I would like to think that if Freud  were alive today, he would have said the same thing, of course when Freud wrote this book in nineteen twenty one er  there was no such thing as group psychotherapy it hadn't been invented yet, it was to become very much  after World War Two but partly existed before and perhaps it's past its peak now, but erm it did become very much a  after World War Two and the point I made was and this is really wh wh what Heather ha h has just said, that if you take Freud's book on, on group seriously, how can you do group psychoanalysis?