Involuntary unwanted erections are extremely rare after spinal cord injury (SCI). A sudden loss of sympathetic tone to the pelvic vasculature following SCI causes an increase in the parasympathetic tone and uncontrolled arterial blood flow into the penile sinusoidal spaces. When occurring immediately after an acute SCI, it is generally self-limiting and settles within a few hours. In contrast, recurrent, unwanted erections in patients with chronic SCI are more unpredictable in frequency and duration and may require treatment. We present a case of recurrent involuntary unwanted erections in a patient with chronic SCI after a stab wound to his neck and review the pathophysiology and available management options.