The shoulder is the commonest major joint involved in dislocations. These are often associated with fractures of the surgical neck and/or of the greater tuberosity of the proximal humerus. A good functional recovery is associated with a successful union of the tuberosity fragment, as this carries the insertion of the superior and posterior rotator cuff tendons. A 29-year-old male patient presented to our Emergency Department (ED) after a fall off his motorbike, resulting in a left shoulder fracture dislocation and an axillary nerve injury. His shoulder was reduced under sedation in the ED, with post-reduction radiographs demonstrating a seemingly satisfactory fracture position. Later on, a computerized tomography (CT) scan was arranged which actually confirmed significant displacement of his greater tuberosity, which was not picked up on initial post-reduction radiographs. As a result of identifying the displacement, surgical fixation with a locking plate and suture construct was undertaken. This case demonstrates the ease with which greater tuberosity fractures can mistakenly be presumed as reduced on post-reduction films, whilst in fact they can be significantly displaced. This risk is especially great when only one radiographic view is obtained. The sign of the 'disappearing tuberosity' on a plain radiograph should prompt the clinician to seek further imaging by way of CT, to uncover the true position of the greater tuberosity.