Liver abscess of oropharyngeal origin in an immunocompetent patient is a rare condition. Furthermore, microbiologic diagnosis of liver abscess can be challenging due to the tremendous diversity of the microorganisms implicated and culture difficulties under laboratory conditions. We report a case of a previously healthy 23-year-old male, who presented multiple liver abscesses, attributed to aggregatibacter aphrophilus, an obligatory oral gram-negative microorganism, that normally is a component of the commensal oral microbiota and non-virulent. The etiopathogenic microorganism was identified after needle aspiration of a liver abscess cavity. Treatment with broad-spectrum antimicrobials and percutaneous catheter drainage under computed tomography guidance of both abscesses, resulted in full recovery. A. aphrophilus represents a rare entity of liver abscess in healthy individuals and suggests that a pathogen of oropharyngeal origin should be suspected when an overt source of infection cannot be documented.