Couldnt Overhaul be used in the same way of Eri's rewind quirk?


According to one My Hero Academia wikia

> he is also capable of using it to "revive" people, as he has done to Rappa
> multiple times

and

> Sir Nighteye assumes that Chisaki's Quirk is responsible for the healing of
> the Team Reservoir Dogs

Also

> Overhaul's characters in his name are composed of "治" (chi, lit. "govern,
> regulate, administer"), "崎" (saki, lit. "promontory, cape, spit") and "廻"
> (kai, lit. "revolve, **return** , curving"

If he can revive and may be heal people, isnt reving the most
difficult/extreme "rewind" of a person's state? Couldnt Overhaul be used in
the same way of Eri's rewind quirk?




According to description of Overhaul ability, it allows its user to
disassemble and reassemble anything, which makes it kinda similar to alchemy
from Fullmetal Alchemist. This leads me to speculation, that while
disassembling something or someone, Kai Chisaki learns how this object or
person is structured, and thus is able to reconstruct it or them to the
previous shape. This is partially backed up by the fact, that most of people,
that were "revived" by Kai Chisaki, were killed by his ability as well.

Description of Eri's ability is rather vague, but it seems she can just
"rewind" person to previous state (it is still not clear what "parameters" of
person she can "rewind"), even being not aware what this state was. Another
difference is that according to situation when

> Midoriya was using 100% Full Cowl for pretty extended time,

Eri is able to "fix" person in their current "state", instantly reverting any
changes to their body, unlike Overhaul, which is singular action.

Most limitations to quirks are never explained by author, but taking into
account, that Kai Chisaki was never using his quirk to achieve same result as
Eri is able to do, I'd say he can't "simulate" it.




According to description of Overhaul ability, it allows its user to
disassemble and reassemble anything, which makes it kinda similar to alchemy
from Fullmetal Alchemist. This leads me to speculation, that while
disassembling something or someone, Kai Chisaki learns how this object or
person is structured, and thus is able to reconstruct it or them to the
previous shape. This is partially backed up by the fact, that most of people,
that were "revived" by Kai Chisaki, were killed by his ability as well.

Description of Eri's ability is rather vague, but it seems she can just
"rewind" person to previous state (it is still not clear what "parameters" of
person she can "rewind"), even being not aware what this state was. Another
difference is that according to situation when

> Midoriya was using 100% Full Cowl for pretty extended time,

Eri is able to "fix" person in their current "state", instantly reverting any
changes to their body, unlike Overhaul, which is singular action.

Most limitations to quirks are never explained by author, but taking into
account, that Kai Chisaki was never using his quirk to achieve same result as
Eri is able to do, I'd say he can't "simulate" it.

