[PAR] [TLE] Sheila Cockrel [SEP] Sheila M. Cockrel née Sheila Murphy(born November 3, 1947) is a former member of the Detroit City Council.  She was a member of the Council from 1994 to 2009.  The widow of Kenneth Cockrel, Sr., she's the stepmother of Kenneth Cockrel, Jr. Sheila Cockrel "had [a] fractious relationship with" Monica Conyers, so when the latter resigned, the former called the action "an appropriate decision".  When Dave Bing proposed a water rate hike, Sheila Cockrel was among those who voted in favor. [PAR] [TLE] Monica Conyers [SEP] Monica Conyers (born October 31, 1964) is a former Detroit City Council member (D) and former president pro tempore of the City Council.  She was first elected to the Detroit City Council in 2005
[PAR] [TLE] Sheila Cockrel [ SEP ] Sheila M. Cockrel née Sheila Murphy(born November 3 , 1947 ) is a former member of the Detroit City Council . She was a member of the Council from 1994 to 2009 . The widow of Kenneth Cockrel , Sr . , she 's the stepmother of Kenneth Cockrel , Jr. Sheila Cockrel " had [ a ] fractious relationship with " Monica Conyers , so when the latter resigned , the former called the action " an appropriate decision " . When Dave Bing proposed a water rate hike , Sheila Cockrel was among those who voted in favor . [PAR] [TLE] Monica Conyers [ SEP ] Monica Conyers ( born October 31 , 1964 ) is a former Detroit City Council member ( D ) and former president pro tempore of the City Council . She was first elected to the Detroit City Council in 2005
In which year was this former Detroit City Council member, with whom Sheila Cockrel had a fractious relationship with, first elected to the council?
In which year was this former Detroit City Council member , with whom Sheila Cockrel had a fractious relationship with , first elected to the council ?
2005
2005