Gestational thrombocytopenia is the commonest cause of thrombocytopenia in pregnancy, accounting for 70-80% of cases. It is a benign condition that recovers completely in the postpartum period. Although the cause is not fully understood, it is thought that pregnancy-related hemodilution and increased platelet consumption play a significant contributory role. Several life-threatening causes of thrombocytopenia in pregnancy make up the remaining 20-30% of cases. There are reports of recurrence of GT in women, but not many case reports document more than three consecutive episodes. We present a case of a young woman who had gestational thrombocytopenia during the third trimester of her four consecutive pregnancies, followed by complete recovery after each pregnancy. We ruled out other sinister and life-threatening causes of thrombocytopenia in pregnancy. During her four consecutive pregnancies, her platelet count fell below normal at the beginning of the third trimester, with a nadir towards the end. The other hematological indices, generally used as markers of hemodilution, remained in the normal pregnancy-specific reference range during each of her four pregnancies. This case argues against pregnancy-related hemodilution being a major factor in gestational thrombocytopenia. A systematic approach is paramount when differentiating the several causes of thrombocytopenia in pregnancy.