 When you hear what happened, it just doesn't seem to make sense. Robin was able to yell for help. Robin was able to scream for the other boat. She didn't need mouth-to-mouth. She didn't need to be resuscitated. She didn't need CPR. She got back on the other boat. If Tyler Mook was guilty of anything, says his lawyer, it was of behaving badly. So he throws her in the water. It's not as if he threw her into the rocks or threw her into the trees or into the mangroves. He threw her into the water as if he's throwing her into a pool.