Often misdiagnosed as melanoma, melanocytoma of the optic disc is a rare benign ocular lesion that requires minimal active intervention, but demands a life time follow-up. We present a case of a 32-year-old man who was referred to our institute for the management of choroidal melanoma of the optic disc, which was detected by chance when the patient presented to a general ophthalmologist with chief complaint of itching in both eyes. The patient had normal visual acuity and fundoscopy revealed classical optic disc melanocytoma. The ancillary tests confirmed the diagnosis. The patient was kept under follow-up for four years, which showed no increase in size of the lesion. The purpose of this presentation was to highlight the identifying features of ocular melanocytoma and differentiate it from other conditions requiring urgent intervention.