 go down swelling dead then i took him into the vet to have him checked out and there was no signs at all inside my cat had issues that developed in his eye so my veterinarian said you know what let's go ahead and remove the eye so that night i heard the carnivore advertising so i said you know what i'm going to order this product that way at least i tried they did the procedure they did all the tests so they're surprised and they said i don't know when you did this product saved his eye