 This, I believe, is the correct decision. The appointments clause, there was no congressional oversight input at all whatsoever. Where did the authority come from? And Smith and the DOJ, I'm sure they're going to file an appeal to a higher court. But the heart of this decision is the appointments clause of the Constitution, which provides the exclusive means for selecting, quote, all officers of the United States, unquote. They must be appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate.