Thought I was getting the same cologne I had before from John Varvatos.  I'm definitely not disappointed, but when I smelled it I knew it wasn't the same one.  The good news is that it smells great and I do not regret it.  I fixed it, however, for Christmas I asked my mother-in-law to get me JT Vintage cologne.  Now, Vintage is what I was after to begin with and it is one of the best smelling masculine colognes out there period.  Still, this is nice and warrants 4-stars.  See other reviews for detailed smell description as I think they've covered that base nicely.