The Baxter of California Herbal Mint Toner is my first time using a toner. I have used several Baxter of California products that were mostly very good, so I thought to try the toner.  I used it daily, at night, and it was refreshing, the scent wasn't overly strong and it cleans very well.  It was after a few weeks when I was told by a friend that my skin looked really good. I hadn't told her I was using anything and told her of the toner.  My skin isn't bad, it just looked clearer, better after a few weeks of daily use. My skin is on the slightly oily side so a nice change was that my skin was clean and the toner didn't dry me out.