1). Although the U.S. Government Has Taken Actions to Facilitate U.S. Resettlement of North Korean Refugees, Processing Times Did Not Improve

The USRAP opened cases for 238 North Korean refugee applicants from  fiscal years 2005 to 2010, as of March 29, 2010. However, the policies of some host  countries affect U.S. processing times for North Korean refugees. From  fiscal years 2006 to 2008, the most current year for which complete data  were available, U.S. processing times did not improve. The U.S. Government Has Taken Actions to Facilitate the U.S. Resettlement Process for North Korean Refugees

The U.S. government, particularly State, has taken actions to facilitate the  U.S. resettlement process for North Korean refugees by placing a high  priority on North Korean cases and providing additional resources to  process these cases. Conducting and clearing security checks involve a number of  federal agencies, and this stage in USRAP can create delays in U.S.  processing times, according to U.S. officials. Processing of North Korean Refugees

Some host countries’ policies affect the processing of North Korean  refugee cases, according to officials from the U.S. government and  international organizations. For example:    Some host countries delay granting exit permission for North Korean  refugees, which can add months to overall processing times, according to  U.S. officials. Processing Times for North Korean Refugees Did Not Improve from Fiscal Year 2006 to 2008, and Were Generally Comparable to Those of Some Other Refugee Populations in Fiscal Year 2008

Overall, average processing times did not improve for the 85 cases created  in fiscal years 2006 to 2008 that arrived in the United States. State officials said that one host country  limited U.S. government access to North Koreans in fiscal years 2007 and  2008, which resulted in longer average processing times for cases created  in those years. At Least 33 North Koreans Have Applied for Asylum Status in the United States, but the Number Is Likely Higher

In the United States, North Koreans have applied for asylum protection  through two processes—the affirmative and the defensive. Defensive Asylum Process

Through the defensive asylum process, applicants, including North  Koreans, request asylum as a defense against removal from the United  States and can be held in detention while their case is processed. The Number of North Koreans Who Have Sought Asylum in the United States Is Likely Higher than 33

DHS/USCIS identified 33 North Koreans—including their dependents  (some of whom may not be North Korean)—who have sought asylum in  the United States since fiscal year 2005 through either the affirmative  asylum or credible fear process. Of the 33 North Korean asylum seekers,  9 have been granted asylum, 15 are pending, as of March 2, 2010, and 9  individual cases were closed or resolved for other reasons (“other  decisions”). Agency Comments

We provided a draft of this report to the Departments of State, Homeland  Security, Justice, and Health and Human Services. State, DHS, and DOJ  provided technical comments, which have been incorporated throughout  the report, as appropriate. Appendix I: Objectives, Scope, and Methodology

In this report, we (1) assess the U.S. government’s efforts to facilitate the  processing of North Korean refugees overseas for resettlement in the  United States, and (2) determine the number of North Koreans who have  sought asylum to remain in the United States and the process by which  they may do so. Citizenship and Immigrations Services  (USCIS). We  requested data on North Korean asylum cases in the defensive process  from EOIR. Affirmative Asylum Process

In the affirmative asylum process, individuals who are physically in the  United States, regardless of how they arrived or their current immigration  status, may present an asylum application to DHS/USCIS.
Why GAO Did This Study

Famine killed hundreds of thousands of North Koreans in the 1990s and compelled a large number of others to leave in search of food, economic opportunities, and escape from a repressive regime. This migration continues. Some North Koreans seek resettlement in other countries, such as South Korea and the United States. To promote a more durable humanitarian solution to the plight of North Korean refugees, Congress passed the North Korean Human Rights Act in 2004. In reauthorizing the Act in 2008, Congress found that delays in processing North Korean refugees have led refugees to abandon their quest for U.S. resettlement. GAO was asked to (1) assess the U.S. government's efforts to facilitate the processing of North Korean refugees who request resettlement in the United States from overseas, and (2) determine the number of North Koreans who have sought asylum to remain in the United States and the process by which they may do so. GAO is issuing a separate classified annex to this report. GAO analyzed data on North Korean refugees and asylees, interviewed agency officials, and conducted fieldwork in Asia. This report does not contain recommendations. The Departments of State (State), Homeland Security, and Justice provided technical comments and GAO incorporated these comments, as appropriate.

What GAO Found

The U.S. government has taken actions to facilitate the U.S. resettlement of North Korean refugees from overseas, but processing times did not improve from fiscal years 2006 to 2008 due in part to some host countries' policies. The United States opened cases for 238 North Korean refugee applicants from October 2004 through March 2010, and 94 of these North Koreans arrived in the United States. As part of its recent actions to facilitate the processing of North Korean refugees, State has placed a high priority on these cases and provided additional staff time and resources to process these cases. However, according to U.S. officials, some U.S. requirements, such as conducting and clearing security checks, can delay U.S. processing. According to officials from the U.S. government and international organizations, the policies of some host countries also can affect U.S. processing of North Korean refugees. For example, some host countries delay granting North Korean refugees permission to leave their countries. Average processing times for North Koreans did not improve from fiscal years 2006 to 2008, the most recent year for which complete data were available. State officials said that one host country limited U.S. government access to North Koreans in fiscal years 2007 and 2008, resulting in longer average processing times for cases created in those years. While processing times for North Koreans were lower in fiscal year 2006 than those of some other refugee populations, the processing times were generally comparable in fiscal year 2008. From October 1, 2004, through March 2, 2010, at least 33 North Koreans have sought asylum protection to remain in the United States, but the actual number is likely higher. Of the 33 North Koreans, 9 individuals have been granted asylum, 15 are still pending, and 9 are categorized as "other decisions," meaning their cases have been denied, dismissed, or withdrawn, according to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) data. The actual number of individuals is likely higher for several reasons including agencies' difficulties in compiling information. North Koreans can seek asylum protection through two processes--the affirmative or the defensive. In the affirmative process, individuals who are physically in the United States may present an asylum application to USCIS and undergo a non-adversarial interview to determine their eligibility for asylum. In the defensive process, applicants request that the Department of Justice grant them asylum as a defense against removal from the United States. USCIS data do not include information on North Koreans who first claimed asylum before an Immigration Judge in the defensive process.