<P> While the Elrics continue their search for the Philosopher 's Stone , they decide to go meet their old mentor , Izumi Curtis . Winry gets them to take her to Rush Valley , the automail capital of the world , along the way , much to their dismay . There she meets a pickpocket named Paninya . They become friends because Winry is interested in her automail legs and Winry convinces her to try to earn her money honestly . Winry also meets the family of Dominic , an automail engineer , and when Dominic 's daughter - in - law goes into labor , Winry successfully delivers her baby . She asks to be Dominic 's apprentice , but is refused both because Dominic does n't take apprentices and because he has an unexplained past with her grandmother , Pinako , and is terrified of her . He introduces her to another engineer named Garfiel , who happily takes her on . Some time later , Winry returns with the Elrics to Central Headquarters and finds that Hughes was murdered , leaving Winry grieving . When the Elrics confront the criminal Scar once again to get closer to the Philosopher 's Stone , Winry goes there to try to help them , only to discover during the fight that Scar killed her parents during the Ishvalan War . She points a gun at Scar , but Ed jumps in front of her and pins the gun down , allowing Scar to flee with Al in pursuit . Winry becomes distressed that she could n't bring herself to shoot , but Ed reassures her that her hands are n't meant to kill , but are meant for saving lives . After Ed delivers her to the custody of others , despite her desire to have him stay , Winry spends the rest of the day with King Bradley . After Scar escapes , Winry returns to Rush Valley , and Ed tells her the next time he makes her cry they will be tears of joy . After this , she realizes she has been in love with him . </P>
<P> While the Elrics continue their search for the Philosopher 's Stone , they decide to go meet their old mentor , Izumi Curtis . Winry gets them to take her to Rush Valley , the automail capital of the world , along the way , much to their dismay . There she meets a pickpocket named Paninya . They become friends because Winry is interested in her automail legs and Winry convinces her to try to earn her money honestly . Winry also meets the family of Dominic , an automail engineer , and when Dominic 's daughter - in - law goes into labor , Winry successfully delivers her baby . She asks to be Dominic 's apprentice , but is refused both because Dominic does n't take apprentices and because he has an unexplained past with her grandmother , Pinako , and is terrified of her . He introduces her to another engineer named Garfiel , who happily takes her on . Some time later , Winry returns with the Elrics to Central Headquarters and finds that Hughes was murdered , leaving Winry grieving . When the Elrics confront the criminal Scar once again to get closer to the Philosopher 's Stone , Winry goes there to try to help them , only to discover during the fight that Scar killed her parents during the Ishvalan War . She points a gun at Scar , but Ed jumps in front of her and pins the gun down , allowing Scar to flee with Al in pursuit . Winry becomes distressed that she could n't bring herself to shoot , but Ed reassures her that her hands are n't meant to kill , but are meant for saving lives . After Ed delivers her to the custody of others , despite her desire to have him stay , Winry spends the rest of the day with King Bradley . After Scar escapes , Winry returns to Rush Valley , and Ed tells her the next time he makes her cry they will be tears of joy . After this , she realizes she has been in love with him . </P>
who killed winry 's parents in fullmetal alchemist
who killed winry 's parents in fullmetal alchemist
Scar
Scar