Cardiac myxoma recurrence is uncommon following surgical resection. Recurrence is about 2-3% in familial cases; however, recurrence is uncommon in sporadic cases. Most of the recurrences will occur during the first three to four years. Ten percent of myxomas are of the inherited autosomal dominant disorder called Carney's complex, while the rest appear sporadic. We are reporting a nonfamilial case of atrial myxoma, recurring rapidly seven years after resection of the initial left atrial myxoma with a pathologically proven clear margin and no malignant transformation. Cardiac neoplasms are rare and occur less commonly than metastatic disease of the heart. Congestive heart failure symptoms and thromboembolism account for nearly half of the presenting signs and symptoms. The initial presentation of our case was an embolic phenomenon, presenting with a stroke. The patient subsequently underwent resection of the mass, with pathology confirming the complete excision of the myxoma with a clear margin and no evidence of malignant transformation. Our patient was closely followed up in the clinic on annual transthoracic echocardiography surveillance, with a recurrence noted on surveillance echocardiography in 2021 (seven years after initial diagnosis) despite the patient being asymptomatic. This case illustrates transthoracic echocardiography as the mainstay of detection of recurrent left atrial myxoma; however, it also asks the question of how often patients need to be screened for recurrence of left atrial myxoma and for how long they need to have surveillance echocardiography. Clinical presentation and transesophageal echocardiographic views are extremely helpful in sharpening the accuracy of the diagnosis.