Thyroid storm is a rare, potentially lethal condition involving collapse of the hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid feedback loop. Thyroid storm carries a significant mortality rate, thus requiring prompt identification and treatment. A 47-year-old woman presented to the emergency department complaining of palpitations, shortness of breath, and emesis for 24 hours after using methamphetamine. Past medical history was significant for untreated hyperthyroidism. Physical examination revealed a prominent, palpable thyroid. The Burch-Wartofsky-Score was 35. Management for thyroid storm included propylthiouracil (PTU), super saturated potassium iodide, intravenous hydrocortisone, and propranolol. However, a rare drug reaction to PTU on day 3 resulted in agranulocytosis. Propylthiouracil was withheld and a modified total thyroidectomy performed on day 8 without complications and the patient discharged on day 10 with levothyroxine. Undertreated hyperthyroidism may predispose patients to catecholamine-induced thyrotoxicosis due to catecholamine hypersensitivity. With known methamphetamine use, methamphetamine toxicity and a methamphetamine-exacerbated thyroid storm need to be included in the differential diagnosis in a patient presenting with signs of thyrotoxicosis. In addition, treating patients with agranulocytosis from PTU with a modified total thyroidectomy using ligation of the vascular supply as the initial surgical step limits release of thyroid hormone into the blood stream during thyroidectomy and decreases the possibility of intra operative thyroid storm.