original_query: What positions did Joe Lhota hold during Rudy Giuliani's administration?
query: What positions did Joe Lhota hold during Rudy Giuliani's administration?
answer: During Rudy Giuliani's two terms as mayor, Joe Lhota served as chief of staff to the deputy mayor for finance and economic development, New York City finance commissioner, director of the New York City Mayor's Office of Management and Budget, and deputy mayor for operations.