 McCuller has a number of different honors and accolades that he racked up over this year, including Associated Press All-American Honorable Mention, NABC All-American Third Team, USBWA All-American Honorable Mention, and Naismith Defensive Player of the Year semifinalist. McCuller led the Big 12 in scoring in the 2023-2024 season at 18.3 points per game, and also was a finalist for the Jerry West Shooting Guard of the Year award.