Look, I don't care that this is not historically accurate, most historical fiction is not. What matters here is the acting and the presentation of the plot. Milla is terrific, as is Besson's direction. You love the way this film moves. Not only is it a great action story, but it is appealing in the way Joan slowly gains the recognition, admiration, and finally idolization of her male Knight partners in battle, exhibiting heroism and absolute unrelenting determination. For me, it is set aside from all those other Joan movies exactly because we are kept guessing as to whether Joan is mentally disturbed, entrusted on a path from God, or maybe a little of both. The supporting characters are believable, and the acting is great, especially from the fantastic Malkovich. I give this a big "thumbs up" (missing you Eber). A great movie for the believer or non-believer.