What tax policy would you have you'd redistribute in a flash wouldn't you because you would know being a good utilitarian that taking some, a small amount, he's scarcely going to notice it, but it will make a huge improvement in the lives and in the welfare of those at the bottom but remember the libertarian theory says we can't just add up and aggregate preferences and satisfactions that way we have to respect persons and if he earned that money fairly without violating anybody else's rights in accordance with the two principles of justice in acquisition and justice in transfer, then it would be wrong it would be a form of coercion to take it away 