   Spring Damping
  HiI'm having some trouble understanding spring damping, in particular, this document. Can anyone help explain where the second part of that equation comes from? I (think) understand the first part (before the + sign,) is Hooke's law, Fs=-kx (where k is spring constant and x is displacement.) With just this, the spring seems to work OK.The problem is the second part. I tried just implementing Fd = -cv for damping, then adding to Fs to get the total force, but everything went totally haywire. I took v to mean the velocity of the spring's current expansion, which is calculated using the velocities of the particles attached to the ends of the spring.So I rewrote the code as per the second part of that equation and now it works, but why? Why didn't the damping force work as calculated before? I really don't like simply taking code for granted...Clearly I am a physics noob and have done something very wrong, so be kind :)   
  For dampening to work you need a very small time step. Otherwise the dampening force will be introduced too abruptly causing the system to be chaotic.You'll also need to be mindful of the sign, it may be possible that you were adding energy rather than removing it. Do you have some graphed or tabled results for your calculation? Can you be more specific about how it was not working correctly?If it works now, it should be possible to see the difference (mistakes) between your coded implementation and your calculations.   ;Quote:I'm having some trouble understanding spring damping, in particular, this document. Can anyone help explain where the second part of that equation comes from? Its the same as F=-c*v. The current velocity of one endpoint is (v2-v1) and the direction to which the spring exerts force is given by the two endpoints, forming the unit vector (r1-r2)/|r1-r2|.Quote:The problem is the second part. I tried just implementing Fd = -cv for damping, then adding to Fs to get the total force, but everything went totally haywire. I took v to mean the velocity of the spring's current expansion, which is calculated using the velocities of the particles attached to the ends of the spring.So I rewrote the code as per the second part of that equation and now it works, but why? Why didn't the damping force work as calculated before? I really don't like simply taking code for granted.. Could you have forgotten a minus sign? Or either calculated v wrongly? (I mean, with the wrong sign) That would run the simulation into a big mess very quickly. Note, in the article you posted, that the velocity is calculated as (v2-v1), and is it added to the original force, instead of subtracting.The article uses:    F = F_ext + (v2-v1)*...which is the same asF = F_ext - (v1-v2)*...where you could easily have writtenF = F_ext -(v2-v1)And if that's the case, havoc introduces itself for you :)   ;  Hi there,I wrote a tutorial on mass-spring-damper systems explaining exactly this in great detail and with several illustrations and easy-to-read code samples (scroll down about halfway to get directly to the spring damping stuff).http://www.freebasic.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9769Cheers,Mike[Edited by - h4tt3n on September 8, 2009 1:03:11 PM]