 no it wasn't and yet uh... i you know i sort of no abby known for years each other abby's a real attorney i mean you can say anything i mean he's got a what he does period but you people get him is that his involvement probably help but i'm not leading it didn't help yeah but even happy as good as he is could not pull the rabbit out of the hat on on this one that we have really was a slam-dunk so menendez is finished