Nozick says that if this is society as a whole can go to Bill Gates or go to Michael Jordan and tax away a portion of their wealth, what the society is really asserting is a collective property right in Bill Gates or in Michael Jordan but that violates the fundamental principle that we belong to ourselves now we've already heard a number of  objections to the libertarian argument what I would like to do today it's to give the libertarians among us a chance to answer the objections that have been raised and some have been some have already identified themselves have agreed to come and make the case for libertarianism to reply to the objections that have been raised so raise your hand if you are among the libertarians who's prepared to stand up for the theory and response to the objections you are? 