 The Colts under Peyton Manning. The Colts under Peyton Manning. And the Colts were very good for a long time. Only were able to secure one Super Bowl. They had two trips, but only won one Super Bowl under Peyton Manning. And Peyton Manning revolutionized the game of football. In fact, I remember when he was younger, he had some rough seasons in his first year or two there. I think he has the rookie record, or he did, for the most interceptions thrown in a season.