Erm so My Lords I am left in the slight dilemma that erm I'm not er none of the amendments we're discussing are absolutely ideal from my point of view and meet the three difficulties er which I have touched on and indeed the amendment to which I have put my name erm number eleven, would I think be better erm to have a minority of er er a minimum number of eighteen rather than sixteen so as to simplify the arithmetical processes of contemplated er a two-thirds majority, but of the er amendments that we are discussing er if the opinion of the House is to be sort, I myself would go along with Amendment five and the two other associated amendments with which the Noble Lord, Lord  has submitted for consideration of the Committee.