Criticism of Crusading, 1095-1274
Michael Gervers|Elizabeth Siberry
Unlike most historical works on criticism of crusading, which focus the 13th century, this detailed study traces subject from time First Crusade to Second Council Lyons. Drawing a wide range Latin and vernacular sources, Siberry argues that critics were actually more concerned with abuses crusading ideals practices than their justification, even made suggestions for improvement. Each chapter covers different type criticism--from bitter those who capable fighting but failed fulfill vows complaints about behavior armies--and assesses its significance. refutes many scholarly misconceptions nature extent critics' protests, concludes there was still much popular enthusiasm in 1274.
The American Historical Review