Karl Shoemaker . Sanctuary and Crime in the Middle Ages, 400–1500 . (Just Ideas: Transformative Ideals of Justice in Ethical and Political Thought.) New York: Fordham University Press. 2011. Pp. xiv, 269. $65.00.
Lisi Oliver
Karl Shoemaker's book fills an important gap in scholarly literature by tracing the institution of sanctuary from its early continental roots to eventual abandonment modern period, guiding reader through practices late imperial Rome reign Henry VIII. That such a broad overview finds room for sort anecdotal and narrative details that bring issues alive non‐specialist is tribute thorough research meticulous planning brought this volume. Shoemaker begins his study Roman Empire, presenting as precursor concept Augustine's belief sinner could redeem himself eyes God society performing penance priestly intercession. The “Ten Laws” attributed Constantine—now known be forgery but accepted genuine Middle Ages—required guilty person fleeing consecrated church defended. This privilege, however, was often denied debtors Jews, and—added edict 398—the ever‐felonious “purple dye fish collector” (p. 36). concludes “Sanctuary drew on meanings embedded deeply both ancient aristocratic Christian traditions” 43).
The American Historical Review