The Vichy Purete Thermale 3-in-1 Calming Cleanser is a nice toner for skin, but not a particularly great make up remover.  I test this cleanser on both unwashed and washed skin, as well as pre and post make up removal.  The cleaner worked well to catch any residual makeup I missed after a makeup removal and washing with my normal remover and cleanser.  While it did work adequately on its own to cleanse skin and remove a light layer of foundation, it wasn't as effective when removing eye make up.  It took a lot of scrubbing to remove everything when used alone.