looking at the income for musicians is since the advent of napster in the file sharing era room we find that the average income for musicians have risen one hundred and fourteen percent and uh... the past ten years the average income to musicians has risen six six percent twenty eight more get some sort of this share ward is truth is that the parasitic middlemen cooled off if i'm going to be a bit derogatory here help who are in the piece of plastic construction industry has have seen their record sales just go through the floor and that's excellent for artists these are the intended valley chain that used to take ninety five percent of the car artists have found out how to circumvent themself much will want to to the artists however at this particular link sits on all the lobbying power and must legislation pass so parasite middleman in trying to legislate that place in the market which from an entrepreneurial perspective is just anti market monopolistic and outrageous from from a solidarity perspective it's outrageous because it's corporation cooperative ist repression if you're looking at if you carry for artists then you certainly should not look at the record industry have done that boast since there is section to roll participant money .I see that that you were talking and i see that the way it's it's a bit sidwell friends documents and i think it has a ourselves to gain a lot of traction the the person sitting at my computer who download say a film for example they know that they're not painful or personal issue without none whatsoever i mean the issue here is if you're running a business it's your responsibility to find a business model would didn't the current constraints of society that allows you to make money you don't get to dismantle civil liberties even if you can't make money or perhaps even especially if you can make money oppressed a corporation's profitability does not factor into our degree of freedom of speech yes the pirate bay might have done something illegal 