Comparison of Aberration Detection Algorithms for Biosurveillance Systems

Keywords: 8, ,<0/ =0@0<,7 ,-0<<,>4:9 /0>0.>4:9 ,72:<4>38= ?=492 , =0> :1 =C9/<:84. /,>, =><0,8= 1<:8 , 7,<20 9?8-0< :1 ><0,>809> 1,.474>40= 49 >30 4:=09=0 =C=>08 <0,74=>4. =429,7 4950.>4:9 =><,>02C A,= /0@4=0/ >: .:8, ,<0 /4110<09> A,C= :1 ,/5?=>492 1:< >:>,7 1,.474>C @4=4>= ,9/ -,.62<:?9/ /,C :1 A006 0110.>= Introduction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ethods (0 ?=0/ /,47C =C9/<:80 .:?9>= ,22<02,>0/ -C 1,.474>C ,= -,=07490 /,>, (0 49.7?/0/ =,8, 70/ 1,.474>40= A4>3 /,>, <0, <>0/ 0@0<C /,C 1<:8 !,9 >3<:?23 #,C ,9/ A4>3 80,9 /,47C =C9/<:84. .:?9>= :@0< >30 09>4<0 =>?/C, 0<4:/ %C9/<:80 2<:?, = .3:=09 A0<0 2,=><:49>0=>49,7 <,=3 ,9/ ?, 0< <0=, 4<,>:<C 4910.>4:9 '$ #?7>4 /,C =429,7= A0<0 <,9/:87C /<,A9 1<:8 , 7:29:<8,7 /4=><4-?>4:9 A3:=0 @,7?0 :9 >30, 0,6 /,C A,= >A4.0 >30 -,.62<:?9/ =>,9/,</ /0@4,>4:9 ,9/ =?.3 >3,> >30 =429,7 /?<,>4:9 <,920/ 1<:8 /,C= 950.>0/ .:?9>= A0<0 ,, 740/ >: -:>3 >30 =C9/<:84. ,9/ >:>,7 @4=4> >480 =0<40= 1:< ,..?<,>0 ,==0==809> :1 >30 >:>,7 @4=4> ,/5?=>809> > , -,.62<:?9/ ,70<> <,>0 :1 A0 .,7.?7,>0/ =09=4>4@4>C >30 <,>4: :1 9?8-0< :1 0@09>= /0>0.>0/ -01:<0 >30 /4=><4-?>4:9, 0,6 >: >30 >:>,7 9?8-0< :1 4950.>0/ =429,7= ,9/ >4807490== ,= >30 9?8-0< :1 /,C= 1<:8 >30 =>,<> :1 4950.>4:9 >: >30 14<=> ,72:<4>38 ,70<> (0 .:8, ,<0/ 14@0 ,72:<4>38= A4>3 -,=07490 /,C= ,9/ /,C =74/492 -?110< ,.3 ,72:<4>38 A,= >0=>0/ A4>3 ,9/ A4>3:?> =><,>414.,>4:9 -C A006/,C @0<=?= A00609/ 3:74/,C :?9> .:?9> -,=0/ %:?9> .:?9> -,=0/ '%'# *+ $,>0 A4>3 .:?9> ,/5?=>0/ 1:< >:>,7 @4=4> *+ $,>4:, 0<.09>,20 .:?9>= >:>,7 @4=4>= -,=0/ %$,>0 '%'# A4>3 .:?9> ,/5?=>0/ 1:< >:>,7 @4=4>= Results :< <,=3 ,9/ '$ <0=, 0.>4@07C >30 80,9 :-=0<@0/ /,47C .:?9>=, 0< 1,.474>C A0<0 ,9/ /?<492 >30 A006 /,C= ,9/ ,9/ /?<492 >30 A00609/= 3:74/,C= &30 8:/4140/ '%'# ,72:<4>38 %$,>0 3,/ >30 34230=> ,@0<,20 =09=4>4@4>C ,9/ >4807490== 4 0 =3:<>0=> >480 >: /0>0.>4:9 1:< ,77 >3<00 =C9/<:80= <02,</70== :1 >30 A006/,C =><,>414.,>4:9 &,-70 (4>3 @0<C 10A 0B.0, >4:9= $,>0 A34.3 ,7=: ,/5?=>0/ 1:< >:>,7 @4=4>= 49 >30 ,72:<4>38, 0<1:<80/ -0>>0< >3,9 :?9> %:?9> ,9/ $,>4: &30 :@0<,77 =09=4>4@4>C ,9/ >4807490== 49.<0,=0/ =?-=>,9>4,77C ,1>0< ,..:?9>492 1:< A006/,C= ,9/ A00609/= 1:< ,77 14@0 ,72:<4>38= ,9/ ,77 >3<00 =>?/40/ =C9/<:80= Conclusions &30=0 ,9,7C=0= :9 >3<00 =C9/<:84. /,>, /08:9=><,>0 >3,> ,..:?9> 492 1:< >:>,7 1,.474>C @4=4>= ,9/ A006/,C A00609/= 48, <:@0= =09=4 >4@4>C ,9/ >4807490== 49 /0>0.>492 8?7>4 /,C :?>-<0,6= 8:/4140/ '%'# ,72:<4>38 :?>, 0<1:<8= 8,9C .?<<09>7C ?=0/ 80>3:/= ?<>30< ,9,7C=0= ?=492 >480 =0<40= 1<:8 ,//4>4:9,7 =C9/<:80= ,<0 900/0/ &,-70 %09=4>4@4>C ,9/ >4807490== ,C >: /0>0.> :1 8?7>4 /,C =429,7 0=> ,8:92 14@0 ,72:<4>38=