[PAR] [TLE] Rudy Giuliani [SEP] Rudolph William Louis Giuliani {'1': ", '2': ", '3': ", '4': "} ( ; born May 28, 1944) is an American lawyer, businessman, public speaker, former mayor of New York City, and an informal adviser on cybersecurity to the White House. [PAR] [TLE] Scott Howell (political consultant) [SEP] Herbert Weston Scott Howell III is an American conservative political consultant, whose recent clients include Meg Whitman and Rudy Giuliani.
[PAR] [TLE] Rudy Giuliani [ SEP ] Rudolph William Louis Giuliani { ' 1 ' : " , ' 2 ' : " , ' 3 ' : " , ' 4 ' : " } ( ; born May 28 , 1944 ) is an American lawyer , businessman , public speaker , former mayor of New York City , and an informal adviser on cybersecurity to the White House . [PAR] [TLE] Scott Howell ( political consultant ) [ SEP ] Herbert Weston Scott Howell III is an American conservative political consultant , whose recent clients include Meg Whitman and Rudy Giuliani .
Scott Howell is a consultant who has worked with the mayor of what city?
Scott Howell is a consultant who has worked with the mayor of what city ?
New York City
New York City