CT chest performed to investigate dyspnea and malaise in an 83 year old man demonstrated bilateral circumferential pleural thickening highly suspicious for pleural mesothelioma or metastatic pleural malignancy. Histopathology of a subsequent pleural biopsy returned a diagnosis of pleural amyloid. This case identifies pleural amyloid as a rare differential consideration for diffuse pleural thickening; the difficulties in distinguishing pleural amyloid from pleural malignancy are highlighted.