<P> In Season 4 , Piney voices his disgust with Clay 's decisions following the agreement to run drugs for the cartel , and he creates a rift in the club culminating in Bobby 's call for a change of presidency vote . The vote is interrupted by attacks on SAMCRO and the Mayans , after which Piney goes to the cabin to clear his mind . It 's also revealed that Piney is privy to the contents of some letters written by John Teller ( which Tara found when she unwrapped and read the package of letters Maureen Ashby had secreted in Jax 's bag and described to Piney ) . In these letters , JT related his concerns about the direction the club had taken , his plans to stop the gunrunning for the IRA , and his fears that he was losing Gemma and that Clay would kill him . Piney believes the latter is what eventually happened and threatens Clay that he will share those letters with Jax and the club , unless Clay pulls out of the cartel deal . Clay goes to the cabin looking for the letters and questions Piney about them , after which Clay murders Piney . Clay then stages the scene to look like a hit by the cartel . Piney is the third member of SOA 's First 9 to be executed by Clay . </P>
<P> In Season 4 , Piney voices his disgust with Clay 's decisions following the agreement to run drugs for the cartel , and he creates a rift in the club culminating in Bobby 's call for a change of presidency vote . The vote is interrupted by attacks on SAMCRO and the Mayans , after which Piney goes to the cabin to clear his mind . It 's also revealed that Piney is privy to the contents of some letters written by John Teller ( which Tara found when she unwrapped and read the package of letters Maureen Ashby had secreted in Jax 's bag and described to Piney ) . In these letters , JT related his concerns about the direction the club had taken , his plans to stop the gunrunning for the IRA , and his fears that he was losing Gemma and that Clay would kill him . Piney believes the latter is what eventually happened and threatens Clay that he will share those letters with Jax and the club , unless Clay pulls out of the cartel deal . Clay goes to the cabin looking for the letters and questions Piney about them , after which Clay murders Piney . Clay then stages the scene to look like a hit by the cartel . Piney is the third member of SOA 's First 9 to be executed by Clay . </P>
when did piney die in sons of anarchy
when did piney die in sons of anarchy
Season 4
Season 4