Generalized pruritus can be the manifestation of many dermatologic and systemic diseases. However, it has been reported infrequently in the literature as a consequence of hyperferritinemia. We report the case of a 70-year-old male presenting to dermatology due to generalized pruritus in the absence of a rash, who was subsequently found to have a significantly elevated serum ferritin and transferrin saturation with otherwise normal iron studies. Hereditary hemochromatosis was ruled out on genetic testing; however, etiologies of secondary iron overload including alcohol use disorder and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease were present. The patient had minimal relief of his pruritus with topical corticosteroids, oral prednisone, and moisturizers. The only successful treatment was phlebotomy which resulted in complete resolution of his long-standing pruritus. We present the fifth case of generalized pruritus associated with hyperferritinemia, treated successfully with phlebotomy.