<P> The guys go to a coffee shop , where Ted points out that Chloe ( Morena Baccarin ) , the girl working there , has drawn a heart next to Marshall 's name on his cup . Ted insists that Chloe has a crush on Marshall because she always laughs at his lame joke about how they fit a pumpkin into a pumpkin - flavored latte . As Marshall leaves , his name is called for ( an unordered ) pumpkin latte on which Chloe has written her number . Later , when Marshall introduces Chloe to Ted and Barney at the bar , they tell him that she has the `` Crazy Eyes '' , an indicator of future mental instability . Both Ted and Barney give Marshall examples of their experiences with this malady ; Barney 's crazy - eyed date wanted a threesome with a teddy bear , while Ted 's crazy - eyed date picked up a long metal rod and repeatedly hit a car that nearly hit them as they were about to cross the street . Marshall shrugs it off . The next day , as Marshall is taking a test , he receives a call from Chloe who says that she is being followed by a hunchback with a limp . Later , Marshall takes Chloe back to his apartment and suspects that she broke a picture of him and Lily that was sitting on the end table . However , it turns out that Lily has been hiding in the apartment , and pops out ( much to Marshall and Chloe 's surprise ) . Lily introduces herself , and leaves the apartment dejected and crying . Marshall follows her out to the steps , leaving Chloe sitting on the sofa . </P>
<P> The guys go to a coffee shop , where Ted points out that Chloe ( Morena Baccarin ) , the girl working there , has drawn a heart next to Marshall 's name on his cup . Ted insists that Chloe has a crush on Marshall because she always laughs at his lame joke about how they fit a pumpkin into a pumpkin - flavored latte . As Marshall leaves , his name is called for ( an unordered ) pumpkin latte on which Chloe has written her number . Later , when Marshall introduces Chloe to Ted and Barney at the bar , they tell him that she has the `` Crazy Eyes '' , an indicator of future mental instability . Both Ted and Barney give Marshall examples of their experiences with this malady ; Barney 's crazy - eyed date wanted a threesome with a teddy bear , while Ted 's crazy - eyed date picked up a long metal rod and repeatedly hit a car that nearly hit them as they were about to cross the street . Marshall shrugs it off . The next day , as Marshall is taking a test , he receives a call from Chloe who says that she is being followed by a hunchback with a limp . Later , Marshall takes Chloe back to his apartment and suspects that she broke a picture of him and Lily that was sitting on the end table . However , it turns out that Lily has been hiding in the apartment , and pops out ( much to Marshall and Chloe 's surprise ) . Lily introduces herself , and leaves the apartment dejected and crying . Marshall follows her out to the steps , leaving Chloe sitting on the sofa . </P>
who plays crazy eyes in how i met your mother
who plays crazy eyes in how i met your mother
Morena Baccarin
Morena Baccarin