I love this movie.  This edition has more extras than the other dvd and I'm getting it.  I prefer fullscreen to widescreen-widescreen is distracting to watch- all that black space at the top and bottom of the screen.  Full screen fills up the entire screen and I can get into the movie more.  I know- if it was shot in widescreen- we are missing part of the picture.  I didn't know til I read other reviews that it is so much of the picture- I never saw this movie in widescreen to know the difference.  To satisfy everybody, and watch one when you don't want the distraction of the black bars, and one when you don't want to miss any of the picture, the special edition should have both versions.  Some dvds do have both versions.  Maybe the'll come out with a version with both on it, and all the extras.  Until then, you can buy this for the full screen edition and the extras, as well as the widescreen edition- without the extras.  They should shoot all movies in full screen- that way we'd have no bars and we wouldn't be missing any of the movie- some movies are shot this way.