1. Introduction {#s0005}
===============

Infection of the central nervous system (CNS) is a nearly universal feature of systemic human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV) infection. It develops early in systemic HIV infection ([@bb0150]) and continues throughout its untreated course ([@bb0025]). While often seemingly innocent, this infection can evolve to a form that is associated with CNS injury, most severely manifesting as HIV-associated dementia (HAD) with high morbidity and mortality ([@bb0115]). However, infected individuals can also manifest less severe CNS injury that elides detection ([@bb0010], [@bb0055]). Individuals with HIV infection can suffer CNS dysfunction from a variety of other conditions that can confuse diagnosis. Current research diagnostic classification depends on performance on a neuropsychological test battery which may be difficult to implement and also can be confounded by other conditions and co-morbidities ([@bb0010]). Moreover, in patients with neurocognitive impairment it may be difficult to distinguish ongoing CNS injury related to HIV infection from prior but now static CNS injury, particularly without clear longitudinal observation. In order to more objectively define ongoing CNS injury in individual patients and in research settings evaluating the prevalence or incidence of CNS disease or CNS treatment effects, sensitive and reliable objective biomarkers can prove to be of great value.

To date, measurement of neurofilament light chain (NFL) concentrations in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) appears the most sensitive and useful biomarker of active CNS injury in HIV infection --- showing elevations in not only overt HAD but also in patients with less severe, inapparent or clinically confounded impairment ([@bb0065], [@bb0105]). However, the need to sample CSF has limited the application of this measurement, particularly in the clinical contexts of screening patients, assessing those who refuse lumbar puncture, or evaluating those who suffer other conditions that obscure evaluation. An assay that could be applied more broadly to cohort studies and clinical trials that do not include lumbar puncture would also be valuable in assessing the prevalence of CNS injury and its response to treatment. Hence, a biomarker requiring only blood sampling rather than lumbar puncture would clearly represent a useful advance in clinical management and research settings.

To address this need we have developed an ultra-sensitive immunoassay for plasma NFL using Single molecule array (Simoa) technology ([@bb0125]). In this study we compare plasma with CSF NFL concentrations of NFL in a cross-sectional study of HIV-infected individuals and HIV-negative controls and show that the plasma analysis using this sensitive method yields results that are concordant with CSF analysis despite the differences of NFL concentrations in the two fluids.

2. Methods {#s0010}
==========

2.1. Study Design and Patients {#s0015}
------------------------------

This was a cross-sectional study using archived blood and CSF samples originated from two cohort studies: one in Gothenburg, Sweden and the second in San Francisco, California. The samples and related background data were all obtained between 1992 and 2014 within the context of research protocols approved by the institutional review boards of the two study sites. All blood and CSF samples were obtained after informed consent of subjects under these IRB-approved protocols.

Blood and CSF were included from 7 defined HIV-infected subject groups (n = 121) as outlined in previous studies ([@bb0065], [@bb0105]): early or 'primary' HIV infection (PHI, defined as within the first twelve months after initial HIV-1 infection) ([@bb0135]); four groups of chronically HIV-infected subject volunteers without a diagnosis of HAD and who were not being evaluated or treated for overt neurological symptoms or signs when recruited, designated as neuroasymptomatic (NA) and divided by blood CD4^+^ T cell counts into those with \> 350, 200--349, 50--199, and CD4 \< 50 cells/μL; and a group presenting with clinically overt HAD, most commonly of subacute onset. All of these subjects were either naïve to treatment or off treatment for at least 6 months at the time of sampling. Also included was a group of treated HIV-infected subjects with \> 1 year of plasma virus suppression to below 50 copies/mL of HIV RNA (ART). A group of uninfected (HIV-neg) volunteer subjects (n = 19), confirmed by serological testing at study visit, were recruited from the San Francisco community for research assessments to provide comparison data for the HIV-infected subjects. Background clinical, laboratory and demographic data for each subject group are summarized in [Table 1](#t0005){ref-type="table"}.

2.2. Blood and CSF Sampling {#s0020}
---------------------------

Blood and CSF were obtained according to standard protocols as previously described ([@bb0120], [@bb0030]). CSF was immediately subjected to low-speed centrifugation to remove cells, aliquoted and stored within 1 h of collection at ≤− 70 °C until the time of the neuronal biomarker assays. Blood was collected in EDTA tubes and plasma was aliquoted and stored in parallel with CSF for later batch assays.

2.3. Background Laboratory Methods {#s0025}
----------------------------------

We explored correlations with background HIV clinical biomarkers including: blood CD4^+^ T cell counts: CSF and blood HIV RNA concentrations; CSF white blood cell (WBC) counts; CSF:serum albumin ratio as an indicator of blood--brain barrier permeability; and blood and CSF neopterin, a marker of macrophage and microglial activation ([@bb0045]).

HIV RNA levels were measured in cell-free CSF and plasma at each site using the Cobas TaqMan RealTime HIV-1 (version 1 or 2; Hoffmann-La Roche, Basel, Switzerland), or the Abbott RealTime HIV-1 assay (Abbot Laboratories, Abbot Park, IL, USA). All recorded viral loads that were below the lower limit of quantitation (40 copies/mL) were standardized to a defined 'floor' value of 20 copies/mL for descriptive purposes. Blood and CSF neopterin were analyzed using a commercially available immunoassay (BRAHMS, Hennigsdorf, Germany), with an upper normal reference value of 8.8 nmol/L in blood and 5.8 nmol/L in CSF ([@bb0045]). Each study visit included assessments by local clinical laboratories using routine methods to measure CSF white blood cell (WBC) count, CSF and blood albumin, and blood CD4^+^ and CD8^+^ T lymphocyte counts by flow cytometry.

2.4. Clinical Evaluations {#s0030}
-------------------------

All HIV-infected subjects and controls underwent routine clinical bedside screening for symptoms or signs of CNS opportunistic infections or other conditions that could impact CSF or blood biomarker concentrations. Diagnosis of HAD was based on clinicians\' assessment at presentation which was characteristically subacute, and met American Academy of Neurology criteria ([@bb0005]). Many of these subjects were studied before publication of the more formal Frascati criteria ([@bb0010]) and were diagnosed with AIDS dementia complex (ADC) stages 1--4 ([@bb0110]) but met the functional criteria for the Frascati diagnosis of HAD without the requisite extensive formal neuropsychological assessment.

2.5. NFL Measurements {#s0035}
---------------------

CSF NFL concentrations were measured using a sensitive sandwich method (NF-light® ELISA kit, UmanDiagnostics AB, Umeå, Sweden) as previously described ([@bb0065], [@bb0090]). The coefficient of variations (CVs) for the repeatability and intermediate precision for this assay is CV \< 6% and CV \< 7%, respectively, and the lower limit of quantification (LLOQ) is 50 pg/mL determined by repeated measurements (n = 15) of a CSF sample with low (52 pg/mL) concentration and still acceptable variability (CV = 12%). Plasma NFL levels were determined using the same monoclonal antibodies and calibrator as in the NF-light assay, transferred onto the Simoa platform using a homebrew kit (Quanterix, Lexington, MA, USA). The limit of detection (mean blank signal + 3 SD) for the Simoa NFL assay was 0.3 pg/mL and the lower limit of quantification (mean blank signal + 10 SD) was 2.7 pg/mL when compensated for a four-fold sample dilution. Samples were analyzed in duplicate, and the CV for the samples was below 10%.

All plasma samples were analyzed in a single run in the Laboratory of Neurochemistry at the University of Gothenburg by board-certified laboratory technicians blind to clinical data using a single batch of reagents for each assay; intra-assay coefficients of variation were below 10% for all analyses. Previously described laboratory cutoffs for CSF NFL were used for descriptive analysis ([@bb0065]). Based on age-related reference values, normal cutoff values in CSF for NFL were defined as \< 380 ng/L (\< 30 years), \< 560 ng/L (30--39 years), \< 890 ng/L (40--59 years), and \< 1850 ng/L (\> 59 years). Laboratory cutoffs for blood NFL have not yet been defined. Some of the CSF NFL results and results of the PHI subjects have been previously reported in a different context ([@bb0105], [@bb0100]), including within a larger data set characterizing CSF in relation to age ([@bb0065]).

2.6. Statistical Methods {#s0040}
------------------------

Descriptive statistics were performed using Prism (version 6, Graphpad Software Inc., La Jolla, CA) or SPSS (IBM SPSS version 21) software. Continuous variables were log~10~ transformed where appropriate to reduce skewness. Comparison of biomarker concentrations was performed with One-way ANOVA and Tukey\'s multiple comparison test for evaluation of multiple groups. Biomarker associations were analyzed with Pearson correlation analysis. The relationship between age and log~10~ plasma and CSF NFL levels, was analyzed with linear regression.

3. Results {#s0045}
==========

Plasma NFL concentrations were within the linear range of the assay in all samples, [Fig. 1](#f0005){ref-type="fig"}a. It was thus possible to quantify plasma NFL in all subjects analyzed, despite more than 50-fold lower concentrations than in CSF. This included the HIV-negative controls and other subjects with low normal CSF NFL levels, [Table 2](#t0010){ref-type="table"}. CSF concentrations were likewise within the quantitative range of the standard assay, [Fig. 1](#f0005){ref-type="fig"}b. Notably, plasma NFL concentrations were highly correlated with those of CSF (r = 0.89, p \< 0.0001), [Fig. 1](#f0005){ref-type="fig"}c. [Fig. 1](#f0005){ref-type="fig"} provides general context for the NFL results, showing plasma and CSF HIV RNA (d and e) and CSF neopterin (f) concentrations are also shown in [Fig. 1](#f0005){ref-type="fig"}.

The patterns of plasma and CSF NFL concentration changes across the HIV-infected groups were very similar. In agreement with previous studies, the CSF NFL elevations were greatest in the HAD groups but there was also a high prevalence of abnormal levels in untreated neuroasymptomatic subjects with low CD4^+^ T-cell counts ([@bb0065], [@bb0105]). Using the laboratory age-related cut-offs for CSF NFL, all of the HAD patients had elevated CSF NFL concentrations, and 75% of untreated neuroasymptomatic subjects with CD4^+^ T-cell count below 50 cells/μL and 58% with 50--199 CD4^+^ cells/μL had abnormal CSF NFL concentrations; additionally 24% of subjects with 200--349 CD4 cells and 16% of those with CD4 cell counts above 350 cells/μL had increased levels---indicating a high level of clinically unappreciated ongoing CNS injury that varied with degree of systemic disease progression. By comparison, in the treated group, and in HIV-negative subjects, the frequency was much lower, 4 and 5%, respectively. There also were moderate elevated CSF NFL levels in a large proportion of subjects with PHI, 54%, in accordance with previous reports ([@bb0135]).

Unlike CSF, age-related reference values have not yet been established for plasma NFL, but the pattern of changes in the subject groups was very similar to that of CSF NFL. Again the HAD had highest plasma NFL concentrations, with all values exceeding the 90th percentile of the HIV negative control levels. Like CSF, there were also elevations of plasma NFL in a substantial portion of the neuroasymptomatic subjects with low CD4^+^ T cell counts.

The reason for the similarity in these patterns was the strong correlation between plasma and CSF NFL ([Fig. 1](#f0005){ref-type="fig"}c) and thus the plasma levels appear to reflect concentrations in CSF and, hence, the severity of CNS injury.

Statistical comparisons between groups using One-way ANOVA with Tukey\'s multiple comparison tests are listed in [Table 3](#t0015){ref-type="table"}. The plasma and CSF NFL concentrations in the HAD group were significantly elevated compared to all other subgroups. The neuroasymptomatic CD4 \< 50 group were also elevated above the other groups, except compared to neuroasymptomatic CD4 50--199, and, for CSF only, also to the PHI group.

CSF NFL increases with age in the absence of HIV infection ([@bb0065]) and, as anticipated, there was a significant correlation between age and CSF NFL in the group of 19 HIV-negative controls (r = 0.67, p = 0.002). Similarly, plasma NFL was strongly associated with age in HIV-negative controls (r = 0.79, p \< 0.0001). In [Fig. 2](#f0010){ref-type="fig"}, plasma (b) and CSF (c) NFL are plotted against age in the different groups studied. The slopes of the plasma and CSF NFL values against age in HIV-negative controls were similar to what has been reported previously in CSF ([@bb0065]), [Fig. 2](#f0010){ref-type="fig"}a.

Plasma and CSF NFL were also significantly correlated with CD4^+^ T cell count, plasma and CSF HIV RNA levels, blood and CSF neopterin, and the albumin ratio. Correlation coefficients were similar for CSF and plasma NFL ([Table 4](#t0020){ref-type="table"}).

4. Discussion {#s0050}
=============

A sensitive and reliable blood biomarker of neural injury in CNS neurodegeneration has long been sought. The results of this study show that plasma levels of NFL provide a good indicator of active CNS injury in HIV infection that agrees well with the results of CSF NFL measurement. This thus promises to be a useful advance in the study of CNS injury in HIV infection. Additionally, because of the sensitivity of CSF NFL to CNS injury in other settings, these findings suggest that this same assay may be useful also in other neurodegenerative conditions.

Using an ultrasensitive immunoassay, NFL was detectable and quantifiable in blood in all subjects analyzed despite more than 50-fold lower concentrations than in CSF. This included detection in subjects with low normal CSF NFL levels, including HIV-negative controls and HIV-infected on suppressive ART. Thus, the assay could be used to analyze the full range of subjects included in this study and could be similarly deployed in other small and large clinical and research settings to assess active CNS injury.

We found elevated levels of NFL, both in CSF and plasma, in patients with HAD and in some neuroasymptomatic HIV-infected patients, mainly in subjects with low CD4^+^ cell count. This is in agreement with previous studies on CSF NFL, reflecting an ongoing subclinical axonal injury in these subjects ([@bb0065]). CSF NFL can predict subsequent development of HAD and we have previously shown that CSF NFL was increased 1--2 years before overt symptoms of dementia in patients developing HAD in the pre-ART era ([@bb0030]). The incidence of HAD has decreased substantially during recent years in the developed world when the majority of HIV-infected patients are on effective ART ([@bb0075]). Nowadays, HAD develops almost exclusively in so called late presenters with low CD4^+^ T cell counts at time of diagnosis. ART effectively prevents HAD, and severe neurocognitive disease rarely develops in patients on effective ART. Exceptions are rare cases with 'neurosymptomatic CSF escape' characterized by new progressive CNS disease in patients on ART with undetectable or low HIV RNA in plasma but disproportionately increased viral loads in CSF ([@bb0015], [@bb0095]). Although CSF NFL can be used to detect active neuronal injury in these settings, it is limited by the need for CSF sampling that sometimes could be an obstacle. While more severe CNS disease is uncommon in treated HIV, mild neurocognitive impairment is frequently found also in patients on ART ([@bb0010], [@bb0050]). In these treatment settings, plasma NFL may be a useful marker to help discriminate active ongoing neuronal injury from neurological or cognitive symptoms related to sequelae of prior CNS damage that occurred before treatment initiation ([@bb0085]), so called inactive disease, though this important issue needs further direct study. This distinction between active and static injury may have important implications for treatment, the first more amenable to intervention either with additional antiviral or adjuvant, anti-inflammatory, interventions. Previous efforts at mitigating neurocognitive impairment of treated-suppressed individuals may have been underpowered because of failure to distinguish between active and static neural injury. Importantly, a plasma assay of injury might prove valuable to assess neurological impact of treatment trials that have not included neurological assessments or lumbar puncture, opening a large experience with different treatment strategies and drug regimens to neurological outcome analysis.

Increased concentrations of CSF NFL are not specific to HIV-related brain damage; CSF NFL levels have been shown to be a sensitive indicator of CNS axonal injury in several neurological diseases ([@bb0090], [@bb0020], [@bb0040]) including various infections ([@bb0140], [@bb0035]), and, by extrapolation, plasma NFL has the potential to become a valuable marker in a wide range of neurological disease settings.

Plasma NFL increased with age in our controls in a pattern similar to that found in the CSF. This age-dependent increase in CSF NFL has been clearly defined in earlier, larger studies ([@bb0065]). The mechanisms underlying the age-dependent increase in CSF NFL have not been established, but these age effects need to be considered when analyzing NFL concentrations, including the effects of treatment in individuals with HIV followed over longer periods of time.

NFL is important for maintenance of the axonal caliber and morphological integrity and is expressed predominantly in large-caliber myelinated axons ([@bb0060]), but is also present in neurites (axons and dendrites) of CNS neurons in the cerebral and cerebellar cortex, hypothalamus and spinal cord ([@bb0145]). Its CSF levels reflect leakage from injured or degenerating neurons, correlate with white-matter lesions and other injuries to subcortical brain regions ([@bb0070]), and predict severity and survival in several neurodegenerative diseases ([@bb0130]). The robust correlation between plasma and CSF levels of NFL strongly suggests that plasma levels indeed reflect ongoing CNS injury, which is in agreement with a recent study on amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, however using a less sensitive method that does not allow proper quantification in all samples ([@bb0080]). However, an increase in plasma NFL without adjacent increase in CSF could theoretically also be a result of peripheral neuronal injury given that NFL is also found in peripheral nervous system neurons ([@bb0145]). The magnitude of this effect needs to be evaluated in future studies of patients with the common HIV distal sensory and other neuropathies.

We have observed a close correlation between plasma and CSF NFL, including a parallel increase in both, in the presence of ongoing neuronal injury in HIV-infected patients. Therefore, we believe that plasma NFL has the potential of being a useful biomarker of CNS injury in HIV infection, and most likely in other neurodegenerative settings as well.

Contributors {#s0055}
============

M.G. initiated the study and wrote the paper. M.G., L.H., S.S., and R.W.P. recruited the subjects. H.Z., K.B., U.A., and N.N. developed the NFL assays and performed the NFL analyses. D.F. performed neopterin measurements. M.G., R.W.P., and S.N. analyzed the data and performed the statistics. All authors edited the manuscript, provided comments, and approved the final version..

Declaration of Interest {#s0060}
=======================

N.N. is employed by UmanDiagnostics AB, Umeå, Sweden. UmanDiagnostics did not play any role in the study design and was not involved in the data analysis or interpretation of the results. H.Z. and K.B. are co-founders of Brain Biomarkers Solutions in Gothenburg AB, a GU Holding-based platform company at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden. All other authors declare no competing financial interest.

This work was supported by the Swedish Research Council (K2011-58P-20931-01-4, K2010-63P-21562-01-4, K2011-61X-20401-05-6, 2013-2546, and K2013-61X-14002-13-5), the Sahlgrenska University Hospital (ALFGBG-430271, ALFGBG-441051, and ALFGBG-139671), the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation, VINNOVA (\# 2014-03496), the Torsten Söderberg Foundation at the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, and the United States National Institutes of Health (R21MH096619, P01MH094177, R01MH62701, UL1 RR024131, and P30 AI027763). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

![Association between CSF and plasma NFL and concentrations of biomarkers in 8 subject groups. Panels a--b and d--f, plot concentrations of different markers for the 8 subject groups, HIV-negative controls (HIV-neg); primary HIV infection (PHI); untreated neuroasymptomatic subjects in different CD4 cell strata (Asympt); HIV-associated dementia (HAD); and subjects on suppressive antiretroviral treatment (ART). Boxes depict median and IQR, whiskers show 10--90 percentiles and '+' designates the means. Dotted horizontal lines in panels d--e show the limit of detection for HIV RNA (40 copies/mL), and in panel f the upper limit of normal for CSF neopterin (5.8 nmol/L). Panel c plots the correlation between log CSF and log plasma NFL.](gr1){#f0005}

![Association between NFL and age. Panel a displays the regression lines for age to log plasma and log CSF NFL in HIV-negative controls. Age was closely correlated with plasma NFL (r = 0.79, p \< 0.0001).](gr2){#f0010}

###### 

Background Subject Characteristics.

  Groups                          N    Age           Plasma HIV-RNA      CSF HIV-RNA         Blood CD4^+^ T cells
  ------------------------------- ---- ------------- ------------------- ------------------- ----------------------
  HIV negative (HIV-neg)          19   34 (29--48)   NA                  NA                  763 (686--993)
  Primary HIV Infection (PHI)     13   36 (30--46)   4.70 (4.11--5.64)   2.73 (1.96--3.94)   539 (340--761)
  Neuroasymtpomatic HIV (NA)                                                                 
   CD4 \> 350                     19   41 (35--43)   4.08 (3.30--4.44)   3.23 (2.45--3.68)   490 (402--582)
   CD4 200--349                   17   48 (36--56)   4.91 (4.30--5.31)   4.28 (3.44--4.68)   240 (215--305)
   CD4 50--199                    19   44 (37--56)   4.97 (4.44--5.25)   3.96 (3.53--4.56)   125 (100--170)
   CD4 \< 50                      20   41 (36--49)   5.40 (4.54--5.88)   3.10 (2.30--3.81)   22 (10--39)
  HIV-associated dementia (HAD)   11   43 (38--56)   5.49 (4.83--5.83)   4.34 (2.59--5.31)   60 (30--144)
  HIV, treated-suppressed (ART)   22   44 (38--52)   1.30 (1.30--1.30)   1.30 (1.30--1.30)   544 (275--725)

###### 

Median (IQR) Plasma NFL (Left Columns) and CSF NFL (Right Columns) Concentrations in Different Groups.

  Groups                          N    Plasma NFL         CSF NFL
  ------------------------------- ---- ------------------ -----------------------
  HIV negative (HIV-neg)          19   9.3 (5.9--13.1)    363 (264--487)
  Primary HIV Infection (PHI)     13   11.2 (8.2--16.6)   732 (456--1288)
  Neuroasymtpomatic HIV (NA)                              
   CD4 \> 350                     19   9.0 (6.5--14.3)    488 (374--694)
   CD4 200--349                   17   9.7 (7.6--12.2)    573 (464--764)
   CD4 50--199                    19   12.1 (7.8--44.7)   640 (490--1530)
   CD4 \< 50                      20   39.6 (12.0--103)   2415 (690--4420)
  HIV-associated dementia (HAD)   11   114 (46.0--235)    16,185 (1513--43,010)
  HIV, treated-suppressed (ART)   22   11.1 (8.6--12.8)   582 (322--706)

###### 

Comparisons of Blood and CSF Neurofilament Light Protein (NFL) Concentrations Among Subject Groups.

                                     Blood NFL (log)   CSF NFL (log)
  ---------------------------------- ----------------- ---------------
  *Overall ANOVA p*                                    
  **Group Comparisons**              \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
                                                       
  *Tukey*\'*s Multiple Comparison*                     
  HAD vs. HIV-                       \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
  HAD vs. PHI                        \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
  HAD vs. NA CD4 \> 350              \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
  HAD vs. NA CD4 200--349            \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
  HAD vs. NA CD4 50--199             \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
  HAD vs. NA CD4 \< 50               0.008             \< 0.0001
  HAD vs. ART                        \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
  NA CD4 \< 50 vs. HIV-              \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001
  NA CD4 \< 50 vs. PHI               0.005             0.063
  NA CD4 \< 50 vs. NA CD4 \> 350     \< 0.0001         0.001
  NA CD4 \< 50 vs. NA CD4 200--349   \< 0.0001         0.001
  NA CD4 \< 50 vs. NA CD4 50--199    0.056             0.129
  NA CD4 \< 50 vs. ART               \< 0.0001         \< 0.0001

###### 

Plasma NFL (Left Columns) and CSF NFL (Right Columns) Correlation With Background HIV Clinical Biomarkers.

                            Log Plasma NFL   Log CSF NFL            
  ------------------------- ---------------- ------------- -------- ----------
  Log CD4                   − 0.43           \< 0.001      − 0.36   \< 0.001
  Log P HIV RNA             0.45             \< 0.001      0.41     \< 0.001
  Log CSF HIV RNA           0.25             0.020         0.29     0.008
  Log S Neopterin           0.48             \< 0.001      0.44     \< 0.001
  Log CSF Neopterin         0.42             \< 0.001      0.30     0.002
  Log CSF/P albumin ratio   0.31             0.004         0.30     0.002
