 that i said i will venture this comment about it because i don't i don't talk about the judge ur john erwin but i'm disappointed that erwin has been silent because they work together for years on this show they did the circuit circuit you know going to judicial circuit conferences and did supreme court review and what has happened to john is appalling but i i don't talk about it because of my prior let me go to your book one of the great things about the indispensable right