 you know i think that's not a middle-class tax cut and i've never been arrived where i think i don't know what you're looking at gross dollars as opposed to put the per biggest percentage wins and i know the numbers well on this were for middle-class taxpayers in percentage no way but the same way i don't know what i think but not even overall dollars when you've got people who are worth billions and billions of dollars and that's not you or me let me know what they want to know that explained that way but you're doing revisionist history