They were speaking in favour of it, now here he comes along er and er we we're I I find myself, regrettable I think because er er his er  a minister very well informed in these areas with er  who made in those committees a very powerful and effective contribution,now we find ourselves  on the er opposite side but I have to say now that we are on opposite side that what is introducing today er is really er too little er and far too er too too late.