Although well documented, constrictive pericarditis is a rare entity and an uncommon cause of heart failure. A stiff and noncompliant pericardium creates the disease's unique hemodynamics and leads to elevated venous pressures, hepatic sinusoidal congestion, and draining of protein-rich fluid into the peritoneal cavity presenting as ascites. The low incidence in addition to its varied and subtle clinical presentations can often lead to a delay in diagnosis. Here, we present 2 clinical cases of constrictive pericarditis in which ascitic fluid analysis was important-one patient who presented with new-onset ascites with concern for cirrhosis and another patient who presented with symptoms concerning for heart failure with ascites. Through their hospital course and workup, we highlight the importance of diagnostic sampling of ascitic fluid to prompt the consideration of constrictive pericarditis followed by utilizing advanced diagnostics, such as echocardiogram and cardiac catheterization to reach the correct diagnosis in an otherwise often overlooked pathology.