<P> During Avery Martin 's ( Alexandra Daddario ) engagement party , Noah Ashby ( Adam DeVine ) recalls his and Avery 's first meeting during a Halloween party three years earlier and is sad to see her engaged to perfect Ethan ( Robbie Amell ) instead of him . Drunk and being driven home by Avery 's photographer roommate Carrie Grey ( Shelley Hennig ) , Noah admits he is secretly in love with Avery but , on the night they met , Avery only saw him as a good friend and met Ethan the next day . </P>
<P> During Avery Martin 's ( Alexandra Daddario ) engagement party , Noah Ashby ( Adam DeVine ) recalls his and Avery 's first meeting during a Halloween party three years earlier and is sad to see her engaged to perfect Ethan ( Robbie Amell ) instead of him . Drunk and being driven home by Avery 's photographer roommate Carrie Grey ( Shelley Hennig ) , Noah admits he is secretly in love with Avery but , on the night they met , Avery only saw him as a good friend and met Ethan the next day . </P>
who plays avery in when we first met
who plays avery in when we first met
Alexandra Daddario
Alexandra Daddario