Familial exudative vitreoretinopathy (FEVR) is a genetic disorder whose presentation can include osteoporosis, multiple fractures, and incomplete retinal angiogenesis leading to retinal detachment and blindness if left untreated. Discussed herein are the cases of two pediatric siblings who presented to the orthopedic service with multiple fractures and, through interdisciplinary management, were diagnosed with FEVR and treated appropriately before permanent visual impairment. The skeletal manifestations of FEVR, which have not been explored in depth in prior literature, are described. One sibling presented to orthopedic services for evaluation of a closed distal radius fracture sustained while playing sports. A comprehensive history revealed he had suffered at least four appendicular fractures in his lifetime, and dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scan revealed his bone density to be in the first percentile for his age. Concurrent evaluation of his younger sibling revealed a similar history of multiple fractures and low bone density. Referral to genetic services and ensuing whole-exome sequencing revealed a likely pathogenic variant in both siblings' LRP5 gene, the only known causative mutation for FEVR that leads to skeletal manifestations. While FEVR is well known in genetic and ophthalmologic settings, greater awareness of FEVR and other genetic disorders that predispose to fractures in pediatric populations is warranted in orthopedic settings. This will lead to reduced sequelae in pediatric patients with genetic disorders and improved interdisciplinary expertise. The story of these siblings illustrates that a high index of suspicion for genetic diseases is essential when treating children with osteoporosis and growth delays.