  
Saying "(I'll give this to you) as the celebration", the manager gave me a
camera.

The omitted verb after と is not 思って but 言って because this happened when he
actually gave the camera. Of course you usually do not have to translate the
sentence verbosely like (3). Although Sentences (1) and (2) are slightly
different in Japanese, they may be translated into English the same way.




So you're essentially asking the difference between these two sentences:

  * (1) 店長が私に、二十歳のお祝い **に** カメラをプレゼントしてくれた。
  * (2) 店長が私に、二十歳のお祝い **にと** カメラをプレゼントしてくれた。

Here, the に after お祝い is a role/function marker ("as" or "for" in English).
It's the same に as in お土産に切手を買う, 彼を助手に雇う, お詫びにランチを奢る, etc. This に is _not_ a
place marker because, 1) to mark the place where some action takes place, you
have to use で, not に, and, 2) while お祝い can refer to a formal event, we
usually say お祝い会 or お祝いの席 for that purpose. (In addition, did this character
really have a party and invite the shop manager? That's not something Japanese
people commonly do...) It's not a time marker because 二十歳のお祝い does not
represent time (while 誕生日 does).

This と is a quotative-と. That is, Sentence (2) means 二十歳のお祝いに was something
actually said by the 店長. So (2) is basically the same as the following
sentence:

  * (3) 店長が私に「二十歳のお祝いに」と(言って)、カメラをプレゼントしてくれた。  
Saying "(I'll give this to you) as the celebration", the manager gave me a
camera.

The omitted verb after と is not 思って but 言って because this happened when he
actually gave the camera. Of course you usually do not have to translate the
sentence verbosely like (3). Although Sentences (1) and (2) are slightly
different in Japanese, they may be translated into English the same way.

