This report describes a 30-year-old immunocompetent male with new-onset seizures, later found on imaging to have 2 enhancing lesions in the brain. The patient underwent a left parietal craniectomy with resection of one of the masses, which demonstrated focal areas of necrosis and many small cystic structures positive for periodic acid-Schiff and Gomori's methenamine silver special stain. Numerous laboratory examinations, including HIV test, rapid plasma reagin, toxoplasma immunoglobulin G and immunoglobulin M, Lyme, cytomegalovirus, tuberculosis, cysticercosis, and Echinococcus serology, were all negative. Despite negative cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) culture and several negative CSF antigen tests, continued investigation, and follow-up, CSF antigen testing ultimately revealed Cryptococcus as the causative agent. In light of the mysterious and unusual presentation, the authors discuss potential infectious differential diagnoses in patients with atypical clinical presentation, laboratory tests, and surgical pathology.