Old fan - new member: I'm not allowed to read private messages yet, so thought I might just as well post the activation post here also, where it's more likely that I'll get an answer.

Zappa in New York was my third Zappa cassette in 1979. I know about the different versions of the album, but I'm curious about a new CD edition which is advertised on various netsites. It's supposed to be a single CD housed in a vinyl replica album cover. Issued by Phantom Sound and Vision 05/27/08. Has anyone checked it out? Is it the original version with Punky's Whips, without other bonus tracks? Or is it just a mistake in the lists, and actually the current Ryko double in a different cover?

_________________Alan Thicke: ''Now Frank, for those of us who have seen you as some kind of guru over the years, that's a kind of nihilistic assesment of music. Where's the hope ?''
Frank Zappa: ''Well, there isn't any...''

The latest editions are not referenced on the Patio pages.From the barcode I referenced in some listings (4988112417694), it seems that Phantom Sound & Vision is distributing the Japanese VideoArts edition (VACK 1325/26).And in this case, it is the remixed version in a beautiful papersleeve.

Okay - I appreciate the help. But check this out: ASIN: B0016FZHA6 - It's listed as just one disc. So that would either have to be an edition with less material than the current Ryko double - or a mistake in the listings. A single disc ZINY following the 1977 original would be lovely, but until proven otherwise I guess it's just the VACK version mislisted.

Okay - I appreciate the help. But check this out: ASIN: B0016FZHA6 - It's listed as just one disc. So that would either have to be an edition with less material than the current Ryko double - or a mistake in the listings. A single disc ZINY following the 1977 original would be lovely, but until proven otherwise I guess it's just the VACK version mislisted.

I don't see the purpose in rereleasing the original ZINY since those mixes are all on Lather. Seems like a weird move, but I guess I've seen weirder!

Mixes are also noticeably different between some songs on the two albums - for instance, "Illinois Enema Bandit" on Lather has some additional echo and other effects on Don Pardo's intro and FZ's vocal at the end, making it sound more like a studio recording.

Okay - I appreciate the help. But check this out: ASIN: B0016FZHA6 - It's listed as just one disc. So that would either have to be an edition with less material than the current Ryko double - or a mistake in the listings. A single disc ZINY following the 1977 original would be lovely, but until proven otherwise I guess it's just the VACK version mislisted.

On the one hand, Amazon Japan report it as a 1 disc edition, but on the other hand they also mention a complete tracks listing for 2 CDs.So yes, it has to be a mistake.

Old fan - new member: I'm not allowed to read private messages yet, so thought I might just as well post the activation post here also, where it's more likely that I'll get an answer.

Zappa in New York was my third Zappa cassette in 1979. I know about the different versions of the album, but I'm curious about a new CD edition which is advertised on various netsites. It's supposed to be a single CD housed in a vinyl replica album cover. Issued by Phantom Sound and Vision 05/27/08. Has anyone checked it out? Is it the original version with Punky's Whips, without other bonus tracks? Or is it just a mistake in the lists, and actually the current Ryko double in a different cover?

I have a several copies of Zappa lp's

The item I wish to discuss is Live in New york

I have copies with Punky's Whips and copies without this track.

it was pulled by the record company.

I have one copy that lists wunky's whips on the back of the gatefold sleeve but does not list it on the inside of the sleeve it does not appear on the record either.

I can only assume that the manufacturer of the gatefold sleeves had some of the outer sleeves left over and used them together with the new inner sleeves.

Potentially making this a rare item.

Is there any way of estimating the value of this itemI have a several copies of Zappa lp's

The item I wish to discuss is Live in New york

I have copies with Punky's Whips and copies without this track.

it was pulled by the record company.

I have one copy that lists wunky's whips on the back of the gatefold sleeve but does not list it on the inside of the sleeve it does not appear on the record either.

I can only assume that the manufacturer of the gatefold sleeves had some of the outer sleeves left over and used them together with the new inner sleeves.

When I started this thread, I was waiting for a copy of ZINY to be shipped from Australia. The seller had told that the cover and label list PW, but the track doesn't actually appear on the record. I was hesitant, but in the end decided to pay 100 dollars + postage for that copy.

In the meantime I was eager to find a way of actually hearing the album as intended by Frank in 1977. I started looking for the bootleg CD, but only found references to the Vack edition which we discussed above.

Eventually the shipment from Australia arrived, and I found out that - in spite of what the seller had said - it is a real and complete copy of the first UK edition, with PW listed on cover, label and on the inside gatefold, with lyrics and the picture of Terry's lithoeroticization... and playing the track as well (with Big Leg Emma between the Black Pages on side two).

So, in answer to your question, I guess a hundred dollars is a fair price for a copy with PW only listed on the cover. But if you're lucky, you can get so much more for that cash

_________________We make a special art in an environment hostile to dreamers. Frank Zappa, 1971

When I started this thread, I was waiting for a copy of ZINY to be shipped from Australia. The seller had told that the cover and label list PW, but the track doesn't actually appear on the record. I was hesitant, but in the end decided to pay 100 dollars + postage for that copy.

In the meantime I was eager to find a way of actually hearing the album as intended by Frank in 1977. I started looking for the bootleg CD, but only found references to the Vack edition which we discussed above.

Eventually the shipment from Australia arrived, and I found out that - in spite of what the seller had said - it is a real and complete copy of the first UK edition, with PW listed on cover, label and on the inside gatefold, with lyrics and the picture of Terry's lithoeroticization... and playing the track as well (with Big Leg Emma between the Black Pages on side two).

So, in answer to your question, I guess a hundred dollars is a fair price for a copy with PW only listed on the cover. But if you're lucky, you can get so much more for that cash

Thanks for that. Most UK releases contain PW. I think the powers that be at warners did not see the uk market as too much of a problem and probably released the stock that they had pressed - save binning them. Later releases do omit the song.

5.0 out of 5 stars obscenity of Zappa's masterpiece, the apex of Unusual Pervert! 2009/11/2

By Mei coffin (Neyagawa City, Osaka)

Target Product Review: Zappa In New York (restrictions apply) (CD).

This is one aspect of Zappa, of obscenity, of transformation (Abnormal Psychology, SM interests, robbery enema), dealing with a so-called "top" some Unusual masterpiece. Light music can do this calmly, and then to let Maeru is not inconceivable Zappa on the planet! Music, including brass, big band, organization, and the sound is impressive too thick. This pattern of a live, John Belushi had also appeared in the Provence, "Saturday Night Live" in the footage, you can watch part 1. By the addition of bonus tracks can also experience the world quite dense Zappa. As usual, speaking of Zappa, the lyrics are so awesome, we recommend that you get the Japanese version by all means. Among the many works of Frank Zappa, one of the best you great board. Naka Naka "dark", but also recommended for beginners!

In addition I got access to a kinky live dance with the back of a bikini clad and tattooed Japanese girl wriggling her bottom obscenely towards a tea pot!

_________________We make a special art in an environment hostile to dreamers. Frank Zappa, 1971

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forumYou cannot reply to topics in this forumYou cannot edit your posts in this forumYou cannot delete your posts in this forumYou cannot post attachments in this forum