Coronary artery anomalies (CAAs) are an uncommon cause of chest pain in the younger population. Misdiagnosis can be detrimental and lead to sudden cardiac deaths. We present a 62-year-old male with a past medical history significant for chest pain history with a workup in 2001 presumed to be non-cardiac in origin from bronchial asthma. He presented from a Micronesian Island for the evaluation of non-exertional chest discomfort. Further workup showed a Brugada type I pattern on ECG and ST wave depressions on anterolateral and inferior leads with associated AVR elevation on exercise stress testing. Further ischemic workup with coronary angiography revealed right dominant circulation with three-vessel coronary artery disease (CAD), including mid-left anterior descending (LAD) artery chronic total occlusion (CTO) with the right to left collaterals, left circumflex, and right coronary artery (RCA) with the accompanied anomalous origin of RCA. The patient underwent surgical correction of the anomalous RCA and coronary artery bypass grafting for the multi-vessel CAD. CAAs are usually found incidentally during ischemic workups similar to this case. Patients with CAAs can be managed conservatively with caution regarding physical activity. However, high-risk patients will warrant surgical treatment to avoid sudden cardiac death. The diagnosis of CAAs can be challenging and prone to misdiagnosis and maltreatment. It may be beneficial to pursue this in younger patients with ischemia-like symptoms. Further studies should be performed to identify the true incidence and guide medical practitioners regarding the risks, costs, and benefits of diagnosing and surgically treating CAAs in the general population.