Introduction
============

Rationale
---------

The CAncer Risk and INsulin analoGues (CARING) project aims to assess the possible carcinogenic effect of

insulin. As part of this project evaluation of the background risk of developing cancer in diabetes patients was performed in this systematic review and meta-analysis.

Diabetes Mellitus is associated with increased morbidity and mortality. Diabetes is the 8^th^ leading cause of mortality in high-income countries; whereas colorectal and breast cancer are the 7^th^ and 10^th^ leading causes, respectively \[[@r1]\]. Associations between diabetes and cancer have already been established for specific cancer sites in several meta-analyses \[[@r2]-[@r23]\], however it is not known whether the observed associations were due to diabetes per sé or caused by competing risks.

Associations between diabetes and cancer have been established by several meta-analyses including only studies of an observational design (case control and/or cohort). All meta-analyses reporting a significant increased risk among diabetes patients for pancreatic cancer between 1.8 to 2.1 \[[@r2]-[@r4]\] and liver cancer between 1.8 to 3.6 \[[@r5]-[@r8], [@r24]\]. Subgroup analyses stratified by gender or statistical adjustment for Body Mass Index (BMI), smoking and alcohol did not influence the risk for pancreatic cancer \[[@r2]\]. However, results were conflicting on whether a duration of diabetes of 10 years was associated with an increased risk of pancreatic cancer \[[@r2], [@r3]\], while duration of diabetes appeared not to influence risk of liver cancer \[[@r5]\]. Furthermore, diabetes treatment modulated the risk of liver cancer with greater risk estimates for insulin or sulfonylurea users than for metformin users \[[@r5]\]. Several observational studies have examined the relationship between diabetes and gastrointestinal cancers. Results were conflicting in the meta-analyses on gastric cancer \[[@r15],[@r16]\], while an increased risk of esophageal cancer was reported \[[@r13]\]. In addition, diabetes has been associated with an increased risk of colorectal cancer \[[@r17]-[@r19], [@r21]-[@r23]\] after adjustment for BMI and smoking \[[@r20]\]. Both endometrial cancer \[[@r7]\] and breast cancer \[[@r25]-[@r28]\] were reported to be increased in diabetes, while prostate cancer was found to be decreased in men with diabetes by 10% \[[@r9],[@r10]\]. The association with prostate cancer was independent of BMI \[[@r10]\]. Diabetes was also associated with increased risk of kidney cancer \[[@r11]\] and bladder cancer \[[@r12]\]; however this last association was not significant when using estimates adjusted for BMI due to wider confidence intervals. Last of all an increased risk among diabetes patients for non-Hodgkin lymphoma and leukemia but not multiple myeloma has also been reported in a meta-analysis \[[@r14]\].

It is uncertain whether the relationship between diabetes and cancer is direct (e.g., due to hyperglycemia), whether diabetes is a marker of underlying biologic factors that alter cancer risk (e.g., insulin resistance and hyperinsulinemia), or whether the association between diabetes and cancer is indirect and due to common risk factors such as obesity. Duration of diabetes has been found to be of importance in the development of cancer among insulin using type 2 diabetes (T2D) patients \[[@r29]\]; however whether cancer risk was influenced by the duration of diabetes is a critical and complex issue and may be complicated further by the multidrug therapy often necessary for diabetes treatment. The incidence of cancer increases with age, and as age increases with duration of diabetes, this may confound the association between diabetes and cancer. However, an association between diabetes and cancer was present for several cancer sites. Few studies take into account duration of diabetes, medication use or age of the participants. Furthermore, a meta-analysis reported an association between obesity and several cancer types including colorectal, kidney, breast and endometrial cancer, and also an independent association between obesity and T2D \[[@r30]\]. Therefore, it is important both to take obesity into account and to distinguish between type 1 diabetes (T1D) and T2D, which have not been done in previous reports. Except from Ge *et al.* \[[@r16]\] (using three databases), none of the meta-analyses described in the introduction have used more than two databases in their search (Medline at PubMed and Embase/ Medline at PubMed and Cochrane database of systematic reviews), and many only used Medline at PubMed leaving them with a possible publication bias.

Objectives
----------

In an attempt to evaluate the risk of cancer in diabetes patients and taking possible determinants into account this thorough systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted. The primary objective was to study the effects of diabetes per sé, by collating observational studies that compared diabetes patients to non-diabetes. A secondary objective was to examine the effects that type of diabetes, body weight, metabolic control, diet as well as study design had on the risk of cancer.

Methods
=======

Protocol and Registration
-------------------------

The systematic review and meta-analysis was developed according to the Cochrane Collaboration (http://www.cochr ane.org/training/cochrane-handbook), and PRISMA guidelines \[[@r31]\] (<http://www.prisma-statement.org/>) and was registered on PROSPERO (<http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/>) with the registration number: CRD42012002310.

Eligibility Criteria
--------------------

The eligibility criteria for the studies were those studies that evaluated the association between diabetes and cancer (incidence, odds or prevalence) as the outcomes. Studies evaluating solely cancer mortality were excluded. The studies needed to compare diabetes patients with a non-diabetes reference group. All types of observational study designs (e.g. case control, cohort and cross-sectional studies) were included. Studies assessing the effect of a specific intervention compared to no intervention were excluded. Studies only published as conference abstracts were excluded. Studies were not excluded due to language or publication year.

Information Sources
-------------------

The systematic literature search included 7 databases: Medline at PubMed, Embase, Cinahl, Bibliotek.dk, Cochrane library, Web of Science, and SveMed+. The first search was performed 11^th^ of January 2012, and updated with the last search on the 9^th^ November 2012. Additional studies were added after assessment of the reference list in meta-analyses and reviews found in the search. Furthermore, studies were retrieved from the literature search of a systematic review of insulin use and cancer risk also performed by the CARING project group (PROSPERO registration number: CRD42012002428).

Search
------

The search terms included: "Diabetes mellitus", "diabetes", "Neoplasms", "cancer", "Prospective study", "statistics", "cancer statistics", and "Risk of cancer". Other search terms such as statistics and cancer statistics were also used but gave to few results and were not used as the final result. The search was performed using the thesaurus if available in the respective databases. Limitations were used to refine the search if available in the databases ("biochemistry", "cancer", "physiology and endocrinology", "cochrane review", "controlled clinical trial", "systematic review", "clinical trial", "randomized controlled trial", "review", "meta-analysis"), qualifiers ("analysis", "blood", "classification", "epidemiology", "statistics and numerical data"), categories ("endocrinology metabolism", "oncology") and research areas ("endocrinology metabolism", "oncology", "biochemistry molecular biology"). Search terms, limitations, qualifiers, categories and research areas used differently by database dependent on the functions available at the database. The search from Embase is listed below. The results from \#9 in the Embase search were used in this study.

Search from the 09^th^ of November 2012

No. No. Query Results

\#1 'Diabetes Mellitus'/exp 526,730

\#2 'Neoplasm'/exp 3,165,370

\#3 \#1 AND \#2 34,949

\#4 \#1 AND \#2 (\[biochemistry\]/lim 15,064

OR \[cancer\]/lim

OR \[physiology and endocrinology\]/lim)

\#5 'Cancer statistics'/exp 2,034

\#6 \#4 AND \#5 7

\#7 'Cancer statistics'/exp 272,379

\#8 \#4 AND \#5 36

\#9 \#1 AND \#2(\[biochemistry\]/lim 634

OR \[cancer\]/lim

OR \[physiology and endocrinology\]/lim)

AND (\[cochrane review\]/lim

OR \[controlled clinical trial\]/lim

OR \[systematic review\]/lim))

Study Selection and Data Collection Process
-------------------------------------------

Studies were assessed for eligibility using the criteria above. Reviewer one (JSL) performed the literature search in collaboration with a research librarian. Reviewer one and reviewer two (ØK) added additional studies from the insulin and cancer literature search, and studies were added from other meta-analyses and reviews by reviewer one. Reviewer one and reviewer two examined all studies by screening title and abstract. Studies passing this round were retrieved in full text and independently assessed for eligibility by reviewer one and two. Records for which both reviewers agreed on were included in the systematic review and meta-analysis. Disagreement were settled by discussion or if necessary by reviewer three (PV). No supplementary data were collected from the authors of the studies.

Data Items
----------

From each study information was extracted on cancer risk (prevalence ratio, risk ratio, odds ratio, incidence ratio, standardized incidence ratio, hazard ratio), cancer site, patient characteristics including type of diabetes mellitus (type 1, type 2 or unspecified), age (mean/median/not reported), duration of diabetes (mean/median/not reported), HbA1c level (mean/median/not reported), BMI (mean/median/not reported), follow up years (mean/median/not reported), and on study design (case control/cohort/cross-sectional), population (population based/hospital based), confounders used to adjust for, and specific comorbidities. Data was extracted by reviewer one and validated by reviewer two. Any disagreement was solved by discussion. Studies that used the same study population as other studies were excluded by reviewer one and reviewer two to secure that no duplicate estimates were used in the meta-analysis.

Risk of Bias in Individual Studies
----------------------------------

The risk of bias in individual studies was assessed using the Newcastle Ottawa Scale (NOS) \[[@r32]\]. The user-defined items required in the NOS score were defined as follows: age was the most important adjustment factor; the exposed patients in cohorts should be representative of the average "diabetic population", minimum follow up time as 5 years, and loss to follow-up less than 10%. A scale modified for cross-sectional studies were produced for the quality score of these studies (the NOS are available in the Supplementary Material 1).

Reviewer one and reviewer two scored the studies based on the NOS. If the reviewers scored differently it was solved by discussion and if this was not possible reviewer three decided the score.

Summary Measures and Synthesis of Results
-----------------------------------------

Prevalence ratios, risk ratios (RR), odds ratios, incidence ratios, standardized incidence ratios (in general standardized by age and sex using a reference population from same cancer registry, same district or the entire population of a country) and hazard ratios including 95% CI comparing the risk of cancer in diabetes patients compared to a non-diabetes group were the summary measures. A random effects model, Der Simonian and Laird, was used in all analyses \[[@r33]\]. The random effects model considers both in study and between study variability. As all the measures are common effect estimates the pooled result can be interpreted as a risk ratio. Only estimates based on two or more populations were included in the meta-analysis. χ^2^ tests were used to test for heterogeneity across studies. All analyses were performed in STATA 8 (StataCorp. 2003. *Stata Statistical Software: Release 8*. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP).

Risk of Bias Across Studies
---------------------------

Risk of publication bias across studies was assessed using Egger's regression analysis \[[@r34]\] in STATA 8.

Additional Analyses
-------------------

Subgroup analyses were performed for cancer sites, study design and gender. Meta-regression analyses were performed to assess whether any of the extracted characteristics were determinants of cancer risk. For the meta-regression the covariates were coded as follows: gender (0 = female, 1 = male), diabetes type (0 = unspecified, 1 = T1D, 2 = T2D), study design (0= case control, 1 = cohort, 2 = cross-sectional), source (1=population, 2=hospital, 3=other), adjustment factor (0= no age adjustment, 1= age + other, 2= BMI / obesity / waist hip ratio + other, 3 = Age, BMI +other, 4= Age, Sex, BMI, Smoking + other) 5= Age, BMI and duration of diabetes), diabetes ascertainment (1 = registry, 2 = questionnaire / interview, 3 = biochemical analysis or criteria, 4 = other), cancer ascertainment (1 = registry with confirmation, 2 = questionnaire / interview, 3 = pathology / histology/ imaging / criteria, 4=other) and NOS (0-9). Other covers mixed ascertainments and other types of ascertainment. Age (years) was calculated as the difference of the age between cases and controls in case control studies and between diabetes cohort and non-diabetes cohort in cohort studies. The same applied for BMI (kg/m^2^). Sub analysis for age and BMI were performed by study design. For age, BMI and follow up years only mean or median estimates were used in the meta-regression. Age BMI and follow up years where treated as numerical outcomes in the meta-regression, whereas other variables were treated as categorical outcomes. Only analyses with the use of three or more populations were included in the meta-regression. HbA1c and duration of diabetes were extracted from the records, but too few values (two studies report on mean HbA1c and 4 studies report mean duration of diabetes) were available to perform a meaningful analysis.

Results
=======

Study Selection
---------------

The selection process is depicted in [Fig. (**1**)](#F1){ref-type="fig"}. 1,849 records were identified from the database search. An additional 172 records were identified from the reference list in meta-analyses and reviews identified in the search, and from the systematic literature search (PROSPERO registration number: CRD42012002428) on insulin and cancer also performed by the CARING group. In total 2,021 records were identified. The RefWorks (RefWorks, RefWorks-COS, ProQuest RefWorks 2.0, 2010) functions exact duplicates and close duplicates were used to remove duplicates. In total 1,785 unique records were retrieved. Screening by title and abstract by reviewer one and two excluded 1,534 records, thus 251 records remained. Of these records, 193 records (106 cohort studies, 80 case-control studies, 6 cross-sectional studies and 1 combined case-control and cross-sectional study \[[@r35]\]) were included in the systematic review, while 66 records were excluded after assessing for full text eligibility (21 were excluded due to duplicate data with other studies, 3 were excluded due to lack of data, 11 were excluded because diabetes was not the exposure, 4 were excluded because they did not compare to a non-diabetes reference, 1 record was excluded due to interventional study design and 16 studies were excluded because the outcome was not incident or prevalent cancer). 190 records were included in the meta-analysis. Two studies were excluded from this analysis due to lack of information on the outcome to an extent that made analysis impossible \[[@r36], [@r37]\]. One study was the only to report on head and neck cancer \[[@r38]\] and was not included in the meta-analysis.

Study Characteristics and Risk of Bias within Studies
-----------------------------------------------------

Tables **[1](#T1){ref-type="table"}-[3](#T3){ref-type="table"}** present the study characteristics and NOS score of the included studies in the systematic review for cohort and cross-sectional studies and case-control studies, respectively. Additional study information is available in the electronic Supplementary Material 2. The study quality ranged from as low as 3 to the highest score of 9, although most of studies (84%) were of fair quality (NOS 6-9). NOS is part of the meta-regression presented below.

Results of Individual Studies
-----------------------------

The results of the individual studies are presented in the electronic Supplementary Material 3. Stott-Miller *et al.* \[[@r38]\] was the only study specifically addressing head and neck cancer, and they presented an odds ratio of 1.09 (0.95-1.24) for head and neck cancer for diabetes patients compared to a non-diabetes reference. Thus it was not used in the included in the meta-analysis.

Synthesis of Results
--------------------

Table **[4](#T4){ref-type="table"}** presents the pooled analysis of the studies and the pooled results are depicted in [Fig. (**2**)](#F2){ref-type="fig"}. All available cancer types were included. Diabetes patients have a significant increased risk of any cancer, biliary and gallbladder cancer, bladder cancer, bone cancer, breast cancer, colon cancer, colorectal cancer, rectal cancer, esophagus cancer, liver cancer, lung cancer, leukemia, lymphoma, non-Hodgkin lymphoma, pancreas cancer, kidney cancer, small intestine cancer, stomach cancer and thyroid cancer. Female diabetes patients were also at increased risk for breast, cervix, endometrial and ovary

cancer. However; diabetes patients have a lower risk of prostate cancer and skin cancer than non-diabetic subjects. In these analyses, only bone and thyroid cancer did not display significant heterogeneity by chi square testing. For the remaining cancer types (testes cancer, myeloma, melanoma, lung, larynx, bone cancer and nervous system cancers) no significantly in- or decreased association between diabetes patients and non-diabetes was observed.

Subgroup analyses were performed on study design (cohort/case control) and gender (male/female). [Figs. (**3**](#F3){ref-type="fig"}**-**[**6**](#F6){ref-type="fig"}) illustrates the results of the analyses. Cohort studies found among diabetes patients an increased risk of any, biliary, breast, cervix, colon, colorectal, endometrial, kidney, liver, ovary, pancreas, rectum, small intestine, stomach, and thyroid cancer, as well as leukemia, all lymphomas, and non-Hodgkin lymphoma, while the risks of prostate, and skin cancer were decreased. Case control studies show similar results as cohort studies including an increased risk of larynx cancer; however the pooled estimates for cervix-, kidney-, leukemia-, non Hodgkin lymphoma-, prostate-, stomach-, and thyroid cancer were without significance. Males with diabetes were at an increased risk of all cancers combined, biliary, colon, colorectal, kidney, liver, pancreas, rectum, small intestine, and thyroid cancer and leukemia, while the risk of prostate cancer was decreased. Females with diabetes were at an increased risk of any, breast, cervix, colon, colorectal, endometrial, kidney, leukemia, liver, ovary, and pancreas cancer.

Risk of Bias Across Studies
---------------------------

Egger's regression test revealed significant publication bias for any cancer (p=0.048), colorectal cancer (p=0.024), esophagus cancer (p=0.022), larynx cancer (p=0.041), lymphoma (p=0.041) and lung cancer (p=0.015). The graphical depictions of the bias test for these cancer types are available in the electronic Supplementary Material 5. All these publication biases have a positive intercept value indicating higher effect size in smaller studies. None of the other cancer types displayed publication bias.

Meta-Regression
---------------

Table **[5](#T5){ref-type="table"}** present results from the meta-analysis. These results reflect the effect modification of the variables on the measured cancer risk in the studies. A positive determinant increases the risk ratio for cancer among diabetes patients, whereas a negative determinant decreases the risk ratio for cancer among diabetes patients. The coefficient is the beta-coefficient from the regression. Not all variables were available for all of the specific cancer analyses. In the following only specific parts will be highlighted. Male gender was a significant negative determinant of the risk of leukemia in (β = -1.52) and reduces the risk of leukemia among diabetes patients. Age difference may both be a significantly positive, negative and no determinant depending on cancer type. BMI differences was no determinant of breast-, colorectal-, endometrial-, kidney-, liver-, pancreas-, and prostate-cancer risk, however it was a negative determinant (β = -0.08) for lung cancer. Diabetes type was only a significantly negative determinant in colon

Age and BMI are provided by means if nothing else is specified. Follow up years are provided by means, medians or follow up period. \*Comobidity in the population examined. Body mass index (BMI), diabetes mellitus (DM), digital rectal examination (DRE), general practicioner (GP), hepatitis C virus (HCV),. Total: For the whole group or the complete study period.

Age and BMI are provided by means if nothing else is specified. Follow up years are provided by means, medians or follow up period. \*Comobidity in the population examined. Body mass index (BMI), diabetes mellitus (DM), digital rectal examination (DRE), general practicioner (GP), Total: For the whole group or the complete study period.

Age and BMI are provided by means if nothing else is specified. Follow up years are provided by means, medians or follow up period. \*Comobidity in the population examined. Body mass index (BMI), diabetes mellitus (DM), digital rectal examination (DRE), general practicioner (GP), hepatitis C virus (HCV),. Total: For the whole group or the complete study period.

Non Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL), Nervous system (Brain), RR (risk ratio)

Non Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL), Nervous system (Brain), RR (Risk ratio)

Non Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL), RR (Risk ratio)

Non Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL), RR (Risk ratio)

Non Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL), Nervous system (Brain), RR (Risk ratio)

Discussion
==========

Summary of Evidence
-------------------

This systematic review and meta-analysis confirms the previous findings of an increased cancer risk among diabetes patients. The addition of several databases to the literature search compared to previous meta-analyses did not change the associations previously found. Diabetes patients were especially susceptible to liver cancer (RR= 2.13; 95% CI 1.81-2.50), pancreas cancer (RR= 2.21; 95%CI 1.93-2.54), and endometrial cancer (RR= 1.81; 95% CI 1.63-2.01). In addition, new cancer sites have been investigated: risks of cervix (RR=1.34; 95% CI 1.10-1.63)), ovary cancer (RR= 1.20; 95% CI 1.03-1.40), and small intestinal cancer was reported (RR=1.47; 95% CI 1.03-2.11) were also slightly increased in diabetes patients. In addition female diabetes patients were at increased risk of breast (RR= 1.13 95% CI 1.07-1.18). Thus females with diabetes were at increased risk of gender specific and hormone related cancers compared to their non-diabetic counterparts. However, male diabetes patients seem to be have a reduced risk of prostate cancer (RR= 0.85; 95% CI 0.80-0.91), which support the previous findings \[[@r9],[@r10]\]. Furthermore, our findings support an increased risk of gastric and stomach cancer (RR=1.13; 95% CI 1.02-1.24), whereas former reports have been conflicting \[[@r15],[@r16]\]. An elevation in thyroid cancer (RR=1.27; 95% CI 1.12-1.43) was also present among diabetes patients. A single study reported on head and neck cancer, which found that cancer risk, was not significantly increased among diabetes patients \[[@r38]\].

Neither study design nor gender appears to modulate the overall increase in cancer risk among diabetes patients. Duration of diabetes was not available for analyses, which may influence results. The increased risk of pancreas cancer in diabetes may be due to cancer diagnosis in the following years after diabetes diagnosis, where the risk especially was increased \[[@r207]\]. Normalization of the cancer risk occurs10 years after diabetes diagnosis \[[@r207]\], and may be a result of detection bias or indicate that diabetes diagnosis was a symptom of pancreatic cancer. Johnson *et al.* \[[@r131]\] investigated time dependent factors in cancer risk and diabetes and conclude that the increased cancer risk may be due to increased ascertainment after diabetes diagnosis.

Obesity may be a confounder when assessing cancer risk in diabetes patients \[[@r30]\]. This was not supported by the meta-regression conducted. BMI was a negative determinant for risk of lung cancer, while no other cancer risk was determined by BMI; hence effect modification was only apparent when looking at lung cancer. When looking at the adjustment performed by the studies in the meta-analysis; adjustment by BMI and age were positive determinants of cancer risk in comparison to adjustment for age alone. These results indicate that obesity among diabetes patients was not an effect modifier on the risk of cancer in diabetes, and obesity may not be the explanation for the increased cancer risk for the types rectum, thyroid, biliary tract and gallbladder, ovary, non-Hodgkin lymphoma, myeloma and cervix cancer (adjustment by BMI and age was a positive determinant for these cancer types). Unsurprisingly, age differences may also affect the outcome (Table **[5](#T5){ref-type="table"}**). The limited analyses on follow up time were inconclusive. Male gender was a significantly negative determinant of risk of leukemia, which was in accordance with the fact that risk of leukemia was increased in female diabetes patients (RR= 1.45, 95% CI 1.06-1.99) and only slightly increased in male diabetes patients (RR= 1.12, 95% CI 1.00-1.26).

From the present literature, it was impossible to distinguish the cancer risk between T1D and T2D. Only a single study report of T1D \[[@r39]\], whereas some studies report of T2D. Some of the studies classified as diabetes unspecified in Table **[1](#T1){ref-type="table"}-[3](#T3){ref-type="table"}** claim to report only of T2D, however exclude T1D by age at diagnosis: excluding diabetes diagnosed at younger age than 18 \[[@r45]\], 20 \[[@r97]\], 21 \[[@r56]\], 25 \[[@r65]\] or 30 \[[@r68],[@r71],[@r115],[@r139]\]. Nevertheless, the investigated population may consist of both T1D and T2D.

Diabetes ascertainment and cancer ascertainment (available in the electronic Supplementary Material 2) varied between studies and may, based on the meta-regression, be a determinant of the study outcome. Whether the study was hospital or population based may also affect the outcome (Table **[5](#T5){ref-type="table"}**). These methodological differences, which may bias the results, raise the question of the necessity of uniform standards to reduce bias. In general the study quality did not determine the outcome of the pooled analysis (Table **[5](#T5){ref-type="table"}**), however study quality based on NOS score was a significantly negative determinant risk of lung cancer and a significantly positive determinant of prostate cancer; meaning that the risk ratios drew closer towards 1 for both cancers. Adjustment for the NOS score only changed the outcome little. Some publication bias was present, with an underreporting of non-significant results from small studies. This may also affect the outcomes. Also only published data as age and BMI were collected, whereas not all studies reported these factors. This may affect the results of the meta-regression. These restrictions and limitations may affect the results, but it is implausible to be the explanation of the increased risk of cancer among diabetes patients.

Conclusion
==========

The present systematic review and meta-analysis confirms the previous findings of an increased cancer risk in diabetes and extends these findings to additional cancer types. The results indicate that the risk was not modified by obesity and was thus either due to diabetes per se or other confounders. Unfortunately, important covariates as HbA1c and duration of diabetes were not available in a sufficient number of studies. It is thus difficult to determine whether the increased cancer risk was due to diabetes per se or other prognostic factors like anti-diabetic treatment.

Nevertheless, the clinical implications of this and previous studies are of importance. It is recommendable that physicians in contact with patients with diabetes are attentive to the increased cancer risk associated with diabetes. Whether the awareness should be aimed at a diabetes group receiving a specific treatment is unknown and the future results of the CARING project are awaited.

Patient consent
===============

Declared none.

The research leading to the results of this study has received funding from the European Community's Seventh Framework Programme (FP-7) under grant agreement number 282526, the CARING project. The funding source had no role in study design, data collection, data analysis, data interpretation or writing of the report. Research librarian Ms. Edith Clausen is acknowledged for great help during the searches. Without her help, the work would not have been possible.

SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL
======================

###### 

Supplementary material is available on the publisher's web site along with the published article.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST
====================

Frank de Vries and Anthonius de Boer are employed by Utrecht University and are conducting research under the umbrella of the Centre for Research Methods. This Centre has received unrestricted funding from the Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development (ZonMW), the Dutch Health Care Insurance Board (CVZ), the Royal Dutch Pharmacists Association (KNMP), the private-public funded Top Institute Pharma ([www.tipharma.nl](http://www.tipharma.nl), includes co-funding from universities, government, and industry), the EU Innovative Medicines Initiative (IMI), the EU 7th Framework Program (FP7), the Dutch Ministry of Health and industry (including GlaxoSmithKline, Pfizer, and others). ML De Bruin is employed by Utrecht University and is conducting research under the umbrella of the WHO Collaborating Centre for pharmaceutical policy and regulation. This Centre receives no direct funding or donations from private parties, including pharma industry. Research funding from public-private partnerships, e.g. IMI, TI Pharma ([www.tipharma.nl](http://www.tipharma.nl)) is accepted under the condition that no company-specific product or company related study is conducted. The Centre has received unrestricted research funding from public sources, e.g. Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development (ZonMW), the Dutch Health Care Insurance Board (CVZ), EU 7th Framework Program (FP7), Dutch Medicines Evaluation Board (MEB), and Dutch Ministry of Health. None of the abovementioned companies was involved in the preparation of this manuscript. Other authors had no conflicts of interest

![PRISMA flow diagram.](CDS-8-296_F1){#F1}

![Plot of the pooled analysis of all populations of the risk of cancer among diabetes patients compared to a non-diabetes population.](CDS-8-296_F2){#F2}

![Plot of the pooled analysis of all cohort populations of the risk of cancer among diabetes patients compared to a non-diabetes population.](CDS-8-296_F3){#F3}

![Plot of the pooled analysis of all case control populations of the risk of cancer among diabetes patients compared to a non-diabetes population.](CDS-8-296_F4){#F4}

![Plot of the pooled analysis of all populations only consisting of males of the risk of cancer among diabetes patients compared to a non-diabetes population.](CDS-8-296_F5){#F5}

![Plot of the pooled analysis of all populations only consisting of females of the risk of cancer among diabetes patients compared to a non-diabetes population.](CDS-8-296_F6){#F6}

###### 

Study Table of Included Cohort Studies Divided by Diabetes Type

  --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  **Authors**                                    **Data Source**                                      **Cancer Site**                **Follow Up Years**   **Source**                                                                                                             **DM (n)**                    **Age**       **BMI**       **Non- DM (n)**                   **Age**                     **BMI**       **Co Morbidity**                                             **NOS-Score (0-9)**
  ---------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------ --------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------- ------------- ------------- --------------------------------- --------------------------- ------------- ------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------
  Type 1 diabetes                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    

  Zendehdel 2003 Sweden \[[@r39]\]               Swedish inpatient registry                           Several                        14.4                  Population                                                                                                             29,187                        17.1          \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           8

  Type 2 diabetes                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    

  Kao 2012 Taiwan \[[@r40]\]                     NHIRD                                                All                            2001-2009             Population                                                                                                             22,910                        56.5          \-            91,636                            56.5                        \-            \-                                                           8

  Bowker 2011 Canada \[[@r41]\]                  BCLHD (1996-2006)                                    Breast                         4.4                   Population                                                                                                             84,506                        61.8          \-            84,506                            61.8                        \-            \-                                                           6

  Michels 2003 US \[[@r42]\]                     Nurses health study (1976-1998)                      Breast                         22 (total)            Nurses                                                                                                                 6,120                         59.1          30.7          110,368                           52.1                        25.0                                                                       6

  Campbell 2010 \[[@r43]\]                       Cancer prevention study II Nutrition cohort          Colorectal                     1992-2007             Population                                                                                                             11,335                        63            \-            143,640                           64                          \-            \-                                                           7

  Ren 2009 China \[[@r44]\]                      Nan-Hu district                                      Colorectal                     \-                    Population                                                                                                             7,938                         61.1          23.6          External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Lai 2006 Taiwan \[[@r45]\]                     KCIS (1999-2003)                                     Liver                          2.78                  Population                                                                                                             5,732                         \-            \-            49,184                            \-                          \-            \-                                                           5

  Wang 2009 Taiwan \[[@r46]\]                    A-Lein Township                                      Liver                          8 (total)             Viral hepatitis screened.                                                                                              352                           \-            \-            5,377                             53.9 (total)                \-            \-                                                           9

  Joh 2011 US \[[@r47]\]                         Nurses Health study                                  Kidney                         1976-2008             Nurses                                                                                                                 6,424                         57,0          30,5          107,714                           56.8                        25,5                                                                       6

  Hemminiki 2010 Sweden \[[@r48]\]               Nationwide hospital discharge 1964-2007              Several                        13 median             Population                                                                                                             125,126                       \-            \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           9

  Hense 2011 Germany \[[@r49]\]                  SHI 2003-2008                                        Several                        3.5 median            Disease management programme                                                                                           26,742                        64            ♂ 29.7\       External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ♀ 31.0                                                                                                                                                 

  Lee 2012 Taiwan \[[@r50]\]                     NHI programme (1999-2009)                            Several                        11 (total)            Population                                                                                                             104,343                       \-            \-            985,815 (Total)                   \-                          \-            \-                                                           9

  Ogunleye 2009 UK \[[@r51]\]                    Tayside                                              Several                        3.9                   Population\                                                                                                            9,577                         \-            \-            19,154                            62 (total)                  \-            \-                                                           6
                                                                                                                                                           (RISCH primary care)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      

  Diabetes type unspecified                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          

  Fillenbaum 2000 US \[[@r52]\]                  EPESE                                                Any                            6 (total)             Population                                                                                                                                                                       4034 total                        73.4                                                                                                   5

  Larsson 2008 Sweden \[[@r53]\]                 COSM                                                 Bladder                        9.3                   Population                                                                                                             2,835                         64.5          27.4          43,071                            60.1                        25.7          \-                                                           8

  Tripathi 2002 US \[[@r54]\]                    IWHS                                                 Bladder                        13 (total)            Population                                                                                                             6%                            \-            \-            37,459 (total)                    \-                          \-            \-                                                           7

  Bosco 2012 US \[[@r55]\]                       Black women's health study                           Breast                         10.5                  Population                                                                                                             1,900                                                     49,172 (total)                                                                                                                           6

  Chlebowski 2012 US \[[@r56]\]                  WHI                                                  Breast                         11.8                  Postmenopausal\                                                                                                        3,401                         62.6          \-            64,618                            64.0                        \-            \-                                                           7
                                                                                                                                                           Population based sample                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   

  De Waard 1974 (36)                             GP Netherlands                                       Breast                         5,4                   Population                                                                                                                                                                       7,259 women                                                                                                                              4

  Goodman 1997 Japan \[[@r57]\]                  LSS Cohort                                           Breast                         8.31                  Population (atomic bomb survivors)                                                                                     \-                            \-            \-            22,200 (total)                    \-                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Lipscombe 2006 \[[@r58]\] Canada               Ontario 1995-2002                                    Breast                         4.5 median            Population                                                                                                             73,796                        66.2          \-            391,714                           64.9                        \-            \-                                                           7

  Mink 2002 US \[[@r59]\]                        ARIC                                                 Breast                         7.1                   Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            7,894 (total)                     \-                          \-            \-                                                           8

  Reeves 2012 US \[[@r60]\]                      SOF                                                  Breast                         14,4                  Population                                                                                                             607                                                       7,772                                                                                                                                    7

  Sellers 1994 US \[[@r61]\]                     IWHS                                                 Breast                         5 (total)             Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            36,603(total)                     \-                          \-            \-                                                           5

  Weiderpass 1997 Sweden \[[@r62]\]              Swedish in patient registry                          Breast, endometrial            6.7                   Population                                                                                                             ♂ 63,988\                     ♂ 59.2\       \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ♀ 70,110                      ♀ 64.2                                                                                                                                                               

  Lambe 2011 Sweden \[[@r63]\]                   AMORIS                                               Breast, endometrial, ovarian   11.7                  Population                                                                                                             5,615                         58.5          26.7          225,122                           46.6                        23.9          \-                                                           7

  Bowers 2006 Finland \[[@r64]\]                 Alpha-Tocopherol, Beta-Carotene Cancer Prevention\   Colorectal                     14.1 median           Population                                                                                                             1,226                         \-            \-            27,757                            \-                          \-            \-                                                           7
                                                 Study                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               

  Flood 2010 UK \[[@r65]\]                       BCDDP                                                Colorectal                     8.4                   Individuals with breast affection and matched healthy individuals (gives no statement on how these were determined).   \-                            64.3          28.0          43,078                            61.8                        24.5          \-                                                           6

  Hartz 2012 US \[[@r66]\]                       WHI                                                  Colorectal                     8 median              Postmenopausal\                                                                                                        4.5% of total                 \-            \-            150,912\                          63.11\                      \-            \-                                                           7
                                                                                                                                                           Population based sample                                                                                                                                                          (total)                           (Total)                                                                                                

  He 2010 US \[[@r67]\]                          Multiethnic cohort                                   Colorectal                     1993-2006             Population                                                                                                             ♂15,060\                      \-            \-            ♂74,418\                          ♂60.2\                      \-            \-                                                           7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ♀ 16,271                                                  ♀93,393                           ♀ 59.7                                                                                                 

  Hu 1999 US \[[@r68]\]                          NHS                                                  Colorectal                     18 (total)            Nurses                                                                                                                 7,069                         45            28            111,003                           42                          24            \-                                                           5

  Khaw 2004 UK \[[@r69]\]                        Norfolk                                              Colorectal                     6                     Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            25,623 (total)                    45-79                       \-            \-                                                           7

  Larsson 2005 \[[@r70]\] Sweden                 COSM                                                 Colorectal                     6.2                   Population                                                                                                                                                                       45,550 men (total)                                                                                                                       6

  Limburg 2005 US \[[@r71]\]                     IWHS                                                 Colorectal                     14 (total)            Population                                                                                                             1,900                         62.3          30.6          33,072                            61.5                        26.8          \-                                                           7

  Nilsen 2001, Norway \[[@r72]\]                 Nord-trøndelag                                       Colorectal                     10.8 median           Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            75,219 (total)                    ♂48.5\                      \-            \-                                                           7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ♀49.8                                                                                                  

  Schoen 1999 US \[[@r73]\]                      CHS 1989-1990                                        Colorectal                     6.6                   Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            5,201                             72.8\                       \-            \-                                                           6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              (without cancer)                                                                                       

  Seow 2006 Singapore \[[@r74]\]                 Singapore Chinese health study                       Colorectal                     7.1                   Population                                                                                                             5,469                         60            24.1          55,851                            56.0                        23            \-                                                           7

  Sturmer 2006 US \[[@r75]\]                     The Physicians' Health Study                         Colorectal                     19 median             physicians                                                                                                             9%                            \-            \-            22,701                            54                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Will 1998 US \[[@r76]\]                        Cancer prevention study                              Colorectal                     1959-1972             25 states                                                                                                              15,487                        ♂57.4\        ♂25.4\        850,946                           ♂52.9\                      ♂25.2\        \-                                                           6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ♀57.8         ♀26.2                                           ♀51.7                       ♀24.2                                                                      

  Anderson 2001 US \[[@r77]\]                    IWHS                                                 Endometrial                    1986-1997             Population                                                                                                             1,325                         62.6          30.5          23,150                            61.8                        26.8          \-                                                           7

  Friberg 2007 Sweden \[[@r78]\]                 Uppsala                                              Endometrial                    7                     Population                                                                                                             1,628                         66.5          27.5          35,145                            61.7                        24.9          \-                                                           8

  Lindemann 2008 Norway \[[@r79]\]               HUNT study                                           Endometrial                    15.7                  Population                                                                                                             1,010                         \-            \-            35,751                            49 (total)                  \-            \-                                                           7

  Lin 2011 US \[[@r80]\]                         NIH-AARP study                                       Esophagus, gastric             7.96                  Population                                                                                                             41,388                        62.81         29.83         428,060                           61.90                       26.83         \-                                                           8

  Chuma 2008 Japan \[[@r81]\]                    Hokkaido University hospital                         Liver                          10.2                  Hospital                                                                                                               19                                                        104 (total)                       50.5 (median)                             Chronic hepatitis or cirrhosis. Hepatitis C virus positive   7

  Di constanzo 2008 Italy \[[@r82]\]             Naples (1994-2004)                                   Liver                          7 median              Hospital                                                                                                               41                            \-            \-            138 (total)                       63.3                        \-            Hepatitis C virus cirrhosis                                  4

  El-Serag 2004 US \[[@r83]\]                    PTF 1985-1990                                        Liver                          8.6                   Hospital (Veteran Affairs (VA))                                                                                        173,643                       61.7          \-            650,620                           54.5                        \-            \-                                                           6

  Hung 2011 Taiwan \[[@r84]\]                    Chang Gung Memorial Hospital                         Liver                          4.4                   Hospital                                                                                                               253 (T2D)                     56 median     25 median     1,217                             52 median                   24 median     Inteferon therapy for hepatitis c                            7

  Ionnau 2007 US \[[@r85]\]                      VA 1994-2005                                         Liver                          3.6                   Veterans                                                                                                               452                           \-            \-            1,668                             \-                          \-            Cirrhosis                                                    6

  Kavamura 2010 Japan \[[@r86]\]                 Toronamon hospital, Tokyo                            Liver                          6.7 median            Hospital                                                                                                               104                           \-            \-            1,954                             50 (total)                  \-            Inteferon therapy for hepatitis c                            7

  N'kontchou2006 France \[[@r87]\]               \-                                                   Liver                          4.2                   Screened for HCC                                                                                                       231                           \-            \-            540                               61.4 total                  25.4 total    alcoholic or viral C cirrhosis                               6

  Ohata 2003 Japan \[[@r88]\]                    Nagasaki university hospital                         Liver                          6.4                   Hospital                                                                                                               26                            \-            \-            161 (total)                       53                          22.7\         Chronic HCV infection                                        7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          0.24                                                                       

  Ohki 2008 Japan \[[@r89]\]                     University of Tokyo Hospital 1994-2004               Liver                          6.1                   Hospital                                                                                                               \-                            \-            \-            1,431                             60.1                        \-            Chronic HCV infection                                        7

  Tazawa 2002 Japan \[[@r90]\]                   Tsuchiura Kyodo General Hospital                     Liver                          5.4                   Hospital                                                                                                               23                            \-            \-            279 (all)                         49.4                        \-            Hepatitis C infection                                        5

  Veldt 2008 Europe and Canada \[[@r91]\]        Hepatology Units                                     Liver                          4.0                   Hospital                                                                                                               85                            51 (median)   27 (median)   456                               49 median                   25 (median)   Hepatitis C and fibrosis or cirrhosis                        6

  Adami 1996 Sweden \[[@r92]\]                   Swedish in patient register                          Liver and biliary tract        6.7                   Hospital                                                                                                               153,852                       ♂60.5\        \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ♀65.2                                                                                                                                                                

  Chen 2010 Taiwan \[[@r93]\]                    NHI                                                  Liver and biliary tract        6.9 median            Population                                                                                                             615,532                       60.1          \-            614,871                           60.0                        \-            \-                                                           9

  Ehrlich 2010 US \[[@r94]\]                     Kaiser Permanente\                                   Lung                           1996- 2005            Medical Care Program                                                                                                   70,645                        60 median     29.80         51,241                            51 median                   26.06         \-                                                           7
                                                 Medical Care Program Northern California                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            

  Hall 2005 UK \[[@r95]\]                        GPRD                                                 Lung                           3.95                  Population (primary care)                                                                                              66,848                        60.8          \-            267,272                           60.7                        \-            \-                                                           8

  Lai 2012 Taiwan \[[@r96]\]                     NHI Taiwan 1 million random sample cohort            Lung                           2000-2008             Population                                                                                                             19624                         56.4                        78,496                            56.5                                                                                                   8

  Luo 2012 US \[[@r97]\]                         WHI                                                  Lung                           11                    Postmenopausal\                                                                                                        8,154                         64.3          32.1          137,611                           63.0                        27.7          \-                                                           7
                                                                                                                                                           Population                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                

  Cerhan 1997 US \[[@r98]\]                      IWHS                                                 NHL                            1986-1992             Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            37, 934 (total)                   61.5 (total)                \-            \-                                                           6

  Erber 2009 US \[[@r99]\]                       Multiethnic cohort (MEC) study                       NHL                            10 median             Population                                                                                                             13%                           \-            \-            ♂87,078\                          \-                          \-            \-                                                           6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ♀105,972\                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            (total)                                                                                                                                  

  Khan 2008 Europe \[[@r100]\]                   EPIC                                                 NHL and multiple myeloma       8.5                   Population                                                                                                             ♂5,111\                       ♂58%\         \-            ♂134,320\                         ♂51.9%\                     \-            \-                                                           7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ♀6,028                        ♀56.8%                      ♀248,018                          ♀50.1%                                                                                                 

  Gapstur 2012 US \[[@r101]\]                    Cancer Prevention\                                   Ovary                          1992-2007             Population                                                                                                             3,577                         63.6          \-            59,863                            62.2                        \-            \-                                                           7
                                                 Study-II Nutrition Cohort                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

  Chen 2011 Taiwan \[[@r102]\]                   NHI                                                  Pancreas                       6.9 median            Population                                                                                                             615,532                       60.1          \-            614,871                           60.0                        \-            \-                                                           9

  Chow 1995 Sweden \[[@r103]\]                   Swedish in patient register                          Pancreas                       6.8                   Hospital                                                                                                               ♂63,987\                      \-            \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ♀70,109                                                                                                                                                                                            

  Gupta 2006 US \[[@r104]\]                      Veterans Health Administration                       Pancreas                       1999-2004             Veterans (developed diabetes)                                                                                          36,631                        61.8          \-            1,385,163                         63.6                        \-            \-                                                           7

  Larsson 2005 Sweden \[[@r105]\]                COSM and SMC                                         Pancreas                       1997-2004             Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            ♀37,147\                          ♀62\                        ♀25 ♂25.8\    \-                                                           8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ♂ 45,906\                         ♂ 60\                       (total)                                                                    
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            (total)                           (total)                                                                                                

  Liao 2012 Taiwan \[[@r106]\]                   NHI                                                  Pancreas                       1998-2007             Population                                                                                                             49,803                        55.92         \-            199,212                           55.92                       \-            \-                                                           8

  Shibata 1994 US \[[@r107]\]                    Laguna Hills                                         Pancreas                       9 (total)             Retirement community                                                                                                   \-                            \-            \-            13,976 (total)                    74                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Stevens 2009 UK \[[@r108]\]                    Breast cancer screening                              Pancreas                       7.2                   Population                                                                                                             2,7%                          \-            \-            1,290,000                         55.9                        26.2          \-                                                           7

  Stolzenberg-Solomon 2002 Finland \[[@r109]\]   ATBC                                                 Pancreas                       10.2 median           Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            29,048                            57                          26.0          Smokers                                                      8

  Yun 2006 Korea \[[@r110]\]                     NHIC                                                 Pancreas                       10 (total)            Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            446407                            \-                          \-            \-                                                           8

  Jamal 2009 US \[[@r111]\]                      VA                                                   Pancreas and gallbladder       1990-2000             Hospital                                                                                                               278,761 (diabetes patients)   65.8          \-            836,283 (non diabetes patients)   64.8                        \-            \-                                                           7

  Giovannuci 1998 US \[[@r112]\]                 Health professionals follow up study                 Prostate                       1986-1994             Health professionals                                                                                                   2,551                         \-            \-            45,230                            \-                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Leitzmann 2008 US \[[@r113]\]                  PLCO                                                 Prostate                       8.9 (total)           From a randomized controlled trial, where participants were randomized to cancer screening.                            3,024                         64.0          28.7          30,064                            62.0                        26.8          \-                                                           7

  Li 2010 Japan \[[@r114]\]                      Ohsaki Cohort                                        Prostate                       1995-2003             Population                                                                                                             1,645                         62.41         23.74         20,813                            59.07                       23.32                                                                      7

  Rodriguez 2005 US \[[@r115]\]                  Cancer prevention study II nutrition cohort          Prostate                       1992-2001             Population                                                                                                             10,053                                                    62,617                                                                                                                                   7

  Thompson 1989 US \[[@r116]\]                   Rancho bernardo                                      Prostate                       14 (total)            Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            1,776 (all)                       65.9                        25.62         \-                                                           7

  Velicer 2007 US \[[@r117]\]                    VITAL                                                Prostate                       2000-2004             Population (mailing list)                                                                                              2,878                         64.3          30.5          32,361                            61.5                        27.4          \-                                                           6

  Waters 2009 US \[[@r118]\]                     The Multiethnic Cohort                               Prostate                       1993-2005             Population                                                                                                             10,825                        \-            \-            86,303 total                      59.9                        \-            \-                                                           7

  Weiderpass 2002 Sweden \[[@r119]\]             Swedish In-Patient Register                          Prostate                       5.6                   Population                                                                                                             135,950                       61.7          \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Will 1999 US \[[@r120]\]                       25 states\                                           Prostate                       13 (total)            Population                                                                                                             6,086                         \-            \-            298,979                           \-                          \-            \-                                                           5
                                                 1959-1972                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

  Nicodemus 2004 US \[[@r121]\]                  IWHS 1986-2000                                       Kidney                         15 total              Population (drivers license list)                                                                                      \-                            \-            \-            34,637 (total)                    \-                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Adami 1991 Sweden \[[@r122]\]                  Uppsala In patient registry                          Several                        1965-1984             Hospital                                                                                                               51,008                        \-            \-            Expected                          \-                          \-            \-                                                           5

  Atchison 2010, US \[[@r123]\]                  VA hospitals                                         Several                        10.5 (median)         Veterans (male)                                                                                                        594,815                       57.5          \-            3,906,763                         51.5                        \-            \-                                                           7

  Carstensen 2012 Denmark \[[@r124]\]            Central personal register                            Several                        1995-2009             The entire Danish Population                                                                                           \-                            \-            \-            \-                                \-                          \-            \-                                                           7

  Chodick 2010 Israel \[[@r125]\]                Maccabi\                                             Several                        8                     Population                                                                                                             16,721                        61.6          \-            83,874                            61.6                        \-            \-                                                           8
                                                 Healthcare Services                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 

  Dankner 2007 Israel \[[@r126]\]                Population registry                                  Several                        20 (total)            Population                                                                                                             437                           57.6          \-            1,740                             51.9                        \-            \-                                                           8

  Folsom 2008 \[[@r127]\]                        ARIC 1987-1989                                       Several                        1987-2000             Population                                                                                                             \-                            \-            \-            13,117 (total)                    \-                          \-            \-                                                           8

  Hjalgrim 1997 Denmark \[[@r128]\]              All men born1949-1964 with DM before age 20          Several                        1968-1992             Population                                                                                                             1,659                         \-            \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           3

  Hjalgrim 1997 Denmark \[[@r128]\]              funen county                                         Several                        1973-1992             Population                                                                                                             1,499                         \-            \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           4

  Inoue 2006 Japan \[[@r129]\]                   Japan Public Health Center--Based Prospective\       Several                        10.7                  Population                                                                                                             ♂3,097♀ 1,571                 ♂54\          \-            ♂43,451\                          ♂51.2\                      \-            \-                                                           7
                                                 Study                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          ♀ 56                        ♀ 49,652                          ♀ 51.6                                                                                                 

  Jee 2005 Korea \[[@r130]\]                     NHIC                                                 Several                        10 total              government employees, teachers and dependents (10.7% of total population)                                              ♂5.1%\                        \-            \-            ♂829,770\                         ♂45.3\                      ♂23.2\        \-                                                           7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ♀4.5%                                                     ♀468,615\                         ♀49.6                       ♀23.2                                                                      
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            (total)                                                                                                                                  

  Johnson 2011 \[[@r131]\] Canada                BCLHD                                                Several                        4,3                   Population                                                                                                             185,100                       60.7                        185,100                           60.7                                                                                                   8

  Joshu 2012 US \[[@r132]\]                      ARIC (1990-2006)                                     Several                        15 median             Population                                                                                                             ♀ 626\                        ♀ 58.5\       ♀ 31.5\       11,667                            \-                          \-            \-                                                           6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  ♂ 499                         ♂ 58.8        ♂ 30.0                                                                                                                                                 

  Khan 2006 Japan \[[@r133]\]                    JACC                                                 Several                        1988-1997             Population                                                                                                             3,307                         40-79         \-            53,574                            40-79                       \-            \-                                                           7

  Ragozzino 1982 US \[[@r134]\]                  Rochester, Minnesota                                 Several                        \-                    Population                                                                                                             1,135                         \-            \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           4

  Rapp 2006 Austria \[[@r135]\]                  VHM&PP                                               Several                        8.4                   Population                                                                                                             3.4%                          \-            \-            140,813                           43                          \-            \-                                                           8

  Steenland 1995 US \[[@r136]\]                  NHANES I                                             Several                        7.7                   Civilian population                                                                                                    \-                            \-            \-            14,407                            60 (cases) 48 (non-cases)   \-            \-                                                           7

  Swerdlow 2005 UK \[[@r137]\]                   The diabetes uk cohort                               Several                        1972-2003             Population                                                                                                             29,701                        0-49          \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           6

  Wideroff 1997 \[[@r138]\] Denmark              Danish Central Hospital\                             Several                        1977-1993             Hospital                                                                                                               109, 581                      ♂ 64\         \-            External standard population      \-                          \-            \-                                                           6
                                                 Discharge Register                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ♀69\                                                                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                median                                                                                                                                                               

  Wotton 2011 UK \[[@r139]\]                     ORLS 1                                               Several                        1963-1998             Hospital                                                                                                               15,898                        \-            \-            275,564                           \-                          \-            \-                                                           7

  Wotton 2011 UK \[[@r139]\]                     ORLS 2                                               Several                        1999-2008             Hospital                                                                                                               7,771                         \-            \-            185,123                           \-                          \-            \-                                                           7

  Yeh 2012 US \[[@r140]\]                        CLUE II                                              Several                        1989-2006             Population                                                                                                             599                           61.8          29.5          17,681                            51.5                        26.3          \-                                                           7

  Aschebrook-kilfoy 2011 US \[[@r141]\]          NIH-AARP study                                       Thyroid                        10                    Population                                                                                                             44,693                        62.9          29.9          451,855                           61.9                        26.8          \-                                                           7

  Kitahara 2012 US \[[@r142]\]                   Pooled analysis of 5 cohort studies                  Thyroid                        10.5 median           Previous studies                                                                                                       8%                            \-            \-            674,491 (total)                   59.8                        \-            \-                                                           7

  Meinhold 2010 US \[[@r143]\]                   US Radiologic Technologists\                         Thyroid                        15.8                  Radiologic technologists                                                                                               \-                            \-            \-            ♀69,50\                           ♂43.3 ♀39.3                 \-            \-                                                           6
                                                 Study                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      6\                                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            ♂21,207 (total)                                                                                                                          
  --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

###### 

Study Table of Cross-Sectional Studies by Diabetes Type

  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  **Authors**                     **Data Source**                                                                **Cancer Site**   **Follow Up Years**   **Source**                                                                                                                          **DM (n)**              **Age**                **BMI**                 **Non- DM (n)**              **Age**                 **BMI**            **Co Morbidity**   **NOS-Score (0-9)**
  ------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------- --------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------- ---------------------- ----------------------- ---------------------------- ----------------------- ------------------ ------------------ ---------------------
  Type 2 diabetes                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              

  Baur 2011 Germany \[[@r144]\]   DETECT study                                                                   Any               \-                    Population                                                                                                                          1,308                   70.4(with cancer)\     28.3\                   6,211                        65.5\                   26.7\              \-                 7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     66.6(without cancer)   (with cancer)\                                       (with cancer)\          (with cancer)\                        
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            29.8 (without cancer)                                55.5 (without cancer)   26.6\                                 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         (without cancer)                      

  Diabetes type unspecified                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    

  Lawlor 2004 UK \[[@r145]\]      The British Women's Heart and Health Study                                     Breast            \-                    Randomly from GP                                                                                                                    147 women with cancer   68.5                   28.1                    3,890 women without cancer   68.9                    27.6               \-                 6

  Sandhu 2001 UK \[[@r146]\]      Norfolk                                                                        Colorectal        \-                    Population (GP lists)                                                                                                               561                     45-74                  \-                      28,782                       45-74                   \-                 \-                 6

  Tung 2010 Taiwan \[[@r35]\]     Tainan                                                                         Liver                                   Population                                                                                                                          72                      68.4                   \-                      56,193                       \-                      \-                 \-                 6

  Moreira 2011 US \[[@r147]\]     Durham VA                                                                      Prostate          \-                    Hospital (performed prostate biopsy, high risk patient population (referred for biopsy because of elevated PSA or Abnomral DRE)))   284                     64                     30,4                    714                          63                      27,7               \-                 5

  Moses 2012 US \[[@r148]\]       Hospital\                                                                      Prostate                                Hospital                                                                                                                            1,045                   \-                     \-                      1,265                        \-                      \-                 \-                 5
                                  (high risk population (referred to biopsy for elevated PSA or abnormal DRE))                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 

  Li 2011US \[[@r149]\]           BRFSS                                                                          Several           \-                    Population                                                                                                                          \-                      \-                     \-                      397,783 total                46.8                    \-                 \-                 4
  ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

###### 

Study Table of Case Control Studies by Diabetes Type

  -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  **Authors**                                                          **Data Source**                                             **Cancer Site**                **Source**                                                          **Cases (n)**                        **Age**                          **BMI**               **Controls (n)**     **Age**                               **BMI**                               **Co Morbidity\***                 **NOS-Score (0-9)**
  -------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------ -------------------------------- --------------------- -------------------- ------------------------------------- ------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- ---------------------
  Type 2 diabetes                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     

  Khachatryan 2011 Armenia \[[@r150]\]                                 \-                                                          Breast                         Population                                                          150                                  55.79                            29.03                 152                  51.11                                 27.67                                 \-                                 6

  Rollison 20078US \[[@r151]\]                                         4 corners breast cancer study                               Breast                         Population                                                          2,324                                \-                               \-                    2,523                56                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Li 2012 China \[[@r152]\]                                            \-                                                          Liver                          Hospital                                                            1,105                                53.8                             \-                    5,170                44.9                                  \-                                    Chronic hepatitis B                6

  Diabetes type unspecified                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

  Grainge 2009 UK \[[@r153]\]                                          GPRD 1987-2002                                              Biliary tract                  Population                                                          611                                  71.3\                            \-                    5,760                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 8
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           (at diagnosis)                                                                                                                                                                             

  Khan 1999 US \[[@r154]\]                                             CPMC 1980-1994                                              Biliary tract                  Hospital                                                            69                                   \-                               \-                    138                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Shaib 2007 US \[[@r155]\]                                            M.D.\                                                       Biliary tract                  Hospital                                                            83 ICC\                              ICC 59.8\                        \-                    236                  58.1                                  \-                                    \-                                 5
                                                                       Anderson Cancer Center                                                                                                                                         163 ECC                              ECC 61.1                                                                                                                                                                                   

  Shebl 2010 China                                                     Shanghai, China                                             Biliary tract                  Population                                                          627                                  \-                               \-                    959                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 7

  Tao 2010 China \[[@r156]\]                                           PUMCH                                                       Biliary tract                  Hospital                                                            190(total)\                          58.6 ECC\                                              380                  59.7                                                                                                           5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      61 ICC\                              58.7 ICC                                                                                                                                                                                   
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      129 ECC                                                                                                                                                                                                                         

  Welzel 2007 US \[[@r157]\]                                           SEER                                                        Biliary tract                  Population                                                          ECC 549\                             ECC 78.7\                        \-                    102,782              77.1                                  \-                                    \-                                 7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ICC 535                              ICC 79                                                                                                                                                                                     

  Kantor 1984 US \[[@r158]\]                                           SEER                                                        Bladder                        Population                                                          2,982                                \-                               \-                    5,782                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Kravchick 2001, Israel \[[@r159]\]                                                                                               Bladder                        Hospital                                                            252                                  ♂71.5\                           \-                    549                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 4
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ♀ 73                                                                                                                                                                                       

  Mackenzie 2012 US \[[@r160]\]                                        New England                                                 Bladder                        Population                                                          331                                  62                               28.0                  263                  60                                    27,0                                  \-                                 6

  Ng 2003 UK \[[@r161]\]                                               Bedford General Hospital                                    Bladder                        Hospital                                                            125                                  \-                               \-                    80                   \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 5

  Risch 1988 Canada \[[@r162]\]                                        Edmonton, Calgary, Toronto, and Kingston                    Bladder                        Population                                                          835                                  35-79                            \-                    792                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Baron 2001 US \[[@r163]\]                                            Wisconsin and New Hampshire                                 Breast                         Population                                                          5,659                                65.3                             \-                    5,928                64.1                                  \-                                    \-                                 6

  Beji 2007 Turkey \[[@r164]\]                                                                                                     Breast                         Hospital                                                            405                                  \-                               \-                    1050                 \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 3

  Cleveland 2012 US \[[@r165]\]                                        Long Island Breast Cancer study project                     Breast                         Population                                                          1,495                                63.6                             30.9                  1,543                57.4                                  26.1                                                                     6

  Garmendia 2007 Chile \[[@r166]\]                                                                                                 Breast                         Hospital (mammography service)                                      170                                  56.5                             28.59                 170                  55.18                                 29.23                                 \-                                 5

  Jordan 2009 Thailand \[[@r167]\]                                     Thai Cohort                                                 Breast                         University students                                                 43                                   39 median                        \-                    860                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 4

  Weiss 1999 US \[[@r168]\]                                            New Jersey, Atlanta, Seattle                                Breast                         Population                                                          2,173                                \-                               \-                    1,990                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 5

  Wu 2007 US \[[@r169]\]                                               Los Angeles\                                                Breast                         Population                                                          1,248                                \-                               \-                    1,148                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6
                                                                       County Cancer Surveillance Program                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             

  Kune 1988 Australia \[[@r170]\]                                      Melbourne 1980-1981                                         Colorectal                     Population                                                          715                                  65                               \-                    727                  65                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Le Marchand 1997 US \[[@r171]\]                                                                                                  Colorectal                     Population                                                          1,192                                ♂67 ♀65 (median)                 \-                    1,192                ♂65 ♀65 (median)                      \-                                    \-                                 7

  Rinaldi 2008 European countries \[[@r172]\]                          EPIC (8 countries)                                          Colorectal                     Population                                                          1,026                                59.1 (CC) 58.2 (RC)              27.3 (CC) 27.0 (RC)   1,026                59.1 (Control CC) 58.2 (control RC)   26.9 (Control CC) 26.6 (control RC)                                      8

  Safaee 2009 Iran \[[@r173]\]                                         Shahid Beheshti University of\                              Colorectal                     Population (cases: cancer registry. Controls: health survey)        862                                  \-                               \-                    862                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 4
                                                                       Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 

  Vinikoor 2009 US \[[@r174]\]                                         NCCCS1                                                      Colorectal                     Population                                                          637                                  63.69                                                  1,044                66.06                                                                                                          6

  Vinikoor 2009 US \[[@r174]\]                                         NCCCS2                                                      Colorectal                     Population                                                          1,007                                61.88                                                  988                  63.86                                                                                                          6

  Yang 2005 UK \[[@r175]\]                                             GPRD                                                        Colorectal                     Population                                                          10,447                               \-                               \-                    104,429              \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 8

  Fortuny 2009 US \[[@r176]\]                                          EDGE study                                                  Endometrial                    Population                                                          469                                  61.7                             \-                    467                  63.6 (all)                            \-                                    \-                                 6

  Inoue 1994 Japan \[[@r177]\]                                         Osaka University Medical School                             Endometrial                    Hospital                                                            143                                  53.6                             \-                    143                  53.2                                  \-                                    \-                                 5

  Saltzman 2008 US \[[@r178]\]                                         Washington State                                            Endometrial                    Population                                                          1,303                                                                                       1,779                                                                                                                               7

  Yamazawa 2003 Japan \[[@r179]\]                                      Chiba University\                                           Endometrial                    Hospital                                                            41                                   \-                               \-                    123                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 5
                                                                       Hospital                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

  Neale 2009 Australia \[[@r180]\]                                     Queensland 2001-2005                                        Esophagus                      Population                                                          1,102                                \-                               \-                    1,580                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Reavis 2004 US \[[@r181]\]                                           Portland VA Medical Center                                  Esophagus                      Hospital (and dental clinic)                                        63                                   69.6                             \-                    50 +\                63.7\                                 \-                                    \-                                 5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  50 +\                64.7\                                                                                                          
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  56                   58.9                                                                                                           

  Rubenstein 2005 US \[[@r182]\]                                       Veterans database 1995-2003                                 Esophagus and gastric cardia   Veterans                                                            311                                  71.2 median                      \-                    10,154               66.3 median                           \-                                    GERD                               7

  Vineis 2000 Italy \[[@r183]\]                                        11 Italian areas                                            Haemapoietic                   Population                                                          2,669                                56.1                             \-                    1,718                54.9                                  \-                                    \-                                 6

  Stott-Miller 2012 (38)                                               Pooled analysis                                             Head and neck                  Mixed                                                               6.448                                \-                               \-                    13.747               \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 4

  Davila 2005 US \[[@r184]\]                                           Surveillance Epidemiology and End-Results Program (SEER)    Liver                          Population                                                          2,061                                76.1                             \-                    6,183                76.4                                  \-                                    \-                                 8

  El-Serag 2001 US \[[@r185]\]                                         1997-1999 VA                                                Liver                          Hospital (veterans)                                                 823                                  62                               \-                    3,459                60                                    \-                                    \-                                 4

  Hassan 2002 US \[[@r186]\]                                           MD Anderson Cancer center 1994-1995                         Liver                          Hospital                                                            115                                  59.5                             \-                    230                  59.1                                  \-                                    \-                                 7

  Hassan 2010 US \[[@r187]\]                                           MD Anderson Cancer center 2000-2008                         Liver                          Hospital                                                            420                                  63                               \-                    1,104                60                                    \-                                    \-                                 7

  Matsuo 2003 Japan \[[@r188]\]                                        Kyushu                                                      Liver                          Population                                                          222                                  ♂63.6.\                                                222                  ♂ 63.5.\                                                                                                       6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           ♀ 64.3                                                                      ♀ 64.1                                                                                                         

  Tung 2010 Taiwan \[[@r35]\]                                          Tainan                                                      Liver                          Population                                                          72                                   68.4                             \-                    144                  68.2                                  \-                                    \-                                 7

  Tung 2010 Taiwan \[[@r35]\]                                          Tainan                                                      Liver                          Population                                                          72                                   68.4                             \-                    144                  67.7                                  \-                                    Hepatitis C infection              7

  Yuan 2004 US \[[@r189]\]                                             Los Angeles county 1984-2001                                Liver                          Population                                                          295                                  60.6                             \-                    435                  60.1                                  \-                                    \-                                 5

  Fortuny 2005 Spain \[[@r190]\]                                                                                                   Lymphoma                       Hospital                                                            565                                  \-                               \-                    601                  59 (total)                            \-                                    \-                                 6

  Cartwright 1988 UK \[[@r191]\]                                       1979-1984 Yorkshire                                         NHL                            Hospital                                                            437                                  \-                               \-                    724                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 4

  Cerhan 2005 US \[[@r192]\]                                           Detroit, LA, Seattle 1998-2000                              NHL                            Population                                                          759                                  56.6                             27.7                  589                  56.9                                  27.7                                  \-                                 6

  Lin 2007 Taiwan \[[@r193]\]                                          CGMH                                                        NHL                            Population                                                          242                                  59 median at diagnosis           \-                    71,379               \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Smedby 2006 Denmark, Sweden \[[@r194]\]                              SCALE                                                       NHL                            Population                                                          3,055                                60 median                        \-                    3,187                59 median                             \-                                    \-                                 6

  Bonelli 2003 Italy \[[@r195]\]                                       Northern Italy 1992-1996                                    Pancreas                       Hospital                                                            202                                  \-                               \-                    404                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Bueno de mesquita 1992 Netherlands \[[@r196]\]                       1984-1987                                                   Pancreas                       Population                                                          174                                  35-79                                                  487                  35-79                                                                                                          6

  Cuzick 1989 UK \[[@r197]\]                                           Leeds, London, Oxford (1983-1986)                           Pancreas                       Hospital                                                            216                                  \-                               \-                    279                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 7

  Ekoe 1992 Canada \[[@r198]\]                                         Quebec                                                      Pancreas                       Population                                                          179                                  63,9                                                   239                  62,1                                                                                                           7

  Friedman 1993 US \[[@r199]\]                                         Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program                      Pancreas                       Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program (inpatient and outpatient)   450                                  54.6                             \-                    2,687                54.4                                  \-                                    \-                                 6

  Frye 2000 New Zeeland \[[@r200]\]                                    Canterbury Health case mix database                         Pancreas                       Hospital                                                            116                                  70.1                             \-                    116                  70.2                                  \-                                    Controls: Fracture of femur neck   6

  Grote 2011 \[[@r201]\]                                               EPIC (10 countries)                                         Pancreas                       Population                                                          466                                  58                               26.6                  466                  58                                    25.9                                                                     5

  Gullo 1994 Italy \[[@r202]\]                                         14 Italian university and community hospitals (1987-1989)   pancreas                       Hospital                                                            720                                  62.6                             \-                    720                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Hassan 2007 US \[[@r203]\]                                                                                                       Pancreas                       Hospital                                                            808                                  61.9                             \-                    808                  60.2                                  \-                                    \-                                 7

  Hiatt 1988 US \[[@r204]\]                                            KPMPC (1960-1984)                                           Pancreas                       Member of medical care program                                      49                                   67.6                             \-                    12,104               \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Jain 1991 Canada \[[@r205]\]                                         Toronto 1983-1986                                           Pancreas                       Population                                                          249                                  64.6                             \-                    505                  64.8                                  \-                                    \-                                 6

  Kalapothaki 1993 Greece \[[@r206]\]                                  Athens 1991-1992                                            Pancreas                       Population                                                          181                                  \-                               \-                    181; 818\            \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 5
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  (2 control groups)                                                                                                                  

  Li 2011 US \[[@r207]\]                                               Three previous studies- pooled analysis                     Pancreas                       Population                                                          2,192                                63                                                     5,113                63                                                                                                             7

  Maisonnueve 2010 Australia, Canada, Poland \[[@r208]\] Netherlands   Multicenter (pooled analysis)                               Pancreas                       Population                                                          823                                  \-                               \-                    1,679                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 5

  Matsubayashi 2011 Japan \[[@r209]\]                                  Shizuoka Cancer center                                      Pancreas                       Hospital                                                            577                                  64.9                                                   577                  64.9                                                                                                           5

  Mizuno 1992 Japan \[[@r210]\]                                        Japanese university hospitals                               Pancreas                       Hospital                                                            124                                  \-                               \-                    124                  \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6

  Baradaran 2009 Iran \[[@r211]\]                                      Multicenter                                                 Prostate                       Hospital                                                            194                                  71.06                            26.3                  317                  66.5                                  26.8                                  \-                                 4

  Coker 2004 US \[[@r212]\]                                            South Carolina\                                             Prostate                       Population                                                          407                                  65-79                            \-                    393                  65-79                                 \-                                    \-                                 6
                                                                       Central Cancer Registry (SCCCR) (1999-2001)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    

  Gong 2006 \[[@r213]\]                                                PCPT                                                        Prostate                       Previous study                                                      1,936                                63.7                             27.6                  8,322                62.6                                  27.7                                                                     7

  Gonzales-Perez 2005 UK \[[@r214]\]                                   GPRD 1995-2001                                              Prostate                       Population                                                          2,183                                72 median                        \-                    10,000               72 median                             \-                                    \-                                 8

  Lightfoot 2004 Canada \[[@r215]\]                                    Ontario 1995-1999                                           Prostate                       Population                                                          760                                  \-                               \-                    1,632                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 5

  Rosenberg 2002 US \[[@r216]\]                                        University\                                                 Prostate                       Hospital                                                            320                                  69.6                             \-                    189                  68.1                                  \-                                    \-                                 6
                                                                       Medical Center in New York City                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                

  Tavani 2002 Italy and Greece \[[@r217]\]                             Milan Pordenone\                                            Prostate                       hospital                                                            608                                  \-                               \-                    1,008                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 6
                                                                       and Athens, Greece                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             

  Turner 2011 UK \[[@r218]\]                                           Protect study                                               Prostate                       Population                                                          1,291                                62.2                             26.7                  6,479                62.0                                  26.9                                  \-                                 7

  Zhu 2004 US \[[@r219]\]                                              US Physicians' Health Study                                 Prostate                       Physicians                                                          1,110                                **-**                            24.9                  1,110                \-                                    24.9                                  \-                                 6

  Attner 2012 Sweden \[[@r220]\]                                       Swedish cancer registry (2003-2007)                         Several                        Population                                                          19,756                               45-84                            \-                    147,324              45-84                                 \-                                    \-                                 7

  Bosetti 2011 Italy and Switzerland \[[@r221]\]                       1991-2009                                                   Several                        Hospital                                                            230- 2390 depending on cancer type   56-66 depending on cancer type                         12,060               56-65 depending on cancer type                                                                                 7

  Jorgensen 2012 Denmark \[[@r222]\]                                   Funen county                                                Several                        Population                                                          6,325                                78 median                        \-                    25,299               78 Median                             \-                                    \-                                 7

  Kuriki 2007 Japan \[[@r223]\]                                        HERPACC 1989-2000                                           Several                        Hospital                                                            ♂5,341\                              ♂65.3\                           ♂22.7\                ♂14,199\             ♂60.6\                                ♂23.0\                                \-                                 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      ♀6,331                               ♀60.6                            ♀22.4                 ♀ 33,569             ♀57.0                                 ♀22.1                                                                    

  La Vecchia 1994 Italy \[[@r224]\]                                    Milan 1983-1992                                             Several                        Hospital                                                            9,991                                \-                               \-                    7,834                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 5

  O Mara 1985\                                                         Roswell Park Memorial Institute (RPMI) (1957-1965)          Several                        Hospital                                                            14,910                               \-                               \-                    4,838                \-                                    \-                                    \-                                 3
  US(37)                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              

  Rousseau 2006 Canada \[[@r225]\]                                     Montreal 1979-1985                                          Several                        Population                                                          3,107                                \-                               \-                    509                  59.6                                  58.2%\                                \-                                 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             BMI\>25                                                                  
  -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(β =-0.23) and colorectal (β =-0.23) cancer and otherwise not a determinant like follow up years was not a determinant. Compared to adjustment of age, adjustment of both age and BMI was a significantly positive determinant in the risk of biliary tract and gallbladder cancer (β =0.79), cervix cancer (β =0.37), myeloma (β =0.49), non Hodgkin lymphoma (β =0.39), ovary-(β =0.52), prostate cancer (β =0.11), rectum cancer (β =0.40) and thyroid cancer (β =0.47), while it was a significantly negative determinant of larynx cancer (β =-0.23). In addition adjustment of age, diabetes and smoking was a positive determinant of risk ratio in colorectal- (β =0.11), ovary-(β =0.51), and skin cancer (β =0.69) compared to adjustment by age. Furthermore some specific cancer risks may be determined by diabetes ascertainment, cancer ascertainment, and data source. In the electronic Supplementary Material 4 the results of the meta-regression are available.

###### 

Results of the Pooled Analysis by Random Effects Model for All Included Studies on Any Cancer and Specific Cancer Sites

  **Cancer Site**                        **RR (95% Confidence Interval)**   **Number of Populations**   **Test for Heterogeneity**
  -------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- --------------------------- ----------------------------
  **Any**                                1.15 (1.06-1.25)                   42                          P \< 0.001
  **Biliary tract and gall bladder\***   1.69 (1.41-2.03)                   26                          P \< 0.001
  **Bladder**                            1.14 (1.05-1.22)                   35                          P \< 0.001
  Bone                                   1.00 (0.69-1.45)                   7                           P = 0.895
  **Breast**                             1.14 (1.08-1.19)                   62                          P \< 0.001
  **Cervix**                             1.34 (1.10-1.63)                   19                          P \< 0.001
  **Colon**                              1.29 (1.21-1.36)                   41                          P \< 0.001
  **Colorectal**                         1.27 (1.21-1.34)                   51                          P \< 0.001
  **Endometrial**                        1.81 (1.63-2.01)                   29                          P \< 0.001
  **Esophagus**                          1.20 (1.02-1.41)                   29                          P \< 0.001
  **Kidney**                             1.37 (1.18-1.59)                   33                          P \< 0.001
  Larynx                                 1.10 (0.84-1.43)                   11                          P \< 0.001
  **Leukemia**                           1.25 (1.08-1.45)                   20                          P \< 0.001
  **Liver**                              2.13 (1.81-2.50)                   61                          P \< 0.001
  Lung                                   1.07 (0.97-1.17)                   44                          P \< 0.001
  **Lymphoma\*\***                       1.39 (1.17-1.64)                   18                          P \< 0.001
  Melanoma                               1.00 (0.91-1.10)                   18                          P = 0.002
  Myeloma                                1.11 (0.92-1.34)                   11                          P \< 0.001
  Nervous system                         1.19 (0.97-1.46)                   19                          P \< 0.001
  **Non-Hodgkin lymfoma**                1.19 (1.05-1.36)                   28                          P \< 0.001
  **Ovary**                              1.20 (1.03-1.40)                   21                          P \< 0.001
  **Pancreas**                           2.21 (1.93-2.54)                   65                          P \< 0.001
  **Prostate**                           0.85 (0.80-0.91)                   27                          P \< 0.001
  **Rectum**                             1.17 (1.08-1.27)                   37                          P \< 0.001
  **Skin\*\*\***                         0.91 (0.83-0.99)                   18                          P \< 0.001
  **Small intestine**                    1.47 (1.03-2.11)                   6                           P = 0.005
  **Stomach**                            1.13 (1.02-1.24)                   37                          P \< 0.001
  Testes                                 0.88 (0.71-1.09)                   6                           P = 0.924
  **Thyroid**                            1.27 (1.12-1.43)                   21                          P = 0.076

Significance is indicated by **bold**. Number of populations covers the number of populations used in the pooled analysis, this may not be the same as the number of records used in the analysis, thus some records have multiple populations. RR: Risk ratio, CI: Confidence interval. \* In this category studies estimating the risk of biliary tract extra- and intra hepatic, gallbladder cancer and cholangiocarcinoma were pooled \*\* In this category estimates of lymphoma, Hodgkin lymphoma and combined estimates of lymphoma including Non-Hodgkin lymphoma were pooled. \*\*\* Some estimates used in skin cancer cover both non-melanoma skin cancer and melanoma.

###### 

Results of the Meta-Regression on the Specific Cancer Types

  **Cancer Site**                  **Gender\***   **Age (Years)\***   **BMI (kg/m^2^)\***   **Diabetes Type\***   **Follow Up (Years) \***   **Source^£^**   **Adjustment (Adjustment for Age *vs* Adjustment for Age and BMI)^£^**   **Diabetes Ascertainment^£^**   **Cancer Ascertainment^£^**   **NOS\***
  -------------------------------- -------------- ------------------- --------------------- --------------------- -------------------------- --------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------- ----------------------------- --------------
  Any                              0 (5)          \- (5)                                                                                     0 (42)          0 (42)                                                                   0 (42)                          0 (42)                        \- (5)
  Biliary tract and gall bladder   0 (7)          0 (7)                                                                                      \- (25)         \+ (25)                                                                  0 (25)                          0 (25)                        0 (7)
  Bladder                          0 (5)          \- (5)                                                                                     0 (33)          0 (33)                                                                   0 (33)                          0 (33)                        0 (5)
  Bone                             0 (4)                                                                                                     0 (7)           0 (7)                                                                                                                                  0 (4)
  Breast                                          0 (7)               0 (7)                 0 (7)                                            0 (60)          0 (60)                                                                   0 (60)                          0 (60)                        0 (7)
  Cervix                                          0 (6)                                     0 (6)                                            0 (17)          \+ (17)                                                                  0 (17)                          0 (17)                        0 (6)
  Colon                            0 (13)         0 (13)                                    \- (13)                                          0 (40)          0 (40)                                                                   0 (40)                          0 (40)                        0 (13)
  Colorectal                       0 (7)          0 (7)               0 (7)                 \- (9)\*\*                                       0 (47)          0 (47)                                                                   0 (47)                          0 (47)                        0 (7)
  Endometrial                                     0 (5)\*\*           0 (4)                                       0 (5)\*\*                  0 (26)          0 (26)                                                                   0 (26)                          0 (26)                        0 (5)\*\*
  Esophagus                        0 (5)          \- (5) C                                                                                   0 (27)          0 (27)                                                                   0 (27)                          0 (27)                        \- (5)
  Kidney                           0 (5)          0 (5)               0 (4)                                                                  0 (31)          0 (31)                                                                   \+ (31)                         0 (31)                        0 (5)
  Larynx                           0 (6)                                                                                                     0 (10)          \- (10)                                                                  \+ (10)                         0 (10)                        0 (6)
  Leukemia                         \- (5)         0 (5)                                                                                      0 (18)          0 (18)                                                                   0 (18)                          0 (18)                        0 (5)
  Liver                            0 (7)\*\*      \- (10)\*\*CC       0 (4)                                                                  0 (58)          0 (58)                                                                   0 (58)                          0 (58)                        0 (7)\*\*
  Lung                             0 (6)\*\*      0 (6)\*\*           \- (5)                                                                 0 (42)          0 (42)                                                                   0 (42)                          0 (42)                        \- (6)\*\*
  Lymphoma                         0 (9)                                                                                                     \- (18)         0 (18)                                                                   0 (18)                          0 (18)                        0 (9)
  Melanoma                         0 (12)                                                                                                    0 (16)          0 (16)                                                                                                   0 (16)                        0 (12)
  Myeloma                          0 (6)                                                                                                     \- (11)         \+ (11)                                                                  0(11)                           0 (11)                        0 (6)
  Nervous system                   0 (12)                                                                                                    0 (17)          0 (17)                                                                   0 (17)                          0 (17)                        0 (12)
  NHL                              0 (13)                                                                                                    \- (26)         \+ (26)                                                                  0 (26)                          0 (26)                        0 (13)
  Ovary                                           0 (7)                                                                                      0 (19)          \+ (19)                                                                  0 (19)                          \- (19)                       0 (7)
  Pancreas                         0 (7)\*\*      0 (7)\*\*           0 (4)                                                                  0 (63)          0 (63)                                                                   0 (63)                          0 (63)                        0 (7)\*\*
  Prostate                                        \+ (5)\*\*\*0       0 (5)\*\*\*           0 (12)                                           0 (26)          \+ (26)                                                                  0 (26)                          \- (26)                       \+ (5)\*\*\*
  Rectum                           0 (11)\*\*     0 (11)\*\*          0 (3)                 0 (11)\*\*                                       0 (35)          \+ (35)                                                                  0 (35)                          0 (35)                        0 (11)\*\*
  Skin                             0 (10)                                                                                                    0 (18)          0 (18)                                                                   0 (18)                          0 (18)                        \- (10)
  Small intestine                  0 (5)                                                                                                     \- (6)                                                                                   0 (6)                                                         0 (5)
  Stomach                          0 (7)          \- (7) C                                                        0 (6)                      0 (35)          0 (35)                                                                   0 (35)                          0 (35)                        0 (7)
  Testes                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            0 (6)
  Thyroid                          0 (6)          0 (6)                                                           0 (5)                      0 (20)          \+ (20)                                                                  0 (20)                          0 (20)                        0 (6)

+: statistically significant positive determinant, -: statistically significant negative determinant, 0: no statistical significance, blank: could not be performed and not included in the meta-regression). The () marks how many populations were available for the regression results. Number of populations covers the number of populations used in the pooled analysis, this may not be the same as the number of records used in the analysis, thus some records have multiple populations. Some estimates used in skin cancer cover both non melanoma skin cancer and melanoma. Gender, diabetes type, source, diabetes ascertainment, cancer ascertainment, adjustment and NOS were all coded as categorical values, \* regression analysis included age, gender, NOS and BMI if available. ^£^ regression analyses included study design, source, diabetes ascertainment, adjustment factors and cancer ascertainment. \*\* Regression performed without BMI. \*\*\* Regression performed without diabetes type. BMI: Body Mass Index, NHL: Non Hodgkin lymphoma, NOS: Newcastle Ottawa Scale score. C: significance only applies to cohort studies not case control studies. CC: significance only apply to case control studies. Variables were entered in the categories as described in the methods section.
