A counter example to the rule on tense in relative clauses?


In the comments to [this
question](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/questions/90962/%E6%98%8E%E6%97%A5-%E6%9E%97%E3%81%95%E3%82%93%E3%81%AB-%E4%BC%9A%E3%81%86-or-%E4%BC%9A%E3%81%A3%E3%81%9F-%E3%81%A8%E3%81%8D%E3%81%AB-%E3%81%93%E3%81%AE%E6%9C%AC%E3%82%92%E8%BF%94%E3%81%9D%E3%81%86)
I learnt that

> 明日、林さんに **会う** ときに、この本を返そう

and

> 明日、林さんに **会った** ときに、この本を返そう

have the same meaning, although 会った is more common.

With my current understanding, that the tense in a subordinate clause is
relative to that of the main clause, I would have expected 会った to be the only
correct choice, since I cannot return the book to 林さん before I've met up with
him.

I was advised to post a separate question about this, so here it is. Could
someone please explain how these sentences can have the same meaning and how
it fits in with the [relative tense
rule](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/a/25378/7944).




Both are indeed correct, but I would understand とき slightly differently in
those two sentences.

林さんに会っ **た** とき refers to a specific point in time. The speaker will be with
Hayashi-san then and he will return the book when that time has come. This is
a typical example of relative tense.

I would understand 林さんに会 **う** とき as referring more to an occasion than a
specific point in time, or, in other words, a longer span of time than in the
sentence with 会った. It sounds like the speaker will return the book taking
advantage of the occasion to go out and meet Hayashi-san.

The probability of him returning the book to someone other than Hayashi-san
seems to increase in this case. He might drop by a library on his way to the
meeting, or meet the owner of the book after the meeting with Hayashi-san is
over. He might as well return the book to Hayashi-san when the two meet, of
course.

I think this can be seen as a case of absolute tense being used in a noun-
modifying clause (recently discussed
[here](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/q/90967/43676)), with とき being the
modified noun.




Both are indeed correct, but I would understand とき slightly differently in
those two sentences.

林さんに会っ **た** とき refers to a specific point in time. The speaker will be with
Hayashi-san then and he will return the book when that time has come. This is
a typical example of relative tense.

I would understand 林さんに会 **う** とき as referring more to an occasion than a
specific point in time, or, in other words, a longer span of time than in the
sentence with 会った. It sounds like the speaker will return the book taking
advantage of the occasion to go out and meet Hayashi-san.

The probability of him returning the book to someone other than Hayashi-san
seems to increase in this case. He might drop by a library on his way to the
meeting, or meet the owner of the book after the meeting with Hayashi-san is
over. He might as well return the book to Hayashi-san when the two meet, of
course.

I think this can be seen as a case of absolute tense being used in a noun-
modifying clause (recently discussed
[here](https://japanese.stackexchange.com/q/90967/43676)), with とき being the
modified noun.

