I think that if you're operating in society in which the government in which the government doesn't redistribute wealth that that allows for people to amass  so much wealth that people who haven't started from the equal footing in our hypothetical situation, that doesn't exist in our real society, get undercut for the rest of their lives. so you're worried that if there isn't some degree of redistribution if some are left at the bottom there will be no genuine equality of opportunity alright. the idea that taxation is theft, 