Er, on paragraph nine the government's own figures show that there is a  shortfall of glee  while the others who have a  a social conscience, a and that they've mixed, the site provision isn't keeping pace with the growth of the number of caravans  and yet, what it's proposing to do in this paper will  make the situation worse by removing any incentive  erm  and any requirement on local authorities actually to provide the sites that are needed to make up that shortfall  and it's quite clear that what this is about is actually what it  is happening in housing in general and that is shifting provision from the pri , from the public to the private sector.